{ "schema_version": 1, "report_kind": "tournament", "board_size": 15, "move_codec": "cell_index_v1", "shuffled_elo_samples": 256, "provenance": { "generated_at_utc": "2026-05-19T21:09:39Z", "generated_at_local": "2026-05-19 14:09:39 PDT", "git_commit": "054e724dbd7b", "git_dirty": false, "command": [ "target/release/gomoku-eval", "tournament", "--bots", "search-d1,search-d3,search-d3+pattern-eval,search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval,search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval,search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4,search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4,search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "--games-per-pair", "64", "--opening-policy", "centered-suite", "--opening-plies", "4", "--search-cpu-time-ms", "2000", "--search-budget-mode", "pooled", "--search-cpu-reserve-ms", "8000", "--search-cpu-max-move-ms", "4000", "--max-moves", "120", "--seed", "63", "--threads", "22", "--report-json", "reports/latest.json" ], "host": { "os": "linux", "arch": "x86_64", "logical_cpus": 24, "cpu_model": "AMD Ryzen 9 7900X 12-Core Processor", "cpu_mhz": 3007.258 } }, "run": { "bots": [ "search-d1", "search-d3", "search-d3+pattern-eval", "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4" ], "schedule": "round-robin", "rules": { "board_size": 15, "win_length": 5, "variant": "renju" }, "games_per_pair": 64, "seed": 63, "opening_plies": 4, "opening_policy": "centered-suite", "threads": 22, "search_time_ms": null, "search_cpu_time_ms": 2000, "search_budget_mode": "pooled", "search_cpu_reserve_ms": 8000, "search_cpu_max_move_ms": 4000, "max_moves": 120, "max_game_ms": null, "total_wall_time_ms": 1435331 }, "standings": [ { "bot": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "wins": 304, "draws": 4, "losses": 140, "sequential_elo": 1389.5850652973618, "shuffled_elo_avg": 1346.7936961247856, "shuffled_elo_stddev": 46.85463118600622, "match_count": 448, "move_count": 7380, "search_move_count": 6484, "total_time_ms": 7807277, "avg_search_time_ms": 1204.0834361505244, "search_nodes": 73527664, "safety_nodes": 361813, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 73889477, "avg_nodes": 11395.662708204813, "eval_calls": 46425325, "avg_eval_calls": 7159.9822640345465, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46425325, "pattern_eval_ns": 977326525, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.051581760601568, "pattern_frame_queries": 46425325, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 977326525, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.051581760601568, "pattern_frame_updates": 146983222, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1620576395267, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11025.58763657392, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25073637, "avg_candidate_generations": 3867.001388032079, "candidate_moves_total": 2178837653, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.89755112112375, "candidate_moves_max": 147, "root_candidate_generations": 6484, "root_candidate_moves_total": 483158, "root_candidate_moves_max": 133, "search_candidate_generations": 25067153, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2178354495, "search_candidate_moves_max": 147, "legality_checks": 917589766, "avg_legality_checks": 141516.0033929673, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1939316, "root_legality_checks": 247262, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 458, "search_legality_checks": 917342504, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1938858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2445633667, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 377179.77590993216, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4766651565860, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1949.0456114415274, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26774514, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4129.320481184454, "renju_forbidden_ns": 105902394644, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3955.3433031128034, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2936775, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19019332053, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9111115, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 56871336517, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14716446, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29938949881, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10178, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 72776193, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72623698, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11200.446946329426, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 595237671866, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8196.190613510207, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97954212, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15107.065391733498, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 262556376459, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2680.3990466382397, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1991550871038, "stage_ordering_ns": 771030217581, "stage_eval_ns": 1621553721792, "stage_threat_ns": 3382867883123, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 507990810, "root_tactical_annotations": 1410922, "search_tactical_annotations": 506579888, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 146989706, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 801652984171, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 416249081, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2441626767067, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50183023, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1541512106616, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 73491611, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104017664223, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 146983222, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17432200465, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 142018404, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 211830982708, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 224042725, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 688176262390, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 141929681, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18138267197, "child_limit_applications": 25067153, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25067153, "child_cap_hits": 25067153, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25067153, "child_moves_before_total": 2176415637, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2176415637, "child_moves_before_max": 147, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 147, "child_moves_after_total": 272926851, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 272926851, "child_moves_after_max": 33, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 33, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.8234073889444, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.887828027379097, "tt_hits": 13269968, "tt_cutoffs": 1999714, "beta_cutoffs": 20147093, "avg_depth": 5.429056138186305, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 35202, "avg_effective_depth": 5.429056138186305, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1127 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 53 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 16 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1121 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 887 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3273 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 851, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13124614435533621, "pooled_budget_moves": 6484, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1547, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23858729179518814, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 851, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13124614435533621, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3623.723781616286, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4144.61674892042, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, { "bot": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins": 295, "draws": 1, "losses": 152, "sequential_elo": 1485.519116377097, "shuffled_elo_avg": 1332.4030148344527, "shuffled_elo_stddev": 51.51569743087118, "match_count": 448, "move_count": 6877, "search_move_count": 5981, "total_time_ms": 7273044, "avg_search_time_ms": 1216.0247450259153, "search_nodes": 65085655, "safety_nodes": 330432, "corridor_nodes": 1372317, "corridor_branch_probes": 1489637, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 845, "corridor_depth_exits": 678966, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5394, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2646, "corridor_plies_followed": 1365572, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1364627, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 945, "corridor_proof_passes": 2875, "corridor_proof_completed": 2813, "corridor_proof_checks": 20830, "corridor_proof_active": 6745, "corridor_proof_quiet": 14085, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6239, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 678966, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 238, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2646, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 306, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 297, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 297, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 103, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 194, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 20830, "corridor_proof_wins": 297, "corridor_proof_losses": 9, "corridor_proof_unknown": 20524, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 60, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 103, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 194, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 145304, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 10692481600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4000000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 631, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 16, "total_nodes": 66788404, "avg_nodes": 11166.762079919747, "eval_calls": 41188529, "avg_eval_calls": 6886.562280555091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41188529, "pattern_eval_ns": 870643256, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.13800315617001, "pattern_frame_queries": 41188529, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 870643256, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.13800315617001, "pattern_frame_updates": 130105818, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1455688470425, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11188.496354751791, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22116169, "avg_candidate_generations": 3697.7376692860726, "candidate_moves_total": 1887286136, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.33512906326588, "candidate_moves_max": 151, "root_candidate_generations": 5981, "root_candidate_moves_total": 434423, "root_candidate_moves_max": 135, "search_candidate_generations": 22110188, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1886851713, "search_candidate_moves_max": 151, "legality_checks": 794790655, "avg_legality_checks": 132885.91456278216, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1664324, "root_legality_checks": 225805, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 355, "search_legality_checks": 794564850, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1663969, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2288112398, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 382563.5174719946, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4473515334370, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1955.1117061732734, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22047883, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3686.320514964053, "renju_forbidden_ns": 95795944208, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4344.904415902425, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2178840, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16605723478, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7975109, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 51690898590, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11692157, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26462793530, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 201777, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1036528610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65904928, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11019.048319678983, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 547745408832, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8311.144939449749, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89098012, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14896.841999665608, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 243990710678, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2738.4529149539276, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1742439581786, "stage_ordering_ns": 681638142256, "stage_eval_ns": 1456559113681, "stage_threat_ns": 3239382362671, "stage_proof_ns": 118241057228, "tactical_annotations": 425560968, "root_tactical_annotations": 1239156, "search_tactical_annotations": 424321812, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 132884603, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 747683107575, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 417612626, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2349387589298, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44955938, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1432038426329, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66439311, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94944937748, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2772804, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16214639451, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 132878622, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15796453153, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 112822827, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 179173483146, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 192494395, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 612022569187, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 120243746, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15355635446, "child_limit_applications": 22110188, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22110188, "child_cap_hits": 22110188, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22110188, "child_moves_before_total": 1885187744, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1885187744, "child_moves_before_max": 151, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 151, "child_moves_after_total": 236788056, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 236788056, "child_moves_after_max": 35, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 35, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.26330685202677, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.709454664067081, "tt_hits": 11633166, "tt_cutoffs": 1754704, "beta_cutoffs": 17713422, "avg_depth": 5.342919244273533, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 31956, "avg_effective_depth": 5.342919244273533, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1107 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 52 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 23 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1048 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 871 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2875 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 852, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14245109513459286, "pooled_budget_moves": 5981, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1451, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.24260157164353788, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 852, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14245109513459286, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3212.430697207825, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3770.5104497575658, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, { "bot": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins": 294, "draws": 1, "losses": 153, "sequential_elo": 1437.362995404858, "shuffled_elo_avg": 1323.8409839193082, "shuffled_elo_stddev": 46.729957960521524, "match_count": 448, "move_count": 6551, "search_move_count": 5655, "total_time_ms": 4501523, "avg_search_time_ms": 796.0252873563219, "search_nodes": 45827372, "safety_nodes": 347284, "corridor_nodes": 1790842, "corridor_branch_probes": 1946034, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 909, "corridor_depth_exits": 893631, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13341, "corridor_terminal_exits": 5170, "corridor_plies_followed": 1779061, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1760966, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 18095, "corridor_proof_passes": 4691, "corridor_proof_completed": 4672, "corridor_proof_checks": 38088, "corridor_proof_active": 11781, "corridor_proof_quiet": 26307, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14250, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 893631, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 80, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 5170, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 863, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 778, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 85, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 778, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 176, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 602, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38088, "corridor_proof_wins": 778, "corridor_proof_losses": 85, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37225, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 18, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 179, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 602, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 283953, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 9226477280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2020240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1233, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 11, "total_nodes": 47965498, "avg_nodes": 8481.962511052167, "eval_calls": 34225161, "avg_eval_calls": 6052.1946949602125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34225161, "pattern_eval_ns": 714765948, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.884224562157648, "pattern_frame_queries": 34225161, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 714765948, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.884224562157648, "pattern_frame_updates": 91604228, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 977400201373, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10669.815386392427, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10936327, "avg_candidate_generations": 1933.9216622458002, "candidate_moves_total": 890075165, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.38702921008122, "candidate_moves_max": 142, "root_candidate_generations": 5655, "root_candidate_moves_total": 406742, "root_candidate_moves_max": 127, "search_candidate_generations": 10930672, "search_candidate_moves_total": 889668423, "search_candidate_moves_max": 142, "legality_checks": 429769086, "avg_legality_checks": 75998.0700265252, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1153170, "root_legality_checks": 197029, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 380, "search_legality_checks": 429572057, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1152790, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1375960665, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 243317.53580901856, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2741029613894, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1992.0842823613712, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12273139, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2170.3163572060125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61638630141, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5022.238413579444, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1338246, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11983987466, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4668354, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33901010551, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5983382, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14425328798, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 283157, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1328303326, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 40706655, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7198.347480106101, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 352034427855, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8648.080463870097, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 55269696, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9773.597877984084, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 160088407045, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2896.4951615619525, "stage_move_gen_ns": 980079776246, "stage_ordering_ns": 333661790482, "stage_eval_ns": 978114967321, "stage_threat_ns": 2023945998153, "stage_proof_ns": 163760349209, "tactical_annotations": 187237662, "root_tactical_annotations": 860276, "search_tactical_annotations": 186377386, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 95244181, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 544726203070, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 257420356, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1374239041917, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22823336, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 762229706952, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47619263, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 67064405448, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3634298, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21737349728, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 95238526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11220470907, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 59218768, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 128204900467, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 88104178, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 324927345108, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 39914716, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4958527083, "child_limit_applications": 10930672, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10930672, "child_cap_hits": 10930672, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10930672, "child_moves_before_total": 888515633, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 888515633, "child_moves_before_max": 142, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 142, "child_moves_after_total": 176695008, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 176695008, "child_moves_after_max": 34, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 34, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.28646006393751, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.165063593528377, "tt_hits": 4421745, "tt_cutoffs": 646319, "beta_cutoffs": 8716239, "avg_depth": 4.453757736516358, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 25186, "avg_effective_depth": 4.453757736516358, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 685 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 13 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 44 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 222 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4691 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 91, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.016091954022988506, "pooled_budget_moves": 5655, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 561, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09920424403183024, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 91, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.016091954022988506, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4874.6702033598585, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5496.924845269673, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, { "bot": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "wins": 270, "draws": 4, "losses": 174, "sequential_elo": 1310.9344182415834, "shuffled_elo_avg": 1287.8704405453816, "shuffled_elo_stddev": 48.1545500923151, "match_count": 448, "move_count": 7039, "search_move_count": 6143, "total_time_ms": 4557545, "avg_search_time_ms": 741.9086765424059, "search_nodes": 51471409, "safety_nodes": 381365, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 51852774, "avg_nodes": 8440.952954582452, "eval_calls": 38348308, "avg_eval_calls": 6242.602637147973, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38348308, "pattern_eval_ns": 801850883, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.90968089126644, "pattern_frame_queries": 38348308, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 801850883, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.90968089126644, "pattern_frame_updates": 102887250, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1092123745637, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10614.762719744185, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12367473, "avg_candidate_generations": 2013.2627380758588, "candidate_moves_total": 1031682242, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.41900095516684, "candidate_moves_max": 154, "root_candidate_generations": 6143, "root_candidate_moves_total": 455436, "root_candidate_moves_max": 134, "search_candidate_generations": 12361330, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1031226806, "search_candidate_moves_max": 154, "legality_checks": 491792314, "avg_legality_checks": 80057.3521080905, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1425185, "root_legality_checks": 232883, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 497, "search_legality_checks": 491559431, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1424688, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1380028531, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 224650.58293993163, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2735161056462, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1981.9597892516324, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14919076, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2428.6303109230016, "renju_forbidden_ns": 73399673083, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4919.853822247437, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1750103, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15690803935, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5499957, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38635523980, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7658015, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18988742774, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 11001, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 84602394, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43956948, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7155.615822887839, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 379843342849, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8641.258325054778, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 60006855, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9768.330620218134, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 172984261638, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2882.741674063738, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1104761244289, "stage_ordering_ns": 377952394387, "stage_eval_ns": 1092925596520, "stage_threat_ns": 1955678657681, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 225998062, "root_tactical_annotations": 988130, "search_tactical_annotations": 225009932, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 102893393, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 557986414832, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 203045645, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1308714557021, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24762460, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 786802567731, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51443625, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 70999489154, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 102887250, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12059551333, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 76165406, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 154298221780, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 102113127, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 367494964948, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 47719529, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5918645341, "child_limit_applications": 12361330, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12361330, "child_cap_hits": 12361330, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12361330, "child_moves_before_total": 1029802118, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1029802118, "child_moves_before_max": 154, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 154, "child_moves_after_total": 200074633, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 200074633, "child_moves_after_max": 33, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 33, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.30835905197904, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.185526395622478, "tt_hits": 5069415, "tt_cutoffs": 734032, "beta_cutoffs": 9881098, "avg_depth": 4.511476477291226, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 27714, "avg_effective_depth": 4.511476477291226, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 651 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 24 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 41 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 243 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5184 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 70, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.011395083835259645, "pooled_budget_moves": 6143, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 512, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08334689890932769, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 70, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.011395083835259645, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5307.434478267947, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5884.78349340713, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, { "bot": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins": 224, "draws": 1, "losses": 223, "sequential_elo": 1215.8631282696983, "shuffled_elo_avg": 1215.9008039516873, "shuffled_elo_stddev": 49.57358108787813, "match_count": 448, "move_count": 6496, "search_move_count": 5600, "total_time_ms": 2962821, "avg_search_time_ms": 529.0751785714285, "search_nodes": 75411288, "safety_nodes": 398468, "corridor_nodes": 1196937, "corridor_branch_probes": 1335307, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1544, "corridor_depth_exits": 554819, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7055, "corridor_terminal_exits": 5601, "corridor_plies_followed": 1187625, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1185993, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 1632, "corridor_proof_passes": 5041, "corridor_proof_completed": 5041, "corridor_proof_checks": 34998, "corridor_proof_active": 9312, "corridor_proof_quiet": 25686, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8599, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 554819, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 5601, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1034, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 858, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 176, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 858, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 67, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 791, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 34998, "corridor_proof_wins": 858, "corridor_proof_losses": 176, "corridor_proof_unknown": 33964, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 67, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 791, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 244168, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 91485160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 28960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1148, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 16, "total_nodes": 77006693, "avg_nodes": 13751.195178571428, "eval_calls": 73311237, "avg_eval_calls": 13091.292321428571, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73311237, "pattern_eval_ns": 1517674782, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.701802944615434, "pattern_frame_queries": 73311237, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1517674782, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.701802944615434, "pattern_frame_updates": 150790318, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1595348959341, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10579.916406443284, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2089522, "avg_candidate_generations": 373.12892857142856, "candidate_moves_total": 166582148, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.7226102429168, "candidate_moves_max": 146, "root_candidate_generations": 5600, "root_candidate_moves_total": 401960, "root_candidate_moves_max": 127, "search_candidate_generations": 2083922, "search_candidate_moves_total": 166180188, "search_candidate_moves_max": 146, "legality_checks": 42296060, "avg_legality_checks": 7552.867857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 40709, "root_legality_checks": 201754, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 256, "search_legality_checks": 42094306, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 40453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 589398905, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 105249.80446428571, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1291203618420, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2190.7126183412233, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7756361, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1385.0644642857144, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60326388128, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7777.666373187117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 48509, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 357845855, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7448873, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 58360542225, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 73469, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 654043198, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 185510, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 953956850, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1777151, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 317.34839285714287, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 16027120235, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9018.434694069329, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2429927, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 433.91553571428574, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 8336295463, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3430.677326108974, "stage_move_gen_ns": 100203713288, "stage_ordering_ns": 71712591, "stage_eval_ns": 1596866634123, "stage_threat_ns": 1124408126557, "stage_proof_ns": 128790026774, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 153241164, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 841470850047, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64225940, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 149485829248, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 675474, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 34443561924, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76617782, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 100999208194, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2445246, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14495499153, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 153235564, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17956739915, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 148750, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1840479, "avg_depth": 2.8601785714285715, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 16017, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8601785714285715, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 224 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 335 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 5041 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 112, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.02, "pooled_budget_moves": 5600, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 325, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05803571428571429, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 112, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.02, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5692.383035714286, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6331.261964285714, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, { "bot": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "wins": 214, "draws": 1, "losses": 233, "sequential_elo": 1005.635715359171, "shuffled_elo_avg": 1189.552561382287, "shuffled_elo_stddev": 50.07627353667332, "match_count": 448, "move_count": 6517, "search_move_count": 5621, "total_time_ms": 2704544, "avg_search_time_ms": 481.1499733143569, "search_nodes": 79866900, "safety_nodes": 390907, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 80257807, "avg_nodes": 14278.20797011208, "eval_calls": 77681738, "avg_eval_calls": 13819.914250133428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77681738, "pattern_eval_ns": 1587546523, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.436547428946557, "pattern_frame_queries": 77681738, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1587546523, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.436547428946557, "pattern_frame_updates": 159701396, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1634293649032, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10233.433707943292, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2174581, "avg_candidate_generations": 386.86728340152996, "candidate_moves_total": 175530785, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.7193592696708, "candidate_moves_max": 151, "root_candidate_generations": 5621, "root_candidate_moves_total": 404450, "root_candidate_moves_max": 127, "search_candidate_generations": 2168960, "search_candidate_moves_total": 175126335, "search_candidate_moves_max": 151, "legality_checks": 45722044, "avg_legality_checks": 8134.1476605586195, "illegal_moves_skipped": 43180, "root_legality_checks": 207488, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 240, "search_legality_checks": 45514556, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42940, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 504768149, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 89800.41789717133, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1104113775058, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2187.3681555489748, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7681263, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1366.5296210638676, "renju_forbidden_ns": 58513867084, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7617.740348690053, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 51769, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 366486722, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7623499, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 58095631550, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5995, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 51748812, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 7182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.277708592777086, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 66579815, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9270.37245892509, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9660, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.7185554171855542, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 31710667, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3282.6777432712215, "stage_move_gen_ns": 104796745392, "stage_ordering_ns": 74173770, "stage_eval_ns": 1635881195555, "stage_threat_ns": 950256719662, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 159707017, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 830298322793, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 15247, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 147077472, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 11028, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5420692, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79850698, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 101656245809, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 159701396, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18155073588, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 154360, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1916134, "avg_depth": 2.8626578900551505, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 16091, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8626578900551505, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 214 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 344 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 5063 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 111, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.019747375911759475, "pooled_budget_moves": 5621, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 290, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05159224337306529, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.019747375911759475, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5786.516989859456, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6422.725493684397, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, { "bot": "search-d3", "wins": 140, "draws": 0, "losses": 308, "sequential_elo": 1081.1978227105212, "shuffled_elo_avg": 1063.6312278869466, "shuffled_elo_stddev": 50.87045508692034, "match_count": 448, "move_count": 6774, "search_move_count": 5878, "total_time_ms": 1266982, "avg_search_time_ms": 215.54644436883294, "search_nodes": 86839043, "safety_nodes": 505350, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87344393, "avg_nodes": 14859.542871725076, "eval_calls": 84665596, "avg_eval_calls": 14403.810139503232, "line_shape_eval_calls": 84665596, "line_shape_eval_ns": 110903991480, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1309.9062277905657, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2162279, "avg_candidate_generations": 367.85964613814224, "candidate_moves_total": 179833487, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.1684935200314, "candidate_moves_max": 145, "root_candidate_generations": 5878, "root_candidate_moves_total": 429187, "root_candidate_moves_max": 132, "search_candidate_generations": 2156401, "search_candidate_moves_total": 179404300, "search_candidate_moves_max": 145, "legality_checks": 60887584, "avg_legality_checks": 10358.554610411704, "illegal_moves_skipped": 136872, "root_legality_checks": 253850, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1041, "search_legality_checks": 60633734, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 135831, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 67664657, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11511.510207553589, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 147360246594, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2177.8023140500068, "renju_forbidden_checks": 163784, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 27.86389928547125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1142295636, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6974.403091877107, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 156004, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1082606024, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7780, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 59689612, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 14093, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.3975842123171147, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 136167065, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9662.035407649188, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19418, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.3035045933991154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 67244054, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3462.975280667422, "stage_move_gen_ns": 139689447403, "stage_ordering_ns": 68110261, "stage_eval_ns": 110903991480, "stage_threat_ns": 1005691495534, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 173649872, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 878700669773, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 15968, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 241951656, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 11616, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5864516, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86821997, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107121031494, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 173643994, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19627842611, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 117891, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1948716, "avg_depth": 2.8979244641034367, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 17034, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8979244641034367, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 140 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 320 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 5418 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 12, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.002041510717931269, "pooled_budget_moves": 5878, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 99, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.016842463422932972, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 12, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.002041510717931269, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6274.132698196666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6883.863899285471, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1216, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, { "bot": "search-d1", "wins": 45, "draws": 0, "losses": 403, "sequential_elo": 673.9017383397097, "shuffled_elo_avg": 840.0072713551515, "shuffled_elo_stddev": 44.25577304948958, "match_count": 448, "move_count": 5978, "search_move_count": 5082, "total_time_ms": 16359, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.21900826446281, "search_nodes": 112790, "safety_nodes": 410406, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 523196, "avg_nodes": 102.95080676898858, "eval_calls": 107708, "avg_eval_calls": 21.194018103109013, "line_shape_eval_calls": 107708, "line_shape_eval_ns": 105522143, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 979.7057135960189, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5082, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 361685, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.1698150334514, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 5082, "root_candidate_moves_total": 361685, "root_candidate_moves_max": 125, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 154103, "avg_legality_checks": 30.323297914207004, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1389, "root_legality_checks": 154103, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1389, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6045274, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1189.5462416371506, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11594595166, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1917.9602390230782, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9550, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.8791814246359702, "renju_forbidden_ns": 95477085, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9997.60052356021, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1428, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16005987, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8122, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 79471098, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 8279, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.6290830381739472, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 92130960, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11128.271530378064, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12188, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.398268398268398, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 51104297, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4193.001066622908, "stage_move_gen_ns": 383822329, "stage_ordering_ns": 247182, "stage_eval_ns": 105522143, "stage_threat_ns": 9972260696, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 220498, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 9618640314, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 13955, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 181533847, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 10119, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5053945, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 107708, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 146105668, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 215416, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25980867, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 5082, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5082 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 5082, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6233.930145611964, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6939.164305391578, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } ], "pairwise": [ { "bot_a": "search-d1", "bot_b": "search-d3", "wins_a": 19, "wins_b": 45, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 19.0, "score_b": 45.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d1", "bot_b": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "wins_a": 4, "wins_b": 60, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 4.0, "score_b": 60.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d1", "bot_b": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "wins_a": 13, "wins_b": 51, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 13.0, "score_b": 51.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d1", "bot_b": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "wins_a": 1, "wins_b": 63, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 1.0, "score_b": 63.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d1", "bot_b": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 3, "wins_b": 61, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 3.0, "score_b": 61.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d1", "bot_b": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 4, "wins_b": 60, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 4.0, "score_b": 60.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d1", "bot_b": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 1, "wins_b": 63, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 1.0, "score_b": 63.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d3", "bot_b": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "wins_a": 15, "wins_b": 49, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 15.0, "score_b": 49.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d3", "bot_b": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "wins_a": 10, "wins_b": 54, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 10.0, "score_b": 54.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d3", "bot_b": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "wins_a": 18, "wins_b": 46, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 18.0, "score_b": 46.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d3", "bot_b": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 16, "wins_b": 48, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 16.0, "score_b": 48.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d3", "bot_b": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 14, "wins_b": 50, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 14.0, "score_b": 50.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d3", "bot_b": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 22, "wins_b": 42, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 22.0, "score_b": 42.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "bot_b": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "wins_a": 17, "wins_b": 46, "draws": 1, "total": 64, "score_a": 17.5, "score_b": 46.5 }, { "bot_a": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "bot_b": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "wins_a": 15, "wins_b": 49, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 15.0, "score_b": 49.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "bot_b": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 32, "wins_b": 32, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 32.0, "score_b": 32.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "bot_b": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 22, "wins_b": 42, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 22.0, "score_b": 42.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "bot_b": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 19, "wins_b": 45, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 19.0, "score_b": 45.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "bot_b": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "wins_a": 24, "wins_b": 38, "draws": 2, "total": 64, "score_a": 25.0, "score_b": 39.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "bot_b": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 41, "wins_b": 22, "draws": 1, "total": 64, "score_a": 41.5, "score_b": 22.5 }, { "bot_a": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "bot_b": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 24, "wins_b": 40, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 24.0, "score_b": 40.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "bot_b": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 30, "wins_b": 34, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 30.0, "score_b": 34.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "bot_b": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 46, "wins_b": 18, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 46.0, "score_b": 18.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "bot_b": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 34, "wins_b": 29, "draws": 1, "total": 64, "score_a": 34.5, "score_b": 29.5 }, { "bot_a": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "bot_b": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 28, "wins_b": 35, "draws": 1, "total": 64, "score_a": 28.5, "score_b": 35.5 }, { "bot_a": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "bot_b": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 22, "wins_b": 42, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 22.0, "score_b": 42.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "bot_b": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 21, "wins_b": 43, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 21.0, "score_b": 43.0 }, { "bot_a": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "bot_b": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "wins_a": 31, "wins_b": 33, "draws": 0, "total": 64, "score_a": 31.0, "score_b": 33.0 } ], "color_splits": [ { "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "black_wins": 8, "white_wins": 24, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 2, "white_wins": 30, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 2, "white_wins": 30, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 12, "white_wins": 20, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 4, "white_wins": 28, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 0, "white_wins": 32, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 0, "white_wins": 32, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "black_wins": 21, "white_wins": 11, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 12, "white_wins": 20, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 13, "white_wins": 19, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 4, "white_wins": 28, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 9, "white_wins": 23, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 12, "white_wins": 20, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 18, "white_wins": 14, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "black_wins": 30, "white_wins": 2, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "black_wins": 29, "white_wins": 3, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 25, "white_wins": 7, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 16, "white_wins": 16, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 21, "white_wins": 11, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 11, "white_wins": 21, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 16, "white_wins": 16, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "black_wins": 31, "white_wins": 1, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "black_wins": 29, "white_wins": 3, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 25, "white_wins": 7, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 19, "white_wins": 13, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 21, "white_wins": 11, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 12, "white_wins": 20, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 15, "white_wins": 17, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "black_wins": 31, "white_wins": 1, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "black_wins": 26, "white_wins": 6, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 30, "white_wins": 1, "draws": 1, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 28, "white_wins": 3, "draws": 1, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 14, "white_wins": 18, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 20, "white_wins": 10, "draws": 2, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 24, "white_wins": 8, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "black_wins": 32, "white_wins": 0, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "black_wins": 27, "white_wins": 5, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 31, "white_wins": 1, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 31, "white_wins": 1, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 22, "white_wins": 10, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 24, "white_wins": 7, "draws": 1, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 26, "white_wins": 6, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "black_wins": 31, "white_wins": 1, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "black_wins": 26, "white_wins": 6, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 28, "white_wins": 4, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 26, "white_wins": 6, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 28, "white_wins": 4, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 27, "white_wins": 5, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 22, "white_wins": 9, "draws": 1, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "black_wins": 31, "white_wins": 1, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "black_wins": 28, "white_wins": 4, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 29, "white_wins": 3, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 26, "white_wins": 6, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 26, "white_wins": 6, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "black_wins": 27, "white_wins": 5, "draws": 0, "total": 32 }, { "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "black_wins": 26, "white_wins": 6, "draws": 0, "total": 32 } ], "end_reasons": [ { "key": "max_moves", "count": 6 }, { "key": "natural", "count": 1786 } ], "matches": [ { "match_index": 1, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 629, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 67, 52, 83, 99, 85, 84, 68, 114, 129, 54, 128, 69 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 244, "safety_nodes": 211, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 455, "avg_nodes": 65.0, "eval_calls": 237, "avg_eval_calls": 33.857142857142854, "line_shape_eval_calls": 237, "line_shape_eval_ns": 178911, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 754.8987341772151, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 343, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.0, "candidate_moves_max": 59, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 343, "root_candidate_moves_max": 59, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 343, "avg_legality_checks": 49.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 343, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8200, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1171.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19490225, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2376.856707317073, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 126310, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10525.833333333334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23940, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 102370, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 17, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.4285714285714284, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 204131, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12007.70588235294, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.5714285714285716, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 116781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4671.24, "stage_move_gen_ns": 907826, "stage_ordering_ns": 320, "stage_eval_ns": 178911, "stage_threat_ns": 15390094, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 481, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14680062, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 304731, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 237, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 345471, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 474, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59830, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 595, "avg_search_time_ms": 85.0, "search_nodes": 43089, "safety_nodes": 283, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 43372, "avg_nodes": 6196.0, "eval_calls": 41818, "avg_eval_calls": 5974.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 41818, "line_shape_eval_ns": 39392446, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 941.9973695537807, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1259, "avg_candidate_generations": 179.85714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 80084, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.60921366163622, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 356, "root_candidate_moves_max": 58, "search_candidate_generations": 1252, "search_candidate_moves_total": 79728, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 4110, "avg_legality_checks": 587.1428571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 35, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4110, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 35, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11911, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1701.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25057972, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2103.767273948451, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6.714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 495603, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10544.744680851063, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 367062, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 128541, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10383736, "stage_ordering_ns": 44220, "stage_eval_ns": 39392446, "stage_threat_ns": 536302330, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 86147, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 471771086, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 78900, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6740, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43070, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 54312338, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 86140, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10140006, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 169, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1026, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5075.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6218.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 2, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1489, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 96, 128, 83, 143, 158, 142, 81, 84, 66, 111, 80, 79, 95, 159, 175, 94, 65, 110, 64, 48, 63, 67, 62 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 1435, "avg_search_time_ms": 110.38461538461539, "search_nodes": 91462, "safety_nodes": 479, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91941, "avg_nodes": 7072.384615384615, "eval_calls": 88052, "avg_eval_calls": 6773.2307692307695, "line_shape_eval_calls": 88052, "line_shape_eval_ns": 117306085, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1332.23646254486, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3386, "avg_candidate_generations": 260.46153846153845, "candidate_moves_total": 260253, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.86148848198464, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 3373, "search_candidate_moves_total": 259445, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 85588, "avg_legality_checks": 6583.692307692308, "illegal_moves_skipped": 383, "root_legality_checks": 808, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 84780, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 378, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 100416, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7724.307692307692, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 220681468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2197.6723629700446, "renju_forbidden_checks": 496, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 38.15384615384615, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3779529, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7620.018145161291, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 476, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3610288, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 169241, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.2307692307692308, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 137311, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8581.9375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.5384615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 55530, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2776.5, "stage_move_gen_ns": 200768645, "stage_ordering_ns": 112140, "stage_eval_ns": 117306085, "stage_threat_ns": 1094545489, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 182863, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 958926554, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 230041, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91425, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 114486069, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 182850, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20902825, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 439, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2795, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6420.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7035.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1943, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 41, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4166666666666665, "search_nodes": 312, "safety_nodes": 680, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 992, "avg_nodes": 82.66666666666667, "eval_calls": 300, "avg_eval_calls": 25.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 300, "line_shape_eval_ns": 317960, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1059.8666666666666, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 748, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.333333333333336, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13762, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1146.8333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27584482, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2004.3948553989246, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 236812, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9108.153846153846, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 236812, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4650, "stage_ordering_ns": 550, "stage_eval_ns": 317960, "stage_threat_ns": 25115690, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 612, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24412476, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 206020, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12640, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 421564, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 600, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 75630, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 3, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2386, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 110, 109, 126, 142, 100, 129, 125, 143, 99, 157, 115, 159, 156, 144, 174, 141, 145, 140 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 37, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7, "search_nodes": 317, "safety_nodes": 349, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 666, "avg_nodes": 66.6, "eval_calls": 307, "avg_eval_calls": 30.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 307, "line_shape_eval_ns": 263612, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 858.671009771987, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 557, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.7, "candidate_moves_max": 69, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 557, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 557, "avg_legality_checks": 55.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 557, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11989, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1198.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24955115, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2081.5009592126116, "renju_forbidden_checks": 80, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 913153, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11414.4125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 194270, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 64, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 718883, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 252031, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12001.47619047619, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 30, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 139680, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4656.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1660240, "stage_ordering_ns": 470, "stage_eval_ns": 263612, "stage_threat_ns": 22410005, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 624, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21548562, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 338681, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 307, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 443752, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 614, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 79010, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2339, "avg_search_time_ms": 233.9, "search_nodes": 167152, "safety_nodes": 452, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 167604, "avg_nodes": 16760.4, "eval_calls": 163509, "avg_eval_calls": 16350.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 163509, "line_shape_eval_ns": 184991922, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1131.3867860484745, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3625, "avg_candidate_generations": 362.5, "candidate_moves_total": 261710, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.19586206896551, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 579, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 3615, "search_candidate_moves_total": 261131, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 7984, "avg_legality_checks": 798.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 176, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7984, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 176, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19350, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1935.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 44543649, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2301.9973643410854, "renju_forbidden_checks": 256, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 25.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3003252, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11731.453125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 176, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2102188, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 80, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 901064, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 25091151, "stage_ordering_ns": 124260, "stage_eval_ns": 184991922, "stage_threat_ns": 2125627356, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 334258, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1860091259, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 108062, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9930, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 167124, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 224086984, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 334248, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41341051, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 320, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3169, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5914.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6714.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 4, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2128, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 97, 129, 126, 130, 131, 115, 96, 141, 95, 98, 81, 66, 82, 146, 162, 67, 80, 83, 65, 49, 50, 110, 35 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 2074, "avg_search_time_ms": 159.53846153846155, "search_nodes": 126471, "safety_nodes": 479, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 126950, "avg_nodes": 9765.384615384615, "eval_calls": 122166, "avg_eval_calls": 9397.384615384615, "line_shape_eval_calls": 122166, "line_shape_eval_ns": 145343712, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1189.7230980796621, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4281, "avg_candidate_generations": 329.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 311715, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.8135949544499, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 4268, "search_candidate_moves_total": 310907, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 119603, "avg_legality_checks": 9200.23076923077, "illegal_moves_skipped": 626, "root_legality_checks": 808, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 118795, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 621, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 134283, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10329.461538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 318939699, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2375.1308728580684, "renju_forbidden_checks": 691, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 53.15384615384615, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6471825, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9365.882778581765, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 671, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6284295, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 187530, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.2307692307692308, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 149590, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9349.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.5384615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 58650, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2932.5, "stage_move_gen_ns": 303588254, "stage_ordering_ns": 139610, "stage_eval_ns": 145343712, "stage_threat_ns": 1607799977, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 252881, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1408468122, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 240100, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 126434, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 168168544, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 252868, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30923211, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 439, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3646, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6323.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6939.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1928, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 41, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4166666666666665, "search_nodes": 312, "safety_nodes": 680, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 992, "avg_nodes": 82.66666666666667, "eval_calls": 300, "avg_eval_calls": 25.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 300, "line_shape_eval_ns": 325013, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1083.3766666666668, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 748, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.333333333333336, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13600, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1133.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27963656, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2056.1511764705883, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 271121, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10427.73076923077, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 271121, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4940, "stage_ordering_ns": 590, "stage_eval_ns": 325013, "stage_threat_ns": 25495042, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 612, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24765168, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 216093, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 436881, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 600, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 76900, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 5, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 557, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 81, 65, 80, 94, 82, 83, 78, 98, 79 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 244, "safety_nodes": 211, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 455, "avg_nodes": 65.0, "eval_calls": 237, "avg_eval_calls": 33.857142857142854, "line_shape_eval_calls": 237, "line_shape_eval_ns": 175650, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 741.1392405063291, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 343, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.0, "candidate_moves_max": 59, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 343, "root_candidate_moves_max": 59, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 343, "avg_legality_checks": 49.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 343, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8200, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1171.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16778622, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2046.1734146341464, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 125700, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10475.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22830, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 102870, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 17, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.4285714285714284, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 194732, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11454.823529411764, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.5714285714285716, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 108901, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4356.04, "stage_move_gen_ns": 900415, "stage_ordering_ns": 240, "stage_eval_ns": 175650, "stage_threat_ns": 15488469, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 481, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14789055, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 300992, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7270, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 237, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 338331, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 474, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60091, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 525, "avg_search_time_ms": 75.0, "search_nodes": 37847, "safety_nodes": 283, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 38130, "avg_nodes": 5447.142857142857, "eval_calls": 36630, "avg_eval_calls": 5232.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 36630, "line_shape_eval_ns": 34264157, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 935.4124215124215, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1205, "avg_candidate_generations": 172.14285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 76840, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.767634854771785, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 356, "root_candidate_moves_max": 58, "search_candidate_generations": 1198, "search_candidate_moves_total": 76484, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 3695, "avg_legality_checks": 527.8571428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3695, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11496, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1642.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24719618, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2150.2799234516356, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.428571428571429, "renju_forbidden_ns": 412726, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10861.21052631579, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 279984, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 132742, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9759579, "stage_ordering_ns": 41820, "stage_eval_ns": 34264157, "stage_threat_ns": 471757699, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 75663, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 415397605, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 79830, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6590, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37828, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 47335304, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 75656, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8944960, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 169, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 987, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5084.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6227.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 6, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2997, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 126, 98, 95, 99, 100, 114, 125, 80, 124, 127, 140, 155, 141, 85, 71, 156, 139, 142, 154, 168, 169, 109, 184 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 2955, "avg_search_time_ms": 227.30769230769232, "search_nodes": 248116, "safety_nodes": 479, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 248595, "avg_nodes": 19122.69230769231, "eval_calls": 242324, "avg_eval_calls": 18640.30769230769, "line_shape_eval_calls": 242324, "line_shape_eval_ns": 210944935, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 870.5078118552021, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5768, "avg_candidate_generations": 443.6923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 434769, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.37604022191401, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 5755, "search_candidate_moves_total": 433961, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 239270, "avg_legality_checks": 18405.384615384617, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1608, "root_legality_checks": 808, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 238462, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1603, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 254098, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19546.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 460910370, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1813.9079016757314, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1888, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 145.23076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9342496, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4948.35593220339, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1868, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9217296, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 125200, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.2307692307692308, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 103640, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6477.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.5384615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 44560, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2228.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 461102437, "stage_ordering_ns": 167440, "stage_eval_ns": 210944935, "stage_threat_ns": 2244675527, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 496171, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1950390200, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 175610, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 248079, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 249205766, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 496158, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44903951, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 439, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5028, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6291.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1920, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.3333333333333335, "search_nodes": 312, "safety_nodes": 680, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 992, "avg_nodes": 82.66666666666667, "eval_calls": 300, "avg_eval_calls": 25.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 300, "line_shape_eval_ns": 211382, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 704.6066666666667, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 748, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.333333333333336, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13762, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1146.8333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20691803, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1503.5462142130505, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 190360, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7321.538461538462, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 190360, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3760, "stage_ordering_ns": 490, "stage_eval_ns": 211382, "stage_threat_ns": 19106610, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 612, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18521067, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 177960, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 348892, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 600, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58691, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.416666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 7, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3506, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 115, 116, 129, 143, 95, 126, 128, 96, 81, 141, 156, 142, 97, 65, 145 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 24, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.6666666666666665, "search_nodes": 220, "safety_nodes": 507, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 727, "avg_nodes": 80.77777777777777, "eval_calls": 211, "avg_eval_calls": 23.444444444444443, "line_shape_eval_calls": 211, "line_shape_eval_ns": 101111, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 479.1990521327014, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 526, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_max": 73, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 526, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 526, "avg_legality_checks": 58.44444444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 526, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10925, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1213.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17689007, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1619.131075514874, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.2222222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3570, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1785.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3570, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 29, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.2222222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 280083, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9658.034482758621, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.777777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 151481, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3522.813953488372, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1092543, "stage_ordering_ns": 350, "stage_eval_ns": 101111, "stage_threat_ns": 14533384, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 431, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 13890600, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 376873, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6760, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 211, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 222311, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 422, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43600, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5775.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6664.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 3475, "avg_search_time_ms": 434.375, "search_nodes": 309698, "safety_nodes": 455, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 310153, "avg_nodes": 38769.125, "eval_calls": 304262, "avg_eval_calls": 38032.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 304262, "line_shape_eval_ns": 226734607, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 745.1952823553385, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5421, "avg_candidate_generations": 677.625, "candidate_moves_total": 398025, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.42280022136137, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 469, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 5413, "search_candidate_moves_total": 397556, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 9304, "avg_legality_checks": 1163.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9304, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18455, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2306.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 35046763, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1899.0389054456787, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 55250, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11050.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12260, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 42990, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22297982, "stage_ordering_ns": 149880, "stage_eval_ns": 226734607, "stage_threat_ns": 3211889995, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 619358, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2810780122, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 108511, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 309675, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 338036366, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 619350, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62964996, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 196, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4966, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5004.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6004.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1991, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 8, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3147, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 115, 116, 95, 159, 175, 144, 142, 100, 96, 158, 80, 64, 130, 101, 145, 160, 161, 99, 97, 102 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 3103, "avg_search_time_ms": 258.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 229590, "safety_nodes": 998, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 230588, "avg_nodes": 19215.666666666668, "eval_calls": 224297, "avg_eval_calls": 18691.416666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 224297, "line_shape_eval_ns": 197794195, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 881.8405729902763, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5270, "avg_candidate_generations": 439.1666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 412490, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.27134724857684, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 818, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 5258, "search_candidate_moves_total": 411672, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 220190, "avg_legality_checks": 18349.166666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 46, "root_legality_checks": 818, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 219372, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 46, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 234244, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19520.333333333332, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 471379819, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2012.3453279486348, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.8333333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 516195, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11221.630434782608, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 46, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 516195, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 493753, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9681.43137254902, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.166666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 252791, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3416.0945945945946, "stage_move_gen_ns": 460068969, "stage_ordering_ns": 159372, "stage_eval_ns": 197794195, "stage_threat_ns": 2423142296, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 459122, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2114850624, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 665793, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10970, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 229555, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 260557251, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 459110, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47068628, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 267, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4801, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6140.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6807.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1916, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 34, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.8333333333333335, "search_nodes": 367, "safety_nodes": 688, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1055, "avg_nodes": 87.91666666666667, "eval_calls": 355, "avg_eval_calls": 29.583333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 355, "line_shape_eval_ns": 292390, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 823.6338028169014, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 836, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.66666666666667, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 836, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13807, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1150.5833333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22775557, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1649.5659448106032, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4460, "stage_ordering_ns": 480, "stage_eval_ns": 292390, "stage_threat_ns": 21102307, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 722, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20452305, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 123110, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11030, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 355, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 446022, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 710, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 80870, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 9, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1414, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 157, 172, 141, 125, 83, 96, 126, 98, 99, 95, 94, 110, 113, 85, 155 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 17, "avg_search_time_ms": 1.8888888888888888, "search_nodes": 220, "safety_nodes": 507, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 727, "avg_nodes": 80.77777777777777, "eval_calls": 211, "avg_eval_calls": 23.444444444444443, "line_shape_eval_calls": 211, "line_shape_eval_ns": 72442, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 343.3270142180095, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 526, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_max": 73, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 526, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 526, "avg_legality_checks": 58.44444444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 526, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10925, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1213.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11956266, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1094.395057208238, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.2222222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2380, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1190.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2380, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 29, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.2222222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 194912, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6721.103448275862, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.777777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 110121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2560.953488372093, "stage_move_gen_ns": 766553, "stage_ordering_ns": 530, "stage_eval_ns": 72442, "stage_threat_ns": 10503062, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 431, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 10014809, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 267282, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 211, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 182490, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 422, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38481, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5775.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6664.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1391, "avg_search_time_ms": 173.875, "search_nodes": 175525, "safety_nodes": 455, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 175980, "avg_nodes": 21997.5, "eval_calls": 171273, "avg_eval_calls": 21409.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 171273, "line_shape_eval_ns": 84803182, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 495.13456294920974, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4237, "avg_candidate_generations": 529.625, "candidate_moves_total": 311473, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.51262685862639, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 469, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 4229, "search_candidate_moves_total": 311004, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 8177, "avg_legality_checks": 1022.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8177, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17328, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2166.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23671846, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1366.1037626962143, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 38370, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6395.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12040, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 26330, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13948919, "stage_ordering_ns": 116700, "stage_eval_ns": 84803182, "stage_threat_ns": 1267760396, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 351012, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1100352972, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 108090, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 175502, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 141160328, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 351004, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26139006, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 196, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3847, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5353.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6353.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1991, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 10, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2949, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 157, 172, 83, 139, 153, 140, 110, 158, 98, 124, 78, 94, 84, 70, 109, 156, 108, 188 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2901, "avg_search_time_ms": 263.72727272727275, "search_nodes": 182372, "safety_nodes": 864, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 183236, "avg_nodes": 16657.81818181818, "eval_calls": 177586, "avg_eval_calls": 16144.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 177586, "line_shape_eval_ns": 152445686, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 858.4330183685651, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4765, "avg_candidate_generations": 433.1818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 352419, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.95991605456453, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 757, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 4754, "search_candidate_moves_total": 351662, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 173543, "avg_legality_checks": 15776.636363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 757, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 172786, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 186354, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16941.272727272728, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 444284078, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2384.0866200886485, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.45454545454545453, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61191, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12238.2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 61191, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 34, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 388573, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11428.617647058823, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.545454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 196990, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3939.8, "stage_move_gen_ns": 431474468, "stage_ordering_ns": 146331, "stage_eval_ns": 152445686, "stage_threat_ns": 2300643863, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 364691, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2023425980, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 571633, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 182340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 232422058, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 364680, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44224192, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 262, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4321, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5800.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6527.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1949, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 37, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3636363636363638, "search_nodes": 370, "safety_nodes": 545, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 915, "avg_nodes": 83.18181818181819, "eval_calls": 359, "avg_eval_calls": 32.63636363636363, "line_shape_eval_calls": 359, "line_shape_eval_ns": 391650, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1090.9470752089137, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 786, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.45454545454545, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12666, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1151.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25460180, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2010.1200063161218, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4490, "stage_ordering_ns": 420, "stage_eval_ns": 391650, "stage_threat_ns": 24321073, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 729, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 23635678, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 91201, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10921, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 359, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 502474, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 718, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 91720, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6179.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 11, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 608, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 109, 108, 95, 81, 65, 80, 94, 78, 82, 77, 96, 79 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.857142857142857, "search_nodes": 274, "safety_nodes": 234, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 508, "avg_nodes": 72.57142857142857, "eval_calls": 267, "avg_eval_calls": 38.142857142857146, "line_shape_eval_calls": 267, "line_shape_eval_ns": 202811, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 759.5917602996254, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 385, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.0, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 385, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 385, "avg_legality_checks": 55.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 385, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17864344, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2137.1388922119872, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.2857142857142856, "renju_forbidden_ns": 176701, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11043.8125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 35380, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 141321, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 189251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12616.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 106420, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4626.95652173913, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1058945, "stage_ordering_ns": 250, "stage_eval_ns": 202811, "stage_threat_ns": 16716716, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 541, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15966800, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 273402, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 406153, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 70361, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 574, "avg_search_time_ms": 82.0, "search_nodes": 39456, "safety_nodes": 313, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 39769, "avg_nodes": 5681.285714285715, "eval_calls": 38190, "avg_eval_calls": 5455.714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 38190, "line_shape_eval_ns": 37586771, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 984.2045299816706, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1254, "avg_candidate_generations": 179.14285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 85323, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.04066985645933, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 393, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 1247, "search_candidate_moves_total": 84930, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 3118, "avg_legality_checks": 445.42857142857144, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3118, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11033, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1576.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24518946, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2222.328106589323, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 383533, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11622.212121212122, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 201131, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 182402, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8645855, "stage_ordering_ns": 42131, "stage_eval_ns": 37586771, "stage_threat_ns": 519191591, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 78881, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 456221749, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 81942, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 39437, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 53171756, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 78874, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9716144, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 185, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1026, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5081.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6224.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 12, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6199, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 95, 81, 65, 129, 145, 80, 79, 127, 47, 63, 125, 128, 130, 140, 93, 51, 109, 108, 141, 77, 157 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6150, "avg_search_time_ms": 512.5, "search_nodes": 396478, "safety_nodes": 629, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 397107, "avg_nodes": 33092.25, "eval_calls": 388087, "avg_eval_calls": 32340.583333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 388087, "line_shape_eval_ns": 511137414, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1317.0691468665532, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8369, "avg_candidate_generations": 697.4166666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 726211, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.77392758991516, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 858, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 8357, "search_candidate_moves_total": 725353, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 384841, "avg_legality_checks": 32070.083333333332, "illegal_moves_skipped": 249, "root_legality_checks": 858, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 383983, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 247, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 398780, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 33231.666666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 887274952, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2224.9735493254425, "renju_forbidden_checks": 527, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 43.916666666666664, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4591955, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8713.387096774193, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 519, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4502644, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 89311, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.9166666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 227631, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9897.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.5833333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 107320, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3461.935483870968, "stage_move_gen_ns": 887639586, "stage_ordering_ns": 244151, "stage_eval_ns": 511137414, "stage_threat_ns": 4707025839, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 792900, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4115085769, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 329982, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12140, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 396444, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 501334247, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 792888, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 90275841, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 439, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7428, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6064.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6731.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1911, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.272727272727273, "search_nodes": 239, "safety_nodes": 896, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1135, "avg_nodes": 103.18181818181819, "eval_calls": 228, "avg_eval_calls": 20.727272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 228, "line_shape_eval_ns": 253872, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1113.4736842105262, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 797, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.45454545454545, "candidate_moves_max": 92, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 797, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12810, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1164.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26287810, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2052.1319281811084, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2727272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 103852, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7418.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 103852, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4550, "stage_ordering_ns": 450, "stage_eval_ns": 253872, "stage_threat_ns": 23054435, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 467, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22456433, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 202751, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11720, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 228, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 337590, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 456, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57661, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 13, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 696, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 67, 52, 83, 99, 85, 84, 68, 54, 114, 39, 98, 69 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 274, "safety_nodes": 234, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 508, "avg_nodes": 72.57142857142857, "eval_calls": 267, "avg_eval_calls": 38.142857142857146, "line_shape_eval_calls": 267, "line_shape_eval_ns": 190351, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 712.9250936329588, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 385, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.0, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 385, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 385, "avg_legality_checks": 55.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 385, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16982820, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2031.68082306496, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.2857142857142856, "renju_forbidden_ns": 172932, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10808.25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 35891, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 137041, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 175902, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11726.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 99521, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4327.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1007616, "stage_ordering_ns": 220, "stage_eval_ns": 190351, "stage_threat_ns": 15712385, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 541, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15023370, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 253932, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6890, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 369742, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65341, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 664, "avg_search_time_ms": 94.85714285714286, "search_nodes": 48619, "safety_nodes": 313, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48932, "avg_nodes": 6990.285714285715, "eval_calls": 47231, "avg_eval_calls": 6747.285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 47231, "line_shape_eval_ns": 42617471, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 902.3198958311278, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1376, "avg_candidate_generations": 196.57142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 93489, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.94258720930233, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 393, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 1369, "search_candidate_moves_total": 93096, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 3362, "avg_legality_checks": 480.2857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3362, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11277, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1611.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23683227, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2100.1354083532856, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 379471, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11499.121212121212, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 198400, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 181071, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8633526, "stage_ordering_ns": 44801, "stage_eval_ns": 42617471, "stage_threat_ns": 601402439, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 97207, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 529499754, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 80850, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6590, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48600, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 60465016, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 97200, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11356819, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 185, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1140, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5060.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6203.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 14, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1343, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 99, 85, 141, 155, 81, 111, 125, 98, 67, 84, 86, 70, 126, 56 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1309, "avg_search_time_ms": 145.44444444444446, "search_nodes": 85281, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85512, "avg_nodes": 9501.333333333334, "eval_calls": 82348, "avg_eval_calls": 9149.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 82348, "line_shape_eval_ns": 81138140, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 985.307961334823, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2917, "avg_candidate_generations": 324.1111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 220160, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.47480287967089, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 550, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 2908, "search_candidate_moves_total": 219610, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 79568, "avg_legality_checks": 8840.888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 23, "root_legality_checks": 550, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 79018, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 23, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 89991, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9999.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 203574079, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2262.1604271538263, "renju_forbidden_checks": 51, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.666666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 287272, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5632.78431372549, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 51, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 287272, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 93280, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10364.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.4444444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 47050, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3619.230769230769, "stage_move_gen_ns": 188483359, "stage_ordering_ns": 91440, "stage_eval_ns": 81138140, "stage_threat_ns": 1025462444, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 170521, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 897679205, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 142030, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85256, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108229444, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 170512, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19411765, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 371, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2405, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5707.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6596.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1926, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.25, "search_nodes": 135, "safety_nodes": 594, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 729, "avg_nodes": 91.125, "eval_calls": 127, "avg_eval_calls": 15.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 127, "line_shape_eval_ns": 106662, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 839.8582677165355, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 487, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.875, "candidate_moves_max": 76, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 487, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9310, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1163.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18518707, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1989.119978517723, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2920, "stage_ordering_ns": 290, "stage_eval_ns": 106662, "stage_threat_ns": 15612125, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 262, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15241184, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 148161, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8270, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 127, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 191130, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 254, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31650, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5496.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6496.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 15, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2915, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 109, 108, 125, 141, 99, 128, 126, 98, 83, 143, 158, 142, 97, 69, 139 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 24, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.6666666666666665, "search_nodes": 220, "safety_nodes": 507, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 727, "avg_nodes": 80.77777777777777, "eval_calls": 211, "avg_eval_calls": 23.444444444444443, "line_shape_eval_calls": 211, "line_shape_eval_ns": 104980, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 497.53554502369667, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 526, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_max": 73, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 526, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 526, "avg_legality_checks": 58.44444444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 526, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10925, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1213.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16342022, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1495.8372540045766, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.2222222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2500, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1250.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2500, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 29, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.2222222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 229772, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7923.172413793103, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.777777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 129952, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3022.139534883721, "stage_move_gen_ns": 970843, "stage_ordering_ns": 330, "stage_eval_ns": 104980, "stage_threat_ns": 14671003, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 431, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14046290, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 316112, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 211, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 262861, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 422, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45740, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5773.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 2885, "avg_search_time_ms": 360.625, "search_nodes": 296303, "safety_nodes": 455, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 296758, "avg_nodes": 37094.75, "eval_calls": 290953, "avg_eval_calls": 36369.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 290953, "line_shape_eval_ns": 180825053, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 621.4923131914777, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5335, "avg_candidate_generations": 666.875, "candidate_moves_total": 391466, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.37694470477976, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 469, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 5327, "search_candidate_moves_total": 390997, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 9466, "avg_legality_checks": 1183.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9466, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18617, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2327.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 33271218, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1787.1417521620024, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33470, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6694.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7990, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 25480, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 21107492, "stage_ordering_ns": 148950, "stage_eval_ns": 180825053, "stage_threat_ns": 2666755907, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 592568, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2320846172, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 93352, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6091, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 296280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 292893173, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 592560, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52923210, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 196, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4887, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5077.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6077.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 16, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2351, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 85, 71, 93, 140, 95, 97, 94, 92, 83, 126, 98, 139, 153, 142, 138, 143 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 2321, "avg_search_time_ms": 193.41666666666666, "search_nodes": 247523, "safety_nodes": 941, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 248464, "avg_nodes": 20705.333333333332, "eval_calls": 242829, "avg_eval_calls": 20235.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 242829, "line_shape_eval_ns": 158374022, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 652.2039048054393, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4672, "avg_candidate_generations": 389.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 373842, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.01755136986301, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 844, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 4660, "search_candidate_moves_total": 372998, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 239371, "avg_legality_checks": 19947.583333333332, "illegal_moves_skipped": 601, "root_legality_checks": 844, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 238527, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 600, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 253444, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21120.333333333332, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 338440122, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1335.3645065576616, "renju_forbidden_checks": 608, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 50.666666666666664, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3705035, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6093.807565789473, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 602, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3682215, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 22820, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.833333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 298552, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5147.448275862069, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.166666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 132101, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1785.1486486486488, "stage_move_gen_ns": 339096146, "stage_ordering_ns": 125390, "stage_eval_ns": 158374022, "stage_threat_ns": 1775236013, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 494990, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1537080969, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 403893, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6290, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 247489, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 201671419, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 494978, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36079732, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 290, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4208, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6222.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6889.416666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1952, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 17, "avg_search_time_ms": 1.5454545454545454, "search_nodes": 78, "safety_nodes": 1223, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1301, "avg_nodes": 118.27272727272727, "eval_calls": 67, "avg_eval_calls": 6.090909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 67, "line_shape_eval_ns": 32070, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 478.65671641791045, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 776, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.54545454545455, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 776, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12840, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1167.2727272727273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14194823, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1105.5158099688474, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.36363636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 26250, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6562.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 26250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3020, "stage_ordering_ns": 360, "stage_eval_ns": 32070, "stage_threat_ns": 12085609, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 145, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 11805897, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 200781, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68361, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 134, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10570, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6180.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6907.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1999, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 17, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 359, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 115, 116, 99, 83, 69, 84, 100, 86, 82, 87, 98, 85 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 16, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.2857142857142856, "search_nodes": 274, "safety_nodes": 234, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 508, "avg_nodes": 72.57142857142857, "eval_calls": 267, "avg_eval_calls": 38.142857142857146, "line_shape_eval_calls": 267, "line_shape_eval_ns": 127501, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 477.53183520599254, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 385, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.0, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 385, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 385, "avg_legality_checks": 55.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 385, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10644575, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1273.4268453164254, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.2857142857142856, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124430, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7776.875, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26060, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 98370, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 145071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9671.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 83651, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3637.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 667515, "stage_ordering_ns": 240, "stage_eval_ns": 127501, "stage_threat_ns": 10147932, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 541, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 9624169, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 209281, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4580, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 267212, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47270, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5140.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6282.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 337, "avg_search_time_ms": 48.142857142857146, "search_nodes": 38286, "safety_nodes": 313, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 38599, "avg_nodes": 5514.142857142857, "eval_calls": 37017, "avg_eval_calls": 5288.142857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 37017, "line_shape_eval_ns": 21216033, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 573.1429613420861, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1257, "avg_candidate_generations": 179.57142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 85230, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.80429594272077, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 393, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 1250, "search_candidate_moves_total": 84837, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 3156, "avg_legality_checks": 450.85714285714283, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3156, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11071, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1581.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15525137, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1402.3247222473128, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.571428571428571, "renju_forbidden_ns": 272651, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8520.34375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 146961, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 125690, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6693846, "stage_ordering_ns": 38200, "stage_eval_ns": 21216033, "stage_threat_ns": 301382685, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 76541, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 262558481, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 46980, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3710, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 32695982, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 76534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6081242, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 185, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1025, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5113.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6255.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1992, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 18, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4738, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 98, 83, 115, 116, 69, 125, 139, 126, 129, 127, 124, 110, 84, 99, 130, 82, 109, 94, 70, 56, 100, 85, 145, 160, 146, 162, 154, 169, 161, 177, 142, 78, 62, 176, 144, 143, 147, 148, 159, 174, 175, 190, 134, 204 ], "move_count": 50, "black_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 4670, "avg_search_time_ms": 203.04347826086956, "search_nodes": 417979, "safety_nodes": 2668, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 420647, "avg_nodes": 18289.0, "eval_calls": 409453, "avg_eval_calls": 17802.304347826088, "line_shape_eval_calls": 409453, "line_shape_eval_ns": 532450783, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1300.3953640588786, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8481, "avg_candidate_generations": 368.7391304347826, "candidate_moves_total": 762886, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.95236410800614, "candidate_moves_max": 138, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1967, "root_candidate_moves_max": 122, "search_candidate_generations": 8458, "search_candidate_moves_total": 760919, "search_candidate_moves_max": 138, "legality_checks": 398863, "avg_legality_checks": 17341.869565217392, "illegal_moves_skipped": 922, "root_legality_checks": 1967, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 396896, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 918, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 425681, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18507.869565217392, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 646189081, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1518.0125046689893, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1156, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 50.26086956521739, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4701322, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4066.887543252595, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1138, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4620132, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 81190, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 144, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.260869565217392, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1017036, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7062.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 200, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.695652173913043, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 540773, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2703.865, "stage_move_gen_ns": 641292534, "stage_ordering_ns": 241710, "stage_eval_ns": 532450783, "stage_threat_ns": 3417521834, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 835845, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2960133566, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 65, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1429710, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 417911, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 386508068, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 835822, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69450490, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 497, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7666, "depth_sum": 68, "avg_depth": 2.9565217391304346, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 68, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9565217391304346, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7071.521739130435, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7419.347826086957, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1951, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 42, "avg_search_time_ms": 1.826086956521739, "search_nodes": 606, "safety_nodes": 1734, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2340, "avg_nodes": 101.73913043478261, "eval_calls": 583, "avg_eval_calls": 25.347826086956523, "line_shape_eval_calls": 583, "line_shape_eval_ns": 490783, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 841.8233276157805, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1998, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.8695652173913, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1998, "root_candidate_moves_max": 122, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1131.5652173913043, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 32584184, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1251.9858602935526, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.8695652173913043, "renju_forbidden_ns": 120431, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6021.55, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 120431, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8370, "stage_ordering_ns": 880, "stage_eval_ns": 490783, "stage_threat_ns": 30292432, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1189, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 29545520, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 56, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 149870, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 583, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 510982, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1166, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 86060, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 23 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7129.826086956522, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7477.652173913043, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1999, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 19, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2087, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 157, 172, 143, 129, 81, 98, 128, 96, 95, 99, 100, 114, 111, 79, 159 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 29, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.2222222222222223, "search_nodes": 220, "safety_nodes": 507, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 727, "avg_nodes": 80.77777777777777, "eval_calls": 211, "avg_eval_calls": 23.444444444444443, "line_shape_eval_calls": 211, "line_shape_eval_ns": 120652, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 571.8104265402843, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 526, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_max": 73, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 526, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 526, "avg_legality_checks": 58.44444444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 526, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10925, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1213.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20231109, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1851.817757437071, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.2222222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3610, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1805.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 29, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.2222222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 287363, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9909.068965517241, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.777777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 158142, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3677.720930232558, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1619837, "stage_ordering_ns": 310, "stage_eval_ns": 120652, "stage_threat_ns": 16903090, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 431, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16173377, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 396843, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7670, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 211, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 281360, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 422, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51510, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5773.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 2051, "avg_search_time_ms": 256.375, "search_nodes": 189878, "safety_nodes": 455, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 190333, "avg_nodes": 23791.625, "eval_calls": 185476, "avg_eval_calls": 23184.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 185476, "line_shape_eval_ns": 129454500, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 697.9582264012595, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4387, "avg_candidate_generations": 548.375, "candidate_moves_total": 321899, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.3756553453385, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 469, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 4379, "search_candidate_moves_total": 321430, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 8148, "avg_legality_checks": 1018.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8148, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17299, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2162.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 34335317, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1984.8151338227642, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 41490, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6915.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15010, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 26480, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19566724, "stage_ordering_ns": 122440, "stage_eval_ns": 129454500, "stage_threat_ns": 1883649166, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 379718, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1651516674, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 114121, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7130, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 189855, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 194766955, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 379710, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37251416, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 196, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3992, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5274.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6274.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 20, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3713, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 129, 157, 172, 81, 145, 161, 144, 114, 156, 96, 130, 80, 64, 158, 171, 159, 160, 175, 141, 111, 186 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 3661, "avg_search_time_ms": 305.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 226921, "safety_nodes": 998, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 227919, "avg_nodes": 18993.25, "eval_calls": 221252, "avg_eval_calls": 18437.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 221252, "line_shape_eval_ns": 210409792, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 950.9961130294868, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5646, "avg_candidate_generations": 470.5, "candidate_moves_total": 426232, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.49273822174992, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 818, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 5634, "search_candidate_moves_total": 425414, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 217286, "avg_legality_checks": 18107.166666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 818, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 216468, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 231340, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19278.333333333332, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 559840949, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2419.99199878966, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 69691, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11615.166666666666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 69691, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 536824, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10525.960784313726, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.166666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 273534, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3696.4054054054054, "stage_move_gen_ns": 546097093, "stage_ordering_ns": 165931, "stage_eval_ns": 210409792, "stage_threat_ns": 2902112407, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 453784, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2542526824, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 727604, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12050, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 226886, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 303807098, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 453772, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55050881, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 267, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5141, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5940.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6607.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1927, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 41, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4166666666666665, "search_nodes": 367, "safety_nodes": 688, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1055, "avg_nodes": 87.91666666666667, "eval_calls": 355, "avg_eval_calls": 29.583333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 355, "line_shape_eval_ns": 359943, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1013.9239436619719, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 836, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.66666666666667, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 836, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13807, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1150.5833333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27270124, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1975.094082711668, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4780, "stage_ordering_ns": 490, "stage_eval_ns": 359943, "stage_threat_ns": 25176609, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 722, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24478607, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 133500, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11830, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 355, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 478442, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 710, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 86060, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 21, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 696, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 67, 52, 81, 95, 79, 80, 66, 50, 110, 35, 96, 65 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 274, "safety_nodes": 234, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 508, "avg_nodes": 72.57142857142857, "eval_calls": 267, "avg_eval_calls": 38.142857142857146, "line_shape_eval_calls": 267, "line_shape_eval_ns": 192754, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 721.9250936329588, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 385, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.0, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 385, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 385, "avg_legality_checks": 55.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 385, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16847019, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2015.434740997727, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.2857142857142856, "renju_forbidden_ns": 168730, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10545.625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 35140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 133590, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 176492, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11766.133333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 100541, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4371.347826086957, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1001646, "stage_ordering_ns": 230, "stage_eval_ns": 192754, "stage_threat_ns": 15766765, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 541, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15089581, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 253182, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7050, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 357652, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66350, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 664, "avg_search_time_ms": 94.85714285714286, "search_nodes": 48489, "safety_nodes": 313, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48802, "avg_nodes": 6971.714285714285, "eval_calls": 47109, "avg_eval_calls": 6729.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 47109, "line_shape_eval_ns": 43105268, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 915.0113141862489, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1368, "avg_candidate_generations": 195.42857142857142, "candidate_moves_total": 92759, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.80628654970761, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 393, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 1361, "search_candidate_moves_total": 92366, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 3444, "avg_legality_checks": 492.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3444, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1622.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23406337, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2060.5983801390967, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.857142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 368661, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10842.970588235294, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 197150, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 171511, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8459553, "stage_ordering_ns": 43001, "stage_eval_ns": 43105268, "stage_threat_ns": 604037312, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 96947, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 532337389, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 77450, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6530, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48470, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 60249734, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 96940, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11372739, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 185, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1137, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5061.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6204.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 22, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2846, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 81, 95, 79, 143, 159, 80, 65, 113, 33, 49, 83, 128, 158, 84, 51, 37, 67, 52, 99, 35, 115 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 2798, "avg_search_time_ms": 233.16666666666666, "search_nodes": 188606, "safety_nodes": 626, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 189232, "avg_nodes": 15769.333333333334, "eval_calls": 183494, "avg_eval_calls": 15291.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 183494, "line_shape_eval_ns": 243266610, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1325.7469454042093, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5090, "avg_candidate_generations": 424.1666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 444523, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.33261296660118, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 855, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 5078, "search_candidate_moves_total": 443668, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 180456, "avg_legality_checks": 15038.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 170, "root_legality_checks": 855, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 179601, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 168, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 194391, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16199.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 408182591, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2099.8018992648836, "renju_forbidden_checks": 264, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 22.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2310712, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8752.69696969697, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 256, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2234562, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 76150, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.9166666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 221112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9613.565217391304, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.5833333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 103341, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3333.5806451612902, "stage_move_gen_ns": 394660465, "stage_ordering_ns": 146930, "stage_eval_ns": 243266610, "stage_threat_ns": 2127152717, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 377156, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1855169624, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 316172, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11440, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 188572, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 230573560, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 377144, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41093361, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 439, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4367, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6279.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6946.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1925, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.272727272727273, "search_nodes": 239, "safety_nodes": 895, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1134, "avg_nodes": 103.0909090909091, "eval_calls": 228, "avg_eval_calls": 20.727272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 228, "line_shape_eval_ns": 236850, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1038.8157894736842, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 796, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.36363636363636, "candidate_moves_max": 92, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 796, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12806, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1164.1818181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25425615, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1985.4454942995471, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.7272727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 81000, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10125.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 81000, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4480, "stage_ordering_ns": 460, "stage_eval_ns": 236850, "stage_threat_ns": 22167461, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 467, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21607391, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 195070, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11200, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 228, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 310930, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 456, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 54070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 23, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5452, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 126, 70, 56, 69, 127, 125, 110, 94, 143, 83, 141, 111, 97, 140, 129, 130, 113, 99, 158, 173, 174 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 39, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5454545454545454, "search_nodes": 275, "safety_nodes": 919, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1194, "avg_nodes": 108.54545454545455, "eval_calls": 264, "avg_eval_calls": 24.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 264, "line_shape_eval_ns": 188381, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 713.564393939394, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 800, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.72727272727273, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 800, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 800, "avg_legality_checks": 72.72727272727273, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 800, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13967, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1269.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28134525, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2014.3570559175198, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.090909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 360522, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10603.588235294117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 71660, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 288862, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 614413, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11378.018518518518, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 78, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 342472, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4390.666666666667, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2057872, "stage_ordering_ns": 440, "stage_eval_ns": 188381, "stage_threat_ns": 23637523, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 539, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22371185, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 843895, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11220, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 356773, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65670, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5401, "avg_search_time_ms": 491.0, "search_nodes": 408677, "safety_nodes": 491, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 409168, "avg_nodes": 37197.09090909091, "eval_calls": 401364, "avg_eval_calls": 36487.63636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 401364, "line_shape_eval_ns": 424920645, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1058.6914745717104, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7293, "avg_candidate_generations": 663.0, "candidate_moves_total": 623384, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.47703277115042, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 832, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 7282, "search_candidate_moves_total": 622552, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 13035, "avg_legality_checks": 1185.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 68, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 13035, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 68, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 25946, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2358.7272727272725, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 58571427, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2257.435712633932, "renju_forbidden_checks": 110, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1294940, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11772.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 856097, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 438843, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 37212413, "stage_ordering_ns": 223810, "stage_eval_ns": 424920645, "stage_threat_ns": 4927754197, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 817303, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4310811209, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 124921, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 408646, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 522869476, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 817292, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 93948591, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 485, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6533, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5788.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6515.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 24, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5652, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 84, 97, 114, 100, 156, 170, 99, 154, 140, 129, 69, 54, 141, 143, 139, 138, 122, 113, 81, 111, 110, 127, 95, 125, 83, 159, 175, 145, 161, 186, 202, 123, 124, 108, 82, 80, 85 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 5591, "avg_search_time_ms": 294.2631578947368, "search_nodes": 443972, "safety_nodes": 2109, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 446081, "avg_nodes": 23477.947368421053, "eval_calls": 434787, "avg_eval_calls": 22883.526315789473, "line_shape_eval_calls": 434787, "line_shape_eval_ns": 445036950, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1023.5746468960664, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9148, "avg_candidate_generations": 481.4736842105263, "candidate_moves_total": 832377, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.99005247048535, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1623, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 9129, "search_candidate_moves_total": 830754, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 428169, "avg_legality_checks": 22535.21052631579, "illegal_moves_skipped": 650, "root_legality_checks": 1623, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 426546, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 646, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 450526, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23711.894736842107, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 823386530, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1827.6115695875487, "renju_forbidden_checks": 666, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 35.05263157894737, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4066147, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6105.325825825826, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 650, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3982727, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 83420, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.157894736842105, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 631872, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6447.673469387755, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 129, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.7894736842105265, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 307262, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2381.875968992248, "stage_move_gen_ns": 820737208, "stage_ordering_ns": 256660, "stage_eval_ns": 445036950, "stage_threat_ns": 4266827618, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 887851, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3718405464, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 53, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 873372, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13740, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 443916, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 462568345, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 887832, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 84980437, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 451, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8440, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6625.368421052632, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7046.421052631579, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1914, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 39, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.0526315789473686, "search_nodes": 535, "safety_nodes": 1713, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2248, "avg_nodes": 118.3157894736842, "eval_calls": 516, "avg_eval_calls": 27.157894736842106, "line_shape_eval_calls": 516, "line_shape_eval_ns": 460374, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 892.1976744186046, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1654, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.05263157894737, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1654, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21962, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1155.8947368421052, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30495814, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1388.571805846462, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.0526315789473684, "renju_forbidden_ns": 117880, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5894.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 117880, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6980, "stage_ordering_ns": 760, "stage_eval_ns": 460374, "stage_threat_ns": 28253152, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1051, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 27370131, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 50, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 257890, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13150, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 516, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 533541, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1032, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 91590, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6945.631578947368, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7366.684210526316, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 25, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 670, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 144, 160, 97, 95, 65, 94, 142, 62, 78, 125, 140, 127, 113, 81, 143, 141, 98, 83, 158 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 30, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.727272727272727, "search_nodes": 432, "safety_nodes": 532, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 964, "avg_nodes": 87.63636363636364, "eval_calls": 421, "avg_eval_calls": 38.27272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 421, "line_shape_eval_ns": 378552, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 899.1733966745843, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 813, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.9090909090909, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 813, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 813, "avg_legality_checks": 73.9090909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 813, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13808, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1255.2727272727273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20918283, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1514.9393829663964, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.3636363636363635, "renju_forbidden_ns": 244023, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 16268.2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 42980, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 201043, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.9090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 76110, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7611.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.3636363636363635, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 45210, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3014.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1646907, "stage_ordering_ns": 390, "stage_eval_ns": 378552, "stage_threat_ns": 19175441, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 853, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18460661, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 132140, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7830, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 421, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 496940, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 842, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 85700, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6180.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6907.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 631, "avg_search_time_ms": 63.1, "search_nodes": 68558, "safety_nodes": 974, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 69532, "avg_nodes": 6953.2, "eval_calls": 66675, "avg_eval_calls": 6667.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 66675, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44388998, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 665.7517510311211, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1864, "avg_candidate_generations": 186.4, "candidate_moves_total": 153458, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.32725321888412, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 745, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 1854, "search_candidate_moves_total": 152713, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 4953, "avg_legality_checks": 495.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4953, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16825, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1682.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24964061, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1483.7480534918277, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 269940, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 13497.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 108340, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 161600, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8719143, "stage_ordering_ns": 54771, "stage_eval_ns": 44388998, "stage_threat_ns": 558259902, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 137068, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 488724585, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 125480, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68529, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 58352971, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 137058, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11056866, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 161, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1628, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5962.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6762.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1988, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 26, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3878, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 97, 95, 125, 65, 50, 94, 142, 78, 62, 82, 111, 79, 81, 77, 76, 83, 113, 66, 127, 157, 114, 115, 100, 156, 86 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3837, "avg_search_time_ms": 274.07142857142856, "search_nodes": 308164, "safety_nodes": 1056, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 309220, "avg_nodes": 22087.14285714286, "eval_calls": 301973, "avg_eval_calls": 21569.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 301973, "line_shape_eval_ns": 221993558, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 735.143731393204, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6165, "avg_candidate_generations": 440.35714285714283, "candidate_moves_total": 457654, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.23422546634225, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 962, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 6151, "search_candidate_moves_total": 456692, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 298523, "avg_legality_checks": 21323.071428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 345, "root_legality_checks": 962, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 297561, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 345, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 314686, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22477.571428571428, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 574902082, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1826.9070819801325, "renju_forbidden_checks": 364, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 26.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2113664, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5806.7692307692305, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 360, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2108624, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5040, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 427073, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6280.485294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.928571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 199442, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2056.103092783505, "stage_move_gen_ns": 571703796, "stage_ordering_ns": 183152, "stage_eval_ns": 221993558, "stage_threat_ns": 3001547064, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 616262, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2616125304, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 555513, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9610, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 308124, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 325035743, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 616248, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59830504, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 293, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5701, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6081.642857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6653.071428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1906, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 29, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.230769230769231, "search_nodes": 271, "safety_nodes": 1059, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1330, "avg_nodes": 102.3076923076923, "eval_calls": 258, "avg_eval_calls": 19.846153846153847, "line_shape_eval_calls": 258, "line_shape_eval_ns": 159940, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 619.922480620155, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 892, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.61538461538461, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 892, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14800, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1138.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19733949, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1333.3749324324324, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4090, "stage_ordering_ns": 560, "stage_eval_ns": 159940, "stage_threat_ns": 17918349, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 529, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17425969, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 185970, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 258, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 262340, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 516, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6459.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7075.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 27, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1041, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 113, 83, 81, 68, 110, 40, 54, 85, 86, 111, 127, 97, 69, 139, 95, 125 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 39, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.9, "search_nodes": 351, "safety_nodes": 609, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 960, "avg_nodes": 96.0, "eval_calls": 341, "avg_eval_calls": 34.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 341, "line_shape_eval_ns": 273883, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 803.1759530791788, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 730, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.0, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 730, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 730, "avg_legality_checks": 73.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 730, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12611, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1261.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25864273, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2050.92958528269, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 192271, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8739.59090909091, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 39251, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 153020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 22, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 279532, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12706.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 33, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 158361, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4798.818181818182, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1861188, "stage_ordering_ns": 510, "stage_eval_ns": 273883, "stage_threat_ns": 22450446, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 692, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21491834, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 431672, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 341, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 446950, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 682, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 79990, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 996, "avg_search_time_ms": 99.6, "search_nodes": 79780, "safety_nodes": 717, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 80497, "avg_nodes": 8049.7, "eval_calls": 77268, "avg_eval_calls": 7726.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 77268, "line_shape_eval_ns": 78266074, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1012.9170419837449, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2494, "avg_candidate_generations": 249.4, "candidate_moves_total": 212098, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.04330392943064, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 746, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 2484, "search_candidate_moves_total": 211352, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 8542, "avg_legality_checks": 854.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8542, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20339, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2033.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 42380862, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2083.723978563351, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 483512, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10988.90909090909, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 203461, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 280051, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20077319, "stage_ordering_ns": 92011, "stage_eval_ns": 78266074, "stage_threat_ns": 874904180, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 159514, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 765303315, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 144021, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9880, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79752, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92463169, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 159504, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16993675, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 327, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2082, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5939.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6739.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 28, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5433, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 113, 83, 81, 85, 86, 68, 110, 54, 40, 111, 97, 65, 142, 94, 128, 129, 114, 100, 127, 157, 156, 170, 125, 124, 140, 154, 95, 80, 155 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 5388, "avg_search_time_ms": 336.75, "search_nodes": 523502, "safety_nodes": 1384, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 524886, "avg_nodes": 32805.375, "eval_calls": 514329, "avg_eval_calls": 32145.5625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 514329, "line_shape_eval_ns": 415255915, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 807.3741029574455, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9143, "avg_candidate_generations": 571.4375, "candidate_moves_total": 771978, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.43377447227387, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1242, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 9127, "search_candidate_moves_total": 770736, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 507845, "avg_legality_checks": 31740.3125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 650, "root_legality_checks": 1242, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 506603, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 643, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 526415, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32900.9375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 772312666, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1467.1175137486584, "renju_forbidden_checks": 782, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 48.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4217697, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5393.47442455243, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 743, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4119057, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 98640, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.6875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 409152, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6934.779661016949, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 82, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 170381, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2077.817073170732, "stage_move_gen_ns": 780207410, "stage_ordering_ns": 268480, "stage_eval_ns": 415255915, "stage_threat_ns": 4094714777, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1046928, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3536469965, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 613164, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 523456, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 472787210, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1046912, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 84844438, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 481, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8435, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6484.8125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6984.8125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1941, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 33, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.2, "search_nodes": 283, "safety_nodes": 1251, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1534, "avg_nodes": 102.26666666666667, "eval_calls": 268, "avg_eval_calls": 17.866666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 268, "line_shape_eval_ns": 155841, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 581.4962686567164, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1162, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.46666666666667, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1162, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17236, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1149.0666666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23188523, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1345.354084474356, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.2666666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 89030, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2618.529411764706, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 89030, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5180, "stage_ordering_ns": 610, "stage_eval_ns": 155841, "stage_threat_ns": 20381030, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 551, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19914478, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 159371, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 268, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 263481, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 536, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43700, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 15, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 15, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6665.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7198.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 29, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5278, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 128, 64, 48, 65, 113, 83, 142, 100, 129, 79, 127, 82, 81, 126, 99, 85, 84, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 40, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 273, "safety_nodes": 823, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1096, "avg_nodes": 109.6, "eval_calls": 263, "avg_eval_calls": 26.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 263, "line_shape_eval_ns": 197951, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 752.6653992395437, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 706, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.6, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 706, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 706, "avg_legality_checks": 70.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 706, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12827, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1282.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27695203, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2159.1333125438528, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 187711, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11041.823529411764, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 38080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 149631, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 906653, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12252.067567567568, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 513303, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4709.201834862385, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1930719, "stage_ordering_ns": 390, "stage_eval_ns": 197951, "stage_threat_ns": 23585963, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 536, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21978897, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1151915, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10850, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 263, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 384771, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 70380, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5229, "avg_search_time_ms": 522.9, "search_nodes": 371559, "safety_nodes": 320, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 371879, "avg_nodes": 37187.9, "eval_calls": 365056, "avg_eval_calls": 36505.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 365056, "line_shape_eval_ns": 388900270, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1065.316745923913, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6485, "avg_candidate_generations": 648.5, "candidate_moves_total": 542191, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.60693909020817, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 733, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 6475, "search_candidate_moves_total": 541458, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 12515, "avg_legality_checks": 1251.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 12515, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24207, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2420.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 57109526, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2359.2153509315485, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 477760, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12250.25641025641, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 189650, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 288110, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 35582430, "stage_ordering_ns": 207990, "stage_eval_ns": 388900270, "stage_threat_ns": 4796529222, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 743072, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4202543043, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 63401, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10470, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 371531, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 503351081, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 743062, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 90571697, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 465, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5771, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5480.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1982, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 30, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11944, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 80, 111, 82, 66, 130, 146, 81, 160, 144, 83, 79, 78, 129, 99, 159, 174, 132, 131, 115, 97, 69, 110, 113, 116, 101, 109, 108, 125, 139, 161, 176, 188, 202, 143, 87, 73, 95, 126, 94, 141, 156, 93, 157, 77 ], "move_count": 49, "black_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 11844, "avg_search_time_ms": 514.9565217391304, "search_nodes": 704322, "safety_nodes": 2022, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 706344, "avg_nodes": 30710.608695652172, "eval_calls": 691849, "avg_eval_calls": 30080.391304347828, "line_shape_eval_calls": 691849, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1233611237, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1783.0642770315487, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12429, "avg_candidate_generations": 540.3913043478261, "candidate_moves_total": 1178852, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.84689033711481, "candidate_moves_max": 141, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2055, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 12406, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1176797, "search_candidate_moves_max": 141, "legality_checks": 674861, "avg_legality_checks": 29341.782608695652, "illegal_moves_skipped": 648, "root_legality_checks": 2055, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 672806, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 644, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 701418, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 30496.434782608696, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1703391511, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2428.49700321349, "renju_forbidden_checks": 687, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 29.869565217391305, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1732881, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2522.3886462882097, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 671, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1714531, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 18350, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 79, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.4347826086956523, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 853865, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10808.417721518987, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 111, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.826086956521739, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 426904, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3845.981981981982, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1695457866, "stage_ordering_ns": 420191, "stage_eval_ns": 1233611237, "stage_threat_ns": 8856286084, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1408533, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 7735932191, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 63, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1229818, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 24210, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 704255, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 947177422, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1408510, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 171946653, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 851, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 11254, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 2.9130434782608696, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9130434782608696, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.043478260869565216, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6701.217391304348, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7049.04347826087, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1222, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 74, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3636363636363638, "search_nodes": 580, "safety_nodes": 2178, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2758, "avg_nodes": 125.36363636363636, "eval_calls": 558, "avg_eval_calls": 25.363636363636363, "line_shape_eval_calls": 558, "line_shape_eval_ns": 963002, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1725.810035842294, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1979, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.95454545454545, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1979, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 25197, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1145.3181818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 51973778, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2062.697067111164, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.1818181818181819, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42891, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1649.6538461538462, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 42891, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11350, "stage_ordering_ns": 910, "stage_eval_ns": 963002, "stage_threat_ns": 47035720, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1138, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 45692824, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 390792, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 24280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 558, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 811004, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 141100, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7089.409090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7453.045454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 31, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2971, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 128, 64, 48, 65, 127, 125, 114, 95, 110, 50, 35, 94, 100, 86, 156 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 32, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 192, "safety_nodes": 670, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 862, "avg_nodes": 107.75, "eval_calls": 184, "avg_eval_calls": 23.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 184, "line_shape_eval_ns": 111551, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 606.2554347826087, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 551, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.875, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 551, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 551, "avg_legality_checks": 68.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 551, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10072, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1259.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21825446, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2166.9426131850673, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66410, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9487.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13020, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 53390, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 404771, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11243.638888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 51, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 221120, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4335.686274509804, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1497026, "stage_ordering_ns": 360, "stage_eval_ns": 111551, "stage_threat_ns": 18138990, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 376, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17186336, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 629382, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8650, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 184, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 275102, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 368, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48170, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 2931, "avg_search_time_ms": 366.375, "search_nodes": 210245, "safety_nodes": 563, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 210808, "avg_nodes": 26351.0, "eval_calls": 206319, "avg_eval_calls": 25789.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 206319, "line_shape_eval_ns": 188668205, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 914.4490085741013, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3912, "avg_candidate_generations": 489.0, "candidate_moves_total": 311816, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.70756646216769, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 578, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 3904, "search_candidate_moves_total": 311238, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 6844, "avg_legality_checks": 855.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6844, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16212, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2026.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 38006256, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2344.3286454478166, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 214513, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11290.157894736842, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 117321, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 97192, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19934834, "stage_ordering_ns": 123510, "stage_eval_ns": 188668205, "stage_threat_ns": 2713122272, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 420454, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2381170125, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 101900, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 210223, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 281028312, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 420446, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50821935, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 156, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3569, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4974.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5974.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 32, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7654, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 80, 97, 110, 94, 158, 174, 95, 160, 144, 125, 65, 50, 143, 141, 145, 146, 132, 111, 83, 113, 114, 127, 99, 129, 81, 153, 139, 155, 169, 188, 202, 131, 130, 116, 82, 84, 79 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 7567, "avg_search_time_ms": 398.2631578947368, "search_nodes": 448029, "safety_nodes": 2116, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 450145, "avg_nodes": 23691.842105263157, "eval_calls": 438719, "avg_eval_calls": 23090.473684210527, "line_shape_eval_calls": 438719, "line_shape_eval_ns": 657618480, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1498.9514472817452, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9273, "avg_candidate_generations": 488.05263157894734, "candidate_moves_total": 843405, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.95276609511485, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1623, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 9254, "search_candidate_moves_total": 841782, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 431579, "avg_legality_checks": 22714.684210526317, "illegal_moves_skipped": 199, "root_legality_checks": 1623, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 429956, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 199, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 453929, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23891.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1123033422, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2474.0288062670593, "renju_forbidden_checks": 199, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.473684210526315, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2300415, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11559.874371859296, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 199, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2300415, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 95, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 952994, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10031.515789473684, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.631578947368421, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 445260, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3533.809523809524, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1108316995, "stage_ordering_ns": 288252, "stage_eval_ns": 657618480, "stage_threat_ns": 5760361072, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 895965, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5040560400, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 53, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1307026, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 447973, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 607190729, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 895946, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 111302917, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 451, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8560, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6550.736842105263, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6971.789473684211, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1788, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 64, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3684210526315788, "search_nodes": 535, "safety_nodes": 1722, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2257, "avg_nodes": 118.78947368421052, "eval_calls": 516, "avg_eval_calls": 27.157894736842106, "line_shape_eval_calls": 516, "line_shape_eval_ns": 716463, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1388.4941860465117, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1663, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.52631578947368, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1663, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21980, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1156.842105263158, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 45580532, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2073.7275705186535, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9490, "stage_ordering_ns": 810, "stage_eval_ns": 716463, "stage_threat_ns": 41381635, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1051, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 40177679, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 50, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 319671, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20350, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 516, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 754095, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1032, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 130190, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6945.631578947368, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7366.684210526316, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 33, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 743, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 111, 81, 79, 66, 114, 34, 50, 83, 84, 113, 127, 95, 129, 99, 126, 125, 130 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 46, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.181818181818182, "search_nodes": 432, "safety_nodes": 532, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 964, "avg_nodes": 87.63636363636364, "eval_calls": 421, "avg_eval_calls": 38.27272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 421, "line_shape_eval_ns": 439223, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1043.2850356294537, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 813, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.9090909090909, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 813, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 813, "avg_legality_checks": 73.9090909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 813, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13808, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1255.2727272727273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29860474, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2162.5488122827346, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.3636363636363635, "renju_forbidden_ns": 194480, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12965.333333333334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 40140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 154340, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.9090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 127140, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12714.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.3636363636363635, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 70390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4692.666666666667, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2194589, "stage_ordering_ns": 470, "stage_eval_ns": 439223, "stage_threat_ns": 26418757, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 853, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 25481335, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 220130, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 421, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 610322, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 842, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 106970, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 687, "avg_search_time_ms": 68.7, "search_nodes": 47763, "safety_nodes": 974, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48737, "avg_nodes": 4873.7, "eval_calls": 46042, "avg_eval_calls": 4604.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 46042, "line_shape_eval_ns": 47076497, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1022.4685504539334, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1702, "avg_candidate_generations": 170.2, "candidate_moves_total": 139852, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.16921269095182, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 745, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 1692, "search_candidate_moves_total": 139107, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 4943, "avg_legality_checks": 494.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4943, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16815, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1681.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 38263802, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2275.575498067202, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 243402, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 13522.333333333334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 80371, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 163031, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13961588, "stage_ordering_ns": 58661, "stage_eval_ns": 47076497, "stage_threat_ns": 611102749, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 95478, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 536676652, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 170521, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47734, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 62872600, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 95468, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11382976, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 161, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1468, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5940.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6740.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 34, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5534, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 111, 81, 83, 79, 78, 66, 114, 50, 34, 110, 97, 65, 95, 35, 20, 125, 127, 94, 113, 115, 142, 157, 100, 156, 86 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 5476, "avg_search_time_ms": 391.14285714285717, "search_nodes": 328640, "safety_nodes": 1056, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 329696, "avg_nodes": 23549.714285714286, "eval_calls": 322247, "avg_eval_calls": 23017.64285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 322247, "line_shape_eval_ns": 358045793, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1111.0911598866708, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6367, "avg_candidate_generations": 454.7857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 472369, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.19019946599654, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 962, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 6353, "search_candidate_moves_total": 471407, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 319499, "avg_legality_checks": 22821.35714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 324, "root_legality_checks": 962, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 318537, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 324, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 335662, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23975.85714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 832264127, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2479.470798005136, "renju_forbidden_checks": 459, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 32.785714285714285, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5261711, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11463.42265795207, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 455, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5255991, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5720, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 667633, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9818.132352941177, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.928571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 292801, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3018.5670103092784, "stage_move_gen_ns": 824370892, "stage_ordering_ns": 203191, "stage_eval_ns": 358045793, "stage_threat_ns": 4267141849, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 657214, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3737861594, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 874133, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 328600, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 447321482, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 657200, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 81084640, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 293, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5897, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5937.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6508.928571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1496, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 43, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3076923076923075, "search_nodes": 271, "safety_nodes": 1059, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1330, "avg_nodes": 102.3076923076923, "eval_calls": 258, "avg_eval_calls": 19.846153846153847, "line_shape_eval_calls": 258, "line_shape_eval_ns": 270842, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1049.7751937984497, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 892, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.61538461538461, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 892, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14800, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1138.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31424818, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2123.2985135135136, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5620, "stage_ordering_ns": 630, "stage_eval_ns": 270842, "stage_threat_ns": 27440651, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 529, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 26712109, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 267951, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 258, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 393550, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 516, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67041, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6458.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7074.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 35, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1117, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 140, 154, 97, 99, 69, 100, 142, 72, 86, 129, 144, 127, 111, 83, 141, 143, 96, 81, 156 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 46, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.181818181818182, "search_nodes": 432, "safety_nodes": 532, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 964, "avg_nodes": 87.63636363636364, "eval_calls": 421, "avg_eval_calls": 38.27272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 421, "line_shape_eval_ns": 449203, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1066.9904988123515, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 813, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.9090909090909, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 813, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 813, "avg_legality_checks": 73.9090909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 813, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13808, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1255.2727272727273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29893328, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2164.928157589803, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.3636363636363635, "renju_forbidden_ns": 215280, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 14352.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 45030, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 170250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.9090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 131181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 13118.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.3636363636363635, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 73601, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4906.733333333334, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2248179, "stage_ordering_ns": 460, "stage_eval_ns": 449203, "stage_threat_ns": 26506301, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 853, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 25563406, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 223891, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 421, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 612914, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 842, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 106090, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 1063, "avg_search_time_ms": 106.3, "search_nodes": 73428, "safety_nodes": 974, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 74402, "avg_nodes": 7440.2, "eval_calls": 71498, "avg_eval_calls": 7149.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 71498, "line_shape_eval_ns": 74880512, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1047.3091834736636, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1911, "avg_candidate_generations": 191.1, "candidate_moves_total": 157250, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.28676085818942, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 745, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 1901, "search_candidate_moves_total": 156505, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 5000, "avg_legality_checks": 500.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5000, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16872, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1687.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 39058305, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2314.977773826458, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 291983, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 14599.15, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 117621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 174362, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15007666, "stage_ordering_ns": 67010, "stage_eval_ns": 74880512, "stage_threat_ns": 958708597, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 146808, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 841432317, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 173910, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10900, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 73399, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 98990170, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 146798, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18112200, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 161, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1674, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5923.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6723.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 36, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4690, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 97, 99, 129, 69, 54, 100, 142, 86, 72, 82, 113, 85, 83, 87, 88, 81, 111, 68, 127, 157, 110, 109, 94, 158, 78 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 4631, "avg_search_time_ms": 330.7857142857143, "search_nodes": 279051, "safety_nodes": 1056, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 280107, "avg_nodes": 20007.64285714286, "eval_calls": 273147, "avg_eval_calls": 19510.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 273147, "line_shape_eval_ns": 314693302, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1152.102355142103, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5878, "avg_candidate_generations": 419.85714285714283, "candidate_moves_total": 438940, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.6750595440626, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 962, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 5864, "search_candidate_moves_total": 437978, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 269611, "avg_legality_checks": 19257.928571428572, "illegal_moves_skipped": 334, "root_legality_checks": 962, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 268649, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 285774, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20412.428571428572, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 713998758, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2498.4734720443425, "renju_forbidden_checks": 353, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 25.214285714285715, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4280870, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12127.110481586402, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 349, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4275010, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5860, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 664002, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9764.735294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.928571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 289492, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2984.453608247423, "stage_move_gen_ns": 701978080, "stage_ordering_ns": 193291, "stage_eval_ns": 314693302, "stage_threat_ns": 3592921843, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 558036, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3138862562, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 867184, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14780, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 279011, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 384145483, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 558022, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69046614, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 293, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5424, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6117.785714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6689.214285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1918, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 43, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3076923076923075, "search_nodes": 271, "safety_nodes": 1059, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1330, "avg_nodes": 102.3076923076923, "eval_calls": 258, "avg_eval_calls": 19.846153846153847, "line_shape_eval_calls": 258, "line_shape_eval_ns": 268851, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1042.0581395348838, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 892, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.61538461538461, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 892, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14800, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1138.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31483171, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2127.2412837837837, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5740, "stage_ordering_ns": 650, "stage_eval_ns": 268851, "stage_threat_ns": 27457600, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 529, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 26724688, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 271991, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 258, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 393201, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 516, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67720, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6458.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7074.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 37, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4166, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 126, 70, 56, 69, 111, 81, 142, 94, 125, 83, 82, 124, 54, 141, 68 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 34, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.25, "search_nodes": 340, "safety_nodes": 441, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 781, "avg_nodes": 97.625, "eval_calls": 332, "avg_eval_calls": 41.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 332, "line_shape_eval_ns": 279030, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 840.4518072289156, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 552, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.0, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 552, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 552, "avg_legality_checks": 69.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 552, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10068, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1258.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21573841, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2142.8129717918155, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 133621, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11135.083333333334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24660, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 108961, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 30, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 373362, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12445.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 44, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 208981, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4749.568181818182, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1496038, "stage_ordering_ns": 340, "stage_eval_ns": 279030, "stage_threat_ns": 19865405, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 672, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18770889, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 527183, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 332, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 483082, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 664, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 84251, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 4126, "avg_search_time_ms": 515.75, "search_nodes": 298743, "safety_nodes": 398, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 299141, "avg_nodes": 37392.625, "eval_calls": 293660, "avg_eval_calls": 36707.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 293660, "line_shape_eval_ns": 284118763, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 967.5092385752231, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5069, "avg_candidate_generations": 633.625, "candidate_moves_total": 420190, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.89406194515684, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 575, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 5061, "search_candidate_moves_total": 419615, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 10277, "avg_legality_checks": 1284.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10277, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19682, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2460.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 45893304, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2331.739863834976, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 351553, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12122.51724137931, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 213372, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 138181, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 28792571, "stage_ordering_ns": 163691, "stage_eval_ns": 284118763, "stage_threat_ns": 3805517809, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 597450, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3331542759, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 88682, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 298721, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 401768164, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 597442, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 72118204, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 312, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4592, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4900.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5900.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 38, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13509, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 84, 113, 82, 68, 124, 138, 83, 154, 140, 81, 85, 86, 125, 95, 155, 170, 122, 123, 109, 97, 65, 111, 108, 114, 115, 129, 145, 186, 202, 156, 94, 128, 142, 130, 127, 100, 72, 99, 101, 144, 159, 172, 158, 131, 132, 146, 162, 160, 176, 139, 141, 157, 69, 53, 147, 67, 39, 117, 148, 80, 174, 190, 175, 177, 161, 189, 191, 143, 188, 171, 185, 169, 173, 168 ], "move_count": 79, "black_stats": { "move_count": 40, "search_move_count": 38, "total_time_ms": 13343, "avg_search_time_ms": 351.13157894736844, "search_nodes": 800908, "safety_nodes": 5750, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 806658, "avg_nodes": 21227.842105263157, "eval_calls": 785195, "avg_eval_calls": 20663.026315789473, "line_shape_eval_calls": 785195, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1790336831, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 2280.1174625411522, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15639, "avg_candidate_generations": 411.55263157894734, "candidate_moves_total": 1556791, "avg_candidate_moves": 99.54543129356097, "candidate_moves_max": 136, "root_candidate_generations": 38, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3744, "root_candidate_moves_max": 119, "search_candidate_generations": 15601, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1553047, "search_candidate_moves_max": 136, "legality_checks": 768837, "avg_legality_checks": 20232.552631578947, "illegal_moves_skipped": 475, "root_legality_checks": 3744, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 765093, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 474, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 810622, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21332.157894736843, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1825932522, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2252.5079778244362, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3741, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 98.44736842105263, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10252269, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2740.515637530072, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3510, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9725866, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 231, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 526403, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 200, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.2631578947368425, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1981369, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9906.845, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 267, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.026315789473684, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 918646, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3440.621722846442, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1808473218, "stage_ordering_ns": 502041, "stage_eval_ns": 1790336831, "stage_threat_ns": 9637592363, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1601630, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 8388825048, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 108, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3554415, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 41040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 800796, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1054910328, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1601592, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 190302572, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 764, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 14486, "depth_sum": 112, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 112, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 37 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 38, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.02631578947368421, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7237.789473684211, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7448.315789473684, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1439, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 39, "search_move_count": 37, "total_time_ms": 124, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3513513513513513, "search_nodes": 1606, "safety_nodes": 2555, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 4161, "avg_nodes": 112.45945945945945, "eval_calls": 1569, "avg_eval_calls": 42.4054054054054, "line_shape_eval_calls": 1569, "line_shape_eval_ns": 5052348, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 3220.10707456979, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3660, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.91891891891892, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 37, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3660, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 39655, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1071.7567567567567, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 76458544, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1928.0934056235028, "renju_forbidden_checks": 142, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.8378378378378377, "renju_forbidden_ns": 403943, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2844.669014084507, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 142, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 403943, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23450, "stage_ordering_ns": 1770, "stage_eval_ns": 5052348, "stage_threat_ns": 78917002, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 3175, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 76145423, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 95, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 282382, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 74, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 41691, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 1569, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 2125445, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 3138, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 363752, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 37 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 37, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7458.5675675675675, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7674.783783783784, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 39, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10186, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 97, 82, 142, 157, 113, 114, 66, 96, 68, 124, 138, 109, 128, 141, 125, 126, 111, 139, 83, 69, 154, 156, 94, 158, 155, 140, 108, 188, 172, 159, 160, 146, 130, 171, 186, 122, 144, 176, 170, 202, 80, 52, 129, 131, 145, 161, 81 ], "move_count": 51, "black_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 92, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.8333333333333335, "search_nodes": 790, "safety_nodes": 1933, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2723, "avg_nodes": 113.45833333333333, "eval_calls": 766, "avg_eval_calls": 31.916666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 766, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1528601, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1995.5626631853786, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1994, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.08333333333333, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1994, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1994, "avg_legality_checks": 83.08333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 1994, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29585, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1232.7083333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 60329422, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2039.1895217170863, "renju_forbidden_checks": 68, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.8333333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 725805, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10673.60294117647, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 139152, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 586653, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 84, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1032845, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12295.77380952381, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 129, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 576572, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4469.550387596899, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5091624, "stage_ordering_ns": 890, "stage_eval_ns": 1528601, "stage_threat_ns": 53289484, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1556, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 50644506, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 65, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1377776, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 25640, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 766, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1076792, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1532, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 190410, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 24 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7165.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7498.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 10075, "avg_search_time_ms": 438.04347826086956, "search_nodes": 693001, "safety_nodes": 1800, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 694801, "avg_nodes": 30208.739130434784, "eval_calls": 679205, "avg_eval_calls": 29530.652173913044, "line_shape_eval_calls": 679205, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1012461254, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1490.656361481438, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13751, "avg_candidate_generations": 597.8695652173913, "candidate_moves_total": 1221623, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.83884808377573, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1909, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 13728, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1219714, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 28678, "avg_legality_checks": 1246.8695652173913, "illegal_moves_skipped": 215, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 28678, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 215, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 54754, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2380.608695652174, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 127341396, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2325.7003323958065, "renju_forbidden_checks": 291, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12.652173913043478, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8068120, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 27725.498281786942, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 229, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7433459, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 62, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 634661, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 89940488, "stage_ordering_ns": 441801, "stage_eval_ns": 1012461254, "stage_threat_ns": 8954868148, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1385889, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 7834421233, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 62, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 280032, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 25020, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 692933, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 949574687, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1385866, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 170592196, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 719, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 12429, "depth_sum": 68, "avg_depth": 2.9565217391304346, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 68, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9565217391304346, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.043478260869565216, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7028.217391304348, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7376.04347826087, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 40, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11341, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 97, 82, 113, 96, 142, 157, 68, 124, 138, 114, 66, 130, 146, 111, 67, 65, 99, 141, 69, 70, 126, 125, 85, 71, 109, 173, 189, 140, 95, 155, 170, 81, 53, 37, 83, 115, 156, 128, 84, 86, 54, 39, 52, 100, 72, 55, 101, 117, 36, 20, 184, 198, 87, 116, 118, 23, 7, 51, 79, 9 ], "move_count": 64, "black_stats": { "move_count": 32, "search_move_count": 30, "total_time_ms": 11202, "avg_search_time_ms": 373.4, "search_nodes": 665526, "safety_nodes": 3106, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 668632, "avg_nodes": 22287.733333333334, "eval_calls": 650587, "avg_eval_calls": 21686.233333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 650587, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1433245250, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 2203.0032109464223, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14880, "avg_candidate_generations": 496.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1554428, "avg_candidate_moves": 104.46424731182796, "candidate_moves_max": 137, "root_candidate_generations": 30, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2957, "root_candidate_moves_max": 126, "search_candidate_generations": 14850, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1551471, "search_candidate_moves_max": 137, "legality_checks": 644200, "avg_legality_checks": 21473.333333333332, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1174, "root_legality_checks": 2957, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 641243, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1164, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 678209, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22606.966666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1550402670, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2286.0249126744116, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2681, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 89.36666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20372204, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7598.73330846699, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2627, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20161453, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 54, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 210751, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 120, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1260827, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10506.891666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 171, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 637004, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3725.1695906432747, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1548095373, "stage_ordering_ns": 451355, "stage_eval_ns": 1433245250, "stage_threat_ns": 8141556946, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1330904, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 7088805522, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 82, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1729529, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 32480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 665437, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 892612617, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1330874, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 158409278, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1029, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 13151, "depth_sum": 89, "avg_depth": 2.966666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 89, "avg_effective_depth": 2.966666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 29 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 30, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.03333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7100.766666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7367.433333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1869, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 32, "search_move_count": 30, "total_time_ms": 106, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.533333333333333, "search_nodes": 1323, "safety_nodes": 2618, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 3941, "avg_nodes": 131.36666666666667, "eval_calls": 1293, "avg_eval_calls": 43.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 1293, "line_shape_eval_ns": 3014742, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 2331.5870069605567, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2995, "avg_candidate_moves": 99.83333333333333, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 30, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2995, "root_candidate_moves_max": 125, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 33437, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1114.5666666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 66867376, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1999.8018961031194, "renju_forbidden_checks": 72, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 246830, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3428.1944444444443, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 246830, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17020, "stage_ordering_ns": 1190, "stage_eval_ns": 3014742, "stage_threat_ns": 68363448, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 2616, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 65747505, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 81, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 486672, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 32980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 1293, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1816149, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 2586, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 313122, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 30 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 30, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7332.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7598.866666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 41, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1915, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 98, 83, 114, 66, 142, 100, 129, 96, 130, 146, 127, 126, 131 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 244, "safety_nodes": 530, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 774, "avg_nodes": 86.0, "eval_calls": 235, "avg_eval_calls": 26.11111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 235, "line_shape_eval_ns": 177201, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 754.0468085106382, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 580, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 580, "avg_legality_checks": 64.44444444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 580, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11184, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1242.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24160829, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2160.3030221745353, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.888888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 427081, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12202.314285714287, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 88430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 338651, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.111111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 468592, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12664.648648648648, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 260982, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4833.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1674507, "stage_ordering_ns": 330, "stage_eval_ns": 177201, "stage_threat_ns": 20701839, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 479, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19687426, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 599153, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 235, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 352610, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 470, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62650, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5773.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1873, "avg_search_time_ms": 208.11111111111111, "search_nodes": 126927, "safety_nodes": 546, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 127473, "avg_nodes": 14163.666666666666, "eval_calls": 124234, "avg_eval_calls": 13803.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 124234, "line_shape_eval_ns": 138870192, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1117.811484778724, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2677, "avg_candidate_generations": 297.44444444444446, "candidate_moves_total": 209723, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.34254762794173, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 605, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 2668, "search_candidate_moves_total": 209118, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 10095, "avg_legality_checks": 1121.6666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 132, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10095, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 132, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20539, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2282.1111111111113, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 49422566, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2406.279078825649, "renju_forbidden_checks": 164, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 18.22222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2006638, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12235.59756097561, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 132, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1616146, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 390492, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 30436918, "stage_ordering_ns": 98160, "stage_eval_ns": 138870192, "stage_threat_ns": 1697948883, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 253813, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1487790296, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 125720, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9150, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 126902, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 177901169, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 253804, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32131698, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 282, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2309, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5699.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6588.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1963, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 42, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4276, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 126, 98, 109, 108, 83, 143, 158, 142, 97, 69, 96, 141, 125, 139, 140, 144, 145, 155, 81, 66, 95, 80, 67, 123, 53 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 4219, "avg_search_time_ms": 301.35714285714283, "search_nodes": 251515, "safety_nodes": 1152, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 252667, "avg_nodes": 18047.64285714286, "eval_calls": 245607, "avg_eval_calls": 17543.35714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 245607, "line_shape_eval_ns": 279480957, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1137.9193467612895, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5882, "avg_candidate_generations": 420.14285714285717, "candidate_moves_total": 449738, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.46004760285616, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 970, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 5868, "search_candidate_moves_total": 448768, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 241851, "avg_legality_checks": 17275.071428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 125, "root_legality_checks": 970, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 240881, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 258238, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18445.571428571428, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 640336359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2479.6364555177784, "renju_forbidden_checks": 265, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 18.928571428571427, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2907823, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10972.916981132075, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 254, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2832503, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 75320, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.357142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 513265, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10920.531914893618, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 69, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.928571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 235743, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3416.5652173913045, "stage_move_gen_ns": 625299819, "stage_ordering_ns": 180902, "stage_eval_ns": 279480957, "stage_threat_ns": 3286538866, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 502964, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2885594883, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 799915, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 251475, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 337198077, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 502950, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62945991, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 281, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5247, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6314.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6886.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1883, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 41, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1538461538461537, "search_nodes": 142, "safety_nodes": 1187, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1329, "avg_nodes": 102.23076923076923, "eval_calls": 129, "avg_eval_calls": 9.923076923076923, "line_shape_eval_calls": 129, "line_shape_eval_ns": 111882, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 867.3023255813954, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 899, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.15384615384616, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 899, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15135, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1164.2307692307693, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31585710, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2086.9316154608523, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.46153846153846156, "renju_forbidden_ns": 59430, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9905.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 59430, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5680, "stage_ordering_ns": 590, "stage_eval_ns": 111882, "stage_threat_ns": 25912857, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 271, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 25380416, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 296411, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14590, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 201180, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 258, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34850, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6458.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7074.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 43, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2089, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 128, 125, 142, 100, 110, 94, 143, 96, 158, 174, 113, 173, 98 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 37, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 244, "safety_nodes": 552, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 796, "avg_nodes": 88.44444444444444, "eval_calls": 235, "avg_eval_calls": 26.11111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 235, "line_shape_eval_ns": 176000, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 748.936170212766, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 596, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 596, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 596, "avg_legality_checks": 66.22222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 596, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11267, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1251.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24499439, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2174.4420875122037, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.444444444444445, "renju_forbidden_ns": 404081, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10102.025, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 83730, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 320351, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 488653, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12529.564102564103, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 57, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 274411, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4814.228070175439, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1723029, "stage_ordering_ns": 340, "stage_eval_ns": 176000, "stage_threat_ns": 20864817, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 479, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19840103, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 617943, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 235, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 344701, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 470, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5773.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2044, "avg_search_time_ms": 227.11111111111111, "search_nodes": 140245, "safety_nodes": 560, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 140805, "avg_nodes": 15645.0, "eval_calls": 137396, "avg_eval_calls": 15266.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 137396, "line_shape_eval_ns": 151239974, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1100.759658214213, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2833, "avg_candidate_generations": 314.77777777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 226828, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.06636074832333, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 627, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 2824, "search_candidate_moves_total": 226201, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 9314, "avg_legality_checks": 1034.888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 103, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9314, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 103, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19828, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2203.1111111111113, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 47093793, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2375.1156445430706, "renju_forbidden_checks": 143, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 15.88888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1589895, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11118.146853146853, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 103, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1220874, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 369021, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 27420299, "stage_ordering_ns": 101360, "stage_eval_ns": 151239974, "stage_threat_ns": 1859384057, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 280449, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1630683979, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 125881, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 140220, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 192571108, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 280440, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36003089, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 295, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2449, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5682.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6571.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 44, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1980, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 96, 128, 67, 52, 129, 125, 124, 110, 113, 81, 98, 95, 145, 161, 80, 140, 155, 142, 64, 48, 100, 99, 94, 156, 170, 158, 174, 141, 109, 79, 139, 154, 171, 111, 143, 63 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 1899, "avg_search_time_ms": 99.94736842105263, "search_nodes": 119394, "safety_nodes": 2136, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 121530, "avg_nodes": 6396.315789473684, "eval_calls": 115467, "avg_eval_calls": 6077.210526315789, "line_shape_eval_calls": 115467, "line_shape_eval_ns": 158031554, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1368.6295997990767, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3890, "avg_candidate_generations": 204.73684210526315, "candidate_moves_total": 334879, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.08714652956299, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1537, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 3871, "search_candidate_moves_total": 333342, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 110091, "avg_legality_checks": 5794.263157894737, "illegal_moves_skipped": 180, "root_legality_checks": 1537, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 108554, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 180, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 132179, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6956.789473684211, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 294452215, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2227.677732468849, "renju_forbidden_checks": 198, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.421052631578947, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1810292, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9142.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 196, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1806202, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4090, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.1052631578947367, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 591803, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10030.559322033898, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.8947368421052633, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 283372, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3829.3513513513512, "stage_move_gen_ns": 260429874, "stage_ordering_ns": 130110, "stage_eval_ns": 158031554, "stage_threat_ns": 1446885093, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 238695, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1265515496, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1190347, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 119338, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 152692342, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 238676, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27486908, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 278, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3458, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6907.894736842105, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7328.9473684210525, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1909, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 63, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3157894736842106, "search_nodes": 634, "safety_nodes": 1318, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1952, "avg_nodes": 102.73684210526316, "eval_calls": 615, "avg_eval_calls": 32.36842105263158, "line_shape_eval_calls": 615, "line_shape_eval_ns": 981983, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1596.720325203252, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1572, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.73684210526316, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1572, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21837, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1149.3157894736842, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 42192656, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1932.1635755827265, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8570, "stage_ordering_ns": 800, "stage_eval_ns": 981983, "stage_threat_ns": 40166997, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1249, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 38907053, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 49, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 226171, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 615, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 883463, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1230, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 150310, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6945.578947368421, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7366.631578947368, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 45, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1058, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 114, 115, 97, 82, 68, 126, 94, 125, 98, 124, 138, 123, 127, 122 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 21, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.625, "search_nodes": 238, "safety_nodes": 401, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 639, "avg_nodes": 79.875, "eval_calls": 230, "avg_eval_calls": 28.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 230, "line_shape_eval_ns": 121901, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 530.0043478260869, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 502, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.75, "candidate_moves_max": 79, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 502, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 502, "avg_legality_checks": 62.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 502, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9917, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1239.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15305408, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1543.3506100635273, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65121, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 13024.2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13550, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 51571, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 164210, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10263.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 92260, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4011.304347826087, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1041798, "stage_ordering_ns": 300, "stage_eval_ns": 121901, "stage_threat_ns": 13289154, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 468, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 12750801, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 233661, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 257962, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46730, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5497.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6497.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1029, "avg_search_time_ms": 128.625, "search_nodes": 81344, "safety_nodes": 513, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 81857, "avg_nodes": 10232.125, "eval_calls": 79381, "avg_eval_calls": 9922.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 79381, "line_shape_eval_ns": 71702986, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 903.2764263488745, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1949, "avg_candidate_generations": 243.625, "candidate_moves_total": 149428, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.66906105695229, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 522, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 1941, "search_candidate_moves_total": 148906, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 7651, "avg_legality_checks": 956.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 87, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7651, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 87, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17033, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2129.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31434066, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1845.4803029413492, "renju_forbidden_checks": 95, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1033345, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10877.315789473685, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 87, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 953773, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 79572, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18527847, "stage_ordering_ns": 70230, "stage_eval_ns": 71702986, "stage_threat_ns": 929398214, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 162652, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 814503847, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 93010, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 81322, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96953311, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 162644, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17848046, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 214, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1673, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5450.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6450.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 46, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4511, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 97, 82, 114, 115, 68, 124, 138, 126, 94, 158, 174, 125, 127, 123, 122, 109, 83, 98, 108, 80, 95, 143, 81, 129, 69, 55, 79, 63, 136, 150, 49, 65, 64, 34, 157, 101, 87, 48, 99, 66, 50, 141, 71, 85, 70, 67, 72 ], "move_count": 53, "black_stats": { "move_count": 27, "search_move_count": 25, "total_time_ms": 4422, "avg_search_time_ms": 176.88, "search_nodes": 396179, "safety_nodes": 3056, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 399235, "avg_nodes": 15969.4, "eval_calls": 386166, "avg_eval_calls": 15446.64, "line_shape_eval_calls": 386166, "line_shape_eval_ns": 475211272, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1230.5880683436658, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9965, "avg_candidate_generations": 398.6, "candidate_moves_total": 991027, "avg_candidate_moves": 99.4507777220271, "candidate_moves_max": 137, "root_candidate_generations": 25, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2342, "root_candidate_moves_max": 122, "search_candidate_generations": 9940, "search_candidate_moves_total": 988685, "search_candidate_moves_max": 137, "legality_checks": 378948, "avg_legality_checks": 15157.92, "illegal_moves_skipped": 248, "root_legality_checks": 2342, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 376606, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 245, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 408317, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16332.68, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 633109305, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1550.5337886984867, "renju_forbidden_checks": 261, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.44, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2581733, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9891.697318007662, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 248, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2432772, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 148961, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 165, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1443435, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8748.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 252, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.08, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 774034, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3071.563492063492, "stage_move_gen_ns": 615174293, "stage_ordering_ns": 297671, "stage_eval_ns": 475211272, "stage_threat_ns": 3241123534, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 792237, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2800652554, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 68, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1893878, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 396106, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 371825891, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 792212, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66751211, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 565, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9012, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 2.92, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 2.92, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 24 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 25, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7122.56, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7442.56, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1941, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 63, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.625, "search_nodes": 844, "safety_nodes": 2108, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2952, "avg_nodes": 123.0, "eval_calls": 820, "avg_eval_calls": 34.166666666666664, "line_shape_eval_calls": 820, "line_shape_eval_ns": 873984, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1065.8341463414633, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2260, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.16666666666667, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2260, "root_candidate_moves_max": 122, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27407, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1141.9583333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 41787074, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1524.6861750647645, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.6666666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 209532, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 13095.75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 209532, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10410, "stage_ordering_ns": 980, "stage_eval_ns": 873984, "stage_threat_ns": 41550181, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1664, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 40176043, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 238661, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 965975, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 169502, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 24 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7165.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7498.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 47, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8970, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 142, 157, 111, 110, 68, 98, 66, 124, 138, 109, 126, 125, 141, 140, 156, 171, 155, 130, 146, 113, 169, 183, 52, 143, 185, 128, 83, 158 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 61, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.066666666666666, "search_nodes": 462, "safety_nodes": 1184, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1646, "avg_nodes": 109.73333333333333, "eval_calls": 447, "avg_eval_calls": 29.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 447, "line_shape_eval_ns": 561883, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1257.0089485458614, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1159, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.26666666666667, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1159, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1159, "avg_legality_checks": 77.26666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 1159, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18925, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1261.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 40517944, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2140.9745838837516, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.6666666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 125012, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12501.2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26581, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 98431, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 696912, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12015.724137931034, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 386080, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4596.190476190476, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3077344, "stage_ordering_ns": 620, "stage_eval_ns": 561883, "stage_threat_ns": 34889799, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 909, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 33167781, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 945174, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 447, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 661163, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 894, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 115681, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 15, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 15, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6664.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7197.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 8897, "avg_search_time_ms": 593.1333333333333, "search_nodes": 631259, "safety_nodes": 762, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 632021, "avg_nodes": 42134.73333333333, "eval_calls": 618376, "avg_eval_calls": 41225.066666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 618376, "line_shape_eval_ns": 832161329, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1345.7206117313738, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12855, "avg_candidate_generations": 857.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1185333, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.20793465577596, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1189, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 12840, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1184144, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 22875, "avg_legality_checks": 1525.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 181, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 22875, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 181, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 40309, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2687.266666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 96954681, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2405.2861891885186, "renju_forbidden_checks": 197, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 13.133333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3930844, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 19953.522842639595, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 181, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3730554, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 200290, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 70964944, "stage_ordering_ns": 405473, "stage_eval_ns": 832161329, "stage_threat_ns": 7960264994, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1262447, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6971316770, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 165120, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15550, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 631216, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 829983284, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1262432, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 158799820, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 656, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 11608, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6506.066666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7039.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 48, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3422, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 111, 98, 142, 157, 66, 130, 146, 110, 68, 124, 138, 113, 67, 65, 69, 70, 83, 125, 55 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3374, "avg_search_time_ms": 306.72727272727275, "search_nodes": 198088, "safety_nodes": 615, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 198703, "avg_nodes": 18063.909090909092, "eval_calls": 193322, "avg_eval_calls": 17574.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 193322, "line_shape_eval_ns": 177748577, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 919.4430897673312, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4746, "avg_candidate_generations": 431.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 374421, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.89190897597977, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 817, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 4735, "search_candidate_moves_total": 373604, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 191083, "avg_legality_checks": 17371.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 338, "root_legality_checks": 817, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 190266, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 336, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 204185, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18562.272727272728, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 521813120, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2555.5898817249063, "renju_forbidden_checks": 350, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 31.818181818181817, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4106467, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11732.762857142858, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 342, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4007647, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 98820, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 30, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.727272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 390771, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 13025.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.181818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 218490, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4749.782608695652, "stage_move_gen_ns": 510854431, "stage_ordering_ns": 146671, "stage_eval_ns": 177748577, "stage_threat_ns": 2668591728, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 396125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2347562109, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 519441, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 198057, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 270189699, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 396114, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50320479, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 389, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4182, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5598.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6325.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1909, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 37, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7, "search_nodes": 379, "safety_nodes": 517, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 896, "avg_nodes": 89.6, "eval_calls": 369, "avg_eval_calls": 36.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 369, "line_shape_eval_ns": 356082, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 964.9918699186992, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 745, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.5, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 745, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11774, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1177.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25158972, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2136.8245286223882, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 100193, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12524.125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 100193, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4200, "stage_ordering_ns": 410, "stage_eval_ns": 356082, "stage_threat_ns": 23892835, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 748, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 23131411, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 125631, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10960, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 369, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 540633, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 738, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 95160, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 49, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2015, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 126, 125, 142, 94, 114, 100, 143, 96, 158, 174, 113, 173, 98 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 37, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 244, "safety_nodes": 536, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 780, "avg_nodes": 86.66666666666667, "eval_calls": 235, "avg_eval_calls": 26.11111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 235, "line_shape_eval_ns": 177641, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 755.9191489361702, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 589, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 589, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 589, "avg_legality_checks": 65.44444444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "root_legality_checks": 589, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11223, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1247.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24424288, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2176.2708723157803, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 443360, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9852.444444444445, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 97620, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 36, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 345740, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.111111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 467183, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12626.567567567568, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 259611, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4807.611111111111, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1710127, "stage_ordering_ns": 410, "stage_eval_ns": 177641, "stage_threat_ns": 20971894, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 479, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19960636, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 597143, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 235, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 351325, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 470, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62790, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5773.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1970, "avg_search_time_ms": 218.88888888888889, "search_nodes": 134956, "safety_nodes": 560, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 135516, "avg_nodes": 15057.333333333334, "eval_calls": 132195, "avg_eval_calls": 14688.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 132195, "line_shape_eval_ns": 146675788, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1109.5411172888537, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2745, "avg_candidate_generations": 305.0, "candidate_moves_total": 216244, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.77741347905283, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 615, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 2736, "search_candidate_moves_total": 215629, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 9315, "avg_legality_checks": 1035.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 116, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9315, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 116, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19787, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2198.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 47404108, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2395.7198160408348, "renju_forbidden_checks": 160, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 17.77777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1799801, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11248.75625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 116, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1394208, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 405593, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 27667823, "stage_ordering_ns": 100500, "stage_eval_ns": 146675788, "stage_threat_ns": 1789464737, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 269871, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1571211446, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 121020, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134931, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184222575, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 269862, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33909696, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 283, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2378, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5686.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6575.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 50, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2108, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 98, 126, 67, 52, 125, 129, 130, 114, 111, 83, 96, 99, 139, 153, 84, 144, 159, 142, 70, 56, 94, 95, 100, 158, 174, 156, 170, 143, 115, 85, 145, 160, 173, 113, 141, 71 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 2020, "avg_search_time_ms": 106.3157894736842, "search_nodes": 120137, "safety_nodes": 2136, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122273, "avg_nodes": 6435.421052631579, "eval_calls": 116092, "avg_eval_calls": 6110.105263157895, "line_shape_eval_calls": 116092, "line_shape_eval_ns": 177831028, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1531.8112186886262, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4008, "avg_candidate_generations": 210.94736842105263, "candidate_moves_total": 347150, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.61427145708583, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1537, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 3989, "search_candidate_moves_total": 345613, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 110674, "avg_legality_checks": 5824.9473684210525, "illegal_moves_skipped": 185, "root_legality_checks": 1537, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 109137, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 185, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 132762, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6987.473684210527, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 310592669, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2339.469644928519, "renju_forbidden_checks": 202, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.631578947368421, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2159720, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10691.683168316831, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 200, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2155670, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4050, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.1052631578947367, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 631053, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10695.813559322034, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.8947368421052633, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 299992, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4053.945945945946, "stage_move_gen_ns": 275178508, "stage_ordering_ns": 135170, "stage_eval_ns": 177831028, "stage_threat_ns": 1538828571, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 240181, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1347850006, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1260885, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20901, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 120081, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 160508539, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 240162, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29209141, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 278, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3570, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6907.263157894737, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7328.315789473684, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1906, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 67, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.526315789473684, "search_nodes": 634, "safety_nodes": 1318, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1952, "avg_nodes": 102.73684210526316, "eval_calls": 615, "avg_eval_calls": 32.36842105263158, "line_shape_eval_calls": 615, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1004964, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1634.0878048780487, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1572, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.73684210526316, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1572, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21837, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1149.3157894736842, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 45106293, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2065.5901909602967, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9090, "stage_ordering_ns": 880, "stage_eval_ns": 1004964, "stage_threat_ns": 42484994, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1249, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 41189254, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 49, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 248561, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 615, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 894739, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1230, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 152440, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6945.578947368421, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7366.631578947368, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 51, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6395, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 114, 115, 127, 142, 94, 96, 68, 125, 128, 140, 95, 124, 138, 143, 79, 63, 98, 83, 139, 144, 141, 158, 174, 145, 146, 155, 170, 129, 99, 85, 130, 162, 84, 157, 171, 101 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 67, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.526315789473684, "search_nodes": 290, "safety_nodes": 2062, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2352, "avg_nodes": 123.78947368421052, "eval_calls": 271, "avg_eval_calls": 14.263157894736842, "line_shape_eval_calls": 271, "line_shape_eval_ns": 254740, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 940.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1545, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.3157894736842, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1545, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1545, "avg_legality_checks": 81.3157894736842, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 1545, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23886, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1257.157894736842, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 47784063, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2000.505023863351, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5263157894736842, "renju_forbidden_ns": 116411, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11641.1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25010, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 91401, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.9473684210526314, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 854028, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11387.04, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 108, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.684210526315789, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 446514, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4134.388888888889, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3789635, "stage_ordering_ns": 870, "stage_eval_ns": 254740, "stage_threat_ns": 38024733, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 561, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 36309222, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 51, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1222498, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 271, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 418393, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 542, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74620, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6945.263157894737, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7366.315789473684, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 6311, "avg_search_time_ms": 332.1578947368421, "search_nodes": 477498, "safety_nodes": 1468, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 478966, "avg_nodes": 25208.736842105263, "eval_calls": 468660, "avg_eval_calls": 24666.315789473683, "line_shape_eval_calls": 468660, "line_shape_eval_ns": 765170843, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1632.677939230999, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8802, "avg_candidate_generations": 463.2631578947368, "candidate_moves_total": 845971, "avg_candidate_moves": 96.11122472165417, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1573, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 8783, "search_candidate_moves_total": 844398, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 21516, "avg_legality_checks": 1132.421052631579, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 21516, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 43518, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2290.4210526315787, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 95427102, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2192.819109334069, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.8947368421052632, "renju_forbidden_ns": 200161, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11774.176470588236, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 63420, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 136741, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 57548397, "stage_ordering_ns": 281611, "stage_eval_ns": 765170843, "stage_threat_ns": 5456770024, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 954905, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4758995700, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 50, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 282541, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 477443, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 590531149, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 954886, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 106960634, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 610, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7962, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6908.8421052631575, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7329.894736842105, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1968, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 52, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7778, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 127, 96, 114, 115, 68, 124, 138, 142, 94, 158, 174, 125, 95, 123, 122, 143, 98, 128, 53, 83, 67, 173, 188, 109, 80, 157, 141, 129, 101, 171 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 7705, "avg_search_time_ms": 481.5625, "search_nodes": 463727, "safety_nodes": 905, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 464632, "avg_nodes": 29039.5, "eval_calls": 451822, "avg_eval_calls": 28238.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 451822, "line_shape_eval_ns": 710516196, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1572.5577683246943, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11874, "avg_candidate_generations": 742.125, "candidate_moves_total": 1135695, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.6455280444669, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1296, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 11858, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1134399, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 442220, "avg_legality_checks": 27638.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 336, "root_legality_checks": 1296, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 440924, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 336, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 460960, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 28810.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1125444114, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2441.5222882679627, "renju_forbidden_checks": 397, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 24.8125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3912916, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9856.211586901763, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 397, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3912916, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 32, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 408502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12765.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 48, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 221020, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4604.583333333333, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1121037553, "stage_ordering_ns": 375112, "stage_eval_ns": 710516196, "stage_threat_ns": 5836002327, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 927376, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5102258009, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 548962, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17310, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 463680, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 620536921, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 927360, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 112658435, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 583, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 10642, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6502.9375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7002.9375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1885, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 55, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4375, "search_nodes": 414, "safety_nodes": 1675, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2089, "avg_nodes": 130.5625, "eval_calls": 398, "avg_eval_calls": 24.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 398, "line_shape_eval_ns": 424182, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1065.78391959799, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1339, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.6875, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1339, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18703, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1168.9375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 39460187, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2109.831952093247, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 74930, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12488.333333333334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 74930, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7580, "stage_ordering_ns": 680, "stage_eval_ns": 424182, "stage_threat_ns": 35379517, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 812, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 34323752, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 351872, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 398, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 599513, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 796, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 104380, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 16, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 16, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6747.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7247.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 53, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1964, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 128, 83, 114, 100, 82, 66, 129, 96, 130, 146, 127, 126, 131 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 37, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 244, "safety_nodes": 544, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 788, "avg_nodes": 87.55555555555556, "eval_calls": 235, "avg_eval_calls": 26.11111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 235, "line_shape_eval_ns": 178430, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 759.2765957446809, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 586, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 586, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 586, "avg_legality_checks": 65.11111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 586, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11215, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1246.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24415971, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2177.0816763263488, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.3333333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 351112, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11703.733333333334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 74881, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 276231, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.111111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 462141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12490.297297297297, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 55, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.111111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 259241, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4713.472727272727, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1676069, "stage_ordering_ns": 330, "stage_eval_ns": 178430, "stage_threat_ns": 20710606, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 479, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19711203, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 587833, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 235, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 348650, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 470, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62920, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5773.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1920, "avg_search_time_ms": 213.33333333333334, "search_nodes": 131212, "safety_nodes": 546, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 131758, "avg_nodes": 14639.777777777777, "eval_calls": 128433, "avg_eval_calls": 14270.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 128433, "line_shape_eval_ns": 144393404, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1124.2702732163852, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2763, "avg_candidate_generations": 307.0, "candidate_moves_total": 219920, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.59464350343829, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 616, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 2754, "search_candidate_moves_total": 219304, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 9255, "avg_legality_checks": 1028.3333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 87, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9255, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 87, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19739, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2193.222222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 47453207, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2404.0329803941436, "renju_forbidden_checks": 115, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12.777777777777779, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1383288, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12028.591304347827, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 87, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1056867, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 326421, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 27764809, "stage_ordering_ns": 101450, "stage_eval_ns": 144393404, "stage_threat_ns": 1740827056, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 262383, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1529585194, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 124191, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9201, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 131187, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 177840937, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 262374, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33276734, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 293, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2380, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5703.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6592.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 54, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2639, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 96, 128, 109, 108, 143, 83, 68, 82, 127, 95, 126, 81, 159, 175, 80, 84, 85, 114, 64, 48, 156, 141, 66, 100, 86, 130, 146, 99, 67, 65, 69, 70, 101, 97, 129, 49 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 2551, "avg_search_time_ms": 134.26315789473685, "search_nodes": 151137, "safety_nodes": 2136, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 153273, "avg_nodes": 8067.0, "eval_calls": 146299, "avg_eval_calls": 7699.9473684210525, "line_shape_eval_calls": 146299, "line_shape_eval_ns": 178777488, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1222.0007518848386, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4801, "avg_candidate_generations": 252.68421052631578, "candidate_moves_total": 391304, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.50468652364091, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1537, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 4782, "search_candidate_moves_total": 389767, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 140800, "avg_legality_checks": 7410.526315789473, "illegal_moves_skipped": 95, "root_legality_checks": 1537, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 139263, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 95, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 162888, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8573.052631578947, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 395637351, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2428.891944157949, "renju_forbidden_checks": 107, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.631578947368421, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1092496, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10210.242990654206, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 105, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1088446, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4050, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.1052631578947367, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 631241, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10699.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.8947368421052633, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 304311, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4112.310810810811, "stage_move_gen_ns": 361123099, "stage_ordering_ns": 159550, "stage_eval_ns": 178777488, "stage_threat_ns": 1986849001, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 302181, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1743045586, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1262263, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 151081, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 204726870, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 302162, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37814282, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 278, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4324, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6800.526315789473, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7221.578947368421, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1894, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 67, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.526315789473684, "search_nodes": 634, "safety_nodes": 1318, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1952, "avg_nodes": 102.73684210526316, "eval_calls": 615, "avg_eval_calls": 32.36842105263158, "line_shape_eval_calls": 615, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1016177, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1652.320325203252, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1572, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.73684210526316, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1572, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21837, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1149.3157894736842, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 45302714, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2074.585062050648, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9280, "stage_ordering_ns": 870, "stage_eval_ns": 1016177, "stage_threat_ns": 42720216, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1249, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 41405617, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 49, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 247801, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20710, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 615, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 907828, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1230, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 158970, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6945.578947368421, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7366.631578947368, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 55, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 687, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 82, 67, 98, 114, 100, 99, 83, 129, 144, 69, 143, 84 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 244, "safety_nodes": 211, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 455, "avg_nodes": 65.0, "eval_calls": 237, "avg_eval_calls": 33.857142857142854, "line_shape_eval_calls": 237, "line_shape_eval_ns": 187811, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 792.451476793249, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 343, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.0, "candidate_moves_max": 59, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 343, "root_candidate_moves_max": 59, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 343, "avg_legality_checks": 49.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 343, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8294, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1184.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18153710, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2188.7762237762236, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 143801, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11983.416666666666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26001, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 117800, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 17, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.4285714285714284, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 216032, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12707.764705882353, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.5714285714285716, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 120670, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4826.8, "stage_move_gen_ns": 975513, "stage_ordering_ns": 340, "stage_eval_ns": 187811, "stage_threat_ns": 16499667, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 481, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15759173, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 325742, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 237, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 350022, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 474, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64730, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 652, "avg_search_time_ms": 93.14285714285714, "search_nodes": 43914, "safety_nodes": 283, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 44197, "avg_nodes": 6313.857142857143, "eval_calls": 42643, "avg_eval_calls": 6091.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 42643, "line_shape_eval_ns": 42495494, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 996.5409094106888, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1259, "avg_candidate_generations": 179.85714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 80984, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.32406671961874, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 356, "root_candidate_moves_max": 58, "search_candidate_generations": 1252, "search_candidate_moves_total": 80628, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 4185, "avg_legality_checks": 597.8571428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 35, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4185, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 35, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12080, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1725.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28006746, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2318.439238410596, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6.714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 563000, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11978.72340425532, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 413500, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 149500, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12068297, "stage_ordering_ns": 45600, "stage_eval_ns": 42495494, "stage_threat_ns": 591108325, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 87797, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 519581316, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 81301, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7070, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43895, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 60264160, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 87790, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11181548, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 169, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1026, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5068.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6211.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 56, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1600, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 111, 143, 98, 158, 173, 157, 96, 99, 81, 126, 95, 94, 110, 174, 190, 109, 80, 125, 79, 63, 78, 82, 77 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 1545, "avg_search_time_ms": 118.84615384615384, "search_nodes": 92689, "safety_nodes": 479, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 93168, "avg_nodes": 7166.7692307692305, "eval_calls": 89279, "avg_eval_calls": 6867.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 89279, "line_shape_eval_ns": 123482956, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1383.1131173064214, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3386, "avg_candidate_generations": 260.46153846153845, "candidate_moves_total": 260484, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.92971057294743, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 3373, "search_candidate_moves_total": 259676, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 86791, "avg_legality_checks": 6676.2307692307695, "illegal_moves_skipped": 383, "root_legality_checks": 808, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 85983, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 378, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 101471, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7805.461538461538, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 243442902, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2399.1377043687357, "renju_forbidden_checks": 496, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 38.15384615384615, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4119578, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8305.600806451614, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 476, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3924448, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 195130, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.2307692307692308, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 152681, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9542.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.5384615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 60751, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3037.55, "stage_move_gen_ns": 222744538, "stage_ordering_ns": 112931, "stage_eval_ns": 123482956, "stage_threat_ns": 1181324267, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 185317, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1032935496, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 250631, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92652, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125500127, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 185304, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22638013, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 439, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2795, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6417.307692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7032.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1939, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 41, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4166666666666665, "search_nodes": 312, "safety_nodes": 680, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 992, "avg_nodes": 82.66666666666667, "eval_calls": 300, "avg_eval_calls": 25.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 300, "line_shape_eval_ns": 331301, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1104.3366666666666, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 748, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.333333333333336, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13600, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1133.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28908235, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2125.6055147058823, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 261812, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10069.692307692309, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 261812, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5070, "stage_ordering_ns": 560, "stage_eval_ns": 331301, "stage_threat_ns": 26226343, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 612, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 25472179, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 219651, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 455901, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 600, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 78612, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 57, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1555, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 109, 108, 125, 141, 99, 128, 124, 142, 98, 156, 114, 158, 155, 143, 173, 140, 144, 139 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.7, "search_nodes": 317, "safety_nodes": 349, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 666, "avg_nodes": 66.6, "eval_calls": 307, "avg_eval_calls": 30.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 307, "line_shape_eval_ns": 171312, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 558.0195439739414, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 557, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.7, "candidate_moves_max": 69, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 557, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 557, "avg_legality_checks": 55.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 557, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11845, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1184.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17813022, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1503.8431405656395, "renju_forbidden_checks": 80, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 492432, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6155.4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 106621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 64, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 385811, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 181402, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8638.190476190477, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 30, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 104462, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3482.0666666666666, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1154815, "stage_ordering_ns": 340, "stage_eval_ns": 171312, "stage_threat_ns": 16414453, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 624, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15736109, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 251462, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 307, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 363622, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 614, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63260, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 1520, "avg_search_time_ms": 152.0, "search_nodes": 165783, "safety_nodes": 452, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 166235, "avg_nodes": 16623.5, "eval_calls": 162140, "avg_eval_calls": 16214.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 162140, "line_shape_eval_ns": 110365409, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 680.6797150610583, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3625, "avg_candidate_generations": 362.5, "candidate_moves_total": 259973, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.71668965517242, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 579, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 3615, "search_candidate_moves_total": 259394, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 7951, "avg_legality_checks": 795.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 176, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7951, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 176, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19173, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1917.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31539698, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1645.0058937046888, "renju_forbidden_checks": 256, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 25.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1634186, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6383.5390625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 176, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1152564, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 80, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 481622, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17434398, "stage_ordering_ns": 106461, "stage_eval_ns": 110365409, "stage_threat_ns": 1372147504, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 331520, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1190036203, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 94340, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6970, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 165755, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 154043629, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 331510, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27973332, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 320, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3169, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5925.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6725.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 58, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1220, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 96, 128, 125, 129, 130, 114, 95, 140, 94, 97, 80, 65, 81, 145, 161, 66, 79, 82, 64, 48, 49, 109, 34 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 1186, "avg_search_time_ms": 91.23076923076923, "search_nodes": 126124, "safety_nodes": 479, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 126603, "avg_nodes": 9738.692307692309, "eval_calls": 121819, "avg_eval_calls": 9370.692307692309, "line_shape_eval_calls": 121819, "line_shape_eval_ns": 78167888, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 641.672382797429, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4281, "avg_candidate_generations": 329.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 312211, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.92945573464144, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 4268, "search_candidate_moves_total": 311403, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 119265, "avg_legality_checks": 9174.23076923077, "illegal_moves_skipped": 626, "root_legality_checks": 808, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 118457, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 621, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 134093, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10314.846153846154, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 179709517, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1340.1856696471853, "renju_forbidden_checks": 691, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 53.15384615384615, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3685118, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5333.021707670044, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 671, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3576648, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 108470, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.2307692307692308, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 86352, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5397.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.5384615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 38840, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1942.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 173419974, "stage_ordering_ns": 121870, "stage_eval_ns": 78167888, "stage_threat_ns": 908084970, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 252187, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 783139131, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 141352, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 126087, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105531937, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 252174, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19272550, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 439, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3646, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6384.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7000.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1960, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 21, "avg_search_time_ms": 1.75, "search_nodes": 312, "safety_nodes": 680, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 992, "avg_nodes": 82.66666666666667, "eval_calls": 300, "avg_eval_calls": 25.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 300, "line_shape_eval_ns": 174281, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 580.9366666666666, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 748, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.333333333333336, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13762, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1146.8333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15677968, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1139.2216247638426, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 174091, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6695.807692307692, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 174091, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3660, "stage_ordering_ns": 460, "stage_eval_ns": 174281, "stage_threat_ns": 15067317, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 612, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14598835, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 138641, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 282151, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 600, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47690, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6332.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6998.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1999, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 59, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 363, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 95, 79, 80, 66, 110, 125, 50, 126, 65 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 14, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.0, "search_nodes": 244, "safety_nodes": 211, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 455, "avg_nodes": 65.0, "eval_calls": 237, "avg_eval_calls": 33.857142857142854, "line_shape_eval_calls": 237, "line_shape_eval_ns": 100231, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 422.915611814346, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 343, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.0, "candidate_moves_max": 59, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 343, "root_candidate_moves_max": 59, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 343, "avg_legality_checks": 49.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 343, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8200, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1171.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9464942, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1154.261219512195, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 81912, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6826.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16640, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 65272, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 17, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.4285714285714284, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 127561, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7503.588235294118, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.5714285714285716, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 72140, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2885.6, "stage_move_gen_ns": 539444, "stage_ordering_ns": 240, "stage_eval_ns": 100231, "stage_threat_ns": 9047194, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 481, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 8603951, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 191811, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 237, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 211922, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 474, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39510, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5140.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6282.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 342, "avg_search_time_ms": 48.857142857142854, "search_nodes": 42603, "safety_nodes": 283, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 42886, "avg_nodes": 6126.571428571428, "eval_calls": 41387, "avg_eval_calls": 5912.428571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 41387, "line_shape_eval_ns": 21046140, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 508.5205499311378, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1204, "avg_candidate_generations": 172.0, "candidate_moves_total": 76497, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.535714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 356, "root_candidate_moves_max": 58, "search_candidate_generations": 1197, "search_candidate_moves_total": 76141, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 4285, "avg_legality_checks": 612.1428571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4285, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12086, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1726.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14394283, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1190.988168128413, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6.285714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 255292, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5802.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 181322, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 73970, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6302991, "stage_ordering_ns": 37420, "stage_eval_ns": 21046140, "stage_threat_ns": 306461146, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 85175, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 266851203, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 46070, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42584, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 33294850, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 85168, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6269023, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 169, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 976, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5103.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6246.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1993, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 60, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 928, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 98, 126, 81, 141, 156, 142, 83, 80, 68, 113, 84, 85, 99, 155, 169, 100, 69, 114, 70, 56, 71, 67, 72 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 895, "avg_search_time_ms": 68.84615384615384, "search_nodes": 95494, "safety_nodes": 479, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 95973, "avg_nodes": 7382.538461538462, "eval_calls": 91974, "avg_eval_calls": 7074.923076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 91974, "line_shape_eval_ns": 67772818, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 736.8693108922087, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3496, "avg_candidate_generations": 268.9230769230769, "candidate_moves_total": 268555, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.81779176201373, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 3483, "search_candidate_moves_total": 267747, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 89349, "avg_legality_checks": 6873.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 434, "root_legality_checks": 808, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 88541, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 429, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 104177, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8013.615384615385, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 136477898, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1310.0578630599844, "renju_forbidden_checks": 547, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 42.07692307692308, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2242946, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4100.449725776965, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 527, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2153155, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 89791, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.2307692307692308, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 84211, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5263.1875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.5384615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 36391, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1819.55, "stage_move_gen_ns": 127457818, "stage_ordering_ns": 99410, "stage_eval_ns": 67772818, "stage_threat_ns": 674999461, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 190927, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 582353226, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 139891, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6620, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 95457, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 78574892, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 190914, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13931452, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 439, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2901, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6437.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7053.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1966, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 22, "avg_search_time_ms": 1.8333333333333333, "search_nodes": 312, "safety_nodes": 680, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 992, "avg_nodes": 82.66666666666667, "eval_calls": 300, "avg_eval_calls": 25.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 300, "line_shape_eval_ns": 176581, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 588.6033333333334, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 748, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.333333333333336, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13762, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1146.8333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15237878, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1107.2429879377996, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 130972, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5037.384615384615, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 130972, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3420, "stage_ordering_ns": 430, "stage_eval_ns": 176581, "stage_threat_ns": 14620940, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 612, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14167199, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 126651, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6850, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 279270, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 600, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47820, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6332.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6998.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1999, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 61, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 338, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 110, 109, 96, 82, 66, 81, 95, 83, 84, 79, 99, 80 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 15, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.142857142857143, "search_nodes": 244, "safety_nodes": 211, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 455, "avg_nodes": 65.0, "eval_calls": 237, "avg_eval_calls": 33.857142857142854, "line_shape_eval_calls": 237, "line_shape_eval_ns": 108251, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 456.7552742616034, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 343, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.0, "candidate_moves_max": 59, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 343, "root_candidate_moves_max": 59, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 343, "avg_legality_checks": 49.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 343, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8294, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1184.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9943004, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1198.8189052326984, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 94460, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7871.666666666667, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17210, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 77250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 17, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.4285714285714284, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 123571, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7268.882352941177, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.5714285714285716, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 70390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2815.6, "stage_move_gen_ns": 540210, "stage_ordering_ns": 190, "stage_eval_ns": 108251, "stage_threat_ns": 9244196, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 481, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 8781254, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 189481, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 237, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 232491, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 474, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40970, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5140.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6282.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 317, "avg_search_time_ms": 45.285714285714285, "search_nodes": 38059, "safety_nodes": 283, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 38342, "avg_nodes": 5477.428571428572, "eval_calls": 36842, "avg_eval_calls": 5263.142857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 36842, "line_shape_eval_ns": 21810702, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 592.0064600184572, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1205, "avg_candidate_generations": 172.14285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 77345, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.18672199170125, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 356, "root_candidate_moves_max": 58, "search_candidate_generations": 1198, "search_candidate_moves_total": 76989, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 3702, "avg_legality_checks": 528.8571428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3702, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11597, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1656.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14843218, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1279.9187720962318, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.428571428571429, "renju_forbidden_ns": 232430, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6116.578947368421, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 154400, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 78030, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5781602, "stage_ordering_ns": 36841, "stage_eval_ns": 21810702, "stage_threat_ns": 280002962, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 76087, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 243336507, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 52520, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3890, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 30822287, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 76080, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5791648, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 169, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 987, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5109.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6251.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1992, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 62, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3309, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 127, 99, 96, 100, 101, 115, 126, 81, 125, 128, 141, 156, 142, 86, 72, 157, 140, 143, 155, 169, 170, 110, 185 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3266, "avg_search_time_ms": 251.23076923076923, "search_nodes": 246371, "safety_nodes": 479, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 246850, "avg_nodes": 18988.46153846154, "eval_calls": 240581, "avg_eval_calls": 18506.23076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 240581, "line_shape_eval_ns": 277426155, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1153.150726782248, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5766, "avg_candidate_generations": 443.53846153846155, "candidate_moves_total": 432395, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.99046132500867, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 5753, "search_candidate_moves_total": 431587, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 237549, "avg_legality_checks": 18273.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1608, "root_legality_checks": 808, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 236741, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1603, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 252229, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19402.23076923077, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 482333028, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1912.2822038702925, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1888, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 145.23076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14522731, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7692.124470338983, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1868, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14361941, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 160790, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.2307692307692308, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 87030, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5439.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.5384615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 36930, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1846.5, "stage_move_gen_ns": 487981613, "stage_ordering_ns": 173100, "stage_eval_ns": 277426155, "stage_threat_ns": 2466064370, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 492681, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2140462245, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 147101, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9670, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 246334, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 275556688, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 492668, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49898336, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 439, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5026, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6353.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6968.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1939, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 32, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.6666666666666665, "search_nodes": 312, "safety_nodes": 680, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 992, "avg_nodes": 82.66666666666667, "eval_calls": 300, "avg_eval_calls": 25.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 300, "line_shape_eval_ns": 276312, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 921.04, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 748, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.333333333333336, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13600, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1133.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21477389, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1579.2197794117646, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 229541, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8828.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 229541, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4090, "stage_ordering_ns": 580, "stage_eval_ns": 276312, "stage_threat_ns": 19933138, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 612, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19362637, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 150380, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10220, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 357891, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 600, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62230, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6332.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6998.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1999, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 63, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 658, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 82, 67, 96, 110, 94, 95, 81, 125, 140, 65, 141, 80 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 244, "safety_nodes": 211, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 455, "avg_nodes": 65.0, "eval_calls": 237, "avg_eval_calls": 33.857142857142854, "line_shape_eval_calls": 237, "line_shape_eval_ns": 182161, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 768.6118143459915, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 343, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.0, "candidate_moves_max": 59, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 343, "root_candidate_moves_max": 59, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 343, "avg_legality_checks": 49.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 343, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8294, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1184.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17522371, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2112.656257535568, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 143370, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11947.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26230, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 117140, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 17, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.4285714285714284, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 204632, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12037.176470588236, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.5714285714285716, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 113381, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4535.24, "stage_move_gen_ns": 941966, "stage_ordering_ns": 300, "stage_eval_ns": 182161, "stage_threat_ns": 16025855, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 481, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15307959, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 311532, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 237, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 344784, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 474, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61580, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 626, "avg_search_time_ms": 89.42857142857143, "search_nodes": 43383, "safety_nodes": 283, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 43666, "avg_nodes": 6238.0, "eval_calls": 42167, "avg_eval_calls": 6023.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 42167, "line_shape_eval_ns": 40247839, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 954.4866601845044, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1204, "avg_candidate_generations": 172.0, "candidate_moves_total": 77352, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.24584717607974, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 356, "root_candidate_moves_max": 58, "search_candidate_generations": 1197, "search_candidate_moves_total": 76996, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 4360, "avg_legality_checks": 622.8571428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4360, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12255, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1750.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27303247, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2227.9271317829457, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6.285714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 521770, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11858.40909090909, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 373460, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 148310, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11840201, "stage_ordering_ns": 43340, "stage_eval_ns": 40247839, "stage_threat_ns": 564921318, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 86735, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 497468863, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 81830, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43364, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 56708414, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 86728, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10662211, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 169, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 976, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5071.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6214.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 64, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1633, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 113, 141, 96, 156, 171, 157, 98, 95, 83, 128, 99, 100, 114, 170, 184, 115, 84, 129, 85, 71, 86, 82, 87 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 1578, "avg_search_time_ms": 121.38461538461539, "search_nodes": 96696, "safety_nodes": 479, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 97175, "avg_nodes": 7475.0, "eval_calls": 93176, "avg_eval_calls": 7167.384615384615, "line_shape_eval_calls": 93176, "line_shape_eval_ns": 127244288, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1365.6337254228556, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3496, "avg_candidate_generations": 268.9230769230769, "candidate_moves_total": 268736, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.8695652173913, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 3483, "search_candidate_moves_total": 267928, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 90527, "avg_legality_checks": 6963.615384615385, "illegal_moves_skipped": 434, "root_legality_checks": 808, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 89719, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 429, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 105207, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8092.846153846154, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 245668796, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2335.099337496554, "renju_forbidden_checks": 547, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 42.07692307692308, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4464163, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8161.1755027422305, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 527, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4286372, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 177791, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.2307692307692308, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 146001, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9125.0625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.5384615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 57560, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2878.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 226307339, "stage_ordering_ns": 112050, "stage_eval_ns": 127244288, "stage_threat_ns": 1206849821, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 193331, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1055310490, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 239511, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 96659, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 127939183, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 193318, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23360637, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 439, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2901, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6417.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7033.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1938, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 41, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4166666666666665, "search_nodes": 312, "safety_nodes": 680, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 992, "avg_nodes": 82.66666666666667, "eval_calls": 300, "avg_eval_calls": 25.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 300, "line_shape_eval_ns": 320490, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1068.3, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 748, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.333333333333336, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13600, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1133.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27950575, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2055.189338235294, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 247561, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9521.576923076924, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 247561, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5840, "stage_ordering_ns": 610, "stage_eval_ns": 320490, "stage_threat_ns": 25430209, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 612, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24704986, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 209220, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12830, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 439573, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 600, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 76430, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 65, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1176, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 67, 52, 83, 99, 85, 84, 68, 54, 114, 39, 100, 69 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 248, "safety_nodes": 214, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 462, "avg_nodes": 66.0, "eval_calls": 241, "avg_eval_calls": 34.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 241, "line_shape_eval_ns": 188142, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 780.6721991701245, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 348, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.714285714285715, "candidate_moves_max": 62, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 348, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 348, "avg_legality_checks": 49.714285714285715, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 348, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8172, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1167.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17372071, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2125.8040871267744, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 125340, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11394.545454545454, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21390, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 103950, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 162640, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12510.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 90150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4744.736842105263, "stage_move_gen_ns": 938814, "stage_ordering_ns": 300, "stage_eval_ns": 188142, "stage_threat_ns": 15980757, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 489, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15330035, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 244120, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 344021, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62581, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1144, "avg_search_time_ms": 163.42857142857142, "search_nodes": 33078, "safety_nodes": 287, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 33365, "avg_nodes": 4766.428571428572, "eval_calls": 31993, "avg_eval_calls": 4570.428571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 31993, "pattern_eval_ns": 675080, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.1008658143969, "pattern_frame_queries": 31993, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 675080, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.1008658143969, "pattern_frame_updates": 66118, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 690519176, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10443.739617048308, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1073, "avg_candidate_generations": 153.28571428571428, "candidate_moves_total": 68264, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.619757688723205, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 361, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 1066, "search_candidate_moves_total": 67903, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 2583, "avg_legality_checks": 369.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2583, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 185813, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26544.714285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 426527231, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2295.4649620855375, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5235, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 747.8571428571429, "renju_forbidden_ns": 48544967, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9273.155109837631, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 86780, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5202, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 48176493, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 281694, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6473922, "stage_ordering_ns": 43130, "stage_eval_ns": 691194256, "stage_threat_ns": 433044277, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 66125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 380837430, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 80790, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 33059, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 44047850, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 66118, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8078207, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 170, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 867, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5004.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6147.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 66, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3339, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 80, 128, 83, 143, 158, 84, 111, 69, 81, 79, 96, 126, 51, 66, 67, 52, 35, 99, 19 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3297, "avg_search_time_ms": 299.72727272727275, "search_nodes": 79191, "safety_nodes": 652, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 79843, "avg_nodes": 7258.454545454545, "eval_calls": 75863, "avg_eval_calls": 6896.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75863, "pattern_eval_ns": 1586975, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.91895917641011, "pattern_frame_queries": 75863, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1586975, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.91895917641011, "pattern_frame_updates": 158320, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2076786247, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13117.649362051541, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3308, "avg_candidate_generations": 300.72727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 237359, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.753022974607, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 664, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 3297, "search_candidate_moves_total": 236695, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 72554, "avg_legality_checks": 6595.818181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 202, "root_legality_checks": 664, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 71890, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 202, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 662957, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 60268.818181818184, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1554966607, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2345.501453337094, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13989, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1271.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 91958009, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6573.594181142326, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 206, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1802938, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13781, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 90152591, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2480, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 41, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.727272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 361343, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8813.243902439024, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 150132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2780.222222222222, "stage_move_gen_ns": 175709239, "stage_ordering_ns": 115050, "stage_eval_ns": 2078373222, "stage_threat_ns": 1020254165, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 158331, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 892115414, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 521994, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11021, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108679967, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 158320, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18936790, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 298, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2861, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6038.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6765.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1869, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1, "search_nodes": 78, "safety_nodes": 824, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 902, "avg_nodes": 90.2, "eval_calls": 68, "avg_eval_calls": 6.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68, "line_shape_eval_ns": 54021, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 794.4264705882352, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 613, "avg_candidate_moves": 61.3, "candidate_moves_max": 79, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 613, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11550, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1155.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24183649, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2093.8224242424244, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4130, "stage_ordering_ns": 490, "stage_eval_ns": 54021, "stage_threat_ns": 19267515, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 146, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18937793, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 207731, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10880, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 103681, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18310, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 67, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11639, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 110, 109, 126, 142, 100, 156, 170, 172, 97, 157, 187, 140, 124, 141, 125, 139, 138, 143 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 34, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4, "search_nodes": 217, "safety_nodes": 617, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 834, "avg_nodes": 83.4, "eval_calls": 207, "avg_eval_calls": 20.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 207, "line_shape_eval_ns": 125632, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 606.9178743961353, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 617, "avg_candidate_moves": 61.7, "candidate_moves_max": 78, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 617, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 617, "avg_legality_checks": 61.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 617, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12183, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1218.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23726435, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1947.5034884675367, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 192180, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12812.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 37560, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 154620, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 29, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 372762, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12853.862068965518, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 208292, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4844.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1504766, "stage_ordering_ns": 460, "stage_eval_ns": 125632, "stage_threat_ns": 19612500, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 424, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18790284, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 510743, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9850, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 207, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 263763, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 414, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47710, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11595, "avg_search_time_ms": 1159.5, "search_nodes": 337753, "safety_nodes": 344, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 338097, "avg_nodes": 33809.7, "eval_calls": 331212, "avg_eval_calls": 33121.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 331212, "pattern_eval_ns": 6792961, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.50940485248119, "pattern_frame_queries": 331212, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6792961, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.50940485248119, "pattern_frame_updates": 675450, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7509644142, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11117.986737730402, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6523, "avg_candidate_generations": 652.3, "candidate_moves_total": 519063, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.57427564004293, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 649, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 6513, "search_candidate_moves_total": 518414, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 9977, "avg_legality_checks": 997.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 123, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9977, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 123, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1970278, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 197027.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4404821148, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2235.6343358652944, "renju_forbidden_checks": 73238, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7323.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 691431946, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9440.890603238757, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 123, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1318306, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 73085, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 689786048, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 327592, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 27227486, "stage_ordering_ns": 217250, "stage_eval_ns": 7516437103, "stage_threat_ns": 4026276395, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 675460, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3514995583, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 109590, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9220, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 337725, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 433672498, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 675450, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 77498724, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 399, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5736, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.6, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3813.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4613.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 68, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5121, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 81, 129, 126, 130, 131, 141, 98, 140, 96, 66, 97, 99, 94, 95, 110, 109, 78, 142, 62 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5078, "avg_search_time_ms": 461.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 115275, "safety_nodes": 652, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 115927, "avg_nodes": 10538.818181818182, "eval_calls": 111132, "avg_eval_calls": 10102.90909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 111132, "pattern_eval_ns": 2355964, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.19969045819386, "pattern_frame_queries": 111132, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2355964, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.19969045819386, "pattern_frame_updates": 230488, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3245893093, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14082.698852000973, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4123, "avg_candidate_generations": 374.8181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 290660, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.49721076885763, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 664, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 4112, "search_candidate_moves_total": 289996, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 106498, "avg_legality_checks": 9681.636363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 664, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 105834, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 978422, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 88947.45454545454, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2414121791, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2467.3625398856525, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15645, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1422.2727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 114511812, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7319.3871524448705, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 474883, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15595, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 114033919, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3010, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 41, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.727272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 372912, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9095.414634146342, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 154661, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2864.0925925925926, "stage_move_gen_ns": 271885377, "stage_ordering_ns": 148532, "stage_eval_ns": 3248249057, "stage_threat_ns": 1536157484, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 230499, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1345502336, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 536004, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115244, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 161074302, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 230488, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29044842, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 298, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3609, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5772.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6499.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1870, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1, "search_nodes": 78, "safety_nodes": 824, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 902, "avg_nodes": 90.2, "eval_calls": 68, "avg_eval_calls": 6.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68, "line_shape_eval_ns": 55281, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 812.9558823529412, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 613, "avg_candidate_moves": 61.3, "candidate_moves_max": 79, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 613, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11482, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1148.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24208864, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2108.4187423793765, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4080, "stage_ordering_ns": 440, "stage_eval_ns": 55281, "stage_threat_ns": 19342454, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 146, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19007243, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 208321, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11020, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108210, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18680, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 69, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1050, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 81, 65, 80, 94, 78, 82, 77, 66, 79 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 248, "safety_nodes": 214, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 462, "avg_nodes": 66.0, "eval_calls": 241, "avg_eval_calls": 34.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 241, "line_shape_eval_ns": 190811, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 791.7468879668049, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 348, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.714285714285715, "candidate_moves_max": 62, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 348, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 348, "avg_legality_checks": 49.714285714285715, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 348, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8172, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1167.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17602927, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2154.053720019579, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 121390, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11035.454545454546, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22590, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 98800, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 163241, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12557.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 89001, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4684.263157894737, "stage_move_gen_ns": 942415, "stage_ordering_ns": 540, "stage_eval_ns": 190811, "stage_threat_ns": 16150800, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 489, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15493207, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 248781, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7540, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 345371, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63441, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1017, "avg_search_time_ms": 145.28571428571428, "search_nodes": 30242, "safety_nodes": 287, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 30529, "avg_nodes": 4361.285714285715, "eval_calls": 29183, "avg_eval_calls": 4169.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 29183, "pattern_eval_ns": 618423, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.191207209676868, "pattern_frame_queries": 29183, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 618423, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.191207209676868, "pattern_frame_updates": 60446, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 592448294, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9801.282036859346, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1047, "avg_candidate_generations": 149.57142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 66672, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.67908309455587, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 361, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 1040, "search_candidate_moves_total": 66311, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 2688, "avg_legality_checks": 384.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2688, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 154809, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22115.571428571428, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 356811859, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2304.8521662177263, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3911, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 558.7142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37183427, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9507.396318077219, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 93991, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3876, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 36808794, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 280642, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6966563, "stage_ordering_ns": 41411, "stage_eval_ns": 593066717, "stage_threat_ns": 404787498, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 60453, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 356414012, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 80050, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6920, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 30223, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 40798442, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 60446, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7494994, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 170, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 840, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5039.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6181.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 70, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19758, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 81, 65, 129, 145, 80, 79, 127, 51, 37, 107, 93, 140, 109, 126, 98, 154, 168, 63, 47, 99, 94, 156, 114, 155, 125, 153, 152, 157 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 19690, "avg_search_time_ms": 1230.625, "search_nodes": 542303, "safety_nodes": 487, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 542790, "avg_nodes": 33924.375, "eval_calls": 530021, "avg_eval_calls": 33126.3125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 530021, "pattern_eval_ns": 11182671, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.098543265266848, "pattern_frame_queries": 530021, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11182671, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.098543265266848, "pattern_frame_updates": 1084514, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 11814588955, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10893.901743084922, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12252, "avg_candidate_generations": 765.75, "candidate_moves_total": 1198871, "avg_candidate_moves": 97.85104472739144, "candidate_moves_max": 136, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1363, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 12236, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1197508, "search_candidate_moves_max": 136, "legality_checks": 500608, "avg_legality_checks": 31288.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 189, "root_legality_checks": 1363, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 499245, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 189, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3812489, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 238280.5625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8618241158, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2260.5287931322555, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41513, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2594.5625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 250151609, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6025.861995037699, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 485, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2410270, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 41014, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 247701319, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 40020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.5625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 240601, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9624.04, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 34, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 116511, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3426.794117647059, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1139599970, "stage_ordering_ns": 462951, "stage_eval_ns": 11825771626, "stage_threat_ns": 6628803305, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1084530, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5784164049, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 339591, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 542257, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 717187534, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1084514, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 127112131, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 952, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 10610, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 2.8125, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8125, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6024.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6524.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1815, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 52, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.466666666666667, "search_nodes": 411, "safety_nodes": 1297, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1708, "avg_nodes": 113.86666666666666, "eval_calls": 396, "avg_eval_calls": 26.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 396, "line_shape_eval_ns": 624151, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1576.138888888889, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1297, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.46666666666667, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1297, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17424, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1161.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 36111843, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2072.5346074380163, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 74250, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3093.75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 74250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7410, "stage_ordering_ns": 740, "stage_eval_ns": 624151, "stage_threat_ns": 32530015, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 807, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 31623413, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 263130, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 396, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 545970, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 792, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 97502, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 15, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 15, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6664.466666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7197.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 71, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6675, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 115, 116, 129, 143, 95, 159, 175, 145, 128, 131, 117, 146, 101, 144, 142, 147 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 34, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7777777777777777, "search_nodes": 232, "safety_nodes": 551, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 783, "avg_nodes": 87.0, "eval_calls": 223, "avg_eval_calls": 24.77777777777778, "line_shape_eval_calls": 223, "line_shape_eval_ns": 163041, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 731.1255605381166, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 564, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.666666666666664, "candidate_moves_max": 78, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 564, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 564, "avg_legality_checks": 62.666666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 564, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10946, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1216.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23760177, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2170.6721176685546, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.7777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 328991, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 13159.64, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 39, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 188160, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4824.615384615385, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1507019, "stage_ordering_ns": 360, "stage_eval_ns": 163041, "stage_threat_ns": 20021748, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 455, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19167225, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 469931, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 223, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 325130, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 446, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59462, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5773.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6633, "avg_search_time_ms": 737.0, "search_nodes": 202571, "safety_nodes": 204, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 202775, "avg_nodes": 22530.555555555555, "eval_calls": 198364, "avg_eval_calls": 22040.444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 198364, "pattern_eval_ns": 4263839, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.495024298763887, "pattern_frame_queries": 198364, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4263839, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.495024298763887, "pattern_frame_updates": 405092, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3871753450, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9557.713926712944, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4191, "avg_candidate_generations": 465.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 322951, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.05821999522787, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 586, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 4182, "search_candidate_moves_total": 322365, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 7760, "avg_legality_checks": 862.2222222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7760, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 908615, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 100957.22222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2210640105, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2432.977779367499, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7330, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 814.4444444444445, "renju_forbidden_ns": 76888665, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10489.585948158254, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7330, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 76888665, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22576030, "stage_ordering_ns": 148032, "stage_eval_ns": 3876017289, "stage_threat_ns": 2716545212, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 405101, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2381469450, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 63451, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 202546, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 283147883, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 405092, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51864428, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 391, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3624, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4763.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5652.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1970, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 72, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6136, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 95, 159, 175, 115, 96, 144, 142, 100, 94, 97, 110, 99, 101, 158, 80, 64, 125, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6088, "avg_search_time_ms": 507.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 148506, "safety_nodes": 312, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148818, "avg_nodes": 12401.5, "eval_calls": 143393, "avg_eval_calls": 11949.416666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 143393, "pattern_eval_ns": 3044110, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.22913949774396, "pattern_frame_queries": 143393, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3044110, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.22913949774396, "pattern_frame_updates": 296944, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3711068837, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12497.537707446521, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5091, "avg_candidate_generations": 424.25, "candidate_moves_total": 380829, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.8043606364172, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 795, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 5079, "search_candidate_moves_total": 380034, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 139128, "avg_legality_checks": 11594.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "root_legality_checks": 795, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 138333, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1051323, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 87610.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2611950715, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2484.441712965473, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14168, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1180.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 112655214, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7951.384387351779, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 350821, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14123, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 112304393, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.8333333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 114261, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11426.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.1666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 57631, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4116.5, "stage_move_gen_ns": 360792557, "stage_ordering_ns": 172010, "stage_eval_ns": 3714112947, "stage_threat_ns": 1990511238, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 296956, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1742248920, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 172102, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12270, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148472, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 209589591, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 296944, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38500625, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 535, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4355, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5776.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6443.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1784, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.272727272727273, "search_nodes": 197, "safety_nodes": 955, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1152, "avg_nodes": 104.72727272727273, "eval_calls": 186, "avg_eval_calls": 16.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 186, "line_shape_eval_ns": 150061, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 806.7795698924731, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 734, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.72727272727273, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12753, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.3636363636363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27173528, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2130.7557437465694, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4750, "stage_ordering_ns": 460, "stage_eval_ns": 150061, "stage_threat_ns": 23097249, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 383, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22486952, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 280804, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12081, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 186, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 277443, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52050, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 73, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4913, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 157, 172, 141, 125, 83, 140, 156, 110, 95, 170, 98, 155 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.857142857142857, "search_nodes": 275, "safety_nodes": 235, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 510, "avg_nodes": 72.85714285714286, "eval_calls": 268, "avg_eval_calls": 38.285714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 268, "line_shape_eval_ns": 207123, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 772.8470149253732, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 386, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.142857142857146, "candidate_moves_max": 66, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 386, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 386, "avg_legality_checks": 55.142857142857146, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 386, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8381, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1197.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18185490, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2169.8472735950363, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 132411, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11034.25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20381, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 112030, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 188971, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12598.066666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 106230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4618.695652173913, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1048375, "stage_ordering_ns": 290, "stage_eval_ns": 207123, "stage_threat_ns": 16822688, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 543, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16071724, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 297272, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7451, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 268, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 382142, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 536, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 71550, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 4880, "avg_search_time_ms": 697.1428571428571, "search_nodes": 153736, "safety_nodes": 191, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 153927, "avg_nodes": 21989.571428571428, "eval_calls": 150030, "avg_eval_calls": 21432.85714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 150030, "pattern_eval_ns": 3197668, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.313523961874292, "pattern_frame_queries": 150030, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3197668, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.313523961874292, "pattern_frame_updates": 307434, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2739435610, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8910.646220001692, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3694, "avg_candidate_generations": 527.7142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 269709, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.01272333513806, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 396, "root_candidate_moves_max": 65, "search_candidate_generations": 3687, "search_candidate_moves_total": 269313, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 8794, "avg_legality_checks": 1256.2857142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8794, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 596855, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 85265.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1450164155, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2429.6758090323447, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7655, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1093.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_ns": 78003659, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10189.896668843892, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 71651, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7633, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 77761637, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 170371, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 25288236, "stage_ordering_ns": 124200, "stage_eval_ns": 2742633278, "stage_threat_ns": 2101234760, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 307441, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1845631170, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 59651, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6931, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 153717, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 214938122, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 307434, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40605817, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 246, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3248, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4042.4285714285716, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5185.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 74, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7156, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 83, 139, 153, 157, 98, 140, 110, 158, 68, 113, 82, 143, 173, 124, 84, 70, 81, 85, 80 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7105, "avg_search_time_ms": 592.0833333333334, "search_nodes": 172434, "safety_nodes": 312, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 172746, "avg_nodes": 14395.5, "eval_calls": 167254, "avg_eval_calls": 13937.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 167254, "pattern_eval_ns": 3578167, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.393610915135064, "pattern_frame_queries": 167254, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3578167, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.393610915135064, "pattern_frame_updates": 344800, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4289133360, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12439.481902552205, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5158, "avg_candidate_generations": 429.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 370676, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.8642884839085, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 795, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 5146, "search_candidate_moves_total": 369881, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 161491, "avg_legality_checks": 13457.583333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 56, "root_legality_checks": 795, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 160696, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 56, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1178293, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 98191.08333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2953043817, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2506.2050075830034, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14008, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1167.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 122594418, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8751.743146773273, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 79, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 682761, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13929, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 121911657, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.8333333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 117421, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11742.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.1666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 58301, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4164.357142857143, "stage_move_gen_ns": 425177797, "stage_ordering_ns": 188632, "stage_eval_ns": 4292711527, "stage_threat_ns": 2362084484, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 344812, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2075137331, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 175561, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 172400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 242088083, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 344800, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44683509, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 535, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4439, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5131.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5798.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 550, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.272727272727273, "search_nodes": 197, "safety_nodes": 955, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1152, "avg_nodes": 104.72727272727273, "eval_calls": 186, "avg_eval_calls": 16.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 186, "line_shape_eval_ns": 161190, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 866.6129032258065, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 734, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.72727272727273, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12753, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.3636363636363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27128008, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2127.1863875166628, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4770, "stage_ordering_ns": 530, "stage_eval_ns": 161190, "stage_threat_ns": 23127352, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 383, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22514030, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 282401, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 186, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 278601, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52320, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 75, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1276, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 109, 108, 95, 81, 65, 80, 94, 78, 82, 77, 96, 79 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 274, "safety_nodes": 234, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 508, "avg_nodes": 72.57142857142857, "eval_calls": 267, "avg_eval_calls": 38.142857142857146, "line_shape_eval_calls": 267, "line_shape_eval_ns": 204763, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 766.9026217228464, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 385, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.0, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 385, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 385, "avg_legality_checks": 55.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 385, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18230753, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2180.9729632731187, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.2857142857142856, "renju_forbidden_ns": 173281, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10830.0625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 31091, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 142190, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 187442, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12496.133333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 105731, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4597.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1068805, "stage_ordering_ns": 280, "stage_eval_ns": 204763, "stage_threat_ns": 16891492, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 541, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16158797, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 276092, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 386183, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 70420, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1240, "avg_search_time_ms": 177.14285714285714, "search_nodes": 36146, "safety_nodes": 313, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 36459, "avg_nodes": 5208.428571428572, "eval_calls": 34923, "avg_eval_calls": 4989.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34923, "pattern_eval_ns": 740504, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.20390573547519, "pattern_frame_queries": 34923, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 740504, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.20390573547519, "pattern_frame_updates": 72254, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 731678686, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10126.480001107206, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1211, "avg_candidate_generations": 173.0, "candidate_moves_total": 82478, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.10734929810074, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 393, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 1204, "search_candidate_moves_total": 82085, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 2736, "avg_legality_checks": 390.85714285714283, "illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2736, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 185207, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26458.14285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 427973227, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2310.78321553721, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6156, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 879.4285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60981157, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9905.970922677063, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 133352, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6122, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60625345, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 222460, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7279594, "stage_ordering_ns": 44271, "stage_eval_ns": 732419190, "stage_threat_ns": 488632837, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 72261, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 430184258, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 87120, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 36127, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 49401460, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 72254, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8959999, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 185, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 980, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5035.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6177.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 76, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21897, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 80, 81, 65, 129, 145, 95, 96, 128, 64, 48, 109, 108, 127, 114, 124, 82, 66, 63, 138, 152, 67, 68, 94, 79, 154, 139, 122, 47, 31, 98, 83, 143, 158, 130, 146, 131, 132, 93, 78, 106, 50, 92, 35, 20, 51, 19, 99 ], "move_count": 53, "black_stats": { "move_count": 27, "search_move_count": 25, "total_time_ms": 21797, "avg_search_time_ms": 871.88, "search_nodes": 574393, "safety_nodes": 1333, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 575726, "avg_nodes": 23029.04, "eval_calls": 558665, "avg_eval_calls": 22346.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 558665, "pattern_eval_ns": 11893172, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.288557543429427, "pattern_frame_queries": 558665, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11893172, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.288557543429427, "pattern_frame_updates": 1148640, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 13360198891, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11631.319552688397, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15680, "avg_candidate_generations": 627.2, "candidate_moves_total": 1465861, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.4860331632653, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 25, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2174, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 15655, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1463687, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 547151, "avg_legality_checks": 21886.04, "illegal_moves_skipped": 417, "root_legality_checks": 2174, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 544977, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 417, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4620958, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 184838.32, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10054238344, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2175.790895307856, "renju_forbidden_checks": 75586, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3023.44, "renju_forbidden_ns": 410734548, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5434.002963511762, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 640, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3173007, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 74946, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 407561541, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 380073, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10859.228571428572, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 47, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.88, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 189542, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4032.808510638298, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1224246655, "stage_ordering_ns": 539473, "stage_eval_ns": 13372092063, "stage_threat_ns": 7086032663, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1148665, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6175925917, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 66, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 522943, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 26330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 574320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 774921768, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1148640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 134662035, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1128, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 13712, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 2.88, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 2.88, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 23 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.04, "pooled_budget_moves": 25, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.04, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6542.16, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6862.16, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1787, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 75, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.125, "search_nodes": 223, "safety_nodes": 3183, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 3406, "avg_nodes": 141.91666666666666, "eval_calls": 199, "avg_eval_calls": 8.291666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 199, "line_shape_eval_ns": 306542, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1540.4120603015076, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2109, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.875, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2109, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27281, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1136.7083333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 55499637, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2034.3695978886406, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12880, "stage_ordering_ns": 1140, "stage_eval_ns": 306542, "stage_threat_ns": 45767597, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 422, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 44762773, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 648432, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 26391, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 199, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 304392, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 398, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52000, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 24 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7165.291666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7498.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 77, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1517, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 67, 52, 83, 99, 85, 84, 68, 54, 114, 39, 98, 69 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.857142857142857, "search_nodes": 274, "safety_nodes": 234, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 508, "avg_nodes": 72.57142857142857, "eval_calls": 267, "avg_eval_calls": 38.142857142857146, "line_shape_eval_calls": 267, "line_shape_eval_ns": 206990, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 775.2434456928839, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 385, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.0, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 385, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 385, "avg_legality_checks": 55.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 385, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17988658, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2152.0107668381384, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.2857142857142856, "renju_forbidden_ns": 183492, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11468.25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34030, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 149462, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 193931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12928.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 112160, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4876.521739130435, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1058665, "stage_ordering_ns": 300, "stage_eval_ns": 206990, "stage_threat_ns": 16787150, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 541, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16049788, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 279631, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 386061, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 71670, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1483, "avg_search_time_ms": 211.85714285714286, "search_nodes": 42066, "safety_nodes": 313, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 42379, "avg_nodes": 6054.142857142857, "eval_calls": 40768, "avg_eval_calls": 5824.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40768, "pattern_eval_ns": 861395, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.129194466248038, "pattern_frame_queries": 40768, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 861395, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.129194466248038, "pattern_frame_updates": 84094, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 897638406, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10674.226532213952, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1286, "avg_candidate_generations": 183.71428571428572, "candidate_moves_total": 87334, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.9113530326594, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 393, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 1279, "search_candidate_moves_total": 86941, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 2791, "avg_legality_checks": 398.7142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2791, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 232513, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 33216.142857142855, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 540815044, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2325.95615729013, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7653, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1093.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 73907637, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9657.341826734613, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 141881, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7620, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73523444, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 242312, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7304200, "stage_ordering_ns": 52290, "stage_eval_ns": 898499801, "stage_threat_ns": 565757359, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 84101, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 496390044, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 84221, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42047, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 57478024, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 84094, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11805070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 185, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1050, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4977.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6120.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 78, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21164, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 84, 99, 85, 141, 155, 83, 98, 126, 67, 52, 111, 142, 66, 114, 70, 56, 100, 55, 50, 34, 68, 69, 64, 65, 78, 41, 27, 53, 54, 36, 86, 38, 116, 132, 102, 118, 130, 115, 144, 158, 88 ], "move_count": 47, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 21075, "avg_search_time_ms": 957.9545454545455, "search_nodes": 595599, "safety_nodes": 752, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 596351, "avg_nodes": 27106.863636363636, "eval_calls": 580705, "avg_eval_calls": 26395.68181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 580705, "pattern_eval_ns": 12340855, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.251504636605507, "pattern_frame_queries": 580705, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 12340855, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.251504636605507, "pattern_frame_updates": 1191070, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 12854353970, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10792.274148454751, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14852, "avg_candidate_generations": 675.0909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 1446352, "avg_candidate_moves": 97.3843253433881, "candidate_moves_max": 136, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1864, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 14830, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1444488, "search_candidate_moves_max": 136, "legality_checks": 557321, "avg_legality_checks": 25332.772727272728, "illegal_moves_skipped": 567, "root_legality_checks": 1864, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 555457, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 566, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4608417, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 209473.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9921063584, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2152.8137718439975, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65237, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2965.318181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 311107778, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4768.885417784386, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 615, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3359161, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 64617, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 307742977, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5640, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.9545454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 209040, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9954.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.2272727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 94080, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3484.4444444444443, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1196620641, "stage_ordering_ns": 545544, "stage_eval_ns": 12866694825, "stage_threat_ns": 6863183987, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1191092, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5962762465, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 61, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 327021, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 22520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 595535, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 766260945, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1191070, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 133833556, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1278, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 12835, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 2.8636363636363638, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8636363636363638, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.045454545454545456, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13636363636363635, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.045454545454545456, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6654.954545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7018.590909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1858, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 65, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0952380952380953, "search_nodes": 183, "safety_nodes": 2442, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2625, "avg_nodes": 125.0, "eval_calls": 162, "avg_eval_calls": 7.714285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 162, "line_shape_eval_ns": 201460, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1243.5802469135801, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1788, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.14285714285714, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1788, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23974, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1141.6190476190477, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 48597524, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2027.0928505881373, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.19047619047619047, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5130, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1282.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5130, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10690, "stage_ordering_ns": 950, "stage_eval_ns": 201460, "stage_threat_ns": 39620754, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 345, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 38889601, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 54, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 445201, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 22940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 162, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 243761, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 324, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42191, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 21, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 21, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7046.047619047619, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7427.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 79, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6495, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 109, 108, 125, 141, 99, 155, 169, 139, 126, 123, 107, 138, 93, 140, 142, 137 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 34, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7777777777777777, "search_nodes": 232, "safety_nodes": 551, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 783, "avg_nodes": 87.0, "eval_calls": 223, "avg_eval_calls": 24.77777777777778, "line_shape_eval_calls": 223, "line_shape_eval_ns": 165890, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 743.9013452914799, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 564, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.666666666666664, "candidate_moves_max": 78, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 564, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 564, "avg_legality_checks": 62.666666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 564, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10946, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1216.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23579869, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2154.199616298191, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.7777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 323202, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12928.08, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 39, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 183931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4716.179487179487, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1460916, "stage_ordering_ns": 340, "stage_eval_ns": 165890, "stage_threat_ns": 20124975, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 455, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19284720, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 462773, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9730, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 223, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 318032, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 446, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59450, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5773.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6453, "avg_search_time_ms": 717.0, "search_nodes": 209980, "safety_nodes": 204, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 210184, "avg_nodes": 23353.777777777777, "eval_calls": 205620, "avg_eval_calls": 22846.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 205620, "pattern_eval_ns": 4312909, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.97514346853419, "pattern_frame_queries": 205620, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4312909, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.97514346853419, "pattern_frame_updates": 419910, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3733898828, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8892.14076349694, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4344, "avg_candidate_generations": 482.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 332756, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.6012891344383, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 586, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 4335, "search_candidate_moves_total": 332170, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 8093, "avg_legality_checks": 899.2222222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8093, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 944126, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 104902.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2126037858, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2251.858182064682, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8918, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 990.8888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 83512345, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9364.470172684458, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8918, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 83512345, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22275353, "stage_ordering_ns": 150371, "stage_eval_ns": 3738211737, "stage_threat_ns": 2679520228, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 419919, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2343857371, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 62280, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 209955, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 284304519, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 419910, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51296058, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 396, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3701, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4746.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5635.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 80, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6288, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 126, 141, 99, 155, 169, 109, 98, 140, 142, 94, 100, 97, 114, 95, 93, 156, 84, 70, 129, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6238, "avg_search_time_ms": 519.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 154656, "safety_nodes": 312, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 154968, "avg_nodes": 12914.0, "eval_calls": 149577, "avg_eval_calls": 12464.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 149577, "pattern_eval_ns": 3176171, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.23435421221177, "pattern_frame_queries": 149577, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3176171, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.23435421221177, "pattern_frame_updates": 309244, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3768264172, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12185.407548731746, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5057, "avg_candidate_generations": 421.4166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 379614, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.06703579197152, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 795, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 5045, "search_candidate_moves_total": 378819, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 145188, "avg_legality_checks": 12099.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 795, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 144393, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1110664, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 92555.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2664815969, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2399.2998503597846, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15085, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1257.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 115443171, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7652.845276764999, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 51, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 371852, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15034, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 115071319, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.8333333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 118071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11807.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.1666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 59571, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4255.071428571428, "stage_move_gen_ns": 366526715, "stage_ordering_ns": 170193, "stage_eval_ns": 3771440343, "stage_threat_ns": 2084055552, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 309256, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1824596114, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 175221, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12060, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 154622, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 219842238, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 309244, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39441979, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 535, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4320, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5821.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6488.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1790, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.272727272727273, "search_nodes": 197, "safety_nodes": 955, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1152, "avg_nodes": 104.72727272727273, "eval_calls": 186, "avg_eval_calls": 16.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 186, "line_shape_eval_ns": 152751, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 821.241935483871, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 734, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.72727272727273, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12753, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.3636363636363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26436883, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2072.9932564886694, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4571, "stage_ordering_ns": 490, "stage_eval_ns": 152751, "stage_threat_ns": 22876466, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 383, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22276363, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 277462, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 186, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 272431, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50210, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 81, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1170, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 115, 116, 99, 83, 69, 84, 100, 82, 81, 86, 129, 85 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.857142857142857, "search_nodes": 271, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 502, "avg_nodes": 71.71428571428571, "eval_calls": 264, "avg_eval_calls": 37.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 264, "line_shape_eval_ns": 200521, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 759.5492424242424, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 380, "avg_candidate_moves": 54.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 64, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 380, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 380, "avg_legality_checks": 54.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 380, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17969085, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2148.641037905058, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 130340, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10861.666666666666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24600, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 105740, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 188120, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12541.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 106570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4633.478260869565, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1028525, "stage_ordering_ns": 250, "stage_eval_ns": 200521, "stage_threat_ns": 16795628, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 535, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16051128, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 298770, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 375590, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 70140, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1135, "avg_search_time_ms": 162.14285714285714, "search_nodes": 33739, "safety_nodes": 311, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34050, "avg_nodes": 4864.285714285715, "eval_calls": 32575, "avg_eval_calls": 4653.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32575, "pattern_eval_ns": 690554, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.198894858019955, "pattern_frame_queries": 32575, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 690554, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.198894858019955, "pattern_frame_updates": 67440, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 661274339, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9805.372760972716, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1152, "avg_candidate_generations": 164.57142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 77460, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.23958333333333, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 390, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 1145, "search_candidate_moves_total": 77070, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 3151, "avg_legality_checks": 450.14285714285717, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3151, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 169328, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24189.714285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 386503709, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2282.5741106019086, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4855, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 693.5714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 48826644, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10056.981256436664, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 120240, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4822, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 48487623, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 218781, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8419946, "stage_ordering_ns": 42190, "stage_eval_ns": 661964893, "stage_threat_ns": 454065964, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 67447, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 399644907, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 86940, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 33720, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 45783007, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 67440, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8551110, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 184, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 925, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5045.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6187.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 82, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24160, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 84, 83, 69, 125, 139, 99, 98, 126, 70, 56, 115, 116, 127, 110, 130, 82, 68, 71, 146, 162, 67, 66, 100, 85, 160, 145, 132, 57, 43, 96, 81, 141, 156, 124, 138, 123, 122, 101, 86, 118, 54, 102, 39, 24, 53, 25, 95 ], "move_count": 53, "black_stats": { "move_count": 27, "search_move_count": 25, "total_time_ms": 24060, "avg_search_time_ms": 962.4, "search_nodes": 633252, "safety_nodes": 1333, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 634585, "avg_nodes": 25383.4, "eval_calls": 616708, "avg_eval_calls": 24668.32, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 616708, "pattern_eval_ns": 13115850, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.267520447278127, "pattern_frame_queries": 616708, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 13115850, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.267520447278127, "pattern_frame_updates": 1266358, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 14740807444, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11640.31612229717, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16496, "avg_candidate_generations": 659.84, "candidate_moves_total": 1531490, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.8400824442289, "candidate_moves_max": 134, "root_candidate_generations": 25, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2174, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 16471, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1529316, "search_candidate_moves_max": 134, "legality_checks": 604517, "avg_legality_checks": 24180.68, "illegal_moves_skipped": 459, "root_legality_checks": 2174, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 602343, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 459, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5015680, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 200627.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10985079713, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2190.1476396022076, "renju_forbidden_checks": 82962, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3318.48, "renju_forbidden_ns": 465649890, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5612.809358501482, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 764, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3902699, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 82198, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 461747191, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 373012, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10657.485714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 47, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.88, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 186352, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3964.936170212766, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1382990529, "stage_ordering_ns": 544762, "stage_eval_ns": 14753923294, "stage_threat_ns": 7818361138, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1266383, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6818937950, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 66, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 515302, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 25800, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 633179, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 846488053, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1266358, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 152419833, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1111, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 14432, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 2.88, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 2.88, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 23 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.04, "pooled_budget_moves": 25, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.04, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6235.96, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6555.96, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1787, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 74, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0833333333333335, "search_nodes": 223, "safety_nodes": 3183, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 3406, "avg_nodes": 141.91666666666666, "eval_calls": 199, "avg_eval_calls": 8.291666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 199, "line_shape_eval_ns": 318793, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1601.9748743718592, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2109, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.875, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2109, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27281, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1136.7083333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 54159560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1985.2483413364612, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12510, "stage_ordering_ns": 1060, "stage_eval_ns": 318793, "stage_threat_ns": 45027156, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 422, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 44029572, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 650062, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 25950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 199, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 294842, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 398, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52680, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 24 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7165.291666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7498.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 83, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4156, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 157, 172, 143, 129, 81, 144, 158, 114, 99, 174, 96, 159 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 24, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4285714285714284, "search_nodes": 275, "safety_nodes": 235, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 510, "avg_nodes": 72.85714285714286, "eval_calls": 268, "avg_eval_calls": 38.285714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 268, "line_shape_eval_ns": 172641, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 644.1828358208955, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 386, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.142857142857146, "candidate_moves_max": 66, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 386, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 386, "avg_legality_checks": 55.142857142857146, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 386, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8381, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1197.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15756083, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1879.976494451736, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65860, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5488.333333333333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10010, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55850, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 151230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10082.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 86970, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3781.304347826087, "stage_move_gen_ns": 895514, "stage_ordering_ns": 250, "stage_eval_ns": 172641, "stage_threat_ns": 14785541, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 543, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14138249, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 233051, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6470, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 268, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 349381, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 536, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64860, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 4126, "avg_search_time_ms": 589.4285714285714, "search_nodes": 172362, "safety_nodes": 191, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 172553, "avg_nodes": 24650.428571428572, "eval_calls": 168377, "avg_eval_calls": 24053.85714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 168377, "pattern_eval_ns": 3343546, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.85749835191267, "pattern_frame_queries": 168377, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3343546, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.85749835191267, "pattern_frame_updates": 344686, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2342076461, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6794.81168657851, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3973, "avg_candidate_generations": 567.5714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 289481, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.86206896551724, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 396, "root_candidate_moves_max": 65, "search_candidate_generations": 3966, "search_candidate_moves_total": 289085, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 8508, "avg_legality_checks": 1215.4285714285713, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8508, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 683610, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 97658.57142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1222564038, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1788.3940229077982, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7978, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1139.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57501833, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7207.549887189772, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 68991, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7955, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57322162, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 110680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20456880, "stage_ordering_ns": 131620, "stage_eval_ns": 2345420007, "stage_threat_ns": 1728540001, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 344693, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1508627388, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 59110, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6120, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 172343, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184992180, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 344686, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34861323, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 246, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3520, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4324.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5466.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 84, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5306, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 129, 81, 145, 161, 157, 96, 144, 114, 156, 66, 111, 82, 141, 171, 130, 80, 64, 83, 79, 84 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5265, "avg_search_time_ms": 438.75, "search_nodes": 169598, "safety_nodes": 312, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 169910, "avg_nodes": 14159.166666666666, "eval_calls": 164518, "avg_eval_calls": 13709.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 164518, "pattern_eval_ns": 3301849, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.069834303845173, "pattern_frame_queries": 164518, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3301849, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.069834303845173, "pattern_frame_updates": 339128, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3179304925, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9374.940804062184, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5058, "avg_candidate_generations": 421.5, "candidate_moves_total": 362409, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.65065243179122, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 795, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 5046, "search_candidate_moves_total": 361614, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 159080, "avg_legality_checks": 13256.666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 39, "root_legality_checks": 795, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 158285, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 39, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1142793, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 95232.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2144390375, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1876.4468937069093, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12965, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1080.4166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 83060622, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6406.526957192441, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 282033, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12917, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 82778589, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.8333333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 121841, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12184.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.1666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 61211, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4372.214285714285, "stage_move_gen_ns": 312355801, "stage_ordering_ns": 166150, "stage_eval_ns": 3182606774, "stage_threat_ns": 1729869991, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 339140, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1509795662, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 176041, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 169564, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 185963800, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 339128, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33934488, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 535, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4348, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5574.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6240.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1526, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 30, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.727272727272727, "search_nodes": 197, "safety_nodes": 955, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1152, "avg_nodes": 104.72727272727273, "eval_calls": 186, "avg_eval_calls": 16.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 186, "line_shape_eval_ns": 122241, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 657.2096774193549, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 734, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.72727272727273, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12753, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.3636363636363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21566620, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1691.1017015604173, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4190, "stage_ordering_ns": 480, "stage_eval_ns": 122241, "stage_threat_ns": 18556650, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 383, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18055818, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 215690, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 186, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 243101, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42041, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6179.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 85, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1386, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 67, 52, 81, 95, 79, 80, 66, 50, 110, 35, 96, 65 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 274, "safety_nodes": 234, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 508, "avg_nodes": 72.57142857142857, "eval_calls": 267, "avg_eval_calls": 38.142857142857146, "line_shape_eval_calls": 267, "line_shape_eval_ns": 184151, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 689.7041198501872, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 385, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.0, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 385, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 385, "avg_legality_checks": 55.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 385, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18003609, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2153.799377916019, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.2857142857142856, "renju_forbidden_ns": 181762, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11360.125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33911, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 147851, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 190550, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12703.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 109830, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4775.217391304348, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1055185, "stage_ordering_ns": 281, "stage_eval_ns": 184151, "stage_threat_ns": 16612648, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 541, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15909918, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 278160, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 358280, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66290, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1353, "avg_search_time_ms": 193.28571428571428, "search_nodes": 41537, "safety_nodes": 313, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 41850, "avg_nodes": 5978.571428571428, "eval_calls": 40239, "avg_eval_calls": 5748.428571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40239, "pattern_eval_ns": 853697, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.215661422997588, "pattern_frame_queries": 40239, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 853697, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.215661422997588, "pattern_frame_updates": 83036, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 802838530, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9668.559781299677, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1286, "avg_candidate_generations": 183.71428571428572, "candidate_moves_total": 87198, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.80559875583204, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 393, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 1279, "search_candidate_moves_total": 86805, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 2827, "avg_legality_checks": 403.85714285714283, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2827, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 224313, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32044.714285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 480188975, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2140.709521962615, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7782, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1111.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62949583, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8089.126574145464, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 141360, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7747, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62597232, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 210991, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7168842, "stage_ordering_ns": 47420, "stage_eval_ns": 803692227, "stage_threat_ns": 525219365, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 83043, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 464033034, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 82221, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 41518, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 51121737, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 83036, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9982373, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 185, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1051, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4982.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6124.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 86, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19578, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 80, 95, 79, 143, 159, 81, 96, 128, 64, 48, 67, 52, 113, 142, 68, 110, 94, 49, 54, 40, 66, 65, 70, 69, 86, 33, 17, 51, 50, 38, 78, 36, 108, 122, 92, 106, 124, 109, 140, 156, 76 ], "move_count": 47, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 19503, "avg_search_time_ms": 886.5, "search_nodes": 579733, "safety_nodes": 921, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 580654, "avg_nodes": 26393.363636363636, "eval_calls": 565066, "avg_eval_calls": 25684.81818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 565066, "pattern_eval_ns": 11547840, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.436267621835327, "pattern_frame_queries": 565066, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11547840, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.436267621835327, "pattern_frame_updates": 1159338, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 11956203611, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10312.957576651503, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14625, "avg_candidate_generations": 664.7727272727273, "candidate_moves_total": 1428663, "avg_candidate_moves": 97.68635897435898, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1886, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 14603, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1426777, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 545532, "avg_legality_checks": 24796.909090909092, "illegal_moves_skipped": 456, "root_legality_checks": 1886, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 543646, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 455, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4582105, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 208277.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9270886298, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2023.2810679807642, "renju_forbidden_checks": 63620, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2891.818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 287889445, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4525.140600440113, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 680, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1468452, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 62935, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 286415913, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5080, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.5909090909090908, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 228881, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6539.457142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 47, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.1363636363636362, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 120061, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2554.4893617021276, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1078575740, "stage_ordering_ns": 499415, "stage_eval_ns": 11967751451, "stage_threat_ns": 6311557391, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1159360, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5480040181, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 61, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 325522, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 579669, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 708446748, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1159338, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 122744940, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1218, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 12649, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 2.8636363636363638, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8636363636363638, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.045454545454545456, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13636363636363635, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.045454545454545456, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6694.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7057.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1905, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 57, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 192, "safety_nodes": 2464, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2656, "avg_nodes": 126.47619047619048, "eval_calls": 171, "avg_eval_calls": 8.142857142857142, "line_shape_eval_calls": 171, "line_shape_eval_ns": 155091, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 906.9649122807018, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1810, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.19047619047619, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1810, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23978, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1141.8095238095239, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 40245816, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1678.4475769455335, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.19047619047619047, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4510, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1127.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4510, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9880, "stage_ordering_ns": 880, "stage_eval_ns": 155091, "stage_threat_ns": 33119464, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 363, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 32516383, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 54, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 382701, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19530, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 171, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 189370, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 342, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31010, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 21, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 21, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7046.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7427.619047619048, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 87, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7028, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 126, 70, 56, 69, 110, 94, 125, 127, 170, 114, 156, 184, 158, 174, 155, 140, 157, 159, 154 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.6, "search_nodes": 189, "safety_nodes": 900, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1089, "avg_nodes": 108.9, "eval_calls": 179, "avg_eval_calls": 17.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 179, "line_shape_eval_ns": 105801, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 591.0670391061452, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 825, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.5, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 825, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 825, "avg_legality_checks": 82.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 825, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12806, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1280.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26740431, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2088.1173668592846, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 300562, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 13067.91304347826, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 157802, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4508.628571428571, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2071440, "stage_ordering_ns": 420, "stage_eval_ns": 105801, "stage_threat_ns": 21052861, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 368, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20362338, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 397912, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 179, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 245041, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 358, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47570, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6983, "avg_search_time_ms": 698.3, "search_nodes": 216424, "safety_nodes": 1073, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 217497, "avg_nodes": 21749.7, "eval_calls": 212554, "avg_eval_calls": 21255.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 212554, "pattern_eval_ns": 4303868, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.248351007273445, "pattern_frame_queries": 212554, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4303868, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.248351007273445, "pattern_frame_updates": 432792, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4205575967, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9717.314476700123, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3852, "avg_candidate_generations": 385.2, "candidate_moves_total": 358675, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.11396677050882, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 860, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 3842, "search_candidate_moves_total": 357815, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 7693, "avg_legality_checks": 769.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7693, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1160942, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 116094.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2667919267, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2298.0642159556637, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11515, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1151.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 105019305, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9120.217542336084, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11510, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 105013765, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5540, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19991433, "stage_ordering_ns": 123942, "stage_eval_ns": 4209879835, "stage_threat_ns": 2730822259, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 432802, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2391462194, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 179880, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 216396, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 287849257, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 432792, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51330928, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 263, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3470, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5412.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6212.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1964, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 88, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25003, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 84, 114, 140, 113, 111, 130, 82, 116, 115, 144, 158, 159, 129, 146, 162, 101, 131, 102, 88, 147, 143, 148, 145, 100, 99, 132, 164, 104, 103, 117, 87, 85, 83, 67, 157, 171, 141, 139, 173, 188, 125, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 48, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 24919, "avg_search_time_ms": 1132.6818181818182, "search_nodes": 735175, "safety_nodes": 406, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 735581, "avg_nodes": 33435.5, "eval_calls": 716535, "avg_eval_calls": 32569.772727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 716535, "pattern_eval_ns": 14498299, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.233902042468266, "pattern_frame_queries": 716535, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 14498299, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.233902042468266, "pattern_frame_updates": 1470220, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 14965606603, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10179.16135204255, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18597, "avg_candidate_generations": 845.3181818181819, "candidate_moves_total": 1586189, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.29273538742808, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1638, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 18575, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1584551, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 696018, "avg_legality_checks": 31637.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 189, "root_legality_checks": 1638, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 694380, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 188, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5177012, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 235318.72727272726, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10820762452, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2090.1559532796136, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46869, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2130.409090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 223575812, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4770.227911839382, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 216, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 798654, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 46648, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 222772088, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5070, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1529728066, "stage_ordering_ns": 635937, "stage_eval_ns": 14980104902, "stage_threat_ns": 8312308695, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1470242, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 7235222785, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 61, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 40881, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 21491, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 735110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 912440784, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1470220, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 164604245, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1227, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 16184, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 2.8636363636363638, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8636363636363638, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5356.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5720.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 64, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.909090909090909, "search_nodes": 145, "safety_nodes": 2481, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2626, "avg_nodes": 119.36363636363636, "eval_calls": 123, "avg_eval_calls": 5.590909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 123, "line_shape_eval_ns": 194391, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1580.4146341463415, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1671, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.95454545454545, "candidate_moves_max": 92, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1671, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24693, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1122.409090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 46222409, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1871.8830842748957, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.36363636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9020, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1127.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10590, "stage_ordering_ns": 940, "stage_eval_ns": 194391, "stage_threat_ns": 37507092, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 268, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 36806178, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 56, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 481972, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 22101, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 187112, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 246, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31830, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7089.409090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7453.045454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 89, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5258, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 144, 160, 97, 95, 65, 142, 158, 94, 78, 108, 66, 109, 111, 81, 123, 53, 107, 67 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 41, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.1, "search_nodes": 273, "safety_nodes": 823, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1096, "avg_nodes": 109.6, "eval_calls": 263, "avg_eval_calls": 26.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 263, "line_shape_eval_ns": 241452, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 918.0684410646388, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 713, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.3, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 713, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 713, "avg_legality_checks": 71.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 713, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12793, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1279.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27745196, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2168.779488782928, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 442764, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11966.594594594595, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 88262, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 354502, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 592572, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12882.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 71, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 339942, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4787.915492957746, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2006411, "stage_ordering_ns": 420, "stage_eval_ns": 241452, "stage_threat_ns": 23578262, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 536, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22297666, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 825433, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10740, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 263, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 385593, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69570, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5209, "avg_search_time_ms": 520.9, "search_nodes": 140989, "safety_nodes": 246, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 141235, "avg_nodes": 14123.5, "eval_calls": 137149, "avg_eval_calls": 13714.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 137149, "pattern_eval_ns": 2937906, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.42127175553595, "pattern_frame_queries": 137149, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2937906, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.42127175553595, "pattern_frame_updates": 281922, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3303809776, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11718.878895581047, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3822, "avg_candidate_generations": 382.2, "candidate_moves_total": 332543, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.00758765044479, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 741, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 3812, "search_candidate_moves_total": 331802, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 7101, "avg_legality_checks": 710.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 56, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7101, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 56, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 807617, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 80761.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1954436358, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2420.003984561989, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39872, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3987.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 378486361, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9492.535137439807, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 61, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 651073, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 39759, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 377232164, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 603124, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19857221, "stage_ordering_ns": 137942, "stage_eval_ns": 3306747682, "stage_threat_ns": 1859149221, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 281932, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1628356934, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 67130, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10020, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 140961, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 195709690, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 281922, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35015467, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 542, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3113, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5873.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6673.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 90, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18811, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 144, 160, 142, 95, 125, 65, 50, 79, 114, 100, 82, 94, 66, 98, 34, 18, 156, 170, 51, 78, 62, 77, 81, 76 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18750, "avg_search_time_ms": 1442.3076923076924, "search_nodes": 430883, "safety_nodes": 424, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 431307, "avg_nodes": 33177.46153846154, "eval_calls": 421215, "avg_eval_calls": 32401.153846153848, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 421215, "pattern_eval_ns": 9033856, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.44713744762176, "pattern_frame_queries": 421215, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 9033856, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.44713744762176, "pattern_frame_updates": 861690, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 12000121087, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13926.262445891214, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9643, "avg_candidate_generations": 741.7692307692307, "candidate_moves_total": 862673, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.46105983615058, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1063, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 9630, "search_candidate_moves_total": 861610, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 410673, "avg_legality_checks": 31590.23076923077, "illegal_moves_skipped": 345, "root_legality_checks": 1063, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 409610, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 344, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3544150, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 272626.92307692306, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8817917472, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2488.0203919134347, "renju_forbidden_checks": 72342, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5564.7692307692305, "renju_forbidden_ns": 638172743, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8821.607682950429, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 393, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3228197, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 71944, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 634894786, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 49760, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.7692307692307693, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 126181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12618.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.0769230769230769, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 68840, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4917.142857142857, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1012975575, "stage_ordering_ns": 363880, "stage_eval_ns": 12009154943, "stage_threat_ns": 5674115736, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 861703, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4967446866, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 188561, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14020, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 430845, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 599687413, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 861690, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 106792896, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 699, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8529, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3651.846153846154, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4215.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 45, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4615384615384617, "search_nodes": 330, "safety_nodes": 1134, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1464, "avg_nodes": 112.61538461538461, "eval_calls": 317, "avg_eval_calls": 24.384615384615383, "line_shape_eval_calls": 317, "line_shape_eval_ns": 309684, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 976.9211356466877, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1096, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1096, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1185.6923076923076, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 32886484, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2133.546386401972, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.6153846153846154, "renju_forbidden_ns": 87621, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10952.625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 87621, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6190, "stage_ordering_ns": 660, "stage_eval_ns": 309684, "stage_threat_ns": 29076926, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 647, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 28360372, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 173261, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13750, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 317, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 459343, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 634, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 83950, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6459.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7074.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 91, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1185, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 113, 83, 81, 110, 124, 69, 97, 54, 68, 39, 99, 24 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.875, "search_nodes": 247, "safety_nodes": 416, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 663, "avg_nodes": 82.875, "eval_calls": 239, "avg_eval_calls": 29.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 239, "line_shape_eval_ns": 169691, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 710.0041841004185, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 519, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.875, "candidate_moves_max": 79, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 519, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 519, "avg_legality_checks": 64.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 519, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9925, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1240.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21585573, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2174.868816120907, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 119820, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 13313.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 64150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4582.142857142857, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1390295, "stage_ordering_ns": 700, "stage_eval_ns": 169691, "stage_threat_ns": 18486571, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17860218, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 208641, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8530, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 354161, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63551, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1146, "avg_search_time_ms": 143.25, "search_nodes": 37614, "safety_nodes": 516, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 38130, "avg_nodes": 4766.25, "eval_calls": 36017, "avg_eval_calls": 4502.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36017, "pattern_eval_ns": 780301, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.664797179109865, "pattern_frame_queries": 36017, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 780301, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.664797179109865, "pattern_frame_updates": 75184, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 617124864, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8208.194083847628, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1583, "avg_candidate_generations": 197.875, "candidate_moves_total": 122805, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.57738471257107, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 531, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 1575, "search_candidate_moves_total": 122274, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 3462, "avg_legality_checks": 432.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3462, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 148300, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18537.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 364461420, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2457.595549561699, "renju_forbidden_checks": 271, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 33.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3141165, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11591.014760147602, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 266, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 3082695, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 58470, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9511555, "stage_ordering_ns": 61810, "stage_eval_ns": 617905165, "stage_threat_ns": 504114438, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 75192, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 443501039, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 165632, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8050, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37592, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 51123865, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 75184, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9323902, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 218, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1302, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5378.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6378.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 92, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19631, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 110, 83, 81, 85, 86, 69, 111, 109, 142, 94, 114, 113, 100, 128, 95, 80, 139, 138, 143, 141, 127, 79, 159 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 19571, "avg_search_time_ms": 1397.9285714285713, "search_nodes": 460397, "safety_nodes": 287, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 460684, "avg_nodes": 32906.0, "eval_calls": 450473, "avg_eval_calls": 32176.64285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 450473, "pattern_eval_ns": 9657233, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.437984074517228, "pattern_frame_queries": 450473, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 9657233, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.437984074517228, "pattern_frame_updates": 920714, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 12254691417, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13309.98705026751, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9898, "avg_candidate_generations": 707.0, "candidate_moves_total": 827881, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.64124065467772, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1046, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 9884, "search_candidate_moves_total": 826835, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 446067, "avg_legality_checks": 31861.928571428572, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1760, "root_legality_checks": 1046, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 445021, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1757, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3419721, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 244265.7857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8553380262, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2501.19242534698, "renju_forbidden_checks": 99818, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7129.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 959327803, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9610.769630727926, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1914, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18434536, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 97889, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 940711736, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 181531, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.7142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 124071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12407.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 66500, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4750.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1155465821, "stage_ordering_ns": 413555, "stage_eval_ns": 12264348650, "stage_threat_ns": 6128411685, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 920728, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5347022224, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 189011, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14220, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 460357, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 666429447, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 920714, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 114771003, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 816, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8682, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3862.9285714285716, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4434.357142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 42, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.230769230769231, "search_nodes": 243, "safety_nodes": 1128, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1371, "avg_nodes": 105.46153846153847, "eval_calls": 230, "avg_eval_calls": 17.692307692307693, "line_shape_eval_calls": 230, "line_shape_eval_ns": 210431, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 914.9173913043478, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 979, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 979, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15354, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1181.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 32267411, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2101.5638270157615, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.9230769230769231, "renju_forbidden_ns": 151901, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12658.416666666666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 151901, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6040, "stage_ordering_ns": 680, "stage_eval_ns": 210431, "stage_threat_ns": 27550971, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 473, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 26923256, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 223512, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 342543, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61660, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6459.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7074.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 93, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6865, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 128, 64, 48, 65, 113, 83, 142, 100, 141, 79, 143, 158, 144, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 34, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.25, "search_nodes": 264, "safety_nodes": 457, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 721, "avg_nodes": 90.125, "eval_calls": 256, "avg_eval_calls": 32.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 256, "line_shape_eval_ns": 185431, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 724.33984375, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 565, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.625, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 565, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 565, "avg_legality_checks": 70.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 565, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10041, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1255.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22016975, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2192.707399661388, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 18, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 214481, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11915.611111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 119521, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4596.961538461538, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1506207, "stage_ordering_ns": 420, "stage_eval_ns": 185431, "stage_threat_ns": 19325258, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 520, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18456034, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 303111, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 256, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 499043, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 512, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6825, "avg_search_time_ms": 853.125, "search_nodes": 202583, "safety_nodes": 251, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 202834, "avg_nodes": 25354.25, "eval_calls": 198758, "avg_eval_calls": 24844.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 198758, "pattern_eval_ns": 4270390, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.48537417361817, "pattern_frame_queries": 198758, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4270390, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.48537417361817, "pattern_frame_updates": 405122, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4115772008, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10159.339675455789, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3811, "avg_candidate_generations": 476.375, "candidate_moves_total": 330476, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.71634741537655, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 595, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 3803, "search_candidate_moves_total": 329881, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 6841, "avg_legality_checks": 855.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6841, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1092065, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 136508.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2559204025, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2343.453938181335, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17493, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2186.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 167974384, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9602.377179443205, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17493, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 167974384, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17383547, "stage_ordering_ns": 138851, "stage_eval_ns": 4120042398, "stage_threat_ns": 2670118029, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 405130, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2340410730, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 61141, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7920, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 202561, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 280030656, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 405122, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49615502, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 395, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3257, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4426.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5426.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 94, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12528, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 80, 82, 144, 97, 67, 68, 54, 124, 110, 127, 142, 126, 125, 95, 129, 159, 99, 84, 115, 111, 143, 141, 81, 156 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 12476, "avg_search_time_ms": 959.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 320939, "safety_nodes": 773, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 321712, "avg_nodes": 24747.076923076922, "eval_calls": 314046, "avg_eval_calls": 24157.384615384617, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 314046, "pattern_eval_ns": 6518266, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.755768263248058, "pattern_frame_queries": 314046, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6518266, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.755768263248058, "pattern_frame_updates": 641804, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7481418506, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11656.858645318509, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6869, "avg_candidate_generations": 528.3846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 535968, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.02707817731839, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 924, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 6856, "search_candidate_moves_total": 535044, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 305749, "avg_legality_checks": 23519.153846153848, "illegal_moves_skipped": 113, "root_legality_checks": 924, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 304825, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 112, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2137967, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 164459.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5236775040, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2449.4180873699174, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25301, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1946.2307692307693, "renju_forbidden_ns": 201357848, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7958.493656377218, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 121, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1044619, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25169, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 200251039, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 62190, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.769230769230769, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 316112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8780.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 44, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.3846153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 127590, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2899.7727272727275, "stage_move_gen_ns": 759896960, "stage_ordering_ns": 228921, "stage_eval_ns": 7487936772, "stage_threat_ns": 4197086001, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 641817, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3677115996, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 491842, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 320902, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 440862415, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 641804, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 78615748, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 408, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6151, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.6923076923076925, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6923076923076925, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4071.4615384615386, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4686.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 40, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3333333333333335, "search_nodes": 314, "safety_nodes": 732, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1046, "avg_nodes": 87.16666666666667, "eval_calls": 302, "avg_eval_calls": 25.166666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 302, "line_shape_eval_ns": 362052, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1198.8476821192053, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 859, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.58333333333333, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 859, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14022, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1168.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28426984, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2027.313079446584, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.3333333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43570, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10892.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 43570, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4990, "stage_ordering_ns": 610, "stage_eval_ns": 362052, "stage_threat_ns": 25275263, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 616, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24601492, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 171890, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 302, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 427430, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 604, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74451, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 95, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13558, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 128, 64, 48, 65, 114, 100, 127, 125, 110, 94, 174, 158, 129, 130, 144, 159, 141, 145, 99, 84, 113, 85, 155 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 41, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4166666666666665, "search_nodes": 193, "safety_nodes": 1114, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1307, "avg_nodes": 108.91666666666667, "eval_calls": 181, "avg_eval_calls": 15.083333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 181, "line_shape_eval_ns": 109630, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 605.6906077348066, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 966, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.5, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 966, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 966, "avg_legality_checks": 80.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 966, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15350, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1279.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31373145, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2043.8530944625406, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.9166666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 391401, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11182.885714285714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 76641, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 314760, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 489064, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11644.380952380952, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 274232, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4352.888888888889, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2471579, "stage_ordering_ns": 580, "stage_eval_ns": 109630, "stage_threat_ns": 24548053, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 374, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 23613708, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 634294, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12370, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 181, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 254061, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 362, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45990, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 13503, "avg_search_time_ms": 1125.25, "search_nodes": 382224, "safety_nodes": 624, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 382848, "avg_nodes": 31904.0, "eval_calls": 375273, "avg_eval_calls": 31272.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 375273, "pattern_eval_ns": 7538666, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.088484916314258, "pattern_frame_queries": 375273, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7538666, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.088484916314258, "pattern_frame_updates": 764380, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8693305335, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11373.015169156703, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6929, "avg_candidate_generations": 577.4166666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 655746, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.63789868667918, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 995, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 6917, "search_candidate_moves_total": 654751, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 14941, "avg_legality_checks": 1245.0833333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 88, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 14941, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 88, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2442552, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 203546.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5478388673, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2242.8954114385283, "renju_forbidden_checks": 85278, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7106.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 765942186, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8981.709069162034, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 88, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 933266, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 85145, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 764494717, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 514203, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 37040391, "stage_ordering_ns": 263841, "stage_eval_ns": 8700844001, "stage_threat_ns": 4727080346, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 764392, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4141206422, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 114021, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 382190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 497892846, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 764380, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 87867057, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 588, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5828, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5393.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6059.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1964, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 96, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8883, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 80, 110, 144, 111, 109, 68, 124, 113, 114, 97, 125, 98, 83, 95, 94, 99 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8849, "avg_search_time_ms": 983.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 220216, "safety_nodes": 347, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 220563, "avg_nodes": 24507.0, "eval_calls": 214691, "avg_eval_calls": 23854.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 214691, "pattern_eval_ns": 4316168, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.10409379061069, "pattern_frame_queries": 214691, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4316168, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.10409379061069, "pattern_frame_updates": 440382, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5468011713, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12416.519551207815, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5509, "avg_candidate_generations": 612.1111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 407439, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.9587946995825, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 578, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 5500, "search_candidate_moves_total": 406861, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 209770, "avg_legality_checks": 23307.777777777777, "illegal_moves_skipped": 56, "root_legality_checks": 578, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 209192, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 56, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1602393, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 178043.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3878951954, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2420.724475206769, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23503, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2611.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 155652490, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6622.66476620006, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 141, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 422895, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23356, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 155220955, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8640, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 273291, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10121.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.777777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 132330, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3077.4418604651164, "stage_move_gen_ns": 518720906, "stage_ordering_ns": 204900, "stage_eval_ns": 5472327881, "stage_threat_ns": 2835464592, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 440391, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2487097794, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 376821, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8670, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 220191, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 294941514, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 440382, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53048463, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 373, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4806, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3006.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3894.8888888888887, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.25, "search_nodes": 147, "safety_nodes": 562, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 709, "avg_nodes": 88.625, "eval_calls": 139, "avg_eval_calls": 17.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 139, "line_shape_eval_ns": 122021, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 877.8489208633093, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 519, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.875, "candidate_moves_max": 73, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 519, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9385, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1173.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18880204, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2011.7425679275439, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3060, "stage_ordering_ns": 400, "stage_eval_ns": 122021, "stage_threat_ns": 15964680, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 286, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15596709, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 132680, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8370, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 139, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 200051, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 278, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35240, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 97, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3387, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 111, 81, 79, 114, 130, 66, 50, 52, 94, 67, 97, 95, 53, 123, 37, 109 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.8, "search_nodes": 273, "safety_nodes": 823, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1096, "avg_nodes": 109.6, "eval_calls": 263, "avg_eval_calls": 26.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 263, "line_shape_eval_ns": 235070, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 893.8022813688212, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 713, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.3, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 713, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 713, "avg_legality_checks": 71.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 713, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12793, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1279.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26033936, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2035.0141483623856, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 409080, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11056.216216216217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 76160, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 332920, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 590682, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12840.91304347826, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 71, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 326492, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4598.478873239436, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1861259, "stage_ordering_ns": 490, "stage_eval_ns": 235070, "stage_threat_ns": 22096274, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 536, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20853078, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 810063, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12970, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 263, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 365343, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67790, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 3339, "avg_search_time_ms": 333.9, "search_nodes": 107052, "safety_nodes": 246, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 107298, "avg_nodes": 10729.8, "eval_calls": 103312, "avg_eval_calls": 10331.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 103312, "pattern_eval_ns": 2080298, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.13607325383305, "pattern_frame_queries": 103312, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2080298, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.13607325383305, "pattern_frame_updates": 214048, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1990761428, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9300.537393481836, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3722, "avg_candidate_generations": 372.2, "candidate_moves_total": 322854, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.74207415368082, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 741, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 3712, "search_candidate_moves_total": 322113, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 8866, "avg_legality_checks": 886.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 30, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8866, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 30, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 503254, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 50325.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1156808260, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2298.656861147651, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18193, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1819.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 175061814, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9622.481943604684, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 31, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 333732, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18110, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 174152152, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 575930, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 21809802, "stage_ordering_ns": 143670, "stage_eval_ns": 1992841726, "stage_threat_ns": 1302076399, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 214058, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1139236093, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 63050, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9550, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 107024, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 138451296, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 214048, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24325960, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 542, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3040, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5906.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6706.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 98, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7870, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 111, 81, 83, 79, 78, 66, 114, 50, 34, 110, 125, 65, 95, 35, 20, 97, 113, 115, 126, 49, 33, 124, 156, 141, 142, 100, 170 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 7828, "avg_search_time_ms": 521.8666666666667, "search_nodes": 309591, "safety_nodes": 818, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 310409, "avg_nodes": 20693.933333333334, "eval_calls": 303067, "avg_eval_calls": 20204.466666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 303067, "pattern_eval_ns": 5560873, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.348658877409946, "pattern_frame_queries": 303067, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5560873, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.348658877409946, "pattern_frame_updates": 619096, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4776621679, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7715.478179474589, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6496, "avg_candidate_generations": 433.06666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 493283, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.93642241379311, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1057, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 6481, "search_candidate_moves_total": 492226, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 299076, "avg_legality_checks": 19938.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 766, "root_legality_checks": 1057, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 298019, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 763, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2290049, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 152669.93333333332, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3301317425, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1441.5924833922768, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28842, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1922.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 135746377, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4706.552146175716, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 777, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3305446, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28050, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 132360261, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 80670, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.6666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 157591, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6303.64, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 34, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.2666666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 82260, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2419.4117647058824, "stage_move_gen_ns": 463021811, "stage_ordering_ns": 199131, "stage_eval_ns": 4782182552, "stage_threat_ns": 2518322685, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 619111, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2183032037, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 238351, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9850, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 309548, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 284547909, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 619096, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50504388, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 436, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5837, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5837.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6370.933333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 669, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.0, "search_nodes": 208, "safety_nodes": 1393, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1601, "avg_nodes": 114.35714285714286, "eval_calls": 194, "avg_eval_calls": 13.857142857142858, "line_shape_eval_calls": 194, "line_shape_eval_ns": 114350, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 589.4329896907217, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 994, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.0, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 994, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15915, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1136.7857142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20742156, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1303.3085768143262, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.8571428571428571, "renju_forbidden_ns": 74080, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6173.333333333333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 74080, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5120, "stage_ordering_ns": 640, "stage_eval_ns": 114350, "stage_threat_ns": 17746049, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 402, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17314098, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 179271, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9620, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 194, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 213540, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 388, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39140, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6569.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7140.928571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 99, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5719, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 140, 154, 97, 99, 69, 142, 156, 100, 86, 116, 68, 115, 113, 83, 131, 51, 117, 67 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.8, "search_nodes": 273, "safety_nodes": 823, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1096, "avg_nodes": 109.6, "eval_calls": 263, "avg_eval_calls": 26.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 263, "line_shape_eval_ns": 226252, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 860.2737642585552, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 713, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.3, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 713, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 713, "avg_legality_checks": 71.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 713, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12793, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1279.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25944976, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2028.0603455014461, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 430600, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11637.837837837838, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 82330, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 348270, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 572703, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12450.065217391304, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 71, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 330452, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4654.2535211267605, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1876661, "stage_ordering_ns": 380, "stage_eval_ns": 226252, "stage_threat_ns": 21919411, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 536, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20702645, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 794675, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10220, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 263, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 357580, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64511, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5671, "avg_search_time_ms": 567.1, "search_nodes": 157345, "safety_nodes": 246, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 157591, "avg_nodes": 15759.1, "eval_calls": 153314, "avg_eval_calls": 15331.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 153314, "pattern_eval_ns": 3130808, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.420887851076873, "pattern_frame_queries": 153314, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3130808, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.420887851076873, "pattern_frame_updates": 314634, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3673183794, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11674.465550449093, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4013, "avg_candidate_generations": 401.3, "candidate_moves_total": 349990, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.21405432344879, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 741, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 4003, "search_candidate_moves_total": 349249, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 7827, "avg_legality_checks": 782.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 64, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7827, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 64, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 939774, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 93977.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2173004736, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2312.2630930415185, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48057, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4805.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 454559750, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9458.762511184636, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 71, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 743392, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 47934, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 453235153, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 581205, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20979109, "stage_ordering_ns": 140911, "stage_eval_ns": 3676314602, "stage_threat_ns": 1955035372, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 314644, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1711565998, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 63660, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10440, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 157317, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 206388502, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 314634, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37017212, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 542, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3267, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5869.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6669.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 100, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9907, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 96, 99, 129, 69, 54, 100, 86, 142, 156, 85, 70, 38, 68, 40, 110, 82, 111, 141, 109, 113, 108 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9859, "avg_search_time_ms": 821.5833333333334, "search_nodes": 252714, "safety_nodes": 447, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 253161, "avg_nodes": 21096.75, "eval_calls": 246512, "avg_eval_calls": 20542.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 246512, "pattern_eval_ns": 4977905, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.193357727007204, "pattern_frame_queries": 246512, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4977905, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.193357727007204, "pattern_frame_updates": 505360, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6082867893, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12036.702336947918, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6180, "avg_candidate_generations": 515.0, "candidate_moves_total": 485671, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.58754045307444, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 850, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 6168, "search_candidate_moves_total": 484821, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 238428, "avg_legality_checks": 19869.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 61, "root_legality_checks": 850, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 237578, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 61, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1876929, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 156410.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4476101396, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2384.8005950145157, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19796, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1649.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 126150321, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6372.515710244494, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 79, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 428194, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19717, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 125722127, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 12, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 114360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9530.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.1666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 47740, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3410.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 570954518, "stage_ordering_ns": 229270, "stage_eval_ns": 6087845798, "stage_threat_ns": 3147154371, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 505372, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2755841607, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 201981, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11740, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 252680, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 331628135, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 505360, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59482648, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 525, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5344, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5030.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5697.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 179, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4545454545454546, "search_nodes": 334, "safety_nodes": 673, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1007, "avg_nodes": 91.54545454545455, "eval_calls": 323, "avg_eval_calls": 29.363636363636363, "line_shape_eval_calls": 323, "line_shape_eval_ns": 270930, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 838.7925696594427, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 786, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.45454545454545, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12671, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1151.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25728922, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2030.536027148607, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4580, "stage_ordering_ns": 530, "stage_eval_ns": 270930, "stage_threat_ns": 23561969, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 657, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22896507, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 135730, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 323, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 447920, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 646, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 81812, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 101, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5920, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 126, 70, 56, 69, 111, 81, 142, 94, 143, 83, 141, 156, 140, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 29, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.625, "search_nodes": 264, "safety_nodes": 453, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 717, "avg_nodes": 89.625, "eval_calls": 256, "avg_eval_calls": 32.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 256, "line_shape_eval_ns": 177870, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 694.8046875, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 563, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.375, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 563, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 563, "avg_legality_checks": 70.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 563, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10031, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1253.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20741832, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2067.7731033795235, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 119240, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11924.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23980, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 95260, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 18, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 205881, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11437.833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 113910, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4381.153846153846, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1465784, "stage_ordering_ns": 340, "stage_eval_ns": 177870, "stage_threat_ns": 17977859, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 520, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17271115, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 292591, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8270, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 256, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 350483, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 512, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63670, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5882, "avg_search_time_ms": 735.25, "search_nodes": 183533, "safety_nodes": 579, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 184112, "avg_nodes": 23014.0, "eval_calls": 180058, "avg_eval_calls": 22507.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 180058, "pattern_eval_ns": 3668265, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.372685468015863, "pattern_frame_queries": 180058, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3668265, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.372685468015863, "pattern_frame_updates": 367022, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3568821912, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9723.727493174796, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3461, "avg_candidate_generations": 432.625, "candidate_moves_total": 298480, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.24097081768275, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 591, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 3453, "search_candidate_moves_total": 297889, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 6374, "avg_legality_checks": 796.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6374, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 950256, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 118782.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2138361067, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2250.2999896869896, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25730, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3216.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 242903972, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9440.496385542168, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 232892, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25694, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 242493399, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 177681, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16482015, "stage_ordering_ns": 116900, "stage_eval_ns": 3572490177, "stage_threat_ns": 2268394313, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 367030, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1990355548, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 109220, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 183511, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 235287306, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 367022, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42642239, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 241, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3066, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4746.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5746.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 102, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12688, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 84, 82, 140, 97, 67, 66, 50, 127, 142, 130, 114, 128, 129, 99, 125, 155, 95, 80, 109, 113, 141, 143, 83, 158 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 12634, "avg_search_time_ms": 971.8461538461538, "search_nodes": 332690, "safety_nodes": 773, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 333463, "avg_nodes": 25651.0, "eval_calls": 325550, "avg_eval_calls": 25042.30769230769, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 325550, "pattern_eval_ns": 6640248, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.397014283520196, "pattern_frame_queries": 325550, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6640248, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.397014283520196, "pattern_frame_updates": 665306, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7564403526, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11369.811073400811, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7116, "avg_candidate_generations": 547.3846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 548391, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.06450252951096, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 916, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 7103, "search_candidate_moves_total": 547475, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 316872, "avg_legality_checks": 24374.76923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 120, "root_legality_checks": 916, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 315956, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 119, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2192542, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 168657.07692307694, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5257698637, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2397.9922104114767, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27444, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2111.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 215134843, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7839.048353009765, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 124, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1106840, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27309, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 213962753, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 65250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.769230769230769, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 324892, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9024.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 44, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.3846153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 135032, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3068.909090909091, "stage_move_gen_ns": 768922512, "stage_ordering_ns": 237971, "stage_eval_ns": 7571043774, "stage_threat_ns": 4265513357, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 665319, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3736550909, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 502072, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 332653, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 449037403, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 665306, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 79422973, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 404, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6389, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.6923076923076925, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6923076923076925, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4055.769230769231, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4671.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 40, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3333333333333335, "search_nodes": 314, "safety_nodes": 724, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1038, "avg_nodes": 86.5, "eval_calls": 302, "avg_eval_calls": 25.166666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 302, "line_shape_eval_ns": 364373, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1206.5331125827815, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 851, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.91666666666667, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 851, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13998, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1166.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28047956, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2003.7116730961566, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.3333333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 45580, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11395.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 45580, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5320, "stage_ordering_ns": 570, "stage_eval_ns": 364373, "stage_threat_ns": 25018387, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 616, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24361334, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 157941, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12821, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 302, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 421912, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 604, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 77200, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 103, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5845, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 97, 82, 142, 157, 113, 114, 66, 96, 68, 146, 130, 124, 138, 141, 128, 126, 129, 131, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4545454545454546, "search_nodes": 271, "safety_nodes": 857, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1128, "avg_nodes": 102.54545454545455, "eval_calls": 260, "avg_eval_calls": 23.636363636363637, "line_shape_eval_calls": 260, "line_shape_eval_ns": 207910, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 799.6538461538462, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 808, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.45454545454545, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 808, "avg_legality_checks": 73.45454545454545, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 808, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13870, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1260.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28313905, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2041.3774333093006, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.909090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 362731, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11335.34375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 70280, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 292451, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.3636363636363638, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 298261, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11471.576923076924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.6363636363636362, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 155441, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3886.025, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2085390, "stage_ordering_ns": 450, "stage_eval_ns": 207910, "stage_threat_ns": 23395890, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 531, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22533845, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 430974, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10831, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 366021, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 520, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65050, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5795, "avg_search_time_ms": 579.5, "search_nodes": 172283, "safety_nodes": 501, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 172784, "avg_nodes": 17278.4, "eval_calls": 167944, "avg_eval_calls": 16794.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 167944, "pattern_eval_ns": 3405616, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.278283237269566, "pattern_frame_queries": 167944, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3405616, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.278283237269566, "pattern_frame_updates": 344508, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3552731299, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10312.47837205522, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4320, "avg_candidate_generations": 432.0, "candidate_moves_total": 379187, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.77476851851851, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 736, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4310, "search_candidate_moves_total": 378451, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 10759, "avg_legality_checks": 1075.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 250, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10759, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 250, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 805736, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 80573.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1907645623, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2367.5814696128755, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47578, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4757.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 470461191, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9888.208646853587, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 250, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2684348, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 47298, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 467415173, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 361670, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 30777253, "stage_ordering_ns": 151963, "stage_eval_ns": 3556136915, "stage_threat_ns": 2183784043, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 344518, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1916415354, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 92410, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 172254, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 226909441, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 344508, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40366838, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 337, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3818, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5652.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6452.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 104, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5084, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 157, 128, 80, 129, 126, 114, 156, 144, 160, 159, 99, 174 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5059, "avg_search_time_ms": 632.375, "search_nodes": 135949, "safety_nodes": 69, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 136018, "avg_nodes": 17002.25, "eval_calls": 132543, "avg_eval_calls": 16567.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 132543, "pattern_eval_ns": 2655931, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.038259281893424, "pattern_frame_queries": 132543, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2655931, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.038259281893424, "pattern_frame_updates": 271854, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3058652071, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11251.083563236149, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3392, "avg_candidate_generations": 424.0, "candidate_moves_total": 225112, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.36556603773585, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 474, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 3384, "search_candidate_moves_total": 224638, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 129608, "avg_legality_checks": 16201.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "root_legality_checks": 474, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 129134, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 59, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 890664, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 111333.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2044091099, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2295.0193327674633, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13473, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1684.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 112600228, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8357.472574779187, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 71, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 434511, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13397, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 112139627, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 26090, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 309533211, "stage_ordering_ns": 111131, "stage_eval_ns": 3061308002, "stage_threat_ns": 1673401803, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 271862, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1469329284, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 13070, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 135927, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 172348293, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 271854, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31711156, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 404, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2795, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3650.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4650.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 658, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 19, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 585, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 652, "avg_nodes": 93.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 60, "avg_eval_calls": 8.571428571428571, "line_shape_eval_calls": 60, "line_shape_eval_ns": 38560, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 642.6666666666666, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 413, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.0, "candidate_moves_max": 70, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 413, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8168, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1166.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13543107, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1658.0689275220373, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 24450, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6112.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 24450, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2590, "stage_ordering_ns": 340, "stage_eval_ns": 38560, "stage_threat_ns": 11182113, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 127, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 10899741, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 181051, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6030, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 60, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 85931, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15390, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5138.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6281.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 105, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6740, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 143, 98, 173, 158, 141, 96, 99, 97, 94, 127, 142, 79, 63, 144, 139, 93, 140 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 37, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3636363636363638, "search_nodes": 332, "safety_nodes": 770, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1102, "avg_nodes": 100.18181818181819, "eval_calls": 321, "avg_eval_calls": 29.181818181818183, "line_shape_eval_calls": 321, "line_shape_eval_ns": 269721, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 840.2523364485982, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 748, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.0, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 748, "avg_legality_checks": 68.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 748, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13744, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24340177, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1770.967476717113, "renju_forbidden_checks": 91, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8.272727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 992078, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10901.956043956045, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 183401, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 808677, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 761522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11715.723076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 94, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.545454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 423001, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4500.010638297872, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1873658, "stage_ordering_ns": 520, "stage_eval_ns": 269721, "stage_threat_ns": 21555269, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 653, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20147594, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 951494, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9730, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 321, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 388301, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 642, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67880, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6180.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6907.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6693, "avg_search_time_ms": 608.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 203591, "safety_nodes": 525, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 204116, "avg_nodes": 18556.0, "eval_calls": 199273, "avg_eval_calls": 18115.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 199273, "pattern_eval_ns": 4028465, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.21580946741405, "pattern_frame_queries": 199273, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4028465, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.21580946741405, "pattern_frame_updates": 407120, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4431655121, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10885.378072804087, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4298, "avg_candidate_generations": 390.72727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 325979, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.8443462075384, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 756, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 4287, "search_candidate_moves_total": 325223, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 9513, "avg_legality_checks": 864.8181818181819, "illegal_moves_skipped": 79, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9513, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 79, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1365692, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 124153.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2679532751, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1962.0329847432656, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58607, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5327.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 472878664, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8068.6379442728685, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 79, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 874587, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 58418, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 470782814, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 110, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1221263, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23316082, "stage_ordering_ns": 152441, "stage_eval_ns": 4435683586, "stage_threat_ns": 2206452864, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 407131, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1924522395, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 68560, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9130, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 203560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 239555390, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 407120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42306519, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 341, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3688, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5407.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6135.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1963, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 106, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4632, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 109, 126, 84, 141, 96, 142, 94, 140, 154, 139, 138, 143 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 4601, "avg_search_time_ms": 575.125, "search_nodes": 112845, "safety_nodes": 73, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 112918, "avg_nodes": 14114.75, "eval_calls": 109621, "avg_eval_calls": 13702.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 109621, "pattern_eval_ns": 2353161, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.46633400534569, "pattern_frame_queries": 109621, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2353161, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.46633400534569, "pattern_frame_updates": 225646, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2759160096, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12227.82631201085, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3210, "avg_candidate_generations": 401.25, "candidate_moves_total": 213506, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.51277258566978, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 478, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 3202, "search_candidate_moves_total": 213028, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 106331, "avg_legality_checks": 13291.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 117, "root_legality_checks": 478, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 105853, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 116, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 733369, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 91671.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1878613874, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2561.621603858358, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12689, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1586.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 121464901, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9572.456537158168, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 128, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1138805, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12556, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 120270096, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 56000, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 281857130, "stage_ordering_ns": 125880, "stage_eval_ns": 2761513257, "stage_threat_ns": 1545321161, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 225654, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1357427153, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 15690, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 112823, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159324250, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 225646, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28554068, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 404, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2644, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4182.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5182.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1618, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 22, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.142857142857143, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 585, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 652, "avg_nodes": 93.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 60, "avg_eval_calls": 8.571428571428571, "line_shape_eval_calls": 60, "line_shape_eval_ns": 42700, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 711.6666666666666, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 413, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.0, "candidate_moves_max": 70, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 413, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8168, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1166.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17446178, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2135.917972575906, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46230, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11557.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 46230, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2820, "stage_ordering_ns": 380, "stage_eval_ns": 42700, "stage_threat_ns": 14091255, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 127, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 13771535, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 211210, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7720, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 60, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92050, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16460, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5138.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6281.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 107, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6315, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 125, 128, 123, 124, 95, 66, 110, 140, 65, 139, 80 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.875, "search_nodes": 307, "safety_nodes": 330, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 637, "avg_nodes": 79.625, "eval_calls": 299, "avg_eval_calls": 37.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 299, "line_shape_eval_ns": 218040, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 729.2307692307693, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 505, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.125, "candidate_moves_max": 76, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 505, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 505, "avg_legality_checks": 63.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 505, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9831, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1228.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20159665, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2050.6220120028484, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 443853, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10322.162790697674, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 79041, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 364812, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 341772, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12658.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 195342, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4883.55, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1349397, "stage_ordering_ns": 380, "stage_eval_ns": 218040, "stage_threat_ns": 18363075, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 606, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17423640, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 467813, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8240, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 299, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 400132, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 598, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 71490, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6276, "avg_search_time_ms": 784.5, "search_nodes": 159151, "safety_nodes": 225, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 159376, "avg_nodes": 19922.0, "eval_calls": 155207, "avg_eval_calls": 19400.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 155207, "pattern_eval_ns": 3301704, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.27290650550555, "pattern_frame_queries": 155207, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3301704, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.27290650550555, "pattern_frame_updates": 318258, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4152000015, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13046.01931451841, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3930, "avg_candidate_generations": 491.25, "candidate_moves_total": 294010, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.81170483460559, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 518, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 3922, "search_candidate_moves_total": 293492, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 6924, "avg_legality_checks": 865.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 78, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6924, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 78, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1016252, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 127031.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2425475361, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2386.6869250933823, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56683, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7085.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 583842417, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10300.132614716935, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 79, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 964735, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 56547, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 582248088, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 629594, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19253432, "stage_ordering_ns": 148562, "stage_eval_ns": 4155301719, "stage_threat_ns": 2088810122, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 318266, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1832694326, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 60610, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 159129, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 217199836, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 318258, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38855350, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 330, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3334, "depth_sum": 21, "avg_depth": 2.625, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 21, "avg_effective_depth": 2.625, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4161.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5161.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1924, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 108, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6474, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 128, 67, 96, 80, 95, 94, 110, 68, 108, 98, 124, 138, 140, 92, 125, 155, 111, 109, 139, 83, 153 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6426, "avg_search_time_ms": 535.5, "search_nodes": 172959, "safety_nodes": 80, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 173039, "avg_nodes": 14419.916666666666, "eval_calls": 168149, "avg_eval_calls": 14012.416666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 168149, "pattern_eval_ns": 3588204, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.339431099798393, "pattern_frame_queries": 168149, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3588204, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.339431099798393, "pattern_frame_updates": 345850, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3739099292, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10811.332346392945, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4788, "avg_candidate_generations": 399.0, "candidate_moves_total": 374076, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.12781954887218, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 805, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 4776, "search_candidate_moves_total": 373271, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 160848, "avg_legality_checks": 13404.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "root_legality_checks": 805, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 160043, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1108585, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 92382.08333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2676681450, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2414.502676835786, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15361, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1280.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 82177747, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5349.76544495801, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 66, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 373080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15295, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 81804667, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 392266260, "stage_ordering_ns": 178600, "stage_eval_ns": 3742687496, "stage_threat_ns": 2259248318, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 345862, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1979445189, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 24472, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12211, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 172925, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 237583687, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 345850, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42194970, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 725, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3796, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6124.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6791.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1852, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1818181818181817, "search_nodes": 145, "safety_nodes": 906, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1051, "avg_nodes": 95.54545454545455, "eval_calls": 134, "avg_eval_calls": 12.181818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 134, "line_shape_eval_ns": 125940, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 939.8507462686567, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 734, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.72727272727273, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12746, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1158.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26804943, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2103.00823787855, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4710, "stage_ordering_ns": 560, "stage_eval_ns": 125940, "stage_threat_ns": 22221287, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 279, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21728621, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 253242, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 204063, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 268, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35361, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 109, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3477, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 114, 115, 97, 82, 68, 126, 94, 125, 98, 124, 138, 123, 127, 122 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.875, "search_nodes": 238, "safety_nodes": 401, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 639, "avg_nodes": 79.875, "eval_calls": 230, "avg_eval_calls": 28.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 230, "line_shape_eval_ns": 162961, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 708.5260869565218, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 502, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.75, "candidate_moves_max": 79, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 502, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 502, "avg_legality_checks": 62.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 502, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9917, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1239.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21381997, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2156.0952909145913, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 63160, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12632.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11590, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 51570, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 199001, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12437.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 108711, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4726.565217391304, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1352926, "stage_ordering_ns": 320, "stage_eval_ns": 162961, "stage_threat_ns": 18453852, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 468, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17776508, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 286761, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8840, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 329371, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61212, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 3438, "avg_search_time_ms": 429.75, "search_nodes": 103941, "safety_nodes": 513, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 104454, "avg_nodes": 13056.75, "eval_calls": 101500, "avg_eval_calls": 12687.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 101500, "pattern_eval_ns": 2169950, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.378817733990147, "pattern_frame_queries": 101500, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2169950, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.378817733990147, "pattern_frame_updates": 207838, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2019590463, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9717.137688969293, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2427, "avg_candidate_generations": 303.375, "candidate_moves_total": 189786, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.19777503090235, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 522, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 2419, "search_candidate_moves_total": 189264, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 4998, "avg_legality_checks": 624.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4998, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 474707, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 59338.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1145030692, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2412.0788022927827, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12025, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1503.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 114717630, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9539.92765072765, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 140860, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12001, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 114458870, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 117900, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13897654, "stage_ordering_ns": 87301, "stage_eval_ns": 2021760413, "stage_threat_ns": 1388618707, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 207846, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1220196561, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 113530, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7960, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 103919, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 142432090, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 207838, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25876526, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 214, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2106, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5298.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6298.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1957, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 110, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6684, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 114, 111, 126, 115, 98, 84, 83, 68, 82, 130, 52, 128, 66, 50, 80, 38, 81, 79, 97, 67, 65, 129, 49 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6634, "avg_search_time_ms": 552.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 172481, "safety_nodes": 80, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 172561, "avg_nodes": 14380.083333333334, "eval_calls": 166867, "avg_eval_calls": 13905.583333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 166867, "pattern_eval_ns": 3582268, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.467803699952658, "pattern_frame_queries": 166867, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3582268, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.467803699952658, "pattern_frame_updates": 344894, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3967507111, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11503.555037199836, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5592, "avg_candidate_generations": 466.0, "candidate_moves_total": 423401, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.71548640915594, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 805, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 5580, "search_candidate_moves_total": 422596, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 160380, "avg_legality_checks": 13365.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 805, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 159575, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1181190, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 98432.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2846681278, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2410.0113258662873, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19277, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1606.4166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 105164358, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5455.431758053639, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 334612, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19207, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 104829746, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 394104594, "stage_ordering_ns": 199000, "stage_eval_ns": 3971089379, "stage_threat_ns": 2240154283, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 344906, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1963265088, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 23950, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 172447, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 234845799, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 344894, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42019446, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 725, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4622, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5726.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6393.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1777, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1818181818181817, "search_nodes": 145, "safety_nodes": 906, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1051, "avg_nodes": 95.54545454545455, "eval_calls": 134, "avg_eval_calls": 12.181818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 134, "line_shape_eval_ns": 127501, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 951.5, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 734, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.72727272727273, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12746, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1158.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26671434, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2092.533657618076, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4850, "stage_ordering_ns": 500, "stage_eval_ns": 127501, "stage_threat_ns": 22108452, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 279, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21624818, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 253214, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 194620, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 268, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35800, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 111, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5972, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 142, 157, 111, 110, 68, 98, 66, 138, 124, 130, 146, 143, 126, 128, 125, 123, 139, 83, 153 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 44, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 271, "safety_nodes": 857, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1128, "avg_nodes": 102.54545454545455, "eval_calls": 260, "avg_eval_calls": 23.636363636363637, "line_shape_eval_calls": 260, "line_shape_eval_ns": 216842, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 834.0076923076923, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 808, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.45454545454545, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 808, "avg_legality_checks": 73.45454545454545, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 808, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13870, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1260.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30012019, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2163.808147080029, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.909090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 366972, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11467.875, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 70501, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 296471, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.3636363636363638, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 372782, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 14337.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.6363636363636362, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 222321, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 5558.025, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2212650, "stage_ordering_ns": 430, "stage_eval_ns": 216842, "stage_threat_ns": 24975033, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 531, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24022598, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 505543, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11290, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 378771, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 520, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 68121, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5918, "avg_search_time_ms": 591.8, "search_nodes": 165733, "safety_nodes": 501, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 166234, "avg_nodes": 16623.4, "eval_calls": 161729, "avg_eval_calls": 16172.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 161729, "pattern_eval_ns": 3456449, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.371856624353086, "pattern_frame_queries": 161729, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3456449, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.371856624353086, "pattern_frame_updates": 331408, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3653035605, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11022.774359701636, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3985, "avg_candidate_generations": 398.5, "candidate_moves_total": 348617, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.4823086574655, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 736, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3975, "search_candidate_moves_total": 347881, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 10631, "avg_legality_checks": 1063.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 82, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10631, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 82, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 801100, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 80110.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1994882298, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2490.178876544751, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45062, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4506.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 460555800, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10220.49176689894, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 82, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 964264, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 44950, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 459220473, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 371063, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 30184165, "stage_ordering_ns": 148071, "stage_eval_ns": 3656492054, "stage_threat_ns": 2210084801, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 331418, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1944337617, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 93231, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10800, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 165704, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 224534757, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 331408, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41119196, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 326, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3474, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5639.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6439.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 112, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5729, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 142, 97, 98, 157, 126, 84, 125, 128, 110, 158, 140, 154, 155, 95, 170 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5697, "avg_search_time_ms": 712.125, "search_nodes": 131198, "safety_nodes": 69, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 131267, "avg_nodes": 16408.375, "eval_calls": 127849, "avg_eval_calls": 15981.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 127849, "pattern_eval_ns": 2761261, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.59783025287644, "pattern_frame_queries": 127849, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2761261, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.59783025287644, "pattern_frame_updates": 262352, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3333880724, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12707.662697444655, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3335, "avg_candidate_generations": 416.875, "candidate_moves_total": 221463, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.40569715142429, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 474, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 3327, "search_candidate_moves_total": 220989, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 124834, "avg_legality_checks": 15604.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 65, "root_legality_checks": 474, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 124360, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 64, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 863406, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 107925.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2251911821, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2608.172541075693, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13300, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1662.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 135840240, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10213.551879699247, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 76, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 716813, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13219, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 135063337, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 60090, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 337836573, "stage_ordering_ns": 116830, "stage_eval_ns": 3336641985, "stage_threat_ns": 2010556909, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 262360, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1790105988, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 15710, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8250, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 131176, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 186213647, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 262352, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34221564, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 404, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2739, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3455.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4455.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 448, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 22, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.142857142857143, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 585, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 652, "avg_nodes": 93.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 60, "avg_eval_calls": 8.571428571428571, "line_shape_eval_calls": 60, "line_shape_eval_ns": 42160, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 702.6666666666666, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 413, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.0, "candidate_moves_max": 70, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 413, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8168, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1166.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17575776, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2151.784524975514, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 49550, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12387.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 49550, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2841, "stage_ordering_ns": 340, "stage_eval_ns": 42160, "stage_threat_ns": 14172622, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 127, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 13861771, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 204421, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 60, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 89990, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16440, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5138.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6281.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 113, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4278, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 129, 126, 143, 96, 111, 159, 79, 66, 95 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 25, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5714285714285716, "search_nodes": 298, "safety_nodes": 243, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 541, "avg_nodes": 77.28571428571429, "eval_calls": 291, "avg_eval_calls": 41.57142857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 291, "line_shape_eval_ns": 202251, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 695.020618556701, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 418, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.714285714285715, "candidate_moves_max": 75, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 418, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 418, "avg_legality_checks": 59.714285714285715, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 418, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8588, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1226.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15546231, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1810.2271774569167, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.285714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 390993, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10567.378378378378, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 73630, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 317363, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 22, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 217871, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9903.227272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 34, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 123310, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3626.764705882353, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1020657, "stage_ordering_ns": 330, "stage_eval_ns": 202251, "stage_threat_ns": 14953129, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 589, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14173173, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 310591, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 291, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 399854, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 582, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69511, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 4248, "avg_search_time_ms": 606.8571428571429, "search_nodes": 154804, "safety_nodes": 351, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 155155, "avg_nodes": 22165.0, "eval_calls": 151379, "avg_eval_calls": 21625.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 151379, "pattern_eval_ns": 2746958, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.14622900138064, "pattern_frame_queries": 151379, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2746958, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.14622900138064, "pattern_frame_updates": 309570, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2808748093, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9073.062935684982, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3413, "avg_candidate_generations": 487.57142857142856, "candidate_moves_total": 247570, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.53735716378553, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 431, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 3406, "search_candidate_moves_total": 247139, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 5702, "avg_legality_checks": 814.5714285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 56, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5702, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 56, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1044133, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 149161.85714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1669708831, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1599.1342396035755, "renju_forbidden_checks": 49404, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7057.714285714285, "renju_forbidden_ns": 332139420, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6722.925674034491, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 56, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 519464, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 49291, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 330980863, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 639093, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12275622, "stage_ordering_ns": 101721, "stage_eval_ns": 2811495051, "stage_threat_ns": 1393900731, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 309577, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1214378001, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 74641, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 154785, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 152374070, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 309570, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27074019, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 197, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2978, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4249.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5392.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1930, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 114, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4241, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 126, 67, 98, 84, 99, 100, 114, 66, 116, 96, 130, 146, 144, 102, 129, 159, 113, 115, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 4205, "avg_search_time_ms": 350.4166666666667, "search_nodes": 158449, "safety_nodes": 80, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 158529, "avg_nodes": 13210.75, "eval_calls": 153899, "avg_eval_calls": 12824.916666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 153899, "pattern_eval_ns": 2844117, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.4804124783137, "pattern_frame_queries": 153899, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2844117, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.4804124783137, "pattern_frame_updates": 316830, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2456483691, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7753.317839219771, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4528, "avg_candidate_generations": 377.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 351591, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.64818904593639, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 805, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 4516, "search_candidate_moves_total": 350786, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 146786, "avg_legality_checks": 12232.166666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "root_legality_checks": 805, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 145981, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1020568, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 85047.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1715651801, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1681.0754413228713, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13925, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1160.4166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51629723, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3707.700035906643, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 64, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 212661, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13861, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 51417062, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 254116194, "stage_ordering_ns": 147640, "stage_eval_ns": 2459327808, "stage_threat_ns": 1457296786, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 316842, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1266726524, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 17450, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 158415, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 161969320, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 316830, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28583492, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 725, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3574, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6203.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6869.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1892, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 25, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.272727272727273, "search_nodes": 145, "safety_nodes": 906, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1051, "avg_nodes": 95.54545454545455, "eval_calls": 134, "avg_eval_calls": 12.181818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 134, "line_shape_eval_ns": 102030, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 761.4179104477612, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 734, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.72727272727273, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12746, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1158.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19098315, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1498.3771379256236, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3660, "stage_ordering_ns": 490, "stage_eval_ns": 102030, "stage_threat_ns": 16032441, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 279, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15665381, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 173390, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 166210, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 268, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27460, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6179.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6907.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 115, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8474, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 114, 115, 127, 142, 94, 96, 68, 124, 138, 174, 158, 125, 128, 143, 129, 140, 130, 131, 95, 141, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 46, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.8333333333333335, "search_nodes": 368, "safety_nodes": 857, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1225, "avg_nodes": 102.08333333333333, "eval_calls": 356, "avg_eval_calls": 29.666666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 356, "line_shape_eval_ns": 344781, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 968.4859550561798, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 903, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.25, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 903, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 903, "avg_legality_checks": 75.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 903, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15198, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1266.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31132637, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2048.4693380707986, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 297133, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11004.925925925925, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 54670, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 242463, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.1666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 410662, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10806.894736842105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 209240, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4023.846153846154, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2302814, "stage_ordering_ns": 590, "stage_eval_ns": 344781, "stage_threat_ns": 26717679, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 724, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 25512282, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 618693, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 356, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 496863, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 712, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 89841, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8417, "avg_search_time_ms": 701.4166666666666, "search_nodes": 273322, "safety_nodes": 501, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 273823, "avg_nodes": 22818.583333333332, "eval_calls": 268098, "avg_eval_calls": 22341.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 268098, "pattern_eval_ns": 5376966, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.055972069914734, "pattern_frame_queries": 268098, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5376966, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.055972069914734, "pattern_frame_updates": 546576, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4921341377, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9003.947075978454, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5202, "avg_candidate_generations": 433.5, "candidate_moves_total": 463239, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.05017301038062, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 922, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 5190, "search_candidate_moves_total": 462317, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 14987, "avg_legality_checks": 1248.9166666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 14987, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1263033, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 105252.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2892449796, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2290.0825204092052, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17875, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1489.5833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 159566854, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8926.817006993007, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 137760, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17818, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 159019423, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 409671, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 39242681, "stage_ordering_ns": 186180, "stage_eval_ns": 4926718343, "stage_threat_ns": 3418644969, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 546588, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3001775596, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 90280, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 273288, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 352972829, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 546576, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63806264, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 503, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4506, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6015.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6682.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 116, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4733, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 115, 128, 80, 143, 98, 142, 100, 144, 160, 145, 141, 146 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 4702, "avg_search_time_ms": 587.75, "search_nodes": 116223, "safety_nodes": 69, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 116292, "avg_nodes": 14536.5, "eval_calls": 112998, "avg_eval_calls": 14124.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 112998, "pattern_eval_ns": 2388244, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.135276730561603, "pattern_frame_queries": 112998, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2388244, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.135276730561603, "pattern_frame_updates": 232402, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2816631967, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12119.654594194542, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3211, "avg_candidate_generations": 401.375, "candidate_moves_total": 214363, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.75895359701028, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 474, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 3203, "search_candidate_moves_total": 213889, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 109692, "avg_legality_checks": 13711.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 133, "root_legality_checks": 474, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 109218, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 132, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 749420, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 93677.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1908076268, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2546.0706519708574, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12869, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1608.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 126226973, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9808.607739529101, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 144, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1330989, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12720, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 124838364, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57620, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 287423351, "stage_ordering_ns": 113710, "stage_eval_ns": 2819020211, "stage_threat_ns": 1581190351, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 232410, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1387719979, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 15220, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7960, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 116201, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 164129962, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 232402, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29325190, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 404, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2644, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4170.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5170.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1645, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 22, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.142857142857143, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 585, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 652, "avg_nodes": 93.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 60, "avg_eval_calls": 8.571428571428571, "line_shape_eval_calls": 60, "line_shape_eval_ns": 41570, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 692.8333333333334, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 413, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.0, "candidate_moves_max": 70, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 413, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8168, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1166.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17130962, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2097.3263956904993, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 45250, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11312.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 45250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2800, "stage_ordering_ns": 360, "stage_eval_ns": 41570, "stage_threat_ns": 13785279, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 127, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 13478837, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 198701, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8680, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 60, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91651, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16090, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5138.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6281.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 117, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1456, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 83, 128, 81, 94, 82, 84, 79, 68, 80 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 290, "safety_nodes": 243, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 533, "avg_nodes": 76.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 283, "avg_eval_calls": 40.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 283, "line_shape_eval_ns": 214211, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 756.9293286219081, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 409, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.42857142857143, "candidate_moves_max": 68, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 409, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 409, "avg_legality_checks": 58.42857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 409, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8561, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1223.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18463683, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2156.720359771055, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 370982, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11241.878787878788, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 67041, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 303941, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 329002, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12185.25925925926, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.714285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 184941, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4623.525, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1164845, "stage_ordering_ns": 310, "stage_eval_ns": 214211, "stage_threat_ns": 17266363, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 573, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16330580, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 455623, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7370, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 405630, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 566, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74530, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1422, "avg_search_time_ms": 203.14285714285714, "search_nodes": 36921, "safety_nodes": 221, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 37142, "avg_nodes": 5306.0, "eval_calls": 35376, "avg_eval_calls": 5053.714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35376, "pattern_eval_ns": 748603, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.16132406151063, "pattern_frame_queries": 35376, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 748603, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.16132406151063, "pattern_frame_updates": 73804, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 901026163, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12208.364898921467, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1533, "avg_candidate_generations": 219.0, "candidate_moves_total": 110462, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.05609915198956, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 427, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 1526, "search_candidate_moves_total": 110035, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 2664, "avg_legality_checks": 380.57142857142856, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2664, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 218527, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 31218.14285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 526007638, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2407.060171054378, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11572, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1653.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 116474088, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10065.16488074663, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 268463, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11500, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 115687071, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 518554, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7615217, "stage_ordering_ns": 53650, "stage_eval_ns": 901774766, "stage_threat_ns": 499795718, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 73811, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 439474599, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 58510, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 36902, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 51115775, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 73804, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9146834, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1221, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4980.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6123.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1956, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 118, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7002, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 109, 96, 80, 81, 66, 82, 124, 52, 126, 68, 54, 84, 36, 83, 85, 97, 67, 69, 125, 55 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6954, "avg_search_time_ms": 579.5, "search_nodes": 181508, "safety_nodes": 80, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 181588, "avg_nodes": 15132.333333333334, "eval_calls": 175762, "avg_eval_calls": 14646.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 175762, "pattern_eval_ns": 3722706, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.180380286978984, "pattern_frame_queries": 175762, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3722706, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.180380286978984, "pattern_frame_updates": 362948, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4159238841, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11459.599835238107, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5724, "avg_candidate_generations": 477.0, "candidate_moves_total": 433897, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.80310971348707, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 805, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 5712, "search_candidate_moves_total": 433092, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 168968, "avg_legality_checks": 14080.666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "root_legality_checks": 805, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 168163, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1242693, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 103557.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2993323028, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2408.73894678734, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19024, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1585.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 105081512, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5523.628679562657, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 323461, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18957, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 104758051, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 411352229, "stage_ordering_ns": 203500, "stage_eval_ns": 4162961547, "stage_threat_ns": 2343933204, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 362960, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2053992290, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 24030, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 181474, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 246065165, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 362948, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43851719, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 725, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4684, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5753.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6419.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1816, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1818181818181817, "search_nodes": 145, "safety_nodes": 906, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1051, "avg_nodes": 95.54545454545455, "eval_calls": 134, "avg_eval_calls": 12.181818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 134, "line_shape_eval_ns": 127560, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 951.9402985074627, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 734, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.72727272727273, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12746, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1158.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26688883, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2093.902636121136, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4821, "stage_ordering_ns": 540, "stage_eval_ns": 127560, "stage_threat_ns": 22085508, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 279, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21601557, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 246961, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 201060, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 268, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35930, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 119, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1274, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 82, 67, 98, 114, 100, 99, 83, 69, 129, 54, 115, 84 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.857142857142857, "search_nodes": 248, "safety_nodes": 214, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 462, "avg_nodes": 66.0, "eval_calls": 241, "avg_eval_calls": 34.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 241, "line_shape_eval_ns": 189601, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 786.7261410788382, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 348, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.714285714285715, "candidate_moves_max": 62, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 348, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 348, "avg_legality_checks": 49.714285714285715, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 348, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8270, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1181.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17902221, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2164.7183796856107, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 128051, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11641.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22630, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 105421, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 167280, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12867.692307692309, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 93260, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4908.421052631579, "stage_move_gen_ns": 959625, "stage_ordering_ns": 340, "stage_eval_ns": 189601, "stage_threat_ns": 16303251, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 489, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15628429, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 257400, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 353831, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63591, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1241, "avg_search_time_ms": 177.28571428571428, "search_nodes": 33940, "safety_nodes": 287, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34227, "avg_nodes": 4889.571428571428, "eval_calls": 32855, "avg_eval_calls": 4693.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32855, "pattern_eval_ns": 693842, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.11830771572059, "pattern_frame_queries": 32855, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 693842, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.11830771572059, "pattern_frame_updates": 67842, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 760149053, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11204.696987117126, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1073, "avg_candidate_generations": 153.28571428571428, "candidate_moves_total": 69205, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.49673811742777, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 361, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 1066, "search_candidate_moves_total": 68844, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 2713, "avg_legality_checks": 387.57142857142856, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2713, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 188864, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26980.571428571428, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 464476219, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2459.3157986699425, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5371, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 767.2857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 53667190, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9992.029417240738, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 93032, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5338, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 53284856, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 289302, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7265618, "stage_ordering_ns": 42190, "stage_eval_ns": 760842895, "stage_threat_ns": 460324766, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 67849, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 404995319, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 81260, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 33921, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 46695204, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 67842, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8552983, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 170, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 867, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4996.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6139.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 120, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3503, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 95, 143, 98, 158, 173, 99, 126, 84, 96, 94, 111, 141, 66, 81, 82, 67, 50, 114, 34 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3458, "avg_search_time_ms": 314.3636363636364, "search_nodes": 79888, "safety_nodes": 652, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 80540, "avg_nodes": 7321.818181818182, "eval_calls": 76560, "avg_eval_calls": 6960.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 76560, "pattern_eval_ns": 1625641, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.23355538140021, "pattern_frame_queries": 76560, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1625641, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.23355538140021, "pattern_frame_updates": 159714, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2189875576, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13711.23117572661, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3308, "avg_candidate_generations": 300.72727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 237680, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.85006045949214, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 664, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 3297, "search_candidate_moves_total": 237016, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 73248, "avg_legality_checks": 6658.909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 202, "root_legality_checks": 664, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 72584, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 202, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 669051, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 60822.818181818184, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1627402879, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2432.4048226517857, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13995, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1272.2727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 93207265, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6660.040371561272, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 206, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1820957, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13787, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 91383578, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2730, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 41, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.727272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 370971, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9048.073170731708, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 153311, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2839.0925925925926, "stage_move_gen_ns": 185573211, "stage_ordering_ns": 118120, "stage_eval_ns": 2191501217, "stage_threat_ns": 1062953723, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 159725, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 930622019, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 531802, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79857, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112060063, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 159714, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19739839, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 298, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2861, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6030.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6757.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1865, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1, "search_nodes": 78, "safety_nodes": 824, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 902, "avg_nodes": 90.2, "eval_calls": 68, "avg_eval_calls": 6.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68, "line_shape_eval_ns": 54500, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 801.4705882352941, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 613, "avg_candidate_moves": 61.3, "candidate_moves_max": 79, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 613, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11482, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1148.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24192341, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2106.9797073680543, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4250, "stage_ordering_ns": 510, "stage_eval_ns": 54500, "stage_threat_ns": 19364544, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 146, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19027784, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 211490, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 106820, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18450, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 121, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11956, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 109, 108, 125, 141, 99, 155, 169, 171, 96, 156, 186, 139, 123, 140, 124, 138, 137, 142 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 37, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7, "search_nodes": 217, "safety_nodes": 617, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 834, "avg_nodes": 83.4, "eval_calls": 207, "avg_eval_calls": 20.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 207, "line_shape_eval_ns": 159530, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 770.6763285024155, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 617, "avg_candidate_moves": 61.7, "candidate_moves_max": 78, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 617, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 617, "avg_legality_checks": 61.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 617, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12033, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1203.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25925054, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2154.496301836616, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 193711, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12914.066666666668, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 37721, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 155990, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 29, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 373932, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12894.206896551725, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 209172, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4864.46511627907, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1652279, "stage_ordering_ns": 540, "stage_eval_ns": 159530, "stage_threat_ns": 21562316, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 424, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20692224, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 513032, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 207, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 303150, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 414, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53910, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11909, "avg_search_time_ms": 1190.9, "search_nodes": 312119, "safety_nodes": 344, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 312463, "avg_nodes": 31246.3, "eval_calls": 306011, "avg_eval_calls": 30601.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 306011, "pattern_eval_ns": 6499991, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.241037086902104, "pattern_frame_queries": 306011, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6499991, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.241037086902104, "pattern_frame_updates": 624182, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7658110354, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12269.034278463654, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6090, "avg_candidate_generations": 609.0, "candidate_moves_total": 480136, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.840065681445, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 649, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 6080, "search_candidate_moves_total": 479487, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 9507, "avg_legality_checks": 950.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 113, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9507, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 113, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1817415, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 181741.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4504462717, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2478.4998016413424, "renju_forbidden_checks": 66608, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6660.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 712198753, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10692.390598726879, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 113, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1325586, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 66465, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 710492476, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 380691, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 29232029, "stage_ordering_ns": 213810, "stage_eval_ns": 7664610345, "stage_threat_ns": 4199051115, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 624192, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3676674233, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 110801, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 312091, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 442975009, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 624182, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 79291072, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 365, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5356, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.6, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3652.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4452.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 122, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5097, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 80, 128, 125, 129, 130, 140, 97, 139, 95, 65, 96, 98, 93, 94, 109, 108, 77, 141, 61 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5054, "avg_search_time_ms": 459.45454545454544, "search_nodes": 114878, "safety_nodes": 652, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 115530, "avg_nodes": 10502.727272727272, "eval_calls": 110739, "avg_eval_calls": 10067.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110739, "pattern_eval_ns": 2360522, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.316085570575858, "pattern_frame_queries": 110739, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2360522, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.316085570575858, "pattern_frame_updates": 229694, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3221063859, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14023.282536766306, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4119, "avg_candidate_generations": 374.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 290426, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.50886137411993, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 664, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 4108, "search_candidate_moves_total": 289762, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 106102, "avg_legality_checks": 9645.636363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 664, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 105438, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 976234, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 88748.54545454546, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2393802433, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2452.0785313766987, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15598, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1418.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 115518398, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7405.974996794461, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 479733, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15548, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 115035665, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3000, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 41, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.727272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 366063, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8928.365853658537, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 152962, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2832.6296296296296, "stage_move_gen_ns": 271099678, "stage_ordering_ns": 155860, "stage_eval_ns": 3223424381, "stage_threat_ns": 1533639175, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 229705, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1342476292, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 531534, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11240, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 114847, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 161888611, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 229694, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28742738, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 298, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3605, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5772.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6499.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1870, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1, "search_nodes": 78, "safety_nodes": 824, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 902, "avg_nodes": 90.2, "eval_calls": 68, "avg_eval_calls": 6.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68, "line_shape_eval_ns": 54710, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 804.5588235294117, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 613, "avg_candidate_moves": 61.3, "candidate_moves_max": 79, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 613, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11550, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1155.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24420686, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2114.345108225108, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4200, "stage_ordering_ns": 480, "stage_eval_ns": 54710, "stage_threat_ns": 19455484, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 146, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19115853, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 216460, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11210, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104941, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18230, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 123, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1209, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 95, 79, 80, 66, 50, 110, 35, 94, 65 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 248, "safety_nodes": 214, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 462, "avg_nodes": 66.0, "eval_calls": 241, "avg_eval_calls": 34.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 241, "line_shape_eval_ns": 190760, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 791.5352697095435, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 348, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.714285714285715, "candidate_moves_max": 62, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 348, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 348, "avg_legality_checks": 49.714285714285715, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 348, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8172, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1167.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17656887, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2160.6567547723935, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 125821, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11438.272727272728, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22520, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 103301, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 162020, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12463.076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 90630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4770.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 932694, "stage_ordering_ns": 280, "stage_eval_ns": 190760, "stage_threat_ns": 16132083, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 489, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15478119, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 247222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7511, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 343312, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63430, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1175, "avg_search_time_ms": 167.85714285714286, "search_nodes": 34032, "safety_nodes": 287, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34319, "avg_nodes": 4902.714285714285, "eval_calls": 32920, "avg_eval_calls": 4702.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32920, "pattern_eval_ns": 699395, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.245291616038884, "pattern_frame_queries": 32920, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 699395, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.245291616038884, "pattern_frame_updates": 68026, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 704487166, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10356.145679593097, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1100, "avg_candidate_generations": 157.14285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 70027, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.660909090909094, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 361, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 1093, "search_candidate_moves_total": 69666, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 2562, "avg_legality_checks": 366.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2562, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 187171, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26738.714285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 431149647, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2303.506670370944, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5566, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 795.1428571428571, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51748065, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9297.173014732303, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 102562, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5531, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 51368741, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 276762, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6494754, "stage_ordering_ns": 42840, "stage_eval_ns": 705186561, "stage_threat_ns": 449564926, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 68033, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 395761050, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 86001, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6930, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34013, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 45432714, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 68026, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8285161, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 170, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 892, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5002.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6145.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 124, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2874, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 95, 79, 143, 159, 80, 65, 113, 93, 51, 64, 67, 49, 33, 94, 34, 109 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2833, "avg_search_time_ms": 283.3, "search_nodes": 72344, "safety_nodes": 229, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 72573, "avg_nodes": 7257.3, "eval_calls": 69292, "avg_eval_calls": 6929.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 69292, "pattern_eval_ns": 1466837, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.168922819373087, "pattern_frame_queries": 69292, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1466837, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.168922819373087, "pattern_frame_updates": 144632, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1716089293, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11865.211661319763, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3034, "avg_candidate_generations": 303.4, "candidate_moves_total": 233282, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.8892551087673, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 637, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 3024, "search_candidate_moves_total": 232645, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 65623, "avg_legality_checks": 6562.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "root_legality_checks": 637, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 64986, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 539238, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 53923.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1242974820, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2305.057915057915, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9049, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 904.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57605886, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6365.994695546469, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 228320, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9014, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57377566, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 102600, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11400.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 53060, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4081.5384615384614, "stage_move_gen_ns": 156590812, "stage_ordering_ns": 106950, "stage_eval_ns": 1717556130, "stage_threat_ns": 933008909, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 144642, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 817800560, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 157280, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10130, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72316, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 97671444, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 144632, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17379625, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 455, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2454, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5846.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6646.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1866, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 29, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.2222222222222223, "search_nodes": 145, "safety_nodes": 738, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 883, "avg_nodes": 98.11111111111111, "eval_calls": 136, "avg_eval_calls": 15.11111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 136, "line_shape_eval_ns": 137540, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1011.3235294117648, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10444, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1160.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22075842, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2113.7343929528915, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3810, "stage_ordering_ns": 510, "stage_eval_ns": 137540, "stage_threat_ns": 18573387, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 281, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18137096, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 201640, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9760, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 136, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 198451, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 272, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36200, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 125, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1094, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 110, 109, 96, 82, 66, 81, 95, 79, 83, 78, 67, 80 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 248, "safety_nodes": 214, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 462, "avg_nodes": 66.0, "eval_calls": 241, "avg_eval_calls": 34.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 241, "line_shape_eval_ns": 189500, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 786.3070539419087, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 348, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.714285714285715, "candidate_moves_max": 62, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 348, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 348, "avg_legality_checks": 49.714285714285715, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 348, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8270, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1181.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17934552, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2168.6278113663843, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124070, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11279.09090909091, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23110, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 100960, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 169921, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 13070.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 91881, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4835.8421052631575, "stage_move_gen_ns": 973345, "stage_ordering_ns": 340, "stage_eval_ns": 189500, "stage_threat_ns": 16385104, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 489, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15701898, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 255031, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7590, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 356595, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 71580, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1060, "avg_search_time_ms": 151.42857142857142, "search_nodes": 30502, "safety_nodes": 287, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 30789, "avg_nodes": 4398.428571428572, "eval_calls": 29443, "avg_eval_calls": 4206.142857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 29443, "pattern_eval_ns": 627254, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.30401114016914, "pattern_frame_queries": 29443, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 627254, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.30401114016914, "pattern_frame_updates": 60966, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 624640368, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10245.716760161402, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1047, "avg_candidate_generations": 149.57142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 67183, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.16714422158549, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 361, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 1040, "search_candidate_moves_total": 66822, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 2705, "avg_legality_checks": 386.42857142857144, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2705, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 155848, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22264.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 375230015, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2407.666540475335, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3961, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 565.8571428571429, "renju_forbidden_ns": 39272318, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9914.748295884878, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 97470, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3926, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38891036, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 283812, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7202073, "stage_ordering_ns": 43080, "stage_eval_ns": 625267622, "stage_threat_ns": 415663284, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 60973, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 365741441, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 81581, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6970, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 30483, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 42236516, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 60966, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7603746, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 170, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 839, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5035.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6178.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 126, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20572, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 82, 66, 130, 146, 81, 80, 128, 52, 38, 108, 94, 141, 110, 127, 99, 155, 169, 64, 48, 100, 95, 157, 115, 156, 126, 154, 153, 158 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 20502, "avg_search_time_ms": 1281.375, "search_nodes": 546031, "safety_nodes": 487, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 546518, "avg_nodes": 34157.375, "eval_calls": 533736, "avg_eval_calls": 33358.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 533736, "pattern_eval_ns": 11369358, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.301463644948065, "pattern_frame_queries": 533736, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11369358, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.301463644948065, "pattern_frame_updates": 1091970, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 12365502406, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11324.031251774317, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12265, "avg_candidate_generations": 766.5625, "candidate_moves_total": 1203446, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.12034243783123, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1363, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 12249, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1202083, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 504458, "avg_legality_checks": 31528.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 189, "root_legality_checks": 1363, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 503095, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 189, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3868485, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 241780.3125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9054671675, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2340.6247342305837, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41793, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2612.0625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 257104479, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6151.855071423444, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 483, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2472089, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 41296, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 254590469, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 41921, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.5625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 249941, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9997.64, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 34, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 119311, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3509.1470588235293, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1181480349, "stage_ordering_ns": 468542, "stage_eval_ns": 12376871764, "stage_threat_ns": 6848368632, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1091986, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5975727424, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 350821, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 545985, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 741686258, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1091970, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 130604129, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 950, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 10600, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 2.8125, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8125, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5931.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6431.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1813, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 52, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.466666666666667, "search_nodes": 411, "safety_nodes": 1297, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1708, "avg_nodes": 113.86666666666666, "eval_calls": 396, "avg_eval_calls": 26.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 396, "line_shape_eval_ns": 649371, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1639.8257575757575, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1297, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.46666666666667, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1297, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1162.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 36531021, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2095.149174122505, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 78051, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3252.125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 78051, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7240, "stage_ordering_ns": 690, "stage_eval_ns": 649371, "stage_threat_ns": 33029525, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 807, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 32114219, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 262032, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 396, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 554803, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 792, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 98471, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 15, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 15, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6664.466666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7197.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 127, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1271, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 82, 67, 96, 110, 94, 95, 81, 65, 125, 50, 109, 80 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.857142857142857, "search_nodes": 248, "safety_nodes": 214, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 462, "avg_nodes": 66.0, "eval_calls": 241, "avg_eval_calls": 34.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 241, "line_shape_eval_ns": 193750, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 803.9419087136929, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 348, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.714285714285715, "candidate_moves_max": 62, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 348, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 348, "avg_legality_checks": 49.714285714285715, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 348, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8270, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1181.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17784276, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2150.4565900846433, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 119441, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10858.272727272728, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22550, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 96891, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 166090, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12776.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 92740, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4881.0526315789475, "stage_move_gen_ns": 946906, "stage_ordering_ns": 300, "stage_eval_ns": 193750, "stage_threat_ns": 16366874, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 489, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15704100, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 251592, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 343782, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67400, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1238, "avg_search_time_ms": 176.85714285714286, "search_nodes": 34952, "safety_nodes": 287, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35239, "avg_nodes": 5034.142857142857, "eval_calls": 33840, "avg_eval_calls": 4834.285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33840, "pattern_eval_ns": 720387, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.28803191489362, "pattern_frame_queries": 33840, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 720387, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.28803191489362, "pattern_frame_updates": 69866, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 741591343, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10614.481192568632, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1100, "avg_candidate_generations": 157.14285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 71033, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.57545454545455, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 361, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 1093, "search_candidate_moves_total": 70672, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 2676, "avg_legality_checks": 382.2857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2676, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 190025, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27146.428571428572, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 451359561, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2375.26410209183, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5673, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 810.4285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 54217645, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9557.138198484046, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 105850, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5638, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 53839284, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 272511, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7076223, "stage_ordering_ns": 40410, "stage_eval_ns": 742311730, "stage_threat_ns": 474591912, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 69873, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 418573940, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 81630, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6840, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34933, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 47044650, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 69866, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8891692, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 170, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 892, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4998.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6141.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 128, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2971, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 110, 94, 158, 174, 95, 80, 128, 108, 66, 79, 82, 64, 48, 109, 49, 124 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2930, "avg_search_time_ms": 293.0, "search_nodes": 73903, "safety_nodes": 229, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 74132, "avg_nodes": 7413.2, "eval_calls": 70846, "avg_eval_calls": 7084.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70846, "pattern_eval_ns": 1509853, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.311760720435874, "pattern_frame_queries": 70846, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1509853, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.311760720435874, "pattern_frame_updates": 147750, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1770397332, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11982.384649746193, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3039, "avg_candidate_generations": 303.9, "candidate_moves_total": 235115, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.36590983876275, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 637, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 3029, "search_candidate_moves_total": 234478, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 67165, "avg_legality_checks": 6716.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "root_legality_checks": 637, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 66528, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 541993, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 54199.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1279700944, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2361.102346340266, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9102, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 910.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 58371007, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6412.98692595034, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 232561, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9067, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 58138446, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 105640, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11737.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 54600, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4200.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 165152385, "stage_ordering_ns": 103310, "stage_eval_ns": 1771907185, "stage_threat_ns": 971657873, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 147760, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 851983676, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 159760, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9930, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 73875, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 101203835, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 147750, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18310602, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 455, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2459, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5843.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6643.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1864, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 29, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.2222222222222223, "search_nodes": 145, "safety_nodes": 738, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 883, "avg_nodes": 98.11111111111111, "eval_calls": 136, "avg_eval_calls": 15.11111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 136, "line_shape_eval_ns": 137413, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1010.3897058823529, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10398, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1155.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22070888, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2122.6089632621656, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3710, "stage_ordering_ns": 370, "stage_eval_ns": 137413, "stage_threat_ns": 18630060, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 281, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18196827, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 206181, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 136, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 191690, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 272, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35362, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 129, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7646, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 67, 52, 83, 141, 99, 51, 115, 131, 68, 128, 81, 143, 158, 155, 169, 84, 80, 79, 96, 129, 130, 54, 64, 48, 110, 124, 66, 65, 111, 126, 125, 69, 139 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 71, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.9444444444444446, "search_nodes": 581, "safety_nodes": 1390, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1971, "avg_nodes": 109.5, "eval_calls": 563, "avg_eval_calls": 31.27777777777778, "line_shape_eval_calls": 563, "line_shape_eval_ns": 664961, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1181.1030195381882, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1474, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.88888888888889, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1474, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1474, "avg_legality_checks": 81.88888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "root_legality_checks": 1474, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22458, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1247.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 46415306, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2066.7604417134207, "renju_forbidden_checks": 64, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.5555555555555554, "renju_forbidden_ns": 636704, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9948.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 127842, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 508862, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 78, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 817335, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10478.653846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 108, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 422544, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3912.4444444444443, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3751380, "stage_ordering_ns": 730, "stage_eval_ns": 664961, "stage_threat_ns": 41076294, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1144, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 39122516, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 48, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 998585, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19060, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 563, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 808123, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1126, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 147070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 18, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 18, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6886.722222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7331.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 7559, "avg_search_time_ms": 444.6470588235294, "search_nodes": 78915, "safety_nodes": 1808, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 80723, "avg_nodes": 4748.411764705882, "eval_calls": 60818, "avg_eval_calls": 3577.529411764706, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60818, "pattern_eval_ns": 1317019, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.655085665427997, "pattern_frame_queries": 60818, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1317019, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.655085665427997, "pattern_frame_updates": 157670, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1933329171, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12261.870812456396, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16517, "avg_candidate_generations": 971.5882352941177, "candidate_moves_total": 1384025, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.79396984924622, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1401, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 16500, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1382624, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 638332, "avg_legality_checks": 37548.94117647059, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4373, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 638332, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4373, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2048903, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 120523.70588235294, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4319561987, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2108.2315692836605, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35890, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2111.176470588235, "renju_forbidden_ns": 393661831, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10968.565923655615, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6223, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 80766903, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15108, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 177602276, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14487, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 134550766, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 741886, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75872, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4463.058823529412, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 862321026, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11365.471135596794, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110670, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6510.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 436955477, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3948.2739405439597, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1635768750, "stage_ordering_ns": 557452698, "stage_eval_ns": 1934646190, "stage_threat_ns": 3381793749, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 340868, "root_tactical_annotations": 836, "search_tactical_annotations": 340032, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 157687, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 948356505, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 315918, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2290802823, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33114, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1143778744, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78835, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 115896553, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 157670, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20244054, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 90946, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 368951647, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 191849, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 777734859, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 58073, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6493814, "child_limit_applications": 16500, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16500, "child_cap_hits": 16500, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16500, "child_moves_before_total": 1378251, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1378251, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 271909, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 271909, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.53036363636363, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.479333333333333, "tt_hits": 5852, "tt_cutoffs": 1517, "beta_cutoffs": 12542, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6430.294117647059, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6900.882352941177, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1840, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 130, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23288, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 83, 128, 67, 143, 158, 127, 82, 52, 81, 84, 99, 51, 79, 80, 53, 95, 69, 111, 159, 142, 37, 85, 160, 157, 68, 172, 187, 66, 38, 23, 39, 25, 40, 36, 41 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 23218, "avg_search_time_ms": 1289.888888888889, "search_nodes": 267925, "safety_nodes": 504, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 268429, "avg_nodes": 14912.722222222223, "eval_calls": 211028, "avg_eval_calls": 11723.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 211028, "pattern_eval_ns": 4524504, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.440301760903765, "pattern_frame_queries": 211028, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4524504, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.440301760903765, "pattern_frame_updates": 535686, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7404563733, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13822.582133936672, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 53242, "avg_candidate_generations": 2957.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 4374704, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.16640997708576, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1315, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 53224, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4373389, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1653922, "avg_legality_checks": 91884.55555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1210, "root_legality_checks": 1315, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1652607, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1209, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6520228, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 362234.8888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13656253736, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2094.4442028714334, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60266, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3348.1111111111113, "renju_forbidden_ns": 282543317, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4688.270616931603, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2005, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14554427, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 32733, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 213429830, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25516, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 54497080, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61980, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 239112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13284.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2040076470, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8531.886605440128, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 315316, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17517.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 872310393, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2766.4640963351053, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3968702305, "stage_ordering_ns": 1703355434, "stage_eval_ns": 7409088237, "stage_threat_ns": 10048954905, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1339943, "root_tactical_annotations": 4223, "search_tactical_annotations": 1335720, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 535704, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3146232066, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1149468, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6401589913, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 106565, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3516010216, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 267843, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 393522634, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 535686, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 68794057, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 470050, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 607271473, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 572839, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2278126183, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 297054, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 38816235, "child_limit_applications": 53224, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 53224, "child_cap_hits": 53224, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 53224, "child_moves_before_total": 4372180, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4372180, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 948297, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 948297, "child_moves_after_max": 32, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 32, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.14677589057568, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.81709379227416, "tt_hits": 22668, "tt_cutoffs": 3591, "beta_cutoffs": 40248, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4503.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4947.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 711, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 53, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1176470588235294, "search_nodes": 164, "safety_nodes": 1851, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2015, "avg_nodes": 118.52941176470588, "eval_calls": 147, "avg_eval_calls": 8.647058823529411, "line_shape_eval_calls": 147, "line_shape_eval_ns": 201971, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1373.952380952381, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1258, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.0, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1258, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19548, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1149.8823529411766, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 40018847, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2047.2092797217106, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5882352941176471, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57160, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5716.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57160, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8000, "stage_ordering_ns": 640, "stage_eval_ns": 201971, "stage_threat_ns": 32957508, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 311, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 32254004, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 440132, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18431, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 224601, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 294, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38771, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6821.529411764706, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7292.117647058823, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 131, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6812, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 110, 109, 126, 98, 97, 82, 66, 129, 130, 99, 96, 81, 141, 156, 142, 84, 144, 69 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.8, "search_nodes": 261, "safety_nodes": 575, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 836, "avg_nodes": 83.6, "eval_calls": 251, "avg_eval_calls": 25.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 251, "line_shape_eval_ns": 195381, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 778.410358565737, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 565, "avg_candidate_moves": 56.5, "candidate_moves_max": 73, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 565, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 565, "avg_legality_checks": 56.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 565, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12222, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1222.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25602128, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2094.7576501390936, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 117520, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9793.333333333334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22410, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 95110, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 495582, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11525.162790697674, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 62, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 266171, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4293.080645161291, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1486436, "stage_ordering_ns": 450, "stage_eval_ns": 195381, "stage_threat_ns": 22143867, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 512, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21037554, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 675182, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10470, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 251, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 362501, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 502, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 68630, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6765, "avg_search_time_ms": 676.5, "search_nodes": 66223, "safety_nodes": 463, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 66686, "avg_nodes": 6668.6, "eval_calls": 49589, "avg_eval_calls": 4958.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49589, "pattern_eval_ns": 1056285, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.300792514468935, "pattern_frame_queries": 49589, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1056285, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.300792514468935, "pattern_frame_updates": 132362, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1510284606, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11410.258276544628, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15425, "avg_candidate_generations": 1542.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1082935, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.20648298217179, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 587, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 15415, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1082348, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 663331, "avg_legality_checks": 66333.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1345, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 663331, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1345, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2005614, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 200561.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4192028664, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2090.147288561009, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18309, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1830.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 81537308, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4453.400404172811, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1355, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13732547, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4678, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44365081, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12266, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23320130, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 119550, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 79653, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7965.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 810196790, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10171.579099343402, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 115243, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11524.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 396526662, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3440.7873970653313, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1639330844, "stage_ordering_ns": 479399692, "stage_eval_ns": 1511340891, "stage_threat_ns": 3098336177, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 250138, "root_tactical_annotations": 1172, "search_tactical_annotations": 248966, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 132372, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 812343669, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 219458, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2164375326, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30891, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1161527299, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66181, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96601846, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 132362, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17650605, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 57608, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 366857871, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 130953, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 635889436, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 61577, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7364731, "child_limit_applications": 15415, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15415, "child_cap_hits": 15415, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15415, "child_moves_before_total": 1081003, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1081003, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 246869, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 246869, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.12669477781382, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01485566007136, "tt_hits": 6213, "tt_cutoffs": 1177, "beta_cutoffs": 12139, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4650.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5450.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1837, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 132, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10307, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 142, 156, 100, 86, 141, 140, 98, 124, 108, 109, 110, 154, 168, 139, 94, 169 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10267, "avg_search_time_ms": 1026.7, "search_nodes": 127916, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 128147, "avg_nodes": 12814.7, "eval_calls": 104279, "avg_eval_calls": 10427.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 104279, "pattern_eval_ns": 2228204, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.367715455652625, "pattern_frame_queries": 104279, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2228204, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.367715455652625, "pattern_frame_updates": 255748, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3348280555, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13092.108462236263, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22286, "avg_candidate_generations": 2228.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1785982, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.13919052319842, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 22276, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1785342, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 742409, "avg_legality_checks": 74240.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 486, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 741769, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 485, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2607589, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 260758.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5932237223, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2274.989357218488, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26440, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2644.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 111875048, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4231.280181543117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1092, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5040636, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15259, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 88794187, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10084, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17984905, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55320, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64159, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6415.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 560331469, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8733.4819588834, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 83206, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8320.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 226786887, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2725.6073720645145, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1860172350, "stage_ordering_ns": 759065957, "stage_eval_ns": 3350508759, "stage_threat_ns": 4261030822, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 340658, "root_tactical_annotations": 1928, "search_tactical_annotations": 338730, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 255758, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1516299918, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 309214, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2512543020, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44613, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1694951430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 127874, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 189267575, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 255748, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33106283, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 94336, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 107154443, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 170257, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 710291266, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76065, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9814026, "child_limit_applications": 22276, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22276, "child_cap_hits": 22276, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22276, "child_moves_before_total": 1784857, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1784857, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 356550, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 356550, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.12466331477823, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00601544262884, "tt_hits": 9227, "tt_cutoffs": 1319, "beta_cutoffs": 15387, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4235.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5035.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1173, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 46860, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 807.9310344827586, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1157.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22061197, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2118.4172268100633, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 47090, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11772.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 47090, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3761, "stage_ordering_ns": 450, "stage_eval_ns": 46860, "stage_threat_ns": 17635615, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17326293, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 201791, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10021, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91481, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16050, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 133, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15411, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 99, 94, 127, 85, 98, 100, 83, 128, 53, 68, 115, 67, 81, 129, 49, 52, 65 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 43, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.909090909090909, "search_nodes": 274, "safety_nodes": 666, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 940, "avg_nodes": 85.45454545454545, "eval_calls": 263, "avg_eval_calls": 23.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 263, "line_shape_eval_ns": 252171, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 958.8250950570342, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 665, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.45454545454545, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 665, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 665, "avg_legality_checks": 60.45454545454545, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 665, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13521, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1229.1818181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28564526, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2112.6045410842394, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.909090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 356932, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11154.125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 66881, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 290051, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.636363636363637, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 886954, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12150.054794520547, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.181818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 500993, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4473.151785714285, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1774390, "stage_ordering_ns": 460, "stage_eval_ns": 252171, "stage_threat_ns": 24615577, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 537, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 23085642, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1076654, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12070, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 263, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 384071, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69210, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 15358, "avg_search_time_ms": 1396.1818181818182, "search_nodes": 156274, "safety_nodes": 196, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 156470, "avg_nodes": 14224.545454545454, "eval_calls": 125536, "avg_eval_calls": 11412.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 125536, "pattern_eval_ns": 2698485, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.495706410910017, "pattern_frame_queries": 125536, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2698485, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.495706410910017, "pattern_frame_updates": 312450, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4092787394, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13099.015503280525, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29013, "avg_candidate_generations": 2637.5454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 2241440, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.25640230241616, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 680, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 29002, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2240760, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1319906, "avg_legality_checks": 119991.45454545454, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10756, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1319906, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10756, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4592880, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 417534.54545454547, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9415691475, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2050.06259144589, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35307, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3209.7272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 334292972, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9468.17832157929, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10756, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 114261630, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17594, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 177663023, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6912, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41848006, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 520313, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 202202, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18382.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2229067435, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11023.963338641557, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 306174, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27834.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1190152880, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3887.1781405344673, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3339158886, "stage_ordering_ns": 899085632, "stage_eval_ns": 4095485879, "stage_threat_ns": 6966752677, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 693691, "root_tactical_annotations": 2456, "search_tactical_annotations": 691235, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 312461, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1895881751, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 586785, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4773369572, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58074, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2066588160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 156225, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 234138966, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 312450, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40187560, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 222006, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1195037597, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 306696, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1511689225, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 164989, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23174828, "child_limit_applications": 29002, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29002, "child_cap_hits": 29002, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29002, "child_moves_before_total": 2230004, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2230004, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 511864, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 511864, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.89138680091028, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.64926556789187, "tt_hits": 11714, "tt_cutoffs": 1687, "beta_cutoffs": 20891, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3255.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3863.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1867, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 134, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7400, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 81, 65, 129, 145, 80, 79, 127, 93, 51, 108, 109, 63, 47, 78, 48, 123 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7362, "avg_search_time_ms": 736.2, "search_nodes": 98436, "safety_nodes": 228, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 98664, "avg_nodes": 9866.4, "eval_calls": 76309, "avg_eval_calls": 7630.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 76309, "pattern_eval_ns": 1548425, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.291512141424995, "pattern_frame_queries": 76309, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1548425, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.291512141424995, "pattern_frame_updates": 196788, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2100927583, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10676.096017033558, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20861, "avg_candidate_generations": 2086.1, "candidate_moves_total": 1600349, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.71487464646948, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 638, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 20851, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1599711, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 575429, "avg_legality_checks": 57542.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 226, "root_legality_checks": 638, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 574791, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 225, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1982370, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 198237.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4192153168, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2114.717821597381, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19615, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1961.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 76614832, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3905.9307672699465, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 624, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2980838, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10702, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57411401, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8284, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16167303, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55290, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47136, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4713.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 381034787, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8083.731903428377, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 60607, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6060.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 156646967, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2584.6348936591485, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1367703445, "stage_ordering_ns": 613509246, "stage_eval_ns": 2102476008, "stage_threat_ns": 3242970899, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 312158, "root_tactical_annotations": 1929, "search_tactical_annotations": 310229, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 196798, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1092868110, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 274781, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1982077084, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41763, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1400768788, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 98394, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 135527063, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 196788, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23070299, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 89610, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 75171066, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 143400, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 506000009, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79148, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9428343, "child_limit_applications": 20851, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20851, "child_cap_hits": 20851, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20851, "child_moves_before_total": 1599486, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1599486, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 333667, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 333667, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.71027768452352, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002445925854875, "tt_hits": 9140, "tt_cutoffs": 1234, "beta_cutoffs": 15826, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4792.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5592.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1298, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 820, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 887, "avg_nodes": 98.55555555555556, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 45430, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 783.2758620689655, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 580, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10442, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1160.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21018543, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2012.884792185405, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.1111111111111112, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64351, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6435.1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 64351, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3670, "stage_ordering_ns": 500, "stage_eval_ns": 45430, "stage_threat_ns": 16681545, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16388012, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 191222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9440, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87180, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15131, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 135, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18424, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 115, 116, 129, 95, 143, 63, 79, 101, 157, 171, 128, 86, 158, 173, 131, 172, 130, 132, 174, 56, 71, 170, 169, 100, 144, 159, 160, 96, 176 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 63, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.9375, "search_nodes": 360, "safety_nodes": 1715, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2075, "avg_nodes": 129.6875, "eval_calls": 344, "avg_eval_calls": 21.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 344, "line_shape_eval_ns": 316080, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 918.8372093023256, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1410, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.125, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1410, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1410, "avg_legality_checks": 88.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 1410, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20547, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1284.1875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 42062809, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2047.1508736068527, "renju_forbidden_checks": 165, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.3125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1775083, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10758.078787878789, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 339821, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 135, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1435262, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.8125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1103234, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11862.731182795698, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 589640, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4303.941605839416, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3795020, "stage_ordering_ns": 800, "stage_eval_ns": 316080, "stage_threat_ns": 34851859, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 704, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 32877658, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1411107, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16440, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 476944, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 86150, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 16, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 16, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6747.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7247.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 18349, "avg_search_time_ms": 1223.2666666666667, "search_nodes": 104190, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 105106, "avg_nodes": 7007.066666666667, "eval_calls": 70669, "avg_eval_calls": 4711.266666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70669, "pattern_eval_ns": 1572884, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.257057549986556, "pattern_frame_queries": 70669, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1572884, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.257057549986556, "pattern_frame_updates": 208238, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2847433324, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13673.937148839308, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30916, "avg_candidate_generations": 2061.0666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 3179426, "avg_candidate_moves": 102.84079441066115, "candidate_moves_max": 141, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1313, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 30901, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3178113, "search_candidate_moves_max": 141, "legality_checks": 2498495, "avg_legality_checks": 166566.33333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 51301, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2498495, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 51301, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5569974, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 371331.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11269928411, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2023.3359098265091, "renju_forbidden_checks": 189048, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12603.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1979653204, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10471.696098345394, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 57803, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 755974007, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 40825, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 503070823, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 90249, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 718704042, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 171, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1904332, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 289902, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19326.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3464778256, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11951.550027250589, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 433569, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 28904.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1934050597, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4460.767714020144, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6585549889, "stage_ordering_ns": 1180976390, "stage_eval_ns": 2849006208, "stage_threat_ns": 7621275973, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 784909, "root_tactical_annotations": 2933, "search_tactical_annotations": 781976, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 208253, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1240616304, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 655781, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6165910216, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61903, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2184833594, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 104119, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159841501, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 208238, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26126189, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 294363, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1951041795, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 299506, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2029896647, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 191040, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28781763, "child_limit_applications": 30901, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30901, "child_cap_hits": 30901, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30901, "child_moves_before_total": 3126812, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3126812, "child_moves_before_max": 139, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 139, "child_moves_after_total": 512671, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 512671, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 101.18805216659655, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.59075758066082, "tt_hits": 14833, "tt_cutoffs": 2549, "beta_cutoffs": 26302, "depth_sum": 71, "avg_depth": 4.733333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 71, "avg_effective_depth": 4.733333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5794.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6327.466666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1865, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 136, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10350, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 115, 128, 158, 144, 96, 100, 142, 129, 99, 97, 81, 145, 161, 174, 159, 160, 176, 146, 147, 132, 118, 188 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 10299, "avg_search_time_ms": 792.2307692307693, "search_nodes": 131778, "safety_nodes": 742, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 132520, "avg_nodes": 10193.846153846154, "eval_calls": 106108, "avg_eval_calls": 8162.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 106108, "pattern_eval_ns": 2304126, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.714913107400008, "pattern_frame_queries": 106108, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2304126, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.714913107400008, "pattern_frame_updates": 263442, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3090470051, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11731.121275271216, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24616, "avg_candidate_generations": 1893.5384615384614, "candidate_moves_total": 1778771, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.2607653558661, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 785, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 24603, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1777986, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 724291, "avg_legality_checks": 55714.692307692305, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1485, "root_legality_checks": 785, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 723506, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1484, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2573136, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 197933.53846153847, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5867425362, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2280.2624354095547, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22088, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1699.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 131052147, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5933.183040565013, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1587, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17141754, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11661, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 94183788, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8833, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19663504, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 63101, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67054, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5158.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 602929703, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8991.703746234378, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86282, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6637.076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 252291543, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2924.034479961058, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1843879273, "stage_ordering_ns": 781893913, "stage_eval_ns": 3092774177, "stage_threat_ns": 4541198800, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 298440, "root_tactical_annotations": 2027, "search_tactical_annotations": 296413, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 263455, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1561672883, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 279550, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2741811508, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49288, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1892100371, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 131721, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 195571036, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 263442, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33307756, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70209, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 129873726, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 160041, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 719357138, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 68190, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8835617, "child_limit_applications": 24603, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24603, "child_cap_hits": 24603, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24603, "child_moves_before_total": 1776502, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1776502, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 393997, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 393997, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.20672275738731, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.014185261959923, "tt_hits": 9755, "tt_cutoffs": 1010, "beta_cutoffs": 17643, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4363.846153846154, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4979.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1036, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1666666666666665, "search_nodes": 129, "safety_nodes": 876, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1005, "avg_nodes": 83.75, "eval_calls": 117, "avg_eval_calls": 9.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 117, "line_shape_eval_ns": 95271, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 814.2820512820513, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 717, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.75, "candidate_moves_max": 75, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 717, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13604, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1133.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28307780, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2080.8423992943253, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.3333333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50060, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12515.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 50060, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5010, "stage_ordering_ns": 690, "stage_eval_ns": 95271, "stage_threat_ns": 23247852, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 246, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22789276, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 256904, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 117, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 170602, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 234, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 137, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17772, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 157, 172, 141, 83, 125, 55, 69, 173, 109, 93, 126, 174, 124, 123, 171, 108, 156, 186, 138, 175, 176, 78, 63, 158, 140, 139, 154, 98, 168 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 65, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0625, "search_nodes": 360, "safety_nodes": 1710, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2070, "avg_nodes": 129.375, "eval_calls": 344, "avg_eval_calls": 21.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 344, "line_shape_eval_ns": 319744, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 929.4883720930233, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1405, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.8125, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1405, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1405, "avg_legality_checks": 87.8125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 1405, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20542, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1283.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 43016357, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2094.068591179048, "renju_forbidden_checks": 165, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.3125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2028849, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12296.054545454546, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 399232, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 135, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1629617, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.8125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1091976, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11741.677419354839, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 578965, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4226.021897810219, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3945118, "stage_ordering_ns": 820, "stage_eval_ns": 319744, "stage_threat_ns": 35839526, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 704, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 33844880, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1402356, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 500720, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 91570, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 16, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 16, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6747.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7247.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 17695, "avg_search_time_ms": 1179.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 106051, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 106967, "avg_nodes": 7131.133333333333, "eval_calls": 72581, "avg_eval_calls": 4838.733333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72581, "pattern_eval_ns": 1652451, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.766991361375567, "pattern_frame_queries": 72581, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1652451, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.766991361375567, "pattern_frame_updates": 211960, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2820707842, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13307.736563502547, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30807, "avg_candidate_generations": 2053.8, "candidate_moves_total": 3124394, "avg_candidate_moves": 101.41831401954101, "candidate_moves_max": 139, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1313, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 30792, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3123081, "search_candidate_moves_max": 139, "legality_checks": 2376455, "avg_legality_checks": 158430.33333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 33810, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2376455, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 33810, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5495780, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 366385.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11114709536, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2022.4080177881938, "renju_forbidden_checks": 154118, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10274.533333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1246071477, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8085.178090813532, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 41036, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 550596240, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 31368, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 397225372, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 81543, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 295980804, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 171, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2269061, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 272336, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18155.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3125307987, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11475.92674857529, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 424258, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 28283.866666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1651601888, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3892.918667414639, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6183892050, "stage_ordering_ns": 1206180771, "stage_eval_ns": 2822360293, "stage_threat_ns": 7384004959, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 775115, "root_tactical_annotations": 2933, "search_tactical_annotations": 772182, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 211975, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1303190997, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 631615, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5856142407, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61685, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2223513566, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 105980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 164823775, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 211960, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27356391, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 278010, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1753120743, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 291911, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1879364468, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 205194, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32491389, "child_limit_applications": 30792, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30792, "child_cap_hits": 30792, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30792, "child_moves_before_total": 3089271, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3089271, "child_moves_before_max": 138, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 138, "child_moves_after_total": 533653, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 533653, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 100.32706547155105, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.330897635749544, "tt_hits": 14978, "tt_cutoffs": 2607, "beta_cutoffs": 26106, "depth_sum": 71, "avg_depth": 4.733333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 71, "avg_effective_depth": 4.733333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5834.733333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6368.066666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1621, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 138, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10014, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 97, 127, 126, 143, 159, 95, 79, 113, 158, 98, 83, 110, 157, 156, 144, 96, 174, 190, 129, 114, 189 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9967, "avg_search_time_ms": 906.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 118039, "safety_nodes": 416, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 118455, "avg_nodes": 10768.636363636364, "eval_calls": 93388, "avg_eval_calls": 8489.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 93388, "pattern_eval_ns": 2037893, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.821786525035336, "pattern_frame_queries": 93388, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2037893, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.821786525035336, "pattern_frame_updates": 235984, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2998953286, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12708.290757000475, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23067, "avg_candidate_generations": 2097.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1668834, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.3472493172064, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 681, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 23056, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1668153, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 764205, "avg_legality_checks": 69473.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 260, "root_legality_checks": 681, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 763524, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 260, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2615738, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 237794.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5932313197, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2267.9309613577507, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15547, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1413.3636363636363, "renju_forbidden_ns": 47078650, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3028.150125426127, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 332, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1678281, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7312, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34665245, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7903, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10735124, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67415, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6128.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 594806837, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8823.063665356374, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92427, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8402.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 246531183, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2667.3069882177288, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1942529737, "stage_ordering_ns": 726147314, "stage_eval_ns": 3000991179, "stage_threat_ns": 4260834156, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 326856, "root_tactical_annotations": 1561, "search_tactical_annotations": 325295, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 235995, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1417080803, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 310022, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2628258492, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46180, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1761972933, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 117992, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 177316619, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 235984, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30395201, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 82911, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 123477220, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 180923, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 742556868, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 63022, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7783041, "child_limit_applications": 23056, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23056, "child_cap_hits": 23056, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23056, "child_moves_before_total": 1667893, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1667893, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 369152, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 369152, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.34095246356696, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.011103400416378, "tt_hits": 7931, "tt_cutoffs": 1549, "beta_cutoffs": 16911, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4608.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5335.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 34, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4, "search_nodes": 254, "safety_nodes": 635, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 889, "avg_nodes": 88.9, "eval_calls": 244, "avg_eval_calls": 24.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 244, "line_shape_eval_ns": 226811, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 929.5532786885246, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 628, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.8, "candidate_moves_max": 80, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 628, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11593, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24725062, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2132.75787112913, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4030, "stage_ordering_ns": 530, "stage_eval_ns": 226811, "stage_threat_ns": 21966275, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 498, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21351273, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 186960, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11050, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 244, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 364031, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 488, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64011, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 139, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18516, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 109, 108, 95, 129, 81, 145, 161, 123, 67, 53, 96, 138, 66, 51, 93, 52, 94, 92, 50, 153, 168, 54, 55, 124, 80, 65, 64, 128, 48 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 64, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 360, "safety_nodes": 1703, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2063, "avg_nodes": 128.9375, "eval_calls": 344, "avg_eval_calls": 21.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 344, "line_shape_eval_ns": 321101, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 933.4331395348837, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1398, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.375, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1398, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1398, "avg_legality_checks": 87.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 1398, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20523, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1282.6875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 43041844, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2097.249135116698, "renju_forbidden_checks": 165, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.3125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2280580, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 13821.69696969697, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 442710, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 135, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1837870, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.8125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1097447, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11800.505376344086, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 589505, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4302.956204379562, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3962542, "stage_ordering_ns": 780, "stage_eval_ns": 321101, "stage_threat_ns": 36110851, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 704, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 34117272, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1406438, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16771, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 497331, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 89810, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 16, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 16, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6747.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7247.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 18437, "avg_search_time_ms": 1229.1333333333334, "search_nodes": 106730, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 107646, "avg_nodes": 7176.4, "eval_calls": 72529, "avg_eval_calls": 4835.266666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72529, "pattern_eval_ns": 1640774, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.622316590605138, "pattern_frame_queries": 72529, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1640774, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.622316590605138, "pattern_frame_updates": 213318, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3101639510, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14539.98026420649, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31426, "avg_candidate_generations": 2095.0666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 3238687, "avg_candidate_moves": 103.0575638006746, "candidate_moves_max": 139, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1313, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 31411, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3237374, "search_candidate_moves_max": 139, "legality_checks": 2520522, "avg_legality_checks": 168034.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 40918, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2520522, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 40918, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5865860, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 391057.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11431264353, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1948.7789263637387, "renju_forbidden_checks": 187704, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12513.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1742819971, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9284.937832971062, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 49529, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 666492967, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 41825, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 562764861, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 96179, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 511053637, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 171, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2508506, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 292350, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19490.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3327090948, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11380.506064648538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 453138, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 30209.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1756906877, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3877.2004930065455, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6452064205, "stage_ordering_ns": 1178151317, "stage_eval_ns": 3103280284, "stage_threat_ns": 7599794523, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 818511, "root_tactical_annotations": 2933, "search_tactical_annotations": 815578, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 213333, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1291043597, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 678838, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6088729713, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62923, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2220049278, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 106659, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 163285709, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 213318, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26944127, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 285640, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1695699920, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 330266, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2172835654, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 202605, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 29791377, "child_limit_applications": 31411, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31411, "child_cap_hits": 31411, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31411, "child_moves_before_total": 3196456, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3196456, "child_moves_before_max": 138, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 138, "child_moves_after_total": 542313, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 542313, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 101.76231256566172, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.26506637802044, "tt_hits": 14665, "tt_cutoffs": 2720, "beta_cutoffs": 26703, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5821.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6355.133333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1881, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 140, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 35298, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 129, 109, 95, 81, 65, 125, 127, 79, 80, 50, 64, 96, 66, 63, 94, 108, 143, 159, 157, 115, 142, 172, 141, 140, 156, 171, 170, 128, 154, 158, 186, 138, 184, 198, 185, 187, 183, 182, 169, 155, 139, 124, 199 ], "move_count": 49, "black_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 35211, "avg_search_time_ms": 1530.9130434782608, "search_nodes": 525968, "safety_nodes": 296, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 526264, "avg_nodes": 22881.043478260868, "eval_calls": 427357, "avg_eval_calls": 18580.739130434784, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 427357, "pattern_eval_ns": 9148411, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.406952501070535, "pattern_frame_queries": 427357, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 9148411, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.406952501070535, "pattern_frame_updates": 1051722, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 11045456399, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10502.258580689573, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 93719, "avg_candidate_generations": 4074.7391304347825, "candidate_moves_total": 8426196, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.90915396024285, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1813, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 93696, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8424383, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 3212459, "avg_legality_checks": 139672.13043478262, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3665, "root_legality_checks": 1813, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 3210646, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10514052, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 457132.6956521739, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19755924066, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1879.0019362658659, "renju_forbidden_checks": 73635, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3201.521739130435, "renju_forbidden_ns": 199278369, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2706.2995722143, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5072, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13396219, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 38012, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 140199771, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30546, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45676318, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6061, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 313478, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13629.478260869566, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1986753252, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6337.775703558144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 373447, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16236.826086956522, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 644937650, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1726.9857570150516, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6706988786, "stage_ordering_ns": 2763233717, "stage_eval_ns": 11054604810, "stage_threat_ns": 14515844142, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2192669, "root_tactical_annotations": 8084, "search_tactical_annotations": 2184585, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1051745, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5493466282, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1921814, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8119634970, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 187544, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4957016137, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 525861, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 721406394, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1051722, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 121997075, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 859544, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 796651379, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 874704, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2365829464, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 458421, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 59339421, "child_limit_applications": 93696, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 93696, "child_cap_hits": 93696, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 93696, "child_moves_before_total": 8420719, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8420719, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 1501009, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1501009, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.87276938183061, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01999018101093, "tt_hits": 39533, "tt_cutoffs": 4808, "beta_cutoffs": 65636, "depth_sum": 107, "avg_depth": 4.6521739130434785, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 107, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6521739130434785, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21739130434782608, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5159.739130434783, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5507.565217391304, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1029, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 64, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.909090909090909, "search_nodes": 252, "safety_nodes": 2429, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2681, "avg_nodes": 121.86363636363636, "eval_calls": 230, "avg_eval_calls": 10.454545454545455, "line_shape_eval_calls": 230, "line_shape_eval_ns": 248912, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1082.2260869565218, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1733, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.77272727272727, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1733, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24877, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1130.7727272727273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 47972229, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1928.3767737267356, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.18181818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5010, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1252.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5010, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14111, "stage_ordering_ns": 1280, "stage_eval_ns": 248912, "stage_threat_ns": 39911891, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 482, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 39044405, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 523444, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 23470, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 292892, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51150, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7089.318181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7452.954545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 141, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16993, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 67, 52, 83, 141, 99, 155, 169, 51, 115, 131, 98, 50, 100, 101, 53, 116, 68, 38, 86, 48, 49, 146, 161, 66, 84, 85, 70, 126, 56 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 53, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3125, "search_nodes": 360, "safety_nodes": 1708, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2068, "avg_nodes": 129.25, "eval_calls": 344, "avg_eval_calls": 21.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 344, "line_shape_eval_ns": 294141, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 855.0610465116279, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1403, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.6875, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1403, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1403, "avg_legality_checks": 87.6875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 1403, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20528, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1283.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 37295744, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1816.8230709275135, "renju_forbidden_checks": 165, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.3125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1713439, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10384.478787878788, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 335512, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 135, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1377927, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.8125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 912933, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9816.483870967742, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 490053, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3577.029197080292, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3384937, "stage_ordering_ns": 670, "stage_eval_ns": 294141, "stage_threat_ns": 31536841, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 704, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 29803131, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1175905, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14720, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 475934, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 81871, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 16, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 16, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6748.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7248.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 16925, "avg_search_time_ms": 1128.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 110741, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 111657, "avg_nodes": 7443.8, "eval_calls": 74673, "avg_eval_calls": 4978.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74673, "pattern_eval_ns": 1504025, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.141483534878738, "pattern_frame_queries": 74673, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1504025, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.141483534878738, "pattern_frame_updates": 221340, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2686780769, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12138.704115839884, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33145, "avg_candidate_generations": 2209.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 3375788, "avg_candidate_moves": 101.84908734349072, "candidate_moves_max": 136, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1313, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 33130, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3374475, "search_candidate_moves_max": 136, "legality_checks": 2679245, "avg_legality_checks": 178616.33333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 59901, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2679245, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 59901, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6041655, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 402777.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10300063700, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1704.8414217627455, "renju_forbidden_checks": 209743, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 13982.866666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1940250258, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9250.607924936709, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 66131, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 766359754, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 48446, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 505254629, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 94995, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 666854975, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 171, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1780900, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 317857, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 21190.466666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3153638080, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9921.562463623579, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 472247, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31483.133333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1756771731, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3720.0272971559375, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6071999923, "stage_ordering_ns": 1079251920, "stage_eval_ns": 2688284794, "stage_threat_ns": 6974345480, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 835781, "root_tactical_annotations": 2933, "search_tactical_annotations": 832848, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 221355, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1135171712, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 708941, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5637797784, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 66361, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2002262745, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 110670, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 147392095, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 221340, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24140310, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 305066, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1681235746, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 337505, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1954167763, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 193210, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 29843579, "child_limit_applications": 33130, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33130, "child_cap_hits": 33130, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33130, "child_moves_before_total": 3314574, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3314574, "child_moves_before_max": 134, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 134, "child_moves_after_total": 549902, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 549902, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 100.04750980984002, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.59830968910353, "tt_hits": 15183, "tt_cutoffs": 2867, "beta_cutoffs": 28268, "depth_sum": 71, "avg_depth": 4.733333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 71, "avg_effective_depth": 4.733333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5964.466666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6497.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1883, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 142, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25202, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 84, 97, 98, 70, 114, 66, 81, 80, 129, 99, 130, 146, 131, 132, 127, 128, 115, 147, 143, 101, 159, 111, 160, 175, 157, 171, 158, 161, 156 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 25143, "avg_search_time_ms": 1676.2, "search_nodes": 323842, "safety_nodes": 96, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 323938, "avg_nodes": 21595.866666666665, "eval_calls": 265446, "avg_eval_calls": 17696.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 265446, "pattern_eval_ns": 5579862, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.020704776112655, "pattern_frame_queries": 265446, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5579862, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.020704776112655, "pattern_frame_updates": 647550, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8372116137, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12928.91072040769, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 55690, "avg_candidate_generations": 3712.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 4625961, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.06627760818819, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1082, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 55675, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4624879, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 1916368, "avg_legality_checks": 127757.86666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3589, "root_legality_checks": 1082, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1915286, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3588, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6726382, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 448425.4666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14425217592, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2144.5730545782267, "renju_forbidden_checks": 115404, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7693.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 419423419, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3634.3923867456933, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5507, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 28491459, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 68645, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 311774622, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 41247, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 79104788, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 52550, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 202208, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13480.533333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1607363105, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7949.057925502453, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 256919, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17127.933333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 591822943, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2303.5390259186747, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4548655825, "stage_ordering_ns": 1825083691, "stage_eval_ns": 8377695999, "stage_threat_ns": 10305400356, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1097225, "root_tactical_annotations": 4538, "search_tactical_annotations": 1092687, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 647565, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3708270546, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 978181, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6008245246, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 111446, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3666348463, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 323775, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 476527542, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 647550, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 81051127, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 377972, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 503602070, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 488749, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1838279953, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 230504, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 31305895, "child_limit_applications": 55675, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 55675, "child_cap_hits": 55675, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 55675, "child_moves_before_total": 4621291, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4621291, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 900101, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 900101, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.00477772788504, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.167058823529413, "tt_hits": 21825, "tt_cutoffs": 2654, "beta_cutoffs": 38475, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2159.266666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2489.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 436, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 44, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.142857142857143, "search_nodes": 163, "safety_nodes": 1407, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1570, "avg_nodes": 112.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 149, "avg_eval_calls": 10.642857142857142, "line_shape_eval_calls": 149, "line_shape_eval_ns": 175732, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1179.4093959731545, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1005, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.78571428571429, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1005, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16149, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1153.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 33136472, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2051.9209858195554, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65440, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4674.285714285715, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 65440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6420, "stage_ordering_ns": 790, "stage_eval_ns": 175732, "stage_threat_ns": 27114422, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 312, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 26537629, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 321862, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15020, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 149, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 216581, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 298, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38350, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6569.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7140.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 143, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19920, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 109, 108, 125, 99, 141, 71, 85, 93, 157, 173, 126, 78, 156, 171, 123, 172, 124, 122, 170, 48, 63, 174, 175, 94, 140, 155, 154, 98, 168 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 64, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 360, "safety_nodes": 1715, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2075, "avg_nodes": 129.6875, "eval_calls": 344, "avg_eval_calls": 21.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 344, "line_shape_eval_ns": 318980, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 927.2674418604652, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1410, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.125, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1410, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1410, "avg_legality_checks": 88.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 1410, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20547, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1284.1875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 42747891, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2080.4930646809753, "renju_forbidden_checks": 165, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.3125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1817921, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11017.70303030303, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 353101, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 135, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1464820, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.8125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1085427, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11671.258064516129, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 578573, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4223.160583941606, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3851437, "stage_ordering_ns": 830, "stage_eval_ns": 318980, "stage_threat_ns": 35765271, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 704, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 33767992, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1394788, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16831, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 512961, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 89530, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 16, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 16, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6747.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7247.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 19842, "avg_search_time_ms": 1322.8, "search_nodes": 109329, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 110245, "avg_nodes": 7349.666666666667, "eval_calls": 73502, "avg_eval_calls": 4900.133333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73502, "pattern_eval_ns": 1664286, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.642730810045986, "pattern_frame_queries": 73502, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1664286, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.642730810045986, "pattern_frame_updates": 218516, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3029166208, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13862.445807172015, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33067, "avg_candidate_generations": 2204.4666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 3385145, "avg_candidate_moves": 102.37230471467022, "candidate_moves_max": 139, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1313, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 33052, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3383832, "search_candidate_moves_max": 139, "legality_checks": 2694980, "avg_legality_checks": 179665.33333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 60033, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2694980, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 60033, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6021869, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 401457.93333333335, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12237867404, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2032.2374007139645, "renju_forbidden_checks": 199914, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 13327.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2101133653, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10510.187645687645, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 65997, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 888989253, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 43156, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 523380604, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 90590, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 686794124, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 171, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1969672, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 316635, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 21109.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3721127356, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11752.10370300188, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 468782, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31252.133333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2044267530, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4360.806366285395, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7206850439, "stage_ordering_ns": 1300693728, "stage_eval_ns": 3030830494, "stage_threat_ns": 8194497249, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 825907, "root_tactical_annotations": 2933, "search_tactical_annotations": 822974, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 218531, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1311182994, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 700909, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6654725939, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 66205, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2365713319, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 109258, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 171806092, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 218516, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27820978, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 300281, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1992199455, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 334414, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2296669605, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 191212, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28961246, "child_limit_applications": 33052, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33052, "child_cap_hits": 33052, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33052, "child_moves_before_total": 3323799, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3323799, "child_moves_before_max": 137, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 137, "child_moves_after_total": 548597, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 548597, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 100.56271935132519, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.5979970954859, "tt_hits": 14955, "tt_cutoffs": 2705, "beta_cutoffs": 28252, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5525.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6059.133333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1868, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 144, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9202, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 141, 109, 126, 156, 140, 98, 139, 142, 95, 155, 125, 80, 153, 97, 167 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9171, "avg_search_time_ms": 1019.0, "search_nodes": 134907, "safety_nodes": 66, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 134973, "avg_nodes": 14997.0, "eval_calls": 110076, "avg_eval_calls": 12230.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110076, "pattern_eval_ns": 2144976, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.48631854355173, "pattern_frame_queries": 110076, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2144976, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.48631854355173, "pattern_frame_updates": 269740, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2886081277, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10699.493130421888, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23880, "avg_candidate_generations": 2653.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 1717851, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.93680904522613, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 498, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 23871, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1717353, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 767679, "avg_legality_checks": 85297.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2853, "root_legality_checks": 498, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 767181, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2851, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2699860, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 299984.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5223797472, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1934.8401294881958, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33261, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3695.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 167202135, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5026.972580499684, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3100, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 28804048, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16499, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 109247838, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13652, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29045699, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 104550, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72557, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8061.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 567569377, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7822.393111622587, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95378, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10597.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 242055840, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2537.8582062949527, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1665885212, "stage_ordering_ns": 652252228, "stage_eval_ns": 2888226253, "stage_threat_ns": 3927053124, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 277849, "root_tactical_annotations": 1903, "search_tactical_annotations": 275946, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 269749, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1376146985, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 264997, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2339269377, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47796, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1554741143, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 174924941, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 269740, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29634608, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 55982, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 107260213, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 161211, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 677260791, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 60656, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7077213, "child_limit_applications": 23871, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23871, "child_cap_hits": 23871, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23871, "child_moves_before_total": 1714502, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1714502, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 381959, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 381959, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.8236353734657, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00096351221147, "tt_hits": 8947, "tt_cutoffs": 923, "beta_cutoffs": 16621, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3252.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4141.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1155, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 24, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0, "search_nodes": 121, "safety_nodes": 546, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 667, "avg_nodes": 83.375, "eval_calls": 113, "avg_eval_calls": 14.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 113, "line_shape_eval_ns": 64232, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 568.4247787610619, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 441, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.125, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 441, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9149, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1143.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16589757, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1813.2863700950923, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 83960, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10495.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 83960, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2660, "stage_ordering_ns": 390, "stage_eval_ns": 64232, "stage_threat_ns": 13895999, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 234, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 13582978, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 160151, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7540, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 113, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 129650, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 226, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23220, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5496.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6496.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 145, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16921, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 115, 116, 99, 125, 83, 139, 153, 131, 67, 51, 98, 146, 68, 53, 101, 52, 100, 102, 54, 161, 176, 50, 49, 130, 84, 69, 70, 126, 56 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 57, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5625, "search_nodes": 360, "safety_nodes": 1703, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2063, "avg_nodes": 128.9375, "eval_calls": 344, "avg_eval_calls": 21.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 344, "line_shape_eval_ns": 294680, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 856.6279069767442, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1398, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.375, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1398, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1398, "avg_legality_checks": 87.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 1398, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20523, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1282.6875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 39904109, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1944.3604248891488, "renju_forbidden_checks": 165, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.3125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1987750, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12046.969696969696, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 389863, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 135, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1597887, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.8125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1009556, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10855.440860215054, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 539214, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3935.868613138686, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3618979, "stage_ordering_ns": 710, "stage_eval_ns": 294680, "stage_threat_ns": 33444860, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 704, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 31592119, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1296867, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15540, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 472672, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 83202, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 16, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 16, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6747.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7247.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 16847, "avg_search_time_ms": 1123.1333333333334, "search_nodes": 103729, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 104645, "avg_nodes": 6976.333333333333, "eval_calls": 70570, "avg_eval_calls": 4704.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70570, "pattern_eval_ns": 1465866, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.77180104860422, "pattern_frame_queries": 70570, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1465866, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.77180104860422, "pattern_frame_updates": 207316, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2823301813, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13618.349828281463, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30431, "avg_candidate_generations": 2028.7333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 3125753, "avg_candidate_moves": 102.7160789983898, "candidate_moves_max": 139, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1313, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 30416, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3124440, "search_candidate_moves_max": 139, "legality_checks": 2404713, "avg_legality_checks": 160314.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 36049, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2404713, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 36049, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5624532, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 374968.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10380747453, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1845.6197694314833, "renju_forbidden_checks": 179127, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11941.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1606299762, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8967.379356545915, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 45096, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 609726227, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 38424, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 510269249, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 95436, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 484088852, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 171, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2215434, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 283110, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18874.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3063090357, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10819.43540320017, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 438183, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 29212.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1620991763, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3699.3488177314043, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5849662719, "stage_ordering_ns": 1102706882, "stage_eval_ns": 2824767679, "stage_threat_ns": 6952406206, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 798487, "root_tactical_annotations": 2933, "search_tactical_annotations": 795554, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 207331, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1177804576, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 653649, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5573143069, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60933, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2026962431, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 103658, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 147607546, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 207316, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24603254, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 280650, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1620045226, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 312057, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1926003812, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 205780, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 29247761, "child_limit_applications": 30416, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30416, "child_cap_hits": 30416, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30416, "child_moves_before_total": 3088391, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3088391, "child_moves_before_max": 138, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 138, "child_moves_after_total": 529615, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 529615, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 101.53836796422935, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.412381641241453, "tt_hits": 14972, "tt_cutoffs": 2672, "beta_cutoffs": 25840, "depth_sum": 71, "avg_depth": 4.733333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 71, "avg_effective_depth": 4.733333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6047.933333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6581.266666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1886, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 146, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14555, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 125, 115, 127, 83, 99, 69, 55, 85, 141, 155, 157, 109, 142, 172, 143, 140, 144, 145, 129, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 14509, "avg_search_time_ms": 1209.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 201135, "safety_nodes": 150, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 201285, "avg_nodes": 16773.75, "eval_calls": 162655, "avg_eval_calls": 13554.583333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 162655, "pattern_eval_ns": 3246658, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.96039470043958, "pattern_frame_queries": 162655, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3246658, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.96039470043958, "pattern_frame_updates": 402166, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4318259674, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10737.505592218138, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 36508, "avg_candidate_generations": 3042.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 3084530, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.4891530623425, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 843, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 36496, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3083687, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1256643, "avg_legality_checks": 104720.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1741, "root_legality_checks": 843, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1255800, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1740, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3959375, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 329947.9166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8276572076, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2090.373373575375, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32805, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2733.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 142738095, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4351.1079103795155, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1917, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15130088, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18826, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 103598530, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12057, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23966897, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 42580, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89436, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7453.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 800911622, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8955.136880003578, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 130251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10854.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 368888473, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2832.1354384995125, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2899547571, "stage_ordering_ns": 1200264383, "stage_eval_ns": 4321506332, "stage_threat_ns": 6023812484, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 530375, "root_tactical_annotations": 3110, "search_tactical_annotations": 527265, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 402178, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2165012949, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 483008, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3529357425, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 73067, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2370753283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 201083, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 267578037, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 402166, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46742336, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 156468, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 221247568, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 253463, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 937346864, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 120444, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15121737, "child_limit_applications": 36496, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 36496, "child_cap_hits": 36496, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 36496, "child_moves_before_total": 3081947, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3081947, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 584069, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 584069, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.44615848312144, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.003644234984655, "tt_hits": 14746, "tt_cutoffs": 1932, "beta_cutoffs": 25784, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4029.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4696.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1128, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1818181818181817, "search_nodes": 131, "safety_nodes": 995, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1126, "avg_nodes": 102.36363636363636, "eval_calls": 120, "avg_eval_calls": 10.909090909090908, "line_shape_eval_calls": 120, "line_shape_eval_ns": 84410, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 703.4166666666666, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 772, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.18181818181819, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 772, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12888, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1171.6363636363637, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24915207, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1933.2097299813781, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.36363636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37760, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9440.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 37760, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4460, "stage_ordering_ns": 460, "stage_eval_ns": 84410, "stage_threat_ns": 20441967, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 251, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20014557, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 234320, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 120, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 163580, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 240, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29510, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 147, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17805, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 157, 172, 143, 81, 129, 49, 65, 171, 115, 101, 128, 170, 130, 131, 173, 116, 158, 188, 146, 168, 169, 86, 71, 156, 144, 145, 160, 96, 176 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 60, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.75, "search_nodes": 360, "safety_nodes": 1715, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2075, "avg_nodes": 129.6875, "eval_calls": 344, "avg_eval_calls": 21.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 344, "line_shape_eval_ns": 302650, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 879.796511627907, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1410, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.125, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1410, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1410, "avg_legality_checks": 88.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 1410, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20547, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1284.1875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 40517500, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1971.9423760159634, "renju_forbidden_checks": 165, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.3125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1672311, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10135.218181818182, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 326082, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 135, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1346229, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.8125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1026416, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11036.731182795698, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 545365, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3980.7664233576643, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3653858, "stage_ordering_ns": 720, "stage_eval_ns": 302650, "stage_threat_ns": 33707424, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 704, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 31837792, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1321719, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16210, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 462322, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 85591, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 16, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 16, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6747.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7247.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 17731, "avg_search_time_ms": 1182.0666666666666, "search_nodes": 109330, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 110246, "avg_nodes": 7349.733333333334, "eval_calls": 74460, "avg_eval_calls": 4964.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74460, "pattern_eval_ns": 1562650, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.986435670158475, "pattern_frame_queries": 74460, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1562650, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.986435670158475, "pattern_frame_updates": 218518, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2753725234, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12601.823346360483, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32150, "avg_candidate_generations": 2143.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 3257653, "avg_candidate_moves": 101.32668740279938, "candidate_moves_max": 139, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1313, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 32135, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3256340, "search_candidate_moves_max": 139, "legality_checks": 2503271, "avg_legality_checks": 166884.73333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 51327, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2503271, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 51327, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5619747, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 374649.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10860176782, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1932.502794520821, "renju_forbidden_checks": 190959, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12730.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1875274702, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9820.30017961971, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 57851, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 699127751, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 41584, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 487037310, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 91353, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 687306060, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 171, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1803581, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 291488, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19432.533333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3305772849, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11341.025527637501, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 435996, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 29066.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1835888943, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4210.793087551262, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6255952456, "stage_ordering_ns": 1167175510, "stage_eval_ns": 2755287884, "stage_threat_ns": 7453179625, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 791020, "root_tactical_annotations": 2933, "search_tactical_annotations": 788087, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 218533, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1228770301, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 664956, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6013190834, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64371, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2214774160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 109259, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 158180857, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 218518, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26309418, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 297620, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1860352556, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 302956, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1937926558, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 190444, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26728215, "child_limit_applications": 32135, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32135, "child_cap_hits": 32135, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32135, "child_moves_before_total": 3205013, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3205013, "child_moves_before_max": 137, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 137, "child_moves_after_total": 532580, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 532580, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 99.73589544110783, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.573206783880504, "tt_hits": 15070, "tt_cutoffs": 2664, "beta_cutoffs": 27323, "depth_sum": 71, "avg_depth": 4.733333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 71, "avg_effective_depth": 4.733333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5821.866666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6355.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1651, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 148, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21369, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 97, 127, 128, 141, 155, 99, 85, 111, 156, 96, 81, 114, 154, 157, 170, 184, 138, 122, 185, 200, 153, 152, 168, 123, 125, 140, 167, 166, 169, 171, 137, 201, 121 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 21301, "avg_search_time_ms": 1253.0, "search_nodes": 262720, "safety_nodes": 609, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 263329, "avg_nodes": 15489.941176470587, "eval_calls": 210768, "avg_eval_calls": 12398.117647058823, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 210768, "pattern_eval_ns": 4412001, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.932973696196765, "pattern_frame_queries": 210768, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4412001, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.932973696196765, "pattern_frame_updates": 525286, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6893506044, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13123.338607920257, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49025, "avg_candidate_generations": 2883.823529411765, "candidate_moves_total": 4254006, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.77217746047934, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1269, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 49008, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4252737, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1686717, "avg_legality_checks": 99218.64705882352, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2553, "root_legality_checks": 1269, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1685448, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2551, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5826786, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 342752.1176470588, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12532658575, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2150.8698920811576, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42302, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2488.3529411764707, "renju_forbidden_ns": 197286655, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4663.766606779821, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2953, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24456084, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20861, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 136913994, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18478, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 35821456, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 95121, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 154624, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9095.529411764706, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1202772124, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7778.689750620861, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 200165, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11774.411764705883, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 484863442, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2422.318796992481, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4075373767, "stage_ordering_ns": 1649007875, "stage_eval_ns": 6897918045, "stage_threat_ns": 8600593637, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 897721, "root_tactical_annotations": 3980, "search_tactical_annotations": 893741, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 525303, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2971308347, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 823639, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5150108882, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 98126, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3319457158, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 262643, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 392044795, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 525286, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65256108, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 311737, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 331868650, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 413762, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1498441632, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 172222, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21875505, "child_limit_applications": 49008, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49008, "child_cap_hits": 49008, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49008, "child_moves_before_total": 4250186, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4250186, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 788255, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 788255, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.72433072151486, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.084210741103494, "tt_hits": 19507, "tt_cutoffs": 2867, "beta_cutoffs": 35200, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 4.470588235294118, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 4.470588235294118, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.29411764705882354, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5565.35294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6035.941176470588, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 51, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1875, "search_nodes": 203, "safety_nodes": 1652, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1855, "avg_nodes": 115.9375, "eval_calls": 187, "avg_eval_calls": 11.6875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 187, "line_shape_eval_ns": 164470, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 879.5187165775401, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1215, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.9375, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1215, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18390, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1149.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 37808869, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2055.947199564981, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 81531, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10191.375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 81531, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7430, "stage_ordering_ns": 880, "stage_eval_ns": 164470, "stage_threat_ns": 31221443, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 390, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 30567470, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 332373, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17211, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 187, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 274000, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 374, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47600, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 16, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 16, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6747.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7247.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 149, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17679, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 67, 52, 81, 143, 95, 159, 175, 53, 109, 123, 96, 54, 94, 93, 51, 108, 66, 36, 78, 55, 56, 138, 153, 68, 80, 79, 64, 128, 48 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 56, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5, "search_nodes": 360, "safety_nodes": 1703, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2063, "avg_nodes": 128.9375, "eval_calls": 344, "avg_eval_calls": 21.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 344, "line_shape_eval_ns": 235450, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 684.4476744186046, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1398, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.375, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1398, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1398, "avg_legality_checks": 87.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 1398, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20523, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1282.6875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 37719061, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1837.8921697607561, "renju_forbidden_checks": 165, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.3125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2136242, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12946.921212121211, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 425813, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 135, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1710429, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.8125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1014125, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10904.569892473119, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 544125, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3971.715328467153, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3542226, "stage_ordering_ns": 770, "stage_eval_ns": 235450, "stage_threat_ns": 31556150, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 704, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 29761362, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1314277, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14930, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 404241, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 76270, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 16, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 16, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6747.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7247.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 17609, "avg_search_time_ms": 1173.9333333333334, "search_nodes": 108637, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 109553, "avg_nodes": 7303.533333333334, "eval_calls": 73522, "avg_eval_calls": 4901.466666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73522, "pattern_eval_ns": 1585650, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.567013955006665, "pattern_frame_queries": 73522, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1585650, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.567013955006665, "pattern_frame_updates": 217132, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2895073440, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13333.241714717315, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32136, "avg_candidate_generations": 2142.4, "candidate_moves_total": 3262008, "avg_candidate_moves": 101.50634802091113, "candidate_moves_max": 134, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1313, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 32121, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3260695, "search_candidate_moves_max": 134, "legality_checks": 2555284, "avg_legality_checks": 170352.26666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 41413, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2555284, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 41413, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5968220, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 397881.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10963194338, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1836.9286551098987, "renju_forbidden_checks": 183295, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12219.666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1561880794, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8521.131476581468, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 49910, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 639786277, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 40101, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 492792959, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 93113, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 427001752, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 171, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2299806, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 300247, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 20016.466666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3159341249, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10522.473993079031, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 463378, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 30891.866666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1674145172, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3612.9146657804213, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6259379118, "stage_ordering_ns": 1139782789, "stage_eval_ns": 2896659090, "stage_threat_ns": 7204107045, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 827459, "root_tactical_annotations": 2933, "search_tactical_annotations": 824526, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 217147, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1219986460, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 688586, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5772252893, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64343, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2087756587, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108566, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 155604357, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 217132, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25992646, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 286035, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1643977608, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 338199, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2040414478, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 203225, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30270689, "child_limit_applications": 32121, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32121, "child_cap_hits": 32121, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32121, "child_moves_before_total": 3219282, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3219282, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 554295, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 554295, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 100.22359204258896, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.25646773139068, "tt_hits": 14861, "tt_cutoffs": 2924, "beta_cutoffs": 27334, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5846.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6380.133333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1849, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 150, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16257, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 127, 97, 96, 83, 69, 125, 139, 113, 128, 68, 53, 80, 129, 126, 101, 37, 115, 87, 130, 131, 160, 144, 145, 100, 175 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 16203, "avg_search_time_ms": 1246.3846153846155, "search_nodes": 191505, "safety_nodes": 439, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 191944, "avg_nodes": 14764.923076923076, "eval_calls": 152909, "avg_eval_calls": 11762.23076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 152909, "pattern_eval_ns": 3288263, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.504705413023434, "pattern_frame_queries": 152909, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3288263, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.504705413023434, "pattern_frame_updates": 382896, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5100932133, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13321.978116773224, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35954, "avg_candidate_generations": 2765.6923076923076, "candidate_moves_total": 3003221, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.5295377426712, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 950, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 35941, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3002271, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1315598, "avg_legality_checks": 101199.84615384616, "illegal_moves_skipped": 968, "root_legality_checks": 950, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1314648, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 968, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4344277, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 334175.1538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9643852926, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2219.898253725534, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45031, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3463.923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 158183460, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3512.7680930914257, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1436, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6056773, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25950, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 123966248, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17645, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28160439, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 122802, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9446.307692307691, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1050208825, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8552.049844465073, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 163115, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12547.307692307691, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 412590193, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2529.4436011403, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3244591247, "stage_ordering_ns": 1221081175, "stage_eval_ns": 5104220396, "stage_threat_ns": 6566333787, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 542171, "root_tactical_annotations": 2691, "search_tactical_annotations": 539480, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 382909, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2248921682, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 509456, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3972825876, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 71964, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2488275043, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 191448, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 281317057, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 382896, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48851634, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 154473, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 244432992, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 283009, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1239867139, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 104689, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14417538, "child_limit_applications": 35941, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35941, "child_cap_hits": 35941, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35941, "child_moves_before_total": 3001303, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3001303, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 575896, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 575896, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.50638546506775, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02337163684928, "tt_hits": 13561, "tt_cutoffs": 2599, "beta_cutoffs": 25990, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4820.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5436.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 39, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.25, "search_nodes": 194, "safety_nodes": 1141, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1335, "avg_nodes": 111.25, "eval_calls": 182, "avg_eval_calls": 15.166666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 182, "line_shape_eval_ns": 157281, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 864.1813186813187, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 891, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.25, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 891, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14015, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1167.9166666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29466473, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2102.495397788084, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16970, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2828.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 16970, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5460, "stage_ordering_ns": 560, "stage_eval_ns": 157281, "stage_threat_ns": 24820212, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 376, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24223189, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 275762, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 182, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 270041, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 364, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51220, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 151, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18545, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 126, 70, 56, 69, 114, 100, 110, 94, 127, 125, 156, 170, 141, 111, 158, 174, 155, 83, 97, 169, 157, 154, 159 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 48, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 202, "safety_nodes": 1291, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1493, "avg_nodes": 124.41666666666667, "eval_calls": 190, "avg_eval_calls": 15.833333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 190, "line_shape_eval_ns": 130652, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 687.6421052631579, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 970, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.83333333333333, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 970, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 970, "avg_legality_checks": 80.83333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 970, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15548, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1295.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 33146753, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2131.8981862618984, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.833333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 657021, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11327.948275862069, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 120230, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 536791, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 79, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.583333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 994515, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12588.79746835443, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 114, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 571102, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 5009.666666666667, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2624235, "stage_ordering_ns": 500, "stage_eval_ns": 130652, "stage_threat_ns": 26467158, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 392, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24868580, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1267976, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13030, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 280311, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 380, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50291, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 18486, "avg_search_time_ms": 1540.5, "search_nodes": 170911, "safety_nodes": 359, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 171270, "avg_nodes": 14272.5, "eval_calls": 135489, "avg_eval_calls": 11290.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 135489, "pattern_eval_ns": 2950436, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.776203234210897, "pattern_frame_queries": 135489, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2950436, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.776203234210897, "pattern_frame_updates": 341716, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3849397121, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11264.901617132355, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33564, "avg_candidate_generations": 2797.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3148909, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.81804910022643, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1008, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 33552, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3147901, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 2129609, "avg_legality_checks": 177467.41666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24539, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2129609, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5567429, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 463952.4166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11302396911, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2030.0926892826114, "renju_forbidden_checks": 118343, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9861.916666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 787207005, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6651.910167901777, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24543, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 240637589, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27648, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 291070567, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 66092, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 254759797, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 739052, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 260916, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 21743.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2803021581, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10743.003805822564, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 375103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31258.583333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1492522439, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3978.9669477450193, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5329934194, "stage_ordering_ns": 1211949880, "stage_eval_ns": 3852347557, "stage_threat_ns": 7997125060, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 793434, "root_tactical_annotations": 3202, "search_tactical_annotations": 790232, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 341728, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1985307184, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 707890, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5702506406, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67180, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2307272826, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 170858, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 245889884, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 341716, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42746016, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 273389, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1392174103, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 367312, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2003002135, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 152733, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20675570, "child_limit_applications": 33552, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33552, "child_cap_hits": 33552, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33552, "child_moves_before_total": 3123362, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3123362, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 548010, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 548010, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.09018836432999, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.33315450643777, "tt_hits": 12882, "tt_cutoffs": 1818, "beta_cutoffs": 24771, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2333.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2798.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 152, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14913, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 114, 156, 113, 170, 184, 111, 66, 82, 126, 140, 84, 70, 99, 69, 97, 96, 129, 144, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14876, "avg_search_time_ms": 1352.3636363636363, "search_nodes": 197567, "safety_nodes": 152, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 197719, "avg_nodes": 17974.454545454544, "eval_calls": 160236, "avg_eval_calls": 14566.90909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 160236, "pattern_eval_ns": 3298139, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.583008812002298, "pattern_frame_queries": 160236, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3298139, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.583008812002298, "pattern_frame_updates": 395040, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4926176475, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12470.07005619684, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35231, "avg_candidate_generations": 3202.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 3166066, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.86591354205103, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 838, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 35220, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3165228, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 1279129, "avg_legality_checks": 116284.45454545454, "illegal_moves_skipped": 904, "root_legality_checks": 838, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1278291, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 904, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4537070, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 412460.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8750273702, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1928.6177427282364, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40545, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3685.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 172512531, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4254.841065482797, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1133, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5941856, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23674, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 141286160, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15738, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25284515, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 116445, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10585.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 910487378, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7819.033689724763, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 157711, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14337.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 401299491, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2544.5244212515295, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2734152681, "stage_ordering_ns": 1151766433, "stage_eval_ns": 4929474614, "stage_threat_ns": 5995480490, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 543716, "root_tactical_annotations": 3084, "search_tactical_annotations": 540632, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 395051, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2016863877, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 489370, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3661262552, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70508, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2366757531, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 257811485, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 395040, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43896090, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 127087, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 195900490, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 291766, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1098595141, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 124863, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15646486, "child_limit_applications": 35220, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35220, "child_cap_hits": 35220, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35220, "child_moves_before_total": 3164324, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3164324, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 569923, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 569923, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.84452015900057, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.181800113571835, "tt_hits": 14672, "tt_cutoffs": 2064, "beta_cutoffs": 24697, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2368.3636363636365, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3020.6363636363635, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 266, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.7, "search_nodes": 75, "safety_nodes": 1176, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1251, "avg_nodes": 125.1, "eval_calls": 65, "avg_eval_calls": 6.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 65, "line_shape_eval_ns": 42680, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 656.6153846153846, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 772, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.2, "candidate_moves_max": 92, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 772, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11909, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1190.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20812463, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1747.6247375934167, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4160, "stage_ordering_ns": 490, "stage_eval_ns": 42680, "stage_threat_ns": 16725551, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 140, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16368438, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 240273, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 65, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99640, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 130, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17200, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 153, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3745, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 144, 160, 97, 95, 65, 142, 158, 81, 113, 78, 94, 79, 82, 77 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 16, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.0, "search_nodes": 247, "safety_nodes": 431, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 678, "avg_nodes": 84.75, "eval_calls": 239, "avg_eval_calls": 29.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 239, "line_shape_eval_ns": 94230, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 394.26778242677824, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 530, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.25, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 530, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 530, "avg_legality_checks": 66.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 530, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11574020, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1158.3286629303443, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 66240, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7360.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 39210, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2800.714285714286, "stage_move_gen_ns": 785321, "stage_ordering_ns": 350, "stage_eval_ns": 94230, "stage_threat_ns": 10303752, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 9930378, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 115442, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 219392, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38540, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5497.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6497.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 3721, "avg_search_time_ms": 465.125, "search_nodes": 79696, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 80225, "avg_nodes": 10028.125, "eval_calls": 64410, "avg_eval_calls": 8051.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64410, "pattern_eval_ns": 1232593, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.13667132432852, "pattern_frame_queries": 64410, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1232593, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.13667132432852, "pattern_frame_updates": 159328, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 826951157, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5190.243755021089, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14427, "avg_candidate_generations": 1803.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1176985, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.58210300131698, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 547, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 14419, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1176438, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 666645, "avg_legality_checks": 83330.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 382, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 666645, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 382, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1731290, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 216411.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2124836635, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1227.3141039340608, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3058, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 382.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8266368, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2703.1942446043167, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 382, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2539292, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 487, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 2920134, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2184, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2772952, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 33990, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47072, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5884.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 287083947, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6098.826202413325, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 73822, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9227.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 141550630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1917.4586166725367, "stage_move_gen_ns": 946145018, "stage_ordering_ns": 287089501, "stage_eval_ns": 828183750, "stage_threat_ns": 1618517240, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 213135, "root_tactical_annotations": 1104, "search_tactical_annotations": 212031, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 159336, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 543725721, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 190685, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 983402670, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28885, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 597414180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79664, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 72650720, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 159328, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12722290, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 53418, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 133801065, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 108376, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 252124605, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 51341, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6015839, "child_limit_applications": 14419, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14419, "child_cap_hits": 14419, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14419, "child_moves_before_total": 1176056, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1176056, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 230725, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 230725, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.56293779041542, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001456411679033, "tt_hits": 5694, "tt_cutoffs": 835, "beta_cutoffs": 10163, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4785.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5785.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1844, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 154, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6455, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 142, 94, 144, 78, 62, 96, 114, 100, 129, 99, 141, 98, 97, 101, 102, 82, 143, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6426, "avg_search_time_ms": 642.6, "search_nodes": 103312, "safety_nodes": 501, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 103813, "avg_nodes": 10381.3, "eval_calls": 80402, "avg_eval_calls": 8040.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80402, "pattern_eval_ns": 1556325, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.356794607099324, "pattern_frame_queries": 80402, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1556325, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.356794607099324, "pattern_frame_updates": 206540, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2132538407, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10325.062491527066, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21590, "avg_candidate_generations": 2159.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1835736, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.02714219546087, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 758, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 21580, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1834978, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 749460, "avg_legality_checks": 74946.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2940, "root_legality_checks": 758, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 748702, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2935, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2798862, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 279886.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3732959935, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1333.7420476607992, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45360, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4536.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 222355677, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4902.021097883598, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3059, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17120141, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27237, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 173693825, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15037, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31403281, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 138430, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 103564, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10356.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 594814937, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5743.45271522923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 141126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14112.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 272836717, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1933.284561314003, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1106333264, "stage_ordering_ns": 450847915, "stage_eval_ns": 2134094732, "stage_threat_ns": 2689365339, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 330828, "root_tactical_annotations": 1729, "search_tactical_annotations": 329099, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 206550, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 778497457, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 303915, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1780211409, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43221, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1013340338, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 103270, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105265742, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 206540, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17747008, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 81860, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 175203529, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 178828, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 591568312, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 70140, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7643723, "child_limit_applications": 21580, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21580, "child_cap_hits": 21580, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21580, "child_moves_before_total": 1832043, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1832043, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 351350, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 351350, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.89541241890639, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.281278962001853, "tt_hits": 8911, "tt_cutoffs": 1288, "beta_cutoffs": 16511, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4725.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5525.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 20, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.2222222222222223, "search_nodes": 86, "safety_nodes": 1166, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1252, "avg_nodes": 139.11111111111111, "eval_calls": 77, "avg_eval_calls": 8.555555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 77, "line_shape_eval_ns": 40400, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 524.6753246753246, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 686, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 686, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10707, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1189.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14669255, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1370.062108900719, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.2222222222222223, "renju_forbidden_ns": 120240, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6012.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 120240, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3220, "stage_ordering_ns": 420, "stage_eval_ns": 40400, "stage_threat_ns": 11804428, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 163, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 11457388, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 245030, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6370, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87870, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 154, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14140, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5775.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6664.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 155, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4806, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 113, 83, 81, 110, 124, 99, 127, 54, 68, 69, 114, 39 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 22, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.75, "search_nodes": 243, "safety_nodes": 415, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 658, "avg_nodes": 82.25, "eval_calls": 235, "avg_eval_calls": 29.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 235, "line_shape_eval_ns": 116970, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 497.74468085106383, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 514, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.25, "candidate_moves_max": 77, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 514, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 514, "avg_legality_checks": 64.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 514, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9912, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1239.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16370459, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1651.579802259887, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 103231, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11470.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 57780, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4127.142857142857, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1093946, "stage_ordering_ns": 400, "stage_eval_ns": 116970, "stage_threat_ns": 13736793, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 478, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 13264878, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 178902, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6700, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 235, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 251433, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 470, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41580, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5497.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6497.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 4775, "avg_search_time_ms": 596.875, "search_nodes": 75377, "safety_nodes": 509, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 75886, "avg_nodes": 9485.75, "eval_calls": 61234, "avg_eval_calls": 7654.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 61234, "pattern_eval_ns": 1185784, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.364797334813993, "pattern_frame_queries": 61234, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1185784, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.364797334813993, "pattern_frame_updates": 150690, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1020765621, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6773.94399761099, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13437, "avg_candidate_generations": 1679.625, "candidate_moves_total": 1070318, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.65453598273425, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 527, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 13429, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1069791, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 611845, "avg_legality_checks": 76480.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 611845, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1571691, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 196461.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2782841866, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1770.6036784584246, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1083, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 135.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5215838, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4816.101569713758, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 275151, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 457, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 3433760, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 592, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1506927, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42754, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5344.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 342218972, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8004.37320484633, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8133.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 163457044, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2511.979898879685, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1249020833, "stage_ordering_ns": 369600677, "stage_eval_ns": 1021951405, "stage_threat_ns": 2103032351, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 197369, "root_tactical_annotations": 1064, "search_tactical_annotations": 196305, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 150698, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 725365183, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 173897, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1263701800, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26905, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 800353883, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75345, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91987194, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 150690, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15701062, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 46112, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 171629123, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 100874, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 291635784, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 50383, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6277112, "child_limit_applications": 13429, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13429, "child_cap_hits": 13429, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13429, "child_moves_before_total": 1069757, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1069757, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 214880, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 214880, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.66021297192643, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00119145133666, "tt_hits": 5319, "tt_cutoffs": 682, "beta_cutoffs": 9381, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4431.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5431.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1931, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 156, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12489, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 81, 85, 86, 69, 94, 78, 111, 109, 140, 154, 125, 95, 127, 124, 142, 158, 157, 172, 97 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 12449, "avg_search_time_ms": 1037.4166666666667, "search_nodes": 191002, "safety_nodes": 257, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 191259, "avg_nodes": 15938.25, "eval_calls": 153703, "avg_eval_calls": 12808.583333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 153703, "pattern_eval_ns": 2892843, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.820992433459335, "pattern_frame_queries": 153703, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2892843, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.820992433459335, "pattern_frame_updates": 381900, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3994984257, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10460.81240377062, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35220, "avg_candidate_generations": 2935.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3034085, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.14664963089155, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 865, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 35208, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3033220, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1243632, "avg_legality_checks": 103636.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1706, "root_legality_checks": 865, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1242767, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1704, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4270944, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 355912.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7183552953, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1681.959059402324, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45764, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3813.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 184898259, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4040.255637619089, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2014, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10381113, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29218, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 151506937, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14522, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22901259, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 108950, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 119569, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9964.083333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 819887914, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6857.027440222801, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 156546, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13045.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 358061052, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2287.257751715151, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2351197252, "stage_ordering_ns": 964344660, "stage_eval_ns": 3997877100, "stage_threat_ns": 5054849482, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 573583, "root_tactical_annotations": 2956, "search_tactical_annotations": 570627, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 381912, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1722718434, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 514532, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3061710842, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70491, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1927149136, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 190950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 218421108, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 381900, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37326436, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 163587, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 229413132, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 280444, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 905015674, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 129552, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14672662, "child_limit_applications": 35208, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35208, "child_cap_hits": 35208, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35208, "child_moves_before_total": 3031516, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3031516, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 564791, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 564791, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.10304476255396, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.041553056123607, "tt_hits": 14250, "tt_cutoffs": 2039, "beta_cutoffs": 25142, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4486.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5153.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1085, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 30, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.727272727272727, "search_nodes": 196, "safety_nodes": 974, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1170, "avg_nodes": 106.36363636363636, "eval_calls": 185, "avg_eval_calls": 16.818181818181817, "line_shape_eval_calls": 185, "line_shape_eval_ns": 133180, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 719.8918918918919, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 791, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.9090909090909, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 791, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12908, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1173.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21409669, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1658.6356523086458, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.7272727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 91280, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11410.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 91280, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3960, "stage_ordering_ns": 510, "stage_eval_ns": 133180, "stage_threat_ns": 18532363, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 381, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18052818, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 181934, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 252270, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 370, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45341, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 157, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10011, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 128, 64, 48, 65, 100, 86, 113, 83, 99, 97, 130, 146, 66, 101, 82 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 32, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 270, "safety_nodes": 628, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 898, "avg_nodes": 112.25, "eval_calls": 262, "avg_eval_calls": 32.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 262, "line_shape_eval_ns": 205923, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 785.9656488549618, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 575, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.875, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 575, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 575, "avg_legality_checks": 71.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 575, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10179, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1272.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21075115, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2070.450437174575, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 195612, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11506.588235294117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34250, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 161362, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 519953, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11817.113636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 288462, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4578.761904761905, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1465597, "stage_ordering_ns": 380, "stage_eval_ns": 205923, "stage_threat_ns": 18547751, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 532, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17415207, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 707913, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 262, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 359411, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 524, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65220, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 9973, "avg_search_time_ms": 1246.625, "search_nodes": 125115, "safety_nodes": 248, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 125363, "avg_nodes": 15670.375, "eval_calls": 103317, "avg_eval_calls": 12914.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 103317, "pattern_eval_ns": 2117028, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.490606579749702, "pattern_frame_queries": 103317, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2117028, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.490606579749702, "pattern_frame_updates": 250162, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2609500296, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10431.2417393529, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20644, "avg_candidate_generations": 2580.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1818165, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.07232125557063, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 604, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 20636, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1817561, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1043850, "avg_legality_checks": 130481.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5479, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1043850, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5479, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2911911, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 363988.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5732166772, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1968.5240283786145, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30449, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3806.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 309138788, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10152.674570593452, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5510, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 60307140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20113, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 207051238, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4801, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41480028, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 300382, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 101589, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12698.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 970230315, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9550.544990107197, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 146030, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18253.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 491208590, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3363.751215503664, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2392146990, "stage_ordering_ns": 649654313, "stage_eval_ns": 2611617324, "stage_threat_ns": 4274043139, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 435651, "root_tactical_annotations": 1858, "search_tactical_annotations": 433793, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 250170, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1401020268, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 384882, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2657028334, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41321, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1375186056, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 125081, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 173236669, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 250162, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29969549, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 125443, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 451611643, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 218112, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 830180825, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 92096, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12788319, "child_limit_applications": 20636, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20636, "child_cap_hits": 20636, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20636, "child_moves_before_total": 1812082, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1812082, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 349701, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 349701, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.81168831168831, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.946162046908317, "tt_hits": 8222, "tt_cutoffs": 1128, "beta_cutoffs": 14319, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3070.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3828.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1856, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 158, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10257, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 82, 130, 52, 146, 162, 99, 68, 54, 144, 84, 69, 128, 67, 97, 66, 70, 65 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10219, "avg_search_time_ms": 1135.4444444444443, "search_nodes": 105705, "safety_nodes": 240, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 105945, "avg_nodes": 11771.666666666666, "eval_calls": 81537, "avg_eval_calls": 9059.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 81537, "pattern_eval_ns": 1763103, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.623348909084218, "pattern_frame_queries": 81537, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1763103, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.623348909084218, "pattern_frame_updates": 211336, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2971635164, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14061.187701101564, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22769, "avg_candidate_generations": 2529.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 1875639, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.37687206289253, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 662, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 22760, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1874977, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 791735, "avg_legality_checks": 87970.55555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 630, "root_legality_checks": 662, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 791073, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 630, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2766407, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 307378.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6168648881, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2229.8414083683274, "renju_forbidden_checks": 59803, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6644.777777777777, "renju_forbidden_ns": 196490671, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3285.632342859054, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1547, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7272609, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27559, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 128998632, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30697, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 60219430, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 94082, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10453.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 939801896, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9989.17854637444, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 129196, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14355.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 430216282, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3329.950478342983, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1993766494, "stage_ordering_ns": 800198291, "stage_eval_ns": 2973398267, "stage_threat_ns": 4406234746, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 298576, "root_tactical_annotations": 1797, "search_tactical_annotations": 296779, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 211345, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1272842977, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 280204, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2939496637, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45574, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1744567232, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 105668, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 158209742, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 211336, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27206998, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 63443, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 251935432, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171181, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 942987073, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 63952, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8478392, "child_limit_applications": 22760, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22760, "child_cap_hits": 22760, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22760, "child_moves_before_total": 1874347, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1874347, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 365279, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 365279, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.35268014059754, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.049165202108963, "tt_hits": 8932, "tt_cutoffs": 1371, "beta_cutoffs": 17511, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2276.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3145.1111111111113, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 403, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.375, "search_nodes": 209, "safety_nodes": 652, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 861, "avg_nodes": 107.625, "eval_calls": 201, "avg_eval_calls": 25.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 201, "line_shape_eval_ns": 130540, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 649.4527363184079, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 600, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.0, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 600, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9338, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1167.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20112038, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2153.784322124652, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3470, "stage_ordering_ns": 330, "stage_eval_ns": 130540, "stage_threat_ns": 17804869, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 410, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17356895, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 110881, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 201, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 284743, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 402, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52350, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 159, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10006, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 128, 64, 48, 65, 110, 94, 114, 100, 127, 125, 144, 95, 129, 130, 99, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.888888888888889, "search_nodes": 268, "safety_nodes": 616, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 259, "avg_eval_calls": 28.77777777777778, "line_shape_eval_calls": 259, "line_shape_eval_ns": 200310, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 773.3976833976834, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 648, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.0, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 648, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 648, "avg_legality_checks": 72.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 648, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11378, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1264.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24457483, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2149.541483564774, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.7777777777777777, "renju_forbidden_ns": 280530, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11221.2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 56190, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 224340, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 34, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.7777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 407632, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11989.176470588236, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.555555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 229281, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4585.62, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1748690, "stage_ordering_ns": 380, "stage_eval_ns": 200310, "stage_threat_ns": 20933793, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 527, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19965749, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 530243, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 259, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 370901, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 518, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66900, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5773.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9961, "avg_search_time_ms": 1106.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 114267, "safety_nodes": 578, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 114845, "avg_nodes": 12760.555555555555, "eval_calls": 93551, "avg_eval_calls": 10394.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 93551, "pattern_eval_ns": 2000625, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.38539406313134, "pattern_frame_queries": 93551, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2000625, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.38539406313134, "pattern_frame_updates": 228460, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2255445473, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9872.386732907293, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19653, "avg_candidate_generations": 2183.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 1728704, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.96132905917672, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 675, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 19644, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1728029, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1013607, "avg_legality_checks": 112623.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7838, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1013607, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7838, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2795985, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 310665.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5854015599, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2093.7221047323214, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35946, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3994.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 276829568, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7701.262115395315, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7838, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 82084895, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14457, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 149734890, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13616, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44616021, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 393762, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 114487, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12720.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1190794525, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10401.133098081005, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 164459, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18273.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 610419193, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3711.6800722368494, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2603960584, "stage_ordering_ns": 690897747, "stage_eval_ns": 2257446098, "stage_threat_ns": 4358831412, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 375216, "root_tactical_annotations": 1610, "search_tactical_annotations": 373606, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 228469, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1337895478, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 328475, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2815189662, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 39342, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1348788079, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 114230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 165649248, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 228460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28240985, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 114627, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 623392493, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 174499, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 842864250, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 86090, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11856039, "child_limit_applications": 19644, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19644, "child_cap_hits": 19644, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19644, "child_moves_before_total": 1720191, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1720191, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 317646, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 317646, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.56826511912034, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.170128283445326, "tt_hits": 7879, "tt_cutoffs": 1035, "beta_cutoffs": 13529, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3212.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4100.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1840, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 160, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16146, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 110, 158, 111, 174, 190, 109, 64, 128, 82, 124, 80, 48, 125, 140, 81, 79, 83, 84, 97, 139, 69 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 16103, "avg_search_time_ms": 1463.909090909091, "search_nodes": 163180, "safety_nodes": 160, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 163340, "avg_nodes": 14849.09090909091, "eval_calls": 126013, "avg_eval_calls": 11455.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 126013, "pattern_eval_ns": 2703458, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.453802385468165, "pattern_frame_queries": 126013, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2703458, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.453802385468165, "pattern_frame_updates": 326266, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5046457892, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15467.311616901547, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35329, "avg_candidate_generations": 3211.7272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 3306279, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.5854114183815, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 889, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 35318, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3305390, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1182798, "avg_legality_checks": 107527.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4692, "root_legality_checks": 889, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1181909, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4689, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4160506, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 378227.8181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9432046789, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2267.043188737139, "renju_forbidden_checks": 72210, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6564.545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 604612003, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8372.967774546461, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5552, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 60814843, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 42291, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 414222525, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24352, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 129374692, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 199943, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 127683, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11607.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1246788937, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9764.721513435617, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 173595, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15781.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 547270097, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3152.568317059823, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2961698343, "stage_ordering_ns": 1343844735, "stage_eval_ns": 5049161350, "stage_threat_ns": 6695383497, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 601557, "root_tactical_annotations": 3236, "search_tactical_annotations": 598321, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 326277, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1975194154, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 537673, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4414887622, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70704, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2729416401, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 163133, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 245823291, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 326266, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41535148, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 183728, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 309713230, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 283232, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1375748301, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 134597, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17943282, "child_limit_applications": 35318, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35318, "child_cap_hits": 35318, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35318, "child_moves_before_total": 3300701, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3300701, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 575495, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 575495, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.45662268531628, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.294665609604166, "tt_hits": 15193, "tt_cutoffs": 1802, "beta_cutoffs": 27198, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1860.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2401.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 357, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1, "search_nodes": 76, "safety_nodes": 1237, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1313, "avg_nodes": 131.3, "eval_calls": 66, "avg_eval_calls": 6.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 66, "line_shape_eval_ns": 48130, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 729.2424242424242, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 813, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.3, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 813, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11924, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1192.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25191444, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2112.6672257631667, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 170132, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 14177.666666666666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 170132, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4420, "stage_ordering_ns": 540, "stage_eval_ns": 48130, "stage_threat_ns": 19974496, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 142, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19590175, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 264511, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10970, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 101820, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 132, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17990, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 161, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6238, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 111, 81, 79, 114, 130, 95, 127, 50, 66, 65, 110, 35 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 30, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.75, "search_nodes": 247, "safety_nodes": 431, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 678, "avg_nodes": 84.75, "eval_calls": 239, "avg_eval_calls": 29.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 239, "line_shape_eval_ns": 167642, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 701.4309623430962, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 530, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.25, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 530, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 530, "avg_legality_checks": 66.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 530, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21564612, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2158.1877502001603, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 115030, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12781.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 65310, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4665.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1395248, "stage_ordering_ns": 400, "stage_eval_ns": 167642, "stage_threat_ns": 18458798, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17855736, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 199341, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8571, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 340621, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63100, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6199, "avg_search_time_ms": 774.875, "search_nodes": 79133, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 79662, "avg_nodes": 9957.75, "eval_calls": 64439, "avg_eval_calls": 8054.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64439, "pattern_eval_ns": 1374990, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.33785440494111, "pattern_frame_queries": 64439, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1374990, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.33785440494111, "pattern_frame_updates": 158202, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1245337746, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7871.820495316115, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14032, "avg_candidate_generations": 1754.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1151925, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.09271664766248, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 547, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 14024, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1151378, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 656014, "avg_legality_checks": 82001.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 390, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 656014, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 390, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1658932, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 207366.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3664853640, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2209.164474493228, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2803, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 350.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13244615, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4725.156974669996, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 390, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4791756, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 361, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 3927839, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2047, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4461880, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 63140, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46972, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5871.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 492742596, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10490.13446308439, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74353, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9294.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 244917793, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3293.986698586473, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1693123807, "stage_ordering_ns": 492020544, "stage_eval_ns": 1246712736, "stage_threat_ns": 2730482787, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 206304, "root_tactical_annotations": 1104, "search_tactical_annotations": 205200, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 158210, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 921172199, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 184721, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1670824676, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28095, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1020769520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79101, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113051278, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 158202, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19571601, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 51684, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 224405414, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 104936, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 425547811, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49684, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5863033, "child_limit_applications": 14024, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14024, "child_cap_hits": 14024, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14024, "child_moves_before_total": 1150988, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1150988, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 224398, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 224398, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.07273245864232, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00099828864803, "tt_hits": 5423, "tt_cutoffs": 638, "beta_cutoffs": 9771, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3929.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4929.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1876, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 162, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11488, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 144, 96, 160, 176, 97, 81, 114, 66, 111, 50, 34, 51, 36, 110, 113, 115, 68, 124, 138, 65, 83, 80, 95, 79, 78, 37, 23, 93 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 11425, "avg_search_time_ms": 816.0714285714286, "search_nodes": 129139, "safety_nodes": 1125, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 130264, "avg_nodes": 9304.57142857143, "eval_calls": 98694, "avg_eval_calls": 7049.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 98694, "pattern_eval_ns": 2147992, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.76415992866841, "pattern_frame_queries": 98694, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2147992, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.76415992866841, "pattern_frame_updates": 258148, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2676230179, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10367.038206765112, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27877, "avg_candidate_generations": 1991.2142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 2430769, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.19621910535567, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1214, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 27863, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2429555, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 1048382, "avg_legality_checks": 74884.42857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 145, "root_legality_checks": 1214, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1047168, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 145, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2959567, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 211397.64285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6733194164, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2275.060562575539, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14619, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1044.2142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61403945, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4200.283535125522, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 158, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1633927, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4849, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43833199, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9612, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15936819, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 80642, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5760.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 816932262, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10130.357158800625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 111375, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7955.357142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 390963860, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3510.3376879910215, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2640243358, "stage_ordering_ns": 1006705876, "stage_eval_ns": 2678378171, "stage_threat_ns": 5036053465, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 467592, "root_tactical_annotations": 1796, "search_tactical_annotations": 465796, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 258162, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1515343934, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 421411, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3290626525, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 55819, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2115316482, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129074, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 185709774, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 258148, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32001939, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 119802, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 201568611, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 245782, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 973179449, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 102008, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12371293, "child_limit_applications": 27863, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27863, "child_cap_hits": 27863, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27863, "child_moves_before_total": 2429410, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2429410, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 461167, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 461167, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.19125722284032, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.55123281771525, "tt_hits": 10245, "tt_cutoffs": 2518, "beta_cutoffs": 21488, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4212.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4783.928571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 48, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4285714285714284, "search_nodes": 400, "safety_nodes": 1519, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1919, "avg_nodes": 137.07142857142858, "eval_calls": 386, "avg_eval_calls": 27.571428571428573, "line_shape_eval_calls": 386, "line_shape_eval_ns": 475497, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1231.8575129533679, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1250, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.28571428571429, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1250, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16513, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1179.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 34816783, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2108.446860049658, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6610, "stage_ordering_ns": 710, "stage_eval_ns": 475497, "stage_threat_ns": 31271754, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 786, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 30331923, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 292410, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 386, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 550151, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 772, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 97270, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6569.071428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7140.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 163, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6636, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 140, 154, 97, 99, 69, 142, 156, 83, 111, 86, 100, 85, 82, 87 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.875, "search_nodes": 247, "safety_nodes": 431, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 678, "avg_nodes": 84.75, "eval_calls": 239, "avg_eval_calls": 29.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 239, "line_shape_eval_ns": 170021, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 711.3849372384938, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 530, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.25, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 530, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 530, "avg_legality_checks": 66.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 530, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21683458, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2170.0818654923937, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 116800, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12977.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 66160, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4725.714285714285, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1410146, "stage_ordering_ns": 380, "stage_eval_ns": 170021, "stage_threat_ns": 18491340, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17871648, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 205690, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 350662, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63340, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6596, "avg_search_time_ms": 824.5, "search_nodes": 79767, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 80296, "avg_nodes": 10037.0, "eval_calls": 64907, "avg_eval_calls": 8113.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64907, "pattern_eval_ns": 1403828, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.62829895080654, "pattern_frame_queries": 64907, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1403828, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.62829895080654, "pattern_frame_updates": 159470, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1530508135, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9597.467454693673, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14116, "avg_candidate_generations": 1764.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1157631, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.00843015018418, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 547, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 14108, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1157084, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 663570, "avg_legality_checks": 82946.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1894, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 663570, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1894, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1721818, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 215227.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3920447690, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2276.923397246399, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5473, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 684.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 54083767, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9881.92344235337, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1894, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21821175, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2442, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26604053, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1132, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5593859, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 64680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42021, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5252.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 436757873, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10393.8000761524, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 61682, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7710.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 206387240, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3345.9881326805225, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1715573216, "stage_ordering_ns": 508288095, "stage_eval_ns": 1531911963, "stage_threat_ns": 2806165893, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 205501, "root_tactical_annotations": 1104, "search_tactical_annotations": 204397, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 159478, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 951843142, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 183569, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1710552463, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28263, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1113619246, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79735, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 117030077, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 159470, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20151158, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 50257, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 213301049, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 105043, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 383525978, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 50201, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6589053, "child_limit_applications": 14108, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14108, "child_cap_hits": 14108, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14108, "child_moves_before_total": 1155190, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1155190, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 225753, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 225753, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.88191097249788, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001772044230226, "tt_hits": 5584, "tt_cutoffs": 720, "beta_cutoffs": 9819, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3700.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4700.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1867, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 164, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10731, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 142, 100, 140, 86, 72, 98, 110, 94, 125, 95, 143, 96, 97, 93, 92, 82, 141, 144, 139 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10692, "avg_search_time_ms": 1069.2, "search_nodes": 103068, "safety_nodes": 501, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 103569, "avg_nodes": 10356.9, "eval_calls": 80495, "avg_eval_calls": 8049.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80495, "pattern_eval_ns": 1747837, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.713609540965276, "pattern_frame_queries": 80495, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1747837, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.713609540965276, "pattern_frame_updates": 206052, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3491014263, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 16942.394458680334, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21340, "avg_candidate_generations": 2134.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1823756, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.46185567010309, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 758, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 21330, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1822998, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 727965, "avg_legality_checks": 72796.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2692, "root_legality_checks": 758, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 727207, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2687, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2785531, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 278553.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6407376305, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2300.235145471366, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48086, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4808.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 408467790, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8494.526265441085, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2885, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 32103647, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29031, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 305898878, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16143, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 70183205, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 282060, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 100836, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10083.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1010454695, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10020.773285334602, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137862, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13786.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 457199887, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3316.3590184387285, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1882454118, "stage_ordering_ns": 774247505, "stage_eval_ns": 3492762100, "stage_threat_ns": 4507137612, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 327838, "root_tactical_annotations": 1729, "search_tactical_annotations": 326109, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 206062, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1279041957, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 299696, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3033746396, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42721, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1744677604, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 103026, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 157861378, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 206052, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26990639, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 79380, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 291751874, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 177589, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 997146137, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 70869, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9497242, "child_limit_applications": 21330, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21330, "child_cap_hits": 21330, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21330, "child_moves_before_total": 1820311, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1820311, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 347693, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 347693, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.3404125644632, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.300656352555087, "tt_hits": 8824, "tt_cutoffs": 1201, "beta_cutoffs": 16270, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2757.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3557.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 292, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 29, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.2222222222222223, "search_nodes": 86, "safety_nodes": 1166, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1252, "avg_nodes": 139.11111111111111, "eval_calls": 77, "avg_eval_calls": 8.555555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 77, "line_shape_eval_ns": 61710, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 801.4285714285714, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 686, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 686, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10707, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1189.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22974151, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2145.7131782945735, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.2222222222222223, "renju_forbidden_ns": 230871, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11543.55, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 230871, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3970, "stage_ordering_ns": 461, "stage_eval_ns": 61710, "stage_threat_ns": 18526415, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 163, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18041732, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 342391, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121742, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 154, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20550, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 165, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10917, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 126, 70, 56, 69, 94, 78, 111, 81, 95, 97, 124, 138, 68, 93, 82 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 33, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.125, "search_nodes": 270, "safety_nodes": 628, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 898, "avg_nodes": 112.25, "eval_calls": 262, "avg_eval_calls": 32.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 262, "line_shape_eval_ns": 211721, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 808.0954198473282, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 575, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.875, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 575, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 575, "avg_legality_checks": 71.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 575, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10179, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1272.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21879928, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2149.51645544749, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 332651, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 19567.70588235294, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 35780, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 296871, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 531533, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12080.295454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 290892, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4617.333333333333, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1556606, "stage_ordering_ns": 370, "stage_eval_ns": 211721, "stage_threat_ns": 19418677, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 532, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18122787, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 844825, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 262, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 383645, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 524, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67420, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 10877, "avg_search_time_ms": 1359.625, "search_nodes": 124016, "safety_nodes": 248, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 124264, "avg_nodes": 15533.0, "eval_calls": 102654, "avg_eval_calls": 12831.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 102654, "pattern_eval_ns": 2202733, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.45783895415668, "pattern_frame_queries": 102654, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2202733, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.45783895415668, "pattern_frame_updates": 247964, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2820303531, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11373.842698940169, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20335, "avg_candidate_generations": 2541.875, "candidate_moves_total": 1794780, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.26063437423161, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 604, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 20327, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1794176, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1048142, "avg_legality_checks": 131017.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5469, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1048142, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5469, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2929030, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 366128.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6317886517, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2156.989350399279, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30488, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3811.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 320050217, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10497.579933088427, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5477, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 62108826, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20117, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 215976502, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4869, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41655239, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 309650, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 101859, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12732.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1049649558, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10304.926987305982, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 146542, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18317.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 527556787, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3600.0381255885686, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2665920530, "stage_ordering_ns": 705692297, "stage_eval_ns": 2822506264, "stage_threat_ns": 4637955035, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 426381, "root_tactical_annotations": 1858, "search_tactical_annotations": 424523, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 247972, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1525659774, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 373873, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2880612931, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40703, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1506102108, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123982, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 186453849, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 247964, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32059690, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 121956, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 468230418, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 211208, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 906227995, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 93217, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13168791, "child_limit_applications": 20327, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20327, "child_cap_hits": 20327, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20327, "child_moves_before_total": 1788707, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1788707, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 343042, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 343042, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.9966055000738, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.87617454617012, "tt_hits": 8079, "tt_cutoffs": 1001, "beta_cutoffs": 14044, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2570.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3216.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1389, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 166, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11554, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 82, 124, 126, 138, 152, 140, 114, 66, 97, 67, 113, 111, 81, 65, 84, 70, 83, 80, 85 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11516, "avg_search_time_ms": 1151.6, "search_nodes": 125303, "safety_nodes": 479, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 125782, "avg_nodes": 12578.2, "eval_calls": 98378, "avg_eval_calls": 9837.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 98378, "pattern_eval_ns": 2072951, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.071286263188924, "pattern_frame_queries": 98378, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2072951, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.071286263188924, "pattern_frame_updates": 250522, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3676950765, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14677.157155858567, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25391, "avg_candidate_generations": 2539.1, "candidate_moves_total": 2140562, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.30396597219487, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 727, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 25381, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2139835, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 844367, "avg_legality_checks": 84436.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1351, "root_legality_checks": 727, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 843640, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1350, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3046171, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 304617.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6838014275, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2244.790024919809, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39245, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3924.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 253325731, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6454.981042170977, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1824, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16847549, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22300, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 191722274, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15112, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44699298, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 56610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93732, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9373.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 868887231, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9269.91028677506, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 126109, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12610.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 368390218, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2921.2048148823637, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2075863968, "stage_ordering_ns": 854377900, "stage_eval_ns": 3679023716, "stage_threat_ns": 4870069014, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 447021, "root_tactical_annotations": 2129, "search_tactical_annotations": 444892, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 250532, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1512483897, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 394405, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3124425362, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50823, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1939838331, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 125261, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 187290762, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 250522, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31862375, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 133723, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 215772321, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 209851, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 968501039, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 103447, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14006618, "child_limit_applications": 25381, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25381, "child_cap_hits": 25381, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25381, "child_moves_before_total": 2138485, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2138485, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 419013, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 419013, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.25534848902723, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.508923998266418, "tt_hits": 10781, "tt_cutoffs": 1502, "beta_cutoffs": 18964, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2812.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3612.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 408, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 73, "safety_nodes": 1040, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1113, "avg_nodes": 123.66666666666667, "eval_calls": 64, "avg_eval_calls": 7.111111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 64, "line_shape_eval_ns": 45020, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 703.4375, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 657, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.0, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 657, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10679, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1186.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21923461, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2052.9507444517276, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43201, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10800.25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 43201, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3840, "stage_ordering_ns": 490, "stage_eval_ns": 45020, "stage_threat_ns": 17498189, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 137, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17067346, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 316531, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9720, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 97161, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17151, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 167, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23674, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 97, 82, 142, 157, 113, 96, 68, 114, 66, 129, 128, 143, 115, 189, 130, 141, 125, 124, 138, 111, 81, 156, 126, 171, 185, 173, 205, 201, 186, 144, 65, 49, 67, 64, 69 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 44, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.4444444444444446, "search_nodes": 349, "safety_nodes": 1716, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2065, "avg_nodes": 114.72222222222223, "eval_calls": 331, "avg_eval_calls": 18.38888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 331, "line_shape_eval_ns": 217482, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 657.0453172205438, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1460, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1460, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1460, "avg_legality_checks": 81.11111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 1460, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22595, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1255.2777777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 33483430, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1481.8955521132993, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.16666666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3280, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1093.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3280, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.611111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 503833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7751.276923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.388888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 281781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2904.958762886598, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2669941, "stage_ordering_ns": 830, "stage_eval_ns": 217482, "stage_threat_ns": 27079560, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 680, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 25971713, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 47, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 685596, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13140, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 331, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 360141, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 662, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62110, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 18, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 18, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6887.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7332.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 23611, "avg_search_time_ms": 1388.8823529411766, "search_nodes": 287512, "safety_nodes": 348, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 287860, "avg_nodes": 16932.941176470587, "eval_calls": 217859, "avg_eval_calls": 12815.235294117647, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 217859, "pattern_eval_ns": 4451045, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.430852064867643, "pattern_frame_queries": 217859, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4451045, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.430852064867643, "pattern_frame_updates": 574864, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4472321715, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7779.790898369006, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 65274, "avg_candidate_generations": 3839.6470588235293, "candidate_moves_total": 6146076, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.15810276679842, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1380, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 65257, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6144696, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 4274949, "avg_legality_checks": 251467.58823529413, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8618, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4274949, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8618, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9140304, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 537664.9411764706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14622708831, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1599.8055240832252, "renju_forbidden_checks": 63124, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3713.176470588235, "renju_forbidden_ns": 274798203, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4353.307822698182, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8620, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 66517903, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20453, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 158145708, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 34041, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 50066992, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 67600, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 292514, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17206.70588235294, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2176973565, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7442.288454569696, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 423062, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 24886.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1080719202, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2554.517309519645, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7824963794, "stage_ordering_ns": 1867496607, "stage_eval_ns": 4476772760, "stage_threat_ns": 9262971614, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1315729, "root_tactical_annotations": 5396, "search_tactical_annotations": 1310333, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 574881, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2654913830, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1173008, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6166251025, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 130628, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3304750532, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 287432, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 347827332, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 574864, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58934294, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 478132, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1250803634, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 564234, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1610657079, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 273363, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 35045133, "child_limit_applications": 65257, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 65257, "child_cap_hits": 65257, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 65257, "child_moves_before_total": 6136078, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6136078, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 1046754, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1046754, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 94.02942213095913, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.040486078121887, "tt_hits": 27190, "tt_cutoffs": 4316, "beta_cutoffs": 51072, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5499.529411764706, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5970.117647058823, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1933, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 168, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7506, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 99, 96, 113, 95, 94, 85, 114, 111, 128, 100, 144, 84, 129, 159, 130, 131, 126 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7479, "avg_search_time_ms": 747.9, "search_nodes": 139724, "safety_nodes": 127, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 139851, "avg_nodes": 13985.1, "eval_calls": 112892, "avg_eval_calls": 11289.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 112892, "pattern_eval_ns": 2167715, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.20167062325054, "pattern_frame_queries": 112892, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2167715, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.20167062325054, "pattern_frame_updates": 279364, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2632917787, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9424.685310204608, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25333, "avg_candidate_generations": 2533.3, "candidate_moves_total": 1880438, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.22879248411164, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 602, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 25323, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1879836, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 783061, "avg_legality_checks": 78306.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2085, "root_legality_checks": 602, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 782459, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2084, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3157663, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 315766.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4237870039, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1342.090666103381, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47789, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4778.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 160920472, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3367.3119755592293, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2530, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11658591, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28579, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 123903500, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16675, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25333041, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 25340, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 103035, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10303.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 514704907, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4995.437540641529, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132541, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13254.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 196357057, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1481.4816320987468, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1174885466, "stage_ordering_ns": 491183876, "stage_eval_ns": 2635085502, "stage_threat_ns": 3131584294, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 465099, "root_tactical_annotations": 2100, "search_tactical_annotations": 462999, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 279374, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1037253487, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 404678, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1919288664, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50707, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1181029484, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 139682, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 139321644, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 279364, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23899921, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 126880, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 134944405, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 227083, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 603307545, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 111136, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11820578, "child_limit_applications": 25323, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25323, "child_cap_hits": 25323, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25323, "child_moves_before_total": 1877752, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1877752, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 430449, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 430449, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.15203569877187, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.99834142874067, "tt_hits": 10356, "tt_cutoffs": 1467, "beta_cutoffs": 18072, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5174.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5974.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1392, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 20, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.2222222222222223, "search_nodes": 81, "safety_nodes": 829, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 910, "avg_nodes": 101.11111111111111, "eval_calls": 72, "avg_eval_calls": 8.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 72, "line_shape_eval_ns": 36131, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 501.81944444444446, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 542, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.22222222222222, "candidate_moves_max": 70, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 542, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10524, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1169.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13748505, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1306.3953819840365, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 23680, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5920.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 23680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2780, "stage_ordering_ns": 440, "stage_eval_ns": 36131, "stage_threat_ns": 11151713, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 153, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 10860323, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 204140, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74450, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 144, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12800, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5775.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6664.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 169, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7692, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 143, 98, 141, 96, 158, 173, 99, 97, 94, 127, 142, 79, 63, 144, 139, 80, 140 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 48, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.363636363636363, "search_nodes": 325, "safety_nodes": 768, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1093, "avg_nodes": 99.36363636363636, "eval_calls": 314, "avg_eval_calls": 28.545454545454547, "line_shape_eval_calls": 314, "line_shape_eval_ns": 279632, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 890.547770700637, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 737, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.0, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 737, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 737, "avg_legality_checks": 67.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 737, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13728, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1248.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27516951, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2004.4399038461538, "renju_forbidden_checks": 86, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7.818181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 873694, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10159.232558139534, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 172211, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 701483, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 766185, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11787.461538461539, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.636363636363637, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 421763, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4439.61052631579, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2002049, "stage_ordering_ns": 510, "stage_eval_ns": 279632, "stage_threat_ns": 24380897, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 639, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22898189, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 962915, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11250, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 314, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 441453, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 628, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 78340, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7635, "avg_search_time_ms": 694.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 81853, "safety_nodes": 650, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 82503, "avg_nodes": 7500.272727272727, "eval_calls": 62631, "avg_eval_calls": 5693.727272727273, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62631, "pattern_eval_ns": 1267635, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.239737510178667, "pattern_frame_queries": 62631, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1267635, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.239737510178667, "pattern_frame_updates": 163608, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1912588397, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11690.066482079115, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17513, "avg_candidate_generations": 1592.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 1362756, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.81396676754412, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 750, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 17502, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1362006, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 686509, "avg_legality_checks": 62409.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9807, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 686509, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9807, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2228464, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 202587.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4480372565, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2010.520504257641, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33571, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3051.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 287178867, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8554.373328170146, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9884, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 96634822, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14599, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 139717791, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8998, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 49899268, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 90, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 926986, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83500, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7590.909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 856789985, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10260.957904191617, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 122818, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11165.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 435769903, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3548.0947662394765, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1690700423, "stage_ordering_ns": 557965823, "stage_eval_ns": 1913856032, "stage_threat_ns": 3408915092, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 301904, "root_tactical_annotations": 1285, "search_tactical_annotations": 300619, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 163619, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 925252599, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 272782, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2342971236, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35074, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1243237540, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 81804, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113354066, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 163608, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19855627, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70580, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 385400760, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 167121, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 714238616, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 64203, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7481564, "child_limit_applications": 17502, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17502, "child_cap_hits": 17502, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17502, "child_moves_before_total": 1352199, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1352199, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 283287, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 283287, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.25968460747343, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.185978745286253, "tt_hits": 6405, "tt_cutoffs": 1671, "beta_cutoffs": 13375, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5110.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5837.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1879, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 170, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11688, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 113, 114, 126, 98, 66, 130, 146, 129, 131, 144, 99, 159, 174, 143, 96, 81, 141, 156, 127, 155, 85 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11643, "avg_search_time_ms": 1058.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 131605, "safety_nodes": 733, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 132338, "avg_nodes": 12030.727272727272, "eval_calls": 108770, "avg_eval_calls": 9888.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 108770, "pattern_eval_ns": 2277504, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.938714719132115, "pattern_frame_queries": 108770, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2277504, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.938714719132115, "pattern_frame_updates": 263116, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4084032626, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15521.795048571732, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21732, "avg_candidate_generations": 1975.6363636363637, "candidate_moves_total": 1699990, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.22519786489968, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 726, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 21721, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1699264, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 807337, "avg_legality_checks": 73394.27272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2936, "root_legality_checks": 726, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 806611, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2933, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3309362, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 300851.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7019935306, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2121.2352429259777, "renju_forbidden_checks": 59170, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5379.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 240212497, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4059.7008112219028, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3184, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26845547, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 32726, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 170411101, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23239, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42807247, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 148602, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 121217, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11019.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1128431945, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9309.18885139873, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 163384, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14853.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 524106686, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3207.821365617196, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2001717526, "stage_ordering_ns": 720464139, "stage_eval_ns": 4086310130, "stage_threat_ns": 4793742006, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 431644, "root_tactical_annotations": 1329, "search_tactical_annotations": 430315, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 263127, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1513917981, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 396907, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3045730821, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43510, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1557571821, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 131558, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 189960264, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 263116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33236348, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116350, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 255715601, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 237039, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1232017426, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78255, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10896592, "child_limit_applications": 21721, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21721, "child_cap_hits": 21721, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21721, "child_moves_before_total": 1696331, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1696331, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 373921, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 373921, "child_moves_after_max": 29, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 29, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.09635836287464, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.214723079047925, "tt_hits": 7695, "tt_cutoffs": 1067, "beta_cutoffs": 15556, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4521.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5249.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 992, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 32, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.2, "search_nodes": 405, "safety_nodes": 317, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 722, "avg_nodes": 72.2, "eval_calls": 395, "avg_eval_calls": 39.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 395, "line_shape_eval_ns": 375101, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 949.6227848101266, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 663, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.3, "candidate_moves_max": 77, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 663, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1146.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22053605, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1923.0558946634112, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 119361, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9946.75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 119361, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3850, "stage_ordering_ns": 450, "stage_eval_ns": 375101, "stage_threat_ns": 22060332, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 800, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21335310, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 61290, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 395, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 563041, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 790, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 100691, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 171, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4447, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 125, 128, 95, 66, 110, 140, 80, 96, 65 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 18, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.5714285714285716, "search_nodes": 290, "safety_nodes": 243, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 533, "avg_nodes": 76.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 283, "avg_eval_calls": 40.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 283, "line_shape_eval_ns": 136621, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 482.75971731448766, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 408, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 408, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 408, "avg_legality_checks": 58.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 408, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1222.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11714283, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1368.4910046728971, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 160801, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5742.892857142857, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 31800, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 129001, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 181321, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6715.592592592592, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.714285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 105321, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2633.025, "stage_move_gen_ns": 727914, "stage_ordering_ns": 330, "stage_eval_ns": 136621, "stage_threat_ns": 11356091, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 573, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 10759826, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 247921, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5100, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 294692, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 566, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53652, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5138.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6281.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 4423, "avg_search_time_ms": 631.8571428571429, "search_nodes": 85705, "safety_nodes": 215, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85920, "avg_nodes": 12274.285714285714, "eval_calls": 69829, "avg_eval_calls": 9975.57142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 69829, "pattern_eval_ns": 1271497, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.208724169041517, "pattern_frame_queries": 69829, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1271497, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.208724169041517, "pattern_frame_updates": 171352, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1218352824, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7110.234044539894, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14950, "avg_candidate_generations": 2135.714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 1124539, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.22, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 421, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 14943, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1124118, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 566079, "avg_legality_checks": 80868.42857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8215, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 566079, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8215, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1953080, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 279011.4285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2476026626, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1267.7548415835502, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37876, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5410.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 200842173, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5302.623640299926, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8387, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 45523473, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22775, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 128571400, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6674, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26520720, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 226580, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74229, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10604.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 493085645, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6642.762868959571, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110520, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15788.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 257772001, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2332.356143684401, "stage_move_gen_ns": 914616326, "stage_ordering_ns": 285024866, "stage_eval_ns": 1219624321, "stage_threat_ns": 1967629801, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 241603, "root_tactical_annotations": 1147, "search_tactical_annotations": 240456, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 171359, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 596753965, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 217782, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1270792138, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29928, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 655152480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85676, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80557165, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 171352, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13861286, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 59004, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 227075431, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 128845, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 388535367, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53754, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5665247, "child_limit_applications": 14943, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14943, "child_cap_hits": 14943, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14943, "child_moves_before_total": 1115903, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1115903, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 244658, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 244658, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.67730710031452, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.372749782506858, "tt_hits": 5066, "tt_cutoffs": 904, "beta_cutoffs": 10364, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 4.142857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 4.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4070.4285714285716, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5213.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1900, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 172, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8666, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 99, 127, 98, 100, 128, 96, 113, 143, 83, 68, 67, 115, 81, 129, 82, 52, 84, 85, 80 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8636, "avg_search_time_ms": 863.6, "search_nodes": 156772, "safety_nodes": 312, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 157084, "avg_nodes": 15708.4, "eval_calls": 127191, "avg_eval_calls": 12719.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 127191, "pattern_eval_ns": 2355021, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.51562610562068, "pattern_frame_queries": 127191, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2355021, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.51562610562068, "pattern_frame_updates": 313460, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3006753830, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9592.145185988644, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28137, "avg_candidate_generations": 2813.7, "candidate_moves_total": 1929538, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.5765362334293, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 558, "root_candidate_moves_max": 65, "search_candidate_generations": 28127, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1928980, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 936364, "avg_legality_checks": 93636.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 408, "root_legality_checks": 558, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 935806, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 408, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3515527, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 351552.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5084445186, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1446.2825021682381, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24885, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2488.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 74673942, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3000.761181434599, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 564, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2712753, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12992, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 58331099, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11327, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13627360, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2730, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 92590, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9259.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 580298642, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6267.400820822983, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 126712, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12671.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 257260111, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2030.2742518467076, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1470354297, "stage_ordering_ns": 536907118, "stage_eval_ns": 3009108851, "stage_threat_ns": 3565653816, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 416883, "root_tactical_annotations": 1883, "search_tactical_annotations": 415000, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 313470, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1210719711, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 391075, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2156274377, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56315, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1327106189, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 156730, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 161685716, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 313460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28075026, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 92899, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 105990836, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 241852, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 722823461, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 82132, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8898986, "child_limit_applications": 28127, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28127, "child_cap_hits": 28127, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28127, "child_moves_before_total": 1928572, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1928572, "child_moves_before_max": 94, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 94, "child_moves_after_total": 455238, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 455238, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.56657304369467, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.18508906033349, "tt_hits": 9741, "tt_cutoffs": 1412, "beta_cutoffs": 19963, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4032.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4832.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 299, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 21, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.3333333333333335, "search_nodes": 116, "safety_nodes": 611, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 727, "avg_nodes": 80.77777777777777, "eval_calls": 107, "avg_eval_calls": 11.88888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 107, "line_shape_eval_ns": 46110, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 430.93457943925233, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 496, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.111111111111114, "candidate_moves_max": 65, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 496, "root_candidate_moves_max": 65, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10270, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1141.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15433005, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1502.7268743914315, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2990, "stage_ordering_ns": 410, "stage_eval_ns": 46110, "stage_threat_ns": 12967666, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 223, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 12689444, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 148340, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6930, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 107, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107171, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 214, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22711, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5775.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6664.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 173, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14720, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 114, 115, 97, 82, 68, 126, 94, 124, 138, 125, 127, 95, 80, 141, 123, 140, 155, 143, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 37, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3636363636363638, "search_nodes": 252, "safety_nodes": 792, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1044, "avg_nodes": 94.9090909090909, "eval_calls": 241, "avg_eval_calls": 21.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 241, "line_shape_eval_ns": 193301, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 802.0788381742739, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 748, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.0, "candidate_moves_max": 82, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 748, "avg_legality_checks": 68.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 748, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13761, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1251.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27620395, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2007.150279776179, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.8181818181818181, "renju_forbidden_ns": 220071, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11003.55, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 43251, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 176820, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 32, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 358533, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11204.15625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 45, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 194301, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4317.8, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1904730, "stage_ordering_ns": 500, "stage_eval_ns": 193301, "stage_threat_ns": 22797843, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 493, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21897158, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 505923, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11220, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 334271, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60491, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14670, "avg_search_time_ms": 1333.6363636363637, "search_nodes": 184195, "safety_nodes": 222, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 184417, "avg_nodes": 16765.18181818182, "eval_calls": 150663, "avg_eval_calls": 13696.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 150663, "pattern_eval_ns": 3046240, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.21889913250101, "pattern_frame_queries": 150663, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3046240, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.21889913250101, "pattern_frame_updates": 368296, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3549633926, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9637.992066164172, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31800, "avg_candidate_generations": 2890.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 2737934, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.0985534591195, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 773, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 31789, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2737161, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1608657, "avg_legality_checks": 146241.54545454544, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10584, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1608657, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10584, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4193134, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 381194.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8537091713, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2035.9692089496782, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42166, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3833.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 378612062, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8979.084143622824, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10584, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 104535300, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22807, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 224920643, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8745, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 48832637, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 323482, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 128143, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11649.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1232610668, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9619.024589716177, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 183172, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16652.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 599754191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3274.267852073461, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3844167383, "stage_ordering_ns": 1099546976, "stage_eval_ns": 3552680166, "stage_threat_ns": 6100536110, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 507697, "root_tactical_annotations": 2662, "search_tactical_annotations": 505035, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 368307, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2048676895, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 455533, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3742526338, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 63646, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2152359511, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 184148, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 250968900, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 368296, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43983164, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 149312, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 628467774, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 242566, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 961648632, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 115819, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14380813, "child_limit_applications": 31789, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31789, "child_cap_hits": 31789, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31789, "child_moves_before_total": 2726577, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2726577, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 509478, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 509478, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.7710843373494, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.026864638711505, "tt_hits": 12697, "tt_cutoffs": 1696, "beta_cutoffs": 21866, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3697.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4368.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1831, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 174, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11214, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 82, 124, 68, 54, 114, 98, 84, 125, 127, 139, 97, 154, 140, 169, 109, 184 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11178, "avg_search_time_ms": 1117.8, "search_nodes": 144112, "safety_nodes": 251, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 144363, "avg_nodes": 14436.3, "eval_calls": 117483, "avg_eval_calls": 11748.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 117483, "pattern_eval_ns": 2368981, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.164457836452932, "pattern_frame_queries": 117483, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2368981, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.164457836452932, "pattern_frame_updates": 288140, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3606567487, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12516.719257999584, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25362, "avg_candidate_generations": 2536.2, "candidate_moves_total": 2012165, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.33778881791658, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 664, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 25352, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2011501, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 881364, "avg_legality_checks": 88136.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1413, "root_legality_checks": 664, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 880700, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1413, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3074387, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 307438.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6497185537, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2113.3271566006492, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34008, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3400.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 185032974, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5440.866090331687, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1593, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13682061, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19643, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 142310116, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12772, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29040797, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 86697, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8669.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 779638986, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8992.687013391467, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 121371, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12137.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 353927089, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2916.0762373219304, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2089863764, "stage_ordering_ns": 799804971, "stage_eval_ns": 3608936468, "stage_threat_ns": 4640176628, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 389990, "root_tactical_annotations": 2047, "search_tactical_annotations": 387943, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 288150, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1597748758, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 356519, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2796061832, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50765, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1736060604, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 144070, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 200850984, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 288140, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34321013, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 110575, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 224884121, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 195171, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 835014767, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 84244, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11194041, "child_limit_applications": 25352, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25352, "child_cap_hits": 25352, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25352, "child_moves_before_total": 2010088, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2010088, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 406073, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 406073, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.28715683180815, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.017395077311456, "tt_hits": 9716, "tt_cutoffs": 1235, "beta_cutoffs": 17636, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3444.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4244.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 963, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.888888888888889, "search_nodes": 201, "safety_nodes": 683, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 192, "avg_eval_calls": 21.333333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 192, "line_shape_eval_ns": 138421, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 720.9427083333334, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 605, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_max": 80, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 605, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10548, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1172.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19089278, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1809.753318164581, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3270, "stage_ordering_ns": 420, "stage_eval_ns": 138421, "stage_threat_ns": 16924683, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 393, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16414700, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 191280, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 192, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 270762, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47941, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5773.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 175, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23097, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 142, 157, 111, 110, 68, 98, 66, 125, 126, 141, 109, 185, 124, 143, 129, 130, 146, 113, 83, 158, 128, 173, 189, 171, 199, 203, 188, 140, 69, 55, 67, 65, 70 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 42, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.3333333333333335, "search_nodes": 349, "safety_nodes": 1727, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2076, "avg_nodes": 115.33333333333333, "eval_calls": 331, "avg_eval_calls": 18.38888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 331, "line_shape_eval_ns": 205124, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 619.7099697885196, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1467, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.5, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1467, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1467, "avg_legality_checks": 81.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 1467, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22610, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1256.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31974464, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1414.1735515258736, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.16666666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2990, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 996.6666666666666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2990, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 63, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 468331, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7433.825396825397, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 93, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.166666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 258690, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2781.6129032258063, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2481213, "stage_ordering_ns": 830, "stage_eval_ns": 205124, "stage_threat_ns": 25992899, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 680, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24953968, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 47, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 648111, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12840, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 331, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 332500, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 662, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58320, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 18, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 18, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6887.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7332.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 23036, "avg_search_time_ms": 1355.0588235294117, "search_nodes": 288866, "safety_nodes": 348, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 289214, "avg_nodes": 17012.58823529412, "eval_calls": 219389, "avg_eval_calls": 12905.235294117647, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 219389, "pattern_eval_ns": 4225016, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.258103186577266, "pattern_frame_queries": 219389, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4225016, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.258103186577266, "pattern_frame_updates": 577572, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4356883162, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7543.445946133123, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 65155, "avg_candidate_generations": 3832.6470588235293, "candidate_moves_total": 6135570, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.16882817895787, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1385, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 65138, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6134185, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 4294880, "avg_legality_checks": 252640.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8660, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4294880, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8660, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9222116, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 542477.4117647059, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14414596910, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1563.046583885954, "renju_forbidden_checks": 66660, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3921.176470588235, "renju_forbidden_ns": 266407816, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3996.516891689169, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8662, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 59967780, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23253, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 145621398, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 34735, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 60719308, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 99330, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 292736, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17219.764705882353, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2164676876, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7394.6384318976825, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 422042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 24826.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1069004833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2532.934715028362, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7759086587, "stage_ordering_ns": 1798384381, "stage_eval_ns": 4361108178, "stage_threat_ns": 8944314880, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1322330, "root_tactical_annotations": 5421, "search_tactical_annotations": 1316909, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 577589, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2508150794, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1171077, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6015870017, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 130390, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3169261342, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 288786, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 328899686, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 577572, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56354422, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 470977, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1189973369, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 569696, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1656596266, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 281657, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 35039961, "child_limit_applications": 65138, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 65138, "child_cap_hits": 65138, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 65138, "child_moves_before_total": 6125525, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6125525, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 1044594, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1044594, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 94.03919371181185, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.036629924161012, "tt_hits": 27150, "tt_cutoffs": 4259, "beta_cutoffs": 50842, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6007.823529411765, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6478.411764705882, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1933, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 176, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9175, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 82, 97, 98, 95, 84, 94, 93, 70, 83, 81, 113, 128, 85, 86, 99, 71, 141 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9146, "avg_search_time_ms": 1016.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 131254, "safety_nodes": 274, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 131528, "avg_nodes": 14614.222222222223, "eval_calls": 105065, "avg_eval_calls": 11673.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105065, "pattern_eval_ns": 2077840, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.776709655927284, "pattern_frame_queries": 105065, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2077840, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.776709655927284, "pattern_frame_updates": 262434, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2821835391, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10752.552607512745, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25168, "avg_candidate_generations": 2796.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 1934266, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.8541799109981, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 561, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 25159, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1933705, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 863548, "avg_legality_checks": 95949.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 850, "root_legality_checks": 561, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 862987, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 850, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2802345, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 311371.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5331512544, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1902.518263811201, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24870, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2763.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 100276888, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4032.0421391234418, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1103, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6982117, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13400, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 76108365, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10365, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17182686, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3720, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 71102, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7900.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 544545585, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7658.653554049112, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95986, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10665.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 224472326, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2338.594440855958, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1809817936, "stage_ordering_ns": 679533845, "stage_eval_ns": 2823913231, "stage_threat_ns": 3791281053, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 292569, "root_tactical_annotations": 1801, "search_tactical_annotations": 290768, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 262443, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1331978417, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 278876, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2256367732, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50372, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1493474352, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 131217, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 166237401, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 262434, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28653171, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 55863, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 101461817, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 172634, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 661357432, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 64072, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8044332, "child_limit_applications": 25159, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25159, "child_cap_hits": 25159, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25159, "child_moves_before_total": 1932855, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1932855, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 402637, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 402637, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.82558925235502, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.003696490321556, "tt_hits": 8775, "tt_cutoffs": 994, "beta_cutoffs": 18302, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3157.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4046.222222222222, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 21, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.625, "search_nodes": 73, "safety_nodes": 744, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 817, "avg_nodes": 102.125, "eval_calls": 65, "avg_eval_calls": 8.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 65, "line_shape_eval_ns": 31611, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 486.32307692307694, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 497, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.125, "candidate_moves_max": 72, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 497, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9317, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1164.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15338776, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1646.3213480734141, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2560, "stage_ordering_ns": 400, "stage_eval_ns": 31611, "stage_threat_ns": 12263350, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 138, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 12007478, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 175901, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6900, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 65, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68571, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 130, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11400, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5497.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6497.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 177, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6833, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 129, 126, 99, 96, 130, 131, 141, 111, 66, 113, 114, 65, 49, 144, 69, 80, 84 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1818181818181817, "search_nodes": 325, "safety_nodes": 768, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1093, "avg_nodes": 99.36363636363636, "eval_calls": 314, "avg_eval_calls": 28.545454545454547, "line_shape_eval_calls": 314, "line_shape_eval_ns": 270523, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 861.5382165605096, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 737, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.0, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 737, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 737, "avg_legality_checks": 67.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 737, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13728, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1248.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24175875, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1761.0631555944055, "renju_forbidden_checks": 86, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7.818181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 777853, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9044.802325581395, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 162940, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 614913, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 611192, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9402.953846153847, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.636363636363637, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 343360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3614.315789473684, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1785987, "stage_ordering_ns": 550, "stage_eval_ns": 270523, "stage_threat_ns": 21807773, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 639, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20518419, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 795914, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10070, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 314, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 417280, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 628, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 76160, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6785, "avg_search_time_ms": 616.8181818181819, "search_nodes": 78681, "safety_nodes": 650, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 79331, "avg_nodes": 7211.909090909091, "eval_calls": 60447, "avg_eval_calls": 5495.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60447, "pattern_eval_ns": 1244459, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.58760567108376, "pattern_frame_queries": 60447, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1244459, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.58760567108376, "pattern_frame_updates": 157264, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1661940909, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10567.840758215485, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16578, "avg_candidate_generations": 1507.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 1281981, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.33025696706478, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 750, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 16567, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1281231, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 675448, "avg_legality_checks": 61404.36363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10405, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 675448, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10405, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2103231, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 191202.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3973938451, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1889.4445978591984, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35475, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3225.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 293896657, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8284.613305144469, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10477, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 93649838, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16283, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 150206930, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8625, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 49250620, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 90, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 789269, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81559, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7414.454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 769343766, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9432.972032516338, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 120646, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10967.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 396864670, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3289.4971238167864, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1571102814, "stage_ordering_ns": 479831096, "stage_eval_ns": 1663185368, "stage_threat_ns": 3030989126, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 287916, "root_tactical_annotations": 1285, "search_tactical_annotations": 286631, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 157275, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 835504427, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 260452, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2066821955, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33204, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1094969909, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78632, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 103927219, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 157264, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17846260, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 74118, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 368113636, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 153123, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 603650790, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 60675, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6889265, "child_limit_applications": 16567, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16567, "child_cap_hits": 16567, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16567, "child_moves_before_total": 1270826, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1270826, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 268741, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 268741, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.70827548741474, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.221464356853986, "tt_hits": 6340, "tt_cutoffs": 1618, "beta_cutoffs": 12579, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5200.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5927.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1850, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 178, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16116, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 67, 127, 126, 129, 140, 130, 131, 98, 83, 114, 82, 52, 84, 146, 162, 81, 69, 111, 68, 66, 99, 115, 54, 39, 40, 96, 26 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 16062, "avg_search_time_ms": 1147.2857142857142, "search_nodes": 186989, "safety_nodes": 384, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 187373, "avg_nodes": 13383.785714285714, "eval_calls": 143254, "avg_eval_calls": 10232.42857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 143254, "pattern_eval_ns": 2923208, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.40576877434487, "pattern_frame_queries": 143254, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2923208, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.40576877434487, "pattern_frame_updates": 373854, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4428885263, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11846.563800307073, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41316, "avg_candidate_generations": 2951.1428571428573, "candidate_moves_total": 3554273, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.02655145706264, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1063, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 41302, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3553210, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1422982, "avg_legality_checks": 101641.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2617, "root_legality_checks": 1063, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1421919, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2616, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4615310, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 329665.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9511780581, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2060.9191107422903, "renju_forbidden_checks": 73750, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5267.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 265735887, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3603.19846779661, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3916, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24270753, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 36278, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 174765292, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 33549, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 66646072, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 53770, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 153504, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10964.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1248744417, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8134.93079659162, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 198599, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14185.642857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 502227288, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2528.85104154603, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3353853326, "stage_ordering_ns": 1364582506, "stage_eval_ns": 4431808471, "stage_threat_ns": 6843726692, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 723634, "root_tactical_annotations": 3418, "search_tactical_annotations": 720216, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 373868, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2059017667, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 641071, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4457661315, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 82693, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2731008259, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 186927, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 260070364, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 373854, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44068732, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 219643, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 354129417, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 338724, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1372375898, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 165267, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22908614, "child_limit_applications": 41302, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41302, "child_cap_hits": 41302, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41302, "child_moves_before_total": 3550594, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3550594, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 699135, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 699135, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.96663599825675, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.92738850418866, "tt_hits": 16514, "tt_cutoffs": 2371, "beta_cutoffs": 32211, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 4.357142857142857, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 4.357142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4452.642857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5024.071428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 41, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1538461538461537, "search_nodes": 163, "safety_nodes": 1387, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1550, "avg_nodes": 119.23076923076923, "eval_calls": 150, "avg_eval_calls": 11.538461538461538, "line_shape_eval_calls": 150, "line_shape_eval_ns": 128170, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 854.4666666666667, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 998, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.76923076923077, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 998, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15229, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1171.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30431487, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1998.259045242629, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.3076923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42680, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10670.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 42680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5681, "stage_ordering_ns": 1040, "stage_eval_ns": 128170, "stage_threat_ns": 25077962, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 313, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24513667, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 312234, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13610, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 150, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 214801, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 300, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37260, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6459.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7074.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 179, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6932, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 114, 115, 127, 142, 94, 96, 68, 140, 128, 95, 98, 83, 143, 158, 174, 125, 80, 155 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 34, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4, "search_nodes": 252, "safety_nodes": 688, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 940, "avg_nodes": 94.0, "eval_calls": 242, "avg_eval_calls": 24.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 242, "line_shape_eval_ns": 167171, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 690.7892561983471, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 652, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.2, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 652, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 652, "avg_legality_checks": 65.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 652, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12495, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25216966, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2018.1645458183273, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3090, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1545.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3090, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 310041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11072.892857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 164110, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4002.682926829268, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1622797, "stage_ordering_ns": 580, "stage_eval_ns": 167171, "stage_threat_ns": 20968110, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 494, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20143516, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 431614, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10071, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 242, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 332480, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 484, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60500, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6887, "avg_search_time_ms": 688.7, "search_nodes": 85680, "safety_nodes": 366, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 86046, "avg_nodes": 8604.6, "eval_calls": 67857, "avg_eval_calls": 6785.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67857, "pattern_eval_ns": 1379995, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.336811235392073, "pattern_frame_queries": 67857, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1379995, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.336811235392073, "pattern_frame_updates": 171276, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1473286458, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8601.826630701324, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16891, "avg_candidate_generations": 1689.1, "candidate_moves_total": 1343965, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.56692913385827, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 675, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 16881, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1343290, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 802953, "avg_legality_checks": 80295.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 485, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 802953, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 485, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2074131, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 207413.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4096182492, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1974.8909263686817, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12561, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1256.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31797223, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2531.424488496139, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 487, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4945823, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1065, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9147122, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11004, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17646748, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57530, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 62758, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6275.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 588164240, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9371.94046974091, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92073, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9207.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 295661490, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3211.1638591117917, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1809225146, "stage_ordering_ns": 537059052, "stage_eval_ns": 1474666453, "stage_threat_ns": 3029162866, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 254951, "root_tactical_annotations": 1458, "search_tactical_annotations": 253493, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 171286, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 958582068, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 220800, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1922972822, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33823, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1153818353, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85638, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 119234122, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 171276, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20176419, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 55108, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 239869766, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 131863, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 529236463, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 67980, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8197435, "child_limit_applications": 16881, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16881, "child_cap_hits": 16881, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16881, "child_moves_before_total": 1342805, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1342805, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 270241, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 270241, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.5453468396422, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.008589538534448, "tt_hits": 6874, "tt_cutoffs": 900, "beta_cutoffs": 12408, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4790.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5590.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1867, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 180, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13093, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 96, 94, 142, 78, 62, 114, 80, 64, 127, 97, 99, 141, 143, 95, 128, 144, 98, 83, 158 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 13051, "avg_search_time_ms": 1186.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 173517, "safety_nodes": 248, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 173765, "avg_nodes": 15796.818181818182, "eval_calls": 141627, "avg_eval_calls": 12875.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 141627, "pattern_eval_ns": 2860009, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.193953130405927, "pattern_frame_queries": 141627, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2860009, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.193953130405927, "pattern_frame_updates": 346940, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4119175808, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11872.876601141408, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30392, "avg_candidate_generations": 2762.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 2538529, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.52622400631745, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 753, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 30381, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2537776, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1071846, "avg_legality_checks": 97440.54545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1699, "root_legality_checks": 753, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1071093, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1699, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3581613, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 325601.1818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7531096075, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2102.710726982508, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33738, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3067.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 195273084, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5787.927085185844, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1870, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17040697, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18694, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 147938809, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13174, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30293578, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 102211, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9291.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 885470633, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8663.163778849634, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137263, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12478.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 373981653, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2724.562722656506, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2487240639, "stage_ordering_ns": 992812194, "stage_eval_ns": 4122035817, "stage_threat_ns": 5392380527, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 439198, "root_tactical_annotations": 2503, "search_tactical_annotations": 436695, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 346951, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1916033848, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 398397, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3189038443, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60830, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1983943898, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 173470, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 234050654, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 346940, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40751598, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 109653, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 282846689, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 227905, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 922149936, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 101640, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12505984, "child_limit_applications": 30381, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30381, "child_cap_hits": 30381, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30381, "child_moves_before_total": 2536077, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2536077, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 486496, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 486496, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.47575787498765, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01316612356407, "tt_hits": 11759, "tt_cutoffs": 1462, "beta_cutoffs": 21058, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3684.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4412.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1004, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 33, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3, "search_nodes": 206, "safety_nodes": 849, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1055, "avg_nodes": 105.5, "eval_calls": 196, "avg_eval_calls": 19.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 196, "line_shape_eval_ns": 146993, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 749.9642857142857, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 688, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.8, "candidate_moves_max": 78, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 688, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11641, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1164.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23404315, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2010.5072588265614, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3920, "stage_ordering_ns": 520, "stage_eval_ns": 146993, "stage_threat_ns": 20183967, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 402, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19606792, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 259373, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10210, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 196, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 268621, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 392, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49181, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 181, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6960, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 83, 128, 81, 94, 82, 84, 80, 96, 79 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.857142857142857, "search_nodes": 290, "safety_nodes": 243, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 533, "avg_nodes": 76.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 283, "avg_eval_calls": 40.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 283, "line_shape_eval_ns": 200694, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 709.1660777385159, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 408, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 408, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 408, "avg_legality_checks": 58.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 408, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1222.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17506232, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2045.1205607476636, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 297872, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10638.285714285714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53471, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 244401, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 312382, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11569.703703703704, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.714285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 173040, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4326.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1086337, "stage_ordering_ns": 340, "stage_eval_ns": 200694, "stage_threat_ns": 16411154, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 573, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15528121, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 423732, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 388821, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 566, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 70480, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 6926, "avg_search_time_ms": 989.4285714285714, "search_nodes": 81524, "safety_nodes": 215, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 81739, "avg_nodes": 11677.0, "eval_calls": 66304, "avg_eval_calls": 9472.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 66304, "pattern_eval_ns": 1348638, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.340220801158303, "pattern_frame_queries": 66304, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1348638, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.340220801158303, "pattern_frame_updates": 162990, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1940237574, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11904.028308485184, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14504, "avg_candidate_generations": 2072.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1108875, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.45304743519029, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 421, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 14497, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1108454, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 568889, "avg_legality_checks": 81269.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8214, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 568889, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8214, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1954732, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 279247.4285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3951384448, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2021.4456242594893, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40439, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5777.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 384661721, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9512.147209377086, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8388, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 83859760, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24764, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 247529064, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7247, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 52841445, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 431452, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74725, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10675.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 779708560, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10434.37350284376, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110996, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15856.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 407930113, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3675.1785019279973, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1437991133, "stage_ordering_ns": 448118637, "stage_eval_ns": 1941586212, "stage_threat_ns": 3069716541, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 248563, "root_tactical_annotations": 1147, "search_tactical_annotations": 247416, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 162997, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 910974662, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 219055, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2019905570, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29036, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1044099854, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 81495, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112358211, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 162990, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19273198, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56513, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 359118525, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 133501, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 616638570, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 58549, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7204900, "child_limit_applications": 14497, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14497, "child_cap_hits": 14497, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14497, "child_moves_before_total": 1100240, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1100240, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 237056, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 237056, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.89432296337174, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.3520728426571, "tt_hits": 4939, "tt_cutoffs": 694, "beta_cutoffs": 10157, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 4.142857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 4.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3059.285714285714, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4072.714285714286, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1869, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 182, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13592, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 109, 144, 96, 95, 97, 127, 99, 100, 143, 129, 126, 125, 80, 159, 114, 130, 131, 158, 116, 160, 176, 161, 157, 162 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 13543, "avg_search_time_ms": 967.3571428571429, "search_nodes": 210887, "safety_nodes": 137, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 211024, "avg_nodes": 15073.142857142857, "eval_calls": 169364, "avg_eval_calls": 12097.42857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 169364, "pattern_eval_ns": 3304884, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.513497555560804, "pattern_frame_queries": 169364, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3304884, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.513497555560804, "pattern_frame_updates": 421650, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4027490957, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9551.739492470058, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39800, "avg_candidate_generations": 2842.8571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 3054155, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.73756281407036, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 884, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 39786, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3053271, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1227990, "avg_legality_checks": 87713.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2230, "root_legality_checks": 884, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1227106, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2228, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4334194, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 309585.28571428574, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7667664038, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1769.1095594705728, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35600, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2542.8571428571427, "renju_forbidden_ns": 137377020, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3858.9050561797753, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2562, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18098090, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18075, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 93166584, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14953, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26002265, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 110081, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 136671, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9762.214285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 891178487, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6520.6114464663315, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 174550, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12467.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 346373848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1984.381827556574, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2470857818, "stage_ordering_ns": 1061482098, "stage_eval_ns": 4030795841, "stage_threat_ns": 5912584134, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 624618, "root_tactical_annotations": 3411, "search_tactical_annotations": 621207, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 421664, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2004798059, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 560265, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3588459086, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 79661, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2345964559, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 210825, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 258978336, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 421650, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44246489, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 191857, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 263341789, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 288735, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 979141508, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 144026, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16102164, "child_limit_applications": 39786, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39786, "child_cap_hits": 39786, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39786, "child_moves_before_total": 3051043, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3051043, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 637784, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 637784, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.68634695621576, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.03036243904891, "tt_hits": 16303, "tt_cutoffs": 1675, "beta_cutoffs": 28686, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5045.214285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5616.642857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 944, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.923076923076923, "search_nodes": 144, "safety_nodes": 1187, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1331, "avg_nodes": 102.38461538461539, "eval_calls": 131, "avg_eval_calls": 10.076923076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 131, "line_shape_eval_ns": 105830, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 807.8625954198474, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 821, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.15384615384615, "candidate_moves_max": 79, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 821, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15051, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1157.7692307692307, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26281893, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1746.1891568666533, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.6153846153846154, "renju_forbidden_ns": 88571, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11071.375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 88571, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4820, "stage_ordering_ns": 610, "stage_eval_ns": 105830, "stage_threat_ns": 21906647, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 275, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21369005, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 323561, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12030, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 131, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 181750, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 262, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32331, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6458.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7074.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 183, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7464, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 82, 67, 98, 156, 114, 66, 130, 146, 83, 143, 96, 158, 173, 170, 184, 99, 95, 94, 111, 144, 145, 69, 79, 63, 125, 139, 81, 80, 126, 141, 140, 84, 154 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 63, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5, "search_nodes": 581, "safety_nodes": 1390, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1971, "avg_nodes": 109.5, "eval_calls": 563, "avg_eval_calls": 31.27777777777778, "line_shape_eval_calls": 563, "line_shape_eval_ns": 612591, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1088.0834813499112, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1474, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.88888888888889, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1474, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1474, "avg_legality_checks": 81.88888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "root_legality_checks": 1474, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1253.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 44096739, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1954.6426861702128, "renju_forbidden_checks": 64, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.5555555555555554, "renju_forbidden_ns": 658545, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10289.765625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 130020, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 528525, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 78, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 782534, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10032.48717948718, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 108, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 401012, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3713.074074074074, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3580479, "stage_ordering_ns": 940, "stage_eval_ns": 612591, "stage_threat_ns": 38577522, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1144, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 36713919, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 48, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 959715, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17760, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 563, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 768845, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1126, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 135043, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 18, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 18, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6886.944444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7331.388888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 7385, "avg_search_time_ms": 434.4117647058824, "search_nodes": 79160, "safety_nodes": 1808, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 80968, "avg_nodes": 4762.823529411765, "eval_calls": 61054, "avg_eval_calls": 3591.4117647058824, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 61054, "pattern_eval_ns": 1258525, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.61330952926917, "pattern_frame_queries": 61054, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1258525, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.61330952926917, "pattern_frame_updates": 158160, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1896442675, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11990.659300708143, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16573, "avg_candidate_generations": 974.8823529411765, "candidate_moves_total": 1410477, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.10692089543232, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1401, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 16556, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1409076, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 653261, "avg_legality_checks": 38427.117647058825, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4381, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 653261, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4381, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2085139, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 122655.23529411765, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4242693038, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2034.729117819004, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35456, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2085.6470588235293, "renju_forbidden_ns": 392068608, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11057.891696750903, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6239, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 83135080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14642, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 171974749, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14503, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 136181226, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 777553, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76225, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4483.823529411765, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 834872886, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10952.743666775992, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 111191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6540.64705882353, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 422405885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3798.9215404124434, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1599543115, "stage_ordering_ns": 536764318, "stage_eval_ns": 1897701200, "stage_threat_ns": 3304038661, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 343975, "root_tactical_annotations": 836, "search_tactical_annotations": 343139, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 158177, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 906715622, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 318895, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2260501972, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33226, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1151161620, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 111137662, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 158160, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18962140, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 91225, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 354880742, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 194435, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 754141698, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 58315, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6721265, "child_limit_applications": 16556, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16556, "child_cap_hits": 16556, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16556, "child_moves_before_total": 1404695, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1404695, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 272799, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 272799, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.8450712732544, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.477349601352984, "tt_hits": 5819, "tt_cutoffs": 1470, "beta_cutoffs": 12585, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6442.588235294118, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6913.176470588235, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1843, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 184, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23179, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 98, 143, 82, 158, 173, 142, 97, 67, 96, 99, 114, 66, 94, 95, 68, 110, 84, 126, 174, 157, 52, 100, 175, 172, 83, 187, 202, 81, 53, 38, 54, 40, 55, 51, 56 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 23108, "avg_search_time_ms": 1283.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 266101, "safety_nodes": 496, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 266597, "avg_nodes": 14810.944444444445, "eval_calls": 209458, "avg_eval_calls": 11636.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 209458, "pattern_eval_ns": 4316134, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.606202675476705, "pattern_frame_queries": 209458, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4316134, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.606202675476705, "pattern_frame_updates": 532038, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7432140291, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13969.190717580323, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52984, "avg_candidate_generations": 2943.5555555555557, "candidate_moves_total": 4386362, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.78653933262872, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1314, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 52966, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4385048, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1668784, "avg_legality_checks": 92710.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1244, "root_legality_checks": 1314, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1667470, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1243, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6593663, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 366314.6111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13700027281, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2077.7566704576802, "renju_forbidden_checks": 62397, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3466.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 293291203, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4700.405516290847, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2010, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15414221, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33153, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 219054938, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 27221, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 58747614, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 74430, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 237251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13180.611111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2008055223, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8463.8430312201, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 314937, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17496.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 848369052, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2693.773840482382, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3914799843, "stage_ordering_ns": 1668841905, "stage_eval_ns": 7436456425, "stage_threat_ns": 10015102797, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1326485, "root_tactical_annotations": 4225, "search_tactical_annotations": 1322260, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 532056, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3062432247, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1138760, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6460558692, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 106049, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3618810889, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 266019, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 384990596, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 532038, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65685038, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 464971, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 593891726, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 567726, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2247681826, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 293788, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 41436224, "child_limit_applications": 52966, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52966, "child_cap_hits": 52966, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52966, "child_moves_before_total": 4383805, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4383805, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 941131, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 941131, "child_moves_after_max": 32, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 32, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.76639731148283, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.7685873956878, "tt_hits": 22549, "tt_cutoffs": 3595, "beta_cutoffs": 40000, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4545.388888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4989.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 707, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 52, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0588235294117645, "search_nodes": 164, "safety_nodes": 1838, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2002, "avg_nodes": 117.76470588235294, "eval_calls": 147, "avg_eval_calls": 8.647058823529411, "line_shape_eval_calls": 147, "line_shape_eval_ns": 191551, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1303.0680272108843, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1250, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.52941176470588, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1250, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19522, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1148.3529411764705, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 38692018, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1981.9699825837517, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5882352941176471, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64851, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6485.1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 64851, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8020, "stage_ordering_ns": 830, "stage_eval_ns": 191551, "stage_threat_ns": 31558149, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 311, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 30871924, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 433804, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 215911, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 294, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36510, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6821.764705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7292.35294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 185, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6119, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 109, 108, 125, 97, 96, 81, 65, 128, 129, 98, 95, 80, 140, 155, 141, 83, 143, 68 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5, "search_nodes": 261, "safety_nodes": 575, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 836, "avg_nodes": 83.6, "eval_calls": 251, "avg_eval_calls": 25.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 251, "line_shape_eval_ns": 189551, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 755.183266932271, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 565, "avg_candidate_moves": 56.5, "candidate_moves_max": 73, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 565, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 565, "avg_legality_checks": 56.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 565, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12078, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1207.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24563571, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2033.7449080973672, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 116652, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9721.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21370, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 95282, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 459241, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10680.023255813954, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 62, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 249531, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4024.6935483870966, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1420696, "stage_ordering_ns": 520, "stage_eval_ns": 189551, "stage_threat_ns": 21202897, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 512, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20154452, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 635254, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10231, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 251, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 348141, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 502, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65050, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6074, "avg_search_time_ms": 607.4, "search_nodes": 66501, "safety_nodes": 463, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 66964, "avg_nodes": 6696.4, "eval_calls": 49722, "avg_eval_calls": 4972.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49722, "pattern_eval_ns": 999883, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.109468645669924, "pattern_frame_queries": 49722, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 999883, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.109468645669924, "pattern_frame_updates": 132918, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1345713254, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10124.386870100363, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15537, "avg_candidate_generations": 1553.7, "candidate_moves_total": 1084153, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.77878612344726, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 587, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 15527, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1083566, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 659610, "avg_legality_checks": 65961.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1347, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 659610, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1347, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2003067, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 200306.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3766841391, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1880.5368921758484, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18357, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1835.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 80790163, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4401.054801982895, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1357, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13780068, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4695, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43963370, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12295, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22923585, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 123140, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 79810, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7981.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 742807730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9307.201227916301, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 115472, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11547.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 366710990, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3175.7568068449496, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1493944273, "stage_ordering_ns": 416918292, "stage_eval_ns": 1346713137, "stage_threat_ns": 2779958597, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 250794, "root_tactical_annotations": 1172, "search_tactical_annotations": 249622, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 132928, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 718766477, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 220282, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1950196290, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31115, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1032088649, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66459, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88400879, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 132918, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15439895, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 57775, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 339790546, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 131386, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 578226385, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 61633, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7155056, "child_limit_applications": 15527, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15527, "child_cap_hits": 15527, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15527, "child_moves_before_total": 1082219, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1082219, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 248659, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 248659, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.69916918915438, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01461969472532, "tt_hits": 6257, "tt_cutoffs": 1210, "beta_cutoffs": 12240, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4949.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5749.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1844, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 186, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9701, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 141, 155, 99, 85, 140, 139, 97, 123, 107, 108, 109, 153, 167, 138, 93, 168 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9665, "avg_search_time_ms": 966.5, "search_nodes": 127981, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 128212, "avg_nodes": 12821.2, "eval_calls": 104334, "avg_eval_calls": 10433.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 104334, "pattern_eval_ns": 2137705, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.489054383039086, "pattern_frame_queries": 104334, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2137705, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.489054383039086, "pattern_frame_updates": 255878, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3124580008, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12211.210061044716, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22300, "avg_candidate_generations": 2230.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1788494, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.20152466367713, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 22290, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1787854, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 743916, "avg_legality_checks": 74391.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 484, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 743276, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 483, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2598874, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 259887.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5575201752, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2145.237418974525, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25773, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2577.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 102628913, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3982.0320878438674, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1082, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4599460, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14929, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 81768694, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9757, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16210819, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 49940, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64260, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6426.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 520086992, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8093.479489573607, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 83153, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8315.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 213008785, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2561.6488280639305, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1775068131, "stage_ordering_ns": 719078604, "stage_eval_ns": 3126717713, "stage_threat_ns": 4005234708, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 341407, "root_tactical_annotations": 1928, "search_tactical_annotations": 339479, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 255888, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1430335718, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 309910, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2351740610, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44641, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1583935712, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 127939, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 182037520, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 255878, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30841967, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 94380, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 98132827, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 170881, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 669533360, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76146, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10278893, "child_limit_applications": 22290, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22290, "child_cap_hits": 22290, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22290, "child_moves_before_total": 1787371, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1787371, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 356773, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 356773, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.18712427097353, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.005966801256168, "tt_hits": 9226, "tt_cutoffs": 1315, "beta_cutoffs": 15398, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4458.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5258.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1215, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44570, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 768.448275862069, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21098352, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2021.6895362207742, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44130, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11032.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 44130, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3410, "stage_ordering_ns": 510, "stage_eval_ns": 44570, "stage_threat_ns": 16719899, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16425398, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 195081, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 84590, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14830, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 187, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15534, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 113, 66, 141, 99, 126, 156, 125, 128, 109, 157, 79, 143, 124, 123, 94, 139, 64 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4545454545454546, "search_nodes": 196, "safety_nodes": 750, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 946, "avg_nodes": 86.0, "eval_calls": 185, "avg_eval_calls": 16.818181818181817, "line_shape_eval_calls": 185, "line_shape_eval_ns": 123670, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 668.4864864864865, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 670, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.90909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 670, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 670, "avg_legality_checks": 60.90909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "root_legality_checks": 670, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13538, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1230.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27455695, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2028.0466095435072, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.454545454545454, "renju_forbidden_ns": 659384, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10989.733333333334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 127120, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 532264, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 757964, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11312.89552238806, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 99, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 424380, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4286.666666666667, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1788308, "stage_ordering_ns": 530, "stage_eval_ns": 123670, "stage_threat_ns": 22705725, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 381, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21510221, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 895174, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 253140, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 370, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47190, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 15486, "avg_search_time_ms": 1407.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 174160, "safety_nodes": 196, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 174356, "avg_nodes": 15850.545454545454, "eval_calls": 141414, "avg_eval_calls": 12855.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 141414, "pattern_eval_ns": 2913315, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.601319529890958, "pattern_frame_queries": 141414, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2913315, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.601319529890958, "pattern_frame_updates": 348226, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4336500362, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12453.120565379955, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30689, "avg_candidate_generations": 2789.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 2395440, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.05532927107433, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 693, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 30678, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2394747, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 1360960, "avg_legality_checks": 123723.63636363637, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15893, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1360960, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15893, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4672740, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 424794.54545454547, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9298988032, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1990.0503841429227, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58206, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5291.454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 513778338, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8826.896505514895, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15893, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 157116217, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 31010, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 296699877, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11218, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 59038112, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 85, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 924132, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 194067, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17642.454545454544, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1966300674, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10132.071264047983, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 283883, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25807.545454545456, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1012603574, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3566.975035489973, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3392343518, "stage_ordering_ns": 894756649, "stage_eval_ns": 4339413677, "stage_threat_ns": 6793181753, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 754227, "root_tactical_annotations": 2343, "search_tactical_annotations": 751884, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 348237, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1967400628, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 642070, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4516207773, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61424, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2032730154, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 174113, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 244569570, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 348226, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41884401, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 236581, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1003523287, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 344056, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1479900952, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 173590, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23119381, "child_limit_applications": 30678, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30678, "child_cap_hits": 30678, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30678, "child_moves_before_total": 2378854, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2378854, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 523840, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 523840, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.5426690136254, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.075428645935197, "tt_hits": 12000, "tt_cutoffs": 2021, "beta_cutoffs": 21529, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.5454545454545454, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3332.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3928.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1848, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 188, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20742, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 81, 126, 67, 141, 156, 127, 95, 53, 82, 52, 83, 80, 85, 84, 51, 99, 65, 113, 155, 142, 37, 79, 154, 157, 66, 172, 187, 68, 36, 21, 35, 19, 34, 38, 33 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 20672, "avg_search_time_ms": 1148.4444444444443, "search_nodes": 259571, "safety_nodes": 504, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 260075, "avg_nodes": 14448.611111111111, "eval_calls": 203218, "avg_eval_calls": 11289.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 203218, "pattern_eval_ns": 4124335, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.29512641596709, "pattern_frame_queries": 203218, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4124335, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.29512641596709, "pattern_frame_updates": 518978, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6267576402, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12076.767034440767, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52850, "avg_candidate_generations": 2936.1111111111113, "candidate_moves_total": 4360812, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.51299905392621, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1324, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 52832, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4359488, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1648066, "avg_legality_checks": 91559.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1071, "root_legality_checks": 1324, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1646742, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1070, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6073587, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 337421.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12105332418, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1993.1108944351995, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54003, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3000.1666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 223110010, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4131.437327555876, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1948, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13499623, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28063, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 157958441, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23980, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 51588355, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 63591, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 215790, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11988.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1673407022, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7754.794114648501, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 276848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15380.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 683673252, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2469.4895827313185, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3750052746, "stage_ordering_ns": 1560699084, "stage_eval_ns": 6271700737, "stage_threat_ns": 9003901435, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1285277, "root_tactical_annotations": 4268, "search_tactical_annotations": 1281009, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 518996, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2839172017, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1111285, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5703827569, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 105781, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3289103816, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 259489, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 363533646, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 518978, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61388042, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 482912, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 556058926, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 522578, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1858487126, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 279787, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 35980161, "child_limit_applications": 52832, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52832, "child_cap_hits": 52832, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52832, "child_moves_before_total": 4358418, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4358418, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 936713, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 936713, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.49579800121138, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.730031041792852, "tt_hits": 22624, "tt_cutoffs": 3439, "beta_cutoffs": 40089, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5403.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5847.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 770, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 52, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0588235294117645, "search_nodes": 164, "safety_nodes": 1859, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2023, "avg_nodes": 119.0, "eval_calls": 147, "avg_eval_calls": 8.647058823529411, "line_shape_eval_calls": 147, "line_shape_eval_ns": 189201, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1287.0816326530612, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1268, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.58823529411765, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1268, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19582, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1151.8823529411766, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 38581586, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1970.2576856296598, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5882352941176471, "renju_forbidden_ns": 58110, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5811.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 58110, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7500, "stage_ordering_ns": 870, "stage_eval_ns": 189201, "stage_threat_ns": 31473926, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 311, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 30799192, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 418372, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 219672, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 294, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36690, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6821.764705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7292.35294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 189, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9929, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 110, 109, 96, 100, 95, 128, 86, 99, 101, 84, 129, 54, 69, 116, 68, 82, 130, 50, 53, 66 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.4545454545454546, "search_nodes": 274, "safety_nodes": 666, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 940, "avg_nodes": 85.45454545454545, "eval_calls": 263, "avg_eval_calls": 23.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 263, "line_shape_eval_ns": 180620, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 686.768060836502, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 665, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.45454545454545, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 665, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 665, "avg_legality_checks": 60.45454545454545, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 665, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13559, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1232.6363636363637, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19009936, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1402.0160778818497, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.909090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 201390, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6293.4375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 38140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 163250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.636363636363637, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 499781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6846.315068493151, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.181818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 290700, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2595.535714285714, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1118674, "stage_ordering_ns": 480, "stage_eval_ns": 180620, "stage_threat_ns": 16866332, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 537, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15874026, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 617952, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 263, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 319003, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55351, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9891, "avg_search_time_ms": 899.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 155969, "safety_nodes": 196, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 156165, "avg_nodes": 14196.818181818182, "eval_calls": 125269, "avg_eval_calls": 11388.09090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 125269, "pattern_eval_ns": 2343611, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.708627034621493, "pattern_frame_queries": 125269, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2343611, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.708627034621493, "pattern_frame_updates": 311840, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2638708630, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8461.738808363263, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28949, "avg_candidate_generations": 2631.7272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 2237814, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.30194479947494, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 680, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 28938, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2237134, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 1318241, "avg_legality_checks": 119840.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10736, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1318241, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10736, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4583943, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 416722.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5894862874, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1285.9808409485022, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35186, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3198.7272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 202203407, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5746.700591144205, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10736, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 68533778, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17528, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 106809933, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6877, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26561136, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 298560, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 201849, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18349.909090909092, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1373020461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6802.215819746444, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 305648, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27786.18181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 739780370, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2420.3671216562843, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2098423448, "stage_ordering_ns": 596485555, "stage_eval_ns": 2641052241, "stage_threat_ns": 4487425268, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 693524, "root_tactical_annotations": 2456, "search_tactical_annotations": 691068, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 311851, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1230107711, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 586569, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3048976106, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 57946, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1359724051, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 155920, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 162984325, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 311840, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28045315, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 221559, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 743828344, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 307055, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 945372520, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 164910, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17311811, "child_limit_applications": 28938, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28938, "child_cap_hits": 28938, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28938, "child_moves_before_total": 2226398, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2226398, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 510761, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 510761, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.93683046513235, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.65018315018315, "tt_hits": 11727, "tt_cutoffs": 1713, "beta_cutoffs": 20843, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5197.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5924.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1872, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 190, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7003, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 82, 66, 130, 146, 81, 80, 128, 94, 52, 109, 110, 64, 48, 79, 49, 124 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6969, "avg_search_time_ms": 696.9, "search_nodes": 98420, "safety_nodes": 228, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 98648, "avg_nodes": 9864.8, "eval_calls": 76304, "avg_eval_calls": 7630.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 76304, "pattern_eval_ns": 1517769, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.89108041518138, "pattern_frame_queries": 76304, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1517769, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.89108041518138, "pattern_frame_updates": 196756, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2010028265, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10215.84228689341, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20856, "avg_candidate_generations": 2085.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1600888, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.759110088224, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 638, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 20846, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1600250, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 575014, "avg_legality_checks": 57501.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 227, "root_legality_checks": 638, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 574376, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 226, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2004295, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 200429.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3984955529, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1988.2080876318107, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19829, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1982.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66093925, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3333.195067829946, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 649, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2533118, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10757, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 50565715, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8418, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12962612, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 32480, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46888, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4688.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 374388037, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7984.7303574475345, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 60401, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6040.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 153055286, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2533.9859604973426, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1316293119, "stage_ordering_ns": 555846740, "stage_eval_ns": 2011546034, "stage_threat_ns": 3037256862, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 311808, "root_tactical_annotations": 1929, "search_tactical_annotations": 309879, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 196766, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1023376530, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 274422, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1856429218, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41753, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1298717575, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 98378, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 127327832, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 196756, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22193128, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 89545, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 69604988, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 143116, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 487963394, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79147, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7930154, "child_limit_applications": 20846, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20846, "child_cap_hits": 20846, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20846, "child_moves_before_total": 1600024, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1600024, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 333587, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 333587, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.75448527295404, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002446512520386, "tt_hits": 9136, "tt_cutoffs": 1228, "beta_cutoffs": 15821, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4773.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5573.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1304, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 22, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.4444444444444446, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 820, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 887, "avg_nodes": 98.55555555555556, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 42671, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 735.7068965517242, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 580, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10420, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1157.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17816184, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1709.8065259117081, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.1111111111111112, "renju_forbidden_ns": 35520, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3552.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 35520, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3120, "stage_ordering_ns": 420, "stage_eval_ns": 42671, "stage_threat_ns": 14426757, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14133975, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 193192, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8130, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 84700, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14890, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 191, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9283, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 82, 67, 96, 128, 81, 156, 114, 141, 171, 140, 143, 124, 172, 94, 158, 139, 138, 109, 154, 79 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 22, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.0, "search_nodes": 196, "safety_nodes": 750, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 946, "avg_nodes": 86.0, "eval_calls": 185, "avg_eval_calls": 16.818181818181817, "line_shape_eval_calls": 185, "line_shape_eval_ns": 76311, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 412.4918918918919, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 670, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.90909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 670, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 670, "avg_legality_checks": 60.90909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "root_legality_checks": 670, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13604, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1236.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15828711, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1163.5335930608644, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.454545454545454, "renju_forbidden_ns": 340772, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5679.533333333334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 70771, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 270001, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 462792, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6907.3432835820895, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 99, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 263612, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2662.747474747475, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1053508, "stage_ordering_ns": 460, "stage_eval_ns": 76311, "stage_threat_ns": 13558518, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 381, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 12801346, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 545592, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6020, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 177960, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 370, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33620, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6180.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6907.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9252, "avg_search_time_ms": 841.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 174143, "safety_nodes": 196, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 174339, "avg_nodes": 15849.0, "eval_calls": 141422, "avg_eval_calls": 12856.545454545454, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 141422, "pattern_eval_ns": 2567134, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.152295965267072, "pattern_frame_queries": 141422, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2567134, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.152295965267072, "pattern_frame_updates": 348192, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2627566239, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7546.314214571271, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30688, "avg_candidate_generations": 2789.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2429428, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.16540667361835, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 693, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 30677, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2428735, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1382367, "avg_legality_checks": 125669.72727272728, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15869, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1382367, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15869, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4716976, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 428816.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5353705839, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1134.9868727337175, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56969, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5179.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 278365121, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4886.2560515368, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15869, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 85003304, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29894, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 160931085, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11121, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31961822, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 85, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 468910, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 194056, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17641.454545454544, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1142114434, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5885.488900111308, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 283879, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25807.18181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 593779670, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2091.6646528978895, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1945925161, "stage_ordering_ns": 541962566, "stage_eval_ns": 2630133373, "stage_threat_ns": 4056585329, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 756340, "root_tactical_annotations": 2343, "search_tactical_annotations": 753997, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 348203, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1176609821, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 644252, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2671169866, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61422, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1208257280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 174096, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 162096021, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 348192, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27258097, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 236504, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 589642501, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 346317, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 873237595, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 173519, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19451524, "child_limit_applications": 30677, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30677, "child_cap_hits": 30677, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30677, "child_moves_before_total": 2412866, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2412866, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 523865, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 523865, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.65391009551129, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.076800208625354, "tt_hits": 11971, "tt_cutoffs": 1997, "beta_cutoffs": 21534, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5625.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6352.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1884, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 192, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12884, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 96, 141, 82, 156, 171, 142, 110, 68, 97, 67, 98, 95, 100, 99, 66, 114, 80, 128, 170, 157, 52, 94, 169, 172, 81, 187, 202, 83, 51, 36, 50, 34, 49, 53, 48 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 12836, "avg_search_time_ms": 713.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 258338, "safety_nodes": 496, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 258834, "avg_nodes": 14379.666666666666, "eval_calls": 202168, "avg_eval_calls": 11231.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 202168, "pattern_eval_ns": 3676902, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.187359028135017, "pattern_frame_queries": 202168, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3676902, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.187359028135017, "pattern_frame_updates": 516512, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4011608548, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7766.728649092373, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52710, "avg_candidate_generations": 2928.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 4392175, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.32716752039461, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1323, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 52692, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4390852, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1672518, "avg_legality_checks": 92917.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1102, "root_legality_checks": 1323, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1671195, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1101, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6158062, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 342114.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7263849635, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1179.5674735005916, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55252, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3069.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 139777249, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2529.813382321002, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1939, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7840098, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27715, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 99883737, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25585, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32010494, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 42920, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 214580, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11921.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 999095041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4656.049217075217, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 277324, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15406.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 414649270, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1495.1798978811787, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2241612946, "stage_ordering_ns": 932774149, "stage_eval_ns": 4015285450, "stage_threat_ns": 5534215026, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1274299, "root_tactical_annotations": 4270, "search_tactical_annotations": 1270029, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 516530, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1745938189, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1102967, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3481670678, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 105501, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2027023405, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 258256, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 239541012, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 516512, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40585463, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 478518, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 339596012, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 518934, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1114945771, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 276847, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26479684, "child_limit_applications": 52692, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52692, "child_cap_hits": 52692, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52692, "child_moves_before_total": 4389751, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4389751, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 931515, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 931515, "child_moves_after_max": 29, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 29, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.30962954528202, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.678490093372808, "tt_hits": 22478, "tt_cutoffs": 3396, "beta_cutoffs": 39940, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6463.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6907.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1260, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 1.8235294117647058, "search_nodes": 164, "safety_nodes": 1846, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2010, "avg_nodes": 118.23529411764706, "eval_calls": 147, "avg_eval_calls": 8.647058823529411, "line_shape_eval_calls": 147, "line_shape_eval_ns": 118651, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 807.1496598639455, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1260, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.11764705882354, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1260, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19558, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1150.4705882352941, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25048092, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1280.7082523775437, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5882352941176471, "renju_forbidden_ns": 35980, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3598.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 35980, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6110, "stage_ordering_ns": 750, "stage_eval_ns": 118651, "stage_threat_ns": 21078229, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 311, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20626287, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 278791, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 148951, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 294, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24200, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6822.529411764706, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7293.117647058823, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 193, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8068, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 67, 127, 142, 96, 128, 83, 114, 100, 143, 158, 144, 141, 129, 99, 115, 157, 130, 116, 146, 162, 145 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 32, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.909090909090909, "search_nodes": 208, "safety_nodes": 729, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 937, "avg_nodes": 85.18181818181819, "eval_calls": 197, "avg_eval_calls": 17.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 197, "line_shape_eval_ns": 172480, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 875.5329949238578, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 626, "avg_candidate_moves": 56.90909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 72, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 626, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 626, "avg_legality_checks": 56.90909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 626, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1219.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22898394, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1707.0518860891607, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.6363636363636362, "renju_forbidden_ns": 436922, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10923.05, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 83431, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 353491, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 467412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8988.692307692309, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 262240, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3450.5263157894738, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1446316, "stage_ordering_ns": 490, "stage_eval_ns": 172480, "stage_threat_ns": 19426028, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 405, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18494175, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 609123, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 270710, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52020, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8025, "avg_search_time_ms": 729.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 92582, "safety_nodes": 193, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92775, "avg_nodes": 8434.09090909091, "eval_calls": 63480, "avg_eval_calls": 5770.909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 63480, "pattern_eval_ns": 1217834, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.184530560806554, "pattern_frame_queries": 63480, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1217834, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.184530560806554, "pattern_frame_updates": 185062, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1687539571, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9118.77949552042, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27166, "avg_candidate_generations": 2469.6363636363635, "candidate_moves_total": 2026957, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.6137451225797, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 659, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 27155, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2026298, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 1292138, "avg_legality_checks": 117467.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16292, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1292138, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16292, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3355066, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 305006.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4870372199, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1451.6472102188154, "renju_forbidden_checks": 51132, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4648.363636363636, "renju_forbidden_ns": 326029725, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6376.236505515138, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16398, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 114513423, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22312, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 159505622, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12362, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 51380198, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 630482, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 123269, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11206.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 888473472, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7207.598601432639, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 170517, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15501.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 443789232, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2602.609898133324, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2210571801, "stage_ordering_ns": 578049242, "stage_eval_ns": 1688757405, "stage_threat_ns": 3483702208, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 557240, "root_tactical_annotations": 2244, "search_tactical_annotations": 554996, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 185073, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 814294538, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 435562, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2524505072, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54382, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1366404271, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92531, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107099876, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 185062, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17910067, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 133608, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 451159419, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 247563, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 706889122, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 176069, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19892655, "child_limit_applications": 27155, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27155, "child_cap_hits": 27155, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27155, "child_moves_before_total": 2010006, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2010006, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 308664, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 308664, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.01973853802247, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.36674645553305, "tt_hits": 13467, "tt_cutoffs": 1896, "beta_cutoffs": 19536, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 4.636363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 4.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5584.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6311.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1624, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 194, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8920, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 83, 99, 85, 141, 155, 84, 69, 111, 53, 37, 52, 67, 55, 41, 54, 51, 56 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8883, "avg_search_time_ms": 888.3, "search_nodes": 94470, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 94701, "avg_nodes": 9470.1, "eval_calls": 61544, "avg_eval_calls": 6154.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 61544, "pattern_eval_ns": 1250827, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.324109580137787, "pattern_frame_queries": 61544, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1250827, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.324109580137787, "pattern_frame_updates": 188860, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2247302694, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11899.304744255003, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30698, "avg_candidate_generations": 3069.8, "candidate_moves_total": 2409417, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.48775164505831, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 30688, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2408777, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 700831, "avg_legality_checks": 70083.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 495, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 700191, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 494, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2445981, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 244598.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5192782695, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2122.9857038954924, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24603, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2460.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 109525906, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4451.729707759217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 995, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4396615, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13776, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 78986602, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9827, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26091649, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 51040, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47398, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4739.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 375530333, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7922.915165196844, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 61708, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6170.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 149538248, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2423.3202826213783, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1663674920, "stage_ordering_ns": 942265944, "stage_eval_ns": 2248553521, "stage_threat_ns": 3992279661, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 468366, "root_tactical_annotations": 1860, "search_tactical_annotations": 466506, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 188870, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1062307295, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 392346, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2753526272, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61435, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2064420535, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 94430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 135055286, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 188860, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22870131, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 100786, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 56687346, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 230117, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 632275811, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 137463, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18520677, "child_limit_applications": 30688, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30688, "child_cap_hits": 30688, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30688, "child_moves_before_total": 2408283, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2408283, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 272987, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 272987, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.47637513034411, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.895561783107404, "tt_hits": 15145, "tt_cutoffs": 2199, "beta_cutoffs": 23271, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 3.9, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 3.9, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4393.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5193.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1085, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44660, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 770.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20914316, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2004.054810272135, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43370, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10842.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 43370, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3530, "stage_ordering_ns": 330, "stage_eval_ns": 44660, "stage_threat_ns": 16564694, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16268854, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 196010, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 84770, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15060, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 195, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25454, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 110, 109, 126, 129, 125, 144, 99, 142, 100, 141, 143, 130, 131, 98, 146, 116, 158, 102, 88, 189, 159, 157, 172, 156, 170, 205, 147, 173 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 49, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.2666666666666666, "search_nodes": 460, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1257, "avg_nodes": 83.8, "eval_calls": 445, "avg_eval_calls": 29.666666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 445, "line_shape_eval_ns": 608022, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1366.3415730337078, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 961, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.06666666666666, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 961, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 961, "avg_legality_checks": 64.06666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 961, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18072, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1204.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 35082133, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1941.2424192120407, "renju_forbidden_checks": 81, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 865753, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10688.308641975309, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 171070, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 65, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 694683, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.933333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 685602, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11620.372881355932, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.733333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 386012, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4488.511627906977, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2406101, "stage_ordering_ns": 740, "stage_eval_ns": 608022, "stage_threat_ns": 30958769, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 905, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 29370860, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 877174, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 445, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 603603, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 890, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 107132, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 15, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 15, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6664.266666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7197.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 25386, "avg_search_time_ms": 1692.4, "search_nodes": 185000, "safety_nodes": 209, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 185209, "avg_nodes": 12347.266666666666, "eval_calls": 119573, "avg_eval_calls": 7971.533333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 119573, "pattern_eval_ns": 2466418, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.626880650314035, "pattern_frame_queries": 119573, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2466418, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.626880650314035, "pattern_frame_updates": 369842, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4835343377, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13074.078598428518, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 60476, "avg_candidate_generations": 4031.733333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4772879, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.92186983266089, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 993, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 60461, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4771886, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 3310465, "avg_legality_checks": 220697.66666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 28137, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3310465, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 28137, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8756157, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 583743.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16341288034, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1866.2625663290414, "renju_forbidden_checks": 120474, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8031.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 745859951, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6191.044964058635, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 30567, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 285728595, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37073, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 317671410, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 52734, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 141412720, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 100, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1047226, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 392546, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 26169.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3751822029, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9557.662105842373, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 588103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 39206.86666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1909329660, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3246.590580221492, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7429529769, "stage_ordering_ns": 1792138938, "stage_eval_ns": 4837809795, "stage_threat_ns": 11207797190, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1539059, "root_tactical_annotations": 4265, "search_tactical_annotations": 1534794, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 369857, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2036918171, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1367015, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8825230599, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 121030, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3908511230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 184921, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 265077442, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 369842, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44484053, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 397405, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1249500133, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 848567, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3667161446, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 293087, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 36086925, "child_limit_applications": 60461, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 60461, "child_cap_hits": 60461, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 60461, "child_moves_before_total": 4743749, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4743749, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 705557, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 705557, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.4596516762872, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.669621739633813, "tt_hits": 24963, "tt_cutoffs": 4892, "beta_cutoffs": 46979, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1008.9333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1321.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 196, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9194, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 142, 156, 100, 86, 141, 140, 98, 124, 108, 109, 110, 154, 168, 139, 94, 169 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9155, "avg_search_time_ms": 915.5, "search_nodes": 87274, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87505, "avg_nodes": 8750.5, "eval_calls": 56877, "avg_eval_calls": 5687.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 56877, "pattern_eval_ns": 1240763, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.814846071346942, "pattern_frame_queries": 56877, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1240763, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.814846071346942, "pattern_frame_updates": 174460, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2376826540, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13623.905422446405, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28488, "avg_candidate_generations": 2848.8, "candidate_moves_total": 2301158, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.77639707947206, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 28478, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2300518, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 641734, "avg_legality_checks": 64173.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 377, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 641094, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 376, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2324513, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 232451.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5387563293, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2317.716998356215, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20415, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2041.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 99114509, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4854.984521185403, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 720, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3805919, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11450, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71407254, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8240, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23840046, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61290, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44868, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4486.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 389577248, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8682.74155299991, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 57777, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5777.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 152250277, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2635.136421067207, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1640794465, "stage_ordering_ns": 968654166, "stage_eval_ns": 2378067303, "stage_threat_ns": 4136912326, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 439008, "root_tactical_annotations": 1864, "search_tactical_annotations": 437144, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 174470, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1075372205, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 370989, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2885779813, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 57019, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2172335586, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 87230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 135617690, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 174460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22982571, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 94481, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 65484683, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 219481, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 647808974, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 125046, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17160047, "child_limit_applications": 28478, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28478, "child_cap_hits": 28478, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28478, "child_moves_before_total": 2300142, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2300142, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 252361, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 252361, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.76908490764801, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.86161247278601, "tt_hits": 13875, "tt_cutoffs": 1876, "beta_cutoffs": 21685, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4258.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5058.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1013, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 46791, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 806.7413793103449, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1157.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22146365, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2126.5954484347994, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50400, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12600.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 50400, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3750, "stage_ordering_ns": 430, "stage_eval_ns": 46791, "stage_threat_ns": 17601074, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17279032, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 214822, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90830, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16390, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 197, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9508, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 109, 113, 114, 126, 98, 95, 82, 66, 99, 100, 84, 129, 83, 81, 67, 115, 68, 52, 54, 40, 69 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.272727272727273, "search_nodes": 208, "safety_nodes": 729, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 937, "avg_nodes": 85.18181818181819, "eval_calls": 197, "avg_eval_calls": 17.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 197, "line_shape_eval_ns": 173331, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 879.8527918781726, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 626, "avg_candidate_moves": 56.90909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 72, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 626, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 626, "avg_legality_checks": 56.90909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 626, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1219.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26822080, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1999.5586700462204, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.6363636363636362, "renju_forbidden_ns": 418424, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10460.6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 84880, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 333544, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 591663, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11378.134615384615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 328502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4322.394736842105, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1636937, "stage_ordering_ns": 530, "stage_eval_ns": 173331, "stage_threat_ns": 22237952, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 405, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21137848, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 774683, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 275941, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49480, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9460, "avg_search_time_ms": 860.0, "search_nodes": 82360, "safety_nodes": 193, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 82553, "avg_nodes": 7504.818181818182, "eval_calls": 56052, "avg_eval_calls": 5095.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 56052, "pattern_eval_ns": 1165726, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.797224006279883, "pattern_frame_queries": 56052, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1165726, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.797224006279883, "pattern_frame_updates": 164618, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1702907419, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10344.600341396444, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24699, "avg_candidate_generations": 2245.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 1844310, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.67144418802381, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 659, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 24688, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1843651, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1155417, "avg_legality_checks": 105037.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5343, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1155417, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5343, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3040055, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 276368.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6002206388, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1974.374275465411, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26984, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2453.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 178281085, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6606.918359027572, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5425, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53804190, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9266, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 86194169, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12233, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37661996, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 620730, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 119101, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10827.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1184286082, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9943.544403489475, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 175677, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15970.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 596725301, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3396.7184150457942, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2706727226, "stage_ordering_ns": 713637752, "stage_eval_ns": 1704073145, "stage_threat_ns": 4281484371, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 467342, "root_tactical_annotations": 2244, "search_tactical_annotations": 465098, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 164629, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 950115937, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 400473, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3180095576, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49448, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1660865139, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 82309, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 117408932, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 164618, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19934026, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 119920, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 480825936, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 231096, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1038351901, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 116326, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13929900, "child_limit_applications": 24688, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24688, "child_cap_hits": 24688, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24688, "child_moves_before_total": 1838308, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1838308, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 274047, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 274047, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.46160077770577, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.100413156189243, "tt_hits": 10720, "tt_cutoffs": 1570, "beta_cutoffs": 18087, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5172.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5899.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1604, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 198, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6984, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 81, 65, 129, 145, 80, 79, 127, 93, 51, 108, 109, 63, 47, 78, 48, 123 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6946, "avg_search_time_ms": 694.6, "search_nodes": 75683, "safety_nodes": 228, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 75911, "avg_nodes": 7591.1, "eval_calls": 50142, "avg_eval_calls": 5014.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50142, "pattern_eval_ns": 1022485, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.39178732399984, "pattern_frame_queries": 50142, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1022485, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.39178732399984, "pattern_frame_updates": 151286, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1742235318, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11516.170154541729, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23906, "avg_candidate_generations": 2390.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1789506, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.85593574834769, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 638, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 23896, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1788868, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 560595, "avg_legality_checks": 56059.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 486, "root_legality_checks": 638, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 559957, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 485, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1947854, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 194785.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4106916624, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2108.431445067238, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25296, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2529.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 90972497, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3596.3194576217584, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1043, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4533616, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14727, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64511254, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9521, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21873507, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 54120, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 40404, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4040.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 316857398, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7842.228442728443, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 52608, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5260.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 124940753, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2374.9382793491486, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1326033146, "stage_ordering_ns": 679407276, "stage_eval_ns": 1743257803, "stage_threat_ns": 3165358673, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 351240, "root_tactical_annotations": 1855, "search_tactical_annotations": 349385, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 151296, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 867868601, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 272194, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2156151017, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47851, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1636994302, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75643, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108043602, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 151286, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18279584, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 77361, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 54820516, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 146974, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 464197649, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 126905, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15015869, "child_limit_applications": 23896, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23896, "child_cap_hits": 23896, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23896, "child_moves_before_total": 1788383, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1788383, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 225289, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 225289, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.8402661533311, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.42789588215601, "tt_hits": 13403, "tt_cutoffs": 1605, "beta_cutoffs": 17923, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4739.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5539.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1206, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 820, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 887, "avg_nodes": 98.55555555555556, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44120, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 760.6896551724138, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 580, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10442, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1160.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20853467, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1997.0759433058802, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.1111111111111112, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61040, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6104.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61040, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3540, "stage_ordering_ns": 470, "stage_eval_ns": 44120, "stage_threat_ns": 16534987, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16253367, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 184950, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9220, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81920, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14750, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 199, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8921, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 115, 116, 129, 143, 95, 145, 128, 142, 141, 146, 99, 144 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 278, "safety_nodes": 236, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 514, "avg_nodes": 73.42857142857143, "eval_calls": 271, "avg_eval_calls": 38.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 271, "line_shape_eval_ns": 194910, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 719.2250922509226, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 389, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.57142857142857, "candidate_moves_max": 66, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 389, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 389, "avg_legality_checks": 55.57142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 389, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8373, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1196.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17052091, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2036.556909112624, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 114852, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10441.09090909091, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22130, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 92722, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 154782, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11906.307692307691, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 86811, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4569.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1009524, "stage_ordering_ns": 360, "stage_eval_ns": 194910, "stage_threat_ns": 15764336, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 549, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15090162, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 230182, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7100, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 271, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 376932, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 542, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67060, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 8888, "avg_search_time_ms": 1269.7142857142858, "search_nodes": 64537, "safety_nodes": 192, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 64729, "avg_nodes": 9247.0, "eval_calls": 37266, "avg_eval_calls": 5323.714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37266, "pattern_eval_ns": 781044, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.9586218000322, "pattern_frame_queries": 37266, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 781044, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.9586218000322, "pattern_frame_updates": 129000, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1219434369, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9452.979604651162, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24716, "avg_candidate_generations": 3530.8571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 1902860, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.98899498300696, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 399, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 24709, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1902461, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 1355866, "avg_legality_checks": 193695.14285714287, "illegal_moves_skipped": 358, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1355866, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 358, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2907235, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 415319.28571428574, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5995322066, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2062.207584182221, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12575, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1796.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14302121, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1137.345606361829, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 358, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3659718, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 864, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 4000030, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11343, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6538733, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 103640, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83218, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11888.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 813623056, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9777.008051142782, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 120980, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17282.85714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 404924738, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3347.038667548355, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3166111634, "stage_ordering_ns": 777906489, "stage_eval_ns": 1220215413, "stage_threat_ns": 3673660337, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 360247, "root_tactical_annotations": 1349, "search_tactical_annotations": 358898, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 129007, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 751056086, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 261917, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2790137018, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49468, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1730374952, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96049233, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 129000, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15851374, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 41611, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 215326113, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 170833, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 844384753, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 147803, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20566626, "child_limit_applications": 24709, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24709, "child_cap_hits": 24709, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24709, "child_moves_before_total": 1902103, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1902103, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 222565, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 222565, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.98016916912866, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.007446679347606, "tt_hits": 14403, "tt_cutoffs": 2525, "beta_cutoffs": 19568, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1666.5714285714287, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2399.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 49, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 200, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32274, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 115, 69, 95, 99, 79, 63, 84, 53, 70, 85, 56, 42, 101, 86, 71, 72, 100, 21, 37, 35, 7, 87, 57, 49, 77, 65, 94, 64, 97, 96, 80, 66, 62, 67 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 32194, "avg_search_time_ms": 1694.421052631579, "search_nodes": 332384, "safety_nodes": 601, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 332985, "avg_nodes": 17525.526315789473, "eval_calls": 201326, "avg_eval_calls": 10596.105263157895, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 201326, "pattern_eval_ns": 4147626, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.601541778011782, "pattern_frame_queries": 201326, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4147626, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.601541778011782, "pattern_frame_updates": 664568, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7124939075, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10721.15882046683, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 119883, "avg_candidate_generations": 6309.631578947368, "candidate_moves_total": 12164946, "avg_candidate_moves": 101.47348664948325, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1738, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 119864, "search_candidate_moves_total": 12163208, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 3132857, "avg_legality_checks": 164887.2105263158, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1147, "root_legality_checks": 1738, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3131119, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1147, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8905887, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 468730.8947368421, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18541772246, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2081.9680561857567, "renju_forbidden_checks": 53565, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2819.2105263157896, "renju_forbidden_ns": 207004480, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3864.5473723513487, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1680, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11448331, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24487, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 134004703, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 27391, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 61531876, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 19570, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 141764, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7461.263157894737, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1114608096, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7862.419909144775, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 182525, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9606.578947368422, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 471591642, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2583.709858923435, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7043568782, "stage_ordering_ns": 4192734888, "stage_eval_ns": 7129086701, "stage_threat_ns": 13685181390, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2121722, "root_tactical_annotations": 7460, "search_tactical_annotations": 2114262, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 664587, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3611872198, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1875037, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9460143528, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 239865, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6955568459, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 332284, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 472370934, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 664568, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 76551590, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 585523, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 261143179, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1049634, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2243345530, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 486565, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 64243140, "child_limit_applications": 119864, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 119864, "child_cap_hits": 119864, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 119864, "child_moves_before_total": 12162061, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 12162061, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 1119872, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1119872, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 101.46550256957886, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.342855235934058, "tt_hits": 58021, "tt_cutoffs": 11100, "beta_cutoffs": 94972, "depth_sum": 93, "avg_depth": 4.894736842105263, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 93, "avg_effective_depth": 4.894736842105263, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 7, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3684210526315789, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3684210526315789, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 7, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3684210526315789, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1290.1052631578948, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1599.9473684210527, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 59, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.2777777777777777, "search_nodes": 472, "safety_nodes": 2150, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2622, "avg_nodes": 145.66666666666666, "eval_calls": 454, "avg_eval_calls": 25.22222222222222, "line_shape_eval_calls": 454, "line_shape_eval_ns": 593933, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1308.2224669603524, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1667, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.61111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1667, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20730, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1151.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 40837489, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1969.9705258080078, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.3333333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 17700, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2950.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 17700, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8621, "stage_ordering_ns": 1050, "stage_eval_ns": 593933, "stage_threat_ns": 36790264, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 926, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 35684099, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 51, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 386394, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19471, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 454, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 609330, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 908, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 110441, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 18, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 18, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6886.944444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7331.388888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 201, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8730, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 157, 172, 141, 125, 83, 155, 126, 110, 95, 170, 143, 140 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 278, "safety_nodes": 236, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 514, "avg_nodes": 73.42857142857143, "eval_calls": 271, "avg_eval_calls": 38.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 271, "line_shape_eval_ns": 198300, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 731.7343173431734, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 389, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.57142857142857, "candidate_moves_max": 66, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 389, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 389, "avg_legality_checks": 55.57142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 389, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8373, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1196.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17178257, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2051.625104502568, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 117743, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10703.90909090909, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23090, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 94653, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 155012, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11924.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 85432, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4496.421052631579, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1011074, "stage_ordering_ns": 340, "stage_eval_ns": 198300, "stage_threat_ns": 15914730, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 549, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15240908, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 233102, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7050, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 271, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 373160, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 542, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67560, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 8698, "avg_search_time_ms": 1242.5714285714287, "search_nodes": 62872, "safety_nodes": 192, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 63064, "avg_nodes": 9009.142857142857, "eval_calls": 36269, "avg_eval_calls": 5181.285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36269, "pattern_eval_ns": 747740, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.616504452838512, "pattern_frame_queries": 36269, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 747740, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.616504452838512, "pattern_frame_updates": 125670, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1126634938, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8965.026959497096, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24120, "avg_candidate_generations": 3445.714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 1865505, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.34266169154229, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 399, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 24113, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1865106, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 1326784, "avg_legality_checks": 189540.57142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 388, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1326784, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 388, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2812374, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 401767.71428571426, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5866164359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2085.840773311089, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12665, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1809.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14327048, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1131.2315831030398, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 388, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4121038, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 728, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 3854472, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11539, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6243307, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 108231, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81119, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11588.42857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 797069150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9825.924259421345, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16875.14285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 396397974, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3355.7216362189524, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3136373322, "stage_ordering_ns": 765569217, "stage_eval_ns": 1127382678, "stage_threat_ns": 3616497256, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 346360, "root_tactical_annotations": 1349, "search_tactical_annotations": 345011, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125677, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 730282792, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 257069, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2757334491, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48276, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1716892841, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 62835, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93192486, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 125670, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15494216, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 43041, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 218154929, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 165747, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 822236301, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 137572, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20193271, "child_limit_applications": 24113, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24113, "child_cap_hits": 24113, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24113, "child_moves_before_total": 1864718, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1864718, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 213758, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 213758, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.33247625762037, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.86484468958653, "tt_hits": 13907, "tt_cutoffs": 2454, "beta_cutoffs": 19093, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1795.4285714285713, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2556.285714285714, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 239, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 202, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9301, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 125, 157, 126, 124, 140, 98, 155, 110, 143, 139, 141, 144, 169, 113, 183 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9266, "avg_search_time_ms": 1029.5555555555557, "search_nodes": 95427, "safety_nodes": 66, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 95493, "avg_nodes": 10610.333333333334, "eval_calls": 62617, "avg_eval_calls": 6957.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62617, "pattern_eval_ns": 1302215, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.79650893527317, "pattern_frame_queries": 62617, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1302215, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.79650893527317, "pattern_frame_updates": 190772, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2212822975, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11599.306895141845, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30669, "avg_candidate_generations": 3407.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2271710, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.07186409729694, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 498, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 30660, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2271212, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 766135, "avg_legality_checks": 85126.11111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1506, "root_legality_checks": 498, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 765637, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1504, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2524703, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 280522.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5537408404, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2193.291014428232, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25161, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2795.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124424441, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4945.130996383292, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1737, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15787787, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11909, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 77890929, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11505, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30638775, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 106950, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52729, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5858.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 456276950, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8653.244893701758, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 69624, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7736.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 191014164, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2743.510341261634, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1876501902, "stage_ordering_ns": 964613963, "stage_eval_ns": 2214125190, "stage_threat_ns": 4175310666, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 285895, "root_tactical_annotations": 2097, "search_tactical_annotations": 283798, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 190781, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1092439573, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 259292, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2909606574, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61378, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2227901402, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 95386, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 139103867, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 190772, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23106148, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 38797, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 80042828, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 159109, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 601654164, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 87989, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11054504, "child_limit_applications": 30660, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30660, "child_cap_hits": 30660, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30660, "child_moves_before_total": 2269708, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2269708, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 264006, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 264006, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.0283105022831, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.610763209393346, "tt_hits": 14227, "tt_cutoffs": 2109, "beta_cutoffs": 22877, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2297.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3186.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.25, "search_nodes": 121, "safety_nodes": 546, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 667, "avg_nodes": 83.375, "eval_calls": 113, "avg_eval_calls": 14.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 113, "line_shape_eval_ns": 78130, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 691.4159292035398, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 441, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.125, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 441, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9149, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1143.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18323767, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2002.8163733741392, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 87560, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10945.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 87560, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3000, "stage_ordering_ns": 470, "stage_eval_ns": 78130, "stage_threat_ns": 15466619, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 234, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15097228, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 174110, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8550, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 113, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 166201, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 226, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29080, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 203, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5618, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 109, 108, 95, 81, 65, 80, 94, 82, 83, 78, 125, 79 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 271, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 502, "avg_nodes": 71.71428571428571, "eval_calls": 264, "avg_eval_calls": 37.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 264, "line_shape_eval_ns": 193230, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 731.9318181818181, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 380, "avg_candidate_moves": 54.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 64, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 380, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 380, "avg_legality_checks": 54.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 380, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17150003, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2050.699868468253, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 126320, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10526.666666666666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20250, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 106070, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 180761, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12050.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 104341, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4536.565217391304, "stage_move_gen_ns": 977655, "stage_ordering_ns": 360, "stage_eval_ns": 193230, "stage_threat_ns": 15850164, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 535, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15133850, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 282222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 367701, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66391, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 5585, "avg_search_time_ms": 797.8571428571429, "search_nodes": 41289, "safety_nodes": 311, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 41600, "avg_nodes": 5942.857142857143, "eval_calls": 23496, "avg_eval_calls": 3356.5714285714284, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23496, "pattern_eval_ns": 501411, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.34027068437181, "pattern_frame_queries": 23496, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 501411, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.34027068437181, "pattern_frame_updates": 82504, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 821762282, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9960.27201105401, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15828, "avg_candidate_generations": 2261.1428571428573, "candidate_moves_total": 1174948, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.23224665150366, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 390, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 15821, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1174558, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 796688, "avg_legality_checks": 113812.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1140, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 796688, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1140, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1799967, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 257138.14285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3700702438, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2055.983491919574, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12920, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1845.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 76750209, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5940.418653250774, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1148, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12428811, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3070, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32928889, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8682, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31175958, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 216551, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 56438, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8062.571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 581848017, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10309.508079662639, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 80041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11434.42857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 305944990, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3822.3534188728277, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1870891987, "stage_ordering_ns": 472296338, "stage_eval_ns": 822263693, "stage_threat_ns": 2385515258, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 231193, "root_tactical_annotations": 919, "search_tactical_annotations": 230274, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 82511, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 486445978, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 164188, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1813272422, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31692, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1084671390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 41252, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 61622992, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 82504, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10043334, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 31243, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 168362822, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 101248, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 560162880, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 98702, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14130532, "child_limit_applications": 15821, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15821, "child_cap_hits": 15821, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15821, "child_moves_before_total": 1173418, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1173418, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 155259, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 155259, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.16838379369193, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.813475760065735, "tt_hits": 9784, "tt_cutoffs": 1935, "beta_cutoffs": 12664, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3056.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4199.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1739, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 204, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18524, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 81, 109, 127, 129, 143, 145, 161, 159, 95, 79, 80, 125, 64, 128, 96, 48, 82, 124, 66, 51, 65, 50, 67, 68, 63 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 18470, "avg_search_time_ms": 1319.2857142857142, "search_nodes": 184868, "safety_nodes": 328, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 185196, "avg_nodes": 13228.285714285714, "eval_calls": 114328, "avg_eval_calls": 8166.285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 114328, "pattern_eval_ns": 2391555, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.918366454411867, "pattern_frame_queries": 114328, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2391555, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.918366454411867, "pattern_frame_updates": 369620, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4459306926, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12064.571522103783, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 66246, "avg_candidate_generations": 4731.857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 5719259, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.33365033360505, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1016, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 66232, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5718243, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1469571, "avg_legality_checks": 104969.35714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1987, "root_legality_checks": 1016, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1468555, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1986, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4986251, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 356160.78571428574, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10822486702, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2170.465686945964, "renju_forbidden_checks": 50502, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3607.285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 221118844, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4378.417567621084, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3002, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19970666, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25035, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 140473915, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22460, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 60669083, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5180, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 80871, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5776.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 677131083, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8372.977742330379, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 104141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7438.642857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 275903888, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2649.3301197415044, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3482808234, "stage_ordering_ns": 2215233389, "stage_eval_ns": 4461698481, "stage_threat_ns": 8237961554, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 986265, "root_tactical_annotations": 3642, "search_tactical_annotations": 982623, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 369634, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2089701188, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 787437, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5790011566, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 132549, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4495930054, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 184810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 267995791, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 369620, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44464524, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 213520, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 95369055, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 441356, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1198617286, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 331389, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 45788485, "child_limit_applications": 66232, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 66232, "child_cap_hits": 66232, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 66232, "child_moves_before_total": 5716257, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5716257, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 680197, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 680197, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.30657386157749, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.269914844788017, "tt_hits": 36499, "tt_cutoffs": 4252, "beta_cutoffs": 51878, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2415.4285714285716, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2986.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 2, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 41, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1538461538461537, "search_nodes": 136, "safety_nodes": 1251, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1387, "avg_nodes": 106.6923076923077, "eval_calls": 123, "avg_eval_calls": 9.461538461538462, "line_shape_eval_calls": 123, "line_shape_eval_ns": 95780, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 778.69918699187, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 944, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.61538461538461, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 944, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15197, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1169.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30079149, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1979.2820293478976, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.3076923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4590, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1147.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4590, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5520, "stage_ordering_ns": 750, "stage_eval_ns": 95780, "stage_threat_ns": 24429248, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 259, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 23951117, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 266691, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13550, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 180460, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 246, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30980, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6458.846153846154, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7074.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 205, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5628, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 67, 52, 83, 99, 85, 84, 68, 114, 129, 54, 81, 69 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 271, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 502, "avg_nodes": 71.71428571428571, "eval_calls": 264, "avg_eval_calls": 37.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 264, "line_shape_eval_ns": 194383, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 736.2992424242424, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 380, "avg_candidate_moves": 54.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 64, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 380, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 380, "avg_legality_checks": 54.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 380, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17190253, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2055.512734664594, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 128090, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10674.166666666666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19610, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 108480, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 184691, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12312.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 106390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4625.652173913043, "stage_move_gen_ns": 983016, "stage_ordering_ns": 380, "stage_eval_ns": 194383, "stage_threat_ns": 15924948, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 535, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15215904, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 285052, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 357362, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66630, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 5595, "avg_search_time_ms": 799.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 42519, "safety_nodes": 311, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 42830, "avg_nodes": 6118.571428571428, "eval_calls": 23987, "avg_eval_calls": 3426.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23987, "pattern_eval_ns": 504253, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.02192854462834, "pattern_frame_queries": 23987, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 504253, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.02192854462834, "pattern_frame_updates": 84964, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 824250681, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9701.175568476061, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15955, "avg_candidate_generations": 2279.285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 1155497, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.42225007834534, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 390, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 15948, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1155107, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 787877, "avg_legality_checks": 112553.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1136, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 787877, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1136, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1812747, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 258963.85714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3713250012, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2048.410512884589, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12434, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1776.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 70897808, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5701.930834807785, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1144, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11566285, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2917, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30144487, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8353, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28975045, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 211991, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58891, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8413.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 599568273, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10180.983053437707, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 83644, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11949.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 313312906, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3745.7905647745206, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1858821616, "stage_ordering_ns": 464429033, "stage_eval_ns": 824754934, "stage_threat_ns": 2409506909, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 232238, "root_tactical_annotations": 919, "search_tactical_annotations": 231319, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 84971, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 494375173, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 165570, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1831213436, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31946, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1083791526, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42482, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 60220740, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 84964, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10312441, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 31024, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 166839490, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 102595, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 580510259, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 98619, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13385119, "child_limit_applications": 15948, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15948, "child_cap_hits": 15948, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15948, "child_moves_before_total": 1153971, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1153971, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 159510, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 159510, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.35835214446952, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.001881113619262, "tt_hits": 10255, "tt_cutoffs": 2547, "beta_cutoffs": 12685, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3029.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4171.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1648, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 206, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10391, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 99, 85, 141, 155, 81, 111, 125, 69, 55, 53, 37, 68, 98, 67, 52, 66, 65, 70 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10349, "avg_search_time_ms": 940.8181818181819, "search_nodes": 108759, "safety_nodes": 240, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 108999, "avg_nodes": 9909.0, "eval_calls": 72138, "avg_eval_calls": 6558.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72138, "pattern_eval_ns": 1495572, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.732096814438993, "pattern_frame_queries": 72138, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1495572, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.732096814438993, "pattern_frame_updates": 217428, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2593851708, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11929.70412274408, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34300, "avg_candidate_generations": 3118.181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 2771848, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.81189504373178, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 740, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 34289, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2771108, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 846682, "avg_legality_checks": 76971.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 632, "root_legality_checks": 740, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 845942, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 632, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2842980, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 258452.72727272726, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6124590906, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2154.285610873098, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25872, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2352.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 112470613, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4347.194380024737, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1154, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5135331, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14306, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 82976882, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10412, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24358400, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59723, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5429.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 470214895, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7873.263148200861, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76827, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6984.272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 176562862, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2298.1876423653143, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2029109902, "stage_ordering_ns": 1122146149, "stage_eval_ns": 2595347280, "stage_threat_ns": 4560402273, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 403107, "root_tactical_annotations": 2357, "search_tactical_annotations": 400750, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 217439, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1245037908, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 337107, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3111196890, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 68644, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2355785229, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108714, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 160077301, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 217428, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26393397, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 64745, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 93281712, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 203709, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 661991739, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 134653, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17696777, "child_limit_applications": 34289, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34289, "child_cap_hits": 34289, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34289, "child_moves_before_total": 2770476, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2770476, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 309886, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 309886, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.79780687684097, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.037475575257371, "tt_hits": 17602, "tt_cutoffs": 2287, "beta_cutoffs": 25414, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4398.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5126.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1013, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1, "search_nodes": 76, "safety_nodes": 1004, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1080, "avg_nodes": 108.0, "eval_calls": 66, "avg_eval_calls": 6.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 66, "line_shape_eval_ns": 51970, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 787.4242424242424, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 672, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.2, "candidate_moves_max": 84, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 672, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11695, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1169.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23472559, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2007.059341598974, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4180, "stage_ordering_ns": 490, "stage_eval_ns": 51970, "stage_threat_ns": 18649573, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 142, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18282161, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 253062, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10561, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 97460, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 132, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16890, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 207, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8974, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 109, 108, 125, 141, 99, 139, 126, 142, 143, 138, 95, 140 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 278, "safety_nodes": 236, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 514, "avg_nodes": 73.42857142857143, "eval_calls": 271, "avg_eval_calls": 38.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 271, "line_shape_eval_ns": 198050, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 730.8118081180812, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 389, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.57142857142857, "candidate_moves_max": 66, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 389, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 389, "avg_legality_checks": 55.57142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 389, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8373, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1196.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17102113, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2042.5311119073212, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 115931, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10539.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24990, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 90941, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 151231, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11633.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 83601, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4400.0526315789475, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1012426, "stage_ordering_ns": 370, "stage_eval_ns": 198050, "stage_threat_ns": 15855684, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 549, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15187961, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 226302, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7060, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 271, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 373601, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 542, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67820, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 8941, "avg_search_time_ms": 1277.2857142857142, "search_nodes": 63326, "safety_nodes": 192, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 63518, "avg_nodes": 9074.0, "eval_calls": 36422, "avg_eval_calls": 5203.142857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36422, "pattern_eval_ns": 752443, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.659024765251772, "pattern_frame_queries": 36422, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 752443, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.659024765251772, "pattern_frame_updates": 126578, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1266358053, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10004.56677305693, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24253, "avg_candidate_generations": 3464.714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 1852686, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.3899723745516, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 399, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 24246, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1852287, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 1319050, "avg_legality_checks": 188435.7142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 964, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1319050, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 964, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2945937, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 420848.14285714284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6008633686, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2039.6341422101016, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13378, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1911.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31010326, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2318.009119449843, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 964, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9258999, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1690, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14187726, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10714, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7458981, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 104620, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 96958, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13851.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 954477291, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9844.234524226986, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 140289, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20041.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 478453026, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3410.481406239976, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3087639914, "stage_ordering_ns": 768772826, "stage_eval_ns": 1267110496, "stage_threat_ns": 3766954626, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 365348, "root_tactical_annotations": 1349, "search_tactical_annotations": 363999, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 126585, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 743343997, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 273459, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2894612932, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48542, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1678167222, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 63289, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94164852, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 126578, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15633650, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 41876, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 231293919, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 183036, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 985102371, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 140436, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19199195, "child_limit_applications": 24246, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24246, "child_cap_hits": 24246, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24246, "child_moves_before_total": 1851323, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1851323, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 236960, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 236960, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.35581126783799, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.773158459127279, "tt_hits": 13582, "tt_cutoffs": 2622, "beta_cutoffs": 19261, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1608.7142857142858, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2335.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 208, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8138, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 85, 71, 93, 95, 80, 139, 97, 140, 155, 138, 142, 137 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8100, "avg_search_time_ms": 810.0, "search_nodes": 84564, "safety_nodes": 375, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 84939, "avg_nodes": 8493.9, "eval_calls": 59391, "avg_eval_calls": 5939.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 59391, "pattern_eval_ns": 1207641, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.333737434964895, "pattern_frame_queries": 59391, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1207641, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.333737434964895, "pattern_frame_updates": 169032, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2310514040, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13669.092479530504, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23727, "avg_candidate_generations": 2372.7, "candidate_moves_total": 1925539, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.15391747797868, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 693, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 23717, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1924846, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 610090, "avg_legality_checks": 61009.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 706, "root_legality_checks": 693, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 609397, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 704, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2242691, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 224269.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4835544956, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2156.135176892403, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22828, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2282.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 138019561, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6046.064526020677, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 853, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7500541, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13460, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 103999688, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8505, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26409632, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 109700, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53414, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5341.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 474521262, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8883.836859250383, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72133, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7213.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 210176506, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2913.735821330043, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1462447265, "stage_ordering_ns": 778612473, "stage_eval_ns": 2311721681, "stage_threat_ns": 3515362236, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 301960, "root_tactical_annotations": 1898, "search_tactical_annotations": 300062, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169042, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 983422677, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 259745, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2377663035, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47501, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1694035954, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84516, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 122414806, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169032, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20645873, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 66967, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 116472087, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 145269, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 566851522, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 89724, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11215845, "child_limit_applications": 23717, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23717, "child_cap_hits": 23717, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23717, "child_moves_before_total": 1924142, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1924142, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 232961, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 232961, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.12923219631487, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.82253236075389, "tt_hits": 11834, "tt_cutoffs": 1408, "beta_cutoffs": 17713, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 4.8, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 4.8, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4544.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5344.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 846, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 70, "safety_nodes": 914, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 984, "avg_nodes": 109.33333333333333, "eval_calls": 61, "avg_eval_calls": 6.777777777777778, "line_shape_eval_calls": 61, "line_shape_eval_ns": 45690, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 749.016393442623, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 621, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.0, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 621, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10546, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1171.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21029161, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1994.0414375118528, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.8888888888888888, "renju_forbidden_ns": 91891, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11486.375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 91891, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3710, "stage_ordering_ns": 490, "stage_eval_ns": 45690, "stage_threat_ns": 16735167, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 131, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16390775, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 238731, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 89761, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 122, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15900, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 209, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5590, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 115, 116, 99, 83, 69, 84, 100, 82, 81, 86, 129, 85 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 271, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 502, "avg_nodes": 71.71428571428571, "eval_calls": 264, "avg_eval_calls": 37.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 264, "line_shape_eval_ns": 190402, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 721.219696969697, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 380, "avg_candidate_moves": 54.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 64, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 380, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 380, "avg_legality_checks": 54.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 380, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17121372, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2047.276336242975, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 123240, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10270.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19380, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 103860, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 175061, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11670.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 98921, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4300.913043478261, "stage_move_gen_ns": 973425, "stage_ordering_ns": 390, "stage_eval_ns": 190402, "stage_threat_ns": 15829852, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 535, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15122438, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 275271, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 365973, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66170, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 5557, "avg_search_time_ms": 793.8571428571429, "search_nodes": 40787, "safety_nodes": 311, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 41098, "avg_nodes": 5871.142857142857, "eval_calls": 23424, "avg_eval_calls": 3346.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23424, "pattern_eval_ns": 484322, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.676314890710383, "pattern_frame_queries": 23424, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 484322, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.676314890710383, "pattern_frame_updates": 81500, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 774286476, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9500.447558282209, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15998, "avg_candidate_generations": 2285.4285714285716, "candidate_moves_total": 1187053, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.20008751093887, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 390, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 15991, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1186663, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 808607, "avg_legality_checks": 115515.28571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1146, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 808607, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1146, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1783915, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 254845.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3692528467, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2069.9015743463115, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12914, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1844.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 76210860, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5901.413969335605, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1150, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12422854, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3017, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32823438, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8727, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30752794, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 211774, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53400, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7628.571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 551883916, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10334.90479400749, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 75522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10788.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 288545563, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3820.6822250470063, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1902702552, "stage_ordering_ns": 483293816, "stage_eval_ns": 774770798, "stage_threat_ns": 2360702107, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 222144, "root_tactical_annotations": 919, "search_tactical_annotations": 221225, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 81507, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 478186041, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 161548, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1801086853, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32032, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1107463152, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40750, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 59849798, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 81500, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10044346, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 31528, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 175190720, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 97983, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 518361621, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 92633, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11535069, "child_limit_applications": 15991, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15991, "child_cap_hits": 15991, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15991, "child_moves_before_total": 1185517, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1185517, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 148140, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 148140, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.13651428928772, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.263960978050154, "tt_hits": 9151, "tt_cutoffs": 1335, "beta_cutoffs": 12853, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3041.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4183.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1625, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 210, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8348, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 83, 115, 98, 68, 84, 126, 85, 82, 129, 69, 99, 144, 71, 127, 57 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8315, "avg_search_time_ms": 923.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 95700, "safety_nodes": 66, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 95766, "avg_nodes": 10640.666666666666, "eval_calls": 62709, "avg_eval_calls": 6967.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62709, "pattern_eval_ns": 1282299, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.448404535234175, "pattern_frame_queries": 62709, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1282299, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.448404535234175, "pattern_frame_updates": 191318, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2077972969, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10861.356322980588, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31071, "avg_candidate_generations": 3452.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2294284, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.84004377071868, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 498, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 31062, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2293786, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 698425, "avg_legality_checks": 77602.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1972, "root_legality_checks": 498, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 697927, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1970, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2458981, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 273220.1111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4912407361, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1997.7410809599587, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26503, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2944.777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 134541274, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5076.454514583254, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20975304, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12570, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 81044664, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11706, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32413766, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 107540, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48245, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5360.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 404342555, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8381.025080319205, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63871, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7096.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 173905961, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2722.7687213289287, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1559400227, "stage_ordering_ns": 862115831, "stage_eval_ns": 2079255268, "stage_threat_ns": 3776647372, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 269564, "root_tactical_annotations": 2097, "search_tactical_annotations": 267467, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 191327, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1011892635, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 238307, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2604539646, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62182, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2012984773, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 95659, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 127918073, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 191318, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21658384, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 37343, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 62871691, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 138774, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 528675432, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 93447, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10638634, "child_limit_applications": 31062, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31062, "child_cap_hits": 31062, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31062, "child_moves_before_total": 2291816, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2291816, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 266800, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 266800, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.78198441826025, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.589273066769687, "tt_hits": 16487, "tt_cutoffs": 1888, "beta_cutoffs": 23203, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3035.1111111111113, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3924.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 888, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 24, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0, "search_nodes": 121, "safety_nodes": 546, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 667, "avg_nodes": 83.375, "eval_calls": 113, "avg_eval_calls": 14.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 113, "line_shape_eval_ns": 65820, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 582.4778761061947, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 441, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.125, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 441, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9149, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1143.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17202594, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1880.2704120668925, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 90310, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11288.75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 90310, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3030, "stage_ordering_ns": 400, "stage_eval_ns": 65820, "stage_threat_ns": 14408530, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 234, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14075610, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 171270, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 113, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 136950, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 226, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24700, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5496.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6496.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 211, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8909, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 157, 172, 143, 129, 81, 159, 128, 114, 99, 174, 141, 144 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 278, "safety_nodes": 236, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 514, "avg_nodes": 73.42857142857143, "eval_calls": 271, "avg_eval_calls": 38.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 271, "line_shape_eval_ns": 198780, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 733.5055350553506, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 389, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.57142857142857, "candidate_moves_max": 66, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 389, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 389, "avg_legality_checks": 55.57142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 389, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8373, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1196.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17097076, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2041.9295354114415, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 114460, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10405.454545454546, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22770, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 91690, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 149941, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11533.923076923076, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 82941, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4365.315789473684, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1005996, "stage_ordering_ns": 380, "stage_eval_ns": 198780, "stage_threat_ns": 15828163, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 549, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15163870, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 225971, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 271, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 369702, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 542, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 68620, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 8875, "avg_search_time_ms": 1267.857142857143, "search_nodes": 65640, "safety_nodes": 192, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 65832, "avg_nodes": 9404.57142857143, "eval_calls": 38144, "avg_eval_calls": 5449.142857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38144, "pattern_eval_ns": 799394, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.957267197986578, "pattern_frame_queries": 38144, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 799394, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.957267197986578, "pattern_frame_updates": 131206, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1155111982, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8803.80456686432, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25024, "avg_candidate_generations": 3574.8571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 1933826, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.27885230179028, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 399, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 25017, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1933427, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 1362557, "avg_legality_checks": 194651.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 382, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1362557, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 382, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2886454, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 412350.5714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5979272372, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2071.4940795869256, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12696, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1813.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14203763, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1118.7589004410838, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 382, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4097924, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 750, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 3842378, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11554, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6155900, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 107561, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 82011, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11715.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 798135210, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9732.050700515785, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 119549, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17078.428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 394457664, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3299.548001237986, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3194528077, "stage_ordering_ns": 790224439, "stage_eval_ns": 1155911376, "stage_threat_ns": 3683712972, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 351264, "root_tactical_annotations": 1349, "search_tactical_annotations": 349915, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 131213, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 759753672, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 260022, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2792598130, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50084, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1753984520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 65603, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 95476997, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 131206, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16160602, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 42247, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 215427692, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 167686, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 823134958, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 141331, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19723571, "child_limit_applications": 25017, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25017, "child_cap_hits": 25017, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25017, "child_moves_before_total": 1933045, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1933045, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 221691, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 221691, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.26925690530439, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.86161410241036, "tt_hits": 14239, "tt_cutoffs": 2443, "beta_cutoffs": 19760, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1655.2857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2391.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 68, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 212, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10511, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 129, 157, 65, 98, 128, 111, 96, 80, 114, 156, 144, 160, 159, 174, 99 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10476, "avg_search_time_ms": 1164.0, "search_nodes": 111908, "safety_nodes": 75, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 111983, "avg_nodes": 12442.555555555555, "eval_calls": 71281, "avg_eval_calls": 7920.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71281, "pattern_eval_ns": 1454965, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.41168053197907, "pattern_frame_queries": 71281, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1454965, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.41168053197907, "pattern_frame_updates": 223732, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2293451672, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10250.887990989218, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37879, "avg_candidate_generations": 4208.777777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 2922859, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.16304548694528, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 546, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 37870, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2922313, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 870428, "avg_legality_checks": 96714.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 750, "root_legality_checks": 546, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 869882, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 750, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2804805, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 311645.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6141162498, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2189.5149566547407, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15642, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1738.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 89441785, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5718.052998337808, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 796, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7523444, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8091, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60232257, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6755, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21686084, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47209, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5245.444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 408753595, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8658.382829545213, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 62553, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6950.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 171444370, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2740.785733697824, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2108978310, "stage_ordering_ns": 1210385361, "stage_eval_ns": 2294906637, "stage_threat_ns": 4818738637, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 361619, "root_tactical_annotations": 2329, "search_tactical_annotations": 359290, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 223741, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1263314310, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 335915, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3360122364, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75799, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2664551257, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111866, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156186667, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 223732, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27049431, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 47629, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 72209832, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 212479, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 623353425, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 101511, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12065865, "child_limit_applications": 37870, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37870, "child_cap_hits": 37870, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37870, "child_moves_before_total": 2921563, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2921563, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 338530, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 338530, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.14716134143121, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.939265909691049, "tt_hits": 16294, "tt_cutoffs": 2716, "beta_cutoffs": 28974, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1588.3333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2427.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.375, "search_nodes": 199, "safety_nodes": 467, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 666, "avg_nodes": 83.25, "eval_calls": 191, "avg_eval_calls": 23.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 191, "line_shape_eval_ns": 138731, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 726.3403141361257, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 487, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.875, "candidate_moves_max": 71, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 487, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9344, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1168.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18717577, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2003.1653467465753, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3040, "stage_ordering_ns": 420, "stage_eval_ns": 138731, "stage_threat_ns": 16612519, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 390, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16151065, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 147870, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8290, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 191, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 266133, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 382, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47451, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 213, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5696, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 67, 52, 81, 95, 79, 80, 66, 110, 125, 50, 83, 65 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 23, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.2857142857142856, "search_nodes": 271, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 502, "avg_nodes": 71.71428571428571, "eval_calls": 264, "avg_eval_calls": 37.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 264, "line_shape_eval_ns": 159911, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 605.7234848484849, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 380, "avg_candidate_moves": 54.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 64, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 380, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 380, "avg_legality_checks": 54.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 380, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14968557, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1789.854956355375, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 76561, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6380.083333333333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10630, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 65931, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 175782, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11718.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 100291, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4360.478260869565, "stage_move_gen_ns": 827394, "stage_ordering_ns": 340, "stage_eval_ns": 159911, "stage_threat_ns": 14063181, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 535, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 13397516, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 275222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 330282, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60161, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 5666, "avg_search_time_ms": 809.4285714285714, "search_nodes": 43396, "safety_nodes": 311, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 43707, "avg_nodes": 6243.857142857143, "eval_calls": 24718, "avg_eval_calls": 3531.1428571428573, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 24718, "pattern_eval_ns": 512650, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.739946597621167, "pattern_frame_queries": 24718, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 512650, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.739946597621167, "pattern_frame_updates": 86718, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 825469325, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9519.007876104153, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16328, "avg_candidate_generations": 2332.5714285714284, "candidate_moves_total": 1173955, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.89827290543852, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 390, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 16321, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1173565, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 810675, "avg_legality_checks": 115810.71428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1134, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 810675, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1134, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1874757, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 267822.4285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3775529286, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2013.8766176096422, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12768, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1824.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 69074199, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5409.946663533835, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1142, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11121609, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2962, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28915680, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8644, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28891510, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 145400, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 62550, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8935.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 624325677, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9981.225851318944, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 88558, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12651.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 324874419, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3668.4931796111023, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1889737463, "stage_ordering_ns": 458425061, "stage_eval_ns": 825981975, "stage_threat_ns": 2456598205, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 241325, "root_tactical_annotations": 919, "search_tactical_annotations": 240406, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 86725, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 498965321, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 173124, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1871846650, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32692, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1094365001, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43359, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 61668329, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 86718, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10383926, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32357, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 170871207, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 108070, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 606540150, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 100898, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13733979, "child_limit_applications": 16321, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16321, "child_cap_hits": 16321, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16321, "child_moves_before_total": 1172431, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1172431, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 164444, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 164444, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.83573310458918, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.075608112248023, "tt_hits": 10135, "tt_cutoffs": 2320, "beta_cutoffs": 12984, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2950.4285714285716, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4093.285714285714, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1595, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 214, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17020, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 96, 97, 68, 110, 80, 64, 83, 81, 65, 95, 67, 94, 51, 35, 69, 66, 54, 40, 99, 115, 84, 114, 39 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 16989, "avg_search_time_ms": 1415.75, "search_nodes": 278032, "safety_nodes": 80, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 278112, "avg_nodes": 23176.0, "eval_calls": 186682, "avg_eval_calls": 15556.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 186682, "pattern_eval_ns": 3621960, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.401763426575673, "pattern_frame_queries": 186682, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3621960, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.401763426575673, "pattern_frame_updates": 555948, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4766556307, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8573.74485923144, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 83986, "avg_candidate_generations": 6998.833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 6375904, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.91627175957898, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 721, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 83974, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6375183, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 1739547, "avg_legality_checks": 144962.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1043, "root_legality_checks": 721, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1738826, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1042, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6831330, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 569277.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9538651095, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1396.309517326787, "renju_forbidden_checks": 71529, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5960.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 167989245, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2348.5473723944133, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2369, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6709177, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 38490, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 119028300, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30665, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42230578, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 21190, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 159379, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13281.583333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 793808764, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4980.635867962529, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 195400, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16283.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 281152751, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1438.8574769703173, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2693027310, "stage_ordering_ns": 1554926340, "stage_eval_ns": 4770178267, "stage_threat_ns": 7848520116, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1743482, "root_tactical_annotations": 3125, "search_tactical_annotations": 1740357, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 555960, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2147927241, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1420990, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5288866609, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 168029, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3617922104, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 277974, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 292124989, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 555948, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48883462, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 335526, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 208005222, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 917424, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1462930693, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 490532, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 70717815, "child_limit_applications": 83974, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 83974, "child_cap_hits": 83974, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 83974, "child_moves_before_total": 6374141, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6374141, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 908225, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 908225, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.90612570557553, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.815550051206326, "tt_hits": 41291, "tt_cutoffs": 7319, "beta_cutoffs": 64022, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3002.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3592.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 19, "avg_search_time_ms": 1.7272727272727273, "search_nodes": 174, "safety_nodes": 707, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 881, "avg_nodes": 80.0909090909091, "eval_calls": 163, "avg_eval_calls": 14.818181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 163, "line_shape_eval_ns": 114320, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 701.3496932515337, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 654, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.45454545454545, "candidate_moves_max": 82, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 654, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1123.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15305813, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1238.4345820859294, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.36363636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20661, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5165.25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 20661, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3980, "stage_ordering_ns": 590, "stage_eval_ns": 114320, "stage_threat_ns": 13868092, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 337, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 13535921, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 115780, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7290, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 163, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184621, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 326, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31770, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6180.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6907.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 215, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14359, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 70, 126, 140, 83, 156, 114, 124, 108, 141, 139, 170, 184, 155, 125, 143, 144, 188, 172, 158, 173, 157, 159, 154 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 25, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.0833333333333335, "search_nodes": 193, "safety_nodes": 1106, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1299, "avg_nodes": 108.25, "eval_calls": 181, "avg_eval_calls": 15.083333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 181, "line_shape_eval_ns": 66451, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 367.1325966850829, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 968, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.66666666666667, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 968, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 968, "avg_legality_checks": 80.66666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 968, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15434, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1286.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18655155, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1208.7051315277959, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.3333333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 283943, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7098.575, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 58421, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 225522, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 354392, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7383.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 70, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.833333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 202382, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2891.1714285714284, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1562884, "stage_ordering_ns": 620, "stage_eval_ns": 66451, "stage_threat_ns": 15429119, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 374, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14778286, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 449152, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7030, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 181, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 171911, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 362, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29770, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6331.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6998.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 14324, "avg_search_time_ms": 1193.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 137367, "safety_nodes": 257, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 137624, "avg_nodes": 11468.666666666666, "eval_calls": 88265, "avg_eval_calls": 7355.416666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 88265, "pattern_eval_ns": 1720408, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.491395230272474, "pattern_frame_queries": 88265, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1720408, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.491395230272474, "pattern_frame_updates": 274626, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2023369933, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7367.7289586565, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 45449, "avg_candidate_generations": 3787.4166666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 4270801, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.96908622851988, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 992, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 45437, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4269809, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 3295564, "avg_legality_checks": 274630.3333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 36318, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3295564, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 36318, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7407194, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 617266.1666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9058087330, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1222.8770206369645, "renju_forbidden_checks": 175104, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 14592.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 676713865, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3864.6396712810674, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 40032, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 246041647, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21291, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 140094711, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 113717, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 290206266, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 64, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 371241, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 379113, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 31592.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2583294062, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6814.0476902664905, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 544097, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 45341.416666666664, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1376273177, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2529.462902754472, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4966440216, "stage_ordering_ns": 962117900, "stage_eval_ns": 2025090341, "stage_threat_ns": 6242722930, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1168410, "root_tactical_annotations": 3305, "search_tactical_annotations": 1165105, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 274638, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1049445387, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 902607, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4978546481, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90951, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1874935248, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 137313, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 143442580, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 274626, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23830212, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 319842, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1171460017, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 491804, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1932115115, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 356764, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 47458270, "child_limit_applications": 45437, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 45437, "child_cap_hits": 45437, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 45437, "child_moves_before_total": 4233491, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4233491, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 666188, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 666188, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.17276668794155, "avg_child_moves_after": 14.661795453044876, "tt_hits": 23575, "tt_cutoffs": 3612, "beta_cutoffs": 37269, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4828.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5495.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1643, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 216, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13437, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 126, 114, 127, 129, 125, 124, 144, 82, 130, 83, 81, 68, 113, 52, 36, 66, 50, 67, 97, 65, 64, 69 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 13407, "avg_search_time_ms": 1117.25, "search_nodes": 212892, "safety_nodes": 251, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 213143, "avg_nodes": 17761.916666666668, "eval_calls": 157004, "avg_eval_calls": 13083.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 157004, "pattern_eval_ns": 3033246, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.319545998828055, "pattern_frame_queries": 157004, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3033246, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.319545998828055, "pattern_frame_updates": 425670, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4617911981, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10848.572793478515, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52853, "avg_candidate_generations": 4404.416666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 4459778, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.38079200802225, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 826, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 52841, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4458952, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1283327, "avg_legality_checks": 106943.91666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2530, "root_legality_checks": 826, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1282501, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2528, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5702944, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 475245.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7582057110, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1329.4987834353626, "renju_forbidden_checks": 149443, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12453.583333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 372483166, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2492.4765027468666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5315, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13971677, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 86930, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 275826111, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 57181, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 82660028, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 25350, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 169360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14113.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 848138866, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5007.905444024563, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 219150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18262.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 334919769, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1528.267255304586, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1927248135, "stage_ordering_ns": 1115193412, "stage_eval_ns": 4620945227, "stage_threat_ns": 5661445516, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1209374, "root_tactical_annotations": 3019, "search_tactical_annotations": 1206355, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 425682, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1574042183, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1081554, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3799887053, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 105762, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2320153128, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 212835, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 219977304, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 425670, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36323419, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 335739, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 210861182, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 640043, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1268707132, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 233592, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 31215557, "child_limit_applications": 52841, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52841, "child_cap_hits": 52841, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52841, "child_moves_before_total": 4456424, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4456424, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 739965, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 739965, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.33648114153782, "avg_child_moves_after": 14.003614617437217, "tt_hits": 21344, "tt_cutoffs": 2991, "beta_cutoffs": 40559, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5086.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5753.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1434, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 24, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.1818181818181817, "search_nodes": 89, "safety_nodes": 1138, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1227, "avg_nodes": 111.54545454545455, "eval_calls": 78, "avg_eval_calls": 7.090909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 78, "line_shape_eval_ns": 53461, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 685.3974358974359, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 759, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.0, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 759, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12915, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1174.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16167125, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1251.8099109562525, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2727272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16640, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1188.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 16640, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3800, "stage_ordering_ns": 540, "stage_eval_ns": 53461, "stage_threat_ns": 13631505, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 167, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 13304552, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 199331, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6800, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 109501, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 156, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18121, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6179.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6907.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 217, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5674, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 144, 160, 97, 95, 65, 142, 158, 81, 113, 78, 94, 79, 82, 77 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 20, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.5, "search_nodes": 247, "safety_nodes": 431, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 678, "avg_nodes": 84.75, "eval_calls": 239, "avg_eval_calls": 29.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 239, "line_shape_eval_ns": 129171, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 540.4644351464435, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 530, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.25, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 530, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 530, "avg_legality_checks": 66.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 530, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15341663, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1535.394615692554, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 67260, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7473.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 39570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2826.4285714285716, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1050434, "stage_ordering_ns": 620, "stage_eval_ns": 129171, "stage_threat_ns": 13235700, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 12807250, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 120890, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 260090, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47470, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5497.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6497.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5644, "avg_search_time_ms": 705.5, "search_nodes": 72062, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 72591, "avg_nodes": 9073.875, "eval_calls": 47983, "avg_eval_calls": 5997.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47983, "pattern_eval_ns": 933453, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.453827397203177, "pattern_frame_queries": 47983, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 933453, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.453827397203177, "pattern_frame_updates": 144048, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 879885741, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6108.281551982673, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22264, "avg_candidate_generations": 2783.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1889052, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.84782608695652, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 547, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 22256, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1888505, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1238449, "avg_legality_checks": 154806.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 581, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1238449, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 581, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2786268, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 348283.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3583841180, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1286.2514230504746, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9230, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1153.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12878600, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1395.2979414951246, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 581, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4228176, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 491, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 2768980, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8153, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5847894, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 33550, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 94102, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11762.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 602655309, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6404.277369237636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 147954, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18494.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 313234430, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2117.106871054517, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1843913673, "stage_ordering_ns": 483656280, "stage_eval_ns": 880819194, "stage_threat_ns": 2379094043, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 392455, "root_tactical_annotations": 1254, "search_tactical_annotations": 391201, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 144056, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 551567942, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 299620, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1722010180, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44565, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 947152157, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72024, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74902926, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 144048, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12476028, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 80250, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 267601109, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 174799, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 507172454, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 137406, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18136967, "child_limit_applications": 22256, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22256, "child_cap_hits": 22256, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22256, "child_moves_before_total": 1887924, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1887924, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 244610, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 244610, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.82764198418404, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.990744069015097, "tt_hits": 11991, "tt_cutoffs": 1786, "beta_cutoffs": 16307, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.625, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.625, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4468.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5468.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1746, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 218, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19188, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 142, 95, 65, 125, 140, 111, 114, 100, 139, 141, 156, 170, 124, 108, 172, 188, 109, 94, 154, 169, 157, 127, 155, 153, 158 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 19130, "avg_search_time_ms": 1366.4285714285713, "search_nodes": 173199, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 174012, "avg_nodes": 12429.42857142857, "eval_calls": 108501, "avg_eval_calls": 7750.071428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 108501, "pattern_eval_ns": 2392653, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.051898139187657, "pattern_frame_queries": 108501, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2392653, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.051898139187657, "pattern_frame_updates": 346258, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5012098327, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14475.03978825038, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 59741, "avg_candidate_generations": 4267.214285714285, "candidate_moves_total": 5182769, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.75397130948595, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1048, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 59727, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5181721, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1285553, "avg_legality_checks": 91825.21428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1591, "root_legality_checks": 1048, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1284505, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1591, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4893735, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 349552.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11174721202, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2283.474933154329, "renju_forbidden_checks": 72128, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5152.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 292060226, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4049.19346162378, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2229, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11364867, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37216, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 195762050, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32672, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 84914369, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 18940, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 110001, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7857.214285714285, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1005352730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9139.487186480123, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 142282, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10163.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 425725928, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2992.127802532998, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3256326655, "stage_ordering_ns": 2130409412, "stage_eval_ns": 5014490980, "stage_threat_ns": 8671623831, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1149105, "root_tactical_annotations": 3332, "search_tactical_annotations": 1145773, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 346272, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2128690685, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 914141, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6180959501, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 119551, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4377925333, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 173129, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 269077608, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 346258, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44956036, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 237398, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 254643580, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 557180, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1547927935, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 354527, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 47940001, "child_limit_applications": 59727, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 59727, "child_cap_hits": 59727, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 59727, "child_moves_before_total": 5180130, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5180130, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 685896, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 685896, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.73012205535186, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.483851524436185, "tt_hits": 31229, "tt_cutoffs": 4901, "beta_cutoffs": 48342, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 4.928571428571429, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 4.928571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2351.714285714286, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2923.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 335, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 42, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.230769230769231, "search_nodes": 202, "safety_nodes": 1156, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1358, "avg_nodes": 104.46153846153847, "eval_calls": 189, "avg_eval_calls": 14.538461538461538, "line_shape_eval_calls": 189, "line_shape_eval_ns": 153230, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 810.7407407407408, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 979, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 979, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15239, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1172.2307692307693, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31705692, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2080.562504101319, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5720, "stage_ordering_ns": 660, "stage_eval_ns": 153230, "stage_threat_ns": 26571551, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 391, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 26006927, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 230921, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 189, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 283342, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 378, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50361, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6458.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7074.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 219, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13601, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 113, 83, 81, 110, 124, 68, 54, 52, 36, 67, 97, 65, 129, 145, 66, 51, 99, 37, 22, 23, 9, 79 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 33, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.5384615384615383, "search_nodes": 196, "safety_nodes": 1388, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1584, "avg_nodes": 121.84615384615384, "eval_calls": 183, "avg_eval_calls": 14.076923076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 183, "line_shape_eval_ns": 89450, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 488.7978142076503, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 992, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 992, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 992, "avg_legality_checks": 76.3076923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 992, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16615, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1278.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25131060, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1512.5525127896478, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2307692307692308, "renju_forbidden_ns": 22020, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1376.25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 22020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 63, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.846153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 593371, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9418.587301587302, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 96, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.384615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 337660, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3517.2916666666665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1863400, "stage_ordering_ns": 570, "stage_eval_ns": 89450, "stage_threat_ns": 19925129, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 379, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18921144, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 766093, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 183, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 203002, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 366, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34890, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6459.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7074.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 13554, "avg_search_time_ms": 1042.6153846153845, "search_nodes": 123200, "safety_nodes": 495, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 123695, "avg_nodes": 9515.0, "eval_calls": 78076, "avg_eval_calls": 6005.846153846154, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 78076, "pattern_eval_ns": 1509694, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.33621087145858, "pattern_frame_queries": 78076, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1509694, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.33621087145858, "pattern_frame_updates": 246284, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1868504107, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7586.786421367202, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41766, "avg_candidate_generations": 3212.769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 3763132, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.10036872096921, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1016, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 41753, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3762116, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 2683675, "avg_legality_checks": 206436.53846153847, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1658, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2683675, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1658, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5861026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 450848.1538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8999526293, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1535.4864989508662, "renju_forbidden_checks": 57155, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4396.538461538462, "renju_forbidden_ns": 93265610, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1631.8014171988452, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1810, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14142525, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4117, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24895701, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 51228, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 54227384, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 226736, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17441.23076923077, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1828359034, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8063.823274645402, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 344470, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26497.69230769231, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 959017535, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2784.0378988010566, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4794219580, "stage_ordering_ns": 1077231434, "stage_eval_ns": 1870013801, "stage_threat_ns": 5708369278, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 871583, "root_tactical_annotations": 2850, "search_tactical_annotations": 868733, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 246297, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1101492524, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 706880, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4407843226, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 83589, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2099624032, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123142, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 144136151, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 246284, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24059392, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 222672, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 810654990, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 400609, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1497465134, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 248302, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30837985, "child_limit_applications": 41753, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41753, "child_cap_hits": 41753, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41753, "child_moves_before_total": 3760458, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3760458, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 475624, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 475624, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.06437860752521, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.391373074988623, "tt_hits": 20824, "tt_cutoffs": 3314, "beta_cutoffs": 32818, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5207.076923076923, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5822.461538461538, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1834, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 220, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20868, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 85, 81, 80, 97, 94, 78, 66, 52, 140, 154, 108, 122, 124, 67, 37, 92, 109, 111, 79, 64, 139 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 20818, "avg_search_time_ms": 1601.3846153846155, "search_nodes": 212334, "safety_nodes": 539, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 212873, "avg_nodes": 16374.846153846154, "eval_calls": 146783, "avg_eval_calls": 11291.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 146783, "pattern_eval_ns": 3014715, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.538584168466375, "pattern_frame_queries": 146783, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3014715, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.538584168466375, "pattern_frame_updates": 424538, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5960840720, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14040.770720171104, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 61007, "avg_candidate_generations": 4692.846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 5362779, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.90432245480027, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 967, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 60994, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5361812, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1675548, "avg_legality_checks": 128888.30769230769, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2749, "root_legality_checks": 967, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1674581, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2749, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6184473, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 475728.6923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12345321218, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1996.1799846163126, "renju_forbidden_checks": 162409, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12493.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 472287453, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2908.0128133293106, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4878, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19526102, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 74514, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 296197831, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 83012, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 156555350, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8170, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 191809, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14754.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1559631801, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8131.17111814357, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 250941, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19303.153846153848, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 648608687, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2584.7059149361803, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3738626649, "stage_ordering_ns": 1941389091, "stage_eval_ns": 5963855435, "stage_threat_ns": 9101564354, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1187031, "root_tactical_annotations": 3532, "search_tactical_annotations": 1183499, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 424551, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2386776823, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 952428, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6321264806, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 122078, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4039209290, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 212269, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 295064134, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 424538, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51022186, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 297102, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 361396018, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 533238, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1920398228, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 356691, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 47436405, "child_limit_applications": 60994, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 60994, "child_cap_hits": 60994, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 60994, "child_moves_before_total": 5359063, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5359063, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 786871, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 786871, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.86213398039152, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.900793520674165, "tt_hits": 33239, "tt_cutoffs": 4492, "beta_cutoffs": 47601, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 4.846153846153846, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 4.846153846153846, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2226.3076923076924, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2634.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 67, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1666666666666665, "search_nodes": 201, "safety_nodes": 1086, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1287, "avg_nodes": 107.25, "eval_calls": 189, "avg_eval_calls": 15.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 189, "line_shape_eval_ns": 144831, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 766.3015873015873, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 900, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.0, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 900, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14034, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1169.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27062078, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1928.3225024939434, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4950, "stage_ordering_ns": 550, "stage_eval_ns": 144831, "stage_threat_ns": 22988016, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 390, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22450292, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 221650, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 189, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 268222, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 378, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47852, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 221, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20461, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 64, 128, 144, 81, 129, 99, 174, 159, 130, 82, 79, 83, 84, 97, 67, 127, 142, 113, 146, 162, 143, 145, 141, 140, 158, 65, 49, 85, 71, 126, 116, 102, 172 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 58, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.411764705882353, "search_nodes": 527, "safety_nodes": 1288, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1815, "avg_nodes": 106.76470588235294, "eval_calls": 510, "avg_eval_calls": 30.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 510, "line_shape_eval_ns": 545494, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1069.5960784313725, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1361, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.05882352941177, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1361, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1361, "avg_legality_checks": 80.05882352941177, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 1361, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21552, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1267.764705882353, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 42434077, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1968.9159706755754, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.411764705882353, "renju_forbidden_ns": 556131, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9588.465517241379, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 114851, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 441280, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 66, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8823529411764706, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 719023, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10894.287878787878, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.705882352941177, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 402491, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4149.3917525773195, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3335095, "stage_ordering_ns": 790, "stage_eval_ns": 545494, "stage_threat_ns": 36995688, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1037, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 35106451, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1056705, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17960, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 708852, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1020, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 123680, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6821.235294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7291.823529411765, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 20383, "avg_search_time_ms": 1199.0, "search_nodes": 136692, "safety_nodes": 1427, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 138119, "avg_nodes": 8124.64705882353, "eval_calls": 80753, "avg_eval_calls": 4750.176470588235, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80753, "pattern_eval_ns": 1698900, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.038227681943706, "pattern_frame_queries": 80753, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1698900, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.038227681943706, "pattern_frame_updates": 273176, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2866520263, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10493.309306088382, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 48628, "avg_candidate_generations": 2860.470588235294, "candidate_moves_total": 4409632, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.68092457020647, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1381, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 48611, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4408251, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 3030747, "avg_legality_checks": 178279.23529411765, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16702, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3030747, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16702, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6793118, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 399595.17647058825, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13266932290, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1952.9960012471445, "renju_forbidden_checks": 86079, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5063.470588235294, "renju_forbidden_ns": 499687343, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5804.9854552213665, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17513, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 170990716, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21264, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 190429887, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 47245, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 137646879, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 619861, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 294035, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17296.176470588234, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2916895686, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9920.232917849917, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 414906, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 24406.235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1501728360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3619.4423797197437, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7006886389, "stage_ordering_ns": 1676092260, "stage_eval_ns": 2868219163, "stage_threat_ns": 8713000231, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1076095, "root_tactical_annotations": 2366, "search_tactical_annotations": 1073729, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 273193, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1566343417, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 890681, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6877863868, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 97359, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3148546612, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 136588, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 202620737, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 273176, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33213600, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 232882, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 892033689, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 560429, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2836996487, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 282784, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32958609, "child_limit_applications": 48611, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 48611, "child_cap_hits": 48611, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 48611, "child_moves_before_total": 4391549, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4391549, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 654744, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 654744, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.340643064327, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.46905021497192, "tt_hits": 27625, "tt_cutoffs": 7227, "beta_cutoffs": 40942, "depth_sum": 101, "avg_depth": 5.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 101, "avg_effective_depth": 5.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4267.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4737.588235294118, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 88, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 222, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12449, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 128, 82, 113, 83, 143, 158, 84, 68, 54, 81, 79, 66, 99, 69, 129, 144, 65, 111, 126, 51 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 12406, "avg_search_time_ms": 1127.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 117506, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 117892, "avg_nodes": 10717.454545454546, "eval_calls": 74270, "avg_eval_calls": 6751.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74270, "pattern_eval_ns": 1523884, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.518163457654502, "pattern_frame_queries": 74270, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1523884, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.518163457654502, "pattern_frame_updates": 234902, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3144215439, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13385.222088360253, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 40020, "avg_candidate_generations": 3638.181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 3154048, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.81179410294853, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 716, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 40009, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3153332, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 914816, "avg_legality_checks": 83165.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4057, "root_legality_checks": 716, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 914100, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4054, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3416756, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 310614.1818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7317949223, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2141.782797191254, "renju_forbidden_checks": 50934, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4630.363636363636, "renju_forbidden_ns": 347107058, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6814.839949738878, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4983, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 50944919, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22009, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 190652630, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23927, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 105325289, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 184220, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 94127, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8557.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 831855881, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8837.590500069056, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 126465, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11496.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 357817468, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2829.3794172300636, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2236093343, "stage_ordering_ns": 1260514610, "stage_eval_ns": 3145739323, "stage_threat_ns": 5720950419, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 675110, "root_tactical_annotations": 2193, "search_tactical_annotations": 672917, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 234913, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1357919500, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 518514, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4132293966, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 80094, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2894525387, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 117451, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 171014419, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 234902, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29001084, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 149003, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 164920960, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 289410, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1072693698, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 236697, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30721450, "child_limit_applications": 40009, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 40009, "child_cap_hits": 40009, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 40009, "child_moves_before_total": 3149278, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3149278, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 421535, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 421535, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.71423929615837, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.536004399010222, "tt_hits": 23340, "tt_cutoffs": 3172, "beta_cutoffs": 32548, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3090.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3818.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 46, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1, "search_nodes": 96, "safety_nodes": 1037, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1133, "avg_nodes": 113.3, "eval_calls": 86, "avg_eval_calls": 8.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 86, "line_shape_eval_ns": 74461, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 865.8255813953489, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 657, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.7, "candidate_moves_max": 76, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 657, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11772, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1177.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23555061, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2000.9396024464831, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 163350, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 13612.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 163350, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4180, "stage_ordering_ns": 480, "stage_eval_ns": 74461, "stage_threat_ns": 19096862, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 182, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18600840, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 347232, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10620, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125050, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 172, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23740, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 223, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8806, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 64, 128, 144, 81, 158, 110, 130, 116, 143, 141, 160, 111, 145, 146, 115, 100, 175 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.888888888888889, "search_nodes": 269, "safety_nodes": 616, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 885, "avg_nodes": 98.33333333333333, "eval_calls": 260, "avg_eval_calls": 28.88888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 260, "line_shape_eval_ns": 187820, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 722.3846153846154, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 649, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 649, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 649, "avg_legality_checks": 72.11111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 649, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11543, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1282.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23774796, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2059.672182274972, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.7777777777777777, "renju_forbidden_ns": 310631, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12425.24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 63730, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 246901, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 34, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.7777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 408182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12005.35294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.555555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 226692, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4533.84, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1708477, "stage_ordering_ns": 400, "stage_eval_ns": 187820, "stage_threat_ns": 20206160, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 529, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19264255, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 524562, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9530, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 353672, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 520, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63671, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5773.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8764, "avg_search_time_ms": 973.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 68915, "safety_nodes": 578, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 69493, "avg_nodes": 7721.444444444444, "eval_calls": 48571, "avg_eval_calls": 5396.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48571, "pattern_eval_ns": 1006153, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.71509748615429, "pattern_frame_queries": 48571, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1006153, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.71509748615429, "pattern_frame_updates": 137746, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1394269626, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10122.033496435468, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19107, "avg_candidate_generations": 2123.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1700077, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.97665776940389, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 672, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 19098, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1699405, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1076908, "avg_legality_checks": 119656.44444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8028, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1076908, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8028, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2705719, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 300635.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5578365041, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2061.6941526448236, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31494, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3499.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 228525198, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7256.150314345589, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8038, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 91634788, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8472, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 93006972, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14949, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43453563, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 429875, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 130575, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14508.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1372919175, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10514.410683515222, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 187303, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20811.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 696711979, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3719.705391798316, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2699617859, "stage_ordering_ns": 676530841, "stage_eval_ns": 1395275779, "stage_threat_ns": 3946508605, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 355232, "root_tactical_annotations": 1684, "search_tactical_annotations": 353548, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 137755, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 801677571, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 326770, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3018137211, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38255, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1340818958, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68873, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 103010717, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 137746, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16813142, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 93152, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 578629953, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 195356, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1098543279, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 66724, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6869964, "child_limit_applications": 19098, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19098, "child_cap_hits": 19098, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19098, "child_moves_before_total": 1691377, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1691377, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 242420, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 242420, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.56304325060216, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.69347575662373, "tt_hits": 7304, "tt_cutoffs": 1205, "beta_cutoffs": 14152, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3901.222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4790.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1426, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 224, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13260, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 128, 110, 127, 125, 129, 130, 140, 82, 124, 81, 79, 114, 66, 95, 65, 98, 146, 97, 94, 99 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 13225, "avg_search_time_ms": 1202.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 163166, "safety_nodes": 243, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 163409, "avg_nodes": 14855.363636363636, "eval_calls": 112608, "avg_eval_calls": 10237.09090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 112608, "pattern_eval_ns": 2287426, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.313174907644218, "pattern_frame_queries": 112608, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2287426, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.313174907644218, "pattern_frame_updates": 326234, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3970139234, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12169.605969947952, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 47524, "avg_candidate_generations": 4320.363636363636, "candidate_moves_total": 3927133, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.63473192492215, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 719, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 47513, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3926414, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 996196, "avg_legality_checks": 90563.27272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1260, "root_legality_checks": 719, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 995477, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1260, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4388020, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 398910.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7642854942, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1741.7548101421598, "renju_forbidden_checks": 92155, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8377.727272727272, "renju_forbidden_ns": 296025660, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3212.2582605393086, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2846, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11529075, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 51206, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 218092750, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 38103, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 66403835, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 116182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10562.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 795662320, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6848.413007178393, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 148219, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13474.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 327817977, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2211.71359272428, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2070970566, "stage_ordering_ns": 1228219172, "stage_eval_ns": 3972426660, "stage_threat_ns": 5891562741, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 936571, "root_tactical_annotations": 2312, "search_tactical_annotations": 934259, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 326245, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1534636910, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 846362, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4098077617, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 95096, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2715825106, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 163117, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 199329861, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 326234, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33668161, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 194400, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 180211398, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 556857, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1201872772, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 185314, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 25850192, "child_limit_applications": 47513, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 47513, "child_cap_hits": 47513, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 47513, "child_moves_before_total": 3925154, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3925154, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 570280, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 570280, "child_moves_after_max": 29, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 29, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.61221139477617, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.002609812051439, "tt_hits": 17780, "tt_cutoffs": 2996, "beta_cutoffs": 38023, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3131.2727272727275, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3858.5454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.6, "search_nodes": 86, "safety_nodes": 953, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1039, "avg_nodes": 103.9, "eval_calls": 76, "avg_eval_calls": 7.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 76, "line_shape_eval_ns": 55940, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 736.0526315789474, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 653, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.3, "candidate_moves_max": 80, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 653, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11719, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1171.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19400417, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1655.4669340387404, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3960, "stage_ordering_ns": 570, "stage_eval_ns": 55940, "stage_threat_ns": 15897130, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 162, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15558158, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 205901, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112670, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20401, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 225, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6464, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 111, 81, 79, 114, 130, 95, 127, 50, 66, 65, 110, 35 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5, "search_nodes": 247, "safety_nodes": 431, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 678, "avg_nodes": 84.75, "eval_calls": 239, "avg_eval_calls": 29.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 239, "line_shape_eval_ns": 164071, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 686.489539748954, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 530, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.25, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 530, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 530, "avg_legality_checks": 66.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 530, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20768244, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2078.4871897518015, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 116221, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12913.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 65931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4709.357142857143, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1363006, "stage_ordering_ns": 380, "stage_eval_ns": 164071, "stage_threat_ns": 17811600, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17205877, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 196851, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8140, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 346892, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61980, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6426, "avg_search_time_ms": 803.25, "search_nodes": 47774, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48303, "avg_nodes": 6037.875, "eval_calls": 30495, "avg_eval_calls": 3811.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 30495, "pattern_eval_ns": 649371, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.294343334972947, "pattern_frame_queries": 30495, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 649371, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.294343334972947, "pattern_frame_updates": 95472, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 851742292, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8921.38314898609, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16078, "avg_candidate_generations": 2009.75, "candidate_moves_total": 1341529, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.43879835800473, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 547, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 16070, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1340982, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 883182, "avg_legality_checks": 110397.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 530, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 883182, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 530, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2065990, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 258248.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4259288902, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2061.6212576053126, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8358, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1044.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18317959, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2191.6677434793014, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 530, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6309060, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 386, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 3712751, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7437, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8235848, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 60300, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 84249, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10531.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 877085358, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10410.63226863227, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 134781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16847.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 449765071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3337.006484593526, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2130763922, "stage_ordering_ns": 544900439, "stage_eval_ns": 852391663, "stage_threat_ns": 2857121876, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 262510, "root_tactical_annotations": 1254, "search_tactical_annotations": 261256, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 95480, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 564425925, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 238708, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2204771186, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32193, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1106939482, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47736, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 70348902, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 95472, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11965097, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 58139, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 302097201, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 148370, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 795625592, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 56001, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5610766, "child_limit_applications": 16070, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16070, "child_cap_hits": 16070, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16070, "child_moves_before_total": 1340452, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1340452, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 169024, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 169024, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.41331673926571, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.51798382078407, "tt_hits": 6608, "tt_cutoffs": 1171, "beta_cutoffs": 12194, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.625, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.625, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4045.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5045.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1740, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 226, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20342, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 114, 81, 79, 83, 84, 97, 100, 86, 68, 52, 144, 160, 116, 132, 130, 67, 37, 102, 115, 113, 85, 70, 145 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 20294, "avg_search_time_ms": 1561.076923076923, "search_nodes": 214286, "safety_nodes": 539, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 214825, "avg_nodes": 16525.0, "eval_calls": 148888, "avg_eval_calls": 11452.923076923076, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 148888, "pattern_eval_ns": 3082023, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.700278061361562, "pattern_frame_queries": 148888, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3082023, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.700278061361562, "pattern_frame_updates": 428434, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5898597213, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13767.808374218666, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 61181, "avg_candidate_generations": 4706.2307692307695, "candidate_moves_total": 5328218, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.08942318693713, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 967, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 61168, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5327251, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1638264, "avg_legality_checks": 126020.30769230769, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4470, "root_legality_checks": 967, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1637297, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4470, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6197055, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 476696.53846153844, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11953904804, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1928.9654205102263, "renju_forbidden_checks": 169897, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 13069.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 494594875, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2911.1454292895105, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6498, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 29384629, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 82582, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 324682492, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 80812, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 140521774, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5980, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 192526, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14809.692307692309, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1517310969, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7881.070447627852, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 253773, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19521.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 642154466, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2530.4286350399766, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3554100213, "stage_ordering_ns": 1858608555, "stage_eval_ns": 5901679236, "stage_threat_ns": 8907968209, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1176767, "root_tactical_annotations": 3536, "search_tactical_annotations": 1173231, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 428447, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2323586811, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 971990, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6198164818, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 122430, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3960862920, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 214217, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 296278764, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 428434, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49926754, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 286842, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 369837066, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 562708, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1867242952, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 327217, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 40011062, "child_limit_applications": 61168, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 61168, "child_cap_hits": 61168, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 61168, "child_moves_before_total": 5322781, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5322781, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 792428, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 792428, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.01904590635627, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.954943761443893, "tt_hits": 31133, "tt_cutoffs": 4163, "beta_cutoffs": 47934, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 5.076923076923077, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 5.076923076923077, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1648.4615384615386, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2091.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.9166666666666665, "search_nodes": 201, "safety_nodes": 1086, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1287, "avg_nodes": 107.25, "eval_calls": 189, "avg_eval_calls": 15.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 189, "line_shape_eval_ns": 147061, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 778.1005291005291, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 900, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.0, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 900, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14034, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1169.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26018221, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1853.941926749323, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4890, "stage_ordering_ns": 520, "stage_eval_ns": 147061, "stage_threat_ns": 22339865, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 390, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21770431, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 244191, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11370, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 189, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 276461, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 378, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48782, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 227, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5647, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 140, 154, 97, 99, 69, 142, 156, 83, 111, 86, 100, 85, 82, 87 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 17, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.125, "search_nodes": 247, "safety_nodes": 431, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 678, "avg_nodes": 84.75, "eval_calls": 239, "avg_eval_calls": 29.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 239, "line_shape_eval_ns": 96800, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 405.02092050209205, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 530, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.25, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 530, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 530, "avg_legality_checks": 66.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 530, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12743337, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1275.3539831865492, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 66610, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7401.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 39070, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2790.714285714286, "stage_move_gen_ns": 786894, "stage_ordering_ns": 370, "stage_eval_ns": 96800, "stage_threat_ns": 10644654, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 10261932, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 115940, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 227432, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39350, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5497.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6497.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5622, "avg_search_time_ms": 702.75, "search_nodes": 72814, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 73343, "avg_nodes": 9167.875, "eval_calls": 48769, "avg_eval_calls": 6096.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48769, "pattern_eval_ns": 934843, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.168795751399454, "pattern_frame_queries": 48769, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 934843, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.168795751399454, "pattern_frame_updates": 145552, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 912868865, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6271.771360063757, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22436, "avg_candidate_generations": 2804.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1890377, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.25641825637369, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 547, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 22428, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1889830, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1255361, "avg_legality_checks": 156920.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7682, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1255361, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7682, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2800380, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 350047.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3536284346, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1262.7873167213022, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16540, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2067.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 81087606, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4902.515477629988, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7682, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 47883034, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4474, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25726248, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4379, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7442784, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 35540, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 88300, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11037.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 557726687, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6316.270520951302, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 126599, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15824.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 284526415, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2247.4617887976997, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1873958432, "stage_ordering_ns": 465219569, "stage_eval_ns": 913803708, "stage_threat_ns": 2317346541, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 380278, "root_tactical_annotations": 1254, "search_tactical_annotations": 379024, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 145560, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 538935153, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 293412, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1676019473, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44909, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 953168534, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72776, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73275713, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 145552, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12294794, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 76984, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 240566588, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171513, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 482211761, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 131781, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16821408, "child_limit_applications": 22428, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22428, "child_cap_hits": 22428, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22428, "child_moves_before_total": 1882148, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1882148, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 232784, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 232784, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.91956482967719, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.37916889602283, "tt_hits": 11739, "tt_cutoffs": 1580, "beta_cutoffs": 16461, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.625, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.625, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4467.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5467.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1786, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 228, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13942, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 141, 99, 129, 69, 54, 100, 140, 154, 142, 86, 72, 139, 127, 97, 110, 94, 109, 113, 157, 172, 125, 93, 173 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 13900, "avg_search_time_ms": 1069.2307692307693, "search_nodes": 179920, "safety_nodes": 632, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 180552, "avg_nodes": 13888.615384615385, "eval_calls": 133583, "avg_eval_calls": 10275.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 133583, "pattern_eval_ns": 2661293, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.922392819445587, "pattern_frame_queries": 133583, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2661293, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.922392819445587, "pattern_frame_updates": 359710, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5027225693, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13975.774076339274, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43729, "avg_candidate_generations": 3363.769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 3900474, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.19650575133207, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 994, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 43716, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3899480, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1209002, "avg_legality_checks": 93000.15384615384, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8522, "root_legality_checks": 994, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1208008, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8519, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5006021, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 385078.53846153844, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7809363143, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1559.9940837243792, "renju_forbidden_checks": 163959, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12612.23076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 870512272, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5309.328990784282, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12058, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 81320033, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 102315, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 625406207, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 49557, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 163546952, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 239080, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 139108, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10700.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 974528551, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7005.55360583144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 196986, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15152.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 440163935, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2234.4934919232837, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2157562522, "stage_ordering_ns": 1060382037, "stage_eval_ns": 5029886986, "stage_threat_ns": 5588637383, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 908287, "root_tactical_annotations": 2728, "search_tactical_annotations": 905559, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 359723, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1596007263, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 717365, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3707646776, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 87522, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2288085821, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 179855, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 211601356, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 359710, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35423215, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 240759, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 224955020, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 389074, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1194381235, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 278454, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 37958773, "child_limit_applications": 43716, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43716, "child_cap_hits": 43716, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43716, "child_moves_before_total": 3890961, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3890961, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 554085, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 554085, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.00542135602525, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.674650013724952, "tt_hits": 22869, "tt_cutoffs": 2556, "beta_cutoffs": 33067, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 4.923076923076923, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 4.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5267.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5882.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1441, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.5833333333333335, "search_nodes": 202, "safety_nodes": 1216, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1418, "avg_nodes": 118.16666666666667, "eval_calls": 190, "avg_eval_calls": 15.833333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 190, "line_shape_eval_ns": 118681, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 624.6368421052632, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 916, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.33333333333333, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 916, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14101, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1175.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21359689, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1514.7641302035317, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.3333333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 267600, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9557.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 267600, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4560, "stage_ordering_ns": 810, "stage_eval_ns": 118681, "stage_threat_ns": 18626955, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 392, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18164223, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 182331, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 239701, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 380, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40700, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6331.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 229, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24478, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 70, 126, 140, 83, 125, 95, 124, 82, 138, 152, 81, 85, 86, 99, 54, 38, 139, 137, 170, 155, 102, 118, 154, 169, 122, 106, 186 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 45, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.2142857142857144, "search_nodes": 372, "safety_nodes": 1228, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1600, "avg_nodes": 114.28571428571429, "eval_calls": 358, "avg_eval_calls": 25.571428571428573, "line_shape_eval_calls": 358, "line_shape_eval_ns": 301042, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 840.8994413407821, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1173, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.78571428571429, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1173, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1173, "avg_legality_checks": 83.78571428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 1173, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17835, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1273.9285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30511085, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1710.7420801794224, "renju_forbidden_checks": 107, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7.642857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1063984, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9943.775700934579, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 205850, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 86, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 858134, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 62, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.428571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 645215, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10406.693548387097, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 88, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.285714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 355744, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4042.5454545454545, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2590812, "stage_ordering_ns": 690, "stage_eval_ns": 301042, "stage_threat_ns": 26273771, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 730, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24903503, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 833735, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 358, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 453513, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 716, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 83020, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6569.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7140.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 24419, "avg_search_time_ms": 1744.2142857142858, "search_nodes": 185929, "safety_nodes": 659, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 186588, "avg_nodes": 13327.714285714286, "eval_calls": 124094, "avg_eval_calls": 8863.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 124094, "pattern_eval_ns": 2579028, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.782858155914067, "pattern_frame_queries": 124094, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2579028, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.782858155914067, "pattern_frame_updates": 371702, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4180281403, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11246.324752086348, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 55574, "avg_candidate_generations": 3969.5714285714284, "candidate_moves_total": 5234493, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.1896030517868, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1203, "root_candidate_moves_max": 114, "search_candidate_generations": 55560, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5233290, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 3794976, "avg_legality_checks": 271069.71428571426, "illegal_moves_skipped": 66275, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3794976, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 66275, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9134363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 652454.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15079665879, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1650.8721931677119, "renju_forbidden_checks": 255687, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 18263.35714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1640383135, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6415.5906831399325, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 70145, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 688481755, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 63928, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 625942988, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 121494, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 324699015, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 120, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1259377, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 440143, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 31438.785714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 4247327109, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9649.879945835784, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 651195, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 46513.92857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2317111217, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3558.244791498706, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7980046538, "stage_ordering_ns": 1603405509, "stage_eval_ns": 4182860431, "stage_threat_ns": 10506656628, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1327894, "root_tactical_annotations": 3909, "search_tactical_annotations": 1323985, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 371716, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1877856496, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1119111, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8294455619, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 111225, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3196669326, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185851, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 248441105, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 371702, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40876711, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 371350, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1947155833, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 636525, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3150501889, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 320019, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 45026697, "child_limit_applications": 55560, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 55560, "child_cap_hits": 55560, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 55560, "child_moves_before_total": 5167015, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5167015, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 842748, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 842748, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 92.99883009359252, "avg_child_moves_after": 15.168250539956803, "tt_hits": 27975, "tt_cutoffs": 6200, "beta_cutoffs": 45674, "depth_sum": 74, "avg_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 74, "avg_effective_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2735.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3000.3571428571427, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 230, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11327, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 126, 82, 111, 81, 141, 156, 80, 66, 50, 83, 85, 68, 95, 65, 125, 140, 69, 113, 128, 53 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11284, "avg_search_time_ms": 1025.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 118069, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 118455, "avg_nodes": 10768.636363636364, "eval_calls": 74848, "avg_eval_calls": 6804.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74848, "pattern_eval_ns": 1509077, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.161888093202222, "pattern_frame_queries": 74848, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1509077, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.161888093202222, "pattern_frame_updates": 236028, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2926153108, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12397.482959648854, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39926, "avg_candidate_generations": 3629.6363636363635, "candidate_moves_total": 3168358, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.35575815258228, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 716, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 39915, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3167642, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 930285, "avg_legality_checks": 84571.36363636363, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4090, "root_legality_checks": 716, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 929569, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4087, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3441808, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 312891.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6643759336, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1930.3108529005685, "renju_forbidden_checks": 51788, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4708.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 312338642, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6031.100679694137, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5012, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 43318475, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22741, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 177316868, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24020, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 91528898, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 174401, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 95232, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8657.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 768199858, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8066.6147723454305, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 127366, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11578.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 329196944, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2584.65323555737, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2056267812, "stage_ordering_ns": 1103769299, "stage_eval_ns": 2927662185, "stage_threat_ns": 5151815371, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 671922, "root_tactical_annotations": 2193, "search_tactical_annotations": 669729, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 236039, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1254620791, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 517107, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3681011460, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 79906, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2551753724, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 118014, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159443980, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 236028, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26838679, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 146423, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 156949245, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 290771, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 972154400, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 234728, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 29900461, "child_limit_applications": 39915, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39915, "child_cap_hits": 39915, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39915, "child_moves_before_total": 3163555, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3163555, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 419245, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 419245, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.25729675560567, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.503444820243017, "tt_hits": 23288, "tt_cutoffs": 3251, "beta_cutoffs": 32438, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3605.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4333.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 341, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 30, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0, "search_nodes": 96, "safety_nodes": 1037, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1133, "avg_nodes": 113.3, "eval_calls": 86, "avg_eval_calls": 8.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 86, "line_shape_eval_ns": 73630, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 856.1627906976744, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 657, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.7, "candidate_moves_max": 76, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 657, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11772, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1177.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22757998, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1933.2312266394836, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 152100, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12675.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 152100, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3770, "stage_ordering_ns": 480, "stage_eval_ns": 73630, "stage_threat_ns": 18223818, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 182, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17736886, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 337802, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 127240, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 172, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21890, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 231, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18290, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 97, 82, 142, 157, 113, 114, 66, 96, 68, 138, 124, 84, 128, 130, 146, 81, 83, 99, 126, 125, 129, 54, 145, 69 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 42, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5, "search_nodes": 351, "safety_nodes": 953, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1304, "avg_nodes": 108.66666666666667, "eval_calls": 339, "avg_eval_calls": 28.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 339, "line_shape_eval_ns": 332972, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 982.2182890855457, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 894, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.5, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 894, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 894, "avg_legality_checks": 74.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 894, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15161, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1263.4166666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30661018, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2022.3611898951256, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.9166666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 394811, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11280.314285714287, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 71830, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 322981, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 33, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 367093, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11124.030303030304, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 48, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 196422, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4092.125, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2308618, "stage_ordering_ns": 530, "stage_eval_ns": 332972, "stage_threat_ns": 26085980, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 690, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24952175, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 586353, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 339, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 463342, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 678, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 84110, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 18233, "avg_search_time_ms": 1519.4166666666667, "search_nodes": 121076, "safety_nodes": 323, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 121399, "avg_nodes": 10116.583333333334, "eval_calls": 73216, "avg_eval_calls": 6101.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73216, "pattern_eval_ns": 1537697, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.002198972902097, "pattern_frame_queries": 73216, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1537697, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.002198972902097, "pattern_frame_updates": 242022, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2612942058, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10796.29974960954, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43933, "avg_candidate_generations": 3661.0833333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 3891620, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.58079348098241, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 909, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 43921, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3890711, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 2690537, "avg_legality_checks": 224211.41666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8336, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2690537, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8336, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5943173, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 495264.4166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12168451965, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2047.4672308882814, "renju_forbidden_checks": 69979, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5831.583333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 232305270, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3319.6426070678344, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8665, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 94724962, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6874, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 56034724, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 54395, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 81031941, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 513643, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 231216, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19268.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2250443014, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9733.07649124628, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 335295, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27941.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1080660428, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3223.0138475074186, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6368105317, "stage_ordering_ns": 1547459738, "stage_eval_ns": 2614479755, "stage_threat_ns": 7603634981, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 808328, "root_tactical_annotations": 3563, "search_tactical_annotations": 804765, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 242034, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1436440650, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 711943, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5934119426, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 87930, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3027620655, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121011, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 179745424, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 242022, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30099787, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 176359, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 618988757, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 447645, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2287458304, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 184324, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23229694, "child_limit_applications": 43921, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43921, "child_cap_hits": 43921, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43921, "child_moves_before_total": 3882375, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3882375, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 441324, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 441324, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.39450376812914, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.048131873135858, "tt_hits": 18968, "tt_cutoffs": 3877, "beta_cutoffs": 35176, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.4166666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.4166666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2265.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2749.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 232, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8536, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 157, 128, 80, 114, 156, 113, 111, 99, 141, 144, 160, 129, 159, 84 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8502, "avg_search_time_ms": 944.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 88920, "safety_nodes": 68, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 88988, "avg_nodes": 9887.555555555555, "eval_calls": 62950, "avg_eval_calls": 6994.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62950, "pattern_eval_ns": 1282594, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.374805401111992, "pattern_frame_queries": 62950, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1282594, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.374805401111992, "pattern_frame_updates": 177762, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2517783015, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14163.78649542647, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24549, "avg_candidate_generations": 2727.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 1745579, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.10591062772414, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 534, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 24540, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1745045, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 597237, "avg_legality_checks": 66359.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 863, "root_legality_checks": 534, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 596703, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 862, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2353590, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 261510.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5110048268, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2171.17181327249, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26122, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2902.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 169622583, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6493.476112089426, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1070, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9584157, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16538, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 133089207, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8509, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26898679, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 50540, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58664, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6518.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 514555708, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8771.234624301105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 79936, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8881.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 218878406, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2738.1706114891913, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1452948843, "stage_ordering_ns": 723527029, "stage_eval_ns": 2519065609, "stage_threat_ns": 3779493037, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 310108, "root_tactical_annotations": 2144, "search_tactical_annotations": 307964, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 177771, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1046698089, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 259517, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2568688964, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49136, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1840666873, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 88881, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 129905241, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 177762, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22158246, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 59108, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 122502272, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 151265, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 605511339, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 99735, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12042497, "child_limit_applications": 24540, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24540, "child_cap_hits": 24540, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24540, "child_moves_before_total": 1744183, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1744183, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 244423, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 244423, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.07510187449063, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.960187449062754, "tt_hits": 12291, "tt_cutoffs": 1391, "beta_cutoffs": 17906, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3134.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4022.8888888888887, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 680, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 25, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.125, "search_nodes": 71, "safety_nodes": 708, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 779, "avg_nodes": 97.375, "eval_calls": 63, "avg_eval_calls": 7.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 63, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44770, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 710.6349206349206, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 475, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.375, "candidate_moves_max": 69, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 475, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9335, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1166.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18609887, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1993.5604713444027, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46381, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11595.25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 46381, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2920, "stage_ordering_ns": 380, "stage_eval_ns": 44770, "stage_threat_ns": 14936924, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 134, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14572433, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 254241, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8220, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 63, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93900, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 126, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16350, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 233, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9647, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 143, 98, 141, 96, 99, 97, 94, 127, 142, 79, 63, 144, 139, 158, 140 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.6, "search_nodes": 315, "safety_nodes": 638, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 953, "avg_nodes": 95.3, "eval_calls": 305, "avg_eval_calls": 30.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 305, "line_shape_eval_ns": 255670, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 838.2622950819672, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 629, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.9, "candidate_moves_max": 78, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 629, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 629, "avg_legality_checks": 62.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "root_legality_checks": 629, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12440, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1244.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24868720, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1999.0932475884244, "renju_forbidden_checks": 76, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 762396, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10031.526315789473, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 144893, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 62, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 617503, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 740984, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11399.753846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 407972, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4294.442105263158, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1696368, "stage_ordering_ns": 420, "stage_eval_ns": 255670, "stage_threat_ns": 22284704, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 620, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20854365, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 933254, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 305, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 421604, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 610, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 75481, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9599, "avg_search_time_ms": 959.9, "search_nodes": 68816, "safety_nodes": 490, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 69306, "avg_nodes": 6930.6, "eval_calls": 41765, "avg_eval_calls": 4176.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41765, "pattern_eval_ns": 873163, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.906572488926134, "pattern_frame_queries": 41765, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 873163, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.906572488926134, "pattern_frame_updates": 137534, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1778645519, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12932.405943257667, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24233, "avg_candidate_generations": 2423.3, "candidate_moves_total": 1867595, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.06825403375562, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 643, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 24223, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1866952, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 1082793, "avg_legality_checks": 108279.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17314, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1082793, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17314, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3002799, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 300279.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6013508106, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2002.6342442501145, "renju_forbidden_checks": 53570, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5357.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 414182377, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7731.610546947919, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17530, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 171186804, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17017, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 160209054, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18938, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 81904054, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 85, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 882465, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 126613, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12661.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1323652556, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10454.317929438525, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 185812, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18581.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 683572816, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3678.8410651626373, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2674470864, "stage_ordering_ns": 759099591, "stage_eval_ns": 1779518682, "stage_threat_ns": 4341741517, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 454216, "root_tactical_annotations": 1412, "search_tactical_annotations": 452804, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 137544, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 812036466, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 374382, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3394560016, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48514, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1725079850, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68767, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 102657363, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 137534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16929173, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 89332, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 457902392, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 236530, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1211504904, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 128354, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15558499, "child_limit_applications": 24223, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24223, "child_cap_hits": 24223, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24223, "child_moves_before_total": 1849638, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1849638, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 299401, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 299401, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.35874994839615, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.360194856128473, "tt_hits": 11630, "tt_cutoffs": 2780, "beta_cutoffs": 19708, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 4.8, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 4.8, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4044.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4844.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1598, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 234, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 56031, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 109, 84, 70, 126, 140, 142, 94, 141, 156, 124, 96, 125, 127, 97, 83, 153, 139, 138, 123, 152, 166, 158, 174, 107, 95, 81, 93, 92, 137, 151, 154, 77, 122, 108, 150, 76, 60, 62, 47, 48, 34, 78, 79, 64, 63, 31, 106, 32, 80, 46, 16, 144, 50, 116, 65, 35, 51, 37, 66, 18, 52, 38, 53, 49, 54 ], "move_count": 72, "black_stats": { "move_count": 36, "search_move_count": 34, "total_time_ms": 55898, "avg_search_time_ms": 1644.0588235294117, "search_nodes": 600913, "safety_nodes": 1027, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 601940, "avg_nodes": 17704.117647058825, "eval_calls": 372839, "avg_eval_calls": 10965.85294117647, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 372839, "pattern_eval_ns": 7695721, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.64086911508721, "pattern_frame_queries": 372839, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7695721, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.64086911508721, "pattern_frame_updates": 1201440, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 12565663227, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10458.835419996005, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 211732, "avg_candidate_generations": 6227.411764705882, "candidate_moves_total": 20625127, "avg_candidate_moves": 97.41147771711408, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 34, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3039, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 211698, "search_candidate_moves_total": 20622088, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 5762377, "avg_legality_checks": 169481.67647058822, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2664, "root_legality_checks": 3039, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5759338, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16110540, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 473839.4117647059, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31586914455, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1960.6366052906978, "renju_forbidden_checks": 144210, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4241.470588235294, "renju_forbidden_ns": 407342364, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2824.647139588101, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8115, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 29577769, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 60783, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 241073609, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 75312, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 136690986, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 293122, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8621.235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2142534901, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7309.362316714542, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 390885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11496.617647058823, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 874630736, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2237.565360655947, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12197381252, "stage_ordering_ns": 6957259539, "stage_eval_ns": 12573358948, "stage_threat_ns": 23933914155, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 5081895, "root_tactical_annotations": 12340, "search_tactical_annotations": 5069555, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1201474, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6287742989, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 4360252, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 16472510453, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 423657, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11264250999, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 600720, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 872498222, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1201440, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 142681014, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1615617, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 563286308, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 2320952, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 4644876996, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1145326, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 158481477, "child_limit_applications": 211698, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 211698, "child_cap_hits": 211698, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 211698, "child_moves_before_total": 20619424, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 20619424, "child_moves_before_max": 135, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 135, "child_moves_after_total": 1837480, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1837480, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 97.40018327995541, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.679723001634404, "tt_hits": 102270, "tt_cutoffs": 16190, "beta_cutoffs": 163337, "depth_sum": 182, "avg_depth": 5.352941176470588, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 182, "avg_effective_depth": 5.352941176470588, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 10 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 11, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3235294117647059, "pooled_budget_moves": 34, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3235294117647059, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 11, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3235294117647059, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2637.823529411765, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2873.1176470588234, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 36, "search_move_count": 34, "total_time_ms": 103, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0294117647058822, "search_nodes": 804, "safety_nodes": 4083, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 4887, "avg_nodes": 143.73529411764707, "eval_calls": 770, "avg_eval_calls": 22.647058823529413, "line_shape_eval_calls": 770, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1719878, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 2233.607792207792, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3070, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.29411764705883, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 34, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3070, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 37252, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1095.6470588235295, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 69405787, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1863.1425695264684, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.0588235294117647, "renju_forbidden_ns": 54311, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1508.638888888889, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 36, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 54311, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18530, "stage_ordering_ns": 1620, "stage_eval_ns": 1719878, "stage_threat_ns": 63476348, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1574, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 61425333, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 94, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 813143, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 35460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1059559, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1540, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 178313, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 34 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 34, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7410.794117647059, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7646.088235294118, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 235, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6954, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 125, 128, 95, 66, 110, 140, 80, 96, 65 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.857142857142857, "search_nodes": 290, "safety_nodes": 243, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 533, "avg_nodes": 76.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 283, "avg_eval_calls": 40.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 283, "line_shape_eval_ns": 204621, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 723.0424028268551, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 408, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 408, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 408, "avg_legality_checks": 58.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 408, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1222.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17567844, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2052.3182242990656, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 314522, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11232.92857142857, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53830, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 260692, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 312071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11558.185185185184, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.714285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 175121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4378.025, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1096945, "stage_ordering_ns": 270, "stage_eval_ns": 204621, "stage_threat_ns": 16486779, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 573, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15600835, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 424921, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7200, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 390083, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 566, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 70940, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 6920, "avg_search_time_ms": 988.5714285714286, "search_nodes": 53257, "safety_nodes": 215, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53472, "avg_nodes": 7638.857142857143, "eval_calls": 35250, "avg_eval_calls": 5035.714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35250, "pattern_eval_ns": 739525, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.979432624113475, "pattern_frame_queries": 35250, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 739525, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.979432624113475, "pattern_frame_updates": 106446, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1291555583, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12133.4346335231, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16647, "avg_candidate_generations": 2378.1428571428573, "candidate_moves_total": 1257117, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.51612903225806, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 421, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 16640, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1256696, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 737093, "avg_legality_checks": 105299.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8937, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 737093, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8937, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2156422, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 308060.28571428574, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4320134177, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2003.3806819815416, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38126, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5446.571428571428, "renju_forbidden_ns": 298872871, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7839.082804385459, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9302, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 97886111, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14381, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 146375263, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14403, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 54158667, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 452830, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 104749, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14964.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1088090140, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10387.594535508691, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 154359, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22051.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 561573093, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3638.097506462208, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1858927487, "stage_ordering_ns": 506080114, "stage_eval_ns": 1292295108, "stage_threat_ns": 3231145775, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 272524, "root_tactical_annotations": 1216, "search_tactical_annotations": 271308, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 106453, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 624693526, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 256409, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2508856168, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33327, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1170732359, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 53223, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 78957526, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 106446, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13020944, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 53447, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 350348712, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 169630, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 987725947, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49447, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5617611, "child_limit_applications": 16640, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16640, "child_cap_hits": 16640, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16640, "child_moves_before_total": 1247759, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1247759, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 201226, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 201226, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.98551682692307, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.092908653846154, "tt_hits": 5974, "tt_cutoffs": 1333, "beta_cutoffs": 12700, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2880.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3895.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1497, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 236, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18083, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 96, 98, 82, 127, 128, 80, 110, 68, 111, 113, 67, 52, 83, 69, 99, 51, 84, 85, 124, 138, 139, 125, 109, 108, 94, 79, 154 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 18033, "avg_search_time_ms": 1288.0714285714287, "search_nodes": 192993, "safety_nodes": 80, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 193073, "avg_nodes": 13790.92857142857, "eval_calls": 130210, "avg_eval_calls": 9300.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 130210, "pattern_eval_ns": 2676260, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.55341371630443, "pattern_frame_queries": 130210, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2676260, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.55341371630443, "pattern_frame_updates": 385862, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4737881395, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12278.693924252711, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 58314, "avg_candidate_generations": 4165.285714285715, "candidate_moves_total": 4661479, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.93756216345989, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 893, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 58300, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4660586, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1354476, "avg_legality_checks": 96748.28571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 529, "root_legality_checks": 893, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1353583, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 529, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4994568, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 356754.85714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10540684372, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2110.429645166509, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24951, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1782.2142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 79836843, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3199.7452206324397, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 743, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3001050, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13279, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 56363649, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10929, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20472144, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 130097, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9292.642857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 946897325, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7278.394774668132, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 159568, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11397.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 295864932, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1854.162062568936, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3145734737, "stage_ordering_ns": 1777705434, "stage_eval_ns": 4740557655, "stage_threat_ns": 8309442881, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1170227, "root_tactical_annotations": 3680, "search_tactical_annotations": 1166547, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 385876, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2274848783, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 962177, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5656369865, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 116689, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3949105891, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 192931, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 282147196, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 385862, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49513095, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 291712, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 281531011, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 553763, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1425719713, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 324752, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 46563942, "child_limit_applications": 58300, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 58300, "child_cap_hits": 58300, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 58300, "child_moves_before_total": 4660057, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4660057, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 615280, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 615280, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.93236706689537, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.55368782161235, "tt_hits": 27647, "tt_cutoffs": 4424, "beta_cutoffs": 43423, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.214285714285714, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.214285714285714, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4548.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5120.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 40, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.076923076923077, "search_nodes": 81, "safety_nodes": 1162, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1243, "avg_nodes": 95.61538461538461, "eval_calls": 68, "avg_eval_calls": 5.230769230769231, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68, "line_shape_eval_ns": 57120, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 840.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 820, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.07692307692308, "candidate_moves_max": 80, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 820, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14874, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1144.1538461538462, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29388508, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1975.8308457711444, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5400, "stage_ordering_ns": 690, "stage_eval_ns": 57120, "stage_threat_ns": 23475117, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 149, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22985929, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 367595, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13901, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 103562, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18031, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6458.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7074.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 237, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15302, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 114, 115, 97, 82, 68, 126, 94, 81, 98, 124, 138, 83, 84, 80, 79, 125, 70, 56, 127, 95, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 40, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3333333333333335, "search_nodes": 256, "safety_nodes": 971, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1227, "avg_nodes": 102.25, "eval_calls": 244, "avg_eval_calls": 20.333333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 244, "line_shape_eval_ns": 182231, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 746.8483606557377, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 840, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.0, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 840, "avg_legality_checks": 70.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 840, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15042, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1253.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30560615, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2031.6856136152107, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.0833333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 281852, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11274.08, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 54241, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 227611, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 443933, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11382.897435897436, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 241093, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4305.232142857143, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2146110, "stage_ordering_ns": 580, "stage_eval_ns": 182231, "stage_threat_ns": 25094167, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 500, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24032411, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 660545, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12551, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 244, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 336541, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 488, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64670, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 15247, "avg_search_time_ms": 1270.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 116309, "safety_nodes": 784, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 117093, "avg_nodes": 9757.75, "eval_calls": 76817, "avg_eval_calls": 6401.416666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 76817, "pattern_eval_ns": 1590768, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.708541078146766, "pattern_frame_queries": 76817, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1590768, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.708541078146766, "pattern_frame_updates": 232490, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2325017055, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10000.503484020817, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 36565, "avg_candidate_generations": 3047.0833333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 3311846, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.57421031040613, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 866, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 36553, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3310980, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 2365930, "avg_legality_checks": 197160.83333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8236, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2365930, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8236, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4833599, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 402799.9166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10023038120, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2073.618047339053, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29026, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2418.8333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 190369779, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6558.595018259492, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8465, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 86259609, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7229, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 69738287, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13297, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 33961162, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 410721, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 146220, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12185.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1405121070, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9609.636643414035, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 202661, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16888.416666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 671290086, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3312.379224419104, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5564847260, "stage_ordering_ns": 1296970062, "stage_eval_ns": 2326607823, "stage_threat_ns": 5970580960, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 694659, "root_tactical_annotations": 2378, "search_tactical_annotations": 692281, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 232502, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1386441177, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 556970, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4356615932, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 73193, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2498860008, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 116245, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 170682586, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 232490, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30621859, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 178731, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 641982159, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 305037, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1215647244, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 210891, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26219406, "child_limit_applications": 36553, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 36553, "child_cap_hits": 36553, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 36553, "child_moves_before_total": 3302744, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3302744, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 363866, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 363866, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.35493666730501, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.954477060706372, "tt_hits": 19769, "tt_cutoffs": 2878, "beta_cutoffs": 28862, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.083333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.083333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4203.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4869.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1655, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 238, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9937, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 82, 124, 68, 54, 114, 98, 84, 125, 127, 139, 97, 154, 140, 169, 109, 184 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9897, "avg_search_time_ms": 989.7, "search_nodes": 97836, "safety_nodes": 251, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 98087, "avg_nodes": 9808.7, "eval_calls": 68182, "avg_eval_calls": 6818.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68182, "pattern_eval_ns": 1392073, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.417016221290076, "pattern_frame_queries": 68182, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1392073, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.417016221290076, "pattern_frame_updates": 195576, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2616150854, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13376.645672270626, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27813, "avg_candidate_generations": 2781.3, "candidate_moves_total": 2164908, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.83798942940352, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 664, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 27803, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2164244, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 828636, "avg_legality_checks": 82863.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1094, "root_legality_checks": 664, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 827972, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1094, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2789834, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 278983.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6031211121, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2161.853042510773, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26787, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2678.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124306756, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4640.562810318438, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1265, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10645803, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13736, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 86190236, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11786, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27470717, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76680, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7668.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 709486803, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9252.566549295774, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 107239, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10723.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 319251280, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2977.007245498373, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2005260190, "stage_ordering_ns": 895325278, "stage_eval_ns": 2617542927, "stage_threat_ns": 4340336284, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 379991, "root_tactical_annotations": 2155, "search_tactical_annotations": 377836, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 195586, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1154229526, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 330361, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3007029566, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 55673, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2024943087, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 97788, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 142202231, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 195576, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24261566, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 86054, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 160706421, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 188626, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 821279588, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 105311, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12613395, "child_limit_applications": 27803, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27803, "child_cap_hits": 27803, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27803, "child_moves_before_total": 2163150, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2163150, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 271812, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 271812, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.80275509837068, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.776355069596805, "tt_hits": 13668, "tt_cutoffs": 1803, "beta_cutoffs": 20217, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 4.8, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 4.8, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3396.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4196.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 552, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 30, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3333333333333335, "search_nodes": 201, "safety_nodes": 683, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 192, "avg_eval_calls": 21.333333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 192, "line_shape_eval_ns": 138261, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 720.109375, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 605, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_max": 80, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 605, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10548, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1172.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21318755, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2021.1182214637845, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3680, "stage_ordering_ns": 470, "stage_eval_ns": 138261, "stage_threat_ns": 18545088, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 393, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18034412, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 195273, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9250, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 192, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 267322, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48081, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5773.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 239, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14966, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 142, 157, 111, 110, 68, 98, 66, 138, 124, 80, 126, 130, 146, 125, 140, 79, 154, 168, 81, 95, 141, 65 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0, "search_nodes": 358, "safety_nodes": 979, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1337, "avg_nodes": 111.41666666666667, "eval_calls": 346, "avg_eval_calls": 28.833333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 346, "line_shape_eval_ns": 322173, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 931.135838150289, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 915, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.25, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 915, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 915, "avg_legality_checks": 76.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 915, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15277, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1273.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27579028, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1805.26464620017, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.9166666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 398441, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11384.028571428571, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 82340, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 316101, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.6666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 486971, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11067.522727272728, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.416666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 265360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4082.4615384615386, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2140718, "stage_ordering_ns": 520, "stage_eval_ns": 322173, "stage_threat_ns": 23383459, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 704, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22254466, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 632111, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 346, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 423192, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 692, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 73690, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6331.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 14913, "avg_search_time_ms": 1242.75, "search_nodes": 112494, "safety_nodes": 679, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 113173, "avg_nodes": 9431.083333333334, "eval_calls": 70138, "avg_eval_calls": 5844.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70138, "pattern_eval_ns": 1438880, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.514984744361115, "pattern_frame_queries": 70138, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1438880, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.514984744361115, "pattern_frame_updates": 224862, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2238008014, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9952.806672536934, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38732, "avg_candidate_generations": 3227.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 3495731, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.25433749870908, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 932, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 38720, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3494799, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 2303926, "avg_legality_checks": 191993.83333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11216, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2303926, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11216, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5189744, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 432478.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9780719687, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1884.6246918923168, "renju_forbidden_checks": 50397, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4199.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 271947788, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5396.110641506439, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11365, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 107138705, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12296, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 108574770, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26674, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 55551588, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 62, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 682725, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 203816, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16984.666666666668, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1846173258, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9058.038907642187, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 297966, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 24830.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 913774017, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3066.7056543364006, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5083996897, "stage_ordering_ns": 1282146164, "stage_eval_ns": 2239446894, "stage_threat_ns": 6204883551, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 661359, "root_tactical_annotations": 2605, "search_tactical_annotations": 658754, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 224874, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1223232810, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 573858, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4782772959, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 77526, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2443332804, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 112431, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 152671864, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 224862, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26003943, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 140430, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 611527841, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 355893, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1727809783, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 165036, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20201975, "child_limit_applications": 38720, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38720, "child_cap_hits": 38720, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38720, "child_moves_before_total": 3483583, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3483583, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 409239, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 409239, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.96856921487603, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.569189049586777, "tt_hits": 17708, "tt_cutoffs": 3575, "beta_cutoffs": 30534, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4021.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4687.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1702, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 240, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27157, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 98, 68, 54, 110, 124, 142, 100, 126, 94, 158, 174, 111, 99, 101, 141, 81, 66, 85, 113, 155, 80, 84, 83, 52, 109, 36, 20, 139, 67, 51, 156, 115, 108, 122, 140, 172, 92 ], "move_count": 43, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 27072, "avg_search_time_ms": 1353.6, "search_nodes": 273960, "safety_nodes": 1195, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 275155, "avg_nodes": 13757.75, "eval_calls": 178232, "avg_eval_calls": 8911.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 178232, "pattern_eval_ns": 3663302, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.55355940571839, "pattern_frame_queries": 178232, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3663302, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.55355940571839, "pattern_frame_updates": 547698, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6827633621, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12466.055419227385, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 88593, "avg_candidate_generations": 4429.65, "candidate_moves_total": 8491323, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.84643256239207, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1762, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 88573, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8489561, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 2340179, "avg_legality_checks": 117008.95, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1510, "root_legality_checks": 1762, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 2338417, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1509, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7694606, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 384730.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15871782453, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2062.7154207765802, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55684, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2784.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 182026983, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3268.927932619783, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1892, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13491120, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24074, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 112170330, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29713, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 56309663, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55870, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 185400, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9270.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1457951984, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7863.8186839266455, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 236866, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11843.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 588225820, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2483.3695844908093, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5324117972, "stage_ordering_ns": 3092356508, "stage_eval_ns": 6831296923, "stage_threat_ns": 11720733562, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1770500, "root_tactical_annotations": 5022, "search_tactical_annotations": 1765478, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 547718, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3126376282, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1431086, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8062294740, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 177296, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5536150562, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 273849, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 395516798, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 547698, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67288862, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 474058, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 401880274, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 779718, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2123941333, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 516724, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 69256880, "child_limit_applications": 88573, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 88573, "child_cap_hits": 88573, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 88573, "child_moves_before_total": 8488052, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8488052, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 959003, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 959003, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.8311449312996, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.82726112923803, "tt_hits": 48251, "tt_cutoffs": 7045, "beta_cutoffs": 70749, "depth_sum": 109, "avg_depth": 5.45, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 109, "avg_effective_depth": 5.45, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5104.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5504.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 719, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 64, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3684210526315788, "search_nodes": 586, "safety_nodes": 1860, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2446, "avg_nodes": 128.73684210526315, "eval_calls": 567, "avg_eval_calls": 29.842105263157894, "line_shape_eval_calls": 567, "line_shape_eval_ns": 666296, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1175.1252204585537, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1678, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.3157894736842, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1678, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22136, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1165.0526315789473, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 43277379, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1955.06771774485, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.42105263157894735, "renju_forbidden_ns": 95061, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11882.625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 95061, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9220, "stage_ordering_ns": 1090, "stage_eval_ns": 666296, "stage_threat_ns": 40061252, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1153, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 38805185, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 53, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 342232, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20800, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 567, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 777235, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1134, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 136600, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6945.473684210527, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7366.526315789473, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 241, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9672, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 129, 126, 99, 96, 141, 111, 66, 113, 114, 65, 49, 144, 69, 130, 84 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.6, "search_nodes": 315, "safety_nodes": 638, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 953, "avg_nodes": 95.3, "eval_calls": 305, "avg_eval_calls": 30.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 305, "line_shape_eval_ns": 259882, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 852.072131147541, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 629, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.9, "candidate_moves_max": 78, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 629, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 629, "avg_legality_checks": 62.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "root_legality_checks": 629, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12440, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1244.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24943551, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2005.1086012861736, "renju_forbidden_checks": 76, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 813026, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10697.71052631579, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 157023, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 62, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 656003, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 744163, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11448.661538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 411751, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4334.221052631579, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1714110, "stage_ordering_ns": 470, "stage_eval_ns": 259882, "stage_threat_ns": 22398548, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 620, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20960933, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 942394, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10210, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 305, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 420181, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 610, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 75040, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9624, "avg_search_time_ms": 962.4, "search_nodes": 68264, "safety_nodes": 490, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68754, "avg_nodes": 6875.4, "eval_calls": 40947, "avg_eval_calls": 4094.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40947, "pattern_eval_ns": 867833, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.19405573057855, "pattern_frame_queries": 40947, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 867833, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.19405573057855, "pattern_frame_updates": 136430, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1704626029, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12494.510217694056, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24134, "avg_candidate_generations": 2413.4, "candidate_moves_total": 1844338, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.42073423386094, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 643, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 24124, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1843695, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 1108088, "avg_legality_checks": 110808.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 19258, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1108088, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 19258, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3023163, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 302316.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6031314969, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1995.0346603871508, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56733, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5673.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 464261333, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8183.267815909611, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 19430, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 198401240, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18135, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 177214080, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19083, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 87698058, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 85, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 947955, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 131714, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13171.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1370211927, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10402.933074692137, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 194086, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19408.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 712057939, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3668.7753830776046, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2771794688, "stage_ordering_ns": 733729737, "stage_eval_ns": 1705493862, "stage_threat_ns": 4363583738, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 465876, "root_tactical_annotations": 1412, "search_tactical_annotations": 464464, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136440, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 801229729, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 384272, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3429392307, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48316, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1710835084, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68215, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 100464270, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136430, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16837549, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96131, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 496733065, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 239819, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1221750678, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 129926, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15659883, "child_limit_applications": 24124, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24124, "child_cap_hits": 24124, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24124, "child_moves_before_total": 1824437, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1824437, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 300482, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 300482, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.6274664234787, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.455728734869838, "tt_hits": 12177, "tt_cutoffs": 3145, "beta_cutoffs": 19714, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 4.8, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 4.8, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4062.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4862.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1570, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 242, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9308, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 127, 142, 126, 114, 156, 100, 86, 82, 98, 84, 141, 111, 155, 113, 154, 140, 153, 157, 152 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9276, "avg_search_time_ms": 927.6, "search_nodes": 100658, "safety_nodes": 251, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 100909, "avg_nodes": 10090.9, "eval_calls": 70415, "avg_eval_calls": 7041.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70415, "pattern_eval_ns": 1427173, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.268025278704823, "pattern_frame_queries": 70415, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1427173, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.268025278704823, "pattern_frame_updates": 201220, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2431101473, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12081.808334161615, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28547, "avg_candidate_generations": 2854.7, "candidate_moves_total": 2246026, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.67817984376642, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 664, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 28537, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2245362, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 880373, "avg_legality_checks": 88037.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 987, "root_legality_checks": 664, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 879709, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 987, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2932449, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 293244.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5627294401, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1918.974345674895, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27096, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2709.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 109178924, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4029.3373191614996, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1180, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8733718, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13995, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 76740223, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11921, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23704983, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81536, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8153.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 647291848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7938.724587912088, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 114913, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11491.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 295724764, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2573.466570361926, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1883323463, "stage_ordering_ns": 851146964, "stage_eval_ns": 2432528646, "stage_threat_ns": 4062863099, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 374676, "root_tactical_annotations": 2155, "search_tactical_annotations": 372521, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 201230, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1072811797, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 327316, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2820639261, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 57141, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1920288644, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 100610, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 133545457, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 201220, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23195440, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 74737, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 110701470, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 195430, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 789547546, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 104509, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12671144, "child_limit_applications": 28537, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28537, "child_cap_hits": 28537, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28537, "child_moves_before_total": 2244375, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2244375, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 277827, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 277827, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.64789571433577, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.735676490170656, "tt_hits": 13735, "tt_cutoffs": 1658, "beta_cutoffs": 20787, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 4.8, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 4.8, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3633.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4433.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 425, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 25, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.7777777777777777, "search_nodes": 201, "safety_nodes": 683, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 192, "avg_eval_calls": 21.333333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 192, "line_shape_eval_ns": 97920, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 510.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 605, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_max": 80, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 605, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10548, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1172.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18128352, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1718.6530147895335, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3290, "stage_ordering_ns": 450, "stage_eval_ns": 97920, "stage_threat_ns": 15646751, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 393, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15218879, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 173810, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 192, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 217292, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36770, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 243, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19404, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 114, 115, 127, 142, 94, 96, 68, 124, 138, 122, 128, 125, 123, 95, 80, 143, 79, 140, 155, 141, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 41, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4166666666666665, "search_nodes": 346, "safety_nodes": 741, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1087, "avg_nodes": 90.58333333333333, "eval_calls": 334, "avg_eval_calls": 27.833333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 334, "line_shape_eval_ns": 306572, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 917.8802395209581, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 859, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.58333333333333, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 859, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 859, "avg_legality_checks": 71.58333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 859, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14988, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30012358, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2002.4258073125168, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5833333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61240, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8748.57142857143, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 49160, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.3333333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 309982, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11070.785714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.4166666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 168302, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4104.926829268293, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2097590, "stage_ordering_ns": 570, "stage_eval_ns": 306572, "stage_threat_ns": 25534492, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 680, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24566184, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 429703, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13130, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 334, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 457075, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 668, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 81530, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 19349, "avg_search_time_ms": 1612.4166666666667, "search_nodes": 127498, "safety_nodes": 397, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 127895, "avg_nodes": 10657.916666666666, "eval_calls": 77667, "avg_eval_calls": 6472.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77667, "pattern_eval_ns": 1619618, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.85336114437277, "pattern_frame_queries": 77667, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1619618, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.85336114437277, "pattern_frame_updates": 254866, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2701935081, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10601.39477607841, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46257, "avg_candidate_generations": 3854.75, "candidate_moves_total": 4123306, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.13907084333182, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 885, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 46245, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4122421, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 2962093, "avg_legality_checks": 246841.08333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1697, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2962093, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1697, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6540353, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 545029.4166666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13034218680, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1992.892230740451, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48395, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4032.9166666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 89650081, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1852.4657712573612, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1941, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17739299, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3264, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21685042, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 43180, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 50110159, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 115581, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 258124, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 21510.333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2580490460, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9997.09620182548, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 376051, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31337.583333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1306382262, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3473.949708949052, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6803253053, "stage_ordering_ns": 1630631456, "stage_eval_ns": 2703554699, "stage_threat_ns": 8103318015, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 877069, "root_tactical_annotations": 3834, "search_tactical_annotations": 873235, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 254878, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1505647600, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 725491, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6346673122, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 92578, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3084289136, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 127433, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 188101448, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 254866, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31731815, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 170735, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 826070985, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 462168, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2436241211, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 244166, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 31164030, "child_limit_applications": 46245, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46245, "child_cap_hits": 46245, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46245, "child_moves_before_total": 4120724, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4120724, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 499633, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 499633, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.10636825602768, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.80404368039788, "tt_hits": 21733, "tt_cutoffs": 3524, "beta_cutoffs": 36844, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.083333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.083333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2050.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2443.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 244, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 83241, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 115, 80, 64, 128, 144, 142, 100, 143, 158, 130, 98, 129, 127, 97, 81, 161, 145, 146, 131, 162, 178, 156, 170, 117, 99, 83, 101, 102, 147, 163, 160, 87, 132, 116, 164, 88, 74, 72, 57, 56, 40, 86, 85, 70, 71, 43, 118, 42, 84, 58, 28, 52, 54, 66, 69, 39, 53, 37, 68, 26, 38, 108, 94, 140, 23, 8, 124, 109, 125, 123, 89, 138, 93, 107, 110, 91, 78, 62, 139, 153, 168, 137, 151, 169, 185, 154, 152, 106, 105, 76, 121, 48, 34, 46, 61, 73, 103, 155, 157, 183, 79, 49, 95, 63, 141, 47, 50, 45 ], "move_count": 115, "black_stats": { "move_count": 58, "search_move_count": 56, "total_time_ms": 83042, "avg_search_time_ms": 1482.892857142857, "search_nodes": 1015748, "safety_nodes": 1393, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1017141, "avg_nodes": 18163.23214285714, "eval_calls": 648493, "avg_eval_calls": 11580.232142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 648493, "pattern_eval_ns": 13425391, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.702445515988607, "pattern_frame_queries": 648493, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 13425391, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.702445515988607, "pattern_frame_updates": 2030870, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 18842944539, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9278.26229103783, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 343499, "avg_candidate_generations": 6133.910714285715, "candidate_moves_total": 34345583, "avg_candidate_moves": 99.98743227782323, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 56, "root_candidate_moves_total": 5269, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 343443, "search_candidate_moves_total": 34340314, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 9388244, "avg_legality_checks": 167647.2142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10113, "root_legality_checks": 5269, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 9382975, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10108, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 25260601, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 451082.16071428574, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 45927677798, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1818.1545956883608, "renju_forbidden_checks": 484981, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8660.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1065636272, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2197.274268476497, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 31860, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 81705137, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 207713, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 593311106, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 245341, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 390486109, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 133920, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 566143, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10109.69642857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3912789462, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6911.309443020579, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 746577, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13331.732142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1638184822, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2194.261036704854, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18577705712, "stage_ordering_ns": 9926529078, "stage_eval_ns": 18856369930, "stage_threat_ns": 35225851329, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 9291000, "root_tactical_annotations": 22614, "search_tactical_annotations": 9268386, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 2030926, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 9724481367, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 7931884, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 23581049047, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 687310, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15156732153, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 1015435, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1420810261, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 2030870, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 231651900, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 3911553, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1413651474, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 3332977, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 7010546120, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 2046470, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 267858754, "child_limit_applications": 343443, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 343443, "child_cap_hits": 343443, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 343443, "child_moves_before_total": 34330206, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 34330206, "child_moves_before_max": 135, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 135, "child_moves_after_total": 3158584, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 3158584, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 99.9589626226186, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.196821597761492, "tt_hits": 177709, "tt_cutoffs": 23507, "beta_cutoffs": 265923, "depth_sum": 301, "avg_depth": 5.375, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 301, "avg_effective_depth": 5.375, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 18 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 9 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 12, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_moves": 56, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26785714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 12, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4722.839285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4865.696428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 57, "search_move_count": 55, "total_time_ms": 145, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.6363636363636362, "search_nodes": 1074, "safety_nodes": 7288, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 8362, "avg_nodes": 152.03636363636363, "eval_calls": 1019, "avg_eval_calls": 18.527272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 1019, "line_shape_eval_ns": 2986790, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 2931.099116781158, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 55, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 5206, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.65454545454546, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 55, "root_candidate_moves_total": 5206, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 54321, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 987.6545454545454, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 96364489, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1773.9822352313101, "renju_forbidden_checks": 139, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.5272727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 250321, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1800.8705035971223, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 139, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 250321, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 35440, "stage_ordering_ns": 2910, "stage_eval_ns": 2986790, "stage_threat_ns": 90784833, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 2093, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 87639090, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 152, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1516414, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 110, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 57260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 1019, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1395338, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 2038, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 233991, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 55 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 55, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7635.763636363637, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7781.218181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 245, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6946, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 83, 128, 81, 94, 82, 84, 80, 96, 79 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.857142857142857, "search_nodes": 290, "safety_nodes": 243, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 533, "avg_nodes": 76.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 283, "avg_eval_calls": 40.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 283, "line_shape_eval_ns": 203901, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 720.4982332155477, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 408, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 408, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 408, "avg_legality_checks": 58.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 408, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1222.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17778818, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2076.964719626168, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 301242, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10758.642857142857, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53130, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 248112, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 310461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11498.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.714285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 173440, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4336.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1097445, "stage_ordering_ns": 360, "stage_eval_ns": 203901, "stage_threat_ns": 16574702, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 573, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15688339, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 425982, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7240, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 389521, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 566, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 70860, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 6912, "avg_search_time_ms": 987.4285714285714, "search_nodes": 50832, "safety_nodes": 215, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 51047, "avg_nodes": 7292.428571428572, "eval_calls": 33401, "avg_eval_calls": 4771.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33401, "pattern_eval_ns": 691912, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.715307924912427, "pattern_frame_queries": 33401, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 691912, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.715307924912427, "pattern_frame_updates": 101596, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1309327942, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12887.593428875152, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16130, "avg_candidate_generations": 2304.285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 1246151, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.25672659640422, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 421, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 16123, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1245730, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 730952, "avg_legality_checks": 104421.71428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9201, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 730952, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9201, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2178683, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 311240.4285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4324759996, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1985.0340760909228, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38072, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5438.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 300567259, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7894.706319604959, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9322, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 96081552, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14581, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 147656955, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14129, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 56389749, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 439003, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 108919, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15559.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1123635300, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10316.246935796325, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 161015, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23002.14285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 577336884, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3585.6093159022453, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1824769500, "stage_ordering_ns": 507884125, "stage_eval_ns": 1310019854, "stage_threat_ns": 3236448871, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 280403, "root_tactical_annotations": 1216, "search_tactical_annotations": 279187, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 101603, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 604297999, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 256983, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2538286268, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32293, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1158323936, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50798, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74522211, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 101596, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12611444, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52636, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 360873133, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 172049, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1019038909, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 55718, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6730949, "child_limit_applications": 16123, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16123, "child_cap_hits": 16123, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16123, "child_moves_before_total": 1236529, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1236529, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 203014, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 203014, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.6934813620294, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.59157724989146, "tt_hits": 6065, "tt_cutoffs": 1275, "beta_cutoffs": 12404, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2916.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3933.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1641, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 246, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27761, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 113, 114, 128, 82, 66, 130, 146, 110, 158, 96, 68, 124, 138, 97, 143, 173, 95, 99, 100, 159, 127, 79, 84, 144, 129, 116, 67, 102, 88, 65, 115, 101, 94, 157, 52, 36, 80, 108, 38 ], "move_count": 43, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 27678, "avg_search_time_ms": 1383.9, "search_nodes": 285758, "safety_nodes": 1193, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 286951, "avg_nodes": 14347.55, "eval_calls": 184002, "avg_eval_calls": 9200.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 184002, "pattern_eval_ns": 3792862, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.613156378735013, "pattern_frame_queries": 184002, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3792862, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.613156378735013, "pattern_frame_updates": 571294, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6903226729, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12083.4924382192, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 94516, "avg_candidate_generations": 4725.8, "candidate_moves_total": 9205496, "avg_candidate_moves": 97.3961657285539, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1761, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 94496, "search_candidate_moves_total": 9203735, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 2557780, "avg_legality_checks": 127889.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2055, "root_legality_checks": 1761, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 2556019, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2053, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8215592, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 410779.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16335337395, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1988.3335729184214, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60970, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3048.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 195132005, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3200.4593242578317, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2421, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18474190, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25829, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 118276998, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32710, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 58277427, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 103390, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 193606, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9680.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1484933765, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7669.874719791742, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 246983, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12349.15, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 597378084, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2418.701222351336, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5651009680, "stage_ordering_ns": 3142823886, "stage_eval_ns": 6907019591, "stage_threat_ns": 11861872436, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1875337, "root_tactical_annotations": 5022, "search_tactical_annotations": 1870315, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 571314, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3117243628, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1537101, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8208232562, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 189142, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5643231347, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 285647, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 399271911, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 571294, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67364054, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 494431, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 350907036, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 853514, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2213774547, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 527392, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 69760281, "child_limit_applications": 94496, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 94496, "child_cap_hits": 94496, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 94496, "child_moves_before_total": 9201682, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 9201682, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 1009672, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1009672, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 97.37641804944124, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.684812055536742, "tt_hits": 49478, "tt_cutoffs": 7150, "beta_cutoffs": 75949, "depth_sum": 110, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 110, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4853.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5253.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 314, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 63, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3157894736842106, "search_nodes": 585, "safety_nodes": 1860, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2445, "avg_nodes": 128.68421052631578, "eval_calls": 566, "avg_eval_calls": 29.789473684210527, "line_shape_eval_calls": 566, "line_shape_eval_ns": 667053, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1178.5388692579506, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1677, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.26315789473684, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1677, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22150, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1165.7894736842106, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 42910049, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1937.2482618510157, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.631578947368421, "renju_forbidden_ns": 137361, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11446.75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 137361, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9240, "stage_ordering_ns": 1050, "stage_eval_ns": 667053, "stage_threat_ns": 39397066, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1151, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 38152902, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 53, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 332322, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 566, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 775111, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1132, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 136731, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6945.526315789473, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7366.578947368421, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 247, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8994, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 82, 142, 157, 111, 143, 98, 129, 115, 158, 173, 159, 156, 144, 114, 130, 172, 145, 131, 161, 177, 160 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 33, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0, "search_nodes": 208, "safety_nodes": 729, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 937, "avg_nodes": 85.18181818181819, "eval_calls": 197, "avg_eval_calls": 17.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 197, "line_shape_eval_ns": 172660, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 876.4467005076142, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 626, "avg_candidate_moves": 56.90909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 72, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 626, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 626, "avg_legality_checks": 56.90909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 626, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13320, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1210.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23472382, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1762.1908408408408, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.6363636363636362, "renju_forbidden_ns": 284430, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7110.75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 51660, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 232770, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 455441, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8758.48076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 257700, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3390.7894736842104, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1368885, "stage_ordering_ns": 620, "stage_eval_ns": 172660, "stage_threat_ns": 20136271, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 405, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19211498, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 598731, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9130, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 276992, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49050, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8952, "avg_search_time_ms": 813.8181818181819, "search_nodes": 78192, "safety_nodes": 193, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 78385, "avg_nodes": 7125.909090909091, "eval_calls": 53332, "avg_eval_calls": 4848.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53332, "pattern_eval_ns": 1112904, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.867471686792168, "pattern_frame_queries": 53332, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1112904, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.867471686792168, "pattern_frame_updates": 156282, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1729905757, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11069.129886999142, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23347, "avg_candidate_generations": 2122.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 1724384, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.85891120914893, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 659, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 23336, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1723725, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 1086272, "avg_legality_checks": 98752.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13837, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1086272, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13837, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2918817, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 265347.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5590081186, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1915.1872782706143, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43647, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3967.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 335166546, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7679.028249364217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 13943, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 120777282, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18600, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 159777957, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11044, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 54184754, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 426553, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 118448, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10768.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1108717659, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9360.374670741592, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 164052, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14913.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 541062603, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3298.1164691683125, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2563255906, "stage_ordering_ns": 661106452, "stage_eval_ns": 1731018661, "stage_threat_ns": 3941934033, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 475494, "root_tactical_annotations": 2244, "search_tactical_annotations": 473250, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 156293, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 833916618, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 402804, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2968697473, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46744, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1533069425, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78141, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107527091, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 156282, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18020872, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 122052, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 475005949, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 233999, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 960568309, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 119443, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13771979, "child_limit_applications": 23336, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23336, "child_cap_hits": 23336, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23336, "child_moves_before_total": 1709888, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1709888, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 265852, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 265852, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.27254028111074, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.392355159410354, "tt_hits": 10113, "tt_cutoffs": 1474, "beta_cutoffs": 17018, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5204.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5931.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1599, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 248, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7262, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 98, 114, 100, 156, 170, 99, 84, 126, 68, 52, 67, 82, 70, 56, 69, 66, 71 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7233, "avg_search_time_ms": 723.3, "search_nodes": 103617, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 103848, "avg_nodes": 10384.8, "eval_calls": 68558, "avg_eval_calls": 6855.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68558, "pattern_eval_ns": 1361375, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.857274132851018, "pattern_frame_queries": 68558, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1361375, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.857274132851018, "pattern_frame_updates": 207154, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2006657573, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9686.791338810739, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32534, "avg_candidate_generations": 3253.4, "candidate_moves_total": 2615835, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.40311673941108, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 32524, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2615195, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 775900, "avg_legality_checks": 77590.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 728, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 775260, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2744302, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 274430.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4159746798, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1515.7758869104057, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30556, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3055.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 110061608, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3601.963869616442, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1280, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4617031, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17571, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 82338450, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11700, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23049327, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 56800, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53650, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5365.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 319448638, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5954.30825722274, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 69829, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6982.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 128095134, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1834.4116914176059, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1303759344, "stage_ordering_ns": 722362638, "stage_eval_ns": 2008018948, "stage_threat_ns": 3152825400, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 510711, "root_tactical_annotations": 1860, "search_tactical_annotations": 508851, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 207164, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 856609863, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 413650, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2143081503, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 65107, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1581774609, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 103577, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 114315612, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 207154, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19395481, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 107195, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 48519916, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 241340, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 512699998, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 162176, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19422941, "child_limit_applications": 32524, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32524, "child_cap_hits": 32524, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32524, "child_moves_before_total": 2614468, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2614468, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 291423, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 291423, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.38580740376338, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.960244742344114, "tt_hits": 16858, "tt_cutoffs": 2496, "beta_cutoffs": 24409, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 3.9, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 3.9, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5143.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5943.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1804, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 22, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.4444444444444446, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 32580, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 561.7241379310345, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1157.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16530911, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1587.373823698867, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 48351, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12087.75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 48351, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3280, "stage_ordering_ns": 450, "stage_eval_ns": 32580, "stage_threat_ns": 13277130, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 13062640, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 141700, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7310, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 62390, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10400, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5775.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6664.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 249, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23368, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 109, 108, 125, 128, 124, 143, 98, 141, 99, 140, 142, 129, 130, 97, 145, 115, 157, 188, 158, 156, 171, 155, 169, 204, 146, 172 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 49, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5, "search_nodes": 434, "safety_nodes": 715, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1149, "avg_nodes": 82.07142857142857, "eval_calls": 420, "avg_eval_calls": 30.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 420, "line_shape_eval_ns": 528333, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1257.9357142857143, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 854, "avg_candidate_moves": 61.0, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 854, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 854, "avg_legality_checks": 61.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "root_legality_checks": 854, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16759, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1197.0714285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 33924086, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2024.2309206993257, "renju_forbidden_checks": 76, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.428571428571429, "renju_forbidden_ns": 814173, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10712.802631578947, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 162230, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 61, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 651943, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.214285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 676823, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11471.57627118644, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 381742, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4438.860465116279, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2232241, "stage_ordering_ns": 700, "stage_eval_ns": 528333, "stage_threat_ns": 30321987, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 854, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 28756260, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 870473, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19150, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 591323, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 840, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 103931, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6568.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7140.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 23304, "avg_search_time_ms": 1664.5714285714287, "search_nodes": 164265, "safety_nodes": 203, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 164468, "avg_nodes": 11747.714285714286, "eval_calls": 107173, "avg_eval_calls": 7655.214285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107173, "pattern_eval_ns": 2241202, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.91200209007866, "pattern_frame_queries": 107173, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2241202, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.91200209007866, "pattern_frame_updates": 328386, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4432099746, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13496.61601286291, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52833, "avg_candidate_generations": 3773.785714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 4044264, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.54806654931576, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 885, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 52819, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4043379, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 2781405, "avg_legality_checks": 198671.7857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24937, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2781405, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24937, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7583940, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 541710.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14960051103, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1972.5961839096828, "renju_forbidden_checks": 109523, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7823.071428571428, "renju_forbidden_ns": 713700368, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6516.442829360043, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 26893, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 264933781, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34647, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 310865879, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 47888, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 136876414, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 95, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1024294, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 348506, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 24893.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3498022949, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10037.195769943703, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 521649, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 37260.642857142855, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1786856502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3425.4000333557624, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6708340356, "stage_ordering_ns": 1615084224, "stage_eval_ns": 4434340948, "stage_threat_ns": 10443860000, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1317726, "root_tactical_annotations": 3631, "search_tactical_annotations": 1314095, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 328400, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1924066023, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1160138, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8200168391, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 105737, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3657707914, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 164193, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 245397937, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 328386, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41365158, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 342944, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1161431053, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 711445, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3380970404, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 263337, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32862491, "child_limit_applications": 52819, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52819, "child_cap_hits": 52819, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52819, "child_moves_before_total": 4018442, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4018442, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 632898, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 632898, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.07947897536872, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.982392699596735, "tt_hits": 21917, "tt_cutoffs": 4205, "beta_cutoffs": 41020, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.785714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.785714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1087.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1429.2142857142858, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 250, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8797, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 141, 155, 99, 85, 140, 139, 97, 123, 107, 108, 109, 153, 167, 138, 93, 168 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8761, "avg_search_time_ms": 876.1, "search_nodes": 92311, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92542, "avg_nodes": 9254.2, "eval_calls": 60583, "avg_eval_calls": 6058.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60583, "pattern_eval_ns": 1236969, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.41775745671228, "pattern_frame_queries": 60583, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1236969, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.41775745671228, "pattern_frame_updates": 184534, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2257693876, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12234.568567310089, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29635, "avg_candidate_generations": 2963.5, "candidate_moves_total": 2404202, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.12711321073056, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 29625, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2403562, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 677628, "avg_legality_checks": 67762.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 447, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 676988, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 446, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2420820, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 242082.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5129627493, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2118.962786576449, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21668, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2166.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 95208367, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4393.961925419974, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 791, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3546705, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12315, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 69597093, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8557, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22017359, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 47210, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47806, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4780.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 374532518, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7834.424925741539, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 61549, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6154.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 148040987, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2405.2541389786998, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1611063910, "stage_ordering_ns": 939234836, "stage_eval_ns": 2258930845, "stage_threat_ns": 3917828608, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 459548, "root_tactical_annotations": 1864, "search_tactical_annotations": 457684, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 184544, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1045875796, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 382410, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2699925736, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59313, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2018232171, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 131465546, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 184534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22571475, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 98634, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 61125785, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 224455, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 620431019, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 136459, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17990055, "child_limit_applications": 29625, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29625, "child_cap_hits": 29625, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29625, "child_moves_before_total": 2403116, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2403116, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 263034, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 263034, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.11783966244725, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.878784810126582, "tt_hits": 14845, "tt_cutoffs": 2060, "beta_cutoffs": 22438, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4478.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5278.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1224, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 43650, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 752.5862068965517, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20933931, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2005.9343618244538, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 39241, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9810.25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 39241, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3500, "stage_ordering_ns": 400, "stage_eval_ns": 43650, "stage_threat_ns": 16679375, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16392643, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 187471, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 84261, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15000, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 251, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8245, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 67, 127, 142, 98, 126, 81, 110, 94, 141, 156, 140, 143, 125, 95, 109, 157, 124, 108, 138, 152, 139 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.8181818181818183, "search_nodes": 208, "safety_nodes": 729, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 937, "avg_nodes": 85.18181818181819, "eval_calls": 197, "avg_eval_calls": 17.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 197, "line_shape_eval_ns": 131560, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 667.8172588832488, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 626, "avg_candidate_moves": 56.90909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 72, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 626, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 626, "avg_legality_checks": 56.90909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 626, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1219.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22780143, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1698.2363948113912, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.6363636363636362, "renju_forbidden_ns": 233361, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5834.025, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53250, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 180111, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 492211, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9465.596153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 278281, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3661.592105263158, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1327747, "stage_ordering_ns": 470, "stage_eval_ns": 131560, "stage_threat_ns": 19067392, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 405, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18134900, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 647902, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9440, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 241280, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43310, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8202, "avg_search_time_ms": 745.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 89481, "safety_nodes": 193, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 89674, "avg_nodes": 8152.181818181818, "eval_calls": 60996, "avg_eval_calls": 5545.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60996, "pattern_eval_ns": 1185335, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.432995606269262, "pattern_frame_queries": 60996, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1185335, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.432995606269262, "pattern_frame_updates": 178860, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1463041666, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8179.814748965671, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26630, "avg_candidate_generations": 2420.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 1987743, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.64299662035299, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 659, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 26619, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1987084, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 1255490, "avg_legality_checks": 114135.45454545454, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5610, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1255490, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5610, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3251673, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 295606.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5165966647, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1588.7103798567691, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28811, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2619.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 140386304, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4872.663357745306, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 39489251, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10325, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71486705, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12712, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28997825, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 412523, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 121762, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11069.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 976292505, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8018.039330825709, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 179245, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16295.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 492196788, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2745.9443108594382, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2381680112, "stage_ordering_ns": 617368930, "stage_eval_ns": 1464227001, "stage_threat_ns": 3679583045, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 505511, "root_tactical_annotations": 2244, "search_tactical_annotations": 503267, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 178871, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 819877149, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 419996, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2720853789, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53310, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1456100545, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104937462, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 178860, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17639220, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 123790, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 376121468, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 242887, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 888579036, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 138834, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16275425, "child_limit_applications": 26619, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26619, "child_cap_hits": 26619, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26619, "child_moves_before_total": 1981474, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1981474, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 294024, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 294024, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.43833352116908, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.045644088808746, "tt_hits": 12240, "tt_cutoffs": 1816, "beta_cutoffs": 19346, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5203.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5930.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1588, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 252, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6882, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 95, 79, 143, 159, 80, 65, 113, 51, 37, 52, 67, 49, 33, 50, 53, 48 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6854, "avg_search_time_ms": 685.4, "search_nodes": 112972, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 113203, "avg_nodes": 11320.3, "eval_calls": 75697, "avg_eval_calls": 7569.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75697, "pattern_eval_ns": 1400049, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.49543575042604, "pattern_frame_queries": 75697, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1400049, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.49543575042604, "pattern_frame_updates": 225864, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1905969510, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8438.571485495697, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34514, "avg_candidate_generations": 3451.4, "candidate_moves_total": 2780399, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.55858492206062, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 34504, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2779759, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 825590, "avg_legality_checks": 82559.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 861, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 824950, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 860, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2889385, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 288938.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3925039360, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1358.4341858215503, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31116, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3111.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 102765788, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3302.6670523203497, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1290, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4181166, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18586, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 78712231, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11235, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19820101, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 52290, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5818.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 306151087, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5262.045805331638, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 75955, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7595.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 124526565, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1639.4781778684749, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1294705473, "stage_ordering_ns": 671880316, "stage_eval_ns": 1907369559, "stage_threat_ns": 2930829057, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 548116, "root_tactical_annotations": 1860, "search_tactical_annotations": 546256, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 225874, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 840551807, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 432603, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1933797078, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69067, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1407930043, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 112932, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113973934, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 225864, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18823417, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 114026, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 44213615, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 249502, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 481571530, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 184588, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23682821, "child_limit_applications": 34504, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34504, "child_cap_hits": 34504, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34504, "child_moves_before_total": 2778899, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2778899, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 309291, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 309291, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.53845930906562, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.963917226988176, "tt_hits": 18537, "tt_cutoffs": 2731, "beta_cutoffs": 25636, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 3.9, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 3.9, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5224.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6024.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1811, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 20, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.2222222222222223, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 30730, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 529.8275862068965, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14795728, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1417.7585281717134, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 45200, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11300.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 45200, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2720, "stage_ordering_ns": 410, "stage_eval_ns": 30730, "stage_threat_ns": 11941464, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 11763324, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 112520, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 55730, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9890, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5776.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6665.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1999, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 253, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8631, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 110, 114, 115, 127, 99, 96, 83, 67, 100, 101, 85, 130, 84, 82, 68, 116, 69, 53, 55, 41, 70 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 32, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.909090909090909, "search_nodes": 208, "safety_nodes": 729, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 937, "avg_nodes": 85.18181818181819, "eval_calls": 197, "avg_eval_calls": 17.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 197, "line_shape_eval_ns": 170240, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 864.1624365482234, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 626, "avg_candidate_moves": 56.90909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 72, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 626, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 626, "avg_legality_checks": 56.90909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 626, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13320, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1210.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22148826, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1662.8247747747748, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.6363636363636362, "renju_forbidden_ns": 374662, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9366.55, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 77980, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 296682, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 411441, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7912.326923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 233600, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3073.684210526316, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1358602, "stage_ordering_ns": 590, "stage_eval_ns": 170240, "stage_threat_ns": 18901777, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 405, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18045733, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 540712, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 266742, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48590, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8590, "avg_search_time_ms": 780.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 88216, "safety_nodes": 193, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 88409, "avg_nodes": 8037.181818181818, "eval_calls": 60220, "avg_eval_calls": 5474.545454545455, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60220, "pattern_eval_ns": 1201938, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.959116572567254, "pattern_frame_queries": 60220, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1201938, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.959116572567254, "pattern_frame_updates": 176330, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1553883486, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8812.360267679918, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26241, "avg_candidate_generations": 2385.5454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 1965735, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.9108265691094, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 659, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 26230, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1965076, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1234729, "avg_legality_checks": 112248.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5678, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1234729, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5678, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3183832, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 289439.2727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5412452607, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1699.980591626694, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28328, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2575.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 173566053, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6127.014014402711, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5760, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52976452, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9999, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 82687916, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12509, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37334902, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 566783, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 119638, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10876.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1010482290, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8446.165014460288, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 176364, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16033.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 512221317, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2904.341685377968, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2509606568, "stage_ordering_ns": 660066016, "stage_eval_ns": 1555085424, "stage_threat_ns": 3808300305, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 496428, "root_tactical_annotations": 2244, "search_tactical_annotations": 494184, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 176341, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 858180571, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 412374, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2805122648, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52532, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1499349330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 88165, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 109591720, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 176330, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18576295, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 124107, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 423398272, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 235726, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 882323196, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 136595, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16829071, "child_limit_applications": 26230, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26230, "child_cap_hits": 26230, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26230, "child_moves_before_total": 1959398, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1959398, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 290675, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 290675, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.70064811284789, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.081776591688905, "tt_hits": 12100, "tt_cutoffs": 1715, "beta_cutoffs": 19104, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5299.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6026.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1600, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 254, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7184, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 82, 66, 130, 146, 81, 80, 128, 94, 52, 109, 110, 64, 48, 79, 49, 124 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7146, "avg_search_time_ms": 714.6, "search_nodes": 74921, "safety_nodes": 228, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 75149, "avg_nodes": 7514.9, "eval_calls": 49619, "avg_eval_calls": 4961.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49619, "pattern_eval_ns": 1021636, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.589612849916364, "pattern_frame_queries": 49619, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1021636, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.589612849916364, "pattern_frame_updates": 149762, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1814154711, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12113.584961472203, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23711, "avg_candidate_generations": 2371.1, "candidate_moves_total": 1782656, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.1826578381342, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 638, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 23701, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1782018, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 558066, "avg_legality_checks": 55806.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 488, "root_legality_checks": 638, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 557428, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 487, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1958334, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 195833.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4244442560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2167.374186425809, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25598, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2559.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 96189654, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3757.701929838269, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1069, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4838094, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14852, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 67881477, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9672, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23415973, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 54110, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39897, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3989.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 326502686, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8183.640023059378, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 51977, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5197.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 127368449, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2450.4771148777345, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1341964388, "stage_ordering_ns": 691886000, "stage_eval_ns": 1815176347, "stage_threat_ns": 3267621915, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 349158, "root_tactical_annotations": 1855, "search_tactical_annotations": 347303, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 149772, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 885107472, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 270333, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2240525004, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47461, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1711058246, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74881, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108604810, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 149762, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18551583, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 77295, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 57700361, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 145569, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 471630396, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 126294, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14833046, "child_limit_applications": 23701, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23701, "child_cap_hits": 23701, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23701, "child_moves_before_total": 1781531, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1781531, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 223459, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 223459, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.16691278848994, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.428251972490612, "tt_hits": 13297, "tt_cutoffs": 1561, "beta_cutoffs": 17777, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4686.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5486.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1165, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 820, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 887, "avg_nodes": 98.55555555555556, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 45480, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 784.1379310344828, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 580, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10420, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1157.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20809763, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1997.0981765834933, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.1111111111111112, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62580, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6258.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 62580, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3520, "stage_ordering_ns": 500, "stage_eval_ns": 45480, "stage_threat_ns": 16538903, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16247622, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 192391, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9370, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 83880, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15010, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 255, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9194, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 82, 142, 157, 113, 141, 96, 125, 109, 156, 171, 155, 158, 140, 110, 124, 172, 139, 123, 153, 167, 154 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 34, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.090909090909091, "search_nodes": 208, "safety_nodes": 729, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 937, "avg_nodes": 85.18181818181819, "eval_calls": 197, "avg_eval_calls": 17.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 197, "line_shape_eval_ns": 174481, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 885.6903553299493, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 626, "avg_candidate_moves": 56.90909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 72, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 626, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 626, "avg_legality_checks": 56.90909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 626, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13320, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1210.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24443137, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1835.0703453453455, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.6363636363636362, "renju_forbidden_ns": 429652, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10741.3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 89650, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 340002, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 548453, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10547.173076923076, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 305462, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4019.2368421052633, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1497138, "stage_ordering_ns": 520, "stage_eval_ns": 174481, "stage_threat_ns": 20600538, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 405, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19565653, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 718183, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 267872, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48830, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9150, "avg_search_time_ms": 831.8181818181819, "search_nodes": 81981, "safety_nodes": 193, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 82174, "avg_nodes": 7470.363636363636, "eval_calls": 55687, "avg_eval_calls": 5062.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 55687, "pattern_eval_ns": 1127114, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.240163772514233, "pattern_frame_queries": 55687, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1127114, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.240163772514233, "pattern_frame_updates": 163860, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1663931740, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10154.59379958501, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24709, "avg_candidate_generations": 2246.2727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 1837663, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.37221255413007, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 659, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 24698, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1837004, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 1151743, "avg_legality_checks": 104703.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5206, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1151743, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5206, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3037635, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 276148.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5805691126, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1911.2536976957404, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27274, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2479.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 178524462, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6545.59147906431, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5310, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52610944, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9549, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 87167254, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12355, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 38131021, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 615243, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 120405, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10945.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1167702773, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9698.125268884183, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 177449, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16131.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 585976166, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3302.2229823780353, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2610599062, "stage_ordering_ns": 692542491, "stage_eval_ns": 1665058854, "stage_threat_ns": 4130603791, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 469652, "root_tactical_annotations": 2244, "search_tactical_annotations": 467408, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 163871, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 896815500, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 404755, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3087279256, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49468, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1587205893, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 81930, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 114615233, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 163860, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19105622, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 119262, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 454693985, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 236016, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1045324348, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 114374, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12788180, "child_limit_applications": 24698, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24698, "child_cap_hits": 24698, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24698, "child_moves_before_total": 1831798, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1831798, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 274064, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 274064, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.16786784355008, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.09660701271358, "tt_hits": 10475, "tt_cutoffs": 1546, "beta_cutoffs": 18116, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5175.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5902.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1556, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 256, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9105, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 110, 94, 158, 174, 95, 80, 128, 66, 52, 67, 82, 64, 48, 65, 68, 63 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9068, "avg_search_time_ms": 906.8, "search_nodes": 89003, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 89234, "avg_nodes": 8923.4, "eval_calls": 57856, "avg_eval_calls": 5785.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 57856, "pattern_eval_ns": 1252806, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.653864767699115, "pattern_frame_queries": 57856, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1252806, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.653864767699115, "pattern_frame_updates": 177926, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2305876770, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12959.75163832155, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29178, "avg_candidate_generations": 2917.8, "candidate_moves_total": 2300140, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.83131126190966, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 29168, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2299500, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 654205, "avg_legality_checks": 65420.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 436, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 653565, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 435, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2340786, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 234078.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5315641479, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2270.8788753008603, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22587, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2258.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 110862753, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4908.254881126311, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 852, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4330713, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12768, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 79964328, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8962, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26510862, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 56850, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43446, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4344.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 366036836, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8425.09865119919, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56263, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5626.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 141468117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2514.4076391234025, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1638356131, "stage_ordering_ns": 964300480, "stage_eval_ns": 2307129576, "stage_threat_ns": 4124104428, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 443404, "root_tactical_annotations": 1860, "search_tactical_annotations": 441544, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 177936, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1087129420, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 376974, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2861921617, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58395, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2174765492, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 88963, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 134864739, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 177926, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23089597, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96822, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 60375932, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 221749, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 626631262, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 124833, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17099055, "child_limit_applications": 29168, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29168, "child_cap_hits": 29168, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29168, "child_moves_before_total": 2299065, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2299065, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 258351, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 258351, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.82148244651673, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.857343664289633, "tt_hits": 14011, "tt_cutoffs": 1940, "beta_cutoffs": 22180, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 3.9, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 3.9, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4333.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5133.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1100, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 47400, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 817.2413793103449, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1157.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22240618, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2135.646053389668, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 49800, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12450.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 49800, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3730, "stage_ordering_ns": 510, "stage_eval_ns": 47400, "stage_threat_ns": 17675177, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17353407, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 210690, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94990, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16090, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 257, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1238, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 67, 52, 83, 99, 85, 84, 68, 54, 114, 39, 100, 69 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 248, "safety_nodes": 214, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 462, "avg_nodes": 66.0, "eval_calls": 241, "avg_eval_calls": 34.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 241, "line_shape_eval_ns": 190540, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 790.6224066390041, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 348, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.714285714285715, "candidate_moves_max": 62, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 348, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 348, "avg_legality_checks": 49.714285714285715, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 348, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8172, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1167.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17578266, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2151.0359765051394, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 117151, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10650.09090909091, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20321, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 96830, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 167941, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12918.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 93191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4904.789473684211, "stage_move_gen_ns": 932814, "stage_ordering_ns": 340, "stage_eval_ns": 190540, "stage_threat_ns": 16080432, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 489, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15432657, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 246851, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 337564, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63360, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1205, "avg_search_time_ms": 172.14285714285714, "search_nodes": 33078, "safety_nodes": 287, "corridor_nodes": 38, "corridor_branch_probes": 42, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 31, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 31, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 26, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 26, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 157, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 65040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 33403, "avg_nodes": 4771.857142857143, "eval_calls": 31993, "avg_eval_calls": 4570.428571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 31993, "pattern_eval_ns": 676582, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.14781358422155, "pattern_frame_queries": 31993, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 676582, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.14781358422155, "pattern_frame_updates": 66118, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 693389503, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10487.151804349798, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1073, "avg_candidate_generations": 153.28571428571428, "candidate_moves_total": 68264, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.619757688723205, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 361, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 1066, "search_candidate_moves_total": 67903, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 2583, "avg_legality_checks": 369.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2583, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 201650, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 28807.14285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 463697652, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2299.5172427473344, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5248, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 749.7142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 48589592, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9258.6875, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 89270, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5202, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 48094500, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 88070, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 317752, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6495081, "stage_ordering_ns": 41641, "stage_eval_ns": 694066085, "stage_threat_ns": 445505302, "stage_proof_ns": 46352388, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 66239, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 387402500, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3555, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5757344, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 140, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3561554, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 33116, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 43745133, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 114, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 519055, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 66232, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8081270, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 170, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 867, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4989.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6132.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 258, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3887, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 80, 128, 83, 143, 158, 84, 111, 69, 81, 79, 66, 126, 52, 67, 38, 94, 24 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 3848, "avg_search_time_ms": 384.8, "search_nodes": 73045, "safety_nodes": 515, "corridor_nodes": 2204, "corridor_branch_probes": 2361, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 917, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2186, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2186, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 74, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 917, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 74, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 71, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 563, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 146880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 75764, "avg_nodes": 7576.4, "eval_calls": 69921, "avg_eval_calls": 6992.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 69921, "pattern_eval_ns": 2083764, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 29.80169047925516, "pattern_frame_queries": 69921, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2083764, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 29.80169047925516, "pattern_frame_updates": 146034, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1865909962, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12777.229699932892, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3106, "avg_candidate_generations": 310.6, "candidate_moves_total": 220916, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.12556342562782, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 595, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 3096, "search_candidate_moves_total": 220321, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 66531, "avg_legality_checks": 6653.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "root_legality_checks": 595, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 65936, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 928735, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 92873.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2049137154, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2206.374427581603, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11697, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1169.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64034430, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5474.431905616825, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 137080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11027, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57746419, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 168, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2005656, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 485, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4145275, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 5244, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 524.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 51893833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9895.849160945843, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6993, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 699.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 27539900, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3938.2096382096383, "stage_move_gen_ns": 157045607, "stage_ordering_ns": 112240, "stage_eval_ns": 1867993726, "stage_threat_ns": 1420654165, "stage_proof_ns": 379406023, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 150564, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 866382272, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 132604, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 412034624, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1418, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 85631545, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75277, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 98269277, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4520, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26264544, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 150554, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17703448, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 289, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2673, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5801.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6601.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1833, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 77, "safety_nodes": 756, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 833, "avg_nodes": 92.55555555555556, "eval_calls": 68, "avg_eval_calls": 7.555555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68, "line_shape_eval_ns": 55691, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 818.9852941176471, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 543, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.333333333333336, "candidate_moves_max": 79, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 543, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10399, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1155.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21580242, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2075.2228098855658, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4090, "stage_ordering_ns": 480, "stage_eval_ns": 55691, "stage_threat_ns": 17240906, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 145, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16935175, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 184111, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 103320, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18300, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 259, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12673, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 110, 109, 126, 142, 100, 156, 170, 172, 97, 157, 187, 140, 124, 143, 139, 141, 144, 125, 173, 93 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1818181818181817, "search_nodes": 217, "safety_nodes": 695, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 912, "avg_nodes": 82.9090909090909, "eval_calls": 206, "avg_eval_calls": 18.727272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 206, "line_shape_eval_ns": 119870, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 581.8932038834952, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 696, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.27272727272727, "candidate_moves_max": 78, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 696, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 696, "avg_legality_checks": 63.27272727272727, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 696, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13374, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1215.8181818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25901975, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1936.7410647525048, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.272727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 302642, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12105.68, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 59702, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 242940, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.5454545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 344842, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12315.785714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.727272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 194312, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4739.317073170731, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1706577, "stage_ordering_ns": 530, "stage_eval_ns": 119870, "stage_threat_ns": 20933590, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 423, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20192046, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 448663, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10760, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 206, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 247331, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 412, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45550, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 12629, "avg_search_time_ms": 1148.090909090909, "search_nodes": 365830, "safety_nodes": 498, "corridor_nodes": 554, "corridor_branch_probes": 627, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 12, "corridor_depth_exits": 203, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 542, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 542, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 57, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 45, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 203, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 57, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 424, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 128400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 366882, "avg_nodes": 33352.90909090909, "eval_calls": 358736, "avg_eval_calls": 32612.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 358736, "pattern_eval_ns": 7174832, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.00031220730565, "pattern_frame_queries": 358736, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7174832, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.00031220730565, "pattern_frame_updates": 731598, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8116717074, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11094.504186725497, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7074, "avg_candidate_generations": 643.0909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 560689, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.26053152389031, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 727, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 7063, "search_candidate_moves_total": 559962, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 10818, "avg_legality_checks": 983.4545454545455, "illegal_moves_skipped": 135, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10818, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 135, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2174605, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 197691.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4857006930, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2233.512260847372, "renju_forbidden_checks": 77543, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7049.363636363636, "renju_forbidden_ns": 765087959, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9866.628309454109, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 135, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1445098, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 77190, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 761098974, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 89, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1000654, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 129, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1543233, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 29594758, "stage_ordering_ns": 232121, "stage_eval_ns": 8123891906, "stage_threat_ns": 4378142708, "stage_proof_ns": 77567074, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 732807, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3781704238, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34432, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 42475865, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 510, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19873813, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 366398, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 462868266, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1198, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7110509, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 732796, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 83983830, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 399, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6258, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.6363636363636362, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6363636363636362, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3968.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4695.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 260, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5362, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 81, 129, 126, 130, 131, 141, 98, 140, 96, 66, 95, 99, 109, 110, 67, 53, 123 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5324, "avg_search_time_ms": 532.4, "search_nodes": 106682, "safety_nodes": 516, "corridor_nodes": 2142, "corridor_branch_probes": 2316, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 901, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 2126, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2126, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 76, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 60, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 901, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 76, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 73, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 572, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 144800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 5, "total_nodes": 109340, "avg_nodes": 10934.0, "eval_calls": 102853, "avg_eval_calls": 10285.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 102853, "pattern_eval_ns": 2071426, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.139675070245886, "pattern_frame_queries": 102853, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2071426, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.139675070245886, "pattern_frame_updates": 213308, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2861660840, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13415.628293359836, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3811, "avg_candidate_generations": 381.1, "candidate_moves_total": 265056, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.55024927840462, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 596, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 3801, "search_candidate_moves_total": 264460, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 98346, "avg_legality_checks": 9834.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "root_legality_checks": 596, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 97750, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1209670, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 120967.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2747620264, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2271.3800160374317, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14406, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1440.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 95396346, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6621.987088713036, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 366181, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13696, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 88707718, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 153, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1969515, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 519, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4352932, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 5144, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 514.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 50989223, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9912.368390357698, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6954, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 695.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 26918544, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3870.943917169974, "stage_move_gen_ns": 240937641, "stage_ordering_ns": 147460, "stage_eval_ns": 2863732266, "stage_threat_ns": 1839172318, "stage_proof_ns": 360342577, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 217722, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1241509767, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 127384, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 402470596, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1404, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 83374807, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108856, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 144263258, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4404, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25087483, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 217712, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25841214, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 289, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3319, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5510.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6310.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1843, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 77, "safety_nodes": 752, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 829, "avg_nodes": 92.11111111111111, "eval_calls": 68, "avg_eval_calls": 7.555555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68, "line_shape_eval_ns": 52240, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 768.2352941176471, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 539, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.888888888888886, "candidate_moves_max": 75, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 539, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10331, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1147.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20751933, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2008.7051592295034, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3730, "stage_ordering_ns": 440, "stage_eval_ns": 52240, "stage_threat_ns": 16586805, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 145, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16290732, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 181221, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 97202, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17650, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 261, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1044, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 81, 65, 80, 94, 78, 82, 77, 66, 79 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 25, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5714285714285716, "search_nodes": 248, "safety_nodes": 214, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 462, "avg_nodes": 66.0, "eval_calls": 241, "avg_eval_calls": 34.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 241, "line_shape_eval_ns": 178880, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 742.2406639004149, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 348, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.714285714285715, "candidate_moves_max": 62, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 348, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 348, "avg_legality_checks": 49.714285714285715, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 348, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8172, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1167.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16550104, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2025.220753793441, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 108950, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9904.545454545454, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17620, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 91330, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 151800, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11676.923076923076, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 84820, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4464.210526315789, "stage_move_gen_ns": 865375, "stage_ordering_ns": 330, "stage_eval_ns": 178880, "stage_threat_ns": 15132031, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 489, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14520365, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 227220, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 325735, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58711, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5138.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6281.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1013, "avg_search_time_ms": 144.71428571428572, "search_nodes": 30242, "safety_nodes": 287, "corridor_nodes": 38, "corridor_branch_probes": 42, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 31, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 31, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 26, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 26, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 157, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 80560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 30567, "avg_nodes": 4366.714285714285, "eval_calls": 29183, "avg_eval_calls": 4169.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 29183, "pattern_eval_ns": 591675, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.274646198129048, "pattern_frame_queries": 29183, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 591675, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.274646198129048, "pattern_frame_updates": 60446, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 562770232, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9310.297323230652, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1047, "avg_candidate_generations": 149.57142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 66672, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.67908309455587, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 361, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 1040, "search_candidate_moves_total": 66311, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 2688, "avg_legality_checks": 384.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2688, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 170655, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24379.285714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 371918151, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2179.356895490903, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3924, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 560.5714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 35245737, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8982.094036697248, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 88380, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3876, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34761076, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 82820, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 313461, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6588579, "stage_ordering_ns": 46750, "stage_eval_ns": 563361907, "stage_threat_ns": 387016129, "stage_proof_ns": 43522626, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 60567, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 336152175, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3555, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5416302, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 140, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3367366, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 30280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 37956807, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 114, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 491750, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 60560, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6999095, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 170, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 840, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5032.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6175.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 262, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4394, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 81, 65, 129, 145, 80, 79, 127, 93, 51, 108, 109, 63, 47, 78, 48, 123 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 4357, "avg_search_time_ms": 435.7, "search_nodes": 108213, "safety_nodes": 228, "corridor_nodes": 923, "corridor_branch_probes": 1036, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 313, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 910, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 910, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 62, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 313, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 62, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 443, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 122400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 109364, "avg_nodes": 10936.4, "eval_calls": 104535, "avg_eval_calls": 10453.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 104535, "pattern_eval_ns": 2111710, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.200985315922896, "pattern_frame_queries": 104535, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2111710, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.200985315922896, "pattern_frame_updates": 216370, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2305102669, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10653.52252622822, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3660, "avg_candidate_generations": 366.0, "candidate_moves_total": 264572, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.28743169398908, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 638, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 3650, "search_candidate_moves_total": 263934, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 101367, "avg_legality_checks": 10136.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 37, "root_legality_checks": 638, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 100729, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 867194, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 86719.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1934815990, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2231.122436271469, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10521, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1052.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 70471104, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6698.137439406901, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 49, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 232304, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10101, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 68726807, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 81, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 546371, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 290, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 965622, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1812, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 181.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 17000847, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9382.365894039734, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2444, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 244.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 8830371, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3613.0814238952535, "stage_move_gen_ns": 241451647, "stage_ordering_ns": 134770, "stage_eval_ns": 2307214379, "stage_threat_ns": 1559807969, "stage_proof_ns": 225474058, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 218324, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1208308137, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 63512, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 172594696, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 740, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 38569070, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 109157, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 142827359, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1944, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10653133, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 218314, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25424644, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 456, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3023, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5453.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6253.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1791, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 820, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 887, "avg_nodes": 98.55555555555556, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 46020, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 793.448275862069, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 580, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10442, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1160.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21204646, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2030.7073357594331, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.1111111111111112, "renju_forbidden_ns": 63742, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6374.2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 63742, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3740, "stage_ordering_ns": 450, "stage_eval_ns": 46020, "stage_threat_ns": 16742107, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16452155, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 189440, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 85452, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15060, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 263, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6908, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 115, 116, 129, 143, 95, 159, 175, 145, 128, 146, 144, 160, 99, 84, 96, 80, 130, 131, 161, 173, 117, 187 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 43, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5833333333333335, "search_nodes": 461, "safety_nodes": 551, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1012, "avg_nodes": 84.33333333333333, "eval_calls": 449, "avg_eval_calls": 37.416666666666664, "line_shape_eval_calls": 449, "line_shape_eval_ns": 450131, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1002.5189309576838, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 790, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.83333333333333, "candidate_moves_max": 78, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 790, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 790, "avg_legality_checks": 65.83333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 790, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14536, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1211.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29563490, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2033.8119152449092, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 256182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12199.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 33, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 146711, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4445.787878787879, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1946558, "stage_ordering_ns": 540, "stage_eval_ns": 450131, "stage_threat_ns": 26692247, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 910, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 25581162, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 388073, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 449, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 614302, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 898, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 108710, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6852, "avg_search_time_ms": 571.0, "search_nodes": 215742, "safety_nodes": 499, "corridor_nodes": 390, "corridor_branch_probes": 449, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 89, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 42, "corridor_plies_followed": 381, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 381, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 48, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 39, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 89, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 42, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 48, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 45, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 311, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 95760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 7, "total_nodes": 216631, "avg_nodes": 18052.583333333332, "eval_calls": 211224, "avg_eval_calls": 17602.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 211224, "pattern_eval_ns": 4295081, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.33424705525887, "pattern_frame_queries": 211224, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4295081, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.33424705525887, "pattern_frame_updates": 431416, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3943320268, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9140.41265970664, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4496, "avg_candidate_generations": 374.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 347087, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.19906583629893, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 807, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 4484, "search_candidate_moves_total": 346280, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 7598, "avg_legality_checks": 633.1666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7598, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1031249, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 85937.41666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2355344750, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2283.9728814282485, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7475, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 622.9166666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 72722831, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9728.806822742476, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7472, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72687051, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 35780, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 21032964, "stage_ordering_ns": 154372, "stage_eval_ns": 3947615349, "stage_threat_ns": 2781212687, "stage_proof_ns": 79142771, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 432286, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2408035962, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30691, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 34068977, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 382, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14019911, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 216137, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 282482063, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 858, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4842760, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 432274, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51782925, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 394, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3881, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5578.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6245.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1968, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 264, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6689, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 95, 159, 175, 115, 96, 144, 142, 100, 94, 97, 110, 99, 101, 158, 80, 64, 125, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6643, "avg_search_time_ms": 553.5833333333334, "search_nodes": 148506, "safety_nodes": 312, "corridor_nodes": 2357, "corridor_branch_probes": 2620, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1017, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 2337, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2337, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 89, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1017, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 89, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 85, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 695, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 257200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 151175, "avg_nodes": 12597.916666666666, "eval_calls": 143393, "avg_eval_calls": 11949.416666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 143393, "pattern_eval_ns": 2897199, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.204605524676936, "pattern_frame_queries": 143393, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2897199, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.204605524676936, "pattern_frame_updates": 296944, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3498192708, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11780.647893205452, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5091, "avg_candidate_generations": 424.25, "candidate_moves_total": 380829, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.8043606364172, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 795, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 5079, "search_candidate_moves_total": 380034, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 139128, "avg_legality_checks": 11594.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "root_legality_checks": 795, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 138333, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1391965, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 115997.08333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3129650740, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2248.3688454810285, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14572, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1214.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 107712271, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7391.728726324458, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 330062, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14123, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 105227858, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 76, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 914083, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 328, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1240268, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 5762, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 480.1666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 54667877, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9487.65654286706, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7937, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 661.4166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 28416279, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3580.229179790853, "stage_move_gen_ns": 339696323, "stage_ordering_ns": 163521, "stage_eval_ns": 3501089907, "stage_threat_ns": 2377374664, "stage_proof_ns": 400409276, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 301808, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1697683488, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 137396, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 415069908, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1464, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 84802356, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 150898, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 202097444, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4852, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26851452, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 301796, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35672372, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 535, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4355, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5761.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6427.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1765, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.272727272727273, "search_nodes": 197, "safety_nodes": 955, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1152, "avg_nodes": 104.72727272727273, "eval_calls": 186, "avg_eval_calls": 16.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 186, "line_shape_eval_ns": 143411, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 771.0268817204301, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 734, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.72727272727273, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12753, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.3636363636363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25619541, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2008.9030816278523, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4690, "stage_ordering_ns": 530, "stage_eval_ns": 143411, "stage_threat_ns": 21778144, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 383, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21203201, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 260102, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 186, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 268391, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46450, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 265, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4769, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 157, 172, 141, 125, 83, 140, 156, 110, 95, 170, 98, 155 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 275, "safety_nodes": 235, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 510, "avg_nodes": 72.85714285714286, "eval_calls": 268, "avg_eval_calls": 38.285714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 268, "line_shape_eval_ns": 194071, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 724.1455223880597, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 386, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.142857142857146, "candidate_moves_max": 66, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 386, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 386, "avg_legality_checks": 55.142857142857146, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 386, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8381, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1197.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17351344, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2070.319055005369, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 127871, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10655.916666666666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20680, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 107191, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 177081, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11805.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 100510, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4370.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1009436, "stage_ordering_ns": 270, "stage_eval_ns": 194071, "stage_threat_ns": 15925477, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 543, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15213285, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 282672, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 268, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 363360, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 536, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66160, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 4737, "avg_search_time_ms": 676.7142857142857, "search_nodes": 153736, "safety_nodes": 191, "corridor_nodes": 78, "corridor_branch_probes": 97, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 74, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 74, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 35, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 278, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 88000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 154005, "avg_nodes": 22000.714285714286, "eval_calls": 150030, "avg_eval_calls": 21432.85714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 150030, "pattern_eval_ns": 3007761, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.047730453909217, "pattern_frame_queries": 150030, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3007761, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.047730453909217, "pattern_frame_updates": 307434, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2645616774, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8605.478814965163, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3694, "avg_candidate_generations": 527.7142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 269709, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.01272333513806, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 396, "root_candidate_moves_max": 65, "search_candidate_generations": 3687, "search_candidate_moves_total": 269313, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 8794, "avg_legality_checks": 1256.2857142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8794, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 619711, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 88530.14285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1447538262, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2335.8279294703498, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7670, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1095.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 76664684, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9995.39556714472, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 71351, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7633, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 76273472, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 104970, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 214891, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 24280188, "stage_ordering_ns": 122451, "stage_eval_ns": 2648624535, "stage_threat_ns": 1991301438, "stage_proof_ns": 62775909, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 307663, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1740033480, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 5926, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8875836, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 198, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4441506, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 153828, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 203841606, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 222, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1063423, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 307656, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37487093, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 246, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3248, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4092.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5235.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 266, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7518, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 83, 139, 153, 157, 98, 140, 110, 158, 68, 113, 82, 143, 173, 124, 84, 70, 81, 85, 80 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7471, "avg_search_time_ms": 622.5833333333334, "search_nodes": 172434, "safety_nodes": 312, "corridor_nodes": 1844, "corridor_branch_probes": 2123, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 744, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 1824, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1824, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 89, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 744, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 89, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 85, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 695, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 259920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 174590, "avg_nodes": 14549.166666666666, "eval_calls": 167254, "avg_eval_calls": 13937.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 167254, "pattern_eval_ns": 3358213, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.07852129097062, "pattern_frame_queries": 167254, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3358213, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.07852129097062, "pattern_frame_updates": 344800, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4064737037, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11788.680501740138, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5158, "avg_candidate_generations": 429.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 370676, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.8642884839085, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 795, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 5146, "search_candidate_moves_total": 369881, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 161491, "avg_legality_checks": 13457.583333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 56, "root_legality_checks": 795, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 160696, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 56, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1467444, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 122287.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3358167437, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2288.4467393645004, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14409, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1200.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 118695893, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8237.621833576237, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 79, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 643474, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13929, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 115983272, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 863672, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 331, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1205475, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4417, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 368.0833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 42275808, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9571.158705003396, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6187, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 515.5833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 22239754, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3594.594149022143, "stage_move_gen_ns": 402347836, "stage_ordering_ns": 171290, "stage_eval_ns": 4068095250, "stage_threat_ns": 2617860826, "stage_proof_ns": 357263469, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 348638, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1988299569, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 113387, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 338480963, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1218, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 71323661, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 174313, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 228874647, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3826, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20223129, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 348626, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41982518, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 535, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4439, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5113.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5779.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 655, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.272727272727273, "search_nodes": 197, "safety_nodes": 955, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1152, "avg_nodes": 104.72727272727273, "eval_calls": 186, "avg_eval_calls": 16.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 186, "line_shape_eval_ns": 143950, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 773.9247311827957, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 734, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.72727272727273, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12753, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.3636363636363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25478227, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1997.8222379048068, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4720, "stage_ordering_ns": 490, "stage_eval_ns": 143950, "stage_threat_ns": 21705335, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 383, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21142333, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 255412, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11100, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 186, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 261450, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46140, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 267, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1254, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 109, 108, 95, 81, 65, 80, 94, 78, 82, 77, 96, 79 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 274, "safety_nodes": 234, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 508, "avg_nodes": 72.57142857142857, "eval_calls": 267, "avg_eval_calls": 38.142857142857146, "line_shape_eval_calls": 267, "line_shape_eval_ns": 196752, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 736.8988764044943, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 385, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.0, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 385, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 385, "avg_legality_checks": 55.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 385, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17003785, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2034.1888981935638, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.2857142857142856, "renju_forbidden_ns": 163250, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10203.125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 28810, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 134440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 171821, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11454.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 98651, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4289.173913043478, "stage_move_gen_ns": 978713, "stage_ordering_ns": 250, "stage_eval_ns": 196752, "stage_threat_ns": 16342070, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 541, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15664478, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 248031, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7120, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 363301, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66260, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1222, "avg_search_time_ms": 174.57142857142858, "search_nodes": 36146, "safety_nodes": 313, "corridor_nodes": 138, "corridor_branch_probes": 174, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 40, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 131, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 131, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 26, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 40, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 26, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 157, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 89040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 36597, "avg_nodes": 5228.142857142857, "eval_calls": 34923, "avg_eval_calls": 4989.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34923, "pattern_eval_ns": 698822, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.010365661598374, "pattern_frame_queries": 34923, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 698822, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.010365661598374, "pattern_frame_updates": 72254, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 685871339, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9492.503376975668, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1211, "avg_candidate_generations": 173.0, "candidate_moves_total": 82478, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.10734929810074, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 393, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 1204, "search_candidate_moves_total": 82085, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 2736, "avg_legality_checks": 390.85714285714283, "illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2736, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 202338, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 28905.428571428572, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 434791139, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2148.835804446026, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6174, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 882.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57379962, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9293.806608357629, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 125581, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6122, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 56865698, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 112442, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 276241, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6823840, "stage_ordering_ns": 45830, "stage_eval_ns": 686570161, "stage_threat_ns": 472740395, "stage_proof_ns": 42864847, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 72575, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 403461483, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 10275, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 13434332, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 180, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5596872, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 36284, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 45980917, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 314, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1476724, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 72568, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8386939, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 185, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 980, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5027.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6170.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 268, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22581, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 80, 81, 65, 129, 145, 95, 96, 128, 64, 48, 109, 108, 127, 114, 124, 82, 66, 63, 138, 152, 67, 68, 94, 79, 154, 139, 122, 47, 31, 98, 83, 143, 158, 130, 146, 131, 132, 93, 78, 106, 50, 92, 35, 20, 51, 19, 99 ], "move_count": 53, "black_stats": { "move_count": 27, "search_move_count": 25, "total_time_ms": 22487, "avg_search_time_ms": 899.48, "search_nodes": 576670, "safety_nodes": 1333, "corridor_nodes": 5113, "corridor_branch_probes": 5649, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2440, "corridor_neutral_exits": 37, "corridor_terminal_exits": 17, "corridor_plies_followed": 5072, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5072, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 24, "corridor_proof_completed": 24, "corridor_proof_checks": 189, "corridor_proof_active": 41, "corridor_proof_quiet": 148, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 37, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2440, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 189, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 186, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1429, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 380800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 583116, "avg_nodes": 23324.64, "eval_calls": 560894, "avg_eval_calls": 22435.76, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 560894, "pattern_eval_ns": 11343842, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.224573627102448, "pattern_frame_queries": 560894, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11343842, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.224573627102448, "pattern_frame_updates": 1153194, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 12840257210, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11134.516143857842, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15728, "avg_candidate_generations": 629.12, "candidate_moves_total": 1471219, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.54139114954222, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 25, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2174, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 15703, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1469045, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 549380, "avg_legality_checks": 21975.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 417, "root_legality_checks": 2174, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 547206, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 417, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5272854, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 210914.16, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10865527548, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2060.6539737303556, "renju_forbidden_checks": 76202, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3048.08, "renju_forbidden_ns": 398099314, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5224.263326421878, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 640, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3047816, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 75194, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 393887594, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 31, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 357130, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 337, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 806774, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10028, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 401.12, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 92886840, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9262.748304746709, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15514, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 620.56, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 51232918, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3302.3667655021272, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1171015589, "stage_ordering_ns": 536152, "stage_eval_ns": 12851601052, "stage_threat_ns": 7605523867, "stage_proof_ns": 747031596, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1163741, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5961803672, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 257401, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 705386545, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2965, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 142026106, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 581858, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 739858422, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10522, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 70997364, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1163716, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 127477864, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1130, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 13755, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 2.92, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 2.92, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 24 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 25, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6529.84, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6849.84, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1769, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 73, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0416666666666665, "search_nodes": 223, "safety_nodes": 3183, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 3406, "avg_nodes": 141.91666666666666, "eval_calls": 199, "avg_eval_calls": 8.291666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 199, "line_shape_eval_ns": 290751, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1461.0603015075376, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2109, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.875, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2109, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27281, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1136.7083333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 52322058, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1917.8936989113301, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12740, "stage_ordering_ns": 1240, "stage_eval_ns": 290751, "stage_threat_ns": 42806080, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 422, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 41867936, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 601973, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 24840, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 199, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 287451, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 398, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48720, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 24 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7165.291666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7498.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 269, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1507, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 67, 52, 83, 99, 85, 84, 68, 54, 114, 39, 98, 69 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 274, "safety_nodes": 234, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 508, "avg_nodes": 72.57142857142857, "eval_calls": 267, "avg_eval_calls": 38.142857142857146, "line_shape_eval_calls": 267, "line_shape_eval_ns": 196691, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 736.6704119850187, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 385, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.0, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 385, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 385, "avg_legality_checks": 55.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 385, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17232855, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2061.5928938868287, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.2857142857142856, "renju_forbidden_ns": 172870, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10804.375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 31850, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 141020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 179840, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11989.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 101910, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4430.869565217391, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1006934, "stage_ordering_ns": 300, "stage_eval_ns": 196691, "stage_threat_ns": 15958467, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 541, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15268744, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 257521, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6960, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 365342, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66860, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1475, "avg_search_time_ms": 210.71428571428572, "search_nodes": 42066, "safety_nodes": 313, "corridor_nodes": 141, "corridor_branch_probes": 181, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 43, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 134, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 134, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 26, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 43, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 26, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 157, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 79760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 42520, "avg_nodes": 6074.285714285715, "eval_calls": 40768, "avg_eval_calls": 5824.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40768, "pattern_eval_ns": 829451, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.345638736263737, "pattern_frame_queries": 40768, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 829451, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.345638736263737, "pattern_frame_updates": 84094, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 857419680, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10195.967369848027, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1286, "avg_candidate_generations": 183.71428571428572, "candidate_moves_total": 87334, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.9113530326594, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 393, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 1279, "search_candidate_moves_total": 86941, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 2791, "avg_legality_checks": 398.7142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2791, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 249630, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 35661.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 551180159, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2207.9884589192006, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7673, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1096.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 71373739, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9301.933924149616, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 138710, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7620, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 70806059, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 125950, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 303020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6955238, "stage_ordering_ns": 46221, "stage_eval_ns": 858249131, "stage_threat_ns": 553354771, "stage_proof_ns": 43651389, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 84421, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 473768839, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 10275, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 13624143, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 180, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5704331, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42207, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 54520898, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 320, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1546899, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 84414, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9893992, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 185, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1050, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4970.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6113.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 270, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23086, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 84, 99, 85, 141, 155, 83, 98, 126, 67, 52, 111, 142, 66, 114, 70, 56, 100, 55, 50, 34, 68, 69, 64, 65, 78, 41, 27, 53, 54, 36, 102, 38, 116, 132, 130, 115, 144, 158, 88 ], "move_count": 45, "black_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 23006, "avg_search_time_ms": 1095.5238095238096, "search_nodes": 553011, "safety_nodes": 754, "corridor_nodes": 19911, "corridor_branch_probes": 20407, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 12305, "corridor_neutral_exits": 90, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 19869, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 19869, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 19, "corridor_proof_completed": 19, "corridor_proof_checks": 175, "corridor_proof_active": 42, "corridor_proof_quiet": 133, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 90, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 12305, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 175, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 171, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1328, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 399040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 12, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 9, "total_nodes": 573676, "avg_nodes": 27317.904761904763, "eval_calls": 538996, "avg_eval_calls": 25666.47619047619, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 538996, "pattern_eval_ns": 10910133, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.241584353130637, "pattern_frame_queries": 538996, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 10910133, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.241584353130637, "pattern_frame_updates": 1105900, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 11648006466, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10532.603730897912, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13975, "avg_candidate_generations": 665.4761904761905, "candidate_moves_total": 1347032, "avg_candidate_moves": 96.38869409660107, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1761, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 13954, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1345271, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 519859, "avg_legality_checks": 24755.190476190477, "illegal_moves_skipped": 389, "root_legality_checks": 1761, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 518098, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 389, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5760490, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 274309.04761904763, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11769863915, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2043.2053375667695, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65581, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3122.904761904762, "renju_forbidden_ns": 303375367, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4625.964334182157, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 481, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3136501, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 62288, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 295509919, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 114, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 638602, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2698, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4090345, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 26534, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1263.5238095238096, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 176666141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6658.104356674456, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35081, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1670.5238095238096, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 75995350, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2166.2823180639093, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1067453620, "stage_ordering_ns": 497630, "stage_eval_ns": 11658916599, "stage_threat_ns": 8745218308, "stage_proof_ns": 1402155021, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1146009, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5827503477, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 715490, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1801793912, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 7888, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 355217873, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 572994, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 718827238, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 40088, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 275051878, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1145988, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 122041803, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1178, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 12059, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.047619047619047616, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23809523809523808, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.047619047619047616, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6377.523809523809, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6758.476190476191, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1832, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 63, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.15, "search_nodes": 182, "safety_nodes": 2346, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2528, "avg_nodes": 126.4, "eval_calls": 162, "avg_eval_calls": 8.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 162, "line_shape_eval_ns": 193822, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1196.432098765432, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1687, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.35, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1687, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22907, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1145.35, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 45282736, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1976.8077880123979, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10170, "stage_ordering_ns": 1100, "stage_eval_ns": 193822, "stage_threat_ns": 37846214, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 344, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 37177421, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 391941, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 162, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 235461, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 324, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41391, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6998.35, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7398.35, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 271, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6254, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 109, 108, 125, 141, 99, 155, 169, 139, 126, 123, 107, 138, 93, 140, 142, 137 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 30, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3333333333333335, "search_nodes": 232, "safety_nodes": 551, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 783, "avg_nodes": 87.0, "eval_calls": 223, "avg_eval_calls": 24.77777777777778, "line_shape_eval_calls": 223, "line_shape_eval_ns": 152590, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 684.2600896860987, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 564, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.666666666666664, "candidate_moves_max": 78, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 564, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 564, "avg_legality_checks": 62.666666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 564, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10946, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1216.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21461009, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1960.625708021195, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.7777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 269121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10764.84, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 39, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 156621, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4015.923076923077, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1324596, "stage_ordering_ns": 360, "stage_eval_ns": 152590, "stage_threat_ns": 18259048, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 455, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17531874, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 371792, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 223, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 300102, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 446, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55280, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5773.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6215, "avg_search_time_ms": 690.5555555555555, "search_nodes": 204020, "safety_nodes": 204, "corridor_nodes": 438, "corridor_branch_probes": 518, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 140, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 427, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 427, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 140, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 67, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 549, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 259920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 204662, "avg_nodes": 22740.222222222223, "eval_calls": 199751, "avg_eval_calls": 22194.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 199751, "pattern_eval_ns": 3994591, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.997852326146052, "pattern_frame_queries": 199751, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3994591, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.997852326146052, "pattern_frame_updates": 407990, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3530681855, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8653.844101571118, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4253, "avg_candidate_generations": 472.55555555555554, "candidate_moves_total": 325948, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.63954855396192, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 586, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 4244, "search_candidate_moves_total": 325362, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 8004, "avg_legality_checks": 889.3333333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8004, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 964777, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 107197.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2081303394, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2157.289605784549, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8621, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 957.8888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 84042120, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9748.534972740981, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8619, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 84018740, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23380, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20964069, "stage_ordering_ns": 146402, "stage_eval_ns": 3534676446, "stage_threat_ns": 2537295953, "stage_proof_ns": 101248195, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 408989, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2195914191, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30592, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 30748260, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 501, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13780152, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 204490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 258703454, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 990, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4674494, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 408980, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47255554, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 394, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3622, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4736.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5625.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1968, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 272, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4821, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 126, 141, 99, 155, 169, 109, 98, 140, 142, 94, 100, 97, 114, 95, 93, 156, 84, 70, 129, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 4790, "avg_search_time_ms": 399.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 154656, "safety_nodes": 312, "corridor_nodes": 2214, "corridor_branch_probes": 2477, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 898, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 2192, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2192, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 89, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 898, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 89, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 85, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 695, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 259920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 157182, "avg_nodes": 13098.5, "eval_calls": 149577, "avg_eval_calls": 12464.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 149577, "pattern_eval_ns": 2803073, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.740000133710396, "pattern_frame_queries": 149577, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2803073, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.740000133710396, "pattern_frame_updates": 309244, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2598600743, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8403.075703974855, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5057, "avg_candidate_generations": 421.4166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 379614, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.06703579197152, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 795, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 5045, "search_candidate_moves_total": 378819, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 145188, "avg_legality_checks": 12099.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 795, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 144393, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1444176, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 120348.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2131291296, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1475.7836274803071, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15382, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1281.8333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 73157241, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4756.0291899622935, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 51, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 201661, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15034, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71989994, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 59, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 400884, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 238, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 564702, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 5217, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 434.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 28131601, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5392.294613762699, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 593.8333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 14930289, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2095.1850968285153, "stage_move_gen_ns": 252495115, "stage_ordering_ns": 155242, "stage_eval_ns": 2601403816, "stage_threat_ns": 1669840346, "stage_proof_ns": 231849071, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 313818, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1243606101, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 135122, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 228363782, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1430, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 46597356, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 156903, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 155151486, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4562, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14907306, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 313806, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27811671, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 535, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4320, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5862.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6528.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1765, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 22, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.0, "search_nodes": 197, "safety_nodes": 955, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1152, "avg_nodes": 104.72727272727273, "eval_calls": 186, "avg_eval_calls": 16.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 186, "line_shape_eval_ns": 84110, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 452.2043010752688, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 734, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.72727272727273, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12753, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.3636363636363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15639927, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1226.3723829687133, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4410, "stage_ordering_ns": 480, "stage_eval_ns": 84110, "stage_threat_ns": 13919162, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 383, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 13538471, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 181050, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 186, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 168381, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31260, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6179.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 273, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 709, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 115, 116, 99, 83, 69, 84, 100, 82, 81, 86, 129, 85 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 14, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.0, "search_nodes": 271, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 502, "avg_nodes": 71.71428571428571, "eval_calls": 264, "avg_eval_calls": 37.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 264, "line_shape_eval_ns": 127651, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 483.5265151515151, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 380, "avg_candidate_moves": 54.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 64, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 380, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 380, "avg_legality_checks": 54.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 380, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9683955, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1157.9522898481407, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64490, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5374.166666666667, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10310, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 54180, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 106000, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7066.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 63690, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2769.1304347826085, "stage_move_gen_ns": 552075, "stage_ordering_ns": 280, "stage_eval_ns": 127651, "stage_threat_ns": 9280818, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 535, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 8821217, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 164630, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4120, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 251441, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43530, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5140.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6282.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 688, "avg_search_time_ms": 98.28571428571429, "search_nodes": 33739, "safety_nodes": 311, "corridor_nodes": 135, "corridor_branch_probes": 170, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 39, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 128, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 128, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 26, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 39, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 26, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 157, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 66720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 34185, "avg_nodes": 4883.571428571428, "eval_calls": 32575, "avg_eval_calls": 4653.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32575, "pattern_eval_ns": 592210, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.17989255564083, "pattern_frame_queries": 32575, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 592210, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.17989255564083, "pattern_frame_updates": 67440, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 384470073, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5700.920418149466, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1152, "avg_candidate_generations": 164.57142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 77460, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.23958333333333, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 390, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 1145, "search_candidate_moves_total": 77070, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 3151, "avg_legality_checks": 450.14285714285717, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3151, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 186413, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26630.428571428572, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 231878136, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1243.8946639987555, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4868, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 695.4285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 26587942, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5461.779375513558, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 62700, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4822, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26288130, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45780, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 191332, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4716943, "stage_ordering_ns": 35111, "stage_eval_ns": 385062283, "stage_threat_ns": 263129875, "stage_proof_ns": 24318815, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 67755, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 221474496, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 10062, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7484973, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 177, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3022543, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 33874, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 28138605, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 308, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 900255, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 67748, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5131546, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 184, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 925, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5079.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6222.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 274, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19124, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 84, 83, 69, 125, 139, 99, 98, 126, 70, 56, 115, 116, 127, 110, 130, 82, 68, 71, 146, 162, 67, 66, 100, 85, 160, 145, 132, 57, 43, 96, 81, 141, 156, 124, 138, 123, 122, 101, 86, 118, 54, 102, 39, 24, 53, 25, 95 ], "move_count": 53, "black_stats": { "move_count": 27, "search_move_count": 25, "total_time_ms": 19047, "avg_search_time_ms": 761.88, "search_nodes": 636737, "safety_nodes": 1333, "corridor_nodes": 5002, "corridor_branch_probes": 5532, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2395, "corridor_neutral_exits": 50, "corridor_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_plies_followed": 4961, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4961, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 23, "corridor_proof_completed": 23, "corridor_proof_checks": 173, "corridor_proof_active": 41, "corridor_proof_quiet": 132, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 50, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2395, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 173, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 170, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1293, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 352320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9360, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 643072, "avg_nodes": 25722.88, "eval_calls": 620125, "avg_eval_calls": 24805.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 620125, "pattern_eval_ns": 11827294, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.0724353960895, "pattern_frame_queries": 620125, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11827294, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.0724353960895, "pattern_frame_updates": 1273328, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 11031932896, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8663.857934483494, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16564, "avg_candidate_generations": 662.56, "candidate_moves_total": 1538377, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.87472832649118, "candidate_moves_max": 134, "root_candidate_generations": 25, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2174, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 16539, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1536203, "search_candidate_moves_max": 134, "legality_checks": 607948, "avg_legality_checks": 24317.92, "illegal_moves_skipped": 473, "root_legality_checks": 2174, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 605774, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 473, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5654291, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 226171.64, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8915214481, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1576.7166000122738, "renju_forbidden_checks": 83976, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3359.04, "renju_forbidden_ns": 337350066, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4017.219991426122, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 778, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2533551, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 82810, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 333982432, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 31, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 250981, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 357, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 583102, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9762, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 390.48, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 74550051, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7636.759987707437, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15109, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 604.36, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 42199596, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2793.0105235290225, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1011550028, "stage_ordering_ns": 529963, "stage_eval_ns": 11043760190, "stage_threat_ns": 6337054371, "stage_proof_ns": 506871974, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1283621, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4996192670, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 251072, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 517121240, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2859, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 99230292, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 641798, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 655453433, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10268, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 54922171, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1283596, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 113364857, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1114, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 14492, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 2.88, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 2.88, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 23 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.04, "pooled_budget_moves": 25, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.12, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.04, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6872.44, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7192.44, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1855, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 57, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.375, "search_nodes": 223, "safety_nodes": 3183, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 3406, "avg_nodes": 141.91666666666666, "eval_calls": 199, "avg_eval_calls": 8.291666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 199, "line_shape_eval_ns": 226381, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1137.5929648241206, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2109, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.875, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2109, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27281, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1136.7083333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 41146860, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1508.2606942560756, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12790, "stage_ordering_ns": 1120, "stage_eval_ns": 226381, "stage_threat_ns": 34152236, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 422, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 33389454, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 507822, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 199, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 219490, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 398, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35470, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 24 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7166.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7499.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1999, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 275, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7135, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 157, 172, 143, 129, 81, 145, 161, 159, 128, 174, 144, 160, 141, 140, 96, 80, 158, 173, 175, 131, 117, 187 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 43, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5833333333333335, "search_nodes": 461, "safety_nodes": 551, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1012, "avg_nodes": 84.33333333333333, "eval_calls": 449, "avg_eval_calls": 37.416666666666664, "line_shape_eval_calls": 449, "line_shape_eval_ns": 454742, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1012.7884187082406, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 790, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.83333333333333, "candidate_moves_max": 78, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 790, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 790, "avg_legality_checks": 65.83333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 790, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14536, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1211.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29815591, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2051.1551320858557, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 262610, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12505.238095238095, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 33, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 151580, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4593.333333333333, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1954428, "stage_ordering_ns": 570, "stage_eval_ns": 454742, "stage_threat_ns": 26875576, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 910, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 25758232, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 402440, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 449, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 606263, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 898, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 108641, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7080, "avg_search_time_ms": 590.0, "search_nodes": 223797, "safety_nodes": 502, "corridor_nodes": 430, "corridor_branch_probes": 491, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 90, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 44, "corridor_plies_followed": 421, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 421, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 48, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 39, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 90, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 44, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 48, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 45, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 311, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 88720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 7, "total_nodes": 224729, "avg_nodes": 18727.416666666668, "eval_calls": 218598, "avg_eval_calls": 18216.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 218598, "pattern_eval_ns": 4434621, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.28664946614333, "pattern_frame_queries": 218598, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4434621, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.28664946614333, "pattern_frame_updates": 447526, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3997863591, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8933.2543606405, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5177, "avg_candidate_generations": 431.4166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 398057, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.88951129998068, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 810, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 5165, "search_candidate_moves_total": 397247, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 10037, "avg_legality_checks": 836.4166666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10037, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1000882, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 83406.83333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2326543997, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2324.4937934741556, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6711, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 559.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 67149187, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10005.83921919237, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6710, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 67137266, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11921, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 27946838, "stage_ordering_ns": 190471, "stage_eval_ns": 4002298212, "stage_threat_ns": 2952575663, "stage_proof_ns": 79239943, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 448476, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2552001921, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34587, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 38938265, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 412, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16079347, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 224232, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 300748696, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 938, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5325095, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 448464, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55561686, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 420, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4505, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5597.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6264.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 276, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7336, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 129, 81, 145, 161, 157, 96, 144, 114, 156, 66, 111, 82, 141, 171, 130, 80, 64, 83, 79, 84 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7290, "avg_search_time_ms": 607.5, "search_nodes": 169598, "safety_nodes": 312, "corridor_nodes": 1745, "corridor_branch_probes": 2030, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 697, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 1725, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1725, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 89, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 697, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 89, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 85, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 695, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 262720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 171655, "avg_nodes": 14304.583333333334, "eval_calls": 164518, "avg_eval_calls": 13709.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 164518, "pattern_eval_ns": 3324393, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.206864902320717, "pattern_frame_queries": 164518, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3324393, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.206864902320717, "pattern_frame_updates": 339128, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3944544749, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11631.433408624473, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5058, "avg_candidate_generations": 421.5, "candidate_moves_total": 362409, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.65065243179122, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 795, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 5046, "search_candidate_moves_total": 361614, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 159080, "avg_legality_checks": 13256.666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 39, "root_legality_checks": 795, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 158285, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 39, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1420373, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 118364.41666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3240960183, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2281.766960509669, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13265, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1105.4166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 106266454, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8011.040633245382, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 347520, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12917, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 104016574, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 71, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 870405, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 229, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1031955, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4119, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 343.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 39689615, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9635.740470988105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5755, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 479.5833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 20805726, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3615.2434404865335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 395130975, "stage_ordering_ns": 176773, "stage_eval_ns": 3947869142, "stage_threat_ns": 2572450021, "stage_proof_ns": 349977401, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 342768, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1961916529, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 108174, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 323496092, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1166, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 68187549, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 171378, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 226746207, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3628, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19113399, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 342756, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41177794, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 535, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4348, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5094.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5761.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 571, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1818181818181817, "search_nodes": 197, "safety_nodes": 955, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1152, "avg_nodes": 104.72727272727273, "eval_calls": 186, "avg_eval_calls": 16.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 186, "line_shape_eval_ns": 144040, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 774.4086021505376, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 734, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.72727272727273, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12753, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.3636363636363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24627165, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1931.0879792989886, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4600, "stage_ordering_ns": 450, "stage_eval_ns": 144040, "stage_threat_ns": 21211614, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 383, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20638420, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 260012, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10821, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 186, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 266321, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46861, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 277, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1032, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 67, 52, 81, 95, 79, 80, 66, 50, 110, 35, 96, 65 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 15, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.142857142857143, "search_nodes": 274, "safety_nodes": 234, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 508, "avg_nodes": 72.57142857142857, "eval_calls": 267, "avg_eval_calls": 38.142857142857146, "line_shape_eval_calls": 267, "line_shape_eval_ns": 111320, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 416.92883895131087, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 385, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.0, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 385, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 385, "avg_legality_checks": 55.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 385, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9463132, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1132.0890058619452, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.2857142857142856, "renju_forbidden_ns": 83360, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5210.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 66930, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 112841, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7522.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 68991, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2999.608695652174, "stage_move_gen_ns": 553503, "stage_ordering_ns": 270, "stage_eval_ns": 111320, "stage_threat_ns": 9218969, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 541, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 8771906, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 158262, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 244821, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43980, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5140.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6282.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1012, "avg_search_time_ms": 144.57142857142858, "search_nodes": 41537, "safety_nodes": 313, "corridor_nodes": 140, "corridor_branch_probes": 176, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 42, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 133, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 133, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 26, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 42, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 26, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 157, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 82160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 41990, "avg_nodes": 5998.571428571428, "eval_calls": 40239, "avg_eval_calls": 5748.428571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40239, "pattern_eval_ns": 759182, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.866820746042396, "pattern_frame_queries": 40239, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 759182, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.866820746042396, "pattern_frame_updates": 83036, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 593906336, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7152.395780143552, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1286, "avg_candidate_generations": 183.71428571428572, "candidate_moves_total": 87198, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.80559875583204, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 393, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 1279, "search_candidate_moves_total": 86805, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 2827, "avg_legality_checks": 403.85714285714283, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2827, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 241426, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 34489.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 364188260, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1508.4881495779246, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7802, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1114.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_ns": 52315221, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6705.360292232761, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 108950, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7747, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 51966869, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 69881, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 169521, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4707392, "stage_ordering_ns": 41250, "stage_eval_ns": 594665518, "stage_threat_ns": 376882297, "stage_proof_ns": 25316559, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 83361, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 320572354, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 10275, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8717918, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 180, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3630123, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 41677, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 39456871, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 318, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1019686, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 83354, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7115468, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 185, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1051, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5043.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6185.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 278, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22471, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 80, 95, 79, 143, 159, 81, 96, 128, 64, 48, 67, 52, 113, 142, 68, 110, 94, 49, 54, 40, 66, 65, 70, 69, 86, 33, 17, 51, 50, 38, 78, 36, 108, 122, 92, 106, 124, 109, 140, 156, 76 ], "move_count": 47, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 22393, "avg_search_time_ms": 1017.8636363636364, "search_nodes": 579365, "safety_nodes": 921, "corridor_nodes": 14487, "corridor_branch_probes": 14923, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 8695, "corridor_neutral_exits": 80, "corridor_terminal_exits": 17, "corridor_plies_followed": 14445, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 14445, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 20, "corridor_proof_completed": 20, "corridor_proof_checks": 170, "corridor_proof_active": 42, "corridor_proof_quiet": 128, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 80, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 8695, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 170, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 166, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1290, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 356640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 594773, "avg_nodes": 27035.136363636364, "eval_calls": 564705, "avg_eval_calls": 25668.409090909092, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 564705, "pattern_eval_ns": 11371728, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.137466464791352, "pattern_frame_queries": 564705, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11371728, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.137466464791352, "pattern_frame_updates": 1158602, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 11875084295, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10249.494041094353, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14618, "avg_candidate_generations": 664.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 1427921, "avg_candidate_moves": 97.68237789027226, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1886, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 14596, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1426035, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 545171, "avg_legality_checks": 24780.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 456, "root_legality_checks": 1886, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 543285, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 455, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5746734, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 261215.18181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11355770936, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1976.039074716178, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65278, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2967.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 293072709, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4489.609194521891, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 680, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1439842, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 62877, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 288266273, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 128, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 731984, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1593, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2634610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 20018, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 909.9090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 136904597, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6839.074682785493, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26830, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1219.5454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 61494762, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2292.01498322773, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1070116252, "stage_ordering_ns": 497242, "stage_eval_ns": 11886456023, "stage_threat_ns": 8185999062, "stage_proof_ns": 1106459630, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1187854, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5783987070, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 547762, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1364279448, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 6051, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 271841697, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 593916, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 720787063, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 29230, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 194031115, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1187832, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 122914366, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1218, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 12643, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 2.8636363636363638, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8636363636363638, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.045454545454545456, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.045454545454545456, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6630.409090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6994.045454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1902, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 59, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.8095238095238093, "search_nodes": 192, "safety_nodes": 2464, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2656, "avg_nodes": 126.47619047619048, "eval_calls": 171, "avg_eval_calls": 8.142857142857142, "line_shape_eval_calls": 171, "line_shape_eval_ns": 200760, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1174.0350877192982, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1810, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.19047619047619, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1810, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23978, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1141.8095238095239, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 43122625, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1798.424597547752, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.19047619047619047, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4510, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1127.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4510, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11550, "stage_ordering_ns": 1150, "stage_eval_ns": 200760, "stage_threat_ns": 34616094, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 363, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 33977880, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 54, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 379533, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 171, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 221961, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 342, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36720, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 21, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 21, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7046.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7427.809523809524, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1999, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 279, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7337, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 126, 70, 56, 69, 110, 94, 125, 127, 170, 114, 156, 184, 158, 174, 155, 140, 157, 159, 154 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5, "search_nodes": 189, "safety_nodes": 900, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1089, "avg_nodes": 108.9, "eval_calls": 179, "avg_eval_calls": 17.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 179, "line_shape_eval_ns": 104510, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 583.8547486033519, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 825, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.5, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 825, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 825, "avg_legality_checks": 82.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 825, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12806, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1280.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26344528, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2057.2019365922224, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 275781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11990.478260869566, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 159191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4548.314285714286, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2053881, "stage_ordering_ns": 470, "stage_eval_ns": 104510, "stage_threat_ns": 20552984, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 368, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19900582, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 364351, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10200, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 179, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 243481, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 358, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44570, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7291, "avg_search_time_ms": 729.1, "search_nodes": 216424, "safety_nodes": 1073, "corridor_nodes": 1725, "corridor_branch_probes": 1965, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 13, "corridor_depth_exits": 714, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1705, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1705, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 35, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 714, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 416, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 93200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 219222, "avg_nodes": 21922.2, "eval_calls": 212554, "avg_eval_calls": 21255.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 212554, "pattern_eval_ns": 4308263, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.269028105799, "pattern_frame_queries": 212554, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4308263, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.269028105799, "pattern_frame_updates": 432792, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4249822296, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9819.549104419675, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3852, "avg_candidate_generations": 385.2, "candidate_moves_total": 358675, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.11396677050882, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 860, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 3842, "search_candidate_moves_total": 357815, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 7693, "avg_legality_checks": 769.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7693, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1216123, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 121612.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2818781843, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2317.8427206787474, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11591, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1159.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 108562001, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9366.059960314036, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11510, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 107606595, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 76, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 949716, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5690, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20073879, "stage_ordering_ns": 133440, "stage_eval_ns": 4254130559, "stage_threat_ns": 2915147453, "stage_proof_ns": 83259329, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 436322, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2422926435, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 104113, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 131612242, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 996, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 51878988, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 218156, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 291783887, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3520, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18164597, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 436312, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50660292, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 263, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3470, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5295.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6095.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1960, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 280, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21040, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 84, 114, 140, 113, 111, 130, 82, 116, 115, 144, 158, 159, 129, 146, 162, 101, 131, 102, 88, 99, 100, 85, 127, 69, 117, 71, 57, 70, 72, 86, 56, 54, 118, 38 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 20971, "avg_search_time_ms": 1165.0555555555557, "search_nodes": 550983, "safety_nodes": 264, "corridor_nodes": 2042, "corridor_branch_probes": 2311, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 718, "corridor_neutral_exits": 26, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2007, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2007, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 180, "corridor_proof_active": 35, "corridor_proof_quiet": 145, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 718, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 180, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 176, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1500, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 369600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 553289, "avg_nodes": 30738.277777777777, "eval_calls": 536552, "avg_eval_calls": 29808.444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 536552, "pattern_eval_ns": 10794920, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.11905649405836, "pattern_frame_queries": 536552, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 10794920, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.11905649405836, "pattern_frame_updates": 1101862, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 12010119114, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10899.839647796185, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14397, "avg_candidate_generations": 799.8333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 1220848, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.79877752309508, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1365, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 14379, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1219483, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 521608, "avg_legality_checks": 28978.222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 198, "root_legality_checks": 1365, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 520243, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 198, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4186196, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 232566.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9358620101, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2235.59052203958, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34167, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1898.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 218342182, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6390.440542043492, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 212, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1196155, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33480, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 213788648, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 136, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1546871, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 339, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1810508, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3295, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 183.05555555555554, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 32124185, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9749.373292867982, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4964, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 275.77777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 17917726, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3609.533843674456, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1222195678, "stage_ordering_ns": 498400, "stage_eval_ns": 12020914034, "stage_threat_ns": 7126352864, "stage_proof_ns": 546504125, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1106254, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5901120704, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 133976, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 341976777, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1820, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 77086851, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 553118, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 726707164, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4374, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28244491, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1106236, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 128303728, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1186, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 12418, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4797.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5242.277777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 52, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0588235294117645, "search_nodes": 100, "safety_nodes": 1884, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1984, "avg_nodes": 116.70588235294117, "eval_calls": 83, "avg_eval_calls": 4.882352941176471, "line_shape_eval_calls": 83, "line_shape_eval_ns": 84360, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1016.3855421686746, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1299, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.41176470588235, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1299, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19472, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1145.4117647058824, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 38247643, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1964.2380341002465, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8070, "stage_ordering_ns": 980, "stage_eval_ns": 84360, "stage_threat_ns": 30265890, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 183, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 29748876, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 371313, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 83, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 124471, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 166, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21230, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6821.588235294118, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7292.176470588235, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 281, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3119, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 144, 160, 97, 95, 65, 142, 158, 94, 78, 108, 66, 109, 111, 81, 123, 53, 107, 67 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 20, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.0, "search_nodes": 273, "safety_nodes": 823, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1096, "avg_nodes": 109.6, "eval_calls": 263, "avg_eval_calls": 26.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 263, "line_shape_eval_ns": 126441, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 480.7642585551331, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 713, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.3, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 713, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 713, "avg_legality_checks": 71.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 713, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12793, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1279.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13948402, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1090.3151723598844, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 202931, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5484.621621621622, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 40011, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 162920, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 341562, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7425.260869565217, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 71, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 207451, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2921.845070422535, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1018248, "stage_ordering_ns": 460, "stage_eval_ns": 126441, "stage_threat_ns": 12225722, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 536, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 11478199, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 462613, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5281, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 263, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 244950, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39960, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5998.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6798.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 3091, "avg_search_time_ms": 309.1, "search_nodes": 140989, "safety_nodes": 246, "corridor_nodes": 1233, "corridor_branch_probes": 1378, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 561, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1217, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1217, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 85, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 561, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 85, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 83, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 686, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 136880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 5840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 142468, "avg_nodes": 14246.8, "eval_calls": 137149, "avg_eval_calls": 13714.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 137149, "pattern_eval_ns": 2487625, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.13811985504816, "pattern_frame_queries": 137149, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2487625, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.13811985504816, "pattern_frame_updates": 281922, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1840964945, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6530.050670043487, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3822, "avg_candidate_generations": 382.2, "candidate_moves_total": 332543, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.00758765044479, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 741, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 3812, "search_candidate_moves_total": 331802, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 7101, "avg_legality_checks": 710.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 56, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7101, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 56, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 875345, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 87534.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1120842802, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1280.458335856148, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40192, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4019.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 195337327, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4860.104672571656, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 61, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 338532, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 39759, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 192818517, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 153, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 907122, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 219, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1273156, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11316819, "stage_ordering_ns": 115451, "stage_eval_ns": 1843452570, "stage_threat_ns": 1128433526, "stage_proof_ns": 78090352, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 284536, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 922444003, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 69539, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 50805016, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 910, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 22635301, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 142263, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 124893978, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2604, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8666833, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 284526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21623696, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 542, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3113, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5918.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6718.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 282, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7307, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 97, 95, 125, 65, 50, 94, 142, 78, 62, 82, 83, 79, 81, 77, 76, 111, 127, 157, 98, 63, 47, 68, 100, 99, 114, 156, 86 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 7270, "avg_search_time_ms": 484.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 274627, "safety_nodes": 818, "corridor_nodes": 2938, "corridor_branch_probes": 3312, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 1290, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 2910, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2910, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 41, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1290, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 451, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 163840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 20400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 278383, "avg_nodes": 18558.866666666665, "eval_calls": 268615, "avg_eval_calls": 17907.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 268615, "pattern_eval_ns": 4867558, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.120946335833814, "pattern_frame_queries": 268615, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4867558, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.120946335833814, "pattern_frame_updates": 549168, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4117344200, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7497.42191824724, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5984, "avg_candidate_generations": 398.93333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 452610, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.63669786096257, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1057, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 5969, "search_candidate_moves_total": 451553, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 263876, "avg_legality_checks": 17591.733333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 658, "root_legality_checks": 1057, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 262819, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 655, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2503914, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 166927.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3322993786, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1327.1197756791967, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26998, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1799.8666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 130202531, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4822.673198014668, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 669, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2961649, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25324, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 123856344, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 271, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1402926, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 734, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1981612, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 7422, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 494.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 46356220, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6245.7855025599565, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10172, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 678.1333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 25162150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2473.667911915061, "stage_move_gen_ns": 379043556, "stage_ordering_ns": 189522, "stage_eval_ns": 4122211758, "stage_threat_ns": 2455088099, "stage_proof_ns": 247554345, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 555141, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1820263773, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 166644, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 330515701, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1631, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 63937530, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 277563, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 240280774, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5958, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21908041, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 555126, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42119810, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 436, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5279, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6011.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6544.466666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1305, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 22, "avg_search_time_ms": 1.5714285714285714, "search_nodes": 208, "safety_nodes": 1393, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1601, "avg_nodes": 114.35714285714286, "eval_calls": 194, "avg_eval_calls": 13.857142857142858, "line_shape_eval_calls": 194, "line_shape_eval_ns": 99921, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 515.0567010309278, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 994, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.0, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 994, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15915, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1136.7857142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18563680, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1166.426641533145, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.8571428571428571, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57721, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4810.083333333333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57721, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6460, "stage_ordering_ns": 630, "stage_eval_ns": 99921, "stage_threat_ns": 16167794, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 402, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15799042, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 155811, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 194, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 182301, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 388, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30640, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6570.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7141.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1999, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 283, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 753, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 113, 83, 81, 110, 124, 69, 97, 54, 68, 39, 99, 24 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 18, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.25, "search_nodes": 247, "safety_nodes": 416, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 663, "avg_nodes": 82.875, "eval_calls": 239, "avg_eval_calls": 29.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 239, "line_shape_eval_ns": 100650, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 421.1297071129707, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 519, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.875, "candidate_moves_max": 79, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 519, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 519, "avg_legality_checks": 64.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 519, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9925, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1240.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11783486, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1187.2529974811084, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 69900, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7766.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 42670, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3047.8571428571427, "stage_move_gen_ns": 856532, "stage_ordering_ns": 330, "stage_eval_ns": 100650, "stage_threat_ns": 10194940, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 9800668, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 116820, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 235452, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42000, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5496.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6496.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 730, "avg_search_time_ms": 91.25, "search_nodes": 37614, "safety_nodes": 516, "corridor_nodes": 290, "corridor_branch_probes": 328, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 92, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 283, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 283, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 53, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 92, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 53, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 414, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 97440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 5600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 38420, "avg_nodes": 4802.5, "eval_calls": 36017, "avg_eval_calls": 4502.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36017, "pattern_eval_ns": 656681, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.23252908348835, "pattern_frame_queries": 36017, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 656681, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.23252908348835, "pattern_frame_updates": 75184, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 351469062, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 4674.785353266652, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1583, "avg_candidate_generations": 197.875, "candidate_moves_total": 122805, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.57738471257107, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 531, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 1575, "search_candidate_moves_total": 122274, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 3462, "avg_legality_checks": 432.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3462, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 185781, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23222.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 238545384, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1284.01388731894, "renju_forbidden_checks": 271, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 33.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1808836, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6674.671586715867, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 266, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 1779976, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 28860, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5551657, "stage_ordering_ns": 52250, "stage_eval_ns": 352125743, "stage_threat_ns": 307530557, "stage_proof_ns": 51701094, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 75864, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 250914409, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 20973, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 16617718, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 371, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7880984, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37928, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 32251234, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 672, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1764220, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 75856, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5982976, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 218, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1302, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5414.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6414.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 284, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20568, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 81, 85, 86, 69, 142, 94, 114, 68, 100, 128, 140, 154, 72, 58, 111, 113, 141, 54, 40, 39, 24, 99 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 20519, "avg_search_time_ms": 1578.3846153846155, "search_nodes": 474557, "safety_nodes": 360, "corridor_nodes": 10096, "corridor_branch_probes": 10750, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 5368, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 10072, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 10072, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 119, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 95, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5368, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 119, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 117, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 965, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 186800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 485013, "avg_nodes": 37308.692307692305, "eval_calls": 464916, "avg_eval_calls": 35762.769230769234, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 464916, "pattern_eval_ns": 9248707, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.893286098994228, "pattern_frame_queries": 464916, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 9248707, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.893286098994228, "pattern_frame_updates": 949038, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 11279381569, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11885.068426132568, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9616, "avg_candidate_generations": 739.6923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 821186, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.39787853577371, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 976, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 9603, "search_candidate_moves_total": 820210, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 460640, "avg_legality_checks": 35433.846153846156, "illegal_moves_skipped": 370, "root_legality_checks": 976, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 459664, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 370, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4862350, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 374026.92307692306, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10252282586, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2108.5036219112158, "renju_forbidden_checks": 72431, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5571.615384615385, "renju_forbidden_ns": 580191143, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8010.260012977868, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 405, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3539505, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 68151, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 554611147, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 532, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6119216, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3343, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 15921275, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 29158, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2242.923076923077, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 263206368, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9026.90061046711, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3104.6153846153848, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 137657117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3410.731342913776, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1000953283, "stage_ordering_ns": 324471, "stage_eval_ns": 11288630276, "stage_threat_ns": 7224551504, "stage_proof_ns": 941593760, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 969433, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4926637148, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 475112, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1478780387, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 5010, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 266088015, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 484710, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 602235004, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 20382, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 112571637, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 969420, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 104327328, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 673, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8362, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3320.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3747.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 868, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.923076923076923, "search_nodes": 280, "safety_nodes": 1057, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1337, "avg_nodes": 102.84615384615384, "eval_calls": 267, "avg_eval_calls": 20.53846153846154, "line_shape_eval_calls": 267, "line_shape_eval_ns": 208531, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 781.0149812734082, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1004, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.23076923076923, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1004, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15210, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1170.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27475701, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1806.4234714003944, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6480, "stage_ordering_ns": 620, "stage_eval_ns": 208531, "stage_threat_ns": 23970395, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 547, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 23387044, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 174400, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11840, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 348671, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60280, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6459.846153846154, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7075.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1999, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 285, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6445, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 128, 64, 48, 65, 113, 83, 142, 100, 141, 79, 143, 158, 144, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 29, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.625, "search_nodes": 264, "safety_nodes": 457, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 721, "avg_nodes": 90.125, "eval_calls": 256, "avg_eval_calls": 32.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 256, "line_shape_eval_ns": 174272, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 680.75, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 565, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.625, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 565, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 565, "avg_legality_checks": 70.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 565, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10041, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1255.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20696963, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2061.245194701723, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 18, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 212191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11788.388888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 117740, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4528.461538461538, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1409826, "stage_ordering_ns": 420, "stage_eval_ns": 174272, "stage_threat_ns": 17878202, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 520, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17169878, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 292891, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8200, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 256, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 352422, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 512, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63011, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6406, "avg_search_time_ms": 800.75, "search_nodes": 202583, "safety_nodes": 251, "corridor_nodes": 2108, "corridor_branch_probes": 2335, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 966, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 2088, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2088, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 53, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 966, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 53, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 414, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 104320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 204942, "avg_nodes": 25617.75, "eval_calls": 198758, "avg_eval_calls": 24844.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 198758, "pattern_eval_ns": 3975132, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.99985912516729, "pattern_frame_queries": 198758, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3975132, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.99985912516729, "pattern_frame_updates": 405122, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3650166253, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9010.042044124979, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3811, "avg_candidate_generations": 476.375, "candidate_moves_total": 330476, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.71634741537655, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 595, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 3803, "search_candidate_moves_total": 329881, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 6841, "avg_legality_checks": 855.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6841, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1151115, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 143889.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2374197993, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2062.520246022335, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17675, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2209.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 147060353, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8320.246280056577, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17493, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 144897788, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 182, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2162565, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16101681, "stage_ordering_ns": 132250, "stage_eval_ns": 3654141385, "stage_threat_ns": 2628279420, "stage_proof_ns": 75870256, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 409412, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2155769787, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 119385, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 156813869, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1112, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 65683492, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 204702, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 249056418, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4282, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21289247, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 409404, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45350099, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 395, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3257, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4498.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5498.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 286, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12811, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 80, 82, 144, 97, 67, 68, 54, 124, 110, 127, 142, 126, 125, 95, 129, 159, 99, 84, 115, 111, 143, 141, 81, 156 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 12758, "avg_search_time_ms": 981.3846153846154, "search_nodes": 326117, "safety_nodes": 773, "corridor_nodes": 810, "corridor_branch_probes": 941, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 288, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 791, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 791, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 73, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 288, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 90, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 708, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 246960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 327700, "avg_nodes": 25207.69230769231, "eval_calls": 319123, "avg_eval_calls": 24547.923076923078, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 319123, "pattern_eval_ns": 6491509, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.34171463667614, "pattern_frame_queries": 319123, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6491509, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.34171463667614, "pattern_frame_updates": 652160, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7354468030, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11277.091557286556, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6970, "avg_candidate_generations": 536.1538461538462, "candidate_moves_total": 542013, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.76370157819225, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 924, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 6957, "search_candidate_moves_total": 541089, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 310826, "avg_legality_checks": 23909.69230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 113, "root_legality_checks": 924, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 309902, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 112, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2336171, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 179705.46153846153, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5491534662, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2350.6561214911067, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25508, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1962.1538461538462, "renju_forbidden_ns": 197082023, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7726.28285243845, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 121, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1039584, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25217, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 194567072, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 716602, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 110, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 758765, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 112.38461538461539, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 14345574, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9819.010266940451, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2011, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 154.69230769230768, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 7376370, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3668.01093983093, "stage_move_gen_ns": 751563878, "stage_ordering_ns": 222583, "stage_eval_ns": 7360959539, "stage_threat_ns": 4346840377, "stage_proof_ns": 258907722, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 653939, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3662640547, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 54730, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 168401481, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 769, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 39396964, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 326963, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 428225676, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1766, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9530904, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 653926, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 78041769, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 410, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6245, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.6923076923076925, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6923076923076925, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3963.846153846154, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4579.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 40, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3333333333333335, "search_nodes": 314, "safety_nodes": 732, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1046, "avg_nodes": 87.16666666666667, "eval_calls": 302, "avg_eval_calls": 25.166666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 302, "line_shape_eval_ns": 362871, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1201.5596026490066, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 859, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.58333333333333, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 859, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14022, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1168.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27838073, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1985.3140065611183, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.3333333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 45031, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11257.75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 45031, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5060, "stage_ordering_ns": 520, "stage_eval_ns": 362871, "stage_threat_ns": 24815902, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 616, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24173629, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 151601, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 302, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 415602, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 604, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 75070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 287, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13404, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 128, 64, 48, 65, 114, 100, 127, 125, 110, 94, 174, 158, 129, 130, 144, 159, 141, 145, 99, 84, 113, 85, 155 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1666666666666665, "search_nodes": 193, "safety_nodes": 1114, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1307, "avg_nodes": 108.91666666666667, "eval_calls": 181, "avg_eval_calls": 15.083333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 181, "line_shape_eval_ns": 119101, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 658.0165745856353, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 966, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.5, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 966, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 966, "avg_legality_checks": 80.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 966, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15350, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1279.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28793817, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1875.818697068404, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.9166666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 307940, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8798.285714285714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 64740, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 243200, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 477373, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11366.02380952381, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 270672, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4296.380952380952, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2255509, "stage_ordering_ns": 550, "stage_eval_ns": 119101, "stage_threat_ns": 22740944, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 374, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21836000, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 614933, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11350, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 181, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 245531, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 362, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44480, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 13353, "avg_search_time_ms": 1112.75, "search_nodes": 382560, "safety_nodes": 624, "corridor_nodes": 2503, "corridor_branch_probes": 2864, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1106, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2481, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2481, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 86, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1106, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 86, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 83, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 687, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 91440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 385687, "avg_nodes": 32140.583333333332, "eval_calls": 375605, "avg_eval_calls": 31300.416666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 375605, "pattern_eval_ns": 7527141, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.040044727839085, "pattern_frame_queries": 375605, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7527141, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.040044727839085, "pattern_frame_updates": 765052, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8287326643, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10832.370404887512, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6933, "avg_candidate_generations": 577.75, "candidate_moves_total": 656174, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.6450310111063, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 995, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 6921, "search_candidate_moves_total": 655179, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 14944, "avg_legality_checks": 1245.3333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 88, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 14944, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 88, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2525904, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 210492.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5366047588, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2124.406781888781, "renju_forbidden_checks": 85568, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7130.666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 708873055, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8284.324221671654, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 88, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 806862, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 85225, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 705353693, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 138, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1546437, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 117, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1166063, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 35861793, "stage_ordering_ns": 253062, "stage_eval_ns": 8294853784, "stage_threat_ns": 4843866973, "stage_proof_ns": 130331381, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 770198, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4070442258, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 145145, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 179685931, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1423, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 68610928, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 385093, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 482092253, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5134, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25879169, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 770186, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 85767362, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 589, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5829, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5224.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5891.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1960, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 288, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8041, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 80, 110, 144, 111, 109, 68, 124, 113, 114, 97, 125, 98, 83, 95, 94, 99 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8015, "avg_search_time_ms": 890.5555555555555, "search_nodes": 223538, "safety_nodes": 347, "corridor_nodes": 587, "corridor_branch_probes": 684, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 197, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 574, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 574, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 82, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 197, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 82, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 80, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 682, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 196080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 224472, "avg_nodes": 24941.333333333332, "eval_calls": 217951, "avg_eval_calls": 24216.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 217951, "pattern_eval_ns": 4278175, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.62906800152328, "pattern_frame_queries": 217951, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4278175, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.62906800152328, "pattern_frame_updates": 447026, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4700866923, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10515.86915078765, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5571, "avg_candidate_generations": 619.0, "candidate_moves_total": 411814, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.92101956560761, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 578, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 5562, "search_candidate_moves_total": 411236, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 213030, "avg_legality_checks": 23670.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 56, "root_legality_checks": 578, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 212452, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 56, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1754669, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 194963.22222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3519215783, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2005.6294281143623, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23640, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2626.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 122209114, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5169.59027072758, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 141, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 366181, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23362, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 120676499, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 55, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 606052, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 82, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 560382, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1076, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 119.55555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 10115042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9400.596654275092, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1495, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 166.11111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 5283279, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3533.9658862876254, "stage_move_gen_ns": 454474508, "stage_ordering_ns": 185591, "stage_eval_ns": 4705145098, "stage_threat_ns": 2638870768, "stage_proof_ns": 188653794, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 448347, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2184018239, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 41334, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 136462658, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 629, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 42461981, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 224169, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 264717335, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1312, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6422011, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 448338, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47250525, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 374, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4860, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3202.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4091.222222222222, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 18, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.25, "search_nodes": 147, "safety_nodes": 562, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 709, "avg_nodes": 88.625, "eval_calls": 139, "avg_eval_calls": 17.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 139, "line_shape_eval_ns": 84030, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 604.5323741007194, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 519, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.875, "candidate_moves_max": 73, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 519, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9385, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1173.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14565241, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1551.970271710176, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3100, "stage_ordering_ns": 460, "stage_eval_ns": 84030, "stage_threat_ns": 12412156, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 286, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 12123656, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 106230, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6370, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 139, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 154490, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 278, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27780, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5496.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6496.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1999, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 289, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2594, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 111, 81, 79, 114, 130, 66, 50, 52, 94, 67, 97, 95, 53, 123, 37, 109 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 24, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.4, "search_nodes": 273, "safety_nodes": 823, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1096, "avg_nodes": 109.6, "eval_calls": 263, "avg_eval_calls": 26.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 263, "line_shape_eval_ns": 131291, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 499.20532319391634, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 713, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.3, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 713, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 713, "avg_legality_checks": 71.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 713, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12793, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1279.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17463835, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1365.1086531697022, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 227501, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6148.675675675676, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 44690, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 182811, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 386333, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8398.54347826087, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 71, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 232701, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3277.478873239437, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1246047, "stage_ordering_ns": 1080, "stage_eval_ns": 131291, "stage_threat_ns": 14546194, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 536, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 13732068, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 534554, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6650, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 263, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 238210, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41362, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5997.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6797.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2561, "avg_search_time_ms": 256.1, "search_nodes": 107052, "safety_nodes": 246, "corridor_nodes": 1217, "corridor_branch_probes": 1369, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 551, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1201, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1201, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 85, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 551, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 85, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 83, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 686, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 138480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 5600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 108515, "avg_nodes": 10851.5, "eval_calls": 103312, "avg_eval_calls": 10331.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 103312, "pattern_eval_ns": 1949604, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.871031438748645, "pattern_frame_queries": 103312, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1949604, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.871031438748645, "pattern_frame_updates": 214048, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1374931226, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6423.471492375542, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3722, "avg_candidate_generations": 372.2, "candidate_moves_total": 322854, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.74207415368082, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 741, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 3712, "search_candidate_moves_total": 322113, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 8866, "avg_legality_checks": 886.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 30, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8866, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 30, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 570935, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 57093.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 882686595, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1546.036930648848, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18494, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1849.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 100559552, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5437.4149453876935, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 31, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 199690, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18110, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 97898382, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 134, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 942425, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 219, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1519055, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15896574, "stage_ordering_ns": 123630, "stage_eval_ns": 1376880830, "stage_threat_ns": 1031842521, "stage_proof_ns": 108473603, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 216630, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 833337923, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 68913, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 65491957, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 904, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 30066170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108310, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104409300, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2572, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10102874, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 216620, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18500467, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 542, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3040, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5916.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6716.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1989, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 290, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10245, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 114, 81, 83, 79, 78, 65, 113, 111, 99, 84, 115, 116, 131, 67, 147 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10206, "avg_search_time_ms": 1020.6, "search_nodes": 262570, "safety_nodes": 288, "corridor_nodes": 1013, "corridor_branch_probes": 1171, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 456, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 999, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 999, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 456, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 415, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 154240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 263871, "avg_nodes": 26387.1, "eval_calls": 256649, "avg_eval_calls": 25664.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 256649, "pattern_eval_ns": 5147219, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.055480442160306, "pattern_frame_queries": 256649, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5147219, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.055480442160306, "pattern_frame_updates": 525084, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5963411762, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11357.062416679997, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5903, "avg_candidate_generations": 590.3, "candidate_moves_total": 450823, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.37184482466543, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 702, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 5893, "search_candidate_moves_total": 450121, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 254625, "avg_legality_checks": 25462.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 283, "root_legality_checks": 702, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 253923, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 283, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1908163, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 190816.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4408661557, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2310.4218858661447, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28268, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2826.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 278489661, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9851.763867270412, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 350, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3356621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27476, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 270769468, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 175, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2081819, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 267, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2281753, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2763, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 276.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 28529342, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10325.494752081071, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3846, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 384.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 15533237, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4038.803172126885, "stage_move_gen_ns": 600621898, "stage_ordering_ns": 204251, "stage_eval_ns": 5968558981, "stage_threat_ns": 3420470524, "stage_proof_ns": 187344100, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 527200, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2821955233, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 57265, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 189813316, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 609, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 39033617, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 263595, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 336834029, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2106, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12132009, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 527190, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59735937, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 479, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5137, "depth_sum": 27, "avg_depth": 2.7, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 27, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3640.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4440.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 230, "safety_nodes": 620, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 850, "avg_nodes": 94.44444444444444, "eval_calls": 221, "avg_eval_calls": 24.555555555555557, "line_shape_eval_calls": 221, "line_shape_eval_ns": 176591, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 799.0542986425339, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 635, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.55555555555556, "candidate_moves_max": 84, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 635, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10659, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1184.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20329678, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1907.2781686837413, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3860, "stage_ordering_ns": 410, "stage_eval_ns": 176591, "stage_threat_ns": 18082672, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 451, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17612470, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 110800, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8780, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 221, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 305521, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 442, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53881, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5775.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1999, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 291, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5983, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 140, 154, 97, 99, 69, 142, 156, 100, 86, 116, 68, 115, 113, 83, 131, 51, 117, 67 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.8, "search_nodes": 273, "safety_nodes": 823, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1096, "avg_nodes": 109.6, "eval_calls": 263, "avg_eval_calls": 26.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 263, "line_shape_eval_ns": 226341, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 860.6121673003802, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 713, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.3, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 713, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 713, "avg_legality_checks": 71.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 713, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12793, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1279.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26557528, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2075.9421558664894, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 434610, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11746.216216216217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 83910, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 350700, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 558612, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12143.739130434782, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 71, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 321910, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4533.943661971831, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1861437, "stage_ordering_ns": 460, "stage_eval_ns": 226341, "stage_threat_ns": 22667352, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 536, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21482495, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 770354, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10060, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 263, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 349973, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64530, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5934, "avg_search_time_ms": 593.4, "search_nodes": 157345, "safety_nodes": 246, "corridor_nodes": 1229, "corridor_branch_probes": 1375, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 552, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1213, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1213, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 85, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 552, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 85, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 83, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 686, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 132480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 158820, "avg_nodes": 15882.0, "eval_calls": 153314, "avg_eval_calls": 15331.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 153314, "pattern_eval_ns": 3110397, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.287755847476422, "pattern_frame_queries": 153314, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3110397, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.287755847476422, "pattern_frame_updates": 314634, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3669739724, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11663.519276365554, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4013, "avg_candidate_generations": 401.3, "candidate_moves_total": 349990, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.21405432344879, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 741, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 4003, "search_candidate_moves_total": 349249, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 7827, "avg_legality_checks": 782.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 64, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7827, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 64, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1007384, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 100738.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2306055239, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2289.152139601185, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48341, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4834.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 463360419, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9585.24687118595, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 71, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 751093, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 47934, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 458725093, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 117, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1320897, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 219, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2563336, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20901012, "stage_ordering_ns": 142470, "stage_eval_ns": 3672850121, "stage_threat_ns": 2080418258, "stage_proof_ns": 140047946, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 317240, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1733725632, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 70251, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 89098196, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 910, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 39490127, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 158615, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 206933575, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2596, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13744735, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 317230, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36916120, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 542, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3267, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5850.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6650.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 292, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10550, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 96, 99, 129, 69, 54, 100, 86, 142, 156, 85, 70, 38, 68, 40, 110, 82, 111, 141, 109, 113, 108 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10500, "avg_search_time_ms": 875.0, "search_nodes": 252714, "safety_nodes": 447, "corridor_nodes": 1640, "corridor_branch_probes": 1705, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 687, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1623, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1623, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 77, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 60, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 687, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 77, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 74, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 569, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 124800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 254801, "avg_nodes": 21233.416666666668, "eval_calls": 246512, "avg_eval_calls": 20542.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 246512, "pattern_eval_ns": 5013626, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.338263451677808, "pattern_frame_queries": 246512, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5013626, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.338263451677808, "pattern_frame_updates": 505360, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6071134809, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12013.48505817635, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6180, "avg_candidate_generations": 515.0, "candidate_moves_total": 485671, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.58754045307444, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 850, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 6168, "search_candidate_moves_total": 484821, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 238428, "avg_legality_checks": 19869.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 61, "root_legality_checks": 850, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 237578, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 61, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2128397, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 177366.41666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4971793703, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2335.933429242759, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20070, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1672.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 127746563, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6365.050473343298, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 79, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 428121, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19717, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 126278808, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 378260, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 244, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 661374, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3829, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 319.0833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 36307081, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9482.131365891877, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5013, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 417.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 18410112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3672.4739676840213, "stage_move_gen_ns": 569763184, "stage_ordering_ns": 210970, "stage_eval_ns": 6076148435, "stage_threat_ns": 3508128350, "stage_proof_ns": 310330805, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 508772, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2783893622, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 97123, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 315442081, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1194, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 64261078, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 254380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 330393440, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3400, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19248184, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 508760, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59151023, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 525, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5344, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4981.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5648.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 127, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4545454545454546, "search_nodes": 334, "safety_nodes": 673, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1007, "avg_nodes": 91.54545454545455, "eval_calls": 323, "avg_eval_calls": 29.363636363636363, "line_shape_eval_calls": 323, "line_shape_eval_ns": 274473, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 849.7616099071207, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 786, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.45454545454545, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12671, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1151.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25642174, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2023.689842948465, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4730, "stage_ordering_ns": 520, "stage_eval_ns": 274473, "stage_threat_ns": 23463242, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 657, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22808100, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 130020, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12010, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 323, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 444841, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 646, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 80281, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 293, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6465, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 126, 70, 56, 69, 111, 81, 142, 94, 143, 83, 141, 156, 140, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 32, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 264, "safety_nodes": 453, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 717, "avg_nodes": 89.625, "eval_calls": 256, "avg_eval_calls": 32.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 256, "line_shape_eval_ns": 178422, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 696.9609375, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 563, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.375, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 563, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 563, "avg_legality_checks": 70.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 563, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10031, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1253.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21149430, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2108.406938490679, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 127961, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12796.1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25980, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 101981, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 18, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 217160, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12064.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 119540, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4597.692307692308, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1490868, "stage_ordering_ns": 350, "stage_eval_ns": 178422, "stage_threat_ns": 18274040, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 520, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17550377, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 300541, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 256, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 358562, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 512, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64560, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6427, "avg_search_time_ms": 803.375, "search_nodes": 183533, "safety_nodes": 579, "corridor_nodes": 2120, "corridor_branch_probes": 2347, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 978, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 2100, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2100, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 53, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 978, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 53, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 414, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 102800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 186232, "avg_nodes": 23279.0, "eval_calls": 180058, "avg_eval_calls": 22507.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 180058, "pattern_eval_ns": 3796557, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.08518921680792, "pattern_frame_queries": 180058, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3796557, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.08518921680792, "pattern_frame_updates": 367022, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3711431220, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10112.285421582357, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3461, "avg_candidate_generations": 432.625, "candidate_moves_total": 298480, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.24097081768275, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 591, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 3453, "search_candidate_moves_total": 297889, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 6374, "avg_legality_checks": 796.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6374, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1009303, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 126162.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2357578528, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2335.848132820372, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25918, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3239.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 255072498, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9841.519330195231, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 243020, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25694, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 252369247, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 184, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2222290, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 237941, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17397246, "stage_ordering_ns": 115120, "stage_eval_ns": 3715227777, "stage_threat_ns": 2594026332, "stage_proof_ns": 79188443, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 371336, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2116038106, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 119385, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 162493290, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1112, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 68209904, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185664, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 247693905, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4306, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22373829, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 371328, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45427202, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 241, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3066, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4534.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5534.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1969, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 294, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13049, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 84, 82, 140, 97, 67, 66, 50, 127, 142, 130, 114, 128, 129, 99, 125, 155, 95, 80, 109, 113, 141, 143, 83, 158 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 12996, "avg_search_time_ms": 999.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 332633, "safety_nodes": 773, "corridor_nodes": 910, "corridor_branch_probes": 1057, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 324, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 890, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 890, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 72, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 324, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 90, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 708, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 248560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 334316, "avg_nodes": 25716.615384615383, "eval_calls": 325497, "avg_eval_calls": 25038.23076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 325497, "pattern_eval_ns": 6593119, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.255544597953282, "pattern_frame_queries": 325497, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6593119, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.255544597953282, "pattern_frame_updates": 665192, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7476730443, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11239.958452597144, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7112, "avg_candidate_generations": 547.0769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 548727, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.1550899887514, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 916, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 7099, "search_candidate_moves_total": 547811, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 316819, "avg_legality_checks": 24370.69230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 120, "root_legality_checks": 916, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 315903, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 119, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2375952, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 182765.53846153847, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5570964193, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2344.7292676788084, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27743, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2134.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 214320416, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7725.206935082723, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 124, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1085065, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27352, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 211140630, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 83, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 960797, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 184, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1133924, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1716, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 132.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 16997842, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9905.502331002332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2352, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 180.92307692307693, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 8804650, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3743.473639455782, "stage_move_gen_ns": 761014208, "stage_ordering_ns": 241572, "stage_eval_ns": 7483323562, "stage_threat_ns": 4453994261, "stage_proof_ns": 272468844, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 667169, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3729311105, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 61359, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 190003344, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 813, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 43669339, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 333578, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 445350075, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1964, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10617420, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 667156, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 78712317, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 405, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6384, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.6923076923076925, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6923076923076925, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3854.6923076923076, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4470.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 40, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3333333333333335, "search_nodes": 314, "safety_nodes": 724, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1038, "avg_nodes": 86.5, "eval_calls": 302, "avg_eval_calls": 25.166666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 302, "line_shape_eval_ns": 364641, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1207.4205298013244, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 851, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.91666666666667, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 851, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13998, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1166.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27785741, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1984.9793541934562, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.3333333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46600, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11650.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 46600, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5370, "stage_ordering_ns": 660, "stage_eval_ns": 364641, "stage_threat_ns": 24753827, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 616, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24109304, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 160541, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12730, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 302, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 410521, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 604, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 73461, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 295, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5974, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 97, 82, 142, 157, 113, 114, 66, 96, 68, 146, 130, 124, 138, 141, 128, 126, 129, 131, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4545454545454546, "search_nodes": 271, "safety_nodes": 857, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1128, "avg_nodes": 102.54545454545455, "eval_calls": 260, "avg_eval_calls": 23.636363636363637, "line_shape_eval_calls": 260, "line_shape_eval_ns": 205873, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 791.8192307692308, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 808, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.45454545454545, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 808, "avg_legality_checks": 73.45454545454545, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 808, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13870, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1260.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28025704, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2020.5987022350396, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.909090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 358260, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11195.625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 69130, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 289130, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.3636363636363638, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 294351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11321.192307692309, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.6363636363636362, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 155570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3889.25, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2049739, "stage_ordering_ns": 430, "stage_eval_ns": 205873, "stage_threat_ns": 23170415, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 531, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22331791, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 417832, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10730, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 357091, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 520, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63701, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5923, "avg_search_time_ms": 592.3, "search_nodes": 173370, "safety_nodes": 501, "corridor_nodes": 324, "corridor_branch_probes": 352, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 88, "corridor_neutral_exits": 30, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 312, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 312, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 71, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 59, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 88, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 71, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 71, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 555, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 133360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 174195, "avg_nodes": 17419.5, "eval_calls": 169009, "avg_eval_calls": 16900.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 169009, "pattern_eval_ns": 3436247, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.331739729836872, "pattern_frame_queries": 169009, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3436247, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.331739729836872, "pattern_frame_updates": 346682, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3523129163, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10162.423093786236, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4342, "avg_candidate_generations": 434.2, "candidate_moves_total": 381078, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.7655458314141, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 736, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4332, "search_candidate_moves_total": 380342, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 10781, "avg_legality_checks": 1078.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 250, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10781, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 250, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 861209, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 86120.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1996192462, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2317.8954957507412, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48188, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4818.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 466237487, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9675.385718436126, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 250, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2629510, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 47757, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 461438765, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 49, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 591352, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 132, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1577860, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 30545034, "stage_ordering_ns": 147290, "stage_eval_ns": 3526565410, "stage_threat_ns": 2225709553, "stage_proof_ns": 122957501, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 347458, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1918598238, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24785, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 35678398, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 488, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18963312, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 173724, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 226654526, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 766, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3832435, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 347448, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40945956, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 337, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3839, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5636.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6436.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1972, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 296, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5753, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 157, 128, 80, 129, 126, 114, 156, 144, 160, 159, 99, 174 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5722, "avg_search_time_ms": 715.25, "search_nodes": 135949, "safety_nodes": 69, "corridor_nodes": 722, "corridor_branch_probes": 840, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 299, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 710, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 710, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 67, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 55, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 299, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 67, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 547, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 203200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 136740, "avg_nodes": 17092.5, "eval_calls": 132543, "avg_eval_calls": 16567.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 132543, "pattern_eval_ns": 2681359, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.230106456018046, "pattern_frame_queries": 132543, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2681359, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.230106456018046, "pattern_frame_updates": 271854, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3234972357, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11899.66804608356, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3392, "avg_candidate_generations": 424.0, "candidate_moves_total": 225112, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.36556603773585, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 474, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 3384, "search_candidate_moves_total": 224638, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 129608, "avg_legality_checks": 16201.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "root_legality_checks": 474, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 129134, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 59, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1023372, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 127921.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2443099176, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2387.303127308545, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13699, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1712.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 130172900, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9502.365136141325, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 71, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 600890, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13397, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 127802062, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 64, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 768153, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 167, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1001795, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1587, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 198.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 15657567, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9866.141776937618, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2210, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 276.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 8244075, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3730.3506787330316, "stage_move_gen_ns": 327604443, "stage_ordering_ns": 109250, "stage_eval_ns": 3237653716, "stage_threat_ns": 1949443953, "stage_proof_ns": 198158844, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 273416, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1584685924, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44582, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 138613347, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 575, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 31424440, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 136704, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 185003710, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1554, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7881917, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 273408, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33259055, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 404, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2795, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3468.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4468.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 619, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 22, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.142857142857143, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 585, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 652, "avg_nodes": 93.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 60, "avg_eval_calls": 8.571428571428571, "line_shape_eval_calls": 60, "line_shape_eval_ns": 40380, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 673.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 413, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.0, "candidate_moves_max": 70, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 413, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8168, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1166.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16452033, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2014.2058031341821, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 45721, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11430.25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 45721, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2550, "stage_ordering_ns": 350, "stage_eval_ns": 40380, "stage_threat_ns": 13246968, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 127, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 12954376, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 187902, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7221, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 60, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88520, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16170, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5138.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6281.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 297, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6856, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 143, 98, 173, 158, 141, 96, 99, 97, 94, 127, 142, 79, 63, 144, 139, 93, 140 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 39, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5454545454545454, "search_nodes": 332, "safety_nodes": 770, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1102, "avg_nodes": 100.18181818181819, "eval_calls": 321, "avg_eval_calls": 29.181818181818183, "line_shape_eval_calls": 321, "line_shape_eval_ns": 290550, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 905.1401869158879, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 748, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.0, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 748, "avg_legality_checks": 68.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 748, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13744, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27519143, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2002.265934225844, "renju_forbidden_checks": 91, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8.272727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 922277, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10134.912087912087, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 175433, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 746844, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 747283, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11496.661538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 94, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.545454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 413272, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4396.510638297872, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2001149, "stage_ordering_ns": 540, "stage_eval_ns": 290550, "stage_threat_ns": 24325964, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 653, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22873988, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 939824, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 321, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 432952, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 642, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 79200, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6806, "avg_search_time_ms": 618.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 174184, "safety_nodes": 525, "corridor_nodes": 351, "corridor_branch_probes": 415, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 155, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 7, "corridor_plies_followed": 343, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 343, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 40, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 155, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 40, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 281, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 84480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 175060, "avg_nodes": 15914.545454545454, "eval_calls": 170366, "avg_eval_calls": 15487.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 170366, "pattern_eval_ns": 3447812, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.237676531702334, "pattern_frame_queries": 170366, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3447812, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.237676531702334, "pattern_frame_updates": 348306, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4424036306, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12701.579375606507, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3798, "avg_candidate_generations": 345.27272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 289568, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.2422327540811, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 756, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 3787, "search_candidate_moves_total": 288812, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 9025, "avg_legality_checks": 820.4545454545455, "illegal_moves_skipped": 77, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9025, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 77, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1197768, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 108888.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2751137582, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2296.886861228552, "renju_forbidden_checks": 51947, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4722.454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 486223044, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9359.983136658517, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 77, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 712774, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 51573, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 482396844, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 91, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 892069, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 206, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2221357, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23771888, "stage_ordering_ns": 142980, "stage_eval_ns": 4427484118, "stage_threat_ns": 2265117059, "stage_proof_ns": 66959755, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 349083, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1959073198, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 20005, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 28487160, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 331, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13364686, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 174536, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 231863359, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 766, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4291487, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 349072, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41401855, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 327, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3247, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5326.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6054.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1934, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 298, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4723, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 109, 126, 84, 141, 96, 142, 94, 140, 154, 139, 138, 143 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 4693, "avg_search_time_ms": 586.625, "search_nodes": 112845, "safety_nodes": 73, "corridor_nodes": 700, "corridor_branch_probes": 823, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 287, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 688, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 688, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 67, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 55, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 287, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 67, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 547, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 190400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 113618, "avg_nodes": 14202.25, "eval_calls": 109621, "avg_eval_calls": 13702.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 109621, "pattern_eval_ns": 2218436, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.23732678957499, "pattern_frame_queries": 109621, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2218436, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.23732678957499, "pattern_frame_updates": 225646, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2593118708, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11491.977291864248, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3210, "avg_candidate_generations": 401.25, "candidate_moves_total": 213506, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.51277258566978, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 478, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 3202, "search_candidate_moves_total": 213028, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 106331, "avg_legality_checks": 13291.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 117, "root_legality_checks": 478, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 105853, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 116, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 864679, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 108084.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2019986042, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2336.1109058968705, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12947, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1618.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 115896498, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8951.610257202441, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 128, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1081734, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12556, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 112801304, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 78, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 906775, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 185, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1106685, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1607, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 200.875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 16100249, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10018.823273179838, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2254, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 281.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 8542027, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3789.7191659272403, "stage_move_gen_ns": 264689053, "stage_ordering_ns": 103040, "stage_eval_ns": 2595337144, "stage_threat_ns": 1625430787, "stage_proof_ns": 196200088, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 227164, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1299960306, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43537, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 137439195, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 563, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 31191590, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 113578, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 152775712, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1510, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7905330, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 227156, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27350244, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 404, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2644, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4143.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5143.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1701, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 22, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.142857142857143, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 585, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 652, "avg_nodes": 93.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 60, "avg_eval_calls": 8.571428571428571, "line_shape_eval_calls": 60, "line_shape_eval_ns": 40500, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 675.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 413, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.0, "candidate_moves_max": 70, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 413, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8168, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1166.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16480066, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2017.6378550440745, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43040, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10760.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 43040, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2630, "stage_ordering_ns": 350, "stage_eval_ns": 40500, "stage_threat_ns": 13248409, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 127, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 12960668, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 187821, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 60, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 84220, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15700, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5138.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6281.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 299, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6429, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 125, 128, 123, 124, 95, 66, 110, 140, 65, 139, 80 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 30, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.75, "search_nodes": 307, "safety_nodes": 330, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 637, "avg_nodes": 79.625, "eval_calls": 299, "avg_eval_calls": 37.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 299, "line_shape_eval_ns": 235930, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 789.0635451505017, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 505, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.125, "candidate_moves_max": 76, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 505, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 505, "avg_legality_checks": 63.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 505, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9831, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1228.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20136199, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2048.2350727291223, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 474633, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11037.976744186046, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 85910, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 388723, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 312420, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11571.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 177180, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4429.5, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1361976, "stage_ordering_ns": 460, "stage_eval_ns": 235930, "stage_threat_ns": 18416186, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 606, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17513680, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 424812, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 299, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 402282, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 598, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 75412, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6389, "avg_search_time_ms": 798.625, "search_nodes": 164780, "safety_nodes": 225, "corridor_nodes": 179, "corridor_branch_probes": 201, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 71, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 174, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 174, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 71, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 35, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 278, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 84640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7360, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 165184, "avg_nodes": 20648.0, "eval_calls": 160724, "avg_eval_calls": 20090.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 160724, "pattern_eval_ns": 3261976, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.29551280455937, "pattern_frame_queries": 160724, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3261976, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.29551280455937, "pattern_frame_updates": 329516, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4168616274, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12650.724923827675, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4042, "avg_candidate_generations": 505.25, "candidate_moves_total": 302354, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.80306778822366, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 518, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 4034, "search_candidate_moves_total": 301836, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 7033, "avg_legality_checks": 879.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 80, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7033, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 80, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1077965, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 134745.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2492119288, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2311.8740293052188, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58529, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7316.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 592875045, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10129.594645389465, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 81, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 965403, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 58272, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 589712085, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 488662, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 134, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1708895, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19067459, "stage_ordering_ns": 140621, "stage_eval_ns": 4171878250, "stage_threat_ns": 2123550187, "stage_proof_ns": 63472496, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 329946, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1844416542, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 11439, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 18813594, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 246, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9746495, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 164969, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 219505928, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 422, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2031728, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 329938, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38782395, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 335, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3428, "depth_sum": 21, "avg_depth": 2.625, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 21, "avg_effective_depth": 2.625, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4113.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5113.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1925, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 300, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7222, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 128, 67, 96, 80, 95, 94, 110, 68, 108, 98, 124, 138, 140, 92, 125, 155, 111, 109, 139, 83, 153 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7177, "avg_search_time_ms": 598.0833333333334, "search_nodes": 172959, "safety_nodes": 80, "corridor_nodes": 2872, "corridor_branch_probes": 3094, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1338, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2851, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2851, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 116, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 95, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1338, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 116, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 112, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 956, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 246480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 175911, "avg_nodes": 14659.25, "eval_calls": 168149, "avg_eval_calls": 14012.416666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 168149, "pattern_eval_ns": 3397106, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.20295095421323, "pattern_frame_queries": 168149, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3397106, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.20295095421323, "pattern_frame_updates": 345850, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3564927451, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10307.727196761602, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4788, "avg_candidate_generations": 399.0, "candidate_moves_total": 374076, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.12781954887218, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 805, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 4776, "search_candidate_moves_total": 373271, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 160848, "avg_legality_checks": 13404.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "root_legality_checks": 805, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 160043, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1501991, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 125165.91666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3329462456, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2216.6993384114817, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15749, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1312.4166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 80501618, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5111.538383389421, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 66, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 351061, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15295, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 78479398, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 694304, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 328, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 976855, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4632, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 386.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 42279445, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9127.686744386874, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6605, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 550.4166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 21334858, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3230.1071915215744, "stage_move_gen_ns": 373181474, "stage_ordering_ns": 165290, "stage_eval_ns": 3568324557, "stage_threat_ns": 2726673320, "stage_proof_ns": 480249953, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 351796, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1943366648, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 157755, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 476897124, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1795, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 101990176, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 175892, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 233504788, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5934, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 32355972, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 351784, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40548788, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 725, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3796, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6087.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6754.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1824, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1818181818181817, "search_nodes": 145, "safety_nodes": 906, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1051, "avg_nodes": 95.54545454545455, "eval_calls": 134, "avg_eval_calls": 12.181818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 134, "line_shape_eval_ns": 122970, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 917.6865671641791, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 734, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.72727272727273, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12746, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1158.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25244976, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1980.61948846697, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4770, "stage_ordering_ns": 550, "stage_eval_ns": 122970, "stage_threat_ns": 20877703, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 279, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20427451, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 228891, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11540, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 188000, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 268, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33361, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 301, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3462, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 114, 115, 97, 82, 68, 126, 94, 125, 98, 124, 138, 123, 127, 122 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5, "search_nodes": 238, "safety_nodes": 401, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 639, "avg_nodes": 79.875, "eval_calls": 230, "avg_eval_calls": 28.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 230, "line_shape_eval_ns": 152260, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 662.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 502, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.75, "candidate_moves_max": 79, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 502, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 502, "avg_legality_checks": 62.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 502, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9917, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1239.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20343189, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2051.3450640314613, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57800, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11560.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11530, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 46270, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 188690, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11793.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 103870, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4516.086956521739, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1286945, "stage_ordering_ns": 300, "stage_eval_ns": 152260, "stage_threat_ns": 17330695, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 468, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16685515, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 271030, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 314030, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60120, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 3426, "avg_search_time_ms": 428.25, "search_nodes": 103941, "safety_nodes": 513, "corridor_nodes": 178, "corridor_branch_probes": 194, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 28, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 169, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 169, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 53, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 53, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 414, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 113440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 104632, "avg_nodes": 13079.0, "eval_calls": 101500, "avg_eval_calls": 12687.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 101500, "pattern_eval_ns": 2049611, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.1932118226601, "pattern_frame_queries": 101500, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2049611, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.1932118226601, "pattern_frame_updates": 207838, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1947115194, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9368.427303957891, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2427, "avg_candidate_generations": 303.375, "candidate_moves_total": 189786, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.19777503090235, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 522, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 2419, "search_candidate_moves_total": 189264, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 4998, "avg_legality_checks": 624.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4998, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 511142, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 63892.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1180490372, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2309.5155005849647, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12123, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1515.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 112362961, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9268.577167367814, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 136482, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12001, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 110948792, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 393741, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 883946, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13397383, "stage_ordering_ns": 84780, "stage_eval_ns": 1949164805, "stage_threat_ns": 1354457969, "stage_proof_ns": 93440943, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 208290, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1168254986, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 15905, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 23630818, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 337, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12916098, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 104141, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 135945576, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 444, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2050696, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 208282, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24575893, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 214, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2106, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5284.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6284.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1954, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 302, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7717, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 114, 111, 126, 115, 98, 84, 83, 68, 82, 130, 52, 128, 66, 50, 80, 38, 81, 79, 97, 67, 65, 129, 49 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7672, "avg_search_time_ms": 639.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 172481, "safety_nodes": 80, "corridor_nodes": 3752, "corridor_branch_probes": 3937, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1744, "corridor_neutral_exits": 39, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 3731, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3731, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 116, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 95, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 39, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1744, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 116, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 112, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 956, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 236240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 176313, "avg_nodes": 14692.75, "eval_calls": 166867, "avg_eval_calls": 13905.583333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 166867, "pattern_eval_ns": 3394633, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.343345298950663, "pattern_frame_queries": 166867, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3394633, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.343345298950663, "pattern_frame_updates": 344894, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3797992623, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11012.057684389987, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5592, "avg_candidate_generations": 466.0, "candidate_moves_total": 423401, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.71548640915594, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 805, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 5580, "search_candidate_moves_total": 422596, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 160380, "avg_legality_checks": 13365.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 805, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 159575, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1675292, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 139607.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3715139398, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2217.607078646588, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19929, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1660.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 102990360, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5167.863916905013, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 314442, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19207, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 101323408, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 218262, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 631, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1134248, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 6273, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 522.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 57149905, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9110.458313406663, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8775, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 731.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 28220378, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3215.9974928774927, "stage_move_gen_ns": 376345582, "stage_ordering_ns": 191280, "stage_eval_ns": 3801387256, "stage_threat_ns": 2890499195, "stage_proof_ns": 571137538, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 352600, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1949700668, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 206615, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 627078411, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2303, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 131438005, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 176294, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 230348840, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7694, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 42787492, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 352588, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40583784, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 725, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4622, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5669.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6336.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1750, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1818181818181817, "search_nodes": 145, "safety_nodes": 906, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1051, "avg_nodes": 95.54545454545455, "eval_calls": 134, "avg_eval_calls": 12.181818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 134, "line_shape_eval_ns": 119400, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 891.044776119403, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 734, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.72727272727273, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12746, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1158.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25408311, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1993.4340969715988, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4520, "stage_ordering_ns": 550, "stage_eval_ns": 119400, "stage_threat_ns": 20914951, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 279, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20455620, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 236451, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11580, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 189290, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 268, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33590, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 303, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6040, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 142, 157, 111, 110, 68, 98, 66, 138, 124, 130, 146, 143, 126, 128, 125, 123, 139, 83, 153 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4545454545454546, "search_nodes": 271, "safety_nodes": 857, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1128, "avg_nodes": 102.54545454545455, "eval_calls": 260, "avg_eval_calls": 23.636363636363637, "line_shape_eval_calls": 260, "line_shape_eval_ns": 206742, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 795.1615384615385, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 808, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.45454545454545, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 808, "avg_legality_checks": 73.45454545454545, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 808, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13870, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1260.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28215856, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2034.3082912761356, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.909090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 357851, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11182.84375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 68120, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 289731, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.3636363636363638, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 291792, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11222.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.6363636363636362, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 153931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3848.275, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2081809, "stage_ordering_ns": 400, "stage_eval_ns": 206742, "stage_threat_ns": 23222653, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 531, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22388619, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 412132, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 357722, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 520, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64180, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5989, "avg_search_time_ms": 598.9, "search_nodes": 170699, "safety_nodes": 501, "corridor_nodes": 310, "corridor_branch_probes": 337, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 88, "corridor_neutral_exits": 26, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 300, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 300, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 71, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 61, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 88, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 71, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 71, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 555, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 127520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 171510, "avg_nodes": 17151.0, "eval_calls": 166611, "avg_eval_calls": 16661.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 166611, "pattern_eval_ns": 3376296, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.26454435781551, "pattern_frame_queries": 166611, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3376296, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.26454435781551, "pattern_frame_updates": 341340, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3588334256, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10512.49269350208, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4069, "avg_candidate_generations": 406.9, "candidate_moves_total": 356340, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.57434259031703, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 736, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4059, "search_candidate_moves_total": 355604, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 10717, "avg_legality_checks": 1071.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10717, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 875415, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 87541.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2063226697, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2356.8555450843314, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47146, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4714.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 459569325, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9747.790374581089, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 86, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 972323, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 46880, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 456428170, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 577195, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 132, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1591637, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 29038352, "stage_ordering_ns": 142700, "stage_eval_ns": 3591710552, "stage_threat_ns": 2223083911, "stage_proof_ns": 124181213, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 342092, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1920356969, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23305, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 34470332, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 479, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18544908, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 171041, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 224274491, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 742, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3742201, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 342082, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40239918, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 328, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3551, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5631.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6431.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 304, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5613, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 142, 97, 98, 157, 126, 84, 125, 128, 110, 158, 140, 154, 155, 95, 170 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5582, "avg_search_time_ms": 697.75, "search_nodes": 131198, "safety_nodes": 69, "corridor_nodes": 779, "corridor_branch_probes": 902, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 322, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 766, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 766, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 67, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 322, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 67, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 547, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 195680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 132046, "avg_nodes": 16505.75, "eval_calls": 127849, "avg_eval_calls": 15981.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 127849, "pattern_eval_ns": 2580903, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.187119179657252, "pattern_frame_queries": 127849, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2580903, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.187119179657252, "pattern_frame_updates": 262352, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3142412989, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11977.850327041531, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3335, "avg_candidate_generations": 416.875, "candidate_moves_total": 221463, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.40569715142429, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 474, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 3327, "search_candidate_moves_total": 220989, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 124834, "avg_legality_checks": 15604.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 65, "root_legality_checks": 474, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 124360, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 64, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1003044, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 125380.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2405361615, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2398.061914532164, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13562, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1695.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 129082685, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9517.968220026545, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 76, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 667472, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13219, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 126449830, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 71, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 825296, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 196, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1140087, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1631, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 203.875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 16035391, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9831.631514408338, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2280, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 285.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 8426001, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3695.6144736842107, "stage_move_gen_ns": 317919098, "stage_ordering_ns": 110680, "stage_eval_ns": 3144993892, "stage_threat_ns": 1899758615, "stage_proof_ns": 204032450, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 264026, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1534272864, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 48147, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 147508813, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 603, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 33705804, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 132009, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 177012651, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1666, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8652538, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 264018, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32311749, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 404, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2739, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3550.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4550.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 746, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 22, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.142857142857143, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 585, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 652, "avg_nodes": 93.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 60, "avg_eval_calls": 8.571428571428571, "line_shape_eval_calls": 60, "line_shape_eval_ns": 39960, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 666.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 413, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.0, "candidate_moves_max": 70, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 413, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8168, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1166.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16375723, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2004.8632468168462, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 45991, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11497.75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 45991, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2810, "stage_ordering_ns": 340, "stage_eval_ns": 39960, "stage_threat_ns": 13181319, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 127, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 12891385, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 189932, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7221, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 60, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 84632, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15370, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5138.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6281.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 305, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6945, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 129, 126, 131, 130, 99, 96, 141, 111, 66, 113, 114, 65, 49, 144, 69, 51, 84 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 40, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.6363636363636362, "search_nodes": 332, "safety_nodes": 770, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1102, "avg_nodes": 100.18181818181819, "eval_calls": 321, "avg_eval_calls": 29.181818181818183, "line_shape_eval_calls": 321, "line_shape_eval_ns": 291611, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 908.4454828660436, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 748, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.0, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 748, "avg_legality_checks": 68.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 748, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13744, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27803599, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2022.9626746216532, "renju_forbidden_checks": 91, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8.272727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1030095, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11319.725274725275, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 195221, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 834874, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 762834, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11735.907692307692, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 94, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.545454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 425964, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4531.531914893617, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2074238, "stage_ordering_ns": 440, "stage_eval_ns": 291611, "stage_threat_ns": 24485884, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 653, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22992179, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 971654, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 321, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 443071, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 642, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 78980, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6894, "avg_search_time_ms": 626.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 184143, "safety_nodes": 525, "corridor_nodes": 432, "corridor_branch_probes": 516, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 194, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 7, "corridor_plies_followed": 423, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 423, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 40, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 194, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 40, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 281, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 79280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 185100, "avg_nodes": 16827.272727272728, "eval_calls": 179652, "avg_eval_calls": 16332.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 179652, "pattern_eval_ns": 3566192, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.850555518446775, "pattern_frame_queries": 179652, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3566192, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.850555518446775, "pattern_frame_updates": 368224, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4513578300, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12257.697216911445, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4471, "avg_candidate_generations": 406.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 337390, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.46186535450683, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 756, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 4460, "search_candidate_moves_total": 336634, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 9433, "avg_legality_checks": 857.5454545454545, "illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9433, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1270354, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 115486.72727272728, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2786599852, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2193.561678083432, "renju_forbidden_checks": 62265, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5660.454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 581582389, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9340.438271902352, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 86, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 973953, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 61884, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 577152462, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 89, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 993666, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 206, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2462308, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23965798, "stage_ordering_ns": 152010, "stage_eval_ns": 4517144492, "stage_threat_ns": 2259983740, "stage_proof_ns": 66249225, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 369161, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1946631440, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24399, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 34422615, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 361, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15863110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 184575, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 232081413, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 926, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5280015, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 369150, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41568257, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 349, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3846, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5219.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5947.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1922, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 306, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6513, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 126, 67, 98, 84, 99, 100, 114, 66, 116, 96, 130, 146, 144, 102, 129, 159, 113, 115, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6468, "avg_search_time_ms": 539.0, "search_nodes": 158449, "safety_nodes": 80, "corridor_nodes": 2088, "corridor_branch_probes": 2304, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 882, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2068, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2068, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 116, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 96, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 882, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 116, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 112, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 956, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 244640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 160617, "avg_nodes": 13384.75, "eval_calls": 153899, "avg_eval_calls": 12824.916666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 153899, "pattern_eval_ns": 3129517, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.33487547027596, "pattern_frame_queries": 153899, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3129517, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.33487547027596, "pattern_frame_updates": 316830, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3270227284, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10321.709699207777, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4528, "avg_candidate_generations": 377.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 351591, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.64818904593639, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 805, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 4516, "search_candidate_moves_total": 350786, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 146786, "avg_legality_checks": 12232.166666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "root_legality_checks": 805, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 145981, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1345716, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 112143.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2978360086, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2213.2159281750382, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14276, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1189.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 76705225, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5373.019403194172, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 64, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 346870, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13861, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 74917115, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 53, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 587344, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 298, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 853896, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3363, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 280.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 31958843, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9503.075527802557, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4841, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 403.4166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 16485377, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3405.3660400743647, "stage_move_gen_ns": 338864130, "stage_ordering_ns": 158081, "stage_eval_ns": 3273356801, "stage_threat_ns": 2402010888, "stage_proof_ns": 424675405, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 321210, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1749802231, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 124631, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 381653411, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1477, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 83507388, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 160599, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 209182225, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4368, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24176341, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 321198, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37196680, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 725, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3574, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6069.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6736.416666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1780, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1818181818181817, "search_nodes": 145, "safety_nodes": 906, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1051, "avg_nodes": 95.54545454545455, "eval_calls": 134, "avg_eval_calls": 12.181818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 134, "line_shape_eval_ns": 119850, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 894.4029850746268, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 734, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.72727272727273, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12746, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1158.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25350017, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1988.8605837125372, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4700, "stage_ordering_ns": 680, "stage_eval_ns": 119850, "stage_threat_ns": 20886233, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 279, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20432201, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 231701, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11640, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 188701, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 268, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33630, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 307, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8685, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 114, 115, 127, 142, 94, 96, 68, 124, 138, 174, 158, 125, 128, 143, 129, 140, 130, 131, 95, 141, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 43, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5833333333333335, "search_nodes": 368, "safety_nodes": 857, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1225, "avg_nodes": 102.08333333333333, "eval_calls": 356, "avg_eval_calls": 29.666666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 356, "line_shape_eval_ns": 332030, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 932.6685393258427, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 903, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.25, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 903, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 903, "avg_legality_checks": 75.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 903, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15198, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1266.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30581481, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2012.2043031977892, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 283022, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10482.296296296296, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 54701, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 228321, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.1666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 404060, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10633.157894736842, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 212530, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4087.1153846153848, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2290330, "stage_ordering_ns": 680, "stage_eval_ns": 332030, "stage_threat_ns": 26160869, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 724, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24994094, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 592051, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12270, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 356, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 486903, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 712, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 87821, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8630, "avg_search_time_ms": 719.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 269179, "safety_nodes": 501, "corridor_nodes": 805, "corridor_branch_probes": 934, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 260, "corridor_neutral_exits": 27, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 786, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 786, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 90, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 71, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 260, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 90, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 88, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 701, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 256400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 270485, "avg_nodes": 22540.416666666668, "eval_calls": 264004, "avg_eval_calls": 22000.333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 264004, "pattern_eval_ns": 5314560, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.13060408175634, "pattern_frame_queries": 264004, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5314560, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.13060408175634, "pattern_frame_updates": 538290, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4926465268, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9152.06536996786, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5153, "avg_candidate_generations": 429.4166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 458587, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.99417814865127, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 922, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 5141, "search_candidate_moves_total": 457665, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 14939, "avg_legality_checks": 1244.9166666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 14939, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1312250, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 109354.16666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3029608441, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2308.712852733854, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17882, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1490.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 158473459, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8862.177552846439, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 126751, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17679, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 156656039, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 64, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 449103, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 122, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1241566, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 38706305, "stage_ordering_ns": 181460, "stage_eval_ns": 4931779828, "stage_threat_ns": 3480591292, "stage_proof_ns": 148897085, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 540054, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2987893830, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 55186, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 68178435, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 765, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 28627283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 270021, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 350763370, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1752, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10482570, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 540042, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63273087, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 502, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4459, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5942.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6609.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1966, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 308, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4901, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 115, 128, 80, 143, 98, 142, 100, 144, 160, 145, 141, 146 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 4871, "avg_search_time_ms": 608.875, "search_nodes": 116223, "safety_nodes": 69, "corridor_nodes": 700, "corridor_branch_probes": 823, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 287, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 688, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 688, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 67, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 55, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 287, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 67, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 547, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 195440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 116992, "avg_nodes": 14624.0, "eval_calls": 112998, "avg_eval_calls": 14124.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 112998, "pattern_eval_ns": 2291335, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.277659781589055, "pattern_frame_queries": 112998, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2291335, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.277659781589055, "pattern_frame_updates": 232402, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2702456873, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11628.371842755227, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3211, "avg_candidate_generations": 401.375, "candidate_moves_total": 214363, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.75895359701028, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 474, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 3203, "search_candidate_moves_total": 213889, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 109692, "avg_legality_checks": 13711.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 133, "root_legality_checks": 474, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 109218, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 132, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 880649, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 110081.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2098428686, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2382.8207219902592, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13126, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1640.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 123056133, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9374.991086393418, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 144, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1284996, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12720, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 119600707, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 81, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 976954, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 181, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1193476, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1585, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 198.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 16092311, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10152.877602523658, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2212, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 276.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 8565772, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3872.4104882459314, "stage_move_gen_ns": 277566348, "stage_ordering_ns": 107942, "stage_eval_ns": 2704748208, "stage_threat_ns": 1675837961, "stage_proof_ns": 197536334, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 233920, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1343954960, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43531, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 139303017, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 563, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 31789145, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 116956, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156406802, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1510, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7902622, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 233912, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28270560, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 404, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2644, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4084.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5084.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1668, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 22, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.142857142857143, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 585, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 652, "avg_nodes": 93.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 60, "avg_eval_calls": 8.571428571428571, "line_shape_eval_calls": 60, "line_shape_eval_ns": 39770, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 662.8333333333334, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 413, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.0, "candidate_moves_max": 70, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 413, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8168, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1166.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16523449, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2022.9491919686582, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42690, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10672.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 42690, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2930, "stage_ordering_ns": 310, "stage_eval_ns": 39770, "stage_threat_ns": 13279949, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 127, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 12993389, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 185190, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7200, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 60, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 86120, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15250, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5138.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6281.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 309, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1160, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 83, 128, 81, 94, 82, 84, 79, 68, 80 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 23, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.2857142857142856, "search_nodes": 290, "safety_nodes": 243, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 533, "avg_nodes": 76.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 283, "avg_eval_calls": 40.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 283, "line_shape_eval_ns": 197351, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 697.3533568904594, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 409, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.42857142857143, "candidate_moves_max": 68, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 409, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 409, "avg_legality_checks": 58.42857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 409, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8561, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1223.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15194165, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1774.811937857727, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 307030, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9303.939393939394, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 54630, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 252400, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 257631, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9541.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.714285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 148830, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3720.75, "stage_move_gen_ns": 940943, "stage_ordering_ns": 330, "stage_eval_ns": 197351, "stage_threat_ns": 14364548, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 573, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 13590001, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 353132, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6070, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 356122, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 566, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65293, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1130, "avg_search_time_ms": 161.42857142857142, "search_nodes": 36921, "safety_nodes": 221, "corridor_nodes": 174, "corridor_branch_probes": 199, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 64, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 169, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 169, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 35, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 278, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 110640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 37316, "avg_nodes": 5330.857142857143, "eval_calls": 35376, "avg_eval_calls": 5053.714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35376, "pattern_eval_ns": 689934, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.50288331071913, "pattern_frame_queries": 35376, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 689934, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.50288331071913, "pattern_frame_updates": 73804, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 669932506, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9077.184244756381, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1533, "avg_candidate_generations": 219.0, "candidate_moves_total": 110462, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.05609915198956, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 427, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 1526, "search_candidate_moves_total": 110035, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 2664, "avg_legality_checks": 380.57142857142856, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2664, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 243769, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 34824.142857142855, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 422260005, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1732.2137146232703, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11656, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1665.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 78854771, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6765.165665751544, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 166821, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11500, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 77663968, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 329141, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 89, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 694841, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5565717, "stage_ordering_ns": 48390, "stage_eval_ns": 670622440, "stage_threat_ns": 400861405, "stage_proof_ns": 39322976, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 74223, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 338952998, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 11648, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 13321166, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 246, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6721673, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37108, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 39964160, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 412, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1406167, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 74216, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7216914, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1221, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4993.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6136.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1955, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 310, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7667, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 109, 96, 80, 81, 66, 82, 124, 52, 126, 68, 54, 84, 36, 83, 85, 97, 67, 69, 125, 55 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7623, "avg_search_time_ms": 635.25, "search_nodes": 181508, "safety_nodes": 80, "corridor_nodes": 2816, "corridor_branch_probes": 2961, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1324, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 2799, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2799, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 116, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 99, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1324, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 116, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 112, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 956, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 218320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 184404, "avg_nodes": 15367.0, "eval_calls": 175762, "avg_eval_calls": 14646.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 175762, "pattern_eval_ns": 3562455, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.268630306892273, "pattern_frame_queries": 175762, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3562455, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.268630306892273, "pattern_frame_updates": 362948, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3921572581, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10804.778042584612, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5724, "avg_candidate_generations": 477.0, "candidate_moves_total": 433897, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.80310971348707, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 805, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 5712, "search_candidate_moves_total": 433092, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 168968, "avg_legality_checks": 14080.666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "root_legality_checks": 805, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 168163, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1629640, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 135803.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3582065133, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2198.071434795415, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19382, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1615.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 99548885, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5136.151325972552, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 305352, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18957, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 98485574, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 188781, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 339, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 569178, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4944, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 412.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 46377263, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9380.514360841424, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7039, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 586.5833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 22314689, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3170.150447506748, "stage_move_gen_ns": 390104221, "stage_ordering_ns": 190411, "stage_eval_ns": 3925135036, "stage_threat_ns": 2800604417, "stage_proof_ns": 468851848, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 368790, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2018881287, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 153413, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 469223736, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1829, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 98183477, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 184389, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 237855528, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5830, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 32204753, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 368778, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42439113, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 725, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4684, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5715.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6382.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1789, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1818181818181817, "search_nodes": 145, "safety_nodes": 906, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1051, "avg_nodes": 95.54545454545455, "eval_calls": 134, "avg_eval_calls": 12.181818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 134, "line_shape_eval_ns": 121360, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 905.6716417910447, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 734, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.72727272727273, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12746, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1158.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25190613, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1976.354385689628, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4790, "stage_ordering_ns": 620, "stage_eval_ns": 121360, "stage_threat_ns": 20861451, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 279, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20406140, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 230450, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11590, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 191161, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 268, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33700, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 311, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1253, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 82, 67, 98, 114, 100, 99, 83, 69, 129, 54, 115, 84 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 25, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5714285714285716, "search_nodes": 248, "safety_nodes": 214, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 462, "avg_nodes": 66.0, "eval_calls": 241, "avg_eval_calls": 34.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 241, "line_shape_eval_ns": 181400, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 752.6970954356847, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 348, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.714285714285715, "candidate_moves_max": 62, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 348, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 348, "avg_legality_checks": 49.714285714285715, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 348, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8270, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1181.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16897556, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2043.23530834341, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 115951, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10541.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19170, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 96781, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 155140, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11933.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 86780, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4567.368421052632, "stage_move_gen_ns": 898182, "stage_ordering_ns": 330, "stage_eval_ns": 181400, "stage_threat_ns": 15307558, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 489, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14689677, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 231630, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 326091, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60160, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1220, "avg_search_time_ms": 174.28571428571428, "search_nodes": 33940, "safety_nodes": 287, "corridor_nodes": 38, "corridor_branch_probes": 42, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 31, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 31, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 26, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 26, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 157, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 65280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 34265, "avg_nodes": 4895.0, "eval_calls": 32855, "avg_eval_calls": 4693.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32855, "pattern_eval_ns": 664193, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.215887992695176, "pattern_frame_queries": 32855, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 664193, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.215887992695176, "pattern_frame_updates": 67842, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 714364017, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10529.819536570267, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1073, "avg_candidate_generations": 153.28571428571428, "candidate_moves_total": 69205, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.49673811742777, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 361, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 1066, "search_candidate_moves_total": 68844, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 2713, "avg_legality_checks": 387.57142857142856, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2713, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 204909, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29272.714285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 470207243, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2294.7124967668574, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5384, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 769.1428571428571, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50755189, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9427.041047548291, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 90030, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5338, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 50248116, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 93360, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 323683, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6863781, "stage_ordering_ns": 39920, "stage_eval_ns": 715028210, "stage_threat_ns": 442518070, "stage_proof_ns": 44080193, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 67963, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 385138689, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3555, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5586128, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 140, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3494279, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 33978, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 43266959, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 114, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 504232, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 67956, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8022062, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 170, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 867, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4992.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6134.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 312, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3923, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 95, 143, 98, 158, 173, 99, 126, 84, 96, 94, 81, 141, 67, 82, 53, 109, 39 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 3885, "avg_search_time_ms": 388.5, "search_nodes": 73629, "safety_nodes": 515, "corridor_nodes": 2204, "corridor_branch_probes": 2361, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 917, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2186, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2186, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 74, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 917, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 74, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 71, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 563, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 146880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 76348, "avg_nodes": 7634.8, "eval_calls": 70505, "avg_eval_calls": 7050.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70505, "pattern_eval_ns": 1423618, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.19173108290192, "pattern_frame_queries": 70505, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1423618, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.19173108290192, "pattern_frame_updates": 147202, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1907666664, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12959.515930490075, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3106, "avg_candidate_generations": 310.6, "candidate_moves_total": 221168, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.20669671603348, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 595, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 3096, "search_candidate_moves_total": 220573, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 67112, "avg_legality_checks": 6711.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "root_legality_checks": 595, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 66517, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 936769, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 93676.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2063228480, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2202.4944036363286, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11704, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1170.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65142639, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5565.844070403281, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 131412, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11034, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 58775200, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 168, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2048321, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 485, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4187706, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 5246, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 524.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 51706669, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9856.3989706443, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6997, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 699.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 27152433, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3880.5821066171216, "stage_move_gen_ns": 161586615, "stage_ordering_ns": 104722, "stage_eval_ns": 1909090282, "stage_threat_ns": 1430958119, "stage_proof_ns": 366004557, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 151732, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 869150161, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 132604, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 416650784, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1418, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 86445012, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75861, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 101507951, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4520, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25816510, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 151722, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17832713, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 289, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2673, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5804.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6604.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1839, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 77, "safety_nodes": 756, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 833, "avg_nodes": 92.55555555555556, "eval_calls": 68, "avg_eval_calls": 7.555555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68, "line_shape_eval_ns": 50740, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 746.1764705882352, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 543, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.333333333333336, "candidate_moves_max": 79, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 543, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10329, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1147.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20745143, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2008.4367315325783, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3461, "stage_ordering_ns": 500, "stage_eval_ns": 50740, "stage_threat_ns": 16500661, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 145, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16208021, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 174380, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 100660, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17600, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 313, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12541, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 109, 108, 125, 141, 99, 155, 169, 171, 96, 156, 186, 139, 123, 142, 138, 140, 143, 124, 172, 92 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.272727272727273, "search_nodes": 217, "safety_nodes": 695, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 912, "avg_nodes": 82.9090909090909, "eval_calls": 206, "avg_eval_calls": 18.727272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 206, "line_shape_eval_ns": 150440, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 730.2912621359224, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 696, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.27272727272727, "candidate_moves_max": 78, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 696, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 696, "avg_legality_checks": 63.27272727272727, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 696, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13202, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1200.1818181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26618585, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2016.2539766702014, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.272727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 302451, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12098.04, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 58220, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 244231, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.5454545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 333792, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11921.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.727272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 189291, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4616.8536585365855, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1752316, "stage_ordering_ns": 490, "stage_eval_ns": 150440, "stage_threat_ns": 21848915, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 423, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21085721, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 435012, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11350, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 206, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 276051, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 412, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52131, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 12493, "avg_search_time_ms": 1135.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 342752, "safety_nodes": 498, "corridor_nodes": 554, "corridor_branch_probes": 627, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 12, "corridor_depth_exits": 203, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 542, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 542, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 57, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 45, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 203, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 57, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 424, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 128880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 343804, "avg_nodes": 31254.909090909092, "eval_calls": 335997, "avg_eval_calls": 30545.18181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 335997, "pattern_eval_ns": 6770041, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.149111450399854, "pattern_frame_queries": 335997, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6770041, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.149111450399854, "pattern_frame_updates": 685442, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7932118159, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11572.267469749446, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6735, "avg_candidate_generations": 612.2727272727273, "candidate_moves_total": 531382, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.89858945805494, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 727, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 6724, "search_candidate_moves_total": 530655, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 10434, "avg_legality_checks": 948.5454545454545, "illegal_moves_skipped": 133, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10434, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 133, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2076726, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 188793.27272727274, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4774703087, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2299.149279683502, "renju_forbidden_checks": 76047, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6913.363636363636, "renju_forbidden_ns": 745865583, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9807.95538285534, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 133, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1446347, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 75696, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 742008682, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 89, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 925301, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 129, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1485253, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 30227813, "stage_ordering_ns": 203824, "stage_eval_ns": 7938888200, "stage_threat_ns": 4409168112, "stage_proof_ns": 91848382, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 686651, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3829868185, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34432, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 42171078, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 510, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19857340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 343320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 447772203, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1198, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7149168, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 686640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 82207478, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 385, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5956, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.6363636363636362, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6363636363636362, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3972.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4700.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 314, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5303, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 80, 128, 125, 129, 130, 140, 97, 139, 95, 65, 94, 98, 108, 109, 66, 52, 122 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5267, "avg_search_time_ms": 526.7, "search_nodes": 106612, "safety_nodes": 516, "corridor_nodes": 2142, "corridor_branch_probes": 2316, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 901, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 2126, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2126, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 76, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 60, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 901, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 76, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 73, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 572, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 144800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 5, "total_nodes": 109270, "avg_nodes": 10927.0, "eval_calls": 102783, "avg_eval_calls": 10278.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 102783, "pattern_eval_ns": 2082738, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.263448235603164, "pattern_frame_queries": 102783, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2082738, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.263448235603164, "pattern_frame_updates": 213168, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2815799091, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13209.29544303085, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3811, "avg_candidate_generations": 381.1, "candidate_moves_total": 265385, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.63657832589871, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 596, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 3801, "search_candidate_moves_total": 264789, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 98270, "avg_legality_checks": 9827.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "root_legality_checks": 596, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 97674, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1207390, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 120739.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2699805769, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2236.0676906384847, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14405, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1440.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 95607035, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6637.0728913571675, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 362561, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13695, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 88885670, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 153, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1987093, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 519, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4371711, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 5144, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 514.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 50238744, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9766.474339035769, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6954, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 695.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 26730053, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3843.838510209951, "stage_move_gen_ns": 239990965, "stage_ordering_ns": 125993, "stage_eval_ns": 2817881829, "stage_threat_ns": 1827006723, "stage_proof_ns": 360057831, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 217582, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1243520163, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 127384, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 388784925, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1404, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 79972183, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108786, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 143898389, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4404, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25069873, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 217572, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25733373, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 289, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3319, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5513.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6313.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1844, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 77, "safety_nodes": 752, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 829, "avg_nodes": 92.11111111111111, "eval_calls": 68, "avg_eval_calls": 7.555555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68, "line_shape_eval_ns": 50961, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 749.4264705882352, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 539, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.888888888888886, "candidate_moves_max": 75, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 539, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10403, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1155.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20907222, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2009.7300778621552, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3420, "stage_ordering_ns": 440, "stage_eval_ns": 50961, "stage_threat_ns": 16682451, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 145, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16386420, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 175570, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 102451, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18010, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 315, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1204, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 95, 79, 80, 66, 50, 110, 35, 94, 65 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 25, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5714285714285716, "search_nodes": 248, "safety_nodes": 214, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 462, "avg_nodes": 66.0, "eval_calls": 241, "avg_eval_calls": 34.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 241, "line_shape_eval_ns": 182111, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 755.6473029045643, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 348, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.714285714285715, "candidate_moves_max": 62, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 348, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 348, "avg_legality_checks": 49.714285714285715, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 348, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8172, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1167.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16761972, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2051.1468428781204, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 117730, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10702.727272727272, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20510, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 97220, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 154980, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11921.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 87740, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4617.894736842105, "stage_move_gen_ns": 883675, "stage_ordering_ns": 310, "stage_eval_ns": 182111, "stage_threat_ns": 15343942, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 489, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14724871, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 232591, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 326510, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59970, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1173, "avg_search_time_ms": 167.57142857142858, "search_nodes": 34032, "safety_nodes": 287, "corridor_nodes": 38, "corridor_branch_probes": 42, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 31, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 31, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 26, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 26, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 157, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 67760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 34357, "avg_nodes": 4908.142857142857, "eval_calls": 32920, "avg_eval_calls": 4702.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32920, "pattern_eval_ns": 663561, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.156773997569868, "pattern_frame_queries": 32920, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 663561, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.156773997569868, "pattern_frame_updates": 68026, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 672785562, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9890.12380560374, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1100, "avg_candidate_generations": 157.14285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 70027, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.660909090909094, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 361, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 1093, "search_candidate_moves_total": 69666, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 2562, "avg_legality_checks": 366.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2562, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 203008, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29001.14285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 444847596, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2191.281112074401, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5579, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 797.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50423597, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9038.106649937265, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 102540, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5531, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 49903436, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 89280, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 328341, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6210484, "stage_ordering_ns": 39220, "stage_eval_ns": 673449123, "stage_threat_ns": 435494999, "stage_proof_ns": 44080785, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 68147, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 379025181, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3555, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5493168, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 140, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3420066, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34070, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 42604467, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 114, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 507431, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 68140, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7864752, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 170, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 892, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4997.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6140.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 316, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3004, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 95, 79, 143, 159, 80, 65, 113, 51, 37, 52, 67, 49, 33, 50, 53, 48 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2966, "avg_search_time_ms": 296.6, "search_nodes": 68398, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 884, "corridor_branch_probes": 998, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 272, "corridor_neutral_exits": 23, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 871, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 871, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 272, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 55, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 428, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 139120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 69513, "avg_nodes": 6951.3, "eval_calls": 65457, "avg_eval_calls": 6545.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 65457, "pattern_eval_ns": 1336444, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.417128802114366, "pattern_frame_queries": 65457, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1336444, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.417128802114366, "pattern_frame_updates": 136740, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1546600603, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11310.520718151236, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2923, "avg_candidate_generations": 292.3, "candidate_moves_total": 222018, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.95552514539857, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 2913, "search_candidate_moves_total": 221378, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 61639, "avg_legality_checks": 6163.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 99, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 60999, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 98, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 672345, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 67234.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1449809134, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2156.347015297206, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8332, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 833.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51818049, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6219.1609457513205, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 110, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 826674, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7900, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 49611308, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 76, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 520792, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 246, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 859275, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1658, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 165.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 15398939, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9287.659227985525, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2205, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 220.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 7876818, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3572.25306122449, "stage_move_gen_ns": 140260711, "stage_ordering_ns": 105050, "stage_eval_ns": 1547937047, "stage_threat_ns": 1034733126, "stage_proof_ns": 220402104, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 138610, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 752280554, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 63696, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 169469251, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 730, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 38421031, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 69300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87566554, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1860, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9762203, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 138600, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15654564, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 455, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2362, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5807.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6607.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1837, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 45050, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 776.7241379310345, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21035123, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2015.630797240322, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44120, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11030.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 44120, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3950, "stage_ordering_ns": 430, "stage_eval_ns": 45050, "stage_threat_ns": 16620330, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16335827, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 186003, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9350, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 83660, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14840, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 317, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 1084, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 110, 109, 96, 82, 66, 81, 95, 79, 83, 78, 67, 80 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 25, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5714285714285716, "search_nodes": 248, "safety_nodes": 214, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 462, "avg_nodes": 66.0, "eval_calls": 241, "avg_eval_calls": 34.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 241, "line_shape_eval_ns": 180781, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 750.1286307053942, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 348, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.714285714285715, "candidate_moves_max": 62, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 348, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 348, "avg_legality_checks": 49.714285714285715, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 348, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8270, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1181.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16908954, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2044.6135429262395, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 128030, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11639.09090909091, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 32020, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 96010, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 154360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11873.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 86640, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4560.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 939773, "stage_ordering_ns": 280, "stage_eval_ns": 180781, "stage_threat_ns": 15498247, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 489, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14871304, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 236090, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7880, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 330192, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60661, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1052, "avg_search_time_ms": 150.28571428571428, "search_nodes": 30502, "safety_nodes": 287, "corridor_nodes": 38, "corridor_branch_probes": 42, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 31, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 31, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 26, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 26, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 157, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 81040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 30827, "avg_nodes": 4403.857142857143, "eval_calls": 29443, "avg_eval_calls": 4206.142857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 29443, "pattern_eval_ns": 600133, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.38287538633971, "pattern_frame_queries": 29443, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 600133, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.38287538633971, "pattern_frame_updates": 60966, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 587451526, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9635.723616441952, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1047, "avg_candidate_generations": 149.57142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 67183, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.16714422158549, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 361, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 1040, "search_candidate_moves_total": 66822, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 2705, "avg_legality_checks": 386.42857142857144, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2705, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 171892, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24556.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 386794974, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2250.220917785586, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3974, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 567.7142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37121263, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9341.032460996477, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 91301, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3926, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 36621181, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 88420, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 320361, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6840622, "stage_ordering_ns": 40920, "stage_eval_ns": 588051659, "stage_threat_ns": 400620443, "stage_proof_ns": 44158994, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 61087, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 348627831, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3555, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5509775, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 140, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3382664, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 30540, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 38737892, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 114, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 502871, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 61080, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7242074, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 170, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 839, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5029.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6172.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 318, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3460, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 82, 66, 130, 146, 81, 80, 128, 94, 52, 109, 110, 64, 48, 79, 49, 124 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 3433, "avg_search_time_ms": 343.3, "search_nodes": 113822, "safety_nodes": 228, "corridor_nodes": 923, "corridor_branch_probes": 1036, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 313, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 910, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 910, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 62, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 313, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 62, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 443, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 122320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 114973, "avg_nodes": 11497.3, "eval_calls": 110029, "avg_eval_calls": 11002.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110029, "pattern_eval_ns": 2088799, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.98407692517427, "pattern_frame_queries": 110029, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2088799, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.98407692517427, "pattern_frame_updates": 227588, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1846264125, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8112.308755294655, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3775, "avg_candidate_generations": 377.5, "candidate_moves_total": 275653, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.02066225165562, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 638, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 3765, "search_candidate_moves_total": 275015, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 106976, "avg_legality_checks": 10697.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 37, "root_legality_checks": 638, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 106338, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 915986, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 91598.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1456710914, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1590.3200638437706, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10854, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1085.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 48735364, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4490.083287267367, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 49, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 127200, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10434, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 47675068, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 81, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 364771, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 290, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 568325, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1814, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 181.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 10442243, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5756.473539140022, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2444, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 244.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 5457111, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2232.860474631751, "stage_move_gen_ns": 195548709, "stage_ordering_ns": 116990, "stage_eval_ns": 1848352924, "stage_threat_ns": 1212657926, "stage_proof_ns": 150792118, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 229542, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 956657302, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 63512, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 109315812, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 740, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 25028187, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 114766, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118949255, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1944, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6574042, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 229532, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21161515, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 456, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3121, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5486.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6286.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1788, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 17, "avg_search_time_ms": 1.8888888888888888, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 820, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 887, "avg_nodes": 98.55555555555556, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 39690, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 684.3103448275862, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 580, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10420, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1157.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14414509, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1383.3501919385797, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.1111111111111112, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32700, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3270.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 32700, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3730, "stage_ordering_ns": 450, "stage_eval_ns": 39690, "stage_threat_ns": 11544169, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 11312149, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 138440, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 79500, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14080, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 319, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 756, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 82, 67, 96, 110, 94, 95, 81, 65, 125, 50, 109, 80 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 14, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.0, "search_nodes": 248, "safety_nodes": 214, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 462, "avg_nodes": 66.0, "eval_calls": 241, "avg_eval_calls": 34.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 241, "line_shape_eval_ns": 102701, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 426.14522821576764, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 348, "avg_candidate_moves": 49.714285714285715, "candidate_moves_max": 62, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 348, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 348, "avg_legality_checks": 49.714285714285715, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 348, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8270, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1181.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9319786, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1126.9390568319227, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 56490, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5135.454545454545, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9890, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 46600, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 91700, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7053.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 53850, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2834.2105263157896, "stage_move_gen_ns": 485981, "stage_ordering_ns": 280, "stage_eval_ns": 102701, "stage_threat_ns": 8908887, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 489, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 8519997, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 137500, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3690, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 212710, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38680, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5140.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6282.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 736, "avg_search_time_ms": 105.14285714285714, "search_nodes": 34952, "safety_nodes": 287, "corridor_nodes": 38, "corridor_branch_probes": 42, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 31, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 31, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 26, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 26, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 157, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 68000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 35277, "avg_nodes": 5039.571428571428, "eval_calls": 33840, "avg_eval_calls": 4834.285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33840, "pattern_eval_ns": 619712, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.313002364066193, "pattern_frame_queries": 33840, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 619712, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.313002364066193, "pattern_frame_updates": 69866, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 426561365, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6105.421306501016, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1100, "avg_candidate_generations": 157.14285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 71033, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.57545454545455, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 361, "root_candidate_moves_max": 62, "search_candidate_generations": 1093, "search_candidate_moves_total": 70672, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 2676, "avg_legality_checks": 382.2857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2676, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 206070, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29438.571428571428, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 263946772, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1280.8597660988985, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5686, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 812.2857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 28547426, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5020.651776292649, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 56180, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5638, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28271095, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 47131, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 173020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3994270, "stage_ordering_ns": 35600, "stage_eval_ns": 427181077, "stage_threat_ns": 269485605, "stage_proof_ns": 24723240, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 69987, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 231575794, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3555, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3160322, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 140, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1915408, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 29040274, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 114, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 312740, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 69980, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5396475, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 170, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 892, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5052.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6195.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 320, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2108, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 110, 94, 158, 174, 95, 80, 128, 66, 52, 67, 82, 64, 48, 65, 68, 63 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2084, "avg_search_time_ms": 208.4, "search_nodes": 67829, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 884, "corridor_branch_probes": 998, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 272, "corridor_neutral_exits": 23, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 871, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 871, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 272, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 55, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 428, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 139280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 68944, "avg_nodes": 6894.4, "eval_calls": 65045, "avg_eval_calls": 6504.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 65045, "pattern_eval_ns": 1216226, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.698224306249518, "pattern_frame_queries": 65045, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1216226, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.698224306249518, "pattern_frame_updates": 135602, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1111381161, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8195.905377501807, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2766, "avg_candidate_generations": 276.6, "candidate_moves_total": 210370, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.05567606652205, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 2756, "search_candidate_moves_total": 209730, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 61246, "avg_legality_checks": 6124.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 99, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 60606, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 98, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 672636, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 67263.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 988664519, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1469.835868136704, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8203, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 820.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37372989, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4556.014750700963, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 110, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 529901, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7770, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35994434, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 77, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 359601, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 246, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 489053, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1658, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 165.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 10007347, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6035.794330518697, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2205, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 220.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 5182412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2350.3002267573697, "stage_move_gen_ns": 99322975, "stage_ordering_ns": 89120, "stage_eval_ns": 1112597387, "stage_threat_ns": 709501246, "stage_proof_ns": 142605519, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 137472, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 513129544, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 63696, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 113043487, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 730, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 25626592, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68731, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 65406839, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1860, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6456903, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 137462, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11464473, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 455, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2209, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5882.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6682.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1895, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 14, "avg_search_time_ms": 1.5555555555555556, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 29980, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 516.8965517241379, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1157.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12416760, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1192.3141924332629, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 22320, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5580.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 22320, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3440, "stage_ordering_ns": 410, "stage_eval_ns": 29980, "stage_threat_ns": 10081263, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 9878673, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 134050, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5530, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 58910, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9630, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5776.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6665.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1999, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 321, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4736, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 67, 52, 83, 141, 99, 51, 115, 131, 68, 128, 81, 143, 158, 155, 169, 129, 130, 125, 126, 84, 80, 79, 96, 110, 111, 66, 95, 140, 170, 142, 144, 139 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 33, "avg_search_time_ms": 1.9411764705882353, "search_nodes": 564, "safety_nodes": 1008, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1572, "avg_nodes": 92.47058823529412, "eval_calls": 547, "avg_eval_calls": 32.1764705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 547, "line_shape_eval_ns": 355181, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 649.3254113345521, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1302, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.58823529411765, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1302, "avg_legality_checks": 76.58823529411765, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20907, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1229.8235294117646, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23763924, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1136.6491605682306, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.2941176470588234, "renju_forbidden_ns": 338770, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6049.464285714285, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 70970, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 267800, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.7058823529411766, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 262291, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5701.978260869565, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 61, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.588235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 134071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2197.8852459016393, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1860927, "stage_ordering_ns": 730, "stage_eval_ns": 355181, "stage_threat_ns": 21201106, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1111, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20283842, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 330472, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 547, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 500292, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1094, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 86500, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6822.35294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7292.941176470588, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 4687, "avg_search_time_ms": 275.70588235294116, "search_nodes": 81813, "safety_nodes": 1995, "corridor_nodes": 3116, "corridor_branch_probes": 3492, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 21, "corridor_depth_exits": 1558, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 25, "corridor_plies_followed": 3089, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3089, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 39, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 46, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1558, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 63, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 364, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 149640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 23440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 86924, "avg_nodes": 5113.176470588235, "eval_calls": 63425, "avg_eval_calls": 3730.8823529411766, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 63425, "pattern_eval_ns": 1158064, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.258793851005123, "pattern_frame_queries": 63425, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1158064, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.258793851005123, "pattern_frame_updates": 163472, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1196098990, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7316.843190271116, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16869, "avg_candidate_generations": 992.2941176470588, "candidate_moves_total": 1396792, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.80230007706444, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1328, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 16852, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1395464, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 653920, "avg_legality_checks": 38465.882352941175, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4585, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 653920, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4585, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2218180, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 130481.17647058824, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2569830076, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1158.5309019105753, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36719, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2159.9411764705883, "renju_forbidden_ns": 216423545, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5894.047904354694, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6453, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 43584364, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15756, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 100956425, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14369, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 70978230, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 141, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 904526, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81334, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4784.35294117647, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 499937088, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6146.717092482849, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118715, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6983.235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 256815192, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2163.2918502295415, "stage_move_gen_ns": 919351243, "stage_ordering_ns": 307711840, "stage_eval_ns": 1197257054, "stage_threat_ns": 2177741798, "stage_proof_ns": 44841427, "tactical_annotations": 358910, "root_tactical_annotations": 836, "search_tactical_annotations": 358074, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169799, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 606209957, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 483191, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1446694852, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35228, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 700891260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84891, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80354509, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6310, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25405196, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169782, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13129600, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 98738, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 221782171, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 198111, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 450496858, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 62061, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5947684, "child_limit_applications": 16852, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16852, "child_cap_hits": 16852, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16852, "child_moves_before_total": 1390879, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1390879, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 281322, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 281322, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.53495134108711, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.693686209352006, "tt_hits": 5968, "tt_cutoffs": 1459, "beta_cutoffs": 12794, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6658.764705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7129.35294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1912, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 322, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22651, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 83, 128, 67, 143, 158, 127, 82, 52, 81, 84, 99, 51, 79, 80, 53, 95, 69, 111, 159, 142, 37, 85, 160, 157, 68, 172, 187, 66, 38, 23, 39, 25, 40, 36, 41 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 22599, "avg_search_time_ms": 1255.5, "search_nodes": 267925, "safety_nodes": 504, "corridor_nodes": 42511, "corridor_branch_probes": 44681, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 27911, "corridor_neutral_exits": 27, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 42433, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 42433, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 165, "corridor_proof_active": 78, "corridor_proof_quiet": 87, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 27, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 27911, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 165, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 161, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1350, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 101334360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1990320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 310940, "avg_nodes": 17274.444444444445, "eval_calls": 211028, "avg_eval_calls": 11723.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 211028, "pattern_eval_ns": 3984297, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.880418712208808, "pattern_frame_queries": 211028, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3984297, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.880418712208808, "pattern_frame_updates": 535686, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5097081433, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9515.054403139153, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 53242, "avg_candidate_generations": 2957.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 4374704, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.16640997708576, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1315, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 53224, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4373389, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1653922, "avg_legality_checks": 91884.55555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1210, "root_legality_checks": 1315, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1652607, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1209, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9616262, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 534236.7777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13716513849, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1426.3872853089902, "renju_forbidden_checks": 66903, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3716.8333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 229567610, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3431.3500141996624, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2005, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10814828, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 32733, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 151034091, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26501, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 49689059, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5664, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 18029632, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 326078, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18115.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1965811552, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6028.65434650605, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 429776, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23876.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 868463781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2020.7358740367074, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2645275539, "stage_ordering_ns": 1149451396, "stage_eval_ns": 5101065730, "stage_threat_ns": 11598806733, "stage_proof_ns": 2008600362, "tactical_annotations": 1339943, "root_tactical_annotations": 4223, "search_tactical_annotations": 1335720, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 620900, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3023390665, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2581016, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7637841929, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 120409, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2914366622, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 310441, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 368272529, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 85196, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 477352469, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 620882, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56244339, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 470050, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 438629893, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 572839, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1537128912, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 297054, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 35704802, "child_limit_applications": 53224, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 53224, "child_cap_hits": 53224, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 53224, "child_moves_before_total": 4372180, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4372180, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 948297, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 948297, "child_moves_after_max": 32, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 32, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.14677589057568, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.81709379227416, "tt_hits": 22668, "tt_cutoffs": 3591, "beta_cutoffs": 40248, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5449.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5893.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1217, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 33, "avg_search_time_ms": 1.9411764705882353, "search_nodes": 164, "safety_nodes": 1851, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2015, "avg_nodes": 118.52941176470588, "eval_calls": 147, "avg_eval_calls": 8.647058823529411, "line_shape_eval_calls": 147, "line_shape_eval_ns": 125490, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 853.6734693877551, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1258, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.0, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1258, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19548, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1149.8823529411766, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26629621, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1362.2683138940045, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5882352941176471, "renju_forbidden_ns": 58540, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5854.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 58540, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8110, "stage_ordering_ns": 880, "stage_eval_ns": 125490, "stage_threat_ns": 21953245, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 311, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21481574, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 300051, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 147730, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 294, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23890, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6822.705882352941, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7293.294117647059, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 323, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6899, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 110, 109, 126, 98, 97, 82, 66, 129, 130, 99, 96, 81, 141, 156, 142, 84, 144, 69 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 34, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4, "search_nodes": 261, "safety_nodes": 575, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 836, "avg_nodes": 83.6, "eval_calls": 251, "avg_eval_calls": 25.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 251, "line_shape_eval_ns": 189140, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 753.5458167330677, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 565, "avg_candidate_moves": 56.5, "candidate_moves_max": 73, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 565, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 565, "avg_legality_checks": 56.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 565, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12222, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1222.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24805314, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2029.5625920471282, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 117690, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9807.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21300, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 96390, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 474572, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11036.558139534884, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 62, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 256232, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4132.774193548387, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1450829, "stage_ordering_ns": 500, "stage_eval_ns": 189140, "stage_threat_ns": 21259114, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 512, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20191598, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 652413, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 251, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 350953, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 502, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64150, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6853, "avg_search_time_ms": 685.3, "search_nodes": 66223, "safety_nodes": 463, "corridor_nodes": 1054, "corridor_branch_probes": 1176, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 325, "corridor_neutral_exits": 56, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 1032, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1032, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 57, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 325, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 550, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 18159200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1987280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67740, "avg_nodes": 6774.0, "eval_calls": 49589, "avg_eval_calls": 4958.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49589, "pattern_eval_ns": 1035165, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.874891609026196, "pattern_frame_queries": 49589, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1035165, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.874891609026196, "pattern_frame_updates": 132362, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1485166566, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11220.490518426739, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15425, "avg_candidate_generations": 1542.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1082935, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.20648298217179, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 587, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 15415, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1082348, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 663331, "avg_legality_checks": 66333.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1345, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 663331, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1345, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2065132, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 206513.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4228425922, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2047.5330012803056, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18439, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1843.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 84229896, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4568.029502684527, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1355, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14116938, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4678, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 45253774, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12364, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24356572, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 502612, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 79653, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7965.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 790852554, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9928.722759971375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 115243, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11524.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 388792493, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3373.675563808648, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1600489735, "stage_ordering_ns": 461887723, "stage_eval_ns": 1486201731, "stage_threat_ns": 3161401258, "stage_proof_ns": 109993643, "tactical_annotations": 250138, "root_tactical_annotations": 1172, "search_tactical_annotations": 248966, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 134574, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 810915075, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 295056, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2215447669, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31743, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1180393518, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67282, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 98303659, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2202, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11674433, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 134564, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16811681, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 57608, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 358269072, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 130953, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 622535232, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 61577, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8248741, "child_limit_applications": 15415, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15415, "child_cap_hits": 15415, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15415, "child_moves_before_total": 1081003, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1081003, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 246869, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 246869, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.12669477781382, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01485566007136, "tt_hits": 6213, "tt_cutoffs": 1177, "beta_cutoffs": 12139, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4627.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5427.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1837, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 324, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10295, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 142, 156, 100, 86, 141, 140, 98, 124, 108, 109, 110, 154, 168, 139, 94, 169 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10257, "avg_search_time_ms": 1025.7, "search_nodes": 127916, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 741, "corridor_branch_probes": 871, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 244, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 725, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 725, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 244, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 422, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 53779040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 128888, "avg_nodes": 12888.8, "eval_calls": 104279, "avg_eval_calls": 10427.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 104279, "pattern_eval_ns": 2126091, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.38848665599018, "pattern_frame_queries": 104279, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2126091, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.38848665599018, "pattern_frame_updates": 255748, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3238005895, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12660.92362403616, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22286, "avg_candidate_generations": 2228.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1785982, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.13919052319842, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 22276, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1785342, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 742409, "avg_legality_checks": 74240.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 486, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 741769, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 485, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2745563, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 274556.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5992468578, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2182.601010430283, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26608, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2660.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 109692157, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4122.525443475646, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1092, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4899063, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15259, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 86317620, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10124, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17817312, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 133, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 658162, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65580, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6558.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 551804377, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8414.217398597133, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 85103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8510.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 224849981, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2642.092299918922, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1789551186, "stage_ordering_ns": 726899410, "stage_eval_ns": 3240131986, "stage_threat_ns": 4273857275, "stage_proof_ns": 192449567, "tactical_annotations": 340658, "root_tactical_annotations": 1928, "search_tactical_annotations": 338730, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 257320, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1467666821, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 361290, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2571316499, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45172, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1665201474, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128655, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 185081628, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1562, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8199584, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 257310, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31352039, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 94336, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 102893262, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 170257, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 682975012, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76065, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10240704, "child_limit_applications": 22276, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22276, "child_cap_hits": 22276, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22276, "child_moves_before_total": 1784857, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1784857, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 356550, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 356550, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.12466331477823, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00601544262884, "tt_hits": 9227, "tt_cutoffs": 1319, "beta_cutoffs": 15387, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4180.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4980.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1164, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44860, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 773.448275862069, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1157.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21054928, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2021.790666410601, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46980, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11745.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 46980, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4040, "stage_ordering_ns": 520, "stage_eval_ns": 44860, "stage_threat_ns": 16665600, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16371099, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 190091, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 89580, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14830, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 325, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14399, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 99, 94, 127, 85, 98, 100, 83, 128, 53, 68, 115, 67, 81, 129, 49, 52, 65 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1818181818181817, "search_nodes": 274, "safety_nodes": 666, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 940, "avg_nodes": 85.45454545454545, "eval_calls": 263, "avg_eval_calls": 23.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 263, "line_shape_eval_ns": 240001, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 912.5513307984791, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 665, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.45454545454545, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 665, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 665, "avg_legality_checks": 60.45454545454545, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 665, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13521, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1229.1818181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24843727, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1837.4178685008505, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.909090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 316682, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9896.3125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 60011, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 256671, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.636363636363637, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 761103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10426.068493150686, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.181818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 432402, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3860.7321428571427, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1565857, "stage_ordering_ns": 490, "stage_eval_ns": 240001, "stage_threat_ns": 21742913, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 537, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20389966, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 921884, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 263, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 365032, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66031, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14352, "avg_search_time_ms": 1304.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 156274, "safety_nodes": 196, "corridor_nodes": 3800, "corridor_branch_probes": 4446, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1575, "corridor_neutral_exits": 32, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 3765, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3765, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 35, "corridor_proof_quiet": 65, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 32, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1575, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 99, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 821, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 69536560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1993440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 160270, "avg_nodes": 14570.0, "eval_calls": 125536, "avg_eval_calls": 11412.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 125536, "pattern_eval_ns": 2572710, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.493802574560284, "pattern_frame_queries": 125536, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2572710, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.493802574560284, "pattern_frame_updates": 312450, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3768246879, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12060.319663946231, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29013, "avg_candidate_generations": 2637.5454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 2241440, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.25640230241616, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 680, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 29002, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2240760, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1319906, "avg_legality_checks": 119991.45454545454, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10756, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1319906, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10756, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4693328, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 426666.1818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8603141526, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1833.0578058895521, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35881, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3261.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 305506010, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8514.42295365235, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10756, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 99377404, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17594, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 163047049, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7386, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41708774, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 145, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1372783, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 202202, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18382.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1901621887, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9404.565172451312, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 306174, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27834.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1017287546, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3322.5797944959404, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2972353362, "stage_ordering_ns": 818731142, "stage_eval_ns": 3770819589, "stage_threat_ns": 6618386841, "stage_proof_ns": 117964156, "tactical_annotations": 693691, "root_tactical_annotations": 2456, "search_tactical_annotations": 691235, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 320191, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1837256670, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 815483, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4456826337, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60090, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1970592519, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 160090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 226130303, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7730, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 36966743, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 320180, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37962248, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 222006, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1045005232, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 306696, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1284997935, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 164989, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23244540, "child_limit_applications": 29002, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29002, "child_cap_hits": 29002, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29002, "child_moves_before_total": 2230004, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2230004, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 511864, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 511864, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.89138680091028, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.64926556789187, "tt_hits": 11714, "tt_cutoffs": 1687, "beta_cutoffs": 20891, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3549.6363636363635, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4248.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1869, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 326, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7859, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 81, 65, 129, 145, 80, 79, 127, 93, 51, 108, 109, 63, 47, 78, 48, 123 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7821, "avg_search_time_ms": 782.1, "search_nodes": 98436, "safety_nodes": 228, "corridor_nodes": 903, "corridor_branch_probes": 1050, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 308, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 887, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 887, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 308, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 422, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 53783680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 99567, "avg_nodes": 9956.7, "eval_calls": 76309, "avg_eval_calls": 7630.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 76309, "pattern_eval_ns": 1582249, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.734762609914952, "pattern_frame_queries": 76309, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1582249, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.734762609914952, "pattern_frame_updates": 196788, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2107201298, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10707.976594101267, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20861, "avg_candidate_generations": 2086.1, "candidate_moves_total": 1600349, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.71487464646948, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 638, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 20851, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1599711, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 575429, "avg_legality_checks": 57542.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 226, "root_legality_checks": 638, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 574791, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 225, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2138583, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 213858.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4530619486, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2118.5146828530856, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19774, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1977.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 77357180, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3912.0653383230506, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 624, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3034337, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10702, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 58078786, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8330, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15731105, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 118, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 512952, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48823, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4882.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 401135652, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8216.12051696946, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 62877, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6287.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 166707030, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2651.319719452264, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1376921091, "stage_ordering_ns": 618754456, "stage_eval_ns": 2108783547, "stage_threat_ns": 3470229948, "stage_proof_ns": 212142793, "tactical_annotations": 312158, "root_tactical_annotations": 1929, "search_tactical_annotations": 310229, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 198684, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1122708636, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 336975, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2166057231, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42409, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1443714207, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 99337, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 138305189, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1886, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9887251, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 198674, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23541482, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 89610, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 75765696, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 143400, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 509562006, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79148, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9730159, "child_limit_applications": 20851, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20851, "child_cap_hits": 20851, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20851, "child_moves_before_total": 1599486, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1599486, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 333667, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 333667, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.71027768452352, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002445925854875, "tt_hits": 9140, "tt_cutoffs": 1234, "beta_cutoffs": 15826, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4608.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5408.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1258, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 820, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 887, "avg_nodes": 98.55555555555556, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 45490, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 784.3103448275862, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 580, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10442, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1160.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20970305, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2008.2651790844666, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.1111111111111112, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61280, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6128.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61280, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3640, "stage_ordering_ns": 440, "stage_eval_ns": 45490, "stage_threat_ns": 16673153, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16385801, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 188472, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9641, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 83990, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14890, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 327, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9724, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 115, 116, 129, 95, 143, 63, 79, 101, 157, 171, 128, 86, 158, 173, 131, 97, 130, 132, 94, 99, 100, 96 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 46, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.8333333333333335, "search_nodes": 340, "safety_nodes": 1033, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1373, "avg_nodes": 114.41666666666667, "eval_calls": 328, "avg_eval_calls": 27.333333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 328, "line_shape_eval_ns": 268760, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 819.390243902439, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 937, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.08333333333333, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 937, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 937, "avg_legality_checks": 78.08333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 937, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15196, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1266.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30712173, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2021.0695577783627, "renju_forbidden_checks": 88, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7.333333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 987596, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11222.681818181818, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 194450, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 71, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 793146, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 646943, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11980.425925925925, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 79, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.583333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 364293, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4611.303797468355, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2481531, "stage_ordering_ns": 550, "stage_eval_ns": 268760, "stage_threat_ns": 26379051, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 668, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 25017204, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 824394, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 328, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 456482, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 656, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 80971, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9667, "avg_search_time_ms": 805.5833333333334, "search_nodes": 67433, "safety_nodes": 782, "corridor_nodes": 656, "corridor_branch_probes": 814, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 237, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_plies_followed": 646, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 646, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 32, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 22, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 237, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 32, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 163, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 39080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 68871, "avg_nodes": 5739.25, "eval_calls": 47907, "avg_eval_calls": 3992.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47907, "pattern_eval_ns": 1010487, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.092679566660404, "pattern_frame_queries": 47907, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1010487, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.092679566660404, "pattern_frame_updates": 134758, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1775753727, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13177.352936374835, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18092, "avg_candidate_generations": 1507.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1687081, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.25011054609772, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 949, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 18080, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1686132, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1225127, "avg_legality_checks": 102093.91666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 29302, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1225127, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 29302, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3000059, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 250004.91666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5970247143, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1990.043243482878, "renju_forbidden_checks": 72079, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6006.583333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 700743718, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9721.884571095603, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 29959, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 311548630, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25217, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 283593467, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16748, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 103910244, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 155, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1691377, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 136263, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11355.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1465708156, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10756.464748317592, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 202264, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16855.333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 773700944, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3825.203417315983, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3134886484, "stage_ordering_ns": 642603049, "stage_eval_ns": 1776764214, "stage_threat_ns": 4008876516, "stage_proof_ns": 48446942, "tactical_annotations": 377634, "root_tactical_annotations": 1576, "search_tactical_annotations": 376058, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136126, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 804835675, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 383627, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3069141684, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36636, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1302057018, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68057, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99558612, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1356, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8492227, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136114, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16557915, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 132856, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 754979376, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 172250, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 980102548, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 72528, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10290403, "child_limit_applications": 18080, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18080, "child_cap_hits": 18080, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18080, "child_moves_before_total": 1656830, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1656830, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 292520, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 292520, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.63882743362832, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.17920353982301, "tt_hits": 7121, "tt_cutoffs": 1392, "beta_cutoffs": 14965, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5730.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6397.416666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1860, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 328, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12021, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 115, 128, 158, 144, 96, 100, 142, 129, 99, 97, 81, 145, 161, 174, 159, 160, 176, 146, 147, 132, 118, 188 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 11972, "avg_search_time_ms": 920.9230769230769, "search_nodes": 131778, "safety_nodes": 742, "corridor_nodes": 6770, "corridor_branch_probes": 7112, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2905, "corridor_neutral_exits": 46, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 6726, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6726, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 125, "corridor_proof_active": 44, "corridor_proof_quiet": 81, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 46, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2905, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 125, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 122, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1010, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 81205920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1990240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 139290, "avg_nodes": 10714.615384615385, "eval_calls": 106108, "avg_eval_calls": 8162.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 106108, "pattern_eval_ns": 2163535, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.38993289855619, "pattern_frame_queries": 106108, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2163535, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.38993289855619, "pattern_frame_updates": 263442, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2944537054, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11177.173928227086, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24616, "avg_candidate_generations": 1893.5384615384614, "candidate_moves_total": 1778771, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.2607653558661, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 785, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 24603, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1777986, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 724291, "avg_legality_checks": 55714.692307692305, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1485, "root_legality_checks": 785, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 723506, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1484, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3389627, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 260740.53846153847, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7188021333, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2120.5936030719604, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22880, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1760.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 128989726, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5637.66284965035, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1587, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16302625, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11661, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 89646958, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8964, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20031652, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 668, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3008491, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 77366, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5951.2307692307695, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 661852022, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8554.817645994364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 100036, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7695.076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 282265536, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2821.6395697548883, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1763619831, "stage_ordering_ns": 749757908, "stage_eval_ns": 2946700589, "stage_threat_ns": 5558524996, "stage_proof_ns": 911711372, "tactical_annotations": 298440, "root_tactical_annotations": 2027, "search_tactical_annotations": 296413, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 277157, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1641995384, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 673690, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3599121990, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53309, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2011168082, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 138572, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 198510759, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 13702, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 77990749, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 277144, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33368593, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70209, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 123243703, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 160041, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 686764028, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 68190, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7537521, "child_limit_applications": 24603, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24603, "child_cap_hits": 24603, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24603, "child_moves_before_total": 1776502, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1776502, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 393997, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 393997, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.20672275738731, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.014185261959923, "tt_hits": 9755, "tt_cutoffs": 1010, "beta_cutoffs": 17643, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4007.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4622.538461538462, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1035, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1666666666666665, "search_nodes": 129, "safety_nodes": 876, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1005, "avg_nodes": 83.75, "eval_calls": 117, "avg_eval_calls": 9.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 117, "line_shape_eval_ns": 89380, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 763.9316239316239, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 717, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.75, "candidate_moves_max": 75, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 717, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13604, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1133.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26954974, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1981.4006174654514, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.3333333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 47260, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11815.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 47260, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5140, "stage_ordering_ns": 560, "stage_eval_ns": 89380, "stage_threat_ns": 22190935, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 246, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21748413, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 242312, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 117, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 170440, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 234, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29770, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 329, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9120, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 157, 172, 141, 83, 125, 55, 69, 173, 109, 93, 126, 174, 124, 123, 171, 113, 156, 186, 68, 143, 158, 98 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 46, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.8333333333333335, "search_nodes": 340, "safety_nodes": 1033, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1373, "avg_nodes": 114.41666666666667, "eval_calls": 328, "avg_eval_calls": 27.333333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 328, "line_shape_eval_ns": 272043, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 829.3993902439024, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 937, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.08333333333333, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 937, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 937, "avg_legality_checks": 78.08333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 937, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15196, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1266.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30777960, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2025.3987891550407, "renju_forbidden_checks": 88, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7.333333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1062303, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12071.625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 205682, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 71, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 856621, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 643033, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11908.018518518518, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 79, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.583333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 365300, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4624.050632911392, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2502430, "stage_ordering_ns": 570, "stage_eval_ns": 272043, "stage_threat_ns": 26429728, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 668, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 25077954, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 819453, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 328, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 451381, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 656, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 80940, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9063, "avg_search_time_ms": 755.25, "search_nodes": 69631, "safety_nodes": 782, "corridor_nodes": 639, "corridor_branch_probes": 782, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 230, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_plies_followed": 629, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 629, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 32, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 22, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 230, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 32, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 163, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 36360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 71052, "avg_nodes": 5921.0, "eval_calls": 50166, "avg_eval_calls": 4180.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50166, "pattern_eval_ns": 1047126, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.87322090659012, "pattern_frame_queries": 50166, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1047126, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.87322090659012, "pattern_frame_updates": 139154, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1759983217, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12647.737161705736, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18010, "avg_candidate_generations": 1500.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1638497, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.97706829539145, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 949, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 17998, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1637548, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1112639, "avg_legality_checks": 92719.91666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 22258, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1112639, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 22258, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2814426, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 234535.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5464142899, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1941.4768407483443, "renju_forbidden_checks": 61176, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5098.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 686860461, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11227.61313260102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22933, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 298303713, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23528, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 281506644, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14560, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 105231686, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 155, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1818418, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 124547, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10378.916666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1264282329, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10151.046022786579, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 183511, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15292.583333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 665116511, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3624.3958727269755, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2786081330, "stage_ordering_ns": 620528094, "stage_eval_ns": 1761030343, "stage_threat_ns": 3794409216, "stage_proof_ns": 48758130, "tactical_annotations": 361767, "root_tactical_annotations": 1576, "search_tactical_annotations": 360191, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 140488, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 819997541, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 360853, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2837019845, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36464, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1303716671, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70238, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 101010672, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1322, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8365176, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 140476, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17099825, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 125679, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 684739302, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 157875, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 816612158, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78213, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10916157, "child_limit_applications": 17998, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17998, "child_cap_hits": 17998, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17998, "child_moves_before_total": 1615290, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1615290, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 293572, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 293572, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.74830536726303, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.311367929769975, "tt_hits": 7262, "tt_cutoffs": 1413, "beta_cutoffs": 14780, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5708.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6374.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1635, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 330, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9962, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 97, 127, 126, 143, 159, 95, 79, 113, 158, 98, 83, 110, 157, 156, 144, 96, 174, 190, 129, 114, 189 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9917, "avg_search_time_ms": 901.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 118398, "safety_nodes": 416, "corridor_nodes": 784, "corridor_branch_probes": 893, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 325, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 773, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 773, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 325, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 417, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23910560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1988560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 119598, "avg_nodes": 10872.545454545454, "eval_calls": 93615, "avg_eval_calls": 8510.454545454546, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 93615, "pattern_eval_ns": 1927259, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.587074720931476, "pattern_frame_queries": 93615, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1927259, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.587074720931476, "pattern_frame_updates": 236702, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2864093972, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12099.999036763526, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23192, "avg_candidate_generations": 2108.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 1676187, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.27436184891341, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 681, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 23181, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1675506, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 770824, "avg_legality_checks": 70074.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 260, "root_legality_checks": 681, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 770143, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 260, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2760026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 250911.45454545456, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5947880813, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2155.008979263239, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15693, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1426.6363636363637, "renju_forbidden_ns": 45045202, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2870.4009430956476, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 332, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1579100, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7320, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32965895, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8005, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10425387, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 36, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 74820, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 69976, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6361.454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 593249073, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8477.89346347319, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 96013, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8728.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 249046128, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2593.879245518836, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1873873208, "stage_ordering_ns": 696029059, "stage_eval_ns": 2866021231, "stage_threat_ns": 4263242540, "stage_proof_ns": 181218266, "tactical_annotations": 328583, "root_tactical_annotations": 1561, "search_tactical_annotations": 327022, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 238369, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1378610045, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 359284, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2668240017, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46980, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1724021888, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 119179, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 170615612, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1656, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8637555, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 238358, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28851936, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 82962, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 117414744, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 182599, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 726978493, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 63022, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8287375, "child_limit_applications": 23181, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23181, "child_cap_hits": 23181, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23181, "child_moves_before_total": 1675246, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1675246, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 371152, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 371152, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.26806436305596, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.011043527026445, "tt_hits": 7938, "tt_cutoffs": 1556, "beta_cutoffs": 17023, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4598.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5325.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 34, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4, "search_nodes": 254, "safety_nodes": 635, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 889, "avg_nodes": 88.9, "eval_calls": 244, "avg_eval_calls": 24.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 244, "line_shape_eval_ns": 216670, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 887.9918032786885, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 628, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.8, "candidate_moves_max": 80, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 628, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11593, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23421290, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2020.2958681963253, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4080, "stage_ordering_ns": 520, "stage_eval_ns": 216670, "stage_threat_ns": 20781727, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 498, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20210225, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 168961, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10670, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 244, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 341981, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 488, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60560, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 331, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16870, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 109, 108, 95, 129, 81, 145, 161, 123, 67, 53, 96, 138, 66, 51, 93, 52, 94, 92, 50, 153, 168, 54, 55, 124, 80, 65, 64, 128, 48 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 59, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.6875, "search_nodes": 360, "safety_nodes": 1703, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2063, "avg_nodes": 128.9375, "eval_calls": 344, "avg_eval_calls": 21.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 344, "line_shape_eval_ns": 302340, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 878.8953488372093, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1398, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.375, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1398, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1398, "avg_legality_checks": 87.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 1398, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20523, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1282.6875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 40144669, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1956.0819081031038, "renju_forbidden_checks": 165, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.3125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2057146, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12467.551515151516, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 413781, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 135, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1643365, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.8125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1028055, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11054.354838709678, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 546851, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3991.6131386861316, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3714397, "stage_ordering_ns": 730, "stage_eval_ns": 302340, "stage_threat_ns": 33507378, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 704, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 31612589, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1323506, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15690, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 486593, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 84690, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 16, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 16, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6747.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7247.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 16796, "avg_search_time_ms": 1119.7333333333333, "search_nodes": 107266, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 420, "corridor_branch_probes": 523, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 106, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 30, "corridor_plies_followed": 410, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 410, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 32, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 22, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 106, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 32, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 28, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 160, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 27920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 108602, "avg_nodes": 7240.133333333333, "eval_calls": 72859, "avg_eval_calls": 4857.266666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72859, "pattern_eval_ns": 1513607, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.77446849394035, "pattern_frame_queries": 72859, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1513607, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.77446849394035, "pattern_frame_updates": 214390, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2878308845, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13425.574163906898, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31621, "avg_candidate_generations": 2108.0666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 3259446, "avg_candidate_moves": 103.07852376585181, "candidate_moves_max": 139, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1313, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 31606, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3258133, "search_candidate_moves_max": 139, "legality_checks": 2539075, "avg_legality_checks": 169271.66666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 41815, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2539075, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 41815, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5924036, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 394935.73333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10320414307, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1742.1255216882544, "renju_forbidden_checks": 189497, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12633.133333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1622534806, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8562.324501179439, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 50426, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 620748749, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 42295, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 536960003, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 96554, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 461814088, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 222, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3011966, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 293506, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19567.066666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2933867078, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9995.935612900588, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 454730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 30315.333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1552098435, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3413.2307853011675, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5805757114, "stage_ordering_ns": 1063709133, "stage_eval_ns": 2879822452, "stage_threat_ns": 6893824480, "stage_proof_ns": 51618913, "tactical_annotations": 823435, "root_tactical_annotations": 2933, "search_tactical_annotations": 820502, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 215289, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1201951500, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 712619, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5483701397, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 63631, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2040390372, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 107637, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 150902199, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 884, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4862632, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 215274, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24619273, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 287476, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1515009362, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 330431, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1906490812, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 205528, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 27787479, "child_limit_applications": 31606, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31606, "child_cap_hits": 31606, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31606, "child_moves_before_total": 3216318, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3216318, "child_moves_before_max": 138, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 138, "child_moves_after_total": 545436, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 545436, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 101.7628931215592, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.257356198190216, "tt_hits": 14860, "tt_cutoffs": 2731, "beta_cutoffs": 26876, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6049.533333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6582.866666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1883, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 332, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 36196, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 129, 109, 95, 81, 65, 125, 127, 79, 80, 50, 64, 96, 66, 63, 94, 108, 143, 159, 157, 115, 142, 172, 141, 140, 156, 171, 170, 128, 154, 158, 184, 198, 186, 138, 183, 187, 169, 155, 139, 124, 199 ], "move_count": 47, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 36122, "avg_search_time_ms": 1641.909090909091, "search_nodes": 494042, "safety_nodes": 287, "corridor_nodes": 56485, "corridor_branch_probes": 57670, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 34223, "corridor_neutral_exits": 125, "corridor_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_plies_followed": 56389, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 56389, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 20, "corridor_proof_completed": 20, "corridor_proof_checks": 265, "corridor_proof_active": 96, "corridor_proof_quiet": 169, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 125, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 34223, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 265, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 261, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 2194, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 241728000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1991040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 550814, "avg_nodes": 25037.0, "eval_calls": 401278, "avg_eval_calls": 18239.909090909092, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 401278, "pattern_eval_ns": 7766717, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.354953423810922, "pattern_frame_queries": 401278, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7766717, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.354953423810922, "pattern_frame_updates": 987880, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8708731970, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8815.576760335263, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 88269, "avg_candidate_generations": 4012.2272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 7869964, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.15886664627446, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1708, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 88247, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7868256, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 3030740, "avg_legality_checks": 137760.9090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2761, "root_legality_checks": 1708, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 3029032, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2760, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14383233, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 653783.3181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21213295990, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1474.8628482900888, "renju_forbidden_checks": 73547, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3343.0454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 157010873, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2134.837219737039, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4149, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9478595, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34855, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 103931173, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32278, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40296236, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2265, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3304869, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 378482, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17203.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1992998084, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5265.767154052241, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 461076, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20958.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 736284796, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1596.8838022365076, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5241192329, "stage_ordering_ns": 2201683953, "stage_eval_ns": 8716498687, "stage_threat_ns": 17249354982, "stage_proof_ns": 2538802495, "tactical_annotations": 1969198, "root_tactical_annotations": 7591, "search_tactical_annotations": 1961607, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1101210, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5294886947, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3813748, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10596843110, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 198885, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4812856432, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 550594, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 655804970, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 113308, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 546606928, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1101188, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 105046388, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 751344, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 626172873, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 801587, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1877776439, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 416267, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 50166639, "child_limit_applications": 88247, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 88247, "child_cap_hits": 88247, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 88247, "child_moves_before_total": 7865496, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7865496, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 1413893, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1413893, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.13046335852776, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02199508198579, "tt_hits": 37101, "tt_cutoffs": 4415, "beta_cutoffs": 61914, "depth_sum": 102, "avg_depth": 4.636363636363637, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 102, "avg_effective_depth": 4.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4160.681818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4523.318181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1049, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 52, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.4761904761904763, "search_nodes": 251, "safety_nodes": 2332, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2583, "avg_nodes": 123.0, "eval_calls": 230, "avg_eval_calls": 10.952380952380953, "line_shape_eval_calls": 230, "line_shape_eval_ns": 218311, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 949.1782608695652, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1632, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.71428571428571, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1632, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23822, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1134.3809523809523, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 38957861, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1635.373226429351, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.19047619047619047, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4790, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1197.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4790, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10470, "stage_ordering_ns": 1080, "stage_eval_ns": 218311, "stage_threat_ns": 32502138, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 481, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 31792246, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 57, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 403071, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 261151, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45670, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 21, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 21, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7046.238095238095, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7427.190476190476, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 333, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9472, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 67, 52, 83, 141, 99, 155, 169, 51, 115, 131, 98, 50, 100, 101, 53, 66, 68, 38, 111, 80, 24, 94 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0, "search_nodes": 342, "safety_nodes": 1028, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1370, "avg_nodes": 114.16666666666667, "eval_calls": 330, "avg_eval_calls": 27.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 330, "line_shape_eval_ns": 219020, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 663.6969696969697, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 931, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.58333333333333, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 931, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 931, "avg_legality_checks": 77.58333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 931, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15208, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1267.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24733731, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1626.3631641241452, "renju_forbidden_checks": 82, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6.833333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 952496, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11615.80487804878, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 190942, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 66, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 761554, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.833333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 620825, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10703.879310344828, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 83, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.916666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 344142, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4146.289156626506, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2147318, "stage_ordering_ns": 640, "stage_eval_ns": 219020, "stage_threat_ns": 21240583, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 672, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19991897, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 819215, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9650, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 365661, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 660, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63810, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6331.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6998.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9424, "avg_search_time_ms": 785.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 70629, "safety_nodes": 983, "corridor_nodes": 746, "corridor_branch_probes": 914, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 292, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 735, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 735, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 34, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 23, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 292, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 34, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 177, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 40880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 72358, "avg_nodes": 6029.833333333333, "eval_calls": 49323, "avg_eval_calls": 4110.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49323, "pattern_eval_ns": 1020520, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.690550047645115, "pattern_frame_queries": 49323, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1020520, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.690550047645115, "pattern_frame_updates": 141150, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1661996075, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11774.679950407368, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19681, "avg_candidate_generations": 1640.0833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1831695, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.06920380061989, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 953, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 19669, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1830742, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1378577, "avg_legality_checks": 114881.41666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 36226, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1378577, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 36226, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3363053, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 280254.4166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5738050983, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1706.202959929564, "renju_forbidden_checks": 85390, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7115.833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 893497580, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10463.726197447008, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 36711, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 392219816, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28683, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 342147525, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19815, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 157055701, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 181, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2074538, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 160782, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13398.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1543463948, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9599.730989787415, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 235208, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19600.666666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 828411014, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3522.0358746301144, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3188150886, "stage_ordering_ns": 604506144, "stage_eval_ns": 1663016595, "stage_threat_ns": 3856354662, "stage_proof_ns": 33897886, "tactical_annotations": 409862, "root_tactical_annotations": 1306, "search_tactical_annotations": 408556, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 142700, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 692624469, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 425133, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3042678865, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 39858, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1191182290, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 71344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87815620, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1538, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8762109, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 142688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14624423, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 133917, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 695439796, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 205952, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1126186473, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 69993, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9849176, "child_limit_applications": 19669, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19669, "child_cap_hits": 19669, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19669, "child_moves_before_total": 1794516, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1794516, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 319201, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 319201, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.2357516904774, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.2286338908943, "tt_hits": 7057, "tt_cutoffs": 1584, "beta_cutoffs": 16442, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 4.416666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 4.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5787.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6454.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1923, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 334, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23442, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 84, 97, 98, 70, 114, 66, 81, 80, 129, 99, 130, 146, 131, 132, 127, 128, 115, 147, 143, 101, 159, 111, 160, 175, 157, 171, 158, 161, 156 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 23391, "avg_search_time_ms": 1559.4, "search_nodes": 323842, "safety_nodes": 96, "corridor_nodes": 8307, "corridor_branch_probes": 8759, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3682, "corridor_neutral_exits": 132, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 8247, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8247, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 163, "corridor_proof_active": 60, "corridor_proof_quiet": 103, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 132, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3682, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 163, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 160, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1363, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 144903920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 332245, "avg_nodes": 22149.666666666668, "eval_calls": 265446, "avg_eval_calls": 17696.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 265446, "pattern_eval_ns": 5213025, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.63874008272869, "pattern_frame_queries": 265446, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5213025, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.63874008272869, "pattern_frame_updates": 647550, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7132313559, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11014.305550150568, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 55690, "avg_candidate_generations": 3712.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 4625961, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.06627760818819, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1082, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 55675, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4624879, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 1916368, "avg_legality_checks": 127757.86666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3589, "root_legality_checks": 1082, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1915286, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3588, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7782300, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 518820.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13709824320, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1761.667414517559, "renju_forbidden_checks": 116890, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7792.666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 386120815, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3303.283557190521, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5507, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25645656, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 68645, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 282646849, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 41504, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 73975416, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1234, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3852894, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 216117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14407.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1497377671, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6928.551067245982, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 275139, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18342.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 579659461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2106.787700035255, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3718679529, "stage_ordering_ns": 1464274303, "stage_eval_ns": 7137526584, "stage_threat_ns": 10058492220, "stage_proof_ns": 912719779, "tactical_annotations": 1097225, "root_tactical_annotations": 4538, "search_tactical_annotations": 1092687, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 664385, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3257011764, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1449092, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6189274909, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 116256, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3240207939, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 332185, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 414902587, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 16820, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 97139911, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 664370, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 70237816, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 377972, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 442962570, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 488749, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1571433020, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 230504, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 29925233, "child_limit_applications": 55675, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 55675, "child_cap_hits": 55675, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 55675, "child_moves_before_total": 4621291, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4621291, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 900101, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 900101, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.00477772788504, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.167058823529413, "tt_hits": 21825, "tt_cutoffs": 2654, "beta_cutoffs": 38475, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3034.9333333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3483.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 407, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 37, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.642857142857143, "search_nodes": 163, "safety_nodes": 1407, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1570, "avg_nodes": 112.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 149, "avg_eval_calls": 10.642857142857142, "line_shape_eval_calls": 149, "line_shape_eval_ns": 166141, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1115.0402684563758, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1005, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.78571428571429, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1005, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16149, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1153.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27538262, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1705.2611307201685, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 55340, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3952.8571428571427, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55340, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6370, "stage_ordering_ns": 720, "stage_eval_ns": 166141, "stage_threat_ns": 22979679, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 312, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22450576, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 284791, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12440, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 149, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 208112, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 298, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36200, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6569.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7140.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 335, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10948, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 109, 108, 125, 99, 141, 71, 85, 93, 157, 173, 126, 78, 156, 171, 123, 94, 124, 122, 97, 80, 66, 136 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 46, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.8333333333333335, "search_nodes": 342, "safety_nodes": 1035, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1377, "avg_nodes": 114.75, "eval_calls": 330, "avg_eval_calls": 27.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 330, "line_shape_eval_ns": 280092, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 848.7636363636364, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 938, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.16666666666667, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 938, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 938, "avg_legality_checks": 78.16666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 938, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15227, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1268.9166666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30636640, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2011.9944834832863, "renju_forbidden_checks": 82, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6.833333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 883476, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10774.09756097561, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 174011, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 66, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 709465, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.833333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 653072, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11259.862068965518, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 83, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.916666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 350402, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4221.710843373494, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2459672, "stage_ordering_ns": 660, "stage_eval_ns": 280092, "stage_threat_ns": 26254583, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 672, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24862085, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 855243, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 455974, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 660, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 81281, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10891, "avg_search_time_ms": 907.5833333333334, "search_nodes": 71315, "safety_nodes": 984, "corridor_nodes": 789, "corridor_branch_probes": 969, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 306, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 779, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 779, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 33, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 23, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 306, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 33, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 30, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 167, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 5400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 73088, "avg_nodes": 6090.666666666667, "eval_calls": 49580, "avg_eval_calls": 4131.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49580, "pattern_eval_ns": 1034791, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.871137555465914, "pattern_frame_queries": 49580, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1034791, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.871137555465914, "pattern_frame_updates": 142522, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1886273036, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13234.960469260886, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20133, "avg_candidate_generations": 1677.75, "candidate_moves_total": 1884276, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.59141707644166, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 954, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 20121, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1883322, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1414128, "avg_legality_checks": 117844.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 37447, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1414128, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 37447, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3421698, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 285141.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6780905783, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1981.7370741076506, "renju_forbidden_checks": 80229, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6685.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 813450328, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10139.10590933453, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 37665, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 405260386, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25827, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 295472462, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16574, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 110955804, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 163, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1761676, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 161468, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13455.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1716671572, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10631.65191864642, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 234878, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19573.166666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 901130171, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3836.5882330401314, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3659888033, "stage_ordering_ns": 723093746, "stage_eval_ns": 1887307827, "stage_threat_ns": 4509055314, "stage_proof_ns": 48605766, "tactical_annotations": 413490, "root_tactical_annotations": 1306, "search_tactical_annotations": 412184, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 144158, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 851170880, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 429658, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3514630378, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40790, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1444998783, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72073, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104720238, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1624, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10039145, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 144146, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17336238, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 134599, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 797181700, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 206125, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1237235907, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 72766, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11158435, "child_limit_applications": 20121, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20121, "child_cap_hits": 20121, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20121, "child_moves_before_total": 1845875, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1845875, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 326502, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 326502, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.73873067938969, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.22692709109885, "tt_hits": 7260, "tt_cutoffs": 1560, "beta_cutoffs": 16865, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5530.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6197.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1868, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 336, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9610, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 141, 109, 126, 156, 140, 98, 139, 142, 153, 97, 125, 167, 95, 155, 80 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9576, "avg_search_time_ms": 1064.0, "search_nodes": 117705, "safety_nodes": 336, "corridor_nodes": 1359, "corridor_branch_probes": 1624, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 443, "corridor_neutral_exits": 35, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 1334, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1334, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 58, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 35, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 443, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 81, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 684, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 61310960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1984800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 119400, "avg_nodes": 13266.666666666666, "eval_calls": 95710, "avg_eval_calls": 10634.444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 95710, "pattern_eval_ns": 1968039, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.56252220248668, "pattern_frame_queries": 95710, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1968039, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.56252220248668, "pattern_frame_updates": 235336, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2694960923, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11451.54554764252, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21140, "avg_candidate_generations": 2348.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 1511695, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.50875118259225, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 516, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 21131, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1511179, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 696635, "avg_legality_checks": 77403.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2790, "root_legality_checks": 516, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 696119, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2788, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2617836, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 290870.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5600939608, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2139.53036324659, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27556, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3061.777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 162040573, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5880.409820002903, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2895, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 29076225, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13641, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 104169338, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10617, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25954493, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 403, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2840517, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68064, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7562.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 598321909, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8790.578117653973, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89376, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9930.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 261167280, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2922.1186895810956, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1706114699, "stage_ordering_ns": 647872981, "stage_eval_ns": 2696928962, "stage_threat_ns": 4171680314, "stage_proof_ns": 319764841, "tactical_annotations": 227476, "root_tactical_annotations": 1595, "search_tactical_annotations": 225881, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 238179, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1364414747, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 317053, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2588219490, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43299, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1612283260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 119085, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 168510212, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2834, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15502953, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 238170, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28523516, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 41188, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 98235121, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 137916, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 678474002, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 48372, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6509396, "child_limit_applications": 21131, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21131, "child_cap_hits": 21131, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21131, "child_moves_before_total": 1508391, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1508391, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 338159, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 338159, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.38284984146514, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002981401732054, "tt_hits": 7808, "tt_cutoffs": 827, "beta_cutoffs": 14825, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2547.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3436.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1057, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.25, "search_nodes": 121, "safety_nodes": 567, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 688, "avg_nodes": 86.0, "eval_calls": 113, "avg_eval_calls": 14.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 113, "line_shape_eval_ns": 79252, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 701.3451327433628, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 456, "avg_candidate_moves": 57.0, "candidate_moves_max": 71, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 456, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9133, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1141.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18264651, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1999.8522938793387, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 84131, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10516.375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 84131, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3260, "stage_ordering_ns": 390, "stage_eval_ns": 79252, "stage_threat_ns": 15434134, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 234, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15072571, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 169072, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 113, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 163301, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 226, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29190, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 337, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9520, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 115, 116, 99, 125, 83, 139, 153, 131, 67, 51, 98, 146, 68, 53, 101, 127, 100, 102, 126, 130, 84, 129 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 47, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.9166666666666665, "search_nodes": 344, "safety_nodes": 1121, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1465, "avg_nodes": 122.08333333333333, "eval_calls": 332, "avg_eval_calls": 27.666666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 332, "line_shape_eval_ns": 278612, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 839.1927710843373, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 929, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.41666666666667, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 929, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 929, "avg_legality_checks": 77.41666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 929, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15243, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1270.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30354025, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1991.3419274421046, "renju_forbidden_checks": 94, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7.833333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1098714, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11688.446808510638, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 209891, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 77, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 888823, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 753983, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11780.984375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.166666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 412162, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4205.734693877551, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2451464, "stage_ordering_ns": 590, "stage_eval_ns": 278612, "stage_threat_ns": 26734801, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 676, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 25235555, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 959864, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12001, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 332, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 457510, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 664, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 81872, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9464, "avg_search_time_ms": 788.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 63703, "safety_nodes": 978, "corridor_nodes": 853, "corridor_branch_probes": 1031, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 324, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 841, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 841, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 33, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 21, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 324, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 33, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 30, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 167, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 33200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 65534, "avg_nodes": 5461.166666666667, "eval_calls": 45325, "avg_eval_calls": 3777.0833333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 45325, "pattern_eval_ns": 944744, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.84377275234418, "pattern_frame_queries": 45325, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 944744, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.84377275234418, "pattern_frame_updates": 127302, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1868782027, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14679.910975475641, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17007, "avg_candidate_generations": 1417.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1572212, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.44499323807844, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 948, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 16995, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1571264, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1111767, "avg_legality_checks": 92647.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 23416, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1111767, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 23416, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2826910, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 235575.83333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5582368052, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1974.7243640582826, "renju_forbidden_checks": 78951, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6579.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1094570645, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 13863.923762840242, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25884, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 394165959, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26128, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 389459471, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26782, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 309102186, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 157, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1843029, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 130944, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10912.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1505441147, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11496.831828873412, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 190221, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15851.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 790394723, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4155.139143417394, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2932437414, "stage_ordering_ns": 590029468, "stage_eval_ns": 1869726771, "stage_threat_ns": 3971304622, "stage_proof_ns": 47704699, "tactical_annotations": 369118, "root_tactical_annotations": 1282, "search_tactical_annotations": 367836, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 129062, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 764028404, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 378438, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3076382322, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34547, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1271791721, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64525, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93561727, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1748, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10618471, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 129050, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15627172, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 119286, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 701950246, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171830, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1062619266, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78002, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11086526, "child_limit_applications": 16995, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16995, "child_cap_hits": 16995, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16995, "child_moves_before_total": 1547848, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1547848, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 279426, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 279426, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.07666960870844, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.441659311562223, "tt_hits": 7014, "tt_cutoffs": 1331, "beta_cutoffs": 14047, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5742.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6409.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1877, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 338, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11253, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 125, 115, 127, 83, 99, 69, 55, 85, 141, 155, 157, 109, 144, 84, 142, 172, 143, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11211, "avg_search_time_ms": 1019.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 147048, "safety_nodes": 496, "corridor_nodes": 838, "corridor_branch_probes": 978, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 280, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 818, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 818, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 80, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 280, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 98, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 821, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 46047440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1993760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 148382, "avg_nodes": 13489.272727272728, "eval_calls": 118032, "avg_eval_calls": 10730.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 118032, "pattern_eval_ns": 2397686, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.313864036871358, "pattern_frame_queries": 118032, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2397686, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.313864036871358, "pattern_frame_updates": 294002, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3045611337, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10359.151764273713, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27620, "avg_candidate_generations": 2510.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 2209705, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.00380159304852, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 754, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 27609, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2208951, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 935923, "avg_legality_checks": 85083.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 325, "root_legality_checks": 754, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 935169, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 325, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3038190, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 276199.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6507775721, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2141.9910278817324, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16269, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1479.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 78542157, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4827.7187903374515, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 427, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3289887, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 59821536, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7576, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15094351, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 126, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 336383, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64900, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5900.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 578183028, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8908.829399075501, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91052, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8277.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 259609425, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2851.2215547159863, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2212140770, "stage_ordering_ns": 884869033, "stage_eval_ns": 3048009023, "stage_threat_ns": 4738801198, "stage_proof_ns": 274482416, "tactical_annotations": 333360, "root_tactical_annotations": 2200, "search_tactical_annotations": 331160, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 295849, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1635257436, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 370635, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2849054110, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56095, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1911440794, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147919, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 199739227, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1836, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10428814, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 295838, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34716837, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 83921, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 131030884, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 173572, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 680369190, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 75867, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9604774, "child_limit_applications": 27609, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27609, "child_cap_hits": 27609, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27609, "child_moves_before_total": 2208626, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2208626, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 441790, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 441790, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.99659531312253, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00166612336557, "tt_hits": 10785, "tt_cutoffs": 1360, "beta_cutoffs": 19843, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3805.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4532.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1060, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 32, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.2, "search_nodes": 130, "safety_nodes": 905, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1035, "avg_nodes": 103.5, "eval_calls": 120, "avg_eval_calls": 12.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 120, "line_shape_eval_ns": 84670, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 705.5833333333334, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 684, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.4, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 684, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11721, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1172.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23072750, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1968.4967152973295, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4180, "stage_ordering_ns": 510, "stage_eval_ns": 84670, "stage_threat_ns": 18989333, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 250, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18579052, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 210311, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 120, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 169800, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 240, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30170, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 339, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9923, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 157, 172, 143, 81, 129, 49, 65, 171, 115, 101, 128, 170, 130, 131, 173, 111, 158, 188, 66, 141, 156, 96 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 45, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.75, "search_nodes": 340, "safety_nodes": 1033, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1373, "avg_nodes": 114.41666666666667, "eval_calls": 328, "avg_eval_calls": 27.333333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 328, "line_shape_eval_ns": 272232, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 829.9756097560976, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 937, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.08333333333333, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 937, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 937, "avg_legality_checks": 78.08333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 937, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15196, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1266.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30424526, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2002.1404316925507, "renju_forbidden_checks": 88, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7.333333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1015545, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11540.28409090909, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 202821, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 71, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 812724, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 650273, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12042.092592592593, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 79, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.583333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 367972, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4657.873417721519, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2483473, "stage_ordering_ns": 630, "stage_eval_ns": 272232, "stage_threat_ns": 26070168, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 668, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24721412, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 827834, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12291, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 328, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 439310, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 656, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 81612, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9868, "avg_search_time_ms": 822.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 72260, "safety_nodes": 782, "corridor_nodes": 680, "corridor_branch_probes": 842, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 245, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_plies_followed": 670, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 670, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 32, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 22, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 245, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 32, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 163, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 39080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 73722, "avg_nodes": 6143.5, "eval_calls": 51490, "avg_eval_calls": 4290.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51490, "pattern_eval_ns": 1075678, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.891007962711207, "pattern_frame_queries": 51490, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1075678, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.891007962711207, "pattern_frame_updates": 144412, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1796783798, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12442.067127385535, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19231, "avg_candidate_generations": 1602.5833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1756888, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.35707971504343, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 949, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 19219, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1755939, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1228991, "avg_legality_checks": 102415.91666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 29302, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1228991, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 29302, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3042110, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 253509.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6024502293, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1980.3696424521138, "renju_forbidden_checks": 72503, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6041.916666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 721427233, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9950.308718259934, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 29964, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 320817295, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25564, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 291929405, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16820, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 106927932, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 155, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1752601, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 137130, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11427.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1463603828, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10673.111850069277, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 203303, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16941.916666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 773261825, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3803.4944147405595, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3138079778, "stage_ordering_ns": 669075337, "stage_eval_ns": 1797859476, "stage_threat_ns": 4158317578, "stage_proof_ns": 48102364, "tactical_annotations": 381709, "root_tactical_annotations": 1576, "search_tactical_annotations": 380133, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 145828, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 859281968, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 392001, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3156624592, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38924, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1388998656, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72908, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105458145, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1404, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8723900, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 145816, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18034472, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 134351, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 753962389, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 175271, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 980451331, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 72087, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10194501, "child_limit_applications": 19219, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19219, "child_cap_hits": 19219, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19219, "child_moves_before_total": 1726637, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1726637, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 310741, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 310741, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.84010614496071, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.16842707737135, "tt_hits": 7309, "tt_cutoffs": 1497, "beta_cutoffs": 15903, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5631.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6298.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1645, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 340, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22788, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 97, 127, 128, 141, 155, 99, 85, 111, 156, 96, 81, 114, 154, 157, 170, 184, 138, 122, 185, 200, 153, 152, 168, 123, 125, 140, 167, 166, 169, 171, 137, 201, 121 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 22721, "avg_search_time_ms": 1336.5294117647059, "search_nodes": 263051, "safety_nodes": 609, "corridor_nodes": 7054, "corridor_branch_probes": 8205, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2877, "corridor_neutral_exits": 154, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 7001, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 7001, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 142, "corridor_proof_active": 53, "corridor_proof_quiet": 89, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 154, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2877, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 142, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 141, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1125, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 103379600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 270714, "avg_nodes": 15924.35294117647, "eval_calls": 211048, "avg_eval_calls": 12414.588235294117, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 211048, "pattern_eval_ns": 4311076, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.42699291156514, "pattern_frame_queries": 211048, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4311076, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.42699291156514, "pattern_frame_updates": 525948, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6676866816, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12694.918159209656, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49074, "avg_candidate_generations": 2886.705882352941, "candidate_moves_total": 4257135, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.74929698007091, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1269, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 49057, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4255866, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1688762, "avg_legality_checks": 99338.94117647059, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2553, "root_legality_checks": 1269, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1687493, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2551, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6658905, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 391700.29411764705, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13675244444, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2053.6776608166056, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43470, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2557.0588235294117, "renju_forbidden_ns": 197875606, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4552.003818725558, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2953, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22976497, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20868, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 131607352, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18794, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37151360, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 855, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6140397, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 167123, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9830.764705882353, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1267345936, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7583.312506357593, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 217531, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12795.941176470587, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 528115507, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2427.771246397065, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3937744031, "stage_ordering_ns": 1581849139, "stage_eval_ns": 6681177892, "stage_threat_ns": 9499412073, "stage_proof_ns": 952326984, "tactical_annotations": 898147, "root_tactical_annotations": 3980, "search_tactical_annotations": 894167, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 540251, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3043178108, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1231774, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5873211084, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 102331, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3382515150, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 270117, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 396166634, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 14286, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 100244963, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 540234, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64319670, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 311738, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 316959600, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 414040, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1450914687, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 172369, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22291614, "child_limit_applications": 49057, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49057, "child_cap_hits": 49057, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49057, "child_moves_before_total": 4253315, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4253315, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 789039, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 789039, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.70149010334916, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.084126628208004, "tt_hits": 19527, "tt_cutoffs": 2869, "beta_cutoffs": 35231, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 4.470588235294118, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 4.470588235294118, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5329.058823529412, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5799.64705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 51, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1875, "search_nodes": 203, "safety_nodes": 1652, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1855, "avg_nodes": 115.9375, "eval_calls": 187, "avg_eval_calls": 11.6875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 187, "line_shape_eval_ns": 160512, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 858.3529411764706, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1215, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.9375, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1215, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18390, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1149.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 36277732, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1972.6879825992387, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 72391, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9048.875, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 72391, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7310, "stage_ordering_ns": 860, "stage_eval_ns": 160512, "stage_threat_ns": 29996255, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 390, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 29366953, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 319700, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16730, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 187, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 263152, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 374, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46450, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 16, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 16, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6747.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7247.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 341, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18310, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 67, 52, 81, 143, 95, 159, 175, 53, 109, 123, 96, 54, 94, 93, 51, 108, 66, 36, 78, 55, 56, 138, 153, 68, 80, 79, 64, 128, 48 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 60, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.75, "search_nodes": 360, "safety_nodes": 1703, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2063, "avg_nodes": 128.9375, "eval_calls": 344, "avg_eval_calls": 21.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 344, "line_shape_eval_ns": 304143, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 884.1366279069767, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1398, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.375, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1398, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1398, "avg_legality_checks": 87.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 1398, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20523, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1282.6875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 40668076, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1981.5853432734007, "renju_forbidden_checks": 165, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.3125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2145558, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 13003.381818181819, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 423332, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 135, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1722226, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.8125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1007376, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10832.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 536593, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3916.7372262773724, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3734535, "stage_ordering_ns": 820, "stage_eval_ns": 304143, "stage_threat_ns": 34026618, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 704, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 32168189, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1300217, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 473652, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 84560, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 16, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 16, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6747.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7247.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 18235, "avg_search_time_ms": 1215.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 109265, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 426, "corridor_branch_probes": 530, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 110, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 30, "corridor_plies_followed": 415, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 415, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 32, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 21, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 110, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 32, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 28, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 160, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 5280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 110607, "avg_nodes": 7373.8, "eval_calls": 73907, "avg_eval_calls": 4927.133333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73907, "pattern_eval_ns": 1577272, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.341307318657233, "pattern_frame_queries": 73907, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1577272, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.341307318657233, "pattern_frame_updates": 218388, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3017146309, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13815.531572247559, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32365, "avg_candidate_generations": 2157.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 3286408, "avg_candidate_moves": 101.54203615016222, "candidate_moves_max": 134, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1313, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 32350, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3285095, "search_candidate_moves_max": 134, "legality_checks": 2576943, "avg_legality_checks": 171796.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42453, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2576943, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6032544, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 402169.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11362355715, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1883.5097953699135, "renju_forbidden_checks": 185353, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12356.866666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1687557893, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9104.562068053929, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 50950, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 672939388, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 40654, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 533577448, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 93527, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 477920336, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 222, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3120721, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 301633, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 20108.866666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3268681214, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10836.616729601867, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 465337, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31022.466666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1727003690, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3711.296737633156, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6424015090, "stage_ordering_ns": 1147689701, "stage_eval_ns": 3018723581, "stage_threat_ns": 7486685244, "stage_proof_ns": 51780260, "tactical_annotations": 833302, "root_tactical_annotations": 2933, "search_tactical_annotations": 830369, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 219297, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1266508491, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 723359, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5999883687, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 65119, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2172842765, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 109641, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 158176180, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 894, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5111737, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 219282, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26231191, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 288558, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1651289548, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 338387, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2153115140, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 206357, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30773958, "child_limit_applications": 32350, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32350, "child_cap_hits": 32350, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32350, "child_moves_before_total": 3242642, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3242642, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 557959, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 557959, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 100.236228748068, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.24757341576507, "tt_hits": 15091, "tt_cutoffs": 2938, "beta_cutoffs": 27537, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5839.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6372.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1854, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 342, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16115, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 127, 97, 96, 83, 69, 125, 139, 113, 128, 68, 53, 80, 129, 126, 101, 37, 115, 87, 130, 131, 160, 144, 145, 100, 175 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 16065, "avg_search_time_ms": 1235.7692307692307, "search_nodes": 192530, "safety_nodes": 439, "corridor_nodes": 1422, "corridor_branch_probes": 1636, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 583, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 1404, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1404, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 57, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 39, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 583, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 57, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 419, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 25858560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1983120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 194391, "avg_nodes": 14953.153846153846, "eval_calls": 153703, "avg_eval_calls": 11823.307692307691, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 153703, "pattern_eval_ns": 3125607, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.33536755951413, "pattern_frame_queries": 153703, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3125607, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.33536755951413, "pattern_frame_updates": 384946, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4881521311, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12681.054773916341, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 36179, "avg_candidate_generations": 2783.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3017808, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.41325078083972, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 950, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 36166, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3016858, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1327790, "avg_legality_checks": 102137.69230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 968, "root_legality_checks": 950, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1326840, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 968, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4581776, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 352444.3076923077, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9661325738, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2108.642093808165, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46040, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3541.5384615384614, "renju_forbidden_ns": 154163527, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3348.4693092962643, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1436, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5785433, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26005, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 119631500, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17941, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27535347, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 658, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1211247, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 126839, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9756.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1034406572, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8155.272211228407, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 168835, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12987.307692307691, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 409537078, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2425.6645719193293, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3121225723, "stage_ordering_ns": 1152100360, "stage_eval_ns": 4884646918, "stage_threat_ns": 6585546815, "stage_proof_ns": 253025625, "tactical_annotations": 544108, "root_tactical_annotations": 2691, "search_tactical_annotations": 541417, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 387881, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2187331722, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 597207, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4050937738, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 73277, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2433278156, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 193934, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 269125715, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2922, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17177892, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 387868, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46282640, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 154658, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 232820344, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 284755, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1187066254, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 104695, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14691108, "child_limit_applications": 36166, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 36166, "child_cap_hits": 36166, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 36166, "child_moves_before_total": 3015890, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3015890, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 579496, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 579496, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.39020074102748, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.023226234584968, "tt_hits": 13573, "tt_cutoffs": 2604, "beta_cutoffs": 26162, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4819.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5435.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 39, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.25, "search_nodes": 194, "safety_nodes": 1141, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1335, "avg_nodes": 111.25, "eval_calls": 182, "avg_eval_calls": 15.166666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 182, "line_shape_eval_ns": 142862, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 784.9560439560439, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 891, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.25, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 891, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14015, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1167.9166666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28184645, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2011.0342490189082, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16210, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2701.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 16210, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5300, "stage_ordering_ns": 660, "stage_eval_ns": 142862, "stage_threat_ns": 23602106, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 376, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 23032672, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 260703, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 182, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 262790, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 364, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45941, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 343, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20120, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 126, 70, 56, 69, 114, 100, 110, 94, 127, 125, 156, 170, 141, 111, 174, 158, 129, 130, 144, 159, 143, 145, 140 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 42, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5, "search_nodes": 192, "safety_nodes": 1113, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1305, "avg_nodes": 108.75, "eval_calls": 180, "avg_eval_calls": 15.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 180, "line_shape_eval_ns": 109861, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 610.3388888888888, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 974, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.16666666666667, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 974, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 974, "avg_legality_checks": 81.16666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 974, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15366, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1280.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31445464, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2046.4313419237278, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.3333333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 469301, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11732.525, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 91630, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 377671, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 558633, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11638.1875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 70, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.833333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 314011, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4485.871428571429, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2491241, "stage_ordering_ns": 630, "stage_eval_ns": 109861, "stage_threat_ns": 24606111, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 372, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 23602717, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 709943, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12310, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 248011, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 360, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45440, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 20066, "avg_search_time_ms": 1672.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 176531, "safety_nodes": 257, "corridor_nodes": 3879, "corridor_branch_probes": 4401, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 37, "corridor_depth_exits": 1651, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 3841, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3841, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 86, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 55, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1651, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 86, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 85, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 690, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 79232480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1987280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 180667, "avg_nodes": 15055.583333333334, "eval_calls": 138698, "avg_eval_calls": 11558.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 138698, "pattern_eval_ns": 2891683, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.848772152446323, "pattern_frame_queries": 138698, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2891683, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.848772152446323, "pattern_frame_updates": 352958, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3917234572, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11098.302268258547, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35717, "avg_candidate_generations": 2976.4166666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 3375381, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.50348573508414, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1002, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 35705, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3374379, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 2349215, "avg_legality_checks": 195767.91666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 28396, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2349215, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 28396, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6125991, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 510499.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12233049817, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1996.9095313721486, "renju_forbidden_checks": 143661, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11971.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 941992778, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6557.052909279484, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 28396, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 306816621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28609, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 303133180, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 86458, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 329787216, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 198, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2255761, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 289159, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 24096.583333333332, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3069182567, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10614.169252902382, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 413415, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 34451.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1653996076, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4000.812926478236, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5825942659, "stage_ordering_ns": 1247617283, "stage_eval_ns": 3920126255, "stage_threat_ns": 8855545892, "stage_proof_ns": 119585386, "tactical_annotations": 865405, "root_tactical_annotations": 3589, "search_tactical_annotations": 861816, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 360824, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2108327102, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 979664, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6379265038, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 73541, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2529929632, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 180406, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 256676454, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7854, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 42192452, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 360812, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43674156, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 296998, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1508318961, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 383585, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2163899036, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 184822, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 25410690, "child_limit_applications": 35705, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35705, "child_cap_hits": 35705, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35705, "child_moves_before_total": 3345983, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3345983, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 586436, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 586436, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.7118890911637, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.42447836437474, "tt_hits": 14744, "tt_cutoffs": 2077, "beta_cutoffs": 26696, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1819.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2151.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 344, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17749, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 114, 156, 113, 170, 184, 111, 66, 82, 126, 140, 84, 70, 99, 69, 97, 96, 129, 144, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 17709, "avg_search_time_ms": 1609.909090909091, "search_nodes": 197567, "safety_nodes": 152, "corridor_nodes": 2820, "corridor_branch_probes": 3345, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1132, "corridor_neutral_exits": 22, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 2781, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2781, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 99, "corridor_proof_active": 39, "corridor_proof_quiet": 60, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1132, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 99, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 97, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 819, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 55930560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1990080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 200539, "avg_nodes": 18230.81818181818, "eval_calls": 160236, "avg_eval_calls": 14566.90909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 160236, "pattern_eval_ns": 3273421, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.428748845452958, "pattern_frame_queries": 160236, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3273421, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.428748845452958, "pattern_frame_updates": 395040, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5585745517, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14139.696023187525, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35231, "avg_candidate_generations": 3202.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 3166066, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.86591354205103, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 838, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 35220, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3165228, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 1279129, "avg_legality_checks": 116284.45454545454, "illegal_moves_skipped": 904, "root_legality_checks": 838, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1278291, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 904, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4976163, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 452378.45454545453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10705114567, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2151.2789205257145, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40835, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3712.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 209818548, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5138.203697808252, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1133, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8060424, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23674, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 168583178, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15858, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31808602, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 170, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1366344, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 123116, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11192.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1100087200, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8935.371519542545, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 167027, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15184.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 483619130, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2895.4548067078977, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3018031656, "stage_ordering_ns": 1261818162, "stage_eval_ns": 5589018938, "stage_threat_ns": 7273799756, "stage_proof_ns": 504137772, "tactical_annotations": 543716, "root_tactical_annotations": 3084, "search_tactical_annotations": 540632, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 400811, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2336656552, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 667008, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4559921733, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 72036, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2661056794, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 200400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 281722103, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5760, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 29155961, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 400800, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48757879, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 127087, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 226329943, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 291766, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1229685351, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 124863, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17585528, "child_limit_applications": 35220, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35220, "child_cap_hits": 35220, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35220, "child_moves_before_total": 3164324, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3164324, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 569923, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 569923, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.84452015900057, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.181800113571835, "tt_hits": 14672, "tt_cutoffs": 2064, "beta_cutoffs": 24697, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.5454545454545454, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1452.1818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1849.7272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 329, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1, "search_nodes": 75, "safety_nodes": 1176, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1251, "avg_nodes": 125.1, "eval_calls": 65, "avg_eval_calls": 6.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 65, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44720, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 688.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 772, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.2, "candidate_moves_max": 92, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 772, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11909, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1190.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23727569, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1992.406499286254, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4330, "stage_ordering_ns": 530, "stage_eval_ns": 44720, "stage_threat_ns": 18659763, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 140, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18290382, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 257970, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 65, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94760, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 130, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16651, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 345, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6333, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 144, 160, 97, 95, 65, 142, 158, 81, 113, 78, 94, 79, 82, 77 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5, "search_nodes": 247, "safety_nodes": 431, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 678, "avg_nodes": 84.75, "eval_calls": 239, "avg_eval_calls": 29.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 239, "line_shape_eval_ns": 161632, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 676.2845188284518, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 530, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.25, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 530, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 530, "avg_legality_checks": 66.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 530, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20501850, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2051.826461168935, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 110190, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12243.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 62620, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4472.857142857143, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1342217, "stage_ordering_ns": 390, "stage_eval_ns": 161632, "stage_threat_ns": 17487989, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16909096, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 189240, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 328612, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61041, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6296, "avg_search_time_ms": 787.0, "search_nodes": 79696, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 1026, "corridor_branch_probes": 1238, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 389, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1009, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1009, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 52, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 35, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 389, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 52, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 413, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24039280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1991760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 81251, "avg_nodes": 10156.375, "eval_calls": 64410, "avg_eval_calls": 8051.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64410, "pattern_eval_ns": 1314885, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.41429902189101, "pattern_frame_queries": 64410, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1314885, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.41429902189101, "pattern_frame_updates": 159328, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1319546195, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8281.947899929704, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14427, "avg_candidate_generations": 1803.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1176985, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.58210300131698, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 547, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 14419, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1176438, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 666645, "avg_legality_checks": 83330.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 382, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 666645, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 382, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1775746, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 221968.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3705792822, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2086.893520807593, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3135, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 391.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14609118, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4660.005741626795, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 382, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4320538, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 487, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 4616258, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2229, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5224450, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 447872, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47072, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5884.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 467922141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9940.56213885112, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 73822, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9227.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 231318824, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3133.4673132670478, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1600489338, "stage_ordering_ns": 485490978, "stage_eval_ns": 1320861080, "stage_threat_ns": 2768886327, "stage_proof_ns": 85341982, "tactical_annotations": 213135, "root_tactical_annotations": 1104, "search_tactical_annotations": 212031, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 161458, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 910632607, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 257559, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1709993230, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29534, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1036098966, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 80725, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 111952892, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2122, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10360689, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 161450, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19207949, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 53418, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 219053731, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 108376, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 404121025, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 51341, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6738960, "child_limit_applications": 14419, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14419, "child_cap_hits": 14419, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14419, "child_moves_before_total": 1176056, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1176056, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 230725, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 230725, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.56293779041542, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001456411679033, "tt_hits": 5694, "tt_cutoffs": 835, "beta_cutoffs": 10163, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3792.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4792.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1728, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 346, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9984, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 142, 94, 144, 78, 62, 96, 114, 100, 129, 99, 141, 98, 97, 101, 102, 82, 143, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9951, "avg_search_time_ms": 995.1, "search_nodes": 103312, "safety_nodes": 501, "corridor_nodes": 7728, "corridor_branch_probes": 8445, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 3746, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 7679, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 7679, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 49, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3746, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 83, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 683, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 25977040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1987280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 111541, "avg_nodes": 11154.1, "eval_calls": 80402, "avg_eval_calls": 8040.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80402, "pattern_eval_ns": 1556515, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.359157732394717, "pattern_frame_queries": 80402, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1556515, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.359157732394717, "pattern_frame_updates": 206540, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2602630194, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12601.095158322843, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21590, "avg_candidate_generations": 2159.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1835736, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.02714219546087, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 758, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 21580, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1834978, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 749460, "avg_legality_checks": 74946.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2940, "root_legality_checks": 758, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 748702, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2935, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3751705, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 375170.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6153000256, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1640.0543902039205, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48152, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4815.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 317364702, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6590.893462369164, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3059, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 28614832, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27237, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 218125774, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16004, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 55598074, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1852, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 15026022, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 125335, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12533.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 948035972, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7564.016212550365, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 171827, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17182.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 444397068, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2586.3052256048236, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1414696935, "stage_ordering_ns": 561725025, "stage_eval_ns": 2604186709, "stage_threat_ns": 4617647836, "stage_proof_ns": 713939611, "tactical_annotations": 330828, "root_tactical_annotations": 1729, "search_tactical_annotations": 329099, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 222074, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1102784833, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 718031, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3279538492, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46876, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1447122147, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111032, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 136653438, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 15524, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 66825330, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 222064, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22218817, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 81860, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 225354454, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 178828, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 750647829, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 70140, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9626926, "child_limit_applications": 21580, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21580, "child_cap_hits": 21580, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21580, "child_moves_before_total": 1832043, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1832043, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 351350, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 351350, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.89541241890639, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.281278962001853, "tt_hits": 8911, "tt_cutoffs": 1288, "beta_cutoffs": 16511, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3469.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4269.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 921, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 23, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.5555555555555554, "search_nodes": 86, "safety_nodes": 1166, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1252, "avg_nodes": 139.11111111111111, "eval_calls": 77, "avg_eval_calls": 8.555555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 77, "line_shape_eval_ns": 47320, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 614.5454545454545, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 686, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 686, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10707, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1189.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17176902, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1604.2684225273185, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.2222222222222223, "renju_forbidden_ns": 218083, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10904.15, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 218083, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3910, "stage_ordering_ns": 450, "stage_eval_ns": 47320, "stage_threat_ns": 13910332, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 163, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 13551671, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 256971, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7310, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87200, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 154, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14490, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5775.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6664.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 347, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5148, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 113, 83, 81, 110, 124, 99, 127, 54, 68, 69, 114, 39 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.375, "search_nodes": 243, "safety_nodes": 415, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 658, "avg_nodes": 82.25, "eval_calls": 235, "avg_eval_calls": 29.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 235, "line_shape_eval_ns": 158130, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 672.8936170212766, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 514, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.25, "candidate_moves_max": 77, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 514, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 514, "avg_legality_checks": 64.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 514, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9912, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1239.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19546509, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1972.0045399515739, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 88861, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9873.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 50400, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3600.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1301777, "stage_ordering_ns": 420, "stage_eval_ns": 158130, "stage_threat_ns": 16555235, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 478, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16018824, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 154991, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 235, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 322110, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 470, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59310, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5113, "avg_search_time_ms": 639.125, "search_nodes": 75377, "safety_nodes": 509, "corridor_nodes": 686, "corridor_branch_probes": 782, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 241, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 671, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 671, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 52, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 241, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 52, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 413, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 49654160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1991760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 76572, "avg_nodes": 9571.5, "eval_calls": 61234, "avg_eval_calls": 7654.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 61234, "pattern_eval_ns": 1211415, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.783371982885324, "pattern_frame_queries": 61234, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1211415, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.783371982885324, "pattern_frame_updates": 150690, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1063258072, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7055.929869268034, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13437, "avg_candidate_generations": 1679.625, "candidate_moves_total": 1070318, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.65453598273425, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 527, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 13429, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1069791, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 611845, "avg_legality_checks": 76480.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 611845, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1612963, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 201620.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3002718368, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1861.61639665634, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1100, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 137.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6730486, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6118.623636363636, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 367021, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 457, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 4416201, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 609, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1947264, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42754, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5344.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 387038877, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9052.693946765216, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8133.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 187979843, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2888.8420801893317, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1289569246, "stage_ordering_ns": 376977886, "stage_eval_ns": 1064469487, "stage_threat_ns": 2265956163, "stage_proof_ns": 80295808, "tactical_annotations": 197369, "root_tactical_annotations": 1064, "search_tactical_annotations": 196305, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152144, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 747093250, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 220677, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1397593040, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27432, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 850890616, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76068, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93106181, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1446, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6395839, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152136, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16074254, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 46112, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 197095823, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 100874, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 319609516, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 50383, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5693599, "child_limit_applications": 13429, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13429, "child_cap_hits": 13429, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13429, "child_moves_before_total": 1069757, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1069757, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 214880, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 214880, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.66021297192643, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00119145133666, "tt_hits": 5319, "tt_cutoffs": 682, "beta_cutoffs": 9381, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4404.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5404.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1867, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 348, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16391, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 81, 85, 86, 69, 94, 78, 111, 109, 140, 154, 125, 95, 127, 124, 142, 158, 157, 172, 97 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 16343, "avg_search_time_ms": 1361.9166666666667, "search_nodes": 191002, "safety_nodes": 257, "corridor_nodes": 2910, "corridor_branch_probes": 3265, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1196, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 2878, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2878, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 103, "corridor_proof_active": 32, "corridor_proof_quiet": 71, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1196, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 103, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 829, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 93144880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 194169, "avg_nodes": 16180.75, "eval_calls": 153703, "avg_eval_calls": 12808.583333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 153703, "pattern_eval_ns": 3088768, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.0956910405132, "pattern_frame_queries": 153703, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3088768, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.0956910405132, "pattern_frame_updates": 381900, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5004621287, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13104.53335166274, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35220, "avg_candidate_generations": 2935.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3034085, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.14664963089155, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 865, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 35208, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3033220, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1243632, "avg_legality_checks": 103636.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1706, "root_legality_checks": 865, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1242767, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1704, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4709785, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 392482.0833333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9766089867, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2073.574455521855, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46945, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3912.0833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 264368562, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5631.453019490894, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2014, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15814541, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29218, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 206442707, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14881, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36084471, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 832, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6026843, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 126512, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10542.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1058049015, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8363.230484064752, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 166214, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13851.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 444092080, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2671.8091135524082, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2825338851, "stage_ordering_ns": 1150695095, "stage_eval_ns": 5007710055, "stage_threat_ns": 6794721246, "stage_proof_ns": 503912458, "tactical_annotations": 573583, "root_tactical_annotations": 2956, "search_tactical_annotations": 570627, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 387874, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2170974482, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 690983, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4263835502, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 72261, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2430482254, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 193931, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 262155318, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5962, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 35908891, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 387862, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45126791, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 163587, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 260474371, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 280444, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1116343942, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 129552, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16720262, "child_limit_applications": 35208, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35208, "child_cap_hits": 35208, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35208, "child_moves_before_total": 3031516, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3031516, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 564791, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 564791, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.10304476255396, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.041553056123607, "tt_hits": 14250, "tt_cutoffs": 2039, "beta_cutoffs": 25142, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4166666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3106.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3748.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1020, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.272727272727273, "search_nodes": 196, "safety_nodes": 974, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1170, "avg_nodes": 106.36363636363636, "eval_calls": 185, "avg_eval_calls": 16.818181818181817, "line_shape_eval_calls": 185, "line_shape_eval_ns": 151441, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 818.6, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 791, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.9090909090909, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 791, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12908, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1173.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25829917, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2001.0781685776262, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.7272727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 94400, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11800.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 94400, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4720, "stage_ordering_ns": 580, "stage_eval_ns": 151441, "stage_threat_ns": 21936234, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 381, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21394484, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 238170, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 257120, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 370, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46460, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 349, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10864, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 128, 64, 48, 65, 100, 86, 113, 83, 99, 97, 130, 146, 66, 101, 82 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 30, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.75, "search_nodes": 270, "safety_nodes": 628, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 898, "avg_nodes": 112.25, "eval_calls": 262, "avg_eval_calls": 32.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 262, "line_shape_eval_ns": 201881, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 770.5381679389313, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 575, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.875, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 575, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 575, "avg_legality_checks": 71.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 575, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10179, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1272.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20894816, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2052.737597013459, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 190361, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11197.70588235294, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34130, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 156231, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 506223, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11505.068181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 277472, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4404.31746031746, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1459437, "stage_ordering_ns": 420, "stage_eval_ns": 201881, "stage_threat_ns": 18343579, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 532, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17234010, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 684354, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 262, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 361065, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 524, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64150, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 10825, "avg_search_time_ms": 1353.125, "search_nodes": 125115, "safety_nodes": 248, "corridor_nodes": 3967, "corridor_branch_probes": 4513, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1966, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_plies_followed": 3937, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3937, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 52, "corridor_proof_active": 30, "corridor_proof_quiet": 22, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1966, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 52, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 413, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 51550240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1987520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 129330, "avg_nodes": 16166.25, "eval_calls": 103317, "avg_eval_calls": 12914.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 103317, "pattern_eval_ns": 2104558, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.369910082561436, "pattern_frame_queries": 103317, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2104558, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.369910082561436, "pattern_frame_updates": 250162, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2678560105, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10707.302088246815, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20644, "avg_candidate_generations": 2580.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1818165, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.07232125557063, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 604, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 20636, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1817561, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1043850, "avg_legality_checks": 130481.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5479, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1043850, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5479, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2983470, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 372933.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6167633024, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2067.268323127097, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30824, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3853.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 310192695, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10063.349824811836, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5510, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 59318944, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20113, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 205225949, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5172, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45299931, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 347871, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 101589, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12698.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1009441263, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9936.521306440658, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 146030, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18253.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 505255592, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3459.9437923714304, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2531561402, "stage_ordering_ns": 678313322, "stage_eval_ns": 2680664663, "stage_threat_ns": 4832311071, "stage_proof_ns": 56882490, "tactical_annotations": 435651, "root_tactical_annotations": 1858, "search_tactical_annotations": 433793, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 258148, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1537251449, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 593951, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3028788036, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43008, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1534263939, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129070, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 181852204, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7978, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 40038983, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 258140, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31397281, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 125443, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 458210376, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 218112, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 870110351, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 92096, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12983118, "child_limit_applications": 20636, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20636, "child_cap_hits": 20636, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20636, "child_moves_before_total": 1812082, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1812082, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 349701, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 349701, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.81168831168831, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.946162046908317, "tt_hits": 8222, "tt_cutoffs": 1128, "beta_cutoffs": 14319, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2596.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3246.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1418, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 350, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10774, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 82, 130, 52, 146, 162, 99, 68, 54, 144, 84, 69, 128, 67, 97, 66, 70, 65 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10738, "avg_search_time_ms": 1193.111111111111, "search_nodes": 105705, "safety_nodes": 240, "corridor_nodes": 2553, "corridor_branch_probes": 2871, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1171, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 2524, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2524, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 67, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1171, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 67, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 547, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 16081520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1979600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 108498, "avg_nodes": 12055.333333333334, "eval_calls": 81537, "avg_eval_calls": 9059.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 81537, "pattern_eval_ns": 1658832, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.34453070385224, "pattern_frame_queries": 81537, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1658832, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.34453070385224, "pattern_frame_updates": 211336, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2854278317, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13505.878397433471, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22769, "avg_candidate_generations": 2529.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 1875639, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.37687206289253, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 662, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 22760, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1874977, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 791735, "avg_legality_checks": 87970.55555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 630, "root_legality_checks": 662, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 791073, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 630, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3124882, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 347209.1111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6636946352, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2123.9030312184586, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60023, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6669.222222222223, "renju_forbidden_ns": 188957212, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3148.080102627326, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1547, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6947022, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27559, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 123146886, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30764, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 58389490, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 153, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 473814, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99743, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11082.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 959552723, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9620.251275778752, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137263, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15251.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 442255756, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3221.9589838485244, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1904699588, "stage_ordering_ns": 755002098, "stage_eval_ns": 2855937149, "stage_threat_ns": 4794998775, "stage_proof_ns": 391386693, "tactical_annotations": 298576, "root_tactical_annotations": 1797, "search_tactical_annotations": 296779, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 216527, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1277620570, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 426615, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3300606063, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46890, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1764380424, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108259, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156164531, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5182, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25799055, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 216518, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26292355, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 63443, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 241298142, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171181, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 904844230, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 63952, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8516201, "child_limit_applications": 22760, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22760, "child_cap_hits": 22760, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22760, "child_moves_before_total": 1874347, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1874347, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 365279, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 365279, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.35268014059754, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.049165202108963, "tt_hits": 8932, "tt_cutoffs": 1371, "beta_cutoffs": 17511, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1912.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2724.222222222222, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 266, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.375, "search_nodes": 209, "safety_nodes": 652, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 861, "avg_nodes": 107.625, "eval_calls": 201, "avg_eval_calls": 25.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 201, "line_shape_eval_ns": 126721, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 630.4527363184079, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 600, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.0, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 600, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9338, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1167.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19226056, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2058.905118869137, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3440, "stage_ordering_ns": 420, "stage_eval_ns": 126721, "stage_threat_ns": 16980636, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 410, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16547675, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 109700, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8290, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 201, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 273121, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 402, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50140, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 351, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9423, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 128, 64, 48, 65, 110, 94, 114, 100, 127, 125, 144, 95, 129, 130, 99, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 34, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7777777777777777, "search_nodes": 268, "safety_nodes": 616, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 259, "avg_eval_calls": 28.77777777777778, "line_shape_eval_calls": 259, "line_shape_eval_ns": 187030, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 722.1235521235521, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 648, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.0, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 648, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 648, "avg_legality_checks": 72.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 648, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11378, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1264.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25039650, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2200.707505712779, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.7777777777777777, "renju_forbidden_ns": 254940, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10197.6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 51060, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 203880, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 34, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.7777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 329271, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9684.441176470587, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.555555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 185500, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3710.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1583637, "stage_ordering_ns": 910, "stage_eval_ns": 187030, "stage_threat_ns": 21957138, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 527, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21106064, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 431441, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 259, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 356602, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 518, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63031, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5773.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9379, "avg_search_time_ms": 1042.111111111111, "search_nodes": 114267, "safety_nodes": 578, "corridor_nodes": 3350, "corridor_branch_probes": 3875, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1469, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 3318, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3318, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 32, "corridor_proof_quiet": 36, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1469, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 67, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 549, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 53494960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1987280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 118195, "avg_nodes": 13132.777777777777, "eval_calls": 93551, "avg_eval_calls": 10394.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 93551, "pattern_eval_ns": 1896080, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.2678752765871, "pattern_frame_queries": 93551, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1896080, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.2678752765871, "pattern_frame_updates": 228460, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2054467385, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8992.678740260877, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19653, "avg_candidate_generations": 2183.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 1728704, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.96132905917672, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 675, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 19644, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1728029, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1013607, "avg_legality_checks": 112623.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7838, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1013607, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7838, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2873495, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 319277.22222222225, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5393957794, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1877.141875660128, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36231, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4025.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 250560971, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6915.651541497613, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7838, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 71414629, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14457, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 136191043, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13803, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41633071, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 133, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1322228, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 114487, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12720.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1050721200, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9177.646370330256, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 164459, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18273.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 537122164, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3265.99434509513, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2322931168, "stage_ordering_ns": 621651258, "stage_eval_ns": 2056363465, "stage_threat_ns": 4247810325, "stage_proof_ns": 84039451, "tactical_annotations": 375216, "root_tactical_annotations": 1610, "search_tactical_annotations": 373606, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 235241, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1289940946, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 524731, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2729749606, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40992, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1291683711, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 117616, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159768686, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6772, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 30113940, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 235232, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26593926, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 114627, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 551516274, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 174499, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 748242774, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 86090, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11643221, "child_limit_applications": 19644, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19644, "child_cap_hits": 19644, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19644, "child_moves_before_total": 1720191, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1720191, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 317646, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 317646, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.56826511912034, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.170128283445326, "tt_hits": 7879, "tt_cutoffs": 1035, "beta_cutoffs": 13529, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3420.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4309.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1843, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 352, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16542, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 110, 158, 111, 174, 190, 109, 64, 128, 82, 124, 80, 48, 81, 125, 127, 123, 122, 79, 94, 66, 97, 67, 95, 93, 98 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 16492, "avg_search_time_ms": 1268.6153846153845, "search_nodes": 166248, "safety_nodes": 349, "corridor_nodes": 6925, "corridor_branch_probes": 7493, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3274, "corridor_neutral_exits": 54, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 6885, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6885, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 89, "corridor_proof_active": 40, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 54, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3274, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 89, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 695, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 30025360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1990720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 173522, "avg_nodes": 13347.846153846154, "eval_calls": 127869, "avg_eval_calls": 9836.076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 127869, "pattern_eval_ns": 2558961, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.012364216502828, "pattern_frame_queries": 127869, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2558961, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.012364216502828, "pattern_frame_updates": 332382, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4232753114, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12734.603901534982, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 36163, "avg_candidate_generations": 2781.769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 3420644, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.58960816303957, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1087, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 36150, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3419557, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1232398, "avg_legality_checks": 94799.84615384616, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2139, "root_legality_checks": 1087, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1231311, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2139, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5106955, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 392842.6923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10086191584, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1974.991278364505, "renju_forbidden_checks": 50419, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3878.3846153846152, "renju_forbidden_ns": 278730323, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5528.279477974573, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2692, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22033564, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24708, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 160876762, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19958, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 69842739, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3061, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 25977258, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 152365, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11720.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1265835576, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8307.915702425098, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 203527, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15655.923076923076, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 542199801, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2664.0190294162444, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2660510934, "stage_ordering_ns": 1232751548, "stage_eval_ns": 4235312075, "stage_threat_ns": 7476711485, "stage_proof_ns": 827518700, "tactical_annotations": 623702, "root_tactical_annotations": 3310, "search_tactical_annotations": 620392, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 346343, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1965539506, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 924596, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5132611289, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75941, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2657913357, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 173165, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 235767953, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 13948, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 84004015, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 346330, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39770674, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 176452, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 293455055, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 301013, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1211502539, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 146237, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19018048, "child_limit_applications": 36150, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 36150, "child_cap_hits": 36150, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 36150, "child_moves_before_total": 3417418, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3417418, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 600430, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 600430, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 94.53438450899031, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.609405255878286, "tt_hits": 15881, "tt_cutoffs": 2172, "beta_cutoffs": 27914, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3292.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3907.5384615384614, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 386, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0, "search_nodes": 86, "safety_nodes": 1631, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1717, "avg_nodes": 143.08333333333334, "eval_calls": 74, "avg_eval_calls": 6.166666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 74, "line_shape_eval_ns": 60190, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 813.3783783783783, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1013, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.41666666666667, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1013, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14234, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1186.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28009803, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1967.8096810453842, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.3333333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4720, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1180.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4720, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5830, "stage_ordering_ns": 620, "stage_eval_ns": 60190, "stage_threat_ns": 21877398, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 160, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21392605, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 353262, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112511, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 148, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19020, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 353, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6058, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 111, 81, 79, 114, 130, 95, 127, 50, 66, 65, 110, 35 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5, "search_nodes": 247, "safety_nodes": 431, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 678, "avg_nodes": 84.75, "eval_calls": 239, "avg_eval_calls": 29.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 239, "line_shape_eval_ns": 159682, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 668.1255230125523, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 530, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.25, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 530, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 530, "avg_legality_checks": 66.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 530, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20334578, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2035.085868694956, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 108150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12016.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 61000, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4357.142857142857, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1318496, "stage_ordering_ns": 370, "stage_eval_ns": 159682, "stage_threat_ns": 17377685, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16810104, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 185881, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 321260, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60440, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6021, "avg_search_time_ms": 752.625, "search_nodes": 79133, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 888, "corridor_branch_probes": 1056, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 333, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 873, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 873, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 52, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 333, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 52, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 413, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 49656880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1992000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 80550, "avg_nodes": 10068.75, "eval_calls": 64439, "avg_eval_calls": 8054.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64439, "pattern_eval_ns": 1305117, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.253526591039588, "pattern_frame_queries": 64439, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1305117, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.253526591039588, "pattern_frame_updates": 158202, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1183689650, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7482.14087053261, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14032, "avg_candidate_generations": 1754.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1151925, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.09271664766248, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 547, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 14024, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1151378, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 656014, "avg_legality_checks": 82001.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 390, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 656014, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 390, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1702274, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 212784.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3527295052, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2072.1076935910437, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2868, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 358.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13341852, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4651.970711297071, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 390, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4577133, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 361, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 3754182, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2080, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4612236, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 398301, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46972, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5871.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 466481664, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9931.05816230946, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74353, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9294.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 232173347, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3122.5821015964384, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1573485916, "stage_ordering_ns": 463539088, "stage_eval_ns": 1184994767, "stage_threat_ns": 2679237470, "stage_proof_ns": 84984261, "tactical_annotations": 206304, "root_tactical_annotations": 1104, "search_tactical_annotations": 205200, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 160060, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 886550169, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 242937, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1651667692, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28695, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 991996873, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 80026, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 106985306, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1850, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9021703, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 160052, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18866980, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 51684, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 212615222, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 104936, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 404542359, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49684, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6145620, "child_limit_applications": 14024, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14024, "child_cap_hits": 14024, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14024, "child_moves_before_total": 1150988, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1150988, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 224398, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 224398, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.07273245864232, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00099828864803, "tt_hits": 5423, "tt_cutoffs": 638, "beta_cutoffs": 9771, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4013.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5013.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1879, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 354, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12246, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 144, 96, 114, 97, 99, 95, 94, 84, 100, 86, 113, 111, 85, 71, 115, 116, 130, 70, 145 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 12207, "avg_search_time_ms": 1220.7, "search_nodes": 127373, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 4695, "corridor_branch_probes": 5027, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2253, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 4668, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4668, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2253, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 59, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 442, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 43732560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 132454, "avg_nodes": 13245.4, "eval_calls": 100237, "avg_eval_calls": 10023.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 100237, "pattern_eval_ns": 2032087, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.272823408521802, "pattern_frame_queries": 100237, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2032087, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.272823408521802, "pattern_frame_updates": 254662, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3206201645, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12590.027742654971, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25629, "avg_candidate_generations": 2562.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1973711, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.01084708728393, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 638, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 25619, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1973073, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 846266, "avg_legality_checks": 84626.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1053, "root_legality_checks": 638, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 845628, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1053, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3467088, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 346708.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7413866766, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2138.3555208290068, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38791, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3879.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 200047674, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5157.064112809672, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1545, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11266296, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20402, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 133741246, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15462, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44000127, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1382, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 11040005, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98285, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9828.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 828384498, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8428.391901103932, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 126180, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12618.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 336670938, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2668.179885877318, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2059577639, "stage_ordering_ns": 806266703, "stage_eval_ns": 3208233732, "stage_threat_ns": 5517156191, "stage_proof_ns": 574520669, "tactical_annotations": 472898, "root_tactical_annotations": 1921, "search_tactical_annotations": 470977, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 264130, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1550221645, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 658063, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3678438435, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53632, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2001148093, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 132060, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 187748401, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9458, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 54161495, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 264120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31870210, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 131707, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 184739454, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 224338, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 839962587, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 116853, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14716005, "child_limit_applications": 25619, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25619, "child_cap_hits": 25619, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25619, "child_moves_before_total": 1972020, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1972020, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 427490, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 427490, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.97490144033725, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.68644365509973, "tt_hits": 9693, "tt_cutoffs": 1475, "beta_cutoffs": 19120, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2563.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3346.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 85, "safety_nodes": 883, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 968, "avg_nodes": 107.55555555555556, "eval_calls": 76, "avg_eval_calls": 8.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 76, "line_shape_eval_ns": 57430, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 755.6578947368421, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 578, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_max": 75, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 578, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10546, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1171.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21438078, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2032.8160439977244, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.3333333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 71630, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5969.166666666667, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 71630, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3760, "stage_ordering_ns": 480, "stage_eval_ns": 57430, "stage_threat_ns": 17178895, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 161, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16805993, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 239912, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113710, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19280, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 355, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6449, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 140, 154, 97, 99, 69, 142, 156, 83, 111, 86, 100, 85, 82, 87 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5, "search_nodes": 247, "safety_nodes": 431, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 678, "avg_nodes": 84.75, "eval_calls": 239, "avg_eval_calls": 29.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 239, "line_shape_eval_ns": 162950, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 681.7991631799163, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 530, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.25, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 530, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 530, "avg_legality_checks": 66.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 530, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20511839, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2052.826160928743, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 110960, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12328.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 62750, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4482.142857142857, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1342736, "stage_ordering_ns": 360, "stage_eval_ns": 162950, "stage_threat_ns": 17467417, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16882656, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 190700, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8220, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 334651, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59410, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6410, "avg_search_time_ms": 801.25, "search_nodes": 79767, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 957, "corridor_branch_probes": 1161, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 352, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 941, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 941, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 52, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 36, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 352, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 52, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 413, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23947760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1983280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 81253, "avg_nodes": 10156.625, "eval_calls": 64907, "avg_eval_calls": 8113.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64907, "pattern_eval_ns": 1325235, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.41744341904571, "pattern_frame_queries": 64907, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1325235, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.41744341904571, "pattern_frame_updates": 159470, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1454825691, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9122.880109111431, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14116, "avg_candidate_generations": 1764.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1157631, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.00843015018418, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 547, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 14108, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1157084, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 663570, "avg_legality_checks": 82946.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1894, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 663570, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1894, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1765558, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 220694.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3760407003, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2129.868859023606, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5550, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 693.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51768926, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9327.734414414414, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1894, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20347776, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2442, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25189264, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1177, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5793052, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 438834, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42021, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5252.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 407880350, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9706.583612955426, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 61682, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7710.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 195611325, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3171.2870043124412, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1620462282, "stage_ordering_ns": 482443864, "stage_eval_ns": 1456150926, "stage_threat_ns": 2733121432, "stage_proof_ns": 85117915, "tactical_annotations": 205501, "root_tactical_annotations": 1104, "search_tactical_annotations": 204397, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 161464, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 926677523, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 246923, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1657704660, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28888, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1047098939, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 80728, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112424457, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1986, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9867220, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 161456, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19459606, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 50257, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 199213963, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 105043, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 362415961, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 50201, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6987966, "child_limit_applications": 14108, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14108, "child_cap_hits": 14108, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14108, "child_moves_before_total": 1155190, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1155190, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 225753, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 225753, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.88191097249788, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001772044230226, "tt_hits": 5584, "tt_cutoffs": 720, "beta_cutoffs": 9819, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3781.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4781.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1871, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 356, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12228, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 142, 100, 140, 86, 72, 98, 110, 94, 125, 95, 143, 96, 97, 93, 92, 82, 141, 144, 139 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 12188, "avg_search_time_ms": 1218.8, "search_nodes": 103068, "safety_nodes": 501, "corridor_nodes": 6312, "corridor_branch_probes": 6965, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 3104, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 6266, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6266, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 46, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3104, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 83, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 683, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 25943040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1987280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 109881, "avg_nodes": 10988.1, "eval_calls": 80495, "avg_eval_calls": 8049.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80495, "pattern_eval_ns": 1632106, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.275868066339523, "pattern_frame_queries": 80495, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1632106, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.275868066339523, "pattern_frame_updates": 206052, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3295403606, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15993.067798419816, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21340, "avg_candidate_generations": 2134.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1823756, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.46185567010309, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 758, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 21330, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1822998, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 727965, "avg_legality_checks": 72796.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2692, "root_legality_checks": 758, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 727207, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2687, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3566836, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 356683.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7565982605, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2121.2028265387025, "renju_forbidden_checks": 49579, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4957.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 401443162, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8097.040319490106, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2885, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30331391, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29031, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 288958608, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16744, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 73749986, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 919, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8403177, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 117792, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11779.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1131141235, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9602.869761953274, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 161629, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16162.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 528127101, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3267.5268732715044, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1778222656, "stage_ordering_ns": 733340697, "stage_eval_ns": 3297035712, "stage_threat_ns": 5581398191, "stage_proof_ns": 765333816, "tactical_annotations": 327838, "root_tactical_annotations": 1729, "search_tactical_annotations": 326109, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 218760, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1363692763, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 634936, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3951019490, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45619, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1851448847, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 109375, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 163368692, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12698, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 66990757, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 218750, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27451901, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 79380, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 275064479, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 177589, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 944872349, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 70869, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8874588, "child_limit_applications": 21330, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21330, "child_cap_hits": 21330, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21330, "child_moves_before_total": 1820311, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1820311, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 347693, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 347693, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.3404125644632, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.300656352555087, "tt_hits": 8824, "tt_cutoffs": 1201, "beta_cutoffs": 16270, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1915.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2700.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 241, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 86, "safety_nodes": 1166, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1252, "avg_nodes": 139.11111111111111, "eval_calls": 77, "avg_eval_calls": 8.555555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 77, "line_shape_eval_ns": 58190, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 755.7142857142857, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 686, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 686, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10707, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1189.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21742608, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2030.6909498458951, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.2222222222222223, "renju_forbidden_ns": 224320, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11216.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 224320, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4050, "stage_ordering_ns": 470, "stage_eval_ns": 58190, "stage_threat_ns": 17615409, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 163, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17163466, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 316862, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 114771, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 154, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20310, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 357, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10840, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 126, 70, 56, 69, 94, 78, 111, 81, 95, 97, 124, 138, 68, 93, 82 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 30, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.75, "search_nodes": 270, "safety_nodes": 628, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 898, "avg_nodes": 112.25, "eval_calls": 262, "avg_eval_calls": 32.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 262, "line_shape_eval_ns": 201291, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 768.2862595419847, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 575, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.875, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 575, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 575, "avg_legality_checks": 71.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 575, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10179, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1272.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20889691, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2052.234109441006, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 197261, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11603.588235294117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34760, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 162501, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 497123, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11298.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 274522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4357.492063492064, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1454326, "stage_ordering_ns": 390, "stage_eval_ns": 201291, "stage_threat_ns": 18415325, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 532, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17318681, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 672653, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 262, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 360221, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 524, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63770, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 10803, "avg_search_time_ms": 1350.375, "search_nodes": 124016, "safety_nodes": 248, "corridor_nodes": 4079, "corridor_branch_probes": 4648, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2004, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 4047, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4047, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 52, "corridor_proof_active": 32, "corridor_proof_quiet": 20, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2004, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 52, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 413, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 51608000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1992800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 128343, "avg_nodes": 16042.875, "eval_calls": 102654, "avg_eval_calls": 12831.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 102654, "pattern_eval_ns": 2081150, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.273442827361816, "pattern_frame_queries": 102654, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2081150, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.273442827361816, "pattern_frame_updates": 247964, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2669422563, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10765.363371295833, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20335, "avg_candidate_generations": 2541.875, "candidate_moves_total": 1794780, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.26063437423161, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 604, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 20327, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1794176, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1048142, "avg_legality_checks": 131017.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5469, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1048142, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5469, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3002355, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 375294.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6146369825, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2047.1829030877427, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30851, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3856.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 306664736, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9940.187870733525, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5477, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 57763863, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20117, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 205250203, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5228, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43297709, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 352961, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 101859, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12732.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 995646884, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9774.75612366114, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 146542, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18317.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 501120631, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3419.6382675273985, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2528567099, "stage_ordering_ns": 674085525, "stage_eval_ns": 2671503713, "stage_threat_ns": 4828377125, "stage_proof_ns": 55741107, "tactical_annotations": 426381, "root_tactical_annotations": 1858, "search_tactical_annotations": 424523, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 256170, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1547962886, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 590732, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3009148565, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42445, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1528829614, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128081, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 185302126, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8198, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 42025396, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 256162, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31515148, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 121956, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 445025316, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 211208, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 861956090, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 93217, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12423004, "child_limit_applications": 20327, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20327, "child_cap_hits": 20327, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20327, "child_moves_before_total": 1788707, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1788707, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 343042, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 343042, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.9966055000738, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.87617454617012, "tt_hits": 8079, "tt_cutoffs": 1001, "beta_cutoffs": 14044, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2545.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3198.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1436, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 358, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12461, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 82, 124, 126, 138, 152, 140, 114, 66, 97, 67, 113, 111, 81, 65, 84, 70, 83, 80, 85 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 12424, "avg_search_time_ms": 1242.4, "search_nodes": 125303, "safety_nodes": 479, "corridor_nodes": 5407, "corridor_branch_probes": 5977, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2423, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 5364, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5364, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 43, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2423, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 81, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 683, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 67490800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1988000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 131189, "avg_nodes": 13118.9, "eval_calls": 98378, "avg_eval_calls": 9837.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 98378, "pattern_eval_ns": 2010828, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.43981377950355, "pattern_frame_queries": 98378, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2010828, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.43981377950355, "pattern_frame_updates": 250522, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3460087144, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13811.510142821788, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25391, "avg_candidate_generations": 2539.1, "candidate_moves_total": 2140562, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.30396597219487, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 727, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 25381, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2139835, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 844367, "avg_legality_checks": 84436.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1351, "root_legality_checks": 727, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 843640, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1350, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3772008, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 377200.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7599837957, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2014.7990028122952, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41552, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4155.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 270339148, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6506.044185598767, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1824, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16844650, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22300, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 187369854, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15945, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 53343117, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1483, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 12781527, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 107114, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10711.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 922573707, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8613.007702074425, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 144529, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14452.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 400380646, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2770.244352344512, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1914851549, "stage_ordering_ns": 766949412, "stage_eval_ns": 3462097972, "stage_threat_ns": 5577202346, "stage_proof_ns": 661932353, "tactical_annotations": 447021, "root_tactical_annotations": 2129, "search_tactical_annotations": 444892, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 261426, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1528469716, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 704998, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3766140144, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53599, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1928496388, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 130708, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 182233857, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10894, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 55879894, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 261416, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31177276, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 133723, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 192413903, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 209851, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 891075452, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 103447, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13301459, "child_limit_applications": 25381, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25381, "child_cap_hits": 25381, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25381, "child_moves_before_total": 2138485, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2138485, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 419013, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 419013, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.25534848902723, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.508923998266418, "tt_hits": 10781, "tt_cutoffs": 1502, "beta_cutoffs": 18964, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2508.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3271.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 448, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.888888888888889, "search_nodes": 73, "safety_nodes": 1040, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1113, "avg_nodes": 123.66666666666667, "eval_calls": 64, "avg_eval_calls": 7.111111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 64, "line_shape_eval_ns": 42042, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 656.90625, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 657, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.0, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 657, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10679, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1186.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19381365, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1814.9044854387114, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 45200, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11300.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 45200, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3810, "stage_ordering_ns": 480, "stage_eval_ns": 42042, "stage_threat_ns": 15579844, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 137, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15208734, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 263030, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92030, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16050, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 359, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20957, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 97, 82, 142, 157, 113, 96, 68, 114, 66, 129, 128, 143, 115, 189, 130, 141, 125, 124, 138, 111, 81, 156, 126, 171, 185, 173, 205, 174, 65, 49, 67, 64, 69 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 49, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.8823529411764706, "search_nodes": 349, "safety_nodes": 1624, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1973, "avg_nodes": 116.05882352941177, "eval_calls": 332, "avg_eval_calls": 19.529411764705884, "line_shape_eval_calls": 332, "line_shape_eval_ns": 248271, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 747.8042168674699, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1366, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.3529411764706, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1366, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1366, "avg_legality_checks": 80.3529411764706, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 1366, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21337, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1255.1176470588234, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 36672288, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1718.7180953273655, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.17647058823529413, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5350, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1783.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5350, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 55, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.235294117647059, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 553952, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10071.854545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.764705882352941, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 299100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3692.5925925925926, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2739311, "stage_ordering_ns": 830, "stage_eval_ns": 248271, "stage_threat_ns": 30055754, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 681, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 28812029, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 740553, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14120, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 332, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 428391, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 664, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74781, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6821.235294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7291.823529411765, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 20891, "avg_search_time_ms": 1305.6875, "search_nodes": 270286, "safety_nodes": 352, "corridor_nodes": 13944, "corridor_branch_probes": 14965, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 49, "corridor_depth_exits": 5920, "corridor_neutral_exits": 30, "corridor_terminal_exits": 48, "corridor_plies_followed": 13862, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 13862, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 186, "corridor_proof_active": 82, "corridor_proof_quiet": 104, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 79, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5920, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 48, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 186, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 185, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1528, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 105831920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 7, "total_nodes": 284582, "avg_nodes": 17786.375, "eval_calls": 207335, "avg_eval_calls": 12958.4375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 207335, "pattern_eval_ns": 3977141, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.1821978922999, "pattern_frame_queries": 207335, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3977141, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.1821978922999, "pattern_frame_updates": 540422, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3796418574, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7024.9149257432155, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 59249, "avg_candidate_generations": 3703.0625, "candidate_moves_total": 5502586, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.87221725261186, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1285, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 59233, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5501301, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 3756996, "avg_legality_checks": 234812.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8585, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3756996, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8585, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8356645, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 522290.3125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12447076366, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1489.4824856147413, "renju_forbidden_checks": 57331, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3583.1875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 217611061, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3795.696237637578, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8587, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 51536335, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19979, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 121326546, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28691, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43859115, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 889065, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 244493, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15280.8125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1743108808, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7129.483494414973, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 352282, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22017.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 863715099, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2451.771873101663, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6286547045, "stage_ordering_ns": 1562375833, "stage_eval_ns": 3800395715, "stage_threat_ns": 8936782967, "stage_proof_ns": 146171254, "tactical_annotations": 1133326, "root_tactical_annotations": 4901, "search_tactical_annotations": 1128425, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 568534, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2566384406, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1800874, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5836424268, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 126288, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3143172988, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 284259, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 326270504, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 28096, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 124113958, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 568518, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 54111598, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 403182, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 966283040, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 489806, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1340793819, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 240338, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 29478233, "child_limit_applications": 59233, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 59233, "child_cap_hits": 59233, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 59233, "child_moves_before_total": 5492716, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5492716, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 949942, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 949942, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 92.73067377981869, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.037377813043406, "tt_hits": 24464, "tt_cutoffs": 3643, "beta_cutoffs": 45737, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5304.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5804.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1883, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 360, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13052, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 99, 96, 113, 95, 94, 85, 114, 111, 129, 84, 156, 100, 128, 170, 130, 131, 126 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 13011, "avg_search_time_ms": 1301.1, "search_nodes": 137292, "safety_nodes": 135, "corridor_nodes": 2888, "corridor_branch_probes": 3102, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1351, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 2870, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2870, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1351, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 66, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 550, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 55549040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1985280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 140315, "avg_nodes": 14031.5, "eval_calls": 111141, "avg_eval_calls": 11114.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 111141, "pattern_eval_ns": 2408180, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.66779136412305, "pattern_frame_queries": 111141, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2408180, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.66779136412305, "pattern_frame_updates": 274500, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4112590338, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14982.114163934426, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24819, "avg_candidate_generations": 2481.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1865361, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.1585881784117, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 624, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 24809, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1864737, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 753814, "avg_legality_checks": 75381.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1785, "root_legality_checks": 624, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 753190, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1784, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3390144, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 339014.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7734622750, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2281.5027178786504, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47617, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4761.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 261937468, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5500.923367704811, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19551496, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25877, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 187442351, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18224, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45231404, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1182, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9712217, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99897, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9989.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 869525114, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8704.216482977467, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 127989, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12798.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 336668638, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2630.4497886537124, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1956515908, "stage_ordering_ns": 810272053, "stage_eval_ns": 4114998518, "stage_threat_ns": 5658789778, "stage_proof_ns": 437569384, "tactical_annotations": 450009, "root_tactical_annotations": 2138, "search_tactical_annotations": 447871, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 280388, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1757643776, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 548378, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3598487939, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51322, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2044752480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 140189, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 214652508, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5878, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 35001126, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 280378, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36703622, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 128859, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 213644378, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 211417, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 898650510, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 109733, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16300807, "child_limit_applications": 24809, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24809, "child_cap_hits": 24809, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24809, "child_moves_before_total": 1862953, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1862953, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 417404, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 417404, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.09182151638518, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.824700713450763, "tt_hits": 10191, "tt_cutoffs": 1300, "beta_cutoffs": 17559, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2752.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3455.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 917, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 81, "safety_nodes": 854, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 935, "avg_nodes": 103.88888888888889, "eval_calls": 72, "avg_eval_calls": 8.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 72, "line_shape_eval_ns": 56740, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 788.0555555555555, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 561, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.333333333333336, "candidate_moves_max": 78, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 561, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10568, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1174.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22649851, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2143.248580620742, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46070, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11517.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 46070, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3860, "stage_ordering_ns": 490, "stage_eval_ns": 56740, "stage_threat_ns": 18148262, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 153, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17715869, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 300722, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11020, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112031, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 144, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19640, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 361, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7971, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 143, 98, 141, 96, 158, 173, 99, 97, 94, 127, 142, 79, 63, 144, 139, 80, 140 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 41, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.727272727272727, "search_nodes": 325, "safety_nodes": 768, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1093, "avg_nodes": 99.36363636363636, "eval_calls": 314, "avg_eval_calls": 28.545454545454547, "line_shape_eval_calls": 314, "line_shape_eval_ns": 285540, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 909.3630573248407, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 737, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.0, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 737, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 737, "avg_legality_checks": 67.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 737, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13728, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1248.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28320151, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2062.9480623543122, "renju_forbidden_checks": 86, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7.818181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 861696, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10019.720930232557, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 166053, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 695643, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 750482, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11545.876923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.636363636363637, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 412780, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4345.0526315789475, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2004408, "stage_ordering_ns": 530, "stage_eval_ns": 285540, "stage_threat_ns": 25037448, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 639, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 23563013, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 942304, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 314, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 448621, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 628, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 83510, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7920, "avg_search_time_ms": 720.0, "search_nodes": 81853, "safety_nodes": 650, "corridor_nodes": 375, "corridor_branch_probes": 430, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 166, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_plies_followed": 366, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 366, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 42, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 166, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 42, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 39, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 286, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23868320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1988720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 82878, "avg_nodes": 7534.363636363636, "eval_calls": 62631, "avg_eval_calls": 5693.727272727273, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62631, "pattern_eval_ns": 1297983, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.724289888393926, "pattern_frame_queries": 62631, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1297983, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.724289888393926, "pattern_frame_updates": 163608, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1972032682, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12053.400090460123, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17513, "avg_candidate_generations": 1592.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 1362756, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.81396676754412, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 750, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 17502, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1362006, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 686509, "avg_legality_checks": 62409.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9807, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 686509, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9807, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2258671, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 205333.72727272726, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4660225520, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2063.259996697173, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33708, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3064.3636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 290259026, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8610.983327400023, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9884, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 97380440, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14599, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 140096124, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9069, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 51130954, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 156, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1651508, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83500, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7590.909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 874769696, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10476.283784431138, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 122818, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11165.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 446760721, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3637.583424253774, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1732453268, "stage_ordering_ns": 566385866, "stage_eval_ns": 1973330665, "stage_threat_ns": 3535404275, "stage_proof_ns": 70500395, "tactical_annotations": 301904, "root_tactical_annotations": 1285, "search_tactical_annotations": 300619, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 164435, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 955592798, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 294341, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2431865734, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35399, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1295406476, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 82212, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 115695157, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 816, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4568641, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 164424, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20156964, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70580, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 391222718, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 167121, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 728926838, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 64203, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7524981, "child_limit_applications": 17502, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17502, "child_cap_hits": 17502, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17502, "child_moves_before_total": 1352199, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1352199, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 283287, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 283287, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.25968460747343, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.185978745286253, "tt_hits": 6405, "tt_cutoffs": 1671, "beta_cutoffs": 13375, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5002.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5730.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1867, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 362, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19694, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 113, 114, 126, 98, 66, 130, 146, 129, 131, 144, 99, 159, 174, 143, 115, 83, 116, 101, 160, 132, 127, 85, 141, 155, 156, 96, 171 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 19636, "avg_search_time_ms": 1402.5714285714287, "search_nodes": 198789, "safety_nodes": 921, "corridor_nodes": 8972, "corridor_branch_probes": 9291, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 6044, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 8953, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8953, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 6044, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 338, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23757280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 208682, "avg_nodes": 14905.857142857143, "eval_calls": 163023, "avg_eval_calls": 11644.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 163023, "pattern_eval_ns": 3330695, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.430828778761278, "pattern_frame_queries": 163023, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3330695, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.430828778761278, "pattern_frame_updates": 397454, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6289676408, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15824.9166142497, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33809, "avg_candidate_generations": 2414.9285714285716, "candidate_moves_total": 2739019, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.01449318228875, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 989, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 33795, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2738030, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1293571, "avg_legality_checks": 92397.92857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8037, "root_legality_checks": 989, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 1292582, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8029, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5792647, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 413760.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11984943271, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2068.99251257672, "renju_forbidden_checks": 104177, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7441.214285714285, "renju_forbidden_ns": 512222030, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4916.84373710128, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8749, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 77646120, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 55781, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 340328731, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37961, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 87068444, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1686, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7178735, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 216885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15491.785714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1831694934, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8445.466187149872, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 279907, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19993.35714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 789931306, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2822.1205829078945, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3150647729, "stage_ordering_ns": 1093215287, "stage_eval_ns": 6293007103, "stage_threat_ns": 8471540135, "stage_proof_ns": 570652195, "tactical_annotations": 760581, "root_tactical_annotations": 2200, "search_tactical_annotations": 758381, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 415486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2448519131, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 981195, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5536001818, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70645, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2488144132, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 207736, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 304037935, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 18018, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 112146731, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 415472, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51063907, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 229839, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 452699135, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 393852, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1846571446, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 136890, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19770613, "child_limit_applications": 33795, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33795, "child_cap_hits": 33795, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33795, "child_moves_before_total": 2730001, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2730001, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 563642, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 563642, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.78121023820091, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.678266015682794, "tt_hits": 12415, "tt_cutoffs": 1909, "beta_cutoffs": 24147, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3962.214285714286, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4483.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 45, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4615384615384617, "search_nodes": 415, "safety_nodes": 878, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1293, "avg_nodes": 99.46153846153847, "eval_calls": 402, "avg_eval_calls": 30.923076923076923, "line_shape_eval_calls": 402, "line_shape_eval_ns": 364452, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 906.5970149253732, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 919, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.6923076923077, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 919, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14936, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1148.923076923077, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30273991, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2026.9142340653455, "renju_forbidden_checks": 50, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.8461538461538463, "renju_forbidden_ns": 405712, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8114.24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 405712, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6010, "stage_ordering_ns": 530, "stage_eval_ns": 364452, "stage_threat_ns": 28376437, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 817, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 27482823, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 242661, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 402, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 551192, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 804, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 99761, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6458.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7074.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 363, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6991, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 125, 128, 95, 66, 110, 140, 80, 96, 65 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.857142857142857, "search_nodes": 290, "safety_nodes": 243, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 533, "avg_nodes": 76.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 283, "avg_eval_calls": 40.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 283, "line_shape_eval_ns": 206390, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 729.2932862190813, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 408, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 408, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 408, "avg_legality_checks": 58.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 408, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1222.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17542867, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2049.4003504672896, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 277482, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9910.07142857143, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 49280, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 228202, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 317982, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11777.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.714285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 179320, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4483.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1084243, "stage_ordering_ns": 290, "stage_eval_ns": 206390, "stage_threat_ns": 16548686, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 573, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15663470, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 426292, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7030, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 387163, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 566, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 71761, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 6958, "avg_search_time_ms": 994.0, "search_nodes": 85705, "safety_nodes": 215, "corridor_nodes": 180, "corridor_branch_probes": 206, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 71, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_plies_followed": 175, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 175, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 71, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 35, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 277, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23890400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 86100, "avg_nodes": 12300.0, "eval_calls": 69829, "avg_eval_calls": 9975.57142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 69829, "pattern_eval_ns": 1422186, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.366695785418667, "pattern_frame_queries": 69829, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1422186, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.366695785418667, "pattern_frame_updates": 171352, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1891621476, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11039.389537326673, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14950, "avg_candidate_generations": 2135.714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 1124539, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.22, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 421, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 14943, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1124118, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 566079, "avg_legality_checks": 80868.42857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8215, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 566079, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8215, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1977680, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 282525.71428571426, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3965092299, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2004.9210686258646, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37949, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5421.285714285715, "renju_forbidden_ns": 350949455, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9247.923660702521, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8387, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 81890123, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22775, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 220363533, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6709, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 47879098, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 78, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 816701, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74229, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10604.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 768139087, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10348.234342372927, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110520, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15788.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 398152951, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3602.5420828809265, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1431693864, "stage_ordering_ns": 451577610, "stage_eval_ns": 1893043662, "stage_threat_ns": 3082583051, "stage_proof_ns": 61495411, "tactical_annotations": 241603, "root_tactical_annotations": 1147, "search_tactical_annotations": 240456, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 171781, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 939523686, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 229411, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2001589723, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30154, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1034634201, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85887, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 111397030, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 422, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2003988, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 171774, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20240302, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 59004, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 360499764, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 128845, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 597170156, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53754, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7828322, "child_limit_applications": 14943, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14943, "child_cap_hits": 14943, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14943, "child_moves_before_total": 1115903, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1115903, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 244658, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 244658, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.67730710031452, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.372749782506858, "tt_hits": 5066, "tt_cutoffs": 904, "beta_cutoffs": 10364, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 4.142857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 4.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3048.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4057.5714285714284, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1850, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 364, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13667, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 67, 127, 128, 125, 96, 124, 123, 80, 95, 94, 98, 99, 113, 143, 81, 109, 129, 65, 145 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 13631, "avg_search_time_ms": 1363.1, "search_nodes": 152623, "safety_nodes": 275, "corridor_nodes": 4570, "corridor_branch_probes": 4661, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2206, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 4553, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4553, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 67, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2206, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 67, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 547, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 29942320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1982160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 157468, "avg_nodes": 15746.8, "eval_calls": 122343, "avg_eval_calls": 12234.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 122343, "pattern_eval_ns": 2507674, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.497077887578367, "pattern_frame_queries": 122343, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2507674, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.497077887578367, "pattern_frame_updates": 305162, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3726274747, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12210.808511544688, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28978, "avg_candidate_generations": 2897.8, "candidate_moves_total": 2213209, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.37549175236386, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 646, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 28968, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2212563, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 944541, "avg_legality_checks": 94454.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 668, "root_legality_checks": 646, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 943895, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3857226, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 385722.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8167392145, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2117.4263952902943, "renju_forbidden_checks": 75770, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7577.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 221532900, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2923.7547842153886, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2278, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7977743, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37423, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 143791317, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 34791, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 64254957, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1278, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5508883, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 106682, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10668.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 882877343, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8275.78544646707, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 136504, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13650.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 345748315, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2532.8804650413176, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2282320450, "stage_ordering_ns": 907200115, "stage_eval_ns": 3728782421, "stage_threat_ns": 6101613386, "stage_proof_ns": 562065900, "tactical_annotations": 390828, "root_tactical_annotations": 2220, "search_tactical_annotations": 388608, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 314412, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1841955590, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 605765, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3939051728, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60519, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2216744593, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 157201, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 222082571, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9240, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 49366233, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 314402, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37953933, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96442, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 183045691, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 207071, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 904876361, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 87315, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11203331, "child_limit_applications": 28968, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28968, "child_cap_hits": 28968, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28968, "child_moves_before_total": 2211895, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2211895, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 465796, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 465796, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.35649682408174, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.079674123170395, "tt_hits": 10619, "tt_cutoffs": 1270, "beta_cutoffs": 21110, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 4.1, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 4.1, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1956.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2597.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 80, "safety_nodes": 838, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 918, "avg_nodes": 102.0, "eval_calls": 71, "avg_eval_calls": 7.888888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 71, "line_shape_eval_ns": 50771, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 715.0845070422536, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 585, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.0, "candidate_moves_max": 72, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 585, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10509, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1167.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21109877, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2008.742696736131, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3610, "stage_ordering_ns": 440, "stage_eval_ns": 50771, "stage_threat_ns": 16934334, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 151, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16596231, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 218143, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 71, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 101730, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 142, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18230, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 365, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14564, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 114, 115, 97, 82, 68, 126, 94, 124, 138, 125, 127, 95, 80, 141, 123, 140, 155, 143, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.272727272727273, "search_nodes": 252, "safety_nodes": 792, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1044, "avg_nodes": 94.9090909090909, "eval_calls": 241, "avg_eval_calls": 21.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 241, "line_shape_eval_ns": 154700, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 641.9087136929461, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 748, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.0, "candidate_moves_max": 82, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 748, "avg_legality_checks": 68.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 748, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13761, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1251.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24705307, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1795.3133493205435, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.8181818181818181, "renju_forbidden_ns": 176840, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8842.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34820, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 142020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 32, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 335903, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10496.96875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 45, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 183943, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4087.6222222222223, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1677630, "stage_ordering_ns": 610, "stage_eval_ns": 154700, "stage_threat_ns": 20571968, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 493, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19724455, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 474493, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 317090, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55930, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14521, "avg_search_time_ms": 1320.090909090909, "search_nodes": 184195, "safety_nodes": 222, "corridor_nodes": 1561, "corridor_branch_probes": 1713, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 586, "corridor_neutral_exits": 32, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1535, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1535, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 74, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 32, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 586, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 99, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 821, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 107363840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 185978, "avg_nodes": 16907.090909090908, "eval_calls": 150663, "avg_eval_calls": 13696.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 150663, "pattern_eval_ns": 3185021, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.140034381367688, "pattern_frame_queries": 150663, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3185021, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.140034381367688, "pattern_frame_updates": 368296, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3422691119, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9293.316025696722, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31800, "avg_candidate_generations": 2890.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 2737934, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.0985534591195, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 773, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 31789, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2737161, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1608657, "avg_legality_checks": 146241.54545454544, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10584, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1608657, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10584, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4275412, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 388673.8181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8413792688, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1967.9489808233686, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42349, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3849.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 351456105, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8299.04141774304, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10584, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 98395288, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22807, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 206741690, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8830, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44870475, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 128, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1448652, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 128143, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11649.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1168795112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9121.02192082283, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 183172, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16652.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 565552329, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3087.5479276308606, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3757076696, "stage_ordering_ns": 1071021851, "stage_eval_ns": 3425876140, "stage_threat_ns": 6044575176, "stage_proof_ns": 149099819, "tactical_annotations": 507697, "root_tactical_annotations": 2662, "search_tactical_annotations": 505035, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 371577, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2013483407, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 555693, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3706570154, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64827, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2145158555, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185783, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 252236623, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3270, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14847992, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 371566, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43070085, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 149312, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 595220426, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 242566, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 910950020, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 115819, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14366915, "child_limit_applications": 31789, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31789, "child_cap_hits": 31789, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31789, "child_moves_before_total": 2726577, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2726577, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 509478, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 509478, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.7710843373494, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.026864638711505, "tt_hits": 12697, "tt_cutoffs": 1696, "beta_cutoffs": 21866, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3404.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4089.3636363636365, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1815, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 366, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12587, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 82, 124, 68, 54, 114, 98, 84, 125, 127, 139, 97, 154, 140, 169, 109, 184 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 12545, "avg_search_time_ms": 1254.5, "search_nodes": 144112, "safety_nodes": 251, "corridor_nodes": 2014, "corridor_branch_probes": 2248, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 918, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 1996, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1996, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 71, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 918, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 71, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 557, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 75312960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 146377, "avg_nodes": 14637.7, "eval_calls": 117483, "avg_eval_calls": 11748.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 117483, "pattern_eval_ns": 2534604, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.57421924874237, "pattern_frame_queries": 117483, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2534604, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.57421924874237, "pattern_frame_updates": 288140, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3796177185, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13174.76638092594, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25362, "avg_candidate_generations": 2536.2, "candidate_moves_total": 2012165, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.33778881791658, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 664, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 25352, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2011501, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 881364, "avg_legality_checks": 88136.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1413, "root_legality_checks": 664, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 880700, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1413, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3362101, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 336210.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7396594720, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2199.9918265394167, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34517, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3451.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 198801566, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5759.526204478952, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1593, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14317143, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19643, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 150371312, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12908, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32232832, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 373, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1880279, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 91688, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9168.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 878652107, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9583.0654720356, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 128472, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12847.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 401052899, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3121.71445139797, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2186354266, "stage_ordering_ns": 846867648, "stage_eval_ns": 3798711789, "stage_threat_ns": 5320410076, "stage_proof_ns": 346506602, "tactical_annotations": 389990, "root_tactical_annotations": 2047, "search_tactical_annotations": 387943, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 292284, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1737188320, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 469885, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3301059977, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51896, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1864467205, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 146137, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 210322351, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4134, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24122944, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 292274, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36810204, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 110575, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 239285550, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 195171, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 886024194, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 84244, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10906280, "child_limit_applications": 25352, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25352, "child_cap_hits": 25352, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25352, "child_moves_before_total": 2010088, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2010088, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 406073, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 406073, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.28715683180815, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.017395077311456, "tt_hits": 9716, "tt_cutoffs": 1235, "beta_cutoffs": 17636, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2954.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3703.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1150, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 30, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3333333333333335, "search_nodes": 201, "safety_nodes": 683, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 192, "avg_eval_calls": 21.333333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 192, "line_shape_eval_ns": 146111, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 760.9947916666666, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 605, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_max": 80, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 605, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10548, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1172.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22359620, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2119.7971179370497, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3860, "stage_ordering_ns": 440, "stage_eval_ns": 146111, "stage_threat_ns": 19571431, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 393, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19038508, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 202471, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 192, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 277672, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52780, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5773.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 367, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30293, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 142, 157, 111, 110, 68, 98, 66, 125, 126, 141, 109, 185, 124, 143, 129, 130, 146, 113, 83, 158, 128, 173, 189, 171, 199, 203, 188, 155, 69, 55, 67, 65, 70 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 62, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4444444444444446, "search_nodes": 363, "safety_nodes": 1713, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2076, "avg_nodes": 115.33333333333333, "eval_calls": 345, "avg_eval_calls": 19.166666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 345, "line_shape_eval_ns": 302951, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 878.1188405797102, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1467, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.5, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1467, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1467, "avg_legality_checks": 81.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 1467, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22572, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1254.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 45298573, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2006.84799751905, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.16666666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5321, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1773.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5321, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 57, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.1666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 621345, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10900.78947368421, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 330264, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4077.3333333333335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3521517, "stage_ordering_ns": 900, "stage_eval_ns": 302951, "stage_threat_ns": 36511553, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 708, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 35051497, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 47, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 903235, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18060, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 345, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 471871, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 690, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 84950, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 18, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 18, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6886.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7331.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 30213, "avg_search_time_ms": 1777.235294117647, "search_nodes": 282023, "safety_nodes": 348, "corridor_nodes": 13831, "corridor_branch_probes": 14740, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 20, "corridor_depth_exits": 5991, "corridor_neutral_exits": 32, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 13751, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 13751, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 179, "corridor_proof_active": 80, "corridor_proof_quiet": 99, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 52, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5991, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 179, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 179, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1500, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 101773680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 296202, "avg_nodes": 17423.647058823528, "eval_calls": 215270, "avg_eval_calls": 12662.941176470587, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 215270, "pattern_eval_ns": 4645298, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.57893807776281, "pattern_frame_queries": 215270, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4645298, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.57893807776281, "pattern_frame_updates": 563888, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5400538682, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9577.325075192237, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 62717, "avg_candidate_generations": 3689.235294117647, "candidate_moves_total": 5879840, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.75193328762536, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1385, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 62700, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5878455, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 4107529, "avg_legality_checks": 241619.35294117648, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8655, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4107529, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8655, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9139862, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 537638.9411764706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18605519879, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2035.645601541905, "renju_forbidden_checks": 66613, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3918.4117647058824, "renju_forbidden_ns": 321944436, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4833.05715100656, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8657, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 73381165, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23092, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 169852985, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 34790, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 77975715, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 734571, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 282960, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16644.70588235294, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2710262151, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9578.251876590331, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 407125, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23948.529411764706, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1339435502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3289.98588148603, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9508260242, "stage_ordering_ns": 2264405493, "stage_eval_ns": 5405183980, "stage_threat_ns": 12701911104, "stage_proof_ns": 176070290, "tactical_annotations": 1248777, "root_tactical_annotations": 5322, "search_tactical_annotations": 1243455, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 591765, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3484248845, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1900081, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8514614572, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 133157, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4457428170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 295874, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 431818232, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 27860, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 158441020, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 591748, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 75061063, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 443481, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1455178734, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 555121, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2099700980, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 250175, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 37727372, "child_limit_applications": 62700, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 62700, "child_cap_hits": 62700, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 62700, "child_moves_before_total": 5869800, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5869800, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 1005416, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1005416, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.61722488038278, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.035342902711324, "tt_hits": 25131, "tt_cutoffs": 3976, "beta_cutoffs": 48677, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4117647058823529, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2296.294117647059, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2528.823529411765, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 368, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8378, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 82, 97, 98, 95, 84, 94, 93, 70, 83, 81, 113, 128, 85, 86, 99, 71, 141 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8347, "avg_search_time_ms": 927.4444444444445, "search_nodes": 122948, "safety_nodes": 274, "corridor_nodes": 292, "corridor_branch_probes": 343, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 74, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 282, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 282, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 41, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 74, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 49, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 411, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 25912160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1967120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 123514, "avg_nodes": 13723.777777777777, "eval_calls": 98138, "avg_eval_calls": 10904.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 98138, "pattern_eval_ns": 2018958, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.57264260531089, "pattern_frame_queries": 98138, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2018958, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.57264260531089, "pattern_frame_updates": 245822, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2454522788, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9984.959800180619, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23828, "avg_candidate_generations": 2647.5555555555557, "candidate_moves_total": 1837628, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.12053046835655, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 561, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 23819, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1837067, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 793096, "avg_legality_checks": 88121.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 850, "root_legality_checks": 561, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 792535, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 850, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2696832, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 299648.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4855873731, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1800.5844379627652, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24276, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2697.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 84599747, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3484.9129593013677, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1103, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5418062, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13144, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 63358994, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9964, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15519091, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 65, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 303600, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65448, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7272.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 465888663, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7118.455308030803, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 87882, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9764.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 189333518, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2154.406112742086, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1597486696, "stage_ordering_ns": 641592158, "stage_eval_ns": 2456541746, "stage_threat_ns": 3495332197, "stage_proof_ns": 102689273, "tactical_annotations": 281389, "root_tactical_annotations": 1801, "search_tactical_annotations": 279588, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 246497, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1178667949, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 289360, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2132914454, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48050, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1429664262, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123244, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 147818741, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 666, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3021090, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 246488, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25635275, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 55297, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 94213294, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 163438, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 564494291, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 62654, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7274688, "child_limit_applications": 23819, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23819, "child_cap_hits": 23819, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23819, "child_moves_before_total": 1836217, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1836217, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 381197, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 381197, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.09043200806079, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00390444603048, "tt_hits": 8480, "tt_cutoffs": 954, "beta_cutoffs": 17412, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3581.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4470.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 22, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.75, "search_nodes": 73, "safety_nodes": 744, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 817, "avg_nodes": 102.125, "eval_calls": 65, "avg_eval_calls": 8.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 65, "line_shape_eval_ns": 34510, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 530.9230769230769, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 497, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.125, "candidate_moves_max": 72, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 497, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9317, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1164.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17536619, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1882.2173446388322, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3270, "stage_ordering_ns": 380, "stage_eval_ns": 34510, "stage_threat_ns": 13884011, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 138, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 13592501, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 207240, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7880, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 65, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 71950, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 130, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12320, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5496.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6496.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 369, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7898, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 129, 126, 99, 96, 130, 131, 141, 111, 66, 113, 114, 65, 49, 144, 69, 80, 84 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 45, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.090909090909091, "search_nodes": 325, "safety_nodes": 768, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1093, "avg_nodes": 99.36363636363636, "eval_calls": 314, "avg_eval_calls": 28.545454545454547, "line_shape_eval_calls": 314, "line_shape_eval_ns": 296860, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 945.4140127388536, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 737, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.0, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 737, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 737, "avg_legality_checks": 67.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 737, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13728, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1248.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29317202, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2135.5770687645686, "renju_forbidden_checks": 86, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7.818181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1003923, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11673.523255813954, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 191310, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 812613, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 797992, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12276.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.636363636363637, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 446222, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4697.073684210526, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2134680, "stage_ordering_ns": 510, "stage_eval_ns": 296860, "stage_threat_ns": 25788698, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 639, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24248681, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1003805, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11841, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 314, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 453031, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 628, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 83181, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7844, "avg_search_time_ms": 713.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 78681, "safety_nodes": 650, "corridor_nodes": 369, "corridor_branch_probes": 427, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 158, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_plies_followed": 360, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 360, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 42, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 158, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 42, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 39, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 286, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23860240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1993520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 79700, "avg_nodes": 7245.454545454545, "eval_calls": 60447, "avg_eval_calls": 5495.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60447, "pattern_eval_ns": 1316378, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.77739176468642, "pattern_frame_queries": 60447, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1316378, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.77739176468642, "pattern_frame_updates": 157264, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1856688491, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11806.188898921559, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16578, "avg_candidate_generations": 1507.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 1281981, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.33025696706478, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 750, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 16567, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1281231, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 675448, "avg_legality_checks": 61404.36363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10405, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 675448, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10405, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2133045, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 193913.18181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4618947964, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2165.4245287839685, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35604, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3236.7272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 346905851, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9743.45160656106, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10477, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 113316769, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16283, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 173273104, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8688, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 58405692, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 156, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1910286, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81559, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7414.454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 901644250, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11055.116541399477, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 120646, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10967.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 463153122, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3838.9430399681714, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1802622878, "stage_ordering_ns": 544915015, "stage_eval_ns": 1858004869, "stage_threat_ns": 3518904310, "stage_proof_ns": 74122741, "tactical_annotations": 287916, "root_tactical_annotations": 1285, "search_tactical_annotations": 286631, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 158079, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 938622839, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 282215, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2431929672, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33526, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1272459013, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79034, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 114805980, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 804, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4805758, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 158068, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21087443, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 74118, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 422445757, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 153123, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 717328823, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 60675, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7652618, "child_limit_applications": 16567, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16567, "child_cap_hits": 16567, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16567, "child_moves_before_total": 1270826, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1270826, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 268741, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 268741, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.70827548741474, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.221464356853986, "tt_hits": 6340, "tt_cutoffs": 1618, "beta_cutoffs": 12579, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5059.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5786.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1834, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 370, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17069, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 67, 127, 126, 129, 140, 130, 131, 98, 83, 114, 82, 52, 84, 146, 162, 81, 69, 111, 68, 66, 99, 115, 54, 39, 40, 96, 26 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 17024, "avg_search_time_ms": 1216.0, "search_nodes": 186063, "safety_nodes": 384, "corridor_nodes": 15477, "corridor_branch_probes": 16005, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 8906, "corridor_neutral_exits": 58, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 15439, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 15439, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 58, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 8906, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 89, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 713, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 22207600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2020240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 201924, "avg_nodes": 14423.142857142857, "eval_calls": 142623, "avg_eval_calls": 10187.357142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 142623, "pattern_eval_ns": 2958076, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.740525721657797, "pattern_frame_queries": 142623, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2958076, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.740525721657797, "pattern_frame_updates": 372002, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3906526903, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10501.359946989533, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41023, "avg_candidate_generations": 2930.214285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 3534875, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.16812519805963, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1063, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 41009, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3533812, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1405126, "avg_legality_checks": 100366.14285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2617, "root_legality_checks": 1063, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1404063, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2616, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5993173, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 428083.78571428574, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10297417589, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1718.1912801449248, "renju_forbidden_checks": 77941, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5567.214285714285, "renju_forbidden_ns": 241602005, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3099.806327863384, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3916, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18492127, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 36258, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 150955861, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 33888, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 59070267, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3879, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13083750, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 178858, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12775.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1214501642, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6790.312102338167, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 232741, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16624.35714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 499660063, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2146.850202585707, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2890360524, "stage_ordering_ns": 1190450535, "stage_eval_ns": 3909484979, "stage_threat_ns": 8003033106, "stage_proof_ns": 952134923, "tactical_annotations": 721002, "root_tactical_annotations": 3418, "search_tactical_annotations": 717584, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 403078, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2130495720, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1295044, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5382448605, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 88729, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2741624356, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 201532, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 267482483, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 31062, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 159187017, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 403064, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43071225, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 219550, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 282590336, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 336185, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1172707180, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 165267, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20348056, "child_limit_applications": 41009, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41009, "child_cap_hits": 41009, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41009, "child_moves_before_total": 3531196, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3531196, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 694447, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 694447, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.1078299885391, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.934014484625326, "tt_hits": 16512, "tt_cutoffs": 2370, "beta_cutoffs": 31951, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 4.357142857142857, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 4.357142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4223.357142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4794.785714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 33, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.5384615384615383, "search_nodes": 163, "safety_nodes": 1387, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1550, "avg_nodes": 119.23076923076923, "eval_calls": 150, "avg_eval_calls": 11.538461538461538, "line_shape_eval_calls": 150, "line_shape_eval_ns": 99101, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 660.6733333333333, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 998, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.76923076923077, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 998, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15229, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1171.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24431447, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1604.2712587825858, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.3076923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51860, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12965.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 51860, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6380, "stage_ordering_ns": 650, "stage_eval_ns": 99101, "stage_threat_ns": 20513262, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 313, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20022958, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 271322, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10840, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 150, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 187402, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 300, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31580, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6459.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7074.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 371, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4575, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 114, 115, 127, 142, 94, 96, 68, 140, 128, 95, 98, 83, 143, 158, 174, 125, 80, 155 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 20, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.0, "search_nodes": 252, "safety_nodes": 688, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 940, "avg_nodes": 94.0, "eval_calls": 242, "avg_eval_calls": 24.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 242, "line_shape_eval_ns": 101901, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 421.07851239669424, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 652, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.2, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 652, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 652, "avg_legality_checks": 65.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 652, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12495, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14690544, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1175.713805522209, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3510, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1755.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3510, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 225231, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8043.964285714285, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 121530, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2964.1463414634145, "stage_move_gen_ns": 987662, "stage_ordering_ns": 410, "stage_eval_ns": 101901, "stage_threat_ns": 12732611, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 494, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 12153788, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 311981, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 242, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 226202, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 484, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40640, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5998.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6798.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 4546, "avg_search_time_ms": 454.6, "search_nodes": 85680, "safety_nodes": 366, "corridor_nodes": 891, "corridor_branch_probes": 969, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 350, "corridor_neutral_exits": 40, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 873, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 873, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 36, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 40, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 350, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 415, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 43724720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 86937, "avg_nodes": 8693.7, "eval_calls": 67857, "avg_eval_calls": 6785.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67857, "pattern_eval_ns": 1313099, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.350973370470253, "pattern_frame_queries": 67857, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1313099, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.350973370470253, "pattern_frame_updates": 171276, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 962395108, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5618.972348723697, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16891, "avg_candidate_generations": 1689.1, "candidate_moves_total": 1343965, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.56692913385827, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 675, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 16881, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1343290, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 802953, "avg_legality_checks": 80295.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 485, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 802953, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 485, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2120477, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 212047.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2613581937, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1232.5443459183948, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12605, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1260.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19619771, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1556.5070210234035, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 487, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2929005, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1065, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 5742143, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11046, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10902293, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 46330, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 62758, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6275.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 379328566, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6044.306160170815, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92073, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9207.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 190263678, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2066.443778306344, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1155423961, "stage_ordering_ns": 337877715, "stage_eval_ns": 963708207, "stage_threat_ns": 1996110868, "stage_proof_ns": 52090585, "tactical_annotations": 254951, "root_tactical_annotations": 1458, "search_tactical_annotations": 253493, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 173140, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 623987844, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 276685, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1261028541, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34508, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 737007955, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86565, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 83422177, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1854, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6306640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 173130, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14256691, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 55108, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 152998939, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 131863, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 348009197, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 67980, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7108975, "child_limit_applications": 16881, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16881, "child_cap_hits": 16881, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16881, "child_moves_before_total": 1342805, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1342805, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 270241, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 270241, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.5453468396422, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.008589538534448, "tt_hits": 6874, "tt_cutoffs": 900, "beta_cutoffs": 12408, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5469.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6269.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1919, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 372, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10988, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 96, 94, 142, 78, 62, 114, 80, 64, 127, 97, 141, 99, 144, 128, 143, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10953, "avg_search_time_ms": 1095.3, "search_nodes": 147787, "safety_nodes": 251, "corridor_nodes": 1336, "corridor_branch_probes": 1516, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 558, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 1317, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1317, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 558, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 70, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 559, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 71327040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 149374, "avg_nodes": 14937.4, "eval_calls": 120613, "avg_eval_calls": 12061.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 120613, "pattern_eval_ns": 2425991, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.11384344971106, "pattern_frame_queries": 120613, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2425991, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.11384344971106, "pattern_frame_updates": 295490, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3501510799, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11849.845338251718, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25918, "avg_candidate_generations": 2591.8, "candidate_moves_total": 2134580, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.3589783162281, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 681, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 25908, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2133899, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 916584, "avg_legality_checks": 91658.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2389, "root_legality_checks": 681, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 915903, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2388, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3334661, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 333466.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6374926647, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1911.7165573951895, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37228, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3722.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 230447782, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6190.173579026539, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2516, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23087548, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22353, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 167993208, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11916, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 35325278, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 443, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4041748, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89890, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8989.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 761453216, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8470.944665702526, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 124633, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12463.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 348285284, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2794.486885495816, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1882651493, "stage_ordering_ns": 751862520, "stage_eval_ns": 3503936790, "stage_threat_ns": 4513083176, "stage_proof_ns": 240259553, "tactical_annotations": 355589, "root_tactical_annotations": 2115, "search_tactical_annotations": 353474, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 298278, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1514102504, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 407855, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2749880399, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52753, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1567232325, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 149134, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 191394130, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2778, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14588613, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 298268, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32524887, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 85409, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 219447084, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 190115, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 764201054, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 80065, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10592643, "child_limit_applications": 25908, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25908, "child_cap_hits": 25908, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25908, "child_moves_before_total": 2131511, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2131511, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 414953, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 414953, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.27230971128608, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.016404199475065, "tt_hits": 9852, "tt_cutoffs": 1224, "beta_cutoffs": 17976, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4138.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4938.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1332, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 25, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.7777777777777777, "search_nodes": 203, "safety_nodes": 699, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 902, "avg_nodes": 100.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 194, "avg_eval_calls": 21.555555555555557, "line_shape_eval_calls": 194, "line_shape_eval_ns": 116130, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 598.6082474226804, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 615, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.33333333333333, "candidate_moves_max": 80, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 615, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10485, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1165.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18177701, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1733.6863137815928, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46690, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11672.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 46690, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3830, "stage_ordering_ns": 450, "stage_eval_ns": 116130, "stage_threat_ns": 15856202, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 397, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15395001, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 193970, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 194, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 227441, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 388, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39790, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5775.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6664.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 373, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7156, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 83, 128, 81, 94, 82, 84, 80, 96, 79 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.857142857142857, "search_nodes": 290, "safety_nodes": 243, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 533, "avg_nodes": 76.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 283, "avg_eval_calls": 40.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 283, "line_shape_eval_ns": 203610, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 719.469964664311, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 408, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 408, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 408, "avg_legality_checks": 58.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 408, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1222.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17506817, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2045.1889018691588, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1011108, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 36111.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53021, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 958087, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 314382, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11643.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.714285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 177522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4438.05, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1083444, "stage_ordering_ns": 400, "stage_eval_ns": 203610, "stage_threat_ns": 16412697, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 573, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15528260, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 426032, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 388054, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 566, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 70351, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 7122, "avg_search_time_ms": 1017.4285714285714, "search_nodes": 81524, "safety_nodes": 215, "corridor_nodes": 175, "corridor_branch_probes": 202, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 64, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_plies_followed": 170, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 170, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 35, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 277, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23860880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1992240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 81914, "avg_nodes": 11702.0, "eval_calls": 66304, "avg_eval_calls": 9472.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 66304, "pattern_eval_ns": 1372029, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.6930049469112, "pattern_frame_queries": 66304, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1372029, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.6930049469112, "pattern_frame_updates": 162990, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1968666044, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12078.446800417203, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14504, "avg_candidate_generations": 2072.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1108875, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.45304743519029, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 421, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 14497, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1108454, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 568889, "avg_legality_checks": 81269.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8214, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 568889, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8214, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1979357, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 282765.28571428574, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4070251790, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2056.350516859768, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40515, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5787.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 395894412, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9771.551573491299, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8388, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 86298960, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24764, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 254063879, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7285, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 54630249, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 78, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 901324, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74725, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10675.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 795259806, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10642.486530612245, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110996, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15856.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 413567662, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3725.9690619481785, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1453952381, "stage_ordering_ns": 454621443, "stage_eval_ns": 1970038073, "stage_threat_ns": 3148807754, "stage_proof_ns": 61433181, "tactical_annotations": 248563, "root_tactical_annotations": 1147, "search_tactical_annotations": 247416, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 163409, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 923299888, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 230894, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2082946765, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29264, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1076849821, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 81701, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113218352, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 412, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2001500, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 163402, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19567511, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56513, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 368522629, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 133501, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 628203222, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 58549, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7773738, "child_limit_applications": 14497, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14497, "child_cap_hits": 14497, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14497, "child_moves_before_total": 1100240, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1100240, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 237056, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 237056, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.89432296337174, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.3520728426571, "tt_hits": 4939, "tt_cutoffs": 694, "beta_cutoffs": 10157, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 4.142857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 4.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2983.5714285714284, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3972.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1866, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 374, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20787, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 109, 144, 96, 95, 97, 127, 99, 100, 143, 129, 126, 125, 80, 159, 114, 130, 131, 158, 116, 160, 176, 161, 157, 162 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 20734, "avg_search_time_ms": 1481.0, "search_nodes": 210887, "safety_nodes": 137, "corridor_nodes": 16892, "corridor_branch_probes": 17138, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 8644, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 16847, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 16847, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 147, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 102, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 8644, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 147, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 145, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1227, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 118629840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1980880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 227916, "avg_nodes": 16279.714285714286, "eval_calls": 169364, "avg_eval_calls": 12097.42857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 169364, "pattern_eval_ns": 3469360, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.484636640608393, "pattern_frame_queries": 169364, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3469360, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.484636640608393, "pattern_frame_updates": 421650, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4758279126, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11284.902468872287, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39800, "avg_candidate_generations": 2842.8571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 3054155, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.73756281407036, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 884, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 39786, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3053271, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1227990, "avg_legality_checks": 87713.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2230, "root_legality_checks": 884, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1227106, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2228, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6149116, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 439222.5714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12613304434, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2051.238655117256, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39541, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2824.3571428571427, "renju_forbidden_ns": 172199770, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4354.9675020864415, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2562, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21715897, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18075, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 105141671, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15296, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 34266277, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3608, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 11075925, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 172341, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12310.07142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1392403559, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8079.351744506531, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 222424, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15887.42857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 563759213, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2534.6150280545266, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2918497472, "stage_ordering_ns": 1246531020, "stage_eval_ns": 4761748486, "stage_threat_ns": 10055111494, "stage_proof_ns": 1685926637, "tactical_annotations": 624618, "root_tactical_annotations": 3411, "search_tactical_annotations": 621207, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 455652, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2751760279, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1387296, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6700743672, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 88189, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3207314211, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 227819, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 334905149, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 33988, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 196008997, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 455638, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 54832098, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 191857, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 319930430, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 288735, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1177732850, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 144026, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16861299, "child_limit_applications": 39786, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39786, "child_cap_hits": 39786, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39786, "child_moves_before_total": 3051043, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3051043, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 637784, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 637784, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.68634695621576, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.03036243904891, "tt_hits": 16303, "tt_cutoffs": 1675, "beta_cutoffs": 28686, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2855.714285714286, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3382.785714285714, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 883, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 41, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1538461538461537, "search_nodes": 144, "safety_nodes": 1187, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1331, "avg_nodes": 102.38461538461539, "eval_calls": 131, "avg_eval_calls": 10.076923076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 131, "line_shape_eval_ns": 112910, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 861.9083969465648, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 821, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.15384615384615, "candidate_moves_max": 79, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 821, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15051, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1157.7692307692307, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29483287, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1958.8922330742143, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.6153846153846154, "renju_forbidden_ns": 88820, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11102.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 88820, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5850, "stage_ordering_ns": 710, "stage_eval_ns": 112910, "stage_threat_ns": 24255289, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 275, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 23651475, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 381114, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13461, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 131, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 189150, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 262, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33550, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6458.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7074.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 375, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8258, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 82, 67, 98, 156, 114, 66, 130, 146, 83, 143, 96, 158, 173, 170, 184, 144, 145, 140, 141, 99, 95, 94, 111, 125, 126, 81, 110, 155, 185, 157, 159, 154 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 59, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4705882352941178, "search_nodes": 564, "safety_nodes": 1008, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1572, "avg_nodes": 92.47058823529412, "eval_calls": 547, "avg_eval_calls": 32.1764705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 547, "line_shape_eval_ns": 640271, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1170.5137111517367, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1302, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.58823529411765, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1302, "avg_legality_checks": 76.58823529411765, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20971, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1233.5882352941176, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 41812643, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1993.8316246244815, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.2941176470588234, "renju_forbidden_ns": 657901, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11748.232142857143, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 131351, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 526550, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.7058823529411766, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 435142, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9459.608695652174, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 61, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.588235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 209861, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3440.344262295082, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3260126, "stage_ordering_ns": 920, "stage_eval_ns": 640271, "stage_threat_ns": 36630040, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1111, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 35191955, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 544272, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17670, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 547, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 761113, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1094, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 132700, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6821.470588235294, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7292.058823529412, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 8180, "avg_search_time_ms": 481.1764705882353, "search_nodes": 82137, "safety_nodes": 1995, "corridor_nodes": 3116, "corridor_branch_probes": 3492, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 21, "corridor_depth_exits": 1558, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 25, "corridor_plies_followed": 3089, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3089, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 39, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 46, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1558, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 63, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 364, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 150440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 23440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 87248, "avg_nodes": 5132.235294117647, "eval_calls": 63712, "avg_eval_calls": 3747.764705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 63712, "pattern_eval_ns": 1312489, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.600342164741335, "pattern_frame_queries": 63712, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1312489, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.600342164741335, "pattern_frame_updates": 164120, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2049522529, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12487.951066292957, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16943, "avg_candidate_generations": 996.6470588235294, "candidate_moves_total": 1424091, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.05187983237916, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1328, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 16926, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1422763, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 669480, "avg_legality_checks": 39381.17647058824, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4602, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 669480, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4602, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2254331, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 132607.70588235295, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4649236629, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2062.357581473173, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36270, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2133.529411764706, "renju_forbidden_ns": 414547002, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11429.473449131514, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6478, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 87670866, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15290, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 183994799, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14361, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 141157713, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 141, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1723624, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81731, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4807.705882352941, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 904350893, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11064.967919149405, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 119304, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7017.882352941177, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 456070142, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3822.756504392141, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1659112236, "stage_ordering_ns": 551948349, "stage_eval_ns": 2050835018, "stage_threat_ns": 3792542750, "stage_proof_ns": 80807236, "tactical_annotations": 362259, "root_tactical_annotations": 836, "search_tactical_annotations": 361423, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 170447, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1031410684, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 486308, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2567907745, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35376, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1260769420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85215, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125228685, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6310, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 40409059, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 170430, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20770042, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 99218, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 392467795, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 200600, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 801949532, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 62441, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6816535, "child_limit_applications": 16926, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16926, "child_cap_hits": 16926, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16926, "child_moves_before_total": 1418161, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1418161, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 282544, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 282544, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.78595060853125, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.69289849935011, "tt_hits": 5951, "tt_cutoffs": 1422, "beta_cutoffs": 12852, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6420.411764705882, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6891.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1838, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 376, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28266, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 98, 143, 82, 158, 173, 142, 97, 67, 96, 99, 114, 66, 94, 95, 68, 110, 84, 126, 174, 157, 52, 100, 175, 172, 83, 187, 202, 81, 53, 38, 54, 40, 55, 51, 56 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 28202, "avg_search_time_ms": 1566.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 266101, "safety_nodes": 496, "corridor_nodes": 42833, "corridor_branch_probes": 44937, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 28185, "corridor_neutral_exits": 27, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 42756, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 42756, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 166, "corridor_proof_active": 77, "corridor_proof_quiet": 89, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 27, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 28185, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 166, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 162, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1366, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 105301160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1990800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 309430, "avg_nodes": 17190.555555555555, "eval_calls": 209458, "avg_eval_calls": 11636.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 209458, "pattern_eval_ns": 4227331, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.18223701171595, "pattern_frame_queries": 209458, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4227331, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.18223701171595, "pattern_frame_updates": 532038, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6773929933, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12732.04157033896, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52984, "avg_candidate_generations": 2943.5555555555557, "candidate_moves_total": 4386362, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.78653933262872, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1314, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 52966, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4385048, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1668784, "avg_legality_checks": 92710.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1244, "root_legality_checks": 1314, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1667470, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1243, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9753968, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 541887.1111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17293536602, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1772.9745065802963, "renju_forbidden_checks": 69958, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3886.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 305368512, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4365.026330083764, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2010, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14564156, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33153, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 205409500, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28250, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 64905278, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6545, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 20489578, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 325105, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18061.38888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2410062704, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7413.182522569631, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 431273, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23959.61111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1067065364, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2474.222508712579, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3491310884, "stage_ordering_ns": 1503798415, "stage_eval_ns": 6778157264, "stage_threat_ns": 14192567840, "stage_proof_ns": 2146825278, "tactical_annotations": 1326485, "root_tactical_annotations": 4225, "search_tactical_annotations": 1322260, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 617900, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3722186116, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2574267, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9446218920, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 119975, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3944650814, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 308941, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 437556592, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 85844, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 480690688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 617882, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69281733, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 464971, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 523589591, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 567726, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2013647144, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 293788, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 36633791, "child_limit_applications": 52966, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52966, "child_cap_hits": 52966, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52966, "child_moves_before_total": 4383805, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4383805, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 941131, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 941131, "child_moves_after_max": 32, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 32, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.76639731148283, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.7685873956878, "tt_hits": 22549, "tt_cutoffs": 3595, "beta_cutoffs": 40000, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3888888888888889, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2549.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2990.222222222222, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 665, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 46, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.7058823529411766, "search_nodes": 164, "safety_nodes": 1838, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2002, "avg_nodes": 117.76470588235294, "eval_calls": 147, "avg_eval_calls": 8.647058823529411, "line_shape_eval_calls": 147, "line_shape_eval_ns": 137451, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 935.0408163265306, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1250, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.52941176470588, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1250, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19522, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1148.3529411764705, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 35052498, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1795.5382645220777, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5882352941176471, "renju_forbidden_ns": 68320, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6832.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 68320, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8140, "stage_ordering_ns": 940, "stage_eval_ns": 137451, "stage_threat_ns": 28396024, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 311, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 27813774, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 380810, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17060, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 172090, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 294, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29350, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6821.764705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7292.35294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 377, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6789, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 109, 108, 125, 97, 96, 81, 65, 128, 129, 98, 95, 80, 140, 155, 141, 83, 143, 68 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 34, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4, "search_nodes": 261, "safety_nodes": 575, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 836, "avg_nodes": 83.6, "eval_calls": 251, "avg_eval_calls": 25.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 251, "line_shape_eval_ns": 187480, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 746.9322709163347, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 565, "avg_candidate_moves": 56.5, "candidate_moves_max": 73, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 565, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 565, "avg_legality_checks": 56.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 565, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12078, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1207.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24183607, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2002.285726113595, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 118390, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9865.833333333334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21710, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 96680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 452051, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10512.813953488372, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 62, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 245070, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3952.7419354838707, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1422145, "stage_ordering_ns": 530, "stage_eval_ns": 187480, "stage_threat_ns": 20889089, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 512, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19845264, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 626151, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 251, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 354133, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 502, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63541, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6744, "avg_search_time_ms": 674.4, "search_nodes": 66501, "safety_nodes": 463, "corridor_nodes": 1054, "corridor_branch_probes": 1176, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 325, "corridor_neutral_exits": 56, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 1032, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1032, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 57, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 325, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 550, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 18159440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1987280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68018, "avg_nodes": 6801.8, "eval_calls": 49722, "avg_eval_calls": 4972.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49722, "pattern_eval_ns": 1033101, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.77754313985761, "pattern_frame_queries": 49722, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1033101, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.77754313985761, "pattern_frame_updates": 132918, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1462751045, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11004.913141937133, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15537, "avg_candidate_generations": 1553.7, "candidate_moves_total": 1084153, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.77878612344726, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 587, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 15527, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1083566, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 659610, "avg_legality_checks": 65961.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1347, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 659610, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1347, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2062724, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 206272.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4135907794, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2005.070864546105, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18486, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1848.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 82936128, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4486.429081467056, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1357, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13802432, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4695, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44475984, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12392, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24155421, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 502291, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 79810, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7981.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 770391810, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9652.82307981456, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 115472, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11547.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 379931934, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3290.2516107801025, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1561888463, "stage_ordering_ns": 450477590, "stage_eval_ns": 1463784146, "stage_threat_ns": 3129052859, "stage_proof_ns": 107379353, "tactical_annotations": 250794, "root_tactical_annotations": 1172, "search_tactical_annotations": 249622, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 135130, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 812875696, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 295880, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2180393713, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31967, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1166721287, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99587613, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2202, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11810902, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 135120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16830157, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 57775, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 347970174, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 131386, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 608664580, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 61633, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7554778, "child_limit_applications": 15527, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15527, "child_cap_hits": 15527, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15527, "child_moves_before_total": 1082219, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1082219, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 248659, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 248659, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.69916918915438, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01461969472532, "tt_hits": 6257, "tt_cutoffs": 1210, "beta_cutoffs": 12240, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4667.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5467.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1843, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 378, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8901, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 141, 155, 99, 85, 140, 139, 97, 123, 107, 108, 109, 153, 167, 138, 93, 168 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8867, "avg_search_time_ms": 886.7, "search_nodes": 127981, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 741, "corridor_branch_probes": 871, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 244, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 725, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 725, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 244, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 422, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 53779280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 128953, "avg_nodes": 12895.3, "eval_calls": 104334, "avg_eval_calls": 10433.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 104334, "pattern_eval_ns": 2149018, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.597485000095848, "pattern_frame_queries": 104334, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2149018, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.597485000095848, "pattern_frame_updates": 255878, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2806822956, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10969.379766920172, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22300, "avg_candidate_generations": 2230.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1788494, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.20152466367713, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 22290, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1787854, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 743916, "avg_legality_checks": 74391.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 484, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 743276, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 483, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2734044, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 273404.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5108819319, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1868.5944041134671, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25941, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2594.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 93486536, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3603.813885355229, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1082, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3897061, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14929, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 75115733, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9797, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14033261, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 133, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 440481, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65681, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6568.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 478438499, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7284.275498241501, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 85050, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8505.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 199534015, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2346.0789535567314, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1560473625, "stage_ordering_ns": 618551158, "stage_eval_ns": 2808971974, "stage_threat_ns": 3668638925, "stage_proof_ns": 161930524, "tactical_annotations": 341407, "root_tactical_annotations": 1928, "search_tactical_annotations": 339479, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 257450, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1279889092, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 361986, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2179697363, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45200, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1404816556, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128720, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 165555045, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1562, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6413346, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 257440, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28504660, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 94380, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 89202296, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 170881, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 595256798, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76146, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8579419, "child_limit_applications": 22290, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22290, "child_cap_hits": 22290, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22290, "child_moves_before_total": 1787371, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1787371, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 356773, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 356773, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.18712427097353, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.005966801256168, "tt_hits": 9226, "tt_cutoffs": 1315, "beta_cutoffs": 15398, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4684.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5484.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1177, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44520, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 767.5862068965517, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19515273, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1869.9954963587581, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 47090, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11772.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 47090, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4160, "stage_ordering_ns": 420, "stage_eval_ns": 44520, "stage_threat_ns": 15900943, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15648350, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 146982, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8620, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90310, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15301, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 379, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16973, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 113, 66, 141, 99, 126, 156, 125, 128, 109, 157, 79, 143, 124, 123, 94, 139, 64 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 43, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.909090909090909, "search_nodes": 196, "safety_nodes": 750, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 946, "avg_nodes": 86.0, "eval_calls": 185, "avg_eval_calls": 16.818181818181817, "line_shape_eval_calls": 185, "line_shape_eval_ns": 132620, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 716.8648648648649, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 670, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.90909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 670, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 670, "avg_legality_checks": 60.90909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "root_legality_checks": 670, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13538, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1230.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28972340, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2140.0753434776184, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.454545454545454, "renju_forbidden_ns": 702742, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11712.366666666667, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 142940, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 559802, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 806363, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12035.268656716418, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 99, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 453781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4583.646464646465, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1972389, "stage_ordering_ns": 580, "stage_eval_ns": 132620, "stage_threat_ns": 24063469, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 381, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22778322, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 951744, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11850, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 282861, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 370, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50542, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 16922, "avg_search_time_ms": 1538.3636363636363, "search_nodes": 174160, "safety_nodes": 196, "corridor_nodes": 3818, "corridor_branch_probes": 4296, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1748, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 3787, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3787, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 85, "corridor_proof_active": 31, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1748, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 85, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 83, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 686, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 63472480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1991040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 178174, "avg_nodes": 16197.636363636364, "eval_calls": 141414, "avg_eval_calls": 12855.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 141414, "pattern_eval_ns": 3084691, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.813193884622457, "pattern_frame_queries": 141414, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3084691, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.813193884622457, "pattern_frame_updates": 348226, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4622168540, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13273.473376485386, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30689, "avg_candidate_generations": 2789.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 2395440, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.05532927107433, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 693, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 30678, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2394747, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 1360960, "avg_legality_checks": 123723.63636363637, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15893, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1360960, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15893, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4766663, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 433333.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10019756367, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2102.0484072400336, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58791, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5344.636363636364, "renju_forbidden_ns": 553752353, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9418.998707285129, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15893, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 166674965, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 31010, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 317013497, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11665, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 67496744, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 223, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2567147, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 194067, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17642.454545454544, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2084313861, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10740.176645179243, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 283883, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25807.545454545456, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1074340852, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3784.449410496578, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3541413168, "stage_ordering_ns": 947022812, "stage_eval_ns": 4625253231, "stage_threat_ns": 7626184222, "stage_proof_ns": 114245769, "tactical_annotations": 754227, "root_tactical_annotations": 2343, "search_tactical_annotations": 751884, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 355981, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2189955474, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 853384, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5051228444, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 63403, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2254544179, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 177985, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 268202050, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7744, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 46016370, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 355970, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45577795, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 236581, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1066858254, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 344056, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1568643261, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 173590, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 25204089, "child_limit_applications": 30678, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30678, "child_cap_hits": 30678, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30678, "child_moves_before_total": 2378854, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2378854, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 523840, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 523840, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.5426690136254, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.075428645935197, "tt_hits": 12000, "tt_cutoffs": 2021, "beta_cutoffs": 21529, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.5454545454545454, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2678.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3144.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1138, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 380, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28911, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 81, 126, 67, 141, 156, 127, 95, 53, 82, 52, 83, 80, 85, 84, 51, 99, 65, 113, 155, 142, 37, 79, 154, 157, 66, 172, 187, 68, 36, 21, 35, 19, 34, 38, 33 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 28841, "avg_search_time_ms": 1602.2777777777778, "search_nodes": 259571, "safety_nodes": 504, "corridor_nodes": 44043, "corridor_branch_probes": 45731, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 30073, "corridor_neutral_exits": 65, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 43975, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 43975, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 154, "corridor_proof_active": 68, "corridor_proof_quiet": 86, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 65, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 30073, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 154, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 150, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 2, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1213, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 95425840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 304118, "avg_nodes": 16895.444444444445, "eval_calls": 203218, "avg_eval_calls": 11289.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 203218, "pattern_eval_ns": 4309730, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.20742257083526, "pattern_frame_queries": 203218, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4309730, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.20742257083526, "pattern_frame_updates": 518978, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6167608939, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11884.143333628786, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52850, "avg_candidate_generations": 2936.1111111111113, "candidate_moves_total": 4360812, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.51299905392621, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1324, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 52832, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4359488, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1648066, "avg_legality_checks": 91559.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1071, "root_legality_checks": 1324, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1646742, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1070, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9005357, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 500297.6111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17705164912, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1966.0702970465247, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60765, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3375.8333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 241869165, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3980.402616637867, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1948, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12181738, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28063, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 150613791, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24932, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 59626368, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5822, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 19447268, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 298914, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16606.333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2363090810, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7905.587593756064, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 384096, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21338.666666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1004647560, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2615.6157835541117, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3736636419, "stage_ordering_ns": 1558083713, "stage_eval_ns": 6171918669, "stage_threat_ns": 14806364792, "stage_proof_ns": 2467953052, "tactical_annotations": 1285277, "root_tactical_annotations": 4268, "search_tactical_annotations": 1281009, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 607254, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3916180044, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2475043, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9738744727, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 119559, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4028540863, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 303618, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 457337257, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 88258, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 585516545, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 607236, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 71673718, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 482912, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 570195588, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 522578, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1856222309, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 279787, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 36912501, "child_limit_applications": 52832, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52832, "child_cap_hits": 52832, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52832, "child_moves_before_total": 4358418, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4358418, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 936713, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 936713, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.49579800121138, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.730031041792852, "tt_hits": 22624, "tt_cutoffs": 3439, "beta_cutoffs": 40089, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3122.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3524.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 653, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 52, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0588235294117645, "search_nodes": 164, "safety_nodes": 1859, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2023, "avg_nodes": 119.0, "eval_calls": 147, "avg_eval_calls": 8.647058823529411, "line_shape_eval_calls": 147, "line_shape_eval_ns": 203961, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1387.4897959183672, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1268, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.58823529411765, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1268, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19582, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1151.8823529411766, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 39537400, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2019.0685323256052, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5882352941176471, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64191, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6419.1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 64191, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8940, "stage_ordering_ns": 870, "stage_eval_ns": 203961, "stage_threat_ns": 32353934, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 311, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 31643779, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 442221, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18401, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 229274, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 294, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38660, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6821.529411764706, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7292.117647058823, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 381, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16098, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 110, 109, 96, 100, 95, 128, 86, 99, 101, 84, 129, 54, 69, 116, 68, 82, 130, 50, 53, 66 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 43, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.909090909090909, "search_nodes": 274, "safety_nodes": 666, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 940, "avg_nodes": 85.45454545454545, "eval_calls": 263, "avg_eval_calls": 23.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 263, "line_shape_eval_ns": 252970, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 961.8631178707225, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 665, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.45454545454545, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 665, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 665, "avg_legality_checks": 60.45454545454545, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 665, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13559, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1232.6363636363637, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28686584, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2115.6858175381667, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.909090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 359702, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11240.6875, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 68590, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 291112, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.636363636363637, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 898633, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12310.04109589041, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.181818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 508651, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4541.526785714285, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1810129, "stage_ordering_ns": 460, "stage_eval_ns": 252970, "stage_threat_ns": 24634717, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 537, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 23101721, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1083305, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12140, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 263, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 380971, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 68720, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 16046, "avg_search_time_ms": 1458.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 155969, "safety_nodes": 196, "corridor_nodes": 3844, "corridor_branch_probes": 4495, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1589, "corridor_neutral_exits": 32, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 3808, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3808, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 36, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 32, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1589, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 99, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 821, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 69543680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1993680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 160009, "avg_nodes": 14546.272727272728, "eval_calls": 125269, "avg_eval_calls": 11388.09090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 125269, "pattern_eval_ns": 2697320, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.532222656842475, "pattern_frame_queries": 125269, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2697320, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.532222656842475, "pattern_frame_updates": 311840, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4130905829, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13246.87605502822, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28949, "avg_candidate_generations": 2631.7272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 2237814, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.30194479947494, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 680, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 28938, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2237134, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 1318241, "avg_legality_checks": 119840.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10736, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1318241, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10736, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4683967, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 425815.1818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9741145451, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2079.67849709445, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35778, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3252.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 346193026, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9676.1424897982, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10736, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 116407434, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17528, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 180542006, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7369, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 47552758, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 145, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1690828, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 201849, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18349.909090909092, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2265799058, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11225.218148219708, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 305648, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27786.18181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1208491791, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3953.8678185363556, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3365169487, "stage_ordering_ns": 919626795, "stage_eval_ns": 4133603149, "stage_threat_ns": 7421286842, "stage_proof_ns": 141157200, "tactical_annotations": 693524, "root_tactical_annotations": 2456, "search_tactical_annotations": 691068, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 319667, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1965380759, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 818287, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5107856728, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59986, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2171010830, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 159828, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 239265209, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7816, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 45967336, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 319656, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40951610, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 221559, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1215269085, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 307055, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1533094158, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 164910, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21865200, "child_limit_applications": 28938, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28938, "child_cap_hits": 28938, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28938, "child_moves_before_total": 2226398, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2226398, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 510761, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 510761, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.93683046513235, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.65018315018315, "tt_hits": 11727, "tt_cutoffs": 1713, "beta_cutoffs": 20843, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2896.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3441.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1859, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 382, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8489, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 82, 66, 130, 146, 81, 80, 128, 94, 52, 109, 110, 64, 48, 79, 49, 124 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8450, "avg_search_time_ms": 845.0, "search_nodes": 98420, "safety_nodes": 228, "corridor_nodes": 903, "corridor_branch_probes": 1050, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 308, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 887, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 887, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 308, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 422, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 53783440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 99551, "avg_nodes": 9955.1, "eval_calls": 76304, "avg_eval_calls": 7630.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 76304, "pattern_eval_ns": 1653805, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.673896519186414, "pattern_frame_queries": 76304, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1653805, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.673896519186414, "pattern_frame_updates": 196756, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2295023474, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11664.31251905914, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20856, "avg_candidate_generations": 2085.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1600888, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.759110088224, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 638, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 20846, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1600250, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 575014, "avg_legality_checks": 57501.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 227, "root_legality_checks": 638, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 574376, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 226, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2163229, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 216322.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4911119785, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2270.2727196242286, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19988, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1998.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 84983280, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4251.71502901741, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 649, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3450330, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10757, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 63357572, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8464, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17613424, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 118, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 561954, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48577, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4857.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 433112997, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8916.009572431398, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 62671, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6267.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 177343953, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2829.761021844234, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1453668910, "stage_ordering_ns": 659988054, "stage_eval_ns": 2296677279, "stage_threat_ns": 3778761007, "stage_proof_ns": 223888595, "tactical_annotations": 311808, "root_tactical_annotations": 1929, "search_tactical_annotations": 309879, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 198652, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1205041206, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 336616, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2380454573, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42399, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1599741611, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 99321, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 147209290, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1886, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10442624, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 198642, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25673517, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 89545, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 83597445, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 143116, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 544261875, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79147, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9939797, "child_limit_applications": 20846, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20846, "child_cap_hits": 20846, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20846, "child_moves_before_total": 1600024, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1600024, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 333587, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 333587, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.75448527295404, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002446512520386, "tt_hits": 9136, "tt_cutoffs": 1228, "beta_cutoffs": 15821, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4377.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5177.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1206, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 820, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 887, "avg_nodes": 98.55555555555556, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 47641, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 821.3965517241379, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 580, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10420, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1157.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22132326, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2124.0236084452977, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.1111111111111112, "renju_forbidden_ns": 67021, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6702.1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 67021, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3990, "stage_ordering_ns": 450, "stage_eval_ns": 47641, "stage_threat_ns": 17587415, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17282954, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 201781, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 86790, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15890, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 383, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16567, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 82, 67, 96, 128, 81, 156, 114, 141, 171, 140, 143, 124, 172, 94, 158, 139, 138, 109, 154, 79 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 42, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.8181818181818183, "search_nodes": 196, "safety_nodes": 750, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 946, "avg_nodes": 86.0, "eval_calls": 185, "avg_eval_calls": 16.818181818181817, "line_shape_eval_calls": 185, "line_shape_eval_ns": 133100, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 719.4594594594595, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 670, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.90909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 670, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 670, "avg_legality_checks": 60.90909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "root_legality_checks": 670, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13604, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1236.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27930030, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2053.074830932079, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.454545454545454, "renju_forbidden_ns": 675393, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11256.55, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 139850, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 535543, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 830734, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12399.014925373134, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 99, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 465134, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4698.323232323232, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1874258, "stage_ordering_ns": 560, "stage_eval_ns": 133100, "stage_threat_ns": 23064884, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 381, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21767277, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 975014, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 272793, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 370, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49800, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 16517, "avg_search_time_ms": 1501.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 174143, "safety_nodes": 196, "corridor_nodes": 3932, "corridor_branch_probes": 4438, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1796, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 3900, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3900, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 85, "corridor_proof_active": 32, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1796, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 85, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 83, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 686, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 63479200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1991200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 178271, "avg_nodes": 16206.454545454546, "eval_calls": 141422, "avg_eval_calls": 12856.545454545454, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 141422, "pattern_eval_ns": 3070770, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.713524062734226, "pattern_frame_queries": 141422, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3070770, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.713524062734226, "pattern_frame_updates": 348192, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4519918757, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12981.110298341146, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30688, "avg_candidate_generations": 2789.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2429428, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.16540667361835, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 693, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 30677, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2428735, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1382367, "avg_legality_checks": 125669.72727272728, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15869, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1382367, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15869, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4809458, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 437223.45454545453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9802220797, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2038.113400096227, "renju_forbidden_checks": 57554, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5232.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 524144490, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9107.003683497238, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15869, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 161909513, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29894, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 296277417, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11568, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 63597628, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 223, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2359932, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 194056, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17641.454545454544, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1999900160, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10305.78884445727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 283879, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25807.18181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1026252260, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3615.1045339739817, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3459952071, "stage_ordering_ns": 945518211, "stage_eval_ns": 4522989527, "stage_threat_ns": 7416844505, "stage_proof_ns": 102684359, "tactical_annotations": 756340, "root_tactical_annotations": 2343, "search_tactical_annotations": 753997, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 356173, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2116877587, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 862334, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4922083241, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 63445, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2240852616, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 178081, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 262328814, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7970, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 45920391, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 356162, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44411755, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 236504, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1028483406, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 346317, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1500747183, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 173519, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 25222717, "child_limit_applications": 30677, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30677, "child_cap_hits": 30677, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30677, "child_moves_before_total": 2412866, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2412866, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 523865, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 523865, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.65391009551129, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.076800208625354, "tt_hits": 11971, "tt_cutoffs": 1997, "beta_cutoffs": 21534, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.45454545454545453, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2838.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3341.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1544, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 384, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29981, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 96, 141, 82, 156, 171, 142, 110, 68, 97, 67, 98, 95, 100, 99, 66, 114, 80, 128, 170, 157, 52, 94, 169, 172, 81, 187, 202, 83, 51, 36, 50, 34, 49, 53, 48 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 29909, "avg_search_time_ms": 1661.611111111111, "search_nodes": 258338, "safety_nodes": 496, "corridor_nodes": 33341, "corridor_branch_probes": 34609, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 21946, "corridor_neutral_exits": 65, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 33277, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 33277, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 147, "corridor_proof_active": 64, "corridor_proof_quiet": 83, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 65, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 21946, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 147, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 145, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 3, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1145, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 85542560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 292175, "avg_nodes": 16231.944444444445, "eval_calls": 202168, "avg_eval_calls": 11231.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 202168, "pattern_eval_ns": 4408818, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.80769459063749, "pattern_frame_queries": 202168, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4408818, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.80769459063749, "pattern_frame_updates": 516512, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6972835748, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13499.852371290503, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52710, "avg_candidate_generations": 2928.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 4392175, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.32716752039461, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1323, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 52692, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4390852, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1672518, "avg_legality_checks": 92917.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1102, "root_legality_checks": 1323, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1671195, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1101, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8611214, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 478400.77777777775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18359352173, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2132.028326435738, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60998, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3388.777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 273650818, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4486.226072986, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1939, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15166808, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27715, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 174469979, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26324, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 67263962, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5020, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 16750069, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 279368, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15520.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2380940390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8522.595250708742, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 362054, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20114.11111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1001443684, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2766.006407883907, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4137149577, "stage_ordering_ns": 1725850059, "stage_eval_ns": 6977244566, "stage_threat_ns": 14849724926, "stage_proof_ns": 2135094310, "tactical_annotations": 1274299, "root_tactical_annotations": 4270, "search_tactical_annotations": 1270029, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 583378, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3970970103, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2220115, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9844146752, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 116695, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4385921498, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 291680, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 469398143, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 66848, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 452314480, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 583360, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74917777, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 478518, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 601354278, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 518934, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2013641965, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 276847, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 37977671, "child_limit_applications": 52692, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52692, "child_cap_hits": 52692, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52692, "child_moves_before_total": 4389751, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4389751, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 931515, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 931515, "child_moves_after_max": 29, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 29, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.30962954528202, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.678490093372808, "tt_hits": 22478, "tt_cutoffs": 3396, "beta_cutoffs": 39940, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3888888888888889, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1956.9444444444443, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2299.9444444444443, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 53, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1176470588235294, "search_nodes": 164, "safety_nodes": 1846, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2010, "avg_nodes": 118.23529411764706, "eval_calls": 147, "avg_eval_calls": 8.647058823529411, "line_shape_eval_calls": 147, "line_shape_eval_ns": 203050, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1381.2925170068027, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1260, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.11764705882354, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1260, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19558, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1150.4705882352941, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 40706439, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2081.319102157685, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5882352941176471, "renju_forbidden_ns": 72450, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7245.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 72450, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8890, "stage_ordering_ns": 860, "stage_eval_ns": 203050, "stage_threat_ns": 33167061, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 311, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 32449518, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 448093, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19020, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 230790, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 294, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38660, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6821.529411764706, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7292.117647058823, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 385, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9996, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 67, 127, 142, 96, 128, 83, 114, 100, 143, 158, 144, 141, 129, 99, 115, 157, 130, 116, 146, 162, 145 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 42, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.8181818181818183, "search_nodes": 208, "safety_nodes": 729, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 937, "avg_nodes": 85.18181818181819, "eval_calls": 197, "avg_eval_calls": 17.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 197, "line_shape_eval_ns": 185150, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 939.8477157360406, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 626, "avg_candidate_moves": 56.90909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 72, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 626, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 626, "avg_legality_checks": 56.90909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 626, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1219.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28894789, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2154.0770090949754, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.6363636363636362, "renju_forbidden_ns": 468954, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11723.85, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 91871, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 377083, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 659573, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12684.096153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 369092, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4856.473684210527, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1763455, "stage_ordering_ns": 570, "stage_eval_ns": 185150, "stage_threat_ns": 23825243, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 405, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22628977, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 853274, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12010, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 290392, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52600, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9945, "avg_search_time_ms": 904.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 76088, "safety_nodes": 193, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 3, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 3, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 3, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 1040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76281, "avg_nodes": 6934.636363636364, "eval_calls": 51839, "avg_eval_calls": 4712.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51839, "pattern_eval_ns": 1144573, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.0793803892822, "pattern_frame_queries": 51839, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1144573, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.0793803892822, "pattern_frame_updates": 152074, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1961379200, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12897.531464944697, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22682, "avg_candidate_generations": 2062.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1665481, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.42743144343532, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 659, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 22671, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1664822, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 1054123, "avg_legality_checks": 95829.36363636363, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13516, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1054123, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13516, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2862639, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 260239.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6232314388, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2177.1220150357763, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42706, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3882.3636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 397050209, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9297.293331147848, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 13622, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 144030179, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18190, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 189282920, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10834, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 63025387, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 711723, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 117916, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10719.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1260036881, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10685.885554123273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 163405, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14855.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 622297223, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3808.312003916649, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2806413389, "stage_ordering_ns": 708543022, "stage_eval_ns": 1962523773, "stage_threat_ns": 4408817484, "stage_proof_ns": 5411573, "tactical_annotations": 462471, "root_tactical_annotations": 2244, "search_tactical_annotations": 460227, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152091, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 941496960, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 396306, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3314341513, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45426, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1700350028, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118452358, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25230, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152080, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19848997, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 120400, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 562515223, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 230465, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1051410561, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 111606, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14652426, "child_limit_applications": 22671, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22671, "child_cap_hits": 22671, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22671, "child_moves_before_total": 1651306, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1651306, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 259115, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 259115, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.83781041859645, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.429359093114552, "tt_hits": 9747, "tt_cutoffs": 1527, "beta_cutoffs": 16553, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5144.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5871.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1593, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 386, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9396, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 83, 99, 85, 141, 155, 84, 69, 111, 53, 37, 52, 67, 55, 41, 54, 51, 56 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9358, "avg_search_time_ms": 935.8, "search_nodes": 91917, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 256, "corridor_branch_probes": 308, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 92, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 253, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 253, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 20, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 17, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 92, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 20, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 20, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 146, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4062960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1973760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92404, "avg_nodes": 9240.4, "eval_calls": 59674, "avg_eval_calls": 5967.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 59674, "pattern_eval_ns": 1303924, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.85078928846734, "pattern_frame_queries": 59674, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1303924, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.85078928846734, "pattern_frame_updates": 183754, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2312187270, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12583.058164720223, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30107, "avg_candidate_generations": 3010.7, "candidate_moves_total": 2353045, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.15607665991298, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 30097, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2352405, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 681132, "avg_legality_checks": 68113.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 447, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 680492, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 446, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2427122, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 242712.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5515847401, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2272.5876165268987, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23189, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2318.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 111356150, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4802.110914657812, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 926, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4480213, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12899, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 80297525, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9356, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26492391, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 86021, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46331, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4633.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 393830036, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8500.356910060218, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 60281, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6028.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 156795274, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2601.072875367031, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1730799104, "stage_ordering_ns": 975050962, "stage_eval_ns": 2313491194, "stage_threat_ns": 4225587582, "stage_proof_ns": 70811319, "tactical_annotations": 456193, "root_tactical_annotations": 1860, "search_tactical_annotations": 454333, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 184310, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1106116755, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 403198, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2935964848, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60438, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2177270441, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92150, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 139450199, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 546, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2684928, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 184300, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23571102, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 98492, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 59477009, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 226938, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 656140200, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 130763, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17799750, "child_limit_applications": 30097, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30097, "child_cap_hits": 30097, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30097, "child_moves_before_total": 2351959, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2351959, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 267362, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 267362, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.14596139150082, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.883343854869256, "tt_hits": 14623, "tt_cutoffs": 2106, "beta_cutoffs": 22885, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 3.9, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 3.9, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4114.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4914.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 860, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 47750, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 823.2758620689655, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22488505, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2154.896991184362, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 45860, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11465.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 45860, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3960, "stage_ordering_ns": 410, "stage_eval_ns": 47750, "stage_threat_ns": 17783197, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17476765, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 201531, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9800, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 89271, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15630, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 387, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25504, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 110, 109, 126, 129, 125, 144, 99, 142, 100, 141, 143, 130, 131, 98, 146, 116, 158, 102, 88, 189, 159, 157, 172, 156, 170, 205, 147, 173 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 51, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4, "search_nodes": 460, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1257, "avg_nodes": 83.8, "eval_calls": 445, "avg_eval_calls": 29.666666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 445, "line_shape_eval_ns": 616014, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1384.3011235955057, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 961, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.06666666666666, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 961, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 961, "avg_legality_checks": 64.06666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 961, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18072, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1204.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 34667912, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1918.3218238158477, "renju_forbidden_checks": 81, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 841581, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10389.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 167660, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 65, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 673921, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.933333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 630562, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10687.49152542373, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.733333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 353441, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4109.779069767442, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2381790, "stage_ordering_ns": 740, "stage_eval_ns": 616014, "stage_threat_ns": 31034931, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 905, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 29501686, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 810773, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 445, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 614052, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 890, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 108420, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 15, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 15, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6664.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7197.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 25436, "avg_search_time_ms": 1695.7333333333333, "search_nodes": 182453, "safety_nodes": 209, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 3, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 3, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 3, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 11040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 182662, "avg_nodes": 12177.466666666667, "eval_calls": 118549, "avg_eval_calls": 7903.266666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 118549, "pattern_eval_ns": 2486738, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.97645699246725, "pattern_frame_queries": 118549, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2486738, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.97645699246725, "pattern_frame_updates": 364748, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4729599685, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12966.759749196706, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 59031, "avg_candidate_generations": 3935.4, "candidate_moves_total": 4662300, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.98053565075978, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 993, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 59016, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4661307, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 3221288, "avg_legality_checks": 214752.53333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27547, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3221288, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 27547, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8536830, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 569122.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16438588804, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1925.6080774713798, "renju_forbidden_checks": 117084, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7805.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 707273298, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6040.733985856308, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 29887, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 281632789, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 36522, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 288873769, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 50575, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 135721701, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 100, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1045039, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 379610, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 25307.333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3770376582, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9932.237248755302, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 569068, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 37937.86666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1916328194, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3367.4854217773623, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7556973232, "stage_ordering_ns": 1807434486, "stage_eval_ns": 4732086423, "stage_threat_ns": 11208671183, "stage_proof_ns": 5394503, "tactical_annotations": 1506350, "root_tactical_annotations": 4265, "search_tactical_annotations": 1502085, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 364769, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1996155918, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1330938, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8870991323, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 118152, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3912617186, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 182377, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 260954318, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25010, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 364754, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43443130, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 393461, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1241111823, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 819306, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3717197232, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 293583, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 37101484, "child_limit_applications": 59016, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 59016, "child_cap_hits": 59016, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 59016, "child_moves_before_total": 4633760, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4633760, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 687582, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 687582, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.51701233563779, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.650772671817812, "tt_hits": 24760, "tt_cutoffs": 4814, "beta_cutoffs": 45620, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1099.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1411.6666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 388, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9039, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 142, 156, 100, 86, 141, 140, 98, 124, 108, 109, 110, 154, 168, 139, 94, 169 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9001, "avg_search_time_ms": 900.1, "search_nodes": 89462, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 271, "corridor_branch_probes": 322, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 101, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 266, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 266, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 20, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 15, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 20, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 20, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 146, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6060560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1982080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 89964, "avg_nodes": 8996.4, "eval_calls": 58502, "avg_eval_calls": 5850.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 58502, "pattern_eval_ns": 1206205, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.618183993709618, "pattern_frame_queries": 58502, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1206205, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.618183993709618, "pattern_frame_updates": 178836, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2303726806, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12881.784461741483, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28999, "avg_candidate_generations": 2899.9, "candidate_moves_total": 2352724, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.13121142108349, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 28989, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2352084, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 660703, "avg_legality_checks": 66070.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 402, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 660063, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 401, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2432479, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 243247.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5318298489, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2186.3697441992304, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21274, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2127.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 98448491, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4627.643649525242, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 750, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3735525, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11983, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71157305, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8531, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23444160, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 111501, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46693, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4669.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 382246037, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8186.367057160603, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 60170, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6017.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 149373711, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2482.5280206082766, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1598574398, "stage_ordering_ns": 942086700, "stage_eval_ns": 2304933011, "stage_threat_ns": 4054925815, "stage_proof_ns": 67841092, "tactical_annotations": 449243, "root_tactical_annotations": 1864, "search_tactical_annotations": 447379, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 179418, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1047762255, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 395130, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2828849525, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58227, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2099955525, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89704, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 134804831, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 572, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2743629, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 179408, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22416969, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96933, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 62666590, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 222002, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 621121358, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 130308, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18348606, "child_limit_applications": 28989, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28989, "child_cap_hits": 28989, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28989, "child_moves_before_total": 2351683, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2351683, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 257046, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 257046, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.12328814377868, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.867018524267825, "tt_hits": 14289, "tt_cutoffs": 1928, "beta_cutoffs": 22011, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4345.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5145.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1164, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 45230, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 779.8275862068965, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1157.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20992858, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2015.8304205876705, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 47200, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11800.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 47200, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3670, "stage_ordering_ns": 530, "stage_eval_ns": 45230, "stage_threat_ns": 16680861, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16386061, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 195070, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 84420, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15310, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 389, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9633, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 109, 113, 114, 126, 98, 95, 82, 66, 99, 100, 84, 129, 83, 81, 67, 115, 68, 52, 54, 40, 69 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.272727272727273, "search_nodes": 208, "safety_nodes": 729, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 937, "avg_nodes": 85.18181818181819, "eval_calls": 197, "avg_eval_calls": 17.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 197, "line_shape_eval_ns": 177381, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 900.4111675126903, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 626, "avg_candidate_moves": 56.90909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 72, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 626, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 626, "avg_legality_checks": 56.90909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 626, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1219.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27082100, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2018.942895482332, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.6363636363636362, "renju_forbidden_ns": 456331, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11408.275, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 88840, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 367491, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 603993, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11615.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 335891, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4419.618421052632, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1661378, "stage_ordering_ns": 530, "stage_eval_ns": 177381, "stage_threat_ns": 22440407, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 405, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21313892, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 790943, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 285642, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49930, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9583, "avg_search_time_ms": 871.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 80673, "safety_nodes": 193, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 3, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 3, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 3, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 80866, "avg_nodes": 7351.454545454545, "eval_calls": 54842, "avg_eval_calls": 4985.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 54842, "pattern_eval_ns": 1142555, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.833576456000877, "pattern_frame_queries": 54842, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1142555, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.833576456000877, "pattern_frame_updates": 161244, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1729443234, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10725.628451291212, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24249, "avg_candidate_generations": 2204.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 1810018, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.6429955874469, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 659, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 24238, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1809359, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1132968, "avg_legality_checks": 102997.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5243, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1132968, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5243, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2995513, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 272319.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6090364449, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2033.1624162539104, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26586, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2416.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 184606904, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6943.763785450989, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5325, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 56105479, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9048, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 88972704, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12153, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 38876735, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 651986, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 118780, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10798.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1212165570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10205.131924566425, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 175258, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15932.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 614263499, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3504.909898549567, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2740864861, "stage_ordering_ns": 717275968, "stage_eval_ns": 1730585789, "stage_threat_ns": 4339328969, "stage_proof_ns": 5105701, "tactical_annotations": 459102, "root_tactical_annotations": 2244, "search_tactical_annotations": 456858, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 161261, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 952757592, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 396697, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3231960044, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48560, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1679292379, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 80625, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 120841831, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 23000, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 161250, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19949825, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 118898, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 493811901, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 229224, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1058797124, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110980, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13796677, "child_limit_applications": 24238, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24238, "child_cap_hits": 24238, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24238, "child_moves_before_total": 1804116, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1804116, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 269690, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 269690, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.4333690898589, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.126743130621339, "tt_hits": 10360, "tt_cutoffs": 1543, "beta_cutoffs": 17788, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5152.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5879.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1596, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 390, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7200, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 81, 65, 129, 145, 80, 79, 127, 93, 51, 108, 109, 63, 47, 78, 48, 123 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7162, "avg_search_time_ms": 716.2, "search_nodes": 75683, "safety_nodes": 228, "corridor_nodes": 307, "corridor_branch_probes": 379, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 110, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 303, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 303, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 21, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 17, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 110, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 21, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 20, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 147, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4126960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1973760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 76218, "avg_nodes": 7621.8, "eval_calls": 50142, "avg_eval_calls": 5014.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50142, "pattern_eval_ns": 1036434, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.669977264568626, "pattern_frame_queries": 50142, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1036434, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.669977264568626, "pattern_frame_updates": 151286, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1750918165, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11573.563746810676, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23906, "avg_candidate_generations": 2390.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1789506, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.85593574834769, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 638, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 23896, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1788868, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 560595, "avg_legality_checks": 56059.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 486, "root_legality_checks": 638, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 559957, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 485, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2003085, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 200308.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4244789917, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2119.126206326741, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25329, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2532.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 90907191, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3589.055667416795, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1043, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4409787, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14727, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64416847, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9535, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21888716, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 191841, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 41066, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4106.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 326708937, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7955.703915647981, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 53499, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5349.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 130890653, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2446.599992523225, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1337756031, "stage_ordering_ns": 691048554, "stage_eval_ns": 1751954599, "stage_threat_ns": 3274077741, "stage_proof_ns": 74201400, "tactical_annotations": 351240, "root_tactical_annotations": 1855, "search_tactical_annotations": 349385, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 151944, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 885223641, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 293016, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2240265309, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48059, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1666780258, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75967, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 110152737, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 648, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3085151, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 151934, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18617807, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 77361, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 54967319, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 146974, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 470221868, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 126905, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16733096, "child_limit_applications": 23896, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23896, "child_cap_hits": 23896, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23896, "child_moves_before_total": 1788383, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1788383, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 225289, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 225289, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.8402661533311, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.42789588215601, "tt_hits": 13403, "tt_cutoffs": 1605, "beta_cutoffs": 17923, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4622.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5422.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1103, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 820, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 887, "avg_nodes": 98.55555555555556, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44180, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 761.7241379310345, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 580, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10442, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1160.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20872193, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1998.869277916108, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.1111111111111112, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57730, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5773.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57730, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3770, "stage_ordering_ns": 370, "stage_eval_ns": 44180, "stage_threat_ns": 16644775, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16351614, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 192081, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9851, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 86170, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14910, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 391, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8535, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 115, 116, 129, 143, 95, 145, 128, 142, 141, 146, 99, 144 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 25, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5714285714285716, "search_nodes": 278, "safety_nodes": 236, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 514, "avg_nodes": 73.42857142857143, "eval_calls": 271, "avg_eval_calls": 38.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 271, "line_shape_eval_ns": 196491, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 725.0590405904059, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 389, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.57142857142857, "candidate_moves_max": 66, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 389, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 389, "avg_legality_checks": 55.57142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 389, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8373, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1196.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15918978, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1901.2275170189896, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 118322, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10756.545454545454, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22181, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 96141, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 118062, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9081.692307692309, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 67141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3533.7368421052633, "stage_move_gen_ns": 933554, "stage_ordering_ns": 330, "stage_eval_ns": 196491, "stage_threat_ns": 15052035, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 549, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14432032, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 178312, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6550, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 271, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 373871, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 542, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67820, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 8505, "avg_search_time_ms": 1215.0, "search_nodes": 68210, "safety_nodes": 192, "corridor_nodes": 56, "corridor_branch_probes": 74, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 19, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 15, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 19, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 19, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 140, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26039680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68458, "avg_nodes": 9779.714285714286, "eval_calls": 39569, "avg_eval_calls": 5652.714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39569, "pattern_eval_ns": 800658, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.234476484116353, "pattern_frame_queries": 39569, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 800658, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.234476484116353, "pattern_frame_updates": 136346, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1165235192, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8546.163378463614, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26009, "avg_candidate_generations": 3715.5714285714284, "candidate_moves_total": 2008335, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.21692491060787, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 399, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 26002, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2007936, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 1434663, "avg_legality_checks": 204951.85714285713, "illegal_moves_skipped": 358, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1434663, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 358, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3057537, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 436791.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5700700274, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1864.4746650653778, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12575, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1796.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13810694, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1098.2659244532804, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 358, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3721121, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 864, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 3765577, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11343, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6218826, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 105170, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83831, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11975.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 769423564, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9178.270138731496, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 121813, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17401.85714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 383683501, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3149.774662802821, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3015514368, "stage_ordering_ns": 749951557, "stage_eval_ns": 1166035850, "stage_threat_ns": 3496638860, "stage_proof_ns": 19679115, "tactical_annotations": 381810, "root_tactical_annotations": 1349, "search_tactical_annotations": 380461, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136495, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 719697703, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 272265, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2644892031, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52150, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1641460856, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68244, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92359813, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 142, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 396782, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136488, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15373314, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 43158, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 198477790, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 172694, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 803025519, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 165958, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23919217, "child_limit_applications": 26002, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26002, "child_cap_hits": 26002, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26002, "child_moves_before_total": 2007578, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2007578, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 233815, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 233815, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.20859933851243, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.992192908237827, "tt_hits": 15574, "tt_cutoffs": 2603, "beta_cutoffs": 20537, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1889.2857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2677.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 444, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 392, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28588, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 115, 69, 95, 99, 79, 63, 84, 70, 80, 71, 68, 85, 57, 53, 101, 37, 21, 55, 100, 52, 116, 132, 54, 41, 83, 40, 25, 39, 38, 23, 7, 87 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 28524, "avg_search_time_ms": 1584.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 343530, "safety_nodes": 486, "corridor_nodes": 730, "corridor_branch_probes": 840, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 355, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 722, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 722, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 355, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 430, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 65357440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998640, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 344746, "avg_nodes": 19152.555555555555, "eval_calls": 216525, "avg_eval_calls": 12029.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 216525, "pattern_eval_ns": 4298548, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.85243274448678, "pattern_frame_queries": 216525, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4298548, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.85243274448678, "pattern_frame_updates": 686886, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6639746624, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9666.446286574483, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 116126, "avg_candidate_generations": 6451.444444444444, "candidate_moves_total": 11453282, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.62805917710074, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1578, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 116108, "search_candidate_moves_total": 11451704, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 3033346, "avg_legality_checks": 168519.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3760, "root_legality_checks": 1578, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3031768, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3760, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9420337, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 523352.05555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16183285363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1717.9093872119438, "renju_forbidden_checks": 111047, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6169.277777777777, "renju_forbidden_ns": 371529865, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3345.6992534692517, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6249, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34833640, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 54530, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 236213920, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 49718, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 98378374, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 550, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2103931, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 191486, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10638.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1370543808, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7157.409982975257, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 270825, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15045.833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 656854789, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2425.384617372842, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5818052723, "stage_ordering_ns": 3374654532, "stage_eval_ns": 6644045172, "stage_threat_ns": 12391879848, "stage_proof_ns": 145023454, "tactical_annotations": 2392292, "root_tactical_annotations": 5975, "search_tactical_annotations": 2386317, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 688458, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3223945408, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1965815, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8566558439, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 232842, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5855999105, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 344220, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 423597253, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1554, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11115406, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 688440, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69269841, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 626071, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 264988331, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1071008, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2380508755, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 695213, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 97393501, "child_limit_applications": 116108, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 116108, "child_cap_hits": 116108, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 116108, "child_moves_before_total": 11447944, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 11447944, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 1400998, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1400998, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 98.59737485789093, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.066334791745616, "tt_hits": 61802, "tt_cutoffs": 10812, "beta_cutoffs": 92563, "depth_sum": 83, "avg_depth": 4.611111111111111, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 83, "avg_effective_depth": 4.611111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1563.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1986.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 47, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.764705882352941, "search_nodes": 247, "safety_nodes": 2097, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2344, "avg_nodes": 137.88235294117646, "eval_calls": 230, "avg_eval_calls": 13.529411764705882, "line_shape_eval_calls": 230, "line_shape_eval_ns": 174712, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 759.6173913043478, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1513, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.0, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1513, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19667, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1156.8823529411766, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 33545053, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1705.651751665226, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7350, "stage_ordering_ns": 870, "stage_eval_ns": 174712, "stage_threat_ns": 28292859, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 477, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 27671977, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 291731, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 280851, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48300, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6821.470588235294, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7292.058823529412, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 393, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8176, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 157, 172, 141, 125, 83, 155, 126, 110, 95, 170, 143, 140 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 20, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.857142857142857, "search_nodes": 278, "safety_nodes": 236, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 514, "avg_nodes": 73.42857142857143, "eval_calls": 271, "avg_eval_calls": 38.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 271, "line_shape_eval_ns": 169670, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 626.0885608856089, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 389, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.57142857142857, "candidate_moves_max": 66, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 389, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 389, "avg_legality_checks": 55.57142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 389, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8373, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1196.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13668590, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1632.4602890242445, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 119311, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10846.454545454546, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23060, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 96251, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 151430, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11648.461538461539, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 84240, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4433.684210526316, "stage_move_gen_ns": 834433, "stage_ordering_ns": 290, "stage_eval_ns": 169670, "stage_threat_ns": 12673134, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 549, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 12092784, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 225390, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 271, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 300570, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 542, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 54390, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5139.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6282.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 8148, "avg_search_time_ms": 1164.0, "search_nodes": 67974, "safety_nodes": 192, "corridor_nodes": 56, "corridor_branch_probes": 74, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 19, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 15, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 19, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 19, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 140, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26038720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68222, "avg_nodes": 9746.0, "eval_calls": 39476, "avg_eval_calls": 5639.428571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39476, "pattern_eval_ns": 790023, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.012741919140744, "pattern_frame_queries": 39476, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 790023, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.012741919140744, "pattern_frame_updates": 135874, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1058047349, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7786.974321798137, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25930, "avg_candidate_generations": 3704.285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 2014983, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.70856151176244, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 399, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 25923, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2014584, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 1438543, "avg_legality_checks": 205506.14285714287, "illegal_moves_skipped": 388, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1438543, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 388, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3014577, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 430653.85714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5491633359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1821.6928474542199, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12665, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1809.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12959489, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1023.2521910777734, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 388, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4091350, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 728, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 3393635, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11539, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5364483, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 110021, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81845, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11692.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 691508132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8448.99666442666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 119178, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17025.428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 344800197, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2893.153073553844, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2996958788, "stage_ordering_ns": 710653915, "stage_eval_ns": 1058837372, "stage_threat_ns": 3300238876, "stage_proof_ns": 29580568, "tactical_annotations": 375229, "root_tactical_annotations": 1349, "search_tactical_annotations": 373880, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136023, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 681652745, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 269419, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2491044140, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51992, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1586574291, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68008, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88653510, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 142, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 614432, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136016, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14842492, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44900, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 197576996, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 168264, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 703534576, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 162065, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23431557, "child_limit_applications": 25923, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25923, "child_cap_hits": 25923, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25923, "child_moves_before_total": 2014196, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2014196, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 229380, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 229380, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.69918605099718, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.84851290359912, "tt_hits": 15523, "tt_cutoffs": 2539, "beta_cutoffs": 20449, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2148.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2986.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 782, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 394, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9261, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 125, 157, 126, 124, 140, 98, 155, 110, 143, 139, 141, 144, 169, 113, 183 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9228, "avg_search_time_ms": 1025.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 95659, "safety_nodes": 66, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 1, "corridor_proof_completed": 1, "corridor_proof_checks": 16, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 16, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 16, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 136, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 174160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 95725, "avg_nodes": 10636.111111111111, "eval_calls": 62713, "avg_eval_calls": 6968.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62713, "pattern_eval_ns": 1304516, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.801364948256342, "pattern_frame_queries": 62713, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1304516, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.801364948256342, "pattern_frame_updates": 191236, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2168633270, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11340.089052270492, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30797, "avg_candidate_generations": 3421.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 2282485, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.11387472805792, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 498, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 30788, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2281987, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 775610, "avg_legality_checks": 86178.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1506, "root_legality_checks": 498, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 775112, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1504, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2548025, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 283113.8888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5518998993, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2165.9909117846173, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25326, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2814.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 123393984, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4872.2255389718075, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1737, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15504953, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11909, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 77832683, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11670, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29952396, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 103952, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52894, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5877.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 449945163, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8506.544466291072, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 69789, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7754.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 187336016, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2684.320107753371, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1881390535, "stage_ordering_ns": 964931608, "stage_eval_ns": 2169937786, "stage_threat_ns": 4147669451, "stage_proof_ns": 27379998, "tactical_annotations": 286738, "root_tactical_annotations": 2097, "search_tactical_annotations": 284641, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 191277, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1093799553, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 260387, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2883358311, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61698, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2210167878, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 95634, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 135556205, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 32, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 99100, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 191268, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23298956, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 38910, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 79007491, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 159739, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 594147962, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 88089, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11557326, "child_limit_applications": 30788, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30788, "child_cap_hits": 30788, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30788, "child_moves_before_total": 2280483, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2280483, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 265030, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 265030, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.07051448616345, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.608223983370145, "tt_hits": 14254, "tt_cutoffs": 2118, "beta_cutoffs": 22989, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2314.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3203.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.25, "search_nodes": 121, "safety_nodes": 546, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 667, "avg_nodes": 83.375, "eval_calls": 113, "avg_eval_calls": 14.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 113, "line_shape_eval_ns": 78011, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 690.362831858407, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 441, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.125, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 441, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9149, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1143.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18170166, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1986.0275439938791, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 88790, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11098.75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 88790, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2840, "stage_ordering_ns": 430, "stage_eval_ns": 78011, "stage_threat_ns": 15353641, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 234, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14990936, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 171312, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8220, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 113, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 162743, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 226, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28650, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 395, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5599, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 109, 108, 95, 81, 65, 80, 94, 82, 83, 78, 125, 79 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 271, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 502, "avg_nodes": 71.71428571428571, "eval_calls": 264, "avg_eval_calls": 37.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 264, "line_shape_eval_ns": 191000, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 723.4848484848485, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 380, "avg_candidate_moves": 54.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 64, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 380, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 380, "avg_legality_checks": 54.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 380, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17022014, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2035.3956714097812, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 126630, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10552.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19770, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 106860, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 174230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11615.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 99420, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4322.608695652174, "stage_move_gen_ns": 971615, "stage_ordering_ns": 380, "stage_eval_ns": 191000, "stage_threat_ns": 15752161, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 535, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15047010, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 275290, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7250, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 363331, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66530, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 5567, "avg_search_time_ms": 795.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 41289, "safety_nodes": 311, "corridor_nodes": 120, "corridor_branch_probes": 152, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 36, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 114, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 114, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 24, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 24, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 155, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 28121920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014640, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 41720, "avg_nodes": 5960.0, "eval_calls": 23496, "avg_eval_calls": 3356.5714285714284, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23496, "pattern_eval_ns": 496831, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.145343888321417, "pattern_frame_queries": 23496, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 496831, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.145343888321417, "pattern_frame_updates": 82504, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 804127041, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9746.52187772714, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15828, "avg_candidate_generations": 2261.1428571428573, "candidate_moves_total": 1174948, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.23224665150366, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 390, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 15821, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1174558, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 796688, "avg_legality_checks": 113812.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1140, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 796688, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1140, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1815588, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 259369.7142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3684887854, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2029.5837238404308, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12920, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1845.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 75705477, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5859.557043343653, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1148, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12243999, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3070, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32449116, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8682, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30792802, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 219560, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 56438, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8062.571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 575436126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10195.898614408732, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 80041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11434.42857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 301926933, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3772.153433865144, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1845346372, "stage_ordering_ns": 466891313, "stage_eval_ns": 804623872, "stage_threat_ns": 2375554897, "stage_proof_ns": 39978853, "tactical_annotations": 231193, "root_tactical_annotations": 919, "search_tactical_annotations": 230274, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 82787, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 486264596, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 173184, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1803413626, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31836, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1075950115, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 41390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 60543546, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 276, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1317736, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 82780, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10143026, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 31243, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 166686061, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 101248, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 553661858, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 98702, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13872367, "child_limit_applications": 15821, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15821, "child_cap_hits": 15821, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15821, "child_moves_before_total": 1173418, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1173418, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 155259, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 155259, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.16838379369193, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.813475760065735, "tt_hits": 9784, "tt_cutoffs": 1935, "beta_cutoffs": 12664, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3068.5714285714284, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4211.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1739, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 396, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9211, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 81, 109, 96, 66, 80, 128, 79, 82, 125, 65, 95, 140, 63, 127, 47 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9177, "avg_search_time_ms": 1019.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 96760, "safety_nodes": 66, "corridor_nodes": 4, "corridor_branch_probes": 2, "corridor_max_depth": 1, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 1, "corridor_proof_completed": 1, "corridor_proof_checks": 16, "corridor_proof_active": 2, "corridor_proof_quiet": 14, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 16, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 136, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 175600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 96830, "avg_nodes": 10758.888888888889, "eval_calls": 63212, "avg_eval_calls": 7023.555555555556, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 63212, "pattern_eval_ns": 1318544, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.859077390368917, "pattern_frame_queries": 63212, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1318544, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.859077390368917, "pattern_frame_updates": 193438, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2209671496, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11423.15106649159, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31612, "avg_candidate_generations": 3512.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 2324063, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.51837909654562, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 498, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 31603, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2323565, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 742982, "avg_legality_checks": 82553.55555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2244, "root_legality_checks": 498, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 742484, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2242, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2549035, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 283226.1111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5476315418, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2148.3876910281733, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27796, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3088.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 139955981, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5035.112282342783, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2489, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23501076, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12602, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 82864333, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12695, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 33483372, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 107200, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52067, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5785.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 452621122, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8693.051683407917, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68715, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7635.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 196867168, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2864.9809794076987, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1795136771, "stage_ordering_ns": 947617229, "stage_eval_ns": 2210990040, "stage_threat_ns": 4160656241, "stage_proof_ns": 28160109, "tactical_annotations": 279262, "root_tactical_annotations": 2097, "search_tactical_annotations": 277165, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 193483, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1100520220, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 249252, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2886448874, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 63328, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2225915557, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 96737, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 138224601, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 36, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 119830, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 193474, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23388297, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 37403, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 62762426, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 148051, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 597288659, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 93808, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11954419, "child_limit_applications": 31603, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31603, "child_cap_hits": 31603, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31603, "child_moves_before_total": 2321323, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2321323, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 271516, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 271516, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.45261525804513, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.591462835806727, "tt_hits": 16531, "tt_cutoffs": 1904, "beta_cutoffs": 23707, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2368.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3257.222222222222, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.25, "search_nodes": 121, "safety_nodes": 546, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 667, "avg_nodes": 83.375, "eval_calls": 113, "avg_eval_calls": 14.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 113, "line_shape_eval_ns": 76661, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 678.4159292035398, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 441, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.125, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 441, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9149, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1143.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18218039, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1991.2601377199694, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 91830, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11478.75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 91830, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2890, "stage_ordering_ns": 430, "stage_eval_ns": 76661, "stage_threat_ns": 15397940, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 234, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15035210, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 171560, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 113, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 162130, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 226, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29040, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 397, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5667, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 67, 52, 83, 99, 85, 84, 68, 114, 129, 54, 81, 69 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 271, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 502, "avg_nodes": 71.71428571428571, "eval_calls": 264, "avg_eval_calls": 37.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 264, "line_shape_eval_ns": 192701, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 729.9280303030303, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 380, "avg_candidate_moves": 54.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 64, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 380, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 380, "avg_legality_checks": 54.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 380, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17165397, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2052.540595480091, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 129561, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10796.75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20200, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 109361, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 177471, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11831.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 100341, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4362.652173913043, "stage_move_gen_ns": 975543, "stage_ordering_ns": 340, "stage_eval_ns": 192701, "stage_threat_ns": 15902884, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 535, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15194952, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 278611, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7130, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 362331, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66990, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 5635, "avg_search_time_ms": 805.0, "search_nodes": 42519, "safety_nodes": 311, "corridor_nodes": 123, "corridor_branch_probes": 159, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 39, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 117, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 117, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 24, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 39, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 24, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 155, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 30090960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014640, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 42953, "avg_nodes": 6136.142857142857, "eval_calls": 23987, "avg_eval_calls": 3426.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23987, "pattern_eval_ns": 511161, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.309917872180765, "pattern_frame_queries": 23987, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 511161, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.309917872180765, "pattern_frame_updates": 84964, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 826311175, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9725.42694552987, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15955, "avg_candidate_generations": 2279.285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 1155497, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.42225007834534, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 390, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 15948, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1155107, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 787877, "avg_legality_checks": 112553.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1136, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 787877, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1136, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1828313, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 261187.57142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3728062374, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2039.0722890446002, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12436, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1776.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_ns": 71681322, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5764.017529752332, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1144, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11707725, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2917, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30493181, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8355, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29266116, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 214300, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58891, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8413.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 597980967, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10154.029766857415, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 83644, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11949.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 312968201, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3741.6694682224665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1848974200, "stage_ordering_ns": 461684487, "stage_eval_ns": 826822336, "stage_threat_ns": 2421664570, "stage_proof_ns": 40436824, "tactical_annotations": 232238, "root_tactical_annotations": 919, "search_tactical_annotations": 231319, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 85253, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 500275973, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 174566, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1834894592, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32090, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1083057018, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42623, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 61140571, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 282, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1330866, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 85246, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10486068, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 31024, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 167065163, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 102595, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 577658937, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 98619, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13536500, "child_limit_applications": 15948, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15948, "child_cap_hits": 15948, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15948, "child_moves_before_total": 1153971, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1153971, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 159510, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 159510, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.35835214446952, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.001881113619262, "tt_hits": 10255, "tt_cutoffs": 2547, "beta_cutoffs": 12685, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3009.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4151.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1648, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 398, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10470, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 99, 85, 141, 155, 81, 111, 125, 69, 55, 53, 37, 68, 98, 67, 52, 66, 65, 70 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10427, "avg_search_time_ms": 947.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 109467, "safety_nodes": 240, "corridor_nodes": 280, "corridor_branch_probes": 338, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 104, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 277, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 277, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 20, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 17, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 20, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 20, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 146, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6089600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1976000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 109987, "avg_nodes": 9998.818181818182, "eval_calls": 72659, "avg_eval_calls": 6605.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72659, "pattern_eval_ns": 1502405, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.677479734100388, "pattern_frame_queries": 72659, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1502405, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.677479734100388, "pattern_frame_updates": 218844, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2573667373, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11760.283000676282, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34459, "avg_candidate_generations": 3132.6363636363635, "candidate_moves_total": 2785512, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.83554368960213, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 740, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 34448, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2784772, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 851604, "avg_legality_checks": 77418.54545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 634, "root_legality_checks": 740, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 850864, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 634, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2911044, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 264640.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6179069717, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2122.630134412259, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26104, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2373.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 114729045, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4395.075275819798, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1160, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5034206, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14429, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 85353404, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10508, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24268165, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 73270, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60790, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5526.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 473317477, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7786.107534133904, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 78230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7111.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 178967774, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2287.71282116835, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2023286074, "stage_ordering_ns": 1121809683, "stage_eval_ns": 2575169778, "stage_threat_ns": 4599176226, "stage_proof_ns": 68673377, "tactical_annotations": 405692, "root_tactical_annotations": 2357, "search_tactical_annotations": 403335, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 219449, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1251137371, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 357132, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3140558000, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69153, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2345135371, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 109719, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 158731426, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 594, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2830414, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 219438, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26881662, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 65004, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 92562207, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 204388, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 658488597, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 136300, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19037353, "child_limit_applications": 34448, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34448, "child_cap_hits": 34448, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34448, "child_moves_before_total": 2784138, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2784138, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 311581, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 311581, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.82147004180213, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.044966326056665, "tt_hits": 17745, "tt_cutoffs": 2316, "beta_cutoffs": 25516, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4332.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5060.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1003, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1, "search_nodes": 76, "safety_nodes": 1004, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1080, "avg_nodes": 108.0, "eval_calls": 66, "avg_eval_calls": 6.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 66, "line_shape_eval_ns": 52271, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 791.9848484848485, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 672, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.2, "candidate_moves_max": 84, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 672, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11695, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1169.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23342865, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1995.969645147499, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4030, "stage_ordering_ns": 500, "stage_eval_ns": 52271, "stage_threat_ns": 18550094, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 142, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18181264, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 252870, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 98830, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 132, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17130, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 399, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7985, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 109, 108, 125, 141, 99, 139, 126, 142, 143, 138, 95, 140 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 278, "safety_nodes": 236, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 514, "avg_nodes": 73.42857142857143, "eval_calls": 271, "avg_eval_calls": 38.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 271, "line_shape_eval_ns": 199780, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 737.1955719557195, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 389, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.57142857142857, "candidate_moves_max": 66, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 389, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 389, "avg_legality_checks": 55.57142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 389, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8373, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1196.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17124678, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2045.2260838409172, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 111281, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10116.454545454546, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20380, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 90901, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 153030, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11771.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 84810, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4463.684210526316, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1012535, "stage_ordering_ns": 360, "stage_eval_ns": 199780, "stage_threat_ns": 15929360, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 549, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15240206, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 228242, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7060, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 271, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 392512, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 542, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 68400, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 7952, "avg_search_time_ms": 1136.0, "search_nodes": 65087, "safety_nodes": 192, "corridor_nodes": 56, "corridor_branch_probes": 74, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 19, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 15, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 19, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 19, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 140, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26039440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 65335, "avg_nodes": 9333.57142857143, "eval_calls": 37505, "avg_eval_calls": 5357.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37505, "pattern_eval_ns": 763212, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.34960671910412, "pattern_frame_queries": 37505, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 763212, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.34960671910412, "pattern_frame_updates": 130100, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1149373887, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8834.541790930054, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24889, "avg_candidate_generations": 3555.5714285714284, "candidate_moves_total": 1903516, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.48021214191009, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 399, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 24882, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1903117, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 1357101, "avg_legality_checks": 193871.57142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 964, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1357101, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 964, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3023553, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 431936.14285714284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5292267642, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1750.3472378357515, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13378, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1911.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30577297, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2285.6403797279113, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 964, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9325449, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1690, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14160703, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10714, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6984345, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 106800, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97179, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13882.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 781553532, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8042.411755626215, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 140563, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20080.428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 390564817, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2778.574852557216, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2734545912, "stage_ordering_ns": 689766790, "stage_eval_ns": 1150137099, "stage_threat_ns": 3291316576, "stage_proof_ns": 32123456, "tactical_annotations": 375163, "root_tactical_annotations": 1349, "search_tactical_annotations": 373814, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 130249, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 672896679, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 280516, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2496591963, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49910, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1483727647, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 65121, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 85635308, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 142, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 631873, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 130242, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14517912, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 42425, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 196187823, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 183918, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 813326989, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 148820, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21042841, "child_limit_applications": 24882, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24882, "child_cap_hits": 24882, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24882, "child_moves_before_total": 1902153, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1902153, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 242609, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 242609, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.44694960212202, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.75038180210594, "tt_hits": 14166, "tt_cutoffs": 2664, "beta_cutoffs": 19741, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2202.714285714286, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3070.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 400, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8409, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 85, 71, 93, 95, 80, 139, 97, 140, 155, 138, 142, 137 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8370, "avg_search_time_ms": 837.0, "search_nodes": 84564, "safety_nodes": 375, "corridor_nodes": 490, "corridor_branch_probes": 584, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 208, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 485, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 485, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 22, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 17, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 208, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 22, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 149, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2203920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2024480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85429, "avg_nodes": 8542.9, "eval_calls": 59391, "avg_eval_calls": 5939.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 59391, "pattern_eval_ns": 1233811, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.774376589045477, "pattern_frame_queries": 59391, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1233811, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.774376589045477, "pattern_frame_updates": 169032, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2336310597, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13821.70593142127, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23727, "avg_candidate_generations": 2372.7, "candidate_moves_total": 1925539, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.15391747797868, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 693, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 23717, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1924846, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 610090, "avg_legality_checks": 61009.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 706, "root_legality_checks": 693, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 609397, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 704, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2320622, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 232062.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5025028701, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2165.380101110823, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22912, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2291.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 140871661, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6148.37905900838, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 853, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7637143, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13460, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 105469349, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8544, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27176933, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 55, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 588236, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54779, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5477.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 491301703, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8968.796491356177, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 73996, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7399.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 219117447, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2961.2066463052056, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1473188683, "stage_ordering_ns": 781227739, "stage_eval_ns": 2337544408, "stage_threat_ns": 3653880077, "stage_proof_ns": 93606369, "tactical_annotations": 301960, "root_tactical_annotations": 1898, "search_tactical_annotations": 300062, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 170056, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1003789409, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 289649, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2487407841, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47763, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1722643158, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85023, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125131287, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1014, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5240472, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 170046, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21008182, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 66967, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 117522077, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 145269, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 570657306, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 89724, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11302886, "child_limit_applications": 23717, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23717, "child_cap_hits": 23717, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23717, "child_moves_before_total": 1924142, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1924142, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 232961, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 232961, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.12923219631487, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.82253236075389, "tt_hits": 11834, "tt_cutoffs": 1408, "beta_cutoffs": 17713, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 4.8, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 4.8, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4398.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5198.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 804, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 70, "safety_nodes": 914, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 984, "avg_nodes": 109.33333333333333, "eval_calls": 61, "avg_eval_calls": 6.777777777777778, "line_shape_eval_calls": 61, "line_shape_eval_ns": 45830, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 751.311475409836, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 621, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.0, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 621, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10546, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1171.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21243227, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2014.3397496681207, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.8888888888888888, "renju_forbidden_ns": 93891, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11736.375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 93891, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3680, "stage_ordering_ns": 490, "stage_eval_ns": 45830, "stage_threat_ns": 16908786, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 131, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16572716, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 231570, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88600, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 122, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15900, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 401, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5643, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 115, 116, 99, 83, 69, 84, 100, 82, 81, 86, 129, 85 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 271, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 502, "avg_nodes": 71.71428571428571, "eval_calls": 264, "avg_eval_calls": 37.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 264, "line_shape_eval_ns": 192881, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 730.6098484848485, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 380, "avg_candidate_moves": 54.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 64, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 380, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 380, "avg_legality_checks": 54.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 380, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17163006, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2052.254693291881, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 128650, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10720.833333333334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20560, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 108090, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 174482, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11632.133333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 98052, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4263.130434782609, "stage_move_gen_ns": 979485, "stage_ordering_ns": 350, "stage_eval_ns": 192881, "stage_threat_ns": 15848346, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 535, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15135111, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 275792, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 371003, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66440, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 5611, "avg_search_time_ms": 801.5714285714286, "search_nodes": 40787, "safety_nodes": 311, "corridor_nodes": 120, "corridor_branch_probes": 152, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 36, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 114, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 114, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 24, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 24, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 155, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 30104960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014640, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 41218, "avg_nodes": 5888.285714285715, "eval_calls": 23424, "avg_eval_calls": 3346.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23424, "pattern_eval_ns": 493044, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.048668032786885, "pattern_frame_queries": 23424, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 493044, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.048668032786885, "pattern_frame_updates": 81500, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 777907796, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9544.880932515338, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15998, "avg_candidate_generations": 2285.4285714285716, "candidate_moves_total": 1187053, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.20008751093887, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 390, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 15991, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1186663, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 808607, "avg_legality_checks": 115515.28571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1146, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 808607, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1146, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1799559, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 257079.85714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3726871825, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2070.991740198571, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12914, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1844.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 75857010, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5874.013473749419, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1150, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12400250, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3017, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32613851, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8727, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30624697, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 218212, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53400, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7628.571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 549652758, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10293.122808988765, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 75522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10788.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 287111565, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3801.6944069277824, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1903785499, "stage_ordering_ns": 480530603, "stage_eval_ns": 778400840, "stage_threat_ns": 2371364730, "stage_proof_ns": 40233475, "tactical_annotations": 222144, "root_tactical_annotations": 919, "search_tactical_annotations": 221225, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 81783, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 481531033, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 170544, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1806680395, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32176, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1110357875, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40888, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 59960182, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 276, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1295445, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 81776, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10216502, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 31528, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 174635508, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 97983, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 514619671, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 92633, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11681173, "child_limit_applications": 15991, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15991, "child_cap_hits": 15991, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15991, "child_moves_before_total": 1185517, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1185517, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 148140, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 148140, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.13651428928772, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.263960978050154, "tt_hits": 9151, "tt_cutoffs": 1335, "beta_cutoffs": 12853, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3009.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4152.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1622, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 402, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9084, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 83, 115, 98, 68, 84, 126, 85, 82, 129, 69, 99, 144, 71, 127, 57 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9049, "avg_search_time_ms": 1005.4444444444445, "search_nodes": 95700, "safety_nodes": 66, "corridor_nodes": 4, "corridor_branch_probes": 2, "corridor_max_depth": 1, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 32, "corridor_proof_active": 2, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 32, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 272, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 192080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 95770, "avg_nodes": 10641.111111111111, "eval_calls": 62709, "avg_eval_calls": 6967.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62709, "pattern_eval_ns": 1288726, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.550893811095698, "pattern_frame_queries": 62709, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1288726, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.550893811095698, "pattern_frame_updates": 191318, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2198792593, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11492.868381438233, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31071, "avg_candidate_generations": 3452.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2294284, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.84004377071868, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 498, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 31062, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2293786, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 698425, "avg_legality_checks": 77602.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1972, "root_legality_checks": 498, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 697927, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1970, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2478732, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 275414.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5377319791, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2169.3832939583626, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26503, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2944.777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 135922687, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5128.577406331358, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20993622, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12570, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 81881529, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11706, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32939226, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 108310, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48245, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5360.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 420728060, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8720.656233806612, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63871, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7096.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 180210666, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2821.478699253182, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1702136898, "stage_ordering_ns": 950830716, "stage_eval_ns": 2200081319, "stage_threat_ns": 4105542672, "stage_proof_ns": 55873602, "tactical_annotations": 269564, "root_tactical_annotations": 2097, "search_tactical_annotations": 267467, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 191395, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1091676297, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 238929, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2842111853, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62310, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2227162599, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 95693, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 137360341, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 68, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 233670, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 191386, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23249497, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 37343, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 63848222, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 138774, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 550593969, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 93447, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10911014, "child_limit_applications": 31062, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31062, "child_cap_hits": 31062, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31062, "child_moves_before_total": 2291816, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2291816, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 266800, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 266800, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.78198441826025, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.589273066769687, "tt_hits": 16487, "tt_cutoffs": 1888, "beta_cutoffs": 23203, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2467.1111111111113, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3356.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 138, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.25, "search_nodes": 121, "safety_nodes": 546, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 667, "avg_nodes": 83.375, "eval_calls": 113, "avg_eval_calls": 14.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 113, "line_shape_eval_ns": 81002, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 716.8318584070796, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 441, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.125, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 441, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9149, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1143.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18301317, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2000.362553284512, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 92522, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11565.25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 92522, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2930, "stage_ordering_ns": 400, "stage_eval_ns": 81002, "stage_threat_ns": 15448486, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 234, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15087705, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 172481, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 113, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159220, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 226, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29080, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 403, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8404, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 157, 172, 143, 129, 81, 159, 128, 114, 99, 174, 141, 144 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 25, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5714285714285716, "search_nodes": 278, "safety_nodes": 236, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 514, "avg_nodes": 73.42857142857143, "eval_calls": 271, "avg_eval_calls": 38.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 271, "line_shape_eval_ns": 197721, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 729.5977859778598, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 389, "avg_candidate_moves": 55.57142857142857, "candidate_moves_max": 66, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 389, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 389, "avg_legality_checks": 55.57142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 389, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8373, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1196.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16200711, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1934.8753135077034, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 115710, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10519.09090909091, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21910, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 93800, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8571428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 120041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9233.923076923076, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7142857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 67351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3544.7894736842104, "stage_move_gen_ns": 963724, "stage_ordering_ns": 350, "stage_eval_ns": 197721, "stage_threat_ns": 15256129, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 549, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14632486, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 183151, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 271, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 373321, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 542, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67171, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 8372, "avg_search_time_ms": 1196.0, "search_nodes": 66330, "safety_nodes": 192, "corridor_nodes": 56, "corridor_branch_probes": 74, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 19, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 15, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 19, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 19, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 140, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26022720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 66578, "avg_nodes": 9511.142857142857, "eval_calls": 38600, "avg_eval_calls": 5514.285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38600, "pattern_eval_ns": 796185, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.62655440414508, "pattern_frame_queries": 38600, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 796185, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.62655440414508, "pattern_frame_updates": 132586, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1103731234, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8324.64388396965, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25251, "avg_candidate_generations": 3607.285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 1952865, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.33812522276345, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 399, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 25244, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1952466, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 1375937, "avg_legality_checks": 196562.42857142858, "illegal_moves_skipped": 382, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1375937, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 382, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2922286, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 417469.4285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5601386011, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1916.7822762727535, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12696, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1813.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14051997, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1106.805056710775, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 382, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3978588, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 750, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 3802593, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11554, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6163346, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 107470, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 82143, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11734.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 777210173, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9461.6726075259, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 119753, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17107.571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 383115384, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3199.213247267292, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2959163718, "stage_ordering_ns": 735850392, "stage_eval_ns": 1104527419, "stage_threat_ns": 3492810235, "stage_proof_ns": 22062564, "tactical_annotations": 354939, "root_tactical_annotations": 1349, "search_tactical_annotations": 353590, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 132735, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 716049104, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 265476, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2651687921, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50634, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1632401683, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66364, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90998377, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 142, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 519951, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 132728, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15464370, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 42501, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 200703781, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 168078, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 815859925, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 144360, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18090512, "child_limit_applications": 25244, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25244, "child_cap_hits": 25244, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25244, "child_moves_before_total": 1952084, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1952084, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 223626, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 223626, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.32863254634765, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.85858025669466, "tt_hits": 14427, "tt_cutoffs": 2450, "beta_cutoffs": 19921, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1954.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2764.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 596, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 404, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10591, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 129, 157, 65, 98, 128, 111, 96, 80, 114, 156, 144, 160, 159, 174, 99 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10556, "avg_search_time_ms": 1172.888888888889, "search_nodes": 118194, "safety_nodes": 75, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 1, "corridor_proof_completed": 1, "corridor_proof_checks": 16, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 16, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 16, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 136, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 163600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 118269, "avg_nodes": 13141.0, "eval_calls": 75200, "avg_eval_calls": 8355.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75200, "pattern_eval_ns": 1524041, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.266502659574467, "pattern_frame_queries": 75200, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1524041, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.266502659574467, "pattern_frame_updates": 236304, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2348534586, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9938.615452975828, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39997, "avg_candidate_generations": 4444.111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 3094663, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.37237792834462, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 546, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 39988, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3094117, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 927256, "avg_legality_checks": 103028.44444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 909, "root_legality_checks": 546, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 926710, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2987007, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 331889.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6182076559, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2069.6558658884965, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16964, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1884.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 98271048, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5792.917236500825, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 967, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9490603, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8668, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 65112628, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7329, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23667817, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50563, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5618.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 429677448, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8497.863022368134, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66967, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7440.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 183012530, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2732.8763420789346, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2118403967, "stage_ordering_ns": 1205515426, "stage_eval_ns": 2350058627, "stage_threat_ns": 4806971711, "stage_proof_ns": 27746865, "tactical_annotations": 377683, "root_tactical_annotations": 2329, "search_tactical_annotations": 375354, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 236345, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1264500631, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 344887, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3341409114, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 80099, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2627451215, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 118168, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159872008, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 32, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 99270, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 236336, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27044299, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 47950, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 69339716, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 216798, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 644580883, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 112935, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14046389, "child_limit_applications": 39988, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39988, "child_cap_hits": 39988, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39988, "child_moves_before_total": 3093208, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3093208, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 356051, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 356051, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.35340602180653, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.903946183855156, "tt_hits": 18304, "tt_cutoffs": 2966, "beta_cutoffs": 30535, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1666.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2501.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.25, "search_nodes": 199, "safety_nodes": 467, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 666, "avg_nodes": 83.25, "eval_calls": 191, "avg_eval_calls": 23.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 191, "line_shape_eval_ns": 136671, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 715.5549738219895, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 487, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.875, "candidate_moves_max": 71, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 487, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9344, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1168.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18062678, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1933.0776969178082, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2950, "stage_ordering_ns": 400, "stage_eval_ns": 136671, "stage_threat_ns": 16065700, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 390, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15612436, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 129560, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7840, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 191, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 275473, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 382, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48231, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5496.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6496.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 405, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5897, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 67, 52, 81, 95, 79, 80, 66, 110, 125, 50, 83, 65 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 26, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.7142857142857144, "search_nodes": 271, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 502, "avg_nodes": 71.71428571428571, "eval_calls": 264, "avg_eval_calls": 37.714285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 264, "line_shape_eval_ns": 193481, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 732.8825757575758, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 380, "avg_candidate_moves": 54.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 64, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 380, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 380, "avg_legality_checks": 54.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 380, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17370617, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2077.079636494081, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 130821, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10901.75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20580, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 110241, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 212741, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 14182.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2857142857142856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 135221, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 5879.173913043478, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1018176, "stage_ordering_ns": 350, "stage_eval_ns": 193481, "stage_threat_ns": 16072640, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 535, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15330047, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 314681, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7310, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 360582, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67330, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 5864, "avg_search_time_ms": 837.7142857142857, "search_nodes": 43396, "safety_nodes": 311, "corridor_nodes": 122, "corridor_branch_probes": 154, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 38, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 116, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 116, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 24, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 24, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 155, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 30098000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014640, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 43829, "avg_nodes": 6261.285714285715, "eval_calls": 24718, "avg_eval_calls": 3531.1428571428573, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 24718, "pattern_eval_ns": 527484, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.34007605793349, "pattern_frame_queries": 24718, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 527484, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.34007605793349, "pattern_frame_updates": 86718, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 857638735, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9889.97365022256, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16328, "avg_candidate_generations": 2332.5714285714284, "candidate_moves_total": 1173955, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.89827290543852, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 390, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 16321, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1173565, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 810675, "avg_legality_checks": 115810.71428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1134, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 810675, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1134, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1890317, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 270045.28571428574, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3886715696, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2056.1184690186883, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12770, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1824.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 74606804, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5842.349569303054, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1142, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12190534, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2962, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31813970, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8646, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30383487, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 218813, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 62550, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8935.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 639729069, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10227.483117505995, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 88558, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12651.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 334421884, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3776.3034847218773, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1920568773, "stage_ordering_ns": 473389979, "stage_eval_ns": 858166219, "stage_threat_ns": 2534862594, "stage_proof_ns": 41715430, "tactical_annotations": 241325, "root_tactical_annotations": 919, "search_tactical_annotations": 240406, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 87005, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 519331938, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 182120, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1924690872, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32836, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1120828547, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43499, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 64187598, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 280, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1412044, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 86998, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10588590, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32357, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 178421526, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 108070, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 618058515, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 100898, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14651552, "child_limit_applications": 16321, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16321, "child_cap_hits": 16321, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16321, "child_moves_before_total": 1172431, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1172431, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 164444, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 164444, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.83573310458918, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.075608112248023, "tt_hits": 10135, "tt_cutoffs": 2320, "beta_cutoffs": 12984, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2878.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4021.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1585, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 406, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19862, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 96, 97, 68, 110, 80, 64, 83, 81, 65, 95, 67, 94, 51, 35, 69, 66, 54, 40, 99, 115, 84, 114, 39 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 19817, "avg_search_time_ms": 1651.4166666666667, "search_nodes": 219351, "safety_nodes": 80, "corridor_nodes": 42, "corridor_branch_probes": 35, "corridor_max_depth": 3, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 35, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 35, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 32, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 25, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 32, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 272, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 102080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 219473, "avg_nodes": 18289.416666666668, "eval_calls": 145584, "avg_eval_calls": 12132.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 145584, "pattern_eval_ns": 3024234, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.773120672601383, "pattern_frame_queries": 145584, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3024234, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.773120672601383, "pattern_frame_updates": 438580, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5305341666, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12096.63383191208, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 68576, "avg_candidate_generations": 5714.666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 5170018, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.39106976201586, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 721, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 68564, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5169297, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 1386593, "avg_legality_checks": 115549.41666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 948, "root_legality_checks": 721, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1385872, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 947, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5501109, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 458425.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11417753593, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2075.536695055488, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54200, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4516.666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 193972679, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3578.831715867159, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1785, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9033866, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29670, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 137545348, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22740, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 47349035, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 44430, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 125585, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10465.416666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 938449457, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7472.623776724928, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 154005, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12833.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 334624264, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2172.814285250479, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3200634338, "stage_ordering_ns": 1867583231, "stage_eval_ns": 5308365900, "stage_threat_ns": 9310218565, "stage_proof_ns": 62592916, "tactical_annotations": 1393091, "root_tactical_annotations": 3363, "search_tactical_annotations": 1389728, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 438726, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2493539321, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1229456, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6401159170, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 137368, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4398736937, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 219357, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 315687504, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 134, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 682911, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 438714, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52911825, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 289281, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 277041967, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 798361, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1719255938, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 305449, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 46237834, "child_limit_applications": 68564, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 68564, "child_cap_hits": 68564, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 68564, "child_moves_before_total": 5168350, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5168350, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 725447, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 725447, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.37993699317425, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.58058164634502, "tt_hits": 29830, "tt_cutoffs": 5143, "beta_cutoffs": 53138, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 4.833333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 4.833333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1569.9166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1931.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 36, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.272727272727273, "search_nodes": 174, "safety_nodes": 707, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 881, "avg_nodes": 80.0909090909091, "eval_calls": 163, "avg_eval_calls": 14.818181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 163, "line_shape_eval_ns": 145581, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 893.1349693251534, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 654, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.45454545454545, "candidate_moves_max": 82, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 654, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1123.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24785508, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2005.4622542276884, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.36363636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 38731, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9682.75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 38731, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4550, "stage_ordering_ns": 590, "stage_eval_ns": 145581, "stage_threat_ns": 21187864, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 337, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20738363, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 175660, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11540, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 163, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 232741, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 326, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41100, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 407, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24176, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 70, 126, 140, 83, 156, 114, 124, 108, 141, 139, 170, 184, 155, 125, 172, 188, 144, 143, 200, 185, 186, 158, 171, 201, 173, 174, 169 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 49, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.5, "search_nodes": 197, "safety_nodes": 1293, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1490, "avg_nodes": 106.42857142857143, "eval_calls": 183, "avg_eval_calls": 13.071428571428571, "line_shape_eval_calls": 183, "line_shape_eval_ns": 95030, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 519.2896174863388, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1158, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.71428571428571, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1158, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1158, "avg_legality_checks": 82.71428571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 1158, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17886, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1277.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 35095271, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1962.1643184613665, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.9285714285714284, "renju_forbidden_ns": 701755, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12759.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 136860, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 564895, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.4285714285714284, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 544622, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11346.291666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 70, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 299971, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4285.3, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2967633, "stage_ordering_ns": 810, "stage_eval_ns": 95030, "stage_threat_ns": 26756529, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 380, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 25808886, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 683242, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13920, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 183, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 225341, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 366, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39060, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6569.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7140.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 24115, "avg_search_time_ms": 1722.5, "search_nodes": 143884, "safety_nodes": 254, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 3, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 3, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 3, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 144138, "avg_nodes": 10295.57142857143, "eval_calls": 96032, "avg_eval_calls": 6859.428571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 96032, "pattern_eval_ns": 2080269, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.662248000666445, "pattern_frame_queries": 96032, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2080269, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.662248000666445, "pattern_frame_updates": 287630, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3475048020, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12081.660536105413, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44553, "avg_candidate_generations": 3182.3571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 4266332, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.75857966915808, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1186, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 44539, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4265146, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 3248062, "avg_legality_checks": 232004.42857142858, "illegal_moves_skipped": 44202, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3248062, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 44202, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7756554, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 554039.5714285715, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15523178336, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2001.2983002503431, "renju_forbidden_checks": 211883, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 15134.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1377955225, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6503.377925553254, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 44337, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 463279252, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28840, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 309297296, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 138636, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 604521863, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 856814, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 438084, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 31291.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 4961035429, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11324.393104975301, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 626923, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 44780.21428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2676514075, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4269.286778440095, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8100716256, "stage_ordering_ns": 1536499736, "stage_eval_ns": 3477128289, "stage_threat_ns": 10876280019, "stage_proof_ns": 4497200, "tactical_annotations": 1204932, "root_tactical_annotations": 4821, "search_tactical_annotations": 1200111, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 287650, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1688851076, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1074281, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8901068240, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 89186, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2975820691, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 143818, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 216587698, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22330, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 287636, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36101787, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 398438, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 2223452670, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 586639, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3701728499, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 219855, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33648888, "child_limit_applications": 44539, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44539, "child_cap_hits": 44539, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44539, "child_moves_before_total": 4220944, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4220944, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 661794, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 661794, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 94.76961763847414, "avg_child_moves_after": 14.858753002986147, "tt_hits": 18693, "tt_cutoffs": 3249, "beta_cutoffs": 36006, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.42857142857142855, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.42857142857142855, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2485.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2770.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 408, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19730, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 126, 114, 127, 129, 125, 124, 144, 82, 130, 83, 81, 68, 113, 52, 36, 66, 50, 67, 97, 65, 64, 69 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 19681, "avg_search_time_ms": 1640.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 194547, "safety_nodes": 251, "corridor_nodes": 346, "corridor_branch_probes": 413, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 144, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 343, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 343, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 1, "corridor_proof_completed": 1, "corridor_proof_checks": 4, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 1, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 144, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 4, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 4, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 10, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 3954080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1977040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 195144, "avg_nodes": 16262.0, "eval_calls": 148545, "avg_eval_calls": 12378.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 148545, "pattern_eval_ns": 3227463, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.727173583762497, "pattern_frame_queries": 148545, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3227463, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.727173583762497, "pattern_frame_updates": 388980, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6848271152, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 17605.71533754949, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43256, "avg_candidate_generations": 3604.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 3583101, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.83477436656186, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 826, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 43244, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3582275, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1212113, "avg_legality_checks": 101009.41666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2584, "root_legality_checks": 826, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1211287, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2582, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5299309, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 441609.0833333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11768555737, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2220.771752883253, "renju_forbidden_checks": 143550, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11962.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 570295253, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3972.7986973180077, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5182, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24014622, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 84789, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 425142323, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 53548, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 120966387, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 31, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 171921, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 170294, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14191.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1439640182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8453.851468636592, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 221747, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18478.916666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 549251393, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2476.928179411672, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3084740470, "stage_ordering_ns": 1499746586, "stage_eval_ns": 6851498615, "stage_threat_ns": 8153821077, "stage_proof_ns": 49663474, "tactical_annotations": 951008, "root_tactical_annotations": 3019, "search_tactical_annotations": 947989, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 389686, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2362855694, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 847117, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5399155592, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 86712, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3194070349, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 194837, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 304830015, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 694, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3702990, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 389674, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51579573, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 270193, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 329385317, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 468931, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1816580516, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 211884, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 31697213, "child_limit_applications": 43244, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43244, "child_cap_hits": 43244, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43244, "child_moves_before_total": 3579693, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3579693, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 594891, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 594891, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.77895199334012, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.7566136342614, "tt_hits": 18804, "tt_cutoffs": 2702, "beta_cutoffs": 31765, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4166666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2238.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2603.4166666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 34, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.090909090909091, "search_nodes": 89, "safety_nodes": 1138, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1227, "avg_nodes": 111.54545454545455, "eval_calls": 78, "avg_eval_calls": 7.090909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 78, "line_shape_eval_ns": 65991, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 846.0384615384615, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 759, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.0, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 759, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12915, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1174.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27341921, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2117.0670538133954, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2727272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32890, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2349.285714285714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 32890, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4790, "stage_ordering_ns": 560, "stage_eval_ns": 65991, "stage_threat_ns": 21856326, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 167, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21380944, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 333762, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12020, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 120530, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 156, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21090, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 409, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6773, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 144, 160, 97, 95, 65, 142, 158, 81, 113, 78, 94, 79, 82, 77 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.875, "search_nodes": 247, "safety_nodes": 431, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 678, "avg_nodes": 84.75, "eval_calls": 239, "avg_eval_calls": 29.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 239, "line_shape_eval_ns": 171982, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 719.5899581589958, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 530, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.25, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 530, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 530, "avg_legality_checks": 66.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 530, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21616302, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2163.360888710969, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 114890, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12765.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 65360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4668.571428571428, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1415867, "stage_ordering_ns": 340, "stage_eval_ns": 171982, "stage_threat_ns": 18511910, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17902057, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 198270, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 348583, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63000, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6734, "avg_search_time_ms": 841.75, "search_nodes": 48855, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 3, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 3, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 3, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 1760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49384, "avg_nodes": 6173.0, "eval_calls": 31683, "avg_eval_calls": 3960.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 31683, "pattern_eval_ns": 707132, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.318972319540446, "pattern_frame_queries": 31683, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 707132, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.318972319540446, "pattern_frame_updates": 97634, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 943773095, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9666.438894237663, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15949, "avg_candidate_generations": 1993.625, "candidate_moves_total": 1326804, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.19041946203524, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 547, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 15941, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1326257, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 864816, "avg_legality_checks": 108102.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 521, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 864816, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 521, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2048504, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 256063.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4423196465, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2159.2325252965093, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8446, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1055.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19814429, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2346.0133791143735, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 521, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6394961, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 472, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 4208586, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7448, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9146862, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 64020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 82631, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10328.875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 895291686, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10834.816061768586, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 131656, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16457.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 458704154, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3484.1112748374553, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2174502572, "stage_ordering_ns": 572091692, "stage_eval_ns": 944480227, "stage_threat_ns": 2998582454, "stage_proof_ns": 5574895, "tactical_annotations": 267851, "root_tactical_annotations": 1254, "search_tactical_annotations": 266597, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 97648, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 606908457, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 244032, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2296282026, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31947, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1160784481, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 76275916, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25320, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 97640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12682092, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 57892, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 308362570, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 154181, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 827020524, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 55778, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6408643, "child_limit_applications": 15941, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15941, "child_cap_hits": 15941, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15941, "child_moves_before_total": 1325736, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1325736, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 171087, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 171087, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.16517157016499, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.73251364406248, "tt_hits": 6651, "tt_cutoffs": 1194, "beta_cutoffs": 12095, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.625, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.625, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3832.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4832.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1593, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 410, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20037, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 142, 95, 65, 125, 140, 111, 114, 100, 139, 141, 156, 170, 124, 108, 172, 188, 109, 94, 154, 169, 157, 127, 155, 153, 158 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 19980, "avg_search_time_ms": 1427.142857142857, "search_nodes": 172868, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 1967, "corridor_branch_probes": 2077, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 898, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1957, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1957, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 70, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 60, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 898, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 70, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 556, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 27834160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 175648, "avg_nodes": 12546.285714285714, "eval_calls": 108221, "avg_eval_calls": 7730.071428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 108221, "pattern_eval_ns": 2376041, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.95545226896813, "pattern_frame_queries": 108221, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2376041, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.95545226896813, "pattern_frame_updates": 345596, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5029833889, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14554.085952962418, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 59692, "avg_candidate_generations": 4263.714285714285, "candidate_moves_total": 5178674, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.75658379682369, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1048, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 59678, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5177626, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1283517, "avg_legality_checks": 91679.78571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1589, "root_legality_checks": 1048, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1282469, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1589, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5148702, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 367764.4285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11758662425, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2283.811031401701, "renju_forbidden_checks": 72304, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5164.571428571428, "renju_forbidden_ns": 296680297, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4103.234910931622, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2215, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11511787, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 36991, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 196511588, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32583, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 87089891, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 515, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1567031, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 113764, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8126.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1050081662, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9230.351095249815, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 147187, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10513.357142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 447650096, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3041.3697948867766, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3255745933, "stage_ordering_ns": 2151297664, "stage_eval_ns": 5032209930, "stage_threat_ns": 9151847679, "stage_proof_ns": 328713675, "tactical_annotations": 1147972, "root_tactical_annotations": 3332, "search_tactical_annotations": 1144640, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 349664, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2191163753, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1021174, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6566524935, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 120692, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4477722563, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 174825, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 271021912, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4054, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 27065961, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 349650, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46179780, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 237284, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 256400166, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 556714, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1562529490, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 353974, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 49891338, "child_limit_applications": 59678, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 59678, "child_cap_hits": 59678, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 59678, "child_moves_before_total": 5176037, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5176037, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 685302, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 685302, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.73274908676564, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.48332718924897, "tt_hits": 31199, "tt_cutoffs": 4899, "beta_cutoffs": 48317, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 4.928571428571429, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 4.928571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2010.2142857142858, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2581.6428571428573, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 314, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 42, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.230769230769231, "search_nodes": 202, "safety_nodes": 1156, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1358, "avg_nodes": 104.46153846153847, "eval_calls": 189, "avg_eval_calls": 14.538461538461538, "line_shape_eval_calls": 189, "line_shape_eval_ns": 152790, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 808.4126984126984, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 979, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 979, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15239, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1172.2307692307693, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 32071569, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2104.571756676947, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6260, "stage_ordering_ns": 630, "stage_eval_ns": 152790, "stage_threat_ns": 26731538, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 391, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 26162706, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 232500, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 189, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 285612, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 378, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50720, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6458.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7074.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 411, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15714, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 113, 83, 81, 110, 124, 68, 54, 52, 36, 67, 97, 65, 129, 145, 66, 51, 99, 37, 22, 23, 9, 79 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 49, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.769230769230769, "search_nodes": 196, "safety_nodes": 1388, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1584, "avg_nodes": 121.84615384615384, "eval_calls": 183, "avg_eval_calls": 14.076923076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 183, "line_shape_eval_ns": 127611, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 697.327868852459, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 992, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 992, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 992, "avg_legality_checks": 76.3076923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 992, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16615, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1278.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 35384553, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2129.675173036413, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2307692307692308, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29381, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1836.3125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 29381, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 63, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.846153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 784764, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12456.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 96, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.384615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 441642, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4600.4375, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2564313, "stage_ordering_ns": 710, "stage_eval_ns": 127611, "stage_threat_ns": 27645501, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 379, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 26300324, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1026055, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 183, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 270252, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 366, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48870, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6458.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7073.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 15652, "avg_search_time_ms": 1204.0, "search_nodes": 99131, "safety_nodes": 495, "corridor_nodes": 1370, "corridor_branch_probes": 1581, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 36, "corridor_depth_exits": 588, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1363, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1363, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 11, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 4, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 588, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 11, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 11, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 40, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 8, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 13873760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1985760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 100996, "avg_nodes": 7768.923076923077, "eval_calls": 61816, "avg_eval_calls": 4755.076923076923, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 61816, "pattern_eval_ns": 1366632, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.108062637504855, "pattern_frame_queries": 61816, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1366632, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.108062637504855, "pattern_frame_updates": 198146, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2043411594, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10312.656293843933, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34576, "avg_candidate_generations": 2659.6923076923076, "candidate_moves_total": 3116966, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.14825312355391, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1016, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 34563, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3115950, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 2227662, "avg_legality_checks": 171358.61538461538, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1193, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2227662, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1193, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4978111, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 382931.6153846154, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10496802703, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2108.5915326114664, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54890, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4222.307692307692, "renju_forbidden_ns": 114872936, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2092.7844051739844, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1345, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14065110, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3397, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25932067, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 50148, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 74875759, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 207553, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15965.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2310967814, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11134.350329795281, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 314974, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 24228.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1212686075, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3850.1148507495855, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5466316249, "stage_ordering_ns": 1224883457, "stage_eval_ns": 2044778226, "stage_threat_ns": 6822502985, "stage_proof_ns": 5536714, "tactical_annotations": 725512, "root_tactical_annotations": 2850, "search_tactical_annotations": 722662, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 200907, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1255095843, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 705186, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5344211605, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69805, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2413189703, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 100447, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 157336645, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2748, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17716441, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 200894, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25860036, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 200199, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1016415875, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 360750, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1859591182, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 164563, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22282415, "child_limit_applications": 34563, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34563, "child_cap_hits": 34563, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34563, "child_moves_before_total": 3114757, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3114757, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 396885, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 396885, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.11824783728264, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.482944188872494, "tt_hits": 15489, "tt_cutoffs": 2696, "beta_cutoffs": 27762, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4570.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5186.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1769, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 412, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21152, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 85, 81, 80, 97, 94, 78, 66, 52, 140, 154, 108, 122, 124, 67, 37, 92, 109, 111, 79, 64, 139 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 21099, "avg_search_time_ms": 1623.0, "search_nodes": 197426, "safety_nodes": 539, "corridor_nodes": 577, "corridor_branch_probes": 632, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 302, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 574, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 574, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 22, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 302, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 22, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 148, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4051920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 198542, "avg_nodes": 15272.461538461539, "eval_calls": 135539, "avg_eval_calls": 10426.076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 135539, "pattern_eval_ns": 2900822, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.402120422904108, "pattern_frame_queries": 135539, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2900822, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.402120422904108, "pattern_frame_updates": 394714, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5904411376, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14958.707763089224, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 57699, "avg_candidate_generations": 4438.384615384615, "candidate_moves_total": 5028852, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.15665782769199, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 967, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 57686, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5027885, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1534826, "avg_legality_checks": 118063.53846153847, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2558, "root_legality_checks": 967, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1533859, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2558, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5797574, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 445967.23076923075, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12580345222, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2169.9326687335083, "renju_forbidden_checks": 142823, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10986.384615384615, "renju_forbidden_ns": 436978887, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3059.583449444417, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4264, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18603418, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 65707, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 274908246, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 72630, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 142707672, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 222, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 759551, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 177287, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13637.461538461539, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1554920042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8770.637677889525, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 232058, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17850.615384615383, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 643087854, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2771.2375957734703, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3721133219, "stage_ordering_ns": 1966877519, "stage_eval_ns": 5907312198, "stage_threat_ns": 9339323097, "stage_proof_ns": 94382257, "tactical_annotations": 1104776, "root_tactical_annotations": 3536, "search_tactical_annotations": 1101240, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 395919, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2418481291, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 932595, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6520692783, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 115776, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4172926179, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197953, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 296846756, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1192, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7021170, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 395906, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51285847, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 280115, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 367165182, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 508486, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1905024318, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 316175, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 44995250, "child_limit_applications": 57686, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 57686, "child_cap_hits": 57686, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 57686, "child_moves_before_total": 5025327, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5025327, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 737732, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 737732, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.11519259439032, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.7887529036508, "tt_hits": 30621, "tt_cutoffs": 4133, "beta_cutoffs": 45187, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 5.153846153846154, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 5.153846153846154, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1658.7692307692307, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2043.3846153846155, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 39, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.25, "search_nodes": 201, "safety_nodes": 1086, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1287, "avg_nodes": 107.25, "eval_calls": 189, "avg_eval_calls": 15.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 189, "line_shape_eval_ns": 152570, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 807.2486772486773, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 900, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.0, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 900, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14034, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1169.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29077060, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2071.9010973350437, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5880, "stage_ordering_ns": 620, "stage_eval_ns": 152570, "stage_threat_ns": 24591600, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 390, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24012438, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 243990, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13030, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 189, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 284452, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 378, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50720, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 413, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15434, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 64, 128, 144, 81, 129, 99, 174, 159, 130, 82, 79, 83, 84, 97, 67, 127, 142, 113, 162, 146, 141, 65, 49, 85, 71, 143, 94, 34, 109 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 60, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 520, "safety_nodes": 1110, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1630, "avg_nodes": 108.66666666666667, "eval_calls": 505, "avg_eval_calls": 33.666666666666664, "line_shape_eval_calls": 505, "line_shape_eval_ns": 545573, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1080.3425742574257, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1186, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.06666666666666, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1186, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1186, "avg_legality_checks": 79.06666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 1186, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19013, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1267.5333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 38775550, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2039.4230263503919, "renju_forbidden_checks": 71, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.733333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 796936, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11224.450704225352, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 145023, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 59, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 651913, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 55, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.6666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 675953, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12290.054545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.066666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 389853, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 5129.644736842105, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3078784, "stage_ordering_ns": 770, "stage_eval_ns": 545573, "stage_threat_ns": 34270907, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1025, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 32539129, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 890103, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15800, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 505, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 716905, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1010, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 124770, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 15, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 15, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6664.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7197.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 15360, "avg_search_time_ms": 1024.0, "search_nodes": 106551, "safety_nodes": 1456, "corridor_nodes": 1300, "corridor_branch_probes": 1647, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 556, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 1292, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1292, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 17, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 9, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 556, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 17, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 33, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 9986880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 109307, "avg_nodes": 7287.133333333333, "eval_calls": 63136, "avg_eval_calls": 4209.066666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 63136, "pattern_eval_ns": 1373447, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.75378547896604, "pattern_frame_queries": 63136, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1373447, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.75378547896604, "pattern_frame_updates": 212930, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2325051068, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10919.321222937115, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37490, "avg_candidate_generations": 2499.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 3264133, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.06676447052547, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1199, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 37475, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3262934, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 2071204, "avg_legality_checks": 138080.26666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9685, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2071204, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9685, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4741507, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 316100.4666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9794704115, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2065.736508456067, "renju_forbidden_checks": 61640, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4109.333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 407622938, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6612.961356262167, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10221, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 111380887, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17489, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 171121315, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 33808, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 123730061, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 122, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1390675, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 182191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12146.066666666668, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1871616895, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10272.828487686, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 259142, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17276.133333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 948487009, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3660.105305199466, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4997780509, "stage_ordering_ns": 1291997928, "stage_eval_ns": 2326424515, "stage_threat_ns": 6634753600, "stage_proof_ns": 18652774, "tactical_annotations": 699782, "root_tactical_annotations": 1476, "search_tactical_annotations": 698306, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 215563, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1303269611, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 660526, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5101405482, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75559, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2573855834, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 107774, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 163205438, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2618, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16275895, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 215548, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26972988, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 103551, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 409786770, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 407767, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2058330988, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 188464, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23624186, "child_limit_applications": 37475, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37475, "child_cap_hits": 37475, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37475, "child_moves_before_total": 3253249, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3253249, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 452851, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 452851, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.81118078719146, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.084082721814543, "tt_hits": 20465, "tt_cutoffs": 5855, "beta_cutoffs": 30749, "depth_sum": 84, "avg_depth": 5.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 84, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3998.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4532.133333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 290, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 414, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12863, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 128, 82, 113, 83, 143, 158, 84, 68, 54, 81, 79, 66, 99, 69, 129, 144, 65, 111, 126, 51 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 12819, "avg_search_time_ms": 1165.3636363636363, "search_nodes": 115675, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 3640, "corridor_branch_probes": 3851, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 1642, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 3626, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3626, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 22, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 8, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1642, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 22, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 21, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 148, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4031600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1977040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 119701, "avg_nodes": 10881.90909090909, "eval_calls": 73098, "avg_eval_calls": 6645.272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73098, "pattern_eval_ns": 1539845, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.065487427836604, "pattern_frame_queries": 73098, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1539845, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.065487427836604, "pattern_frame_updates": 231240, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2873130452, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12424.885192873206, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39375, "avg_candidate_generations": 3579.5454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 3099830, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.72584126984127, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 716, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 39364, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3099114, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 900591, "avg_legality_checks": 81871.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4057, "root_legality_checks": 716, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 899875, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4054, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3832574, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 348415.8181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7693893464, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2007.5003024077291, "renju_forbidden_checks": 53362, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4851.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 348207773, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6525.388347513212, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4983, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 48574919, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22007, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 177136012, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24639, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 109308046, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1733, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13188796, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 104005, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9455.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 884560477, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8504.980308639007, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 139885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12716.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 394327352, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2818.939500303821, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2098970656, "stage_ordering_ns": 1174877891, "stage_eval_ns": 2874670297, "stage_threat_ns": 6183283169, "stage_proof_ns": 437174941, "tactical_annotations": 667549, "root_tactical_annotations": 2193, "search_tactical_annotations": 665356, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 238547, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1359585660, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 720664, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4552012913, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 80658, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2837593788, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 119268, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 166715976, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7296, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 46168546, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 238536, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28262257, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 148260, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 154294940, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 288960, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1008469487, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 230329, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30537817, "child_limit_applications": 39364, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39364, "child_cap_hits": 39364, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39364, "child_moves_before_total": 3095060, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3095060, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 415141, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 415141, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.62666395691495, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.54620973478305, "tt_hits": 22788, "tt_cutoffs": 3158, "beta_cutoffs": 32069, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.909090909090909, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2906.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3634.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 30, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0, "search_nodes": 96, "safety_nodes": 1037, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1133, "avg_nodes": 113.3, "eval_calls": 86, "avg_eval_calls": 8.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 86, "line_shape_eval_ns": 76541, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 890.0116279069767, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 657, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.7, "candidate_moves_max": 76, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 657, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11772, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1177.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23829682, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2024.26792388719, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 162990, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 13582.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 162990, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4150, "stage_ordering_ns": 510, "stage_eval_ns": 76541, "stage_threat_ns": 19353164, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 182, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18857951, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 340493, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 131660, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 172, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23060, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 415, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9051, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 64, 128, 144, 81, 158, 110, 130, 116, 143, 141, 160, 111, 145, 146, 115, 100, 175 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.222222222222222, "search_nodes": 269, "safety_nodes": 616, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 885, "avg_nodes": 98.33333333333333, "eval_calls": 260, "avg_eval_calls": 28.88888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 260, "line_shape_eval_ns": 198113, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 761.973076923077, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 649, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 649, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 649, "avg_legality_checks": 72.11111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 649, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11543, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1282.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25151727, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2178.959282682145, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.7777777777777777, "renju_forbidden_ns": 326373, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 13054.92, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 68750, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 257623, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 34, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.7777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 435132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12798.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.555555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 239440, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4788.8, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1805908, "stage_ordering_ns": 500, "stage_eval_ns": 198113, "stage_threat_ns": 21348389, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 529, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20340405, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 559483, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10010, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 380521, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 520, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67980, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5773.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9007, "avg_search_time_ms": 1000.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 68296, "safety_nodes": 578, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 3, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 3, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 3, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68874, "avg_nodes": 7652.666666666667, "eval_calls": 48306, "avg_eval_calls": 5367.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48306, "pattern_eval_ns": 1067037, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.089119364054156, "pattern_frame_queries": 48306, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1067037, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.089119364054156, "pattern_frame_updates": 136508, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1445923522, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10592.22552524394, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18768, "avg_candidate_generations": 2085.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 1666888, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.8154305200341, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 672, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 18759, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1666216, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1047210, "avg_legality_checks": 116356.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7815, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1047210, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7815, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2643279, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 293697.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5711758596, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2160.8610351007214, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30821, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3424.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 232393854, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7540.114013172837, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7825, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 92151009, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8414, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 95682592, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14547, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44105841, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 454412, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 126559, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14062.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1392259527, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11000.873323904267, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 181438, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20159.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 704222798, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3881.341273603104, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2751804120, "stage_ordering_ns": 697135447, "stage_eval_ns": 1446990559, "stage_threat_ns": 4057026411, "stage_proof_ns": 5588485, "tactical_annotations": 347520, "root_tactical_annotations": 1684, "search_tactical_annotations": 345836, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136523, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 839424932, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 319338, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3084600638, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37589, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1380154464, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68257, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105682078, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28360, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136514, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17777782, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 91643, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 593445951, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 190093, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1110843953, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 65784, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9512621, "child_limit_applications": 18759, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18759, "child_cap_hits": 18759, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18759, "child_moves_before_total": 1658401, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1658401, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 237795, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 237795, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.40561863638787, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.676315368623062, "tt_hits": 7216, "tt_cutoffs": 1190, "beta_cutoffs": 13852, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3758.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4647.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1392, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 416, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16536, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 128, 110, 127, 125, 129, 130, 140, 82, 124, 81, 79, 114, 66, 83, 84, 111, 113, 97, 139, 69 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 16491, "avg_search_time_ms": 1499.1818181818182, "search_nodes": 158638, "safety_nodes": 238, "corridor_nodes": 330, "corridor_branch_probes": 395, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 132, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 327, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 327, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 1, "corridor_proof_completed": 1, "corridor_proof_checks": 4, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 1, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 132, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 4, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 4, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 10, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 3954080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1977040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 159206, "avg_nodes": 14473.272727272728, "eval_calls": 114308, "avg_eval_calls": 10391.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 114308, "pattern_eval_ns": 2488686, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.77175700738356, "pattern_frame_queries": 114308, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2488686, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.77175700738356, "pattern_frame_updates": 317172, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5213338039, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 16436.94285435032, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41588, "avg_candidate_generations": 3780.7272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 3370655, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.04874002115994, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 711, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 41577, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3369944, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1025916, "avg_legality_checks": 93265.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1236, "root_legality_checks": 711, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1025205, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1236, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4300020, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 390910.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9755519459, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2268.714903419054, "renju_forbidden_checks": 94510, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8591.818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 448725281, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4747.913247275421, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2953, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18405470, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 52721, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 329740430, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 38830, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 100508241, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 71140, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 124496, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11317.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1112014880, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8932.133401876366, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 158833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14439.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 435295949, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2740.588851183318, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2626179902, "stage_ordering_ns": 1398575961, "stage_eval_ns": 5215826725, "stage_threat_ns": 7161136061, "stage_proof_ns": 49023010, "tactical_annotations": 778130, "root_tactical_annotations": 2542, "search_tactical_annotations": 775588, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 317845, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1960470577, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 716370, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4883844325, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 83369, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3081219228, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 158917, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 247540562, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 662, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3522808, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 317834, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42069407, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 181208, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 258958664, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 430927, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1486931275, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 165995, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23688382, "child_limit_applications": 41577, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41577, "child_cap_hits": 41577, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41577, "child_moves_before_total": 3368708, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3368708, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 489975, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 489975, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.023354258364, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.784760805252905, "tt_hits": 17545, "tt_cutoffs": 2701, "beta_cutoffs": 31839, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2168.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2673.2727272727275, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1, "search_nodes": 86, "safety_nodes": 951, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1037, "avg_nodes": 103.7, "eval_calls": 76, "avg_eval_calls": 7.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 76, "line_shape_eval_ns": 62050, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 816.4473684210526, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 651, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.1, "candidate_moves_max": 76, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 651, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11725, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1172.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25114714, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2141.97987206823, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4210, "stage_ordering_ns": 590, "stage_eval_ns": 62050, "stage_threat_ns": 20045209, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 162, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19663427, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 241990, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118111, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21681, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 417, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6636, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 111, 81, 79, 114, 130, 95, 127, 50, 66, 65, 110, 35 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 33, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.125, "search_nodes": 247, "safety_nodes": 431, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 678, "avg_nodes": 84.75, "eval_calls": 239, "avg_eval_calls": 29.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 239, "line_shape_eval_ns": 170421, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 713.0585774058577, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 530, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.25, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 530, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 530, "avg_legality_checks": 66.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 530, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21921999, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2193.955064051241, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 114821, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12757.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 64480, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4605.714285714285, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1426287, "stage_ordering_ns": 450, "stage_eval_ns": 170421, "stage_threat_ns": 18718218, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18099406, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 200992, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 351610, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66210, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6596, "avg_search_time_ms": 824.5, "search_nodes": 46322, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 3, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 3, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 3, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 1760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 46851, "avg_nodes": 5856.375, "eval_calls": 29598, "avg_eval_calls": 3699.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 29598, "pattern_eval_ns": 656945, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.19558753969863, "pattern_frame_queries": 29598, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 656945, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.19558753969863, "pattern_frame_updates": 92568, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 875055122, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9453.10606257022, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15644, "avg_candidate_generations": 1955.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1304562, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.39056507287138, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 547, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 15636, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1304015, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 856771, "avg_legality_checks": 107096.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 517, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 856771, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 517, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2015503, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 251937.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4372407517, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2169.3877493608297, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8307, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1038.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19662036, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2366.9237992054896, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 517, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6623166, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 382, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 3920371, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7403, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9051749, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 66750, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83288, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10411.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 907010291, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10890.047677936798, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 133403, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16675.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 467409191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3503.7382292752036, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2172306594, "stage_ordering_ns": 555751682, "stage_eval_ns": 875712067, "stage_threat_ns": 2946249424, "stage_proof_ns": 5594263, "tactical_annotations": 253681, "root_tactical_annotations": 1254, "search_tactical_annotations": 252427, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 92582, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 575284093, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 234991, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2279529495, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31337, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1139396278, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 46287, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73087489, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25261, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 92574, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12077600, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56404, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 306866738, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 147238, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 833153419, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 50039, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6245486, "child_limit_applications": 15636, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15636, "child_cap_hits": 15636, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15636, "child_moves_before_total": 1303498, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1303498, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 163926, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 163926, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.36518291123049, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.483883346124328, "tt_hits": 6134, "tt_cutoffs": 1050, "beta_cutoffs": 11882, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.625, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.625, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3944.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4944.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1714, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 418, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20837, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 114, 81, 79, 83, 84, 97, 100, 86, 68, 52, 144, 160, 116, 132, 130, 67, 37, 102, 115, 113, 85, 70, 145 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 20780, "avg_search_time_ms": 1598.4615384615386, "search_nodes": 187393, "safety_nodes": 539, "corridor_nodes": 216, "corridor_branch_probes": 269, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 86, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 214, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 214, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 21, "corridor_proof_active": 2, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 21, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 21, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 147, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4053840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 188148, "avg_nodes": 14472.923076923076, "eval_calls": 128779, "avg_eval_calls": 9906.076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 128779, "pattern_eval_ns": 2843600, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.081239953719162, "pattern_frame_queries": 128779, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2843600, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.081239953719162, "pattern_frame_updates": 374650, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5947281491, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15874.233260376352, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 55014, "avg_candidate_generations": 4231.846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 4736934, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.10415530592213, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 967, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 55001, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4735967, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1391628, "avg_legality_checks": 107048.30769230769, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3251, "root_legality_checks": 967, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1390661, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3251, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5372011, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 413231.6153846154, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12310614479, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2291.6212343943453, "renju_forbidden_checks": 136409, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10493.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 502100548, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3680.846190500627, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4888, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26356044, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 67226, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 325355544, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 64274, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 150206008, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 182952, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 157788, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12137.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1484438427, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9407.803045859, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 207615, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15970.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 625669439, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3013.604214531705, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3535991713, "stage_ordering_ns": 1957295513, "stage_eval_ns": 5950125091, "stage_threat_ns": 9219185003, "stage_proof_ns": 66734240, "tactical_annotations": 1033578, "root_tactical_annotations": 3442, "search_tactical_annotations": 1030136, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 375133, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2368174026, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 874582, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6464011005, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 110256, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4215228941, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 187560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 296013284, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 470, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2378073, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 375120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50327465, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 261145, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 395744443, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 489445, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1813423580, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 282988, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 38281150, "child_limit_applications": 55001, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 55001, "child_cap_hits": 55001, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 55001, "child_moves_before_total": 4732716, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4732716, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 702851, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 702851, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.0478173124125, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.778876747695497, "tt_hits": 27711, "tt_cutoffs": 3545, "beta_cutoffs": 43353, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1418.3846153846155, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1824.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 39, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.25, "search_nodes": 201, "safety_nodes": 1086, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1287, "avg_nodes": 107.25, "eval_calls": 189, "avg_eval_calls": 15.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 189, "line_shape_eval_ns": 153580, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 812.5925925925926, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 900, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.0, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 900, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14034, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1169.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29917683, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2131.8001282599403, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5430, "stage_ordering_ns": 690, "stage_eval_ns": 153580, "stage_threat_ns": 25175719, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 390, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24585137, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 257861, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13550, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 189, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 281820, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 378, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50901, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 419, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6836, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 140, 154, 97, 99, 69, 142, 156, 83, 111, 86, 100, 85, 82, 87 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 32, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 247, "safety_nodes": 431, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 678, "avg_nodes": 84.75, "eval_calls": 239, "avg_eval_calls": 29.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 239, "line_shape_eval_ns": 171000, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 715.4811715481171, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 530, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.25, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 530, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 530, "avg_legality_checks": 66.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 530, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1249.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21664972, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2168.231785428343, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 116690, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12965.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 66190, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4727.857142857143, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1412085, "stage_ordering_ns": 470, "stage_eval_ns": 171000, "stage_threat_ns": 18500570, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17888528, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 200720, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8620, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 347301, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64021, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6798, "avg_search_time_ms": 849.75, "search_nodes": 48334, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 3, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 3, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 3, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48863, "avg_nodes": 6107.875, "eval_calls": 31550, "avg_eval_calls": 3943.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 31550, "pattern_eval_ns": 693091, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.968019017432646, "pattern_frame_queries": 31550, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 693091, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.968019017432646, "pattern_frame_updates": 96592, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 981722159, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10163.596974904754, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15771, "avg_candidate_generations": 1971.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1307406, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.8993722655507, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 547, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 15763, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1306859, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 866313, "avg_legality_checks": 108289.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4604, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 866313, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4604, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2026303, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 253287.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4434890066, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2188.660859703608, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10069, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1258.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 79994371, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7944.619227331414, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4604, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 54343994, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1616, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16599207, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3844, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8987580, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 63590, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 77087, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9635.875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 826662919, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10723.765602501071, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 112845, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14105.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 419140457, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3714.3024236784972, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2247866365, "stage_ordering_ns": 568446154, "stage_eval_ns": 982415250, "stage_threat_ns": 2953455452, "stage_proof_ns": 5585674, "tactical_annotations": 254628, "root_tactical_annotations": 1254, "search_tactical_annotations": 253374, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 96606, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 611140999, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 236987, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2248676544, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31591, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1188325279, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48299, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74649543, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25480, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 96598, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13111871, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 55301, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 285366297, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 150083, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 774873288, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49244, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5851015, "child_limit_applications": 15763, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15763, "child_cap_hits": 15763, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15763, "child_moves_before_total": 1302255, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1302255, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 159461, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 159461, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.61466725877054, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.116158091733807, "tt_hits": 6128, "tt_cutoffs": 983, "beta_cutoffs": 12002, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.625, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.625, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3801.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4801.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1614, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 420, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18332, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 141, 99, 129, 69, 54, 100, 140, 154, 142, 86, 72, 139, 127, 97, 110, 94, 109, 113, 157, 172, 125, 93, 173 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18278, "avg_search_time_ms": 1406.0, "search_nodes": 162757, "safety_nodes": 632, "corridor_nodes": 550, "corridor_branch_probes": 658, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 236, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 545, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 545, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 27, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 22, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 236, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 27, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 27, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 160, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6071120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2021040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 163939, "avg_nodes": 12610.692307692309, "eval_calls": 119068, "avg_eval_calls": 9159.076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 119068, "pattern_eval_ns": 2612049, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.937455907548628, "pattern_frame_queries": 119068, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2612049, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.937455907548628, "pattern_frame_updates": 325384, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6201178938, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 19058.032779731024, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41169, "avg_candidate_generations": 3166.846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 3643701, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.50593893463528, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 994, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 41156, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3642707, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1118167, "avg_legality_checks": 86012.84615384616, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7137, "root_legality_checks": 994, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1117173, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7134, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4652026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 357848.1538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10604895215, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2279.629394805618, "renju_forbidden_checks": 136930, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10533.076923076924, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1033230715, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7545.685496238954, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9617, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 96051295, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 85066, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 732304210, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 42095, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 203438117, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 152, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1437093, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 126118, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9701.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1260266421, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9992.756156932397, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 176367, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13566.692307692309, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 563445802, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3194.73485402598, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2919670495, "stage_ordering_ns": 1468114883, "stage_eval_ns": 6203790987, "stage_threat_ns": 7522037892, "stage_proof_ns": 114528011, "tactical_annotations": 837198, "root_tactical_annotations": 2728, "search_tactical_annotations": 834470, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 326541, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2065730575, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 709011, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5113886087, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 82710, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3212663466, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 163264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 257374089, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1144, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6709175, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 326528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43637037, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 225847, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 303928498, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 367869, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1506207333, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 243482, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 34700929, "child_limit_applications": 41156, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41156, "child_cap_hits": 41156, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41156, "child_moves_before_total": 3635573, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3635573, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 515435, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 515435, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.33640295461173, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.523933326853921, "tt_hits": 21010, "tt_cutoffs": 2468, "beta_cutoffs": 31404, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 4.923076923076923, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 4.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4008.4615384615386, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4564.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 294, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 39, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.25, "search_nodes": 202, "safety_nodes": 1216, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1418, "avg_nodes": 118.16666666666667, "eval_calls": 190, "avg_eval_calls": 15.833333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 190, "line_shape_eval_ns": 155401, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 817.9, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 916, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.33333333333333, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 916, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14101, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1175.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29996860, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2127.286008084533, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.3333333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 312602, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11164.357142857143, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 312602, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5650, "stage_ordering_ns": 710, "stage_eval_ns": 155401, "stage_threat_ns": 25415568, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 392, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24787184, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 291083, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13440, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 286811, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 380, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50490, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6997.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 421, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15826, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 70, 126, 140, 83, 125, 95, 170, 155, 124, 82, 85, 81, 80, 97, 67, 127, 142, 111, 152, 138, 143, 69, 55, 79, 63, 141, 100, 40, 115 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 63, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.2, "search_nodes": 520, "safety_nodes": 1110, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1630, "avg_nodes": 108.66666666666667, "eval_calls": 505, "avg_eval_calls": 33.666666666666664, "line_shape_eval_calls": 505, "line_shape_eval_ns": 555052, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1099.1128712871287, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1186, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.06666666666666, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1186, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 1186, "avg_legality_checks": 79.06666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 1186, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19013, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1267.5333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 40239314, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2116.4105611949717, "renju_forbidden_checks": 71, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.733333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 845622, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11910.169014084508, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 149821, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 59, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 695801, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 55, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.6666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 690841, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12560.745454545455, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.066666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 402420, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 5295.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3154674, "stage_ordering_ns": 1120, "stage_eval_ns": 555052, "stage_threat_ns": 35640506, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1025, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 33855389, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 909453, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16350, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 505, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 745454, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1010, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 130210, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 15, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 15, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6664.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7197.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 15751, "avg_search_time_ms": 1050.0666666666666, "search_nodes": 104774, "safety_nodes": 1456, "corridor_nodes": 1320, "corridor_branch_probes": 1658, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 572, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 1312, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1312, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 17, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 9, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 572, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 17, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 33, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 9983680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 107550, "avg_nodes": 7170.0, "eval_calls": 62143, "avg_eval_calls": 4142.866666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62143, "pattern_eval_ns": 1383825, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.268397084144635, "pattern_frame_queries": 62143, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1383825, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.268397084144635, "pattern_frame_updates": 209376, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2425500589, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11584.42509647715, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 36682, "avg_candidate_generations": 2445.4666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 3193953, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.0713974156262, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1199, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 36667, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3192754, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1992337, "avg_legality_checks": 132822.46666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11036, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1992337, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11036, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4657728, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 310515.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10006373525, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2148.3378859821782, "renju_forbidden_checks": 64492, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4299.466666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 452088629, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7009.995487812442, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11541, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 131341929, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18354, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 187023550, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 34475, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 132295685, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 122, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1427465, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 182388, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12159.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1936396981, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10616.909999561374, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 260847, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17389.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 982654054, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3767.166400226953, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5038201698, "stage_ordering_ns": 1309873710, "stage_eval_ns": 2426884414, "stage_threat_ns": 6875174506, "stage_proof_ns": 18563405, "tactical_annotations": 696481, "root_tactical_annotations": 1476, "search_tactical_annotations": 695005, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 212049, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1342423004, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 670561, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5297791275, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 73957, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2670318761, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 106017, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 169358716, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2658, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16669447, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 212034, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27742485, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 103463, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 403775612, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 419096, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2164220752, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 173922, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21189579, "child_limit_applications": 36667, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 36667, "child_cap_hits": 36667, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 36667, "child_moves_before_total": 3181718, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3181718, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 445690, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 445690, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.77333842419614, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.155071317533476, "tt_hits": 19285, "tt_cutoffs": 5879, "beta_cutoffs": 30064, "depth_sum": 84, "avg_depth": 5.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 84, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3716.866666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4250.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 422, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14456, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 126, 82, 111, 81, 141, 156, 80, 66, 50, 83, 85, 68, 95, 65, 125, 140, 69, 113, 128, 53 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14410, "avg_search_time_ms": 1310.0, "search_nodes": 114401, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 3579, "corridor_branch_probes": 3805, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 1599, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 3565, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3565, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 22, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 8, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1599, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 22, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 21, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 148, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4031600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1977040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 118366, "avg_nodes": 10760.545454545454, "eval_calls": 72530, "avg_eval_calls": 6593.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72530, "pattern_eval_ns": 1606194, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.145236453881154, "pattern_frame_queries": 72530, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1606194, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.145236453881154, "pattern_frame_updates": 228692, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3386130646, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14806.511141622794, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38623, "avg_candidate_generations": 3511.181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 3062889, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.30220335033529, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 716, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 38612, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3062173, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 902768, "avg_legality_checks": 82069.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4090, "root_legality_checks": 716, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 902052, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4087, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3810407, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 346400.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8694377022, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2281.744974224538, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54185, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4925.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 403576111, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7448.114994924795, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5012, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 54820487, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22732, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 213476519, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24725, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 121670426, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1716, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13608679, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 104683, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9516.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 994374135, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9498.907511248244, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 140203, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12745.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 434190906, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3096.873148220794, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2370163216, "stage_ordering_ns": 1294118918, "stage_eval_ns": 3387736840, "stage_threat_ns": 6877006157, "stage_proof_ns": 441339237, "tactical_annotations": 656700, "root_tactical_annotations": 2193, "search_tactical_annotations": 654507, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 235877, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1543771837, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 713070, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5035778591, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 79131, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3153824385, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 117933, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 189122727, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7174, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 45965855, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 235866, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31455710, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 144667, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 177538220, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 289506, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1147285396, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 222527, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30911437, "child_limit_applications": 38612, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38612, "child_cap_hits": 38612, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38612, "child_moves_before_total": 3058086, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3058086, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 406505, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 406505, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.20040401947581, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.527944680410235, "tt_hits": 22148, "tt_cutoffs": 3204, "beta_cutoffs": 31469, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.909090909090909, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2130.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2823.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 31, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.1, "search_nodes": 96, "safety_nodes": 1037, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1133, "avg_nodes": 113.3, "eval_calls": 86, "avg_eval_calls": 8.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 86, "line_shape_eval_ns": 77290, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 898.7209302325581, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 657, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.7, "candidate_moves_max": 76, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 657, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11772, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1177.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25249171, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2144.8497281685354, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 173682, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 14473.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 173682, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4370, "stage_ordering_ns": 590, "stage_eval_ns": 77290, "stage_threat_ns": 20377269, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 182, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19857936, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 361592, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 134291, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 172, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23450, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 10, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 10, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5996.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 423, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18305, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 97, 82, 142, 157, 113, 114, 66, 96, 68, 138, 124, 84, 128, 130, 146, 81, 83, 99, 126, 125, 129, 54, 145, 69 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 50, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.166666666666667, "search_nodes": 351, "safety_nodes": 953, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1304, "avg_nodes": 108.66666666666667, "eval_calls": 339, "avg_eval_calls": 28.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 339, "line_shape_eval_ns": 354431, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1045.519174041298, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 894, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.5, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 894, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 894, "avg_legality_checks": 74.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 894, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15161, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1263.4166666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 32759759, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2160.7914385594618, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.9166666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 429823, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12280.657142857142, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 80061, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 349762, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 33, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 393120, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11912.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 48, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 209740, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4369.583333333333, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2467219, "stage_ordering_ns": 760, "stage_eval_ns": 354431, "stage_threat_ns": 27732251, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 690, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 26520046, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 627373, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13181, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 339, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 497121, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 678, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 87711, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 18246, "avg_search_time_ms": 1520.5, "search_nodes": 112369, "safety_nodes": 323, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 3, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 3, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 3, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 112692, "avg_nodes": 9391.0, "eval_calls": 68171, "avg_eval_calls": 5680.916666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68171, "pattern_eval_ns": 1523378, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.346422965777236, "pattern_frame_queries": 68171, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1523378, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.346422965777236, "pattern_frame_updates": 224608, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2637349260, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11742.009456475282, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 40648, "avg_candidate_generations": 3387.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 3582794, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.14195040346388, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 909, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 40636, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3581885, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 2496252, "avg_legality_checks": 208021.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7930, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2496252, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7930, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5542373, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 461864.4166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12168277876, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2195.4996309342587, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65990, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5499.166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 239994813, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3636.8360812244277, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8243, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 98605867, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6372, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57279314, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 51330, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 83524907, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 584725, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 218716, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18226.333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2298865834, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10510.734623895829, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 318105, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26508.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1109727052, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3488.5558290501563, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6341505847, "stage_ordering_ns": 1518586610, "stage_eval_ns": 2638872638, "stage_threat_ns": 7649749714, "stage_proof_ns": 5552075, "tactical_annotations": 748422, "root_tactical_annotations": 3563, "search_tactical_annotations": 744859, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 224626, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1442135910, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 668081, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5972090697, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 81372, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3009628869, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 112307, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 182705720, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28620, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 224614, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30057006, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 166991, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 633830263, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 419703, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2328570935, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 161728, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22731761, "child_limit_applications": 40636, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 40636, "child_cap_hits": 40636, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 40636, "child_moves_before_total": 3573955, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3573955, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 408436, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 408436, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.95046264396102, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.051087705482823, "tt_hits": 17276, "tt_cutoffs": 3501, "beta_cutoffs": 32511, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.4166666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.4166666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2203.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2686.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 424, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9280, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 157, 128, 80, 114, 156, 113, 111, 99, 141, 144, 160, 129, 159, 84 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9244, "avg_search_time_ms": 1027.111111111111, "search_nodes": 88920, "safety_nodes": 68, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 1, "corridor_proof_completed": 1, "corridor_proof_checks": 16, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 16, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 16, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 136, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 259680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 28960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 88988, "avg_nodes": 9887.555555555555, "eval_calls": 62950, "avg_eval_calls": 6994.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62950, "pattern_eval_ns": 1359869, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.602366957903097, "pattern_frame_queries": 62950, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1359869, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.602366957903097, "pattern_frame_updates": 177762, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2749037252, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15464.70703524938, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24549, "avg_candidate_generations": 2727.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 1745579, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.10591062772414, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 534, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 24540, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1745045, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 597237, "avg_legality_checks": 66359.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 863, "root_legality_checks": 534, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 596703, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 862, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2363239, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 262582.1111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5564350642, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2354.544183639488, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26122, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2902.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 187152655, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7164.560715106041, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1070, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10694925, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16538, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 146767439, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8509, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29633120, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57171, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58664, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6518.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 558724826, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9524.151540979135, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 79936, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8881.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 237993481, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2977.3003527822257, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1573061928, "stage_ordering_ns": 777390285, "stage_eval_ns": 2750397121, "stage_threat_ns": 4088158858, "stage_proof_ns": 29546897, "tactical_annotations": 310108, "root_tactical_annotations": 2144, "search_tactical_annotations": 307964, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 177803, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1127153439, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 259613, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2784141460, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49200, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1992714639, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 88897, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 140083880, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 32, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 113990, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 177794, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23930924, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 59108, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 132895533, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 151265, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 658490528, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 99735, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12735165, "child_limit_applications": 24540, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24540, "child_cap_hits": 24540, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24540, "child_moves_before_total": 1744183, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1744183, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 244423, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 244423, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.07510187449063, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.960187449062754, "tt_hits": 12291, "tt_cutoffs": 1391, "beta_cutoffs": 17906, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2703.1111111111113, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3592.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 375, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 25, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.125, "search_nodes": 71, "safety_nodes": 708, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 779, "avg_nodes": 97.375, "eval_calls": 63, "avg_eval_calls": 7.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 63, "line_shape_eval_ns": 47870, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 759.8412698412699, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 475, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.375, "candidate_moves_max": 69, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 475, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9335, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1166.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19957865, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2137.9608998393146, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 47570, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11892.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 47570, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3190, "stage_ordering_ns": 450, "stage_eval_ns": 47870, "stage_threat_ns": 16010816, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 134, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15616205, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 276521, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8850, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 63, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 100480, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 126, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17610, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 8, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 8, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5495.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6495.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 425, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10285, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 143, 98, 141, 96, 158, 173, 99, 97, 94, 127, 142, 79, 63, 144, 139, 80, 140 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 45, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.090909090909091, "search_nodes": 325, "safety_nodes": 768, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1093, "avg_nodes": 99.36363636363636, "eval_calls": 314, "avg_eval_calls": 28.545454545454547, "line_shape_eval_calls": 314, "line_shape_eval_ns": 293510, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 934.7452229299363, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 737, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.0, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 737, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 737, "avg_legality_checks": 67.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 737, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13728, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1248.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29418904, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2142.9854312354314, "renju_forbidden_checks": 86, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7.818181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 949956, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11046.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 185150, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 764806, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 806124, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12401.907692307692, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.636363636363637, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 442994, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4663.094736842106, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2150279, "stage_ordering_ns": 590, "stage_eval_ns": 293510, "stage_threat_ns": 25826014, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 639, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 24263486, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1012615, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 314, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 466953, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 628, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 82960, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10230, "avg_search_time_ms": 930.0, "search_nodes": 68290, "safety_nodes": 650, "corridor_nodes": 226, "corridor_branch_probes": 268, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 94, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 222, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 222, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 11, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 94, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 11, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 9, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 21, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 58080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 16560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 69166, "avg_nodes": 6287.818181818182, "eval_calls": 41225, "avg_eval_calls": 3747.7272727272725, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41225, "pattern_eval_ns": 914142, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.174457246816253, "pattern_frame_queries": 41225, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 914142, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.174457246816253, "pattern_frame_updates": 136468, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1942946487, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14237.377898115308, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24018, "avg_candidate_generations": 2183.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 1893524, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.83770505454243, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 750, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 24007, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1892774, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1058833, "avg_legality_checks": 96257.54545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16520, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1058833, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16520, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2932861, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 266623.7272727273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6369865549, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2171.894797946442, "renju_forbidden_checks": 53095, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4826.818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 456752303, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8602.548319050758, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16707, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 180921263, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17759, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 182455516, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18505, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 91945165, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 124, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1430359, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 118022, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10729.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1334079860, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11303.65406449645, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 173248, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15749.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 690706540, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3986.8081594015516, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2818883967, "stage_ordering_ns": 815478882, "stage_eval_ns": 1943860629, "stage_threat_ns": 4587744921, "stage_proof_ns": 18168879, "tactical_annotations": 444433, "root_tactical_annotations": 1513, "search_tactical_annotations": 442920, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136945, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 878209235, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 378254, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3561663324, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48231, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1853833111, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68467, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 111363703, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 466, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2903862, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136934, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18151151, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 85541, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 479882460, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 231095, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1216588276, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 127797, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15453646, "child_limit_applications": 24007, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24007, "child_cap_hits": 24007, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24007, "child_moves_before_total": 1876254, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1876254, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 293294, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 293294, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.15445495063939, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.217020035822886, "tt_hits": 12138, "tt_cutoffs": 3003, "beta_cutoffs": 19480, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4443.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5170.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1564, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 426, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d1", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 56743, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 109, 84, 70, 126, 140, 142, 94, 141, 156, 124, 96, 125, 127, 97, 83, 153, 139, 138, 123, 152, 166, 158, 174, 107, 95, 81, 93, 92, 137, 151, 154, 77, 122, 108, 150, 76, 60, 62, 47, 48, 34, 78, 79, 64, 63, 31, 106, 32, 80, 46, 16, 144, 50, 116, 65, 35, 51, 37, 66, 18, 52, 38, 53, 49, 54 ], "move_count": 72, "black_stats": { "move_count": 36, "search_move_count": 34, "total_time_ms": 56602, "avg_search_time_ms": 1664.764705882353, "search_nodes": 586710, "safety_nodes": 1027, "corridor_nodes": 1093, "corridor_branch_probes": 1206, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 329, "corridor_neutral_exits": 78, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1077, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1077, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 78, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 329, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 415, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 36023120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4000000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 588830, "avg_nodes": 17318.529411764706, "eval_calls": 361721, "avg_eval_calls": 10638.85294117647, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 361721, "pattern_eval_ns": 7887400, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.805203457913695, "pattern_frame_queries": 361721, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7887400, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.805203457913695, "pattern_frame_updates": 1173032, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 12641594934, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10776.854283600107, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 208944, "avg_candidate_generations": 6145.411764705882, "candidate_moves_total": 20343248, "avg_candidate_moves": 97.36220231258136, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 34, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3039, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 208910, "search_candidate_moves_total": 20340209, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 5604946, "avg_legality_checks": 164851.35294117648, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2641, "root_legality_checks": 3039, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5601907, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2641, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15867824, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 466700.70588235295, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31900469685, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2010.387163671591, "renju_forbidden_checks": 138166, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4063.705882352941, "renju_forbidden_ns": 416667380, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3015.701257907155, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7866, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30864734, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 57952, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 246577413, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 72208, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 139059353, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 140, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 165880, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 284208, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8359.058823529413, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2158788129, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7595.803527698024, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 380154, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11181.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 886730486, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2332.5559799449697, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12170166934, "stage_ordering_ns": 6993559396, "stage_eval_ns": 12649482334, "stage_threat_ns": 24354694702, "stage_proof_ns": 188646524, "tactical_annotations": 5015600, "root_tactical_annotations": 12436, "search_tactical_annotations": 5003164, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1175328, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6370270345, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 4409117, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 16786711848, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 418950, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11396686762, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 587647, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 876410189, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2262, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20370604, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1175294, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 144256560, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1599732, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 572467760, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 2328155, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 4698831203, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1087713, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 156675156, "child_limit_applications": 208910, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 208910, "child_cap_hits": 208910, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 208910, "child_moves_before_total": 20337568, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 20337568, "child_moves_before_max": 135, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 135, "child_moves_after_total": 1817615, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1817615, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 97.35085922167441, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.700469101526974, "tt_hits": 99254, "tt_cutoffs": 15895, "beta_cutoffs": 162006, "depth_sum": 182, "avg_depth": 5.352941176470588, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 182, "avg_effective_depth": 5.352941176470588, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 12 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 12, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_moves": 34, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3235294117647059, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 12, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2328.9117647058824, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2564.205882352941, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 36, "search_move_count": 34, "total_time_ms": 109, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.2058823529411766, "search_nodes": 804, "safety_nodes": 4083, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 4887, "avg_nodes": 143.73529411764707, "eval_calls": 770, "avg_eval_calls": 22.647058823529413, "line_shape_eval_calls": 770, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1805399, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 2344.674025974026, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3070, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.29411764705883, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 34, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3070, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 37252, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1095.6470588235295, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 73579943, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1975.1944325136906, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.0588235294117647, "renju_forbidden_ns": 55520, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1542.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 36, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55520, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 21080, "stage_ordering_ns": 1980, "stage_eval_ns": 1805399, "stage_threat_ns": 67100248, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1574, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 64919002, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 94, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 863342, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 36880, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1129483, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1540, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 188421, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 34 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 34, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7410.794117647059, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7646.088235294118, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 427, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7110, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 125, 128, 95, 66, 110, 140, 80, 96, 65 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.0, "search_nodes": 290, "safety_nodes": 243, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 533, "avg_nodes": 76.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 283, "avg_eval_calls": 40.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 283, "line_shape_eval_ns": 215470, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 761.3780918727915, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 408, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 408, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 408, "avg_legality_checks": 58.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 408, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1222.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18508976, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2162.2635514018693, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 320013, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11429.035714285714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 54682, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 265331, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 333272, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12343.407407407407, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.714285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 188982, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4724.55, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1157695, "stage_ordering_ns": 370, "stage_eval_ns": 215470, "stage_threat_ns": 17450435, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 573, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16500650, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 453882, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7640, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 419073, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 566, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 76830, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 7073, "avg_search_time_ms": 1010.4285714285714, "search_nodes": 52479, "safety_nodes": 215, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 3, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 3, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 3, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 14560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 52694, "avg_nodes": 7527.714285714285, "eval_calls": 34919, "avg_eval_calls": 4988.428571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34919, "pattern_eval_ns": 780932, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.364099773762135, "pattern_frame_queries": 34919, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 780932, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.364099773762135, "pattern_frame_updates": 104890, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1345909084, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12831.624406521118, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16229, "avg_candidate_generations": 2318.4285714285716, "candidate_moves_total": 1221581, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.2714893092612, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 421, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 16222, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1221160, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 705159, "avg_legality_checks": 100737.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8512, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 705159, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8512, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2078396, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 296913.71428571426, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4404601858, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2119.2313004836424, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36808, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5258.285714285715, "renju_forbidden_ns": 303554176, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8246.961964790264, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8877, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 96974549, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14266, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 150966890, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13625, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 55142207, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 470530, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99113, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14159.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1088377790, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10981.180975250472, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 146270, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20895.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 560411882, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3831.3521706433307, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1874963863, "stage_ordering_ns": 513206022, "stage_eval_ns": 1346690016, "stage_threat_ns": 3302184126, "stage_proof_ns": 5543153, "tactical_annotations": 262970, "root_tactical_annotations": 1216, "search_tactical_annotations": 261754, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 104903, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 651177504, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 246980, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2549515060, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32503, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1206980599, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52448, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81751162, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26121, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 104896, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13697177, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52058, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 358154074, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 162408, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 984322467, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 48504, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6017102, "child_limit_applications": 16222, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16222, "child_cap_hits": 16222, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16222, "child_moves_before_total": 1212648, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1212648, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 194641, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 194641, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.75329799038343, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.998582172358525, "tt_hits": 5876, "tt_cutoffs": 1305, "beta_cutoffs": 12323, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2800.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3792.4285714285716, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1464, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 428, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19644, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 96, 98, 82, 127, 128, 80, 110, 68, 111, 113, 67, 52, 83, 69, 99, 51, 84, 85, 124, 138, 139, 125, 109, 108, 94, 79, 154 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 19591, "avg_search_time_ms": 1399.357142857143, "search_nodes": 186809, "safety_nodes": 80, "corridor_nodes": 4488, "corridor_branch_probes": 4499, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2544, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 4481, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4481, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 1, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 7, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2544, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 7, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 7, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 28, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 7, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 191377, "avg_nodes": 13669.785714285714, "eval_calls": 125906, "avg_eval_calls": 8993.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 125906, "pattern_eval_ns": 2721942, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.618842628627707, "pattern_frame_queries": 125906, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2721942, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.618842628627707, "pattern_frame_updates": 373494, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4848750313, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12982.137097249219, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 56760, "avg_candidate_generations": 4054.285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 4525017, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.72193446088795, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 893, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 56746, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4524124, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1292506, "avg_legality_checks": 92321.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 492, "root_legality_checks": 893, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1291613, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 492, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5260004, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 375714.5714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11602008171, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2205.703298134374, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24130, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1723.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_ns": 84113548, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3485.849481972648, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 696, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3091372, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12641, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57459973, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10539, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22082751, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 254, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1479452, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 134464, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9604.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1042163892, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7750.504908376964, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 166632, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11902.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 344505493, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2067.4629903019827, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3168742624, "stage_ordering_ns": 1822673061, "stage_eval_ns": 4851472255, "stage_threat_ns": 9314864829, "stage_proof_ns": 378703532, "tactical_annotations": 1138305, "root_tactical_annotations": 3680, "search_tactical_annotations": 1134625, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 382484, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2422413203, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1145989, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6446776381, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 115539, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4168933827, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 191235, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 298944296, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8976, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 52341983, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 382470, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50056090, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 285771, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 288623681, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 547015, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1456117132, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 305519, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 44332876, "child_limit_applications": 56746, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 56746, "child_cap_hits": 56746, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 56746, "child_moves_before_total": 4523632, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4523632, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 598164, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 598164, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.71719592570402, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.541077785218341, "tt_hits": 26378, "tt_cutoffs": 4097, "beta_cutoffs": 42440, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.214285714285714, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.214285714285714, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3674.4285714285716, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4245.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 39, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0, "search_nodes": 81, "safety_nodes": 1162, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1243, "avg_nodes": 95.61538461538461, "eval_calls": 68, "avg_eval_calls": 5.230769230769231, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68, "line_shape_eval_ns": 61790, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 908.6764705882352, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 820, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.07692307692308, "candidate_moves_max": 80, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 820, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14874, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1144.1538461538462, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29929940, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2012.2320828290979, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5511, "stage_ordering_ns": 680, "stage_eval_ns": 61790, "stage_threat_ns": 23883961, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 149, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 23387749, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 370950, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 106872, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18390, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 13, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 13, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6459.076923076923, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7074.461538461538, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 429, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15611, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 114, 115, 97, 82, 68, 126, 94, 81, 98, 124, 138, 83, 84, 80, 79, 125, 70, 56, 127, 95, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 45, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.75, "search_nodes": 256, "safety_nodes": 971, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1227, "avg_nodes": 102.25, "eval_calls": 244, "avg_eval_calls": 20.333333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 244, "line_shape_eval_ns": 189740, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 777.6229508196722, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 840, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.0, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 840, "avg_legality_checks": 70.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 840, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15042, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1253.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 32087056, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2133.164206887382, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.0833333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 293920, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11756.8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 55770, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 238150, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 461941, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11844.641025641025, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 249620, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4457.5, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2255110, "stage_ordering_ns": 660, "stage_eval_ns": 189740, "stage_threat_ns": 26345340, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 500, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 25221016, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 693752, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 244, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 365532, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 488, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65040, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 15553, "avg_search_time_ms": 1296.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 109547, "safety_nodes": 784, "corridor_nodes": 763, "corridor_branch_probes": 830, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 9, "corridor_depth_exits": 286, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 755, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 755, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 15, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 286, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 15, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 15, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 47, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 7, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 8105600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2023040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 111094, "avg_nodes": 9257.833333333334, "eval_calls": 71464, "avg_eval_calls": 5955.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71464, "pattern_eval_ns": 1571738, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.993423262062016, "pattern_frame_queries": 71464, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1571738, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.993423262062016, "pattern_frame_updates": 218966, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2310323640, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10551.061077975575, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35247, "avg_candidate_generations": 2937.25, "candidate_moves_total": 3183492, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.3195165546004, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 866, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 35235, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3182626, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 2282811, "avg_legality_checks": 190234.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7882, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2282811, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7882, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4687717, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 390643.0833333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10208811326, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2177.7789329005996, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28348, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2362.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 193544685, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6827.454670523493, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8111, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 86905939, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6964, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71085982, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13238, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 35125893, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 426871, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 144447, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12037.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1444645430, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10001.214493897416, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 200265, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16688.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 692051460, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3455.678525953112, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5653963150, "stage_ordering_ns": 1319440763, "stage_eval_ns": 2311895378, "stage_threat_ns": 6159161376, "stage_proof_ns": 19626153, "tactical_annotations": 668476, "root_tactical_annotations": 2378, "search_tactical_annotations": 666098, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 220518, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1399404865, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 590290, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4519791351, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 71008, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2571710182, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 110253, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 173298374, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1540, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9418582, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 220506, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28971273, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 173650, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 648260154, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 298137, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1260497713, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 196689, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28276931, "child_limit_applications": 35235, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35235, "child_cap_hits": 35235, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35235, "child_moves_before_total": 3174744, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3174744, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 349933, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 349933, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.10200085142614, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.931403434085427, "tt_hits": 18725, "tt_cutoffs": 2785, "beta_cutoffs": 27997, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.083333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.083333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4015.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4682.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1629, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 430, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10526, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 82, 124, 68, 54, 114, 98, 84, 125, 127, 139, 97, 154, 140, 169, 109, 184 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10484, "avg_search_time_ms": 1048.4, "search_nodes": 97836, "safety_nodes": 251, "corridor_nodes": 62, "corridor_branch_probes": 71, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 59, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 59, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 21, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 21, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 21, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 147, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4064080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 98149, "avg_nodes": 9814.9, "eval_calls": 68182, "avg_eval_calls": 6818.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68182, "pattern_eval_ns": 1474067, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.61959168108885, "pattern_frame_queries": 68182, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1474067, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.61959168108885, "pattern_frame_updates": 195576, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2752502229, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14073.824134863173, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27813, "avg_candidate_generations": 2781.3, "candidate_moves_total": 2164908, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.83798942940352, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 664, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 27803, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2164244, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 828636, "avg_legality_checks": 82863.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1094, "root_legality_checks": 664, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 827972, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1094, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2812155, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 281215.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6396278694, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2274.5114312689025, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26788, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2678.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 131013866, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4890.766985217261, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1265, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11186750, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13736, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 90986851, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11787, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28840265, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76766, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7676.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 741194140, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9655.239819711851, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 107351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10735.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 333049710, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3102.4369591340555, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2117557383, "stage_ordering_ns": 941921437, "stage_eval_ns": 2753976296, "stage_threat_ns": 4583707406, "stage_proof_ns": 48288592, "tactical_annotations": 379991, "root_tactical_annotations": 2155, "search_tactical_annotations": 377836, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 195746, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1218089279, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 335380, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3174111038, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 55785, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2134581167, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 97868, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 149827994, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 160, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 804323, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 195736, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25824211, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 86054, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 168691386, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 188626, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 859330528, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 105311, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15050561, "child_limit_applications": 27803, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27803, "child_cap_hits": 27803, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27803, "child_moves_before_total": 2163150, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2163150, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 271812, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 271812, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.80275509837068, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.776355069596805, "tt_hits": 13668, "tt_cutoffs": 1803, "beta_cutoffs": 20217, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 4.8, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 4.8, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3071.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3871.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 368, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 30, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3333333333333335, "search_nodes": 201, "safety_nodes": 683, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 192, "avg_eval_calls": 21.333333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 192, "line_shape_eval_ns": 147120, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 766.25, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 605, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_max": 80, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 605, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10548, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1172.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22392423, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2122.906996587031, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3720, "stage_ordering_ns": 530, "stage_eval_ns": 147120, "stage_threat_ns": 19543131, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 393, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 19005379, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 202440, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10100, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 192, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 282111, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53201, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5773.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 431, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15665, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 142, 157, 111, 110, 68, 98, 66, 138, 124, 80, 126, 130, 146, 125, 140, 79, 154, 168, 81, 95, 141, 65 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 50, "avg_search_time_ms": 4.166666666666667, "search_nodes": 358, "safety_nodes": 979, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1337, "avg_nodes": 111.41666666666667, "eval_calls": 346, "avg_eval_calls": 28.833333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 346, "line_shape_eval_ns": 367521, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1062.199421965318, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 915, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.25, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 915, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 915, "avg_legality_checks": 76.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 915, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15277, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1273.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 32537910, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2129.8625384565034, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.9166666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 426701, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12191.457142857143, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 89781, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 336920, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.6666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 528332, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12007.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.416666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 292311, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4497.092307692307, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2472031, "stage_ordering_ns": 720, "stage_eval_ns": 367521, "stage_threat_ns": 27798707, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 704, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 26508732, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 686053, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13140, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 346, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 514852, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 692, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 89070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 15608, "avg_search_time_ms": 1300.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 101227, "safety_nodes": 679, "corridor_nodes": 158, "corridor_branch_probes": 199, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 48, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 154, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 154, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 11, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 48, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 11, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 11, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 25, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 8012400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2004480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 102064, "avg_nodes": 8505.333333333334, "eval_calls": 62075, "avg_eval_calls": 5172.916666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62075, "pattern_eval_ns": 1372565, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.11139750302054, "pattern_frame_queries": 62075, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1372565, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.11139750302054, "pattern_frame_updates": 202328, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2271785779, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11228.232271361354, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35739, "avg_candidate_generations": 2978.25, "candidate_moves_total": 3203709, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.64181986065643, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 932, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 35727, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3202777, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 2107815, "avg_legality_checks": 175651.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10017, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2107815, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10017, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4791786, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 399315.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10255381015, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2140.200128928963, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46211, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3850.9166666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 270358161, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5850.515266927788, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10166, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 108753800, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10777, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 103780763, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25190, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 56879544, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 78, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 944054, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 192903, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16075.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1995469351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10344.418443466406, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 282638, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23553.166666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 986740748, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3491.1821764943143, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5293252530, "stage_ordering_ns": 1338572985, "stage_eval_ns": 2273158344, "stage_threat_ns": 6596351557, "stage_proof_ns": 18799780, "tactical_annotations": 607614, "root_tactical_annotations": 2605, "search_tactical_annotations": 605009, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 202670, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1278021113, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 549667, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5111316940, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 71657, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2574369955, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 101329, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 158325868, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 330, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2121860, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 202658, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26281949, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 130605, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 641417680, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 336285, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1886506911, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 140724, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20283827, "child_limit_applications": 35727, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35727, "child_cap_hits": 35727, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35727, "child_moves_before_total": 3192760, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3192760, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 374932, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 374932, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.36546589414169, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.49436000783721, "tt_hits": 15892, "tt_cutoffs": 3363, "beta_cutoffs": 28408, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3516.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4182.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1669, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 432, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27263, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 98, 68, 54, 110, 124, 142, 100, 126, 94, 158, 174, 111, 99, 101, 141, 81, 66, 85, 113, 155, 80, 84, 83, 52, 109, 36, 20, 139, 67, 51, 156, 115, 108, 122, 140, 172, 92 ], "move_count": 43, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 27184, "avg_search_time_ms": 1359.2, "search_nodes": 268367, "safety_nodes": 1195, "corridor_nodes": 563, "corridor_branch_probes": 673, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 183, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 547, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 547, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 80, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 183, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 80, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 80, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 579, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 61768720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2029600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 270125, "avg_nodes": 13506.25, "eval_calls": 174570, "avg_eval_calls": 8728.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 174570, "pattern_eval_ns": 3798251, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.75775333677035, "pattern_frame_queries": 174570, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3798251, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.75775333677035, "pattern_frame_updates": 536512, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6865304825, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12796.181306289514, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 86764, "avg_candidate_generations": 4338.2, "candidate_moves_total": 8292249, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.57246092849569, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1762, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 86744, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8290487, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 2308775, "avg_legality_checks": 115438.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1507, "root_legality_checks": 1762, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 2307013, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1506, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7680395, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 384019.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15967081067, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2078.9400892792623, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54941, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2747.05, "renju_forbidden_ns": 184243042, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3353.4708505487706, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1867, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13704407, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23625, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 113845636, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29394, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 56298268, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 55, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 394731, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 183576, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9178.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1493407025, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8135.088600906437, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 234657, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11732.85, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 601182712, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2561.9636831630846, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5290697382, "stage_ordering_ns": 3015292118, "stage_eval_ns": 6869103076, "stage_threat_ns": 11723391338, "stage_proof_ns": 184626430, "tactical_annotations": 1717944, "root_tactical_annotations": 5022, "search_tactical_annotations": 1712922, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 537786, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3139893737, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1422850, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8040540289, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 174206, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5416240619, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 268883, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 397675585, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1254, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6444612, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 537766, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67632320, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 459943, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 413344962, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 750313, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2139506395, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 507688, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 71204795, "child_limit_applications": 86744, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 86744, "child_cap_hits": 86744, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 86744, "child_moves_before_total": 8288981, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8288981, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 933617, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 933617, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.55682237388177, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.76290002766762, "tt_hits": 47570, "tt_cutoffs": 6944, "beta_cutoffs": 69209, "depth_sum": 109, "avg_depth": 5.45, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 109, "avg_effective_depth": 5.45, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5046.55, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5446.55, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 494, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 56, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.9473684210526314, "search_nodes": 586, "safety_nodes": 1860, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2446, "avg_nodes": 128.73684210526315, "eval_calls": 567, "avg_eval_calls": 29.842105263157894, "line_shape_eval_calls": 567, "line_shape_eval_ns": 598274, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1055.1569664902997, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1678, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.3157894736842, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1678, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22136, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1165.0526315789473, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 39633979, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1790.4761022768341, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.42105263157894735, "renju_forbidden_ns": 88140, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11017.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 88140, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9590, "stage_ordering_ns": 1060, "stage_eval_ns": 598274, "stage_threat_ns": 36769663, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1153, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 35594917, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 53, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 332842, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17471, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 567, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 716414, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1134, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 125490, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6945.473684210527, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7366.526315789473, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 433, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10249, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 67, 52, 81, 129, 126, 99, 96, 130, 131, 141, 111, 66, 113, 114, 65, 49, 144, 69, 80, 84 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 38, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.4545454545454546, "search_nodes": 325, "safety_nodes": 768, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1093, "avg_nodes": 99.36363636363636, "eval_calls": 314, "avg_eval_calls": 28.545454545454547, "line_shape_eval_calls": 314, "line_shape_eval_ns": 232570, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 740.6687898089172, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 737, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.0, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 737, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 737, "avg_legality_checks": 67.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 737, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13728, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1248.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25968846, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1891.6700174825176, "renju_forbidden_checks": 86, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7.818181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 764031, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8884.081395348838, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 147160, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 616871, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 683882, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10521.261538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.636363636363637, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 383330, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4035.0526315789475, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1826276, "stage_ordering_ns": 600, "stage_eval_ns": 232570, "stage_threat_ns": 22913758, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 639, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 21579433, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 844174, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 314, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 415341, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 628, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74810, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10200, "avg_search_time_ms": 927.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 69276, "safety_nodes": 650, "corridor_nodes": 245, "corridor_branch_probes": 278, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 95, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 241, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 241, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 11, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 95, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 11, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 9, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 21, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 55600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 70171, "avg_nodes": 6379.181818181818, "eval_calls": 41482, "avg_eval_calls": 3771.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41482, "pattern_eval_ns": 951852, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.946145316040692, "pattern_frame_queries": 41482, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 951852, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.946145316040692, "pattern_frame_updates": 138440, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1856693461, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13411.539013290956, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24362, "avg_candidate_generations": 2214.7272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 1906555, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.25937936130039, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 750, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 24351, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1905805, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1112455, "avg_legality_checks": 101132.27272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 18542, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1112455, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 18542, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3034800, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 275890.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6356814659, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2094.640391129564, "renju_forbidden_checks": 57611, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5237.363636363636, "renju_forbidden_ns": 486383404, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8442.544028050199, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 18730, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 195102292, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19291, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 194432499, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19466, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 95557116, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 124, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1291497, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 127430, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11584.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1408891016, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11056.195683904889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 188502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17136.545454545456, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 733143505, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3889.3141982578436, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2865744882, "stage_ordering_ns": 779547914, "stage_eval_ns": 1857645313, "stage_threat_ns": 4630924227, "stage_proof_ns": 17397346, "tactical_annotations": 465942, "root_tactical_annotations": 1513, "search_tactical_annotations": 464429, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 138955, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 858636923, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 400445, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3627642572, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48942, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1826969434, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 69472, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108225248, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 504, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3061920, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 138944, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17880626, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 93221, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 500895307, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 243060, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1287024265, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 129661, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15476938, "child_limit_applications": 24351, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24351, "child_cap_hits": 24351, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24351, "child_moves_before_total": 1887263, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1887263, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 299849, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 299849, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.50248449755657, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.313621617182045, "tt_hits": 12720, "tt_cutoffs": 3388, "beta_cutoffs": 19845, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4419.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5146.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1533, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 434, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10645, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 127, 142, 126, 114, 156, 100, 86, 82, 98, 84, 141, 111, 155, 113, 154, 140, 153, 157, 152 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10604, "avg_search_time_ms": 1060.4, "search_nodes": 100658, "safety_nodes": 251, "corridor_nodes": 60, "corridor_branch_probes": 70, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 58, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 58, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 21, "corridor_proof_active": 2, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 21, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 21, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 147, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4059520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2025680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 100969, "avg_nodes": 10096.9, "eval_calls": 70415, "avg_eval_calls": 7041.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70415, "pattern_eval_ns": 1531405, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.748278065753034, "pattern_frame_queries": 70415, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1531405, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.748278065753034, "pattern_frame_updates": 201220, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2771887130, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13775.405675380181, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28547, "avg_candidate_generations": 2854.7, "candidate_moves_total": 2246026, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.67817984376642, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 664, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 28537, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2245362, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 880373, "avg_legality_checks": 88037.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 987, "root_legality_checks": 664, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 879709, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 987, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2954517, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 295451.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6500904055, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2200.327178689444, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27097, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2709.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 133667636, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4932.931173192605, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1180, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10367703, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13995, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 94566610, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11922, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28733323, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81622, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8162.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 781588136, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9575.704295410551, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 115025, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11502.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 356811270, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3102.0323407954793, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2175853342, "stage_ordering_ns": 962631251, "stage_eval_ns": 2773418535, "stage_threat_ns": 4602904037, "stage_proof_ns": 48100133, "tactical_annotations": 374676, "root_tactical_annotations": 2155, "search_tactical_annotations": 372521, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 201388, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1194935924, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 332120, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3218153057, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 57253, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2134010083, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 100689, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 149258090, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 158, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 757219, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 201378, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25719262, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 74737, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 136137079, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 195430, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 936645899, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 104509, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14080485, "child_limit_applications": 28537, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28537, "child_cap_hits": 28537, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28537, "child_moves_before_total": 2244375, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2244375, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 277827, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 277827, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.64789571433577, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.735676490170656, "tt_hits": 13735, "tt_cutoffs": 1658, "beta_cutoffs": 20787, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 4.8, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 4.8, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3094.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3894.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 571, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 29, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.2222222222222223, "search_nodes": 201, "safety_nodes": 683, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 192, "avg_eval_calls": 21.333333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 192, "line_shape_eval_ns": 146760, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 764.375, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 605, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_max": 80, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 605, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10548, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1172.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21283104, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2017.7383390216155, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3790, "stage_ordering_ns": 520, "stage_eval_ns": 146760, "stage_threat_ns": 18665088, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 393, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 18149347, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 182200, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 192, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 282590, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50951, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 435, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18785, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 114, 115, 127, 142, 94, 96, 68, 124, 138, 122, 128, 125, 123, 95, 80, 141, 79, 140, 155, 143, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 35, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.9166666666666665, "search_nodes": 345, "safety_nodes": 740, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1085, "avg_nodes": 90.41666666666667, "eval_calls": 333, "avg_eval_calls": 27.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 333, "line_shape_eval_ns": 248431, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 746.039039039039, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 857, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.41666666666667, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 857, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 857, "avg_legality_checks": 71.41666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 857, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14982, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1248.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24639910, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1644.6342277399547, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5833333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29860, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4265.714285714285, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5960, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 23900, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.3333333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 264161, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9434.32142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.4166666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 144240, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3518.048780487805, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1668229, "stage_ordering_ns": 530, "stage_eval_ns": 248431, "stage_threat_ns": 21256289, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 678, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 20391285, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 367071, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9930, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 333, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 423483, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 666, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74450, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 12, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 12, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 18739, "avg_search_time_ms": 1561.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 154971, "safety_nodes": 226, "corridor_nodes": 359, "corridor_branch_probes": 435, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 130, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 353, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 353, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 45, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 130, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 412, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 295880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 20200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 155556, "avg_nodes": 12963.0, "eval_calls": 95378, "avg_eval_calls": 7948.166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 95378, "pattern_eval_ns": 1880216, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.713309148860326, "pattern_frame_queries": 95378, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1880216, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.713309148860326, "pattern_frame_updates": 309810, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2677692463, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8643.014954326845, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 55459, "avg_candidate_generations": 4621.583333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4957217, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.38525757766999, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 883, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 55447, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4956334, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 3493325, "avg_legality_checks": 291110.4166666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1844, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3493325, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1844, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7751388, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 645949.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12441774949, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1605.1028472578073, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56328, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4694.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 82348711, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1461.9498473228234, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2237, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16109676, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4169, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20913314, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 49848, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44854620, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 471101, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 291146, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 24262.166666666668, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2381146689, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8178.531351967741, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 425069, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35422.416666666664, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1197422931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2817.008370405746, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6510553354, "stage_ordering_ns": 1574138925, "stage_eval_ns": 2679572679, "stage_threat_ns": 7796227710, "stage_proof_ns": 49200420, "tactical_annotations": 1109996, "root_tactical_annotations": 3992, "search_tactical_annotations": 1106004, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 310630, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1481979709, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 905796, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6046488057, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 111345, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2972434154, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 155309, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 190973237, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 808, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3105408, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 310618, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31820394, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 201530, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 704828383, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 570167, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2359260781, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 338299, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 41860905, "child_limit_applications": 55447, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 55447, "child_cap_hits": 55447, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 55447, "child_moves_before_total": 4954490, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4954490, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 601492, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 601492, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.35542049164067, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.848053095749094, "tt_hits": 26637, "tt_cutoffs": 4082, "beta_cutoffs": 44111, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2303.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2747.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 81, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 436, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 70011, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 115, 80, 64, 128, 144, 142, 100, 143, 158, 130, 98, 129, 127, 97, 81, 161, 145, 146, 131, 162, 178, 156, 170, 117, 99, 83, 101, 102, 147, 163, 160, 87, 132, 116, 164, 88, 74, 72, 57, 56, 40, 86, 85, 70, 71, 43, 118, 42, 84, 58, 28, 52, 54, 66, 69, 39, 53, 37, 68, 26, 38, 108, 94, 140, 23, 8, 124, 109, 125, 123, 89, 138, 93, 107, 110, 139, 78, 62, 155, 137, 136, 151, 165, 95 ], "move_count": 91, "black_stats": { "move_count": 46, "search_move_count": 44, "total_time_ms": 69845, "avg_search_time_ms": 1587.3863636363637, "search_nodes": 802048, "safety_nodes": 1198, "corridor_nodes": 1610, "corridor_branch_probes": 1838, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 491, "corridor_neutral_exits": 77, "corridor_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_plies_followed": 1586, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1586, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 17, "corridor_proof_completed": 17, "corridor_proof_checks": 140, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 116, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 78, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 491, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 140, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 138, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1104, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 91441920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4000000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 804856, "avg_nodes": 18292.18181818182, "eval_calls": 510678, "avg_eval_calls": 11606.318181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 510678, "pattern_eval_ns": 10465657, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.493651576923227, "pattern_frame_queries": 510678, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 10465657, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.493651576923227, "pattern_frame_updates": 1603592, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 15910933923, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9922.05868013809, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 272000, "avg_candidate_generations": 6181.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 26735970, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.29400735294118, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 44, "root_candidate_moves_total": 4020, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 271956, "search_candidate_moves_total": 26731950, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 7531293, "avg_legality_checks": 171165.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5860, "root_legality_checks": 4020, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 7527273, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5856, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21127429, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 480168.8409090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 39291594499, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1859.7432985811952, "renju_forbidden_checks": 264567, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6012.886363636364, "renju_forbidden_ns": 682172194, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2578.447780713392, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 20345, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 61390659, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 106022, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 379818508, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 137219, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 239358008, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 981, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1605019, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 429873, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9769.84090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3063142031, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7125.6906830622065, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 580459, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13192.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1279095490, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2203.593173678072, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15246169107, "stage_ordering_ns": 8381181432, "stage_eval_ns": 15921399580, "stage_threat_ns": 29590109162, "stage_proof_ns": 327646221, "tactical_annotations": 6820405, "root_tactical_annotations": 16786, "search_tactical_annotations": 6803619, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1607088, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 7900142669, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 5857276, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 20144859127, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 545741, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13195073313, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 803522, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1111617929, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3452, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 29600115, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1607044, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 182007023, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 2413923, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 945084998, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 2811080, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 5839423497, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1595402, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 221882299, "child_limit_applications": 271956, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 271956, "child_cap_hits": 271956, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 271956, "child_moves_before_total": 26726094, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 26726094, "child_moves_before_max": 135, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 135, "child_moves_after_total": 2392383, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 2392383, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 98.27359572872082, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.796948771124741, "tt_hits": 136545, "tt_cutoffs": 19171, "beta_cutoffs": 208688, "depth_sum": 242, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 242, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 10, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.22727272727272727, "pooled_budget_moves": 44, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 10, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.22727272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3858.1363636363635, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4039.9545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 45, "search_move_count": 43, "total_time_ms": 119, "avg_search_time_ms": 2.7674418604651163, "search_nodes": 1025, "safety_nodes": 5228, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 6253, "avg_nodes": 145.41860465116278, "eval_calls": 982, "avg_eval_calls": 22.837209302325583, "line_shape_eval_calls": 982, "line_shape_eval_ns": 2642159, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 2690.589613034623, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3953, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.93023255813954, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 43, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3953, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 45182, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1050.7441860465117, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 80643694, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1784.8633083971492, "renju_forbidden_checks": 86, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 119420, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1388.6046511627908, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 86, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 119420, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 26110, "stage_ordering_ns": 2400, "stage_eval_ns": 2642159, "stage_threat_ns": 75121097, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 2007, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 72550049, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 120, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1072504, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 86, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 44311, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 982, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1283524, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1964, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 215020, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 43 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 43, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7534.209302325581, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7720.2558139534885, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 437, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6932, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 109, 108, 95, 83, 128, 81, 94, 82, 84, 80, 96, 79 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.857142857142857, "search_nodes": 290, "safety_nodes": 243, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 533, "avg_nodes": 76.14285714285714, "eval_calls": 283, "avg_eval_calls": 40.42857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 283, "line_shape_eval_ns": 206262, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 728.8409893992933, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 408, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.285714285714285, "candidate_moves_max": 67, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 408, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 408, "avg_legality_checks": 58.285714285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 408, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1222.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17519363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2046.6545560747663, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 298491, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10660.392857142857, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52710, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 245781, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 314061, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11631.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.714285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 178950, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4473.75, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1091412, "stage_ordering_ns": 410, "stage_eval_ns": 206262, "stage_threat_ns": 16471558, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 573, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 15573986, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 429411, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7130, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 397151, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 566, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 71010, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 7, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 7, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5137.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6280.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 6898, "avg_search_time_ms": 985.4285714285714, "search_nodes": 50727, "safety_nodes": 215, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 3, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 3, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 3, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 50942, "avg_nodes": 7277.428571428572, "eval_calls": 33357, "avg_eval_calls": 4765.285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33357, "pattern_eval_ns": 694612, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.82357526156429, "pattern_frame_queries": 33357, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 694612, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.82357526156429, "pattern_frame_updates": 101386, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1308688217, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12907.977600457656, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16072, "avg_candidate_generations": 2296.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1240778, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.20121951219512, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 421, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 16065, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1240357, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 726195, "avg_legality_checks": 103742.14285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9139, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 726195, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9139, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2169636, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 309948.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4323889967, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1992.910316292687, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37923, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5417.571428571428, "renju_forbidden_ns": 304677901, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8034.119162513514, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9260, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 97421852, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14568, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 149627204, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14055, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 57191742, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 437103, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 108233, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15461.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1122472905, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10370.893396653517, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 160016, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22859.428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 578213153, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3613.470859164084, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1821971751, "stage_ordering_ns": 502005143, "stage_eval_ns": 1309382829, "stage_threat_ns": 3228457833, "stage_proof_ns": 5225360, "tactical_annotations": 279221, "root_tactical_annotations": 1216, "search_tactical_annotations": 278005, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 101399, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 600771539, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 255856, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2533889283, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32189, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1155697094, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50696, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74984219, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26961, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 101392, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12581272, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52458, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 359648606, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171198, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1018490512, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 55565, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6204559, "child_limit_applications": 16065, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16065, "child_cap_hits": 16065, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16065, "child_moves_before_total": 1231218, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1231218, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 202184, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 202184, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.63977591036415, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.585371926548397, "tt_hits": 6048, "tt_cutoffs": 1272, "beta_cutoffs": 12353, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2922.714285714286, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3941.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1639, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 438, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29162, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 113, 114, 128, 82, 66, 130, 146, 110, 158, 96, 68, 124, 138, 97, 143, 173, 95, 99, 100, 159, 127, 79, 84, 144, 129, 116, 67, 102, 88, 65, 115, 101, 94, 157, 52, 36, 80, 108, 38 ], "move_count": 43, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 29077, "avg_search_time_ms": 1453.85, "search_nodes": 271505, "safety_nodes": 1193, "corridor_nodes": 940, "corridor_branch_probes": 1102, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 348, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 919, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 919, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 80, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 59, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 348, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 80, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 80, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 579, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 59830400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2033680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 273638, "avg_nodes": 13681.9, "eval_calls": 175472, "avg_eval_calls": 8773.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 175472, "pattern_eval_ns": 3762800, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.443877085802864, "pattern_frame_queries": 175472, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3762800, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.443877085802864, "pattern_frame_updates": 542788, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7084679422, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13052.387713066611, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 89203, "avg_candidate_generations": 4460.15, "candidate_moves_total": 8621040, "avg_candidate_moves": 96.64518009483986, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1761, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 89183, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8619279, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 2475386, "avg_legality_checks": 123769.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2046, "root_legality_checks": 1761, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 2473625, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2044, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8021294, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 401064.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17254207086, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2151.0503275406686, "renju_forbidden_checks": 59504, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2975.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 205333518, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3450.751512503361, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2406, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19621596, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24858, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 123468346, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32038, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 61401712, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 202, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 841864, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 189577, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9478.85, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1564931645, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8254.860267859498, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 242247, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12112.35, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 633312377, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2614.324953456596, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5866882675, "stage_ordering_ns": 3283151469, "stage_eval_ns": 7088442222, "stage_threat_ns": 12461876177, "stage_proof_ns": 249306198, "tactical_annotations": 1730106, "root_tactical_annotations": 5022, "search_tactical_annotations": 1725084, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 544806, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3233299902, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1463377, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8667160804, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 179255, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5880859212, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 272393, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 406967899, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1998, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12941494, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 544786, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69256680, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 456954, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 373858597, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 768559, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2278124043, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 504593, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 72249398, "child_limit_applications": 89183, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 89183, "child_cap_hits": 89183, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 89183, "child_moves_before_total": 8617235, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8617235, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 937242, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 937242, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 96.62418846641177, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.509200183891549, "tt_hits": 47617, "tt_cutoffs": 6739, "beta_cutoffs": 71356, "depth_sum": 109, "avg_depth": 5.45, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 109, "avg_effective_depth": 5.45, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4650.05, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5050.05, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 254, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 64, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.3684210526315788, "search_nodes": 585, "safety_nodes": 1860, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 2445, "avg_nodes": 128.68421052631578, "eval_calls": 566, "avg_eval_calls": 29.789473684210527, "line_shape_eval_calls": 566, "line_shape_eval_ns": 681215, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1203.560070671378, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1677, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.26315789473684, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1677, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22150, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1165.7894736842106, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 44488524, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2008.5112415349888, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.631578947368421, "renju_forbidden_ns": 143311, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11942.583333333334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 143311, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9370, "stage_ordering_ns": 1120, "stage_eval_ns": 681215, "stage_threat_ns": 41010698, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1151, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 39743241, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 53, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 342912, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 566, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 786124, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1132, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 138421, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6945.473684210527, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7366.526315789473, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 439, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10015, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 82, 142, 157, 111, 143, 98, 129, 115, 158, 173, 159, 156, 144, 114, 130, 172, 145, 131, 161, 177, 160 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 41, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.727272727272727, "search_nodes": 208, "safety_nodes": 729, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 937, "avg_nodes": 85.18181818181819, "eval_calls": 197, "avg_eval_calls": 17.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 197, "line_shape_eval_ns": 187691, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 952.746192893401, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 626, "avg_candidate_moves": 56.90909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 72, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 626, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 626, "avg_legality_checks": 56.90909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 626, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13320, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1210.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28828228, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2164.2813813813814, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.6363636363636362, "renju_forbidden_ns": 470575, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11764.375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 90721, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 379854, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 651212, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12523.307692307691, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 359031, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4724.0921052631575, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1774517, "stage_ordering_ns": 610, "stage_eval_ns": 187691, "stage_threat_ns": 23772597, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 405, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22578484, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 848932, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 290551, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 54630, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9963, "avg_search_time_ms": 905.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 76082, "safety_nodes": 193, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 3, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 3, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 3, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76275, "avg_nodes": 6934.090909090909, "eval_calls": 51863, "avg_eval_calls": 4714.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51863, "pattern_eval_ns": 1146116, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.098914447679462, "pattern_frame_queries": 51863, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1146116, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.098914447679462, "pattern_frame_updates": 152062, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1973185456, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12976.190343412556, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22733, "avg_candidate_generations": 2066.6363636363635, "candidate_moves_total": 1675523, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.70443848150266, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 659, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 22722, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1674864, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 1053914, "avg_legality_checks": 95810.36363636363, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13475, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1053914, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13475, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2855482, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 259589.27272727274, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6245688082, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2187.262284265844, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42658, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3878.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 403078277, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9449.066458811945, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 13581, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 145979148, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18166, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 192194521, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10851, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 64202226, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 702382, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 117879, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10716.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1273853012, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10806.445694313661, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 163291, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14844.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 624336163, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3823.457281785279, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2810448866, "stage_ordering_ns": 713638576, "stage_eval_ns": 1974331572, "stage_threat_ns": 4411733411, "stage_proof_ns": 5430423, "tactical_annotations": 463049, "root_tactical_annotations": 2244, "search_tactical_annotations": 460805, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152079, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 927701696, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 397635, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3329801331, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45528, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1692002904, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76034, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 119555453, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25930, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152068, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19635063, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 120307, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 564172403, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 231785, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1073563574, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110957, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15013938, "child_limit_applications": 22722, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22722, "child_cap_hits": 22722, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22722, "child_moves_before_total": 1661389, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1661389, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 259643, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 259643, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.11807939441951, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.426943050787782, "tt_hits": 9622, "tt_cutoffs": 1446, "beta_cutoffs": 16608, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5099.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5826.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1569, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 440, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9573, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 98, 114, 100, 156, 170, 99, 84, 126, 68, 52, 67, 82, 70, 56, 69, 66, 71 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9534, "avg_search_time_ms": 953.4, "search_nodes": 89964, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 256, "corridor_branch_probes": 308, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 92, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 253, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 253, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 20, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 17, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 92, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 20, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 20, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 146, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4066560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1973760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 90451, "avg_nodes": 9045.1, "eval_calls": 58401, "avg_eval_calls": 5840.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 58401, "pattern_eval_ns": 1278033, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.883751990548106, "pattern_frame_queries": 58401, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1278033, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.883751990548106, "pattern_frame_updates": 179848, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2395049261, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13317.074757573062, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29495, "avg_candidate_generations": 2949.5, "candidate_moves_total": 2326830, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.88896423122563, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 29485, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2326190, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 673190, "avg_legality_checks": 67319.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 419, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 672550, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 418, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2436067, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 243606.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5632511557, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2312.1332693230524, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23822, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2382.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 116799876, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4903.025606582151, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 921, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4527859, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13261, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 84562666, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9632, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27614181, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 95170, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45495, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4549.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 400787133, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8809.476491922189, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 59048, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5904.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 158302915, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2680.9191674569843, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1725027284, "stage_ordering_ns": 979301072, "stage_eval_ns": 2396327294, "stage_threat_ns": 4327231701, "stage_proof_ns": 71041186, "tactical_annotations": 448203, "root_tactical_annotations": 1860, "search_tactical_annotations": 446343, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 180404, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1116130664, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 398329, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3025721601, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59214, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2257822099, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 90197, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 141311175, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 546, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2783873, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 180394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23615024, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96662, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 60145022, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 225123, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 661593909, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 126418, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17669364, "child_limit_applications": 29485, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29485, "child_cap_hits": 29485, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29485, "child_moves_before_total": 2325772, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2325772, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 262058, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 262058, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.87983720535865, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.887841275224691, "tt_hits": 14214, "tt_cutoffs": 2038, "beta_cutoffs": 22434, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 3.9, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 3.9, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4017.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4817.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 766, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 48060, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 828.6206896551724, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1157.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22364763, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2147.5670251584406, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51460, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12865.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 51460, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3930, "stage_ordering_ns": 480, "stage_eval_ns": 48060, "stage_threat_ns": 17769304, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17457053, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 204791, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91750, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15710, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 441, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25058, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 109, 108, 125, 128, 124, 143, 98, 141, 99, 140, 142, 129, 130, 97, 145, 115, 157, 101, 87, 188, 158, 156, 171, 155, 169, 204, 146, 172 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 48, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.2, "search_nodes": 475, "safety_nodes": 802, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1277, "avg_nodes": 85.13333333333334, "eval_calls": 460, "avg_eval_calls": 30.666666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 460, "line_shape_eval_ns": 503170, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1093.8478260869565, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 981, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.4, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 981, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 981, "avg_legality_checks": 65.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 981, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1201.7333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31452995, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1744.868245867081, "renju_forbidden_checks": 81, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 763873, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9430.530864197532, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 155650, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 65, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 608223, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.933333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 629042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10661.728813559323, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.733333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 355441, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4133.03488372093, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2142029, "stage_ordering_ns": 780, "stage_eval_ns": 503170, "stage_threat_ns": 28363779, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 935, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 26891144, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 799683, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 571172, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 920, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 101780, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 15, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 15, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6664.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7197.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 24996, "avg_search_time_ms": 1666.4, "search_nodes": 196886, "safety_nodes": 214, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 3, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 3, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 3, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 11040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 197100, "avg_nodes": 13140.0, "eval_calls": 128443, "avg_eval_calls": 8562.866666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 128443, "pattern_eval_ns": 2696669, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.995063958331713, "pattern_frame_queries": 128443, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2696669, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.995063958331713, "pattern_frame_updates": 393614, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4703897412, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11950.533802151347, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 63114, "avg_candidate_generations": 4207.6, "candidate_moves_total": 5093010, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.6954083087746, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1018, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 63099, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5091992, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 3475698, "avg_legality_checks": 231713.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 28808, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3475698, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 28808, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9088074, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 605871.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15956809913, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1755.7966531742588, "renju_forbidden_checks": 121017, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8067.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 692904605, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5725.679904476231, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 31286, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 268865253, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 38592, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 290667391, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 51039, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 132382347, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 100, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 989614, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 393140, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 26209.333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3611464972, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9186.205860507707, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 589384, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 39292.26666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1854577198, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3146.6364848723415, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7380544429, "stage_ordering_ns": 1765955643, "stage_eval_ns": 4706594081, "stage_threat_ns": 11006010056, "stage_proof_ns": 5401002, "tactical_annotations": 1626034, "root_tactical_annotations": 4355, "search_tactical_annotations": 1621679, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 393635, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2032385822, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1426347, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8615285893, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 126318, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3835737811, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 196810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 271690211, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25000, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 393620, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44431239, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 426285, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1195155732, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 873725, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3584327640, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 326024, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 42191891, "child_limit_applications": 63099, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 63099, "child_cap_hits": 63099, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 63099, "child_moves_before_total": 5063184, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5063184, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 729372, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 729372, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.2419055769505, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.559168925022584, "tt_hits": 26607, "tt_cutoffs": 5271, "beta_cutoffs": 48441, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1129.7333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1467.9333333333334, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 442, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8703, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 141, 155, 99, 85, 140, 139, 97, 123, 107, 108, 109, 153, 167, 138, 93, 168 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8666, "avg_search_time_ms": 866.6, "search_nodes": 89245, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 271, "corridor_branch_probes": 322, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 101, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 266, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 266, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 20, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 15, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 20, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 20, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 146, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6086400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1982080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 89747, "avg_nodes": 8974.7, "eval_calls": 58274, "avg_eval_calls": 5827.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 58274, "pattern_eval_ns": 1270145, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.796084016885747, "pattern_frame_queries": 58274, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1270145, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.796084016885747, "pattern_frame_updates": 178402, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2208052053, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12376.834637504064, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28972, "avg_candidate_generations": 2897.2, "candidate_moves_total": 2342863, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.86645726908739, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 28962, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2342223, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 655920, "avg_legality_checks": 65592.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 395, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 655280, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 394, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2392505, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 239250.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5091763469, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2128.214348141383, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20425, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2042.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 95743620, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4687.570134638923, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 733, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3584239, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11506, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 69638817, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8176, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22414133, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 106431, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46348, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4634.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 366028503, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7897.395853111246, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 59664, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5966.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 144581267, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2423.258028291767, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1567963985, "stage_ordering_ns": 918213964, "stage_eval_ns": 2209322198, "stage_threat_ns": 3858918932, "stage_proof_ns": 71489371, "tactical_annotations": 445648, "root_tactical_annotations": 1864, "search_tactical_annotations": 443784, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 178984, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1009755754, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 393215, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2678056588, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58173, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1968795668, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89487, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 129130204, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 572, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2844992, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 178974, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21949976, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96371, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 60887781, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 220703, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 604248690, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 128574, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17181418, "child_limit_applications": 28962, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28962, "child_cap_hits": 28962, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28962, "child_moves_before_total": 2341829, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2341829, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 256677, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 256677, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.85867688695532, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.862544023202817, "tt_hits": 14275, "tt_cutoffs": 1966, "beta_cutoffs": 22007, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4618.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5418.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1573, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 27, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.0, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 47330, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 816.0344827586207, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21151439, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2026.7764469145266, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46090, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11522.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 46090, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3640, "stage_ordering_ns": 560, "stage_eval_ns": 47330, "stage_threat_ns": 16827871, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16546180, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 179320, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9470, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 86791, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15580, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 443, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9831, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 67, 127, 142, 98, 126, 81, 110, 94, 141, 156, 140, 143, 125, 95, 109, 157, 124, 108, 138, 152, 139 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 41, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.727272727272727, "search_nodes": 208, "safety_nodes": 729, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 937, "avg_nodes": 85.18181818181819, "eval_calls": 197, "avg_eval_calls": 17.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 197, "line_shape_eval_ns": 184992, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 939.0456852791879, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 626, "avg_candidate_moves": 56.90909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 72, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 626, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 626, "avg_legality_checks": 56.90909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 626, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1219.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28590954, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2131.426420158044, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.6363636363636362, "renju_forbidden_ns": 460492, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11512.3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 95801, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 364691, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 632623, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12165.826923076924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 352332, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4635.9473684210525, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1735959, "stage_ordering_ns": 610, "stage_eval_ns": 184992, "stage_threat_ns": 23633263, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 405, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22466179, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 829453, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 284661, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52970, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9780, "avg_search_time_ms": 889.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 93230, "safety_nodes": 193, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 3, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 3, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 3, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 3520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 3520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 93423, "avg_nodes": 8493.0, "eval_calls": 63654, "avg_eval_calls": 5786.727272727273, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 63654, "pattern_eval_ns": 1355006, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.287051874194866, "pattern_frame_queries": 63654, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1355006, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.287051874194866, "pattern_frame_updates": 186358, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1834887135, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9846.033628821944, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27630, "avg_candidate_generations": 2511.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2066796, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.80260586319218, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 659, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 27619, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2066137, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 1308092, "avg_legality_checks": 118917.45454545454, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6109, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1308092, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6109, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3362705, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 305700.45454545453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6153718612, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1829.9906212409355, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30573, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2779.3636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 189705262, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6204.993360154384, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6213, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 54076274, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11198, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 93718999, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13102, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41215118, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 694871, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 122831, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11166.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1165075561, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9485.191531453786, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 180776, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16434.18181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 588431456, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3255.0308448024075, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2770003353, "stage_ordering_ns": 723128544, "stage_eval_ns": 1836242141, "stage_threat_ns": 4380892967, "stage_proof_ns": 5384231, "tactical_annotations": 525972, "root_tactical_annotations": 2244, "search_tactical_annotations": 523728, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 186375, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1000526740, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 428802, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3214626461, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 55322, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1710990088, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 93182, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 126409991, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26440, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 186364, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21473472, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 126567, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 488968967, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 246898, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1014604915, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 152507, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17829863, "child_limit_applications": 27619, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27619, "child_cap_hits": 27619, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27619, "child_moves_before_total": 2060028, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2060028, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 305478, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 305478, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.58734928853326, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.060429414533473, "tt_hits": 13084, "tt_cutoffs": 1906, "beta_cutoffs": 20020, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5095.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5823.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1557, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 444, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9209, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 95, 79, 143, 159, 80, 65, 113, 51, 37, 52, 67, 49, 33, 50, 53, 48 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9172, "avg_search_time_ms": 917.2, "search_nodes": 91097, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 284, "corridor_branch_probes": 351, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 106, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 281, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 281, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 20, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 17, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 106, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 20, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 20, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 146, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4078080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1973760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91612, "avg_nodes": 9161.2, "eval_calls": 59289, "avg_eval_calls": 5928.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 59289, "pattern_eval_ns": 1299862, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.924168058155814, "pattern_frame_queries": 59289, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1299862, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.924168058155814, "pattern_frame_updates": 182114, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2276715161, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12501.593293211945, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29772, "avg_candidate_generations": 2977.2, "candidate_moves_total": 2329043, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.22930941824534, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 29762, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2328403, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 660886, "avg_legality_checks": 66088.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 456, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 660246, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 455, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2384772, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 238477.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5379852990, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2255.9192199505865, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21973, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2197.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 108033430, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4916.644518272426, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 847, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4183326, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12520, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 78284104, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8589, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25384199, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 181801, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44863, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4486.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 372505446, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8303.177362191562, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 58296, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5829.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 146320419, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2509.9564121037465, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1668523082, "stage_ordering_ns": 958478169, "stage_eval_ns": 2278015023, "stage_threat_ns": 4154387363, "stage_proof_ns": 72925105, "tactical_annotations": 452467, "root_tactical_annotations": 1860, "search_tactical_annotations": 450607, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 182726, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1104447602, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 401510, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2865540978, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59775, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2130200189, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91358, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 140239709, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 602, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3041560, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 182716, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23365117, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 99034, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 58896350, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 223910, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 628508703, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 129523, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17752397, "child_limit_applications": 29762, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29762, "child_cap_hits": 29762, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29762, "child_moves_before_total": 2327948, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2327948, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 263589, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 263589, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.218802499832, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.856562059001412, "tt_hits": 14446, "tt_cutoffs": 2007, "beta_cutoffs": 22600, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 3.9, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 3.9, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4240.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5040.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1022, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 47960, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 826.8965517241379, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22279688, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2134.887696435416, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 47590, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11897.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 47590, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3760, "stage_ordering_ns": 440, "stage_eval_ns": 47960, "stage_threat_ns": 17606651, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17305471, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 196740, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9900, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88730, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15710, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 445, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9846, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 110, 114, 115, 127, 99, 96, 83, 67, 100, 101, 85, 130, 84, 82, 68, 116, 69, 53, 55, 41, 70 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 41, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.727272727272727, "search_nodes": 208, "safety_nodes": 729, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 937, "avg_nodes": 85.18181818181819, "eval_calls": 197, "avg_eval_calls": 17.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 197, "line_shape_eval_ns": 186510, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 946.751269035533, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 626, "avg_candidate_moves": 56.90909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 72, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 626, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 626, "avg_legality_checks": 56.90909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 626, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13320, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1210.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28506006, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2140.0905405405406, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.6363636363636362, "renju_forbidden_ns": 453622, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11340.55, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 94190, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 359432, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 643342, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12371.961538461539, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 355502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4677.6578947368425, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1763457, "stage_ordering_ns": 610, "stage_eval_ns": 186510, "stage_threat_ns": 23623451, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 405, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22434645, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 844033, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 291922, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52851, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9795, "avg_search_time_ms": 890.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 79145, "safety_nodes": 193, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 3, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 3, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 3, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 79338, "avg_nodes": 7212.545454545455, "eval_calls": 53768, "avg_eval_calls": 4888.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53768, "pattern_eval_ns": 1194924, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.22370183008481, "pattern_frame_queries": 53768, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1194924, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.22370183008481, "pattern_frame_updates": 158188, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1758340697, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11115.512535716995, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23807, "avg_candidate_generations": 2164.2727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 1772473, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.45175788633595, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 659, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 23796, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1771814, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1106653, "avg_legality_checks": 100604.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4973, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1106653, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4973, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2926786, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 266071.45454545453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6246736596, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2134.333222859478, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25829, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2348.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 183902813, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7120.0128924851915, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5055, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 55077684, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8775, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 88959256, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11939, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39196411, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 669462, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 117274, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10661.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1259165036, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10736.949673414398, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 173080, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15734.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 633941686, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3662.70907094985, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2808885175, "stage_ordering_ns": 737715864, "stage_eval_ns": 1759535621, "stage_threat_ns": 4427408431, "stage_proof_ns": 5407033, "tactical_annotations": 450190, "root_tactical_annotations": 2244, "search_tactical_annotations": 447946, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 158205, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 963654769, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 391362, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3310553741, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47676, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1701690378, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79097, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 120308076, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24710, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 158194, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20417797, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 117777, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 509891262, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 225894, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1098911230, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 106519, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12449338, "child_limit_applications": 23796, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23796, "child_cap_hits": 23796, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23796, "child_moves_before_total": 1766841, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1766841, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 264546, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 264546, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.24949571356531, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.117246596066567, "tt_hits": 10087, "tt_cutoffs": 1530, "beta_cutoffs": 17473, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5075.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5802.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1570, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 446, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7787, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 82, 66, 130, 146, 81, 80, 128, 94, 52, 109, 110, 64, 48, 79, 49, 124 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7750, "avg_search_time_ms": 775.0, "search_nodes": 74921, "safety_nodes": 228, "corridor_nodes": 307, "corridor_branch_probes": 379, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 110, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 303, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 303, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 21, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 17, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 110, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 21, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 20, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 147, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4130560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1973760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 75456, "avg_nodes": 7545.6, "eval_calls": 49619, "avg_eval_calls": 4961.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49619, "pattern_eval_ns": 1081874, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.803623611922852, "pattern_frame_queries": 49619, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1081874, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.803623611922852, "pattern_frame_updates": 149762, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1925122211, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12854.543949733577, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23711, "avg_candidate_generations": 2371.1, "candidate_moves_total": 1782656, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.1826578381342, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 638, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 23701, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1782018, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 558066, "avg_legality_checks": 55806.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 488, "root_legality_checks": 638, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 557428, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 487, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2014670, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 201467.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4633803517, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2300.031030888433, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25631, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2563.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 101601667, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3964.0149428426516, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1069, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5040272, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14852, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71521132, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9686, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24822671, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 217592, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 40561, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4056.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 352094948, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8680.6278937896, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 52868, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5286.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 137835695, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2607.1668116819246, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1424596599, "stage_ordering_ns": 732854992, "stage_eval_ns": 1926204085, "stage_threat_ns": 3552356628, "stage_proof_ns": 79076288, "tactical_annotations": 349158, "root_tactical_annotations": 1855, "search_tactical_annotations": 347303, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 150420, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 940183403, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 291155, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2455158590, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47669, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1836987868, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75205, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 115957299, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 648, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3356722, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 150410, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19713763, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 77295, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 61684193, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 145569, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 501055407, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 126294, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17986851, "child_limit_applications": 23701, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23701, "child_cap_hits": 23701, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23701, "child_moves_before_total": 1781531, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1781531, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 223459, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 223459, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.16691278848994, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.428251972490612, "tt_hits": 13297, "tt_cutoffs": 1561, "beta_cutoffs": 17777, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4446.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5246.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 946, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 820, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 887, "avg_nodes": 98.55555555555556, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 48120, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 829.6551724137931, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 580, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10420, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1157.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22264932, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2136.7497120921307, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.1111111111111112, "renju_forbidden_ns": 67971, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6797.1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 67971, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3980, "stage_ordering_ns": 320, "stage_eval_ns": 48120, "stage_threat_ns": 17676282, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17363570, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 208852, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88040, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15820, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 447, "black": "search-d1", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9868, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 82, 142, 157, 113, 141, 96, 125, 109, 156, 171, 155, 158, 140, 110, 124, 172, 139, 123, 153, 167, 154 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 41, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.727272727272727, "search_nodes": 208, "safety_nodes": 729, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 937, "avg_nodes": 85.18181818181819, "eval_calls": 197, "avg_eval_calls": 17.90909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 197, "line_shape_eval_ns": 187681, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 952.6954314720812, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 626, "avg_candidate_moves": 56.90909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 72, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 626, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 626, "avg_legality_checks": 56.90909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 626, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13320, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1210.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28360077, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2129.1349099099098, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.6363636363636362, "renju_forbidden_ns": 474466, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11861.65, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 96010, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 378456, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 647454, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12451.038461538461, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 362212, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4765.9473684210525, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1720946, "stage_ordering_ns": 500, "stage_eval_ns": 187681, "stage_threat_ns": 23472416, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 405, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 22293999, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 840865, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 285271, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52281, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 11, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 11, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6178.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9819, "avg_search_time_ms": 892.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 78747, "safety_nodes": 193, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 3, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 3, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 3, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 78940, "avg_nodes": 7176.363636363636, "eval_calls": 53419, "avg_eval_calls": 4856.272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53419, "pattern_eval_ns": 1162952, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.770381324996723, "pattern_frame_queries": 53419, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1162952, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.770381324996723, "pattern_frame_updates": 157392, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1783200967, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11329.679824895802, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23795, "avg_candidate_generations": 2163.181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 1763544, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.11405757512082, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 659, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 23784, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1762885, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 1102910, "avg_legality_checks": 100264.54545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5006, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1102910, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5006, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2943165, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 267560.45454545453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6268771091, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2129.942117074646, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26592, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2417.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 193270841, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7268.006956979542, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5110, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 56215003, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9241, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 94836778, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12181, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41524745, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 694315, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 119629, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10875.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1273951700, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10649.18790594254, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 176349, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16031.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 638389681, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3620.035730284833, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2807937351, "stage_ordering_ns": 732539048, "stage_eval_ns": 1784363919, "stage_threat_ns": 4432041651, "stage_proof_ns": 5333074, "tactical_annotations": 452864, "root_tactical_annotations": 2244, "search_tactical_annotations": 450620, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 157409, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 944708600, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 397193, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3335301089, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47652, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1698204951, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78699, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118968235, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24590, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 157398, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20058116, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116841, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 498042573, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 232685, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1138991665, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 103338, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12981021, "child_limit_applications": 23784, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23784, "child_cap_hits": 23784, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23784, "child_moves_before_total": 1757879, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1757879, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 264833, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 264833, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.91014968045745, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.134922637066936, "tt_hits": 9738, "tt_cutoffs": 1494, "beta_cutoffs": 17507, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5055.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5782.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1527, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 448, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d1", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9373, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 110, 94, 158, 174, 95, 80, 128, 66, 52, 67, 82, 64, 48, 65, 68, 63 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9334, "avg_search_time_ms": 933.4, "search_nodes": 89140, "safety_nodes": 231, "corridor_nodes": 284, "corridor_branch_probes": 351, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 106, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 281, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 281, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 20, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 17, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 106, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 20, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 20, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 146, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4081680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1973760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 89655, "avg_nodes": 8965.5, "eval_calls": 57968, "avg_eval_calls": 5796.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 57968, "pattern_eval_ns": 1246814, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.508659950317416, "pattern_frame_queries": 57968, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1246814, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.508659950317416, "pattern_frame_updates": 178200, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2330908031, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13080.291980920314, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29201, "avg_candidate_generations": 2920.1, "candidate_moves_total": 2302395, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.84644361494469, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 29191, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2301755, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 655304, "avg_legality_checks": 65530.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 437, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 654664, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 436, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2396322, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 239632.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5509219486, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2299.031384763817, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22634, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2263.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 111302420, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4917.487850136962, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 853, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4281324, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12784, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 80184903, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8980, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26647233, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 188960, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44135, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4413.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 378150458, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8568.040285487708, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 57185, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5718.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 147081566, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2572.0305324822943, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1662572063, "stage_ordering_ns": 972469503, "stage_eval_ns": 2332154845, "stage_threat_ns": 4257907027, "stage_proof_ns": 73866620, "tactical_annotations": 443811, "root_tactical_annotations": 1860, "search_tactical_annotations": 441951, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 178812, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1098762229, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 396235, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2977554498, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58633, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2231690517, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89401, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 138032969, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 602, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3044412, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 178802, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23323185, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96916, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 60249765, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 221895, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 635018645, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 125000, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17189734, "child_limit_applications": 29191, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29191, "child_cap_hits": 29191, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29191, "child_moves_before_total": 2301319, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2301319, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 258558, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 258558, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.83659347059024, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.857456065225584, "tt_hits": 14025, "tt_cutoffs": 1941, "beta_cutoffs": 22192, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 3.9, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 3.9, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4136.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4936.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 912, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 28, "avg_search_time_ms": 3.111111111111111, "search_nodes": 67, "safety_nodes": 817, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 884, "avg_nodes": 98.22222222222223, "eval_calls": 58, "avg_eval_calls": 6.444444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58, "line_shape_eval_ns": 47720, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 822.7586206896551, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9, "avg_candidate_generations": 1.0, "candidate_moves_total": 577, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 577, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 0, "search_candidate_moves_total": 0, "search_candidate_moves_max": 0, "legality_checks": 0, "avg_legality_checks": 0.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 0, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1157.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22265578, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2138.0428269637027, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 48030, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12007.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 48030, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3940, "stage_ordering_ns": 440, "stage_eval_ns": 47720, "stage_threat_ns": 17618173, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 17309212, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 201430, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10060, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91791, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15740, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 0, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 0, "depth_sum": 9, "avg_depth": 1.0, "max_depth": 1, "effective_depth_sum": 9, "avg_effective_depth": 1.0, "max_effective_depth": 1, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5774.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1997, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 449, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3958, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 96, 128, 83, 129, 67, 52, 126, 99, 141, 111, 68, 143, 158, 159, 95, 175 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 424, "avg_search_time_ms": 47.111111111111114, "search_nodes": 31280, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 31809, "avg_nodes": 3534.3333333333335, "eval_calls": 29927, "avg_eval_calls": 3325.222222222222, "line_shape_eval_calls": 29927, "line_shape_eval_ns": 25334783, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 846.5527115982223, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1336, "avg_candidate_generations": 148.44444444444446, "candidate_moves_total": 81698, "avg_candidate_moves": 61.15119760479042, "candidate_moves_max": 84, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 468, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 1327, "search_candidate_moves_total": 81230, "search_candidate_moves_max": 84, "legality_checks": 26513, "avg_legality_checks": 2945.8888888888887, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 468, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 26045, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 36820, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4091.1111111111113, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 69334480, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1883.0657251493753, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.888888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 403880, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11539.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 316340, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 87540, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 485272, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10783.822222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.222222222222222, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 262920, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4044.923076923077, "stage_move_gen_ns": 53529956, "stage_ordering_ns": 43080, "stage_eval_ns": 25334783, "stage_threat_ns": 333854052, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 62517, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 292224548, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 625933, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 31254, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 34657891, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 62508, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6345680, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 146, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1121, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5741.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6629.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1970, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 3526, "avg_search_time_ms": 391.77777777777777, "search_nodes": 98806, "safety_nodes": 564, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 99370, "avg_nodes": 11041.111111111111, "eval_calls": 96015, "avg_eval_calls": 10668.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 96015, "pattern_eval_ns": 1870593, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.482299640681145, "pattern_frame_queries": 96015, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1870593, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.482299640681145, "pattern_frame_updates": 197562, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2353934971, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11914.917701784756, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2775, "avg_candidate_generations": 308.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 176967, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.77189189189189, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 493, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 2766, "search_candidate_moves_total": 176474, "search_candidate_moves_max": 86, "legality_checks": 4542, "avg_legality_checks": 504.6666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4542, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 752056, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 83561.77777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1593778381, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2119.2283300711647, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15645, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1738.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 140187497, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8960.530329178651, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 213192, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15609, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 139810424, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 163881, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11006636, "stage_ordering_ns": 91710, "stage_eval_ns": 2355805564, "stage_threat_ns": 1145493347, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 197571, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1002297500, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 151381, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 98781, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121150838, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 197562, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21893628, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 175, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2447, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5457.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6345.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1990, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 450, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2408, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 80, 128, 83, 143, 158, 84, 111, 125, 126, 99, 81, 79, 96, 141, 66 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1745, "avg_search_time_ms": 193.88888888888889, "search_nodes": 45594, "safety_nodes": 600, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 46194, "avg_nodes": 5132.666666666667, "eval_calls": 43344, "avg_eval_calls": 4816.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 43344, "pattern_eval_ns": 855522, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.73795681063123, "pattern_frame_queries": 43344, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 855522, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.73795681063123, "pattern_frame_updates": 91138, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1080373340, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11854.257719063398, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2234, "avg_candidate_generations": 248.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 150371, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.31020590868397, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 498, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 2225, "search_candidate_moves_total": 149873, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 40805, "avg_legality_checks": 4533.888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 28, "root_legality_checks": 498, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 40307, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 374197, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 41577.444444444445, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 816983926, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2183.2989735353303, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5789, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 643.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 24245441, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4188.191570219382, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 72150, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5753, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24115401, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57890, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 31, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.4444444444444446, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 236731, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7636.4838709677415, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 37, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.111111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 79171, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2139.7567567567567, "stage_move_gen_ns": 92683520, "stage_ordering_ns": 78050, "stage_eval_ns": 1081228862, "stage_threat_ns": 554635735, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 91147, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 485936449, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 369453, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8310, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 45569, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 58035575, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 91138, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10294258, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 163, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1964, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5614.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6503.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1879, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 656, "avg_search_time_ms": 82.0, "search_nodes": 49294, "safety_nodes": 527, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49821, "avg_nodes": 6227.625, "eval_calls": 47320, "avg_eval_calls": 5915.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 47320, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44412190, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 938.5500845308537, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1959, "avg_candidate_generations": 244.875, "candidate_moves_total": 138502, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.7003573251659, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 446, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 1951, "search_candidate_moves_total": 138056, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 4209, "avg_legality_checks": 526.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4209, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13381, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1672.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28742549, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2148.0120319856514, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66790, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11131.666666666666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21340, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 45450, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11587945, "stage_ordering_ns": 62170, "stage_eval_ns": 44412190, "stage_threat_ns": 591959428, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 98550, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 517969155, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 148822, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 49271, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 62678781, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 98542, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11162670, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 126, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1740, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5426.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6426.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1988, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 451, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5937, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 97, 129, 126, 144, 110, 109, 99, 142, 100, 98, 83, 130, 131, 146, 82, 162 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 930, "avg_search_time_ms": 103.33333333333333, "search_nodes": 58559, "safety_nodes": 537, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59096, "avg_nodes": 6566.222222222223, "eval_calls": 56423, "avg_eval_calls": 6269.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 56423, "line_shape_eval_ns": 43921865, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 778.4390230934193, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2119, "avg_candidate_generations": 235.44444444444446, "candidate_moves_total": 127935, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.375176970268996, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 476, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 2110, "search_candidate_moves_total": 127459, "search_candidate_moves_max": 85, "legality_checks": 53299, "avg_legality_checks": 5922.111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 89, "root_legality_checks": 476, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 52823, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 87, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 63708, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7078.666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 151110743, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2371.927277578954, "renju_forbidden_checks": 98, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.88888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1130384, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11534.530612244898, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 90, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1042214, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 88170, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 500062, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11112.488888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.222222222222222, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 267011, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4107.861538461539, "stage_move_gen_ns": 135175661, "stage_ordering_ns": 66970, "stage_eval_ns": 43921865, "stage_threat_ns": 741242850, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 117075, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 651326558, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 645912, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58533, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 75204109, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 117066, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14066271, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 146, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1864, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5586.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6475.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1932, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4999, "avg_search_time_ms": 555.4444444444445, "search_nodes": 129880, "safety_nodes": 577, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 130457, "avg_nodes": 14495.222222222223, "eval_calls": 126419, "avg_eval_calls": 14046.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 126419, "pattern_eval_ns": 2510732, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.860400730902793, "pattern_frame_queries": 126419, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2510732, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.860400730902793, "pattern_frame_updates": 259710, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3336534929, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12847.156170343846, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3445, "avg_candidate_generations": 382.77777777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 224279, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.10275761973875, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 501, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 3436, "search_candidate_moves_total": 223778, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 5239, "avg_legality_checks": 582.1111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5239, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 946083, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 105120.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2192394369, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2317.338298014022, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20778, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2308.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 199082769, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9581.421166618538, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 253963, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20729, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 198597074, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 231732, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14993731, "stage_ordering_ns": 105371, "stage_eval_ns": 3339045661, "stage_threat_ns": 1635883913, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 259719, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1430454001, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 197732, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8830, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129855, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 174210328, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 259710, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31021852, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 178, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2982, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5104.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5993.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 452, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5082, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 81, 129, 126, 130, 131, 141, 98, 84, 99, 100, 96, 66, 109, 110, 95, 97, 67, 53, 123 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4303, "avg_search_time_ms": 391.1818181818182, "search_nodes": 104831, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 105747, "avg_nodes": 9613.363636363636, "eval_calls": 101588, "avg_eval_calls": 9235.272727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 101588, "pattern_eval_ns": 2012370, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.809130999724378, "pattern_frame_queries": 101588, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2012370, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.809130999724378, "pattern_frame_updates": 209600, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2719739217, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12975.85504293893, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3223, "avg_candidate_generations": 293.0, "candidate_moves_total": 218067, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.65963388147688, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 664, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 3212, "search_candidate_moves_total": 217403, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 98798, "avg_legality_checks": 8981.636363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "root_legality_checks": 664, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 98134, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 871442, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 79222.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2025188432, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2323.9509135432995, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11269, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1024.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61204971, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5431.269056704233, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 528631, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11207, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60673430, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2910, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.181818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 351711, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7645.891304347826, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 55, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 109811, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1996.5636363636363, "stage_move_gen_ns": 238356903, "stage_ordering_ns": 100350, "stage_eval_ns": 2721751587, "stage_threat_ns": 1325263606, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 209611, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1160223730, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 553304, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 104800, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 139638450, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 209600, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24848122, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 177, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2892, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5802.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6530.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1878, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 769, "avg_search_time_ms": 76.9, "search_nodes": 56028, "safety_nodes": 690, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 56718, "avg_nodes": 5671.8, "eval_calls": 53680, "avg_eval_calls": 5368.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 53680, "line_shape_eval_ns": 48214702, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 898.1874441132638, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2329, "avg_candidate_generations": 232.9, "candidate_moves_total": 163032, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.00085873765565, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 609, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 2319, "search_candidate_moves_total": 162423, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 6056, "avg_legality_checks": 605.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6056, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17486, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1748.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 38444688, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2198.5981928399865, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16968667, "stage_ordering_ns": 70921, "stage_eval_ns": 48214702, "stage_threat_ns": 694792653, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 112008, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 609381436, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 157150, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10620, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 55999, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 72133174, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 111998, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13120893, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 128, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2111, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5898.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6698.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 453, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2782, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 126, 98, 95, 83, 109, 108, 128, 81, 129, 127, 94, 99, 100, 85, 141, 71 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1150, "avg_search_time_ms": 127.77777777777777, "search_nodes": 73484, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 74013, "avg_nodes": 8223.666666666666, "eval_calls": 71047, "avg_eval_calls": 7894.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 71047, "line_shape_eval_ns": 53966947, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 759.5950145678213, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2420, "avg_candidate_generations": 268.8888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 143802, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.422314049586774, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 468, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 2411, "search_candidate_moves_total": 143334, "search_candidate_moves_max": 85, "legality_checks": 68766, "avg_legality_checks": 7640.666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "root_legality_checks": 468, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 68298, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 23, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 79073, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8785.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 184128208, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2328.5850796099808, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.6666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 354901, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10754.575757575758, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 273541, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 81360, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 490423, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10898.288888888888, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.222222222222222, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 262942, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4045.2615384615383, "stage_move_gen_ns": 168371084, "stage_ordering_ns": 76052, "stage_eval_ns": 53966947, "stage_threat_ns": 916468736, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 146925, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 803991203, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 645624, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9210, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 73458, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94328189, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 146916, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17503720, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 146, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2116, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5523.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6412.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1920, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1625, "avg_search_time_ms": 180.55555555555554, "search_nodes": 47537, "safety_nodes": 564, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48101, "avg_nodes": 5344.555555555556, "eval_calls": 45476, "avg_eval_calls": 5052.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 45476, "pattern_eval_ns": 909984, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.010203184097104, "pattern_frame_queries": 45476, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 909984, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.010203184097104, "pattern_frame_updates": 95024, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1003624741, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10561.802712998822, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2045, "avg_candidate_generations": 227.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 131207, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.159902200489, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 493, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 2036, "search_candidate_moves_total": 130714, "search_candidate_moves_max": 89, "legality_checks": 4427, "avg_legality_checks": 491.8888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4427, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 287324, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 31924.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 651029383, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2265.837114198605, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5184, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 576.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 48396139, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9335.674961419752, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 78491, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5161, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 48159507, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 158141, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11788507, "stage_ordering_ns": 70540, "stage_eval_ns": 1004534725, "stage_threat_ns": 593373661, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 95033, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 520128792, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 173490, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8750, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47512, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 62035345, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 95024, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11036034, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 175, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1756, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5616.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6505.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 454, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5563, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 81, 65, 80, 79, 127, 51, 93, 63, 47, 64, 62, 109, 108, 94, 124, 49 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 4894, "avg_search_time_ms": 489.4, "search_nodes": 135440, "safety_nodes": 161, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 135601, "avg_nodes": 13560.1, "eval_calls": 130677, "avg_eval_calls": 13067.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 130677, "pattern_eval_ns": 2618111, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.03497937663093, "pattern_frame_queries": 130677, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2618111, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.03497937663093, "pattern_frame_updates": 270824, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2901443312, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10713.390659616578, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4745, "avg_candidate_generations": 474.5, "candidate_moves_total": 314428, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.26512118018967, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 584, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 4735, "search_candidate_moves_total": 313844, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 124178, "avg_legality_checks": 12417.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 142, "root_legality_checks": 584, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 123594, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 896344, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 89634.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2019634336, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2253.1911141258265, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14180, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1418.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 110243005, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7774.541960507758, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 160, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1359390, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14020, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 108883615, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 95940, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10660.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 48850, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3757.6923076923076, "stage_move_gen_ns": 294084845, "stage_ordering_ns": 166850, "stage_eval_ns": 2904061423, "stage_threat_ns": 1669005562, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 270834, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1460397781, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 151270, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9600, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 135412, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 177302997, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 270824, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31153514, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 469, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4018, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5298.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6098.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1827, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 663, "avg_search_time_ms": 73.66666666666667, "search_nodes": 48827, "safety_nodes": 748, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49575, "avg_nodes": 5508.333333333333, "eval_calls": 47365, "avg_eval_calls": 5262.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 47365, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44261204, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 934.4706851050354, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1445, "avg_candidate_generations": 160.55555555555554, "candidate_moves_total": 97197, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.2643598615917, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 527, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1436, "search_candidate_moves_total": 96670, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 3032, "avg_legality_checks": 336.8888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3032, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13181, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1464.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28281008, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2145.588953797132, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8691381, "stage_ordering_ns": 43581, "stage_eval_ns": 44261204, "stage_threat_ns": 597337685, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 97611, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 524687266, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 216581, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9240, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48801, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 61104474, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 97602, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11329364, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 61, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1321, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5705.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6594.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 455, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16860, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 115, 116, 95, 175, 159, 142, 96, 144, 80, 64, 145, 130, 158, 102, 88, 140, 141, 101, 97, 100, 99, 161, 81, 129, 82, 146, 110, 131 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 4004, "avg_search_time_ms": 250.25, "search_nodes": 297745, "safety_nodes": 1033, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 298778, "avg_nodes": 18673.625, "eval_calls": 290480, "avg_eval_calls": 18155.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 290480, "line_shape_eval_ns": 375848518, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1293.8877650784907, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7234, "avg_candidate_generations": 452.125, "candidate_moves_total": 652773, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.2367984517556, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1234, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 7218, "search_candidate_moves_total": 651539, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 282817, "avg_legality_checks": 17676.0625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1530, "root_legality_checks": 1234, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 281583, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1521, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 301437, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18839.8125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 587278800, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1948.263816319828, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1738, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 108.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14564871, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8380.247986191023, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1690, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14209140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 355731, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 41, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.5625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 478513, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11671.048780487805, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 62, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 262812, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4238.903225806452, "stage_move_gen_ns": 585657887, "stage_ordering_ns": 210140, "stage_eval_ns": 375848518, "stage_threat_ns": 3013841650, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 595412, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2604733968, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 678904, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 297698, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 329047969, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 595396, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 79380809, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 454, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6395, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6601.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7101.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1915, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 12841, "avg_search_time_ms": 802.5625, "search_nodes": 426032, "safety_nodes": 1088, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 427120, "avg_nodes": 26695.0, "eval_calls": 417438, "avg_eval_calls": 26089.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 417438, "pattern_eval_ns": 8331107, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.957711085239005, "pattern_frame_queries": 417438, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 8331107, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.957711085239005, "pattern_frame_updates": 851972, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7604558125, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8925.831042569474, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8564, "avg_candidate_generations": 535.25, "candidate_moves_total": 749420, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.50817375058384, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1244, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 8548, "search_candidate_moves_total": 748176, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 18608, "avg_legality_checks": 1163.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 29, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 18608, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 29, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2007047, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 125440.4375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4420338379, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2202.409001383625, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36213, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2263.3125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 304628176, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8412.122055615388, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 36, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 269192, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 36101, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 303781171, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 76, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 577813, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 48963293, "stage_ordering_ns": 306920, "stage_eval_ns": 7612889232, "stage_threat_ns": 5143137741, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 851988, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4489853711, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 205581, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14850, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 425986, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 555132049, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 851972, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 97946400, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 468, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7758, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5930.8125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6430.8125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1972, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 456, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4233, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 95, 143, 96, 115, 116, 97, 81, 158, 173, 126, 67, 53, 80, 129, 79, 63, 82, 78, 83 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3243, "avg_search_time_ms": 294.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 111626, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 112542, "avg_nodes": 10231.09090909091, "eval_calls": 108312, "avg_eval_calls": 9846.545454545454, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 108312, "pattern_eval_ns": 2038092, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.816862397518282, "pattern_frame_queries": 108312, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2038092, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.816862397518282, "pattern_frame_updates": 223188, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1960554776, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8784.319837984121, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3293, "avg_candidate_generations": 299.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 226927, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.91193440631643, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 725, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 3282, "search_candidate_moves_total": 226202, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 105496, "avg_legality_checks": 9590.545454545454, "illegal_moves_skipped": 109, "root_legality_checks": 725, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 104771, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 105, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 726059, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 66005.36363636363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1298848987, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1788.902812305887, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13479, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1225.3636363636363, "renju_forbidden_ns": 112963976, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8380.7386304622, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 109, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 982865, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13350, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 111776341, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 204770, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.636363636363637, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 426672, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8366.117647058823, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.181818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 222540, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3272.6470588235293, "stage_move_gen_ns": 191294652, "stage_ordering_ns": 100360, "stage_eval_ns": 1962592868, "stage_threat_ns": 1063389643, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 223199, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 925074044, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 596052, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8760, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111594, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 116799414, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 223188, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20920133, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 192, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2947, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5846.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6574.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1882, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 981, "avg_search_time_ms": 89.18181818181819, "search_nodes": 88236, "safety_nodes": 646, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 88882, "avg_nodes": 8080.181818181818, "eval_calls": 85057, "avg_eval_calls": 7732.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 85057, "line_shape_eval_ns": 80388411, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 945.1122306218183, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3159, "avg_candidate_generations": 287.1818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 242688, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.82431149097816, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3148, "search_candidate_moves_total": 241940, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 9495, "avg_legality_checks": 863.1818181818181, "illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9495, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22143, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2013.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 37492927, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1693.218037302985, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.181818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 453154, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9851.173913043478, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 222702, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 230452, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19409053, "stage_ordering_ns": 100651, "stage_eval_ns": 80388411, "stage_threat_ns": 863057982, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 176421, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 753306157, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 128920, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8440, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 88205, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92447645, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 176410, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17175260, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 335, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2706, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6139.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6866.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1990, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 457, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 38734, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 157, 172, 83, 110, 98, 140, 155, 156, 124, 139, 153, 188, 204, 137, 141, 138, 136, 113, 84, 70, 81, 82, 143, 145, 129, 115, 114, 99, 169, 183, 185, 171, 170, 130, 200, 215, 201, 217, 202, 203, 199, 198, 100, 218, 214, 175, 160, 173, 158, 174 ], "move_count": 58, "black_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 23371, "avg_search_time_ms": 865.5925925925926, "search_nodes": 1484153, "safety_nodes": 2150, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1486303, "avg_nodes": 55048.25925925926, "eval_calls": 1459916, "avg_eval_calls": 54070.96296296296, "line_shape_eval_calls": 1459916, "line_shape_eval_ns": 3009908951, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 2061.700091649109, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24184, "avg_candidate_generations": 895.7037037037037, "candidate_moves_total": 2435276, "avg_candidate_moves": 100.6978167383394, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2211, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 24157, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2433065, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 1435596, "avg_legality_checks": 53170.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 139, "root_legality_checks": 2211, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1433385, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 139, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1465503, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 54277.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3261698472, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2225.651173692582, "renju_forbidden_checks": 143, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.296296296296297, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1489936, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10419.132867132867, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 141, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1487146, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2790, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8888888888888888, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 486552, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9540.235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 69, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.5555555555555554, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 239071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3464.7971014492755, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3295909191, "stage_ordering_ns": 739974, "stage_eval_ns": 3009908951, "stage_threat_ns": 17016820819, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 2968173, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 14782183222, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 76, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 878933, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 27690, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 1484073, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1895400944, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 2968146, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 338357720, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 967, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 22461, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 2.962962962962963, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 2.962962962962963, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 26 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18518518518518517, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5908.2962962962965, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6204.592592592592, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1925, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 15337, "avg_search_time_ms": 568.0370370370371, "search_nodes": 575919, "safety_nodes": 1921, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 577840, "avg_nodes": 21401.48148148148, "eval_calls": 560435, "avg_eval_calls": 20756.85185185185, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 560435, "pattern_eval_ns": 11263588, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.097938208712876, "pattern_frame_queries": 560435, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11263588, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.097938208712876, "pattern_frame_updates": 1151680, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8453955665, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7340.542220929425, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15432, "avg_candidate_generations": 571.5555555555555, "candidate_moves_total": 1426847, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.46027734577501, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2225, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 15405, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1424622, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 28941, "avg_legality_checks": 1071.888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 28941, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2260770, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 83732.22222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4762036448, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2106.3781136515436, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6504, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 240.88888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60243147, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9262.476476014761, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6504, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60243147, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 76049711, "stage_ordering_ns": 486602, "stage_eval_ns": 8465219253, "stage_threat_ns": 6736357759, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1151707, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5860449149, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 71, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 313721, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 27530, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 575840, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 743591307, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1151680, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 132003582, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 888, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 13829, "depth_sum": 79, "avg_depth": 2.925925925925926, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 79, "avg_effective_depth": 2.925925925925926, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 26 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6982.814814814815, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7279.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 458, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5082, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 83, 125, 98, 123, 124, 113, 96, 99, 95, 94, 110, 141, 85, 155 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4424, "avg_search_time_ms": 491.55555555555554, "search_nodes": 124210, "safety_nodes": 701, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 124911, "avg_nodes": 13879.0, "eval_calls": 121215, "avg_eval_calls": 13468.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 121215, "pattern_eval_ns": 2389838, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.715695252237758, "pattern_frame_queries": 121215, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2389838, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.715695252237758, "pattern_frame_updates": 248370, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2600663829, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10470.925751902403, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2979, "avg_candidate_generations": 331.0, "candidate_moves_total": 180552, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.60825780463243, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 509, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 2970, "search_candidate_moves_total": 180043, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 119953, "avg_legality_checks": 13328.111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "root_legality_checks": 509, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 119444, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 760269, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 84474.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1705946570, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2243.872326768552, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8519, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 946.5555555555555, "renju_forbidden_ns": 83434140, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9793.888954102595, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 54, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 480863, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8465, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 82953277, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 367992, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9435.692307692309, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.777777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 163761, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3149.25, "stage_move_gen_ns": 282200863, "stage_ordering_ns": 88470, "stage_eval_ns": 2603053667, "stage_threat_ns": 1525440083, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 248379, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1338642173, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 525374, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8690, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124185, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 157443704, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 248370, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28828832, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 114, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2731, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4442.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5331.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1047, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 650, "avg_search_time_ms": 81.25, "search_nodes": 47005, "safety_nodes": 458, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 47463, "avg_nodes": 5932.875, "eval_calls": 44843, "avg_eval_calls": 5605.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 44843, "line_shape_eval_ns": 39513887, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 881.1606493767143, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2147, "avg_candidate_generations": 268.375, "candidate_moves_total": 143194, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.69492314857942, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 455, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 2139, "search_candidate_moves_total": 142739, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 6234, "avg_legality_checks": 779.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6234, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15383, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1922.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 33565353, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2181.977052590522, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16358710, "stage_ordering_ns": 67640, "stage_eval_ns": 39513887, "stage_threat_ns": 586084106, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 93972, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 515951532, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 168780, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 46982, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 58861866, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 93964, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11101928, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 174, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1867, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5405.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6405.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 459, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13911, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 95, 129, 109, 108, 81, 123, 80, 125, 127, 122, 124, 143, 138, 96, 139, 154, 140, 141, 156, 145, 161, 115, 65, 50, 67, 53, 94, 79, 152, 166, 172, 188, 157, 142, 144, 98, 158, 83, 128, 68 ], "move_count": 46, "black_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 6062, "avg_search_time_ms": 288.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 383676, "safety_nodes": 2178, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 385854, "avg_nodes": 18374.0, "eval_calls": 374471, "avg_eval_calls": 17831.95238095238, "line_shape_eval_calls": 374471, "line_shape_eval_ns": 656829086, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1754.0185648554896, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9164, "avg_candidate_generations": 436.3809523809524, "candidate_moves_total": 827604, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.3103448275862, "candidate_moves_max": 134, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1736, "root_candidate_moves_max": 119, "search_candidate_generations": 9143, "search_candidate_moves_total": 825868, "search_candidate_moves_max": 134, "legality_checks": 367625, "avg_legality_checks": 17505.95238095238, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2438, "root_legality_checks": 1736, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 365889, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2427, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 391689, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18651.85714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 853599160, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2179.2778454334943, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2623, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 124.9047619047619, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10021807, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3820.742279832253, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2559, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9702394, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 64, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 319413, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 105, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 832493, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7928.504761904762, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 124, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.904761904761905, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 337200, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2719.3548387096776, "stage_move_gen_ns": 841405981, "stage_ordering_ns": 288011, "stage_eval_ns": 656829086, "stage_threat_ns": 4533861220, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 767249, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3956317652, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1207295, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 22660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 383614, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 487936386, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 767228, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 88399887, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 513, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8379, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 2.9523809523809526, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9523809523809526, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6941.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7322.380952380952, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1916, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 7831, "avg_search_time_ms": 372.9047619047619, "search_nodes": 255666, "safety_nodes": 2048, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 257714, "avg_nodes": 12272.095238095239, "eval_calls": 249362, "avg_eval_calls": 11874.380952380952, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 249362, "pattern_eval_ns": 5093222, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.42501263223747, "pattern_frame_queries": 249362, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5093222, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.42501263223747, "pattern_frame_updates": 511210, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4672455730, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9139.992820954207, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6264, "avg_candidate_generations": 298.2857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 615856, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.31673052362707, "candidate_moves_max": 138, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1761, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 6243, "search_candidate_moves_total": 614095, "search_candidate_moves_max": 138, "legality_checks": 12222, "avg_legality_checks": 582.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 62, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 12222, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 62, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1483440, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 70640.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3025233579, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2039.3366627568355, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34946, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1664.095238095238, "renju_forbidden_ns": 138598496, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3966.0761174383333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 66, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 375901, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34772, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 137729405, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 108, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 493190, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 31366395, "stage_ordering_ns": 208261, "stage_eval_ns": 4677548952, "stage_threat_ns": 3071668944, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 511231, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2678786051, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 54, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 534512, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 21920, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 255605, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 332892933, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 511210, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59455448, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 375, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5640, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 2.9047619047619047, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9047619047619047, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.047619047619047616, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6956.809523809524, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7337.761904761905, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 460, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14708, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 80, 81, 65, 95, 96, 64, 124, 82, 138, 152, 128, 144, 109, 108, 139, 129, 145, 94, 140, 137, 125, 153, 141, 142, 93, 157, 77 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 13509, "avg_search_time_ms": 900.6, "search_nodes": 367554, "safety_nodes": 270, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 367824, "avg_nodes": 24521.6, "eval_calls": 358159, "avg_eval_calls": 23877.266666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 358159, "pattern_eval_ns": 7489707, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.911681683274747, "pattern_frame_queries": 358159, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7489707, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.911681683274747, "pattern_frame_updates": 735022, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7917247791, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10771.443291493315, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9367, "avg_candidate_generations": 624.4666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 770553, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.26251734813708, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1067, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 9352, "search_candidate_moves_total": 769486, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 344417, "avg_legality_checks": 22961.133333333335, "illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "root_legality_checks": 1067, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 343350, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2413085, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 160872.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5607283103, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2323.698959216107, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24484, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1632.2666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 149184992, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6093.162555138049, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 41, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 249451, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24443, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 148935541, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 7, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.4666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 44990, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6427.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 22640, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2515.5555555555557, "stage_move_gen_ns": 820131474, "stage_ordering_ns": 362142, "stage_eval_ns": 7924737498, "stage_threat_ns": 4713851741, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 735037, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4124699123, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 103820, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17610, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 367511, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 501522749, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 735022, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 87526049, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 830, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8047, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6085.733333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6619.066666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1786, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 1186, "avg_search_time_ms": 84.71428571428571, "search_nodes": 89885, "safety_nodes": 1317, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91202, "avg_nodes": 6514.428571428572, "eval_calls": 86976, "avg_eval_calls": 6212.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 86976, "line_shape_eval_ns": 104363376, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1199.9100441501105, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2882, "avg_candidate_generations": 205.85714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 225944, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.39833448993754, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1001, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 2868, "search_candidate_moves_total": 224943, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 7285, "avg_legality_checks": 520.3571428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7285, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23490, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1677.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 48746440, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2075.1996594295447, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17803394, "stage_ordering_ns": 94270, "stage_eval_ns": 104363376, "stage_threat_ns": 1041136042, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 179702, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 912160477, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 329323, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14690, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89844, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108614313, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 179688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20031929, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 163, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2612, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6510.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7081.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 461, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7846, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 155, 53, 80, 79, 115, 131, 50, 65, 37, 111, 95, 109, 66, 93, 107, 125, 77, 157 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2920, "avg_search_time_ms": 208.57142857142858, "search_nodes": 179016, "safety_nodes": 1279, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 180295, "avg_nodes": 12878.214285714286, "eval_calls": 173934, "avg_eval_calls": 12423.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 173934, "line_shape_eval_ns": 206574051, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1187.6576804994997, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5055, "avg_candidate_generations": 361.07142857142856, "candidate_moves_total": 415101, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.11691394658753, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1058, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 5041, "search_candidate_moves_total": 414043, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 166550, "avg_legality_checks": 11896.42857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 396, "root_legality_checks": 1058, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 165492, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 396, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 182967, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13069.07142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 436084946, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2383.407641815191, "renju_forbidden_checks": 402, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 28.714285714285715, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4881223, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12142.345771144279, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 402, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4881223, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 553504, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11296.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 289313, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4254.60294117647, "stage_move_gen_ns": 418130626, "stage_ordering_ns": 170511, "stage_eval_ns": 206574051, "stage_threat_ns": 2268691954, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 357964, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1983973145, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 817875, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 178975, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 241066137, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 357950, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42834797, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 334, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4529, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6525.214285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7096.642857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1921, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 4913, "avg_search_time_ms": 350.92857142857144, "search_nodes": 168852, "safety_nodes": 1045, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 169897, "avg_nodes": 12135.5, "eval_calls": 163894, "avg_eval_calls": 11706.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 163894, "pattern_eval_ns": 3490849, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.299431339768386, "pattern_frame_queries": 163894, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3490849, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.299431339768386, "pattern_frame_updates": 337624, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2732800794, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8094.213663720589, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4932, "avg_candidate_generations": 352.2857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 444668, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.15977291159773, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1092, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 4918, "search_candidate_moves_total": 443576, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 11266, "avg_legality_checks": 804.7142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11266, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 734292, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 52449.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1662086222, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2263.522171016435, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3361, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 240.07142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 28118877, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8366.223445403153, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3361, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28118877, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 28110644, "stage_ordering_ns": 176360, "stage_eval_ns": 2736291643, "stage_threat_ns": 2111674436, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 337638, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1848556410, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 260281, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 168812, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 222920195, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 337624, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39937550, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 433, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4314, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6413.642857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6985.071428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 462, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9677, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 84, 99, 85, 83, 98, 70, 66, 114, 50, 34, 126, 140, 67, 52, 65, 141, 155, 68, 80, 35, 81, 49, 95, 110, 53, 109, 39 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 8277, "avg_search_time_ms": 551.8, "search_nodes": 237571, "safety_nodes": 270, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 237841, "avg_nodes": 15856.066666666668, "eval_calls": 229755, "avg_eval_calls": 15317.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 229755, "pattern_eval_ns": 4884877, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.26124349850928, "pattern_frame_queries": 229755, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4884877, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.26124349850928, "pattern_frame_updates": 475056, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4856611430, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10223.239849617728, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7788, "avg_candidate_generations": 519.2, "candidate_moves_total": 645909, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.9364406779661, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1067, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 7773, "search_candidate_moves_total": 644842, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 213655, "avg_legality_checks": 14243.666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "root_legality_checks": 1067, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 212588, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1553824, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 103588.26666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3517820178, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2263.9759573799865, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19101, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1273.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 104770143, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5485.060625098163, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 232021, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19062, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 104538122, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 7, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.4666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 76021, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10860.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 36491, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4054.5555555555557, "stage_move_gen_ns": 477935451, "stage_ordering_ns": 291342, "stage_eval_ns": 4861496307, "stage_threat_ns": 2877237674, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 475071, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2514101291, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 143051, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 237528, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 308692414, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 475056, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 54300918, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 850, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6540, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6538.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7071.466666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1858, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 1385, "avg_search_time_ms": 98.92857142857143, "search_nodes": 98366, "safety_nodes": 1317, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 99683, "avg_nodes": 7120.214285714285, "eval_calls": 95317, "avg_eval_calls": 6808.357142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 95317, "line_shape_eval_ns": 118245927, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1240.5544341513057, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3022, "avg_candidate_generations": 215.85714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 233291, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.19755129053607, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1001, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 3008, "search_candidate_moves_total": 232290, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 7277, "avg_legality_checks": 519.7857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7277, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23482, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1677.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 50395078, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2146.115237202964, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18691924, "stage_ordering_ns": 103702, "stage_eval_ns": 118245927, "stage_threat_ns": 1224750686, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 196664, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1073903580, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 316942, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 98325, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 127216246, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 196650, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23313918, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 163, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2721, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6481.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7052.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 463, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4662, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 85, 123, 80, 65, 157, 173, 78, 79, 107, 97, 81, 67, 94, 51, 37, 83, 35, 115 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 1957, "avg_search_time_ms": 139.78571428571428, "search_nodes": 207904, "safety_nodes": 1279, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 209183, "avg_nodes": 14941.642857142857, "eval_calls": 202429, "avg_eval_calls": 14459.214285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 202429, "line_shape_eval_ns": 124804787, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 616.536104016717, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5448, "avg_candidate_generations": 389.14285714285717, "candidate_moves_total": 448302, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.28744493392071, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1058, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 5434, "search_candidate_moves_total": 447244, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 196096, "avg_legality_checks": 14006.857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 95, "root_legality_checks": 1058, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 195038, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 95, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 212513, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15179.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 290871043, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1368.7211747046063, "renju_forbidden_checks": 109, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7.785714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 580413, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5324.8899082568805, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 109, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 580413, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 308090, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6287.551020408163, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 167760, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2467.0588235294117, "stage_move_gen_ns": 284367253, "stage_ordering_ns": 157741, "stage_eval_ns": 124804787, "stage_threat_ns": 1513813923, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 415740, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1310378842, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 455360, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 207863, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 171982183, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 415726, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30997538, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 334, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4879, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6473.071428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7044.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1951, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2688, "avg_search_time_ms": 192.0, "search_nodes": 162322, "safety_nodes": 1045, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 163367, "avg_nodes": 11669.07142857143, "eval_calls": 157094, "avg_eval_calls": 11221.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 157094, "pattern_eval_ns": 2827555, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 17.999127910677682, "pattern_frame_queries": 157094, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2827555, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 17.999127910677682, "pattern_frame_updates": 324564, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1481706794, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 4565.2222489247115, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5202, "avg_candidate_generations": 371.57142857142856, "candidate_moves_total": 474618, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.23760092272202, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1092, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 5188, "search_candidate_moves_total": 473526, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 11672, "avg_legality_checks": 833.7142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11672, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 686090, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 49006.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 822551767, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1198.8977641417307, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2666, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 190.42857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10269627, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3852.0731432858215, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2666, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10269627, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17645821, "stage_ordering_ns": 154912, "stage_eval_ns": 1484534349, "stage_threat_ns": 1149444849, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 324578, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 992598295, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 148950, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 162282, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 133015380, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 324564, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23682224, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 433, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4588, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6493.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7064.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 464, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3579, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 126, 99, 141, 98, 109, 108, 97, 83, 156, 171, 128, 67, 51, 84, 125, 85, 71, 82, 86, 81 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2547, "avg_search_time_ms": 231.54545454545453, "search_nodes": 108677, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 109593, "avg_nodes": 9963.0, "eval_calls": 105369, "avg_eval_calls": 9579.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105369, "pattern_eval_ns": 1902053, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.05135286469455, "pattern_frame_queries": 105369, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1902053, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.05135286469455, "pattern_frame_updates": 217290, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1536935115, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7073.197639099821, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3287, "avg_candidate_generations": 298.8181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 227615, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.24703376939459, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 725, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 3276, "search_candidate_moves_total": 226890, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 102217, "avg_legality_checks": 9292.454545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 109, "root_legality_checks": 725, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 101492, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 105, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 722703, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 65700.27272727272, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 994739981, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1376.4160118333534, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14625, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1329.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 79978109, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5468.58864957265, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 109, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 569973, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14496, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 79288416, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 119720, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.636363636363637, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 327222, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6416.117647058823, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.181818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 169900, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2498.529411764706, "stage_move_gen_ns": 150687547, "stage_ordering_ns": 98870, "stage_eval_ns": 1538837168, "stage_threat_ns": 838376577, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 217301, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 721944376, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 447004, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6010, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108645, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99179280, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 217290, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16805917, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 192, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2940, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5868.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6595.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1883, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1020, "avg_search_time_ms": 92.72727272727273, "search_nodes": 128655, "safety_nodes": 646, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 129301, "avg_nodes": 11754.636363636364, "eval_calls": 124326, "avg_eval_calls": 11302.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 124326, "line_shape_eval_ns": 72428796, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 582.5715940350369, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4309, "avg_candidate_generations": 391.72727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 324769, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.36992341610582, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4298, "search_candidate_moves_total": 324021, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 11177, "avg_legality_checks": 1016.0909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11177, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23825, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2165.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 32149750, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1349.4123819517313, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.363636363636363, "renju_forbidden_ns": 348473, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7259.854166666667, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 183291, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 165182, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18803413, "stage_ordering_ns": 125911, "stage_eval_ns": 72428796, "stage_threat_ns": 910687141, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 257259, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 787202966, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 113370, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6750, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128624, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104169633, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 257248, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19201172, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 335, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3794, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6115.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6842.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1989, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 465, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5287, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 98, 83, 115, 116, 69, 82, 126, 84, 85, 100, 68, 79, 99, 125, 139, 132, 148, 127, 71, 57, 70, 67, 72 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 1246, "avg_search_time_ms": 95.84615384615384, "search_nodes": 136340, "safety_nodes": 1086, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 137426, "avg_nodes": 10571.23076923077, "eval_calls": 132423, "avg_eval_calls": 10186.384615384615, "line_shape_eval_calls": 132423, "line_shape_eval_ns": 71408818, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 539.2478496937844, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3893, "avg_candidate_generations": 299.46153846153845, "candidate_moves_total": 281194, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.23067043411251, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 901, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 3880, "search_candidate_moves_total": 280293, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 127464, "avg_legality_checks": 9804.923076923076, "illegal_moves_skipped": 414, "root_legality_checks": 901, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 126563, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 412, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 142585, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10968.076923076924, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 186263036, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1306.3298102885997, "renju_forbidden_checks": 425, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 32.69230769230769, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2561817, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6027.804705882353, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 414, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2509136, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 52681, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8461538461538463, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 288221, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5764.42, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 69, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.3076923076923075, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 144751, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2097.840579710145, "stage_move_gen_ns": 179370748, "stage_ordering_ns": 109811, "stage_eval_ns": 71408818, "stage_threat_ns": 968472630, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 272619, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 836899793, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 411113, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6850, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 136303, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 111269894, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 272606, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19891830, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 249, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3505, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6357.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6972.615384615385, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1951, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 4031, "avg_search_time_ms": 335.9166666666667, "search_nodes": 216845, "safety_nodes": 929, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 217774, "avg_nodes": 18147.833333333332, "eval_calls": 211195, "avg_eval_calls": 17599.583333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 211195, "pattern_eval_ns": 3800739, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 17.9963493453917, "pattern_frame_queries": 211195, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3800739, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 17.9963493453917, "pattern_frame_updates": 433620, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2376525871, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5480.664800977815, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5627, "avg_candidate_generations": 468.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 423704, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.29838279722765, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 823, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 5615, "search_candidate_moves_total": 422881, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 9195, "avg_legality_checks": 766.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 65, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9195, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 65, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 961108, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 80092.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1218402474, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1267.706099626681, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39784, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3315.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 205273826, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5159.708073597426, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 65, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 378760, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 39709, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 204832066, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 63000, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15314489, "stage_ordering_ns": 164011, "stage_eval_ns": 2380326610, "stage_threat_ns": 1592963482, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 433632, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1375274212, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 159071, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6650, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 216810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184917837, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 433620, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32612362, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 257, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5033, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6011.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6678.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 466, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10765, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 84, 83, 69, 99, 98, 70, 130, 82, 146, 162, 126, 140, 115, 116, 145, 125, 139, 100, 144, 147, 129, 161, 143, 142, 101, 157, 87 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 10019, "avg_search_time_ms": 667.9333333333333, "search_nodes": 462028, "safety_nodes": 270, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 462298, "avg_nodes": 30819.866666666665, "eval_calls": 450523, "avg_eval_calls": 30034.866666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 450523, "pattern_eval_ns": 8149842, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.089735707167005, "pattern_frame_queries": 450523, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 8149842, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.089735707167005, "pattern_frame_updates": 923970, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5889313901, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6373.923288634913, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11477, "avg_candidate_generations": 765.1333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 936177, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.56983532281956, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1067, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 11462, "search_candidate_moves_total": 935110, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 439907, "avg_legality_checks": 29327.133333333335, "illegal_moves_skipped": 156, "root_legality_checks": 1067, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 438840, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 156, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3013669, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 200911.26666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3929750937, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1303.9756313649575, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25671, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1711.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 110381214, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4299.840832067313, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 178, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 780126, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25493, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 109601088, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 7, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.4666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 42510, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6072.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 20920, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2324.4444444444443, "stage_move_gen_ns": 615561977, "stage_ordering_ns": 335944, "stage_eval_ns": 5897463743, "stage_threat_ns": 3420269346, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 923985, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2933673845, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 82880, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8130, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 461985, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 416887622, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 923970, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69624999, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 850, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 10053, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6222.466666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6755.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1880, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 733, "avg_search_time_ms": 52.357142857142854, "search_nodes": 92457, "safety_nodes": 1317, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 93774, "avg_nodes": 6698.142857142857, "eval_calls": 89427, "avg_eval_calls": 6387.642857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 89427, "line_shape_eval_ns": 58243092, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 651.2920258982186, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3003, "avg_candidate_generations": 214.5, "candidate_moves_total": 234771, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.17882117882118, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1001, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 2989, "search_candidate_moves_total": 233770, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 7586, "avg_legality_checks": 541.8571428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7586, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23791, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1699.357142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28767422, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1209.1724601740154, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11766581, "stage_ordering_ns": 83160, "stage_eval_ns": 58243092, "stage_threat_ns": 643217911, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 184846, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 556695229, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 198683, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8640, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92416, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73008360, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 184832, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13315639, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 163, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2732, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6519.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7091.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1992, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 467, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21388, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 129, 157, 172, 81, 114, 96, 144, 159, 158, 130, 145, 161, 186, 200, 147, 143, 146, 148, 111, 80, 64, 82, 83, 175, 191, 79, 78, 69, 99, 84, 92, 50, 106, 120, 156, 65, 115, 131, 116, 117, 125, 139, 51, 67, 95, 68, 66, 54, 110, 40 ], "move_count": 57, "black_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 5152, "avg_search_time_ms": 190.8148148148148, "search_nodes": 522298, "safety_nodes": 2532, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 524830, "avg_nodes": 19438.14814814815, "eval_calls": 511047, "avg_eval_calls": 18927.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 511047, "line_shape_eval_ns": 510883850, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 999.6807534336372, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11199, "avg_candidate_generations": 414.77777777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 1077416, "avg_candidate_moves": 96.2064470041968, "candidate_moves_max": 144, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2509, "root_candidate_moves_max": 125, "search_candidate_generations": 11172, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1074907, "search_candidate_moves_max": 144, "legality_checks": 490560, "avg_legality_checks": 18168.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 151, "root_legality_checks": 2509, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 488051, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 151, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 520631, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19282.62962962963, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 732880468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1407.677353058116, "renju_forbidden_checks": 157, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.814814814814815, "renju_forbidden_ns": 907762, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5781.923566878981, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 157, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 907762, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 57, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.111111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 429112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7528.2807017543855, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 80, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.962962962962963, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 218111, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2726.3875, "stage_move_gen_ns": 720273789, "stage_ordering_ns": 330132, "stage_eval_ns": 510883850, "stage_threat_ns": 3824739486, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1044465, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3297763866, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 70, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 676575, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19650, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 522219, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 446689967, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1044438, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 79609078, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 734, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9998, "depth_sum": 79, "avg_depth": 2.925925925925926, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 79, "avg_effective_depth": 2.925925925925926, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 26 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.037037037037037035, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7141.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7437.740740740741, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1958, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 28, "search_move_count": 26, "total_time_ms": 16212, "avg_search_time_ms": 623.5384615384615, "search_nodes": 815330, "safety_nodes": 2532, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 817862, "avg_nodes": 31456.23076923077, "eval_calls": 797777, "avg_eval_calls": 30683.73076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 797777, "pattern_eval_ns": 14676214, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.39638645887259, "pattern_frame_queries": 797777, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 14676214, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.39638645887259, "pattern_frame_updates": 1630506, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 9558093154, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5862.041080498937, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17502, "avg_candidate_generations": 673.1538461538462, "candidate_moves_total": 1883810, "avg_candidate_moves": 107.63398468746429, "candidate_moves_max": 151, "root_candidate_generations": 26, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2423, "root_candidate_moves_max": 126, "search_candidate_generations": 17476, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1881387, "search_candidate_moves_max": 151, "legality_checks": 26679, "avg_legality_checks": 1026.1153846153845, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 26679, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4424858, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 170186.84615384616, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5820226266, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1315.3475808715218, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25192, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 968.9230769230769, "renju_forbidden_ns": 127649276, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5067.056049539537, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25192, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 127649276, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 52323933, "stage_ordering_ns": 510943, "stage_eval_ns": 9572769368, "stage_threat_ns": 6413723426, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1630532, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5535320837, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 72, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 387142, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19220, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 815253, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 746909584, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1630506, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 131105863, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 917, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 15151, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 2.9615384615384617, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9615384615384617, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 25 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 26, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.11538461538461539, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6904.807692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7212.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1991, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 468, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6056, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 81, 129, 96, 130, 131, 111, 95, 157, 172, 98, 109, 123, 80, 143, 65, 49, 110, 50, 125 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5061, "avg_search_time_ms": 460.09090909090907, "search_nodes": 140556, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 141472, "avg_nodes": 12861.09090909091, "eval_calls": 136877, "avg_eval_calls": 12443.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 136877, "pattern_eval_ns": 2719714, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.869766286520015, "pattern_frame_queries": 136877, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2719714, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.869766286520015, "pattern_frame_updates": 281048, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3010256009, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10710.825229142352, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3658, "avg_candidate_generations": 332.54545454545456, "candidate_moves_total": 244176, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.75123018042646, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 725, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 3647, "search_candidate_moves_total": 243451, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 135388, "avg_legality_checks": 12308.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 119, "root_legality_checks": 725, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 134663, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 115, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 871784, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 79253.09090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1971913620, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2261.9291246455546, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13488, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1226.1818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 143624723, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10648.333555753263, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 119, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1143406, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13349, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 142263997, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 217320, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 479851, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10663.355555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 60, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.454545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 244071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4067.85, "stage_move_gen_ns": 317497534, "stage_ordering_ns": 120250, "stage_eval_ns": 3012975723, "stage_threat_ns": 1709931519, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 281059, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1499387033, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 674582, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 140524, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 177438742, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 281048, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32431162, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 192, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3321, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5102.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5829.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1049, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 984, "avg_search_time_ms": 89.45454545454545, "search_nodes": 71261, "safety_nodes": 646, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 71907, "avg_nodes": 6537.0, "eval_calls": 68068, "avg_eval_calls": 6188.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68068, "line_shape_eval_ns": 74359726, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1092.4329494035376, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3173, "avg_candidate_generations": 288.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 244210, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.96501733375355, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3162, "search_candidate_moves_total": 243462, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 8605, "avg_legality_checks": 782.2727272727273, "illegal_moves_skipped": 23, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8605, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 23, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21255, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1932.2727272727273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 45476319, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2139.5586450247, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.909090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 497823, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11577.279069767443, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 267821, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 230002, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23044488, "stage_ordering_ns": 109700, "stage_eval_ns": 74359726, "stage_threat_ns": 872716782, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 142471, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 766051131, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 135901, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10650, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 71230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 89931060, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 142460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16598690, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 335, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2712, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6130.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6858.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1993, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 469, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13550, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 81, 143, 67, 52, 95, 53, 80, 83, 113, 38, 68, 129, 54, 96, 69, 70, 84, 99, 100, 159, 175, 115, 79, 78, 109, 123, 66, 65, 40, 26, 116, 132, 101, 131, 147, 130, 133, 128 ], "move_count": 44, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 5157, "avg_search_time_ms": 257.85, "search_nodes": 349457, "safety_nodes": 1915, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 351372, "avg_nodes": 17568.6, "eval_calls": 339929, "avg_eval_calls": 16996.45, "line_shape_eval_calls": 339929, "line_shape_eval_ns": 479891207, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1411.7395309020412, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9489, "avg_candidate_generations": 474.45, "candidate_moves_total": 811976, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.57023922436505, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1603, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 9469, "search_candidate_moves_total": 810373, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 334862, "avg_legality_checks": 16743.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3724, "root_legality_checks": 1603, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 333259, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 357761, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17888.05, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 737278017, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2060.8115948915615, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3866, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 193.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18453651, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4773.318934299017, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3816, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18189260, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 264391, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 96, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 784662, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8173.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 114, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 311231, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2730.09649122807, "stage_move_gen_ns": 734012404, "stage_ordering_ns": 307461, "stage_eval_ns": 479891207, "stage_threat_ns": 3880632945, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 698816, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3383633368, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 56, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1124322, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 349398, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 419913283, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 698796, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 75961972, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 507, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8474, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 2.95, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 2.95, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6969.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7369.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1924, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 8373, "avg_search_time_ms": 418.65, "search_nodes": 288764, "safety_nodes": 1693, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 290457, "avg_nodes": 14522.85, "eval_calls": 282844, "avg_eval_calls": 14142.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 282844, "pattern_eval_ns": 5759450, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.362638061970557, "pattern_frame_queries": 282844, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5759450, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.362638061970557, "pattern_frame_updates": 577412, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4928964952, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8536.305016175625, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5882, "avg_candidate_generations": 294.1, "candidate_moves_total": 539619, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.74073444406665, "candidate_moves_max": 134, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1632, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 5862, "search_candidate_moves_total": 537987, "search_candidate_moves_max": 134, "legality_checks": 9508, "avg_legality_checks": 475.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 62, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9508, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 62, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1588482, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 79424.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3111635394, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1958.873562306655, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44518, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2225.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 159320298, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3578.7838177815715, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 62, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 351382, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 44396, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 158595815, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 373101, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23512667, "stage_ordering_ns": 194201, "stage_eval_ns": 4934724402, "stage_threat_ns": 3362087709, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 577432, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2932060990, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 425951, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 288706, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 364930011, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 577412, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64670757, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 479, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5198, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6906.95, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7306.95, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 470, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9820, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 80, 95, 79, 81, 96, 64, 68, 110, 54, 40, 128, 144, 67, 52, 69, 143, 159, 66, 84, 39, 83, 55, 99, 114, 51, 115, 35 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 8479, "avg_search_time_ms": 565.2666666666667, "search_nodes": 254004, "safety_nodes": 270, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 254274, "avg_nodes": 16951.6, "eval_calls": 245984, "avg_eval_calls": 16398.933333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 245984, "pattern_eval_ns": 5001591, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.332993202809938, "pattern_frame_queries": 245984, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5001591, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.332993202809938, "pattern_frame_updates": 507922, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4970781751, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9786.506099361713, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7992, "avg_candidate_generations": 532.8, "candidate_moves_total": 661023, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.71058558558559, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1067, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 7977, "search_candidate_moves_total": 659956, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 228208, "avg_legality_checks": 15213.866666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 30, "root_legality_checks": 1067, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 227141, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 30, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1652485, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 110165.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3601409949, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2179.3904023334553, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19652, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1310.1333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 104942692, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5340.051496030938, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 84, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 358562, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19568, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 104584130, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 7, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.4666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 77491, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11070.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 35750, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3972.222222222222, "stage_move_gen_ns": 493757706, "stage_ordering_ns": 276260, "stage_eval_ns": 4975783342, "stage_threat_ns": 2958015121, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 507937, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2580898162, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 143521, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14960, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 253961, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 321316896, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 507922, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55656542, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 850, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6684, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6535.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7068.466666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1860, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 1326, "avg_search_time_ms": 94.71428571428571, "search_nodes": 97841, "safety_nodes": 1317, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 99158, "avg_nodes": 7082.714285714285, "eval_calls": 94916, "avg_eval_calls": 6779.714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 94916, "line_shape_eval_ns": 110821347, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1167.5728749631253, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2898, "avg_candidate_generations": 207.0, "candidate_moves_total": 223668, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.18012422360249, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1001, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 2884, "search_candidate_moves_total": 222667, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 7392, "avg_legality_checks": 528.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7392, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23597, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1685.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 48751983, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2066.024621773954, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18184378, "stage_ordering_ns": 91910, "stage_eval_ns": 110821347, "stage_threat_ns": 1175830601, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 195614, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1032794969, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 312791, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 97800, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 120598777, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 195600, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22124064, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 163, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2620, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6483.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7055.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 471, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6058, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 140, 97, 156, 114, 172, 124, 141, 139, 157, 127, 125, 82, 67, 66, 130, 50 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 516, "avg_search_time_ms": 57.333333333333336, "search_nodes": 31040, "safety_nodes": 839, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 31879, "avg_nodes": 3542.1111111111113, "eval_calls": 29361, "avg_eval_calls": 3262.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 29361, "line_shape_eval_ns": 22057589, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 751.2546915976976, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1663, "avg_candidate_generations": 184.77777777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 113953, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.52254960914011, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 566, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 1654, "search_candidate_moves_total": 113387, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 27456, "avg_legality_checks": 3050.6666666666665, "illegal_moves_skipped": 286, "root_legality_checks": 566, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 26890, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 279, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 38305, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4256.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 90116578, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2352.606134969325, "renju_forbidden_checks": 318, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 35.333333333333336, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3464303, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10894.034591194968, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 288, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3133833, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 330470, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 86, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9.555555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 908704, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10566.32558139535, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13.11111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 450422, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3817.135593220339, "stage_move_gen_ns": 73341145, "stage_ordering_ns": 52951, "stage_eval_ns": 22057589, "stage_threat_ns": 408849977, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 62039, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 359683272, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1145686, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 31015, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 40521227, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 62030, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7499792, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 124, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1459, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5667.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6556.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1912, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5534, "avg_search_time_ms": 691.75, "search_nodes": 141609, "safety_nodes": 235, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 141844, "avg_nodes": 17730.5, "eval_calls": 137921, "avg_eval_calls": 17240.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 137921, "pattern_eval_ns": 2808174, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.360742744034628, "pattern_frame_queries": 137921, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2808174, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.360742744034628, "pattern_frame_updates": 283172, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3666299646, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12947.253421948497, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3673, "avg_candidate_generations": 459.125, "candidate_moves_total": 267334, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.78355567655868, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 504, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 3665, "search_candidate_moves_total": 266830, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 5781, "avg_legality_checks": 722.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5781, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 964562, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 120570.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2285165672, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2369.1226401205936, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37309, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4663.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 352623817, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9451.441126805865, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 761387, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37197, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 351381179, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 481251, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17244106, "stage_ordering_ns": 124430, "stage_eval_ns": 3669107820, "stage_threat_ns": 1837046303, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 283180, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1611867397, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 62750, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 141586, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 190396077, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 283172, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34720079, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 316, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3180, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4327.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5327.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1966, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 472, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6360, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 140, 82, 141, 143, 114, 156, 84, 97, 100, 86, 52, 68, 99, 129, 139, 138, 127, 113, 54, 69, 81, 83, 53, 55, 111, 41 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2762, "avg_search_time_ms": 197.28571428571428, "search_nodes": 74918, "safety_nodes": 1222, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76140, "avg_nodes": 5438.571428571428, "eval_calls": 71835, "avg_eval_calls": 5131.071428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71835, "pattern_eval_ns": 1446157, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.131648917658524, "pattern_frame_queries": 71835, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1446157, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.131648917658524, "pattern_frame_updates": 149756, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1694764616, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11316.83949891824, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3057, "avg_candidate_generations": 218.35714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 243371, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.6110565914295, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1031, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 3043, "search_candidate_moves_total": 242340, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 66337, "avg_legality_checks": 4738.357142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 52, "root_legality_checks": 1031, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 65306, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 52, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 579709, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 41407.78571428572, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1238863572, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2137.043882361668, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12306, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 879.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 82242138, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6683.092637737689, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 58, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 477971, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12244, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 81757527, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6640, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 474082, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9675.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 245761, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3413.347222222222, "stage_move_gen_ns": 146564794, "stage_ordering_ns": 107590, "stage_eval_ns": 1696210773, "stage_threat_ns": 887489362, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 149770, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 776211589, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 661392, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74878, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93986302, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 149756, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16630079, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 278, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2644, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6398.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6969.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1772, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3584, "avg_search_time_ms": 275.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 363582, "safety_nodes": 882, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 364464, "avg_nodes": 28035.69230769231, "eval_calls": 354833, "avg_eval_calls": 27294.846153846152, "line_shape_eval_calls": 354833, "line_shape_eval_ns": 268683179, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 757.2102341101307, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8724, "avg_candidate_generations": 671.0769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 750163, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.98842274186153, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 962, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 8711, "search_candidate_moves_total": 749201, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 16681, "avg_legality_checks": 1283.1538461538462, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 16681, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 31853, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2450.230769230769, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 60722683, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1906.341098169717, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.3846153846153846, "renju_forbidden_ns": 301540, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9727.09677419355, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 253720, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 47820, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 36223841, "stage_ordering_ns": 255111, "stage_eval_ns": 268683179, "stage_threat_ns": 3234402477, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 727101, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2820195573, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 284431, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12580, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 363544, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 349397373, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 727088, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64525100, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 447, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7957, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6270.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6885.538461538462, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1958, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 473, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11580, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 97, 95, 125, 142, 94, 65, 50, 158, 174, 81, 111, 83, 82, 67, 139, 153, 109, 53, 39, 79, 93, 77, 78, 68, 160, 144, 154, 124, 64, 38, 98, 23 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 5524, "avg_search_time_ms": 324.94117647058823, "search_nodes": 413389, "safety_nodes": 1813, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 415202, "avg_nodes": 24423.647058823528, "eval_calls": 405184, "avg_eval_calls": 23834.352941176472, "line_shape_eval_calls": 405184, "line_shape_eval_ns": 422328054, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1042.3117744037277, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8172, "avg_candidate_generations": 480.70588235294116, "candidate_moves_total": 723746, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.56412139011258, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1420, "root_candidate_moves_max": 114, "search_candidate_generations": 8155, "search_candidate_moves_total": 722326, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 399037, "avg_legality_checks": 23472.764705882353, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 1420, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 397617, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 418970, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24645.29411764706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 815571755, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1946.611344487672, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.8235294117647058, "renju_forbidden_ns": 80320, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5737.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 80320, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.235294117647059, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 421471, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5853.763888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.235294117647059, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 191960, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2156.85393258427, "stage_move_gen_ns": 811509889, "stage_ordering_ns": 240381, "stage_eval_ns": 422328054, "stage_threat_ns": 4237229901, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 826695, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3698788815, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 658112, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 413339, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 454961164, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 826678, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 82821810, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 331, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7603, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6435.176470588235, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6905.764705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1925, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 6040, "avg_search_time_ms": 355.29411764705884, "search_nodes": 284169, "safety_nodes": 1640, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 285809, "avg_nodes": 16812.29411764706, "eval_calls": 277116, "avg_eval_calls": 16300.941176470587, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 277116, "pattern_eval_ns": 5206190, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.7870422494551, "pattern_frame_queries": 277116, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5206190, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.7870422494551, "pattern_frame_updates": 568240, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3381976272, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5951.668787836125, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7021, "avg_candidate_generations": 413.0, "candidate_moves_total": 575290, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.93847030337558, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1454, "root_candidate_moves_max": 114, "search_candidate_generations": 7004, "search_candidate_moves_total": 573836, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 16405, "avg_legality_checks": 965.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 16405, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1205400, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 70905.88235294117, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1911048933, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1585.4064484818318, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5425, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 319.11764705882354, "renju_forbidden_ns": 35881200, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6614.046082949309, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5425, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35881200, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 29039748, "stage_ordering_ns": 215450, "stage_eval_ns": 3387182462, "stage_threat_ns": 2563664769, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 568257, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2235264820, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 271521, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12600, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 284120, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 278236160, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 568240, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49892268, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 423, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6272, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 2.823529411764706, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 2.823529411764706, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6511.64705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6982.235294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 474, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13478, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 144, 160, 142, 95, 125, 94, 127, 65, 50, 78, 62, 97, 157, 172, 143, 145, 141, 140, 173, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 13024, "avg_search_time_ms": 1085.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 355425, "safety_nodes": 383, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 355808, "avg_nodes": 29650.666666666668, "eval_calls": 348288, "avg_eval_calls": 29024.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 348288, "pattern_eval_ns": 6839757, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.638221816427784, "pattern_frame_queries": 348288, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6839757, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.638221816427784, "pattern_frame_updates": 710782, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8197022684, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11532.400488476072, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7115, "avg_candidate_generations": 592.9166666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 584842, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.19845397048489, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 921, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 7103, "search_candidate_moves_total": 583921, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 343173, "avg_legality_checks": 28597.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 412, "root_legality_checks": 921, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 342252, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 410, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2635190, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 219599.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5628672450, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2135.9645604301777, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56163, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4680.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 538013391, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9579.498798141125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 505, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4750164, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 55641, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 533085886, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 177341, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.8333333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 115970, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11597.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.1666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 62320, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4451.428571428572, "stage_move_gen_ns": 746247241, "stage_ordering_ns": 236270, "stage_eval_ns": 8203862441, "stage_threat_ns": 4029680039, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 710794, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3521955213, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 168670, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9540, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 355391, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 429777320, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 710782, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 77778836, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 558, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6199, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4439.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5106.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 442, "avg_search_time_ms": 40.18181818181818, "search_nodes": 38916, "safety_nodes": 1082, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 39998, "avg_nodes": 3636.181818181818, "eval_calls": 37231, "avg_eval_calls": 3384.6363636363635, "line_shape_eval_calls": 37231, "line_shape_eval_ns": 27106561, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 728.0642743949934, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1664, "avg_candidate_generations": 151.27272727272728, "candidate_moves_total": 139812, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.02163461538461, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 850, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 1653, "search_candidate_moves_total": 138962, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 4429, "avg_legality_checks": 402.6363636363636, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4429, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17473, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1588.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 33797373, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1934.262748240142, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7272727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 206562, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10871.684210526315, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 59310, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 147252, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10930362, "stage_ordering_ns": 52290, "stage_eval_ns": 27106561, "stage_threat_ns": 389053153, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 77779, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 341894783, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 205260, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38884, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 39633043, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 77768, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7320067, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 154, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1402, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6137.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6864.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1988, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 475, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13005, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 113, 83, 81, 110, 68, 85, 86, 124, 138, 99, 97, 129, 114, 115, 65, 49, 67, 131, 147, 69, 53, 39, 54, 130, 154, 140, 64, 66, 70, 132, 128, 133 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 5202, "avg_search_time_ms": 306.0, "search_nodes": 331450, "safety_nodes": 1813, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 333263, "avg_nodes": 19603.70588235294, "eval_calls": 324038, "avg_eval_calls": 19061.058823529413, "line_shape_eval_calls": 324038, "line_shape_eval_ns": 384166395, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1185.5597028743543, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7379, "avg_candidate_generations": 434.05882352941177, "candidate_moves_total": 641571, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.94552107331617, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1420, "root_candidate_moves_max": 114, "search_candidate_generations": 7362, "search_candidate_moves_total": 640151, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 317998, "avg_legality_checks": 18705.764705882353, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 1420, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 316578, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 337931, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19878.29411764706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 773388726, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2288.5995247550536, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.8235294117647058, "renju_forbidden_ns": 110170, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7869.285714285715, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 110170, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.235294117647059, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 635043, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8820.041666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.235294117647059, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 281900, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3167.4157303370785, "stage_move_gen_ns": 754741814, "stage_ordering_ns": 234990, "stage_eval_ns": 384166395, "stage_threat_ns": 4025244283, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 662817, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3526145151, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 969453, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 331400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 421123782, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 662800, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 77005897, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 331, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6828, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6404.117647058823, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6874.705882352941, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1893, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 7788, "avg_search_time_ms": 458.11764705882354, "search_nodes": 277317, "safety_nodes": 1640, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 278957, "avg_nodes": 16409.235294117647, "eval_calls": 270390, "avg_eval_calls": 15905.29411764706, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 270390, "pattern_eval_ns": 5512415, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.386904101483044, "pattern_frame_queries": 270390, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5512415, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.386904101483044, "pattern_frame_updates": 554536, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4290006411, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7736.209030612981, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6895, "avg_candidate_generations": 405.5882352941176, "candidate_moves_total": 568507, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.45206671501087, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1454, "root_candidate_moves_max": 114, "search_candidate_generations": 6878, "search_candidate_moves_total": 567053, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 16722, "avg_legality_checks": 983.6470588235294, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 16722, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1133062, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 66650.70588235294, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2505851926, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2211.5752942027884, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3859, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 227.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 34042521, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8821.591344908007, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3859, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34042521, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 41467246, "stage_ordering_ns": 241900, "stage_eval_ns": 4295518826, "stage_threat_ns": 3407075701, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 554553, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2985728519, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 324211, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 277268, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 357508159, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 554536, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63514812, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 426, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6213, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 2.823529411764706, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 2.823529411764706, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6413.235294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6883.823529411765, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 476, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11727, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 110, 83, 81, 68, 111, 54, 40, 85, 86, 113, 95, 125, 109, 108, 123, 67, 137 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10768, "avg_search_time_ms": 978.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 287612, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 287998, "avg_nodes": 26181.636363636364, "eval_calls": 281110, "avg_eval_calls": 25555.454545454544, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 281110, "pattern_eval_ns": 5667838, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.162349258297464, "pattern_frame_queries": 281110, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5667838, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.162349258297464, "pattern_frame_updates": 575162, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6480239886, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11266.808109715175, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6482, "avg_candidate_generations": 589.2727272727273, "candidate_moves_total": 519230, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.10336315951866, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 823, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 6471, "search_candidate_moves_total": 518407, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 277486, "avg_legality_checks": 25226.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 204, "root_legality_checks": 823, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 276663, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 204, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1926482, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 175134.72727272726, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4536542049, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2354.832305207108, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25573, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2324.818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 247778733, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9689.075704844954, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 208, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1849987, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25365, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 245928746, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.9090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 119040, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11904.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.2727272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 65390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4670.714285714285, "stage_move_gen_ns": 666420932, "stage_ordering_ns": 208272, "stage_eval_ns": 6485907724, "stage_threat_ns": 3575586207, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 575173, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3131242292, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 174001, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10690, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 287581, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 376561423, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 575162, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67608491, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 506, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5690, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4323.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5050.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 949, "avg_search_time_ms": 94.9, "search_nodes": 70868, "safety_nodes": 986, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 71854, "avg_nodes": 7185.4, "eval_calls": 68399, "avg_eval_calls": 6839.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68399, "line_shape_eval_ns": 61024952, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 892.1907045424641, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2450, "avg_candidate_generations": 245.0, "candidate_moves_total": 199152, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.2865306122449, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 755, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2440, "search_candidate_moves_total": 198397, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 5685, "avg_legality_checks": 568.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5685, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1756.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 37925253, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2159.752448747153, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15294807, "stage_ordering_ns": 72880, "stage_eval_ns": 61024952, "stage_threat_ns": 859981713, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 141688, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 754369265, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 224480, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70839, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 89133380, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 141678, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16254588, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 154, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2137, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5903.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6703.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 477, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5685, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 144, 111, 130, 82, 116, 102, 129, 159, 115, 113, 100, 110, 109, 68, 124, 54 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 549, "avg_search_time_ms": 61.0, "search_nodes": 37833, "safety_nodes": 885, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 38718, "avg_nodes": 4302.0, "eval_calls": 35901, "avg_eval_calls": 3989.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 35901, "line_shape_eval_ns": 25994283, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 724.0545667251608, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1916, "avg_candidate_generations": 212.88888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 134613, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.25730688935282, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 592, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 1907, "search_candidate_moves_total": 134021, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 34298, "avg_legality_checks": 3810.8888888888887, "illegal_moves_skipped": 70, "root_legality_checks": 592, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 33706, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 63, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 45058, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5006.444444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 94456173, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2096.324137777975, "renju_forbidden_checks": 100, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11.11111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1182118, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11821.18, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 848516, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 333602, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8.222222222222221, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 755256, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10206.162162162162, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 101, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11.222222222222221, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 370864, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3671.920792079208, "stage_move_gen_ns": 76862805, "stage_ordering_ns": 57431, "stage_eval_ns": 25994283, "stage_threat_ns": 435361439, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 75625, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 380772506, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 974656, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8270, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37808, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 45507531, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 75616, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8106746, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 124, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1708, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5680.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6569.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1916, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5126, "avg_search_time_ms": 640.75, "search_nodes": 143970, "safety_nodes": 249, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 144219, "avg_nodes": 18027.375, "eval_calls": 139974, "avg_eval_calls": 17496.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 139974, "pattern_eval_ns": 2885672, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.615771500421506, "pattern_frame_queries": 139974, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2885672, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.615771500421506, "pattern_frame_updates": 287894, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3286530651, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11415.766396659881, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3981, "avg_candidate_generations": 497.625, "candidate_moves_total": 302777, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.05551369002764, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 532, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 3973, "search_candidate_moves_total": 302245, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 6406, "avg_legality_checks": 800.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6406, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 839786, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 104973.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1983100323, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2361.43532161765, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28826, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3603.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 284954670, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9885.335114133075, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 47, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 510884, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28744, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 284061255, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 382531, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17211302, "stage_ordering_ns": 132580, "stage_eval_ns": 3289416323, "stage_threat_ns": 1805172481, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 287902, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1578119833, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 57810, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 143947, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 192432930, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 287894, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34561908, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 330, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3398, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4596.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5596.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 478, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11026, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 144, 82, 129, 99, 130, 110, 146, 162, 68, 97, 67, 111, 113, 126, 83, 53, 159, 174, 81, 124, 138, 125, 127, 80, 64, 95, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 8711, "avg_search_time_ms": 580.7333333333333, "search_nodes": 219030, "safety_nodes": 439, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 219469, "avg_nodes": 14631.266666666666, "eval_calls": 212096, "avg_eval_calls": 14139.733333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 212096, "pattern_eval_ns": 4409805, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.791551938744718, "pattern_frame_queries": 212096, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4409805, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.791551938744718, "pattern_frame_updates": 437974, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5474909437, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12500.535276066616, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6906, "avg_candidate_generations": 460.4, "candidate_moves_total": 623497, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.28337677381987, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1170, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 6891, "search_candidate_moves_total": 622327, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 200203, "avg_legality_checks": 13346.866666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 697, "root_legality_checks": 1170, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 199033, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 694, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1743812, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 116254.13333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4068699970, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2333.221683300723, "renju_forbidden_checks": 49163, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3277.5333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 238606185, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4853.369098712446, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 804, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1688799, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 48344, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 236900186, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 17200, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 98271, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10919.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 48970, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4080.8333333333335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 474685027, "stage_ordering_ns": 269433, "stage_eval_ns": 5479319242, "stage_threat_ns": 2712934153, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 437989, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2366120261, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 161721, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 218987, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 295211586, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 437974, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51440585, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 787, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5846, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6510.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7043.466666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1814, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2301, "avg_search_time_ms": 164.35714285714286, "search_nodes": 160427, "safety_nodes": 1566, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 161993, "avg_nodes": 11570.92857142857, "eval_calls": 156506, "avg_eval_calls": 11179.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 156506, "line_shape_eval_ns": 151367245, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 967.1657636128966, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3894, "avg_candidate_generations": 278.14285714285717, "candidate_moves_total": 304281, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.14098613251156, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1099, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 3880, "search_candidate_moves_total": 303182, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 6752, "avg_legality_checks": 482.2857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6752, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23121, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1651.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 51430443, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2224.4039185156353, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29030, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1319.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8330, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 20700, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19924606, "stage_ordering_ns": 125351, "stage_eval_ns": 151367245, "stage_threat_ns": 2107333382, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 320786, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1849837469, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 429642, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 160386, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 216781784, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 320772, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40284487, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 145, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3591, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6361.071428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6932.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1970, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 479, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5742, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 144, 97, 158, 110, 172, 130, 143, 145, 157, 127, 129, 82, 67, 68, 124, 54 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 509, "avg_search_time_ms": 56.55555555555556, "search_nodes": 30201, "safety_nodes": 839, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 31040, "avg_nodes": 3448.8888888888887, "eval_calls": 28473, "avg_eval_calls": 3163.6666666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 28473, "line_shape_eval_ns": 22160751, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 778.3075545253398, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1712, "avg_candidate_generations": 190.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 117540, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.65654205607477, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 566, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 1703, "search_candidate_moves_total": 116974, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 26497, "avg_legality_checks": 2944.1111111111113, "illegal_moves_skipped": 73, "root_legality_checks": 566, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 25931, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 66, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 37346, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4149.555555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 90603324, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2426.051625341402, "renju_forbidden_checks": 105, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11.666666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1299010, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12371.52380952381, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 944417, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 354593, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 86, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9.555555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 915316, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10643.209302325582, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13.11111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 454314, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3850.1186440677966, "stage_move_gen_ns": 71259509, "stage_ordering_ns": 56360, "stage_eval_ns": 22160751, "stage_threat_ns": 405589807, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 60361, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 356392291, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1150096, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8800, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 30176, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 40602016, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 60352, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7445404, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 124, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1505, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5672.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6561.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1916, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5224, "avg_search_time_ms": 653.0, "search_nodes": 129096, "safety_nodes": 235, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 129331, "avg_nodes": 16166.375, "eval_calls": 125670, "avg_eval_calls": 15708.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 125670, "pattern_eval_ns": 2613600, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.797326330866554, "pattern_frame_queries": 125670, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2613600, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.797326330866554, "pattern_frame_updates": 258146, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3477382071, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13470.60218248588, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3411, "avg_candidate_generations": 426.375, "candidate_moves_total": 248972, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.99091175608326, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 504, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 3403, "search_candidate_moves_total": 248468, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 4898, "avg_legality_checks": 612.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 57, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4898, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 57, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 880401, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 110050.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2154761544, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2447.477392688105, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34918, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4364.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 340550963, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9752.877112091184, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 742104, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34809, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 339316328, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 492531, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15096164, "stage_ordering_ns": 116710, "stage_eval_ns": 3479995671, "stage_threat_ns": 1715540348, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 258154, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1505691485, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 63520, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8440, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129073, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 177406078, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 258146, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32379265, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 316, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2946, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4490.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5490.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1970, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 480, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8156, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 144, 82, 143, 141, 110, 158, 80, 97, 94, 78, 52, 66, 95, 125, 145, 146, 127, 111, 50, 65, 83, 81, 51, 49, 113, 33 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2875, "avg_search_time_ms": 205.35714285714286, "search_nodes": 71544, "safety_nodes": 1222, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 72766, "avg_nodes": 5197.571428571428, "eval_calls": 68557, "avg_eval_calls": 4896.928571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68557, "pattern_eval_ns": 1436734, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.956780489227942, "pattern_frame_queries": 68557, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1436734, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.956780489227942, "pattern_frame_updates": 143008, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1776350906, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12421.33940758559, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2961, "avg_candidate_generations": 211.5, "candidate_moves_total": 236638, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.91827085444106, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1031, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 2947, "search_candidate_moves_total": 235607, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 63534, "avg_legality_checks": 4538.142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "root_legality_checks": 1031, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 62503, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 551600, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 39400.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1300814461, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2358.256818346628, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12663, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 904.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 98549928, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7782.510305614784, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 338262, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12619, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 98204066, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7600, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 544493, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11112.102040816326, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 281051, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3903.4861111111113, "stage_move_gen_ns": 151375066, "stage_ordering_ns": 105422, "stage_eval_ns": 1777787640, "stage_threat_ns": 917100047, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 143022, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 803774039, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 761913, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14370, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 71504, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 95664114, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 143008, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16899981, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 278, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2550, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6426.928571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6998.357142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1818, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 5268, "avg_search_time_ms": 405.2307692307692, "search_nodes": 374890, "safety_nodes": 882, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 375772, "avg_nodes": 28905.53846153846, "eval_calls": 366266, "avg_eval_calls": 28174.30769230769, "line_shape_eval_calls": 366266, "line_shape_eval_ns": 457603067, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1249.3735891401332, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8599, "avg_candidate_generations": 661.4615384615385, "candidate_moves_total": 741081, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.18223049191766, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 962, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 8586, "search_candidate_moves_total": 740119, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 17428, "avg_legality_checks": 1340.6153846153845, "illegal_moves_skipped": 28, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 17428, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 28, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32600, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2507.6923076923076, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 76409362, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2343.8454601226995, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.4615384615384617, "renju_forbidden_ns": 397262, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12414.4375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 348882, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 48380, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 49954770, "stage_ordering_ns": 283921, "stage_eval_ns": 457603067, "stage_threat_ns": 4743908826, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 749717, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4153248618, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 299260, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13710, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 374852, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 498235791, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 749704, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 92125157, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 447, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7842, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6226.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6842.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1962, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 481, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13756, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 111, 81, 83, 114, 66, 79, 78, 130, 146, 95, 97, 125, 110, 109, 69, 55, 67, 123, 137, 65, 51, 35, 50, 124, 160, 144, 70, 68, 64, 122, 126, 121 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 6050, "avg_search_time_ms": 355.88235294117646, "search_nodes": 366544, "safety_nodes": 1813, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 368357, "avg_nodes": 21668.058823529413, "eval_calls": 358650, "avg_eval_calls": 21097.058823529413, "line_shape_eval_calls": 358650, "line_shape_eval_ns": 445113325, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1241.0799526000278, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7861, "avg_candidate_generations": 462.4117647058824, "candidate_moves_total": 686190, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.29042106602213, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1420, "root_candidate_moves_max": 114, "search_candidate_generations": 7844, "search_candidate_moves_total": 684770, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 352561, "avg_legality_checks": 20738.882352941175, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "root_legality_checks": 1420, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 351141, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 372494, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21911.41176470588, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 910910308, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2445.436189576208, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.8823529411764706, "renju_forbidden_ns": 129602, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8640.133333333333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 129602, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.235294117647059, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 662973, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9207.958333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.235294117647059, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 287210, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3227.078651685393, "stage_move_gen_ns": 893104764, "stage_ordering_ns": 255981, "stage_eval_ns": 445113325, "stage_threat_ns": 4661305283, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 733005, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4089689269, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1010066, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 366494, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 481654868, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 732988, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 88951080, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 331, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7306, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6307.058823529412, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6777.64705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1515, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 7695, "avg_search_time_ms": 452.6470588235294, "search_nodes": 254367, "safety_nodes": 1640, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 256007, "avg_nodes": 15059.235294117647, "eval_calls": 248050, "avg_eval_calls": 14591.176470588236, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 248050, "pattern_eval_ns": 5273903, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.261451320298328, "pattern_frame_queries": 248050, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5273903, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.261451320298328, "pattern_frame_updates": 508636, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4303859460, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8461.570671364198, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6285, "avg_candidate_generations": 369.70588235294116, "candidate_moves_total": 522175, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.08273667462211, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1454, "root_candidate_moves_max": 114, "search_candidate_generations": 6268, "search_candidate_moves_total": 520721, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 17170, "avg_legality_checks": 1010.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 17170, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1090211, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 64130.05882352941, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2567484268, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2355.034271347473, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5095, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 299.70588235294116, "renju_forbidden_ns": 49419575, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9699.622178606476, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5095, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 49419575, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 44907390, "stage_ordering_ns": 235912, "stage_eval_ns": 4309133363, "stage_threat_ns": 3297422240, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 508653, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2887855158, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 337202, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17891, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 254318, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 348044651, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 508636, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61185229, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 415, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5640, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 2.823529411764706, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 2.823529411764706, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6428.823529411765, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6899.411764705882, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1982, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 482, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14225, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 114, 81, 83, 66, 113, 50, 34, 79, 78, 111, 115, 116, 129, 159, 99, 84, 131, 67, 147 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 13210, "avg_search_time_ms": 1100.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 324675, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 325061, "avg_nodes": 27088.416666666668, "eval_calls": 317664, "avg_eval_calls": 26472.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 317664, "pattern_eval_ns": 6721604, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.159476679762264, "pattern_frame_queries": 317664, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6721604, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.159476679762264, "pattern_frame_updates": 649282, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8102681703, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12479.449149984137, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6989, "avg_candidate_generations": 582.4166666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 579851, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.9662326513092, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 924, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 6977, "search_candidate_moves_total": 578927, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 313082, "avg_legality_checks": 26090.166666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 565, "root_legality_checks": 924, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 312158, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 563, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2247815, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 187317.91666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5638881068, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2508.6054982282794, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42570, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3547.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 466857446, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10966.818087855298, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 661, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6757484, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 41892, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 459916802, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 183160, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.8333333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 124291, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12429.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.1666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 67151, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4796.5, "stage_move_gen_ns": 801919786, "stage_ordering_ns": 249173, "stage_eval_ns": 8109403307, "stage_threat_ns": 4263814666, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 649294, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3726260626, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 184071, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 324641, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 457925979, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 649282, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 79443990, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 570, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6138, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4362.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5028.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1004, "avg_search_time_ms": 91.27272727272727, "search_nodes": 70667, "safety_nodes": 1092, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 71759, "avg_nodes": 6523.545454545455, "eval_calls": 68124, "avg_eval_calls": 6193.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68124, "line_shape_eval_ns": 65443282, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 960.6494333861782, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2522, "avg_candidate_generations": 229.27272727272728, "candidate_moves_total": 209408, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.0325138778747, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 855, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2511, "search_candidate_moves_total": 208553, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 5692, "avg_legality_checks": 517.4545454545455, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5692, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18734, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1703.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 42829651, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2286.1989430981102, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7272727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 222101, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11689.526315789473, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 61840, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 160261, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16616385, "stage_ordering_ns": 81270, "stage_eval_ns": 65443282, "stage_threat_ns": 906985407, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 141281, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 796228457, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 261091, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11880, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70635, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93301844, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 141270, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17194015, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 154, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2152, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6091.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6818.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 483, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10458, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 97, 99, 129, 142, 100, 69, 54, 156, 170, 83, 113, 81, 82, 67, 140, 154, 115, 53, 145, 161, 130, 85, 160 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3472, "avg_search_time_ms": 267.0769230769231, "search_nodes": 206537, "safety_nodes": 1284, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 207821, "avg_nodes": 15986.23076923077, "eval_calls": 201761, "avg_eval_calls": 15520.076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 201761, "line_shape_eval_ns": 190126727, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 942.336363320959, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4752, "avg_candidate_generations": 365.53846153846155, "candidate_moves_total": 349732, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.59680134680134, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 936, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 4739, "search_candidate_moves_total": 348796, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 198476, "avg_legality_checks": 15267.384615384615, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 936, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 197540, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 213845, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16449.615384615383, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 542512514, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2536.942710841965, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.7692307692307693, "renju_forbidden_ns": 80222, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8022.2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 75362, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4860, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 62, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.769230769230769, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 620323, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10005.209677419354, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 82, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.3076923076923075, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 289953, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3536.012195121951, "stage_move_gen_ns": 523258940, "stage_ordering_ns": 150950, "stage_eval_ns": 190126727, "stage_threat_ns": 2740743537, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 413013, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2405308343, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 883313, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13610, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 206500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 282269703, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 413000, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52282178, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 208, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4408, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5982.307692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6597.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1918, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6973, "avg_search_time_ms": 581.0833333333334, "search_nodes": 223887, "safety_nodes": 668, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 224555, "avg_nodes": 18712.916666666668, "eval_calls": 217702, "avg_eval_calls": 18141.833333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 217702, "pattern_eval_ns": 4635276, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.29183930326777, "pattern_frame_queries": 217702, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4635276, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.29183930326777, "pattern_frame_updates": 447704, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3969039913, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8865.321536104211, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6162, "avg_candidate_generations": 513.5, "candidate_moves_total": 477657, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.51655306718598, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 861, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 6150, "search_candidate_moves_total": 476796, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 13095, "avg_legality_checks": 1091.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 13095, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 936886, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 78073.83333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2311114153, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2466.8040220475064, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4437, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 369.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46308986, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10437.003831417625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4437, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 46308986, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 35856242, "stage_ordering_ns": 210040, "stage_eval_ns": 3973675189, "stage_threat_ns": 2934972062, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 447716, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2570967606, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 184441, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13261, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 223852, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 308261105, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 447704, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55558910, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 369, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5466, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5644.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6311.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 484, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14132, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 140, 154, 142, 99, 129, 100, 127, 69, 54, 86, 72, 97, 157, 172, 141, 139, 143, 144, 171, 115, 185 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 13531, "avg_search_time_ms": 1127.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 311228, "safety_nodes": 383, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 311611, "avg_nodes": 25967.583333333332, "eval_calls": 304687, "avg_eval_calls": 25390.583333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 304687, "pattern_eval_ns": 6514808, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.381969037077393, "pattern_frame_queries": 304687, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6514808, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.381969037077393, "pattern_frame_updates": 622388, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8572961123, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13774.303365424783, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6519, "avg_candidate_generations": 543.25, "candidate_moves_total": 536141, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.24282865470164, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 921, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 6507, "search_candidate_moves_total": 535220, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 299442, "avg_legality_checks": 24953.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 427, "root_legality_checks": 921, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 298521, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 425, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2321938, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 193494.83333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5954883835, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2564.6179333815116, "renju_forbidden_checks": 51751, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4312.583333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 576085474, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11131.871345481246, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 523, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5555714, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 51211, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 570343890, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 185870, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.8333333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 133151, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 13315.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.1666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 72110, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 5150.714285714285, "stage_move_gen_ns": 778208017, "stage_ordering_ns": 228780, "stage_eval_ns": 8579475931, "stage_threat_ns": 4142641035, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 622400, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3618474691, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 194901, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 311194, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 446289344, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 622388, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 77682099, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 548, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5595, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4388.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5055.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 590, "avg_search_time_ms": 53.63636363636363, "search_nodes": 39630, "safety_nodes": 1082, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40712, "avg_nodes": 3701.090909090909, "eval_calls": 37942, "avg_eval_calls": 3449.2727272727275, "line_shape_eval_calls": 37942, "line_shape_eval_ns": 37384759, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 985.3133466870487, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1667, "avg_candidate_generations": 151.54545454545453, "candidate_moves_total": 139814, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.87162567486503, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 850, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 1656, "search_candidate_moves_total": 138964, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 4557, "avg_legality_checks": 414.27272727272725, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4557, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17601, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1600.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 39899447, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2266.8852337935346, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.8181818181818181, "renju_forbidden_ns": 232611, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11630.55, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 73240, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 159371, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13208115, "stage_ordering_ns": 58070, "stage_eval_ns": 37384759, "stage_threat_ns": 523776102, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 79207, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 460847527, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 259312, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 39598, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 52952483, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 79196, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9716780, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 154, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1407, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6124.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6851.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 485, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5922, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 140, 113, 124, 82, 108, 92, 125, 155, 109, 111, 94, 114, 115, 66, 130, 50 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 896, "avg_search_time_ms": 99.55555555555556, "search_nodes": 54348, "safety_nodes": 885, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 55233, "avg_nodes": 6137.0, "eval_calls": 52049, "avg_eval_calls": 5783.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 52049, "line_shape_eval_ns": 39841563, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 765.4626025475994, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2283, "avg_candidate_generations": 253.66666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 160327, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.22645641699518, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 592, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 2274, "search_candidate_moves_total": 159735, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 50358, "avg_legality_checks": 5595.333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 71, "root_legality_checks": 592, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 49766, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 64, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 61118, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6790.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 148744160, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2433.72099872378, "renju_forbidden_checks": 101, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11.222222222222221, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1174174, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11625.485148514852, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 71, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 853632, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 320542, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8.222222222222221, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 794365, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10734.662162162162, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 101, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11.222222222222221, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 388182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3843.3861386138615, "stage_move_gen_ns": 131050327, "stage_ordering_ns": 72261, "stage_eval_ns": 39841563, "stage_threat_ns": 711854918, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 108655, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 625016841, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1032186, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8890, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 54323, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 72459421, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 108646, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13346470, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 124, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2029, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5575.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6464.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1896, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5017, "avg_search_time_ms": 627.125, "search_nodes": 142396, "safety_nodes": 249, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 142645, "avg_nodes": 17830.625, "eval_calls": 138225, "avg_eval_calls": 17278.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 138225, "pattern_eval_ns": 2812252, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.3454657261711, "pattern_frame_queries": 138225, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2812252, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.3454657261711, "pattern_frame_updates": 284746, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3159882314, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11097.196497931489, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4156, "avg_candidate_generations": 519.5, "candidate_moves_total": 313412, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.41193455245428, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 532, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 4148, "search_candidate_moves_total": 312880, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 7262, "avg_legality_checks": 907.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 45, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7262, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 45, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 801624, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 100203.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1912349651, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2385.5943073061685, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25004, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3125.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 245758223, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9828.756318988962, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 449340, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24924, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 244908231, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 400652, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20311272, "stage_ordering_ns": 138030, "stage_eval_ns": 3162694566, "stage_threat_ns": 1825617542, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 284754, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1594325162, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 64931, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 142373, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 197146674, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 284746, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34080775, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 330, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3620, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4576.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5576.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 486, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12632, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 140, 82, 125, 95, 124, 114, 138, 152, 66, 97, 67, 113, 111, 128, 81, 51, 155, 170, 83, 130, 146, 129, 127, 84, 70, 99, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 10297, "avg_search_time_ms": 686.4666666666667, "search_nodes": 272736, "safety_nodes": 439, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 273175, "avg_nodes": 18211.666666666668, "eval_calls": 264963, "avg_eval_calls": 17664.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 264963, "pattern_eval_ns": 5350125, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.191970199612776, "pattern_frame_queries": 264963, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5350125, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.191970199612776, "pattern_frame_updates": 545386, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6403929986, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11742.013887411851, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7745, "avg_candidate_generations": 516.3333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 709845, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.65203357004519, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1170, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 7730, "search_candidate_moves_total": 708675, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 252707, "avg_legality_checks": 16847.133333333335, "illegal_moves_skipped": 977, "root_legality_checks": 1170, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 251537, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 974, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2109239, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 140615.93333333332, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4720710003, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2238.1105237481383, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56630, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3775.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 270060298, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4768.8556948613805, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2459339, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 55498, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 267585779, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 15180, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 98601, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10955.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 49180, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4098.333333333333, "stage_move_gen_ns": 574258304, "stage_ordering_ns": 270072, "stage_eval_ns": 6409280111, "stage_threat_ns": 3275691257, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 545401, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2858183302, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 162101, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14690, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 272693, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 354167689, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 545386, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63178165, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 787, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6573, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6402.533333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6935.866666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1763, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2321, "avg_search_time_ms": 165.78571428571428, "search_nodes": 169964, "safety_nodes": 1566, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 171530, "avg_nodes": 12252.142857142857, "eval_calls": 165849, "avg_eval_calls": 11846.357142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 165849, "line_shape_eval_ns": 152255495, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 918.0368588294172, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4088, "avg_candidate_generations": 292.0, "candidate_moves_total": 314518, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.93688845401174, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1099, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 4074, "search_candidate_moves_total": 313419, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 6935, "avg_legality_checks": 495.35714285714283, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6935, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23304, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1664.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 49805644, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2137.2143837967733, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 23970, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1089.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 16890, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19405448, "stage_ordering_ns": 119250, "stage_eval_ns": 152255495, "stage_threat_ns": 2137158624, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 339860, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1881693077, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 405871, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 169923, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 213898127, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 339846, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41161549, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 145, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3786, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6347.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6918.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1967, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 487, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8765, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 97, 82, 113, 114, 142, 157, 66, 96, 68, 146, 130, 124, 138, 141, 81, 129, 65, 49, 67, 69, 64 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3071, "avg_search_time_ms": 279.1818181818182, "search_nodes": 197577, "safety_nodes": 621, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 198198, "avg_nodes": 18018.0, "eval_calls": 192799, "avg_eval_calls": 17527.18181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 192799, "line_shape_eval_ns": 156190822, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 810.1225732498613, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4758, "avg_candidate_generations": 432.54545454545456, "candidate_moves_total": 369556, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.67044976881043, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 829, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 4747, "search_candidate_moves_total": 368727, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 191072, "avg_legality_checks": 17370.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 447, "root_legality_checks": 829, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 190243, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 442, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 204160, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18560.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 482640942, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2364.032827194357, "renju_forbidden_checks": 471, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 42.81818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5082681, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10791.254777070064, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 451, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4853361, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 229320, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.3636363636363638, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 298292, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11472.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.4545454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 159481, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4196.868421052632, "stage_move_gen_ns": 473343226, "stage_ordering_ns": 137610, "stage_eval_ns": 156190822, "stage_threat_ns": 2431489414, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 395103, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2135479167, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 418692, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10780, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197546, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 249580207, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 395092, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46011348, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 387, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4216, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5624.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6351.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1912, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5684, "avg_search_time_ms": 568.4, "search_nodes": 170885, "safety_nodes": 520, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 171405, "avg_nodes": 17140.5, "eval_calls": 166406, "avg_eval_calls": 16640.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 166406, "pattern_eval_ns": 3335263, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.042925134911002, "pattern_frame_queries": 166406, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3335263, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.042925134911002, "pattern_frame_updates": 341712, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3484789021, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10198.029396099639, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4460, "avg_candidate_generations": 446.0, "candidate_moves_total": 384737, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.26390134529149, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 746, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 4450, "search_candidate_moves_total": 383991, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 12260, "avg_legality_checks": 1226.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 248, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 12260, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 248, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 810683, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 81068.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1887065653, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2327.7479026943947, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47659, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4765.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 454292577, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9532.146645964036, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 248, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2598558, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 47386, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 451404247, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 289772, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 34329459, "stage_ordering_ns": 150030, "stage_eval_ns": 3488124284, "stage_threat_ns": 2144993112, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 341722, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1882024795, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 116740, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 170856, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 222755522, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 341712, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40096055, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 328, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3958, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5612.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6412.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 488, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11681, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 99, 128, 80, 129, 130, 125, 126, 157, 172, 141, 109, 144, 160, 143, 145, 140 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11244, "avg_search_time_ms": 1124.4, "search_nodes": 281678, "safety_nodes": 77, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 281755, "avg_nodes": 28175.5, "eval_calls": 275205, "avg_eval_calls": 27520.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 275205, "pattern_eval_ns": 5516032, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.043356770407513, "pattern_frame_queries": 275205, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5516032, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.043356770407513, "pattern_frame_updates": 563300, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6945684079, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12330.346314574826, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6455, "avg_candidate_generations": 645.5, "candidate_moves_total": 472041, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.12796281951975, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 6445, "search_candidate_moves_total": 471401, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 269433, "avg_legality_checks": 26943.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 485, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 268793, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 483, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1948629, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 194862.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4694371346, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2409.063678103939, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46958, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4695.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 449078592, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9563.40968525065, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 500, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5014584, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 46448, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 443959096, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 104912, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 667087451, "stage_ordering_ns": 212611, "stage_eval_ns": 6951200111, "stage_threat_ns": 3614147187, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 563310, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3166595168, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 20270, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 281650, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 379045715, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 563300, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 68486034, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 561, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5543, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3360.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4160.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 707, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 429, "avg_search_time_ms": 47.666666666666664, "search_nodes": 30080, "safety_nodes": 751, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 30831, "avg_nodes": 3425.6666666666665, "eval_calls": 28715, "avg_eval_calls": 3190.5555555555557, "line_shape_eval_calls": 28715, "line_shape_eval_ns": 24755381, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 862.1062510882814, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1348, "avg_candidate_generations": 149.77777777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 92919, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.93100890207715, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 573, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 1339, "search_candidate_moves_total": 92346, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 2748, "avg_legality_checks": 305.3333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2748, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13244, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1471.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28081631, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2120.3285261250376, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.4444444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 146570, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11274.615384615385, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 58410, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 88160, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7767614, "stage_ordering_ns": 41300, "stage_eval_ns": 24755381, "stage_threat_ns": 385653903, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 60117, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 339551005, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 194371, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 30054, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 38647332, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 60108, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7261195, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 66, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1225, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5709.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6598.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 489, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23222, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 126, 98, 109, 108, 83, 66, 114, 94, 80, 50, 34, 158, 143, 122, 127, 95, 97, 125, 96, 141, 124, 157, 140, 159, 138, 152, 154, 168, 139, 169, 64, 48, 55, 69, 156, 136, 150, 184, 120, 200 ], "move_count": 46, "black_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 8244, "avg_search_time_ms": 392.57142857142856, "search_nodes": 537580, "safety_nodes": 2078, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 539658, "avg_nodes": 25698.0, "eval_calls": 526735, "avg_eval_calls": 25082.619047619046, "line_shape_eval_calls": 526735, "line_shape_eval_ns": 783575685, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1487.608920994428, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10804, "avg_candidate_generations": 514.4761904761905, "candidate_moves_total": 1005533, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.0704368752314, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1806, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 10783, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1003727, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 509366, "avg_legality_checks": 24255.52380952381, "illegal_moves_skipped": 704, "root_legality_checks": 1806, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 507560, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 700, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 533407, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 25400.333333333332, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1164949775, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2183.979166002696, "renju_forbidden_checks": 930, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 44.285714285714285, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10065488, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10823.105376344087, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 914, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9883748, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 181740, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 70, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.3333333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 601651, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8595.014285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.380952380952381, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 260430, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2830.7608695652175, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1161017245, "stage_ordering_ns": 341740, "stage_eval_ns": 783575685, "stage_threat_ns": 6256384575, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1075057, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5463801500, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 950915, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 21180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 537518, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 670854514, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1075036, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 120777646, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 615, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9852, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 2.9523809523809526, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9523809523809526, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.047619047619047616, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6846.952380952381, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7227.9047619047615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1891, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 14956, "avg_search_time_ms": 712.1904761904761, "search_nodes": 579984, "safety_nodes": 1325, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 581309, "avg_nodes": 27681.380952380954, "eval_calls": 569072, "avg_eval_calls": 27098.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 569072, "pattern_eval_ns": 11413445, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.056240686591504, "pattern_frame_queries": 569072, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11413445, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.056240686591504, "pattern_frame_updates": 1159846, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8078482494, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6965.133728098385, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10872, "avg_candidate_generations": 517.7142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 1024741, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.25505886681384, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1829, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 10851, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1022912, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 25662, "avg_legality_checks": 1222.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 75, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 25662, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2002397, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 95352.23809523809, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4261898047, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2128.3981383312102, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40931, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1949.095238095238, "renju_forbidden_ns": 358713073, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8763.848256822457, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 78, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 755044, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 40826, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 357675078, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 282951, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 61794752, "stage_ordering_ns": 358592, "stage_eval_ns": 8089895939, "stage_threat_ns": 6738620734, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1159867, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5881081641, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 55, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 236930, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 21330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 579923, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 728415238, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1159846, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 128886925, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 787, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9684, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.047619047619047616, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09523809523809523, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.047619047619047616, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6750.238095238095, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7131.190476190476, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1939, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 490, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10654, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 143, 126, 84, 141, 156, 81, 96, 109, 108, 95, 67, 140, 154, 125, 155, 80 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9913, "avg_search_time_ms": 991.3, "search_nodes": 242580, "safety_nodes": 77, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 242657, "avg_nodes": 24265.7, "eval_calls": 236004, "avg_eval_calls": 23600.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 236004, "pattern_eval_ns": 4744785, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.10468042914527, "pattern_frame_queries": 236004, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4744785, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.10468042914527, "pattern_frame_updates": 485104, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6249385793, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12882.56908415515, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6558, "avg_candidate_generations": 655.8, "candidate_moves_total": 479605, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.13281488258616, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 6548, "search_candidate_moves_total": 478965, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 227204, "avg_legality_checks": 22720.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 316, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 226564, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 314, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1777915, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 177791.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4249895068, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2390.3814681804247, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44101, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4410.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 415673399, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9425.486927734066, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 328, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2918695, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 43763, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 412644314, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 110390, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 559370869, "stage_ordering_ns": 220821, "stage_eval_ns": 6254130578, "stage_threat_ns": 3089842064, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 485114, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2701687310, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 20250, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9640, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 242552, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 330378697, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 485104, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57755807, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 561, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5669, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4152.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4952.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1737, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 730, "avg_search_time_ms": 81.11111111111111, "search_nodes": 51760, "safety_nodes": 751, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 52511, "avg_nodes": 5834.555555555556, "eval_calls": 50167, "avg_eval_calls": 5574.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 50167, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44457571, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 886.1915402555464, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1576, "avg_candidate_generations": 175.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 107294, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.07994923857868, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 573, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 1567, "search_candidate_moves_total": 106721, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 3255, "avg_legality_checks": 361.6666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3255, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13751, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1527.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29518435, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2146.639153516108, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.6666666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 173461, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11564.066666666668, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 84331, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 89130, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9364451, "stage_ordering_ns": 51010, "stage_eval_ns": 44457571, "stage_threat_ns": 668097352, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 103477, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 587815890, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 204361, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13721, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51734, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 67460630, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 103468, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12616471, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 66, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1443, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5662.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6551.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1965, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 491, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10321, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 96, 128, 67, 52, 129, 100, 142, 68, 84, 86, 72, 124, 125, 36, 111, 83, 81, 4, 20, 113, 98, 99, 95, 94, 109, 53, 123 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 2209, "avg_search_time_ms": 147.26666666666668, "search_nodes": 142665, "safety_nodes": 1303, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 143968, "avg_nodes": 9597.866666666667, "eval_calls": 139396, "avg_eval_calls": 9293.066666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 139396, "line_shape_eval_ns": 197358753, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1415.8136029728257, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3241, "avg_candidate_generations": 216.06666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 293561, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.57729095958038, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1172, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 3226, "search_candidate_moves_total": 292389, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 137026, "avg_legality_checks": 9135.066666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1224, "root_legality_checks": 1172, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 135854, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1217, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 154507, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10300.466666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 335336581, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2170.3649737552346, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1459, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 97.26666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 17608263, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12068.7203564085, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1429, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17274192, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 334071, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 570042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9828.310344827587, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 82, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.466666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 274680, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3349.756097560976, "stage_move_gen_ns": 326830753, "stage_ordering_ns": 103462, "stage_eval_ns": 197358753, "stage_threat_ns": 1656185805, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 285259, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1451667755, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 785584, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 142622, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 172404067, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 285244, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31328399, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 319, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2801, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6619.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7152.933333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1914, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 8096, "avg_search_time_ms": 578.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 251938, "safety_nodes": 1095, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 253033, "avg_nodes": 18073.785714285714, "eval_calls": 245361, "avg_eval_calls": 17525.785714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 245361, "pattern_eval_ns": 4968590, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.25012124991339, "pattern_frame_queries": 245361, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4968590, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.25012124991339, "pattern_frame_updates": 503794, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4954252936, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9833.886342433614, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6550, "avg_candidate_generations": 467.85714285714283, "candidate_moves_total": 542207, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.77969465648854, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1092, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 6536, "search_candidate_moves_total": 541115, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 17737, "avg_legality_checks": 1266.9285714285713, "illegal_moves_skipped": 150, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 17737, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 150, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1319238, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 94231.28571428571, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2992426587, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2268.2992659398833, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40316, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2879.714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 420080579, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10419.698854052982, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 153, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1732601, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 40116, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 417804106, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 47, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 543872, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 45287057, "stage_ordering_ns": 206470, "stage_eval_ns": 4959221526, "stage_threat_ns": 3049013731, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 503808, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2679636348, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 235580, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14540, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 251897, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 312139683, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 503794, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57002120, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 406, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5848, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6053.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6624.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1929, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 492, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5210, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 128, 125, 96, 80, 95, 94, 52, 67, 68, 110, 98, 99, 54, 40, 144, 160, 83, 113, 53, 38, 55, 56, 51 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 4290, "avg_search_time_ms": 330.0, "search_nodes": 114175, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 115224, "avg_nodes": 8863.384615384615, "eval_calls": 110451, "avg_eval_calls": 8496.23076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110451, "pattern_eval_ns": 2227676, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.168907479334727, "pattern_frame_queries": 110451, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2227676, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.168907479334727, "pattern_frame_updates": 228276, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2609791101, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11432.612718814067, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3700, "avg_candidate_generations": 284.61538461538464, "candidate_moves_total": 276742, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.79513513513514, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3687, "search_candidate_moves_total": 275828, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 102978, "avg_legality_checks": 7921.384615384615, "illegal_moves_skipped": 173, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 102064, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 170, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 848377, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 65259.769230769234, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1874988529, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2210.088827254864, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17599, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1353.7692307692307, "renju_forbidden_ns": 123420596, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7012.932325700324, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 273, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2410240, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17287, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 120751144, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 259212, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.615384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 592121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9868.683333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 278931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3320.6071428571427, "stage_move_gen_ns": 237206324, "stage_ordering_ns": 129400, "stage_eval_ns": 2612018777, "stage_threat_ns": 1414272634, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 228289, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1240516397, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 879553, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12730, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 114138, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 146482604, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 228276, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26394080, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3186, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6280.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6895.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1862, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 908, "avg_search_time_ms": 75.66666666666667, "search_nodes": 66929, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67941, "avg_nodes": 5661.75, "eval_calls": 64457, "avg_eval_calls": 5371.416666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 64457, "line_shape_eval_ns": 58369120, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 905.551297764401, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2449, "avg_candidate_generations": 204.08333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 170857, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.76602694977542, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 2437, "search_candidate_moves_total": 170017, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3825, "avg_legality_checks": 318.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3825, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17731, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1477.5833333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 37147345, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2095.050758558457, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.0833333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 256742, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10269.68, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 74340, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 182402, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10874383, "stage_ordering_ns": 70230, "stage_eval_ns": 58369120, "stage_threat_ns": 822595440, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 133800, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 724853413, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 197260, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13120, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66894, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 82120838, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 133788, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15423929, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2216, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6215.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6882.416666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 493, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4124, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 97, 82, 114, 115, 68, 126, 94, 125, 83, 124, 138, 123, 127, 122 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1259, "avg_search_time_ms": 157.375, "search_nodes": 78641, "safety_nodes": 505, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 79146, "avg_nodes": 9893.25, "eval_calls": 76168, "avg_eval_calls": 9521.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 76168, "line_shape_eval_ns": 54540941, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 716.0610886461507, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2458, "avg_candidate_generations": 307.25, "candidate_moves_total": 164695, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.00366151342556, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 498, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 2450, "search_candidate_moves_total": 164197, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 71665, "avg_legality_checks": 8958.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 125, "root_legality_checks": 498, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 71167, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 124, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 81128, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10141.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 195831334, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2413.856301153732, "renju_forbidden_checks": 129, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 16.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1431507, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11096.953488372093, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1383867, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 47640, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 299401, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11515.423076923076, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 37, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 159301, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4305.4324324324325, "stage_move_gen_ns": 182847336, "stage_ordering_ns": 76441, "stage_eval_ns": 54540941, "stage_threat_ns": 1014113472, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 157244, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 891759521, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 417902, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8290, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78618, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 102859855, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 157236, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19076194, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 175, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2191, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5160.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6160.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1902, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 2856, "avg_search_time_ms": 357.0, "search_nodes": 91497, "safety_nodes": 517, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92014, "avg_nodes": 11501.75, "eval_calls": 89226, "avg_eval_calls": 11153.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89226, "pattern_eval_ns": 1808078, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.26402618070966, "pattern_frame_queries": 89226, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1808078, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.26402618070966, "pattern_frame_updates": 182950, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1661445662, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9081.419305821262, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2257, "avg_candidate_generations": 282.125, "candidate_moves_total": 171529, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.99867080194949, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 518, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 2249, "search_candidate_moves_total": 171011, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 5381, "avg_legality_checks": 672.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5381, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 399226, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 49903.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 917326246, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2297.7617840521407, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11334, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1416.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 107765845, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9508.191724016235, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 137100, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11310, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 107509785, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 118960, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14263482, "stage_ordering_ns": 77810, "stage_eval_ns": 1663253740, "stage_threat_ns": 1164808357, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 182958, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1023744107, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 104960, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91475, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 119155037, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 182950, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21804253, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 206, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1947, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5276.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6276.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1959, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 494, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6180, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 114, 111, 126, 81, 98, 84, 83, 68, 116, 115, 130, 82, 128, 143, 146, 162, 140, 154, 129, 127, 131, 132, 161, 176, 101 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 5826, "avg_search_time_ms": 448.15384615384613, "search_nodes": 156217, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 157266, "avg_nodes": 12097.384615384615, "eval_calls": 151686, "avg_eval_calls": 11668.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 151686, "pattern_eval_ns": 3048149, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.095124138021966, "pattern_frame_queries": 151686, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3048149, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.095124138021966, "pattern_frame_updates": 312360, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3461809947, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11082.756905493661, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4507, "avg_candidate_generations": 346.6923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 328814, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.95629021522076, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4494, "search_candidate_moves_total": 327900, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 148636, "avg_legality_checks": 11433.538461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 147722, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 81, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1048601, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 80661.61538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2416419784, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2304.4225439418806, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17156, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1319.6923076923076, "renju_forbidden_ns": 129626990, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7555.781650734437, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 98, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 857071, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17019, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 128516929, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 252990, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.615384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 609111, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10151.85, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 295770, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3521.0714285714284, "stage_move_gen_ns": 356707633, "stage_ordering_ns": 142371, "stage_eval_ns": 3464858096, "stage_threat_ns": 1980817036, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 312373, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1737349108, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 897353, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 156180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 205301831, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 312360, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37268744, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3926, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5863.307692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6478.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1791, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 343, "avg_search_time_ms": 28.583333333333332, "search_nodes": 23229, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 24241, "avg_nodes": 2020.0833333333333, "eval_calls": 21748, "avg_eval_calls": 1812.3333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 21748, "line_shape_eval_ns": 19953546, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 917.4887805775244, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1458, "avg_candidate_generations": 121.5, "candidate_moves_total": 106274, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.89026063100137, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 1446, "search_candidate_moves_total": 105434, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3433, "avg_legality_checks": 286.0833333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3433, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17339, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1444.9166666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 35987173, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2075.5045273660535, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 265331, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10205.038461538461, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 84110, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 181221, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9266797, "stage_ordering_ns": 43570, "stage_eval_ns": 19953546, "stage_threat_ns": 297423839, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 46400, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 263420717, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 196380, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15750, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 23194, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 28422305, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 46388, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5384437, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1321, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6291.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6958.416666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 495, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8951, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 111, 110, 142, 157, 68, 98, 66, 138, 124, 130, 146, 143, 83, 125, 69, 55, 67, 65, 70 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3180, "avg_search_time_ms": 289.09090909090907, "search_nodes": 200083, "safety_nodes": 621, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 200704, "avg_nodes": 18245.81818181818, "eval_calls": 195100, "avg_eval_calls": 17736.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 195100, "line_shape_eval_ns": 169235390, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 867.4289595079447, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4963, "avg_candidate_generations": 451.1818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 394318, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.45154140640742, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 829, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 4952, "search_candidate_moves_total": 393489, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 193386, "avg_legality_checks": 17580.545454545456, "illegal_moves_skipped": 583, "root_legality_checks": 829, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 192557, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 578, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 206474, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18770.363636363636, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 489715508, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2371.8022995631413, "renju_forbidden_checks": 607, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 55.18181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6271294, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10331.621087314663, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 587, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6050443, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 220851, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.3636363636363638, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 304271, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11702.73076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.4545454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 164841, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4337.921052631579, "stage_move_gen_ns": 481866591, "stage_ordering_ns": 142921, "stage_eval_ns": 169235390, "stage_threat_ns": 2512154812, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 400115, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2211193342, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 424361, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 200052, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 252459157, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 400104, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48077952, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 387, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4409, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5640.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6367.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1915, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5758, "avg_search_time_ms": 575.8, "search_nodes": 171183, "safety_nodes": 520, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 171703, "avg_nodes": 17170.3, "eval_calls": 166903, "avg_eval_calls": 16690.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 166903, "pattern_eval_ns": 3356260, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.109045373660148, "pattern_frame_queries": 166903, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3356260, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.109045373660148, "pattern_frame_updates": 342308, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3547056210, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10362.177366582142, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4261, "avg_candidate_generations": 426.1, "candidate_moves_total": 366053, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.90776812954705, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 746, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 4251, "search_candidate_moves_total": 365307, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 12010, "avg_legality_checks": 1201.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 12010, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 835260, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 83526.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1932769078, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2313.9729880516247, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47620, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4762.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 449755072, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9444.667618647627, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 84, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 907289, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 47511, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 448566953, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 280830, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 31897203, "stage_ordering_ns": 139591, "stage_eval_ns": 3550412470, "stage_threat_ns": 2154480615, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 342318, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1895659592, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 119210, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 171154, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 218489897, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 342308, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40211916, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 320, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3740, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5606.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6406.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 496, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11791, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 142, 97, 98, 95, 126, 84, 125, 124, 129, 128, 157, 172, 143, 115, 140, 154, 141, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11355, "avg_search_time_ms": 1135.5, "search_nodes": 286777, "safety_nodes": 77, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 286854, "avg_nodes": 28685.4, "eval_calls": 280191, "avg_eval_calls": 28019.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 280191, "pattern_eval_ns": 5689292, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.305049055822636, "pattern_frame_queries": 280191, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5689292, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.305049055822636, "pattern_frame_updates": 573498, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6941391452, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12103.60184691141, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6568, "avg_candidate_generations": 656.8, "candidate_moves_total": 482207, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.41763093788063, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 6558, "search_candidate_moves_total": 481567, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 274350, "avg_legality_checks": 27435.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 369, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 273710, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 367, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1949029, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 194902.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4696892795, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2409.862959966219, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43956, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4395.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 428474721, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9747.809650559651, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 386, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4001792, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 43560, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 424357289, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 115640, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 682123825, "stage_ordering_ns": 206550, "stage_eval_ns": 6947080744, "stage_threat_ns": 3706719297, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 573508, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3250090448, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 19570, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9590, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 286749, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 386932908, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 573498, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69676371, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 561, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5616, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3251.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4051.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 802, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 427, "avg_search_time_ms": 47.44444444444444, "search_nodes": 29442, "safety_nodes": 751, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 30193, "avg_nodes": 3354.777777777778, "eval_calls": 28087, "avg_eval_calls": 3120.777777777778, "line_shape_eval_calls": 28087, "line_shape_eval_ns": 24522692, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 873.0975896322142, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1338, "avg_candidate_generations": 148.66666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 92259, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.95291479820628, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 573, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 1329, "search_candidate_moves_total": 91686, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 2884, "avg_legality_checks": 320.44444444444446, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2884, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13380, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1486.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28499333, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2129.9949925261585, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.3333333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 155300, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12941.666666666666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53180, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 102120, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8076105, "stage_ordering_ns": 40620, "stage_eval_ns": 24522692, "stage_threat_ns": 382216762, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 58841, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 337096526, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 195262, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9740, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 29416, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 37837375, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 58832, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7087599, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 66, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1208, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5706.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6595.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 497, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10365, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 98, 126, 67, 52, 125, 94, 142, 66, 80, 78, 62, 130, 129, 38, 113, 81, 83, 10, 24, 111, 96, 95, 99, 100, 115, 51, 131 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 2444, "avg_search_time_ms": 162.93333333333334, "search_nodes": 158123, "safety_nodes": 1303, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 159426, "avg_nodes": 10628.4, "eval_calls": 154591, "avg_eval_calls": 10306.066666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 154591, "line_shape_eval_ns": 221712439, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1434.187235996921, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3504, "avg_candidate_generations": 233.6, "candidate_moves_total": 318412, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.87100456621005, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1172, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 3489, "search_candidate_moves_total": 317240, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 151635, "avg_legality_checks": 10109.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1120, "root_legality_checks": 1172, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 150463, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1113, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 169116, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11274.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 364238444, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2153.7787317580833, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1286, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 85.73333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14227970, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11063.740279937792, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1256, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13909930, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 318040, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 577492, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9956.758620689656, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 82, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.466666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 277820, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3388.048780487805, "stage_move_gen_ns": 353002628, "stage_ordering_ns": 116131, "stage_eval_ns": 221712439, "stage_threat_ns": 1839968171, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 316175, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1608926786, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 995755, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 158080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 195117482, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 316160, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34928148, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 319, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3035, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6618.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7151.933333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1911, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 7905, "avg_search_time_ms": 564.6428571428571, "search_nodes": 247810, "safety_nodes": 1095, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 248905, "avg_nodes": 17778.928571428572, "eval_calls": 241308, "avg_eval_calls": 17236.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 241308, "pattern_eval_ns": 4888404, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.25794420408772, "pattern_frame_queries": 241308, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4888404, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.25794420408772, "pattern_frame_updates": 495538, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4781630426, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9649.37184635689, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6475, "avg_candidate_generations": 462.5, "candidate_moves_total": 535273, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.66764478764479, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1092, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 6461, "search_candidate_moves_total": 534181, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 17704, "avg_legality_checks": 1264.5714285714287, "illegal_moves_skipped": 200, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 17704, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 200, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1271614, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 90829.57142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2884730965, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2268.558670319767, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37598, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2685.5714285714284, "renju_forbidden_ns": 376014733, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10000.923799138252, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 201, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2048720, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37350, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 373447990, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 47, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 518023, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 45144952, "stage_ordering_ns": 207882, "stage_eval_ns": 4786518830, "stage_threat_ns": 3032915658, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 495552, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2661603628, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 234310, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14840, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 247769, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 314288280, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 495538, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56789440, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 405, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5832, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6071.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6642.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1925, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 498, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3431, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 126, 129, 98, 84, 99, 96, 130, 114, 83, 100, 67, 52, 115, 51, 131 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2631, "avg_search_time_ms": 292.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 68125, "safety_nodes": 313, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68438, "avg_nodes": 7604.222222222223, "eval_calls": 65117, "avg_eval_calls": 7235.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 65117, "pattern_eval_ns": 1329234, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.413010427384553, "pattern_frame_queries": 65117, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1329234, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.413010427384553, "pattern_frame_updates": 136200, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1593629648, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11700.658208516887, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2992, "avg_candidate_generations": 332.44444444444446, "candidate_moves_total": 199947, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.82720588235294, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 513, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 2983, "search_candidate_moves_total": 199434, "search_candidate_moves_max": 86, "legality_checks": 59726, "avg_legality_checks": 6636.222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 513, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 59213, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 495438, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 55048.666666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1144719390, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2310.519964152931, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6147, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 683.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43573992, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7088.659834065398, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 170980, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6126, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43400142, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2870, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 24, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.6666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 232571, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9690.458333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.888888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 107360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3067.4285714285716, "stage_move_gen_ns": 144854977, "stage_ordering_ns": 102371, "stage_eval_ns": 1594958882, "stage_threat_ns": 877541759, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136209, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 769873264, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 334833, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8671, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68100, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90723207, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136200, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16610455, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 336, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2538, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5499.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6388.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1818, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 790, "avg_search_time_ms": 98.75, "search_nodes": 57585, "safety_nodes": 558, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 58143, "avg_nodes": 7267.875, "eval_calls": 55300, "avg_eval_calls": 6912.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 55300, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44477179, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 804.2889511754069, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2270, "avg_candidate_generations": 283.75, "candidate_moves_total": 145622, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.15066079295154, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 455, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 2262, "search_candidate_moves_total": 145167, "search_candidate_moves_max": 83, "legality_checks": 3941, "avg_legality_checks": 492.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3941, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13138, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1642.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28628238, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2179.0407976861015, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10948944, "stage_ordering_ns": 67200, "stage_eval_ns": 44477179, "stage_threat_ns": 724883510, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 115132, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 639555073, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 173021, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57562, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 71165820, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 115124, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13989596, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 121, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1977, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5309.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6309.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1972, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 499, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18539, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 127, 142, 114, 115, 94, 96, 68, 124, 138, 174, 158, 125, 95, 143, 83, 98, 99, 141, 79, 63, 144, 129, 85, 71, 157, 140, 139, 156, 172, 170, 155, 184, 128, 198 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 4817, "avg_search_time_ms": 267.6111111111111, "search_nodes": 305503, "safety_nodes": 1806, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 307309, "avg_nodes": 17072.722222222223, "eval_calls": 297090, "avg_eval_calls": 16505.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 297090, "line_shape_eval_ns": 375899571, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1265.2717055437747, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8378, "avg_candidate_generations": 465.44444444444446, "candidate_moves_total": 763962, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.18667939842445, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1521, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 8360, "search_candidate_moves_total": 762441, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 287990, "avg_legality_checks": 15999.444444444445, "illegal_moves_skipped": 256, "root_legality_checks": 1521, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 286469, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 255, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 309284, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17182.444444444445, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 710093497, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2295.9270346994995, "renju_forbidden_checks": 260, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 14.444444444444445, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2294636, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8825.523076923077, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 256, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2250535, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 44101, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.2777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 649285, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11004.830508474577, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 88, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.888888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 341762, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3883.659090909091, "stage_move_gen_ns": 689977433, "stage_ordering_ns": 257240, "stage_eval_ns": 375899571, "stage_threat_ns": 3721253735, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 610918, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3261057920, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 49, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 958155, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 305450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 388057198, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 610900, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 71180462, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 396, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7584, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6688.055555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7132.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1891, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 13704, "avg_search_time_ms": 761.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 449430, "safety_nodes": 1578, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 451008, "avg_nodes": 25056.0, "eval_calls": 441258, "avg_eval_calls": 24514.333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 441258, "pattern_eval_ns": 8940313, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.26096524029026, "pattern_frame_queries": 441258, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 8940313, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.26096524029026, "pattern_frame_updates": 898756, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8084723747, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8995.46011041929, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8138, "avg_candidate_generations": 452.1111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 776032, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.35905627918407, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1543, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 8120, "search_candidate_moves_total": 774489, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 21675, "avg_legality_checks": 1204.1666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 21675, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2370525, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 131695.83333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5131327106, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2164.6374140749413, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9508, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 528.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 89204440, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9382.04038704249, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17830, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9501, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 89130800, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55810, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 54824742, "stage_ordering_ns": 262760, "stage_eval_ns": 8093664060, "stage_threat_ns": 5506508555, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 898774, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4820757700, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 49, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 302822, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18060, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 449378, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 580893401, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 898756, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 104554632, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 557, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7254, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6626.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7071.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1970, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 500, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10339, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 141, 128, 80, 143, 158, 83, 98, 115, 116, 99, 67, 144, 160, 129, 159, 84 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9635, "avg_search_time_ms": 963.5, "search_nodes": 238512, "safety_nodes": 77, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 238589, "avg_nodes": 23858.9, "eval_calls": 232225, "avg_eval_calls": 23222.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 232225, "pattern_eval_ns": 4687672, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.185905910216384, "pattern_frame_queries": 232225, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4687672, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.185905910216384, "pattern_frame_updates": 476968, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5993001473, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12564.787308582547, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6269, "avg_candidate_generations": 626.9, "candidate_moves_total": 458131, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.0788004466422, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 6259, "search_candidate_moves_total": 457491, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 223878, "avg_legality_checks": 22387.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 273, "root_legality_checks": 640, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 223238, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 271, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1718744, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 171874.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4106935468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2389.4980683568933, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41286, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4128.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 382649790, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9268.269873564888, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 286, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2464040, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 40990, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 380082579, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 103171, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 550588728, "stage_ordering_ns": 202491, "stage_eval_ns": 5997689145, "stage_threat_ns": 3064619686, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 476978, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2685037900, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 20420, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9530, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 238484, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 321616680, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 476968, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57944686, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 561, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5390, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4281.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5081.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1747, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 693, "avg_search_time_ms": 77.0, "search_nodes": 49030, "safety_nodes": 751, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49781, "avg_nodes": 5531.222222222223, "eval_calls": 47448, "avg_eval_calls": 5272.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 47448, "line_shape_eval_ns": 42339891, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 892.3430070814366, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1565, "avg_candidate_generations": 173.88888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 106519, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.0632587859425, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 573, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 1556, "search_candidate_moves_total": 105946, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 3070, "avg_legality_checks": 341.1111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3070, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13566, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1507.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28827072, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2124.950022114109, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.6666666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 157390, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10492.666666666666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 73510, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 83880, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8638797, "stage_ordering_ns": 46511, "stage_eval_ns": 42339891, "stage_threat_ns": 631558708, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 98017, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 555859895, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 197450, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9610, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 49004, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 63479914, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 98008, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12021449, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 66, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1434, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5668.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6557.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1966, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 501, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5679, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 96, 128, 109, 108, 143, 156, 114, 124, 140, 170, 184, 127, 125, 155, 80, 95, 141, 157, 126, 81, 154, 168, 139, 97, 169, 199, 137, 138, 153, 167, 185, 201, 121 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 2588, "avg_search_time_ms": 143.77777777777777, "search_nodes": 165391, "safety_nodes": 1892, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 167283, "avg_nodes": 9293.5, "eval_calls": 160499, "avg_eval_calls": 8916.611111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 160499, "line_shape_eval_ns": 212790931, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1325.808453635225, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4858, "avg_candidate_generations": 269.8888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 378417, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.89563606422396, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1294, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 4840, "search_candidate_moves_total": 377123, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 155867, "avg_legality_checks": 8659.277777777777, "illegal_moves_skipped": 114, "root_legality_checks": 1294, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 154573, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 113, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 176550, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9808.333333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 389457447, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2205.932863211555, "renju_forbidden_checks": 122, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6.777777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1164424, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9544.459016393443, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 114, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1129514, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 34910, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.222222222222222, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 986894, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8811.55357142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.333333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 453272, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3021.8133333333335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 362982313, "stage_ordering_ns": 153832, "stage_eval_ns": 212790931, "stage_threat_ns": 1981101380, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 330696, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1735239599, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 51, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1385436, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 165339, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 205886880, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 330678, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38589465, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 333, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4333, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6745.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7189.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1901, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 3070, "avg_search_time_ms": 180.58823529411765, "search_nodes": 102035, "safety_nodes": 1189, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 103224, "avg_nodes": 6072.0, "eval_calls": 97883, "avg_eval_calls": 5757.823529411765, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 97883, "pattern_eval_ns": 1938501, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.804266317951022, "pattern_frame_queries": 97883, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1938501, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.804266317951022, "pattern_frame_updates": 203970, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1826846452, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8956.446791194783, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4119, "avg_candidate_generations": 242.2941176470588, "candidate_moves_total": 327949, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.6185967467832, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1234, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 4102, "search_candidate_moves_total": 326715, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 8082, "avg_legality_checks": 475.4117647058824, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8082, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 549892, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32346.58823529412, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1128675417, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2052.5401660689736, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8825, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 519.1176470588235, "renju_forbidden_ns": 72272667, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8189.5373371104815, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 84051, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8804, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72096135, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 92481, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19819595, "stage_ordering_ns": 130960, "stage_eval_ns": 1828784953, "stage_threat_ns": 1192353658, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 203987, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1046735108, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 218941, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17100, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 101985, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 122585330, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 203970, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22814279, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 352, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3533, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6702.058823529412, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7172.64705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1959, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 502, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5082, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 83, 96, 80, 81, 66, 108, 109, 124, 82, 126, 141, 138, 152, 144, 160, 125, 127, 123, 122, 153, 168, 93 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 4797, "avg_search_time_ms": 369.0, "search_nodes": 157343, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 158392, "avg_nodes": 12184.0, "eval_calls": 152809, "avg_eval_calls": 11754.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 152809, "pattern_eval_ns": 2928420, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.163923590887972, "pattern_frame_queries": 152809, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2928420, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.163923590887972, "pattern_frame_updates": 314612, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2887684570, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9178.558255883438, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4510, "avg_candidate_generations": 346.9230769230769, "candidate_moves_total": 329655, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.09423503325942, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4497, "search_candidate_moves_total": 328741, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 149572, "avg_legality_checks": 11505.538461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 87, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 148658, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1077930, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 82917.69230769231, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1987670080, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1843.969534199809, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18419, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1416.8461538461538, "renju_forbidden_ns": 116342753, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6316.45328193713, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 101, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 785965, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18279, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 115299837, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 256951, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.615384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 572704, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9545.066666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 281602, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3352.404761904762, "stage_move_gen_ns": 286814573, "stage_ordering_ns": 145920, "stage_eval_ns": 2890612990, "stage_threat_ns": 1588955984, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 314625, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1384024911, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 844855, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 157306, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 173489551, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 314612, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30596667, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3917, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6094.307692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6709.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1899, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 272, "avg_search_time_ms": 22.666666666666668, "search_nodes": 24281, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 25293, "avg_nodes": 2107.75, "eval_calls": 22792, "avg_eval_calls": 1899.3333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 22792, "line_shape_eval_ns": 16160539, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 709.0443576693576, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1466, "avg_candidate_generations": 122.16666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 106699, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.78240109140519, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 1454, "search_candidate_moves_total": 105859, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3436, "avg_legality_checks": 286.3333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3436, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17342, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1445.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29872023, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1722.5246799677084, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 273540, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10520.76923076923, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 88470, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 185070, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7281890, "stage_ordering_ns": 41590, "stage_eval_ns": 16160539, "stage_threat_ns": 235646679, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 48504, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 207476829, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 160712, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10920, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 24246, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 23653476, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 48492, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4355662, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1328, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6305.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6971.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 503, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4521, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 111, 143, 98, 144, 82, 67, 141, 114, 156, 126, 83, 158, 173, 174, 110, 190 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 516, "avg_search_time_ms": 57.333333333333336, "search_nodes": 31675, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 32204, "avg_nodes": 3578.222222222222, "eval_calls": 30322, "avg_eval_calls": 3369.1111111111113, "line_shape_eval_calls": 30322, "line_shape_eval_ns": 28866261, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 951.9906668425566, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1336, "avg_candidate_generations": 148.44444444444446, "candidate_moves_total": 82093, "avg_candidate_moves": 61.44685628742515, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 468, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 1327, "search_candidate_moves_total": 81625, "search_candidate_moves_max": 85, "legality_checks": 26883, "avg_legality_checks": 2987.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 468, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 26415, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 37260, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4140.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 85913152, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2305.7743424584005, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.888888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 426611, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12188.885714285714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 332601, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 94010, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 525754, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11683.422222222222, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.222222222222222, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 285163, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4387.123076923077, "stage_move_gen_ns": 67322718, "stage_ordering_ns": 45321, "stage_eval_ns": 28866261, "stage_threat_ns": 408213353, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 63307, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 359401569, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 676664, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 31649, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 40532247, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 63298, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7602873, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 146, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1121, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5716.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6605.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1943, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 3998, "avg_search_time_ms": 444.22222222222223, "search_nodes": 100799, "safety_nodes": 564, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 101363, "avg_nodes": 11262.555555555555, "eval_calls": 97998, "avg_eval_calls": 10888.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 97998, "pattern_eval_ns": 1977824, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.182289434478253, "pattern_frame_queries": 97998, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1977824, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.182289434478253, "pattern_frame_updates": 201548, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2674781540, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13271.188699466133, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2785, "avg_candidate_generations": 309.44444444444446, "candidate_moves_total": 179167, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.33285457809694, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 493, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 2776, "search_candidate_moves_total": 178674, "search_candidate_moves_max": 89, "legality_checks": 4577, "avg_legality_checks": 508.55555555555554, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4577, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 760328, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 84480.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1791850651, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2356.6811310381836, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15877, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1764.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 151599361, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9548.363103860931, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 222691, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15841, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 151199910, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 176760, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12856172, "stage_ordering_ns": 88730, "stage_eval_ns": 2676759364, "stage_threat_ns": 1288081361, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 201557, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1131286065, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 185890, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 100774, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 132211467, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 201548, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24397939, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 175, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2457, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5339.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6228.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 504, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2564, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 95, 143, 98, 158, 173, 99, 126, 140, 141, 114, 96, 94, 111, 156, 81 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1868, "avg_search_time_ms": 207.55555555555554, "search_nodes": 45857, "safety_nodes": 600, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 46457, "avg_nodes": 5161.888888888889, "eval_calls": 43607, "avg_eval_calls": 4845.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 43607, "pattern_eval_ns": 876403, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.09775953401977, "pattern_frame_queries": 43607, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 876403, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.09775953401977, "pattern_frame_updates": 91664, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1166201813, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12722.571707540583, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2234, "avg_candidate_generations": 248.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 150445, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.34333034914951, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 498, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 2225, "search_candidate_moves_total": 149947, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 41068, "avg_legality_checks": 4563.111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 28, "root_legality_checks": 498, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 40570, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 376219, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 41802.11111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 875318057, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2326.6184243751645, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5787, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 643.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 25112939, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4339.543632279247, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 74220, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5751, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24981559, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57160, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 31, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.4444444444444446, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 256541, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8275.516129032258, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 37, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.111111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 88061, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2380.027027027027, "stage_move_gen_ns": 100406421, "stage_ordering_ns": 72230, "stage_eval_ns": 1167078216, "stage_threat_ns": 587578071, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 91673, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 515676386, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 393991, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8750, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 45832, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 60613759, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 91664, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10893935, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 163, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1964, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5604.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6493.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1873, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 686, "avg_search_time_ms": 85.75, "search_nodes": 49542, "safety_nodes": 527, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 50069, "avg_nodes": 6258.625, "eval_calls": 47568, "avg_eval_calls": 5946.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 47568, "line_shape_eval_ns": 45682773, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 960.3677472250253, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1959, "avg_candidate_generations": 244.875, "candidate_moves_total": 138500, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.69933639612047, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 446, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 1951, "search_candidate_moves_total": 138054, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 4209, "avg_legality_checks": 526.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4209, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13291, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1661.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29368568, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2209.6582649913476, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64232, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10705.333333333334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20550, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 43682, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11906399, "stage_ordering_ns": 60330, "stage_eval_ns": 45682773, "stage_threat_ns": 621658285, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 99046, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 545769344, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 153371, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 49519, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 64029661, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 99038, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11705909, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 126, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1740, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5423.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6423.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 505, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6041, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 96, 128, 125, 143, 109, 108, 98, 141, 99, 97, 82, 129, 130, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 959, "avg_search_time_ms": 106.55555555555556, "search_nodes": 58366, "safety_nodes": 537, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 58903, "avg_nodes": 6544.777777777777, "eval_calls": 56230, "avg_eval_calls": 6247.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 56230, "line_shape_eval_ns": 45915885, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 816.572736973146, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2119, "avg_candidate_generations": 235.44444444444446, "candidate_moves_total": 127545, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.191127890514394, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 476, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 2110, "search_candidate_moves_total": 127069, "search_candidate_moves_max": 85, "legality_checks": 53123, "avg_legality_checks": 5902.555555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 89, "root_legality_checks": 476, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 52647, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 87, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 63462, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7051.333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 152403605, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2401.493886105071, "renju_forbidden_checks": 98, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.88888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1099744, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11221.877551020409, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 90, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1007664, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 92080, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 522123, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11602.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.222222222222222, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 280220, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4311.076923076923, "stage_move_gen_ns": 135678300, "stage_ordering_ns": 66510, "stage_eval_ns": 45915885, "stage_threat_ns": 765143388, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 116689, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 673248487, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 672744, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9640, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 76647852, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116680, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14574305, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 146, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1864, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5582.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6471.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1931, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5073, "avg_search_time_ms": 563.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 128824, "safety_nodes": 577, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 129401, "avg_nodes": 14377.888888888889, "eval_calls": 125368, "avg_eval_calls": 13929.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 125368, "pattern_eval_ns": 2600915, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.746243060430093, "pattern_frame_queries": 125368, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2600915, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.746243060430093, "pattern_frame_updates": 257598, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3356582934, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13030.314420143013, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3440, "avg_candidate_generations": 382.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 223147, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.86831395348837, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 501, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 3431, "search_candidate_moves_total": 222646, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 5232, "avg_legality_checks": 581.3333333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5232, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 941246, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 104582.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2203895637, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2341.4661385015183, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20673, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2297.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 196096410, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9485.629081410536, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 256970, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20624, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 195606090, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 233350, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14946572, "stage_ordering_ns": 106011, "stage_eval_ns": 3359183849, "stage_threat_ns": 1685770533, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 257607, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1478354797, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 204000, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9020, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128799, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 174670713, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 257598, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32541023, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 178, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2979, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5089.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5978.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 506, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5292, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 80, 128, 125, 129, 130, 140, 97, 83, 98, 99, 95, 65, 108, 109, 94, 96, 66, 52, 122 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4467, "avg_search_time_ms": 406.09090909090907, "search_nodes": 104814, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 105730, "avg_nodes": 9611.818181818182, "eval_calls": 101571, "avg_eval_calls": 9233.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 101571, "pattern_eval_ns": 2126744, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.938496224315994, "pattern_frame_queries": 101571, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2126744, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.938496224315994, "pattern_frame_updates": 209566, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2802425345, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13372.519134783313, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3223, "avg_candidate_generations": 293.0, "candidate_moves_total": 218293, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.72975488675148, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 664, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 3212, "search_candidate_moves_total": 217629, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 98781, "avg_legality_checks": 8980.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "root_legality_checks": 664, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 98117, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 873583, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 79416.63636363637, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2085668358, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2387.4873457931303, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11268, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1024.3636363636363, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61756375, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5480.686457223997, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 549881, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11206, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 61203444, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3050, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.181818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 366021, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7956.978260869565, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 55, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 118730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2158.7272727272725, "stage_move_gen_ns": 249098195, "stage_ordering_ns": 103010, "stage_eval_ns": 2804552089, "stage_threat_ns": 1394829752, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 209577, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1222239540, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 581972, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 104783, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 145471990, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 209566, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26536250, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 177, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2892, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5786.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6513.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1872, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 814, "avg_search_time_ms": 81.4, "search_nodes": 56081, "safety_nodes": 690, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 56771, "avg_nodes": 5677.1, "eval_calls": 53733, "avg_eval_calls": 5373.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 53733, "line_shape_eval_ns": 51468733, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 957.8607745705618, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2329, "avg_candidate_generations": 232.9, "candidate_moves_total": 163307, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.118935165307, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 609, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 2319, "search_candidate_moves_total": 162698, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 6059, "avg_legality_checks": 605.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6059, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17561, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1756.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 39768587, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2264.596947782017, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17021420, "stage_ordering_ns": 73330, "stage_eval_ns": 51468733, "stage_threat_ns": 733400934, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 112114, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 645663326, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 162331, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11030, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56052, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73645927, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 112104, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13929350, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 128, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2111, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5893.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6693.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 507, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4514, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 98, 126, 81, 125, 67, 52, 128, 95, 143, 113, 66, 141, 156, 155, 99, 169 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 536, "avg_search_time_ms": 59.55555555555556, "search_nodes": 32291, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 32820, "avg_nodes": 3646.6666666666665, "eval_calls": 30883, "avg_eval_calls": 3431.4444444444443, "line_shape_eval_calls": 30883, "line_shape_eval_ns": 30681918, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 993.4889097561766, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1391, "avg_candidate_generations": 154.55555555555554, "candidate_moves_total": 85742, "avg_candidate_moves": 61.64054636951833, "candidate_moves_max": 84, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 468, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 1382, "search_candidate_moves_total": 85274, "search_candidate_moves_max": 84, "legality_checks": 27474, "avg_legality_checks": 3052.6666666666665, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 468, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 27006, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 37781, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4197.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 87193662, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2307.870675736481, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.888888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 422983, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12085.228571428572, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 333373, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 89610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 528294, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11739.866666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.222222222222222, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 286522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4408.030769230769, "stage_move_gen_ns": 67943692, "stage_ordering_ns": 48280, "stage_eval_ns": 30681918, "stage_threat_ns": 424681347, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 64539, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 373118111, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 686634, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 32265, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 42832117, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 64530, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8044485, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 146, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1172, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5714.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6603.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1939, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 3970, "avg_search_time_ms": 441.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 101095, "safety_nodes": 564, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 101659, "avg_nodes": 11295.444444444445, "eval_calls": 98245, "avg_eval_calls": 10916.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 98245, "pattern_eval_ns": 2053866, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.90555244541707, "pattern_frame_queries": 98245, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2053866, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.90555244541707, "pattern_frame_updates": 202140, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2616317188, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12943.094825368556, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2834, "avg_candidate_generations": 314.8888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 182128, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.26534932956952, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 493, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 2825, "search_candidate_moves_total": 181635, "search_candidate_moves_max": 86, "legality_checks": 4681, "avg_legality_checks": 520.1111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 19, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4681, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 19, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 752059, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 83562.11111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1759688515, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2339.8277462273572, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17418, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1935.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 162528716, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9331.07796532323, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 191780, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17384, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 162167415, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 169521, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12782512, "stage_ordering_ns": 92001, "stage_eval_ns": 2618371054, "stage_threat_ns": 1316277818, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 202149, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1155779252, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 185662, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8970, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 101070, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 134990531, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 202140, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25322373, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 175, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2485, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5362.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6250.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 508, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2870, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 95, 79, 80, 65, 113, 93, 51, 49, 33, 64, 34, 67, 52, 66, 68, 63 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2223, "avg_search_time_ms": 222.3, "search_nodes": 79400, "safety_nodes": 161, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 79561, "avg_nodes": 7956.1, "eval_calls": 75822, "avg_eval_calls": 7582.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75822, "pattern_eval_ns": 1501253, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.799701933475774, "pattern_frame_queries": 75822, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1501253, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.799701933475774, "pattern_frame_updates": 158744, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1321538724, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8324.968023988307, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3560, "avg_candidate_generations": 356.0, "candidate_moves_total": 246153, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.1441011235955, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 584, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 3550, "search_candidate_moves_total": 245569, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 69421, "avg_legality_checks": 6942.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "root_legality_checks": 584, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 68837, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 562379, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 56237.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 936825981, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1665.826748509457, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9797, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 979.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44411161, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4533.138818005512, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 243891, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9747, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44167270, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 106250, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11805.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 54410, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4185.384615384615, "stage_move_gen_ns": 120792650, "stage_ordering_ns": 123390, "stage_eval_ns": 1323039977, "stage_threat_ns": 750711503, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 158754, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 653384456, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 160720, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8310, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79372, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 82449845, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 158744, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14716482, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 469, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2940, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5821.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6621.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1868, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 639, "avg_search_time_ms": 71.0, "search_nodes": 53579, "safety_nodes": 748, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 54327, "avg_nodes": 6036.333333333333, "eval_calls": 52024, "avg_eval_calls": 5780.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 52024, "line_shape_eval_ns": 39547868, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 760.1850684299554, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1538, "avg_candidate_generations": 170.88888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 102935, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.92782834850455, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 527, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1529, "search_candidate_moves_total": 102408, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 2729, "avg_legality_checks": 303.22222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2729, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12878, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1430.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23817093, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1849.4403634104674, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6933427, "stage_ordering_ns": 47210, "stage_eval_ns": 39547868, "stage_threat_ns": 580088902, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 107115, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 508422085, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 201641, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7880, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 53553, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 60242656, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 107106, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11222520, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 61, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1407, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5688.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6577.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 509, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2808, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 127, 99, 96, 84, 110, 109, 129, 82, 130, 128, 95, 100, 101, 86, 142, 72 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1103, "avg_search_time_ms": 122.55555555555556, "search_nodes": 73652, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 74181, "avg_nodes": 8242.333333333334, "eval_calls": 71215, "avg_eval_calls": 7912.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 71215, "line_shape_eval_ns": 53859192, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 756.289995085305, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2420, "avg_candidate_generations": 268.8888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 144167, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.57314049586777, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 468, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 2411, "search_candidate_moves_total": 143699, "search_candidate_moves_max": 85, "legality_checks": 68929, "avg_legality_checks": 7658.777777777777, "illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "root_legality_checks": 468, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 68461, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 23, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 79306, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8811.777777777777, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 173617362, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2189.2084079388696, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.6666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 375743, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11386.151515151516, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 292543, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 83200, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 528732, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11749.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.222222222222222, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 281482, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4330.492307692308, "stage_move_gen_ns": 158979527, "stage_ordering_ns": 74760, "stage_eval_ns": 53859192, "stage_threat_ns": 879273996, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 147261, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 771755603, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 687744, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8590, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 73626, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 89664161, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 147252, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17166488, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 146, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2116, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5551.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6439.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1951, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1694, "avg_search_time_ms": 188.22222222222223, "search_nodes": 47656, "safety_nodes": 564, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48220, "avg_nodes": 5357.777777777777, "eval_calls": 45594, "avg_eval_calls": 5066.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 45594, "pattern_eval_ns": 959076, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.03513620213186, "pattern_frame_queries": 45594, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 959076, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.03513620213186, "pattern_frame_updates": 95262, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1041974683, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10937.988736327183, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2046, "avg_candidate_generations": 227.33333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 131652, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.34604105571847, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 493, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 2037, "search_candidate_moves_total": 131159, "search_candidate_moves_max": 89, "legality_checks": 4429, "avg_legality_checks": 492.1111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4429, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 287701, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 31966.777777777777, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 678548632, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2358.5202415007248, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5186, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 576.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 48160810, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9286.696876205167, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 75600, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5163, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 47931329, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 153881, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11921389, "stage_ordering_ns": 68800, "stage_eval_ns": 1042933759, "stage_threat_ns": 624129038, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 95271, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 548550083, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 175271, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47631, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 63346884, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 95262, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12056800, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 175, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1757, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5611.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6500.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1991, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 510, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6000, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 82, 66, 81, 80, 128, 52, 94, 64, 48, 65, 63, 110, 109, 95, 125, 50 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5280, "avg_search_time_ms": 528.0, "search_nodes": 138121, "safety_nodes": 161, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 138282, "avg_nodes": 13828.2, "eval_calls": 133267, "avg_eval_calls": 13326.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 133267, "pattern_eval_ns": 2824744, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.19612507222343, "pattern_frame_queries": 133267, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2824744, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.19612507222343, "pattern_frame_updates": 276186, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3130712631, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11335.522550020638, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4836, "avg_candidate_generations": 483.6, "candidate_moves_total": 323800, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.95616211745244, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 584, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 4826, "search_candidate_moves_total": 323216, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 126719, "avg_legality_checks": 12671.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 142, "root_legality_checks": 584, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 126135, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 915250, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 91525.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2179585695, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2381.410210325048, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14357, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1435.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 119252370, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8306.217872814655, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 160, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1499015, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14197, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 117753355, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 103240, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11471.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 52660, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4050.769230769231, "stage_move_gen_ns": 314329918, "stage_ordering_ns": 182340, "stage_eval_ns": 3133537375, "stage_threat_ns": 1807343676, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 276196, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1583420390, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 159021, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 138093, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 189586776, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 276186, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34177489, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 469, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4105, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5236.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6036.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1818, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 711, "avg_search_time_ms": 79.0, "search_nodes": 49005, "safety_nodes": 748, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49753, "avg_nodes": 5528.111111111111, "eval_calls": 47543, "avg_eval_calls": 5282.555555555556, "line_shape_eval_calls": 47543, "line_shape_eval_ns": 47253465, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 993.9100393328144, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1445, "avg_candidate_generations": 160.55555555555554, "candidate_moves_total": 97577, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.5273356401384, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 527, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1436, "search_candidate_moves_total": 97050, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 3032, "avg_legality_checks": 336.8888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3032, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13271, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1474.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29515291, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2224.044231783588, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8698175, "stage_ordering_ns": 46240, "stage_eval_ns": 47253465, "stage_threat_ns": 641458147, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 97967, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 564500180, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 231900, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9690, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48979, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 64657381, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 97958, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12068686, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 61, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1321, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5701.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6589.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 511, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4846, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 113, 141, 96, 140, 82, 67, 143, 110, 158, 128, 81, 156, 171, 170, 114, 184 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 559, "avg_search_time_ms": 62.111111111111114, "search_nodes": 32726, "safety_nodes": 529, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 33255, "avg_nodes": 3695.0, "eval_calls": 31318, "avg_eval_calls": 3479.777777777778, "line_shape_eval_calls": 31318, "line_shape_eval_ns": 31086248, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 992.600038316623, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1391, "avg_candidate_generations": 154.55555555555554, "candidate_moves_total": 86177, "avg_candidate_moves": 61.953271028037385, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 468, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 1382, "search_candidate_moves_total": 85709, "search_candidate_moves_max": 85, "legality_checks": 27884, "avg_legality_checks": 3098.222222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 468, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 27416, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 38261, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4251.222222222223, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 92606429, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2420.3870520895953, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.888888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 423300, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12094.285714285714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 330410, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 92890, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 538843, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11974.288888888888, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.222222222222222, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 288051, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4431.553846153846, "stage_move_gen_ns": 72811752, "stage_ordering_ns": 50660, "stage_eval_ns": 31086248, "stage_threat_ns": 442414443, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 65409, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 388512266, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 703734, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9610, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 32700, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 44990871, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 65400, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8207572, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 146, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1172, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5711.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6600.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1937, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4279, "avg_search_time_ms": 475.44444444444446, "search_nodes": 104056, "safety_nodes": 564, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 104620, "avg_nodes": 11624.444444444445, "eval_calls": 101186, "avg_eval_calls": 11242.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 101186, "pattern_eval_ns": 2142700, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.17585436720495, "pattern_frame_queries": 101186, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2142700, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.17585436720495, "pattern_frame_updates": 208062, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2843874196, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13668.397862175698, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2854, "avg_candidate_generations": 317.1111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 185473, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.98703573931324, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 493, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 2845, "search_candidate_moves_total": 184980, "search_candidate_moves_max": 89, "legality_checks": 4726, "avg_legality_checks": 525.1111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 19, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4726, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 19, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 765479, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 85053.22222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1888244914, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2466.7494653674366, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17894, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1988.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 175796717, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9824.338716888342, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 195381, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17860, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 175433265, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 168071, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13592972, "stage_ordering_ns": 108371, "stage_eval_ns": 2846016896, "stage_threat_ns": 1403070448, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 208071, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1230382981, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 188580, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9130, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 104031, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 146116794, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 208062, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26382093, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 175, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2505, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5316.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6205.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 512, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3960, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 110, 94, 95, 80, 128, 108, 66, 64, 48, 79, 49, 82, 67, 81, 83, 78 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 3165, "avg_search_time_ms": 316.5, "search_nodes": 82428, "safety_nodes": 161, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 82589, "avg_nodes": 8258.9, "eval_calls": 78797, "avg_eval_calls": 7879.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 78797, "pattern_eval_ns": 1672202, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.221645494117798, "pattern_frame_queries": 78797, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1672202, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.221645494117798, "pattern_frame_updates": 164800, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1899504433, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11526.119132281554, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3613, "avg_candidate_generations": 361.3, "candidate_moves_total": 253446, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.14835316911154, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 584, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 3603, "search_candidate_moves_total": 252862, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 72356, "avg_legality_checks": 7235.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 35, "root_legality_checks": 584, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 71772, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 35, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 579357, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 57935.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1371259376, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2366.864258134449, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10001, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1000.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60875362, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6086.927507249275, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 51, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 347711, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9950, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60527651, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 104900, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11655.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 53170, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4090.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 175120523, "stage_ordering_ns": 135281, "stage_eval_ns": 1901176635, "stage_threat_ns": 1065290726, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 164810, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 933155806, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 163020, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 82400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112235315, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 164800, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19736585, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 469, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2992, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5812.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6612.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1863, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 785, "avg_search_time_ms": 87.22222222222223, "search_nodes": 54074, "safety_nodes": 748, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 54822, "avg_nodes": 6091.333333333333, "eval_calls": 52519, "avg_eval_calls": 5835.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 52519, "line_shape_eval_ns": 51673778, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 983.9063576991184, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1538, "avg_candidate_generations": 170.88888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 103503, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.29713914174252, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 527, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1529, "search_candidate_moves_total": 102976, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 2729, "avg_legality_checks": 303.22222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2729, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12968, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1440.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29218559, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2253.1276218383714, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8374685, "stage_ordering_ns": 49610, "stage_eval_ns": 51673778, "stage_threat_ns": 714931480, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 108105, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 627946966, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 226592, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 54048, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73415072, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 108096, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13342850, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 61, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1407, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5686.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6575.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 513, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8908, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 96, 128, 83, 129, 67, 52, 126, 143, 158, 115, 157, 159, 175, 95, 141, 111 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 335, "avg_search_time_ms": 37.22222222222222, "search_nodes": 21624, "safety_nodes": 618, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 22242, "avg_nodes": 2471.3333333333335, "eval_calls": 20559, "avg_eval_calls": 2284.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 20559, "line_shape_eval_ns": 15688200, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 763.0818619582665, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1048, "avg_candidate_generations": 116.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_total": 65159, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.17461832061068, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 506, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 1039, "search_candidate_moves_total": 64653, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 16201, "avg_legality_checks": 1800.111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 81, "root_legality_checks": 506, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 15695, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 70, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26733, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2970.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 59402453, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2222.064601803015, "renju_forbidden_checks": 127, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 14.11111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1251787, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9856.590551181102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 81, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 826373, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 46, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 425414, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7.111111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 689683, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10776.296875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.222222222222221, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 374521, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4070.8804347826085, "stage_move_gen_ns": 40951203, "stage_ordering_ns": 35861, "stage_eval_ns": 15688200, "stage_threat_ns": 266042155, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 43205, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 233499909, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 879963, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 21598, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 26788514, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 43196, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4873769, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 86, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 893, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5714.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6603.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1941, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8565, "avg_search_time_ms": 951.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 93467, "safety_nodes": 205, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 93672, "avg_nodes": 10408.0, "eval_calls": 73885, "avg_eval_calls": 8209.444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73885, "pattern_eval_ns": 1545906, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.923137307978614, "pattern_frame_queries": 73885, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1545906, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.923137307978614, "pattern_frame_updates": 186856, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2401263998, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12850.879811191506, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18299, "avg_candidate_generations": 2033.2222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 1325663, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.44455981201159, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 531, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 18290, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1325132, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 778359, "avg_legality_checks": 86484.33333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12394, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 778359, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12394, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2671971, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 296885.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5034484530, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1884.1838216058484, "renju_forbidden_checks": 66551, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7394.555555555556, "renju_forbidden_ns": 452746507, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6803.000811407793, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12431, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 110627210, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 32182, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 269468191, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21871, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 71973962, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 677144, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 108115, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12012.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1082120112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10008.972963973547, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 158630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17625.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 581996434, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3668.892605434029, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1849768593, "stage_ordering_ns": 492929737, "stage_eval_ns": 2402809904, "stage_threat_ns": 3780929148, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 414172, "root_tactical_annotations": 1658, "search_tactical_annotations": 412514, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 186865, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1009403930, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 357675, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2607179248, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36636, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1254891796, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 93428, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 130860074, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 186856, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21809477, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 124497, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 554951391, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 196535, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 797281141, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 93140, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11676419, "child_limit_applications": 18290, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18290, "child_cap_hits": 18290, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18290, "child_moves_before_total": 1312738, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1312738, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 308783, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 308783, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.77353745215964, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.882613449972663, "tt_hits": 7560, "tt_cutoffs": 1253, "beta_cutoffs": 13645, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4284.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5173.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1840, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 514, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14937, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 83, 99, 127, 82, 69, 111, 66, 114, 67, 68, 54, 129, 144, 115, 55, 41, 53, 130, 146, 116, 117, 52, 84, 85, 39, 24, 81, 25, 95 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 11938, "avg_search_time_ms": 795.8666666666667, "search_nodes": 147940, "safety_nodes": 706, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148646, "avg_nodes": 9909.733333333334, "eval_calls": 109906, "avg_eval_calls": 7327.066666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 109906, "pattern_eval_ns": 2324674, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.151474896729933, "pattern_frame_queries": 109906, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2324674, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.151474896729933, "pattern_frame_updates": 295746, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3199849685, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10819.587365509593, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35816, "avg_candidate_generations": 2387.733333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 2672109, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.60657248157248, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1000, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 35801, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2671109, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 1024629, "avg_legality_checks": 68308.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1805, "root_legality_checks": 1000, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1023629, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1802, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3462326, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 230821.73333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6969708018, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2013.0132223251076, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28607, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1907.1333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 122908226, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4296.438843639668, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1905, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16341959, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12716, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 78711452, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13969, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27708474, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 146341, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 106011, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7067.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 831738741, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7845.777711746894, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 136011, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9067.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 342512665, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2518.271794193117, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2330441241, "stage_ordering_ns": 981865033, "stage_eval_ns": 3202174359, "stage_threat_ns": 5358376047, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 651575, "root_tactical_annotations": 2682, "search_tactical_annotations": 648893, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 295761, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1591564043, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 563817, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3508554392, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 71698, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2276338378, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147873, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 204647521, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 295746, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34159864, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 195258, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 236173818, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 296849, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 995641683, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 159468, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19450227, "child_limit_applications": 35801, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35801, "child_cap_hits": 35801, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35801, "child_moves_before_total": 2669307, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2669307, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 577226, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 577226, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.55956537526885, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.12318091673417, "tt_hits": 14986, "tt_cutoffs": 2166, "beta_cutoffs": 28694, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5364.066666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5897.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1225, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2986, "avg_search_time_ms": 213.28571428571428, "search_nodes": 218414, "safety_nodes": 1034, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 219448, "avg_nodes": 15674.857142857143, "eval_calls": 212778, "avg_eval_calls": 15198.42857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 212778, "line_shape_eval_ns": 271674499, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1276.7978785400746, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5609, "avg_candidate_generations": 400.64285714285717, "candidate_moves_total": 420392, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.94954537350687, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 950, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 5595, "search_candidate_moves_total": 419442, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 11469, "avg_legality_checks": 819.2142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11469, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27192, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1942.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 59525045, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2189.064614592527, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.357142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 323932, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9816.121212121212, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 207082, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 116850, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 30507558, "stage_ordering_ns": 186960, "stage_eval_ns": 271674499, "stage_threat_ns": 2656239949, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 436760, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2322865387, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 271132, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 218373, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 281281278, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 436746, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51822152, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 327, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5063, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6535.642857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7107.071428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1953, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 515, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7256, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 97, 129, 126, 144, 110, 109, 99, 130, 131, 146, 162, 82, 147, 98 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 736, "avg_search_time_ms": 92.0, "search_nodes": 45377, "safety_nodes": 474, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 45851, "avg_nodes": 5731.375, "eval_calls": 43717, "avg_eval_calls": 5464.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 43717, "line_shape_eval_ns": 29519844, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 675.2486218175995, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1645, "avg_candidate_generations": 205.625, "candidate_moves_total": 95796, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.23465045592705, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 425, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 1637, "search_candidate_moves_total": 95371, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 40378, "avg_legality_checks": 5047.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 152, "root_legality_checks": 425, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 39953, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 144, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 49694, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6211.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 119540275, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2405.5273272427253, "renju_forbidden_checks": 186, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 23.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1927569, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10363.274193548386, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 152, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1526818, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 400751, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 462643, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8896.98076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 250813, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3389.364864864865, "stage_move_gen_ns": 106413829, "stage_ordering_ns": 52580, "stage_eval_ns": 29519844, "stage_threat_ns": 592636615, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 90716, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 520011030, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 607004, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7740, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 45354, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 60738686, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 90708, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11279895, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 84, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1460, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5273.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6273.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1927, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6514, "avg_search_time_ms": 814.25, "search_nodes": 66632, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 66832, "avg_nodes": 8354.0, "eval_calls": 51936, "avg_eval_calls": 6492.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51936, "pattern_eval_ns": 1118622, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.538470425138634, "pattern_frame_queries": 51936, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1118622, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.538470425138634, "pattern_frame_updates": 133196, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1910770058, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14345.55135289348, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13697, "avg_candidate_generations": 1712.125, "candidate_moves_total": 962385, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.26246623348179, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 450, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 13689, "search_candidate_moves_total": 961935, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 574160, "avg_legality_checks": 71770.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8393, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 574160, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8393, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1961672, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 245209.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3841208794, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1958.1300003262522, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41768, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5221.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 342714581, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8205.19490997893, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8426, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 80586597, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 213971795, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11152, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 47625867, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 530322, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74835, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9354.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 737100799, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9849.679949221621, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109097, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13637.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 388519147, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3561.226679010422, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1376754682, "stage_ordering_ns": 387033851, "stage_eval_ns": 1911888680, "stage_threat_ns": 2804900310, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 289797, "root_tactical_annotations": 1288, "search_tactical_annotations": 288509, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 133204, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 766173177, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 248365, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1917517104, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27427, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 981457509, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66598, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96211352, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 133196, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16672201, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 78764, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 368098336, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 142168, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 567908479, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 68865, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8326476, "child_limit_applications": 13689, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13689, "child_cap_hits": 13689, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13689, "child_moves_before_total": 953542, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 953542, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 227391, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 227391, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.65753524727884, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.611220688143764, "tt_hits": 5706, "tt_cutoffs": 973, "beta_cutoffs": 10418, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4320.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5320.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1835, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 516, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3693, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 142, 129, 110, 109, 94, 78, 158 ], "move_count": 15, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 3226, "avg_search_time_ms": 537.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 37219, "safety_nodes": 166, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 37385, "avg_nodes": 6230.833333333333, "eval_calls": 28854, "avg_eval_calls": 4809.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 28854, "pattern_eval_ns": 618641, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.440389547376448, "pattern_frame_queries": 28854, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 618641, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.440389547376448, "pattern_frame_updates": 74394, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 973412054, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13084.550555152297, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7892, "avg_candidate_generations": 1315.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 498149, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.120755195134315, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 304, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 7886, "search_candidate_moves_total": 497845, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 203226, "avg_legality_checks": 33871.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 91, "root_legality_checks": 304, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 202922, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 91, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 814495, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 135749.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1904204288, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2337.8956138466165, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5730, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 955.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30002779, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5236.087085514834, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 93, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 864867, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2725, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22485597, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2912, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6652315, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21076, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3512.6666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 216995868, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10295.875308407667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 29638, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4939.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 102183512, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3447.719549227343, "stage_move_gen_ns": 530580021, "stage_ordering_ns": 225415083, "stage_eval_ns": 974030695, "stage_threat_ns": 1481268892, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 80435, "root_tactical_annotations": 701, "search_tactical_annotations": 79734, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 74400, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 462565661, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 77694, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 950538253, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15805, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 665900106, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37197, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 56574235, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 74394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9839064, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 16422, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 41830043, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 45462, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 242653303, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 18551, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1751679, "child_limit_applications": 7886, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 7886, "child_cap_hits": 7886, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 7886, "child_moves_before_total": 497754, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 497754, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 126189, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 126189, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 63.118691351762614, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001648490996704, "tt_hits": 3299, "tt_cutoffs": 457, "beta_cutoffs": 5992, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2977.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4311.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1161, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 7, "search_move_count": 5, "total_time_ms": 462, "avg_search_time_ms": 92.4, "search_nodes": 31495, "safety_nodes": 190, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 31685, "avg_nodes": 6337.0, "eval_calls": 30027, "avg_eval_calls": 6005.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 30027, "line_shape_eval_ns": 22834977, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 760.481466679988, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1459, "avg_candidate_generations": 291.8, "candidate_moves_total": 87552, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.00822481151474, "candidate_moves_max": 78, "root_candidate_generations": 5, "root_candidate_moves_total": 248, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 1454, "search_candidate_moves_total": 87304, "search_candidate_moves_max": 78, "legality_checks": 3197, "avg_legality_checks": 639.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3197, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8853, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1770.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21040053, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2376.6014910199933, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9488525, "stage_ordering_ns": 49601, "stage_eval_ns": 22834977, "stage_threat_ns": 424764106, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 62967, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 373907093, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 55380, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 10, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5620, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 31481, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 42743581, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 62962, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8058052, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 95, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1282, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3780.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5380.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 517, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10396, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 126, 98, 95, 83, 109, 108, 128, 99, 100, 67, 115, 85, 71, 141, 129, 127 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1026, "avg_search_time_ms": 114.0, "search_nodes": 60921, "safety_nodes": 618, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 61539, "avg_nodes": 6837.666666666667, "eval_calls": 58886, "avg_eval_calls": 6542.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58886, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44206372, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 750.7110688448868, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2018, "avg_candidate_generations": 224.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 119271, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.10356788899901, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 506, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 2009, "search_candidate_moves_total": 118765, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 53230, "avg_legality_checks": 5914.444444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 63, "root_legality_checks": 506, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 52724, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 52, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 63762, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7084.666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 158242370, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2481.766098930397, "renju_forbidden_checks": 109, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12.11111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1202709, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11034.02752293578, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 63, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 706976, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 46, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 495733, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7.111111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 750784, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11731.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.222222222222221, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 404463, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4396.336956521739, "stage_move_gen_ns": 140205716, "stage_ordering_ns": 64201, "stage_eval_ns": 44206372, "stage_threat_ns": 825821839, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 121799, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 726916353, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 959904, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9830, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 60895, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 82227781, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 121790, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15717801, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 86, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1783, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5504.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6393.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1914, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9362, "avg_search_time_ms": 1040.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 90121, "safety_nodes": 205, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 90326, "avg_nodes": 10036.222222222223, "eval_calls": 71588, "avg_eval_calls": 7954.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71588, "pattern_eval_ns": 1549367, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.642831200759904, "pattern_frame_queries": 71588, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1549367, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.642831200759904, "pattern_frame_updates": 180164, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2579038790, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14314.950767078884, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17307, "avg_candidate_generations": 1923.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1271820, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.48587276824406, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 531, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 17298, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1271289, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 774277, "avg_legality_checks": 86030.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12363, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 774277, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2591191, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 287910.1111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5584216701, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2155.0772216328323, "renju_forbidden_checks": 52194, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5799.333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 471652808, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9036.533088094417, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16285, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 169857855, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23174, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 233120320, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12668, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 67941777, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 732856, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 103762, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11529.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1164397506, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11221.810547213816, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 152006, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16889.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 597788629, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3932.6646908674657, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2122137469, "stage_ordering_ns": 535459636, "stage_eval_ns": 2580588157, "stage_threat_ns": 4087747355, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 410434, "root_tactical_annotations": 1658, "search_tactical_annotations": 408776, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 180173, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1113916094, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 347359, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2800609679, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34652, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1333581804, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 90082, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 137022895, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 180164, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23798433, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 119436, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 569540583, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 193264, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 897432372, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 97734, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12400254, "child_limit_applications": 17298, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17298, "child_cap_hits": 17298, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17298, "child_moves_before_total": 1258926, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1258926, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 288163, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 288163, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.77870274020118, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.65874667591629, "tt_hits": 7430, "tt_cutoffs": 1196, "beta_cutoffs": 12776, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4195.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5084.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1866, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 518, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5786, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 81, 65, 80, 79, 127, 93, 51, 108, 109, 63, 47, 78, 48, 123 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5258, "avg_search_time_ms": 584.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 64219, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 64377, "avg_nodes": 7153.0, "eval_calls": 46535, "avg_eval_calls": 5170.555555555556, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46535, "pattern_eval_ns": 1004814, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.592650693026755, "pattern_frame_queries": 46535, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1004814, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.592650693026755, "pattern_frame_updates": 128364, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1347387501, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10496.61510236515, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16688, "avg_candidate_generations": 1854.2222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 1124497, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.3835690316395, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 16679, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1123997, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 362105, "avg_legality_checks": 40233.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 177, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 361605, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 176, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1335558, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 148395.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2990374825, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2239.0452717141447, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12497, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1388.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 52153946, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4173.317276146275, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 427, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2300843, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5839, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 36640632, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6226, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13156211, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 56260, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 31269, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3474.3333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 274660241, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8783.787169401005, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40788, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4532.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 116019131, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2844.442752770423, "stage_move_gen_ns": 913223147, "stage_ordering_ns": 458354801, "stage_eval_ns": 1348392315, "stage_threat_ns": 2513493020, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 225222, "root_tactical_annotations": 1636, "search_tactical_annotations": 223586, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 128373, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 774872836, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 199914, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1620850025, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33412, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1207409293, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64182, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 95692654, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128364, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16289865, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70559, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 57746459, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 95935, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 355547852, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 58728, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5787640, "child_limit_applications": 16679, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16679, "child_cap_hits": 16679, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16679, "child_moves_before_total": 1123821, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1123821, "child_moves_before_max": 93, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 93, "child_moves_after_total": 266876, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 266876, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.37939924455902, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00071946759398, "tt_hits": 7724, "tt_cutoffs": 968, "beta_cutoffs": 13634, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4522.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5411.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1251, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 520, "avg_search_time_ms": 65.0, "search_nodes": 35030, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35626, "avg_nodes": 4453.25, "eval_calls": 33821, "avg_eval_calls": 4227.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 33821, "line_shape_eval_ns": 30360545, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 897.6832441382574, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1194, "avg_candidate_generations": 149.25, "candidate_moves_total": 75947, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.607202680067005, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1186, "search_candidate_moves_total": 75500, "search_candidate_moves_max": 88, "legality_checks": 2613, "avg_legality_checks": 326.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2613, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11638, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1454.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26277641, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2257.917253823681, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 76340, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6940.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11270, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 65070, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7645746, "stage_ordering_ns": 38681, "stage_eval_ns": 30360545, "stage_threat_ns": 469803950, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 70022, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 413685269, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 173231, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35007, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 47180800, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 70014, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8764650, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1085, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5413.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6413.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 519, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8586, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 115, 116, 95, 141, 96, 144, 142, 156, 80, 64, 110, 125, 126, 159, 175, 158, 94, 78, 93, 92, 97 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3948, "avg_search_time_ms": 303.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 235968, "safety_nodes": 846, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 236814, "avg_nodes": 18216.46153846154, "eval_calls": 229573, "avg_eval_calls": 17659.46153846154, "line_shape_eval_calls": 229573, "line_shape_eval_ns": 273972816, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1193.4017327821653, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6371, "avg_candidate_generations": 490.0769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 506296, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.46884319573066, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 894, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 6358, "search_candidate_moves_total": 505402, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 219834, "avg_legality_checks": 16910.30769230769, "illegal_moves_skipped": 278, "root_legality_checks": 894, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 218940, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 277, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 235037, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18079.76923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 586500495, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2495.3539017261114, "renju_forbidden_checks": 283, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 21.76923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3371128, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11912.113074204946, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 278, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3320098, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 51030, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.923076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 538243, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10553.78431372549, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.538461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 257631, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3578.2083333333335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 573104054, "stage_ordering_ns": 216442, "stage_eval_ns": 273972816, "stage_threat_ns": 3082054499, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 471875, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2698252573, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 730104, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13970, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 235931, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 324002877, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 471862, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59068945, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 410, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5644, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6265.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6881.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1909, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 4627, "avg_search_time_ms": 385.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 50267, "safety_nodes": 1109, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 51376, "avg_nodes": 4281.333333333333, "eval_calls": 37027, "avg_eval_calls": 3085.5833333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37027, "pattern_eval_ns": 800583, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.62160045372296, "pattern_frame_queries": 37027, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 800583, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.62160045372296, "pattern_frame_updates": 100424, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 956024266, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9519.878375687087, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12419, "avg_candidate_generations": 1034.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 948153, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.34696835494002, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 817, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 12407, "search_candidate_moves_total": 947336, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 411535, "avg_legality_checks": 34294.583333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 292, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 411535, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 292, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1219365, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 101613.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2720349801, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2230.956113222866, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3202, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 266.8333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 17239783, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5384.067145534042, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 298, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3409988, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1062, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9302879, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1837, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4464336, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 62580, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 34581, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2881.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 355005617, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10265.915300309418, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50580, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4215.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 169425401, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3349.6520561486755, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1048096553, "stage_ordering_ns": 420942190, "stage_eval_ns": 956824849, "stage_threat_ns": 2168785722, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 164627, "root_tactical_annotations": 656, "search_tactical_annotations": 163971, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 100436, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 618848216, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 161753, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1457863390, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24893, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 953680789, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50212, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 76297982, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 100424, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12976810, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 34519, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 142381420, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 102333, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 361504779, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 27775, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2799324, "child_limit_applications": 12407, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12407, "child_cap_hits": 12407, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12407, "child_moves_before_total": 947044, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 947044, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 199749, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 199749, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.3314258080116, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.09970178125252, "tt_hits": 4053, "tt_cutoffs": 778, "beta_cutoffs": 9966, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5759.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6426.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1856, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 520, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17940, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 79, 129, 115, 99, 144, 145, 97, 128, 95, 63, 69, 83, 80, 142, 94, 96, 100, 131, 84, 173, 158, 159, 117, 187 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 11234, "avg_search_time_ms": 802.4285714285714, "search_nodes": 148035, "safety_nodes": 406, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148441, "avg_nodes": 10602.92857142857, "eval_calls": 110950, "avg_eval_calls": 7925.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110950, "pattern_eval_ns": 2305710, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.781523208652548, "pattern_frame_queries": 110950, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2305710, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.781523208652548, "pattern_frame_updates": 295946, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2900089894, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9799.388719563703, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35264, "avg_candidate_generations": 2518.8571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 2939771, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.36464950090745, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1010, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 35250, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2938761, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 962300, "avg_legality_checks": 68735.71428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 302, "root_legality_checks": 1010, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 961290, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 302, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3169622, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 226401.57142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6371708953, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2010.2425314438126, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17406, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1243.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50785064, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2917.675743996323, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 358, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1444214, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8065, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35855528, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8983, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13485322, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75170, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5369.285714285715, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 527419480, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7016.355993082347, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92884, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6634.571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 192961929, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2077.4506804185867, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2136312338, "stage_ordering_ns": 1140149411, "stage_eval_ns": 2902395604, "stage_threat_ns": 4994131160, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 542579, "root_tactical_annotations": 3102, "search_tactical_annotations": 539477, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 295960, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1569839162, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 489644, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3174805314, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70589, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2329643354, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147973, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 199631446, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 295946, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33789778, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 179372, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 181218802, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 239672, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 663829897, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 123535, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16065460, "child_limit_applications": 35250, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35250, "child_cap_hits": 35250, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35250, "child_moves_before_total": 2938459, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2938459, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 581136, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 581136, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.3605390070922, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.486127659574468, "tt_hits": 14743, "tt_cutoffs": 1773, "beta_cutoffs": 27998, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5387.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5958.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1017, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 6695, "avg_search_time_ms": 515.0, "search_nodes": 503308, "safety_nodes": 845, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 504153, "avg_nodes": 38781.0, "eval_calls": 491465, "avg_eval_calls": 37805.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 491465, "line_shape_eval_ns": 595861636, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1212.4192689204724, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11818, "avg_candidate_generations": 909.0769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 987659, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.57243188356743, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 937, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 11805, "search_candidate_moves_total": 986722, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 20395, "avg_legality_checks": 1568.8461538461538, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 20395, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 35607, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2739.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 78678063, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2209.6234729126295, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 55595772, "stage_ordering_ns": 357962, "stage_eval_ns": 595861636, "stage_threat_ns": 6012757566, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1006553, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5255140266, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 263112, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 503270, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 639916659, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1006540, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 117437529, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 435, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 10606, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6147.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6763.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 521, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 34765, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 157, 172, 83, 95, 98, 140, 110, 94, 84, 70, 81, 82, 53, 68, 158, 174, 156, 155, 159, 160, 143, 92, 96, 146, 188, 139, 153, 91, 93, 123, 107, 171, 187, 173, 175, 170 ], "move_count": 44, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 17439, "avg_search_time_ms": 871.95, "search_nodes": 1138839, "safety_nodes": 1305, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1140144, "avg_nodes": 57007.2, "eval_calls": 1119962, "avg_eval_calls": 55998.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 1119962, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1595821477, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1424.8889489107667, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18838, "avg_candidate_generations": 941.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1694690, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.96124854018473, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1673, "root_candidate_moves_max": 115, "search_candidate_generations": 18818, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1693017, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 1101168, "avg_legality_checks": 55058.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 492, "root_legality_checks": 1673, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1099495, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 492, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1124184, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 56209.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2491813778, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2216.5533204528797, "renju_forbidden_checks": 533, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 26.65, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5048189, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9471.273921200751, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 533, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5048189, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.95, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 315171, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8081.307692307692, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 164521, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2937.875, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2525692654, "stage_ordering_ns": 591662, "stage_eval_ns": 1595821477, "stage_threat_ns": 13241951220, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 2277580, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 11548098665, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 55, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 456421, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 1138780, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1434465337, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 2277560, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 258930797, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 742, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 17293, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 2.85, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 2.85, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5895.45, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6295.45, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1955, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 17307, "avg_search_time_ms": 865.35, "search_nodes": 146971, "safety_nodes": 1238, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148209, "avg_nodes": 7410.45, "eval_calls": 100850, "avg_eval_calls": 5042.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 100850, "pattern_eval_ns": 2143165, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.251016360932077, "pattern_frame_queries": 100850, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2143165, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.251016360932077, "pattern_frame_updates": 293758, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2420365239, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8239.316849243254, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43132, "avg_candidate_generations": 2156.6, "candidate_moves_total": 4371846, "avg_candidate_moves": 101.3596865436335, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1697, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 43112, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4370149, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 3163241, "avg_legality_checks": 158162.05, "illegal_moves_skipped": 118, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3163241, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 118, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6089579, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 304478.95, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11466008712, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1882.890214906482, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14488, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 724.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 23748492, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1639.1836002208724, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 212, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1567373, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1613, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12585321, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12663, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9595798, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 191462, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9573.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1800884313, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9405.962086471467, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 282298, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14114.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 940773923, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3332.5561038335377, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6812640497, "stage_ordering_ns": 1486033746, "stage_eval_ns": 2422508404, "stage_threat_ns": 6448071491, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1153072, "root_tactical_annotations": 4049, "search_tactical_annotations": 1149023, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 293778, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1498476759, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 977805, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4681888434, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 86355, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2289437810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 146879, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 199474840, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 293758, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32386181, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 488352, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 828053345, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 403083, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1564197698, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 261637, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 35845277, "child_limit_applications": 43112, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43112, "child_cap_hits": 43112, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43112, "child_moves_before_total": 4370031, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4370031, "child_moves_before_max": 135, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 135, "child_moves_after_total": 704380, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 704380, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 101.3646084616812, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.338374466505844, "tt_hits": 20689, "tt_cutoffs": 2917, "beta_cutoffs": 36914, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6616.05, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7016.05, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1786, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 522, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4614, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 97, 127, 126, 143, 159, 113, 158, 79, 95, 83, 110, 98 ], "move_count": 16, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 4218, "avg_search_time_ms": 703.0, "search_nodes": 47556, "safety_nodes": 253, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 47809, "avg_nodes": 7968.166666666667, "eval_calls": 35878, "avg_eval_calls": 5979.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35878, "pattern_eval_ns": 779503, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.72648977089024, "pattern_frame_queries": 35878, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 779503, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.72648977089024, "pattern_frame_updates": 95060, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1002094154, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10541.701598990112, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10920, "avg_candidate_generations": 1820.0, "candidate_moves_total": 691046, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.282600732600734, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 315, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 10914, "search_candidate_moves_total": 690731, "search_candidate_moves_max": 86, "legality_checks": 359700, "avg_legality_checks": 59950.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 95, "root_legality_checks": 315, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 359385, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 94, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1080297, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 180049.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2541362013, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2352.46604683712, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4599, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 766.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15497166, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3369.6816699282454, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 105, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1066794, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1658, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10503938, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2831, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3868554, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57880, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25855, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4309.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 236574930, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9150.064977760589, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 36538, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6089.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 97386777, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2665.3559855492913, "stage_move_gen_ns": 945243087, "stage_ordering_ns": 323774853, "stage_eval_ns": 1002873657, "stage_threat_ns": 1924669987, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 88093, "root_tactical_annotations": 585, "search_tactical_annotations": 87508, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 95066, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 588476391, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 95849, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1251457268, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21866, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 919689498, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47530, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 70580890, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 95060, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12434369, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 9906, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 17961179, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 64072, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 313553400, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 14115, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1721069, "child_limit_applications": 10914, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10914, "child_cap_hits": 10914, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10914, "child_moves_before_total": 690637, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 690637, "child_moves_before_max": 86, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 86, "child_moves_after_total": 174624, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 174624, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 63.279915704599595, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 2807, "tt_cutoffs": 739, "beta_cutoffs": 8566, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1982.3333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3281.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 391, "avg_search_time_ms": 65.16666666666667, "search_nodes": 25919, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 26305, "avg_nodes": 4384.166666666667, "eval_calls": 24929, "avg_eval_calls": 4154.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 24929, "line_shape_eval_ns": 20484337, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 821.7071282442135, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 980, "avg_candidate_generations": 163.33333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 62041, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.30714285714286, "candidate_moves_max": 84, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 327, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 974, "search_candidate_moves_total": 61714, "search_candidate_moves_max": 84, "legality_checks": 1993, "avg_legality_checks": 332.1666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1993, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8900, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1483.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20413500, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2293.6516853932585, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.6666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 184332, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11520.75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 46221, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 138111, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6007679, "stage_ordering_ns": 32070, "stage_eval_ns": 20484337, "stage_threat_ns": 357390151, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 51812, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 314903315, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 131781, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 11, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6210, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 25903, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 35688576, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 51806, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6666479, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 109, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 799, "depth_sum": 16, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 16, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4546.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5880.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1982, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 523, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10512, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 95, 129, 109, 108, 81, 145, 161, 123, 80, 125, 127, 124, 122, 79, 96, 128, 82, 143, 66, 51, 98, 173, 158, 130, 84, 83, 94, 131, 132, 159, 117, 187 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 5416, "avg_search_time_ms": 318.5882352941176, "search_nodes": 331962, "safety_nodes": 1153, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 333115, "avg_nodes": 19595.0, "eval_calls": 323046, "avg_eval_calls": 19002.70588235294, "line_shape_eval_calls": 323046, "line_shape_eval_ns": 539195304, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1669.0976021990675, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8883, "avg_candidate_generations": 522.5294117647059, "candidate_moves_total": 818158, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.10379376336823, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1331, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 8866, "search_candidate_moves_total": 816827, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 322391, "avg_legality_checks": 18964.176470588234, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3053, "root_legality_checks": 1331, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 321060, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3047, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 342050, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20120.58823529412, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 786551504, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2299.5220114018416, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3218, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 189.2941176470588, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4454047, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1384.1041019266625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3193, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4375797, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 78250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.4705882352941178, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 521313, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8835.813559322034, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.352941176470588, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 214332, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2896.3783783783783, "stage_move_gen_ns": 772617496, "stage_ordering_ns": 272070, "stage_eval_ns": 539195304, "stage_threat_ns": 4060270115, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 663841, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3541452591, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 715095, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19610, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 331912, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 438851177, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 663824, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 79251252, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 565, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7635, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6683.64705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7154.235294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1910, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 5078, "avg_search_time_ms": 298.70588235294116, "search_nodes": 42924, "safety_nodes": 2099, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 45023, "avg_nodes": 2648.4117647058824, "eval_calls": 29284, "avg_eval_calls": 1722.5882352941176, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 29284, "pattern_eval_ns": 638235, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.794666029230978, "pattern_frame_queries": 29284, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 638235, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.794666029230978, "pattern_frame_updates": 85694, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 917926600, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10711.67876397414, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13073, "avg_candidate_generations": 769.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1145483, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.62204543716057, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1360, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 13056, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1144123, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 665793, "avg_legality_checks": 39164.294117647056, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1224, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 665793, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1224, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1547369, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 91021.70588235294, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3265787457, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2110.542124729137, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9640, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 567.0588235294117, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31759063, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3294.5086099585064, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1224, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5013382, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3094, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18663167, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5267, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7938533, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 55, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 143981, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 61802, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3635.4117647058824, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 434846318, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7036.120481537814, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 71929, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4231.117647058823, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 125969822, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1751.3078452362747, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1552337535, "stage_ordering_ns": 447474917, "stage_eval_ns": 918564835, "stage_threat_ns": 2112824484, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 259524, "root_tactical_annotations": 807, "search_tactical_annotations": 258717, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 85711, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 535364333, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 235062, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1496682430, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 880727615, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42847, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 64809011, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 85694, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10996091, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 82270, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 202193437, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 126557, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 413248997, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 50697, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4972619, "child_limit_applications": 13056, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13056, "child_cap_hits": 13056, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13056, "child_moves_before_total": 1142899, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1142899, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 222035, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 222035, "child_moves_after_max": 33, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 33, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.5382199754902, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.006357230392158, "tt_hits": 4887, "tt_cutoffs": 507, "beta_cutoffs": 11296, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6610.823529411765, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7081.411764705882, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1882, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 524, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21489, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 129, 109, 95, 81, 65, 125, 127, 79, 80, 50, 64, 96, 66, 63, 94, 52, 143, 159, 157, 171, 141, 67, 142, 172, 144, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 20204, "avg_search_time_ms": 1346.9333333333334, "search_nodes": 271884, "safety_nodes": 85, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 271969, "avg_nodes": 18131.266666666666, "eval_calls": 219230, "avg_eval_calls": 14615.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 219230, "pattern_eval_ns": 4717394, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.51801304565981, "pattern_frame_queries": 219230, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4717394, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.51801304565981, "pattern_frame_updates": 543634, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6197022752, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11399.255293083213, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 50046, "avg_candidate_generations": 3336.4, "candidate_moves_total": 4042975, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.78517763657435, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1029, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 50031, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4041946, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1572421, "avg_legality_checks": 104828.06666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 442, "root_legality_checks": 1029, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1571392, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 442, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5217122, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 347808.13333333336, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11509163901, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2206.036949298866, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29017, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1934.4666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 98926021, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3409.2435813488646, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 889, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5279929, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13382, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 69839389, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14746, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23806703, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 125129, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8341.933333333332, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1015271462, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8113.798256199602, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 155924, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10394.933333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 377609335, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2421.7524883917804, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3834958107, "stage_ordering_ns": 1627351161, "stage_eval_ns": 6201740146, "stage_threat_ns": 8453067687, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 755778, "root_tactical_annotations": 4377, "search_tactical_annotations": 751401, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 543649, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3154841818, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 684595, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4809343750, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 100158, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3257304053, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 271817, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 396770549, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 543634, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69315154, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 223393, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 274583635, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 361030, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1277440722, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 171355, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22796416, "child_limit_applications": 50031, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 50031, "child_cap_hits": 50031, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 50031, "child_moves_before_total": 4041504, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4041504, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 800535, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 800535, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.77999640223062, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000779516699644, "tt_hits": 20938, "tt_cutoffs": 2556, "beta_cutoffs": 35617, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3705.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4238.466666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1031, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 1271, "avg_search_time_ms": 90.78571428571429, "search_nodes": 87641, "safety_nodes": 1198, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 88839, "avg_nodes": 6345.642857142857, "eval_calls": 84375, "avg_eval_calls": 6026.785714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 84375, "line_shape_eval_ns": 130829596, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1550.5729896296295, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3239, "avg_candidate_generations": 231.35714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 270218, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.4263661623958, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 955, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 3225, "search_candidate_moves_total": 269263, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 9676, "avg_legality_checks": 691.1428571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9676, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 25734, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1838.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 57535450, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2235.775627574415, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 25700698, "stage_ordering_ns": 109780, "stage_eval_ns": 130829596, "stage_threat_ns": 1090990457, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 175214, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 956557676, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 311291, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15920, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 87600, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113360549, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 175200, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20760941, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 212, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2841, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6516.928571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7088.357142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 525, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12716, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 155, 169, 51, 84, 81, 111, 66, 36, 69, 98, 126, 114, 125, 100, 101, 128, 123, 124, 156, 144, 129, 68, 171, 186, 139, 187, 107 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 7657, "avg_search_time_ms": 450.4117647058824, "search_nodes": 481124, "safety_nodes": 1153, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 482277, "avg_nodes": 28369.235294117647, "eval_calls": 470120, "avg_eval_calls": 27654.117647058825, "line_shape_eval_calls": 470120, "line_shape_eval_ns": 825525282, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1755.9884327405769, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10971, "avg_candidate_generations": 645.3529411764706, "candidate_moves_total": 1045158, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.26551818430407, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1331, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 10954, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1043827, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 467931, "avg_legality_checks": 27525.352941176472, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2100, "root_legality_checks": 1331, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 466600, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2094, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 487590, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 28681.764705882353, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1072570143, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2199.737777641051, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2175, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 127.94117647058823, "renju_forbidden_ns": 7712367, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3545.9158620689655, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2150, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7639157, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 73210, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.4705882352941178, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 532830, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9031.016949152543, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.352941176470588, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 221120, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2988.108108108108, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1071046665, "stage_ordering_ns": 333090, "stage_eval_ns": 825525282, "stage_threat_ns": 5691777204, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 962165, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4958338163, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 719653, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18800, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 481074, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 617888271, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 962148, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 114831117, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 565, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9309, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6781.823529411765, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7252.411764705882, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1921, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 5044, "avg_search_time_ms": 296.70588235294116, "search_nodes": 42521, "safety_nodes": 2099, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 44620, "avg_nodes": 2624.705882352941, "eval_calls": 28831, "avg_eval_calls": 1695.9411764705883, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 28831, "pattern_eval_ns": 640835, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.227290069716624, "pattern_frame_queries": 28831, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 640835, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.227290069716624, "pattern_frame_updates": 84888, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 877543440, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10337.661860333616, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13046, "avg_candidate_generations": 767.4117647058823, "candidate_moves_total": 1132981, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.84508661658747, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1360, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 13029, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1131621, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 661105, "avg_legality_checks": 38888.529411764706, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1221, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 661105, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1221, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1527653, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 89861.94117647059, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3243267341, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2123.0392903362217, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9473, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 557.2352941176471, "renju_forbidden_ns": 25195879, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2659.757099123826, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1221, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4449886, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2739, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13754627, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5458, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6874505, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 55, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 116861, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 63359, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3727.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 458559972, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7237.487523477327, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74367, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4374.529411764706, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 138202129, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1858.3797786652683, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1555262124, "stage_ordering_ns": 442012684, "stage_eval_ns": 878184275, "stage_threat_ns": 2121131958, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 260564, "root_tactical_annotations": 807, "search_tactical_annotations": 259757, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 84905, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 531896296, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 236422, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1509056269, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26168, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 865594845, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42444, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 63858730, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 84888, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11378238, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 83382, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 220454367, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 126859, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 422491795, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 50323, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4942425, "child_limit_applications": 13029, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13029, "child_cap_hits": 13029, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13029, "child_moves_before_total": 1130400, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1130400, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 222079, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 222079, "child_moves_after_max": 32, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 32, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.76030393737048, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.044976590682325, "tt_hits": 4994, "tt_cutoffs": 584, "beta_cutoffs": 11276, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6607.882352941177, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7078.470588235294, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1865, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 526, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19957, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 84, 97, 98, 70, 114, 66, 81, 80, 129, 99, 130, 146, 131, 132, 127, 128, 115, 52, 85, 83, 145, 100, 160, 175, 126, 140, 94, 67, 117, 69, 68, 55, 41, 111 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 18713, "avg_search_time_ms": 1100.764705882353, "search_nodes": 237523, "safety_nodes": 1033, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 238556, "avg_nodes": 14032.70588235294, "eval_calls": 189347, "avg_eval_calls": 11138.058823529413, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 189347, "pattern_eval_ns": 4139939, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.86429676731081, "pattern_frame_queries": 189347, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4139939, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.86429676731081, "pattern_frame_updates": 474886, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5479149038, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11537.81968303972, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 45647, "avg_candidate_generations": 2685.1176470588234, "candidate_moves_total": 3775221, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.7046903410958, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1274, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 45630, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3773947, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1484805, "avg_legality_checks": 87341.4705882353, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1403, "root_legality_checks": 1274, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1483531, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1403, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4817981, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 283410.64705882355, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10678718109, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2216.430099869634, "renju_forbidden_checks": 49379, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2904.6470588235293, "renju_forbidden_ns": 203184302, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4114.791753579457, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2566, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14832994, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26274, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 142674123, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20536, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45672035, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5150, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 133088, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7828.705882352941, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1129320981, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8485.520715616734, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 166431, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9790.058823529413, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 442965350, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2661.5555395328997, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3630346639, "stage_ordering_ns": 1516657265, "stage_eval_ns": 5483288977, "stage_threat_ns": 7995263262, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 785780, "root_tactical_annotations": 3396, "search_tactical_annotations": 782384, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 474903, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2769572996, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 725632, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4799752338, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 91374, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3106712488, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 237443, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 345136502, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 474886, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59535008, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 256992, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 363042265, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 377251, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1329296973, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 151537, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21266418, "child_limit_applications": 45630, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 45630, "child_cap_hits": 45630, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 45630, "child_moves_before_total": 3772544, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3772544, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 730340, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 730340, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.67683541529695, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.005698005698004, "tt_hits": 17387, "tt_cutoffs": 2466, "beta_cutoffs": 33252, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4142.823529411765, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4613.411764705882, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 340, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 1229, "avg_search_time_ms": 72.29411764705883, "search_nodes": 84504, "safety_nodes": 1554, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 86058, "avg_nodes": 5062.235294117647, "eval_calls": 81020, "avg_eval_calls": 4765.882352941177, "line_shape_eval_calls": 81020, "line_shape_eval_ns": 135223980, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1669.0197482103185, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3452, "avg_candidate_generations": 203.05882352941177, "candidate_moves_total": 309212, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.5747392815759, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 3435, "search_candidate_moves_total": 307910, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 10786, "avg_legality_checks": 634.4705882352941, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10786, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 30242, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1778.9411764705883, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 66500307, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2198.9387937305733, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.1176470588235294, "renju_forbidden_ns": 158871, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8361.631578947368, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 96201, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 62670, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 28501208, "stage_ordering_ns": 130372, "stage_eval_ns": 135223980, "stage_threat_ns": 1034223423, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 168927, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 905605742, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 308950, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84455, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108415284, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 168910, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19893447, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 260, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3063, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6788.882352941177, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7259.470588235294, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1901, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 527, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23755, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 71, 85, 93, 140, 95, 97, 94, 92, 139, 126, 98, 142, 83, 156, 171, 128, 53, 68, 114, 124, 115, 144, 143, 157, 173, 158, 174, 159, 155, 160 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 15823, "avg_search_time_ms": 832.7894736842105, "search_nodes": 961493, "safety_nodes": 1819, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 963312, "avg_nodes": 50700.63157894737, "eval_calls": 946902, "avg_eval_calls": 49836.94736842105, "line_shape_eval_calls": 946902, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1688385207, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1783.0622461458524, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14555, "avg_candidate_generations": 766.0526315789474, "candidate_moves_total": 1355336, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.11824115424253, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1530, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 14536, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1353806, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 943874, "avg_legality_checks": 49677.57894736842, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3317, "root_legality_checks": 1530, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 942344, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3307, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 965916, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 50837.68421052631, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2248399678, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2327.738310577731, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3537, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 186.1578947368421, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13145736, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3716.63443596268, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3488, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13046586, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 49, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 99150, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 110, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.7894736842105265, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 828142, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7528.563636363637, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.947368421052632, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 268241, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2032.128787878788, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2276757171, "stage_ordering_ns": 464992, "stage_eval_ns": 1688385207, "stage_threat_ns": 11784309736, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1922895, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 10264699467, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1181223, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20020, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 961438, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1287276098, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1922876, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 231152948, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 524, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 13453, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.10526315789473684, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6663.0526315789475, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7084.105263157895, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1909, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 7912, "avg_search_time_ms": 439.55555555555554, "search_nodes": 61131, "safety_nodes": 1896, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 63027, "avg_nodes": 3501.5, "eval_calls": 40434, "avg_eval_calls": 2246.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40434, "pattern_eval_ns": 905477, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.3939506356037, "pattern_frame_queries": 40434, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 905477, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.3939506356037, "pattern_frame_updates": 122092, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1273866168, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10433.657962847688, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19629, "avg_candidate_generations": 1090.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1785000, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.93687910744308, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1445, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 19611, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1783555, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1133140, "avg_legality_checks": 62952.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5048, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1133140, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5048, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2505990, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 139221.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5180118026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2067.0944520927856, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20467, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1137.0555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31883298, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1557.7904920115307, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5073, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8405824, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5346, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14841450, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9976, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8486704, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 149320, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 125991, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6999.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 819850264, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6507.212927907549, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 141682, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7871.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 206301327, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1456.0870611651444, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2610421414, "stage_ordering_ns": 681459147, "stage_eval_ns": 1274771645, "stage_threat_ns": 3282655010, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 440354, "root_tactical_annotations": 1261, "search_tactical_annotations": 439093, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 122110, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 752110820, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 395308, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2409421819, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 39343, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1280273059, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61046, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94377420, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 122092, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15764799, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 148760, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 406203819, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 207193, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 722525659, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 84401, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10980152, "child_limit_applications": 19611, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19611, "child_cap_hits": 19611, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19611, "child_moves_before_total": 1778507, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1778507, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 330903, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 330903, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.6892560297792, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.873336392840752, "tt_hits": 7585, "tt_cutoffs": 1001, "beta_cutoffs": 17170, "depth_sum": 85, "avg_depth": 4.722222222222222, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 85, "avg_effective_depth": 4.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6646.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7091.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1865, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 528, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20630, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 141, 85, 125, 109, 97, 139, 95, 80, 154, 140, 78, 94, 79, 66, 63, 47, 108, 71, 99, 93, 67, 70, 83, 69, 51, 35, 115 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 14254, "avg_search_time_ms": 950.2666666666667, "search_nodes": 172966, "safety_nodes": 745, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 173711, "avg_nodes": 11580.733333333334, "eval_calls": 121716, "avg_eval_calls": 8114.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 121716, "pattern_eval_ns": 2633073, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.63292418416642, "pattern_frame_queries": 121716, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2633073, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.63292418416642, "pattern_frame_updates": 345798, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3288202282, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9509.026315941677, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49079, "avg_candidate_generations": 3271.9333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 4445186, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.57205729538092, "candidate_moves_max": 132, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1189, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 49064, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4443997, "search_candidate_moves_max": 132, "legality_checks": 1277156, "avg_legality_checks": 85143.73333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 161, "root_legality_checks": 1189, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1275967, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 161, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3789793, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 252652.86666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7978000781, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2105.1283753492603, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17727, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1181.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 58377566, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3293.1441304225195, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 290, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1884229, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5891, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37720832, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11546, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18772505, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68237, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4549.133333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 510339910, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7478.932397379721, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86253, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5750.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 190323869, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2206.5768031256885, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2844524024, "stage_ordering_ns": 1726880037, "stage_eval_ns": 3290835355, "stage_threat_ns": 6315086504, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 688037, "root_tactical_annotations": 3615, "search_tactical_annotations": 684422, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 345813, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1928349876, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 661397, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4087699016, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 98224, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3146160966, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 172899, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 241401656, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 345798, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40963197, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 249560, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 108005508, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 313600, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 833310431, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 124877, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16672759, "child_limit_applications": 49064, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49064, "child_cap_hits": 49064, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49064, "child_moves_before_total": 4443836, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4443836, "child_moves_before_max": 132, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 132, "child_moves_after_total": 785028, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 785028, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.57223218653188, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0000815261699, "tt_hits": 18749, "tt_cutoffs": 2119, "beta_cutoffs": 41201, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5112.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5645.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1046, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6362, "avg_search_time_ms": 454.42857142857144, "search_nodes": 535513, "safety_nodes": 1011, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 536524, "avg_nodes": 38323.142857142855, "eval_calls": 521220, "avg_eval_calls": 37230.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 521220, "line_shape_eval_ns": 574847376, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1102.888177736848, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14266, "avg_candidate_generations": 1019.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1277218, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.5288097574653, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1101, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 14252, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1276117, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 25351, "avg_legality_checks": 1810.7857142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 25351, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 41735, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2981.0714285714284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 91310801, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2187.871115370792, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 65168722, "stage_ordering_ns": 440693, "stage_eval_ns": 574847376, "stage_threat_ns": 5651710912, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1070958, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4938354983, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 224141, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14970, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 535472, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 602457155, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1070944, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 110674633, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 472, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 13049, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6284.357142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6855.785714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 529, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14191, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 98, 83, 115, 116, 69, 125, 139, 126, 129, 141, 84, 99, 70, 56, 96, 157, 109, 158, 82, 127, 130, 124 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 1738, "avg_search_time_ms": 144.83333333333334, "search_nodes": 105238, "safety_nodes": 1052, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 106290, "avg_nodes": 8857.5, "eval_calls": 102119, "avg_eval_calls": 8509.916666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 102119, "line_shape_eval_ns": 111456454, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1091.4369901781256, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3096, "avg_candidate_generations": 258.0, "candidate_moves_total": 227180, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.37855297157623, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 834, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 3084, "search_candidate_moves_total": 226346, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 90741, "avg_legality_checks": 7561.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 130, "root_legality_checks": 834, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 89907, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 127, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 105039, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8753.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 257072865, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2447.403964241853, "renju_forbidden_checks": 144, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1665317, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11564.701388888889, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 130, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1524386, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 140931, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 843126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11710.083333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.583333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 442244, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4293.631067961165, "stage_move_gen_ns": 234851011, "stage_ordering_ns": 107191, "stage_eval_ns": 111456454, "stage_threat_ns": 1374268724, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 210418, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1207168910, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1102916, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 105203, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 139754227, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 210406, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26242671, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 198, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2783, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6123.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6790.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1910, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 12440, "avg_search_time_ms": 1036.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 131780, "safety_nodes": 551, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 132331, "avg_nodes": 11027.583333333334, "eval_calls": 104476, "avg_eval_calls": 8706.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 104476, "pattern_eval_ns": 2276407, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.788803170106053, "pattern_frame_queries": 104476, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2276407, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.788803170106053, "pattern_frame_updates": 263452, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2849413103, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10815.682184990055, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25584, "avg_candidate_generations": 2132.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2193814, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.74945278298937, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 854, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 25572, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2192960, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1339152, "avg_legality_checks": 111596.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7815, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1339152, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7815, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3478809, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 289900.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7447297075, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2140.7605519590184, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44232, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3686.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 385896206, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8724.367109784771, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7881, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 89430653, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22476, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 233201771, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13845, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 62908430, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 355352, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 121871, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10155.916666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1279213980, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10496.459206866277, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 174836, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14569.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 645336171, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3691.094345558123, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3373468908, "stage_ordering_ns": 898317677, "stage_eval_ns": 2851689510, "stage_threat_ns": 5252424916, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 471233, "root_tactical_annotations": 2200, "search_tactical_annotations": 469033, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 263464, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1551017350, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 411856, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3457918464, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51221, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1839562931, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 131726, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 194290878, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 263452, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33290486, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 148464, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 671951602, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 212163, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 946303560, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110606, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15907738, "child_limit_applications": 25572, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25572, "child_cap_hits": 25572, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25572, "child_moves_before_total": 2185145, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2185145, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 412222, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 412222, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.45068825277647, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.12005318316909, "tt_hits": 10935, "tt_cutoffs": 1678, "beta_cutoffs": 18690, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5295.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5962.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1873, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 530, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13675, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 125, 115, 127, 99, 123, 83, 67, 98, 100, 53, 95, 84, 110, 69, 55, 68, 38, 54, 39, 131, 147, 80, 71, 82, 81, 109, 87, 23, 103 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 11310, "avg_search_time_ms": 706.875, "search_nodes": 129397, "safety_nodes": 990, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 130387, "avg_nodes": 8149.1875, "eval_calls": 96808, "avg_eval_calls": 6050.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 96808, "pattern_eval_ns": 2118859, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.8872303941823, "pattern_frame_queries": 96808, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2118859, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.8872303941823, "pattern_frame_updates": 258650, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2659205216, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10281.094977769186, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30921, "avg_candidate_generations": 1932.5625, "candidate_moves_total": 2481574, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.2552957536949, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1205, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 30905, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2480369, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1033927, "avg_legality_checks": 64620.4375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 79, "root_legality_checks": 1205, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1032722, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 79, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2928107, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 183006.6875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6627115562, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2263.2764314965266, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30729, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1920.5625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 73153662, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2380.6066582056037, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 875, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2903065, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7648, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33771104, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22200, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36466803, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 12690, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73611, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4600.6875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 648747167, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8813.182364048851, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 94763, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5922.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 265669602, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2803.5161613709993, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2599193637, "stage_ordering_ns": 1032845697, "stage_eval_ns": 2661324075, "stage_threat_ns": 4950632092, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 420006, "root_tactical_annotations": 2297, "search_tactical_annotations": 417709, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 258666, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1530320666, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 389652, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3187250528, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61913, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2223470414, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129325, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 187334628, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 258650, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32616981, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116307, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 142894581, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 211422, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 820623940, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 92277, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13109289, "child_limit_applications": 30905, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30905, "child_cap_hits": 30905, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30905, "child_moves_before_total": 2480290, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2480290, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 494949, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 494949, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.2552984953891, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.015175537938845, "tt_hits": 11990, "tt_cutoffs": 1612, "beta_cutoffs": 24581, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5169.4375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5669.4375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1041, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 2352, "avg_search_time_ms": 156.8, "search_nodes": 165573, "safety_nodes": 1301, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 166874, "avg_nodes": 11124.933333333332, "eval_calls": 160747, "avg_eval_calls": 10716.466666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 160747, "line_shape_eval_ns": 206342349, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1283.6466559251494, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4797, "avg_candidate_generations": 319.8, "candidate_moves_total": 396366, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.62789243277048, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1144, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 4782, "search_candidate_moves_total": 395222, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 10789, "avg_legality_checks": 719.2666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10789, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 28011, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1867.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 63726451, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2275.0509085716326, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 29991658, "stage_ordering_ns": 172150, "stage_eval_ns": 206342349, "stage_threat_ns": 2092701153, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 331073, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1833251267, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 355401, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 165529, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 218663998, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 331058, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40430487, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 422, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4159, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6609.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7142.466666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 531, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15870, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 81, 129, 96, 130, 131, 157, 172, 141, 95, 98, 109, 67, 51, 66, 65, 49, 93, 94, 79, 37, 107 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 2104, "avg_search_time_ms": 175.33333333333334, "search_nodes": 120705, "safety_nodes": 1191, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 121896, "avg_nodes": 10158.0, "eval_calls": 117496, "avg_eval_calls": 9791.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 117496, "line_shape_eval_ns": 84191029, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 716.5437887247225, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3186, "avg_candidate_generations": 265.5, "candidate_moves_total": 205976, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.65034526051475, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 835, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 3174, "search_candidate_moves_total": 205141, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 116405, "avg_legality_checks": 9700.416666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 37, "root_legality_checks": 835, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 115570, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 29, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 130551, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10879.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 341252731, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2613.9419154200273, "renju_forbidden_checks": 69, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 810951, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11752.91304347826, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 439241, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 371710, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 786954, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11572.85294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 409312, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4449.04347826087, "stage_move_gen_ns": 319726355, "stage_ordering_ns": 100930, "stage_eval_ns": 84191029, "stage_threat_ns": 1685082075, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 241352, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1487107759, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 999184, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 120670, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 165340787, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 241340, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31634345, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 113, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2968, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5902.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6569.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1922, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 13754, "avg_search_time_ms": 1146.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 122410, "safety_nodes": 299, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122709, "avg_nodes": 10225.75, "eval_calls": 93205, "avg_eval_calls": 7767.083333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 93205, "pattern_eval_ns": 2032634, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.808207714178423, "pattern_frame_queries": 93205, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2032634, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.808207714178423, "pattern_frame_updates": 244716, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2756388178, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11263.620596936857, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27592, "avg_candidate_generations": 2299.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2336549, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.68211800521891, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 858, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 27580, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2335691, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1565902, "avg_legality_checks": 130491.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17820, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1565902, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17820, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3919508, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 326625.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8396088959, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2142.1282872748316, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65619, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5468.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 535888696, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8166.669653606425, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17820, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 189857360, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26185, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 271780700, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21564, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 73686795, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 563841, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 167894, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13991.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1746961677, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10405.146562712187, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 236766, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19730.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 862646707, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3643.456860360018, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4037182839, "stage_ordering_ns": 981457718, "stage_eval_ns": 2758420812, "stage_threat_ns": 5883322505, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 575806, "root_tactical_annotations": 2626, "search_tactical_annotations": 573180, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 244728, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1484836013, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 483686, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4160432485, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 55235, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2034979044, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 122358, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 183811277, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 244716, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31994085, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 198815, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1076898899, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 229627, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1048496792, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 147364, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22248645, "child_limit_applications": 27580, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27580, "child_cap_hits": 27580, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27580, "child_moves_before_total": 2317871, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2317871, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 449053, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 449053, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.04173313995649, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.28183466279913, "tt_hits": 12502, "tt_cutoffs": 1573, "beta_cutoffs": 21536, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5131.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5797.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1625, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 532, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4654, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 97, 127, 128, 141, 155, 111, 156, 85, 99, 81, 114, 96 ], "move_count": 16, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 4240, "avg_search_time_ms": 706.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 48829, "safety_nodes": 253, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49082, "avg_nodes": 8180.333333333333, "eval_calls": 36823, "avg_eval_calls": 6137.166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36823, "pattern_eval_ns": 744584, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.22062298020259, "pattern_frame_queries": 36823, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 744584, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.22062298020259, "pattern_frame_updates": 97606, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 999010618, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10235.135319550027, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11257, "avg_candidate_generations": 1876.1666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 716082, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.612152438482724, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 315, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 11251, "search_candidate_moves_total": 715767, "search_candidate_moves_max": 86, "legality_checks": 399159, "avg_legality_checks": 66526.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 103, "root_legality_checks": 315, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 398844, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 102, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1166250, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 194375.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2586588561, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2217.8680051446945, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5111, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 851.8333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18256681, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3572.0369790647624, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 111, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1087765, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1770, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12609229, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3225, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4502317, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57370, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 30204, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5034.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 261011993, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8641.636637531452, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 42826, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7137.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 107803152, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2517.236071545323, "stage_move_gen_ns": 992809073, "stage_ordering_ns": 317599496, "stage_eval_ns": 999755202, "stage_threat_ns": 1908668665, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 89467, "root_tactical_annotations": 585, "search_tactical_annotations": 88882, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 97612, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 570073660, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 98226, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1256648474, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22540, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 901612162, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48803, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68295327, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 97606, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11990906, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 9281, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 15649599, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 66400, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 339151573, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 13786, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1660298, "child_limit_applications": 11251, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11251, "child_cap_hits": 11251, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11251, "child_moves_before_total": 715665, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 715665, "child_moves_before_max": 86, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 86, "child_moves_after_total": 180016, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 180016, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 63.60901253221936, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 2892, "tt_cutoffs": 730, "beta_cutoffs": 8873, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1967.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3264.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 408, "avg_search_time_ms": 68.0, "search_nodes": 29110, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 29496, "avg_nodes": 4916.0, "eval_calls": 28030, "avg_eval_calls": 4671.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 28030, "line_shape_eval_ns": 21460920, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 765.64109882269, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1070, "avg_candidate_generations": 178.33333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 67833, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.39532710280374, "candidate_moves_max": 84, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 327, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 1064, "search_candidate_moves_total": 67506, "search_candidate_moves_max": 84, "legality_checks": 2087, "avg_legality_checks": 347.8333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2087, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8994, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1499.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19313591, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2147.3861463197686, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.6666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 182600, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11412.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 49100, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 133500, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5967894, "stage_ordering_ns": 33141, "stage_eval_ns": 21460920, "stage_threat_ns": 374399426, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 58194, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 330412924, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 118791, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 11, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5440, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 29094, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 36792771, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 58188, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7074940, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 109, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 874, "depth_sum": 16, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 16, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4537.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5871.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1982, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 533, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12412, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 81, 143, 67, 52, 95, 159, 175, 53, 80, 83, 113, 68, 38, 65, 96, 128, 110, 129, 94, 93, 126, 131, 130, 158, 140, 125, 66, 173, 188, 145, 187, 117 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 7267, "avg_search_time_ms": 427.47058823529414, "search_nodes": 452727, "safety_nodes": 1153, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 453880, "avg_nodes": 26698.823529411766, "eval_calls": 441661, "avg_eval_calls": 25980.058823529413, "line_shape_eval_calls": 441661, "line_shape_eval_ns": 779572516, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1765.0924940169043, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11033, "avg_candidate_generations": 649.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1052209, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.36925586875736, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1331, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 11016, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1050878, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 439081, "avg_legality_checks": 25828.29411764706, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1635, "root_legality_checks": 1331, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 437750, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1629, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 458740, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26984.70588235294, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1011920006, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2205.8682608885206, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1690, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 99.41176470588235, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6688619, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3957.7627218934913, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1665, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6616959, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 71660, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.4705882352941178, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 535113, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9069.71186440678, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.352941176470588, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 220132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2974.7567567567567, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1008435172, "stage_ordering_ns": 333780, "stage_eval_ns": 779572516, "stage_threat_ns": 5455520045, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 905371, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4717486006, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 725754, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 452677, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 631939015, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 905354, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 105369270, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 565, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9809, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6785.294117647059, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7255.882352941177, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1920, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 5129, "avg_search_time_ms": 301.70588235294116, "search_nodes": 43164, "safety_nodes": 2099, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 45263, "avg_nodes": 2662.529411764706, "eval_calls": 29224, "avg_eval_calls": 1719.0588235294117, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 29224, "pattern_eval_ns": 638513, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.848925540651518, "pattern_frame_queries": 29224, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 638513, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.848925540651518, "pattern_frame_updates": 86174, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 905370706, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10506.309397265997, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13292, "avg_candidate_generations": 781.8823529411765, "candidate_moves_total": 1153856, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.80830574781824, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1360, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 13275, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1152496, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 678938, "avg_legality_checks": 39937.529411764706, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1340, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 678938, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1340, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1569701, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 92335.35294117648, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3298942217, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2101.6373290199854, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10409, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 612.2941176470588, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31473837, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3023.7138053607455, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1340, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5090361, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3202, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18272332, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5812, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7996913, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 55, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 114231, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65196, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3835.0588235294117, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 465171807, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7134.974645683785, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76476, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4498.588235294118, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 138586781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1812.1604294157644, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1583704013, "stage_ordering_ns": 443817884, "stage_eval_ns": 906009219, "stage_threat_ns": 2149403585, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 266290, "root_tactical_annotations": 807, "search_tactical_annotations": 265483, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 86191, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 538530665, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 242419, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1527923499, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26660, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 873133836, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43087, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 66601635, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 86174, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11168328, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 84335, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 216700708, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 131411, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 437569230, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 50544, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5179458, "child_limit_applications": 13275, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13275, "child_cap_hits": 13275, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13275, "child_moves_before_total": 1151156, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1151156, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 226044, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 226044, "child_moves_after_max": 32, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 32, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.71608286252354, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.027796610169492, "tt_hits": 4991, "tt_cutoffs": 588, "beta_cutoffs": 11498, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6607.117647058823, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7077.705882352941, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1850, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 534, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9611, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 127, 97, 96, 83, 69, 113, 68, 125, 139, 128, 143, 110, 67, 70, 84, 95, 54, 40, 39, 99, 24 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8518, "avg_search_time_ms": 774.3636363636364, "search_nodes": 100984, "safety_nodes": 693, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 101677, "avg_nodes": 9243.363636363636, "eval_calls": 79338, "avg_eval_calls": 7212.545454545455, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79338, "pattern_eval_ns": 1737878, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.90473669616073, "pattern_frame_queries": 79338, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1737878, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.90473669616073, "pattern_frame_updates": 201874, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2386429232, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11821.379830983682, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20280, "avg_candidate_generations": 1843.6363636363637, "candidate_moves_total": 1445995, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.30152859960552, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 677, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 20269, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1445318, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 721776, "avg_legality_checks": 65616.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 148, "root_legality_checks": 677, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 721099, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 148, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2266029, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 206002.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5119050079, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2259.039967714447, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13076, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1188.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 40575726, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3103.068675435913, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 253, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1650872, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5671, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29619951, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7150, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9302473, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2430, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 61241, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5567.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 544109277, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8884.72227755915, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84239, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7658.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 229002714, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2718.488039981481, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1837390926, "stage_ordering_ns": 614658996, "stage_eval_ns": 2388167110, "stage_threat_ns": 3639906016, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 270105, "root_tactical_annotations": 1194, "search_tactical_annotations": 268911, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 201885, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1195363868, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 264555, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2258068252, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40606, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1475411473, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 100937, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 155170659, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 201874, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25312253, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 65030, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 69631388, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 158911, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 712507628, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 46164, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5990984, "child_limit_applications": 20269, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20269, "child_cap_hits": 20269, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20269, "child_moves_before_total": 1445170, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1445170, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 324320, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 324320, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.2995214366767, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000789382801322, "tt_hits": 6470, "tt_cutoffs": 1331, "beta_cutoffs": 15152, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4767.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5495.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 1080, "avg_search_time_ms": 108.0, "search_nodes": 72666, "safety_nodes": 742, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 73408, "avg_nodes": 7340.8, "eval_calls": 70400, "avg_eval_calls": 7040.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 70400, "line_shape_eval_ns": 72059540, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1023.5730113636364, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2247, "avg_candidate_generations": 224.7, "candidate_moves_total": 157538, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.11036938139742, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 623, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 2237, "search_candidate_moves_total": 156915, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 4467, "avg_legality_checks": 446.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4467, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16070, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1607.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 36735207, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2285.949408836341, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13021560, "stage_ordering_ns": 77340, "stage_eval_ns": 72059540, "stage_threat_ns": 985489585, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 145284, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 866158094, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 231171, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72637, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99757937, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 145274, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19342383, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 186, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1949, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5880.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6680.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1982, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 535, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19182, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 140, 97, 100, 114, 141, 84, 70, 143, 139, 138, 55, 115, 113, 99, 129, 83, 131, 130, 82, 96, 95, 111, 125, 110, 109, 124, 152, 67, 51, 66, 81, 146, 162, 69, 54, 68, 65, 53, 38, 86, 93, 157, 77 ], "move_count": 48, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 5491, "avg_search_time_ms": 249.5909090909091, "search_nodes": 330175, "safety_nodes": 2570, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 332745, "avg_nodes": 15124.772727272728, "eval_calls": 321876, "avg_eval_calls": 14630.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 321876, "line_shape_eval_ns": 570039870, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1770.9921522573911, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8256, "avg_candidate_generations": 375.27272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 746516, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.42102713178295, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1815, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 8234, "search_candidate_moves_total": 744701, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 313014, "avg_legality_checks": 14227.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1009, "root_legality_checks": 1815, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 311199, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1000, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 338434, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15383.363636363636, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 787398966, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2326.595336165988, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1473, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 66.95454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14920595, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10129.39239646979, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1429, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14421883, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 498712, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 104, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 998036, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9596.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 445815, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3377.3863636363635, "stage_move_gen_ns": 772400655, "stage_ordering_ns": 281112, "stage_eval_ns": 570039870, "stage_threat_ns": 4112891843, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 660242, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3579676288, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1503529, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 23920, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 330110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 444518310, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 660220, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 87193716, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 500, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7263, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 2.9545454545454546, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.045454545454545456, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7037.863636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7401.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1906, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 13667, "avg_search_time_ms": 621.2272727272727, "search_nodes": 121783, "safety_nodes": 1653, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 123436, "avg_nodes": 5610.727272727273, "eval_calls": 88240, "avg_eval_calls": 4010.909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 88240, "pattern_eval_ns": 1944863, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.040605167724387, "pattern_frame_queries": 88240, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1944863, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.040605167724387, "pattern_frame_updates": 243358, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2930779659, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12043.079163208113, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31409, "avg_candidate_generations": 1427.6818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2713066, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.37861759368334, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1829, "root_candidate_moves_max": 115, "search_candidate_generations": 31387, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2711237, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 1628341, "avg_legality_checks": 74015.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11247, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1628341, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11247, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3881865, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 176448.4090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8398950622, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2163.637999260665, "renju_forbidden_checks": 92685, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4212.954545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 547701962, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5909.283724443006, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 20395, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 128135102, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34884, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 303696975, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37344, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 115177157, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 62, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 692728, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 132596, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6027.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1229251298, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9270.651437449094, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 172332, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7833.272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 524092692, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3041.18034955783, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4024968251, "stage_ordering_ns": 1070528528, "stage_eval_ns": 2932724522, "stage_threat_ns": 5551559716, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 653182, "root_tactical_annotations": 2570, "search_tactical_annotations": 650612, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 243380, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1455917614, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 583975, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3862658849, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62921, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2197222973, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121679, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184505450, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 243358, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31553143, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 232697, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 617797999, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 288345, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1047346307, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 132140, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16924660, "child_limit_applications": 31387, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31387, "child_cap_hits": 31387, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31387, "child_moves_before_total": 2699990, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2699990, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 503970, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 503970, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.02255710963138, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.056647656673146, "tt_hits": 12738, "tt_cutoffs": 2052, "beta_cutoffs": 25621, "depth_sum": 104, "avg_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 104, "avg_effective_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6137.045454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6500.681818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1755, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 536, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8443, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 114, 127, 113, 111, 126, 84, 130, 82, 85, 95, 115, 116, 100, 70, 145 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7691, "avg_search_time_ms": 961.375, "search_nodes": 94191, "safety_nodes": 343, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 94534, "avg_nodes": 11816.75, "eval_calls": 76057, "avg_eval_calls": 9507.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 76057, "pattern_eval_ns": 1633731, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.480350263618075, "pattern_frame_queries": 76057, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1633731, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.480350263618075, "pattern_frame_updates": 188318, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2417750527, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12838.65868902601, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17066, "avg_candidate_generations": 2133.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1158720, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.89640220321107, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 458, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 17058, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1158262, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 536204, "avg_legality_checks": 67025.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 155, "root_legality_checks": 458, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 535746, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 155, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2004876, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 250609.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4535360779, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2262.1652306676324, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13727, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1715.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 67375761, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4908.2655350768555, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 246, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1851937, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6956, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 55312672, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6522, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10205462, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5690, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58862, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7357.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 530356065, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9010.160460059122, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 77540, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9692.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 223372516, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2880.739179778179, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1348951728, "stage_ordering_ns": 518828256, "stage_eval_ns": 2419384258, "stage_threat_ns": 3375561033, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 220830, "root_tactical_annotations": 1290, "search_tactical_annotations": 219540, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 188326, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1110677322, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 205614, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2095679762, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34163, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1379076244, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 94159, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 139146082, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 188318, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24032913, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 47175, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 126110223, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 124269, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 590307154, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49386, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6024954, "child_limit_applications": 17058, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17058, "child_cap_hits": 17058, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17058, "child_moves_before_total": 1158107, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1158107, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 273118, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 273118, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.89230859420799, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.011138468753664, "tt_hits": 6697, "tt_cutoffs": 1044, "beta_cutoffs": 12033, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2153.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3153.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 258, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 746, "avg_search_time_ms": 106.57142857142857, "search_nodes": 54177, "safety_nodes": 429, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 54606, "avg_nodes": 7800.857142857143, "eval_calls": 52560, "avg_eval_calls": 7508.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 52560, "line_shape_eval_ns": 45924452, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 873.7528919330289, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1604, "avg_candidate_generations": 229.14285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 109904, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.51870324189527, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 393, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 1597, "search_candidate_moves_total": 109511, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 4659, "avg_legality_checks": 665.5714285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4659, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12701, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1814.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26168007, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2060.3107629320525, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10768990, "stage_ordering_ns": 55280, "stage_eval_ns": 45924452, "stage_threat_ns": 681236491, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 108321, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 596557825, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 159741, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7270, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 54157, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 70397575, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 108314, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14121350, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 115, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1416, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5028.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6171.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1837, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 537, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 41799, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 97, 95, 125, 142, 94, 111, 67, 127, 82, 52, 79, 143, 159, 144, 141, 158, 174, 130, 116, 157, 172, 171, 129, 145, 146, 160, 175, 85, 131, 101, 109, 185, 199, 64, 93, 77, 124, 139, 65, 107, 81, 113, 51, 37, 173, 176, 83, 100, 115, 71, 66, 99 ], "move_count": 58, "black_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 14767, "avg_search_time_ms": 546.925925925926, "search_nodes": 871720, "safety_nodes": 1562, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 873282, "avg_nodes": 32343.777777777777, "eval_calls": 853540, "avg_eval_calls": 31612.59259259259, "line_shape_eval_calls": 853540, "line_shape_eval_ns": 2071366041, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 2426.794340042646, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18127, "avg_candidate_generations": 671.3703703703703, "candidate_moves_total": 1868031, "avg_candidate_moves": 103.0524080101506, "candidate_moves_max": 141, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2367, "root_candidate_moves_max": 119, "search_candidate_generations": 18100, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1865664, "search_candidate_moves_max": 141, "legality_checks": 823986, "avg_legality_checks": 30518.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1364, "root_legality_checks": 2367, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 821619, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1353, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 854166, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 31635.777777777777, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1968803498, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2304.942479564862, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1647, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 61.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4867546, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2955.4013357619915, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1591, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4712926, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 56, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 154620, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.4814814814814814, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 414272, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10356.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 201320, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3728.1481481481483, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1970466545, "stage_ordering_ns": 630894, "stage_eval_ns": 2071366041, "stage_threat_ns": 10641480767, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1743307, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 9265823599, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 76, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 746693, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 29420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 871640, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1147373867, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1743280, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 227536608, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1258, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 16112, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 2.962962962962963, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 2.962962962962963, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 26 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6878.62962962963, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7174.925925925926, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1693, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 27004, "avg_search_time_ms": 1000.1481481481482, "search_nodes": 289763, "safety_nodes": 2007, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 291770, "avg_nodes": 10806.296296296296, "eval_calls": 223226, "avg_eval_calls": 8267.62962962963, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 223226, "pattern_eval_ns": 4839890, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.681569351240448, "pattern_frame_queries": 223226, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4839890, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.681569351240448, "pattern_frame_updates": 579272, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5771745568, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9963.79173859603, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 63292, "avg_candidate_generations": 2344.1481481481483, "candidate_moves_total": 5693833, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.96133792580422, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2400, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 63265, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5691433, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 3400931, "avg_legality_checks": 125960.4074074074, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3536, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3400931, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3536, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7695358, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 285013.25925925927, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16421637786, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2133.9667090212047, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58750, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2175.925925925926, "renju_forbidden_ns": 299260706, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5093.79925106383, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4088, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24737266, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21847, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 200857828, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32721, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 73398712, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 94, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 266900, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 204654, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7579.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1892890419, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9249.222683162801, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 282872, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10476.74074074074, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 876328992, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3097.9700783393196, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8115398512, "stage_ordering_ns": 2192084607, "stage_eval_ns": 5776585458, "stage_threat_ns": 10760462820, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1326962, "root_tactical_annotations": 4866, "search_tactical_annotations": 1322096, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 579299, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3388572679, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1201536, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6829624986, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 126710, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4047352671, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 289636, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 435592546, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 579272, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 73876229, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 495127, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 989075445, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 579679, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1792860540, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 252156, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32796380, "child_limit_applications": 63265, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 63265, "child_cap_hits": 63265, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 63265, "child_moves_before_total": 5687897, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5687897, "child_moves_before_max": 131, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 131, "child_moves_after_total": 1013897, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1013897, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.9059037382439, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.026191417055244, "tt_hits": 25047, "tt_cutoffs": 3145, "beta_cutoffs": 48651, "depth_sum": 127, "avg_depth": 4.703703703703703, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 127, "avg_effective_depth": 4.703703703703703, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 25 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25925925925925924, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6323.37037037037, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6619.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1715, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 538, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16223, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 142, 111, 156, 114, 96, 80, 127, 97, 172, 157, 140, 124, 144, 160, 158, 130, 143, 141, 173, 188, 113 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 15889, "avg_search_time_ms": 1444.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 200795, "safety_nodes": 82, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 200877, "avg_nodes": 18261.545454545456, "eval_calls": 163063, "avg_eval_calls": 14823.90909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 163063, "pattern_eval_ns": 3470248, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.28163961168383, "pattern_frame_queries": 163063, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3470248, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.28163961168383, "pattern_frame_updates": 401496, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5084398092, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12663.63324167613, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35505, "avg_candidate_generations": 3227.7272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 2812390, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.21109702858752, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 728, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 35494, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2811662, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1188338, "avg_legality_checks": 108030.72727272728, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1390, "root_legality_checks": 728, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1187610, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1389, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4266822, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 387892.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9124329832, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2138.4369519047195, "renju_forbidden_checks": 77897, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7081.545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 289647211, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3718.335892267995, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2512, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12655468, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 42356, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 214416724, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 33024, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 62569519, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5500, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 130434, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11857.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1067382642, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8183.316021896131, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 164329, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14939.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 417080210, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2538.080375344583, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2875051842, "stage_ordering_ns": 1159701162, "stage_eval_ns": 5087868340, "stage_threat_ns": 6710112287, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 589508, "root_tactical_annotations": 2918, "search_tactical_annotations": 586590, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 401507, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2277596259, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 526031, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4074415112, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 71056, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2567266235, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 200748, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 289487993, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 401496, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50088258, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 160759, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 282290040, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 294206, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1224848077, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 134543, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18524665, "child_limit_applications": 35494, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35494, "child_cap_hits": 35494, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35494, "child_moves_before_total": 2810273, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2810273, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 568364, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 568364, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.17600157773144, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01295993689074, "tt_hits": 14496, "tt_cutoffs": 2191, "beta_cutoffs": 24742, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1883.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2443.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 294, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 322, "avg_search_time_ms": 32.2, "search_nodes": 21006, "safety_nodes": 927, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 21933, "avg_nodes": 2193.3, "eval_calls": 19922, "avg_eval_calls": 1992.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 19922, "line_shape_eval_ns": 17081736, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 857.4307800421644, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1065, "avg_candidate_generations": 106.5, "candidate_moves_total": 73941, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.4281690140845, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 664, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 1055, "search_candidate_moves_total": 73277, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 2557, "avg_legality_checks": 255.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2557, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14243, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1424.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30212097, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2121.18914554518, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 7440, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1240.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2580, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4860, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7240899, "stage_ordering_ns": 35270, "stage_eval_ns": 17081736, "stage_threat_ns": 287553364, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 41964, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 253479414, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 234102, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10651, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 20977, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 28069430, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 41954, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5770418, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 59, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 944, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5942.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6742.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1895, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 539, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26516, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 113, 83, 81, 110, 68, 97, 114, 111, 115, 116, 69, 125, 139, 140, 95, 124, 138, 108, 92, 109, 107, 141, 93, 156, 172, 155, 170, 157, 173, 158, 154, 159 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 4945, "avg_search_time_ms": 290.88235294117646, "search_nodes": 292587, "safety_nodes": 1498, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 294085, "avg_nodes": 17299.117647058825, "eval_calls": 286026, "avg_eval_calls": 16825.058823529413, "line_shape_eval_calls": 286026, "line_shape_eval_ns": 252068729, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 881.2790760280534, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6528, "avg_candidate_generations": 384.0, "candidate_moves_total": 452998, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.39307598039215, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1205, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 6511, "search_candidate_moves_total": 451793, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 283423, "avg_legality_checks": 16671.941176470587, "illegal_moves_skipped": 55, "root_legality_checks": 1205, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 282218, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 51, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 302881, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17816.529411764706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 770371887, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2543.4803998930274, "renju_forbidden_checks": 71, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.176470588235294, "renju_forbidden_ns": 778626, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10966.56338028169, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 55, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 606925, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 171701, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.3529411764705883, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 415780, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10394.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.176470588235294, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 202720, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3754.074074074074, "stage_move_gen_ns": 747424062, "stage_ordering_ns": 204890, "stage_eval_ns": 252068729, "stage_threat_ns": 3923382269, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 585091, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3439338564, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 696193, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18710, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 292537, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 405466806, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 585074, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 77880706, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 180, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6091, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6235.411764705882, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6706.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1741, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 21556, "avg_search_time_ms": 1268.0, "search_nodes": 211344, "safety_nodes": 551, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 211895, "avg_nodes": 12464.411764705883, "eval_calls": 159132, "avg_eval_calls": 9360.70588235294, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 159132, "pattern_eval_ns": 3495228, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.964331498378705, "pattern_frame_queries": 159132, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3495228, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.964331498378705, "pattern_frame_updates": 422534, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3917959225, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9272.530080419563, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49624, "avg_candidate_generations": 2919.0588235294117, "candidate_moves_total": 4247046, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.58451555698855, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1246, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 49607, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4245800, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 2898291, "avg_legality_checks": 170487.70588235295, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5029, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2898291, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5029, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6523727, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 383748.64705882355, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13563576998, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2079.1147449916284, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32675, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1922.0588235294117, "renju_forbidden_ns": 154722718, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4735.201775057383, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5029, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 47788913, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7566, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71942408, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20055, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 34719017, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 272380, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 220565, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12974.411764705883, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2178972496, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9879.049241720128, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 325335, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19137.352941176472, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1101196310, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3384.8073831588977, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6952058581, "stage_ordering_ns": 1651474787, "stage_eval_ns": 3921454453, "stage_threat_ns": 8902423140, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1015539, "root_tactical_annotations": 4500, "search_tactical_annotations": 1011039, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 422551, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2483321964, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 880205, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6018548117, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 99324, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3233502132, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 211267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 316248773, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 422534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53498425, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 394545, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1268287221, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 386321, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1516600983, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 234673, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30805861, "child_limit_applications": 49607, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49607, "child_cap_hits": 49607, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49607, "child_moves_before_total": 4240771, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4240771, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 798413, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 798413, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.48735057552362, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.094764851734634, "tt_hits": 22490, "tt_cutoffs": 2528, "beta_cutoffs": 39200, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.29411764705882354, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6033.529411764706, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6504.117647058823, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1862, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 540, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9278, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 81, 68, 111, 54, 40, 113, 142, 94, 127, 97, 95, 85, 86, 79, 140, 154, 125, 80, 155 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8489, "avg_search_time_ms": 707.4166666666666, "search_nodes": 122250, "safety_nodes": 337, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122587, "avg_nodes": 10215.583333333334, "eval_calls": 92734, "avg_eval_calls": 7727.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 92734, "pattern_eval_ns": 1875230, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.22160157008217, "pattern_frame_queries": 92734, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1875230, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.22160157008217, "pattern_frame_updates": 244396, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2410295880, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9862.255847067874, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27837, "avg_candidate_generations": 2319.75, "candidate_moves_total": 2251917, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.89654057549305, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 842, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 27825, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2251075, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 802832, "avg_legality_checks": 66902.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2483, "root_legality_checks": 842, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 801990, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2481, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2921688, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 243474.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4874112848, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1668.252341796934, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40727, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3393.9166666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 135271634, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3321.4239693569375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2648, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13561770, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22443, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 95800604, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15626, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25853519, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55741, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93064, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7755.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 603226323, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6481.84392461102, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 123799, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10316.583333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 255708518, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2065.5135986558857, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1588845825, "stage_ordering_ns": 700781031, "stage_eval_ns": 2412171110, "stage_threat_ns": 3731278647, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 501417, "root_tactical_annotations": 2434, "search_tactical_annotations": 498983, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 244408, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1137994092, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 432737, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2405341397, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 55725, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1560384935, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 122198, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 150740640, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 244396, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25424124, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 153610, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 190573531, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 223393, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 654238240, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 124414, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11778394, "child_limit_applications": 27825, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27825, "child_cap_hits": 27825, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27825, "child_moves_before_total": 2248594, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2248594, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 454005, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 454005, "child_moves_after_max": 29, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 29, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.81200359389038, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.31644204851752, "tt_hits": 12034, "tt_cutoffs": 1639, "beta_cutoffs": 22012, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5092.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5758.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 932, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 777, "avg_search_time_ms": 70.63636363636364, "search_nodes": 64480, "safety_nodes": 1137, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 65617, "avg_nodes": 5965.181818181818, "eval_calls": 61836, "avg_eval_calls": 5621.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 61836, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44975133, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 727.3292742091985, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2623, "avg_candidate_generations": 238.45454545454547, "candidate_moves_total": 191745, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.10141059855128, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 774, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 2612, "search_candidate_moves_total": 190971, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 7827, "avg_legality_checks": 711.5454545454545, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7827, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20690, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1880.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 37519947, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1813.4338811019816, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.1818181818181819, "renju_forbidden_ns": 81950, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6303.846153846154, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 48870, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19533698, "stage_ordering_ns": 83190, "stage_eval_ns": 44975133, "stage_threat_ns": 703892605, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 128907, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 611324645, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 266871, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64448, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 78715433, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128896, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13585656, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 137, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2396, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6058.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6786.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 541, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18850, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 144, 111, 66, 82, 129, 80, 64, 99, 159, 174, 63, 67, 97, 81, 83, 95, 53, 68, 110, 126, 141, 127, 62, 65, 60, 61, 109, 142, 94, 158, 190, 157, 172, 50, 35, 54, 40, 125, 124, 143, 79 ], "move_count": 46, "black_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 5662, "avg_search_time_ms": 269.6190476190476, "search_nodes": 414729, "safety_nodes": 1866, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 416595, "avg_nodes": 19837.85714285714, "eval_calls": 404430, "avg_eval_calls": 19258.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 404430, "line_shape_eval_ns": 620976887, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1535.4372499567291, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10258, "avg_candidate_generations": 488.4761904761905, "candidate_moves_total": 929723, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.63394423864301, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1692, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 10237, "search_candidate_moves_total": 928031, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 389043, "avg_legality_checks": 18525.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1768, "root_legality_checks": 1692, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "search_legality_checks": 387351, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1750, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 413181, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19675.285714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 761216645, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1842.332161933874, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2103, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 100.14285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10231905, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4865.385164051355, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2018, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9777574, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 85, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 454331, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.285714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 740873, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8231.922222222222, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 122, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.809523809523809, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 341810, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2801.72131147541, "stage_move_gen_ns": 756337397, "stage_ordering_ns": 325224, "stage_eval_ns": 620976887, "stage_threat_ns": 4228689035, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 829355, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3663352122, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 60, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 979133, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 414667, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 473723703, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 829334, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 90634077, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 570, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9130, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 2.9523809523809526, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9523809523809526, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7016.9047619047615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7397.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1948, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 13169, "avg_search_time_ms": 627.0952380952381, "search_nodes": 139358, "safety_nodes": 1458, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 140816, "avg_nodes": 6705.523809523809, "eval_calls": 98779, "avg_eval_calls": 4703.761904761905, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 98779, "pattern_eval_ns": 2068726, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.942973708986727, "pattern_frame_queries": 98779, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2068726, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.942973708986727, "pattern_frame_updates": 278518, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2283467916, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8198.636770334413, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37815, "avg_candidate_generations": 1800.7142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 3368956, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.09046674600026, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1702, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 37794, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3367254, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 2221924, "avg_legality_checks": 105805.90476190476, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16156, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2221924, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16156, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4701683, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 223889.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8360546877, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1778.2030130487317, "renju_forbidden_checks": 50347, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2397.4761904761904, "renju_forbidden_ns": 163784933, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3253.1219933660395, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16494, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 49787348, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13889, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73781153, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19862, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39595121, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 102, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 621311, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 174673, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8317.761904761905, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1167194734, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6682.170306801852, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 221836, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10563.619047619048, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 419075908, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1889.1248850502172, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4540362917, "stage_ordering_ns": 1082309945, "stage_eval_ns": 2285536642, "stage_threat_ns": 5147212258, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 849509, "root_tactical_annotations": 3114, "search_tactical_annotations": 846395, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 278539, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1371555387, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 745757, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3542560879, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75728, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1918821216, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 139259, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 178488758, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 278518, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30428879, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 326791, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 668847587, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 343225, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 954627804, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 179493, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24178355, "child_limit_applications": 37794, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37794, "child_cap_hits": 37794, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37794, "child_moves_before_total": 3351098, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3351098, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 604891, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 604891, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.66746044345663, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.004947875324124, "tt_hits": 16551, "tt_cutoffs": 2686, "beta_cutoffs": 31347, "depth_sum": 99, "avg_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 99, "avg_effective_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.047619047619047616, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6735.047619047619, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7116.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1912, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 542, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11746, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 82, 99, 68, 54, 144, 84, 69, 128, 97, 67, 83, 55, 111, 125, 110, 124, 109, 113, 108 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11355, "avg_search_time_ms": 1135.5, "search_nodes": 134253, "safety_nodes": 140, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 134393, "avg_nodes": 13439.3, "eval_calls": 107478, "avg_eval_calls": 10747.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107478, "pattern_eval_ns": 2301438, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.41310779880534, "pattern_frame_queries": 107478, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2301438, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.41310779880534, "pattern_frame_updates": 268422, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3903532883, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14542.522159137478, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25089, "avg_candidate_generations": 2508.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1795937, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.58264578101956, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 626, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 25079, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1795311, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 745458, "avg_legality_checks": 74545.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1652, "root_legality_checks": 626, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 744832, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1651, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2955139, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 295513.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6704758486, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2268.847078259263, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34177, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3417.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 188468335, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5514.47859671709, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1911, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18485734, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 141093663, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13181, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28824198, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 64740, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81119, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8111.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 747492547, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9214.765307757738, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109278, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10927.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 315067695, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2883.175890847197, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1880321880, "stage_ordering_ns": 756701662, "stage_eval_ns": 3905834321, "stage_threat_ns": 4773698936, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 412956, "root_tactical_annotations": 2127, "search_tactical_annotations": 410829, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 268432, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1615332857, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 367406, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2909642295, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50219, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1841513527, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134211, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 199400957, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 268422, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34670068, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 106579, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 168334520, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 210600, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 899784328, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 95777, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14652759, "child_limit_applications": 25079, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25079, "child_cap_hits": 25079, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25079, "child_moves_before_total": 1793660, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1793660, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 401477, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 401477, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.5203955500618, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.008493161609316, "tt_hits": 10516, "tt_cutoffs": 1654, "beta_cutoffs": 17982, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3139.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3939.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 383, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 381, "avg_search_time_ms": 42.333333333333336, "search_nodes": 25238, "safety_nodes": 814, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 26052, "avg_nodes": 2894.6666666666665, "eval_calls": 24168, "avg_eval_calls": 2685.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 24168, "line_shape_eval_ns": 19304681, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 798.77031612049, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1053, "avg_candidate_generations": 117.0, "candidate_moves_total": 70544, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.99335232668567, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 566, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 1044, "search_candidate_moves_total": 69978, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 2648, "avg_legality_checks": 294.22222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2648, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13046, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1449.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29229074, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2240.462517246666, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.8888888888888888, "renju_forbidden_ns": 105371, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 13171.375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52561, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 52810, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7642728, "stage_ordering_ns": 35170, "stage_eval_ns": 19304681, "stage_threat_ns": 341945358, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 50433, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 302114176, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 213810, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 25212, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 33188225, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 50424, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6429147, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 62, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 938, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5682.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6570.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1852, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 543, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13803, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 144, 97, 94, 110, 143, 80, 64, 141, 145, 146, 49, 109, 111, 95, 125, 81, 123, 124, 82, 98, 99, 113, 129, 114, 115, 130, 162, 67, 53, 68, 83, 138, 152, 65, 50, 66, 69, 51, 36, 78, 101, 157, 87 ], "move_count": 48, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 3713, "avg_search_time_ms": 168.77272727272728, "search_nodes": 304742, "safety_nodes": 2570, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 307312, "avg_nodes": 13968.727272727272, "eval_calls": 296857, "avg_eval_calls": 13493.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 296857, "line_shape_eval_ns": 372511281, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1254.8509248560754, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7842, "avg_candidate_generations": 356.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 707347, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.19982147411375, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1815, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 7820, "search_candidate_moves_total": 705532, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 288412, "avg_legality_checks": 13109.636363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 701, "root_legality_checks": 1815, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 286597, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 692, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 313832, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14265.09090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 535180089, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1705.3075817634913, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1105, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 50.22727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6046429, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5471.881447963801, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1061, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5732653, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 313776, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 104, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 773611, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7438.567307692308, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 330010, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2500.0757575757575, "stage_move_gen_ns": 516517739, "stage_ordering_ns": 252621, "stage_eval_ns": 372511281, "stage_threat_ns": 2767961779, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 609376, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2390917354, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1232902, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 304677, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 312141640, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 609354, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63669883, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 500, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6784, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 2.9545454545454546, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7048.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7411.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1915, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 10070, "avg_search_time_ms": 457.72727272727275, "search_nodes": 120392, "safety_nodes": 1653, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122045, "avg_nodes": 5547.5, "eval_calls": 87342, "avg_eval_calls": 3970.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87342, "pattern_eval_ns": 1777890, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.355499072611114, "pattern_frame_queries": 87342, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1777890, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.355499072611114, "pattern_frame_updates": 240576, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1994040275, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8288.60848546821, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30895, "avg_candidate_generations": 1404.3181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 2634253, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.26470302637968, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1829, "root_candidate_moves_max": 115, "search_candidate_generations": 30873, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2632424, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1589840, "avg_legality_checks": 72265.45454545454, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9374, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1589840, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9374, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3760007, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 170909.4090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6205265521, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1650.33350230465, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54499, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2477.2272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 268429230, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4925.3973467403075, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10187, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 65591296, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27749, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 157012002, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16501, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45424611, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 62, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 401321, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 133490, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6067.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 903255591, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6766.466334556896, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 169953, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7725.136363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 364762125, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2146.2529346348697, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3092019918, "stage_ordering_ns": 801872371, "stage_eval_ns": 1995818165, "stage_threat_ns": 4091256890, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 632981, "root_tactical_annotations": 2570, "search_tactical_annotations": 630411, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 240598, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1070400421, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 562579, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2839061646, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61893, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1596411789, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 120288, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 142576619, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 240576, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24091363, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 220227, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 466645345, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 280447, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 775811922, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 132307, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15126841, "child_limit_applications": 30873, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30873, "child_cap_hits": 30873, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30873, "child_moves_before_total": 2623050, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2623050, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 495765, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 495765, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.9625886697114, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.058206199591876, "tt_hits": 12747, "tt_cutoffs": 2073, "beta_cutoffs": 25168, "depth_sum": 104, "avg_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 104, "avg_effective_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6569.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6933.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1814, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 544, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9183, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 110, 127, 111, 113, 124, 82, 128, 80, 79, 99, 109, 108, 94, 64, 139 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 8310, "avg_search_time_ms": 1038.75, "search_nodes": 98818, "safety_nodes": 343, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 99161, "avg_nodes": 12395.125, "eval_calls": 79946, "avg_eval_calls": 9993.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79946, "pattern_eval_ns": 1729627, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.634941085232533, "pattern_frame_queries": 79946, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1729627, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.634941085232533, "pattern_frame_updates": 197572, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2655560033, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13440.973584313566, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17840, "avg_candidate_generations": 2230.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1212981, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.99220852017937, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 463, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 17832, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1212518, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 560770, "avg_legality_checks": 70096.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 247, "root_legality_checks": 463, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 560307, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 247, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2118722, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 264840.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4900302802, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2312.8578463809786, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16382, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2047.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 87971010, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5369.979855939446, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 376, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2970382, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8625, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71375383, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7378, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13619345, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5900, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 62730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7841.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 577689265, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9209.138609915512, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 82555, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10319.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 242617871, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2938.8634364968807, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1455141791, "stage_ordering_ns": 553744804, "stage_eval_ns": 2657289660, "stage_threat_ns": 3616750622, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 229580, "root_tactical_annotations": 1315, "search_tactical_annotations": 228265, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 197580, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1212392009, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 216004, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2221833487, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35711, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1445147347, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 98786, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 150365370, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 197572, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25846675, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 51139, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 128439711, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 129147, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 648059028, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49294, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6313081, "child_limit_applications": 17832, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17832, "child_cap_hits": 17832, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17832, "child_moves_before_total": 1212271, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1212271, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 285496, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 285496, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.98289591745177, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01031852848811, "tt_hits": 6888, "tt_cutoffs": 1008, "beta_cutoffs": 12554, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1859.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2824.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 327, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 867, "avg_search_time_ms": 123.85714285714286, "search_nodes": 59420, "safety_nodes": 439, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59859, "avg_nodes": 8551.285714285714, "eval_calls": 57683, "avg_eval_calls": 8240.42857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 57683, "line_shape_eval_ns": 54962273, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 952.8331224104155, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1724, "avg_candidate_generations": 246.28571428571428, "candidate_moves_total": 118506, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.73897911832947, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 398, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 1717, "search_candidate_moves_total": 118108, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 4793, "avg_legality_checks": 684.7142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4793, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12853, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1836.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30237894, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2352.5942581498484, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13883550, "stage_ordering_ns": 60581, "stage_eval_ns": 54962273, "stage_threat_ns": 790982663, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 118807, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 694419922, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 154890, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7830, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 59400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80984242, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 118800, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15423609, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 115, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1523, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5028.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6171.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1838, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 545, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26538, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 111, 81, 83, 114, 66, 97, 109, 113, 110, 108, 65, 129, 145, 144, 99, 130, 146, 116, 102, 115, 117, 143, 101, 158, 172, 159, 174, 157, 171, 156, 160, 155 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 4994, "avg_search_time_ms": 293.7647058823529, "search_nodes": 293476, "safety_nodes": 1508, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 294984, "avg_nodes": 17352.0, "eval_calls": 287000, "avg_eval_calls": 16882.352941176472, "line_shape_eval_calls": 287000, "line_shape_eval_ns": 245239378, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 854.492606271777, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6443, "avg_candidate_generations": 379.0, "candidate_moves_total": 446282, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.26618035076828, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1210, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 6426, "search_candidate_moves_total": 445072, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 284553, "avg_legality_checks": 16738.41176470588, "illegal_moves_skipped": 51, "root_legality_checks": 1210, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 283343, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 304029, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17884.058823529413, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 774623208, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2547.85960549816, "renju_forbidden_checks": 67, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.9411764705882355, "renju_forbidden_ns": 733375, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10945.89552238806, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 51, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 559674, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 173701, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.3529411764705883, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 411491, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10287.275, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.176470588235294, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 201670, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3734.6296296296296, "stage_move_gen_ns": 754105014, "stage_ordering_ns": 213610, "stage_eval_ns": 245239378, "stage_threat_ns": 4003172952, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 586869, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3499383970, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 683824, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18350, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 293426, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 425252216, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 586852, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 77852942, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 180, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6053, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6177.882352941177, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6648.470588235294, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1480, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 21528, "avg_search_time_ms": 1266.3529411764705, "search_nodes": 213753, "safety_nodes": 561, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 214314, "avg_nodes": 12606.70588235294, "eval_calls": 160117, "avg_eval_calls": 9418.64705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 160117, "pattern_eval_ns": 3490619, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.800427187619054, "pattern_frame_queries": 160117, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3490619, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.800427187619054, "pattern_frame_updates": 427352, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3960490247, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9267.513073531889, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 50878, "avg_candidate_generations": 2992.823529411765, "candidate_moves_total": 4364968, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.79283776878022, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1251, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 50861, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4363717, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 2933440, "avg_legality_checks": 172555.29411764705, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5032, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2933440, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5032, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6628161, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 389891.82352941175, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13436762840, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2027.2233640673485, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44960, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2644.705882352941, "renju_forbidden_ns": 264881862, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5891.500489323844, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5032, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 48509481, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17336, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 163126229, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22567, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 52971041, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 275111, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 221130, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13007.64705882353, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2177398459, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9846.689544611767, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 332487, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19558.058823529413, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1130460429, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3400.0139223488436, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6878888744, "stage_ordering_ns": 1672218014, "stage_eval_ns": 3963980866, "stage_threat_ns": 8889688008, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1044650, "root_tactical_annotations": 4500, "search_tactical_annotations": 1040150, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 427369, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2428183809, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 911910, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6065258744, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 101832, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3260848360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 213676, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 311666797, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 427352, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52410435, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 404289, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1289223690, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 405774, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1515072494, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 234587, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32168223, "child_limit_applications": 50861, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 50861, "child_cap_hits": 50861, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 50861, "child_moves_before_total": 4358685, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4358685, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 815836, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 815836, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.6979807711213, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.040502546155206, "tt_hits": 22690, "tt_cutoffs": 2698, "beta_cutoffs": 40394, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.29411764705882354, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6053.35294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6523.941176470588, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1876, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 546, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13310, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 144, 96, 160, 176, 97, 68, 110, 66, 114, 81, 111, 113, 83, 69, 67, 54, 40, 51, 36, 52, 50, 38, 125, 139, 109, 108, 80, 24, 10, 39, 84, 9 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 9762, "avg_search_time_ms": 610.125, "search_nodes": 105629, "safety_nodes": 1829, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 107458, "avg_nodes": 6716.125, "eval_calls": 79940, "avg_eval_calls": 4996.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79940, "pattern_eval_ns": 1736913, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.72770828121091, "pattern_frame_queries": 79940, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1736913, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.72770828121091, "pattern_frame_updates": 211108, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2176697560, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10310.824601625709, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23762, "avg_candidate_generations": 1485.125, "candidate_moves_total": 2000047, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.16997727464017, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1366, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 23746, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1998681, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 955682, "avg_legality_checks": 59730.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 924, "root_legality_checks": 1366, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 954316, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2581350, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 161334.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5813137681, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2251.97578050245, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18998, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1187.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 94310836, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4964.250763238236, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1264, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9383211, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7047, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62065222, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10646, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22707102, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 41, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 155301, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75857, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4741.0625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 757937510, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9991.662074693173, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 103515, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6469.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 355113023, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3430.5465198280444, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2402496327, "stage_ordering_ns": 850547039, "stage_eval_ns": 2178434473, "stage_threat_ns": 4274044062, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 336098, "root_tactical_annotations": 1406, "search_tactical_annotations": 334692, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 211124, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1256601906, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 327013, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2828269096, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47599, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1787889577, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 105554, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 154803169, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 211108, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26744735, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 93091, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 229121009, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 186311, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 810004797, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 56696, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7625156, "child_limit_applications": 23746, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23746, "child_cap_hits": 23746, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23746, "child_moves_before_total": 1997758, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1997758, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 383011, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 383011, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.13029562873747, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.129495493977934, "tt_hits": 7922, "tt_cutoffs": 1869, "beta_cutoffs": 18567, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 4.5625, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5625, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5097.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5597.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 3533, "avg_search_time_ms": 220.8125, "search_nodes": 265477, "safety_nodes": 1144, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 266621, "avg_nodes": 16663.8125, "eval_calls": 256962, "avg_eval_calls": 16060.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 256962, "line_shape_eval_ns": 406245732, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1580.9564527050693, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8485, "avg_candidate_generations": 530.3125, "candidate_moves_total": 833829, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.27094873305833, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1398, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 8469, "search_candidate_moves_total": 832431, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 15744, "avg_legality_checks": 984.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 15744, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 34386, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2149.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 74026424, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2152.807072645844, "renju_forbidden_checks": 97, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6.0625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 362302, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3735.0721649484535, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 33, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 132721, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 64, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 229581, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 39790935, "stage_ordering_ns": 272051, "stage_eval_ns": 406245732, "stage_threat_ns": 3033565291, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 530878, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2650296259, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 197201, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17120, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 265431, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 322886696, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 530862, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60185135, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 621, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7422, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6706.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7206.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 547, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 39077, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 97, 99, 129, 142, 100, 113, 67, 127, 82, 52, 85, 141, 155, 140, 143, 156, 170, 124, 108, 157, 172, 173, 125, 139, 138, 154, 169, 79, 123, 93, 115, 189, 205, 70, 101, 87, 130, 145, 171, 168, 69, 117, 83, 111, 53, 37, 81, 94, 109, 63, 68, 95 ], "move_count": 58, "black_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 13324, "avg_search_time_ms": 493.48148148148147, "search_nodes": 781345, "safety_nodes": 1562, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 782907, "avg_nodes": 28996.555555555555, "eval_calls": 764917, "avg_eval_calls": 28330.25925925926, "line_shape_eval_calls": 764917, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1829277391, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 2391.471742685808, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16375, "avg_candidate_generations": 606.4814814814815, "candidate_moves_total": 1668555, "avg_candidate_moves": 101.89648854961833, "candidate_moves_max": 139, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2364, "root_candidate_moves_max": 119, "search_candidate_generations": 16348, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1666191, "search_candidate_moves_max": 139, "legality_checks": 730288, "avg_legality_checks": 27047.703703703704, "illegal_moves_skipped": 833, "root_legality_checks": 2364, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 727924, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 825, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 760474, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 28165.703703703704, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1767223290, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2323.844457535695, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1075, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 39.81481481481482, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3692008, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3434.426046511628, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1031, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3548588, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 143420, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.4814814814814814, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 426081, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10652.025, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 206361, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3821.5, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1760781899, "stage_ordering_ns": 588243, "stage_eval_ns": 1829277391, "stage_threat_ns": 9741656056, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1562557, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 8427026094, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 76, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 765142, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 29720, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 781265, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1125977795, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1562530, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 187887025, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1248, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 14497, "depth_sum": 79, "avg_depth": 2.925925925925926, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 79, "avg_effective_depth": 2.925925925925926, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 25 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.037037037037037035, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.037037037037037035, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.037037037037037035, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6915.592592592592, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7211.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1917, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 25724, "avg_search_time_ms": 952.7407407407408, "search_nodes": 284904, "safety_nodes": 2004, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 286908, "avg_nodes": 10626.222222222223, "eval_calls": 220364, "avg_eval_calls": 8161.62962962963, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 220364, "pattern_eval_ns": 4754556, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.575919841716434, "pattern_frame_queries": 220364, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4754556, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.575919841716434, "pattern_frame_updates": 569554, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5584498968, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9805.038623203418, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 61306, "avg_candidate_generations": 2270.5925925925926, "candidate_moves_total": 5531102, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.22121815156754, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2397, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 61279, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5528705, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 3256891, "avg_legality_checks": 120625.5925925926, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3088, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3256891, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3088, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7424884, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 274995.7037037037, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15551723955, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2094.5409995630907, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55676, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2062.074074074074, "renju_forbidden_ns": 274454508, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4929.494001005819, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3620, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21905437, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21307, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 182741930, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30670, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 69557439, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 79, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 249702, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 192278, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7121.407407407408, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1729288633, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8993.689517261466, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 266569, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9872.925925925925, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 793398701, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2976.3352115212197, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7566524220, "stage_ordering_ns": 2098135274, "stage_eval_ns": 5589253524, "stage_threat_ns": 10322048338, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1282296, "root_tactical_annotations": 4876, "search_tactical_annotations": 1277420, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 569581, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3321083277, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1153091, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6477833513, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 122738, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3929078616, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 284777, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 418841311, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 569554, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 72022507, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 478747, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 921672117, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 551586, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1626745540, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 251963, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32267730, "child_limit_applications": 61279, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 61279, "child_cap_hits": 61279, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 61279, "child_moves_before_total": 5525617, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5525617, "child_moves_before_max": 131, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 131, "child_moves_after_total": 982935, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 982935, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.17146167528844, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.040323765074497, "tt_hits": 24979, "tt_cutoffs": 3134, "beta_cutoffs": 46835, "depth_sum": 127, "avg_depth": 4.703703703703703, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 127, "avg_effective_depth": 4.703703703703703, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 25 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18518518518518517, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6517.962962962963, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6814.259259259259, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1868, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 548, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8869, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 142, 113, 158, 110, 127, 97, 98, 140, 155, 81, 157, 172, 156, 154, 159 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 8399, "avg_search_time_ms": 1049.875, "search_nodes": 100493, "safety_nodes": 343, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 100836, "avg_nodes": 12604.5, "eval_calls": 81293, "avg_eval_calls": 10161.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 81293, "pattern_eval_ns": 1767628, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.743913990134452, "pattern_frame_queries": 81293, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1767628, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.743913990134452, "pattern_frame_updates": 200922, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2544547423, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12664.354441026866, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18234, "avg_candidate_generations": 2279.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1283386, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.38422726774158, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 470, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 18226, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1282916, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 593709, "avg_legality_checks": 74213.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 190, "root_legality_checks": 470, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 593239, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 190, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2095901, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 261987.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4901910321, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2338.808140747106, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15829, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1978.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65806394, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4157.331101143471, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 327, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2439801, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7434, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 51524278, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8065, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11836425, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5890, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60221, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7527.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 548351693, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9105.65571810498, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 78533, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9816.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 225900042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2876.498312811175, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1558404025, "stage_ordering_ns": 597593976, "stage_eval_ns": 2546315051, "stage_threat_ns": 3664342397, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 224677, "root_tactical_annotations": 1350, "search_tactical_annotations": 223327, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 200930, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1223014954, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 212595, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2256528839, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36499, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1511553403, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 100461, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 152383417, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 200922, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26715342, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 48116, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 135440356, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 127973, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 609352760, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 48588, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5699845, "child_limit_applications": 18226, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18226, "child_cap_hits": 18226, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18226, "child_moves_before_total": 1282726, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1282726, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 291686, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 291686, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.37890925052123, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.003840667178757, "tt_hits": 6868, "tt_cutoffs": 942, "beta_cutoffs": 12860, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1822.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2776.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 267, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 463, "avg_search_time_ms": 66.14285714285714, "search_nodes": 30419, "safety_nodes": 453, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 30872, "avg_nodes": 4410.285714285715, "eval_calls": 29120, "avg_eval_calls": 4160.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 29120, "line_shape_eval_ns": 26110159, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 896.6400755494506, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1286, "avg_candidate_generations": 183.71428571428572, "candidate_moves_total": 86794, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.4914463452566, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 405, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 1279, "search_candidate_moves_total": 86389, "search_candidate_moves_max": 89, "legality_checks": 3451, "avg_legality_checks": 493.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3451, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11533, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1647.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26995244, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2340.695742651522, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10255602, "stage_ordering_ns": 49640, "stage_eval_ns": 26110159, "stage_threat_ns": 420260122, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 60805, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 368756853, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 155461, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7960, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 30399, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 42717866, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 60798, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8629942, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 115, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1106, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5055.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6198.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1888, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 549, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15484, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 140, 113, 68, 82, 125, 84, 70, 95, 155, 170, 71, 67, 97, 83, 81, 99, 51, 66, 114, 128, 143, 127, 141, 142, 157, 156, 184, 115, 131, 130, 129, 50, 34, 85, 86, 100, 145, 101, 102, 54, 173, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 48, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 4846, "avg_search_time_ms": 220.27272727272728, "search_nodes": 354759, "safety_nodes": 2570, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 357329, "avg_nodes": 16242.227272727272, "eval_calls": 345658, "avg_eval_calls": 15711.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 345658, "line_shape_eval_ns": 478028273, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1382.9515677345817, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9058, "avg_candidate_generations": 411.72727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 805525, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.92967542503864, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1815, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 9036, "search_candidate_moves_total": 803710, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 336982, "avg_legality_checks": 15317.363636363636, "illegal_moves_skipped": 771, "root_legality_checks": 1815, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 335167, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 762, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 362402, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16472.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 679955165, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1876.245619505411, "renju_forbidden_checks": 941, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 42.77272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5928146, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6299.836344314559, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 897, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5628296, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 299850, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 104, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 753952, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7249.538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 342621, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2595.6136363636365, "stage_move_gen_ns": 669599281, "stage_ordering_ns": 282602, "stage_eval_ns": 478028273, "stage_threat_ns": 3647805756, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 709410, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3168701563, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1126445, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17540, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 354694, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 403158768, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 709388, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74818980, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 500, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8087, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 2.9545454545454546, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7007.863636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7371.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1896, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 10614, "avg_search_time_ms": 482.45454545454544, "search_nodes": 118242, "safety_nodes": 1653, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 119895, "avg_nodes": 5449.772727272727, "eval_calls": 86032, "avg_eval_calls": 3910.5454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 86032, "pattern_eval_ns": 1776398, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.648107680862935, "pattern_frame_queries": 86032, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1776398, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.648107680862935, "pattern_frame_updates": 236276, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1903628711, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8056.800991213665, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29930, "avg_candidate_generations": 1360.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 2625567, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.72358837287003, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1829, "root_candidate_moves_max": 115, "search_candidate_generations": 29908, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2623738, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1589156, "avg_legality_checks": 72234.36363636363, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7283, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1589156, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7283, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3650725, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 165942.04545454544, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6684009612, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1830.8718438118456, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33606, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1527.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 160537933, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4777.061625900137, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7634, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 51614805, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10588, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73842220, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15322, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 34582274, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 62, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 498634, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 128081, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5821.863636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1030169859, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8043.112241472193, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 174840, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7947.272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 442417793, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2530.4151967513153, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3395619578, "stage_ordering_ns": 861855587, "stage_eval_ns": 1905405109, "stage_threat_ns": 4370861021, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 610898, "root_tactical_annotations": 2570, "search_tactical_annotations": 608328, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 236298, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1138340734, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 549465, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3043285748, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59963, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1678670496, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 118138, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 150156206, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 236276, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24807220, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 228573, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 566887964, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 260917, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 797489986, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 121408, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14271113, "child_limit_applications": 29908, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29908, "child_cap_hits": 29908, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29908, "child_moves_before_total": 2616455, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2616455, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 480421, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 480421, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.48344924434934, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.063294101912533, "tt_hits": 12693, "tt_cutoffs": 2198, "beta_cutoffs": 24275, "depth_sum": 104, "avg_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 104, "avg_effective_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6479.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6842.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1821, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 550, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7107, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 82, 95, 84, 126, 66, 50, 97, 80, 65, 67, 81, 125, 140, 49, 114, 130, 129, 113, 99, 144, 69 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6717, "avg_search_time_ms": 610.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 128581, "safety_nodes": 205, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 128786, "avg_nodes": 11707.818181818182, "eval_calls": 100812, "avg_eval_calls": 9164.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 100812, "pattern_eval_ns": 1828695, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.139655993334127, "pattern_frame_queries": 100812, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1828695, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.139655993334127, "pattern_frame_updates": 257068, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2297112258, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8935.815651889772, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26168, "avg_candidate_generations": 2378.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 1935606, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.96843472944053, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 703, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 26157, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1934903, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 746090, "avg_legality_checks": 67826.36363636363, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1038, "root_legality_checks": 703, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 745387, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1038, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3066337, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 278757.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3864690317, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1260.3605921332196, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42581, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3871.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 133823866, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3142.8070266081118, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1382, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5227093, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24397, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 106165693, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16802, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22431080, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98337, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8939.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 499077437, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5075.174522305948, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 130910, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11900.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 205943462, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1573.1682988312582, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1067298165, "stage_ordering_ns": 442280736, "stage_eval_ns": 2298940953, "stage_threat_ns": 2861802904, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 483604, "root_tactical_annotations": 2193, "search_tactical_annotations": 481411, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 257079, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 907942456, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 425029, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1798713749, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52382, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1088040901, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128534, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 123346053, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 257068, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21051749, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 133537, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 136178797, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 239102, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 574487101, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110965, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10748897, "child_limit_applications": 26157, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26157, "child_cap_hits": 26157, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26157, "child_moves_before_total": 1933865, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1933865, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 419444, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 419444, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.93298161104101, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.035630997438545, "tt_hits": 10773, "tt_cutoffs": 1565, "beta_cutoffs": 19563, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5192.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5919.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1114, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 379, "avg_search_time_ms": 37.9, "search_nodes": 38282, "safety_nodes": 948, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 39230, "avg_nodes": 3923.0, "eval_calls": 36878, "avg_eval_calls": 3687.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 36878, "line_shape_eval_ns": 22789914, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 617.9812896577905, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1385, "avg_candidate_generations": 138.5, "candidate_moves_total": 94277, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.07003610108303, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 639, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 1375, "search_candidate_moves_total": 93638, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 2856, "avg_legality_checks": 285.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2856, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14470, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1447.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20591001, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1423.013199723566, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5495245, "stage_ordering_ns": 41401, "stage_eval_ns": 22789914, "stage_threat_ns": 342019959, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 76516, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 297820928, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 208962, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6601, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38253, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 36411159, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 76506, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7578910, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 66, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1254, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5953.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6753.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1916, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 551, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14717, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 97, 82, 113, 96, 142, 157, 68, 114, 66, 129, 99, 141, 65, 67, 81, 49, 128, 125, 109, 143, 115, 171, 185, 156, 85, 71, 186, 95, 80, 155, 140, 154, 158, 153 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 4057, "avg_search_time_ms": 238.64705882352942, "search_nodes": 444676, "safety_nodes": 1531, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 446207, "avg_nodes": 26247.470588235294, "eval_calls": 433313, "avg_eval_calls": 25489.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 433313, "line_shape_eval_ns": 258219090, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 595.9181700064388, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11330, "avg_candidate_generations": 666.4705882352941, "candidate_moves_total": 911963, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.4909973521624, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1301, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 11313, "search_candidate_moves_total": 910662, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 424343, "avg_legality_checks": 24961.352941176472, "illegal_moves_skipped": 165, "root_legality_checks": 1301, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 423042, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 165, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 444254, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26132.58823529412, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 585501900, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1317.9440140100032, "renju_forbidden_checks": 209, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12.294117647058824, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1078732, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5161.397129186603, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 209, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1078732, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.0588235294117645, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 395461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7605.0192307692305, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 78, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.588235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 214010, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2743.7179487179487, "stage_move_gen_ns": 584528543, "stage_ordering_ns": 311512, "stage_eval_ns": 258219090, "stage_threat_ns": 3133585664, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 889269, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2708908085, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 48, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 609462, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10210, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 444626, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 355761032, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 889252, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 68307085, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 409, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 10434, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6606.882352941177, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7077.470588235294, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1950, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 10643, "avg_search_time_ms": 626.0588235294117, "search_nodes": 195132, "safety_nodes": 686, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 195818, "avg_nodes": 11518.70588235294, "eval_calls": 149465, "avg_eval_calls": 8792.058823529413, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 149465, "pattern_eval_ns": 2717588, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.182102833439266, "pattern_frame_queries": 149465, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2717588, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.182102833439266, "pattern_frame_updates": 390110, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2096667246, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5374.553961703109, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42925, "avg_candidate_generations": 2525.0, "candidate_moves_total": 4034069, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.97947582993594, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1326, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 42908, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4032743, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 2589914, "avg_legality_checks": 152347.88235294117, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2971, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2589914, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2971, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5484599, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 322623.4705882353, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6353991339, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1158.515205760713, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14108, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 829.8823529411765, "renju_forbidden_ns": 36354072, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2576.8409413098952, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2977, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15939095, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2733, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14230569, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8393, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6152768, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 31640, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 132866, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7815.64705882353, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 725393304, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5459.585627624825, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 201600, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11858.823529411764, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 372186679, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1846.16408234127, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3412538460, "stage_ordering_ns": 866623560, "stage_eval_ns": 2099384834, "stage_threat_ns": 4154175675, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 889167, "root_tactical_annotations": 3790, "search_tactical_annotations": 885377, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 390127, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1324992586, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 787597, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2596309847, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 85926, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1539962553, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 195055, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 181525954, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 390110, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30481940, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 337037, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 399814040, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 364621, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 656450503, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 187509, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20865348, "child_limit_applications": 42908, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42908, "child_cap_hits": 42908, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42908, "child_moves_before_total": 4029772, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4029772, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 690570, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 690570, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.91656567539853, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.09420154749697, "tt_hits": 18598, "tt_cutoffs": 2682, "beta_cutoffs": 33288, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6604.941176470588, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7075.529411764706, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1937, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 552, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15491, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 99, 96, 113, 141, 114, 111, 156, 81, 126, 51, 66, 95, 94, 128, 80, 108, 157, 172, 115, 116, 52, 38, 71, 85, 143, 109, 107, 67, 123, 53 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 14288, "avg_search_time_ms": 893.0, "search_nodes": 168724, "safety_nodes": 510, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 169234, "avg_nodes": 10577.125, "eval_calls": 121239, "avg_eval_calls": 7577.4375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 121239, "pattern_eval_ns": 2459020, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.28241737394733, "pattern_frame_queries": 121239, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2459020, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.28241737394733, "pattern_frame_updates": 337296, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4025477523, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11934.55458410417, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44948, "avg_candidate_generations": 2809.25, "candidate_moves_total": 3914276, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.08454213758121, "candidate_moves_max": 132, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1182, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 44932, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3913094, "search_candidate_moves_max": 132, "legality_checks": 971313, "avg_legality_checks": 60707.0625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2519, "root_legality_checks": 1182, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 970131, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2516, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4058399, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 253649.9375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8089006960, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1993.1522159353972, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34145, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2134.0625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 191812171, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5617.577126958559, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2794, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 27795495, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14975, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 117381312, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16347, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 46339753, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 295611, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 119380, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7461.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1000519780, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8380.966493550008, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 161350, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10084.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 433234255, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2685.058909203595, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2137963023, "stage_ordering_ns": 1436531189, "stage_eval_ns": 4027936543, "stage_threat_ns": 6633322639, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 960688, "root_tactical_annotations": 3663, "search_tactical_annotations": 957025, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 337312, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1828197033, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 832868, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4507592963, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 89972, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2902898746, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 168648, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 230650061, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 337296, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39691516, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 296143, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 397912458, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 446742, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1206645588, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 217803, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 27191066, "child_limit_applications": 44932, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44932, "child_cap_hits": 44932, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44932, "child_moves_before_total": 3910578, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3910578, "child_moves_before_max": 132, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 132, "child_moves_after_total": 724241, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 724241, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.03325024481438, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.118601442179294, "tt_hits": 18427, "tt_cutoffs": 2477, "beta_cutoffs": 37141, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 4.75, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 4.75, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6095.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6595.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1423, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 1189, "avg_search_time_ms": 74.3125, "search_nodes": 84779, "safety_nodes": 1831, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 86610, "avg_nodes": 5413.125, "eval_calls": 81723, "avg_eval_calls": 5107.6875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 81723, "line_shape_eval_ns": 103532450, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1266.8704036807264, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3026, "avg_candidate_generations": 189.125, "candidate_moves_total": 238425, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.79213483146067, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1215, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 3010, "search_candidate_moves_total": 237210, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 7685, "avg_legality_checks": 480.3125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7685, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26122, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1632.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 68673511, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2628.9530280989206, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.8125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 468171, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10403.8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 122630, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 345541, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 35224005, "stage_ordering_ns": 93340, "stage_eval_ns": 103532450, "stage_threat_ns": 1027990008, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169482, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 902530729, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 360431, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15611, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84733, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104973751, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169466, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20125097, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 104, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2792, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6677.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7177.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 553, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10572, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 126, 98, 109, 108, 83, 114, 66, 146, 130, 143, 158, 142, 96, 81, 100, 97, 156, 141, 144, 129, 65, 145 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 1444, "avg_search_time_ms": 120.33333333333333, "search_nodes": 104428, "safety_nodes": 1263, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 105691, "avg_nodes": 8807.583333333334, "eval_calls": 101046, "avg_eval_calls": 8420.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 101046, "line_shape_eval_ns": 72752009, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 719.9890050076203, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3359, "avg_candidate_generations": 279.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 247276, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.61595713009824, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 858, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 3347, "search_candidate_moves_total": 246418, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 98753, "avg_legality_checks": 8229.416666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 858, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 97895, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 113050, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9420.833333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 232022084, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2052.3846439628483, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44520, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7420.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 40890, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3630, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 61, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.083333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 639663, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10486.27868852459, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 83, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.916666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 327243, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3942.6867469879517, "stage_move_gen_ns": 209616007, "stage_ordering_ns": 96650, "stage_eval_ns": 72752009, "stage_threat_ns": 1144112537, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 208798, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1003186193, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 923884, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12350, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 104393, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 117708181, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 208786, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22294279, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 119, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3076, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6111.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6777.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1889, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9116, "avg_search_time_ms": 759.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 73304, "safety_nodes": 752, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 74056, "avg_nodes": 6171.333333333333, "eval_calls": 51419, "avg_eval_calls": 4284.916666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51419, "pattern_eval_ns": 1083853, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.078842451233978, "pattern_frame_queries": 51419, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1083853, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.078842451233978, "pattern_frame_updates": 146504, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1550103828, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10580.624610932126, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20511, "avg_candidate_generations": 1709.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1712440, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.48885963629272, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 881, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 20499, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1711559, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1248247, "avg_legality_checks": 104020.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1168, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1248247, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1168, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2923051, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 243587.58333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5967780847, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2041.6273431424904, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23752, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1979.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 82238293, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3462.3734001347257, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1192, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11829563, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4352, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 42827047, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18208, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27581683, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 116450, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9704.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1170445824, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10051.059029626449, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 157569, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13130.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 588927918, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3737.5874569236335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2941430070, "stage_ordering_ns": 695537797, "stage_eval_ns": 1551187681, "stage_threat_ns": 3876418415, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 404381, "root_tactical_annotations": 1769, "search_tactical_annotations": 402612, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 146516, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 868688591, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 344875, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2870002387, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41073, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1421478798, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 73252, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 106353756, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 146504, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18049515, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 115127, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 516382940, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 188667, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 932022879, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 100587, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13324166, "child_limit_applications": 20499, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20499, "child_cap_hits": 20499, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20499, "child_moves_before_total": 1710391, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1710391, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 328113, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 328113, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.43777745255866, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.006292989901947, "tt_hits": 9023, "tt_cutoffs": 1334, "beta_cutoffs": 17153, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5487.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6154.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1878, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 554, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20611, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 113, 114, 126, 98, 66, 100, 110, 109, 142, 86, 72, 94, 141, 96, 97, 127, 171, 156, 83, 130, 146, 129, 131, 125, 116, 101, 69, 55, 174, 158, 176, 161, 160, 99, 102, 144, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 17060, "avg_search_time_ms": 897.8947368421053, "search_nodes": 184940, "safety_nodes": 839, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 185779, "avg_nodes": 9777.842105263158, "eval_calls": 132476, "avg_eval_calls": 6972.421052631579, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 132476, "pattern_eval_ns": 2729613, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.604584981430598, "pattern_frame_queries": 132476, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2729613, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.604584981430598, "pattern_frame_updates": 369700, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4670508138, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12633.238133621855, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49200, "avg_candidate_generations": 2589.4736842105262, "candidate_moves_total": 4765796, "avg_candidate_moves": 96.86577235772357, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1625, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 49181, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4764171, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 1317226, "avg_legality_checks": 69327.68421052632, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2607, "root_legality_checks": 1625, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1315601, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2604, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4759081, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 250477.94736842104, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9772375750, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2053.416562987686, "renju_forbidden_checks": 103419, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5443.105263157895, "renju_forbidden_ns": 364432463, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3523.844390295787, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4293, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 32710893, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 43344, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 209236569, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 55763, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 122296831, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 188170, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 143664, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7561.263157894737, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1297335111, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9030.34240310725, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 191829, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10096.263157894737, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 605741452, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3157.7157364110744, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3056615218, "stage_ordering_ns": 1663640246, "stage_eval_ns": 4673237751, "stage_threat_ns": 7611705164, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1206141, "root_tactical_annotations": 4876, "search_tactical_annotations": 1201265, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 369719, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2105904575, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 994113, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5146186104, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 98490, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3188126495, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 184850, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 271596217, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 369700, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45876633, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 431439, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 445991698, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 464170, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1511766539, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 310532, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 42141635, "child_limit_applications": 49181, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49181, "child_cap_hits": 49181, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49181, "child_moves_before_total": 4761567, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4761567, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 799457, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 799457, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 96.8172058315203, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.25540350948537, "tt_hits": 24106, "tt_cutoffs": 3193, "beta_cutoffs": 40787, "depth_sum": 90, "avg_depth": 4.7368421052631575, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 90, "avg_effective_depth": 4.7368421052631575, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6285.0526315789475, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6706.105263157895, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1015, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 3534, "avg_search_time_ms": 186.0, "search_nodes": 259967, "safety_nodes": 2350, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 262317, "avg_nodes": 13806.157894736842, "eval_calls": 253961, "avg_eval_calls": 13366.368421052632, "line_shape_eval_calls": 253961, "line_shape_eval_ns": 283674484, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1117.000185067786, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5970, "avg_candidate_generations": 314.2105263157895, "candidate_moves_total": 485791, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.37202680067001, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1666, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 5951, "search_candidate_moves_total": 484125, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 17048, "avg_legality_checks": 897.2631578947369, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 17048, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 39197, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2063.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 86419462, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2204.746842870628, "renju_forbidden_checks": 59, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.1052631578947367, "renju_forbidden_ns": 422411, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7159.5084745762715, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 219290, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 203121, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 46340450, "stage_ordering_ns": 184021, "stage_eval_ns": 283674484, "stage_threat_ns": 3204230731, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 519843, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2794361856, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 50, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 493911, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 259912, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 348352064, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 519824, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61022900, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 236, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5553, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6741.526315789473, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7162.578947368421, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1967, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 555, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8973, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 96, 128, 67, 52, 129, 142, 100, 170, 156, 125, 124, 110, 98, 99, 94, 95, 140, 172, 113, 157, 187, 174, 158, 173, 171, 141, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 2061, "avg_search_time_ms": 137.4, "search_nodes": 129418, "safety_nodes": 1368, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 130786, "avg_nodes": 8719.066666666668, "eval_calls": 125913, "avg_eval_calls": 8394.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 125913, "line_shape_eval_ns": 181028576, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1437.7274467290906, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3476, "avg_candidate_generations": 231.73333333333332, "candidate_moves_total": 306559, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.19303797468355, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1134, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3461, "search_candidate_moves_total": 305425, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 123199, "avg_legality_checks": 8213.266666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 148, "root_legality_checks": 1134, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 122065, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 147, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 140834, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9388.933333333332, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 322141581, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2287.385013562066, "renju_forbidden_checks": 154, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.266666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1683685, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10933.01948051948, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 148, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1639065, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 44620, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.533333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 569684, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10748.754716981131, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 73, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.866666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 297333, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4073.054794520548, "stage_move_gen_ns": 296726632, "stage_ordering_ns": 108920, "stage_eval_ns": 181028576, "stage_threat_ns": 1566547388, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 258763, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1369910926, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 796035, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15740, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129374, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 165120963, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 258748, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30719464, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 203, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3113, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6619.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7152.933333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1914, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 6896, "avg_search_time_ms": 459.73333333333335, "search_nodes": 64600, "safety_nodes": 1461, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 66061, "avg_nodes": 4404.066666666667, "eval_calls": 46607, "avg_eval_calls": 3107.133333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46607, "pattern_eval_ns": 963076, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.663762954062694, "pattern_frame_queries": 46607, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 963076, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.663762954062694, "pattern_frame_updates": 129066, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1325358930, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10268.846404165311, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16657, "avg_candidate_generations": 1110.4666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1336200, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.21852674551239, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1153, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 16642, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1335047, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 865242, "avg_legality_checks": 57682.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 230, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 865242, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 230, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2143125, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 142875.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4421162437, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2062.951268358122, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12115, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 807.6666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 48317716, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3988.2555509698723, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 340, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3035667, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3343, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31001758, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8427, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14225260, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55031, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75761, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5050.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 735950570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9714.108446298227, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 105196, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7013.066666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 354986905, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3374.528546712803, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2041846226, "stage_ordering_ns": 533578366, "stage_eval_ns": 1326322006, "stage_threat_ns": 2944803501, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 301281, "root_tactical_annotations": 1465, "search_tactical_annotations": 299816, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 129081, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 756996101, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 256582, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2072832922, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33380, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1133240795, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64533, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90260663, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 129066, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15942980, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 79682, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 353382972, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 143509, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 585901784, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78090, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8770835, "child_limit_applications": 16642, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16642, "child_cap_hits": 16642, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16642, "child_moves_before_total": 1334817, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1334817, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 266560, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 266560, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.20772743660618, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.017305612306213, "tt_hits": 7735, "tt_cutoffs": 1284, "beta_cutoffs": 13586, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6090.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6624.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1854, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 556, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12716, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 67, 127, 128, 141, 96, 80, 95, 94, 81, 109, 113, 129, 98, 99, 83, 143, 68 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 12280, "avg_search_time_ms": 1364.4444444444443, "search_nodes": 157759, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 157959, "avg_nodes": 17551.0, "eval_calls": 128003, "avg_eval_calls": 14222.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 128003, "pattern_eval_ns": 2617147, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.44598173480309, "pattern_frame_queries": 128003, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2617147, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.44598173480309, "pattern_frame_updates": 315444, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3870915517, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12271.323965585018, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28461, "avg_candidate_generations": 3162.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2101087, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.82337233407118, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 559, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 28452, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2100528, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 928646, "avg_legality_checks": 103182.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 926, "root_legality_checks": 559, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 928087, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 926, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3309972, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 367774.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7149566443, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2160.0081339056646, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39959, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4439.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 175620905, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4395.027528216422, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1719, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10514642, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23020, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 130992673, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15213, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 34095230, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 18360, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97879, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10875.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 795091567, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8123.208931435753, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 126942, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14104.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 304662757, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2400.01541648942, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2264709043, "stage_ordering_ns": 873838614, "stage_eval_ns": 3873532664, "stage_threat_ns": 5228718669, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 455104, "root_tactical_annotations": 2134, "search_tactical_annotations": 452970, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 315453, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1789706430, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 406915, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3165853520, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56958, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2056558957, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 157722, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 221577689, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 315444, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38178345, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 131261, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 169310003, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 218688, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 939855449, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 105155, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13402685, "child_limit_applications": 28452, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28452, "child_cap_hits": 28452, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28452, "child_moves_before_total": 2099602, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2099602, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 475164, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 475164, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.79453114016589, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.700548291859974, "tt_hits": 10307, "tt_cutoffs": 1267, "beta_cutoffs": 20232, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1184.6666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1824.3333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 427, "avg_search_time_ms": 53.375, "search_nodes": 29991, "safety_nodes": 745, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 30736, "avg_nodes": 3842.0, "eval_calls": 28698, "avg_eval_calls": 3587.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 28698, "line_shape_eval_ns": 20597464, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 717.731688619416, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1278, "avg_candidate_generations": 159.75, "candidate_moves_total": 85074, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.5680751173709, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 499, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 1270, "search_candidate_moves_total": 84575, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 3028, "avg_legality_checks": 378.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3028, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12441, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1555.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26934362, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2164.9676071055383, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18320, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2617.1428571428573, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2680, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 15640, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8526008, "stage_ordering_ns": 40681, "stage_eval_ns": 20597464, "stage_threat_ns": 389874272, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 59944, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 343506075, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 219340, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 29968, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 38945023, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 59936, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7203834, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 66, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1144, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5365.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6365.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1955, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 557, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13047, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 97, 82, 114, 115, 68, 126, 94, 124, 138, 125, 127, 95, 80, 141, 83, 140, 155, 143, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1376, "avg_search_time_ms": 125.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 95322, "safety_nodes": 896, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 96218, "avg_nodes": 8747.09090909091, "eval_calls": 92347, "avg_eval_calls": 8395.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 92347, "line_shape_eval_ns": 65930094, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 713.9386661180114, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2954, "avg_candidate_generations": 268.54545454545456, "candidate_moves_total": 209670, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.97833446174678, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 742, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 2943, "search_candidate_moves_total": 208928, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 87108, "avg_legality_checks": 7918.909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 174, "root_legality_checks": 742, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 86366, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 172, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 100173, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9106.636363636364, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 218502885, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2181.2552783684228, "renju_forbidden_checks": 182, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 16.545454545454547, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1852082, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10176.274725274725, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 174, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1757092, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 94990, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8181818181818183, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 473523, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11274.357142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.363636363636363, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 252522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4280.033898305085, "stage_move_gen_ns": 202597770, "stage_ordering_ns": 94781, "stage_eval_ns": 65930094, "stage_threat_ns": 1094706209, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 190591, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 958355291, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 655794, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9920, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 95290, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113751016, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 190580, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21944108, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 186, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2652, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5935.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6662.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1901, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11660, "avg_search_time_ms": 1060.0, "search_nodes": 147450, "safety_nodes": 533, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 147983, "avg_nodes": 13453.0, "eval_calls": 118942, "avg_eval_calls": 10812.90909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 118942, "pattern_eval_ns": 2405744, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.22619427956483, "pattern_frame_queries": 118942, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2405744, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.22619427956483, "pattern_frame_updates": 294806, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2660163407, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9023.43713153735, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26849, "avg_candidate_generations": 2440.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2296539, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.5353644456032, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 766, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 26838, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2295773, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1362480, "avg_legality_checks": 123861.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8261, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1362480, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8261, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3487974, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 317088.54545454547, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6891420343, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1975.7659727394757, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33051, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3004.6363636363635, "renju_forbidden_ns": 295584093, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8943.272306435509, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8261, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 82326996, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18820, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 176883155, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5955, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36190702, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 183240, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 108791, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9890.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1031151582, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9478.280207002417, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 153579, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13961.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 501484768, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3265.3212223025284, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3199095975, "stage_ordering_ns": 882432518, "stage_eval_ns": 2662569151, "stage_threat_ns": 4848879143, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 402534, "root_tactical_annotations": 2206, "search_tactical_annotations": 400328, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 294817, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1551960628, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 364204, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3059809177, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53744, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1762081441, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147403, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 192189197, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 294806, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33472915, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116227, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 538809379, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 194224, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 758836167, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 92083, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11447226, "child_limit_applications": 26838, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26838, "child_cap_hits": 26838, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26838, "child_moves_before_total": 2287512, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2287512, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 430136, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 430136, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.23407109322602, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02712571726656, "tt_hits": 11036, "tt_cutoffs": 1623, "beta_cutoffs": 18985, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4479.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5206.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1829, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 558, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10414, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 82, 124, 114, 98, 140, 125, 127, 139, 97, 109, 68, 54, 94, 128, 93, 95, 83, 123, 122, 81, 67, 137 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 9718, "avg_search_time_ms": 747.5384615384615, "search_nodes": 120592, "safety_nodes": 331, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 120923, "avg_nodes": 9301.76923076923, "eval_calls": 89829, "avg_eval_calls": 6909.923076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89829, "pattern_eval_ns": 1807368, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.12009484687573, "pattern_frame_queries": 89829, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1807368, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.12009484687573, "pattern_frame_updates": 241070, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2519608438, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10451.771012568963, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29399, "avg_candidate_generations": 2261.4615384615386, "candidate_moves_total": 2298269, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.17507398210823, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 854, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 29386, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2297415, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 809948, "avg_legality_checks": 62303.692307692305, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1122, "root_legality_checks": 854, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 809094, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1121, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2811063, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 216235.61538461538, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5636241441, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2005.0213890617179, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20026, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1540.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_ns": 94167495, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4702.261809647458, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1262, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11169261, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8032, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 56570668, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10727, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26374646, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 52920, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89334, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6871.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 682400833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7638.758289117245, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 114788, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8829.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 263776824, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2297.9477297278463, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1840470806, "stage_ordering_ns": 890655716, "stage_eval_ns": 2521415806, "stage_threat_ns": 4421037082, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 472738, "root_tactical_annotations": 2577, "search_tactical_annotations": 470161, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 241083, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1298426377, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 419774, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2917785204, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58854, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1942510897, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 120535, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 163414159, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 241070, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28083188, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 151396, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 228684259, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 209514, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 746487708, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 111828, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13328154, "child_limit_applications": 29386, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29386, "child_cap_hits": 29386, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29386, "child_moves_before_total": 2296294, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2296294, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 471166, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 471166, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.14244878513578, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.033689512012522, "tt_hits": 12500, "tt_cutoffs": 1320, "beta_cutoffs": 23529, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5342.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5958.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1339, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 681, "avg_search_time_ms": 56.75, "search_nodes": 48491, "safety_nodes": 1176, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49667, "avg_nodes": 4138.916666666667, "eval_calls": 45809, "avg_eval_calls": 3817.4166666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 45809, "line_shape_eval_ns": 39774086, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 868.2592067061058, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2659, "avg_candidate_generations": 221.58333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 187992, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.70026325686348, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 784, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 2647, "search_candidate_moves_total": 187208, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 6040, "avg_legality_checks": 503.3333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6040, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19974, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1664.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 42479512, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2126.7403624712124, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 102940, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11437.777777777777, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 56840, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 46100, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16405163, "stage_ordering_ns": 82670, "stage_eval_ns": 39774086, "stage_threat_ns": 611654898, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 96924, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 538023655, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 400992, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48456, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 61750990, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 96912, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11479261, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 137, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2392, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6240.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6907.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 559, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20734, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 111, 110, 142, 157, 68, 98, 66, 125, 95, 143, 65, 67, 63, 79, 49, 113, 81, 33, 64, 62, 128, 129, 115, 144, 99, 78, 126, 147, 50, 146, 130, 145 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 5058, "avg_search_time_ms": 297.52941176470586, "search_nodes": 332849, "safety_nodes": 1497, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 334346, "avg_nodes": 19667.41176470588, "eval_calls": 323885, "avg_eval_calls": 19052.058823529413, "line_shape_eval_calls": 323885, "line_shape_eval_ns": 331321560, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1022.9604952375072, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8931, "avg_candidate_generations": 525.3529411764706, "candidate_moves_total": 709260, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.41551897883775, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1294, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 8914, "search_candidate_moves_total": 707966, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 311479, "avg_legality_checks": 18322.29411764706, "illegal_moves_skipped": 190, "root_legality_checks": 1294, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 310185, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 190, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 331306, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19488.58823529412, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 735232857, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2219.1957193651792, "renju_forbidden_checks": 230, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 13.529411764705882, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2105520, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9154.434782608696, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 228, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2102130, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3390, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.4705882352941178, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 609555, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10331.440677966102, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 85, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 324762, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3820.7294117647057, "stage_move_gen_ns": 719952444, "stage_ordering_ns": 274294, "stage_eval_ns": 331321560, "stage_threat_ns": 3973844929, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 665615, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3484936757, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 50, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 886695, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 332799, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 412301430, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 665598, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 75720047, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 514, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8025, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6468.117647058823, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6938.705882352941, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1915, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 15661, "avg_search_time_ms": 921.2352941176471, "search_nodes": 219702, "safety_nodes": 928, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 220630, "avg_nodes": 12978.235294117647, "eval_calls": 176324, "avg_eval_calls": 10372.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 176324, "pattern_eval_ns": 3517746, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.950466187246207, "pattern_frame_queries": 176324, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3517746, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.950466187246207, "pattern_frame_updates": 439246, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3549945634, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8081.90771003037, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 40444, "avg_candidate_generations": 2379.0588235294117, "candidate_moves_total": 3667119, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.67152111561666, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1319, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 40427, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3665800, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1982657, "avg_legality_checks": 116626.88235294117, "illegal_moves_skipped": 583, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1982657, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 583, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4757723, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 279866.0588235294, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9035838531, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1899.193906622979, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18002, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1058.9411764705883, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51641809, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2868.6706477058106, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 649, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6481369, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2789, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20301398, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14559, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24802402, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 56640, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 115021, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6765.941176470588, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 985325263, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8566.481451213256, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 169264, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9956.70588235294, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 461246327, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2725.0113845826636, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4207258788, "stage_ordering_ns": 1290605585, "stage_eval_ns": 3553463380, "stage_threat_ns": 6519184744, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 866130, "root_tactical_annotations": 3172, "search_tactical_annotations": 862958, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 439263, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2310523895, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 787424, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3848290273, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 80966, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2323469387, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 219623, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 291284528, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 439246, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49904681, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 298916, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 438691052, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 407530, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1085977274, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 159684, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19181367, "child_limit_applications": 40427, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 40427, "child_cap_hits": 40427, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 40427, "child_moves_before_total": 3665217, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3665217, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 657272, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 657272, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.66260172656888, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.258243253271328, "tt_hits": 15757, "tt_cutoffs": 2872, "beta_cutoffs": 29277, "depth_sum": 79, "avg_depth": 4.647058823529412, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 79, "avg_effective_depth": 4.647058823529412, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6094.176470588235, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6564.764705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1883, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 560, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13534, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 66, 97, 98, 82, 126, 84, 129, 128, 140, 154, 142, 83, 157, 172, 85, 68, 110, 40, 54, 81, 80, 94, 141, 95, 93, 139, 109, 125, 111, 113, 108 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 11946, "avg_search_time_ms": 746.625, "search_nodes": 171401, "safety_nodes": 940, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 172341, "avg_nodes": 10771.3125, "eval_calls": 133721, "avg_eval_calls": 8357.5625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 133721, "pattern_eval_ns": 2622828, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.614181766513862, "pattern_frame_queries": 133721, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2622828, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.614181766513862, "pattern_frame_updates": 342658, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3524242378, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10285.014148217757, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35455, "avg_candidate_generations": 2215.9375, "candidate_moves_total": 2909128, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.0512762656889, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1257, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 35439, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2907871, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1117022, "avg_legality_checks": 69813.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2373, "root_legality_checks": 1257, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 1115765, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2366, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3683849, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 230240.5625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6763471482, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1835.9795643089606, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47582, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2973.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 267446474, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5620.748896641587, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3347, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33338859, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20995, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 158236075, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23184, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 75317239, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 56, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 554301, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 94533, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5908.3125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 776663003, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8215.787111379095, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 133016, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8313.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 353689931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2659.00290942443, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2237689833, "stage_ordering_ns": 987235313, "stage_eval_ns": 3526865206, "stage_threat_ns": 5125029591, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 590347, "root_tactical_annotations": 2747, "search_tactical_annotations": 587600, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 342674, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1640663328, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 520322, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3223114079, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70981, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2088599714, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 171329, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 208646391, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 342658, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35878314, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 173241, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 180346172, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 276089, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 953765501, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 141017, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16727479, "child_limit_applications": 35439, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35439, "child_cap_hits": 35439, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35439, "child_moves_before_total": 2905505, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2905505, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 576105, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 576105, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.98608877225655, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.256243121984255, "tt_hits": 14308, "tt_cutoffs": 2169, "beta_cutoffs": 26705, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5303.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5803.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 464, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 1574, "avg_search_time_ms": 104.93333333333334, "search_nodes": 123037, "safety_nodes": 1499, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 124536, "avg_nodes": 8302.4, "eval_calls": 118805, "avg_eval_calls": 7920.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 118805, "line_shape_eval_ns": 136931439, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1152.5730314380708, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4203, "avg_candidate_generations": 280.2, "candidate_moves_total": 363422, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.46728527242446, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1190, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 4188, "search_candidate_moves_total": 362232, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 13133, "avg_legality_checks": 875.5333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 13133, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 30734, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2048.9333333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 62018150, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2017.9003709247088, "renju_forbidden_checks": 77, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.133333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 823053, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10689.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 334201, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 488852, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 31808782, "stage_ordering_ns": 130981, "stage_eval_ns": 136931439, "stage_threat_ns": 1383087943, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 246001, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1207924127, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 41, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 328204, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15010, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 122993, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 148356430, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 245986, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26479182, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 291, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3714, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6627.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7160.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1946, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 561, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9577, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 98, 126, 67, 52, 125, 142, 94, 174, 158, 129, 130, 114, 96, 95, 100, 99, 144, 172, 111, 157, 187, 170, 156, 171, 173, 143, 115, 185 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 2268, "avg_search_time_ms": 151.2, "search_nodes": 147301, "safety_nodes": 1368, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148669, "avg_nodes": 9911.266666666666, "eval_calls": 143544, "avg_eval_calls": 9569.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 143544, "line_shape_eval_ns": 202609017, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1411.476738839659, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3728, "avg_candidate_generations": 248.53333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 329892, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.49034334763948, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1134, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3713, "search_candidate_moves_total": 328758, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 140786, "avg_legality_checks": 9385.733333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 149, "root_legality_checks": 1134, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 139652, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 148, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 158421, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10561.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 356156838, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2248.1668339424696, "renju_forbidden_checks": 155, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.333333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1363867, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8799.14193548387, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 149, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1320305, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 43562, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.533333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 558852, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10544.377358490567, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 73, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.866666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 290542, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3980.027397260274, "stage_move_gen_ns": 333188198, "stage_ordering_ns": 120550, "stage_eval_ns": 202609017, "stage_threat_ns": 1708453455, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 294529, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1493275098, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 776324, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14900, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147257, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 181845761, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 294514, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32556272, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 203, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3333, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6630.933333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7164.266666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1952, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 7296, "avg_search_time_ms": 486.4, "search_nodes": 67068, "safety_nodes": 1461, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68529, "avg_nodes": 4568.6, "eval_calls": 48186, "avg_eval_calls": 3212.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48186, "pattern_eval_ns": 976857, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.27263105466318, "pattern_frame_queries": 48186, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 976857, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.27263105466318, "pattern_frame_updates": 134002, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1391771391, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10386.198646288862, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17568, "avg_candidate_generations": 1171.2, "candidate_moves_total": 1407034, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.09073315118397, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1153, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 17553, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1405881, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 929076, "avg_legality_checks": 61938.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 137, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 929076, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 137, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2331100, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 155406.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4689721997, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2011.8064420230792, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21020, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1401.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 67133112, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3193.773168411037, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 247, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2064174, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4130, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38737142, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16638, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26277056, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 54740, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 88545, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5903.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 864881796, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9767.709029307132, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 121121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8074.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 425933091, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3516.5915984841604, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2147343133, "stage_ordering_ns": 553904724, "stage_eval_ns": 1392748248, "stage_threat_ns": 3153114940, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 323061, "root_tactical_annotations": 1465, "search_tactical_annotations": 321596, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 134017, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 770836030, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 276540, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2262833549, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35202, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1174662174, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67001, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 95358830, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 134002, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15980853, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 84214, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 370839570, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 157113, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 717029624, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 81734, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8105678, "child_limit_applications": 17553, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17553, "child_cap_hits": 17553, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17553, "child_moves_before_total": 1405744, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1405744, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 281301, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 281301, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.08568335896997, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02580755426423, "tt_hits": 7901, "tt_cutoffs": 1262, "beta_cutoffs": 14401, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6057.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6590.466666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1858, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 562, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12602, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 67, 127, 126, 143, 98, 84, 99, 100, 83, 115, 111, 125, 96, 95, 81, 141, 66 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 12159, "avg_search_time_ms": 1351.0, "search_nodes": 155341, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 155541, "avg_nodes": 17282.333333333332, "eval_calls": 125263, "avg_eval_calls": 13918.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 125263, "pattern_eval_ns": 2524162, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.150898509535935, "pattern_frame_queries": 125263, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2524162, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.150898509535935, "pattern_frame_updates": 310608, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3762971786, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12114.85791093597, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28577, "avg_candidate_generations": 3175.222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 2105297, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.67102914931588, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 559, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 28568, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2104738, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 968488, "avg_legality_checks": 107609.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1106, "root_legality_checks": 559, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 967929, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1106, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3368938, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 374326.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7131313476, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2116.7838280193937, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42363, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4707.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 182021201, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4296.702334584425, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1883, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12215305, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23844, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 133546517, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16629, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36242048, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 17331, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 104288, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11587.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 841692642, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8070.848438938325, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 135546, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15060.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 325209128, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2399.25285880808, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2320484947, "stage_ordering_ns": 863090696, "stage_eval_ns": 3765495948, "stage_threat_ns": 5166670621, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 461571, "root_tactical_annotations": 2134, "search_tactical_annotations": 459437, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 310617, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1724040439, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 414718, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3176319052, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 57190, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2012931695, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 155304, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 215735997, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 310608, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37024680, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 132628, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 177813900, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 224892, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 985449326, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 104051, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13550453, "child_limit_applications": 28568, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28568, "child_cap_hits": 28568, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28568, "child_moves_before_total": 2103632, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2103632, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 476831, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 476831, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.63595631475778, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.691087930551667, "tt_hits": 10432, "tt_cutoffs": 1473, "beta_cutoffs": 20482, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1261.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1914.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 433, "avg_search_time_ms": 54.125, "search_nodes": 31121, "safety_nodes": 745, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 31866, "avg_nodes": 3983.25, "eval_calls": 29797, "avg_eval_calls": 3724.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 29797, "line_shape_eval_ns": 20666068, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 693.5620364466222, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1309, "avg_candidate_generations": 163.625, "candidate_moves_total": 87159, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.58441558441558, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 499, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 1301, "search_candidate_moves_total": 86660, "search_candidate_moves_max": 86, "legality_checks": 3191, "avg_legality_checks": 398.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3191, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12604, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1575.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26728411, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2120.629244684227, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18100, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2585.714285714286, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2650, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 15450, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8709604, "stage_ordering_ns": 41380, "stage_eval_ns": 20666068, "stage_threat_ns": 393884528, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 62204, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 347333051, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 210271, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 31098, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 39080240, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 62196, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7260966, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 66, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1175, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5361.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6361.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1954, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 563, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12950, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 127, 142, 114, 115, 94, 96, 68, 140, 95, 138, 124, 158, 174, 141, 139, 143, 144, 154, 129, 159, 128, 156, 83, 98, 97, 125, 81, 65, 145 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 5093, "avg_search_time_ms": 318.3125, "search_nodes": 321820, "safety_nodes": 1276, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 323096, "avg_nodes": 20193.5, "eval_calls": 313757, "avg_eval_calls": 19609.8125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 313757, "line_shape_eval_ns": 400936985, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1277.8582947950165, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8033, "avg_candidate_generations": 502.0625, "candidate_moves_total": 675831, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.1318311963152, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1214, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 8017, "search_candidate_moves_total": 674617, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 305142, "avg_legality_checks": 19071.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3506, "root_legality_checks": 1214, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 303928, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3497, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 324029, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20251.8125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 755366232, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2331.168605279157, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3674, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 229.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 11327041, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3083.0269461077846, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3632, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11198751, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 128290, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.1875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 579423, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8648.10447761194, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 239042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2779.5581395348836, "stage_move_gen_ns": 749539228, "stage_ordering_ns": 252951, "stage_eval_ns": 400936985, "stage_threat_ns": 3921332349, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 643564, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3431229922, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 764244, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 321774, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 411609441, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 643548, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 77728742, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 397, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7340, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6527.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7027.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1893, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 7842, "avg_search_time_ms": 522.8, "search_nodes": 82649, "safety_nodes": 1318, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 83967, "avg_nodes": 5597.8, "eval_calls": 62697, "avg_eval_calls": 4179.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62697, "pattern_eval_ns": 1299107, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.72040129511779, "pattern_frame_queries": 62697, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1299107, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.72040129511779, "pattern_frame_updates": 165158, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1490829132, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9026.68433863331, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18800, "avg_candidate_generations": 1253.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1609210, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.59627659574468, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1143, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 18785, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1608067, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 997585, "avg_legality_checks": 66505.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3849, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 997585, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3849, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2396470, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 159764.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4880096507, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2036.3687035514736, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14710, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 980.6666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64570804, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4389.58558803535, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3875, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30079329, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3459, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20648974, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7326, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13684710, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 157791, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90573, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6038.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 772342985, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8527.298256654853, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118638, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7909.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 329529838, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2777.607832229134, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2333538566, "stage_ordering_ns": 638089182, "stage_eval_ns": 1492128239, "stage_threat_ns": 3325445013, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 322525, "root_tactical_annotations": 1536, "search_tactical_annotations": 320989, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 165173, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 937144483, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 284572, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2243631446, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37670, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1255399664, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 82579, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 115763348, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 165158, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20413620, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96297, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 396552623, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 150595, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 591406329, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 75633, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8492116, "child_limit_applications": 18785, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18785, "child_cap_hits": 18785, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18785, "child_moves_before_total": 1604218, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1604218, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 301003, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 301003, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.39888208677137, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.023582645727974, "tt_hits": 7979, "tt_cutoffs": 1097, "beta_cutoffs": 14677, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6063.933333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6597.266666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1867, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 564, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22229, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 96, 94, 142, 114, 128, 80, 144, 160, 145, 143, 129, 161, 81, 97, 130, 78, 62, 127, 158, 116, 131, 132, 117, 159, 89, 103, 98, 95, 66, 51, 65, 146, 68, 83, 67, 69, 64 ], "move_count": 43, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 17812, "avg_search_time_ms": 890.6, "search_nodes": 234776, "safety_nodes": 1081, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 235857, "avg_nodes": 11792.85, "eval_calls": 173922, "avg_eval_calls": 8696.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 173922, "pattern_eval_ns": 3490869, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.071463069651912, "pattern_frame_queries": 173922, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3490869, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.071463069651912, "pattern_frame_updates": 469368, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4826810027, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10283.636777539159, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 57286, "avg_candidate_generations": 2864.3, "candidate_moves_total": 5255524, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.74185664909402, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1613, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 57266, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5253911, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1625143, "avg_legality_checks": 81257.15, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1781, "root_legality_checks": 1613, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1623530, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1779, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5212644, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 260632.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10085287127, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1934.7738167041525, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33349, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1667.45, "renju_forbidden_ns": 192946925, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5785.688476416084, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1933, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18065008, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14745, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 115371544, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16651, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 59427703, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 82670, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 114009, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5700.45, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 881661661, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7733.263698479945, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 149115, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7455.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 373536422, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2505.022445763337, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3405301424, "stage_ordering_ns": 1841604546, "stage_eval_ns": 4830300896, "stage_threat_ns": 7641264449, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1230390, "root_tactical_annotations": 5018, "search_tactical_annotations": 1225372, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 469388, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2343308514, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1091097, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4911180410, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 114663, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3366197844, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 234684, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 307174526, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 469368, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51943372, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 471899, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 288537497, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 504517, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1256073477, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 253974, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 27657627, "child_limit_applications": 57266, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 57266, "child_cap_hits": 57266, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 57266, "child_moves_before_total": 5252132, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5252132, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 929728, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 929728, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.71466489714665, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.23525302972095, "tt_hits": 24564, "tt_cutoffs": 3496, "beta_cutoffs": 45849, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6106.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6506.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 4399, "avg_search_time_ms": 231.52631578947367, "search_nodes": 333089, "safety_nodes": 1801, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 334890, "avg_nodes": 17625.78947368421, "eval_calls": 325650, "avg_eval_calls": 17139.473684210527, "line_shape_eval_calls": 325650, "line_shape_eval_ns": 641728940, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1970.6093658836173, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7402, "avg_candidate_generations": 389.57894736842104, "candidate_moves_total": 689596, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.1634693326128, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1532, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 7383, "search_candidate_moves_total": 688064, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 15189, "avg_legality_checks": 799.421052631579, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 15189, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 37046, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1949.7894736842106, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 75310954, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2032.9037952815418, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 93710, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4932.105263157895, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 28210, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 65500, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 38399844, "stage_ordering_ns": 225661, "stage_eval_ns": 641728940, "stage_threat_ns": 3680441416, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 666085, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3205869056, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 50, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 384520, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20100, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 333033, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 400600549, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 666066, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 73587291, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 340, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6734, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6856.421052631579, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7277.473684210527, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1970, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 565, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10448, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 96, 128, 109, 108, 143, 114, 100, 156, 170, 124, 140, 130, 125, 155, 95, 80, 127, 79, 159 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1181, "avg_search_time_ms": 107.36363636363636, "search_nodes": 73393, "safety_nodes": 1121, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 74514, "avg_nodes": 6774.0, "eval_calls": 70994, "avg_eval_calls": 6454.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 70994, "line_shape_eval_ns": 53866269, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 758.7439642786715, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2379, "avg_candidate_generations": 216.27272727272728, "candidate_moves_total": 163510, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.73055905842791, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 743, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 2368, "search_candidate_moves_total": 162767, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 69687, "avg_legality_checks": 6335.181818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "root_legality_checks": 743, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 68944, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 82810, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7528.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 194015550, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2342.9000120758365, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.090909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 426861, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9485.8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 247521, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 179340, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 871933, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11472.802631578947, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 116, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.545454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 478531, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4125.267241379311, "stage_move_gen_ns": 172866282, "stage_ordering_ns": 69361, "stage_eval_ns": 53866269, "stage_threat_ns": 942991106, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 146735, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 830611713, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1116383, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10930, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 73362, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93328901, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 146724, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17934109, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 119, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2135, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5946.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6673.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1901, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9256, "avg_search_time_ms": 925.6, "search_nodes": 95004, "safety_nodes": 391, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 95395, "avg_nodes": 9539.5, "eval_calls": 73996, "avg_eval_calls": 7399.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73996, "pattern_eval_ns": 1497145, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.232782853127198, "pattern_frame_queries": 73996, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1497145, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.232782853127198, "pattern_frame_updates": 189918, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2172688819, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11440.141634810812, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19766, "avg_candidate_generations": 1976.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1635491, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.74263887483558, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 678, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 19756, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1634813, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1022128, "avg_legality_checks": 102212.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5057, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1022128, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5057, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2728368, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 272836.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5655580594, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2072.880415691725, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27937, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2793.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 218668628, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7827.205068547088, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5075, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53317086, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13629, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 133328955, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9213, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31807835, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 214752, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89376, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8937.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 912279382, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10207.207550125313, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132085, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13208.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 461260503, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3492.1490176780103, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2467908679, "stage_ordering_ns": 676333872, "stage_eval_ns": 2174185964, "stage_threat_ns": 3894291667, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 365045, "root_tactical_annotations": 1696, "search_tactical_annotations": 363349, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 189928, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1104887624, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 306619, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2619889493, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 39577, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1446189018, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 94959, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 134030020, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 189918, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23589298, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 89538, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 392135120, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 177498, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 781517185, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 98009, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11895232, "child_limit_applications": 19756, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19756, "child_cap_hits": 19756, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19756, "child_moves_before_total": 1629756, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1629756, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 316378, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 316378, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.49422960113384, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.014274144563675, "tt_hits": 8547, "tt_cutoffs": 1207, "beta_cutoffs": 14896, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4446.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5246.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1871, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 566, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11957, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 83, 144, 96, 95, 97, 127, 99, 100, 143, 129, 68, 53, 126, 80, 65, 109, 108, 79, 63, 81, 67, 78, 82, 77 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 11359, "avg_search_time_ms": 811.3571428571429, "search_nodes": 135782, "safety_nodes": 365, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 136147, "avg_nodes": 9724.785714285714, "eval_calls": 99942, "avg_eval_calls": 7138.714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 99942, "pattern_eval_ns": 2044665, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.458515939244762, "pattern_frame_queries": 99942, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2044665, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.458515939244762, "pattern_frame_updates": 271440, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3042346863, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11208.17441423519, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34209, "avg_candidate_generations": 2443.5, "candidate_moves_total": 2716483, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.4084305299775, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 922, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 34195, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2715561, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 807472, "avg_legality_checks": 57676.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1456, "root_legality_checks": 922, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 806550, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1454, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3140848, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 224346.2857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6522155828, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2076.5588872813964, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25703, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1835.9285714285713, "renju_forbidden_ns": 101927413, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3965.584289771622, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1619, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14121865, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11620, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 63535642, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12454, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24167335, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 102571, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 102689, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7334.928571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 842902686, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8208.305524447604, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 135370, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9669.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 342946695, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2533.402489473295, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1916479043, "stage_ordering_ns": 1076273489, "stage_eval_ns": 3044391528, "stage_threat_ns": 5278385338, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 566726, "root_tactical_annotations": 3192, "search_tactical_annotations": 563534, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 271454, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1538357216, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 497236, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3501517508, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 68479, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2309728765, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 135720, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 188737454, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 271440, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33202218, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 181121, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 291849391, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 247625, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 899770291, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 137980, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16570942, "child_limit_applications": 34195, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34195, "child_cap_hits": 34195, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34195, "child_moves_before_total": 2714107, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2714107, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 548998, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 548998, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.3714578154701, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.05492030998684, "tt_hits": 15312, "tt_cutoffs": 1583, "beta_cutoffs": 27802, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5441.071428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6012.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 944, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 584, "avg_search_time_ms": 44.92307692307692, "search_nodes": 40711, "safety_nodes": 1167, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 41878, "avg_nodes": 3221.3846153846152, "eval_calls": 38391, "avg_eval_calls": 2953.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 38391, "line_shape_eval_ns": 36232745, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 943.7822666770858, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2295, "avg_candidate_generations": 176.53846153846155, "candidate_moves_total": 161562, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.39738562091503, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 861, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 2282, "search_candidate_moves_total": 160701, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 5169, "avg_legality_checks": 397.61538461538464, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5169, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20211, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1554.6923076923076, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 42474951, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2101.575924001781, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.0769230769230769, "renju_forbidden_ns": 152171, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10869.357142857143, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 67480, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 84691, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13930744, "stage_ordering_ns": 71680, "stage_eval_ns": 36232745, "stage_threat_ns": 518107918, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 81359, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 457769855, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 328422, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40673, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 50378922, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 81346, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9630719, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 135, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2045, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6407.538461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7022.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 567, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9731, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 111, 143, 98, 144, 82, 67, 141, 158, 173, 130, 172, 174, 190, 110, 156, 126 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 363, "avg_search_time_ms": 40.333333333333336, "search_nodes": 21849, "safety_nodes": 618, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 22467, "avg_nodes": 2496.3333333333335, "eval_calls": 20784, "avg_eval_calls": 2309.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 20784, "line_shape_eval_ns": 18200048, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 875.6759045419553, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1048, "avg_candidate_generations": 116.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_total": 65199, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.212786259541986, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 506, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 1039, "search_candidate_moves_total": 64693, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 16401, "avg_legality_checks": 1822.3333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 81, "root_legality_checks": 506, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 15895, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 70, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26959, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2995.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 61495483, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2281.0743351014503, "renju_forbidden_checks": 127, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 14.11111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1455893, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11463.72440944882, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 81, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 944112, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 46, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 511781, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7.111111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 745423, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11647.234375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.222222222222221, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 404742, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4399.369565217391, "stage_move_gen_ns": 42290874, "stage_ordering_ns": 32520, "stage_eval_ns": 18200048, "stage_threat_ns": 290392068, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 43655, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 256262801, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 944974, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 21823, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 27883683, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 43646, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5300610, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 86, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 893, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5716.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6605.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1942, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9360, "avg_search_time_ms": 1040.0, "search_nodes": 93655, "safety_nodes": 205, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 93860, "avg_nodes": 10428.888888888889, "eval_calls": 74014, "avg_eval_calls": 8223.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74014, "pattern_eval_ns": 1517580, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.503958710514226, "pattern_frame_queries": 74014, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1517580, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.503958710514226, "pattern_frame_updates": 187232, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2630921937, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14051.668181721074, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18347, "avg_candidate_generations": 2038.5555555555557, "candidate_moves_total": 1341427, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.11424211042677, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 531, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 18338, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1340896, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 788005, "avg_legality_checks": 87556.11111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12424, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 788005, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12424, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2697862, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 299762.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5544822290, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2055.2653508593103, "renju_forbidden_checks": 66657, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7406.333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 525086524, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7877.440088812878, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12461, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 129172380, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 32177, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 311281570, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21952, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 83876551, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 756023, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 108388, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12043.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1200309808, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11074.194634092335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 159050, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17672.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 641152138, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4031.135730902232, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2032905987, "stage_ordering_ns": 546264975, "stage_eval_ns": 2632439517, "stage_threat_ns": 4113513075, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 416130, "root_tactical_annotations": 1658, "search_tactical_annotations": 414472, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 187241, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1076274076, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 359678, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2867416597, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36732, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1366703423, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 93616, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 134290362, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 187232, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23027015, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 124854, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 618855617, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 198085, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 881804207, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 93191, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12505025, "child_limit_applications": 18338, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18338, "child_cap_hits": 18338, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18338, "child_moves_before_total": 1328472, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1328472, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 309646, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 309646, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.443668884284, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.88548369505944, "tt_hits": 7574, "tt_cutoffs": 1264, "beta_cutoffs": 13689, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4197.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5086.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1840, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 568, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12593, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 98, 114, 142, 97, 84, 126, 81, 129, 82, 83, 69, 144, 159, 130, 70, 56, 68, 145, 161, 131, 132, 67, 99, 100, 54, 39, 96, 40, 110 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 10483, "avg_search_time_ms": 698.8666666666667, "search_nodes": 149342, "safety_nodes": 722, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 150064, "avg_nodes": 10004.266666666666, "eval_calls": 110894, "avg_eval_calls": 7392.933333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110894, "pattern_eval_ns": 2218860, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.008837268021715, "pattern_frame_queries": 110894, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2218860, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.008837268021715, "pattern_frame_updates": 298550, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2865452041, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9597.896637079217, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 36209, "avg_candidate_generations": 2413.9333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 2738064, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.61832693529233, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1011, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 36194, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2737053, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1064940, "avg_legality_checks": 70996.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1949, "root_legality_checks": 1011, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1063929, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1946, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3608136, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 240542.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6018991280, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1668.1719536070702, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29516, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1967.7333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 96702125, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3276.261180376745, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2050, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10691640, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13040, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 65479377, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14409, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20419857, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 111251, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 110777, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7385.133333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 683363359, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6168.819872356175, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 141801, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9453.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 282022382, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1988.8603183334392, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1970188568, "stage_ordering_ns": 857507984, "stage_eval_ns": 2867670901, "stage_threat_ns": 4733909853, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 662943, "root_tactical_annotations": 2682, "search_tactical_annotations": 660261, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 298565, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1430891059, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 575409, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3066191335, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 72484, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2044180969, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 149275, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 191106276, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 298550, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31311696, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 197994, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 178919301, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 304919, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 842828604, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 160030, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14409487, "child_limit_applications": 36194, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 36194, "child_cap_hits": 36194, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 36194, "child_moves_before_total": 2735107, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2735107, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 584110, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 584110, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.56796706636459, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.138310217163067, "tt_hits": 15043, "tt_cutoffs": 2187, "beta_cutoffs": 29033, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5189.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5722.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 702, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2096, "avg_search_time_ms": 149.71428571428572, "search_nodes": 228518, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 229557, "avg_nodes": 16396.928571428572, "eval_calls": 222812, "avg_eval_calls": 15915.142857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 222812, "line_shape_eval_ns": 168939375, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 758.2148851946932, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5679, "avg_candidate_generations": 405.64285714285717, "candidate_moves_total": 433505, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.3347420320479, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 955, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 5665, "search_candidate_moves_total": 432550, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 11673, "avg_legality_checks": 833.7857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11673, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27590, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1970.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 43705993, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1584.124429140993, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.357142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 207183, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6278.272727272727, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 137802, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 69381, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22930007, "stage_ordering_ns": 173740, "stage_eval_ns": 168939375, "stage_threat_ns": 1888654555, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 456968, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1619510082, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 218291, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 228477, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 230853230, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 456954, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38072952, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 327, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5133, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6525.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7096.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1917, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 569, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6429, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 96, 128, 125, 143, 109, 108, 98, 129, 130, 145, 161, 81, 146, 97 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 486, "avg_search_time_ms": 60.75, "search_nodes": 45282, "safety_nodes": 474, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 45756, "avg_nodes": 5719.5, "eval_calls": 43622, "avg_eval_calls": 5452.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 43622, "line_shape_eval_ns": 19871363, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 455.5353491357572, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1645, "avg_candidate_generations": 205.625, "candidate_moves_total": 95741, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.20121580547112, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 425, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 1637, "search_candidate_moves_total": 95316, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 40290, "avg_legality_checks": 5036.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 152, "root_legality_checks": 425, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 39865, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 144, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 49576, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6197.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 77445099, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1562.149003550105, "renju_forbidden_checks": 186, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 23.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1621764, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8719.161290322581, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 152, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1280733, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 341031, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 497171, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9560.98076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 273351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3693.9324324324325, "stage_move_gen_ns": 66257731, "stage_ordering_ns": 48881, "stage_eval_ns": 19871363, "stage_threat_ns": 389259062, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 90526, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 337008444, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 643963, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 45259, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 43331733, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 90518, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8274922, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 84, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1460, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5366.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6366.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1958, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5935, "avg_search_time_ms": 741.875, "search_nodes": 66454, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 66654, "avg_nodes": 8331.75, "eval_calls": 51784, "avg_eval_calls": 6473.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51784, "pattern_eval_ns": 1074554, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.75069519542716, "pattern_frame_queries": 51784, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1074554, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.75069519542716, "pattern_frame_updates": 132840, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1766752526, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13299.85340258958, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13666, "avg_candidate_generations": 1708.25, "candidate_moves_total": 957885, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.09256549099956, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 450, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 13658, "search_candidate_moves_total": 957435, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 571150, "avg_legality_checks": 71393.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8377, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 571150, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8377, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1953106, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 244138.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3467155655, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1775.2009645149828, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41742, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5217.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 336807558, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8068.793014230272, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8410, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 82947517, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22222, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 206864364, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11060, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 46578625, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 417052, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74480, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9310.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 691679347, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9286.779632116004, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 108546, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13568.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 365583043, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3368.001059458663, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1253976973, "stage_ordering_ns": 341171020, "stage_eval_ns": 1767827080, "stage_threat_ns": 2549016994, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 288772, "root_tactical_annotations": 1288, "search_tactical_annotations": 287484, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 132848, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 698473755, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 247316, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1735517033, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27365, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 862517999, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91669936, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 132840, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15371289, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 78449, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 343521575, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 141496, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 529441549, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 68827, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7984981, "child_limit_applications": 13658, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13658, "child_cap_hits": 13658, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13658, "child_moves_before_total": 949058, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 949058, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 226833, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 226833, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.48733343095621, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.60806853126373, "tt_hits": 5706, "tt_cutoffs": 978, "beta_cutoffs": 10393, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4703.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5703.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1909, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 570, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3654, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 99, 141, 128, 109, 108, 93, 77, 157 ], "move_count": 15, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 3186, "avg_search_time_ms": 531.0, "search_nodes": 37202, "safety_nodes": 166, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 37368, "avg_nodes": 6228.0, "eval_calls": 28838, "avg_eval_calls": 4806.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 28838, "pattern_eval_ns": 618227, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.437929121298286, "pattern_frame_queries": 28838, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 618227, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.437929121298286, "pattern_frame_updates": 74360, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 955155301, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12845.014806347499, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7891, "avg_candidate_generations": 1315.1666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 497914, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.09897351413002, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 304, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 7885, "search_candidate_moves_total": 497610, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 203056, "avg_legality_checks": 33842.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 91, "root_legality_checks": 304, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 202752, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 91, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 813057, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 135509.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1870297910, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2300.3281565745083, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5717, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 952.8333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29164626, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5101.386391464054, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 93, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 851382, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2720, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21821463, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2904, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6491781, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21064, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3510.6666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 213287292, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10125.678503608051, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 29629, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4938.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 101509539, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3426.0197441695636, "stage_move_gen_ns": 522836916, "stage_ordering_ns": 226720992, "stage_eval_ns": 955773528, "stage_threat_ns": 1469244028, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 80428, "root_tactical_annotations": 701, "search_tactical_annotations": 79727, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 74366, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 461933775, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 77685, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 937570326, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15803, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 656404785, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 57538236, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 74360, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10151728, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 16422, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 41607302, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 45455, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 239403518, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 18551, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2049963, "child_limit_applications": 7885, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 7885, "child_cap_hits": 7885, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 7885, "child_moves_before_total": 497519, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 497519, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 126174, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 126174, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 63.096892834495875, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001775523145213, "tt_hits": 3299, "tt_cutoffs": 457, "beta_cutoffs": 5992, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3008.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4342.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1191, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 7, "search_move_count": 5, "total_time_ms": 464, "avg_search_time_ms": 92.8, "search_nodes": 31494, "safety_nodes": 190, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 31684, "avg_nodes": 6336.8, "eval_calls": 30026, "avg_eval_calls": 6005.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 30026, "line_shape_eval_ns": 22677238, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 755.2533804036502, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1459, "avg_candidate_generations": 291.8, "candidate_moves_total": 87557, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.01165181631254, "candidate_moves_max": 78, "root_candidate_generations": 5, "root_candidate_moves_total": 248, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 1454, "search_candidate_moves_total": 87309, "search_candidate_moves_max": 78, "legality_checks": 3197, "avg_legality_checks": 639.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3197, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8833, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1766.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20793348, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2354.0527567078, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9422099, "stage_ordering_ns": 47451, "stage_eval_ns": 22677238, "stage_threat_ns": 427833120, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 62965, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 375396169, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 55490, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 10, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 31480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 44383864, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 62960, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7997597, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 95, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1282, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3780.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5380.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 571, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9429, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 98, 126, 81, 125, 67, 52, 128, 141, 156, 109, 157, 155, 169, 99, 143, 113 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 372, "avg_search_time_ms": 41.333333333333336, "search_nodes": 21728, "safety_nodes": 618, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 22346, "avg_nodes": 2482.8888888888887, "eval_calls": 20658, "avg_eval_calls": 2295.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 20658, "line_shape_eval_ns": 18933103, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 916.5022267402459, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1053, "avg_candidate_generations": 117.0, "candidate_moves_total": 65420, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.12725546058879, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 506, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 1044, "search_candidate_moves_total": 64914, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 16272, "avg_legality_checks": 1808.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 76, "root_legality_checks": 506, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 15766, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 65, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26804, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2978.222222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 62317352, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2324.927324279958, "renju_forbidden_checks": 122, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 13.555555555555555, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1402377, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11494.893442622952, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 76, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 888006, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 46, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 514371, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7.111111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 764784, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11949.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.222222222222221, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 419461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4559.358695652174, "stage_move_gen_ns": 42253737, "stage_ordering_ns": 38530, "stage_eval_ns": 18933103, "stage_threat_ns": 299770145, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 43413, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 262802828, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 980656, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9670, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 21702, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 30638589, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 43404, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5348072, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 86, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 898, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5713.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6601.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1938, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9049, "avg_search_time_ms": 1005.4444444444445, "search_nodes": 93066, "safety_nodes": 205, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 93271, "avg_nodes": 10363.444444444445, "eval_calls": 73764, "avg_eval_calls": 8196.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73764, "pattern_eval_ns": 1566676, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.239032590423513, "pattern_frame_queries": 73764, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1566676, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.239032590423513, "pattern_frame_updates": 186054, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2523685480, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13564.26349339439, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18062, "avg_candidate_generations": 2006.888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 1313233, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.70695382571144, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 531, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 18053, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1312702, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 778161, "avg_legality_checks": 86462.33333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12095, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 778161, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12095, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2658188, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 295354.22222222225, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5341910462, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2009.6059654170435, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65481, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7275.666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 498249269, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7609.066278767887, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12423, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 124262695, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 31024, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 292403426, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21967, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 80820825, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 762323, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 107836, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11981.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1181048962, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10952.26976148967, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 158594, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17621.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 632686825, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3989.3490611246325, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1970509647, "stage_ordering_ns": 511742238, "stage_eval_ns": 2525252156, "stage_threat_ns": 4007029154, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 412470, "root_tactical_annotations": 1658, "search_tactical_annotations": 410812, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 186063, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1059933262, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 355675, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2773286430, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36162, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1299680344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 93027, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 138420480, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 186054, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22948128, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 123901, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 612630908, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 195605, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 860919828, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 92964, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12440854, "child_limit_applications": 18053, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18053, "child_cap_hits": 18053, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18053, "child_moves_before_total": 1300607, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1300607, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 304902, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 304902, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.04381543233812, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.889270481360438, "tt_hits": 7508, "tt_cutoffs": 1210, "beta_cutoffs": 13419, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4348.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5236.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1839, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 572, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14780, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 81, 95, 127, 82, 129, 113, 126, 128, 98, 84, 157, 142, 143, 115, 154, 140, 156, 155, 125, 68, 171, 185, 141, 186, 173, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 14216, "avg_search_time_ms": 1015.4285714285714, "search_nodes": 185054, "safety_nodes": 579, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 185633, "avg_nodes": 13259.5, "eval_calls": 148576, "avg_eval_calls": 10612.57142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 148576, "pattern_eval_ns": 3232292, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.755142149472324, "pattern_frame_queries": 148576, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3232292, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.755142149472324, "pattern_frame_updates": 369984, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4422274994, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11952.611448062618, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34391, "avg_candidate_generations": 2456.5, "candidate_moves_total": 2537438, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.78203599779012, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 893, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 34377, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2536545, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1018319, "avg_legality_checks": 72737.07142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 414, "root_legality_checks": 893, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1017426, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 414, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3574377, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 255312.64285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8105438194, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2267.6506126801955, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22200, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1585.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 74590152, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3359.916756756757, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 531, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4259149, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10667, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 54869572, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10998, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15455491, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5940, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 80625, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5758.928571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 687467840, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8526.732899224806, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 100989, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7213.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 264757252, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2621.6444563269265, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2536529451, "stage_ordering_ns": 1078411884, "stage_eval_ns": 4425507286, "stage_threat_ns": 6126985895, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 577140, "root_tactical_annotations": 2849, "search_tactical_annotations": 574291, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 369998, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2188436827, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 502439, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3592412018, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 68843, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2487212074, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 184992, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 279222095, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 369984, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49312042, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 150723, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 152250509, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 282860, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 952683513, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 143557, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17602913, "child_limit_applications": 34377, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34377, "child_cap_hits": 34377, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34377, "child_moves_before_total": 2536131, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2536131, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 550077, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 550077, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.77406405445501, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001309014748234, "tt_hits": 14398, "tt_cutoffs": 2039, "beta_cutoffs": 24569, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4239.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4810.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 711, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 553, "avg_search_time_ms": 42.53846153846154, "search_nodes": 35577, "safety_nodes": 1059, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 36636, "avg_nodes": 2818.153846153846, "eval_calls": 34013, "avg_eval_calls": 2616.3846153846152, "line_shape_eval_calls": 34013, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44539172, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1309.474965454385, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1539, "avg_candidate_generations": 118.38461538461539, "candidate_moves_total": 109914, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.41910331384015, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 843, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 1526, "search_candidate_moves_total": 109071, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 5984, "avg_legality_checks": 460.3076923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5984, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20945, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1611.1538461538462, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 46469219, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2218.6306517068515, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16197867, "stage_ordering_ns": 55691, "stage_eval_ns": 44539172, "stage_threat_ns": 477442757, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 71091, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 418052377, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 253572, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35539, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 50325081, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 71078, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8811727, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 128, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1345, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6427.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7042.538461538462, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1920, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 573, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10418, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 127, 99, 96, 84, 110, 109, 129, 100, 101, 68, 116, 86, 72, 142, 130, 128 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1023, "avg_search_time_ms": 113.66666666666667, "search_nodes": 60924, "safety_nodes": 618, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 61542, "avg_nodes": 6838.0, "eval_calls": 58889, "avg_eval_calls": 6543.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 58889, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44051914, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 748.0499583963049, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2018, "avg_candidate_generations": 224.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 119271, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.10356788899901, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 506, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 2009, "search_candidate_moves_total": 118765, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 53268, "avg_legality_checks": 5918.666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 63, "root_legality_checks": 506, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 52762, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 52, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 63826, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7091.777777777777, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 159182235, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2494.002992510889, "renju_forbidden_checks": 109, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12.11111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1228968, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11274.935779816513, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 63, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 725365, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 46, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 503603, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7.111111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 773455, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12085.234375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.222222222222221, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 414073, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4500.79347826087, "stage_move_gen_ns": 141235317, "stage_ordering_ns": 66890, "stage_eval_ns": 44051914, "stage_threat_ns": 827505327, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 121805, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 724980377, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 992987, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9752, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 60898, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 86031268, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 121796, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15500695, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 86, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1783, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5504.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6393.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1914, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9388, "avg_search_time_ms": 1043.111111111111, "search_nodes": 90357, "safety_nodes": 205, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 90562, "avg_nodes": 10062.444444444445, "eval_calls": 71803, "avg_eval_calls": 7978.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71803, "pattern_eval_ns": 1572243, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.89661991838781, "pattern_frame_queries": 71803, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1572243, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.89661991838781, "pattern_frame_updates": 180636, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2600661975, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14397.251793662394, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17333, "avg_candidate_generations": 1925.888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 1274913, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.55408757860728, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 531, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 17324, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1274382, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 774640, "avg_legality_checks": 86071.11111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12362, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 774640, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12362, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2597454, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 288606.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5597766474, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2155.097443111601, "renju_forbidden_checks": 52394, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5821.555555555556, "renju_forbidden_ns": 480004942, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9161.448677329465, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16268, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 171556537, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23358, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 238705442, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12701, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 68997600, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 745363, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 103664, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11518.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1172518546, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11310.759241395277, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 151880, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16875.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 598180231, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3938.5056031077165, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2117392511, "stage_ordering_ns": 537847728, "stage_eval_ns": 2602234218, "stage_threat_ns": 4096015784, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 411517, "root_tactical_annotations": 1658, "search_tactical_annotations": 409859, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 180645, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1102847891, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 348280, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2814518282, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34704, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1335841897, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 90318, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 140744306, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 180636, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24609371, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 119510, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 573363363, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 194059, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 905256932, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 97948, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13295934, "child_limit_applications": 17324, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17324, "child_cap_hits": 17324, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17324, "child_moves_before_total": 1262020, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1262020, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 288712, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 288712, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.84807203879012, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.665435234356963, "tt_hits": 7429, "tt_cutoffs": 1191, "beta_cutoffs": 12793, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4182.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5071.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1864, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 574, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5919, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 82, 66, 81, 80, 128, 94, 52, 109, 110, 64, 48, 79, 49, 124 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5393, "avg_search_time_ms": 599.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 64126, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 64284, "avg_nodes": 7142.666666666667, "eval_calls": 46456, "avg_eval_calls": 5161.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46456, "pattern_eval_ns": 1009184, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.72343723092819, "pattern_frame_queries": 46456, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1009184, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.72343723092819, "pattern_frame_updates": 128178, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1402659456, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10943.059308149604, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16670, "avg_candidate_generations": 1852.2222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 1128284, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.68350329934013, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 16661, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1127784, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 362360, "avg_legality_checks": 40262.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 177, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 361860, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 176, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1351710, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 150190.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3082166180, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2280.1978087015705, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12570, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1396.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 54161657, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4308.803261734288, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 427, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2456352, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5872, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37688518, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6266, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13956267, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 60520, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 31126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3458.4444444444443, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 282181503, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9065.78111546617, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40552, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4505.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 117275047, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2891.9670299861905, "stage_move_gen_ns": 924448068, "stage_ordering_ns": 466882166, "stage_eval_ns": 1403668640, "stage_threat_ns": 2576213055, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 224973, "root_tactical_annotations": 1636, "search_tactical_annotations": 223337, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 128187, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 782000702, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 199632, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1672473288, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33376, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1249296191, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64089, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 98497801, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128178, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17199087, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70507, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 59947576, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 95741, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 363084920, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 58725, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6042177, "child_limit_applications": 16661, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16661, "child_cap_hits": 16661, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16661, "child_moves_before_total": 1127608, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1127608, "child_moves_before_max": 97, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 97, "child_moves_after_total": 266589, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 266589, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.67949102694917, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0007802652902, "tt_hits": 7726, "tt_cutoffs": 972, "beta_cutoffs": 13620, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4487.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5376.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1247, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 518, "avg_search_time_ms": 64.75, "search_nodes": 35108, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35704, "avg_nodes": 4463.0, "eval_calls": 33899, "avg_eval_calls": 4237.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 33899, "line_shape_eval_ns": 30176679, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 890.1937815274787, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1194, "avg_candidate_generations": 149.25, "candidate_moves_total": 76195, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.814907872696814, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1186, "search_candidate_moves_total": 75748, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 2613, "avg_legality_checks": 326.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2613, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11724, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1465.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26491480, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2259.593995223473, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 79410, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7219.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 67980, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7829334, "stage_ordering_ns": 39011, "stage_eval_ns": 30176679, "stage_threat_ns": 470749517, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 70178, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 413534566, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 180300, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35085, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 48311948, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 70170, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8722703, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1085, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5413.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6413.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 575, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8872, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 113, 141, 96, 140, 82, 67, 143, 156, 171, 124, 172, 170, 184, 114, 158, 128 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 341, "avg_search_time_ms": 37.888888888888886, "search_nodes": 21953, "safety_nodes": 618, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 22571, "avg_nodes": 2507.8888888888887, "eval_calls": 20883, "avg_eval_calls": 2320.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 20883, "line_shape_eval_ns": 16828762, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 805.8594071732989, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1053, "avg_candidate_generations": 117.0, "candidate_moves_total": 65460, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.16524216524216, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 506, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 1044, "search_candidate_moves_total": 64954, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 16472, "avg_legality_checks": 1830.2222222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 76, "root_legality_checks": 506, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 15966, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 65, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27030, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3003.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 59088073, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2186.018238993711, "renju_forbidden_checks": 122, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 13.555555555555555, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1307440, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10716.72131147541, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 76, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 822378, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 46, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 485062, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7.111111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 712203, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11128.171875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.222222222222221, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 384941, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4184.141304347826, "stage_move_gen_ns": 40585985, "stage_ordering_ns": 35020, "stage_eval_ns": 16828762, "stage_threat_ns": 272873717, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 43863, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 239925161, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 905555, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8921, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 21927, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 27051867, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 43854, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4991134, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 86, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 898, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5718.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6607.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1944, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8524, "avg_search_time_ms": 947.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 93290, "safety_nodes": 205, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 93495, "avg_nodes": 10388.333333333334, "eval_calls": 73922, "avg_eval_calls": 8213.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73922, "pattern_eval_ns": 1721651, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 23.29010308162658, "pattern_frame_queries": 73922, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1721651, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 23.29010308162658, "pattern_frame_updates": 186502, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2313702297, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12405.777401850919, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18110, "avg_candidate_generations": 2012.2222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 1328836, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.37581446714522, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 531, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 18101, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1328305, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 788393, "avg_legality_checks": 87599.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12161, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 788393, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12161, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2685944, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 298438.22222222225, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5085505759, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1893.3774341535043, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65718, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7302.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 452216042, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6881.159530113516, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12476, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 118054845, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 31098, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 258306700, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22077, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 75160593, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 693904, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 108292, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12032.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1140483875, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10531.561657370812, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 159262, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17695.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 612888172, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3848.301365046276, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1918441717, "stage_ordering_ns": 481894981, "stage_eval_ns": 2315423948, "stage_threat_ns": 3768714416, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 414461, "root_tactical_annotations": 1658, "search_tactical_annotations": 412803, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 186511, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 966479097, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 357767, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2647206646, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36258, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1234138871, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 93251, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 123178503, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 186502, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20946188, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 124255, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 578844032, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 197247, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 834175613, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 92959, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10903982, "child_limit_applications": 18101, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18101, "child_cap_hits": 18101, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18101, "child_moves_before_total": 1316144, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1316144, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 305849, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 305849, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.71112093254516, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.896801281697144, "tt_hits": 7525, "tt_cutoffs": 1228, "beta_cutoffs": 13463, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4460.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5349.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1849, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 576, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13287, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 96, 110, 142, 97, 144, 128, 141, 143, 113, 99, 172, 157, 158, 130, 169, 155, 171, 170, 140, 83, 186, 200, 156, 201, 188, 124, 204 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 12762, "avg_search_time_ms": 911.5714285714286, "search_nodes": 185479, "safety_nodes": 551, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 186030, "avg_nodes": 13287.857142857143, "eval_calls": 148973, "avg_eval_calls": 10640.92857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 148973, "pattern_eval_ns": 2956994, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.849194149275373, "pattern_frame_queries": 148973, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2956994, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.849194149275373, "pattern_frame_updates": 370834, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4000289464, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10787.278038151842, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34445, "avg_candidate_generations": 2460.3571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 2535455, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.60879663231238, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 876, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 34431, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2534579, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1018360, "avg_legality_checks": 72740.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 415, "root_legality_checks": 876, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1017484, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 415, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3623037, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 258788.35714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7250327637, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2001.1740528733214, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21199, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1514.2142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66152350, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3120.541063257701, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 519, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3837151, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10252, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 49317423, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10426, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12995166, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 80524, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5751.714285714285, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 597487689, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7419.995144304804, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 101061, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7218.642857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 233243353, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2307.94622059944, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2239086027, "stage_ordering_ns": 958826128, "stage_eval_ns": 4003246458, "stage_threat_ns": 5493670508, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 577303, "root_tactical_annotations": 2849, "search_tactical_annotations": 574454, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 370848, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1946947081, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 502543, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3235138253, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 68951, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2274433154, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185417, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 249821046, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 370834, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42426980, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 150561, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 130593036, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 283018, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 829880732, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 143724, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19337148, "child_limit_applications": 34431, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34431, "child_cap_hits": 34431, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34431, "child_moves_before_total": 2534164, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2534164, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 550931, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 550931, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.60123144840405, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001016525805234, "tt_hits": 14386, "tt_cutoffs": 2013, "beta_cutoffs": 24598, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4830.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5401.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1055, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 512, "avg_search_time_ms": 39.38461538461539, "search_nodes": 35424, "safety_nodes": 1048, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 36472, "avg_nodes": 2805.5384615384614, "eval_calls": 33871, "avg_eval_calls": 2605.4615384615386, "line_shape_eval_calls": 33871, "line_shape_eval_ns": 40788689, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1204.2363378701543, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1528, "avg_candidate_generations": 117.53846153846153, "candidate_moves_total": 107685, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.47447643979058, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 832, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 1515, "search_candidate_moves_total": 106853, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 5956, "avg_legality_checks": 458.15384615384613, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5956, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20735, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1595.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 42798678, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2064.078996865204, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15403376, "stage_ordering_ns": 52180, "stage_eval_ns": 40788689, "stage_threat_ns": 440252019, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 70785, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 386947769, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 218451, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35386, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 44784621, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 70772, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8301178, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 128, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1334, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6429.307692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7044.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1925, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 577, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9403, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 67, 96, 128, 83, 127, 80, 81, 69, 111, 110, 143, 158, 95, 159, 79 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1994, "avg_search_time_ms": 249.25, "search_nodes": 128841, "safety_nodes": 221, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 129062, "avg_nodes": 16132.75, "eval_calls": 124870, "avg_eval_calls": 15608.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 124870, "line_shape_eval_ns": 94024719, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 752.9808520861696, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3956, "avg_candidate_generations": 494.5, "candidate_moves_total": 238096, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.18604651162791, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 404, "root_candidate_moves_max": 65, "search_candidate_generations": 3948, "search_candidate_moves_total": 237692, "search_candidate_moves_max": 86, "legality_checks": 119509, "avg_legality_checks": 14938.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "root_legality_checks": 404, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 119105, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 128515, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16064.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 295235546, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2297.2847216278255, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 535793, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9922.092592592593, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 54, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 535793, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 6, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 56720, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9453.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 26350, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3293.75, "stage_move_gen_ns": 285622882, "stage_ordering_ns": 121850, "stage_eval_ns": 94024719, "stage_threat_ns": 1602005166, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 257644, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1408719128, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 104040, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8200, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128818, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 162697847, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 257636, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30484151, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 234, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3557, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5060.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6060.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1944, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7402, "avg_search_time_ms": 925.25, "search_nodes": 61713, "safety_nodes": 598, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 62311, "avg_nodes": 7788.875, "eval_calls": 40094, "avg_eval_calls": 5011.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40094, "pattern_eval_ns": 835814, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.846361051528906, "pattern_frame_queries": 40094, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 835814, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.846361051528906, "pattern_frame_updates": 123344, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1469831979, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11916.525968024387, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19591, "avg_candidate_generations": 2448.875, "candidate_moves_total": 1290126, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.85299372160686, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 431, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 19583, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1289695, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 818284, "avg_legality_checks": 102285.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1508, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 818284, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1508, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2346363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 293295.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4782717791, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2038.3537376782706, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15951, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1993.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 83233647, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5218.083317660335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1522, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14644028, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5948, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 53818959, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8481, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14770660, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 95851, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11981.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 898853599, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9377.613160008763, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 133260, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16657.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 417063874, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3129.700390214618, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1939771241, "stage_ordering_ns": 526213482, "stage_eval_ns": 1470667793, "stage_threat_ns": 3415140906, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 312344, "root_tactical_annotations": 700, "search_tactical_annotations": 311644, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 123352, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 734409107, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 274380, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2567310361, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 39222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1410256294, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61672, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88935949, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 123344, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15399841, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 53709, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 304200434, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 181442, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 852645232, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 77193, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9085648, "child_limit_applications": 19583, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19583, "child_cap_hits": 19583, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19583, "child_moves_before_total": 1288187, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1288187, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 212475, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 212475, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 65.78088137670429, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.849971914415564, "tt_hits": 9177, "tt_cutoffs": 1996, "beta_cutoffs": 15245, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2509.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3509.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 496, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 578, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7763, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 83, 99, 85, 84, 69, 111, 53, 101, 52, 67, 55, 41, 54, 56, 51 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7234, "avg_search_time_ms": 803.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 77110, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 77268, "avg_nodes": 8585.333333333334, "eval_calls": 47087, "avg_eval_calls": 5231.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47087, "pattern_eval_ns": 962355, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.43780661329029, "pattern_frame_queries": 47087, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 962355, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.43780661329029, "pattern_frame_updates": 154134, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1620464223, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10513.346977305462, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28169, "avg_candidate_generations": 3129.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 1932337, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.5979977989989, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 28160, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1931837, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 572003, "avg_legality_checks": 63555.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 183, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 571503, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2025581, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 225064.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4295143305, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2120.45003631057, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22180, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2464.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 68813172, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3102.487466185753, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1361, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4571580, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10087, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 42264273, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10727, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21922668, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 54651, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37274, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4141.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 296559612, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7956.20571980469, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 48156, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5350.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 119319185, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2477.7636223938866, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1360770566, "stage_ordering_ns": 759360798, "stage_eval_ns": 1621426578, "stage_threat_ns": 3455783728, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 394351, "root_tactical_annotations": 1800, "search_tactical_annotations": 392551, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 154143, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 871765546, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 290400, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2440462408, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56380, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1944757502, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77067, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 109450397, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 154134, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18577137, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 87518, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 57255333, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 146494, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 438313862, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 160339, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15528240, "child_limit_applications": 28160, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28160, "child_cap_hits": 28160, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28160, "child_moves_before_total": 1931655, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1931655, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 255329, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 255329, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.595703125, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.06708096590909, "tt_hits": 17029, "tt_cutoffs": 1820, "beta_cutoffs": 22237, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3655.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4543.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1118, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 520, "avg_search_time_ms": 65.0, "search_nodes": 38283, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 38879, "avg_nodes": 4859.875, "eval_calls": 36926, "avg_eval_calls": 4615.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 36926, "line_shape_eval_ns": 31383829, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 849.9114174294535, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1342, "avg_candidate_generations": 167.75, "candidate_moves_total": 84955, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.304769001490314, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1334, "search_candidate_moves_total": 84508, "search_candidate_moves_max": 88, "legality_checks": 2405, "avg_legality_checks": 300.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2405, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11430, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1428.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23977596, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2097.7774278215225, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 81190, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6765.833333333333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21410, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 59780, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6570780, "stage_ordering_ns": 39960, "stage_eval_ns": 31383829, "stage_threat_ns": 472361920, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 76528, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 415844172, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 159461, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8290, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 47461097, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 76520, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8897190, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1224, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5409.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6409.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 579, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19481, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 97, 129, 126, 144, 110, 109, 99, 130, 131, 98, 82, 146, 162, 159, 174, 142, 156, 100, 86, 145, 143, 115, 85, 160 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 819, "avg_search_time_ms": 63.0, "search_nodes": 52730, "safety_nodes": 1047, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53777, "avg_nodes": 4136.692307692308, "eval_calls": 50513, "avg_eval_calls": 3885.6153846153848, "line_shape_eval_calls": 50513, "line_shape_eval_ns": 35978188, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 712.256013303506, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2192, "avg_candidate_generations": 168.6153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 144760, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.04014598540147, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 847, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 2179, "search_candidate_moves_total": 143913, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 49258, "avg_legality_checks": 3789.076923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 180, "root_legality_checks": 847, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 48411, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 169, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 64317, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4947.461538461538, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 141318162, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2197.213209571342, "renju_forbidden_checks": 224, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 17.23076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2059497, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9194.183035714286, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 180, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1681246, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 378251, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.615384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 624614, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10410.233333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 85, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.538461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 330881, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3892.7176470588233, "stage_move_gen_ns": 120845307, "stage_ordering_ns": 65431, "stage_eval_ns": 35978188, "stage_threat_ns": 644851058, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 105397, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 567546332, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 795224, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11100, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52692, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 64237073, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 105384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12272429, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 93, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1976, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6327.538461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6942.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1931, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18651, "avg_search_time_ms": 1434.6923076923076, "search_nodes": 150125, "safety_nodes": 744, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 150869, "avg_nodes": 11605.307692307691, "eval_calls": 99873, "avg_eval_calls": 7682.538461538462, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 99873, "pattern_eval_ns": 2064127, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.667517747539375, "pattern_frame_queries": 99873, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2064127, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.667517747539375, "pattern_frame_updates": 300126, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3600299152, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11995.958870607677, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 45649, "avg_candidate_generations": 3511.4615384615386, "candidate_moves_total": 3618476, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.26736620736489, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 886, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 45636, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3617590, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 2709347, "avg_legality_checks": 208411.3076923077, "illegal_moves_skipped": 37477, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2709347, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 37477, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7001873, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 538605.6153846154, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11822108617, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1688.4208863828292, "renju_forbidden_checks": 125752, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9673.23076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 726927684, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5780.645111012151, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 37632, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 304507827, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 35756, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 301013391, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 52294, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 120709930, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 696536, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 333778, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 25675.23076923077, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2867009731, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8589.570705678625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 465760, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35827.692307692305, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1445515373, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3103.562721143937, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5520823174, "stage_ordering_ns": 1227900802, "stage_eval_ns": 3602363279, "stage_threat_ns": 8193081077, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1087847, "root_tactical_annotations": 2797, "search_tactical_annotations": 1085050, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 300139, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1541535548, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 890719, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6381962285, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 91359, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2791220742, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 150063, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 201841077, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 300126, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33640452, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 263545, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1052627324, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 535804, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2538013967, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 288498, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 34101715, "child_limit_applications": 45636, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 45636, "child_cap_hits": 45636, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 45636, "child_moves_before_total": 3580113, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3580113, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 627021, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 627021, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.44931632921377, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.739613463055482, "tt_hits": 23879, "tt_cutoffs": 4556, "beta_cutoffs": 37497, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 4.461538461538462, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 4.461538461538462, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1658.4615384615386, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2230.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 580, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 65460, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 110, 109, 142, 94, 96, 141, 124, 82, 98, 86, 72, 84, 81, 66, 129, 85, 83, 97, 140, 154, 125, 155, 80, 95, 156, 169, 183, 108, 138, 152, 153, 123, 158, 174, 172, 188, 139, 167, 137, 136, 186, 122, 150, 87, 88, 144, 56, 40, 184, 55, 70, 185, 71, 69, 73, 74, 200, 214, 168, 198, 64, 48, 58, 54, 99, 68, 26, 52, 36, 116 ], "move_count": 78, "black_stats": { "move_count": 39, "search_move_count": 37, "total_time_ms": 63714, "avg_search_time_ms": 1722.0, "search_nodes": 787682, "safety_nodes": 1131, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 788813, "avg_nodes": 21319.27027027027, "eval_calls": 485434, "avg_eval_calls": 13119.837837837838, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 485434, "pattern_eval_ns": 10161184, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.932163795696223, "pattern_frame_queries": 485434, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 10161184, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.932163795696223, "pattern_frame_updates": 1574912, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 13988369752, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8882.000868619962, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 280968, "avg_candidate_generations": 7593.72972972973, "candidate_moves_total": 29475396, "avg_candidate_moves": 104.90659434526351, "candidate_moves_max": 140, "root_candidate_generations": 37, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3464, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 280931, "search_candidate_moves_total": 29471932, "search_candidate_moves_max": 140, "legality_checks": 7128464, "avg_legality_checks": 192661.1891891892, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8581, "root_legality_checks": 3464, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 7125000, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8576, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21251972, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 574377.6216216217, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 35232817628, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1657.8610976901343, "renju_forbidden_checks": 113560, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3069.189189189189, "renju_forbidden_ns": 234288497, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2063.1251937301868, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9627, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20061994, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 45979, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 147877274, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 57929, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 66322329, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 26900, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 624009, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16865.108108108107, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3555037874, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5697.093910504496, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 749389, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20253.756756756757, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1225815581, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1635.7533684107987, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13062664174, "stage_ordering_ns": 8067877236, "stage_eval_ns": 13998530936, "stage_threat_ns": 28202728135, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 10143039, "root_tactical_annotations": 16569, "search_tactical_annotations": 10126470, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1574949, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 7299483032, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 7934909, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 19349605160, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 562162, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12251721368, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 787456, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1037878485, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1574912, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 169260712, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 4668982, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1505991112, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 2703737, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 5591676049, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 2770320, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 346500746, "child_limit_applications": 280931, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 280931, "child_cap_hits": 280931, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 280931, "child_moves_before_total": 29463356, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 29463356, "child_moves_before_max": 139, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 139, "child_moves_after_total": 4031387, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 4031387, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 104.87755356297454, "avg_child_moves_after": 14.350096642947912, "tt_hits": 177803, "tt_cutoffs": 21092, "beta_cutoffs": 237652, "depth_sum": 225, "avg_depth": 6.081081081081081, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 225, "avg_effective_depth": 6.081081081081081, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 27 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.02702702702702703, "pooled_budget_moves": 37, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.5135135135135135, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.02702702702702703, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5341.4324324324325, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5557.648648648648, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1213, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 39, "search_move_count": 37, "total_time_ms": 1708, "avg_search_time_ms": 46.16216216216216, "search_nodes": 145394, "safety_nodes": 5449, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 150843, "avg_nodes": 4076.837837837838, "eval_calls": 139280, "avg_eval_calls": 3764.324324324324, "line_shape_eval_calls": 139280, "line_shape_eval_ns": 289369948, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 2077.613067202757, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6042, "avg_candidate_generations": 163.2972972972973, "candidate_moves_total": 589320, "avg_candidate_moves": 97.53723932472691, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 37, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3488, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 6005, "search_candidate_moves_total": 585832, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 12713, "avg_legality_checks": 343.5945945945946, "illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 12713, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 52423, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1416.837837837838, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 88998066, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1697.6912042424126, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2432432432432432, "renju_forbidden_ns": 54040, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1174.7826086956522, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22120, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 31920, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 29100433, "stage_ordering_ns": 181192, "stage_eval_ns": 289369948, "stage_threat_ns": 1336086996, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 290607, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1158509349, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 96, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 779995, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 73, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 33860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 145285, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 149826402, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 290570, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26971250, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 147, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5695, "depth_sum": 109, "avg_depth": 2.945945945945946, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 109, "avg_effective_depth": 2.945945945945946, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 36 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 37, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7448.756756756757, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7664.972972972973, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1991, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 581, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 55008, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 109, 126, 98, 95, 113, 125, 140, 128, 99, 100, 127, 141, 142, 85, 65, 81, 115, 114, 86, 124, 67, 123, 122, 156, 171, 83, 82, 139, 66, 68, 52, 37, 38, 153, 167, 24, 54, 70, 50, 34, 53, 51, 55, 56, 35, 80, 77, 138, 63, 64, 49, 21, 91 ], "move_count": 58, "black_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 7031, "avg_search_time_ms": 260.4074074074074, "search_nodes": 465408, "safety_nodes": 2593, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 468001, "avg_nodes": 17333.37037037037, "eval_calls": 454191, "avg_eval_calls": 16821.88888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 454191, "line_shape_eval_ns": 705188790, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1552.6260758139197, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11164, "avg_candidate_generations": 413.48148148148147, "candidate_moves_total": 956113, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.64251164457184, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2259, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 11137, "search_candidate_moves_total": 953854, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 441439, "avg_legality_checks": 16349.592592592593, "illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "root_legality_checks": 2259, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 439180, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 94, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 471447, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17461.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1008625142, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2139.4242449310314, "renju_forbidden_checks": 104, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.8518518518518516, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1190036, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11442.653846153846, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 96, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1101686, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 88350, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.3703703703703702, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 602393, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9412.390625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 87, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2222222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 300891, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3458.5172413793102, "stage_move_gen_ns": 980813084, "stage_ordering_ns": 363453, "stage_eval_ns": 705188790, "stage_threat_ns": 5284926767, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 930683, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4603828098, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 74, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 966685, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 27680, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 465328, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 576238833, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 930656, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 103893151, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 638, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 10152, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 2.962962962962963, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 2.962962962962963, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 26 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.037037037037037035, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7140.814814814815, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7437.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1915, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 47951, "avg_search_time_ms": 1775.962962962963, "search_nodes": 377875, "safety_nodes": 1229, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 379104, "avg_nodes": 14040.888888888889, "eval_calls": 233740, "avg_eval_calls": 8657.037037037036, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 233740, "pattern_eval_ns": 4964717, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.240339693676734, "pattern_frame_queries": 233740, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4964717, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.240339693676734, "pattern_frame_updates": 755436, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6850049843, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9067.677265843831, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 134181, "avg_candidate_generations": 4969.666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 13060989, "avg_candidate_moves": 97.33858743041117, "candidate_moves_max": 137, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2292, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 134154, "search_candidate_moves_total": 13058697, "search_candidate_moves_max": 137, "legality_checks": 9312904, "avg_legality_checks": 344922.3703703704, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4414, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9312904, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4414, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17681528, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 654871.4074074074, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31837395166, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1800.6020274944563, "renju_forbidden_checks": 57442, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2127.4814814814813, "renju_forbidden_ns": 155330581, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2704.1290519132344, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4669, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 45719432, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8864, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 65297758, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 43894, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44137730, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 175661, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 547150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 20264.814814814814, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 4454570095, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8141.405638307594, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 764175, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 28302.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2217243833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2901.487006248569, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18686816105, "stage_ordering_ns": 4151558323, "stage_eval_ns": 6855014560, "stage_threat_ns": 17914284660, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 3555012, "root_tactical_annotations": 9433, "search_tactical_annotations": 3545579, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 755463, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3974526694, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2880311, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 13191001258, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 268518, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6933245881, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 377718, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 540217333, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 755436, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 88448786, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1328400, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 2463173139, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1283370, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3794346165, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 943242, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 120090589, "child_limit_applications": 134154, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 134154, "child_cap_hits": 134154, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 134154, "child_moves_before_total": 13054283, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 13054283, "child_moves_before_max": 137, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 137, "child_moves_after_total": 1325637, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1325637, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 97.3081905869374, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.8814571313565, "tt_hits": 73489, "tt_cutoffs": 9828, "beta_cutoffs": 107795, "depth_sum": 152, "avg_depth": 5.62962962962963, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 152, "avg_effective_depth": 5.62962962962963, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18518518518518517, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18518518518518517, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3537.925925925926, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3768.3703703703704, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 269, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 582, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7647, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 81, 65, 80, 79, 127, 93, 51, 108, 109, 63, 47, 78, 48, 123 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7136, "avg_search_time_ms": 792.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 77311, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 77469, "avg_nodes": 8607.666666666666, "eval_calls": 47302, "avg_eval_calls": 5255.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47302, "pattern_eval_ns": 993258, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.998224176567586, "pattern_frame_queries": 47302, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 993258, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.998224176567586, "pattern_frame_updates": 154536, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1611335613, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10426.927143189936, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28107, "avg_candidate_generations": 3123.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1972825, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.1898103675241, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 28098, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1972325, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 575880, "avg_legality_checks": 63986.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 242, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 575380, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 241, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2032972, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 225885.77777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4216529420, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2074.0715661602817, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21190, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2354.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 74213566, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3502.291930155734, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 911, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3625016, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10463, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 48489956, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9811, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22054854, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 43740, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38134, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4237.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 292029683, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7657.987176797608, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 49062, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5451.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 115275467, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2349.5876034405446, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1335818837, "stage_ordering_ns": 740654852, "stage_eval_ns": 1612328871, "stage_threat_ns": 3413681114, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 395666, "root_tactical_annotations": 1800, "search_tactical_annotations": 393866, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 154545, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 872189614, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 293070, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2397176467, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56256, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1908212871, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77268, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 109189066, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 154536, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18539737, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 88617, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 63230486, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 148189, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 425598740, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 158860, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16586230, "child_limit_applications": 28098, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28098, "child_cap_hits": 28098, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28098, "child_moves_before_total": 1972084, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1972084, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 248212, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 248212, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.18592070610008, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.833795999715282, "tt_hits": 17082, "tt_cutoffs": 1868, "beta_cutoffs": 22225, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3742.777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4631.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1205, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 504, "avg_search_time_ms": 63.0, "search_nodes": 35030, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35626, "avg_nodes": 4453.25, "eval_calls": 33821, "avg_eval_calls": 4227.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 33821, "line_shape_eval_ns": 28553329, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 844.2485142367168, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1194, "avg_candidate_generations": 149.25, "candidate_moves_total": 75947, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.607202680067005, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1186, "search_candidate_moves_total": 75500, "search_candidate_moves_max": 88, "legality_checks": 2613, "avg_legality_checks": 326.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2613, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11638, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1454.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24224045, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2081.4611617116343, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 68422, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6220.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9100, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 59322, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6995085, "stage_ordering_ns": 36110, "stage_eval_ns": 28553329, "stage_threat_ns": 459082508, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 70022, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 407375462, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 160912, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35007, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 43193682, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 70014, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8352452, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1085, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5419.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6419.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 583, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11566, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 115, 116, 95, 141, 96, 159, 175, 144, 142, 156, 80, 64, 110, 171, 126, 186, 201, 158, 65, 50, 125 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3643, "avg_search_time_ms": 280.2307692307692, "search_nodes": 233272, "safety_nodes": 877, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 234149, "avg_nodes": 18011.46153846154, "eval_calls": 227028, "avg_eval_calls": 17463.69230769231, "line_shape_eval_calls": 227028, "line_shape_eval_ns": 264735945, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1166.0938078122522, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6220, "avg_candidate_generations": 478.46153846153845, "candidate_moves_total": 526946, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.71800643086817, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 934, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 6207, "search_candidate_moves_total": 526012, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 219045, "avg_legality_checks": 16849.615384615383, "illegal_moves_skipped": 166, "root_legality_checks": 934, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 218111, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 165, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 234169, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18013.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 540913544, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2309.928060503312, "renju_forbidden_checks": 173, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 13.307692307692308, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1863075, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10769.21965317919, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 168, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1816175, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 46900, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.923076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 379301, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9981.605263157895, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.3076923076923075, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 183801, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3282.160714285714, "stage_move_gen_ns": 527249885, "stage_ordering_ns": 191660, "stage_eval_ns": 264735945, "stage_threat_ns": 2830158140, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 466483, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2479051103, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 551222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13620, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 233235, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 296144681, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 466470, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 54411134, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 342, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5549, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6269.538461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6884.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1915, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7913, "avg_search_time_ms": 659.4166666666666, "search_nodes": 64564, "safety_nodes": 1254, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 65818, "avg_nodes": 5484.833333333333, "eval_calls": 38874, "avg_eval_calls": 3239.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38874, "pattern_eval_ns": 786505, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.232160312805473, "pattern_frame_queries": 38874, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 786505, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.232160312805473, "pattern_frame_updates": 128994, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1090028184, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8450.223917391506, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23874, "avg_candidate_generations": 1989.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1926728, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.7040294881461, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 854, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 23862, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1925874, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1261595, "avg_legality_checks": 105132.91666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 887, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1261595, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 887, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2771559, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 230963.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5193270543, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1873.772322003609, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14574, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1214.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33036685, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2266.8234527240293, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1038, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9438649, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2037, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12832053, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11494, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10707143, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 58840, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89335, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7444.583333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 816974069, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9145.061498852634, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 130926, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10910.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 394929589, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3016.433626628783, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2654543290, "stage_ordering_ns": 717848171, "stage_eval_ns": 1090814689, "stage_threat_ns": 3392402844, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 336887, "root_tactical_annotations": 900, "search_tactical_annotations": 335987, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 129006, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 699718820, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 275357, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2578672786, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47815, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1510523248, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64497, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 86897615, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128994, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14943268, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 41550, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 197915052, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 185983, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 869841794, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 109354, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12170355, "child_limit_applications": 23862, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23862, "child_cap_hits": 23862, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23862, "child_moves_before_total": 1924987, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1924987, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 231554, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 231554, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.67165367529964, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.703880647053893, "tt_hits": 12179, "tt_cutoffs": 1761, "beta_cutoffs": 18952, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5078.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5744.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1744, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 584, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28017, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 79, 63, 115, 64, 97, 62, 65, 96, 128, 48, 80, 34, 76, 20, 6, 61, 60, 78, 93, 51, 125, 33, 18, 126, 83, 69, 139 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 23614, "avg_search_time_ms": 1574.2666666666667, "search_nodes": 258190, "safety_nodes": 603, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 258793, "avg_nodes": 17252.866666666665, "eval_calls": 167605, "avg_eval_calls": 11173.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 167605, "pattern_eval_ns": 3401973, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.29756272187584, "pattern_frame_queries": 167605, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3401973, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.29756272187584, "pattern_frame_updates": 516216, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5467410120, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10591.32246966386, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 82236, "avg_candidate_generations": 5482.4, "candidate_moves_total": 7165849, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.13761612918917, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1151, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 82221, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7164698, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 2362702, "avg_legality_checks": 157513.46666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7837, "root_legality_checks": 1151, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 2361551, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7832, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7050660, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 470044.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13655267800, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1936.7361069743824, "renju_forbidden_checks": 78916, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5261.066666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 492515026, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6241.00342135942, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8207, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 70226612, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 39738, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 312832097, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30946, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 109194825, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 261492, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 186505, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12433.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1499184156, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8038.3054395324525, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 262232, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17482.133333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 712008070, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2715.1837685713413, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5334550261, "stage_ordering_ns": 2551101324, "stage_eval_ns": 5470812093, "stage_threat_ns": 10137920913, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1384248, "root_tactical_annotations": 4702, "search_tactical_annotations": 1379546, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 516231, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2685814803, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1210463, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7004334408, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 164554, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4536182375, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 258108, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 348656839, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 516216, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56697624, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 310254, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 176166879, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 735641, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2291535741, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 338353, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 42417239, "child_limit_applications": 82221, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 82221, "child_cap_hits": 82221, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 82221, "child_moves_before_total": 7156866, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7156866, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 959985, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 959985, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.04425876600868, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.67566680045244, "tt_hits": 40525, "tt_cutoffs": 8283, "beta_cutoffs": 63543, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 5.133333333333334, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 5.133333333333334, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1507.3333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1938.1333333333334, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 4389, "avg_search_time_ms": 292.6, "search_nodes": 341664, "safety_nodes": 1162, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 342826, "avg_nodes": 22855.066666666666, "eval_calls": 332943, "avg_eval_calls": 22196.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 332943, "line_shape_eval_ns": 345954572, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1039.0804792411914, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8693, "avg_candidate_generations": 579.5333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 712510, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.96364891291844, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1177, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 8678, "search_candidate_moves_total": 711333, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 16793, "avg_legality_checks": 1119.5333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 16793, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 34008, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2267.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 71589520, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2105.078804987062, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.933333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 479421, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10895.931818181818, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 184570, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 294851, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 42677674, "stage_ordering_ns": 262521, "stage_eval_ns": 345954572, "stage_threat_ns": 3964700659, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 683257, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3477420048, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 212932, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 341621, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 411157509, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 683242, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 75910170, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 386, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7872, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6190.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6723.733333333334, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 585, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23718, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 157, 172, 83, 95, 98, 139, 153, 140, 110, 94, 84, 70, 81, 93, 96, 82, 158, 174, 156, 155, 53, 170, 185, 171, 173, 123, 187, 107 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 13949, "avg_search_time_ms": 871.8125, "search_nodes": 869652, "safety_nodes": 819, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 870471, "avg_nodes": 54404.4375, "eval_calls": 855041, "avg_eval_calls": 53440.0625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 855041, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1287161851, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1505.3802694841534, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14580, "avg_candidate_generations": 911.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1358997, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.20967078189301, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1240, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 14564, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1357757, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 841474, "avg_legality_checks": 52592.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 528, "root_legality_checks": 1240, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 840234, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 528, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 859959, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 53747.4375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2027880284, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2358.1127518870085, "renju_forbidden_checks": 811, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 50.6875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 7182204, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8855.985203452528, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 811, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7182204, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.5625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 271663, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10866.52, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 138912, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3858.6666666666665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2050872550, "stage_ordering_ns": 467171, "stage_eval_ns": 1287161851, "stage_threat_ns": 10564496019, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1739226, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 9238681078, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 386353, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16900, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 869605, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1121876880, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1739210, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 203551708, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 605, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 13146, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6086.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6586.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1924, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 9751, "avg_search_time_ms": 609.4375, "search_nodes": 79682, "safety_nodes": 1973, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 81655, "avg_nodes": 5103.4375, "eval_calls": 47342, "avg_eval_calls": 2958.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47342, "pattern_eval_ns": 978585, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.670546238012758, "pattern_frame_queries": 47342, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 978585, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.670546238012758, "pattern_frame_updates": 159190, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1318190335, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8280.610182800427, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29288, "avg_candidate_generations": 1830.5, "candidate_moves_total": 2475967, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.53861649822453, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1268, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 29272, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2474699, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1609383, "avg_legality_checks": 100586.4375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 645, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1609383, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 645, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3348185, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 209261.5625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6385747349, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1907.2265567762834, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21356, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1334.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46934201, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2197.705609664731, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2442, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12058141, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3543, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16591222, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15328, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18053097, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 43, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 231741, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 96604, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6037.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 879364365, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9102.773849944102, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 139032, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8689.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 411157094, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2957.283891478221, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3425829301, "stage_ordering_ns": 898130765, "stage_eval_ns": 1319168920, "stage_threat_ns": 4034045792, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 472918, "root_tactical_annotations": 991, "search_tactical_annotations": 471927, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 159206, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 866650870, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 380205, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3021021570, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58662, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1815694208, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79595, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 110833176, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 159190, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18289036, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 82007, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 226691079, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 239524, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 978252573, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 151387, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17251140, "child_limit_applications": 29272, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29272, "child_cap_hits": 29272, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29272, "child_moves_before_total": 2474054, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2474054, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 286381, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 286381, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.51947253347909, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.783444930308827, "tt_hits": 16196, "tt_cutoffs": 2982, "beta_cutoffs": 23496, "depth_sum": 86, "avg_depth": 5.375, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 86, "avg_effective_depth": 5.375, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5818.3125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6318.3125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1786, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 586, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20804, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 125, 69, 157, 172, 141, 173, 143, 140, 171, 129, 113, 55, 83, 155, 156, 126, 115, 144, 99, 85, 131, 67, 147 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 20037, "avg_search_time_ms": 1541.3076923076924, "search_nodes": 197326, "safety_nodes": 172, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 197498, "avg_nodes": 15192.153846153846, "eval_calls": 125446, "avg_eval_calls": 9649.692307692309, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 125446, "pattern_eval_ns": 2676377, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.334893101414153, "pattern_frame_queries": 125446, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2676377, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.334893101414153, "pattern_frame_updates": 394510, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4956746289, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12564.310889457809, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 67092, "avg_candidate_generations": 5160.923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 5820477, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.75366660704704, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 942, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 67079, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5819535, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1519603, "avg_legality_checks": 116892.53846153847, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1044, "root_legality_checks": 942, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1518661, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1044, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5301364, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 407797.23076923075, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11747296372, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2215.9007327170893, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30115, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2316.5384615384614, "renju_forbidden_ns": 193039362, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6410.073451768222, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1294, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11479889, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15517, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 133456919, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13304, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 48102554, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 114988, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8845.23076923077, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 918475274, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7987.574999130344, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 143781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11060.076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 343948182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2392.167129175621, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3698603574, "stage_ordering_ns": 2380522136, "stage_eval_ns": 4959422666, "stage_threat_ns": 8935355272, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 993437, "root_tactical_annotations": 4488, "search_tactical_annotations": 988949, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 394523, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2311229537, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 842338, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6244061599, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 134254, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4701680043, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197255, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 294916257, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 394510, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49442233, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 272529, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 316367302, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 435544, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1226002164, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 285364, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 35705646, "child_limit_applications": 67079, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 67079, "child_cap_hits": 67079, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 67079, "child_moves_before_total": 5818491, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5818491, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 594382, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 594382, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.74087270233605, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.860925177775458, "tt_hits": 36129, "tt_cutoffs": 4733, "beta_cutoffs": 52757, "depth_sum": 68, "avg_depth": 5.230769230769231, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 68, "avg_effective_depth": 5.230769230769231, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1295.3076923076924, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1760.2307692307693, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 753, "avg_search_time_ms": 62.75, "search_nodes": 52192, "safety_nodes": 1214, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53406, "avg_nodes": 4450.5, "eval_calls": 49989, "avg_eval_calls": 4165.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 49989, "line_shape_eval_ns": 58195479, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1164.1656964532197, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2180, "avg_candidate_generations": 181.66666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 174599, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.09128440366972, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 866, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 2168, "search_candidate_moves_total": 173733, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 8150, "avg_legality_checks": 679.1666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8150, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22213, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1851.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 49169898, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2213.5640390762164, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 21751249, "stage_ordering_ns": 75051, "stage_eval_ns": 58195479, "stage_threat_ns": 658034993, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 104326, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 578214503, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 348572, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12900, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52157, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 67025921, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 104314, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12445997, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 158, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1953, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6290.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6957.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 587, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12960, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 95, 129, 109, 108, 81, 123, 80, 125, 127, 124, 122, 79, 96, 128, 82, 93, 66, 51, 67, 53, 68, 54, 69, 65, 70 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2902, "avg_search_time_ms": 207.28571428571428, "search_nodes": 189033, "safety_nodes": 1047, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 190080, "avg_nodes": 13577.142857142857, "eval_calls": 183341, "avg_eval_calls": 13095.785714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 183341, "line_shape_eval_ns": 218367290, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1191.0445017753802, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5666, "avg_candidate_generations": 404.7142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 412661, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.83109777620896, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 892, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 5652, "search_candidate_moves_total": 411769, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 179387, "avg_legality_checks": 12813.357142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 73, "root_legality_checks": 892, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 178495, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 70, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 195419, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13958.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 427617004, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2188.2058755801636, "renju_forbidden_checks": 171, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12.214285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 760842, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4449.368421052632, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 149, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 694621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 66221, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.357142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 712473, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8005.314606741573, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 115, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.214285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 285362, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2481.4086956521737, "stage_move_gen_ns": 408922328, "stage_ordering_ns": 167371, "stage_eval_ns": 218367290, "stage_threat_ns": 2252326560, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 378000, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1971479029, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1009164, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 188993, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 236084287, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 377986, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43754080, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 356, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5013, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6412.357142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6983.785714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1916, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 10046, "avg_search_time_ms": 772.7692307692307, "search_nodes": 82960, "safety_nodes": 1066, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 84026, "avg_nodes": 6463.538461538462, "eval_calls": 49401, "avg_eval_calls": 3800.076923076923, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49401, "pattern_eval_ns": 1015032, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.546790550798566, "pattern_frame_queries": 49401, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1015032, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.546790550798566, "pattern_frame_updates": 165764, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1725018954, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10406.475193648803, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30928, "avg_candidate_generations": 2379.076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 2467431, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.7798435075013, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 825, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 30915, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2466606, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1372779, "avg_legality_checks": 105598.38461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1618, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1372779, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1618, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3250712, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 250054.76923076922, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6461746278, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1987.7941441751839, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23228, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1786.7692307692307, "renju_forbidden_ns": 72496770, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3121.093938350267, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1661, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13394677, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5587, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35771597, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15958, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23242606, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 87890, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 121102, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9315.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 814067563, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6722.164481181153, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 146270, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11251.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 240268057, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1642.6338757093047, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3025649697, "stage_ordering_ns": 917351358, "stage_eval_ns": 1726033986, "stage_threat_ns": 4315211061, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 600146, "root_tactical_annotations": 961, "search_tactical_annotations": 599185, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 165777, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 954723153, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 484761, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3200379610, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61934, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1976726474, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 82882, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118856715, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 165764, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20413716, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116097, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 280531708, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 306722, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 942849236, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 177327, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20837867, "child_limit_applications": 30915, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30915, "child_cap_hits": 30915, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30915, "child_moves_before_total": 2464988, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2464988, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 384131, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 384131, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.73436842956494, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.425392204431505, "tt_hits": 15800, "tt_cutoffs": 2567, "beta_cutoffs": 26255, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 5.923076923076923, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 5.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5654.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6269.615384615385, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1742, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 588, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9677, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 81, 129, 127, 98, 95, 143, 109, 108, 67, 123, 53 ], "move_count": 17, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 7702, "avg_search_time_ms": 1100.2857142857142, "search_nodes": 76291, "safety_nodes": 315, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76606, "avg_nodes": 10943.714285714286, "eval_calls": 48139, "avg_eval_calls": 6877.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48139, "pattern_eval_ns": 983211, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.42441679303683, "pattern_frame_queries": 48139, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 983211, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.42441679303683, "pattern_frame_updates": 152516, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1694177560, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11108.195599150253, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26481, "avg_candidate_generations": 3783.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1921370, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.5565499792304, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 391, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 26474, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1920979, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 664120, "avg_legality_checks": 94874.28571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1277, "root_legality_checks": 391, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 663729, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1277, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2156541, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 308077.28571428574, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4663429363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2162.458011695581, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17132, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2447.4285714285716, "renju_forbidden_ns": 99075471, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5783.065082885828, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13608356, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6983, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 59979292, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8812, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25484983, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2840, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49782, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7111.714285714285, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 435162503, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8741.36240006428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66593, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9513.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 186413091, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2799.2895799858843, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1605452582, "stage_ordering_ns": 804503318, "stage_eval_ns": 1695160771, "stage_threat_ns": 3566703584, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 249776, "root_tactical_annotations": 1321, "search_tactical_annotations": 248455, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152523, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 872795530, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 224019, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2557669232, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52994, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1930830529, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76258, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108730113, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152516, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18541244, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 34370, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 43703846, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 136649, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 582911695, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78757, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8967465, "child_limit_applications": 26474, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26474, "child_cap_hits": 26474, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26474, "child_moves_before_total": 1919702, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1919702, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 231642, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 231642, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.5127294704238, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.749792248999018, "tt_hits": 13642, "tt_cutoffs": 1645, "beta_cutoffs": 20281, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.42857142857142855, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1533.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2436.5714285714284, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 394, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 1969, "avg_search_time_ms": 328.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 144335, "safety_nodes": 317, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 144652, "avg_nodes": 24108.666666666668, "eval_calls": 141185, "avg_eval_calls": 23530.833333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 141185, "line_shape_eval_ns": 107878224, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 764.0912561532741, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3139, "avg_candidate_generations": 523.1666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 205675, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.52245938196879, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 330, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 3133, "search_candidate_moves_total": 205345, "search_candidate_moves_max": 83, "legality_checks": 5832, "avg_legality_checks": 972.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5832, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12718, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2119.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29166973, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2293.361613461236, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16678406, "stage_ordering_ns": 90760, "stage_eval_ns": 107878224, "stage_threat_ns": 1843957952, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 288642, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1624603042, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 100810, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 12, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 144318, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184272878, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 288636, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34981222, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 110, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2908, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4013.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5346.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 589, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 36930, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 155, 53, 80, 79, 115, 131, 50, 65, 37, 68, 100, 55, 54, 93, 107, 36, 20, 66, 101, 98, 85, 21, 6, 70, 102, 103, 73, 87, 130, 145, 117, 71, 39, 119 ], "move_count": 48, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 8062, "avg_search_time_ms": 366.45454545454544, "search_nodes": 533974, "safety_nodes": 2044, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 536018, "avg_nodes": 24364.454545454544, "eval_calls": 522362, "avg_eval_calls": 23743.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 522362, "line_shape_eval_ns": 994259924, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1903.3925208954709, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11569, "avg_candidate_generations": 525.8636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 1161141, "avg_candidate_moves": 100.36658311003544, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1945, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 11547, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1159196, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 512809, "avg_legality_checks": 23309.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 627, "root_legality_checks": 1945, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 510864, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 626, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 538107, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24459.409090909092, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1118870480, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2079.2713716788667, "renju_forbidden_checks": 673, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 30.59090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6757605, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10041.017830609213, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 669, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6721225, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 36380, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 69, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.1363636363636362, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 740203, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10727.579710144928, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.409090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 391671, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4037.8453608247423, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1109749045, "stage_ordering_ns": 383823, "stage_eval_ns": 994259924, "stage_threat_ns": 5870816267, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1067840, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5098700938, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 61, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1068294, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 22760, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 533909, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 653748388, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1067818, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 117298647, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 682, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 10410, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 2.9545454545454546, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.045454545454545456, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7043.863636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7407.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1926, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 28847, "avg_search_time_ms": 1311.2272727272727, "search_nodes": 206421, "safety_nodes": 1848, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 208269, "avg_nodes": 9466.772727272728, "eval_calls": 122730, "avg_eval_calls": 5578.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 122730, "pattern_eval_ns": 2674238, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.789603194003096, "pattern_frame_queries": 122730, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2674238, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.789603194003096, "pattern_frame_updates": 412578, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3957625522, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9592.429848416541, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 75898, "avg_candidate_generations": 3449.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 7636010, "avg_candidate_moves": 100.60884344778519, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1985, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 75876, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7634025, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 4917177, "avg_legality_checks": 223508.04545454544, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2244, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4917177, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2244, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9557788, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 434444.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18934056906, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1981.0082527463467, "renju_forbidden_checks": 72305, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3286.590909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 164713716, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2278.040467464214, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2322, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20081269, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9217, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 61660658, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 60756, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 82877197, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 94592, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 277226, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12601.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2726249337, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9834.031934234163, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 416145, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18915.68181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1422764753, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3418.9158898941473, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10856472410, "stage_ordering_ns": 2744603927, "stage_eval_ns": 3960299760, "stage_threat_ns": 11087717238, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1681204, "root_tactical_annotations": 4899, "search_tactical_annotations": 1676305, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 412600, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2424028661, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1293986, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8234038597, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 151927, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4467678970, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 206289, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 310286450, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 412578, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51651533, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 407126, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1407297092, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 734918, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2358716073, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 539160, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 67711997, "child_limit_applications": 75876, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 75876, "child_cap_hits": 75876, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 75876, "child_moves_before_total": 7631781, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7631781, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 763739, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 763739, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 100.58227898149613, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.065620222468239, "tt_hits": 45001, "tt_cutoffs": 7684, "beta_cutoffs": 63071, "depth_sum": 131, "avg_depth": 5.954545454545454, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 131, "avg_effective_depth": 5.954545454545454, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.045454545454545456, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.045454545454545456, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5101.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5464.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1651, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 590, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8903, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 99, 85, 84, 69, 111, 55, 41, 52, 67, 70, 141, 155, 126, 81, 156 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8180, "avg_search_time_ms": 908.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 88216, "safety_nodes": 255, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 88471, "avg_nodes": 9830.111111111111, "eval_calls": 51525, "avg_eval_calls": 5725.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51525, "pattern_eval_ns": 1083402, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.026724890829694, "pattern_frame_queries": 51525, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1083402, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.026724890829694, "pattern_frame_updates": 176336, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1748440384, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9915.390980854732, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34164, "avg_candidate_generations": 3796.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2580740, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.53974944385904, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 548, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 34155, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2580192, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 634396, "avg_legality_checks": 70488.44444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1157, "root_legality_checks": 548, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 633848, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1154, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2341131, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 260125.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4761538285, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2033.862387452902, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19866, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2207.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 82614288, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4158.57686499547, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1349, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8547663, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9179, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 48688964, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9323, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25257010, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 120651, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44382, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4931.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 366528506, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8258.494569870669, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 59532, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6614.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 166666944, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2799.6194315662165, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1460206236, "stage_ordering_ns": 967725808, "stage_eval_ns": 1749523786, "stage_threat_ns": 3964404489, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 385728, "root_tactical_annotations": 2236, "search_tactical_annotations": 383492, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 176345, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 963345178, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 303433, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2844504922, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 68376, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2258434035, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 88168, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121058702, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 176336, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20725120, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 65690, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 108418795, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 169360, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 477503721, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 150678, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14770567, "child_limit_applications": 34155, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34155, "child_cap_hits": 34155, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34155, "child_moves_before_total": 2579038, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2579038, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 310481, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 310481, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.5098228663446, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.090352803396282, "tt_hits": 20444, "tt_cutoffs": 2488, "beta_cutoffs": 27726, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3342.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4231.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 909, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 712, "avg_search_time_ms": 79.11111111111111, "search_nodes": 52376, "safety_nodes": 825, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53201, "avg_nodes": 5911.222222222223, "eval_calls": 50860, "avg_eval_calls": 5651.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 50860, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44938102, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 883.5647267007472, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1500, "avg_candidate_generations": 166.66666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 100761, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.174, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 573, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 1491, "search_candidate_moves_total": 100188, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 2756, "avg_legality_checks": 306.22222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2756, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13083, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1453.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26905310, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2056.5092104257433, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.6666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 207771, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8657.125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 72831, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 134940, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7679657, "stage_ordering_ns": 46850, "stage_eval_ns": 44938102, "stage_threat_ns": 649070327, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 104711, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 572695946, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 209710, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8470, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52351, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 64101425, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 104702, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12063246, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 67, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1362, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5667.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6556.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 591, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 46527, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 85, 123, 80, 65, 157, 173, 78, 79, 107, 124, 156, 51, 37, 153, 138, 92, 76, 94, 126, 171, 158, 155, 142, 174, 172, 187, 139, 159, 97, 83, 67, 145, 131, 201 ], "move_count": 48, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 12839, "avg_search_time_ms": 583.5909090909091, "search_nodes": 817171, "safety_nodes": 2274, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 819445, "avg_nodes": 37247.5, "eval_calls": 803251, "avg_eval_calls": 36511.40909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 803251, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1540385713, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1917.6891320396737, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13877, "avg_candidate_generations": 630.7727272727273, "candidate_moves_total": 1408667, "avg_candidate_moves": 101.51091734524753, "candidate_moves_max": 134, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1961, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 13855, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1406706, "search_candidate_moves_max": 134, "legality_checks": 795922, "avg_legality_checks": 36178.27272727273, "illegal_moves_skipped": 334, "root_legality_checks": 1961, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 793961, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 821348, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 37334.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1822966020, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2219.4806829748172, "renju_forbidden_checks": 372, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 16.90909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3943880, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10601.827956989247, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 360, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3912200, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 31680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 84, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8181818181818183, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 849652, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10114.904761904761, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 116, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.2727272727272725, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 439582, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3789.5, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1828183529, "stage_ordering_ns": 401314, "stage_eval_ns": 1540385713, "stage_threat_ns": 9381683521, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1634234, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 8192543377, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 61, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1206215, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 22560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 817106, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1002833265, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1634212, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 185100664, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 502, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 12616, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 2.8636363636363638, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8636363636363638, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6622.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6986.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1914, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 33665, "avg_search_time_ms": 1530.2272727272727, "search_nodes": 228077, "safety_nodes": 1199, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 229276, "avg_nodes": 10421.636363636364, "eval_calls": 134069, "avg_eval_calls": 6094.045454545455, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 134069, "pattern_eval_ns": 2798505, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.87361731645645, "pattern_frame_queries": 134069, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2798505, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.87361731645645, "pattern_frame_updates": 455898, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4155087396, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9114.072437255702, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 86293, "avg_candidate_generations": 3922.409090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 8888937, "avg_candidate_moves": 103.00878402651432, "candidate_moves_max": 140, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1992, "root_candidate_moves_max": 115, "search_candidate_generations": 86271, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8886945, "search_candidate_moves_max": 140, "legality_checks": 6473242, "avg_legality_checks": 294238.2727272727, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1691, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6473242, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1691, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12221791, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 555535.9545454546, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22645751746, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1852.899607430695, "renju_forbidden_checks": 92846, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4220.272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 174769309, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1882.3569028283393, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2377, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16667951, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9375, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 54132588, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 81066, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 103892240, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 76530, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 412519, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18750.863636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3827204870, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9277.645078166097, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 589652, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26802.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1979422041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3356.9326331463303, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13497085347, "stage_ordering_ns": 3064219305, "stage_eval_ns": 4157885901, "stage_threat_ns": 12712082048, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2036578, "root_tactical_annotations": 6735, "search_tactical_annotations": 2029843, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 455920, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2541360818, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1519129, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9688427418, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 172713, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4756807239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 227949, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 330300622, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 455898, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55269135, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 579908, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 2135064602, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 766493, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2796368326, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 690177, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 96724055, "child_limit_applications": 86271, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 86271, "child_cap_hits": 86271, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 86271, "child_moves_before_total": 8885254, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8885254, "child_moves_before_max": 140, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 140, "child_moves_after_total": 961794, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 961794, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 102.99236128015208, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.148520360260111, "tt_hits": 53281, "tt_cutoffs": 7613, "beta_cutoffs": 72684, "depth_sum": 124, "avg_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 124, "avg_effective_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4384.227272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4700.772727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 750, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 592, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10856, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 80, 139, 85, 71, 97, 140, 155, 138, 142, 137 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10364, "avg_search_time_ms": 1036.4, "search_nodes": 103770, "safety_nodes": 382, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 104152, "avg_nodes": 10415.2, "eval_calls": 67934, "avg_eval_calls": 6793.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67934, "pattern_eval_ns": 1386764, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.413401242382314, "pattern_frame_queries": 67934, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1386764, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.413401242382314, "pattern_frame_updates": 207436, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2805675441, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13525.499146724773, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33208, "avg_candidate_generations": 3320.8, "candidate_moves_total": 2738683, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.47057937846301, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 668, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 33198, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2738015, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 740012, "avg_legality_checks": 74001.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1221, "root_legality_checks": 668, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 739344, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1219, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2850851, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 285085.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6126349225, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2148.9545490101027, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29523, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2952.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 186534532, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6318.278359245334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12542754, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16327, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 130095971, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11811, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43799987, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 95820, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65229, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6522.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 584207174, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8956.249122322894, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 88530, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8853.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 261861884, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2957.8886705071727, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1771043975, "stage_ordering_ns": 1111593358, "stage_eval_ns": 2807062205, "stage_threat_ns": 4638115707, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 467079, "root_tactical_annotations": 2004, "search_tactical_annotations": 465075, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 207446, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1201996453, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 370203, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3236030324, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 66467, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2378925939, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 103718, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 151335708, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 207436, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25569608, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 115167, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 159428248, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 188561, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 697370067, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 163351, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23183614, "child_limit_applications": 33198, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33198, "child_cap_hits": 33198, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33198, "child_moves_before_total": 2736796, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2736796, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 327688, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 327688, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.4385806373878, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.870715103319476, "tt_hits": 19603, "tt_cutoffs": 2586, "beta_cutoffs": 26363, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 5.2, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 5.2, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3397.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4197.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 845, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 482, "avg_search_time_ms": 53.55555555555556, "search_nodes": 34310, "safety_nodes": 864, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35174, "avg_nodes": 3908.222222222222, "eval_calls": 32755, "avg_eval_calls": 3639.4444444444443, "line_shape_eval_calls": 32755, "line_shape_eval_ns": 26915050, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 821.708136162418, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1538, "avg_candidate_generations": 170.88888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 108520, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.5591677503251, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 596, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 1529, "search_candidate_moves_total": 107924, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 3507, "avg_legality_checks": 389.6666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3507, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13981, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1553.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29505823, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2110.422931120807, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2222222222222223, "renju_forbidden_ns": 114970, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10451.818181818182, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 31040, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 83930, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9426672, "stage_ordering_ns": 49370, "stage_eval_ns": 26915050, "stage_threat_ns": 434970622, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 68577, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 383603849, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 230610, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34284, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 43029590, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 68568, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8106573, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 63, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1405, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5687.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6576.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 593, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15724, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 98, 83, 115, 116, 69, 125, 139, 126, 129, 141, 84, 99, 70, 56, 96, 157, 109, 158, 82, 127, 130, 124 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 1639, "avg_search_time_ms": 136.58333333333334, "search_nodes": 105238, "safety_nodes": 1052, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 106290, "avg_nodes": 8857.5, "eval_calls": 102119, "avg_eval_calls": 8509.916666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 102119, "line_shape_eval_ns": 105328483, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1031.428852613128, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3096, "avg_candidate_generations": 258.0, "candidate_moves_total": 227180, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.37855297157623, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 834, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 3084, "search_candidate_moves_total": 226346, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 90741, "avg_legality_checks": 7561.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 130, "root_legality_checks": 834, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 89907, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 127, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 105039, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8753.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 243124424, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2314.610992107693, "renju_forbidden_checks": 144, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1548628, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10754.361111111111, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 130, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1416778, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 131850, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 768004, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10666.722222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.583333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 410172, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3982.252427184466, "stage_move_gen_ns": 222542208, "stage_ordering_ns": 98101, "stage_eval_ns": 105328483, "stage_threat_ns": 1297113972, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 210418, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1136888374, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1006194, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12070, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 105203, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 134297005, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 210406, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24922399, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 198, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2783, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6134.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6801.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1914, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 14074, "avg_search_time_ms": 1172.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 99826, "safety_nodes": 551, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 100377, "avg_nodes": 8364.75, "eval_calls": 62194, "avg_eval_calls": 5182.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62194, "pattern_eval_ns": 1298544, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.878927227706853, "pattern_frame_queries": 62194, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1298544, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.878927227706853, "pattern_frame_updates": 199546, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2068716365, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10367.115176450543, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34965, "avg_candidate_generations": 2913.75, "candidate_moves_total": 2935370, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.95166595166596, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 854, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 34953, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2934516, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 2052203, "avg_legality_checks": 171016.91666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9406, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2052203, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9406, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4641756, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 386813.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9238892057, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1990.387270894894, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45997, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3833.0833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 284829997, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6192.36030610692, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9464, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 102547359, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12650, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 122881654, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23853, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 59061422, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 339562, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 185209, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15434.083333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1785399718, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9639.918783644423, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 264063, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22005.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 887907277, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3362.4827295001573, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4784403650, "stage_ordering_ns": 1140514873, "stage_eval_ns": 2070014909, "stage_threat_ns": 5997952797, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 640603, "root_tactical_annotations": 2346, "search_tactical_annotations": 638257, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 199558, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1165781885, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 538452, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4635352875, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69982, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2379824661, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 99773, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 147363895, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 199546, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24866330, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 159005, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 691870418, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 309457, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1563558466, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 172141, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24587812, "child_limit_applications": 34953, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34953, "child_cap_hits": 34953, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34953, "child_moves_before_total": 2925110, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2925110, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 385689, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 385689, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.68695104855091, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.034503476096472, "tt_hits": 17299, "tt_cutoffs": 2628, "beta_cutoffs": 27701, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4527.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5194.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1638, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 594, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 65756, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 83, 125, 126, 96, 98, 84, 82, 66, 99, 81, 51, 115, 127, 139, 153, 141, 53, 68, 52, 50, 85, 71, 69, 37, 55, 54, 70, 100, 40, 25, 41, 27, 39, 116, 132, 38, 146, 130, 160, 118, 174, 188, 140, 154, 158, 117, 119, 142, 157, 159, 42, 43, 28, 101, 56, 14, 35, 67, 88, 131, 86, 145, 103, 173 ], "move_count": 70, "black_stats": { "move_count": 35, "search_move_count": 33, "total_time_ms": 62165, "avg_search_time_ms": 1883.7878787878788, "search_nodes": 724131, "safety_nodes": 788, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 724919, "avg_nodes": 21967.242424242424, "eval_calls": 461963, "avg_eval_calls": 13998.878787878788, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 461963, "pattern_eval_ns": 9483758, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.529258836746667, "pattern_frame_queries": 461963, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 9483758, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.529258836746667, "pattern_frame_updates": 1447916, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 12673359599, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8752.827925791275, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 244808, "avg_candidate_generations": 7418.424242424242, "candidate_moves_total": 25085818, "avg_candidate_moves": 102.47139799352962, "candidate_moves_max": 136, "root_candidate_generations": 33, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3018, "root_candidate_moves_max": 124, "search_candidate_generations": 244775, "search_candidate_moves_total": 25082800, "search_candidate_moves_max": 136, "legality_checks": 6711528, "avg_legality_checks": 203379.63636363635, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1698, "root_legality_checks": 3018, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6708510, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1698, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18114448, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 548922.6666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 34362176647, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1896.948593023646, "renju_forbidden_checks": 84942, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2574.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 216967627, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2554.3032539850724, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4545, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18326797, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 36477, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 134218398, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 43920, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 64422432, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 445479, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13499.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2787085729, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6256.379602629978, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 532199, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16127.242424242424, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 873643972, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1641.5738699245958, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13901305569, "stage_ordering_ns": 7832925697, "stage_eval_ns": 12682843357, "stage_threat_ns": 27465906427, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 6233680, "root_tactical_annotations": 13492, "search_tactical_annotations": 6220188, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1447949, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 7460831284, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 5424464, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 18642363487, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 489789, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12203614527, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 723958, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1016687661, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1447916, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 168634242, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 2195934, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1101791851, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 2738714, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 5336896759, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1299032, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 177389753, "child_limit_applications": 244775, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 244775, "child_cap_hits": 244775, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 244775, "child_moves_before_total": 25081102, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 25081102, "child_moves_before_max": 136, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 136, "child_moves_after_total": 2971607, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 2971607, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 102.46594627719334, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.140157287304667, "tt_hits": 115519, "tt_cutoffs": 17223, "beta_cutoffs": 195109, "depth_sum": 164, "avg_depth": 4.96969696969697, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 164, "avg_effective_depth": 4.96969696969697, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 9, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_moves": 33, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.5454545454545454, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 9, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1814.6060606060605, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1935.3939393939395, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 35, "search_move_count": 33, "total_time_ms": 3554, "avg_search_time_ms": 107.6969696969697, "search_nodes": 265408, "safety_nodes": 4242, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 269650, "avg_nodes": 8171.212121212121, "eval_calls": 257329, "avg_eval_calls": 7797.848484848485, "line_shape_eval_calls": 257329, "line_shape_eval_ns": 487836489, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1895.7695751353326, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8015, "avg_candidate_generations": 242.87878787878788, "candidate_moves_total": 726505, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.64316905801621, "candidate_moves_max": 136, "root_candidate_generations": 33, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3046, "root_candidate_moves_max": 123, "search_candidate_generations": 7982, "search_candidate_moves_total": 723459, "search_candidate_moves_max": 136, "legality_checks": 18141, "avg_legality_checks": 549.7272727272727, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 18141, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 53974, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1635.5757575757575, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 106519823, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1973.539537555119, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.21212121212121213, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9200, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1314.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4210, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4990, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 45003299, "stage_ordering_ns": 249582, "stage_eval_ns": 487836489, "stage_threat_ns": 2976355042, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 530655, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2592155548, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 86, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 678861, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 65, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 33850, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 265311, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 324142416, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 530622, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59378217, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 350, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7426, "depth_sum": 97, "avg_depth": 2.9393939393939394, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 97, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9393939393939394, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 32 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 33, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7299.484848484848, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7541.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 595, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14076, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 129, 157, 172, 81, 99, 96, 145, 161, 144, 114, 100, 80, 64, 82, 101, 98, 102, 103, 130, 79, 78, 83 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 6080, "avg_search_time_ms": 467.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 388682, "safety_nodes": 877, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 389559, "avg_nodes": 29966.076923076922, "eval_calls": 381222, "avg_eval_calls": 29324.76923076923, "line_shape_eval_calls": 381222, "line_shape_eval_ns": 439583625, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1153.090915529534, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7436, "avg_candidate_generations": 572.0, "candidate_moves_total": 621357, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.56065088757397, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 934, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 7423, "search_candidate_moves_total": 620423, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 374832, "avg_legality_checks": 28833.23076923077, "illegal_moves_skipped": 442, "root_legality_checks": 934, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 373898, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 441, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 389956, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29996.615384615383, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 913436466, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2342.409056406364, "renju_forbidden_checks": 449, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 34.53846153846154, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4959240, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11045.077951002228, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 444, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4910940, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 48300, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.923076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 389181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10241.605263157895, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.3076923076923075, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 183870, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3283.3928571428573, "stage_move_gen_ns": 911283776, "stage_ordering_ns": 228300, "stage_eval_ns": 439583625, "stage_threat_ns": 4702021423, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 777303, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4121498714, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 561953, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 388645, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 489369983, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 777290, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 90590773, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 342, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6698, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5991.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6607.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1926, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7982, "avg_search_time_ms": 665.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 59786, "safety_nodes": 1254, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 61040, "avg_nodes": 5086.666666666667, "eval_calls": 35945, "avg_eval_calls": 2995.4166666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35945, "pattern_eval_ns": 759144, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.11959938795382, "pattern_frame_queries": 35945, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 759144, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.11959938795382, "pattern_frame_updates": 119438, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1068784872, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8948.449170280815, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22067, "avg_candidate_generations": 1838.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1779440, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.63805682693615, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 854, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 22055, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1778586, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1156509, "avg_legality_checks": 96375.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1020, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1156509, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1020, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2567366, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 213947.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5267585027, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2051.7468202819546, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14474, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1206.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37093098, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2562.739947492055, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1163, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11183720, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2183, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14782788, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11123, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11065910, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 60680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 87578, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7298.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 844001712, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9637.14302678755, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 126613, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10551.083333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 402069788, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3175.5806117855195, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2690735414, "stage_ordering_ns": 723812582, "stage_eval_ns": 1069544016, "stage_threat_ns": 3444409315, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 302936, "root_tactical_annotations": 900, "search_tactical_annotations": 302036, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 119450, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 698955046, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 262143, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2632929213, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44201, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1534622138, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 59719, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88175199, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 119438, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14665768, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 40704, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 196186018, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 177229, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 901709675, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 85003, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9684089, "child_limit_applications": 22055, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22055, "child_cap_hits": 22055, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22055, "child_moves_before_total": 1777566, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1777566, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 212713, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 212713, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.59696214010428, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.644661074586262, "tt_hits": 10539, "tt_cutoffs": 1720, "beta_cutoffs": 17552, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5035.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5701.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1683, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 596, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11657, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 129, 65, 49, 157, 128, 111, 96, 80, 114, 156, 144, 160, 159, 174, 99 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10831, "avg_search_time_ms": 1203.4444444444443, "search_nodes": 119545, "safety_nodes": 83, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 119628, "avg_nodes": 13292.0, "eval_calls": 78720, "avg_eval_calls": 8746.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 78720, "pattern_eval_ns": 1609648, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.447764227642278, "pattern_frame_queries": 78720, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1609648, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.447764227642278, "pattern_frame_updates": 239004, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2482358304, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10386.262589747452, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37555, "avg_candidate_generations": 4172.777777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 3029509, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.6685927306617, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 604, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 37546, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3028905, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1014220, "avg_legality_checks": 112691.11111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 630, "root_legality_checks": 604, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1013616, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 630, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2974684, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 330520.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6481040069, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2178.732285177182, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18299, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2033.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 100275552, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5479.837805344554, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 700, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6425910, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9802, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71851545, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7797, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21998097, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 56556, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6284.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 492057574, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8700.360244713205, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74727, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8303.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 204471210, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2736.2427235135897, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2435842692, "stage_ordering_ns": 1242709619, "stage_eval_ns": 2483967952, "stage_threat_ns": 4609852073, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 265115, "root_tactical_annotations": 2650, "search_tactical_annotations": 262465, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 239013, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1287962858, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 255953, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3119421381, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75152, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2438216713, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 119502, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 165745873, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 239004, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27501874, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 47023, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 88843001, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 133770, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 592353537, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 84322, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9220087, "child_limit_applications": 37546, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37546, "child_cap_hits": 37546, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37546, "child_moves_before_total": 3028275, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3028275, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 327957, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 327957, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.65506312256964, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.73480530549193, "tt_hits": 19099, "tt_cutoffs": 3236, "beta_cutoffs": 27813, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1591.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2391.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 816, "avg_search_time_ms": 102.0, "search_nodes": 59534, "safety_nodes": 515, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 60049, "avg_nodes": 7506.125, "eval_calls": 55526, "avg_eval_calls": 6940.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 55526, "line_shape_eval_ns": 46427710, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 836.1436083996687, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3993, "avg_candidate_generations": 499.125, "candidate_moves_total": 322581, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.78662659654395, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 531, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 3985, "search_candidate_moves_total": 322050, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 12309, "avg_legality_checks": 1538.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 12309, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21721, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2715.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 49378589, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2273.3110354035266, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 32412106, "stage_ordering_ns": 123533, "stage_eval_ns": 46427710, "stage_threat_ns": 725576371, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 119030, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 637661035, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 154780, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 59511, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74149491, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 119022, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13611065, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 201, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3667, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5361.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6361.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 597, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14853, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 81, 143, 67, 52, 95, 53, 80, 83, 113, 68, 38, 65, 96, 128, 110, 51, 94, 93, 109, 123, 124, 138, 139, 79, 154 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 4779, "avg_search_time_ms": 341.35714285714283, "search_nodes": 313373, "safety_nodes": 1047, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 314420, "avg_nodes": 22458.571428571428, "eval_calls": 305882, "avg_eval_calls": 21848.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 305882, "line_shape_eval_ns": 398365608, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1302.3506057891605, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7465, "avg_candidate_generations": 533.2142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 561591, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.22987273945077, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 892, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 7451, "search_candidate_moves_total": 560699, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 302494, "avg_legality_checks": 21606.714285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1014, "root_legality_checks": 892, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 301602, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1011, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 318526, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22751.85714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 686118050, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2154.04095741007, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1112, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 79.42857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6490841, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5837.087230215828, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1090, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6427861, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 62980, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.357142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 726082, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8158.224719101124, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 115, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.214285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 287151, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2496.965217391304, "stage_move_gen_ns": 680475810, "stage_ordering_ns": 220921, "stage_eval_ns": 398365608, "stage_threat_ns": 3661785161, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 626680, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3196216518, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1028454, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 313333, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 393691540, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 626666, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 70848649, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 356, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6788, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6527.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7098.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1924, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 10058, "avg_search_time_ms": 773.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 82352, "safety_nodes": 1066, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 83418, "avg_nodes": 6416.7692307692305, "eval_calls": 48999, "avg_eval_calls": 3769.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48999, "pattern_eval_ns": 1021582, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.849037735463988, "pattern_frame_queries": 48999, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1021582, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.849037735463988, "pattern_frame_updates": 164548, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1726391647, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10491.720634708414, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30808, "avg_candidate_generations": 2369.846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 2436447, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.08488055050636, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 825, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 30795, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2435622, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1348736, "avg_legality_checks": 103748.92307692308, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1657, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1348736, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1657, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3221585, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 247814.23076923078, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6502719252, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2018.4844578057075, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24390, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1876.1538461538462, "renju_forbidden_ns": 68824838, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2821.846576465765, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1686, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13128366, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6216, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33216976, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16466, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22393726, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 85770, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 122865, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9451.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 829407487, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6750.559451430432, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 148153, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11396.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 243960667, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1646.6805734612192, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3029182109, "stage_ordering_ns": 898257874, "stage_eval_ns": 1727413229, "stage_threat_ns": 4342934919, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 593017, "root_tactical_annotations": 961, "search_tactical_annotations": 592056, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 164561, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 953494760, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 487554, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3233444153, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61694, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1987236016, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 82274, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118860481, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 164548, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20206143, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 114481, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 283523886, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 311371, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 962406591, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 167165, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16929382, "child_limit_applications": 30795, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30795, "child_cap_hits": 30795, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30795, "child_moves_before_total": 2433965, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2433965, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 382176, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 382176, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.03766845267089, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.410326351680467, "tt_hits": 15199, "tt_cutoffs": 2481, "beta_cutoffs": 26079, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 5.923076923076923, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 5.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5597.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6213.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1588, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 598, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 31277, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 96, 97, 68, 110, 80, 64, 83, 84, 52, 99, 66, 100, 101, 94, 69, 67, 85, 53, 24, 38, 54, 40, 39, 9, 117, 133, 36, 78, 20, 4, 51, 81, 21, 6, 22, 23, 18, 19, 50, 34, 49, 48, 35, 65, 63, 7, 77 ], "move_count": 51, "black_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 29975, "avg_search_time_ms": 1248.9583333333333, "search_nodes": 331332, "safety_nodes": 1660, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 332992, "avg_nodes": 13874.666666666666, "eval_calls": 206222, "avg_eval_calls": 8592.583333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 206222, "pattern_eval_ns": 4250887, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.61315960469785, "pattern_frame_queries": 206222, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4250887, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.61315960469785, "pattern_frame_updates": 662394, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6728409042, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10157.714354296688, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 115582, "avg_candidate_generations": 4815.916666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 9768618, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.51677596857643, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 115558, "search_candidate_moves_total": 9766810, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 2578294, "avg_legality_checks": 107428.91666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2661, "root_legality_checks": 1808, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 2576486, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2659, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8527288, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 355303.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16971374561, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1990.242919085177, "renju_forbidden_checks": 59990, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2499.5833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 147930066, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2465.912085347558, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3729, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9507010, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29955, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 96459334, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26289, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41941362, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 22360, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 191749, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7989.541666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1217145781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6347.599106123109, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 220875, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9203.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 338946934, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1534.5645002829656, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5712466141, "stage_ordering_ns": 3427308788, "stage_eval_ns": 6732659929, "stage_threat_ns": 13962343170, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2591325, "root_tactical_annotations": 5706, "search_tactical_annotations": 2585619, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 662418, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3633181940, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2233365, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9713766324, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 231298, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6739683737, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 331197, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 462955534, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 662394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 77826539, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 634999, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 379158796, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1367047, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2594421018, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 589279, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 74612833, "child_limit_applications": 115558, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 115558, "child_cap_hits": 115558, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 115558, "child_moves_before_total": 9764151, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 9764151, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 1282450, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1282450, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.4956731684522, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.097890236937296, "tt_hits": 51240, "tt_cutoffs": 9425, "beta_cutoffs": 90535, "depth_sum": 127, "avg_depth": 5.291666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 127, "avg_effective_depth": 5.291666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 8, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 8, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3392.5416666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3725.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 1282, "avg_search_time_ms": 55.73913043478261, "search_nodes": 97716, "safety_nodes": 1971, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 99687, "avg_nodes": 4334.217391304348, "eval_calls": 93458, "avg_eval_calls": 4063.391304347826, "line_shape_eval_calls": 93458, "line_shape_eval_ns": 124937124, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1336.8264247041452, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4213, "avg_candidate_generations": 183.17391304347825, "candidate_moves_total": 333883, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.25065274151436, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4190, "search_candidate_moves_total": 332135, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 9102, "avg_legality_checks": 395.7391304347826, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9102, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 34124, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1483.6521739130435, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 68346330, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2002.8815496424804, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.6086956521739131, "renju_forbidden_ns": 17530, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1252.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7850, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22383333, "stage_ordering_ns": 132650, "stage_eval_ns": 124937124, "stage_threat_ns": 1095921553, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 195319, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 961189188, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 56, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 298742, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 25890, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 97648, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113499457, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 195296, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20934166, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 225, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3788, "depth_sum": 68, "avg_depth": 2.9565217391304346, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 68, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9565217391304346, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7114.173913043478, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7462.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1948, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 599, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16061, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 84, 97, 156, 114, 140, 113, 111, 96, 95, 115, 116, 130, 170, 184, 82, 129, 81, 145, 161, 160, 100, 175 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5950, "avg_search_time_ms": 495.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 390266, "safety_nodes": 644, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 390910, "avg_nodes": 32575.833333333332, "eval_calls": 379933, "avg_eval_calls": 31661.083333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 379933, "line_shape_eval_ns": 337574850, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 888.5115270323978, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10311, "avg_candidate_generations": 859.25, "candidate_moves_total": 804115, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.98613131607021, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 863, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 10299, "search_candidate_moves_total": 803252, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 372408, "avg_legality_checks": 31034.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4103, "root_legality_checks": 863, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 371545, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4096, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 386435, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32202.916666666668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 894886056, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2315.7479420859913, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4194, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 349.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 41816601, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9970.577253218884, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4161, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 41498059, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 33, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 318542, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 32, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.6666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 228431, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7138.46875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.083333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 113700, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2320.408163265306, "stage_move_gen_ns": 934349718, "stage_ordering_ns": 324211, "stage_eval_ns": 337574850, "stage_threat_ns": 4663802375, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 780476, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4076117454, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 311232, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 390232, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 496167030, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 780464, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 91206659, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 466, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9522, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5659.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6325.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1908, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10097, "avg_search_time_ms": 917.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 84002, "safety_nodes": 1080, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85082, "avg_nodes": 7734.727272727273, "eval_calls": 53865, "avg_eval_calls": 4896.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53865, "pattern_eval_ns": 1158987, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.51651350598719, "pattern_frame_queries": 53865, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1158987, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.51651350598719, "pattern_frame_updates": 167876, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2044348517, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12177.729496771426, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26431, "avg_candidate_generations": 2402.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2094714, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.2521660171768, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 26420, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2093928, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1164471, "avg_legality_checks": 105861.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8946, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1164471, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8946, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3188649, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 289877.1818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6381924306, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2001.4508671227218, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44611, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4055.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 280709450, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6292.3819237407815, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9967, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 98147562, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14827, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 132402499, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19782, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 49789859, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 369530, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 121655, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11059.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1141209024, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9380.699716411164, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 169704, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15427.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 535818872, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3157.373261679159, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2796287093, "stage_ordering_ns": 804626045, "stage_eval_ns": 2045507504, "stage_threat_ns": 4401049641, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 467506, "root_tactical_annotations": 869, "search_tactical_annotations": 466637, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 167887, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 925802793, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 410248, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3323992554, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52926, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1809553083, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 83938, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 119144117, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 167876, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20061422, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 90566, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 397587922, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 266748, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1116570117, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110192, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12048755, "child_limit_applications": 26420, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26420, "child_cap_hits": 26420, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26420, "child_moves_before_total": 2084982, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2084982, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 311345, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 311345, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.91680545041635, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.78444360333081, "tt_hits": 13017, "tt_cutoffs": 3654, "beta_cutoffs": 20910, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3242.5454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3969.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 600, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18066, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 126, 114, 127, 129, 125, 124, 144, 82, 130, 83, 81, 68, 113, 52, 100, 66, 50, 67, 97, 65, 64, 69 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 17671, "avg_search_time_ms": 1472.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 191037, "safety_nodes": 248, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 191285, "avg_nodes": 15940.416666666666, "eval_calls": 143374, "avg_eval_calls": 11947.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 143374, "pattern_eval_ns": 3055245, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.309616806394466, "pattern_frame_queries": 143374, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3055245, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.309616806394466, "pattern_frame_updates": 381960, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6177762758, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 16173.847413341711, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44751, "avg_candidate_generations": 3729.25, "candidate_moves_total": 3663520, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.86453933990302, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 812, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 44739, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3662708, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 1189277, "avg_legality_checks": 99106.41666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2266, "root_legality_checks": 812, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1188465, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2264, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5088408, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 424034.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10454845890, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2054.6398578887542, "renju_forbidden_checks": 122472, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10206.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 501230161, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4092.6102374420275, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4719, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22392640, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 70869, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 370352890, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 46867, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 108449021, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 35610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 159236, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13269.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1272981810, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7994.3091386369915, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 204129, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17010.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 482070765, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2361.5986214599593, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2721180479, "stage_ordering_ns": 1381281186, "stage_eval_ns": 6180818003, "stage_threat_ns": 7337039469, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 960446, "root_tactical_annotations": 2971, "search_tactical_annotations": 957475, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 381972, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2143887036, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 830510, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4838325467, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 89558, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2902264577, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 190980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 277406845, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 381960, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46822369, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 272306, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 283523325, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 468636, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1652368043, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 219504, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30597752, "child_limit_applications": 44739, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44739, "child_cap_hits": 44739, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44739, "child_moves_before_total": 3660444, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3660444, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 593318, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 593318, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.81774290887145, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.26176266791837, "tt_hits": 20129, "tt_cutoffs": 2867, "beta_cutoffs": 33279, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4166666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3347.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3879.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1003, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 386, "avg_search_time_ms": 35.09090909090909, "search_nodes": 25352, "safety_nodes": 1128, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 26480, "avg_nodes": 2407.2727272727275, "eval_calls": 23968, "avg_eval_calls": 2178.909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 23968, "line_shape_eval_ns": 18870855, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 787.335405540721, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1363, "avg_candidate_generations": 123.9090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 98902, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.56199559794571, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 749, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 1352, "search_candidate_moves_total": 98153, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 3128, "avg_legality_checks": 284.3636363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3128, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16055, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1459.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 34192404, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2129.7043911554033, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7272727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 39700, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2089.4736842105262, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9070, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 30630, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8796784, "stage_ordering_ns": 44720, "stage_eval_ns": 18870855, "stage_threat_ns": 344731317, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 50651, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 305039505, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 308771, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11740, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 25320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 33052577, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 50640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6330464, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 76, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1236, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6107.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6835.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1989, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 601, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 87237, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 97, 95, 125, 142, 94, 111, 67, 127, 82, 52, 79, 143, 159, 144, 141, 109, 65, 158, 174, 130, 116, 157, 172, 171, 129, 107, 108, 146, 145, 185, 199, 113, 49, 66, 81, 33, 117, 173, 131, 103, 115, 24, 38, 114, 99, 83, 98, 100, 101, 203, 188, 155, 86, 71, 87, 73, 118, 119, 34, 64, 147, 163, 102, 132, 70, 134, 56, 84, 187, 149, 72, 57, 104, 36, 68, 123, 139, 137, 151, 153, 88, 40, 85, 89, 69, 53, 133 ], "move_count": 93, "black_stats": { "move_count": 47, "search_move_count": 45, "total_time_ms": 18592, "avg_search_time_ms": 413.15555555555557, "search_nodes": 1134432, "safety_nodes": 6045, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1140477, "avg_nodes": 25343.933333333334, "eval_calls": 1108455, "avg_eval_calls": 24632.333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 1108455, "line_shape_eval_ns": 3141513194, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 2834.1368788087925, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25889, "avg_candidate_generations": 575.3111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 2905345, "avg_candidate_moves": 112.22314496504306, "candidate_moves_max": 145, "root_candidate_generations": 45, "root_candidate_moves_total": 4683, "root_candidate_moves_max": 132, "search_candidate_generations": 25844, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2900662, "search_candidate_moves_max": 145, "legality_checks": 1087802, "avg_legality_checks": 24173.37777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2165, "root_legality_checks": 4683, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "search_legality_checks": 1083119, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2145, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1135403, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 25231.17777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2467685563, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2173.400601372376, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3168, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 70.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15301499, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4830.018623737374, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2958, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14825295, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 210, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 476204, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 261, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2709604, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10381.624521072798, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 420, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.333333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1506427, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3586.730952380952, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2469737724, "stage_ordering_ns": 871953, "stage_eval_ns": 3141513194, "stage_threat_ns": 12825304955, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 2268643, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 11110477253, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 123, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3422028, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 89, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 50490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 1134299, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1456719255, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 2268598, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 254686419, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1166, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 23896, "depth_sum": 133, "avg_depth": 2.9555555555555557, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 133, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9555555555555557, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 44 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 45, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.044444444444444446, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7327.866666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7505.644444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1702, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 46, "search_move_count": 44, "total_time_ms": 68603, "avg_search_time_ms": 1559.159090909091, "search_nodes": 474594, "safety_nodes": 3413, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 478007, "avg_nodes": 10863.795454545454, "eval_calls": 284061, "avg_eval_calls": 6455.931818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 284061, "pattern_eval_ns": 6270478, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.074406553521953, "pattern_frame_queries": 284061, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6270478, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.074406553521953, "pattern_frame_updates": 948636, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8719439169, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9191.554156704995, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 175550, "avg_candidate_generations": 3989.7727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 18853971, "avg_candidate_moves": 107.3994360581031, "candidate_moves_max": 147, "root_candidate_generations": 44, "root_candidate_moves_total": 4595, "root_candidate_moves_max": 133, "search_candidate_generations": 175506, "search_candidate_moves_total": 18849376, "search_candidate_moves_max": 147, "legality_checks": 13060518, "avg_legality_checks": 296829.95454545453, "illegal_moves_skipped": 57706, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 13060518, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 57706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 25292295, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 574824.8863636364, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 45070244300, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1781.975273497324, "renju_forbidden_checks": 432101, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9820.477272727272, "renju_forbidden_ns": 641532766, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1484.6824376708223, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 63095, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 106321059, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 49182, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 166766478, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 319627, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 367857694, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 197, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 587535, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1020791, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 23199.795454545456, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 9333497706, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9143.397332068955, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1620435, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 36828.068181818184, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4974119954, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3069.6201661899427, "stage_move_gen_ns": 26540782878, "stage_ordering_ns": 5962403012, "stage_eval_ns": 8725709647, "stage_threat_ns": 26885690243, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 5279659, "root_tactical_annotations": 11953, "search_tactical_annotations": 5267706, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 948680, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5037913001, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 4558030, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 20878085643, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 351376, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8624438859, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 474318, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 714591744, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 948636, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 112864186, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 2257915, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 5461866232, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1948712, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 6791463951, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1073032, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 142235669, "child_limit_applications": 175506, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 175506, "child_cap_hits": 175506, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 175506, "child_moves_before_total": 18791670, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 18791670, "child_moves_before_max": 147, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 147, "child_moves_after_total": 1961867, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1961867, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 107.07138217496838, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.178347179013823, "tt_hits": 90971, "tt_cutoffs": 14758, "beta_cutoffs": 147133, "depth_sum": 265, "avg_depth": 6.0227272727272725, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 265, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0227272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 9 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 24 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 11, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_moves": 44, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 11, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4200.568181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4334.704545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 602, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15068, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 142, 95, 65, 94, 127, 125, 140, 97, 114, 100, 156, 170, 172, 157, 188, 124, 204 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 13047, "avg_search_time_ms": 1304.7, "search_nodes": 123795, "safety_nodes": 258, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 124053, "avg_nodes": 12405.3, "eval_calls": 79693, "avg_eval_calls": 7969.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79693, "pattern_eval_ns": 1663470, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.87347696786418, "pattern_frame_queries": 79693, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1663470, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.87347696786418, "pattern_frame_updates": 247490, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3429722958, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13858.026417228979, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41254, "avg_candidate_generations": 4125.4, "candidate_moves_total": 3342725, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.02790032481698, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 661, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 41244, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3342064, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 940201, "avg_legality_checks": 94020.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1757, "root_legality_checks": 661, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 939540, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1757, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3544524, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 354452.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7784233072, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2196.1293172228484, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47334, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4733.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 264923127, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5596.888642413487, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2034, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14839251, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26947, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 190242991, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18353, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 59840885, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 92427, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9242.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 837080755, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9056.669101020265, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 122729, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12272.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 362351550, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2952.4525580751088, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2273102110, "stage_ordering_ns": 1348452052, "stage_eval_ns": 3431386428, "stage_threat_ns": 5952518600, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 637519, "root_tactical_annotations": 2147, "search_tactical_annotations": 635372, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 247500, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1451054106, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 492631, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4255328805, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 82557, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3032928711, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123745, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184451093, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 247490, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31519484, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 137433, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 232014814, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 272633, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 990246050, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 227453, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30165112, "child_limit_applications": 41244, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41244, "child_cap_hits": 41244, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41244, "child_moves_before_total": 3340307, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3340307, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 408477, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 408477, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.98891960042673, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.903913296479487, "tt_hits": 23691, "tt_cutoffs": 2808, "beta_cutoffs": 33218, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2028.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2728.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 561, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2011, "avg_search_time_ms": 223.44444444444446, "search_nodes": 148502, "safety_nodes": 715, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 149217, "avg_nodes": 16579.666666666668, "eval_calls": 144471, "avg_eval_calls": 16052.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 144471, "line_shape_eval_ns": 112598545, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 779.3851015082612, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4014, "avg_candidate_generations": 446.0, "candidate_moves_total": 283944, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.73841554559043, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 600, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 4005, "search_candidate_moves_total": 283344, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 8343, "avg_legality_checks": 927.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8343, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18935, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2103.8888888888887, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 43144086, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2278.536361235807, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23546326, "stage_ordering_ns": 117442, "stage_eval_ns": 112598545, "stage_threat_ns": 1864882639, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 296961, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1642542347, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 195021, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148476, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 186569719, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 296952, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35575552, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 131, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3705, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5342.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6231.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 603, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29435, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 113, 83, 81, 110, 68, 97, 114, 111, 115, 116, 69, 125, 139, 140, 95, 124, 138, 108, 92, 109, 107, 141, 93, 172, 156, 173, 157, 170, 94, 155 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 4898, "avg_search_time_ms": 306.125, "search_nodes": 292155, "safety_nodes": 1511, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 293666, "avg_nodes": 18354.125, "eval_calls": 285692, "avg_eval_calls": 17855.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 285692, "line_shape_eval_ns": 250723683, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 877.6013434047856, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6432, "avg_candidate_generations": 402.0, "candidate_moves_total": 443411, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.93827736318408, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1123, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 6416, "search_candidate_moves_total": 442288, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 282882, "avg_legality_checks": 17680.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 52, "root_legality_checks": 1123, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 281759, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 49, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 301374, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18835.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 759021047, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2518.5352651522694, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.0625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 672793, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10350.661538461538, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 540092, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 132701, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.6875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 622631, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10553.06779661017, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 83, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.1875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 320571, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3862.3012048192772, "stage_move_gen_ns": 739781114, "stage_ordering_ns": 202100, "stage_eval_ns": 250723683, "stage_threat_ns": 3889344102, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 584232, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3415087181, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 918842, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 292108, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 398921739, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 584216, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74416340, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 179, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5996, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6129.6875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6629.6875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1747, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 24520, "avg_search_time_ms": 1532.5, "search_nodes": 173210, "safety_nodes": 361, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 173571, "avg_nodes": 10848.1875, "eval_calls": 107487, "avg_eval_calls": 6717.9375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107487, "pattern_eval_ns": 2377709, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.12089834119475, "pattern_frame_queries": 107487, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2377709, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.12089834119475, "pattern_frame_updates": 346256, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3647806309, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10534.998119888176, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 61878, "avg_candidate_generations": 3867.375, "candidate_moves_total": 5149965, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.2277222922525, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1151, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 61862, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5148814, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 3558589, "avg_legality_checks": 222411.8125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5042, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3558589, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5042, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7628428, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 476776.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16209766682, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2124.9157338838354, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47443, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2965.1875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 199335833, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4201.5857555382245, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5763, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 54733581, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7991, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 79902171, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 33664, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 64422338, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 277743, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 256010, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16000.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2433548909, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9505.679110191008, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 380615, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23788.4375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1153435631, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3030.452375760283, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8602255541, "stage_ordering_ns": 2078449242, "stage_eval_ns": 3650184018, "stage_threat_ns": 10047993118, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1168708, "root_tactical_annotations": 4236, "search_tactical_annotations": 1164472, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 346272, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2125341467, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 993140, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7570390145, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 123837, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4274230615, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 173128, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 269406309, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 346256, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45225263, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 313438, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 950933268, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 555851, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2345098420, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 299419, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 37629934, "child_limit_applications": 61862, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 61862, "child_cap_hits": 61862, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 61862, "child_moves_before_total": 5143772, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5143772, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 602721, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 602721, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.14913840483658, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.7429924671042, "tt_hits": 29738, "tt_cutoffs": 3781, "beta_cutoffs": 48979, "depth_sum": 79, "avg_depth": 4.9375, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 79, "avg_effective_depth": 4.9375, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2841.6875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3313.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 316, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 604, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11212, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 85, 68, 111, 81, 80, 113, 94, 78, 108, 109, 122, 66, 136 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10568, "avg_search_time_ms": 1174.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 97254, "safety_nodes": 247, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 97501, "avg_nodes": 10833.444444444445, "eval_calls": 61123, "avg_eval_calls": 6791.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 61123, "pattern_eval_ns": 1351054, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.103856158892725, "pattern_frame_queries": 61123, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1351054, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.103856158892725, "pattern_frame_updates": 194414, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2469752290, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12703.57222216507, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33649, "avg_candidate_generations": 3738.777777777778, "candidate_moves_total": 2633655, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.26844779934025, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 555, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 33640, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2633100, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 770349, "avg_legality_checks": 85594.33333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 749, "root_legality_checks": 555, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 769794, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 749, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2742851, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 304761.22222222225, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6341826193, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2312.129311070853, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26259, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2917.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 121442712, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4624.803381697704, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 908, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6195315, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13246, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 84752315, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12105, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30495082, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68383, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7598.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 648305215, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9480.502683415469, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91053, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10117.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 280697524, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3082.792703150912, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1966889379, "stage_ordering_ns": 1122170345, "stage_eval_ns": 2471103344, "stage_threat_ns": 4966922380, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 475922, "root_tactical_annotations": 1898, "search_tactical_annotations": 474024, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 194423, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1196546030, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 370698, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3571573456, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67344, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2618964791, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 97207, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 149462447, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 194414, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25360263, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 95167, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 187407393, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 208180, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 765055972, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 172575, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23980184, "child_limit_applications": 33640, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33640, "child_cap_hits": 33640, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33640, "child_moves_before_total": 2632351, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2632351, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 328146, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 328146, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.2506242568371, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.754637336504162, "tt_hits": 19259, "tt_cutoffs": 2444, "beta_cutoffs": 27082, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 5.222222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 5.222222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2200.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3029.8888888888887, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 535, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 636, "avg_search_time_ms": 79.5, "search_nodes": 43789, "safety_nodes": 614, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 44403, "avg_nodes": 5550.375, "eval_calls": 41825, "avg_eval_calls": 5228.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 41825, "line_shape_eval_ns": 33928441, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 811.2000239091452, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1949, "avg_candidate_generations": 243.625, "candidate_moves_total": 134147, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.82863006670087, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 1941, "search_candidate_moves_total": 133647, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 6543, "avg_legality_checks": 817.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6543, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15879, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1984.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 37895974, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2386.5466339190125, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19014848, "stage_ordering_ns": 66750, "stage_eval_ns": 33928441, "stage_threat_ns": 571884450, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 87540, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 502664127, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 201460, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8830, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43766, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 58195366, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 87532, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10823497, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 130, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1744, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5342.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6342.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 605, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22129, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 80, 111, 130, 82, 116, 97, 127, 68, 110, 81, 66, 83, 146, 162, 125, 67, 52, 69, 55, 65, 38, 24, 94 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7186, "avg_search_time_ms": 598.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 430505, "safety_nodes": 798, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 431303, "avg_nodes": 35941.916666666664, "eval_calls": 420508, "avg_eval_calls": 35042.333333333336, "line_shape_eval_calls": 420508, "line_shape_eval_ns": 415815691, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 988.8413323884445, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9974, "avg_candidate_generations": 831.1666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 775355, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.73761780629637, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 857, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 9962, "search_candidate_moves_total": 774498, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 414089, "avg_legality_checks": 34507.416666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1083, "root_legality_checks": 857, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 413232, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1081, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 428180, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 35681.666666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1067043577, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2492.044413564389, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1243, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 103.58333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14254127, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11467.519710378117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1235, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14152477, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 101650, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 63, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 533582, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8469.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 204522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2691.0789473684213, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1079153714, "stage_ordering_ns": 318005, "stage_eval_ns": 415815691, "stage_threat_ns": 5674563116, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 860952, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4975382149, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 721792, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 430470, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 589566153, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 860940, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 108893022, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 413, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9226, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5228.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5895.416666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1216, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 14931, "avg_search_time_ms": 1244.25, "search_nodes": 123390, "safety_nodes": 1237, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 124627, "avg_nodes": 10385.583333333334, "eval_calls": 75393, "avg_eval_calls": 6282.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75393, "pattern_eval_ns": 1682359, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.314525221174378, "pattern_frame_queries": 75393, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1682359, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.314525221174378, "pattern_frame_updates": 246634, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3250433100, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13179.176836932458, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41762, "avg_candidate_generations": 3480.1666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 3561812, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.288348259183, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 873, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 41750, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3560939, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1316684, "avg_legality_checks": 109723.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3775, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1316684, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4101628, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 341802.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9026309023, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2200.6649610837453, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34820, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2901.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 230028271, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6606.211114302125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4887, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 54415372, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13093, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 119470841, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16823, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 55948397, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 193661, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 136095, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11341.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1297950899, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9537.094669164922, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 187368, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15614.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 566744346, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3024.765947226848, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3332892232, "stage_ordering_ns": 1458028103, "stage_eval_ns": 3252115459, "stage_threat_ns": 6819994578, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 913676, "root_tactical_annotations": 917, "search_tactical_annotations": 912759, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 246646, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1498200902, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 821321, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5082094947, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 83596, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2993323245, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123317, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 187172770, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 246634, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32057851, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 177185, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 543639170, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 560531, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1544783082, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 175960, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20468108, "child_limit_applications": 41750, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41750, "child_cap_hits": 41750, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41750, "child_moves_before_total": 3557164, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3557164, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 601507, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 601507, "child_moves_after_max": 33, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 33, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.20153293413173, "avg_child_moves_after": 14.407353293413173, "tt_hits": 20237, "tt_cutoffs": 6174, "beta_cutoffs": 35122, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2541.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3208.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 606, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13666, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 128, 82, 113, 83, 143, 158, 84, 68, 54, 81, 79, 66, 99, 69, 129, 144, 70, 111, 51, 126 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 13034, "avg_search_time_ms": 1184.909090909091, "search_nodes": 115591, "safety_nodes": 391, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 115982, "avg_nodes": 10543.818181818182, "eval_calls": 73119, "avg_eval_calls": 6647.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73119, "pattern_eval_ns": 1619063, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.142849327808094, "pattern_frame_queries": 73119, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1619063, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.142849327808094, "pattern_frame_updates": 231072, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3339286530, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14451.281548608225, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39271, "avg_candidate_generations": 3570.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 3093466, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.77227470652645, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 725, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 39260, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3092741, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 899852, "avg_legality_checks": 81804.72727272728, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4062, "root_legality_checks": 725, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 899127, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4059, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3377620, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 307056.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7694326847, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2278.0321193621544, "renju_forbidden_checks": 51033, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4639.363636363636, "renju_forbidden_ns": 371131287, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7272.378402210335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4988, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53968266, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22263, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 205677642, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23767, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 111286159, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 199220, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 94182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8562.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 878076505, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9323.18813573719, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 126656, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11514.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 376170293, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2970.0155776275897, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2332800558, "stage_ordering_ns": 1304823473, "stage_eval_ns": 3340905593, "stage_threat_ns": 6009685872, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 667035, "root_tactical_annotations": 2205, "search_tactical_annotations": 664830, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 231083, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1431371314, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 516370, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4335616931, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 78596, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3031030474, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115536, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 178518499, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 231072, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30306793, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 148853, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 176275472, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 288914, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1128141304, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 229268, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33872335, "child_limit_applications": 39260, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39260, "child_cap_hits": 39260, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39260, "child_moves_before_total": 3088682, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3088682, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 414511, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 414511, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.67249108507387, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.558099847172695, "tt_hits": 22691, "tt_cutoffs": 3158, "beta_cutoffs": 31989, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.909090909090909, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2800.6363636363635, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3527.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 619, "avg_search_time_ms": 61.9, "search_nodes": 41956, "safety_nodes": 1041, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 42997, "avg_nodes": 4299.7, "eval_calls": 40320, "avg_eval_calls": 4032.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 40320, "line_shape_eval_ns": 40930275, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1015.1357886904761, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1617, "avg_candidate_generations": 161.7, "candidate_moves_total": 118037, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.99752628324057, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 661, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 1607, "search_candidate_moves_total": 117376, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 3469, "avg_legality_checks": 346.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3469, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15257, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1525.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 34377465, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2253.225732450678, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 315214, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 13704.95652173913, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 152210, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 163004, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10310349, "stage_ordering_ns": 53000, "stage_eval_ns": 40930275, "stage_threat_ns": 555046644, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 83864, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 488077571, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 361591, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10890, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 41927, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 56226531, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 83854, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10380951, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 84, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1464, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5915.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6715.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1982, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 607, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 53356, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 80, 97, 158, 110, 144, 111, 113, 94, 95, 67, 82, 83, 125, 109, 108, 124, 139, 99, 51, 84, 69, 98, 100, 68, 143, 53, 38, 70, 56, 115, 131, 138, 152, 79, 64, 141, 130, 116, 132, 129, 145, 146, 117, 159, 102, 87, 101, 103, 133, 134, 85 ], "move_count": 56, "black_stats": { "move_count": 28, "search_move_count": 26, "total_time_ms": 17722, "avg_search_time_ms": 681.6153846153846, "search_nodes": 1137116, "safety_nodes": 2448, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1139564, "avg_nodes": 43829.38461538462, "eval_calls": 1110229, "avg_eval_calls": 42701.11538461538, "line_shape_eval_calls": 1110229, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1745396891, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1572.1052962947283, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26836, "avg_candidate_generations": 1032.1538461538462, "candidate_moves_total": 2374276, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.4735430019377, "candidate_moves_max": 132, "root_candidate_generations": 26, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2307, "root_candidate_moves_max": 115, "search_candidate_generations": 26810, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2371969, "search_candidate_moves_max": 132, "legality_checks": 1092805, "avg_legality_checks": 42030.96153846154, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3639, "root_legality_checks": 2307, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1090498, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3636, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1122326, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 43166.38461538462, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2474284151, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2204.603788025939, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4070, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 156.53846153846155, "renju_forbidden_ns": 41797310, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10269.609336609337, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4058, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 41656480, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 140830, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.230769230769231, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 518544, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8940.413793103447, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 82, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.1538461538461537, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 226471, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2761.8414634146343, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2532696920, "stage_ordering_ns": 834373, "stage_eval_ns": 1745396891, "stage_threat_ns": 13340349139, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 2274104, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 11637647249, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 76, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 955504, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 27090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 1137039, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1438342510, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 2274078, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 263403876, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1012, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 23961, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 2.9615384615384617, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9615384615384617, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 25 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 26, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.11538461538461539, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6757.7307692307695, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7065.423076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1792, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 28, "search_move_count": 26, "total_time_ms": 35607, "avg_search_time_ms": 1369.5, "search_nodes": 305878, "safety_nodes": 1701, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 307579, "avg_nodes": 11829.961538461539, "eval_calls": 200717, "avg_eval_calls": 7719.884615384615, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 200717, "pattern_eval_ns": 4442279, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.13205159503181, "pattern_frame_queries": 200717, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4442279, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.13205159503181, "pattern_frame_updates": 611436, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4896623350, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8008.398834873969, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 96124, "avg_candidate_generations": 3697.076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 9757218, "avg_candidate_moves": 101.5065748408306, "candidate_moves_max": 147, "root_candidate_generations": 26, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2320, "root_candidate_moves_max": 114, "search_candidate_generations": 96098, "search_candidate_moves_total": 9754898, "search_candidate_moves_max": 147, "legality_checks": 6555157, "avg_legality_checks": 252121.42307692306, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6045, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6555157, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6045, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11747074, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 451810.53846153844, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22870136303, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1946.8793933706386, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56468, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2171.846153846154, "renju_forbidden_ns": 260490741, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4613.068304172274, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6907, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 77291002, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12681, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 119993686, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 36865, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 63020301, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 185752, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 340843, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13109.346153846154, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2540265969, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7452.891709672782, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 450210, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17315.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 976543255, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2169.0838830767866, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13819040368, "stage_ordering_ns": 3322634883, "stage_eval_ns": 4901065629, "stage_threat_ns": 13292966295, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1950652, "root_tactical_annotations": 6271, "search_tactical_annotations": 1944381, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 611462, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3462486011, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1706219, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9245959617, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 192407, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5441010366, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 305718, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 452643019, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 611436, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 75252719, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 648498, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1249505166, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 865296, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2555126003, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 436858, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 56624929, "child_limit_applications": 96098, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 96098, "child_cap_hits": 96098, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 96098, "child_moves_before_total": 9748853, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 9748853, "child_moves_before_max": 147, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 147, "child_moves_after_total": 996768, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 996768, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 101.44699161272867, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.372411496597223, "tt_hits": 48204, "tt_cutoffs": 8906, "beta_cutoffs": 76816, "depth_sum": 156, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 156, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_moves": 26, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.19230769230769232, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5230.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5538.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 608, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16691, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 128, 110, 127, 125, 129, 130, 140, 82, 124, 81, 79, 114, 66, 83, 84, 111, 113, 97, 139, 69 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 16276, "avg_search_time_ms": 1479.6363636363637, "search_nodes": 156941, "safety_nodes": 238, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 157179, "avg_nodes": 14289.0, "eval_calls": 113128, "avg_eval_calls": 10284.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 113128, "pattern_eval_ns": 2456309, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.71265292412135, "pattern_frame_queries": 113128, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2456309, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.71265292412135, "pattern_frame_updates": 313778, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5170030442, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 16476.71424382844, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41073, "avg_candidate_generations": 3733.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 3332305, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.131278455433, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 711, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 41062, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3331594, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1011957, "avg_legality_checks": 91996.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1236, "root_legality_checks": 711, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1011246, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1236, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4218209, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 383473.54545454547, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9587989870, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2273.000192735827, "renju_forbidden_checks": 94533, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8593.90909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 442174486, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4677.461690626554, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2957, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18161052, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 52749, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 324705174, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 38827, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 99308260, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 123419, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11219.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1090385421, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8834.826250415252, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 157386, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14307.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 425637852, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2704.4200373603753, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2593668619, "stage_ordering_ns": 1402022247, "stage_eval_ns": 5172486751, "stage_threat_ns": 7061546723, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 774519, "root_tactical_annotations": 2542, "search_tactical_annotations": 771977, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 313789, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1934656070, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 696485, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4816738345, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 82197, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3073377770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 156889, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 244282985, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 313778, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41399034, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 180694, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 256837419, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 433585, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1486352665, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 160240, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24470289, "child_limit_applications": 41062, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41062, "child_cap_hits": 41062, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41062, "child_moves_before_total": 3330358, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3330358, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 485409, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 485409, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.10559641517705, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.82136768788661, "tt_hits": 17007, "tt_cutoffs": 2701, "beta_cutoffs": 31490, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2291.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2816.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 406, "avg_search_time_ms": 40.6, "search_nodes": 26341, "safety_nodes": 951, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 27292, "avg_nodes": 2729.2, "eval_calls": 25060, "avg_eval_calls": 2506.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 25060, "line_shape_eval_ns": 20575005, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 821.0297286512371, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1262, "avg_candidate_generations": 126.2, "candidate_moves_total": 89261, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.72979397781299, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 651, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 1252, "search_candidate_moves_total": 88610, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 2689, "avg_legality_checks": 268.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2689, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1441.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 32164988, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2231.5101984182047, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7935031, "stage_ordering_ns": 42390, "stage_eval_ns": 20575005, "stage_threat_ns": 363680759, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 52634, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 320817623, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 241413, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 26312, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 35960611, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 52624, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6661112, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 74, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1138, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5914.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6714.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 609, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 37033, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 111, 81, 83, 114, 66, 97, 109, 113, 110, 108, 65, 129, 145, 144, 99, 67, 79, 130, 146, 116, 102, 115, 117, 143, 101, 158, 172, 159, 174, 157, 171, 156, 160, 155 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 5167, "avg_search_time_ms": 287.05555555555554, "search_nodes": 309043, "safety_nodes": 1521, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 310564, "avg_nodes": 17253.555555555555, "eval_calls": 301959, "avg_eval_calls": 16775.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 301959, "line_shape_eval_ns": 267318249, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 885.2799519140016, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7049, "avg_candidate_generations": 391.6111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 496555, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.443325294368, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1291, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 7031, "search_candidate_moves_total": 495264, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 298297, "avg_legality_checks": 16572.055555555555, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 1291, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 297006, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 318935, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17718.61111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 797835088, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2501.560154890495, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7777777777777777, "renju_forbidden_ns": 335563, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10486.34375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 255752, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 79811, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.7222222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 452042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9225.34693877551, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.7777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 223741, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3290.3088235294117, "stage_move_gen_ns": 775848748, "stage_ordering_ns": 225463, "stage_eval_ns": 267318249, "stage_threat_ns": 4100714934, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 617998, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3601895519, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 47, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 717404, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19200, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 308990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 419924931, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 617980, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 78177080, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 253, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6561, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6292.611111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6737.055555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1515, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 31849, "avg_search_time_ms": 1769.388888888889, "search_nodes": 219947, "safety_nodes": 564, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 220511, "avg_nodes": 12250.611111111111, "eval_calls": 138622, "avg_eval_calls": 7701.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 138622, "pattern_eval_ns": 3035223, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.895680339340075, "pattern_frame_queries": 138622, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3035223, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.895680339340075, "pattern_frame_updates": 439696, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4497722019, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10229.162919380664, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 76909, "avg_candidate_generations": 4272.722222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 6645153, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.4028007125304, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1333, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 76891, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6643820, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 4673650, "avg_legality_checks": 259647.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5625, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4673650, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10586214, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 588123.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21068285749, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1990.162464975675, "renju_forbidden_checks": 52863, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2936.8333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 197861444, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3742.9098613396895, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 57882007, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7772, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 77714224, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 38974, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 62104652, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 160561, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 454059, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 25225.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 4359780873, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9601.793760282255, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 665466, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 36970.333333333336, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2197041236, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3301.5078696732817, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10919807952, "stage_ordering_ns": 2594560797, "stage_eval_ns": 4500757242, "stage_threat_ns": 13650282726, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1737734, "root_tactical_annotations": 5645, "search_tactical_annotations": 1732089, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 439714, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2586015397, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1524036, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10628999490, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 153916, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5004520381, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 219848, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 333396525, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 439696, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55280351, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 538175, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1936803283, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 831929, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3687559285, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 367630, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 46590963, "child_limit_applications": 76891, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 76891, "child_cap_hits": 76891, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 76891, "child_moves_before_total": 6638195, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6638195, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 866549, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 866549, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.33253566737329, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.269836521829603, "tt_hits": 34408, "tt_cutoffs": 4340, "beta_cutoffs": 61200, "depth_sum": 93, "avg_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 93, "avg_effective_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1733.2777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1968.7777777777778, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 610, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10298, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 114, 81, 79, 66, 113, 83, 84, 111, 100, 86, 116, 115, 132, 68, 148 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9768, "avg_search_time_ms": 1085.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 101181, "safety_nodes": 247, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 101428, "avg_nodes": 11269.777777777777, "eval_calls": 63777, "avg_eval_calls": 7086.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 63777, "pattern_eval_ns": 1305962, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.47700581714411, "pattern_frame_queries": 63777, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1305962, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.47700581714411, "pattern_frame_updates": 202268, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2308383065, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11412.497602191152, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34946, "avg_candidate_generations": 3882.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 2734901, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.2607737652378, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 555, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 34937, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2734346, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 827146, "avg_legality_checks": 91905.11111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 761, "root_legality_checks": 555, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 826591, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 761, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2889106, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 321011.77777777775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5875670005, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2033.7329281099412, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27703, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3078.1111111111113, "renju_forbidden_ns": 116429043, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4202.7593762408405, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 980, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5791111, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13806, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 81416040, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12917, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29221892, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74637, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8293.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 625387780, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8379.058375872557, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 99201, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11022.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 270242711, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2724.193415388958, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1869781489, "stage_ordering_ns": 1015161418, "stage_eval_ns": 2309689027, "stage_threat_ns": 4533768096, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 482253, "root_tactical_annotations": 1898, "search_tactical_annotations": 480355, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 202277, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1100692992, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 383469, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3250822671, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69938, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2346705706, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 101134, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 139403334, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 202268, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23622817, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96685, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 174226325, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 216839, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 729755029, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 168729, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19226282, "child_limit_applications": 34937, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34937, "child_cap_hits": 34937, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34937, "child_moves_before_total": 2733585, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2733585, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 337053, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 337053, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.24326645104044, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.647451126313078, "tt_hits": 19411, "tt_cutoffs": 2420, "beta_cutoffs": 28124, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 5.222222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 5.222222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2684.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3573.222222222222, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 859, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 522, "avg_search_time_ms": 65.25, "search_nodes": 40101, "safety_nodes": 614, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40715, "avg_nodes": 5089.375, "eval_calls": 38241, "avg_eval_calls": 4780.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 38241, "line_shape_eval_ns": 27195832, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 711.1694777856228, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1845, "avg_candidate_generations": 230.625, "candidate_moves_total": 127409, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.05636856368564, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 1837, "search_candidate_moves_total": 126909, "search_candidate_moves_max": 86, "legality_checks": 6613, "avg_legality_checks": 826.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6613, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15949, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1993.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 32842386, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2059.212866010408, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16703465, "stage_ordering_ns": 61181, "stage_eval_ns": 27195832, "stage_threat_ns": 466313086, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 80164, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 409881700, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 168390, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8140, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40078, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 47464762, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 80156, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8798234, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 130, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1647, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5367.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6367.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 611, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 39209, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 97, 99, 129, 142, 100, 113, 67, 127, 82, 52, 85, 141, 155, 140, 143, 115, 69, 156, 170, 124, 108, 157, 172, 173, 125, 117, 116, 138, 139, 189, 205, 111, 55, 131, 70, 40, 68, 66, 71 ], "move_count": 45, "black_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 4837, "avg_search_time_ms": 230.33333333333334, "search_nodes": 300113, "safety_nodes": 1960, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 302073, "avg_nodes": 14384.42857142857, "eval_calls": 292019, "avg_eval_calls": 13905.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 292019, "line_shape_eval_ns": 390171732, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1336.1176224834685, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8054, "avg_candidate_generations": 383.5238095238095, "candidate_moves_total": 660364, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.99205363794388, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1694, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 8033, "search_candidate_moves_total": 658670, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 284972, "avg_legality_checks": 13570.095238095239, "illegal_moves_skipped": 90, "root_legality_checks": 1694, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 283278, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 90, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 309039, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14716.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 728580021, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2357.5665886829815, "renju_forbidden_checks": 339, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 16.142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1725562, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5090.153392330383, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 320, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1676152, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 49410, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.1904761904761907, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 677942, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10118.537313432837, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 93, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.428571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 338650, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3641.3978494623657, "stage_move_gen_ns": 700731336, "stage_ordering_ns": 251631, "stage_eval_ns": 390171732, "stage_threat_ns": 3715875181, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 600125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3255543529, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 56, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1035483, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 22180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 300052, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 387101356, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 600104, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 72194813, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 464, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7321, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 2.9047619047619047, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9047619047619047, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6758.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7139.380952380952, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1923, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 34349, "avg_search_time_ms": 1717.45, "search_nodes": 244541, "safety_nodes": 917, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 245458, "avg_nodes": 12272.9, "eval_calls": 154018, "avg_eval_calls": 7700.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 154018, "pattern_eval_ns": 3328508, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.61116233167552, "pattern_frame_queries": 154018, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3328508, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.61116233167552, "pattern_frame_updates": 488856, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4941593690, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10108.485300374752, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 85210, "avg_candidate_generations": 4260.5, "candidate_moves_total": 7704963, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.42322497359464, "candidate_moves_max": 140, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1612, "root_candidate_moves_max": 115, "search_candidate_generations": 85190, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7703351, "search_candidate_moves_max": 140, "legality_checks": 5377145, "avg_legality_checks": 268857.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3854, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5377145, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3854, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11123756, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 556187.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22762577816, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2046.3032285138222, "renju_forbidden_checks": 77164, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3858.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 228222305, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2957.6266782437406, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5536, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 42953207, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11914, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 91761812, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 59661, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 93339014, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 53, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 168272, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 391858, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19592.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3713997145, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9477.915839411215, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 555917, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27795.85, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1808892540, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3253.8895914318146, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12524204258, "stage_ordering_ns": 2957619611, "stage_eval_ns": 4944922198, "stage_threat_ns": 13721507545, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1895314, "root_tactical_annotations": 6006, "search_tactical_annotations": 1889308, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 488876, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2835313801, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1592414, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10394362663, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 170533, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5404750271, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 244428, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 369502084, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 488856, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61371557, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 586188, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1527858018, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 835676, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3461597034, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 473450, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 60957440, "child_limit_applications": 85190, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 85190, "child_cap_hits": 85190, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 85190, "child_moves_before_total": 7699497, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7699497, "child_moves_before_max": 140, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 140, "child_moves_after_total": 856594, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 856594, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.38029111398052, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.055100363892477, "tt_hits": 40916, "tt_cutoffs": 5223, "beta_cutoffs": 67141, "depth_sum": 109, "avg_depth": 5.45, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 109, "avg_effective_depth": 5.45, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2405.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2693.05, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 240, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 612, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26773, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 141, 99, 129, 100, 140, 154, 142, 69, 54, 143, 127, 86, 72, 157, 156, 171, 124, 185, 199, 172, 169, 155, 96, 111, 138, 139, 110, 82, 152 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 25665, "avg_search_time_ms": 1604.0625, "search_nodes": 243875, "safety_nodes": 920, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 244795, "avg_nodes": 15299.6875, "eval_calls": 175645, "avg_eval_calls": 10977.8125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 175645, "pattern_eval_ns": 3821562, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.757305929573857, "pattern_frame_queries": 175645, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3821562, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.757305929573857, "pattern_frame_updates": 487584, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8347870287, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 17120.88642572357, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 63717, "avg_candidate_generations": 3982.3125, "candidate_moves_total": 6058095, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.0781581053722, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1299, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 63701, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6056796, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 1693816, "avg_legality_checks": 105863.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3301, "root_legality_checks": 1299, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1692517, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3300, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6803601, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 425225.0625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15168126251, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2229.4261893076914, "renju_forbidden_checks": 114303, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7143.9375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 725824232, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6350.001592259171, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 43085225, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 70960, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 527419675, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37991, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 155230732, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 88600, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 187505, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11719.0625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1712282601, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9131.930353857231, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 254615, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15913.4375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 726191737, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2852.1168705692908, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4142167019, "stage_ordering_ns": 2324945630, "stage_eval_ns": 8351691849, "stage_threat_ns": 10778249458, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1368385, "root_tactical_annotations": 3905, "search_tactical_annotations": 1364480, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 487600, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2958229266, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1142909, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7330440984, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 127516, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4672192918, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 243792, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 373620841, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 487584, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64051896, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 393045, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 481494717, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 622336, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2176292407, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 353004, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 51906471, "child_limit_applications": 63701, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 63701, "child_cap_hits": 63701, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 63701, "child_moves_before_total": 6053496, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6053496, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 812391, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 812391, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.02984254564292, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.753190687744306, "tt_hits": 32313, "tt_cutoffs": 4448, "beta_cutoffs": 49887, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3857.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4257.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 322, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 1093, "avg_search_time_ms": 72.86666666666666, "search_nodes": 74361, "safety_nodes": 1839, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76200, "avg_nodes": 5080.0, "eval_calls": 71577, "avg_eval_calls": 4771.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 71577, "line_shape_eval_ns": 89943676, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1256.6002486832363, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2755, "avg_candidate_generations": 183.66666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 230170, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.54627949183303, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1223, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 2740, "search_candidate_moves_total": 228947, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 7603, "avg_legality_checks": 506.8666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7603, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 25170, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1678.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 57332483, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2277.810210568137, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 120690, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5747.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 29740, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 90950, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22308827, "stage_ordering_ns": 90780, "stage_eval_ns": 89943676, "stage_threat_ns": 960567716, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 148649, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 845472923, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 41, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 426751, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74317, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96355711, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 148634, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18312331, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 141, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2506, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6599.066666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7132.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 613, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18063, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 84, 113, 124, 82, 108, 97, 127, 66, 114, 81, 138, 152, 129, 99, 140, 67, 52, 65, 49, 68, 64, 69 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 4529, "avg_search_time_ms": 377.4166666666667, "search_nodes": 296655, "safety_nodes": 962, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 297617, "avg_nodes": 24801.416666666668, "eval_calls": 289748, "avg_eval_calls": 24145.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 289748, "line_shape_eval_ns": 219692725, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 758.2199877134614, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6885, "avg_candidate_generations": 573.75, "candidate_moves_total": 510784, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.18794480755265, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 868, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 6873, "search_candidate_moves_total": 509916, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 283761, "avg_legality_checks": 23646.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1039, "root_legality_checks": 868, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 282893, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1034, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 297953, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24829.416666666668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 687796941, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2308.40750386806, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1153, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 96.08333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 11634111, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10090.295750216826, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1130, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11396620, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 237491, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 670714, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9315.472222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 99, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 314791, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3179.7070707070707, "stage_move_gen_ns": 689860787, "stage_ordering_ns": 205570, "stage_eval_ns": 219692725, "stage_threat_ns": 3597195521, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 593254, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3160921971, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 842984, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 296621, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 366430076, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 593242, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69000490, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 337, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6343, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5484.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6151.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1569, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 13522, "avg_search_time_ms": 1229.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 115380, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 116296, "avg_nodes": 10572.363636363636, "eval_calls": 74950, "avg_eval_calls": 6813.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74950, "pattern_eval_ns": 1522907, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.31897264843229, "pattern_frame_queries": 74950, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1522907, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.31897264843229, "pattern_frame_updates": 230636, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2743905916, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11897.127577654832, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 36451, "avg_candidate_generations": 3313.7272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 3094239, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.88762996899948, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 792, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 36440, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3093447, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1659620, "avg_legality_checks": 150874.54545454544, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5484, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1659620, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5484, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4487265, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 407933.1818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8603441745, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1917.3019077322156, "renju_forbidden_checks": 49040, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4458.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 279699660, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5703.500407830343, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6746, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 63258959, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19021, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 152311891, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23248, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 63826060, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 302750, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 185996, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16908.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1563490026, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8406.041129916772, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 258793, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23526.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 682871639, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2638.6789403113685, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3724652370, "stage_ordering_ns": 1106559829, "stage_eval_ns": 2745428823, "stage_threat_ns": 5876873195, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 712258, "root_tactical_annotations": 1351, "search_tactical_annotations": 710907, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 230647, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1253022654, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 638944, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4422407546, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 72964, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2333922516, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115318, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159289749, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 230636, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26771625, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 166741, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 622217660, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 399231, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1466045728, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 146286, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15381621, "child_limit_applications": 36440, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 36440, "child_cap_hits": 36440, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 36440, "child_moves_before_total": 3087963, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3087963, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 446307, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 446307, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.74102634467619, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.247722283205269, "tt_hits": 15944, "tt_cutoffs": 3928, "beta_cutoffs": 29242, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 5.454545454545454, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 5.454545454545454, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2682.6363636363635, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3409.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 11, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 614, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13063, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 126, 82, 111, 81, 141, 156, 80, 66, 50, 83, 85, 68, 95, 65, 125, 140, 64, 113, 53, 128 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 12404, "avg_search_time_ms": 1127.6363636363637, "search_nodes": 118297, "safety_nodes": 391, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 118688, "avg_nodes": 10789.818181818182, "eval_calls": 75062, "avg_eval_calls": 6823.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75062, "pattern_eval_ns": 1542958, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.555780554741414, "pattern_frame_queries": 75062, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1542958, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.555780554741414, "pattern_frame_updates": 236484, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3173488040, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13419.461950914227, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39940, "avg_candidate_generations": 3630.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 3171100, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.39659489233851, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 725, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 39929, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3170375, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 931815, "avg_legality_checks": 84710.45454545454, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4095, "root_legality_checks": 725, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 931090, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4092, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3447313, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 313392.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7320384877, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2123.5045605084306, "renju_forbidden_checks": 51891, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4717.363636363636, "renju_forbidden_ns": 348115045, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6708.582316779403, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5017, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 49590138, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22997, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 196287725, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23862, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 102053611, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 183571, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 95396, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8672.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 820580767, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8601.83620906537, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 127719, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11610.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 348643732, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2729.7718585331863, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2254907170, "stage_ordering_ns": 1242208801, "stage_eval_ns": 3175030998, "stage_threat_ns": 5686959453, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 672698, "root_tactical_annotations": 2205, "search_tactical_annotations": 670493, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 236495, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1370530907, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 517902, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4085210285, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 79934, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2861918169, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 118242, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 170640935, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 236484, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28977762, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 147177, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 166166581, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 290784, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1056966014, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 234737, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 31599564, "child_limit_applications": 39929, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39929, "child_cap_hits": 39929, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39929, "child_moves_before_total": 3166283, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3166283, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 419796, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 419796, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.29782864584638, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.513561571789927, "tt_hits": 23292, "tt_cutoffs": 3251, "beta_cutoffs": 32448, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3065.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3793.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 10, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 650, "avg_search_time_ms": 65.0, "search_nodes": 47020, "safety_nodes": 1041, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48061, "avg_nodes": 4806.1, "eval_calls": 45288, "avg_eval_calls": 4528.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 45288, "line_shape_eval_ns": 42455995, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 937.4667682388271, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1713, "avg_candidate_generations": 171.3, "candidate_moves_total": 125083, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.01984821949796, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 661, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 1703, "search_candidate_moves_total": 124422, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 3666, "avg_legality_checks": 366.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3666, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15454, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1545.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 32620878, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2110.8371942539147, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 299292, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 13012.695652173914, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 142491, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 156801, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10192936, "stage_ordering_ns": 53471, "stage_eval_ns": 42455995, "stage_threat_ns": 582444927, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 93992, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 512196295, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 347582, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 46991, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 58944402, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 93982, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10956648, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 84, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1547, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5905.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6705.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 615, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 31925, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 97, 82, 113, 114, 142, 157, 66, 96, 68, 138, 124, 84, 81, 65, 125, 123, 128, 126, 129, 145, 130, 131, 111, 83, 95, 79, 141, 85, 86, 99, 143, 159, 140, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 15780, "avg_search_time_ms": 876.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 950347, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 951320, "avg_nodes": 52851.11111111111, "eval_calls": 931962, "avg_eval_calls": 51775.666666666664, "line_shape_eval_calls": 931962, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1392415102, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1494.0685371291963, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18351, "avg_candidate_generations": 1019.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1644661, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.62241839681761, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1405, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 18333, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1643256, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 917322, "avg_legality_checks": 50962.333333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1011, "root_legality_checks": 1405, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 915917, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1008, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 938347, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 52130.38888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2255240905, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2403.418889813683, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1205, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 66.94444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10550652, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8755.727800829876, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1190, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10441639, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 109013, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 41, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.2777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 411202, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10029.317073170732, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 197042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3339.6949152542375, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2283287611, "stage_ordering_ns": 579463, "stage_eval_ns": 1392415102, "stage_threat_ns": 12086809437, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1900608, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 10575911128, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 50, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 621703, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19721, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 950295, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1277031867, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1900590, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 233244739, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 804, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 16617, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6167.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6611.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1913, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 16128, "avg_search_time_ms": 948.7058823529412, "search_nodes": 118285, "safety_nodes": 1609, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 119894, "avg_nodes": 7052.588235294118, "eval_calls": 71955, "avg_eval_calls": 4232.64705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71955, "pattern_eval_ns": 1548853, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.525300535056633, "pattern_frame_queries": 71955, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1548853, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.525300535056633, "pattern_frame_updates": 236378, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2455881188, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10389.635194476643, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41633, "avg_candidate_generations": 2449.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3641642, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.47008382773281, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1322, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 41616, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3640320, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 2211598, "avg_legality_checks": 130094.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3498, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2211598, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3498, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5056711, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 297453.5882352941, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10478778219, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2072.251750001137, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45025, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2648.529411764706, "renju_forbidden_ns": 125247602, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2781.734636313159, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3879, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34957989, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7029, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43543999, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 34095, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 46590483, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 155131, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 186851, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10991.235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1787666786, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9567.338606697314, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 268663, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15803.70588235294, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 832845046, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3099.9618332260115, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5236100932, "stage_ordering_ns": 1471759008, "stage_eval_ns": 2457430041, "stage_threat_ns": 6866554841, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 733508, "root_tactical_annotations": 1829, "search_tactical_annotations": 731679, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 236395, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1420407277, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 648498, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5222624855, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 83362, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2795385668, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 118189, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 176384216, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 236378, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29648897, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 128881, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 464371268, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 436244, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1962520287, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 168383, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17489596, "child_limit_applications": 41616, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41616, "child_cap_hits": 41616, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41616, "child_moves_before_total": 3636822, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3636822, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 431415, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 431415, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.3899942329873, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.366565743944637, "tt_hits": 18915, "tt_cutoffs": 4620, "beta_cutoffs": 33286, "depth_sum": 94, "avg_depth": 5.529411764705882, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 94, "avg_effective_depth": 5.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5001.35294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5471.941176470588, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1262, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 616, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14858, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 99, 128, 80, 100, 114, 144, 160, 143, 145, 175, 159, 129, 130, 157, 172, 115, 171, 101 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14517, "avg_search_time_ms": 1319.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 176350, "safety_nodes": 367, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 176717, "avg_nodes": 16065.181818181818, "eval_calls": 113351, "avg_eval_calls": 10304.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 113351, "pattern_eval_ns": 2290284, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.205238595160168, "pattern_frame_queries": 113351, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2290284, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.205238595160168, "pattern_frame_updates": 352606, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4170355586, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11827.239428710798, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 57320, "avg_candidate_generations": 5210.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 4421585, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.13860781577111, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 709, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 57309, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4420876, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1363304, "avg_legality_checks": 123936.72727272728, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4764, "root_legality_checks": 709, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1362595, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4764, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5199334, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 472666.7272727273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8365271023, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1608.9120304639018, "renju_forbidden_checks": 92362, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8396.545454545454, "renju_forbidden_ns": 424635916, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4597.517550507785, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5797, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 31771510, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 50183, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 295948025, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 36380, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 96913731, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2650, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 127012, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11546.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 832406848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6553.765376499859, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 179905, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16355.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 371950336, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2067.4819265723577, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2434631544, "stage_ordering_ns": 1326020337, "stage_eval_ns": 4172645870, "stage_threat_ns": 6507240866, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1027636, "root_tactical_annotations": 2634, "search_tactical_annotations": 1025002, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 352617, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1611343489, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 854337, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4609523040, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 114686, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3177972510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 176303, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 210621666, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 352606, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35866683, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 141397, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 154368650, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 598244, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1277027280, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 287995, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 39885988, "child_limit_applications": 57309, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 57309, "child_cap_hits": 57309, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 57309, "child_moves_before_total": 4416112, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4416112, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 719944, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 719944, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.05791411471148, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.562494547104293, "tt_hits": 28416, "tt_cutoffs": 5644, "beta_cutoffs": 45437, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.090909090909091, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.090909090909091, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2417.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3104.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1072, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 333, "avg_search_time_ms": 33.3, "search_nodes": 27830, "safety_nodes": 966, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 28796, "avg_nodes": 2879.6, "eval_calls": 26526, "avg_eval_calls": 2652.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 26526, "line_shape_eval_ns": 18668242, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 703.771469501621, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1285, "avg_candidate_generations": 128.5, "candidate_moves_total": 88604, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.95252918287937, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 645, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1275, "search_candidate_moves_total": 87959, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 2837, "avg_legality_checks": 283.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2837, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14487, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1448.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24785159, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1710.855180506661, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6809082, "stage_ordering_ns": 40810, "stage_eval_ns": 18668242, "stage_threat_ns": 297105953, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 55612, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 260787117, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 203840, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 27801, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 30407517, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 55602, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5707479, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 67, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1154, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5945.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6745.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 617, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18832, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 126, 98, 109, 108, 83, 114, 66, 158, 143, 156, 96, 81, 142, 97, 94, 78, 129, 93, 123, 140, 172, 92, 127, 124 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 1554, "avg_search_time_ms": 119.53846153846153, "search_nodes": 100750, "safety_nodes": 1331, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 102081, "avg_nodes": 7852.384615384615, "eval_calls": 97645, "avg_eval_calls": 7511.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 97645, "line_shape_eval_ns": 77686496, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 795.6013723180911, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3080, "avg_candidate_generations": 236.92307692307693, "candidate_moves_total": 214956, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.7909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 897, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 3067, "search_candidate_moves_total": 214059, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 91142, "avg_legality_checks": 7010.923076923077, "illegal_moves_skipped": 149, "root_legality_checks": 897, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 90245, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 147, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 106718, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8209.076923076924, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 241517265, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2263.135225547705, "renju_forbidden_checks": 158, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12.153846153846153, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1680008, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10632.962025316456, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 149, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1592758, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 87250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1063375, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10962.62886597938, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.846153846153847, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 577812, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4097.95744680851, "stage_move_gen_ns": 218920724, "stage_ordering_ns": 92102, "stage_eval_ns": 77686496, "stage_threat_ns": 1236353105, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 201437, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1086302374, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1347267, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 100712, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125076429, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 201424, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23627035, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 121, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2798, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6212.538461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6827.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1897, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 17268, "avg_search_time_ms": 1328.3076923076924, "search_nodes": 142890, "safety_nodes": 391, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 143281, "avg_nodes": 11021.615384615385, "eval_calls": 98845, "avg_eval_calls": 7603.461538461538, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 98845, "pattern_eval_ns": 2002949, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.263533815569833, "pattern_frame_queries": 98845, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2002949, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.263533815569833, "pattern_frame_updates": 285650, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3366222741, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11784.431090495362, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41052, "avg_candidate_generations": 3157.846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 3350671, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.62016466920004, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 915, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 41039, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3349756, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 2274276, "avg_legality_checks": 174944.3076923077, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9059, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2274276, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9059, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5533310, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 425639.23076923075, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11123692056, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2010.3142704818636, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58725, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4517.307692307692, "renju_forbidden_ns": 332584152, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5663.41680715198, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9150, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 93126447, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17269, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 153273801, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32291, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 86020574, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 163330, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 193168, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14859.076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1896307589, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9816.882656547668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 271545, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20888.076923076922, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 945252514, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3481.0160894142778, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5311535106, "stage_ordering_ns": 1320572510, "stage_eval_ns": 3368225690, "stage_threat_ns": 7185087096, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 898761, "root_tactical_annotations": 3253, "search_tactical_annotations": 895508, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 285663, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1668674196, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 682131, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5233294849, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 82168, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2796416543, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 142825, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 209796102, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 285650, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35207022, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 226678, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 939152131, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 373276, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1497676255, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 298807, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 38114927, "child_limit_applications": 41039, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41039, "child_cap_hits": 41039, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41039, "child_moves_before_total": 3340697, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3340697, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 484162, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 484162, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.40298252881405, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.797607154170423, "tt_hits": 22821, "tt_cutoffs": 2941, "beta_cutoffs": 31726, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3682.4615384615386, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4297.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1620, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 618, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16061, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 143, 126, 84, 158, 142, 140, 154, 125, 155, 153, 139, 156, 141, 108, 109, 124, 92, 172 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 15531, "avg_search_time_ms": 1411.909090909091, "search_nodes": 146153, "safety_nodes": 366, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 146519, "avg_nodes": 13319.90909090909, "eval_calls": 93948, "avg_eval_calls": 8540.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 93948, "pattern_eval_ns": 1929210, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.534870353812746, "pattern_frame_queries": 93948, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1929210, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.534870353812746, "pattern_frame_updates": 292206, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4376502603, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14977.456325332128, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 48088, "avg_candidate_generations": 4371.636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 3600378, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.8706122109466, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 714, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 48077, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3599664, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 1072048, "avg_legality_checks": 97458.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3843, "root_legality_checks": 714, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1071334, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3842, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4212206, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 382927.8181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9127392487, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2166.891288555213, "renju_forbidden_checks": 66053, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6004.818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 461881491, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6992.589148108337, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4361, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 41402201, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 36670, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 314614041, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24998, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 105661118, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 204131, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97549, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8868.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 871129006, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8930.168489682108, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 136765, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12433.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 382633079, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2797.7412276532737, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2611221668, "stage_ordering_ns": 1473428059, "stage_eval_ns": 4378431813, "stage_threat_ns": 7001019798, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 724953, "root_tactical_annotations": 2586, "search_tactical_annotations": 722367, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 292217, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1722603735, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 635587, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4997468214, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 96225, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3546032739, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 146103, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 218037223, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 292206, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37074577, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 120999, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 166864359, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 418353, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1284367094, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 185601, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 25836049, "child_limit_applications": 48077, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 48077, "child_cap_hits": 48077, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 48077, "child_moves_before_total": 3595822, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3595822, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 551199, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 551199, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.79297793123531, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.46492085612663, "tt_hits": 22876, "tt_cutoffs": 4079, "beta_cutoffs": 37874, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 4.363636363636363, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 4.363636363636363, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1839.3636363636363, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2439.6363636363635, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 648, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 519, "avg_search_time_ms": 51.9, "search_nodes": 35817, "safety_nodes": 968, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 36785, "avg_nodes": 3678.5, "eval_calls": 34391, "avg_eval_calls": 3439.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 34391, "line_shape_eval_ns": 28977557, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 842.5912884184816, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1407, "avg_candidate_generations": 140.7, "candidate_moves_total": 94860, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.42004264392324, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 648, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 1397, "search_candidate_moves_total": 94212, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 3195, "avg_legality_checks": 319.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3195, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14828, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1482.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31842519, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2147.4587941731857, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 216122, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10291.52380952381, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 56300, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 159822, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9047913, "stage_ordering_ns": 44490, "stage_eval_ns": 28977557, "stage_threat_ns": 469893492, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 71586, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 414078566, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 223541, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10730, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35788, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 46852388, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 71576, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8738997, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 68, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1268, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5907.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6707.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1965, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 619, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17800, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 96, 128, 67, 52, 129, 142, 100, 124, 125, 94, 98, 99, 110, 113, 68, 54, 141, 53, 51, 80, 108, 38, 111, 66 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 663, "avg_search_time_ms": 51.0, "search_nodes": 39825, "safety_nodes": 1331, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 41156, "avg_nodes": 3165.846153846154, "eval_calls": 38128, "avg_eval_calls": 2932.923076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 38128, "line_shape_eval_ns": 42031463, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1102.3778587914394, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1672, "avg_candidate_generations": 128.6153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 124051, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.19318181818181, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 897, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 1659, "search_candidate_moves_total": 123154, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 33668, "avg_legality_checks": 2589.846153846154, "illegal_moves_skipped": 74, "root_legality_checks": 897, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 32771, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 72, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 49244, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3788.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 111664286, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2267.571399561368, "renju_forbidden_checks": 83, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6.384615384615385, "renju_forbidden_ns": 949052, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11434.361445783132, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 850892, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 98160, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1142893, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11782.40206185567, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.846153846153847, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 623872, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4424.624113475177, "stage_move_gen_ns": 83316503, "stage_ordering_ns": 55200, "stage_eval_ns": 42031463, "stage_threat_ns": 519002403, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 79587, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 456355025, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1448216, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 39787, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 51576002, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 79574, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9623160, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 121, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1473, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6404.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7019.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1909, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 17125, "avg_search_time_ms": 1317.3076923076924, "search_nodes": 132536, "safety_nodes": 391, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 132927, "avg_nodes": 10225.153846153846, "eval_calls": 90068, "avg_eval_calls": 6928.307692307692, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 90068, "pattern_eval_ns": 1944922, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.5939290313985, "pattern_frame_queries": 90068, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1944922, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.5939290313985, "pattern_frame_updates": 264942, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3295560174, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12438.798582331226, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39551, "avg_candidate_generations": 3042.3846153846152, "candidate_moves_total": 3229456, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.65295441328917, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 915, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 39538, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3228541, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 2271109, "avg_legality_checks": 174700.6923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8970, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2271109, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8970, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5364667, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 412666.6923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11061671052, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2061.949241583867, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58124, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4471.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 424701577, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7306.819506572156, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9304, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 97877017, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25358, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 241722188, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23447, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 84923211, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 179161, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 186413, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14339.461538461539, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1866174793, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10010.969154511757, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 262627, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20202.076923076922, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 939019463, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3575.487147170702, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5411352925, "stage_ordering_ns": 1280743117, "stage_eval_ns": 3297505096, "stage_threat_ns": 7043855737, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 856530, "root_tactical_annotations": 3253, "search_tactical_annotations": 853277, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 264955, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1608959108, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 649559, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5165413171, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 79166, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2786376474, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 132471, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 200851995, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 264942, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34303694, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 225368, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 934508993, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 345016, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1444470374, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 286146, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 34327769, "child_limit_applications": 39538, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39538, "child_cap_hits": 39538, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39538, "child_moves_before_total": 3219571, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3219571, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 456615, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 456615, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.42978906368556, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.548763215134807, "tt_hits": 22336, "tt_cutoffs": 2866, "beta_cutoffs": 31209, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 4.923076923076923, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 4.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3897.3076923076924, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4512.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1475, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 620, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7020, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 96, 111, 128, 80, 127, 142, 98, 95, 113, 143, 99, 100, 141, 85, 155 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6782, "avg_search_time_ms": 847.75, "search_nodes": 68708, "safety_nodes": 64, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68772, "avg_nodes": 8596.5, "eval_calls": 49767, "avg_eval_calls": 6220.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49767, "pattern_eval_ns": 1059283, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.284847388831956, "pattern_frame_queries": 49767, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1059283, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.284847388831956, "pattern_frame_updates": 137348, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2044425950, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14885.007062352564, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17856, "avg_candidate_generations": 2232.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1232446, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.02139336917563, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 438, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 17848, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1232008, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 437933, "avg_legality_checks": 54741.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 503, "root_legality_checks": 438, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 437495, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 503, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1811463, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 226432.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4147263696, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2289.4553717078406, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16963, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2120.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 71330645, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4205.07251075871, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 726, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4877302, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9033, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 50181046, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7204, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16272297, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50779, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6347.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 472891885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9312.745130861183, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 69469, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8683.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 197986042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2849.9912478947444, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1132892832, "stage_ordering_ns": 556925358, "stage_eval_ns": 2045485233, "stage_threat_ns": 3019620226, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 180616, "root_tactical_annotations": 1721, "search_tactical_annotations": 178895, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 137356, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 858559649, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 176987, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2033044272, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35745, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1405427121, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68674, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105758486, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 137348, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18345537, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 38678, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 109047219, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 102557, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 518562532, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 39381, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3912282, "child_limit_applications": 17848, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17848, "child_cap_hits": 17848, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17848, "child_moves_before_total": 1231505, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1231505, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 162433, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 162433, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.99960779919319, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.100907664724339, "tt_hits": 7081, "tt_cutoffs": 1060, "beta_cutoffs": 12694, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 4.125, "max_depth": 6, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 4.125, "max_effective_depth": 6, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2899.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3899.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 231, "avg_search_time_ms": 33.0, "search_nodes": 14570, "safety_nodes": 532, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 15102, "avg_nodes": 2157.4285714285716, "eval_calls": 13633, "avg_eval_calls": 1947.5714285714287, "line_shape_eval_calls": 13633, "line_shape_eval_ns": 9417303, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 690.7726105772757, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 924, "avg_candidate_generations": 132.0, "candidate_moves_total": 55760, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.34632034632035, "candidate_moves_max": 76, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 374, "root_candidate_moves_max": 60, "search_candidate_generations": 917, "search_candidate_moves_total": 55386, "search_candidate_moves_max": 76, "legality_checks": 2160, "avg_legality_checks": 308.57142857142856, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2160, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10204, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1457.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22898494, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2244.0703645629164, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6325788, "stage_ordering_ns": 29800, "stage_eval_ns": 9417303, "stage_threat_ns": 206962048, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 29107, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 182946281, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 200023, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7680, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 14550, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 20063615, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 29100, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 3752129, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 55, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 815, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5049.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6192.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1879, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 621, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 38102, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 97, 82, 114, 115, 68, 126, 94, 81, 125, 83, 80, 99, 67, 70, 84, 100, 139, 153, 85, 101, 98, 87, 129, 103, 102, 131, 147, 145, 117, 146, 132, 162, 116, 71, 55, 73, 59, 72, 69, 74 ], "move_count": 46, "black_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 3161, "avg_search_time_ms": 150.52380952380952, "search_nodes": 193126, "safety_nodes": 2450, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 195576, "avg_nodes": 9313.142857142857, "eval_calls": 187513, "avg_eval_calls": 8929.190476190477, "line_shape_eval_calls": 187513, "line_shape_eval_ns": 214102382, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1141.8002058523941, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5572, "avg_candidate_generations": 265.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 444763, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.82106963388371, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1690, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 5551, "search_candidate_moves_total": 443073, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 181851, "avg_legality_checks": 8659.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1845, "root_legality_checks": 1690, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "search_legality_checks": 180161, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1830, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 206351, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9826.238095238095, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 487473115, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2362.349176887924, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1905, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 90.71428571428571, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20320302, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10666.825196850394, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1845, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19712175, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 608127, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 87, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 910095, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10460.862068965518, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 111, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.285714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 469533, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4230.027027027027, "stage_move_gen_ns": 471960773, "stage_ordering_ns": 182110, "stage_eval_ns": 214102382, "stage_threat_ns": 2444284677, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 386149, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2141109013, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1318890, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 21721, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 193064, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 254928580, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 386128, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46928194, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 285, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5079, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 2.9523809523809526, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9523809523809526, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6913.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7294.0952380952385, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1898, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 34919, "avg_search_time_ms": 1662.8095238095239, "search_nodes": 283104, "safety_nodes": 562, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 283666, "avg_nodes": 13507.904761904761, "eval_calls": 190763, "avg_eval_calls": 9083.952380952382, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 190763, "pattern_eval_ns": 4154815, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.77998353978497, "pattern_frame_queries": 190763, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4154815, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.77998353978497, "pattern_frame_updates": 566000, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4870497393, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8605.119068904594, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 86877, "avg_candidate_generations": 4137.0, "candidate_moves_total": 8189316, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.26333782243861, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1713, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 86856, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8187603, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 5994667, "avg_legality_checks": 285460.3333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 39413, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5994667, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 39413, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11263370, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 536350.9523809524, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22656721584, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2011.5402036868184, "renju_forbidden_checks": 90654, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4316.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 586071818, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6464.930593244644, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 39463, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 371059613, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14739, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 135862490, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 36372, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 78326782, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 80, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 822933, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 337947, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16092.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3106333849, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9191.778145685566, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 453284, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21584.95238095238, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1462547534, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3226.5589211178863, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13764145013, "stage_ordering_ns": 3025168021, "stage_eval_ns": 4874652208, "stage_threat_ns": 13029681525, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1644468, "root_tactical_annotations": 6710, "search_tactical_annotations": 1637758, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 566021, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3224458622, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1380375, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9261512553, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 173857, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5173524283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 283000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 421681703, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 566000, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69288628, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 561774, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1671563985, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 644727, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2416305255, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 437967, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 52740019, "child_limit_applications": 86856, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 86856, "child_cap_hits": 86856, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 86856, "child_moves_before_total": 8148190, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8148190, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 819147, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 819147, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.81263240305793, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.431092843326885, "tt_hits": 45116, "tt_cutoffs": 5385, "beta_cutoffs": 67850, "depth_sum": 100, "avg_depth": 4.761904761904762, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 100, "avg_effective_depth": 4.761904761904762, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.19047619047619047, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.19047619047619047, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3362.9523809523807, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3705.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1640, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 622, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 44531, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 82, 124, 114, 98, 140, 125, 127, 139, 97, 123, 122, 109, 68, 54, 94, 93, 141, 107, 143, 144, 155, 75, 91, 61, 77, 84, 70, 108, 169, 183, 78, 79, 62, 46, 121, 137, 95, 31, 76, 151, 165, 167, 153, 199, 135, 215 ], "move_count": 53, "black_stats": { "move_count": 27, "search_move_count": 25, "total_time_ms": 43275, "avg_search_time_ms": 1731.0, "search_nodes": 462355, "safety_nodes": 574, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 462929, "avg_nodes": 18517.16, "eval_calls": 303653, "avg_eval_calls": 12146.12, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 303653, "pattern_eval_ns": 6594248, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.716393383236788, "pattern_frame_queries": 303653, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6594248, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.716393383236788, "pattern_frame_updates": 924436, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 10947066619, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11841.886965674206, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 146731, "avg_candidate_generations": 5869.24, "candidate_moves_total": 13888506, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.65284091296317, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 25, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2117, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 146706, "search_candidate_moves_total": 13886389, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 3221046, "avg_legality_checks": 128841.84, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12659, "root_legality_checks": 2117, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 3218929, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12651, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12087556, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 483502.24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24386810719, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2017.513773586654, "renju_forbidden_checks": 136182, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5447.28, "renju_forbidden_ns": 428041588, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3143.158332231866, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 13935, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 41329274, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 70638, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 272593986, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 51569, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 114010907, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 107421, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 359890, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14395.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2988591855, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8304.181430437078, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 494280, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19771.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1337393467, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2705.740606538804, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7473458988, "stage_ordering_ns": 5170234096, "stage_eval_ns": 10953660867, "stage_threat_ns": 19531017931, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 3499206, "root_tactical_annotations": 9184, "search_tactical_annotations": 3490022, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 924461, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5101038673, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2825807, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 13488634393, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 293598, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8639592928, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 462218, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 697477252, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 924436, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 112572330, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1267432, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1091294788, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1264757, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3757657986, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 967017, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 131295283, "child_limit_applications": 146706, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 146706, "child_cap_hits": 146706, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 146706, "child_moves_before_total": 13873738, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 13873738, "child_moves_before_max": 134, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 134, "child_moves_after_total": 1632768, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1632768, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 94.56830668138998, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.129524354832114, "tt_hits": 83616, "tt_cutoffs": 11865, "beta_cutoffs": 121301, "depth_sum": 129, "avg_depth": 5.16, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 129, "avg_effective_depth": 5.16, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 8, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.32, "pooled_budget_moves": 25, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 8, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.32, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1314.44, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1588.16, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 1231, "avg_search_time_ms": 51.291666666666664, "search_nodes": 89187, "safety_nodes": 3174, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92361, "avg_nodes": 3848.375, "eval_calls": 85114, "avg_eval_calls": 3546.4166666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 85114, "line_shape_eval_ns": 126318636, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1484.1111450525177, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4026, "avg_candidate_generations": 167.75, "candidate_moves_total": 335698, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.38251366120218, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2044, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 4002, "search_candidate_moves_total": 333654, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 9054, "avg_legality_checks": 377.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9054, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 36155, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1506.4583333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 75107314, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2077.3700456368415, "renju_forbidden_checks": 52, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 170102, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3271.1923076923076, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 82382, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 87720, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23554161, "stage_ordering_ns": 126620, "stage_eval_ns": 126318636, "stage_threat_ns": 1050076198, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 178256, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 917508601, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 65, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 695743, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 26340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89116, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 111890701, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 178232, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19981153, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 159, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3692, "depth_sum": 71, "avg_depth": 2.9583333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 71, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9583333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 23 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7127.708333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7461.041666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 623, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14279, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 111, 110, 142, 157, 68, 98, 66, 138, 124, 80, 83, 130, 146, 125, 69, 55, 67, 65, 70 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2882, "avg_search_time_ms": 262.0, "search_nodes": 171081, "safety_nodes": 1009, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 172090, "avg_nodes": 15644.545454545454, "eval_calls": 166953, "avg_eval_calls": 15177.545454545454, "line_shape_eval_calls": 166953, "line_shape_eval_ns": 133142956, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 797.4876522134972, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4108, "avg_candidate_generations": 373.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 296948, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.28529698149951, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 822, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 4097, "search_candidate_moves_total": 296126, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 162868, "avg_legality_checks": 14806.181818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 422, "root_legality_checks": 822, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 162046, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 419, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 176017, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16001.545454545454, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 448603973, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2548.640034769369, "renju_forbidden_checks": 437, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 39.72727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5185128, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11865.281464530892, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 422, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5029187, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 155941, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.4545454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 434152, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11425.052631578947, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 55, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 222202, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4040.0363636363636, "stage_move_gen_ns": 436387196, "stage_ordering_ns": 131390, "stage_eval_ns": 133142956, "stage_threat_ns": 2301006167, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 342111, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2025081913, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 606742, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 171050, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 231511028, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 342100, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43806484, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 194, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3760, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5598.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6326.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1910, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11385, "avg_search_time_ms": 1138.5, "search_nodes": 74015, "safety_nodes": 688, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 74703, "avg_nodes": 7470.3, "eval_calls": 44935, "avg_eval_calls": 4493.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44935, "pattern_eval_ns": 996976, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.18707021252921, "pattern_frame_queries": 44935, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 996976, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.18707021252921, "pattern_frame_updates": 147934, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1554536299, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10508.309780037043, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26686, "avg_candidate_generations": 2668.6, "candidate_moves_total": 2251047, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.3531064977891, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 739, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 26676, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2250308, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1532443, "avg_legality_checks": 153244.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5784, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1532443, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5784, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3490357, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 349035.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7542334417, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2160.9062961181335, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33079, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3307.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 164672107, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4978.146467547386, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5786, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 64129540, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6259, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 61945818, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21019, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 38409236, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 187513, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 146101, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14610.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1506231436, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10309.521741808749, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 212068, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21206.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 728748819, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3436.392190240866, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3878788318, "stage_ordering_ns": 969683740, "stage_eval_ns": 1555533275, "stage_threat_ns": 4917685997, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 374250, "root_tactical_annotations": 1698, "search_tactical_annotations": 372552, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 147944, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 931332390, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 355051, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3843603318, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53420, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1964504670, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 73967, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 115470240, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 147934, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19195846, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 66486, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 415832834, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 235138, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1463098944, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 72626, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8084203, "child_limit_applications": 26676, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26676, "child_cap_hits": 26676, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26676, "child_moves_before_total": 2244524, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2244524, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 265108, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 265108, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.14020092967462, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.93807167491378, "tt_hits": 11279, "tt_cutoffs": 2356, "beta_cutoffs": 21054, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3106.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3906.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1110, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 624, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12298, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 98, 68, 54, 81, 111, 83, 84, 80, 79, 110, 124, 95, 70, 126, 56 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8691, "avg_search_time_ms": 965.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 76603, "safety_nodes": 569, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 77172, "avg_nodes": 8574.666666666666, "eval_calls": 47804, "avg_eval_calls": 5311.555555555556, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47804, "pattern_eval_ns": 1047468, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.911722868379215, "pattern_frame_queries": 47804, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1047468, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.911722868379215, "pattern_frame_updates": 153120, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1879593469, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12275.296950104494, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26781, "avg_candidate_generations": 2975.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 1963093, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.30170643366566, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 545, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 26772, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1962548, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 706743, "avg_legality_checks": 78527.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1072, "root_legality_checks": 545, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 706198, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1072, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2280441, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 253382.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5301579199, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2324.804368540997, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16747, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1860.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 99689974, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5952.706395175255, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1138, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12240157, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7025, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62432942, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8584, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25016875, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59720, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6635.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 581274271, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9733.32670797053, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 83557, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9284.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 255204152, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3054.2522110655, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1838154676, "stage_ordering_ns": 857940456, "stage_eval_ns": 1880640937, "stage_threat_ns": 4080048734, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 336357, "root_tactical_annotations": 1068, "search_tactical_annotations": 335289, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 153129, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 954295270, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 277903, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2970755352, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53604, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2120817632, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 119956776, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 153120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20050088, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44902, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 82560769, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 179391, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 766973808, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 112064, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14991248, "child_limit_applications": 26772, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26772, "child_cap_hits": 26772, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26772, "child_moves_before_total": 1961476, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1961476, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 249829, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 249829, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.26594949947706, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.33172717764829, "tt_hits": 13881, "tt_cutoffs": 1985, "beta_cutoffs": 20829, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2335.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3223.8888888888887, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 3600, "avg_search_time_ms": 450.0, "search_nodes": 262408, "safety_nodes": 547, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 262955, "avg_nodes": 32869.375, "eval_calls": 256184, "avg_eval_calls": 32023.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 256184, "line_shape_eval_ns": 223769279, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 873.4709388564469, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6209, "avg_candidate_generations": 776.125, "candidate_moves_total": 441016, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.02850700595909, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 489, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 6201, "search_candidate_moves_total": 440527, "search_candidate_moves_max": 89, "legality_checks": 11595, "avg_legality_checks": 1449.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11595, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20855, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2606.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 53167365, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2549.382162550947, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 36253851, "stage_ordering_ns": 198553, "stage_eval_ns": 223769279, "stage_threat_ns": 3327946137, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 524778, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2915741355, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 257850, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8960, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 262385, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 348052084, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 524770, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63894848, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 191, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5760, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4626.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5626.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 625, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16459, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 98, 126, 67, 52, 125, 142, 94, 130, 129, 100, 96, 95, 114, 111, 66, 50, 143, 51, 53, 84, 116, 36, 113, 68 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 621, "avg_search_time_ms": 47.76923076923077, "search_nodes": 41474, "safety_nodes": 1331, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 42805, "avg_nodes": 3292.6923076923076, "eval_calls": 39728, "avg_eval_calls": 3056.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 39728, "line_shape_eval_ns": 35133346, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 884.3472110350383, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1721, "avg_candidate_generations": 132.3846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 127867, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.29808251016851, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 897, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 1708, "search_candidate_moves_total": 126970, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 35286, "avg_legality_checks": 2714.3076923076924, "illegal_moves_skipped": 110, "root_legality_checks": 897, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 34389, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 108, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 50862, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3912.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 102275844, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2010.8498289489205, "renju_forbidden_checks": 119, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9.153846153846153, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1084694, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9115.0756302521, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 110, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1032683, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 52011, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 929673, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9584.257731958764, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.846153846153847, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 511662, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3628.808510638298, "stage_move_gen_ns": 79663010, "stage_ordering_ns": 56811, "stage_eval_ns": 35133346, "stage_threat_ns": 491035333, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 82885, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 432629314, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1178736, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11070, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 41436, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 48334728, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 82872, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8892555, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 121, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1519, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6403.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7018.538461538462, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1906, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 15826, "avg_search_time_ms": 1217.3846153846155, "search_nodes": 150142, "safety_nodes": 391, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 150533, "avg_nodes": 11579.461538461539, "eval_calls": 105347, "avg_eval_calls": 8103.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105347, "pattern_eval_ns": 2177928, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.673849279049236, "pattern_frame_queries": 105347, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2177928, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.673849279049236, "pattern_frame_updates": 300154, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3218520770, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10722.898145618583, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41847, "avg_candidate_generations": 3219.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3417631, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.66967763519487, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 915, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 41834, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3416716, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 2325556, "avg_legality_checks": 178888.92307692306, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13883, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2325556, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13883, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5685461, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 437343.1538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9960451150, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1751.9161858642597, "renju_forbidden_checks": 82205, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6323.461538461538, "renju_forbidden_ns": 518394165, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6306.114774040509, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 14215, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 124755883, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34752, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 287196633, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 33223, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 106316946, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 124703, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 195883, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15067.923076923076, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1669243183, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8521.633745654293, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 274686, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21129.69230769231, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 838811126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3053.7090568867725, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4831328909, "stage_ordering_ns": 1157947240, "stage_eval_ns": 3220698698, "stage_threat_ns": 6519749165, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 924322, "root_tactical_annotations": 3253, "search_tactical_annotations": 921069, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 300167, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1518220865, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 701049, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4737225998, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 83758, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2572385783, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 150077, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 191846461, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 300154, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32920780, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 233425, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 795826254, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 383857, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1368956021, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 307040, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 39535061, "child_limit_applications": 41834, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41834, "child_cap_hits": 41834, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41834, "child_moves_before_total": 3402833, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3402833, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 497232, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 497232, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.34132523784481, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.885834488693407, "tt_hits": 23209, "tt_cutoffs": 2896, "beta_cutoffs": 32215, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3982.846153846154, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4598.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1535, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 626, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32725, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 127, 142, 126, 114, 156, 82, 98, 140, 141, 111, 155, 113, 171, 186, 157, 100, 86, 158, 173, 125, 139, 95, 80, 187, 172, 170, 185, 143, 169, 183, 154, 153, 124, 109, 184 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 31645, "avg_search_time_ms": 1758.0555555555557, "search_nodes": 329099, "safety_nodes": 359, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 329458, "avg_nodes": 18303.222222222223, "eval_calls": 224352, "avg_eval_calls": 12464.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 224352, "pattern_eval_ns": 4911038, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.889878405363, "pattern_frame_queries": 224352, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4911038, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.889878405363, "pattern_frame_updates": 658000, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8250686300, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12539.036930091186, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 98646, "avg_candidate_generations": 5480.333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 8539559, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.56771688664517, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1329, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 98628, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8538230, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 2166929, "avg_legality_checks": 120384.94444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2728, "root_legality_checks": 1329, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 2165600, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2726, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8550964, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 475053.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18060718054, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2112.1265454982617, "renju_forbidden_checks": 69892, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3882.8888888888887, "renju_forbidden_ns": 262420306, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3754.6544096606194, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3235, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22690482, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34960, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 164613318, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 31680, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 75038546, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 77960, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 267646, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14869.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2165947456, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8092.582949119359, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 348351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19352.833333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 877601374, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2519.302008606262, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5279098880, "stage_ordering_ns": 3472188157, "stage_eval_ns": 8255597338, "stage_threat_ns": 14542557483, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2056723, "root_tactical_annotations": 5759, "search_tactical_annotations": 2050964, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 658018, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3793559704, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1754542, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10100372259, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 197390, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6528074878, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 329000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 498274953, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 658000, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 83196157, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 601691, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 798021372, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 955446, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2774160428, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 499586, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 67154410, "child_limit_applications": 98628, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 98628, "child_cap_hits": 98628, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 98628, "child_moves_before_total": 8535504, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8535504, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 1000464, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1000464, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.54240175203796, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.143813115950845, "tt_hits": 47483, "tt_cutoffs": 6022, "beta_cutoffs": 79682, "depth_sum": 95, "avg_depth": 5.277777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 95, "avg_effective_depth": 5.277777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1188.6666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1438.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 1061, "avg_search_time_ms": 62.411764705882355, "search_nodes": 72148, "safety_nodes": 1941, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 74089, "avg_nodes": 4358.176470588235, "eval_calls": 68750, "avg_eval_calls": 4044.1176470588234, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68750, "line_shape_eval_ns": 70778952, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1029.512029090909, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3365, "avg_candidate_generations": 197.94117647058823, "candidate_moves_total": 254433, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.61158989598812, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1257, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 3348, "search_candidate_moves_total": 253176, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 6375, "avg_legality_checks": 375.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6375, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 25885, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1522.6470588235295, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 56401743, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2178.9354066061424, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.411764705882353, "renju_forbidden_ns": 134371, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5598.791666666667, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 51341, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 83030, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18520651, "stage_ordering_ns": 107630, "stage_eval_ns": 70778952, "stage_threat_ns": 954104539, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 144213, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 838417513, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 47, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 492012, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72098, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 97107120, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 144196, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18087894, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 143, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3066, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6737.823529411765, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7208.411764705882, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 627, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25071, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 127, 142, 114, 115, 94, 96, 68, 124, 138, 122, 95, 143, 83, 125, 123, 98, 109, 137, 93, 108, 67, 81, 79, 63, 66, 65, 99, 158, 174, 141, 69, 70, 84, 54, 129 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 6982, "avg_search_time_ms": 367.4736842105263, "search_nodes": 610387, "safety_nodes": 1078, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 611465, "avg_nodes": 32182.36842105263, "eval_calls": 593989, "avg_eval_calls": 31262.57894736842, "line_shape_eval_calls": 593989, "line_shape_eval_ns": 634401178, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1068.0352296086292, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16362, "avg_candidate_generations": 861.1578947368421, "candidate_moves_total": 1456628, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.02505806136169, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1478, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 16343, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1455150, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 576288, "avg_legality_checks": 30330.947368421053, "illegal_moves_skipped": 759, "root_legality_checks": 1478, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 574810, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 757, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 598240, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 31486.315789473683, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 991709013, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1657.7109738566462, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1183, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 62.26315789473684, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5832396, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4930.1741335587485, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1170, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5767776, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 64620, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.736842105263158, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 461884, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8882.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.5789473684210527, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 198222, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2915.029411764706, "stage_move_gen_ns": 995883922, "stage_ordering_ns": 469843, "stage_eval_ns": 634401178, "stage_threat_ns": 5261007017, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1220683, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4557966029, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 668784, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15290, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 610332, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 596319726, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1220664, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 106052478, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 797, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 14617, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6748.1578947368425, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7169.210526315789, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1886, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 18067, "avg_search_time_ms": 1003.7222222222222, "search_nodes": 163033, "safety_nodes": 1840, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 164873, "avg_nodes": 9159.611111111111, "eval_calls": 97496, "avg_eval_calls": 5416.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 97496, "pattern_eval_ns": 1939985, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.898098383523426, "pattern_frame_queries": 97496, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1939985, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.898098383523426, "pattern_frame_updates": 325856, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2797681367, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8585.637112712364, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 57570, "avg_candidate_generations": 3198.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 5150872, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.47146083029355, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1405, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 57552, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5149467, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 3003965, "avg_legality_checks": 166886.94444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1834, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3003965, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1834, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6990960, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 388386.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11628594733, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1663.3759502271505, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65064, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3614.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 134968203, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2074.391414607156, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4242, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18546731, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15923, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62675781, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 44870, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 53624350, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 121341, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 263843, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14657.944444444445, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2042562703, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7741.583832051637, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 362382, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20132.333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 946086405, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2610.743373015216, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5845693032, "stage_ordering_ns": 1600930668, "stage_eval_ns": 2799621352, "stage_threat_ns": 7692539656, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1169380, "root_tactical_annotations": 2038, "search_tactical_annotations": 1167342, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 325874, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1569099190, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1024626, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5863859357, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 115245, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3053168044, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 162928, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 202204891, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 325856, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33764322, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 220070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 518940623, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 689298, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2291440797, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 260012, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23611896, "child_limit_applications": 57552, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 57552, "child_cap_hits": 57552, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 57552, "child_moves_before_total": 5147633, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5147633, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 663307, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 663307, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.44316444259105, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.525350986933555, "tt_hits": 27867, "tt_cutoffs": 7882, "beta_cutoffs": 47013, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4823.722222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5268.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1053, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 628, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16163, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 141, 128, 80, 156, 142, 144, 160, 129, 159, 161, 145, 158, 143, 116, 115, 130, 102, 172 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 15646, "avg_search_time_ms": 1422.3636363636363, "search_nodes": 147633, "safety_nodes": 366, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 147999, "avg_nodes": 13454.454545454546, "eval_calls": 95174, "avg_eval_calls": 8652.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 95174, "pattern_eval_ns": 1972953, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.729957761573537, "pattern_frame_queries": 95174, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1972953, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.729957761573537, "pattern_frame_updates": 295166, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4406033298, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14927.306322543924, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 48284, "avg_candidate_generations": 4389.454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 3639086, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.36836219037362, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 714, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 48273, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3638372, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 1090613, "avg_legality_checks": 99146.63636363637, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3801, "root_legality_checks": 714, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1089899, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3800, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4255469, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 386860.8181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9246453157, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2172.8399753352687, "renju_forbidden_checks": 67127, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6102.454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 459726928, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6848.614238681901, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4329, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 40942010, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37342, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 314921962, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25432, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 103649856, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 213100, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 101094, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9190.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 907986630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8981.60751379904, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 141575, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12870.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 397600931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2808.412014833127, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2668139710, "stage_ordering_ns": 1476082738, "stage_eval_ns": 4408006251, "stage_threat_ns": 7048828862, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 725327, "root_tactical_annotations": 2586, "search_tactical_annotations": 722741, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 295177, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1734430778, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 635293, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5035857177, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 96617, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3548805807, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147583, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 217079551, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 295166, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37087943, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 122447, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 180190083, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 416219, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1306666256, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 186661, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24373413, "child_limit_applications": 48273, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 48273, "child_cap_hits": 48273, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 48273, "child_moves_before_total": 3634572, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3634572, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 551130, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 551130, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.29202659871979, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.416941147225156, "tt_hits": 22937, "tt_cutoffs": 4137, "beta_cutoffs": 38119, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 4.363636363636363, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 4.363636363636363, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1715.7272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2297.3636363636365, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 494, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 504, "avg_search_time_ms": 50.4, "search_nodes": 34920, "safety_nodes": 968, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35888, "avg_nodes": 3588.8, "eval_calls": 33495, "avg_eval_calls": 3349.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 33495, "line_shape_eval_ns": 28145251, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 840.2821615166442, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1406, "avg_candidate_generations": 140.6, "candidate_moves_total": 94807, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.43029871977241, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 648, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 1396, "search_candidate_moves_total": 94159, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 3031, "avg_legality_checks": 303.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3031, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14664, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1466.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 33097542, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2257.0609656301144, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 217770, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10370.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 59470, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 158300, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8598849, "stage_ordering_ns": 44480, "stage_eval_ns": 28145251, "stage_threat_ns": 457276508, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 69792, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 403773314, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 227002, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34891, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 44813020, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 69782, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8463172, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 68, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1267, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5910.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6710.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1966, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 629, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17471, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 96, 128, 109, 108, 143, 114, 100, 156, 170, 124, 140, 83, 68, 82, 125, 155, 95, 80, 127, 79, 159 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 1304, "avg_search_time_ms": 108.66666666666667, "search_nodes": 80432, "safety_nodes": 1235, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 81667, "avg_nodes": 6805.583333333333, "eval_calls": 77906, "avg_eval_calls": 6492.166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 77906, "line_shape_eval_ns": 64664059, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 830.0266860062126, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2504, "avg_candidate_generations": 208.66666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 176773, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.59624600638978, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 844, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 2492, "search_candidate_moves_total": 175929, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 76502, "avg_legality_checks": 6375.166666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 844, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 75658, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 90858, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7571.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 215531957, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2372.184694798477, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.3333333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 365772, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9144.3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 177461, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 188311, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 868663, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11429.776315789473, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.833333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 470030, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3983.3050847457625, "stage_move_gen_ns": 191995242, "stage_ordering_ns": 75850, "stage_eval_ns": 64664059, "stage_threat_ns": 1033659393, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 160808, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 908860390, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1139065, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11780, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 80398, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104140385, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 160796, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19519553, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 121, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2256, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6114.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6781.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1900, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 16154, "avg_search_time_ms": 1468.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 107567, "safety_nodes": 406, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 107973, "avg_nodes": 9815.727272727272, "eval_calls": 68744, "avg_eval_calls": 6249.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68744, "pattern_eval_ns": 1445595, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.02867159315722, "pattern_frame_queries": 68744, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1445595, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.02867159315722, "pattern_frame_updates": 215020, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2743665027, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12760.045702725329, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35544, "avg_candidate_generations": 3231.2727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 3030558, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.26215395003376, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 780, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 35533, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3029778, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 2184561, "avg_legality_checks": 198596.45454545456, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10355, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2184561, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10355, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5189965, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 471815.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10628340453, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2047.8636085214448, "renju_forbidden_checks": 71711, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6519.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 365466143, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5096.374935505013, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11273, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 115181255, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18582, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 160572874, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 41836, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 89492583, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 219431, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 213959, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19450.81818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2190456455, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10237.739263129852, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 312337, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 28394.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1109598586, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3552.568494926954, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5263937704, "stage_ordering_ns": 1226290370, "stage_eval_ns": 2745110622, "stage_threat_ns": 6840775466, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 729291, "root_tactical_annotations": 2632, "search_tactical_annotations": 726659, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 215031, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1298894108, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 606026, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5328093151, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 71145, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2569233074, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 107510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 161840499, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 215020, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27441692, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 157126, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 641391412, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 377748, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2117416845, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 194417, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24506016, "child_limit_applications": 35533, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35533, "child_cap_hits": 35533, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35533, "child_moves_before_total": 3019423, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3019423, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 419333, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 419333, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.975178003546, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.80122702839614, "tt_hits": 17847, "tt_cutoffs": 3235, "beta_cutoffs": 28333, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.909090909090909, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2545.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3081.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 48, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 630, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12827, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 113, 114, 128, 82, 66, 110, 158, 68, 143, 173, 124, 54, 127, 96 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 8167, "avg_search_time_ms": 1166.7142857142858, "search_nodes": 78493, "safety_nodes": 388, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 78881, "avg_nodes": 11268.714285714286, "eval_calls": 47924, "avg_eval_calls": 6846.285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47924, "pattern_eval_ns": 984243, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.537580335531256, "pattern_frame_queries": 47924, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 984243, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.537580335531256, "pattern_frame_updates": 156910, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1638006972, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10439.149652667134, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28369, "avg_candidate_generations": 4052.714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 2156220, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.00620395502132, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 444, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 28362, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2155776, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 697034, "avg_legality_checks": 99576.28571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2203, "root_legality_checks": 444, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 696590, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2199, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2184627, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 312089.5714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4844345974, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2217.4705219701123, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16413, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2344.714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 101321521, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6173.248096021446, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2209, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23826294, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6344, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 54188540, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7838, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23053855, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 252832, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43315, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6187.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 402751465, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9298.198430105045, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 58011, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8287.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 179312574, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3091.0098774370376, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1732565191, "stage_ordering_ns": 916587198, "stage_eval_ns": 1638991215, "stage_threat_ns": 3846179453, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 324950, "root_tactical_annotations": 1241, "search_tactical_annotations": 323709, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 156917, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 914202915, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 298966, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2789912723, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56776, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2117146458, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78455, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112417988, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 156910, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19465991, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 45050, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 50652485, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 197133, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 621802308, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 82767, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10179836, "child_limit_applications": 28362, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28362, "child_cap_hits": 28362, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28362, "child_moves_before_total": 2153577, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2153577, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 254166, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 254166, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.93177491009097, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.961497778718003, "tt_hits": 12184, "tt_cutoffs": 2169, "beta_cutoffs": 21929, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1242.5714285714287, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2079.5714285714284, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 4653, "avg_search_time_ms": 664.7142857142857, "search_nodes": 343301, "safety_nodes": 244, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 343545, "avg_nodes": 49077.857142857145, "eval_calls": 335947, "avg_eval_calls": 47992.42857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 335947, "line_shape_eval_ns": 286012869, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 851.363069174602, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7342, "avg_candidate_generations": 1048.857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 568594, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.44402070280577, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 459, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 7335, "search_candidate_moves_total": 568135, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 14016, "avg_legality_checks": 2002.2857142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 262, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 14016, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 262, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22188, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3169.714285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 53797980, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2424.643050297458, "renju_forbidden_checks": 282, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 40.285714285714285, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3275009, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11613.50709219858, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 262, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3039279, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 235730, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 43508370, "stage_ordering_ns": 216341, "stage_eval_ns": 286012869, "stage_threat_ns": 4327062642, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 686571, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3803443977, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 54331, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6760, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 343282, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 441171252, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 686564, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 82393082, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 261, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6798, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3851.714285714286, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4994.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 631, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9532, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 82, 111, 143, 98, 142, 95, 96, 84, 126, 125, 158, 173, 110, 174, 94 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 2047, "avg_search_time_ms": 255.875, "search_nodes": 129812, "safety_nodes": 221, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 130033, "avg_nodes": 16254.125, "eval_calls": 125841, "avg_eval_calls": 15730.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 125841, "line_shape_eval_ns": 94770006, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 753.0932367034592, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3956, "avg_candidate_generations": 494.5, "candidate_moves_total": 239067, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.43149646107179, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 404, "root_candidate_moves_max": 65, "search_candidate_generations": 3948, "search_candidate_moves_total": 238663, "search_candidate_moves_max": 86, "legality_checks": 120480, "avg_legality_checks": 15060.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "root_legality_checks": 404, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 120076, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 129468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16183.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 313229785, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2419.3606528254086, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 595461, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11027.055555555555, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 54, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 595461, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 6, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 58851, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9808.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 26671, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3333.875, "stage_move_gen_ns": 303299509, "stage_ordering_ns": 122830, "stage_eval_ns": 94770006, "stage_threat_ns": 1639606632, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 259586, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1441863170, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 106951, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129789, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 166369938, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 259578, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31266573, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 234, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3557, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5049.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6049.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1943, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7477, "avg_search_time_ms": 934.625, "search_nodes": 60698, "safety_nodes": 598, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 61296, "avg_nodes": 7662.0, "eval_calls": 39384, "avg_eval_calls": 4923.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39384, "pattern_eval_ns": 809343, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.55004570383912, "pattern_frame_queries": 39384, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 809343, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.55004570383912, "pattern_frame_updates": 121314, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1494831678, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12322.004698550869, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19331, "avg_candidate_generations": 2416.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1283380, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.38973669235942, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 431, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 19323, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1282949, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 811972, "avg_legality_checks": 101496.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1465, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 811972, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1465, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2319711, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 289963.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4849689580, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2090.6438689991987, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15603, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1950.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 83832648, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5372.854451067103, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1479, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14847780, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5773, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 53919397, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8351, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15065471, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93640, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11705.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 906807613, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9683.977071764204, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 130100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16262.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 419488537, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3224.354627209839, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1960730175, "stage_ordering_ns": 546980790, "stage_eval_ns": 1495641021, "stage_threat_ns": 3441340790, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 307528, "root_tactical_annotations": 700, "search_tactical_annotations": 306828, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 121322, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 724904014, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 270033, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2603092585, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38702, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1437627640, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 60657, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90033485, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 121314, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15271155, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52937, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 308566190, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 178387, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 856686615, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76204, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8039551, "child_limit_applications": 19323, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19323, "child_cap_hits": 19323, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19323, "child_moves_before_total": 1281484, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1281484, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 209447, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 209447, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 66.31910158878021, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.83925891424727, "tt_hits": 9035, "tt_cutoffs": 1951, "beta_cutoffs": 15058, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2435.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3435.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 445, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 632, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8177, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 98, 114, 100, 99, 84, 126, 68, 116, 67, 82, 70, 56, 69, 71, 66 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7627, "avg_search_time_ms": 847.4444444444445, "search_nodes": 76524, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76682, "avg_nodes": 8520.222222222223, "eval_calls": 46701, "avg_eval_calls": 5189.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46701, "pattern_eval_ns": 978982, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.962763109997645, "pattern_frame_queries": 46701, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 978982, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.962763109997645, "pattern_frame_updates": 152962, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1738322239, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11364.405793595795, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28020, "avg_candidate_generations": 3113.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 1946521, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.46898643825838, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 28011, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1946021, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 573891, "avg_legality_checks": 63765.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 183, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 573391, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2062409, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 229156.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4559122928, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2210.581377408652, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22300, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2477.777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 74736912, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3351.4310313901346, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1361, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5026434, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10151, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 45589777, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10783, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24063051, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57650, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4122.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 312315096, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8417.515996011105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 47826, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5314.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 123601841, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2584.406828921507, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1397360648, "stage_ordering_ns": 797082625, "stage_eval_ns": 1739301221, "stage_threat_ns": 3665698751, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 393813, "root_tactical_annotations": 1800, "search_tactical_annotations": 392013, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152971, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 899757053, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 289845, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2615812612, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56082, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2096420853, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76481, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112375061, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152962, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18853208, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 87656, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 60954672, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 146099, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 458293047, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 160058, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18900817, "child_limit_applications": 28011, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28011, "child_cap_hits": 28011, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28011, "child_moves_before_total": 1945839, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1945839, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 254167, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 254167, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.46695940880369, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.073828138945414, "tt_hits": 16934, "tt_cutoffs": 1769, "beta_cutoffs": 22133, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3467.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4355.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 968, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 541, "avg_search_time_ms": 67.625, "search_nodes": 38593, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 39189, "avg_nodes": 4898.625, "eval_calls": 37236, "avg_eval_calls": 4654.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 37236, "line_shape_eval_ns": 31245018, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 839.1077989042861, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1342, "avg_candidate_generations": 167.75, "candidate_moves_total": 85333, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.58643815201192, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1334, "search_candidate_moves_total": 84886, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 2405, "avg_legality_checks": 300.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2405, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11516, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1439.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24803856, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2153.860368183397, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 87330, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7277.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22890, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 64440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7017537, "stage_ordering_ns": 40260, "stage_eval_ns": 31245018, "stage_threat_ns": 494262913, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 77148, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 435361179, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 166931, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 49507251, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 77140, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9227552, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1224, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5406.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6406.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 633, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19664, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 96, 128, 125, 143, 109, 108, 98, 129, 130, 97, 81, 145, 161, 158, 173, 141, 155, 99, 85, 144, 142, 114, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 868, "avg_search_time_ms": 66.76923076923077, "search_nodes": 52640, "safety_nodes": 1047, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53687, "avg_nodes": 4129.7692307692305, "eval_calls": 50423, "avg_eval_calls": 3878.6923076923076, "line_shape_eval_calls": 50423, "line_shape_eval_ns": 40874809, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 810.6381809888345, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2192, "avg_candidate_generations": 168.6153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 144880, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.0948905109489, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 847, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 2179, "search_candidate_moves_total": 144033, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 49168, "avg_legality_checks": 3782.153846153846, "illegal_moves_skipped": 180, "root_legality_checks": 847, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 48321, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 169, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 64225, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4940.384615384615, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 152903066, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2380.740615025302, "renju_forbidden_checks": 224, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 17.23076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2504565, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11181.09375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 180, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2001722, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 502843, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.615384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 663173, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11052.883333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 85, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.538461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 352082, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4142.141176470588, "stage_move_gen_ns": 128029584, "stage_ordering_ns": 69470, "stage_eval_ns": 40874809, "stage_threat_ns": 682907205, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 105217, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 601017155, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 849724, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13780, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52602, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68347854, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 105204, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12692472, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 93, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1976, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6326.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6942.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1930, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18782, "avg_search_time_ms": 1444.7692307692307, "search_nodes": 127381, "safety_nodes": 744, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 128125, "avg_nodes": 9855.76923076923, "eval_calls": 83814, "avg_eval_calls": 6447.2307692307695, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83814, "pattern_eval_ns": 1775745, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.18673491302169, "pattern_frame_queries": 83814, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1775745, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.18673491302169, "pattern_frame_updates": 254638, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3463439990, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13601.42629929547, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39513, "avg_candidate_generations": 3039.4615384615386, "candidate_moves_total": 3060603, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.45812770480602, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 886, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 39500, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3059717, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 2255404, "avg_legality_checks": 173492.61538461538, "illegal_moves_skipped": 31067, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2255404, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 31067, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5971958, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 459381.3846153846, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12062499472, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2019.856715670137, "renju_forbidden_checks": 106053, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8157.923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 756984925, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7137.798317822221, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 31214, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 331859801, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 30370, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 295543208, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 44399, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 128777322, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 804594, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 286889, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 22068.384615384617, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2917420037, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10169.159629682561, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 400061, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 30773.923076923078, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1472765891, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3681.3533211185295, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5669531115, "stage_ordering_ns": 1260487057, "stage_eval_ns": 3465215735, "stage_threat_ns": 8304364706, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 923146, "root_tactical_annotations": 2797, "search_tactical_annotations": 920349, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 254651, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1516315857, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 769006, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6536629052, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 79087, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2918846743, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 127319, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 190457705, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 254638, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32170821, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 228580, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1134367675, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 461328, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2483288532, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 233238, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28791271, "child_limit_applications": 39500, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39500, "child_cap_hits": 39500, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39500, "child_moves_before_total": 3028650, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3028650, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 535047, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 535047, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.6746835443038, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.545493670886076, "tt_hits": 20438, "tt_cutoffs": 4009, "beta_cutoffs": 32484, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 4.461538461538462, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 4.461538461538462, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1616.3846153846155, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2175.4615384615386, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 634, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 63156, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 123, 81, 97, 85, 71, 83, 80, 65, 128, 84, 82, 96, 139, 153, 124, 154, 79, 94, 155, 168, 182, 107, 137, 151, 152, 122, 138, 166, 136, 135, 157, 173, 171, 187, 185, 86, 87, 143, 55, 39, 183, 54, 69, 184, 70, 68, 72, 73, 103, 119, 167, 197, 199, 213, 63, 47, 102, 53, 98, 67, 25, 51, 35, 115 ], "move_count": 78, "black_stats": { "move_count": 39, "search_move_count": 37, "total_time_ms": 61361, "avg_search_time_ms": 1658.4054054054054, "search_nodes": 835721, "safety_nodes": 1022, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 836743, "avg_nodes": 22614.675675675677, "eval_calls": 529066, "avg_eval_calls": 14299.081081081082, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 529066, "pattern_eval_ns": 10702316, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.228697364790026, "pattern_frame_queries": 529066, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 10702316, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.228697364790026, "pattern_frame_updates": 1670990, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 14271792170, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8540.920155117625, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 285915, "avg_candidate_generations": 7727.4324324324325, "candidate_moves_total": 29754301, "avg_candidate_moves": 104.06694647010475, "candidate_moves_max": 136, "root_candidate_generations": 37, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3414, "root_candidate_moves_max": 119, "search_candidate_generations": 285878, "search_candidate_moves_total": 29750887, "search_candidate_moves_max": 136, "legality_checks": 6798972, "avg_legality_checks": 183756.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9053, "root_legality_checks": 3414, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 6795558, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9048, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21235926, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 573943.9459459459, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 33780609072, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1590.7292703883033, "renju_forbidden_checks": 110644, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2990.3783783783783, "renju_forbidden_ns": 244214062, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2207.205650554933, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10051, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18831832, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 49490, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 159686130, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 51078, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 65682940, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13160, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 614391, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16605.162162162163, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3383994433, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5507.884121023908, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 746032, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20163.027027027027, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1200648492, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1609.3793456580952, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11712106708, "stage_ordering_ns": 7546331583, "stage_eval_ns": 14282494486, "stage_threat_ns": 27485153613, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 9921353, "root_tactical_annotations": 16979, "search_tactical_annotations": 9904374, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1671027, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 7332808840, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 7730598, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 18602390019, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 572056, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12067389531, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 835495, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1047612332, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1670990, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 167501409, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 4473318, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1375336004, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 2685195, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 5159337233, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 2762840, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 334841013, "child_limit_applications": 285878, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 285878, "child_cap_hits": 285878, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 285878, "child_moves_before_total": 29741839, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 29741839, "child_moves_before_max": 136, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 136, "child_moves_after_total": 3911796, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 3911796, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 104.0368234001917, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.68344538579394, "tt_hits": 179061, "tt_cutoffs": 20553, "beta_cutoffs": 239178, "depth_sum": 222, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 222, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 24 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.10810810810810811, "pooled_budget_moves": 37, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.43243243243243246, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.10810810810810811, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3400.675675675676, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3616.891891891892, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 39, "search_move_count": 37, "total_time_ms": 1755, "avg_search_time_ms": 47.432432432432435, "search_nodes": 135266, "safety_nodes": 5291, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 140557, "avg_nodes": 3798.837837837838, "eval_calls": 129221, "avg_eval_calls": 3492.4594594594596, "line_shape_eval_calls": 129221, "line_shape_eval_ns": 272247315, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 2106.8349184730037, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5973, "avg_candidate_generations": 161.43243243243242, "candidate_moves_total": 577855, "avg_candidate_moves": 96.74451699313578, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 37, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3445, "root_candidate_moves_max": 119, "search_candidate_generations": 5936, "search_candidate_moves_total": 574410, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 12436, "avg_legality_checks": 336.1081081081081, "illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 12436, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 51873, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1401.972972972973, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 91809684, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1769.8934705916372, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2432432432432432, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37460, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 814.3478260869565, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18410, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 19050, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 30945552, "stage_ordering_ns": 176961, "stage_eval_ns": 272247315, "stage_threat_ns": 1405503500, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 270351, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1224693895, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 95, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 763552, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 73, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 32860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 135157, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 152458624, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 270314, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27587429, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 141, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5631, "depth_sum": 109, "avg_depth": 2.945945945945946, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 109, "avg_effective_depth": 2.945945945945946, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 36 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 37, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7443.081081081081, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7659.2972972972975, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 635, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 41795, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 67, 98, 126, 81, 127, 83, 84, 128, 141, 156, 113, 99, 114, 155, 79, 95, 157, 142, 125, 100, 101, 109, 123, 124, 143, 108, 129, 115, 189, 173, 140, 139, 154, 171, 159, 175, 172, 85, 130, 92, 144, 174, 158, 186, 116 ], "move_count": 50, "black_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 9878, "avg_search_time_ms": 429.4782608695652, "search_nodes": 668926, "safety_nodes": 1264, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 670190, "avg_nodes": 29138.695652173912, "eval_calls": 655064, "avg_eval_calls": 28481.043478260868, "line_shape_eval_calls": 655064, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1185384187, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1809.570037431457, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13817, "avg_candidate_generations": 600.7391304347826, "candidate_moves_total": 1189837, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.11399001230369, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1718, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 13794, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1188119, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 635308, "avg_legality_checks": 27622.08695652174, "illegal_moves_skipped": 224, "root_legality_checks": 1718, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 633590, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 661120, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 28744.347826086956, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1368775538, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2070.3889430058084, "renju_forbidden_checks": 244, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.608695652173912, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1825157, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7480.151639344263, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 236, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1734717, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 90440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.0869565217391304, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 224171, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8966.84, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.3478260869565217, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 93080, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3002.5806451612902, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1361062136, "stage_ordering_ns": 470034, "stage_eval_ns": 1185384187, "stage_threat_ns": 7261770158, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1337739, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6303836109, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 62, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 425672, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 25060, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 668858, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 812333500, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1337716, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 145174877, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 800, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 12454, "depth_sum": 68, "avg_depth": 2.9565217391304346, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 68, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9565217391304346, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.043478260869565216, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6968.304347826087, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7316.130434782609, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1938, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 31891, "avg_search_time_ms": 1386.5652173913043, "search_nodes": 241149, "safety_nodes": 1459, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 242608, "avg_nodes": 10548.173913043478, "eval_calls": 142563, "avg_eval_calls": 6198.391304347826, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 142563, "pattern_eval_ns": 3134580, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.9873319164159, "pattern_frame_queries": 142563, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3134580, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.9873319164159, "pattern_frame_updates": 482006, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4991715489, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10356.12728679726, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 90619, "avg_candidate_generations": 3939.9565217391305, "candidate_moves_total": 8026956, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.57917213829329, "candidate_moves_max": 132, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1747, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 90596, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8025209, "search_candidate_moves_max": 132, "legality_checks": 5190353, "avg_legality_checks": 225667.52173913043, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8462, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5190353, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8462, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10777159, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 468572.1304347826, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20908884673, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1940.1109952075496, "renju_forbidden_checks": 102641, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4462.652173913043, "renju_forbidden_ns": 319454185, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3112.3448232187916, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12746, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 85074066, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22630, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 123671149, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 67250, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 110538899, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 170071, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 342748, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14902.08695652174, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2856833625, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8335.084741559396, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 474860, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20646.08695652174, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1290951304, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2718.5934886071686, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11402941241, "stage_ordering_ns": 2889954976, "stage_eval_ns": 4994850069, "stage_threat_ns": 12397265174, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2060318, "root_tactical_annotations": 5954, "search_tactical_annotations": 2054364, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 482029, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2692879693, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1627278, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9222283907, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 181383, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5204121106, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 241003, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 355876984, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 482006, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58415055, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 627031, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1445550081, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 818843, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2572253647, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 614444, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 67809535, "child_limit_applications": 90596, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 90596, "child_cap_hits": 90596, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 90596, "child_moves_before_total": 8016747, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8016747, "child_moves_before_max": 132, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 132, "child_moves_after_total": 891439, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 891439, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.48897302309153, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.839716985297365, "tt_hits": 50343, "tt_cutoffs": 7844, "beta_cutoffs": 73038, "depth_sum": 145, "avg_depth": 6.304347826086956, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 145, "avg_effective_depth": 6.304347826086956, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.043478260869565216, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2608695652173913, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.043478260869565216, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5116.695652173913, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5464.521739130435, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 566, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 636, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7591, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 95, 79, 80, 65, 113, 51, 93, 52, 67, 49, 33, 50, 48, 53 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7072, "avg_search_time_ms": 785.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 76999, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 77157, "avg_nodes": 8573.0, "eval_calls": 47156, "avg_eval_calls": 5239.555555555556, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47156, "pattern_eval_ns": 1009538, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.408474001187546, "pattern_frame_queries": 47156, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1009538, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.408474001187546, "pattern_frame_updates": 153912, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1616558085, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10503.132211913302, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28085, "avg_candidate_generations": 3120.5555555555557, "candidate_moves_total": 1940421, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.09100943564181, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 28076, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1939921, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 553444, "avg_legality_checks": 61493.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 248, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 552944, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 247, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2002366, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 222485.11111111112, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4172081611, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2083.5759351686957, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23245, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2582.777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 74468292, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3203.6262422026243, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1355, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3999265, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11087, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 47825228, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10798, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22587788, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 56011, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36563, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4062.5555555555557, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 277367661, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7586.020321089626, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 47326, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5258.444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 112058789, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2367.806047415797, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1287026577, "stage_ordering_ns": 738212548, "stage_eval_ns": 1617567623, "stage_threat_ns": 3395442329, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 384498, "root_tactical_annotations": 1800, "search_tactical_annotations": 382698, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 153921, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 864778189, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 287128, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2387188917, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56212, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1922652149, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76956, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108671217, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 153912, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18406390, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 89726, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 56949524, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 141182, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 407439994, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 153590, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16397616, "child_limit_applications": 28076, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28076, "child_cap_hits": 28076, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28076, "child_moves_before_total": 1939674, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1939674, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 245658, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 245658, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.08655079071093, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.749750676734578, "tt_hits": 17016, "tt_cutoffs": 1724, "beta_cutoffs": 22214, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3687.8888888888887, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4576.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1069, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 510, "avg_search_time_ms": 63.75, "search_nodes": 39914, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40510, "avg_nodes": 5063.75, "eval_calls": 38581, "avg_eval_calls": 4822.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 38581, "line_shape_eval_ns": 28781644, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 746.0056504497032, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1318, "avg_candidate_generations": 164.75, "candidate_moves_total": 83765, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.5546282245827, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1310, "search_candidate_moves_total": 83318, "search_candidate_moves_max": 88, "legality_checks": 2373, "avg_legality_checks": 296.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2373, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11398, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1424.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24300322, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2131.9812247762766, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 85030, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7085.833333333333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22260, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 62770, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6586974, "stage_ordering_ns": 42190, "stage_eval_ns": 28781644, "stage_threat_ns": 465115520, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 79790, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 408914570, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 156101, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 39891, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 47151014, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 79782, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8893835, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1199, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5399.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6399.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 637, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 37693, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 110, 127, 99, 96, 114, 126, 141, 129, 100, 101, 128, 142, 143, 86, 66, 82, 116, 115, 157, 125, 158, 173, 130, 87, 73, 102, 156, 159, 186, 187, 144, 172, 154, 155, 201, 145, 171 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 6146, "avg_search_time_ms": 323.4736842105263, "search_nodes": 375579, "safety_nodes": 1101, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 376680, "avg_nodes": 19825.263157894737, "eval_calls": 365405, "avg_eval_calls": 19231.842105263157, "line_shape_eval_calls": 365405, "line_shape_eval_ns": 599647123, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1641.0479413253786, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10137, "avg_candidate_generations": 533.5263157894736, "candidate_moves_total": 817222, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.61773700305811, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1330, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 10118, "search_candidate_moves_total": 815892, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 344133, "avg_legality_checks": 18112.263157894737, "illegal_moves_skipped": 107, "root_legality_checks": 1330, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 342803, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 104, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 365573, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19240.684210526317, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 875437281, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2394.698954791519, "renju_forbidden_checks": 228, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1683767, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7384.94298245614, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 208, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1540056, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 143711, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.1052631578947367, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 408512, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10212.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 57, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 201241, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3530.5438596491226, "stage_move_gen_ns": 856799186, "stage_ordering_ns": 349840, "stage_eval_ns": 599647123, "stage_threat_ns": 4654171935, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 751065, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4057454420, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 54, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 611243, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 21830, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 375523, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 504584992, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 751046, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 91521280, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 582, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9141, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6804.473684210527, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7225.526315789473, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1914, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 31530, "avg_search_time_ms": 1659.4736842105262, "search_nodes": 227103, "safety_nodes": 1126, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 228229, "avg_nodes": 12012.052631578947, "eval_calls": 136632, "avg_eval_calls": 7191.1578947368425, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 136632, "pattern_eval_ns": 3053822, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.350708472393, "pattern_frame_queries": 136632, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3053822, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.350708472393, "pattern_frame_updates": 453980, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5040169380, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11102.18375258822, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 83722, "avg_candidate_generations": 4406.421052631579, "candidate_moves_total": 7089481, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.67882993717302, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1352, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 83703, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7088129, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 4813749, "avg_legality_checks": 253355.2105263158, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4871, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4813749, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4871, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10088697, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 530984.052631579, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20823198899, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2064.012716310144, "renju_forbidden_checks": 92662, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4876.9473684210525, "renju_forbidden_ns": 255246279, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2754.594968811379, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6556, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53476548, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15452, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 94099303, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 70629, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 107395616, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 274812, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 295443, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15549.631578947368, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2862991824, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9690.50484865101, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 431089, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22688.894736842107, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1393819813, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3233.2530243174842, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11115833633, "stage_ordering_ns": 2765961367, "stage_eval_ns": 5043223202, "stage_threat_ns": 12418151795, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1893843, "root_tactical_annotations": 4882, "search_tactical_annotations": 1888961, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 453999, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2637616558, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1534204, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9309674739, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 167556, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5277015504, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 226990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 343494746, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 453980, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57632750, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 573341, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1447365852, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 793290, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2584991172, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 527212, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 69733002, "child_limit_applications": 83703, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 83703, "child_cap_hits": 83703, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 83703, "child_moves_before_total": 7083258, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7083258, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 831015, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 831015, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.62370524353966, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.928138776387943, "tt_hits": 43904, "tt_cutoffs": 6658, "beta_cutoffs": 68392, "depth_sum": 110, "avg_depth": 5.7894736842105265, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 110, "avg_effective_depth": 5.7894736842105265, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.15789473684210525, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3684210526315789, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.15789473684210525, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2342.9473684210525, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2688.9473684210525, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 638, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8467, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 82, 66, 81, 80, 128, 94, 52, 109, 110, 64, 48, 79, 49, 124 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7941, "avg_search_time_ms": 882.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 76687, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76845, "avg_nodes": 8538.333333333334, "eval_calls": 46888, "avg_eval_calls": 5209.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46888, "pattern_eval_ns": 1019940, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.75268725473469, "pattern_frame_queries": 46888, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1019940, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.75268725473469, "pattern_frame_updates": 153288, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1811126437, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11815.187340170138, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27943, "avg_candidate_generations": 3104.777777777778, "candidate_moves_total": 1970667, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.5245320831693, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 27934, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1970167, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 573354, "avg_legality_checks": 63706.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 242, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 572854, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 241, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2045603, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 227289.22222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4740351457, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2317.3369695879405, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21422, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2380.222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 86230598, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4025.329007562319, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 933, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4311112, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10543, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 55860308, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9941, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25999318, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 59860, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37756, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4195.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 328745916, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8707.11717342939, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 48488, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5387.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 126554301, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2610.012807292526, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1467335990, "stage_ordering_ns": 816775025, "stage_eval_ns": 1812146377, "stage_threat_ns": 3814184817, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 394391, "root_tactical_annotations": 1800, "search_tactical_annotations": 392591, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 153297, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 951979888, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 291892, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2704306722, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 55928, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2159411504, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76644, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118584150, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 153288, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19902771, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 88769, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 72106350, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 147187, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 472644257, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 158435, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19411286, "child_limit_applications": 27934, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27934, "child_cap_hits": 27934, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27934, "child_moves_before_total": 1969926, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1969926, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 246742, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 246742, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.52072742893964, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.833035011097587, "tt_hits": 16987, "tt_cutoffs": 1822, "beta_cutoffs": 22109, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3381.8888888888887, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4270.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 518, "avg_search_time_ms": 64.75, "search_nodes": 35108, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35704, "avg_nodes": 4463.0, "eval_calls": 33899, "avg_eval_calls": 4237.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 33899, "line_shape_eval_ns": 30269550, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 892.9334198648928, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1194, "avg_candidate_generations": 149.25, "candidate_moves_total": 76195, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.814907872696814, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1186, "search_candidate_moves_total": 75748, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 2613, "avg_legality_checks": 326.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2613, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11724, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1465.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26512962, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2261.426305015353, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 80550, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7322.727272727273, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11620, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 68930, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7764973, "stage_ordering_ns": 39531, "stage_eval_ns": 30269550, "stage_threat_ns": 469395649, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 70178, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 413774230, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 175151, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8951, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35085, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 46650654, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 70170, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8795614, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1085, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5413.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6413.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 639, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 62001, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 82, 113, 141, 96, 142, 98, 99, 143, 156, 171, 128, 114, 129, 170, 94, 110, 172, 157, 115, 83, 140, 68, 53, 124, 186, 185, 199, 138, 152, 139, 158, 200, 130, 144, 190, 174, 131, 132, 188, 204, 189, 187, 145, 203, 155, 202, 201, 100, 117, 84, 116, 52, 36, 56, 70, 205, 206, 159, 146, 191, 175, 160, 161, 176, 101 ], "move_count": 70, "black_stats": { "move_count": 35, "search_move_count": 33, "total_time_ms": 13532, "avg_search_time_ms": 410.06060606060606, "search_nodes": 960895, "safety_nodes": 3685, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 964580, "avg_nodes": 29229.696969696968, "eval_calls": 941412, "avg_eval_calls": 28527.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 941412, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1653749012, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1756.6687189030945, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19418, "avg_candidate_generations": 588.4242424242424, "candidate_moves_total": 1775416, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.43145535070553, "candidate_moves_max": 136, "root_candidate_generations": 33, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2935, "root_candidate_moves_max": 122, "search_candidate_generations": 19385, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1772481, "search_candidate_moves_max": 136, "legality_checks": 917538, "avg_legality_checks": 27804.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 183, "root_legality_checks": 2935, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 914603, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 180, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 953276, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 28887.151515151516, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1868326971, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1959.901404210323, "renju_forbidden_checks": 201, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6.090909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1998289, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9941.73631840796, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 183, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1892299, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 105990, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 77, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.3333333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 552212, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7171.584415584415, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 105, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.1818181818181817, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 270661, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2577.7238095238095, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1866602626, "stage_ordering_ns": 609531, "stage_eval_ns": 1653749012, "stage_threat_ns": 9872316353, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1921627, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 8575414508, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 91, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 980534, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 66, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 30660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 960797, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1095125893, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1921594, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 200795418, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 714, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 17889, "depth_sum": 97, "avg_depth": 2.9393939393939394, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 97, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9393939393939394, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 31 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.030303030303030304, "pooled_budget_moves": 33, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.030303030303030304, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.030303030303030304, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7196.060606060606, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7438.484848484848, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1937, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 35, "search_move_count": 33, "total_time_ms": 48437, "avg_search_time_ms": 1467.7878787878788, "search_nodes": 364780, "safety_nodes": 1548, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 366328, "avg_nodes": 11100.848484848484, "eval_calls": 212214, "avg_eval_calls": 6430.727272727273, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 212214, "pattern_eval_ns": 4588031, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.61983186783153, "pattern_frame_queries": 212214, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4588031, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.61983186783153, "pattern_frame_updates": 729144, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6399792854, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8777.13161460562, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 142434, "avg_candidate_generations": 4316.181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 13981820, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.16350028785261, "candidate_moves_max": 136, "root_candidate_generations": 33, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2960, "root_candidate_moves_max": 121, "search_candidate_generations": 142401, "search_candidate_moves_total": 13978860, "search_candidate_moves_max": 136, "legality_checks": 10568723, "avg_legality_checks": 320264.3333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5001, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10568723, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5001, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18070625, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 547594.696969697, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 32665981698, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1807.6841115346037, "renju_forbidden_checks": 74823, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2267.3636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 177062252, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2366.414765513278, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5283, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 45712598, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10885, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72908339, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 58632, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 58256044, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 185271, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 410757, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12447.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3413726423, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8310.81740055556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 591814, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17933.757575757576, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1629077433, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2752.6848519974183, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20822406489, "stage_ordering_ns": 4377994429, "stage_eval_ns": 6404380885, "stage_threat_ns": 16416442197, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 3934323, "root_tactical_annotations": 10413, "search_tactical_annotations": 3923910, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 729177, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3651087772, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2950975, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 12017951313, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 285075, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6862125903, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 364572, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 503765561, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 729144, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 81627085, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1416472, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1283216114, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1249406, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3872424666, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1268445, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 162010466, "child_limit_applications": 142401, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 142401, "child_cap_hits": 142401, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 142401, "child_moves_before_total": 13973859, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 13973859, "child_moves_before_max": 136, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 136, "child_moves_after_total": 1322420, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1322420, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 98.13034318579223, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.286592088538704, "tt_hits": 86898, "tt_cutoffs": 9959, "beta_cutoffs": 119146, "depth_sum": 204, "avg_depth": 6.181818181818182, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 204, "avg_effective_depth": 6.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 24 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.12121212121212122, "pooled_budget_moves": 33, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.12121212121212122, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4731.30303030303, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4973.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 640, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8602, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 110, 94, 95, 80, 128, 66, 108, 67, 82, 64, 48, 65, 63, 68 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7993, "avg_search_time_ms": 888.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 76796, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76954, "avg_nodes": 8550.444444444445, "eval_calls": 47047, "avg_eval_calls": 5227.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47047, "pattern_eval_ns": 1026494, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.818479392947477, "pattern_frame_queries": 47047, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1026494, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.818479392947477, "pattern_frame_updates": 153506, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1855851574, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12089.765702969265, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28039, "avg_candidate_generations": 3115.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 1960845, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.93277221013588, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 28030, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1960345, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 561597, "avg_legality_checks": 62399.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 248, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 561097, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 247, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2051896, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 227988.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4753598241, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2316.685758439999, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23436, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2604.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 92579484, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3950.3108038914493, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1355, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5571991, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11163, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 58329017, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10913, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28617416, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61060, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36747, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4083.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 322183076, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8767.60214439274, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 47409, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5267.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 124732091, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2630.9791600750914, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1439419958, "stage_ordering_ns": 838229111, "stage_eval_ns": 1856878068, "stage_threat_ns": 3828918974, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 384335, "root_tactical_annotations": 1800, "search_tactical_annotations": 382535, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 153515, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 951781653, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 287100, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2718413713, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56120, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2188199992, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76753, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 120218609, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 153506, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20090745, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 89857, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 67283744, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 141115, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 462778067, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 153363, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18414254, "child_limit_applications": 28030, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28030, "child_cap_hits": 28030, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28030, "child_moves_before_total": 1960098, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1960098, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 245279, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 245279, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.92857652515163, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.750588655012487, "tt_hits": 16938, "tt_cutoffs": 1676, "beta_cutoffs": 22182, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3340.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4229.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 927, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 601, "avg_search_time_ms": 75.125, "search_nodes": 40224, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40820, "avg_nodes": 5102.5, "eval_calls": 38891, "avg_eval_calls": 4861.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 38891, "line_shape_eval_ns": 34643953, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 890.7961482090972, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1318, "avg_candidate_generations": 164.75, "candidate_moves_total": 84143, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.84142640364188, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1310, "search_candidate_moves_total": 83696, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 2373, "avg_legality_checks": 296.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2373, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11484, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1435.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26134037, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2275.6911354928598, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 93570, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7797.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24320, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 69250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7277066, "stage_ordering_ns": 42690, "stage_eval_ns": 34643953, "stage_threat_ns": 548114458, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 80410, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 483012891, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 182900, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40201, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 54599929, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 80402, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10318738, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1199, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5396.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6396.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 641, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9396, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 96, 128, 83, 129, 67, 52, 126, 131, 130, 143, 158, 159, 175, 95, 174, 111 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 338, "avg_search_time_ms": 37.55555555555556, "search_nodes": 19544, "safety_nodes": 562, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 20106, "avg_nodes": 2234.0, "eval_calls": 18513, "avg_eval_calls": 2057.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 18513, "line_shape_eval_ns": 16472719, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 889.7919840112354, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1014, "avg_candidate_generations": 112.66666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 62678, "avg_candidate_moves": 61.81262327416174, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 513, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 1005, "search_candidate_moves_total": 62165, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 14200, "avg_legality_checks": 1577.7777777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "root_legality_checks": 513, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 13687, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 37, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24634, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2737.1111111111113, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 58252796, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2364.731509296095, "renju_forbidden_checks": 89, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9.88888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1081164, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12147.91011235955, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 47, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 578063, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 503101, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 653514, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12102.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 78, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.666666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 353273, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4529.141025641025, "stage_move_gen_ns": 37453995, "stage_ordering_ns": 34470, "stage_eval_ns": 16472719, "stage_threat_ns": 271137202, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 39045, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 239066380, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 832514, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 19518, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 26332568, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 39036, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4905740, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 85, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 867, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5713.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6602.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1940, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9051, "avg_search_time_ms": 1005.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 196683, "safety_nodes": 206, "corridor_nodes": 2512, "corridor_branch_probes": 2874, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1093, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 2489, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2489, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 40, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 17, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1093, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 40, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 284, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 199280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 199401, "avg_nodes": 22155.666666666668, "eval_calls": 191963, "avg_eval_calls": 21329.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 191963, "pattern_eval_ns": 4106904, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.394247849846064, "pattern_frame_queries": 191963, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4106904, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.394247849846064, "pattern_frame_updates": 393316, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6049030705, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15379.569366616155, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4704, "avg_candidate_generations": 522.6666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 333722, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.94430272108843, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 535, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 4695, "search_candidate_moves_total": 333187, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 7574, "avg_legality_checks": 841.5555555555555, "illegal_moves_skipped": 111, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7574, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1589903, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 176655.88888888888, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3945081998, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2481.3350235832, "renju_forbidden_checks": 71021, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7891.222222222223, "renju_forbidden_ns": 763587605, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10751.574956702947, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 111, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1248774, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 70615, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 758834300, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 206, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2420076, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 89, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1084455, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22258625, "stage_ordering_ns": 161432, "stage_eval_ns": 6053137609, "stage_threat_ns": 2901556874, "stage_proof_ns": 50148204, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 398383, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2351151563, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 149472, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 192381573, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1184, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 64989694, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 199187, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 281948187, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5058, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26267442, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 398374, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49808109, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 331, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4104, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4476.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5365.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 642, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3255, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 80, 128, 83, 143, 158, 84, 111, 125, 126, 99, 81, 79, 96, 141, 66 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2541, "avg_search_time_ms": 282.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 45594, "safety_nodes": 600, "corridor_nodes": 1507, "corridor_branch_probes": 1671, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 625, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1489, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1489, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 625, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 62, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 466, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 153120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 47701, "avg_nodes": 5300.111111111111, "eval_calls": 43344, "avg_eval_calls": 4816.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 43344, "pattern_eval_ns": 930641, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.471045588778146, "pattern_frame_queries": 43344, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 930641, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.471045588778146, "pattern_frame_updates": 91138, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1178399535, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12929.83755403893, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2234, "avg_candidate_generations": 248.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 150371, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.31020590868397, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 498, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 2225, "search_candidate_moves_total": 149873, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 40805, "avg_legality_checks": 4533.888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 28, "root_legality_checks": 498, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 40307, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 599317, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 66590.77777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1362676751, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2273.716165234759, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6011, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 667.8888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 28483180, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4738.509399434371, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 79091, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5753, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26226711, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 82, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1094334, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 148, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1083044, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3188, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 354.22222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 32791324, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10285.860727728983, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4281, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 475.6666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 17375152, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4058.6666666666665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 100837998, "stage_ordering_ns": 77250, "stage_eval_ns": 1179330176, "stage_threat_ns": 946933790, "stage_proof_ns": 293365192, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 94253, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 565714256, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 91758, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 285782847, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 938, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 61845583, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47122, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 65381741, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3106, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18515860, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 94244, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11539086, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 163, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1964, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5555.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6444.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1831, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 708, "avg_search_time_ms": 88.5, "search_nodes": 49294, "safety_nodes": 527, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49821, "avg_nodes": 6227.625, "eval_calls": 47320, "avg_eval_calls": 5915.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 47320, "line_shape_eval_ns": 48128721, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1017.0904691462384, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1959, "avg_candidate_generations": 244.875, "candidate_moves_total": 138502, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.7003573251659, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 446, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 1951, "search_candidate_moves_total": 138056, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 4209, "avg_legality_checks": 526.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4209, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13381, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1672.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31108967, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2324.8611464016144, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 69971, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11661.833333333334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23330, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 46641, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12422849, "stage_ordering_ns": 64860, "stage_eval_ns": 48128721, "stage_threat_ns": 635090680, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 98550, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 557805072, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 162971, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 49271, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 65044498, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 98542, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12078139, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 126, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1740, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5420.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6420.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 643, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11490, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 97, 129, 126, 144, 110, 109, 99, 174, 159, 100, 142, 72, 86, 94, 96, 81, 83, 130, 131, 115, 69, 55, 125 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3048, "avg_search_time_ms": 234.46153846153845, "search_nodes": 185903, "safety_nodes": 946, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 186849, "avg_nodes": 14373.0, "eval_calls": 181217, "avg_eval_calls": 13939.76923076923, "line_shape_eval_calls": 181217, "line_shape_eval_ns": 247963871, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1368.3256592924504, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4662, "avg_candidate_generations": 358.61538461538464, "candidate_moves_total": 392131, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.11218361218361, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 900, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 4649, "search_candidate_moves_total": 391231, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 173933, "avg_legality_checks": 13379.461538461539, "illegal_moves_skipped": 273, "root_legality_checks": 900, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 173033, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 271, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 189185, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14552.692307692309, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 455180928, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2406.0096096413563, "renju_forbidden_checks": 418, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 32.15384615384615, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4846842, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11595.315789473685, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 388, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4555652, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 291190, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 69, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.3076923076923075, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 803183, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11640.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.6923076923076925, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 401332, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4013.32, "stage_move_gen_ns": 439778558, "stage_ordering_ns": 158220, "stage_eval_ns": 247963871, "stage_threat_ns": 2332399050, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 371745, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2039084207, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 998384, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13580, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185866, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 247325881, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 371732, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44990578, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 276, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4218, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6319.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6935.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1926, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8432, "avg_search_time_ms": 702.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 186424, "safety_nodes": 1053, "corridor_nodes": 4247, "corridor_branch_probes": 4911, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 15, "corridor_depth_exits": 1979, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 17, "corridor_plies_followed": 4214, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4199, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 15, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 80, "corridor_proof_active": 33, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 27, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1979, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 80, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 3, "corridor_proof_unknown": 76, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 500, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 154400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 191724, "avg_nodes": 15977.0, "eval_calls": 181418, "avg_eval_calls": 15118.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 181418, "pattern_eval_ns": 3849385, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.21831902016338, "pattern_frame_queries": 181418, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3849385, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.21831902016338, "pattern_frame_updates": 372778, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5351446888, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14355.58667088723, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4983, "avg_candidate_generations": 415.25, "candidate_moves_total": 361132, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.47280754565523, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 818, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4971, "search_candidate_moves_total": 360314, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 7753, "avg_legality_checks": 646.0833333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 74, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7753, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 74, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1453728, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 121144.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3631992040, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2498.398627528671, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46060, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3838.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 496453696, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10778.412852800695, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 83, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 951813, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 45464, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 490112520, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 299, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3332738, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 214, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2056625, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 192, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1975669, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10289.942708333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 259, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21.583333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 864364, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3337.3127413127413, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23680115, "stage_ordering_ns": 166411, "stage_eval_ns": 5355296273, "stage_threat_ns": 2928095910, "stage_proof_ns": 103168161, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 381378, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2282220363, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 228625, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 273426474, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1899, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 86993191, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 190683, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 271971638, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8588, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 52472903, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 381366, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48004532, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 238, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4300, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5424.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6090.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 644, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6175, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 81, 129, 126, 130, 131, 141, 98, 84, 99, 100, 96, 66, 109, 110, 95, 97, 67, 53, 123 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5330, "avg_search_time_ms": 484.54545454545456, "search_nodes": 104831, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 1545, "corridor_branch_probes": 1727, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 643, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 1525, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1525, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 643, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 62, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 468, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 157680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 107292, "avg_nodes": 9753.818181818182, "eval_calls": 101588, "avg_eval_calls": 9235.272727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 101588, "pattern_eval_ns": 2190256, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.560184273733118, "pattern_frame_queries": 101588, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2190256, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.560184273733118, "pattern_frame_updates": 209600, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2945385095, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14052.409804389314, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3223, "avg_candidate_generations": 293.0, "candidate_moves_total": 218067, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.65963388147688, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 664, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 3212, "search_candidate_moves_total": 217403, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 98798, "avg_legality_checks": 8981.636363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "root_legality_checks": 664, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 98134, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1105988, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 100544.36363636363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2687370204, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2429.8366745389644, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11514, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1046.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 68252236, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5927.760639221817, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 581571, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11207, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 65588281, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 75, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1037863, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 172, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1044521, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3244, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 294.90909090909093, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 34044297, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10494.542848335388, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4367, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 397.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 17793012, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4074.424547744447, "stage_move_gen_ns": 257195800, "stage_ordering_ns": 115920, "stage_eval_ns": 2947575351, "stage_threat_ns": 1804061984, "stage_proof_ns": 300559635, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 212793, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1294442455, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 93597, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 310244254, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 960, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 66668307, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 106391, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 153213627, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3182, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18889945, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 212782, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27271703, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 177, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2892, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5694.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6421.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1834, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 835, "avg_search_time_ms": 83.5, "search_nodes": 56028, "safety_nodes": 690, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 56718, "avg_nodes": 5671.8, "eval_calls": 53680, "avg_eval_calls": 5368.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 53680, "line_shape_eval_ns": 52270246, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 973.7378166915053, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2329, "avg_candidate_generations": 232.9, "candidate_moves_total": 163032, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.00085873765565, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 609, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 2319, "search_candidate_moves_total": 162423, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 6056, "avg_legality_checks": 605.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6056, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17486, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1748.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 41311501, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2362.547237790232, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18062265, "stage_ordering_ns": 78810, "stage_eval_ns": 52270246, "stage_threat_ns": 753453584, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 112008, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 661731821, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 164201, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 55999, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 77182014, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 111998, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14375548, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 128, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2111, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5890.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6690.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 645, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5819, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 126, 98, 95, 83, 109, 108, 128, 53, 68, 81, 129, 127, 94, 99, 100, 85, 141, 71 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 1418, "avg_search_time_ms": 141.8, "search_nodes": 84736, "safety_nodes": 625, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85361, "avg_nodes": 8536.1, "eval_calls": 82097, "avg_eval_calls": 8209.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 82097, "line_shape_eval_ns": 75029262, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 913.909911446216, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2620, "avg_candidate_generations": 262.0, "candidate_moves_total": 164169, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.65992366412214, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 566, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 2610, "search_candidate_moves_total": 163603, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 79236, "avg_legality_checks": 7923.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 37, "root_legality_checks": 566, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 78670, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 33, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 90695, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9069.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 227139429, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2504.4316555488176, "renju_forbidden_checks": 53, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 664393, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12535.716981132075, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 475661, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 188732, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 530782, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11795.155555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 286071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4401.092307692307, "stage_move_gen_ns": 208849244, "stage_ordering_ns": 89761, "stage_eval_ns": 75029262, "stage_threat_ns": 1121745248, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169424, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 984491472, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 690183, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84707, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 115375667, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169414, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21187926, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 155, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2305, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5755.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6555.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1915, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 4391, "avg_search_time_ms": 439.1, "search_nodes": 108758, "safety_nodes": 620, "corridor_nodes": 2548, "corridor_branch_probes": 2880, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1131, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 2522, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2522, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 62, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 36, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1131, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 62, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 59, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 445, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 192960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 111926, "avg_nodes": 11192.6, "eval_calls": 105199, "avg_eval_calls": 10519.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105199, "pattern_eval_ns": 2230867, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.206161655529044, "pattern_frame_queries": 105199, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2230867, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.206161655529044, "pattern_frame_updates": 217460, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2546776149, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11711.469461050308, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3541, "avg_candidate_generations": 354.1, "candidate_moves_total": 248209, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.09573566789042, "candidate_moves_max": 92, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 590, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 3531, "search_candidate_moves_total": 247619, "search_candidate_moves_max": 92, "legality_checks": 6973, "avg_legality_checks": 697.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6973, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 704318, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 70431.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1737929036, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2467.534602267726, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20869, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2086.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 221810089, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10628.687958215534, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 290861, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20541, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 218213936, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 205, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2144855, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 97, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1160437, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19626408, "stage_ordering_ns": 125820, "stage_eval_ns": 2549007016, "stage_threat_ns": 1717738690, "stage_proof_ns": 87602830, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 222638, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1308963805, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 147981, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 195114454, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1322, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 75509580, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111314, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156974159, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5168, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 29666706, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 222628, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27019566, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 234, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3106, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5769.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6569.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 646, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5217, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 81, 65, 80, 79, 127, 93, 51, 108, 109, 63, 47, 78, 48, 123 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4704, "avg_search_time_ms": 522.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 119750, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 859, "corridor_branch_probes": 963, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 287, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 847, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 847, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 287, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 57, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 442, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 185360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 120767, "avg_nodes": 13418.555555555555, "eval_calls": 115794, "avg_eval_calls": 12866.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 115794, "pattern_eval_ns": 2436472, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.04143565296993, "pattern_frame_queries": 115794, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2436472, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.04143565296993, "pattern_frame_updates": 239450, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2516887363, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10511.118659427855, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3940, "avg_candidate_generations": 437.77777777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 250616, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.60812182741117, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 3931, "search_candidate_moves_total": 250116, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 112564, "avg_legality_checks": 12507.111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 149, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 112064, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 148, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 927771, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 103085.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2040690513, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2199.562729380418, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13955, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1550.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 107692939, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7717.157936223576, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 161, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1329770, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13428, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 104893119, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 78, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 531523, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 288, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 938527, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1666, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 185.11111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 15999957, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9603.815726290517, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2244, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 249.33333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 8152825, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3633.166221033868, "stage_move_gen_ns": 262320121, "stage_ordering_ns": 137600, "stage_eval_ns": 2519323835, "stage_threat_ns": 1676319701, "stage_proof_ns": 222160466, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 241275, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1316559277, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59901, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 165550267, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 706, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 37359330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 120633, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 155801732, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1816, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10049931, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 241266, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28358494, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 387, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3332, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4943.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5832.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1776, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 505, "avg_search_time_ms": 63.125, "search_nodes": 35030, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35626, "avg_nodes": 4453.25, "eval_calls": 33821, "avg_eval_calls": 4227.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 33821, "line_shape_eval_ns": 30143698, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 891.27163596582, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1194, "avg_candidate_generations": 149.25, "candidate_moves_total": 75947, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.607202680067005, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1186, "search_candidate_moves_total": 75500, "search_candidate_moves_max": 88, "legality_checks": 2613, "avg_legality_checks": 326.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2613, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11638, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1454.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24531955, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2107.9184567795155, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 70710, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6428.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10100, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 60610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7321809, "stage_ordering_ns": 38750, "stage_eval_ns": 30143698, "stage_threat_ns": 457102405, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 70022, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 403301859, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 149790, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35007, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 45007257, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 70014, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8643499, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1085, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5418.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6418.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1991, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 647, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17264, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 115, 116, 95, 175, 159, 142, 96, 144, 80, 64, 145, 130, 158, 102, 88, 140, 141, 101, 97, 100, 99, 103, 104, 161, 81, 129, 82, 146, 110, 131 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 3661, "avg_search_time_ms": 215.35294117647058, "search_nodes": 218276, "safety_nodes": 1123, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 219399, "avg_nodes": 12905.823529411764, "eval_calls": 212784, "avg_eval_calls": 12516.70588235294, "line_shape_eval_calls": 212784, "line_shape_eval_ns": 337828712, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1587.6603128054742, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5459, "avg_candidate_generations": 321.11764705882354, "candidate_moves_total": 463353, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.87873236856566, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1319, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 5442, "search_candidate_moves_total": 462034, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 205929, "avg_legality_checks": 12113.470588235294, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1094, "root_legality_checks": 1319, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 204610, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1084, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 225651, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13273.588235294117, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 545202027, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2416.129452118537, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1255, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 73.82352941176471, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13511612, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10766.224701195219, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1203, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12966569, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 545043, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 41, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.411764705882353, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 499753, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12189.09756097561, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 62, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.6470588235294117, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 278743, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4495.854838709677, "stage_move_gen_ns": 531358285, "stage_ordering_ns": 174412, "stage_eval_ns": 337828712, "stage_threat_ns": 2766958554, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 436469, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2419910251, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 699454, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 218226, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 292747382, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 436452, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53601467, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 451, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4751, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6675.235294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7145.823529411765, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1909, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 13585, "avg_search_time_ms": 799.1176470588235, "search_nodes": 411579, "safety_nodes": 1257, "corridor_nodes": 374, "corridor_branch_probes": 416, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 129, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 361, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 361, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 95, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 82, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 129, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 95, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 92, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 703, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 244640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 413210, "avg_nodes": 24306.470588235294, "eval_calls": 403102, "avg_eval_calls": 23711.882352941175, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 403102, "pattern_eval_ns": 8655679, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.472676890712524, "pattern_frame_queries": 403102, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 8655679, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.472676890712524, "pattern_frame_updates": 823060, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7879490326, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9573.409382062062, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8445, "avg_candidate_generations": 496.7647058823529, "candidate_moves_total": 739068, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.51545293072824, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1328, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 8428, "search_candidate_moves_total": 737740, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 18669, "avg_legality_checks": 1098.1764705882354, "illegal_moves_skipped": 33, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 18669, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 33, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1997561, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 117503.58823529411, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4757164133, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2381.4862890294717, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33487, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1969.8235294117646, "renju_forbidden_ns": 316510866, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9451.753396840564, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 365792, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33197, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 313529494, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 49, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 503530, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 203, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2112050, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 51611236, "stage_ordering_ns": 302710, "stage_eval_ns": 7888146005, "stage_threat_ns": 5435455149, "stage_proof_ns": 167961078, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 823989, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4731355328, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24965, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 35612921, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 599, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17415403, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 411986, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 559856970, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 912, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5512386, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 823972, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 103117544, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 465, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7648, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.764705882352941, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.764705882352941, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6019.470588235294, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6490.058823529412, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1967, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 648, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6660, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 95, 143, 96, 115, 116, 97, 81, 158, 173, 126, 67, 53, 80, 129, 79, 63, 82, 78, 83 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5360, "avg_search_time_ms": 487.27272727272725, "search_nodes": 111626, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 1998, "corridor_branch_probes": 2246, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 932, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 1978, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1978, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 73, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 932, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 73, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 73, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 478, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 197120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 114540, "avg_nodes": 10412.727272727272, "eval_calls": 108312, "avg_eval_calls": 9846.545454545454, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 108312, "pattern_eval_ns": 2331100, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.52208434891794, "pattern_frame_queries": 108312, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2331100, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.52208434891794, "pattern_frame_updates": 223188, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2742977889, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12289.988211731814, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3293, "avg_candidate_generations": 299.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 226927, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.91193440631643, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 725, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 3282, "search_candidate_moves_total": 226202, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 105496, "avg_legality_checks": 9590.545454545454, "illegal_moves_skipped": 109, "root_legality_checks": 725, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 104771, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 105, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 999881, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 90898.27272727272, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2417453900, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2417.741611251739, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14534, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1321.2727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 155618359, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10707.194096601073, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 109, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1066575, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13350, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 143835397, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 328, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4240862, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 747, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6475525, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4897, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 445.1818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 52629545, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10747.303451092506, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6785, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 616.8181818181819, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 28381465, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4182.971997052321, "stage_move_gen_ns": 277104942, "stage_ordering_ns": 125340, "stage_eval_ns": 2745308989, "stage_threat_ns": 1975293930, "stage_proof_ns": 341795955, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 227301, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1396471177, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 109359, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 359653277, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1080, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 74344832, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 113645, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 163025666, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4102, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26876638, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 227290, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29267172, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 192, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2947, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5442.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6169.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1750, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1289, "avg_search_time_ms": 117.18181818181819, "search_nodes": 88236, "safety_nodes": 646, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 88882, "avg_nodes": 8080.181818181818, "eval_calls": 85057, "avg_eval_calls": 7732.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 85057, "line_shape_eval_ns": 101030753, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1187.8005690301798, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3159, "avg_candidate_generations": 287.1818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 242688, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.82431149097816, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3148, "search_candidate_moves_total": 241940, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 9495, "avg_legality_checks": 863.1818181818181, "illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9495, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22143, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2013.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 51702470, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2334.9351939664907, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.181818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 563132, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12242.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 277612, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 285520, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 26838353, "stage_ordering_ns": 120700, "stage_eval_ns": 101030753, "stage_threat_ns": 1145624329, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 176421, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1005616634, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 156351, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12670, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 88205, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118018837, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 176410, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21832507, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 335, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2706, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6103.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6830.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 649, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 31223, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 157, 172, 83, 110, 98, 140, 155, 156, 124, 139, 153, 188, 204, 137, 141, 138, 136, 113, 84, 70, 169, 183, 82, 81, 85, 86, 65, 95, 80, 102, 54, 109, 123, 158, 69, 118, 134, 108, 107, 129, 145, 53, 67, 99, 66, 68, 50, 114, 34 ], "move_count": 57, "black_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 9102, "avg_search_time_ms": 337.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 544614, "safety_nodes": 2339, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 546953, "avg_nodes": 20257.51851851852, "eval_calls": 532489, "avg_eval_calls": 19721.814814814814, "line_shape_eval_calls": 532489, "line_shape_eval_ns": 999820117, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1877.6352506812348, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12073, "avg_candidate_generations": 447.14814814814815, "candidate_moves_total": 1186951, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.31450343742235, "candidate_moves_max": 145, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2505, "root_candidate_moves_max": 125, "search_candidate_generations": 12046, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1184446, "search_candidate_moves_max": 145, "legality_checks": 513210, "avg_legality_checks": 19007.777777777777, "illegal_moves_skipped": 208, "root_legality_checks": 2505, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 510705, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 208, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 543227, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20119.51851851852, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1310156749, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2411.803443127827, "renju_forbidden_checks": 216, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2283787, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10573.087962962964, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 216, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2283787, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.8148148148148149, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 559122, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11410.65306122449, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 70, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.5925925925925926, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 289671, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4138.157142857143, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1287258585, "stage_ordering_ns": 413551, "stage_eval_ns": 999820117, "stage_threat_ns": 6771702194, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1089097, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5905997651, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 70, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 867142, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 28180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 544535, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 730175660, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1089070, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 134661741, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 824, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 10857, "depth_sum": 78, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 78, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 25 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.037037037037037035, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.037037037037037035, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.037037037037037035, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6983.37037037037, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7279.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1920, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 28, "search_move_count": 26, "total_time_ms": 22094, "avg_search_time_ms": 849.7692307692307, "search_nodes": 641866, "safety_nodes": 2535, "corridor_nodes": 21185, "corridor_branch_probes": 21968, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 10703, "corridor_neutral_exits": 150, "corridor_terminal_exits": 17, "corridor_plies_followed": 21117, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 21112, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 24, "corridor_proof_completed": 24, "corridor_proof_checks": 209, "corridor_proof_active": 68, "corridor_proof_quiet": 141, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 150, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 10703, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 209, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 208, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1483, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 610800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 15760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 665586, "avg_nodes": 25599.46153846154, "eval_calls": 625960, "avg_eval_calls": 24075.384615384617, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 625960, "pattern_eval_ns": 13212112, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.10695891111253, "pattern_frame_queries": 625960, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 13212112, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.10695891111253, "pattern_frame_updates": 1283578, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 11867338824, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9245.5143544062, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15855, "avg_candidate_generations": 609.8076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 1664854, "avg_candidate_moves": 105.00498265531378, "candidate_moves_max": 146, "root_candidate_generations": 26, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2419, "root_candidate_moves_max": 125, "search_candidate_generations": 15829, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1662435, "search_candidate_moves_max": 146, "legality_checks": 27268, "avg_legality_checks": 1048.7692307692307, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 27268, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3784998, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 145576.84615384616, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8243859585, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2178.0353873370605, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22088, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 849.5384615384615, "renju_forbidden_ns": 191408823, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8665.738093082216, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20495, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 184079715, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1588, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7326038, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3070, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.5384615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 243021, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6075.525, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 48, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.8461538461538463, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 84390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1758.125, "stage_move_gen_ns": 75261030, "stage_ordering_ns": 531061, "stage_eval_ns": 11880550936, "stage_threat_ns": 9981013035, "stage_proof_ns": 277889000, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1326256, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 7459442827, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 934553, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1146688224, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 10967, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 494102994, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 663115, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 894765768, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 42652, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 322449366, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1326230, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 157666850, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 872, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 14041, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 24 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.038461538461538464, "pooled_budget_moves": 26, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.038461538461538464, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6520.961538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6828.653846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 650, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6008, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 83, 125, 98, 123, 124, 113, 96, 99, 95, 94, 110, 141, 85, 155 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5337, "avg_search_time_ms": 593.0, "search_nodes": 124210, "safety_nodes": 701, "corridor_nodes": 1147, "corridor_branch_probes": 1349, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 495, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1133, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1133, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 495, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 337, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 175360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 126058, "avg_nodes": 14006.444444444445, "eval_calls": 121215, "avg_eval_calls": 13468.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 121215, "pattern_eval_ns": 2458568, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.282704285773214, "pattern_frame_queries": 121215, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2458568, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.282704285773214, "pattern_frame_updates": 248370, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2870894015, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11558.9403510891, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2979, "avg_candidate_generations": 331.0, "candidate_moves_total": 180552, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.60825780463243, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 509, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 2970, "search_candidate_moves_total": 180043, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 119953, "avg_legality_checks": 13328.111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "root_legality_checks": 509, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 119444, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 934578, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 103842.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2237662047, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2394.3020775151995, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8739, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 971.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 95328815, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10908.435175649387, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 54, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 512622, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8465, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 92649125, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 86, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1060623, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 134, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1106445, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2722, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 302.44444444444446, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 27575845, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10130.729243203526, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3768, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 418.6666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 14816630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3932.2266454352443, "stage_move_gen_ns": 311295937, "stage_ordering_ns": 96040, "stage_eval_ns": 2873352583, "stage_threat_ns": 1923111274, "stage_proof_ns": 217684819, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 250753, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1493021905, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 67293, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 211288016, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 647, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 44237471, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 125372, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 175115337, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2374, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12358831, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 250744, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31327185, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 114, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2731, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4070.222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4959.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 602, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 661, "avg_search_time_ms": 82.625, "search_nodes": 47005, "safety_nodes": 458, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 47463, "avg_nodes": 5932.875, "eval_calls": 44843, "avg_eval_calls": 5605.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 44843, "line_shape_eval_ns": 39585417, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 882.7557701313472, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2147, "avg_candidate_generations": 268.375, "candidate_moves_total": 143194, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.69492314857942, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 455, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 2139, "search_candidate_moves_total": 142739, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 6234, "avg_legality_checks": 779.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6234, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15383, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1922.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 34762119, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2259.7750113761945, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17233908, "stage_ordering_ns": 77190, "stage_eval_ns": 39585417, "stage_threat_ns": 594859924, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 93972, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 522590226, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 171151, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8250, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 46982, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 60769397, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 93964, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11329150, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 174, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1867, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5404.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6404.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 651, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15469, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 95, 129, 109, 108, 81, 123, 80, 125, 127, 122, 124, 143, 138, 96, 139, 154, 140, 141, 156, 145, 161, 98, 128, 115, 65, 50, 53, 67, 152, 166, 172, 188, 157, 142, 144, 100, 99, 130, 160, 85 ], "move_count": 46, "black_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 5770, "avg_search_time_ms": 274.76190476190476, "search_nodes": 363929, "safety_nodes": 2004, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 365933, "avg_nodes": 17425.380952380954, "eval_calls": 354975, "avg_eval_calls": 16903.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 354975, "line_shape_eval_ns": 600133720, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1690.636580040848, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8913, "avg_candidate_generations": 424.42857142857144, "candidate_moves_total": 785523, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.13227869404241, "candidate_moves_max": 134, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1709, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 8892, "search_candidate_moves_total": 783814, "search_candidate_moves_max": 134, "legality_checks": 349228, "avg_legality_checks": 16629.904761904763, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3704, "root_legality_checks": 1709, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "search_legality_checks": 347519, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3687, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 373268, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17774.666666666668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 825344129, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2211.130150454901, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3903, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 185.85714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 11273986, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2888.5436843453754, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3821, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10964215, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 82, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 309771, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.571428571428571, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 906876, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7751.076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 140, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 362922, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2592.3, "stage_move_gen_ns": 812973171, "stage_ordering_ns": 290962, "stage_eval_ns": 600133720, "stage_threat_ns": 4314231657, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 727755, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3761229033, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 58, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1218446, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 21870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 363867, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 467513143, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 727734, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 84271035, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 520, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8107, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 2.9523809523809526, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9523809523809526, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6939.476190476191, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7320.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1914, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 9677, "avg_search_time_ms": 460.8095238095238, "search_nodes": 309545, "safety_nodes": 1716, "corridor_nodes": 4904, "corridor_branch_probes": 5505, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2084, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 54, "corridor_plies_followed": 4861, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4501, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 360, "corridor_proof_passes": 20, "corridor_proof_completed": 20, "corridor_proof_checks": 80, "corridor_proof_active": 43, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2084, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 54, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 8, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 80, "corridor_proof_wins": 9, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 71, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 8, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 391, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 192720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 14, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 316165, "avg_nodes": 15055.47619047619, "eval_calls": 301749, "avg_eval_calls": 14369.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 301749, "pattern_eval_ns": 6175115, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.46440916125654, "pattern_frame_queries": 301749, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6175115, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.46440916125654, "pattern_frame_updates": 618968, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5258422237, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8495.467030605783, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7756, "avg_candidate_generations": 369.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 777125, "avg_candidate_moves": 100.19662197008768, "candidate_moves_max": 139, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1738, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 7735, "search_candidate_moves_total": 775387, "search_candidate_moves_max": 139, "legality_checks": 15526, "avg_legality_checks": 739.3333333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 119, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 15526, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 119, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1773803, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 84466.80952380953, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3529723599, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1989.9186093382411, "renju_forbidden_checks": 76957, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3664.6190476190477, "renju_forbidden_ns": 183232886, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2380.9775069194484, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 119, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 423112, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 76119, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 178150984, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 317, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2097065, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 402, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2561725, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 713, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 33.95238095238095, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 7329721, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10280.113604488079, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 964, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 45.904761904761905, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4028095, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4178.5217842323655, "stage_move_gen_ns": 39778852, "stage_ordering_ns": 270131, "stage_eval_ns": 5264597352, "stage_threat_ns": 4204487008, "stage_proof_ns": 119426692, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 628871, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3309143592, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 266297, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 349711901, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2699, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 131566177, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 314425, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 410876887, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9882, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 62560548, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 628850, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 72194080, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 562, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6939, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 2.9047619047619047, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9047619047619047, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.047619047619047616, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6945.809523809524, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7326.761904761905, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 652, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14366, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 80, 81, 65, 95, 96, 64, 124, 82, 138, 152, 128, 144, 109, 108, 139, 129, 145, 94, 140, 137, 125, 153, 141, 142, 93, 157, 77 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 13150, "avg_search_time_ms": 876.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 372767, "safety_nodes": 270, "corridor_nodes": 2041, "corridor_branch_probes": 2289, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 825, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 2018, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2018, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 151, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 128, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 825, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 151, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 149, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1237, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 389520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 375078, "avg_nodes": 25005.2, "eval_calls": 363267, "avg_eval_calls": 24217.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 363267, "pattern_eval_ns": 7427263, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.44574101143236, "pattern_frame_queries": 363267, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7427263, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.44574101143236, "pattern_frame_updates": 745448, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7177593835, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9628.564078245565, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9472, "avg_candidate_generations": 631.4666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 780585, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.40973395270271, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1067, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 9457, "search_candidate_moves_total": 779518, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 349525, "avg_legality_checks": 23301.666666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "root_legality_checks": 1067, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 348458, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2783716, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 185581.06666666668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5622808907, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2019.8931597188794, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24836, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1655.7333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 131475076, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5293.729908197777, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 41, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 191122, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24635, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 130662412, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 268962, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 132, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 352580, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3524, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 234.93333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 28942622, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8213.00283768445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4849, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 323.26666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 15142040, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3122.7139616415757, "stage_move_gen_ns": 750696437, "stage_ordering_ns": 349311, "stage_eval_ns": 7185021098, "stage_threat_ns": 4713606455, "stage_proof_ns": 434050358, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 749801, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3823125244, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 125170, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 319445133, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1580, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 72187008, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 374893, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 465642040, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4338, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22589798, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 749786, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 82804240, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 833, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8135, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6007.933333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6541.266666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1767, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 1201, "avg_search_time_ms": 85.78571428571429, "search_nodes": 89885, "safety_nodes": 1317, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91202, "avg_nodes": 6514.428571428572, "eval_calls": 86976, "avg_eval_calls": 6212.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 86976, "line_shape_eval_ns": 101563640, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1167.7202906548932, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2882, "avg_candidate_generations": 205.85714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 225944, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.39833448993754, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1001, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 2868, "search_candidate_moves_total": 224943, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 7285, "avg_legality_checks": 520.3571428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7285, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23490, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1677.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 46249378, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1968.896466581524, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18573728, "stage_ordering_ns": 95251, "stage_eval_ns": 101563640, "stage_threat_ns": 1061845344, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 179702, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 932075160, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 255920, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89844, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 109031226, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 179688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20483038, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 163, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2612, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6487.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7059.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 653, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8322, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 155, 53, 80, 79, 115, 131, 50, 65, 37, 111, 95, 109, 66, 93, 107, 125, 77, 157 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2919, "avg_search_time_ms": 208.5, "search_nodes": 179016, "safety_nodes": 1279, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 180295, "avg_nodes": 12878.214285714286, "eval_calls": 173934, "avg_eval_calls": 12423.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 173934, "line_shape_eval_ns": 208844096, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1200.708866581577, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5055, "avg_candidate_generations": 361.07142857142856, "candidate_moves_total": 415101, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.11691394658753, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1058, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 5041, "search_candidate_moves_total": 414043, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 166550, "avg_legality_checks": 11896.42857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 396, "root_legality_checks": 1058, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 165492, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 396, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 182967, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13069.07142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 427936179, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2338.870829165915, "renju_forbidden_checks": 402, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 28.714285714285715, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4528939, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11266.017412935324, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 402, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4528939, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 552513, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11275.775510204081, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 288982, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4249.735294117647, "stage_move_gen_ns": 409777644, "stage_ordering_ns": 171990, "stage_eval_ns": 208844096, "stage_threat_ns": 2267050137, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 357964, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1985247489, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 798206, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 178975, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 237658756, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 357950, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43345686, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 334, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4529, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6525.214285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7096.642857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1922, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 5388, "avg_search_time_ms": 384.85714285714283, "search_nodes": 168852, "safety_nodes": 1045, "corridor_nodes": 2454, "corridor_branch_probes": 2605, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 872, "corridor_neutral_exits": 50, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 2428, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2428, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 95, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 56, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 872, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 95, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 93, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 708, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 295040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 172351, "avg_nodes": 12310.785714285714, "eval_calls": 163894, "avg_eval_calls": 11706.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 163894, "pattern_eval_ns": 3534529, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.5659450620523, "pattern_frame_queries": 163894, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3534529, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.5659450620523, "pattern_frame_updates": 337624, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2738100516, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8109.910776485084, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4932, "avg_candidate_generations": 352.2857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 444668, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.15977291159773, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1092, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 4918, "search_candidate_moves_total": 443576, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 11266, "avg_legality_checks": 804.7142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11266, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 826967, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 59069.07142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1857791530, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2246.5122913006203, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3391, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 242.21428571428572, "renju_forbidden_ns": 27972481, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8249.035977587731, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3361, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27617878, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 354603, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 28070368, "stage_ordering_ns": 183261, "stage_eval_ns": 2741635045, "stage_threat_ns": 2429517436, "stage_proof_ns": 146754740, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 342684, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1922241585, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 156335, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 205449169, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1799, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 88606397, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 171335, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 229516870, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5046, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 31213676, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 342670, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41096136, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 433, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4314, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6401.928571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6973.357142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 654, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10753, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 84, 99, 85, 83, 98, 70, 66, 114, 50, 34, 126, 140, 67, 52, 65, 141, 155, 68, 80, 35, 81, 49, 95, 110, 53, 109, 39 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 9338, "avg_search_time_ms": 622.5333333333333, "search_nodes": 237571, "safety_nodes": 270, "corridor_nodes": 1798, "corridor_branch_probes": 2021, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 672, "corridor_neutral_exits": 37, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1776, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1776, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 167, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 145, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 37, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 672, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 167, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 165, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1373, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 356160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 239639, "avg_nodes": 15975.933333333332, "eval_calls": 229755, "avg_eval_calls": 15317.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 229755, "pattern_eval_ns": 4935649, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.482226719766707, "pattern_frame_queries": 229755, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4935649, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.482226719766707, "pattern_frame_updates": 475056, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4922430265, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10361.789483766124, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7788, "avg_candidate_generations": 519.2, "candidate_moves_total": 645909, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.9364406779661, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1067, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 7773, "search_candidate_moves_total": 644842, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 213655, "avg_legality_checks": 14243.666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "root_legality_checks": 1067, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 212588, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1883418, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 125561.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4249100245, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2256.0579993394986, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19221, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1281.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 107305040, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5582.6980906300405, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 234401, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19062, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 106242786, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 363682, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 90, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 464171, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3066, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 204.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 29685616, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9682.196999347685, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 278.73333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 15617650, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3735.3862712269793, "stage_move_gen_ns": 484235497, "stage_ordering_ns": 289772, "stage_eval_ns": 4927365914, "stage_threat_ns": 3345680296, "stage_proof_ns": 517428312, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 478957, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2604124716, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 116022, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 344175253, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1566, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 80301525, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 239471, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 317372235, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3886, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24367872, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 478942, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55640220, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 850, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6540, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6501.933333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7035.266666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1823, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 1402, "avg_search_time_ms": 100.14285714285714, "search_nodes": 98366, "safety_nodes": 1317, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 99683, "avg_nodes": 7120.214285714285, "eval_calls": 95317, "avg_eval_calls": 6808.357142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 95317, "line_shape_eval_ns": 120226856, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1261.33697032009, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3022, "avg_candidate_generations": 215.85714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 233291, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.19755129053607, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1001, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 3008, "search_candidate_moves_total": 232290, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 7277, "avg_legality_checks": 519.7857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7277, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23482, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1677.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 50874659, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2166.5385827442296, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18987675, "stage_ordering_ns": 101422, "stage_eval_ns": 120226856, "stage_threat_ns": 1238155899, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 196664, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1086152617, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 311252, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15640, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 98325, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 128180020, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 196650, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23512010, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 163, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2721, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6480.642857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7052.071428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 655, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8724, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 85, 123, 80, 65, 157, 173, 78, 79, 107, 97, 81, 67, 94, 51, 37, 83, 35, 115 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3449, "avg_search_time_ms": 246.35714285714286, "search_nodes": 207904, "safety_nodes": 1279, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 209183, "avg_nodes": 14941.642857142857, "eval_calls": 202429, "avg_eval_calls": 14459.214285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 202429, "line_shape_eval_ns": 233392100, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1152.9578271887922, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5448, "avg_candidate_generations": 389.14285714285717, "candidate_moves_total": 448302, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.28744493392071, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1058, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 5434, "search_candidate_moves_total": 447244, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 196096, "avg_legality_checks": 14006.857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 95, "root_legality_checks": 1058, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 195038, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 95, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 212513, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15179.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 516123475, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2428.6677756184326, "renju_forbidden_checks": 109, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7.785714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1141195, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10469.678899082568, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 109, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1141195, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 545341, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11129.408163265307, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 280781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4129.132352941177, "stage_move_gen_ns": 496424967, "stage_ordering_ns": 183661, "stage_eval_ns": 233392100, "stage_threat_ns": 2696100601, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 415740, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2364478606, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 789314, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 207863, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 279264459, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 415726, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51568222, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 334, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4879, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6395.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6967.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1909, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 5261, "avg_search_time_ms": 375.7857142857143, "search_nodes": 162322, "safety_nodes": 1045, "corridor_nodes": 2362, "corridor_branch_probes": 2505, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 854, "corridor_neutral_exits": 54, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 2337, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2337, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 95, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 70, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 58, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 854, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 95, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 93, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 708, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 302000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 165729, "avg_nodes": 11837.785714285714, "eval_calls": 157094, "avg_eval_calls": 11221.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 157094, "pattern_eval_ns": 3367125, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.433823061351802, "pattern_frame_queries": 157094, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3367125, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.433823061351802, "pattern_frame_updates": 324564, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2654603437, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8178.982995649549, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5202, "avg_candidate_generations": 371.57142857142856, "candidate_moves_total": 474618, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.23760092272202, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1092, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 5188, "search_candidate_moves_total": 473526, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 11672, "avg_legality_checks": 833.7142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11672, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 777305, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 55521.78571428572, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1766558524, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2272.6709901518707, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2686, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 191.85714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19498158, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7259.180193596426, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2666, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19261567, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 236591, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 31371890, "stage_ordering_ns": 186270, "stage_eval_ns": 2657970562, "stage_threat_ns": 2389275703, "stage_proof_ns": 147986665, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 329442, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1899064731, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 149211, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 196933286, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1740, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 85494936, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 164714, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 222558665, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4864, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 30257775, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 329428, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40461246, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 433, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4588, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6417.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6988.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1967, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 656, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7112, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 126, 99, 141, 98, 109, 108, 97, 83, 156, 171, 128, 67, 51, 84, 125, 85, 71, 82, 86, 81 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5242, "avg_search_time_ms": 476.54545454545456, "search_nodes": 108677, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 2016, "corridor_branch_probes": 2263, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 936, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1996, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1996, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 73, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 936, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 73, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 73, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 478, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 194720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 111609, "avg_nodes": 10146.272727272728, "eval_calls": 105369, "avg_eval_calls": 9579.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105369, "pattern_eval_ns": 2257161, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.421490191612335, "pattern_frame_queries": 105369, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2257161, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.421490191612335, "pattern_frame_updates": 217290, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2673726670, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12304.87675456763, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3287, "avg_candidate_generations": 298.8181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 227615, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.24703376939459, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 725, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 3276, "search_candidate_moves_total": 226890, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 102217, "avg_legality_checks": 9292.454545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 109, "root_legality_checks": 725, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 101492, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 105, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 999167, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 90833.36363636363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2386476470, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2388.4660622298375, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15708, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1428.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 158935885, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10118.149032340209, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 109, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1081376, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14496, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 147429281, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 332, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4072530, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 771, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6352698, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4956, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 450.54545454545456, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 52811520, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10656.077481840193, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6863, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 623.9090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 28354014, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4131.431443974938, "stage_move_gen_ns": 266640910, "stage_ordering_ns": 111500, "stage_eval_ns": 2675983831, "stage_threat_ns": 1938500262, "stage_proof_ns": 343446631, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 221439, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1361059624, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 110759, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 361850822, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1090, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 74055943, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 110714, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159990945, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4138, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 27039112, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 221428, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28559759, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 192, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2940, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5490.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6218.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1754, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1857, "avg_search_time_ms": 168.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 128655, "safety_nodes": 646, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 129301, "avg_nodes": 11754.636363636364, "eval_calls": 124326, "avg_eval_calls": 11302.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 124326, "line_shape_eval_ns": 139525412, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1122.2544922220613, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4309, "avg_candidate_generations": 391.72727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 324769, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.36992341610582, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4298, "search_candidate_moves_total": 324021, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 11177, "avg_legality_checks": 1016.0909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11177, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23825, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2165.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 56268128, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2361.726253934942, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.363636363636363, "renju_forbidden_ns": 584905, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12185.520833333334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 300662, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 284243, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 32007251, "stage_ordering_ns": 149010, "stage_eval_ns": 139525412, "stage_threat_ns": 1675678692, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 257259, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1469509719, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 155392, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11670, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128624, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 173609626, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 257248, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32403955, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 335, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3794, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6058.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6785.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 657, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18145, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 98, 83, 115, 116, 69, 125, 139, 126, 129, 96, 84, 99, 70, 56, 81, 124, 127, 110, 82, 123, 122, 141, 156, 138, 152, 130, 67, 71, 85, 86, 68, 101 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 2295, "avg_search_time_ms": 135.0, "search_nodes": 142372, "safety_nodes": 1386, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 143758, "avg_nodes": 8456.35294117647, "eval_calls": 137993, "avg_eval_calls": 8117.235294117647, "line_shape_eval_calls": 137993, "line_shape_eval_ns": 201743801, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1461.9857601472538, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4346, "avg_candidate_generations": 255.64705882352942, "candidate_moves_total": 356713, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.07846295444087, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1288, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 4329, "search_candidate_moves_total": 355425, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 131027, "avg_legality_checks": 7707.470588235294, "illegal_moves_skipped": 706, "root_legality_checks": 1288, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 129739, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 701, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 150835, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8872.64705882353, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 347117607, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2301.3067723008585, "renju_forbidden_checks": 730, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 42.94117647058823, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2877784, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3942.1698630136984, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 708, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2730904, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 146880, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.294117647058823, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 806426, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11046.931506849314, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.0588235294117645, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 434973, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4223.038834951456, "stage_move_gen_ns": 319172639, "stage_ordering_ns": 143481, "stage_eval_ns": 201743801, "stage_threat_ns": 1744246441, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 284661, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1524978074, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1059416, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17920, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 142322, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184142940, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 284644, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34066011, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 306, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3882, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6674.64705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7145.235294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1908, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 15835, "avg_search_time_ms": 931.4705882352941, "search_nodes": 477788, "safety_nodes": 1285, "corridor_nodes": 4048, "corridor_branch_probes": 4596, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 8, "corridor_depth_exits": 2022, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 37, "corridor_plies_followed": 4021, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4021, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 106, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 79, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2022, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 37, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 106, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 754, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 197520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 483121, "avg_nodes": 28418.882352941175, "eval_calls": 467651, "avg_eval_calls": 27508.882352941175, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 467651, "pattern_eval_ns": 9910621, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.192344290934905, "pattern_frame_queries": 467651, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 9910621, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.192344290934905, "pattern_frame_updates": 955478, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 9340029060, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9775.242402232181, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10105, "avg_candidate_generations": 594.4117647058823, "candidate_moves_total": 857159, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.8252350321623, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1316, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 10088, "search_candidate_moves_total": 855843, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 16565, "avg_legality_checks": 974.4117647058823, "illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 16565, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2652262, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 156015.41176470587, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5919300494, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2231.7932745709136, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56585, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3328.529411764706, "renju_forbidden_ns": 498671836, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8812.792012017318, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 567250, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 56390, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 497071481, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 51, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 487373, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 84, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 545732, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 43109404, "stage_ordering_ns": 337431, "stage_eval_ns": 9349939681, "stage_threat_ns": 6264890468, "stage_proof_ns": 136631635, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 963749, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5223930169, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 197797, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 228273898, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1906, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 78099055, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 481866, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 645304619, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8254, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 54249011, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 963732, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 113132771, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 540, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8958, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 2.823529411764706, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 2.823529411764706, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5970.588235294118, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6441.176470588235, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1969, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 658, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18422, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 84, 83, 69, 99, 98, 70, 130, 82, 146, 162, 126, 140, 115, 116, 145, 125, 139, 100, 144, 147, 129, 161, 143, 142, 101, 157, 87 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 17066, "avg_search_time_ms": 1137.7333333333333, "search_nodes": 425232, "safety_nodes": 270, "corridor_nodes": 2019, "corridor_branch_probes": 2270, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 777, "corridor_neutral_exits": 29, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1995, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1995, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 151, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 127, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 29, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 777, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 151, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 149, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1237, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 378400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 427521, "avg_nodes": 28501.4, "eval_calls": 414502, "avg_eval_calls": 27633.466666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 414502, "pattern_eval_ns": 8838739, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.323754770785182, "pattern_frame_queries": 414502, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 8838739, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.323754770785182, "pattern_frame_updates": 850378, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 9482782257, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11151.255391131943, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10702, "avg_candidate_generations": 713.4666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 860962, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.44870117735003, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1067, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 10687, "search_candidate_moves_total": 859895, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 403886, "avg_legality_checks": 26925.733333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 156, "root_legality_checks": 1067, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 402819, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 156, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3147606, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 209840.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7405766444, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2352.8251134354173, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25213, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1680.8666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 202727142, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8040.5799389203985, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 178, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1594328, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24919, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 200572650, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 241582, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 94, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 318582, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3381, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 225.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 32641440, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9654.374445430347, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4633, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 308.8666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 17031503, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3676.128426505504, "stage_move_gen_ns": 998875327, "stage_ordering_ns": 366030, "stage_eval_ns": 9491620996, "stage_threat_ns": 6023200542, "stage_proof_ns": 516060419, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 854685, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4911881670, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 128035, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 377054817, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1604, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 84936450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 427335, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 603019343, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4292, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25708714, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 854670, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 105535998, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 830, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9358, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4858.266666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5391.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1748, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 1341, "avg_search_time_ms": 95.78571428571429, "search_nodes": 92457, "safety_nodes": 1317, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 93774, "avg_nodes": 6698.142857142857, "eval_calls": 89427, "avg_eval_calls": 6387.642857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 89427, "line_shape_eval_ns": 114863971, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1284.4439710601944, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3003, "avg_candidate_generations": 214.5, "candidate_moves_total": 234771, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.17882117882118, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1001, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 2989, "search_candidate_moves_total": 233770, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 7586, "avg_legality_checks": 541.8571428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7586, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23791, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1699.357142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 52952057, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2225.7180026060273, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 21088502, "stage_ordering_ns": 98951, "stage_eval_ns": 114863971, "stage_threat_ns": 1188683735, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 184846, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1041776068, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 316231, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15541, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92416, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 123760542, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 184832, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22830894, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 163, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2732, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6475.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7046.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 659, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15279, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 129, 157, 172, 81, 161, 145, 114, 96, 144, 80, 64, 159, 158, 130, 186, 200, 156, 111, 84, 99, 171, 141, 201, 216, 175, 95, 143, 110, 174, 82, 173 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 3891, "avg_search_time_ms": 228.88235294117646, "search_nodes": 229618, "safety_nodes": 1122, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 230740, "avg_nodes": 13572.941176470587, "eval_calls": 223819, "avg_eval_calls": 13165.823529411764, "line_shape_eval_calls": 223819, "line_shape_eval_ns": 291605729, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1302.8640508625274, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5766, "avg_candidate_generations": 339.1764705882353, "candidate_moves_total": 462892, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.27956989247312, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1314, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 5749, "search_candidate_moves_total": 461578, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 212982, "avg_legality_checks": 12528.35294117647, "illegal_moves_skipped": 843, "root_legality_checks": 1314, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 211668, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 834, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 232696, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13688.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 586637309, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2521.0459526592635, "renju_forbidden_checks": 954, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 56.11764705882353, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10462319, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10966.791404612159, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 906, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9943945, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 518374, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 41, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.411764705882353, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 499582, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12184.926829268292, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 62, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.6470588235294117, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 275041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4436.145161290323, "stage_move_gen_ns": 570024883, "stage_ordering_ns": 187891, "stage_eval_ns": 291605729, "stage_threat_ns": 3006411545, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 459153, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2640023217, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 705752, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18370, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 229568, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 308051409, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 459136, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57631167, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 448, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5119, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6531.117647058823, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7001.705882352941, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1922, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 11371, "avg_search_time_ms": 668.8823529411765, "search_nodes": 340316, "safety_nodes": 1436, "corridor_nodes": 598, "corridor_branch_probes": 679, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 195, "corridor_neutral_exits": 27, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 580, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 580, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 102, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 84, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 29, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 195, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 102, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 99, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 731, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 242080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 342350, "avg_nodes": 20138.235294117647, "eval_calls": 331366, "avg_eval_calls": 19492.117647058825, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 331366, "pattern_eval_ns": 7075525, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.352598033594273, "pattern_frame_queries": 331366, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7075525, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.352598033594273, "pattern_frame_updates": 680534, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6556355391, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9634.133476064384, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8918, "avg_candidate_generations": 524.5882352941177, "candidate_moves_total": 778389, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.28291096658444, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1323, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 8901, "search_candidate_moves_total": 777066, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 18384, "avg_legality_checks": 1081.4117647058824, "illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 18384, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1680998, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 98882.23529411765, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4009900416, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2385.4284276364397, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25508, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1500.4705882352941, "renju_forbidden_ns": 232793463, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9126.292261251372, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 381731, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25189, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 229407834, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 81, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 846963, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 198, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2156935, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 51781689, "stage_ordering_ns": 305192, "stage_eval_ns": 6563430916, "stage_threat_ns": 4542883516, "stage_proof_ns": 180097378, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 681915, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3925936858, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40315, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 53108118, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 727, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 22546914, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 340949, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 470048946, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1364, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8504693, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 681898, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 85284901, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 467, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8066, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 2.823529411764706, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 2.823529411764706, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6275.294117647059, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6745.882352941177, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 660, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6473, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 81, 129, 96, 130, 131, 111, 95, 157, 172, 98, 109, 123, 80, 143, 65, 49, 110, 50, 125 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5572, "avg_search_time_ms": 506.54545454545456, "search_nodes": 140556, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 1821, "corridor_branch_probes": 2057, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 851, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1801, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1801, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 73, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 851, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 73, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 73, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 478, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 208720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 143293, "avg_nodes": 13026.636363636364, "eval_calls": 136877, "avg_eval_calls": 12443.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 136877, "pattern_eval_ns": 2719312, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.866829343132885, "pattern_frame_queries": 136877, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2719312, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.866829343132885, "pattern_frame_updates": 281048, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2954863352, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10513.732003074208, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3658, "avg_candidate_generations": 332.54545454545456, "candidate_moves_total": 244176, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.75123018042646, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 725, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 3647, "search_candidate_moves_total": 243451, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 135388, "avg_legality_checks": 12308.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 119, "root_legality_checks": 725, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 134663, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 115, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1124110, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 102191.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2363820435, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2102.8372979512683, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14058, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1278.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 140046348, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9962.03926589842, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 119, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1146333, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13349, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 133054691, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 156, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2039070, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 434, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3806254, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 395.54545454545456, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 38466986, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8840.952884394392, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5899, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 536.2727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 20819765, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3529.3719274453297, "stage_move_gen_ns": 309864504, "stage_ordering_ns": 113240, "stage_eval_ns": 2957582664, "stage_threat_ns": 2014602948, "stage_proof_ns": 270256406, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 284807, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1513451878, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 99737, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 269041527, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1007, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 55103774, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 142398, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 180008836, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3748, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20060912, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 284796, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32039795, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 192, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3321, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5029.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5756.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 900, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 890, "avg_search_time_ms": 80.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 71261, "safety_nodes": 646, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 71907, "avg_nodes": 6537.0, "eval_calls": 68068, "avg_eval_calls": 6188.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68068, "line_shape_eval_ns": 68547411, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1007.0431186460598, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3173, "avg_candidate_generations": 288.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 244210, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.96501733375355, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3162, "search_candidate_moves_total": 243462, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 8605, "avg_legality_checks": 782.2727272727273, "illegal_moves_skipped": 23, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8605, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 23, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21255, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1932.2727272727273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 38784388, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1824.7183250999765, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.909090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 450070, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10466.744186046511, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 261570, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 188500, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19312480, "stage_ordering_ns": 104500, "stage_eval_ns": 68547411, "stage_threat_ns": 796253494, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 142471, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 692732386, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 130320, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9250, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 71230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88219597, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 142460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15171191, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 335, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2712, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6147.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6874.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 661, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11685, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 81, 143, 67, 52, 95, 53, 80, 83, 113, 38, 68, 129, 54, 96, 69, 70, 84, 99, 100, 159, 175, 126, 128, 115, 79, 78, 109, 123, 101, 171, 157, 124, 110, 125 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 3741, "avg_search_time_ms": 207.83333333333334, "search_nodes": 347265, "safety_nodes": 1315, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 348580, "avg_nodes": 19365.555555555555, "eval_calls": 338191, "avg_eval_calls": 18788.38888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 338191, "line_shape_eval_ns": 358622209, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1060.4132250710397, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9039, "avg_candidate_generations": 502.1666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 752978, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.30324150901649, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1354, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 9021, "search_candidate_moves_total": 751624, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 327274, "avg_legality_checks": 18181.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4056, "root_legality_checks": 1354, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "search_legality_checks": 325920, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4041, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 347975, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19331.944444444445, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 514151039, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1477.5516603204253, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4216, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 234.22222222222223, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10112554, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2398.6133776091083, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4148, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9946743, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 68, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 165811, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.444444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 618781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6314.091836734694, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 237431, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2029.3247863247864, "stage_move_gen_ns": 516389810, "stage_ordering_ns": 257891, "stage_eval_ns": 358622209, "stage_threat_ns": 2797648604, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 694442, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2419232680, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 51, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 812583, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 347212, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 319620403, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 694424, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57982938, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 504, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8035, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6869.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7314.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1957, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 7926, "avg_search_time_ms": 440.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 307791, "safety_nodes": 1369, "corridor_nodes": 6228, "corridor_branch_probes": 6811, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 2788, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 6191, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5831, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 360, "corridor_proof_passes": 17, "corridor_proof_completed": 17, "corridor_proof_checks": 73, "corridor_proof_active": 37, "corridor_proof_quiet": 36, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2788, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 73, "corridor_proof_wins": 6, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 67, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 370, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 205680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 315388, "avg_nodes": 17521.555555555555, "eval_calls": 301434, "avg_eval_calls": 16746.333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 301434, "pattern_eval_ns": 5771006, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.145172740964856, "pattern_frame_queries": 301434, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5771006, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.145172740964856, "pattern_frame_updates": 615478, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4340565391, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7052.348566480036, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6323, "avg_candidate_generations": 351.27777777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 565385, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.41720702198323, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1378, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 6305, "search_candidate_moves_total": 564007, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 13008, "avg_legality_checks": 722.6666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 94, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 13008, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 94, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1958211, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 108789.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2951964101, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1507.4800933096587, "renju_forbidden_checks": 75579, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4198.833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 145965642, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1931.2989322430833, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 94, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 249102, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 74768, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 142377927, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 351, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1963859, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 366, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1374754, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 713, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 39.611111111111114, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 4082883, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5726.343618513324, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 964, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 53.55555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2286857, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2372.258298755187, "stage_move_gen_ns": 24220364, "stage_ordering_ns": 218772, "stage_eval_ns": 4346336397, "stage_threat_ns": 3455534187, "stage_proof_ns": 69726043, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 628024, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2621037453, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 326517, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 370679887, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 3361, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 151930326, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 314003, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 333845988, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12528, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 71794482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 628006, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58176377, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 546, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5554, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6820.944444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7265.388888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 662, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9517, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 80, 95, 79, 81, 96, 64, 68, 110, 54, 40, 128, 144, 67, 52, 69, 143, 159, 66, 84, 39, 83, 55, 99, 114, 51, 115, 35 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 8275, "avg_search_time_ms": 551.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 254004, "safety_nodes": 270, "corridor_nodes": 1711, "corridor_branch_probes": 1928, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 631, "corridor_neutral_exits": 36, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1690, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1690, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 167, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 146, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 631, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 167, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 165, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1373, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 398080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 255985, "avg_nodes": 17065.666666666668, "eval_calls": 245984, "avg_eval_calls": 16398.933333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 245984, "pattern_eval_ns": 4822482, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.604860478730323, "pattern_frame_queries": 245984, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4822482, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.604860478730323, "pattern_frame_updates": 507922, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4426759880, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8715.432448289304, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7992, "avg_candidate_generations": 532.8, "candidate_moves_total": 661023, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.71058558558559, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1067, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 7977, "search_candidate_moves_total": 659956, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 228208, "avg_legality_checks": 15213.866666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 30, "root_legality_checks": 1067, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 227141, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 30, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1974509, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 131633.93333333332, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3707663656, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1877.7648802816295, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19738, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1315.8666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 93820696, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4753.30307021988, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 84, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 363803, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19568, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 92855138, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 283393, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 61, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 318362, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2982, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 198.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 24172323, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8106.077464788732, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4057, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 270.46666666666664, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 12698272, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3129.965984717772, "stage_move_gen_ns": 434200300, "stage_ordering_ns": 290731, "stage_eval_ns": 4431582362, "stage_threat_ns": 2929799005, "stage_proof_ns": 410815639, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 511651, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2315612431, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 111760, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 259898849, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1534, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 60866714, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 255818, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 285302687, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3714, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18439346, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 511636, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50545692, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 850, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6684, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6545.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7078.466666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1901, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 1227, "avg_search_time_ms": 87.64285714285714, "search_nodes": 97841, "safety_nodes": 1317, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 99158, "avg_nodes": 7082.714285714285, "eval_calls": 94916, "avg_eval_calls": 6779.714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 94916, "line_shape_eval_ns": 103032512, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1085.5125795440179, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2898, "avg_candidate_generations": 207.0, "candidate_moves_total": 223668, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.18012422360249, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1001, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 2884, "search_candidate_moves_total": 222667, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 7392, "avg_legality_checks": 528.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7392, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23597, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1685.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 44408426, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1881.9521973132178, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17314277, "stage_ordering_ns": 94330, "stage_eval_ns": 103032512, "stage_threat_ns": 1084829077, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 195614, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 952191367, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 255821, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13140, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 97800, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 111732107, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 195600, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20649782, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 163, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2620, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6486.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7057.928571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1993, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 663, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6640, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 140, 97, 156, 114, 172, 124, 141, 139, 157, 127, 125, 82, 67, 66, 130, 50 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 512, "avg_search_time_ms": 56.888888888888886, "search_nodes": 31040, "safety_nodes": 839, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 31879, "avg_nodes": 3542.1111111111113, "eval_calls": 29361, "avg_eval_calls": 3262.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 29361, "line_shape_eval_ns": 21771122, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 741.4979735022649, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1663, "avg_candidate_generations": 184.77777777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 113953, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.52254960914011, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 566, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 1654, "search_candidate_moves_total": 113387, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 27456, "avg_legality_checks": 3050.6666666666665, "illegal_moves_skipped": 286, "root_legality_checks": 566, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 26890, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 279, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 38305, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4256.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 90243551, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2355.9209241613366, "renju_forbidden_checks": 318, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 35.333333333333336, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3550446, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11164.924528301886, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 288, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3208594, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 341852, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 86, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9.555555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 915184, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10641.67441860465, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13.11111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 454682, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3853.237288135593, "stage_move_gen_ns": 73530102, "stage_ordering_ns": 53610, "stage_eval_ns": 21771122, "stage_threat_ns": 405457773, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 62039, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 356395797, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1139546, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8710, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 31015, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 40048640, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 62030, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7873790, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 124, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1459, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5668.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6557.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1913, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6119, "avg_search_time_ms": 764.875, "search_nodes": 141609, "safety_nodes": 235, "corridor_nodes": 3928, "corridor_branch_probes": 4329, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 1741, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 3898, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3898, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 30, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1741, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 66, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 549, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 204480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 145772, "avg_nodes": 18221.5, "eval_calls": 137921, "avg_eval_calls": 17240.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 137921, "pattern_eval_ns": 2783128, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.17914603287389, "pattern_frame_queries": 137921, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2783128, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.17914603287389, "pattern_frame_updates": 283172, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3756583270, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13266.083051996666, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3673, "avg_candidate_generations": 459.125, "candidate_moves_total": 267334, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.78355567655868, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 504, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 3665, "search_candidate_moves_total": 266830, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 5781, "avg_legality_checks": 722.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5781, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1048605, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 131075.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2523560024, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2406.5878228694314, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37999, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4749.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 375479428, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9881.297613095081, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 779624, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37197, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 365472528, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 525, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6707666, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 207, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2519610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17499960, "stage_ordering_ns": 139020, "stage_eval_ns": 3759366398, "stage_threat_ns": 2253280256, "stage_proof_ns": 85059364, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 291112, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1705836452, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 228320, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 264512796, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2127, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 107470938, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 145552, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 200401019, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7932, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 41684099, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 291104, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40845890, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 316, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3180, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4105.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5105.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1962, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 664, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8400, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 140, 82, 141, 143, 114, 156, 84, 97, 100, 86, 52, 68, 99, 129, 139, 138, 127, 113, 54, 69, 81, 83, 53, 55, 111, 41 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3509, "avg_search_time_ms": 250.64285714285714, "search_nodes": 74918, "safety_nodes": 1222, "corridor_nodes": 1386, "corridor_branch_probes": 1676, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 581, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_plies_followed": 1370, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1370, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 73, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 581, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 73, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 70, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 464, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 198240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 15760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 77526, "avg_nodes": 5537.571428571428, "eval_calls": 71835, "avg_eval_calls": 5131.071428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71835, "pattern_eval_ns": 1440818, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.057325816106356, "pattern_frame_queries": 71835, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1440818, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.057325816106356, "pattern_frame_updates": 149756, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1804952578, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12052.62278639921, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3057, "avg_candidate_generations": 218.35714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 243371, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.6110565914295, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1031, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 3043, "search_candidate_moves_total": 242340, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 66337, "avg_legality_checks": 4738.357142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 52, "root_legality_checks": 1031, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 65306, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 52, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 799416, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 57101.142857142855, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1754982929, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2195.331253064737, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12974, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 926.7142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 94859808, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7311.531370433174, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 58, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 504320, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12244, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 90802077, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 187, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1434920, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 485, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2118491, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3639, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 259.92857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 36869086, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10131.653201428964, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5242, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 374.42857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 20071380, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3828.954597481877, "stage_move_gen_ns": 154339648, "stage_ordering_ns": 119310, "stage_eval_ns": 1806393396, "stage_threat_ns": 1247098687, "stage_proof_ns": 274566823, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152656, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 848788826, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 81856, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 263034886, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 851, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 53520770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76321, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99918371, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2886, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17865090, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152642, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17491514, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 278, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2644, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6362.357142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6933.785714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1734, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 4879, "avg_search_time_ms": 375.3076923076923, "search_nodes": 363582, "safety_nodes": 882, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 364464, "avg_nodes": 28035.69230769231, "eval_calls": 354833, "avg_eval_calls": 27294.846153846152, "line_shape_eval_calls": 354833, "line_shape_eval_ns": 402916384, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1135.5098990229205, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8724, "avg_candidate_generations": 671.0769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 750163, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.98842274186153, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 962, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 8711, "search_candidate_moves_total": 749201, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 16681, "avg_legality_checks": 1283.1538461538462, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 16681, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 31853, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2450.230769230769, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 72697661, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2282.286158289643, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.3846153846153846, "renju_forbidden_ns": 392492, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12661.032258064517, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 345752, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 46740, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 47410205, "stage_ordering_ns": 281422, "stage_eval_ns": 402916384, "stage_threat_ns": 4413339393, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 727101, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3866639621, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 285823, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13651, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 363544, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 462019776, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 727088, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 84394173, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 447, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7957, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6241.846153846154, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6857.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1958, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 665, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13985, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 97, 95, 125, 142, 94, 65, 50, 158, 174, 81, 111, 83, 82, 67, 139, 153, 109, 53, 39, 79, 93, 77, 78, 68, 160, 144, 154, 124, 64, 38, 98, 23 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 6519, "avg_search_time_ms": 383.47058823529414, "search_nodes": 413389, "safety_nodes": 1813, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 415202, "avg_nodes": 24423.647058823528, "eval_calls": 405184, "avg_eval_calls": 23834.352941176472, "line_shape_eval_calls": 405184, "line_shape_eval_ns": 529245153, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1306.1847284196808, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8172, "avg_candidate_generations": 480.70588235294116, "candidate_moves_total": 723746, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.56412139011258, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1420, "root_candidate_moves_max": 114, "search_candidate_generations": 8155, "search_candidate_moves_total": 722326, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 399037, "avg_legality_checks": 23472.764705882353, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 1420, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 397617, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 418970, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24645.29411764706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 960678726, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2292.9534954770033, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.8235294117647058, "renju_forbidden_ns": 113950, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8139.285714285715, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 113950, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.235294117647059, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 625081, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8681.680555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.235294117647059, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 274931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3089.112359550562, "stage_move_gen_ns": 947298101, "stage_ordering_ns": 266962, "stage_eval_ns": 529245153, "stage_threat_ns": 5010669875, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 826695, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4385717819, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 943621, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 413339, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 528058262, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 826678, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 95950173, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 331, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7603, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6399.64705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6870.235294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1868, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 7452, "avg_search_time_ms": 438.3529411764706, "search_nodes": 244350, "safety_nodes": 1640, "corridor_nodes": 1525, "corridor_branch_probes": 1761, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 24, "corridor_depth_exits": 548, "corridor_neutral_exits": 39, "corridor_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_plies_followed": 1495, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1495, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 102, "corridor_proof_active": 30, "corridor_proof_quiet": 72, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 63, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 548, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 102, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 723, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 367200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 247515, "avg_nodes": 14559.70588235294, "eval_calls": 237908, "avg_eval_calls": 13994.588235294117, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 237908, "pattern_eval_ns": 4798166, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.168157439010038, "pattern_frame_queries": 237908, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4798166, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.168157439010038, "pattern_frame_updates": 488602, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4014249359, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8215.785770422552, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6410, "avg_candidate_generations": 377.05882352941177, "candidate_moves_total": 529482, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.60249609984399, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1454, "root_candidate_moves_max": 114, "search_candidate_generations": 6393, "search_candidate_moves_total": 528028, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 15805, "avg_legality_checks": 929.7058823529412, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 15805, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1123914, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 66112.58823529411, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2540333120, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2260.2557846952704, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4514, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 265.52941176470586, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43374357, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9608.85179441737, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4483, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43126986, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 31, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 247371, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 39438057, "stage_ordering_ns": 227561, "stage_eval_ns": 4019047525, "stage_threat_ns": 3194908979, "stage_proof_ns": 158594796, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 491813, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2691196964, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 95448, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 111344714, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1157, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 47324014, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 245898, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 316637230, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3194, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19167073, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 491796, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56562998, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 412, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5707, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 2.823529411764706, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 2.823529411764706, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6363.529411764706, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6834.117647058823, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 666, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14519, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 144, 160, 142, 95, 125, 94, 127, 65, 50, 78, 62, 97, 157, 172, 143, 145, 141, 140, 173, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 13970, "avg_search_time_ms": 1164.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 327212, "safety_nodes": 383, "corridor_nodes": 1894, "corridor_branch_probes": 2181, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 888, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 1871, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1871, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 70, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 888, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 70, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 68, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 551, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 231600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 329489, "avg_nodes": 27457.416666666668, "eval_calls": 320510, "avg_eval_calls": 26709.166666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 320510, "pattern_eval_ns": 6460002, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.155383607375747, "pattern_frame_queries": 320510, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6460002, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.155383607375747, "pattern_frame_updates": 654356, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8324374995, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12721.477292177347, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6680, "avg_candidate_generations": 556.6666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 548347, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.08787425149701, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 921, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 6668, "search_candidate_moves_total": 547426, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 315312, "avg_legality_checks": 26276.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 329, "root_legality_checks": 921, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 314391, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 327, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2691214, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 224267.83333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6294080171, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2338.7512739603762, "renju_forbidden_checks": 52795, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4399.583333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 556334195, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10537.630362723743, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 422, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3913969, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 51151, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 537746115, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 399, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5258048, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 823, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9416063, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4845, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 403.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 51818417, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10695.235706914345, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6785, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 565.4166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 28606538, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4216.144141488578, "stage_move_gen_ns": 758273555, "stage_ordering_ns": 238010, "stage_eval_ns": 8330834997, "stage_threat_ns": 4536245822, "stage_proof_ns": 312406939, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 658250, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3658592757, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 102958, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 340621288, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1001, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 69780934, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 329119, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 437268585, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3882, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22481199, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 658238, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 77281993, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 546, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5811, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4191.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4857.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 536, "avg_search_time_ms": 48.72727272727273, "search_nodes": 38916, "safety_nodes": 1082, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 39998, "avg_nodes": 3636.181818181818, "eval_calls": 37231, "avg_eval_calls": 3384.6363636363635, "line_shape_eval_calls": 37231, "line_shape_eval_ns": 34420430, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 924.5099513845988, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1664, "avg_candidate_generations": 151.27272727272728, "candidate_moves_total": 139812, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.02163461538461, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 850, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 1653, "search_candidate_moves_total": 138962, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 4429, "avg_legality_checks": 402.6363636363636, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4429, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17473, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1588.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 36690743, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2099.853659932467, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7272727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 208310, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10963.684210526315, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 59410, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 148900, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11715714, "stage_ordering_ns": 53590, "stage_eval_ns": 34420430, "stage_threat_ns": 476416508, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 77779, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 419990500, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 236531, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11240, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38884, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 47436760, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 77768, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8752717, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 154, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1402, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6129.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6856.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 667, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13220, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 113, 83, 81, 110, 68, 85, 86, 124, 138, 99, 97, 129, 114, 115, 65, 49, 67, 131, 147, 69, 53, 39, 54, 130, 154, 140, 64, 66, 70, 132, 128, 133 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 5162, "avg_search_time_ms": 303.6470588235294, "search_nodes": 331450, "safety_nodes": 1813, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 333263, "avg_nodes": 19603.70588235294, "eval_calls": 324038, "avg_eval_calls": 19061.058823529413, "line_shape_eval_calls": 324038, "line_shape_eval_ns": 380513876, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1174.2878180954085, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7379, "avg_candidate_generations": 434.05882352941177, "candidate_moves_total": 641571, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.94552107331617, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1420, "root_candidate_moves_max": 114, "search_candidate_generations": 7362, "search_candidate_moves_total": 640151, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 317998, "avg_legality_checks": 18705.764705882353, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 1420, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 316578, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 337931, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19878.29411764706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 772034592, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2284.5923931216726, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.8235294117647058, "renju_forbidden_ns": 109530, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7823.571428571428, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 109530, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.235294117647059, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 621684, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8634.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.235294117647059, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 274972, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3089.5730337078653, "stage_move_gen_ns": 753034363, "stage_ordering_ns": 228590, "stage_eval_ns": 380513876, "stage_threat_ns": 3980862906, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 662817, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3494841912, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 934937, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 331400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 408587098, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 662800, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 76498959, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 331, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6828, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6403.882352941177, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6874.470588235294, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1892, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 8043, "avg_search_time_ms": 473.11764705882354, "search_nodes": 277800, "safety_nodes": 1640, "corridor_nodes": 1520, "corridor_branch_probes": 1730, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 27, "corridor_depth_exits": 542, "corridor_neutral_exits": 47, "corridor_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_plies_followed": 1489, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1489, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 102, "corridor_proof_active": 31, "corridor_proof_quiet": 71, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 74, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 542, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 102, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 723, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 327280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 280960, "avg_nodes": 16527.058823529413, "eval_calls": 270864, "avg_eval_calls": 15933.176470588236, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 270864, "pattern_eval_ns": 5446429, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.10761489160612, "pattern_frame_queries": 270864, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5446429, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.10761489160612, "pattern_frame_updates": 555502, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4278556932, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7702.1449643745655, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6904, "avg_candidate_generations": 406.11764705882354, "candidate_moves_total": 569150, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.43771726535341, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1454, "root_candidate_moves_max": 114, "search_candidate_generations": 6887, "search_candidate_moves_total": 567696, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 16731, "avg_legality_checks": 984.1764705882352, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 16731, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1215048, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 71473.41176470589, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2675635156, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2202.0818568484538, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3914, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 230.23529411764707, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33838806, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8645.581502299437, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3879, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33615686, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 223120, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 41263212, "stage_ordering_ns": 235291, "stage_eval_ns": 4284003361, "stage_threat_ns": 3507041704, "stage_proof_ns": 158374819, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 558701, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2964813437, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 94604, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 110504522, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1168, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 46995409, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 279342, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 348981716, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3182, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19380107, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 558684, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63361922, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 426, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6222, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 2.823529411764706, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 2.823529411764706, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6380.35294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6850.941176470588, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 668, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12145, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 110, 83, 81, 68, 111, 54, 40, 85, 86, 113, 95, 125, 109, 108, 123, 67, 137 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11178, "avg_search_time_ms": 1016.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 286613, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 1447, "corridor_branch_probes": 1662, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 650, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1429, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1429, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 650, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 416, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 180480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 288446, "avg_nodes": 26222.363636363636, "eval_calls": 280132, "avg_eval_calls": 25466.545454545456, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 280132, "pattern_eval_ns": 5643381, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.145435009209944, "pattern_frame_queries": 280132, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5643381, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.145435009209944, "pattern_frame_updates": 573164, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6391556244, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11151.356756530417, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6461, "avg_candidate_generations": 587.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 517813, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.14440489088376, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 823, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 6450, "search_candidate_moves_total": 516990, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 276508, "avg_legality_checks": 25137.090909090908, "illegal_moves_skipped": 204, "root_legality_checks": 823, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 275685, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 204, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2134163, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 194014.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4891379673, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2291.9428708116484, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26054, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2368.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 252817691, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9703.60370768404, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 208, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1883509, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25301, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 245391690, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 212, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2586250, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 333, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2956242, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3804, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 345.8181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 39493496, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10382.096740273397, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5284, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 480.3636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 21536211, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4075.740158970477, "stage_move_gen_ns": 654251153, "stage_ordering_ns": 209890, "stage_eval_ns": 6397199625, "stage_threat_ns": 3833327807, "stage_proof_ns": 249079490, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 576143, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3106698091, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 82289, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 272406503, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 796, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 55863048, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 288066, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 370739167, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2968, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17230001, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 576132, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66254045, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 506, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5670, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4112.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4839.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 958, "avg_search_time_ms": 95.8, "search_nodes": 70868, "safety_nodes": 986, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 71854, "avg_nodes": 7185.4, "eval_calls": 68399, "avg_eval_calls": 6839.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68399, "line_shape_eval_ns": 61386153, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 897.4714981213176, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2450, "avg_candidate_generations": 245.0, "candidate_moves_total": 199152, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.2865306122449, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 755, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2440, "search_candidate_moves_total": 198397, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 5685, "avg_legality_checks": 568.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5685, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1756.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 37085358, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2111.9224373576308, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15430568, "stage_ordering_ns": 74531, "stage_eval_ns": 61386153, "stage_threat_ns": 869230944, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 141688, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 761557243, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 214901, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9800, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70839, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91032607, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 141678, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16426193, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 154, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2137, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5901.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6701.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 669, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6269, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 144, 111, 130, 82, 116, 102, 129, 159, 115, 113, 100, 110, 109, 68, 124, 54 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 613, "avg_search_time_ms": 68.11111111111111, "search_nodes": 37833, "safety_nodes": 885, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 38718, "avg_nodes": 4302.0, "eval_calls": 35901, "avg_eval_calls": 3989.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 35901, "line_shape_eval_ns": 28384346, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 790.628283334726, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1916, "avg_candidate_generations": 212.88888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 134613, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.25730688935282, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 592, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 1907, "search_candidate_moves_total": 134021, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 34298, "avg_legality_checks": 3810.8888888888887, "illegal_moves_skipped": 70, "root_legality_checks": 592, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 33706, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 63, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 45058, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5006.444444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 105146467, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2333.5804296684273, "renju_forbidden_checks": 100, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11.11111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1178502, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11785.02, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 850587, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 327915, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8.222222222222221, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 786752, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10631.783783783783, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 101, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11.222222222222221, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 388181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3843.3762376237623, "stage_move_gen_ns": 86604791, "stage_ordering_ns": 59500, "stage_eval_ns": 28384346, "stage_threat_ns": 484920282, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 75625, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 425645963, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1015372, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8840, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37808, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 49174791, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 75616, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9084156, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 124, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1708, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5660.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6548.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1914, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5647, "avg_search_time_ms": 705.875, "search_nodes": 143970, "safety_nodes": 249, "corridor_nodes": 3129, "corridor_branch_probes": 3433, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 1302, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 3105, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3105, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1302, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 66, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 549, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 187360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 147348, "avg_nodes": 18418.5, "eval_calls": 139974, "avg_eval_calls": 17496.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 139974, "pattern_eval_ns": 2842806, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.309528912512324, "pattern_frame_queries": 139974, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2842806, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.309528912512324, "pattern_frame_updates": 287894, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3341869010, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11607.984223359987, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3981, "avg_candidate_generations": 497.625, "candidate_moves_total": 302777, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.05551369002764, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 532, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 3973, "search_candidate_moves_total": 302245, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 6406, "avg_legality_checks": 800.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6406, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 918933, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 114866.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2193727989, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2387.255642141484, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29458, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3682.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 295337147, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10025.702593522981, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 47, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 520102, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28744, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 286506749, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 500, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6302817, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 167, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2007479, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18246070, "stage_ordering_ns": 133041, "stage_eval_ns": 3344711816, "stage_threat_ns": 2172011517, "stage_proof_ns": 95815299, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 294248, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1671260224, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 190968, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 234785583, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1851, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 98678261, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147120, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 198134918, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6346, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 32534716, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 294240, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35296076, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 330, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3398, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4363.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5363.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 670, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13203, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 144, 82, 129, 99, 130, 110, 146, 162, 68, 97, 67, 111, 113, 126, 83, 53, 159, 174, 81, 124, 138, 125, 127, 80, 64, 95, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 10974, "avg_search_time_ms": 731.6, "search_nodes": 219030, "safety_nodes": 439, "corridor_nodes": 8646, "corridor_branch_probes": 9008, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4928, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 8618, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8618, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4928, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 6, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 698, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 192960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 228115, "avg_nodes": 15207.666666666666, "eval_calls": 212096, "avg_eval_calls": 14139.733333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 212096, "pattern_eval_ns": 4288381, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.21905646499698, "pattern_frame_queries": 212096, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4288381, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.21905646499698, "pattern_frame_updates": 437974, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5416718891, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12367.672261367114, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6906, "avg_candidate_generations": 460.4, "candidate_moves_total": 623497, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.28337677381987, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1170, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 6891, "search_candidate_moves_total": 622327, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 200203, "avg_legality_checks": 13346.866666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 697, "root_legality_checks": 1170, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 199033, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 694, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2591935, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 172795.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5723010112, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2208.0068026397266, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54043, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3602.866666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 264515666, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4894.540754584313, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 804, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1697865, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 48344, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 236406589, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1234, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10592451, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3661, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 15818761, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 17276, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1151.7333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 156783510, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9075.22053716138, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22879, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1525.2666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 74565066, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3259.105118230692, "stage_move_gen_ns": 467203579, "stage_ordering_ns": 257471, "stage_eval_ns": 5421007272, "stage_threat_ns": 4225375625, "stage_proof_ns": 817835459, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 455409, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2553088635, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 373825, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1193408750, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 3786, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 241967961, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 227697, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 309563019, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 17420, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 116941419, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 455394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52373802, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 787, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5846, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6465.933333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6999.266666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1774, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2216, "avg_search_time_ms": 158.28571428571428, "search_nodes": 160427, "safety_nodes": 1566, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 161993, "avg_nodes": 11570.92857142857, "eval_calls": 156506, "avg_eval_calls": 11179.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 156506, "line_shape_eval_ns": 145679797, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 930.82563607785, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3894, "avg_candidate_generations": 278.14285714285717, "candidate_moves_total": 304281, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.14098613251156, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1099, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 3880, "search_candidate_moves_total": 303182, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 6752, "avg_legality_checks": 482.2857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6752, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23121, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1651.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 50901627, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2201.532243415077, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 27890, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1267.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7960, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 19930, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19938044, "stage_ordering_ns": 119810, "stage_eval_ns": 145679797, "stage_threat_ns": 2034109979, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 320786, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1787305334, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 397515, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14590, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 160386, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 207614775, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 320772, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38792355, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 145, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3591, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6366.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6938.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1969, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 671, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6208, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 144, 97, 158, 110, 172, 130, 143, 145, 157, 127, 129, 82, 67, 68, 124, 54 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 495, "avg_search_time_ms": 55.0, "search_nodes": 30201, "safety_nodes": 839, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 31040, "avg_nodes": 3448.8888888888887, "eval_calls": 28473, "avg_eval_calls": 3163.6666666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 28473, "line_shape_eval_ns": 21666755, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 760.9579250518035, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1712, "avg_candidate_generations": 190.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 117540, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.65654205607477, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 566, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 1703, "search_candidate_moves_total": 116974, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 26497, "avg_legality_checks": 2944.1111111111113, "illegal_moves_skipped": 73, "root_legality_checks": 566, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 25931, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 66, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 37346, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4149.555555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 88103698, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2359.1200664060407, "renju_forbidden_checks": 105, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11.666666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1268284, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12078.895238095238, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 930081, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 338203, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 86, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9.555555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 920625, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10704.941860465116, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13.11111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 464393, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3935.5338983050847, "stage_move_gen_ns": 68970658, "stage_ordering_ns": 54430, "stage_eval_ns": 21666755, "stage_threat_ns": 394241624, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 60361, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 346609140, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1149645, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8880, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 30176, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 39240335, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 60352, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7242504, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 124, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1505, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5676.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6565.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1919, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5703, "avg_search_time_ms": 712.875, "search_nodes": 129096, "safety_nodes": 235, "corridor_nodes": 4592, "corridor_branch_probes": 5044, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 2027, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 4558, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4558, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 34, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2027, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 66, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 549, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 308160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 133923, "avg_nodes": 16740.375, "eval_calls": 125670, "avg_eval_calls": 15708.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 125670, "pattern_eval_ns": 2538377, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.198750696268004, "pattern_frame_queries": 125670, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2538377, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.198750696268004, "pattern_frame_updates": 258146, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3437777830, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13317.184190341899, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3411, "avg_candidate_generations": 426.375, "candidate_moves_total": 248972, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.99091175608326, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 504, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 3403, "search_candidate_moves_total": 248468, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 4898, "avg_legality_checks": 612.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 57, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4898, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 57, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 970986, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 121373.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2339407954, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2409.311724370897, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35689, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4461.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 349341861, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9788.502367676314, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 728404, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34809, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 338419220, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 606, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7673204, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 207, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2521033, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14920817, "stage_ordering_ns": 106980, "stage_eval_ns": 3440316207, "stage_threat_ns": 2156043168, "stage_proof_ns": 80336386, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 267406, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1577962895, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 267542, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 309395804, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2440, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 124760726, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 133699, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 186249058, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9252, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 49315799, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 267398, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33119612, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 316, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2946, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4330.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5330.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1967, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 672, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8424, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 144, 82, 143, 141, 110, 158, 80, 97, 94, 78, 52, 66, 95, 125, 145, 146, 127, 111, 50, 65, 83, 81, 51, 49, 113, 33 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3353, "avg_search_time_ms": 239.5, "search_nodes": 71544, "safety_nodes": 1222, "corridor_nodes": 1398, "corridor_branch_probes": 1708, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 597, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_plies_followed": 1382, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1382, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 73, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 597, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 73, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 70, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 464, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 202480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 15760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 74164, "avg_nodes": 5297.428571428572, "eval_calls": 68557, "avg_eval_calls": 4896.928571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68557, "pattern_eval_ns": 1391515, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.29719795206908, "pattern_frame_queries": 68557, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1391515, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.29719795206908, "pattern_frame_updates": 143008, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1696948414, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11866.108287648243, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2961, "avg_candidate_generations": 211.5, "candidate_moves_total": 236638, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.91827085444106, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1031, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 2947, "search_candidate_moves_total": 235607, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 63534, "avg_legality_checks": 4538.142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "root_legality_checks": 1031, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 62503, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 770496, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 55035.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1670269873, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2167.7852617015533, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13312, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 950.8571428571429, "renju_forbidden_ns": 96499776, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7249.0817307692305, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 314572, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12619, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 92960916, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 176, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1273478, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 477, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1950810, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3656, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 261.14285714285717, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 37134289, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10157.081236323851, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5292, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 378.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 20185832, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3814.4051398337115, "stage_move_gen_ns": 145920811, "stage_ordering_ns": 104060, "stage_eval_ns": 1698339929, "stage_threat_ns": 1207285992, "stage_proof_ns": 275119852, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 145932, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 817498504, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 81468, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 259265300, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 851, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 52775513, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72959, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 95725702, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2910, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18100716, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 145918, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16695770, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 278, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2550, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6392.928571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6964.357142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1781, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 5056, "avg_search_time_ms": 388.9230769230769, "search_nodes": 374890, "safety_nodes": 882, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 375772, "avg_nodes": 28905.53846153846, "eval_calls": 366266, "avg_eval_calls": 28174.30769230769, "line_shape_eval_calls": 366266, "line_shape_eval_ns": 420770513, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1148.811281964474, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8599, "avg_candidate_generations": 661.4615384615385, "candidate_moves_total": 741081, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.18223049191766, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 962, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 8586, "search_candidate_moves_total": 740119, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 17428, "avg_legality_checks": 1340.6153846153845, "illegal_moves_skipped": 28, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 17428, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 28, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32600, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2507.6923076923076, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 74506093, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2285.462975460123, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.4615384615384617, "renju_forbidden_ns": 389022, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12156.9375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 344372, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 44650, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 48676062, "stage_ordering_ns": 267803, "stage_eval_ns": 420770513, "stage_threat_ns": 4566361386, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 749717, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4003675167, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 284641, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 374852, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 475053385, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 749704, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 87348193, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 447, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7842, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6236.538461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6851.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1961, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 673, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13851, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 111, 81, 83, 114, 66, 79, 78, 130, 146, 95, 97, 125, 110, 109, 69, 55, 67, 123, 137, 65, 51, 35, 50, 124, 160, 144, 70, 68, 64, 122, 126, 121 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 5903, "avg_search_time_ms": 347.2352941176471, "search_nodes": 366544, "safety_nodes": 1813, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 368357, "avg_nodes": 21668.058823529413, "eval_calls": 358650, "avg_eval_calls": 21097.058823529413, "line_shape_eval_calls": 358650, "line_shape_eval_ns": 439894917, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1226.5298117942284, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7861, "avg_candidate_generations": 462.4117647058824, "candidate_moves_total": 686190, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.29042106602213, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1420, "root_candidate_moves_max": 114, "search_candidate_generations": 7844, "search_candidate_moves_total": 684770, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 352561, "avg_legality_checks": 20738.882352941175, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "root_legality_checks": 1420, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 351141, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 372494, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21911.41176470588, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 864699718, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2321.3789161704617, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.8823529411764706, "renju_forbidden_ns": 127820, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8521.333333333334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 127820, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.235294117647059, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 651852, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9053.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.235294117647059, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 284011, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3191.1348314606744, "stage_move_gen_ns": 847319760, "stage_ordering_ns": 242991, "stage_eval_ns": 439894917, "stage_threat_ns": 4576571937, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 733005, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4016918592, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 979114, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 366494, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 470912007, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 732988, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 87762224, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 331, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7306, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6329.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6799.588235294118, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1602, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 7932, "avg_search_time_ms": 466.5882352941176, "search_nodes": 258746, "safety_nodes": 1640, "corridor_nodes": 1550, "corridor_branch_probes": 1757, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 27, "corridor_depth_exits": 566, "corridor_neutral_exits": 39, "corridor_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_plies_followed": 1519, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1519, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 102, "corridor_proof_active": 31, "corridor_proof_quiet": 71, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 66, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 566, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 102, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 723, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 327200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 261936, "avg_nodes": 15408.0, "eval_calls": 252361, "avg_eval_calls": 14844.764705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 252361, "pattern_eval_ns": 5256766, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.830342247811668, "pattern_frame_queries": 252361, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5256766, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.830342247811668, "pattern_frame_updates": 517394, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4221486856, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8159.133766529956, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6353, "avg_candidate_generations": 373.70588235294116, "candidate_moves_total": 527657, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.05635133008028, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1454, "root_candidate_moves_max": 114, "search_candidate_generations": 6336, "search_candidate_moves_total": 526203, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 17236, "avg_legality_checks": 1013.8823529411765, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 17236, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1186544, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 69796.70588235294, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2689795686, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2266.9160907644386, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5230, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 307.6470588235294, "renju_forbidden_ns": 47897083, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9158.14206500956, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5191, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 47618223, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 278860, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 44441812, "stage_ordering_ns": 215900, "stage_eval_ns": 4226743622, "stage_threat_ns": 3451473020, "stage_proof_ns": 163954309, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 520653, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2909085501, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 95242, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 114056315, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1171, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 48840321, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 260318, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 345663362, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3242, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20234098, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 520636, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62433744, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 417, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5703, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 2.823529411764706, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 2.823529411764706, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6405.117647058823, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6875.705882352941, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 674, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14919, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 114, 81, 83, 66, 113, 50, 34, 79, 78, 111, 115, 116, 129, 159, 99, 84, 131, 67, 147 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 13915, "avg_search_time_ms": 1159.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 326561, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 1924, "corridor_branch_probes": 2216, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 896, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 1901, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1901, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 70, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 896, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 70, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 68, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 551, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 248400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 328871, "avg_nodes": 27405.916666666668, "eval_calls": 319515, "avg_eval_calls": 26626.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 319515, "pattern_eval_ns": 6737245, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.085848864685538, "pattern_frame_queries": 319515, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6737245, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.085848864685538, "pattern_frame_updates": 653054, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8029477641, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12295.27365424605, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7024, "avg_candidate_generations": 585.3333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 582689, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.95686218678816, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 924, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 7012, "search_candidate_moves_total": 581765, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 314938, "avg_legality_checks": 26244.833333333332, "illegal_moves_skipped": 570, "root_legality_checks": 924, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 314014, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 568, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2535200, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 211266.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6154726828, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2427.708594193752, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44179, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3681.5833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 466341203, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10555.721111840467, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6721963, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 42166, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 442571162, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 451, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6237030, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 896, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 10811048, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 5004, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 417.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 56404707, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11271.92386091127, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6990, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 582.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 31215832, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4465.78426323319, "stage_move_gen_ns": 800077244, "stage_ordering_ns": 252222, "stage_eval_ns": 8036214886, "stage_threat_ns": 4706056132, "stage_proof_ns": 331878811, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 657008, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3774432285, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 105176, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 373100672, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1022, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 77133989, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 328498, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 453715511, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3942, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24306705, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 656996, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 80500959, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 579, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6163, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4088.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4754.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 992, "avg_search_time_ms": 90.18181818181819, "search_nodes": 70667, "safety_nodes": 1092, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 71759, "avg_nodes": 6523.545454545455, "eval_calls": 68124, "avg_eval_calls": 6193.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68124, "line_shape_eval_ns": 64864442, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 952.152574716693, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2522, "avg_candidate_generations": 229.27272727272728, "candidate_moves_total": 209408, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.0325138778747, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 855, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2511, "search_candidate_moves_total": 208553, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 5692, "avg_legality_checks": 517.4545454545455, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5692, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18734, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1703.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 42298981, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2257.8723710899967, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7272727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 215670, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11351.052631578947, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 60560, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 155110, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16393739, "stage_ordering_ns": 79830, "stage_eval_ns": 64864442, "stage_threat_ns": 894006976, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 141281, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 786013328, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 247391, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12010, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70635, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90936631, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 141270, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16809626, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 154, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2152, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6092.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6819.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 675, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10592, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 97, 99, 129, 142, 100, 69, 54, 156, 170, 83, 113, 81, 82, 67, 140, 154, 115, 66, 145, 161, 130, 85, 160 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3418, "avg_search_time_ms": 262.9230769230769, "search_nodes": 208208, "safety_nodes": 1282, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 209490, "avg_nodes": 16114.615384615385, "eval_calls": 203342, "avg_eval_calls": 15641.692307692309, "line_shape_eval_calls": 203342, "line_shape_eval_ns": 187000909, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 919.6374039795026, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4842, "avg_candidate_generations": 372.46153846153845, "candidate_moves_total": 357888, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.91325898389096, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 936, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 4829, "search_candidate_moves_total": 356952, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 199917, "avg_legality_checks": 15378.23076923077, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 936, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 198981, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 215260, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16558.46153846154, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 531894730, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2470.9408622131377, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.7692307692307693, "renju_forbidden_ns": 74840, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7484.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 73330, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1510, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 544702, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9391.413793103447, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.846153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 249351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3280.934210526316, "stage_move_gen_ns": 513812575, "stage_ordering_ns": 147850, "stage_eval_ns": 187000909, "stage_threat_ns": 2702060534, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 416355, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2373219734, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 752213, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13050, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 208171, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 276481088, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 416342, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51607499, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 210, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4493, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5981.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6596.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1919, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7160, "avg_search_time_ms": 596.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 228859, "safety_nodes": 668, "corridor_nodes": 1314, "corridor_branch_probes": 1518, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 483, "corridor_neutral_exits": 19, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1292, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1292, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 79, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 483, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 79, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 77, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 579, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 202160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 230841, "avg_nodes": 19236.75, "eval_calls": 222603, "avg_eval_calls": 18550.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 222603, "pattern_eval_ns": 4580807, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.578370462212998, "pattern_frame_queries": 222603, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4580807, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.578370462212998, "pattern_frame_updates": 457648, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3902273070, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8526.800226374855, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6233, "avg_candidate_generations": 519.4166666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 482835, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.4643029038986, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 861, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 6221, "search_candidate_moves_total": 481974, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 13165, "avg_legality_checks": 1097.0833333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 13165, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1021102, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 85091.83333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2409095226, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2359.309085674105, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4572, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 381.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 45890254, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10037.238407699038, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4560, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 45795014, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 95240, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 35899005, "stage_ordering_ns": 209341, "stage_eval_ns": 3906853877, "stage_threat_ns": 3059695372, "stage_proof_ns": 128768829, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 460402, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2582543057, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 83817, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 100681677, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 940, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 41055836, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 230195, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 305671969, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2742, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15390128, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 460390, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55408541, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 370, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5530, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5581.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6248.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1972, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 676, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25267, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 96, 99, 129, 86, 100, 83, 85, 67, 115, 69, 54, 70, 68, 82, 101, 51, 35, 87, 81, 66, 145, 130, 97, 113, 143, 157, 141, 111, 140, 154, 94, 95, 142, 139, 110, 158, 78 ], "move_count": 43, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 23759, "avg_search_time_ms": 1187.95, "search_nodes": 586539, "safety_nodes": 842, "corridor_nodes": 5374, "corridor_branch_probes": 5712, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2658, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 5340, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5340, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 18, "corridor_proof_completed": 18, "corridor_proof_checks": 119, "corridor_proof_active": 34, "corridor_proof_quiet": 85, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2658, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 119, "corridor_proof_wins": 6, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 113, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 793, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 247360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 12, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 7, "total_nodes": 592755, "avg_nodes": 29637.75, "eval_calls": 574478, "avg_eval_calls": 28723.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 574478, "pattern_eval_ns": 12003960, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.895421582723795, "pattern_frame_queries": 574478, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 12003960, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.895421582723795, "pattern_frame_updates": 1172962, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 13685080361, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11667.113138362538, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12023, "avg_candidate_generations": 601.15, "candidate_moves_total": 1028598, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.55252432837062, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1526, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 12003, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1027072, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 553702, "avg_legality_checks": 27685.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 354, "root_legality_checks": 1526, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 552176, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 352, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5323387, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 266169.35, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11729134874, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2203.321846410941, "renju_forbidden_checks": 53237, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2661.85, "renju_forbidden_ns": 250273586, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4701.121137554708, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 536, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1130943, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 50473, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 243112406, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 213, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1557845, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2015, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4472392, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10291, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 514.55, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 99029440, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9622.917112039646, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13465, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 673.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 49469492, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3673.931823245451, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1226157741, "stage_ordering_ns": 412130, "stage_eval_ns": 13697084321, "stage_threat_ns": 8036363109, "stage_proof_ns": 686705802, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1183900, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6183090729, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 268418, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 876021548, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2865, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 179128860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 591940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 766833883, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10918, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 74084185, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1183880, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 136332764, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 991, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 10188, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 2.85, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 2.85, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5920.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6320.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 583, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 1487, "avg_search_time_ms": 78.26315789473684, "search_nodes": 104443, "safety_nodes": 1692, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 106135, "avg_nodes": 5586.0526315789475, "eval_calls": 100161, "avg_eval_calls": 5271.631578947368, "line_shape_eval_calls": 100161, "line_shape_eval_ns": 111855841, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1116.7604257145995, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4245, "avg_candidate_generations": 223.42105263157896, "candidate_moves_total": 320718, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.55194346289753, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1453, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 4226, "search_candidate_moves_total": 319265, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 11168, "avg_legality_checks": 587.7894736842105, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11168, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32504, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1710.7368421052631, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 72351872, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2225.9374846172777, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.3157894736842106, "renju_forbidden_ns": 103551, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2353.431818181818, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 28071, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 75480, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 31263224, "stage_ordering_ns": 141901, "stage_eval_ns": 111855841, "stage_threat_ns": 1316318410, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 208793, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1156320422, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 49, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 299983, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 24280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 104387, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 134521470, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 208774, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25176535, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 263, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3784, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6861.1578947368425, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7282.210526315789, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 677, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6578, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 140, 113, 124, 82, 108, 92, 125, 155, 109, 111, 94, 114, 115, 66, 130, 50 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 908, "avg_search_time_ms": 100.88888888888889, "search_nodes": 54348, "safety_nodes": 885, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 55233, "avg_nodes": 6137.0, "eval_calls": 52049, "avg_eval_calls": 5783.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 52049, "line_shape_eval_ns": 40857125, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 784.9742550289151, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2283, "avg_candidate_generations": 253.66666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 160327, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.22645641699518, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 592, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 2274, "search_candidate_moves_total": 159735, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 50358, "avg_legality_checks": 5595.333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 71, "root_legality_checks": 592, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 49766, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 64, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 61118, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6790.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 149303117, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2442.8665368631173, "renju_forbidden_checks": 101, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11.222222222222221, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1217379, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12053.257425742575, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 71, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 878878, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 338501, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8.222222222222221, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 827802, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11186.513513513513, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 101, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11.222222222222221, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 412442, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4083.5841584158416, "stage_move_gen_ns": 130747173, "stage_ordering_ns": 72320, "stage_eval_ns": 40857125, "stage_threat_ns": 722303279, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 108655, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 635074037, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1064835, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 54323, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 72542879, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 108646, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13621528, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 124, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2029, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5577.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6465.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1896, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5662, "avg_search_time_ms": 707.75, "search_nodes": 142396, "safety_nodes": 249, "corridor_nodes": 3491, "corridor_branch_probes": 3875, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1457, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 3464, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3464, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 41, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1457, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 66, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 549, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 219280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 146136, "avg_nodes": 18267.0, "eval_calls": 138225, "avg_eval_calls": 17278.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 138225, "pattern_eval_ns": 2932716, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.216972327726534, "pattern_frame_queries": 138225, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2932716, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.216972327726534, "pattern_frame_updates": 284746, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3240150252, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11379.089616711033, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4156, "avg_candidate_generations": 519.5, "candidate_moves_total": 313412, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.41193455245428, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 532, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 4148, "search_candidate_moves_total": 312880, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 7262, "avg_legality_checks": 907.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 45, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7262, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 45, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 883671, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 110458.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2156460328, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2440.342987378787, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25770, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3221.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 259475662, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10068.904229724485, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 465523, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24924, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 249524379, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 634, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7469537, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 167, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2016223, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 21114036, "stage_ordering_ns": 135980, "stage_eval_ns": 3243082968, "stage_threat_ns": 2285115481, "stage_proof_ns": 95008414, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 291818, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1736810637, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 212498, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 266142239, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1987, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 109897444, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 145905, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 206237497, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7064, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 39021456, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 291810, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36903652, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 330, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3620, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4337.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5337.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 678, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15094, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 140, 82, 125, 95, 124, 114, 138, 152, 66, 97, 67, 113, 111, 128, 81, 51, 155, 170, 83, 130, 146, 129, 127, 84, 70, 99, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 12744, "avg_search_time_ms": 849.6, "search_nodes": 272736, "safety_nodes": 439, "corridor_nodes": 8670, "corridor_branch_probes": 9032, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4922, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 8642, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8642, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4922, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 6, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 698, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 190800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 281845, "avg_nodes": 18789.666666666668, "eval_calls": 264963, "avg_eval_calls": 17664.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 264963, "pattern_eval_ns": 5342694, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.163924774402464, "pattern_frame_queries": 264963, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5342694, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.163924774402464, "pattern_frame_updates": 545386, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6464288152, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11852.68443267704, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7745, "avg_candidate_generations": 516.3333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 709845, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.65203357004519, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1170, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 7730, "search_candidate_moves_total": 708675, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 252707, "avg_legality_checks": 16847.133333333335, "illegal_moves_skipped": 977, "root_legality_checks": 1170, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 251537, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 974, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2968642, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 197909.46666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6427143073, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2165.0111643640425, "renju_forbidden_checks": 61257, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4083.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 299732762, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4893.036910067421, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2488333, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 55498, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 273217236, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1223, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10235766, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3419, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13791427, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 17912, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1194.1333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 159409762, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8899.607079053148, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23587, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1572.4666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 76097984, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3226.268028999025, "stage_move_gen_ns": 577418204, "stage_ordering_ns": 281873, "stage_eval_ns": 6469630846, "stage_threat_ns": 4846061281, "stage_proof_ns": 801130584, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 562869, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3096293424, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 376953, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1196883003, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 3820, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 237492820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 281427, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 374787952, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 17468, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 112928863, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 562854, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65168039, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 787, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6573, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6348.866666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6882.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1709, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2335, "avg_search_time_ms": 166.78571428571428, "search_nodes": 169964, "safety_nodes": 1566, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 171530, "avg_nodes": 12252.142857142857, "eval_calls": 165849, "avg_eval_calls": 11846.357142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 165849, "line_shape_eval_ns": 152925663, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 922.0776911527956, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4088, "avg_candidate_generations": 292.0, "candidate_moves_total": 314518, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.93688845401174, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1099, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 4074, "search_candidate_moves_total": 313419, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 6935, "avg_legality_checks": 495.35714285714283, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6935, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23304, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1664.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 50415153, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2163.369078269825, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5714285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 24700, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1122.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6900, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 17800, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19933781, "stage_ordering_ns": 124980, "stage_eval_ns": 152925663, "stage_threat_ns": 2147840934, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 339860, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1893501081, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 403513, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14550, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 169923, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 212678989, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 339846, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41257351, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 145, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3786, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6345.214285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6916.642857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1965, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 679, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9033, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 97, 82, 113, 114, 142, 157, 66, 96, 68, 146, 130, 124, 138, 141, 81, 129, 65, 49, 67, 69, 64 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3167, "avg_search_time_ms": 287.90909090909093, "search_nodes": 197577, "safety_nodes": 621, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 198198, "avg_nodes": 18018.0, "eval_calls": 192799, "avg_eval_calls": 17527.18181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 192799, "line_shape_eval_ns": 159843666, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 829.0689578265448, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4758, "avg_candidate_generations": 432.54545454545456, "candidate_moves_total": 369556, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.67044976881043, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 829, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 4747, "search_candidate_moves_total": 368727, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 191072, "avg_legality_checks": 17370.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 447, "root_legality_checks": 829, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 190243, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 442, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 204160, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18560.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 493025450, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2414.8973844043885, "renju_forbidden_checks": 471, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 42.81818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5104673, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10837.946921443736, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 451, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4869760, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 234913, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.3636363636363638, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 297891, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11457.346153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.4545454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 162350, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4272.368421052632, "stage_move_gen_ns": 483901474, "stage_ordering_ns": 139700, "stage_eval_ns": 159843666, "stage_threat_ns": 2504280493, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 395103, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2204401583, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 414073, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197546, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 251692087, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 395092, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47772750, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 387, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4216, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5586.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6314.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1911, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5855, "avg_search_time_ms": 585.5, "search_nodes": 169291, "safety_nodes": 520, "corridor_nodes": 200, "corridor_branch_probes": 217, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 12, "corridor_neutral_exits": 38, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 186, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 181, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 70, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 38, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 70, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 552, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 152640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 170011, "avg_nodes": 17001.1, "eval_calls": 164848, "avg_eval_calls": 16484.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 164848, "pattern_eval_ns": 3307796, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.065733281568477, "pattern_frame_queries": 164848, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3307796, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.065733281568477, "pattern_frame_updates": 338524, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3492487708, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10316.809762380215, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4424, "avg_candidate_generations": 442.4, "candidate_moves_total": 381644, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.26672694394213, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 746, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 4414, "search_candidate_moves_total": 380898, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 12223, "avg_legality_checks": 1222.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 247, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 12223, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 247, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 851440, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 85144.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1987585499, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2334.3811648501364, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47133, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4713.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 460141729, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9762.623406106126, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 247, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2645091, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 46718, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 455540456, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 43, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 513645, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 125, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1442537, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 125340, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8952.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 59760, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3145.2631578947367, "stage_move_gen_ns": 34501718, "stage_ordering_ns": 158352, "stage_eval_ns": 3495795504, "stage_threat_ns": 2177360856, "stage_proof_ns": 122991898, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 339046, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1881307659, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 20412, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 30993854, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 440, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17255752, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 169518, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 223000265, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 512, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2294989, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 339036, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39764089, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 328, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3923, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5587.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6387.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 680, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7797, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 99, 128, 80, 130, 129, 144, 160, 172, 157, 158, 116, 186 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7493, "avg_search_time_ms": 936.625, "search_nodes": 168387, "safety_nodes": 79, "corridor_nodes": 1878, "corridor_branch_probes": 2034, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 856, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1864, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1864, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 67, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 856, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 67, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 63, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 547, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 151920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 19, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 16, "total_nodes": 170344, "avg_nodes": 21293.0, "eval_calls": 164342, "avg_eval_calls": 20542.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 164342, "pattern_eval_ns": 3297493, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.064822139197528, "pattern_frame_queries": 164342, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3297493, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.064822139197528, "pattern_frame_updates": 336730, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4142123279, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12301.022418554925, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4031, "avg_candidate_generations": 503.875, "candidate_moves_total": 274515, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.10096750186058, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 496, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 4023, "search_candidate_moves_total": 274019, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 161039, "avg_legality_checks": 20129.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 118, "root_legality_checks": 496, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 160543, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 117, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1411534, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 176441.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3332108804, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2360.629502371179, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20301, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2537.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 201480140, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9924.641150682233, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 123, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1144064, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19749, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 196844127, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 129, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1599727, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 300, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1892222, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 604.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 48646159, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10065.416718394372, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 854.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 26319932, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3851.8852626957414, "stage_move_gen_ns": 407063671, "stage_ordering_ns": 136331, "stage_eval_ns": 4145420772, "stage_threat_ns": 2615899171, "stage_proof_ns": 312406104, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 340600, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1984596092, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 107334, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 334699075, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1114, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 67542342, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 170296, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 234845845, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3862, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19979620, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 340592, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41778539, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 416, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3407, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2734.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3734.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 599, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 296, "avg_search_time_ms": 42.285714285714285, "search_nodes": 20418, "safety_nodes": 546, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 20964, "avg_nodes": 2994.8571428571427, "eval_calls": 19415, "avg_eval_calls": 2773.5714285714284, "line_shape_eval_calls": 19415, "line_shape_eval_ns": 14531297, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 748.457223796034, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 990, "avg_candidate_generations": 141.42857142857142, "candidate_moves_total": 65261, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.92020202020203, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 434, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 983, "search_candidate_moves_total": 64827, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 2222, "avg_legality_checks": 317.42857142857144, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2222, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10375, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1482.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22201199, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2139.8746024096386, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.7142857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60800, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12160.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12590, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 48210, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6255302, "stage_ordering_ns": 31400, "stage_eval_ns": 14531297, "stage_threat_ns": 267152139, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 40803, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 235771584, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 121040, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7210, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 20398, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 26296696, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 40796, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4962819, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 62, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 886, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5057.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6199.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 681, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23592, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 126, 98, 109, 108, 83, 66, 114, 94, 80, 50, 34, 158, 143, 122, 127, 95, 97, 125, 96, 141, 124, 157, 140, 159, 138, 152, 154, 168, 139, 169, 64, 48, 55, 69, 156, 136, 150, 184, 120, 200 ], "move_count": 46, "black_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 8238, "avg_search_time_ms": 392.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 537580, "safety_nodes": 2078, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 539658, "avg_nodes": 25698.0, "eval_calls": 526735, "avg_eval_calls": 25082.619047619046, "line_shape_eval_calls": 526735, "line_shape_eval_ns": 783173712, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1486.8457801361217, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10804, "avg_candidate_generations": 514.4761904761905, "candidate_moves_total": 1005533, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.0704368752314, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1806, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 10783, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1003727, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 509366, "avg_legality_checks": 24255.52380952381, "illegal_moves_skipped": 704, "root_legality_checks": 1806, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 507560, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 700, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 533407, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 25400.333333333332, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1159754451, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2174.2392788246125, "renju_forbidden_checks": 930, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 44.285714285714285, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10109879, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10870.837634408603, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 914, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9934408, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 175471, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 70, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.3333333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 602953, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8613.614285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.380952380952381, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 267651, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2909.25, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1155687448, "stage_ordering_ns": 335341, "stage_eval_ns": 783173712, "stage_threat_ns": 6236490629, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1075057, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5453111617, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 939114, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 21240, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 537518, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 661958052, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1075036, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 120481846, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 615, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9852, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 2.9523809523809526, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9523809523809526, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.047619047619047616, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6847.619047619048, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7228.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1891, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 15332, "avg_search_time_ms": 730.0952380952381, "search_nodes": 584229, "safety_nodes": 1325, "corridor_nodes": 1235, "corridor_branch_probes": 1369, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 423, "corridor_neutral_exits": 31, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 1207, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1207, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 19, "corridor_proof_completed": 19, "corridor_proof_checks": 135, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 107, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 33, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 423, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 135, "corridor_proof_wins": 6, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 129, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 998, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 296000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 586789, "avg_nodes": 27942.333333333332, "eval_calls": 573264, "avg_eval_calls": 27298.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 573264, "pattern_eval_ns": 11497310, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.055873035808983, "pattern_frame_queries": 573264, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11497310, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.055873035808983, "pattern_frame_updates": 1168336, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8028571887, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6871.80048119719, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10925, "avg_candidate_generations": 520.2380952380952, "candidate_moves_total": 1029405, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.22471395881007, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1829, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 10904, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1027576, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 25715, "avg_legality_checks": 1224.5238095238096, "illegal_moves_skipped": 75, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 25715, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2117493, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 100833.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4444171469, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2098.7892139430924, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41720, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1986.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 359634141, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8620.18554650048, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 78, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 747214, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 41486, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 357187737, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 231040, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 135, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1468150, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 62029246, "stage_ordering_ns": 373473, "stage_eval_ns": 8040069197, "stage_threat_ns": 6919501020, "stage_proof_ns": 216847782, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1171041, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5955571710, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 80143, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 92473948, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1226, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 41081990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 585510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 726622298, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2684, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14313658, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1171020, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 130519406, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 787, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9731, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.047619047619047616, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09523809523809523, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.047619047619047616, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6736.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7117.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1936, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 682, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6180, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 143, 126, 84, 156, 141, 140, 154, 108, 109, 124, 92, 172 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5655, "avg_search_time_ms": 706.875, "search_nodes": 129435, "safety_nodes": 82, "corridor_nodes": 1605, "corridor_branch_probes": 1780, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 721, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1590, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1590, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 721, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 57, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 466, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 156320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 13, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 10, "total_nodes": 131122, "avg_nodes": 16390.25, "eval_calls": 125609, "avg_eval_calls": 15701.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 125609, "pattern_eval_ns": 2522768, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.08429332293068, "pattern_frame_queries": 125609, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2522768, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.08429332293068, "pattern_frame_updates": 258826, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3060301594, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11823.779658921438, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3812, "avg_candidate_generations": 476.5, "candidate_moves_total": 258563, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.82869884575027, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 499, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 3804, "search_candidate_moves_total": 258064, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 119790, "avg_legality_checks": 14973.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 55, "root_legality_checks": 499, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 119291, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1119935, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 139991.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2557881738, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2283.9555313478013, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15584, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1948.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 139995263, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8983.268929671458, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 529433, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15154, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 136618420, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 111, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1307145, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 259, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1540265, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4102, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 512.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 40782058, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9941.993661628474, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5788, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 723.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 21826199, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3770.9397028334483, "stage_move_gen_ns": 295795772, "stage_ordering_ns": 128231, "stage_eval_ns": 3062824362, "stage_threat_ns": 2006360583, "stage_proof_ns": 272845081, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 262136, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1499903367, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 92879, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 284293056, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 958, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 57602425, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 131064, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 173134397, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3302, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17349686, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 262128, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31680077, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 416, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3216, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3735.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4735.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1729, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 518, "avg_search_time_ms": 74.0, "search_nodes": 36706, "safety_nodes": 546, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 37252, "avg_nodes": 5321.714285714285, "eval_calls": 35420, "avg_eval_calls": 5060.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 35420, "line_shape_eval_ns": 26778714, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 756.0337097684924, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1273, "avg_candidate_generations": 181.85714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 83467, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.56716417910448, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 434, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 1266, "search_candidate_moves_total": 83033, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 2790, "avg_legality_checks": 398.57142857142856, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2790, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10943, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1563.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23566698, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2153.586585031527, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.7142857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 56280, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11256.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10920, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 45360, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7778528, "stage_ordering_ns": 39631, "stage_eval_ns": 26778714, "stage_threat_ns": 475653896, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 73379, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 419333815, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 121531, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 36686, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 47250847, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 73372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8947703, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 62, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1157, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4997.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6140.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1965, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 683, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10622, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 96, 128, 67, 52, 129, 100, 142, 68, 84, 86, 72, 124, 125, 36, 111, 83, 81, 4, 20, 113, 98, 99, 95, 94, 109, 53, 123 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 2206, "avg_search_time_ms": 147.06666666666666, "search_nodes": 142665, "safety_nodes": 1303, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 143968, "avg_nodes": 9597.866666666667, "eval_calls": 139396, "avg_eval_calls": 9293.066666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 139396, "line_shape_eval_ns": 197778608, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1418.8255617090879, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3241, "avg_candidate_generations": 216.06666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 293561, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.57729095958038, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1172, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 3226, "search_candidate_moves_total": 292389, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 137026, "avg_legality_checks": 9135.066666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1224, "root_legality_checks": 1172, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 135854, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1217, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 154507, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10300.466666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 331515103, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2145.6316089238676, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1459, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 97.26666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 17016552, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11663.161069225496, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1429, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16690180, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 326372, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 573584, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9889.379310344828, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 82, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.466666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 280303, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3418.329268292683, "stage_move_gen_ns": 322331670, "stage_ordering_ns": 103610, "stage_eval_ns": 197778608, "stage_threat_ns": 1659768886, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 285259, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1454581699, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 780344, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 142622, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 172865633, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 285244, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31541210, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 319, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2801, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6619.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7152.933333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1914, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 8399, "avg_search_time_ms": 599.9285714285714, "search_nodes": 251610, "safety_nodes": 1095, "corridor_nodes": 879, "corridor_branch_probes": 1077, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 299, "corridor_neutral_exits": 34, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 859, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 859, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 101, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 81, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 299, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 101, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 732, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 321360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 28720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 253584, "avg_nodes": 18113.14285714286, "eval_calls": 245038, "avg_eval_calls": 17502.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 245038, "pattern_eval_ns": 4883944, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.931373909352835, "pattern_frame_queries": 245038, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4883944, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.931373909352835, "pattern_frame_updates": 503138, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4967207831, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9872.456127344783, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6545, "avg_candidate_generations": 467.5, "candidate_moves_total": 541759, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.77448433919022, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1092, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 6531, "search_candidate_moves_total": 540667, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 17732, "avg_legality_checks": 1266.5714285714287, "illegal_moves_skipped": 149, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 17732, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 149, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1390313, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 99308.07142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3143965799, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2261.3366910904233, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40492, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2892.285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 422499963, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10434.15892028055, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 152, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1694365, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 40103, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 418115566, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 405730, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 195, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2284302, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 45304931, "stage_ordering_ns": 208150, "stage_eval_ns": 4972091775, "stage_threat_ns": 3170148963, "stage_proof_ns": 167488282, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 505072, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2710216431, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59999, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 76507577, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 858, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 33218914, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 252529, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 315745394, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1920, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10057823, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 505058, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57621738, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 405, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5845, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6021.642857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6593.071428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1925, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 684, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6825, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 128, 125, 96, 80, 95, 94, 52, 67, 68, 110, 98, 99, 54, 40, 144, 160, 83, 113, 53, 38, 55, 56, 51 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 5902, "avg_search_time_ms": 454.0, "search_nodes": 114175, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 4556, "corridor_branch_probes": 4887, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2171, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 4528, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4528, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 109, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 81, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2171, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 109, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 857, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 310640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 119780, "avg_nodes": 9213.846153846154, "eval_calls": 110451, "avg_eval_calls": 8496.23076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110451, "pattern_eval_ns": 2227301, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.165512308625544, "pattern_frame_queries": 110451, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2227301, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.165512308625544, "pattern_frame_updates": 228276, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2635387690, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11544.742723720408, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3700, "avg_candidate_generations": 284.61538461538464, "candidate_moves_total": 276742, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.79513513513514, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3687, "search_candidate_moves_total": 275828, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 102978, "avg_legality_checks": 7921.384615384615, "illegal_moves_skipped": 173, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 102064, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 170, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1435234, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 110402.61538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3034729469, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2114.4492598419492, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19064, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1466.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_ns": 130832375, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6862.797681493916, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 273, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2449227, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17287, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 120649822, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 202, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2301928, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1302, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5431398, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10161, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 781.6153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 96561042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9503.104222025391, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14034, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1079.5384615384614, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 49617853, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3535.5460310674075, "stage_move_gen_ns": 239332666, "stage_ordering_ns": 125101, "stage_eval_ns": 2637614991, "stage_threat_ns": 2373063464, "stage_proof_ns": 624593816, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 237563, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1365313752, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 246432, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 767238465, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2527, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 156276927, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 118775, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159241085, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9274, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 53061866, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 237550, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28208296, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3186, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6199.307692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6814.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1826, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 912, "avg_search_time_ms": 76.0, "search_nodes": 66929, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67941, "avg_nodes": 5661.75, "eval_calls": 64457, "avg_eval_calls": 5371.416666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 64457, "line_shape_eval_ns": 58862971, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 913.2130102238701, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2449, "avg_candidate_generations": 204.08333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 170857, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.76602694977542, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 2437, "search_candidate_moves_total": 170017, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3825, "avg_legality_checks": 318.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3825, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17731, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1477.5833333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 37371591, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2107.6978737803847, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.0833333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 251180, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10047.2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 71630, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 179550, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10924347, "stage_ordering_ns": 73590, "stage_eval_ns": 58862971, "stage_threat_ns": 826340799, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 133800, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 727619662, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 186493, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13011, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66894, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 82960469, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 133788, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15574175, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2216, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6216.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6882.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 685, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4221, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 97, 82, 114, 115, 68, 126, 94, 125, 83, 124, 138, 123, 127, 122 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1250, "avg_search_time_ms": 156.25, "search_nodes": 78641, "safety_nodes": 505, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 79146, "avg_nodes": 9893.25, "eval_calls": 76168, "avg_eval_calls": 9521.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 76168, "line_shape_eval_ns": 54156636, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 711.0155971011449, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2458, "avg_candidate_generations": 307.25, "candidate_moves_total": 164695, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.00366151342556, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 498, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 2450, "search_candidate_moves_total": 164197, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 71665, "avg_legality_checks": 8958.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 125, "root_legality_checks": 498, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 71167, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 124, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 81128, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10141.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 192670949, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2374.900761759195, "renju_forbidden_checks": 129, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 16.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1350333, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10467.697674418605, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1300713, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 49620, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 295631, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11370.423076923076, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 37, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 159451, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4309.486486486487, "stage_move_gen_ns": 179594627, "stage_ordering_ns": 75811, "stage_eval_ns": 54156636, "stage_threat_ns": 1005986401, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 157244, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 885820511, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 407733, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8210, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78618, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 100821870, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 157236, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18936287, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 175, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2191, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5162.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6162.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1901, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 2965, "avg_search_time_ms": 370.625, "search_nodes": 91497, "safety_nodes": 517, "corridor_nodes": 238, "corridor_branch_probes": 265, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 36, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 226, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 226, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 53, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 41, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 53, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 414, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 153040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 92252, "avg_nodes": 11531.5, "eval_calls": 89226, "avg_eval_calls": 11153.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89226, "pattern_eval_ns": 1777676, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.92329590029812, "pattern_frame_queries": 89226, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1777676, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.92329590029812, "pattern_frame_updates": 182950, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1643967851, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8985.886039901612, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2257, "avg_candidate_generations": 282.125, "candidate_moves_total": 171529, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.99867080194949, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 518, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 2249, "search_candidate_moves_total": 171011, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 5381, "avg_legality_checks": 672.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5381, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 436787, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 54598.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 986189695, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2257.8274879975825, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11446, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1430.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 106160407, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9274.891403110258, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 133543, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11310, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 104637152, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 545941, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 843771, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14055378, "stage_ordering_ns": 74250, "stage_eval_ns": 1645745527, "stage_threat_ns": 1198539987, "stage_proof_ns": 91399918, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 183516, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1024451426, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21529, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 30389492, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 374, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15797798, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91754, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 119449500, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 558, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2529849, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 183508, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21719720, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 206, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1947, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5241.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6241.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1955, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 686, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8207, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 114, 111, 126, 81, 98, 84, 83, 68, 116, 115, 130, 82, 128, 143, 146, 162, 140, 154, 129, 127, 131, 132, 161, 176, 101 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7852, "avg_search_time_ms": 604.0, "search_nodes": 156217, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 6430, "corridor_branch_probes": 6841, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2995, "corridor_neutral_exits": 34, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 6387, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6387, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 109, "corridor_proof_active": 43, "corridor_proof_quiet": 66, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2995, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 109, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 857, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 365040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 163696, "avg_nodes": 12592.0, "eval_calls": 151686, "avg_eval_calls": 11668.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 151686, "pattern_eval_ns": 3019641, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.907183260155847, "pattern_frame_queries": 151686, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3019641, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.907183260155847, "pattern_frame_updates": 312360, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3394766223, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10868.120831732616, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4507, "avg_candidate_generations": 346.6923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 328814, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.95629021522076, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4494, "search_candidate_moves_total": 327900, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 148636, "avg_legality_checks": 11433.538461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 147722, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 81, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1865100, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 143469.23076923078, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3931740847, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2108.0590032706023, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18711, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1439.3076923076924, "renju_forbidden_ns": 135081072, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7219.340067340067, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 98, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 845543, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17019, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 126258567, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 221, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2469258, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1373, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5507704, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13863, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1066.3846153846155, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 131537266, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9488.369472697108, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18999, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1461.4615384615386, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 67740002, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3565.450918469393, "stage_move_gen_ns": 347680599, "stage_ordering_ns": 144201, "stage_eval_ns": 3397785864, "stage_threat_ns": 3263177057, "stage_proof_ns": 818553165, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 325365, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1842257357, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 356187, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1096465708, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 3419, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 218644837, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 162676, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 216725156, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12992, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 69371284, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 325352, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38357552, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3926, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5559.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6174.538461538462, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1752, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 344, "avg_search_time_ms": 28.666666666666668, "search_nodes": 23229, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 24241, "avg_nodes": 2020.0833333333333, "eval_calls": 21748, "avg_eval_calls": 1812.3333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 21748, "line_shape_eval_ns": 19933664, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 916.5745815707191, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1458, "avg_candidate_generations": 121.5, "candidate_moves_total": 106274, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.89026063100137, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 1446, "search_candidate_moves_total": 105434, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3433, "avg_legality_checks": 286.0833333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3433, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17339, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1444.9166666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 35964358, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2074.1887075379204, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 263110, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10119.615384615385, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 86050, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 177060, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9326993, "stage_ordering_ns": 44240, "stage_eval_ns": 19933664, "stage_threat_ns": 298246908, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 46400, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 263728558, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 185510, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12730, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 23194, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 28970000, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 46388, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5362840, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1321, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6291.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6958.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 687, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9120, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 111, 110, 142, 157, 68, 98, 66, 138, 124, 130, 146, 143, 83, 125, 69, 55, 67, 65, 70 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3206, "avg_search_time_ms": 291.45454545454544, "search_nodes": 200083, "safety_nodes": 621, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 200704, "avg_nodes": 18245.81818181818, "eval_calls": 195100, "avg_eval_calls": 17736.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 195100, "line_shape_eval_ns": 170166492, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 872.2013941568426, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4963, "avg_candidate_generations": 451.1818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 394318, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.45154140640742, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 829, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 4952, "search_candidate_moves_total": 393489, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 193386, "avg_legality_checks": 17580.545454545456, "illegal_moves_skipped": 583, "root_legality_checks": 829, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 192557, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 578, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 206474, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18770.363636363636, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 492757865, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2386.537118474965, "renju_forbidden_checks": 607, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 55.18181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6615283, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10898.324546952224, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 587, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6391163, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 224120, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.3636363636363638, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 299783, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11530.115384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.4545454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 163811, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4310.815789473684, "stage_move_gen_ns": 485228338, "stage_ordering_ns": 142731, "stage_eval_ns": 170166492, "stage_threat_ns": 2535709567, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 400115, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2230116068, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 414383, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 200052, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 256581864, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 400104, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48597252, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 387, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4409, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5635.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6362.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1915, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5904, "avg_search_time_ms": 590.4, "search_nodes": 169957, "safety_nodes": 520, "corridor_nodes": 194, "corridor_branch_probes": 212, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 12, "corridor_neutral_exits": 36, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 181, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 176, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 70, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 70, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 552, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 143120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 170671, "avg_nodes": 17067.1, "eval_calls": 165697, "avg_eval_calls": 16569.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 165697, "pattern_eval_ns": 3348340, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.207607862544283, "pattern_frame_queries": 165697, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3348340, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.207607862544283, "pattern_frame_updates": 339856, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3520155364, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10357.784955981357, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4241, "avg_candidate_generations": 424.1, "candidate_moves_total": 364141, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.8620608347088, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 746, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 4231, "search_candidate_moves_total": 363395, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 11990, "avg_legality_checks": 1199.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 83, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11990, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 83, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 878098, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 87809.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2030613649, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2312.513693232418, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47315, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4731.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 446897441, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9445.153566522244, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 83, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 912123, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 47063, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 444116021, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 488361, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 125, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1380936, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 127270, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9090.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 62270, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3277.3684210526317, "stage_move_gen_ns": 31917866, "stage_ordering_ns": 139851, "stage_eval_ns": 3523503704, "stage_threat_ns": 2203326525, "stage_proof_ns": 123536423, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 340368, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1905383770, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19784, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 30303208, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 436, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16801306, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 170179, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 224950065, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 502, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2217700, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 340358, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40471782, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 319, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3722, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5581.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6381.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 688, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8086, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 142, 97, 98, 95, 126, 84, 124, 125, 140, 154, 172, 157, 156, 108, 188 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7773, "avg_search_time_ms": 971.625, "search_nodes": 175829, "safety_nodes": 79, "corridor_nodes": 1911, "corridor_branch_probes": 2067, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 889, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1897, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1897, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 52, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 889, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 62, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 531, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 150880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 18, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 15, "total_nodes": 177819, "avg_nodes": 22227.375, "eval_calls": 171633, "avg_eval_calls": 21454.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 171633, "pattern_eval_ns": 3463270, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.17834565613839, "pattern_frame_queries": 171633, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3463270, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.17834565613839, "pattern_frame_updates": 351614, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4300236942, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12229.993521304612, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4182, "avg_candidate_generations": 522.75, "candidate_moves_total": 285998, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.38785270205643, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 496, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 4174, "search_candidate_moves_total": 285502, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 168377, "avg_legality_checks": 21047.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 133, "root_legality_checks": 496, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 167881, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 132, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1458031, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 182253.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3445283114, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2362.9697269811136, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21174, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2646.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 206827148, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9767.977141777652, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 138, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1262096, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20589, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 201701128, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 147, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1790215, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 300, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2073709, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4865, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 608.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 49550516, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10185.100924974306, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6855, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 856.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 26789465, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3908.018234865062, "stage_move_gen_ns": 426211374, "stage_ordering_ns": 137391, "stage_eval_ns": 4303700212, "stage_threat_ns": 2717345658, "stage_proof_ns": 313804769, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 355548, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2072848991, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 107310, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 337158144, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1110, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 68904394, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 177770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 242382874, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3926, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20995575, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 355540, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43960074, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 416, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3536, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2593.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3593.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 732, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 305, "avg_search_time_ms": 43.57142857142857, "search_nodes": 20784, "safety_nodes": 546, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 21330, "avg_nodes": 3047.1428571428573, "eval_calls": 19755, "avg_eval_calls": 2822.1428571428573, "line_shape_eval_calls": 19755, "line_shape_eval_ns": 14857289, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 752.0773981270564, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1016, "avg_candidate_generations": 145.14285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 67000, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.94488188976378, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 434, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 1009, "search_candidate_moves_total": 66566, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 2384, "avg_legality_checks": 340.57142857142856, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2384, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10537, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1505.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22736950, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2157.820062636424, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.7142857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 53930, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10786.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11030, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 42900, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6663755, "stage_ordering_ns": 31640, "stage_eval_ns": 14857289, "stage_threat_ns": 274393728, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 41535, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 241985771, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 121813, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 20764, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 27225408, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 41528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5060736, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 62, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 908, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5052.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6195.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 689, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10636, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 98, 126, 67, 52, 125, 94, 142, 66, 80, 78, 62, 130, 129, 38, 113, 81, 83, 10, 24, 111, 96, 95, 99, 100, 115, 51, 131 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 2445, "avg_search_time_ms": 163.0, "search_nodes": 158123, "safety_nodes": 1303, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 159426, "avg_nodes": 10628.4, "eval_calls": 154591, "avg_eval_calls": 10306.066666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 154591, "line_shape_eval_ns": 222169225, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1437.1420393166484, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3504, "avg_candidate_generations": 233.6, "candidate_moves_total": 318412, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.87100456621005, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1172, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 3489, "search_candidate_moves_total": 317240, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 151635, "avg_legality_checks": 10109.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1120, "root_legality_checks": 1172, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 150463, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1113, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 169116, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11274.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 361915261, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2140.0415158825895, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1286, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 85.73333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14046909, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10922.946345256609, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1256, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13741278, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 305631, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 572641, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9873.120689655172, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 82, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.466666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 278410, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3395.243902439024, "stage_move_gen_ns": 350569918, "stage_ordering_ns": 112170, "stage_eval_ns": 222169225, "stage_threat_ns": 1843260178, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 316175, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1612428643, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 778843, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15120, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 158080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 194786790, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 316160, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35265902, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 319, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3035, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6619.066666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7152.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1912, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 8178, "avg_search_time_ms": 584.1428571428571, "search_nodes": 248236, "safety_nodes": 1095, "corridor_nodes": 780, "corridor_branch_probes": 979, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 228, "corridor_neutral_exits": 44, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 757, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 757, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 101, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 78, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 46, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 228, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 101, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 732, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 334720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 28720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 250111, "avg_nodes": 17865.071428571428, "eval_calls": 241728, "avg_eval_calls": 17266.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 241728, "pattern_eval_ns": 4881472, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.194069367222664, "pattern_frame_queries": 241728, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4881472, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.194069367222664, "pattern_frame_updates": 496390, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4787992016, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9645.62544773263, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6481, "avg_candidate_generations": 462.92857142857144, "candidate_moves_total": 535806, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.67335287764234, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1092, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 6467, "search_candidate_moves_total": 534714, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 17709, "avg_legality_checks": 1264.9285714285713, "illegal_moves_skipped": 200, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 17709, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 200, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1344991, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 96070.78571428571, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3033964144, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2255.7505172897067, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37831, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2702.214285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 377041008, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9966.456292458566, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 201, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2073549, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37399, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 372480370, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 36, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 330470, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 195, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2156619, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 45291454, "stage_ordering_ns": 211243, "stage_eval_ns": 4792873488, "stage_threat_ns": 3126218395, "stage_proof_ns": 169223634, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 498120, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2676933902, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 56801, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 70440126, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 826, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 30010410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 249053, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 312070412, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1716, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9331453, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 498106, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57442502, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 406, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5836, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6045.785714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6617.214285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1922, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 690, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4404, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 126, 129, 98, 84, 99, 96, 130, 114, 83, 100, 67, 52, 115, 51, 131 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 3605, "avg_search_time_ms": 400.55555555555554, "search_nodes": 68125, "safety_nodes": 313, "corridor_nodes": 2265, "corridor_branch_probes": 2404, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 841, "corridor_neutral_exits": 36, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 2246, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2246, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 98, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 79, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 841, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 98, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 96, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 818, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 276240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 70703, "avg_nodes": 7855.888888888889, "eval_calls": 65117, "avg_eval_calls": 7235.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 65117, "pattern_eval_ns": 1317878, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.238616643887156, "pattern_frame_queries": 65117, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1317878, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.238616643887156, "pattern_frame_updates": 136200, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1596341254, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11720.567209985316, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2992, "avg_candidate_generations": 332.44444444444446, "candidate_moves_total": 199947, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.82720588235294, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 513, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 2983, "search_candidate_moves_total": 199434, "search_candidate_moves_max": 86, "legality_checks": 59726, "avg_legality_checks": 6636.222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 513, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 59213, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 857679, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 95297.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1864126761, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2173.4550583609953, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6271, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 696.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44667578, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7122.879604528784, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 170600, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6126, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43315934, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 55, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 623973, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 71, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 557071, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4189, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 465.44444444444446, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 38903982, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9287.176414418716, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5712, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 634.6666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 19611213, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3433.3356092436975, "stage_move_gen_ns": 144795855, "stage_ordering_ns": 102622, "stage_eval_ns": 1597659132, "stage_threat_ns": 1405338288, "stage_proof_ns": 442046121, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 140897, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 821969679, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 149015, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 446698942, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1700, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 97961884, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70444, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 95813399, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4688, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 23637438, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 140888, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17218830, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 336, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2538, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5377.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6266.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1783, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 790, "avg_search_time_ms": 98.75, "search_nodes": 57585, "safety_nodes": 558, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 58143, "avg_nodes": 7267.875, "eval_calls": 55300, "avg_eval_calls": 6912.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 55300, "line_shape_eval_ns": 44328745, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 801.6047920433996, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2270, "avg_candidate_generations": 283.75, "candidate_moves_total": 145622, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.15066079295154, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 455, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 2262, "search_candidate_moves_total": 145167, "search_candidate_moves_max": 83, "legality_checks": 3941, "avg_legality_checks": 492.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3941, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13138, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1642.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28707161, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2185.0480286192724, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11064140, "stage_ordering_ns": 68581, "stage_eval_ns": 44328745, "stage_threat_ns": 727482422, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 115132, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 640098881, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 168050, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57562, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73254647, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 115124, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13960844, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 121, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1977, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5308.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6308.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1972, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 691, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18869, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 127, 142, 114, 115, 94, 96, 68, 124, 138, 174, 158, 125, 95, 143, 83, 98, 99, 141, 79, 63, 144, 129, 85, 71, 157, 140, 139, 156, 172, 170, 155, 184, 128, 198 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 4802, "avg_search_time_ms": 266.77777777777777, "search_nodes": 305503, "safety_nodes": 1806, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 307309, "avg_nodes": 17072.722222222223, "eval_calls": 297090, "avg_eval_calls": 16505.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 297090, "line_shape_eval_ns": 374085862, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1259.1667912080513, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8378, "avg_candidate_generations": 465.44444444444446, "candidate_moves_total": 763962, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.18667939842445, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1521, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 8360, "search_candidate_moves_total": 762441, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 287990, "avg_legality_checks": 15999.444444444445, "illegal_moves_skipped": 256, "root_legality_checks": 1521, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 286469, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 255, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 309284, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17182.444444444445, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 711003281, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2298.8686158999494, "renju_forbidden_checks": 260, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 14.444444444444445, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2337172, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8989.123076923077, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 256, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2295512, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 41660, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.2777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 648882, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10998.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 88, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.888888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 348081, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3955.465909090909, "stage_move_gen_ns": 689435649, "stage_ordering_ns": 257950, "stage_eval_ns": 374085862, "stage_threat_ns": 3710680605, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 610918, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3249841749, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 49, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 940834, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18610, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 305450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 388568576, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 610900, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 71329446, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 396, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7584, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6687.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7132.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1892, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 14051, "avg_search_time_ms": 780.6111111111111, "search_nodes": 449249, "safety_nodes": 1578, "corridor_nodes": 1546, "corridor_branch_probes": 1771, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 24, "corridor_depth_exits": 620, "corridor_neutral_exits": 36, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 1521, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1521, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 87, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 62, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 60, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 620, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 87, "corridor_proof_wins": 6, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 81, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 590, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 225360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 452373, "avg_nodes": 25131.833333333332, "eval_calls": 441079, "avg_eval_calls": 24504.38888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 441079, "pattern_eval_ns": 8884898, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.143552515535767, "pattern_frame_queries": 441079, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 8884898, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.143552515535767, "pattern_frame_updates": 898394, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8149338710, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9071.007497823895, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8136, "avg_candidate_generations": 452.0, "candidate_moves_total": 775850, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.36012782694199, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1543, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 8118, "search_candidate_moves_total": 774307, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 21672, "avg_legality_checks": 1204.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 21672, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2440363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 135575.72222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5311857555, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2176.6669774127868, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9576, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 532.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 89716212, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9368.86090225564, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17300, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9501, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 88904879, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 36, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 389033, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 405000, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 54792965, "stage_ordering_ns": 268122, "stage_eval_ns": 8158223608, "stage_threat_ns": 5645252476, "stage_proof_ns": 138282791, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 901628, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4837604562, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 89001, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 108997443, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1107, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 42711651, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 450805, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 573045348, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3216, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20193618, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 901610, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 105411505, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 557, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7251, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6594.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7039.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1966, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 692, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4786, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 141, 128, 80, 158, 143, 144, 160, 116, 115, 130, 102, 172 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 4464, "avg_search_time_ms": 558.0, "search_nodes": 131766, "safety_nodes": 82, "corridor_nodes": 1836, "corridor_branch_probes": 2018, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 838, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1821, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1821, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 838, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 59, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 489, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 160400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 15, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 12, "total_nodes": 133684, "avg_nodes": 16710.5, "eval_calls": 128013, "avg_eval_calls": 16001.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 128013, "pattern_eval_ns": 2431907, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.997344019747995, "pattern_frame_queries": 128013, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2431907, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.997344019747995, "pattern_frame_updates": 263488, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2447998861, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9290.741365830701, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3739, "avg_candidate_generations": 467.375, "candidate_moves_total": 255128, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.23428724257823, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 499, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 3731, "search_candidate_moves_total": 254629, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 122376, "avg_legality_checks": 15297.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 89, "root_legality_checks": 499, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 121877, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 88, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1151853, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 143981.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1968164648, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1708.694293455849, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15709, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1963.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 118958387, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7572.626328856069, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 94, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 675729, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15205, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 116163760, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 124, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1011994, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 286, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1106904, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4662, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 582.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 29965620, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6427.6319176319175, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6601, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 825.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 16486291, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2497.5444629601575, "stage_move_gen_ns": 234701067, "stage_ordering_ns": 116350, "stage_eval_ns": 2450430768, "stage_threat_ns": 1557077767, "stage_proof_ns": 195556320, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 267264, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1166353066, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 104813, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 206193730, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1069, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 41687860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 133628, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 145853843, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3768, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13191285, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 267256, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25485843, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 416, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3146, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4403.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5403.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1740, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 315, "avg_search_time_ms": 45.0, "search_nodes": 35004, "safety_nodes": 546, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35550, "avg_nodes": 5078.571428571428, "eval_calls": 33726, "avg_eval_calls": 4818.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 33726, "line_shape_eval_ns": 15317019, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 454.16055861946273, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1265, "avg_candidate_generations": 180.71428571428572, "candidate_moves_total": 82901, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.53438735177866, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 434, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 1258, "search_candidate_moves_total": 82467, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 2612, "avg_legality_checks": 373.14285714285717, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2612, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10765, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1537.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17876610, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1660.6233163028332, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.7142857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 58780, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11756.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11580, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 47200, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4945366, "stage_ordering_ns": 34891, "stage_eval_ns": 15317019, "stage_threat_ns": 284052633, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 69975, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 248620926, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 91341, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5981, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34984, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 29705938, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 69968, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5634428, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 62, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1152, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5054.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6197.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1966, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 693, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7058, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 96, 128, 109, 108, 143, 156, 114, 124, 140, 170, 184, 127, 125, 155, 80, 95, 141, 157, 126, 81, 154, 168, 139, 97, 169, 199, 137, 138, 153, 167, 185, 201, 121 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 2628, "avg_search_time_ms": 146.0, "search_nodes": 165391, "safety_nodes": 1892, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 167283, "avg_nodes": 9293.5, "eval_calls": 160499, "avg_eval_calls": 8916.611111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 160499, "line_shape_eval_ns": 217999805, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1358.2626994560715, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4858, "avg_candidate_generations": 269.8888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 378417, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.89563606422396, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1294, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 4840, "search_candidate_moves_total": 377123, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 155867, "avg_legality_checks": 8659.277777777777, "illegal_moves_skipped": 114, "root_legality_checks": 1294, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 154573, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 113, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 176550, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9808.333333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 397709229, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2252.6719286321154, "renju_forbidden_checks": 122, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6.777777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1274474, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10446.508196721312, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 114, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1226964, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 47510, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.222222222222222, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1000934, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8936.910714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.333333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 466081, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3107.2066666666665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 369153836, "stage_ordering_ns": 156114, "stage_eval_ns": 217999805, "stage_threat_ns": 2015857688, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 330696, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1763241855, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 51, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1389697, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17742, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 165339, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 211657433, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 330678, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39568703, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 333, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4333, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6744.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7188.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1900, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 4414, "avg_search_time_ms": 259.6470588235294, "search_nodes": 102035, "safety_nodes": 1189, "corridor_nodes": 12161, "corridor_branch_probes": 12834, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 7262, "corridor_neutral_exits": 28, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 12133, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 12133, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 106, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 78, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 31, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 7262, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 106, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 106, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 751, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 319040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 115385, "avg_nodes": 6787.35294117647, "eval_calls": 97883, "avg_eval_calls": 5757.823529411765, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 97883, "pattern_eval_ns": 1967877, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.10437971864369, "pattern_frame_queries": 97883, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1967877, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.10437971864369, "pattern_frame_updates": 203970, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1977012379, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9692.6625435113, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4119, "avg_candidate_generations": 242.2941176470588, "candidate_moves_total": 327949, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.6185967467832, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1234, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 4102, "search_candidate_moves_total": 326715, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 8082, "avg_legality_checks": 475.4117647058824, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8082, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 721684, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 42452.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1569401965, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2174.638713065552, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9037, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 531.5882352941177, "renju_forbidden_ns": 88984949, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9846.735531703, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 105141, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8804, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 87352365, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 148, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 726170, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 801273, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 21210317, "stage_ordering_ns": 131761, "stage_eval_ns": 1978980256, "stage_threat_ns": 2357978627, "stage_proof_ns": 145566894, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 228465, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1432782499, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 466529, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 579421297, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 5095, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 239858065, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 114224, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 155752981, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 24478, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 162703799, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 228448, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27318051, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 352, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3533, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6687.764705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7158.35294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1955, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 694, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7640, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 83, 96, 80, 81, 66, 108, 109, 124, 82, 126, 141, 138, 152, 144, 160, 125, 127, 123, 122, 153, 168, 93 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7280, "avg_search_time_ms": 560.0, "search_nodes": 157343, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 4296, "corridor_branch_probes": 4618, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1919, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 4261, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4261, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 109, "corridor_proof_active": 35, "corridor_proof_quiet": 74, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1919, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 109, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 857, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 281760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 162688, "avg_nodes": 12514.461538461539, "eval_calls": 152809, "avg_eval_calls": 11754.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 152809, "pattern_eval_ns": 3044256, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.921967946914123, "pattern_frame_queries": 152809, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3044256, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.921967946914123, "pattern_frame_updates": 314612, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3426202869, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10890.248525167508, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4510, "avg_candidate_generations": 346.9230769230769, "candidate_moves_total": 329655, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.09423503325942, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4497, "search_candidate_moves_total": 328741, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 149572, "avg_legality_checks": 11505.538461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 87, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 148658, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1662826, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 127909.69230769231, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3532948423, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2124.6651321304817, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19446, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1495.8461538461538, "renju_forbidden_ns": 139056492, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7150.904659055847, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 101, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 897477, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18279, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 131543310, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 178, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2007589, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 888, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4608116, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9644, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 741.8461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 94794399, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9829.365304852758, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13511, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1039.3076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 50303398, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3723.1439567759603, "stage_move_gen_ns": 344604731, "stage_ordering_ns": 149391, "stage_eval_ns": 3429247125, "stage_threat_ns": 2853527373, "stage_proof_ns": 624238991, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 323365, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1788029266, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 246307, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 768630292, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2466, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 158103301, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 161676, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 210946748, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8740, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 48557530, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 323352, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37363537, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3917, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5775.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6390.615384615385, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1804, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 344, "avg_search_time_ms": 28.666666666666668, "search_nodes": 24281, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 25293, "avg_nodes": 2107.75, "eval_calls": 22792, "avg_eval_calls": 1899.3333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 22792, "line_shape_eval_ns": 19997654, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 877.3979466479467, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1466, "avg_candidate_generations": 122.16666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 106699, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.78240109140519, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 1454, "search_candidate_moves_total": 105859, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3436, "avg_legality_checks": 286.3333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3436, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17342, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1445.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 35061252, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2021.7536616307232, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 250550, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9636.538461538461, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 80070, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 170480, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9246942, "stage_ordering_ns": 46041, "stage_eval_ns": 19997654, "stage_threat_ns": 302722471, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 48504, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 267390415, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 170522, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12130, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 24246, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 29669646, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 48492, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5491888, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1328, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6290.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6957.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 695, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9215, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 111, 143, 98, 144, 82, 67, 141, 146, 145, 158, 173, 174, 190, 110, 189, 126 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 330, "avg_search_time_ms": 36.666666666666664, "search_nodes": 19694, "safety_nodes": 562, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 20256, "avg_nodes": 2250.6666666666665, "eval_calls": 18663, "avg_eval_calls": 2073.6666666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 18663, "line_shape_eval_ns": 15738241, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 843.2856989765847, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1014, "avg_candidate_generations": 112.66666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 62733, "avg_candidate_moves": 61.866863905325445, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 513, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 1005, "search_candidate_moves_total": 62220, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 14325, "avg_legality_checks": 1591.6666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "root_legality_checks": 513, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 13812, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 37, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24807, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2756.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 59164725, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2385.0012093360747, "renju_forbidden_checks": 89, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9.88888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1007753, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11323.067415730337, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 47, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 544462, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 463291, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 636833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11793.203703703704, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 78, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.666666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 343952, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4409.641025641025, "stage_move_gen_ns": 39779569, "stage_ordering_ns": 31310, "stage_eval_ns": 15738241, "stage_threat_ns": 262772665, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 39345, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 232139798, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 801564, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 19668, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 24931817, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 39336, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4899486, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 85, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 867, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5716.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6605.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1943, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8877, "avg_search_time_ms": 986.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 204209, "safety_nodes": 206, "corridor_nodes": 2512, "corridor_branch_probes": 2874, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1093, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 2489, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2489, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 40, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 17, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1093, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 40, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 284, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 199520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 206927, "avg_nodes": 22991.88888888889, "eval_calls": 199405, "avg_eval_calls": 22156.11111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 199405, "pattern_eval_ns": 4010380, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.11173240390161, "pattern_frame_queries": 199405, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4010380, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.11173240390161, "pattern_frame_updates": 408368, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5936367092, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14536.807712651334, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4788, "avg_candidate_generations": 532.0, "candidate_moves_total": 343992, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.84461152882206, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 535, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 4779, "search_candidate_moves_total": 343457, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 7767, "avg_legality_checks": 863.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 113, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7767, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 113, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1626556, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 180728.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3833872565, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2357.0492285540736, "renju_forbidden_checks": 72446, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8049.555555555556, "renju_forbidden_ns": 727775308, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10045.762471357977, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 113, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1200047, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 72038, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 723397045, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 206, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2173280, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 89, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1004936, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22124510, "stage_ordering_ns": 157180, "stage_eval_ns": 5940377472, "stage_threat_ns": 2845254350, "stage_proof_ns": 48032052, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 413435, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2327819959, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 149472, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 170830887, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1184, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 56206838, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 206713, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 272502485, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5058, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24185988, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 413426, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49915031, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 331, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4186, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4566.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5455.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 696, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3182, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 95, 143, 98, 158, 173, 99, 126, 140, 141, 114, 96, 94, 111, 156, 81 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2485, "avg_search_time_ms": 276.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 45857, "safety_nodes": 600, "corridor_nodes": 1507, "corridor_branch_probes": 1671, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 625, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1489, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1489, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 625, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 62, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 466, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 153120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 47964, "avg_nodes": 5329.333333333333, "eval_calls": 43607, "avg_eval_calls": 4845.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 43607, "pattern_eval_ns": 884136, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.275093448299586, "pattern_frame_queries": 43607, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 884136, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.275093448299586, "pattern_frame_updates": 91664, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1162436321, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12681.49241796125, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2234, "avg_candidate_generations": 248.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 150445, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.34333034914951, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 498, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 2225, "search_candidate_moves_total": 149947, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 41068, "avg_legality_checks": 4563.111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 28, "root_legality_checks": 498, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 40570, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 606478, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 67386.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1324554993, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2184.011609654431, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6009, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 667.6666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 27148533, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4517.978532201698, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 74360, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5751, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24979976, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 82, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1043904, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 148, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1050293, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3188, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 354.22222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 31412015, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9853.204203262234, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4281, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 475.6666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 16412627, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3833.8301798645175, "stage_move_gen_ns": 100191043, "stage_ordering_ns": 71191, "stage_eval_ns": 1163320457, "stage_threat_ns": 932298529, "stage_proof_ns": 274771801, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 94779, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 555110608, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 91758, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 284683713, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 938, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 61086476, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47385, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 63671435, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3106, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17391418, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 94770, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11441355, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 163, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1964, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5562.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6451.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1839, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 687, "avg_search_time_ms": 85.875, "search_nodes": 49542, "safety_nodes": 527, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 50069, "avg_nodes": 6258.625, "eval_calls": 47568, "avg_eval_calls": 5946.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 47568, "line_shape_eval_ns": 45625755, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 959.1690842583249, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1959, "avg_candidate_generations": 244.875, "candidate_moves_total": 138500, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.69933639612047, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 446, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 1951, "search_candidate_moves_total": 138054, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 4209, "avg_legality_checks": 526.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4209, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13291, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1661.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29457687, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2216.363479045971, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65641, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10940.166666666666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21350, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 44291, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12044387, "stage_ordering_ns": 61030, "stage_eval_ns": 45625755, "stage_threat_ns": 621150338, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 99046, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 545200220, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 150302, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 49519, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 63993225, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 99038, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11806591, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 126, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1740, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5422.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6422.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 697, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10388, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 96, 128, 125, 143, 109, 108, 98, 173, 158, 99, 141, 71, 85, 93, 95, 80, 82, 129, 130, 114, 68, 54, 124 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 2933, "avg_search_time_ms": 225.6153846153846, "search_nodes": 188144, "safety_nodes": 946, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 189090, "avg_nodes": 14545.384615384615, "eval_calls": 183441, "avg_eval_calls": 14110.846153846154, "line_shape_eval_calls": 183441, "line_shape_eval_ns": 238304885, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1299.0819118953777, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4679, "avg_candidate_generations": 359.9230769230769, "candidate_moves_total": 395350, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.49455011754648, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 900, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 4666, "search_candidate_moves_total": 394450, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 176119, "avg_legality_checks": 13547.615384615385, "illegal_moves_skipped": 273, "root_legality_checks": 900, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 175219, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 271, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 191329, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14717.615384615385, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 440153280, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2300.5047849515754, "renju_forbidden_checks": 418, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 32.15384615384615, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4656244, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11139.33971291866, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 388, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4377684, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 278560, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 69, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.3076923076923075, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 758733, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10996.130434782608, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.6923076923076925, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 383152, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3831.52, "stage_move_gen_ns": 425703180, "stage_ordering_ns": 149500, "stage_eval_ns": 238304885, "stage_threat_ns": 2247118445, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 376227, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1961921598, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 947475, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 188107, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 240575340, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 376214, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43674032, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 276, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4235, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6326.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6942.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1930, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7444, "avg_search_time_ms": 620.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 184575, "safety_nodes": 1053, "corridor_nodes": 4247, "corridor_branch_probes": 4911, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 15, "corridor_depth_exits": 1979, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 17, "corridor_plies_followed": 4214, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4199, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 15, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 80, "corridor_proof_active": 33, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 27, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1979, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 80, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 3, "corridor_proof_unknown": 76, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 500, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 154400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 189875, "avg_nodes": 15822.916666666666, "eval_calls": 179585, "avg_eval_calls": 14965.416666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 179585, "pattern_eval_ns": 3574316, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.903199042236267, "pattern_frame_queries": 179585, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3574316, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.903199042236267, "pattern_frame_updates": 369080, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4645876424, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12587.72196813699, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4967, "avg_candidate_generations": 413.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 358774, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.2315280853634, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 818, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4955, "search_candidate_moves_total": 357956, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 7727, "avg_legality_checks": 643.9166666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 74, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7727, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 74, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1444963, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 120413.58333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3167749045, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2192.2700062216127, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45679, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3806.5833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 412569922, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9031.93857133475, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 83, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 823603, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 45083, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 406670699, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 299, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3140319, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 214, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1935301, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 192, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1913277, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9964.984375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 259, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21.583333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 840204, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3244.030888030888, "stage_move_gen_ns": 21576420, "stage_ordering_ns": 149781, "stage_eval_ns": 4649450740, "stage_threat_ns": 2653646868, "stage_proof_ns": 96618455, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 377680, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2042963646, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 228625, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 269797077, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1899, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 86198619, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 188834, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 246849161, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8588, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 50317199, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 377668, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43719785, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 238, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4287, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5652.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6319.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 698, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5715, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 80, 128, 125, 129, 130, 140, 97, 83, 98, 99, 95, 65, 108, 109, 94, 96, 66, 52, 122 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4923, "avg_search_time_ms": 447.54545454545456, "search_nodes": 104814, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 1545, "corridor_branch_probes": 1727, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 643, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 1525, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1525, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 643, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 62, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 468, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 157680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 107275, "avg_nodes": 9752.272727272728, "eval_calls": 101571, "avg_eval_calls": 9233.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 101571, "pattern_eval_ns": 2053433, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.21672524637938, "pattern_frame_queries": 101571, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2053433, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.21672524637938, "pattern_frame_updates": 209566, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2712564946, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12943.726301022112, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3223, "avg_candidate_generations": 293.0, "candidate_moves_total": 218293, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.72975488675148, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 664, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 3212, "search_candidate_moves_total": 217629, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 98781, "avg_legality_checks": 8980.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "root_legality_checks": 664, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 98117, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1102560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 100232.72727272728, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2465836170, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2236.464382890727, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11513, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1046.6363636363637, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62473813, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5426.371319378094, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 531620, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11206, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60020767, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 75, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 969694, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 172, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 951732, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3244, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 294.90909090909093, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 30910020, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9528.366214549938, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4367, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 397.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 16200008, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3709.642317380353, "stage_move_gen_ns": 240265502, "stage_ordering_ns": 104552, "stage_eval_ns": 2714618379, "stage_threat_ns": 1668249434, "stage_proof_ns": 281264485, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 212759, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1211857239, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 93597, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 269052574, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 960, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 57170246, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 106374, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 144254246, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3182, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17425871, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 212748, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25659504, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 177, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2892, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5740.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6467.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1843, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 781, "avg_search_time_ms": 78.1, "search_nodes": 56081, "safety_nodes": 690, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 56771, "avg_nodes": 5677.1, "eval_calls": 53733, "avg_eval_calls": 5373.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 53733, "line_shape_eval_ns": 49167352, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 915.0308376602833, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2329, "avg_candidate_generations": 232.9, "candidate_moves_total": 163307, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.118935165307, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 609, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 2319, "search_candidate_moves_total": 162698, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 6059, "avg_legality_checks": 605.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6059, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17561, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1756.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 38779386, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2208.267524628438, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16875915, "stage_ordering_ns": 71691, "stage_eval_ns": 49167352, "stage_threat_ns": 705103260, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 112114, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 618999773, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 153191, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56052, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 72554131, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 112104, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13396165, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 128, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2111, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5897.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6697.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 699, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9190, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 98, 126, 81, 125, 67, 52, 128, 123, 124, 141, 156, 155, 169, 99, 170, 113 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 322, "avg_search_time_ms": 35.77777777777778, "search_nodes": 19839, "safety_nodes": 562, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 20401, "avg_nodes": 2266.777777777778, "eval_calls": 18804, "avg_eval_calls": 2089.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 18804, "line_shape_eval_ns": 15880143, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 844.5087747287811, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1018, "avg_candidate_generations": 113.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 62869, "avg_candidate_moves": 61.7573673870334, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 513, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 1009, "search_candidate_moves_total": 62356, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 14318, "avg_legality_checks": 1590.888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "root_legality_checks": 513, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 13805, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 37, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24752, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2750.222222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 54441640, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2199.4844861021334, "renju_forbidden_checks": 89, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9.88888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1003193, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11271.831460674157, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 47, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 534140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 469053, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 607573, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11251.351851851852, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 78, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.666666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 330790, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4240.897435897436, "stage_move_gen_ns": 34975198, "stage_ordering_ns": 31830, "stage_eval_ns": 15880143, "stage_threat_ns": 259922649, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 39635, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 229384239, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 772523, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 19813, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 25070475, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 39626, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4695412, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 85, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 870, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5716.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6605.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1941, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8859, "avg_search_time_ms": 984.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 211250, "safety_nodes": 206, "corridor_nodes": 2096, "corridor_branch_probes": 2378, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 913, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 2075, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2075, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 40, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 913, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 40, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 284, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 146400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 213552, "avg_nodes": 23728.0, "eval_calls": 206268, "avg_eval_calls": 22918.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 206268, "pattern_eval_ns": 4162909, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.18203987045979, "pattern_frame_queries": 206268, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4162909, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.18203987045979, "pattern_frame_updates": 422450, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5887442824, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13936.42519588117, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4966, "avg_candidate_generations": 551.7777777777778, "candidate_moves_total": 353816, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.24768425291985, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 535, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 4957, "search_candidate_moves_total": 353281, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 8373, "avg_legality_checks": 930.3333333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 108, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8373, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 108, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1651670, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 183518.88888888888, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3824482969, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2315.5248742182157, "renju_forbidden_checks": 75419, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8379.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 741724285, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9834.71386520638, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 108, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1082404, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 75100, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 738368235, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 122, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1274361, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 89, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 999285, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22687431, "stage_ordering_ns": 162460, "stage_eval_ns": 5891605733, "stage_threat_ns": 2875330721, "stage_proof_ns": 50883805, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 426689, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2365648760, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 124618, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 153719748, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1046, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 54936269, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 213340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 284901258, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4230, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20538768, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 426680, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50522187, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 361, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4279, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4621.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5510.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 700, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3056, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 95, 79, 80, 65, 113, 51, 93, 52, 67, 49, 33, 50, 48, 53 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2500, "avg_search_time_ms": 277.77777777777777, "search_nodes": 57600, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 814, "corridor_branch_probes": 918, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 244, "corridor_neutral_exits": 23, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 802, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 802, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 58, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 244, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 58, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 427, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 210160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 58572, "avg_nodes": 6508.0, "eval_calls": 54818, "avg_eval_calls": 6090.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 54818, "pattern_eval_ns": 1109967, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.24822138713561, "pattern_frame_queries": 54818, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1109967, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.24822138713561, "pattern_frame_updates": 115150, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1269548828, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11025.17436387321, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2766, "avg_candidate_generations": 307.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 182758, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.07302964569776, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 2757, "search_candidate_moves_total": 182258, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 51867, "avg_legality_checks": 5763.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 92, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 51367, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 91, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 583315, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 64812.77777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1217816869, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2087.7516761955376, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9379, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1042.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 52112636, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5556.310480861499, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 109, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 787434, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8950, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 50019664, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 75, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 499124, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 245, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 806414, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1505, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 167.22222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 13737462, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9127.881727574751, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1999, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 222.11111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 6999568, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3501.534767383692, "stage_move_gen_ns": 116445243, "stage_ordering_ns": 92452, "stage_eval_ns": 1270658795, "stage_threat_ns": 886354648, "stage_proof_ns": 207722502, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 116879, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 635084929, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59669, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 154545059, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 693, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 35383318, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58435, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74484704, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1720, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8806336, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116870, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13433620, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 387, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2259, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5530.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6419.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1838, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 546, "avg_search_time_ms": 68.25, "search_nodes": 39914, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40510, "avg_nodes": 5063.75, "eval_calls": 38581, "avg_eval_calls": 4822.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 38581, "line_shape_eval_ns": 32489913, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 842.1221067364766, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1318, "avg_candidate_generations": 164.75, "candidate_moves_total": 83765, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.5546282245827, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1310, "search_candidate_moves_total": 83318, "search_candidate_moves_max": 88, "legality_checks": 2373, "avg_legality_checks": 296.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2373, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11398, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1424.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24119996, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2116.160379013862, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 71311, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5942.583333333333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18170, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 53141, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6580570, "stage_ordering_ns": 39760, "stage_eval_ns": 32489913, "stage_threat_ns": 498257849, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 79790, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 439349933, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 161262, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8370, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 39891, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 49357988, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 79782, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9388666, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1199, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5405.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6405.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 701, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5423, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 127, 99, 96, 84, 110, 109, 129, 54, 69, 82, 130, 128, 95, 100, 101, 86, 142, 72 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 1336, "avg_search_time_ms": 133.6, "search_nodes": 84905, "safety_nodes": 625, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85530, "avg_nodes": 8553.0, "eval_calls": 82266, "avg_eval_calls": 8226.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 82266, "line_shape_eval_ns": 70959871, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 862.5661998881676, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2620, "avg_candidate_generations": 262.0, "candidate_moves_total": 164549, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.80496183206107, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 566, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 2610, "search_candidate_moves_total": 163983, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 79402, "avg_legality_checks": 7940.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 37, "root_legality_checks": 566, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 78836, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 33, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 90949, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9094.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 209602439, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2304.615102969796, "renju_forbidden_checks": 53, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 593233, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11193.075471698114, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 430072, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 163161, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 509892, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11330.933333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 276431, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4252.784615384616, "stage_move_gen_ns": 192166628, "stage_ordering_ns": 83420, "stage_eval_ns": 70959871, "stage_threat_ns": 1060490532, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169762, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 931183202, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 657093, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10220, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84876, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108387410, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169752, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20262827, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 155, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2305, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5768.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6568.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1919, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 4077, "avg_search_time_ms": 407.7, "search_nodes": 107917, "safety_nodes": 620, "corridor_nodes": 2548, "corridor_branch_probes": 2880, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1131, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 2522, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2522, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 62, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 36, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1131, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 62, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 59, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 445, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 192880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 111085, "avg_nodes": 11108.5, "eval_calls": 104378, "avg_eval_calls": 10437.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 104378, "pattern_eval_ns": 2105418, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.171089693230375, "pattern_frame_queries": 104378, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2105418, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.171089693230375, "pattern_frame_updates": 215778, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2363808238, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10954.815773619182, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3521, "avg_candidate_generations": 352.1, "candidate_moves_total": 247335, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.24566884407838, "candidate_moves_max": 92, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 590, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 3511, "search_candidate_moves_total": 246745, "search_candidate_moves_max": 92, "legality_checks": 6966, "avg_legality_checks": 696.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6966, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 697460, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 69746.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1618105568, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2319.997660080865, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20551, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2055.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 198883065, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9677.537102817381, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 265850, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20222, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 195647290, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 206, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1927393, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 97, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1042532, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18354491, "stage_ordering_ns": 113341, "stage_eval_ns": 2365913656, "stage_threat_ns": 1591979811, "stage_proof_ns": 82955385, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 220956, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1218413135, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 147981, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 172915603, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1322, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 66105827, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 110473, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 147906454, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5168, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 27093941, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 220946, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25650678, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 234, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3087, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5799.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6599.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 702, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5746, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 82, 66, 81, 80, 128, 94, 52, 109, 110, 64, 48, 79, 49, 124 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5230, "avg_search_time_ms": 581.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 125252, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 859, "corridor_branch_probes": 963, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 287, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 847, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 847, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 287, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 57, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 442, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 185280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 126269, "avg_nodes": 14029.888888888889, "eval_calls": 121181, "avg_eval_calls": 13464.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 121181, "pattern_eval_ns": 2548033, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.026670847740156, "pattern_frame_queries": 121181, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2548033, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.026670847740156, "pattern_frame_updates": 250454, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2857755666, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11410.301556373626, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4055, "avg_candidate_generations": 450.55555555555554, "candidate_moves_total": 260862, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.33094944512948, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 4046, "search_candidate_moves_total": 260362, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 118046, "avg_legality_checks": 13116.222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 149, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 117546, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 148, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 980195, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 108910.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2302533714, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2349.056783599182, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14287, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1587.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 119287685, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8349.38650521453, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 161, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1441637, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13760, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 116299629, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 78, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 543255, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 288, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1003164, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1668, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 185.33333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 16322273, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9785.535371702637, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2244, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 249.33333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 8254740, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3678.5828877005347, "stage_move_gen_ns": 293600741, "stage_ordering_ns": 137960, "stage_eval_ns": 2860303699, "stage_threat_ns": 1835310393, "stage_proof_ns": 219249562, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 252279, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1446715598, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59901, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 175029088, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 706, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 39496438, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 126135, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 172586422, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1816, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10052831, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 252270, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30926454, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 387, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3430, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4829.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5718.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1789, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 508, "avg_search_time_ms": 63.5, "search_nodes": 35108, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35704, "avg_nodes": 4463.0, "eval_calls": 33899, "avg_eval_calls": 4237.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 33899, "line_shape_eval_ns": 29838109, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 880.2061712734888, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1194, "avg_candidate_generations": 149.25, "candidate_moves_total": 76195, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.814907872696814, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1186, "search_candidate_moves_total": 75748, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 2613, "avg_legality_checks": 326.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2613, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11724, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1465.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25671111, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2189.620522006141, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 79610, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7237.272727272727, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12220, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 67390, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7341450, "stage_ordering_ns": 37250, "stage_eval_ns": 29838109, "stage_threat_ns": 460370182, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 70178, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 405479557, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 174110, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35085, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 46063934, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 70170, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8652581, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1085, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5417.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6417.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 703, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9736, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 113, 141, 96, 140, 82, 67, 143, 138, 139, 156, 171, 170, 184, 114, 185, 128 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 350, "avg_search_time_ms": 38.888888888888886, "search_nodes": 19989, "safety_nodes": 562, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 20551, "avg_nodes": 2283.4444444444443, "eval_calls": 18954, "avg_eval_calls": 2106.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 18954, "line_shape_eval_ns": 16908709, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 892.0918539622244, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1018, "avg_candidate_generations": 113.11111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 62924, "avg_candidate_moves": 61.81139489194499, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 513, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 1009, "search_candidate_moves_total": 62411, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 14443, "avg_legality_checks": 1604.7777777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "root_legality_checks": 513, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 13930, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 37, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24925, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2769.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 59623239, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2392.1058776328987, "renju_forbidden_checks": 89, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9.88888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1036705, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11648.370786516854, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 47, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 567682, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 469023, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 648644, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12011.925925925925, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 78, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.666666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 353234, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4528.641025641025, "stage_move_gen_ns": 39242313, "stage_ordering_ns": 34760, "stage_eval_ns": 16908709, "stage_threat_ns": 282054842, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 39935, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 248697152, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 824364, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 19963, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 27434054, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 39926, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5099272, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 85, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 870, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5711.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6600.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1937, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9377, "avg_search_time_ms": 1041.888888888889, "search_nodes": 208303, "safety_nodes": 206, "corridor_nodes": 2096, "corridor_branch_probes": 2378, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 913, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 2075, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2075, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 40, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 913, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 40, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 284, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 146640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 210605, "avg_nodes": 23400.555555555555, "eval_calls": 203469, "avg_eval_calls": 22607.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 203469, "pattern_eval_ns": 4335313, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.30699516879721, "pattern_frame_queries": 203469, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4335313, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.30699516879721, "pattern_frame_updates": 416556, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6241960865, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14984.686008603885, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4818, "avg_candidate_generations": 535.3333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 347650, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.15649647156496, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 535, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 4809, "search_candidate_moves_total": 347115, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 8357, "avg_legality_checks": 928.5555555555555, "illegal_moves_skipped": 106, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8357, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 106, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1607647, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 178627.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4012344514, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2495.787019165277, "renju_forbidden_checks": 73766, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8196.222222222223, "renju_forbidden_ns": 762536858, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10337.240164845593, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 106, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1113393, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 73449, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 759050797, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 122, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1326985, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 89, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1045683, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 24788370, "stage_ordering_ns": 174260, "stage_eval_ns": 6246296178, "stage_threat_ns": 3045363148, "stage_proof_ns": 53854733, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 420795, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2506290238, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 124618, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 154370336, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1046, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 54833967, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 210393, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 309336632, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4230, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21864103, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 420786, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53501839, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 339, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4167, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4390.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5279.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 704, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3379, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 110, 94, 95, 80, 128, 66, 108, 67, 82, 64, 48, 65, 63, 68 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2780, "avg_search_time_ms": 308.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 60933, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 814, "corridor_branch_probes": 918, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 244, "corridor_neutral_exits": 23, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 802, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 802, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 58, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 244, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 58, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 427, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 210080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 61905, "avg_nodes": 6878.333333333333, "eval_calls": 58080, "avg_eval_calls": 6453.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 58080, "pattern_eval_ns": 1228831, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.157558539944905, "pattern_frame_queries": 58080, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1228831, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.157558539944905, "pattern_frame_updates": 121816, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1442053157, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11837.961819465423, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2837, "avg_candidate_generations": 315.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 190740, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.23299259781459, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 2828, "search_candidate_moves_total": 190240, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 55177, "avg_legality_checks": 6130.777777777777, "illegal_moves_skipped": 92, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 54677, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 91, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 618580, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 68731.11111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1360380367, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2199.1987568301593, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9658, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1073.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 54784739, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5672.472458065852, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 109, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 590043, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9229, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 52726719, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 75, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 549653, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 245, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 918324, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1506, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 167.33333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 15019791, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9973.30079681275, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1999, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 222.11111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 7622136, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3812.9744872436218, "stage_move_gen_ns": 129272460, "stage_ordering_ns": 105620, "stage_eval_ns": 1443281988, "stage_threat_ns": 971566868, "stage_proof_ns": 219014465, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 123545, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 689107420, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59669, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 175264520, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 693, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 40183073, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61768, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 83225252, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1720, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9527780, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 123536, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14441896, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 387, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2325, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5507.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6396.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1825, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 591, "avg_search_time_ms": 73.875, "search_nodes": 40224, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40820, "avg_nodes": 5102.5, "eval_calls": 38891, "avg_eval_calls": 4861.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 38891, "line_shape_eval_ns": 34248512, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 880.6282173253452, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1318, "avg_candidate_generations": 164.75, "candidate_moves_total": 84143, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.84142640364188, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1310, "search_candidate_moves_total": 83696, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 2373, "avg_legality_checks": 296.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2373, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11484, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1435.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24713207, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2151.968564959944, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 89480, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7456.666666666667, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23290, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 66190, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7070039, "stage_ordering_ns": 42970, "stage_eval_ns": 34248512, "stage_threat_ns": 539338270, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 80410, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 475201572, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 174730, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40201, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 53807179, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 80402, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10154789, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1199, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5397.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6397.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 705, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7219, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 96, 128, 83, 129, 67, 52, 126, 143, 158, 159, 175, 95, 174, 111 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 321, "avg_search_time_ms": 40.125, "search_nodes": 18984, "safety_nodes": 474, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 19458, "avg_nodes": 2432.25, "eval_calls": 18043, "avg_eval_calls": 2255.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 18043, "line_shape_eval_ns": 15043797, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 833.7747048716953, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 926, "avg_candidate_generations": 115.75, "candidate_moves_total": 54817, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.19762419006479, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 425, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 918, "search_candidate_moves_total": 54392, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 14143, "avg_legality_checks": 1767.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 55, "root_legality_checks": 425, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 13718, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23429, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2928.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 54772837, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2337.822228861667, "renju_forbidden_checks": 89, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1013914, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11392.292134831461, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 55, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 621914, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 392000, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 604853, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11631.788461538461, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 325192, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4394.486486486487, "stage_move_gen_ns": 36754023, "stage_ordering_ns": 31790, "stage_eval_ns": 15043797, "stage_threat_ns": 258715469, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 37930, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 227849253, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 777963, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8610, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 18961, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 25341529, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 37922, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4746724, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 84, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 782, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5428.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6428.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1941, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6891, "avg_search_time_ms": 861.375, "search_nodes": 65889, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 2488, "corridor_branch_probes": 2925, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1062, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2466, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2466, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 40, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1062, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 40, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 287, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 273200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 17680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 68577, "avg_nodes": 8572.125, "eval_calls": 51372, "avg_eval_calls": 6421.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51372, "pattern_eval_ns": 1087158, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.16246204157907, "pattern_frame_queries": 51372, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1087158, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.16246204157907, "pattern_frame_updates": 131710, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1741574509, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13222.79636322223, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13560, "avg_candidate_generations": 1695.0, "candidate_moves_total": 937008, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.1008849557522, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 450, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 13552, "search_candidate_moves_total": 936558, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 568785, "avg_legality_checks": 71098.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7514, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 568785, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7514, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1938222, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 242277.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4018339587, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2073.209150964131, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42516, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5314.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 319095727, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7505.309224762443, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7549, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 80010583, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20611, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 185359775, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14278, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 52839435, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 78, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 885934, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74920, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9365.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 834109657, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11133.337653497063, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109529, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13691.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 441215366, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4028.2972180883603, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1472730095, "stage_ordering_ns": 388195274, "stage_eval_ns": 1742661667, "stage_threat_ns": 3204258476, "stage_proof_ns": 49897951, "tactical_annotations": 280605, "root_tactical_annotations": 1288, "search_tactical_annotations": 279317, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136730, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 821670557, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 389869, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2229124152, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28246, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1059559850, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68361, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 100597932, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5012, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25789670, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136722, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16991049, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 80279, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 407421985, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 134417, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 634502472, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 65909, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10085116, "child_limit_applications": 13552, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13552, "child_cap_hits": 13552, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13552, "child_moves_before_total": 929044, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 929044, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 223157, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 223157, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.55401416765054, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.46672077922078, "tt_hits": 5701, "tt_cutoffs": 931, "beta_cutoffs": 10309, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4005.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5005.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1837, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 706, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18616, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 83, 99, 127, 82, 69, 111, 66, 114, 67, 68, 54, 129, 144, 115, 55, 41, 53, 130, 146, 116, 117, 52, 84, 85, 39, 24, 81, 25, 95 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 15575, "avg_search_time_ms": 1038.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 147940, "safety_nodes": 706, "corridor_nodes": 7473, "corridor_branch_probes": 8451, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3368, "corridor_neutral_exits": 48, "corridor_terminal_exits": 57, "corridor_plies_followed": 7414, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 7414, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 154, "corridor_proof_active": 59, "corridor_proof_quiet": 95, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 48, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3368, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 57, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 154, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 153, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1255, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 44389360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 156119, "avg_nodes": 10407.933333333332, "eval_calls": 109906, "avg_eval_calls": 7327.066666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 109906, "pattern_eval_ns": 2390129, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.747029279566174, "pattern_frame_queries": 109906, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2390129, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.747029279566174, "pattern_frame_updates": 295746, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3433870485, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11610.877188533404, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35816, "avg_candidate_generations": 2387.733333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 2672109, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.60657248157248, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1000, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 35801, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2671109, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 1024629, "avg_legality_checks": 68308.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1805, "root_legality_checks": 1000, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1023629, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1802, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4408455, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 293897.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9482906996, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2151.0726537982127, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31276, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2085.0666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 149119295, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4767.850588310525, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1905, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16827362, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12716, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 84797911, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14291, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32879106, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2364, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 14614916, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 127247, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8483.133333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1107524047, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8703.734052669219, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 164384, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10958.933333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 483960794, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2944.086979268055, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2536550961, "stage_ordering_ns": 1064982289, "stage_eval_ns": 3436260614, "stage_threat_ns": 7451203736, "stage_proof_ns": 1022032048, "tactical_annotations": 651575, "root_tactical_annotations": 2682, "search_tactical_annotations": 648893, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 310897, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1928834454, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 962244, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5120176079, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75801, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2729011943, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 155441, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 233802058, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 15136, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 105357034, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 310882, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38872449, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 195258, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 253560680, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 296849, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1082443059, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 159468, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24161662, "child_limit_applications": 35801, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35801, "child_cap_hits": 35801, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35801, "child_moves_before_total": 2669307, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2669307, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 577226, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 577226, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.55956537526885, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.12318091673417, "tt_hits": 14986, "tt_cutoffs": 2166, "beta_cutoffs": 28694, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4520.733333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5054.066666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 652, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3028, "avg_search_time_ms": 216.28571428571428, "search_nodes": 218414, "safety_nodes": 1034, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 219448, "avg_nodes": 15674.857142857143, "eval_calls": 212778, "avg_eval_calls": 15198.42857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 212778, "line_shape_eval_ns": 274903327, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1291.9725112558629, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5609, "avg_candidate_generations": 400.64285714285717, "candidate_moves_total": 420392, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.94954537350687, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 950, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 5595, "search_candidate_moves_total": 419442, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 11469, "avg_legality_checks": 819.2142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11469, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27192, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1942.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 60668736, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2231.1244483671667, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.357142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 331670, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10050.60606060606, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 210570, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 121100, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 30663961, "stage_ordering_ns": 185591, "stage_eval_ns": 274903327, "stage_threat_ns": 2695478357, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 436760, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2361458222, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 270332, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 218373, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 281335916, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 436746, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52413887, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 327, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5063, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6525.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7096.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1917, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 707, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8280, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 97, 129, 126, 144, 110, 109, 99, 130, 131, 146, 162, 82, 147, 98 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 783, "avg_search_time_ms": 97.875, "search_nodes": 45377, "safety_nodes": 474, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 45851, "avg_nodes": 5731.375, "eval_calls": 43717, "avg_eval_calls": 5464.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 43717, "line_shape_eval_ns": 31963754, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 731.15158862685, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1645, "avg_candidate_generations": 205.625, "candidate_moves_total": 95796, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.23465045592705, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 425, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 1637, "search_candidate_moves_total": 95371, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 40378, "avg_legality_checks": 5047.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 152, "root_legality_checks": 425, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 39953, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 144, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 49694, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6211.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 126959255, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2554.820602084759, "renju_forbidden_checks": 186, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 23.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2145092, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11532.752688172042, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 152, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1752481, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 392611, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 619013, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11904.096153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 328452, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4438.540540540541, "stage_move_gen_ns": 111577225, "stage_ordering_ns": 52540, "stage_eval_ns": 31963754, "stage_threat_ns": 629988457, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 90716, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 554600008, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 795704, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 45354, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 62607717, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 90708, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11985028, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 84, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1460, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5268.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6268.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1926, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7490, "avg_search_time_ms": 936.25, "search_nodes": 66632, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 1913, "corridor_branch_probes": 2239, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 807, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1894, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1894, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 807, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 35, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 278, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 237200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 68745, "avg_nodes": 8593.125, "eval_calls": 51936, "avg_eval_calls": 6492.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51936, "pattern_eval_ns": 1138334, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.91801447935921, "pattern_frame_queries": 51936, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1138334, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.91801447935921, "pattern_frame_updates": 133196, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2063614064, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15493.063335235292, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13697, "avg_candidate_generations": 1712.125, "candidate_moves_total": 962385, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.26246623348179, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 450, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 13689, "search_candidate_moves_total": 961935, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 574160, "avg_legality_checks": 71770.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8393, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 574160, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8393, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2000933, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 250116.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4413447027, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2205.6945569891645, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41934, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5241.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 378459187, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9025.115347927696, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8426, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 92128908, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 230570453, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11308, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 55052434, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 707392, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74835, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9354.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 859392461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11483.830573929312, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109097, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13637.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 450299107, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4127.511361448986, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1562523646, "stage_ordering_ns": 432817678, "stage_eval_ns": 2064752398, "stage_threat_ns": 3351835059, "stage_proof_ns": 49650547, "tactical_annotations": 289797, "root_tactical_annotations": 1288, "search_tactical_annotations": 288509, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 137066, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 868772483, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 365211, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2328672892, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28313, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1148504392, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68529, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107360171, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3862, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19710123, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 137058, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18402467, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 78764, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 415892453, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 142168, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 667245032, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 68865, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8916923, "child_limit_applications": 13689, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13689, "child_cap_hits": 13689, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13689, "child_moves_before_total": 953542, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 953542, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 227391, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 227391, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.65753524727884, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.611220688143764, "tt_hits": 5706, "tt_cutoffs": 973, "beta_cutoffs": 10418, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3821.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4821.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1829, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 708, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3946, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 142, 129, 110, 109, 94, 78, 158 ], "move_count": 15, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 3476, "avg_search_time_ms": 579.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 37219, "safety_nodes": 166, "corridor_nodes": 383, "corridor_branch_probes": 467, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 148, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 376, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 376, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 148, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 283, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23966720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 37768, "avg_nodes": 6294.666666666667, "eval_calls": 28854, "avg_eval_calls": 4809.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 28854, "pattern_eval_ns": 626543, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.714251057045818, "pattern_frame_queries": 28854, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 626543, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.714251057045818, "pattern_frame_updates": 74394, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 983974075, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13226.52465252574, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7892, "avg_candidate_generations": 1315.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 498149, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.120755195134315, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 304, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 7886, "search_candidate_moves_total": 497845, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 203226, "avg_legality_checks": 33871.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 91, "root_legality_checks": 304, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 202922, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 91, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 890078, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 148346.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2082084461, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2339.2157327784757, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5778, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 963.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30611084, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5297.868466597439, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 93, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 862254, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2725, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22514073, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2935, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6975394, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 259363, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 22067, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3677.8333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 229663804, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10407.56804277881, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 30997, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5166.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 108711552, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3507.1636609994516, "stage_move_gen_ns": 533637439, "stage_ordering_ns": 228271725, "stage_eval_ns": 984600618, "stage_threat_ns": 1601205337, "stage_proof_ns": 115918167, "tactical_annotations": 80435, "root_tactical_annotations": 701, "search_tactical_annotations": 79734, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 75226, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 476004572, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 102730, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1050441480, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16087, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 693767783, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37610, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 58423693, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 826, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4231856, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 75220, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10045593, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 16422, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 42490325, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 45462, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 245777925, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 18551, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2058143, "child_limit_applications": 7886, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 7886, "child_cap_hits": 7886, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 7886, "child_moves_before_total": 497754, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 497754, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 126189, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 126189, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 63.118691351762614, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001648490996704, "tt_hits": 3299, "tt_cutoffs": 457, "beta_cutoffs": 5992, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2828.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4162.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1115, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 7, "search_move_count": 5, "total_time_ms": 465, "avg_search_time_ms": 93.0, "search_nodes": 31495, "safety_nodes": 190, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 31685, "avg_nodes": 6337.0, "eval_calls": 30027, "avg_eval_calls": 6005.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 30027, "line_shape_eval_ns": 22941821, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 764.0397309088487, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1459, "avg_candidate_generations": 291.8, "candidate_moves_total": 87552, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.00822481151474, "candidate_moves_max": 78, "root_candidate_generations": 5, "root_candidate_moves_total": 248, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 1454, "search_candidate_moves_total": 87304, "search_candidate_moves_max": 78, "legality_checks": 3197, "avg_legality_checks": 639.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3197, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8853, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1770.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21127095, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2386.4334124025754, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9547571, "stage_ordering_ns": 48160, "stage_eval_ns": 22941821, "stage_threat_ns": 426633492, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 62967, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 374909864, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 58591, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 10, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 31481, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 43542808, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 62962, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8122229, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 95, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1282, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3779.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5379.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 709, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8002, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 126, 98, 95, 83, 109, 108, 128, 99, 100, 85, 71, 141, 86, 127 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 989, "avg_search_time_ms": 123.625, "search_nodes": 58894, "safety_nodes": 474, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59368, "avg_nodes": 7421.0, "eval_calls": 56979, "avg_eval_calls": 7122.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 56979, "line_shape_eval_ns": 41128786, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 721.8235841274856, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1900, "avg_candidate_generations": 237.5, "candidate_moves_total": 109259, "avg_candidate_moves": 57.50473684210527, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 425, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 1892, "search_candidate_moves_total": 108834, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 51840, "avg_legality_checks": 6480.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 40, "root_legality_checks": 425, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 51415, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 61126, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7640.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 152928641, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2501.859127049046, "renju_forbidden_checks": 74, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 844074, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11406.405405405405, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 466774, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 377300, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 613023, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11788.903846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 324070, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4379.324324324324, "stage_move_gen_ns": 137053993, "stage_ordering_ns": 62610, "stage_eval_ns": 41128786, "stage_threat_ns": 800618552, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 117750, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 703842872, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 787474, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8750, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58871, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80813565, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 117742, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15174641, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 84, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1674, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5192.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6192.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1915, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7006, "avg_search_time_ms": 875.75, "search_nodes": 63871, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 2354, "corridor_branch_probes": 2773, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1028, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 2333, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2333, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 39, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1028, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 39, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 283, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 307360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 66425, "avg_nodes": 8303.125, "eval_calls": 49920, "avg_eval_calls": 6240.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49920, "pattern_eval_ns": 1084014, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.71502403846154, "pattern_frame_queries": 49920, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1084014, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.71502403846154, "pattern_frame_updates": 127674, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1773966580, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13894.501464667826, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12962, "avg_candidate_generations": 1620.25, "candidate_moves_total": 911521, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.32255824718408, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 450, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 12954, "search_candidate_moves_total": 911071, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 567439, "avg_legality_checks": 70929.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7453, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 567439, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1893082, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 236635.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4117144827, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2174.837026077053, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32988, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4123.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 301180624, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9130.005577785862, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9909, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 104472038, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14516, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 150926726, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8491, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44970638, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 811222, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72810, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9101.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 812310099, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11156.573259167697, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 105512, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13189.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 414545170, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3928.891216164986, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1544550143, "stage_ordering_ns": 388580809, "stage_eval_ns": 1775050594, "stage_threat_ns": 3219404171, "stage_proof_ns": 48159536, "tactical_annotations": 282200, "root_tactical_annotations": 1288, "search_tactical_annotations": 280912, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 132426, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 856554154, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 379348, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2206989084, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26982, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1063516411, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66209, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 103213608, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4744, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25381113, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 132418, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17488659, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 79884, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 378910530, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 134183, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 646386938, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 68133, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9777553, "child_limit_applications": 12954, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12954, "child_cap_hits": 12954, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12954, "child_moves_before_total": 903618, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 903618, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 211971, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 211971, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.75590551181102, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.363362667901807, "tt_hits": 5664, "tt_cutoffs": 963, "beta_cutoffs": 9793, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4007.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5007.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1862, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 710, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6162, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 81, 65, 80, 79, 127, 93, 51, 108, 109, 63, 47, 78, 48, 123 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5636, "avg_search_time_ms": 626.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 64219, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 747, "corridor_branch_probes": 863, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 242, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 732, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 732, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 242, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 421, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24226800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 65124, "avg_nodes": 7236.0, "eval_calls": 46535, "avg_eval_calls": 5170.555555555556, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46535, "pattern_eval_ns": 1012004, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.747158053078326, "pattern_frame_queries": 46535, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1012004, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.747158053078326, "pattern_frame_updates": 128364, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1348118168, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10502.307251254246, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16688, "avg_candidate_generations": 1854.2222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 1124497, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.3835690316395, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 16679, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1123997, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 362105, "avg_legality_checks": 40233.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 177, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 361605, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 176, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1471023, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 163447.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3272956119, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2224.9523759995595, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12650, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1405.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 52894820, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4181.408695652174, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 427, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2264166, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5839, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 36650608, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6269, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13474783, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 115, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 505263, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 32678, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3630.8888888888887, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 286374593, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8763.528765530325, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 42690, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4743.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 121620698, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2848.9271023658935, "stage_move_gen_ns": 912155781, "stage_ordering_ns": 456747397, "stage_eval_ns": 1349130172, "stage_threat_ns": 2687304748, "stage_proof_ns": 202643512, "tactical_annotations": 225222, "root_tactical_annotations": 1636, "search_tactical_annotations": 223586, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 129947, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 790481367, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 253044, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1770429320, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33996, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1240567882, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64969, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 95941932, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1574, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8548267, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 129938, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16502239, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70559, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 57494713, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 95935, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 354136513, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 58728, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5401623, "child_limit_applications": 16679, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16679, "child_cap_hits": 16679, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16679, "child_moves_before_total": 1123821, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1123821, "child_moves_before_max": 93, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 93, "child_moves_after_total": 266876, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 266876, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.37939924455902, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00071946759398, "tt_hits": 7724, "tt_cutoffs": 968, "beta_cutoffs": 13634, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4375.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5264.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1208, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 518, "avg_search_time_ms": 64.75, "search_nodes": 35030, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35626, "avg_nodes": 4453.25, "eval_calls": 33821, "avg_eval_calls": 4227.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 33821, "line_shape_eval_ns": 30430491, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 899.7513674935691, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1194, "avg_candidate_generations": 149.25, "candidate_moves_total": 75947, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.607202680067005, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1186, "search_candidate_moves_total": 75500, "search_candidate_moves_max": 88, "legality_checks": 2613, "avg_legality_checks": 326.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2613, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11638, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1454.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26171972, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2248.837600962365, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 76700, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6972.727272727273, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11380, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 65320, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7567866, "stage_ordering_ns": 42651, "stage_eval_ns": 30430491, "stage_threat_ns": 469674015, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 70022, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 413483932, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 178371, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35007, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 47210871, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 70014, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8800841, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1085, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5413.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6413.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 711, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8547, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 115, 116, 95, 141, 96, 144, 142, 156, 80, 64, 110, 125, 126, 158, 94, 78, 93, 92, 97 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 3882, "avg_search_time_ms": 323.5, "search_nodes": 232503, "safety_nodes": 737, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 233240, "avg_nodes": 19436.666666666668, "eval_calls": 226232, "avg_eval_calls": 18852.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 226232, "line_shape_eval_ns": 267327321, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1181.651229711093, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6249, "avg_candidate_generations": 520.75, "candidate_moves_total": 492903, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.87710033605377, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 793, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 6237, "search_candidate_moves_total": 492110, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 216869, "avg_legality_checks": 18072.416666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 278, "root_legality_checks": 793, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 216076, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 277, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 230908, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19242.333333333332, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 576612571, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2497.152853084345, "renju_forbidden_checks": 283, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 23.583333333333332, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3401050, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12017.844522968198, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 278, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3351189, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 49861, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 525543, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10304.764705882353, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 253321, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3518.347222222222, "stage_move_gen_ns": 565278207, "stage_ordering_ns": 214761, "stage_eval_ns": 267327321, "stage_threat_ns": 3031930738, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 464950, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2653192379, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 678155, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13521, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 232469, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 319843704, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 464938, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58216500, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 403, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5533, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6121.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6788.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1909, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4652, "avg_search_time_ms": 422.90909090909093, "search_nodes": 49089, "safety_nodes": 923, "corridor_nodes": 848, "corridor_branch_probes": 1047, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 12, "corridor_depth_exits": 295, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 831, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 831, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 295, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 328, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 378960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 20320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 50860, "avg_nodes": 4623.636363636364, "eval_calls": 36298, "avg_eval_calls": 3299.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36298, "pattern_eval_ns": 793041, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.848063254173784, "pattern_frame_queries": 36298, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 793041, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.848063254173784, "pattern_frame_updates": 98078, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 922912672, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9409.98666367585, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12001, "avg_candidate_generations": 1091.0, "candidate_moves_total": 908678, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.71685692858928, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 716, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 11990, "search_candidate_moves_total": 907962, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 397173, "avg_legality_checks": 36106.63636363636, "illegal_moves_skipped": 290, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 397173, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 290, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1218508, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 110773.45454545454, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2717765694, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2230.4044733395267, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2888, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 262.54545454545456, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16423070, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5686.658587257618, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 292, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3332847, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 946, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8742045, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1633, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4131376, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 216802, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 33186, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3016.909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 340470949, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10259.475351051648, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 48811, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4437.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 162380964, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3326.7288930773802, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1012466984, "stage_ordering_ns": 406014401, "stage_eval_ns": 923705713, "stage_threat_ns": 2191467911, "stage_proof_ns": 89189079, "tactical_annotations": 152868, "root_tactical_annotations": 646, "search_tactical_annotations": 152222, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 99859, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 624457807, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 204942, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1465515563, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24616, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 945022650, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 49924, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74418143, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1770, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11111692, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 99848, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12966738, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 31609, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 137436272, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 94376, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 340479139, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 26883, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2997968, "child_limit_applications": 11990, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11990, "child_cap_hits": 11990, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11990, "child_moves_before_total": 907672, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 907672, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 192420, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 192420, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.70241868223519, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.04837364470392, "tt_hits": 3943, "tt_cutoffs": 751, "beta_cutoffs": 9597, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5536.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6263.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1853, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 712, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19379, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 79, 129, 115, 99, 144, 145, 97, 128, 95, 63, 69, 83, 80, 142, 94, 96, 100, 131, 84, 173, 158, 159, 117, 187 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 12393, "avg_search_time_ms": 885.2142857142857, "search_nodes": 148035, "safety_nodes": 406, "corridor_nodes": 2058, "corridor_branch_probes": 2253, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 663, "corridor_neutral_exits": 28, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 2025, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2025, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 138, "corridor_proof_active": 33, "corridor_proof_quiet": 105, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 663, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 138, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 137, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1119, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26236480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 150499, "avg_nodes": 10749.92857142857, "eval_calls": 110950, "avg_eval_calls": 7925.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110950, "pattern_eval_ns": 2372291, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.381622352410997, "pattern_frame_queries": 110950, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2372291, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.381622352410997, "pattern_frame_updates": 295946, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3152600375, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10652.62032600542, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35264, "avg_candidate_generations": 2518.8571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 2939771, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.36464950090745, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1010, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 35250, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2938761, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 962300, "avg_legality_checks": 68735.71428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 302, "root_legality_checks": 1010, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 961290, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 302, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3525228, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 251802.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7204330157, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2043.6494198389437, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18078, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1291.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57124399, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3159.884887708817, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 358, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1555055, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8065, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 39770311, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9098, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14522036, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 557, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1276997, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 78445, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5603.214285714285, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 588603045, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7503.385110587035, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97190, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6942.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 215766570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2220.0490791233665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2158588174, "stage_ordering_ns": 1083227448, "stage_eval_ns": 3154972666, "stage_threat_ns": 5460305348, "stage_proof_ns": 473947189, "tactical_annotations": 542579, "root_tactical_annotations": 3102, "search_tactical_annotations": 539477, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 300286, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1681129247, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 631035, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3490094222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 72297, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2303983626, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 150136, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 209667349, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4326, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26528091, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 300272, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35501530, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 179372, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 195730734, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 239672, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 704781270, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 123535, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17384909, "child_limit_applications": 35250, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35250, "child_cap_hits": 35250, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35250, "child_moves_before_total": 2938459, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2938459, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 581136, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 581136, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.3605390070922, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.486127659574468, "tt_hits": 14743, "tt_cutoffs": 1773, "beta_cutoffs": 27998, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5433.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6004.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 6975, "avg_search_time_ms": 536.5384615384615, "search_nodes": 503308, "safety_nodes": 845, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 504153, "avg_nodes": 38781.0, "eval_calls": 491465, "avg_eval_calls": 37805.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 491465, "line_shape_eval_ns": 636448557, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1295.0028120008546, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11818, "avg_candidate_generations": 909.0769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 987659, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.57243188356743, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 937, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 11805, "search_candidate_moves_total": 986722, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 20395, "avg_legality_checks": 1568.8461538461538, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 20395, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 35607, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2739.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 87295078, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2451.626871120847, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 60233232, "stage_ordering_ns": 365690, "stage_eval_ns": 636448557, "stage_threat_ns": 6241536614, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1006553, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5458246339, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 227612, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 503270, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 662147990, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1006540, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 120914673, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 435, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 10606, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6149.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6765.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 713, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 33300, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 157, 172, 83, 95, 98, 140, 110, 94, 84, 70, 81, 82, 53, 68, 158, 174, 156, 155, 159, 160, 143, 139, 153, 92, 96, 91, 93, 170, 185, 171, 173, 123, 187, 107 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 18616, "avg_search_time_ms": 979.7894736842105, "search_nodes": 1109865, "safety_nodes": 1063, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1110928, "avg_nodes": 58469.89473684211, "eval_calls": 1091393, "avg_eval_calls": 57441.73684210526, "line_shape_eval_calls": 1091393, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1652997872, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1514.5762085701485, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18435, "avg_candidate_generations": 970.2631578947369, "candidate_moves_total": 1648173, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.40455655004068, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1531, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 18416, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1646642, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 1072630, "avg_legality_checks": 56454.21052631579, "illegal_moves_skipped": 495, "root_legality_checks": 1531, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1071099, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 493, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1094534, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 57607.05263157895, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2662479456, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2432.5232984996355, "renju_forbidden_checks": 544, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 28.63157894736842, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5566093, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10231.788602941177, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 536, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5485113, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 80980, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 33, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.736842105263158, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 380761, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11538.212121212122, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 48, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.526315789473684, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 200810, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4183.541666666667, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2695027768, "stage_ordering_ns": 607552, "stage_eval_ns": 1652997872, "stage_threat_ns": 14220596952, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 2219637, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 12459544537, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 526922, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19830, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 1109809, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1483748282, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 2219618, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 276777211, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 737, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 16906, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 2.8421052631578947, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8421052631578947, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.10526315789473684, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21052631578947367, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.10526315789473684, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5442.263157894737, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5863.315789473684, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1919, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 14668, "avg_search_time_ms": 772.0, "search_nodes": 128837, "safety_nodes": 1451, "corridor_nodes": 7156, "corridor_branch_probes": 7507, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 21, "corridor_depth_exits": 4560, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_plies_followed": 7126, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 7126, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 17, "corridor_proof_completed": 17, "corridor_proof_checks": 74, "corridor_proof_active": 30, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 39, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4560, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 74, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 388, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 440320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 137444, "avg_nodes": 7233.894736842105, "eval_calls": 89947, "avg_eval_calls": 4734.0526315789475, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89947, "pattern_eval_ns": 1956374, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.75029739735622, "pattern_frame_queries": 89947, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1956374, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.75029739735622, "pattern_frame_updates": 257500, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2208839899, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8578.019025242718, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 36031, "avg_candidate_generations": 1896.3684210526317, "candidate_moves_total": 3477570, "avg_candidate_moves": 96.51605561877273, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1556, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 36012, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3476014, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 2353740, "avg_legality_checks": 123881.05263157895, "illegal_moves_skipped": 182, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2353740, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4649976, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 244735.57894736843, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9150551948, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1967.8707907309629, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13089, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 688.8947368421053, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30377710, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2320.857972343189, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 276, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2376150, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1831, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15923891, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10972, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11976259, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 101410, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 109077, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5740.894736842105, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1086273201, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9958.77408619599, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 171874, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9046.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 592612943, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3447.9499109813, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5038531276, "stage_ordering_ns": 1252812939, "stage_eval_ns": 2210796273, "stage_threat_ns": 6004319644, "stage_proof_ns": 115084352, "tactical_annotations": 833971, "root_tactical_annotations": 2864, "search_tactical_annotations": 831107, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 271919, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1630532884, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 979666, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4027657757, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 74736, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2293674144, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 135950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 197947010, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 14400, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 90773171, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 271900, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33516796, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 332017, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 591019159, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 327546, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 961735298, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 174408, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23892026, "child_limit_applications": 36012, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 36012, "child_cap_hits": 36012, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 36012, "child_moves_before_total": 3475832, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3475832, "child_moves_before_max": 131, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 131, "child_moves_after_total": 600363, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 600363, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 96.51871598356104, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.671192935688104, "tt_hits": 16758, "tt_cutoffs": 2791, "beta_cutoffs": 30778, "depth_sum": 87, "avg_depth": 4.578947368421052, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 87, "avg_effective_depth": 4.578947368421052, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21052631578947367, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6401.894736842105, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6822.9473684210525, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1615, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 714, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4606, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 97, 127, 126, 143, 159, 113, 158, 79, 95, 83, 110, 98 ], "move_count": 16, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 4231, "avg_search_time_ms": 705.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 48243, "safety_nodes": 253, "corridor_nodes": 260, "corridor_branch_probes": 286, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 140, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 258, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 258, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 20, "corridor_proof_active": 2, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 140, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 20, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 20, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 142, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 38560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48756, "avg_nodes": 8126.0, "eval_calls": 36286, "avg_eval_calls": 6047.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36286, "pattern_eval_ns": 740180, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.398500799206307, "pattern_frame_queries": 36286, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 740180, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.398500799206307, "pattern_frame_updates": 96434, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 972731028, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10087.013169628968, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11182, "avg_candidate_generations": 1863.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 707024, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.22876050795922, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 315, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 11176, "search_candidate_moves_total": 706709, "search_candidate_moves_max": 86, "legality_checks": 374394, "avg_legality_checks": 62399.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 95, "root_legality_checks": 315, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 374079, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 94, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1161238, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 193539.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2570806824, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2213.850066911348, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4748, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 791.3333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15152067, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3191.2525273799492, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 105, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1033416, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1668, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10108676, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2938, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3899884, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 110091, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28970, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4828.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 253466733, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8749.28315498792, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 40955, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6825.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 106115841, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2591.035062873886, "stage_move_gen_ns": 933268515, "stage_ordering_ns": 314248103, "stage_eval_ns": 973471208, "stage_threat_ns": 1931456375, "stage_proof_ns": 56885433, "tactical_annotations": 92030, "root_tactical_annotations": 585, "search_tactical_annotations": 91445, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 96996, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 572543140, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 112988, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1274680096, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22568, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 900086302, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48495, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 67829772, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 556, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2735728, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 96990, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12034555, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 10099, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 18425160, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 67774, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 324815943, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 14157, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1633084, "child_limit_applications": 11176, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11176, "child_cap_hits": 11176, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11176, "child_moves_before_total": 706615, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 706615, "child_moves_before_max": 86, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 86, "child_moves_after_total": 178816, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 178816, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 63.22610952040086, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 2831, "tt_cutoffs": 756, "beta_cutoffs": 8804, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1995.6666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3293.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 370, "avg_search_time_ms": 61.666666666666664, "search_nodes": 25919, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 26305, "avg_nodes": 4384.166666666667, "eval_calls": 24929, "avg_eval_calls": 4154.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 24929, "line_shape_eval_ns": 19409404, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 778.5873480685145, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 980, "avg_candidate_generations": 163.33333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 62041, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.30714285714286, "candidate_moves_max": 84, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 327, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 974, "search_candidate_moves_total": 61714, "search_candidate_moves_max": 84, "legality_checks": 1993, "avg_legality_checks": 332.1666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1993, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8900, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1483.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19554002, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2197.078876404494, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.6666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 183210, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11450.625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 46320, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 136890, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5755200, "stage_ordering_ns": 33860, "stage_eval_ns": 19409404, "stage_threat_ns": 337340283, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 51812, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 297208738, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 122671, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 11, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5650, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 25903, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 33665442, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 51806, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6343432, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 109, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 799, "depth_sum": 16, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 16, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4553.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5886.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 715, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13238, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 95, 129, 109, 108, 81, 145, 161, 123, 80, 125, 127, 124, 122, 79, 96, 128, 82, 143, 66, 51, 98, 173, 158, 114, 94, 144, 84, 83, 67, 53, 68, 54, 69, 65, 70 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 4370, "avg_search_time_ms": 230.0, "search_nodes": 283315, "safety_nodes": 1783, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 285098, "avg_nodes": 15005.157894736842, "eval_calls": 274674, "avg_eval_calls": 14456.526315789473, "line_shape_eval_calls": 274674, "line_shape_eval_ns": 419790335, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1528.322065430292, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8605, "avg_candidate_generations": 452.89473684210526, "candidate_moves_total": 776986, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.29471237652528, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1513, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 8586, "search_candidate_moves_total": 775473, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 272996, "avg_legality_checks": 14368.21052631579, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2577, "root_legality_checks": 1513, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 271483, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2567, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 295053, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15529.105263157895, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 641085430, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2172.780585183001, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2771, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 145.8421052631579, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3228682, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1165.1685312161674, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2722, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3133892, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 49, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 94790, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 114, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 813674, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7137.491228070176, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 136, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.157894736842105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 270441, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1988.5367647058824, "stage_move_gen_ns": 619837404, "stage_ordering_ns": 257351, "stage_eval_ns": 419790335, "stage_threat_ns": 3291095975, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 566539, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2869591748, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1288076, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 283260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 355928284, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 566520, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64287867, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 535, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7574, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6828.8421052631575, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7249.894736842105, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1915, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 8850, "avg_search_time_ms": 491.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 60647, "safety_nodes": 1888, "corridor_nodes": 9454, "corridor_branch_probes": 10098, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 39, "corridor_depth_exits": 4106, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 9427, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3369, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 6058, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 45, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4106, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 2, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 335, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 128360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 71989, "avg_nodes": 3999.3888888888887, "eval_calls": 40519, "avg_eval_calls": 2251.0555555555557, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40519, "pattern_eval_ns": 842676, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.797058170241122, "pattern_frame_queries": 40519, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 842676, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.797058170241122, "pattern_frame_updates": 121124, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1195401470, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9869.237062844688, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19245, "avg_candidate_generations": 1069.1666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1800349, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.54892179786958, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1437, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 19227, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1798912, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1221105, "avg_legality_checks": 67839.16666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2457, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1221105, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2457, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2943021, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 163501.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5747321358, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1952.8645422509728, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19195, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1066.388888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 41335094, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2153.430268299036, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2486, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6211955, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4956, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19820495, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10891, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14070041, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 862, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1232603, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 128089, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7116.055555555556, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 770800408, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6017.694009633927, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 140980, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7832.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 187946600, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1333.1437083274222, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2629860559, "stage_ordering_ns": 641771028, "stage_eval_ns": 1196244146, "stage_threat_ns": 4125513887, "stage_proof_ns": 194653411, "tactical_annotations": 446090, "root_tactical_annotations": 1261, "search_tactical_annotations": 444829, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 140124, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 971755130, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 678027, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2876298240, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46022, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1512521914, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70053, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108979384, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 18982, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 139892156, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 140106, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17056254, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 163978, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 402132263, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 189256, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 590510423, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 92856, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11532723, "child_limit_applications": 19227, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19227, "child_cap_hits": 19227, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19227, "child_moves_before_total": 1796455, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1796455, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 330182, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 330182, "child_moves_after_max": 34, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 34, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.4339730587195, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.17282987465543, "tt_hits": 7943, "tt_cutoffs": 816, "beta_cutoffs": 16999, "depth_sum": 85, "avg_depth": 4.722222222222222, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 85, "avg_effective_depth": 4.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6648.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7093.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1884, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 716, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23002, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 129, 109, 95, 81, 65, 125, 127, 79, 80, 50, 64, 96, 66, 63, 94, 52, 143, 159, 157, 171, 141, 67, 142, 172, 144, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 21742, "avg_search_time_ms": 1449.4666666666667, "search_nodes": 271884, "safety_nodes": 85, "corridor_nodes": 5749, "corridor_branch_probes": 6141, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2232, "corridor_neutral_exits": 117, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 5700, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5700, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 193, "corridor_proof_active": 49, "corridor_proof_quiet": 144, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 117, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2232, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 193, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 192, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1633, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 156802320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1991040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 277718, "avg_nodes": 18514.533333333333, "eval_calls": 219230, "avg_eval_calls": 14615.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 219230, "pattern_eval_ns": 4567268, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.833225379738174, "pattern_frame_queries": 219230, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4567268, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.833225379738174, "pattern_frame_updates": 543634, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5981046694, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11001.973191522238, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 50046, "avg_candidate_generations": 3336.4, "candidate_moves_total": 4042975, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.78517763657435, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1029, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 50031, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4041946, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1572421, "avg_legality_checks": 104828.06666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 442, "root_legality_checks": 1029, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1571392, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 442, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6042150, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 402810.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12733426871, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2107.4330943455557, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29113, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1940.8666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 93967463, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3227.680520729571, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 889, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4934519, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13382, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 66173931, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14751, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22715152, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 91, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 143861, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 133574, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8904.933333333332, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1049318887, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7855.712092173627, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 166992, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11132.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 396510574, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2374.4285594519497, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3697633440, "stage_ordering_ns": 1563337855, "stage_eval_ns": 5985613962, "stage_threat_ns": 9441357165, "stage_proof_ns": 967517194, "tactical_annotations": 755778, "root_tactical_annotations": 4377, "search_tactical_annotations": 751401, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 555435, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3210919631, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1036274, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5667833114, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 103938, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3338190703, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 277710, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 397542468, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 11786, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 75059728, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 555420, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67016223, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 223393, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 266872088, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 361030, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1224561137, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 171355, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22986001, "child_limit_applications": 50031, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 50031, "child_cap_hits": 50031, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 50031, "child_moves_before_total": 4041504, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4041504, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 800535, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 800535, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.77999640223062, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000779516699644, "tt_hits": 20938, "tt_cutoffs": 2556, "beta_cutoffs": 35617, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3278.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3811.9333333333334, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1050, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 1245, "avg_search_time_ms": 88.92857142857143, "search_nodes": 87641, "safety_nodes": 1198, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 88839, "avg_nodes": 6345.642857142857, "eval_calls": 84375, "avg_eval_calls": 6026.785714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 84375, "line_shape_eval_ns": 129289948, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1532.3253096296296, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3239, "avg_candidate_generations": 231.35714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 270218, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.4263661623958, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 955, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 3225, "search_candidate_moves_total": 269263, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 9676, "avg_legality_checks": 691.1428571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9676, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 25734, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1838.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 55725720, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2165.4511541151783, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 25420752, "stage_ordering_ns": 114100, "stage_eval_ns": 129289948, "stage_threat_ns": 1069517256, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 175214, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 936176157, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 287343, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14680, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 87600, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112600310, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 175200, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20453446, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 212, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2841, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6520.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7091.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 717, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15044, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 155, 169, 51, 84, 81, 111, 66, 36, 69, 98, 126, 114, 125, 100, 101, 128, 123, 124, 142, 68, 140, 144, 129, 115, 131, 130, 146, 145, 85, 160 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 7269, "avg_search_time_ms": 382.57894736842104, "search_nodes": 450987, "safety_nodes": 1783, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 452770, "avg_nodes": 23830.0, "eval_calls": 440538, "avg_eval_calls": 23186.21052631579, "line_shape_eval_calls": 440538, "line_shape_eval_ns": 798740279, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1813.101886783887, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10413, "avg_candidate_generations": 548.0526315789474, "candidate_moves_total": 977083, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.83299721501969, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1513, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 10394, "search_candidate_moves_total": 975570, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 438736, "avg_legality_checks": 23091.36842105263, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3136, "root_legality_checks": 1513, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 437223, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3126, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 460793, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24252.263157894737, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1014655664, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2201.977165451732, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3298, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 173.57894736842104, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8568070, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2597.9593693147363, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3249, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8467950, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 49, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 100120, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 114, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 867534, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7609.9473684210525, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 136, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.157894736842105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 288483, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2121.198529411765, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1008129251, "stage_ordering_ns": 322041, "stage_eval_ns": 798740279, "stage_threat_ns": 5403062599, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 901883, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4709001493, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1364777, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 450932, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 585960242, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 901864, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 106736087, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 535, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9294, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6913.210526315789, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7334.263157894737, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1921, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 7755, "avg_search_time_ms": 430.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 59503, "safety_nodes": 1888, "corridor_nodes": 4785, "corridor_branch_probes": 5379, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 38, "corridor_depth_exits": 2200, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 4759, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3141, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 1618, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 43, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2200, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 2, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 335, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 156520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 66176, "avg_nodes": 3676.4444444444443, "eval_calls": 39632, "avg_eval_calls": 2201.777777777778, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39632, "pattern_eval_ns": 872857, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.024046225272507, "pattern_frame_queries": 39632, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 872857, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.024046225272507, "pattern_frame_updates": 118836, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1144548255, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9631.325987074624, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19001, "avg_candidate_generations": 1055.611111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 1740347, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.59238987421715, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1437, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 18983, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1738910, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1167024, "avg_legality_checks": 64834.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5998, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1167024, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5998, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2648723, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 147151.27777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4963247701, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1873.8266330605352, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22322, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1240.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 34987607, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1567.404668040498, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6027, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8105381, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5338, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15757161, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10633, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10572805, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 324, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 552260, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 126472, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7026.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 716173341, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5662.702740527548, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 140571, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7809.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 189570793, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1348.5768259456077, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2392288435, "stage_ordering_ns": 604142947, "stage_eval_ns": 1145421112, "stage_threat_ns": 3434592746, "stage_proof_ns": 114069134, "tactical_annotations": 443755, "root_tactical_annotations": 1261, "search_tactical_annotations": 442494, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 128500, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 821488100, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 579669, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2418060404, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41036, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1265889544, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96723017, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9646, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 70716373, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15799927, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 160389, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 391777862, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 192757, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 566682832, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 90609, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11804925, "child_limit_applications": 18983, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18983, "child_cap_hits": 18983, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18983, "child_moves_before_total": 1732912, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1732912, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 329642, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 329642, "child_moves_after_max": 32, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 32, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.28757309171364, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.365116156561132, "tt_hits": 7712, "tt_cutoffs": 803, "beta_cutoffs": 16723, "depth_sum": 85, "avg_depth": 4.722222222222222, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 85, "avg_effective_depth": 4.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6670.944444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7115.388888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1862, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 718, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21822, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 84, 97, 98, 70, 114, 66, 81, 80, 129, 99, 130, 146, 131, 132, 127, 128, 115, 52, 85, 83, 145, 100, 160, 175, 126, 140, 94, 67, 142, 69, 68, 55, 41, 111 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 20582, "avg_search_time_ms": 1210.7058823529412, "search_nodes": 237589, "safety_nodes": 1029, "corridor_nodes": 5915, "corridor_branch_probes": 6403, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2156, "corridor_neutral_exits": 132, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 5850, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5850, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 175, "corridor_proof_active": 65, "corridor_proof_quiet": 110, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 132, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2156, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 175, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 174, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1328, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 127130000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 7, "total_nodes": 244533, "avg_nodes": 14384.29411764706, "eval_calls": 189398, "avg_eval_calls": 11141.058823529413, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 189398, "pattern_eval_ns": 4077952, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.531124932681443, "pattern_frame_queries": 189398, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4077952, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.531124932681443, "pattern_frame_updates": 475018, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5364282938, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11292.799300237044, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 45665, "avg_candidate_generations": 2686.176470588235, "candidate_moves_total": 3776881, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.70844191393846, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1270, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 45648, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3775611, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1486337, "avg_legality_checks": 87431.58823529411, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1403, "root_legality_checks": 1270, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1485067, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1403, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5700790, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 335340.5882352941, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12119020007, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2125.8492256336403, "renju_forbidden_checks": 51268, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3015.764705882353, "renju_forbidden_ns": 200647439, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3913.697413591324, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2566, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12593869, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26291, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 135279484, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21121, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45980464, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1290, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6793622, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 143173, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8421.941176470587, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1174639390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8204.33594322952, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 179808, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10576.941176470587, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 467057482, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2597.5344923473926, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3499341769, "stage_ordering_ns": 1444430789, "stage_eval_ns": 5368360890, "stage_threat_ns": 9161036425, "stage_proof_ns": 1027051273, "tactical_annotations": 786271, "root_tactical_annotations": 3396, "search_tactical_annotations": 782875, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 487085, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2869664373, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1109432, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5782409650, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 95288, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3239981037, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 243534, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 351407305, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12050, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 77947666, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 487068, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60367852, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 257281, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 338129786, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 377238, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1282648502, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 151752, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19239579, "child_limit_applications": 45648, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 45648, "child_cap_hits": 45648, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 45648, "child_moves_before_total": 3774208, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3774208, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 730628, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 730628, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.68068699614442, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.005695758850333, "tt_hits": 17389, "tt_cutoffs": 2463, "beta_cutoffs": 33267, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3216.8823529411766, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3687.470588235294, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 317, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 1219, "avg_search_time_ms": 71.70588235294117, "search_nodes": 84302, "safety_nodes": 1542, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85844, "avg_nodes": 5049.64705882353, "eval_calls": 80818, "avg_eval_calls": 4754.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 80818, "line_shape_eval_ns": 134331826, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1662.1523175530203, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3452, "avg_candidate_generations": 203.05882352941177, "candidate_moves_total": 308320, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.31633835457706, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1296, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 3435, "search_candidate_moves_total": 307024, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 10592, "avg_legality_checks": 623.0588235294117, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10592, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 30020, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1765.8823529411766, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 66009553, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2198.85253164557, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.35294117647058826, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18080, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3013.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 18080, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 27808767, "stage_ordering_ns": 123070, "stage_eval_ns": 134331826, "stage_threat_ns": 1033275566, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 168523, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 904024562, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 265191, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84253, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 109029086, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 168506, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19956727, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 262, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3061, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6788.882352941177, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7259.470588235294, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1901, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 719, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24379, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 71, 85, 93, 140, 95, 97, 94, 92, 139, 126, 98, 142, 83, 156, 171, 128, 53, 68, 114, 124, 115, 144, 143, 157, 173, 158, 174, 159, 155, 160 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 14936, "avg_search_time_ms": 786.1052631578947, "search_nodes": 961493, "safety_nodes": 1819, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 963312, "avg_nodes": 50700.63157894737, "eval_calls": 946902, "avg_eval_calls": 49836.94736842105, "line_shape_eval_calls": 946902, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1556837762, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1644.1382128245584, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14555, "avg_candidate_generations": 766.0526315789474, "candidate_moves_total": 1355336, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.11824115424253, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1530, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 14536, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1353806, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 943874, "avg_legality_checks": 49677.57894736842, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3317, "root_legality_checks": 1530, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 942344, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3307, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 965916, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 50837.68421052631, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2110458139, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2184.9292681765287, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3537, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 186.1578947368421, "renju_forbidden_ns": 11287966, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3191.3955329375176, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3488, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11202245, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 49, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 85721, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 110, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.7894736842105265, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 763473, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6940.663636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.947368421052632, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 257421, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1950.159090909091, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2139369770, "stage_ordering_ns": 444204, "stage_eval_ns": 1556837762, "stage_threat_ns": 11170454687, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1922895, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 9722139963, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1083164, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19051, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 961438, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1226499631, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1922876, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 220731929, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 524, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 13453, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.10526315789473684, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6661.105263157895, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7082.1578947368425, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1910, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 9424, "avg_search_time_ms": 523.5555555555555, "search_nodes": 61131, "safety_nodes": 1896, "corridor_nodes": 12415, "corridor_branch_probes": 13540, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 61, "corridor_depth_exits": 5886, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 17, "corridor_plies_followed": 12385, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6699, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5686, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 78, "corridor_proof_active": 30, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 66, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5886, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 78, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 2, "corridor_proof_unknown": 76, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 468, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 121480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 75442, "avg_nodes": 4191.222222222223, "eval_calls": 40434, "avg_eval_calls": 2246.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40434, "pattern_eval_ns": 887264, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.943512885195627, "pattern_frame_queries": 40434, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 887264, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.943512885195627, "pattern_frame_updates": 122092, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1258481444, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10307.648691150935, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19629, "avg_candidate_generations": 1090.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1785000, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.93687910744308, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1445, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 19611, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1783555, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1133140, "avg_legality_checks": 62952.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5048, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1133140, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5048, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2903190, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 161288.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5943607091, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2047.2676920904246, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24010, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1333.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 40487825, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1686.2900874635568, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5073, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7958073, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5346, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14259028, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12343, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16206641, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1248, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2064083, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 130659, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7258.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 856155758, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6552.596897266932, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 148170, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8231.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 222114359, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1499.050813255045, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2593528282, "stage_ordering_ns": 679786984, "stage_eval_ns": 1259368708, "stage_threat_ns": 4669831345, "stage_proof_ns": 200608899, "tactical_annotations": 440354, "root_tactical_annotations": 1261, "search_tactical_annotations": 439093, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 147036, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1085093482, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 797436, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3245073997, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47661, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1656526259, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 73509, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121865675, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 24926, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 187703319, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 147018, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18896128, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 148760, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 407310667, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 207193, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 717205186, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 84401, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11198744, "child_limit_applications": 19611, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19611, "child_cap_hits": 19611, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19611, "child_moves_before_total": 1778507, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1778507, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 330903, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 330903, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.6892560297792, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.873336392840752, "tt_hits": 7585, "tt_cutoffs": 1001, "beta_cutoffs": 17170, "depth_sum": 85, "avg_depth": 4.722222222222222, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 85, "avg_effective_depth": 4.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6613.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7058.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1861, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 720, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21912, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 141, 85, 125, 109, 97, 139, 95, 80, 154, 140, 78, 94, 79, 66, 63, 47, 108, 71, 99, 93, 67, 70, 83, 69, 51, 35, 115 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 14665, "avg_search_time_ms": 977.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 172966, "safety_nodes": 745, "corridor_nodes": 771, "corridor_branch_probes": 862, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 262, "corridor_neutral_exits": 28, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 747, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 747, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 156, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 132, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 262, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 156, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 155, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1257, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26190600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 174482, "avg_nodes": 11632.133333333333, "eval_calls": 121716, "avg_eval_calls": 8114.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 121716, "pattern_eval_ns": 2592518, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.299730520227413, "pattern_frame_queries": 121716, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2592518, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.299730520227413, "pattern_frame_updates": 345798, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3202055852, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9259.902752473989, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49079, "avg_candidate_generations": 3271.9333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 4445186, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.57205729538092, "candidate_moves_max": 132, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1189, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 49064, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4443997, "search_candidate_moves_max": 132, "legality_checks": 1277156, "avg_legality_checks": 85143.73333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 161, "root_legality_checks": 1189, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1275967, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 161, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3987563, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 265837.5333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8377562532, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2100.92292761268, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17857, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1190.4666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 59874450, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3352.996023968192, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 290, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1887052, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5891, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37321893, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11583, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19880291, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 93, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 785214, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 69443, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4629.533333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 513696192, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7397.37903028383, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 87832, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5855.466666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 187242404, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2131.8244375626196, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2885530725, "stage_ordering_ns": 1719434016, "stage_eval_ns": 3204648370, "stage_threat_ns": 6412396846, "stage_proof_ns": 364632467, "tactical_annotations": 688037, "root_tactical_annotations": 3615, "search_tactical_annotations": 684422, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 347619, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1869658851, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 714666, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4241214449, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 99218, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3188040048, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 173802, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 234393558, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1806, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10380121, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 347604, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39915956, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 249560, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 103705998, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 313600, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 833331764, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 124877, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16833911, "child_limit_applications": 49064, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49064, "child_cap_hits": 49064, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49064, "child_moves_before_total": 4443836, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4443836, "child_moves_before_max": 132, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 132, "child_moves_after_total": 785028, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 785028, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.57223218653188, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0000815261699, "tt_hits": 18749, "tt_cutoffs": 2119, "beta_cutoffs": 41201, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5328.933333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5862.266666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1415, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 7233, "avg_search_time_ms": 516.6428571428571, "search_nodes": 535513, "safety_nodes": 1011, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 536524, "avg_nodes": 38323.142857142855, "eval_calls": 521220, "avg_eval_calls": 37230.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 521220, "line_shape_eval_ns": 667524814, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1280.696853535935, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14266, "avg_candidate_generations": 1019.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1277218, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.5288097574653, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1101, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 14252, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1276117, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 25351, "avg_legality_checks": 1810.7857142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 25351, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 41735, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2981.0714285714284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 94341095, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2260.479094285372, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 69463962, "stage_ordering_ns": 449171, "stage_eval_ns": 667524814, "stage_threat_ns": 6464835675, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1070958, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5653588895, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 190290, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 535472, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 686020161, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1070944, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 125036329, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 472, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 13049, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6315.642857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6887.071428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 721, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14762, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 98, 83, 115, 116, 69, 125, 139, 126, 129, 141, 84, 99, 70, 56, 96, 157, 109, 158, 82, 127, 130, 124 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 1752, "avg_search_time_ms": 146.0, "search_nodes": 105238, "safety_nodes": 1052, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 106290, "avg_nodes": 8857.5, "eval_calls": 102119, "avg_eval_calls": 8509.916666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 102119, "line_shape_eval_ns": 112690035, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1103.5168284060753, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3096, "avg_candidate_generations": 258.0, "candidate_moves_total": 227180, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.37855297157623, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 834, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 3084, "search_candidate_moves_total": 226346, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 90741, "avg_legality_checks": 7561.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 130, "root_legality_checks": 834, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 89907, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 127, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 105039, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8753.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 262003581, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2494.345728729329, "renju_forbidden_checks": 144, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1730289, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12015.895833333334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 130, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1581929, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 148360, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 824193, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11447.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.583333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 441512, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4286.52427184466, "stage_move_gen_ns": 239619974, "stage_ordering_ns": 107891, "stage_eval_ns": 112690035, "stage_threat_ns": 1384063192, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 210418, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1214855482, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1080734, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 105203, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 141711021, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 210406, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26415955, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 198, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2783, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6121.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6787.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1908, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 12997, "avg_search_time_ms": 1083.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 131780, "safety_nodes": 551, "corridor_nodes": 2410, "corridor_branch_probes": 2675, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1000, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2384, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2384, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 101, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 75, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1000, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 101, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 822, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 52004400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 134741, "avg_nodes": 11228.416666666666, "eval_calls": 104476, "avg_eval_calls": 8706.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 104476, "pattern_eval_ns": 2281659, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.839073088556223, "pattern_frame_queries": 104476, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2281659, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.839073088556223, "pattern_frame_updates": 263452, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2898817202, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11003.208182135646, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25584, "avg_candidate_generations": 2132.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2193814, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.74945278298937, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 854, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 25572, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2192960, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1339152, "avg_legality_checks": 111596.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7815, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1339152, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7815, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3566998, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 297249.8333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7731518383, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2167.5140785052304, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44390, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3699.1666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 400858273, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9030.373349853571, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7881, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 92568279, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22476, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 241044399, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13939, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 66059862, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 94, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1185733, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 121871, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10155.916666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1288867060, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10575.666565466763, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 174836, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14569.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 648290596, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3707.9926102175755, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3407082682, "stage_ordering_ns": 900868287, "stage_eval_ns": 2901098861, "stage_threat_ns": 5562629821, "stage_proof_ns": 161989537, "tactical_annotations": 471233, "root_tactical_annotations": 2200, "search_tactical_annotations": 469033, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 268434, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1616256012, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 554656, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3666848627, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52738, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1924562283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134211, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 199651353, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4970, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 30412604, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 268422, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33524693, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 148464, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 678612011, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 212163, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 950558988, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110606, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15936532, "child_limit_applications": 25572, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25572, "child_cap_hits": 25572, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25572, "child_moves_before_total": 2185145, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2185145, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 412222, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 412222, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.45068825277647, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.12005318316909, "tt_hits": 10935, "tt_cutoffs": 1678, "beta_cutoffs": 18690, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5164.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5830.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1867, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 722, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17414, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 125, 115, 127, 99, 123, 83, 67, 98, 100, 53, 95, 84, 110, 69, 55, 68, 38, 54, 39, 131, 147, 80, 71, 82, 81, 109, 87, 23, 103 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 15057, "avg_search_time_ms": 941.0625, "search_nodes": 129397, "safety_nodes": 990, "corridor_nodes": 17433, "corridor_branch_probes": 18639, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 11050, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 17403, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 17403, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 118, "corridor_proof_active": 30, "corridor_proof_quiet": 88, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 11050, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 118, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 117, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 886, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 25832640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 147820, "avg_nodes": 9238.75, "eval_calls": 96808, "avg_eval_calls": 6050.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 96808, "pattern_eval_ns": 2091400, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.603586480456162, "pattern_frame_queries": 96808, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2091400, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.603586480456162, "pattern_frame_updates": 258650, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2607785892, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10082.29612217282, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30921, "avg_candidate_generations": 1932.5625, "candidate_moves_total": 2481574, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.2552957536949, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1205, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 30905, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2480369, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1033927, "avg_legality_checks": 64620.4375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 79, "root_legality_checks": 1205, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1032722, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 79, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4404185, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 275261.5625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9300083943, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2111.646977363576, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37268, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2329.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 81819646, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2195.4396801545563, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 875, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1797921, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7648, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32658830, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22387, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 34753572, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6358, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 12609323, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 120229, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7514.3125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1062133980, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8834.257791381448, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 161492, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10093.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 489899874, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3033.5860228370448, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2458951426, "stage_ordering_ns": 975535815, "stage_eval_ns": 2609877292, "stage_threat_ns": 7679220272, "stage_proof_ns": 1273360543, "tactical_annotations": 420006, "root_tactical_annotations": 2297, "search_tactical_annotations": 417709, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 293708, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1945832466, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1007698, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5222342118, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 68646, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2517384451, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 146846, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 225769474, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 35042, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 237687766, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 293692, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36155023, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116307, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 137437995, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 211422, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 776355359, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 92277, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11433425, "child_limit_applications": 30905, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30905, "child_cap_hits": 30905, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30905, "child_moves_before_total": 2480290, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2480290, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 494949, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 494949, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.2552984953891, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.015175537938845, "tt_hits": 11990, "tt_cutoffs": 1612, "beta_cutoffs": 24581, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4983.0625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5483.0625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 2341, "avg_search_time_ms": 156.06666666666666, "search_nodes": 165573, "safety_nodes": 1301, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 166874, "avg_nodes": 11124.933333333332, "eval_calls": 160747, "avg_eval_calls": 10716.466666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 160747, "line_shape_eval_ns": 204844674, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1274.329685779517, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4797, "avg_candidate_generations": 319.8, "candidate_moves_total": 396366, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.62789243277048, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1144, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 4782, "search_candidate_moves_total": 395222, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 10789, "avg_legality_checks": 719.2666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10789, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 28011, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1867.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 64340851, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2296.9851486915854, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 30330536, "stage_ordering_ns": 164550, "stage_eval_ns": 204844674, "stage_threat_ns": 2086434393, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 331073, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1827320889, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 351462, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 165529, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 218659133, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 331058, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40102909, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 422, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4159, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6608.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7142.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 723, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13990, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 81, 129, 96, 130, 131, 157, 172, 141, 95, 98, 51, 111, 109, 67, 65, 49, 93, 94, 79, 37, 107 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 2046, "avg_search_time_ms": 170.5, "search_nodes": 121260, "safety_nodes": 1192, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122452, "avg_nodes": 10204.333333333334, "eval_calls": 118023, "avg_eval_calls": 9835.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 118023, "line_shape_eval_ns": 80735846, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 684.0687493115748, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3214, "avg_candidate_generations": 267.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 208263, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.79869321717486, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 837, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 3202, "search_candidate_moves_total": 207426, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 117033, "avg_legality_checks": 9752.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "root_legality_checks": 837, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 116196, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 131179, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10931.583333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 330486764, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2519.357244680932, "renju_forbidden_checks": 91, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7.583333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 733914, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8064.989010989011, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 47, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 383302, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 350612, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 70, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.833333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 648203, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9260.042857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 94, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.833333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 336052, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3575.021276595745, "stage_move_gen_ns": 312568672, "stage_ordering_ns": 97530, "stage_eval_ns": 80735846, "stage_threat_ns": 1643388137, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 242462, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1448449800, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 825094, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11210, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121225, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 163105024, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 242450, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31008219, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 113, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2996, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5905.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6572.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1921, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 11933, "avg_search_time_ms": 994.4166666666666, "search_nodes": 159486, "safety_nodes": 299, "corridor_nodes": 4246, "corridor_branch_probes": 4416, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 2026, "corridor_neutral_exits": 23, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 4223, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4223, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 57, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 27, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2026, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 57, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 419, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 22027920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1984400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 164031, "avg_nodes": 13669.25, "eval_calls": 127599, "avg_eval_calls": 10633.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 127599, "pattern_eval_ns": 2480663, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.44108496148089, "pattern_frame_queries": 127599, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2480663, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.44108496148089, "pattern_frame_updates": 318868, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2648049006, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8304.530420111143, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30102, "avg_candidate_generations": 2508.5, "candidate_moves_total": 2582929, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.8058932961265, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 856, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 30090, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2582073, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 1569746, "avg_legality_checks": 130812.16666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21050, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1569746, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 21050, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4186470, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 348872.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6828914629, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1631.1868063069842, "renju_forbidden_checks": 75423, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6285.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 474284263, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6288.3240258276655, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21050, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 148657350, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 35134, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 259872365, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19122, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 64722963, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 117, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1031585, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 154615, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12884.583333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1210887513, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7831.630262264334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 214314, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17859.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 603851297, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2817.6007960282577, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3032031378, "stage_ordering_ns": 817960359, "stage_eval_ns": 2650529669, "stage_threat_ns": 5285897711, "stage_proof_ns": 77736527, "tactical_annotations": 611761, "root_tactical_annotations": 2616, "search_tactical_annotations": 609145, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 327440, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1512592871, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 751124, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3491430869, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62503, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1823494886, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 163714, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 191975026, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8560, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 38335461, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 327428, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32901039, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 190471, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 655231682, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 274551, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 889287806, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 146739, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18662445, "child_limit_applications": 30090, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30090, "child_cap_hits": 30090, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30090, "child_moves_before_total": 2561023, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2561023, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 487850, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 487850, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.11209704220671, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.213027583914922, "tt_hits": 12690, "tt_cutoffs": 1745, "beta_cutoffs": 21813, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5560.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6226.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1620, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 724, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4830, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 97, 127, 128, 141, 155, 111, 156, 85, 99, 81, 114, 96 ], "move_count": 16, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 4407, "avg_search_time_ms": 734.5, "search_nodes": 48765, "safety_nodes": 253, "corridor_nodes": 251, "corridor_branch_probes": 273, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 131, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 249, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 249, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 20, "corridor_proof_active": 2, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 131, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 20, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 20, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 142, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 3680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49269, "avg_nodes": 8211.5, "eval_calls": 36770, "avg_eval_calls": 6128.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36770, "pattern_eval_ns": 749104, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.372695131901008, "pattern_frame_queries": 36770, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 749104, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.372695131901008, "pattern_frame_updates": 97478, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1015866637, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10421.496512033484, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11247, "avg_candidate_generations": 1874.5, "candidate_moves_total": 715450, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.612518893927266, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 315, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 11241, "search_candidate_moves_total": 715135, "search_candidate_moves_max": 86, "legality_checks": 398647, "avg_legality_checks": 66441.16666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 103, "root_legality_checks": 315, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 398332, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 102, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1203391, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 200565.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2699899166, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2243.575999820507, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5140, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 856.6666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18779196, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3653.540077821012, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 111, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1132734, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1767, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12813541, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3218, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4692481, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 140440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 30629, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5104.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 271331899, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8858.660060726763, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 43457, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7242.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 113338171, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2608.053271049543, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1004211751, "stage_ordering_ns": 321209954, "stage_eval_ns": 1016615741, "stage_threat_ns": 1985730121, "stage_proof_ns": 57815885, "tactical_annotations": 89370, "root_tactical_annotations": 585, "search_tactical_annotations": 88785, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 98022, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 581520398, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 110841, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1316851410, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22698, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 921824451, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 49008, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 70122400, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 538, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2780105, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 98016, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12441240, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 9281, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 15974473, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 66316, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 347140879, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 13773, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2014568, "child_limit_applications": 11241, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11241, "child_cap_hits": 11241, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11241, "child_moves_before_total": 715033, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 715033, "child_moves_before_max": 86, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 86, "child_moves_after_total": 179856, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 179856, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 63.60937639000089, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 2889, "tt_cutoffs": 729, "beta_cutoffs": 8866, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1892.3333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3163.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 417, "avg_search_time_ms": 69.5, "search_nodes": 29110, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 29496, "avg_nodes": 4916.0, "eval_calls": 28030, "avg_eval_calls": 4671.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 28030, "line_shape_eval_ns": 21926135, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 782.2381377095969, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1070, "avg_candidate_generations": 178.33333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 67833, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.39532710280374, "candidate_moves_max": 84, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 327, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 1064, "search_candidate_moves_total": 67506, "search_candidate_moves_max": 84, "legality_checks": 2087, "avg_legality_checks": 347.8333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2087, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8994, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1499.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20227201, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2248.966088503447, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.6666666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 189050, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11815.625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 48310, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 140740, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6339493, "stage_ordering_ns": 34850, "stage_eval_ns": 21926135, "stage_threat_ns": 383155146, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 58194, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 337028641, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 120663, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 11, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5801, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 29094, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 38860291, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 58188, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7145551, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 109, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 874, "depth_sum": 16, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 16, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4534.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5868.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 725, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15201, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 81, 143, 67, 52, 95, 159, 175, 53, 80, 83, 113, 68, 38, 65, 96, 128, 110, 129, 94, 93, 126, 131, 130, 142, 66, 144, 140, 125, 109, 123, 124, 138, 139, 79, 154 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 6804, "avg_search_time_ms": 358.10526315789474, "search_nodes": 441941, "safety_nodes": 1783, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 443724, "avg_nodes": 23353.894736842107, "eval_calls": 431515, "avg_eval_calls": 22711.315789473683, "line_shape_eval_calls": 431515, "line_shape_eval_ns": 741999308, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1719.5214720229887, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10390, "avg_candidate_generations": 546.8421052631579, "candidate_moves_total": 975912, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.92800769971126, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1513, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 10371, "search_candidate_moves_total": 974399, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 429499, "avg_legality_checks": 22605.21052631579, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2911, "root_legality_checks": 1513, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 427986, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2901, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 451556, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23766.105263157893, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 956347957, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2117.8944737751244, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3073, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 161.73684210526315, "renju_forbidden_ns": 7168800, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2332.8343638138626, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3024, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7076350, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 49, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 92450, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 114, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 824082, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7228.789473684211, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 136, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.157894736842105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 273670, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2012.2794117647059, "stage_move_gen_ns": 948276347, "stage_ordering_ns": 323991, "stage_eval_ns": 741999308, "stage_threat_ns": 5049842003, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 883791, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4392902279, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1305394, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19670, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 441886, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 556863803, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 883772, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 98770527, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 535, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9306, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6914.578947368421, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7335.631578947368, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1923, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 8379, "avg_search_time_ms": 465.5, "search_nodes": 60030, "safety_nodes": 1888, "corridor_nodes": 6121, "corridor_branch_probes": 6750, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 39, "corridor_depth_exits": 2775, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 6094, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3368, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 2726, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 43, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2775, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 2, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 335, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 134680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 68039, "avg_nodes": 3779.9444444444443, "eval_calls": 39911, "avg_eval_calls": 2217.277777777778, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39911, "pattern_eval_ns": 845531, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.18541254290797, "pattern_frame_queries": 39911, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 845531, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.18541254290797, "pattern_frame_updates": 119890, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1187725540, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9906.794061222787, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19205, "avg_candidate_generations": 1066.9444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 1758404, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.55969799531373, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1437, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 19187, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1756967, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1183953, "avg_legality_checks": 65775.16666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6103, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1183953, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6103, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2748977, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 152720.94444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5423223487, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1972.8151552377485, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23552, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1308.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42808721, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1817.6257218070652, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6132, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9375373, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5781, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19816090, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11179, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12885217, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 460, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 732041, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 128676, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7148.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 809495786, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6290.961686717025, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 143467, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7970.388888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 211060996, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1471.1466469641102, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2593771809, "stage_ordering_ns": 634329506, "stage_eval_ns": 1188571071, "stage_threat_ns": 3764365959, "stage_proof_ns": 136843573, "tactical_annotations": 448378, "root_tactical_annotations": 1261, "search_tactical_annotations": 447117, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 132224, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 869058567, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 616140, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2676031368, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42602, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1361119062, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66103, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 101944443, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12316, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 88243290, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 132206, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16303238, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 160558, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 419718964, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 196411, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 650549665, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 91409, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12785053, "child_limit_applications": 19187, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19187, "child_cap_hits": 19187, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19187, "child_moves_before_total": 1750864, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1750864, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 332959, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 332959, "child_moves_after_max": 32, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 32, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.25261896075467, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.353364257049044, "tt_hits": 7766, "tt_cutoffs": 847, "beta_cutoffs": 16913, "depth_sum": 85, "avg_depth": 4.722222222222222, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 85, "avg_effective_depth": 4.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6649.055555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7093.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1852, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 726, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9537, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 127, 97, 96, 83, 69, 113, 68, 125, 139, 128, 143, 110, 67, 70, 84, 95, 54, 40, 39, 99, 24 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8527, "avg_search_time_ms": 775.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 102048, "safety_nodes": 693, "corridor_nodes": 899, "corridor_branch_probes": 1020, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 354, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 885, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 885, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 41, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 354, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 417, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23883040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1984800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 103640, "avg_nodes": 9421.818181818182, "eval_calls": 80112, "avg_eval_calls": 7282.909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80112, "pattern_eval_ns": 1671968, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.870381465947673, "pattern_frame_queries": 80112, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1671968, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.870381465947673, "pattern_frame_updates": 204002, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2259112139, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11073.970544406428, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20553, "avg_candidate_generations": 1868.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 1463279, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.19539726560599, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 677, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 20542, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1462602, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 736518, "avg_legality_checks": 66956.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 148, "root_legality_checks": 677, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 735841, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 148, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2445334, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 222303.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5178236529, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2117.598875654614, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13244, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1204.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 38668722, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2919.7162488674117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 253, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1547026, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5721, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28197287, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7234, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8868909, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 36, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55500, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64365, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5851.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 542023337, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8421.088122426785, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 88650, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8059.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 229530565, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2589.1772701635646, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1771148803, "stage_ordering_ns": 589857875, "stage_eval_ns": 2260784107, "stage_threat_ns": 3662738235, "stage_proof_ns": 198549146, "tactical_annotations": 272481, "root_tactical_annotations": 1194, "search_tactical_annotations": 271287, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 205893, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1159983885, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 323752, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2317282711, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41770, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1440682866, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102941, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 143803439, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1880, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10404141, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 205882, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24542329, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 65313, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 67688379, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 160971, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 687754274, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 46197, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6721730, "child_limit_applications": 20542, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20542, "child_cap_hits": 20542, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20542, "child_moves_before_total": 1462454, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1462454, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 328688, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 328688, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.19335994547755, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000778892026094, "tt_hits": 6500, "tt_cutoffs": 1348, "beta_cutoffs": 15373, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4770.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5498.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 1000, "avg_search_time_ms": 100.0, "search_nodes": 72666, "safety_nodes": 742, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 73408, "avg_nodes": 7340.8, "eval_calls": 70400, "avg_eval_calls": 7040.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 70400, "line_shape_eval_ns": 68635162, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 974.931278409091, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2247, "avg_candidate_generations": 224.7, "candidate_moves_total": 157538, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.11036938139742, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 623, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 2237, "search_candidate_moves_total": 156915, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 4467, "avg_legality_checks": 446.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4467, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16070, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1607.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 34665739, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2157.171064094586, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12183920, "stage_ordering_ns": 74281, "stage_eval_ns": 68635162, "stage_threat_ns": 906324258, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 145284, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 796089090, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 215971, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10610, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72637, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92828148, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 145274, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17191049, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 186, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1949, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5887.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6687.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 727, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18366, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 140, 97, 100, 114, 141, 84, 70, 143, 139, 138, 55, 115, 113, 99, 129, 83, 131, 130, 82, 96, 95, 111, 125, 110, 109, 124, 152, 67, 51, 66, 81, 146, 162, 69, 54, 68, 65, 53, 38, 86, 93, 157, 77 ], "move_count": 48, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 5115, "avg_search_time_ms": 232.5, "search_nodes": 330175, "safety_nodes": 2570, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 332745, "avg_nodes": 15124.772727272728, "eval_calls": 321876, "avg_eval_calls": 14630.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 321876, "line_shape_eval_ns": 537512994, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1669.9380941729114, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8256, "avg_candidate_generations": 375.27272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 746516, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.42102713178295, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1815, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 8234, "search_candidate_moves_total": 744701, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 313014, "avg_legality_checks": 14227.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1009, "root_legality_checks": 1815, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 311199, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1000, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 338434, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15383.363636363636, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 729196468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2154.6194176708013, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1473, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 66.95454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13485024, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9154.802443991854, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1429, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13061422, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 423602, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 104, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 816832, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7854.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 361900, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2741.6666666666665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 716792735, "stage_ordering_ns": 270350, "stage_eval_ns": 537512994, "stage_threat_ns": 3811727964, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 660242, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3324373259, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1262383, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 21571, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 330110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 411294253, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 660220, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74798069, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 500, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7263, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 2.9545454545454546, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7047.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7410.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1912, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 13232, "avg_search_time_ms": 601.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 121783, "safety_nodes": 1653, "corridor_nodes": 4006, "corridor_branch_probes": 4317, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 2015, "corridor_neutral_exits": 39, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 3967, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3967, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 20, "corridor_proof_completed": 20, "corridor_proof_checks": 124, "corridor_proof_active": 39, "corridor_proof_quiet": 85, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 40, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2015, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 124, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 122, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 873, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 590080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 127442, "avg_nodes": 5792.818181818182, "eval_calls": 88240, "avg_eval_calls": 4010.909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 88240, "pattern_eval_ns": 1812834, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.54435630099728, "pattern_frame_queries": 88240, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1812834, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.54435630099728, "pattern_frame_updates": 243358, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2720106800, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11177.388045595379, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31409, "avg_candidate_generations": 1427.6818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2713066, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.37861759368334, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1829, "root_candidate_moves_max": 115, "search_candidate_generations": 31387, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2711237, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 1628341, "avg_legality_checks": 74015.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11247, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1628341, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11247, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3996013, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 181636.95454545456, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8019956077, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2006.9894860201907, "renju_forbidden_checks": 93011, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4227.772727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 510910765, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5493.014428400942, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 20395, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 118193283, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34884, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 281369168, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37484, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 109102309, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 248, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2246005, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 132596, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6027.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1135489632, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8563.528552897524, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 172332, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7833.272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 480640382, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2789.037334911682, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3754448066, "stage_ordering_ns": 996536557, "stage_eval_ns": 2721919634, "stage_threat_ns": 5522450479, "stage_proof_ns": 181218244, "tactical_annotations": 653182, "root_tactical_annotations": 2570, "search_tactical_annotations": 650612, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 251562, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1442203340, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 771643, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3801189729, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 65179, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2129012179, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 125770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 178354114, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8182, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 53471759, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 251540, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29937036, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 232697, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 564898727, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 288345, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 980777165, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 132140, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17294501, "child_limit_applications": 31387, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31387, "child_cap_hits": 31387, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31387, "child_moves_before_total": 2699990, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2699990, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 503970, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 503970, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.02255710963138, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.056647656673146, "tt_hits": 12738, "tt_cutoffs": 2052, "beta_cutoffs": 25621, "depth_sum": 104, "avg_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 104, "avg_effective_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6257.227272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6620.863636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1767, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 728, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9345, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 114, 127, 113, 111, 126, 84, 130, 82, 85, 95, 115, 116, 100, 70, 145 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 8591, "avg_search_time_ms": 1073.875, "search_nodes": 94191, "safety_nodes": 343, "corridor_nodes": 2649, "corridor_branch_probes": 3001, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 974, "corridor_neutral_exits": 41, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 2616, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2616, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 81, "corridor_proof_active": 33, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 41, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 974, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 81, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 80, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 681, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 65749120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1993120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 97183, "avg_nodes": 12147.875, "eval_calls": 76057, "avg_eval_calls": 9507.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 76057, "pattern_eval_ns": 1549637, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.37467951667828, "pattern_frame_queries": 76057, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1549637, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.37467951667828, "pattern_frame_updates": 188318, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2354445264, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12502.497180301405, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17066, "avg_candidate_generations": 2133.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1158720, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.89640220321107, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 458, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 17058, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1158262, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 536204, "avg_legality_checks": 67025.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 155, "root_legality_checks": 458, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 535746, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 155, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2418179, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 302272.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5240918220, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2167.299534070886, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13777, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1722.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66913836, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4856.92356826595, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 246, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1842586, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6956, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 54649913, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6546, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10247896, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 173441, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 63826, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7978.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 564013235, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8836.731661078556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84291, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10536.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 240600683, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2854.4053694937775, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1322380281, "stage_ordering_ns": 504351267, "stage_eval_ns": 2355994901, "stage_threat_ns": 3908405823, "stage_proof_ns": 474782986, "tactical_annotations": 220830, "root_tactical_annotations": 1290, "search_tactical_annotations": 219540, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 193720, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1148171924, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 383361, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2561894250, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35743, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1442363108, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 96856, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 141098387, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5394, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26319972, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 193712, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24384121, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 47175, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 122400919, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 124269, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 573291343, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49386, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6537169, "child_limit_applications": 17058, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17058, "child_cap_hits": 17058, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17058, "child_moves_before_total": 1158107, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1158107, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 273118, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 273118, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.89230859420799, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.011138468753664, "tt_hits": 6697, "tt_cutoffs": 1044, "beta_cutoffs": 12033, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1659.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2588.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 316, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 746, "avg_search_time_ms": 106.57142857142857, "search_nodes": 54177, "safety_nodes": 429, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 54606, "avg_nodes": 7800.857142857143, "eval_calls": 52560, "avg_eval_calls": 7508.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 52560, "line_shape_eval_ns": 46805230, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 890.5104642313546, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1604, "avg_candidate_generations": 229.14285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 109904, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.51870324189527, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 393, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 1597, "search_candidate_moves_total": 109511, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 4659, "avg_legality_checks": 665.5714285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4659, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12701, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1814.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 28165647, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2217.592866703409, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12666383, "stage_ordering_ns": 53200, "stage_eval_ns": 46805230, "stage_threat_ns": 677844048, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 108321, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 596380579, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 146081, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 54157, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68352965, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 108314, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12964423, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 115, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1416, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5034.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6177.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1845, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 729, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16249, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 97, 95, 125, 142, 94, 111, 67, 127, 82, 52, 79, 143, 159, 158, 174, 50, 65, 144, 141, 51, 53, 48, 81, 49 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3276, "avg_search_time_ms": 252.0, "search_nodes": 206424, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 207397, "avg_nodes": 15953.615384615385, "eval_calls": 201436, "avg_eval_calls": 15495.076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 201436, "line_shape_eval_ns": 151106216, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 750.1450386226891, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4963, "avg_candidate_generations": 381.7692307692308, "candidate_moves_total": 335358, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.57163006246222, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 844, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 4950, "search_candidate_moves_total": 334514, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 197145, "avg_legality_checks": 15165.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 274, "root_legality_checks": 844, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 196301, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 266, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 212143, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16318.692307692309, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 508961759, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2399.1447231348666, "renju_forbidden_checks": 308, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 23.692307692307693, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3080784, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10002.545454545454, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 274, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2734053, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 346731, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.8461538461538463, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 360692, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9748.432432432432, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.8461538461538463, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 177381, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3547.62, "stage_move_gen_ns": 494108992, "stage_ordering_ns": 156122, "stage_eval_ns": 151106216, "stage_threat_ns": 2614867811, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 412785, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2301299670, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 599725, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 206386, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 263435078, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 412772, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49533338, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 174, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4648, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5878.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6493.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1865, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 12961, "avg_search_time_ms": 997.0, "search_nodes": 123153, "safety_nodes": 361, "corridor_nodes": 1983, "corridor_branch_probes": 2152, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 769, "corridor_neutral_exits": 22, "corridor_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_plies_followed": 1956, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1956, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 81, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 769, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 81, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 77, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 587, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6412080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1976480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 125497, "avg_nodes": 9653.615384615385, "eval_calls": 87734, "avg_eval_calls": 6748.7692307692305, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87734, "pattern_eval_ns": 1828877, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.845704059999544, "pattern_frame_queries": 87734, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1828877, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.845704059999544, "pattern_frame_updates": 246188, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2193421358, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8909.538068468, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33399, "avg_candidate_generations": 2569.153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 2635764, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.91745261834187, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 871, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 33386, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2634893, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1680948, "avg_legality_checks": 129303.69230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11552, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1680948, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11552, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3958921, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 304532.3846153846, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8041513044, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2031.2385733385436, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31554, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2427.230769230769, "renju_forbidden_ns": 237927914, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7540.340812575268, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11796, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 119080310, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8468, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 83220363, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11223, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 34921980, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 705261, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 122818, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9447.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1164588069, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9482.226294191405, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 177476, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13652.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 578508747, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3259.6449491762264, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3979263330, "stage_ordering_ns": 1023127555, "stage_eval_ns": 2195250235, "stage_threat_ns": 5561998030, "stage_proof_ns": 123125206, "tactical_annotations": 565451, "root_tactical_annotations": 2957, "search_tactical_annotations": 562494, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 250275, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1414084343, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 622426, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3906478536, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 68187, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2284950891, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 125131, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 175716529, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4074, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20659812, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 250262, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29608113, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 178240, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 624135153, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 252032, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 905577271, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 135179, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15450697, "child_limit_applications": 33386, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33386, "child_cap_hits": 33386, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33386, "child_moves_before_total": 2623341, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2623341, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 534412, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 534412, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.5760797939256, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00706883124663, "tt_hits": 14394, "tt_cutoffs": 1974, "beta_cutoffs": 27656, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5332.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5948.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1729, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 730, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18291, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 142, 111, 156, 114, 96, 80, 127, 97, 172, 157, 140, 124, 144, 160, 158, 130, 143, 141, 173, 188, 113 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 17963, "avg_search_time_ms": 1633.0, "search_nodes": 200795, "safety_nodes": 82, "corridor_nodes": 5465, "corridor_branch_probes": 5999, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2397, "corridor_neutral_exits": 28, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 5419, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5419, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 114, "corridor_proof_active": 46, "corridor_proof_quiet": 68, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2397, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 114, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 112, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 954, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 71511360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1992960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 206342, "avg_nodes": 18758.363636363636, "eval_calls": 163063, "avg_eval_calls": 14823.90909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 163063, "pattern_eval_ns": 3373884, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.690677836173748, "pattern_frame_queries": 163063, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3373884, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.690677836173748, "pattern_frame_updates": 401496, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5119260148, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12750.463636001356, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35505, "avg_candidate_generations": 3227.7272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 2812390, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.21109702858752, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 728, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 35494, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2811662, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1188338, "avg_legality_checks": 108030.72727272728, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1390, "root_legality_checks": 728, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1187610, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1389, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4982387, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 452944.2727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10649245385, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2137.3782054665767, "renju_forbidden_checks": 79297, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7208.818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 294561474, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3714.661008613188, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2512, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12563269, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 42356, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 211399975, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 33347, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 65316360, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1082, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5281870, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 141861, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12896.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1181756246, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8330.381472004286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 179657, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16332.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 474840601, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2643.039798059636, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2903438222, "stage_ordering_ns": 1177439278, "stage_eval_ns": 5122634032, "stage_threat_ns": 7920946017, "stage_proof_ns": 788140874, "tactical_annotations": 589508, "root_tactical_annotations": 2918, "search_tactical_annotations": 586590, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 412573, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2434711419, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 844959, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5055317842, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 74019, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2787716891, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 206281, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 301537701, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 11066, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 60523071, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 412562, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51298515, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 160759, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 284607779, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 294206, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1227650899, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 134543, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17557469, "child_limit_applications": 35494, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35494, "child_cap_hits": 35494, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35494, "child_moves_before_total": 2810273, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2810273, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 568364, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 568364, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.17600157773144, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01295993689074, "tt_hits": 14496, "tt_cutoffs": 2191, "beta_cutoffs": 24742, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 673.8181818181819, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1049.7272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 144, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 316, "avg_search_time_ms": 31.6, "search_nodes": 21006, "safety_nodes": 927, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 21933, "avg_nodes": 2193.3, "eval_calls": 19922, "avg_eval_calls": 1992.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 19922, "line_shape_eval_ns": 16956826, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 851.1608272261822, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1065, "avg_candidate_generations": 106.5, "candidate_moves_total": 73941, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.4281690140845, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 664, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 1055, "search_candidate_moves_total": 73277, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 2557, "avg_legality_checks": 255.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2557, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14243, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1424.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30327502, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2129.291722249526, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 7270, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1211.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2580, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4690, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7167606, "stage_ordering_ns": 34611, "stage_eval_ns": 16956826, "stage_threat_ns": 281479310, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 41964, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 248681258, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 231451, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 20977, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 27448156, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 41954, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5118445, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 59, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 944, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5944.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6744.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1903, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 731, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17995, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 113, 83, 81, 110, 68, 97, 114, 111, 115, 116, 69, 125, 139, 124, 138, 86, 85, 140, 95, 101, 131, 56, 99, 71 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 4835, "avg_search_time_ms": 371.9230769230769, "search_nodes": 289621, "safety_nodes": 963, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 290584, "avg_nodes": 22352.615384615383, "eval_calls": 283374, "avg_eval_calls": 21798.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 283374, "line_shape_eval_ns": 244365526, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 862.3427907994381, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6222, "avg_candidate_generations": 478.61538461538464, "candidate_moves_total": 422992, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.98328511732562, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 839, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 6209, "search_candidate_moves_total": 422153, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 278442, "avg_legality_checks": 21418.615384615383, "illegal_moves_skipped": 256, "root_legality_checks": 839, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 277603, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 248, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 293422, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22570.923076923078, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 738816912, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2517.93291573229, "renju_forbidden_checks": 290, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 22.307692307692307, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2988251, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10304.313793103449, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 256, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2629166, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 359085, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.8461538461538463, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 395892, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10699.783783783783, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.8461538461538463, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 192290, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3845.8, "stage_move_gen_ns": 728065535, "stage_ordering_ns": 190480, "stage_eval_ns": 244365526, "stage_threat_ns": 3853292290, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 579179, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3383498486, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 649793, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 289583, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 395195094, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 579166, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 73948917, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 174, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5807, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5702.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6317.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1758, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 13145, "avg_search_time_ms": 1011.1538461538462, "search_nodes": 115373, "safety_nodes": 351, "corridor_nodes": 1959, "corridor_branch_probes": 2094, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 755, "corridor_neutral_exits": 30, "corridor_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_plies_followed": 1933, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1933, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 81, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 55, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 755, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 81, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 77, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 587, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6537200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1975760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 117683, "avg_nodes": 9052.538461538461, "eval_calls": 82295, "avg_eval_calls": 6330.384615384615, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82295, "pattern_eval_ns": 1816254, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.07004070721186, "pattern_frame_queries": 82295, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1816254, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.07004070721186, "pattern_frame_updates": 230628, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2195614913, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9520.157626133861, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31118, "avg_candidate_generations": 2393.6923076923076, "candidate_moves_total": 2475835, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.56279323864001, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 866, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 31105, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2474969, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 1666961, "avg_legality_checks": 128227.76923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11344, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1666961, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11344, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3824350, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 294180.76923076925, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8194514307, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2142.720804058206, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33103, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2546.3846153846152, "renju_forbidden_ns": 249811153, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7546.480772135456, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11474, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 117462078, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10035, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 95071500, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11527, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36553001, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 724574, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 119250, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9173.076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1200062639, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10063.41835639413, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 173161, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13320.076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 599603230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3462.6921188951324, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4180908408, "stage_ordering_ns": 997504775, "stage_eval_ns": 2197431167, "stage_threat_ns": 5546656613, "stage_proof_ns": 136404215, "tactical_annotations": 548087, "root_tactical_annotations": 2957, "search_tactical_annotations": 545130, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 234669, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1423853421, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 597794, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3873318593, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 63634, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2223609004, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 117328, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 180683148, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4028, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22108206, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 234656, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30160120, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 180373, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 674487305, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 231255, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 879636008, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 136459, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16533125, "child_limit_applications": 31105, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31105, "child_cap_hits": 31105, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31105, "child_moves_before_total": 2463625, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2463625, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 497861, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 497861, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.20350425976531, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.005819000160745, "tt_hits": 14259, "tt_cutoffs": 1914, "beta_cutoffs": 25728, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5463.307692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6078.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1859, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 732, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13541, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 81, 68, 111, 54, 40, 113, 142, 94, 127, 97, 95, 85, 86, 79, 140, 154, 125, 80, 155 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 12655, "avg_search_time_ms": 1054.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 122250, "safety_nodes": 337, "corridor_nodes": 4151, "corridor_branch_probes": 4624, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1786, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 4117, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4117, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 88, "corridor_proof_active": 34, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1786, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 88, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 85, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 694, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24129840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 126738, "avg_nodes": 10561.5, "eval_calls": 92734, "avg_eval_calls": 7727.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 92734, "pattern_eval_ns": 2003795, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.607986283348072, "pattern_frame_queries": 92734, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2003795, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.607986283348072, "pattern_frame_updates": 244396, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3240689940, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13259.995826445605, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27837, "avg_candidate_generations": 2319.75, "candidate_moves_total": 2251917, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.89654057549305, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 842, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 27825, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2251075, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 802832, "avg_legality_checks": 66902.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2483, "root_legality_checks": 842, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 801990, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2481, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3494198, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 291183.1666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7650339129, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2189.4406467521303, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42554, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3546.1666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 242248759, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5692.737674484185, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2648, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25342465, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22443, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 151687391, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16279, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 51367271, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1184, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13851632, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 103780, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8648.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 935651173, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9015.717604548083, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 138219, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11518.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 395665166, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2862.5960685578684, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2008551338, "stage_ordering_ns": 904894225, "stage_eval_ns": 3242693735, "stage_threat_ns": 5818212716, "stage_proof_ns": 634009233, "tactical_annotations": 501417, "root_tactical_annotations": 2434, "search_tactical_annotations": 498983, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 252818, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1549982472, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 675986, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3979049466, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58006, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2168931250, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 126403, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 188881099, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8410, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 51700930, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 252806, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32163716, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 153610, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 269910017, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 223393, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 877927975, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 124414, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16435033, "child_limit_applications": 27825, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27825, "child_cap_hits": 27825, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27825, "child_moves_before_total": 2248594, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2248594, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 454005, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 454005, "child_moves_after_max": 29, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 29, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.81200359389038, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.31644204851752, "tt_hits": 12034, "tt_cutoffs": 1639, "beta_cutoffs": 22012, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4512.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5178.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 820, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 872, "avg_search_time_ms": 79.27272727272727, "search_nodes": 64480, "safety_nodes": 1137, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 65617, "avg_nodes": 5965.181818181818, "eval_calls": 61836, "avg_eval_calls": 5621.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 61836, "line_shape_eval_ns": 53676460, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 868.0454751277573, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2623, "avg_candidate_generations": 238.45454545454547, "candidate_moves_total": 191745, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.10141059855128, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 774, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 2612, "search_candidate_moves_total": 190971, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 7827, "avg_legality_checks": 711.5454545454545, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7827, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20690, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1880.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 46529979, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2248.9115031416145, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.1818181818181819, "renju_forbidden_ns": 162613, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12508.692307692309, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 64611, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 98002, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 21803914, "stage_ordering_ns": 86340, "stage_eval_ns": 53676460, "stage_threat_ns": 780732369, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 128907, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 683722685, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 348611, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11600, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64448, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81701544, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128896, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14959529, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 137, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2396, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6058.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6785.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 733, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17622, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 144, 111, 66, 82, 129, 80, 64, 99, 159, 174, 63, 67, 97, 81, 83, 95, 53, 68, 110, 126, 141, 127, 62, 65, 60, 61, 109, 142, 94, 158, 190, 157, 172, 50, 35, 54, 40, 125, 124, 143, 79 ], "move_count": 46, "black_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 4537, "avg_search_time_ms": 216.04761904761904, "search_nodes": 414729, "safety_nodes": 1866, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 416595, "avg_nodes": 19837.85714285714, "eval_calls": 404430, "avg_eval_calls": 19258.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 404430, "line_shape_eval_ns": 448685603, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1109.4271023415672, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10258, "avg_candidate_generations": 488.4761904761905, "candidate_moves_total": 929723, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.63394423864301, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1692, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 10237, "search_candidate_moves_total": 928031, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 389043, "avg_legality_checks": 18525.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1768, "root_legality_checks": 1692, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "search_legality_checks": 387351, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1750, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 413181, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19675.285714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 616290335, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1491.5747214900975, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2103, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 100.14285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8536208, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4059.0622919638613, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2018, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8064464, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 85, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 471744, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.285714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 742844, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8253.822222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 122, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.809523809523809, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 370041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3033.122950819672, "stage_move_gen_ns": 609782617, "stage_ordering_ns": 319280, "stage_eval_ns": 448685603, "stage_threat_ns": 3387672265, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 829355, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2926269749, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 60, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 967455, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 414667, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 392080251, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 829334, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 68354810, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 570, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9130, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 2.9523809523809526, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9523809523809526, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6994.476190476191, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7375.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1910, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 13065, "avg_search_time_ms": 622.1428571428571, "search_nodes": 139358, "safety_nodes": 1458, "corridor_nodes": 1426, "corridor_branch_probes": 1715, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 479, "corridor_neutral_exits": 51, "corridor_terminal_exits": 32, "corridor_plies_followed": 1390, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1390, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 19, "corridor_proof_completed": 19, "corridor_proof_checks": 153, "corridor_proof_active": 36, "corridor_proof_quiet": 117, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 62, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 479, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 32, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 153, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 153, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1142, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 616840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 142242, "avg_nodes": 6773.428571428572, "eval_calls": 98779, "avg_eval_calls": 4703.761904761905, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 98779, "pattern_eval_ns": 2092656, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.185231678798125, "pattern_frame_queries": 98779, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2092656, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.185231678798125, "pattern_frame_updates": 278518, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2290667689, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8224.487067263157, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37815, "avg_candidate_generations": 1800.7142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 3368956, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.09046674600026, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1702, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 37794, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3367254, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 2221924, "avg_legality_checks": 105805.90476190476, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16156, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2221924, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16156, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4807686, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 228937.42857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8118335867, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1688.6160758002914, "renju_forbidden_checks": 50800, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2419.0476190476193, "renju_forbidden_ns": 199730556, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3931.7038582677164, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16494, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 63806645, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13889, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 87214292, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20025, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 46139073, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 392, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2570546, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 174673, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8317.761904761905, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1254776944, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7183.576992437297, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 221836, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10563.619047619048, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 542832157, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2446.9975883084803, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4089811002, "stage_ordering_ns": 1006458102, "stage_eval_ns": 2292760345, "stage_threat_ns": 5324275343, "stage_proof_ns": 223862770, "tactical_annotations": 849509, "root_tactical_annotations": 3114, "search_tactical_annotations": 846395, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 281625, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1403918617, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 834536, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3672416655, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 77012, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1968408769, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 140802, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 181882711, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3086, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15507118, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 281604, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30032284, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 326791, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 692267347, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 343225, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 965367867, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 179493, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20517958, "child_limit_applications": 37794, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37794, "child_cap_hits": 37794, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37794, "child_moves_before_total": 3351098, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3351098, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 604891, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 604891, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.66746044345663, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.004947875324124, "tt_hits": 16551, "tt_cutoffs": 2686, "beta_cutoffs": 31347, "depth_sum": 99, "avg_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 99, "avg_effective_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09523809523809523, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6221.619047619048, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6602.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1836, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 734, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7316, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 82, 99, 68, 54, 144, 84, 69, 128, 97, 67, 111, 83, 110, 124, 109, 113, 108 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7025, "avg_search_time_ms": 780.5555555555555, "search_nodes": 90318, "safety_nodes": 403, "corridor_nodes": 2504, "corridor_branch_probes": 2910, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 938, "corridor_neutral_exits": 44, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2467, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2467, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 74, "corridor_proof_active": 37, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 44, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 938, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 74, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 72, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 582, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 45830000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1986240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 8, "total_nodes": 93225, "avg_nodes": 10358.333333333334, "eval_calls": 71153, "avg_eval_calls": 7905.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71153, "pattern_eval_ns": 1447337, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.34119432771633, "pattern_frame_queries": 71153, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1447337, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.34119432771633, "pattern_frame_updates": 180562, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2006624249, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11113.214568956924, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17923, "avg_candidate_generations": 1991.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 1238264, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.08798750209229, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 544, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 17914, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1237720, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 546692, "avg_legality_checks": 60743.555555555555, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1346, "root_legality_checks": 544, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 546148, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1345, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2408131, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 267570.1111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4218662438, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1751.8409247669665, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22081, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2453.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 117154798, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5305.683528825687, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1457, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15277740, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11135, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 81320899, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9210, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17424690, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 279, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3131469, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 62942, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6993.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 454506168, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7221.031552858187, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84799, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9422.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 202012293, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2382.2485288741614, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1068360991, "stage_ordering_ns": 410908209, "stage_eval_ns": 2008071586, "stage_threat_ns": 3115097803, "stage_proof_ns": 384020044, "tactical_annotations": 242053, "root_tactical_annotations": 1398, "search_tactical_annotations": 240655, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 185653, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 912293126, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 387535, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2038716612, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37323, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1109805972, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92822, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 115113760, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5082, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22840738, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 185644, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19537164, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 54781, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 91518604, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 131373, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 476913542, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 55899, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6596403, "child_limit_applications": 17914, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17914, "child_cap_hits": 17914, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17914, "child_moves_before_total": 1236375, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1236375, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 286755, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 286755, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.01724907893268, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.007312716311265, "tt_hits": 7379, "tt_cutoffs": 1214, "beta_cutoffs": 13213, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3998.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4887.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1045, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 283, "avg_search_time_ms": 35.375, "search_nodes": 23951, "safety_nodes": 740, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 24691, "avg_nodes": 3086.375, "eval_calls": 23023, "avg_eval_calls": 2877.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 23023, "line_shape_eval_ns": 14659267, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 636.7227120705381, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 913, "avg_candidate_generations": 114.125, "candidate_moves_total": 59755, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.44906900328587, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 492, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 905, "search_candidate_moves_total": 59263, "search_candidate_moves_max": 88, "legality_checks": 2418, "avg_legality_checks": 302.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2418, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11653, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1456.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22780599, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1954.9128121513772, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 106630, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 13328.75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52050, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 54580, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5739390, "stage_ordering_ns": 29520, "stage_eval_ns": 14659267, "stage_threat_ns": 250643162, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 47864, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 220113408, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 162641, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7680, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 23928, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 25620406, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 47856, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4746707, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 62, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 807, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5429.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6429.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1916, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 735, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18151, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 144, 97, 94, 110, 143, 80, 64, 141, 145, 146, 49, 109, 111, 95, 125, 81, 123, 124, 82, 98, 99, 113, 129, 114, 115, 130, 162, 67, 53, 68, 83, 138, 152, 65, 50, 66, 69, 51, 36, 78, 101, 157, 87 ], "move_count": 48, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 4874, "avg_search_time_ms": 221.54545454545453, "search_nodes": 304742, "safety_nodes": 2570, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 307312, "avg_nodes": 13968.727272727272, "eval_calls": 296857, "avg_eval_calls": 13493.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 296857, "line_shape_eval_ns": 510606848, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1720.0431453528129, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7842, "avg_candidate_generations": 356.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 707347, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.19982147411375, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1815, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 7820, "search_candidate_moves_total": 705532, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 288412, "avg_legality_checks": 13109.636363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 701, "root_legality_checks": 1815, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 286597, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 692, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 313832, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14265.09090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 683743791, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2178.6936673124474, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1105, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 50.22727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9217644, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8341.7592760181, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1061, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8860432, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 357212, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 104, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 824295, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7925.913461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 359940, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2726.818181818182, "stage_move_gen_ns": 666588833, "stage_ordering_ns": 256901, "stage_eval_ns": 510606848, "stage_threat_ns": 3659171638, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 609376, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3184958948, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1281086, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 21450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 304677, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 402362985, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 609354, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 70568619, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 500, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6784, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 2.9545454545454546, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7048.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7411.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1915, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 13256, "avg_search_time_ms": 602.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 120392, "safety_nodes": 1653, "corridor_nodes": 4114, "corridor_branch_probes": 4403, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 2131, "corridor_neutral_exits": 39, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 4076, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4076, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 20, "corridor_proof_completed": 20, "corridor_proof_checks": 124, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 86, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 40, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2131, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 124, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 122, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 873, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 580240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 126159, "avg_nodes": 5734.5, "eval_calls": 87342, "avg_eval_calls": 3970.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87342, "pattern_eval_ns": 1900398, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.758123239678504, "pattern_frame_queries": 87342, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1900398, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.758123239678504, "pattern_frame_updates": 240576, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2646797357, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11001.91771830939, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30895, "avg_candidate_generations": 1404.3181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 2634253, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.26470302637968, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1829, "root_candidate_moves_max": 115, "search_candidate_generations": 30873, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2632424, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1589840, "avg_legality_checks": 72265.45454545454, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9374, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1589840, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9374, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3874143, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 176097.4090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8038155552, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2074.8215933175416, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54799, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2490.8636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 433402736, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7908.953375061588, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10187, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 99832131, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27749, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 260314204, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16615, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 71068854, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 248, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2187547, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 133490, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6067.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1132034614, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8480.295258071767, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 169953, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7725.136363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 470035226, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2765.6777226645013, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3800386906, "stage_ordering_ns": 996101872, "stage_eval_ns": 2648697755, "stage_threat_ns": 5544836856, "stage_proof_ns": 211286433, "tactical_annotations": 632981, "root_tactical_annotations": 2570, "search_tactical_annotations": 630411, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 248998, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1481516266, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 749079, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3771726004, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64160, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2105272768, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124488, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 185950701, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8400, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 58148398, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 248976, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30231855, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 220227, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 582609511, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 280447, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 952463707, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 132307, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17263632, "child_limit_applications": 30873, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30873, "child_cap_hits": 30873, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30873, "child_moves_before_total": 2623050, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2623050, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 495765, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 495765, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.9625886697114, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.058206199591876, "tt_hits": 12747, "tt_cutoffs": 2073, "beta_cutoffs": 25168, "depth_sum": 104, "avg_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 104, "avg_effective_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6220.863636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6584.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1808, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 736, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10410, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 110, 127, 111, 113, 124, 82, 128, 80, 79, 99, 109, 108, 94, 64, 139 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 9535, "avg_search_time_ms": 1191.875, "search_nodes": 98818, "safety_nodes": 343, "corridor_nodes": 3145, "corridor_branch_probes": 3524, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1316, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 3112, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3112, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 81, "corridor_proof_active": 33, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1316, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 81, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 80, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 681, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 75467200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1990560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 102306, "avg_nodes": 12788.25, "eval_calls": 79946, "avg_eval_calls": 9993.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79946, "pattern_eval_ns": 1704466, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.32021614589848, "pattern_frame_queries": 79946, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1704466, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.32021614589848, "pattern_frame_updates": 197572, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2638765748, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13355.970218452007, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17840, "avg_candidate_generations": 2230.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1212981, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.99220852017937, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 463, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 17832, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1212518, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 560770, "avg_legality_checks": 70096.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 247, "root_legality_checks": 463, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 560307, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 247, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2569078, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 321134.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5825856915, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2267.6839375838335, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16459, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2057.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 87709610, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5328.975636429916, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 376, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2975434, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8625, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 70383235, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7410, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14073660, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 277281, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 69035, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8629.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 643336783, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9318.994466574926, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91268, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11408.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 278387155, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3050.216450453609, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1450097764, "stage_ordering_ns": 553928234, "stage_eval_ns": 2640470214, "stage_threat_ns": 4334623966, "stage_proof_ns": 529093593, "tactical_annotations": 229580, "root_tactical_annotations": 1315, "search_tactical_annotations": 228265, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 203966, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1276434849, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 409887, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2834356616, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37418, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1569736972, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 101979, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156519812, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6386, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 33531647, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 203958, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27267487, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 51139, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 128481565, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 129147, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 645298211, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49294, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6513555, "child_limit_applications": 17832, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17832, "child_cap_hits": 17832, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17832, "child_moves_before_total": 1212271, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1212271, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 285496, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 285496, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.98289591745177, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01031852848811, "tt_hits": 6888, "tt_cutoffs": 1008, "beta_cutoffs": 12554, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1130.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1941.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 269, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 868, "avg_search_time_ms": 124.0, "search_nodes": 59420, "safety_nodes": 439, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59859, "avg_nodes": 8551.285714285714, "eval_calls": 57683, "avg_eval_calls": 8240.42857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 57683, "line_shape_eval_ns": 54980084, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 953.1418962259245, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1724, "avg_candidate_generations": 246.28571428571428, "candidate_moves_total": 118506, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.73897911832947, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 398, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 1717, "search_candidate_moves_total": 118108, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 4793, "avg_legality_checks": 684.7142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4793, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12853, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1836.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 30408182, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2365.84314945927, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14042239, "stage_ordering_ns": 58130, "stage_eval_ns": 54980084, "stage_threat_ns": 791516231, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 118807, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 695157328, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 152271, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 59400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81256309, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 118800, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14950323, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 115, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1523, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5029.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6172.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1839, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 737, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18071, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 111, 81, 83, 114, 66, 97, 109, 113, 110, 108, 65, 129, 145, 130, 146, 78, 79, 144, 99, 93, 123, 48, 95, 63 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 4946, "avg_search_time_ms": 380.46153846153845, "search_nodes": 292200, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 293173, "avg_nodes": 22551.76923076923, "eval_calls": 286038, "avg_eval_calls": 22002.923076923078, "line_shape_eval_calls": 286038, "line_shape_eval_ns": 241181699, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 843.1806228543061, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6137, "avg_candidate_generations": 472.0769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 416276, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.83053609255336, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 844, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 6124, "search_candidate_moves_total": 415432, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 281548, "avg_legality_checks": 21657.53846153846, "illegal_moves_skipped": 206, "root_legality_checks": 844, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 280704, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 198, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 296546, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22811.23076923077, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 764510894, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2578.051614252089, "renju_forbidden_checks": 240, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 18.46153846153846, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2529544, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10539.766666666666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 206, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2181314, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 348230, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.8461538461538463, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 385340, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10414.594594594595, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.8461538461538463, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 190540, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3810.8, "stage_move_gen_ns": 753343752, "stage_ordering_ns": 194231, "stage_eval_ns": 241181699, "stage_threat_ns": 3943068699, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 584337, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3460079642, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 638990, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 292162, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 407352441, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 584324, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74997626, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 174, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5769, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5620.076923076923, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6235.461538461538, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1478, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 13112, "avg_search_time_ms": 1008.6153846153846, "search_nodes": 117946, "safety_nodes": 361, "corridor_nodes": 1895, "corridor_branch_probes": 2032, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 737, "corridor_neutral_exits": 21, "corridor_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_plies_followed": 1869, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1869, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 81, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 55, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 21, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 737, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 81, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 77, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 587, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6527200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1976480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 120202, "avg_nodes": 9246.307692307691, "eval_calls": 83533, "avg_eval_calls": 6425.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83533, "pattern_eval_ns": 1847668, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.11901883088121, "pattern_frame_queries": 83533, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1847668, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.11901883088121, "pattern_frame_updates": 235774, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2187337072, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9277.26158100554, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32347, "avg_candidate_generations": 2488.230769230769, "candidate_moves_total": 2579486, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.74421120969487, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 871, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 32334, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2578615, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 1671954, "avg_legality_checks": 128611.84615384616, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11446, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1671954, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11446, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3874265, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 298020.3846153846, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8111305128, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2093.6371487236934, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32647, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2511.3076923076924, "renju_forbidden_ns": 255038646, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7812.0086378534015, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11732, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 121450817, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9077, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 93612345, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11771, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39247600, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 727884, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 121527, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9348.23076923077, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1197844494, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9856.612061517193, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 177393, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13645.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 601893217, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3392.993054968347, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4086163441, "stage_ordering_ns": 1025309390, "stage_eval_ns": 2189184740, "stage_threat_ns": 5580929811, "stage_proof_ns": 137425102, "tactical_annotations": 559818, "root_tactical_annotations": 2957, "search_tactical_annotations": 556861, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 239687, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1427179661, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 607269, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3906098704, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 66048, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2252116263, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 119837, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 178881088, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3900, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21165923, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 239674, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30124080, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 179557, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 645470232, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 243634, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 916435307, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 136627, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17480355, "child_limit_applications": 32334, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32334, "child_cap_hits": 32334, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32334, "child_moves_before_total": 2567169, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2567169, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 517534, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 517534, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.39534236407496, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0058761675017, "tt_hits": 14436, "tt_cutoffs": 2020, "beta_cutoffs": 26867, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5439.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6055.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1871, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 738, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13204, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 144, 96, 160, 176, 97, 68, 110, 66, 114, 81, 111, 113, 83, 69, 67, 54, 40, 51, 36, 52, 50, 38, 125, 139, 109, 108, 80, 24, 10, 39, 84, 9 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 10649, "avg_search_time_ms": 665.5625, "search_nodes": 105284, "safety_nodes": 1829, "corridor_nodes": 4384, "corridor_branch_probes": 4932, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2242, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 4361, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4361, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2242, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 365, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 27962160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2008160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 111497, "avg_nodes": 6968.5625, "eval_calls": 79638, "avg_eval_calls": 4977.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79638, "pattern_eval_ns": 1717790, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.569979155679448, "pattern_frame_queries": 79638, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1717790, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.569979155679448, "pattern_frame_updates": 210418, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2064086059, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9809.455745230922, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23723, "avg_candidate_generations": 1482.6875, "candidate_moves_total": 1996850, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.17358681448384, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1366, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 23707, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1995484, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 953984, "avg_legality_checks": 59624.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 924, "root_legality_checks": 1366, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 952618, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3106068, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 194129.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6445204499, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2075.0365088594326, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24586, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1536.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 110504621, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4494.615675587733, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1264, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9220777, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7013, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 55562869, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11598, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29434963, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4711, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 16286012, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 91259, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5703.6875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 845626069, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9266.221074085843, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 125560, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7847.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 407697792, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3247.035616438356, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2295118480, "stage_ordering_ns": 816701388, "stage_eval_ns": 2065803849, "stage_threat_ns": 4960401346, "stage_proof_ns": 449858362, "tactical_annotations": 335485, "root_tactical_annotations": 1406, "search_tactical_annotations": 334079, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 219282, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1318015671, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 537006, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3394116290, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49408, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1863655715, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 109633, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 158508168, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8848, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 54873468, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 219266, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26911583, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 93025, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 204315173, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 186045, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 760900789, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 56415, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7976166, "child_limit_applications": 23707, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23707, "child_cap_hits": 23707, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23707, "child_moves_before_total": 1994561, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1994561, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 382386, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 382386, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.13384232505167, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.12966634327414, "tt_hits": 7895, "tt_cutoffs": 1864, "beta_cutoffs": 18548, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 4.5625, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5625, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5029.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5529.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 2539, "avg_search_time_ms": 158.6875, "search_nodes": 265477, "safety_nodes": 1144, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 266621, "avg_nodes": 16663.8125, "eval_calls": 256962, "avg_eval_calls": 16060.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 256962, "line_shape_eval_ns": 258627580, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1006.4818144317059, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8485, "avg_candidate_generations": 530.3125, "candidate_moves_total": 833829, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.27094873305833, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1398, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 8469, "search_candidate_moves_total": 832431, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 15744, "avg_legality_checks": 984.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 15744, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 34386, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2149.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 65287962, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1898.6785901238877, "renju_forbidden_checks": 97, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6.0625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 378914, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3906.3298969072166, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 33, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 146261, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 64, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 232653, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 33556260, "stage_ordering_ns": 259491, "stage_eval_ns": 258627580, "stage_threat_ns": 2199679906, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 530878, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1890194497, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 189211, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15530, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 265431, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 265028382, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 530862, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44267816, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 621, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7422, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6706.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7206.1875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 739, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16389, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 97, 99, 129, 142, 100, 113, 67, 127, 82, 52, 85, 141, 155, 156, 170, 54, 69, 140, 143, 53, 51, 56, 83, 55 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3013, "avg_search_time_ms": 231.76923076923077, "search_nodes": 178968, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 179941, "avg_nodes": 13841.615384615385, "eval_calls": 174297, "avg_eval_calls": 13407.461538461539, "line_shape_eval_calls": 174297, "line_shape_eval_ns": 141721226, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 813.1019237278897, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4646, "avg_candidate_generations": 357.38461538461536, "candidate_moves_total": 315138, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.82996125699526, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 844, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 4633, "search_candidate_moves_total": 314294, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 169655, "avg_legality_checks": 13050.384615384615, "illegal_moves_skipped": 168, "root_legality_checks": 844, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 168811, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 160, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 184653, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14204.076923076924, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 473546258, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2564.5197099424327, "renju_forbidden_checks": 202, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 15.538461538461538, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2050504, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10151.009900990099, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 168, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1701123, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 349381, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.8461538461538463, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 386492, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10445.72972972973, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.8461538461538463, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 189631, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3792.62, "stage_move_gen_ns": 454854517, "stage_ordering_ns": 145850, "stage_eval_ns": 141721226, "stage_threat_ns": 2397778299, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 357873, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2108796348, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 643004, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 178930, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 242387534, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 357860, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45951413, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 174, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4334, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5950.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6566.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1918, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 13362, "avg_search_time_ms": 1027.8461538461538, "search_nodes": 120444, "safety_nodes": 361, "corridor_nodes": 2221, "corridor_branch_probes": 2398, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 894, "corridor_neutral_exits": 22, "corridor_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_plies_followed": 2194, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2194, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 81, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 894, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 81, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 77, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 587, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6410080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1976480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 123026, "avg_nodes": 9463.538461538461, "eval_calls": 86068, "avg_eval_calls": 6620.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 86068, "pattern_eval_ns": 1860017, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.611016870381558, "pattern_frame_queries": 86068, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1860017, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.611016870381558, "pattern_frame_updates": 240770, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2280323077, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9470.960156996303, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32505, "avg_candidate_generations": 2500.3846153846152, "candidate_moves_total": 2576757, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.27263497923397, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 871, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 32492, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2575886, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1661886, "avg_legality_checks": 127837.38461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11571, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1661886, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11571, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3916210, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 301246.92307692306, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8279569313, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2114.179094839143, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30938, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2379.846153846154, "renju_forbidden_ns": 238261796, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7701.266920938651, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11815, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 122761374, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8018, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 80488517, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11038, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 34281439, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 730466, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 121237, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9325.923076923076, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1216849552, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10036.948720275164, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 175493, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13499.461538461539, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 609043460, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3470.471528778926, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4080980961, "stage_ordering_ns": 1050898216, "stage_eval_ns": 2282183094, "stage_threat_ns": 5720871416, "stage_proof_ns": 134014050, "tactical_annotations": 556326, "root_tactical_annotations": 2957, "search_tactical_annotations": 553369, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 245333, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1442764991, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 622768, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4021468747, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 66508, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2326785506, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 122660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 182327018, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4550, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25063656, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 245320, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30760742, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 178652, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 648579724, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 242654, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 938666382, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 135020, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18486262, "child_limit_applications": 32492, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32492, "child_cap_hits": 32492, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32492, "child_moves_before_total": 2564315, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2564315, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 520035, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 520035, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.92142681275391, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.005016619475562, "tt_hits": 14202, "tt_cutoffs": 1825, "beta_cutoffs": 26879, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5301.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5916.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1864, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 740, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9928, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 142, 113, 158, 110, 127, 97, 98, 140, 155, 81, 157, 172, 156, 154, 159 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 9509, "avg_search_time_ms": 1188.625, "search_nodes": 100493, "safety_nodes": 343, "corridor_nodes": 3151, "corridor_branch_probes": 3502, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1376, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 3119, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3119, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 81, "corridor_proof_active": 32, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1376, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 81, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 80, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 681, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 75494560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1992960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 103987, "avg_nodes": 12998.375, "eval_calls": 81293, "avg_eval_calls": 10161.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 81293, "pattern_eval_ns": 1738303, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.383181823773263, "pattern_frame_queries": 81293, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1738303, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.383181823773263, "pattern_frame_updates": 200922, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2491811799, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12401.886299160868, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18234, "avg_candidate_generations": 2279.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1283386, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.38422726774158, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 470, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 18226, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1282916, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 593709, "avg_legality_checks": 74213.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 190, "root_legality_checks": 470, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 593239, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 190, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2533190, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 316648.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5749374251, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2269.6182485324825, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15962, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1995.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64554877, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4044.2849893497055, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 327, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2371368, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7434, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 50083861, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8086, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11774758, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 115, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 324890, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 66559, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8319.875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 609796328, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9161.741131928064, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 87232, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10904.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 259640482, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2976.436193140132, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1534840184, "stage_ordering_ns": 591469320, "stage_eval_ns": 2493550102, "stage_threat_ns": 4334343751, "stage_proof_ns": 527995793, "tactical_annotations": 224677, "root_tactical_annotations": 1350, "search_tactical_annotations": 223327, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 207330, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1277245952, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 400512, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2833636279, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38182, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1615036298, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 103661, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156813166, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6400, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 33233812, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 207322, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27339338, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 48116, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 133619252, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 127973, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 604157339, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 48588, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6075204, "child_limit_applications": 18226, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18226, "child_cap_hits": 18226, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18226, "child_moves_before_total": 1282726, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1282726, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 291686, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 291686, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.37890925052123, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.003840667178757, "tt_hits": 6868, "tt_cutoffs": 942, "beta_cutoffs": 12860, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1140.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1956.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 231, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 411, "avg_search_time_ms": 58.714285714285715, "search_nodes": 30419, "safety_nodes": 453, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 30872, "avg_nodes": 4410.285714285715, "eval_calls": 29120, "avg_eval_calls": 4160.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 29120, "line_shape_eval_ns": 22374191, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 768.3444711538461, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1286, "avg_candidate_generations": 183.71428571428572, "candidate_moves_total": 86794, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.4914463452566, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 405, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 1279, "search_candidate_moves_total": 86389, "search_candidate_moves_max": 89, "legality_checks": 3451, "avg_legality_checks": 493.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3451, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11533, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1647.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24093436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2089.086621000607, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9434246, "stage_ordering_ns": 42770, "stage_eval_ns": 22374191, "stage_threat_ns": 371092182, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 60805, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 325065792, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 154801, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 30399, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 38746355, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 60798, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7125234, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 115, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1106, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5056.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6199.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1889, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 741, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17840, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 140, 113, 68, 82, 125, 84, 70, 95, 155, 170, 71, 67, 97, 83, 81, 99, 51, 66, 114, 128, 143, 127, 141, 142, 157, 156, 184, 115, 131, 130, 129, 50, 34, 85, 86, 100, 145, 101, 102, 54, 173, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 48, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 5554, "avg_search_time_ms": 252.45454545454547, "search_nodes": 354759, "safety_nodes": 2570, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 357329, "avg_nodes": 16242.227272727272, "eval_calls": 345658, "avg_eval_calls": 15711.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 345658, "line_shape_eval_ns": 584884891, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1692.0912896562497, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9058, "avg_candidate_generations": 411.72727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 805525, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.92967542503864, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1815, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 9036, "search_candidate_moves_total": 803710, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 336982, "avg_legality_checks": 15317.363636363636, "illegal_moves_skipped": 771, "root_legality_checks": 1815, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 335167, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 762, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 362402, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16472.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 780898945, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2154.786521597563, "renju_forbidden_checks": 941, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 42.77272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10137282, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10772.882040382572, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 897, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9656612, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 480670, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 104, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.7272727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 946104, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9097.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 425893, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3226.462121212121, "stage_move_gen_ns": 765754707, "stage_ordering_ns": 300130, "stage_eval_ns": 584884891, "stage_threat_ns": 4149449113, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 709410, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3608836558, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1436458, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 21910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 354694, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 458299829, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 709388, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 80876268, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 500, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8087, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 2.9545454545454546, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7042.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7406.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1940, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 12265, "avg_search_time_ms": 557.5, "search_nodes": 118242, "safety_nodes": 1653, "corridor_nodes": 4642, "corridor_branch_probes": 4903, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2438, "corridor_neutral_exits": 48, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 4604, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4604, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 20, "corridor_proof_completed": 20, "corridor_proof_checks": 124, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 86, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 48, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2438, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 124, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 122, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 873, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 604640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 124537, "avg_nodes": 5660.772727272727, "eval_calls": 86032, "avg_eval_calls": 3910.5454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 86032, "pattern_eval_ns": 1842056, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.411288822763623, "pattern_frame_queries": 86032, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1842056, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.411288822763623, "pattern_frame_updates": 236276, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2221062987, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9400.290283397382, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29930, "avg_candidate_generations": 1360.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 2625567, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.72358837287003, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1829, "root_candidate_moves_max": 115, "search_candidate_generations": 29908, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2623738, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1589156, "avg_legality_checks": 72234.36363636363, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7283, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1589156, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7283, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3769428, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 171337.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7491358478, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1987.3992759644168, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33907, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1541.2272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 194030904, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5722.443861149615, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7634, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52483064, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10588, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 93195289, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15437, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45791809, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 248, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2560742, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 128081, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5821.863636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1100913717, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8595.449106424841, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 174840, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7947.272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 488031573, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2791.303894989705, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3579073827, "stage_ordering_ns": 955953273, "stage_eval_ns": 2222905043, "stage_threat_ns": 5246900724, "stage_proof_ns": 211720182, "tactical_annotations": 610898, "root_tactical_annotations": 2570, "search_tactical_annotations": 608328, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 245754, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1431977026, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 755741, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3526833689, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62458, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1910675990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 122866, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 179078092, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9456, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 65276987, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 245732, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29115297, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 228573, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 624021609, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 260917, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 853043434, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 121408, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14619633, "child_limit_applications": 29908, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29908, "child_cap_hits": 29908, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29908, "child_moves_before_total": 2616455, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2616455, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 480421, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 480421, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.48344924434934, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.063294101912533, "tt_hits": 12693, "tt_cutoffs": 2198, "beta_cutoffs": 24275, "depth_sum": 104, "avg_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 104, "avg_effective_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6558.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6922.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1898, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 742, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10299, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 82, 95, 84, 126, 66, 50, 97, 80, 65, 67, 113, 81, 114, 130, 115, 111, 116 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9817, "avg_search_time_ms": 1090.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 82903, "safety_nodes": 393, "corridor_nodes": 8365, "corridor_branch_probes": 9068, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4393, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 8322, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8322, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 74, "corridor_proof_active": 43, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4393, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 74, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 72, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 567, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 22167920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1983840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 12, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 11, "total_nodes": 91661, "avg_nodes": 10184.555555555555, "eval_calls": 63350, "avg_eval_calls": 7038.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 63350, "pattern_eval_ns": 1338498, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.128618784530385, "pattern_frame_queries": 63350, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1338498, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.128618784530385, "pattern_frame_updates": 165732, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2298675386, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13869.834347018077, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18490, "avg_candidate_generations": 2054.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 1270174, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.69518658734451, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 537, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 18481, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1269637, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 506636, "avg_legality_checks": 56292.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 584, "root_legality_checks": 537, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 506099, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 584, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2943333, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 327037.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6148322631, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2088.8980726951386, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23096, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2566.222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 143806568, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6226.470730862487, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 667, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6575026, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11544, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 102883444, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9927, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28511240, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 958, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5836858, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 82958, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9217.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 772036405, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9306.352672436655, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 111859, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12428.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 351810361, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3145.123423238184, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1275661479, "stage_ordering_ns": 528025002, "stage_eval_ns": 2300013884, "stage_threat_ns": 4886475770, "stage_proof_ns": 800656945, "tactical_annotations": 299317, "root_tactical_annotations": 1415, "search_tactical_annotations": 297902, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 182533, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1174775012, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 683224, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3461248476, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40620, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1656533384, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91262, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 141030502, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 16792, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 78081683, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 182524, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23021568, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 77626, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 143775988, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 154209, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 709637080, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 67482, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8318529, "child_limit_applications": 18481, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18481, "child_cap_hits": 18481, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18481, "child_moves_before_total": 1269053, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1269053, "child_moves_before_max": 94, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 94, "child_moves_after_total": 296265, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 296265, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.66798333423516, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.030788377252314, "tt_hits": 7290, "tt_cutoffs": 1035, "beta_cutoffs": 14344, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1778.7777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2667.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 473, "avg_search_time_ms": 59.125, "search_nodes": 37002, "safety_nodes": 726, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 37728, "avg_nodes": 4716.0, "eval_calls": 35764, "avg_eval_calls": 4470.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 35764, "line_shape_eval_ns": 26358466, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 737.0111285091153, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1223, "avg_candidate_generations": 152.875, "candidate_moves_total": 80743, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.0204415372036, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 481, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 1215, "search_candidate_moves_total": 80262, "search_candidate_moves_max": 85, "legality_checks": 2554, "avg_legality_checks": 319.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2554, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11791, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1473.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22448026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1903.827156305657, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57210, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8172.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25320, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 31890, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6726588, "stage_ordering_ns": 38700, "stage_eval_ns": 26358466, "stage_threat_ns": 433901108, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 73966, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 379458533, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 208041, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7050, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 36979, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 46193051, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 73958, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8041483, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 64, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1103, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5395.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6395.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1847, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 743, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22675, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 97, 82, 113, 96, 142, 157, 68, 114, 66, 129, 99, 141, 65, 67, 81, 49, 128, 125, 109, 143, 115, 171, 185, 156, 85, 71, 186, 140, 95, 155, 170, 154, 158, 153 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 5434, "avg_search_time_ms": 319.6470588235294, "search_nodes": 440547, "safety_nodes": 1532, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 442079, "avg_nodes": 26004.647058823528, "eval_calls": 429259, "avg_eval_calls": 25250.529411764706, "line_shape_eval_calls": 429259, "line_shape_eval_ns": 389841256, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 908.1725857815445, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11255, "avg_candidate_generations": 662.0588235294117, "candidate_moves_total": 904053, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.3245668591737, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1301, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 11238, "search_candidate_moves_total": 902752, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 420298, "avg_legality_checks": 24723.41176470588, "illegal_moves_skipped": 165, "root_legality_checks": 1301, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 418997, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 165, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 440208, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 25894.58823529412, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 808714913, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1837.1199819176388, "renju_forbidden_checks": 209, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12.294117647058824, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1222595, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5849.736842105263, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 209, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1222595, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.0588235294117645, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 458843, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8823.903846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 78, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.588235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 247010, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3166.7948717948716, "stage_move_gen_ns": 802142579, "stage_ordering_ns": 326472, "stage_eval_ns": 389841256, "stage_threat_ns": 4167738556, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 881011, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3637676561, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 48, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 716953, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14670, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 440497, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 447502183, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 880994, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 81842859, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 408, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 10363, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6607.176470588235, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7077.764705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1950, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 17224, "avg_search_time_ms": 1013.1764705882352, "search_nodes": 175510, "safety_nodes": 686, "corridor_nodes": 23194, "corridor_branch_probes": 23760, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 12108, "corridor_neutral_exits": 42, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 23137, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 23137, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 133, "corridor_proof_active": 57, "corridor_proof_quiet": 76, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 42, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 12108, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 133, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 131, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1011, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 28555040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 199390, "avg_nodes": 11728.823529411764, "eval_calls": 130799, "avg_eval_calls": 7694.058823529412, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 130799, "pattern_eval_ns": 2614815, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.991093204076485, "pattern_frame_queries": 130799, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2614815, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.991093204076485, "pattern_frame_updates": 350866, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2571854084, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7330.017966973146, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42016, "avg_candidate_generations": 2471.529411764706, "candidate_moves_total": 3942857, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.84179836252856, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1326, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 41999, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3941531, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 2635508, "avg_legality_checks": 155029.88235294117, "illegal_moves_skipped": 529, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2635508, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 529, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5629053, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 331120.76470588235, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10203344688, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1812.6218900408292, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12007, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 706.2941176470588, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20766220, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1729.5094528191887, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 535, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3265729, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1671, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8723666, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9764, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8528682, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 248143, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 126191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7423.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1028347969, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8149.138757914589, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 190955, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11232.64705882353, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 528812512, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2769.304349192218, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5414482983, "stage_ordering_ns": 1281269001, "stage_eval_ns": 2574468899, "stage_threat_ns": 7904704348, "stage_proof_ns": 92701458, "tactical_annotations": 850205, "root_tactical_annotations": 3790, "search_tactical_annotations": 846415, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 397423, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2263611785, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1834225, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5015576459, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 95241, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2797851226, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 198703, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 270754743, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 46540, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 287858884, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 397406, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43494706, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 334579, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 581901231, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 335197, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 887057952, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 180429, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23407771, "child_limit_applications": 41999, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41999, "child_cap_hits": 41999, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41999, "child_moves_before_total": 3941002, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3941002, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 676091, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 676091, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.83561513369366, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.097788042572443, "tt_hits": 18736, "tt_cutoffs": 2635, "beta_cutoffs": 33621, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6363.235294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6833.823529411765, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1934, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 744, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14807, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 99, 96, 113, 141, 114, 111, 156, 81, 126, 51, 66, 95, 94, 128, 129, 84, 80, 108, 157, 172, 159, 144, 158, 155, 160 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 13956, "avg_search_time_ms": 996.8571428571429, "search_nodes": 136143, "safety_nodes": 387, "corridor_nodes": 8472, "corridor_branch_probes": 8767, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4414, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 8444, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8444, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 82, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4414, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 82, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 78, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 601, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 27918640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1970800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 145002, "avg_nodes": 10357.285714285714, "eval_calls": 104431, "avg_eval_calls": 7459.357142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 104431, "pattern_eval_ns": 2133764, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.432285432486523, "pattern_frame_queries": 104431, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2133764, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.432285432486523, "pattern_frame_updates": 272162, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3472918762, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12760.483689861185, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30107, "avg_candidate_generations": 2150.5, "candidate_moves_total": 2334163, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.52891354170127, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 931, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 30093, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2333232, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 786042, "avg_legality_checks": 56145.857142857145, "illegal_moves_skipped": 600, "root_legality_checks": 931, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 785111, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 600, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4066853, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 290489.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8490875194, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2087.8244662396205, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29442, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2103.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 118618697, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4028.8939949731675, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 983, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7476048, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13034, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73584987, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13952, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30823840, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1473, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6733822, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 119412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8529.42857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 973541811, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8152.797130941614, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 154915, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11065.357142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 387905263, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2503.9877545750896, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1881405850, "stage_ordering_ns": 940350281, "stage_eval_ns": 3475052526, "stage_threat_ns": 6740696621, "stage_proof_ns": 871234846, "tactical_annotations": 597635, "root_tactical_annotations": 2691, "search_tactical_annotations": 594944, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 289228, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1773540579, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 923435, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4601176651, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64338, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2376166181, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 144607, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 213555563, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 17052, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 99847901, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 289214, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35987626, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 192130, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 225324182, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 261250, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 921130250, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 144255, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16588301, "child_limit_applications": 30093, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30093, "child_cap_hits": 30093, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30093, "child_moves_before_total": 2332632, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2332632, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 487791, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 487791, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.51410627056126, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.209450702821254, "tt_hits": 13028, "tt_cutoffs": 1557, "beta_cutoffs": 23333, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5113.785714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5685.214285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 969, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 834, "avg_search_time_ms": 64.15384615384616, "search_nodes": 59358, "safety_nodes": 1344, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 60702, "avg_nodes": 4669.384615384615, "eval_calls": 56914, "avg_eval_calls": 4378.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 56914, "line_shape_eval_ns": 53672406, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 943.0439962048002, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2419, "avg_candidate_generations": 186.07692307692307, "candidate_moves_total": 170471, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.4716825134353, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 861, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 2406, "search_candidate_moves_total": 169610, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 6557, "avg_legality_checks": 504.38461538461536, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6557, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21606, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1662.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 46624061, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2157.9219198370824, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7692307692307692, "renju_forbidden_ns": 225890, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9821.304347826086, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53580, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 172310, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18063805, "stage_ordering_ns": 75250, "stage_eval_ns": 53672406, "stage_threat_ns": 745911909, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 118653, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 656084042, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 358091, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 59320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 75400041, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 118640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14069735, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 92, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2214, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6368.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6984.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1972, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 745, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16853, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 126, 98, 109, 108, 83, 114, 66, 146, 130, 143, 158, 142, 96, 81, 100, 156, 170, 97, 129, 144, 145, 140, 141, 124, 172, 92 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 1691, "avg_search_time_ms": 120.78571428571429, "search_nodes": 103681, "safety_nodes": 1389, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 105070, "avg_nodes": 7505.0, "eval_calls": 100595, "avg_eval_calls": 7185.357142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 100595, "line_shape_eval_ns": 83301768, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 828.0905412793876, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3059, "avg_candidate_generations": 218.5, "candidate_moves_total": 221860, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.52696959790781, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1058, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 3045, "search_candidate_moves_total": 220802, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 98485, "avg_legality_checks": 7034.642857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 1058, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 97427, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 115022, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8215.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 276012100, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2399.6461546486757, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.2857142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16800, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4200.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13320, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3480, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.642857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 558861, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10958.058823529413, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 71, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.071428571428571, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 296391, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4174.521126760564, "stage_move_gen_ns": 249232353, "stage_ordering_ns": 90001, "stage_eval_ns": 83301768, "stage_threat_ns": 1340443909, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 207294, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1177298442, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 783163, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 103640, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 137299140, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 207280, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25063164, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 116, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2782, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6327.214285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6898.642857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1889, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 15148, "avg_search_time_ms": 1082.0, "search_nodes": 138252, "safety_nodes": 856, "corridor_nodes": 2553, "corridor_branch_probes": 2877, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 978, "corridor_neutral_exits": 39, "corridor_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_plies_followed": 2521, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2521, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 80, "corridor_proof_active": 32, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 40, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 978, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 80, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 76, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 573, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 28107520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 141661, "avg_nodes": 10118.642857142857, "eval_calls": 105139, "avg_eval_calls": 7509.928571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105139, "pattern_eval_ns": 2177988, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.71531971960928, "pattern_frame_queries": 105139, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2177988, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.71531971960928, "pattern_frame_updates": 276380, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2942725619, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10647.389894348362, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31252, "avg_candidate_generations": 2232.285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 2818798, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.19576347113785, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1083, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 31238, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2817715, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1941381, "avg_legality_checks": 138670.07142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1166, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1941381, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1166, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4595232, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 328230.85714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9558642288, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2080.121806254831, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24863, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1775.9285714285713, "renju_forbidden_ns": 90127120, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3624.949523388167, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1190, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12306031, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4772, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 47499454, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18901, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30321635, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 152334, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10881.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1534308593, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10072.003577664867, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 207866, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14847.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 762856056, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3669.941481531371, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4582674567, "stage_ordering_ns": 1130346930, "stage_eval_ns": 2944903607, "stage_threat_ns": 6280841709, "stage_proof_ns": 125178898, "tactical_annotations": 670061, "root_tactical_annotations": 2749, "search_tactical_annotations": 667312, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 281596, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1670779338, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 729263, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4315026041, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64159, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2211801138, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 140791, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 204819443, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5202, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 31181648, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 281582, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35187750, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 208841, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 693315096, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 298890, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1293678452, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 162330, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23847489, "child_limit_applications": 31238, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31238, "child_cap_hits": 31238, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31238, "child_moves_before_total": 2816549, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2816549, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 499933, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 499933, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.16419104936296, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00400153659005, "tt_hits": 13605, "tt_cutoffs": 1813, "beta_cutoffs": 24345, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5460.357142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6031.785714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1872, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 746, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9143, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 113, 114, 126, 98, 66, 100, 110, 109, 142, 86, 72, 94, 127, 97, 96, 81, 141, 156, 99, 85, 155 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6717, "avg_search_time_ms": 610.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 69952, "safety_nodes": 689, "corridor_nodes": 1267, "corridor_branch_probes": 1494, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 494, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_plies_followed": 1247, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1247, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 494, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 331, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23784640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 5, "total_nodes": 71908, "avg_nodes": 6537.090909090909, "eval_calls": 51903, "avg_eval_calls": 4718.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51903, "pattern_eval_ns": 1071874, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.651484499932568, "pattern_frame_queries": 51903, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1071874, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.651484499932568, "pattern_frame_updates": 139810, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1586420297, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11346.973013375295, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17127, "avg_candidate_generations": 1557.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1401993, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.85864424592748, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 791, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 17116, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1401202, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 510104, "avg_legality_checks": 46373.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 704, "root_legality_checks": 791, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 509313, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 701, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1845687, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 167789.72727272726, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3992322808, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2163.055170242842, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21140, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1921.8181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 112650579, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5328.788032166509, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1060, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8518534, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8605, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 69856107, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11184, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31488949, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 291, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2786989, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45967, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4178.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 419400607, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9123.949942349947, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 60307, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5482.454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 183013355, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3034.6950602749266, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1237684482, "stage_ordering_ns": 555807619, "stage_eval_ns": 1587492171, "stage_threat_ns": 3053461722, "stage_proof_ns": 246673658, "tactical_annotations": 276170, "root_tactical_annotations": 1544, "search_tactical_annotations": 274626, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 142423, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 834994634, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 319218, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2076968565, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35080, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1297818779, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 71206, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99636562, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2602, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15076407, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 142412, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17511682, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 77509, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 78879474, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 127474, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 497938988, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 71187, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9273872, "child_limit_applications": 17116, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17116, "child_cap_hits": 17116, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17116, "child_moves_before_total": 1400501, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1400501, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 275719, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 275719, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.82408272960973, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.108845524655294, "tt_hits": 7355, "tt_cutoffs": 886, "beta_cutoffs": 13723, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5084.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5812.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2416, "avg_search_time_ms": 241.6, "search_nodes": 177631, "safety_nodes": 903, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 178534, "avg_nodes": 17853.4, "eval_calls": 173406, "avg_eval_calls": 17340.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 173406, "line_shape_eval_ns": 147410497, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 850.0887916219739, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4206, "avg_candidate_generations": 420.6, "candidate_moves_total": 304622, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.42558250118877, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 724, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 4196, "search_candidate_moves_total": 303898, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 8417, "avg_legality_checks": 841.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8417, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20196, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2019.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 45739941, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2264.801990493167, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 210620, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11701.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 72770, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 137850, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 24021117, "stage_ordering_ns": 123251, "stage_eval_ns": 147410497, "stage_threat_ns": 2233337320, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 355214, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1961551543, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 213962, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10680, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 177602, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 229097893, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 355204, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42473922, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 126, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3944, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5607.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6407.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1967, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 747, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8663, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 96, 128, 67, 52, 129, 142, 100, 170, 156, 125, 124, 110, 98, 99, 94, 95, 140, 158, 174, 80, 65, 172, 66, 157, 187, 68, 81, 113, 51, 36, 111 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 1570, "avg_search_time_ms": 92.3529411764706, "search_nodes": 154937, "safety_nodes": 1562, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 156499, "avg_nodes": 9205.823529411764, "eval_calls": 150733, "avg_eval_calls": 8866.64705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 150733, "line_shape_eval_ns": 138876400, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 921.3403833268096, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4172, "avg_candidate_generations": 245.41176470588235, "candidate_moves_total": 386636, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.67401725790988, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1338, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 4155, "search_candidate_moves_total": 385298, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 146965, "avg_legality_checks": 8645.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 242, "root_legality_checks": 1338, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 145627, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 241, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 166934, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9819.64705882353, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 238293595, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1427.4719050642768, "renju_forbidden_checks": 464, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 27.294117647058822, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1490778, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3212.8836206896553, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 458, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1468647, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 22131, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.9411764705882355, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 523192, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7808.835820895522, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.235294117647059, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 270731, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3041.921348314607, "stage_move_gen_ns": 220003241, "stage_ordering_ns": 120001, "stage_eval_ns": 138876400, "stage_threat_ns": 1175699119, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 309793, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1013026692, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 722422, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11960, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 154888, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 138368830, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 309776, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23581175, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 318, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3664, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6781.235294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7251.823529411765, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1913, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 7078, "avg_search_time_ms": 442.375, "search_nodes": 69287, "safety_nodes": 1589, "corridor_nodes": 2146, "corridor_branch_probes": 2487, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 817, "corridor_neutral_exits": 19, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 2117, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2117, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 817, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 80, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 575, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24205360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 73022, "avg_nodes": 4563.875, "eval_calls": 49757, "avg_eval_calls": 3109.8125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49757, "pattern_eval_ns": 1007155, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.241473561508933, "pattern_frame_queries": 49757, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1007155, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.241473561508933, "pattern_frame_updates": 138424, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1295516789, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9359.047484540253, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18137, "avg_candidate_generations": 1133.5625, "candidate_moves_total": 1483724, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.80647295583614, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1267, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 18121, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1482457, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 903598, "avg_legality_checks": 56474.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 324, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 903598, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 324, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2366380, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 147898.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4435263803, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1874.282153753835, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16145, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1009.0625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43790180, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2712.305977082688, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 381, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2205276, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4474, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26635864, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11285, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14921530, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 27510, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81202, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5075.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 741975531, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9137.404632890815, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 112182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7011.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 363054425, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3236.298381201975, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1972008235, "stage_ordering_ns": 520635437, "stage_eval_ns": 1296523944, "stage_threat_ns": 3115202579, "stage_proof_ns": 122563812, "tactical_annotations": 348449, "root_tactical_annotations": 1421, "search_tactical_annotations": 347028, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 142840, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 773366587, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 438115, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2202215829, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37748, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1167666596, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 71412, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94385538, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4400, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20427297, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 142824, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16063577, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 92487, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 354880114, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 173999, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 595730174, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 81963, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8743751, "child_limit_applications": 18121, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18121, "child_cap_hits": 18121, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18121, "child_moves_before_total": 1482133, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1482133, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 291259, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 291259, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.7909055791623, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.073009215826943, "tt_hits": 7931, "tt_cutoffs": 1334, "beta_cutoffs": 14869, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6145.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6645.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1848, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 748, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10137, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 99, 128, 100, 98, 127, 82, 142, 157, 130, 113, 143, 83, 68, 84, 85, 66, 50, 115, 111, 81, 80, 116, 117, 95, 145, 141, 159, 175, 131, 173, 103 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 9195, "avg_search_time_ms": 574.6875, "search_nodes": 151022, "safety_nodes": 851, "corridor_nodes": 1755, "corridor_branch_probes": 1971, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 665, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1727, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1727, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 86, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 58, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 665, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 86, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 596, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 29872480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1984080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 7, "total_nodes": 153628, "avg_nodes": 9601.75, "eval_calls": 119046, "avg_eval_calls": 7440.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 119046, "pattern_eval_ns": 2232107, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.74995379937167, "pattern_frame_queries": 119046, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2232107, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.74995379937167, "pattern_frame_updates": 301900, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2663731792, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8823.22554488241, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30452, "avg_candidate_generations": 1903.25, "candidate_moves_total": 2371582, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.87935110994351, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1100, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 30436, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2370482, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1104621, "avg_legality_checks": 69038.8125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2167, "root_legality_checks": 1100, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1103521, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2164, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3863853, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 241490.8125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5407148382, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1399.4187620491773, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40215, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2513.4375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 154990262, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3854.0410791993036, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2329, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16649502, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22081, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 114948186, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15624, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22509081, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 181, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 883493, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 104882, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6555.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 650108492, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6198.475353254134, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 145708, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9106.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 299318631, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2054.2360817525464, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1755613689, "stage_ordering_ns": 604811569, "stage_eval_ns": 2665963899, "stage_threat_ns": 3822538504, "stage_proof_ns": 274734628, "tactical_annotations": 448495, "root_tactical_annotations": 2102, "search_tactical_annotations": 446393, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 305542, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1191033877, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 538894, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2418429193, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62153, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1349759363, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 152763, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159477240, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3626, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18996161, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 305526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27185893, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116257, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 151567134, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 253683, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 736134919, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78555, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7416140, "child_limit_applications": 30436, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30436, "child_cap_hits": 30436, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30436, "child_moves_before_total": 2368318, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2368318, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 487063, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 487063, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.81305033512945, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002858457090287, "tt_hits": 10629, "tt_cutoffs": 1468, "beta_cutoffs": 22806, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5839.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6339.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 267, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 928, "avg_search_time_ms": 61.86666666666667, "search_nodes": 81574, "safety_nodes": 1344, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 82918, "avg_nodes": 5527.866666666667, "eval_calls": 78395, "avg_eval_calls": 5226.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 78395, "line_shape_eval_ns": 75586387, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 964.1735697429683, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3150, "avg_candidate_generations": 210.0, "candidate_moves_total": 237102, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.27047619047619, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1036, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 3135, "search_candidate_moves_total": 236066, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 7500, "avg_legality_checks": 500.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7500, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24742, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1649.4666666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 42329986, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1710.8554684342414, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.2666666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 384222, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11300.64705882353, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 202230, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 181992, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16516153, "stage_ordering_ns": 96150, "stage_eval_ns": 75586387, "stage_threat_ns": 819103528, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 163075, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 711096496, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 215620, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 81530, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91560690, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 163060, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16230722, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 271, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2717, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6644.933333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7178.266666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1936, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 749, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13436, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 97, 82, 114, 115, 68, 126, 94, 124, 138, 125, 127, 95, 80, 141, 83, 140, 155, 143, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1487, "avg_search_time_ms": 135.1818181818182, "search_nodes": 95322, "safety_nodes": 896, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 96218, "avg_nodes": 8747.09090909091, "eval_calls": 92347, "avg_eval_calls": 8395.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 92347, "line_shape_eval_ns": 78192415, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 846.7239325587187, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2954, "avg_candidate_generations": 268.54545454545456, "candidate_moves_total": 209670, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.97833446174678, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 742, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 2943, "search_candidate_moves_total": 208928, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 87108, "avg_legality_checks": 7918.909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 174, "root_legality_checks": 742, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 86366, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 172, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 100173, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9106.636363636364, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 231788766, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2313.8846395735377, "renju_forbidden_checks": 182, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 16.545454545454547, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1412587, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7761.4670329670325, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 174, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1343216, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 69371, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8181818181818183, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 438834, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10448.42857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.363636363636363, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 235692, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3994.7796610169494, "stage_move_gen_ns": 213581393, "stage_ordering_ns": 97810, "stage_eval_ns": 78192415, "stage_threat_ns": 1186034437, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 190591, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1034666628, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 608584, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 95290, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 128080915, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 190580, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22678310, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 186, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2652, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5939.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6667.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1900, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11941, "avg_search_time_ms": 1085.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 147450, "safety_nodes": 533, "corridor_nodes": 1581, "corridor_branch_probes": 1735, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 588, "corridor_neutral_exits": 34, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1554, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1554, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 73, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 588, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 99, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 821, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 83683120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1991040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 149564, "avg_nodes": 13596.727272727272, "eval_calls": 118942, "avg_eval_calls": 10812.90909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 118942, "pattern_eval_ns": 2404110, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.21245649139917, "pattern_frame_queries": 118942, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2404110, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.21245649139917, "pattern_frame_updates": 294806, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2711687612, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9198.210389205104, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26849, "avg_candidate_generations": 2440.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2296539, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.5353644456032, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 766, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 26838, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2295773, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1362480, "avg_legality_checks": 123861.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8261, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1362480, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8261, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3570602, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 324600.1818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6987125825, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1956.8481239298023, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33233, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3021.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 284756342, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8568.481388980832, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8261, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 74881279, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18820, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 172291913, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6041, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36482576, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 111, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1100574, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 108791, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9890.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1032741594, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9492.895496870146, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 153579, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13961.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 508441445, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3310.6182811452086, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3089279127, "stage_ordering_ns": 878626143, "stage_eval_ns": 2714091722, "stage_threat_ns": 5043528687, "stage_proof_ns": 148411506, "tactical_annotations": 402534, "root_tactical_annotations": 2206, "search_tactical_annotations": 400328, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 298125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1596506815, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 466378, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3184041182, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54939, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1797864325, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 149057, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 197740427, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3308, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19734105, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 298114, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33872231, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116227, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 537035301, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 194224, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 775828443, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 92083, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11633927, "child_limit_applications": 26838, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26838, "child_cap_hits": 26838, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26838, "child_moves_before_total": 2287512, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2287512, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 430136, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 430136, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.23407109322602, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02712571726656, "tt_hits": 11036, "tt_cutoffs": 1623, "beta_cutoffs": 18985, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4589.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5316.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1825, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 750, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15812, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 82, 124, 114, 98, 140, 125, 127, 139, 97, 109, 68, 54, 94, 128, 93, 95, 83, 123, 122, 81, 67, 137 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 15119, "avg_search_time_ms": 1163.0, "search_nodes": 120592, "safety_nodes": 331, "corridor_nodes": 20606, "corridor_branch_probes": 22147, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 12146, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_plies_followed": 20569, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 20569, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 119, "corridor_proof_active": 37, "corridor_proof_quiet": 82, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 12146, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 119, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 117, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 965, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24359280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 141529, "avg_nodes": 10886.846153846154, "eval_calls": 89829, "avg_eval_calls": 6909.923076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89829, "pattern_eval_ns": 1840007, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.483440759665587, "pattern_frame_queries": 89829, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1840007, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.483440759665587, "pattern_frame_updates": 241070, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2612690161, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10837.89007757083, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29399, "avg_candidate_generations": 2261.4615384615386, "candidate_moves_total": 2298269, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.17507398210823, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 854, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 29386, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2297415, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 809948, "avg_legality_checks": 62303.692307692305, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1122, "root_legality_checks": 854, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 809094, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1121, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4743719, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 364901.46153846156, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9451258996, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1992.373282650174, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23509, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1808.3846153846155, "renju_forbidden_ns": 106716630, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4539.3946999021655, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1262, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11178278, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8032, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57260719, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11089, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30267701, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3126, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8009932, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 139005, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10692.692307692309, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1134516680, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8161.696917377073, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 184137, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14164.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 494659373, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2686.365982936618, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1911890304, "stage_ordering_ns": 920282642, "stage_eval_ns": 2614530168, "stage_threat_ns": 7991918236, "stage_proof_ns": 1636470694, "tactical_annotations": 472738, "root_tactical_annotations": 2577, "search_tactical_annotations": 470161, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 282459, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1851503756, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1274941, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5647359866, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67302, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2488015655, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 141223, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 214321561, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 41376, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 231782313, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 282446, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34198644, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 151396, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 232560816, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 209514, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 763080789, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 111828, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12752096, "child_limit_applications": 29386, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29386, "child_cap_hits": 29386, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29386, "child_moves_before_total": 2296294, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2296294, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 471166, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 471166, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.14244878513578, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.033689512012522, "tt_hits": 12500, "tt_cutoffs": 1320, "beta_cutoffs": 23529, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4187.538461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4802.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 929, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 679, "avg_search_time_ms": 56.583333333333336, "search_nodes": 48491, "safety_nodes": 1176, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49667, "avg_nodes": 4138.916666666667, "eval_calls": 45809, "avg_eval_calls": 3817.4166666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 45809, "line_shape_eval_ns": 39596676, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 864.3863869545286, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2659, "avg_candidate_generations": 221.58333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 187992, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.70026325686348, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 784, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 2647, "search_candidate_moves_total": 187208, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 6040, "avg_legality_checks": 503.3333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6040, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19974, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1664.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 42388835, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2122.2006107940324, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 107000, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11888.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 58980, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 48020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16295482, "stage_ordering_ns": 82690, "stage_eval_ns": 39596676, "stage_threat_ns": 610808781, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 96924, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 537665964, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 395701, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48456, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 61209579, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 96912, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11537537, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 137, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2392, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6240.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6907.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 751, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20492, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 111, 110, 142, 157, 68, 98, 66, 125, 95, 143, 65, 67, 63, 79, 49, 113, 81, 33, 64, 62, 128, 94, 126, 129, 115, 144, 99, 109, 141, 124, 138, 139 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 4937, "avg_search_time_ms": 290.4117647058824, "search_nodes": 317920, "safety_nodes": 1654, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 319574, "avg_nodes": 18798.470588235294, "eval_calls": 309150, "avg_eval_calls": 18185.29411764706, "line_shape_eval_calls": 309150, "line_shape_eval_ns": 314554401, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1017.4814847161572, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8737, "avg_candidate_generations": 513.9411764705883, "candidate_moves_total": 685613, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.47235893327229, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1267, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 8720, "search_candidate_moves_total": 684346, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 299384, "avg_legality_checks": 17610.823529411766, "illegal_moves_skipped": 190, "root_legality_checks": 1267, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 298117, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 190, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 319240, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18778.823529411766, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 735444146, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2303.7343252725223, "renju_forbidden_checks": 230, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 13.529411764705882, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2206590, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9593.869565217392, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 228, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2203270, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3320, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.823529411764706, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 680734, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10472.83076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.588235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 366132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3854.021052631579, "stage_move_gen_ns": 718392967, "stage_ordering_ns": 271802, "stage_eval_ns": 314554401, "stage_threat_ns": 3875054066, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 635757, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3395449095, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 50, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 972585, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 317870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 404727412, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 635740, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 73904974, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 415, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7929, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6467.176470588235, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6937.764705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1915, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 15541, "avg_search_time_ms": 914.1764705882352, "search_nodes": 193805, "safety_nodes": 925, "corridor_nodes": 6829, "corridor_branch_probes": 7273, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3681, "corridor_neutral_exits": 44, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 6793, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6793, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 82, "corridor_proof_active": 36, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 44, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3681, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 82, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 78, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 510, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26056720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1987680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 5, "total_nodes": 201559, "avg_nodes": 11856.411764705883, "eval_calls": 152771, "avg_eval_calls": 8986.529411764706, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 152771, "pattern_eval_ns": 3091479, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.23603301673747, "pattern_frame_queries": 152771, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3091479, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.23603301673747, "pattern_frame_updates": 387452, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3430019107, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8852.75881141406, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38187, "avg_candidate_generations": 2246.294117647059, "candidate_moves_total": 3401517, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.07526121454946, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1299, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 38170, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3400218, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1909090, "avg_legality_checks": 112299.41176470589, "illegal_moves_skipped": 583, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1909090, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 583, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4681843, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 275402.5294117647, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8984759722, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1919.0647191714886, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16097, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 946.8823529411765, "renju_forbidden_ns": 49939341, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3102.4005094116915, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 649, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6558612, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2738, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20418915, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12673, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22513294, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 448520, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 109940, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6467.058823529412, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 929377699, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8453.499172275786, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 161096, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9476.235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 445154236, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2763.285469533694, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4046063819, "stage_ordering_ns": 1200953680, "stage_eval_ns": 3433110586, "stage_threat_ns": 6701148211, "stage_proof_ns": 124242205, "tactical_annotations": 831461, "root_tactical_annotations": 3109, "search_tactical_annotations": 828352, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 401219, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2248729811, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1051464, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4018701092, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 79585, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2363668450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 200601, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 280696679, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 13750, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 85458323, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 401202, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46552926, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 297705, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 462901468, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 371599, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 970566858, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 162157, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21009380, "child_limit_applications": 38170, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38170, "child_cap_hits": 38170, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38170, "child_moves_before_total": 3399635, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3399635, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 617844, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 617844, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.06562745611737, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.186638721509038, "tt_hits": 15518, "tt_cutoffs": 2785, "beta_cutoffs": 28368, "depth_sum": 79, "avg_depth": 4.647058823529412, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 79, "avg_effective_depth": 4.647058823529412, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6180.705882352941, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6651.294117647059, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1879, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 752, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20599, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 82, 97, 98, 95, 84, 126, 81, 83, 111, 69, 110, 55, 41, 113, 42, 70, 40, 39, 71, 54, 43, 44, 57, 85, 109, 108, 72, 115, 100, 117, 116, 101, 53, 133 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 16274, "avg_search_time_ms": 957.2941176470588, "search_nodes": 200986, "safety_nodes": 324, "corridor_nodes": 2092, "corridor_branch_probes": 2676, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 770, "corridor_neutral_exits": 37, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2057, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2057, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 194, "corridor_proof_active": 35, "corridor_proof_quiet": 159, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 37, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 770, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 194, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 194, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1634, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 942000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 203402, "avg_nodes": 11964.823529411764, "eval_calls": 139971, "avg_eval_calls": 8233.588235294117, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 139971, "pattern_eval_ns": 2838586, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.279815104557372, "pattern_frame_queries": 139971, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2838586, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.279815104557372, "pattern_frame_updates": 401812, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3517396598, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8753.836615133445, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 57266, "avg_candidate_generations": 3368.5882352941176, "candidate_moves_total": 4532407, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.14656165962352, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1185, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 57249, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4531222, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 1533906, "avg_legality_checks": 90229.76470588235, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1153, "root_legality_checks": 1185, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1532721, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1150, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4890854, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 287697.29411764705, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9533228023, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1949.19497147124, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22297, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1311.5882352941176, "renju_forbidden_ns": 92373843, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4142.882136610307, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1723, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8783236, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8628, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 55646795, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11536, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25413589, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 410, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2530223, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 101696, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5982.117647058823, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 705065794, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6933.073021554436, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 135599, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7976.411764705882, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 275202056, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2029.5286543411087, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3359799957, "stage_ordering_ns": 1586356891, "stage_eval_ns": 3520235184, "stage_threat_ns": 7196552157, "stage_proof_ns": 528469455, "tactical_annotations": 841658, "root_tactical_annotations": 4306, "search_tactical_annotations": 837352, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 406331, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2072403499, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 927420, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4766340941, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 116300, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3348287296, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 203157, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 268537315, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4502, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 27741424, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 406314, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44698175, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 301045, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 180337043, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 380795, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 981608277, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 159818, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16830803, "child_limit_applications": 57249, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 57249, "child_cap_hits": 57249, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 57249, "child_moves_before_total": 4530072, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4530072, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 917566, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 917566, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.12927736729026, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.027633670457124, "tt_hits": 23214, "tt_cutoffs": 3687, "beta_cutoffs": 48244, "depth_sum": 79, "avg_depth": 4.647058823529412, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 79, "avg_effective_depth": 4.647058823529412, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5101.529411764706, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5572.117647058823, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 4307, "avg_search_time_ms": 253.35294117647058, "search_nodes": 382252, "safety_nodes": 1622, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 383874, "avg_nodes": 22580.823529411766, "eval_calls": 372869, "avg_eval_calls": 21933.470588235294, "line_shape_eval_calls": 372869, "line_shape_eval_ns": 448774261, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1203.5708546433198, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9351, "avg_candidate_generations": 550.0588235294117, "candidate_moves_total": 747750, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.96470965672121, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1206, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 9334, "search_candidate_moves_total": 746544, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 14700, "avg_legality_checks": 864.7058823529412, "illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 14700, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 33779, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1987.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 66731994, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1975.5467598211908, "renju_forbidden_checks": 195, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11.470588235294118, "renju_forbidden_ns": 822154, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4216.174358974359, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 167, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 658093, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 164061, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 36228370, "stage_ordering_ns": 279652, "stage_eval_ns": 448774261, "stage_threat_ns": 3795823145, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 764423, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3276594133, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 47, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 458821, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15930, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 382203, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 442137901, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 764406, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 76632290, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 323, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8563, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6783.764705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7254.35294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 753, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11306, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 98, 126, 67, 52, 125, 142, 94, 174, 158, 129, 130, 114, 96, 95, 100, 99, 144, 156, 170, 84, 69, 172, 68, 157, 187, 66, 83, 111, 53, 38, 113 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 2894, "avg_search_time_ms": 170.23529411764707, "search_nodes": 180405, "safety_nodes": 1562, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 181967, "avg_nodes": 10703.941176470587, "eval_calls": 175825, "avg_eval_calls": 10342.64705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 175825, "line_shape_eval_ns": 295078347, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1678.2502317645385, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4548, "avg_candidate_generations": 267.52941176470586, "candidate_moves_total": 424097, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.24912049252418, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1338, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 4531, "search_candidate_moves_total": 422759, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 172176, "avg_legality_checks": 10128.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 320, "root_legality_checks": 1338, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 170838, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 319, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 192145, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11302.64705882353, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 437013485, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2274.3942595435738, "renju_forbidden_checks": 575, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 33.8235294117647, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3243402, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5640.699130434783, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 569, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3200562, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 42840, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.9411764705882355, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 667243, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9958.850746268658, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.235294117647059, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 328411, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3690.0112359550562, "stage_move_gen_ns": 412016383, "stage_ordering_ns": 141310, "stage_eval_ns": 295078347, "stage_threat_ns": 2158301118, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 360729, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1885993954, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 932663, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17070, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 180356, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 229900711, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 360712, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41473790, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 318, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4002, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6781.529411764706, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7252.117647058823, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1912, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 8399, "avg_search_time_ms": 524.9375, "search_nodes": 71335, "safety_nodes": 1589, "corridor_nodes": 1856, "corridor_branch_probes": 2167, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 699, "corridor_neutral_exits": 19, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 1828, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1828, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 55, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 21, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 699, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 80, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 575, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24147200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 74780, "avg_nodes": 4673.75, "eval_calls": 50970, "avg_eval_calls": 3185.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50970, "pattern_eval_ns": 1062706, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.8496370413969, "pattern_frame_queries": 50970, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1062706, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.8496370413969, "pattern_frame_updates": 142520, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1559292968, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10940.871232107775, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18985, "avg_candidate_generations": 1186.5625, "candidate_moves_total": 1548838, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.58219647089808, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1267, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 18969, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1547571, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 966533, "avg_legality_checks": 60408.3125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 228, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 966533, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 228, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2544209, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 159013.0625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5283694397, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2076.753284419637, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24738, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1546.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 78444642, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3171.0179480960464, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 274, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2209705, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5019, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43224699, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19440, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32958698, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 51540, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93938, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5871.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 949412693, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10106.801219953586, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 128123, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8007.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 469209886, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3662.1831052972534, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2298466076, "stage_ordering_ns": 626450080, "stage_eval_ns": 1560355674, "stage_threat_ns": 3722818370, "stage_proof_ns": 136569633, "tactical_annotations": 368321, "root_tactical_annotations": 1421, "search_tactical_annotations": 366900, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 146358, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 896404061, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 438834, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2669859581, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 39307, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1364106138, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 73171, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107816750, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3822, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20933408, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 146342, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18245978, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96384, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 404523237, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 186457, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 815347304, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 85480, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9558592, "child_limit_applications": 18969, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18969, "child_cap_hits": 18969, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18969, "child_moves_before_total": 1547343, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1547343, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 304960, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 304960, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.57219674205282, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.076756813748748, "tt_hits": 8108, "tt_cutoffs": 1321, "beta_cutoffs": 15643, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6059.4375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6559.4375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1844, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 754, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12991, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 67, 127, 126, 143, 98, 84, 99, 100, 83, 115, 111, 125, 96, 95, 81, 141, 66 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 12626, "avg_search_time_ms": 1402.888888888889, "search_nodes": 155195, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 3516, "corridor_branch_probes": 3735, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1478, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 3493, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3493, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1478, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 546, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 75322880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 158911, "avg_nodes": 17656.777777777777, "eval_calls": 125161, "avg_eval_calls": 13906.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 125161, "pattern_eval_ns": 2482976, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.838256325852303, "pattern_frame_queries": 125161, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2482976, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.838256325852303, "pattern_frame_updates": 310316, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3527297462, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11366.79211513425, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28533, "avg_candidate_generations": 3170.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2102614, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.69060386219465, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 559, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 28524, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2102055, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 966143, "avg_legality_checks": 107349.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1106, "root_legality_checks": 559, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 965584, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1106, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3858818, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 428757.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7572646771, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1962.4265179129982, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43278, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4808.666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 177280364, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4096.316003512177, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1883, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10965860, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23838, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 124777433, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16823, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37142573, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 734, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4394498, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 112483, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12498.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 881937506, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7840.629303983713, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 146888, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16320.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 347579132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2366.2867763193726, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2158608434, "stage_ordering_ns": 797556413, "stage_eval_ns": 3529780438, "stage_threat_ns": 5611883027, "stage_proof_ns": 481335526, "tactical_annotations": 461149, "root_tactical_annotations": 2134, "search_tactical_annotations": 459015, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 317443, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1688620273, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 626665, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3624315970, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59150, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1989318041, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 158717, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 209826010, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7118, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 39806088, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 317434, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36017893, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 132612, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 165087131, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 224486, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 938617062, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 104051, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13296793, "child_limit_applications": 28524, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28524, "child_cap_hits": 28524, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28524, "child_moves_before_total": 2100949, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2100949, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 476127, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 476127, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.65548310194923, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.692153975599496, "tt_hits": 10432, "tt_cutoffs": 1473, "beta_cutoffs": 20444, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1185.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1789.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 356, "avg_search_time_ms": 44.5, "search_nodes": 31121, "safety_nodes": 745, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 31866, "avg_nodes": 3983.25, "eval_calls": 29797, "avg_eval_calls": 3724.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 29797, "line_shape_eval_ns": 16675241, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 559.6281840453737, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1309, "avg_candidate_generations": 163.625, "candidate_moves_total": 87159, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.58441558441558, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 499, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 1301, "search_candidate_moves_total": 86660, "search_candidate_moves_max": 86, "legality_checks": 3191, "avg_legality_checks": 398.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3191, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12604, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1575.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25331055, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2009.7631704220883, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18000, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2571.4285714285716, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2640, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 15360, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8025279, "stage_ordering_ns": 38610, "stage_eval_ns": 16675241, "stage_threat_ns": 321218213, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 62204, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 281021253, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 197791, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7900, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 31098, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 33987215, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 62196, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6011954, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 66, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1175, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5390.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6390.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1953, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 755, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12698, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 127, 142, 114, 115, 94, 96, 68, 140, 95, 138, 124, 158, 174, 141, 139, 143, 144, 154, 129, 159, 128, 186, 83, 98, 97, 125, 81, 65, 145 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 4999, "avg_search_time_ms": 312.4375, "search_nodes": 319028, "safety_nodes": 1331, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 320359, "avg_nodes": 20022.4375, "eval_calls": 310984, "avg_eval_calls": 19436.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 310984, "line_shape_eval_ns": 387467374, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1245.939900445039, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8014, "avg_candidate_generations": 500.875, "candidate_moves_total": 682525, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.1665834789119, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1246, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 7998, "search_candidate_moves_total": 681279, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 302722, "avg_legality_checks": 18920.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3454, "root_legality_checks": 1246, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 301476, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3445, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 321619, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20101.1875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 735926940, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2288.1948516723205, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3648, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 228.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10957960, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3003.8267543859647, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3606, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10832930, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 125030, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 70, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 524134, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7487.628571428571, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 218253, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2452.2808988764045, "stage_move_gen_ns": 732240718, "stage_ordering_ns": 249263, "stage_eval_ns": 387467374, "stage_threat_ns": 3873932852, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 637980, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3374939265, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 689125, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14720, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 318982, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 424532278, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 637964, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 73772184, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 401, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7321, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6523.9375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7023.9375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1892, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 7683, "avg_search_time_ms": 512.2, "search_nodes": 82641, "safety_nodes": 1342, "corridor_nodes": 1885, "corridor_branch_probes": 2210, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 632, "corridor_neutral_exits": 77, "corridor_terminal_exits": 48, "corridor_plies_followed": 1847, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1832, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 15, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 81, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 80, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 632, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 48, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 81, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 3, "corridor_proof_unknown": 76, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 499, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 34020960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 85868, "avg_nodes": 5724.533333333334, "eval_calls": 62715, "avg_eval_calls": 4181.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62715, "pattern_eval_ns": 1268253, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.2224826596508, "pattern_frame_queries": 62715, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1268253, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.2224826596508, "pattern_frame_updates": 165142, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1401777324, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8488.315050078114, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18805, "avg_candidate_generations": 1253.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1613388, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.79569263493751, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1167, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 18790, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1612221, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 997290, "avg_legality_checks": 66486.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3834, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 997290, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3834, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2473288, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 164885.86666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4689577382, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1896.090298420564, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14793, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 986.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64769518, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4378.389643750423, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3860, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 29803581, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20418135, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7399, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14245871, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 104, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 301931, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90569, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6037.933333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 721468937, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7965.958959467367, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118665, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7911.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 310158359, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2613.7307462183458, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2170115899, "stage_ordering_ns": 599725398, "stage_eval_ns": 1403045577, "stage_threat_ns": 3345547749, "stage_proof_ns": 118025888, "tactical_annotations": 322489, "root_tactical_annotations": 1536, "search_tactical_annotations": 320953, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169013, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 931345733, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 408799, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2248027592, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 39006, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1238024824, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84499, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 114445835, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3856, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 23492315, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 168998, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19201299, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96069, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 374347613, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 150915, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 552395259, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 75505, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9034975, "child_limit_applications": 18790, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18790, "child_cap_hits": 18790, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18790, "child_moves_before_total": 1608387, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1608387, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 301071, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 301071, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.5980308674827, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.022937732836617, "tt_hits": 7933, "tt_cutoffs": 1066, "beta_cutoffs": 14683, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6095.866666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6629.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1862, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 756, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6253, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 96, 94, 142, 114, 128, 80, 143, 98, 144, 160, 145, 146, 141 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5552, "avg_search_time_ms": 694.0, "search_nodes": 64202, "safety_nodes": 448, "corridor_nodes": 916, "corridor_branch_probes": 1092, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 366, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 898, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 898, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 60, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 366, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 60, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 447, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23854880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 7, "total_nodes": 65566, "avg_nodes": 8195.75, "eval_calls": 48366, "avg_eval_calls": 6045.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48366, "pattern_eval_ns": 989651, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.461708638299633, "pattern_frame_queries": 48366, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 989651, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.461708638299633, "pattern_frame_updates": 128340, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1312985118, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10230.521411874708, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15171, "avg_candidate_generations": 1896.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1129124, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.42647155757696, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 489, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 15163, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1128635, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 390293, "avg_legality_checks": 48786.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 635, "root_legality_checks": 489, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 389804, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 632, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1489851, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 186231.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3229544837, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2167.696526028442, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10757, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1344.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 76131559, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7077.39695082272, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 651, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6928610, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4706, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44820517, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4870, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19209677, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 530, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5172755, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 33022, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4127.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 318319355, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9639.614650838836, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 45798, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5724.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 147917259, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3229.7755142145948, "stage_move_gen_ns": 956457251, "stage_ordering_ns": 469288648, "stage_eval_ns": 1313974769, "stage_threat_ns": 2568389841, "stage_proof_ns": 212295507, "tactical_annotations": 167585, "root_tactical_annotations": 1164, "search_tactical_annotations": 166421, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 130264, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 754293453, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 219272, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1695545815, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30984, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1121529733, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 65128, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 89281648, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1916, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10295756, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 130256, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15224531, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 41701, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 62380042, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 89548, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 362332042, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 36336, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3748638, "child_limit_applications": 15163, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15163, "child_cap_hits": 15163, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15163, "child_moves_before_total": 1128003, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1128003, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 242695, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 242695, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.39180900877135, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00573765086065, "tt_hits": 5669, "tt_cutoffs": 641, "beta_cutoffs": 12002, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3482.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4482.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 993, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 695, "avg_search_time_ms": 99.28571428571429, "search_nodes": 51287, "safety_nodes": 476, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 51763, "avg_nodes": 7394.714285714285, "eval_calls": 49153, "avg_eval_calls": 7021.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 49153, "line_shape_eval_ns": 36034462, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 733.1080910626005, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2121, "avg_candidate_generations": 303.0, "candidate_moves_total": 142653, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.25742574257426, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 418, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 2114, "search_candidate_moves_total": 142235, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 4958, "avg_legality_checks": 708.2857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4958, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13110, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1872.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29194391, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2226.879557589626, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.857142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 240831, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12041.55, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 96970, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 143861, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13808936, "stage_ordering_ns": 65610, "stage_eval_ns": 36034462, "stage_threat_ns": 637717598, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 102541, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 560133056, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 141571, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 65421424, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 102534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12021547, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 119, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1893, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4919.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6062.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1969, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 757, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10713, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 96, 128, 109, 108, 143, 114, 100, 156, 170, 124, 140, 130, 125, 155, 95, 80, 127, 79, 159 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1201, "avg_search_time_ms": 109.18181818181819, "search_nodes": 73393, "safety_nodes": 1121, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 74514, "avg_nodes": 6774.0, "eval_calls": 70994, "avg_eval_calls": 6454.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 70994, "line_shape_eval_ns": 54584980, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 768.8675099304166, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2379, "avg_candidate_generations": 216.27272727272728, "candidate_moves_total": 163510, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.73055905842791, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 743, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 2368, "search_candidate_moves_total": 162767, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 69687, "avg_legality_checks": 6335.181818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "root_legality_checks": 743, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 68944, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 82810, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7528.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 199928852, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2414.3080787344525, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.090909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 454411, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10098.022222222222, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 261490, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 192921, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 855495, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11256.513157894737, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 116, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.545454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 466564, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4022.103448275862, "stage_move_gen_ns": 178809887, "stage_ordering_ns": 74081, "stage_eval_ns": 54584980, "stage_threat_ns": 955922937, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 146735, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 840554466, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1094557, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 73362, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96370736, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 146724, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17903178, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 119, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2135, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5942.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6669.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1900, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9501, "avg_search_time_ms": 950.1, "search_nodes": 95004, "safety_nodes": 391, "corridor_nodes": 987, "corridor_branch_probes": 1188, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 307, "corridor_neutral_exits": 34, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 966, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 966, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 84, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 63, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 307, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 84, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 685, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 51861240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1993120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 96382, "avg_nodes": 9638.2, "eval_calls": 73996, "avg_eval_calls": 7399.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73996, "pattern_eval_ns": 1568865, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.202024433753177, "pattern_frame_queries": 73996, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1568865, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.202024433753177, "pattern_frame_updates": 189918, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2169176090, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11421.645604945292, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19766, "avg_candidate_generations": 1976.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1635491, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.74263887483558, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 678, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 19756, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1634813, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1022128, "avg_legality_checks": 102212.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5057, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1022128, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5057, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2792294, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 279229.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5784920725, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2071.744853872837, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27972, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2797.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 216375461, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7735.430466180466, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5075, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 51553150, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13629, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 131957558, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9248, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32637892, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 226861, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89376, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8937.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 908930730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10169.740534371644, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132085, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13208.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 461218871, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3491.8338267025024, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2477881460, "stage_ordering_ns": 668805408, "stage_eval_ns": 2170744955, "stage_threat_ns": 4004058886, "stage_proof_ns": 133426987, "tactical_annotations": 365045, "root_tactical_annotations": 1696, "search_tactical_annotations": 363349, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 192028, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1116346168, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 377501, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2700648739, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40400, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1478667299, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 96009, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 139176097, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2100, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10692148, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 192018, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24216498, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 89538, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 386246557, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 177498, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 785116834, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 98009, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12979236, "child_limit_applications": 19756, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19756, "child_cap_hits": 19756, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19756, "child_moves_before_total": 1629756, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1629756, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 316378, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 316378, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.49422960113384, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.014274144563675, "tt_hits": 8547, "tt_cutoffs": 1207, "beta_cutoffs": 14896, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4411.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5211.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1865, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 758, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17217, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 83, 144, 96, 95, 97, 127, 99, 100, 143, 129, 68, 53, 126, 80, 65, 109, 108, 79, 63, 81, 67, 78, 82, 77 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 16619, "avg_search_time_ms": 1187.0714285714287, "search_nodes": 135782, "safety_nodes": 365, "corridor_nodes": 20623, "corridor_branch_probes": 21156, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 12284, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 20583, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 20583, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 104, "corridor_proof_active": 40, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 12284, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 104, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 827, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24117360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1970560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 156770, "avg_nodes": 11197.857142857143, "eval_calls": 99942, "avg_eval_calls": 7138.714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 99942, "pattern_eval_ns": 2037498, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.386804346520982, "pattern_frame_queries": 99942, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2037498, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.386804346520982, "pattern_frame_updates": 271440, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3070943749, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11313.526926760978, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34209, "avg_candidate_generations": 2443.5, "candidate_moves_total": 2716483, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.4084305299775, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 922, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 34195, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2715561, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 807472, "avg_legality_checks": 57676.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1456, "root_legality_checks": 922, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 806550, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1454, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5055726, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 361123.28571428574, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10294684632, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2036.242595425464, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28978, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2069.8571428571427, "renju_forbidden_ns": 119275316, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4116.064462695838, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1619, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14391711, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11620, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64528993, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12815, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28682415, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2924, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 11672197, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 149335, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10666.785714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1270739266, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8509.319757591991, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 198749, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14196.357142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 558127967, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2808.2051582649474, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1942435123, "stage_ordering_ns": 1081484290, "stage_eval_ns": 3072981247, "stage_threat_ns": 8837279664, "stage_proof_ns": 1640620054, "tactical_annotations": 566726, "root_tactical_annotations": 3192, "search_tactical_annotations": 563534, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 312828, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2026043302, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1340362, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6290625974, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 76752, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2848615258, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 156407, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 238792355, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 41374, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 228352219, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 312814, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38504380, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 181121, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 293534655, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 247625, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 909000529, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 137980, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14961434, "child_limit_applications": 34195, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34195, "child_cap_hits": 34195, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34195, "child_moves_before_total": 2714107, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2714107, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 548998, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 548998, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.3714578154701, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.05492030998684, "tt_hits": 15312, "tt_cutoffs": 1583, "beta_cutoffs": 27802, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4352.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4923.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 887, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 582, "avg_search_time_ms": 44.76923076923077, "search_nodes": 40711, "safety_nodes": 1167, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 41878, "avg_nodes": 3221.3846153846152, "eval_calls": 38391, "avg_eval_calls": 2953.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 38391, "line_shape_eval_ns": 35768325, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 931.685160584512, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2295, "avg_candidate_generations": 176.53846153846155, "candidate_moves_total": 161562, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.39738562091503, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 861, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 2282, "search_candidate_moves_total": 160701, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 5169, "avg_legality_checks": 397.61538461538464, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5169, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20211, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1554.6923076923076, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 42774964, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2116.4199693236355, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.0769230769230769, "renju_forbidden_ns": 154570, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11040.714285714286, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 67480, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 87090, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14084893, "stage_ordering_ns": 71460, "stage_eval_ns": 35768325, "stage_threat_ns": 514708655, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 81359, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 454235357, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 327021, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40673, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 50590824, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 81346, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9555453, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 135, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2045, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6407.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7023.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 759, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6303, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 111, 143, 98, 144, 82, 67, 141, 158, 173, 174, 190, 110, 189, 126 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 295, "avg_search_time_ms": 36.875, "search_nodes": 19159, "safety_nodes": 474, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 19633, "avg_nodes": 2454.125, "eval_calls": 18218, "avg_eval_calls": 2277.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 18218, "line_shape_eval_ns": 12593612, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 691.273026676913, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 926, "avg_candidate_generations": 115.75, "candidate_moves_total": 54847, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.23002159827214, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 425, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 918, "search_candidate_moves_total": 54422, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 14293, "avg_legality_checks": 1786.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 55, "root_legality_checks": 425, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 13868, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23609, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2951.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 53100584, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2249.1670125799483, "renju_forbidden_checks": 89, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 771465, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8668.14606741573, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 55, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 479512, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 291953, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 529762, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10187.73076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 284610, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3846.0810810810813, "stage_move_gen_ns": 36878700, "stage_ordering_ns": 29960, "stage_eval_ns": 12593612, "stage_threat_ns": 236361645, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 38280, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 208081883, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 671483, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 19136, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 23245724, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 38272, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4362555, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 84, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 782, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5430.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6430.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1942, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5999, "avg_search_time_ms": 749.875, "search_nodes": 66012, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 2488, "corridor_branch_probes": 2925, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1062, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2466, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2466, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 40, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1062, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 40, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 287, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 273200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 17680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 68700, "avg_nodes": 8587.5, "eval_calls": 51470, "avg_eval_calls": 6433.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51470, "pattern_eval_ns": 1006866, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.562191567903632, "pattern_frame_queries": 51470, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1006866, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.562191567903632, "pattern_frame_updates": 131956, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1469840039, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11138.864765527904, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13577, "avg_candidate_generations": 1697.125, "candidate_moves_total": 949048, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.90115636738602, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 450, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 13569, "search_candidate_moves_total": 948598, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 577891, "avg_legality_checks": 72236.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7548, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 577891, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7548, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1959131, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 244891.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3523648011, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1798.5770277740487, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42657, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5332.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 236660358, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5547.984105773964, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7583, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 60009267, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20638, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 136022482, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14358, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39995825, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 78, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 632784, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75207, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9400.875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 729782975, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9703.657571768585, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109963, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13745.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 384670031, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3498.1769413348125, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1290339561, "stage_ordering_ns": 345930113, "stage_eval_ns": 1470846905, "stage_threat_ns": 2807674582, "stage_proof_ns": 51841470, "tactical_annotations": 281641, "root_tactical_annotations": 1288, "search_tactical_annotations": 280353, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136976, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 718021483, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 390914, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1957803358, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28280, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 948121359, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68484, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87522343, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5012, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22124895, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136968, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14859706, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 80537, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 351095762, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 135170, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 553250292, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 65934, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7342797, "child_limit_applications": 13569, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13569, "child_cap_hits": 13569, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13569, "child_moves_before_total": 941050, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 941050, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 223523, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 223523, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.3529368413295, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.47306360085489, "tt_hits": 5711, "tt_cutoffs": 939, "beta_cutoffs": 10323, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4239.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5239.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1835, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 760, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13787, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 98, 114, 142, 97, 84, 126, 81, 129, 82, 83, 69, 144, 159, 130, 70, 56, 68, 145, 161, 131, 132, 67, 99, 100, 54, 39, 96, 40, 110 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 11572, "avg_search_time_ms": 771.4666666666667, "search_nodes": 149342, "safety_nodes": 722, "corridor_nodes": 7585, "corridor_branch_probes": 8555, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3428, "corridor_neutral_exits": 48, "corridor_terminal_exits": 57, "corridor_plies_followed": 7526, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 7526, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 154, "corridor_proof_active": 59, "corridor_proof_quiet": 95, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 48, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3428, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 57, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 154, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 153, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1255, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 44394080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 157649, "avg_nodes": 10509.933333333332, "eval_calls": 110894, "avg_eval_calls": 7392.933333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110894, "pattern_eval_ns": 2074979, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.711373022886722, "pattern_frame_queries": 110894, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2074979, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.711373022886722, "pattern_frame_updates": 298550, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2562054158, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8581.658542957628, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 36209, "avg_candidate_generations": 2413.9333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 2738064, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.61832693529233, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1011, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 36194, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2737053, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1064940, "avg_legality_checks": 70996.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1949, "root_legality_checks": 1011, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1063929, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1946, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4561697, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 304113.13333333336, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6954726480, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1524.591940236276, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32189, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2145.9333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 134768138, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4186.776165770915, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2050, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17101135, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13040, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72590985, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14734, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30119415, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2365, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 14956603, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 132118, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8807.866666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 878598126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6650.101621277949, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 170146, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11343.066666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 393508797, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2312.7713669436835, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1697024752, "stage_ordering_ns": 780703233, "stage_eval_ns": 2564129137, "stage_threat_ns": 5611121955, "stage_proof_ns": 850656447, "tactical_annotations": 662943, "root_tactical_annotations": 2682, "search_tactical_annotations": 660261, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 313925, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1364348408, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 978944, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3919554184, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 76639, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1969448986, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 156955, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 175457828, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 15360, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 106675425, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 313910, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28271999, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 197994, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 203577050, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 304919, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 814797938, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 160030, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16814111, "child_limit_applications": 36194, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 36194, "child_cap_hits": 36194, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 36194, "child_moves_before_total": 2735107, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2735107, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 584110, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 584110, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.56796706636459, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.138310217163067, "tt_hits": 15043, "tt_cutoffs": 2187, "beta_cutoffs": 29033, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5932.866666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6466.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1250, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2203, "avg_search_time_ms": 157.35714285714286, "search_nodes": 228518, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 229557, "avg_nodes": 16396.928571428572, "eval_calls": 222812, "avg_eval_calls": 15915.142857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 222812, "line_shape_eval_ns": 198862865, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 892.5141599195734, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5679, "avg_candidate_generations": 405.64285714285717, "candidate_moves_total": 433505, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.3347420320479, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 955, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 5665, "search_candidate_moves_total": 432550, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 11673, "avg_legality_checks": 833.7857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11673, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27590, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1970.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 44959852, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1629.570569046756, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.357142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 344231, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10431.242424242424, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 216990, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 127241, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23461356, "stage_ordering_ns": 168331, "stage_eval_ns": 198862865, "stage_threat_ns": 1943090159, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 456968, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1688050891, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 211140, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 228477, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 215154373, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 456954, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39673755, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 327, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5133, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6546.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7117.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1955, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 761, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7925, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 96, 128, 125, 143, 109, 108, 98, 129, 130, 145, 161, 81, 146, 97 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 735, "avg_search_time_ms": 91.875, "search_nodes": 45282, "safety_nodes": 474, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 45756, "avg_nodes": 5719.5, "eval_calls": 43622, "avg_eval_calls": 5452.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 43622, "line_shape_eval_ns": 29943597, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 686.4333822383201, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1645, "avg_candidate_generations": 205.625, "candidate_moves_total": 95741, "avg_candidate_moves": 58.20121580547112, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 425, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 1637, "search_candidate_moves_total": 95316, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 40290, "avg_legality_checks": 5036.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 152, "root_legality_checks": 425, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 39865, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 144, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 49576, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6197.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 119023050, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2400.8199532031626, "renju_forbidden_checks": 186, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 23.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2054960, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11048.172043010753, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 152, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1673147, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 381813, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 589143, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11329.673076923076, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 317971, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4296.905405405405, "stage_move_gen_ns": 104574613, "stage_ordering_ns": 51560, "stage_eval_ns": 29943597, "stage_threat_ns": 590870916, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 90526, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 518791942, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 765204, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 45259, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 59950903, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 90518, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11362867, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 84, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1460, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5282.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6282.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1931, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7182, "avg_search_time_ms": 897.75, "search_nodes": 66454, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 1913, "corridor_branch_probes": 2239, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 807, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1894, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1894, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 807, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 35, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 278, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 237200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 68567, "avg_nodes": 8570.875, "eval_calls": 51784, "avg_eval_calls": 6473.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51784, "pattern_eval_ns": 1089175, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.033041093774138, "pattern_frame_queries": 51784, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1089175, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.033041093774138, "pattern_frame_updates": 132840, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1998755059, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15046.334379704907, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13666, "avg_candidate_generations": 1708.25, "candidate_moves_total": 957885, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.09256549099956, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 450, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 13658, "search_candidate_moves_total": 957435, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 571150, "avg_legality_checks": 71393.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8377, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 571150, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8377, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1993115, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 249139.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4212880126, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2113.7165321619677, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41908, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5238.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 375378943, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8957.214445929178, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8410, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 88784289, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22222, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 233391379, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11216, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 52520373, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 682902, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74480, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9310.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 818313768, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10987.026960257788, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 108546, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13568.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 433438795, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3993.1346618023695, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1487291930, "stage_ordering_ns": 407003009, "stage_eval_ns": 1999844234, "stage_threat_ns": 3207107029, "stage_proof_ns": 51004608, "tactical_annotations": 288772, "root_tactical_annotations": 1288, "search_tactical_annotations": 287484, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136710, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 836931632, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 364162, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2222990780, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28251, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1095687691, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68351, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 102262124, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3862, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18644214, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136702, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17520375, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 78449, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 392291391, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 141496, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 639625407, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 68827, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8757904, "child_limit_applications": 13658, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13658, "child_cap_hits": 13658, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13658, "child_moves_before_total": 949058, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 949058, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 226833, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 226833, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.48733343095621, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.60806853126373, "tt_hits": 5706, "tt_cutoffs": 978, "beta_cutoffs": 10393, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3977.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4977.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1842, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 762, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2876, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 99, 141, 128, 109, 108, 93, 77, 157 ], "move_count": 15, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 2559, "avg_search_time_ms": 426.5, "search_nodes": 37202, "safety_nodes": 166, "corridor_nodes": 383, "corridor_branch_probes": 467, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 148, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 376, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 376, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 148, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 283, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23966720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 37751, "avg_nodes": 6291.833333333333, "eval_calls": 28838, "avg_eval_calls": 4806.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 28838, "pattern_eval_ns": 552242, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.149802344129274, "pattern_frame_queries": 28838, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 552242, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.149802344129274, "pattern_frame_updates": 74360, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 718708358, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9665.254948897256, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7891, "avg_candidate_generations": 1315.1666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 497914, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.09897351413002, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 304, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 7885, "search_candidate_moves_total": 497610, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 203056, "avg_legality_checks": 33842.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 91, "root_legality_checks": 304, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 202752, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 91, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 887330, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 147888.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1512030914, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1704.0232089527008, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5765, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 960.8333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18845673, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3268.9805724197745, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 93, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 486860, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2720, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14033487, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2927, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4203925, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 121401, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 22055, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3675.8333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 178073004, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8074.04234867377, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 30988, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5164.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 84989690, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2742.6645798373565, "stage_move_gen_ns": 423336933, "stage_ordering_ns": 161523738, "stage_eval_ns": 719260600, "stage_threat_ns": 1157713509, "stage_proof_ns": 81705215, "tactical_annotations": 80428, "root_tactical_annotations": 701, "search_tactical_annotations": 79727, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 75192, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 348161675, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 102721, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 752936202, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16085, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 491538549, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37593, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 44788434, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 826, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2597890, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 75186, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7598025, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 16422, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 29102378, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 45455, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 196049755, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 18551, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1631283, "child_limit_applications": 7885, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 7885, "child_cap_hits": 7885, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 7885, "child_moves_before_total": 497519, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 497519, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 126174, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 126174, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 63.096892834495875, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001775523145213, "tt_hits": 3299, "tt_cutoffs": 457, "beta_cutoffs": 5992, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3375.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4708.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1387, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 7, "search_move_count": 5, "total_time_ms": 313, "avg_search_time_ms": 62.6, "search_nodes": 31494, "safety_nodes": 190, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 31684, "avg_nodes": 6336.8, "eval_calls": 30026, "avg_eval_calls": 6005.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 30026, "line_shape_eval_ns": 14583819, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 485.7063544927729, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1459, "avg_candidate_generations": 291.8, "candidate_moves_total": 87557, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.01165181631254, "candidate_moves_max": 78, "root_candidate_generations": 5, "root_candidate_moves_total": 248, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 1454, "search_candidate_moves_total": 87309, "search_candidate_moves_max": 78, "legality_checks": 3197, "avg_legality_checks": 639.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3197, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8833, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1766.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13208175, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1495.3215215668515, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6515215, "stage_ordering_ns": 41991, "stage_eval_ns": 14583819, "stage_threat_ns": 287358961, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 62965, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 249774552, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 30370, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 10, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3240, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 31480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 31913644, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 62960, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5640395, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 95, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1282, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3843.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5443.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1991, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 763, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4576, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 98, 126, 81, 125, 67, 52, 128, 141, 156, 155, 169, 99, 170, 113 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 208, "avg_search_time_ms": 26.0, "search_nodes": 19069, "safety_nodes": 474, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 19543, "avg_nodes": 2442.875, "eval_calls": 18124, "avg_eval_calls": 2265.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 18124, "line_shape_eval_ns": 10356255, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 571.4111123372325, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 930, "avg_candidate_generations": 116.25, "candidate_moves_total": 55008, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.148387096774194, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 425, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 922, "search_candidate_moves_total": 54583, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 14198, "avg_legality_checks": 1774.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 52, "root_legality_checks": 425, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 13773, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 44, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23484, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2935.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 33005894, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1405.4630386646227, "renju_forbidden_checks": 86, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 779305, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9061.686046511628, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 463343, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 315962, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 433863, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8343.51923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 244343, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3301.9324324324325, "stage_move_gen_ns": 21827763, "stage_ordering_ns": 26780, "stage_eval_ns": 10356255, "stage_threat_ns": 170040464, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 38100, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 147501746, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 561233, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 19046, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 18737449, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 38092, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 3240036, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 84, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 784, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5460.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6460.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1967, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 4359, "avg_search_time_ms": 544.875, "search_nodes": 65328, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 2482, "corridor_branch_probes": 2932, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1068, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 2460, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2460, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 40, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1068, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 40, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 287, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 271040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 17680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 68010, "avg_nodes": 8501.25, "eval_calls": 51106, "avg_eval_calls": 6388.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51106, "pattern_eval_ns": 961174, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.80745900677024, "pattern_frame_queries": 51106, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 961174, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.80745900677024, "pattern_frame_updates": 130588, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1196481677, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9162.263584709162, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13281, "avg_candidate_generations": 1660.125, "candidate_moves_total": 920575, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.3151871094044, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 450, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 13273, "search_candidate_moves_total": 920125, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 567256, "avg_legality_checks": 70907.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7266, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 567256, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7266, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1920288, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 240036.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2431802568, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1266.3738814177873, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41614, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5201.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 209991169, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5046.166410342673, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7483, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 47334657, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19777, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 130368636, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14276, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31593894, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 78, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 693982, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74543, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9317.875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 490571459, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6581.053338341629, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109301, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13662.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 268420491, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2455.7917219421597, "stage_move_gen_ns": 871794845, "stage_ordering_ns": 231783179, "stage_eval_ns": 1197442851, "stage_threat_ns": 2002203512, "stage_proof_ns": 26062214, "tactical_annotations": 277739, "root_tactical_annotations": 1288, "search_tactical_annotations": 276451, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 135596, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 559052081, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 386292, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1333922618, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27680, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 630157490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67794, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73049376, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5000, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17925422, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 135588, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12104595, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 79463, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 254801120, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 132692, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 362172428, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 65584, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6149420, "child_limit_applications": 13273, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13273, "child_cap_hits": 13273, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13273, "child_moves_before_total": 912859, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 912859, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 218719, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 218719, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.77563474723122, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.478490168010246, "tt_hits": 5667, "tt_cutoffs": 915, "beta_cutoffs": 10049, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5008.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6008.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1913, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 764, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14494, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 81, 95, 127, 82, 129, 113, 126, 128, 98, 84, 157, 142, 143, 115, 154, 140, 156, 155, 125, 68, 171, 185, 141, 186, 173, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 13968, "avg_search_time_ms": 997.7142857142857, "search_nodes": 185054, "safety_nodes": 579, "corridor_nodes": 1756, "corridor_branch_probes": 2070, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 546, "corridor_neutral_exits": 55, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1711, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1711, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 162, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 117, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 55, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 546, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 162, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 160, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1362, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 133648560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1993440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 187389, "avg_nodes": 13384.92857142857, "eval_calls": 148576, "avg_eval_calls": 10612.57142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 148576, "pattern_eval_ns": 3023220, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.347970062459616, "pattern_frame_queries": 148576, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3023220, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.347970062459616, "pattern_frame_updates": 369984, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4081780628, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11032.316608285764, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34391, "avg_candidate_generations": 2456.5, "candidate_moves_total": 2537438, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.78203599779012, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 893, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 34377, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2536545, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1018319, "avg_legality_checks": 72737.07142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 414, "root_legality_checks": 893, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1017426, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 414, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3919047, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 279931.9285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8103377301, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2067.690767934143, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22287, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1591.9285714285713, "renju_forbidden_ns": 68353989, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3066.9892313904966, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 531, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3720399, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10667, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 50012322, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11021, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14454458, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 68, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 166810, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83149, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5939.214285714285, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 643412931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7738.071786792385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 104271, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7447.928571428572, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 250430123, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2401.723614427789, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2330266279, "stage_ordering_ns": 1000039415, "stage_eval_ns": 4084803848, "stage_threat_ns": 6017723147, "stage_proof_ns": 476333456, "tactical_annotations": 577140, "root_tactical_annotations": 2849, "search_tactical_annotations": 574291, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 373744, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2040555218, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 629098, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3643142220, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70331, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2378636733, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 186865, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 255104805, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3746, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18195459, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 373730, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44145761, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 150723, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 140418420, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 282860, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 871117954, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 143557, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16579684, "child_limit_applications": 34377, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34377, "child_cap_hits": 34377, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34377, "child_moves_before_total": 2536131, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2536131, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 550077, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 550077, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.77406405445501, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001309014748234, "tt_hits": 14398, "tt_cutoffs": 2039, "beta_cutoffs": 24569, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4373.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4944.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 732, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 514, "avg_search_time_ms": 39.53846153846154, "search_nodes": 35577, "safety_nodes": 1059, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 36636, "avg_nodes": 2818.153846153846, "eval_calls": 34013, "avg_eval_calls": 2616.3846153846152, "line_shape_eval_calls": 34013, "line_shape_eval_ns": 42261019, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1242.4960750301354, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1539, "avg_candidate_generations": 118.38461538461539, "candidate_moves_total": 109914, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.41910331384015, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 843, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 1526, "search_candidate_moves_total": 109071, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 5984, "avg_legality_checks": 460.3076923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5984, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20945, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1611.1538461538462, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 42480741, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2028.2043924564334, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14908234, "stage_ordering_ns": 52120, "stage_eval_ns": 42261019, "stage_threat_ns": 442086572, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 71091, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 388529754, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 212901, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13601, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35539, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 45007827, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 71078, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8336090, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 128, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1345, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6430.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7045.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1924, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 765, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7622, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 127, 99, 96, 84, 110, 109, 129, 100, 101, 86, 72, 142, 87, 128 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 940, "avg_search_time_ms": 117.5, "search_nodes": 58895, "safety_nodes": 474, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59369, "avg_nodes": 7421.125, "eval_calls": 56980, "avg_eval_calls": 7122.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 56980, "line_shape_eval_ns": 39027299, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 684.9297823797824, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1900, "avg_candidate_generations": 237.5, "candidate_moves_total": 109274, "avg_candidate_moves": 57.51263157894737, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 425, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 1892, "search_candidate_moves_total": 108849, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 51875, "avg_legality_checks": 6484.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 40, "root_legality_checks": 425, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 51450, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 61191, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7648.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 145652956, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2380.300305600497, "renju_forbidden_checks": 74, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 794342, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10734.351351351352, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 437440, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 356902, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 591922, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11383.115384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 314332, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4247.72972972973, "stage_move_gen_ns": 130706675, "stage_ordering_ns": 56270, "stage_eval_ns": 39027299, "stage_threat_ns": 760815670, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 117752, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 668120304, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 765454, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58872, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 77474880, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 117744, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14455032, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 84, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1674, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5206.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6206.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1918, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6674, "avg_search_time_ms": 834.25, "search_nodes": 63893, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 2354, "corridor_branch_probes": 2773, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1028, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 2333, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2333, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 39, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1028, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 39, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 283, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 307360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 66447, "avg_nodes": 8305.875, "eval_calls": 49952, "avg_eval_calls": 6244.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49952, "pattern_eval_ns": 1028137, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.58249919923126, "pattern_frame_queries": 49952, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1028137, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.58249919923126, "pattern_frame_updates": 127718, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1684950470, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13192.74080395872, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12949, "avg_candidate_generations": 1618.625, "candidate_moves_total": 911924, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.42427986717121, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 450, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 12941, "search_candidate_moves_total": 911474, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 567550, "avg_legality_checks": 70943.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7420, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 567550, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7420, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1894033, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 236754.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3946238848, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2083.5111362896, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32953, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4119.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 286103859, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8682.179437380511, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9880, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 99356609, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14517, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 142913814, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8484, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43067164, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 766272, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72634, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9079.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 783905708, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10792.544923864856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 105269, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13158.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 400131546, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3801.038729350521, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1476957206, "stage_ordering_ns": 375542740, "stage_eval_ns": 1685978607, "stage_threat_ns": 3055280920, "stage_proof_ns": 50868830, "tactical_annotations": 282149, "root_tactical_annotations": 1288, "search_tactical_annotations": 280861, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 132470, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 797975429, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 379214, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2109960291, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26956, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1017894851, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66231, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 98108451, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4744, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 23960340, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 132462, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16531635, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 79844, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 362897156, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 134115, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 621893216, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 68190, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8744774, "child_limit_applications": 12941, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12941, "child_cap_hits": 12941, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12941, "child_moves_before_total": 904054, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 904054, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 211829, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 211829, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.85967081369292, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.36882775674214, "tt_hits": 5667, "tt_cutoffs": 966, "beta_cutoffs": 9781, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4135.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5135.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1867, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 766, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6074, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 82, 66, 81, 80, 128, 94, 52, 109, 110, 64, 48, 79, 49, 124 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5566, "avg_search_time_ms": 618.4444444444445, "search_nodes": 64126, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 747, "corridor_branch_probes": 863, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 242, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 732, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 732, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 242, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 421, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24226800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 65031, "avg_nodes": 7225.666666666667, "eval_calls": 46456, "avg_eval_calls": 5161.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46456, "pattern_eval_ns": 954384, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.54382641639401, "pattern_frame_queries": 46456, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 954384, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.54382641639401, "pattern_frame_updates": 128178, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1339879773, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10453.274142208491, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16670, "avg_candidate_generations": 1852.2222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 1128284, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.68350329934013, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 16661, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1127784, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 362360, "avg_legality_checks": 40262.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 177, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 361860, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 176, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1489962, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 165551.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3262577956, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2189.705479737067, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12723, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1413.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 52777897, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4148.227383478739, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 427, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2330751, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5872, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 36313719, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6309, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13636882, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 115, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 496545, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 32537, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3615.222222222222, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 287955414, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8850.091096290376, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 42454, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4717.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 120139268, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2829.869223159184, "stage_move_gen_ns": 889839578, "stage_ordering_ns": 446011309, "stage_eval_ns": 1340834157, "stage_threat_ns": 2673680785, "stage_proof_ns": 192670548, "tactical_annotations": 224973, "root_tactical_annotations": 1636, "search_tactical_annotations": 223337, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 129761, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 765007554, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 252762, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1785215644, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33960, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1255053741, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64876, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93614839, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1574, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8199256, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 129752, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15840013, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70507, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 57349069, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 95741, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 351059775, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 58725, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5803479, "child_limit_applications": 16661, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16661, "child_cap_hits": 16661, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16661, "child_moves_before_total": 1127608, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1127608, "child_moves_before_max": 97, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 97, "child_moves_after_total": 266589, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 266589, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.67949102694917, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0007802652902, "tt_hits": 7726, "tt_cutoffs": 972, "beta_cutoffs": 13620, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4419.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5308.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1241, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 496, "avg_search_time_ms": 62.0, "search_nodes": 35108, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35704, "avg_nodes": 4463.0, "eval_calls": 33899, "avg_eval_calls": 4237.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 33899, "line_shape_eval_ns": 28954877, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 854.1513613970914, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1194, "avg_candidate_generations": 149.25, "candidate_moves_total": 76195, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.814907872696814, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1186, "search_candidate_moves_total": 75748, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 2613, "avg_legality_checks": 326.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2613, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11724, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1465.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25286418, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2156.8080859774823, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 75940, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6903.636363636364, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11020, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 64920, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7334305, "stage_ordering_ns": 36461, "stage_eval_ns": 28954877, "stage_threat_ns": 453983338, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 70178, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 397830144, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 165300, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35085, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 47615792, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 70170, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8372102, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1085, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5417.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6417.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 767, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7262, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 113, 141, 96, 140, 82, 67, 143, 156, 171, 170, 184, 114, 185, 128 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 323, "avg_search_time_ms": 40.375, "search_nodes": 19244, "safety_nodes": 474, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 19718, "avg_nodes": 2464.75, "eval_calls": 18299, "avg_eval_calls": 2287.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 18299, "line_shape_eval_ns": 14763333, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 806.7835947319526, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 930, "avg_candidate_generations": 116.25, "candidate_moves_total": 55038, "avg_candidate_moves": 59.18064516129032, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 425, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 922, "search_candidate_moves_total": 54613, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 14348, "avg_legality_checks": 1793.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 52, "root_legality_checks": 425, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 13923, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 44, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23664, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2958.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 54965356, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2322.741548343475, "renju_forbidden_checks": 86, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 946014, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11000.162790697674, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 587272, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 358742, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 602053, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11577.942307692309, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 317772, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4294.216216216216, "stage_move_gen_ns": 37304816, "stage_ordering_ns": 30540, "stage_eval_ns": 14763333, "stage_threat_ns": 259978955, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 38450, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 229158901, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 768343, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 19221, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 25324429, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 38442, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4727282, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 84, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 784, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5429.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6429.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1940, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6930, "avg_search_time_ms": 866.25, "search_nodes": 65523, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 2482, "corridor_branch_probes": 2932, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1068, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 2460, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2460, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 40, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1068, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 40, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 287, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 271040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 17680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 68205, "avg_nodes": 8525.625, "eval_calls": 51260, "avg_eval_calls": 6407.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51260, "pattern_eval_ns": 1051154, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.5063207179087, "pattern_frame_queries": 51260, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1051154, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.5063207179087, "pattern_frame_updates": 130978, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1767906923, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13497.739490601474, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13313, "avg_candidate_generations": 1664.125, "candidate_moves_total": 933822, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.14361901900398, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 450, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 13305, "search_candidate_moves_total": 933372, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 577522, "avg_legality_checks": 72190.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7328, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 577522, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7328, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1944635, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 243079.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4089464613, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2102.9471407230662, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41843, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5230.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 316994779, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7575.81385177927, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7558, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 77996510, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19823, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 185540491, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14384, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 52598194, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 78, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 859584, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75074, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9384.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 834755573, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11119.103457921517, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110087, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13760.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 441534287, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4010.775904511886, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1482500531, "stage_ordering_ns": 383490070, "stage_eval_ns": 1768958077, "stage_threat_ns": 3215302291, "stage_proof_ns": 52129813, "tactical_annotations": 279244, "root_tactical_annotations": 1288, "search_tactical_annotations": 277956, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 135986, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 821228353, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 387826, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2241910793, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27744, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1088934177, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67989, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 101600825, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5000, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24843461, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 135978, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16959679, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 79842, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 406476141, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 133783, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 631455810, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 65619, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8759180, "child_limit_applications": 13305, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13305, "child_cap_hits": 13305, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13305, "child_moves_before_total": 926044, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 926044, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 219364, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 219364, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.60120255543029, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.487335588124765, "tt_hits": 5678, "tt_cutoffs": 924, "beta_cutoffs": 10076, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4034.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5034.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1834, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 768, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15279, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 96, 110, 142, 97, 144, 128, 141, 143, 113, 99, 172, 157, 158, 130, 169, 155, 171, 170, 140, 83, 186, 200, 156, 201, 188, 124, 204 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 14729, "avg_search_time_ms": 1052.0714285714287, "search_nodes": 185479, "safety_nodes": 551, "corridor_nodes": 1747, "corridor_branch_probes": 2069, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 545, "corridor_neutral_exits": 54, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1702, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1702, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 162, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 117, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 54, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 545, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 162, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 160, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1362, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 133649680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1993440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 187777, "avg_nodes": 13412.642857142857, "eval_calls": 148973, "avg_eval_calls": 10640.92857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 148973, "pattern_eval_ns": 3057527, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.524034556597503, "pattern_frame_queries": 148973, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3057527, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.524034556597503, "pattern_frame_updates": 370834, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4274884336, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11527.757260661105, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34445, "avg_candidate_generations": 2460.3571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 2535455, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.60879663231238, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 876, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 34431, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2534579, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1018360, "avg_legality_checks": 72740.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 415, "root_legality_checks": 876, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1017484, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 415, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3959883, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 282848.78571428574, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8556553612, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2160.809703721044, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21262, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1518.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 70209884, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3302.1298090490077, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 519, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4013160, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10252, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 52005309, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10449, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14032805, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 158610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83008, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5929.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 673033417, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8108.054850134927, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 104319, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7451.357142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 265831764, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2548.258361372329, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2440684983, "stage_ordering_ns": 1050378981, "stage_eval_ns": 4277941863, "stage_threat_ns": 6400097521, "stage_proof_ns": 510932674, "tactical_annotations": 577303, "root_tactical_annotations": 2849, "search_tactical_annotations": 574454, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 374576, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2142336576, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 628410, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3904847729, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70429, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2584055063, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 187281, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 268185409, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3728, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19433058, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 374562, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46355009, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 150561, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 141200988, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 283018, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 914153769, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 143724, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18939740, "child_limit_applications": 34431, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34431, "child_cap_hits": 34431, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34431, "child_moves_before_total": 2534164, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2534164, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 550931, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 550931, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.60123144840405, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001016525805234, "tt_hits": 14386, "tt_cutoffs": 2013, "beta_cutoffs": 24598, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3921.5714285714284, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4493.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 681, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 535, "avg_search_time_ms": 41.15384615384615, "search_nodes": 35424, "safety_nodes": 1048, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 36472, "avg_nodes": 2805.5384615384614, "eval_calls": 33871, "avg_eval_calls": 2605.4615384615386, "line_shape_eval_calls": 33871, "line_shape_eval_ns": 42669659, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1259.7696849812523, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1528, "avg_candidate_generations": 117.53846153846153, "candidate_moves_total": 107685, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.47447643979058, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 832, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 1515, "search_candidate_moves_total": 106853, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 5956, "avg_legality_checks": 458.15384615384613, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5956, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20735, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1595.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 44349672, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2138.8797685073546, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15658718, "stage_ordering_ns": 52350, "stage_eval_ns": 42669659, "stage_threat_ns": 465568751, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 70785, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 407465309, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 223532, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35386, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 49190287, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 70772, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8689623, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 128, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1334, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6428.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7043.615384615385, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1922, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 769, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9633, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 67, 96, 128, 83, 127, 80, 81, 69, 111, 110, 143, 158, 95, 159, 79 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 2019, "avg_search_time_ms": 252.375, "search_nodes": 128841, "safety_nodes": 221, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 129062, "avg_nodes": 16132.75, "eval_calls": 124870, "avg_eval_calls": 15608.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 124870, "line_shape_eval_ns": 94586674, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 757.4811724193161, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3956, "avg_candidate_generations": 494.5, "candidate_moves_total": 238096, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.18604651162791, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 404, "root_candidate_moves_max": 65, "search_candidate_generations": 3948, "search_candidate_moves_total": 237692, "search_candidate_moves_max": 86, "legality_checks": 119509, "avg_legality_checks": 14938.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "root_legality_checks": 404, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 119105, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 128515, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16064.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 301135306, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2343.191891997043, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 594625, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11011.574074074075, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 54, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 594625, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 6, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 58300, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9716.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 27100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3387.5, "stage_move_gen_ns": 290999072, "stage_ordering_ns": 129021, "stage_eval_ns": 94586674, "stage_threat_ns": 1626710617, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 257644, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1422981174, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 106290, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8250, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128818, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 172849719, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 257636, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30773434, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 234, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3557, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5053.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6053.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1943, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7605, "avg_search_time_ms": 950.625, "search_nodes": 61174, "safety_nodes": 598, "corridor_nodes": 1016, "corridor_branch_probes": 1254, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 9, "corridor_depth_exits": 411, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1009, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1009, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 27, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 20, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 411, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 27, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 27, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 164, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 35897200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2012800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 62788, "avg_nodes": 7848.5, "eval_calls": 39720, "avg_eval_calls": 4965.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39720, "pattern_eval_ns": 855844, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.546928499496474, "pattern_frame_queries": 39720, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 855844, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.546928499496474, "pattern_frame_updates": 122266, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1475370491, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12066.890967235373, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19426, "avg_candidate_generations": 2428.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1278216, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.79923813445897, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 431, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 19418, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1277785, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 809672, "avg_legality_checks": 101209.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1491, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 809672, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1491, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2343670, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 292958.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4848352553, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2068.7010342753033, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15848, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1981.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 84472224, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5330.150429076224, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1505, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14736801, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5876, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 54160142, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8467, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15575281, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 94622, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11827.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 902730103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9540.382817949314, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 131516, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16439.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 418968086, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3185.6814836217645, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1943125239, "stage_ordering_ns": 527749681, "stage_eval_ns": 1476226335, "stage_threat_ns": 3584117732, "stage_proof_ns": 37519609, "tactical_annotations": 309325, "root_tactical_annotations": 700, "search_tactical_annotations": 308625, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 124346, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 794109731, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 332820, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2661843957, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 39352, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1434721576, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 62169, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91590116, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2072, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10764574, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 124338, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15874665, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 53222, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 306452347, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 179421, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 867188277, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76682, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9934689, "child_limit_applications": 19418, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19418, "child_cap_hits": 19418, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19418, "child_moves_before_total": 1276294, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1276294, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 210658, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 210658, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 65.72736636110825, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.848594087959626, "tt_hits": 9128, "tt_cutoffs": 1996, "beta_cutoffs": 15118, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2392.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3392.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 441, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 770, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8286, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 83, 99, 85, 84, 69, 111, 53, 101, 52, 67, 55, 41, 54, 56, 51 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7749, "avg_search_time_ms": 861.0, "search_nodes": 77110, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 664, "corridor_branch_probes": 762, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 210, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 654, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 654, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 28, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 210, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 284, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 33888640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 77932, "avg_nodes": 8659.111111111111, "eval_calls": 47087, "avg_eval_calls": 5231.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47087, "pattern_eval_ns": 1017853, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.616433410495464, "pattern_frame_queries": 47087, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1017853, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.616433410495464, "pattern_frame_updates": 154134, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1670064228, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10835.144925843746, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28169, "avg_candidate_generations": 3129.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 1932337, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.5979977989989, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 28160, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1931837, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 572003, "avg_legality_checks": 63555.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 183, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 571503, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2140487, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 237831.88888888888, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4631096438, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2163.571391930902, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22305, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2478.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 70533410, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3162.224164985429, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1361, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4706646, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10087, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 42921714, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10756, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22577760, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 101, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 327290, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38438, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4270.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 314632965, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8185.466595556481, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 49741, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5526.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 127756522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2568.434932952695, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1394416380, "stage_ordering_ns": 773150486, "stage_eval_ns": 1671082081, "stage_threat_ns": 3721449015, "stage_proof_ns": 155082987, "tactical_annotations": 394351, "root_tactical_annotations": 1800, "search_tactical_annotations": 392551, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 155527, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 926516999, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 338142, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2634010536, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56866, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2021218258, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77759, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113781249, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1384, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7281846, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 155518, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19127713, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 87518, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 58626671, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 146494, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 453019137, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 160339, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20730672, "child_limit_applications": 28160, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28160, "child_cap_hits": 28160, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28160, "child_moves_before_total": 1931655, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1931655, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 255329, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 255329, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.595703125, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.06708096590909, "tt_hits": 17029, "tt_cutoffs": 1820, "beta_cutoffs": 22237, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3413.222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4302.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1006, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 528, "avg_search_time_ms": 66.0, "search_nodes": 38283, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 38879, "avg_nodes": 4859.875, "eval_calls": 36926, "avg_eval_calls": 4615.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 36926, "line_shape_eval_ns": 31314762, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 848.0410009207604, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1342, "avg_candidate_generations": 167.75, "candidate_moves_total": 84955, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.304769001490314, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1334, "search_candidate_moves_total": 84508, "search_candidate_moves_max": 88, "legality_checks": 2405, "avg_legality_checks": 300.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2405, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11430, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1428.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24620300, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2154.0069991251094, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 84350, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7029.166666666667, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20820, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 63530, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6900035, "stage_ordering_ns": 42480, "stage_eval_ns": 31314762, "stage_threat_ns": 479390716, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 76528, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 421384890, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 168910, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8470, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 48767992, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 76520, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9068924, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1224, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5408.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6408.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 771, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19664, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 97, 129, 126, 144, 110, 109, 99, 130, 131, 98, 82, 146, 162, 159, 174, 142, 156, 100, 86, 145, 143, 115, 85, 160 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 877, "avg_search_time_ms": 67.46153846153847, "search_nodes": 52730, "safety_nodes": 1047, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53777, "avg_nodes": 4136.692307692308, "eval_calls": 50513, "avg_eval_calls": 3885.6153846153848, "line_shape_eval_calls": 50513, "line_shape_eval_ns": 41140893, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 814.4614851622355, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2192, "avg_candidate_generations": 168.6153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 144760, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.04014598540147, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 847, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 2179, "search_candidate_moves_total": 143913, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 49258, "avg_legality_checks": 3789.076923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 180, "root_legality_checks": 847, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 48411, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 169, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 64317, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4947.461538461538, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 152660895, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2373.5698959839547, "renju_forbidden_checks": 224, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 17.23076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2528292, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11287.017857142857, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 180, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2016931, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 511361, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.615384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 671893, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11198.216666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 85, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.538461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 353472, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4158.494117647058, "stage_move_gen_ns": 127898836, "stage_ordering_ns": 67980, "stage_eval_ns": 41140893, "stage_threat_ns": 692539572, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 105397, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 609411857, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 856264, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13440, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52692, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68861667, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 105384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13409784, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 93, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1976, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6326.076923076923, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6941.461538461538, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1930, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18774, "avg_search_time_ms": 1444.1538461538462, "search_nodes": 126464, "safety_nodes": 744, "corridor_nodes": 1629, "corridor_branch_probes": 1905, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 688, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1614, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1614, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 35, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 20, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 688, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 35, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 276, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 41610320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1992960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 128837, "avg_nodes": 9910.538461538461, "eval_calls": 83573, "avg_eval_calls": 6428.692307692308, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83573, "pattern_eval_ns": 1767501, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.14918693836526, "pattern_frame_queries": 83573, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1767501, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.14918693836526, "pattern_frame_updates": 252806, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3422972200, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13539.916774127196, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39155, "avg_candidate_generations": 3011.923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 3025646, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.27355382454348, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 886, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 39142, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3024760, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 2249544, "avg_legality_checks": 173041.84615384616, "illegal_moves_skipped": 29849, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2249544, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 29849, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5966166, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 458935.8461538461, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12008817683, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2012.8199052792027, "renju_forbidden_checks": 107380, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8260.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 731784505, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6814.905056807599, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 29991, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 316354276, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29281, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 284915644, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 48036, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 129681432, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 833153, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 287110, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 22085.384615384617, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2931206870, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10209.351363588868, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 400739, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 30826.076923076922, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1472762411, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3675.1162502277043, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5613510605, "stage_ordering_ns": 1237436947, "stage_eval_ns": 3424739701, "stage_threat_ns": 8365193458, "stage_proof_ns": 46208967, "tactical_annotations": 916042, "root_tactical_annotations": 2729, "search_tactical_annotations": 913313, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 256117, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1530313611, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 863070, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6561219797, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 79135, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2849108192, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128052, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 191855828, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3298, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15941294, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 256104, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32620947, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 227451, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1132611490, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 457864, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2501833006, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 230727, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33241981, "child_limit_applications": 39142, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39142, "child_cap_hits": 39142, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39142, "child_moves_before_total": 2994911, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2994911, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 529239, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 529239, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.51400030657605, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.521000459864085, "tt_hits": 19682, "tt_cutoffs": 3692, "beta_cutoffs": 32155, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1547.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2107.4615384615386, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 772, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 44502, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 110, 109, 142, 94, 96, 141, 124, 82, 98, 86, 72, 84, 81, 66, 129, 85, 83, 97, 140, 154, 125, 155, 80, 95, 156, 169, 183, 108, 68, 53, 138, 152, 153, 87, 88, 123, 56, 137, 151, 40, 167, 139, 199, 135, 215 ], "move_count": 53, "black_stats": { "move_count": 27, "search_move_count": 25, "total_time_ms": 42973, "avg_search_time_ms": 1718.92, "search_nodes": 396708, "safety_nodes": 996, "corridor_nodes": 20516, "corridor_branch_probes": 21212, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 11610, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 20459, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 20459, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 121, "corridor_proof_active": 57, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 11610, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 121, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 121, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 968, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 69697280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 418220, "avg_nodes": 16728.8, "eval_calls": 248533, "avg_eval_calls": 9941.32, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 248533, "pattern_eval_ns": 5269531, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.20254050769918, "pattern_frame_queries": 248533, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5269531, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.20254050769918, "pattern_frame_updates": 793134, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8916579999, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11242.211277035154, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 138018, "avg_candidate_generations": 5520.72, "candidate_moves_total": 13388989, "avg_candidate_moves": 97.0090060716718, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 25, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2104, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 137993, "search_candidate_moves_total": 13386885, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 3287695, "avg_legality_checks": 131507.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1842, "root_legality_checks": 2104, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 3285591, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1841, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12793700, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 511748.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25311343272, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1978.4224479235875, "renju_forbidden_checks": 52326, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2093.04, "renju_forbidden_ns": 190618453, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3642.901291900776, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2237, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12586849, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21211, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 121371824, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28502, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 53727224, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 376, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2932556, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 347892, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13915.68, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2394333302, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6882.404027686754, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 422266, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16890.64, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 818913404, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1939.3306683464925, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7188962622, "stage_ordering_ns": 4578707739, "stage_eval_ns": 8921849530, "stage_threat_ns": 20472701029, "stage_proof_ns": 1649944952, "tactical_annotations": 3969883, "root_tactical_annotations": 8992, "search_tactical_annotations": 3960891, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 834319, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4855139981, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 4033445, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 14497449462, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 284859, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8547105571, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 417147, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 607740559, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 41160, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 268875735, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 834294, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 100416436, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1595212, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 881666621, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1285279, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3045073388, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1089392, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 143078856, "child_limit_applications": 137993, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 137993, "child_cap_hits": 137993, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 137993, "child_moves_before_total": 13385044, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 13385044, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 1786536, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1786536, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 96.99799265180118, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.946569753538222, "tt_hits": 81779, "tt_cutoffs": 10047, "beta_cutoffs": 114879, "depth_sum": 135, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 135, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 7, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.28, "pooled_budget_moves": 25, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 7, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.28, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1494.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1779.92, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 1501, "avg_search_time_ms": 62.541666666666664, "search_nodes": 108686, "safety_nodes": 3190, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 111876, "avg_nodes": 4661.5, "eval_calls": 104677, "avg_eval_calls": 4361.541666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 104677, "line_shape_eval_ns": 192919729, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1843.0001719575455, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3962, "avg_candidate_generations": 165.08333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 350470, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.45784957092377, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2019, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 3938, "search_candidate_moves_total": 348451, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 8392, "avg_legality_checks": 349.6666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8392, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 35538, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1480.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 71934216, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2024.1492486915415, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.4583333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 11490, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1044.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3530, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7960, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22425422, "stage_ordering_ns": 121691, "stage_eval_ns": 192919729, "stage_threat_ns": 1253561459, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 217254, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1093997656, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 626451, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 28410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108615, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 134699145, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 217230, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24238207, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 107, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3707, "depth_sum": 71, "avg_depth": 2.9583333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 71, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9583333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 23 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7141.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7474.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 773, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9877, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 109, 126, 98, 95, 113, 125, 99, 100, 140, 94, 142, 79, 127, 78, 62, 80, 65, 81, 77, 82 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1708, "avg_search_time_ms": 155.27272727272728, "search_nodes": 108934, "safety_nodes": 657, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 109591, "avg_nodes": 9962.818181818182, "eval_calls": 105398, "avg_eval_calls": 9581.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 105398, "line_shape_eval_ns": 91979652, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 872.6887796732386, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3516, "avg_candidate_generations": 319.6363636363636, "candidate_moves_total": 223609, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.59755403868032, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 642, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 3505, "search_candidate_moves_total": 222967, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 100996, "avg_legality_checks": 9181.454545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 162, "root_legality_checks": 642, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 100354, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 159, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 113561, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10323.727272727272, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 262266542, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2309.477214888914, "renju_forbidden_checks": 176, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 16.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1894666, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10765.147727272728, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 162, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1762696, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 131970, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.5454545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 207102, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7396.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.272727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 77010, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2139.1666666666665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 245620287, "stage_ordering_ns": 115171, "stage_eval_ns": 91979652, "stage_threat_ns": 1355480429, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 217817, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1188288611, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 377573, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10710, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108903, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 140761276, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 217806, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26052969, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 269, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3076, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5951.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6678.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1919, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8158, "avg_search_time_ms": 815.8, "search_nodes": 66398, "safety_nodes": 747, "corridor_nodes": 295, "corridor_branch_probes": 346, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 112, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 289, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 289, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 25, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 112, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 25, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 151, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 31940640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 67440, "avg_nodes": 6744.0, "eval_calls": 42026, "avg_eval_calls": 4202.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 42026, "pattern_eval_ns": 901298, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.446199971446248, "pattern_frame_queries": 42026, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 901298, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.446199971446248, "pattern_frame_updates": 132686, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1634215700, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12316.413939677133, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22199, "avg_candidate_generations": 2219.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1493354, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.27122843371323, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 583, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 22189, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1492771, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 847303, "avg_legality_checks": 84730.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2952, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 847303, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2952, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2529219, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 252921.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5209550508, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2059.7467075804825, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20334, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2033.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 112564341, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5535.769696075538, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2964, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 29420488, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7288, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62028743, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10057, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20834667, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 280443, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 96509, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9650.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 918786405, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9520.214746811178, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 134904, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13490.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 432287097, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3204.4053326810176, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2034202385, "stage_ordering_ns": 607705068, "stage_eval_ns": 1635116998, "stage_threat_ns": 3801468622, "stage_proof_ns": 40423094, "tactical_annotations": 361098, "root_tactical_annotations": 687, "search_tactical_annotations": 360411, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 133324, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 806986359, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 335300, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2865677545, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44680, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1625520549, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66657, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 98041171, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 628, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3360763, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 133314, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17051415, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56297, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 281802764, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 215426, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 943765671, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 89375, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10351369, "child_limit_applications": 22189, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22189, "child_cap_hits": 22189, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22189, "child_moves_before_total": 1489819, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1489819, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 237762, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 237762, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.1422326377935, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.715309387534363, "tt_hits": 10144, "tt_cutoffs": 2129, "beta_cutoffs": 17442, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3456.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4256.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 428, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 774, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8163, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 81, 65, 80, 79, 127, 93, 51, 108, 109, 63, 47, 78, 48, 123 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7666, "avg_search_time_ms": 851.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 77311, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 724, "corridor_branch_probes": 839, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 242, "corridor_neutral_exits": 19, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 714, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 714, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 28, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 242, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 284, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 33947680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 78193, "avg_nodes": 8688.111111111111, "eval_calls": 47302, "avg_eval_calls": 5255.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47302, "pattern_eval_ns": 1004093, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.227284258593716, "pattern_frame_queries": 47302, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1004093, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.227284258593716, "pattern_frame_updates": 154536, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1663570869, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10764.940654604752, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28107, "avg_candidate_generations": 3123.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1972825, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.1898103675241, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 28098, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1972325, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 575880, "avg_legality_checks": 63986.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 242, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 575380, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 241, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2154792, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 239421.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4584150622, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2127.4214040148654, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21335, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2370.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 77860502, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3649.4259198500117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 911, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3768833, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10463, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 50397930, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9852, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23238345, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 109, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 455394, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39516, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4390.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 312827298, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7916.471758275129, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5659.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 125067183, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2455.620015314838, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1374872075, "stage_ordering_ns": 758041681, "stage_eval_ns": 1664574962, "stage_threat_ns": 3677139917, "stage_proof_ns": 158633707, "tactical_annotations": 395666, "root_tactical_annotations": 1800, "search_tactical_annotations": 393866, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 156049, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 913091758, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 343731, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2607066100, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56762, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1995734749, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78020, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112655848, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1504, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7830306, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 156040, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19028836, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 88617, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 64756229, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 148189, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 438313726, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 158860, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17467069, "child_limit_applications": 28098, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28098, "child_cap_hits": 28098, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28098, "child_moves_before_total": 1972084, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1972084, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 248212, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 248212, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.18592070610008, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.833795999715282, "tt_hits": 17082, "tt_cutoffs": 1868, "beta_cutoffs": 22225, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3488.777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4377.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1129, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 487, "avg_search_time_ms": 60.875, "search_nodes": 35030, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35626, "avg_nodes": 4453.25, "eval_calls": 33821, "avg_eval_calls": 4227.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 33821, "line_shape_eval_ns": 28835666, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 852.5964933029775, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1194, "avg_candidate_generations": 149.25, "candidate_moves_total": 75947, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.607202680067005, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1186, "search_candidate_moves_total": 75500, "search_candidate_moves_max": 88, "legality_checks": 2613, "avg_legality_checks": 326.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2613, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11638, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1454.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24912667, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2140.631294036776, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 72601, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6600.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10841, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61760, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7258880, "stage_ordering_ns": 36861, "stage_eval_ns": 28835666, "stage_threat_ns": 443294548, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 70022, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 390326991, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 166711, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35007, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 44525477, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 70014, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8275369, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1085, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5418.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6418.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 775, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11768, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 115, 116, 95, 141, 96, 159, 175, 144, 142, 156, 80, 64, 110, 171, 126, 186, 201, 158, 65, 50, 125 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3677, "avg_search_time_ms": 282.84615384615387, "search_nodes": 233272, "safety_nodes": 877, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 234149, "avg_nodes": 18011.46153846154, "eval_calls": 227028, "avg_eval_calls": 17463.69230769231, "line_shape_eval_calls": 227028, "line_shape_eval_ns": 266956380, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1175.874253396057, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6220, "avg_candidate_generations": 478.46153846153845, "candidate_moves_total": 526946, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.71800643086817, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 934, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 6207, "search_candidate_moves_total": 526012, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 219045, "avg_legality_checks": 16849.615384615383, "illegal_moves_skipped": 166, "root_legality_checks": 934, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 218111, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 165, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 234169, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18013.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 551373705, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2354.5973420905416, "renju_forbidden_checks": 173, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 13.307692307692308, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1931847, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11166.745664739885, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 168, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1882137, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 49710, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.923076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 387412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10195.052631578947, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.3076923076923075, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 186720, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3334.285714285714, "stage_move_gen_ns": 537324487, "stage_ordering_ns": 195990, "stage_eval_ns": 266956380, "stage_threat_ns": 2858172355, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 466483, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2503891988, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 564502, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 233235, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 298776552, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 466470, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 54939313, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 342, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5549, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6266.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6881.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1914, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8075, "avg_search_time_ms": 672.9166666666666, "search_nodes": 58765, "safety_nodes": 1254, "corridor_nodes": 216, "corridor_branch_probes": 260, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 62, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 207, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 207, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 29, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 20, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 62, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 29, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 163, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24010160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 60235, "avg_nodes": 5019.583333333333, "eval_calls": 35202, "avg_eval_calls": 2933.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35202, "pattern_eval_ns": 756572, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.492301573774217, "pattern_frame_queries": 35202, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 756572, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.492301573774217, "pattern_frame_updates": 117396, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1085521227, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9246.662807932127, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21860, "avg_candidate_generations": 1821.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1760450, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.53293687099726, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 854, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 21848, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1759596, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1140002, "avg_legality_checks": 95000.16666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 887, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1140002, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 887, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2573483, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 214456.91666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5313316976, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2064.6404021320523, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14466, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1205.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 35422831, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2448.6956311350755, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1038, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10277101, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2037, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13697574, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11378, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11286296, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 161860, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 87496, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7291.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 854178168, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9762.482490628143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 128164, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10680.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 413622832, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3227.293405324428, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2684665339, "stage_ordering_ns": 724717898, "stage_eval_ns": 1086277799, "stage_threat_ns": 3478013755, "stage_proof_ns": 48332815, "tactical_annotations": 309937, "root_tactical_annotations": 900, "search_tactical_annotations": 309037, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 117880, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 703943053, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 281822, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2659209988, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44002, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1531377312, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58934, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 86977715, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 472, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2632635, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 117868, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14642887, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 40136, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 198157260, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 182060, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 918069846, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 87741, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10607477, "child_limit_applications": 21848, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21848, "child_cap_hits": 21848, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21848, "child_moves_before_total": 1758709, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1758709, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 212212, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 212212, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.49748260710362, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.713108751373124, "tt_hits": 10482, "tt_cutoffs": 1649, "beta_cutoffs": 17462, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5035.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5702.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1735, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 776, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26211, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 79, 63, 115, 64, 97, 62, 65, 96, 128, 48, 80, 34, 76, 78, 93, 20, 6, 33, 18, 51, 125, 61, 60, 126, 83, 69, 139 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 21111, "avg_search_time_ms": 1407.4, "search_nodes": 220311, "safety_nodes": 953, "corridor_nodes": 3694, "corridor_branch_probes": 4247, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1870, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 3675, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3675, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1870, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 66, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 475, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4202400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 224958, "avg_nodes": 14997.2, "eval_calls": 140719, "avg_eval_calls": 9381.266666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 140719, "pattern_eval_ns": 3004680, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.352340479963615, "pattern_frame_queries": 140719, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3004680, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.352340479963615, "pattern_frame_updates": 440456, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4534669054, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10295.39625751494, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 71548, "avg_candidate_generations": 4769.866666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 6200957, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.66848828758316, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1154, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 71533, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6199803, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 2055956, "avg_legality_checks": 137063.73333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7640, "root_legality_checks": 1154, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 2054802, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7633, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6467043, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 431136.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12399582654, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1917.349653311413, "renju_forbidden_checks": 66905, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4460.333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 345794878, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5168.445975637097, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7973, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 55614205, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 31450, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 211611849, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26419, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 70549331, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1063, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8019493, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 172694, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11512.933333333332, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1253305502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7257.377222138581, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 241074, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16071.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 596437355, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2474.0841193990227, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4552669299, "stage_ordering_ns": 2228455636, "stage_eval_ns": 4537673734, "stage_threat_ns": 9202560580, "stage_proof_ns": 463215474, "tactical_annotations": 1133827, "root_tactical_annotations": 3655, "search_tactical_annotations": 1130172, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 447953, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2391018885, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1130326, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6363043066, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 144790, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4134759041, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 223969, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 306405123, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7482, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 48071795, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 447938, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49423948, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 239653, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 165397549, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 568181, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1716967211, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 325993, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 44597763, "child_limit_applications": 71533, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 71533, "child_cap_hits": 71533, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 71533, "child_moves_before_total": 6192170, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6192170, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 813553, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 813553, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.56382368976556, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.373114506591364, "tt_hits": 37738, "tt_cutoffs": 7978, "beta_cutoffs": 55569, "depth_sum": 81, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 81, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1997.8666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2531.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 5086, "avg_search_time_ms": 339.06666666666666, "search_nodes": 369435, "safety_nodes": 1163, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 370598, "avg_nodes": 24706.533333333333, "eval_calls": 360061, "avg_eval_calls": 24004.066666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 360061, "line_shape_eval_ns": 423626182, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1176.5400362716318, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9346, "avg_candidate_generations": 623.0666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 770459, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.43729937941366, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1180, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 9331, "search_candidate_moves_total": 769279, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 17350, "avg_legality_checks": 1156.6666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 85, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 17350, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 85, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 34565, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2304.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 80005745, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2314.6461738753073, "renju_forbidden_checks": 121, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8.066666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1453357, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12011.214876033058, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 85, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1060594, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 36, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 392763, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 49876626, "stage_ordering_ns": 300631, "stage_eval_ns": 423626182, "stage_threat_ns": 4585014506, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 738799, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4014470599, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 216002, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 369392, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 482668462, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 738784, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 87659443, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 387, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8490, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6138.266666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6671.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1982, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 777, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 56276, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 157, 172, 83, 95, 98, 139, 153, 140, 110, 94, 84, 70, 81, 93, 96, 82, 53, 68, 143, 156, 158, 174, 124, 138, 141, 69, 144, 145, 67, 171, 39, 25, 173, 91, 92, 188, 204, 155, 189, 205, 187, 160, 202, 115, 175, 85, 159, 191, 201, 215, 203, 200, 161, 147, 217 ], "move_count": 63, "black_stats": { "move_count": 32, "search_move_count": 30, "total_time_ms": 13331, "avg_search_time_ms": 444.3666666666667, "search_nodes": 1095935, "safety_nodes": 3921, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1099856, "avg_nodes": 36661.86666666667, "eval_calls": 1078128, "avg_eval_calls": 35937.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 1078128, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1310338797, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1215.3833283246515, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17749, "avg_candidate_generations": 591.6333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1699511, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.75249309820272, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 30, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2731, "root_candidate_moves_max": 114, "search_candidate_generations": 17719, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1696780, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 1067040, "avg_legality_checks": 35568.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 495, "root_legality_checks": 2731, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 1064309, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 491, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1100788, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 36692.933333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1906787894, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1732.202653008572, "renju_forbidden_checks": 598, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 19.933333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4305433, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7199.720735785953, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 579, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4173702, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 131731, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 123, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1122008, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9122.016260162602, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 187, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.233333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 624404, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3339.0588235294117, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1916961245, "stage_ordering_ns": 552271, "stage_eval_ns": 1310338797, "stage_threat_ns": 9958668618, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 2191724, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 8627670286, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 84, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1597399, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 26880, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 1095847, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1127701796, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 2191694, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 201699137, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 568, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 16034, "depth_sum": 88, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 88, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 29 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 30, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7061.266666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7327.933333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1919, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 31, "search_move_count": 29, "total_time_ms": 42914, "avg_search_time_ms": 1479.7931034482758, "search_nodes": 398253, "safety_nodes": 2007, "corridor_nodes": 23359, "corridor_branch_probes": 24120, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 35, "corridor_depth_exits": 13939, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 23310, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 23310, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 105, "corridor_proof_active": 49, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 41, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 13939, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 105, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 743, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 93344600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2013200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 423619, "avg_nodes": 14607.551724137931, "eval_calls": 270137, "avg_eval_calls": 9315.068965517241, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 270137, "pattern_eval_ns": 5680595, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.028570688206354, "pattern_frame_queries": 270137, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5680595, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.028570688206354, "pattern_frame_updates": 796186, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6064924238, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7617.471593321158, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 118462, "avg_candidate_generations": 4084.896551724138, "candidate_moves_total": 12383096, "avg_candidate_moves": 104.53222130303388, "candidate_moves_max": 134, "root_candidate_generations": 29, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2638, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 118433, "search_candidate_moves_total": 12380458, "search_candidate_moves_max": 134, "legality_checks": 9451938, "avg_legality_checks": 325928.8965517241, "illegal_moves_skipped": 35298, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9451938, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 35298, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17662364, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 609047.0344827586, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27307764342, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1546.099057974346, "renju_forbidden_checks": 115011, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3965.896551724138, "renju_forbidden_ns": 447059890, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3887.105494257071, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 36007, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 248932865, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20134, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 115442403, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 58722, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 81626690, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 148, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1057932, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 521969, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17998.931034482757, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 4071478618, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7800.230699524302, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 771362, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26598.689655172413, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2098679494, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2720.745245423031, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16505671220, "stage_ordering_ns": 3337787776, "stage_eval_ns": 6070604833, "stage_threat_ns": 16763473430, "stage_proof_ns": 67899472, "tactical_annotations": 3555677, "root_tactical_annotations": 7467, "search_tactical_annotations": 3548210, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 843045, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4127310463, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3677128, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11589857937, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 246598, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5502667045, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 421508, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 544003869, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 46830, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 283504798, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 843016, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 85695017, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1430913, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 2096704125, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1169702, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3505010902, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 955062, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 133101346, "child_limit_applications": 118433, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 118433, "child_cap_hits": 118433, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 118433, "child_moves_before_total": 12345160, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 12345160, "child_moves_before_max": 134, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 134, "child_moves_after_total": 1270033, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1270033, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 104.2375013720838, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.7236412148641, "tt_hits": 69361, "tt_cutoffs": 9526, "beta_cutoffs": 97295, "depth_sum": 156, "avg_depth": 5.379310344827586, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 156, "avg_effective_depth": 5.379310344827586, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13793103448275862, "pooled_budget_moves": 29, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3448275862068966, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13793103448275862, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5134.517241379311, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5410.379310344828, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 863, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 778, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20286, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 125, 69, 157, 172, 141, 173, 143, 140, 171, 129, 113, 55, 83, 155, 156, 126, 115, 144, 99, 85, 131, 67, 147 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 19631, "avg_search_time_ms": 1510.076923076923, "search_nodes": 221484, "safety_nodes": 172, "corridor_nodes": 1116, "corridor_branch_probes": 1308, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 458, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1101, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1101, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 458, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 544, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 37801040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1979600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 222772, "avg_nodes": 17136.30769230769, "eval_calls": 142555, "avg_eval_calls": 10965.76923076923, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 142555, "pattern_eval_ns": 2912103, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.427926063624565, "pattern_frame_queries": 142555, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2912103, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.427926063624565, "pattern_frame_updates": 442826, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4809873714, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10861.768988270787, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 72643, "avg_candidate_generations": 5587.923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 6373760, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.74086973280289, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 942, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 72630, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6372818, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1727550, "avg_legality_checks": 132888.46153846153, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1129, "root_legality_checks": 942, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1726608, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1129, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6104565, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 469581.92307692306, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11514037154, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1886.135564778162, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34391, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2645.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_ns": 193334706, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5621.665726498211, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1541, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11495772, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17500, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 131189510, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15143, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 48925938, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 207, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1723486, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 135336, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10410.461538461539, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 921607730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6809.77515221375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 166962, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12843.23076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 354938563, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2125.8643463782178, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3569302672, "stage_ordering_ns": 2211209014, "stage_eval_ns": 4812785817, "stage_threat_ns": 8718881786, "stage_proof_ns": 242007264, "tactical_annotations": 1119408, "root_tactical_annotations": 4488, "search_tactical_annotations": 1114920, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 445169, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2254547099, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 985931, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6057186486, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 146054, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4427611148, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 222578, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 297322935, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2330, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13013558, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 445156, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49577155, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 301638, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 297158924, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 470127, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1159750787, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 347643, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 47234553, "child_limit_applications": 72630, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 72630, "child_cap_hits": 72630, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 72630, "child_moves_before_total": 6371689, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6371689, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 644402, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 644402, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.72806003029051, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.872394327412914, "tt_hits": 41463, "tt_cutoffs": 6228, "beta_cutoffs": 56225, "depth_sum": 68, "avg_depth": 5.230769230769231, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 68, "avg_effective_depth": 5.230769230769231, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1410.6923076923076, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1906.4615384615386, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 642, "avg_search_time_ms": 53.5, "search_nodes": 52192, "safety_nodes": 1214, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53406, "avg_nodes": 4450.5, "eval_calls": 49989, "avg_eval_calls": 4165.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 49989, "line_shape_eval_ns": 46143902, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 923.0811178459261, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2180, "avg_candidate_generations": 181.66666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 174599, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.09128440366972, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 866, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 2168, "search_candidate_moves_total": 173733, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 8150, "avg_legality_checks": 679.1666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8150, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22213, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1851.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 40769657, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1835.3962544455949, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17380531, "stage_ordering_ns": 71330, "stage_eval_ns": 46143902, "stage_threat_ns": 565853170, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 104326, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 495045671, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 327832, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10680, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52157, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 59574994, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 104314, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10904673, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 158, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1953, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6292.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6959.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 779, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13795, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 95, 129, 109, 108, 81, 123, 80, 125, 127, 124, 122, 79, 96, 128, 82, 145, 161, 93, 66, 51, 67, 53, 68, 54, 69, 65, 70 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 2483, "avg_search_time_ms": 165.53333333333333, "search_nodes": 200224, "safety_nodes": 1264, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 201488, "avg_nodes": 13432.533333333333, "eval_calls": 194105, "avg_eval_calls": 12940.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 194105, "line_shape_eval_ns": 203514810, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1048.4779371989387, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6091, "avg_candidate_generations": 406.06666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 477046, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.31981612214743, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1045, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 6076, "search_candidate_moves_total": 476001, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 189915, "avg_legality_checks": 12661.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 73, "root_legality_checks": 1045, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 188870, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 70, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 207265, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13817.666666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 362203344, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1747.537423105686, "renju_forbidden_checks": 187, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12.466666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 639422, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3419.3689839572194, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 165, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 592581, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 46841, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.933333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 656602, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7377.550561797752, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 115, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 252181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2192.878260869565, "stage_move_gen_ns": 346913217, "stage_ordering_ns": 184060, "stage_eval_ns": 203514810, "stage_threat_ns": 1889587291, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 400377, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1643019493, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 41, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 943423, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 200181, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 207681534, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 400362, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37942841, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 357, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5429, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6573.533333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7106.866666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1948, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 11300, "avg_search_time_ms": 807.1428571428571, "search_nodes": 115048, "safety_nodes": 1130, "corridor_nodes": 3189, "corridor_branch_probes": 3843, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 1376, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 3162, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3162, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 58, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1376, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 58, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 338, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 16025240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 119367, "avg_nodes": 8526.214285714286, "eval_calls": 67423, "avg_eval_calls": 4815.928571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67423, "pattern_eval_ns": 1375606, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.402622250567315, "pattern_frame_queries": 67423, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1375606, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.402622250567315, "pattern_frame_updates": 229926, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1851855114, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8054.135304402286, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44071, "avg_candidate_generations": 3147.9285714285716, "candidate_moves_total": 3784361, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.8696421683193, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 970, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 44057, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3783391, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 2177021, "avg_legality_checks": 155501.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1591, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2177021, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1591, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4870693, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 347906.64285714284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7057167639, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1448.9042193790494, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31665, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2261.785714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60194476, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1900.9782409600505, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1630, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8704608, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6493, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28317244, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23512, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23053254, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 119370, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 184234, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13159.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 859381258, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4664.618137803011, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 215931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15423.642857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 223490497, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1035.0088546804304, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3449624338, "stage_ordering_ns": 1040968652, "stage_eval_ns": 1853230720, "stage_threat_ns": 4820563581, "stage_proof_ns": 39550218, "tactical_annotations": 928430, "root_tactical_annotations": 1528, "search_tactical_annotations": 926902, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 236380, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1045650461, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 939333, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3558651614, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 89627, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2081942048, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 118183, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 138186835, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6440, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24855412, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 236366, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22792762, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 191065, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 308635243, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 477242, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1076909218, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 260123, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30426497, "child_limit_applications": 44057, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44057, "child_cap_hits": 44057, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44057, "child_moves_before_total": 3781800, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3781800, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 567529, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 567529, "child_moves_after_max": 29, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 29, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.83879973670473, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.881698708491273, "tt_hits": 22744, "tt_cutoffs": 3484, "beta_cutoffs": 38036, "depth_sum": 84, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 84, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5887.357142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6458.785714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1844, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 780, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19410, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 81, 129, 127, 98, 143, 95, 96, 109, 128, 144, 159, 175, 82, 145, 161, 68, 80, 64, 83, 79, 84 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 16714, "avg_search_time_ms": 1392.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 152975, "safety_nodes": 271, "corridor_nodes": 68, "corridor_branch_probes": 70, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 61, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 61, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 39, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 39, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 39, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 300, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 370000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 153314, "avg_nodes": 12776.166666666666, "eval_calls": 96929, "avg_eval_calls": 8077.416666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 96929, "pattern_eval_ns": 2160531, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.28983070082225, "pattern_frame_queries": 96929, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2160531, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.28983070082225, "pattern_frame_updates": 305826, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3803562609, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12437.015194914755, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52818, "avg_candidate_generations": 4401.5, "candidate_moves_total": 4026040, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.22477185807868, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 772, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 52806, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4025268, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 1293334, "avg_legality_checks": 107777.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2562, "root_legality_checks": 772, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1292562, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2562, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4448968, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 370747.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10041095855, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2256.949444230662, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34592, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2882.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 196551515, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5681.993379972248, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2664, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 27963443, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13961, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 116097907, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17963, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 52446795, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 43370, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 120120, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10010.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1063278261, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8851.800374625374, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 157616, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13134.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 428974087, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2721.6404870063952, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3280828000, "stage_ordering_ns": 1732110946, "stage_eval_ns": 3805723140, "stage_threat_ns": 7748905948, "stage_proof_ns": 82399661, "tactical_annotations": 687947, "root_tactical_annotations": 3175, "search_tactical_annotations": 684772, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 306038, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1870919589, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 587785, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5575659527, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 105882, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3995250957, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 153013, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 234947657, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 200, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 951683, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 306026, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40073896, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 148420, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 208166774, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 327932, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1361332622, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 211595, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26353596, "child_limit_applications": 52806, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52806, "child_cap_hits": 52806, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52806, "child_moves_before_total": 4022706, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4022706, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 468532, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 468532, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.17895693671174, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.872703859409915, "tt_hits": 28245, "tt_cutoffs": 3181, "beta_cutoffs": 41652, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 4.833333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 4.833333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1154.1666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1766.4166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2683, "avg_search_time_ms": 243.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 185954, "safety_nodes": 836, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 186790, "avg_nodes": 16980.909090909092, "eval_calls": 181177, "avg_eval_calls": 16470.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 181177, "line_shape_eval_ns": 161926579, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 893.7479867753633, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4756, "avg_candidate_generations": 432.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 325584, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.45752733389403, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 699, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 4745, "search_candidate_moves_total": 324885, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 8441, "avg_legality_checks": 767.3636363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8441, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21175, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1925.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 49851859, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2354.279055489965, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 25217364, "stage_ordering_ns": 151110, "stage_eval_ns": 161926579, "stage_threat_ns": 2487984184, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 371855, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2186293442, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 257431, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12270, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185922, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 253335681, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 371844, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48097630, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 178, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4410, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5770.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6497.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 781, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12751, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 155, 36, 68, 50, 80, 79, 115, 131, 49, 54, 65, 53 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2515, "avg_search_time_ms": 228.63636363636363, "search_nodes": 152770, "safety_nodes": 874, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 153644, "avg_nodes": 13967.636363636364, "eval_calls": 148771, "avg_eval_calls": 13524.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 148771, "line_shape_eval_ns": 157843901, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1060.9856826935356, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3978, "avg_candidate_generations": 361.6363636363636, "candidate_moves_total": 303236, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.228255404726, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 762, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 3967, "search_candidate_moves_total": 302474, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 143055, "avg_legality_checks": 13005.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1077, "root_legality_checks": 762, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 142293, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1069, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 156069, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14188.09090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 378876091, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2427.6191364076144, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1115, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 101.36363636363636, "renju_forbidden_ns": 11778300, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10563.497757847534, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1077, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11403628, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 374672, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 69, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.2727272727272725, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 733683, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10633.08695652174, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.272727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 372572, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4094.197802197802, "stage_move_gen_ns": 372497858, "stage_ordering_ns": 130450, "stage_eval_ns": 157843901, "stage_threat_ns": 1961578987, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 305487, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1719425573, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1003693, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 152738, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 203993373, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 305476, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37156348, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 236, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3599, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6122.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6849.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1921, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10225, "avg_search_time_ms": 929.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 67900, "safety_nodes": 653, "corridor_nodes": 408, "corridor_branch_probes": 488, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 95, "corridor_neutral_exits": 30, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 396, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 396, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 33, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 21, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 95, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 33, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 30, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 172, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 8019200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 68961, "avg_nodes": 6269.181818181818, "eval_calls": 39421, "avg_eval_calls": 3583.7272727272725, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39421, "pattern_eval_ns": 900575, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.84505720301362, "pattern_frame_queries": 39421, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 900575, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.84505720301362, "pattern_frame_updates": 135678, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1575583212, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11612.665369477734, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26279, "avg_candidate_generations": 2389.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2176553, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.82480307469842, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 783, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 26268, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2175770, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1349537, "avg_legality_checks": 122685.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8444, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1349537, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3056011, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 277819.1818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6682495931, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2186.672734816727, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28009, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2546.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 199379833, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7118.420257774287, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8448, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 80997745, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8563, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 76247492, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10945, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41567974, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 53, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 566622, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97287, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8844.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 965268794, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9921.868224942695, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 131698, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11972.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 464343301, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3525.8189266351806, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3406122085, "stage_ordering_ns": 914129489, "stage_eval_ns": 1576483787, "stage_threat_ns": 4209103992, "stage_proof_ns": 56900553, "tactical_annotations": 458300, "root_tactical_annotations": 1731, "search_tactical_annotations": 456569, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136547, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 861667300, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 383325, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3196453891, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52983, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1909702013, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68268, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108444805, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 858, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4785467, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136536, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17760662, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 104126, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 421672738, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 194198, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 841276473, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 159976, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19991867, "child_limit_applications": 26268, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26268, "child_cap_hits": 26268, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26268, "child_moves_before_total": 2167326, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2167326, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 262410, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 262410, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.50822293284605, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.98972133394244, "tt_hits": 15177, "tt_cutoffs": 2150, "beta_cutoffs": 21747, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4602.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5329.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1623, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 782, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7394, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 99, 85, 84, 69, 111, 53, 141, 155, 126, 81, 156 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 6771, "avg_search_time_ms": 967.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 63205, "safety_nodes": 237, "corridor_nodes": 891, "corridor_branch_probes": 1013, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 290, "corridor_neutral_exits": 22, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 878, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 878, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 46, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 290, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 46, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 45, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 337, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 8214880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 10, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 10, "total_nodes": 64333, "avg_nodes": 9190.42857142857, "eval_calls": 38211, "avg_eval_calls": 5458.714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38211, "pattern_eval_ns": 852557, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.311821203318416, "pattern_frame_queries": 38211, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 852557, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.311821203318416, "pattern_frame_updates": 126334, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1318900884, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10439.793594756757, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23549, "avg_candidate_generations": 3364.1428571428573, "candidate_moves_total": 1681888, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.42078219881948, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 385, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 23542, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1681503, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 478626, "avg_legality_checks": 68375.14285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 208, "root_legality_checks": 385, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 478241, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 208, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1799035, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 257005.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4081894883, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2268.9357811271043, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10053, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1436.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 40147751, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3993.608972446036, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 364, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2542961, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4442, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 23837260, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5042, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12656732, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 205, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1110798, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 31638, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4519.714285714285, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 292218083, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9236.300745938428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 42249, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6035.571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 129569962, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3066.8172501124286, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1223972650, "stage_ordering_ns": 737914953, "stage_eval_ns": 1319753441, "stage_threat_ns": 3250884648, "stage_proof_ns": 206989462, "tactical_annotations": 216848, "root_tactical_annotations": 1317, "search_tactical_annotations": 215531, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 128189, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 775162134, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 238218, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2343353833, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47770, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1781657107, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64091, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 95861643, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1848, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10255151, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128182, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16365124, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 29467, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 54074435, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 98463, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 368866710, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 88918, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9886763, "child_limit_applications": 23542, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23542, "child_cap_hits": 23542, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23542, "child_moves_before_total": 1681295, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1681295, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 204311, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 204311, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.41682949621952, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.678574462662475, "tt_hits": 13448, "tt_cutoffs": 1414, "beta_cutoffs": 18544, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2277.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3312.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 849, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 617, "avg_search_time_ms": 88.14285714285714, "search_nodes": 42764, "safety_nodes": 639, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 43403, "avg_nodes": 6200.428571428572, "eval_calls": 41427, "avg_eval_calls": 5918.142857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 41427, "line_shape_eval_ns": 35343046, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 853.1403673932459, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1325, "avg_candidate_generations": 189.28571428571428, "candidate_moves_total": 85273, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.35698113207548, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 407, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 1318, "search_candidate_moves_total": 84866, "search_candidate_moves_max": 89, "legality_checks": 2341, "avg_legality_checks": 334.42857142857144, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2341, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1495.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24055030, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2297.958540313336, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6945522, "stage_ordering_ns": 45900, "stage_eval_ns": 35343046, "stage_threat_ns": 565555614, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 85497, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 497407769, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 214390, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42745, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 57263666, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 85490, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10669789, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 65, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1196, "depth_sum": 19, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 19, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4999.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6142.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 783, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13277, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 85, 92, 124, 78, 80, 65, 157, 173, 63, 138, 79, 123 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3046, "avg_search_time_ms": 276.90909090909093, "search_nodes": 181763, "safety_nodes": 874, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 182637, "avg_nodes": 16603.363636363636, "eval_calls": 177705, "avg_eval_calls": 16155.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 177705, "line_shape_eval_ns": 181922261, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1023.7318083340367, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4037, "avg_candidate_generations": 367.0, "candidate_moves_total": 297276, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.6378498885311, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 762, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 4026, "search_candidate_moves_total": 296514, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 168077, "avg_legality_checks": 15279.727272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 695, "root_legality_checks": 762, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 167315, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 687, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 181091, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16462.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 452490982, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2498.693927362486, "renju_forbidden_checks": 733, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 66.63636363636364, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8015051, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10934.585266030013, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 695, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7614218, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 400833, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 69, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.2727272727272725, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 727473, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10543.08695652174, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.272727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 365601, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4017.5934065934066, "stage_move_gen_ns": 443924417, "stage_ordering_ns": 134720, "stage_eval_ns": 181922261, "stage_threat_ns": 2400905677, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 363473, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2108104398, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 994105, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11880, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 181731, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 245849852, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 363462, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45957322, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 236, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3624, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5958.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6686.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1909, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10221, "avg_search_time_ms": 929.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 67380, "safety_nodes": 653, "corridor_nodes": 412, "corridor_branch_probes": 492, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 99, "corridor_neutral_exits": 30, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 400, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 400, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 33, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 21, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 99, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 33, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 30, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 172, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 8022960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 68445, "avg_nodes": 6222.272727272727, "eval_calls": 39003, "avg_eval_calls": 3545.7272727272725, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39003, "pattern_eval_ns": 885173, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.69499782068046, "pattern_frame_queries": 39003, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 885173, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.69499782068046, "pattern_frame_updates": 134638, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1597723185, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11866.807179251029, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26064, "avg_candidate_generations": 2369.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 2186056, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.87262124002456, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 783, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 26053, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2185273, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1350542, "avg_legality_checks": 122776.54545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8523, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1350542, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8523, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3069322, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 279029.2727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6664685859, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2171.38699002581, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27407, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2491.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 197429336, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7203.609880687415, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8523, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 83845037, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8234, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73908967, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10597, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39094629, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 53, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 580703, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97692, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8881.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 960537162, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9832.3011300823, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132914, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12083.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 458940949, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3452.916540018358, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3388797867, "stage_ordering_ns": 932119641, "stage_eval_ns": 1598608358, "stage_threat_ns": 4181478694, "stage_proof_ns": 56755863, "tactical_annotations": 463749, "root_tactical_annotations": 1731, "search_tactical_annotations": 462018, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 135515, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 850627355, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 388519, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3183219557, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52553, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1894503594, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67752, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105327187, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 866, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4798051, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 135504, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17855687, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 104542, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 420451538, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 199406, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 844453170, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 159801, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19650857, "child_limit_applications": 26053, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26053, "child_cap_hits": 26053, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26053, "child_moves_before_total": 2176750, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2176750, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 260767, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 260767, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.55083867500863, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.009096841054774, "tt_hits": 15171, "tt_cutoffs": 2263, "beta_cutoffs": 21634, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4659.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5387.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1707, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 784, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12228, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 80, 139, 85, 71, 97, 140, 155, 138, 142, 137 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11707, "avg_search_time_ms": 1170.7, "search_nodes": 103770, "safety_nodes": 382, "corridor_nodes": 1507, "corridor_branch_probes": 1802, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 632, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1491, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1491, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 39, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 23, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 632, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 39, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 286, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 18033920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2024480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 105659, "avg_nodes": 10565.9, "eval_calls": 67934, "avg_eval_calls": 6793.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67934, "pattern_eval_ns": 1513925, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.285232725881002, "pattern_frame_queries": 67934, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1513925, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.285232725881002, "pattern_frame_updates": 207436, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3029091846, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14602.536907769143, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33208, "avg_candidate_generations": 3320.8, "candidate_moves_total": 2738683, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.47057937846301, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 668, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 33198, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2738015, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 740012, "avg_legality_checks": 74001.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1221, "root_legality_checks": 668, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 739344, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1219, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3070603, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 307060.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7006972199, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2281.95315350112, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30068, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3006.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 209101831, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6954.297957961953, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13718234, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16327, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 142812885, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11988, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 49674531, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 378, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2896181, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 69268, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6926.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 665885376, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9613.174568343247, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 93970, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9397.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 302484581, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3218.948398425029, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1891685521, "stage_ordering_ns": 1175872337, "stage_eval_ns": 3030605771, "stage_threat_ns": 5318424259, "stage_proof_ns": 250550119, "tactical_annotations": 467079, "root_tactical_annotations": 2004, "search_tactical_annotations": 465075, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 210506, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1323672116, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 461598, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3760456030, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67192, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2600917259, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 105248, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 166493133, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3060, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18231351, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 210496, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27632184, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 115167, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 170215226, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 188561, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 743998235, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 163351, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21939445, "child_limit_applications": 33198, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33198, "child_cap_hits": 33198, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33198, "child_moves_before_total": 2736796, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2736796, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 327688, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 327688, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.4385806373878, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.870715103319476, "tt_hits": 19603, "tt_cutoffs": 2586, "beta_cutoffs": 26363, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 5.2, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 5.2, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2668.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3468.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 607, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 514, "avg_search_time_ms": 57.111111111111114, "search_nodes": 34310, "safety_nodes": 864, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35174, "avg_nodes": 3908.222222222222, "eval_calls": 32755, "avg_eval_calls": 3639.4444444444443, "line_shape_eval_calls": 32755, "line_shape_eval_ns": 28515372, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 870.5654709204701, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1538, "avg_candidate_generations": 170.88888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 108520, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.5591677503251, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 596, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 1529, "search_candidate_moves_total": 107924, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 3507, "avg_legality_checks": 389.6666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3507, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13981, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1553.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31959772, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2285.9432086402976, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.2222222222222223, "renju_forbidden_ns": 141940, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12903.636363636364, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 41330, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 100610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10514397, "stage_ordering_ns": 49810, "stage_eval_ns": 28515372, "stage_threat_ns": 462567675, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 68577, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 406954547, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 244732, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34284, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 46738494, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 68568, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8629902, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 63, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1405, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5681.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6570.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 785, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15835, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 98, 83, 115, 116, 69, 125, 139, 126, 129, 141, 84, 99, 70, 56, 96, 157, 109, 158, 82, 127, 130, 124 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 1623, "avg_search_time_ms": 135.25, "search_nodes": 105238, "safety_nodes": 1052, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 106290, "avg_nodes": 8857.5, "eval_calls": 102119, "avg_eval_calls": 8509.916666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 102119, "line_shape_eval_ns": 104874413, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1026.9823735054201, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3096, "avg_candidate_generations": 258.0, "candidate_moves_total": 227180, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.37855297157623, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 834, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 3084, "search_candidate_moves_total": 226346, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 90741, "avg_legality_checks": 7561.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 130, "root_legality_checks": 834, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 89907, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 127, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 105039, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8753.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 241783824, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2301.8481135578213, "renju_forbidden_checks": 144, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1604198, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11140.263888888889, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 130, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1464337, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 139861, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 779093, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10820.736111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.583333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 418812, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4066.135922330097, "stage_move_gen_ns": 219962174, "stage_ordering_ns": 98250, "stage_eval_ns": 104874413, "stage_threat_ns": 1281493569, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 210418, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1124461479, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1019084, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 105203, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 131448922, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 210406, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24564084, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 198, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2783, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6137.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6803.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1916, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 14198, "avg_search_time_ms": 1183.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 100293, "safety_nodes": 551, "corridor_nodes": 777, "corridor_branch_probes": 888, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 313, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 766, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 766, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 35, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 313, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 35, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 35, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 276, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23973920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 101621, "avg_nodes": 8468.416666666666, "eval_calls": 62500, "avg_eval_calls": 5208.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62500, "pattern_eval_ns": 1289337, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.629392, "pattern_frame_queries": 62500, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1289337, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.629392, "pattern_frame_updates": 200480, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2077159352, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10360.930526735834, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35117, "avg_candidate_generations": 2926.4166666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2947225, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.92587635618077, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 854, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 35105, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2946371, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 2060742, "avg_legality_checks": 171728.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9441, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2060742, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9441, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4686775, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 390564.5833333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9290842947, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1982.353099306026, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46095, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3841.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 286543065, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6216.358932639115, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9499, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 103252530, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12676, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 123751523, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23890, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 59199420, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 339592, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 185363, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15446.916666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1777634396, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9590.017403688978, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 264260, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22021.666666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 883217221, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3342.228188148036, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4780533476, "stage_ordering_ns": 1139288267, "stage_eval_ns": 2078448689, "stage_threat_ns": 6068372973, "stage_proof_ns": 51953898, "tactical_annotations": 642755, "root_tactical_annotations": 2346, "search_tactical_annotations": 640409, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 202094, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1186972706, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 587369, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4677222428, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70765, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2399617201, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 101041, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 148022085, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1602, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8761624, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 202082, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24773891, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 159217, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 690000125, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 309940, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1550866249, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 173598, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22620239, "child_limit_applications": 35105, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35105, "child_cap_hits": 35105, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35105, "child_moves_before_total": 2936930, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2936930, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 387091, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 387091, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.66130180885914, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.026662868537246, "tt_hits": 17426, "tt_cutoffs": 2636, "beta_cutoffs": 27812, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4445.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5112.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1631, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 786, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 65796, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 83, 125, 126, 96, 98, 84, 82, 66, 99, 81, 51, 115, 127, 139, 153, 141, 53, 68, 52, 50, 85, 71, 69, 37, 55, 54, 70, 100, 40, 25, 41, 27, 39, 116, 132, 38, 146, 130, 160, 118, 174, 188, 158, 142, 140, 154, 157, 117, 119, 159, 42, 43, 28, 101, 56, 14, 35, 67, 88, 131, 86, 145, 103, 173 ], "move_count": 70, "black_stats": { "move_count": 35, "search_move_count": 33, "total_time_ms": 62308, "avg_search_time_ms": 1888.121212121212, "search_nodes": 727367, "safety_nodes": 1027, "corridor_nodes": 17468, "corridor_branch_probes": 18522, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 8640, "corridor_neutral_exits": 81, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 17423, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 17423, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 145, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 100, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 81, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 8640, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 145, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 145, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 2, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1137, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 93567840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2026880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 745862, "avg_nodes": 22601.878787878788, "eval_calls": 461739, "avg_eval_calls": 13992.09090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 461739, "pattern_eval_ns": 9317458, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.17905786602388, "pattern_frame_queries": 461739, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 9317458, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.17905786602388, "pattern_frame_updates": 1454382, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 11739715311, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8071.961362970664, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 247514, "avg_candidate_generations": 7500.424242424242, "candidate_moves_total": 25295705, "avg_candidate_moves": 102.19908772837093, "candidate_moves_max": 136, "root_candidate_generations": 33, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3018, "root_candidate_moves_max": 124, "search_candidate_generations": 247481, "search_candidate_moves_total": 25292687, "search_candidate_moves_max": 136, "legality_checks": 6727021, "avg_legality_checks": 203849.12121212122, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1708, "root_legality_checks": 3018, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6724003, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1708, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19831297, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 600948.3939393939, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 34957596785, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1762.748890554158, "renju_forbidden_checks": 90470, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2741.5151515151515, "renju_forbidden_ns": 208676245, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2306.579473858738, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5705, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17967280, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 35378, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 121258220, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 47634, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 65818105, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1753, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3632640, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 464676, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14081.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2779719626, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5982.059813719667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 557696, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16899.878787878788, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 896358711, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1607.2532544612118, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12818077185, "stage_ordering_ns": 7285365380, "stage_eval_ns": 11749032769, "stage_threat_ns": 28577732677, "stage_proof_ns": 1561713835, "tactical_annotations": 6274175, "root_tactical_annotations": 13074, "search_tactical_annotations": 6261101, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1489551, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 7415835386, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 6313132, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 19609325351, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 504397, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11806633083, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 744759, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 997843769, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 35136, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 223110683, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1489518, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 162014458, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 2187440, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1009667657, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 2802130, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 4954158815, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1284605, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 169603030, "child_limit_applications": 247481, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 247481, "child_cap_hits": 247481, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 247481, "child_moves_before_total": 25290979, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 25290979, "child_moves_before_max": 136, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 136, "child_moves_after_total": 2990347, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 2990347, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 102.19361890407748, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.083137695419042, "tt_hits": 114912, "tt_cutoffs": 17976, "beta_cutoffs": 197890, "depth_sum": 165, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 165, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 9 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 14, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.42424242424242425, "pooled_budget_moves": 33, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.45454545454545453, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 14, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.42424242424242425, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 993.2424242424242, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1114.030303030303, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 35, "search_move_count": 33, "total_time_ms": 3454, "avg_search_time_ms": 104.66666666666667, "search_nodes": 274180, "safety_nodes": 4244, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 278424, "avg_nodes": 8437.09090909091, "eval_calls": 266098, "avg_eval_calls": 8063.575757575758, "line_shape_eval_calls": 266098, "line_shape_eval_ns": 499438414, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1876.8965343595216, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8018, "avg_candidate_generations": 242.96969696969697, "candidate_moves_total": 726915, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.66038912446994, "candidate_moves_max": 136, "root_candidate_generations": 33, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3046, "root_candidate_moves_max": 123, "search_candidate_generations": 7985, "search_candidate_moves_total": 723869, "search_candidate_moves_max": 136, "legality_checks": 18146, "avg_legality_checks": 549.8787878787879, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 18146, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 53979, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1635.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 104523020, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1936.3645121250856, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.21212121212121213, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9450, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1350.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4200, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 43240051, "stage_ordering_ns": 248322, "stage_eval_ns": 499438414, "stage_threat_ns": 2852054704, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 548199, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2481476165, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 86, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 669581, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 65, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 33590, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 274083, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 311520758, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 548166, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58388200, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 352, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7426, "depth_sum": 97, "avg_depth": 2.9393939393939394, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 97, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9393939393939394, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 32 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 33, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7312.515151515152, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7554.939393939394, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 787, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20111, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 129, 157, 172, 81, 130, 96, 144, 80, 64, 158, 145, 161, 160, 175, 100, 115, 159, 114, 131, 156, 170, 173, 174, 143, 189 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 1972, "avg_search_time_ms": 140.85714285714286, "search_nodes": 168733, "safety_nodes": 1341, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 170074, "avg_nodes": 12148.142857142857, "eval_calls": 164642, "avg_eval_calls": 11760.142857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 164642, "line_shape_eval_ns": 127122638, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 772.1154869352899, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4064, "avg_candidate_generations": 290.2857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 289117, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.14099409448819, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1007, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 4050, "search_candidate_moves_total": 288110, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 153373, "avg_legality_checks": 10955.214285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 1007, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 152366, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 170018, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12144.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 291244489, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1713.0214977237704, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.857142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 399716, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9992.9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 223613, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 176103, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 82, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 742323, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9052.719512195123, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 125, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.928571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 416072, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3328.576, "stage_move_gen_ns": 272303109, "stage_ordering_ns": 116281, "stage_eval_ns": 127122638, "stage_threat_ns": 1543749571, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 337398, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1347303662, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 956076, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 168692, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 164155260, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 337384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31334573, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 179, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3769, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6360.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6931.928571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1927, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 18125, "avg_search_time_ms": 1294.642857142857, "search_nodes": 158604, "safety_nodes": 506, "corridor_nodes": 444, "corridor_branch_probes": 533, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 160, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 434, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 434, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 160, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 39, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 289, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 29910720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 159554, "avg_nodes": 11396.714285714286, "eval_calls": 98672, "avg_eval_calls": 7048.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 98672, "pattern_eval_ns": 1951033, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.772914301929625, "pattern_frame_queries": 98672, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1951033, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.772914301929625, "pattern_frame_updates": 317074, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2624150015, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8276.143786623943, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 54180, "avg_candidate_generations": 3870.0, "candidate_moves_total": 4736263, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.4171834625323, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1024, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 54166, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4735239, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 3371264, "avg_legality_checks": 240804.57142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10867, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3371264, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10867, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7641807, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 545843.3571428572, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11873927177, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1553.8114449893853, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40689, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2906.3571428571427, "renju_forbidden_ns": 178788629, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4394.028582663619, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10867, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 90345713, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7732, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62194933, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22060, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25951000, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 296983, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 316266, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 22590.428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2571636802, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8131.2464887151955, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 455988, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 32570.571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1340166271, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2939.038463731502, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6151489827, "stage_ordering_ns": 1430554111, "stage_eval_ns": 2626101048, "stage_threat_ns": 7752156924, "stage_proof_ns": 43580802, "tactical_annotations": 1081743, "root_tactical_annotations": 3252, "search_tactical_annotations": 1078491, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 318038, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1517034389, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 911739, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5961553966, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 108812, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2765349743, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 159012, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 197393924, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 950, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4416723, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 318024, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32677903, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 283281, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1064415759, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 491499, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2118253871, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 306963, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 39080019, "child_limit_applications": 54166, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 54166, "child_cap_hits": 54166, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 54166, "child_moves_before_total": 4724372, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4724372, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 638429, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 638429, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.22024886460142, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.786526603404349, "tt_hits": 29641, "tt_cutoffs": 5701, "beta_cutoffs": 43237, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4680.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5251.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1684, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 788, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11632, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 129, 65, 49, 157, 128, 111, 96, 80, 114, 156, 144, 160, 159, 174, 99 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10814, "avg_search_time_ms": 1201.5555555555557, "search_nodes": 119868, "safety_nodes": 83, "corridor_nodes": 40, "corridor_branch_probes": 48, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 39, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 39, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 32, "corridor_proof_active": 1, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 32, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 272, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 204880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 119991, "avg_nodes": 13332.333333333334, "eval_calls": 78982, "avg_eval_calls": 8775.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 78982, "pattern_eval_ns": 1609431, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.37718720721177, "pattern_frame_queries": 78982, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1609431, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.37718720721177, "pattern_frame_updates": 239650, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2465513259, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10287.975209680784, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37615, "avg_candidate_generations": 4179.444444444444, "candidate_moves_total": 3035158, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.690097035757, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 604, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 37606, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3034554, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1017040, "avg_legality_checks": 113004.44444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 631, "root_legality_checks": 604, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1016436, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 631, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3006537, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 334059.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6480481931, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2155.4638878550304, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18380, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2042.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 99865538, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5433.3807399347115, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 703, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6354009, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9847, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71530192, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7826, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21938377, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 42960, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 56834, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6314.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 490460700, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8629.705809902523, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 75107, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8345.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 205357730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2734.202271426099, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2418018842, "stage_ordering_ns": 1234522515, "stage_eval_ns": 2467122690, "stage_threat_ns": 4585106562, "stage_proof_ns": 60068000, "tactical_annotations": 265524, "root_tactical_annotations": 2650, "search_tactical_annotations": 262874, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 239801, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1282235449, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 259144, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3100349854, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75413, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2414528078, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 119896, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 163807604, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 142, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 614603, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 239792, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27096114, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 47077, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 87570690, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 134057, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 591917454, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 84390, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11002938, "child_limit_applications": 37606, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37606, "child_cap_hits": 37606, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37606, "child_moves_before_total": 3033923, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3033923, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 328498, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 328498, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.67656756900494, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.735255012498005, "tt_hits": 19133, "tt_cutoffs": 3237, "beta_cutoffs": 27843, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1608.3333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2411.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 809, "avg_search_time_ms": 101.125, "search_nodes": 59534, "safety_nodes": 515, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 60049, "avg_nodes": 7506.125, "eval_calls": 55526, "avg_eval_calls": 6940.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 55526, "line_shape_eval_ns": 45967472, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 827.8549148146814, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3993, "avg_candidate_generations": 499.125, "candidate_moves_total": 322581, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.78662659654395, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 531, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 3985, "search_candidate_moves_total": 322050, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 12309, "avg_legality_checks": 1538.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 12309, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21721, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2715.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 48520015, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2233.783665577091, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 31846324, "stage_ordering_ns": 122602, "stage_eval_ns": 45967472, "stage_threat_ns": 718250742, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 119030, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 632720763, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 149520, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8370, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 59511, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 71914859, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 119022, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13465600, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 201, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3667, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5363.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6363.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 789, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14898, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 81, 143, 67, 52, 95, 53, 80, 83, 113, 68, 38, 65, 96, 128, 110, 51, 94, 93, 109, 123, 124, 138, 139, 79, 154 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 4727, "avg_search_time_ms": 337.64285714285717, "search_nodes": 313373, "safety_nodes": 1047, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 314420, "avg_nodes": 22458.571428571428, "eval_calls": 305882, "avg_eval_calls": 21848.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 305882, "line_shape_eval_ns": 392855166, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1284.3356784642444, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7465, "avg_candidate_generations": 533.2142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 561591, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.22987273945077, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 892, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 7451, "search_candidate_moves_total": 560699, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 302494, "avg_legality_checks": 21606.714285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1014, "root_legality_checks": 892, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 301602, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1011, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 318526, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22751.85714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 684626682, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2149.3588655243216, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1112, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 79.42857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6657909, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5987.328237410072, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1090, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6589148, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 68761, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.357142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 720754, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8098.359550561798, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 115, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.214285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 287202, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2497.4086956521737, "stage_move_gen_ns": 679042107, "stage_ordering_ns": 219373, "stage_eval_ns": 392855166, "stage_threat_ns": 3631178842, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 626680, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3165368720, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1015284, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 313333, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 394465576, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 626666, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 70329262, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 356, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6788, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6528.071428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7099.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1925, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 10157, "avg_search_time_ms": 781.3076923076923, "search_nodes": 82273, "safety_nodes": 1066, "corridor_nodes": 1151, "corridor_branch_probes": 1399, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 432, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1135, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1135, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 42, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 26, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 432, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 42, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 42, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 202, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 15999040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 84490, "avg_nodes": 6499.2307692307695, "eval_calls": 48952, "avg_eval_calls": 3765.5384615384614, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48952, "pattern_eval_ns": 1018535, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.806810753391076, "pattern_frame_queries": 48952, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1018535, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.806810753391076, "pattern_frame_updates": 164390, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1726538957, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10502.700632641889, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30775, "avg_candidate_generations": 2367.3076923076924, "candidate_moves_total": 2433860, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.08562144597887, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 825, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 30762, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2433035, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1346378, "avg_legality_checks": 103567.53846153847, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1657, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1346378, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1657, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3254298, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 250330.61538461538, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6502811484, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1998.2224995989918, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24484, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1883.3846153846155, "renju_forbidden_ns": 69333062, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2831.7702172847576, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1686, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13067261, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6216, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32954298, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16552, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23137433, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 174070, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 122770, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9443.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 818881176, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6670.042974668078, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 148058, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11389.076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 240021869, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1621.1340758351457, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2986300347, "stage_ordering_ns": 887956393, "stage_eval_ns": 1727557492, "stage_threat_ns": 4436804918, "stage_proof_ns": 60058610, "tactical_annotations": 592245, "root_tactical_annotations": 961, "search_tactical_annotations": 591284, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 166757, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 978579599, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 561270, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3284970415, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62268, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1993563037, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 83372, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 120307384, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2354, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12518352, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 166744, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20473095, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 114295, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 279543264, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 311347, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 954816434, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 166603, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19956073, "child_limit_applications": 30762, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30762, "child_cap_hits": 30762, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30762, "child_moves_before_total": 2431378, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2431378, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 381762, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 381762, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.03835901436838, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.410181392627267, "tt_hits": 15167, "tt_cutoffs": 2481, "beta_cutoffs": 26050, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 5.923076923076923, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 5.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5595.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6210.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1593, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 790, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15166, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 96, 97, 68, 110, 80, 64, 83, 84, 52, 99, 38, 100, 101, 94, 53, 23, 54, 40, 55, 56, 51 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14313, "avg_search_time_ms": 1301.1818181818182, "search_nodes": 146452, "safety_nodes": 157, "corridor_nodes": 3212, "corridor_branch_probes": 3247, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1857, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 3210, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3210, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 1, "corridor_proof_completed": 1, "corridor_proof_checks": 2, "corridor_proof_active": 2, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1857, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 2, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 1, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 149821, "avg_nodes": 13620.09090909091, "eval_calls": 93466, "avg_eval_calls": 8496.90909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 93466, "pattern_eval_ns": 1902912, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.359403419425245, "pattern_frame_queries": 93466, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1902912, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.359403419425245, "pattern_frame_updates": 292806, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3179231324, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10857.80798207687, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49715, "avg_candidate_generations": 4519.545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 3853504, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.5118978175601, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 709, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 49704, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3852795, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 1087502, "avg_legality_checks": 98863.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 310, "root_legality_checks": 709, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1086793, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 310, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4092944, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 372085.8181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8491863277, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2074.7567709208824, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23121, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2101.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 71345627, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3085.7500540634055, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 923, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3365595, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10884, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 48255880, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11198, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19470901, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 116, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 253251, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93646, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8513.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 664450306, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7095.341028981484, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 113336, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10303.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 216407593, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1909.4338339097903, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2532152263, "stage_ordering_ns": 1470253139, "stage_eval_ns": 3181134236, "stage_threat_ns": 6838141822, "stage_proof_ns": 241872376, "tactical_annotations": 777396, "root_tactical_annotations": 2620, "search_tactical_annotations": 774776, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 299241, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1725151718, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 830170, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4797666812, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 100826, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3295239929, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 149615, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 215628056, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6424, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 37721690, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 299230, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35710440, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 165711, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 140942374, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 425888, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1052894980, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 185797, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26263106, "child_limit_applications": 49704, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49704, "child_cap_hits": 49704, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49704, "child_moves_before_total": 3852485, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3852485, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 467265, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 467265, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.50855061966844, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.400953645581845, "tt_hits": 20525, "tt_cutoffs": 3235, "beta_cutoffs": 38497, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2575.5454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3280.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 843, "avg_search_time_ms": 84.3, "search_nodes": 64589, "safety_nodes": 826, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 65415, "avg_nodes": 6541.5, "eval_calls": 62054, "avg_eval_calls": 6205.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 62054, "line_shape_eval_ns": 59987099, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 966.6918973797016, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2516, "avg_candidate_generations": 251.6, "candidate_moves_total": 183052, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.75516693163752, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 644, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 2506, "search_candidate_moves_total": 182408, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 5514, "avg_legality_checks": 551.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5514, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16889, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1688.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 36024698, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2133.0272958730534, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14337418, "stage_ordering_ns": 78160, "stage_eval_ns": 59987099, "stage_threat_ns": 753854160, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 129130, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 660136393, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 178081, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10700, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 79430206, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 129120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14109480, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 123, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2235, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5962.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6762.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1947, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 791, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16699, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 84, 97, 156, 114, 140, 113, 111, 96, 95, 115, 116, 130, 170, 184, 82, 129, 81, 145, 161, 160, 100, 175 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6220, "avg_search_time_ms": 518.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 390266, "safety_nodes": 644, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 390910, "avg_nodes": 32575.833333333332, "eval_calls": 379933, "avg_eval_calls": 31661.083333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 379933, "line_shape_eval_ns": 363685405, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 957.2356310191534, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10311, "avg_candidate_generations": 859.25, "candidate_moves_total": 804115, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.98613131607021, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 863, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 10299, "search_candidate_moves_total": 803252, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 372408, "avg_legality_checks": 31034.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4103, "root_legality_checks": 863, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 371545, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4096, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 386435, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32202.916666666668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 947709772, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2452.442899840853, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4194, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 349.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46604074, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11112.08249880782, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4161, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 46290684, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 33, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 313390, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 32, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.6666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 307832, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9619.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.083333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 144701, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2953.081632653061, "stage_move_gen_ns": 990028207, "stage_ordering_ns": 319141, "stage_eval_ns": 363685405, "stage_threat_ns": 4858219049, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 780476, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4253271592, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 402583, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12030, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 390232, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 510968003, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 780464, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 93576871, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 466, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9522, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5682.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6348.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1913, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10468, "avg_search_time_ms": 951.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 82518, "safety_nodes": 1080, "corridor_nodes": 472, "corridor_branch_probes": 584, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 172, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 464, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 464, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 27, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 172, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 27, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 27, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 160, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 33857600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2001280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 84070, "avg_nodes": 7642.727272727273, "eval_calls": 52847, "avg_eval_calls": 4804.272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 52847, "pattern_eval_ns": 1112108, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.043919238556587, "pattern_frame_queries": 52847, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1112108, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.043919238556587, "pattern_frame_updates": 164908, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2138292250, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12966.57681858976, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25986, "avg_candidate_generations": 2362.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 2057652, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.1830985915493, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 25975, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2056866, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1134664, "avg_legality_checks": 103151.27272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8512, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1134664, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8512, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3131187, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 284653.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6601041043, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2108.1593156205618, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43188, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3926.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 291893650, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6758.674863387978, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9533, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 98636316, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14274, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 137276274, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19328, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 55383058, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 53, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 598002, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 117661, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10696.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1140648072, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9694.359830360103, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 164157, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14923.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 532593710, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3244.416686464787, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2802018998, "stage_ordering_ns": 836734298, "stage_eval_ns": 2139404358, "stage_threat_ns": 4601029219, "stage_proof_ns": 42955036, "tactical_annotations": 458895, "root_tactical_annotations": 869, "search_tactical_annotations": 458026, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 165901, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 977740532, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 433845, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3462463201, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52326, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1922020652, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 82945, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 123537713, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 982, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5013378, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 165890, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20646929, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 89286, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 406573027, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 261033, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1111280806, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 108576, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11627466, "child_limit_applications": 25975, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25975, "child_cap_hits": 25975, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25975, "child_moves_before_total": 2048354, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2048354, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 306026, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 306026, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.85867179980751, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.781559191530318, "tt_hits": 12853, "tt_cutoffs": 3633, "beta_cutoffs": 20569, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3184.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3912.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 792, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18081, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 126, 114, 127, 129, 125, 124, 144, 82, 130, 83, 81, 68, 113, 52, 100, 66, 50, 67, 97, 65, 64, 69 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 17700, "avg_search_time_ms": 1475.0, "search_nodes": 190700, "safety_nodes": 248, "corridor_nodes": 346, "corridor_branch_probes": 413, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 144, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 343, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 343, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 1, "corridor_proof_completed": 1, "corridor_proof_checks": 4, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 1, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 144, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 4, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 4, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 10, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 3954080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1977040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 191294, "avg_nodes": 15941.166666666666, "eval_calls": 142829, "avg_eval_calls": 11902.416666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 142829, "pattern_eval_ns": 2888713, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.224975320138068, "pattern_frame_queries": 142829, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2888713, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.224975320138068, "pattern_frame_updates": 381286, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5918934831, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15523.609130678808, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44928, "avg_candidate_generations": 3744.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3679272, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.8926282051282, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 812, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 44916, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3678460, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 1175948, "avg_legality_checks": 97995.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2262, "root_legality_checks": 812, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1175136, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2260, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5136263, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 428021.9166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10515773963, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2047.3589383954832, "renju_forbidden_checks": 123897, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10324.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 458681973, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3702.123320177244, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4747, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20597160, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 71622, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 337804625, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 47497, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 100119098, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 31, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 161090, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 160181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13348.416666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1231563041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7688.571309955612, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 205312, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17109.333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 472211437, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2299.9699822708853, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2765154087, "stage_ordering_ns": 1432093987, "stage_eval_ns": 5921823544, "stage_threat_ns": 7484842665, "stage_proof_ns": 47136726, "tactical_annotations": 980979, "root_tactical_annotations": 2971, "search_tactical_annotations": 978008, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 381992, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2099030429, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 878822, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5034718264, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90056, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3070220930, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 190990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 272462933, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 694, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3588105, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 381980, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45553540, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 279839, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 267287913, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 487646, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1640808612, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 213494, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 29489394, "child_limit_applications": 44916, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44916, "child_cap_hits": 44916, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44916, "child_moves_before_total": 3676200, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3676200, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 601927, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 601927, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.84611274378841, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.40117107489536, "tt_hits": 19614, "tt_cutoffs": 2900, "beta_cutoffs": 33596, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2689.5833333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3221.0833333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 370, "avg_search_time_ms": 33.63636363636363, "search_nodes": 25352, "safety_nodes": 1128, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 26480, "avg_nodes": 2407.2727272727275, "eval_calls": 23968, "avg_eval_calls": 2178.909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 23968, "line_shape_eval_ns": 17838050, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 744.244409212283, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1363, "avg_candidate_generations": 123.9090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 98902, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.56199559794571, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 749, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 1352, "search_candidate_moves_total": 98153, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 3128, "avg_legality_checks": 284.3636363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3128, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16055, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1459.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31871392, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1985.138087823108, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.7272727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19520, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1027.3684210526317, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4510, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 15010, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8559950, "stage_ordering_ns": 46910, "stage_eval_ns": 17838050, "stage_threat_ns": 331476598, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 50651, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 292499071, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 316011, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10580, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 25320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 32606698, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 50640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6054818, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 76, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1236, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6107.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6835.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 793, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 69633, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 97, 95, 125, 142, 94, 111, 67, 127, 82, 52, 79, 143, 159, 144, 141, 109, 65, 158, 174, 130, 116, 157, 172, 171, 129, 107, 108, 146, 145, 185, 199, 113, 49, 66, 81, 33, 117, 173, 131, 103, 115, 24, 38, 114, 99, 83, 98, 100, 101, 203, 188, 155, 86, 71, 87, 73, 118, 119, 34, 64, 147, 163, 102, 132, 70, 134, 56, 84, 187, 149, 72, 57, 104, 36, 68, 50, 88, 40, 85, 89, 69, 53, 133 ], "move_count": 89, "black_stats": { "move_count": 45, "search_move_count": 43, "total_time_ms": 15023, "avg_search_time_ms": 349.3720930232558, "search_nodes": 1127374, "safety_nodes": 5792, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1133166, "avg_nodes": 26352.697674418603, "eval_calls": 1101665, "avg_eval_calls": 25620.116279069767, "line_shape_eval_calls": 1101665, "line_shape_eval_ns": 2694100004, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 2445.480253979204, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25625, "avg_candidate_generations": 595.9302325581396, "candidate_moves_total": 2872590, "avg_candidate_moves": 112.10107317073171, "candidate_moves_max": 145, "root_candidate_generations": 43, "root_candidate_moves_total": 4432, "root_candidate_moves_max": 132, "search_candidate_generations": 25582, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2868158, "search_candidate_moves_max": 145, "legality_checks": 1080954, "avg_legality_checks": 25138.46511627907, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2032, "root_legality_checks": 4432, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "search_legality_checks": 1076522, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2016, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1126925, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26207.558139534885, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1938716638, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1720.3599511946225, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3016, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 70.13953488372093, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13649068, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4525.553050397878, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2825, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13184806, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 191, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 464262, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 252, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.8604651162790695, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2460753, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9764.892857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 411, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.55813953488372, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1401465, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3409.890510948905, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1952953611, "stage_ordering_ns": 781745, "stage_eval_ns": 2694100004, "stage_threat_ns": 10147760433, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 2254537, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 8757769857, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 119, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3058578, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 85, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 36730, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 1127247, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1177305960, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 2254494, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 209626038, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1161, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 23647, "depth_sum": 127, "avg_depth": 2.953488372093023, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 127, "avg_effective_depth": 2.953488372093023, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 42 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 43, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.023255813953488372, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7394.697674418605, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7580.7441860465115, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1956, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 44, "search_move_count": 42, "total_time_ms": 54562, "avg_search_time_ms": 1299.095238095238, "search_nodes": 486499, "safety_nodes": 3404, "corridor_nodes": 9382, "corridor_branch_probes": 10238, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4302, "corridor_neutral_exits": 49, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 9327, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9327, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 25, "corridor_proof_completed": 25, "corridor_proof_checks": 139, "corridor_proof_active": 55, "corridor_proof_quiet": 84, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 49, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4302, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 139, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 139, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 928, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 77410360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1990000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 499285, "avg_nodes": 11887.738095238095, "eval_calls": 296141, "avg_eval_calls": 7050.976190476191, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 296141, "pattern_eval_ns": 5965173, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.143016333435764, "pattern_frame_queries": 296141, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5965173, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.143016333435764, "pattern_frame_updates": 972480, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7344977484, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7552.831404244817, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 174892, "avg_candidate_generations": 4164.0952380952385, "candidate_moves_total": 18128881, "avg_candidate_moves": 103.65757724767285, "candidate_moves_max": 147, "root_candidate_generations": 42, "root_candidate_moves_total": 4347, "root_candidate_moves_max": 133, "search_candidate_generations": 174850, "search_candidate_moves_total": 18124534, "search_candidate_moves_max": 147, "legality_checks": 11693539, "avg_legality_checks": 278417.59523809527, "illegal_moves_skipped": 35740, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11693539, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 35740, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23386590, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 556823.5714285715, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 34942844955, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1494.1402297213915, "renju_forbidden_checks": 322211, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7671.690476190476, "renju_forbidden_ns": 526051312, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1632.6298977998888, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 40666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 93438415, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 46398, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 160543633, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 234932, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 271318771, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 215, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 750493, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 846865, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 20163.45238095238, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 6666251759, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7871.681742662644, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1308722, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31160.04761904762, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3519161284, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2689.005979879608, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20232954748, "stage_ordering_ns": 4834393325, "stage_eval_ns": 7350942657, "stage_threat_ns": 21646819643, "stage_proof_ns": 95871734, "tactical_annotations": 4703404, "root_tactical_annotations": 10045, "search_tactical_annotations": 4693359, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 991454, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4366345195, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 4390132, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 16312614668, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 355140, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7137324988, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 495706, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 614028218, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 18932, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 122706078, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 991412, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 97641430, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1741633, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 3899404042, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1851173, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 5024165853, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1110598, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 133484054, "child_limit_applications": 174850, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 174850, "child_cap_hits": 174850, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 174850, "child_moves_before_total": 18088794, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 18088794, "child_moves_before_max": 147, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 147, "child_moves_after_total": 1903866, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1903866, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 103.453211323992, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.888567343437233, "tt_hits": 91402, "tt_cutoffs": 15254, "beta_cutoffs": 142467, "depth_sum": 251, "avg_depth": 5.976190476190476, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 251, "avg_effective_depth": 5.976190476190476, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 25 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 8, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.19047619047619047, "pooled_budget_moves": 42, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2619047619047619, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 8, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.19047619047619047, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6184.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6374.476190476191, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1782, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 794, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13056, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 142, 95, 65, 94, 127, 125, 140, 97, 156, 114, 172, 157, 188, 124, 204 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 11069, "avg_search_time_ms": 1229.888888888889, "search_nodes": 98832, "safety_nodes": 250, "corridor_nodes": 2095, "corridor_branch_probes": 2349, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 926, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 2080, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2080, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 40, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 25, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 926, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 40, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 39, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 289, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4144480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 101177, "avg_nodes": 11241.888888888889, "eval_calls": 61939, "avg_eval_calls": 6882.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 61939, "pattern_eval_ns": 1296804, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.936792650833883, "pattern_frame_queries": 61939, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1296804, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.936792650833883, "pattern_frame_updates": 197570, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2423362192, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12265.840927266285, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34511, "avg_candidate_generations": 3834.5555555555557, "candidate_moves_total": 2717542, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.7442264785141, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 561, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 34502, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2716981, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 790603, "avg_legality_checks": 87844.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 759, "root_legality_checks": 561, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 790042, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 759, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3136497, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 348499.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6759934934, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2155.2499281842133, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29611, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3290.1111111111113, "renju_forbidden_ns": 132018893, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4458.440883455472, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 927, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5806557, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14540, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 87838915, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13421, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 34373115, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 723, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4000306, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 80555, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8950.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 733145622, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9101.180832971262, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 107579, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11953.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 324701840, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3018.2641593619574, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1905564957, "stage_ordering_ns": 1092955038, "stage_eval_ns": 2424658996, "stage_threat_ns": 5313527771, "stage_proof_ns": 295221196, "tactical_annotations": 495364, "root_tactical_annotations": 1901, "search_tactical_annotations": 493463, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 201819, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1190537236, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 512348, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3906178684, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70142, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2603884036, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 100905, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 148560995, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4240, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22787988, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 201810, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24525274, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 97431, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 182031358, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 224265, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 809423568, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 173668, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20937594, "child_limit_applications": 34502, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34502, "child_cap_hits": 34502, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34502, "child_moves_before_total": 2716222, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2716222, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 340820, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 340820, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.72650860819662, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.878267926497015, "tt_hits": 19245, "tt_cutoffs": 2344, "beta_cutoffs": 27933, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 5.222222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 5.222222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1958.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2732.1111111111113, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 533, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1978, "avg_search_time_ms": 247.25, "search_nodes": 146968, "safety_nodes": 620, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 147588, "avg_nodes": 18448.5, "eval_calls": 143028, "avg_eval_calls": 17878.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 143028, "line_shape_eval_ns": 109984496, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 768.9717817490282, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3925, "avg_candidate_generations": 490.625, "candidate_moves_total": 275219, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.11949044585987, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 506, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 3917, "search_candidate_moves_total": 274713, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 8161, "avg_legality_checks": 1020.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8161, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17533, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2191.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 40307368, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2298.943021730451, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23140188, "stage_ordering_ns": 121830, "stage_eval_ns": 109984496, "stage_threat_ns": 1832682590, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 293898, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1614664678, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 199281, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 146945, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 182980155, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 293890, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34838476, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 130, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3618, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5013.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6013.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 795, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 36561, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 113, 83, 81, 110, 68, 97, 114, 111, 115, 116, 69, 125, 139, 140, 95, 67, 85, 124, 138, 108, 92, 109, 107, 141, 93, 156, 172, 155, 170, 157, 173, 158, 154, 159 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 4760, "avg_search_time_ms": 264.44444444444446, "search_nodes": 301834, "safety_nodes": 1511, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 303345, "avg_nodes": 16852.5, "eval_calls": 294840, "avg_eval_calls": 16380.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 294840, "line_shape_eval_ns": 250225320, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 848.6817256817257, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6959, "avg_candidate_generations": 386.6111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 488516, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.19916654691767, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1286, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 6941, "search_candidate_moves_total": 487230, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 291170, "avg_legality_checks": 16176.111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "root_legality_checks": 1286, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 289884, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 311790, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17321.666666666668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 735427619, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2358.7274094743257, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.8888888888888888, "renju_forbidden_ns": 338473, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9955.088235294117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 260653, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 77820, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.7222222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 475424, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9702.530612244898, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.7777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 239541, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3522.6617647058824, "stage_move_gen_ns": 713567649, "stage_ordering_ns": 216262, "stage_eval_ns": 250225320, "stage_threat_ns": 3764789676, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 603580, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3311900456, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 47, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 732156, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 301781, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 380010132, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 603562, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 72146932, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 253, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6435, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6391.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6835.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1888, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 31784, "avg_search_time_ms": 1765.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 218754, "safety_nodes": 554, "corridor_nodes": 1765, "corridor_branch_probes": 1914, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 695, "corridor_neutral_exits": 24, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1743, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1743, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 58, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 36, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 695, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 58, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 440, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 77253680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1992480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 221073, "avg_nodes": 12281.833333333334, "eval_calls": 135150, "avg_eval_calls": 7508.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 135150, "pattern_eval_ns": 2857198, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.14093969663337, "pattern_frame_queries": 135150, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2857198, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.14093969663337, "pattern_frame_updates": 437316, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4343335308, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9931.800592706419, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 78866, "avg_candidate_generations": 4381.444444444444, "candidate_moves_total": 6807350, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.31539573453706, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1328, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 78848, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6806022, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 4892947, "avg_legality_checks": 271830.3888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5658, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4892947, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5658, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10997753, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 610986.2777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21157714096, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1923.8215384542643, "renju_forbidden_checks": 57595, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3199.722222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 192779130, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3347.1504470874206, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6663, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 57369827, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8894, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72375107, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 42023, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 62883016, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 151180, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 467973, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 25998.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 4367262109, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9332.295044799594, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 685395, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 38077.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2199769703, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3209.4919032090984, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10998529560, "stage_ordering_ns": 2538731779, "stage_eval_ns": 4346192506, "stage_threat_ns": 13639629463, "stage_proof_ns": 84904940, "tactical_annotations": 1817027, "root_tactical_annotations": 5407, "search_tactical_annotations": 1811620, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 440936, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2529472359, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1677226, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10665041670, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 158904, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4995169618, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 220459, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 324096605, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3602, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17829268, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 440918, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53275287, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 568061, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 2115341095, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 840524, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3471950711, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 408442, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 49914274, "child_limit_applications": 78848, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 78848, "child_cap_hits": 78848, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 78848, "child_moves_before_total": 6800364, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6800364, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 900561, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 900561, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.24649959415585, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.421481838474026, "tt_hits": 36097, "tt_cutoffs": 4665, "beta_cutoffs": 63460, "depth_sum": 90, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 90, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3888888888888889, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2031.7222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2271.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 796, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10991, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 85, 68, 111, 81, 80, 113, 94, 78, 108, 109, 122, 66, 136 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10388, "avg_search_time_ms": 1154.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 97254, "safety_nodes": 247, "corridor_nodes": 1173, "corridor_branch_probes": 1411, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 458, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1160, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1160, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 25, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 458, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 284, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4151840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 98674, "avg_nodes": 10963.777777777777, "eval_calls": 61123, "avg_eval_calls": 6791.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 61123, "pattern_eval_ns": 1277032, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.892822669044385, "pattern_frame_queries": 61123, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1277032, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.892822669044385, "pattern_frame_updates": 194414, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2310735600, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11885.644037980805, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33649, "avg_candidate_generations": 3738.777777777778, "candidate_moves_total": 2633655, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.26844779934025, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 555, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 33640, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2633100, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 770349, "avg_legality_checks": 85594.33333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 749, "root_legality_checks": 555, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 769794, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 749, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2928395, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 325377.22222222225, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6312042293, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2155.461368087297, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26482, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2942.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 116886522, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4413.810210709161, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 908, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5883875, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13246, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 80366484, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12188, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29620486, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 140, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1015677, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 71404, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7933.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 635911968, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8905.831157918325, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95223, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10580.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 277480157, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2914.003518057612, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1847536611, "stage_ordering_ns": 1049234097, "stage_eval_ns": 2312012632, "stage_threat_ns": 4936457593, "stage_proof_ns": 205474739, "tactical_annotations": 475922, "root_tactical_annotations": 1898, "search_tactical_annotations": 474024, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 196819, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1144433924, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 445824, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3589786169, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67982, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2505490469, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 98405, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 141910187, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2396, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12420667, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 196810, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24106483, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 95167, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 175088203, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 208180, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 716692310, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 172575, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23800163, "child_limit_applications": 33640, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33640, "child_cap_hits": 33640, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33640, "child_moves_before_total": 2632351, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2632351, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 328146, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 328146, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.2506242568371, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.754637336504162, "tt_hits": 19259, "tt_cutoffs": 2444, "beta_cutoffs": 27082, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 5.222222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 5.222222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2285.777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3135.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 701, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 594, "avg_search_time_ms": 74.25, "search_nodes": 43789, "safety_nodes": 614, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 44403, "avg_nodes": 5550.375, "eval_calls": 41825, "avg_eval_calls": 5228.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 41825, "line_shape_eval_ns": 31749776, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 759.1100059772863, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1949, "avg_candidate_generations": 243.625, "candidate_moves_total": 134147, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.82863006670087, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 1941, "search_candidate_moves_total": 133647, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 6543, "avg_legality_checks": 817.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6543, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15879, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1984.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 35182745, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2215.67762453555, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17432421, "stage_ordering_ns": 62810, "stage_eval_ns": 31749776, "stage_threat_ns": 532320628, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 87540, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 469009850, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 188120, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8120, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43766, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 53084369, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 87532, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10038289, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 130, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1744, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5353.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6353.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 797, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18626, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 80, 111, 130, 82, 116, 97, 127, 68, 110, 81, 66, 83, 146, 162, 125, 67, 52, 69, 55, 65, 38, 24, 94 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5957, "avg_search_time_ms": 496.4166666666667, "search_nodes": 430505, "safety_nodes": 798, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 431303, "avg_nodes": 35941.916666666664, "eval_calls": 420508, "avg_eval_calls": 35042.333333333336, "line_shape_eval_calls": 420508, "line_shape_eval_ns": 313213307, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 744.8450612116773, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9974, "avg_candidate_generations": 831.1666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 775355, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.73761780629637, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 857, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 9962, "search_candidate_moves_total": 774498, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 414089, "avg_legality_checks": 34507.416666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1083, "root_legality_checks": 857, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 413232, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1081, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 428180, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 35681.666666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 891826734, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2082.8313653136534, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1243, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 103.58333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12925348, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10398.510056315366, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1235, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12831637, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 93711, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 63, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 324901, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5157.158730158731, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 135581, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1783.9605263157894, "stage_move_gen_ns": 906397325, "stage_ordering_ns": 307730, "stage_eval_ns": 313213307, "stage_threat_ns": 4704125087, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 860952, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4116010346, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 445112, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 430470, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 496467245, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 860940, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 91202384, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 413, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9226, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5327.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5993.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1393, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 12661, "avg_search_time_ms": 1055.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 125387, "safety_nodes": 1237, "corridor_nodes": 2142, "corridor_branch_probes": 2698, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 952, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2126, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2126, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 22, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 952, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 184, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 39772800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 128766, "avg_nodes": 10730.5, "eval_calls": 76850, "avg_eval_calls": 6404.166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 76850, "pattern_eval_ns": 1549559, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.16342225113858, "pattern_frame_queries": 76850, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1549559, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.16342225113858, "pattern_frame_updates": 250628, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2662309342, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10622.553513573903, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42282, "avg_candidate_generations": 3523.5, "candidate_moves_total": 3604723, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.2543162575091, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 873, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 42270, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3603850, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1349983, "avg_legality_checks": 112498.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3910, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1349983, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3910, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4228624, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 352385.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7663284286, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1812.2406451838706, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36082, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3006.8333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 214035440, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5931.917299484508, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5022, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52768998, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13624, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 110585660, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17411, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 50427339, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 253443, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 140798, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11733.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1166304878, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8283.532990525433, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 194170, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16180.833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 523973383, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2698.529036411392, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2917538089, "stage_ordering_ns": 1160222077, "stage_eval_ns": 2663858901, "stage_threat_ns": 5807748687, "stage_proof_ns": 46188621, "tactical_annotations": 923010, "root_tactical_annotations": 917, "search_tactical_annotations": 922093, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 254968, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1262493085, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 951374, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4320048050, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 85488, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2483362844, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 127478, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 160324559, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4328, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18838056, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 254956, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26857372, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 179051, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 489929215, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 566080, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1275143290, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 177879, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19187565, "child_limit_applications": 42270, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42270, "child_cap_hits": 42270, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42270, "child_moves_before_total": 3599940, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3599940, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 607618, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 607618, "child_moves_after_max": 33, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 33, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.1653655074521, "avg_child_moves_after": 14.374686538916489, "tt_hits": 20439, "tt_cutoffs": 6195, "beta_cutoffs": 35504, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3114.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3781.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 10, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 798, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10922, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 128, 82, 113, 83, 143, 158, 84, 68, 54, 81, 79, 66, 99, 69, 129, 144, 70, 111, 51, 126 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10450, "avg_search_time_ms": 950.0, "search_nodes": 117734, "safety_nodes": 391, "corridor_nodes": 3640, "corridor_branch_probes": 3851, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 1642, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 3626, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3626, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1642, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 284, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4042400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1977040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 121765, "avg_nodes": 11069.545454545454, "eval_calls": 74484, "avg_eval_calls": 6771.272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74484, "pattern_eval_ns": 1425193, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.13421674453574, "pattern_frame_queries": 74484, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1425193, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.13421674453574, "pattern_frame_updates": 235358, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2428162328, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10316.888858674869, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 40034, "avg_candidate_generations": 3639.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 3156790, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.85272518359395, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 725, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 40023, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3156065, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 916346, "avg_legality_checks": 83304.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4062, "root_legality_checks": 725, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 915621, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4059, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3885945, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 353267.7272727273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6215160893, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1599.3949716220893, "renju_forbidden_checks": 53469, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4860.818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 332111974, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6211.299519347659, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4988, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 47835825, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22265, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 168393089, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24483, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 103388530, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1733, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 12494530, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 104265, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9478.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 748651133, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7180.272699371793, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 140380, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12761.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 332988635, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2372.0518236215985, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1627046532, "stage_ordering_ns": 910631915, "stage_eval_ns": 2429587521, "stage_threat_ns": 5016725475, "stage_proof_ns": 410405247, "tactical_annotations": 675886, "root_tactical_annotations": 2205, "search_tactical_annotations": 673681, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 242697, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1091784628, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 724038, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3691127535, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 82040, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2227126122, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121343, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 139528842, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7328, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 42447725, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 242686, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22841012, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 149757, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 134727098, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 289423, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 827089454, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 236706, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28995733, "child_limit_applications": 40023, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 40023, "child_cap_hits": 40023, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 40023, "child_moves_before_total": 3152006, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3152006, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 422086, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 422086, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.75486595207755, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.546086000549684, "tt_hits": 23344, "tt_cutoffs": 3172, "beta_cutoffs": 32558, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4537.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5264.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1656, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 462, "avg_search_time_ms": 46.2, "search_nodes": 41956, "safety_nodes": 1041, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 42997, "avg_nodes": 4299.7, "eval_calls": 40320, "avg_eval_calls": 4032.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 40320, "line_shape_eval_ns": 32209813, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 798.8544890873015, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1617, "avg_candidate_generations": 161.7, "candidate_moves_total": 118037, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.99752628324057, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 661, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 1607, "search_candidate_moves_total": 117376, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 3469, "avg_legality_checks": 346.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3469, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15257, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1525.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25453645, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1668.325686570099, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 308960, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 13433.04347826087, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 149560, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 159400, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7677135, "stage_ordering_ns": 48580, "stage_eval_ns": 32209813, "stage_threat_ns": 409621551, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 83864, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 358784955, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 299751, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 41927, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 42658357, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 83854, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7878488, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 84, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1464, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5951.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6751.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1990, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 799, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26901, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 80, 97, 158, 110, 144, 111, 113, 94, 95, 67, 82, 83, 125, 109, 108, 124, 139, 99, 51, 84, 174, 190, 141, 98, 100, 69, 55, 114, 54, 129 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 9011, "avg_search_time_ms": 563.1875, "search_nodes": 745543, "safety_nodes": 904, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 746447, "avg_nodes": 46652.9375, "eval_calls": 726630, "avg_eval_calls": 45414.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 726630, "line_shape_eval_ns": 609368146, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 838.6223332369982, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18883, "avg_candidate_generations": 1180.1875, "candidate_moves_total": 1545251, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.83291849812001, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1227, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 18867, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1544024, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 714497, "avg_legality_checks": 44656.0625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3561, "root_legality_checks": 1227, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 713270, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3558, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 733184, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 45824.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1314054138, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1792.2569750567388, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3821, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 238.8125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30181740, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7898.9112797696935, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3804, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30058309, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 123431, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.6875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 332261, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7727.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 116160, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1968.8135593220338, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1353566102, "stage_ordering_ns": 541873, "stage_eval_ns": 609368146, "stage_threat_ns": 6956622697, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1491010, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6054301312, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 553103, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 745497, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 763001691, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1490994, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 138766591, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 714, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 16945, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6184.4375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6684.4375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1920, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 17874, "avg_search_time_ms": 1191.6, "search_nodes": 160688, "safety_nodes": 1310, "corridor_nodes": 1637, "corridor_branch_probes": 2020, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 651, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1618, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1618, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 651, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 346, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 53909680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2002480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 163635, "avg_nodes": 10909.0, "eval_calls": 98435, "avg_eval_calls": 6562.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 98435, "pattern_eval_ns": 1982585, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.141057550667952, "pattern_frame_queries": 98435, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1982585, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.141057550667952, "pattern_frame_updates": 321194, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2932138539, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9128.870835071639, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 55831, "avg_candidate_generations": 3722.0666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 5061663, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.66043954075693, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1147, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 55816, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5060516, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 3291402, "avg_legality_checks": 219426.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6289, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3291402, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6289, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7045654, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 469710.26666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11488681768, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1630.605443866531, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65604, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4373.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 257682420, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3927.8461679165903, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7150, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 74534458, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14050, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 115888687, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 44371, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 66911134, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 33, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 348141, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 284683, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18978.866666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1771835779, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6223.890358749908, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 358203, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23880.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 656075572, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1831.5747550969702, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5829829796, "stage_ordering_ns": 1529888946, "stage_eval_ns": 2934121124, "stage_threat_ns": 7385524764, "stage_proof_ns": 73522421, "tactical_annotations": 1127813, "root_tactical_annotations": 2135, "search_tactical_annotations": 1125678, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 324567, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1567520248, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1068565, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5536183786, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 112593, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3028524439, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 162276, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 204402594, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3358, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13976164, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 324552, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33586853, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 293513, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 728163366, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 563176, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1726395912, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 271124, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 29855119, "child_limit_applications": 55816, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 55816, "child_cap_hits": 55816, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 55816, "child_moves_before_total": 5054227, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5054227, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 643795, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 643795, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.55158019205962, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.534237494625197, "tt_hits": 26812, "tt_cutoffs": 6346, "beta_cutoffs": 45751, "depth_sum": 89, "avg_depth": 5.933333333333334, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 89, "avg_effective_depth": 5.933333333333334, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4146.933333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4680.266666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 800, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16503, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 128, 110, 127, 125, 129, 130, 140, 82, 124, 81, 79, 114, 66, 83, 84, 111, 113, 97, 139, 69 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 16104, "avg_search_time_ms": 1464.0, "search_nodes": 159557, "safety_nodes": 238, "corridor_nodes": 330, "corridor_branch_probes": 395, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 132, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 327, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 327, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 1, "corridor_proof_completed": 1, "corridor_proof_checks": 4, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 1, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 132, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 4, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 4, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 10, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 3954080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1977040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 160125, "avg_nodes": 14556.818181818182, "eval_calls": 114593, "avg_eval_calls": 10417.545454545454, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 114593, "pattern_eval_ns": 2375454, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.729486094264047, "pattern_frame_queries": 114593, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2375454, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.729486094264047, "pattern_frame_updates": 319010, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5066566516, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15882.155781950409, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42205, "avg_candidate_generations": 3836.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 3429705, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.26300201397939, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 711, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 42194, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3428994, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1026439, "avg_legality_checks": 93312.63636363637, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1241, "root_legality_checks": 711, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1025728, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1241, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4325649, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 393240.8181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9525185464, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2202.0245896049355, "renju_forbidden_checks": 95075, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8643.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 434819051, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4573.432037864844, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2970, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18101446, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 53007, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 318625451, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 39092, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 98021024, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 71130, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 124403, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11309.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1068804311, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8591.46733599672, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 158704, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14427.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 420485928, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2649.4979836677085, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2539384948, "stage_ordering_ns": 1386108624, "stage_eval_ns": 5068941970, "stage_threat_ns": 7024531227, "stage_proof_ns": 46950443, "tactical_annotations": 793955, "root_tactical_annotations": 2542, "search_tactical_annotations": 791413, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 319683, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1897562872, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 732897, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4821429389, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 84603, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3071223871, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 159836, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 239982677, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 662, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3369062, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 319672, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39686220, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 183918, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 247911605, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 443510, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1447872513, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 166527, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22501007, "child_limit_applications": 42194, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42194, "child_cap_hits": 42194, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42194, "child_moves_before_total": 3427753, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3427753, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 498260, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 498260, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.23792482343461, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.808787979333555, "tt_hits": 17596, "tt_cutoffs": 2720, "beta_cutoffs": 32438, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2313.2727272727275, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2853.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 387, "avg_search_time_ms": 38.7, "search_nodes": 26341, "safety_nodes": 951, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 27292, "avg_nodes": 2729.2, "eval_calls": 25060, "avg_eval_calls": 2506.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 25060, "line_shape_eval_ns": 19528253, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 779.2598962490024, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1262, "avg_candidate_generations": 126.2, "candidate_moves_total": 89261, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.72979397781299, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 651, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 1252, "search_candidate_moves_total": 88610, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 2689, "avg_legality_checks": 268.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2689, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1441.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31127653, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2159.5430137366448, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7832427, "stage_ordering_ns": 43160, "stage_eval_ns": 19528253, "stage_threat_ns": 349368133, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 52634, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 307473401, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 229682, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 26312, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 35323493, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 52624, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6341557, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 74, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1138, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5918.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6718.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1982, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 801, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 36750, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 111, 81, 83, 114, 66, 97, 109, 113, 110, 108, 65, 129, 145, 144, 99, 67, 79, 130, 146, 116, 102, 115, 117, 143, 101, 158, 172, 157, 171, 159, 174, 156, 160, 155 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 4991, "avg_search_time_ms": 277.27777777777777, "search_nodes": 307930, "safety_nodes": 1523, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 309453, "avg_nodes": 17191.833333333332, "eval_calls": 300845, "avg_eval_calls": 16713.61111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 300845, "line_shape_eval_ns": 259471150, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 862.4745300736259, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7050, "avg_candidate_generations": 391.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 496751, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.46113475177305, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1292, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 7032, "search_candidate_moves_total": 495459, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 297181, "avg_legality_checks": 16510.055555555555, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 1292, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 295889, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 317825, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17656.944444444445, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 777182425, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2445.3155824746323, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.3888888888888888, "renju_forbidden_ns": 167550, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6702.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 127320, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 40230, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.7222222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 485363, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9905.367346938776, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.7777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 243330, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3578.3823529411766, "stage_move_gen_ns": 756137666, "stage_ordering_ns": 220151, "stage_eval_ns": 259471150, "stage_threat_ns": 3954137524, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 615772, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3475615997, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 47, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 740494, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18511, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 307877, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 402638980, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 615754, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 75142053, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 253, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6563, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6330.611111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6775.055555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1634, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 31740, "avg_search_time_ms": 1763.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 223593, "safety_nodes": 564, "corridor_nodes": 1808, "corridor_branch_probes": 1962, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 730, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1786, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1786, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 58, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 36, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 730, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 58, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 440, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 77264560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 225965, "avg_nodes": 12553.611111111111, "eval_calls": 141016, "avg_eval_calls": 7834.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 141016, "pattern_eval_ns": 3029630, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.484299653939978, "pattern_frame_queries": 141016, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3029630, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.484299653939978, "pattern_frame_updates": 446990, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4406145203, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9857.36862793351, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 78014, "avg_candidate_generations": 4334.111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 6732184, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.29456251442049, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1334, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 77996, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6730850, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 4698074, "avg_legality_checks": 261004.11111111112, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3384, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4698074, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3384, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10716456, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 595358.6666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20954198286, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1955.3291018971197, "renju_forbidden_checks": 51545, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2863.6111111111113, "renju_forbidden_ns": 164589844, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3193.1291880880785, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3898, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 36040967, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7097, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 68436459, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 40540, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 60033168, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 79250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 455379, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 25298.833333333332, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 4351003694, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9554.686742252059, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 667208, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 37067.11111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2199080493, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3295.944432620712, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10761366673, "stage_ordering_ns": 2553456300, "stage_eval_ns": 4409174833, "stage_threat_ns": 13748222588, "stage_proof_ns": 77176236, "tactical_annotations": 1729941, "root_tactical_annotations": 5566, "search_tactical_annotations": 1724375, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 450696, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2592381435, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1640584, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10714177415, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 157208, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5022363966, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 225339, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 330261327, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3688, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15760499, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 450678, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 54634666, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 523121, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1922071510, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 849674, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3697469448, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 357146, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 41007246, "child_limit_applications": 77996, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 77996, "child_cap_hits": 77996, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 77996, "child_moves_before_total": 6727466, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6727466, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 869550, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 869550, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.25398738396841, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.14864864864865, "tt_hits": 34361, "tt_cutoffs": 4487, "beta_cutoffs": 61949, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 5.111111111111111, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 5.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1735.388888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1982.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 802, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12155, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 114, 81, 79, 66, 113, 83, 84, 111, 100, 86, 116, 115, 132, 68, 148 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 11567, "avg_search_time_ms": 1285.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 101181, "safety_nodes": 247, "corridor_nodes": 1236, "corridor_branch_probes": 1466, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 493, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1223, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1223, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 25, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 493, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 284, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4144240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 102664, "avg_nodes": 11407.111111111111, "eval_calls": 63777, "avg_eval_calls": 7086.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 63777, "pattern_eval_ns": 1400724, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.9628392680747, "pattern_frame_queries": 63777, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1400724, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.9628392680747, "pattern_frame_updates": 202268, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2556015704, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12636.777463563194, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34946, "avg_candidate_generations": 3882.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 2734901, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.2607737652378, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 555, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 34937, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2734346, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 827146, "avg_legality_checks": 91905.11111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 761, "root_legality_checks": 555, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 826591, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 761, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3079810, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 342201.1111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7045365767, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2287.597535886954, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27989, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3109.8888888888887, "renju_forbidden_ns": 130453331, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4660.878595162385, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 980, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6361958, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13806, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 89534858, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13008, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 33281138, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 195, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1275377, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 77844, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8649.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 744935132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9569.589589435282, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 103613, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11512.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 324913985, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3135.8418827753276, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2104447235, "stage_ordering_ns": 1161578545, "stage_eval_ns": 2557416428, "stage_threat_ns": 5478032454, "stage_proof_ns": 224241312, "tactical_annotations": 482253, "root_tactical_annotations": 1898, "search_tactical_annotations": 480355, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 204799, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1270505543, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 461458, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3987715129, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70610, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2747155977, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102395, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 157514485, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2522, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13706870, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 204790, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26550591, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96685, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 197235783, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 216839, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 830711044, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 168729, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22039836, "child_limit_applications": 34937, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34937, "child_cap_hits": 34937, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34937, "child_moves_before_total": 2733585, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2733585, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 337053, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 337053, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.24326645104044, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.647451126313078, "tt_hits": 19411, "tt_cutoffs": 2420, "beta_cutoffs": 28124, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 5.222222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 5.222222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1637.3333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2356.8888888888887, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 342, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 581, "avg_search_time_ms": 72.625, "search_nodes": 40101, "safety_nodes": 614, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40715, "avg_nodes": 5089.375, "eval_calls": 38241, "avg_eval_calls": 4780.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 38241, "line_shape_eval_ns": 30873492, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 807.340080018828, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1845, "avg_candidate_generations": 230.625, "candidate_moves_total": 127409, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.05636856368564, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 1837, "search_candidate_moves_total": 126909, "search_candidate_moves_max": 86, "legality_checks": 6613, "avg_legality_checks": 826.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6613, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15949, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1993.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 37575831, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2355.9991849018747, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18580930, "stage_ordering_ns": 64012, "stage_eval_ns": 30873492, "stage_threat_ns": 520302333, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 80164, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 457786135, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 201042, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8730, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40078, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 52574435, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 80156, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9740721, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 130, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1647, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5356.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6356.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 803, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 39765, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 97, 99, 129, 142, 100, 113, 67, 127, 82, 52, 85, 141, 155, 140, 143, 115, 69, 156, 170, 124, 108, 157, 172, 173, 125, 117, 116, 138, 139, 189, 205, 111, 55, 131, 70, 40, 68, 66, 71 ], "move_count": 45, "black_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 4982, "avg_search_time_ms": 237.23809523809524, "search_nodes": 300113, "safety_nodes": 1960, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 302073, "avg_nodes": 14384.42857142857, "eval_calls": 292019, "avg_eval_calls": 13905.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 292019, "line_shape_eval_ns": 395178893, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1353.2643184176372, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8054, "avg_candidate_generations": 383.5238095238095, "candidate_moves_total": 660364, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.99205363794388, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1694, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 8033, "search_candidate_moves_total": 658670, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 284972, "avg_legality_checks": 13570.095238095239, "illegal_moves_skipped": 90, "root_legality_checks": 1694, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 283278, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 90, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 309039, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14716.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 756821050, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2448.94997071567, "renju_forbidden_checks": 339, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 16.142857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1740399, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5133.920353982301, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 320, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1690719, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 49680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.1904761904761907, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 662494, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9887.970149253732, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 93, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.428571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 333522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3586.2580645161293, "stage_move_gen_ns": 729524647, "stage_ordering_ns": 270510, "stage_eval_ns": 395178893, "stage_threat_ns": 3823575386, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 600125, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3351031239, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 56, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1016036, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 22221, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 300052, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 397714483, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 600104, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 73813628, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 464, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7321, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 2.9047619047619047, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9047619047619047, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6735.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7116.619047619048, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1918, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 34761, "avg_search_time_ms": 1738.05, "search_nodes": 249602, "safety_nodes": 917, "corridor_nodes": 4758, "corridor_branch_probes": 5463, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 2241, "corridor_neutral_exits": 17, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 4721, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4721, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 94, "corridor_proof_active": 37, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2241, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 94, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 94, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 722, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 75396520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1990000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 255277, "avg_nodes": 12763.85, "eval_calls": 157676, "avg_eval_calls": 7883.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 157676, "pattern_eval_ns": 3500694, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.201818919810243, "pattern_frame_queries": 157676, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3500694, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.201818919810243, "pattern_frame_updates": 498978, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5005765064, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10032.035608784356, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 86400, "avg_candidate_generations": 4320.0, "candidate_moves_total": 7801095, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.29045138888888, "candidate_moves_max": 140, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1612, "root_candidate_moves_max": 115, "search_candidate_generations": 86380, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7799483, "search_candidate_moves_max": 140, "legality_checks": 5430180, "avg_legality_checks": 271509.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4018, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5430180, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4018, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11334980, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 566749.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22769050695, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2008.7420264526272, "renju_forbidden_checks": 78572, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3928.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 226824832, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2886.84050297816, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5750, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 41229924, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12366, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 91777524, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 60379, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 93569873, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 77, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 247511, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 391217, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19560.85, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3632684831, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9285.600653857067, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 554846, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27742.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1777790363, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3204.114949012879, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12336255584, "stage_ordering_ns": 2942945377, "stage_eval_ns": 5009265758, "stage_threat_ns": 14168125554, "stage_proof_ns": 104426183, "tactical_annotations": 1916026, "root_tactical_annotations": 6006, "search_tactical_annotations": 1910020, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 508628, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2982796588, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1850582, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10613006589, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 175365, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5539187625, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 254304, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 386309668, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9630, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 57975675, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 508608, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63008247, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 589269, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1514820113, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 840617, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3375474552, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 486140, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 65028787, "child_limit_applications": 86380, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 86380, "child_cap_hits": 86380, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 86380, "child_moves_before_total": 7795465, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7795465, "child_moves_before_max": 140, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 140, "child_moves_after_total": 867097, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 867097, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.24617967122019, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.038168557536467, "tt_hits": 41903, "tt_cutoffs": 5436, "beta_cutoffs": 67900, "depth_sum": 109, "avg_depth": 5.45, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 109, "avg_effective_depth": 5.45, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2187.05, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2455.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 804, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27245, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 141, 99, 129, 100, 140, 154, 142, 69, 54, 143, 127, 86, 72, 157, 156, 171, 124, 185, 199, 172, 169, 155, 96, 111, 138, 139, 110, 82, 152 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 26139, "avg_search_time_ms": 1633.6875, "search_nodes": 243813, "safety_nodes": 920, "corridor_nodes": 696, "corridor_branch_probes": 815, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 310, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 690, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 690, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 27, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 21, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 310, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 27, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 27, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 160, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6079760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 245429, "avg_nodes": 15339.3125, "eval_calls": 175596, "avg_eval_calls": 10974.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 175596, "pattern_eval_ns": 3833351, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.830514362513952, "pattern_frame_queries": 175596, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3833351, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.830514362513952, "pattern_frame_updates": 487460, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8412978396, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 17258.80768883601, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 63703, "avg_candidate_generations": 3981.4375, "candidate_moves_total": 6056358, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.07178625810401, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1299, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 63687, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6055059, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 1693717, "avg_legality_checks": 105857.3125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3300, "root_legality_checks": 1299, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1692418, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3299, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6907456, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 431716.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15523644711, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2247.3751133557707, "renju_forbidden_checks": 114530, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7158.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 740888594, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6468.947821531477, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 44032426, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 70933, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 537114553, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 38066, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 157993758, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 197, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1747857, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 189442, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11840.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1750230333, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9238.871702156861, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 257382, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16086.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 745631504, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2896.9838761063324, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4186927850, "stage_ordering_ns": 2328311664, "stage_eval_ns": 8416811747, "stage_threat_ns": 11013158833, "stage_proof_ns": 129710043, "tactical_annotations": 1368017, "root_tactical_annotations": 3905, "search_tactical_annotations": 1364112, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 488910, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2993865285, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1183134, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7517023238, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 127855, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4726027050, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 244447, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 378619588, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1434, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8232666, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 488894, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64190670, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 392894, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 485063257, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 622286, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2192610750, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 352837, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 51227386, "child_limit_applications": 63687, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 63687, "child_cap_hits": 63687, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 63687, "child_moves_before_total": 6051760, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6051760, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 812172, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 812172, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.02347417840376, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.752555466578738, "tt_hits": 32299, "tt_cutoffs": 4447, "beta_cutoffs": 49874, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3596.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3967.8125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 299, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 1090, "avg_search_time_ms": 72.66666666666667, "search_nodes": 74361, "safety_nodes": 1839, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76200, "avg_nodes": 5080.0, "eval_calls": 71577, "avg_eval_calls": 4771.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 71577, "line_shape_eval_ns": 88097006, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1230.8004806013105, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2755, "avg_candidate_generations": 183.66666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 230170, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.54627949183303, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1223, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 2740, "search_candidate_moves_total": 228947, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 7603, "avg_legality_checks": 506.8666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7603, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 25170, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1678.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 57389116, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2280.060230433055, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 118320, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5634.285714285715, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 29080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 89240, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22141017, "stage_ordering_ns": 92930, "stage_eval_ns": 88097006, "stage_threat_ns": 959077687, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 148649, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 842257364, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 41, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 423753, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16540, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74317, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 98309649, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 148634, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18086921, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 141, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2506, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6600.066666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7133.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 805, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19845, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 84, 113, 124, 82, 108, 97, 127, 66, 114, 81, 138, 152, 129, 99, 140, 67, 52, 65, 49, 68, 64, 69 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 4981, "avg_search_time_ms": 415.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 296655, "safety_nodes": 962, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 297617, "avg_nodes": 24801.416666666668, "eval_calls": 289748, "avg_eval_calls": 24145.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 289748, "line_shape_eval_ns": 245007982, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 845.5898988086199, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6885, "avg_candidate_generations": 573.75, "candidate_moves_total": 510784, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.18794480755265, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 868, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 6873, "search_candidate_moves_total": 509916, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 283761, "avg_legality_checks": 23646.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1039, "root_legality_checks": 868, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 282893, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1034, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 297953, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24829.416666666668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 765423249, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2568.9395609374633, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1153, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 96.08333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14204112, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12319.264527320034, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1130, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13920011, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 284101, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 730311, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10143.208333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 99, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 347010, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3505.151515151515, "stage_move_gen_ns": 768153637, "stage_ordering_ns": 226250, "stage_eval_ns": 245007982, "stage_threat_ns": 3962608405, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 593254, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3475754065, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 916022, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12640, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 296621, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 410657225, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 593242, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 75281093, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 337, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6343, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5372.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6038.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1406, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14853, "avg_search_time_ms": 1350.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 110813, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 1165, "corridor_branch_probes": 1469, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 479, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1153, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1153, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 32, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 20, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 479, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 32, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 172, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 35762160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 112894, "avg_nodes": 10263.09090909091, "eval_calls": 71690, "avg_eval_calls": 6517.272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71690, "pattern_eval_ns": 1569545, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.893499790765798, "pattern_frame_queries": 71690, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1569545, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.893499790765798, "pattern_frame_updates": 221502, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3003636723, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13560.314231925671, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35199, "avg_candidate_generations": 3199.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 2989345, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.92698656211824, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 792, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 35188, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2988553, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1579832, "avg_legality_checks": 143621.0909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5134, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1579832, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5134, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4302132, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 391102.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9389808124, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2182.5941472739564, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46329, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4211.727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 317760695, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6858.785965593905, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6385, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 71350218, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18034, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 171218211, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21877, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 74756265, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 33, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 436001, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 174455, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15859.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1663073597, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9532.966077211888, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 242911, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22082.81818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 728076307, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2997.296569525464, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3964524893, "stage_ordering_ns": 1220546128, "stage_eval_ns": 3005206268, "stage_threat_ns": 6551660032, "stage_proof_ns": 47362161, "tactical_annotations": 686579, "root_tactical_annotations": 1351, "search_tactical_annotations": 685228, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 223883, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1399084860, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 684347, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4917683956, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 71001, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2623714200, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111936, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 175427607, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2370, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13746575, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 223872, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29052522, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 161551, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 674354522, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 381360, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1563914752, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 143668, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16664512, "child_limit_applications": 35188, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35188, "child_cap_hits": 35188, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35188, "child_moves_before_total": 2983419, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2983419, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 431234, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 431234, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.78512561100375, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.255143799022393, "tt_hits": 15652, "tt_cutoffs": 3875, "beta_cutoffs": 28289, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 5.454545454545454, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 5.454545454545454, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1910.1818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2564.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 806, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14999, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 126, 82, 111, 81, 141, 156, 80, 66, 50, 83, 85, 68, 95, 65, 125, 140, 64, 113, 53, 128 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14298, "avg_search_time_ms": 1299.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 115041, "safety_nodes": 391, "corridor_nodes": 3579, "corridor_branch_probes": 3805, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 1599, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 3565, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3565, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 22, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 8, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1599, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 22, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 21, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 148, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4031600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1977040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 119011, "avg_nodes": 10819.181818181818, "eval_calls": 72992, "avg_eval_calls": 6635.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72992, "pattern_eval_ns": 1601382, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.939144015782553, "pattern_frame_queries": 72992, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1601382, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.939144015782553, "pattern_frame_updates": 229972, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3341070197, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14528.16080653297, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38789, "avg_candidate_generations": 3526.2727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 3077064, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.32826316739282, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 725, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 38778, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3076339, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 907257, "avg_legality_checks": 82477.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4095, "root_legality_checks": 725, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 906532, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4092, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3825350, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 347759.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8641315980, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2258.960874168377, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54292, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4935.636363636364, "renju_forbidden_ns": 393850840, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7254.307080232815, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5017, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53255632, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22990, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 209489570, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24569, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 118052796, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1716, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13052842, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 104902, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9536.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 983993724, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9380.123582009875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 140625, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12784.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 428103220, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3044.2895644444443, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2360342397, "stage_ordering_ns": 1292784353, "stage_eval_ns": 3342671579, "stage_threat_ns": 6822159305, "stage_proof_ns": 436578533, "tactical_annotations": 659324, "root_tactical_annotations": 2205, "search_tactical_annotations": 657119, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 237157, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1523678118, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 714663, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5004736607, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 79463, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3141456940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 118573, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184585484, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7174, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 45318596, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 237146, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31008966, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 145726, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 177802938, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 289708, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1134092519, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 223890, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32831534, "child_limit_applications": 38778, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38778, "child_cap_hits": 38778, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38778, "child_moves_before_total": 3072247, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3072247, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 408602, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 408602, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.2265459796792, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.536953942957346, "tt_hits": 22295, "tt_cutoffs": 3217, "beta_cutoffs": 31593, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.909090909090909, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2185.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2889.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 690, "avg_search_time_ms": 69.0, "search_nodes": 47020, "safety_nodes": 1041, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48061, "avg_nodes": 4806.1, "eval_calls": 45288, "avg_eval_calls": 4528.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 45288, "line_shape_eval_ns": 45376776, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1001.9602543720191, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1713, "avg_candidate_generations": 171.3, "candidate_moves_total": 125083, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.01984821949796, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 661, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 1703, "search_candidate_moves_total": 124422, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 3666, "avg_legality_checks": 366.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3666, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15454, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1545.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 35060262, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2268.6852594797465, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 318381, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 13842.652173913044, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 151780, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 166601, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10995892, "stage_ordering_ns": 58370, "stage_eval_ns": 45376776, "stage_threat_ns": 621367272, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 93992, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 546485426, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 356851, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 46991, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 62933184, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 93982, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11591811, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 84, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1547, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5899.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6699.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 807, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32379, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 97, 82, 113, 114, 142, 157, 66, 96, 68, 138, 124, 84, 81, 65, 125, 123, 128, 126, 129, 145, 130, 131, 111, 83, 95, 79, 141, 85, 86, 99, 143, 159, 140, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 15936, "avg_search_time_ms": 885.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 951616, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 952589, "avg_nodes": 52921.61111111111, "eval_calls": 933209, "avg_eval_calls": 51844.944444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 933209, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1388468828, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1487.8433748495781, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18373, "avg_candidate_generations": 1020.7222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 1646966, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.64055951668209, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1405, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 18355, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1645561, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 918569, "avg_legality_checks": 51031.61111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1011, "root_legality_checks": 1405, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 917164, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1008, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 939594, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 52199.666666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2315031295, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2463.8634293109576, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1205, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 66.94444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10874560, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9024.53112033195, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1190, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10760750, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 113810, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 41, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.2777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 383423, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9351.780487804877, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 59, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 180311, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3056.1186440677966, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2344037253, "stage_ordering_ns": 605815, "stage_eval_ns": 1388468828, "stage_threat_ns": 12135958825, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1903146, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 10632519797, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 50, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 583933, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19010, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 951564, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1270513904, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1903128, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 232341191, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 804, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 16638, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6130.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6575.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1885, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 16426, "avg_search_time_ms": 966.2352941176471, "search_nodes": 123121, "safety_nodes": 1609, "corridor_nodes": 1060, "corridor_branch_probes": 1290, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 20, "corridor_depth_exits": 382, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_plies_followed": 1044, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1044, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 39, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 23, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 38, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 382, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 39, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 39, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 189, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 39922720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2007120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 125790, "avg_nodes": 7399.411764705882, "eval_calls": 75135, "avg_eval_calls": 4419.705882352941, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75135, "pattern_eval_ns": 1648449, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.939828309043722, "pattern_frame_queries": 75135, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1648449, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.939828309043722, "pattern_frame_updates": 246050, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2489832853, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10119.215009144484, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43199, "avg_candidate_generations": 2541.1176470588234, "candidate_moves_total": 3779019, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.4793166508484, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1322, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 43182, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3777697, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 2280464, "avg_legality_checks": 134144.9411764706, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3730, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2280464, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3730, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5228797, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 307576.29411764705, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10604297412, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2028.0568191880466, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45391, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2670.0588235294117, "renju_forbidden_ns": 128259667, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2825.6629508052256, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4111, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 36451271, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7288, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44714444, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 33967, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 46935301, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 158651, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 187561, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11033.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1748003146, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9319.651452060929, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 270000, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15882.35294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 817111038, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3026.337177777778, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5279216300, "stage_ordering_ns": 1480373950, "stage_eval_ns": 2491481302, "stage_threat_ns": 7015098194, "stage_proof_ns": 59490204, "tactical_annotations": 750547, "root_tactical_annotations": 1829, "search_tactical_annotations": 748718, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 248233, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1468709518, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 719990, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5296162279, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 87078, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2863727705, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124108, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184875195, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2166, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14175129, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 248216, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30369157, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 130456, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 467226255, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 438797, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1914656370, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 181294, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20806916, "child_limit_applications": 43182, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43182, "child_cap_hits": 43182, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43182, "child_moves_before_total": 3773967, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3773967, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 446494, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 446494, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.3967625399472, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.339817516557826, "tt_hits": 20026, "tt_cutoffs": 4709, "beta_cutoffs": 34401, "depth_sum": 94, "avg_depth": 5.529411764705882, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 94, "avg_effective_depth": 5.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4898.64705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5369.235294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1094, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 808, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16584, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 99, 128, 80, 100, 114, 144, 160, 143, 145, 175, 159, 130, 129, 172, 157, 158, 116, 186 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 16157, "avg_search_time_ms": 1468.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 140734, "safety_nodes": 362, "corridor_nodes": 344, "corridor_branch_probes": 409, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 142, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 340, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 340, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 32, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 28, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 142, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 32, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 272, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 19904640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1966400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 141440, "avg_nodes": 12858.181818181818, "eval_calls": 92290, "avg_eval_calls": 8390.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 92290, "pattern_eval_ns": 2025269, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.944620218875283, "pattern_frame_queries": 92290, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2025269, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.944620218875283, "pattern_frame_updates": 281368, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4546685057, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 16159.21162676637, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44668, "avg_candidate_generations": 4060.7272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 3374055, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.5362899614937, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 710, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 44657, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3373345, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1056975, "avg_legality_checks": 96088.63636363637, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3273, "root_legality_checks": 710, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1056265, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3272, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4141611, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 376510.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9592256400, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2316.0688920325933, "renju_forbidden_checks": 63625, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5784.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 469115106, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7373.125438113949, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3807, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 37720703, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 36614, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 332382367, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23152, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 98536924, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 475112, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 100458, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9132.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 964925625, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9605.264140237712, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 141058, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12823.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 425700902, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3017.913921932822, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2748842866, "stage_ordering_ns": 1452589535, "stage_eval_ns": 4548710326, "stage_threat_ns": 7260633178, "stage_proof_ns": 101661792, "tactical_annotations": 713939, "root_tactical_annotations": 2586, "search_tactical_annotations": 711353, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 282123, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1778581777, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 633105, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5187977408, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 89644, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3549435255, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 141056, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 222747560, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 744, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3842697, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 282112, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39212022, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 107040, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 191774880, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 415085, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1385411640, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 191814, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28271714, "child_limit_applications": 44657, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44657, "child_cap_hits": 44657, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44657, "child_moves_before_total": 3370073, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3370073, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 520559, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 520559, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.46572765747811, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.656828716662561, "tt_hits": 21472, "tt_cutoffs": 3738, "beta_cutoffs": 34971, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 4.363636363636363, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 4.363636363636363, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1294.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1830.7272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 416, "avg_search_time_ms": 41.6, "search_nodes": 26985, "safety_nodes": 968, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 27953, "avg_nodes": 2795.3, "eval_calls": 25679, "avg_eval_calls": 2567.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 25679, "line_shape_eval_ns": 24045875, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 936.402313174189, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1287, "avg_candidate_generations": 128.7, "candidate_moves_total": 88768, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.97280497280498, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 648, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 1277, "search_candidate_moves_total": 88120, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 2847, "avg_legality_checks": 284.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2847, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14480, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1448.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 32804973, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2265.5368093922652, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 223050, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10621.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 58040, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 165010, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8568115, "stage_ordering_ns": 43270, "stage_eval_ns": 24045875, "stage_threat_ns": 371323479, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 53922, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 327106622, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 239380, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11120, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 26956, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 36719233, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 53912, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7258244, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 68, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1154, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5937.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6737.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 809, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20659, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 126, 98, 109, 108, 83, 114, 66, 158, 143, 156, 96, 81, 142, 97, 94, 78, 129, 93, 123, 140, 172, 92, 127, 124 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 1714, "avg_search_time_ms": 131.84615384615384, "search_nodes": 100750, "safety_nodes": 1331, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 102081, "avg_nodes": 7852.384615384615, "eval_calls": 97645, "avg_eval_calls": 7511.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 97645, "line_shape_eval_ns": 85027037, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 870.7771724102616, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3080, "avg_candidate_generations": 236.92307692307693, "candidate_moves_total": 214956, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.7909090909091, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 897, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 3067, "search_candidate_moves_total": 214059, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 91142, "avg_legality_checks": 7010.923076923077, "illegal_moves_skipped": 149, "root_legality_checks": 897, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 90245, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 147, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 106718, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8209.076923076924, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 270456466, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2534.309732191383, "renju_forbidden_checks": 158, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 12.153846153846153, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1848256, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11697.822784810127, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 149, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1751756, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 96500, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1150416, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11859.958762886597, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.846153846153847, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 623065, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4418.900709219858, "stage_move_gen_ns": 245849244, "stage_ordering_ns": 103010, "stage_eval_ns": 85027037, "stage_threat_ns": 1368696185, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 201437, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1201001814, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1458966, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14020, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 100712, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 140420417, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 201424, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25814988, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 121, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2798, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6182.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6798.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1882, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18932, "avg_search_time_ms": 1456.3076923076924, "search_nodes": 141426, "safety_nodes": 391, "corridor_nodes": 1204, "corridor_branch_probes": 1321, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 508, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1193, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1193, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 39, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 508, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 50, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 411, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 57674880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 143021, "avg_nodes": 11001.615384615385, "eval_calls": 97676, "avg_eval_calls": 7513.538461538462, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 97676, "pattern_eval_ns": 2180719, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.32604734018592, "pattern_frame_queries": 97676, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2180719, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.32604734018592, "pattern_frame_updates": 282722, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3650154432, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12910.754847518057, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 40766, "avg_candidate_generations": 3135.846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 3323733, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.53198744051416, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 915, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 40753, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3322818, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 2256674, "avg_legality_checks": 173590.3076923077, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8977, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2256674, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8977, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5540193, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 426168.6923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12199047985, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2201.9175117184545, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58580, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4506.153846153846, "renju_forbidden_ns": 362463232, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6187.4911573916015, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9068, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 100512691, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17231, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 167646295, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32266, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 94124806, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 179440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 192578, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14813.692307692309, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2072498360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10761.864595125093, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 270743, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20826.384615384617, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1032624211, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3814.0384460540067, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5767816483, "stage_ordering_ns": 1398208901, "stage_eval_ns": 3652335151, "stage_threat_ns": 7939469073, "stage_proof_ns": 81262683, "tactical_annotations": 892015, "root_tactical_annotations": 3253, "search_tactical_annotations": 888762, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 285221, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1818637068, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 750508, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5802767331, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 82382, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3086821452, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 142604, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 226129478, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2486, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14132838, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 285208, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37937796, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 225080, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1028186272, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 371649, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1633370682, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 295286, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 39864562, "child_limit_applications": 40753, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 40753, "child_cap_hits": 40753, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 40753, "child_moves_before_total": 3313841, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3313841, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 480970, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 480970, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.31526513385518, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.802075920791108, "tt_hits": 22608, "tt_cutoffs": 2933, "beta_cutoffs": 31536, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 4.923076923076923, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 4.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2811.6153846153848, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3362.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1313, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 810, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16716, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 143, 126, 84, 158, 142, 140, 154, 125, 155, 153, 139, 156, 141, 108, 109, 124, 92, 172 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 16155, "avg_search_time_ms": 1468.6363636363637, "search_nodes": 141209, "safety_nodes": 366, "corridor_nodes": 346, "corridor_branch_probes": 410, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 142, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 341, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 341, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 32, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 27, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 142, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 32, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 272, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 19925440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1965600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 141921, "avg_nodes": 12901.90909090909, "eval_calls": 91003, "avg_eval_calls": 8273.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 91003, "pattern_eval_ns": 2010937, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.09748030284716, "pattern_frame_queries": 91003, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2010937, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.09748030284716, "pattern_frame_updates": 282318, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4481161284, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15872.743799545193, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46327, "avg_candidate_generations": 4211.545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 3461043, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.70898180326807, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 714, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 46316, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3460329, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 1047441, "avg_legality_checks": 95221.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3710, "root_legality_checks": 714, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1046727, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3709, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4148202, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 377109.2727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9564217439, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2305.6296291742783, "renju_forbidden_checks": 63049, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5731.727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 463116229, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7345.338213135815, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 42182350, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34826, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 316244965, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23952, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 104214332, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 54, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 474582, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 96642, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8785.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 922131096, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9541.721984230458, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 135583, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12325.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 405481681, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2990.652817831144, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2720925515, "stage_ordering_ns": 1495910237, "stage_eval_ns": 4483172221, "stage_threat_ns": 7305328211, "stage_proof_ns": 102265956, "tactical_annotations": 689759, "root_tactical_annotations": 2586, "search_tactical_annotations": 687173, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 283075, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1781630282, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 628433, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5231540994, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 92962, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3658936649, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 141532, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 224607596, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 746, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3939256, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 283064, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37976486, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 115361, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 175284629, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 398559, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1336263312, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 175839, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 25633597, "child_limit_applications": 46316, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46316, "child_cap_hits": 46316, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46316, "child_moves_before_total": 3456620, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3456620, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 524907, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 524907, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.63122894895932, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.33316780378271, "tt_hits": 21916, "tt_cutoffs": 3842, "beta_cutoffs": 36424, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 4.363636363636363, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 4.363636363636363, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1347.7272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1884.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 552, "avg_search_time_ms": 55.2, "search_nodes": 35817, "safety_nodes": 968, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 36785, "avg_nodes": 3678.5, "eval_calls": 34391, "avg_eval_calls": 3439.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 34391, "line_shape_eval_ns": 30755449, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 894.287720624582, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1407, "avg_candidate_generations": 140.7, "candidate_moves_total": 94860, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.42004264392324, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 648, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 1397, "search_candidate_moves_total": 94212, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 3195, "avg_legality_checks": 319.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3195, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14828, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1482.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 33793842, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2279.055975182088, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 236870, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11279.52380952381, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 62830, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 174040, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9627721, "stage_ordering_ns": 47550, "stage_eval_ns": 30755449, "stage_threat_ns": 498841830, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 71586, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 439763167, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 236562, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35788, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 49563734, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 71576, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9278367, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 68, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1268, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5901.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6701.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1963, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 811, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19093, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 96, 128, 67, 52, 129, 142, 100, 124, 125, 94, 98, 99, 110, 113, 68, 54, 141, 53, 51, 80, 108, 38, 111, 66 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 683, "avg_search_time_ms": 52.53846153846154, "search_nodes": 39825, "safety_nodes": 1331, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 41156, "avg_nodes": 3165.846153846154, "eval_calls": 38128, "avg_eval_calls": 2932.923076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 38128, "line_shape_eval_ns": 43182149, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1132.5574118757868, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1672, "avg_candidate_generations": 128.6153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 124051, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.19318181818181, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 897, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 1659, "search_candidate_moves_total": 123154, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 33668, "avg_legality_checks": 2589.846153846154, "illegal_moves_skipped": 74, "root_legality_checks": 897, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 32771, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 72, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 49244, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3788.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 116435297, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2364.456522622045, "renju_forbidden_checks": 83, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6.384615384615385, "renju_forbidden_ns": 995443, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11993.289156626506, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 896133, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 99310, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1163437, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11994.19587628866, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.846153846153847, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 631224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4476.765957446809, "stage_move_gen_ns": 86946607, "stage_ordering_ns": 56530, "stage_eval_ns": 43182149, "stage_threat_ns": 534956078, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 79587, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 469420130, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1478669, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14130, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 39787, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 54304710, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 79574, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9752569, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 121, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1473, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6403.307692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7018.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1908, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18396, "avg_search_time_ms": 1415.076923076923, "search_nodes": 132239, "safety_nodes": 391, "corridor_nodes": 1324, "corridor_branch_probes": 1500, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 557, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1311, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1311, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 557, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 50, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 411, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 57692320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 133954, "avg_nodes": 10304.153846153846, "eval_calls": 89819, "avg_eval_calls": 6909.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89819, "pattern_eval_ns": 2012154, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.402320221779355, "pattern_frame_queries": 89819, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2012154, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.402320221779355, "pattern_frame_updates": 264348, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3447857291, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13042.87261866933, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39502, "avg_candidate_generations": 3038.6153846153848, "candidate_moves_total": 3225100, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.64396739405599, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 915, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 39489, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3224185, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 2268457, "avg_legality_checks": 174496.6923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8917, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2268457, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8917, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5405456, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 415804.3076923077, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11902352575, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2201.91461645419, "renju_forbidden_checks": 57836, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4448.923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 436118628, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7540.608409986859, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9251, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 100189471, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25043, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 247196135, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23527, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 88543732, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 189290, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 186324, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14332.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2017047399, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10825.483560893927, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 262520, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20193.846153846152, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1012545948, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3857.0240286454364, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5779400195, "stage_ordering_ns": 1349612739, "stage_eval_ns": 3449869445, "stage_threat_ns": 7647087482, "stage_proof_ns": 80616312, "tactical_annotations": 855404, "root_tactical_annotations": 3253, "search_tactical_annotations": 852151, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 267083, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1714459254, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 728503, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5626935665, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 79907, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3000176577, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 133535, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 214550845, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2722, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15336806, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 267070, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35572458, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 225105, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 995946892, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 344679, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1570688740, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 285620, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 40232454, "child_limit_applications": 39489, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39489, "child_cap_hits": 39489, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39489, "child_moves_before_total": 3215268, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3215268, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 456068, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 456068, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.42186431664514, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.549241560941022, "tt_hits": 22304, "tt_cutoffs": 2866, "beta_cutoffs": 31180, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 4.923076923076923, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 4.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3186.846153846154, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3776.4615384615386, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1460, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 812, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7067, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 96, 111, 128, 80, 127, 142, 98, 95, 113, 143, 99, 100, 141, 85, 155 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6825, "avg_search_time_ms": 853.125, "search_nodes": 68389, "safety_nodes": 64, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68453, "avg_nodes": 8556.625, "eval_calls": 49564, "avg_eval_calls": 6195.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49564, "pattern_eval_ns": 1079955, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.789100960374466, "pattern_frame_queries": 49564, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1079955, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.789100960374466, "pattern_frame_updates": 136712, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2066182511, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15113.395393235414, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17740, "avg_candidate_generations": 2217.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1223805, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.98562570462232, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 438, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 17732, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1223367, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 433735, "avg_legality_checks": 54216.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 503, "root_legality_checks": 438, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 433297, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 503, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1803032, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 225379.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4182538316, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2319.7249499731565, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16956, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2119.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 72321762, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4265.260792639773, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 726, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4952611, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9033, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 50984904, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7197, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16384247, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50735, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6341.875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 477577750, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9413.181235833252, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 69390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8673.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 199539390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2875.621703415478, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1138021659, "stage_ordering_ns": 555359898, "stage_eval_ns": 2067262466, "stage_threat_ns": 3039874459, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 180319, "root_tactical_annotations": 1676, "search_tactical_annotations": 178643, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136720, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 862978743, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 176626, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2048651007, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35512, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1413388536, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68356, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 106049541, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136712, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18295161, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 38626, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 110108775, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 102481, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 525145826, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 39212, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3900007, "child_limit_applications": 17732, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17732, "child_cap_hits": 17732, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17732, "child_moves_before_total": 1222864, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1222864, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 161505, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 161505, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.96368147981052, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.108109632303181, "tt_hits": 7035, "tt_cutoffs": 1060, "beta_cutoffs": 12610, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2873.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3873.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 236, "avg_search_time_ms": 33.714285714285715, "search_nodes": 14570, "safety_nodes": 532, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 15102, "avg_nodes": 2157.4285714285716, "eval_calls": 13633, "avg_eval_calls": 1947.5714285714287, "line_shape_eval_calls": 13633, "line_shape_eval_ns": 9579492, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 702.6694051199296, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 924, "avg_candidate_generations": 132.0, "candidate_moves_total": 55760, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.34632034632035, "candidate_moves_max": 76, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 374, "root_candidate_moves_max": 60, "search_candidate_generations": 917, "search_candidate_moves_total": 55386, "search_candidate_moves_max": 76, "legality_checks": 2160, "avg_legality_checks": 308.57142857142856, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2160, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10204, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1457.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23332808, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2286.6334770678163, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6544558, "stage_ordering_ns": 31640, "stage_eval_ns": 9579492, "stage_threat_ns": 210304719, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 29107, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 185979384, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 195980, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7780, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 14550, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 20333925, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 29100, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 3795430, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 55, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 815, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5047.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6189.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1876, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 813, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 37397, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 97, 82, 114, 115, 68, 126, 94, 81, 125, 83, 80, 99, 67, 70, 84, 100, 139, 153, 85, 101, 98, 87, 129, 103, 102, 131, 147, 145, 117, 146, 132, 162, 116, 71, 55, 73, 59, 72, 69, 74 ], "move_count": 46, "black_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 3001, "avg_search_time_ms": 142.9047619047619, "search_nodes": 193126, "safety_nodes": 2450, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 195576, "avg_nodes": 9313.142857142857, "eval_calls": 187513, "avg_eval_calls": 8929.190476190477, "line_shape_eval_calls": 187513, "line_shape_eval_ns": 197805858, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1054.8914368603778, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5572, "avg_candidate_generations": 265.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 444763, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.82106963388371, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1690, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 5551, "search_candidate_moves_total": 443073, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 181851, "avg_legality_checks": 8659.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1845, "root_legality_checks": 1690, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "search_legality_checks": 180161, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1830, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 206351, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9826.238095238095, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 462387264, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2240.7803402939653, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1905, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 90.71428571428571, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19337372, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10150.851443569554, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1845, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18778020, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 559352, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 87, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 846724, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9732.459770114943, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 111, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.285714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 433992, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3909.837837837838, "stage_move_gen_ns": 449232049, "stage_ordering_ns": 178920, "stage_eval_ns": 197805858, "stage_threat_ns": 2324542952, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 386149, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2036751254, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1236214, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19580, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 193064, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 242368866, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 386128, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44186618, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 285, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5079, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 2.9523809523809526, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9523809523809526, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6918.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7299.238095238095, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1902, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 34375, "avg_search_time_ms": 1636.904761904762, "search_nodes": 290661, "safety_nodes": 562, "corridor_nodes": 3112, "corridor_branch_probes": 3352, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 906, "corridor_neutral_exits": 129, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 3086, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3086, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 129, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 906, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 72, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 568, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 83369040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 294335, "avg_nodes": 14015.952380952382, "eval_calls": 196065, "avg_eval_calls": 9336.42857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 196065, "pattern_eval_ns": 4014723, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.47648993956086, "pattern_frame_queries": 196065, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4014723, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.47648993956086, "pattern_frame_updates": 581114, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4659404628, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8018.056057847513, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 88990, "avg_candidate_generations": 4237.619047619048, "candidate_moves_total": 8401316, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.40741656365884, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1713, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 88969, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8399603, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 6153840, "avg_legality_checks": 293040.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 40214, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6153840, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 40214, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11635098, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 554052.2857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22222113308, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1909.9205961135867, "renju_forbidden_checks": 93332, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4444.380952380952, "renju_forbidden_ns": 587741135, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6297.316408091544, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 40264, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 382115576, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15183, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 126799358, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37709, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 77034617, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 176, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1791584, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 344870, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16422.380952380954, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2973257286, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8621.385698959028, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 462931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22044.333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1405576219, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3036.2542560338366, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13440840045, "stage_ordering_ns": 2921268373, "stage_eval_ns": 4663419351, "stage_threat_ns": 13018935464, "stage_proof_ns": 99973680, "tactical_annotations": 1687169, "root_tactical_annotations": 6710, "search_tactical_annotations": 1680459, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 587451, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3146710542, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1638019, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9305963532, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 180354, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5212137651, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 293715, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 406692278, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6316, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 32875193, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 587430, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66204809, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 572321, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1587354102, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 663706, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2342426984, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 451142, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 60489110, "child_limit_applications": 88969, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 88969, "child_cap_hits": 88969, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 88969, "child_moves_before_total": 8359389, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8359389, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 840100, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 840100, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.95844620036192, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.44261484337241, "tt_hits": 46278, "tt_cutoffs": 5526, "beta_cutoffs": 69520, "depth_sum": 100, "avg_depth": 4.761904761904762, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 100, "avg_effective_depth": 4.761904761904762, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.19047619047619047, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.19047619047619047, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2782.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3150.809523809524, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 268, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 814, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 35053, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 82, 124, 114, 98, 140, 125, 127, 139, 97, 109, 68, 54, 94, 70, 84, 93, 141, 123, 122, 108, 143, 144, 78, 86, 62, 46, 38, 107, 155, 61, 77, 91, 75, 76, 106, 31 ], "move_count": 43, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 34112, "avg_search_time_ms": 1705.6, "search_nodes": 354447, "safety_nodes": 461, "corridor_nodes": 10470, "corridor_branch_probes": 10753, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 5779, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 10439, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 10439, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 31, "corridor_proof_quiet": 52, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5779, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 83, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 2, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 618, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 85248480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 365378, "avg_nodes": 18268.9, "eval_calls": 232842, "avg_eval_calls": 11642.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 232842, "pattern_eval_ns": 4786382, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.556351517337937, "pattern_frame_queries": 232842, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4786382, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.556351517337937, "pattern_frame_updates": 708700, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7973497610, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11250.878524058135, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 112668, "avg_candidate_generations": 5633.4, "candidate_moves_total": 10418246, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.46854475094969, "candidate_moves_max": 148, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1600, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 112648, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10416646, "search_candidate_moves_max": 148, "legality_checks": 2519936, "avg_legality_checks": 125996.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8361, "root_legality_checks": 1600, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 2518336, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8351, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10672189, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 533609.45, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19854036367, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1860.3527698956607, "renju_forbidden_checks": 100254, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5012.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 276618487, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2759.1765615337044, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8830, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 27654136, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 51848, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 171456253, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 38820, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 74095443, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 756, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3412655, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 322625, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16131.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2484760771, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7701.699406431616, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 427225, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21361.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1072888017, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2511.2950248697994, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5439695964, "stage_ordering_ns": 3544589325, "stage_eval_ns": 7978283992, "stage_threat_ns": 16144142535, "stage_proof_ns": 890465650, "tactical_annotations": 2559320, "root_tactical_annotations": 6160, "search_tactical_annotations": 2553160, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 729764, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3947369874, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2551239, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11393016291, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 230152, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6641312653, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 364872, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 512868652, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 21044, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 110194440, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 729744, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 83169516, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 824526, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 844726436, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1022493, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2784107468, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 712301, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 97523762, "child_limit_applications": 112648, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 112648, "child_cap_hits": 112648, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 112648, "child_moves_before_total": 10408295, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10408295, "child_moves_before_max": 148, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 148, "child_moves_after_total": 1324710, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1324710, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 92.39662488459626, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.759729422626235, "tt_hits": 62364, "tt_cutoffs": 8860, "beta_cutoffs": 93091, "depth_sum": 93, "avg_depth": 4.65, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 93, "avg_effective_depth": 4.65, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.45, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1488.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1787.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 919, "avg_search_time_ms": 48.36842105263158, "search_nodes": 67505, "safety_nodes": 2310, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 69815, "avg_nodes": 3674.4736842105262, "eval_calls": 64080, "avg_eval_calls": 3372.6315789473683, "line_shape_eval_calls": 64080, "line_shape_eval_ns": 73839809, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1152.3066323345818, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3388, "avg_candidate_generations": 178.31578947368422, "candidate_moves_total": 269268, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.47697756788666, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1518, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 3369, "search_candidate_moves_total": 267750, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 7727, "avg_legality_checks": 406.6842105263158, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7727, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29559, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1555.7368421052631, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 58806213, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1989.4520450624175, "renju_forbidden_checks": 61, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.210526315789474, "renju_forbidden_ns": 167680, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2748.8524590163934, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 78350, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 89330, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20213278, "stage_ordering_ns": 105251, "stage_eval_ns": 73839809, "stage_threat_ns": 802744969, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 134917, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 704866883, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 508083, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67449, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 82303978, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 134898, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15066025, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 148, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3087, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6891.8421052631575, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7312.894736842105, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 815, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14166, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 111, 110, 142, 157, 68, 98, 66, 138, 124, 80, 83, 130, 146, 125, 69, 55, 67, 65, 70 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2804, "avg_search_time_ms": 254.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 171081, "safety_nodes": 1009, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 172090, "avg_nodes": 15644.545454545454, "eval_calls": 166953, "avg_eval_calls": 15177.545454545454, "line_shape_eval_calls": 166953, "line_shape_eval_ns": 129943135, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 778.3216533994597, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4108, "avg_candidate_generations": 373.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 296948, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.28529698149951, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 822, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 4097, "search_candidate_moves_total": 296126, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 162868, "avg_legality_checks": 14806.181818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 422, "root_legality_checks": 822, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 162046, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 419, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 176017, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16001.545454545454, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 440945697, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2505.1313054989005, "renju_forbidden_checks": 437, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 39.72727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5350931, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 12244.693363844393, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 422, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5194500, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 156431, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.4545454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 450693, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11860.342105263158, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 55, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 217932, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3962.4, "stage_move_gen_ns": 429185030, "stage_ordering_ns": 135410, "stage_eval_ns": 129943135, "stage_threat_ns": 2230836793, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 342111, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1961993691, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 610733, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11150, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 171050, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 225814885, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 342100, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42417484, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 194, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3760, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5629.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6356.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1915, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11352, "avg_search_time_ms": 1135.2, "search_nodes": 75135, "safety_nodes": 688, "corridor_nodes": 168, "corridor_branch_probes": 195, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 20, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 159, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 159, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 22, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 13, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 22, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 149, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 27894480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 75991, "avg_nodes": 7599.1, "eval_calls": 45767, "avg_eval_calls": 4576.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 45767, "pattern_eval_ns": 990536, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.64301789498984, "pattern_frame_queries": 45767, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 990536, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.64301789498984, "pattern_frame_updates": 150174, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1541343482, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10263.717301263867, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26953, "avg_candidate_generations": 2695.3, "candidate_moves_total": 2276157, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.44911512633102, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 739, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 26943, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2275418, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1543175, "avg_legality_checks": 154317.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5784, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1543175, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5784, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3529709, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 352970.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7533734989, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2134.378496640941, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33039, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3303.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 166517683, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5040.033990132873, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5786, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 64918095, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6267, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62567046, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20971, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 38848280, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 184262, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 145950, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14595.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1487022603, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10188.57556012333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 211823, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21182.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 721940037, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3408.2230777583172, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3862850673, "stage_ordering_ns": 953496322, "stage_eval_ns": 1542334018, "stage_threat_ns": 4890209674, "stage_proof_ns": 37793359, "tactical_annotations": 376578, "root_tactical_annotations": 1698, "search_tactical_annotations": 374880, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 150546, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 921659477, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 371440, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3825226337, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54149, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1957277492, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75268, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113235288, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 362, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1768748, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 150536, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18886933, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 66711, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 409864676, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 235018, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1446679809, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 74849, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9432891, "child_limit_applications": 26943, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26943, "child_cap_hits": 26943, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26943, "child_moves_before_total": 2269634, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2269634, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 267579, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 267579, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.23835504583751, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.931299409865272, "tt_hits": 11483, "tt_cutoffs": 2378, "beta_cutoffs": 21198, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3145.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3945.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1175, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 816, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12491, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 98, 68, 54, 81, 111, 83, 84, 80, 79, 110, 124, 95, 70, 126, 56 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8904, "avg_search_time_ms": 989.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 76330, "safety_nodes": 569, "corridor_nodes": 775, "corridor_branch_probes": 985, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 344, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 769, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 769, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 25, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 344, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 25, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 25, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 157, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4109280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2029600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 77674, "avg_nodes": 8630.444444444445, "eval_calls": 47590, "avg_eval_calls": 5287.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47590, "pattern_eval_ns": 1046956, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.999495692372346, "pattern_frame_queries": 47590, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1046956, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.999495692372346, "pattern_frame_updates": 152574, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1840201219, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12061.040668790227, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26724, "avg_candidate_generations": 2969.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 1958713, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.29415506660679, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 545, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 26715, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1958168, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 705134, "avg_legality_checks": 78348.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1061, "root_legality_checks": 545, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 704589, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1061, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2390173, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 265574.77777777775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5473910509, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2290.1733510503213, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16867, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1874.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 100001691, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5928.836841169147, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1127, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11764952, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6931, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 61095865, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8646, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25565082, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 163, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1575792, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 61739, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6859.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 592279756, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9593.283921022368, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86542, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9615.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 262144007, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3029.0957800836586, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1835448049, "stage_ordering_ns": 852503349, "stage_eval_ns": 1841248175, "stage_threat_ns": 4207161674, "stage_proof_ns": 128944003, "tactical_annotations": 335405, "root_tactical_annotations": 1068, "search_tactical_annotations": 334337, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 154171, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 959804812, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 322181, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3085955405, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53840, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2125128773, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77081, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 117008905, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1588, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8750179, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 154162, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20301813, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44777, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 81090194, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 179079, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 752771969, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 111549, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15340560, "child_limit_applications": 26715, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26715, "child_cap_hits": 26715, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26715, "child_moves_before_total": 1957107, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1957107, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 249224, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 249224, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.25873104997193, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.328991203443758, "tt_hits": 13837, "tt_cutoffs": 1982, "beta_cutoffs": 20792, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2239.222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3128.1111111111113, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 3579, "avg_search_time_ms": 447.375, "search_nodes": 262408, "safety_nodes": 547, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 262955, "avg_nodes": 32869.375, "eval_calls": 256184, "avg_eval_calls": 32023.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 256184, "line_shape_eval_ns": 222969601, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 870.3494402460732, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6209, "avg_candidate_generations": 776.125, "candidate_moves_total": 441016, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.02850700595909, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 489, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 6201, "search_candidate_moves_total": 440527, "search_candidate_moves_max": 89, "legality_checks": 11595, "avg_legality_checks": 1449.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11595, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20855, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2606.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 50515643, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2422.2317429872933, "renju_forbidden_checks": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 0, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 0.0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 34045723, "stage_ordering_ns": 197381, "stage_eval_ns": 222969601, "stage_threat_ns": 3305425586, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 524778, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2900553930, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 240821, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 262385, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 341236367, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 524770, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63394468, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 191, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5760, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4630.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5630.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 817, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18416, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 98, 126, 67, 52, 125, 142, 94, 130, 129, 100, 96, 95, 114, 111, 66, 50, 143, 51, 53, 84, 116, 36, 113, 68 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 673, "avg_search_time_ms": 51.76923076923077, "search_nodes": 41474, "safety_nodes": 1331, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 42805, "avg_nodes": 3292.6923076923076, "eval_calls": 39728, "avg_eval_calls": 3056.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 39728, "line_shape_eval_ns": 42373286, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1066.584927507048, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1721, "avg_candidate_generations": 132.3846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 127867, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.29808251016851, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 897, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 1708, "search_candidate_moves_total": 126970, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 35286, "avg_legality_checks": 2714.3076923076924, "illegal_moves_skipped": 110, "root_legality_checks": 897, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 34389, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 108, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 50862, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3912.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 114421963, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2249.655204278243, "renju_forbidden_checks": 119, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9.153846153846153, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1388648, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11669.310924369747, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 110, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1297808, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 90840, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1098117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11320.79381443299, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10.846153846153847, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 598922, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4247.673758865249, "stage_move_gen_ns": 87282037, "stage_ordering_ns": 55770, "stage_eval_ns": 42373286, "stage_threat_ns": 522747847, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 82885, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 459172480, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1389977, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 41436, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 52557597, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 82872, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9627793, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 121, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1519, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6406.307692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7021.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1911, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 17733, "avg_search_time_ms": 1364.076923076923, "search_nodes": 147438, "safety_nodes": 391, "corridor_nodes": 1223, "corridor_branch_probes": 1381, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 510, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1210, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1210, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 510, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 50, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 411, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 53623920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 149052, "avg_nodes": 11465.538461538461, "eval_calls": 103136, "avg_eval_calls": 7933.538461538462, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 103136, "pattern_eval_ns": 2142031, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.768994337573687, "pattern_frame_queries": 103136, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2142031, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.768994337573687, "pattern_frame_updates": 294746, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3661896390, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12423.905294728342, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41367, "avg_candidate_generations": 3182.076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 3373736, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.55621630768486, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 915, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 41354, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3372821, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 2297586, "avg_legality_checks": 176737.38461538462, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13496, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2297586, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13496, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5666065, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 435851.1538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11183017108, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1973.6831660067437, "renju_forbidden_checks": 79171, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6090.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 574563087, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7257.241755188137, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 13828, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 138109998, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 32456, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 316056864, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32872, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 120218794, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 177431, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 195110, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15008.461538461539, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1899825604, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9737.20262416073, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 273683, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21052.53846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 958317966, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3501.5619019084124, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5269020141, "stage_ordering_ns": 1260279484, "stage_eval_ns": 3664038421, "stage_threat_ns": 7374425035, "stage_proof_ns": 76756273, "tactical_annotations": 912925, "root_tactical_annotations": 3253, "search_tactical_annotations": 909672, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 297279, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1746809350, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 768559, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5322075221, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 83598, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2823893027, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148633, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 217024826, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2520, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13249137, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 297266, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36379451, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 231318, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 944461893, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 380398, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1501592784, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 301209, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 38887050, "child_limit_applications": 41354, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41354, "child_cap_hits": 41354, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41354, "child_moves_before_total": 3359325, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3359325, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 491881, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 491881, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.23337524785994, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.894399574406345, "tt_hits": 22867, "tt_cutoffs": 2884, "beta_cutoffs": 31908, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 4.923076923076923, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 4.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3571.5384615384614, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4186.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1563, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 818, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32391, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 127, 142, 126, 114, 156, 82, 98, 140, 141, 111, 155, 113, 171, 186, 157, 100, 86, 158, 173, 125, 139, 95, 80, 187, 172, 170, 185, 143, 169, 183, 154, 153, 124, 109, 184 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 31360, "avg_search_time_ms": 1742.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 331092, "safety_nodes": 359, "corridor_nodes": 2417, "corridor_branch_probes": 2605, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1113, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 21, "corridor_plies_followed": 2402, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2402, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1113, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 21, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 55, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 424, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 57582640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2025680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 333868, "avg_nodes": 18548.222222222223, "eval_calls": 224901, "avg_eval_calls": 12494.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 224901, "pattern_eval_ns": 4656994, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.70686213044851, "pattern_frame_queries": 224901, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4656994, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.70686213044851, "pattern_frame_updates": 661986, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7962204829, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12027.754105071708, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 99983, "avg_candidate_generations": 5554.611111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 8686935, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.88412030045107, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1329, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 99965, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8685606, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 2157289, "avg_legality_checks": 119849.38888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2785, "root_legality_checks": 1329, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 2155960, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2783, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8904457, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 494692.05555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18015703341, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2023.2231275865558, "renju_forbidden_checks": 71953, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3997.3888888888887, "renju_forbidden_ns": 258425513, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3591.587744777841, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3322, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22031228, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 35959, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 160487247, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32270, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 74004254, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 402, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1902784, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 271920, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15106.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2121932005, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7803.515758311268, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 354942, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19719.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 868225806, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2446.106141285055, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5044861293, "stage_ordering_ns": 3321826734, "stage_eval_ns": 7966861823, "stage_threat_ns": 14585888595, "stage_proof_ns": 336653839, "tactical_annotations": 2103591, "root_tactical_annotations": 5759, "search_tactical_annotations": 2097832, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 666918, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3713382400, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1936057, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10210771843, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 201372, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6410042934, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 333450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 485175401, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4914, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26894365, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 666900, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 81037604, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 611478, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 765737126, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 990151, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2692752631, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 501962, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 68626982, "child_limit_applications": 99965, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 99965, "child_cap_hits": 99965, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 99965, "child_moves_before_total": 8682823, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8682823, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 1013981, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1013981, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.85863052068224, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.143360176061622, "tt_hits": 47652, "tt_cutoffs": 6130, "beta_cutoffs": 81034, "depth_sum": 95, "avg_depth": 5.277777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 95, "avg_effective_depth": 5.277777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3888888888888889, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1166.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1431.2222222222222, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 1017, "avg_search_time_ms": 59.8235294117647, "search_nodes": 72148, "safety_nodes": 1941, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 74089, "avg_nodes": 4358.176470588235, "eval_calls": 68750, "avg_eval_calls": 4044.1176470588234, "line_shape_eval_calls": 68750, "line_shape_eval_ns": 67121211, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 976.3085236363636, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3365, "avg_candidate_generations": 197.94117647058823, "candidate_moves_total": 254433, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.61158989598812, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1257, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 3348, "search_candidate_moves_total": 253176, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 6375, "avg_legality_checks": 375.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6375, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 25885, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1522.6470588235295, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 54443845, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2103.297083252849, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.411764705882353, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124901, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5204.208333333333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 48180, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 76721, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17961962, "stage_ordering_ns": 102810, "stage_eval_ns": 67121211, "stage_threat_ns": 911160760, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 144213, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 800478364, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 47, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 487861, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72098, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92983218, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 144196, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17211317, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 143, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3066, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6739.588235294118, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7210.176470588235, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 819, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 31251, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 127, 142, 114, 115, 94, 96, 68, 124, 138, 122, 95, 143, 83, 125, 123, 98, 109, 137, 93, 108, 67, 81, 79, 63, 66, 65, 99, 158, 174, 141, 69, 70, 84, 54, 129 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 9491, "avg_search_time_ms": 499.5263157894737, "search_nodes": 610387, "safety_nodes": 1078, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 611465, "avg_nodes": 32182.36842105263, "eval_calls": 593989, "avg_eval_calls": 31262.57894736842, "line_shape_eval_calls": 593989, "line_shape_eval_ns": 908267940, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1529.0989227073228, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16362, "avg_candidate_generations": 861.1578947368421, "candidate_moves_total": 1456628, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.02505806136169, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1478, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 16343, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1455150, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 576288, "avg_legality_checks": 30330.947368421053, "illegal_moves_skipped": 759, "root_legality_checks": 1478, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 574810, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 757, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 598240, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 31486.315789473683, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1350610162, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2257.639345413212, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1183, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 62.26315789473684, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10316727, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8720.817413355875, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1170, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10220965, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 95762, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.736842105263158, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 458093, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8809.48076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.5789473684210527, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 196821, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2894.426470588235, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1356420843, "stage_ordering_ns": 510721, "stage_eval_ns": 908267940, "stage_threat_ns": 7171881077, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1220683, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6256826515, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 669283, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 610332, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 775165255, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1220664, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 139220024, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 797, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 14617, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6757.631578947368, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7178.684210526316, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1892, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 21744, "avg_search_time_ms": 1208.0, "search_nodes": 159068, "safety_nodes": 1840, "corridor_nodes": 3151, "corridor_branch_probes": 3903, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 66, "corridor_depth_exits": 1365, "corridor_neutral_exits": 34, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 3125, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3125, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 29, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 100, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1365, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 55, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 250, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 41951440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 164059, "avg_nodes": 9114.388888888889, "eval_calls": 94929, "avg_eval_calls": 5273.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 94929, "pattern_eval_ns": 1999956, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.067913914609868, "pattern_frame_queries": 94929, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1999956, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.067913914609868, "pattern_frame_updates": 317928, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3415949500, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10744.412256863188, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 56266, "avg_candidate_generations": 3125.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 5023406, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.27960046919988, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1405, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 56248, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5022001, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 2955573, "avg_legality_checks": 164198.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1807, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2955573, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1807, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6928958, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 384942.1111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13872806202, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2002.148981419717, "renju_forbidden_checks": 64544, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3585.777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 188358152, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2918.290654437283, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4215, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25556306, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15747, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 90154369, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 44529, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 72279307, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 53, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 368170, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 262383, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14576.833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2369768198, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9031.713937259654, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 360311, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20017.277777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1081085670, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3000.4237172886756, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6759360625, "stage_ordering_ns": 1931533788, "stage_eval_ns": 3417949456, "stage_threat_ns": 9457888096, "stage_proof_ns": 64248447, "tactical_annotations": 1153882, "root_tactical_annotations": 1957, "search_tactical_annotations": 1151925, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 324306, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1953173181, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1181827, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7152788310, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 113972, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3689663470, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 162144, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 241549084, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6360, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 39898753, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 324288, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40020223, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 219100, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 605157096, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 682686, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2726493482, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 252096, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30458545, "child_limit_applications": 56248, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 56248, "child_cap_hits": 56248, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 56248, "child_moves_before_total": 5020194, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5020194, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 651073, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 651073, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.25106670459394, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.575042668183757, "tt_hits": 27178, "tt_cutoffs": 7789, "beta_cutoffs": 46042, "depth_sum": 102, "avg_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 102, "avg_effective_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4008.9444444444443, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4453.388888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1112, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 820, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16355, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 141, 128, 80, 156, 142, 144, 160, 129, 159, 161, 145, 158, 143, 116, 115, 130, 102, 172 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 15839, "avg_search_time_ms": 1439.909090909091, "search_nodes": 147002, "safety_nodes": 366, "corridor_nodes": 344, "corridor_branch_probes": 409, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 142, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 340, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 340, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 32, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 28, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 142, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 32, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 272, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 19903520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1966880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 147712, "avg_nodes": 13428.363636363636, "eval_calls": 94826, "avg_eval_calls": 8620.545454545454, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 94826, "pattern_eval_ns": 1960490, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.67460401155801, "pattern_frame_queries": 94826, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1960490, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.67460401155801, "pattern_frame_updates": 293904, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4403123357, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14981.501976835974, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 48026, "avg_candidate_generations": 4366.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3618880, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.3525173864157, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 714, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 48015, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3618166, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 1088077, "avg_legality_checks": 98916.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3783, "root_legality_checks": 714, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1087363, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3782, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4305268, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 391388.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9379107774, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2178.5189154310488, "renju_forbidden_checks": 66780, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6070.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 459577800, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6881.967654986523, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4311, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 40934919, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37114, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 314469737, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25301, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 103730434, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 54, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 442710, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 101827, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9257.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 916895702, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9004.445795319512, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 142619, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12965.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 401841915, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2817.5903280769044, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2662932941, "stage_ordering_ns": 1474244867, "stage_eval_ns": 4405083847, "stage_threat_ns": 7147052581, "stage_proof_ns": 95972043, "tactical_annotations": 719992, "root_tactical_annotations": 2586, "search_tactical_annotations": 717406, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 294659, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1750501501, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 653283, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5110889528, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 96360, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3564954998, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147324, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 218267531, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 744, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3616537, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 294648, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37066160, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 121734, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 180678790, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 413853, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1308031793, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 184405, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26711324, "child_limit_applications": 48015, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 48015, "child_cap_hits": 48015, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 48015, "child_moves_before_total": 3614384, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3614384, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 547312, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 547312, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.27614287201916, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.39877121732792, "tt_hits": 22782, "tt_cutoffs": 4112, "beta_cutoffs": 37893, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 4.363636363636363, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 4.363636363636363, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1574.3636363636363, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2138.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 306, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 506, "avg_search_time_ms": 50.6, "search_nodes": 34920, "safety_nodes": 968, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35888, "avg_nodes": 3588.8, "eval_calls": 33495, "avg_eval_calls": 3349.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 33495, "line_shape_eval_ns": 28176267, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 841.2081504702194, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1406, "avg_candidate_generations": 140.6, "candidate_moves_total": 94807, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.43029871977241, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 648, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 1396, "search_candidate_moves_total": 94159, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 3031, "avg_legality_checks": 303.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3031, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14664, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1466.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31399227, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2141.2457037643208, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 225341, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10730.52380952381, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 59911, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 165430, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8579098, "stage_ordering_ns": 44900, "stage_eval_ns": 28176267, "stage_threat_ns": 457049678, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 69792, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 403157814, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 225441, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34891, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 45099316, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 69782, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8567107, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 68, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1267, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5910.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6710.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1966, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 821, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17530, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 96, 128, 109, 108, 143, 114, 100, 156, 170, 124, 140, 83, 68, 82, 125, 155, 95, 80, 127, 79, 159 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 1314, "avg_search_time_ms": 109.5, "search_nodes": 80432, "safety_nodes": 1235, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 81667, "avg_nodes": 6805.583333333333, "eval_calls": 77906, "avg_eval_calls": 6492.166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 77906, "line_shape_eval_ns": 64773036, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 831.4255127974739, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2504, "avg_candidate_generations": 208.66666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 176773, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.59624600638978, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 844, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 2492, "search_candidate_moves_total": 175929, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 76502, "avg_legality_checks": 6375.166666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 844, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 75658, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 90858, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7571.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 219694895, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2418.0027625525545, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3.3333333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 374531, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9363.275, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 177960, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 196571, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 870502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11453.973684210527, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.833333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 479112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4060.271186440678, "stage_move_gen_ns": 196165874, "stage_ordering_ns": 77010, "stage_eval_ns": 64773036, "stage_threat_ns": 1039355426, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 160808, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 913015111, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1147144, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12010, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 80398, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105659365, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 160796, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19533806, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 121, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2256, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6113.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6779.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1899, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 16204, "avg_search_time_ms": 1473.090909090909, "search_nodes": 107074, "safety_nodes": 406, "corridor_nodes": 126, "corridor_branch_probes": 146, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 50, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 123, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 123, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 18, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 15, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 50, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 18, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 18, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 139, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 25751040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1984160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 107606, "avg_nodes": 9782.363636363636, "eval_calls": 68508, "avg_eval_calls": 6228.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68508, "pattern_eval_ns": 1453488, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.216325100718166, "pattern_frame_queries": 68508, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1453488, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.216325100718166, "pattern_frame_updates": 214034, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2756284863, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12877.789804423595, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35334, "avg_candidate_generations": 3212.181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 3011165, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.22004301805626, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 780, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 35323, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3010385, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 2168791, "avg_legality_checks": 197162.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10308, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2168791, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10308, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5172149, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 470195.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10659570905, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2060.9558821681276, "renju_forbidden_checks": 71218, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6474.363636363636, "renju_forbidden_ns": 366025105, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5139.502724030442, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11208, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 115810815, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18456, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 160950435, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 41534, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 89040733, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 223122, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 212871, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19351.909090909092, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2186490109, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10271.432506071753, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 310905, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 28264.090909090908, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1107615852, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3562.5540020263425, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5252293693, "stage_ordering_ns": 1221899210, "stage_eval_ns": 2757738351, "stage_threat_ns": 6861202872, "stage_proof_ns": 30285086, "tactical_annotations": 724390, "root_tactical_annotations": 2632, "search_tactical_annotations": 721758, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 214327, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1306367229, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 611051, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5340098692, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70852, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2578070144, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 107158, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 160873526, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 282, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1276267, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 214316, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27401330, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 156134, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 639284457, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 375971, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2116151456, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 192285, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 25185828, "child_limit_applications": 35323, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35323, "child_cap_hits": 35323, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35323, "child_moves_before_total": 3000077, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3000077, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 416764, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 416764, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.93267842482236, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.798658098123036, "tt_hits": 17670, "tt_cutoffs": 3188, "beta_cutoffs": 28160, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.909090909090909, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2485.5454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3016.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 822, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 49174, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 113, 114, 128, 82, 66, 110, 127, 96, 68, 97, 95, 99, 100, 124, 138, 143, 84, 52, 67, 65, 81, 109, 70, 69, 85, 115, 53, 39, 55, 40, 79, 63, 116, 132, 87, 130, 146, 86, 131, 101, 141, 129, 157, 126, 158, 94, 78, 37, 155, 169, 156, 154, 159 ], "move_count": 57, "black_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 41303, "avg_search_time_ms": 1529.7407407407406, "search_nodes": 377754, "safety_nodes": 1567, "corridor_nodes": 13219, "corridor_branch_probes": 13986, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 6595, "corridor_neutral_exits": 30, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 13170, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 13170, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 128, "corridor_proof_active": 49, "corridor_proof_quiet": 79, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 6595, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 128, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 128, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 990, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 34035280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2033680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 392540, "avg_nodes": 14538.518518518518, "eval_calls": 230132, "avg_eval_calls": 8523.407407407407, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 230132, "pattern_eval_ns": 4755362, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.663627830983955, "pattern_frame_queries": 230132, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4755362, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.663627830983955, "pattern_frame_updates": 755174, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8250465178, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10925.250575364089, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 135679, "avg_candidate_generations": 5025.148148148148, "candidate_moves_total": 12793459, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.29210857980969, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2321, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 135652, "search_candidate_moves_total": 12791138, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 3917550, "avg_legality_checks": 145094.44444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7643, "root_legality_checks": 2321, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 3915229, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7642, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12867184, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 476562.3703703704, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24489713600, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1903.2690913567412, "renju_forbidden_checks": 101799, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3770.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 392425075, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3854.9010795783847, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9445, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 69300890, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 36246, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 205648700, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 50611, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 108230221, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5497, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9245264, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 323164, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11969.037037037036, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2529904399, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7828.546493421297, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 449259, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16639.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1137875174, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2532.7821457110485, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8286078847, "stage_ordering_ns": 4157807275, "stage_eval_ns": 8255220540, "stage_threat_ns": 19194139364, "stage_proof_ns": 1238910787, "tactical_annotations": 3342459, "root_tactical_annotations": 8536, "search_tactical_annotations": 3333923, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 781797, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4540704300, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3343441, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 13702460216, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 278022, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8117066429, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 390885, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 559590998, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 26596, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 182881121, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 781770, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 92261032, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1075499, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 660576672, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1354150, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3467589504, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 912810, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 116241697, "child_limit_applications": 135652, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 135652, "child_cap_hits": 135652, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 135652, "child_moves_before_total": 12783496, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 12783496, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 1639211, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1639211, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 94.23743107362958, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.08394273582402, "tt_hits": 75965, "tt_cutoffs": 11806, "beta_cutoffs": 110410, "depth_sum": 161, "avg_depth": 5.962962962962963, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 161, "avg_effective_depth": 5.962962962962963, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2993.5925925925926, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3289.8888888888887, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 28, "search_move_count": 26, "total_time_ms": 7845, "avg_search_time_ms": 301.7307692307692, "search_nodes": 783721, "safety_nodes": 2460, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 786181, "avg_nodes": 30237.73076923077, "eval_calls": 768441, "avg_eval_calls": 29555.423076923078, "line_shape_eval_calls": 768441, "line_shape_eval_ns": 1151298112, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1498.225774002168, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15229, "avg_candidate_generations": 585.7307692307693, "candidate_moves_total": 1485059, "avg_candidate_moves": 97.5152012607525, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 26, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2239, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 15203, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1482820, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 31704, "avg_legality_checks": 1219.3846153846155, "illegal_moves_skipped": 111, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 31704, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 60827, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2339.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 107110177, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1760.8985647820869, "renju_forbidden_checks": 119, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4.576923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1424086, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11967.10924369748, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 111, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1329346, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 94740, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 67995516, "stage_ordering_ns": 464584, "stage_eval_ns": 1151298112, "stage_threat_ns": 6481835748, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1567314, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5622947478, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 71, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 442050, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 23010, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 783644, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 722270700, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1567288, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 136175520, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 718, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 13931, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 2.9615384615384617, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9615384615384617, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 25 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 26, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.038461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7048.038461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7355.7307692307695, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 823, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8382, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 82, 111, 143, 98, 142, 95, 96, 84, 126, 125, 158, 173, 110, 174, 94 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1452, "avg_search_time_ms": 181.5, "search_nodes": 129812, "safety_nodes": 221, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 130033, "avg_nodes": 16254.125, "eval_calls": 125841, "avg_eval_calls": 15730.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 125841, "line_shape_eval_ns": 62266356, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 494.8018213459842, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3956, "avg_candidate_generations": 494.5, "candidate_moves_total": 239067, "avg_candidate_moves": 60.43149646107179, "candidate_moves_max": 86, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 404, "root_candidate_moves_max": 65, "search_candidate_generations": 3948, "search_candidate_moves_total": 238663, "search_candidate_moves_max": 86, "legality_checks": 120480, "avg_legality_checks": 15060.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "root_legality_checks": 404, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 120076, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 129468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16183.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 229903104, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1775.7523403466494, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 333260, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6171.481481481482, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 54, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 333260, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 6, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 57040, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9506.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 26430, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3303.75, "stage_move_gen_ns": 225174488, "stage_ordering_ns": 116241, "stage_eval_ns": 62266356, "stage_threat_ns": 1143966654, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 259586, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 998251807, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 100560, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5310, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129789, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 122539000, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 259578, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23075287, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 234, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3557, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5158.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6158.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1967, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6922, "avg_search_time_ms": 865.25, "search_nodes": 81876, "safety_nodes": 598, "corridor_nodes": 1016, "corridor_branch_probes": 1254, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 9, "corridor_depth_exits": 411, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1009, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1009, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 27, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 20, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 411, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 27, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 27, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 164, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 35898960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2012800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 83490, "avg_nodes": 10436.25, "eval_calls": 52768, "avg_eval_calls": 6596.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 52768, "pattern_eval_ns": 998043, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.91379244996968, "pattern_frame_queries": 52768, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 998043, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.91379244996968, "pattern_frame_updates": 163668, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1420005739, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8676.135463254881, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26284, "avg_candidate_generations": 3285.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1762761, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.06593364784659, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 431, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 26276, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1762330, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 1059011, "avg_legality_checks": 132376.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2532, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1059011, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2532, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3133325, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 391665.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4340843845, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1385.3793797323929, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22941, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2867.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 87134512, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3798.2002528224575, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2546, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15105503, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9082, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 55710947, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11313, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16318062, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 123874, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15484.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 793061561, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6402.163173870223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 172339, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21542.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 372996963, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2164.3212679660437, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1718170503, "stage_ordering_ns": 503135166, "stage_eval_ns": 1421003782, "stage_threat_ns": 3201014579, "stage_proof_ns": 33773139, "tactical_annotations": 426071, "root_tactical_annotations": 748, "search_tactical_annotations": 425323, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 165748, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 679157622, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 429457, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2397507911, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53069, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1326273921, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 82870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88802491, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2072, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7108408, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 165740, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15030822, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 66716, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 276451013, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 248847, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 763008449, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110508, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13407325, "child_limit_applications": 26276, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26276, "child_cap_hits": 26276, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26276, "child_moves_before_total": 1759798, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1759798, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 289093, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 289093, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 66.97358806515452, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.002169279951286, "tt_hits": 12275, "tt_cutoffs": 2791, "beta_cutoffs": 20515, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 5.125, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 5.125, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2732.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3732.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 589, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 824, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5002, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 98, 114, 100, 99, 84, 126, 68, 116, 67, 82, 70, 56, 69, 71, 66 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4673, "avg_search_time_ms": 519.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 76524, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 664, "corridor_branch_probes": 762, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 210, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 654, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 654, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 28, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 210, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 284, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 33892000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 77346, "avg_nodes": 8594.0, "eval_calls": 46701, "avg_eval_calls": 5189.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46701, "pattern_eval_ns": 856214, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.333954305047, "pattern_frame_queries": 46701, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 856214, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.333954305047, "pattern_frame_updates": 152962, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1066246110, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6970.660098586577, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28020, "avg_candidate_generations": 3113.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 1946521, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.46898643825838, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 28011, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1946021, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 573891, "avg_legality_checks": 63765.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 183, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 573391, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2179974, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 242219.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2734702794, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1254.46578445431, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22425, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2491.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44237391, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1972.681872909699, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1361, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2616012, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10151, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27831092, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10812, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13522105, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 101, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 268182, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38268, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4252.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 189985513, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4964.605231525034, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 49411, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5490.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 77877943, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1576.1256198012588, "stage_move_gen_ns": 798691459, "stage_ordering_ns": 454258283, "stage_eval_ns": 1067102324, "stage_threat_ns": 2226755034, "stage_proof_ns": 91068107, "tactical_annotations": 393813, "root_tactical_annotations": 1800, "search_tactical_annotations": 392013, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 154355, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 533281754, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 337587, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1588463946, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56568, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1213503777, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77173, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73152121, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1384, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4736498, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 154346, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12294638, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 87656, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 37418455, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 146099, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 269643455, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 160058, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14826077, "child_limit_applications": 28011, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28011, "child_cap_hits": 28011, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28011, "child_moves_before_total": 1945839, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1945839, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 254167, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 254167, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.46695940880369, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.073828138945414, "tt_hits": 16934, "tt_cutoffs": 1769, "beta_cutoffs": 22133, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4733.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5622.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1797, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 320, "avg_search_time_ms": 40.0, "search_nodes": 38593, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 39189, "avg_nodes": 4898.625, "eval_calls": 37236, "avg_eval_calls": 4654.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 37236, "line_shape_eval_ns": 17733674, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 476.2507788161994, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1342, "avg_candidate_generations": 167.75, "candidate_moves_total": 85333, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.58643815201192, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1334, "search_candidate_moves_total": 84886, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 2405, "avg_legality_checks": 300.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2405, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11516, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1439.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14443259, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1254.1906043765196, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44780, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3731.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11210, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 33570, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4232068, "stage_ordering_ns": 37550, "stage_eval_ns": 17733674, "stage_threat_ns": 291335370, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 77148, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 253135143, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 123241, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5020, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 32058189, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 77140, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6018797, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1224, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5445.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6445.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1990, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 825, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15383, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 96, 128, 125, 143, 109, 108, 98, 129, 130, 97, 81, 145, 161, 99, 141, 157, 66, 51, 82, 114, 124, 68, 138 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 620, "avg_search_time_ms": 47.69230769230769, "search_nodes": 62041, "safety_nodes": 1282, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 63323, "avg_nodes": 4871.0, "eval_calls": 59539, "avg_eval_calls": 4579.923076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 59539, "line_shape_eval_ns": 32385046, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 543.9299618737298, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2478, "avg_candidate_generations": 190.6153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 171147, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.06658595641646, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 844, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 2465, "search_candidate_moves_total": 170303, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 57852, "avg_legality_checks": 4450.153846153846, "illegal_moves_skipped": 300, "root_legality_checks": 844, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "search_legality_checks": 57008, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 285, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 73179, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5629.153846153846, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 104496702, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1427.9602344935022, "renju_forbidden_checks": 366, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 28.153846153846153, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2696334, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7367.0327868852455, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 300, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2299511, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 66, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 396823, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 106, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8.153846153846153, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 786613, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7420.877358490566, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 143, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 404612, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2829.4545454545455, "stage_move_gen_ns": 90765212, "stage_ordering_ns": 71990, "stage_eval_ns": 32385046, "stage_threat_ns": 478219526, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 124021, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 414426353, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1010243, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 62004, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 53026497, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 124008, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9756433, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 114, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2235, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6384.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7000.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1961, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 14755, "avg_search_time_ms": 1229.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 181539, "safety_nodes": 543, "corridor_nodes": 2986, "corridor_branch_probes": 3327, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 8, "corridor_depth_exits": 1406, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 2963, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2963, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1406, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 432, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 41637600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1992960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 185068, "avg_nodes": 15422.333333333334, "eval_calls": 123122, "avg_eval_calls": 10260.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 123122, "pattern_eval_ns": 2267378, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.415701499325873, "pattern_frame_queries": 123122, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2267378, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.415701499325873, "pattern_frame_updates": 362960, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3005316961, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8280.022484571302, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52570, "avg_candidate_generations": 4380.833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4202257, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.93640859805973, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 787, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 52558, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4201470, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 2953436, "avg_legality_checks": 246119.66666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 41361, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2953436, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 41361, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7796493, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 649707.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8962010103, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1149.4924837359567, "renju_forbidden_checks": 125168, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10430.666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 528029176, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4218.563658443052, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 41572, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 230825887, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 39391, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 215565789, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 44032, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 80483055, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 173, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1154445, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 330693, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 27557.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1921416913, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5810.273918710102, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 466331, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 38860.916666666664, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 988841937, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2120.4722332420533, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4186996201, "stage_ordering_ns": 983411916, "stage_eval_ns": 3007584339, "stage_threat_ns": 6426338653, "stage_proof_ns": 37008206, "tactical_annotations": 1281338, "root_tactical_annotations": 2161, "search_tactical_annotations": 1279177, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 369010, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1338010283, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1146629, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4801436542, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 106608, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2226696047, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 184499, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 181958410, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6038, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22156615, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 368998, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30006761, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 263815, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 721110757, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 615437, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1779832547, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 402086, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 52770042, "child_limit_applications": 52558, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52558, "child_cap_hits": 52558, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52558, "child_moves_before_total": 4160109, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4160109, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 745041, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 745041, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.1527265116633, "avg_child_moves_after": 14.17559648388447, "tt_hits": 29156, "tt_cutoffs": 5802, "beta_cutoffs": 42762, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3597.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4264.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1735, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 826, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 67839, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 123, 81, 97, 85, 71, 83, 80, 65, 128, 84, 82, 96, 139, 153, 124, 154, 79, 94, 155, 168, 182, 107, 137, 151, 152, 122, 157, 173, 171, 187, 138, 166, 136, 135, 185, 86, 87, 143, 55, 39, 183, 54, 69, 184, 70, 68, 72, 73, 103, 119, 63, 47, 169, 197, 199, 213, 102, 53, 98, 67, 25, 51, 35, 115 ], "move_count": 78, "black_stats": { "move_count": 39, "search_move_count": 37, "total_time_ms": 66360, "avg_search_time_ms": 1793.5135135135135, "search_nodes": 813064, "safety_nodes": 1022, "corridor_nodes": 111168, "corridor_branch_probes": 112833, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 66414, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 32, "corridor_plies_followed": 111054, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 111054, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 22, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 211, "corridor_proof_active": 114, "corridor_proof_quiet": 97, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 66414, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 37, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 32, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 211, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 211, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 8, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1551, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 91813040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 925254, "avg_nodes": 25006.864864864863, "eval_calls": 509483, "avg_eval_calls": 13769.81081081081, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 509483, "pattern_eval_ns": 10037670, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.701677975516358, "pattern_frame_queries": 509483, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 10037670, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.701677975516358, "pattern_frame_updates": 1625678, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 11714467573, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7205.8966000647115, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 283445, "avg_candidate_generations": 7660.675675675676, "candidate_moves_total": 29767312, "avg_candidate_moves": 105.01971105505477, "candidate_moves_max": 137, "root_candidate_generations": 37, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3466, "root_candidate_moves_max": 123, "search_candidate_generations": 283408, "search_candidate_moves_total": 29763846, "search_candidate_moves_max": 137, "legality_checks": 6506537, "avg_legality_checks": 175852.35135135136, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10291, "root_legality_checks": 3466, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 6503071, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10285, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 28474639, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 769584.8378378379, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 37548775241, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1318.6743207174636, "renju_forbidden_checks": 120820, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3265.4054054054054, "renju_forbidden_ns": 199093946, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1647.8558682337361, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11264, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16014607, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 50709, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 120249021, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 55103, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 56409342, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3744, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6420976, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 759283, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 20521.162162162163, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3445875783, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4538.32863767528, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 914810, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 24724.594594594593, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1277696465, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1396.6796001355472, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9564358460, "stage_ordering_ns": 6486032402, "stage_eval_ns": 11724505243, "stage_threat_ns": 33727385922, "stage_proof_ns": 4469432412, "tactical_annotations": 9889194, "root_tactical_annotations": 17217, "search_tactical_annotations": 9871977, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1848245, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 8231345472, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 11719877, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 22686566767, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 611728, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11123776871, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 924104, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1079610912, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 222530, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1247387335, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1848208, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 164591042, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 4502179, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1245207432, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 2684299, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 4345649683, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 2702716, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 317884394, "child_limit_applications": 283408, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 283408, "child_cap_hits": 283408, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 283408, "child_moves_before_total": 29753561, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 29753561, "child_moves_before_max": 137, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 137, "child_moves_after_total": 4031490, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 4031490, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 104.98490162592446, "avg_child_moves_after": 14.225039518997347, "tt_hits": 177167, "tt_cutoffs": 19951, "beta_cutoffs": 239401, "depth_sum": 219, "avg_depth": 5.918918918918919, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 219, "avg_effective_depth": 5.918918918918919, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 14, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3783783783783784, "pooled_budget_moves": 37, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.32432432432432434, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 14, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3783783783783784, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2992.7567567567567, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3149.7567567567567, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 39, "search_move_count": 37, "total_time_ms": 1440, "avg_search_time_ms": 38.91891891891892, "search_nodes": 133117, "safety_nodes": 5343, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 138460, "avg_nodes": 3742.162162162162, "eval_calls": 127048, "avg_eval_calls": 3433.7297297297296, "line_shape_eval_calls": 127048, "line_shape_eval_ns": 240235082, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 1890.9001479755682, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5997, "avg_candidate_generations": 162.0810810810811, "candidate_moves_total": 585679, "avg_candidate_moves": 97.66199766549941, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 37, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3497, "root_candidate_moves_max": 122, "search_candidate_generations": 5960, "search_candidate_moves_total": 582182, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 12615, "avg_legality_checks": 340.94594594594594, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 12615, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 52074, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1407.4054054054054, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 74661505, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1433.7578254023122, "renju_forbidden_checks": 52, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.4054054054054055, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42680, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 820.7692307692307, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16540, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 26140, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 25268710, "stage_ordering_ns": 180810, "stage_eval_ns": 240235082, "stage_threat_ns": 1132542272, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 266053, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 979631232, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 95, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 636864, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 73, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 27460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 133008, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 129284344, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 266016, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22989832, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 141, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5659, "depth_sum": 109, "avg_depth": 2.945945945945946, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 109, "avg_effective_depth": 2.945945945945946, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 36 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 37, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7449.5675675675675, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7665.783783783784, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1991, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 827, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10399, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 67, 98, 126, 81, 127, 83, 141, 156, 84, 66, 114, 65, 113, 50, 34, 80, 79, 95, 35, 110 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2058, "avg_search_time_ms": 187.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 127364, "safety_nodes": 657, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 128021, "avg_nodes": 11638.272727272728, "eval_calls": 123606, "avg_eval_calls": 11236.90909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 123606, "line_shape_eval_ns": 102176103, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 826.6273724576477, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3738, "avg_candidate_generations": 339.8181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 234308, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.682718031032636, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 642, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 3727, "search_candidate_moves_total": 233666, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 118370, "avg_legality_checks": 10760.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 141, "root_legality_checks": 642, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 117728, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 138, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 130935, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11903.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 311311653, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2377.6045595142627, "renju_forbidden_checks": 155, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 14.090909090909092, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1639229, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10575.670967741935, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 141, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1509099, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 130130, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.5454545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 298640, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10665.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.272727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 80620, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2239.4444444444443, "stage_move_gen_ns": 294421854, "stage_ordering_ns": 124650, "stage_eval_ns": 102176103, "stage_threat_ns": 1644779308, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 254677, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1445597145, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 474860, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 127333, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 167253213, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 254666, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31454090, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 269, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3333, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5827.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6554.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1938, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8329, "avg_search_time_ms": 832.9, "search_nodes": 66723, "safety_nodes": 747, "corridor_nodes": 353, "corridor_branch_probes": 420, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 148, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_plies_followed": 348, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 348, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 25, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 20, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 148, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 25, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 151, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 31872480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 67823, "avg_nodes": 6782.3, "eval_calls": 42687, "avg_eval_calls": 4268.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 42687, "pattern_eval_ns": 928235, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.74514489188746, "pattern_frame_queries": 42687, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 928235, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.74514489188746, "pattern_frame_updates": 133336, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1729270117, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12969.266492170156, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21822, "avg_candidate_generations": 2182.2, "candidate_moves_total": 1446501, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.28636238658235, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 583, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 21812, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1445918, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 814398, "avg_legality_checks": 81439.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2693, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 814398, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2693, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2465083, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 246508.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5307334452, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2153.0043621249265, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19549, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1954.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 113113817, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5786.168960049107, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2705, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 27404576, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7350, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64547948, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9469, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20881853, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 279440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 92245, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9224.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 914347310, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9912.161201149114, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 129271, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12927.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 428497668, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3314.723859179553, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2041297561, "stage_ordering_ns": 608197908, "stage_eval_ns": 1730198352, "stage_threat_ns": 3867967797, "stage_proof_ns": 41017079, "tactical_annotations": 355004, "root_tactical_annotations": 687, "search_tactical_annotations": 354317, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 134092, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 847968716, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 329557, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2887016283, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43933, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1647649379, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67041, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 101537411, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 746, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4013526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 134082, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17622409, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 53115, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 271954375, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 211375, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 949746652, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 90514, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9809452, "child_limit_applications": 21812, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21812, "child_cap_hits": 21812, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21812, "child_moves_before_total": 1443225, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1443225, "child_moves_before_max": 96, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 96, "child_moves_after_total": 234299, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 234299, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 66.16655969191271, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.74174766183752, "tt_hits": 10236, "tt_cutoffs": 2170, "beta_cutoffs": 17002, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3356.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4156.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 345, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 828, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7037, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 95, 79, 80, 65, 113, 51, 93, 52, 67, 49, 33, 50, 48, 53 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6563, "avg_search_time_ms": 729.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 76999, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 680, "corridor_branch_probes": 797, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 224, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 670, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 670, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 28, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 224, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 284, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 33898800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 77837, "avg_nodes": 8648.555555555555, "eval_calls": 47156, "avg_eval_calls": 5239.555555555556, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47156, "pattern_eval_ns": 938591, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.903957078632622, "pattern_frame_queries": 47156, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 938591, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.903957078632622, "pattern_frame_updates": 153912, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1423166604, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9246.625370341493, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28085, "avg_candidate_generations": 3120.5555555555557, "candidate_moves_total": 1940421, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.09100943564181, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 28076, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1939921, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 553444, "avg_legality_checks": 61493.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 248, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 552944, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 247, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2118981, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 235442.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3908840629, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1844.6794138314594, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23447, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2605.222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 59453757, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2535.6658421119973, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1355, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3322248, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11087, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38009420, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10850, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17778157, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 155, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 343932, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37865, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4207.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 270701783, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7149.12935428496, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 49085, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5453.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 116317556, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2369.716940002037, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1154275048, "stage_ordering_ns": 644325116, "stage_eval_ns": 1424105195, "stage_threat_ns": 3164211597, "stage_proof_ns": 139180304, "tactical_annotations": 384498, "root_tactical_annotations": 1800, "search_tactical_annotations": 382698, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 155337, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 780494822, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 335090, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2246899078, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56691, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1726437515, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77664, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 97355139, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1416, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6555301, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 155328, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16652466, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 89726, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 50481357, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 141182, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 379109368, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 153590, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16254791, "child_limit_applications": 28076, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28076, "child_cap_hits": 28076, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28076, "child_moves_before_total": 1939674, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1939674, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 245658, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 245658, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.08655079071093, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.749750676734578, "tt_hits": 17016, "tt_cutoffs": 1724, "beta_cutoffs": 22214, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3834.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4723.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1221, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 467, "avg_search_time_ms": 58.375, "search_nodes": 39914, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40510, "avg_nodes": 5063.75, "eval_calls": 38581, "avg_eval_calls": 4822.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 38581, "line_shape_eval_ns": 26138329, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 677.4922630310257, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1318, "avg_candidate_generations": 164.75, "candidate_moves_total": 83765, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.5546282245827, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1310, "search_candidate_moves_total": 83318, "search_candidate_moves_max": 88, "legality_checks": 2373, "avg_legality_checks": 296.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2373, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11398, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1424.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19315709, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1694.6577469731533, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 41250, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3437.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10370, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 30880, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5853135, "stage_ordering_ns": 38860, "stage_eval_ns": 26138329, "stage_threat_ns": 426136055, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 79790, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 374095041, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 143001, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 39891, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 43760826, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 79782, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8137187, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1199, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5405.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6405.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 829, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8624, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 110, 127, 99, 96, 114, 126, 100, 101, 141, 95, 143, 80, 128, 79, 63, 81, 66, 82, 78, 83 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1323, "avg_search_time_ms": 120.27272727272727, "search_nodes": 109195, "safety_nodes": 657, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 109852, "avg_nodes": 9986.545454545454, "eval_calls": 105659, "avg_eval_calls": 9605.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 105659, "line_shape_eval_ns": 75487257, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 714.442281301167, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3516, "avg_candidate_generations": 319.6363636363636, "candidate_moves_total": 223720, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.629124004550626, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 642, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 3505, "search_candidate_moves_total": 223078, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 101264, "avg_legality_checks": 9205.818181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 162, "root_legality_checks": 642, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 100622, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 159, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 113781, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10343.727272727272, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 203581613, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1789.240848647841, "renju_forbidden_checks": 176, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 16.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1844232, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10478.59090909091, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 162, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1713831, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 130401, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.5454545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 190410, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6800.357142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.272727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 67850, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1884.7222222222222, "stage_move_gen_ns": 190160436, "stage_ordering_ns": 106150, "stage_eval_ns": 75487257, "stage_threat_ns": 1036333343, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 218339, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 903263288, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 345391, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 109164, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 111860087, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 218328, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20864577, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 269, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3076, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6044.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6771.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1955, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7293, "avg_search_time_ms": 729.3, "search_nodes": 76203, "safety_nodes": 747, "corridor_nodes": 295, "corridor_branch_probes": 346, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 112, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 289, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 289, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 25, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 112, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 25, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 151, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 31940640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 77245, "avg_nodes": 7724.5, "eval_calls": 48411, "avg_eval_calls": 4841.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48411, "pattern_eval_ns": 939413, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.40494928838487, "pattern_frame_queries": 48411, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 939413, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.40494928838487, "pattern_frame_updates": 152296, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1527366460, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10028.933524189735, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25452, "avg_candidate_generations": 2545.2, "candidate_moves_total": 1719788, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.56985698569856, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 583, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 25442, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1719205, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 1016445, "avg_legality_checks": 101644.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3370, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1016445, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3370, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3012021, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 301202.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4596208664, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1525.9550527702163, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24231, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2423.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 106478834, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4394.3227270851385, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3382, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 27134316, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8573, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 59570807, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12251, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19516550, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 257161, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 121230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12123.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 834450837, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6883.204132640435, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 169500, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16950.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 389465041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2297.728855457227, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1782943082, "stage_ordering_ns": 543158283, "stage_eval_ns": 1528305873, "stage_threat_ns": 3364389284, "stage_proof_ns": 26054262, "tactical_annotations": 419783, "root_tactical_annotations": 687, "search_tactical_annotations": 419096, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152934, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 704990903, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 392474, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2540232431, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51186, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1404317429, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76462, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90604718, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 628, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3093907, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152924, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15384988, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 64474, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 232769298, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 257917, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 890811440, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 97392, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10082337, "child_limit_applications": 25442, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25442, "child_cap_hits": 25442, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25442, "child_moves_before_total": 1715835, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1715835, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 273323, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 273323, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.4410423708828, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.742984042135053, "tt_hits": 11015, "tt_cutoffs": 2296, "beta_cutoffs": 20035, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3972.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4772.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1098, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 830, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7746, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 82, 66, 81, 80, 128, 94, 52, 109, 110, 64, 48, 79, 49, 124 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7261, "avg_search_time_ms": 806.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 76687, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 724, "corridor_branch_probes": 839, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 242, "corridor_neutral_exits": 19, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 714, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 714, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 28, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 242, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 284, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 33951040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 77569, "avg_nodes": 8618.777777777777, "eval_calls": 46888, "avg_eval_calls": 5209.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46888, "pattern_eval_ns": 955902, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.38692202695786, "pattern_frame_queries": 46888, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 955902, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.38692202695786, "pattern_frame_updates": 153288, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1556763322, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10155.806860289129, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27943, "avg_candidate_generations": 3104.777777777778, "candidate_moves_total": 1970667, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.5245320831693, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 27934, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1970167, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 573354, "avg_legality_checks": 63706.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 242, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 572854, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 241, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2170201, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 241133.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4374332728, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2015.6348319810008, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21567, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2396.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66033864, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3061.8010849909583, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 933, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3456112, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10543, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 42477367, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9982, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19673331, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 109, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 427054, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39140, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4348.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 303218670, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7747.027848748084, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50357, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5595.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 120290303, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2388.750382270588, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1311717513, "stage_ordering_ns": 702514888, "stage_eval_ns": 1557719224, "stage_threat_ns": 3500234033, "stage_proof_ns": 156532137, "tactical_annotations": 394391, "root_tactical_annotations": 1800, "search_tactical_annotations": 392591, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 154801, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 847773731, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 342553, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2502978792, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56434, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1908167910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77396, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104472560, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1504, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7886071, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 154792, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18108869, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 88769, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 61753694, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 147187, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 418855154, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 158435, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19014010, "child_limit_applications": 27934, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27934, "child_cap_hits": 27934, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27934, "child_moves_before_total": 1969926, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1969926, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 246742, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 246742, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.52072742893964, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.833035011097587, "tt_hits": 16987, "tt_cutoffs": 1822, "beta_cutoffs": 22109, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3571.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4460.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1149, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 476, "avg_search_time_ms": 59.5, "search_nodes": 35108, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35704, "avg_nodes": 4463.0, "eval_calls": 33899, "avg_eval_calls": 4237.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 33899, "line_shape_eval_ns": 27793701, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 819.8973716038821, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1194, "avg_candidate_generations": 149.25, "candidate_moves_total": 76195, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.814907872696814, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1186, "search_candidate_moves_total": 75748, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 2613, "avg_legality_checks": 326.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2613, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11724, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1465.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21568448, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1839.683384510406, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 39570, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3597.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5700, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 33870, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6894279, "stage_ordering_ns": 36701, "stage_eval_ns": 27793701, "stage_threat_ns": 434019423, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 70178, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 381872220, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 163631, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6920, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35085, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 43768190, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 70170, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8215382, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1085, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5417.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6417.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 831, "black": "search-d3", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9753, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 82, 113, 141, 96, 142, 98, 156, 171, 99, 81, 129, 80, 128, 65, 49, 95, 94, 110, 50, 125 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1756, "avg_search_time_ms": 159.63636363636363, "search_nodes": 128280, "safety_nodes": 657, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 128937, "avg_nodes": 11721.545454545454, "eval_calls": 124522, "avg_eval_calls": 11320.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 124522, "line_shape_eval_ns": 82725449, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 664.3440436228136, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3738, "avg_candidate_generations": 339.8181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 234929, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.84884965222044, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 642, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 3727, "search_candidate_moves_total": 234287, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 119281, "avg_legality_checks": 10843.727272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 141, "root_legality_checks": 642, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 118639, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 138, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 131798, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11981.636363636364, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 268487549, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2037.1139850377092, "renju_forbidden_checks": 155, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 14.090909090909092, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1544806, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9966.490322580645, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 141, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1415126, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 129680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.5454545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 150801, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5385.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.272727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 59521, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1653.361111111111, "stage_move_gen_ns": 258444482, "stage_ordering_ns": 118131, "stage_eval_ns": 82725449, "stage_threat_ns": 1399708088, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 256509, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1226249782, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 276341, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8100, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128249, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 145717054, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 256498, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27464911, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 269, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3333, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5879.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6606.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1966, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7987, "avg_search_time_ms": 798.7, "search_nodes": 70698, "safety_nodes": 747, "corridor_nodes": 353, "corridor_branch_probes": 420, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 148, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_plies_followed": 348, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 348, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 25, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 20, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 148, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 25, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 151, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 31873280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 71798, "avg_nodes": 7179.8, "eval_calls": 45393, "avg_eval_calls": 4539.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 45393, "pattern_eval_ns": 936352, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.627673870420548, "pattern_frame_queries": 45393, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 936352, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.627673870420548, "pattern_frame_updates": 141286, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1681584613, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11901.990381212576, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23056, "avg_candidate_generations": 2305.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1541961, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.87894691186676, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 583, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 23046, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1541378, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 884946, "avg_legality_checks": 88494.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2868, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 884946, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2868, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2668526, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 266852.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5095458418, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1909.4655319078772, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21098, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2109.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 110398947, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5232.673570954593, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2880, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26688927, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7890, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 63201427, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10303, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20230863, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 277730, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 101447, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10144.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 897201675, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8844.0434414029, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 142209, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14220.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 419356167, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2948.8722021812964, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1964867618, "stage_ordering_ns": 584241308, "stage_eval_ns": 1682520965, "stage_threat_ns": 3676955109, "stage_proof_ns": 37223188, "tactical_annotations": 377591, "root_tactical_annotations": 687, "search_tactical_annotations": 376904, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 142042, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 786083263, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 350505, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2763331923, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46401, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1556022550, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 71016, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 97255672, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 746, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3349582, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 142032, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16763549, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56180, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 264634067, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 226790, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 928001128, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 94621, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10171120, "child_limit_applications": 23046, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23046, "child_cap_hits": 23046, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23046, "child_moves_before_total": 1538510, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1538510, "child_moves_before_max": 96, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 96, "child_moves_after_total": 247817, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 247817, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 66.75822268506465, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.753145882148745, "tt_hits": 10612, "tt_cutoffs": 2204, "beta_cutoffs": 17964, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3551.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4351.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 554, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 832, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4987, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 110, 94, 95, 80, 128, 66, 108, 67, 82, 64, 48, 65, 63, 68 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4627, "avg_search_time_ms": 514.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 76796, "safety_nodes": 158, "corridor_nodes": 680, "corridor_branch_probes": 797, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 224, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 670, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 670, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 28, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 224, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 284, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 33902160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 77634, "avg_nodes": 8626.0, "eval_calls": 47047, "avg_eval_calls": 5227.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47047, "pattern_eval_ns": 852782, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.126171700639787, "pattern_frame_queries": 47047, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 852782, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.126171700639787, "pattern_frame_updates": 153506, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1076470521, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7012.5631636548405, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28039, "avg_candidate_generations": 3115.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 1960845, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.93277221013588, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 28030, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1960345, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 561597, "avg_legality_checks": 62399.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 248, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 561097, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 247, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2171145, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 241238.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2690801300, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1239.3466580997583, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23638, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2626.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 53366207, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2257.644766900753, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1355, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2785489, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11163, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34481429, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10965, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15771505, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 155, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 327784, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38050, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4227.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 181862435, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4779.5646517739815, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 49168, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5463.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 73664270, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1498.2157094044908, "stage_move_gen_ns": 766766309, "stage_ordering_ns": 451621408, "stage_eval_ns": 1077323303, "stage_threat_ns": 2208072772, "stage_proof_ns": 87444160, "tactical_annotations": 384335, "root_tactical_annotations": 1800, "search_tactical_annotations": 382535, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 154931, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 542550528, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 335062, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1561521450, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56599, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1205618480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77461, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74008809, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1416, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4572092, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 154922, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12334464, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 89857, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 38638737, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 141115, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 252896049, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 153363, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13085429, "child_limit_applications": 28030, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28030, "child_cap_hits": 28030, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28030, "child_moves_before_total": 1960098, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1960098, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 245279, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 245279, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.92857652515163, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.750588655012487, "tt_hits": 16938, "tt_cutoffs": 1676, "beta_cutoffs": 22182, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4804.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5693.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1816, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 351, "avg_search_time_ms": 43.875, "search_nodes": 40224, "safety_nodes": 596, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40820, "avg_nodes": 5102.5, "eval_calls": 38891, "avg_eval_calls": 4861.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 38891, "line_shape_eval_ns": 19185542, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 493.3157285747345, "pattern_eval_calls": 0, "pattern_eval_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_queries": 0, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_updates": 0, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 0, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 0.0, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1318, "avg_candidate_generations": 164.75, "candidate_moves_total": 84143, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.84142640364188, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 1310, "search_candidate_moves_total": 83696, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 2373, "avg_legality_checks": 296.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2373, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11484, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1435.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18049195, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1571.6819052594915, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 81870, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6822.5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20750, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61120, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4847403, "stage_ordering_ns": 38781, "stage_eval_ns": 19185542, "stage_threat_ns": 316474863, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 80410, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 276035158, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 102680, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40201, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 33964804, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 80402, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6372221, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 57, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1199, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5438.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6438.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1993, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 833, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10870, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 80, 99, 85, 141, 155, 128, 83, 143, 158, 84, 69, 111, 52, 67, 55, 41, 159, 126, 156, 157, 79, 81, 96, 129, 125, 130 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3146, "avg_search_time_ms": 224.71428571428572, "search_nodes": 73932, "safety_nodes": 1451, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 75383, "avg_nodes": 5384.5, "eval_calls": 70709, "avg_eval_calls": 5050.642857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70709, "pattern_eval_ns": 1447895, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.47681341837673, "pattern_frame_queries": 70709, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1447895, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.47681341837673, "pattern_frame_updates": 147782, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2034018780, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13763.643610182566, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3196, "avg_candidate_generations": 228.28571428571428, "candidate_moves_total": 262699, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.19618272841052, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1051, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 3182, "search_candidate_moves_total": 261648, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 68100, "avg_legality_checks": 4864.285714285715, "illegal_moves_skipped": 324, "root_legality_checks": 1051, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 67049, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 318, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 661372, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 47240.857142857145, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1510304865, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2283.593597854158, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15266, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1090.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_ns": 118244742, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7745.6270142800995, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 332, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2862955, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14884, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 115025334, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 356453, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 79, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.642857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 740224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9369.924050632912, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.928571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 344223, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3548.6907216494847, "stage_move_gen_ns": 160344201, "stage_ordering_ns": 133960, "stage_eval_ns": 2035466675, "stage_threat_ns": 921731898, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 147796, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 805685401, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1042475, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14710, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 73891, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 98030793, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 147782, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16973229, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 187, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2877, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6463.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7034.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1873, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 7711, "avg_search_time_ms": 550.7857142857143, "search_nodes": 56210, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 57183, "avg_nodes": 4084.5, "eval_calls": 37399, "avg_eval_calls": 2671.3571428571427, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37399, "pattern_eval_ns": 811465, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.697505280889864, "pattern_frame_queries": 37399, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 811465, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.697505280889864, "pattern_frame_updates": 112296, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1184369377, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10546.852755218351, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17637, "avg_candidate_generations": 1259.7857142857142, "candidate_moves_total": 1497125, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.8854680501219, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1096, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 17623, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1496029, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1081577, "avg_legality_checks": 77255.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3554, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1081577, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3554, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2453291, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 175235.07142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5058448724, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2061.9032654503685, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58204, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4157.428571428572, "renju_forbidden_ns": 146929767, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2524.3929455020275, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5470, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 38918008, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7402, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33488922, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 45208, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 73939975, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 124, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 582862, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98796, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7056.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 992301505, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10043.94413741447, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 130465, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9318.92857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 489565420, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3752.465565477331, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2612415767, "stage_ordering_ns": 597581340, "stage_eval_ns": 1185180842, "stage_threat_ns": 3259586621, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 344535, "root_tactical_annotations": 1582, "search_tactical_annotations": 342953, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 112310, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 690243748, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 300472, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2462245663, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35335, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1236870444, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56148, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 82799301, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 112296, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14246946, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 107419, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 509121010, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 157709, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 715995349, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79407, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10050963, "child_limit_applications": 17623, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17623, "child_cap_hits": 17623, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17623, "child_moves_before_total": 1492475, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1492475, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 282757, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 282757, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.68904272825286, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.044771037848268, "tt_hits": 7777, "tt_cutoffs": 1126, "beta_cutoffs": 15262, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5696.214285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6267.642857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1848, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 834, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17746, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 83, 128, 67, 82, 111, 69, 35, 51, 66, 125, 65, 64, 80, 50, 52, 94, 36, 79, 38, 24, 37, 34, 39 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10200, "avg_search_time_ms": 850.0, "search_nodes": 121063, "safety_nodes": 380, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 121443, "avg_nodes": 10120.25, "eval_calls": 82675, "avg_eval_calls": 6889.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82675, "pattern_eval_ns": 1715177, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.746017538554582, "pattern_frame_queries": 82675, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1715177, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.746017538554582, "pattern_frame_updates": 242022, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2367306697, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9781.3698630703, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35206, "avg_candidate_generations": 2933.8333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2630086, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.70561836050673, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 769, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 35194, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2629317, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 851647, "avg_legality_checks": 70970.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 129, "root_legality_checks": 769, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 850878, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 129, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2747938, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 228994.83333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5913853570, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2152.105895402298, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12218, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1018.1666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37592881, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3076.8440825012276, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 143, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1353356, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3511, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25072987, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8561, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11162068, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4470, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59062, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4921.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 513203117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8689.226863296197, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 79326, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6610.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 221709444, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2794.915210649724, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2037294276, "stage_ordering_ns": 1034750867, "stage_eval_ns": 2369021874, "stage_threat_ns": 4706013501, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 419246, "root_tactical_annotations": 2716, "search_tactical_annotations": 416530, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 242034, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1376358672, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 410358, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3122754116, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70463, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2307477773, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121011, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 168431457, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 242022, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28759788, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 126655, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 112895005, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 213229, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 702145847, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79362, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9709468, "child_limit_applications": 35194, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35194, "child_cap_hits": 35194, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35194, "child_moves_before_total": 2629188, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2629188, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 563108, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 563108, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.70557481388873, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000113655736772, "tt_hits": 15109, "tt_cutoffs": 3142, "beta_cutoffs": 29794, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4643.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5309.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 734, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7534, "avg_search_time_ms": 684.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 250272, "safety_nodes": 908, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 251180, "avg_nodes": 22834.545454545456, "eval_calls": 245760, "avg_eval_calls": 22341.81818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 245760, "pattern_eval_ns": 5001620, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.351643880208332, "pattern_frame_queries": 245760, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5001620, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.351643880208332, "pattern_frame_updates": 500480, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4336708493, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8665.09849144821, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4491, "avg_candidate_generations": 408.27272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 339821, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.66711200178133, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 718, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 4480, "search_candidate_moves_total": 339103, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 9459, "avg_legality_checks": 859.9090909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9459, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1214283, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 110389.36363636363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2666993141, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2196.352202081393, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3088, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 280.72727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21571766, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6985.675518134715, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3088, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21571766, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23522990, "stage_ordering_ns": 143320, "stage_eval_ns": 4341710113, "stage_threat_ns": 3134490270, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 500491, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2751945255, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 254051, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 250240, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 323211450, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 500480, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59079514, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 177, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4132, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5610.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6337.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1815, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 835, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11587, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 81, 100, 142, 72, 86, 129, 126, 130, 131, 66, 110, 109, 94, 78, 158 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 3763, "avg_search_time_ms": 418.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 91539, "safety_nodes": 510, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92049, "avg_nodes": 10227.666666666666, "eval_calls": 88931, "avg_eval_calls": 9881.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 88931, "pattern_eval_ns": 1832599, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.606976195027606, "pattern_frame_queries": 88931, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1832599, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.606976195027606, "pattern_frame_updates": 183028, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2353122809, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12856.627450444741, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2592, "avg_candidate_generations": 288.0, "candidate_moves_total": 189345, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.04976851851852, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 628, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 2583, "search_candidate_moves_total": 188717, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 86742, "avg_legality_checks": 9638.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 628, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 86114, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 707379, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 78597.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1723220684, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2436.064237134549, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8151, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 905.6666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 63135346, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7745.717826033616, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 173110, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8126, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62962236, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 12, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.3333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 120260, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10021.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.6666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 54910, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3660.6666666666665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 213510742, "stage_ordering_ns": 82741, "stage_eval_ns": 2354955408, "stage_threat_ns": 1174821252, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 183037, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1028905841, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 203001, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8780, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91514, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 123656655, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 183028, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22055755, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2213, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5279.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6168.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1877, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7819, "avg_search_time_ms": 977.375, "search_nodes": 61211, "safety_nodes": 553, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 61764, "avg_nodes": 7720.5, "eval_calls": 41827, "avg_eval_calls": 5228.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41827, "pattern_eval_ns": 882693, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.103426016687784, "pattern_frame_queries": 41827, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 882693, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.103426016687784, "pattern_frame_updates": 122352, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1311399685, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10718.252950503465, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18202, "avg_candidate_generations": 2275.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1477381, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.1658608944072, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 555, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 18194, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1476826, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1068565, "avg_legality_checks": 133570.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 691, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1068565, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 691, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2448267, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 306033.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5197040693, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2122.7426146739713, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14970, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1871.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 39079153, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2610.4978623914494, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 697, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7154580, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1876, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14017602, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12397, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17906971, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 96354, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12044.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 894792666, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9286.512921103431, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 128562, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16070.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 392637392, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3054.0703473810304, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2571332649, "stage_ordering_ns": 612473771, "stage_eval_ns": 1312282378, "stage_threat_ns": 3276585003, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 266823, "root_tactical_annotations": 981, "search_tactical_annotations": 265842, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 122360, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 722955870, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 254157, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2441307149, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36439, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1299723409, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61176, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 89172088, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 122352, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15404601, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 53748, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 284347773, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 163964, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 857133396, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49111, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7745295, "child_limit_applications": 18194, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18194, "child_cap_hits": 18194, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18194, "child_moves_before_total": 1476135, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1476135, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 291151, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 291151, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.13306584588325, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00258326920963, "tt_hits": 5615, "tt_cutoffs": 1156, "beta_cutoffs": 15502, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2638.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3638.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 648, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 836, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11893, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 142, 110, 141, 96, 98, 140, 68, 125, 83, 53, 95, 124, 82, 156, 84, 70, 81, 85, 80 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8253, "avg_search_time_ms": 687.75, "search_nodes": 90448, "safety_nodes": 900, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91348, "avg_nodes": 7612.333333333333, "eval_calls": 67644, "avg_eval_calls": 5637.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67644, "pattern_eval_ns": 1472457, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.767739932588256, "pattern_frame_queries": 67644, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1472457, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.767739932588256, "pattern_frame_updates": 180792, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2115225751, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11699.775161511572, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21899, "avg_candidate_generations": 1824.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1638336, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.81327914516645, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 742, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 21887, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1637594, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 704042, "avg_legality_checks": 58670.166666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 731, "root_legality_checks": 742, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 703300, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 730, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2130992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 177582.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4899128868, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2298.9897981785007, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11704, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 975.3333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 58980459, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5039.342019822283, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 755, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8288576, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4490, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37344687, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6452, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13277956, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 69240, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54626, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4552.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 466723813, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8543.986618093948, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68669, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5722.416666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 179698730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2616.8828729120855, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1774802131, "stage_ordering_ns": 720541078, "stage_eval_ns": 2116698208, "stage_threat_ns": 3597947195, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 280565, "root_tactical_annotations": 1377, "search_tactical_annotations": 279188, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 180804, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1089947431, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 270776, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2340903932, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43849, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1650657447, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 90396, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 136791624, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 180792, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23622092, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 78564, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 94757352, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 148352, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 594994212, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53649, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6682116, "child_limit_applications": 21887, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21887, "child_cap_hits": 21887, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21887, "child_moves_before_total": 1636864, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1636864, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 350195, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 350195, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.7870425366656, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000137067665737, "tt_hits": 8177, "tt_cutoffs": 865, "beta_cutoffs": 17463, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5013.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5680.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1152, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3632, "avg_search_time_ms": 330.1818181818182, "search_nodes": 111777, "safety_nodes": 518, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 112295, "avg_nodes": 10208.636363636364, "eval_calls": 107737, "avg_eval_calls": 9794.272727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107737, "pattern_eval_ns": 2332727, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.652050827478025, "pattern_frame_queries": 107737, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2332727, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.652050827478025, "pattern_frame_updates": 223490, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2110085483, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9441.520797351111, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4019, "avg_candidate_generations": 365.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 297477, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.01766608609107, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 678, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 4008, "search_candidate_moves_total": 296799, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 10186, "avg_legality_checks": 926.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10186, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 557800, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 50709.09090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1320978038, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2368.1929688060236, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2882, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 262.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16160404, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5607.357390700902, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34070, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2874, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16063831, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 62503, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 27813664, "stage_ordering_ns": 148041, "stage_eval_ns": 2112418210, "stage_threat_ns": 1468285819, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 223501, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1284186829, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 168062, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12130, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111745, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156139885, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 223490, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27791043, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 316, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3524, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5977.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6704.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 837, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11276, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 145, 129, 98, 125, 99, 100, 140, 127, 79, 157, 143, 109, 108, 141, 93, 173 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5514, "avg_search_time_ms": 551.4, "search_nodes": 141900, "safety_nodes": 555, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 142455, "avg_nodes": 14245.5, "eval_calls": 137719, "avg_eval_calls": 13771.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 137719, "pattern_eval_ns": 2818119, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.462819218844167, "pattern_frame_queries": 137719, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2818119, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.462819218844167, "pattern_frame_updates": 283744, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3349585585, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11804.956527715123, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4163, "avg_candidate_generations": 416.3, "candidate_moves_total": 294895, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.83713668027865, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 619, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 4153, "search_candidate_moves_total": 294276, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 135276, "avg_legality_checks": 13527.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 619, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 134657, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1047161, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 104716.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2437377952, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2327.6057377996317, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18634, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1863.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 83126618, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4461.018460877965, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 77, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 259140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18546, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 82848778, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 18700, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 313741, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8715.027777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 45, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 130160, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2892.4444444444443, "stage_move_gen_ns": 330343308, "stage_ordering_ns": 137010, "stage_eval_ns": 3352403704, "stage_threat_ns": 1812815624, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 283754, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1586198247, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 391442, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9690, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 141872, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 192337025, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 283744, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33888910, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 294, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3563, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5451.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6251.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1824, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5752, "avg_search_time_ms": 639.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 45942, "safety_nodes": 593, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 46535, "avg_nodes": 5170.555555555556, "eval_calls": 30598, "avg_eval_calls": 3399.777777777778, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 30598, "pattern_eval_ns": 648363, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.18971828224067, "pattern_frame_queries": 30598, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 648363, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.18971828224067, "pattern_frame_updates": 91804, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 910452737, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9917.353677399678, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14593, "avg_candidate_generations": 1621.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 1097319, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.19488795998082, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 552, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 14584, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1096767, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 743318, "avg_legality_checks": 82590.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 743318, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1841468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 204607.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3787274762, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2056.6606435734966, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20281, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2253.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31164022, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1536.6117055372024, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52290, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1538, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7628389, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18719, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23483343, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 82905, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9211.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 724745679, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8741.881418491044, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 111398, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12377.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 308941622, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2773.3139015063107, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1769446963, "stage_ordering_ns": 452048301, "stage_eval_ns": 911101100, "stage_threat_ns": 2585611619, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 241531, "root_tactical_annotations": 921, "search_tactical_annotations": 240610, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 91813, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 549836906, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 216964, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1949017781, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29226, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1041982789, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 45902, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68088803, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 91804, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11468747, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62986, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 278396411, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 124745, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 628448320, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53800, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7199382, "child_limit_applications": 14584, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14584, "child_cap_hits": 14584, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14584, "child_moves_before_total": 1096759, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1096759, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 237792, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 237792, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.20289358200768, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.30499177180472, "tt_hits": 5255, "tt_cutoffs": 720, "beta_cutoffs": 12616, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4718.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5607.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1874, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 838, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "draw", "winner": null, "end_reason": "max_moves", "duration_ms": 74108, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 129, 81, 109, 125, 80, 127, 143, 140, 155, 98, 126, 139, 157, 171, 156, 158, 145, 161, 144, 142, 159, 153, 167, 138, 141, 174, 173, 79, 63, 131, 114, 99, 146, 147, 189, 205, 187, 201, 115, 101, 100, 137, 136, 169, 185, 130, 188, 186, 190, 191, 86, 72, 117, 116, 172, 123, 108, 121, 105, 122, 124, 154, 170, 106, 90, 92, 200, 215, 204, 220, 107, 177, 163, 162, 192, 176, 120, 175, 178, 133, 119, 134, 132, 168, 183, 182, 196, 135, 193, 221, 206, 223, 217, 202, 148, 208, 222, 70, 48, 71, 60, 75, 64, 32, 78, 93, 62, 61, 66, 65, 94, 52, 46 ], "move_count": 120, "black_stats": { "move_count": 60, "search_move_count": 58, "total_time_ms": 28405, "avg_search_time_ms": 489.7413793103448, "search_nodes": 363783, "safety_nodes": 5732, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 369515, "avg_nodes": 6370.948275862069, "eval_calls": 249067, "avg_eval_calls": 4294.258620689655, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 249067, "pattern_eval_ns": 5162262, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.726398920772322, "pattern_frame_queries": 249067, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5162262, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.726398920772322, "pattern_frame_updates": 726986, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6301623695, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8668.149998762012, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 107984, "avg_candidate_generations": 1861.7931034482758, "candidate_moves_total": 10683105, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.932295525263, "candidate_moves_max": 141, "root_candidate_generations": 58, "root_candidate_moves_total": 5396, "root_candidate_moves_max": 120, "search_candidate_generations": 107926, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10677709, "search_candidate_moves_max": 141, "legality_checks": 3511142, "avg_legality_checks": 60536.93103448276, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6141, "root_legality_checks": 5396, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 3505746, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6130, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8927469, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 153921.87931034484, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16282490310, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1823.8641108694974, "renju_forbidden_checks": 68273, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1177.1206896551723, "renju_forbidden_ns": 228580741, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3348.0400890542383, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6611, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 49157912, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21503, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 112267647, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 40096, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 66678512, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 63, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 476670, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 256659, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4425.1551724137935, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1796396294, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6999.155665688715, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 336135, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5795.431034482759, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 777454060, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2312.9220700016363, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7127485305, "stage_ordering_ns": 3107488984, "stage_eval_ns": 6306785957, "stage_threat_ns": 11670564331, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2635991, "root_tactical_annotations": 8590, "search_tactical_annotations": 2627401, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 727044, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3414926547, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2477285, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7628704369, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 216258, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4599993161, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 363493, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 506095234, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 726986, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 82043635, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1380806, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 849696563, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 880182, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2177303781, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 375003, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 38794546, "child_limit_applications": 107926, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 107926, "child_cap_hits": 107926, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 107926, "child_moves_before_total": 10671579, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10671579, "child_moves_before_max": 140, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 140, "child_moves_after_total": 1727130, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1727130, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 98.87866686433297, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00290940088579, "tt_hits": 45842, "tt_cutoffs": 6500, "beta_cutoffs": 91798, "depth_sum": 290, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 290, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 5, "count": 58 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 58, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.034482758620689655, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7449.103448275862, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7587.0344827586205, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1288, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 60, "search_move_count": 58, "total_time_ms": 45646, "avg_search_time_ms": 787.0, "search_nodes": 1773453, "safety_nodes": 5735, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1779188, "avg_nodes": 30675.655172413793, "eval_calls": 1737182, "avg_eval_calls": 29951.41379310345, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 1737182, "pattern_eval_ns": 35310659, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.32640160904269, "pattern_frame_queries": 1737182, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 35310659, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.32640160904269, "pattern_frame_updates": 3546558, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 26112809182, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7362.859759236984, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 36155, "avg_candidate_generations": 623.3620689655172, "candidate_moves_total": 3786091, "avg_candidate_moves": 104.71832388328032, "candidate_moves_max": 144, "root_candidate_generations": 58, "root_candidate_moves_total": 5428, "root_candidate_moves_max": 121, "search_candidate_generations": 36097, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3780663, "search_candidate_moves_max": 144, "legality_checks": 92996, "avg_legality_checks": 1603.3793103448277, "illegal_moves_skipped": 49, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 92996, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 49, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8362691, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 144184.3275862069, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16249836609, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1943.1348843332846, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46582, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 803.1379310344828, "renju_forbidden_ns": 315706382, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6777.432956936155, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 49, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 351791, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 46473, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 314878510, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 476081, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 223849684, "stage_ordering_ns": 1225479, "stage_eval_ns": 26148119841, "stage_threat_ns": 19028407755, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 3546616, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16409183454, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 158, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 892782, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 116, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 60271, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 1773279, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 2231220301, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 3546558, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 387111218, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1791, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 33100, "depth_sum": 171, "avg_depth": 2.9482758620689653, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 171, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9482758620689653, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 55 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05172413793103448, "pooled_budget_moves": 58, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.10344827586206896, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05172413793103448, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6977.275862068966, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7115.206896551724, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 839, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16708, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 95, 141, 96, 159, 175, 144, 142, 156, 93, 171, 126, 186, 201, 94, 100, 86, 80, 64, 110, 125, 68, 124, 116, 115, 84, 52, 132 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 11504, "avg_search_time_ms": 719.0, "search_nodes": 296610, "safety_nodes": 565, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 297175, "avg_nodes": 18573.4375, "eval_calls": 287706, "avg_eval_calls": 17981.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 287706, "pattern_eval_ns": 5842684, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.307828130105037, "pattern_frame_queries": 287706, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5842684, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.307828130105037, "pattern_frame_updates": 593128, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7148380982, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12052.00392158185, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8874, "avg_candidate_generations": 554.625, "candidate_moves_total": 804776, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.68920441739914, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1267, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 8858, "search_candidate_moves_total": 803509, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 275753, "avg_legality_checks": 17234.5625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "root_legality_checks": 1267, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 274486, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2220325, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 138770.3125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5155301010, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2321.867749090786, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28698, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1793.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 209950606, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7315.861941598718, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 111, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 841113, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28587, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 209109493, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.1875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 189761, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9987.421052631578, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 89350, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3436.5384615384614, "stage_move_gen_ns": 656625113, "stage_ordering_ns": 309261, "stage_eval_ns": 7154223666, "stage_threat_ns": 3658664810, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 593144, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3196657947, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 272602, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 296564, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 392997967, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 593128, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 68736294, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 827, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7756, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6238.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6738.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1795, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 5187, "avg_search_time_ms": 345.8, "search_nodes": 53369, "safety_nodes": 1750, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 55119, "avg_nodes": 3674.6, "eval_calls": 38187, "avg_eval_calls": 2545.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38187, "pattern_eval_ns": 789492, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.67436562180847, "pattern_frame_queries": 38187, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 789492, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.67436562180847, "pattern_frame_updates": 106598, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1003492526, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9413.802566652283, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14506, "avg_candidate_generations": 967.0666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1110333, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.54301668275197, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1186, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 14491, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1109147, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 534941, "avg_legality_checks": 35662.73333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 57, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 534941, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 57, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1484313, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 98954.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3173122999, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2137.772153851647, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4761, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 317.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16076349, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3376.6748582230625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 646231, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1292, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10070237, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3397, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5359881, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45688, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3045.866666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 434151274, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9502.523069514971, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63821, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4254.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 198044704, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3103.127559894079, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1295717614, "stage_ordering_ns": 465415569, "stage_eval_ns": 1004282018, "stage_threat_ns": 2386751990, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 192804, "root_tactical_annotations": 646, "search_tactical_annotations": 192158, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 106613, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 632416695, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 186130, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1659708196, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29082, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1068316788, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 53299, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 77170756, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 106598, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13200899, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 45950, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 200581609, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 111087, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 390461866, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 35767, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4255444, "child_limit_applications": 14491, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14491, "child_cap_hits": 14491, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14491, "child_moves_before_total": 1109090, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1109090, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 232799, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 232799, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.53647091298048, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.06507487405976, "tt_hits": 4842, "tt_cutoffs": 621, "beta_cutoffs": 12002, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5970.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6503.933333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1863, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 840, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3663, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 95, 129, 97, 115, 116, 101, 157, 87 ], "move_count": 15, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 3053, "avg_search_time_ms": 508.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 42858, "safety_nodes": 295, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 43153, "avg_nodes": 7192.166666666667, "eval_calls": 33192, "avg_eval_calls": 5532.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33192, "pattern_eval_ns": 676492, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.38117618703302, "pattern_frame_queries": 33192, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 676492, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.38117618703302, "pattern_frame_updates": 85672, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 758259254, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8850.724320664862, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9225, "avg_candidate_generations": 1537.5, "candidate_moves_total": 636470, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.9940379403794, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 325, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 9219, "search_candidate_moves_total": 636145, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 222773, "avg_legality_checks": 37128.833333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "root_legality_checks": 325, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 222448, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 761710, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 126951.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1705162070, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2238.5974583502907, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3039, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 506.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9841553, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3238.4182296808162, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 152630, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1152, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7046043, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1861, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2639840, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3040, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15507, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2584.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 141952347, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9154.081834010447, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20376, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3396.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 61952115, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3040.4453769140164, "stage_move_gen_ns": 555551793, "stage_ordering_ns": 275410662, "stage_eval_ns": 758935746, "stage_threat_ns": 1448185599, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 65638, "root_tactical_annotations": 733, "search_tactical_annotations": 64905, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 85678, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 485824420, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 70509, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 891234916, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18471, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 690098577, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42836, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 59431508, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 85672, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10193408, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 10766, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 19015486, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 41267, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 181937993, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 13605, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1501347, "child_limit_applications": 9219, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9219, "child_cap_hits": 9219, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9219, "child_moves_before_total": 636133, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 636133, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 147504, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 147504, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.00238637596269, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 3564, "tt_cutoffs": 425, "beta_cutoffs": 7037, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2985.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4319.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1071, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 7, "search_move_count": 5, "total_time_ms": 605, "avg_search_time_ms": 121.0, "search_nodes": 20255, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 20455, "avg_nodes": 4091.0, "eval_calls": 19068, "avg_eval_calls": 3813.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 19068, "pattern_eval_ns": 385740, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.229704216488358, "pattern_frame_queries": 19068, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 385740, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.229704216488358, "pattern_frame_updates": 40482, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 321189095, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7934.121214366879, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1178, "avg_candidate_generations": 235.6, "candidate_moves_total": 74808, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.50424448217318, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 5, "root_candidate_moves_total": 266, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 1173, "search_candidate_moves_total": 74542, "search_candidate_moves_max": 83, "legality_checks": 3985, "avg_legality_checks": 797.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3985, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 78717, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15743.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 183606721, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2332.491342403801, "renju_forbidden_checks": 195, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 39.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1823730, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9352.461538461539, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 195, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 1823730, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10680248, "stage_ordering_ns": 44380, "stage_eval_ns": 321574835, "stage_threat_ns": 265520892, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 40487, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 233678737, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 53521, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 10, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5200, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 20241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 26896479, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 40482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4892155, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 107, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1020, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3703.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5303.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1972, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 841, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30078, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 83, 95, 98, 139, 153, 140, 110, 94, 53, 93, 96, 92, 91, 68, 158, 174, 84, 70, 157, 172, 82, 81, 66, 114, 156, 155, 50, 34, 52, 170, 185, 171, 173, 123, 187, 107 ], "move_count": 44, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 24098, "avg_search_time_ms": 1204.9, "search_nodes": 631315, "safety_nodes": 799, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 632114, "avg_nodes": 31605.7, "eval_calls": 616936, "avg_eval_calls": 30846.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 616936, "pattern_eval_ns": 12380290, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.067381381537146, "pattern_frame_queries": 616936, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 12380290, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.067381381537146, "pattern_frame_updates": 1262512, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 14988860794, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11872.252140177678, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14340, "avg_candidate_generations": 717.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1355460, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.52301255230125, "candidate_moves_max": 140, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1709, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 14320, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1353751, "search_candidate_moves_max": 140, "legality_checks": 594644, "avg_legality_checks": 29732.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 273, "root_legality_checks": 1709, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 592935, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4823504, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 241175.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10882026665, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2256.0418038421863, "renju_forbidden_checks": 61063, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3053.15, "renju_forbidden_ns": 494908045, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8104.876029674271, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 399, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2867271, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 60664, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 492040774, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.95, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 184471, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9709.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 86571, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3329.653846153846, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1365605706, "stage_ordering_ns": 533532, "stage_eval_ns": 15001241084, "stage_threat_ns": 7649506548, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1262532, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6680562878, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 54, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 270932, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20341, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 631256, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 823402062, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1262512, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 145270676, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 955, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 12816, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5578.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5978.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 752, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 5959, "avg_search_time_ms": 297.95, "search_nodes": 64727, "safety_nodes": 2744, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67471, "avg_nodes": 3373.55, "eval_calls": 46533, "avg_eval_calls": 2326.65, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46533, "pattern_eval_ns": 953575, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.49244622096147, "pattern_frame_queries": 46533, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 953575, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.49244622096147, "pattern_frame_updates": 129270, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1146894142, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8872.082787963178, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17361, "avg_candidate_generations": 868.05, "candidate_moves_total": 1393880, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.2880018432118, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1742, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 17341, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1392138, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 629235, "avg_legality_checks": 31461.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 629235, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1738758, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 86937.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3582701851, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2060.4948192905513, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8590, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 429.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20984016, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2442.842374854482, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 406, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1361303, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2185, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10596673, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5963, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8871200, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 36, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 154840, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53161, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2658.05, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 474191097, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8919.905513440304, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72951, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3647.55, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 212348082, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2910.831681539664, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1465742289, "stage_ordering_ns": 550594266, "stage_eval_ns": 1147847717, "stage_threat_ns": 2746641309, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 273204, "root_tactical_annotations": 715, "search_tactical_annotations": 272489, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 129290, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 749829594, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 263936, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1886596363, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34813, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1204060221, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64635, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90151713, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 129270, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15650720, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 75487, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 226730543, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 153621, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 455313587, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 44096, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4412919, "child_limit_applications": 17341, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17341, "child_cap_hits": 17341, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17341, "child_moves_before_total": 1392102, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1392102, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 285558, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 285558, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.27806931549507, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.46721642350499, "tt_hits": 5647, "tt_cutoffs": 761, "beta_cutoffs": 14395, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6454.45, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6854.45, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1645, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 842, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17084, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 97, 127, 126, 143, 159, 158, 113, 95, 79, 173, 188, 129, 98, 140, 101, 157, 115, 125, 70, 84, 100, 99, 85, 130, 55 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8170, "avg_search_time_ms": 628.4615384615385, "search_nodes": 87217, "safety_nodes": 1113, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 88330, "avg_nodes": 6794.615384615385, "eval_calls": 62715, "avg_eval_calls": 4824.2307692307695, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62715, "pattern_eval_ns": 1273442, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.305222036195488, "pattern_frame_queries": 62715, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1273442, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.305222036195488, "pattern_frame_updates": 174320, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2044844250, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11730.405289123451, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22880, "avg_candidate_generations": 1760.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1767950, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.27054195804196, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 916, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 22867, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1767034, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 745179, "avg_legality_checks": 57321.46153846154, "illegal_moves_skipped": 205, "root_legality_checks": 916, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 744263, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 205, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2268011, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 174462.38461538462, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4988918584, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2199.6888833431585, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8844, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 680.3076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30408961, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3438.371890547264, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 249, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2230254, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3489, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20957292, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5103, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7216255, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5160, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52413, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4031.769230769231, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 454700828, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8675.344437448724, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72755, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5596.538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 187338226, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2574.918919661879, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1794516458, "stage_ordering_ns": 729776371, "stage_eval_ns": 2046117692, "stage_threat_ns": 3558112749, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 280672, "root_tactical_annotations": 1369, "search_tactical_annotations": 279303, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 174333, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1013252056, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 273682, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2391260515, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45816, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1692929943, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 87160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 124961886, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 174320, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21381324, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56453, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 57061771, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171403, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 640756698, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 52816, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7256968, "child_limit_applications": 22867, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22867, "child_cap_hits": 22867, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22867, "child_moves_before_total": 1766829, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1766829, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 365883, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 365883, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.26544802553899, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0004810425504, "tt_hits": 7754, "tt_cutoffs": 1578, "beta_cutoffs": 18768, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5204.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5820.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8901, "avg_search_time_ms": 741.75, "search_nodes": 273364, "safety_nodes": 517, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 273881, "avg_nodes": 22823.416666666668, "eval_calls": 267339, "avg_eval_calls": 22278.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 267339, "pattern_eval_ns": 5368095, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.079730230157217, "pattern_frame_queries": 267339, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5368095, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.079730230157217, "pattern_frame_updates": 546658, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5431738746, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9936.264988347377, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6002, "avg_candidate_generations": 500.1666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 491728, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.92735754748418, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 865, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 5990, "search_candidate_moves_total": 490863, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 10972, "avg_legality_checks": 914.3333333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10972, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1486823, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 123901.91666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3434737132, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2310.118374547609, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6988, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 582.3333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60225672, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8618.441900400687, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6988, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60225672, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 29615507, "stage_ordering_ns": 196011, "stage_eval_ns": 5437106841, "stage_threat_ns": 3413247693, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 546670, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2988252833, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 91700, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12370, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 273329, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 360126877, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 546658, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64776283, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 436, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5287, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5818.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6484.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1968, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 843, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14263, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 80, 129, 81, 145, 161, 128, 125, 95, 79, 130, 127, 131, 132, 78, 96, 83, 64, 48, 109, 108, 94, 49, 124 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 6728, "avg_search_time_ms": 517.5384615384615, "search_nodes": 173233, "safety_nodes": 1083, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 174316, "avg_nodes": 13408.923076923076, "eval_calls": 167538, "avg_eval_calls": 12887.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 167538, "pattern_eval_ns": 3385444, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.207021690601536, "pattern_frame_queries": 167538, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3385444, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.207021690601536, "pattern_frame_updates": 346392, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4202004015, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12130.776735605903, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5671, "avg_candidate_generations": 436.2307692307692, "candidate_moves_total": 458083, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.77640627755245, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 938, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 5658, "search_candidate_moves_total": 457145, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 163034, "avg_legality_checks": 12541.076923076924, "illegal_moves_skipped": 179, "root_legality_checks": 938, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 162096, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 179, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1378726, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 106055.84615384616, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3116841227, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2260.6676214128115, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17150, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1319.2307692307693, "renju_forbidden_ns": 116323532, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6782.713236151603, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 181, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1764077, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16964, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 114551925, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7530, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.6153846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 407032, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8660.255319148937, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 185942, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2860.646153846154, "stage_move_gen_ns": 380526824, "stage_ordering_ns": 186461, "stage_eval_ns": 4205389459, "stage_threat_ns": 2115134610, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 346405, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1847801942, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 539772, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 173196, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 226616858, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 346392, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40176038, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 273, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5091, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6003.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6619.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1799, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7524, "avg_search_time_ms": 627.0, "search_nodes": 56416, "safety_nodes": 934, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 57350, "avg_nodes": 4779.166666666667, "eval_calls": 37278, "avg_eval_calls": 3106.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37278, "pattern_eval_ns": 782453, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.989672192714202, "pattern_frame_queries": 37278, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 782453, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.989672192714202, "pattern_frame_updates": 112722, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1308693772, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11609.923280282464, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17862, "avg_candidate_generations": 1488.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1474252, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.53566229985444, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 868, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 17850, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1473384, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1051524, "avg_legality_checks": 87627.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1906, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1051524, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1906, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2455704, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 204642.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5019917549, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2044.1867378967497, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17607, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1467.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 83185579, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4724.574260237406, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1942, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19820920, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4625, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44107598, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11040, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19257061, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99654, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8304.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 897478279, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9005.943354004858, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 133251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11104.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 402552186, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3021.006866740212, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2452260687, "stage_ordering_ns": 567294148, "stage_eval_ns": 1309476225, "stage_threat_ns": 3146064449, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 350160, "root_tactical_annotations": 1391, "search_tactical_annotations": 348769, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 112734, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 666032221, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 308557, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2372293123, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35779, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1227281272, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56361, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 82741198, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 112722, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14007839, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 103533, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 404342730, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 169236, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 740459728, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 77391, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10990068, "child_limit_applications": 17850, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17850, "child_cap_hits": 17850, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17850, "child_moves_before_total": 1471478, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1471478, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 288264, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 288264, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.43574229691876, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.14924369747899, "tt_hits": 7489, "tt_cutoffs": 1233, "beta_cutoffs": 15452, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5203.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5869.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1888, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 844, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8879, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 129, 98, 96, 128, 143, 124, 127, 95, 157, 171, 141, 172, 109, 108, 125, 173, 93 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7201, "avg_search_time_ms": 720.1, "search_nodes": 102432, "safety_nodes": 167, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 102599, "avg_nodes": 10259.9, "eval_calls": 77473, "avg_eval_calls": 7747.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77473, "pattern_eval_ns": 1530556, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.755992410259058, "pattern_frame_queries": 77473, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1530556, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.755992410259058, "pattern_frame_updates": 204780, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1886020829, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9209.98549174724, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23914, "avg_candidate_generations": 2391.4, "candidate_moves_total": 1731892, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.42167767834741, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 576, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 23904, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1731316, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 638994, "avg_legality_checks": 63899.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 114, "root_legality_checks": 576, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 638418, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 114, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2192471, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 219247.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4141564087, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1888.9937823578966, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11854, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1185.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 35931955, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3031.2092964400204, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 182, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 976494, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4757, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25542752, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6915, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9412709, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58796, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5879.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 431416339, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7337.51171848425, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 75224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7522.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 178384415, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2371.3763559502286, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1359464484, "stage_ordering_ns": 616805821, "stage_eval_ns": 1887551385, "stage_threat_ns": 3303322061, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 294311, "root_tactical_annotations": 2017, "search_tactical_annotations": 292294, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 204790, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1026464469, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 276998, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2117589177, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47869, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1505471202, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 129568620, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 204780, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22360677, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 84645, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 102417552, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 144475, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 509599873, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 65191, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7339118, "child_limit_applications": 23904, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23904, "child_cap_hits": 23904, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23904, "child_moves_before_total": 1731202, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1731202, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 382492, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 382492, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.42310910307899, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001171352074966, "tt_hits": 9671, "tt_cutoffs": 1013, "beta_cutoffs": 18850, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4349.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5149.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1084, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1667, "avg_search_time_ms": 185.22222222222223, "search_nodes": 68066, "safety_nodes": 449, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68515, "avg_nodes": 7612.777777777777, "eval_calls": 64381, "avg_eval_calls": 7153.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64381, "pattern_eval_ns": 1222773, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.992761839673197, "pattern_frame_queries": 64381, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1222773, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.992761839673197, "pattern_frame_updates": 136080, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 974687120, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7162.603762492651, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3668, "avg_candidate_generations": 407.55555555555554, "candidate_moves_total": 255356, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.61723009814612, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 516, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 3659, "search_candidate_moves_total": 254840, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 7053, "avg_legality_checks": 783.6666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7053, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 337183, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 37464.77777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 598915326, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1776.232271496487, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1030, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 114.44444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5988922, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5814.487378640777, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1030, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 5988922, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14460004, "stage_ordering_ns": 112841, "stage_eval_ns": 975909893, "stage_threat_ns": 664009288, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136089, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 577590386, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 109110, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7350, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 70933150, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136080, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15376642, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 231, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3226, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5569.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6458.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 845, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3647, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 84, 85, 99, 126, 69, 114, 83, 111, 67, 52, 51, 35, 115 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1020, "avg_search_time_ms": 127.5, "search_nodes": 37214, "safety_nodes": 411, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 37625, "avg_nodes": 4703.125, "eval_calls": 35213, "avg_eval_calls": 4401.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35213, "pattern_eval_ns": 657916, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.683895152358502, "pattern_frame_queries": 35213, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 657916, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.683895152358502, "pattern_frame_updates": 74384, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 613302789, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8245.09019412777, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1987, "avg_candidate_generations": 248.375, "candidate_moves_total": 125917, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.3704076497232, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 444, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 1979, "search_candidate_moves_total": 125473, "search_candidate_moves_max": 85, "legality_checks": 32316, "avg_legality_checks": 4039.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 444, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 31872, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 285521, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 35690.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 435707006, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1526.0068646439315, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5567, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 695.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19748425, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3547.408837794144, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 63380, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5553, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19683165, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1880, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 112090, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4151.481481481482, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 34, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 39620, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1165.2941176470588, "stage_move_gen_ns": 55509350, "stage_ordering_ns": 65820, "stage_eval_ns": 613960705, "stage_threat_ns": 339105649, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 74392, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 295552386, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 172570, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37192, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 36803388, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 74384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6577305, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 224, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1677, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5302.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6302.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1866, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 2619, "avg_search_time_ms": 374.14285714285717, "search_nodes": 34352, "safety_nodes": 430, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34782, "avg_nodes": 4968.857142857143, "eval_calls": 23139, "avg_eval_calls": 3305.5714285714284, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23139, "pattern_eval_ns": 431836, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.66269069536281, "pattern_frame_queries": 23139, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 431836, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.66269069536281, "pattern_frame_updates": 68644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 516498425, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7524.305474622691, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10574, "avg_candidate_generations": 1510.5714285714287, "candidate_moves_total": 729093, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.9514847739739, "candidate_moves_max": 92, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 383, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 10567, "search_candidate_moves_total": 728710, "search_candidate_moves_max": 92, "legality_checks": 467793, "avg_legality_checks": 66827.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 758, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 467793, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 758, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1253924, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 179132.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1658122281, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1322.3467139954255, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7141, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1020.1428571428571, "renju_forbidden_ns": 24535991, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3435.9320823414087, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 768, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4064000, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2836, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15630766, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3537, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4841225, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48681, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6954.428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 289006989, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5936.751278732976, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65044, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9292.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 134104158, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2061.7452493696574, "stage_move_gen_ns": 710792801, "stage_ordering_ns": 198424965, "stage_eval_ns": 516930261, "stage_threat_ns": 1169597689, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 162312, "root_tactical_annotations": 556, "search_tactical_annotations": 161756, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 68651, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 266492803, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 148496, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 858085183, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21178, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 480347489, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34322, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 35082876, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 68644, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5841657, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 35218, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 104755346, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 92095, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 272849956, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 34999, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4095170, "child_limit_applications": 10567, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10567, "child_cap_hits": 10567, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10567, "child_moves_before_total": 727952, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 727952, "child_moves_before_max": 92, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 92, "child_moves_after_total": 169073, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 169073, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.8891833065203, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000094634238668, "tt_hits": 3534, "tt_cutoffs": 616, "beta_cutoffs": 9070, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 4.285714285714286, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 4.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4198.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5341.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1874, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 846, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23366, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 84, 141, 83, 81, 126, 98, 85, 86, 97, 127, 155, 143, 111, 128, 158, 125, 142, 110, 69, 55, 53, 101, 54, 99, 67, 52, 66, 100, 102, 72, 114, 58, 44, 68, 39, 24, 11, 25, 157, 156, 116, 56, 21, 37, 130, 144, 40, 26, 27, 57, 59, 22, 23, 41, 71, 73, 9, 89 ], "move_count": 62, "black_stats": { "move_count": 31, "search_move_count": 29, "total_time_ms": 19719, "avg_search_time_ms": 679.9655172413793, "search_nodes": 384378, "safety_nodes": 1485, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 385863, "avg_nodes": 13305.620689655172, "eval_calls": 306375, "avg_eval_calls": 10564.655172413793, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 306375, "pattern_eval_ns": 5699652, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.6035152998776, "pattern_frame_queries": 306375, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5699652, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.6035152998776, "pattern_frame_updates": 768476, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6438691753, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8378.52028300168, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 73560, "avg_candidate_generations": 2536.551724137931, "candidate_moves_total": 6270846, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.24804241435562, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 29, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2251, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 73531, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6268595, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 2487138, "avg_legality_checks": 85763.37931034483, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1257, "root_legality_checks": 2251, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2484887, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1257, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8409210, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 289972.7586206897, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11116714180, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1321.9689102781356, "renju_forbidden_checks": 107167, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3695.4137931034484, "renju_forbidden_ns": 245573203, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2291.5002099526905, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3072, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9701603, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 55994, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 181018263, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 48095, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 54848647, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4690, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 250647, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8643.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1232603925, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4917.688721588529, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 303214, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10455.655172413793, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 489308036, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1613.7382706603257, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3603447924, "stage_ordering_ns": 1481964398, "stage_eval_ns": 6444391405, "stage_threat_ns": 8045183810, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1746725, "root_tactical_annotations": 6056, "search_tactical_annotations": 1740669, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 768505, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2775456502, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1536367, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4781285114, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 147260, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2857779724, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 384238, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 386092101, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 768476, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64524135, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 669137, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 372209280, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 719949, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1551062519, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 357639, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 37825958, "child_limit_applications": 73531, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 73531, "child_cap_hits": 73531, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 73531, "child_moves_before_total": 6267338, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6267338, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 1186976, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1186976, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.23395574655588, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.142524921461696, "tt_hits": 30693, "tt_cutoffs": 4332, "beta_cutoffs": 53610, "depth_sum": 140, "avg_depth": 4.827586206896552, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 140, "avg_effective_depth": 4.827586206896552, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 27 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 29, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6686.068965517241, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6961.931034482759, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 749, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 31, "search_move_count": 29, "total_time_ms": 3617, "avg_search_time_ms": 124.72413793103448, "search_nodes": 212317, "safety_nodes": 2593, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 214910, "avg_nodes": 7410.689655172414, "eval_calls": 203584, "avg_eval_calls": 7020.137931034483, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 203584, "pattern_eval_ns": 3721792, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.281358063502044, "pattern_frame_queries": 203584, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3721792, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.281358063502044, "pattern_frame_updates": 424464, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2054718077, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 4840.73579149233, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8677, "avg_candidate_generations": 299.2068965517241, "candidate_moves_total": 744830, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.83957589028466, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 29, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2278, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 8648, "search_candidate_moves_total": 742552, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 17058, "avg_legality_checks": 588.2068965517242, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 17058, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1130024, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 38966.34482758621, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1307637783, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1157.1770006654726, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7466, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 257.44827586206895, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15385234, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2060.7064023573535, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7459, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15375864, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9370, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 26783179, "stage_ordering_ns": 257852, "stage_eval_ns": 2058439869, "stage_threat_ns": 1467246126, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 424493, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1255010163, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 78, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 381853, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 57, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 212232, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 180434197, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 424464, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31419913, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 682, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7440, "depth_sum": 85, "avg_depth": 2.9310344827586206, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 85, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9310344827586206, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 28 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 29, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7241.413793103448, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7517.275862068966, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1554, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 847, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5286, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 126, 141, 99, 143, 98, 155, 169, 140, 142, 158, 100, 173, 128, 188, 203, 156, 101, 97, 102 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2385, "avg_search_time_ms": 216.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 101499, "safety_nodes": 671, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 102170, "avg_nodes": 9288.181818181818, "eval_calls": 97804, "avg_eval_calls": 8891.272727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 97804, "pattern_eval_ns": 1755363, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 17.947762872684144, "pattern_frame_queries": 97804, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1755363, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 17.947762872684144, "pattern_frame_updates": 202936, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1450993186, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7150.003873142271, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3675, "avg_candidate_generations": 334.09090909090907, "candidate_moves_total": 247290, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.28979591836735, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 699, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 3664, "search_candidate_moves_total": 246591, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 92992, "avg_legality_checks": 8453.818181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 699, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 92293, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 706353, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 64213.90909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 968536863, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1371.1796552148855, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7642, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 694.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37009307, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4842.882360638576, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 210430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7600, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 36798877, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 30, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.727272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 139010, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4633.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.4545454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 54290, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1428.6842105263158, "stage_move_gen_ns": 137444536, "stage_ordering_ns": 107870, "stage_eval_ns": 1452748549, "stage_threat_ns": 772679790, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 202947, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 668326342, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 207071, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 101468, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88454413, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 202936, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15691964, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 241, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3260, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5826.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6554.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1874, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2892, "avg_search_time_ms": 289.2, "search_nodes": 50510, "safety_nodes": 972, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 51482, "avg_nodes": 5148.2, "eval_calls": 36400, "avg_eval_calls": 3640.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36400, "pattern_eval_ns": 664703, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.26107142857143, "pattern_frame_queries": 36400, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 664703, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.26107142857143, "pattern_frame_updates": 100930, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 523893227, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5190.659139998019, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13513, "avg_candidate_generations": 1351.3, "candidate_moves_total": 988525, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.15362983793383, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 636, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 13503, "search_candidate_moves_total": 987889, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 571087, "avg_legality_checks": 57108.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 62, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 571087, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 62, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1453562, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 145356.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1747403827, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1202.1529367168378, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4383, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 438.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8767748, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2000.3988135979923, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 62, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 332853, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 909, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 5995294, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3412, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2439601, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4715.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 255909278, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5427.556267232238, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65665, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6566.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 120995006, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1842.6103099063428, "stage_move_gen_ns": 782111743, "stage_ordering_ns": 242035646, "stage_eval_ns": 524557930, "stage_threat_ns": 1313873666, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 157790, "root_tactical_annotations": 631, "search_tactical_annotations": 157159, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 100940, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 347061978, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 147732, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 908944883, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27071, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 578763059, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50465, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 46190898, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 100930, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7863480, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 33635, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 118912516, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 87017, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 210991666, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 37138, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3812427, "child_limit_applications": 13503, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13503, "child_cap_hits": 13503, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13503, "child_moves_before_total": 987827, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 987827, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 216061, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 216061, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.15611345626898, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000962749018736, "tt_hits": 4903, "tt_cutoffs": 562, "beta_cutoffs": 11123, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5416.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6216.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1929, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 848, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4253, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 141, 99, 125, 97, 109, 108, 93, 157, 77 ], "move_count": 15, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 3285, "avg_search_time_ms": 547.5, "search_nodes": 43786, "safety_nodes": 295, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 44081, "avg_nodes": 7346.833333333333, "eval_calls": 33906, "avg_eval_calls": 5651.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33906, "pattern_eval_ns": 724762, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.37562673273167, "pattern_frame_queries": 33906, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 724762, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.37562673273167, "pattern_frame_updates": 87528, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 815926752, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9321.894159583218, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9436, "avg_candidate_generations": 1572.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 651064, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.99788045782111, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 325, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 9430, "search_candidate_moves_total": 650739, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 240577, "avg_legality_checks": 40096.166666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 325, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 240252, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 795911, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 132651.83333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1847633124, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2321.4066949696635, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3371, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 561.8333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 11053050, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3278.863838623554, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 135510, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1246, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8202595, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2101, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2712045, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2900, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15956, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2659.3333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 151174973, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9474.490661820006, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20996, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3499.3333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 65881661, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3137.8196323109164, "stage_move_gen_ns": 619109351, "stage_ordering_ns": 294391488, "stage_eval_ns": 816651514, "stage_threat_ns": 1538270241, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 67199, "root_tactical_annotations": 733, "search_tactical_annotations": 66466, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 87534, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 517497545, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 72322, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 941789746, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18893, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 726359841, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43764, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 66711687, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 87528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10784708, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 11057, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 18857353, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 42367, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 196372841, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 13775, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1486555, "child_limit_applications": 9430, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9430, "child_cap_hits": 9430, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9430, "child_moves_before_total": 650729, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 650729, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 150880, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 150880, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.00625662778367, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 3621, "tt_cutoffs": 428, "beta_cutoffs": 7204, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2843.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4177.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1042, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 7, "search_move_count": 5, "total_time_ms": 962, "avg_search_time_ms": 192.4, "search_nodes": 31696, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 31896, "avg_nodes": 6379.2, "eval_calls": 30280, "avg_eval_calls": 6056.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 30280, "pattern_eval_ns": 645483, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.31714002642008, "pattern_frame_queries": 30280, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 645483, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.31714002642008, "pattern_frame_updates": 63364, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 498238146, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7863.110693769333, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1407, "avg_candidate_generations": 281.4, "candidate_moves_total": 88619, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.98436389481166, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 5, "root_candidate_moves_total": 266, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 1402, "search_candidate_moves_total": 88353, "search_candidate_moves_max": 83, "legality_checks": 4089, "avg_legality_checks": 817.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4089, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 107323, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21464.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 260712152, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2429.229074848821, "renju_forbidden_checks": 432, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 86.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2551601, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5906.4837962962965, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 432, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 2551601, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11648078, "stage_ordering_ns": 48813, "stage_eval_ns": 498883629, "stage_threat_ns": 449832948, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 63369, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 390965218, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 56020, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 10, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 31682, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 50711534, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 63364, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8100176, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 107, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1221, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3510.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5110.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1970, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 849, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16803, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 84, 125, 83, 139, 153, 126, 129, 99, 85, 124, 127, 123, 122, 86, 98, 81, 70, 56, 115, 116, 100, 55, 130 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8046, "avg_search_time_ms": 618.9230769230769, "search_nodes": 191808, "safety_nodes": 1083, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 192891, "avg_nodes": 14837.76923076923, "eval_calls": 185846, "avg_eval_calls": 14295.846153846154, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 185846, "pattern_eval_ns": 3998727, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.516346867836813, "pattern_frame_queries": 185846, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3998727, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.516346867836813, "pattern_frame_updates": 383542, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5008201954, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13057.766695694343, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5938, "avg_candidate_generations": 456.7692307692308, "candidate_moves_total": 478279, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.5454698551701, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 938, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 5925, "search_candidate_moves_total": 477341, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 181552, "avg_legality_checks": 13965.538461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 162, "root_legality_checks": 938, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 180614, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 162, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1507380, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 115952.30769230769, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3704538828, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2457.601154320742, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18412, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1416.3076923076924, "renju_forbidden_ns": 133342324, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7242.142298500978, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 164, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1640495, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18243, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 131693868, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7961, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.6153846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 464332, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9879.404255319148, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 215752, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3319.2615384615383, "stage_move_gen_ns": 463568925, "stage_ordering_ns": 203190, "stage_eval_ns": 5012200681, "stage_threat_ns": 2548549452, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 383555, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2219658657, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 610582, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13590, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 191771, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 280557624, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 383542, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47722589, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 273, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5346, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5856.307692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6471.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1782, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8746, "avg_search_time_ms": 728.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 58984, "safety_nodes": 934, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59918, "avg_nodes": 4993.166666666667, "eval_calls": 38526, "avg_eval_calls": 3210.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38526, "pattern_eval_ns": 858795, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.29130976483414, "pattern_frame_queries": 38526, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 858795, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.29130976483414, "pattern_frame_updates": 117858, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1461100549, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12397.126618473078, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19143, "avg_candidate_generations": 1595.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1559115, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.4456981664316, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 868, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 19131, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1558247, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1146489, "avg_legality_checks": 95540.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4774, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1146489, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4774, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2682144, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 223512.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5823567573, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2171.235986211031, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25309, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2109.0833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 158774820, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6273.452921885495, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4810, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52111385, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7162, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 74618645, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13337, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32044790, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 114781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9565.083333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1113490921, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9701.003833387058, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 150888, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12574.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 499465896, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3310.1763957372355, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2877541881, "stage_ordering_ns": 642108030, "stage_eval_ns": 1461959344, "stage_threat_ns": 3712493085, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 374416, "root_tactical_annotations": 1391, "search_tactical_annotations": 373025, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 117870, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 744689156, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 337717, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2847242846, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38341, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1438995259, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58929, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 95183693, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 117858, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15639759, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 110577, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 465532908, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 188790, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 942487287, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 75049, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9737631, "child_limit_applications": 19131, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19131, "child_cap_hits": 19131, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19131, "child_moves_before_total": 1553473, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1553473, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 308804, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 308804, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.2018713083477, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.141550363284722, "tt_hits": 7476, "tt_cutoffs": 1272, "beta_cutoffs": 16639, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4866.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5533.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1872, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 850, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10845, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 125, 96, 98, 126, 141, 130, 127, 99, 157, 173, 143, 172, 115, 116, 129, 171, 101 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8745, "avg_search_time_ms": 874.5, "search_nodes": 103055, "safety_nodes": 167, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 103222, "avg_nodes": 10322.2, "eval_calls": 77739, "avg_eval_calls": 7773.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77739, "pattern_eval_ns": 1696969, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.829056200877293, "pattern_frame_queries": 77739, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1696969, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.829056200877293, "pattern_frame_updates": 206026, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2223935431, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10794.440657975207, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24222, "avg_candidate_generations": 2422.2, "candidate_moves_total": 1756349, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.51048633473701, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 576, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 24212, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1755773, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 654816, "avg_legality_checks": 65481.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "root_legality_checks": 576, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 654240, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2203563, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 220356.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5045113215, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2289.52528927015, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11598, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1159.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 40831924, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3520.600448353164, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 168, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1033208, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4428, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28314522, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7002, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11484194, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58433, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5843.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 502445124, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8598.653569044889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 73926, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7392.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 197191565, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2667.4182966750536, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1677064414, "stage_ordering_ns": 777041441, "stage_eval_ns": 2225632400, "stage_threat_ns": 4032483813, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 295891, "root_tactical_annotations": 2017, "search_tactical_annotations": 293874, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 206036, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1247638075, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 279024, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2593631011, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48485, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1870908429, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 103013, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156784082, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 206026, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27557214, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 85113, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 125775782, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 145417, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 596832689, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 65361, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6873431, "child_limit_applications": 24212, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24212, "child_cap_hits": 24212, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24212, "child_moves_before_total": 1755677, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1755677, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 387406, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 387406, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.51267966297704, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00057822567322, "tt_hits": 9711, "tt_cutoffs": 1062, "beta_cutoffs": 19141, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3745.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4545.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1031, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2091, "avg_search_time_ms": 232.33333333333334, "search_nodes": 64160, "safety_nodes": 449, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 64609, "avg_nodes": 7178.777777777777, "eval_calls": 60441, "avg_eval_calls": 6715.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60441, "pattern_eval_ns": 1306906, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.62283880147582, "pattern_frame_queries": 60441, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1306906, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.62283880147582, "pattern_frame_updates": 128268, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1186005113, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9246.30549318614, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3702, "avg_candidate_generations": 411.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 255465, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.00729335494327, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 516, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 3693, "search_candidate_moves_total": 254949, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 6891, "avg_legality_checks": 765.6666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6891, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 296372, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32930.22222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 711466258, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2400.585271213205, "renju_forbidden_checks": 589, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 65.44444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5276527, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8958.449915110357, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 589, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 5276527, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19709859, "stage_ordering_ns": 126811, "stage_eval_ns": 1187312019, "stage_threat_ns": 871711850, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 128277, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 760775227, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 166421, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9780, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64134, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94472126, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128268, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16298076, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 231, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3276, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5505.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6394.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 851, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20182, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 81, 129, 96, 130, 131, 111, 95, 157, 172, 98, 67, 109, 65, 49, 66, 64, 93, 94, 79, 51, 68, 69, 110, 50, 82, 54, 124 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 5615, "avg_search_time_ms": 374.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 142812, "safety_nodes": 1634, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 144446, "avg_nodes": 9629.733333333334, "eval_calls": 138883, "avg_eval_calls": 9258.866666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 138883, "pattern_eval_ns": 2967657, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.36803640474356, "pattern_frame_queries": 138883, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2967657, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.36803640474356, "pattern_frame_updates": 285536, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3307433066, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11583.243675053232, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3900, "avg_candidate_generations": 260.0, "candidate_moves_total": 271237, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.54794871794871, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1101, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 3885, "search_candidate_moves_total": 270136, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 137179, "avg_legality_checks": 9145.266666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "root_legality_checks": 1101, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 136078, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 43, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 910754, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 60716.933333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2194234307, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2409.250255282985, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13861, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 924.0666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 130683808, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9428.165933193854, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 404452, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13754, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 129974613, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 304743, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.933333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 723113, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9771.797297297297, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 365511, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3847.4842105263156, "stage_move_gen_ns": 351455546, "stage_ordering_ns": 138790, "stage_eval_ns": 3310400723, "stage_threat_ns": 1945961191, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 285551, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1694220187, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 41, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1038573, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14470, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 142768, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 214712044, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 285536, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35990387, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 126, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3607, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5655.266666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6188.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 438, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 14552, "avg_search_time_ms": 970.1333333333333, "search_nodes": 124182, "safety_nodes": 576, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 124758, "avg_nodes": 8317.2, "eval_calls": 85716, "avg_eval_calls": 5714.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 85716, "pattern_eval_ns": 1831562, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.367795977413785, "pattern_frame_queries": 85716, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1831562, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.367795977413785, "pattern_frame_updates": 248230, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2418054801, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9741.186806590662, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 36505, "avg_candidate_generations": 2433.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 3241166, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.78690590330092, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1126, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 36490, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3240040, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 2399274, "avg_legality_checks": 159951.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 19339, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2399274, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 19339, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5253588, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 350239.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9194332469, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1750.1053506670107, "renju_forbidden_checks": 78513, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5234.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 493083337, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6280.276349139633, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 19461, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 166279398, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25358, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 233123760, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 33640, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 93264219, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 54, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 415960, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 219982, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14665.466666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1858731420, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8449.470502131993, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 280361, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18690.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 927842296, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3309.4556518203317, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4897330952, "stage_ordering_ns": 1095842929, "stage_eval_ns": 2419886363, "stage_threat_ns": 6048742484, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 862643, "root_tactical_annotations": 3437, "search_tactical_annotations": 859206, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 248245, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1334666124, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 738423, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4479826518, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 73076, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2193547172, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124115, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 180646252, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 248230, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28670756, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 351026, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1075996675, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 314310, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1210179360, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 197307, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24932834, "child_limit_applications": 36490, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 36490, "child_cap_hits": 36490, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 36490, "child_moves_before_total": 3220701, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3220701, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 585236, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 585236, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.26256508632503, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.038257056727872, "tt_hits": 16832, "tt_cutoffs": 1909, "beta_cutoffs": 30990, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6110.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6644.133333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1624, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 852, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16948, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 97, 127, 128, 141, 155, 156, 111, 99, 85, 171, 186, 125, 96, 144, 95, 93, 109, 114, 64, 80, 94, 98, 79, 124, 49 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 9255, "avg_search_time_ms": 711.9230769230769, "search_nodes": 90845, "safety_nodes": 1116, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91961, "avg_nodes": 7073.923076923077, "eval_calls": 64852, "avg_eval_calls": 4988.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64852, "pattern_eval_ns": 1411087, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.75857336705113, "pattern_frame_queries": 64852, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1411087, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.75857336705113, "pattern_frame_updates": 181576, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2314863490, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12748.73050403137, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24328, "avg_candidate_generations": 1871.3846153846155, "candidate_moves_total": 1927195, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.21715718513647, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 911, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 24315, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1926284, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 792946, "avg_legality_checks": 60995.846153846156, "illegal_moves_skipped": 285, "root_legality_checks": 911, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 792035, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 285, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2434327, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 187255.92307692306, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5659547703, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2324.892137744847, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9260, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 712.3076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 39330236, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4247.325701943844, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 308, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3248585, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27142577, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5328, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8933824, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58236, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4479.692307692308, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 544719563, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9353.656896078028, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81392, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6260.923076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 230480914, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2831.7391635541576, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2018815091, "stage_ordering_ns": 846428882, "stage_eval_ns": 2316274577, "stage_threat_ns": 4034870712, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 281639, "root_tactical_annotations": 1334, "search_tactical_annotations": 280305, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 181589, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1127188282, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 282615, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2734415567, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48712, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1920011381, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 90788, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 142457744, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 181576, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24515917, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56318, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 68210427, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 177575, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 745574817, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 47746, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6293202, "child_limit_applications": 24315, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24315, "child_cap_hits": 24315, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24315, "child_moves_before_total": 1925999, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1925999, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 389054, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 389054, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.21032284597985, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00057577626979, "tt_hits": 8146, "tt_cutoffs": 1622, "beta_cutoffs": 20100, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5042.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5658.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7679, "avg_search_time_ms": 639.9166666666666, "search_nodes": 220445, "safety_nodes": 667, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 221112, "avg_nodes": 18426.0, "eval_calls": 215402, "avg_eval_calls": 17950.166666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 215402, "pattern_eval_ns": 4638165, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.532599511610847, "pattern_frame_queries": 215402, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4638165, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.532599511610847, "pattern_frame_updates": 440820, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4687826165, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10634.331847466086, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5020, "avg_candidate_generations": 418.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 394994, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.68406374501993, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 851, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 5008, "search_candidate_moves_total": 394143, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 8829, "avg_legality_checks": 735.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8829, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1203124, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 100260.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2949739181, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2451.733305128981, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6279, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 523.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 63250057, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10073.269151138717, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6279, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 63250057, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 25542255, "stage_ordering_ns": 168660, "stage_eval_ns": 4692464330, "stage_threat_ns": 2946057936, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 440832, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2573283082, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 165460, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 220410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 316924672, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 440820, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55684722, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 350, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4443, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5766.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6432.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1963, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 853, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5128, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 80, 79, 95, 128, 65, 110, 81, 113, 67, 52, 53, 39, 109 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1568, "avg_search_time_ms": 196.0, "search_nodes": 38987, "safety_nodes": 411, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 39398, "avg_nodes": 4924.75, "eval_calls": 36951, "avg_eval_calls": 4618.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36951, "pattern_eval_ns": 803304, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.739709344807988, "pattern_frame_queries": 36951, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 803304, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.739709344807988, "pattern_frame_updates": 77930, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 950759814, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12200.177261645065, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2022, "avg_candidate_generations": 252.75, "candidate_moves_total": 128277, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.4406528189911, "candidate_moves_max": 84, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 444, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 2014, "search_candidate_moves_total": 127833, "search_candidate_moves_max": 84, "legality_checks": 34006, "avg_legality_checks": 4250.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 444, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 33562, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 302479, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 37809.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 706150604, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2334.54422951676, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5253, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 656.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32106835, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6112.09499333714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 115091, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5239, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31988904, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2840, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 205031, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7593.740740740741, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 34, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 66720, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1962.3529411764705, "stage_move_gen_ns": 83146368, "stage_ordering_ns": 75460, "stage_eval_ns": 951563118, "stage_threat_ns": 520800347, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 77938, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 455809101, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 310661, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38965, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 55191852, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 77930, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9488733, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 224, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1710, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5258.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6258.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1855, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 3550, "avg_search_time_ms": 507.14285714285717, "search_nodes": 29592, "safety_nodes": 430, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 30022, "avg_nodes": 4288.857142857143, "eval_calls": 19812, "avg_eval_calls": 2830.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 19812, "pattern_eval_ns": 434471, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.929689077326874, "pattern_frame_queries": 19812, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 434471, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.929689077326874, "pattern_frame_updates": 59124, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 667979186, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11297.936303362425, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9143, "avg_candidate_generations": 1306.142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 629924, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.89686098654708, "candidate_moves_max": 92, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 383, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 9136, "search_candidate_moves_total": 629541, "search_candidate_moves_max": 92, "legality_checks": 407942, "avg_legality_checks": 58277.42857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 236, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 407942, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 236, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1069810, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 152830.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2306232332, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2155.7401145997887, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5250, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 750.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 26931696, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5129.8468571428575, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 246, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2501044, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2067, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18843464, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2937, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5587188, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39934, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5704.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 397374546, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9950.782441027695, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 53815, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7687.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 186207834, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3460.1474310136578, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1015175776, "stage_ordering_ns": 265687574, "stage_eval_ns": 668413657, "stage_threat_ns": 1578592604, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 140638, "root_tactical_annotations": 556, "search_tactical_annotations": 140082, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 59131, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 363103533, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 126583, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1157973234, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18316, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 644790916, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 29562, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 45644881, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 59124, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7661913, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 30938, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 152914649, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 77324, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 360120919, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 32376, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4209043, "child_limit_applications": 9136, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9136, "child_cap_hits": 9136, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9136, "child_moves_before_total": 629305, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 629305, "child_moves_before_max": 92, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 92, "child_moves_after_total": 146177, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 146177, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.88189579684763, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00010945709282, "tt_hits": 3357, "tt_cutoffs": 614, "beta_cutoffs": 7839, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 4.285714285714286, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 4.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3803.285714285714, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4946.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1849, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 854, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13868, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 127, 97, 96, 83, 69, 68, 113, 53, 38, 99, 128, 125, 139, 80, 131, 67, 115, 95, 160, 144, 130, 129, 145, 100, 175 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7690, "avg_search_time_ms": 591.5384615384615, "search_nodes": 83745, "safety_nodes": 1109, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 84854, "avg_nodes": 6527.2307692307695, "eval_calls": 60117, "avg_eval_calls": 4624.384615384615, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60117, "pattern_eval_ns": 1303158, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.677029791905785, "pattern_frame_queries": 60117, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1303158, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.677029791905785, "pattern_frame_updates": 167376, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1827797247, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10920.306656868368, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21763, "avg_candidate_generations": 1674.076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 1598318, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.44198869641134, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 899, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 21750, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1597419, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 691693, "avg_legality_checks": 53207.153846153844, "illegal_moves_skipped": 226, "root_legality_checks": 899, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 690794, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 226, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2033687, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 156437.46153846153, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4623017536, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2273.2197904593972, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9540, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 733.8461538461538, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32647222, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3422.1406708595387, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 290, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2588202, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3125, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21814307, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6122, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8239233, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5480, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50359, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3873.769230769231, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 448540025, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8906.84932186898, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68487, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5268.2307692307695, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 179688313, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2623.684976710909, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1737117467, "stage_ordering_ns": 666870210, "stage_eval_ns": 1829100405, "stage_threat_ns": 3415360878, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 282472, "root_tactical_annotations": 1304, "search_tactical_annotations": 281168, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 167389, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1008617556, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 274380, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2253773972, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43582, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1559477511, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 83688, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125298807, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 167376, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21877758, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62988, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 58820793, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 167800, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 634926164, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 51684, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5792785, "child_limit_applications": 21750, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21750, "child_cap_hits": 21750, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21750, "child_moves_before_total": 1597193, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1597193, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 348019, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 348019, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.43416091954023, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00087356321839, "tt_hits": 7628, "tt_cutoffs": 1822, "beta_cutoffs": 17907, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5274.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5890.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6164, "avg_search_time_ms": 513.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 204148, "safety_nodes": 637, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 204785, "avg_nodes": 17065.416666666668, "eval_calls": 198377, "avg_eval_calls": 16531.416666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 198377, "pattern_eval_ns": 4265612, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.50255321937523, "pattern_frame_queries": 198377, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4265612, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.50255321937523, "pattern_frame_updates": 408226, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3463835998, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8485.094036146644, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5748, "avg_candidate_generations": 479.0, "candidate_moves_total": 432096, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.17327766179541, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 848, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 5736, "search_candidate_moves_total": 431248, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 15997, "avg_legality_checks": 1333.0833333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 15997, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 839178, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 69931.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2042114910, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2433.470503278208, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4388, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 365.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44162335, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10064.342525068369, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4388, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44162335, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 41721512, "stage_ordering_ns": 207130, "stage_eval_ns": 3468101610, "stage_threat_ns": 2621218028, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 408238, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2292306574, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 145370, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 204113, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 279476223, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 408226, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49289861, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 399, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5131, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5842.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6509.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1969, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 855, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24642, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 140, 82, 114, 156, 141, 143, 127, 100, 155, 84, 70, 113, 125, 110, 109, 157, 139, 138, 124, 154, 171, 123, 153, 111, 170, 185, 167, 181, 169, 183, 168 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 1972, "avg_search_time_ms": 123.25, "search_nodes": 50063, "safety_nodes": 1656, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 51719, "avg_nodes": 3232.4375, "eval_calls": 47222, "avg_eval_calls": 2951.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47222, "pattern_eval_ns": 974565, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.63794417856084, "pattern_frame_queries": 47222, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 974565, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.63794417856084, "pattern_frame_updates": 100032, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1184747702, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11843.687040147153, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2810, "avg_candidate_generations": 175.625, "candidate_moves_total": 208836, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.31886120996441, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1169, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 2794, "search_candidate_moves_total": 207667, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 43885, "avg_legality_checks": 2742.8125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 1169, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 42716, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 19, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 376459, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23528.6875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 886241216, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2354.1506937010404, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3038, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 189.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 27150398, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8936.931533903884, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 169292, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3007, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26895926, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 85180, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 86, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 864994, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10058.06976744186, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 462242, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3820.181818181818, "stage_move_gen_ns": 108645300, "stage_ordering_ns": 94391, "stage_eval_ns": 1185722267, "stage_threat_ns": 652379894, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 100048, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 572218671, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1171594, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50016, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 67057913, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 100032, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11931716, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 182, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2492, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6586.6875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7086.6875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1757, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 22653, "avg_search_time_ms": 1415.8125, "search_nodes": 238913, "safety_nodes": 252, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 239165, "avg_nodes": 14947.8125, "eval_calls": 185294, "avg_eval_calls": 11580.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 185294, "pattern_eval_ns": 3884289, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.962842833551004, "pattern_frame_queries": 185294, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3884289, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.962842833551004, "pattern_frame_updates": 477682, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4763818176, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9972.781423624921, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 51042, "avg_candidate_generations": 3190.125, "candidate_moves_total": 4497794, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.11947024019435, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1196, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 51026, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4496598, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 2976209, "avg_legality_checks": 186013.0625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4690, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2976209, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4690, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7337081, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 458567.5625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14305242004, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1949.7184239890496, "renju_forbidden_checks": 70417, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4401.0625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 226524733, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3216.9040572589006, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4700, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 42111061, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11208, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 100118738, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 54499, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 84186563, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 108371, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 284746, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17796.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2587522711, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9087.12575769282, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 401394, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25087.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1262346836, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3144.9070887955477, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6688435325, "stage_ordering_ns": 1642897373, "stage_eval_ns": 4767702465, "stage_threat_ns": 9434424872, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1191355, "root_tactical_annotations": 4572, "search_tactical_annotations": 1186783, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 477698, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2581775479, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1009734, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6417834453, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 102155, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3122216673, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 238841, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 338538434, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 477682, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56320694, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 438772, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1491617401, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 468793, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1803936099, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 283790, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 39955812, "child_limit_applications": 51026, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 51026, "child_cap_hits": 51026, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 51026, "child_moves_before_total": 4491908, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4491908, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 842294, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 842294, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.03174852036217, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.507153216007527, "tt_hits": 22295, "tt_cutoffs": 2521, "beta_cutoffs": 39187, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5055.8125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5555.8125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1758, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 856, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12265, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 114, 156, 113, 111, 66, 82, 126, 140, 84, 70, 99, 69, 97, 170, 184, 96, 129, 144, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9697, "avg_search_time_ms": 881.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 103763, "safety_nodes": 171, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 103934, "avg_nodes": 9448.545454545454, "eval_calls": 75036, "avg_eval_calls": 6821.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75036, "pattern_eval_ns": 1588509, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.16995841995842, "pattern_frame_queries": 75036, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1588509, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.16995841995842, "pattern_frame_updates": 207432, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2734566604, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13182.954433260056, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26860, "avg_candidate_generations": 2441.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2207464, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.18406552494416, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 26849, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2206678, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 676854, "avg_legality_checks": 61532.181818181816, "illegal_moves_skipped": 446, "root_legality_checks": 786, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 676068, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 446, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2609471, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 237224.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5759167101, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2207.0247575083226, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23930, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2175.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 100111809, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4183.527329711659, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 562, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3194184, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11366, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71317282, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12002, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25600343, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 71396, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6490.545454545455, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 656156072, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9190.375819373634, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98916, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8992.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 289052151, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2922.1981378139026, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1657395194, "stage_ordering_ns": 932414340, "stage_eval_ns": 2736155113, "stage_threat_ns": 4328509993, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 372569, "root_tactical_annotations": 2729, "search_tactical_annotations": 369840, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 207443, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1222174138, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 337467, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2918528066, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53766, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2011162631, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 103716, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 151927578, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 207432, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25936297, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 113019, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 193375623, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 170673, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 713978352, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 88877, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9943914, "child_limit_applications": 26849, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26849, "child_cap_hits": 26849, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26849, "child_moves_before_total": 2206232, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2206232, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 432294, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 432294, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.17184997579054, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.100934857909046, "tt_hits": 12930, "tt_cutoffs": 1831, "beta_cutoffs": 21973, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4510.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5237.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 370, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2557, "avg_search_time_ms": 255.7, "search_nodes": 72100, "safety_nodes": 1085, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 73185, "avg_nodes": 7318.5, "eval_calls": 70448, "avg_eval_calls": 7044.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70448, "pattern_eval_ns": 1488767, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.13284976152623, "pattern_frame_queries": 70448, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1488767, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.13284976152623, "pattern_frame_updates": 144142, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1536646026, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10660.640382400688, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1633, "avg_candidate_generations": 163.3, "candidate_moves_total": 126409, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.40906307409675, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 720, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 1623, "search_candidate_moves_total": 125689, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 3340, "avg_legality_checks": 334.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3340, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 404224, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 40422.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 973105368, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2407.341889645345, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2335, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 233.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18245549, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7813.939614561028, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2335, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18245549, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9391820, "stage_ordering_ns": 59010, "stage_eval_ns": 1538134793, "stage_threat_ns": 984481452, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 144152, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 865511792, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 269903, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10531, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72071, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 100459334, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 144142, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18240423, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1502, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5652.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6452.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1638, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 857, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18800, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 144, 160, 142, 95, 125, 50, 65, 78, 127, 94, 62, 157, 143, 141, 113, 158, 97, 82, 81, 49, 129 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 11674, "avg_search_time_ms": 972.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 291592, "safety_nodes": 727, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 292319, "avg_nodes": 24359.916666666668, "eval_calls": 285101, "avg_eval_calls": 23758.416666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 285101, "pattern_eval_ns": 5760102, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.203724294197496, "pattern_frame_queries": 285101, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5760102, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.203724294197496, "pattern_frame_updates": 583116, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7290572413, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12502.782316040033, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6469, "avg_candidate_generations": 539.0833333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 526896, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.44937393723914, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 919, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 6457, "search_candidate_moves_total": 525977, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 277954, "avg_legality_checks": 23162.833333333332, "illegal_moves_skipped": 315, "root_legality_checks": 919, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 277035, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 312, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2173705, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 181142.08333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5192415364, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2388.7396698264024, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38343, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3195.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 357065650, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9312.407740656705, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 326, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3193709, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37991, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 353659381, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 212560, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.1666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 355312, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9350.315789473685, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 47, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.9166666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 157461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3350.2340425531916, "stage_move_gen_ns": 667365184, "stage_ordering_ns": 234910, "stage_eval_ns": 7296332515, "stage_threat_ns": 3680005614, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 583128, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3219424215, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 449532, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 291558, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 391444363, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 583116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 68687504, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 443, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5742, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4634.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5301.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7113, "avg_search_time_ms": 646.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 86192, "safety_nodes": 1023, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87215, "avg_nodes": 7928.636363636364, "eval_calls": 69008, "avg_eval_calls": 6273.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 69008, "pattern_eval_ns": 1403028, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.331381868768837, "pattern_frame_queries": 69008, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1403028, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.331381868768837, "pattern_frame_updates": 172284, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1562347982, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9068.445021011818, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16129, "avg_candidate_generations": 1466.2727272727273, "candidate_moves_total": 1375846, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.3026226052452, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 845, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 16118, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1375001, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 738064, "avg_legality_checks": 67096.72727272728, "illegal_moves_skipped": 350, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 738064, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 350, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2043107, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 185737.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4285350386, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2097.4674287739213, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5011, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 455.54545454545456, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43325579, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8646.09439233686, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 367, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3921332, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2839, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28942652, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1783, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10253143, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 208452, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73180, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6652.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 734758300, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10040.424979502597, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 104529, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9502.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 354858838, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3394.8362464005204, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1766462808, "stage_ordering_ns": 546664593, "stage_eval_ns": 1563751010, "stage_threat_ns": 3193953267, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 282688, "root_tactical_annotations": 1121, "search_tactical_annotations": 281567, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 172295, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 957196698, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 245713, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2088181929, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32308, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1134162132, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86142, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 120122101, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 172284, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20207920, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62180, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 338494162, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 151217, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 615294784, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 69291, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8244619, "child_limit_applications": 16118, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16118, "child_cap_hits": 16118, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16118, "child_moves_before_total": 1374651, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1374651, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 258931, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 258931, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.28669810150143, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.064710261819084, "tt_hits": 6151, "tt_cutoffs": 1016, "beta_cutoffs": 11562, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4930.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5657.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1734, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 858, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15381, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 142, 94, 144, 96, 141, 143, 114, 100, 129, 99, 97, 82, 127, 157, 130, 131, 156, 170, 159, 174, 176, 160, 124, 171, 116, 185, 199, 68, 54, 78, 62, 172, 173, 102, 113, 115, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 43, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 10473, "avg_search_time_ms": 523.65, "search_nodes": 102127, "safety_nodes": 2005, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 104132, "avg_nodes": 5206.6, "eval_calls": 70485, "avg_eval_calls": 3524.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70485, "pattern_eval_ns": 1437919, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.400354685394056, "pattern_frame_queries": 70485, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1437919, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.400354685394056, "pattern_frame_updates": 204070, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2471322208, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12110.169098838634, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29669, "avg_candidate_generations": 1483.45, "candidate_moves_total": 2580565, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.97849607334254, "candidate_moves_max": 138, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1742, "root_candidate_moves_max": 128, "search_candidate_generations": 29649, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2578823, "search_candidate_moves_max": 138, "legality_checks": 902869, "avg_legality_checks": 45143.45, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3562, "root_legality_checks": 1742, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 901127, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3554, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3021311, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 151065.55, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6201709002, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2052.6549574009427, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46126, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2306.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 252640238, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5477.1763864198065, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3603, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34605847, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15972, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 139505307, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26499, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 78046312, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 482772, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 111992, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5599.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1059836800, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9463.504536038288, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 161906, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8095.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 510295775, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3151.802743567255, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2119339140, "stage_ordering_ns": 995879062, "stage_eval_ns": 2472760127, "stage_threat_ns": 4825898926, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 573210, "root_tactical_annotations": 2452, "search_tactical_annotations": 570758, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 204090, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1177461815, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 525211, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3462750404, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59429, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2045074616, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102035, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 150012500, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 204070, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24559952, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 218023, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 390230452, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 247744, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1026140558, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 107443, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11114255, "child_limit_applications": 29649, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29649, "child_cap_hits": 29649, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29649, "child_moves_before_total": 2575269, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2575269, "child_moves_before_max": 138, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 138, "child_moves_after_total": 483890, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 483890, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.8585449762218, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.320617896050457, "tt_hits": 12904, "tt_cutoffs": 1901, "beta_cutoffs": 25176, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6103.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6503.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 399, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 4886, "avg_search_time_ms": 257.1578947368421, "search_nodes": 168954, "safety_nodes": 2347, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 171301, "avg_nodes": 9015.842105263158, "eval_calls": 163951, "avg_eval_calls": 8629.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 163951, "pattern_eval_ns": 3295335, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.099511439393478, "pattern_frame_queries": 163951, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3295335, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.099511439393478, "pattern_frame_updates": 337796, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2783880867, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8241.307969898993, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4966, "avg_candidate_generations": 261.36842105263156, "candidate_moves_total": 498609, "avg_candidate_moves": 100.40455094643576, "candidate_moves_max": 138, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1648, "root_candidate_moves_max": 127, "search_candidate_generations": 4947, "search_candidate_moves_total": 496961, "search_candidate_moves_max": 138, "legality_checks": 10441, "avg_legality_checks": 549.5263157894736, "illegal_moves_skipped": 48, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10441, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 48, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 771868, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 40624.63157894737, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1659083543, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2149.43946762918, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13906, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 731.8947368421053, "renju_forbidden_ns": 101534319, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7301.47555012225, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 441664, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13818, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 100661944, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 430711, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 27571825, "stage_ordering_ns": 160822, "stage_eval_ns": 2787176202, "stage_threat_ns": 2040443288, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 337815, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1777051838, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 50, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 434751, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19900, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 168898, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 224444202, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 337796, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38512497, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 200, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4591, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6896.9473684210525, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7318.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1835, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 859, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29569, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 110, 83, 81, 86, 85, 54, 111, 68, 40, 109, 125, 95, 94, 142, 127, 128, 78, 62, 124, 123, 156, 114, 100, 69, 108, 99 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 22405, "avg_search_time_ms": 1493.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 595657, "safety_nodes": 400, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 596057, "avg_nodes": 39737.13333333333, "eval_calls": 584007, "avg_eval_calls": 38933.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 584007, "pattern_eval_ns": 11724953, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.07673366928821, "pattern_frame_queries": 584007, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11724953, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.07673366928821, "pattern_frame_updates": 1191226, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 13928128689, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11692.263843300936, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11621, "avg_candidate_generations": 774.7333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1079743, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.91308837449445, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1265, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 11606, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1078478, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 557879, "avg_legality_checks": 37191.933333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 296, "root_legality_checks": 1265, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 556614, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 295, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4497441, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 299829.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10223630304, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2273.210544396247, "renju_forbidden_checks": 72812, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4854.133333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 546745438, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7509.001785419986, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 352, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2934763, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 72455, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 543754615, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 56060, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.6666666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 111721, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11172.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.9333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 60321, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4308.642857142857, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1269412911, "stage_ordering_ns": 406521, "stage_eval_ns": 13939853642, "stage_threat_ns": 7128419400, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1191241, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6215140639, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 174271, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 595613, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 778742942, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1191226, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 134361548, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 827, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 10268, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4775.533333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5271.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 7150, "avg_search_time_ms": 476.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 91389, "safety_nodes": 1765, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 93154, "avg_nodes": 6210.266666666666, "eval_calls": 72943, "avg_eval_calls": 4862.866666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72943, "pattern_eval_ns": 1495834, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.50688894067971, "pattern_frame_queries": 72943, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1495834, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.50688894067971, "pattern_frame_updates": 182644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1434247378, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7852.693644466832, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17486, "avg_candidate_generations": 1165.7333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1559321, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.1753974608258, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1285, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 17471, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1558036, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 826274, "avg_legality_checks": 55084.933333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 321, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 826274, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 321, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2045881, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 136392.06666666668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4204822555, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2055.262527488158, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6517, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 434.46666666666664, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50454499, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7741.982353843793, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 321, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3287657, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3766, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35939617, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2420, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11114984, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 112241, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 63033, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4202.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 579930124, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9200.420795456348, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 87978, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5865.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 266775713, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3032.3002682488805, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1939925593, "stage_ordering_ns": 607517257, "stage_eval_ns": 1435743212, "stage_threat_ns": 3117543440, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 278938, "root_tactical_annotations": 1172, "search_tactical_annotations": 277766, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 182659, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1008992209, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 258519, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1955298266, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35038, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1162834165, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91322, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 126348661, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 182644, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21241376, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71215, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 292618367, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 152255, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 499481372, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 55468, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5662928, "child_limit_applications": 17471, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17471, "child_cap_hits": 17471, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17471, "child_moves_before_total": 1557715, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1557715, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 281362, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 281362, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.16003663213326, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.10451605517715, "tt_hits": 6555, "tt_cutoffs": 908, "beta_cutoffs": 12669, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5935.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6469.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1872, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 860, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11038, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 81, 68, 111, 54, 40, 109, 142, 94, 127, 157, 128, 125, 114, 113, 156, 100, 170 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8548, "avg_search_time_ms": 777.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 96461, "safety_nodes": 586, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 97047, "avg_nodes": 8822.454545454546, "eval_calls": 70111, "avg_eval_calls": 6373.727272727273, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70111, "pattern_eval_ns": 1446279, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.62841779463993, "pattern_frame_queries": 70111, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1446279, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.62841779463993, "pattern_frame_updates": 192828, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2128464022, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11038.14810089821, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24720, "avg_candidate_generations": 2247.2727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 1974199, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.86241909385113, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 760, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 24709, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1973439, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 722087, "avg_legality_checks": 65644.27272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1245, "root_legality_checks": 760, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 721327, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1245, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2345197, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 213199.72727272726, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5018606452, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2139.9509090281117, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22919, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2083.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 133576030, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5828.178803612723, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1339, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12299283, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 89623012, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10957, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31650885, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2850, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72676, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6606.909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 635044602, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8738.02358412681, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95933, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8721.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 267070234, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2783.924551509908, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1727090653, "stage_ordering_ns": 770401920, "stage_eval_ns": 2129910301, "stage_threat_ns": 3881342819, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 403416, "root_tactical_annotations": 2034, "search_tactical_annotations": 401382, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 192839, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1082342108, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 364394, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2630373322, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49486, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1734097647, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 96414, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 135399980, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 192828, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22945487, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 132553, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 187381729, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 182346, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 708534074, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 88517, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10281922, "child_limit_applications": 24709, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24709, "child_cap_hits": 24709, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24709, "child_moves_before_total": 1972194, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1972194, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 401339, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 401339, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.81682787648225, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.242624145048364, "tt_hits": 10451, "tt_cutoffs": 1594, "beta_cutoffs": 20153, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4817.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5544.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1071, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2482, "avg_search_time_ms": 248.2, "search_nodes": 95373, "safety_nodes": 987, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 96360, "avg_nodes": 9636.0, "eval_calls": 91742, "avg_eval_calls": 9174.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 91742, "pattern_eval_ns": 1853271, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.20090035098428, "pattern_frame_queries": 91742, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1853271, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.20090035098428, "pattern_frame_updates": 190688, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1290010984, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6765.034947138782, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3612, "avg_candidate_generations": 361.2, "candidate_moves_total": 258982, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.70044296788483, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 694, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 3602, "search_candidate_moves_total": 258288, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 8859, "avg_legality_checks": 885.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8859, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 296962, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29696.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 685311429, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2307.7411554340288, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1740, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 174.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16990598, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9764.711494252873, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1740, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16990598, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23360307, "stage_ordering_ns": 118661, "stage_eval_ns": 1291864255, "stage_threat_ns": 1144141679, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 190698, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1000880455, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 314651, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 95344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121416848, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 190688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21529725, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 135, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3337, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5618.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6418.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 861, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12949, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 144, 82, 129, 99, 130, 110, 68, 97, 67, 111, 146, 162, 113, 126, 83, 53, 159, 174, 141, 124, 138, 125, 127, 80, 64, 95, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 7491, "avg_search_time_ms": 499.4, "search_nodes": 192445, "safety_nodes": 443, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 192888, "avg_nodes": 12859.2, "eval_calls": 186057, "avg_eval_calls": 12403.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 186057, "pattern_eval_ns": 3716866, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.977028545015774, "pattern_frame_queries": 186057, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3716866, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.977028545015774, "pattern_frame_updates": 384804, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4773508725, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12405.039253749961, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6360, "avg_candidate_generations": 424.0, "candidate_moves_total": 549801, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.44669811320755, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1151, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 6345, "search_candidate_moves_total": 548650, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 176250, "avg_legality_checks": 11750.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 605, "root_legality_checks": 1151, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 175099, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 602, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1590412, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 106027.46666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3565968864, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2242.166724094134, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48979, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3265.266666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 229368476, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4682.996304538679, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 721, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1486968, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 48243, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 227864168, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 17340, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 93461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10384.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 44351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3695.9166666666665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 397842193, "stage_ordering_ns": 245413, "stage_eval_ns": 4777225591, "stage_threat_ns": 2280433985, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 384819, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1990402424, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 153201, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13730, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 192402, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 247100022, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 384804, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42778338, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 764, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5294, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6556.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7089.733333333334, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1889, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 5440, "avg_search_time_ms": 388.57142857142856, "search_nodes": 47363, "safety_nodes": 1523, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48886, "avg_nodes": 3491.8571428571427, "eval_calls": 32211, "avg_eval_calls": 2300.785714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32211, "pattern_eval_ns": 666725, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.698674365899848, "pattern_frame_queries": 32211, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 666725, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.698674365899848, "pattern_frame_updates": 94596, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 961461185, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10163.867235401074, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14464, "avg_candidate_generations": 1033.142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 1154036, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.78678097345133, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1080, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 14450, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1152956, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 686801, "avg_legality_checks": 49057.21428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 593, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 686801, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 593, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1690425, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 120744.64285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3531848832, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2089.3259576733662, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10857, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 775.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42911678, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3952.44340057106, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 693, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3134461, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4266, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27962350, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5878, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11791097, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 23770, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60341, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4310.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 548527428, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9090.459687443032, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81411, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5815.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 242895471, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2983.570659984523, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1650368665, "stage_ordering_ns": 455468051, "stage_eval_ns": 962127910, "stage_threat_ns": 2335791018, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 236636, "root_tactical_annotations": 751, "search_tactical_annotations": 235885, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 94610, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 544189980, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 222154, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1707729341, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28993, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 983604232, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47298, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 67622369, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 94596, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11150655, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70127, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 246159740, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 123024, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 477580125, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 43485, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5098673, "child_limit_applications": 14450, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14450, "child_cap_hits": 14450, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14450, "child_moves_before_total": 1152363, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1152363, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 234066, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 234066, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.7483044982699, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.198339100346022, "tt_hits": 5266, "tt_cutoffs": 637, "beta_cutoffs": 12387, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5882.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6453.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1914, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 862, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17450, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 82, 130, 52, 97, 80, 128, 68, 146, 162, 110, 36, 84, 66, 94, 81, 51, 79, 78, 83 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 13370, "avg_search_time_ms": 1337.0, "search_nodes": 148672, "safety_nodes": 176, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148848, "avg_nodes": 14884.8, "eval_calls": 116432, "avg_eval_calls": 11643.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 116432, "pattern_eval_ns": 2419924, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.784011268379828, "pattern_frame_queries": 116432, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2419924, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.784011268379828, "pattern_frame_updates": 297260, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4310188857, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14499.727030209244, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30381, "avg_candidate_generations": 3038.1, "candidate_moves_total": 2691296, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.58483920871598, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 775, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 30371, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2690521, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1053406, "avg_legality_checks": 105340.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1239, "root_legality_checks": 775, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1052631, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1239, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3910009, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 391000.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8144232263, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2082.919057986823, "renju_forbidden_checks": 63069, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6306.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 289098800, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4583.849434746072, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1744, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11059639, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37274, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 220387878, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24051, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 57651283, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 131015, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13101.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1144417268, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8735.009487463267, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 172241, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17224.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 502536393, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2917.635133330624, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2492166191, "stage_ordering_ns": 1032289408, "stage_eval_ns": 4312608781, "stage_threat_ns": 5483218489, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 508977, "root_tactical_annotations": 2621, "search_tactical_annotations": 506356, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 297270, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1639924974, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 464760, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3580608659, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60803, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2073622705, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 213273562, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 297260, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34959477, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 148644, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 335496701, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 255305, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1171480282, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 105028, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14451817, "child_limit_applications": 30371, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30371, "child_cap_hits": 30371, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30371, "child_moves_before_total": 2689282, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2689282, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 490258, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 490258, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.54769352342696, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.14230680583451, "tt_hits": 12636, "tt_cutoffs": 1827, "beta_cutoffs": 22947, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2552.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3219.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 459, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4071, "avg_search_time_ms": 452.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 121136, "safety_nodes": 995, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122131, "avg_nodes": 13570.111111111111, "eval_calls": 118496, "avg_eval_calls": 13166.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 118496, "pattern_eval_ns": 2438360, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.57757223872536, "pattern_frame_queries": 118496, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2438360, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.57757223872536, "pattern_frame_updates": 242220, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2467455864, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10186.83784988853, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2623, "avg_candidate_generations": 291.44444444444446, "candidate_moves_total": 202368, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.15135341212353, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 707, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 2614, "search_candidate_moves_total": 201661, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 5048, "avg_legality_checks": 560.8888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5048, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 646116, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 71790.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1492827454, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2310.463529768648, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10384, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1153.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 78396488, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7549.738828967643, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10384, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 78396488, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13479944, "stage_ordering_ns": 89420, "stage_eval_ns": 2469894224, "stage_threat_ns": 1572356684, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 242229, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1379434365, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 235931, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 163555634, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 242220, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29130754, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 124, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2378, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4371.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5260.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 941, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 863, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23956, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 144, 82, 110, 158, 143, 141, 127, 94, 159, 80, 64, 111, 129, 114, 115, 157, 145, 146, 130, 160, 173, 131, 161, 113, 174, 189, 177, 193, 175, 191, 176 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 1871, "avg_search_time_ms": 116.9375, "search_nodes": 47044, "safety_nodes": 1656, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48700, "avg_nodes": 3043.75, "eval_calls": 44352, "avg_eval_calls": 2772.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44352, "pattern_eval_ns": 945533, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.31883567821068, "pattern_frame_queries": 44352, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 945533, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.31883567821068, "pattern_frame_updates": 93994, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1117876189, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11893.059014405175, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2661, "avg_candidate_generations": 166.3125, "candidate_moves_total": 197657, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.27921833897031, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1169, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 2645, "search_candidate_moves_total": 196488, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 41646, "avg_legality_checks": 2602.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 1169, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 40477, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 19, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 354043, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22127.6875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 839078961, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2369.9916705033006, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3190, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 199.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 27398001, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8588.715047021944, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 212642, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3159, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27060779, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 124580, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 86, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 926945, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10778.43023255814, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 495433, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4094.4876033057853, "stage_move_gen_ns": 103541682, "stage_ordering_ns": 88610, "stage_eval_ns": 1118821722, "stage_threat_ns": 624454003, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 94010, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 547944012, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1255676, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 46997, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 63853022, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 93994, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11401293, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 182, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2341, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6613.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7113.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1806, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 22069, "avg_search_time_ms": 1379.3125, "search_nodes": 238010, "safety_nodes": 252, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 238262, "avg_nodes": 14891.375, "eval_calls": 184540, "avg_eval_calls": 11533.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 184540, "pattern_eval_ns": 3919787, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.24085293161374, "pattern_frame_queries": 184540, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3919787, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.24085293161374, "pattern_frame_updates": 475876, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4450168432, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9351.52945725357, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 50878, "avg_candidate_generations": 3179.875, "candidate_moves_total": 4478459, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.0234875584732, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1196, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 50862, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4477263, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 2971299, "avg_legality_checks": 185706.1875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4834, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2971299, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4834, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7272484, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 454530.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13947807263, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1917.8876520044596, "renju_forbidden_checks": 64473, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4029.5625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 203525942, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3156.7623966621686, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4936, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 55127151, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7378, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72889952, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 52149, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 75381417, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 127422, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 284159, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17759.9375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2612040436, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9192.179153220555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 400325, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25020.3125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1285357107, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3210.784005495535, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6645032430, "stage_ordering_ns": 1627620610, "stage_eval_ns": 4454088219, "stage_threat_ns": 9217815890, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1194133, "root_tactical_annotations": 4572, "search_tactical_annotations": 1189561, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 475892, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2452035608, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1013389, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6352526640, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 101827, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3057570090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 237938, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 321678291, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 475876, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53772205, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 443594, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1473998873, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 467954, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1820893277, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 282585, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 37803146, "child_limit_applications": 50862, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 50862, "child_cap_hits": 50862, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 50862, "child_moves_before_total": 4472429, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4472429, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 839553, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 839553, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.93262160355472, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.506488144390705, "tt_hits": 22281, "tt_cutoffs": 2536, "beta_cutoffs": 39083, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4766.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5266.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1813, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 864, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11409, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 110, 158, 111, 113, 68, 82, 128, 144, 80, 64, 95, 65, 97, 174, 190, 98, 125, 140, 139, 83, 153 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8889, "avg_search_time_ms": 808.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 103593, "safety_nodes": 171, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 103764, "avg_nodes": 9433.09090909091, "eval_calls": 74853, "avg_eval_calls": 6804.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74853, "pattern_eval_ns": 1528030, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.413744272106662, "pattern_frame_queries": 74853, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1528030, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.413744272106662, "pattern_frame_updates": 207092, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2545029374, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12289.36595329612, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26849, "avg_candidate_generations": 2440.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2223720, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.82319639465157, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 26838, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2222934, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 681863, "avg_legality_checks": 61987.545454545456, "illegal_moves_skipped": 537, "root_legality_checks": 786, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 681077, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 537, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2607091, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 237008.27272727274, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5274084101, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2022.9766053428898, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24715, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2246.818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 100703765, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4074.6010519927167, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 652, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3965896, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11808, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71819922, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12255, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24917947, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 70163, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6378.454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 600232550, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8554.83018114961, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98444, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8949.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 264774152, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2689.591564747471, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1495946744, "stage_ordering_ns": 864321998, "stage_eval_ns": 2546557404, "stage_threat_ns": 3941769072, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 376752, "root_tactical_annotations": 2729, "search_tactical_annotations": 374023, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 207103, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1105321482, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 342463, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2663633303, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53744, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1821633245, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 103546, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 139981105, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 207092, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23636799, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116870, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 167653749, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171840, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 674335549, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 88042, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9196383, "child_limit_applications": 26838, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26838, "child_cap_hits": 26838, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26838, "child_moves_before_total": 2222397, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2222397, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 431882, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 431882, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.80784708249497, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.09218272598554, "tt_hits": 12959, "tt_cutoffs": 1855, "beta_cutoffs": 21959, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4985.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5712.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1014, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2510, "avg_search_time_ms": 251.0, "search_nodes": 76241, "safety_nodes": 1085, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 77326, "avg_nodes": 7732.6, "eval_calls": 74559, "avg_eval_calls": 7455.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74559, "pattern_eval_ns": 1528973, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.506887163186203, "pattern_frame_queries": 74559, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1528973, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.506887163186203, "pattern_frame_updates": 152424, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1515498699, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9942.651413163281, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1663, "avg_candidate_generations": 166.3, "candidate_moves_total": 128224, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.10402886349969, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 720, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 1653, "search_candidate_moves_total": 127504, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 3399, "avg_legality_checks": 339.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3399, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 430537, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 43053.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 960734647, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2231.47986584196, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2502, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 250.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18261207, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7298.643884892086, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2502, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18261207, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8730762, "stage_ordering_ns": 55151, "stage_eval_ns": 1517027672, "stage_threat_ns": 969143061, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152434, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 851010424, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 263432, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76212, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99903710, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152424, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17965495, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1527, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5661.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6461.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1688, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 865, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12834, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 111, 81, 83, 114, 66, 97, 109, 113, 144, 160, 65, 130, 146, 145, 129, 115, 100, 175 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7257, "avg_search_time_ms": 725.7, "search_nodes": 247789, "safety_nodes": 707, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 248496, "avg_nodes": 24849.6, "eval_calls": 242406, "avg_eval_calls": 24240.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 242406, "pattern_eval_ns": 4610645, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.020341905728404, "pattern_frame_queries": 242406, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4610645, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.020341905728404, "pattern_frame_updates": 495520, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4334360301, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8747.094569341298, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5364, "avg_candidate_generations": 536.4, "candidate_moves_total": 360564, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.2192393736018, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 624, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 5354, "search_candidate_moves_total": 359940, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 240551, "avg_legality_checks": 24055.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 624, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 239927, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1600337, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 160033.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2965431010, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1853.0040922630672, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7061, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 706.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57008254, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8073.67993202096, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7061, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57008254, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 108750, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5723.684210526316, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 24, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 40360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1681.6666666666667, "stage_move_gen_ns": 450764270, "stage_ordering_ns": 168721, "stage_eval_ns": 4338970946, "stage_threat_ns": 2419233282, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 495530, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2110142057, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 230290, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8890, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 247760, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 261675463, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 495520, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47185472, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 170, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4934, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4167.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4967.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5568, "avg_search_time_ms": 556.8, "search_nodes": 71274, "safety_nodes": 359, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 71633, "avg_nodes": 7163.3, "eval_calls": 48800, "avg_eval_calls": 4880.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48800, "pattern_eval_ns": 934656, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.152786885245902, "pattern_frame_queries": 48800, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 934656, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.152786885245902, "pattern_frame_updates": 142464, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 810895266, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5691.931056266846, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21275, "avg_candidate_generations": 2127.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1664450, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.23501762632198, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 647, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 21265, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1663803, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1048572, "avg_legality_checks": 104857.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 123, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1048572, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 123, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2285829, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 228582.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3550619780, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1553.3181965930085, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9874, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 987.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19336859, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1958.3612517723313, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 123, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1154878, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1044, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9134928, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8707, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9047053, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 63799, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6379.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 468647708, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7345.690496716249, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91419, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9141.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 236005631, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2581.5818484122556, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1909397681, "stage_ordering_ns": 477214774, "stage_eval_ns": 811829922, "stage_threat_ns": 2316623217, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 290154, "root_tactical_annotations": 1699, "search_tactical_annotations": 288455, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 142474, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 590610614, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 266816, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1629540679, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42591, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1022373139, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 71232, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 76423123, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 142464, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13084303, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 89575, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 277692223, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 134642, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 329416037, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 65937, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6964498, "child_limit_applications": 21265, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21265, "child_cap_hits": 21265, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21265, "child_moves_before_total": 1663680, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1663680, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 340241, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 340241, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.23559840112861, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00004702562897, "tt_hits": 8897, "tt_cutoffs": 1167, "beta_cutoffs": 18083, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5471.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6271.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1933, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 866, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8368, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 144, 96, 114, 110, 124, 95, 99, 68, 54, 94, 97, 84, 113, 116, 129, 159, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6681, "avg_search_time_ms": 668.1, "search_nodes": 78397, "safety_nodes": 824, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 79221, "avg_nodes": 7922.1, "eval_calls": 60247, "avg_eval_calls": 6024.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60247, "pattern_eval_ns": 1242379, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.621425133201654, "pattern_frame_queries": 60247, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1242379, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.621425133201654, "pattern_frame_updates": 156710, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1540000340, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9827.071278157106, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16895, "avg_candidate_generations": 1689.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1319406, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.09446581828944, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 713, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 16885, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1318693, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 656595, "avg_legality_checks": 65659.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 641, "root_legality_checks": 713, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 655882, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 637, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1823503, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 182350.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3992093165, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2189.244089535361, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15890, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1589.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 68691576, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4322.943738200126, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1041, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6936349, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5109, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 41359346, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9716, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20210010, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 185871, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53911, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5391.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 501633881, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9304.852089555008, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 73350, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7335.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 226275829, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3084.8783776414452, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1617065094, "stage_ordering_ns": 545195113, "stage_eval_ns": 1541242719, "stage_threat_ns": 2939056031, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 252472, "root_tactical_annotations": 977, "search_tactical_annotations": 251495, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 156720, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 875830590, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 237464, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1930275578, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33831, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1239445227, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78355, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107632032, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 156710, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18417825, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 73331, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 132211484, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 130295, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 557976835, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 48846, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6900006, "child_limit_applications": 16885, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16885, "child_cap_hits": 16885, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16885, "child_moves_before_total": 1318056, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1318056, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 275480, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 275480, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.06076399170861, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.315072549600238, "tt_hits": 5669, "tt_cutoffs": 1223, "beta_cutoffs": 12943, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4170.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4970.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 18, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1677, "avg_search_time_ms": 186.33333333333334, "search_nodes": 55340, "safety_nodes": 857, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 56197, "avg_nodes": 6244.111111111111, "eval_calls": 52517, "avg_eval_calls": 5835.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 52517, "pattern_eval_ns": 1067394, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.324732943618258, "pattern_frame_queries": 52517, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1067394, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.324732943618258, "pattern_frame_updates": 110628, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 945962655, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8550.84296019091, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2806, "avg_candidate_generations": 311.77777777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 217509, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.51568068424804, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 644, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 2797, "search_candidate_moves_total": 216865, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 7249, "avg_legality_checks": 805.4444444444445, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7249, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 245132, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27236.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 581345975, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2371.5629742342903, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4372, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 485.77777777777777, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20296184, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4642.311070448307, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 49891, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4334, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20061043, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 185250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19570399, "stage_ordering_ns": 95661, "stage_eval_ns": 947030049, "stage_threat_ns": 695054983, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 110637, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 609996878, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 206021, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9250, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 55314, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 71956092, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 110628, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12895992, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 147, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2558, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5512.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6401.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 867, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20607, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 96, 142, 100, 99, 129, 141, 97, 140, 143, 170, 156, 155, 185, 139, 138, 171, 95, 94, 123, 169, 127, 168, 172, 167 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 6369, "avg_search_time_ms": 489.9230769230769, "search_nodes": 161089, "safety_nodes": 1236, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 162325, "avg_nodes": 12486.538461538461, "eval_calls": 156549, "avg_eval_calls": 12042.23076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 156549, "pattern_eval_ns": 3162737, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.202856613584245, "pattern_frame_queries": 156549, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3162737, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.202856613584245, "pattern_frame_updates": 322102, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3863558182, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11994.828290417321, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4515, "avg_candidate_generations": 347.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 317576, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.33798449612404, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 901, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 4502, "search_candidate_moves_total": 316675, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 154445, "avg_legality_checks": 11880.384615384615, "illegal_moves_skipped": 98, "root_legality_checks": 901, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 153544, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 95, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1097223, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 84401.76923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2703209811, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2463.6831446296696, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10397, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 799.7692307692307, "renju_forbidden_ns": 102657677, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9873.778686159469, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 98, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 977695, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10284, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 101509168, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 170814, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.153846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 734973, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10969.746268656716, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 96, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.384615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 380381, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3962.3020833333335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 390312870, "stage_ordering_ns": 148750, "stage_eval_ns": 3866720919, "stage_threat_ns": 2094982522, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 322115, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1834893602, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1008486, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 161051, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 219887612, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 322102, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39192822, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 181, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4045, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5131.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5746.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 165, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 14224, "avg_search_time_ms": 1094.1538461538462, "search_nodes": 118594, "safety_nodes": 435, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 119029, "avg_nodes": 9156.076923076924, "eval_calls": 84463, "avg_eval_calls": 6497.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84463, "pattern_eval_ns": 1760677, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.84554183488628, "pattern_frame_queries": 84463, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1760677, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.84554183488628, "pattern_frame_updates": 237070, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2579382363, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10880.256308263382, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32391, "avg_candidate_generations": 2491.6153846153848, "candidate_moves_total": 2688753, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.00926183199037, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 920, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 32378, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2687833, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1946763, "avg_legality_checks": 149751.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3554, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1946763, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3554, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4487339, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 345179.92307692306, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9342269840, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2081.9175551479398, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36215, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2785.769230769231, "renju_forbidden_ns": 145684000, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4022.753002899351, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3554, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 40139370, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7746, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64156592, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24895, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41155447, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 232591, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 162307, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12485.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1635805563, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10078.46588871706, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 231732, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17825.53846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 818418885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3531.747384910155, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4627969808, "stage_ordering_ns": 1081076942, "stage_eval_ns": 2581143040, "stage_threat_ns": 5856443234, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 648893, "root_tactical_annotations": 3126, "search_tactical_annotations": 645767, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 237083, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1361542983, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 540882, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4272688957, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64840, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2234097151, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 118535, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 173004688, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 237070, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29297159, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 206524, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 993467730, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 269507, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1045035316, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 172862, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19909447, "child_limit_applications": 32378, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32378, "child_cap_hits": 32378, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32378, "child_moves_before_total": 2684279, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2684279, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 522373, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 522373, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.9044104021249, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.133578355673606, "tt_hits": 15075, "tt_cutoffs": 1694, "beta_cutoffs": 27076, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5179.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5794.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1875, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 868, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16421, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 142, 100, 140, 98, 143, 141, 110, 94, 125, 95, 97, 82, 127, 157, 124, 123, 155, 170, 158, 174, 168, 154, 130, 173, 108, 189, 205, 66, 50, 86, 72, 172, 171, 92, 111, 109, 139, 83, 153 ], "move_count": 43, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 11162, "avg_search_time_ms": 558.1, "search_nodes": 102107, "safety_nodes": 2001, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 104108, "avg_nodes": 5205.4, "eval_calls": 70905, "avg_eval_calls": 3545.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70905, "pattern_eval_ns": 1552157, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.89065651223468, "pattern_frame_queries": 70905, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1552157, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.89065651223468, "pattern_frame_updates": 204030, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2698362265, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13225.3211047395, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29304, "avg_candidate_generations": 1465.2, "candidate_moves_total": 2556998, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.257644007644, "candidate_moves_max": 138, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1740, "root_candidate_moves_max": 128, "search_candidate_generations": 29284, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2555258, "search_candidate_moves_max": 138, "legality_checks": 892673, "avg_legality_checks": 44633.65, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3744, "root_legality_checks": 1740, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 890933, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3736, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3010959, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 150547.95, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6592563794, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2189.5229373764305, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47358, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2367.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 278139454, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5873.125005278939, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3800, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 38790823, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16675, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 154397249, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26831, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 84433501, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 517881, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 110069, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5503.45, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1112188462, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10104.465944089616, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 159246, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7962.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 537773731, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3376.9999309244818, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2232849528, "stage_ordering_ns": 1053757070, "stage_eval_ns": 2699914422, "stage_threat_ns": 5121027255, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 566503, "root_tactical_annotations": 2452, "search_tactical_annotations": 564051, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 204050, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1268177737, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 517043, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3657502150, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58699, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2172135137, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102015, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 157077452, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 204030, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26119535, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 215792, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 410456039, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 242537, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1073522887, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 108174, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12150381, "child_limit_applications": 29284, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29284, "child_cap_hits": 29284, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29284, "child_moves_before_total": 2551522, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2551522, "child_moves_before_max": 138, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 138, "child_moves_after_total": 477861, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 477861, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.13024177024997, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.318160087419752, "tt_hits": 12774, "tt_cutoffs": 1826, "beta_cutoffs": 24783, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6004.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6404.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 302, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 5238, "avg_search_time_ms": 275.6842105263158, "search_nodes": 171178, "safety_nodes": 2345, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 173523, "avg_nodes": 9132.78947368421, "eval_calls": 166169, "avg_eval_calls": 8745.736842105263, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 166169, "pattern_eval_ns": 3540875, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.308878310635556, "pattern_frame_queries": 166169, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3540875, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.308878310635556, "pattern_frame_updates": 342244, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2994021377, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8748.20705987541, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4972, "avg_candidate_generations": 261.6842105263158, "candidate_moves_total": 498762, "avg_candidate_moves": 100.3141592920354, "candidate_moves_max": 138, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1646, "root_candidate_moves_max": 127, "search_candidate_generations": 4953, "search_candidate_moves_total": 497116, "search_candidate_moves_max": 138, "legality_checks": 10188, "avg_legality_checks": 536.2105263157895, "illegal_moves_skipped": 31, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10188, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 31, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 792655, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 41718.68421052631, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1789976302, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2258.2035084620675, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13064, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 687.578947368421, "renju_forbidden_ns": 100544232, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7696.282302510716, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 31, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 322532, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12993, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 99766210, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 455490, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 28532488, "stage_ordering_ns": 178831, "stage_eval_ns": 2997562252, "stage_threat_ns": 2179003910, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 342263, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1903488097, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 50, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 458331, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20800, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 171122, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 233809798, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 342244, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41247684, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 200, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4600, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6885.105263157895, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7306.1578947368425, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1807, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 869, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14012, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 140, 82, 125, 95, 124, 114, 66, 97, 67, 113, 138, 152, 111, 128, 81, 51, 155, 170, 143, 130, 146, 129, 127, 84, 70, 99, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 8522, "avg_search_time_ms": 568.1333333333333, "search_nodes": 217437, "safety_nodes": 443, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 217880, "avg_nodes": 14525.333333333334, "eval_calls": 210779, "avg_eval_calls": 14051.933333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 210779, "pattern_eval_ns": 4251139, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.1687027645069, "pattern_frame_queries": 210779, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4251139, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.1687027645069, "pattern_frame_updates": 434788, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5352883679, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12311.479799350487, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6630, "avg_candidate_generations": 442.0, "candidate_moves_total": 571350, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.17647058823529, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1151, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 6615, "search_candidate_moves_total": 570199, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 200703, "avg_legality_checks": 13380.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1008, "root_legality_checks": 1151, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 199552, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1005, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1751072, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 116738.13333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3950620844, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2256.115593190914, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55023, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3668.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 246875247, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4486.764571179325, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1144, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2027886, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 53864, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 244831471, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 15890, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 91861, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10206.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 44031, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3669.25, "stage_move_gen_ns": 462452503, "stage_ordering_ns": 240840, "stage_eval_ns": 5357134818, "stage_threat_ns": 2661653124, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 434803, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2323652407, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 152761, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14900, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 217394, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 287729395, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 434788, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50118561, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 764, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5507, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6429.733333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6963.066666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1762, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 5477, "avg_search_time_ms": 391.2142857142857, "search_nodes": 47928, "safety_nodes": 1523, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49451, "avg_nodes": 3532.214285714286, "eval_calls": 32554, "avg_eval_calls": 2325.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32554, "pattern_eval_ns": 693193, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.293635190759968, "pattern_frame_queries": 32554, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 693193, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.293635190759968, "pattern_frame_updates": 95726, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 971764821, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10151.524361197586, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14675, "avg_candidate_generations": 1048.2142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 1173318, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.95352640545144, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1080, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 14661, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1172238, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 690449, "avg_legality_checks": 49317.78571428572, "illegal_moves_skipped": 651, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 690449, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 651, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1705569, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 121826.35714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3534018035, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2072.0463581361996, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11246, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 803.2857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 41710485, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3708.917392850791, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 757, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3107545, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4416, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27095476, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6053, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11485274, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 22190, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60815, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4343.928571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 538810331, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8859.826210638823, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81984, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5856.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 235908501, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2877.4944013466043, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1623757738, "stage_ordering_ns": 465244406, "stage_eval_ns": 972458014, "stage_threat_ns": 2371648805, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 242335, "root_tactical_annotations": 751, "search_tactical_annotations": 241584, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 95740, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 558593289, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 227659, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1729436029, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29415, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1013182924, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47863, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 67466128, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 95726, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11723254, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71468, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 239484938, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 126766, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 476339835, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 44101, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4430105, "child_limit_applications": 14661, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14661, "child_cap_hits": 14661, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14661, "child_moves_before_total": 1171587, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1171587, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 237547, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 237547, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.91180683445877, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.20264647704795, "tt_hits": 5303, "tt_cutoffs": 648, "beta_cutoffs": 12574, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5855.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6426.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1833, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 870, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7243, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 82, 124, 126, 140, 127, 97, 130, 114, 84, 70, 83, 81, 128, 129, 113, 143, 68 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5988, "avg_search_time_ms": 665.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 75872, "safety_nodes": 223, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76095, "avg_nodes": 8455.0, "eval_calls": 51361, "avg_eval_calls": 5706.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51361, "pattern_eval_ns": 1016759, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.796324059110997, "pattern_frame_queries": 51361, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1016759, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.796324059110997, "pattern_frame_updates": 151670, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1412921207, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9315.759260236038, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22751, "avg_candidate_generations": 2527.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 1790316, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.69174981319503, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 588, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 22742, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1789728, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 536899, "avg_legality_checks": 59655.444444444445, "illegal_moves_skipped": 271, "root_legality_checks": 588, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 536311, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 271, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1875655, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 208406.11111111112, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3493921599, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1862.7741237061186, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17410, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1934.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 56749896, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3259.614933946008, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 379, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2122603, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7501, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 39294963, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9528, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15329920, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2410, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46498, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5166.444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 357947163, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7698.1195535291845, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63634, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7070.444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 157139677, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2469.429503095829, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1100520042, "stage_ordering_ns": 614263756, "stage_eval_ns": 1413937966, "stage_threat_ns": 2825303499, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 326902, "root_tactical_annotations": 2193, "search_tactical_annotations": 324709, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 151679, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 750195825, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 285894, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1955649631, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45538, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1428351295, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75835, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94746312, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 151670, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16275560, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 94874, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 109805216, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 145474, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 417451870, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 86554, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8436171, "child_limit_applications": 22742, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22742, "child_cap_hits": 22742, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22742, "child_moves_before_total": 1789457, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1789457, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 366468, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 366468, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.68512004221265, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.114150030780056, "tt_hits": 10867, "tt_cutoffs": 1732, "beta_cutoffs": 19384, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4170.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5059.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 516, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1248, "avg_search_time_ms": 156.0, "search_nodes": 42734, "safety_nodes": 731, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 43465, "avg_nodes": 5433.125, "eval_calls": 41533, "avg_eval_calls": 5191.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41533, "pattern_eval_ns": 817133, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.67430717742518, "pattern_frame_queries": 41533, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 817133, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.67430717742518, "pattern_frame_updates": 85422, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 717684535, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8401.635819812227, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1186, "avg_candidate_generations": 148.25, "candidate_moves_total": 87025, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.37689713322091, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 527, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 1178, "search_candidate_moves_total": 86498, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 2630, "avg_legality_checks": 328.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2630, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 208918, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26114.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 434916444, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2081.7566892273526, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1474, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 184.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8071698, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5476.050203527815, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1474, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8071698, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6269352, "stage_ordering_ns": 37350, "stage_eval_ns": 718501668, "stage_threat_ns": 511712876, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 85430, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 449427809, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 139240, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6800, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42711, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 52510287, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 85422, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9635540, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 66, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1078, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5228.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6228.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1747, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 871, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22815, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 128, 64, 113, 157, 172, 143, 83, 68, 111, 69, 125, 139, 140, 80, 48, 155, 156, 124, 141, 70, 126, 67, 171 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7437, "avg_search_time_ms": 572.0769230769231, "search_nodes": 227520, "safety_nodes": 1090, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 228610, "avg_nodes": 17585.384615384617, "eval_calls": 222254, "avg_eval_calls": 17096.46153846154, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 222254, "pattern_eval_ns": 4299825, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.346445958227974, "pattern_frame_queries": 222254, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4299825, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.346445958227974, "pattern_frame_updates": 454964, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4512375080, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9918.092596337292, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5241, "avg_candidate_generations": 403.15384615384613, "candidate_moves_total": 386619, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.76817401259302, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 956, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 5228, "search_candidate_moves_total": 385663, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 206535, "avg_legality_checks": 15887.307692307691, "illegal_moves_skipped": 92, "root_legality_checks": 956, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 205579, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 89, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1608947, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 123765.15384615384, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3110318513, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1933.1391978728946, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23797, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1830.5384615384614, "renju_forbidden_ns": 119415271, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5018.080892549481, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 308, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 831704, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23462, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 118440886, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 142681, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8461538461538463, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 452301, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9046.02, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.538461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 237311, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3295.9861111111113, "stage_move_gen_ns": 439647838, "stage_ordering_ns": 168682, "stage_eval_ns": 4516674905, "stage_threat_ns": 2443397397, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 454977, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2136958573, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 648993, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 227482, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 258818427, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 454964, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46971404, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 258, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4675, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5073.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5689.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1000, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 15367, "avg_search_time_ms": 1182.076923076923, "search_nodes": 150837, "safety_nodes": 524, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 151361, "avg_nodes": 11643.153846153846, "eval_calls": 110325, "avg_eval_calls": 8486.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110325, "pattern_eval_ns": 2190840, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.85805574439157, "pattern_frame_queries": 110325, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2190840, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.85805574439157, "pattern_frame_updates": 301558, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2537685424, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8415.248224222207, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38067, "avg_candidate_generations": 2928.230769230769, "candidate_moves_total": 3402903, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.39246591535976, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 992, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 38054, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3401911, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 2466392, "avg_legality_checks": 189722.46153846153, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6295, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2466392, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6295, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5776165, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 444320.3846153846, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9917495757, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1716.9689157079135, "renju_forbidden_checks": 137755, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10596.538461538461, "renju_forbidden_ns": 280913701, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2039.2268955754782, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 18005, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 82977431, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 36262, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 77609365, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 83461, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 120164294, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 162611, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 246605, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18969.615384615383, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2219131855, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8998.73017578719, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 354362, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27258.615384615383, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1133708704, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3199.2953646271326, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5123299128, "stage_ordering_ns": 1138624601, "stage_eval_ns": 2539876264, "stage_threat_ns": 6461622041, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 720027, "root_tactical_annotations": 3068, "search_tactical_annotations": 716959, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 301571, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1474583995, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 660832, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4749603918, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 76191, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2119921738, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 150779, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 188544639, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 301558, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31573941, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 282117, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1317823482, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 302514, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1311778847, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 135396, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17315548, "child_limit_applications": 38054, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38054, "child_cap_hits": 38054, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38054, "child_moves_before_total": 3395616, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3395616, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 609061, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 609061, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.23151311294477, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.005176853944395, "tt_hits": 15827, "tt_cutoffs": 2400, "beta_cutoffs": 30850, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 4.461538461538462, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 4.461538461538462, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5293.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5908.615384615385, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1934, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 872, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7311, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 99, 95, 113, 141, 85, 71, 157, 172, 114, 115, 128, 156, 96, 80, 144, 160, 129, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6381, "avg_search_time_ms": 580.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 96311, "safety_nodes": 425, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 96736, "avg_nodes": 8794.181818181818, "eval_calls": 68772, "avg_eval_calls": 6252.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68772, "pattern_eval_ns": 1345846, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.569679520735182, "pattern_frame_queries": 68772, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1345846, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.569679520735182, "pattern_frame_updates": 192528, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1671077548, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8679.659831297266, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26318, "avg_candidate_generations": 2392.5454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 2107682, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.0851888441371, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 772, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 26307, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2106910, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 517771, "avg_legality_checks": 47070.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2401, "root_legality_checks": 772, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 516999, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2398, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1985574, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 180506.72727272726, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3464236158, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1744.7026189907806, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19244, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1749.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 119544823, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6212.056900852213, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2451, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16005610, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9472, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 76384399, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7302, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27067864, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 86950, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39879, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3625.3636363636365, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 288778929, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7241.378394643797, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 54726, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4975.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 132505357, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2421.250539049081, "stage_move_gen_ns": 991449459, "stage_ordering_ns": 670653418, "stage_eval_ns": 1672423394, "stage_threat_ns": 3003573749, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 308498, "root_tactical_annotations": 2593, "search_tactical_annotations": 305905, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 192539, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 891753917, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 274517, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1969894001, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52682, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1526047066, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 96264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113230075, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 192528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19349593, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 78118, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 84683717, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 143707, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 359019768, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 86673, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9346163, "child_limit_applications": 26307, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26307, "child_cap_hits": 26307, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26307, "child_moves_before_total": 2104512, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2104512, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 421314, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 421314, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.99817539058046, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0152811038887, "tt_hits": 12113, "tt_cutoffs": 1185, "beta_cutoffs": 21849, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5218.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5945.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1410, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 921, "avg_search_time_ms": 92.1, "search_nodes": 39264, "safety_nodes": 982, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40246, "avg_nodes": 4024.6, "eval_calls": 37505, "avg_eval_calls": 3750.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37505, "pattern_eval_ns": 731542, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.505185975203307, "pattern_frame_queries": 37505, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 731542, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.505185975203307, "pattern_frame_updates": 78470, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 478435986, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6097.056021409456, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1740, "avg_candidate_generations": 174.0, "candidate_moves_total": 127887, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.49827586206897, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 705, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 1730, "search_candidate_moves_total": 127182, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 5396, "avg_legality_checks": 539.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5396, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 131681, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13168.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 240489067, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1826.3004305860375, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2898, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 289.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19708244, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6800.63630089717, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 50580, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2874, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19550164, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 107500, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10221404, "stage_ordering_ns": 56190, "stage_eval_ns": 479167528, "stage_threat_ns": 417077874, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 78480, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 365521804, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 224353, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8091, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 39235, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 43476842, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 78470, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7854875, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 73, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1583, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5864.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6664.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 873, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12165, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 126, 70, 127, 108, 109, 125, 155, 141, 97, 80, 129, 130, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5505, "avg_search_time_ms": 611.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 160286, "safety_nodes": 589, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 160875, "avg_nodes": 17875.0, "eval_calls": 155391, "avg_eval_calls": 17265.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 155391, "pattern_eval_ns": 3069209, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.75152357601148, "pattern_frame_queries": 155391, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3069209, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.75152357601148, "pattern_frame_updates": 320520, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3265406245, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10187.8392768002, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4878, "avg_candidate_generations": 542.0, "candidate_moves_total": 348666, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.47724477244772, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 607, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 4869, "search_candidate_moves_total": 348059, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 150131, "avg_legality_checks": 16681.222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 607, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 149524, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1032255, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 114695.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2263391093, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2192.6666308228105, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10006, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1111.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64742093, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6470.327103737757, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52461, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9999, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64689632, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.5555555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 119841, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8560.07142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 46860, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2603.3333333333335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 342858250, "stage_ordering_ns": 154751, "stage_eval_ns": 3268475454, "stage_threat_ns": 1852764524, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 320529, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1621128683, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 220422, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8310, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 160260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 196414072, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 320520, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35001347, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 238, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4358, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4501.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5390.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1869, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6650, "avg_search_time_ms": 738.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 51120, "safety_nodes": 586, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 51706, "avg_nodes": 5745.111111111111, "eval_calls": 32990, "avg_eval_calls": 3665.5555555555557, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32990, "pattern_eval_ns": 689337, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.89533191876326, "pattern_frame_queries": 32990, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 689337, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.89533191876326, "pattern_frame_updates": 102166, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 830670762, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8130.59884893213, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17077, "avg_candidate_generations": 1897.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 1409356, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.52948410142297, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 638, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 17068, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1408718, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1085577, "avg_legality_checks": 120619.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1072, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1085577, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1072, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2130967, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 236774.11111111112, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4493284318, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2108.5658848776166, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13519, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1502.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 41319723, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3056.4185960500035, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1090, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10894928, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1794, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17381219, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10635, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13043576, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67176, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7464.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 632766240, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9419.528403001072, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 93432, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10381.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 302122162, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3233.6047820875074, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2574197704, "stage_ordering_ns": 577075263, "stage_eval_ns": 831360099, "stage_threat_ns": 2596682876, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 187288, "root_tactical_annotations": 1352, "search_tactical_annotations": 185936, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 102175, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 584784059, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 184747, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1922602138, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34190, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1158086611, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51083, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 72135748, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 102166, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12124180, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 59672, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 340699539, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 90878, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 423730328, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 36738, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5036751, "child_limit_applications": 17068, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17068, "child_cap_hits": 17068, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17068, "child_moves_before_total": 1407646, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1407646, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 273088, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 273088, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.47281462385752, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 6930, "tt_cutoffs": 1025, "beta_cutoffs": 14924, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4563.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5452.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1931, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 874, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14423, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 113, 114, 126, 98, 66, 100, 110, 109, 142, 86, 72, 94, 141, 96, 97, 130, 146, 85, 127, 157, 155, 99, 169 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7000, "avg_search_time_ms": 583.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 73186, "safety_nodes": 987, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 74173, "avg_nodes": 6181.083333333333, "eval_calls": 54028, "avg_eval_calls": 4502.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 54028, "pattern_eval_ns": 1157705, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.42787073369364, "pattern_frame_queries": 54028, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1157705, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.42787073369364, "pattern_frame_updates": 146268, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1773537447, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12125.259434736237, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18124, "avg_candidate_generations": 1510.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1512427, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.44885235047451, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 910, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 18112, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1511517, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 575233, "avg_legality_checks": 47936.083333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1737, "root_legality_checks": 910, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 574323, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1728, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1830846, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 152570.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4090014655, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2233.947942645094, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29026, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2418.8333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 161166978, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5552.503893061394, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2187, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19864167, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12236, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 98341406, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14547, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42474073, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 56, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 487332, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 55425, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4618.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 523342507, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9442.354659449707, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74210, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6184.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 230707081, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3108.8408705026277, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1457614229, "stage_ordering_ns": 610720974, "stage_eval_ns": 1774695152, "stage_threat_ns": 3113399425, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 290023, "root_tactical_annotations": 1486, "search_tactical_annotations": 288537, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 146280, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 881518361, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 254456, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2097413461, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36299, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1362411475, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 73134, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107499165, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 146268, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18369192, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 76656, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 108639753, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 141492, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 625666789, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 71875, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8599246, "child_limit_applications": 18112, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18112, "child_cap_hits": 18112, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18112, "child_moves_before_total": 1509789, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1509789, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 291941, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 291941, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.35849160777386, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.11865061837456, "tt_hits": 7682, "tt_cutoffs": 994, "beta_cutoffs": 14597, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5325.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5992.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 943, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7413, "avg_search_time_ms": 673.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 236323, "safety_nodes": 840, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 237163, "avg_nodes": 21560.272727272728, "eval_calls": 231262, "avg_eval_calls": 21023.81818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 231262, "pattern_eval_ns": 4723300, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.4240212399789, "pattern_frame_queries": 231262, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4723300, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.4240212399789, "pattern_frame_updates": 472582, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4441349028, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9398.049498288128, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5040, "avg_candidate_generations": 458.1818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 435029, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.31527777777778, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 841, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 5029, "search_candidate_moves_total": 434188, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 19109, "avg_legality_checks": 1737.1818181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 19109, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1125679, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 102334.45454545454, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2627869620, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2334.4751212379374, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33879, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3079.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 295677990, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8727.470999734349, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 305890, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33775, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 294827199, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 69, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 544901, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 49450026, "stage_ordering_ns": 175991, "stage_eval_ns": 4446072328, "stage_threat_ns": 2884666092, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 472593, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2528300569, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 209120, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 236291, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 301280861, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 472582, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 54875542, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 292, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4583, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5627.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6355.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 875, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11599, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 128, 144, 80, 99, 129, 113, 96, 64, 141, 54, 94, 85, 71, 69, 84, 95, 52, 67, 66, 38, 108 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 3637, "avg_search_time_ms": 303.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 94579, "safety_nodes": 638, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 95217, "avg_nodes": 7934.75, "eval_calls": 91028, "avg_eval_calls": 7585.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 91028, "pattern_eval_ns": 1820497, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.99930790525992, "pattern_frame_queries": 91028, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1820497, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.99930790525992, "pattern_frame_updates": 189090, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2270385875, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12006.906102913956, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3529, "avg_candidate_generations": 294.0833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 282661, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.09662793992632, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 860, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 3517, "search_candidate_moves_total": 281801, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 84729, "avg_legality_checks": 7060.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 41, "root_legality_checks": 860, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 83869, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 41, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 732260, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 61021.666666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1662053085, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2269.7581255291834, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17415, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1451.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 134223880, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7707.371805914441, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 397173, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17365, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 133826707, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.0833333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 232051, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9282.04, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 32, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.6666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 100970, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3155.3125, "stage_move_gen_ns": 192823203, "stage_ordering_ns": 118051, "stage_eval_ns": 2272206372, "stage_threat_ns": 1152362242, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 189102, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1008764540, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 339012, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11900, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 94545, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121933373, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 189090, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21325317, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 423, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2973, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6156.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6823.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1863, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7949, "avg_search_time_ms": 722.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 66251, "safety_nodes": 846, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67097, "avg_nodes": 6099.727272727273, "eval_calls": 44620, "avg_eval_calls": 4056.3636363636365, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44620, "pattern_eval_ns": 933454, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.92008068130883, "pattern_frame_queries": 44620, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 933454, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.92008068130883, "pattern_frame_updates": 132402, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1303083881, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9841.87460159212, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20416, "avg_candidate_generations": 1856.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1604597, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.59507249216301, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 20405, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1603811, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1082574, "avg_legality_checks": 98415.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3615, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1082574, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3615, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2505574, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 227779.45454545456, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5176063478, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2065.819440176183, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18485, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1680.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 125969668, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6814.696672978091, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3689, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 39356131, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6189, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 59607421, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8602, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26950185, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55931, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89209, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8109.909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 859906906, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9639.239381676736, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 125669, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11424.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 412667884, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3283.7683438238546, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2587503055, "stage_ordering_ns": 648084887, "stage_eval_ns": 1304017335, "stage_threat_ns": 3360514140, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 309977, "root_tactical_annotations": 1296, "search_tactical_annotations": 308681, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 132413, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 756366801, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 278788, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2485276691, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40882, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1389656893, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66201, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93617679, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 132402, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15740154, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 73687, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 357935969, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 164211, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 737558058, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 72079, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9512815, "child_limit_applications": 20405, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20405, "child_cap_hits": 20405, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20405, "child_moves_before_total": 1600196, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1600196, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 326544, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 326544, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.42175937270277, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.003136486155356, "tt_hits": 7970, "tt_cutoffs": 1176, "beta_cutoffs": 17492, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4795.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5523.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1856, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 876, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12250, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 67, 82, 98, 96, 68, 111, 141, 110, 66, 69, 83, 53, 99, 124, 138, 51, 113, 128, 127, 85, 155 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9928, "avg_search_time_ms": 902.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 122619, "safety_nodes": 260, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122879, "avg_nodes": 11170.818181818182, "eval_calls": 93511, "avg_eval_calls": 8501.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 93511, "pattern_eval_ns": 1902182, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.341799360503042, "pattern_frame_queries": 93511, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1902182, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.341799360503042, "pattern_frame_updates": 245144, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2831173549, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11549.022407238195, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27449, "avg_candidate_generations": 2495.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 2046013, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.53870814965937, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 713, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 27438, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2045300, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 818073, "avg_legality_checks": 74370.27272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1445, "root_legality_checks": 713, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 817360, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1445, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2727428, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 247948.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5819094268, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2133.546428356679, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26131, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2375.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 135822123, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5197.739198652941, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1558, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13305147, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13584, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 90925413, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10989, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31591563, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67061, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6096.454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 544097550, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8113.4720627488405, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 88971, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8088.272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 216694820, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2435.5668701037416, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1949987196, "stage_ordering_ns": 819598185, "stage_eval_ns": 2833075731, "stage_threat_ns": 4278129306, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 380660, "root_tactical_annotations": 2225, "search_tactical_annotations": 378435, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 245155, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1376442725, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 348524, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2695574507, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54944, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1888286375, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 122572, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 167380144, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 245144, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29404202, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 102172, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 99738409, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 191399, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 707426892, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 87089, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9327728, "child_limit_applications": 27438, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27438, "child_cap_hits": 27438, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27438, "child_moves_before_total": 2043855, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2043855, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 441153, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 441153, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.48994095779575, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.078176251913405, "tt_hits": 10548, "tt_cutoffs": 1624, "beta_cutoffs": 21475, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3936.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4664.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2310, "avg_search_time_ms": 231.0, "search_nodes": 74146, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 74943, "avg_nodes": 7494.3, "eval_calls": 71548, "avg_eval_calls": 7154.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71548, "pattern_eval_ns": 1437847, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.09625705819869, "pattern_frame_queries": 71548, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1437847, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.09625705819869, "pattern_frame_updates": 148234, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1355065117, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9141.392103026295, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2579, "avg_candidate_generations": 257.9, "candidate_moves_total": 182687, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.83637068631252, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 648, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 2569, "search_candidate_moves_total": 182039, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 5014, "avg_legality_checks": 501.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5014, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 391452, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 39145.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 861412371, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2200.556826890653, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3260, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 326.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29513230, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9053.138036809816, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3260, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29513230, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12804655, "stage_ordering_ns": 82260, "stage_eval_ns": 1356502964, "stage_threat_ns": 925795275, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 148244, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 812420257, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 218181, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10150, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74117, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 95909026, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 148234, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17247811, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 184, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2271, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5727.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6527.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1952, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 877, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22288, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 114, 111, 126, 98, 154, 97, 115, 116, 99, 95, 94, 127, 79, 143, 159, 144, 140, 168, 145, 130, 158, 129, 64, 128, 109, 131 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 6347, "avg_search_time_ms": 488.2307692307692, "search_nodes": 163025, "safety_nodes": 1090, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 164115, "avg_nodes": 12624.23076923077, "eval_calls": 158354, "avg_eval_calls": 12181.076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 158354, "pattern_eval_ns": 3197241, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.190465665534184, "pattern_frame_queries": 158354, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3197241, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.190465665534184, "pattern_frame_updates": 325974, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3865047227, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11856.91873278237, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4646, "avg_candidate_generations": 357.38461538461536, "candidate_moves_total": 346616, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.60525182953079, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 956, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 4633, "search_candidate_moves_total": 345660, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 148717, "avg_legality_checks": 11439.76923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 219, "root_legality_checks": 956, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 147761, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 216, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1176331, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 90487.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2741479638, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2330.5342101840383, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14676, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1128.923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 106884546, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7282.948078495503, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 273, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1982483, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14376, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 104742552, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 159511, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8461538461538463, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 528073, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10561.46, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.538461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 276853, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3845.1805555555557, "stage_move_gen_ns": 370449980, "stage_ordering_ns": 146972, "stage_eval_ns": 3868244468, "stage_threat_ns": 2094128295, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 325987, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1833364922, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 754993, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 162987, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 220331448, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 325974, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39676932, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 258, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4147, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5640.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6255.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1788, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 15926, "avg_search_time_ms": 1225.076923076923, "search_nodes": 139162, "safety_nodes": 524, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 139686, "avg_nodes": 10745.076923076924, "eval_calls": 102058, "avg_eval_calls": 7850.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 102058, "pattern_eval_ns": 2089703, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.475641302004743, "pattern_frame_queries": 102058, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2089703, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.475641302004743, "pattern_frame_updates": 278206, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2680489160, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9634.907802132233, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34838, "avg_candidate_generations": 2679.846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 3151275, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.45510649291005, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 992, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 34825, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3150283, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 2240687, "avg_legality_checks": 172360.53846153847, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5327, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2240687, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5327, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5219807, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 401523.6153846154, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10330506471, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1979.0974016855412, "renju_forbidden_checks": 57141, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4395.461538461538, "renju_forbidden_ns": 175205723, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3066.1998039936298, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5847, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53871498, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9135, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57702043, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 42132, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 63408859, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 223323, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 210319, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16178.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2081688788, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9897.768570599897, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 306641, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23587.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1057589255, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3448.9492761894203, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5200511395, "stage_ordering_ns": 1251772206, "stage_eval_ns": 2682578863, "stage_threat_ns": 6710837703, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 669049, "root_tactical_annotations": 3074, "search_tactical_annotations": 665975, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 278219, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1580060852, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 595333, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4877809682, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69734, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2358457604, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 139103, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 200892582, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 278206, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33715002, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 235378, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1157405333, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 290211, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1361849305, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 143460, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18359585, "child_limit_applications": 34825, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34825, "child_cap_hits": 34825, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34825, "child_moves_before_total": 3144956, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3144956, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 557686, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 557686, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.30742282842786, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.013955491744436, "tt_hits": 15024, "tt_cutoffs": 2220, "beta_cutoffs": 28161, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5104.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5720.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1883, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 878, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15691, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 124, 82, 114, 98, 140, 84, 70, 85, 138, 152, 141, 139, 83, 97, 67, 99, 71, 129, 145, 125, 153, 128, 127, 143, 158, 101, 100, 115, 157, 87 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 10252, "avg_search_time_ms": 603.0588235294117, "search_nodes": 151383, "safety_nodes": 363, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 151746, "avg_nodes": 8926.235294117647, "eval_calls": 103650, "avg_eval_calls": 6097.058823529412, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 103650, "pattern_eval_ns": 2002330, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.318186203569706, "pattern_frame_queries": 103650, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2002330, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.318186203569706, "pattern_frame_updates": 302612, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2664534648, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8805.118924563467, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44992, "avg_candidate_generations": 2646.5882352941176, "candidate_moves_total": 3990302, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.68914473684211, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1329, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 44975, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3988973, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 949444, "avg_legality_checks": 55849.64705882353, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2085, "root_legality_checks": 1329, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 948115, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2084, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3537353, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 208079.58823529413, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5735035727, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1621.2788848045418, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34137, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2008.0588235294117, "renju_forbidden_ns": 177364306, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5195.6617746140555, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2267, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20111008, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14795, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 104727765, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17070, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 52470513, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 80839, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4755.235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 580159176, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7176.723809052562, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109725, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6454.411764705882, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 262146739, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2389.1249851902485, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1746137914, "stage_ordering_ns": 1070490420, "stage_eval_ns": 2666536978, "stage_threat_ns": 4710357253, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 850970, "root_tactical_annotations": 4740, "search_tactical_annotations": 846230, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 302629, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1313185445, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 728035, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3177465175, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90060, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2258866440, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 151306, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 172567426, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 302612, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29280352, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 312558, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 157493924, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 325403, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 760998370, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 213009, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17858855, "child_limit_applications": 44975, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44975, "child_cap_hits": 44975, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44975, "child_moves_before_total": 3986889, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3986889, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 722292, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 722292, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.64678154530294, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.059855475264037, "tt_hits": 22178, "tt_cutoffs": 2681, "beta_cutoffs": 38306, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5922.117647058823, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6392.705882352941, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 970, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 5423, "avg_search_time_ms": 338.9375, "search_nodes": 192642, "safety_nodes": 1728, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 194370, "avg_nodes": 12148.125, "eval_calls": 188022, "avg_eval_calls": 11751.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 188022, "pattern_eval_ns": 3677003, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.556238099796833, "pattern_frame_queries": 188022, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3677003, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.556238099796833, "pattern_frame_updates": 385190, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3227664084, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8379.40778317194, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4589, "avg_candidate_generations": 286.8125, "candidate_moves_total": 360934, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.65199389845282, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1247, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 4573, "search_candidate_moves_total": 359687, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 8582, "avg_legality_checks": 536.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8582, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 954777, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 59673.5625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1872003008, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1960.6704057596696, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15617, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 976.0625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 131139726, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8397.241851828136, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 42820, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15601, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 131006576, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 90330, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19742074, "stage_ordering_ns": 140291, "stage_eval_ns": 3231341087, "stage_threat_ns": 2149745734, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 385206, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1880239608, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 265122, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11800, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 192595, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 227873587, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 385190, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41367417, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 150, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4136, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6166.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6666.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1959, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 879, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23422, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 142, 97, 98, 126, 70, 111, 157, 172, 141, 81, 66, 113, 65, 129, 145, 144, 84, 56, 159, 158, 130, 143, 64, 128, 67, 173 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 6586, "avg_search_time_ms": 506.61538461538464, "search_nodes": 224036, "safety_nodes": 1090, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 225126, "avg_nodes": 17317.384615384617, "eval_calls": 218879, "avg_eval_calls": 16836.846153846152, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 218879, "pattern_eval_ns": 4150748, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.963664855924964, "pattern_frame_queries": 218879, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4150748, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.963664855924964, "pattern_frame_updates": 447996, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4055643015, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9052.855416119786, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5132, "avg_candidate_generations": 394.7692307692308, "candidate_moves_total": 378292, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.71239282930631, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 956, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 5119, "search_candidate_moves_total": 377336, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 203339, "avg_legality_checks": 15641.461538461539, "illegal_moves_skipped": 92, "root_legality_checks": 956, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 202383, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 89, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1584356, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 121873.53846153847, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2832847419, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1788.0119234565968, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20912, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1608.6153846153845, "renju_forbidden_ns": 105902207, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5064.183578806427, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 142, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 908137, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20743, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 104817269, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 176801, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8461538461538463, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 537103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10742.06, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.538461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 283230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3933.75, "stage_move_gen_ns": 377952668, "stage_ordering_ns": 166651, "stage_eval_ns": 4059793763, "stage_threat_ns": 2097467705, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 448009, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1826140047, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 769434, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11840, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 223998, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 229747629, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 447996, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40810595, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 258, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4573, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5621.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6237.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1897, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 16822, "avg_search_time_ms": 1294.0, "search_nodes": 148016, "safety_nodes": 524, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148540, "avg_nodes": 11426.153846153846, "eval_calls": 107849, "avg_eval_calls": 8296.076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107849, "pattern_eval_ns": 2231419, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.69021502285603, "pattern_frame_queries": 107849, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2231419, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.69021502285603, "pattern_frame_updates": 295914, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2673318586, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9034.106483640517, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37826, "avg_candidate_generations": 2909.6923076923076, "candidate_moves_total": 3436403, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.84764447734362, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 992, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 37813, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3435411, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 2492671, "avg_legality_checks": 191743.92307692306, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6363, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2492671, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5726864, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 440528.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10953391989, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1912.633509194561, "renju_forbidden_checks": 78101, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6007.7692307692305, "renju_forbidden_ns": 226655875, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2902.0867210407037, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7469, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 70769999, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10626, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 63425650, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 59979, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 92230595, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 229631, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 246138, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18933.69230769231, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2459530919, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9992.487624828349, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 355310, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27331.53846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1266278788, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3563.870389237567, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5645975494, "stage_ordering_ns": 1270715669, "stage_eval_ns": 2675550005, "stage_threat_ns": 7133277771, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 720019, "root_tactical_annotations": 3074, "search_tactical_annotations": 716945, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 295927, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1609389082, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 657277, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5264542068, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75710, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2337587401, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147957, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 205759585, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 295914, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34036724, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 272540, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1453100852, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 309017, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1473771475, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 138462, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19550312, "child_limit_applications": 37813, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37813, "child_cap_hits": 37813, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37813, "child_moves_before_total": 3429048, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3429048, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 605559, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 605559, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.68436781001243, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.014571708142704, "tt_hits": 15677, "tt_cutoffs": 2295, "beta_cutoffs": 30769, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4870.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5486.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1918, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 880, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 31784, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 82, 97, 98, 95, 84, 126, 81, 83, 111, 94, 93, 110, 142, 80, 125, 66, 157, 172, 108, 65, 50, 64, 63, 78, 62, 109, 79, 70, 52, 48, 32, 124, 68, 138, 152, 100, 47, 77, 51, 53, 31, 15, 33, 34, 19, 61, 17, 2, 20, 36, 18, 21, 16 ], "move_count": 57, "black_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 19832, "avg_search_time_ms": 734.5185185185185, "search_nodes": 244542, "safety_nodes": 1402, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 245944, "avg_nodes": 9109.037037037036, "eval_calls": 167433, "avg_eval_calls": 6201.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 167433, "pattern_eval_ns": 3441385, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.55380361099664, "pattern_frame_queries": 167433, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3441385, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.55380361099664, "pattern_frame_updates": 488830, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4499086274, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9203.785107297015, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 72936, "avg_candidate_generations": 2701.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 6982405, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.73331413842273, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2282, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 72909, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6980123, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 2022575, "avg_legality_checks": 74910.18518518518, "illegal_moves_skipped": 170, "root_legality_checks": 2282, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2020293, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 170, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5671866, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 210069.11111111112, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11264204744, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1985.9786433600511, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44534, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1649.4074074074074, "renju_forbidden_ns": 101409432, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2277.123815511744, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 792, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2725360, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14684, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 55691247, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29050, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42978745, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 14080, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 129691, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4803.37037037037, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 983273867, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7581.666168045585, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 171737, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6360.62962962963, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 418093110, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2434.496410208633, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4482425173, "stage_ordering_ns": 2308826874, "stage_eval_ns": 4502527659, "stage_threat_ns": 8422548581, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1382093, "root_tactical_annotations": 6345, "search_tactical_annotations": 1375748, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 488857, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2552965993, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1240038, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5441485783, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 145998, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3730128168, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 244415, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 339164911, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 488830, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55440456, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 555313, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 297157614, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 538706, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1413766189, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 288074, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33491438, "child_limit_applications": 72909, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 72909, "child_cap_hits": 72909, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 72909, "child_moves_before_total": 6979953, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6979953, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 1166922, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1166922, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.73513557996955, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.005184545117885, "tt_hits": 31838, "tt_cutoffs": 4074, "beta_cutoffs": 62190, "depth_sum": 126, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 126, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 24 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.037037037037037035, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.037037037037037035, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.037037037037037035, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6382.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6678.62962962963, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 28, "search_move_count": 26, "total_time_ms": 11927, "avg_search_time_ms": 458.7307692307692, "search_nodes": 478661, "safety_nodes": 2253, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 480914, "avg_nodes": 18496.69230769231, "eval_calls": 465810, "avg_eval_calls": 17915.76923076923, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 465810, "pattern_eval_ns": 9398651, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.17700564607887, "pattern_frame_queries": 465810, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 9398651, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.17700564607887, "pattern_frame_updates": 957168, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6488369562, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6778.71550448824, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12800, "avg_candidate_generations": 492.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 1217721, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.134453125, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 26, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2214, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 12774, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1215507, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 30517, "avg_legality_checks": 1173.7307692307693, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 30517, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2165180, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 83276.15384615384, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4021472231, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1857.3385265890133, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4041, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 155.42307692307693, "renju_forbidden_ns": 24207544, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5990.483543677307, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4041, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24207544, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 70952721, "stage_ordering_ns": 424601, "stage_eval_ns": 6497768213, "stage_threat_ns": 5252552031, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 957194, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4567643576, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 73, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 435913, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 27410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 478584, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 582647780, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 957168, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 101824762, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 881, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 11355, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 2.9615384615384617, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9615384615384617, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 25 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 26, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.038461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7058.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7366.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1948, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 881, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22854, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 126, 98, 154, 143, 113, 111, 52, 67, 95, 129, 140, 168, 81, 157, 115, 159, 175, 114, 65, 49, 144, 142, 156, 131, 130, 187, 145, 172 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 7262, "avg_search_time_ms": 484.1333333333333, "search_nodes": 188963, "safety_nodes": 1382, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 190345, "avg_nodes": 12689.666666666666, "eval_calls": 183762, "avg_eval_calls": 12250.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 183762, "pattern_eval_ns": 3681164, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.032237350485953, "pattern_frame_queries": 183762, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3681164, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.032237350485953, "pattern_frame_updates": 377838, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4489214381, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11881.320515670737, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5172, "avg_candidate_generations": 344.8, "candidate_moves_total": 440557, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.18116782675948, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1218, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 5157, "search_candidate_moves_total": 439339, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 164140, "avg_legality_checks": 10942.666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 1218, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 162922, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1423413, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 94894.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3300520600, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2318.7371479675962, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8683, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 578.8666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 78882653, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9084.723367499711, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 43090, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8673, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 78787543, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 52020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.533333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 348832, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9179.78947368421, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.3333333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 160031, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3200.62, "stage_move_gen_ns": 386523450, "stage_ordering_ns": 171272, "stage_eval_ns": 4492895545, "stage_threat_ns": 2352291080, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 377853, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2060108391, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 577363, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 188919, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 247806850, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 377838, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43798476, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 295, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4674, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6335.733333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6869.066666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1817, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 15576, "avg_search_time_ms": 1038.4, "search_nodes": 151660, "safety_nodes": 458, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 152118, "avg_nodes": 10141.2, "eval_calls": 110083, "avg_eval_calls": 7338.866666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110083, "pattern_eval_ns": 2247388, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.415395656005014, "pattern_frame_queries": 110083, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2247388, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.415395656005014, "pattern_frame_updates": 303186, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2502947753, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8255.485916236237, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39259, "avg_candidate_generations": 2617.266666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 3805945, "avg_candidate_moves": 96.9445222751471, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1253, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 39244, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3804692, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 2658741, "avg_legality_checks": 177249.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 69, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2658741, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 69, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5181045, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 345403.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10107958594, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1950.9497782783203, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9545, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 636.3333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15004229, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1571.946464117339, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 69, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 522754, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1266, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10051007, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8200, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4324397, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 106071, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 137734, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9182.266666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1151306896, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8358.915707087575, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 187307, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12487.133333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 530788293, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2833.787808250626, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5748983854, "stage_ordering_ns": 1346950640, "stage_eval_ns": 2505195141, "stage_threat_ns": 5857270774, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 752063, "root_tactical_annotations": 3808, "search_tactical_annotations": 748255, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 303201, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1636470673, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 654267, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3957517726, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 78584, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2369945722, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 151593, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 206623807, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 303186, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34642571, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 259888, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 582920624, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 315784, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1004591800, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 176391, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22015997, "child_limit_applications": 39244, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39244, "child_cap_hits": 39244, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39244, "child_moves_before_total": 3804623, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3804623, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 628461, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 628461, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 96.94789012333095, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.014193252471717, "tt_hits": 18003, "tt_cutoffs": 2266, "beta_cutoffs": 32077, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5828.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6361.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1847, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 882, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12520, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 67, 82, 96, 98, 66, 113, 143, 114, 68, 65, 81, 51, 95, 130, 146, 53, 111, 126, 127, 79, 159 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10076, "avg_search_time_ms": 916.0, "search_nodes": 121677, "safety_nodes": 260, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 121937, "avg_nodes": 11085.181818181818, "eval_calls": 92591, "avg_eval_calls": 8417.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 92591, "pattern_eval_ns": 1940339, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.95602164357227, "pattern_frame_queries": 92591, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1940339, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.95602164357227, "pattern_frame_updates": 243260, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2858023158, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11748.841396037162, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27438, "avg_candidate_generations": 2494.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 2047519, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.62347838763759, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 713, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 27427, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2046806, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 849810, "avg_legality_checks": 77255.45454545454, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1474, "root_legality_checks": 713, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 849097, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1474, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2752040, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 250185.45454545456, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5952064901, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2162.782845089461, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26479, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2407.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 135859640, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5130.844820423732, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1587, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14141487, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13302, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 89076833, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11590, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32641320, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 69015, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6274.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 565192456, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8189.414706947765, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91078, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8279.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 223166032, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2450.273743384791, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2053180177, "stage_ordering_ns": 816387454, "stage_eval_ns": 2859963497, "stage_threat_ns": 4300063020, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 381355, "root_tactical_annotations": 2225, "search_tactical_annotations": 379130, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 243271, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1368511191, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 350691, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2724243807, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54922, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1881700324, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 168485808, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 243260, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28867071, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 100902, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 100589912, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 194858, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 741828411, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 85595, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9955143, "child_limit_applications": 27427, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27427, "child_cap_hits": 27427, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27427, "child_moves_before_total": 2045332, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2045332, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 440975, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 440975, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.57366828307872, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.07813468479965, "tt_hits": 10425, "tt_cutoffs": 1612, "beta_cutoffs": 21495, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3840.2727272727275, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4567.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2433, "avg_search_time_ms": 243.3, "search_nodes": 75880, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76677, "avg_nodes": 7667.7, "eval_calls": 73292, "avg_eval_calls": 7329.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73292, "pattern_eval_ns": 1481527, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.21403427386345, "pattern_frame_queries": 73292, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1481527, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.21403427386345, "pattern_frame_updates": 151702, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1449196850, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9552.9185508431, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2569, "avg_candidate_generations": 256.9, "candidate_moves_total": 182041, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.86064616582328, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 648, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 2559, "search_candidate_moves_total": 181393, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 4779, "avg_legality_checks": 477.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4779, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 414641, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 41464.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 932785161, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2249.6211445563754, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3310, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 331.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30497606, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9213.778247734139, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3310, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30497606, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12388772, "stage_ordering_ns": 86081, "stage_eval_ns": 1450678377, "stage_threat_ns": 951832407, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 151712, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 836456176, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 219682, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75851, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 97475833, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 151702, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17680716, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 184, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2255, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5737.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6537.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1949, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 883, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16707, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 128, 64, 127, 115, 116, 129, 125, 124, 97, 139, 83, 69, 84, 80, 48, 85, 100, 68, 99, 154, 98, 109, 101 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 4966, "avg_search_time_ms": 382.0, "search_nodes": 175435, "safety_nodes": 1090, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 176525, "avg_nodes": 13578.846153846154, "eval_calls": 170389, "avg_eval_calls": 13106.846153846154, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 170389, "pattern_eval_ns": 3356887, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.701312878178754, "pattern_frame_queries": 170389, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3356887, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.701312878178754, "pattern_frame_updates": 350794, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3027512510, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8630.45693483925, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5021, "avg_candidate_generations": 386.2307692307692, "candidate_moves_total": 367384, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.16948814977096, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 956, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 5008, "search_candidate_moves_total": 366428, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 157761, "avg_legality_checks": 12135.461538461539, "illegal_moves_skipped": 151, "root_legality_checks": 956, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 156805, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 148, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1210393, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 93107.15384615384, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2088045900, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1725.0974683429267, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19196, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1476.6153846153845, "renju_forbidden_ns": 98673066, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5140.29308189206, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 229, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1658453, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18940, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 96842053, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 172560, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8461538461538463, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 394242, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7884.84, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.538461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 211182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2933.0833333333335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 273738050, "stage_ordering_ns": 167400, "stage_eval_ns": 3030869397, "stage_threat_ns": 1634829661, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 350807, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1409998308, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 571293, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 175397, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 192458817, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 350794, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31801243, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 258, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4513, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5845.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6460.615384615385, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1853, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 11727, "avg_search_time_ms": 902.0769230769231, "search_nodes": 147718, "safety_nodes": 524, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148242, "avg_nodes": 11403.23076923077, "eval_calls": 107449, "avg_eval_calls": 8265.307692307691, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107449, "pattern_eval_ns": 2152348, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.03134510325829, "pattern_frame_queries": 107449, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2152348, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.03134510325829, "pattern_frame_updates": 295318, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2040701441, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6910.183060294326, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37899, "avg_candidate_generations": 2915.3076923076924, "candidate_moves_total": 3423081, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.32114303807488, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 992, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 37886, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3422089, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 2489300, "avg_legality_checks": 191484.61538461538, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2200, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2489300, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2200, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5779524, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 444578.76923076925, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7347470427, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1271.2933499367768, "renju_forbidden_checks": 91617, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7047.461538461538, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124273154, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1356.4420795267254, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3256, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17533135, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8461, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27203134, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 79873, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 79323651, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 213234, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 254486, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19575.846153846152, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1663550829, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6536.905091046266, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 371467, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 28574.384615384617, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 874303786, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2353.6512960774444, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3697923714, "stage_ordering_ns": 874652160, "stage_eval_ns": 2042853789, "stage_threat_ns": 5000804005, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 730966, "root_tactical_annotations": 3074, "search_tactical_annotations": 727892, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 295331, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1224456186, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 665601, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3569310472, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75856, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1572831623, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147659, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 161835600, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 295318, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27165031, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 279195, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 995973083, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 310540, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1000413064, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 141231, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18036716, "child_limit_applications": 37886, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37886, "child_cap_hits": 37886, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37886, "child_moves_before_total": 3419889, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3419889, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 607939, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 607939, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.26788259515388, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.04653433986169, "tt_hits": 15728, "tt_cutoffs": 2324, "beta_cutoffs": 30875, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6024.076923076923, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6639.461538461538, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1918, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 884, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16253, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 96, 94, 142, 114, 128, 80, 144, 160, 145, 78, 62, 81, 79, 143, 127, 157, 129, 161, 99, 85, 95, 63, 98, 97, 83, 68, 131, 130, 115, 67, 147 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 13940, "avg_search_time_ms": 820.0, "search_nodes": 156925, "safety_nodes": 363, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 157288, "avg_nodes": 9252.235294117647, "eval_calls": 107258, "avg_eval_calls": 6309.294117647059, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107258, "pattern_eval_ns": 2340033, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.81686214548099, "pattern_frame_queries": 107258, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2340033, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.81686214548099, "pattern_frame_updates": 313696, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3488889080, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11121.879399163521, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46923, "avg_candidate_generations": 2760.176470588235, "candidate_moves_total": 4156545, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.58225177418323, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1329, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 46906, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4155216, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 938889, "avg_legality_checks": 55228.76470588235, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1943, "root_legality_checks": 1329, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 937560, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1942, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3477550, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 204561.76470588235, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7699407930, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2214.032272720737, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31210, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1835.8823529411766, "renju_forbidden_ns": 193390278, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6196.420314001923, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2092, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22218348, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13236, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 110445976, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15877, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 60665413, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 60541, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76830, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4519.411764705882, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 721650344, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9392.819783938565, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 104885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6169.705882352941, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 320152130, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3052.4110215950805, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2306748215, "stage_ordering_ns": 1641827510, "stage_eval_ns": 3491229113, "stage_threat_ns": 6433719868, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 847515, "root_tactical_annotations": 4740, "search_tactical_annotations": 842775, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 313713, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1823271750, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 744245, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4315222068, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 93922, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3116595779, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 156848, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 233690596, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 313696, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39830838, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 326872, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 220671845, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 323437, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 977835613, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 197206, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21704616, "child_limit_applications": 46906, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46906, "child_cap_hits": 46906, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46906, "child_moves_before_total": 4153274, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4153274, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 752914, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 752914, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.54462115720803, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.051549908327292, "tt_hits": 22204, "tt_cutoffs": 2684, "beta_cutoffs": 39964, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5755.470588235294, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6226.058823529412, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 941, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 2297, "avg_search_time_ms": 143.5625, "search_nodes": 81732, "safety_nodes": 1728, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 83460, "avg_nodes": 5216.25, "eval_calls": 78231, "avg_eval_calls": 4889.4375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 78231, "pattern_eval_ns": 1664514, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.276910687579093, "pattern_frame_queries": 78231, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1664514, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.276910687579093, "pattern_frame_updates": 163370, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1240428627, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7592.756485278815, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3470, "avg_candidate_generations": 216.875, "candidate_moves_total": 279918, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.66801152737752, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1247, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 3454, "search_candidate_moves_total": 278671, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 7797, "avg_legality_checks": 487.3125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7797, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 330692, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20668.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 739684323, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2236.77719146517, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2822, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 176.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 23271178, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8246.342310418144, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 61230, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2806, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 23086767, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 123181, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20884393, "stage_ordering_ns": 114760, "stage_eval_ns": 1242093141, "stage_threat_ns": 1003677195, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 163386, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 878576086, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 377610, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17780, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 81685, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105754960, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 163370, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18968539, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 150, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3149, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6619.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7119.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1968, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 885, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20318, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 96, 160, 97, 108, 109, 95, 129, 145, 127, 130, 99, 100, 115, 144, 176, 85, 143, 157, 83, 67, 53, 68, 81, 175, 65 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 8023, "avg_search_time_ms": 573.0714285714286, "search_nodes": 196070, "safety_nodes": 1182, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 197252, "avg_nodes": 14089.42857142857, "eval_calls": 190595, "avg_eval_calls": 13613.92857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 190595, "pattern_eval_ns": 4102268, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.52348172827199, "pattern_frame_queries": 190595, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4102268, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.52348172827199, "pattern_frame_updates": 392058, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4918826554, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12546.170602308843, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5448, "avg_candidate_generations": 389.14285714285717, "candidate_moves_total": 401084, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.62041116005874, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 989, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 5434, "search_candidate_moves_total": 400095, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 185472, "avg_legality_checks": 13248.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 174, "root_legality_checks": 989, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 184483, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 169, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1442574, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 103041.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3423390015, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2373.1122389561992, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19543, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1395.9285714285713, "renju_forbidden_ns": 189612963, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9702.346773780893, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 176, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1701798, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19342, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 187653644, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 257521, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 56, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 507183, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9056.839285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 75, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.357142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 244362, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3258.16, "stage_move_gen_ns": 470394750, "stage_ordering_ns": 180101, "stage_eval_ns": 4922928822, "stage_threat_ns": 2606680068, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 392072, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2281237791, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 771884, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14880, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 196029, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 275157063, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 392058, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49513330, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 248, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4910, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5738.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6309.928571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1817, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 12283, "avg_search_time_ms": 877.3571428571429, "search_nodes": 93037, "safety_nodes": 540, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 93577, "avg_nodes": 6684.071428571428, "eval_calls": 62070, "avg_eval_calls": 4433.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62070, "pattern_eval_ns": 1352977, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.797599484453038, "pattern_frame_queries": 62070, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1352977, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.797599484453038, "pattern_frame_updates": 185950, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1735693370, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9334.193976875504, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29489, "avg_candidate_generations": 2106.3571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 2526871, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.6885957475669, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1025, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 29475, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2525846, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1913801, "avg_legality_checks": 136700.07142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6846, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1913801, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6846, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4077659, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 291261.35714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8157400207, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2000.5106378439198, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20942, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1495.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 108494230, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5180.70050615987, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6846, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 59692622, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3965, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34105358, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10091, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14284488, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 411762, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 152657, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10904.07142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1458558525, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9554.48177941398, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 217788, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15556.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 736418354, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3381.354133377413, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4424444917, "stage_ordering_ns": 995076936, "stage_eval_ns": 1737046347, "stage_threat_ns": 5041599671, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 544876, "root_tactical_annotations": 2684, "search_tactical_annotations": 542192, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 185964, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1074568741, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 493808, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3791575214, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59039, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1987509272, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92975, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 137095200, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 185950, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23329496, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 206890, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 765864139, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 227869, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1038090593, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110117, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15031020, "child_limit_applications": 29475, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29475, "child_cap_hits": 29475, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29475, "child_moves_before_total": 2519000, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2519000, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 472464, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 472464, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.46225614927906, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.029312977099238, "tt_hits": 12668, "tt_cutoffs": 1430, "beta_cutoffs": 25530, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5707.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6279.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1863, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 886, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9635, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 83, 144, 96, 95, 99, 127, 68, 53, 100, 97, 101, 102, 143, 67, 82, 81, 109, 39 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8141, "avg_search_time_ms": 740.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 94448, "safety_nodes": 288, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 94736, "avg_nodes": 8612.363636363636, "eval_calls": 72140, "avg_eval_calls": 6558.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72140, "pattern_eval_ns": 1516684, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.024175214859994, "pattern_frame_queries": 72140, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1516684, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.024175214859994, "pattern_frame_updates": 188802, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2136848405, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11317.933099225644, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21403, "avg_candidate_generations": 1945.7272727272727, "candidate_moves_total": 1637081, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.48838947811055, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 716, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 21392, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1636365, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 629551, "avg_legality_checks": 57231.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3899, "root_legality_checks": 716, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 628835, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2191059, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 199187.18181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4728900696, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2158.2717288763106, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23250, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2113.6363636363635, "renju_forbidden_ns": 140148812, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6027.905892473118, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3949, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 41079274, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10106, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 76612925, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9145, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21954390, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 502223, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74084, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6734.909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 656516073, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8861.779507046056, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98905, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8991.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 283151538, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2862.8637379303373, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1576187169, "stage_ordering_ns": 690885093, "stage_eval_ns": 2138365089, "stage_threat_ns": 3693764395, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 272745, "root_tactical_annotations": 1806, "search_tactical_annotations": 270939, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 188813, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1105873067, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 258550, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2422488361, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42852, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1557949884, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 94401, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 134593606, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 188802, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23510264, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70875, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 179981310, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 144816, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 684548547, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 57054, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7299097, "child_limit_applications": 21392, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21392, "child_cap_hits": 21392, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21392, "child_moves_before_total": 1632476, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1632476, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 342814, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 342814, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.31245325355273, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.025336574420344, "tt_hits": 8499, "tt_cutoffs": 869, "beta_cutoffs": 16707, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4665.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5393.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 889, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 1483, "avg_search_time_ms": 148.3, "search_nodes": 47429, "safety_nodes": 915, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48344, "avg_nodes": 4834.4, "eval_calls": 44922, "avg_eval_calls": 4492.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44922, "pattern_eval_ns": 926132, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.61644628467121, "pattern_frame_queries": 44922, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 926132, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.61644628467121, "pattern_frame_updates": 94800, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 842892731, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8891.273533755275, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2488, "avg_candidate_generations": 248.8, "candidate_moves_total": 175176, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.40836012861736, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 650, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 2478, "search_candidate_moves_total": 174526, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 5079, "avg_legality_checks": 507.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5079, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 222239, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22223.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 506119243, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2277.3646524687388, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3764, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 376.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33108027, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8795.968916046759, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 238541, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3690, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32356143, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 513343, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14092438, "stage_ordering_ns": 80250, "stage_eval_ns": 843818863, "stage_threat_ns": 607365084, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 94810, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 533967211, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 291313, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 61800944, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 94800, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11305616, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 131, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2215, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5835.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6635.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1957, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 887, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10977, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 95, 114, 100, 156, 170, 143, 98, 158, 173, 99, 84, 126, 67, 82, 70, 56, 174, 141, 171, 172, 94, 96, 111, 144, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3221, "avg_search_time_ms": 230.07142857142858, "search_nodes": 74516, "safety_nodes": 1451, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 75967, "avg_nodes": 5426.214285714285, "eval_calls": 71293, "avg_eval_calls": 5092.357142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71293, "pattern_eval_ns": 1449983, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.338364215280603, "pattern_frame_queries": 71293, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1449983, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.338364215280603, "pattern_frame_updates": 148950, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2086422075, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14007.533232628399, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3196, "avg_candidate_generations": 228.28571428571428, "candidate_moves_total": 263070, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.31226533166458, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1051, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 3182, "search_candidate_moves_total": 262019, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 68683, "avg_legality_checks": 4905.928571428572, "illegal_moves_skipped": 323, "root_legality_checks": 1051, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 67632, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 317, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 668895, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 47778.21428571428, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1550756838, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2318.3860516224518, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15291, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1092.2142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124401497, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8135.602445883199, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 331, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3076165, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14910, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 120943940, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 381392, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 79, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.642857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 751216, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9509.06329113924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.928571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 350895, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3617.4742268041236, "stage_move_gen_ns": 167353402, "stage_ordering_ns": 104300, "stage_eval_ns": 2087872058, "stage_threat_ns": 939214992, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 148964, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 822092105, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1037956, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14350, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74475, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 98580858, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 148950, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17504073, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 187, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2877, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6460.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7031.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1873, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 7742, "avg_search_time_ms": 553.0, "search_nodes": 56249, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 57222, "avg_nodes": 4087.285714285714, "eval_calls": 37435, "avg_eval_calls": 2673.9285714285716, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37435, "pattern_eval_ns": 829044, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.146226793108053, "pattern_frame_queries": 37435, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 829044, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.146226793108053, "pattern_frame_updates": 112374, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1197145616, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10653.225977539289, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17648, "avg_candidate_generations": 1260.5714285714287, "candidate_moves_total": 1511056, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.6219401631913, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1096, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 17634, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1509960, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1092459, "avg_legality_checks": 78032.78571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3552, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1092459, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3552, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2482005, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 177286.07142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5088732366, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2050.2506505828956, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58239, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4159.928571428572, "renju_forbidden_ns": 147792595, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2537.6911519771975, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5468, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 41121322, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7410, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34406819, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 45237, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 71656353, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 124, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 608101, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98813, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7058.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 979917831, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9916.89181585419, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 130490, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9320.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 479692098, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3676.0832094413363, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2612178903, "stage_ordering_ns": 603428497, "stage_eval_ns": 1197974660, "stage_threat_ns": 3275769669, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 344895, "root_tactical_annotations": 1582, "search_tactical_annotations": 343313, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 112388, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 687131640, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 300873, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2483065374, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35357, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1272063288, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56187, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81517927, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 112374, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14519668, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 107539, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 499458103, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 157968, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 711283293, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79388, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9535060, "child_limit_applications": 17634, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17634, "child_cap_hits": 17634, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17634, "child_moves_before_total": 1506408, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1506408, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 282947, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 282947, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.42633548826132, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.045537030736078, "tt_hits": 7768, "tt_cutoffs": 1118, "beta_cutoffs": 15272, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5676.214285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6247.642857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1842, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 888, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18585, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 98, 143, 82, 97, 126, 84, 50, 66, 81, 140, 80, 79, 95, 65, 67, 109, 51, 94, 53, 39, 52, 49, 54 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10559, "avg_search_time_ms": 879.9166666666666, "search_nodes": 122291, "safety_nodes": 395, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122686, "avg_nodes": 10223.833333333334, "eval_calls": 83714, "avg_eval_calls": 6976.166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83714, "pattern_eval_ns": 1719597, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.54133119908259, "pattern_frame_queries": 83714, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1719597, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.54133119908259, "pattern_frame_updates": 244478, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2416439259, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9884.076518132511, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35846, "avg_candidate_generations": 2987.1666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2755252, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.86358310550689, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 779, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 35834, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2754473, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 906732, "avg_legality_checks": 75561.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 131, "root_legality_checks": 779, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 905953, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 131, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2883473, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 240289.41666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6177900534, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2142.5206804433406, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12974, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1081.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 39136650, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3016.5446277169726, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 145, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1335776, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3663, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26138866, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9163, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11657568, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 61848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5154.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 531001245, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8585.584740007762, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 82531, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6877.583333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 225815472, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2736.129115120379, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2142692221, "stage_ordering_ns": 1099018220, "stage_eval_ns": 2418158856, "stage_threat_ns": 4849148541, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 433390, "root_tactical_annotations": 2716, "search_tactical_annotations": 430674, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 244490, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1372408076, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 424482, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3269265227, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 71743, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2430835119, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 122239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 168059898, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 244478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29457180, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 130861, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 114168889, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 221867, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 724025527, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 80662, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9958160, "child_limit_applications": 35834, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35834, "child_cap_hits": 35834, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35834, "child_moves_before_total": 2754342, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2754342, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 573348, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 573348, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.86392811296534, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00011162583022, "tt_hits": 14799, "tt_cutoffs": 2691, "beta_cutoffs": 30391, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4502.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5168.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 713, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8012, "avg_search_time_ms": 728.3636363636364, "search_nodes": 265790, "safety_nodes": 913, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 266703, "avg_nodes": 24245.727272727272, "eval_calls": 261156, "avg_eval_calls": 23741.454545454544, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 261156, "pattern_eval_ns": 5287428, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.2462436245003, "pattern_frame_queries": 261156, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5287428, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.2462436245003, "pattern_frame_updates": 531516, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4637000709, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8724.103712776285, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4613, "avg_candidate_generations": 419.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 358757, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.77086494688922, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 723, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 4602, "search_candidate_moves_total": 358034, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 9487, "avg_legality_checks": 862.4545454545455, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9487, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1288049, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 117095.36363636363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2822209353, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2191.072973931892, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3165, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 287.72727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 22103114, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6983.6063191153235, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3165, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22103114, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 24345052, "stage_ordering_ns": 145710, "stage_eval_ns": 4642288137, "stage_threat_ns": 3315038788, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 531527, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2907565428, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 252570, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11350, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 265758, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 343577686, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 531516, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63643104, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 175, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4252, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5604.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6331.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1814, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 889, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11436, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 80, 99, 141, 71, 85, 128, 125, 129, 130, 65, 109, 108, 93, 77, 157 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 3725, "avg_search_time_ms": 413.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 92008, "safety_nodes": 510, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92518, "avg_nodes": 10279.777777777777, "eval_calls": 89400, "avg_eval_calls": 9933.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89400, "pattern_eval_ns": 1807943, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.22307606263982, "pattern_frame_queries": 89400, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1807943, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.22307606263982, "pattern_frame_updates": 183966, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2322876139, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12626.660029570681, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2592, "avg_candidate_generations": 288.0, "candidate_moves_total": 190185, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.3738425925926, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 628, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 2583, "search_candidate_moves_total": 189557, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 87211, "avg_legality_checks": 9690.111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 628, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 86583, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 714772, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 79419.11111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1696947044, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2374.1095678062375, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8189, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 909.8888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62159108, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7590.561484918793, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 169281, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8164, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 61989827, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 12, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.3333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 114290, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9524.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.6666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 50420, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3361.3333333333335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 212536338, "stage_ordering_ns": 88780, "stage_eval_ns": 2324684082, "stage_threat_ns": 1170278919, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 183975, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1027248188, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 195321, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91983, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 120838417, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 183966, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21996993, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2213, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5284.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6173.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1879, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7702, "avg_search_time_ms": 962.75, "search_nodes": 61227, "safety_nodes": 553, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 61780, "avg_nodes": 7722.5, "eval_calls": 41829, "avg_eval_calls": 5228.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41829, "pattern_eval_ns": 875981, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.941954146644672, "pattern_frame_queries": 41829, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 875981, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.941954146644672, "pattern_frame_updates": 122384, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1257112523, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10271.869876781278, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18205, "avg_candidate_generations": 2275.625, "candidate_moves_total": 1486856, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.67294699258446, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 555, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 18197, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1486301, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1076416, "avg_legality_checks": 134552.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 691, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1076416, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 691, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2453620, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 306702.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5137690621, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2093.9227023744506, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14982, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1872.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37760295, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2520.3774529435323, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 697, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6728706, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1876, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13641110, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12409, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17390479, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 96429, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12053.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 868729117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9009.002654803016, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 128659, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16082.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 383257006, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2978.858890555655, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2598823867, "stage_ordering_ns": 611098266, "stage_eval_ns": 1257988504, "stage_threat_ns": 3185449545, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 266942, "root_tactical_annotations": 981, "search_tactical_annotations": 265961, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 122392, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 705593259, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 254278, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2373108305, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36445, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1265963443, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61192, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 84906106, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 122384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14959813, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 53859, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 275897493, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 163968, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 831147688, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49115, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6882062, "child_limit_applications": 18197, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18197, "child_cap_hits": 18197, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18197, "child_moves_before_total": 1485610, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1485610, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 291199, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 291199, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.64038028246414, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002582843325822, "tt_hits": 5627, "tt_cutoffs": 1167, "beta_cutoffs": 15505, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2689.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3689.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 723, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 890, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11196, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 99, 141, 109, 140, 95, 97, 139, 67, 124, 82, 52, 94, 123, 81, 155, 83, 69, 80, 84, 79 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7786, "avg_search_time_ms": 648.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 90402, "safety_nodes": 900, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91302, "avg_nodes": 7608.5, "eval_calls": 67607, "avg_eval_calls": 5633.916666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67607, "pattern_eval_ns": 1391189, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.577588119573416, "pattern_frame_queries": 67607, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1391189, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.577588119573416, "pattern_frame_updates": 180700, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2001247869, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11074.974371887105, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21891, "avg_candidate_generations": 1824.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1640447, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.93705175642958, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 742, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 21879, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1639705, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 705127, "avg_legality_checks": 58760.583333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 731, "root_legality_checks": 742, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 704385, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 730, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2134572, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 177881.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4614780627, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2161.9231522759596, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11643, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 970.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 55135439, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4735.501073606459, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 755, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7813702, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4470, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34917036, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6411, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12345951, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 58750, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54645, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4553.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 436723407, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7992.010376063684, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68623, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5718.583333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 168405318, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2454.0652259446542, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1672545893, "stage_ordering_ns": 675499103, "stage_eval_ns": 2002639058, "stage_threat_ns": 3399564595, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 280629, "root_tactical_annotations": 1377, "search_tactical_annotations": 279252, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 180712, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1034749137, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 270674, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2206519879, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43833, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1559184445, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 90350, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 130248701, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 180700, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22004017, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 78565, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 88946651, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 148265, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 557923251, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53799, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6042861, "child_limit_applications": 21879, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21879, "child_cap_hits": 21879, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21879, "child_moves_before_total": 1638975, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1638975, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 350067, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 350067, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.9108734402852, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000137117784178, "tt_hits": 8191, "tt_cutoffs": 864, "beta_cutoffs": 17458, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5159.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5826.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1222, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3397, "avg_search_time_ms": 308.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 111074, "safety_nodes": 518, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 111592, "avg_nodes": 10144.727272727272, "eval_calls": 107038, "avg_eval_calls": 9730.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107038, "pattern_eval_ns": 2186848, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.430576057101216, "pattern_frame_queries": 107038, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2186848, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.430576057101216, "pattern_frame_updates": 222084, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1968363099, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8863.146822823797, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4015, "avg_candidate_generations": 365.0, "candidate_moves_total": 296538, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.85753424657534, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 678, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 4004, "search_candidate_moves_total": 295860, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 10181, "avg_legality_checks": 925.5454545454545, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10181, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 554459, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 50405.36363636364, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1229074578, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2216.7095817725026, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2852, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 259.27272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15110996, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5298.3856942496495, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 32130, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2844, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15017136, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61730, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 26054713, "stage_ordering_ns": 150861, "stage_eval_ns": 1970549947, "stage_threat_ns": 1378377379, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 222095, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1207466336, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 155470, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111042, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 144709108, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 222084, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26046465, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 316, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3520, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5991.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6718.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 891, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9684, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 159, 143, 126, 83, 141, 156, 84, 113, 129, 67, 52, 65, 49, 79, 80, 128, 98, 114, 100, 68, 66, 115, 116, 99, 51, 131 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 5426, "avg_search_time_ms": 361.73333333333335, "search_nodes": 132779, "safety_nodes": 1348, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 134127, "avg_nodes": 8941.8, "eval_calls": 128723, "avg_eval_calls": 8581.533333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 128723, "pattern_eval_ns": 2600258, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.200414844278022, "pattern_frame_queries": 128723, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2600258, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.200414844278022, "pattern_frame_updates": 265472, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3490289893, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13147.487844292431, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4028, "avg_candidate_generations": 268.53333333333336, "candidate_moves_total": 314600, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.10327706057596, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1037, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 4013, "search_candidate_moves_total": 313563, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 125401, "avg_legality_checks": 8360.066666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1213, "root_legality_checks": 1037, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 124364, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1209, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1228089, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 81872.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2644988170, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2153.743067481266, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28813, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1920.8666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 198914156, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6903.625308020685, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9265260, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27554, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 189429405, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 219491, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 110, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 973073, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8846.118181818181, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 147, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 463591, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3153.6802721088434, "stage_move_gen_ns": 285689484, "stage_ordering_ns": 156881, "stage_eval_ns": 3492890151, "stage_threat_ns": 1616807058, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 265487, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1410289571, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1171134, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 132736, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 174924964, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 265472, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30421389, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 334, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3525, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6551.466666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7084.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1872, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 4246, "avg_search_time_ms": 303.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 42116, "safety_nodes": 1246, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 43362, "avg_nodes": 3097.285714285714, "eval_calls": 28275, "avg_eval_calls": 2019.642857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 28275, "pattern_eval_ns": 575604, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.3573474801061, "pattern_frame_queries": 28275, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 575604, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.3573474801061, "pattern_frame_updates": 84102, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 796302837, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9468.298459014055, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12938, "avg_candidate_generations": 924.1428571428571, "candidate_moves_total": 948713, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.32763951151647, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 968, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 12924, "search_candidate_moves_total": 947745, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 549426, "avg_legality_checks": 39244.71428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 401, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 549426, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 401, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1503466, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 107390.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2702072552, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1797.2289044115398, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8053, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 575.2142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 22933521, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2847.8232956662114, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 403, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3425969, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2073, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12330490, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5557, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6986542, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 190520, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 57124, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4080.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 475519680, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8324.341432672782, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 80487, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5749.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 228737729, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2841.9214158808254, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1141794103, "stage_ordering_ns": 343723194, "stage_eval_ns": 796878441, "stage_threat_ns": 1925160344, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 202021, "root_tactical_annotations": 586, "search_tactical_annotations": 201435, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 84116, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 448762844, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 194366, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1409067155, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25941, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 782380124, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42051, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 54884923, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 84102, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9395666, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 49555, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 180519153, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 118862, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 445937087, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 33604, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3049756, "child_limit_applications": 12924, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12924, "child_cap_hits": 12924, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12924, "child_moves_before_total": 947344, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 947344, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 207700, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 207700, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.30114515629836, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.070875889817394, "tt_hits": 4317, "tt_cutoffs": 852, "beta_cutoffs": 11085, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6034.357142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6605.785714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1847, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 892, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20504, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 81, 126, 67, 82, 39, 53, 65, 49, 68, 66, 50, 141, 156, 110, 35, 80, 51, 124, 138, 83, 37, 79, 20, 5, 36, 38, 52, 84, 4 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 13647, "avg_search_time_ms": 909.8, "search_nodes": 177856, "safety_nodes": 416, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 178272, "avg_nodes": 11884.8, "eval_calls": 132457, "avg_eval_calls": 8830.466666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 132457, "pattern_eval_ns": 2713856, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.488581199936583, "pattern_frame_queries": 132457, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2713856, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.488581199936583, "pattern_frame_updates": 355578, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3765013766, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10588.432822053108, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41854, "avg_candidate_generations": 2790.266666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 3398624, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.20189229225403, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1084, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 41839, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3397540, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1139455, "avg_legality_checks": 75963.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 262, "root_legality_checks": 1084, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1138371, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 262, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3928268, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 261884.53333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7901727830, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2011.5042634565666, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35341, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2356.0666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 83409138, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2360.1238787810194, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 430, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2011297, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15316, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 54705761, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19595, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26692080, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 111059, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7403.933333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 811223711, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7304.439180975878, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 139002, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9266.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 321333655, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2311.7196515158057, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2579038548, "stage_ordering_ns": 1213024109, "stage_eval_ns": 3767727622, "stage_threat_ns": 6021236153, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 773771, "root_tactical_annotations": 3779, "search_tactical_annotations": 769992, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 355593, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1924099135, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 682516, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3790331190, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 83774, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2526084280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 177789, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 244479462, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 355578, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41294573, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 265398, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 230985353, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 333332, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1033152027, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 175041, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21031793, "child_limit_applications": 41839, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41839, "child_cap_hits": 41839, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41839, "child_moves_before_total": 3397278, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3397278, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 670239, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 670239, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.1988336241306, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.019479433064845, "tt_hits": 19304, "tt_cutoffs": 3493, "beta_cutoffs": 33185, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5683.066666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6216.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 766, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6841, "avg_search_time_ms": 488.64285714285717, "search_nodes": 244755, "safety_nodes": 1418, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 246173, "avg_nodes": 17583.785714285714, "eval_calls": 239964, "avg_eval_calls": 17140.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 239964, "pattern_eval_ns": 4863205, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.266394125785535, "pattern_frame_queries": 239964, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4863205, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.266394125785535, "pattern_frame_updates": 489428, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3807600605, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7779.695082831387, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4764, "avg_candidate_generations": 340.2857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 373138, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.32451721242653, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1033, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 4750, "search_candidate_moves_total": 372105, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 11229, "avg_legality_checks": 802.0714285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11229, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1077897, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 76992.64285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2269383263, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2105.38044265825, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4538, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 324.14285714285717, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33069223, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7287.180035257823, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4538, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33069223, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 27042093, "stage_ordering_ns": 172491, "stage_eval_ns": 3812463810, "stage_threat_ns": 2959350999, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 489442, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2595185187, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 300590, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 244714, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 308500244, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 489428, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55364978, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 184, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4407, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6224.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6796.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1826, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 893, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10172, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 110, 109, 82, 124, 126, 81, 94, 78, 80, 64, 95, 65, 127, 33, 49, 146, 162, 79, 141, 156, 155, 99, 169 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6797, "avg_search_time_ms": 485.5, "search_nodes": 184665, "safety_nodes": 482, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 185147, "avg_nodes": 13224.785714285714, "eval_calls": 178676, "avg_eval_calls": 12762.57142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 178676, "pattern_eval_ns": 3591311, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.09957129105196, "pattern_frame_queries": 178676, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3591311, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.09957129105196, "pattern_frame_updates": 369250, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4112859972, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11138.41563168585, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5963, "avg_candidate_generations": 425.92857142857144, "candidate_moves_total": 470657, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.92956565487171, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1002, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 5949, "search_candidate_moves_total": 469655, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 170646, "avg_legality_checks": 12189.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 189, "root_legality_checks": 1002, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 169644, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 189, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1344422, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 96030.14285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3010096094, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2238.951827625552, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24991, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1785.0714285714287, "renju_forbidden_ns": 127798663, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5113.787483494058, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 222, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 596602, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24755, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 127161021, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 41040, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 233110, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11100.47619047619, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 30, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 121210, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4040.3333333333335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 388999285, "stage_ordering_ns": 215460, "stage_eval_ns": 4116451283, "stage_threat_ns": 2261714438, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 369264, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1974118286, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 325870, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14070, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 184625, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 244913589, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 369250, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42356693, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 628, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5096, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6207.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6778.928571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1823, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3362, "avg_search_time_ms": 258.61538461538464, "search_nodes": 34325, "safety_nodes": 1481, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35806, "avg_nodes": 2754.3076923076924, "eval_calls": 24340, "avg_eval_calls": 1872.3076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 24340, "pattern_eval_ns": 507940, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.868529170090387, "pattern_frame_queries": 24340, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 507940, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.868529170090387, "pattern_frame_updates": 68530, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 728111130, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10624.706405953597, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9520, "avg_candidate_generations": 732.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 726058, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.26659663865546, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 919, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 9507, "search_candidate_moves_total": 725139, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 314416, "avg_legality_checks": 24185.846153846152, "illegal_moves_skipped": 111, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 314416, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1006921, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 77455.46153846153, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2048935588, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2034.8523747146003, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5297, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 407.46153846153845, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19185001, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3621.8616197847837, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 149, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1083193, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1812, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12354835, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3322, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5703293, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 43680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3019.3076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 326635505, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8321.71167613564, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 51947, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3995.923076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 134740920, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2593.8152347585037, "stage_move_gen_ns": 733801653, "stage_ordering_ns": 287721594, "stage_eval_ns": 728619070, "stage_threat_ns": 1585494639, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 164462, "root_tactical_annotations": 381, "search_tactical_annotations": 164081, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 68543, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 410487145, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 157541, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1114368119, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19100, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 659607370, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34265, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 49955237, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 68530, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8306006, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44797, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 147463002, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 93634, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 306884906, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 26031, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2378132, "child_limit_applications": 9507, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9507, "child_cap_hits": 9507, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9507, "child_moves_before_total": 725028, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 725028, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 157133, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 157133, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.26254338908173, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.52813716209109, "tt_hits": 2970, "tt_cutoffs": 418, "beta_cutoffs": 7952, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6172.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6788.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1872, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 894, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 46535, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 82, 110, 126, 81, 128, 144, 141, 156, 99, 127, 140, 158, 172, 157, 159, 146, 162, 145, 143, 160, 154, 168, 139, 142, 175, 174, 132, 115, 100, 147, 148, 190, 206, 188, 202, 116, 102, 101, 138, 137, 80, 64, 170, 186, 191, 207, 131, 187, 189, 73, 87, 117, 118, 133, 85, 71, 122, 106, 40, 70, 72, 78, 92, 184, 185, 200, 125, 155, 124, 123, 109, 94, 169 ], "move_count": 81, "black_stats": { "move_count": 41, "search_move_count": 39, "total_time_ms": 16613, "avg_search_time_ms": 425.97435897435895, "search_nodes": 183209, "safety_nodes": 4973, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 188182, "avg_nodes": 4825.179487179487, "eval_calls": 127853, "avg_eval_calls": 3278.2820512820513, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 127853, "pattern_eval_ns": 2604168, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.368454396846378, "pattern_frame_queries": 127853, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2604168, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.368454396846378, "pattern_frame_updates": 366044, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3615030220, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9875.944476620298, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52017, "avg_candidate_generations": 1333.7692307692307, "candidate_moves_total": 4946004, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.08437626160678, "candidate_moves_max": 138, "root_candidate_generations": 39, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3641, "root_candidate_moves_max": 125, "search_candidate_generations": 51978, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4942363, "search_candidate_moves_max": 138, "legality_checks": 2106849, "avg_legality_checks": 54021.769230769234, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3751, "root_legality_checks": 3641, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 2103208, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3742, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5443410, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 139574.61538461538, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9983990713, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1834.1426997047806, "renju_forbidden_checks": 52991, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1358.7435897435898, "renju_forbidden_ns": 175847608, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3318.44290539903, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4614, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33670572, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15592, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 84657722, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32709, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 57075000, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 76, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 444314, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 177911, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4561.820512820513, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1423374796, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8000.487861908482, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 240063, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6155.461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 656649829, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2735.322931897044, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4236177644, "stage_ordering_ns": 1578658527, "stage_eval_ns": 3617634388, "stage_threat_ns": 7062926084, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1125414, "root_tactical_annotations": 3750, "search_tactical_annotations": 1121664, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 366083, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1865889641, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1056067, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4889167736, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 104220, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2834264290, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 183022, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 250559245, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 366044, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41477457, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 487631, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 583262929, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 464187, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1469317719, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 173596, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15832005, "child_limit_applications": 51978, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 51978, "child_cap_hits": 51978, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 51978, "child_moves_before_total": 4938621, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4938621, "child_moves_before_max": 137, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 137, "child_moves_after_total": 833316, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 833316, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.01367886413483, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.03209049982685, "tt_hits": 20805, "tt_cutoffs": 3191, "beta_cutoffs": 43666, "depth_sum": 187, "avg_depth": 4.794871794871795, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 187, "avg_effective_depth": 4.794871794871795, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 37 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 39, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7200.51282051282, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7405.641025641025, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1283, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 40, "search_move_count": 38, "total_time_ms": 29889, "avg_search_time_ms": 786.5526315789474, "search_nodes": 1130842, "safety_nodes": 2386, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1133228, "avg_nodes": 29821.78947368421, "eval_calls": 1106872, "avg_eval_calls": 29128.21052631579, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 1106872, "pattern_eval_ns": 22261922, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.11246286833527, "pattern_frame_queries": 1106872, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 22261922, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.11246286833527, "pattern_frame_updates": 2261458, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 17121699210, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7571.088744517917, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23895, "avg_candidate_generations": 628.8157894736842, "candidate_moves_total": 2519581, "avg_candidate_moves": 105.44385854781335, "candidate_moves_max": 143, "root_candidate_generations": 38, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3559, "root_candidate_moves_max": 125, "search_candidate_generations": 23857, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2516022, "search_candidate_moves_max": 143, "legality_checks": 58016, "avg_legality_checks": 1526.7368421052631, "illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 58016, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5310811, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 139758.18421052632, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10569045908, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1990.100176413734, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34103, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 897.4473684210526, "renju_forbidden_ns": 192237835, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5636.97724540363, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 331383, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34014, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 191444509, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 461943, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 141723137, "stage_ordering_ns": 850783, "stage_eval_ns": 17143961132, "stage_threat_ns": 12447852012, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 2261496, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 10779420771, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 103, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 317212, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 76, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 39240, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 1130729, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1417476962, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 2261458, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 250637067, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1806, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 21185, "depth_sum": 112, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 112, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 36 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.02631578947368421, "pooled_budget_moves": 38, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.10526315789473684, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.02631578947368421, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6761.6578947368425, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6972.184210526316, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 895, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10336, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 158, 82, 67, 110, 68, 98, 95, 66, 50, 80, 64, 81, 79, 113, 47, 63, 174, 190, 65, 99, 100, 85, 141, 71 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 7038, "avg_search_time_ms": 502.7142857142857, "search_nodes": 183315, "safety_nodes": 482, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 183797, "avg_nodes": 13128.357142857143, "eval_calls": 177472, "avg_eval_calls": 12676.57142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 177472, "pattern_eval_ns": 3569798, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.114711053011177, "pattern_frame_queries": 177472, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3569798, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.114711053011177, "pattern_frame_updates": 366550, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4406376587, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12021.2156240622, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5817, "avg_candidate_generations": 415.5, "candidate_moves_total": 474381, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.55079938112429, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1002, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 5803, "search_candidate_moves_total": 473379, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 169547, "avg_legality_checks": 12110.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 191, "root_legality_checks": 1002, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 168545, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 191, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1460955, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 104353.92857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3271322533, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2239.1672111735134, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33547, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2396.214285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 208085426, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6202.8028139625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 226, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1212876, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33307, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 206831340, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 41210, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 233371, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11112.904761904761, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 30, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 122471, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4082.366666666667, "stage_move_gen_ns": 378352341, "stage_ordering_ns": 218422, "stage_eval_ns": 4409946385, "stage_threat_ns": 2215845890, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 366564, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1935868574, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 324382, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 183275, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 238513976, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 366550, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41138958, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 628, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4972, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6428.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6999.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1870, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3284, "avg_search_time_ms": 252.6153846153846, "search_nodes": 33172, "safety_nodes": 1481, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34653, "avg_nodes": 2665.6153846153848, "eval_calls": 23350, "avg_eval_calls": 1796.1538461538462, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23350, "pattern_eval_ns": 480793, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.59070663811563, "pattern_frame_queries": 23350, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 480793, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.59070663811563, "pattern_frame_updates": 66224, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 703194661, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10618.426265402271, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9320, "avg_candidate_generations": 716.9230769230769, "candidate_moves_total": 708621, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.03229613733906, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 919, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 9307, "search_candidate_moves_total": 707702, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 310822, "avg_legality_checks": 23909.384615384617, "illegal_moves_skipped": 173, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 310822, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 173, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 991189, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 76245.30769230769, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2017662421, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2035.5980756445038, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5059, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 389.15384615384613, "renju_forbidden_ns": 17020133, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3364.3275350859853, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 211, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1438115, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1636, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10372985, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3198, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5166613, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 42420, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39000, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3000.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 327054079, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8386.002025641026, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 51559, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3966.076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 136337633, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2644.3032836168272, "stage_move_gen_ns": 725544131, "stage_ordering_ns": 280237602, "stage_eval_ns": 703675454, "stage_threat_ns": 1548287481, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 162041, "root_tactical_annotations": 381, "search_tactical_annotations": 161660, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 66237, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 395041045, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 154903, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1094762827, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18700, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 643055400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 33112, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 48353784, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 66224, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7987113, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44521, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 149221406, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 91672, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 302086498, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 25848, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2142712, "child_limit_applications": 9307, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9307, "child_cap_hits": 9307, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9307, "child_moves_before_total": 707529, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 707529, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 153978, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 153978, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.02116686365102, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.544321478457075, "tt_hits": 3023, "tt_cutoffs": 455, "beta_cutoffs": 7818, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6167.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6782.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1839, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 896, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19040, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 96, 141, 82, 97, 54, 68, 80, 64, 83, 81, 65, 156, 171, 125, 50, 95, 66, 139, 153, 34, 52, 94, 35, 20, 51, 53, 67, 19, 99 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 12074, "avg_search_time_ms": 804.9333333333333, "search_nodes": 149057, "safety_nodes": 431, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 149488, "avg_nodes": 9965.866666666667, "eval_calls": 105213, "avg_eval_calls": 7014.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105213, "pattern_eval_ns": 2121671, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.165483352817617, "pattern_frame_queries": 105213, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2121671, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.165483352817617, "pattern_frame_updates": 297980, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3212080015, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10779.515454057318, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 40986, "avg_candidate_generations": 2732.4, "candidate_moves_total": 3449666, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.16693505099302, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1109, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 40971, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3448557, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1021840, "avg_legality_checks": 68122.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 346, "root_legality_checks": 1109, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1020731, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 346, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3626784, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 241785.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7086449835, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1953.9211144087985, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27992, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1866.1333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65037595, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2323.435088596742, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 560, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2605833, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11642, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43437490, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15790, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18994272, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93034, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6202.266666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 706120755, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7589.921480319023, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 119497, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7966.466666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 288890043, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2417.5505912282315, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2242695038, "stage_ordering_ns": 1158584856, "stage_eval_ns": 3214201686, "stage_threat_ns": 5399389351, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 741763, "root_tactical_annotations": 3859, "search_tactical_annotations": 737904, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 297995, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1573189336, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 647551, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3578083639, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 82038, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2488100495, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 196571492, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 297980, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33398047, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 259650, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 186829227, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 305851, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 903077396, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 176262, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18146837, "child_limit_applications": 40971, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 40971, "child_cap_hits": 40971, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 40971, "child_moves_before_total": 3448211, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3448211, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 662917, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 662917, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.16223670401016, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.180151814698203, "tt_hits": 19048, "tt_cutoffs": 2806, "beta_cutoffs": 34191, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5583.733333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6117.066666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 712, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6951, "avg_search_time_ms": 496.5, "search_nodes": 241441, "safety_nodes": 1446, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 242887, "avg_nodes": 17349.071428571428, "eval_calls": 236771, "avg_eval_calls": 16912.214285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 236771, "pattern_eval_ns": 4780499, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.190390715079126, "pattern_frame_queries": 236771, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4780499, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.190390715079126, "pattern_frame_updates": 482800, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3916386866, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8111.820352112676, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4643, "avg_candidate_generations": 331.64285714285717, "candidate_moves_total": 375427, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.85871203962955, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1056, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 4629, "search_candidate_moves_total": 374371, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 11126, "avg_legality_checks": 794.7142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11126, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1063081, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 75934.35714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2305914095, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2169.0859821594026, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4554, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 325.2857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 36341134, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7980.046991655688, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4554, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 36341134, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 27375712, "stage_ordering_ns": 146842, "stage_eval_ns": 3921167365, "stage_threat_ns": 2970356216, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 482814, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2608114440, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 290593, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 241400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 306442261, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 482800, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55508922, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 181, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4308, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6214.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6786.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1822, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 897, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14823, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 67, 83, 128, 111, 125, 81, 80, 96, 126, 66, 51, 55, 69, 85, 84, 124, 110, 95, 158, 143, 142, 94, 174 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6494, "avg_search_time_ms": 541.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 170015, "safety_nodes": 814, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 170829, "avg_nodes": 14235.75, "eval_calls": 164466, "avg_eval_calls": 13705.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 164466, "pattern_eval_ns": 3414850, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.763258059416536, "pattern_frame_queries": 164466, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3414850, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.763258059416536, "pattern_frame_updates": 339960, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3887404684, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11434.888469231675, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5526, "avg_candidate_generations": 460.5, "candidate_moves_total": 355461, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.32519001085777, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 724, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 5514, "search_candidate_moves_total": 354737, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 158802, "avg_legality_checks": 13233.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 724, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 158078, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1206676, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 100556.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2832507021, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2347.363352714399, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9621, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 801.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 70792745, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7358.148321380314, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 190734, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9597, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 70602011, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 333803, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9272.305555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.8333333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 146931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3194.1521739130435, "stage_move_gen_ns": 381047717, "stage_ordering_ns": 176021, "stage_eval_ns": 3890819534, "stage_threat_ns": 2197762551, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 339972, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1924012687, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 451063, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12760, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 169980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 231806161, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 339960, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41492640, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 261, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4981, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5232.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5899.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1608, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8316, "avg_search_time_ms": 693.0, "search_nodes": 74450, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 75263, "avg_nodes": 6271.916666666667, "eval_calls": 42726, "avg_eval_calls": 3560.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 42726, "pattern_eval_ns": 917416, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.47207789168188, "pattern_frame_queries": 42726, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 917416, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.47207789168188, "pattern_frame_updates": 148760, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1431926262, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9625.747929550955, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28549, "avg_candidate_generations": 2379.0833333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 1951878, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.36939997898351, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 749, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 28537, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1951129, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 1039911, "avg_legality_checks": 86659.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1039911, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2677496, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 223124.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5306612261, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1981.93097618073, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14036, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1169.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20754211, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1478.6414220575662, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 767516, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2388, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10656080, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11538, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9323415, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7200, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 77284, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6440.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 657052704, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8501.794731121578, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 102833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8569.416666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 272746574, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2652.325362480916, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2294537926, "stage_ordering_ns": 739517880, "stage_eval_ns": 1432843678, "stage_threat_ns": 3795640660, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 400794, "root_tactical_annotations": 901, "search_tactical_annotations": 399893, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 148772, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 851092569, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 345165, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2811078808, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 57167, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1855823052, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104196076, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 148760, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18032861, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 66358, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 225076818, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 221632, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 729958846, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 112804, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11240346, "child_limit_applications": 28537, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28537, "child_cap_hits": 28537, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28537, "child_moves_before_total": 1951033, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1951033, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 262260, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 262260, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.36853908960298, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.190174159862634, "tt_hits": 14385, "tt_cutoffs": 3117, "beta_cutoffs": 23000, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 5.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 5.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4509.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5176.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 898, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24160, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 53, 95, 111, 125, 69, 55, 68, 155, 169, 110, 140, 80, 65, 66, 38, 23, 37, 94, 108, 21, 39, 25, 36, 40, 35 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 21422, "avg_search_time_ms": 1190.111111111111, "search_nodes": 231813, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 232610, "avg_nodes": 12922.777777777777, "eval_calls": 149483, "avg_eval_calls": 8304.611111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 149483, "pattern_eval_ns": 3064037, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.49756159563295, "pattern_frame_queries": 149483, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3064037, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.49756159563295, "pattern_frame_updates": 463418, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5436850216, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11732.06525426289, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 76325, "avg_candidate_generations": 4240.277777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 6517279, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.38852276449394, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 76307, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6515977, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1625370, "avg_legality_checks": 90298.33333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1850, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1624068, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1850, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6225069, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 345837.1666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12377364304, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1988.309576006306, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55741, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3096.722222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 281544495, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5050.940869378016, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3228, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23848637, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26568, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 179236885, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25931, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 78352622, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 106351, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 178384, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9910.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1358229271, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7614.075651403713, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 233822, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12990.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 545658495, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2333.649079214103, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3657657132, "stage_ordering_ns": 2339828200, "stage_eval_ns": 5439914253, "stage_threat_ns": 9907918600, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1633722, "root_tactical_annotations": 4128, "search_tactical_annotations": 1629594, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 463436, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2540341101, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1225134, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6908924947, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 152753, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4750359059, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 231709, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 332462910, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 463418, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 54681543, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 473031, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 437924991, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 599337, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1720193516, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 561354, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 71508099, "child_limit_applications": 76307, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 76307, "child_cap_hits": 76307, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 76307, "child_moves_before_total": 6514127, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6514127, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 914885, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 914885, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.36735817159631, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.989529138873236, "tt_hits": 47171, "tt_cutoffs": 5919, "beta_cutoffs": 62841, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4814.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5258.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1121, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 2719, "avg_search_time_ms": 159.94117647058823, "search_nodes": 84204, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 86095, "avg_nodes": 5064.411764705882, "eval_calls": 81401, "avg_eval_calls": 4788.294117647059, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 81401, "pattern_eval_ns": 1637298, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.113978943747618, "pattern_frame_queries": 81401, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1637298, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.113978943747618, "pattern_frame_updates": 168308, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1627742137, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9671.210738645816, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2770, "avg_candidate_generations": 162.94117647058823, "candidate_moves_total": 217538, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.53357400722021, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1235, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2753, "search_candidate_moves_total": 216303, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5313, "avg_legality_checks": 312.52941176470586, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5313, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 520187, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 30599.235294117647, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1086359905, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2088.4026417422965, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4285, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 252.05882352941177, "renju_forbidden_ns": 27430285, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6401.46674445741, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 48710, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4265, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27267384, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 114191, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13828085, "stage_ordering_ns": 84530, "stage_eval_ns": 1629379435, "stage_threat_ns": 1050617022, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 168325, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 918844396, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 446934, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84154, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 111790937, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 168308, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19534755, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2573, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6734.764705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7205.35294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 899, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18664, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 81, 142, 156, 129, 126, 130, 131, 100, 86, 141, 140, 98, 109, 110, 154, 168, 146, 66, 82, 101, 97, 99, 102, 84, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3735, "avg_search_time_ms": 266.7857142857143, "search_nodes": 102431, "safety_nodes": 1339, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 103770, "avg_nodes": 7412.142857142857, "eval_calls": 98621, "avg_eval_calls": 7044.357142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 98621, "pattern_eval_ns": 1915031, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.418085397633366, "pattern_frame_queries": 98621, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1915031, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.418085397633366, "pattern_frame_updates": 204780, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2357747780, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11513.564703584334, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3783, "avg_candidate_generations": 270.2142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 295710, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.16812053925456, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1043, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 3769, "search_candidate_moves_total": 294667, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 95522, "avg_legality_checks": 6823.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 104, "root_legality_checks": 1043, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 94479, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 847060, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 60504.28571428572, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1713321844, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2022.6688121266498, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13025, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 930.3571428571429, "renju_forbidden_ns": 78287114, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6010.5269865642995, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 118, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 843023, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12831, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 76980190, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 76, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 463901, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.857142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 534541, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7860.89705882353, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 260041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3023.732558139535, "stage_move_gen_ns": 205920840, "stage_ordering_ns": 118230, "stage_eval_ns": 2359662811, "stage_threat_ns": 1146246875, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 204794, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 999435084, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 720833, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 124159027, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 204780, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21931931, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 180, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3436, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6265.928571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6837.357142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1877, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 14917, "avg_search_time_ms": 1065.5, "search_nodes": 119316, "safety_nodes": 886, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 120202, "avg_nodes": 8585.857142857143, "eval_calls": 73690, "avg_eval_calls": 5263.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73690, "pattern_eval_ns": 1498726, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.338254851404532, "pattern_frame_queries": 73690, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1498726, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.338254851404532, "pattern_frame_updates": 238476, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2452194056, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10282.770828091716, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41484, "avg_candidate_generations": 2963.1428571428573, "candidate_moves_total": 3584185, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.39921415485489, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1091, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 41470, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3583094, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 2258093, "avg_legality_checks": 161292.35714285713, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17071, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2258093, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17071, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5257936, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 375566.85714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9516398693, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1809.9114734374857, "renju_forbidden_checks": 112556, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8039.714285714285, "renju_forbidden_ns": 354119028, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3146.158605494154, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21610, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 138341555, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22536, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 100145345, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 68234, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 114929325, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 176, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 702803, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 196213, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14015.214285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1685965009, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8592.524496338163, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 262130, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18723.571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 816983656, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3116.711768969595, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4755885357, "stage_ordering_ns": 1227257277, "stage_eval_ns": 2453692782, "stage_threat_ns": 6388344263, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 895489, "root_tactical_annotations": 2295, "search_tactical_annotations": 893194, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 238490, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1296299565, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 724254, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4866624783, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 83045, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2641433961, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 119238, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 164277497, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 238476, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28026038, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 228368, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 847711167, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 412830, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1377138194, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 254291, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33116380, "child_limit_applications": 41470, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41470, "child_cap_hits": 41470, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41470, "child_moves_before_total": 3566023, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3566023, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 502473, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 502473, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.99042681456474, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.116542078611044, "tt_hits": 22597, "tt_cutoffs": 4078, "beta_cutoffs": 34447, "depth_sum": 78, "avg_depth": 5.571428571428571, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 78, "avg_effective_depth": 5.571428571428571, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4415.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4986.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 467, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 900, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25859, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 110, 109, 142, 94, 96, 141, 124, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 125, 86, 72, 83, 85, 81, 80, 95, 123, 122, 108, 67, 53, 92, 138, 152, 93, 153, 78 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 24514, "avg_search_time_ms": 1361.888888888889, "search_nodes": 251661, "safety_nodes": 811, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 252472, "avg_nodes": 14026.222222222223, "eval_calls": 165794, "avg_eval_calls": 9210.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 165794, "pattern_eval_ns": 3427050, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.670530899791306, "pattern_frame_queries": 165794, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3427050, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.670530899791306, "pattern_frame_updates": 503114, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6432222825, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12784.821779954444, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 79531, "avg_candidate_generations": 4418.388888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 7179434, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.27214545271656, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1337, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 79513, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7178097, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1922674, "avg_legality_checks": 106815.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2238, "root_legality_checks": 1337, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1921337, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2238, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7086795, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 393710.8333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14234407670, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2008.5818300091933, "renju_forbidden_checks": 67545, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3752.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 346076511, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5123.643659782368, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3711, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 31377604, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 31216, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 217211950, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32604, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 97356307, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 130650, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 211847, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11769.277777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1623272233, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7662.474488663988, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 274057, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15225.388888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 631794141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2305.3384551388945, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4319909822, "stage_ordering_ns": 2644681827, "stage_eval_ns": 6435649875, "stage_threat_ns": 11034948554, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1767368, "root_tactical_annotations": 4207, "search_tactical_annotations": 1763161, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 503132, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2816296773, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1370167, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7717485322, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 159165, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5150984410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 251557, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 365248723, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 503114, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61598104, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 542383, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 508045808, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 668606, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2057998611, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 556379, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 74319632, "child_limit_applications": 79513, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 79513, "child_cap_hits": 79513, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 79513, "child_moves_before_total": 7175859, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7175859, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 950410, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 950410, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.24761988605637, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.952888206959868, "tt_hits": 47914, "tt_cutoffs": 6250, "beta_cutoffs": 64604, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3888888888888889, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3864.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4308.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 486, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 1325, "avg_search_time_ms": 77.94117647058823, "search_nodes": 42782, "safety_nodes": 1927, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 44709, "avg_nodes": 2629.9411764705883, "eval_calls": 40302, "avg_eval_calls": 2370.705882352941, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40302, "pattern_eval_ns": 847523, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.029303756637386, "pattern_frame_queries": 40302, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 847523, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.029303756637386, "pattern_frame_updates": 85464, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 751350818, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8791.430520453056, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2447, "avg_candidate_generations": 143.94117647058823, "candidate_moves_total": 194805, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.60972619534124, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1261, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 2430, "search_candidate_moves_total": 193544, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 5529, "avg_legality_checks": 325.2352941176471, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5529, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 229012, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13471.29411764706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 502192384, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2192.864932841947, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1419, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 83.47058823529412, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8850069, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6236.8350951374205, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 32730, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1401, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8692019, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 125320, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14136349, "stage_ordering_ns": 176520, "stage_eval_ns": 752198341, "stage_threat_ns": 536748911, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 85481, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 470353264, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 460431, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42732, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 56187275, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 85464, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9747941, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2257, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6758.705882352941, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7229.294117647059, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 901, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12204, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 109, 95, 98, 127, 143, 125, 140, 126, 128, 79, 63, 65, 80, 124, 123, 158, 142, 113, 114, 141, 156, 100, 170 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 4651, "avg_search_time_ms": 387.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 124321, "safety_nodes": 892, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 125213, "avg_nodes": 10434.416666666666, "eval_calls": 119474, "avg_eval_calls": 9956.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 119474, "pattern_eval_ns": 2506966, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.98336039640424, "pattern_frame_queries": 119474, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2506966, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.98336039640424, "pattern_frame_updates": 248572, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2712078541, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10910.635715205253, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4824, "avg_candidate_generations": 402.0, "candidate_moves_total": 317188, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.75207296849088, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 4812, "search_candidate_moves_total": 316466, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 115328, "avg_legality_checks": 9610.666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 114606, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 809811, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 67484.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1930753581, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2384.202710262024, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8471, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 705.9166666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50043878, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5907.670641010506, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 134411, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8454, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 49909467, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.083333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 469054, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9572.530612244898, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 221683, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3358.8333333333335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 283364818, "stage_ordering_ns": 158261, "stage_eval_ns": 2714585507, "stage_threat_ns": 1630298269, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 248584, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1426694119, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 643844, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124286, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 172496779, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 248572, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30463527, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 265, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4276, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5786.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6453.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1884, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7541, "avg_search_time_ms": 628.4166666666666, "search_nodes": 61520, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 62559, "avg_nodes": 5213.25, "eval_calls": 35912, "avg_eval_calls": 2992.6666666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35912, "pattern_eval_ns": 795343, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.146998217865896, "pattern_frame_queries": 35912, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 795343, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.146998217865896, "pattern_frame_updates": 122908, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1345648245, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10948.418695284277, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23438, "avg_candidate_generations": 1953.1666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1586729, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.69899308814745, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 744, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 23426, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1585985, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 797548, "avg_legality_checks": 66462.33333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 68, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 797548, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 68, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2169042, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 180753.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4783613197, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2205.4036745254357, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11030, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 919.1666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20130245, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1825.0448776065277, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 679845, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2200, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11672089, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8758, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7778311, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64801, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5400.083333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 586907487, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9057.074535886792, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 85842, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7153.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 241629757, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2814.8197502388107, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1964982334, "stage_ordering_ns": 674208139, "stage_eval_ns": 1346443588, "stage_threat_ns": 3514420374, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 314791, "root_tactical_annotations": 456, "search_tactical_annotations": 314335, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 122920, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 784195767, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 284267, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2608851668, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46941, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1737039175, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61454, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96974348, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 122908, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16345642, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 40874, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 165597355, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 196445, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 705972504, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 77472, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8052949, "child_limit_applications": 23426, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23426, "child_cap_hits": 23426, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23426, "child_moves_before_total": 1585917, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1585917, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 216062, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 216062, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.69900964740033, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.223170835823444, "tt_hits": 10218, "tt_cutoffs": 2117, "beta_cutoffs": 18719, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4451.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5118.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 902, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23903, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 129, 109, 108, 81, 123, 125, 80, 93, 141, 127, 143, 79, 63, 94, 145, 161, 142, 144, 140, 139, 124, 92, 91, 107, 156, 172, 121, 77, 61, 122, 62, 137 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 21212, "avg_search_time_ms": 1178.4444444444443, "search_nodes": 221333, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 222130, "avg_nodes": 12340.555555555555, "eval_calls": 140290, "avg_eval_calls": 7793.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 140290, "pattern_eval_ns": 2906655, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.71890369947965, "pattern_frame_queries": 140290, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2906655, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.71890369947965, "pattern_frame_updates": 442458, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5180761513, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11709.04698977078, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 74920, "avg_candidate_generations": 4162.222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 6412497, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.59125734116391, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 74902, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6411195, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1627205, "avg_legality_checks": 90400.27777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1552, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1625903, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1552, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6048102, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 336005.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12203760108, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2017.7834480966094, "renju_forbidden_checks": 49573, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2754.0555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 258601417, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5216.5779153974945, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2779, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22874341, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23078, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 159860251, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23702, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 75753274, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 113551, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 173605, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9644.722222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1345927877, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7752.8174706949685, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 225570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12531.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 536432633, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2378.1204637141464, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3728257267, "stage_ordering_ns": 2383310646, "stage_eval_ns": 5183668168, "stage_threat_ns": 9843463010, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1615693, "root_tactical_annotations": 4128, "search_tactical_annotations": 1611565, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 442476, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2482912658, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1211209, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6907558124, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 149943, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4728403011, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 221229, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 319109547, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 442458, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63382010, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 461975, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 432997984, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 599278, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1745707656, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 554440, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 70500671, "child_limit_applications": 74902, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 74902, "child_cap_hits": 74902, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 74902, "child_moves_before_total": 6409643, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6409643, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 900259, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 900259, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.57372299805078, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.019158366932793, "tt_hits": 46479, "tt_cutoffs": 6037, "beta_cutoffs": 61843, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4935.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5379.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1175, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 2672, "avg_search_time_ms": 157.1764705882353, "search_nodes": 83574, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85465, "avg_nodes": 5027.35294117647, "eval_calls": 80904, "avg_eval_calls": 4759.058823529412, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80904, "pattern_eval_ns": 1638417, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.251371996440227, "pattern_frame_queries": 80904, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1638417, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.251371996440227, "pattern_frame_updates": 167048, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1574173051, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9423.477389732292, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2637, "avg_candidate_generations": 155.11764705882354, "candidate_moves_total": 209213, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.33750474023512, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1235, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2620, "search_candidate_moves_total": 207978, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5654, "avg_legality_checks": 332.5882352941176, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5654, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 486464, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 28615.529411764706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1014671382, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2085.8098070977503, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4192, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 246.58823529411765, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29483952, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7033.385496183206, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 69251, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4169, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29296840, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 117861, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14863876, "stage_ordering_ns": 79340, "stage_eval_ns": 1575811468, "stage_threat_ns": 1054491701, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 167065, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 923395037, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 461241, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17960, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 83524, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 110721264, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 167048, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19914159, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2451, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6760.235294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7230.823529411765, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 903, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22687, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 95, 141, 96, 159, 175, 144, 142, 156, 93, 171, 126, 94, 100, 86, 80, 64, 110, 125, 68, 186, 201, 124, 116, 115, 84, 52, 132 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 12298, "avg_search_time_ms": 768.625, "search_nodes": 303887, "safety_nodes": 590, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 304477, "avg_nodes": 19029.8125, "eval_calls": 294779, "avg_eval_calls": 18423.6875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 294779, "pattern_eval_ns": 6234612, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.15012263424464, "pattern_frame_queries": 294779, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6234612, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.15012263424464, "pattern_frame_updates": 607682, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7615327670, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12531.764426130772, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9078, "avg_candidate_generations": 567.375, "candidate_moves_total": 818159, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.12546816479401, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1280, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 9062, "search_candidate_moves_total": 816879, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 282850, "avg_legality_checks": 17678.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "root_legality_checks": 1280, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 281570, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2261522, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 141345.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5493837593, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2429.2655976815613, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29993, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1874.5625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 224799355, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7495.060680825526, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 111, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 870494, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29882, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 223928861, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.1875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 200910, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10574.21052631579, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 94490, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3634.230769230769, "stage_move_gen_ns": 705255453, "stage_ordering_ns": 335601, "stage_eval_ns": 7621562282, "stage_threat_ns": 3926396550, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 607698, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3432804683, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 286130, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17130, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 303841, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 418921838, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 607682, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74383899, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 815, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7963, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6195.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6695.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1787, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 10370, "avg_search_time_ms": 691.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 82437, "safety_nodes": 1782, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 84219, "avg_nodes": 5614.6, "eval_calls": 49521, "avg_eval_calls": 3301.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49521, "pattern_eval_ns": 1085256, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.915066335494032, "pattern_frame_queries": 49521, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1085256, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.915066335494032, "pattern_frame_updates": 164694, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1692483923, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10276.536625499411, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29335, "avg_candidate_generations": 1955.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 2389261, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.44745184932674, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1199, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 29320, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2388062, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 1230502, "avg_legality_checks": 82033.46666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 315, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1230502, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 315, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3010484, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 200698.93333333332, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6550418774, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2175.868987843815, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16004, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1066.9333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37448522, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2339.9476380904775, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 500, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3620982, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3542, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19264579, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11962, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14562961, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98038, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6535.866666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 887796288, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9055.6344274669, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8804.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 373649922, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2829.1594823996184, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3005683438, "stage_ordering_ns": 1022272601, "stage_eval_ns": 1693569179, "stage_threat_ns": 4585207151, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 442107, "root_tactical_annotations": 917, "search_tactical_annotations": 441190, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 164709, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1017660419, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 399134, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3410172822, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58760, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2126952175, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 82347, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 124761904, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 164694, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21614198, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71111, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 292546397, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 269252, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 990318467, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 101744, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10997808, "child_limit_applications": 29320, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29320, "child_cap_hits": 29320, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29320, "child_moves_before_total": 2387747, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2387747, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 297955, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 297955, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.43748294679399, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.162175989085949, "tt_hits": 13830, "tt_cutoffs": 3507, "beta_cutoffs": 23434, "depth_sum": 89, "avg_depth": 5.933333333333334, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 89, "avg_effective_depth": 5.933333333333334, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5223.733333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5757.066666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 443, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 904, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8551, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 95, 99, 96, 129, 79, 63, 94, 97, 81, 144, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7386, "avg_search_time_ms": 923.25, "search_nodes": 67335, "safety_nodes": 342, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67677, "avg_nodes": 8459.625, "eval_calls": 40795, "avg_eval_calls": 5099.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40795, "pattern_eval_ns": 885392, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.703444049515873, "pattern_frame_queries": 40795, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 885392, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.703444049515873, "pattern_frame_updates": 134582, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1515068657, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11257.587619443908, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24867, "avg_candidate_generations": 3108.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1855398, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.61286041742068, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 468, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 24859, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1854930, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 597332, "avg_legality_checks": 74666.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 603, "root_legality_checks": 468, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 596864, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 603, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1923488, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 240436.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4464431965, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2321.0084830266683, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14537, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1817.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66607374, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4581.920203618353, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 654, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7011774, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4429, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37683581, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9452, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21908769, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44585, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5573.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 404718164, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9077.451250420545, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 61848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7731.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 165044738, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2668.5541650497994, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1537207299, "stage_ordering_ns": 811293067, "stage_eval_ns": 1515954049, "stage_threat_ns": 3488164014, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 248399, "root_tactical_annotations": 1321, "search_tactical_annotations": 247078, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 134590, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 826187780, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 217261, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2530588400, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49777, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1930353324, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67291, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 103975075, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 134582, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17245403, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 36788, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 67297423, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 130691, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 532803773, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 80920, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10167356, "child_limit_applications": 24859, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24859, "child_cap_hits": 24859, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24859, "child_moves_before_total": 1854327, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1854327, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 213756, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 213756, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.59378896978961, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.59873687598053, "tt_hits": 13217, "tt_cutoffs": 1637, "beta_cutoffs": 19570, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2334.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3334.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 670, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1161, "avg_search_time_ms": 165.85714285714286, "search_nodes": 38407, "safety_nodes": 526, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 38933, "avg_nodes": 5561.857142857143, "eval_calls": 36196, "avg_eval_calls": 5170.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36196, "pattern_eval_ns": 771333, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.309896121118356, "pattern_frame_queries": 36196, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 771333, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.309896121118356, "pattern_frame_updates": 76774, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 616484353, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8029.85845468518, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2198, "avg_candidate_generations": 314.0, "candidate_moves_total": 147949, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.31073703366697, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 407, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 2191, "search_candidate_moves_total": 147542, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 4717, "avg_legality_checks": 673.8571428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4717, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 140059, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20008.428571428572, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 341569588, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2438.755010388479, "renju_forbidden_checks": 832, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 118.85714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8027888, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9648.903846153846, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 832, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8027888, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13877067, "stage_ordering_ns": 73440, "stage_eval_ns": 617255686, "stage_threat_ns": 515954092, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 76781, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 452751743, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 243391, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38387, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 53423200, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 76774, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9535758, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 122, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1961, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4855.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5998.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 905, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 38860, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 83, 95, 98, 139, 153, 140, 110, 94, 53, 93, 96, 68, 158, 174, 84, 70, 157, 172, 82, 81, 66, 50, 156, 155, 114, 130, 69, 91, 92, 123, 107, 109, 137, 67 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 23310, "avg_search_time_ms": 1226.842105263158, "search_nodes": 576548, "safety_nodes": 694, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 577242, "avg_nodes": 30381.157894736843, "eval_calls": 563692, "avg_eval_calls": 29668.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 563692, "pattern_eval_ns": 12024610, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.3318798208951, "pattern_frame_queries": 563692, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 12024610, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.3318798208951, "pattern_frame_updates": 1152984, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 14410135648, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12498.122825641987, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12819, "avg_candidate_generations": 674.6842105263158, "candidate_moves_total": 1167760, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.09602933146111, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1584, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 12800, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1166176, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 540676, "avg_legality_checks": 28456.63157894737, "illegal_moves_skipped": 267, "root_legality_checks": 1584, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 539092, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 267, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4262029, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 224317.31578947368, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10344618263, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2427.158112485861, "renju_forbidden_checks": 59371, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3124.7894736842104, "renju_forbidden_ns": 504261795, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8493.402418689258, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 513, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3384053, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 58858, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 500877742, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 197562, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10398.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.368421052631579, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 92831, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3570.423076923077, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1330903843, "stage_ordering_ns": 496044, "stage_eval_ns": 14422160258, "stage_threat_ns": 7489374579, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1153003, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6551264555, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 292302, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 576492, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 795703363, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1152984, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 142114359, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 940, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 11377, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21052631578947367, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5453.263157894737, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5874.315789473684, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 570, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 15527, "avg_search_time_ms": 817.2105263157895, "search_nodes": 120676, "safety_nodes": 2503, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 123179, "avg_nodes": 6483.105263157895, "eval_calls": 72041, "avg_eval_calls": 3791.6315789473683, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72041, "pattern_eval_ns": 1613853, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.401868380505544, "pattern_frame_queries": 72041, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1613853, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.401868380505544, "pattern_frame_updates": 241124, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2438841125, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10114.468592923144, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41704, "avg_candidate_generations": 2194.9473684210525, "candidate_moves_total": 3738449, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.64245635910224, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1610, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 41685, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3736839, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 2071736, "avg_legality_checks": 109038.73684210527, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2374, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2071736, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2374, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4614191, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 242852.15789473685, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9772547926, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2117.9331167695486, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55485, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2920.2631578947367, "renju_forbidden_ns": 140762433, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2536.945715058124, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6774, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 35247618, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11240, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 48624081, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37447, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 56835464, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55270, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 154471, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8130.0526315789475, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1340864051, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8680.361045115264, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 203685, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10720.263157894737, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 550491064, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2702.6588310381226, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4912802585, "stage_ordering_ns": 1470286052, "stage_eval_ns": 2440454978, "stage_threat_ns": 6608678979, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 859174, "root_tactical_annotations": 1003, "search_tactical_annotations": 858171, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 241143, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1478004387, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 740084, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4890176629, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 83521, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2837986562, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 120562, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 185023452, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 241124, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31305741, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 168860, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 470124913, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 487689, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1581567410, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 202625, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24168770, "child_limit_applications": 41685, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41685, "child_cap_hits": 41685, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41685, "child_moves_before_total": 3734465, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3734465, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 494749, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 494749, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.58774139378673, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.868753748350725, "tt_hits": 22260, "tt_cutoffs": 6837, "beta_cutoffs": 34386, "depth_sum": 113, "avg_depth": 5.947368421052632, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 113, "avg_effective_depth": 5.947368421052632, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15789473684210525, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5810.789473684211, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6231.8421052631575, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 489, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 906, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18538, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 125, 83, 113, 96, 99, 141, 126, 94, 98, 69, 55, 84, 140, 154, 95, 80, 124, 123, 172, 157, 156, 108, 188 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 16767, "avg_search_time_ms": 1289.7692307692307, "search_nodes": 155879, "safety_nodes": 393, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 156272, "avg_nodes": 12020.923076923076, "eval_calls": 98468, "avg_eval_calls": 7574.461538461538, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 98468, "pattern_eval_ns": 2147887, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.813045862615265, "pattern_frame_queries": 98468, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2147887, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.813045862615265, "pattern_frame_updates": 311628, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3740738818, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12003.859787952302, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 53955, "avg_candidate_generations": 4150.384615384615, "candidate_moves_total": 4302944, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.75060698730424, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 885, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 53942, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4302059, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1322375, "avg_legality_checks": 101721.15384615384, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1298, "root_legality_checks": 885, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1321490, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1298, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4429433, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 340725.6153846154, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9979976392, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2253.1047183691458, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38980, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2998.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_ns": 137922636, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3538.292355053874, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1551, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11433965, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17291, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 86310289, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20138, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40178382, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 120124, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9240.307692307691, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1035748477, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8622.327569844494, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 157771, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12136.23076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 400869816, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2540.8333343897166, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3341912110, "stage_ordering_ns": 1831315601, "stage_eval_ns": 3742886705, "stage_threat_ns": 7787569834, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 791423, "root_tactical_annotations": 2745, "search_tactical_annotations": 788678, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 311641, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1905169888, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 642618, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5569269637, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 107974, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3971870979, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 155814, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 238407347, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 311628, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40659737, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 157485, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 231616742, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 377148, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1365605325, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 256790, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 34063225, "child_limit_applications": 53942, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 53942, "child_cap_hits": 53942, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 53942, "child_moves_before_total": 4300761, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4300761, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 500872, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 500872, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.72935745801045, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.285380593971302, "tt_hits": 28194, "tt_cutoffs": 3406, "beta_cutoffs": 42994, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.769230769230769, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.769230769230769, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2173.230769230769, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2788.6153846153848, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 1759, "avg_search_time_ms": 146.58333333333334, "search_nodes": 57852, "safety_nodes": 956, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 58808, "avg_nodes": 4900.666666666667, "eval_calls": 54559, "avg_eval_calls": 4546.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 54559, "pattern_eval_ns": 1170824, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.459777488590333, "pattern_frame_queries": 54559, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1170824, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.459777488590333, "pattern_frame_updates": 115634, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 943475372, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8159.15191033779, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3270, "avg_candidate_generations": 272.5, "candidate_moves_total": 230196, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.39633027522936, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 812, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 3258, "search_candidate_moves_total": 229384, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 8222, "avg_legality_checks": 685.1666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8222, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 225632, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18802.666666666668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 546825440, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2423.5278683874626, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1479, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 123.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12158302, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8220.62339418526, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1479, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12158302, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23581897, "stage_ordering_ns": 110770, "stage_eval_ns": 944646196, "stage_threat_ns": 770294202, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 115646, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 676692582, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 241361, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13290, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57817, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 78995569, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 115634, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14364690, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 182, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2932, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6170.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6836.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 907, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24292, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 80, 129, 81, 145, 161, 128, 125, 95, 79, 78, 83, 82, 109, 108, 64, 94, 93, 96, 98, 127, 130, 141, 155, 99, 85, 142, 61, 77, 51, 144, 143, 114, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 12071, "avg_search_time_ms": 670.6111111111111, "search_nodes": 342157, "safety_nodes": 1093, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 343250, "avg_nodes": 19069.444444444445, "eval_calls": 332184, "avg_eval_calls": 18454.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 332184, "pattern_eval_ns": 6828100, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.555174240782218, "pattern_frame_queries": 332184, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6828100, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.555174240782218, "pattern_frame_updates": 684208, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7555890606, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11043.265506980333, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9938, "avg_candidate_generations": 552.1111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 845702, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.097806399678, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1389, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 9920, "search_candidate_moves_total": 844313, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 315206, "avg_legality_checks": 17511.444444444445, "illegal_moves_skipped": 145, "root_legality_checks": 1389, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 313817, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 145, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2801303, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 155627.94444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5601072626, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1999.4526211552268, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26078, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1448.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 140790872, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5398.8370273794, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 157, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1085325, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25919, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 139703347, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2200, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 210612, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7800.444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.9444444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 102461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2927.457142857143, "stage_move_gen_ns": 673175428, "stage_ordering_ns": 348892, "stage_eval_ns": 7562718706, "stage_threat_ns": 3793126880, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 684226, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3299480987, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 48, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 325713, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14030, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 342104, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 420089613, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 684208, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 73230567, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 580, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8768, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6332.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6776.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1793, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 12203, "avg_search_time_ms": 677.9444444444445, "search_nodes": 123673, "safety_nodes": 1764, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 125437, "avg_nodes": 6968.722222222223, "eval_calls": 74617, "avg_eval_calls": 4145.388888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74617, "pattern_eval_ns": 1521537, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.391291528740098, "pattern_frame_queries": 74617, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1521537, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.391291528740098, "pattern_frame_updates": 247122, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2093773976, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8472.632853408439, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44211, "avg_candidate_generations": 2456.1666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 3801042, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.97502883897673, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1428, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 44193, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3799614, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 2513541, "avg_legality_checks": 139641.16666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3558, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2513541, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3558, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5374931, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 298607.27777777775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7853905576, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1461.2104929347, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32320, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1795.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 122586601, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3792.9022586633664, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3645, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25379815, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10234, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 67664621, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18441, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29542165, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 161169, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8953.833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1038632857, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6444.3711693936175, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 213049, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11836.055555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 481537673, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2260.220292045492, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4030487720, "stage_ordering_ns": 1044170516, "stage_eval_ns": 2095295513, "stage_threat_ns": 4932225558, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 922391, "root_tactical_annotations": 2755, "search_tactical_annotations": 919636, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 247140, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1101459251, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 723195, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3631255588, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 88533, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2164955491, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123561, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 145961760, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 247122, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24127562, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 239986, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 440269847, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 394662, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1025754370, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 287743, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 29421397, "child_limit_applications": 44193, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44193, "child_cap_hits": 44193, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44193, "child_moves_before_total": 3796056, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3796056, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 440843, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 440843, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.89722354218993, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.975403344421062, "tt_hits": 26411, "tt_cutoffs": 4751, "beta_cutoffs": 35513, "depth_sum": 112, "avg_depth": 6.222222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 112, "avg_effective_depth": 6.222222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5553.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5998.277777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1507, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 908, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7583, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 81, 129, 127, 98, 95, 143, 109, 108, 67, 53, 123 ], "move_count": 17, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 4796, "avg_search_time_ms": 685.1428571428571, "search_nodes": 76291, "safety_nodes": 319, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76610, "avg_nodes": 10944.285714285714, "eval_calls": 48139, "avg_eval_calls": 6877.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48139, "pattern_eval_ns": 924596, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.206796983734602, "pattern_frame_queries": 48139, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 924596, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.206796983734602, "pattern_frame_updates": 152516, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1100620404, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7216.425843845892, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26481, "avg_candidate_generations": 3783.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1921374, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.55670103092784, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 395, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 26474, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1920979, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 664124, "avg_legality_checks": 94874.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1277, "root_legality_checks": 395, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 663729, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1277, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2156545, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 308077.85714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2821831998, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1308.4966916989908, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17132, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2447.4285714285716, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60513628, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3532.1986925052533, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7425658, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6983, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37870212, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8812, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15215348, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2410, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49782, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7111.714285714285, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 267747885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5378.407556948295, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66593, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9513.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 117586521, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1765.7489676092082, "stage_move_gen_ns": 974165985, "stage_ordering_ns": 480032048, "stage_eval_ns": 1101545000, "stage_threat_ns": 2203459529, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 249776, "root_tactical_annotations": 1321, "search_tactical_annotations": 248455, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152523, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 540923421, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 224019, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1568833610, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52994, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1178081494, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76258, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74425084, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152516, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12365701, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 34370, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 27507701, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 136649, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 363095795, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78757, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6911713, "child_limit_applications": 26474, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26474, "child_cap_hits": 26474, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26474, "child_moves_before_total": 1919702, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1919702, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 231642, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 231642, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.5127294704238, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.749792248999018, "tt_hits": 13642, "tt_cutoffs": 1645, "beta_cutoffs": 20281, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3214.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4357.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1745, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 2781, "avg_search_time_ms": 463.5, "search_nodes": 142815, "safety_nodes": 317, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 143132, "avg_nodes": 23855.333333333332, "eval_calls": 139429, "avg_eval_calls": 23238.166666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 139429, "pattern_eval_ns": 2664887, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.112860308831017, "pattern_frame_queries": 139429, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2664887, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.112860308831017, "pattern_frame_updates": 285596, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1590728626, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5569.856111430132, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3375, "avg_candidate_generations": 562.5, "candidate_moves_total": 220115, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.21925925925926, "candidate_moves_max": 82, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 330, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 3369, "search_candidate_moves_total": 219785, "search_candidate_moves_max": 82, "legality_checks": 5514, "avg_legality_checks": 919.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5514, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 590233, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 98372.16666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 829063115, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1404.6370077579531, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6316, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1052.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 35734706, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5657.806523115896, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6316, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35734706, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10337409, "stage_ordering_ns": 100260, "stage_eval_ns": 1593393513, "stage_threat_ns": 1151537670, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 285602, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 999075490, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 59530, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 12, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3440, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 142798, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 128210719, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 285596, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24191931, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 110, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3025, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3573.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4906.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1990, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 909, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20076, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 84, 141, 99, 155, 169, 126, 81, 83, 69, 54, 129, 114, 67, 52, 70, 68, 53, 98, 128, 111, 156, 95, 79, 143, 159, 142, 25, 39, 144, 140, 139, 110, 125, 94, 78, 158 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 3843, "avg_search_time_ms": 202.26315789473685, "search_nodes": 110492, "safety_nodes": 1541, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 112033, "avg_nodes": 5896.473684210527, "eval_calls": 105137, "avg_eval_calls": 5533.526315789473, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105137, "pattern_eval_ns": 2210813, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.027925468674205, "pattern_frame_queries": 105137, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2210813, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.027925468674205, "pattern_frame_updates": 220872, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2363115806, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10699.028423702415, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5318, "avg_candidate_generations": 279.89473684210526, "candidate_moves_total": 445555, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.78243700639338, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1467, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 5299, "search_candidate_moves_total": 444088, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 97188, "avg_legality_checks": 5115.1578947368425, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "root_legality_checks": 1467, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 95721, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 872211, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 45905.84210526316, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1799584825, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2063.2448169078352, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10333, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 543.8421052631579, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51601751, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4993.878931578438, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 93740, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10316, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 51504591, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3420, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.263157894736842, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 339773, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7901.697674418605, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 55, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.8947368421052633, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 163042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2964.4, "stage_move_gen_ns": 201724766, "stage_ordering_ns": 192912, "stage_eval_ns": 2365326619, "stage_threat_ns": 1232411025, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 220891, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1075775697, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 50, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 520905, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 110436, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 132689232, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 220872, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23425191, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 426, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4688, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6898.894736842105, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7319.9473684210525, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1916, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 16216, "avg_search_time_ms": 853.4736842105264, "search_nodes": 138437, "safety_nodes": 1363, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 139800, "avg_nodes": 7357.894736842105, "eval_calls": 82689, "avg_eval_calls": 4352.0526315789475, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82689, "pattern_eval_ns": 1729948, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.921138240878474, "pattern_frame_queries": 82689, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1729948, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.921138240878474, "pattern_frame_updates": 276644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2236067646, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8082.834422579199, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 50744, "avg_candidate_generations": 2670.7368421052633, "candidate_moves_total": 4481086, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.30770140312156, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1504, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 50725, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4479582, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 3154442, "avg_legality_checks": 166023.26315789475, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2358, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3154442, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2358, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6396201, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 336642.15789473685, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10829241633, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1693.074003302898, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32586, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1715.0526315789473, "renju_forbidden_ns": 85172813, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2613.785460013503, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2449, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15277474, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6676, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 39712405, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23461, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30182934, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 208549, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10976.263157894737, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1510549458, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7243.139300596023, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 270152, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14218.526315789473, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 692142522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2562.048483816518, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6221895167, "stage_ordering_ns": 1414006860, "stage_eval_ns": 2237797594, "stage_threat_ns": 6204362505, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1083372, "root_tactical_annotations": 3575, "search_tactical_annotations": 1079797, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 276663, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1325156874, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 838544, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4636093538, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 101602, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2620898458, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 138322, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 176821963, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 276644, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29135682, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 330123, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 777783781, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 406804, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1237173648, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 346445, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 37154448, "child_limit_applications": 50725, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 50725, "child_cap_hits": 50725, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 50725, "child_moves_before_total": 4477224, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4477224, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 516806, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 516806, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.2646426811237, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.18838836865451, "tt_hits": 31208, "tt_cutoffs": 4908, "beta_cutoffs": 41232, "depth_sum": 115, "avg_depth": 6.052631578947368, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 115, "avg_effective_depth": 6.052631578947368, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15789473684210525, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5979.263157894737, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6400.315789473684, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1779, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 910, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20108, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 53, 95, 111, 125, 69, 55, 85, 155, 169, 110, 140, 65, 80, 79, 37, 101, 21 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 17102, "avg_search_time_ms": 1221.5714285714287, "search_nodes": 163901, "safety_nodes": 741, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 164642, "avg_nodes": 11760.142857142857, "eval_calls": 102938, "avg_eval_calls": 7352.714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 102938, "pattern_eval_ns": 2268091, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.033563892828692, "pattern_frame_queries": 102938, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2268091, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.033563892828692, "pattern_frame_updates": 327638, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4139926399, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12635.672293812073, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 56485, "avg_candidate_generations": 4034.6428571428573, "candidate_moves_total": 4653254, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.38034876515889, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 979, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 56471, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4652275, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1264842, "avg_legality_checks": 90345.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4117, "root_legality_checks": 979, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 1263863, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4542467, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 324461.9285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10095691811, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2222.512967292883, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37933, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2709.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 247048916, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6512.770305538713, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4285, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 42535418, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16664, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 143914825, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16954, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 60260239, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 338434, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 118664, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8476.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 990816474, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8349.76466325086, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 150098, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10721.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 394328922, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2627.143079854495, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3157092307, "stage_ordering_ns": 1888078795, "stage_eval_ns": 4142194490, "stage_threat_ns": 7846558325, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 959265, "root_tactical_annotations": 2964, "search_tactical_annotations": 956301, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 327652, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1967645560, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 718927, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5541749179, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 113051, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4026029062, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 163819, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 249856915, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 327638, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41709839, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 252311, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 313718699, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 353555, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1201554476, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 353399, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 45596832, "child_limit_applications": 56471, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 56471, "child_cap_hits": 56471, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 56471, "child_moves_before_total": 4648164, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4648164, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 611864, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 611864, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.31063731826956, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.835012661366012, "tt_hits": 35494, "tt_cutoffs": 4410, "beta_cutoffs": 46222, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 5.857142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 5.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3324.9285714285716, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3896.3571428571427, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 900, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 2995, "avg_search_time_ms": 230.3846153846154, "search_nodes": 84826, "safety_nodes": 1386, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 86212, "avg_nodes": 6631.692307692308, "eval_calls": 82350, "avg_eval_calls": 6334.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82350, "pattern_eval_ns": 1771114, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.50715239829994, "pattern_frame_queries": 82350, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1771114, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.50715239829994, "pattern_frame_updates": 169576, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1823455251, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10753.026672406473, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2451, "avg_candidate_generations": 188.53846153846155, "candidate_moves_total": 186715, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.17911056711546, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 898, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2438, "search_candidate_moves_total": 185817, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 4564, "avg_legality_checks": 351.0769230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4564, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 510769, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 39289.92307692308, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1180537024, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2311.293410524131, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8406, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 646.6153846153846, "renju_forbidden_ns": 73272848, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8716.731858196526, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 247651, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8352, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72684587, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 340610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13184277, "stage_ordering_ns": 79141, "stage_eval_ns": 1825226365, "stage_threat_ns": 1133360100, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169589, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 994065310, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 391171, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15310, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84788, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 117771652, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169576, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21131967, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 78, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2253, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6292.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6907.615384615385, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 911, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11578, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 126, 141, 99, 143, 98, 155, 169, 140, 142, 158, 100, 173, 128, 188, 203, 156, 101, 97, 102 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3986, "avg_search_time_ms": 362.3636363636364, "search_nodes": 101499, "safety_nodes": 671, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 102170, "avg_nodes": 9288.181818181818, "eval_calls": 97804, "avg_eval_calls": 8891.272727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 97804, "pattern_eval_ns": 2070220, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.167027933417856, "pattern_frame_queries": 97804, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2070220, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.167027933417856, "pattern_frame_updates": 202936, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2400241923, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11827.580729885283, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3675, "avg_candidate_generations": 334.09090909090907, "candidate_moves_total": 247290, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.28979591836735, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 699, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 3664, "search_candidate_moves_total": 246591, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 92992, "avg_legality_checks": 8453.818181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 699, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 92293, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 706353, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 64213.90909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1670400529, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2364.824003012658, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7642, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 694.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60041906, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7856.831457733578, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 256762, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7600, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 59785144, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 30, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.727272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 262651, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8755.033333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.4545454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 101030, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2658.684210526316, "stage_move_gen_ns": 236413008, "stage_ordering_ns": 131541, "stage_eval_ns": 2402312143, "stage_threat_ns": 1331575993, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 202947, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1165266183, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 372872, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 101468, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 141031043, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 202936, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24905895, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 241, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3260, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5490.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6217.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1786, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7579, "avg_search_time_ms": 757.9, "search_nodes": 61176, "safety_nodes": 972, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 62148, "avg_nodes": 6214.8, "eval_calls": 37392, "avg_eval_calls": 3739.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37392, "pattern_eval_ns": 824651, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.05420945656825, "pattern_frame_queries": 37392, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 824651, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.05420945656825, "pattern_frame_updates": 122234, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1242384567, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10163.985200517041, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21547, "avg_candidate_generations": 2154.7, "candidate_moves_total": 1613610, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.88791943193948, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 636, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 21537, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1612974, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 872006, "avg_legality_checks": 87200.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 419, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 872006, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 419, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2227223, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 222722.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4857291787, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2180.873575299824, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7468, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 746.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21086627, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2823.597616497054, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 421, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4530268, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1420, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10164409, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5627, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6391950, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74439, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7443.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 707847579, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9509.0957562568, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 102369, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10236.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 316424115, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3091.0150045423907, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2173037984, "stage_ordering_ns": 705143021, "stage_eval_ns": 1243209218, "stage_threat_ns": 3414558334, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 270816, "root_tactical_annotations": 863, "search_tactical_annotations": 269953, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 122244, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 753296359, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 243926, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2543804362, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43153, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1604612110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61117, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94197820, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 122234, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15725598, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 40776, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 241220657, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 159988, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 697535263, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 70052, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7534195, "child_limit_applications": 21537, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21537, "child_cap_hits": 21537, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21537, "child_moves_before_total": 1612555, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1612555, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 201059, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 201059, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.873705715745, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.335515624274505, "tt_hits": 10076, "tt_cutoffs": 2188, "beta_cutoffs": 16820, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 5.8, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 5.8, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3776.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4576.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 354, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 912, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22618, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 123, 81, 97, 83, 139, 153, 157, 173, 155, 85, 71, 82, 84, 79, 80, 65, 107, 171, 91 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 21014, "avg_search_time_ms": 1400.9333333333334, "search_nodes": 197795, "safety_nodes": 791, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 198586, "avg_nodes": 13239.066666666668, "eval_calls": 126057, "avg_eval_calls": 8403.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 126057, "pattern_eval_ns": 2741282, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.746368706220203, "pattern_frame_queries": 126057, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2741282, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.746368706220203, "pattern_frame_updates": 395412, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5050628992, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12773.079704207257, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 66148, "avg_candidate_generations": 4409.866666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 5772495, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.26635725947874, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1105, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 66133, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5771390, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1690225, "avg_legality_checks": 112681.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6331, "root_legality_checks": 1105, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 1689120, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6324, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5717719, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 381181.26666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12358596769, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2161.455777907239, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54089, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3605.9333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 324535947, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6000.035996228438, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6568, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 65626836, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21800, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 181852083, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25686, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 76667146, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 389882, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 162692, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10846.133333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1349910491, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8297.337859267818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 209723, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13981.533333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 552945929, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2636.5535921191286, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4148091748, "stage_ordering_ns": 2316390430, "stage_eval_ns": 5053370274, "stage_threat_ns": 9419887343, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1209201, "root_tactical_annotations": 3550, "search_tactical_annotations": 1205651, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 395427, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2361568922, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 973243, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6658651976, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 132384, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4570274995, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197706, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 301286132, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 395412, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52133794, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 337064, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 410111486, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 503784, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1677795262, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 368353, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 46246519, "child_limit_applications": 66133, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 66133, "child_cap_hits": 66133, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 66133, "child_moves_before_total": 5765066, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5765066, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 730628, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 730628, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.17381640028428, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.04785810412351, "tt_hits": 38316, "tt_cutoffs": 5518, "beta_cutoffs": 53909, "depth_sum": 87, "avg_depth": 5.8, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 87, "avg_effective_depth": 5.8, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2302.4666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2835.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 1591, "avg_search_time_ms": 113.64285714285714, "search_nodes": 48567, "safety_nodes": 1536, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 50103, "avg_nodes": 3578.785714285714, "eval_calls": 46124, "avg_eval_calls": 3294.5714285714284, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46124, "pattern_eval_ns": 985978, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.376680253230422, "pattern_frame_queries": 46124, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 985978, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.376680253230422, "pattern_frame_updates": 97052, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 895829347, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9230.405833985904, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2416, "avg_candidate_generations": 172.57142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 189523, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.44495033112582, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1021, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 2402, "search_candidate_moves_total": 188502, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 5696, "avg_legality_checks": 406.85714285714283, "illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5696, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 238018, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17001.285714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 556566858, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2338.339360888672, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3627, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 259.07142857142856, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31977686, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8816.566308243728, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 274812, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3567, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31307871, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 395003, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15990469, "stage_ordering_ns": 81010, "stage_eval_ns": 896815325, "stage_threat_ns": 653638821, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 97066, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 572861302, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 384222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48526, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 67690952, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 97052, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12702345, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 79, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2226, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6429.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7000.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 913, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 31024, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 84, 125, 83, 139, 153, 126, 129, 99, 85, 86, 81, 82, 115, 116, 70, 100, 101, 98, 96, 127, 124, 143, 159, 95, 79, 142, 73, 87, 53, 140, 141, 110, 80, 155 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 14450, "avg_search_time_ms": 802.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 344976, "safety_nodes": 1093, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 346069, "avg_nodes": 19226.055555555555, "eval_calls": 335098, "avg_eval_calls": 18616.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 335098, "pattern_eval_ns": 7172397, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.40387886528717, "pattern_frame_queries": 335098, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7172397, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.40387886528717, "pattern_frame_updates": 689846, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 9106823018, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13201.240592827964, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9843, "avg_candidate_generations": 546.8333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 840186, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.35873209387383, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1389, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 9825, "search_candidate_moves_total": 838797, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 318114, "avg_legality_checks": 17673.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 123, "root_legality_checks": 1389, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 316725, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 123, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2832600, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 157366.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6845652215, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2416.738055143684, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24400, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1355.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 181461911, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7436.96356557377, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 131, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1290329, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24267, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 180168172, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3410, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 273061, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10113.37037037037, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.9444444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 132141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3775.457142857143, "stage_move_gen_ns": 799063689, "stage_ordering_ns": 362933, "stage_eval_ns": 9113995415, "stage_threat_ns": 4492811732, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 689864, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3918825586, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 48, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 412612, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19550, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 344923, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 484086495, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 689846, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 89487039, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 569, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8786, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6254.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6698.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1782, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 16555, "avg_search_time_ms": 919.7222222222222, "search_nodes": 110906, "safety_nodes": 1764, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 112670, "avg_nodes": 6259.444444444444, "eval_calls": 65315, "avg_eval_calls": 3628.6111111111113, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 65315, "pattern_eval_ns": 1472535, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.54512745923601, "pattern_frame_queries": 65315, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1472535, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.54512745923601, "pattern_frame_updates": 221588, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2632921012, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11882.05594165749, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41173, "avg_candidate_generations": 2287.3888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 3497015, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.93466592184198, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1428, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 41155, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3495587, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 2412447, "avg_legality_checks": 134024.83333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8009, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2412447, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8009, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5061563, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 281197.94444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10948410860, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2163.049409836448, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43788, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2432.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 307769111, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7028.6176806430985, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8088, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 88186168, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13561, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 143243557, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22139, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 76339386, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 157558, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8753.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1472851745, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9347.99721372447, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 203314, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11295.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 665534563, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3273.432045997816, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5869266144, "stage_ordering_ns": 1412105578, "stage_eval_ns": 2634393547, "stage_threat_ns": 6531165862, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 854187, "root_tactical_annotations": 2755, "search_tactical_annotations": 851432, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 221606, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1372434233, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 683085, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4924892285, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 82457, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2890863690, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 110794, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 171986883, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 221588, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30821187, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 233966, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 584231675, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 366648, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1449453760, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 253573, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 31031274, "child_limit_applications": 41155, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41155, "child_cap_hits": 41155, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41155, "child_moves_before_total": 3487578, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3487578, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 397283, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 397283, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.74251002308347, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.65333495322561, "tt_hits": 24397, "tt_cutoffs": 4325, "beta_cutoffs": 33367, "depth_sum": 111, "avg_depth": 6.166666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 111, "avg_effective_depth": 6.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4919.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5363.611111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 914, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 42422, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 83, 125, 126, 95, 115, 116, 99, 131, 129, 84, 101, 143, 127, 141, 140, 154, 85, 71, 69, 139, 153, 53, 67, 51, 68, 66, 87, 73, 117, 133, 144, 159, 130, 96, 81, 94, 93, 98 ], "move_count": 44, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 36153, "avg_search_time_ms": 1807.65, "search_nodes": 353962, "safety_nodes": 425, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 354387, "avg_nodes": 17719.35, "eval_calls": 221217, "avg_eval_calls": 11060.85, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 221217, "pattern_eval_ns": 4848848, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.91896644471266, "pattern_frame_queries": 221217, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4848848, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.91896644471266, "pattern_frame_updates": 707686, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8852224548, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12508.689656146935, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 123257, "avg_candidate_generations": 6162.85, "candidate_moves_total": 11127709, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.28054390420017, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1569, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 123237, "search_candidate_moves_total": 11126140, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 2665550, "avg_legality_checks": 133277.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 14308, "root_legality_checks": 1569, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 2663981, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 14297, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9605135, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 480256.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20137252108, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2096.5090139805425, "renju_forbidden_checks": 116301, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5815.05, "renju_forbidden_ns": 827487895, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7115.053997816012, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15196, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 163237057, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 52415, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 455695726, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 48621, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 207802550, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 69, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 752562, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 246217, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12310.85, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2016233471, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8188.847524744433, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 316552, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15827.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 845268729, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2670.236577244813, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6328223676, "stage_ordering_ns": 4102563303, "stage_eval_ns": 8857073396, "stage_threat_ns": 16736427681, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 3123342, "root_tactical_annotations": 7898, "search_tactical_annotations": 3115444, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 707706, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4103512626, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2595279, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11912474467, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 246633, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7937600133, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 353843, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 530776292, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 707686, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 88737709, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 958965, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 703169345, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1389664, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3271600268, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 774713, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 100926587, "child_limit_applications": 123237, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 123237, "child_cap_hits": 123237, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 123237, "child_moves_before_total": 11111843, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 11111843, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 1587936, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1587936, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.16645163384374, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.885221159229777, "tt_hits": 64225, "tt_cutoffs": 9395, "beta_cutoffs": 101604, "depth_sum": 110, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 110, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 9, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.45, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 9, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.45, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 607.65, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 807.35, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 3997 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 6248, "avg_search_time_ms": 312.4, "search_nodes": 201926, "safety_nodes": 2303, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 204229, "avg_nodes": 10211.45, "eval_calls": 196409, "avg_eval_calls": 9820.45, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 196409, "pattern_eval_ns": 4209961, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.43466439928924, "pattern_frame_queries": 196409, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4209961, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.43466439928924, "pattern_frame_updates": 403736, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3553764282, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8802.198174054332, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5479, "avg_candidate_generations": 273.95, "candidate_moves_total": 426513, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.84504471618908, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1586, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 5459, "search_candidate_moves_total": 424927, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 10342, "avg_legality_checks": 517.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 29, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10342, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 29, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 865169, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 43258.45, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1973070193, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2280.560437324962, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17200, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 860.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 159177284, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9254.493255813954, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 369800, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17089, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 157962381, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 76, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 845103, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 29106152, "stage_ordering_ns": 187161, "stage_eval_ns": 3557974243, "stage_threat_ns": 2623731007, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 403756, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2297032648, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 546782, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 201868, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 275722241, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 403736, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50429336, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 152, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5072, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6534.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6934.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 915, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12771, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 129, 81, 157, 96, 144, 114, 156, 66, 111, 82, 171, 141, 143, 115, 185 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5514, "avg_search_time_ms": 612.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 143191, "safety_nodes": 224, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 143415, "avg_nodes": 15935.0, "eval_calls": 138797, "avg_eval_calls": 15421.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 138797, "pattern_eval_ns": 2935945, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.15279869161437, "pattern_frame_queries": 138797, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2935945, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.15279869161437, "pattern_frame_updates": 286330, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3236442715, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11303.19112562428, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4377, "avg_candidate_generations": 486.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 280277, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.03404158099154, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 4368, "search_candidate_moves_total": 279777, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 132681, "avg_legality_checks": 14742.333333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 132181, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 889359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 98817.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2151537892, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2419.2006737436736, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8536, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 948.4444444444445, "renju_forbidden_ns": 69680261, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8163.10461574508, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 223570, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8511, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 69456691, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.1111111111111112, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 111540, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11154.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.5555555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 54960, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3925.714285714286, "stage_move_gen_ns": 341001581, "stage_ordering_ns": 154911, "stage_eval_ns": 3239378660, "stage_threat_ns": 1930786737, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 286339, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1683343331, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 164320, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 143165, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 211555151, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 286330, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35723935, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 327, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3874, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4133.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5022.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 467, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7248, "avg_search_time_ms": 805.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 75678, "safety_nodes": 743, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76421, "avg_nodes": 8491.222222222223, "eval_calls": 45420, "avg_eval_calls": 5046.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 45420, "pattern_eval_ns": 942501, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.750792602377807, "pattern_frame_queries": 45420, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 942501, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.750792602377807, "pattern_frame_updates": 151258, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1180180478, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7802.433444842587, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27112, "avg_candidate_generations": 3012.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 2003543, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.8987533195633, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 511, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 27103, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2003032, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 976272, "avg_legality_checks": 108474.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 356, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 976272, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 356, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2582549, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 286949.8888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4532929770, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1755.2153976555721, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10054, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1117.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21010215, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2089.7369206286057, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 358, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2854731, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1804, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10232991, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7892, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7922493, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81258, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9028.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 630076252, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7754.0211671466195, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 113325, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12591.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 284039013, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2506.4108802117803, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1971279089, "stage_ordering_ns": 696004136, "stage_eval_ns": 1181122979, "stage_threat_ns": 3352634497, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 327339, "root_tactical_annotations": 835, "search_tactical_annotations": 326504, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 151267, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 740448735, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 300518, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2490485995, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54272, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1628069869, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75629, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 97819913, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 151258, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16008673, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 45868, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 225439712, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 200370, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 636734044, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 81101, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7871181, "child_limit_applications": 27103, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27103, "child_cap_hits": 27103, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27103, "child_moves_before_total": 2002676, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2002676, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 257501, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 257501, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.89130354573294, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.500830166402244, "tt_hits": 12309, "tt_cutoffs": 3106, "beta_cutoffs": 21313, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 5.444444444444445, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 5.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3463.8888888888887, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4352.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 994, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 916, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 38123, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 129, 81, 96, 83, 157, 172, 143, 171, 141, 144, 173, 125, 111, 95, 80, 64, 159, 175, 145, 65, 49, 131, 115, 101, 130, 100, 189, 205, 187, 201, 140, 139, 128, 53, 158, 188, 156, 160, 155 ], "move_count": 45, "black_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 35978, "avg_search_time_ms": 1713.2380952380952, "search_nodes": 361365, "safety_nodes": 751, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 362116, "avg_nodes": 17243.619047619046, "eval_calls": 222112, "avg_eval_calls": 10576.761904761905, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 222112, "pattern_eval_ns": 4590263, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.66643405128944, "pattern_frame_queries": 222112, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4590263, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.66643405128944, "pattern_frame_updates": 722478, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8567605350, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11858.638394525507, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 129011, "avg_candidate_generations": 6143.380952380952, "candidate_moves_total": 11886386, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.13467068699568, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1685, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 128990, "search_candidate_moves_total": 11884701, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 3056693, "avg_legality_checks": 145556.80952380953, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15367, "root_legality_checks": 1685, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 3055008, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15356, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10217413, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 486543.4761904762, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20404966311, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1997.0775685586948, "renju_forbidden_checks": 124571, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5931.952380952381, "renju_forbidden_ns": 805410592, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6465.474243604049, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16756, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 164012081, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 53293, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 427921452, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 54453, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 212819316, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 69, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 657743, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 261087, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12432.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2089733112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8003.972285100369, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 340388, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16208.952380952382, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 868272995, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2550.8331521675264, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6824521225, "stage_ordering_ns": 4119628825, "stage_eval_ns": 8572195613, "stage_threat_ns": 16343090500, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 3279750, "root_tactical_annotations": 8128, "search_tactical_annotations": 3271622, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 722499, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3950059827, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2583401, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11661650489, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 258147, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7791647524, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 361239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 520457774, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 722478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 85865829, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1037651, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 782306398, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1287584, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3087362875, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 954515, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 125056581, "child_limit_applications": 128990, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 128990, "child_cap_hits": 128990, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 128990, "child_moves_before_total": 11869345, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 11869345, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 1645707, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1645707, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 92.0175595007365, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.758407628498333, "tt_hits": 72322, "tt_cutoffs": 10140, "beta_cutoffs": 106996, "depth_sum": 120, "avg_depth": 5.714285714285714, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 120, "avg_effective_depth": 5.714285714285714, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 910.2380952380952, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1204.4285714285713, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 2124, "avg_search_time_ms": 106.2, "search_nodes": 84883, "safety_nodes": 2009, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 86892, "avg_nodes": 4344.6, "eval_calls": 80915, "avg_eval_calls": 4045.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80915, "pattern_eval_ns": 1616650, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.979608230859544, "pattern_frame_queries": 80915, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1616650, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.979608230859544, "pattern_frame_updates": 169648, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1069207814, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6302.507627558238, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3929, "avg_candidate_generations": 196.45, "candidate_moves_total": 328241, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.543140748282, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1593, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 3909, "search_candidate_moves_total": 326648, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 15474, "avg_legality_checks": 773.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 15474, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 289656, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14482.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 595699873, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2056.5770189466125, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4557, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 227.85, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31398097, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6890.080535439983, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 143, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1251917, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4352, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29493608, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 62, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 652572, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 36646597, "stage_ordering_ns": 133752, "stage_eval_ns": 1070824464, "stage_threat_ns": 980052867, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169668, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 857647712, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 475242, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20590, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84824, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 103535001, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169648, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18394912, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 245, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3512, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 2.95, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 2.95, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6938.45, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7338.45, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 917, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23038, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 80, 143, 95, 159, 175, 128, 83, 81, 65, 50, 125, 110, 67, 52, 64, 66, 51, 96, 126, 113, 158, 99, 85, 141, 155, 142, 19, 35, 140, 144, 145, 114, 129, 100, 86, 156 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 4944, "avg_search_time_ms": 260.2105263157895, "search_nodes": 134460, "safety_nodes": 1541, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 136001, "avg_nodes": 7157.9473684210525, "eval_calls": 128226, "avg_eval_calls": 6748.736842105263, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 128226, "pattern_eval_ns": 2589241, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.1927924133951, "pattern_frame_queries": 128226, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2589241, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.1927924133951, "pattern_frame_updates": 268808, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3048036145, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11339.082709591976, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6197, "avg_candidate_generations": 326.1578947368421, "candidate_moves_total": 526043, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.88671938034533, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1467, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 6178, "search_candidate_moves_total": 524576, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 120585, "avg_legality_checks": 6346.578947368421, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "root_legality_checks": 1467, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 119118, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1052288, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 55383.57894736842, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2346933109, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2230.314428179358, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12617, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 664.0526315789474, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66761147, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5291.364587461361, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 131290, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12600, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 66626517, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3340, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.263157894736842, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 385351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8961.651162790698, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 55, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.8947368421052633, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 181560, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3301.090909090909, "stage_move_gen_ns": 263703827, "stage_ordering_ns": 214701, "stage_eval_ns": 3050625386, "stage_threat_ns": 1584493508, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 268827, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1388473095, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 50, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 584931, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19530, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134404, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 165711324, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 268808, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29724158, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 426, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5498, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6865.473684210527, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7286.526315789473, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1862, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 18075, "avg_search_time_ms": 951.3157894736842, "search_nodes": 132830, "safety_nodes": 1363, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 134193, "avg_nodes": 7062.789473684211, "eval_calls": 78760, "avg_eval_calls": 4145.263157894737, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 78760, "pattern_eval_ns": 1659648, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.07221940071102, "pattern_frame_queries": 78760, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1659648, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.07221940071102, "pattern_frame_updates": 265430, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2671197619, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10063.661300531214, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49229, "avg_candidate_generations": 2591.0, "candidate_moves_total": 4292925, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.20317292652705, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1504, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 49210, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4291421, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 3014231, "avg_legality_checks": 158643.73684210525, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3209, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3014231, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3209, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6146957, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 323524.05263157893, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12103225125, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1968.978329440079, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31410, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1653.157894736842, "renju_forbidden_ns": 154660041, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4923.910888252149, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3300, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34216955, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8693, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 81782968, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19417, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 38660118, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 197390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10388.947368421053, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1694884616, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8586.476599625108, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 254788, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13409.894736842105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 777890704, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3053.0900356374714, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6617682359, "stage_ordering_ns": 1556218405, "stage_eval_ns": 2672857267, "stage_threat_ns": 7106995065, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1032842, "root_tactical_annotations": 3575, "search_tactical_annotations": 1029267, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 265449, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1517900683, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 794507, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5327574666, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 98572, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3080498573, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 132715, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 192258184, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 265430, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32159291, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 308529, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 819991319, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 387391, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1426810763, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 336922, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 37102241, "child_limit_applications": 49210, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49210, "child_cap_hits": 49210, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49210, "child_moves_before_total": 4288212, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4288212, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 495337, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 495337, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.1410688884373, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.065779313147734, "tt_hits": 30448, "tt_cutoffs": 4745, "beta_cutoffs": 39984, "depth_sum": 114, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 114, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2631578947368421, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5157.736842105263, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5578.789473684211, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 918, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17741, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 96, 97, 68, 110, 80, 128, 83, 81, 65, 113, 66, 129, 145, 143, 158, 64, 52, 94, 36, 84, 35, 95, 38, 24, 37, 39, 34 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 15836, "avg_search_time_ms": 1131.142857142857, "search_nodes": 172235, "safety_nodes": 556, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 172791, "avg_nodes": 12342.214285714286, "eval_calls": 114835, "avg_eval_calls": 8202.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 114835, "pattern_eval_ns": 2325547, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.251203901249617, "pattern_frame_queries": 114835, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2325547, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.251203901249617, "pattern_frame_updates": 344336, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4213339535, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12236.12847625575, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 53926, "avg_candidate_generations": 3851.8571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 4366821, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.97802544227274, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 929, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 53912, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4365892, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1312410, "avg_legality_checks": 93743.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3051, "root_legality_checks": 929, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 1311481, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3045, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4669962, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 333568.71428571426, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9325586400, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1996.9298251249154, "renju_forbidden_checks": 61436, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4388.285714285715, "renju_forbidden_ns": 272666833, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4438.225682010548, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3923, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21123837, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33284, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 186266593, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24187, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 65173793, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 102610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 119855, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8561.07142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 925916286, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7725.303792082099, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 156752, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11196.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 367798689, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2346.37318184138, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2999176543, "stage_ordering_ns": 1573183364, "stage_eval_ns": 4215665082, "stage_threat_ns": 6972801411, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1047176, "root_tactical_annotations": 3150, "search_tactical_annotations": 1044026, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 344350, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1824105810, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 929635, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4848917242, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 107918, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3208736894, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 172168, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 232754048, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 344336, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39041259, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 277786, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 236692317, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 543920, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1403270210, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 225470, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 27983052, "child_limit_applications": 53912, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 53912, "child_cap_hits": 53912, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 53912, "child_moves_before_total": 4362847, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4362847, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 640954, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 640954, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.92534129692832, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.888893010832467, "tt_hits": 23474, "tt_cutoffs": 3422, "beta_cutoffs": 41750, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4844.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5415.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 1889, "avg_search_time_ms": 145.30769230769232, "search_nodes": 58047, "safety_nodes": 1344, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59391, "avg_nodes": 4568.538461538462, "eval_calls": 56066, "avg_eval_calls": 4312.7692307692305, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 56066, "pattern_eval_ns": 1129494, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.14579245888774, "pattern_frame_queries": 56066, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1129494, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.14579245888774, "pattern_frame_updates": 116018, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1135701192, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9789.008533158647, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1956, "avg_candidate_generations": 150.46153846153845, "candidate_moves_total": 139315, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.22443762781187, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 870, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 1943, "search_candidate_moves_total": 138445, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 4365, "avg_legality_checks": 335.7692307692308, "illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4365, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 378249, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29096.076923076922, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 767713422, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2029.650896631584, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9584, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 737.2307692307693, "renju_forbidden_ns": 25434306, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2653.8299248747912, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26530, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9512, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25285114, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 49, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 122662, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11104917, "stage_ordering_ns": 65511, "stage_eval_ns": 1136830686, "stage_threat_ns": 720658871, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 116031, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 632820719, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 316132, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58009, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74183303, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116018, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13338717, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 127, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1726, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6405.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7021.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1885, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 919, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23783, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 84, 114, 140, 113, 111, 130, 82, 116, 115, 144, 158, 159, 129, 146, 162, 101, 86, 102, 88, 85, 141, 99, 100, 71, 57, 127 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 15707, "avg_search_time_ms": 1121.9285714285713, "search_nodes": 429469, "safety_nodes": 422, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 429891, "avg_nodes": 30706.5, "eval_calls": 418577, "avg_eval_calls": 29898.35714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 418577, "pattern_eval_ns": 8390619, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.04558062196442, "pattern_frame_queries": 418577, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 8390619, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.04558062196442, "pattern_frame_updates": 858858, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 9387408457, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10930.10539227672, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10866, "avg_candidate_generations": 776.1428571428571, "candidate_moves_total": 882774, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.24185532854776, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1013, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 10852, "search_candidate_moves_total": 881761, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 405553, "avg_legality_checks": 28968.071428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 357, "root_legality_checks": 1013, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 404540, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 357, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2854246, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 203874.7142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6602777741, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2313.3176821479296, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30244, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2160.285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 231254820, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7646.304060309483, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 372, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3367285, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29867, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 227878585, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8950, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.6428571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 231401, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10060.91304347826, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 37, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.642857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 118950, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3214.864864864865, "stage_move_gen_ns": 972467502, "stage_ordering_ns": 377650, "stage_eval_ns": 9395799076, "stage_threat_ns": 5305134456, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 858872, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4633597030, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 350372, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14580, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 429429, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 570086956, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 858858, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 101100098, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 762, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9454, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 2.7857142857142856, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7857142857142856, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4513.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5084.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8061, "avg_search_time_ms": 620.0769230769231, "search_nodes": 59611, "safety_nodes": 1187, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 60798, "avg_nodes": 4676.7692307692305, "eval_calls": 35017, "avg_eval_calls": 2693.6153846153848, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35017, "pattern_eval_ns": 741795, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.183853556843818, "pattern_frame_queries": 35017, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 741795, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.183853556843818, "pattern_frame_updates": 119074, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1212581089, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10183.424500730638, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22690, "avg_candidate_generations": 1745.3846153846155, "candidate_moves_total": 1859588, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.9562802996915, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 944, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 22677, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1858644, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1123186, "avg_legality_checks": 86398.92307692308, "illegal_moves_skipped": 637, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1123186, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 637, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2566527, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 197425.15384615384, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5285313838, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2059.3252430229645, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22123, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1701.7692307692307, "renju_forbidden_ns": 53696292, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2427.170456086426, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 757, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6184010, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4566, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27207178, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16800, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20305104, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6950.076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 801898659, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8875.37115250523, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 126027, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9694.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 359249712, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2850.5773524720894, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2615211350, "stage_ordering_ns": 739939837, "stage_eval_ns": 1213322884, "stage_threat_ns": 3439648997, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 367106, "root_tactical_annotations": 964, "search_tactical_annotations": 366142, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 119087, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 693010794, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 335073, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2637432275, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45454, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1526466148, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 59537, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 86829301, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 119074, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14633832, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71191, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 267971510, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 218420, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 842761807, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 77495, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7742795, "child_limit_applications": 22677, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22677, "child_cap_hits": 22677, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22677, "child_moves_before_total": 1858007, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1858007, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 211453, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 211453, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.93354500154341, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.324557922123738, "tt_hits": 9011, "tt_cutoffs": 1844, "beta_cutoffs": 18007, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5174.538461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5789.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 920, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32968, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 126, 114, 110, 158, 125, 129, 94, 78, 124, 127, 99, 82, 66, 130, 146, 70, 56, 97, 67, 65, 122, 123, 81, 115, 111, 96, 109, 116, 113, 144, 172, 102 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 26831, "avg_search_time_ms": 1578.2941176470588, "search_nodes": 232611, "safety_nodes": 1145, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 233756, "avg_nodes": 13750.35294117647, "eval_calls": 140580, "avg_eval_calls": 8269.411764705883, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 140580, "pattern_eval_ns": 2922470, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.788661260492248, "pattern_frame_queries": 140580, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2922470, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.788661260492248, "pattern_frame_updates": 465016, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6089209745, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13094.624152717326, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 82582, "avg_candidate_generations": 4857.764705882353, "candidate_moves_total": 8195761, "avg_candidate_moves": 99.24391513889225, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1491, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 82565, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8194270, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 2576969, "avg_legality_checks": 151586.41176470587, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5387, "root_legality_checks": 1491, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 2575478, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5385, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7841210, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 461247.64705882355, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15992551487, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2039.5514833807538, "renju_forbidden_checks": 119640, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7037.64705882353, "renju_forbidden_ns": 610587438, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5103.53926780341, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7880, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 59253718, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 44363, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 344956672, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 67376, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 206241768, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 135280, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 230960, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13585.882352941177, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2106827953, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9122.04690422584, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 321839, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18931.70588235294, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 978413179, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3040.0702804818557, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5827410196, "stage_ordering_ns": 2882289161, "stage_eval_ns": 6092132215, "stage_threat_ns": 11911305817, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1993652, "root_tactical_annotations": 4744, "search_tactical_annotations": 1988908, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 465033, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2630682103, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1467235, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8806956696, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 165266, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5564602244, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 232508, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 329367453, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 465016, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56277181, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 482604, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 597024491, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 819353, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2644613118, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 691695, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 88022384, "child_limit_applications": 82565, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 82565, "child_cap_hits": 82565, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 82565, "child_moves_before_total": 8188885, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8188885, "child_moves_before_max": 131, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 131, "child_moves_after_total": 1097736, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1097736, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 99.18106946042512, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.295415733058801, "tt_hits": 51679, "tt_cutoffs": 9364, "beta_cutoffs": 69926, "depth_sum": 100, "avg_depth": 5.882352941176471, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 100, "avg_effective_depth": 5.882352941176471, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4117647058823529, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2019.5882352941176, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2448.823529411765, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 6120, "avg_search_time_ms": 382.5, "search_nodes": 192718, "safety_nodes": 1412, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 194130, "avg_nodes": 12133.125, "eval_calls": 187669, "avg_eval_calls": 11729.3125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 187669, "pattern_eval_ns": 3923140, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.904571346359813, "pattern_frame_queries": 187669, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3923140, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.904571346359813, "pattern_frame_updates": 385342, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3622690614, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9401.234783646734, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5018, "avg_candidate_generations": 313.625, "candidate_moves_total": 477194, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.0964527700279, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1408, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 5002, "search_candidate_moves_total": 475786, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 16061, "avg_legality_checks": 1003.8125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 16061, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1011474, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 63217.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2341807019, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2315.2419330600687, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16815, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1050.9375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 91614418, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5448.3745465358315, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 42321, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16801, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 91451097, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 121000, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 41198700, "stage_ordering_ns": 199880, "stage_eval_ns": 3626613754, "stage_threat_ns": 2412752596, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 385358, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2112772313, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 228323, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 192671, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 254501256, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 385342, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45250704, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 476, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4386, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6531.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7031.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1964, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 921, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15073, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 97, 95, 125, 142, 94, 111, 67, 127, 144, 160, 79, 158, 174, 159, 143, 157, 156, 161 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5126, "avg_search_time_ms": 512.6, "search_nodes": 159013, "safety_nodes": 707, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 159720, "avg_nodes": 15972.0, "eval_calls": 154929, "avg_eval_calls": 15492.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 154929, "pattern_eval_ns": 3138792, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.259551149236103, "pattern_frame_queries": 154929, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3138792, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.259551149236103, "pattern_frame_updates": 317968, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3028444236, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9524.367974135763, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4065, "avg_candidate_generations": 406.5, "candidate_moves_total": 270297, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.49372693726937, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 624, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 4055, "search_candidate_moves_total": 269673, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 153195, "avg_legality_checks": 15319.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 624, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 152571, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1002600, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 100260.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2021739268, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2016.4963774187113, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5536, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 553.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46663165, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8429.039920520232, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5536, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 46663165, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 155620, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8190.526315789473, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 24, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 66130, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2755.4166666666665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 323381739, "stage_ordering_ns": 127451, "stage_eval_ns": 3031583028, "stage_threat_ns": 1742322875, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 317978, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1524737702, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 285212, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8370, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 158984, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 183668238, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 317968, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33631723, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 170, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3671, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4383.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5183.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 205, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9938, "avg_search_time_ms": 993.8, "search_nodes": 93325, "safety_nodes": 359, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 93684, "avg_nodes": 9368.4, "eval_calls": 58013, "avg_eval_calls": 5801.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 58013, "pattern_eval_ns": 1238984, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.357006188268148, "pattern_frame_queries": 58013, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1238984, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.357006188268148, "pattern_frame_updates": 186546, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1576553851, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8451.287355397597, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33221, "avg_candidate_generations": 3322.1, "candidate_moves_total": 2572445, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.4343036031426, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 647, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 33211, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2571798, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1474163, "avg_legality_checks": 147416.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 448, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1474163, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 448, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3303147, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 330314.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6361786372, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1925.977370065577, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9393, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 939.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33358502, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3551.421484083892, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 468, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2923785, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2253, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19579990, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6672, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10854727, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76589, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7658.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 657456195, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8584.21176670279, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109078, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10907.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 307665886, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2820.604393186527, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3104313928, "stage_ordering_ns": 940596739, "stage_eval_ns": 1577792835, "stage_threat_ns": 4253861757, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 459329, "root_tactical_annotations": 1867, "search_tactical_annotations": 457462, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 186556, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 991954864, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 383170, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3098815320, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 66493, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2151346496, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 93273, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 126159391, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 186546, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21387001, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 87713, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 329362369, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 228956, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 618031435, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 142660, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15545181, "child_limit_applications": 33211, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33211, "child_cap_hits": 33211, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33211, "child_moves_before_total": 2571350, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2571350, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 291848, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 291848, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.42464845984765, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.787690825328957, "tt_hits": 16657, "tt_cutoffs": 2050, "beta_cutoffs": 25948, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 5.1, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 5.1, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2900.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3700.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 24, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 922, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12906, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 142, 95, 65, 94, 127, 140, 125, 97, 114, 156, 113, 78, 62, 111, 141, 155, 157, 172, 173, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9884, "avg_search_time_ms": 823.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 149505, "safety_nodes": 493, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 149998, "avg_nodes": 12499.833333333334, "eval_calls": 99994, "avg_eval_calls": 8332.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 99994, "pattern_eval_ns": 1957021, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.571384283056982, "pattern_frame_queries": 99994, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1957021, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.571384283056982, "pattern_frame_updates": 298890, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2721728706, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9106.121670179664, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46428, "avg_candidate_generations": 3869.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3800603, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.86014904798829, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 807, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 46416, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3799796, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1119692, "avg_legality_checks": 93307.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1176, "root_legality_checks": 807, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1118885, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1176, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4217466, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 351455.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5771630494, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1368.5067037884835, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37921, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3160.0833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 117645880, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3102.3939242108595, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1306, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5943364, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21317, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 88672587, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15298, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23029929, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 117939, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9828.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 644112405, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5461.402971027395, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 154959, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12913.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 271773362, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1753.8404481185346, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1692084044, "stage_ordering_ns": 962392791, "stage_eval_ns": 2723685727, "stage_threat_ns": 4445661325, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 781490, "root_tactical_annotations": 2778, "search_tactical_annotations": 778712, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 298902, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1138203856, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 627373, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3099457169, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 92915, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2141601698, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 149445, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 155679472, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 298890, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25843224, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 202738, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 187890639, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 331711, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 769774802, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 247041, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26477604, "child_limit_applications": 46416, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46416, "child_cap_hits": 46416, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46416, "child_moves_before_total": 3798620, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3798620, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 496873, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 496873, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.83859014133057, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.704778524646674, "tt_hits": 25583, "tt_cutoffs": 3035, "beta_cutoffs": 36829, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5140.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5807.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1713, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3012, "avg_search_time_ms": 273.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 148788, "safety_nodes": 1080, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 149868, "avg_nodes": 13624.363636363636, "eval_calls": 144378, "avg_eval_calls": 13125.272727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 144378, "pattern_eval_ns": 2833354, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.62455498760199, "pattern_frame_queries": 144378, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2833354, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.62455498760199, "pattern_frame_updates": 297512, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1648718116, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5541.686103417677, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4389, "avg_candidate_generations": 399.0, "candidate_moves_total": 314768, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.71747550694919, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 743, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 4378, "search_candidate_moves_total": 314025, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 9512, "avg_legality_checks": 864.7272727272727, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9512, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 535937, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 48721.545454545456, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 852188955, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1590.0916618930955, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4071, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 370.09090909090907, "renju_forbidden_ns": 27016191, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6636.254237288135, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4071, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27016191, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17475981, "stage_ordering_ns": 135141, "stage_eval_ns": 1651551470, "stage_threat_ns": 1310457353, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 297523, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1140452226, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 232401, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6740, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148756, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 143728161, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 297512, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26044565, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 140, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4012, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5620.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6347.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 923, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28969, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 81, 68, 142, 54, 40, 94, 111, 109, 127, 157, 128, 85, 86, 125, 158, 174, 143, 113, 95, 79, 159 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 15118, "avg_search_time_ms": 1162.923076923077, "search_nodes": 421378, "safety_nodes": 914, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 422292, "avg_nodes": 32484.0, "eval_calls": 413101, "avg_eval_calls": 31777.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 413101, "pattern_eval_ns": 8579179, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.767751712051048, "pattern_frame_queries": 413101, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 8579179, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.767751712051048, "pattern_frame_updates": 842682, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 9301102065, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11037.499394789493, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8253, "avg_candidate_generations": 634.8461538461538, "candidate_moves_total": 668048, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.94608021325578, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 986, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 8240, "search_candidate_moves_total": 667062, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 407771, "avg_legality_checks": 31367.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1570, "root_legality_checks": 986, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 406785, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1567, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2912271, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 224020.84615384616, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6557525856, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2251.688066117473, "renju_forbidden_checks": 67784, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5214.153846153846, "renju_forbidden_ns": 439904890, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6489.804231086982, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1580, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5563199, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 66183, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 434316001, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 25690, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.769230769230769, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 396392, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8089.632653061224, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 64, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.923076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 150412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2350.1875, "stage_move_gen_ns": 894351112, "stage_ordering_ns": 278762, "stage_eval_ns": 9309681244, "stage_threat_ns": 4855404855, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 842695, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4228617315, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 503912, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12020, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 421341, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 532921333, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 842682, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 93362295, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 435, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7475, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4602.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5217.615384615385, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1436, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 13837, "avg_search_time_ms": 1153.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 110724, "safety_nodes": 1306, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 112030, "avg_nodes": 9335.833333333334, "eval_calls": 68144, "avg_eval_calls": 5678.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68144, "pattern_eval_ns": 1480391, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.72445116224466, "pattern_frame_queries": 68144, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1480391, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.72445116224466, "pattern_frame_updates": 221306, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2732369233, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12346.566441940118, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38033, "avg_candidate_generations": 3169.4166666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 3199890, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.13456734940709, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 912, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 38021, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3198978, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1667080, "avg_legality_checks": 138923.33333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3934, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1667080, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3934, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4257555, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 354796.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8683545866, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2039.5616418343393, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48718, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4059.8333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 264943544, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5438.309125990394, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4159, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 31288788, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20344, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 164719778, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24195, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 68910637, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 24341, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 150193, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12516.083333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1279737666, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8520.621240670338, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 200705, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16725.416666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 533449328, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2657.877621384619, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3783023190, "stage_ordering_ns": 1214418105, "stage_eval_ns": 2733849624, "stage_threat_ns": 6036221224, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 749521, "root_tactical_annotations": 961, "search_tactical_annotations": 748560, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 221318, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1285885229, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 644543, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4539015245, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 76137, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2626966480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 110653, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 162083730, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 221306, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27561953, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 126811, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 378840627, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 441586, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1532862167, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 181124, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21675067, "child_limit_applications": 38021, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38021, "child_cap_hits": 38021, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38021, "child_moves_before_total": 3195044, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3195044, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 471332, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 471332, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.0336656058494, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.396622918913232, "tt_hits": 18214, "tt_cutoffs": 4489, "beta_cutoffs": 31302, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 5.833333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 5.833333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3046.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3713.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 909, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 924, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13823, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 85, 68, 111, 80, 81, 113, 94, 78, 95, 36, 109, 108, 123, 67, 137 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11460, "avg_search_time_ms": 1146.0, "search_nodes": 106403, "safety_nodes": 568, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 106971, "avg_nodes": 10697.1, "eval_calls": 66571, "avg_eval_calls": 6657.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 66571, "pattern_eval_ns": 1478360, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.20726742876027, "pattern_frame_queries": 66571, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1478360, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.20726742876027, "pattern_frame_updates": 212698, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2601557380, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12231.226339692897, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37197, "avg_candidate_generations": 3719.7, "candidate_moves_total": 2972424, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.91031534801193, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 651, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 37187, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2971773, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 891539, "avg_legality_checks": 89153.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 818, "root_legality_checks": 651, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 890888, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 815, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3000171, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 300017.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6880405261, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2293.3377000844284, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18368, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1836.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 103606597, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5640.60305966899, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 873, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7992471, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8780, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72746432, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8698, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22707094, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 160600, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72017, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7201.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 649837528, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9023.390699418193, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 93376, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9337.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 266401789, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2853.00065327279, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2250130603, "stage_ordering_ns": 1251821022, "stage_eval_ns": 2603035740, "stage_threat_ns": 5308800509, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 509747, "root_tactical_annotations": 2024, "search_tactical_annotations": 507723, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 212708, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1298585715, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 398987, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3796799605, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 74447, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2817135267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 106349, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 163244877, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 212698, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27464185, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 95465, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 158420912, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 229067, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 820820283, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 185215, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22706127, "child_limit_applications": 37187, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37187, "child_cap_hits": 37187, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37187, "child_moves_before_total": 2970958, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2970958, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 345703, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 345703, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.8923817463092, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.29634011885874, "tt_hits": 21246, "tt_cutoffs": 2591, "beta_cutoffs": 29428, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2595.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3395.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 544, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2354, "avg_search_time_ms": 261.55555555555554, "search_nodes": 82940, "safety_nodes": 627, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 83567, "avg_nodes": 9285.222222222223, "eval_calls": 79466, "avg_eval_calls": 8829.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79466, "pattern_eval_ns": 1692955, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.30414265220346, "pattern_frame_queries": 79466, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1692955, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.30414265220346, "pattern_frame_updates": 165828, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1250339319, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7539.9770786598165, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3457, "avg_candidate_generations": 384.1111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 248091, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.7648249927683, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 583, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 3448, "search_candidate_moves_total": 247508, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 11384, "avg_legality_checks": 1264.888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11384, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 295710, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32856.666666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 685847344, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2319.324148659159, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2035, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 226.11111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16226013, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7973.470761670762, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 37951, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2016, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16022761, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 165301, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 27466262, "stage_ordering_ns": 120321, "stage_eval_ns": 1252032274, "stage_threat_ns": 1054571493, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 165837, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 924291499, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 205261, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 82914, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 110263932, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 165828, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19810801, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 200, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3124, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5339.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6228.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 925, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21534, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 80, 82, 144, 97, 127, 68, 110, 52, 67, 84, 100, 85, 83, 54, 40, 51, 50, 36, 20, 65, 81, 37, 79, 53, 55, 69, 101, 21 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 10898, "avg_search_time_ms": 726.5333333333333, "search_nodes": 287825, "safety_nodes": 89, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 287914, "avg_nodes": 19194.266666666666, "eval_calls": 278725, "avg_eval_calls": 18581.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 278725, "pattern_eval_ns": 5987862, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.483046013095343, "pattern_frame_queries": 278725, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5987862, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.483046013095343, "pattern_frame_updates": 575564, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6456832722, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11218.270638886379, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9072, "avg_candidate_generations": 604.8, "candidate_moves_total": 726660, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.09920634920636, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1101, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 9057, "search_candidate_moves_total": 725559, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 268188, "avg_legality_checks": 17879.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 66, "root_legality_checks": 1101, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 267087, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 66, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1946223, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 129748.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4602200709, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2364.683137030032, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23892, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1592.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 170855439, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7151.156830738322, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 205, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1426133, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23680, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 169365266, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 64040, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 656374098, "stage_ordering_ns": 323830, "stage_eval_ns": 6462820584, "stage_threat_ns": 3722491295, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 575579, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3259927531, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 31640, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15650, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 287782, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 392618069, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 575564, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69914055, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 990, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7670, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5475.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6009.133333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 10621, "avg_search_time_ms": 758.6428571428571, "search_nodes": 81625, "safety_nodes": 1354, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 82979, "avg_nodes": 5927.071428571428, "eval_calls": 51532, "avg_eval_calls": 3680.8571428571427, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51532, "pattern_eval_ns": 1139881, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.11986726694093, "pattern_frame_queries": 51532, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1139881, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.11986726694093, "pattern_frame_updates": 163090, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1823915830, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11183.492734073212, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27996, "avg_candidate_generations": 1999.7142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 2304354, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.3101157308187, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1029, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 27982, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2303325, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 1357241, "avg_legality_checks": 96945.78571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4121, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1357241, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4121, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3199468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 228533.42857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6774082025, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2117.2526260615828, "renju_forbidden_checks": 51942, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3710.1428571428573, "renju_forbidden_ns": 176941232, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3406.515575064495, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4953, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 42551899, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12701, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72687412, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 34281, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 61634591, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 67330, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 112203, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8014.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1021859104, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9107.235136315428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 159017, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11358.357142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 456228887, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2869.057314626738, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3317696027, "stage_ordering_ns": 941540493, "stage_eval_ns": 1825055711, "stage_threat_ns": 4471221217, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 467379, "root_tactical_annotations": 976, "search_tactical_annotations": 466403, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 163104, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 990187518, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 445195, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3325457484, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56072, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1875726718, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 81545, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125969136, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 163090, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20806822, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 97987, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 283430156, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 291127, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1166001016, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78265, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8800257, "child_limit_applications": 27982, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27982, "child_cap_hits": 27982, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27982, "child_moves_before_total": 2299204, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2299204, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 249231, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 249231, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.16725037524122, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.906832964048316, "tt_hits": 9583, "tt_cutoffs": 2033, "beta_cutoffs": 21294, "depth_sum": 78, "avg_depth": 5.571428571428571, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 78, "avg_effective_depth": 5.571428571428571, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5213.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5785.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 926, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28203, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 128, 82, 142, 100, 143, 83, 156, 170, 158, 113, 81, 110, 124, 68, 54, 64, 48, 111, 109, 67, 188, 173, 140, 172, 141, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 22368, "avg_search_time_ms": 1597.7142857142858, "search_nodes": 190408, "safety_nodes": 725, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 191133, "avg_nodes": 13652.357142857143, "eval_calls": 120744, "avg_eval_calls": 8624.57142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 120744, "pattern_eval_ns": 2652942, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.971625919300337, "pattern_frame_queries": 120744, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2652942, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.971625919300337, "pattern_frame_updates": 380654, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5649465940, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14841.472675973457, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 63257, "avg_candidate_generations": 4518.357142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 5928505, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.72093207075896, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1168, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 63243, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5927337, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 1688805, "avg_legality_checks": 120628.92857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3912, "root_legality_checks": 1168, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1687637, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3910, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5786122, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 413294.4285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13233137628, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2287.047806458281, "renju_forbidden_checks": 84264, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6018.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 574430449, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6817.032766068546, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5067, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 50180919, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 41039, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 362684286, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 38120, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 161153064, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 412180, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 156723, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11194.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1603668495, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10232.502536322047, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 220664, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15761.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 749389198, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3396.064595946779, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4309182390, "stage_ordering_ns": 2338445123, "stage_eval_ns": 5652118882, "stage_threat_ns": 9987314668, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1343444, "root_tactical_annotations": 3719, "search_tactical_annotations": 1339725, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 380668, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2339417315, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1050031, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7245535114, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 126595, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4772737017, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 190327, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 294526685, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 380654, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49776314, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 353337, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 460591429, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 570090, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2011882077, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 420017, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 58059240, "child_limit_applications": 63243, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 63243, "child_cap_hits": 63243, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 63243, "child_moves_before_total": 5923427, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5923427, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 791202, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 791202, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.66138544977309, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.510507091693942, "tt_hits": 37186, "tt_cutoffs": 6345, "beta_cutoffs": 51885, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1660.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2067.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 5820, "avg_search_time_ms": 415.7142857142857, "search_nodes": 159158, "safety_nodes": 1726, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 160884, "avg_nodes": 11491.714285714286, "eval_calls": 155446, "avg_eval_calls": 11103.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 155446, "pattern_eval_ns": 3333570, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.445196402609266, "pattern_frame_queries": 155446, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3333570, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.445196402609266, "pattern_frame_updates": 318236, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3638653275, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11433.820419437146, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3686, "avg_candidate_generations": 263.2857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 316223, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.79028757460662, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1195, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 3672, "search_candidate_moves_total": 315028, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 6336, "avg_legality_checks": 452.57142857142856, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6336, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 961573, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 68683.78571428571, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2330232927, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2423.355197161318, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22338, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1595.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_ns": 191383874, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8567.636941534605, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 224635, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22267, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 190658576, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 500663, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18438911, "stage_ordering_ns": 119361, "stage_eval_ns": 3641986845, "stage_threat_ns": 2132984366, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 318250, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1869401885, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 308890, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14960, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 159118, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 223679715, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 318236, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39593876, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 167, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3390, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6222.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6793.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 927, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23198, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 80, 110, 144, 111, 113, 124, 82, 108, 109, 140, 156, 155, 125, 138, 152, 93, 78, 92, 76, 79, 143, 95, 94, 63, 47, 127 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 14572, "avg_search_time_ms": 1040.857142857143, "search_nodes": 373189, "safety_nodes": 422, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 373611, "avg_nodes": 26686.5, "eval_calls": 363306, "avg_eval_calls": 25950.428571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 363306, "pattern_eval_ns": 7808006, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.491541565512268, "pattern_frame_queries": 363306, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7808006, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.491541565512268, "pattern_frame_updates": 746298, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8643778912, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11582.208329648478, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9857, "avg_candidate_generations": 704.0714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 795278, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.68154610936391, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1013, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 9843, "search_candidate_moves_total": 794265, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 351242, "avg_legality_checks": 25088.714285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 372, "root_legality_checks": 1013, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 350229, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 372, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2467202, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 176228.7142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6092608104, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2469.4403230866383, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27399, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1957.0714285714287, "renju_forbidden_ns": 214823695, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7840.56699149604, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 385, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3378671, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27009, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 211435954, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9070, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.6428571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 236432, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10279.652173913044, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 37, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.642857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 123412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3335.4594594594596, "stage_move_gen_ns": 905592186, "stage_ordering_ns": 354223, "stage_eval_ns": 8651586918, "stage_threat_ns": 4970246308, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 746312, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4352419594, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 362503, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 373149, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 523612431, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 746298, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 93851780, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 751, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8550, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 2.7857142857142856, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7857142857142856, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4651.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5222.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8611, "avg_search_time_ms": 662.3846153846154, "search_nodes": 62771, "safety_nodes": 1187, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 63958, "avg_nodes": 4919.846153846154, "eval_calls": 37027, "avg_eval_calls": 2848.230769230769, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37027, "pattern_eval_ns": 831982, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.46960326248413, "pattern_frame_queries": 37027, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 831982, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.46960326248413, "pattern_frame_updates": 125394, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1294524796, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10323.658197361916, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23791, "avg_candidate_generations": 1830.076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 1955450, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.19284603421463, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 944, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 23778, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1954506, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1183961, "avg_legality_checks": 91073.92307692308, "illegal_moves_skipped": 609, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1183961, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 609, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2690750, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 206980.76923076922, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5609932003, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2084.8952905323795, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23387, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1799.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 56745564, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2426.372087056912, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 723, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5904993, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4630, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29956676, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18034, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20883895, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 96994, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7461.076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 853602145, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8800.566478338866, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 135274, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10405.692307692309, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 379883942, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2808.2554075432085, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2791232247, "stage_ordering_ns": 789047296, "stage_eval_ns": 1295356778, "stage_threat_ns": 3676781832, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 389231, "root_tactical_annotations": 964, "search_tactical_annotations": 388267, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125407, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 757419291, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 357884, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2798552190, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47656, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1608673165, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 62697, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 95882551, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 125394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15843899, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 78391, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 299806142, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 231829, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 889821712, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79011, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9083901, "child_limit_applications": 23778, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23778, "child_cap_hits": 23778, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23778, "child_moves_before_total": 1953897, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1953897, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 222018, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 222018, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.17247035074439, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.337118344688367, "tt_hits": 9212, "tt_cutoffs": 1892, "beta_cutoffs": 18846, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5151.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5766.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 928, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24511, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 128, 110, 114, 156, 129, 125, 100, 86, 130, 127, 95, 82, 68, 124, 138, 64, 48, 84, 85, 83, 81, 97, 67, 111, 69, 139 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 20380, "avg_search_time_ms": 1455.7142857142858, "search_nodes": 184868, "safety_nodes": 1105, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 185973, "avg_nodes": 13283.785714285714, "eval_calls": 117992, "avg_eval_calls": 8428.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 117992, "pattern_eval_ns": 2535664, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.490134924401655, "pattern_frame_queries": 117992, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2535664, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.490134924401655, "pattern_frame_updates": 369580, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5217925056, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14118.526586936523, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 61077, "avg_candidate_generations": 4362.642857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 5682364, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.03606922409418, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1145, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 61063, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5681219, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 1618908, "avg_legality_checks": 115636.28571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2940, "root_legality_checks": 1145, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1617763, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2940, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5664682, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 404620.14285714284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12135706689, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2142.3456231082346, "renju_forbidden_checks": 79719, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5694.214285714285, "renju_forbidden_ns": 466892946, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5856.733601776239, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3670, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 31258107, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 39528, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 308363156, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 36507, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 127222002, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 49681, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 157189, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11227.785714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1509550884, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9603.412986913843, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 221744, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15838.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 707841289, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3192.1553187459413, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3892993661, "stage_ordering_ns": 2090819218, "stage_eval_ns": 5220460720, "stage_threat_ns": 9103318667, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1264214, "root_tactical_annotations": 3262, "search_tactical_annotations": 1260952, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 369594, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2132787149, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 979284, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6598998922, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 122231, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4323270876, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 184790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 273078070, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 369580, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46005316, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 308349, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 386224647, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 548693, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1888938196, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 407172, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 52449210, "child_limit_applications": 61063, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 61063, "child_cap_hits": 61063, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 61063, "child_moves_before_total": 5678279, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5678279, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 749217, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 749217, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 92.99050161308813, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.26957404647659, "tt_hits": 35605, "tt_cutoffs": 5738, "beta_cutoffs": 50054, "depth_sum": 74, "avg_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 74, "avg_effective_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2022.2142857142858, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2573.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 4116, "avg_search_time_ms": 316.61538461538464, "search_nodes": 146036, "safety_nodes": 1187, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 147223, "avg_nodes": 11324.846153846154, "eval_calls": 141888, "avg_eval_calls": 10914.461538461539, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 141888, "pattern_eval_ns": 2910930, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.515688430311233, "pattern_frame_queries": 141888, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2910930, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.515688430311233, "pattern_frame_updates": 291996, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2447910421, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8383.369707119276, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4123, "avg_candidate_generations": 317.15384615384613, "candidate_moves_total": 366664, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.9313606597138, "candidate_moves_max": 132, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1072, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 4110, "search_candidate_moves_total": 365592, "search_candidate_moves_max": 132, "legality_checks": 9553, "avg_legality_checks": 734.8461538461538, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9553, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 791244, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 60864.92307692308, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1540786827, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1947.2966960886906, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18168, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1397.5384615384614, "renju_forbidden_ns": 53107445, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2923.131054601497, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14610, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18148, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 53051445, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 41390, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20447905, "stage_ordering_ns": 140542, "stage_eval_ns": 2450821351, "stage_threat_ns": 1631628113, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 292009, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1409939632, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 201411, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12290, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 145998, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 169557239, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 291996, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51929831, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 253, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3744, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6112.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6727.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1962, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 929, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18372, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 114, 81, 83, 66, 113, 50, 34, 111, 99, 79, 78, 129, 115, 116, 131, 67, 147 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10570, "avg_search_time_ms": 960.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 297127, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 297513, "avg_nodes": 27046.636363636364, "eval_calls": 290576, "avg_eval_calls": 26416.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 290576, "pattern_eval_ns": 6044852, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.802998182919442, "pattern_frame_queries": 290576, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6044852, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.802998182919442, "pattern_frame_updates": 594192, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6398184939, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10767.87459104128, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6531, "avg_candidate_generations": 593.7272727272727, "candidate_moves_total": 511669, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.34466391058031, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 817, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 6520, "search_candidate_moves_total": 510852, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 287379, "avg_legality_checks": 26125.363636363636, "illegal_moves_skipped": 202, "root_legality_checks": 817, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 286562, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 202, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1975461, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 179587.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4431966134, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2243.5098106214195, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26062, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2369.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 251906650, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9665.66840610851, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 206, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1765256, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25856, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 250141394, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.9090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 126601, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12660.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.2727272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 68760, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4911.428571428572, "stage_move_gen_ns": 646981460, "stage_ordering_ns": 231220, "stage_eval_ns": 6404229791, "stage_threat_ns": 3474503281, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 594203, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3034417092, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 182691, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10760, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 297096, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 373024039, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 594192, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66879459, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 499, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5747, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4085.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4813.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7791, "avg_search_time_ms": 779.1, "search_nodes": 56448, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 57421, "avg_nodes": 5742.1, "eval_calls": 34731, "avg_eval_calls": 3473.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34731, "pattern_eval_ns": 769665, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.16074976246005, "pattern_frame_queries": 34731, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 769665, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.16074976246005, "pattern_frame_updates": 112788, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1110277292, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9843.931021030607, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19695, "avg_candidate_generations": 1969.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1717282, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.19380553439959, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 749, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 19685, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1716533, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1066021, "avg_legality_checks": 106602.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1092, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1066021, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1092, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2353365, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 235336.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5100336704, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2167.252722803305, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17037, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1703.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 84133013, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4938.252802723484, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1343, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14315025, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4604, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 45859507, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11090, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23958481, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81827, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8182.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 845775352, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10336.14029599032, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 112923, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11292.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 403570759, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3573.857929739734, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2630856781, "stage_ordering_ns": 710969824, "stage_eval_ns": 1111046957, "stage_threat_ns": 3286971755, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 306018, "root_tactical_annotations": 951, "search_tactical_annotations": 305067, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 112798, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 679129938, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 269760, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2498946488, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 39444, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1389280814, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56394, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 85108961, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 112788, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15050578, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 51440, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 318588881, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 178869, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 790891513, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 75709, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8735790, "child_limit_applications": 19685, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19685, "child_cap_hits": 19685, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19685, "child_moves_before_total": 1715441, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1715441, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 200769, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 200769, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.14457708915418, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.199085598171196, "tt_hits": 8863, "tt_cutoffs": 1979, "beta_cutoffs": 15613, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 5.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4355.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5155.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1843, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 930, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13243, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 114, 81, 79, 66, 113, 84, 83, 111, 100, 86, 99, 38, 115, 116, 131, 67, 147 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11591, "avg_search_time_ms": 1159.1, "search_nodes": 108360, "safety_nodes": 568, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 108928, "avg_nodes": 10892.8, "eval_calls": 67957, "avg_eval_calls": 6795.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67957, "pattern_eval_ns": 1475785, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.716453051194136, "pattern_frame_queries": 67957, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1475785, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.716453051194136, "pattern_frame_updates": 216612, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2628736942, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12135.693968939855, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37842, "avg_candidate_generations": 3784.2, "candidate_moves_total": 3018548, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.76713704349665, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 651, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 37832, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3017897, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 917711, "avg_legality_checks": 91771.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 856, "root_legality_checks": 651, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 917060, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 853, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3064582, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 306458.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6980800734, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2277.896539887006, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19124, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1912.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 105796297, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5532.121784145576, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 910, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8385374, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9112, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73953563, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9085, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23293280, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 164080, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74801, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7480.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 672002400, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8983.869199609631, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 96883, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9688.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 277285709, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2862.067741502637, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2283488339, "stage_ordering_ns": 1256426301, "stage_eval_ns": 2630212727, "stage_threat_ns": 5372614629, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 505226, "root_tactical_annotations": 2024, "search_tactical_annotations": 503202, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 216622, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1307436266, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 400681, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3850093800, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75737, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2848770518, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108306, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 164167535, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 216612, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27497989, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 95822, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 162555512, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 229114, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 838327409, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 180290, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23419039, "child_limit_applications": 37832, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37832, "child_cap_hits": 37832, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37832, "child_moves_before_total": 3017044, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3017044, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 348153, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 348153, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.74846690632269, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.202606259251427, "tt_hits": 21229, "tt_cutoffs": 2517, "beta_cutoffs": 29974, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2426.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3226.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 357, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1644, "avg_search_time_ms": 182.66666666666666, "search_nodes": 52848, "safety_nodes": 627, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53475, "avg_nodes": 5941.666666666667, "eval_calls": 50368, "avg_eval_calls": 5596.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50368, "pattern_eval_ns": 1077525, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.39304717280813, "pattern_frame_queries": 50368, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1077525, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.39304717280813, "pattern_frame_updates": 105644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 897874448, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8499.057665366703, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2463, "avg_candidate_generations": 273.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 173850, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.58465286236297, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 583, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 2454, "search_candidate_moves_total": 173267, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 10814, "avg_legality_checks": 1201.5555555555557, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10814, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 214832, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23870.222222222223, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 529246946, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2463.5387000074475, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2554, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 283.77777777777777, "renju_forbidden_ns": 25768750, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10089.565387627252, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 39251, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2535, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25563629, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 165870, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 29201521, "stage_ordering_ns": 91900, "stage_eval_ns": 898951973, "stage_threat_ns": 699385593, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 105653, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 613635212, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 206551, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52822, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 72655012, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 105644, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12888818, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 200, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2172, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5503.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6392.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1982, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 931, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19196, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 140, 154, 142, 99, 129, 100, 127, 69, 54, 97, 143, 86, 72, 141, 157, 172, 171, 115, 185 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11344, "avg_search_time_ms": 1031.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 266507, "safety_nodes": 383, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 266890, "avg_nodes": 24262.727272727272, "eval_calls": 260526, "avg_eval_calls": 23684.18181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 260526, "pattern_eval_ns": 5585928, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.4409617466203, "pattern_frame_queries": 260526, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5585928, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.4409617466203, "pattern_frame_updates": 532952, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7067959522, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13261.906366802263, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5961, "avg_candidate_generations": 541.9090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 464059, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.84918637812447, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 809, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 5950, "search_candidate_moves_total": 463250, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 256632, "avg_legality_checks": 23330.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 89, "root_legality_checks": 809, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 255823, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 89, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1919275, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 174479.54545454544, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4934897927, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2571.2302442328482, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31589, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2871.7272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 348146001, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11021.114976732408, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 92, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 859391, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 31497, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 347286610, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.9090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 122121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12212.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.2727272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 65721, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4694.357142857143, "stage_move_gen_ns": 665968900, "stage_ordering_ns": 211230, "stage_eval_ns": 7073545450, "stage_threat_ns": 3575816134, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 532963, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3133157362, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 179101, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 266476, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 374908237, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 532952, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67571434, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 495, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5105, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4009.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4737.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7841, "avg_search_time_ms": 784.1, "search_nodes": 52756, "safety_nodes": 953, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53709, "avg_nodes": 5370.9, "eval_calls": 32325, "avg_eval_calls": 3232.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32325, "pattern_eval_ns": 719111, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.24627996906419, "pattern_frame_queries": 32325, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 719111, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.24627996906419, "pattern_frame_updates": 105404, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1195032535, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11337.639321088383, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18336, "avg_candidate_generations": 1833.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1576258, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.96520506108203, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 739, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 18326, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1575519, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 965186, "avg_legality_checks": 96518.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 526, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 965186, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 526, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2381195, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 238119.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5180481883, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2175.580699186753, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14616, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1461.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 59944100, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4101.265736179529, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 730, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7490053, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3634, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33728669, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10252, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18725378, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 101105, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10110.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1088537093, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10766.402185846397, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 143611, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14361.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 537114336, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3740.064034092096, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2429462731, "stage_ordering_ns": 660533672, "stage_eval_ns": 1195751646, "stage_threat_ns": 3508795038, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 330653, "root_tactical_annotations": 951, "search_tactical_annotations": 329702, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 105414, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 654848245, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 291621, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2749604317, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36726, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1352264874, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52702, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81801260, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 105404, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13630563, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 54326, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 346503959, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 200562, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1050622454, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 75765, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8910653, "child_limit_applications": 18326, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18326, "child_cap_hits": 18326, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18326, "child_moves_before_total": 1574993, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1574993, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 211464, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 211464, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.94308632543927, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.539015606242497, "tt_hits": 8168, "tt_cutoffs": 2052, "beta_cutoffs": 14456, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 5.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4231.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5031.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1619, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 932, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18485, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 141, 99, 129, 86, 140, 154, 142, 54, 69, 143, 127, 157, 156, 171, 97, 82, 111, 96, 83, 55, 125 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 16896, "avg_search_time_ms": 1408.0, "search_nodes": 156427, "safety_nodes": 719, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 157146, "avg_nodes": 13095.5, "eval_calls": 99479, "avg_eval_calls": 8289.916666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 99479, "pattern_eval_ns": 2104836, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.158596286653463, "pattern_frame_queries": 99479, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2104836, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.158596286653463, "pattern_frame_updates": 312726, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4644217044, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14850.754475163561, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52729, "avg_candidate_generations": 4394.083333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4708626, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.29860228716646, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 887, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 52717, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4707739, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1125529, "avg_legality_checks": 93794.08333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2774, "root_legality_checks": 887, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1124642, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2772, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4575753, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 381312.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9887591861, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2160.866607310316, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58833, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4902.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 459272086, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7806.368636649499, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3187, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 32513271, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 32971, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 314608630, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22655, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 112000214, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 149971, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 120275, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10022.916666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1158891322, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9635.3466805238, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 168180, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14015.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 551930101, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3281.7820252110832, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2684332491, "stage_ordering_ns": 1844418764, "stage_eval_ns": 4646321880, "stage_threat_ns": 7665479098, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 941478, "root_tactical_annotations": 2532, "search_tactical_annotations": 938946, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 312738, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1833461137, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 719577, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5514131474, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 105521, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3824490397, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 156363, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 230804753, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 312726, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38929667, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 247724, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 398279615, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 366322, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1290840370, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 327432, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 48152067, "child_limit_applications": 52717, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52717, "child_cap_hits": 52717, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52717, "child_moves_before_total": 4704967, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4704967, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 602790, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 602790, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.24952102737258, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.434451884591308, "tt_hits": 31606, "tt_cutoffs": 4167, "beta_cutoffs": 44183, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3174.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3770.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 493, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1579, "avg_search_time_ms": 143.54545454545453, "search_nodes": 53783, "safety_nodes": 1057, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 54840, "avg_nodes": 4985.454545454545, "eval_calls": 51085, "avg_eval_calls": 4644.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51085, "pattern_eval_ns": 1073746, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.0188117842811, "pattern_frame_queries": 51085, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1073746, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.0188117842811, "pattern_frame_updates": 107502, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 840864760, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7821.852244609403, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2677, "avg_candidate_generations": 243.36363636363637, "candidate_moves_total": 200622, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.94284646992902, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 807, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 2666, "search_candidate_moves_total": 199815, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 7120, "avg_legality_checks": 647.2727272727273, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7120, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 195039, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17730.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 472171152, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2420.906341808561, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1863, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 169.36363636363637, "renju_forbidden_ns": 17763986, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9535.150831991412, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 36550, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1842, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17591985, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 135451, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19738649, "stage_ordering_ns": 89161, "stage_eval_ns": 841938506, "stage_threat_ns": 695798610, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 107513, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 611773931, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 247011, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11830, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 53751, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 70791279, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 107502, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12986389, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 132, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2435, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5975.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6702.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 933, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21206, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 84, 82, 140, 97, 127, 66, 114, 52, 67, 80, 94, 79, 81, 50, 34, 53, 54, 38, 24, 69, 83, 37, 85, 51, 49, 65, 93, 23 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 10969, "avg_search_time_ms": 731.2666666666667, "search_nodes": 312988, "safety_nodes": 89, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 313077, "avg_nodes": 20871.8, "eval_calls": 303479, "avg_eval_calls": 20231.933333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 303479, "pattern_eval_ns": 6145344, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.249651540963296, "pattern_frame_queries": 303479, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6145344, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.249651540963296, "pattern_frame_updates": 625890, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6496076987, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10378.943563565483, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9481, "avg_candidate_generations": 632.0666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 759406, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.09766902225503, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1101, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 9466, "search_candidate_moves_total": 758305, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 292144, "avg_legality_checks": 19476.266666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "root_legality_checks": 1101, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 291043, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2127760, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 141850.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4637645610, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2179.590560025567, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26813, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1787.5333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 169152226, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6308.590086898146, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 184, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1259054, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26622, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 167833842, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 59330, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 661368626, "stage_ordering_ns": 325742, "stage_eval_ns": 6502222331, "stage_threat_ns": 3754560823, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 625905, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3287286089, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 31260, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 312945, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 396773886, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 625890, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 70469588, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 995, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7966, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5504.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6037.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 10221, "avg_search_time_ms": 730.0714285714286, "search_nodes": 84791, "safety_nodes": 1354, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 86145, "avg_nodes": 6153.214285714285, "eval_calls": 53828, "avg_eval_calls": 3844.8571428571427, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53828, "pattern_eval_ns": 1126015, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.918759753288253, "pattern_frame_queries": 53828, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1126015, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.918759753288253, "pattern_frame_updates": 169422, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1760903144, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10393.592001038825, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28830, "avg_candidate_generations": 2059.285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 2368595, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.15730142212972, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1029, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 28816, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2367566, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 1421749, "avg_legality_checks": 101553.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1520, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1421749, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1520, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3370427, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 240744.7857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6556179348, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1945.2073425711342, "renju_forbidden_checks": 53028, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3787.714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 137402028, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2591.122199592668, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2397, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18237118, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11969, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60423536, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 38655, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 58679913, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61461, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 121345, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8667.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1035103560, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8530.253080060984, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 175489, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12534.92857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 469040891, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2672.7651932599765, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3185002190, "stage_ordering_ns": 886604851, "stage_eval_ns": 1762029159, "stage_threat_ns": 4319969510, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 481895, "root_tactical_annotations": 976, "search_tactical_annotations": 480919, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169436, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 953855119, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 462968, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3218246915, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 57740, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1774401435, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84711, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 119449705, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169422, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20105374, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 102095, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 307109987, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 303124, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1136460003, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76676, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8312397, "child_limit_applications": 28816, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28816, "child_cap_hits": 28816, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28816, "child_moves_before_total": 2366046, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2366046, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 259212, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 259212, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.10875902276513, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.99541921154914, "tt_hits": 9659, "tt_cutoffs": 2069, "beta_cutoffs": 21855, "depth_sum": 78, "avg_depth": 5.571428571428571, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 78, "avg_effective_depth": 5.571428571428571, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5230.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5801.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 934, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28633, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 126, 82, 142, 94, 141, 81, 156, 111, 158, 174, 83, 114, 130, 66, 50, 70, 56, 113, 115, 67, 186, 171, 144, 172, 143, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 22348, "avg_search_time_ms": 1596.2857142857142, "search_nodes": 199884, "safety_nodes": 713, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 200597, "avg_nodes": 14328.357142857143, "eval_calls": 127323, "avg_eval_calls": 9094.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 127323, "pattern_eval_ns": 2658416, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.879306959465296, "pattern_frame_queries": 127323, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2658416, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.879306959465296, "pattern_frame_updates": 399606, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5707574405, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14283.004772200618, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 65630, "avg_candidate_generations": 4687.857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 6174073, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.07394484229773, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1156, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 65616, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6172917, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 1786871, "avg_legality_checks": 127633.64285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4774, "root_legality_checks": 1156, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1785715, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4772, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6096567, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 435469.0714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13144565750, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2156.060246692934, "renju_forbidden_checks": 101278, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7234.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 644801674, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6366.650940974348, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6225, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 57311313, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 51167, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 411528478, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 43848, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 175581483, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 380400, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 166871, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11919.357142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1598847368, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9581.337488239418, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 233118, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16651.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 738888395, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3169.5896284285213, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4292250086, "stage_ordering_ns": 2326427668, "stage_eval_ns": 5710232821, "stage_threat_ns": 9943930117, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1423447, "root_tactical_annotations": 3719, "search_tactical_annotations": 1419728, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 399620, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2337185809, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1113885, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7200391191, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 131341, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4705680711, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 199803, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 295065214, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 399606, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49252931, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 362194, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 460392311, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 620341, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2034015749, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 440912, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 62034972, "child_limit_applications": 65616, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 65616, "child_cap_hits": 65616, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 65616, "child_moves_before_total": 6168145, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6168145, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 837985, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 837985, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 94.00367288466228, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.771046695927822, "tt_hits": 38561, "tt_cutoffs": 6867, "beta_cutoffs": 53818, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1730.2857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2138.214285714286, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6269, "avg_search_time_ms": 447.7857142857143, "search_nodes": 183308, "safety_nodes": 1703, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 185011, "avg_nodes": 13215.07142857143, "eval_calls": 179294, "avg_eval_calls": 12806.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 179294, "pattern_eval_ns": 3642976, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.318449027853692, "pattern_frame_queries": 179294, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3642976, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.318449027853692, "pattern_frame_updates": 366536, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3898417367, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10635.83759030491, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3988, "avg_candidate_generations": 284.85714285714283, "candidate_moves_total": 339615, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.15922768304915, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1184, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 3974, "search_candidate_moves_total": 338431, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 7185, "avg_legality_checks": 513.2142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7185, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1081234, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 77231.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2475144341, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2289.1847102477354, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24054, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1718.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 192158031, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7988.610251933151, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 233281, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23978, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 191401928, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 522822, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19626229, "stage_ordering_ns": 129640, "stage_eval_ns": 3902060343, "stage_threat_ns": 2324173777, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 366550, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2036944568, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 289761, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14010, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 183268, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 243912525, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 366536, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43026923, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 169, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3679, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6136.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6708.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 935, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30603, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 128, 64, 113, 157, 172, 143, 83, 68, 111, 69, 125, 139, 140, 80, 48, 155, 156, 124, 141, 70, 126, 67, 171 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8935, "avg_search_time_ms": 687.3076923076923, "search_nodes": 227520, "safety_nodes": 1090, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 228610, "avg_nodes": 17585.384615384617, "eval_calls": 222254, "avg_eval_calls": 17096.46153846154, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 222254, "pattern_eval_ns": 4517793, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.32716171587463, "pattern_frame_queries": 222254, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4517793, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.32716171587463, "pattern_frame_updates": 454964, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5462813812, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12007.13421721279, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5241, "avg_candidate_generations": 403.15384615384613, "candidate_moves_total": 386619, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.76817401259302, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 956, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 5228, "search_candidate_moves_total": 385663, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 206535, "avg_legality_checks": 15887.307692307691, "illegal_moves_skipped": 92, "root_legality_checks": 956, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 205579, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 89, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1608947, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 123765.15384615384, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3823594123, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2376.4574737390353, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23797, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1830.5384615384614, "renju_forbidden_ns": 148552327, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6242.481279152835, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 308, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1311297, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23462, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 147066970, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 174060, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8461538461538463, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 537201, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10744.02, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.538461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 278080, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3862.222222222222, "stage_move_gen_ns": 510259480, "stage_ordering_ns": 182382, "stage_eval_ns": 5467331605, "stage_threat_ns": 2938590048, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 454977, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2573973055, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 783263, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 227482, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 309208269, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 454964, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 54625461, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 258, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4675, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4777.538461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5392.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 313, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 21654, "avg_search_time_ms": 1665.6923076923076, "search_nodes": 151492, "safety_nodes": 524, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 152016, "avg_nodes": 11693.538461538461, "eval_calls": 95059, "avg_eval_calls": 7312.2307692307695, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 95059, "pattern_eval_ns": 2010261, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.147508389526504, "pattern_frame_queries": 95059, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2010261, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.147508389526504, "pattern_frame_updates": 302840, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3241987056, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10705.280200766081, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 51661, "avg_candidate_generations": 3973.923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 4593846, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.92290122142428, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 992, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 51648, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4592854, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 3145241, "avg_legality_checks": 241941.61538461538, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8572, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3145241, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8572, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7122352, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 547873.2307692308, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14264905919, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2002.836411202367, "renju_forbidden_checks": 144202, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11092.461538461539, "renju_forbidden_ns": 387702570, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2688.607439563945, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 19097, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 114347021, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 31277, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 112035900, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 93801, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 161088535, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 231114, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 269842, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 20757.076923076922, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2748662122, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10186.190889483476, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 389390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 29953.076923076922, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1415162280, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3634.305657566964, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7386478638, "stage_ordering_ns": 1771851934, "stage_eval_ns": 3243997317, "stage_threat_ns": 9139086602, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 974067, "root_tactical_annotations": 4013, "search_tactical_annotations": 970054, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 302853, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1820006382, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 822202, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7022411689, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 103393, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3618371174, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 151420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 226321582, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 302840, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37997558, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 281254, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1408604077, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 437545, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1995335887, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 255268, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32349391, "child_limit_applications": 51648, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 51648, "child_cap_hits": 51648, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 51648, "child_moves_before_total": 4584282, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4584282, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 571641, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 571641, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.76010687732342, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.06801812267658, "tt_hits": 28149, "tt_cutoffs": 4716, "beta_cutoffs": 40766, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 5.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1835.3076923076924, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2173.6923076923076, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 936, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16540, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 99, 128, 144, 129, 130, 126, 125, 111, 141, 95, 143, 81, 66, 79, 63, 80, 64, 82, 78, 83 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 15819, "avg_search_time_ms": 1318.25, "search_nodes": 185970, "safety_nodes": 222, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 186192, "avg_nodes": 15516.0, "eval_calls": 119024, "avg_eval_calls": 9918.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 119024, "pattern_eval_ns": 2375069, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.95453858045436, "pattern_frame_queries": 119024, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2375069, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.95453858045436, "pattern_frame_updates": 371812, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3973292848, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10686.29535356578, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 62774, "avg_candidate_generations": 5231.166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 4623347, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.65066747379488, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 62762, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4622613, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1267475, "avg_legality_checks": 105622.91666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1386, "root_legality_checks": 734, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1266741, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1386, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5030537, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 419211.4166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9316600222, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1852.0090841196477, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37677, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3139.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 131303063, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3484.9659739363537, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1576, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9195482, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18758, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 88376913, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17343, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 33730668, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 125728, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10477.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 900603191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7163.107589399338, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 165200, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13766.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 366678135, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2219.6013014527844, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2670448360, "stage_ordering_ns": 1629482391, "stage_eval_ns": 3975667917, "stage_threat_ns": 7483978508, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1053829, "root_tactical_annotations": 3546, "search_tactical_annotations": 1050283, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 371824, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1867506301, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 762226, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5286423055, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 125611, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3891571158, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185906, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 240837362, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 371812, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40701991, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 222214, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 216908521, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 414390, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1177858986, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 417225, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 48509799, "child_limit_applications": 62762, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 62762, "child_cap_hits": 62762, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 62762, "child_moves_before_total": 4621227, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4621227, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 728330, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 728330, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.63097096969504, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.604633376884102, "tt_hits": 38503, "tt_cutoffs": 4120, "beta_cutoffs": 50365, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1813.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2479.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 621, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 710, "avg_search_time_ms": 64.54545454545455, "search_nodes": 25142, "safety_nodes": 888, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 26030, "avg_nodes": 2366.3636363636365, "eval_calls": 23851, "avg_eval_calls": 2168.2727272727275, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23851, "pattern_eval_ns": 468962, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.662152530292232, "pattern_frame_queries": 23851, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 468962, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.662152530292232, "pattern_frame_updates": 50220, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 388935096, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7744.625567502987, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1270, "avg_candidate_generations": 115.45454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 83926, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.08346456692914, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 670, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 1259, "search_candidate_moves_total": 83256, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 3671, "avg_legality_checks": 333.72727272727275, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3671, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 123954, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11268.545454545454, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 237947287, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1919.6418590767544, "renju_forbidden_checks": 473, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 43.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3758275, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7945.61310782241, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 473, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 3758275, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8828967, "stage_ordering_ns": 40051, "stage_eval_ns": 389404058, "stage_threat_ns": 300435515, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 50231, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 263566007, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 223532, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9151, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 25110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 31138836, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 50220, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5507140, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1130, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6076.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6803.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1956, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 937, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26217, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 126, 70, 127, 108, 109, 125, 99, 85, 129, 130, 84, 114, 97, 146, 162, 100, 115, 81, 143, 101, 131, 83, 145, 161, 173, 158, 159, 117, 187 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 4422, "avg_search_time_ms": 276.375, "search_nodes": 159042, "safety_nodes": 1718, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 160760, "avg_nodes": 10047.5, "eval_calls": 154012, "avg_eval_calls": 9625.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 154012, "pattern_eval_ns": 2898828, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.82209178505571, "pattern_frame_queries": 154012, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2898828, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.82209178505571, "pattern_frame_updates": 317990, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2668131135, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8390.613336897386, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4999, "avg_candidate_generations": 312.4375, "candidate_moves_total": 356110, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.23624724944989, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1185, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4983, "search_candidate_moves_total": 354925, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 149705, "avg_legality_checks": 9356.5625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 1185, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 148520, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1097575, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 68598.4375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1826503800, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1664.1266428262306, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11448, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 715.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57149045, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4992.054944095038, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13460, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11434, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57126394, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9191, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 525371, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7726.044117647059, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 254531, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2797.043956043956, "stage_move_gen_ns": 261001635, "stage_ordering_ns": 150840, "stage_eval_ns": 2671029963, "stage_threat_ns": 1455049080, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 318006, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1263850547, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 765681, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 158995, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 162211284, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 317990, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28221568, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 188, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4553, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6163.6875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6663.6875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1870, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 21780, "avg_search_time_ms": 1361.25, "search_nodes": 207875, "safety_nodes": 426, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 208301, "avg_nodes": 13018.8125, "eval_calls": 129357, "avg_eval_calls": 8084.8125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 129357, "pattern_eval_ns": 2548820, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.70376554805693, "pattern_frame_queries": 129357, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2548820, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.70376554805693, "pattern_frame_updates": 415562, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2945199335, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7087.268169370635, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 73474, "avg_candidate_generations": 4592.125, "candidate_moves_total": 6584000, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.60993004328061, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1222, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 73458, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6582778, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 4792249, "avg_legality_checks": 299515.5625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1321, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4792249, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1321, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9580414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 598775.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14467689008, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1510.1319220651633, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37951, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2371.9375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60561744, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1595.7878316776896, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1545, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8327394, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6702, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29891324, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29704, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22343026, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 309327, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19332.9375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2248493090, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7268.984246444701, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 437067, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27316.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1132155061, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2590.3466997050796, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8294339913, "stage_ordering_ns": 1871087293, "stage_eval_ns": 2947748155, "stage_threat_ns": 8490035751, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1349137, "root_tactical_annotations": 4857, "search_tactical_annotations": 1344280, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 415578, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1837718565, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1054543, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6313325251, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 147041, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3435182018, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 207781, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 243649205, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 415562, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40651764, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 361597, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1294789921, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 545893, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1583314341, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 441647, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 54690966, "child_limit_applications": 73458, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 73458, "child_cap_hits": 73458, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 73458, "child_moves_before_total": 6581457, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6581457, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 779494, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 779494, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.59482969860328, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.6114242151978, "tt_hits": 43239, "tt_cutoffs": 4969, "beta_cutoffs": 60359, "depth_sum": 91, "avg_depth": 5.6875, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 91, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6875, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4837.9375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5337.0625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1777, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 938, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19911, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 143, 126, 140, 141, 156, 96, 81, 97, 95, 83, 125, 99, 100, 69, 55, 84, 70, 114, 54, 129 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 17916, "avg_search_time_ms": 1493.0, "search_nodes": 183292, "safety_nodes": 222, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 183514, "avg_nodes": 15292.833333333334, "eval_calls": 117150, "avg_eval_calls": 9762.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 117150, "pattern_eval_ns": 2446508, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.883551002987623, "pattern_frame_queries": 117150, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2446508, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.883551002987623, "pattern_frame_updates": 366456, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4572842267, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12478.557499399654, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 61772, "avg_candidate_generations": 5147.666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 4550283, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.66254937512142, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 61760, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4549549, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 1216355, "avg_legality_checks": 101362.91666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1523, "root_legality_checks": 734, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1215621, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1523, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4919000, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 409916.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10562679573, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2147.3225397438505, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38559, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3213.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 166120746, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4308.222360538396, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1654, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12452839, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19685, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 111953676, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17220, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41714231, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 123780, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10315.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1023296282, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8267.056729681693, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 162493, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13541.083333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 403943740, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2485.914716326242, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2920316457, "stage_ordering_ns": 1862814434, "stage_eval_ns": 4575288775, "stage_threat_ns": 8503668544, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1036462, "root_tactical_annotations": 3546, "search_tactical_annotations": 1032916, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 366468, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2123801387, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 754935, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6012994782, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 123607, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4406177425, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 183228, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 267433757, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 366456, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46080364, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 215810, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 256691233, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 415507, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1349993423, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 405145, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 53358254, "child_limit_applications": 61760, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 61760, "child_cap_hits": 61760, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 61760, "child_moves_before_total": 4548026, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4548026, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 714034, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 714034, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.64031735751296, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.56143134715026, "tt_hits": 37876, "tt_cutoffs": 4319, "beta_cutoffs": 49685, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1127.1666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1638.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1984, "avg_search_time_ms": 180.36363636363637, "search_nodes": 61763, "safety_nodes": 888, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 62651, "avg_nodes": 5695.545454545455, "eval_calls": 59607, "avg_eval_calls": 5418.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 59607, "pattern_eval_ns": 1221738, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.496552418340126, "pattern_frame_queries": 59607, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1221738, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.496552418340126, "pattern_frame_updates": 123462, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1146020628, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9282.375370559363, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2135, "avg_candidate_generations": 194.0909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 138974, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.09320843091335, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 670, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 2124, "search_candidate_moves_total": 138304, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 4468, "avg_legality_checks": 406.1818181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4468, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 303695, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27608.636363636364, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 692028489, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2278.6956946936893, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1669, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 151.72727272727272, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13198852, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7908.239664469742, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1669, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13198852, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12173299, "stage_ordering_ns": 74890, "stage_eval_ns": 1147242366, "stage_threat_ns": 808661545, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 123473, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 710530292, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 241481, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61731, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 82827851, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 123462, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15061921, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1937, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5885.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6612.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1938, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 939, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30703, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 128, 96, 160, 111, 52, 67, 81, 143, 159, 141, 156, 144, 142, 113, 170, 184, 158, 157, 99, 125, 173, 171, 129, 155, 169, 123, 124, 139, 187, 107 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 4570, "avg_search_time_ms": 285.625, "search_nodes": 115688, "safety_nodes": 1718, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 117406, "avg_nodes": 7337.875, "eval_calls": 112202, "avg_eval_calls": 7012.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 112202, "pattern_eval_ns": 2285404, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.368656530186627, "pattern_frame_queries": 112202, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2285404, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.368656530186627, "pattern_frame_updates": 231282, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2804374870, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12125.34857879126, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3455, "avg_candidate_generations": 215.9375, "candidate_moves_total": 273460, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.14905933429812, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1185, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3439, "search_candidate_moves_total": 272275, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 108555, "avg_legality_checks": 6784.6875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 1185, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 107370, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 868739, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 54296.1875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2008992522, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2312.5386589067602, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11555, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 722.1875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 107789455, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9328.382085677196, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11110, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11545, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 107768705, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9640, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 633583, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9317.39705882353, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 301811, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3316.6043956043954, "stage_move_gen_ns": 258348968, "stage_ordering_ns": 116551, "stage_eval_ns": 2806660274, "stage_threat_ns": 1478750269, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 231298, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1295336545, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 948936, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16640, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115641, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 154925309, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 231282, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27539479, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 188, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3124, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6612.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7112.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1859, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 26118, "avg_search_time_ms": 1632.375, "search_nodes": 184440, "safety_nodes": 426, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 184866, "avg_nodes": 11554.125, "eval_calls": 112575, "avg_eval_calls": 7035.9375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 112575, "pattern_eval_ns": 2394039, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.266169220519654, "pattern_frame_queries": 112575, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2394039, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.266169220519654, "pattern_frame_updates": 368692, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3322119428, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9010.554685211504, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 67274, "avg_candidate_generations": 4204.625, "candidate_moves_total": 5930821, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.15918482623302, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1222, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 67258, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5929599, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 4422955, "avg_legality_checks": 276434.6875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 279, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4422955, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 279, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8829301, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 551831.3125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17733423519, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2008.4742290471238, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30649, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1915.5625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 58208641, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1899.201964175014, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2659844, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4033, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27208812, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26283, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28339985, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 293871, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18366.9375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2784438131, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9475.035410094906, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 416509, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26031.8125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1388182113, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3332.898239893976, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10007168077, "stage_ordering_ns": 2227534619, "stage_eval_ns": 3324513467, "stage_threat_ns": 10392767219, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1212624, "root_tactical_annotations": 4857, "search_tactical_annotations": 1207767, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 368708, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2122419960, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 954400, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7898586570, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 134641, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4360570216, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 184346, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 272888425, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 368692, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44905543, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 322389, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1381024030, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 497358, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2156933794, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 392877, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 53966721, "child_limit_applications": 67258, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 67258, "child_cap_hits": 67258, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 67258, "child_moves_before_total": 5929320, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5929320, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 704138, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 704138, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.15783995955871, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.469208123940646, "tt_hits": 39336, "tt_cutoffs": 4513, "beta_cutoffs": 55490, "depth_sum": 91, "avg_depth": 5.6875, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 91, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6875, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2415.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2790.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 940, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20713, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 96, 128, 95, 98, 94, 93, 82, 127, 125, 142, 100, 158, 174, 130, 129, 144, 67, 52, 172, 146, 162, 143, 113, 145 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 13102, "avg_search_time_ms": 1091.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 120934, "safety_nodes": 1021, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 121955, "avg_nodes": 10162.916666666666, "eval_calls": 72015, "avg_eval_calls": 6001.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72015, "pattern_eval_ns": 1456693, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.22763313198639, "pattern_frame_queries": 72015, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1456693, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.22763313198639, "pattern_frame_updates": 241732, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3032174832, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12543.539258352224, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44115, "avg_candidate_generations": 3676.25, "candidate_moves_total": 3397543, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.01559560240281, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 868, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 44103, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3396675, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 1157044, "avg_legality_checks": 96420.33333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8711, "root_legality_checks": 868, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 1156176, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8701, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3900530, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 325044.1666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7787143058, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1996.4320382101919, "renju_forbidden_checks": 59081, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4923.416666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 466623236, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7898.025355021073, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9116, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 98353453, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25046, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 255419542, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24867, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 112264439, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 585802, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 111400, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9283.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1066378737, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9572.520080789945, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 151086, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12590.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 504591645, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3339.7644057027123, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2734735523, "stage_ordering_ns": 1248244482, "stage_eval_ns": 3033631525, "stage_threat_ns": 6023463209, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 685735, "root_tactical_annotations": 1450, "search_tactical_annotations": 684285, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 241744, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1297467250, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 573514, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4508916274, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 88298, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2926282957, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 120866, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 162379952, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 241732, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27672358, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 95304, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 138735295, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 389903, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1443122658, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 200528, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 27027375, "child_limit_applications": 44103, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44103, "child_cap_hits": 44103, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44103, "child_moves_before_total": 3387974, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3387974, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 496753, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 496753, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.81958143436954, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.263474140081174, "tt_hits": 22188, "tt_cutoffs": 4750, "beta_cutoffs": 35972, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2588.4166666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3255.0833333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7601, "avg_search_time_ms": 633.4166666666666, "search_nodes": 208263, "safety_nodes": 468, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 208731, "avg_nodes": 17394.25, "eval_calls": 203437, "avg_eval_calls": 16953.083333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 203437, "pattern_eval_ns": 4118615, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.24516189287101, "pattern_frame_queries": 203437, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4118615, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.24516189287101, "pattern_frame_updates": 416458, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4945518644, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11875.19184167431, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4804, "avg_candidate_generations": 400.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 424274, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.31681931723564, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 904, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 4792, "search_candidate_moves_total": 423370, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 8101, "avg_legality_checks": 675.0833333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 64, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8101, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 64, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1216428, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 101369.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2873831396, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2362.5166438128686, "renju_forbidden_checks": 63450, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5287.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 606806374, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9563.536233254532, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 64, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 610203, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 63331, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 605578709, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 55, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 617462, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22388358, "stage_ordering_ns": 169040, "stage_eval_ns": 4949637259, "stage_threat_ns": 2605259831, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 416470, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2281013039, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 112170, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11590, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 208229, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 275030261, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 416458, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49104361, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 552, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3984, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6239.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6906.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1776, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 941, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16175, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 114, 111, 126, 140, 84, 143, 141, 127, 98, 70, 95, 145, 68, 144, 146, 175, 159, 130, 83, 53, 128 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4991, "avg_search_time_ms": 453.72727272727275, "search_nodes": 122041, "safety_nodes": 800, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122841, "avg_nodes": 11167.363636363636, "eval_calls": 118141, "avg_eval_calls": 10740.09090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 118141, "pattern_eval_ns": 2368439, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.047561811733438, "pattern_frame_queries": 118141, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2368439, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.047561811733438, "pattern_frame_updates": 244020, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3132106628, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12835.450487664946, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3880, "avg_candidate_generations": 352.72727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 279087, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.92963917525773, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 756, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 3869, "search_candidate_moves_total": 278331, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 112047, "avg_legality_checks": 10186.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 97, "root_legality_checks": 756, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 111291, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 97, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 910257, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 82750.63636363637, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2202551424, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2419.702813600994, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15719, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1429.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 145542421, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9259.012723455691, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 97, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 926583, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 144614288, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1550, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 34, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 324282, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9537.70588235294, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 47, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.2727272727272725, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 143512, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3053.446808510638, "stage_move_gen_ns": 279367866, "stage_ordering_ns": 138051, "stage_eval_ns": 3134475067, "stage_threat_ns": 1562805874, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 244031, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1370130239, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 446762, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 122010, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 163081789, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 244020, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29147084, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 249, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3451, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5376.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6103.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1786, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11171, "avg_search_time_ms": 1117.1, "search_nodes": 79968, "safety_nodes": 719, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 80687, "avg_nodes": 8068.7, "eval_calls": 47928, "avg_eval_calls": 4792.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47928, "pattern_eval_ns": 1005756, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.984727090635953, "pattern_frame_queries": 47928, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1005756, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.984727090635953, "pattern_frame_updates": 159816, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1958423285, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12254.237904840567, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29695, "avg_candidate_generations": 2969.5, "candidate_moves_total": 2283694, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.90500084189257, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 681, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 29685, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2283013, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 1457714, "avg_legality_checks": 145771.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5409, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1457714, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5409, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3429499, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 342949.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7331675862, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2137.8270884464464, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34036, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3403.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 240297520, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7060.098719003408, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5541, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 58731384, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12525, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 128661065, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15965, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 52843581, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61490, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 108335, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10833.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1027730729, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9486.599243088567, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 150387, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15038.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 479871397, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3190.910098612247, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3553581862, "stage_ordering_ns": 940802950, "stage_eval_ns": 1959429041, "stage_threat_ns": 4667292091, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 428027, "root_tactical_annotations": 1824, "search_tactical_annotations": 426203, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 159826, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 955988849, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 356857, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3552210011, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59450, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2192266766, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79908, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 122310795, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 159816, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19872486, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 73050, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 310412147, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 224349, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1049352168, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 130628, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16909950, "child_limit_applications": 29685, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29685, "child_cap_hits": 29685, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29685, "child_moves_before_total": 2277604, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2277604, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 277709, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 277709, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.72575374768401, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.3551962270507, "tt_hits": 15465, "tt_cutoffs": 2296, "beta_cutoffs": 23817, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 5.9, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 5.9, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2666.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3466.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1486, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 942, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24689, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 124, 82, 114, 98, 140, 97, 138, 152, 139, 141, 137, 136, 67, 128, 83, 81, 129, 168, 184, 127, 99, 143, 158, 95, 159, 79 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 19757, "avg_search_time_ms": 1317.1333333333334, "search_nodes": 210516, "safety_nodes": 757, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 211273, "avg_nodes": 14084.866666666667, "eval_calls": 145405, "avg_eval_calls": 9693.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 145405, "pattern_eval_ns": 2954459, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.318826725353322, "pattern_frame_queries": 145405, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2954459, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.318826725353322, "pattern_frame_updates": 420878, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5554275559, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13196.877857716489, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 60390, "avg_candidate_generations": 4026.0, "candidate_moves_total": 5077081, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.07155158138765, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1079, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 60375, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5076002, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1702539, "avg_legality_checks": 113502.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8862, "root_legality_checks": 1079, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 1701460, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8856, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6106610, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 407107.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11611862674, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1901.5235415394138, "renju_forbidden_checks": 101378, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6758.533333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 675844654, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6666.581053088441, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10108, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 102303345, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 51455, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 429182025, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 39783, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 144018732, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 340552, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 198748, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13249.866666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1614323049, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8122.461856219937, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 264540, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17636.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 703961083, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2661.0761434943674, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3718137036, "stage_ordering_ns": 1721117457, "stage_eval_ns": 5557230018, "stage_threat_ns": 8690822001, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1230846, "root_tactical_annotations": 3337, "search_tactical_annotations": 1227509, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 420893, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2199993474, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1012367, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6113974167, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 120856, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3761631395, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 210439, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 285266441, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 420878, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47516277, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 295751, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 430360529, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 595749, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1921705642, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 339346, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 44071642, "child_limit_applications": 60375, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 60375, "child_cap_hits": 60375, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 60375, "child_moves_before_total": 5067146, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5067146, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 811260, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 811260, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.92788405797101, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.437018633540372, "tt_hits": 30744, "tt_cutoffs": 4659, "beta_cutoffs": 47809, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 5.133333333333334, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 5.133333333333334, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3578.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4112.133333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 622, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 4917, "avg_search_time_ms": 351.2142857142857, "search_nodes": 149653, "safety_nodes": 1586, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 151239, "avg_nodes": 10802.785714285714, "eval_calls": 145778, "avg_eval_calls": 10412.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 145778, "pattern_eval_ns": 2926622, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.075882506276667, "pattern_frame_queries": 145778, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2926622, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.075882506276667, "pattern_frame_updates": 299224, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3002598165, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10034.61675868246, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3848, "avg_candidate_generations": 274.85714285714283, "candidate_moves_total": 284244, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.86798336798337, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1002, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 3834, "search_candidate_moves_total": 283242, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 6984, "avg_legality_checks": 498.85714285714283, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6984, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 783287, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 55949.07142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1776625268, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2268.1664166518785, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16219, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1158.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 163470231, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10078.934027991862, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 210291, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16161, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 162852156, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 407784, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18429780, "stage_ordering_ns": 119700, "stage_eval_ns": 3005524787, "stage_threat_ns": 1876445250, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 299238, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1646896486, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 530423, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 149612, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 193736641, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 299224, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35281700, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 144, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3416, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5900.928571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6472.357142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1959, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 943, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29835, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 142, 97, 98, 126, 70, 111, 157, 172, 141, 81, 66, 113, 65, 129, 145, 144, 84, 56, 159, 158, 130, 143, 64, 128, 67, 173 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8019, "avg_search_time_ms": 616.8461538461538, "search_nodes": 224036, "safety_nodes": 1090, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 225126, "avg_nodes": 17317.384615384617, "eval_calls": 218879, "avg_eval_calls": 16836.846153846152, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 218879, "pattern_eval_ns": 4532589, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.708194938756115, "pattern_frame_queries": 218879, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4532589, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.708194938756115, "pattern_frame_updates": 447996, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4932343549, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11009.793723604675, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5132, "avg_candidate_generations": 394.7692307692308, "candidate_moves_total": 378292, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.71239282930631, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 956, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 5119, "search_candidate_moves_total": 377336, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 203339, "avg_legality_checks": 15641.461538461539, "illegal_moves_skipped": 92, "root_legality_checks": 956, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 202383, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 89, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1584356, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 121873.53846153847, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3451382345, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2178.413402669602, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20912, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1608.6153846153845, "renju_forbidden_ns": 126438031, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6046.195055470544, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 142, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 961646, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20743, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 125291524, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 184861, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8461538461538463, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 557052, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11141.04, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.538461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 290460, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4034.1666666666665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 449073472, "stage_ordering_ns": 184540, "stage_eval_ns": 4936876138, "stage_threat_ns": 2594851657, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 448009, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2266034758, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 801113, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13150, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 223998, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 278719017, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 447996, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49296769, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 258, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4573, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5251.307692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5866.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1465, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 21802, "avg_search_time_ms": 1677.076923076923, "search_nodes": 146234, "safety_nodes": 524, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 146758, "avg_nodes": 11289.076923076924, "eval_calls": 91971, "avg_eval_calls": 7074.692307692308, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 91971, "pattern_eval_ns": 2060471, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.403485881419144, "pattern_frame_queries": 91971, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2060471, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.403485881419144, "pattern_frame_updates": 292318, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3145414556, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10760.249303840339, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49840, "avg_candidate_generations": 3833.846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 4465522, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.59715088282503, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 992, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 49827, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4464530, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 3078397, "avg_legality_checks": 236799.76923076922, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8177, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3078397, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8177, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6906903, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 531300.2307692308, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14472101153, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2095.309743455207, "renju_forbidden_checks": 98583, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7583.307692307692, "renju_forbidden_ns": 314163757, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3186.794447318503, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10647, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 95691386, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14826, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 91850819, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 73083, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 126378951, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 242601, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 264804, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 20369.53846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2804046005, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10589.137645201734, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 382541, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 29426.23076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1443754282, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3774.1164528769464, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7552421211, "stage_ordering_ns": 1797670762, "stage_eval_ns": 3147475027, "stage_threat_ns": 9185731166, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 933147, "root_tactical_annotations": 3931, "search_tactical_annotations": 929216, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 292331, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1798965180, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 792767, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7092285414, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 99754, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3616993355, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 146159, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 224370153, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 292318, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37864311, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 266949, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1440958351, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 426054, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2034248398, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 240144, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32246108, "child_limit_applications": 49827, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49827, "child_cap_hits": 49827, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49827, "child_moves_before_total": 4456353, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4456353, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 555207, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 555207, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.43651032572701, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.142693720272142, "tt_hits": 26630, "tt_cutoffs": 4363, "beta_cutoffs": 39420, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 5.538461538461538, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 5.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1829.6923076923076, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2159.769230769231, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 944, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21455, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 98, 68, 54, 142, 126, 84, 140, 154, 125, 128, 100, 83, 99, 101, 85, 170, 156, 80, 81, 124, 110, 113, 70, 115, 86, 38, 53, 52, 95, 155, 67, 109, 39 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 16299, "avg_search_time_ms": 905.5, "search_nodes": 218095, "safety_nodes": 1321, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 219416, "avg_nodes": 12189.777777777777, "eval_calls": 139218, "avg_eval_calls": 7734.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 139218, "pattern_eval_ns": 2778453, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.957570141792008, "pattern_frame_queries": 139218, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2778453, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.957570141792008, "pattern_frame_updates": 435986, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3942428671, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9042.55795140211, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 72130, "avg_candidate_generations": 4007.222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 6256481, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.73895743795924, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1427, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 72112, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6255054, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 2057134, "avg_legality_checks": 114285.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3499, "root_legality_checks": 1427, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2055707, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3499, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6497227, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 360957.05555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9437933434, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1452.609464622369, "renju_forbidden_checks": 70265, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3903.6111111111113, "renju_forbidden_ns": 230571151, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3281.4509499750943, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4092, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22275272, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29486, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 146102378, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 36684, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 62189591, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3910, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 175798, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9766.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1049168695, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5968.035444089239, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 245301, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13627.833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 484052406, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1973.2997664094316, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3311616710, "stage_ordering_ns": 1672204287, "stage_eval_ns": 3945207124, "stage_threat_ns": 7258357304, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1438696, "root_tactical_annotations": 3966, "search_tactical_annotations": 1434730, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 436004, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1798484015, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1179301, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5129744283, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 144361, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3448915149, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 217993, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 242582551, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 435986, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40415019, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 411934, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 215657370, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 622992, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1464633921, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 403770, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 47131436, "child_limit_applications": 72112, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 72112, "child_cap_hits": 72112, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 72112, "child_moves_before_total": 6251555, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6251555, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 828068, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 828068, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.69229809185711, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.483081872642556, "tt_hits": 40009, "tt_cutoffs": 6663, "beta_cutoffs": 57259, "depth_sum": 102, "avg_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 102, "avg_effective_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5046.611111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5491.055555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 486, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 5139, "avg_search_time_ms": 302.29411764705884, "search_nodes": 247233, "safety_nodes": 1762, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 248995, "avg_nodes": 14646.764705882353, "eval_calls": 240661, "avg_eval_calls": 14156.529411764706, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 240661, "pattern_eval_ns": 4770520, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.82257199961772, "pattern_frame_queries": 240661, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4770520, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.82257199961772, "pattern_frame_updates": 494366, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2864219172, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5793.722003535842, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6539, "avg_candidate_generations": 384.6470588235294, "candidate_moves_total": 534383, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.72243462303105, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1346, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 6522, "search_candidate_moves_total": 533037, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 16545, "avg_legality_checks": 973.2352941176471, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 16545, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1057807, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 62223.94117647059, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1575404853, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1489.312183602491, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9502, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 558.9411764705883, "renju_forbidden_ns": 49790313, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5239.982424752684, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9502, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 49790313, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 32818164, "stage_ordering_ns": 217430, "stage_eval_ns": 2868989692, "stage_threat_ns": 2175698248, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 494383, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1890068930, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 47, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 244830, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 247183, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 241436687, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 494366, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43947801, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 328, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5942, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6396.64705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6867.235294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 945, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18522, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 126, 98, 154, 113, 52, 67, 83, 141, 155, 143, 158, 140, 142, 111, 174, 190, 156, 157, 95, 129, 171, 101, 115, 131, 130, 99, 152, 85 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 2844, "avg_search_time_ms": 189.6, "search_nodes": 111391, "safety_nodes": 1472, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 112863, "avg_nodes": 7524.2, "eval_calls": 108120, "avg_eval_calls": 7208.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 108120, "pattern_eval_ns": 2096846, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.393692193858676, "pattern_frame_queries": 108120, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2096846, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.393692193858676, "pattern_frame_updates": 222694, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1754884156, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7880.248933514149, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3242, "avg_candidate_generations": 216.13333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 256536, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.12893275755707, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1126, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 3227, "search_candidate_moves_total": 255410, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 101306, "avg_legality_checks": 6753.733333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 1126, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 100180, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 830312, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 55354.13333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1195407874, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1439.7092586883002, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11758, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 783.8666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62766831, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5338.22342235074, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 39371, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11732, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62664070, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 63390, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 436181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7520.362068965517, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 77, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.133333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 207080, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2689.3506493506493, "stage_move_gen_ns": 153889166, "stage_ordering_ns": 104421, "stage_eval_ns": 1756981002, "stage_threat_ns": 902419406, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 222709, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 780400244, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 664841, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10200, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111347, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 103063941, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 222694, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18290380, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 184, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2917, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6565.266666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7098.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1882, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 15664, "avg_search_time_ms": 1044.2666666666667, "search_nodes": 192428, "safety_nodes": 441, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 192869, "avg_nodes": 12857.933333333332, "eval_calls": 123155, "avg_eval_calls": 8210.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 123155, "pattern_eval_ns": 2412018, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.585221874873127, "pattern_frame_queries": 123155, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2412018, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.585221874873127, "pattern_frame_updates": 384682, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2300507515, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5980.283753853832, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 64748, "avg_candidate_generations": 4316.533333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 5743095, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.69918761969481, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1171, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 64733, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5741924, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 4171521, "avg_legality_checks": 278101.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 336, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4171521, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 336, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8367006, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 557800.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10149025886, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1212.9817865554298, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25520, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1701.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33411774, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1309.2387931034482, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 386, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1776791, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4172, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17877270, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20942, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13622272, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 135441, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 254091, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16939.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1470521590, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5787.381646732863, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 358625, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23908.333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 737633975, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2056.8392471244338, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5708510052, "stage_ordering_ns": 1316479776, "stage_eval_ns": 2302919533, "stage_threat_ns": 6174172319, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1157148, "root_tactical_annotations": 4263, "search_tactical_annotations": 1152885, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 384697, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1411660856, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 875566, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4486129101, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 129582, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2575693095, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 192341, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 196021224, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 384682, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32260839, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 293616, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 815172427, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 452357, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1095224979, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 411175, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 48100299, "child_limit_applications": 64733, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 64733, "child_cap_hits": 64733, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 64733, "child_moves_before_total": 5741588, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5741588, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 686394, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 686394, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.69646084686327, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.60346345758732, "tt_hits": 39812, "tt_cutoffs": 4453, "beta_cutoffs": 52489, "depth_sum": 87, "avg_depth": 5.8, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 87, "avg_effective_depth": 5.8, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5624.466666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6157.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1717, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 946, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19370, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 127, 142, 126, 156, 114, 82, 98, 140, 113, 170, 184, 155, 125, 185, 200, 115, 96, 99, 129, 81, 168, 152, 111, 83, 95, 94, 79, 143, 63 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 16705, "avg_search_time_ms": 1113.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 192403, "safety_nodes": 757, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 193160, "avg_nodes": 12877.333333333334, "eval_calls": 132794, "avg_eval_calls": 8852.933333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 132794, "pattern_eval_ns": 2669243, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.100629546515655, "pattern_frame_queries": 132794, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2669243, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.100629546515655, "pattern_frame_updates": 384652, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4495089830, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11686.12103927706, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 55181, "avg_candidate_generations": 3678.733333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4560974, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.65479059821315, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1079, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 55166, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4559895, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1623301, "avg_legality_checks": 108220.06666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6216, "root_legality_checks": 1079, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 1622222, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6210, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5581288, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 372085.86666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9910795912, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1775.7184205509552, "renju_forbidden_checks": 69423, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4628.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 383392201, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5522.553058784552, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6856, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 59620655, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33622, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 229653923, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28913, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 93812822, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 304801, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 175347, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11689.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1306207005, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7449.2691919451145, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 235319, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15687.933333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 548371388, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2330.331966394554, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3267671521, "stage_ordering_ns": 1497422386, "stage_eval_ns": 4497759073, "stage_threat_ns": 7370975484, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1044802, "root_tactical_annotations": 3337, "search_tactical_annotations": 1041465, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 384667, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1859524303, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 831577, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5183995552, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 110438, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3268421048, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 192326, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 246100137, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 384652, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41633607, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 248582, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 332628362, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 472546, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1582605040, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 323674, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 39721885, "child_limit_applications": 55166, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 55166, "child_cap_hits": 55166, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 55166, "child_moves_before_total": 4553685, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4553685, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 693895, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 693895, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.5451364971178, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.578309103433273, "tt_hits": 29965, "tt_cutoffs": 4366, "beta_cutoffs": 42692, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 5.133333333333334, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 5.133333333333334, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5194.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5727.466666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1716, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2649, "avg_search_time_ms": 189.21428571428572, "search_nodes": 86437, "safety_nodes": 1587, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 88024, "avg_nodes": 6287.428571428572, "eval_calls": 83709, "avg_eval_calls": 5979.214285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83709, "pattern_eval_ns": 1670555, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.95669521795745, "pattern_frame_queries": 83709, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1670555, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.95669521795745, "pattern_frame_updates": 172792, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1678259081, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9712.597116764666, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2701, "avg_candidate_generations": 192.92857142857142, "candidate_moves_total": 202444, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.95149944465012, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1003, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 2687, "search_candidate_moves_total": 201441, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 4861, "avg_legality_checks": 347.2142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4861, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 518426, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 37030.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1046610947, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2018.8241851296038, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11511, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 822.2142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 104305754, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9061.398140908695, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 223412, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11452, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 103711792, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 370550, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11172360, "stage_ordering_ns": 88840, "stage_eval_ns": 1679929636, "stage_threat_ns": 936647263, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 172806, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 818387476, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 539320, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86396, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99638848, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 172792, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18081619, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 144, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2439, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6409.071428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6980.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1982, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 947, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28294, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 128, 64, 127, 115, 116, 129, 125, 124, 97, 139, 83, 69, 84, 80, 48, 85, 100, 68, 99, 154, 98, 109, 101 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 6673, "avg_search_time_ms": 513.3076923076923, "search_nodes": 175435, "safety_nodes": 1090, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 176525, "avg_nodes": 13578.846153846154, "eval_calls": 170389, "avg_eval_calls": 13106.846153846154, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 170389, "pattern_eval_ns": 3458897, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.300001760677038, "pattern_frame_queries": 170389, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3458897, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.300001760677038, "pattern_frame_updates": 350794, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4034605071, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11501.351422772339, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5021, "avg_candidate_generations": 386.2307692307692, "candidate_moves_total": 367384, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.16948814977096, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 956, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 5008, "search_candidate_moves_total": 366428, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 157761, "avg_legality_checks": 12135.461538461539, "illegal_moves_skipped": 151, "root_legality_checks": 956, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 156805, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 148, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1210393, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 93107.15384615384, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2843706394, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2349.4075015304948, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19196, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1476.6153846153845, "renju_forbidden_ns": 120062398, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6254.552927693269, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 229, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1607122, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18940, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 118279055, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 176221, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8461538461538463, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 529131, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10582.62, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.538461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 275760, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3830.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 385271929, "stage_ordering_ns": 167682, "stage_eval_ns": 4038063968, "stage_threat_ns": 2225442204, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 350807, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1950630650, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 759382, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 175397, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 232453346, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 350794, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41598826, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 258, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4513, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5353.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5969.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1739, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 21608, "avg_search_time_ms": 1662.1538461538462, "search_nodes": 150937, "safety_nodes": 524, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 151461, "avg_nodes": 11650.846153846154, "eval_calls": 94848, "avg_eval_calls": 7296.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 94848, "pattern_eval_ns": 2022580, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.32443488529015, "pattern_frame_queries": 94848, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2022580, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.32443488529015, "pattern_frame_updates": 301730, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3134549884, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10388.592065754152, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 51596, "avg_candidate_generations": 3968.923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 4602266, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.19811613303357, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 992, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 51583, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4601274, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 3182000, "avg_legality_checks": 244769.23076923078, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4083, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3182000, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4083, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7167527, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 551348.2307692308, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14356279789, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2002.9613824963617, "renju_forbidden_checks": 117223, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9017.153846153846, "renju_forbidden_ns": 279524118, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2384.5501138855, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6618, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 48903557, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14616, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 75627649, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 95962, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 154763261, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 229651, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 279634, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 21510.30769230769, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2842065097, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10163.517658796856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 410153, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31550.23076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1474039845, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3593.878004061899, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7421555978, "stage_ordering_ns": 1776309961, "stage_eval_ns": 3136572464, "stage_threat_ns": 9164642169, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 988324, "root_tactical_annotations": 4013, "search_tactical_annotations": 984311, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 301743, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1801077446, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 833964, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7069046147, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 103263, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3564774022, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 150865, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 223058809, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 301730, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37930060, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 283527, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1469210474, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 447164, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2034963201, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 257633, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33529707, "child_limit_applications": 51583, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 51583, "child_cap_hits": 51583, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 51583, "child_moves_before_total": 4597191, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4597191, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 580409, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 580409, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.12221080588566, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.251943469747784, "tt_hits": 27691, "tt_cutoffs": 4435, "beta_cutoffs": 40832, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 5.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1811.3846153846155, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2153.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 948, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19678, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 141, 128, 144, 143, 158, 98, 83, 97, 99, 81, 129, 95, 94, 65, 49, 80, 64, 110, 50, 125 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 17899, "avg_search_time_ms": 1491.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 181801, "safety_nodes": 222, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 182023, "avg_nodes": 15168.583333333334, "eval_calls": 115849, "avg_eval_calls": 9654.083333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 115849, "pattern_eval_ns": 2404088, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.75190981363672, "pattern_frame_queries": 115849, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2404088, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.75190981363672, "pattern_frame_updates": 363474, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4521560718, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12439.846365902375, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 61766, "avg_candidate_generations": 5147.166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 4546325, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.60562445358288, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 61754, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4545591, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 1234775, "avg_legality_checks": 102897.91666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1437, "root_legality_checks": 734, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1234041, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1437, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4928514, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 410709.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10601492396, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2151.0525071045754, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37467, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3122.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 149195139, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3982.0412362879333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1626, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11785604, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17802, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 97119681, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18039, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40289854, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 124230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10352.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1033944131, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8322.821629236094, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 163495, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13624.583333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 413829169, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2531.142658796905, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2975759519, "stage_ordering_ns": 1863040349, "stage_eval_ns": 4523964806, "stage_threat_ns": 8491662396, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1030126, "root_tactical_annotations": 3546, "search_tactical_annotations": 1026580, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 363486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2109897164, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 755755, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6022116886, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 123595, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4401362894, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 181737, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 265791254, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 363474, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45675271, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 214736, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 253802173, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 417413, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1366816389, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 397977, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 48181821, "child_limit_applications": 61754, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 61754, "child_cap_hits": 61754, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 61754, "child_moves_before_total": 4544154, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4544154, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 711070, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 711070, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.58477183664216, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.514557761440555, "tt_hits": 37506, "tt_cutoffs": 4135, "beta_cutoffs": 49773, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4166666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1051.8333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1563.9166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1768, "avg_search_time_ms": 160.72727272727272, "search_nodes": 55652, "safety_nodes": 888, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 56540, "avg_nodes": 5140.0, "eval_calls": 53624, "avg_eval_calls": 4874.909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53624, "pattern_eval_ns": 1089217, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.312117708488735, "pattern_frame_queries": 53624, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1089217, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.312117708488735, "pattern_frame_updates": 111240, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1012372608, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9100.796548004315, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2007, "avg_candidate_generations": 182.45454545454547, "candidate_moves_total": 131150, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.3462879920279, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 670, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 1996, "search_candidate_moves_total": 130480, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 4313, "avg_legality_checks": 392.09090909090907, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4313, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 267787, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24344.272727272728, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 611813205, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2284.7009190139925, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1274, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 115.81818181818181, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9544185, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7491.510989010989, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1274, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9544185, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11695981, "stage_ordering_ns": 62740, "stage_eval_ns": 1013461825, "stage_threat_ns": 727527772, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 111251, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 639839960, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 239361, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 55620, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73858132, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 111240, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13590319, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1823, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5923.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6650.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1942, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 949, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16563, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 144, 80, 141, 143, 127, 96, 64, 99, 138, 66, 155, 169, 139, 140, 81, 108, 109, 94, 122, 52 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5205, "avg_search_time_ms": 433.75, "search_nodes": 128322, "safety_nodes": 638, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 128960, "avg_nodes": 10746.666666666666, "eval_calls": 124114, "avg_eval_calls": 10342.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 124114, "pattern_eval_ns": 2519630, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.300933013197543, "pattern_frame_queries": 124114, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2519630, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.300933013197543, "pattern_frame_updates": 256576, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3260238514, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12706.716583000749, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4186, "avg_candidate_generations": 348.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 320214, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.49641662685141, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 860, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 4174, "search_candidate_moves_total": 319354, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 116447, "avg_legality_checks": 9703.916666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 66, "root_legality_checks": 860, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 115587, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 66, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 972119, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 81009.91666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2320544699, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2387.099417869623, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17497, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1458.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 143761835, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8216.370520660685, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 630910, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17422, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 143130925, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.0833333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 235472, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9418.88, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 32, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.6666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 102060, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3189.375, "stage_move_gen_ns": 285501015, "stage_ordering_ns": 144901, "stage_eval_ns": 3262758144, "stage_threat_ns": 1640924151, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 256588, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1438397288, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 341942, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11800, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128288, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 171756558, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 256576, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30428363, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 423, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3594, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5683.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6350.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1824, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11346, "avg_search_time_ms": 1031.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 78952, "safety_nodes": 846, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 79798, "avg_nodes": 7254.363636363636, "eval_calls": 46824, "avg_eval_calls": 4256.727272727273, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46824, "pattern_eval_ns": 989194, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.125790193063388, "pattern_frame_queries": 46824, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 989194, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.125790193063388, "pattern_frame_updates": 157780, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1887218563, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11961.075947521866, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29808, "avg_candidate_generations": 2709.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2316723, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.72151771336554, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 29797, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2315937, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1520341, "avg_legality_checks": 138212.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6321, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1520341, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6321, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3507196, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 318836.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7451835064, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2124.7272932564933, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36746, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3340.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 258588716, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7037.193599303326, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6519, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 67950766, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13475, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 135069622, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16747, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 55508118, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 60210, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 113279, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10298.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1097156898, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9685.43947245297, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 158234, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14384.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 525007051, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3317.9155617629585, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3714730326, "stage_ordering_ns": 960490429, "stage_eval_ns": 1888207757, "stage_threat_ns": 4724796836, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 439267, "root_tactical_annotations": 1732, "search_tactical_annotations": 437535, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 157791, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 957230797, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 363224, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3612119546, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59678, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2181117793, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78890, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 119009164, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 157780, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20065667, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 76389, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 334885058, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 227149, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1095985223, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 135729, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16371662, "child_limit_applications": 29797, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29797, "child_cap_hits": 29797, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29797, "child_moves_before_total": 2309616, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2309616, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 280679, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 280679, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.51169580830285, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.419706681880726, "tt_hits": 15370, "tt_cutoffs": 2270, "beta_cutoffs": 23960, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3108.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3835.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1427, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 950, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 33917, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 113, 114, 128, 130, 82, 110, 96, 144, 97, 146, 162, 145, 143, 147, 148, 67, 126, 81, 83, 125, 176, 190, 141, 156, 69, 55, 64, 80, 95, 159, 127, 79, 99, 155, 85 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 28371, "avg_search_time_ms": 1576.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 276429, "safety_nodes": 1059, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 277488, "avg_nodes": 15416.0, "eval_calls": 185640, "avg_eval_calls": 10313.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 185640, "pattern_eval_ns": 3868572, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.839107950872656, "pattern_frame_queries": 185640, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3868572, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.839107950872656, "pattern_frame_updates": 552662, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7636713460, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13818.054181398395, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 84841, "avg_candidate_generations": 4713.388888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 7515544, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.58386864841292, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1432, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 84823, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7514112, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 2246898, "avg_legality_checks": 124827.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10061, "root_legality_checks": 1432, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 2245466, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10052, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7942537, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 441252.05555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16407082209, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2065.7231069871, "renju_forbidden_checks": 136248, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7569.333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 780704153, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5730.022848041806, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11594, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 111510151, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 61885, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 488496286, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 62721, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 180228134, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 469582, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 245325, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13629.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2039190858, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8312.201601956589, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 323945, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17996.944444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 836116436, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2581.044424207813, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5180882623, "stage_ordering_ns": 2816701028, "stage_eval_ns": 7640582032, "stage_threat_ns": 12653854401, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1938460, "root_tactical_annotations": 4684, "search_tactical_annotations": 1933776, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 552680, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3133883085, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1600111, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8981277657, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 169779, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5589454763, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 276331, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 403421151, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 552662, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67870554, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 465717, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 506615389, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 964601, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2884976994, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 508142, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 67401954, "child_limit_applications": 84823, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 84823, "child_cap_hits": 84823, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 84823, "child_moves_before_total": 7504060, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7504060, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 1218717, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1218717, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.4672789219905, "avg_child_moves_after": 14.367765818233263, "tt_hits": 41073, "tt_cutoffs": 5871, "beta_cutoffs": 69192, "depth_sum": 95, "avg_depth": 5.277777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 95, "avg_effective_depth": 5.277777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3888888888888889, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2733.777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3161.6111111111113, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 5528, "avg_search_time_ms": 325.1764705882353, "search_nodes": 177127, "safety_nodes": 1953, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 179080, "avg_nodes": 10534.117647058823, "eval_calls": 172839, "avg_eval_calls": 10167.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 172839, "pattern_eval_ns": 3450763, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.965187255191246, "pattern_frame_queries": 172839, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3450763, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.965187255191246, "pattern_frame_updates": 354154, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3365016908, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9501.564031466538, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4255, "avg_candidate_generations": 250.2941176470588, "candidate_moves_total": 337525, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.32432432432432, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1349, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 4238, "search_candidate_moves_total": 336176, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 7705, "avg_legality_checks": 453.2352941176471, "illegal_moves_skipped": 23, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7705, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 23, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 910559, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 53562.294117647056, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1988050372, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2183.329550309206, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18784, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1104.9411764705883, "renju_forbidden_ns": 182770254, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9730.102959965929, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 224992, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18709, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 181996961, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 548301, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19785374, "stage_ordering_ns": 134961, "stage_eval_ns": 3368467671, "stage_threat_ns": 2119161864, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 354171, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1856925969, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 546010, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 177077, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 221178146, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 354154, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40511739, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 148, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3837, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6240.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6710.588235294118, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 951, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13987, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 82, 98, 143, 126, 140, 96, 95, 111, 141, 81, 66, 70, 84, 100, 99, 139, 125, 110, 173, 158, 157, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5666, "avg_search_time_ms": 472.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 170780, "safety_nodes": 814, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 171594, "avg_nodes": 14299.5, "eval_calls": 165242, "avg_eval_calls": 13770.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 165242, "pattern_eval_ns": 3231405, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.55559119352223, "pattern_frame_queries": 165242, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3231405, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.55559119352223, "pattern_frame_updates": 341490, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3474892731, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10175.679320038655, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5515, "avg_candidate_generations": 459.5833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 356631, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.66563916591114, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 724, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 5503, "search_candidate_moves_total": 355907, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 159578, "avg_legality_checks": 13298.166666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 724, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 158854, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1221662, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 101805.16666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2510628033, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2055.092188346695, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9579, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 798.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65913151, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6881.005428541602, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 203700, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9555, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 65709451, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 315370, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8760.277777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.8333333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 131980, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2869.1304347826085, "stage_move_gen_ns": 326147317, "stage_ordering_ns": 169690, "stage_eval_ns": 3478124136, "stage_threat_ns": 1835442013, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 341502, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1603421497, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 428261, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 170745, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 196530924, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 341490, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35061331, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 261, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4972, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5602.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6269.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1921, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8310, "avg_search_time_ms": 692.5, "search_nodes": 79538, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 80351, "avg_nodes": 6695.916666666667, "eval_calls": 45337, "avg_eval_calls": 3778.0833333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 45337, "pattern_eval_ns": 919374, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.278668637095528, "pattern_frame_queries": 45337, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 919374, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.278668637095528, "pattern_frame_updates": 158936, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1451353188, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9131.683117732924, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30697, "avg_candidate_generations": 2558.0833333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2117987, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.99654689383327, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 749, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 30685, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2117238, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 1122493, "avg_legality_checks": 93541.08333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1122493, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2883608, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 240300.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5269332770, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1827.3401828542576, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14469, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1205.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21559107, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1490.020526643168, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 797228, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2593, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11144476, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11766, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9608363, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9040, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 78987, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6582.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 551478676, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6981.891653056832, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 105103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8758.583333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 227977748, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2169.088874722891, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2272473897, "stage_ordering_ns": 783377356, "stage_eval_ns": 1452272562, "stage_threat_ns": 3749026443, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 425504, "root_tactical_annotations": 901, "search_tactical_annotations": 424603, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 158948, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 835854486, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 363251, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2776207597, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61463, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1933566928, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79468, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104681883, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 158936, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17839041, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 68174, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 215522968, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 233606, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 626917220, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 123724, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14443436, "child_limit_applications": 30685, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30685, "child_cap_hits": 30685, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30685, "child_moves_before_total": 2117142, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2117142, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 280318, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 280318, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.99599152680463, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.135343001466515, "tt_hits": 15866, "tt_cutoffs": 3446, "beta_cutoffs": 24759, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 5.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 5.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4526.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5192.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 952, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25394, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 98, 156, 82, 67, 114, 66, 96, 99, 68, 110, 126, 140, 84, 70, 83, 170, 184, 125, 155, 95, 80, 81, 53, 38, 52, 109, 123, 36, 54, 40, 51, 55, 50 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 22501, "avg_search_time_ms": 1250.0555555555557, "search_nodes": 226818, "safety_nodes": 811, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 227629, "avg_nodes": 12646.055555555555, "eval_calls": 145054, "avg_eval_calls": 8058.555555555556, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 145054, "pattern_eval_ns": 3063240, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.117928495594743, "pattern_frame_queries": 145054, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3063240, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.117928495594743, "pattern_frame_updates": 453428, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5696417814, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12563.004080030347, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 75767, "avg_candidate_generations": 4209.277777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 6622187, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.40199559174839, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1337, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 75749, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6620850, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1664392, "avg_legality_checks": 92466.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1803, "root_legality_checks": 1337, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1663055, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1803, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6294480, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 349693.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13070970280, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2076.5766639976614, "renju_forbidden_checks": 53697, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2983.1666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 289402839, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5389.553215263422, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3135, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26707553, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24327, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 176507893, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26221, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 86054682, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 132711, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 177668, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9870.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1429577939, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8046.344524618952, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 232168, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12898.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 566514446, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2440.10563902002, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3851178382, "stage_ordering_ns": 2490831899, "stage_eval_ns": 5699481054, "stage_threat_ns": 10389989704, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1659698, "root_tactical_annotations": 4207, "search_tactical_annotations": 1655491, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 453446, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2597890705, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1235046, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7327805795, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 151637, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5051475643, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 226714, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 330874915, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 453428, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55075403, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 485201, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 455402526, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 598195, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1820465584, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 576302, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 78342886, "child_limit_applications": 75749, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 75749, "child_cap_hits": 75749, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 75749, "child_moves_before_total": 6619047, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6619047, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 924994, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 924994, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.38131196451438, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.21130311951313, "tt_hits": 47254, "tt_cutoffs": 5912, "beta_cutoffs": 62528, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4523.722222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4968.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 2874, "avg_search_time_ms": 169.05882352941177, "search_nodes": 85002, "safety_nodes": 1927, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 86929, "avg_nodes": 5113.470588235294, "eval_calls": 82184, "avg_eval_calls": 4834.35294117647, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82184, "pattern_eval_ns": 1681917, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.465260878029788, "pattern_frame_queries": 82184, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1681917, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.465260878029788, "pattern_frame_updates": 169904, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1747122416, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10282.997551558527, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2785, "avg_candidate_generations": 163.8235294117647, "candidate_moves_total": 222994, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.06965888689408, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1261, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 2768, "search_candidate_moves_total": 221733, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 5365, "avg_legality_checks": 315.5882352941176, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5365, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 522590, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 30740.58823529412, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1157541031, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2215.0080005357927, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4576, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 269.1764705882353, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32124067, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7020.119536713287, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 49820, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4557, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31934296, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 139951, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14135476, "stage_ordering_ns": 86230, "stage_eval_ns": 1748804333, "stage_threat_ns": 1089820335, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169921, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 956164293, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 468522, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17760, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84952, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113167524, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169904, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20019996, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2591, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6731.529411764706, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7202.117647058823, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 953, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23312, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 80, 141, 155, 128, 125, 129, 130, 99, 85, 140, 139, 97, 108, 109, 153, 167, 145, 100, 98, 114, 65, 95, 144, 86, 142, 72 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 4713, "avg_search_time_ms": 336.64285714285717, "search_nodes": 105245, "safety_nodes": 1510, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 106755, "avg_nodes": 7625.357142857143, "eval_calls": 101469, "avg_eval_calls": 7247.785714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 101469, "pattern_eval_ns": 2209182, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.771989474617865, "pattern_frame_queries": 101469, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2209182, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.771989474617865, "pattern_frame_updates": 210408, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2995879503, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14238.429636705829, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3749, "avg_candidate_generations": 267.7857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 291372, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.71992531341691, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1033, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 3735, "search_candidate_moves_total": 290339, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 97921, "avg_legality_checks": 6994.357142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 109, "root_legality_checks": 1033, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 96888, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 104, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 886032, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 63288.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2210364804, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2494.678300557993, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13435, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 959.6428571428571, "renju_forbidden_ns": 103234496, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7683.996724972088, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 123, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1042268, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13255, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 101815568, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 376660, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 92, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.571428571428571, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 936793, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10182.532608695652, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.428571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 461511, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3911.1101694915255, "stage_move_gen_ns": 256653791, "stage_ordering_ns": 128321, "stage_eval_ns": 2998088685, "stage_threat_ns": 1432029352, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 210422, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1253500663, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1311844, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 105204, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 150488786, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 210408, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26728059, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 190, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3390, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6246.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6818.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1870, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 18586, "avg_search_time_ms": 1327.5714285714287, "search_nodes": 130044, "safety_nodes": 981, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 131025, "avg_nodes": 9358.92857142857, "eval_calls": 81986, "avg_eval_calls": 5856.142857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 81986, "pattern_eval_ns": 1867812, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.782084746176178, "pattern_frame_queries": 81986, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1867812, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.782084746176178, "pattern_frame_updates": 259916, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3227593767, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12417.834096400375, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43570, "avg_candidate_generations": 3112.1428571428573, "candidate_moves_total": 3759001, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.27498278632086, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1078, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 43556, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3757923, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 2264928, "avg_legality_checks": 161780.57142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12247, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2264928, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12247, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5499705, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 392836.0714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11923985983, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2168.113741191573, "renju_forbidden_checks": 101383, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7241.642857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 353707751, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3488.827032145429, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16786, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 121108588, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22286, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 112979882, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 62155, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 119014570, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 156, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 604711, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 204080, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14577.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2097800270, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10279.303557428459, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 274264, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19590.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1023026280, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3730.078610389989, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5716108170, "stage_ordering_ns": 1545910630, "stage_eval_ns": 3229461579, "stage_threat_ns": 8001331026, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 967534, "root_tactical_annotations": 2562, "search_tactical_annotations": 964972, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 259930, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1653672297, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 799020, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6072746822, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 87225, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3275113335, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129958, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 206166688, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 259916, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35276822, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 249952, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1055738027, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 461833, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1741540329, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 255749, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33468397, "child_limit_applications": 43556, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43556, "child_cap_hits": 43556, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43556, "child_moves_before_total": 3745676, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3745676, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 524256, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 524256, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.99678574708422, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.036366975847185, "tt_hits": 22995, "tt_cutoffs": 4416, "beta_cutoffs": 35499, "depth_sum": 84, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 84, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3575.285714285714, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4146.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 76, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 954, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23078, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 123, 81, 97, 83, 139, 153, 124, 85, 71, 82, 84, 80, 79, 94, 122, 121, 107, 66, 52, 91, 137, 151, 92, 152, 77 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 21905, "avg_search_time_ms": 1216.9444444444443, "search_nodes": 257087, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 257884, "avg_nodes": 14326.888888888889, "eval_calls": 170750, "avg_eval_calls": 9486.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 170750, "pattern_eval_ns": 3574380, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.93341142020498, "pattern_frame_queries": 170750, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3574380, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.93341142020498, "pattern_frame_updates": 513966, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5769861608, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11226.154274796387, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 80012, "avg_candidate_generations": 4445.111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 7078312, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.46563015547667, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 79994, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7077010, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1923732, "avg_legality_checks": 106874.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2337, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1922430, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2337, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7080211, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 393345.05555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12642208333, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1785.569431899699, "renju_forbidden_checks": 69656, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3869.777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 277601140, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3985.3155507063284, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4004, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22305044, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 32714, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 181693145, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32924, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 73516281, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 86670, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 215726, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11984.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1399613569, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6487.922498910655, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 280374, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15576.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 560738920, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1999.967614686098, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3873553973, "stage_ordering_ns": 2325055777, "stage_eval_ns": 5773435988, "stage_threat_ns": 9825860804, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1731978, "root_tactical_annotations": 4128, "search_tactical_annotations": 1727850, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 513984, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2544896338, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1339040, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6819206562, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 160127, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4608464476, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 256983, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 337994333, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 513966, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56477825, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 522236, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 419058141, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 656664, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1791262654, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 553078, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 67285746, "child_limit_applications": 79994, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 79994, "child_cap_hits": 79994, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 79994, "child_moves_before_total": 7074673, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7074673, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 938984, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 938984, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.44004550341276, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.738180363527265, "tt_hits": 48405, "tt_cutoffs": 6239, "beta_cutoffs": 64700, "depth_sum": 104, "avg_depth": 5.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 104, "avg_effective_depth": 5.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3888888888888889, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4062.777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4507.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 718, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 1155, "avg_search_time_ms": 67.94117647058823, "search_nodes": 42485, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 44376, "avg_nodes": 2610.3529411764707, "eval_calls": 40031, "avg_eval_calls": 2354.764705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40031, "pattern_eval_ns": 823560, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.57305588169169, "pattern_frame_queries": 40031, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 823560, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.57305588169169, "pattern_frame_updates": 84870, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 649448759, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7652.277117945093, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2421, "avg_candidate_generations": 142.41176470588235, "candidate_moves_total": 189525, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.28376703841388, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1235, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2404, "search_candidate_moves_total": 188290, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5477, "avg_legality_checks": 322.1764705882353, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5477, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 226934, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13349.058823529413, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 419130325, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1846.9260886425127, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1378, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 81.05882352941177, "renju_forbidden_ns": 7094222, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5148.201741654572, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24950, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1359, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7002462, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 66810, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12009699, "stage_ordering_ns": 76060, "stage_eval_ns": 650272319, "stage_threat_ns": 471714624, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 84887, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 412413948, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 392511, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13760, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42435, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 49993751, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 84870, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8914414, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2230, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6753.882352941177, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7224.470588235294, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 955, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9147, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 67, 81, 126, 113, 129, 83, 84, 98, 128, 65, 49, 79, 80, 68, 53, 130, 114, 127, 142, 99, 100, 156, 86 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 3869, "avg_search_time_ms": 322.4166666666667, "search_nodes": 162713, "safety_nodes": 892, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 163605, "avg_nodes": 13633.75, "eval_calls": 156970, "avg_eval_calls": 13080.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 156970, "pattern_eval_ns": 3053762, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.454430782952155, "pattern_frame_queries": 156970, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3053762, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.454430782952155, "pattern_frame_updates": 325356, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2286220633, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7026.827945389051, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5720, "avg_candidate_generations": 476.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 372730, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.16258741258741, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 5708, "search_candidate_moves_total": 372008, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 151449, "avg_legality_checks": 12620.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 150727, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1107056, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 92254.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1575718657, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1423.3414181396424, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8812, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 734.3333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37185296, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4219.847480708126, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 111762, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8790, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37073534, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.083333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 304384, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6211.918367346939, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 150562, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2281.242424242424, "stage_move_gen_ns": 228318878, "stage_ordering_ns": 182042, "stage_eval_ns": 2289274395, "stage_threat_ns": 1311010639, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 325368, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1129877249, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 429314, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6730, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 162678, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 154348013, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 325356, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26356063, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 265, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5174, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5784.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6450.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1920, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5266, "avg_search_time_ms": 438.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 75326, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76365, "avg_nodes": 6363.75, "eval_calls": 42395, "avg_eval_calls": 3532.9166666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 42395, "pattern_eval_ns": 826484, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.494846090340843, "pattern_frame_queries": 42395, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 826484, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.494846090340843, "pattern_frame_updates": 150520, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 974721162, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6475.692014350252, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29311, "avg_candidate_generations": 2442.5833333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 1958557, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.81986285012452, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 744, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 29299, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1957813, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 955102, "avg_legality_checks": 79591.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 955102, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2570126, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 214177.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3227152928, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1255.6399678459345, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11706, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 975.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14324944, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1223.7266359132068, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 56, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 250971, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2692, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8920659, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8958, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5153314, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67717, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5643.083333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 355071207, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5243.457433140866, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89114, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7426.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 148043910, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1661.2867787328591, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1333372337, "stage_ordering_ns": 471406958, "stage_eval_ns": 975547646, "stage_threat_ns": 2434560003, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 372094, "root_tactical_annotations": 456, "search_tactical_annotations": 371638, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 150532, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 562281846, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 321036, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1772374964, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58687, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1230770568, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 76165419, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 150520, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12699732, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 45839, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 119515867, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 216503, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 421906277, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 109752, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11038042, "child_limit_applications": 29299, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29299, "child_cap_hits": 29299, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29299, "child_moves_before_total": 1957763, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1957763, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 265033, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 265033, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 66.82013037987645, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.045803611044745, "tt_hits": 15363, "tt_cutoffs": 3566, "beta_cutoffs": 23511, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5109.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5776.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 733, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 956, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16779, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 143, 67, 52, 95, 53, 83, 80, 51, 99, 113, 129, 65, 49, 66, 159, 175, 114, 144, 84, 69, 68, 36, 21, 37, 100, 116, 23, 35, 19, 38, 34, 39 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 14955, "avg_search_time_ms": 830.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 233838, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 234635, "avg_nodes": 13035.277777777777, "eval_calls": 151508, "avg_eval_calls": 8417.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 151508, "pattern_eval_ns": 2992565, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.751861287852787, "pattern_frame_queries": 151508, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2992565, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.751861287852787, "pattern_frame_updates": 467468, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3895840231, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8333.918537739482, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 76470, "avg_candidate_generations": 4248.333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 6533243, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.43537334902577, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 76452, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6531941, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1631761, "avg_legality_checks": 90653.38888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1782, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1630459, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1782, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6247168, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 347064.8888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8306904719, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1329.7072719990883, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55271, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3070.6111111111113, "renju_forbidden_ns": 203788112, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3687.0711946590436, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3193, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16494961, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26980, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 130178488, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25084, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 57050493, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 64170, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 180493, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10027.388888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 939554096, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5205.487725285745, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 235865, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13103.611111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 385391324, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1633.9487588239035, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2457260461, "stage_ordering_ns": 1621919766, "stage_eval_ns": 3898832796, "stage_threat_ns": 6877003514, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1650385, "root_tactical_annotations": 4128, "search_tactical_annotations": 1646257, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 467486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1788001335, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1229801, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4727917269, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 153043, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3181717849, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 233734, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 254195336, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 467468, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42407757, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 480082, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 314368476, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 596663, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1231479594, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 573640, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 64481817, "child_limit_applications": 76452, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 76452, "child_cap_hits": 76452, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 76452, "child_moves_before_total": 6530159, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6530159, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 921236, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 921236, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.4151493747711, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.049861350912991, "tt_hits": 47510, "tt_cutoffs": 5774, "beta_cutoffs": 62845, "depth_sum": 104, "avg_depth": 5.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 104, "avg_effective_depth": 5.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6325.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6769.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1803, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 1808, "avg_search_time_ms": 106.3529411764706, "search_nodes": 83589, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85480, "avg_nodes": 5028.235294117647, "eval_calls": 80899, "avg_eval_calls": 4758.764705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80899, "pattern_eval_ns": 1576382, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.485803285578314, "pattern_frame_queries": 80899, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1576382, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.485803285578314, "pattern_frame_updates": 167078, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1071092261, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6410.731879720849, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2657, "avg_candidate_generations": 156.2941176470588, "candidate_moves_total": 210366, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.1742566804667, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1235, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2640, "search_candidate_moves_total": 209131, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5095, "avg_legality_checks": 299.70588235294116, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5095, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 515285, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 30310.882352941175, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 678788078, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1317.3061082701806, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4382, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 257.7647058823529, "renju_forbidden_ns": 17382333, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3966.757873117298, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 41690, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4359, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17275783, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 64860, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9459749, "stage_ordering_ns": 82370, "stage_eval_ns": 1072668643, "stage_threat_ns": 693862158, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 167095, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 602080708, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 306210, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11750, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 83539, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 77518651, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 167078, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13956589, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2469, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6771.058823529412, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7241.64705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1988, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 957, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8764, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 110, 96, 99, 128, 144, 126, 141, 127, 129, 80, 64, 66, 81, 125, 124, 159, 143, 114, 115, 142, 157, 101, 171 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 3072, "avg_search_time_ms": 256.0, "search_nodes": 124935, "safety_nodes": 892, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 125827, "avg_nodes": 10485.583333333334, "eval_calls": 120088, "avg_eval_calls": 10007.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 120088, "pattern_eval_ns": 2339293, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.479823129704883, "pattern_frame_queries": 120088, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2339293, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.479823129704883, "pattern_frame_updates": 249800, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1793104569, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7178.160804643715, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4824, "avg_candidate_generations": 402.0, "candidate_moves_total": 318208, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.96351575456053, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 4812, "search_candidate_moves_total": 317486, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 115942, "avg_legality_checks": 9661.833333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 115220, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 814948, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 67912.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1225534539, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1503.819309943702, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8482, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 706.8333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29568679, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3486.0503419004954, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 75811, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8465, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29492868, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.083333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 357452, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7294.938775510204, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 172191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2608.9545454545455, "stage_move_gen_ns": 185811373, "stage_ordering_ns": 152080, "stage_eval_ns": 1795443862, "stage_threat_ns": 1052524839, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 249812, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 910554738, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 511503, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124900, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 120110837, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 249800, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21347761, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 265, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4276, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6016.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6682.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1866, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5679, "avg_search_time_ms": 473.25, "search_nodes": 76959, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 77998, "avg_nodes": 6499.833333333333, "eval_calls": 43466, "avg_eval_calls": 3622.1666666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 43466, "pattern_eval_ns": 850025, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.556089817328488, "pattern_frame_queries": 43466, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 850025, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.556089817328488, "pattern_frame_updates": 153786, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1041072770, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6769.6199263912185, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30064, "avg_candidate_generations": 2505.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2033627, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.64326104310804, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 744, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 30052, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2032883, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 997333, "avg_legality_checks": 83111.08333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 76, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 997333, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 76, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2680634, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 223386.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3491787019, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1302.5974523191155, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12015, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1001.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15336304, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1276.4297960882232, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 80, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 480571, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2754, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9207923, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9181, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5647810, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68653, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5721.083333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 365408798, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5322.54669133177, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91029, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7585.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 153034999, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1681.1675290292105, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1457519372, "stage_ordering_ns": 524665400, "stage_eval_ns": 1041922795, "stage_threat_ns": 2601595000, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 383131, "root_tactical_annotations": 456, "search_tactical_annotations": 382675, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 153798, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 588223826, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 332741, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1907748874, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60193, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1338645850, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76893, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 79131980, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 153786, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13278608, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 45425, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 118578898, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 227116, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 450343563, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110590, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13211712, "child_limit_applications": 30052, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30052, "child_cap_hits": 30052, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30052, "child_moves_before_total": 2032807, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2032807, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 270678, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 270678, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.64298549181419, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.006987887661387, "tt_hits": 15087, "tt_cutoffs": 3375, "beta_cutoffs": 24165, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5020.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5686.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 555, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 958, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24439, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 110, 109, 82, 124, 126, 81, 94, 142, 128, 144, 80, 64, 95, 146, 162, 143, 145, 141, 140, 125, 93, 92, 108, 157, 173, 122, 78, 62, 123, 63, 138 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 21644, "avg_search_time_ms": 1202.4444444444443, "search_nodes": 222116, "safety_nodes": 811, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 222927, "avg_nodes": 12384.833333333334, "eval_calls": 140822, "avg_eval_calls": 7823.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 140822, "pattern_eval_ns": 3029961, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.516247461334167, "pattern_frame_queries": 140822, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3029961, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.516247461334167, "pattern_frame_updates": 444024, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5269990007, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11868.705310974181, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 75237, "avg_candidate_generations": 4179.833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 6590440, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.59573082392971, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1337, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 75219, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6589103, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1696291, "avg_legality_checks": 94238.38888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1613, "root_legality_checks": 1337, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1694954, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1613, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6213526, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 345195.8888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12511240227, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2013.54918720868, "renju_forbidden_checks": 49153, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2730.722222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 240518368, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4893.259170345656, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2983, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24930633, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21260, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 139405745, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24896, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 76045789, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 136201, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 177151, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9841.722222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1386828895, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7828.5129352924905, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 230676, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12815.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 543298912, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2355.2468050425705, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3859389071, "stage_ordering_ns": 2416510580, "stage_eval_ns": 5273019968, "stage_threat_ns": 10007879085, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1660492, "root_tactical_annotations": 4207, "search_tactical_annotations": 1656285, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 444042, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2500173276, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1233128, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7045045265, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 150577, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4831186166, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 222012, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 328392296, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 444024, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53690560, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 484512, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 430270277, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 598026, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1783169921, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 577954, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 80577688, "child_limit_applications": 75219, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 75219, "child_cap_hits": 75219, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 75219, "child_moves_before_total": 6587490, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6587490, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 919546, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 919546, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.5774737765724, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.2249165769287, "tt_hits": 47088, "tt_cutoffs": 5972, "beta_cutoffs": 62072, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4925.611111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5370.055555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 2777, "avg_search_time_ms": 163.35294117647058, "search_nodes": 85132, "safety_nodes": 1927, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87059, "avg_nodes": 5121.117647058823, "eval_calls": 82452, "avg_eval_calls": 4850.117647058823, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82452, "pattern_eval_ns": 1762099, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.37120991607238, "pattern_frame_queries": 82452, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1762099, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.37120991607238, "pattern_frame_updates": 170164, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1655107188, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9726.541383606404, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2647, "avg_candidate_generations": 155.7058823529412, "candidate_moves_total": 214210, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.92557612391387, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1261, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 2630, "search_candidate_moves_total": 212949, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 5666, "avg_legality_checks": 333.29411764705884, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5666, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 495785, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29163.823529411766, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1069501590, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2157.1882771765986, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4651, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 273.5882352941176, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33440656, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7189.992689744141, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 80440, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4628, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33217906, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 142310, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15007509, "stage_ordering_ns": 85990, "stage_eval_ns": 1656869287, "stage_threat_ns": 1076096118, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 170181, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 942113815, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 496265, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17401, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85082, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113250405, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 170164, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20235633, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2463, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6766.235294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7236.823529411765, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 959, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13326, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 82, 96, 141, 128, 144, 98, 99, 113, 143, 80, 64, 94, 95, 83, 68, 145, 129, 142, 157, 114, 115, 171, 101 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5995, "avg_search_time_ms": 499.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 164463, "safety_nodes": 892, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 165355, "avg_nodes": 13779.583333333334, "eval_calls": 158720, "avg_eval_calls": 13226.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 158720, "pattern_eval_ns": 3218251, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.276278981854837, "pattern_frame_queries": 158720, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3218251, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.276278981854837, "pattern_frame_updates": 328856, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3585951677, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10904.32188252609, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5720, "avg_candidate_generations": 476.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 374674, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.50244755244755, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 5708, "search_candidate_moves_total": 373952, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 153206, "avg_legality_checks": 12767.166666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 152484, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1124154, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 93679.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2561213579, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2278.3476098470496, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8817, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 734.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62885769, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7132.331745491664, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 186301, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8795, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62699468, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.083333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 468071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9552.469387755102, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 220481, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3340.621212121212, "stage_move_gen_ns": 355853497, "stage_ordering_ns": 185830, "stage_eval_ns": 3589169928, "stage_threat_ns": 2021229541, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 328868, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1768428650, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 632962, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 164428, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 214152428, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 328856, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38015501, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 265, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5175, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5406.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6073.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1762, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7319, "avg_search_time_ms": 609.9166666666666, "search_nodes": 63871, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 64910, "avg_nodes": 5409.166666666667, "eval_calls": 36773, "avg_eval_calls": 3064.4166666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36773, "pattern_eval_ns": 782374, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.275772985614445, "pattern_frame_queries": 36773, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 782374, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.275772985614445, "pattern_frame_updates": 127610, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1304084783, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10219.29929472612, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24537, "avg_candidate_generations": 2044.75, "candidate_moves_total": 1661387, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.70945918408934, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 744, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 24525, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1660643, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 824045, "avg_legality_checks": 68670.41666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 824045, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2248940, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 187411.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4659273068, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2071.7640612910973, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11031, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 919.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19556325, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1772.8515093826488, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 56, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 494791, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2283, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11715742, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8692, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7345792, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65074, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5422.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 547804002, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8418.170114024035, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 85519, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7126.583333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 222805885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2605.3378196658055, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1912854808, "stage_ordering_ns": 671727026, "stage_eval_ns": 1304867157, "stage_threat_ns": 3384626703, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 322886, "root_tactical_annotations": 456, "search_tactical_annotations": 322430, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 127622, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 746450967, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 286552, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2520949337, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49139, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1710546406, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 63805, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91380306, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 127610, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15646325, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 42566, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 169866863, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 194840, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 640269407, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 85480, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10199768, "child_limit_applications": 24525, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24525, "child_cap_hits": 24525, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24525, "child_moves_before_total": 1660593, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1660593, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 225675, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 225675, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.71021406727829, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.20183486238532, "tt_hits": 11619, "tt_cutoffs": 2508, "beta_cutoffs": 19626, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4517.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5184.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 960, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24597, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 158, 82, 67, 110, 68, 98, 95, 66, 114, 128, 144, 80, 64, 81, 174, 190, 129, 159, 99, 84, 83, 51, 36, 52, 115, 131, 38, 50, 34, 53, 49, 54 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 21727, "avg_search_time_ms": 1207.0555555555557, "search_nodes": 219550, "safety_nodes": 811, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 220361, "avg_nodes": 12242.277777777777, "eval_calls": 138986, "avg_eval_calls": 7721.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 138986, "pattern_eval_ns": 2928103, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.06761112630049, "pattern_frame_queries": 138986, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2928103, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.06761112630049, "pattern_frame_updates": 438892, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5382969471, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12264.90679028098, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 74726, "avg_candidate_generations": 4151.444444444444, "candidate_moves_total": 6513009, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.15853919653132, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1337, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 74708, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6511672, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1628288, "avg_legality_checks": 90460.44444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1715, "root_legality_checks": 1337, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1626951, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1715, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6119201, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 339955.6111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12603830501, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2059.7183359396104, "renju_forbidden_checks": 49653, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2758.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 266017813, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5357.537570740942, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3018, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26328482, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22156, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 156355113, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24465, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 83198798, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 135420, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 172130, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9562.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1379577728, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8014.743089525358, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 224011, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12445.055555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 542480765, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2421.670208159421, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3748464092, "stage_ordering_ns": 2443696171, "stage_eval_ns": 5385897574, "stage_threat_ns": 10070421772, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1639043, "root_tactical_annotations": 4207, "search_tactical_annotations": 1634836, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 438910, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2498746163, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1216171, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7125092177, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 149555, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4926970066, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 219446, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 318859603, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 438892, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55479353, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 480295, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 434458563, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 586308, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1763193586, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 572440, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 72244476, "child_limit_applications": 74708, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 74708, "child_cap_hits": 74708, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 74708, "child_moves_before_total": 6509957, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6509957, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 912281, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 912281, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.13868661990684, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.211289286287947, "tt_hits": 46776, "tt_cutoffs": 5752, "beta_cutoffs": 61764, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4836.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5280.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1100, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 2850, "avg_search_time_ms": 167.64705882352942, "search_nodes": 84800, "safety_nodes": 1927, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 86727, "avg_nodes": 5101.588235294118, "eval_calls": 82097, "avg_eval_calls": 4829.235294117647, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82097, "pattern_eval_ns": 1692924, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.62102147459712, "pattern_frame_queries": 82097, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1692924, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.62102147459712, "pattern_frame_updates": 169500, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1721353921, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10155.480359882005, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2670, "avg_candidate_generations": 157.05882352941177, "candidate_moves_total": 215657, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.77041198501873, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1261, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 2653, "search_candidate_moves_total": 214396, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 5112, "avg_legality_checks": 300.70588235294116, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5112, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 519294, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 30546.70588235294, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1138710912, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2192.8058325341713, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4670, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 274.70588235294116, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32874072, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7039.415845824411, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 74530, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4648, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32657661, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 141881, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13449888, "stage_ordering_ns": 82670, "stage_eval_ns": 1723046845, "stage_threat_ns": 1087486453, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169517, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 954980928, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 467223, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17920, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84750, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 111517950, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169500, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20520352, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2484, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6746.588235294118, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7217.176470588235, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 961, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3921, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 80, 141, 99, 128, 83, 143, 158, 155, 169, 79, 67, 52, 51, 115, 35 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1653, "avg_search_time_ms": 183.66666666666666, "search_nodes": 40345, "safety_nodes": 457, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40802, "avg_nodes": 4533.555555555556, "eval_calls": 38580, "avg_eval_calls": 4286.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38580, "pattern_eval_ns": 791293, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.510445826853292, "pattern_frame_queries": 38580, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 791293, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.510445826853292, "pattern_frame_updates": 80640, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1030053995, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12773.487041170634, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1749, "avg_candidate_generations": 194.33333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 130497, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.6123499142367, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 591, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 1740, "search_candidate_moves_total": 129906, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 36952, "avg_legality_checks": 4105.777777777777, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 591, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 36361, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 328308, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 36478.666666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 768511677, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2340.825313425198, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5053, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 561.4444444444445, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32621756, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6455.918464278647, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 153630, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5031, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32468126, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 12, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.3333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 117350, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9779.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.6666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 53000, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3533.3333333333335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 89075625, "stage_ordering_ns": 59170, "stage_eval_ns": 1030845288, "stage_threat_ns": 517055088, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 80649, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 454623599, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 196701, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8730, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 52829530, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 80640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9405258, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1414, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5603.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6492.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1873, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 2261, "avg_search_time_ms": 282.625, "search_nodes": 60758, "safety_nodes": 648, "corridor_nodes": 1830, "corridor_branch_probes": 2122, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 808, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1810, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1805, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 808, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 49, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 325, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 204480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 63236, "avg_nodes": 7904.5, "eval_calls": 58731, "avg_eval_calls": 7341.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 58731, "pattern_eval_ns": 1202558, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.47569426708212, "pattern_frame_queries": 58731, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1202558, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.47569426708212, "pattern_frame_updates": 121470, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1173451699, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9660.423964764963, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2012, "avg_candidate_generations": 251.5, "candidate_moves_total": 141608, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.3817097415507, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 528, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 2004, "search_candidate_moves_total": 141080, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 3424, "avg_legality_checks": 428.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3424, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 367153, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 45894.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 837886076, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2282.116926730818, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2984, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 373.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18476444, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6191.837801608579, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2926, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18008293, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 457291, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 10860, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 239791, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8881.148148148148, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 108790, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3108.285714285714, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9374353, "stage_ordering_ns": 66170, "stage_eval_ns": 1174654257, "stage_threat_ns": 990459981, "stage_proof_ns": 73073678, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125198, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 736129592, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 107761, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 135043551, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 915, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 47126368, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 62595, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 85774941, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3720, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18468164, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 125190, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15043733, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 127, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1806, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4993.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5993.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 962, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3882, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 80, 141, 99, 128, 83, 143, 158, 155, 169, 79, 67, 52, 51, 115, 35 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1888, "avg_search_time_ms": 209.77777777777777, "search_nodes": 40345, "safety_nodes": 457, "corridor_nodes": 546, "corridor_branch_probes": 637, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 181, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 537, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 537, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 181, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 287, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 100000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 41348, "avg_nodes": 4594.222222222223, "eval_calls": 38580, "avg_eval_calls": 4286.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38580, "pattern_eval_ns": 784192, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.326386728875065, "pattern_frame_queries": 38580, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 784192, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.326386728875065, "pattern_frame_updates": 80640, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1002131327, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12427.223797123015, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1749, "avg_candidate_generations": 194.33333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 130497, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.6123499142367, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 591, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 1740, "search_candidate_moves_total": 129906, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 36952, "avg_legality_checks": 4105.777777777777, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 591, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 36361, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 429612, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 47734.666666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 948685241, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2208.237295513161, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5220, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 580.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32768636, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6277.516475095786, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 152231, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5031, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31550449, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 501071, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 125, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 564885, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1443, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 160.33333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 14152035, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9807.370062370062, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1935, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 215.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 7272670, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3758.485788113695, "stage_move_gen_ns": 86772777, "stage_ordering_ns": 58160, "stage_eval_ns": 1002915519, "stage_threat_ns": 641509042, "stage_proof_ns": 141018296, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 81805, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 459001349, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37966, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 113559910, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 413, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 23866794, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40898, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 53617594, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1156, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5984132, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 81796, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9346057, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1414, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5559.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6447.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1839, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1986, "avg_search_time_ms": 248.25, "search_nodes": 60758, "safety_nodes": 648, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 61406, "avg_nodes": 7675.75, "eval_calls": 58731, "avg_eval_calls": 7341.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 58731, "pattern_eval_ns": 1200217, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.43583456777511, "pattern_frame_queries": 58731, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1200217, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.43583456777511, "pattern_frame_updates": 121470, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1174467101, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9668.783246892237, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2012, "avg_candidate_generations": 251.5, "candidate_moves_total": 141608, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.3817097415507, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 528, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 2004, "search_candidate_moves_total": 141080, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 3424, "avg_legality_checks": 428.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3424, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 316351, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 39543.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 727387629, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2299.3056099079818, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2926, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 365.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 17879941, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6110.711209842789, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2926, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17879941, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9318444, "stage_ordering_ns": 64200, "stage_eval_ns": 1175667318, "stage_threat_ns": 787679466, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 121478, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 692216424, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 132900, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8070, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 60735, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80757733, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 121470, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14572409, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 127, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1806, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5075.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6075.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 963, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5836, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 81, 100, 142, 129, 126, 130, 131, 86, 72, 66, 110, 109, 94, 158, 78 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2824, "avg_search_time_ms": 313.77777777777777, "search_nodes": 86686, "safety_nodes": 457, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87143, "avg_nodes": 9682.555555555555, "eval_calls": 84124, "avg_eval_calls": 9347.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84124, "pattern_eval_ns": 1627108, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.341781180162616, "pattern_frame_queries": 84124, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1627108, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.341781180162616, "pattern_frame_updates": 173322, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1745411156, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10070.33819134328, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2546, "avg_candidate_generations": 282.8888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 183096, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.91516103692067, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 591, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 2537, "search_candidate_moves_total": 182505, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 82153, "avg_legality_checks": 9128.111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 591, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 81562, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 658556, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 73172.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1227115107, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1863.3420802483008, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8019, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 891.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44114408, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5501.2355655318615, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 101551, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7984, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44012857, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 12, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.3333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 116960, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9746.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.6666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 52360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3490.6666666666665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 164176760, "stage_ordering_ns": 77500, "stage_eval_ns": 1747038264, "stage_threat_ns": 895260876, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 173331, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 780433682, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 193641, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7100, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86661, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 97503577, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 173322, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17129976, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2169, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5269.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6158.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1876, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 3004, "avg_search_time_ms": 375.5, "search_nodes": 92820, "safety_nodes": 648, "corridor_nodes": 1700, "corridor_branch_probes": 1964, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 762, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1683, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1678, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 762, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 49, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 325, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 146080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 95168, "avg_nodes": 11896.0, "eval_calls": 89555, "avg_eval_calls": 11194.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89555, "pattern_eval_ns": 1806067, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.167126346937636, "pattern_frame_queries": 89555, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1806067, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.167126346937636, "pattern_frame_updates": 185594, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1616852714, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8711.772546526288, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3250, "avg_candidate_generations": 406.25, "candidate_moves_total": 227981, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.148, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 528, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 3242, "search_candidate_moves_total": 227453, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5952, "avg_legality_checks": 744.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5952, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 462535, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 57816.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1036561597, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2241.04467121407, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2272, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 284.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19478366, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8573.224471830987, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2224, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19117325, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 352851, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8190, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 143060, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5298.518518518518, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 67510, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1928.857142857143, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15274386, "stage_ordering_ns": 99001, "stage_eval_ns": 1618658781, "stage_threat_ns": 1296326280, "stage_proof_ns": 64466554, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 189068, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1041503185, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 98891, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 95742355, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 866, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 34579038, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 94530, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 123634621, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3466, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13468933, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 189060, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21977186, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 127, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2961, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4518.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5518.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 964, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4030, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 81, 100, 142, 129, 126, 130, 131, 86, 72, 66, 110, 109, 94, 158, 78 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2325, "avg_search_time_ms": 258.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 86686, "safety_nodes": 457, "corridor_nodes": 462, "corridor_branch_probes": 550, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 139, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 453, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 453, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 139, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 287, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 101360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 87605, "avg_nodes": 9733.888888888889, "eval_calls": 84124, "avg_eval_calls": 9347.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84124, "pattern_eval_ns": 1538888, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.293091151157814, "pattern_frame_queries": 84124, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1538888, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.293091151157814, "pattern_frame_updates": 173322, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1367330654, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7888.961897508683, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2546, "avg_candidate_generations": 282.8888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 183096, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.91516103692067, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 591, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 2537, "search_candidate_moves_total": 182505, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 82153, "avg_legality_checks": 9128.111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 591, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 81562, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 752336, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 83592.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1046201546, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1390.604126347802, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8153, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 905.8888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 35675526, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4375.754446216117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 98140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7984, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35103285, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 33, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 245090, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 101, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 229011, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1276, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 141.77777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 7224987, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5662.2155172413795, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1749, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 194.33333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3821006, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2184.680388793596, "stage_move_gen_ns": 123961758, "stage_ordering_ns": 75780, "stage_eval_ns": 1368869542, "stage_threat_ns": 738922338, "stage_proof_ns": 72285570, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 174319, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 586551653, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33583, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 58597527, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 380, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12085297, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 87155, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 77259006, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 988, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2951937, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 174310, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13562215, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2169, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5442.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6331.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1910, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1695, "avg_search_time_ms": 211.875, "search_nodes": 92820, "safety_nodes": 648, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 93468, "avg_nodes": 11683.5, "eval_calls": 89555, "avg_eval_calls": 11194.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89555, "pattern_eval_ns": 1632298, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.22676567472503, "pattern_frame_queries": 89555, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1632298, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.22676567472503, "pattern_frame_updates": 185594, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 976563364, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5261.826158173217, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3250, "avg_candidate_generations": 406.25, "candidate_moves_total": 227981, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.148, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 528, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 3242, "search_candidate_moves_total": 227453, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5952, "avg_legality_checks": 744.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5952, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 413806, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 51725.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 548500510, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1325.5015877005167, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2224, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 278.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10886231, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4894.888039568345, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2224, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10886231, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9824360, "stage_ordering_ns": 91800, "stage_eval_ns": 978195662, "stage_threat_ns": 686506654, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 185602, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 595051419, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 78880, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92797, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 77278963, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 185594, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14097392, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 127, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2961, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5021.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6021.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1988, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 965, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6799, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 129, 109, 108, 81, 123, 125, 80, 93, 141, 127, 143, 79, 63, 94, 145, 161, 142, 144, 140, 139, 124, 92, 91, 65, 156, 172, 51, 77, 61, 107, 121, 122, 62, 137 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 5057, "avg_search_time_ms": 266.1578947368421, "search_nodes": 223952, "safety_nodes": 804, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 224756, "avg_nodes": 11829.263157894737, "eval_calls": 216070, "avg_eval_calls": 11372.105263157895, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 216070, "pattern_eval_ns": 3958100, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.31860045355672, "pattern_frame_queries": 216070, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3958100, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.31860045355672, "pattern_frame_updates": 447794, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3068283122, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6851.996949490167, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7846, "avg_candidate_generations": 412.94736842105266, "candidate_moves_total": 640860, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.67983685954627, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1421, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 7827, "search_candidate_moves_total": 639439, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 205151, "avg_legality_checks": 10797.421052631578, "illegal_moves_skipped": 150, "root_legality_checks": 1421, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 203730, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 149, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1701488, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 89552.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2165073570, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1272.4589124342929, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28917, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1521.9473684210527, "renju_forbidden_ns": 98457995, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3404.8481861880555, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 191, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 711761, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28721, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 97724524, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 21710, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.894736842105263, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 203192, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5644.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.5789473684210527, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 106321, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2169.816326530612, "stage_move_gen_ns": 287108340, "stage_ordering_ns": 253322, "stage_eval_ns": 3072241222, "stage_threat_ns": 1639991782, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 447813, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1412435558, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 51, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 284032, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 223897, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 193296534, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 447794, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33975658, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 818, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6674, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6790.789473684211, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7211.8421052631575, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1897, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 1724, "avg_search_time_ms": 95.77777777777777, "search_nodes": 87144, "safety_nodes": 2007, "corridor_nodes": 1131, "corridor_branch_probes": 1376, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 9, "corridor_depth_exits": 441, "corridor_neutral_exits": 24, "corridor_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_plies_followed": 1111, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1106, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 17, "corridor_proof_completed": 17, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 35, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 33, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 441, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 219, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 213760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 90282, "avg_nodes": 5015.666666666667, "eval_calls": 84292, "avg_eval_calls": 4682.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84292, "pattern_eval_ns": 1528729, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.13611018839273, "pattern_frame_queries": 84292, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1528729, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.13611018839273, "pattern_frame_updates": 174182, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 936461697, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5376.340247557153, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2817, "avg_candidate_generations": 156.5, "candidate_moves_total": 228844, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.23677671281506, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1349, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 2799, "search_candidate_moves_total": 227495, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 5915, "avg_legality_checks": 328.6111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5915, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 548472, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 30470.666666666668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 625135066, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1139.7757150775244, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2918, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 162.11111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 11398404, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3906.2385195339275, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7410, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2899, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11307084, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45830, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 38080, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.2222222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 202361, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5059.025, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 69521, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1390.42, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9109642, "stage_ordering_ns": 76000, "stage_eval_ns": 937990426, "stage_threat_ns": 704944824, "stage_proof_ns": 44580880, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 176532, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 565110089, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 66070, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 42879526, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 695, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14591793, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 88257, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74537346, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2332, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9309196, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 176514, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13108667, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 82, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2624, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6850.388888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7294.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1989, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 966, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11731, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 129, 109, 108, 81, 123, 125, 80, 93, 141, 127, 143, 79, 63, 94, 145, 161, 142, 144, 140, 139, 124, 92, 91, 107, 156, 172, 121, 77, 61, 122, 62, 137 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 10070, "avg_search_time_ms": 559.4444444444445, "search_nodes": 194432, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 41577, "corridor_branch_probes": 43803, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 23823, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 50, "corridor_plies_followed": 41530, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 41530, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 17, "corridor_proof_completed": 17, "corridor_proof_checks": 137, "corridor_proof_active": 47, "corridor_proof_quiet": 90, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 23823, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 50, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 137, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 133, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1040, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 307520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 23360, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 236806, "avg_nodes": 13155.888888888889, "eval_calls": 187332, "avg_eval_calls": 10407.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 187332, "pattern_eval_ns": 3458989, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.4644855123524, "pattern_frame_queries": 187332, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3458989, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.4644855123524, "pattern_frame_updates": 388760, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2832527213, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7286.056212058854, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7066, "avg_candidate_generations": 392.55555555555554, "candidate_moves_total": 554443, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.46631757712991, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 7048, "search_candidate_moves_total": 553141, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 178517, "avg_legality_checks": 9917.611111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 177215, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 60, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5070883, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 281715.72222222225, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5737841224, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1131.5270385847987, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31503, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1750.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 122079462, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3875.169412436911, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 315, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1402264, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24854, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 95175581, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1866, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10868876, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4468, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 14632741, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 87859, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4881.055555555556, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 410400242, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4671.123527470151, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 117576, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6532.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 206890226, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1759.6297373613663, "stage_move_gen_ns": 263866854, "stage_ordering_ns": 225893, "stage_eval_ns": 2835986202, "stage_threat_ns": 5177345217, "stage_proof_ns": 1737508647, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 472112, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1903001926, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1731227, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2682348968, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17944, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 496530668, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 236047, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 237437794, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 83334, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 317169976, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 472094, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37386553, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 707, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6033, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6709.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7153.944444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1878, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 1644, "avg_search_time_ms": 96.70588235294117, "search_nodes": 83574, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85465, "avg_nodes": 5027.35294117647, "eval_calls": 80904, "avg_eval_calls": 4759.058823529412, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80904, "pattern_eval_ns": 1526151, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.86372738059923, "pattern_frame_queries": 80904, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1526151, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.86372738059923, "pattern_frame_updates": 167048, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 963730947, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5769.185784924093, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2637, "avg_candidate_generations": 155.11764705882354, "candidate_moves_total": 209213, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.33750474023512, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1235, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2620, "search_candidate_moves_total": 207978, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5654, "avg_legality_checks": 332.5882352941176, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5654, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 486464, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 28615.529411764706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 596332837, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1225.8519376562294, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4192, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 246.58823529411765, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16742439, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3993.9024332061067, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 39430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4169, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16620459, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 82550, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9610947, "stage_ordering_ns": 75790, "stage_eval_ns": 965257098, "stage_threat_ns": 638818318, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 167065, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 553481891, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 302902, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12290, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 83524, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 71917236, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 167048, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13116289, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2451, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6786.470588235294, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7257.058823529412, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1991, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 967, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9208, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 95, 115, 96, 144, 142, 100, 94, 97, 110, 101, 99, 129, 157, 87 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4152, "avg_search_time_ms": 461.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 110138, "safety_nodes": 224, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 110362, "avg_nodes": 12262.444444444445, "eval_calls": 106100, "avg_eval_calls": 11788.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 106100, "pattern_eval_ns": 2191598, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.655966069745524, "pattern_frame_queries": 106100, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2191598, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.655966069745524, "pattern_frame_updates": 220224, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2447084358, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11111.796888622493, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4021, "avg_candidate_generations": 446.77777777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 263027, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.41333001740861, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 4012, "search_candidate_moves_total": 262527, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 99905, "avg_legality_checks": 11100.555555555555, "illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 99405, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 693201, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 77022.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1652018143, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2383.1733407770616, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7218, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 802.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 59986557, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8310.689526184538, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 183641, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7199, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 59802916, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.1111111111111112, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 106770, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10677.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.5555555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 53910, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3850.714285714286, "stage_move_gen_ns": 250269008, "stage_ordering_ns": 139410, "stage_eval_ns": 2449275956, "stage_threat_ns": 1440785794, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 220233, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1259830830, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 158160, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9370, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 110112, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 153522325, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 220224, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27274479, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 327, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3503, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4976.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5865.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1797, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5048, "avg_search_time_ms": 560.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 157941, "safety_nodes": 743, "corridor_nodes": 452, "corridor_branch_probes": 531, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 162, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 441, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 441, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 49, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 162, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 49, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 47, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 312, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 179200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 159136, "avg_nodes": 17681.777777777777, "eval_calls": 154392, "avg_eval_calls": 17154.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 154392, "pattern_eval_ns": 3199738, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.724765531892846, "pattern_frame_queries": 154392, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3199738, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.724765531892846, "pattern_frame_updates": 315832, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2813048021, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8906.785952658376, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3533, "avg_candidate_generations": 392.55555555555554, "candidate_moves_total": 234461, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.36314746674215, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 511, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 3524, "search_candidate_moves_total": 233950, "search_candidate_moves_max": 89, "legality_checks": 6180, "avg_legality_checks": 686.6666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6180, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 691338, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 76815.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1605632892, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2322.500559784071, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4896, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 544.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44920934, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9175.027369281046, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4896, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44920934, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17440015, "stage_ordering_ns": 110600, "stage_eval_ns": 2816247759, "stage_threat_ns": 2124060023, "stage_proof_ns": 80616347, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 316821, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1826273971, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29481, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 33920165, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 404, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13355268, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 158406, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 218765591, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 980, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5336621, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 316812, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39763675, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 128, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3223, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4539.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5428.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1968, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 968, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10073, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 95, 115, 96, 144, 142, 100, 94, 97, 110, 101, 99, 129, 157, 87 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5153, "avg_search_time_ms": 572.5555555555555, "search_nodes": 110138, "safety_nodes": 224, "corridor_nodes": 2636, "corridor_branch_probes": 2980, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1118, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 2614, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2614, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 86, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1118, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 86, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 692, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 305440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 112998, "avg_nodes": 12555.333333333334, "eval_calls": 106100, "avg_eval_calls": 11788.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 106100, "pattern_eval_ns": 2160137, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.359443920829406, "pattern_frame_queries": 106100, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2160137, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.359443920829406, "pattern_frame_updates": 220224, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2439653728, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11078.05565242662, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4021, "avg_candidate_generations": 446.77777777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 263027, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.41333001740861, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 4012, "search_candidate_moves_total": 262527, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 99905, "avg_legality_checks": 11100.555555555555, "illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 99405, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1076560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 119617.77777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2399408574, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2228.7736624061827, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7658, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 850.8888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62884224, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8211.572734395404, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 182941, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7199, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60027534, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 100, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1233694, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 340, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1440055, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 6705, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 745.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 65008854, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9695.578523489932, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9340, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1037.7777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 33992185, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3639.4202355460384, "stage_move_gen_ns": 250788313, "stage_ordering_ns": 136471, "stage_eval_ns": 2441813865, "stage_threat_ns": 2013406018, "stage_proof_ns": 431241556, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 225633, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1319116709, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 157371, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 480420316, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1556, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 97759411, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 112812, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 157267602, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5400, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28722163, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 225624, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27879228, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 327, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3503, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4829.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5718.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1764, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4912, "avg_search_time_ms": 545.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 157941, "safety_nodes": 743, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 158684, "avg_nodes": 17631.555555555555, "eval_calls": 154392, "avg_eval_calls": 17154.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 154392, "pattern_eval_ns": 3148470, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.39270169438831, "pattern_frame_queries": 154392, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3148470, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.39270169438831, "pattern_frame_updates": 315832, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2813298120, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8907.577826186074, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3533, "avg_candidate_generations": 392.55555555555554, "candidate_moves_total": 234461, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.36314746674215, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 511, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 3524, "search_candidate_moves_total": 233950, "search_candidate_moves_max": 89, "legality_checks": 6180, "avg_legality_checks": 686.6666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6180, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 657544, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 73060.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1541447764, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2344.2503680362074, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4896, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 544.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 45553444, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9304.216503267973, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4896, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 45553444, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17396152, "stage_ordering_ns": 113650, "stage_eval_ns": 2816446590, "stage_threat_ns": 2069354760, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 315841, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1812033764, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 251712, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8780, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 157916, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 217536638, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 315832, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39532646, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 128, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3223, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4576.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5465.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1972, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 969, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10307, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 83, 157, 98, 140, 110, 158, 68, 113, 82, 173, 143, 141, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5596, "avg_search_time_ms": 621.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 144851, "safety_nodes": 224, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 145075, "avg_nodes": 16119.444444444445, "eval_calls": 140326, "avg_eval_calls": 15591.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 140326, "pattern_eval_ns": 2854138, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.339338397730998, "pattern_frame_queries": 140326, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2854138, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.339338397730998, "pattern_frame_updates": 289650, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3314307006, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11442.45470740549, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4508, "avg_candidate_generations": 500.8888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 289553, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.23092280390416, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 4499, "search_candidate_moves_total": 289053, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 134057, "avg_legality_checks": 14895.222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 133557, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 910742, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 101193.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2217442989, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2434.765267221672, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9164, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1018.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 83467199, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9108.162265386294, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 69, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 653801, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9095, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 82813398, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.1111111111111112, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 108191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10819.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.5555555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 55310, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3950.714285714286, "stage_move_gen_ns": 343358820, "stage_ordering_ns": 153850, "stage_eval_ns": 3317161144, "stage_threat_ns": 1924039941, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 289659, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1685550913, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 159151, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 144825, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 201894665, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 289650, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36435212, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 327, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3997, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4159.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5048.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 685, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4703, "avg_search_time_ms": 522.5555555555555, "search_nodes": 146642, "safety_nodes": 743, "corridor_nodes": 544, "corridor_branch_probes": 651, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 178, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 533, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 533, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 49, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 178, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 49, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 47, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 312, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 180880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 147929, "avg_nodes": 16436.555555555555, "eval_calls": 142969, "avg_eval_calls": 15885.444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 142969, "pattern_eval_ns": 2913861, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.381068623267982, "pattern_frame_queries": 142969, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2913861, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.381068623267982, "pattern_frame_updates": 293234, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2606118516, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8887.50457313954, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3657, "avg_candidate_generations": 406.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 242226, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.23625922887612, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 511, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 3648, "search_candidate_moves_total": 241715, "search_candidate_moves_max": 89, "legality_checks": 7005, "avg_legality_checks": 778.3333333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7005, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 640666, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 71185.11111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1503977689, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2347.5222487224232, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5575, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 619.4444444444445, "renju_forbidden_ns": 52206692, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9364.429058295964, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5571, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 52157482, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 49210, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19519231, "stage_ordering_ns": 116050, "stage_eval_ns": 2609032377, "stage_threat_ns": 1985019146, "stage_proof_ns": 79777368, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 294407, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1695316162, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37279, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 42674726, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 448, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16632216, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147199, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 203523506, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1164, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6282049, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 294398, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37222703, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 128, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3350, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4696.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5585.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 970, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11292, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 83, 157, 98, 140, 110, 158, 68, 113, 82, 173, 143, 141, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6455, "avg_search_time_ms": 717.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 144851, "safety_nodes": 224, "corridor_nodes": 2100, "corridor_branch_probes": 2464, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 826, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 2078, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2078, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 86, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 826, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 86, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 692, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 293520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 147175, "avg_nodes": 16352.777777777777, "eval_calls": 140326, "avg_eval_calls": 15591.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 140326, "pattern_eval_ns": 2861995, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.395329447144505, "pattern_frame_queries": 140326, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2861995, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.395329447144505, "pattern_frame_updates": 289650, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3304551372, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11408.773940963232, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4508, "avg_candidate_generations": 500.8888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 289553, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.23092280390416, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 4499, "search_candidate_moves_total": 289053, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 134057, "avg_legality_checks": 14895.222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 133557, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1240119, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 137791.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2853337369, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2300.8577152676476, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9590, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1065.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 83986738, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8757.74118873827, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 69, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 632045, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9095, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 80916784, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 87, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1054813, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 339, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1383096, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 5164, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 573.7777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 50470397, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9773.50832687839, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7236, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 804.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 26616009, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3678.276533996683, "stage_move_gen_ns": 343122993, "stage_ordering_ns": 152401, "stage_eval_ns": 3307413367, "stage_threat_ns": 2401712516, "stage_proof_ns": 390533239, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 293987, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1733685846, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 132702, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 403323855, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1308, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 84519371, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 146989, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 205566426, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4328, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22223644, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 293978, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36912745, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 327, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3997, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3893.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4782.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 609, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4828, "avg_search_time_ms": 536.4444444444445, "search_nodes": 146642, "safety_nodes": 743, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 147385, "avg_nodes": 16376.111111111111, "eval_calls": 142969, "avg_eval_calls": 15885.444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 142969, "pattern_eval_ns": 2886220, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.18773300505704, "pattern_frame_queries": 142969, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2886220, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.18773300505704, "pattern_frame_updates": 293234, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2887900537, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9848.450510513787, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3657, "avg_candidate_generations": 406.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 242226, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.23625922887612, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 511, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 3648, "search_candidate_moves_total": 241715, "search_candidate_moves_max": 89, "legality_checks": 7005, "avg_legality_checks": 778.3333333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7005, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 605436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 67270.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1696646197, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2802.3543314239655, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5571, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 619.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61273061, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10998.574941662178, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5571, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 61273061, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19433748, "stage_ordering_ns": 121431, "stage_eval_ns": 2890786757, "stage_threat_ns": 1908963405, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 293243, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1671909030, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 254054, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8690, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 146617, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 200164393, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 293234, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36635928, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 128, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3350, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4616.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5505.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 971, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9356, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 80, 129, 81, 128, 125, 145, 161, 130, 127, 95, 79, 131, 132, 82, 109, 108, 77, 78, 93, 141, 61 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 4954, "avg_search_time_ms": 412.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 122420, "safety_nodes": 515, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122935, "avg_nodes": 10244.583333333334, "eval_calls": 118366, "avg_eval_calls": 9863.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 118366, "pattern_eval_ns": 2395901, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.241462920095298, "pattern_frame_queries": 118366, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2395901, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.241462920095298, "pattern_frame_updates": 244772, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3087006918, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12611.764899580017, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4032, "avg_candidate_generations": 336.0, "candidate_moves_total": 297835, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.86780753968254, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 812, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 4020, "search_candidate_moves_total": 297023, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 114871, "avg_legality_checks": 9572.583333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 71, "root_legality_checks": 812, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 114059, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 71, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 984640, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 82053.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2285661424, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2321.3168508287295, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11651, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 970.9166666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 85163286, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7309.525877607072, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 101, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 901392, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11550, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 84261894, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.3333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 158380, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9898.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 76550, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3645.2380952380954, "stage_move_gen_ns": 279508290, "stage_ordering_ns": 131941, "stage_eval_ns": 3089402819, "stage_threat_ns": 1566770219, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 244784, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1368545191, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 229230, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 122386, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 168394751, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 244772, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29601047, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 415, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3421, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5853.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6520.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1800, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4389, "avg_search_time_ms": 399.0, "search_nodes": 118610, "safety_nodes": 1014, "corridor_nodes": 1879, "corridor_branch_probes": 2257, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 14, "corridor_depth_exits": 819, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_plies_followed": 1863, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1858, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 819, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 348, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 247200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 121503, "avg_nodes": 11045.727272727272, "eval_calls": 115405, "avg_eval_calls": 10491.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 115405, "pattern_eval_ns": 2336340, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.244703435726354, "pattern_frame_queries": 115405, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2336340, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.244703435726354, "pattern_frame_updates": 237156, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2540047747, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10710.451124997891, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3184, "avg_candidate_generations": 289.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 223118, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.07474874371859, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 3173, "search_candidate_moves_total": 222370, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 6444, "avg_legality_checks": 585.8181818181819, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6444, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 762724, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 69338.54545454546, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1735691345, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2275.6479998007144, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8513, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 773.9090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 77323933, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9083.04158346059, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 49840, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8431, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 76533760, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 51, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 510002, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 230331, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 218461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9498.304347826086, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.8181818181818183, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 113251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3653.2580645161293, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17397383, "stage_ordering_ns": 101380, "stage_eval_ns": 2542384087, "stage_threat_ns": 1731913747, "stage_proof_ns": 84980433, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 241011, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1394309677, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 108071, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 120049582, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 936, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 35778090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 120500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 166583589, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3844, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21092828, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 241000, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29878071, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 133, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2823, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5370.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6098.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 972, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9560, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 80, 129, 81, 128, 125, 145, 161, 130, 127, 95, 79, 131, 132, 82, 109, 108, 77, 78, 93, 141, 61 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5413, "avg_search_time_ms": 451.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 122420, "safety_nodes": 515, "corridor_nodes": 946, "corridor_branch_probes": 1094, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 379, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 931, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 931, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 379, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 60, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 439, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 179600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 123881, "avg_nodes": 10323.416666666666, "eval_calls": 118366, "avg_eval_calls": 9863.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 118366, "pattern_eval_ns": 2389060, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.183667607252083, "pattern_frame_queries": 118366, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2389060, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.183667607252083, "pattern_frame_updates": 244772, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3111213905, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12710.660962038142, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4032, "avg_candidate_generations": 336.0, "candidate_moves_total": 297835, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.86780753968254, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 812, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 4020, "search_candidate_moves_total": 297023, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 114871, "avg_legality_checks": 9572.583333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 71, "root_legality_checks": 812, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 114059, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 71, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1142746, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 95228.83333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2612826449, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2286.4454996998456, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11829, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 985.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 88860209, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7512.064333417871, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 101, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 914726, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11550, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 86387525, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 601944, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 126, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 956014, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2044, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 170.33333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 20094237, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9830.840019569472, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2735, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 227.91666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 10655371, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3895.9308957952467, "stage_move_gen_ns": 281596126, "stage_ordering_ns": 134030, "stage_eval_ns": 3113602965, "stage_threat_ns": 1782108570, "stage_proof_ns": 214677847, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 246772, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1394670606, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 58436, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 175979515, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 658, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 38532342, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 167563071, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1988, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11051588, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 246760, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32843790, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 415, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3421, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5779.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6446.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1762, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4136, "avg_search_time_ms": 376.0, "search_nodes": 118610, "safety_nodes": 1014, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 119624, "avg_nodes": 10874.90909090909, "eval_calls": 115405, "avg_eval_calls": 10491.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 115405, "pattern_eval_ns": 2331540, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.203110783761534, "pattern_frame_queries": 115405, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2331540, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.203110783761534, "pattern_frame_updates": 237156, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2560031175, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10794.713922481405, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3184, "avg_candidate_generations": 289.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 223118, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.07474874371859, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 3173, "search_candidate_moves_total": 222370, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 6444, "avg_legality_checks": 585.8181818181819, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6444, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 711292, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 64662.90909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1639279924, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2304.6511474893573, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8443, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 767.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 77619631, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9193.370958190217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52180, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8431, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 77493090, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 74361, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17510431, "stage_ordering_ns": 102130, "stage_eval_ns": 2562362715, "stage_threat_ns": 1542063470, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 237167, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1351220525, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 222422, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 118578, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 160846148, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 237156, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29774375, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 133, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2823, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5410.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6137.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 973, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5749, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 84, 141, 99, 126, 81, 155, 169, 156, 111, 83, 69, 171, 186, 114, 67, 52, 39, 54, 53, 95, 25 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 2787, "avg_search_time_ms": 232.25, "search_nodes": 65204, "safety_nodes": 515, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 65719, "avg_nodes": 5476.583333333333, "eval_calls": 62262, "avg_eval_calls": 5188.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62262, "pattern_eval_ns": 1323086, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.250297131476664, "pattern_frame_queries": 62262, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1323086, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.250297131476664, "pattern_frame_updates": 130340, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1762425140, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13521.751879699248, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2920, "avg_candidate_generations": 243.33333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 225591, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.25719178082191, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 812, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 2908, "search_candidate_moves_total": 224779, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 59030, "avg_legality_checks": 4919.166666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 812, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 58218, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 572428, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 47702.333333333336, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1367861912, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2389.578972377312, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7422, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 618.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 47061700, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6340.838049043385, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 342171, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7382, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 46719529, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.3333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 175770, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10985.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 86950, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4140.476190476191, "stage_move_gen_ns": 144691134, "stage_ordering_ns": 106151, "stage_eval_ns": 1763748226, "stage_threat_ns": 854536994, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 130352, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 749381495, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 252032, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12780, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 65170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88894357, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 130340, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16009110, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 415, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2393, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6197.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6863.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1858, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2950, "avg_search_time_ms": 268.1818181818182, "search_nodes": 72766, "safety_nodes": 1014, "corridor_nodes": 2006, "corridor_branch_probes": 2400, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 23, "corridor_depth_exits": 891, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1988, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1983, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 41, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 29, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 891, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 348, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 337120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 75786, "avg_nodes": 6889.636363636364, "eval_calls": 70124, "avg_eval_calls": 6374.909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70124, "pattern_eval_ns": 1498857, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.374379670298328, "pattern_frame_queries": 70124, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1498857, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.374379670298328, "pattern_frame_updates": 145468, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1625352788, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11173.266890312647, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2621, "avg_candidate_generations": 238.27272727272728, "candidate_moves_total": 182865, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.76917207172835, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 2610, "search_candidate_moves_total": 182117, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 4512, "avg_legality_checks": 410.1818181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4512, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 493917, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 44901.545454545456, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1181724284, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2392.5564092752425, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5040, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 458.1818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42484173, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8429.399404761905, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 49230, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4930, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 41657222, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 79, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 530881, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 246840, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 227370, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9885.652173913044, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.8181818181818183, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 117300, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3783.8709677419356, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12913087, "stage_ordering_ns": 88160, "stage_eval_ns": 1626851645, "stage_threat_ns": 1205448281, "stage_proof_ns": 88761999, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 149573, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 920719221, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 112779, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 135000210, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 971, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 40684982, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74781, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 106713310, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4094, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24060286, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 149562, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18955254, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 133, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2378, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5835.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6563.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1970, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 974, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5909, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 84, 141, 99, 126, 81, 155, 169, 156, 111, 83, 69, 171, 186, 114, 67, 52, 39, 54, 53, 95, 25 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 3238, "avg_search_time_ms": 269.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 65204, "safety_nodes": 515, "corridor_nodes": 936, "corridor_branch_probes": 1075, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 379, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 921, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 921, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 379, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 60, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 439, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 183920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 66655, "avg_nodes": 5554.583333333333, "eval_calls": 62262, "avg_eval_calls": 5188.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62262, "pattern_eval_ns": 1334639, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.435851723362564, "pattern_frame_queries": 62262, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1334639, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.435851723362564, "pattern_frame_updates": 130340, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1770349997, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13582.553299063986, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2920, "avg_candidate_generations": 243.33333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 225591, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.25719178082191, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 812, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 2908, "search_candidate_moves_total": 224779, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 59030, "avg_legality_checks": 4919.166666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 812, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 58218, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 728598, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 60716.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1701755651, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2335.65786757581, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7581, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 631.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 48999706, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6463.488457987073, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 344992, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7382, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 47152565, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 541752, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 117, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 960397, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1980, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 165.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 20408625, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10307.386363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2619, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 218.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 10792226, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4120.743031691485, "stage_move_gen_ns": 144763298, "stage_ordering_ns": 107430, "stage_eval_ns": 1771684636, "stage_threat_ns": 1070918032, "stage_proof_ns": 225441429, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 132320, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 769462555, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 57811, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 184056511, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 655, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 40408184, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66154, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 89596993, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1968, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11688366, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 132308, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16113607, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 415, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2393, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6158.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6825.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1825, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2658, "avg_search_time_ms": 241.63636363636363, "search_nodes": 72766, "safety_nodes": 1014, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 73780, "avg_nodes": 6707.272727272727, "eval_calls": 70124, "avg_eval_calls": 6374.909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70124, "pattern_eval_ns": 1508119, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.50645998516913, "pattern_frame_queries": 70124, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1508119, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.50645998516913, "pattern_frame_updates": 145468, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1637147427, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11254.347533478152, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2621, "avg_candidate_generations": 238.27272727272728, "candidate_moves_total": 182865, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.76917207172835, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 2610, "search_candidate_moves_total": 182117, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 4512, "avg_legality_checks": 410.1818181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4512, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 441113, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 40101.181818181816, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1070152946, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2426.029035643928, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4942, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 449.27272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 41924547, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8483.315864022663, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 48870, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4930, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 41800447, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 75230, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12970489, "stage_ordering_ns": 87941, "stage_eval_ns": 1638655546, "stage_threat_ns": 987933055, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 145479, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 867328216, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 238200, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11930, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72734, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 101886445, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 145468, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18480194, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 133, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2378, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5861.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6589.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 975, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9436, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 126, 141, 99, 109, 98, 140, 142, 94, 100, 97, 114, 93, 95, 125, 157, 77 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4472, "avg_search_time_ms": 496.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 112998, "safety_nodes": 224, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 113222, "avg_nodes": 12580.222222222223, "eval_calls": 108867, "avg_eval_calls": 12096.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 108867, "pattern_eval_ns": 2338771, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.482827670460285, "pattern_frame_queries": 108867, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2338771, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.482827670460285, "pattern_frame_updates": 225944, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2646883479, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11714.776577382007, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4114, "avg_candidate_generations": 457.1111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 270058, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.64365580943121, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 4105, "search_candidate_moves_total": 269558, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 102686, "avg_legality_checks": 11409.555555555555, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 102186, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 723444, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 80382.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1811166804, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2503.534211355682, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8128, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 903.1111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 71130763, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8751.324187992126, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 235582, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8106, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 70895181, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.1111111111111112, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 115931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11593.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.5555555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 61480, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4391.428571428572, "stage_move_gen_ns": 268864508, "stage_ordering_ns": 143980, "stage_eval_ns": 2649222250, "stage_threat_ns": 1538697202, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 225953, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1348786212, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 168112, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9721, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 112972, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 160839593, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 225944, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28903285, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 327, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3594, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4949.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5838.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1789, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4955, "avg_search_time_ms": 550.5555555555555, "search_nodes": 150057, "safety_nodes": 743, "corridor_nodes": 466, "corridor_branch_probes": 549, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 170, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 455, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 455, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 49, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 170, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 49, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 47, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 312, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 176800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 151266, "avg_nodes": 16807.333333333332, "eval_calls": 146502, "avg_eval_calls": 16278.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 146502, "pattern_eval_ns": 3174046, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.66554722802419, "pattern_frame_queries": 146502, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3174046, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.66554722802419, "pattern_frame_updates": 300064, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2743576322, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9143.303835181829, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3539, "avg_candidate_generations": 393.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 234115, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.15286804181973, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 511, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 3530, "search_candidate_moves_total": 233604, "search_candidate_moves_max": 89, "legality_checks": 6050, "avg_legality_checks": 672.2222222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6050, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 656341, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 72926.77777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1586810026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2417.660981105858, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4245, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 471.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 40170863, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9463.100824499412, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4245, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 40170863, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17612977, "stage_ordering_ns": 115480, "stage_eval_ns": 2746750368, "stage_threat_ns": 2090129905, "stage_proof_ns": 84240848, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 301081, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1800607078, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30293, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 35589667, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 406, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13847041, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 150536, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 209511292, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1008, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5727812, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 301072, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38694056, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 128, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3143, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4530.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5418.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1967, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 976, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8711, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 126, 141, 99, 109, 98, 140, 142, 94, 100, 97, 114, 93, 95, 125, 157, 77 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5251, "avg_search_time_ms": 583.4444444444445, "search_nodes": 112998, "safety_nodes": 224, "corridor_nodes": 2538, "corridor_branch_probes": 2886, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1016, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 2513, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2513, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 86, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 61, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1016, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 86, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 692, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 309680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 115760, "avg_nodes": 12862.222222222223, "eval_calls": 108867, "avg_eval_calls": 12096.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 108867, "pattern_eval_ns": 2319362, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.304545913821453, "pattern_frame_queries": 108867, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2319362, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.304545913821453, "pattern_frame_updates": 225944, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2540192644, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11242.576231278546, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4114, "avg_candidate_generations": 457.1111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 270058, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.64365580943121, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 4105, "search_candidate_moves_total": 269558, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 102686, "avg_legality_checks": 11409.555555555555, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 102186, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1105079, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 122786.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2449602562, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2216.6764204188116, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8461, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 940.1111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 69897508, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8261.140290745774, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 236532, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8106, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 67316839, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 83, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1026884, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 250, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1317253, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 6180, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 686.6666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 54985216, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8897.284142394821, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8525, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 947.2222222222222, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 29154806, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3419.9185923753666, "stage_move_gen_ns": 258058128, "stage_ordering_ns": 147101, "stage_eval_ns": 2542512006, "stage_threat_ns": 2004987007, "stage_proof_ns": 429394393, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 231151, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1334282707, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 157957, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 458434153, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1545, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 94882086, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115571, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 157881205, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5198, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26119006, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 231142, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28269936, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 327, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3594, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4788.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5677.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1754, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 3451, "avg_search_time_ms": 383.44444444444446, "search_nodes": 150057, "safety_nodes": 743, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 150800, "avg_nodes": 16755.555555555555, "eval_calls": 146502, "avg_eval_calls": 16278.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 146502, "pattern_eval_ns": 2919029, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.924840616510355, "pattern_frame_queries": 146502, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2919029, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.924840616510355, "pattern_frame_updates": 300064, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1977818101, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6591.320854884291, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3539, "avg_candidate_generations": 393.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 234115, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.15286804181973, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 511, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 3530, "search_candidate_moves_total": 233604, "search_candidate_moves_max": 89, "legality_checks": 6050, "avg_legality_checks": 672.2222222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6050, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 622539, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 69171.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1081817697, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1737.750883077205, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4245, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 471.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 24845819, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5852.960895170789, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4245, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24845819, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14004544, "stage_ordering_ns": 112151, "stage_eval_ns": 1980737130, "stage_threat_ns": 1424312453, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 300073, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1239621899, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 243121, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7890, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 150032, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156044566, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 300064, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28402867, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 128, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3143, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5029.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5917.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 977, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10386, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 84, 125, 83, 126, 129, 139, 153, 124, 127, 99, 85, 123, 122, 82, 115, 116, 87, 86, 101, 143, 73 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5865, "avg_search_time_ms": 488.75, "search_nodes": 137901, "safety_nodes": 515, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 138416, "avg_nodes": 11534.666666666666, "eval_calls": 133608, "avg_eval_calls": 11134.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 133608, "pattern_eval_ns": 2871564, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.492455541584338, "pattern_frame_queries": 133608, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2871564, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.492455541584338, "pattern_frame_updates": 275734, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3651930949, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13244.398402083167, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4271, "avg_candidate_generations": 355.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 314849, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.71786466869585, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 812, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 4259, "search_candidate_moves_total": 314037, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 130326, "avg_legality_checks": 10860.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "root_legality_checks": 812, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 129514, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1089553, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 90796.08333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2679751841, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2459.496546748988, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12182, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1015.1666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 101829758, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8359.034477097357, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 119, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1101297, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12063, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 100728461, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.3333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 169911, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10619.4375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 82310, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3919.5238095238096, "stage_move_gen_ns": 335337941, "stage_ordering_ns": 162950, "stage_eval_ns": 3654802513, "stage_threat_ns": 1849489548, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 275746, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1618541962, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 245082, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 137867, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 196038305, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 275734, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34664199, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 415, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3640, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5740.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6406.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1784, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4511, "avg_search_time_ms": 410.09090909090907, "search_nodes": 116115, "safety_nodes": 1014, "corridor_nodes": 1825, "corridor_branch_probes": 2196, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 14, "corridor_depth_exits": 811, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 1810, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1805, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 811, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 348, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 242880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 118954, "avg_nodes": 10814.0, "eval_calls": 112772, "avg_eval_calls": 10252.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 112772, "pattern_eval_ns": 2428956, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.538644344340796, "pattern_frame_queries": 112772, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2428956, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.538644344340796, "pattern_frame_updates": 232166, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2597026607, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11186.076372078598, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3322, "avg_candidate_generations": 302.0, "candidate_moves_total": 232173, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.88952438290187, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 3311, "search_candidate_moves_total": 231425, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 6742, "avg_legality_checks": 612.9090909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6742, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 720130, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 65466.36363636364, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1756642035, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2439.34016774749, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8105, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 736.8181818181819, "renju_forbidden_ns": 80463812, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9927.675755706354, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52890, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8023, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 79627988, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 51, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 542983, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 239951, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 225882, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9820.95652173913, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.8181818181818183, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 116271, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3750.6774193548385, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19260788, "stage_ordering_ns": 114550, "stage_eval_ns": 2599455563, "stage_threat_ns": 1784829710, "stage_proof_ns": 90220252, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 235915, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1442158528, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 103281, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 119574172, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 904, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 34961465, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 117952, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 170846748, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3738, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22109296, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 235904, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30140966, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 133, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2961, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5323.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6050.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1970, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 978, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10576, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 84, 125, 83, 126, 129, 139, 153, 124, 127, 99, 85, 123, 122, 82, 115, 116, 87, 86, 101, 143, 73 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6374, "avg_search_time_ms": 531.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 137901, "safety_nodes": 515, "corridor_nodes": 1045, "corridor_branch_probes": 1210, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 410, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1030, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1030, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 410, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 60, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 439, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 169360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 139461, "avg_nodes": 11621.75, "eval_calls": 133608, "avg_eval_calls": 11134.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 133608, "pattern_eval_ns": 2876655, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.530559547332494, "pattern_frame_queries": 133608, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2876655, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.530559547332494, "pattern_frame_updates": 275734, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3661631358, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13279.578717169446, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4271, "avg_candidate_generations": 355.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 314849, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.71786466869585, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 812, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 4259, "search_candidate_moves_total": 314037, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 130326, "avg_legality_checks": 10860.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "root_legality_checks": 812, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 129514, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1260702, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 105058.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3051506085, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2420.4816721160114, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12427, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1035.5833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 104221940, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8386.73372495373, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 119, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1084182, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12063, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 100814897, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 61, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 786302, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 184, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1536559, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2269, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 189.08333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 23341084, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10286.94755398854, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 253.41666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 12201965, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4012.4843801381126, "stage_move_gen_ns": 339033770, "stage_ordering_ns": 170780, "stage_eval_ns": 3664508013, "stage_threat_ns": 2103681357, "stage_proof_ns": 239500007, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 277932, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1654426177, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 65318, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 204577601, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 707, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 43728223, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 138960, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 196765409, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2186, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12592299, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 277920, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35319871, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 415, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3640, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5682.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6349.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1750, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4189, "avg_search_time_ms": 380.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 116115, "safety_nodes": 1014, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 117129, "avg_nodes": 10648.09090909091, "eval_calls": 112772, "avg_eval_calls": 10252.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 112772, "pattern_eval_ns": 2435476, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.596460114212746, "pattern_frame_queries": 112772, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2435476, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.596460114212746, "pattern_frame_updates": 232166, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2570182443, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11070.451500219671, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3322, "avg_candidate_generations": 302.0, "candidate_moves_total": 232173, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.88952438290187, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 3311, "search_candidate_moves_total": 231425, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 6742, "avg_legality_checks": 612.9090909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6742, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 669874, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 60897.63636363636, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1630577557, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2434.155612846595, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8035, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 730.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 78805097, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9807.728313627878, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52041, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8023, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 78671674, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 81382, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19265387, "stage_ordering_ns": 124770, "stage_eval_ns": 2572617919, "stage_threat_ns": 1580062374, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 232177, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1385898956, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 232811, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 116083, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 163917054, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 232166, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30013553, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 133, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2961, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5383.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6110.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 979, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9518, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 129, 81, 157, 96, 144, 114, 156, 66, 111, 82, 171, 141, 143, 115, 185 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5243, "avg_search_time_ms": 582.5555555555555, "search_nodes": 143191, "safety_nodes": 224, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 143415, "avg_nodes": 15935.0, "eval_calls": 138797, "avg_eval_calls": 15421.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 138797, "pattern_eval_ns": 2933847, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.137683091133095, "pattern_frame_queries": 138797, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2933847, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.137683091133095, "pattern_frame_updates": 286330, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3093758876, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10804.871567771452, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4377, "avg_candidate_generations": 486.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 280277, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.03404158099154, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 4368, "search_candidate_moves_total": 279777, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 132681, "avg_legality_checks": 14742.333333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 132181, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 889359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 98817.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2050608533, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2305.715164517366, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8536, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 948.4444444444445, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66215518, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7757.206888472352, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 214620, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8511, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 66000898, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.1111111111111112, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 67550, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6755.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.5555555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 35030, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2502.1428571428573, "stage_move_gen_ns": 324542983, "stage_ordering_ns": 163860, "stage_eval_ns": 3096692723, "stage_threat_ns": 1796354892, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 286339, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1577223380, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 103600, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8930, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 143165, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184671445, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 286330, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34356467, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 327, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3874, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4283.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5172.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 701, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4267, "avg_search_time_ms": 474.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 161534, "safety_nodes": 743, "corridor_nodes": 508, "corridor_branch_probes": 598, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 180, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 497, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 497, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 49, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 180, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 49, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 47, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 312, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 179760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 162785, "avg_nodes": 18087.222222222223, "eval_calls": 157735, "avg_eval_calls": 17526.11111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 157735, "pattern_eval_ns": 3214540, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.379370463118523, "pattern_frame_queries": 157735, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3214540, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.379370463118523, "pattern_frame_updates": 323018, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2380696463, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7370.166563473243, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3783, "avg_candidate_generations": 420.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 250665, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.2609040444092, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 511, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 3774, "search_candidate_moves_total": 250154, "search_candidate_moves_max": 89, "legality_checks": 7017, "avg_legality_checks": 779.6666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7017, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 711475, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 79052.77777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1351509346, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1899.587963034541, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6548, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 727.5555555555555, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44581119, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6808.356597434331, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6546, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44552189, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28930, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18851548, "stage_ordering_ns": 134840, "stage_eval_ns": 2383911003, "stage_threat_ns": 1774916330, "stage_proof_ns": 58147506, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 324119, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1514395994, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33381, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 36806300, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 429, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13964181, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 162055, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184073239, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1092, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5906054, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 324110, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33734743, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 128, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3473, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4906.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5795.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 980, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10234, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 129, 81, 157, 96, 144, 114, 156, 66, 111, 82, 171, 141, 143, 115, 185 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5817, "avg_search_time_ms": 646.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 143191, "safety_nodes": 224, "corridor_nodes": 2018, "corridor_branch_probes": 2384, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 792, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1996, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1996, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 86, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 792, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 86, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 692, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 298720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 145433, "avg_nodes": 16159.222222222223, "eval_calls": 138797, "avg_eval_calls": 15421.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 138797, "pattern_eval_ns": 2918783, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.029150485961512, "pattern_frame_queries": 138797, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2918783, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.029150485961512, "pattern_frame_updates": 286330, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2992724967, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10452.01329584745, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4377, "avg_candidate_generations": 486.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 280277, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.03404158099154, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 4368, "search_candidate_moves_total": 279777, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 132681, "avg_legality_checks": 14742.333333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 132181, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1208181, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 134242.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2494284520, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2064.4957336690445, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8867, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 985.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62697146, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7070.84087064396, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 163620, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8511, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60683228, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 92, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 878684, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 239, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 971614, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4894, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 543.7777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 41611067, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8502.465672251737, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6835, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 759.4444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 21996902, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3218.2738844184346, "stage_move_gen_ns": 331919431, "stage_ordering_ns": 158960, "stage_eval_ns": 2995643750, "stage_threat_ns": 2146852391, "stage_proof_ns": 320374412, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 290503, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1586352802, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 127847, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 320858261, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1258, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 66861745, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 145247, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 187302616, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4164, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17970013, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 290494, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34368699, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 327, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3874, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3984.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4873.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 409, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4407, "avg_search_time_ms": 489.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 161534, "safety_nodes": 743, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 162277, "avg_nodes": 18030.777777777777, "eval_calls": 157735, "avg_eval_calls": 17526.11111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 157735, "pattern_eval_ns": 3282373, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.809414524360477, "pattern_frame_queries": 157735, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3282373, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.809414524360477, "pattern_frame_updates": 323018, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2535202390, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7848.486431096719, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3783, "avg_candidate_generations": 420.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 250665, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.2609040444092, "candidate_moves_max": 89, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 511, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 3774, "search_candidate_moves_total": 250154, "search_candidate_moves_max": 89, "legality_checks": 7017, "avg_legality_checks": 779.6666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7017, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 677013, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 75223.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1375523543, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2031.7535158113656, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6546, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 727.3333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51774861, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7909.389092575619, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6546, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 51774861, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18079050, "stage_ordering_ns": 129060, "stage_eval_ns": 2538484763, "stage_threat_ns": 1823720547, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 323027, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1594984427, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 203580, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7710, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 161509, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 193093533, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 323018, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35439007, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 128, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3473, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4771.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5660.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 981, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6067, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 80, 143, 95, 128, 83, 159, 175, 158, 113, 81, 65, 173, 188, 110, 67, 52, 35, 50, 51, 99, 19 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 2720, "avg_search_time_ms": 226.66666666666666, "search_nodes": 63533, "safety_nodes": 515, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 64048, "avg_nodes": 5337.333333333333, "eval_calls": 60652, "avg_eval_calls": 5054.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60652, "pattern_eval_ns": 1303405, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.489893160983975, "pattern_frame_queries": 60652, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1303405, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.489893160983975, "pattern_frame_updates": 126998, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1718432186, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13531.175183861164, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2859, "avg_candidate_generations": 238.25, "candidate_moves_total": 220841, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.24414130814971, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 812, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 2847, "search_candidate_moves_total": 220029, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 57554, "avg_legality_checks": 4796.166666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 812, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 56742, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 552974, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 46081.166666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1331953584, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2408.7092413024843, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7051, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 587.5833333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46212560, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6554.04339809956, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 41, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 353920, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7010, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 45858640, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.3333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 172711, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10794.4375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 84431, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4020.5238095238096, "stage_move_gen_ns": 141437107, "stage_ordering_ns": 107311, "stage_eval_ns": 1719735591, "stage_threat_ns": 833898141, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 127010, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 730890836, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 248721, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 63499, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87332275, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 126998, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15426309, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 415, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2335, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6190.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6856.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1854, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3336, "avg_search_time_ms": 303.27272727272725, "search_nodes": 83306, "safety_nodes": 1014, "corridor_nodes": 1927, "corridor_branch_probes": 2324, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 16, "corridor_depth_exits": 847, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_plies_followed": 1911, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1906, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 847, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 348, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 259440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 86247, "avg_nodes": 7840.636363636364, "eval_calls": 80536, "avg_eval_calls": 7321.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80536, "pattern_eval_ns": 1743664, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.65074004172047, "pattern_frame_queries": 80536, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1743664, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.65074004172047, "pattern_frame_updates": 166548, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1868351662, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11218.09725724716, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2749, "avg_candidate_generations": 249.9090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 193034, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.21971626045836, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 2738, "search_candidate_moves_total": 192286, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 4675, "avg_legality_checks": 425.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4675, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 557283, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 50662.09090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1335710734, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2396.8266284814, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6008, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 546.1818181818181, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50523645, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8409.394973368842, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 48420, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5905, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 49616183, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 609142, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 249900, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 226932, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9866.608695652174, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.8181818181818183, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 117782, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3799.4193548387098, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13486128, "stage_ordering_ns": 92951, "stage_eval_ns": 1870095326, "stage_threat_ns": 1342387489, "stage_proof_ns": 89976918, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 170499, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1045796995, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 109905, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 130309390, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 939, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 37148583, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85244, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121433534, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3940, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 23158010, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 170488, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21689560, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 133, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2485, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5734.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6462.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 982, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6250, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 80, 143, 95, 128, 83, 159, 175, 158, 113, 81, 65, 173, 188, 110, 67, 52, 35, 50, 51, 99, 19 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 3183, "avg_search_time_ms": 265.25, "search_nodes": 63533, "safety_nodes": 515, "corridor_nodes": 952, "corridor_branch_probes": 1097, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 387, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 937, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 937, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 387, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 60, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 439, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 178080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 65000, "avg_nodes": 5416.666666666667, "eval_calls": 60652, "avg_eval_calls": 5054.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60652, "pattern_eval_ns": 1302334, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.472235045835255, "pattern_frame_queries": 60652, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1302334, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.472235045835255, "pattern_frame_updates": 126998, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1724277995, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13577.205900880328, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2859, "avg_candidate_generations": 238.25, "candidate_moves_total": 220841, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.24414130814971, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 812, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 2847, "search_candidate_moves_total": 220029, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 57554, "avg_legality_checks": 4796.166666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 812, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 56742, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 711495, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 59291.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1668530758, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2345.1053879507235, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7230, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 602.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 48019594, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6641.714246196404, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 41, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 355012, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7010, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 45944116, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 668281, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 127, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1052185, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2077, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 173.08333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 21634289, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10416.12373615792, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2761, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 230.08333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 11399147, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4128.629844259326, "stage_move_gen_ns": 141644170, "stage_ordering_ns": 105980, "stage_eval_ns": 1725580329, "stage_threat_ns": 1062801073, "stage_proof_ns": 228960085, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 129010, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 757681660, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 58646, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 188097170, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 659, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 40904404, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64499, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 89467596, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2000, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11966265, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128998, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15588382, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 415, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2335, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6148.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6815.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1818, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3056, "avg_search_time_ms": 277.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 83306, "safety_nodes": 1014, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 84320, "avg_nodes": 7665.454545454545, "eval_calls": 80536, "avg_eval_calls": 7321.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80536, "pattern_eval_ns": 1732216, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.508592430714216, "pattern_frame_queries": 80536, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1732216, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.508592430714216, "pattern_frame_updates": 166548, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1882170737, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11301.070784398491, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2749, "avg_candidate_generations": 249.9090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 193034, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.21971626045836, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 2738, "search_candidate_moves_total": 192286, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 4675, "avg_legality_checks": 425.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4675, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 506132, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 46012.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1232243435, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2434.6285850331533, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5917, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 537.9090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50095442, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8466.35828967382, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 48560, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5905, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 49969292, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 77590, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13392339, "stage_ordering_ns": 91710, "stage_eval_ns": 1883902953, "stage_threat_ns": 1138444400, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 166559, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1000013178, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 239290, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12140, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 83274, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 117135245, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 166548, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21056687, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 133, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2485, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5772.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6499.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 983, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12233, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 140, 82, 141, 143, 114, 156, 84, 97, 100, 86, 52, 68, 99, 129, 139, 138, 127, 113, 54, 69, 81, 83, 53, 55, 111, 41 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3119, "avg_search_time_ms": 222.78571428571428, "search_nodes": 74918, "safety_nodes": 1222, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76140, "avg_nodes": 5438.571428571428, "eval_calls": 71835, "avg_eval_calls": 5131.071428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71835, "pattern_eval_ns": 1545336, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.512299018584255, "pattern_frame_queries": 71835, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1545336, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.512299018584255, "pattern_frame_updates": 149756, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1928069161, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12874.737312695317, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3057, "avg_candidate_generations": 218.35714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 243371, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.6110565914295, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1031, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 3043, "search_candidate_moves_total": 242340, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 66337, "avg_legality_checks": 4738.357142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 52, "root_legality_checks": 1031, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 65306, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 52, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 579709, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 41407.78571428572, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1413639512, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2438.532974302624, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12306, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 879.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 99199318, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8061.052982285064, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 58, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 532160, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12244, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 98659638, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7520, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 549272, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11209.632653061224, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 281521, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3910.0138888888887, "stage_move_gen_ns": 165570129, "stage_ordering_ns": 122712, "stage_eval_ns": 1929614497, "stage_threat_ns": 998475524, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 149770, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 874082741, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 753982, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74878, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105266932, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 149756, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18371869, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 278, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2644, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6385.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6956.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1755, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 9100, "avg_search_time_ms": 700.0, "search_nodes": 267062, "safety_nodes": 882, "corridor_nodes": 1238, "corridor_branch_probes": 1484, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 420, "corridor_neutral_exits": 23, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1211, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1211, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 117, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 90, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 420, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 117, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 117, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 876, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 387440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 269182, "avg_nodes": 20706.30769230769, "eval_calls": 259207, "avg_eval_calls": 19939.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 259207, "pattern_eval_ns": 5598729, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.599451403704375, "pattern_frame_queries": 259207, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5598729, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.599451403704375, "pattern_frame_updates": 534048, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5165885187, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9673.072808062198, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7830, "avg_candidate_generations": 602.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 675108, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.22068965517241, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 962, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 7817, "search_candidate_moves_total": 674146, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 13478, "avg_legality_checks": 1036.7692307692307, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 13478, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1400696, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 107745.84615384616, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3346198261, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2388.9539636009526, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12762, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 981.6923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 121988406, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9558.721673718854, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 59150, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12646, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 120504591, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 966983, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 457682, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 37336516, "stage_ordering_ns": 286702, "stage_eval_ns": 5171483916, "stage_threat_ns": 3651149705, "stage_proof_ns": 205864466, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 536717, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3081344903, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 85743, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 115877419, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1078, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 48840792, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 268352, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 373493945, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2656, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14621792, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 536704, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65811646, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 447, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6760, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5893.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6509.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1959, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 984, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12432, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 140, 82, 141, 143, 114, 156, 84, 97, 100, 86, 52, 68, 99, 129, 139, 138, 127, 113, 54, 69, 81, 83, 53, 55, 111, 41 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3739, "avg_search_time_ms": 267.07142857142856, "search_nodes": 74918, "safety_nodes": 1222, "corridor_nodes": 1386, "corridor_branch_probes": 1676, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 581, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_plies_followed": 1370, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1370, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 73, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 581, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 73, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 70, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 464, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 198240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 15760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 77526, "avg_nodes": 5537.571428571428, "eval_calls": 71835, "avg_eval_calls": 5131.071428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71835, "pattern_eval_ns": 1554126, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.63466276884527, "pattern_frame_queries": 71835, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1554126, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.63466276884527, "pattern_frame_updates": 149756, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1918438383, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12810.427515425092, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3057, "avg_candidate_generations": 218.35714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 243371, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.6110565914295, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1031, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 3043, "search_candidate_moves_total": 242340, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 66337, "avg_legality_checks": 4738.357142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 52, "root_legality_checks": 1031, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 65306, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 52, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 799416, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 57101.142857142855, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1862252781, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2329.516523312018, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12974, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 926.7142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 101976413, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7860.059580699861, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 58, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 545000, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12244, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 97664457, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 187, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1523606, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 485, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2243350, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3639, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 259.92857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 39171757, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10764.4289640011, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5242, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 374.42857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 21258834, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4055.481495612362, "stage_move_gen_ns": 164870701, "stage_ordering_ns": 120880, "stage_eval_ns": 1919992509, "stage_threat_ns": 1335570482, "stage_proof_ns": 290534183, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152656, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 911923134, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 81856, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 278475829, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 851, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 56593711, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76321, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107258948, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2886, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19178849, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152642, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18733722, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 278, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2644, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6350.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6922.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1718, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8680, "avg_search_time_ms": 667.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 267062, "safety_nodes": 882, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 267944, "avg_nodes": 20611.076923076922, "eval_calls": 259207, "avg_eval_calls": 19939.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 259207, "pattern_eval_ns": 5619210, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.678465473540452, "pattern_frame_queries": 259207, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5619210, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.678465473540452, "pattern_frame_updates": 534048, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5129526913, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9604.99227223021, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7830, "avg_candidate_generations": 602.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 675108, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.22068965517241, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 962, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 7817, "search_candidate_moves_total": 674146, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 13478, "avg_legality_checks": 1036.7692307692307, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 13478, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1312826, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 100986.61538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3130718164, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2384.716759113546, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12656, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 973.5384615384615, "renju_forbidden_ns": 118750166, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9382.914506953224, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 60750, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12646, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 118628396, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 37175014, "stage_ordering_ns": 283803, "stage_eval_ns": 5135146123, "stage_threat_ns": 3463570176, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 534061, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3036880319, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 301470, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14270, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 267024, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 360881977, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 534048, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65506410, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 447, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6760, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5942.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6558.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1964, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 985, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11925, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 144, 160, 142, 95, 125, 78, 127, 50, 65, 157, 143, 145, 113, 158, 141, 140, 155, 99, 169 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10283, "avg_search_time_ms": 934.8181818181819, "search_nodes": 248106, "safety_nodes": 625, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 248731, "avg_nodes": 22611.909090909092, "eval_calls": 241965, "avg_eval_calls": 21996.81818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 241965, "pattern_eval_ns": 5212718, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.543272787386606, "pattern_frame_queries": 241965, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5212718, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.543272787386606, "pattern_frame_updates": 496150, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6270082981, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12637.47451577144, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6121, "avg_candidate_generations": 556.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 484421, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.14082666231008, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 810, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 6110, "search_candidate_moves_total": 483611, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 236338, "avg_legality_checks": 21485.272727272728, "illegal_moves_skipped": 242, "root_legality_checks": 810, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 235528, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 239, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1694169, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 154015.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4358987874, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2572.9356835120934, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31722, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2883.818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 299280074, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9434.464220414855, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 250, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2599246, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 31453, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 296482046, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 198782, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.3636363636363638, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 359511, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9716.513513513513, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 48, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.363636363636363, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 155451, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3238.5625, "stage_move_gen_ns": 608799940, "stage_ordering_ns": 224780, "stage_eval_ns": 6275295699, "stage_threat_ns": 3372642926, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 496161, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2952439962, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 455801, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 248075, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 357389808, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 496150, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62357355, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 419, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5424, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4156.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4883.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 1633, "avg_search_time_ms": 163.3, "search_nodes": 45077, "safety_nodes": 960, "corridor_nodes": 1539, "corridor_branch_probes": 1815, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 754, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1526, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1526, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 41, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 754, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 328, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 161520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 47576, "avg_nodes": 4757.6, "eval_calls": 43009, "avg_eval_calls": 4300.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 43009, "pattern_eval_ns": 925544, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.519774930828433, "pattern_frame_queries": 43009, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 925544, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.519774930828433, "pattern_frame_updates": 90096, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 764891200, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8489.735393358196, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2049, "avg_candidate_generations": 204.9, "candidate_moves_total": 168716, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.34065397755002, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 733, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 2039, "search_candidate_moves_total": 167983, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 5657, "avg_legality_checks": 565.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5657, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 229853, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22985.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 564018750, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2453.8237482216896, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2200, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 220.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 22341780, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10155.354545454546, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 69062, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2108, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21122347, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 61, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 812150, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 338221, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15700317, "stage_ordering_ns": 75650, "stage_eval_ns": 765816744, "stage_threat_ns": 749328653, "stage_proof_ns": 84533448, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 93266, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 563455449, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 79707, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 89142228, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 763, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 30907151, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 46628, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 66212126, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3160, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19277027, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 93256, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11241823, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 157, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1804, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5873.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6673.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 986, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19279, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 97, 95, 125, 142, 94, 65, 50, 158, 174, 81, 83, 111, 98, 143, 68, 113, 127, 144, 82, 67, 66, 114, 34 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 11460, "avg_search_time_ms": 881.5384615384615, "search_nodes": 261067, "safety_nodes": 1033, "corridor_nodes": 2167, "corridor_branch_probes": 2427, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 883, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 2141, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2141, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 94, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 68, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 883, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 94, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 92, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 658, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 209360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 264267, "avg_nodes": 20328.23076923077, "eval_calls": 255070, "avg_eval_calls": 19620.76923076923, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 255070, "pattern_eval_ns": 5395991, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.154941780687654, "pattern_frame_queries": 255070, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5395991, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.154941780687654, "pattern_frame_updates": 522060, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6604715353, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12651.257236716086, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5973, "avg_candidate_generations": 459.46153846153845, "candidate_moves_total": 456425, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.41469948099783, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 885, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 5960, "search_candidate_moves_total": 455540, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 250257, "avg_legality_checks": 19250.53846153846, "illegal_moves_skipped": 604, "root_legality_checks": 885, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 249372, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 602, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2300150, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 176934.61538461538, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5356888968, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2328.930273243049, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31529, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2425.3076923076924, "renju_forbidden_ns": 293865790, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9320.491928066225, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 608, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5473551, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28810, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 274380793, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 484, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3718362, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1627, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 10293084, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 5059, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 389.15384615384613, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 51888291, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10256.629966396522, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6511, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 500.84615384615387, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 27695680, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4253.675318691446, "stage_move_gen_ns": 602292848, "stage_ordering_ns": 202290, "stage_eval_ns": 6610111344, "stage_threat_ns": 3797958046, "stage_proof_ns": 411706216, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 526543, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2934039270, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 128638, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 419167099, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1369, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 87255703, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 263265, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 353038313, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4470, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 29105608, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 526530, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62607756, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 301, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5360, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5115.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5731.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 4, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7804, "avg_search_time_ms": 650.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 249071, "safety_nodes": 645, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 249716, "avg_nodes": 20809.666666666668, "eval_calls": 242582, "avg_eval_calls": 20215.166666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 242582, "pattern_eval_ns": 5231681, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.56664962775474, "pattern_frame_queries": 242582, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5231681, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.56664962775474, "pattern_frame_updates": 498072, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4461762065, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8958.06643417016, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6466, "avg_candidate_generations": 538.8333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 502805, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.76136715125271, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 828, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 6454, "search_candidate_moves_total": 501977, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 13436, "avg_legality_checks": 1119.6666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 13436, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1108241, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 92353.41666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2661345451, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2401.413998399265, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7336, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 611.3333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 54954293, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7491.043211559433, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 55370, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7320, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 54786243, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 112680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 36446383, "stage_ordering_ns": 227562, "stage_eval_ns": 4466993746, "stage_threat_ns": 3267481914, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 498084, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2866653597, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 96762, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12831, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 249036, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 339093805, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 498072, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61637750, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 360, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5792, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5720.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6386.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1988, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 987, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24333, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 110, 83, 81, 54, 111, 68, 40, 109, 114, 113, 125, 95, 155, 170, 94, 142, 124, 127, 108, 85, 86, 99, 71, 141 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 21563, "avg_search_time_ms": 1540.2142857142858, "search_nodes": 565008, "safety_nodes": 400, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 565408, "avg_nodes": 40386.28571428572, "eval_calls": 552290, "avg_eval_calls": 39449.28571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 552290, "pattern_eval_ns": 11795637, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.35768708468377, "pattern_frame_queries": 552290, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11795637, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.35768708468377, "pattern_frame_updates": 1129934, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 13011198706, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11515.007696024724, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12691, "avg_candidate_generations": 906.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1113232, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.71822551414388, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1096, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 12677, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1112136, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 538692, "avg_legality_checks": 38478.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 196, "root_legality_checks": 1096, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 537596, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 196, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3808422, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 272030.14285714284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9250631675, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2428.9933402863444, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48071, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3433.6428571428573, "renju_forbidden_ns": 508883665, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10586.084437602713, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 198, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2033951, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 47873, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 506849714, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.7142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 124630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12463.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 68100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4864.285714285715, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1305548733, "stage_ordering_ns": 453581, "stage_eval_ns": 13022994343, "stage_threat_ns": 7155279123, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1129948, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6247753104, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 188181, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15210, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 564967, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 771691018, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1129934, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 135646820, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 670, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 11495, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2874.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3340.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2755, "avg_search_time_ms": 196.78571428571428, "search_nodes": 85927, "safety_nodes": 1633, "corridor_nodes": 3135, "corridor_branch_probes": 3770, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 7, "corridor_depth_exits": 1648, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 3119, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3119, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 45, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1648, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 59, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 341, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 139920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9360, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 90695, "avg_nodes": 6478.214285714285, "eval_calls": 82881, "avg_eval_calls": 5920.071428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82881, "pattern_eval_ns": 1781537, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.495119508693186, "pattern_frame_queries": 82881, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1781537, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.495119508693186, "pattern_frame_updates": 171774, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1252738697, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7292.947110738529, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3020, "avg_candidate_generations": 215.71428571428572, "candidate_moves_total": 259569, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.95, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1124, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 3006, "search_candidate_moves_total": 258445, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 7665, "avg_legality_checks": 547.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7665, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 359101, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 25650.071428571428, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 839208089, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2336.969512755464, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2391, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 170.78571428571428, "renju_forbidden_ns": 25110107, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10501.926808866583, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2280, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 23884701, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 111, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1225406, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20911983, "stage_ordering_ns": 103371, "stage_eval_ns": 1254520234, "stage_threat_ns": 1372332880, "stage_proof_ns": 85626801, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 178148, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1027657353, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 147281, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 160626309, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1225, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 48954355, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89067, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121964369, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6360, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 40646468, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 178134, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21438381, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 171, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2746, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6452.785714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7024.214285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 988, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24965, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 110, 83, 81, 54, 111, 68, 40, 109, 114, 113, 125, 95, 155, 170, 94, 142, 124, 127, 108, 85, 86, 99, 71, 141 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 22606, "avg_search_time_ms": 1614.7142857142858, "search_nodes": 567959, "safety_nodes": 400, "corridor_nodes": 3130, "corridor_branch_probes": 3744, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1370, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 3094, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3094, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 101, "corridor_proof_active": 36, "corridor_proof_quiet": 65, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1370, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 101, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 99, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 822, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 357040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 571489, "avg_nodes": 40820.642857142855, "eval_calls": 555191, "avg_eval_calls": 39656.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 555191, "pattern_eval_ns": 11762776, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.186899643546095, "pattern_frame_queries": 555191, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11762776, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.186899643546095, "pattern_frame_updates": 1135836, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 12892017316, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11350.245384016707, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12741, "avg_candidate_generations": 910.0714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 1117678, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.72294168432619, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1096, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 12727, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1116582, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 541593, "avg_legality_checks": 38685.21428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 196, "root_legality_checks": 1096, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 540497, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 196, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4269124, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 304937.4285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10055377733, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2355.372608760017, "renju_forbidden_checks": 50111, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3579.3571428571427, "renju_forbidden_ns": 520440564, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10385.75490411287, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 198, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2002299, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 48168, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 502809418, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 565, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6591303, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1180, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9037544, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 7498, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 535.5714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 79575434, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10612.887970125366, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10856, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 775.4285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 44079845, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4060.4131355932204, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1297646771, "stage_ordering_ns": 444327, "stage_eval_ns": 12903780092, "stage_threat_ns": 7809949699, "stage_proof_ns": 516851856, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1142240, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6282173880, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 177007, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 577391970, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1671, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 116698990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 571113, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 772735781, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6390, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 42410425, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1142226, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 135237643, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 671, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 11541, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2396.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2788.9285714285716, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2344, "avg_search_time_ms": 167.42857142857142, "search_nodes": 85927, "safety_nodes": 1633, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87560, "avg_nodes": 6254.285714285715, "eval_calls": 82881, "avg_eval_calls": 5920.071428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82881, "pattern_eval_ns": 1746519, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.072610127773554, "pattern_frame_queries": 82881, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1746519, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.072610127773554, "pattern_frame_updates": 171774, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1229888849, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7159.924371557978, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3020, "avg_candidate_generations": 215.71428571428572, "candidate_moves_total": 259569, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.95, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1124, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 3006, "search_candidate_moves_total": 258445, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 7665, "avg_legality_checks": 547.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7665, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 300777, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21484.071428571428, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 697595582, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2319.3115896494746, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2280, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 162.85714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 23613472, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10356.78596491228, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2280, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 23613472, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20579188, "stage_ordering_ns": 102041, "stage_eval_ns": 1231635368, "stage_threat_ns": 1063549620, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 171788, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 930031062, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 375780, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85887, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113228261, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 171774, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19914517, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 171, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2746, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6462.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7034.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 989, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8885, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 144, 82, 129, 99, 130, 110, 146, 162, 159, 174, 68, 97, 127, 111, 113, 83, 69, 80, 64, 81, 84, 79 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5771, "avg_search_time_ms": 480.9166666666667, "search_nodes": 135314, "safety_nodes": 343, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 135657, "avg_nodes": 11304.75, "eval_calls": 130300, "avg_eval_calls": 10858.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 130300, "pattern_eval_ns": 2699363, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.716523407521105, "pattern_frame_queries": 130300, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2699363, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.716523407521105, "pattern_frame_updates": 270560, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3763518579, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13910.10710748078, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4992, "avg_candidate_generations": 416.0, "candidate_moves_total": 424161, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.96814903846153, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 876, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 4980, "search_candidate_moves_total": 423285, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 125272, "avg_legality_checks": 10439.333333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 278, "root_legality_checks": 876, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 124396, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 277, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1172105, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 97675.41666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2777458667, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2369.6329825399603, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30851, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2570.9166666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 249602481, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8090.57991637224, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 294, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2934919, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 30552, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 246602732, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 64830, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 93480, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10386.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 46090, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3840.8333333333335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 301499961, "stage_ordering_ns": 175150, "stage_eval_ns": 3766217942, "stage_threat_ns": 1680872584, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 270572, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1469674815, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 147890, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 135280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 179389023, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 270560, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31660856, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 590, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4195, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6135.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6802.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1809, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3101, "avg_search_time_ms": 281.90909090909093, "search_nodes": 92152, "safety_nodes": 1205, "corridor_nodes": 711, "corridor_branch_probes": 826, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 341, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 702, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 697, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 45, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 341, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 322, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 189120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 94068, "avg_nodes": 8551.636363636364, "eval_calls": 89350, "avg_eval_calls": 8122.727272727273, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89350, "pattern_eval_ns": 1816840, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.333967543368775, "pattern_frame_queries": 89350, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1816840, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.333967543368775, "pattern_frame_updates": 184240, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1705638256, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9257.697872340426, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2781, "avg_candidate_generations": 252.8181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 206756, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.34591873426825, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 2770, "search_candidate_moves_total": 205948, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 4663, "avg_legality_checks": 423.90909090909093, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4663, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 462255, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 42023.181818181816, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1081862070, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2340.4010124282054, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3424, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 311.27272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 34733184, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10144.03738317757, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25730, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3384, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34405262, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 152010, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 150182, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 406002, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7518.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 79, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.181818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 145841, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1846.0886075949368, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12826439, "stage_ordering_ns": 90680, "stage_eval_ns": 1707455096, "stage_threat_ns": 1270583286, "stage_proof_ns": 91807015, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 185763, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1071373584, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38834, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 44830684, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 488, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17463207, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92876, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 124007277, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1512, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7892276, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 185752, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22479465, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 131, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2479, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5665.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6392.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 990, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9770, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 144, 82, 129, 99, 130, 110, 146, 162, 159, 174, 68, 97, 127, 111, 113, 83, 69, 80, 64, 81, 84, 79 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6849, "avg_search_time_ms": 570.75, "search_nodes": 135314, "safety_nodes": 343, "corridor_nodes": 3281, "corridor_branch_probes": 3592, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1452, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 3259, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3259, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 89, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1452, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 89, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 695, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 192080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 138938, "avg_nodes": 11578.166666666666, "eval_calls": 130300, "avg_eval_calls": 10858.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 130300, "pattern_eval_ns": 2675168, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.53083653108212, "pattern_frame_queries": 130300, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2675168, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.53083653108212, "pattern_frame_updates": 270560, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3674696158, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13581.816077764637, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4992, "avg_candidate_generations": 416.0, "candidate_moves_total": 424161, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.96814903846153, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 876, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 4980, "search_candidate_moves_total": 423285, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 125272, "avg_legality_checks": 10439.333333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 278, "root_legality_checks": 876, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 124396, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 277, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1632194, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 136016.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3570056704, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2187.274738174506, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32521, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2710.0833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 261121034, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8029.305187417361, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 294, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2924169, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 30552, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 241443605, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 541, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6769602, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1134, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9983658, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 8763, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 730.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 84109870, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9598.296245577998, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11744, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 978.6666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 44277783, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3770.247190054496, "stage_move_gen_ns": 295179289, "stage_ordering_ns": 184100, "stage_eval_ns": 3677371326, "stage_threat_ns": 2369598140, "stage_proof_ns": 482704328, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 277268, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1527578101, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 187205, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 588319760, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1920, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 121692836, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 138628, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184476513, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6696, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 37107859, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 277256, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32115907, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 590, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4195, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6081.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6748.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1772, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2909, "avg_search_time_ms": 264.45454545454544, "search_nodes": 92152, "safety_nodes": 1205, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 93357, "avg_nodes": 8487.0, "eval_calls": 89350, "avg_eval_calls": 8122.727272727273, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89350, "pattern_eval_ns": 1830348, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.485148293228875, "pattern_frame_queries": 89350, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1830348, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.485148293228875, "pattern_frame_updates": 184240, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1676244896, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9098.159444203213, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2781, "avg_candidate_generations": 252.8181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 206756, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.34591873426825, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 2770, "search_candidate_moves_total": 205948, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 4663, "avg_legality_checks": 423.90909090909093, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4663, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 422374, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 38397.63636363636, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 981446028, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2323.6421465336407, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3391, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 308.27272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32096377, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9465.165732822177, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24410, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3384, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32003447, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 68520, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12674711, "stage_ordering_ns": 86971, "stage_eval_ns": 1678075244, "stage_threat_ns": 1200001547, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 184251, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1054843379, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 356783, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92120, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 122157329, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 184240, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22644056, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 131, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2479, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5700.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6427.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 991, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11476, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 144, 82, 143, 141, 110, 158, 80, 97, 94, 78, 52, 66, 95, 125, 145, 146, 127, 111, 50, 65, 83, 81, 51, 49, 113, 33 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2750, "avg_search_time_ms": 196.42857142857142, "search_nodes": 71544, "safety_nodes": 1222, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 72766, "avg_nodes": 5197.571428571428, "eval_calls": 68557, "avg_eval_calls": 4896.928571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68557, "pattern_eval_ns": 1387896, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.24440976122059, "pattern_frame_queries": 68557, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1387896, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.24440976122059, "pattern_frame_updates": 143008, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1690226623, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11819.105385712688, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2961, "avg_candidate_generations": 211.5, "candidate_moves_total": 236638, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.91827085444106, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1031, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 2947, "search_candidate_moves_total": 235607, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 63534, "avg_legality_checks": 4538.142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "root_legality_checks": 1031, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 62503, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 551600, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 39400.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1235888299, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2240.551666062364, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12663, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 904.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 93687168, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7398.497038616441, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 314351, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12619, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 93365797, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 506122, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10329.020408163266, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 261841, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3636.6805555555557, "stage_move_gen_ns": 145348144, "stage_ordering_ns": 105280, "stage_eval_ns": 1691614519, "stage_threat_ns": 888013160, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 143022, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 778395891, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 697752, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 71504, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92635929, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 143008, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16283588, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 278, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2550, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6426.785714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6998.214285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1818, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8711, "avg_search_time_ms": 670.0769230769231, "search_nodes": 279251, "safety_nodes": 882, "corridor_nodes": 1116, "corridor_branch_probes": 1345, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 358, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_plies_followed": 1090, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1090, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 117, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 91, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 358, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 117, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 117, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 876, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 439760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 281249, "avg_nodes": 21634.53846153846, "eval_calls": 271545, "avg_eval_calls": 20888.076923076922, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 271545, "pattern_eval_ns": 5465574, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.127691542838203, "pattern_frame_queries": 271545, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5465574, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.127691542838203, "pattern_frame_updates": 558426, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4926688327, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8822.455127447503, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7681, "avg_candidate_generations": 590.8461538461538, "candidate_moves_total": 670358, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.27483400598881, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 962, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 7668, "search_candidate_moves_total": 669396, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 12548, "avg_legality_checks": 965.2307692307693, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 12548, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1453191, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 111783.92307692308, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3182926202, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2190.3013451087986, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15111, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1162.3846153846155, "renju_forbidden_ns": 132834809, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8790.603467672556, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 28050, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15008, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 131658866, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 63, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 735012, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 412881, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 32212542, "stage_ordering_ns": 251570, "stage_eval_ns": 4932153901, "stage_threat_ns": 3516952351, "stage_proof_ns": 192208201, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 560853, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2981435032, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 79005, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 100420501, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1041, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 43383528, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 280420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 358614015, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2414, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12662733, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 560840, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63820070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 447, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6425, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6086.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6701.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1968, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 992, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11808, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 144, 82, 143, 141, 110, 158, 80, 97, 94, 78, 52, 66, 95, 125, 145, 146, 127, 111, 50, 65, 83, 81, 51, 49, 113, 33 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3361, "avg_search_time_ms": 240.07142857142858, "search_nodes": 71544, "safety_nodes": 1222, "corridor_nodes": 1398, "corridor_branch_probes": 1708, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 597, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_plies_followed": 1382, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1382, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 73, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 597, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 73, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 70, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 464, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 202480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 15760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 74164, "avg_nodes": 5297.428571428572, "eval_calls": 68557, "avg_eval_calls": 4896.928571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68557, "pattern_eval_ns": 1403727, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.47532710007731, "pattern_frame_queries": 68557, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1403727, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.47532710007731, "pattern_frame_updates": 143008, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1703282298, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11910.398704967554, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2961, "avg_candidate_generations": 211.5, "candidate_moves_total": 236638, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.91827085444106, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1031, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 2947, "search_candidate_moves_total": 235607, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 63534, "avg_legality_checks": 4538.142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "root_legality_checks": 1031, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 62503, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 770496, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 55035.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1668685088, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2165.7284242877317, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13312, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 950.8571428571429, "renju_forbidden_ns": 97695377, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7338.8955078125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 314650, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12619, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 94083575, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 176, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1313685, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 477, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1983467, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3656, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 261.14285714285717, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 36747355, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10051.24589715536, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5292, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 378.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 19983619, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3776.1940665154953, "stage_move_gen_ns": 146394671, "stage_ordering_ns": 104890, "stage_eval_ns": 1704686025, "stage_threat_ns": 1207491980, "stage_proof_ns": 272344122, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 145932, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 818962665, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 81468, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 257719986, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 851, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 52649313, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72959, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96008733, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2910, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17971494, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 145918, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16829102, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 278, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2550, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6391.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6963.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1779, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8436, "avg_search_time_ms": 648.9230769230769, "search_nodes": 279251, "safety_nodes": 882, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 280133, "avg_nodes": 21548.69230769231, "eval_calls": 271545, "avg_eval_calls": 20888.076923076922, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 271545, "pattern_eval_ns": 5519698, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.32701025612698, "pattern_frame_queries": 271545, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5519698, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.32701025612698, "pattern_frame_updates": 558426, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4966765701, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8894.223587368782, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7681, "avg_candidate_generations": 590.8461538461538, "candidate_moves_total": 670358, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.27483400598881, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 962, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 7668, "search_candidate_moves_total": 669396, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 12548, "avg_legality_checks": 965.2307692307693, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 12548, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1366088, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 105083.69230769231, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3023627453, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2213.3474951833264, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15016, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1155.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 132802337, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8844.055474160896, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 27770, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15008, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 132718087, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 56480, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 32348079, "stage_ordering_ns": 246923, "stage_eval_ns": 4972285399, "stage_threat_ns": 3384461740, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 558439, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2966846431, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 277971, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13530, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 279213, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 353089429, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 558426, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64247909, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 447, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6425, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6118.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6733.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 993, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25451, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 114, 81, 83, 50, 113, 66, 34, 115, 110, 111, 129, 99, 159, 174, 100, 142, 130, 127, 116, 79, 78, 95, 63, 143 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 22970, "avg_search_time_ms": 1640.7142857142858, "search_nodes": 625367, "safety_nodes": 400, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 625767, "avg_nodes": 44697.642857142855, "eval_calls": 611968, "avg_eval_calls": 43712.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 611968, "pattern_eval_ns": 12530074, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.4750477149132, "pattern_frame_queries": 611968, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 12530074, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.4750477149132, "pattern_frame_updates": 1250652, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 13903306540, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11116.846684769225, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13372, "avg_candidate_generations": 955.1428571428571, "candidate_moves_total": 1177657, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.06887526174096, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1096, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 13358, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1176561, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 598496, "avg_legality_checks": 42749.71428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 249, "root_legality_checks": 1096, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 597400, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 249, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4283026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 305930.4285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9867349289, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2303.8266144076642, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60265, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4304.642857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 589592425, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9783.330706048288, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 253, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2446495, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 60012, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 587145930, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.7142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 119360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11936.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 63860, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4561.428571428572, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1383192827, "stage_ordering_ns": 437973, "stage_eval_ns": 13915836614, "stage_threat_ns": 7581601866, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1250666, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6624682390, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 179830, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14440, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 625326, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 813213672, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1250652, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 143525974, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 682, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 12134, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7142857142857144, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2604.3571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2971.214285714286, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2469, "avg_search_time_ms": 176.35714285714286, "search_nodes": 80765, "safety_nodes": 1633, "corridor_nodes": 3181, "corridor_branch_probes": 3815, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 7, "corridor_depth_exits": 1696, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 3166, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3166, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1696, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 59, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 341, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 143120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 85579, "avg_nodes": 6112.785714285715, "eval_calls": 77771, "avg_eval_calls": 5555.071428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77771, "pattern_eval_ns": 1600221, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.57606305692353, "pattern_frame_queries": 77771, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1600221, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.57606305692353, "pattern_frame_updates": 161450, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1101231842, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6820.884744502942, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2968, "avg_candidate_generations": 212.0, "candidate_moves_total": 255356, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.03638814016172, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1124, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 2954, "search_candidate_moves_total": 254232, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 8217, "avg_legality_checks": 586.9285714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8217, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 325616, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23258.285714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 741363376, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2276.8026632597907, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2847, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 203.35714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29037610, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10199.371268001405, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2733, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27781352, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 114, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1256258, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 21423831, "stage_ordering_ns": 98600, "stage_eval_ns": 1102832063, "stage_threat_ns": 1241189751, "stage_proof_ns": 81725583, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 167918, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 923557295, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 147061, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 150975816, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1225, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 46517469, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 83952, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 109057647, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6454, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 38798916, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 167904, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18800077, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 171, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2689, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6465.357142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7036.785714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 994, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 33649, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 114, 81, 83, 50, 113, 66, 34, 115, 110, 111, 129, 99, 159, 174, 100, 142, 86, 72, 78, 94, 108, 188, 146, 65, 35, 67, 68, 52, 38, 37, 22, 97 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 24710, "avg_search_time_ms": 1372.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 646991, "safety_nodes": 1390, "corridor_nodes": 2550, "corridor_branch_probes": 2940, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1154, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 2521, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2516, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 93, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1154, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 93, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 92, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 700, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 339120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 650931, "avg_nodes": 36162.833333333336, "eval_calls": 633084, "avg_eval_calls": 35171.333333333336, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 633084, "pattern_eval_ns": 12905347, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.384888893101074, "pattern_frame_queries": 633084, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 12905347, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.384888893101074, "pattern_frame_updates": 1293876, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 14397812542, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11127.660256469708, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13872, "avg_candidate_generations": 770.6666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 1260948, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.89878892733564, "candidate_moves_max": 137, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1641, "root_candidate_moves_max": 124, "search_candidate_generations": 13854, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1259307, "search_candidate_moves_max": 137, "legality_checks": 617908, "avg_legality_checks": 34328.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 264, "root_legality_checks": 1641, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 616267, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 260, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4810584, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 267254.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10988252531, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2284.1826545384097, "renju_forbidden_checks": 64092, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3560.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 632620498, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9870.506428259378, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 266, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2599722, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 62282, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 615281828, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 539, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6270774, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1005, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8468174, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 6359, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 353.27777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 66013211, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10381.067935209938, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9036, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 502.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 36565528, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4046.6498450641875, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1427586545, "stage_ordering_ns": 446600, "stage_eval_ns": 14410717889, "stage_threat_ns": 8367384700, "stage_proof_ns": 419470805, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1299122, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6880602717, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 141574, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 463292535, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1401, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 94129978, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 649552, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 843231601, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5228, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 32381869, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1299104, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 147875978, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 657, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 12648, "depth_sum": 48, "avg_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 48, "avg_effective_depth": 2.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3000.8888888888887, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3445.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 8922, "avg_search_time_ms": 495.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 314885, "safety_nodes": 1197, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 316082, "avg_nodes": 17560.11111111111, "eval_calls": 307524, "avg_eval_calls": 17084.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 307524, "pattern_eval_ns": 6246264, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.31146837320014, "pattern_frame_queries": 307524, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6246264, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.31146837320014, "pattern_frame_updates": 629666, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5135522496, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8155.946956005248, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7327, "avg_candidate_generations": 407.05555555555554, "candidate_moves_total": 801729, "avg_candidate_moves": 109.4211819298485, "candidate_moves_max": 142, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1681, "root_candidate_moves_max": 125, "search_candidate_generations": 7309, "search_candidate_moves_total": 800048, "search_candidate_moves_max": 142, "legality_checks": 25970, "avg_legality_checks": 1442.7777777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 25970, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1482567, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 82364.83333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3227565292, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2177.01142140625, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16757, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 930.9444444444445, "renju_forbidden_ns": 160775138, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9594.506057170138, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 176641, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16714, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 160312915, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 285582, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 59981970, "stage_ordering_ns": 283431, "stage_eval_ns": 5141768760, "stage_threat_ns": 3652511032, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 629684, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3191291986, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 48, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 257210, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 314833, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 391934171, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 629666, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69027665, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 876, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6278, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6813.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7258.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 995, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9872, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 96, 99, 129, 100, 142, 116, 68, 115, 140, 154, 117, 85, 70, 86, 72, 83, 82, 87 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5294, "avg_search_time_ms": 529.4, "search_nodes": 132993, "safety_nodes": 970, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 133963, "avg_nodes": 13396.3, "eval_calls": 129652, "avg_eval_calls": 12965.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 129652, "pattern_eval_ns": 2633242, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.310076203992224, "pattern_frame_queries": 129652, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2633242, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.310076203992224, "pattern_frame_updates": 265928, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3187283386, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11985.512567311453, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3322, "avg_candidate_generations": 332.2, "candidate_moves_total": 225823, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.97802528597231, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 681, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 3312, "search_candidate_moves_total": 225142, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 128349, "avg_legality_checks": 12834.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 249, "root_legality_checks": 681, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 127668, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 240, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 863693, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 86369.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2180751283, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2524.9148516891996, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9151, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 915.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 108338902, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11839.023276144684, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 249, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2692059, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8857, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 105112212, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 534631, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 724274, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11142.676923076922, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 379222, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4260.921348314607, "stage_move_gen_ns": 333410107, "stage_ordering_ns": 104261, "stage_eval_ns": 3189916628, "stage_threat_ns": 1763080123, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 265938, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1543133102, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 957044, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 132964, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 186214253, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 265928, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32775724, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 116, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2973, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4351.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5151.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 109, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 4570, "avg_search_time_ms": 457.0, "search_nodes": 114988, "safety_nodes": 254, "corridor_nodes": 3860, "corridor_branch_probes": 4038, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 1640, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 3835, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3835, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 70, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 45, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1640, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 70, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 67, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 551, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 250240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 119102, "avg_nodes": 11910.2, "eval_calls": 110575, "avg_eval_calls": 11057.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110575, "pattern_eval_ns": 2247064, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.32162785439747, "pattern_frame_queries": 110575, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2247064, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.32162785439747, "pattern_frame_updates": 229920, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2609660531, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11350.29806454419, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4395, "avg_candidate_generations": 439.5, "candidate_moves_total": 346498, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.8391353811149, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 709, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 4385, "search_candidate_moves_total": 345789, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 8933, "avg_legality_checks": 893.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 38, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8933, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 38, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 788834, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 78883.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1865422472, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2364.7845706447742, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18294, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1829.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 189884179, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10379.587788345905, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 409834, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17795, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 183723419, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 363, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4575060, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 98, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1175866, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 24218460, "stage_ordering_ns": 165020, "stage_eval_ns": 2611907595, "stage_threat_ns": 1829756718, "stage_proof_ns": 95473214, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 237740, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1335925174, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 229825, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 264888903, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2320, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 115267224, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 118865, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 160612564, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7810, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 40569737, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 237730, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27760340, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 502, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3716, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5641.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6441.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 996, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9970, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 96, 99, 129, 100, 142, 116, 68, 115, 140, 154, 117, 85, 70, 86, 72, 83, 82, 87 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5710, "avg_search_time_ms": 571.0, "search_nodes": 132993, "safety_nodes": 970, "corridor_nodes": 888, "corridor_branch_probes": 1095, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 368, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 876, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 871, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 368, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 327, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 109600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 134851, "avg_nodes": 13485.1, "eval_calls": 129652, "avg_eval_calls": 12965.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 129652, "pattern_eval_ns": 2673872, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.623453552586923, "pattern_frame_queries": 129652, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2673872, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.623453552586923, "pattern_frame_updates": 265928, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3175069715, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11939.584079149243, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3322, "avg_candidate_generations": 332.2, "candidate_moves_total": 225823, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.97802528597231, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 681, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 3312, "search_candidate_moves_total": 225142, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 128349, "avg_legality_checks": 12834.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 249, "root_legality_checks": 681, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 127668, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 240, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1012686, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 101268.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2484278686, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2453.1579245689186, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10051, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1005.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 119235466, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11863.045070142274, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 249, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2903965, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8857, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 107949154, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 189, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2343218, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 756, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6039129, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2701, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 270.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 30835164, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11416.202887819327, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 373.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 16781179, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4498.975603217158, "stage_move_gen_ns": 329389681, "stage_ordering_ns": 115500, "stage_eval_ns": 3177743587, "stage_threat_ns": 1976657786, "stage_proof_ns": 205685288, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 267800, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1551916052, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 53189, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 195589711, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 560, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 40050476, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 133895, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184597487, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1862, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11700962, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 267790, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32853574, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 116, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2973, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4293.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5093.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 160, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 4251, "avg_search_time_ms": 425.1, "search_nodes": 114988, "safety_nodes": 254, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 115242, "avg_nodes": 11524.2, "eval_calls": 110575, "avg_eval_calls": 11057.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110575, "pattern_eval_ns": 2365328, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.391164368075966, "pattern_frame_queries": 110575, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2365328, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.391164368075966, "pattern_frame_updates": 229920, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2717066306, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11817.442179888656, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4395, "avg_candidate_generations": 439.5, "candidate_moves_total": 346498, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.8391353811149, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 709, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 4385, "search_candidate_moves_total": 345789, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 8933, "avg_legality_checks": 893.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 38, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8933, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 38, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 699268, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 69926.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1741582462, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2490.5793801518157, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17883, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1788.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 195583041, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10936.813789632612, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 437104, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17795, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 194501264, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 644673, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 25414517, "stage_ordering_ns": 165871, "stage_eval_ns": 2719431634, "stage_threat_ns": 1483472602, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 229930, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1298778887, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 63490, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10350, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 114960, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156624679, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 229920, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28005546, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 502, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3716, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5715.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6515.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 997, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10702, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 140, 82, 125, 95, 124, 114, 138, 152, 155, 170, 66, 97, 127, 113, 111, 81, 65, 84, 70, 83, 80, 85 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6778, "avg_search_time_ms": 564.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 158351, "safety_nodes": 343, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 158694, "avg_nodes": 13224.5, "eval_calls": 152798, "avg_eval_calls": 12733.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 152798, "pattern_eval_ns": 3170684, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.750821345829134, "pattern_frame_queries": 152798, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3170684, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.750821345829134, "pattern_frame_updates": 316634, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4361901485, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13775.846829462407, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5531, "avg_candidate_generations": 460.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 467600, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.54167419996384, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 876, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 5519, "search_candidate_moves_total": 466724, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 147492, "avg_legality_checks": 12291.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 348, "root_legality_checks": 876, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 146616, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 347, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1325274, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 110439.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3187880594, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2405.4501891684286, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34516, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2876.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 279287554, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8091.538822575038, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 369, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3277146, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34142, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 275951948, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 58460, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 99661, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11073.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 48710, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4059.1666666666665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 361057306, "stage_ordering_ns": 200631, "stage_eval_ns": 4365072169, "stage_threat_ns": 2027015640, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 316646, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1772438128, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 156681, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 158317, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 216750676, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 316634, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37670155, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 590, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4714, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6046.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6713.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1745, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3913, "avg_search_time_ms": 355.72727272727275, "search_nodes": 113543, "safety_nodes": 1205, "corridor_nodes": 720, "corridor_branch_probes": 837, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 348, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 711, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 706, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 45, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 348, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 322, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 195280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 115468, "avg_nodes": 10497.09090909091, "eval_calls": 110345, "avg_eval_calls": 10031.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110345, "pattern_eval_ns": 2364467, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.427948706330145, "pattern_frame_queries": 110345, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2364467, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.427948706330145, "pattern_frame_updates": 227022, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2148600294, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9464.282289822131, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3177, "avg_candidate_generations": 288.8181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 232964, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.32829713566258, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 3166, "search_candidate_moves_total": 232156, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 5056, "avg_legality_checks": 459.6363636363636, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5056, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 541118, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 49192.545454545456, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1325074077, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2448.77102036894, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3503, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 318.45454545454544, "renju_forbidden_ns": 35211635, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10051.851270339708, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19991, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3474, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35056862, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12320, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 122462, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.909090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 414183, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7670.055555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 79, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.181818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 152791, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1934.0632911392406, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14704156, "stage_ordering_ns": 109341, "stage_eval_ns": 2150964761, "stage_threat_ns": 1638161958, "stage_proof_ns": 93602860, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 228563, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1389951086, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38826, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 47013323, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 490, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18252798, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 114276, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 163290384, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1530, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8587726, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 228552, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29319439, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 131, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2840, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5433.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6160.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 998, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8809, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 140, 82, 125, 95, 124, 114, 138, 152, 155, 170, 66, 97, 127, 113, 111, 81, 65, 84, 70, 83, 80, 85 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5805, "avg_search_time_ms": 483.75, "search_nodes": 158351, "safety_nodes": 343, "corridor_nodes": 3540, "corridor_branch_probes": 3855, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1573, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 3517, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3517, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 89, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 66, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1573, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 89, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 695, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 186400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 162234, "avg_nodes": 13519.5, "eval_calls": 152798, "avg_eval_calls": 12733.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 152798, "pattern_eval_ns": 2906820, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.023940103928062, "pattern_frame_queries": 152798, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2906820, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.023940103928062, "pattern_frame_updates": 316634, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3076242098, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9715.450955993356, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5531, "avg_candidate_generations": 460.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 467600, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.54167419996384, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 876, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 5519, "search_candidate_moves_total": 466724, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 147492, "avg_legality_checks": 12291.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 348, "root_legality_checks": 876, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 146616, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 347, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1817044, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 151420.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2881782630, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1585.9729483710905, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36149, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3012.4166666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 192323128, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5320.289025975822, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 369, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1937512, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34142, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 179736995, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 509, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4402799, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1129, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6245822, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9492, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 791.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 66245850, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6979.124525916562, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12654, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1054.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 34890610, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2757.2791212264897, "stage_move_gen_ns": 259297440, "stage_ordering_ns": 183751, "stage_eval_ns": 3079148918, "stage_threat_ns": 2039944686, "stage_proof_ns": 390279545, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 323858, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1335017369, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 201178, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 478917300, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2056, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 97115148, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 161923, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 167271400, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7212, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 29434292, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 323846, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29304325, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 590, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4714, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6010.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6676.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1724, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2995, "avg_search_time_ms": 272.27272727272725, "search_nodes": 113543, "safety_nodes": 1205, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 114748, "avg_nodes": 10431.636363636364, "eval_calls": 110345, "avg_eval_calls": 10031.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110345, "pattern_eval_ns": 2167817, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.645810865920524, "pattern_frame_queries": 110345, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2167817, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.645810865920524, "pattern_frame_updates": 227022, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1714715055, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7553.078798530539, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3177, "avg_candidate_generations": 288.8181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 232964, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.32829713566258, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 3166, "search_candidate_moves_total": 232156, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 5056, "avg_legality_checks": 459.6363636363636, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5056, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 501197, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 45563.36363636364, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 977079854, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1949.4926226613488, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3481, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 316.45454545454544, "renju_forbidden_ns": 26559941, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7629.974432634301, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9990, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3474, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26521001, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 28950, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12215988, "stage_ordering_ns": 94521, "stage_eval_ns": 1716882872, "stage_threat_ns": 1245749237, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 227033, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1092298933, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 289771, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9060, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 113511, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 129058003, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 227022, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24102530, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 131, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2840, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5643.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6370.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 999, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7142, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 99, 128, 144, 129, 130, 172, 157, 156, 114, 126, 125, 170, 184, 80, 64, 141, 111, 171, 186, 169, 168, 173 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 6249, "avg_search_time_ms": 480.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 182826, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 183875, "avg_nodes": 14144.23076923077, "eval_calls": 177705, "avg_eval_calls": 13669.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 177705, "pattern_eval_ns": 3548061, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.96601671309192, "pattern_frame_queries": 177705, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3548061, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.96601671309192, "pattern_frame_updates": 365578, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3754325556, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10269.560958263353, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5097, "avg_candidate_generations": 392.0769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 365928, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.79281930547381, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 5084, "search_candidate_moves_total": 365014, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 172346, "avg_legality_checks": 13257.384615384615, "illegal_moves_skipped": 321, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 171432, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 318, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1205183, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 92706.38461538461, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2539542767, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2107.184358723945, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19689, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1514.5384615384614, "renju_forbidden_ns": 156015477, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7923.991924424806, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3537621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19315, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 152186124, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 291732, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.615384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 636194, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10603.233333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 298163, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3549.559523809524, "stage_move_gen_ns": 377428739, "stage_ordering_ns": 170660, "stage_eval_ns": 3757873617, "stage_threat_ns": 2080079728, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 365591, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1818189860, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 938065, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12240, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 182789, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 221362747, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 365578, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39589056, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4463, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5681.846153846154, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6297.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1645, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 880, "avg_search_time_ms": 73.33333333333333, "search_nodes": 24265, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 839, "corridor_branch_probes": 1050, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 19, "corridor_depth_exits": 312, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 827, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 827, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 312, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 175, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 77360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 26116, "avg_nodes": 2176.3333333333335, "eval_calls": 22890, "avg_eval_calls": 1907.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22890, "pattern_eval_ns": 471243, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.587287024901705, "pattern_frame_queries": 22890, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 471243, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.587287024901705, "pattern_frame_updates": 48460, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 383199825, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7907.549009492365, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1352, "avg_candidate_generations": 112.66666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 97884, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.39940828402366, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 1340, "search_candidate_moves_total": 97044, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3807, "avg_legality_checks": 317.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3807, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 124459, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10371.583333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 284729580, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2287.737969933874, "renju_forbidden_checks": 799, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 66.58333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6971372, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8725.12140175219, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 88770, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 760, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6523432, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23980, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 335190, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10222415, "stage_ordering_ns": 44770, "stage_eval_ns": 383671068, "stage_threat_ns": 415206648, "stage_proof_ns": 53628798, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 50198, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 309715110, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 51387, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 54403437, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 480, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12038966, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 25093, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 34191095, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1726, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10838991, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 50186, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6058015, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1219, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6231.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6898.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1000, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9647, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 99, 128, 144, 129, 130, 172, 157, 156, 114, 126, 125, 170, 184, 80, 64, 141, 111, 171, 186, 169, 168, 173 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8857, "avg_search_time_ms": 681.3076923076923, "search_nodes": 182826, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 3121, "corridor_branch_probes": 3357, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1374, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 3097, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3097, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 109, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 85, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1374, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 109, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 857, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 236560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 186996, "avg_nodes": 14384.307692307691, "eval_calls": 177705, "avg_eval_calls": 13669.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 177705, "pattern_eval_ns": 3826049, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.530339607776934, "pattern_frame_queries": 177705, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3826049, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.530339607776934, "pattern_frame_updates": 365578, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4538722586, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12415.196171542051, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5097, "avg_candidate_generations": 392.0769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 365928, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.79281930547381, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 5084, "search_candidate_moves_total": 365014, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 172346, "avg_legality_checks": 13257.384615384615, "illegal_moves_skipped": 321, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 171432, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 318, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1654139, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 127241.46153846153, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4042047433, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2443.5959934443235, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20715, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1593.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_ns": 183785922, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8872.117885590153, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3545466, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19315, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 172995283, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 169, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2100478, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 896, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5144695, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 7597, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 584.3846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 80937134, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10653.828353297355, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10675, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 821.1538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 42719453, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4001.8222950819672, "stage_move_gen_ns": 462789262, "stage_ordering_ns": 180571, "stage_eval_ns": 4542548635, "stage_threat_ns": 3272141978, "stage_proof_ns": 558456038, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 372003, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2303242258, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 180219, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 609964560, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1918, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 124220942, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185995, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 273005861, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6412, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 37873352, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 371990, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48055947, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4463, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4939.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5554.538461538462, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 360, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 778, "avg_search_time_ms": 64.83333333333333, "search_nodes": 24265, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 25277, "avg_nodes": 2106.4166666666665, "eval_calls": 22890, "avg_eval_calls": 1907.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22890, "pattern_eval_ns": 491412, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.468414154652688, "pattern_frame_queries": 22890, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 491412, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.468414154652688, "pattern_frame_updates": 48460, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 402797510, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8311.958522492778, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1352, "avg_candidate_generations": 112.66666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 97884, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.39940828402366, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 1340, "search_candidate_moves_total": 97044, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3807, "avg_legality_checks": 317.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3807, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 97971, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8164.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 239364835, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2443.221310387768, "renju_forbidden_checks": 790, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 65.83333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6977503, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8832.282278481012, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 88571, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 760, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6648501, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 240431, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10868317, "stage_ordering_ns": 46850, "stage_eval_ns": 403288922, "stage_threat_ns": 345545736, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 48472, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 304814885, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 199471, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13811, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 24230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 34416314, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 48460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6115066, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1219, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6229.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6896.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1953, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1001, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8119, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 143, 126, 140, 141, 156, 108, 109, 94, 142, 96, 81, 78, 62, 84, 70, 95, 97, 93, 92, 63, 48, 123 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 5766, "avg_search_time_ms": 443.53846153846155, "search_nodes": 141773, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 142822, "avg_nodes": 10986.307692307691, "eval_calls": 137027, "avg_eval_calls": 10540.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 137027, "pattern_eval_ns": 2947452, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.510008976333133, "pattern_frame_queries": 137027, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2947452, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.510008976333133, "pattern_frame_updates": 283472, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3472531677, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12249.998860557656, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4722, "avg_candidate_generations": 363.2307692307692, "candidate_moves_total": 336694, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.30326132994495, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4709, "search_candidate_moves_total": 335780, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 128289, "avg_legality_checks": 9868.384615384615, "illegal_moves_skipped": 133, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 127375, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 130, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 963135, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 74087.30769230769, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2411530024, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2503.8338592201508, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15320, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1178.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_ns": 129202302, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8433.570626631854, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 147, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1354935, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15134, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 127575954, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 271413, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.615384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 629342, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10489.033333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 294452, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3505.3809523809523, "stage_move_gen_ns": 336263029, "stage_ordering_ns": 171440, "stage_eval_ns": 3475479129, "stage_threat_ns": 1931752613, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 283485, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1693388068, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 922363, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13530, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 141736, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 201494928, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 283472, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35947254, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4134, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5501.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6116.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1597, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 2340, "avg_search_time_ms": 195.0, "search_nodes": 67975, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 842, "corridor_branch_probes": 1055, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 18, "corridor_depth_exits": 314, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 830, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 830, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 314, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 175, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 65520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 69829, "avg_nodes": 5819.083333333333, "eval_calls": 65773, "avg_eval_calls": 5481.083333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 65773, "pattern_eval_ns": 1410569, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.446018883128335, "pattern_frame_queries": 65773, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1410569, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.446018883128335, "pattern_frame_updates": 135880, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1224692143, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9013.041970856639, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2179, "avg_candidate_generations": 181.58333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 151150, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.36668196420376, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 2167, "search_candidate_moves_total": 150310, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 4565, "avg_legality_checks": 380.4166666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4565, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 322112, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26842.666666666668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 765849583, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2377.5878669531094, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2672, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 222.66666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21702804, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8122.306886227545, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 62580, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2632, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21289784, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43410, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 307030, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13195994, "stage_ordering_ns": 71151, "stage_eval_ns": 1226102712, "stage_threat_ns": 1024433887, "stage_proof_ns": 58133515, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 137624, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 843290074, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 51589, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 55163252, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 480, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12244805, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68806, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 97924674, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1732, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10498635, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 137612, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17557252, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1988, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6035.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6701.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1930, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1002, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9282, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 143, 126, 140, 141, 156, 108, 109, 94, 142, 96, 81, 78, 62, 84, 70, 95, 97, 93, 92, 63, 48, 123 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7067, "avg_search_time_ms": 543.6153846153846, "search_nodes": 141773, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 3081, "corridor_branch_probes": 3326, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1340, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 3056, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3056, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 109, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 84, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1340, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 109, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 857, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 245680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 145903, "avg_nodes": 11223.307692307691, "eval_calls": 137027, "avg_eval_calls": 10540.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 137027, "pattern_eval_ns": 2955319, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.567421019215193, "pattern_frame_queries": 137027, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2955319, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.567421019215193, "pattern_frame_updates": 283472, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3500408160, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12348.338319128521, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4722, "avg_candidate_generations": 363.2307692307692, "candidate_moves_total": 336694, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.30326132994495, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4709, "search_candidate_moves_total": 335780, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 128289, "avg_legality_checks": 9868.384615384615, "illegal_moves_skipped": 133, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 127375, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 130, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1408805, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 108369.61538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3355251907, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2381.6297550051286, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16323, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1255.6153846153845, "renju_forbidden_ns": 136548336, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8365.394596581511, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 147, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1362857, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15134, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 128432069, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 160, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1937208, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 882, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4816202, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 7342, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 564.7692307692307, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 77342999, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10534.322936529556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10381, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 798.5384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 40703430, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3920.9546286484924, "stage_move_gen_ns": 337212402, "stage_ordering_ns": 175661, "stage_eval_ns": 3503363479, "stage_threat_ns": 2657874993, "stage_proof_ns": 545244076, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 289815, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1778884191, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 179614, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 595921301, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1915, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 122346286, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 144901, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 208494667, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6330, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 37650473, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 289802, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36924361, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4134, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5321.538461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5936.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1517, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 2202, "avg_search_time_ms": 183.5, "search_nodes": 67975, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68987, "avg_nodes": 5748.916666666667, "eval_calls": 65773, "avg_eval_calls": 5481.083333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 65773, "pattern_eval_ns": 1409764, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.433779818466544, "pattern_frame_queries": 65773, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1409764, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.433779818466544, "pattern_frame_updates": 135880, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1235594503, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9093.2771783927, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2179, "avg_candidate_generations": 181.58333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 151150, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.36668196420376, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 2167, "search_candidate_moves_total": 150310, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 4565, "avg_legality_checks": 380.4166666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4565, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 295595, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24632.916666666668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 712198295, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2409.3719278066274, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2661, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 221.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21665361, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8141.811724915446, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 62910, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2632, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21367110, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 235341, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13239465, "stage_ordering_ns": 71990, "stage_eval_ns": 1237004267, "stage_threat_ns": 932639181, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 135892, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 821716716, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 200520, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13620, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93399558, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 135880, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17322387, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1988, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6044.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6710.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1934, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1003, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6644, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 128, 125, 96, 80, 95, 94, 52, 67, 68, 110, 98, 99, 54, 40, 144, 160, 83, 113, 53, 38, 55, 56, 51 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 4601, "avg_search_time_ms": 353.9230769230769, "search_nodes": 114175, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 115224, "avg_nodes": 8863.384615384615, "eval_calls": 110451, "avg_eval_calls": 8496.23076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110451, "pattern_eval_ns": 2368349, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.442531077129225, "pattern_frame_queries": 110451, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2368349, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.442531077129225, "pattern_frame_updates": 228276, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2808455050, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12302.892332089225, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3700, "avg_candidate_generations": 284.61538461538464, "candidate_moves_total": 276742, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.79513513513514, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3687, "search_candidate_moves_total": 275828, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 102978, "avg_legality_checks": 7921.384615384615, "illegal_moves_skipped": 173, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 102064, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 170, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 848377, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 65259.769230769234, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2012905197, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2372.654134895218, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17599, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1353.7692307692307, "renju_forbidden_ns": 133447109, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7582.652934825843, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 273, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2573368, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17287, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 130605830, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 267911, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.615384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 613712, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10228.533333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 288731, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3437.2738095238096, "stage_move_gen_ns": 253344896, "stage_ordering_ns": 138180, "stage_eval_ns": 2810823399, "stage_threat_ns": 1509581110, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 228289, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1323883675, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 907944, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13531, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 114138, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156540213, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 228276, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28249278, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3186, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6267.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6882.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1852, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 2030, "avg_search_time_ms": 169.16666666666666, "search_nodes": 58718, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 840, "corridor_branch_probes": 1057, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 322, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 828, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 828, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 322, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 175, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 57280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 60570, "avg_nodes": 5047.5, "eval_calls": 56482, "avg_eval_calls": 4706.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 56482, "pattern_eval_ns": 1206057, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.352944300839205, "pattern_frame_queries": 56482, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1206057, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.352944300839205, "pattern_frame_updates": 117366, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1061184990, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9041.672971729462, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2213, "avg_candidate_generations": 184.41666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 153732, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.46769091730683, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 2201, "search_candidate_moves_total": 152892, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3533, "avg_legality_checks": 294.4166666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3533, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 295860, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24655.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 686772880, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2321.276549719462, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3781, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 315.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31984358, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8459.232478180376, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 65220, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3735, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31562295, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 49050, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 307793, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10244998, "stage_ordering_ns": 69940, "stage_eval_ns": 1062391047, "stage_threat_ns": 880233915, "stage_proof_ns": 57809766, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 119106, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 717106445, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52345, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 55012516, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 466, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12698992, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 59547, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 82490540, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1728, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10744050, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 119094, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14880364, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1985, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6056.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6723.416666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1920, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1004, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8029, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 128, 125, 96, 80, 95, 94, 52, 67, 68, 110, 98, 99, 54, 40, 144, 160, 83, 113, 53, 38, 55, 56, 51 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 6245, "avg_search_time_ms": 480.38461538461536, "search_nodes": 114175, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 4556, "corridor_branch_probes": 4887, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2171, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 4528, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4528, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 109, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 81, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2171, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 109, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 857, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 310640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 119780, "avg_nodes": 9213.846153846154, "eval_calls": 110451, "avg_eval_calls": 8496.23076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110451, "pattern_eval_ns": 2358952, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.357452626051373, "pattern_frame_queries": 110451, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2358952, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.357452626051373, "pattern_frame_updates": 228276, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2809751045, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12308.569648145227, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3700, "avg_candidate_generations": 284.61538461538464, "candidate_moves_total": 276742, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.79513513513514, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3687, "search_candidate_moves_total": 275828, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 102978, "avg_legality_checks": 7921.384615384615, "illegal_moves_skipped": 173, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 102064, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 170, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1435234, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 110402.61538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3217985277, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2242.132834785129, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19064, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1466.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_ns": 142585809, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7479.322754930759, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 273, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2607410, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17287, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 131647958, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 202, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2483897, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1302, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5846544, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10161, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 781.6153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 101390042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9978.35272118886, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14034, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1079.5384615384614, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 52039209, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3708.0810175288584, "stage_move_gen_ns": 252912126, "stage_ordering_ns": 145100, "stage_eval_ns": 2812109997, "stage_threat_ns": 2495398016, "stage_proof_ns": 660247610, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 237563, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1434778873, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 246432, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 807711247, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2527, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 164545243, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 118775, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 167383692, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9274, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 56157561, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 237550, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29366643, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3186, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6173.538461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6788.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1816, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 1771, "avg_search_time_ms": 147.58333333333334, "search_nodes": 58718, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59730, "avg_nodes": 4977.5, "eval_calls": 56482, "avg_eval_calls": 4706.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 56482, "pattern_eval_ns": 1199064, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.2291349456464, "pattern_frame_queries": 56482, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1199064, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.2291349456464, "pattern_frame_updates": 117366, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1000421292, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8523.944685854507, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2213, "avg_candidate_generations": 184.41666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 153732, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.46769091730683, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 2201, "search_candidate_moves_total": 152892, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3533, "avg_legality_checks": 294.4166666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3533, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 269309, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22442.416666666668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 594643384, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2208.0338347400198, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3764, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 313.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29365926, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7801.78692879915, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 67950, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3735, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29058255, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 239721, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9824780, "stage_ordering_ns": 71900, "stage_eval_ns": 1001620356, "stage_threat_ns": 736110826, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 117378, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 646323206, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 198241, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13470, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58683, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 75774983, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 117366, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13814396, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1985, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6095.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6762.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1924, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1005, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6338, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 114, 111, 126, 81, 98, 84, 83, 68, 116, 115, 130, 82, 128, 143, 146, 162, 140, 154, 129, 127, 131, 132, 161, 176, 101 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 5706, "avg_search_time_ms": 438.9230769230769, "search_nodes": 156217, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 157266, "avg_nodes": 12097.384615384615, "eval_calls": 151686, "avg_eval_calls": 11668.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 151686, "pattern_eval_ns": 3172609, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.91563493005287, "pattern_frame_queries": 151686, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3172609, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.91563493005287, "pattern_frame_updates": 312360, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3394339005, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10866.753121398386, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4507, "avg_candidate_generations": 346.6923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 328814, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.95629021522076, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4494, "search_candidate_moves_total": 327900, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 148636, "avg_legality_checks": 11433.538461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 147722, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 81, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1048601, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 80661.61538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2346650428, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2237.886887386146, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17156, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1319.6923076923076, "renju_forbidden_ns": 122011614, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7111.891699696899, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 98, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 668242, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17019, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 121069571, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 273801, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.615384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 642870, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10714.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 308640, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3674.285714285714, "stage_move_gen_ns": 348732919, "stage_ordering_ns": 152711, "stage_eval_ns": 3397511614, "stage_threat_ns": 1935548803, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 312373, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1691697528, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 939933, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11890, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 156180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 205823829, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 312360, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37087513, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3926, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5897.076923076923, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6512.461538461538, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1773, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 622, "avg_search_time_ms": 51.833333333333336, "search_nodes": 18441, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 837, "corridor_branch_probes": 1052, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 320, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 825, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 825, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 320, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 175, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 75600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 20290, "avg_nodes": 1690.8333333333333, "eval_calls": 17115, "avg_eval_calls": 1426.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 17115, "pattern_eval_ns": 348542, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.364709319310546, "pattern_frame_queries": 17115, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 348542, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.364709319310546, "pattern_frame_updates": 36812, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 256249956, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6961.044116049115, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1303, "avg_candidate_generations": 108.58333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 94004, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.14428242517268, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 1291, "search_candidate_moves_total": 93164, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3433, "avg_legality_checks": 286.0833333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3433, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 110649, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9220.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 206429612, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1865.6256450577953, "renju_forbidden_checks": 806, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 67.16666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6695990, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8307.679900744417, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 66610, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 761, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6290057, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29980, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 309343, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8893329, "stage_ordering_ns": 44180, "stage_eval_ns": 256598498, "stage_threat_ns": 301867909, "stage_proof_ns": 37342619, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 38546, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 211241056, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52143, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 52669737, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 466, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11638937, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 19267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 23230837, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1722, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10636193, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 38534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4090086, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1167, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6249.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6916.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1955, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1006, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9153, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 114, 111, 126, 81, 98, 84, 83, 68, 116, 115, 130, 82, 128, 143, 146, 162, 140, 154, 129, 127, 131, 132, 161, 176, 101 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8528, "avg_search_time_ms": 656.0, "search_nodes": 156217, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 6430, "corridor_branch_probes": 6841, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2995, "corridor_neutral_exits": 34, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 6387, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6387, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 109, "corridor_proof_active": 43, "corridor_proof_quiet": 66, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2995, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 109, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 857, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 365040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 163696, "avg_nodes": 12592.0, "eval_calls": 151686, "avg_eval_calls": 11668.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 151686, "pattern_eval_ns": 3238583, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.35057289400472, "pattern_frame_queries": 151686, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3238583, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.35057289400472, "pattern_frame_updates": 312360, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3711577984, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11882.372851837623, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4507, "avg_candidate_generations": 346.6923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 328814, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.95629021522076, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4494, "search_candidate_moves_total": 327900, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 148636, "avg_legality_checks": 11433.538461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 147722, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 81, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1865100, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 143469.23076923078, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4273938118, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2291.532956946008, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18711, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1439.3076923076924, "renju_forbidden_ns": 148420740, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7932.271925605259, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 98, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 910382, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17019, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 138813805, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 221, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2669491, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1373, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6027062, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 13863, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1066.3846153846155, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 140446426, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10131.026906153069, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18999, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1461.4615384615386, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 72665524, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3824.702563292805, "stage_move_gen_ns": 380070698, "stage_ordering_ns": 156150, "stage_eval_ns": 3714816567, "stage_threat_ns": 3535918020, "stage_proof_ns": 875405378, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 325365, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2012297285, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 356187, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1169922038, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 3419, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 234312897, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 162676, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 237450203, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12992, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 74747443, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 325352, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41501051, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3926, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5442.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6058.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1735, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 612, "avg_search_time_ms": 51.0, "search_nodes": 18441, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 19453, "avg_nodes": 1621.0833333333333, "eval_calls": 17115, "avg_eval_calls": 1426.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 17115, "pattern_eval_ns": 369633, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.597020157756354, "pattern_frame_queries": 17115, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 369633, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.597020157756354, "pattern_frame_updates": 36812, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 318603271, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8654.875339563187, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1303, "avg_candidate_generations": 108.58333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 94004, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.14428242517268, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 1291, "search_candidate_moves_total": 93164, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3433, "avg_legality_checks": 286.0833333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3433, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 84106, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7008.833333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 201035780, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2390.2668061731624, "renju_forbidden_checks": 791, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 65.91666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 7392448, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9345.699115044248, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 67490, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 761, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7085537, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 239421, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9652232, "stage_ordering_ns": 45660, "stage_eval_ns": 318972904, "stage_threat_ns": 265551159, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 36824, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 235081434, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 197990, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13780, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 18406, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 25599324, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 36812, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4672411, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1167, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6233.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6900.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1959, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1007, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8689, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 142, 97, 98, 95, 126, 140, 125, 124, 172, 157, 158, 110, 128, 129, 174, 190, 84, 70, 143, 113, 173, 188, 175, 176, 171 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7798, "avg_search_time_ms": 599.8461538461538, "search_nodes": 201843, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 202892, "avg_nodes": 15607.076923076924, "eval_calls": 196537, "avg_eval_calls": 15118.23076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 196537, "pattern_eval_ns": 4010748, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.407088741560113, "pattern_frame_queries": 196537, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4010748, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.407088741560113, "pattern_frame_updates": 403612, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4665052741, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11558.260757856555, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5282, "avg_candidate_generations": 406.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 379795, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.90363498674745, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 5269, "search_candidate_moves_total": 378881, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 190909, "avg_legality_checks": 14685.307692307691, "illegal_moves_skipped": 324, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 189995, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 321, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1332923, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 102532.53846153847, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3185249807, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2389.672777047136, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21459, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1650.6923076923076, "renju_forbidden_ns": 180260642, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8400.234959690573, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 338, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3043723, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21082, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 176949598, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 267321, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.615384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 605583, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10093.05, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 286401, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3409.535714285714, "stage_move_gen_ns": 477508704, "stage_ordering_ns": 173291, "stage_eval_ns": 4669063489, "stage_threat_ns": 2620512024, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 403625, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2296097181, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 886424, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12821, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 201806, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 274522118, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 403612, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49006301, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4613, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5196.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5811.615384615385, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 805, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 878, "avg_search_time_ms": 73.16666666666667, "search_nodes": 25106, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 839, "corridor_branch_probes": 1050, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 19, "corridor_depth_exits": 312, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 827, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 827, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 312, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 175, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 76320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 26957, "avg_nodes": 2246.4166666666665, "eval_calls": 23735, "avg_eval_calls": 1977.9166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23735, "pattern_eval_ns": 482653, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.335074784074152, "pattern_frame_queries": 23735, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 482653, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.335074784074152, "pattern_frame_updates": 50142, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 380315377, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7584.7668022815205, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1348, "avg_candidate_generations": 112.33333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 97642, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.43471810089021, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 1336, "search_candidate_moves_total": 96802, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3786, "avg_legality_checks": 315.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3786, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 123508, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10292.333333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 276032276, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2234.934384817178, "renju_forbidden_checks": 797, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 66.41666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6577633, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8252.989962358846, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 71770, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 758, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6184442, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22200, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 299221, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10104107, "stage_ordering_ns": 43400, "stage_eval_ns": 380798030, "stage_threat_ns": 417480144, "stage_proof_ns": 54118238, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 51880, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 315402039, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 51387, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 51040249, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 480, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11474609, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 25934, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 34672238, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1726, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10193436, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 51868, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6172182, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1212, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6225.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6892.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1954, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1008, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9715, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 142, 97, 98, 95, 126, 140, 125, 124, 172, 157, 158, 110, 128, 129, 174, 190, 84, 70, 143, 113, 173, 188, 175, 176, 171 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8960, "avg_search_time_ms": 689.2307692307693, "search_nodes": 201843, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 3051, "corridor_branch_probes": 3276, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1358, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 3028, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3028, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 109, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 86, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1358, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 109, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 857, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 237840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 205943, "avg_nodes": 15841.76923076923, "eval_calls": 196537, "avg_eval_calls": 15118.23076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 196537, "pattern_eval_ns": 3978871, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.244895363214052, "pattern_frame_queries": 196537, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3978871, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.244895363214052, "pattern_frame_updates": 403612, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4670060072, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11570.667056479986, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5282, "avg_candidate_generations": 406.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 379795, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.90363498674745, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 5269, "search_candidate_moves_total": 378881, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 190909, "avg_legality_checks": 14685.307692307691, "illegal_moves_skipped": 324, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 189995, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 321, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1770169, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 136166.84615384616, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4040578875, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2282.594981044183, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22491, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1730.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 187361587, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8330.513849984438, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 338, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3024841, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21082, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 177453811, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 174, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2033739, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 897, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4849196, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 7543, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 580.2307692307693, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 75031631, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9947.186928277873, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10571, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 813.1538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 39880078, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3772.5927537602875, "stage_move_gen_ns": 477161255, "stage_ordering_ns": 183760, "stage_eval_ns": 4674038943, "stage_threat_ns": 3284447471, "stage_proof_ns": 502797253, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 409899, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2365098083, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 174546, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 553634585, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1874, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 112222463, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 204943, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 281483165, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6274, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 34832139, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 409886, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49399499, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4613, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4967.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5583.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 739, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 745, "avg_search_time_ms": 62.083333333333336, "search_nodes": 25106, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 26118, "avg_nodes": 2176.5, "eval_calls": 23735, "avg_eval_calls": 1977.9166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23735, "pattern_eval_ns": 481643, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.29252159258479, "pattern_frame_queries": 23735, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 481643, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.29252159258479, "pattern_frame_updates": 50142, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 382494669, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7628.229209046309, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1348, "avg_candidate_generations": 112.33333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 97642, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.43471810089021, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 1336, "search_candidate_moves_total": 96802, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3786, "avg_legality_checks": 315.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3786, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 97020, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8085.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 221423436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2282.2452690166974, "renju_forbidden_checks": 788, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 65.66666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6555279, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8318.881979695432, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 77780, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 758, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6243948, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 233551, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10163371, "stage_ordering_ns": 44650, "stage_eval_ns": 382976312, "stage_threat_ns": 334146045, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 50154, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 294790573, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 187242, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 25071, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 33210972, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 50142, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5957258, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1212, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6235.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6902.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1958, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1009, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6617, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 126, 129, 98, 84, 99, 100, 52, 67, 66, 114, 96, 95, 50, 34, 140, 154, 81, 111, 51, 36, 49, 48, 53 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 4289, "avg_search_time_ms": 329.9230769230769, "search_nodes": 104367, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 105416, "avg_nodes": 8108.923076923077, "eval_calls": 100827, "avg_eval_calls": 7755.923076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 100827, "pattern_eval_ns": 2161003, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.432780901940948, "pattern_frame_queries": 100827, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2161003, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.432780901940948, "pattern_frame_updates": 208660, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2639050871, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12647.612724048691, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3516, "avg_candidate_generations": 270.46153846153845, "candidate_moves_total": 262264, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.59158134243458, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3503, "search_candidate_moves_total": 261350, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 93017, "avg_legality_checks": 7155.153846153846, "illegal_moves_skipped": 166, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 92103, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 163, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 783179, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 60244.53846153846, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1891770580, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2415.5021776630883, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16684, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1283.3846153846155, "renju_forbidden_ns": 130561736, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7825.565571805322, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 264, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2742252, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16381, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 127530093, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 289391, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.615384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 638282, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10638.033333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 301091, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3584.4166666666665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 231936990, "stage_ordering_ns": 136790, "stage_eval_ns": 2641211874, "stage_threat_ns": 1387659605, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 208673, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1215924813, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 931104, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13840, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 104330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 144727893, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 208660, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26075795, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3023, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6254.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6870.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1805, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 2313, "avg_search_time_ms": 192.75, "search_nodes": 66055, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 840, "corridor_branch_probes": 1057, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 322, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 828, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 828, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 322, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 175, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 57520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 67907, "avg_nodes": 5658.916666666667, "eval_calls": 63712, "avg_eval_calls": 5309.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 63712, "pattern_eval_ns": 1372717, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.54565858864892, "pattern_frame_queries": 63712, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1372717, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.54565858864892, "pattern_frame_updates": 132040, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1237636659, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9373.194933353529, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2320, "avg_candidate_generations": 193.33333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 160038, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.98189655172413, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 2308, "search_candidate_moves_total": 159198, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3704, "avg_legality_checks": 308.6666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3704, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 332588, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27715.666666666668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 793095009, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2384.6170306806016, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4370, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 364.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 38721399, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8860.732036613272, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 75041, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4324, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38264787, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 52230, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 329341, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10894792, "stage_ordering_ns": 74891, "stage_eval_ns": 1239009376, "stage_threat_ns": 981801922, "stage_proof_ns": 59582335, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 133780, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 805764935, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52345, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 55965050, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 466, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13045444, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66884, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92178668, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1728, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10935005, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 133768, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16958264, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2065, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6014.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6681.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1916, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1010, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8149, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 126, 129, 98, 84, 99, 100, 52, 67, 66, 114, 96, 95, 50, 34, 140, 154, 81, 111, 51, 36, 49, 48, 53 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 5975, "avg_search_time_ms": 459.61538461538464, "search_nodes": 104367, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 4608, "corridor_branch_probes": 4957, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2163, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 4578, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4578, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 109, "corridor_proof_active": 30, "corridor_proof_quiet": 79, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2163, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 109, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 857, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 322960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 110024, "avg_nodes": 8463.384615384615, "eval_calls": 100827, "avg_eval_calls": 7755.923076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 100827, "pattern_eval_ns": 2168953, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.51162882957938, "pattern_frame_queries": 100827, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2168953, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.51162882957938, "pattern_frame_updates": 208660, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2624171226, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12576.30224288316, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3516, "avg_candidate_generations": 270.46153846153845, "candidate_moves_total": 262264, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.59158134243458, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3503, "search_candidate_moves_total": 261350, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 93017, "avg_legality_checks": 7155.153846153846, "illegal_moves_skipped": 166, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 92103, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 163, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1383125, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 106394.23076923077, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3127023137, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2260.839141075463, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18135, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1395.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 137708596, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7593.526109732561, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 264, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2694611, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16381, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 126898441, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 194, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2364607, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1296, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5750937, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10198, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 784.4615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 102579324, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10058.768778191803, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1084.6153846153845, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 52658637, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3734.655106382979, "stage_move_gen_ns": 231523203, "stage_ordering_ns": 141320, "stage_eval_ns": 2626340179, "stage_threat_ns": 2407649789, "stage_proof_ns": 680238352, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 218047, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1334932265, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 252804, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 832239676, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2563, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 170118058, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 109017, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156362964, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9374, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 56811712, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 218034, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27303172, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3023, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6154.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6769.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1766, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 2163, "avg_search_time_ms": 180.25, "search_nodes": 66055, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67067, "avg_nodes": 5588.916666666667, "eval_calls": 63712, "avg_eval_calls": 5309.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 63712, "pattern_eval_ns": 1370995, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.518630713209443, "pattern_frame_queries": 63712, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1370995, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.518630713209443, "pattern_frame_updates": 132040, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1232317070, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9332.907225083309, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2320, "avg_candidate_generations": 193.33333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 160038, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.98189655172413, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 2308, "search_candidate_moves_total": 159198, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3704, "avg_legality_checks": 308.6666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3704, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 306036, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 25503.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 727437960, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2376.968591930361, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4353, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 362.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 38221554, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8780.508614748449, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 75430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4324, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37901064, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 245060, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10891919, "stage_ordering_ns": 75261, "stage_eval_ns": 1233688065, "stage_threat_ns": 895868276, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 132052, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 786841703, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 205332, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13801, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66020, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92064367, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 132040, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16756874, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2065, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6025.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6691.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1919, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1011, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7796, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 141, 128, 144, 143, 158, 116, 115, 100, 142, 98, 83, 86, 72, 80, 64, 99, 97, 101, 102, 71, 56, 131 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 5667, "avg_search_time_ms": 435.9230769230769, "search_nodes": 139944, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 140993, "avg_nodes": 10845.615384615385, "eval_calls": 135157, "avg_eval_calls": 10396.692307692309, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 135157, "pattern_eval_ns": 2894399, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.41508763882004, "pattern_frame_queries": 135157, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2894399, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.41508763882004, "pattern_frame_updates": 279814, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3407307836, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12177.045594573538, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4763, "avg_candidate_generations": 366.38461538461536, "candidate_moves_total": 342771, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.96535796766743, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4750, "search_candidate_moves_total": 341857, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 126997, "avg_legality_checks": 9769.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 142, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 126083, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 139, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 934059, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 71850.69230769231, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2359818291, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2526.4124546736343, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13807, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1062.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 118759890, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8601.426088216122, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 156, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1526543, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13612, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 116956887, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 276460, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.615384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 649083, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10818.05, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 297312, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3539.4285714285716, "stage_move_gen_ns": 333864852, "stage_ordering_ns": 181181, "stage_eval_ns": 3410202235, "stage_threat_ns": 1898375288, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 279827, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1662770575, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 945755, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13550, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 139907, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 199066470, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 279814, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35592488, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4172, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5571.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6186.538461538462, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1599, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 2116, "avg_search_time_ms": 176.33333333333334, "search_nodes": 61614, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 839, "corridor_branch_probes": 1050, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 19, "corridor_depth_exits": 312, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 827, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 827, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 312, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 175, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 64000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 63465, "avg_nodes": 5288.75, "eval_calls": 59536, "avg_eval_calls": 4961.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 59536, "pattern_eval_ns": 1270366, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.33777882289707, "pattern_frame_queries": 59536, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1270366, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.33777882289707, "pattern_frame_updates": 123158, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1097482386, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8911.174150278504, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2055, "avg_candidate_generations": 171.25, "candidate_moves_total": 143538, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.84817518248175, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 2043, "search_candidate_moves_total": 142698, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 4426, "avg_legality_checks": 368.8333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4426, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 288984, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24082.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 693790557, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2400.792282617723, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2278, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 189.83333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18419195, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8085.687006145742, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 63420, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2238, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17994853, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44051, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 316871, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12769529, "stage_ordering_ns": 67151, "stage_eval_ns": 1098752752, "stage_threat_ns": 927190387, "stage_proof_ns": 57795321, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 124896, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 758344308, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 51387, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 54688219, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 480, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12304316, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 62442, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87645353, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1726, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10620773, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 124884, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15891734, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1879, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6073.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6739.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1934, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1012, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8939, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 141, 128, 144, 143, 158, 116, 115, 100, 142, 98, 83, 86, 72, 80, 64, 99, 97, 101, 102, 71, 56, 131 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 6940, "avg_search_time_ms": 533.8461538461538, "search_nodes": 139944, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 3119, "corridor_branch_probes": 3368, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1366, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 3094, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3094, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 109, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 84, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1366, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 109, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 857, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 246720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 144112, "avg_nodes": 11085.538461538461, "eval_calls": 135157, "avg_eval_calls": 10396.692307692309, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 135157, "pattern_eval_ns": 2909168, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.52436055846164, "pattern_frame_queries": 135157, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2909168, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.52436055846164, "pattern_frame_updates": 279814, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3394189095, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12130.161803912599, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4763, "avg_candidate_generations": 366.38461538461536, "candidate_moves_total": 342771, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.96535796766743, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4750, "search_candidate_moves_total": 341857, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 126997, "avg_legality_checks": 9769.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 142, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 126083, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 139, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1383665, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 106435.76923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3292387432, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2379.4686083698007, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14813, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1139.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124311504, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8392.05454668197, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 156, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1444605, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13612, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 116088791, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 161, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1954968, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 884, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4823140, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 7517, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 578.2307692307693, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 79205252, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10536.816815218837, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10601, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 815.4615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 41754983, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3938.7777568153947, "stage_move_gen_ns": 334034334, "stage_ordering_ns": 182791, "stage_eval_ns": 3397098263, "stage_threat_ns": 2633716986, "stage_proof_ns": 549348715, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 286233, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1748066719, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 180864, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 605552452, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1922, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 124154415, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 143110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 205331656, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6406, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 38068854, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 286220, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36697305, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4172, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5406.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6022.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1525, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 1985, "avg_search_time_ms": 165.41666666666666, "search_nodes": 61614, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 62626, "avg_nodes": 5218.833333333333, "eval_calls": 59536, "avg_eval_calls": 4961.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 59536, "pattern_eval_ns": 1285785, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.596764982531578, "pattern_frame_queries": 59536, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1285785, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.596764982531578, "pattern_frame_updates": 123158, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1104626464, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8969.181571639683, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2055, "avg_candidate_generations": 171.25, "candidate_moves_total": 143538, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.84817518248175, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 2043, "search_candidate_moves_total": 142698, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 4426, "avg_legality_checks": 368.8333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4426, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 262467, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21872.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 638528916, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2432.7969459017704, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2267, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 188.91666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18278634, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8062.917512130569, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 63300, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2238, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17975142, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 240192, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12877557, "stage_ordering_ns": 69630, "stage_eval_ns": 1105912249, "stage_threat_ns": 845797479, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 123170, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 743733595, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 206410, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13700, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61579, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 86076814, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 123158, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15780660, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1879, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6081.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6748.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1939, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1013, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7198, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 83, 96, 80, 81, 66, 108, 109, 124, 82, 126, 141, 138, 152, 144, 160, 125, 127, 123, 122, 153, 168, 93 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 6378, "avg_search_time_ms": 490.61538461538464, "search_nodes": 157343, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 158392, "avg_nodes": 12184.0, "eval_calls": 152809, "avg_eval_calls": 11754.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 152809, "pattern_eval_ns": 3302203, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.610003337499755, "pattern_frame_queries": 152809, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3302203, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.610003337499755, "pattern_frame_updates": 314612, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3822193485, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12148.911945507482, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4510, "avg_candidate_generations": 346.9230769230769, "candidate_moves_total": 329655, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.09423503325942, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4497, "search_candidate_moves_total": 328741, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 149572, "avg_legality_checks": 11505.538461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 87, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 148658, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1077930, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 82917.69230769231, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2678618157, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2484.964846511369, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18419, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1416.8461538461538, "renju_forbidden_ns": 149316177, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8106.638634019219, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 101, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 971072, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18279, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 148072173, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 272932, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.615384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 625083, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10418.05, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6.461538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 295691, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3520.1309523809523, "stage_move_gen_ns": 385367009, "stage_ordering_ns": 160660, "stage_eval_ns": 3825495688, "stage_threat_ns": 2143805872, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 314625, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1875265238, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 919953, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13580, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 157306, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 227366366, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 314612, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40254315, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3917, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5824.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6439.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1814, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 810, "avg_search_time_ms": 67.5, "search_nodes": 19517, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 840, "corridor_branch_probes": 1057, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 322, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 828, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 828, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 322, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 175, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 78080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 21369, "avg_nodes": 1780.75, "eval_calls": 18091, "avg_eval_calls": 1507.5833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 18091, "pattern_eval_ns": 388100, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.452656016803935, "pattern_frame_queries": 18091, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 388100, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.452656016803935, "pattern_frame_updates": 38964, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 349931169, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8980.88412380659, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1403, "avg_candidate_generations": 116.91666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 100742, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.80470420527442, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 1391, "search_candidate_moves_total": 99902, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3517, "avg_legality_checks": 293.0833333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3517, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 119020, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9918.333333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 281684591, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2366.699638716182, "renju_forbidden_checks": 921, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 76.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8895298, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9658.304017372422, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 70121, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 876, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8481786, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30870, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 312521, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10026801, "stage_ordering_ns": 47670, "stage_eval_ns": 350319269, "stage_threat_ns": 372272773, "stage_proof_ns": 57730623, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 40704, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 272045959, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52345, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 54818938, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 466, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12797654, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 20346, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 29498430, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1728, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10693232, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 40692, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5216214, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1263, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6210.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6877.416666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1953, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1014, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8749, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 83, 96, 80, 81, 66, 108, 109, 124, 82, 126, 141, 138, 152, 144, 160, 125, 127, 123, 122, 153, 168, 93 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8069, "avg_search_time_ms": 620.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 157343, "safety_nodes": 1049, "corridor_nodes": 4296, "corridor_branch_probes": 4618, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1919, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 4261, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4261, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 109, "corridor_proof_active": 35, "corridor_proof_quiet": 74, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1919, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 109, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 857, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 281760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 162688, "avg_nodes": 12514.461538461539, "eval_calls": 152809, "avg_eval_calls": 11754.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 152809, "pattern_eval_ns": 3352597, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.939787577956796, "pattern_frame_queries": 152809, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3352597, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.939787577956796, "pattern_frame_updates": 314612, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3840153053, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12205.996761089851, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4510, "avg_candidate_generations": 346.9230769230769, "candidate_moves_total": 329655, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.09423503325942, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4497, "search_candidate_moves_total": 328741, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 149572, "avg_legality_checks": 11505.538461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 87, "root_legality_checks": 914, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 148658, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1662826, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 127909.69230769231, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3910689116, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2351.833033642726, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19446, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1495.8461538461538, "renju_forbidden_ns": 157669874, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8108.087730124447, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 101, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 988293, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18279, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 149522561, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 178, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2200603, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 888, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4958417, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9644, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 741.8461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 101020912, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10475.001244296973, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13511, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1039.3076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 53342168, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3948.0547701872547, "stage_move_gen_ns": 385996091, "stage_ordering_ns": 160150, "stage_eval_ns": 3843505650, "stage_threat_ns": 3138324222, "stage_proof_ns": 676585222, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 323365, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1989494583, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 246307, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 818312615, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2466, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 166328338, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 161676, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 237887734, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8740, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 51254859, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 323352, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41374431, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 372, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3917, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5582.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6198.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1774, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 669, "avg_search_time_ms": 55.75, "search_nodes": 19517, "safety_nodes": 1012, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 20529, "avg_nodes": 1710.75, "eval_calls": 18091, "avg_eval_calls": 1507.5833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 18091, "pattern_eval_ns": 394392, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.80045326405395, "pattern_frame_queries": 18091, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 394392, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.80045326405395, "pattern_frame_updates": 38964, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 354297828, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9092.953187557745, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1403, "avg_candidate_generations": 116.91666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 100742, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.80470420527442, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 840, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 1391, "search_candidate_moves_total": 99902, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 3517, "avg_legality_checks": 293.0833333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3517, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 92479, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7706.583333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 224153613, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2423.832578206944, "renju_forbidden_checks": 906, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 75.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8851780, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9770.1766004415, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 68980, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 876, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8550768, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 232032, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10042162, "stage_ordering_ns": 47770, "stage_eval_ns": 354692220, "stage_threat_ns": 284078191, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 38976, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 251025432, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 202542, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13591, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 19482, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 27889562, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 38964, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4960655, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1263, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6220.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6886.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1956, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1015, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4246, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 95, 156, 114, 143, 98, 158, 173, 170, 184, 94, 82, 67, 66, 130, 50 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1797, "avg_search_time_ms": 199.66666666666666, "search_nodes": 40771, "safety_nodes": 457, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 41228, "avg_nodes": 4580.888888888889, "eval_calls": 39006, "avg_eval_calls": 4334.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39006, "pattern_eval_ns": 851442, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.828487924934624, "pattern_frame_queries": 39006, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 851442, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.828487924934624, "pattern_frame_updates": 81492, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1121521510, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13762.351028321798, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1749, "avg_candidate_generations": 194.33333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 130536, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.63464837049743, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 591, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 1740, "search_candidate_moves_total": 129945, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 37382, "avg_legality_checks": 4153.555555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 591, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 36791, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 326447, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 36271.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 830522537, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2544.1267250120236, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5050, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 561.1111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 35612394, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7051.959207920792, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 167140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5028, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35445254, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 12, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.3333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 127630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10635.833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.6666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 57410, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3827.3333333333335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 97292413, "stage_ordering_ns": 65050, "stage_eval_ns": 1122372952, "stage_threat_ns": 562386726, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 81501, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 493338486, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 212340, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40746, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 58609503, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 81492, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10226397, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1414, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5585.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6474.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1863, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 2439, "avg_search_time_ms": 304.875, "search_nodes": 60337, "safety_nodes": 648, "corridor_nodes": 1830, "corridor_branch_probes": 2122, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 808, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1810, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1805, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 808, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 49, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 325, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 197440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 62815, "avg_nodes": 7851.875, "eval_calls": 58328, "avg_eval_calls": 7291.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 58328, "pattern_eval_ns": 1272854, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.82234947195172, "pattern_frame_queries": 58328, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1272854, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.82234947195172, "pattern_frame_updates": 120628, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1288755048, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10683.713963590542, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1994, "avg_candidate_generations": 249.25, "candidate_moves_total": 140335, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.37863590772317, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 528, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 1986, "search_candidate_moves_total": 139807, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 3406, "avg_legality_checks": 425.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3406, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 363068, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 45383.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 904018363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2489.9422780305617, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2943, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 367.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19770283, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6717.731226639484, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2885, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19270821, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 487862, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 11600, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 268103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9929.74074074074, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 121041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3458.3142857142857, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10158408, "stage_ordering_ns": 71940, "stage_eval_ns": 1290027902, "stage_threat_ns": 1051904919, "stage_proof_ns": 77622199, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 124356, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 787408583, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 107761, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 136155678, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 915, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 47433852, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 62174, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92385794, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3720, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19645301, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 124348, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16309563, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 127, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1789, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4933.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5933.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1016, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4263, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 95, 156, 114, 143, 98, 158, 173, 170, 184, 94, 82, 67, 66, 130, 50 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2103, "avg_search_time_ms": 233.66666666666666, "search_nodes": 40771, "safety_nodes": 457, "corridor_nodes": 546, "corridor_branch_probes": 637, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 181, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 537, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 537, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 181, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 287, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 100000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 41774, "avg_nodes": 4641.555555555556, "eval_calls": 39006, "avg_eval_calls": 4334.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39006, "pattern_eval_ns": 839833, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.530867046095473, "pattern_frame_queries": 39006, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 839833, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.530867046095473, "pattern_frame_updates": 81492, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1127506899, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13835.798593726991, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1749, "avg_candidate_generations": 194.33333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 130536, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.63464837049743, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 591, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 1740, "search_candidate_moves_total": 129945, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 37382, "avg_legality_checks": 4153.555555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 591, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 36791, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 429424, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 47713.77777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1055936218, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2458.9594852639816, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5217, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 579.6666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37091178, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7109.675675675676, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 170500, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5028, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35742224, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 548862, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 125, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 629592, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1443, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 160.33333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 15300208, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10603.054747054746, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1935, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 215.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 7853941, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4058.884237726098, "stage_move_gen_ns": 97710497, "stage_ordering_ns": 66130, "stage_eval_ns": 1128346732, "stage_threat_ns": 710386798, "stage_proof_ns": 149899136, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 82657, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 507576826, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37966, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 126351179, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 413, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 26503047, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 41324, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 59722370, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1156, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6371848, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 82648, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10364575, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1414, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5537.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6426.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1826, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 2153, "avg_search_time_ms": 269.125, "search_nodes": 60337, "safety_nodes": 648, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 60985, "avg_nodes": 7623.125, "eval_calls": 58328, "avg_eval_calls": 7291.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 58328, "pattern_eval_ns": 1251112, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.449595391578658, "pattern_frame_queries": 58328, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1251112, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.449595391578658, "pattern_frame_updates": 120628, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1288421137, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10680.945858341347, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1994, "avg_candidate_generations": 249.25, "candidate_moves_total": 140335, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.37863590772317, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 528, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 1986, "search_candidate_moves_total": 139807, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 3406, "avg_legality_checks": 425.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3406, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 313289, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 39161.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 788062533, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2515.4490997130447, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2885, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 360.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19291262, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6686.745927209706, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2885, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19291262, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10116996, "stage_ordering_ns": 76240, "stage_eval_ns": 1289672249, "stage_threat_ns": 841311118, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 120636, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 739197945, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 136660, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8700, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 60314, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 86331290, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 120628, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15645223, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 127, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1789, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5030.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6030.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1017, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7085, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 80, 99, 141, 128, 125, 129, 130, 85, 71, 65, 109, 108, 93, 157, 77 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 3772, "avg_search_time_ms": 419.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 87016, "safety_nodes": 457, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87473, "avg_nodes": 9719.222222222223, "eval_calls": 84454, "avg_eval_calls": 9383.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84454, "pattern_eval_ns": 1829762, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.665782556184432, "pattern_frame_queries": 84454, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1829762, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.665782556184432, "pattern_frame_updates": 173982, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2346894355, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13489.294036164662, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2546, "avg_candidate_generations": 282.8888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 183756, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.17439120188531, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 591, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 2537, "search_candidate_moves_total": 183165, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 82479, "avg_legality_checks": 9164.333333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 591, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 81888, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 666203, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 74022.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1698121500, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2548.9550482360482, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8025, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 891.6666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 63733790, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7941.905295950156, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 184352, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7990, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 63549438, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 12, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.3333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 122260, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10188.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.6666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 55430, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3695.3333333333335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 216654752, "stage_ordering_ns": 95890, "stage_eval_ns": 2348724117, "stage_threat_ns": 1189203129, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 173991, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1041222032, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 206470, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86991, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125911250, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 173982, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21863377, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2169, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5242.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6131.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1868, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 3307, "avg_search_time_ms": 413.375, "search_nodes": 92715, "safety_nodes": 648, "corridor_nodes": 1700, "corridor_branch_probes": 1964, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 762, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1683, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1678, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 762, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 49, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 325, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 146080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 95063, "avg_nodes": 11882.875, "eval_calls": 89450, "avg_eval_calls": 11181.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89450, "pattern_eval_ns": 1937074, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.655382895472332, "pattern_frame_queries": 89450, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1937074, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.655382895472332, "pattern_frame_updates": 185384, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1747500651, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9426.383350235188, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3250, "avg_candidate_generations": 406.25, "candidate_moves_total": 228308, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.24861538461539, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 528, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 3242, "search_candidate_moves_total": 227780, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5952, "avg_legality_checks": 744.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5952, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 463115, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 57889.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1144125315, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2470.499368407415, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2265, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 283.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21559199, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9518.410154525387, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2217, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21097389, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 450220, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 11590, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 257121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9523.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 116360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3324.5714285714284, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17380559, "stage_ordering_ns": 115780, "stage_eval_ns": 1749437725, "stage_threat_ns": 1448928140, "stage_proof_ns": 78293764, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 188858, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1138839855, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 98891, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 131612503, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 866, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 47352875, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 94425, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 136178892, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3466, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18348126, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 188850, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23948764, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 127, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2961, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4439.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5439.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1018, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7043, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 80, 99, 141, 128, 125, 129, 130, 85, 71, 65, 109, 108, 93, 157, 77 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4023, "avg_search_time_ms": 447.0, "search_nodes": 87016, "safety_nodes": 457, "corridor_nodes": 462, "corridor_branch_probes": 550, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 139, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 453, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 453, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 139, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 287, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 101360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 87935, "avg_nodes": 9770.555555555555, "eval_calls": 84454, "avg_eval_calls": 9383.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84454, "pattern_eval_ns": 1823338, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.589717479337864, "pattern_frame_queries": 84454, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1823338, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.589717479337864, "pattern_frame_updates": 173982, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2332204505, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13404.860876412502, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2546, "avg_candidate_generations": 282.8888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 183756, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.17439120188531, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 591, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 2537, "search_candidate_moves_total": 183165, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 82479, "avg_legality_checks": 9164.333333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "root_legality_checks": 591, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 81888, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 27, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 758478, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 84275.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1884458231, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2484.5258939613277, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8159, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 906.5555555555555, "renju_forbidden_ns": 63613060, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7796.67361196225, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 183300, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7990, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62577967, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 33, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 419762, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 101, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 432031, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1276, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 141.77777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 13441879, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10534.387931034482, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1749, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 194.33333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 6994505, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3999.145225843339, "stage_move_gen_ns": 215838539, "stage_ordering_ns": 91501, "stage_eval_ns": 2334027843, "stage_threat_ns": 1313476953, "stage_proof_ns": 141459815, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 174979, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1054026874, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33583, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 106663244, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 380, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 22244211, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 87485, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125499612, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 988, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5173046, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 174970, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22114177, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2169, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5193.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6082.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1833, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 3014, "avg_search_time_ms": 376.75, "search_nodes": 92715, "safety_nodes": 648, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 93363, "avg_nodes": 11670.375, "eval_calls": 89450, "avg_eval_calls": 11181.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89450, "pattern_eval_ns": 1934389, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.625366126327556, "pattern_frame_queries": 89450, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1934389, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.625366126327556, "pattern_frame_updates": 185384, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1728480066, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9323.78234367583, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3250, "avg_candidate_generations": 406.25, "candidate_moves_total": 228308, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.24861538461539, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 528, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 3242, "search_candidate_moves_total": 227780, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5952, "avg_legality_checks": 744.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5952, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 413457, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 51682.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1022421819, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2472.8613108497375, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2217, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 277.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20590290, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9287.45602165088, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2217, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20590290, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17267618, "stage_ordering_ns": 112290, "stage_eval_ns": 1730414455, "stage_threat_ns": 1251833570, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 185392, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1098178218, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 138100, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8690, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92692, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 130206025, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 185384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23311227, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 127, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2961, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4539.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5539.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1019, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10013, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 143, 67, 52, 95, 53, 83, 80, 51, 99, 113, 129, 65, 49, 66, 159, 175, 114, 144, 84, 69, 68, 36, 21, 37, 100, 116, 23, 35, 19, 38, 34, 39 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 6877, "avg_search_time_ms": 382.05555555555554, "search_nodes": 172736, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 173533, "avg_nodes": 9640.722222222223, "eval_calls": 165916, "avg_eval_calls": 9217.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 165916, "pattern_eval_ns": 3577550, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.562417126738833, "pattern_frame_queries": 165916, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3577550, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.562417126738833, "pattern_frame_updates": 345368, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4290810037, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12423.878405063584, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6786, "avg_candidate_generations": 377.0, "candidate_moves_total": 543573, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.10212201591511, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 6768, "search_candidate_moves_total": 542271, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 157288, "avg_legality_checks": 8738.222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 127, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 155986, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 127, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1398991, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 77721.72222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3190190517, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2280.3509936804453, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27971, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1553.9444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 222122601, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7941.174823924779, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 370, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3025235, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27587, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 218970715, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 126651, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 367421, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10206.138888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7222222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 181321, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3700.4285714285716, "stage_move_gen_ns": 366324768, "stage_ordering_ns": 250720, "stage_eval_ns": 4294387587, "stage_threat_ns": 2165235163, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 345386, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1892491694, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 48, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 502051, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 172684, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 231487764, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 345368, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40753654, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 707, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5823, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6778.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7223.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1864, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 3119, "avg_search_time_ms": 183.47058823529412, "search_nodes": 83589, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 1160, "corridor_branch_probes": 1414, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 462, "corridor_neutral_exits": 24, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 1140, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1135, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 35, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 462, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 218, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 214560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 86640, "avg_nodes": 5096.470588235294, "eval_calls": 80899, "avg_eval_calls": 4758.764705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80899, "pattern_eval_ns": 1751634, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.652109420388385, "pattern_frame_queries": 80899, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1751634, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.652109420388385, "pattern_frame_updates": 167078, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1740420726, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10416.81565496355, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2657, "avg_candidate_generations": 156.2941176470588, "candidate_moves_total": 210366, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.1742566804667, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1235, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2640, "search_candidate_moves_total": 209131, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5095, "avg_legality_checks": 299.70588235294116, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5095, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 558911, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32877.117647058825, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1251474373, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2239.1299741819357, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4401, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 258.88235294117646, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30663868, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6967.477391501931, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 78371, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4359, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30284505, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 82431, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 218561, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.7058823529411766, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 305660, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6644.782608695652, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2941176470588234, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 97630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1743.392857142857, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14050197, "stage_ordering_ns": 85772, "stage_eval_ns": 1742172360, "stage_threat_ns": 1247495546, "stage_proof_ns": 84054167, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169483, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1012231433, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 67032, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 80190543, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 697, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 27490975, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84733, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 117691884, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2388, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16336208, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169466, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21045478, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2469, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6734.705882352941, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7205.294117647059, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1020, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18101, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 143, 67, 52, 95, 53, 83, 80, 51, 99, 113, 129, 65, 49, 66, 159, 175, 114, 144, 84, 69, 68, 36, 21, 37, 100, 116, 23, 35, 19, 38, 34, 39 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 15283, "avg_search_time_ms": 849.0555555555555, "search_nodes": 172736, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 33916, "corridor_branch_probes": 36108, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 18642, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 45, "corridor_plies_followed": 33871, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 33871, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 17, "corridor_proof_completed": 17, "corridor_proof_checks": 136, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 91, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 18642, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 45, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 136, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 132, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1038, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 322880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 23360, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 207449, "avg_nodes": 11524.944444444445, "eval_calls": 165916, "avg_eval_calls": 9217.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 165916, "pattern_eval_ns": 3550660, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.400347163624968, "pattern_frame_queries": 165916, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3550660, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.400347163624968, "pattern_frame_updates": 345368, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4188372743, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12127.275089180237, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6786, "avg_candidate_generations": 377.0, "candidate_moves_total": 543573, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.10212201591511, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 6768, "search_candidate_moves_total": 542271, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 157288, "avg_legality_checks": 8738.222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 127, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 155986, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 127, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4537652, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 252091.77777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9253528223, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2039.2767499579077, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32486, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1804.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 251822366, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7751.71969463769, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 370, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2840377, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27587, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 212185814, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1550, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16239516, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2979, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 20556659, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76363, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4242.388888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 655524766, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8584.324424132106, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 102602, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5700.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 332372728, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3239.4371259819495, "stage_move_gen_ns": 358744032, "stage_ordering_ns": 244572, "stage_eval_ns": 4191923403, "stage_threat_ns": 7809535504, "stage_proof_ns": 2874450441, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 413400, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2716973063, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1494944, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4285442866, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15472, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 807562854, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 206691, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 307173264, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 68014, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 451553342, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 413382, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48392969, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 707, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5823, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6652.277777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7096.722222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1828, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 2799, "avg_search_time_ms": 164.64705882352942, "search_nodes": 83589, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85480, "avg_nodes": 5028.235294117647, "eval_calls": 80899, "avg_eval_calls": 4758.764705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80899, "pattern_eval_ns": 1732427, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.414689922001507, "pattern_frame_queries": 80899, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1732427, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.414689922001507, "pattern_frame_updates": 167078, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1675301216, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10027.060510659692, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2657, "avg_candidate_generations": 156.2941176470588, "candidate_moves_total": 210366, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.1742566804667, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1235, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2640, "search_candidate_moves_total": 209131, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5095, "avg_legality_checks": 299.70588235294116, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5095, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 515285, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 30310.882352941175, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1107490086, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2149.2767808106196, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4382, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 257.7647058823529, "renju_forbidden_ns": 25916099, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5914.2170241898675, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 44310, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4359, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25802958, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 68831, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13337597, "stage_ordering_ns": 87390, "stage_eval_ns": 1677033643, "stage_threat_ns": 1078589425, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 167095, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 946478704, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 444622, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 83539, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 111576528, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 167078, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20089571, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2469, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6742.176470588235, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7212.764705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1021, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9820, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 110, 109, 82, 124, 126, 81, 94, 142, 128, 144, 80, 64, 95, 146, 162, 143, 145, 141, 140, 125, 154, 168, 93, 92, 108, 157, 173, 122, 78, 62, 123, 63, 138 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 7059, "avg_search_time_ms": 371.5263157894737, "search_nodes": 209691, "safety_nodes": 1020, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 210711, "avg_nodes": 11090.052631578947, "eval_calls": 202053, "avg_eval_calls": 10634.368421052632, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 202053, "pattern_eval_ns": 4056060, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.07423794746923, "pattern_frame_queries": 202053, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4056060, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.07423794746923, "pattern_frame_updates": 419272, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4271858096, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10188.751206853785, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7602, "avg_candidate_generations": 400.10526315789474, "candidate_moves_total": 643202, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.60957642725599, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1483, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 7583, "search_candidate_moves_total": 641719, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 192968, "avg_legality_checks": 10156.21052631579, "illegal_moves_skipped": 61, "root_legality_checks": 1483, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 191485, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 61, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1577600, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 83031.57894736843, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3098925711, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1964.3291778651117, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27003, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1421.2105263157894, "renju_forbidden_ns": 156832486, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5807.965263118913, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 238, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1757838, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26751, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 154948098, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 126550, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.5789473684210527, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 457394, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9334.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.473684210526316, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 216062, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3273.6666666666665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 401745202, "stage_ordering_ns": 263442, "stage_eval_ns": 4275914156, "stage_threat_ns": 2322939179, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 419291, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2025052937, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 51, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 631165, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18100, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 209636, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 252942776, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 419272, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44312301, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 768, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6500, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6677.736842105263, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7098.789473684211, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1813, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 2742, "avg_search_time_ms": 152.33333333333334, "search_nodes": 86098, "safety_nodes": 2090, "corridor_nodes": 1249, "corridor_branch_probes": 1526, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 10, "corridor_depth_exits": 488, "corridor_neutral_exits": 21, "corridor_terminal_exits": 34, "corridor_plies_followed": 1227, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1222, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 17, "corridor_proof_completed": 17, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 31, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 488, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 219, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 202960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 89437, "avg_nodes": 4968.722222222223, "eval_calls": 83276, "avg_eval_calls": 4626.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83276, "pattern_eval_ns": 1657559, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.904402228733368, "pattern_frame_queries": 83276, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1657559, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.904402228733368, "pattern_frame_updates": 172090, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1505027670, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8745.584694055437, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2787, "avg_candidate_generations": 154.83333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 233432, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.75744528166487, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1402, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 2769, "search_candidate_moves_total": 232030, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 5949, "avg_legality_checks": 330.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5949, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 544459, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 30247.722222222223, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1052131811, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1932.4353367287529, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4733, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 262.94444444444446, "renju_forbidden_ns": 34574148, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7304.911895203888, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 75740, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4691, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34217957, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 67770, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 212681, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.2222222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 257902, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6447.55, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 82340, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1646.8, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14481093, "stage_ordering_ns": 85680, "stage_eval_ns": 1506685229, "stage_threat_ns": 1114936389, "stage_proof_ns": 75771960, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 174672, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 897497512, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 72348, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 75388573, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 743, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 26573605, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 87327, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107284447, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2564, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15827133, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 174654, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18938724, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 82, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2600, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6823.611111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7268.055555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1022, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19252, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 110, 109, 82, 124, 126, 81, 94, 142, 128, 144, 80, 64, 95, 146, 162, 143, 145, 141, 140, 125, 154, 168, 93, 92, 108, 157, 173, 122, 78, 62, 123, 63, 138 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 16533, "avg_search_time_ms": 870.1578947368421, "search_nodes": 209691, "safety_nodes": 1020, "corridor_nodes": 37473, "corridor_branch_probes": 40036, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 20497, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 48, "corridor_plies_followed": 37419, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 37419, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 18, "corridor_proof_completed": 18, "corridor_proof_checks": 145, "corridor_proof_active": 54, "corridor_proof_quiet": 91, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 20497, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 48, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 145, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 141, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1083, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 333280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 23360, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 248184, "avg_nodes": 13062.315789473685, "eval_calls": 202053, "avg_eval_calls": 10634.368421052632, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 202053, "pattern_eval_ns": 4035433, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.972150871306045, "pattern_frame_queries": 202053, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4035433, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.972150871306045, "pattern_frame_updates": 419272, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4430520064, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10567.173729702914, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7602, "avg_candidate_generations": 400.10526315789474, "candidate_moves_total": 643202, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.60957642725599, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1483, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 7583, "search_candidate_moves_total": 641719, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 192968, "avg_legality_checks": 10156.21052631579, "illegal_moves_skipped": 61, "root_legality_checks": 1483, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 191485, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 61, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5118759, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 269408.36842105264, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9850768762, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1924.4447261533508, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32657, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1718.7894736842106, "renju_forbidden_ns": 197773230, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6056.074654744772, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 238, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1291493, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26751, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 150789696, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1896, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19430128, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3772, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 26261913, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83863, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4413.8421052631575, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 718107818, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8562.868225558352, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 113214, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5958.631578947368, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 362014476, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3197.6122741003765, "stage_move_gen_ns": 415563559, "stage_ordering_ns": 263492, "stage_eval_ns": 4434555497, "stage_threat_ns": 8649598465, "stage_proof_ns": 2988500448, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 494419, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3018902217, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1657796, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4749490857, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17190, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 908088175, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 247200, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 336674649, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 75128, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 489788374, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 494400, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 54742368, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 768, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6500, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.10526315789473684, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6536.789473684211, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6957.8421052631575, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1787, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 2698, "avg_search_time_ms": 149.88888888888889, "search_nodes": 86098, "safety_nodes": 2090, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 88188, "avg_nodes": 4899.333333333333, "eval_calls": 83276, "avg_eval_calls": 4626.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83276, "pattern_eval_ns": 1681259, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.188998030645084, "pattern_frame_queries": 83276, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1681259, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.188998030645084, "pattern_frame_updates": 172090, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1606851900, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9337.276425126387, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2787, "avg_candidate_generations": 154.83333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 233432, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.75744528166487, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1402, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 2769, "search_candidate_moves_total": 232030, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 5949, "avg_legality_checks": 330.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5949, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 498850, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27713.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1040930625, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2086.6605693094116, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4714, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 261.8888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30729660, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6518.8078065337295, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 60280, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4691, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30561330, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 108050, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14753915, "stage_ordering_ns": 87450, "stage_eval_ns": 1608533159, "stage_threat_ns": 1049441159, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 172108, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 920396842, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 47, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 452560, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86045, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108951829, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 172090, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19639928, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 82, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2600, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6829.944444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7274.388888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1023, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7545, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 158, 82, 67, 110, 68, 98, 95, 66, 114, 128, 144, 80, 64, 81, 174, 190, 129, 159, 99, 84, 83, 70, 56, 51, 36, 52, 115, 131, 38, 50, 34, 53, 49, 54 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 5632, "avg_search_time_ms": 296.42105263157896, "search_nodes": 252146, "safety_nodes": 1020, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 253166, "avg_nodes": 13324.526315789473, "eval_calls": 243876, "avg_eval_calls": 12835.578947368422, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 243876, "pattern_eval_ns": 4402062, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.050410864537717, "pattern_frame_queries": 243876, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4402062, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.050410864537717, "pattern_frame_updates": 504182, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3485564272, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6913.305655497419, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8234, "avg_candidate_generations": 433.36842105263156, "candidate_moves_total": 735776, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.3582705853777, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1483, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 8215, "search_candidate_moves_total": 734293, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 234835, "avg_legality_checks": 12359.736842105263, "illegal_moves_skipped": 191, "root_legality_checks": 1483, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 233352, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 191, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1953724, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 102827.57894736843, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2455797731, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1256.9829366891126, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42820, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2253.684210526316, "renju_forbidden_ns": 182743608, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4267.716207379729, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 642, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2925169, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 42164, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 179752639, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 65800, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.5789473684210527, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 281240, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5739.591836734694, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.473684210526316, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 142950, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2165.909090909091, "stage_move_gen_ns": 307089602, "stage_ordering_ns": 251310, "stage_eval_ns": 3489966334, "stage_threat_ns": 1766541535, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 504201, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1519098027, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 51, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 380231, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10411, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 252091, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 210922868, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 504182, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36140409, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 768, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7134, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6897.736842105263, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7318.789473684211, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1907, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 1893, "avg_search_time_ms": 105.16666666666667, "search_nodes": 88442, "safety_nodes": 2090, "corridor_nodes": 1265, "corridor_branch_probes": 1541, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 12, "corridor_depth_exits": 504, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_plies_followed": 1243, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1238, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 17, "corridor_proof_completed": 17, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 37, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 504, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 219, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 202480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 91797, "avg_nodes": 5099.833333333333, "eval_calls": 85586, "avg_eval_calls": 4754.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 85586, "pattern_eval_ns": 1547267, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.07850583039282, "pattern_frame_queries": 85586, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1547267, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.07850583039282, "pattern_frame_updates": 176778, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1062510559, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6010.423010781885, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2821, "avg_candidate_generations": 156.72222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 235901, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.62318326834456, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1402, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 2803, "search_candidate_moves_total": 234499, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 5434, "avg_legality_checks": 301.8888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5434, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 577129, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32062.722222222223, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 719546285, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1246.7685474131433, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5097, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 283.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19617998, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3848.9303511869725, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 43240, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5056, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19405848, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 47460, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 121450, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 40, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.2222222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 154660, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 3866.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 55070, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1101.4, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8595700, "stage_ordering_ns": 79690, "stage_eval_ns": 1064057826, "stage_threat_ns": 749469398, "stage_proof_ns": 44475904, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 179392, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 602410153, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 72496, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 45890472, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 747, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15640742, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89687, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 77173817, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2596, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10172261, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 179374, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13822695, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 82, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2631, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6843.611111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7288.055555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1024, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14834, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 158, 82, 67, 110, 68, 98, 95, 66, 114, 128, 144, 80, 64, 81, 174, 190, 129, 159, 99, 84, 83, 70, 56, 51, 36, 52, 115, 131, 38, 50, 34, 53, 49, 54 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 12942, "avg_search_time_ms": 681.1578947368421, "search_nodes": 252146, "safety_nodes": 1020, "corridor_nodes": 35804, "corridor_branch_probes": 38388, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 19378, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 45, "corridor_plies_followed": 35751, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 35751, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 18, "corridor_proof_completed": 18, "corridor_proof_checks": 145, "corridor_proof_active": 53, "corridor_proof_quiet": 92, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 19378, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 45, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 145, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 141, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1083, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 363440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 23360, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 288970, "avg_nodes": 15208.947368421053, "eval_calls": 243876, "avg_eval_calls": 12835.578947368422, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 243876, "pattern_eval_ns": 4645409, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.04824172940347, "pattern_frame_queries": 243876, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4645409, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.04824172940347, "pattern_frame_updates": 504182, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4498424272, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8922.223070240509, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8234, "avg_candidate_generations": 433.36842105263156, "candidate_moves_total": 735776, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.3582705853777, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1483, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 8215, "search_candidate_moves_total": 734293, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 234835, "avg_legality_checks": 12359.736842105263, "illegal_moves_skipped": 191, "root_legality_checks": 1483, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 233352, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 191, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5377925, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 283048.6842105263, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7222018456, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1342.9005529084172, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47962, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2524.315789473684, "renju_forbidden_ns": 285418677, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5950.933593261332, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 642, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5322983, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 42164, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 251565425, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1819, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12944002, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3337, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 15586267, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 80719, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4248.368421052632, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 440400052, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5455.965163096669, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109057, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5739.8421052631575, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 227606150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2087.0384294451524, "stage_move_gen_ns": 405809254, "stage_ordering_ns": 265531, "stage_eval_ns": 4503069681, "stage_threat_ns": 6143252799, "stage_proof_ns": 1822446227, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 575993, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2583870579, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1603957, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2887411831, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16646, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 552285409, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 287987, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 314184840, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 71792, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 307213488, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 575974, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50572061, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 768, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7134, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6881.473684210527, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7302.526315789473, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1905, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 1873, "avg_search_time_ms": 104.05555555555556, "search_nodes": 88442, "safety_nodes": 2090, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 90532, "avg_nodes": 5029.555555555556, "eval_calls": 85586, "avg_eval_calls": 4754.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 85586, "pattern_eval_ns": 1571509, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.36175309045872, "pattern_frame_queries": 85586, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1571509, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.36175309045872, "pattern_frame_updates": 176778, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1117323981, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6320.492261480501, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2821, "avg_candidate_generations": 156.72222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 235901, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.62318326834456, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1402, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 2803, "search_candidate_moves_total": 234499, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 5434, "avg_legality_checks": 301.8888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5434, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 531540, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29530.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 706626174, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1329.3941641268766, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5078, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 282.1111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 28164993, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5546.473611658133, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 78220, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5056, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27933233, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 153540, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9835090, "stage_ordering_ns": 80000, "stage_eval_ns": 1118895490, "stage_threat_ns": 714808729, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 176796, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 621784644, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 47, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 308330, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 88389, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 78540939, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 176778, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14174816, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 82, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2631, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6847.277777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7291.722222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1989, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1025, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14745, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 80, 99, 85, 141, 155, 128, 83, 143, 158, 84, 69, 111, 52, 67, 55, 41, 159, 129, 79, 81, 157, 156, 126, 144, 114, 142, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 4745, "avg_search_time_ms": 316.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 110608, "safety_nodes": 1647, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 112255, "avg_nodes": 7483.666666666667, "eval_calls": 106747, "avg_eval_calls": 7116.466666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 106747, "pattern_eval_ns": 2152934, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.168566798130158, "pattern_frame_queries": 106747, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2152934, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.168566798130158, "pattern_frame_updates": 221128, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3136657807, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14184.806116819218, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3832, "avg_candidate_generations": 255.46666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 328864, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.8204592901879, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1149, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 3817, "search_candidate_moves_total": 327715, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 104095, "avg_legality_checks": 6939.666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 721, "root_legality_checks": 1149, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 102946, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 715, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1045288, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 69685.86666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2338010906, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2236.714576269889, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26941, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1796.0666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 225190153, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8358.641215990498, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 729, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6131104, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26160, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 218702258, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 356791, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 94, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.266666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 869875, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9253.989361702128, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 116, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.733333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 415102, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3578.4655172413795, "stage_move_gen_ns": 239882532, "stage_ordering_ns": 119660, "stage_eval_ns": 3138810741, "stage_threat_ns": 1335228684, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 221143, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1166075111, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 41, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1195976, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16310, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 110564, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 142964429, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 221128, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24993168, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 193, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3492, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6566.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7099.466666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1874, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 9985, "avg_search_time_ms": 665.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 68400, "safety_nodes": 976, "corridor_nodes": 2195, "corridor_branch_probes": 2537, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 843, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 79, "corridor_plies_followed": 2168, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1988, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 180, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 843, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 79, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 453, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 179120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 16560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 71571, "avg_nodes": 4771.4, "eval_calls": 45228, "avg_eval_calls": 3015.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 45228, "pattern_eval_ns": 943813, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.867891571592818, "pattern_frame_queries": 45228, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 943813, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.867891571592818, "pattern_frame_updates": 136666, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1418447380, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10378.933897238523, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21738, "avg_candidate_generations": 1449.2, "candidate_moves_total": 1923680, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.49388168184745, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1193, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 21723, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1922487, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1429537, "avg_legality_checks": 95302.46666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6527, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1429537, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6527, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3241317, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 216087.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6515811516, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2010.2358134054768, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65729, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4381.933333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 193921316, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2950.315933606171, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8447, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 64799617, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9134, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 47764818, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 47863, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 80353352, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 285, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1003529, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 130575, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8705.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1292197548, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9896.209442848938, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 171362, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11424.133333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 646905963, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3775.084108495466, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3367094973, "stage_ordering_ns": 745906129, "stage_eval_ns": 1419391193, "stage_threat_ns": 4273753666, "stage_proof_ns": 117144219, "tactical_annotations": 468878, "root_tactical_annotations": 2060, "search_tactical_annotations": 466818, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 141155, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 870970254, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 533677, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3239322899, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44763, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1541000504, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 106072697, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4474, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25027608, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 141140, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17561522, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 162812, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 709809092, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 195354, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 869677358, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110712, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14798686, "child_limit_applications": 21723, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21723, "child_cap_hits": 21723, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21723, "child_moves_before_total": 1915960, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1915960, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 348960, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 348960, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.19960410624684, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.06407954702389, "tt_hits": 10030, "tt_cutoffs": 1382, "beta_cutoffs": 18864, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5784.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6317.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1844, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1026, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18210, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 83, 128, 67, 82, 111, 69, 35, 51, 66, 125, 65, 64, 80, 50, 52, 94, 36, 79, 38, 24, 37, 34, 39 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10704, "avg_search_time_ms": 892.0, "search_nodes": 121063, "safety_nodes": 380, "corridor_nodes": 1038, "corridor_branch_probes": 1178, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 285, "corridor_neutral_exits": 84, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1002, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1002, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 145, "corridor_proof_active": 36, "corridor_proof_quiet": 109, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 84, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 285, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 145, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 144, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1225, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 858880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 122481, "avg_nodes": 10206.75, "eval_calls": 82675, "avg_eval_calls": 6889.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82675, "pattern_eval_ns": 1709077, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.672234653764743, "pattern_frame_queries": 82675, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1709077, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.672234653764743, "pattern_frame_updates": 242022, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2329252029, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9624.133463073606, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35206, "avg_candidate_generations": 2933.8333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2630086, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.70561836050673, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 769, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 35194, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2629317, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 851647, "avg_legality_checks": 70970.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 129, "root_legality_checks": 769, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 850878, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 129, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2986917, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 248909.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6302334623, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2109.9798297040056, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12231, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1019.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37191411, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3040.749816041207, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 143, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1287294, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3511, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24924718, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8565, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10955469, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 23930, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60340, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5028.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 514566775, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8527.788780245277, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81014, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6751.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 221548880, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2734.6986940528795, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2002298219, "stage_ordering_ns": 1018569176, "stage_eval_ns": 2330961106, "stage_threat_ns": 4905404006, "stage_proof_ns": 395934112, "tactical_annotations": 419246, "root_tactical_annotations": 2716, "search_tactical_annotations": 416530, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 244328, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1388048863, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 490607, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3298341381, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 71605, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2331430656, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 122158, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 167634735, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2294, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11732615, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 244316, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28816170, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 126655, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 111678462, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 213229, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 688964124, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79362, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10830242, "child_limit_applications": 35194, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35194, "child_cap_hits": 35194, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35194, "child_moves_before_total": 2629188, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2629188, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 563108, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 563108, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.70557481388873, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000113655736772, "tt_hits": 15109, "tt_cutoffs": 3142, "beta_cutoffs": 29794, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4388.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5054.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 727, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7494, "avg_search_time_ms": 681.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 250659, "safety_nodes": 908, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 251567, "avg_nodes": 22869.727272727272, "eval_calls": 246141, "avg_eval_calls": 22376.454545454544, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 246141, "pattern_eval_ns": 5071650, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.604653430350897, "pattern_frame_queries": 246141, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5071650, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.604653430350897, "pattern_frame_updates": 501254, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4321379364, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8621.136916613134, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4497, "avg_candidate_generations": 408.8181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 340261, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.66399822103625, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 718, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 4486, "search_candidate_moves_total": 339543, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 9465, "avg_legality_checks": 860.4545454545455, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9465, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1216024, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 110547.63636363637, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2655618693, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2183.8538491016625, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3088, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 280.72727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21599099, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6994.526878238342, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3088, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21599099, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23318477, "stage_ordering_ns": 145180, "stage_eval_ns": 4326451014, "stage_threat_ns": 3114533122, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 501265, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2734749852, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 237941, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 250627, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 321031499, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 501254, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58513830, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 177, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4138, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5615.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6342.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1818, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1027, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11688, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 81, 100, 142, 72, 86, 129, 126, 130, 131, 66, 110, 109, 94, 78, 158 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 3729, "avg_search_time_ms": 414.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 91539, "safety_nodes": 510, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92049, "avg_nodes": 10227.666666666666, "eval_calls": 88931, "avg_eval_calls": 9881.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 88931, "pattern_eval_ns": 1829391, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.570903284568935, "pattern_frame_queries": 88931, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1829391, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.570903284568935, "pattern_frame_updates": 183028, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2337536168, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12771.467578731123, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2592, "avg_candidate_generations": 288.0, "candidate_moves_total": 189345, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.04976851851852, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 628, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 2583, "search_candidate_moves_total": 188717, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 86742, "avg_legality_checks": 9638.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 628, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 86114, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 707379, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 78597.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1712348883, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2420.695105452664, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8151, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 905.6666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 63040319, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7734.059501901607, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 172442, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8126, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62867877, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 12, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.3333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 114111, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9509.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.6666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 50371, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3358.0666666666666, "stage_move_gen_ns": 212126155, "stage_ordering_ns": 83711, "stage_eval_ns": 2339365559, "stage_threat_ns": 1163573757, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 183037, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1020109464, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 191911, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91514, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121494585, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 183028, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21777797, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2213, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5278.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6167.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1875, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7950, "avg_search_time_ms": 993.75, "search_nodes": 61238, "safety_nodes": 553, "corridor_nodes": 1046, "corridor_branch_probes": 1222, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 448, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1034, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1034, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 42, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 448, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 42, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 42, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 296, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 192720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 16560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 62837, "avg_nodes": 7854.625, "eval_calls": 41839, "avg_eval_calls": 5229.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41839, "pattern_eval_ns": 873262, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.871961566959058, "pattern_frame_queries": 41839, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 873262, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.871961566959058, "pattern_frame_updates": 122406, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1300159425, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10621.696853095436, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18213, "avg_candidate_generations": 2276.625, "candidate_moves_total": 1478479, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.17712622851809, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 555, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 18205, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1477924, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1069663, "avg_legality_checks": 133707.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 691, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1069663, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 691, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2486083, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 310760.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5242765565, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2108.845748512821, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15003, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1875.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 39014019, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2600.4145170965808, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 697, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7065848, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1876, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13880324, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12430, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18067847, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 96391, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12048.875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 887923262, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9211.682231743627, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 128615, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16076.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 389551731, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3028.820363099172, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2557310828, "stage_ordering_ns": 610723873, "stage_eval_ns": 1301032687, "stage_threat_ns": 3367069654, "stage_proof_ns": 64430207, "tactical_annotations": 267019, "root_tactical_annotations": 981, "search_tactical_annotations": 266038, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 124566, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 742357727, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 317509, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2503547412, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37032, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1321941910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 62279, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87933277, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2152, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10510877, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 124558, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15577832, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 53792, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 281580696, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 163964, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 850163966, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49263, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7142529, "child_limit_applications": 18205, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18205, "child_cap_hits": 18205, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18205, "child_moves_before_total": 1477233, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1477233, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 291327, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 291327, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.14435594616863, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00258170832189, "tt_hits": 5629, "tt_cutoffs": 1159, "beta_cutoffs": 15514, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2530.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3530.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 511, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1028, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12047, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 142, 110, 141, 96, 98, 140, 68, 125, 83, 53, 95, 124, 82, 156, 84, 70, 81, 85, 80 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8606, "avg_search_time_ms": 717.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 90448, "safety_nodes": 900, "corridor_nodes": 1719, "corridor_branch_probes": 1956, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 536, "corridor_neutral_exits": 79, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 1680, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1680, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 106, "corridor_proof_active": 39, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 79, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 536, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 106, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 105, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 776, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24290080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 93067, "avg_nodes": 7755.583333333333, "eval_calls": 67644, "avg_eval_calls": 5637.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67644, "pattern_eval_ns": 1390363, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.55412157767134, "pattern_frame_queries": 67644, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1390363, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.55412157767134, "pattern_frame_updates": 180792, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1982648235, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10966.459992698792, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21899, "avg_candidate_generations": 1824.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1638336, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.81327914516645, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 742, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 21887, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1637594, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 704042, "avg_legality_checks": 58670.166666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 731, "root_legality_checks": 742, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 703300, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 730, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2439301, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 203275.08333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5227396537, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2142.989543725846, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11933, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 994.4166666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57041437, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4780.142210676276, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 755, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7865774, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4490, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35036264, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6498, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13051515, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 190, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1087884, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 57297, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4774.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 464401526, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8105.163027732691, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72177, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6014.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 180481725, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2500.5434556714745, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1674974828, "stage_ordering_ns": 685403563, "stage_eval_ns": 1984038598, "stage_threat_ns": 3817549606, "stage_proof_ns": 406505750, "tactical_annotations": 280565, "root_tactical_annotations": 1377, "search_tactical_annotations": 279188, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 184376, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1070760641, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 393920, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2565467976, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45129, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1635714925, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92182, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 132657289, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3572, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19519573, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 184364, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22530759, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 78564, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 90166545, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 148352, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 561677541, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53649, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6613368, "child_limit_applications": 21887, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21887, "child_cap_hits": 21887, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21887, "child_moves_before_total": 1636864, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1636864, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 350195, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 350195, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.7870425366656, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000137067665737, "tt_hits": 8177, "tt_cutoffs": 865, "beta_cutoffs": 17463, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4948.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5614.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1174, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3430, "avg_search_time_ms": 311.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 111777, "safety_nodes": 518, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 112295, "avg_nodes": 10208.636363636364, "eval_calls": 107737, "avg_eval_calls": 9794.272727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107737, "pattern_eval_ns": 2207252, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.487409153772614, "pattern_frame_queries": 107737, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2207252, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.487409153772614, "pattern_frame_updates": 223490, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1996739629, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8934.357819141796, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4019, "avg_candidate_generations": 365.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 297477, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.01766608609107, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 678, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 4008, "search_candidate_moves_total": 296799, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 10186, "avg_legality_checks": 926.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10186, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 557800, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 50709.09090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1250345179, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2241.5653979921117, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2882, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 262.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15225751, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5283.050312283137, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33260, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2874, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15134511, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57980, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 26234606, "stage_ordering_ns": 142050, "stage_eval_ns": 1998946881, "stage_threat_ns": 1385363918, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 223501, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1212149942, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 154271, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11720, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111745, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 146732568, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 223490, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26327137, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 316, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3524, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5989.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6716.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1029, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11408, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 145, 129, 98, 125, 99, 100, 140, 127, 79, 157, 143, 109, 108, 141, 93, 173 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5524, "avg_search_time_ms": 552.4, "search_nodes": 141900, "safety_nodes": 555, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 142455, "avg_nodes": 14245.5, "eval_calls": 137719, "avg_eval_calls": 13771.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 137719, "pattern_eval_ns": 2803324, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.355390323775225, "pattern_frame_queries": 137719, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2803324, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.355390323775225, "pattern_frame_updates": 283744, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3355657434, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11826.355566989963, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4163, "avg_candidate_generations": 416.3, "candidate_moves_total": 294895, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.83713668027865, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 619, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 4153, "search_candidate_moves_total": 294276, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 135276, "avg_legality_checks": 13527.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 619, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 134657, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1047161, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 104716.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2442665852, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2332.655486596617, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18634, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1863.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 82412099, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4422.673553719008, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 77, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 258801, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18546, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 82134748, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 18550, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 315591, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8766.416666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 45, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 131770, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2928.222222222222, "stage_move_gen_ns": 330659460, "stage_ordering_ns": 133031, "stage_eval_ns": 3358460758, "stage_threat_ns": 1819747495, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 283754, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1592544441, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 390311, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9880, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 141872, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 192190709, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 283744, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34622034, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 294, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3563, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5446.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6246.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1823, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5876, "avg_search_time_ms": 652.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 45942, "safety_nodes": 593, "corridor_nodes": 254, "corridor_branch_probes": 330, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 82, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 246, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 246, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 58, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 82, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 58, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 427, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 127440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 46789, "avg_nodes": 5198.777777777777, "eval_calls": 30598, "avg_eval_calls": 3399.777777777778, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 30598, "pattern_eval_ns": 636714, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.80900712464867, "pattern_frame_queries": 30598, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 636714, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.80900712464867, "pattern_frame_updates": 91804, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 909936280, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9911.72802927977, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14593, "avg_candidate_generations": 1621.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 1097319, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.19488795998082, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 552, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 14584, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1096767, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 743318, "avg_legality_checks": 82590.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 743318, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1879263, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 208807.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3855348606, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2051.5215837272376, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20285, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2253.8888888888887, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31061434, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1531.2513680059158, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53831, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1538, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7630153, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18723, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23377450, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 82905, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9211.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 720648053, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8692.455859115855, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 111398, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12377.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 307100196, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2756.78374836173, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1763909608, "stage_ordering_ns": 455332514, "stage_eval_ns": 910572994, "stage_threat_ns": 2613364522, "stage_proof_ns": 97533746, "tactical_annotations": 241531, "root_tactical_annotations": 921, "search_tactical_annotations": 240610, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 92421, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 556461786, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 235140, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1966203103, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29566, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1049469459, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 46206, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68577207, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 608, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3356718, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 92412, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11587623, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62986, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 276470955, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 124745, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 626714978, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53800, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7178085, "child_limit_applications": 14584, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14584, "child_cap_hits": 14584, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14584, "child_moves_before_total": 1096759, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1096759, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 237792, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 237792, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.20289358200768, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.30499177180472, "tt_hits": 5255, "tt_cutoffs": 720, "beta_cutoffs": 12616, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4687.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5576.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1869, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1030, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9112, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 129, 81, 109, 125, 80, 127, 143, 126, 128, 140, 155, 98, 154, 84 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5426, "avg_search_time_ms": 602.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 59974, "safety_nodes": 410, "corridor_nodes": 1142, "corridor_branch_probes": 1423, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 384, "corridor_neutral_exits": 34, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1120, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1120, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 71, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 384, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 71, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 558, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24230080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 61526, "avg_nodes": 6836.222222222223, "eval_calls": 44079, "avg_eval_calls": 4897.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44079, "pattern_eval_ns": 909625, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.636244016425056, "pattern_frame_queries": 44079, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 909625, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.636244016425056, "pattern_frame_updates": 119874, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1258804853, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10501.066561556301, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15001, "avg_candidate_generations": 1666.7777777777778, "candidate_moves_total": 1020572, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.03359776014932, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 491, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 14992, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1020081, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 357106, "avg_legality_checks": 39678.444444444445, "illegal_moves_skipped": 450, "root_legality_checks": 491, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 356615, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 450, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1513347, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 168149.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3227654688, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2132.7922069426245, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8308, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 923.1111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 47786320, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5751.844005777564, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 456, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4515397, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3352, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30683137, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4351, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11391121, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 149, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1196665, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 33694, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3743.777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 305932634, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9079.736273520508, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 46146, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5127.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 138896773, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3009.941771767867, "stage_move_gen_ns": 863753636, "stage_ordering_ns": 427381492, "stage_eval_ns": 1259714478, "stage_threat_ns": 2584023844, "stage_proof_ns": 267124380, "tactical_annotations": 166750, "root_tactical_annotations": 1315, "search_tactical_annotations": 165435, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 122265, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 717896958, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 234702, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1747666864, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30816, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1162337052, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61128, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87417781, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2382, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12427312, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 122256, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14848307, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 40689, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 62944773, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 85100, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 339219732, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 40961, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3766622, "child_limit_applications": 14992, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14992, "child_cap_hits": 14992, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14992, "child_moves_before_total": 1019631, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1019631, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 239872, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 239872, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.01167289220918, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 6526, "tt_cutoffs": 866, "beta_cutoffs": 12104, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4368.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5257.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1258, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 3679, "avg_search_time_ms": 459.875, "search_nodes": 111012, "safety_nodes": 547, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 111559, "avg_nodes": 13944.875, "eval_calls": 108412, "avg_eval_calls": 13551.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 108412, "pattern_eval_ns": 2248298, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.738460687008818, "pattern_frame_queries": 108412, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2248298, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.738460687008818, "pattern_frame_updates": 221978, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2207928338, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9946.608844119688, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2585, "avg_candidate_generations": 323.125, "candidate_moves_total": 168809, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.30328820116054, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 434, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 2577, "search_candidate_moves_total": 168375, "search_candidate_moves_max": 88, "legality_checks": 4982, "avg_legality_checks": 622.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4982, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 583670, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 72958.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1328052908, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2275.348926619494, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6745, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 843.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51693023, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7663.902594514455, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6745, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 51693023, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13512110, "stage_ordering_ns": 82970, "stage_eval_ns": 2210176636, "stage_threat_ns": 1444882861, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 221986, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1269614427, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 204641, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 110989, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 147616759, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 221978, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27447034, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 108, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2316, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4561.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5561.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1031, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17040, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 95, 141, 96, 159, 175, 144, 142, 156, 93, 171, 126, 186, 201, 94, 100, 86, 80, 64, 110, 125, 68, 124, 116, 115, 84, 52, 132 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 11575, "avg_search_time_ms": 723.4375, "search_nodes": 296610, "safety_nodes": 565, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 297175, "avg_nodes": 18573.4375, "eval_calls": 287706, "avg_eval_calls": 17981.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 287706, "pattern_eval_ns": 5863371, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.37973139246314, "pattern_frame_queries": 287706, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5863371, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.37973139246314, "pattern_frame_updates": 593128, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7197459881, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12134.749802740724, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8874, "avg_candidate_generations": 554.625, "candidate_moves_total": 804776, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.68920441739914, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1267, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 8858, "search_candidate_moves_total": 803509, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 275753, "avg_legality_checks": 17234.5625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "root_legality_checks": 1267, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 274486, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2220325, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 138770.3125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5191300500, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2338.0813619627756, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28698, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1793.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 209874213, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7313.199979092619, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 111, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 851115, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28587, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 209023098, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.1875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 192281, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10120.052631578947, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 90980, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3499.230769230769, "stage_move_gen_ns": 658454736, "stage_ordering_ns": 325253, "stage_eval_ns": 7203323252, "stage_threat_ns": 3681457642, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 593144, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3212082748, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 274942, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16351, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 296564, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 399653983, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 593128, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69445969, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 827, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7756, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6234.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6734.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1796, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 5452, "avg_search_time_ms": 363.46666666666664, "search_nodes": 53369, "safety_nodes": 1750, "corridor_nodes": 275, "corridor_branch_probes": 358, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 90, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 263, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 263, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 62, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 90, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 62, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 62, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 338, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 348720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 20320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 55394, "avg_nodes": 3692.9333333333334, "eval_calls": 38187, "avg_eval_calls": 2545.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38187, "pattern_eval_ns": 800733, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.968732814832272, "pattern_frame_queries": 38187, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 800733, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.968732814832272, "pattern_frame_updates": 106598, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1007264048, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9449.183361789152, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14506, "avg_candidate_generations": 967.0666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1110333, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.54301668275197, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1186, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 14491, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1109147, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 534941, "avg_legality_checks": 35662.73333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 57, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 534941, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 57, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1523724, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 101581.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3327521125, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2183.808304522341, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4761, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 317.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16055476, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3372.290695232094, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 671712, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1292, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10024652, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3397, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5359112, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45688, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3045.866666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 440863225, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9649.431469970234, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63821, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4254.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 196457242, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3078.2538976199057, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1299124957, "stage_ordering_ns": 511522964, "stage_eval_ns": 1008064781, "stage_threat_ns": 2493274602, "stage_proof_ns": 104876685, "tactical_annotations": 192804, "root_tactical_annotations": 646, "search_tactical_annotations": 192158, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 107263, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 642903118, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 204512, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1749826243, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29442, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1136971323, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 53624, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 79613124, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 650, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3757643, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 107248, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13205584, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 45950, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 202246183, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 111087, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 397497443, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 35767, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3968890, "child_limit_applications": 14491, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14491, "child_cap_hits": 14491, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14491, "child_moves_before_total": 1109090, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1109090, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 232799, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 232799, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.53647091298048, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.06507487405976, "tt_hits": 4842, "tt_cutoffs": 621, "beta_cutoffs": 12002, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5913.933333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6447.266666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1859, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1032, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3766, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 95, 129, 97, 115, 116, 101, 157, 87 ], "move_count": 15, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 3154, "avg_search_time_ms": 525.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 42858, "safety_nodes": 295, "corridor_nodes": 57, "corridor_branch_probes": 67, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 49, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 49, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 48, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 409, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 25748160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 43210, "avg_nodes": 7201.666666666667, "eval_calls": 33192, "avg_eval_calls": 5532.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33192, "pattern_eval_ns": 677115, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.399945770065077, "pattern_frame_queries": 33192, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 677115, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.399945770065077, "pattern_frame_updates": 85672, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 753332262, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8793.214375758707, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9225, "avg_candidate_generations": 1537.5, "candidate_moves_total": 636470, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.9940379403794, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 325, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 9219, "search_candidate_moves_total": 636145, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 222773, "avg_legality_checks": 37128.833333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "root_legality_checks": 325, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 222448, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 799182, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 133197.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1778781915, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2225.7532264240185, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3049, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 508.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9955197, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3265.0695309937682, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 154320, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1152, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7083062, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1865, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2671865, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 45950, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2605.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 142059698, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9088.91222008957, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20542, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3423.6666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 61966626, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3016.5819297049948, "stage_move_gen_ns": 553070375, "stage_ordering_ns": 275552131, "stage_eval_ns": 754009377, "stage_threat_ns": 1463400537, "stage_proof_ns": 93286869, "tactical_annotations": 65638, "root_tactical_annotations": 733, "search_tactical_annotations": 64905, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 85880, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 486999228, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 75071, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 904021789, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18686, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 695137702, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42937, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 59616837, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 202, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 865843, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 85874, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10289353, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 10766, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 19016520, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 41267, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 180501367, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 13605, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1607487, "child_limit_applications": 9219, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9219, "child_cap_hits": 9219, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9219, "child_moves_before_total": 636133, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 636133, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 147504, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 147504, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.00238637596269, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 3564, "tt_cutoffs": 425, "beta_cutoffs": 7037, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2919.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4253.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1032, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 7, "search_move_count": 5, "total_time_ms": 605, "avg_search_time_ms": 121.0, "search_nodes": 20255, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 20455, "avg_nodes": 4091.0, "eval_calls": 19068, "avg_eval_calls": 3813.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 19068, "pattern_eval_ns": 389812, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.44325571638347, "pattern_frame_queries": 19068, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 389812, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.44325571638347, "pattern_frame_updates": 40482, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 320952018, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7928.26485845561, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1178, "avg_candidate_generations": 235.6, "candidate_moves_total": 74808, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.50424448217318, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 5, "root_candidate_moves_total": 266, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 1173, "search_candidate_moves_total": 74542, "search_candidate_moves_max": 83, "legality_checks": 3985, "avg_legality_checks": 797.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3985, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 78717, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15743.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 183406604, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2329.9491088329078, "renju_forbidden_checks": 195, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 39.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1840872, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9440.36923076923, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 195, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 1840872, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10712101, "stage_ordering_ns": 41220, "stage_eval_ns": 321341830, "stage_threat_ns": 266801454, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 40487, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 234423777, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 52610, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 10, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5210, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 20241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 26938631, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 40482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5386436, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 107, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1020, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3703.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5303.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1972, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1033, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30183, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 83, 95, 98, 139, 153, 140, 110, 94, 53, 93, 96, 92, 91, 68, 158, 174, 84, 70, 157, 172, 82, 81, 66, 114, 156, 155, 50, 34, 52, 170, 185, 171, 173, 123, 187, 107 ], "move_count": 44, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 24002, "avg_search_time_ms": 1200.1, "search_nodes": 629654, "safety_nodes": 799, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 630453, "avg_nodes": 31522.65, "eval_calls": 615297, "avg_eval_calls": 30764.85, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 615297, "pattern_eval_ns": 12452362, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.2379696309262, "pattern_frame_queries": 615297, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 12452362, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.2379696309262, "pattern_frame_updates": 1259190, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 14975030436, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11892.59002692207, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14318, "avg_candidate_generations": 715.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1352911, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.49022209805838, "candidate_moves_max": 140, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1709, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 14298, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1351202, "search_candidate_moves_max": 140, "legality_checks": 593005, "avg_legality_checks": 29650.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 273, "root_legality_checks": 1709, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 591296, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4809595, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 240479.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10860439130, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2258.077682216486, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60905, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3045.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 499372989, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8199.211706756423, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 399, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2903922, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 60506, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 496469067, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.95, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 188481, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9920.052631578947, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 88910, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3419.6153846153848, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1357660431, "stage_ordering_ns": 487982, "stage_eval_ns": 14987482798, "stage_threat_ns": 7594790635, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1259210, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6628563221, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 54, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 277111, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20140, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 629595, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 815348296, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1259190, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 150602007, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 954, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 12797, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5564.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5964.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 703, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 6161, "avg_search_time_ms": 308.05, "search_nodes": 64727, "safety_nodes": 2744, "corridor_nodes": 255, "corridor_branch_probes": 313, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 64, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 241, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 241, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 18, "corridor_proof_completed": 18, "corridor_proof_checks": 67, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 67, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 342, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 363760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 67726, "avg_nodes": 3386.3, "eval_calls": 46533, "avg_eval_calls": 2326.65, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46533, "pattern_eval_ns": 951233, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.442116347538306, "pattern_frame_queries": 46533, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 951233, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.442116347538306, "pattern_frame_updates": 129270, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1162861305, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8995.600719424461, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17361, "avg_candidate_generations": 868.05, "candidate_moves_total": 1393880, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.2880018432118, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1742, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 17341, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1392138, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 629235, "avg_legality_checks": 31461.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 629235, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1781220, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 89061.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3708168792, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2081.8140330784518, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8605, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 430.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21105651, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2452.7194654270775, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 406, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1383363, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2185, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10647180, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5966, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8885528, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 189580, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53161, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2658.05, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 481007009, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9048.11815052388, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72951, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3647.55, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 215462135, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2953.5185946731367, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1480898736, "stage_ordering_ns": 551846805, "stage_eval_ns": 1163812538, "stage_threat_ns": 2809200883, "stage_proof_ns": 111548275, "tactical_annotations": 273204, "root_tactical_annotations": 715, "search_tactical_annotations": 272489, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 129906, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 761029247, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 282638, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1931071413, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35192, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1227945343, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64943, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92558987, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 616, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3567375, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 129886, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16160689, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 75487, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 230693339, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 153621, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 459714644, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 44096, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4813172, "child_limit_applications": 17341, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17341, "child_cap_hits": 17341, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17341, "child_moves_before_total": 1392102, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1392102, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 285558, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 285558, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.27806931549507, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.46721642350499, "tt_hits": 5647, "tt_cutoffs": 761, "beta_cutoffs": 14395, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6420.15, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6820.15, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1637, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1034, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16780, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 97, 127, 126, 143, 159, 158, 113, 95, 79, 173, 188, 129, 98, 140, 101, 157, 115, 125, 70, 84, 100, 99, 85, 130, 55 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7998, "avg_search_time_ms": 615.2307692307693, "search_nodes": 87219, "safety_nodes": 1113, "corridor_nodes": 367, "corridor_branch_probes": 414, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 129, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 355, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 355, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 129, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 446, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 252400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 17520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 88699, "avg_nodes": 6823.0, "eval_calls": 62716, "avg_eval_calls": 4824.307692307692, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62716, "pattern_eval_ns": 1264530, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.162797372281396, "pattern_frame_queries": 62716, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1264530, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.162797372281396, "pattern_frame_updates": 174324, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1954243620, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11210.410614717423, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22882, "avg_candidate_generations": 1760.1538461538462, "candidate_moves_total": 1768062, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.26868280744691, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 916, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 22869, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1767146, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 745291, "avg_legality_checks": 57330.07692307692, "illegal_moves_skipped": 205, "root_legality_checks": 916, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 744375, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 205, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2351103, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 180854.07692307694, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4893996861, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2081.574844232686, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8880, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 683.0769230769231, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29674393, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3341.7109234234235, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 249, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2187162, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3489, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20395867, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5108, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7016014, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 75350, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52943, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4072.5384615384614, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 430599396, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8133.264000906635, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 73453, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5650.2307692307695, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 176628237, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2404.642928130914, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1702108345, "stage_ordering_ns": 682542234, "stage_eval_ns": 1955508150, "stage_threat_ns": 3452766682, "stage_proof_ns": 163155318, "tactical_annotations": 280708, "root_tactical_annotations": 1369, "search_tactical_annotations": 279339, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 175173, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 982387890, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 297873, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2316943678, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46246, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1613631177, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 87580, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 120833899, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 836, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5366009, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 175160, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20982441, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56453, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 50186270, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171439, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 604910681, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 52816, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6252765, "child_limit_applications": 22869, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22869, "child_cap_hits": 22869, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22869, "child_moves_before_total": 1766941, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1766941, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 365915, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 365915, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.26358826358826, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000481000481, "tt_hits": 7754, "tt_cutoffs": 1578, "beta_cutoffs": 18769, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5188.076923076923, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5803.461538461538, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8769, "avg_search_time_ms": 730.75, "search_nodes": 299728, "safety_nodes": 517, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 300245, "avg_nodes": 25020.416666666668, "eval_calls": 293252, "avg_eval_calls": 24437.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 293252, "pattern_eval_ns": 5805349, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.79645151610219, "pattern_frame_queries": 293252, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5805349, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.79645151610219, "pattern_frame_updates": 599386, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5345585934, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8918.43642327315, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6453, "avg_candidate_generations": 537.75, "candidate_moves_total": 525978, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.50906555090656, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 865, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 6441, "search_candidate_moves_total": 525113, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 11416, "avg_legality_checks": 951.3333333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11416, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1625342, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 135445.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3353748423, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2063.410914749019, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8122, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 676.8333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57681798, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7101.920462940163, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8122, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57681798, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 29094914, "stage_ordering_ns": 216890, "stage_eval_ns": 5351391283, "stage_threat_ns": 3357714783, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 599398, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2929680719, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 92050, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12060, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 299693, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 353698751, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 599386, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74243263, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 443, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5710, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5828.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6494.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1968, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1035, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13716, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 80, 129, 81, 145, 161, 128, 125, 95, 79, 127, 130, 78, 96, 83, 64, 48, 109, 108, 94, 49, 124 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6106, "avg_search_time_ms": 508.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 153421, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 154394, "avg_nodes": 12866.166666666666, "eval_calls": 148379, "avg_eval_calls": 12364.916666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 148379, "pattern_eval_ns": 3001136, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.226150600826262, "pattern_frame_queries": 148379, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3001136, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.226150600826262, "pattern_frame_updates": 306774, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3801419516, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12391.596145696833, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5020, "avg_candidate_generations": 418.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 388017, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.29422310756972, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 838, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 5008, "search_candidate_moves_total": 387179, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 143985, "avg_legality_checks": 11998.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 181, "root_legality_checks": 838, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 143147, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 181, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1202462, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 100205.16666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2793821597, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2323.4177853437363, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16617, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1384.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 120628365, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7259.334717458025, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 183, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1813280, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16429, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 118807265, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7820, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.9166666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 435203, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9259.63829787234, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.416666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 201242, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3096.0307692307692, "stage_move_gen_ns": 347494886, "stage_ordering_ns": 181270, "stage_eval_ns": 3804420652, "stage_threat_ns": 1927131979, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 306786, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1686486353, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 568213, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11930, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 153387, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 203457340, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 306774, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36620073, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 267, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4487, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5843.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6510.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1797, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7597, "avg_search_time_ms": 690.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 53507, "safety_nodes": 765, "corridor_nodes": 1362, "corridor_branch_probes": 1581, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 599, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1343, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1343, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 76, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 599, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 76, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 75, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 569, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 468240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 55634, "avg_nodes": 5057.636363636364, "eval_calls": 35176, "avg_eval_calls": 3197.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35176, "pattern_eval_ns": 748421, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.27646690925631, "pattern_frame_queries": 35176, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 748421, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.27646690925631, "pattern_frame_updates": 106914, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1245862213, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11652.9379968947, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17121, "avg_candidate_generations": 1556.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 1392652, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.34174405700601, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 770, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 17110, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1391882, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 1010821, "avg_legality_checks": 91892.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1901, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1010821, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1901, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2420983, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 220089.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5030773329, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2077.9878788905166, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17133, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1557.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 84243405, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4917.025914901068, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1937, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20186022, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4499, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44073560, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10697, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19983823, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97372, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8852.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 898255015, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9224.982695230661, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 130179, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11834.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 406756492, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3124.5937670438398, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2402988575, "stage_ordering_ns": 553732356, "stage_eval_ns": 1246610634, "stage_threat_ns": 3220287670, "stage_proof_ns": 118815073, "tactical_annotations": 307661, "root_tactical_annotations": 1346, "search_tactical_annotations": 306315, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 109763, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 672049894, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 348915, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2426489695, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35129, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1238703088, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 54876, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81806344, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2838, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16382645, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 109752, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13680864, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 83056, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 399475137, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 153145, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 726636671, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 71460, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9878228, "child_limit_applications": 17110, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17110, "child_cap_hits": 17110, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17110, "child_moves_before_total": 1389981, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1389981, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 273940, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 273940, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.23793103448276, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01052016364699, "tt_hits": 7184, "tt_cutoffs": 1171, "beta_cutoffs": 14830, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4864.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5591.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1883, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1036, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11433, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 129, 98, 96, 128, 143, 124, 127, 95, 157, 171, 141, 172, 109, 108, 125, 173, 93 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9276, "avg_search_time_ms": 927.6, "search_nodes": 102432, "safety_nodes": 167, "corridor_nodes": 2524, "corridor_branch_probes": 2628, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 963, "corridor_neutral_exits": 33, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 2501, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2501, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 101, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 78, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 33, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 963, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 101, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 100, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 827, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26102800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 105123, "avg_nodes": 10512.3, "eval_calls": 77473, "avg_eval_calls": 7747.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77473, "pattern_eval_ns": 1592843, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.55997573348134, "pattern_frame_queries": 77473, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1592843, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.55997573348134, "pattern_frame_updates": 204780, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2126448936, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10384.065514210371, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23914, "avg_candidate_generations": 2391.4, "candidate_moves_total": 1731892, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.42167767834741, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 576, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 23904, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1731316, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 638994, "avg_legality_checks": 63899.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 114, "root_legality_checks": 576, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 638418, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 114, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2573407, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 257340.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5535338671, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2150.9767677635136, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12150, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1215.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43411987, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3573.0030452674896, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 182, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1116525, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4757, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28451823, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7036, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12261545, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 175, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1582094, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 63351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6335.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 525732598, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8298.726113242095, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 80691, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8069.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 214466198, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2657.870121822756, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1558632473, "stage_ordering_ns": 719787734, "stage_eval_ns": 2128041779, "stage_threat_ns": 4360697731, "stage_proof_ns": 470507990, "tactical_annotations": 294311, "root_tactical_annotations": 2017, "search_tactical_annotations": 292294, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 209994, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1231881563, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 438199, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2916789707, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49680, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1853475903, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 104992, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 150545755, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5204, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28203929, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 209984, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25847443, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 84645, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 118249608, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 144475, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 576011924, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 65191, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7429334, "child_limit_applications": 23904, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23904, "child_cap_hits": 23904, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23904, "child_moves_before_total": 1731202, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1731202, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 382492, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 382492, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.42310910307899, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001171352074966, "tt_hits": 9671, "tt_cutoffs": 1013, "beta_cutoffs": 18850, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3666.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4466.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1050, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2150, "avg_search_time_ms": 238.88888888888889, "search_nodes": 68066, "safety_nodes": 449, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68515, "avg_nodes": 7612.777777777777, "eval_calls": 64381, "avg_eval_calls": 7153.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64381, "pattern_eval_ns": 1323068, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.550597225889625, "pattern_frame_queries": 64381, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1323068, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.550597225889625, "pattern_frame_updates": 136080, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1243532612, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9138.24670781893, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3668, "avg_candidate_generations": 407.55555555555554, "candidate_moves_total": 255356, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.61723009814612, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 516, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 3659, "search_candidate_moves_total": 254840, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 7053, "avg_legality_checks": 783.6666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7053, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 337183, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 37464.77777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 769796711, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2283.0234946601695, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1030, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 114.44444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6908341, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6707.12718446602, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1030, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6908341, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19102467, "stage_ordering_ns": 121865, "stage_eval_ns": 1244855680, "stage_threat_ns": 871147141, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136089, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 763302847, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 149531, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91149717, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136080, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16545046, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 231, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3226, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5517.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6406.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1037, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5538, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 84, 85, 99, 126, 69, 114, 83, 111, 67, 52, 51, 35, 115 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1441, "avg_search_time_ms": 180.125, "search_nodes": 37214, "safety_nodes": 411, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 37625, "avg_nodes": 4703.125, "eval_calls": 35213, "avg_eval_calls": 4401.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35213, "pattern_eval_ns": 714280, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.284553999943203, "pattern_frame_queries": 35213, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 714280, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.284553999943203, "pattern_frame_updates": 74384, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 876108105, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11778.179514411702, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1987, "avg_candidate_generations": 248.375, "candidate_moves_total": 125917, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.3704076497232, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 444, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 1979, "search_candidate_moves_total": 125473, "search_candidate_moves_max": 85, "legality_checks": 32316, "avg_legality_checks": 4039.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 444, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 31872, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 285521, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 35690.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 647268620, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2266.973777760655, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5567, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 695.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31998700, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5747.9252739356925, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 114741, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5553, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31881389, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2570, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 197431, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7312.259259259259, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 34, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 64830, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1906.764705882353, "stage_move_gen_ns": 76483323, "stage_ordering_ns": 72201, "stage_eval_ns": 876822385, "stage_threat_ns": 474132550, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 74392, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 415694386, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 298901, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7740, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37192, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 49372997, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 74384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8766266, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 224, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1677, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5279.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6279.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1864, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 4089, "avg_search_time_ms": 584.1428571428571, "search_nodes": 34352, "safety_nodes": 430, "corridor_nodes": 122, "corridor_branch_probes": 159, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 43, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 118, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 118, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 43, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 281, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 268560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34904, "avg_nodes": 4986.285714285715, "eval_calls": 23139, "avg_eval_calls": 3305.5714285714284, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23139, "pattern_eval_ns": 487031, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.04805739228143, "pattern_frame_queries": 23139, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 487031, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.04805739228143, "pattern_frame_updates": 68644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 775416046, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11296.195530563487, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10574, "avg_candidate_generations": 1510.5714285714287, "candidate_moves_total": 729093, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.9514847739739, "candidate_moves_max": 92, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 383, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 10567, "search_candidate_moves_total": 728710, "search_candidate_moves_max": 92, "legality_checks": 467793, "avg_legality_checks": 66827.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 758, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 467793, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 758, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1277839, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 182548.42857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2657334745, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2079.553640951638, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7145, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1020.7142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 41727327, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5840.073757872638, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 768, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7863724, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2836, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25786634, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3541, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8076969, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48681, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6954.428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 451123215, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9266.925802674556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65044, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9292.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 206410361, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3173.39587048767, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1128707546, "stage_ordering_ns": 300997200, "stage_eval_ns": 775903077, "stage_threat_ns": 1793200756, "stage_proof_ns": 64924067, "tactical_annotations": 162312, "root_tactical_annotations": 556, "search_tactical_annotations": 161756, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 68963, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 402118341, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 156912, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1326337808, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21378, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 735548178, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34478, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 49876593, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 312, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1556057, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 68956, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8445076, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 35218, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 161709593, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 92095, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 422362783, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 34999, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4866881, "child_limit_applications": 10567, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10567, "child_cap_hits": 10567, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10567, "child_moves_before_total": 727952, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 727952, "child_moves_before_max": 92, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 92, "child_moves_after_total": 169073, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 169073, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.8891833065203, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000094634238668, "tt_hits": 3534, "tt_cutoffs": 616, "beta_cutoffs": 9070, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 4.285714285714286, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 4.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3566.714285714286, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4709.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1869, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1038, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16233, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 84, 141, 83, 81, 126, 98, 85, 86, 97, 127, 155, 143, 111, 128, 158, 125, 142, 110, 69, 55, 99, 54, 67, 52, 51, 115, 35 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 14990, "avg_search_time_ms": 1070.7142857142858, "search_nodes": 214586, "safety_nodes": 434, "corridor_nodes": 5053, "corridor_branch_probes": 5710, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2263, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 5011, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5011, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 138, "corridor_proof_active": 42, "corridor_proof_quiet": 96, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2263, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 138, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 136, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1111, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 69427040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1983600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 220073, "avg_nodes": 15719.5, "eval_calls": 173025, "avg_eval_calls": 12358.92857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 173025, "pattern_eval_ns": 3366920, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.45915330154602, "pattern_frame_queries": 173025, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3366920, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.45915330154602, "pattern_frame_updates": 429048, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4483097299, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10448.941141783669, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39594, "avg_candidate_generations": 2828.1428571428573, "candidate_moves_total": 3106018, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.44668384098601, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 941, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 39580, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3105077, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1215902, "avg_legality_checks": 86850.14285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1030, "root_legality_checks": 941, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1214961, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1030, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5347809, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 381986.35714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8747581744, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1635.7318939401164, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58741, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4195.785714285715, "renju_forbidden_ns": 209234762, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3561.9884237585334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1919, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9015094, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 32818, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 155467652, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23498, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42745428, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 506, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2006588, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 149778, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10698.42857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 981577986, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6553.552497696591, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 192384, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13741.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 438650422, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2280.0774596640053, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2304476638, "stage_ordering_ns": 990685233, "stage_eval_ns": 4486464219, "stage_threat_ns": 6559437159, "stage_proof_ns": 573990013, "tactical_annotations": 718050, "root_tactical_annotations": 3261, "search_tactical_annotations": 714789, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 439360, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2028683254, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 915708, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4158075126, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 81855, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2344428656, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 219673, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 261866998, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10298, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 47062248, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 439346, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44335132, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 217700, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 202226850, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 336082, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1076259308, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 164268, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19414401, "child_limit_applications": 39580, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39580, "child_cap_hits": 39580, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39580, "child_moves_before_total": 3104047, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3104047, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 635598, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 635598, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.42463365336029, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.058564931783728, "tt_hits": 16033, "tt_cutoffs": 1919, "beta_cutoffs": 28407, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4490.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5062.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 401, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 1229, "avg_search_time_ms": 94.53846153846153, "search_nodes": 45514, "safety_nodes": 1210, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 46724, "avg_nodes": 3594.153846153846, "eval_calls": 43205, "avg_eval_calls": 3323.4615384615386, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 43205, "pattern_eval_ns": 865266, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.026987617173937, "pattern_frame_queries": 43205, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 865266, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.026987617173937, "pattern_frame_updates": 90952, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 688837720, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7573.64016184361, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2284, "avg_candidate_generations": 175.69230769230768, "candidate_moves_total": 168036, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.57092819614711, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 877, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 2271, "search_candidate_moves_total": 167159, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 4918, "avg_legality_checks": 378.3076923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4918, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 213732, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16440.923076923078, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 416221518, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1947.3991634383246, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1398, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 107.53846153846153, "renju_forbidden_ns": 11240142, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8040.158798283262, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1398, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11240142, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11472046, "stage_ordering_ns": 73620, "stage_eval_ns": 689702986, "stage_threat_ns": 512685251, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 90965, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 448927467, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 236240, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10470, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 45476, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 53838138, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 90952, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9683406, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 136, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2023, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6305.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6920.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1554, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1039, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5310, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 126, 141, 99, 143, 98, 155, 169, 140, 142, 158, 100, 173, 128, 156, 101, 97, 102 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2351, "avg_search_time_ms": 235.1, "search_nodes": 99765, "safety_nodes": 586, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 100351, "avg_nodes": 10035.1, "eval_calls": 96165, "avg_eval_calls": 9616.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 96165, "pattern_eval_ns": 1751369, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.212124993500755, "pattern_frame_queries": 96165, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1751369, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.212124993500755, "pattern_frame_updates": 199474, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1421360665, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7125.543504416616, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3582, "avg_candidate_generations": 358.2, "candidate_moves_total": 239291, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.8037409268565, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 614, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 3572, "search_candidate_moves_total": 238677, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 91424, "avg_legality_checks": 9142.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 614, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 90810, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 689522, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 68952.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 945883821, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1371.7964343414712, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7553, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 755.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 35613792, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4715.184959618695, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 224730, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7511, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35389062, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 30, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 160321, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5344.033333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 58880, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1549.4736842105262, "stage_move_gen_ns": 134855905, "stage_ordering_ns": 106230, "stage_eval_ns": 1423112034, "stage_threat_ns": 763936359, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 199484, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 660838842, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 220601, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6030, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 99737, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87245515, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 199474, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15631401, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 237, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3174, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5614.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6414.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1882, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2951, "avg_search_time_ms": 327.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 49928, "safety_nodes": 819, "corridor_nodes": 309, "corridor_branch_probes": 404, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 91, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 297, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 297, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 91, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 49, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 312, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2335600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 51056, "avg_nodes": 5672.888888888889, "eval_calls": 35976, "avg_eval_calls": 3997.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35976, "pattern_eval_ns": 658562, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.305592617300423, "pattern_frame_queries": 35976, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 658562, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.305592617300423, "pattern_frame_updates": 99772, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 520204673, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5213.9345006615085, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13360, "avg_candidate_generations": 1484.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 975558, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.02080838323353, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 555, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 13351, "search_candidate_moves_total": 975003, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 560366, "avg_legality_checks": 62262.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 62, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 560366, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 62, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1460585, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 162287.22222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1772743011, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1213.7212219761261, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4086, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 454.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8546455, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2091.6434165442975, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 62, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 316702, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 888, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 5922220, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3136, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2307533, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45677, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5075.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 255825193, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5600.744203866278, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63912, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7101.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 122174079, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1911.5984322193015, "stage_move_gen_ns": 775706655, "stage_ordering_ns": 240384305, "stage_eval_ns": 520863235, "stage_threat_ns": 1332826828, "stage_proof_ns": 50812853, "tactical_annotations": 154919, "root_tactical_annotations": 609, "search_tactical_annotations": 154310, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 100475, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 349480724, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 166171, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 921545388, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27098, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 582018057, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50233, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 47363739, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 694, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2763555, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 100466, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7996389, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32808, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 116674539, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 85083, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 213255760, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 37028, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3677033, "child_limit_applications": 13351, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13351, "child_cap_hits": 13351, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13351, "child_moves_before_total": 974941, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 974941, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 213629, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 213629, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.02381844056625, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00097370983447, "tt_hits": 4870, "tt_cutoffs": 559, "beta_cutoffs": 10998, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5090.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5979.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1909, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1040, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 2475, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 141, 99, 125, 97, 109, 108, 93, 157, 77 ], "move_count": 15, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 1938, "avg_search_time_ms": 323.0, "search_nodes": 43786, "safety_nodes": 295, "corridor_nodes": 57, "corridor_branch_probes": 67, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 49, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 49, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 48, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 409, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 25749520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 44138, "avg_nodes": 7356.333333333333, "eval_calls": 33906, "avg_eval_calls": 5651.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33906, "pattern_eval_ns": 619204, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.26237244145579, "pattern_frame_queries": 33906, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 619204, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.26237244145579, "pattern_frame_updates": 87528, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 484695002, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5537.599419614295, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9436, "avg_candidate_generations": 1572.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 651064, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.99788045782111, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 325, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 9430, "search_candidate_moves_total": 650739, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 240577, "avg_legality_checks": 40096.166666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 325, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 240252, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 833383, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 138897.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1064581474, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1277.4216344705856, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3381, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 563.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6387429, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1889.2129547471163, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 70430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1246, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 4760081, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2105, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1532798, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 24120, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16079, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2679.8333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 85414433, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5312.173207289011, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21162, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3527.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 38033652, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1797.2616954919195, "stage_move_gen_ns": 346155346, "stage_ordering_ns": 161960183, "stage_eval_ns": 485314206, "stage_threat_ns": 874931948, "stage_proof_ns": 50689563, "tactical_annotations": 67199, "root_tactical_annotations": 733, "search_tactical_annotations": 66466, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 87736, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 291406540, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 76884, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 534873049, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19108, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 407988247, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43865, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 39865664, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 202, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 505875, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 87730, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6748314, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 11057, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 10587662, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 42367, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 111030298, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 13775, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1532506, "child_limit_applications": 9430, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9430, "child_cap_hits": 9430, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9430, "child_moves_before_total": 650729, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 650729, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 150880, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 150880, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.00625662778367, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 3621, "tt_cutoffs": 428, "beta_cutoffs": 7204, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3720.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5053.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1450, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 7, "search_move_count": 5, "total_time_ms": 533, "avg_search_time_ms": 106.6, "search_nodes": 31696, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 31896, "avg_nodes": 6379.2, "eval_calls": 30280, "avg_eval_calls": 6056.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 30280, "pattern_eval_ns": 549636, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.151783355350066, "pattern_frame_queries": 30280, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 549636, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.151783355350066, "pattern_frame_updates": 63364, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 279334324, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 4408.4073606464235, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1407, "avg_candidate_generations": 281.4, "candidate_moves_total": 88619, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.98436389481166, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 5, "root_candidate_moves_total": 266, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 1402, "search_candidate_moves_total": 88353, "search_candidate_moves_max": 83, "legality_checks": 4089, "avg_legality_checks": 817.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4089, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 107323, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21464.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 138228894, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1287.9708357015738, "renju_forbidden_checks": 432, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 86.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1400287, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3241.4050925925926, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 432, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 1400287, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6463988, "stage_ordering_ns": 40870, "stage_eval_ns": 279883960, "stage_threat_ns": 238502257, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 63369, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 206793189, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 13, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 30750, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 10, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2780, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 31682, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 26866217, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 63364, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4812101, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 107, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1221, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3729.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5329.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1041, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13356, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 84, 125, 83, 139, 153, 126, 129, 99, 85, 127, 124, 86, 98, 81, 70, 56, 115, 116, 100, 55, 130 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6372, "avg_search_time_ms": 531.0, "search_nodes": 170390, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 171363, "avg_nodes": 14280.25, "eval_calls": 164958, "avg_eval_calls": 13746.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 164958, "pattern_eval_ns": 3318110, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.11487772645158, "pattern_frame_queries": 164958, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3318110, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.11487772645158, "pattern_frame_updates": 340712, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3971647278, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11656.904593909225, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5410, "avg_candidate_generations": 450.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 418931, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.43641404805915, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 838, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 5398, "search_candidate_moves_total": 418093, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 160821, "avg_legality_checks": 13401.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 162, "root_legality_checks": 838, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 159983, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 162, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1318273, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 109856.08333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2901250579, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2200.796480698611, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19020, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1585.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 118011012, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6204.57476340694, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 212, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1411135, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18803, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 116592537, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7340, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.9166666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 390933, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8317.72340425532, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.416666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 179082, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2755.107692307692, "stage_move_gen_ns": 366531291, "stage_ordering_ns": 178790, "stage_eval_ns": 3974965388, "stage_threat_ns": 2001640795, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 340724, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1747662778, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 514713, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10590, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 170356, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 214820829, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 340712, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38642475, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 267, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4875, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5888.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6554.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1879, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6971, "avg_search_time_ms": 633.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 56638, "safety_nodes": 765, "corridor_nodes": 1226, "corridor_branch_probes": 1428, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 540, "corridor_neutral_exits": 17, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1208, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1208, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 76, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 58, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 540, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 76, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 75, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 569, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 459680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 58629, "avg_nodes": 5329.909090909091, "eval_calls": 36766, "avg_eval_calls": 3342.3636363636365, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36766, "pattern_eval_ns": 744104, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.238916390143068, "pattern_frame_queries": 36766, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 744104, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.238916390143068, "pattern_frame_updates": 113176, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1116392762, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9864.218226479112, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18602, "avg_candidate_generations": 1691.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 1496184, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.43135146758414, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 770, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 18591, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1495414, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1106629, "avg_legality_checks": 100602.63636363637, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4776, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1106629, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4776, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2659031, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 241730.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4560199413, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1714.9854262699457, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25083, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2280.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 110070018, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4388.231790455687, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4812, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34508472, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7240, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 52060941, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13031, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23500605, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 112323, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10211.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 858714754, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7645.048244794031, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 147648, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13422.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 386239041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2615.9449569245776, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2187829332, "stage_ordering_ns": 506670347, "stage_eval_ns": 1117136866, "stage_threat_ns": 3009380163, "stage_proof_ns": 98486824, "tactical_annotations": 335339, "root_tactical_annotations": 1346, "search_tactical_annotations": 333993, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 115755, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 603782122, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 373203, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2295199012, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38037, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1159058510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57872, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74973534, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2568, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13413830, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 115744, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12727676, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 90292, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 351266070, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 174955, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 735979847, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 70092, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9283989, "child_limit_applications": 18591, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18591, "child_cap_hits": 18591, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18591, "child_moves_before_total": 1490638, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1490638, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 297624, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 297624, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.18062503361841, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.009036630627723, "tt_hits": 7255, "tt_cutoffs": 1231, "beta_cutoffs": 16197, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5059.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5786.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1930, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1042, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7603, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 125, 96, 98, 126, 141, 130, 127, 99, 157, 173, 143, 172, 115, 116, 129, 171, 101 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6379, "avg_search_time_ms": 637.9, "search_nodes": 103055, "safety_nodes": 167, "corridor_nodes": 2666, "corridor_branch_probes": 2800, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1025, "corridor_neutral_exits": 34, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 2641, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2641, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 101, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 76, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1025, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 101, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 100, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 827, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26166960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 105888, "avg_nodes": 10588.8, "eval_calls": 77739, "avg_eval_calls": 7773.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77739, "pattern_eval_ns": 1467136, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.87258647525695, "pattern_frame_queries": 77739, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1467136, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.87258647525695, "pattern_frame_updates": 206026, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1476155416, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7164.898682690534, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24222, "avg_candidate_generations": 2422.2, "candidate_moves_total": 1756349, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.51048633473701, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 576, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 24212, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1755773, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 654816, "avg_legality_checks": 65481.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "root_legality_checks": 576, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 654240, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2601229, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 260122.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3681908708, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1415.4496616791525, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11912, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1191.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 28528572, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2394.943922095366, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 168, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 618940, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4428, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18642835, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7132, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8327881, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 184, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 938916, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 63306, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6330.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 327235048, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5169.10005370739, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 79838, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7983.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 133966668, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1677.9812620556627, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1021216731, "stage_ordering_ns": 503668034, "stage_eval_ns": 1477622552, "stage_threat_ns": 3012829987, "stage_proof_ns": 319543607, "tactical_annotations": 295891, "root_tactical_annotations": 2017, "search_tactical_annotations": 293874, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 211520, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 855792067, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 448126, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1999444139, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50362, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1297315810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 105755, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 111828777, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5484, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20082761, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 211510, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18953209, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 85113, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 81022217, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 145417, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 364011976, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 65361, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6729034, "child_limit_applications": 24212, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24212, "child_cap_hits": 24212, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24212, "child_moves_before_total": 1755677, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1755677, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 387406, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 387406, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.51267966297704, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00057822567322, "tt_hits": 9711, "tt_cutoffs": 1062, "beta_cutoffs": 19141, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4743.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5543.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1059, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1216, "avg_search_time_ms": 135.11111111111111, "search_nodes": 64160, "safety_nodes": 449, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 64609, "avg_nodes": 7178.777777777777, "eval_calls": 60441, "avg_eval_calls": 6715.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60441, "pattern_eval_ns": 1107825, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.329031617610564, "pattern_frame_queries": 60441, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1107825, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.329031617610564, "pattern_frame_updates": 128268, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 690547756, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5383.632363488945, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3702, "avg_candidate_generations": 411.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 255465, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.00729335494327, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 516, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 3693, "search_candidate_moves_total": 254949, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 6891, "avg_legality_checks": 765.6666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6891, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 296372, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32930.22222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 397483592, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1341.1644554816244, "renju_forbidden_checks": 589, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 65.44444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2946231, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5002.0899830220715, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 589, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 2946231, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11427883, "stage_ordering_ns": 107811, "stage_eval_ns": 691655581, "stage_threat_ns": 494218745, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 128277, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 427668679, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 125061, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64134, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 56330041, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128268, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10094964, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 231, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3276, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5617.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6506.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1043, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18777, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 81, 129, 96, 130, 131, 111, 95, 157, 172, 98, 67, 109, 65, 49, 66, 64, 51, 36, 93, 94, 79, 107, 37 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 4481, "avg_search_time_ms": 344.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 134343, "safety_nodes": 1278, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 135621, "avg_nodes": 10432.384615384615, "eval_calls": 130826, "avg_eval_calls": 10063.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 130826, "pattern_eval_ns": 2616982, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.00353140812988, "pattern_frame_queries": 130826, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2616982, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.00353140812988, "pattern_frame_updates": 268610, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2651961633, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9872.907311715871, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3492, "avg_candidate_generations": 268.61538461538464, "candidate_moves_total": 231710, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.35452462772051, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 920, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 3479, "search_candidate_moves_total": 230790, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 129497, "avg_legality_checks": 9961.307692307691, "illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "root_legality_checks": 920, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 128577, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 28, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 839220, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 64555.38461538462, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1736209699, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2068.837371606968, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11605, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 892.6923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 114527301, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9868.789401120206, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 342101, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11541, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 113848289, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 336911, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 56, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.3076923076923075, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 578404, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10328.642857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 73, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.615384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 282751, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3873.301369863014, "stage_move_gen_ns": 275578054, "stage_ordering_ns": 105980, "stage_eval_ns": 2654578615, "stage_threat_ns": 1511976816, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 268623, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1320155271, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 806454, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12620, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134305, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 161531285, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 268610, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29483806, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 116, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3220, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5674.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6289.538461538462, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1401, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 14282, "avg_search_time_ms": 1098.6153846153845, "search_nodes": 108755, "safety_nodes": 401, "corridor_nodes": 2675, "corridor_branch_probes": 2930, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1058, "corridor_neutral_exits": 45, "corridor_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_plies_followed": 2648, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2648, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 88, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 61, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 45, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1058, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 88, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 85, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 690, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24231680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1984240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 111831, "avg_nodes": 8602.384615384615, "eval_calls": 75402, "avg_eval_calls": 5800.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75402, "pattern_eval_ns": 1578740, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.93764091138166, "pattern_frame_queries": 75402, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1578740, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.93764091138166, "pattern_frame_updates": 217396, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2192574623, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10085.625416291008, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31600, "avg_candidate_generations": 2430.769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 2743597, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.82268987341772, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 949, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 31587, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2742648, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 2045482, "avg_legality_checks": 157344.76923076922, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16362, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2045482, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16362, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4621551, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 355503.92307692306, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9086507657, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1966.116495739201, "renju_forbidden_checks": 67036, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5156.615384615385, "renju_forbidden_ns": 486978454, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7264.431857509398, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16364, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 167969765, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22139, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 227236284, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28412, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 90530489, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 121, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1241916, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 199501, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15346.23076923077, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1866329071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9354.986045182732, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 249270, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19174.615384615383, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 897486878, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3600.4608577044974, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4773576513, "stage_ordering_ns": 1045707903, "stage_eval_ns": 2194153363, "stage_threat_ns": 6062801710, "stage_proof_ns": 129492164, "tactical_annotations": 696820, "root_tactical_annotations": 2952, "search_tactical_annotations": 693868, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 222881, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1290371259, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 758863, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4531245515, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64968, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2159753973, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111434, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 160640258, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5472, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 31954481, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 222868, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26846324, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 268059, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1127327730, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 264267, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1138821691, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 164494, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21743873, "child_limit_applications": 31587, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31587, "child_cap_hits": 31587, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31587, "child_moves_before_total": 2726286, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2726286, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 509304, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 509304, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.31038085288252, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.123848418653242, "tt_hits": 14521, "tt_cutoffs": 1709, "beta_cutoffs": 26749, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5721.076923076923, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6336.461538461538, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1796, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1044, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16150, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 97, 127, 128, 141, 155, 156, 111, 99, 85, 171, 186, 125, 96, 144, 95, 93, 109, 114, 64, 80, 94, 98, 79, 124, 49 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8506, "avg_search_time_ms": 654.3076923076923, "search_nodes": 92260, "safety_nodes": 1116, "corridor_nodes": 375, "corridor_branch_probes": 421, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 135, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 363, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 363, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 135, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 446, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 256720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 93751, "avg_nodes": 7211.615384615385, "eval_calls": 66004, "avg_eval_calls": 5077.2307692307695, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 66004, "pattern_eval_ns": 1370087, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.757635900854492, "pattern_frame_queries": 66004, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1370087, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.757635900854492, "pattern_frame_updates": 184406, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2059151739, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11166.403148487576, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24579, "avg_candidate_generations": 1890.6923076923076, "candidate_moves_total": 1942840, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.04471296635339, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 911, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 24566, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1941929, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 803757, "avg_legality_checks": 61827.46153846154, "illegal_moves_skipped": 285, "root_legality_checks": 911, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 802846, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 285, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2549458, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 196112.15384615384, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5209836730, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2043.507572982179, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9388, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 722.1538461538462, "renju_forbidden_ns": 34459802, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3670.6222837665105, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 308, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2424571, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3656, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24027358, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5386, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7951163, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 56710, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59895, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4607.307692307692, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 503110421, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8399.873461891644, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 83716, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6439.692307692308, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 214694341, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2564.555652443977, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1814910419, "stage_ordering_ns": 738319483, "stage_eval_ns": 2060521826, "stage_threat_ns": 3687683086, "stage_proof_ns": 157813551, "tactical_annotations": 283881, "root_tactical_annotations": 1334, "search_tactical_annotations": 282547, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 185271, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1025247744, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 309184, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2503380563, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49646, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1721545703, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92629, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125928293, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 852, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5541952, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 185258, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21843534, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56405, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 63418728, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 179188, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 666554274, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 48288, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5741000, "child_limit_applications": 24566, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24566, "child_cap_hits": 24566, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24566, "child_moves_before_total": 1941644, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1941644, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 393070, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 393070, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.03785720100953, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00056989334853, "tt_hits": 8230, "tt_cutoffs": 1633, "beta_cutoffs": 20276, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5128.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5743.615384615385, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7634, "avg_search_time_ms": 636.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 225759, "safety_nodes": 667, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 226426, "avg_nodes": 18868.833333333332, "eval_calls": 220639, "avg_eval_calls": 18386.583333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 220639, "pattern_eval_ns": 4632607, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.996319780274565, "pattern_frame_queries": 220639, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4632607, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.996319780274565, "pattern_frame_updates": 451448, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4673392107, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10352.005340592936, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5097, "avg_candidate_generations": 424.75, "candidate_moves_total": 401032, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.68000784775359, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 851, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 5085, "search_candidate_moves_total": 400181, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 8905, "avg_legality_checks": 742.0833333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8905, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1231046, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 102587.16666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2947379472, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2394.207423605617, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6495, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 541.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62409644, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9608.875134719015, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6495, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62409644, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 24973609, "stage_ordering_ns": 179241, "stage_eval_ns": 4678024714, "stage_threat_ns": 2911366302, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 451460, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2547950175, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 158970, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 225724, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 307800316, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 451448, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55456841, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 351, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4515, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5784.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6450.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1965, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1045, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4585, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 80, 79, 95, 128, 65, 110, 81, 113, 67, 52, 53, 39, 109 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1465, "avg_search_time_ms": 183.125, "search_nodes": 38987, "safety_nodes": 411, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 39398, "avg_nodes": 4924.75, "eval_calls": 36951, "avg_eval_calls": 4618.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36951, "pattern_eval_ns": 784874, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.240940705258314, "pattern_frame_queries": 36951, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 784874, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.240940705258314, "pattern_frame_updates": 77930, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 884805412, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11353.848479404594, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2022, "avg_candidate_generations": 252.75, "candidate_moves_total": 128277, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.4406528189911, "candidate_moves_max": 84, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 444, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 2014, "search_candidate_moves_total": 127833, "search_candidate_moves_max": 84, "legality_checks": 34006, "avg_legality_checks": 4250.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 444, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 33562, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 302479, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 37809.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 656921387, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2171.791717772143, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5253, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 656.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29086566, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5537.134209023415, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 89060, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5239, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28994396, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3110, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 209600, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7762.962962962963, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 34, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 68610, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2017.9411764705883, "stage_move_gen_ns": 79348815, "stage_ordering_ns": 73240, "stage_eval_ns": 885590286, "stage_threat_ns": 484099283, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 77938, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 423980724, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 316930, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7650, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38965, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 50770871, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 77930, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9030758, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 224, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1710, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5271.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6271.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1853, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 3112, "avg_search_time_ms": 444.57142857142856, "search_nodes": 29592, "safety_nodes": 430, "corridor_nodes": 124, "corridor_branch_probes": 161, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 45, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 120, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 120, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 45, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 281, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 252080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 30146, "avg_nodes": 4306.571428571428, "eval_calls": 19812, "avg_eval_calls": 2830.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 19812, "pattern_eval_ns": 414902, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.94195437108823, "pattern_frame_queries": 19812, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 414902, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.94195437108823, "pattern_frame_updates": 59124, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 558205938, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9441.274913740614, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9143, "avg_candidate_generations": 1306.142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 629924, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.89686098654708, "candidate_moves_max": 92, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 383, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 9136, "search_candidate_moves_total": 629541, "search_candidate_moves_max": 92, "legality_checks": 407942, "avg_legality_checks": 58277.42857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 236, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 407942, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 236, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1093710, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 156244.2857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2019056168, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1846.0617238573298, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5254, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 750.5714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20672065, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3934.5384468976017, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 246, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1862075, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2067, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14675050, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2941, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4134940, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39934, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5704.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 354983500, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8889.254770371112, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 53815, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7687.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 167452124, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3111.625457586175, "stage_move_gen_ns": 881047083, "stage_ordering_ns": 224320967, "stage_eval_ns": 558620840, "stage_threat_ns": 1368377340, "stage_proof_ns": 54187089, "tactical_annotations": 140638, "root_tactical_annotations": 556, "search_tactical_annotations": 140082, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 59447, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 307380843, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 134999, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1011439321, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18516, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 549784267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 29720, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 38421026, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 316, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1566105, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 59440, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6478077, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 30938, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 131947090, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 77324, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 322566095, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 32376, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3091968, "child_limit_applications": 9136, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9136, "child_cap_hits": 9136, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9136, "child_moves_before_total": 629305, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 629305, "child_moves_before_max": 92, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 92, "child_moves_after_total": 146177, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 146177, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.88189579684763, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00010945709282, "tt_hits": 3357, "tt_cutoffs": 614, "beta_cutoffs": 7839, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 4.285714285714286, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 4.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3977.5714285714284, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5120.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1843, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1046, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14204, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 127, 97, 96, 83, 69, 68, 113, 53, 38, 99, 128, 125, 139, 80, 131, 67, 115, 95, 160, 144, 130, 129, 145, 100, 175 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7991, "avg_search_time_ms": 614.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 83711, "safety_nodes": 1109, "corridor_nodes": 412, "corridor_branch_probes": 468, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 144, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 399, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 399, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 144, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 446, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 222000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 85232, "avg_nodes": 6556.307692307692, "eval_calls": 60103, "avg_eval_calls": 4623.307692307692, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60103, "pattern_eval_ns": 1313719, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.85779412009384, "pattern_frame_queries": 60103, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1313719, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.85779412009384, "pattern_frame_updates": 167308, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1833050617, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10956.144458125134, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21747, "avg_candidate_generations": 1672.8461538461538, "candidate_moves_total": 1597311, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.44971720237274, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 899, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 21734, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1596412, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 690743, "avg_legality_checks": 53134.07692307692, "illegal_moves_skipped": 226, "root_legality_checks": 899, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 689844, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 226, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2120494, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 163114.92307692306, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4843557919, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2284.164878089728, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9573, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 736.3846153846154, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32823231, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3428.7298652460045, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 290, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2557678, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3125, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21887924, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6126, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8312078, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 65551, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50783, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3906.3846153846152, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 454729132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8954.357403067956, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 69037, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5310.538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 183560952, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2658.877877080406, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1746376841, "stage_ordering_ns": 671261597, "stage_eval_ns": 1834364336, "stage_threat_ns": 3523814149, "stage_proof_ns": 167072328, "tactical_annotations": 282310, "root_tactical_annotations": 1304, "search_tactical_annotations": 281006, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 168245, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1014446622, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 301476, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2354010847, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44003, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1594509275, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84116, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 122515300, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 924, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5901871, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 168232, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21247858, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62957, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 59033257, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 167676, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 640392597, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 51677, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5691651, "child_limit_applications": 21734, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21734, "child_cap_hits": 21734, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21734, "child_moves_before_total": 1596186, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1596186, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 347763, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 347763, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.44188828563541, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00087420631269, "tt_hits": 7622, "tt_cutoffs": 1818, "beta_cutoffs": 17892, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5250.538461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5865.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6200, "avg_search_time_ms": 516.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 204148, "safety_nodes": 637, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 204785, "avg_nodes": 17065.416666666668, "eval_calls": 198377, "avg_eval_calls": 16531.416666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 198377, "pattern_eval_ns": 4287516, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.612969245426637, "pattern_frame_queries": 198377, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4287516, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.612969245426637, "pattern_frame_updates": 408226, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3484413457, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8535.501063136597, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5748, "avg_candidate_generations": 479.0, "candidate_moves_total": 432096, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.17327766179541, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 848, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 5736, "search_candidate_moves_total": 431248, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 15997, "avg_legality_checks": 1333.0833333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 15997, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 839178, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 69931.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2055342455, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2449.233005393373, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4388, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 365.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43941879, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10014.101868732909, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4388, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43941879, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 41887270, "stage_ordering_ns": 206011, "stage_eval_ns": 3488700973, "stage_threat_ns": 2635458796, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 408238, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2307429766, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 151070, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 204113, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 277769933, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 408226, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50108027, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 399, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5131, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5835.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6501.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1969, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1047, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18043, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 140, 82, 114, 156, 141, 143, 127, 100, 155, 84, 70, 113, 125, 110, 109, 157, 139, 138, 171, 96, 124, 68, 54, 116, 52, 132 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2401, "avg_search_time_ms": 171.5, "search_nodes": 56705, "safety_nodes": 1496, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 58201, "avg_nodes": 4157.214285714285, "eval_calls": 53933, "avg_eval_calls": 3852.3571428571427, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53933, "pattern_eval_ns": 1167954, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.655646821055754, "pattern_frame_queries": 53933, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1167954, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.655646821055754, "pattern_frame_updates": 113330, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1470805503, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12978.077322862437, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2746, "avg_candidate_generations": 196.14285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 203219, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.00546249089585, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1003, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 2732, "search_candidate_moves_total": 202216, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 50324, "avg_legality_checks": 3594.5714285714284, "illegal_moves_skipped": 55, "root_legality_checks": 1003, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 49321, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 53, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 447928, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 31994.85714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1111048009, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2480.4165156007216, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6046, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 431.85714285714283, "renju_forbidden_ns": 39587509, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6547.718987760502, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 56, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 551334, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5964, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38884175, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 152000, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.785714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 896705, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11070.432098765432, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 111, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.928571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 441403, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3976.6036036036035, "stage_move_gen_ns": 130083568, "stage_ordering_ns": 99201, "stage_eval_ns": 1471973457, "stage_threat_ns": 774019727, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 113344, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 678407651, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1303896, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14710, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56665, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80001243, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 113330, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14306937, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 198, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2418, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6383.214285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6954.642857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1757, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 15630, "avg_search_time_ms": 1202.3076923076924, "search_nodes": 122999, "safety_nodes": 425, "corridor_nodes": 11685, "corridor_branch_probes": 12759, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 6189, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 11646, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 11646, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 119, "corridor_proof_active": 39, "corridor_proof_quiet": 80, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 6189, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 119, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 117, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 963, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 57851440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1989680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 135109, "avg_nodes": 10393.0, "eval_calls": 89457, "avg_eval_calls": 6881.307692307692, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89457, "pattern_eval_ns": 1975049, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.07819399264451, "pattern_frame_queries": 89457, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1975049, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.07819399264451, "pattern_frame_updates": 245878, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2605697796, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10597.523145625066, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31933, "avg_candidate_generations": 2456.3846153846152, "candidate_moves_total": 2690705, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.26095261954718, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 935, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 31920, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2689770, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1842363, "avg_legality_checks": 141720.23076923078, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4698, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1842363, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4698, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4397622, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 338278.6153846154, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9706820283, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2207.2884579438614, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47487, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3652.846153846154, "renju_forbidden_ns": 222387526, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4683.1243498220565, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4724, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52629718, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10310, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 105243464, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32379, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 63577871, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 936473, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 146818, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11293.692307692309, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1565381768, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10662.05620564236, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 208758, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16058.307692307691, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 781102629, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3741.6656080246025, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4666246618, "stage_ordering_ns": 1131391754, "stage_eval_ns": 2607672845, "stage_threat_ns": 7047609816, "stage_proof_ns": 143967832, "tactical_annotations": 613496, "root_tactical_annotations": 2796, "search_tactical_annotations": 610700, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 269421, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1749647339, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1070936, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4884235222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69371, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2555477194, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134704, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 212859660, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 23530, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 145565093, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 269408, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34451415, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 197891, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 851430794, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 257590, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1121272903, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 158015, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20851087, "child_limit_applications": 31920, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31920, "child_cap_hits": 31920, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31920, "child_moves_before_total": 2685072, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2685072, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 514533, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 514533, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.11879699248121, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.119454887218044, "tt_hits": 14126, "tt_cutoffs": 1562, "beta_cutoffs": 26144, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4211.307692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4826.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1753, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1048, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13857, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 114, 156, 113, 111, 66, 82, 126, 140, 84, 70, 99, 69, 97, 170, 184, 96, 129, 144, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11262, "avg_search_time_ms": 1023.8181818181819, "search_nodes": 103763, "safety_nodes": 171, "corridor_nodes": 2715, "corridor_branch_probes": 3228, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1066, "corridor_neutral_exits": 30, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2677, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2677, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 99, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 61, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1066, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 99, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 96, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 819, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 761600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 20000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 106649, "avg_nodes": 9695.363636363636, "eval_calls": 75036, "avg_eval_calls": 6821.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75036, "pattern_eval_ns": 1636486, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.809344847806386, "pattern_frame_queries": 75036, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1636486, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.809344847806386, "pattern_frame_updates": 207432, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2839157416, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13687.17177677504, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26860, "avg_candidate_generations": 2441.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2207464, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.18406552494416, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 26849, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2206678, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 676854, "avg_legality_checks": 61532.181818181816, "illegal_moves_skipped": 446, "root_legality_checks": 786, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 676068, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 446, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3039744, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 276340.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6890055008, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2266.6563394812197, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24254, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2204.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 106774568, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4402.348808443968, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 562, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3319533, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11366, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 74020902, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12119, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27933420, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 207, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1500713, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 77925, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7084.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 754188537, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9678.389951876805, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 108057, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9823.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 338196820, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3129.800198043625, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1720999839, "stage_ordering_ns": 960803808, "stage_eval_ns": 2840793902, "stage_threat_ns": 5165859611, "stage_proof_ns": 530630026, "tactical_annotations": 372569, "root_tactical_annotations": 2729, "search_tactical_annotations": 369840, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 212995, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1329460985, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 511813, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3605496933, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 55275, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2197864175, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 106492, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 163937548, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5552, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 29829435, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 212984, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27818616, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 113019, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 200121014, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 170673, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 744733953, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 88877, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9316094, "child_limit_applications": 26849, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26849, "child_cap_hits": 26849, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26849, "child_moves_before_total": 2206232, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2206232, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 432294, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 432294, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.17184997579054, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.100934857909046, "tt_hits": 12930, "tt_cutoffs": 1831, "beta_cutoffs": 21973, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3757.6363636363635, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4484.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 216, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2585, "avg_search_time_ms": 258.5, "search_nodes": 72100, "safety_nodes": 1085, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 73185, "avg_nodes": 7318.5, "eval_calls": 70448, "avg_eval_calls": 7044.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70448, "pattern_eval_ns": 1530938, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.731461503520325, "pattern_frame_queries": 70448, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1530938, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.731461503520325, "pattern_frame_updates": 144142, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1557911946, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10808.174896976592, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1633, "avg_candidate_generations": 163.3, "candidate_moves_total": 126409, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.40906307409675, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 720, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 1623, "search_candidate_moves_total": 125689, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 3340, "avg_legality_checks": 334.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3340, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 404224, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 40422.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 993930991, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2458.8618958795123, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2335, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 233.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18407512, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7883.30278372591, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2335, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18407512, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9677883, "stage_ordering_ns": 54940, "stage_eval_ns": 1559442884, "stage_threat_ns": 997512049, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 144152, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 877590899, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 276141, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11130, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72071, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 100895102, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 144142, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18749907, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1502, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5646.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6446.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1625, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1049, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19148, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 144, 160, 142, 95, 125, 50, 65, 78, 127, 94, 62, 157, 143, 141, 113, 158, 97, 82, 81, 49, 129 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 11558, "avg_search_time_ms": 963.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 284728, "safety_nodes": 727, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 285455, "avg_nodes": 23787.916666666668, "eval_calls": 278372, "avg_eval_calls": 23197.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 278372, "pattern_eval_ns": 5901265, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.199204661388357, "pattern_frame_queries": 278372, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5901265, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.199204661388357, "pattern_frame_updates": 569388, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7208625841, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12660.30517151749, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6334, "avg_candidate_generations": 527.8333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 518012, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.78275970950426, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 919, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 6322, "search_candidate_moves_total": 517093, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 271225, "avg_legality_checks": 22602.083333333332, "illegal_moves_skipped": 315, "root_legality_checks": 919, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 270306, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 312, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2135098, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 177924.83333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5124034485, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2399.9059926054915, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38093, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3174.4166666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 336406866, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8831.199065445095, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 326, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2323110, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37741, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 333951716, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 132040, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.1666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 284141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7477.394736842105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 47, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.9166666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 134290, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2857.2340425531916, "stage_move_gen_ns": 661172019, "stage_ordering_ns": 229623, "stage_eval_ns": 7214527106, "stage_threat_ns": 3644332470, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 569400, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3191188103, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 365333, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11140, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 284694, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 384125589, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 569388, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 68653445, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 439, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5622, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4563.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5230.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7578, "avg_search_time_ms": 688.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 86192, "safety_nodes": 1023, "corridor_nodes": 541, "corridor_branch_probes": 687, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 254, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 533, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 533, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 254, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 431, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26016560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87756, "avg_nodes": 7977.818181818182, "eval_calls": 69008, "avg_eval_calls": 6273.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 69008, "pattern_eval_ns": 1481495, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.468452932993277, "pattern_frame_queries": 69008, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1481495, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.468452932993277, "pattern_frame_updates": 172284, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1617932557, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9391.078434445451, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16129, "avg_candidate_generations": 1466.2727272727273, "candidate_moves_total": 1375846, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.3026226052452, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 845, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 16118, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1375001, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 738064, "avg_legality_checks": 67096.72727272728, "illegal_moves_skipped": 350, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 738064, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 350, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2084734, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 189521.27272727274, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4557791765, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2186.270174036592, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5038, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 458.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 38633711, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7668.461889638746, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 367, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2923381, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2839, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26391780, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1806, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9154920, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 163630, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73180, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6652.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 765368893, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10458.716766876196, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 104529, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9502.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 370663618, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3546.0362004802496, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1851987925, "stage_ordering_ns": 571599428, "stage_eval_ns": 1619414052, "stage_threat_ns": 3373748669, "stage_proof_ns": 107145433, "tactical_annotations": 282688, "root_tactical_annotations": 1121, "search_tactical_annotations": 281567, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 173483, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1013845256, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 275059, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2199221899, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32730, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1193429769, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86736, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125127870, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1188, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5819276, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 173472, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21428764, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62180, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 350434638, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 151217, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 637627820, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 69291, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8305604, "child_limit_applications": 16118, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16118, "child_cap_hits": 16118, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16118, "child_moves_before_total": 1374651, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1374651, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 258931, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 258931, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.28669810150143, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.064710261819084, "tt_hits": 6151, "tt_cutoffs": 1016, "beta_cutoffs": 11562, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4738.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5465.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1710, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1050, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10709, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 142, 94, 144, 96, 141, 143, 114, 100, 129, 99, 97, 82, 156, 170, 157, 127, 159, 174, 158, 160, 155 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10143, "avg_search_time_ms": 922.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 75224, "safety_nodes": 688, "corridor_nodes": 11190, "corridor_branch_probes": 12737, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 5409, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 11130, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 11130, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 60, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5409, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 97, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 821, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 504560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 87102, "avg_nodes": 7918.363636363636, "eval_calls": 52751, "avg_eval_calls": 4795.545454545455, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 52751, "pattern_eval_ns": 1116767, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.170537051430305, "pattern_frame_queries": 52751, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1116767, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.170537051430305, "pattern_frame_updates": 150354, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1751447885, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11648.82799925509, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21146, "avg_candidate_generations": 1922.3636363636363, "candidate_moves_total": 1678401, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.37203253570415, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 745, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 21135, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1677656, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 549047, "avg_legality_checks": 49913.36363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1794, "root_legality_checks": 745, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 548302, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1788, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3372609, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 306600.8181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6444411615, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1910.8089953504839, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25495, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2317.7272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 175859766, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6897.813924298882, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1815, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17435104, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10801, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 95428101, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10451, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43791619, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2428, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 19204942, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99545, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9049.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 865203152, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8691.578200813703, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137735, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12521.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 415084240, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3013.643881366392, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1244295580, "stage_ordering_ns": 616334223, "stage_eval_ns": 1752564652, "stage_threat_ns": 5296486404, "stage_proof_ns": 1195027606, "tactical_annotations": 309773, "root_tactical_annotations": 1871, "search_tactical_annotations": 307902, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 172825, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1067176729, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 883419, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3950430208, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47589, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1730757890, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86407, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 126855149, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 22460, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 125208001, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 172814, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19993291, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 98909, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 188379436, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 143121, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 578404771, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 67743, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6823026, "child_limit_applications": 21135, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21135, "child_cap_hits": 21135, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21135, "child_moves_before_total": 1675868, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1675868, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 339399, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 339399, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.29349420392714, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.05862313697658, "tt_hits": 9536, "tt_cutoffs": 1291, "beta_cutoffs": 17750, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3784.5454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4511.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 250, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 555, "avg_search_time_ms": 55.5, "search_nodes": 17563, "safety_nodes": 927, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 18490, "avg_nodes": 1849.0, "eval_calls": 16463, "avg_eval_calls": 1646.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 16463, "pattern_eval_ns": 344030, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.897163335965498, "pattern_frame_queries": 16463, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 344030, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.897163335965498, "pattern_frame_updates": 35068, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 305318761, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8706.47772898369, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1081, "avg_candidate_generations": 108.1, "candidate_moves_total": 78046, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.19796484736355, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 673, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 1071, "search_candidate_moves_total": 77373, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 3065, "avg_legality_checks": 306.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3065, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 86700, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8670.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 197011931, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2272.3406113033448, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1514, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 151.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14342998, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9473.5785997358, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 127301, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1469, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13928486, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 287211, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7911627, "stage_ordering_ns": 37451, "stage_eval_ns": 305662791, "stage_threat_ns": 226191035, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 35078, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 199533521, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 188231, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10250, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 17534, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 22410730, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 35068, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4058553, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 948, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5907.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6707.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1822, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1051, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27448, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 110, 83, 81, 86, 85, 54, 111, 68, 40, 109, 125, 95, 94, 142, 127, 128, 78, 62, 124, 123, 156, 114, 100, 69, 108, 99 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 20270, "avg_search_time_ms": 1351.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 594751, "safety_nodes": 400, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 595151, "avg_nodes": 39676.73333333333, "eval_calls": 583120, "avg_eval_calls": 38874.666666666664, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 583120, "pattern_eval_ns": 11557879, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.820755590615995, "pattern_frame_queries": 583120, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11557879, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.820755590615995, "pattern_frame_updates": 1189414, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 12579545877, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10576.255094525539, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11602, "avg_candidate_generations": 773.4666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1078468, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.95535252542665, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1265, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 11587, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1077203, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 556992, "avg_legality_checks": 37132.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 296, "root_legality_checks": 1265, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 555727, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 295, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4492529, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 299501.93333333335, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9122503459, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2030.5942285514461, "renju_forbidden_checks": 72755, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4850.333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 491562174, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6756.404013469864, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 352, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2479910, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 72398, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 489026434, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55830, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.6666666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 118630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11863.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.9333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 64690, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4620.714285714285, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1153621225, "stage_ordering_ns": 407403, "stage_eval_ns": 12591103756, "stage_threat_ns": 6447175784, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1189429, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5620539079, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 180640, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 594707, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 703634976, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1189414, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 122821089, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 827, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 10249, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4923.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5456.466666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 7162, "avg_search_time_ms": 477.46666666666664, "search_nodes": 91389, "safety_nodes": 1765, "corridor_nodes": 257, "corridor_branch_probes": 329, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 102, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_plies_followed": 249, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 249, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 58, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 102, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 437, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26033440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 93411, "avg_nodes": 6227.4, "eval_calls": 72943, "avg_eval_calls": 4862.866666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72943, "pattern_eval_ns": 1489315, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.417517787861755, "pattern_frame_queries": 72943, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1489315, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.417517787861755, "pattern_frame_updates": 182644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1403149546, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7682.428910886752, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17486, "avg_candidate_generations": 1165.7333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1559321, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.1753974608258, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1285, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 17471, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1558036, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 826274, "avg_legality_checks": 55084.933333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 321, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 826274, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 321, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2088624, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 139241.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4198101644, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2009.9843935528845, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6520, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 434.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 48563541, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7448.395858895706, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 321, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2822231, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3766, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35045523, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2423, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10583927, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 111860, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 63033, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4202.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 565667135, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8974.142671299162, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 87978, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5865.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 260781895, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2964.1716679169795, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1910169722, "stage_ordering_ns": 592803507, "stage_eval_ns": 1404638861, "stage_threat_ns": 3095311529, "stage_proof_ns": 110702813, "tactical_annotations": 278938, "root_tactical_annotations": 1172, "search_tactical_annotations": 277766, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 183289, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1015319176, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 274754, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1926460922, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35390, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1143313779, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91637, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 123351864, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 630, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3324927, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 183274, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20970370, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71215, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 285815693, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 152255, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 486337490, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 55468, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5884270, "child_limit_applications": 17471, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17471, "child_cap_hits": 17471, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17471, "child_moves_before_total": 1557715, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1557715, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 281362, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 281362, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.16003663213326, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.10451605517715, "tt_hits": 6555, "tt_cutoffs": 908, "beta_cutoffs": 12669, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5886.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6419.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1865, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1052, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11340, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 81, 68, 111, 54, 40, 109, 142, 94, 127, 157, 128, 125, 114, 113, 156, 100, 170 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8973, "avg_search_time_ms": 815.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 96461, "safety_nodes": 586, "corridor_nodes": 4081, "corridor_branch_probes": 4486, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1725, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 4049, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4049, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 87, "corridor_proof_active": 32, "corridor_proof_quiet": 55, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1725, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 87, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 85, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 693, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24138320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 101128, "avg_nodes": 9193.454545454546, "eval_calls": 70111, "avg_eval_calls": 6373.727272727273, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70111, "pattern_eval_ns": 1409139, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.098686368758113, "pattern_frame_queries": 70111, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1409139, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.098686368758113, "pattern_frame_updates": 192828, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1905316836, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9880.913746966207, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24720, "avg_candidate_generations": 2247.2727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 1974199, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.86241909385113, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 760, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 24709, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1973439, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 722087, "avg_legality_checks": 65644.27272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1245, "root_legality_checks": 760, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 721327, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1245, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2921004, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 265545.8181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5439020274, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1862.0379410640999, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24676, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2243.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 115076858, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4663.513454368617, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1339, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9501064, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 70257547, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11621, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29573838, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1095, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5744409, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83231, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7566.454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 648118244, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7786.981341086855, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110232, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10021.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 282025662, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2558.4736011321575, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1582048595, "stage_ordering_ns": 682639536, "stage_eval_ns": 1906725975, "stage_threat_ns": 4261203839, "stage_proof_ns": 495919240, "tactical_annotations": 403416, "root_tactical_annotations": 2034, "search_tactical_annotations": 401382, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 201111, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1069759972, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 606836, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2988980385, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51786, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1684881648, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 100550, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 131342670, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8272, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 38865988, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 201100, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21898034, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 132553, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 164368150, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 182346, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 626579551, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 88517, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10356790, "child_limit_applications": 24709, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24709, "child_cap_hits": 24709, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24709, "child_moves_before_total": 1972194, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1972194, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 401339, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 401339, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.81682787648225, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.242624145048364, "tt_hits": 10451, "tt_cutoffs": 1594, "beta_cutoffs": 20153, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4517.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5244.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1019, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2356, "avg_search_time_ms": 235.6, "search_nodes": 95373, "safety_nodes": 987, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 96360, "avg_nodes": 9636.0, "eval_calls": 91742, "avg_eval_calls": 9174.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 91742, "pattern_eval_ns": 1837072, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.02432909681498, "pattern_frame_queries": 91742, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1837072, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.02432909681498, "pattern_frame_updates": 190688, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1222768862, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6412.405930105722, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3612, "avg_candidate_generations": 361.2, "candidate_moves_total": 258982, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.70044296788483, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 694, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 3602, "search_candidate_moves_total": 258288, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 8859, "avg_legality_checks": 885.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8859, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 296962, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29696.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 643624610, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2167.363534728349, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1740, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 174.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15387676, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8843.49195402299, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1740, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15387676, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22436616, "stage_ordering_ns": 110471, "stage_eval_ns": 1224605934, "stage_threat_ns": 1088012681, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 190698, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 951866391, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 256891, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 95344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 115169265, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 190688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20720134, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 135, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3337, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5620.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6420.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1053, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13342, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 144, 82, 129, 99, 130, 110, 68, 97, 67, 111, 146, 162, 113, 126, 83, 53, 159, 174, 141, 124, 138, 125, 127, 80, 64, 95, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 7471, "avg_search_time_ms": 498.06666666666666, "search_nodes": 192445, "safety_nodes": 443, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 192888, "avg_nodes": 12859.2, "eval_calls": 186057, "avg_eval_calls": 12403.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 186057, "pattern_eval_ns": 3720276, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.995356261790743, "pattern_frame_queries": 186057, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3720276, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.995356261790743, "pattern_frame_updates": 384804, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4751418071, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12347.631706011372, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6360, "avg_candidate_generations": 424.0, "candidate_moves_total": 549801, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.44669811320755, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1151, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 6345, "search_candidate_moves_total": 548650, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 176250, "avg_legality_checks": 11750.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 605, "root_legality_checks": 1151, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 175099, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 602, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1590412, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 106027.46666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3551621960, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2233.145851515205, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48979, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3265.266666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 224794963, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4589.61928581637, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 721, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1444400, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 48243, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 223334103, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 16460, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 93430, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10381.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 45100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3758.3333333333335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 398670115, "stage_ordering_ns": 228241, "stage_eval_ns": 4755138347, "stage_threat_ns": 2282324886, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 384819, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1993091638, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 153460, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 192402, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 245986567, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 384804, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43093221, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 764, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5294, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6534.466666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7067.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1810, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 5856, "avg_search_time_ms": 418.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 47363, "safety_nodes": 1523, "corridor_nodes": 4033, "corridor_branch_probes": 4514, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2243, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 4010, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4010, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2243, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 72, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 396, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 277360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 52919, "avg_nodes": 3779.9285714285716, "eval_calls": 32211, "avg_eval_calls": 2300.785714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32211, "pattern_eval_ns": 668664, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.75887119307069, "pattern_frame_queries": 32211, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 668664, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.75887119307069, "pattern_frame_updates": 94596, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 959138557, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10139.314104190453, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14464, "avg_candidate_generations": 1033.142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 1154036, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.78678097345133, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1080, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 14450, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1152956, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 686801, "avg_legality_checks": 49057.21428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 593, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 686801, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 593, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1771063, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 126504.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3670537520, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2072.505337190151, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10984, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 784.5714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42288361, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3849.9964493809175, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 693, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2989327, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4266, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27445472, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5995, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11819362, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 34200, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60341, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4310.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 546022470, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9048.946321738122, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81411, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5815.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 240941641, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2959.5710776185038, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1624115152, "stage_ordering_ns": 454106398, "stage_eval_ns": 959807221, "stage_threat_ns": 2699281085, "stage_proof_ns": 80079600, "tactical_annotations": 236636, "root_tactical_annotations": 751, "search_tactical_annotations": 235885, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 102774, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 639369878, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 404468, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1916968319, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30621, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1066778563, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74770850, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8164, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 50527594, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 102760, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12180464, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70127, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 244878310, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 123024, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 475831380, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 43485, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5463980, "child_limit_applications": 14450, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14450, "child_cap_hits": 14450, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14450, "child_moves_before_total": 1152363, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1152363, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 234066, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 234066, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.7483044982699, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.198339100346022, "tt_hits": 5266, "tt_cutoffs": 637, "beta_cutoffs": 12387, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5840.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6412.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1914, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1054, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16480, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 82, 130, 52, 97, 80, 128, 68, 146, 162, 110, 36, 84, 66, 94, 81, 51, 79, 78, 83 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 12878, "avg_search_time_ms": 1287.8, "search_nodes": 148672, "safety_nodes": 176, "corridor_nodes": 6605, "corridor_branch_probes": 7389, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3239, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 6554, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6554, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 51, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3239, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 81, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 683, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 14185040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1978160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 155453, "avg_nodes": 15545.3, "eval_calls": 116432, "avg_eval_calls": 11643.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 116432, "pattern_eval_ns": 2369320, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.349388484265493, "pattern_frame_queries": 116432, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2369320, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.349388484265493, "pattern_frame_updates": 297260, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3626058026, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12198.27096144789, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30381, "avg_candidate_generations": 3038.1, "candidate_moves_total": 2691296, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.58483920871598, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 775, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 30371, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2690521, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1053406, "avg_legality_checks": 105340.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1239, "root_legality_checks": 775, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1052631, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1239, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4697963, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 469796.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7967586670, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1695.9662453706, "renju_forbidden_checks": 66049, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6604.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 245242849, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3713.044088479765, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1744, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7872899, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37274, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 177000804, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24647, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 52427919, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2384, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7941227, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 147516, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14751.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1077555793, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7304.670632338187, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 194285, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19428.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 484549067, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2494.011719896029, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2133952495, "stage_ordering_ns": 882697934, "stage_eval_ns": 3628427346, "stage_threat_ns": 5597426801, "stage_proof_ns": 574899623, "tactical_annotations": 508977, "root_tactical_annotations": 2621, "search_tactical_annotations": 506356, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 310544, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1497700530, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 815327, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3809505058, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 63711, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1930820608, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 155267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 193688722, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 13274, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 52788685, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 310534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31702631, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 148644, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 281796410, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 255305, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 987767097, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 105028, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12041175, "child_limit_applications": 30371, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30371, "child_cap_hits": 30371, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30371, "child_moves_before_total": 2689282, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2689282, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 490258, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 490258, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.54769352342696, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.14230680583451, "tt_hits": 12636, "tt_cutoffs": 1827, "beta_cutoffs": 22947, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2478.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3198.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 103, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 3595, "avg_search_time_ms": 399.44444444444446, "search_nodes": 121136, "safety_nodes": 995, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122131, "avg_nodes": 13570.111111111111, "eval_calls": 118496, "avg_eval_calls": 13166.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 118496, "pattern_eval_ns": 2444358, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.62818998109641, "pattern_frame_queries": 118496, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2444358, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.62818998109641, "pattern_frame_updates": 242220, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2163645535, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8932.563516637767, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2623, "avg_candidate_generations": 291.44444444444446, "candidate_moves_total": 202368, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.15135341212353, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 707, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 2614, "search_candidate_moves_total": 201661, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 5048, "avg_legality_checks": 560.8888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5048, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 646116, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 71790.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1281918283, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1984.0373601644287, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10384, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1153.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 67301153, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6481.235843605547, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10384, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 67301153, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12135936, "stage_ordering_ns": 85330, "stage_eval_ns": 2166089893, "stage_threat_ns": 1392083836, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 242229, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1221797437, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 165710, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8730, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 143639617, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 242220, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26481072, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 124, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2378, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4516.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5405.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1062, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1055, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16847, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 144, 82, 110, 158, 143, 141, 127, 94, 159, 80, 64, 111, 129, 114, 115, 157, 145, 146, 173, 98, 130, 66, 50, 108, 52, 122 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2148, "avg_search_time_ms": 153.42857142857142, "search_nodes": 54111, "safety_nodes": 1496, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 55607, "avg_nodes": 3971.9285714285716, "eval_calls": 51423, "avg_eval_calls": 3673.0714285714284, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51423, "pattern_eval_ns": 1088773, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.17287983976042, "pattern_frame_queries": 51423, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1088773, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.17287983976042, "pattern_frame_updates": 108142, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1305429973, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12071.44285291561, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2662, "avg_candidate_generations": 190.14285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 198267, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.48046581517656, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1003, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 2648, "search_candidate_moves_total": 197264, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 48362, "avg_legality_checks": 3454.4285714285716, "illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "root_legality_checks": 1003, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 47359, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 52, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 429734, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 30695.285714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 982600324, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2286.5314915738572, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6368, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 454.85714285714283, "renju_forbidden_ns": 36250679, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5692.631752512563, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 55, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 550591, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6287, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35553028, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 147060, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5.785714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 768283, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9484.975308641975, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 111, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.928571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 383510, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3455.045045045045, "stage_move_gen_ns": 116845014, "stage_ordering_ns": 93790, "stage_eval_ns": 1306518746, "stage_threat_ns": 698869488, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 108156, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 612335168, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1127014, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 54071, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 72587978, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 108142, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12819328, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 198, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2333, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6414.928571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6986.357142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1806, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 14688, "avg_search_time_ms": 1129.8461538461538, "search_nodes": 121895, "safety_nodes": 425, "corridor_nodes": 8852, "corridor_branch_probes": 9300, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4476, "corridor_neutral_exits": 22, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 8816, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8816, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 120, "corridor_proof_active": 36, "corridor_proof_quiet": 84, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4476, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 120, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 118, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 967, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 59778800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1989680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 131172, "avg_nodes": 10090.153846153846, "eval_calls": 88630, "avg_eval_calls": 6817.692307692308, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 88630, "pattern_eval_ns": 1931698, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.795080672458536, "pattern_frame_queries": 88630, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1931698, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.795080672458536, "pattern_frame_updates": 243670, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2427131055, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9960.729901095745, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31654, "avg_candidate_generations": 2434.923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 2661354, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.0763884501169, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 935, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 31641, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2660419, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1838367, "avg_legality_checks": 141412.84615384616, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4842, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1838367, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4842, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4330670, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 333128.46153846156, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9212546865, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2127.2798123615976, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41807, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3215.923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 171637654, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4105.476451311982, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4960, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 54431151, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6904, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 66602963, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29869, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 49653143, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 950397, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 146237, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11249.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1519128632, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10388.127710497343, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 207672, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15974.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 757665514, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3648.3758715667013, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4504129978, "stage_ordering_ns": 1081520974, "stage_eval_ns": 2429062753, "stage_threat_ns": 6450513716, "stage_proof_ns": 155726297, "tactical_annotations": 614405, "root_tactical_annotations": 2796, "search_tactical_annotations": 611609, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 261555, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1606536557, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 960122, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4501050882, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67772, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2336942286, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 130771, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 196866272, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 17872, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 92946238, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 261542, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32300620, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 200480, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 796895835, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 257389, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1124243168, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 156536, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20813147, "child_limit_applications": 31641, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31641, "child_cap_hits": 31641, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31641, "child_moves_before_total": 2655577, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2655577, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 510112, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 510112, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.92835245409437, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.121867197623338, "tt_hits": 14024, "tt_cutoffs": 1564, "beta_cutoffs": 25929, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4565.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5181.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1809, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1056, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13920, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 110, 158, 111, 113, 68, 82, 128, 144, 80, 64, 95, 65, 97, 174, 190, 98, 125, 140, 139, 83, 153 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11178, "avg_search_time_ms": 1016.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 103593, "safety_nodes": 171, "corridor_nodes": 2713, "corridor_branch_probes": 3224, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1056, "corridor_neutral_exits": 30, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2675, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2675, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 99, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 61, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1056, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 99, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 96, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 819, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 725520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 106477, "avg_nodes": 9679.727272727272, "eval_calls": 74853, "avg_eval_calls": 6804.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74853, "pattern_eval_ns": 1636387, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.861341562796415, "pattern_frame_queries": 74853, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1636387, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.861341562796415, "pattern_frame_updates": 207092, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2830834014, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13669.451325980723, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26849, "avg_candidate_generations": 2440.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2223720, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.82319639465157, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 26838, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2222934, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 681863, "avg_legality_checks": 61987.545454545456, "illegal_moves_skipped": 537, "root_legality_checks": 786, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 681077, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 537, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3038565, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 276233.1818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6833232853, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2248.835503930309, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25035, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2275.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 111895009, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4469.542999800279, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 652, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4211136, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11808, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 78128926, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12374, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28028743, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 201, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1526204, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6966.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 738173047, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9632.951154900169, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 107481, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9771.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 333131694, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3099.4472883579424, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1717741467, "stage_ordering_ns": 958732120, "stage_eval_ns": 2832470401, "stage_threat_ns": 5095887375, "stage_proof_ns": 529905134, "tactical_annotations": 376752, "root_tactical_annotations": 2729, "search_tactical_annotations": 374023, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 212651, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1323922177, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 517610, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3544802267, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 55261, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2154569956, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 106320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159560654, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5548, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 29827310, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 212640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27240828, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116870, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 178456074, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171840, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 753034845, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 88042, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10534139, "child_limit_applications": 26838, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26838, "child_cap_hits": 26838, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26838, "child_moves_before_total": 2222397, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2222397, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 431882, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 431882, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.80784708249497, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.09218272598554, "tt_hits": 12959, "tt_cutoffs": 1855, "beta_cutoffs": 21959, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3827.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4554.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 288, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2731, "avg_search_time_ms": 273.1, "search_nodes": 76241, "safety_nodes": 1085, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 77326, "avg_nodes": 7732.6, "eval_calls": 74559, "avg_eval_calls": 7455.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74559, "pattern_eval_ns": 1605168, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.52882951756327, "pattern_frame_queries": 74559, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1605168, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.52882951756327, "pattern_frame_updates": 152424, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1647956190, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10811.658203432531, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1663, "avg_candidate_generations": 166.3, "candidate_moves_total": 128224, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.10402886349969, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 720, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 1653, "search_candidate_moves_total": 127504, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 3399, "avg_legality_checks": 339.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3399, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 430537, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 43053.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1045502071, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2428.367529387718, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2502, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 250.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20113684, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8039.0423661071145, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2502, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20113684, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9770425, "stage_ordering_ns": 55620, "stage_eval_ns": 1649561358, "stage_threat_ns": 1057100100, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152434, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 930431325, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 287061, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11020, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76212, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 106845059, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152424, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19536655, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1527, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5603.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6403.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1569, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1057, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 53903, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 114, 81, 83, 78, 79, 50, 113, 66, 34, 115, 129, 99, 100, 142, 127, 126, 86, 72, 130, 131, 110, 111, 174, 159, 158, 172, 116, 102, 173, 143, 84, 68, 87, 85, 132, 148, 147, 64, 36, 65, 67, 35, 20, 95 ], "move_count": 52, "black_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 42141, "avg_search_time_ms": 1755.875, "search_nodes": 1181955, "safety_nodes": 721, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 1182676, "avg_nodes": 49278.166666666664, "eval_calls": 1158704, "avg_eval_calls": 48279.333333333336, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 1158704, "pattern_eval_ns": 24308966, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.97944427567351, "pattern_frame_queries": 1158704, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 24308966, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.97944427567351, "pattern_frame_updates": 2363768, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 25991584926, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10995.827393382091, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23204, "avg_candidate_generations": 966.8333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 2416501, "avg_candidate_moves": 104.1415704188933, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2255, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 23180, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2414246, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 1112328, "avg_legality_checks": 46347.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 280, "root_legality_checks": 2255, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1110073, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 280, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8889968, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 370415.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19496745999, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2193.1176804010993, "renju_forbidden_checks": 94656, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3944.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 717360548, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7578.606195064232, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 363, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3026153, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 94293, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 714334395, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.5833333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 155470, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11105.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.9166666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 89090, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4049.5454545454545, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2408115285, "stage_ordering_ns": 807383, "stage_eval_ns": 26015893892, "stage_threat_ns": 13538230586, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 2363792, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 11774896128, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 68, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 255880, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 24080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 1181884, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1502393647, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 2363768, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 260684931, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1367, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 20766, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 2.625, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 2.625, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 9 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 8, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 8, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2941.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3190.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 11738, "avg_search_time_ms": 489.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 179421, "safety_nodes": 2434, "corridor_nodes": 1160, "corridor_branch_probes": 1409, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 9, "corridor_depth_exits": 537, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1145, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1145, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 22, "corridor_proof_completed": 22, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 68, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 537, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 81, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 469, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26039520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 183015, "avg_nodes": 7625.625, "eval_calls": 144256, "avg_eval_calls": 6010.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 144256, "pattern_eval_ns": 2872691, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.91384067213842, "pattern_frame_queries": 144256, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2872691, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.91384067213842, "pattern_frame_updates": 358618, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2333588296, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6507.170013775103, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32883, "avg_candidate_generations": 1370.125, "candidate_moves_total": 3303040, "avg_candidate_moves": 100.44825593771859, "candidate_moves_max": 137, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2277, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 32859, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3300763, "search_candidate_moves_max": 137, "legality_checks": 1758259, "avg_legality_checks": 73260.79166666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 289, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1758259, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 289, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3985288, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 166053.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6681645997, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1676.5779529609906, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9266, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 386.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 45485585, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4908.869522987266, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 289, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2898226, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3356, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30292272, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5621, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12295087, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 100047, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4168.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 810361798, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8099.811068797665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 152492, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6353.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 387260658, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2539.5473729769433, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3176224674, "stage_ordering_ns": 1009371120, "stage_eval_ns": 2336460987, "stage_threat_ns": 4977049856, "stage_proof_ns": 133623350, "tactical_annotations": 778117, "root_tactical_annotations": 2409, "search_tactical_annotations": 775708, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 361098, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1684205014, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 785327, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3014013660, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 66617, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1729965621, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 180537, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 214716885, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2456, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16699916, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 361074, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36393935, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 298713, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 453241797, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 362531, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 789659520, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 116873, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11020446, "child_limit_applications": 32859, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32859, "child_cap_hits": 32859, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32859, "child_moves_before_total": 3300474, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3300474, "child_moves_before_max": 137, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 137, "child_moves_after_total": 531546, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 531546, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 100.44353145257007, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.176572628503607, "tt_hits": 12838, "tt_cutoffs": 2194, "beta_cutoffs": 23532, "depth_sum": 112, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 112, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.041666666666666664, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6634.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6967.416666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1872, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1058, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9661, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 144, 96, 160, 176, 97, 110, 124, 66, 114, 81, 111, 83, 84, 68, 54, 53, 113, 38 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7457, "avg_search_time_ms": 828.5555555555555, "search_nodes": 84072, "safety_nodes": 832, "corridor_nodes": 347, "corridor_branch_probes": 367, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 163, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 341, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 341, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 26, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 20, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 163, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 26, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 26, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 155, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23856640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85251, "avg_nodes": 9472.333333333334, "eval_calls": 64843, "avg_eval_calls": 7204.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64843, "pattern_eval_ns": 1409574, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.73826010517712, "pattern_frame_queries": 64843, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1409574, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.73826010517712, "pattern_frame_updates": 168064, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1498215419, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8914.552902465728, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17871, "avg_candidate_generations": 1985.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1415976, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.23317105925801, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 676, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 17862, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1415300, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 766507, "avg_legality_checks": 85167.44444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 79, "root_legality_checks": 676, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 765831, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 78, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1909008, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 212112.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4459906233, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2336.2428198310326, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6918, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 768.6666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 23968503, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3464.657849089332, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 85, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 552032, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1711, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14214390, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4806, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7119506, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 316, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2082575, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43646, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4849.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 423173213, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9695.57835769601, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 57946, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6438.444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 184611479, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3185.922738411625, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1969418215, "stage_ordering_ns": 631930592, "stage_eval_ns": 1499624993, "stage_threat_ns": 3224346634, "stage_proof_ns": 85291837, "tactical_annotations": 197866, "root_tactical_annotations": 886, "search_tactical_annotations": 196980, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 168807, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1002676655, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 223410, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2069728479, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36038, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1409029124, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84399, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 122078493, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 734, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4859509, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 168798, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21228820, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 37823, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 62093346, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 130890, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 547489388, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 29153, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3774678, "child_limit_applications": 17862, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17862, "child_cap_hits": 17862, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17862, "child_moves_before_total": 1415222, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1415222, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 285867, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 285867, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.23088120031352, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.004198857910648, "tt_hits": 4877, "tt_cutoffs": 1327, "beta_cutoffs": 13605, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 4.222222222222222, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 4.222222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2842.222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3731.1111111111113, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2194, "avg_search_time_ms": 243.77777777777777, "search_nodes": 75814, "safety_nodes": 251, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76065, "avg_nodes": 8451.666666666666, "eval_calls": 72610, "avg_eval_calls": 8067.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72610, "pattern_eval_ns": 1587036, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.85698939540008, "pattern_frame_queries": 72610, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1587036, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.85698939540008, "pattern_frame_updates": 151578, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1159648153, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7650.504380582935, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3188, "avg_candidate_generations": 354.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 293651, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.11135508155583, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 703, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 3179, "search_candidate_moves_total": 292948, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 6293, "avg_legality_checks": 699.2222222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6293, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 248363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27595.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 629124620, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2533.085121374762, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3680, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 408.8888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12920647, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3511.0453804347826, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1540, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3668, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12907527, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 11580, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17073355, "stage_ordering_ns": 123041, "stage_eval_ns": 1161235189, "stage_threat_ns": 994531410, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 151587, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 873162345, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 63760, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75789, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 102786632, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 151578, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18518673, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 503, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2608, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5687.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6576.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1059, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16725, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 140, 154, 142, 99, 129, 54, 69, 83, 127, 157, 141, 139, 111, 156, 143, 144, 95, 79, 159 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9439, "avg_search_time_ms": 858.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 221961, "safety_nodes": 577, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 222538, "avg_nodes": 20230.727272727272, "eval_calls": 216594, "avg_eval_calls": 19690.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 216594, "pattern_eval_ns": 4656035, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.496601937265112, "pattern_frame_queries": 216594, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4656035, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.496601937265112, "pattern_frame_updates": 443860, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5802367779, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13072.517863740819, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5347, "avg_candidate_generations": 486.09090909090907, "candidate_moves_total": 393981, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.68262577146064, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 761, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 5336, "search_candidate_moves_total": 393220, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 210606, "avg_legality_checks": 19146.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 217, "root_legality_checks": 761, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 209845, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 214, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1551288, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 141026.18181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4037907039, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2602.938357674397, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28798, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2618.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 288515031, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10018.57875546913, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 220, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2472509, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28561, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 285838510, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 204012, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.1818181818181817, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 330041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9429.742857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 44, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 138491, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3147.5227272727275, "stage_move_gen_ns": 560077091, "stage_ordering_ns": 191750, "stage_eval_ns": 5807023814, "stage_threat_ns": 3047525225, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 443871, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2670637547, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 426281, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11710, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 221930, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 319427466, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 443860, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57033931, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 407, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4638, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4402.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5129.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7277, "avg_search_time_ms": 727.7, "search_nodes": 81237, "safety_nodes": 743, "corridor_nodes": 295, "corridor_branch_probes": 369, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 127, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 289, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 289, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 57, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 127, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 57, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 57, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 421, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26014720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 82275, "avg_nodes": 8227.5, "eval_calls": 65199, "avg_eval_calls": 6519.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 65199, "pattern_eval_ns": 1416530, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.72625347014525, "pattern_frame_queries": 65199, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1416530, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.72625347014525, "pattern_frame_updates": 162384, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1574134652, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9693.902428810721, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15032, "avg_candidate_generations": 1503.2, "candidate_moves_total": 1262561, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.99155135710484, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 691, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 15022, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1261870, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 683842, "avg_legality_checks": 68384.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 278, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 683842, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 278, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1949710, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 194971.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4393377267, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2253.349096532305, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3700, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 370.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 34637110, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9361.381081081081, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 278, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3198522, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2048, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22255236, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1355, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8916122, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 267230, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68123, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6812.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 742459903, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10898.813954171132, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9784.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 360363494, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3682.8907489166872, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1759189237, "stage_ordering_ns": 543293619, "stage_eval_ns": 1575551182, "stage_threat_ns": 3253673118, "stage_proof_ns": 104259600, "tactical_annotations": 256351, "root_tactical_annotations": 1101, "search_tactical_annotations": 255250, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 163086, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 973918719, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 238174, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2123634115, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30437, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1150656719, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 81538, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121600021, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 692, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4203786, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 163076, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20526316, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52727, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 338353886, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 137957, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 620363851, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 65667, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9790161, "child_limit_applications": 15022, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15022, "child_cap_hits": 15022, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15022, "child_moves_before_total": 1261592, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1261592, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 240894, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 240894, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.98295832778591, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.03608041539076, "tt_hits": 5793, "tt_cutoffs": 971, "beta_cutoffs": 10704, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4480.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5280.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1863, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1060, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9851, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 142, 100, 140, 98, 143, 141, 110, 94, 125, 95, 97, 82, 154, 168, 155, 170, 157, 127, 156, 158, 153 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9290, "avg_search_time_ms": 844.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 74486, "safety_nodes": 711, "corridor_nodes": 10839, "corridor_branch_probes": 12371, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 5322, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 10779, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 10779, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 60, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5322, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 97, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 821, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 505600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 86036, "avg_nodes": 7821.454545454545, "eval_calls": 52432, "avg_eval_calls": 4766.545454545455, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 52432, "pattern_eval_ns": 1051047, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.045907079646017, "pattern_frame_queries": 52432, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1051047, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.045907079646017, "pattern_frame_updates": 148878, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1661475872, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11159.982482300944, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20761, "avg_candidate_generations": 1887.3636363636363, "candidate_moves_total": 1659779, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.94696787245316, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 756, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 20750, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1659023, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 532658, "avg_legality_checks": 48423.454545454544, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1746, "root_legality_checks": 756, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 531902, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1740, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3287328, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 298848.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5876664919, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1787.6722125081526, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26195, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2381.3636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 172979963, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6603.5488833746895, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1764, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16136083, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11427, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 96414153, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10585, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42600808, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2419, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 17828919, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 95405, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8673.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 793245278, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8314.504250301346, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132055, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12005.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 383217125, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2901.9508916739237, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1111450327, "stage_ordering_ns": 564485991, "stage_eval_ns": 1662526919, "stage_threat_ns": 4832954073, "stage_proof_ns": 1085715353, "tactical_annotations": 301634, "root_tactical_annotations": 1871, "search_tactical_annotations": 299763, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 170647, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 975948493, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 847702, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3595050034, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46566, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1572660891, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85318, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118861603, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 21758, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 116669551, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 170636, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18421016, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 94056, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 168929140, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 140217, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 542818475, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 67361, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8003376, "child_limit_applications": 20750, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20750, "child_cap_hits": 20750, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20750, "child_moves_before_total": 1657283, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1657283, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 333157, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 333157, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.86906024096386, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.05575903614458, "tt_hits": 9411, "tt_cutoffs": 1257, "beta_cutoffs": 17381, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4180.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4908.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 528, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 548, "avg_search_time_ms": 54.8, "search_nodes": 20254, "safety_nodes": 942, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 21196, "avg_nodes": 2119.6, "eval_calls": 19090, "avg_eval_calls": 1909.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 19090, "pattern_eval_ns": 371261, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.447930853850185, "pattern_frame_queries": 19090, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 371261, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.447930853850185, "pattern_frame_updates": 40450, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 306095778, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7567.262744128554, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1145, "avg_candidate_generations": 114.5, "candidate_moves_total": 84430, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.73799126637554, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 688, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 1135, "search_candidate_moves_total": 83742, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 3166, "avg_legality_checks": 316.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3166, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 100202, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10020.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 196651771, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1962.5533522284984, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1669, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 166.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14357942, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8602.721390053925, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 137750, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1624, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13925170, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 295022, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7531466, "stage_ordering_ns": 36940, "stage_eval_ns": 306467039, "stage_threat_ns": 220374076, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 40460, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 193602106, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 171112, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9781, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 20225, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 22521900, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 40450, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4078958, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1013, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5925.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6725.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1879, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1061, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15596, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 140, 82, 125, 95, 124, 114, 66, 97, 67, 113, 138, 152, 111, 128, 81, 51, 155, 170, 143, 130, 146, 129, 127, 84, 70, 99, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 9149, "avg_search_time_ms": 609.9333333333333, "search_nodes": 217437, "safety_nodes": 443, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 217880, "avg_nodes": 14525.333333333334, "eval_calls": 210779, "avg_eval_calls": 14051.933333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 210779, "pattern_eval_ns": 4555980, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.614961642288844, "pattern_frame_queries": 210779, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4555980, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.614961642288844, "pattern_frame_updates": 434788, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5757573503, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13242.254852939823, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6630, "avg_candidate_generations": 442.0, "candidate_moves_total": 571350, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.17647058823529, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1151, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 6615, "search_candidate_moves_total": 570199, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 200703, "avg_legality_checks": 13380.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1008, "root_legality_checks": 1151, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 199552, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1005, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1751072, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 116738.13333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4267354487, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2436.995444504852, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55023, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3668.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 269030058, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4889.410937244425, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1144, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2206798, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 53864, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 266806650, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 16610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 99920, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11102.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 48260, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4021.6666666666665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 498033428, "stage_ordering_ns": 259100, "stage_eval_ns": 5762129483, "stage_threat_ns": 2845653278, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 434803, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2490646910, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 165102, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15961, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 217394, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 301835082, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 434788, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53006184, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 764, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5507, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6400.466666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6933.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1742, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6433, "avg_search_time_ms": 459.5, "search_nodes": 47928, "safety_nodes": 1523, "corridor_nodes": 4054, "corridor_branch_probes": 4544, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 2254, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_plies_followed": 4031, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4031, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2254, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 72, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 396, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 276080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53505, "avg_nodes": 3821.785714285714, "eval_calls": 32554, "avg_eval_calls": 2325.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32554, "pattern_eval_ns": 728163, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.367850340971923, "pattern_frame_queries": 32554, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 728163, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.367850340971923, "pattern_frame_updates": 95726, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1054494264, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11015.756053736706, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14675, "avg_candidate_generations": 1048.2142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 1173318, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.95352640545144, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1080, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 14661, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1172238, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 690449, "avg_legality_checks": 49317.78571428572, "illegal_moves_skipped": 651, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 690449, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 651, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1786681, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 127620.07142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4032991239, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2257.253107297833, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11338, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 809.8571428571429, "renju_forbidden_ns": 45408800, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4005.009701887458, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 757, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3398594, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4416, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29329184, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6135, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12645032, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 35990, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60815, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4343.928571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 593605818, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9760.845482200115, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81984, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5856.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 258684337, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3155.302705405933, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1761939967, "stage_ordering_ns": 503039782, "stage_eval_ns": 1055222427, "stage_threat_ns": 2985295582, "stage_proof_ns": 87278007, "tactical_annotations": 242335, "root_tactical_annotations": 751, "search_tactical_annotations": 241584, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 103946, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 708280936, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 410770, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2119960083, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31059, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1195956260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51966, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 82432223, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8206, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 55604085, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 103932, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13417757, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71468, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 261872274, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 126766, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 524920688, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 44101, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5600498, "child_limit_applications": 14661, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14661, "child_cap_hits": 14661, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14661, "child_moves_before_total": 1171587, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1171587, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 237547, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 237547, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.91180683445877, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.20264647704795, "tt_hits": 5303, "tt_cutoffs": 648, "beta_cutoffs": 12574, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5710.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6281.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1816, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1062, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5620, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 82, 124, 126, 140, 127, 97, 130, 114, 84, 70, 83, 81, 128, 129, 113, 143, 68 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4751, "avg_search_time_ms": 527.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 75872, "safety_nodes": 223, "corridor_nodes": 2529, "corridor_branch_probes": 2964, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 965, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 2493, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2493, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 82, "corridor_proof_active": 36, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 965, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 82, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 80, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 682, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 462240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 78624, "avg_nodes": 8736.0, "eval_calls": 51361, "avg_eval_calls": 5706.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51361, "pattern_eval_ns": 940193, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.305582056424136, "pattern_frame_queries": 51361, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 940193, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.305582056424136, "pattern_frame_updates": 151670, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1004304203, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6621.6404232874, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22751, "avg_candidate_generations": 2527.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 1790316, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.69174981319503, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 588, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 22742, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1789728, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 536899, "avg_legality_checks": 59655.444444444445, "illegal_moves_skipped": 271, "root_legality_checks": 588, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 536311, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 271, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2276626, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 252958.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2802580993, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1231.0238892993402, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17895, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1988.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43925038, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2454.5983794355966, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 379, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1628788, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7501, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28846206, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9691, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11986651, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 324, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1463393, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51985, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5776.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 278423113, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5355.835587188612, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 71329, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7925.444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 126893076, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1778.9829662549594, "stage_move_gen_ns": 740269155, "stage_ordering_ns": 409931408, "stage_eval_ns": 1005244396, "stage_threat_ns": 2302805166, "stage_proof_ns": 261475739, "tactical_annotations": 326902, "root_tactical_annotations": 2193, "search_tactical_annotations": 324709, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 156829, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 552647812, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 451909, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1637358172, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46980, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1023883782, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73924573, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5150, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16148956, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 156820, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15434579, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 94874, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 76637296, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 145474, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 288577615, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 86554, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7291074, "child_limit_applications": 22742, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22742, "child_cap_hits": 22742, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22742, "child_moves_before_total": 1789457, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1789457, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 366468, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 366468, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.68512004221265, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.114150030780056, "tt_hits": 10867, "tt_cutoffs": 1732, "beta_cutoffs": 19384, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4675.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5564.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1069, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 861, "avg_search_time_ms": 107.625, "search_nodes": 42734, "safety_nodes": 731, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 43465, "avg_nodes": 5433.125, "eval_calls": 41533, "avg_eval_calls": 5191.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41533, "pattern_eval_ns": 762592, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.361110442298894, "pattern_frame_queries": 41533, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 762592, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.361110442298894, "pattern_frame_updates": 85422, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 497755071, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5827.012607993257, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1186, "avg_candidate_generations": 148.25, "candidate_moves_total": 87025, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.37689713322091, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 527, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 1178, "search_candidate_moves_total": 86498, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 2630, "avg_legality_checks": 328.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2630, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 208918, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26114.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 287916773, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1378.132918178424, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1474, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 184.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5576694, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3783.3744911804615, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1474, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 5576694, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4371218, "stage_ordering_ns": 37590, "stage_eval_ns": 498517663, "stage_threat_ns": 349101007, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 85430, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 301116499, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 87850, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42711, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 37875726, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 85422, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10020932, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 66, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1078, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5308.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6308.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1851, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1063, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17886, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 128, 113, 155, 99, 85, 111, 140, 95, 143, 81, 66, 67, 53, 115, 114, 83, 51, 131 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10514, "avg_search_time_ms": 955.8181818181819, "search_nodes": 251336, "safety_nodes": 368, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 251704, "avg_nodes": 22882.18181818182, "eval_calls": 245088, "avg_eval_calls": 22280.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 245088, "pattern_eval_ns": 5315245, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.687087903120513, "pattern_frame_queries": 245088, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5315245, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.687087903120513, "pattern_frame_updates": 502610, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6376140935, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12686.060633493165, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6228, "avg_candidate_generations": 566.1818181818181, "candidate_moves_total": 439726, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.60468850353243, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 717, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 6217, "search_candidate_moves_total": 439009, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 236139, "avg_legality_checks": 21467.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "root_legality_checks": 717, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 235422, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1744465, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 158587.72727272726, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4485326029, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2571.1757065919924, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18419, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1674.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 159060251, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8635.661599435365, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 66, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 464232, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18351, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 158592359, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3660, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 184111, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8004.826086956522, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.4545454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 62721, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2323.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 629788740, "stage_ordering_ns": 221460, "stage_eval_ns": 6381456180, "stage_threat_ns": 3485953331, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 502621, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3054978096, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 248031, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 251305, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 365599583, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 502610, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65127621, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 511, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5374, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3438.3636363636365, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4165.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7359, "avg_search_time_ms": 735.9, "search_nodes": 59566, "safety_nodes": 791, "corridor_nodes": 81, "corridor_branch_probes": 92, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 19, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_plies_followed": 74, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 74, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 65, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 58, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 65, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 447, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 138880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 16720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 60438, "avg_nodes": 6043.8, "eval_calls": 40191, "avg_eval_calls": 4019.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40191, "pattern_eval_ns": 907012, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.567539996516633, "pattern_frame_queries": 40191, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 907012, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.567539996516633, "pattern_frame_updates": 119042, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1212201963, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10182.977125720334, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18166, "avg_candidate_generations": 1816.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1330591, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.2462292194209, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 647, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 18156, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1329944, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 834296, "avg_legality_checks": 83429.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 51, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 834296, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 51, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2125154, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 212515.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4761475728, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2240.5320875569487, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6167, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 616.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21719920, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3521.958813037133, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 53, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 483671, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1625, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16739081, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4489, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4497168, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 78850, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7885.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 762087724, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9665.031376030438, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110135, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11013.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 336306896, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3053.5878331139056, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2126845215, "stage_ordering_ns": 601490170, "stage_eval_ns": 1213108975, "stage_threat_ns": 3255775353, "stage_proof_ns": 119361769, "tactical_annotations": 217380, "root_tactical_annotations": 921, "search_tactical_annotations": 216459, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 119330, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 754668012, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 222608, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2385770096, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36673, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1420410251, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 59660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92362604, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 278, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1627484, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 119320, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15708122, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 53498, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 317342062, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 126233, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 643685463, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 37649, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5639035, "child_limit_applications": 18156, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18156, "child_cap_hits": 18156, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18156, "child_moves_before_total": 1329893, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1329893, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 290499, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 290499, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.24812734082397, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00016523463318, "tt_hits": 5727, "tt_cutoffs": 1174, "beta_cutoffs": 15513, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4242.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5042.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1872, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1064, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8247, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 99, 95, 113, 141, 85, 71, 157, 172, 114, 115, 128, 156, 84, 96, 94, 126, 111, 171, 186, 69, 86, 100, 87, 83, 88 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 7136, "avg_search_time_ms": 509.7142857142857, "search_nodes": 125971, "safety_nodes": 331, "corridor_nodes": 2611, "corridor_branch_probes": 3038, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1050, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 34, "corridor_plies_followed": 2574, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2574, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 125, "corridor_proof_active": 37, "corridor_proof_quiet": 88, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1050, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 125, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 120, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1001, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 28178880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1970800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 13, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 9, "total_nodes": 128913, "avg_nodes": 9208.07142857143, "eval_calls": 92884, "avg_eval_calls": 6634.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 92884, "pattern_eval_ns": 1809390, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.48010421601137, "pattern_frame_queries": 92884, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1809390, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.48010421601137, "pattern_frame_updates": 251818, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1751804466, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6956.629256050004, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31540, "avg_candidate_generations": 2252.8571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 2597867, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.36737476220672, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1015, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 31526, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2596852, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 727534, "avg_legality_checks": 51966.71428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2642, "root_legality_checks": 1015, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 726519, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2640, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3040809, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 217200.64285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3929151217, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1292.1400906798158, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31754, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2268.1428571428573, "renju_forbidden_ns": 107141803, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3374.1198904075077, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2771, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13616663, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15247, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64829243, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13056, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25828101, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 680, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2867796, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64499, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4607.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 356226975, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5522.984464875424, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89371, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6383.642857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 163437033, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1828.7479495585817, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1061497868, "stage_ordering_ns": 622682008, "stage_eval_ns": 1753613856, "stage_threat_ns": 3327960980, "stage_proof_ns": 331927569, "tactical_annotations": 429357, "root_tactical_annotations": 3086, "search_tactical_annotations": 426271, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 257230, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 952072403, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 542918, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2181725129, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64731, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1424871751, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128608, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 140059478, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5398, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22228855, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 257216, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21520959, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 122759, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 91655523, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 196357, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 408839016, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110241, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10354156, "child_limit_applications": 31526, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31526, "child_cap_hits": 31526, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31526, "child_moves_before_total": 2594212, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2594212, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 507431, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 507431, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.28801624056335, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.095635348601153, "tt_hits": 14245, "tt_cutoffs": 1499, "beta_cutoffs": 25478, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5976.357142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6547.785714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1351, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 1097, "avg_search_time_ms": 84.38461538461539, "search_nodes": 59877, "safety_nodes": 1478, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 61355, "avg_nodes": 4719.615384615385, "eval_calls": 57556, "avg_eval_calls": 4427.384615384615, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 57556, "pattern_eval_ns": 1110964, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.302314267843492, "pattern_frame_queries": 57556, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1110964, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.302314267843492, "pattern_frame_updates": 119678, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 595497779, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 4975.833311051321, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2296, "avg_candidate_generations": 176.6153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 176216, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.74912891986062, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 957, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 2283, "search_candidate_moves_total": 175259, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 6592, "avg_legality_checks": 507.0769230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6592, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 240165, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18474.23076923077, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 318991454, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1328.217908521225, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3839, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 295.3076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16782053, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4371.464704350091, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 49831, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3822, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16647662, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 84560, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11177663, "stage_ordering_ns": 69190, "stage_eval_ns": 596608743, "stage_threat_ns": 471438446, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 119691, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 405239870, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 290770, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8720, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 59839, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 56304707, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 119678, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9603099, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 85, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2109, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6379.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6995.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1065, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10538, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 126, 70, 127, 108, 109, 125, 155, 141, 97, 80, 129, 130, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4953, "avg_search_time_ms": 550.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 160286, "safety_nodes": 589, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 160875, "avg_nodes": 17875.0, "eval_calls": 155391, "avg_eval_calls": 17265.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 155391, "pattern_eval_ns": 3167672, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.38517031230895, "pattern_frame_queries": 155391, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3167672, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.38517031230895, "pattern_frame_updates": 320520, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2963326872, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9245.372744290527, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4878, "avg_candidate_generations": 542.0, "candidate_moves_total": 348666, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.47724477244772, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 607, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 4869, "search_candidate_moves_total": 348059, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 150131, "avg_legality_checks": 16681.222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 607, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 149524, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1032255, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 114695.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2005581559, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1942.9129033039317, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10006, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1111.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61184359, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6114.767039776134, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34400, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9999, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 61149959, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.5555555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 112760, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8054.285714285715, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 49170, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2731.6666666666665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 301789864, "stage_ordering_ns": 161671, "stage_eval_ns": 2966494544, "stage_threat_ns": 1656106600, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 320529, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1443124374, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 190322, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6731, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 160260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 180716688, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 320520, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32075216, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 238, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4358, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4480.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5369.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1861, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5577, "avg_search_time_ms": 619.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 51120, "safety_nodes": 586, "corridor_nodes": 547, "corridor_branch_probes": 620, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 154, "corridor_neutral_exits": 36, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 535, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 535, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 154, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 67, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 549, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 343520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 52253, "avg_nodes": 5805.888888888889, "eval_calls": 32990, "avg_eval_calls": 3665.5555555555557, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32990, "pattern_eval_ns": 690033, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.916429220976053, "pattern_frame_queries": 32990, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 690033, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.916429220976053, "pattern_frame_updates": 102166, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 699333674, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6845.072470293444, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17077, "avg_candidate_generations": 1897.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 1409356, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.52948410142297, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 638, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 17068, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1408718, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1085577, "avg_legality_checks": 120619.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1072, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1085577, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1072, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2181422, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 242380.22222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3679893148, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1686.9240101181706, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13580, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1508.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37809687, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2784.218483063328, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1090, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9704513, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1794, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16004468, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10696, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12100706, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67176, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7464.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 552666661, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8227.144530784804, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 93432, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10381.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 271674530, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2907.724655364329, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2055515182, "stage_ordering_ns": 465027677, "stage_eval_ns": 700023707, "stage_threat_ns": 2210689036, "stage_proof_ns": 98564614, "tactical_annotations": 187288, "root_tactical_annotations": 1352, "search_tactical_annotations": 185936, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 103381, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 492847429, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 225956, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1633940511, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34755, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 938275144, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51686, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 63099685, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1206, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5853283, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 103372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10654078, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 59672, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 300163424, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 90878, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 366412261, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 36738, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4294050, "child_limit_applications": 17068, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17068, "child_cap_hits": 17068, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17068, "child_moves_before_total": 1407646, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1407646, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 273088, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 273088, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.47281462385752, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 6930, "tt_cutoffs": 1025, "beta_cutoffs": 14924, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4970.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5859.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1925, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1066, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8147, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 113, 114, 126, 98, 66, 100, 110, 109, 142, 86, 72, 94, 127, 130, 146, 97, 96, 81, 141, 156, 99, 85, 155 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5918, "avg_search_time_ms": 493.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 72696, "safety_nodes": 802, "corridor_nodes": 1424, "corridor_branch_probes": 1710, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 566, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 17, "corridor_plies_followed": 1403, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1403, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 566, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 332, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23784640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 5, "total_nodes": 74922, "avg_nodes": 6243.5, "eval_calls": 53856, "avg_eval_calls": 4488.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53856, "pattern_eval_ns": 1105964, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.535576351752823, "pattern_frame_queries": 53856, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1105964, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.535576351752823, "pattern_frame_updates": 145288, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1473558838, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10142.329979076043, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17815, "avg_candidate_generations": 1484.5833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1497412, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.05343811394891, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 913, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 17803, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1496499, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 546423, "avg_legality_checks": 45535.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 909, "root_legality_checks": 913, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 545510, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 905, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1972387, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 164365.58333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3466462072, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1757.4959031873561, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22818, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1901.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 122676781, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5376.316110088526, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1270, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11032449, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9294, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 76164285, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11895, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32425277, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 359, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3054770, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50222, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4185.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 364375912, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7255.304687188881, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65816, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5484.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 159157644, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2418.2211620274707, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1016970624, "stage_ordering_ns": 492290956, "stage_eval_ns": 1474664802, "stage_threat_ns": 2685406420, "stage_proof_ns": 209101304, "tactical_annotations": 310395, "root_tactical_annotations": 1597, "search_tactical_annotations": 308798, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 148216, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 716008244, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 355681, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1840225091, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36526, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1124665568, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74102, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 89668614, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2916, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15208150, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 148204, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15146025, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 89988, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 77834880, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 141620, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 441304906, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78787, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9150296, "child_limit_applications": 17803, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17803, "child_cap_hits": 17803, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17803, "child_moves_before_total": 1495594, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1495594, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 288470, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 288470, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.00797618378925, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.203448856934223, "tt_hits": 7673, "tt_cutoffs": 985, "beta_cutoffs": 14278, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5748.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6414.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1352, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2217, "avg_search_time_ms": 201.54545454545453, "search_nodes": 90421, "safety_nodes": 1116, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91537, "avg_nodes": 8321.545454545454, "eval_calls": 87590, "avg_eval_calls": 7962.727272727273, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87590, "pattern_eval_ns": 1781464, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.33866879780797, "pattern_frame_queries": 87590, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1781464, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.33866879780797, "pattern_frame_updates": 180778, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1252129536, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6926.338027857372, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2810, "avg_candidate_generations": 255.45454545454547, "candidate_moves_total": 220912, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.61637010676156, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 844, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 2799, "search_candidate_moves_total": 220068, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 6634, "avg_legality_checks": 603.0909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6634, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 374423, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 34038.454545454544, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 707317458, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1889.0865625242038, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4607, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 418.8181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37223661, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8079.804862166268, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 112451, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4577, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 36861719, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 249491, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13573353, "stage_ordering_ns": 92230, "stage_eval_ns": 1253911000, "stage_threat_ns": 922332719, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 180789, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 804271490, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 228611, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9680, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 90389, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99833644, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 180778, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17998974, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 129, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2573, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5977.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6705.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1067, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12619, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 128, 144, 80, 99, 129, 113, 96, 64, 141, 54, 94, 85, 71, 69, 84, 95, 52, 67, 66, 38, 108 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 3920, "avg_search_time_ms": 326.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 94579, "safety_nodes": 638, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 95217, "avg_nodes": 7934.75, "eval_calls": 91028, "avg_eval_calls": 7585.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 91028, "pattern_eval_ns": 1965830, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.595882585578064, "pattern_frame_queries": 91028, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1965830, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.595882585578064, "pattern_frame_updates": 189090, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2445193204, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12931.372383521075, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3529, "avg_candidate_generations": 294.0833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 282661, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.09662793992632, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 860, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 3517, "search_candidate_moves_total": 281801, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 84729, "avg_legality_checks": 7060.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 41, "root_legality_checks": 860, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 83869, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 41, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 732260, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 61021.666666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1780525067, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2431.5476292573676, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17415, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1451.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 145338737, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8345.606488659201, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 432633, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17365, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 144906104, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.0833333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 242620, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9704.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 32, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.6666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 106440, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3326.25, "stage_move_gen_ns": 206789743, "stage_ordering_ns": 138421, "stage_eval_ns": 2447159034, "stage_threat_ns": 1238134468, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 189102, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1083716099, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 354071, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12591, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 94545, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 131227359, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 189090, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22836939, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 423, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2973, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6141.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6807.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1850, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8687, "avg_search_time_ms": 789.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 66251, "safety_nodes": 846, "corridor_nodes": 338, "corridor_branch_probes": 396, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 110, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 325, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 325, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 82, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 110, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 82, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 82, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 597, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 339120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67435, "avg_nodes": 6130.454545454545, "eval_calls": 44620, "avg_eval_calls": 4056.3636363636365, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44620, "pattern_eval_ns": 989925, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.185679067682653, "pattern_frame_queries": 44620, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 989925, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.185679067682653, "pattern_frame_updates": 132402, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1395290055, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10538.28533556895, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20416, "avg_candidate_generations": 1856.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1604597, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.59507249216301, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 20405, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1603811, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1082574, "avg_legality_checks": 98415.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3615, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1082574, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3615, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2559924, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 232720.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5640991667, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2203.5777886374754, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18565, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1687.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 135617680, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7305.0191220037705, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3689, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 41902321, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6189, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64138423, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8650, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29111695, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 465241, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89209, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8109.909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 917741219, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10287.540707776121, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 125669, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11424.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 439487126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3497.1801001042422, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2764663534, "stage_ordering_ns": 689760403, "stage_eval_ns": 1396279980, "stage_threat_ns": 3629039231, "stage_proof_ns": 148907560, "tactical_annotations": 309977, "root_tactical_annotations": 1296, "search_tactical_annotations": 308681, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 133227, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 817537884, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 302622, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2680775400, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41368, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1494997755, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66608, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99284062, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 814, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4735606, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 133216, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17074207, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 73687, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 382548851, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 164211, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 786135750, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 72079, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9632072, "child_limit_applications": 20405, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20405, "child_cap_hits": 20405, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20405, "child_moves_before_total": 1600196, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1600196, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 326544, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 326544, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.42175937270277, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.003136486155356, "tt_hits": 7970, "tt_cutoffs": 1176, "beta_cutoffs": 17492, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4514.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5242.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1839, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1068, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11248, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 67, 82, 98, 96, 68, 111, 141, 110, 66, 69, 113, 124, 138, 128, 65, 64, 81, 129, 49 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8898, "avg_search_time_ms": 889.8, "search_nodes": 95458, "safety_nodes": 255, "corridor_nodes": 1068, "corridor_branch_probes": 1238, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 455, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 25, "corridor_plies_followed": 1058, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1058, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 455, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 416, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 409920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 21520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 96781, "avg_nodes": 9678.1, "eval_calls": 71163, "avg_eval_calls": 7116.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71163, "pattern_eval_ns": 1548061, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.75373438444135, "pattern_frame_queries": 71163, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1548061, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.75373438444135, "pattern_frame_updates": 190832, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2274711097, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11919.966761339818, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22902, "avg_candidate_generations": 2290.2, "candidate_moves_total": 1656263, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.31957907606322, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 639, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 22892, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1655624, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 648346, "avg_legality_checks": 64834.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1356, "root_legality_checks": 639, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 647707, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1356, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2294628, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 229462.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5273847390, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2298.345261192664, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18246, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1824.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 123685198, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6778.756878219884, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1418, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14454938, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8872, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 79025156, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7760, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29245709, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 196, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 959395, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49202, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4920.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 464960920, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9450.041055241656, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68640, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6864.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 204927341, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2985.5381847319345, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1680553009, "stage_ordering_ns": 716865779, "stage_eval_ns": 2276259158, "stage_threat_ns": 3960293539, "stage_proof_ns": 219529332, "tactical_annotations": 292107, "root_tactical_annotations": 1872, "search_tactical_annotations": 290235, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 193066, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1177472560, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 330455, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2595266470, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46491, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1775876742, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 96528, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 142775153, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2224, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13324835, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 193056, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24468687, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 72250, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 65873342, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 149997, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 596301057, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 69860, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6985834, "child_limit_applications": 22892, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22892, "child_cap_hits": 22892, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22892, "child_moves_before_total": 1654268, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1654268, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 367759, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 367759, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.26402236589202, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.064957190284815, "tt_hits": 8757, "tt_cutoffs": 1361, "beta_cutoffs": 18391, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 4.1, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 4.1, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3240.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4040.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2341, "avg_search_time_ms": 260.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 69430, "safety_nodes": 659, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 70089, "avg_nodes": 7787.666666666667, "eval_calls": 66872, "avg_eval_calls": 7430.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 66872, "pattern_eval_ns": 1438052, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.50454599832516, "pattern_frame_queries": 66872, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1438052, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.50454599832516, "pattern_frame_updates": 138808, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1378843658, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9933.45958446199, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2541, "avg_candidate_generations": 282.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 179363, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.58756395120031, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 2532, "search_candidate_moves_total": 178783, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 4869, "avg_legality_checks": 541.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4869, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 369735, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 41081.666666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 879335774, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2378.2865403599876, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3544, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 393.77777777777777, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33556843, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9468.635158013543, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3544, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33556843, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13404437, "stage_ordering_ns": 91330, "stage_eval_ns": 1380281710, "stage_threat_ns": 928587818, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 138817, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 815052292, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 141351, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10220, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 69404, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96186938, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 138808, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17207237, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 182, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2239, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5450.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6339.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1948, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1069, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18333, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 114, 111, 126, 98, 154, 97, 115, 116, 99, 95, 94, 83, 69, 139, 125, 84, 140, 168, 155, 170, 127, 141, 128, 124, 129 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 10926, "avg_search_time_ms": 840.4615384615385, "search_nodes": 250086, "safety_nodes": 662, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 250748, "avg_nodes": 19288.30769230769, "eval_calls": 243908, "avg_eval_calls": 18762.153846153848, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 243908, "pattern_eval_ns": 5265324, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.587336208734442, "pattern_frame_queries": 243908, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5265324, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.587336208734442, "pattern_frame_updates": 500098, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6877968724, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13753.241812604729, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6154, "avg_candidate_generations": 473.38461538461536, "candidate_moves_total": 488395, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.36220344491387, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 949, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 6141, "search_candidate_moves_total": 487446, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 240271, "avg_legality_checks": 18482.384615384617, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1199, "root_legality_checks": 949, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 239322, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1197, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1900908, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 146223.6923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4745211517, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2496.2867834740027, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47517, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3655.153846153846, "renju_forbidden_ns": 482761800, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10159.770187511838, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1211, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12787466, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 46296, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 469858883, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 115451, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.1538461538461537, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 134891, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8992.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.4615384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 51590, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2715.2631578947367, "stage_move_gen_ns": 631472231, "stage_ordering_ns": 215391, "stage_eval_ns": 6883234048, "stage_threat_ns": 3385351892, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 500111, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2958162249, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 263081, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13590, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 250049, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 363840290, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 500098, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63086272, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 484, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5309, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 2.769230769230769, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 2.769230769230769, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5316.307692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5931.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1772, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7396, "avg_search_time_ms": 616.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 51752, "safety_nodes": 925, "corridor_nodes": 668, "corridor_branch_probes": 798, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 204, "corridor_neutral_exits": 31, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 656, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 656, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 52, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 31, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 204, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 62, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 438, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 302560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 53345, "avg_nodes": 4445.416666666667, "eval_calls": 33583, "avg_eval_calls": 2798.5833333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33583, "pattern_eval_ns": 747834, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.268230950183128, "pattern_frame_queries": 33583, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 747834, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.268230950183128, "pattern_frame_updates": 103394, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1032374565, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9984.859517960424, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17026, "avg_candidate_generations": 1418.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1366922, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.28438858216845, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 888, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 17014, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1366034, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 952464, "avg_legality_checks": 79372.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 228, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 952464, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 228, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2232119, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 186009.91666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4894913598, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2192.944730097275, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7945, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 662.0833333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30376034, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3823.289364380113, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 232, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2260278, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2248, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21142724, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5447, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6755950, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 217082, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81139, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6761.583333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 832370496, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10258.57474210922, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 115732, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9644.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 406283641, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3510.555775412159, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2393117479, "stage_ordering_ns": 604858650, "stage_eval_ns": 1033122399, "stage_threat_ns": 3202823142, "stage_proof_ns": 112287226, "tactical_annotations": 247237, "root_tactical_annotations": 1371, "search_tactical_annotations": 245866, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 104846, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 676201172, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 279570, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2415796230, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34697, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1354098772, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52417, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 82809310, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1440, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8396413, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 104834, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13774838, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71236, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 404719454, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 125869, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 618348285, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 50132, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5845179, "child_limit_applications": 17014, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17014, "child_cap_hits": 17014, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17014, "child_moves_before_total": 1365806, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1365806, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 272251, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 272251, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.27542024215352, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001586928411896, "tt_hits": 7126, "tt_cutoffs": 1100, "beta_cutoffs": 14833, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5202.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5869.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1870, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1070, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10096, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 124, 82, 114, 98, 140, 83, 128, 84, 70, 85, 86, 81 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5728, "avg_search_time_ms": 716.0, "search_nodes": 59746, "safety_nodes": 448, "corridor_nodes": 908, "corridor_branch_probes": 1059, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 398, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 891, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 891, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 398, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 57, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 440, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23840000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 61102, "avg_nodes": 7637.75, "eval_calls": 45250, "avg_eval_calls": 5656.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 45250, "pattern_eval_ns": 985741, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.784331491712706, "pattern_frame_queries": 45250, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 985741, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.784331491712706, "pattern_frame_updates": 119428, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1400029388, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11722.79019995311, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13786, "avg_candidate_generations": 1723.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1006831, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.03285942260264, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 489, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 13778, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1006342, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 377439, "avg_legality_checks": 47179.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 783, "root_legality_checks": 489, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 376950, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 780, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1453031, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 181628.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3392100152, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2334.4995062046164, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11355, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1419.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 87224713, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7681.612769704976, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 805, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8863805, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5143, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 52953761, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4909, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20524074, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 498, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4883073, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 34274, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4284.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 356823053, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10410.896102001518, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 47332, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5916.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 166634657, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3520.549670413251, "stage_move_gen_ns": 996178256, "stage_ordering_ns": 460698818, "stage_eval_ns": 1401015129, "stage_threat_ns": 2626393299, "stage_proof_ns": 216043323, "tactical_annotations": 151302, "root_tactical_annotations": 1164, "search_tactical_annotations": 150138, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 121336, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 749484177, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 197047, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1755703230, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28196, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1155962302, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 60664, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91686734, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1900, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10431273, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 121328, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15366277, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 38136, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 68244007, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 77851, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 380820215, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 35315, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3721608, "child_limit_applications": 13778, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13778, "child_cap_hits": 13778, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13778, "child_moves_before_total": 1005562, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1005562, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 220701, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 220701, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.9831615619103, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.018362607054726, "tt_hits": 5635, "tt_cutoffs": 686, "beta_cutoffs": 10818, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3325.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4325.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 845, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 4363, "avg_search_time_ms": 623.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 124619, "safety_nodes": 476, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 125095, "avg_nodes": 17870.714285714286, "eval_calls": 121700, "avg_eval_calls": 17385.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 121700, "pattern_eval_ns": 2672747, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.96176663927691, "pattern_frame_queries": 121700, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2672747, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.96176663927691, "pattern_frame_updates": 249198, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2611101771, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10478.020574001397, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2906, "avg_candidate_generations": 415.14285714285717, "candidate_moves_total": 202972, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.84583620096352, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 418, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 2899, "search_candidate_moves_total": 202554, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 5113, "avg_legality_checks": 730.4285714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5113, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 592193, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 84599.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1493926613, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2522.7022490978447, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11645, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1663.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124063355, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10653.787462430228, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 85770, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11622, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 123796064, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 181521, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15275046, "stage_ordering_ns": 97811, "stage_eval_ns": 2613774518, "stage_threat_ns": 1719470875, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 249205, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1510616221, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 150311, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7640, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124599, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 176416276, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 249198, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32288067, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 119, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2537, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3648.285714285714, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4791.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1956, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1071, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18515, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 142, 97, 98, 126, 70, 111, 157, 172, 141, 81, 66, 125, 139, 69, 83, 140, 85, 84, 113, 99, 129, 54 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8921, "avg_search_time_ms": 811.0, "search_nodes": 210619, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 211432, "avg_nodes": 19221.090909090908, "eval_calls": 205259, "avg_eval_calls": 18659.909090909092, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 205259, "pattern_eval_ns": 4423368, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.550178067709577, "pattern_frame_queries": 205259, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4423368, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.550178067709577, "pattern_frame_updates": 421174, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5455057636, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12952.028463295455, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5339, "avg_candidate_generations": 485.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 392498, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.51526503090466, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 755, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 5328, "search_candidate_moves_total": 391743, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 201719, "avg_legality_checks": 18338.090909090908, "illegal_moves_skipped": 194, "root_legality_checks": 755, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 200964, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 193, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1483840, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 134894.54545454544, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3766779193, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2538.5346081787793, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22920, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2083.6363636363635, "renju_forbidden_ns": 210710226, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9193.290837696335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 196, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1772917, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22715, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 208876159, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61150, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.272727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 254752, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10190.08, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.1818181818181817, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 117692, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3362.6285714285714, "stage_move_gen_ns": 534279659, "stage_ordering_ns": 182540, "stage_eval_ns": 5459481004, "stage_threat_ns": 2899259825, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 421185, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2543128368, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 400662, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 210587, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 301613025, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 421174, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 54117770, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 245, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4763, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4075.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4803.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 125, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9584, "avg_search_time_ms": 871.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 62977, "safety_nodes": 652, "corridor_nodes": 1029, "corridor_branch_probes": 1196, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 343, "corridor_neutral_exits": 32, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 1014, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1014, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 68, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 343, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 81, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 609, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 398800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 13, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 9, "total_nodes": 64658, "avg_nodes": 5878.0, "eval_calls": 40376, "avg_eval_calls": 3670.5454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40376, "pattern_eval_ns": 898304, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.248464434317416, "pattern_frame_queries": 40376, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 898304, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.248464434317416, "pattern_frame_updates": 125860, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1201203210, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9543.963213093914, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21294, "avg_candidate_generations": 1935.8181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 1769281, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.08824081901005, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 783, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 21283, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1768498, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1322459, "avg_legality_checks": 120223.54545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1155, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1322459, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1155, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2967218, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 269747.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6390456088, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2153.6860749698876, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25591, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2326.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 68340759, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2670.4997460044547, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1170, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12106018, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2746, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25510672, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21657, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30530278, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 193791, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 120576, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10961.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1244270198, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10319.385267383228, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 173148, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15740.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 616647746, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3561.3910989442556, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3311386564, "stage_ordering_ns": 765055905, "stage_eval_ns": 1202101514, "stage_threat_ns": 4101099069, "stage_proof_ns": 142866940, "tactical_annotations": 351823, "root_tactical_annotations": 1757, "search_tactical_annotations": 350066, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 128065, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 814527393, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 393504, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3147583975, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43473, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1597806401, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64027, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99737172, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2194, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13974762, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128054, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16728100, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 123091, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 668816616, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 157778, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 824301945, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 70954, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8547667, "child_limit_applications": 21283, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21283, "child_cap_hits": 21283, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21283, "child_moves_before_total": 1767343, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1767343, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 341221, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 341221, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.04012592209745, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.032561199079076, "tt_hits": 8968, "tt_cutoffs": 1271, "beta_cutoffs": 18665, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4805.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5532.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1845, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1072, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 31503, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 82, 97, 98, 95, 84, 126, 81, 83, 111, 94, 93, 110, 142, 80, 125, 66, 157, 172, 108, 65, 50, 64, 63, 78, 62, 109, 79, 70, 52, 48, 32, 124, 68, 138, 152, 100, 47, 77, 51, 53, 31, 15, 33, 34, 19, 61, 17, 2, 20, 36, 18, 21, 16 ], "move_count": 57, "black_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 20269, "avg_search_time_ms": 750.7037037037037, "search_nodes": 243298, "safety_nodes": 1402, "corridor_nodes": 4461, "corridor_branch_probes": 4842, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1804, "corridor_neutral_exits": 96, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 4409, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4409, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 24, "corridor_proof_completed": 24, "corridor_proof_checks": 201, "corridor_proof_active": 52, "corridor_proof_quiet": 149, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 96, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1804, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 201, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 198, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1477, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 1003360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 249161, "avg_nodes": 9228.185185185184, "eval_calls": 166398, "avg_eval_calls": 6162.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 166398, "pattern_eval_ns": 3501572, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.04335388646498, "pattern_frame_queries": 166398, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3501572, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.04335388646498, "pattern_frame_updates": 486342, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4361907258, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8968.806432510455, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 72729, "avg_candidate_generations": 2693.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 6967088, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.79518486435947, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2282, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 72702, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6964806, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 2011140, "avg_legality_checks": 74486.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 170, "root_legality_checks": 2282, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2008858, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 170, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6204057, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 229779.88888888888, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11597627753, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1869.3618954500257, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45703, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1692.7037037037037, "renju_forbidden_ns": 98972596, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2165.560160164541, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 792, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2689361, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14647, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 54043886, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29285, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40578598, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 979, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1660751, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 135726, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5026.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 946167277, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6971.157162223893, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 180375, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6680.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 406032783, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2251.048, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4147735822, "stage_ordering_ns": 2202373760, "stage_eval_ns": 4365408830, "stage_threat_ns": 8732942759, "stage_proof_ns": 691304265, "tactical_annotations": 1380926, "root_tactical_annotations": 6345, "search_tactical_annotations": 1374581, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 495589, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2574680699, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1485560, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5668250545, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 148643, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3707306447, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 247781, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 339110512, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9220, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 59981773, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 495562, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55113607, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 555232, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 280457975, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 537675, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1301064581, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 288019, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 35805623, "child_limit_applications": 72702, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 72702, "child_cap_hits": 72702, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 72702, "child_moves_before_total": 6964636, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6964636, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 1163610, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1163610, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.79703446947815, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0051993067591, "tt_hits": 31813, "tt_cutoffs": 4071, "beta_cutoffs": 62051, "depth_sum": 126, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 126, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 24 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.037037037037037035, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.037037037037037035, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.037037037037037035, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6293.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6590.074074074074, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 28, "search_move_count": 26, "total_time_ms": 11208, "avg_search_time_ms": 431.0769230769231, "search_nodes": 478661, "safety_nodes": 2253, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 480914, "avg_nodes": 18496.69230769231, "eval_calls": 465810, "avg_eval_calls": 17915.76923076923, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 465810, "pattern_eval_ns": 9446273, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.27924046284966, "pattern_frame_queries": 465810, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 9446273, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.27924046284966, "pattern_frame_updates": 957168, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6109929458, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6383.340707169484, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12800, "avg_candidate_generations": 492.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 1217721, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.134453125, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 26, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2214, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 12774, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1215507, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 30517, "avg_legality_checks": 1173.7307692307693, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 30517, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2165180, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 83276.15384615384, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3767849517, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1740.2015153474538, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4041, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 155.42307692307693, "renju_forbidden_ns": 22879376, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5661.810442959663, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4041, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22879376, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 67228199, "stage_ordering_ns": 428622, "stage_eval_ns": 6119375731, "stage_threat_ns": 4910678154, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 957194, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4263157668, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 73, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 428373, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 23890, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 478584, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 550170058, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 957168, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 96922055, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 881, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 11355, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 2.9615384615384617, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9615384615384617, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 25 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 26, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.038461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7058.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7365.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1945, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1073, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29975, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 126, 98, 154, 143, 113, 111, 52, 67, 95, 129, 140, 168, 81, 157, 115, 159, 175, 158, 65, 49, 156, 114, 144, 100, 86, 131, 130, 173, 188, 145, 187, 117 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 7609, "avg_search_time_ms": 447.5882352941176, "search_nodes": 209298, "safety_nodes": 1827, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 211125, "avg_nodes": 12419.117647058823, "eval_calls": 203450, "avg_eval_calls": 11967.64705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 203450, "pattern_eval_ns": 4071143, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.01053330056525, "pattern_frame_queries": 203450, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4071143, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.01053330056525, "pattern_frame_updates": 418496, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4706071849, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11245.201504912831, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5815, "avg_candidate_generations": 342.05882352941177, "candidate_moves_total": 506949, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.17953568357696, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 5798, "search_candidate_moves_total": 505502, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 192734, "avg_legality_checks": 11337.29411764706, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 1447, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 191287, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1621463, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 95380.17647058824, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3472628717, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2141.6638659038167, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9317, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 548.0588235294117, "renju_forbidden_ns": 80528974, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8643.230009659761, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9910, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9316, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 80519064, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.176470588235294, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 518930, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9609.814814814816, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.235294117647059, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 244870, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3400.972222222222, "stage_move_gen_ns": 421647016, "stage_ordering_ns": 193600, "stage_eval_ns": 4710142992, "stage_threat_ns": 2431759475, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 418513, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2130253071, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 47, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 796400, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17700, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 209248, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 254577895, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 418496, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46132109, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 308, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5284, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6531.529411764706, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7002.117647058823, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1818, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 22348, "avg_search_time_ms": 1314.5882352941176, "search_nodes": 181903, "safety_nodes": 696, "corridor_nodes": 7473, "corridor_branch_probes": 7870, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4087, "corridor_neutral_exits": 53, "corridor_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_plies_followed": 7444, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 7444, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 110, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 81, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 53, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4087, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 110, "corridor_proof_wins": 6, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 837, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2583520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1972240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 10, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 190072, "avg_nodes": 11180.70588235294, "eval_calls": 129948, "avg_eval_calls": 7644.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 129948, "pattern_eval_ns": 2776078, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.36299135038631, "pattern_frame_queries": 129948, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2776078, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.36299135038631, "pattern_frame_updates": 363652, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3354199748, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9223.652689934333, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49083, "avg_candidate_generations": 2887.235294117647, "candidate_moves_total": 4966779, "avg_candidate_moves": 101.1914308416356, "candidate_moves_max": 134, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1494, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 49066, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4965285, "search_candidate_moves_max": 134, "legality_checks": 3590740, "avg_legality_checks": 211220.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3590740, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7055374, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 415022.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14535116711, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2060.148294193901, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28147, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1655.7058823529412, "renju_forbidden_ns": 40711005, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1446.3710164493552, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 91, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 366391, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1265, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9016908, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26791, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31327706, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 202237, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11896.29411764706, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1931830343, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9552.309137299308, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 282927, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16642.764705882353, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 947942486, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3350.4843510870296, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8218347171, "stage_ordering_ns": 1817455796, "stage_eval_ns": 3356975826, "stage_threat_ns": 8709176597, "stage_proof_ns": 162662831, "tactical_annotations": 1072345, "root_tactical_annotations": 4836, "search_tactical_annotations": 1067509, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 378777, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2294466277, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1254455, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5952780007, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 101799, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3183795369, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 189380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 281342945, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 15108, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 100536622, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 378760, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46834200, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 427043, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1142490362, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 398402, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1400388767, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 246900, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33216546, "child_limit_applications": 49066, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49066, "child_cap_hits": 49066, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49066, "child_moves_before_total": 4965272, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4965272, "child_moves_before_max": 134, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 134, "child_moves_after_total": 786221, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 786221, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 101.1957771165369, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.023743529124037, "tt_hits": 23218, "tt_cutoffs": 2812, "beta_cutoffs": 40605, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.29411764705882354, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5636.058823529412, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6106.64705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1843, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1074, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11429, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 67, 82, 96, 98, 66, 113, 143, 114, 68, 65, 111, 130, 146, 126, 69, 70, 83, 125, 55 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9009, "avg_search_time_ms": 900.9, "search_nodes": 95078, "safety_nodes": 255, "corridor_nodes": 880, "corridor_branch_probes": 1017, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 357, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 26, "corridor_plies_followed": 870, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 870, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 357, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 416, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 479440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 26080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 96213, "avg_nodes": 9621.3, "eval_calls": 70740, "avg_eval_calls": 7074.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70740, "pattern_eval_ns": 1533283, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.67490811422109, "pattern_frame_queries": 70740, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1533283, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.67490811422109, "pattern_frame_updates": 190072, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2275892472, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11973.84397491477, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22938, "avg_candidate_generations": 2293.8, "candidate_moves_total": 1661174, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.4201761269509, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 639, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 22928, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1660535, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 686247, "avg_legality_checks": 68624.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1376, "root_legality_checks": 639, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 685608, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1376, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2312059, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 231205.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5376452612, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2325.395940155506, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18623, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1862.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124157054, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6666.866455458305, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1435, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15180594, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8597, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 77631170, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8383, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30347927, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 208, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 997363, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51410, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5141.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 489051438, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9512.768683135577, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 71271, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7127.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 213027219, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2988.9747442858948, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1798491003, "stage_ordering_ns": 727469682, "stage_eval_ns": 2277425755, "stage_threat_ns": 3958686353, "stage_proof_ns": 204957331, "tactical_annotations": 286154, "root_tactical_annotations": 1872, "search_tactical_annotations": 284282, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 191930, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1173340166, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 321449, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2599545786, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46486, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1768397922, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 95960, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 140696943, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1848, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11795187, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 191920, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26512208, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71240, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 71542988, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 150520, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 623810414, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 64394, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6796063, "child_limit_applications": 22928, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22928, "child_cap_hits": 22928, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22928, "child_moves_before_total": 1659159, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1659159, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 368525, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 368525, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.36387822749477, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.073142009769715, "tt_hits": 8665, "tt_cutoffs": 1368, "beta_cutoffs": 18416, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 4.1, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 4.1, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3142.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3942.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2411, "avg_search_time_ms": 267.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 69720, "safety_nodes": 659, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 70379, "avg_nodes": 7819.888888888889, "eval_calls": 67181, "avg_eval_calls": 7464.555555555556, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67181, "pattern_eval_ns": 1448746, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.564817433500544, "pattern_frame_queries": 67181, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1448746, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.564817433500544, "pattern_frame_updates": 139388, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1438599067, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10320.82436795133, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2522, "avg_candidate_generations": 280.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 178037, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.59357652656622, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 2513, "search_candidate_moves_total": 177457, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 4631, "avg_legality_checks": 514.5555555555555, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4631, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 385128, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 42792.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 933334075, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2423.4386359859577, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3527, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 391.8888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33553195, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9513.23929685285, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3527, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33553195, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12926688, "stage_ordering_ns": 88230, "stage_eval_ns": 1440047813, "stage_threat_ns": 938042321, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 139397, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 824216395, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 140551, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10200, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 69694, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96109907, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 139388, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17575468, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 182, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2214, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5464.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6353.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1945, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1075, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12205, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 128, 64, 127, 115, 116, 129, 125, 124, 143, 159, 79, 95, 144, 65, 80, 97, 81, 83, 78 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5595, "avg_search_time_ms": 508.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 153980, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 154793, "avg_nodes": 14072.09090909091, "eval_calls": 149213, "avg_eval_calls": 13564.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 149213, "pattern_eval_ns": 3090387, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.71124499876016, "pattern_frame_queries": 149213, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3090387, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.71124499876016, "pattern_frame_updates": 307896, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3363678252, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10924.722152934757, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4746, "avg_candidate_generations": 431.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 335712, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.73577749683945, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 755, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 4735, "search_candidate_moves_total": 334957, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 144641, "avg_legality_checks": 13149.181818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 179, "root_legality_checks": 755, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 143886, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 178, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1066495, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 96954.09090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2303516222, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2159.894066076259, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14787, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1344.2727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 93762878, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6340.899303442213, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 179, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 935562, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14599, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 92796486, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 30830, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.272727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 164422, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6576.88, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.1818181818181817, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 76172, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2176.342857142857, "stage_move_gen_ns": 336396225, "stage_ordering_ns": 159040, "stage_eval_ns": 3366768639, "stage_threat_ns": 1864231037, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 307907, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1634089305, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 265792, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 153948, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 194851767, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 307896, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35024173, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 245, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4243, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4824.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5551.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1587, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6600, "avg_search_time_ms": 600.0, "search_nodes": 63013, "safety_nodes": 652, "corridor_nodes": 920, "corridor_branch_probes": 1081, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 282, "corridor_neutral_exits": 41, "corridor_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_plies_followed": 905, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 905, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 68, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 43, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 282, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 81, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 609, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 435680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 13, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 9, "total_nodes": 64585, "avg_nodes": 5871.363636363636, "eval_calls": 40310, "avg_eval_calls": 3664.5454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40310, "pattern_eval_ns": 820775, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.361572810716943, "pattern_frame_queries": 40310, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 820775, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.361572810716943, "pattern_frame_updates": 125932, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 866400909, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6879.910658132961, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21334, "avg_candidate_generations": 1939.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 1764821, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.72339926877285, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 783, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 21323, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1764038, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1323739, "avg_legality_checks": 120339.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1144, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1323739, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1144, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2961003, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 269182.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4307645006, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1454.7925165898178, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26019, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2365.3636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 41837310, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1607.9522656520235, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1184, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6263192, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3222, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16731617, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21595, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18741159, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 101342, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 120196, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10926.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 768903751, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6397.082689939765, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 172394, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15672.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 380977121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2209.921000730884, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2278806428, "stage_ordering_ns": 519066318, "stage_eval_ns": 867221684, "stage_threat_ns": 2772182958, "stage_proof_ns": 99810673, "tactical_annotations": 351349, "root_tactical_annotations": 1757, "search_tactical_annotations": 349592, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 127919, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 594057402, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 387033, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2072026148, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43515, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1108412042, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 63954, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 79519957, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1976, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7498716, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 127908, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12482103, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 123405, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 414047045, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 156320, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 517650554, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 71624, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6598632, "child_limit_applications": 21323, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21323, "child_cap_hits": 21323, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21323, "child_moves_before_total": 1762894, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1762894, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 341889, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 341889, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.67570229329831, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.033813253294564, "tt_hits": 9072, "tt_cutoffs": 1333, "beta_cutoffs": 18702, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5268.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5995.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1855, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1076, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4372, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 96, 94, 142, 114, 128, 80, 143, 98, 144, 160, 145, 146, 141 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 3643, "avg_search_time_ms": 455.375, "search_nodes": 64202, "safety_nodes": 448, "corridor_nodes": 916, "corridor_branch_probes": 1092, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 366, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 898, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 898, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 60, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 366, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 60, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 447, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23854880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 7, "total_nodes": 65566, "avg_nodes": 8195.75, "eval_calls": 48366, "avg_eval_calls": 6045.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48366, "pattern_eval_ns": 936042, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.353306041434067, "pattern_frame_queries": 48366, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 936042, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.353306041434067, "pattern_frame_updates": 128340, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 890206050, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6936.310191678354, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15171, "avg_candidate_generations": 1896.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1129124, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.42647155757696, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 489, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 15163, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1128635, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 390293, "avg_legality_checks": 48786.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 635, "root_legality_checks": 489, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 389804, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 632, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1489851, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 186231.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2071651118, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1390.5089287452236, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10757, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1344.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 55144150, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5126.3502835363015, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 651, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4615347, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4706, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32702738, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4870, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13414158, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 530, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4411907, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 33022, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4127.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 203580045, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6164.982284537581, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 45798, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5724.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 95931268, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2094.660640202629, "stage_move_gen_ns": 594219617, "stage_ordering_ns": 297597306, "stage_eval_ns": 891142092, "stage_threat_ns": 1678438919, "stage_proof_ns": 149729705, "tactical_annotations": 167585, "root_tactical_annotations": 1164, "search_tactical_annotations": 166421, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 130264, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 482288591, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 219272, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1109350377, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30984, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 725103735, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 65128, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 63994970, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1916, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8166062, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 130256, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10650157, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 41701, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 41681200, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 89548, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 225491323, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 36336, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3988762, "child_limit_applications": 15163, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15163, "child_cap_hits": 15163, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15163, "child_moves_before_total": 1128003, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1128003, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 242695, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 242695, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.39180900877135, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00573765086065, "tt_hits": 5669, "tt_cutoffs": 641, "beta_cutoffs": 12002, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4459.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5459.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1379, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 721, "avg_search_time_ms": 103.0, "search_nodes": 35686, "safety_nodes": 476, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 36162, "avg_nodes": 5166.0, "eval_calls": 33872, "avg_eval_calls": 4838.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33872, "pattern_eval_ns": 654811, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.331926074633916, "pattern_frame_queries": 33872, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 654811, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.331926074633916, "pattern_frame_updates": 71332, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 394958462, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5536.9043626983685, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1801, "avg_candidate_generations": 257.2857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 123911, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.80122154358689, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 418, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 1794, "search_candidate_moves_total": 123493, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 4161, "avg_legality_checks": 594.4285714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4161, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 144927, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20703.85714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 222183044, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1533.068675954101, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1242, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 177.42857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9576591, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7710.62077294686, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 68760, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1220, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9325841, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 181990, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7548206, "stage_ordering_ns": 59990, "stage_eval_ns": 395613273, "stage_threat_ns": 301604667, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 71339, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 262106000, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 105110, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5600, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35666, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 33452207, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 71332, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5941350, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 119, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1572, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4944.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6086.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1982, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1077, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16780, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 96, 160, 97, 108, 109, 95, 129, 145, 127, 130, 99, 100, 115, 144, 176, 85, 157, 143, 141, 155, 125, 173, 93 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7075, "avg_search_time_ms": 544.2307692307693, "search_nodes": 178022, "safety_nodes": 1100, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 179122, "avg_nodes": 13778.615384615385, "eval_calls": 173048, "avg_eval_calls": 13311.384615384615, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 173048, "pattern_eval_ns": 3522612, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.356271092413664, "pattern_frame_queries": 173048, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3522612, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.356271092413664, "pattern_frame_updates": 355968, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4316060213, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12124.854517821826, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4949, "avg_candidate_generations": 380.6923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 354620, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.65487977369166, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 891, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 4936, "search_candidate_moves_total": 353729, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 170058, "avg_legality_checks": 13081.384615384615, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 891, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 169167, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1272489, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 97883.76923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3012733214, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2367.590772100977, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14926, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1148.1538461538462, "renju_forbidden_ns": 145506799, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9748.54609406405, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 32420, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14921, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 145474379, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.6923076923076925, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 453952, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9457.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.076923076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 217170, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3290.4545454545455, "stage_move_gen_ns": 421041710, "stage_ordering_ns": 159291, "stage_eval_ns": 4319582825, "stage_threat_ns": 2311762091, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 355981, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2025548961, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 661082, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13670, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 177984, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 242395185, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 355968, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43156863, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 245, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4431, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5628.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6244.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1815, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 9693, "avg_search_time_ms": 745.6153846153846, "search_nodes": 72001, "safety_nodes": 535, "corridor_nodes": 1812, "corridor_branch_probes": 2062, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 704, "corridor_neutral_exits": 31, "corridor_terminal_exits": 29, "corridor_plies_followed": 1792, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1792, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 78, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 58, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 35, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 704, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 29, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 78, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 76, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 575, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 417680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 74348, "avg_nodes": 5719.076923076923, "eval_calls": 47600, "avg_eval_calls": 3661.5384615384614, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47600, "pattern_eval_ns": 1007602, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.16810924369748, "pattern_frame_queries": 47600, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1007602, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.16810924369748, "pattern_frame_updates": 143888, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1249248045, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8682.086379684199, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23185, "avg_candidate_generations": 1783.4615384615386, "candidate_moves_total": 1918324, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.73987491912875, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 925, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 23172, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1917399, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1419502, "avg_legality_checks": 109192.46153846153, "illegal_moves_skipped": 38, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1419502, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 38, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3171061, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 243927.76923076922, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6424216987, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2025.888807247795, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7741, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 595.4615384615385, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13390683, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1729.838909701589, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 390013, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 926, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8971275, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6777, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4029395, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 118734, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9133.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1167856579, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9835.90697694005, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 173330, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13333.076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 597278040, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3445.9011134829516, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3299927763, "stage_ordering_ns": 771169794, "stage_eval_ns": 1250255647, "stage_threat_ns": 4189346818, "stage_proof_ns": 121726720, "tactical_annotations": 381228, "root_tactical_annotations": 2233, "search_tactical_annotations": 378995, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 147641, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 885311014, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 448332, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3146186675, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47571, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1656581324, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 73814, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107051781, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3740, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22976165, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 147628, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18113611, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 130361, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 600001508, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 160847, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 808513385, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 90020, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9707572, "child_limit_applications": 23172, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23172, "child_cap_hits": 23172, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23172, "child_moves_before_total": 1917361, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1917361, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 372778, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 372778, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.74473502503021, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.087433108924564, "tt_hits": 10487, "tt_cutoffs": 1172, "beta_cutoffs": 20138, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5617.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6233.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1858, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1078, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10749, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 83, 144, 96, 95, 99, 127, 68, 53, 100, 97, 101, 102, 143, 67, 82, 81, 109, 39 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9244, "avg_search_time_ms": 840.3636363636364, "search_nodes": 94448, "safety_nodes": 288, "corridor_nodes": 3230, "corridor_branch_probes": 3428, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1649, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 3206, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3206, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 84, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 60, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1649, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 84, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 81, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 684, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24008720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1970560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 97966, "avg_nodes": 8906.0, "eval_calls": 72140, "avg_eval_calls": 6558.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72140, "pattern_eval_ns": 1490854, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.666121430551705, "pattern_frame_queries": 72140, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1490854, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.666121430551705, "pattern_frame_updates": 188802, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2143010125, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11350.568982320103, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21403, "avg_candidate_generations": 1945.7272727272727, "candidate_moves_total": 1637081, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.48838947811055, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 716, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 21392, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1636365, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 629551, "avg_legality_checks": 57231.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3899, "root_legality_checks": 716, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 628835, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2595423, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 235947.54545454544, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5547931451, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2137.5827566450635, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24105, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2191.3636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 151429477, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6282.07745281062, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3949, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 41930865, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10106, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 78040000, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9378, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25063465, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 672, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6395147, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81301, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7391.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 737632693, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9072.86125631911, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109056, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9914.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 328613112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3013.2511003521126, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1576587243, "stage_ordering_ns": 682551763, "stage_eval_ns": 2144500979, "stage_threat_ns": 4350921732, "stage_proof_ns": 451769371, "tactical_annotations": 272745, "root_tactical_annotations": 1806, "search_tactical_annotations": 270939, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 195393, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1167284698, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 422753, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2977046696, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44543, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1671605579, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 97691, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 140672976, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6580, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 35640494, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 195382, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23765941, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70875, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 182107707, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 144816, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 693035111, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 57054, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6510927, "child_limit_applications": 21392, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21392, "child_cap_hits": 21392, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21392, "child_moves_before_total": 1632476, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1632476, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 342814, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 342814, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.31245325355273, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.025336574420344, "tt_hits": 8499, "tt_cutoffs": 869, "beta_cutoffs": 16707, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4369.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5096.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 879, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 1495, "avg_search_time_ms": 149.5, "search_nodes": 47429, "safety_nodes": 915, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48344, "avg_nodes": 4834.4, "eval_calls": 44922, "avg_eval_calls": 4492.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44922, "pattern_eval_ns": 911523, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.29123814611994, "pattern_frame_queries": 44922, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 911523, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.29123814611994, "pattern_frame_updates": 94800, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 853390960, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9002.014345991562, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2488, "avg_candidate_generations": 248.8, "candidate_moves_total": 175176, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.40836012861736, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 650, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 2478, "search_candidate_moves_total": 174526, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 5079, "avg_legality_checks": 507.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5079, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 222239, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22223.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 512813590, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2307.48693973605, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3764, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 376.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33620331, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8932.07518597237, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 236351, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3690, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32871676, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 512304, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14108442, "stage_ordering_ns": 79830, "stage_eval_ns": 854302483, "stage_threat_ns": 609061512, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 94810, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 534914146, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 288111, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 62596395, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 94800, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11262860, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 131, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2215, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5833.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6633.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1959, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1079, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15946, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 95, 114, 100, 156, 170, 143, 98, 158, 173, 99, 84, 126, 67, 82, 70, 56, 174, 144, 94, 96, 172, 171, 141, 159, 129, 157, 155, 160 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 5144, "avg_search_time_ms": 342.93333333333334, "search_nodes": 109530, "safety_nodes": 1647, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 111177, "avg_nodes": 7411.8, "eval_calls": 105697, "avg_eval_calls": 7046.466666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105697, "pattern_eval_ns": 2249856, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.28590215427117, "pattern_frame_queries": 105697, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2249856, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.28590215427117, "pattern_frame_updates": 218972, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3411137208, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15577.960689037867, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3804, "avg_candidate_generations": 253.6, "candidate_moves_total": 326703, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.88406940063092, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1149, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 3789, "search_candidate_moves_total": 325554, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 103031, "avg_legality_checks": 6868.733333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 684, "root_legality_checks": 1149, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 101882, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 678, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1039491, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 69299.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2524277545, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2428.3784515690854, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26348, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1756.5333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 246389714, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9351.36306361014, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 692, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6842152, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25604, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 239142499, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 405063, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 94, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.266666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 938443, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9983.436170212766, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 116, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7.733333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 446851, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3852.1637931034484, "stage_move_gen_ns": 261558543, "stage_ordering_ns": 125420, "stage_eval_ns": 3413387064, "stage_threat_ns": 1439760149, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 218987, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1259273426, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 41, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1282486, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 109486, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 152345577, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 218972, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26858660, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 193, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3465, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6556.533333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7089.866666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1863, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 10787, "avg_search_time_ms": 719.1333333333333, "search_nodes": 68450, "safety_nodes": 976, "corridor_nodes": 2195, "corridor_branch_probes": 2537, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 843, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 79, "corridor_plies_followed": 2168, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1988, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 180, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 843, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 79, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 453, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 179120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 16560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 71621, "avg_nodes": 4774.733333333334, "eval_calls": 45267, "avg_eval_calls": 3017.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 45267, "pattern_eval_ns": 1024276, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.627432787681975, "pattern_frame_queries": 45267, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1024276, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.627432787681975, "pattern_frame_updates": 136766, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1549291984, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11328.049252007078, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21746, "avg_candidate_generations": 1449.7333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1938412, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.13878414421043, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1193, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 21731, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1937219, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1440846, "avg_legality_checks": 96056.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6519, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1440846, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6519, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3268344, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 217889.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7044516156, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2155.3778170229325, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65797, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4386.466666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 217367706, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3303.6111980789397, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8439, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 74933156, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9168, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 53972744, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 47905, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 87321943, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 285, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1139863, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 130549, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8703.266666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1387806024, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10630.537376770408, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 171336, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11422.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 694308714, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4052.3224191063173, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3628266824, "stage_ordering_ns": 805971836, "stage_eval_ns": 1550316260, "stage_threat_ns": 4608926366, "stage_proof_ns": 123819450, "tactical_annotations": 469159, "root_tactical_annotations": 2060, "search_tactical_annotations": 467099, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 141255, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 932092827, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 534004, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3504152210, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44779, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1684257205, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70620, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112223036, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4474, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26448089, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 141240, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18858196, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 162850, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 758334460, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 195627, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 937945783, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110682, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15152008, "child_limit_applications": 21731, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21731, "child_cap_hits": 21731, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21731, "child_moves_before_total": 1930700, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1930700, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 349117, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 349117, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.84542819014311, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.065390456030556, "tt_hits": 10030, "tt_cutoffs": 1385, "beta_cutoffs": 18871, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5657.066666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6190.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1827, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1080, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20216, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 98, 143, 82, 97, 126, 84, 50, 66, 81, 140, 80, 79, 95, 65, 67, 109, 51, 94, 53, 39, 52, 49, 54 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 11913, "avg_search_time_ms": 992.75, "search_nodes": 122291, "safety_nodes": 395, "corridor_nodes": 1046, "corridor_branch_probes": 1188, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 289, "corridor_neutral_exits": 83, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1010, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1010, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 145, "corridor_proof_active": 36, "corridor_proof_quiet": 109, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 83, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 289, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 145, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 144, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1225, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 860480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 123732, "avg_nodes": 10311.0, "eval_calls": 83714, "avg_eval_calls": 6976.166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83714, "pattern_eval_ns": 1875598, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.404830733210694, "pattern_frame_queries": 83714, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1875598, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.404830733210694, "pattern_frame_updates": 244478, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2558285619, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10464.277436006512, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35846, "avg_candidate_generations": 2987.1666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2755252, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.86358310550689, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 779, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 35834, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2754473, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 906732, "avg_legality_checks": 75561.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 131, "root_legality_checks": 779, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 905953, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 131, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3125906, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 260492.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7071681153, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2262.282088137007, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12987, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1082.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 41402983, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3188.032879032879, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 145, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1407734, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3663, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27648530, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9167, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12321179, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 25540, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 63139, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5261.583333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 576118582, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9124.607326691901, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84229, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7019.083333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 245829833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2918.589001412815, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2272299268, "stage_ordering_ns": 1171346885, "stage_eval_ns": 2560161217, "stage_threat_ns": 5432771646, "stage_proof_ns": 419380493, "tactical_annotations": 433390, "root_tactical_annotations": 2716, "search_tactical_annotations": 430674, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 246800, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1485467540, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 505129, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3715491626, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 72887, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2646647875, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123394, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 178811481, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2310, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12435460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 246788, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31352698, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 130861, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 120253946, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 221867, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 768062168, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 80662, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9212841, "child_limit_applications": 35834, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35834, "child_cap_hits": 35834, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35834, "child_moves_before_total": 2754342, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2754342, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 573348, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 573348, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.86392811296534, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00011162583022, "tt_hits": 14799, "tt_cutoffs": 2691, "beta_cutoffs": 30391, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3912.4166666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4579.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 593, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8291, "avg_search_time_ms": 753.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 258354, "safety_nodes": 913, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 259267, "avg_nodes": 23569.727272727272, "eval_calls": 253826, "avg_eval_calls": 23075.090909090908, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 253826, "pattern_eval_ns": 5527094, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.77512941936602, "pattern_frame_queries": 253826, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5527094, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.77512941936602, "pattern_frame_updates": 516644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4799509030, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9289.779867761941, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4507, "avg_candidate_generations": 409.72727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 350474, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.76214777013534, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 723, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 4496, "search_candidate_moves_total": 349751, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 9385, "avg_legality_checks": 853.1818181818181, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9385, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1256632, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 114239.27272727272, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2932249332, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2333.419276287728, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3089, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 280.8181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 22448481, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7267.232437682098, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3089, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22448481, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 25423946, "stage_ordering_ns": 154670, "stage_eval_ns": 4805036124, "stage_threat_ns": 3417684869, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 516655, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3006733036, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 256430, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 258322, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 346010558, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 516644, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64684845, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 171, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4156, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5585.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6312.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1804, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1081, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12120, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 80, 99, 141, 71, 85, 128, 125, 129, 130, 65, 109, 108, 93, 77, 157 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 3965, "avg_search_time_ms": 440.55555555555554, "search_nodes": 92008, "safety_nodes": 510, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92518, "avg_nodes": 10279.777777777777, "eval_calls": 89400, "avg_eval_calls": 9933.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89400, "pattern_eval_ns": 1935979, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.655246085011186, "pattern_frame_queries": 89400, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1935979, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.655246085011186, "pattern_frame_updates": 183966, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2466617377, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13408.006789298022, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2592, "avg_candidate_generations": 288.0, "candidate_moves_total": 190185, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.3738425925926, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 628, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 2583, "search_candidate_moves_total": 189557, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 87211, "avg_legality_checks": 9690.111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 628, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 86583, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 714772, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 79419.11111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1806438130, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2527.2928010610376, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8189, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 909.8888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66001497, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8059.77494199536, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 179481, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8164, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 65822016, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 12, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.3333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 120682, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10056.833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.6666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 53962, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3597.4666666666667, "stage_move_gen_ns": 226079284, "stage_ordering_ns": 85831, "stage_eval_ns": 2468553356, "stage_threat_ns": 1253222578, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 183975, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1098847162, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 204912, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 17, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91983, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 130866269, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 183966, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23304235, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2213, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5248.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6137.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1871, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 8148, "avg_search_time_ms": 1018.5, "search_nodes": 58384, "safety_nodes": 553, "corridor_nodes": 1046, "corridor_branch_probes": 1222, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 448, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1034, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1034, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 42, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 448, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 42, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 42, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 296, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 192480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 16560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59983, "avg_nodes": 7497.875, "eval_calls": 39647, "avg_eval_calls": 4955.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39647, "pattern_eval_ns": 886816, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.367795797916614, "pattern_frame_queries": 39647, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 886816, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.367795797916614, "pattern_frame_updates": 116698, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1298283784, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11125.158820202574, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17572, "avg_candidate_generations": 2196.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1428597, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.29962440245846, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 555, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 17564, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1428042, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1041541, "avg_legality_checks": 130192.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 690, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1041541, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 690, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2419272, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 302409.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5372134164, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2220.5581530311597, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14989, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1873.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 40722182, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2716.804456601508, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 696, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7351262, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1858, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14318095, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12435, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19052825, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 95451, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11931.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 922551071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9665.179736199725, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 127314, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15914.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 407345225, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3199.5320624597452, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2642693148, "stage_ordering_ns": 634387764, "stage_eval_ns": 1299170600, "stage_threat_ns": 3455546591, "stage_proof_ns": 68551169, "tactical_annotations": 258195, "root_tactical_annotations": 981, "search_tactical_annotations": 257214, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 118858, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 756923873, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 312693, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2573138952, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35750, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1340972284, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 59425, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92203444, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2152, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11059169, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 118850, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15431293, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52356, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 284887025, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 161866, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 892069909, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 43973, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6789860, "child_limit_applications": 17564, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17564, "child_cap_hits": 17564, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17564, "child_moves_before_total": 1427352, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1427352, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 281071, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 281071, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.26577089501252, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002675928034616, "tt_hits": 5201, "tt_cutoffs": 1138, "beta_cutoffs": 15013, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2410.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3394.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 344, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1082, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12762, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 99, 141, 109, 140, 95, 97, 139, 67, 124, 82, 52, 94, 123, 81, 155, 83, 69, 80, 84, 79 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9144, "avg_search_time_ms": 762.0, "search_nodes": 90402, "safety_nodes": 900, "corridor_nodes": 1719, "corridor_branch_probes": 1956, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 536, "corridor_neutral_exits": 79, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 1680, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1680, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 106, "corridor_proof_active": 39, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 79, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 536, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 106, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 105, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 776, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24289840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 93021, "avg_nodes": 7751.75, "eval_calls": 67607, "avg_eval_calls": 5633.916666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67607, "pattern_eval_ns": 1488959, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.02374014525123, "pattern_frame_queries": 67607, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1488959, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.02374014525123, "pattern_frame_updates": 180700, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2109621886, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11674.719900387383, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21891, "avg_candidate_generations": 1824.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1640447, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.93705175642958, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 742, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 21879, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1639705, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 705127, "avg_legality_checks": 58760.583333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 731, "root_legality_checks": 742, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 704385, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 730, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2440572, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 203381.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5547277734, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2272.941644008044, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11872, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 989.3333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 59510051, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5012.63906671159, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 755, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8132955, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4470, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 36624312, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6457, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13602822, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 190, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1149962, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 57316, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4776.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 490111379, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8551.039482866914, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72131, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6010.916666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 191230911, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2651.161234420707, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1780150436, "stage_ordering_ns": 722795194, "stage_eval_ns": 2111110845, "stage_threat_ns": 4057145222, "stage_proof_ns": 431321468, "tactical_annotations": 280629, "root_tactical_annotations": 1377, "search_tactical_annotations": 279252, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 184284, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1146827281, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 393818, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2718466701, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45113, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1743484260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92136, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 140766471, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3572, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20763844, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 184272, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23801064, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 78565, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 94035442, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 148265, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 593395301, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53799, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6519861, "child_limit_applications": 21879, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21879, "child_cap_hits": 21879, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21879, "child_moves_before_total": 1638975, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1638975, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 350067, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 350067, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.9108734402852, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000137117784178, "tt_hits": 8191, "tt_cutoffs": 864, "beta_cutoffs": 17458, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4767.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5433.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1130, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3607, "avg_search_time_ms": 327.90909090909093, "search_nodes": 111074, "safety_nodes": 518, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 111592, "avg_nodes": 10144.727272727272, "eval_calls": 107038, "avg_eval_calls": 9730.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107038, "pattern_eval_ns": 2316379, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.6407163810983, "pattern_frame_queries": 107038, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2316379, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.6407163810983, "pattern_frame_updates": 222084, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2085111352, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9388.840943066587, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4015, "avg_candidate_generations": 365.0, "candidate_moves_total": 296538, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.85753424657534, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 678, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 4004, "search_candidate_moves_total": 295860, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 10181, "avg_legality_checks": 925.5454545454545, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10181, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 554459, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 50405.36363636364, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1304951350, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2353.5578825485745, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2852, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 259.27272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15846393, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5556.238779803646, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 32610, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2844, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15746673, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 67110, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 27727886, "stage_ordering_ns": 146581, "stage_eval_ns": 2087427731, "stage_threat_ns": 1471299986, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 222095, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1287726564, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 163390, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12550, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111042, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 155726232, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 222084, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27683800, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 316, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3520, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5978.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6705.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1083, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11060, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 159, 143, 126, 83, 141, 156, 84, 113, 129, 67, 52, 65, 49, 79, 80, 128, 98, 114, 100, 68, 66, 115, 116, 99, 51, 131 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 5803, "avg_search_time_ms": 386.8666666666667, "search_nodes": 132779, "safety_nodes": 1348, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 134127, "avg_nodes": 8941.8, "eval_calls": 128723, "avg_eval_calls": 8581.533333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 128723, "pattern_eval_ns": 2793523, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.7018170800867, "pattern_frame_queries": 128723, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2793523, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.7018170800867, "pattern_frame_updates": 265472, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3737095422, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14077.17357009402, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4028, "avg_candidate_generations": 268.53333333333336, "candidate_moves_total": 314600, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.10327706057596, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1037, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 4013, "search_candidate_moves_total": 313563, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 125401, "avg_legality_checks": 8360.066666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1213, "root_legality_checks": 1037, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 124364, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1209, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1228089, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 81872.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2839549066, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2312.1687972125796, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28813, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1920.8666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 212920522, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7389.738034914795, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9953528, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27554, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 202733984, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 233010, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 110, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7.333333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1114274, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10129.763636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 147, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 528522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3595.387755102041, "stage_move_gen_ns": 306283251, "stage_ordering_ns": 141881, "stage_eval_ns": 3739888945, "stage_threat_ns": 1725571744, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 265487, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1507489820, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1334604, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 132736, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184354786, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 265472, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32392534, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 334, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3525, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6540.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7073.533333333334, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1864, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 5242, "avg_search_time_ms": 374.42857142857144, "search_nodes": 42116, "safety_nodes": 1246, "corridor_nodes": 354, "corridor_branch_probes": 453, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 108, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 344, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 344, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 52, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 108, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 52, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 307, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 95520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 43716, "avg_nodes": 3122.5714285714284, "eval_calls": 28275, "avg_eval_calls": 2019.642857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 28275, "pattern_eval_ns": 634826, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.45184792219275, "pattern_frame_queries": 28275, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 634826, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.45184792219275, "pattern_frame_updates": 84102, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 940002049, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11176.928598606453, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12938, "avg_candidate_generations": 924.1428571428571, "candidate_moves_total": 948713, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.32763951151647, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 968, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 12924, "search_candidate_moves_total": 947745, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 549426, "avg_legality_checks": 39244.71428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 401, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 549426, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 401, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1538166, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 109869.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3353887719, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2180.445881003741, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8085, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 577.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 26123708, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3231.1327149041435, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 403, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3693625, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2073, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13859934, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5573, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8211878, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 36, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 358271, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 57124, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4080.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 583977245, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10222.975369371892, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 80487, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5749.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 283332418, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3520.2258501372894, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1388995918, "stage_ordering_ns": 412828377, "stage_eval_ns": 940636875, "stage_threat_ns": 2370146963, "stage_proof_ns": 91617474, "tactical_annotations": 202021, "root_tactical_annotations": 586, "search_tactical_annotations": 201435, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 84908, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 541241147, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 219563, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1743504703, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26303, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 963765769, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42447, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 65837386, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 792, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4797250, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 84894, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11088694, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 49555, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 222119908, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 118862, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 537961412, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 33604, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3677783, "child_limit_applications": 12924, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12924, "child_cap_hits": 12924, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12924, "child_moves_before_total": 947344, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 947344, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 207700, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 207700, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.30114515629836, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.070875889817394, "tt_hits": 4317, "tt_cutoffs": 852, "beta_cutoffs": 11085, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5813.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6385.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1833, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1084, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15997, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 81, 126, 67, 82, 39, 53, 65, 49, 68, 66, 50, 141, 156, 110, 35, 80, 51, 124, 138, 83, 37, 79, 20, 5, 36, 38, 52, 84, 4 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 9864, "avg_search_time_ms": 657.6, "search_nodes": 177856, "safety_nodes": 416, "corridor_nodes": 4817, "corridor_branch_probes": 5010, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2538, "corridor_neutral_exits": 88, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 4772, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4772, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 133, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 88, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 88, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2538, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 133, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 130, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1093, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 949680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 183089, "avg_nodes": 12205.933333333332, "eval_calls": 132457, "avg_eval_calls": 8830.466666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 132457, "pattern_eval_ns": 2462482, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.590803053066278, "pattern_frame_queries": 132457, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2462482, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.590803053066278, "pattern_frame_updates": 355578, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2501472906, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7034.948467003021, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41854, "avg_candidate_generations": 2790.266666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 3398624, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.20189229225403, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1084, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 41839, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3397540, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1139455, "avg_legality_checks": 75963.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 262, "root_legality_checks": 1084, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1138371, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 262, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4447458, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 296497.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5661293252, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1272.9278729557423, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36556, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2437.0666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 52986821, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1449.469881825145, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 430, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1232134, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15316, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34689837, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19603, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16119678, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1207, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 945172, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 118224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7881.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 541002159, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4576.077268574909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 147961, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9864.066666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 222522473, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1503.9265279364156, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1619344370, "stage_ordering_ns": 793132082, "stage_eval_ns": 2503935388, "stage_threat_ns": 4458977867, "stage_proof_ns": 417434035, "tactical_annotations": 773771, "root_tactical_annotations": 3779, "search_tactical_annotations": 769992, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 365403, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1330719682, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 912473, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2859856375, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 86339, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1730795305, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 182694, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 181536554, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9810, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 39463086, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 365388, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29862590, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 265398, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 155555886, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 333332, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 661729389, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 175041, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17539580, "child_limit_applications": 41839, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41839, "child_cap_hits": 41839, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41839, "child_moves_before_total": 3397278, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3397278, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 670239, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 670239, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.1988336241306, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.019479433064845, "tt_hits": 19304, "tt_cutoffs": 3493, "beta_cutoffs": 33185, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6170.066666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6703.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1275, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6115, "avg_search_time_ms": 436.7857142857143, "search_nodes": 339050, "safety_nodes": 1418, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 340468, "avg_nodes": 24319.14285714286, "eval_calls": 332773, "avg_eval_calls": 23769.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 332773, "pattern_eval_ns": 6142769, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.45933714574199, "pattern_frame_queries": 332773, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6142769, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.45933714574199, "pattern_frame_updates": 678018, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3388209828, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 4997.226958576321, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6250, "avg_candidate_generations": 446.42857142857144, "candidate_moves_total": 490770, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.5232, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1033, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 6236, "search_candidate_moves_total": 489737, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 12691, "avg_legality_checks": 906.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 12691, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1454610, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 103900.71428571429, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1907587832, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1311.4084407504417, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6199, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 442.7857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 27741005, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4475.077431843846, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6199, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27741005, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20402481, "stage_ordering_ns": 184311, "stage_eval_ns": 3394352597, "stage_threat_ns": 2631740274, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 678032, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2280971367, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 219530, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 339009, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 296956600, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 678018, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53592777, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 208, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5822, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6291.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6863.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1874, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1085, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10995, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 110, 109, 82, 124, 126, 81, 94, 78, 80, 64, 95, 65, 127, 33, 49, 146, 162, 79, 141, 156, 155, 99, 169 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 7235, "avg_search_time_ms": 516.7857142857143, "search_nodes": 184665, "safety_nodes": 482, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 185147, "avg_nodes": 13224.785714285714, "eval_calls": 178676, "avg_eval_calls": 12762.57142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 178676, "pattern_eval_ns": 3834313, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.459586066399517, "pattern_frame_queries": 178676, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3834313, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.459586066399517, "pattern_frame_updates": 369250, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4365720308, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11823.21004197698, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5963, "avg_candidate_generations": 425.92857142857144, "candidate_moves_total": 470657, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.92956565487171, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1002, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 5949, "search_candidate_moves_total": 469655, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 170646, "avg_legality_checks": 12189.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 189, "root_legality_checks": 1002, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 169644, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 189, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1344422, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 96030.14285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3206519044, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2385.053981562337, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24991, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1785.0714285714287, "renju_forbidden_ns": 134491899, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5381.613340802689, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 222, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 635491, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24755, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 133811638, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 44770, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 244691, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11651.952380952382, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 30, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 128471, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4282.366666666667, "stage_move_gen_ns": 415500306, "stage_ordering_ns": 214660, "stage_eval_ns": 4369554621, "stage_threat_ns": 2414256195, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 369264, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2111823701, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 340412, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 184625, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 257016420, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 369250, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45075662, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 628, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5096, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6177.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6749.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1812, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3748, "avg_search_time_ms": 288.3076923076923, "search_nodes": 34325, "safety_nodes": 1481, "corridor_nodes": 760, "corridor_branch_probes": 859, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 14, "corridor_depth_exits": 320, "corridor_neutral_exits": 21, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 741, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 741, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 35, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 320, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 224, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 134720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 36566, "avg_nodes": 2812.769230769231, "eval_calls": 24340, "avg_eval_calls": 1872.3076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 24340, "pattern_eval_ns": 529931, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.77202136400986, "pattern_frame_queries": 24340, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 529931, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.77202136400986, "pattern_frame_updates": 68530, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 772315488, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11269.743003064352, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9520, "avg_candidate_generations": 732.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 726058, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.26659663865546, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 919, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 9507, "search_candidate_moves_total": 725139, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 314416, "avg_legality_checks": 24185.846153846152, "illegal_moves_skipped": 111, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 314416, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1046056, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 80465.84615384616, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2266725726, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2166.9257917358154, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5313, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 408.6923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20381321, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3836.1229060794276, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 149, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1131992, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1812, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12991932, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3338, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6212057, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 45340, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3019.3076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 348249615, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8872.375608264758, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 51947, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3995.923076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 142122705, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2735.91747357884, "stage_move_gen_ns": 780023868, "stage_ordering_ns": 306183451, "stage_eval_ns": 772845419, "stage_threat_ns": 1777323790, "stage_proof_ns": 82043558, "tactical_annotations": 164462, "root_tactical_annotations": 381, "search_tactical_annotations": 164081, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 70127, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 458051162, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 200629, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1241896958, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19624, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 726178993, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35057, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 54002216, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1584, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11546465, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 70114, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9038774, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44797, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 157093155, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 93634, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 327159005, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 26031, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2788215, "child_limit_applications": 9507, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9507, "child_cap_hits": 9507, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9507, "child_moves_before_total": 725028, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 725028, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 157133, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 157133, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.26254338908173, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.52813716209109, "tt_hits": 2970, "tt_cutoffs": 418, "beta_cutoffs": 7952, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6145.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6760.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1859, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1086, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9687, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 82, 110, 126, 81, 128, 144, 127, 129, 141, 156, 99, 155, 85 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5795, "avg_search_time_ms": 643.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 60004, "safety_nodes": 410, "corridor_nodes": 1142, "corridor_branch_probes": 1423, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 384, "corridor_neutral_exits": 34, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1120, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1120, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 71, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 384, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 71, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 558, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24230080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 61556, "avg_nodes": 6839.555555555556, "eval_calls": 44094, "avg_eval_calls": 4899.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44094, "pattern_eval_ns": 960322, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.778972195763597, "pattern_frame_queries": 44094, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 960322, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.778972195763597, "pattern_frame_updates": 119934, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1348481766, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11243.531992595928, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15016, "avg_candidate_generations": 1668.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 1022656, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.10442194992008, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 491, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 15007, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1022165, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 357651, "avg_legality_checks": 39739.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 450, "root_legality_checks": 491, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 357160, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 450, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1524604, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 169400.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3457155110, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2267.5757836133184, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8322, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 924.6666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50650621, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6086.351958663783, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 456, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4859323, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3356, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32414947, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4361, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12117276, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 149, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1259075, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 33696, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3744.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 327643311, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9723.507567663817, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 46146, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5127.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 148276116, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3213.1954232219477, "stage_move_gen_ns": 914151032, "stage_ordering_ns": 457302737, "stage_eval_ns": 1349442088, "stage_threat_ns": 2766874338, "stage_proof_ns": 281357922, "tactical_annotations": 167007, "root_tactical_annotations": 1315, "search_tactical_annotations": 165692, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 122325, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 755912898, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 234989, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1885799749, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30846, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1254860853, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61158, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92135267, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2382, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13061978, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 122316, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15785581, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 40791, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 68710999, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 85255, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 361288361, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 40961, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4178865, "child_limit_applications": 15007, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15007, "child_cap_hits": 15007, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15007, "child_moves_before_total": 1021715, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1021715, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 240112, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 240112, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.08256147131338, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 6526, "tt_cutoffs": 866, "beta_cutoffs": 12118, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4230.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5119.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1211, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 3884, "avg_search_time_ms": 485.5, "search_nodes": 110599, "safety_nodes": 547, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 111146, "avg_nodes": 13893.25, "eval_calls": 108020, "avg_eval_calls": 13502.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 108020, "pattern_eval_ns": 2301434, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.30562858729865, "pattern_frame_queries": 108020, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2301434, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.30562858729865, "pattern_frame_updates": 221152, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2337612010, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10570.159935248155, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2564, "avg_candidate_generations": 320.5, "candidate_moves_total": 167524, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.33697347893916, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 434, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 2556, "search_candidate_moves_total": 167090, "search_candidate_moves_max": 88, "legality_checks": 4961, "avg_legality_checks": 620.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4961, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 581867, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 72733.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1422512030, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2444.737422813117, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6740, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 842.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 54857188, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8139.048664688427, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6740, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 54857188, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14098084, "stage_ordering_ns": 80330, "stage_eval_ns": 2339913444, "stage_threat_ns": 1519789518, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 221160, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1332509397, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 221831, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8930, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 110576, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 158425465, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 221152, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28632825, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 108, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2296, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4499.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5499.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1087, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9880, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 158, 82, 67, 110, 68, 98, 95, 66, 50, 80, 64, 81, 79, 113, 47, 63, 174, 190, 65, 99, 100, 85, 141, 71 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6677, "avg_search_time_ms": 476.92857142857144, "search_nodes": 183315, "safety_nodes": 482, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 183797, "avg_nodes": 13128.357142857143, "eval_calls": 177472, "avg_eval_calls": 12676.57142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 177472, "pattern_eval_ns": 3717776, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.94852145690588, "pattern_frame_queries": 177472, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3717776, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.94852145690588, "pattern_frame_updates": 366550, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4167296535, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11368.97158641386, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5817, "avg_candidate_generations": 415.5, "candidate_moves_total": 474381, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.55079938112429, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1002, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 5803, "search_candidate_moves_total": 473379, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 169547, "avg_legality_checks": 12110.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 191, "root_legality_checks": 1002, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 168545, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 191, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1460955, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 104353.92857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3053592958, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2090.134848780421, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33547, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2396.214285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 204359562, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6091.738814200971, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 226, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1201056, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33307, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 203116176, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 42330, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 249741, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11892.42857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 30, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.142857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 131471, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4382.366666666667, "stage_move_gen_ns": 359505542, "stage_ordering_ns": 199840, "stage_eval_ns": 4171014311, "stage_threat_ns": 2110486269, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 366564, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1836616423, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 344941, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 183275, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 233283717, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 366550, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40241188, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 628, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4972, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6411.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6982.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1863, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3187, "avg_search_time_ms": 245.15384615384616, "search_nodes": 33172, "safety_nodes": 1481, "corridor_nodes": 728, "corridor_branch_probes": 835, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 14, "corridor_depth_exits": 304, "corridor_neutral_exits": 27, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 709, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 709, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 41, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 304, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 224, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 123200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35381, "avg_nodes": 2721.6153846153848, "eval_calls": 23350, "avg_eval_calls": 1796.1538461538462, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23350, "pattern_eval_ns": 493041, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.11524625267666, "pattern_frame_queries": 23350, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 493041, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.11524625267666, "pattern_frame_updates": 66224, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 642913514, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9708.164925102681, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9320, "avg_candidate_generations": 716.9230769230769, "candidate_moves_total": 708621, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.03229613733906, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 919, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 9307, "search_candidate_moves_total": 707702, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 310822, "avg_legality_checks": 23909.384615384617, "illegal_moves_skipped": 173, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 310822, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 173, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1030316, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 79255.07692307692, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1933555058, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1876.6621677233004, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5063, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 389.46153846153845, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16039879, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3168.0582658502863, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 211, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1362285, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1636, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9820792, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3202, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4812362, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 44440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39000, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3000.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 304280697, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7802.069153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 51559, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3966.076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 129509083, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2511.8618088015673, "stage_move_gen_ns": 679762813, "stage_ordering_ns": 252694204, "stage_eval_ns": 643406555, "stage_threat_ns": 1509837388, "stage_proof_ns": 74692277, "tactical_annotations": 162041, "root_tactical_annotations": 381, "search_tactical_annotations": 161660, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 67757, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 386326209, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 196387, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1056125261, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19216, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 613168786, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 33872, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 46839653, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1520, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10827645, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 67744, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7763854, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44521, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 139114620, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 91672, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 274697518, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 25848, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1954766, "child_limit_applications": 9307, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9307, "child_cap_hits": 9307, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9307, "child_moves_before_total": 707529, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 707529, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 153978, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 153978, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.02116686365102, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.544321478457075, "tt_hits": 3023, "tt_cutoffs": 455, "beta_cutoffs": 7818, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6142.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6758.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1828, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1088, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18434, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 96, 141, 82, 97, 54, 68, 80, 64, 83, 81, 65, 156, 171, 125, 50, 95, 66, 139, 153, 34, 52, 94, 35, 20, 51, 53, 67, 19, 99 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 12048, "avg_search_time_ms": 803.2, "search_nodes": 149057, "safety_nodes": 431, "corridor_nodes": 3147, "corridor_branch_probes": 3356, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1424, "corridor_neutral_exits": 84, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 3102, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3102, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 133, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 88, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 84, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1424, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 133, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 130, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1093, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 977360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 152635, "avg_nodes": 10175.666666666666, "eval_calls": 105213, "avg_eval_calls": 7014.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105213, "pattern_eval_ns": 2198691, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.897522169313678, "pattern_frame_queries": 105213, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2198691, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.897522169313678, "pattern_frame_updates": 297980, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3028923657, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10164.855550708102, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 40986, "avg_candidate_generations": 2732.4, "candidate_moves_total": 3449666, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.16693505099302, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1109, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 40971, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3448557, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1021840, "avg_legality_checks": 68122.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 346, "root_legality_checks": 1109, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1020731, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 346, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4055309, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 270353.93333333335, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7146286229, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1762.2051066885408, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28495, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1899.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66677613, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2339.9758905071067, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 560, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2536885, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11642, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44686545, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15794, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18757796, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 499, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 696387, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97936, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6529.066666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 685593821, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7000.427023770626, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 125766, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8384.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 284715264, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2263.8492438337867, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2026986236, "stage_ordering_ns": 1021475194, "stage_eval_ns": 3031122348, "stage_threat_ns": 5449435660, "stage_proof_ns": 450912687, "tactical_annotations": 741763, "root_tactical_annotations": 3859, "search_tactical_annotations": 737904, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 304465, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1522881786, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 823246, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3646882445, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 84043, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2321703718, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 152225, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 192420635, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6470, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 35668227, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 304450, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32752646, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 259650, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 172232591, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 305851, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 823779117, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 176262, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18829921, "child_limit_applications": 40971, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 40971, "child_cap_hits": 40971, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 40971, "child_moves_before_total": 3448211, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3448211, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 662917, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 662917, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.16223670401016, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.180151814698203, "tt_hits": 19048, "tt_cutoffs": 2806, "beta_cutoffs": 34191, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5520.866666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6054.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 663, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6371, "avg_search_time_ms": 455.07142857142856, "search_nodes": 301504, "safety_nodes": 1446, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 302950, "avg_nodes": 21639.285714285714, "eval_calls": 295872, "avg_eval_calls": 21133.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 295872, "pattern_eval_ns": 5864110, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.819753136491457, "pattern_frame_queries": 295872, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5864110, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.819753136491457, "pattern_frame_updates": 602926, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3562594295, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5908.841706942477, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5605, "avg_candidate_generations": 400.35714285714283, "candidate_moves_total": 452083, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.657091882248, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1056, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 5591, "search_candidate_moves_total": 451027, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 12072, "avg_legality_checks": 862.2857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 12072, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1300540, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 92895.71428571429, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1983191828, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1524.898755901395, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5625, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 401.7857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31514508, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5602.5792, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5625, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31514508, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22292193, "stage_ordering_ns": 179001, "stage_eval_ns": 3568458405, "stage_threat_ns": 2712331809, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 602940, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2361030769, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 232682, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10220, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 301463, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 296908743, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 602926, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 54159615, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 197, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5222, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6228.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6800.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1811, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1089, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14694, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 67, 83, 128, 111, 125, 81, 80, 96, 126, 66, 51, 55, 69, 85, 84, 124, 110, 95, 158, 143, 142, 94, 174 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6558, "avg_search_time_ms": 546.5, "search_nodes": 170015, "safety_nodes": 814, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 170829, "avg_nodes": 14235.75, "eval_calls": 164466, "avg_eval_calls": 13705.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 164466, "pattern_eval_ns": 3492003, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.232370216336506, "pattern_frame_queries": 164466, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3492003, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.232370216336506, "pattern_frame_updates": 339960, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3937677843, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11582.768099188139, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5526, "avg_candidate_generations": 460.5, "candidate_moves_total": 355461, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.32519001085777, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 724, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 5514, "search_candidate_moves_total": 354737, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 158802, "avg_legality_checks": 13233.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 724, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 158078, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1206676, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 100556.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2858585594, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2368.975262622278, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9621, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 801.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 75496082, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7847.009874233448, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 210391, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9597, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 75285691, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 319062, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8862.833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.8333333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 134840, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2931.304347826087, "stage_move_gen_ns": 385047408, "stage_ordering_ns": 182971, "stage_eval_ns": 3941169846, "stage_threat_ns": 2207595877, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 339972, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1931876854, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 434722, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12240, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 169980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 233543543, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 339960, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41740758, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 261, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4981, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5161.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5828.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1498, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8122, "avg_search_time_ms": 676.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 67826, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 478, "corridor_branch_probes": 629, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 162, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 467, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 467, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 18, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 162, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 18, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 17, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 37, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 7985520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 69117, "avg_nodes": 5759.75, "eval_calls": 39552, "avg_eval_calls": 3296.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39552, "pattern_eval_ns": 871283, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.02879753236246, "pattern_frame_queries": 39552, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 871283, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.02879753236246, "pattern_frame_updates": 135512, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1412836920, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10425.917409528307, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25636, "avg_candidate_generations": 2136.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 1763572, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.79279138711188, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 749, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 25624, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1762823, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 957582, "avg_legality_checks": 79798.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 957582, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2486536, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 207211.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5151711281, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2071.8426280576673, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13736, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1144.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20161543, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1467.7885119394293, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 608313, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2190, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10884131, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11436, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8660189, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8910, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75699, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6308.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 638501834, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8434.74595437192, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 100848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8404.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 264312747, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2620.9022191813424, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2161676975, "stage_ordering_ns": 715691897, "stage_eval_ns": 1413708203, "stage_threat_ns": 3755440060, "stage_proof_ns": 27117378, "tactical_annotations": 371013, "root_tactical_annotations": 901, "search_tactical_annotations": 370112, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136494, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 839793907, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 355911, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2779378460, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51631, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1825119160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 103776794, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 970, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5827019, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17527512, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 64213, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 204487603, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 208539, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 725677170, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 98261, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9136368, "child_limit_applications": 25624, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25624, "child_cap_hits": 25624, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25624, "child_moves_before_total": 1762727, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1762727, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 238382, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 238382, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.79203090852326, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.303075241960661, "tt_hits": 12220, "tt_cutoffs": 2581, "beta_cutoffs": 20591, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 5.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 5.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4458.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5125.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1090, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32160, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 53, 95, 111, 125, 69, 55, 68, 155, 169, 110, 140, 80, 65, 66, 38, 23, 37, 94, 108, 21, 39, 25, 36, 40, 35 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 29230, "avg_search_time_ms": 1623.888888888889, "search_nodes": 219478, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 25280, "corridor_branch_probes": 27518, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 12728, "corridor_neutral_exits": 27, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 25230, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 25230, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 50, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 27, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 12728, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 100, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 762, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 67487360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 245555, "avg_nodes": 13641.944444444445, "eval_calls": 140454, "avg_eval_calls": 7803.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 140454, "pattern_eval_ns": 3094521, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.032273911743346, "pattern_frame_queries": 140454, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3094521, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.032273911743346, "pattern_frame_updates": 438748, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5571283736, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12698.140472435201, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 73142, "avg_candidate_generations": 4063.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 6219193, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.02902573077029, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 73124, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6217891, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1565024, "avg_legality_checks": 86945.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1777, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1563722, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1777, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8514636, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 473035.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17910043190, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2103.4420250025955, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56177, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3120.9444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 320595211, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5706.87667550777, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3119, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 28662331, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24766, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 180843165, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26552, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 95944381, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1740, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 15145334, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 227376, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12632.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1913791797, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8416.859285940469, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 301411, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16745.055555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 831539795, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2758.8236494354883, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3820569063, "stage_ordering_ns": 2442720818, "stage_eval_ns": 5574378257, "stage_threat_ns": 14891894896, "stage_proof_ns": 2419510793, "tactical_annotations": 1546871, "root_tactical_annotations": 4128, "search_tactical_annotations": 1542743, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 489426, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3268894117, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2419466, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10759136820, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 158803, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5603158094, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 244704, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 397877040, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 50660, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 338610380, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 489408, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62808826, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 448013, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 448420145, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 589835, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1814871374, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 509023, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 64567713, "child_limit_applications": 73124, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 73124, "child_cap_hits": 73124, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 73124, "child_moves_before_total": 6216114, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6216114, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 869726, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 869726, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.00784967999563, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.893851539850118, "tt_hits": 44306, "tt_cutoffs": 5796, "beta_cutoffs": 60278, "depth_sum": 102, "avg_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 102, "avg_effective_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1850.8333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2234.6111111111113, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 2911, "avg_search_time_ms": 171.23529411764707, "search_nodes": 84204, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 86095, "avg_nodes": 5064.411764705882, "eval_calls": 81401, "avg_eval_calls": 4788.294117647059, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 81401, "pattern_eval_ns": 1755287, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.56345745138266, "pattern_frame_queries": 81401, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1755287, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.56345745138266, "pattern_frame_updates": 168308, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1747173951, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10380.813455094232, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2770, "avg_candidate_generations": 162.94117647058823, "candidate_moves_total": 217538, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.53357400722021, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1235, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2753, "search_candidate_moves_total": 216303, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5313, "avg_legality_checks": 312.52941176470586, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5313, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 520187, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 30599.235294117647, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1161716640, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2233.2673442435125, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4285, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 252.05882352941177, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29524559, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6890.212135355892, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53810, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4265, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29343509, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 127240, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14494972, "stage_ordering_ns": 90600, "stage_eval_ns": 1748929238, "stage_threat_ns": 1119818483, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 168325, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 982042661, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 474462, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19061, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84154, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 116349342, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 168308, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20952018, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2573, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6728.35294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7198.941176470588, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1091, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22967, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 81, 142, 156, 129, 126, 130, 131, 100, 86, 141, 140, 98, 109, 110, 154, 168, 146, 101, 99, 115, 66, 96, 145, 87, 143, 73 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 4479, "avg_search_time_ms": 319.92857142857144, "search_nodes": 105042, "safety_nodes": 1510, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 106552, "avg_nodes": 7610.857142857143, "eval_calls": 101266, "avg_eval_calls": 7233.285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 101266, "pattern_eval_ns": 2067555, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.417069895127682, "pattern_frame_queries": 101266, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2067555, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.417069895127682, "pattern_frame_updates": 210002, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2854847934, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13594.38450109999, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3749, "avg_candidate_generations": 267.7857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 290966, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.61162976793811, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1033, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 3735, "search_candidate_moves_total": 289933, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 97729, "avg_legality_checks": 6980.642857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 109, "root_legality_checks": 1033, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 96696, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 104, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 874518, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 62465.57142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2107237309, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2409.598554861078, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13427, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 959.0714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 101170129, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7534.827511730096, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 123, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1092693, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13247, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 99699415, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 378021, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 92, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.571428571428571, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 901763, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9801.771739130434, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.428571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 443050, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3754.6610169491523, "stage_move_gen_ns": 242057618, "stage_ordering_ns": 131721, "stage_eval_ns": 2856915489, "stage_threat_ns": 1358029721, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 210016, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1188896682, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1236524, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 105001, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 142813171, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 210002, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25083344, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 190, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3390, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6257.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6829.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1875, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 18478, "avg_search_time_ms": 1319.857142857143, "search_nodes": 134032, "safety_nodes": 981, "corridor_nodes": 2104, "corridor_branch_probes": 2428, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 825, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 61, "corridor_plies_followed": 2079, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1809, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 270, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 825, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 61, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 55, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 347, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 15891480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1988240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 137117, "avg_nodes": 9794.07142857143, "eval_calls": 84937, "avg_eval_calls": 6066.928571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84937, "pattern_eval_ns": 1794862, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.13168583773856, "pattern_frame_queries": 84937, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1794862, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.13168583773856, "pattern_frame_updates": 267892, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3199702478, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11944.001605124453, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44517, "avg_candidate_generations": 3179.785714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 3859167, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.68973650515534, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1078, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 44503, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3858089, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 2334452, "avg_legality_checks": 166746.57142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12849, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2334452, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12849, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5726999, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 409071.35714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11806673982, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2061.581289258126, "renju_forbidden_checks": 104348, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7453.428571428572, "renju_forbidden_ns": 367560988, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3522.4535975773374, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17388, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 128467847, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23179, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 120569683, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 63380, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 117263486, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 401, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1259972, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 208049, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14860.642857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2020573478, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9712.00764243039, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 279569, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19969.214285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 987452432, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3532.0526667835134, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5609325517, "stage_ordering_ns": 1499573353, "stage_eval_ns": 3201497340, "stage_threat_ns": 7974834709, "stage_proof_ns": 104475390, "tactical_annotations": 995014, "root_tactical_annotations": 2562, "search_tactical_annotations": 992452, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 272176, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1652252114, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 938282, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6026475861, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90292, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3217694705, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 136081, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 202868617, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4270, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 23368138, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 272162, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34842276, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 257859, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1034454327, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 467771, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1658330473, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 269384, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 35027703, "child_limit_applications": 44503, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44503, "child_cap_hits": 44503, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44503, "child_moves_before_total": 3845240, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3845240, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 537696, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 537696, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.40406264746197, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.082241646630564, "tt_hits": 23821, "tt_cutoffs": 4506, "beta_cutoffs": 36225, "depth_sum": 84, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 84, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3654.9285714285716, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4226.357142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 181, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1092, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30026, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 110, 109, 142, 94, 96, 141, 124, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 125, 86, 72, 83, 85, 81, 80, 95, 123, 122, 108, 67, 53, 92, 138, 152, 93, 153, 78 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 28782, "avg_search_time_ms": 1599.0, "search_nodes": 239731, "safety_nodes": 811, "corridor_nodes": 25668, "corridor_branch_probes": 27954, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 12952, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 25615, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 25615, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 53, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 12952, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 100, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 762, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 71480720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 266210, "avg_nodes": 14789.444444444445, "eval_calls": 156232, "avg_eval_calls": 8679.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 156232, "pattern_eval_ns": 3170703, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.294837165241436, "pattern_frame_queries": 156232, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3170703, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.294837165241436, "pattern_frame_updates": 479254, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5743390092, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11984.021191268095, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 77275, "avg_candidate_generations": 4293.055555555556, "candidate_moves_total": 6963677, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.1155224846328, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1337, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 77257, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6962340, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1836829, "avg_legality_checks": 102046.05555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2120, "root_legality_checks": 1337, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1835492, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2120, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9433279, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 524071.05555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17616820194, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1867.5181974369675, "renju_forbidden_checks": 68494, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3805.222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 342096516, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4994.547201214705, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3598, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 27650722, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 30333, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 196782974, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32769, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 101422809, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1794, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 16240011, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 259272, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14404.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1967714002, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7589.381043845845, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 340008, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18889.333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 838034588, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2464.7496176560553, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3919046722, "stage_ordering_ns": 2402876797, "stage_eval_ns": 5746560795, "stage_threat_ns": 14455671381, "stage_proof_ns": 2173698767, "tactical_annotations": 1707613, "root_tactical_annotations": 4207, "search_tactical_annotations": 1703406, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 530702, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3131500923, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2582494, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10500460594, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 167226, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5382696210, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 265342, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 381024476, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 51430, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 317998509, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 530684, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60865871, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 526710, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 453695320, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 649467, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1865887134, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 531436, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 63821008, "child_limit_applications": 77257, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 77257, "child_cap_hits": 77257, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 77257, "child_moves_before_total": 6960220, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6960220, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 918685, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 918685, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.09177161940018, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.891284932109711, "tt_hits": 46435, "tt_cutoffs": 6138, "beta_cutoffs": 63063, "depth_sum": 102, "avg_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 102, "avg_effective_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2078.777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2485.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 1225, "avg_search_time_ms": 72.05882352941177, "search_nodes": 42782, "safety_nodes": 1927, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 44709, "avg_nodes": 2629.9411764705883, "eval_calls": 40302, "avg_eval_calls": 2370.705882352941, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40302, "pattern_eval_ns": 798962, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.824375961490745, "pattern_frame_queries": 40302, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 798962, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.824375961490745, "pattern_frame_updates": 85464, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 693388991, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8113.228856594589, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2447, "avg_candidate_generations": 143.94117647058823, "candidate_moves_total": 194805, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.60972619534124, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1261, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 2430, "search_candidate_moves_total": 193544, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 5529, "avg_legality_checks": 325.2352941176471, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5529, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 229012, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13471.29411764706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 459128811, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2004.8242493843118, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1419, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 83.47058823529412, "renju_forbidden_ns": 7993665, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5633.30866807611, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17490, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1401, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7915085, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61090, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12870025, "stage_ordering_ns": 73950, "stage_eval_ns": 694187953, "stage_threat_ns": 495840610, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 85481, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 434458626, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 408712, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15541, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42732, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 51797948, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 85464, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9175324, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2257, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6758.176470588235, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7228.764705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1093, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9852, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 109, 95, 98, 127, 143, 125, 140, 126, 128, 79, 63, 65, 80, 124, 123, 158, 142, 113, 114, 141, 156, 100, 170 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 3568, "avg_search_time_ms": 297.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 124321, "safety_nodes": 892, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 125213, "avg_nodes": 10434.416666666666, "eval_calls": 119474, "avg_eval_calls": 9956.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 119474, "pattern_eval_ns": 2345208, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.629442389139058, "pattern_frame_queries": 119474, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2345208, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.629442389139058, "pattern_frame_updates": 248572, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2047511652, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8237.096905524355, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4824, "avg_candidate_generations": 402.0, "candidate_moves_total": 317188, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.75207296849088, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 4812, "search_candidate_moves_total": 316466, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 115328, "avg_legality_checks": 9610.666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 114606, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 809811, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 67484.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1401378854, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1730.5011342152675, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8471, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 705.9166666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 34272933, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4045.9134694841223, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 69751, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8454, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34203182, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.083333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 259440, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5294.693877551021, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 128260, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1943.3333333333333, "stage_move_gen_ns": 221406766, "stage_ordering_ns": 151210, "stage_eval_ns": 2049856860, "stage_threat_ns": 1274619670, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 248584, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1109503013, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 363510, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124286, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 139971318, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 248572, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24781829, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 265, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4276, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5795.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6462.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1814, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6274, "avg_search_time_ms": 522.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 61599, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 569, "corridor_branch_probes": 732, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 181, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 25, "corridor_plies_followed": 558, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 558, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 18, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 181, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 18, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 17, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 37, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 7988320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 63207, "avg_nodes": 5267.25, "eval_calls": 35946, "avg_eval_calls": 2995.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35946, "pattern_eval_ns": 743462, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.682746341734823, "pattern_frame_queries": 35946, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 743462, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.682746341734823, "pattern_frame_updates": 123066, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1083511624, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8804.313327807842, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23480, "avg_candidate_generations": 1956.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1589211, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.68360306643952, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 744, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 23468, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1588467, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 799803, "avg_legality_checks": 66650.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 68, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 799803, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 68, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2190926, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 182577.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3971531807, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1812.7183697669386, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11037, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 919.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15249899, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1381.7068949895804, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 422620, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2200, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9135355, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8765, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5691924, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64846, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5403.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 493903644, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7616.562995404497, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 85887, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7157.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 207464051, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2415.5466019304436, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1666712551, "stage_ordering_ns": 544259436, "stage_eval_ns": 1084255086, "stage_threat_ns": 2915692060, "stage_proof_ns": 19052633, "tactical_annotations": 315332, "root_tactical_annotations": 456, "search_tactical_annotations": 314876, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 124230, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 647285799, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 321178, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2161505287, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47372, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1434224891, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 62109, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80766031, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1152, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4417940, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 124218, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13696531, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 40933, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 139813338, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 196445, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 571091620, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 77954, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8020472, "child_limit_applications": 23468, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23468, "child_cap_hits": 23468, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23468, "child_moves_before_total": 1588399, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1588399, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 216400, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 216400, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.68361172660644, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.221066984830408, "tt_hits": 10263, "tt_cutoffs": 2120, "beta_cutoffs": 18759, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4702.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5369.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1094, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29421, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 129, 109, 108, 81, 123, 125, 80, 93, 141, 127, 143, 79, 63, 94, 145, 161, 142, 144, 140, 139, 124, 92, 91, 107, 156, 172, 121, 77, 61, 122, 62, 137 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 27113, "avg_search_time_ms": 1506.2777777777778, "search_nodes": 221265, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 36611, "corridor_branch_probes": 38947, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 20053, "corridor_neutral_exits": 26, "corridor_terminal_exits": 36, "corridor_plies_followed": 36557, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 36557, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 103, "corridor_proof_active": 54, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 20053, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 103, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 103, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 768, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 67567360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 258673, "avg_nodes": 14370.722222222223, "eval_calls": 140228, "avg_eval_calls": 7790.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 140228, "pattern_eval_ns": 2807604, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.021707504920556, "pattern_frame_queries": 140228, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2807604, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.021707504920556, "pattern_frame_updates": 442322, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4633530129, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10475.468389544269, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 74914, "avg_candidate_generations": 4161.888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 6411885, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.58994313479457, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 74896, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6410583, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1626890, "avg_legality_checks": 90382.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1552, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1625588, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1552, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9445687, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 524760.3888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16645239468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1762.2052761223192, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54253, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3014.0555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 268141590, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4942.428805780325, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2778, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20186657, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23063, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 143091529, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25306, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 84409641, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3106, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 20453763, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 254721, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14151.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1839899927, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7223.19685852364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 334720, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18595.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 798588575, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2385.8406279875717, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3267725405, "stage_ordering_ns": 2129816004, "stage_eval_ns": 4636337733, "stage_threat_ns": 14288322818, "stage_proof_ns": 2704299079, "tactical_annotations": 1615499, "root_tactical_annotations": 4128, "search_tactical_annotations": 1611371, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 515660, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3048340500, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2838098, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10292591565, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 166324, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4892764038, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 257821, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 371366936, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 73320, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 445693479, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 515642, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55884265, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 461946, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 405183496, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 599196, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1573130763, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 554357, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 74446073, "child_limit_applications": 74896, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 74896, "child_cap_hits": 74896, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 74896, "child_moves_before_total": 6409031, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6409031, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 900153, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 900153, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.57240707113864, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.018705938901943, "tt_hits": 46476, "tt_cutoffs": 6037, "beta_cutoffs": 61840, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3938.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4382.944444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1827, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 2291, "avg_search_time_ms": 134.76470588235293, "search_nodes": 83574, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85465, "avg_nodes": 5027.35294117647, "eval_calls": 80904, "avg_eval_calls": 4759.058823529412, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80904, "pattern_eval_ns": 1580284, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.532829031939087, "pattern_frame_queries": 80904, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1580284, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.532829031939087, "pattern_frame_updates": 167048, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1355411910, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8113.9068411474545, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2637, "avg_candidate_generations": 155.11764705882354, "candidate_moves_total": 209213, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.33750474023512, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1235, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2620, "search_candidate_moves_total": 207978, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5654, "avg_legality_checks": 332.5882352941176, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5654, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 486464, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 28615.529411764706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 868754170, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1785.855006742534, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4192, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 246.58823529411765, "renju_forbidden_ns": 25684799, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6127.098998091603, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 68900, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4169, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25501829, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 114070, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12040004, "stage_ordering_ns": 81070, "stage_eval_ns": 1356992194, "stage_threat_ns": 897413618, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 167065, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 783127971, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 388061, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 83524, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96343252, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 167048, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17554334, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2451, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6787.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7257.588235294118, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1991, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1095, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18420, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 95, 141, 96, 159, 175, 144, 142, 156, 93, 171, 126, 94, 100, 86, 80, 64, 110, 125, 68, 186, 201, 124, 116, 115, 84, 52, 132 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 9435, "avg_search_time_ms": 589.6875, "search_nodes": 303887, "safety_nodes": 590, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 304477, "avg_nodes": 19029.8125, "eval_calls": 294779, "avg_eval_calls": 18423.6875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 294779, "pattern_eval_ns": 5677779, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.261138005081772, "pattern_frame_queries": 294779, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5677779, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.261138005081772, "pattern_frame_updates": 607682, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5838406798, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9607.6678229732, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9078, "avg_candidate_generations": 567.375, "candidate_moves_total": 818159, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.12546816479401, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1280, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 9062, "search_candidate_moves_total": 816879, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 282850, "avg_legality_checks": 17678.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "root_legality_checks": 1280, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 281570, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2261522, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 141345.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4116609110, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1820.2825840296932, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29993, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1874.5625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 176594829, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5887.868135898376, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 111, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 806591, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29882, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 175788238, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.1875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 159040, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8370.526315789473, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 78640, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3024.6153846153848, "stage_move_gen_ns": 541221956, "stage_ordering_ns": 302622, "stage_eval_ns": 5844084577, "stage_threat_ns": 2993367607, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 607698, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2603475367, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 225930, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12070, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 303841, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 331520698, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 607682, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58145612, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 815, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7963, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6272.0625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6772.0625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1799, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 8969, "avg_search_time_ms": 597.9333333333333, "search_nodes": 83860, "safety_nodes": 1782, "corridor_nodes": 334, "corridor_branch_probes": 428, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 17, "corridor_depth_exits": 107, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 321, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 321, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 40, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 27, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 107, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 40, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 40, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 194, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 36043600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85976, "avg_nodes": 5731.733333333334, "eval_calls": 50312, "avg_eval_calls": 3354.133333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50312, "pattern_eval_ns": 1017132, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.21648910796629, "pattern_frame_queries": 50312, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1017132, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.21648910796629, "pattern_frame_updates": 167540, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1448169241, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8643.72234093351, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29880, "avg_candidate_generations": 1992.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2431172, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.36452476572958, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1199, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 29865, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2429973, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 1245508, "avg_legality_checks": 83033.86666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 330, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1245508, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 330, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3080879, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 205391.93333333332, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5651451844, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1834.3634540661935, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16281, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1085.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31628085, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1942.6377372397274, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 515, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3386847, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3612, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16207113, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12154, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12034125, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99320, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6621.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 779327820, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7846.635320177205, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 133784, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8918.933333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 335658501, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2508.9584778448843, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2571118462, "stage_ordering_ns": 861043025, "stage_eval_ns": 1449186373, "stage_threat_ns": 3979776271, "stage_proof_ns": 52071275, "tactical_annotations": 448614, "root_tactical_annotations": 917, "search_tactical_annotations": 447697, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 168277, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 873862173, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 427574, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2962806528, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60151, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1840271408, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84131, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 111343489, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 722, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3255706, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 168262, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18569901, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71387, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 257891268, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 274620, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 852622027, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 102607, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9938474, "child_limit_applications": 29865, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29865, "child_cap_hits": 29865, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29865, "child_moves_before_total": 2429643, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2429643, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 302901, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 302901, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.35419387242591, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.142340532395782, "tt_hits": 14004, "tt_cutoffs": 3593, "beta_cutoffs": 23875, "depth_sum": 89, "avg_depth": 5.933333333333334, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 89, "avg_effective_depth": 5.933333333333334, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5352.733333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5886.066666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 483, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1096, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 7589, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 95, 99, 96, 129, 79, 63, 94, 97, 81, 144, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6499, "avg_search_time_ms": 812.375, "search_nodes": 67335, "safety_nodes": 342, "corridor_nodes": 103, "corridor_branch_probes": 130, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 99, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 99, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 35, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 35, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 275, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 236400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 67780, "avg_nodes": 8472.5, "eval_calls": 40795, "avg_eval_calls": 5099.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40795, "pattern_eval_ns": 832783, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.413849736487315, "pattern_frame_queries": 40795, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 832783, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.413849736487315, "pattern_frame_updates": 134582, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1321296417, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9817.779621346093, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24867, "avg_candidate_generations": 3108.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1855398, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.61286041742068, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 468, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 24859, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1854930, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 597332, "avg_legality_checks": 74666.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 603, "root_legality_checks": 468, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 596864, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 603, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1961702, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 245212.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3939941277, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2008.43006583059, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14597, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1824.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61750860, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4230.380215112695, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 654, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6673934, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4429, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34499849, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9456, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20489056, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 58, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 88021, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45002, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5625.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 372878491, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8285.820430203103, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 62434, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7804.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 152923247, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2449.358474549124, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1344680895, "stage_ordering_ns": 695435867, "stage_eval_ns": 1322129200, "stage_threat_ns": 3027522835, "stage_proof_ns": 77442191, "tactical_annotations": 248399, "root_tactical_annotations": 1321, "search_tactical_annotations": 247078, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 134858, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 707412120, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 226289, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2204206408, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49958, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1645996595, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67425, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90254072, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 268, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1268495, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 134850, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15040122, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 36788, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 60812470, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 130691, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 477923376, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 80920, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9341618, "child_limit_applications": 24859, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24859, "child_cap_hits": 24859, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24859, "child_moves_before_total": 1854327, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1854327, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 213756, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 213756, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.59378896978961, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.59873687598053, "tt_hits": 13217, "tt_cutoffs": 1637, "beta_cutoffs": 19570, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2992.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3992.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1502, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1083, "avg_search_time_ms": 154.71428571428572, "search_nodes": 38407, "safety_nodes": 526, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 38933, "avg_nodes": 5561.857142857143, "eval_calls": 36196, "avg_eval_calls": 5170.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36196, "pattern_eval_ns": 735083, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.308404243562826, "pattern_frame_queries": 36196, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 735083, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.308404243562826, "pattern_frame_updates": 76774, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 575243963, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7492.692356787454, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2198, "avg_candidate_generations": 314.0, "candidate_moves_total": 147949, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.31073703366697, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 407, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 2191, "search_candidate_moves_total": 147542, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 4717, "avg_legality_checks": 673.8571428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4717, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 140059, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20008.428571428572, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 318569379, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2274.53700940318, "renju_forbidden_checks": 832, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 118.85714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 7371024, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8859.403846153846, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 832, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7371024, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12674664, "stage_ordering_ns": 69080, "stage_eval_ns": 575979046, "stage_threat_ns": 483541524, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 76781, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 423890047, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 20, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 213710, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38387, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 50513043, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 76774, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8924724, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 122, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1961, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4879.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6022.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1097, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 37225, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 83, 95, 98, 139, 153, 140, 110, 94, 53, 93, 96, 68, 158, 174, 84, 70, 157, 172, 82, 81, 66, 50, 156, 155, 114, 130, 69, 91, 92, 123, 107, 109, 137, 67 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 22159, "avg_search_time_ms": 1166.2631578947369, "search_nodes": 581739, "safety_nodes": 694, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 582433, "avg_nodes": 30654.36842105263, "eval_calls": 568807, "avg_eval_calls": 29937.21052631579, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 568807, "pattern_eval_ns": 11499505, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.216883758462888, "pattern_frame_queries": 568807, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11499505, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.216883758462888, "pattern_frame_updates": 1163366, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 13719762242, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11793.160743910343, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12895, "avg_candidate_generations": 678.6842105263158, "candidate_moves_total": 1175877, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.18860023264831, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1584, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 12876, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1174293, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 545814, "avg_legality_checks": 28727.052631578947, "illegal_moves_skipped": 290, "root_legality_checks": 1584, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 544230, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 290, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4308863, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 226782.26315789475, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9837552812, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2283.0971446527774, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60874, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3203.8947368421054, "renju_forbidden_ns": 490646802, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8060.038801458751, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 536, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3388732, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 60338, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 487258070, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 191840, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10096.842105263158, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.368421052631579, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 91820, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3531.5384615384614, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1269736768, "stage_ordering_ns": 445682, "stage_eval_ns": 13731261747, "stage_threat_ns": 7101110367, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1163385, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6206823786, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 278880, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 581683, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 759530232, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1163366, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 134477469, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 942, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 11446, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15789473684210525, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5613.578947368421, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6034.631578947368, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 722, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 15048, "avg_search_time_ms": 792.0, "search_nodes": 122101, "safety_nodes": 2503, "corridor_nodes": 1530, "corridor_branch_probes": 1907, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 59, "corridor_depth_exits": 618, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1512, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1512, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 65, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 618, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 50, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 217, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 46065360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2008880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 126134, "avg_nodes": 6638.631578947368, "eval_calls": 72904, "avg_eval_calls": 3837.0526315789475, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72904, "pattern_eval_ns": 1527907, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.957793811039174, "pattern_frame_queries": 72904, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1527907, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.957793811039174, "pattern_frame_updates": 243974, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2330453652, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9552.05739955897, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42184, "avg_candidate_generations": 2220.2105263157896, "candidate_moves_total": 3776090, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.51474492698654, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1610, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 42165, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3774480, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 2087100, "avg_legality_checks": 109847.36842105263, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2374, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2087100, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2374, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4697579, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 247241.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9438880985, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2009.3075571480545, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55792, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2936.4210526315787, "renju_forbidden_ns": 133734565, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2397.020450960711, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6774, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34123750, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11275, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 45347884, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37695, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 54142030, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 120901, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 155649, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8192.052631578947, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1292970080, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8306.960404499869, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 205291, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10804.78947368421, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 531814573, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2590.540125967529, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4690015470, "stage_ordering_ns": 1401308297, "stage_eval_ns": 2331981559, "stage_threat_ns": 6468749476, "stage_proof_ns": 67664153, "tactical_annotations": 864138, "root_tactical_annotations": 1003, "search_tactical_annotations": 863135, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 247119, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1439759634, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 827785, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4772914731, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 85284, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2746993518, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123550, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 181024494, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3126, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19344671, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 247100, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29968180, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 169235, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 452247877, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 491277, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1513914674, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 203626, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 25737766, "child_limit_applications": 42165, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42165, "child_cap_hits": 42165, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42165, "child_moves_before_total": 3772106, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3772106, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 499066, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 499066, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.46059528044587, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.83602513933357, "tt_hits": 22455, "tt_cutoffs": 6918, "beta_cutoffs": 34748, "depth_sum": 113, "avg_depth": 5.947368421052632, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 113, "avg_effective_depth": 5.947368421052632, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.10526315789473684, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5835.421052631579, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6256.473684210527, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 509, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1098, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 31194, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 125, 83, 98, 81, 157, 172, 141, 173, 143, 140, 84, 70, 171, 129, 113, 155, 99, 85, 69, 54, 156, 186, 159, 100, 115, 86, 114, 116, 160, 158, 175, 191, 130, 145, 146, 82, 162 ], "move_count": 43, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 29773, "avg_search_time_ms": 1488.65, "search_nodes": 380267, "safety_nodes": 1342, "corridor_nodes": 57789, "corridor_branch_probes": 61034, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 32749, "corridor_neutral_exits": 43, "corridor_terminal_exits": 70, "corridor_plies_followed": 57712, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 57712, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 164, "corridor_proof_active": 77, "corridor_proof_quiet": 87, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 43, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 32749, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 70, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 164, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 162, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1309, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 91340400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 439398, "avg_nodes": 21969.9, "eval_calls": 251767, "avg_eval_calls": 12588.35, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 251767, "pattern_eval_ns": 4460352, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 17.71618996929701, "pattern_frame_queries": 251767, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4460352, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 17.71618996929701, "pattern_frame_updates": 760310, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5802279830, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7631.465888913733, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 117338, "avg_candidate_generations": 5866.9, "candidate_moves_total": 10471308, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.24055293255383, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1523, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 117318, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10469785, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 3348279, "avg_legality_checks": 167413.95, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5910, "root_legality_checks": 1523, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 3346756, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5908, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15607368, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 780368.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17803329806, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1140.700328588395, "renju_forbidden_checks": 98716, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4935.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 303976585, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3079.3041148344746, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6579, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30554198, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 46465, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 199323161, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 40366, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 66527678, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5306, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7571548, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 383827, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19191.35, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1725326188, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4495.062067024988, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 497402, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 24870.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 726186663, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1459.959274389729, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4624435516, "stage_ordering_ns": 2338933652, "stage_eval_ns": 5806740182, "stage_threat_ns": 14838797994, "stage_proof_ns": 2008957050, "tactical_annotations": 2690676, "root_tactical_annotations": 5245, "search_tactical_annotations": 2685431, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 876082, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3454752925, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 4450173, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10349187335, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 259679, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5340430295, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 438031, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 441221542, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 115752, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 447258758, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 876062, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67817952, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 757915, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 395891928, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1073712, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1917527046, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 859049, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 78559482, "child_limit_applications": 117318, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 117318, "child_cap_hits": 117318, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 117318, "child_moves_before_total": 10463877, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10463877, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 1413971, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1413971, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.19242571472408, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.052464242486234, "tt_hits": 67345, "tt_cutoffs": 11070, "beta_cutoffs": 92418, "depth_sum": 111, "avg_depth": 5.55, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 111, "avg_effective_depth": 5.55, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2284.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2684.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 1402, "avg_search_time_ms": 73.78947368421052, "search_nodes": 87493, "safety_nodes": 1696, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 89189, "avg_nodes": 4694.1578947368425, "eval_calls": 82817, "avg_eval_calls": 4358.789473684211, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82817, "pattern_eval_ns": 1437166, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 17.35351437506792, "pattern_frame_queries": 82817, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1437166, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 17.35351437506792, "pattern_frame_updates": 174874, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 720003159, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 4117.2681988174345, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4639, "avg_candidate_generations": 244.1578947368421, "candidate_moves_total": 375380, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.91830135805131, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1436, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 4620, "search_candidate_moves_total": 373944, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 14302, "avg_legality_checks": 752.7368421052631, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 14302, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 317372, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16703.78947368421, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 388064829, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1222.7443788361923, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1118, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 58.8421052631579, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5121370, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4580.831842576029, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23680, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1102, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 5066200, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 31490, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23840261, "stage_ordering_ns": 129100, "stage_eval_ns": 721440325, "stage_threat_ns": 630222775, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 174893, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 545859990, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 50, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 269642, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 87437, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 71355639, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 174874, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12737504, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 310, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4122, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6876.0526315789475, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7297.105263157895, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1099, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14209, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 80, 129, 81, 145, 161, 128, 125, 95, 79, 127, 130, 78, 96, 83, 64, 48, 109, 108, 94, 49, 124 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 4414, "avg_search_time_ms": 367.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 153421, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 154394, "avg_nodes": 12866.166666666666, "eval_calls": 148379, "avg_eval_calls": 12364.916666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 148379, "pattern_eval_ns": 2835703, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.111215198916288, "pattern_frame_queries": 148379, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2835703, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.111215198916288, "pattern_frame_updates": 306774, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2710275005, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8834.761110785139, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5020, "avg_candidate_generations": 418.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 388017, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.29422310756972, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 838, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 5008, "search_candidate_moves_total": 387179, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 143985, "avg_legality_checks": 11998.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 181, "root_legality_checks": 838, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 143147, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 181, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1202462, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 100205.16666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1902112300, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1581.8481581954356, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16617, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1384.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 74915637, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4508.373172052717, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 183, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 927845, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16429, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73982752, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5040, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.9166666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 289871, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6167.468085106383, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.416666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 140290, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2158.3076923076924, "stage_move_gen_ns": 255943534, "stage_ordering_ns": 148420, "stage_eval_ns": 2713110708, "stage_threat_ns": 1413676623, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 306786, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1229174114, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 385361, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 153387, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156509633, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 306774, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27607515, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 267, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4487, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5824.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6490.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1786, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9781, "avg_search_time_ms": 889.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 105307, "safety_nodes": 765, "corridor_nodes": 1305, "corridor_branch_probes": 1514, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 604, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1289, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1289, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 77, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 61, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 604, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 77, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 76, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 575, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 30103760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 107377, "avg_nodes": 9761.545454545454, "eval_calls": 64782, "avg_eval_calls": 5889.272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64782, "pattern_eval_ns": 1256072, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.38921305300855, "pattern_frame_queries": 64782, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1256072, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.38921305300855, "pattern_frame_updates": 210486, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1721365591, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8178.052654333304, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 36933, "avg_candidate_generations": 3357.5454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 3024765, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.89870847209812, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 770, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 36922, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3023995, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1941954, "avg_legality_checks": 176541.27272727274, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3591, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1941954, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3591, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4548799, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 413527.1818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6250569452, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1374.114233669151, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38283, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3480.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 115454857, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3015.825745108795, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3684, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22767699, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11533, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 63695683, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23066, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28991475, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 152881, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13898.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 932291367, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6098.150633499257, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 206938, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18812.545454545456, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 419913568, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2029.175733794663, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2978333651, "stage_ordering_ns": 785678191, "stage_eval_ns": 1722621663, "stage_threat_ns": 4135551788, "stage_proof_ns": 82451602, "tactical_annotations": 662066, "root_tactical_annotations": 1878, "search_tactical_annotations": 660188, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 213229, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 892664898, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 596327, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3076320822, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 74741, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1788105691, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 106609, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 116051992, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2732, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9524495, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 213218, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19470805, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 120074, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 348285934, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 330347, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 906511167, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 211645, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21518776, "child_limit_applications": 36922, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 36922, "child_cap_hits": 36922, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 36922, "child_moves_before_total": 3020404, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3020404, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 395116, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 395116, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.80499431233412, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.701370456638319, "tt_hits": 20076, "tt_cutoffs": 3539, "beta_cutoffs": 29868, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 5.818181818181818, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 5.818181818181818, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3950.5454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4677.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1502, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1100, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12097, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 81, 129, 127, 98, 95, 143, 109, 108, 67, 53, 123 ], "move_count": 17, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 7823, "avg_search_time_ms": 1117.5714285714287, "search_nodes": 76291, "safety_nodes": 319, "corridor_nodes": 95, "corridor_branch_probes": 113, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 28, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 91, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 91, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 33, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 29, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 33, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 273, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 324320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 76705, "avg_nodes": 10957.857142857143, "eval_calls": 48139, "avg_eval_calls": 6877.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48139, "pattern_eval_ns": 999355, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.759778973389558, "pattern_frame_queries": 48139, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 999355, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.759778973389558, "pattern_frame_updates": 152516, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1699692943, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11144.358250937606, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26481, "avg_candidate_generations": 3783.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1921374, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.55670103092784, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 395, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 26474, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1920979, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 664124, "avg_legality_checks": 94874.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1277, "root_legality_checks": 395, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 663729, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1277, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2190093, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 312870.4285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4745543251, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2166.8227107250696, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17150, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2450.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 100040383, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5833.258483965014, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13695399, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6983, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60516559, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8816, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25778835, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 49590, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50012, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7144.571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 438831517, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8774.52445413101, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66903, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9557.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 187211180, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2798.2479111549555, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1617183442, "stage_ordering_ns": 802330663, "stage_eval_ns": 1700692298, "stage_threat_ns": 3603486565, "stage_proof_ns": 65835591, "tactical_annotations": 249776, "root_tactical_annotations": 1321, "search_tactical_annotations": 248455, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152771, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 873751360, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 231184, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2590111259, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53163, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1945265617, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76382, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 109916684, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 248, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 981214, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152764, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18572394, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 34370, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 43880520, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 136649, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 589348006, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78757, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10153654, "child_limit_applications": 26474, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26474, "child_cap_hits": 26474, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26474, "child_moves_before_total": 1919702, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1919702, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 231642, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 231642, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.5127294704238, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.749792248999018, "tt_hits": 13642, "tt_cutoffs": 1645, "beta_cutoffs": 20281, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.42857142857142855, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1448.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2334.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 240, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 4269, "avg_search_time_ms": 711.5, "search_nodes": 142815, "safety_nodes": 317, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 143132, "avg_nodes": 23855.333333333332, "eval_calls": 139429, "avg_eval_calls": 23238.166666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 139429, "pattern_eval_ns": 2814718, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.187464587711307, "pattern_frame_queries": 139429, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2814718, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.187464587711307, "pattern_frame_updates": 285596, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2431246500, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8512.887085253295, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3375, "avg_candidate_generations": 562.5, "candidate_moves_total": 220115, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.21925925925926, "candidate_moves_max": 82, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 330, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 3369, "search_candidate_moves_total": 219785, "search_candidate_moves_max": 82, "legality_checks": 5514, "avg_legality_checks": 919.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5514, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 590233, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 98372.16666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1318812526, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2234.3930718885595, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6316, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1052.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 58900826, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9325.653261557947, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6316, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 58900826, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14751127, "stage_ordering_ns": 101181, "stage_eval_ns": 2434061218, "stage_threat_ns": 1817456701, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 285602, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1590748836, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 16, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 77140, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 12, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4720, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 142798, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 191281123, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 285596, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35349602, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 110, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3025, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2773.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4063.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1927, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1101, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10933, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 84, 141, 99, 155, 169, 126, 81, 83, 69, 111, 156, 54, 98, 129, 67, 52, 70, 56, 68, 66, 71 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 1913, "avg_search_time_ms": 159.41666666666666, "search_nodes": 77542, "safety_nodes": 957, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 78499, "avg_nodes": 6541.583333333333, "eval_calls": 74193, "avg_eval_calls": 6182.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74193, "pattern_eval_ns": 1338225, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.037078969714123, "pattern_frame_queries": 74193, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1338225, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.037078969714123, "pattern_frame_updates": 155016, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1180734007, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7616.852499096867, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3327, "avg_candidate_generations": 277.25, "candidate_moves_total": 260441, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.28103396453261, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 831, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 3315, "search_candidate_moves_total": 259610, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 70022, "avg_legality_checks": 5835.166666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 148, "root_legality_checks": 831, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 69191, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 147, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 643789, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 53649.083333333336, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 853507972, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1325.7573086834352, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11723, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 976.9166666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42049836, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3586.9518041456963, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 150, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 660237, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11563, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 41358929, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 30670, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 291460, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6072.083333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 141140, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2138.4848484848485, "stage_move_gen_ns": 101787438, "stage_ordering_ns": 99020, "stage_eval_ns": 1182072232, "stage_threat_ns": 604253250, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 155028, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 523769373, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 386940, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77508, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68045632, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 155016, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12051305, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 267, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2910, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6210.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6876.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1864, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9009, "avg_search_time_ms": 819.0, "search_nodes": 100551, "safety_nodes": 758, "corridor_nodes": 1245, "corridor_branch_probes": 1437, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 574, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 1230, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1230, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 77, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 62, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 574, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 77, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 76, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 575, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 30133120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 102554, "avg_nodes": 9323.09090909091, "eval_calls": 61355, "avg_eval_calls": 5577.727272727273, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 61355, "pattern_eval_ns": 1148679, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.721848260125498, "pattern_frame_queries": 61355, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1148679, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.721848260125498, "pattern_frame_updates": 200974, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1517406083, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7550.260645655657, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35689, "avg_candidate_generations": 3244.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 2864218, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.25492448653647, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 763, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 35678, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2863455, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1775012, "avg_legality_checks": 161364.72727272726, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2436, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1775012, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2436, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4224610, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 384055.45454545453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5763144583, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1364.1838141272212, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33234, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3021.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 82520368, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2483.010411024854, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2537, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16657961, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8315, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 42134992, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22377, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23698735, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 28680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 141029, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12820.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 876394272, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6214.284097596948, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 193714, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17610.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 404321229, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2087.2070629897685, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2731403941, "stage_ordering_ns": 734109151, "stage_eval_ns": 1518554762, "stage_threat_ns": 3872221925, "stage_proof_ns": 80191400, "tactical_annotations": 637428, "root_tactical_annotations": 1878, "search_tactical_annotations": 635550, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 203599, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 831480352, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 568451, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2888101446, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 72230, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1685908363, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 101794, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107896542, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2614, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8995158, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 203588, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18393213, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116019, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 343529682, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 312184, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 827187080, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 209225, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17355214, "child_limit_applications": 35678, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35678, "child_cap_hits": 35678, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35678, "child_moves_before_total": 2861019, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2861019, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 383921, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 383921, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.19000504512584, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.760720892426706, "tt_hits": 19591, "tt_cutoffs": 3454, "beta_cutoffs": 28797, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 5.818181818181818, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 5.818181818181818, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4179.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4906.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1646, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1102, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11674, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 53, 95, 111, 125, 68, 155, 169, 110, 140, 65, 80, 79, 38, 23, 98 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 10154, "avg_search_time_ms": 781.0769230769231, "search_nodes": 138128, "safety_nodes": 699, "corridor_nodes": 8367, "corridor_branch_probes": 9062, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3740, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 8329, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8329, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 85, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3740, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 85, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 82, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 650, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 63464160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2024480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 15, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 13, "total_nodes": 147194, "avg_nodes": 11322.615384615385, "eval_calls": 88397, "avg_eval_calls": 6799.7692307692305, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 88397, "pattern_eval_ns": 1642224, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.57782503931129, "pattern_frame_queries": 88397, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1642224, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.57782503931129, "pattern_frame_updates": 276114, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2158381746, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7816.994958604055, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46395, "avg_candidate_generations": 3568.846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 3741747, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.64978984804397, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 864, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 46382, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3740883, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 1025448, "avg_legality_checks": 78880.61538461539, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1525, "root_legality_checks": 864, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1024584, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1525, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4781969, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 367843.76923076925, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6065411699, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1268.392099363254, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28823, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2217.153846153846, "renju_forbidden_ns": 105134367, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3647.5858515768655, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1660, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7158730, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13435, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 65961100, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12258, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25926337, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1470, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6088200, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 109769, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8443.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 548042465, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4992.688873907934, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 145360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11181.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 243019361, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1671.8448059988993, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1554921349, "stage_ordering_ns": 941187330, "stage_eval_ns": 2160023970, "stage_threat_ns": 4916742086, "stage_proof_ns": 523061688, "tactical_annotations": 708793, "root_tactical_annotations": 2451, "search_tactical_annotations": 706342, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 292955, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1148990392, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1009393, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3515155237, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 97248, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2231635482, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 146471, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 153259726, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 16828, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 55646032, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 292942, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24631380, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 185788, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 139064432, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 258184, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 554951262, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 264821, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19059319, "child_limit_applications": 46382, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46382, "child_cap_hits": 46382, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46382, "child_moves_before_total": 3739358, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3739358, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 465746, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 465746, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.62088741322064, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.041524729420896, "tt_hits": 28680, "tt_cutoffs": 3278, "beta_cutoffs": 37284, "depth_sum": 71, "avg_depth": 5.461538461538462, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 71, "avg_effective_depth": 5.461538461538462, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4968.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5584.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1122, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 1505, "avg_search_time_ms": 125.41666666666667, "search_nodes": 78865, "safety_nodes": 1258, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 80123, "avg_nodes": 6676.916666666667, "eval_calls": 76614, "avg_eval_calls": 6384.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 76614, "pattern_eval_ns": 1371209, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 17.89762967603832, "pattern_frame_queries": 76614, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1371209, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 17.89762967603832, "pattern_frame_updates": 157660, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 902378122, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5723.570480781428, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2228, "avg_candidate_generations": 185.66666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 163131, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.21858168761221, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 794, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 2216, "search_candidate_moves_total": 162337, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 3942, "avg_legality_checks": 328.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3942, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 477719, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 39809.916666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 563233297, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1179.0054341568998, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3726, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 310.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13974889, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3750.641170155663, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3726, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13974889, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6283838, "stage_ordering_ns": 59711, "stage_eval_ns": 903749331, "stage_threat_ns": 573066095, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 157672, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 496621926, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 252912, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6890, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78830, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 64430482, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 157660, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11760775, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 80, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2035, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6225.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6892.416666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1103, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11545, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 126, 141, 99, 143, 98, 155, 169, 140, 142, 158, 100, 173, 128, 188, 203, 156, 101, 97, 102 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3975, "avg_search_time_ms": 361.3636363636364, "search_nodes": 101499, "safety_nodes": 671, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 102170, "avg_nodes": 9288.181818181818, "eval_calls": 97804, "avg_eval_calls": 8891.272727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 97804, "pattern_eval_ns": 1993562, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.38323585947405, "pattern_frame_queries": 97804, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1993562, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.38323585947405, "pattern_frame_updates": 202936, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2399803939, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11825.422492805614, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3675, "avg_candidate_generations": 334.09090909090907, "candidate_moves_total": 247290, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.28979591836735, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 699, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 3664, "search_candidate_moves_total": 246591, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 92992, "avg_legality_checks": 8453.818181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 699, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 92293, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 706353, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 64213.90909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1683311964, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2383.1030150647057, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7642, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 694.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64773311, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8475.963229521069, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 405730, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7600, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64367581, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 30, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.727272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 250351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8345.033333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.4545454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 94321, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2482.1315789473683, "stage_move_gen_ns": 234091852, "stage_ordering_ns": 120762, "stage_eval_ns": 2401797501, "stage_threat_ns": 1323274013, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 202947, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1159565005, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 364221, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 101468, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 138543647, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 202936, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24801140, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 241, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3260, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5519.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6246.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1800, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7560, "avg_search_time_ms": 756.0, "search_nodes": 63261, "safety_nodes": 972, "corridor_nodes": 167, "corridor_branch_probes": 214, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 54, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 158, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 158, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 29, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 20, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 29, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 167, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26018880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 64400, "avg_nodes": 6440.0, "eval_calls": 38677, "avg_eval_calls": 3867.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38677, "pattern_eval_ns": 811141, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.972179848488764, "pattern_frame_queries": 38677, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 811141, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.972179848488764, "pattern_frame_updates": 126404, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1228024320, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9715.074839403816, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22236, "avg_candidate_generations": 2223.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1667569, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.99410865263536, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 636, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 22226, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1666933, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 886846, "avg_legality_checks": 88684.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 419, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 886846, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 419, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2298374, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 229837.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4830287583, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2101.610783536535, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7574, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 757.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21162077, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2794.0423818325853, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 421, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4431616, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1463, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10193289, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5690, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6537172, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75622, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7562.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 688869277, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9109.376596757558, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 104152, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10415.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 308478993, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2961.8153564021814, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2123426564, "stage_ordering_ns": 708382343, "stage_eval_ns": 1228835461, "stage_threat_ns": 3410025577, "stage_proof_ns": 48314411, "tactical_annotations": 277287, "root_tactical_annotations": 863, "search_tactical_annotations": 276424, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 126788, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 751095323, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 262175, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2539828350, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44716, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1609039893, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 63389, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92606027, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 374, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2028318, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 126778, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15779946, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 41098, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 233132811, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 164853, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 689062708, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 71336, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8687613, "child_limit_applications": 22226, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22226, "child_cap_hits": 22226, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22226, "child_moves_before_total": 1666514, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1666514, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 207073, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 207073, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.98038333483308, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.316701160802664, "tt_hits": 10328, "tt_cutoffs": 2299, "beta_cutoffs": 17338, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 5.8, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 5.8, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3805.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4605.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 411, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1104, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12726, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 123, 81, 97, 83, 124, 85, 71, 82, 84, 79, 80, 65, 122, 121, 126 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 11606, "avg_search_time_ms": 892.7692307692307, "search_nodes": 150312, "safety_nodes": 699, "corridor_nodes": 9417, "corridor_branch_probes": 10298, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4436, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 30, "corridor_plies_followed": 9377, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9377, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 75, "corridor_proof_active": 40, "corridor_proof_quiet": 35, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4436, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 75, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 72, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 565, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 65477920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2024480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 160428, "avg_nodes": 12340.615384615385, "eval_calls": 97406, "avg_eval_calls": 7492.7692307692305, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 97406, "pattern_eval_ns": 1785867, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.33426072315874, "pattern_frame_queries": 97406, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1785867, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.33426072315874, "pattern_frame_updates": 300482, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2434748785, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8102.810767367097, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49201, "avg_candidate_generations": 3784.6923076923076, "candidate_moves_total": 4120507, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.74844007235625, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 864, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 49188, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4119643, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1222871, "avg_legality_checks": 94067.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1899, "root_legality_checks": 864, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1222007, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1899, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5321473, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 409344.07692307694, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6963240870, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1308.5175608332504, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34684, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2668.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 119757076, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3452.8046361434667, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2018, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9119285, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15299, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 74213776, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15391, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29340171, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1976, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7083844, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 132416, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10185.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 662310655, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5001.741896749638, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 175380, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13490.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 289501855, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1650.7119112783669, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1905699011, "stage_ordering_ns": 1077678728, "stage_eval_ns": 2436534652, "stage_threat_ns": 5545784240, "stage_proof_ns": 581821764, "tactical_annotations": 779074, "root_tactical_annotations": 2451, "search_tactical_annotations": 776623, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 319399, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1289901568, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1119317, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3972372643, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 103157, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2457587734, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 159693, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 169684606, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 18904, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 64694298, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 319386, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27240831, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 208846, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 165782825, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 305795, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 679541685, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 264433, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21890294, "child_limit_applications": 49188, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49188, "child_cap_hits": 49188, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49188, "child_moves_before_total": 4117744, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4117744, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 494216, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 494216, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.71440188663902, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.047491258030414, "tt_hits": 28951, "tt_cutoffs": 3647, "beta_cutoffs": 39152, "depth_sum": 71, "avg_depth": 5.461538461538462, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 71, "avg_effective_depth": 5.461538461538462, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4482.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5098.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 801, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 1106, "avg_search_time_ms": 92.16666666666667, "search_nodes": 48558, "safety_nodes": 1258, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49816, "avg_nodes": 4151.333333333333, "eval_calls": 46425, "avg_eval_calls": 3868.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46425, "pattern_eval_ns": 865441, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.641701669359183, "pattern_frame_queries": 46425, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 865441, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.641701669359183, "pattern_frame_updates": 97046, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 615372056, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6341.034725800136, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2110, "avg_candidate_generations": 175.83333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 151619, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.85734597156399, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 794, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 2098, "search_candidate_moves_total": 150825, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 4696, "avg_legality_checks": 391.3333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4696, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 227838, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18986.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 368543264, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1617.5671485880318, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1364, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 113.66666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5624028, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4123.187683284457, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1364, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 5624028, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9649618, "stage_ordering_ns": 60001, "stage_eval_ns": 616237497, "stage_threat_ns": 468091582, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 97058, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 408549657, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 268542, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48523, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 50309535, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 97046, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8963848, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 80, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1925, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6176.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6842.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1972, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1105, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13116, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 84, 125, 83, 139, 153, 126, 129, 99, 85, 127, 124, 86, 98, 81, 70, 56, 115, 116, 100, 55, 130 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 4483, "avg_search_time_ms": 373.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 170390, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 171363, "avg_nodes": 14280.25, "eval_calls": 164958, "avg_eval_calls": 13746.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 164958, "pattern_eval_ns": 3015065, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.277773736345008, "pattern_frame_queries": 164958, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3015065, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.277773736345008, "pattern_frame_updates": 340712, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2757299419, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8092.75698830684, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5410, "avg_candidate_generations": 450.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 418931, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.43641404805915, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 838, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 5398, "search_candidate_moves_total": 418093, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 160821, "avg_legality_checks": 13401.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 162, "root_legality_checks": 838, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 159983, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 162, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1318273, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 109856.08333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1923610246, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1459.189595781754, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19020, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1585.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 74073824, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3894.522818086225, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 212, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 850835, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18803, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73217939, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5050, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.9166666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 247730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5270.851063829788, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.416666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 119170, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1833.3846153846155, "stage_move_gen_ns": 262466319, "stage_ordering_ns": 153350, "stage_eval_ns": 2760314484, "stage_threat_ns": 1427030257, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 340724, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1236609077, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 327260, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 170356, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 160888423, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 340712, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29205497, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 267, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4875, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5881.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6548.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1878, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8622, "avg_search_time_ms": 783.8181818181819, "search_nodes": 108334, "safety_nodes": 765, "corridor_nodes": 1192, "corridor_branch_probes": 1393, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 546, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1176, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1176, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 77, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 61, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 546, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 77, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 76, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 575, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 30044000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 110291, "avg_nodes": 10026.454545454546, "eval_calls": 67028, "avg_eval_calls": 6093.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67028, "pattern_eval_ns": 1216306, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.14623739332816, "pattern_frame_queries": 67028, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1216306, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.14623739332816, "pattern_frame_updates": 216540, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1617232670, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7468.5169945506605, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37667, "avg_candidate_generations": 3424.2727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 3039156, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.6848434969602, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 770, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 37656, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3038386, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1909558, "avg_legality_checks": 173596.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9763, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1909558, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9763, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4583882, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 416716.54545454547, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5362446272, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1169.8482360584326, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58779, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5343.545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 215777356, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3670.9939944538014, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9854, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53799786, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21161, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 110677092, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 27764, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 51300478, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 154691, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14062.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 778029978, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5029.5749461830355, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 203511, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18501.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 349192361, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1715.84022976645, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2554819742, "stage_ordering_ns": 682482082, "stage_eval_ns": 1618448976, "stage_threat_ns": 3614017359, "stage_proof_ns": 73675583, "tactical_annotations": 672352, "root_tactical_annotations": 1878, "search_tactical_annotations": 670474, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 219057, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 779948004, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 604124, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2683226190, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 76169, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1575610259, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 109523, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 103869325, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2506, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9194675, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 219046, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17911839, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 119256, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 271320004, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 342994, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 805252834, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 210102, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19867326, "child_limit_applications": 37656, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37656, "child_cap_hits": 37656, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37656, "child_moves_before_total": 3028623, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3028623, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 399723, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 399723, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.42869662205226, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.615121096239642, "tt_hits": 20110, "tt_cutoffs": 3586, "beta_cutoffs": 30110, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 5.818181818181818, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 5.818181818181818, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4586.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5313.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1639, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1106, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20169, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 83, 125, 126, 95, 115, 116, 99, 131, 129, 84, 127, 141, 101, 139, 153, 143, 140, 154, 100, 102, 85, 71, 130, 145, 70 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 16822, "avg_search_time_ms": 1201.5714285714287, "search_nodes": 241008, "safety_nodes": 164, "corridor_nodes": 8554, "corridor_branch_probes": 9289, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4118, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 8511, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8511, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 112, "corridor_proof_active": 43, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4118, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 112, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 112, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 952, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 77467120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1988800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 249726, "avg_nodes": 17837.571428571428, "eval_calls": 162248, "avg_eval_calls": 11589.142857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 162248, "pattern_eval_ns": 2937634, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.1058256496228, "pattern_frame_queries": 162248, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2937634, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.1058256496228, "pattern_frame_updates": 481872, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4007602736, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8316.737092007836, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 72267, "avg_candidate_generations": 5161.928571428572, "candidate_moves_total": 5949476, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.32631768303652, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 963, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 72253, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5948513, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1954033, "avg_legality_checks": 139573.7857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4608, "root_legality_checks": 963, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1953070, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4607, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7886918, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 563351.2857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9950064198, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1261.5909279137934, "renju_forbidden_checks": 63063, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4504.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 223185471, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3539.0874363731505, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4897, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26733844, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 30166, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 143739898, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 27176, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 48947327, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 824, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3764402, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 216054, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15432.42857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1097246877, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5078.577008525646, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 291511, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20822.214285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 495945304, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1701.2919032214909, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2868420332, "stage_ordering_ns": 1497315460, "stage_eval_ns": 4010540370, "stage_threat_ns": 7825639902, "stage_proof_ns": 538075114, "tactical_annotations": 1406917, "root_tactical_annotations": 4466, "search_tactical_annotations": 1402451, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 499132, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1899722615, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1536251, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5524621069, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 148810, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3427265595, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 249559, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 261154566, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 17246, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 57847855, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 499118, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42271861, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 383814, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 250029425, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 555780, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1241650691, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 467323, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 40021936, "child_limit_applications": 72253, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 72253, "child_cap_hits": 72253, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 72253, "child_moves_before_total": 5943906, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5943906, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 907443, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 907443, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.26517930051347, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.55924321481461, "tt_hits": 42610, "tt_cutoffs": 6435, "beta_cutoffs": 56998, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3128.714285714286, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3700.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1092, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3332, "avg_search_time_ms": 256.3076923076923, "search_nodes": 150329, "safety_nodes": 1310, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 151639, "avg_nodes": 11664.538461538461, "eval_calls": 146166, "avg_eval_calls": 11243.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 146166, "pattern_eval_ns": 2772649, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.969178878809025, "pattern_frame_queries": 146166, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2772649, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.969178878809025, "pattern_frame_updates": 300582, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1873768887, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6233.80271273729, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4138, "avg_candidate_generations": 318.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 289440, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.94683421942968, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 884, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 4125, "search_candidate_moves_total": 288556, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 7630, "avg_legality_checks": 586.9230769230769, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7630, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 626219, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 48170.692307692305, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 977161837, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1560.415504799439, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8372, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 644.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 52376745, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6256.180721452461, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34270, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8361, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 52311895, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 30580, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16504908, "stage_ordering_ns": 116401, "stage_eval_ns": 1876541536, "stage_threat_ns": 1418079353, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 300595, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1232575658, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 249802, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 150291, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156827332, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 300582, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28426561, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 131, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3793, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5960.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6576.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1107, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 38164, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 129, 81, 99, 96, 145, 161, 144, 114, 100, 51, 101, 98, 66, 156, 170, 80, 64, 157, 172, 82, 83, 68, 54, 158, 159, 110, 124, 65, 103, 102, 131, 117, 115, 147, 67 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 21951, "avg_search_time_ms": 1155.3157894736842, "search_nodes": 542008, "safety_nodes": 694, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 542702, "avg_nodes": 28563.263157894737, "eval_calls": 529674, "avg_eval_calls": 27877.57894736842, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 529674, "pattern_eval_ns": 11431845, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.582794322545567, "pattern_frame_queries": 529674, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11431845, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.582794322545567, "pattern_frame_updates": 1083904, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 13561971568, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12512.151969178081, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12297, "avg_candidate_generations": 647.2105263157895, "candidate_moves_total": 1128697, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.78637065951045, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1584, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 12278, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1127113, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 505659, "avg_legality_checks": 26613.63157894737, "illegal_moves_skipped": 304, "root_legality_checks": 1584, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 504075, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 304, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3994293, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 210225.94736842104, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9691069786, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2426.2290688239445, "renju_forbidden_checks": 59286, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3120.315789473684, "renju_forbidden_ns": 509144499, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8587.93811355126, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 362, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3340801, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 58924, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 505803698, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 19, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 201870, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10624.736842105263, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.368421052631579, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 96520, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3712.3076923076924, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1251908158, "stage_ordering_ns": 460940, "stage_eval_ns": 13573403413, "stage_threat_ns": 7078655297, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1083923, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6185877904, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 297141, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20690, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 541952, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 759319226, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1083904, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 133161026, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 940, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 10920, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21052631578947367, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5444.684210526316, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5865.736842105263, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 480, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 16195, "avg_search_time_ms": 852.3684210526316, "search_nodes": 126454, "safety_nodes": 2503, "corridor_nodes": 1571, "corridor_branch_probes": 1956, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 49, "corridor_depth_exits": 659, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1553, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1553, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 56, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 659, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 50, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 217, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 44060400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2008880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 130528, "avg_nodes": 6869.894736842105, "eval_calls": 77246, "avg_eval_calls": 4065.5789473684213, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77246, "pattern_eval_ns": 1727135, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.358892369831448, "pattern_frame_queries": 77246, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1727135, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.358892369831448, "pattern_frame_updates": 252680, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2546248759, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10076.969918473958, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42357, "avg_candidate_generations": 2229.315789473684, "candidate_moves_total": 3802854, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.7810043204193, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1610, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 42338, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3801244, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 2106525, "avg_legality_checks": 110869.73684210527, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2197, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2106525, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2197, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4732331, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 249070.05263157896, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10116255651, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2137.6897877599854, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55327, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2911.9473684210525, "renju_forbidden_ns": 143577219, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2595.0660437037973, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6878, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 36013963, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10974, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 49232794, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37427, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 58205482, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 124980, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 155060, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8161.0526315789475, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1346793207, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8685.626254353154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 203832, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10728.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 552078094, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2708.495692531104, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5036664216, "stage_ordering_ns": 1526224268, "stage_eval_ns": 2547975894, "stage_threat_ns": 6918375101, "stage_proof_ns": 71636869, "tactical_annotations": 863144, "root_tactical_annotations": 1003, "search_tactical_annotations": 862141, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 255907, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1586560673, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 827221, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5054116873, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 85635, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2932178398, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 127944, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 198571002, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3208, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22860834, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 255888, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33017711, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 171578, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 478460291, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 487006, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1573762673, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 204560, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23248008, "child_limit_applications": 42338, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42338, "child_cap_hits": 42338, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42338, "child_moves_before_total": 3799047, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3799047, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 499101, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 499101, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.73137606877982, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.788487883225471, "tt_hits": 22331, "tt_cutoffs": 6757, "beta_cutoffs": 34679, "depth_sum": 113, "avg_depth": 5.947368421052632, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 113, "avg_effective_depth": 5.947368421052632, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15789473684210525, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5733.736842105263, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6154.789473684211, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 331, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1108, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19473, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 129, 81, 111, 95, 157, 172, 143, 171, 141, 144, 173, 65, 49, 125, 158, 110, 80, 155, 140, 139, 188, 203, 128 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18129, "avg_search_time_ms": 1394.5384615384614, "search_nodes": 164198, "safety_nodes": 483, "corridor_nodes": 730, "corridor_branch_probes": 841, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 384, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 723, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 723, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 384, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 48, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 410, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26174880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1993200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 165411, "avg_nodes": 12723.923076923076, "eval_calls": 101164, "avg_eval_calls": 7781.846153846154, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 101164, "pattern_eval_ns": 2225799, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.001888023407535, "pattern_frame_queries": 101164, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2225799, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.001888023407535, "pattern_frame_updates": 328258, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3896010645, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11868.745453271513, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 58706, "avg_candidate_generations": 4515.846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 4830269, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.27896637481689, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 883, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 58693, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4829386, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1479907, "avg_legality_checks": 113839.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1349, "root_legality_checks": 883, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1479024, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1349, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4731541, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 363964.6923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10812093968, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2285.11048895064, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30315, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2331.923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 167043839, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5510.270130298532, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1439, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14819295, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12109, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 106351700, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16538, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45241651, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 229, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 631193, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 110861, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8527.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 900744248, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8124.98757904042, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 140639, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10818.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 330588637, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2350.618512645852, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3736580399, "stage_ordering_ns": 2025162780, "stage_eval_ns": 3898236444, "stage_threat_ns": 8238042542, "stage_proof_ns": 155451967, "tactical_annotations": 941845, "root_tactical_annotations": 3310, "search_tactical_annotations": 938535, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 329817, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2002100131, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 786436, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5891860540, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 117973, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4298821410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 164902, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 253015816, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1546, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9860135, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 329804, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42395015, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 217237, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 237359997, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 416812, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1269639975, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 307796, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 38810905, "child_limit_applications": 58693, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 58693, "child_cap_hits": 58693, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 58693, "child_moves_before_total": 4828037, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4828037, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 647225, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 647225, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.25916208065698, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.027294566643382, "tt_hits": 31637, "tt_cutoffs": 4273, "beta_cutoffs": 47241, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 5.076923076923077, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 5.076923076923077, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1302.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1913.4615384615386, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 1334, "avg_search_time_ms": 111.16666666666667, "search_nodes": 44519, "safety_nodes": 1176, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 45695, "avg_nodes": 3807.9166666666665, "eval_calls": 41907, "avg_eval_calls": 3492.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41907, "pattern_eval_ns": 908383, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.676163886701506, "pattern_frame_queries": 41907, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 908383, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.676163886701506, "pattern_frame_updates": 88968, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 696048143, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7823.578623774841, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2589, "avg_candidate_generations": 215.75, "candidate_moves_total": 185432, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.62302047122441, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 813, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 2577, "search_candidate_moves_total": 184619, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 6902, "avg_legality_checks": 575.1666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6902, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 165967, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13830.583333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 399661617, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2408.078816873234, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1054, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 87.83333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9451468, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8967.237191650855, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1054, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9451468, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19427903, "stage_ordering_ns": 88300, "stage_eval_ns": 696956526, "stage_threat_ns": 595872686, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 88980, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 523528372, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 374211, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 44484, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 60963740, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 88968, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11006363, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 131, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2326, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6202.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6869.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1983, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1109, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17051, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 80, 143, 95, 159, 175, 128, 83, 81, 65, 113, 158, 50, 96, 129, 94, 93, 52, 67, 66, 38, 108 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 3124, "avg_search_time_ms": 260.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 75993, "safety_nodes": 970, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76963, "avg_nodes": 6413.583333333333, "eval_calls": 72637, "avg_eval_calls": 6053.083333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72637, "pattern_eval_ns": 1578048, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.725126313036057, "pattern_frame_queries": 72637, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1578048, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.725126313036057, "pattern_frame_updates": 151918, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1949847936, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12834.871022525309, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3334, "avg_candidate_generations": 277.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 261373, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.39622075584883, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 837, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 3322, "search_candidate_moves_total": 260536, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 68293, "avg_legality_checks": 5691.083333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 19, "root_legality_checks": 837, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 67456, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 19, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 629472, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 52456.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1471125104, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2337.077906562961, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11431, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 952.5833333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 69879027, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6113.115825387105, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 183922, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11401, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 69681285, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13820, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.166666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 427981, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8559.62, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.666666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 178570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2626.029411764706, "stage_move_gen_ns": 164247368, "stage_ordering_ns": 121911, "stage_eval_ns": 1951425984, "stage_threat_ns": 984962968, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 151930, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 861086095, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 598943, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75959, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104960311, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 151918, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18317619, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 270, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2914, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6195.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6862.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1853, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 13914, "avg_search_time_ms": 1264.909090909091, "search_nodes": 94608, "safety_nodes": 762, "corridor_nodes": 876, "corridor_branch_probes": 1001, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 412, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 866, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 866, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 45, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 35, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 412, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 45, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 44, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 303, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 30002720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 96246, "avg_nodes": 8749.636363636364, "eval_calls": 57849, "avg_eval_calls": 5259.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 57849, "pattern_eval_ns": 1296054, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.404086501063112, "pattern_frame_queries": 57849, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1296054, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.404086501063112, "pattern_frame_updates": 189088, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2292852653, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12125.849620282619, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33657, "avg_candidate_generations": 3059.7272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 2705479, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.383842885581, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 767, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 33646, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2704712, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1774880, "avg_legality_checks": 161352.72727272726, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2995, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1774880, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2995, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4172040, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 379276.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9146572137, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2192.3500582448874, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37175, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3379.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 157254717, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4230.12016139879, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3099, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33278168, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9759, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 80532056, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24317, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43444493, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 153314, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13937.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1452323445, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9472.869046531954, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 208725, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18975.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 641584343, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3073.826053419571, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4425707706, "stage_ordering_ns": 1130333634, "stage_eval_ns": 2294148707, "stage_threat_ns": 5924609825, "stage_proof_ns": 65601431, "tactical_annotations": 597313, "root_tactical_annotations": 1878, "search_tactical_annotations": 595435, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 190921, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1219089438, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 544521, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4498652348, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67886, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2520763454, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 95455, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 151227585, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1822, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10409434, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 190910, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25383101, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 113761, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 494977703, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 315398, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1443149841, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 168154, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19847919, "child_limit_applications": 33646, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33646, "child_cap_hits": 33646, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33646, "child_moves_before_total": 2701717, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2701717, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 356622, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 356622, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.29831183498781, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.599239136895916, "tt_hits": 16849, "tt_cutoffs": 3050, "beta_cutoffs": 27236, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2224.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2952.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1110, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12758, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 96, 97, 68, 110, 80, 128, 83, 81, 65, 113, 35, 129, 145, 143, 158, 95, 64, 48, 67, 66, 51, 99, 19 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10739, "avg_search_time_ms": 894.9166666666666, "search_nodes": 101685, "safety_nodes": 732, "corridor_nodes": 3149, "corridor_branch_probes": 3267, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1285, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 3138, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3138, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 25, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 14, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1285, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 25, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 21, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 160, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 115360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11360, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 105566, "avg_nodes": 8797.166666666666, "eval_calls": 65038, "avg_eval_calls": 5419.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 65038, "pattern_eval_ns": 1417302, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.791906270180508, "pattern_frame_queries": 65038, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1417302, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.791906270180508, "pattern_frame_updates": 203250, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2189799819, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10773.922848708487, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34444, "avg_candidate_generations": 2870.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2496879, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.4909708512368, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 784, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 34432, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2496095, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 833997, "avg_legality_checks": 69499.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1562, "root_legality_checks": 784, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 833213, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1559, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3072453, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 256037.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6575278958, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2140.074708384473, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22896, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1908.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 102938444, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4495.913871418588, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1877, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14364999, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9057, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 55982799, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10855, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28250267, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1107, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4340379, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67547, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5628.916666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 545618879, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8077.618236191097, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86973, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7247.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 224017435, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2575.7124049992526, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1992825481, "stage_ordering_ns": 998210935, "stage_eval_ns": 2191217121, "stage_threat_ns": 5088751107, "stage_proof_ns": 416555385, "tactical_annotations": 429129, "root_tactical_annotations": 1872, "search_tactical_annotations": 427257, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 209588, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1226437802, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 540772, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3621966021, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70781, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2419466219, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 104788, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156051619, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6326, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 41370462, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 209576, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24933242, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 79530, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 96525670, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 202369, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 680735403, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 147230, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17991961, "child_limit_applications": 34432, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34432, "child_cap_hits": 34432, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34432, "child_moves_before_total": 2494536, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2494536, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 306027, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 306027, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.448187732342, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.88786593866171, "tt_hits": 17563, "tt_cutoffs": 2155, "beta_cutoffs": 26267, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.916666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.916666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4034.9166666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4701.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2010, "avg_search_time_ms": 182.72727272727272, "search_nodes": 58697, "safety_nodes": 987, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59684, "avg_nodes": 5425.818181818182, "eval_calls": 57024, "avg_eval_calls": 5184.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 57024, "pattern_eval_ns": 1234422, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.647411616161616, "pattern_frame_queries": 57024, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1234422, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.647411616161616, "pattern_frame_updates": 117330, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1216751407, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10370.335012358306, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1652, "avg_candidate_generations": 150.1818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 117741, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.27179176755448, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 728, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 1641, "search_candidate_moves_total": 117013, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 3777, "avg_legality_checks": 343.3636363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3777, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 344607, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 31327.909090909092, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 767076795, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2225.9466435678905, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8241, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 749.1818181818181, "renju_forbidden_ns": 75420434, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9151.854629292562, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 122960, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8216, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 75108624, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 188850, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9609631, "stage_ordering_ns": 59490, "stage_eval_ns": 1217985829, "stage_threat_ns": 761274693, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 117341, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 667294547, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 197451, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58665, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 79593999, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 117330, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14188696, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 121, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1444, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6131.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6859.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1931, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1111, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22250, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 84, 114, 140, 113, 111, 130, 82, 116, 115, 144, 158, 159, 129, 146, 162, 101, 86, 102, 88, 85, 141, 99, 100, 71, 57, 127 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 15027, "avg_search_time_ms": 1073.357142857143, "search_nodes": 421076, "safety_nodes": 422, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 421498, "avg_nodes": 30107.0, "eval_calls": 410362, "avg_eval_calls": 29311.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 410362, "pattern_eval_ns": 8707011, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.217878361056822, "pattern_frame_queries": 410362, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 8707011, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.217878361056822, "pattern_frame_updates": 842072, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8986585167, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10671.991429473965, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10688, "avg_candidate_generations": 763.4285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 870984, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.49176646706587, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1013, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 10674, "search_candidate_moves_total": 869971, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 397338, "avg_legality_checks": 28381.285714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 357, "root_legality_checks": 1013, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 396325, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 357, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2808948, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 200639.14285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6246207042, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2223.6819770248508, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30103, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2150.214285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 201472397, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6692.768062983756, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 372, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2065531, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29726, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 199401726, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5140, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.6428571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 140230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6096.95652173913, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 37, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.642857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 77500, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2094.5945945945946, "stage_move_gen_ns": 929558642, "stage_ordering_ns": 375311, "stage_eval_ns": 8995292178, "stage_threat_ns": 5057208376, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 842086, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4409038110, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 221251, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 421036, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 548862476, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 842072, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 99086539, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 756, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9300, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 2.7857142857142856, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7857142857142856, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4389.785714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4961.214285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7211, "avg_search_time_ms": 554.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 57572, "safety_nodes": 1187, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 13, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 13, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 22, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4004880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 58759, "avg_nodes": 4519.923076923077, "eval_calls": 33795, "avg_eval_calls": 2599.6153846153848, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33795, "pattern_eval_ns": 746000, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.074271341914486, "pattern_frame_queries": 33795, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 746000, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.074271341914486, "pattern_frame_updates": 114996, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1114206198, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9689.086559532505, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21932, "avg_candidate_generations": 1687.076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 1798464, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.00182381907715, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 944, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 21919, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1797520, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1074399, "avg_legality_checks": 82646.07692307692, "illegal_moves_skipped": 637, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1074399, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 637, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2468026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 189848.15384615384, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4659570299, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1887.9745590200428, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21364, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1643.3846153846155, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43483007, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2035.3401516569932, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 757, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4268386, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4439, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24119717, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16168, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15094904, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 85825, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6601.923076923077, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 688788119, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8025.495123798427, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 119772, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9213.23076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 309133788, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2581.018835787997, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2259074383, "stage_ordering_ns": 664526564, "stage_eval_ns": 1114952198, "stage_threat_ns": 3095307365, "stage_proof_ns": 21156229, "tactical_annotations": 357070, "root_tactical_annotations": 964, "search_tactical_annotations": 356106, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 115035, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 634114302, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 325107, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2360150804, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43990, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1393804000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57511, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81336619, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 26, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 143320, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 115022, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13503720, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 69927, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 217881857, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 211156, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 748200927, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 75987, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6058600, "child_limit_applications": 21919, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21919, "child_cap_hits": 21919, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21919, "child_moves_before_total": 1796883, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1796883, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 204847, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 204847, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.97832930334413, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.345636206031298, "tt_hits": 8772, "tt_cutoffs": 1785, "beta_cutoffs": 17422, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5155.076923076923, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5770.461538461538, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1112, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17053, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 126, 114, 110, 158, 125, 129, 94, 78, 124, 127, 99, 82, 66, 113, 122, 123, 80, 108, 95, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14188, "avg_search_time_ms": 1289.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 119138, "safety_nodes": 659, "corridor_nodes": 2560, "corridor_branch_probes": 3022, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1117, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 2538, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2538, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1117, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 435, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 19936320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 16, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 16, "total_nodes": 122357, "avg_nodes": 11123.363636363636, "eval_calls": 75043, "avg_eval_calls": 6822.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75043, "pattern_eval_ns": 1571450, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.94066068787229, "pattern_frame_queries": 75043, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1571450, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.94066068787229, "pattern_frame_updates": 238152, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3109966434, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13058.745817797037, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 40437, "avg_candidate_generations": 3676.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 3509324, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.78497415733116, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 797, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 40426, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3508527, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 1149482, "avg_legality_checks": 104498.36363636363, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1592, "root_legality_checks": 797, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1148685, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1592, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4107948, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 373449.8181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8743056084, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2128.326863923302, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34823, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3165.7272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 196841492, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5652.628779829423, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2021, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18623837, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14922, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 117325140, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17314, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 56438503, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 566, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4454012, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 114486, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10407.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1070173603, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9347.637291895953, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 159262, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14478.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 497236139, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3122.126678052517, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2719061862, "stage_ordering_ns": 1374264346, "stage_eval_ns": 3111537884, "stage_threat_ns": 6552031247, "stage_proof_ns": 378441808, "tactical_annotations": 754982, "root_tactical_annotations": 1808, "search_tactical_annotations": 753174, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 243357, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1427978684, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 700020, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4845852221, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 82208, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3008081478, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121673, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 178536949, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5194, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 31409514, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 243346, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29951162, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 151147, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 264865619, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 319749, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1194335621, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 284086, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 38302717, "child_limit_applications": 40426, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 40426, "child_cap_hits": 40426, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 40426, "child_moves_before_total": 3506935, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3506935, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 484999, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 484999, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.74949290060852, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.997204769207935, "tt_hits": 24015, "tt_cutoffs": 3607, "beta_cutoffs": 32924, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2502.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3219.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 104, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2854, "avg_search_time_ms": 259.45454545454544, "search_nodes": 86461, "safety_nodes": 1280, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87741, "avg_nodes": 7976.454545454545, "eval_calls": 83689, "avg_eval_calls": 7608.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83689, "pattern_eval_ns": 1717316, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.52021173630943, "pattern_frame_queries": 83689, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1717316, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.52021173630943, "pattern_frame_updates": 172860, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1717382267, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9935.105096609974, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2752, "avg_candidate_generations": 250.1818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 215500, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.30668604651163, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 815, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 2741, "search_candidate_moves_total": 214685, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 5223, "avg_legality_checks": 474.8181818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5223, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 462587, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 42053.36363636364, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1091486648, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2359.527284597276, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5538, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 503.45454545454544, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46051889, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8315.61737089202, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 67420, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5512, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 45832759, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 151710, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14382620, "stage_ordering_ns": 88520, "stage_eval_ns": 1719099583, "stage_threat_ns": 1104280494, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 172871, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 966775545, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 401181, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10840, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 115072442, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 172860, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22031326, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 164, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2483, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5857.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6585.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1964, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1113, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18954, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 144, 160, 142, 95, 125, 94, 127, 65, 50, 97, 141, 78, 62, 143, 157, 172, 173, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11052, "avg_search_time_ms": 1004.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 259369, "safety_nodes": 383, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 259752, "avg_nodes": 23613.81818181818, "eval_calls": 253613, "avg_eval_calls": 23055.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 253613, "pattern_eval_ns": 5486943, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.635101512935062, "pattern_frame_queries": 253613, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5486943, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.635101512935062, "pattern_frame_updates": 518676, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6846187309, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13199.352406897562, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5736, "avg_candidate_generations": 521.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 446019, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.75784518828452, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 809, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 5725, "search_candidate_moves_total": 445210, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 250105, "avg_legality_checks": 22736.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 135, "root_legality_checks": 809, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 249296, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 135, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1854039, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 168549.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4779321868, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2577.7892849071677, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29724, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2702.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 331238903, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11143.819909837168, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 138, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1419631, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29586, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 329819272, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.9090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 124140, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12414.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.2727272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 65090, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4649.285714285715, "stage_move_gen_ns": 650320535, "stage_ordering_ns": 196070, "stage_eval_ns": 6851674252, "stage_threat_ns": 3519690106, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 518687, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3087751401, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 179340, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11270, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 259338, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 366044331, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 518676, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65715034, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 486, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4977, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4028.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4755.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7889, "avg_search_time_ms": 788.9, "search_nodes": 52659, "safety_nodes": 953, "corridor_nodes": 547, "corridor_branch_probes": 611, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 260, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 541, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 541, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 260, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 13, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 35, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4015280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2002560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 54159, "avg_nodes": 5415.9, "eval_calls": 32157, "avg_eval_calls": 3215.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32157, "pattern_eval_ns": 724865, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.541437323133376, "pattern_frame_queries": 32157, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 724865, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.541437323133376, "pattern_frame_updates": 105210, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1195089780, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11359.089250071285, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18424, "avg_candidate_generations": 1842.4, "candidate_moves_total": 1586661, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.11924663482414, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 739, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 18414, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1585922, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 962394, "avg_legality_checks": 96239.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 699, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 962394, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 699, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2381470, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 238147.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5180162015, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2175.195158872461, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15043, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1504.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 68283720, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4539.235524828824, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 890, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9318551, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3982, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38999700, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10171, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19965469, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 100597, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10059.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1088895726, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10824.335974233823, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 142965, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14296.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 538269549, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3765.044234602875, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2415992135, "stage_ordering_ns": 662763054, "stage_eval_ns": 1195814645, "stage_threat_ns": 3548577145, "stage_proof_ns": 18718851, "tactical_annotations": 334073, "root_tactical_annotations": 951, "search_tactical_annotations": 333122, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 106328, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 665908500, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 324398, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2772335152, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37170, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1354914954, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 53159, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 82530568, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1108, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6474250, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 106318, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13715191, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 54329, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 353626801, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 203612, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1044587813, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76132, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7613484, "child_limit_applications": 18414, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18414, "child_cap_hits": 18414, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18414, "child_moves_before_total": 1585223, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1585223, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 214089, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 214089, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.08792223308352, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.626425545780384, "tt_hits": 8238, "tt_cutoffs": 2034, "beta_cutoffs": 14540, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 5.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4219.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5019.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1597, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1114, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20913, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 142, 95, 65, 94, 127, 140, 125, 97, 114, 156, 113, 78, 62, 111, 141, 155, 157, 172, 173, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 16610, "avg_search_time_ms": 1384.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 149505, "safety_nodes": 493, "corridor_nodes": 4032, "corridor_branch_probes": 4471, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1746, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 4005, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4005, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1746, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 555, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 55583520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 154030, "avg_nodes": 12835.833333333334, "eval_calls": 99994, "avg_eval_calls": 8332.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 99994, "pattern_eval_ns": 2087073, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.871982318939136, "pattern_frame_queries": 99994, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2087073, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.871982318939136, "pattern_frame_updates": 298890, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4068444707, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13611.84618756064, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46428, "avg_candidate_generations": 3869.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3800603, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.86014904798829, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 807, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 46416, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3799796, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1119692, "avg_legality_checks": 93307.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1176, "root_legality_checks": 807, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1118885, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1176, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4759475, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 396622.9166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10187142375, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2140.3920337852387, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39364, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3280.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 192612281, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4893.107433187684, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1306, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9815175, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21317, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 132016412, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15868, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42521909, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 873, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8258785, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 128003, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10666.916666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1117131126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8727.382373850613, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 168713, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14059.416666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 469841528, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2784.856697468482, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2676831572, "stage_ordering_ns": 1498247854, "stage_eval_ns": 4070531780, "stage_threat_ns": 7754642196, "stage_proof_ns": 556469298, "tactical_annotations": 781490, "root_tactical_annotations": 2778, "search_tactical_annotations": 778712, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 307050, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1846884465, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 862827, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5559795325, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 95071, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3472632649, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 153519, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 230990369, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8148, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 46351359, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 307038, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38594780, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 202738, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 291468638, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 331711, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1197471225, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 247041, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32025898, "child_limit_applications": 46416, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46416, "child_cap_hits": 46416, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46416, "child_moves_before_total": 3798620, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3798620, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 496873, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 496873, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.83859014133057, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.704778524646674, "tt_hits": 25583, "tt_cutoffs": 3035, "beta_cutoffs": 36829, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4166666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2312.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2935.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 513, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4288, "avg_search_time_ms": 389.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 148788, "safety_nodes": 1080, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 149868, "avg_nodes": 13624.363636363636, "eval_calls": 144378, "avg_eval_calls": 13125.272727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 144378, "pattern_eval_ns": 2943825, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.389706187923366, "pattern_frame_queries": 144378, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2943825, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.389706187923366, "pattern_frame_updates": 297512, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2341791321, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7871.249969749119, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4389, "avg_candidate_generations": 399.0, "candidate_moves_total": 314768, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.71747550694919, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 743, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 4378, "search_candidate_moves_total": 314025, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 9512, "avg_legality_checks": 864.7272727272727, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9512, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 535937, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 48721.545454545456, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1265094190, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2360.527804574045, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4071, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 370.09090909090907, "renju_forbidden_ns": 40732841, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10005.61066077131, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4071, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 40732841, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 25671087, "stage_ordering_ns": 167531, "stage_eval_ns": 2344735146, "stage_threat_ns": 1899120739, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 297523, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1667283257, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 374591, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148756, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 195352897, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 297512, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36109994, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 140, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4012, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5316.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6044.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1115, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15713, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 110, 83, 81, 68, 111, 54, 40, 113, 95, 85, 86, 125, 109, 108, 123, 67, 137 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8370, "avg_search_time_ms": 760.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 273720, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 274106, "avg_nodes": 24918.727272727272, "eval_calls": 267393, "avg_eval_calls": 24308.454545454544, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 267393, "pattern_eval_ns": 5169181, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.33177383102774, "pattern_frame_queries": 267393, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5169181, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.33177383102774, "pattern_frame_updates": 547378, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4960365328, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9062.047301864524, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6307, "avg_candidate_generations": 573.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 494671, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.43205961629936, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 817, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 6296, "search_candidate_moves_total": 493854, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 263836, "avg_legality_checks": 23985.090909090908, "illegal_moves_skipped": 185, "root_legality_checks": 817, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 263019, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 185, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1806413, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 164219.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3355950239, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1857.797878447509, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23442, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2131.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 162838290, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6946.433324801638, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 189, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1322126, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23253, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 161516164, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.9090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 116050, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11605.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.2727272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 62550, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4467.857142857143, "stage_move_gen_ns": 527303916, "stage_ordering_ns": 191720, "stage_eval_ns": 4965534509, "stage_threat_ns": 2846700844, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 547389, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2473582523, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 167270, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8750, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 273689, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 317507773, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 547378, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55443278, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 500, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5521, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4388.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5116.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7334, "avg_search_time_ms": 733.4, "search_nodes": 64359, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 679, "corridor_branch_probes": 794, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 334, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 673, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 673, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 334, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 13, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 35, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4015520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2002560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 66011, "avg_nodes": 6601.1, "eval_calls": 39838, "avg_eval_calls": 3983.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39838, "pattern_eval_ns": 818412, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.5435011797781, "pattern_frame_queries": 39838, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 818412, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.5435011797781, "pattern_frame_updates": 128610, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1052289094, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8182.016126273229, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22146, "avg_candidate_generations": 2214.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1930951, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.19186309040008, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 749, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 22136, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1930202, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1236408, "avg_legality_checks": 123640.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2065, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1236408, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2065, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2663338, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 266333.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4708547138, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1767.911972870135, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19511, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1951.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 83308529, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4269.823637947824, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2316, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18629564, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5698, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44301983, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11497, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20376982, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 85100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8510.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 680171999, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7992.620434782609, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 117738, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11773.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 329301730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2796.902699213508, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2480891686, "stage_ordering_ns": 665316677, "stage_eval_ns": 1053107506, "stage_threat_ns": 3069746656, "stage_proof_ns": 14960597, "tactical_annotations": 344635, "root_tactical_annotations": 951, "search_tactical_annotations": 343684, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 129992, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 685524942, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 323018, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2263095713, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44635, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1337469414, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64991, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87921066, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1372, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6589579, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 129982, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14560427, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56483, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 277488072, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 186706, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 628182681, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 101446, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12054929, "child_limit_applications": 22136, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22136, "child_cap_hits": 22136, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22136, "child_moves_before_total": 1928137, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1928137, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 224067, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 224067, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.10412902059993, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.122289483194796, "tt_hits": 11402, "tt_cutoffs": 2331, "beta_cutoffs": 17412, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 5.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4434.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5234.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1781, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1116, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15179, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 85, 68, 111, 80, 81, 113, 94, 78, 95, 36, 109, 108, 123, 67, 137 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 12720, "avg_search_time_ms": 1272.0, "search_nodes": 106403, "safety_nodes": 568, "corridor_nodes": 2765, "corridor_branch_probes": 3172, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1191, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2742, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2742, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1191, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 555, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 27922880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 109736, "avg_nodes": 10973.6, "eval_calls": 66571, "avg_eval_calls": 6657.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 66571, "pattern_eval_ns": 1463437, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.98310074957564, "pattern_frame_queries": 66571, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1463437, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.98310074957564, "pattern_frame_updates": 212698, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2634039808, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12383.942528843712, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37197, "avg_candidate_generations": 3719.7, "candidate_moves_total": 2972424, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.91031534801193, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 651, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 37187, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2971773, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 891539, "avg_legality_checks": 89153.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 818, "root_legality_checks": 651, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 890888, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 815, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3386534, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 338653.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7804464152, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2304.5580383955985, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19101, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1910.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 112827725, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5906.901471127166, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 873, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8074428, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8780, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73863260, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9015, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26937181, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 433, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3952856, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 78283, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7828.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 728452402, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9305.371562152703, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 102275, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10227.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 305212508, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2984.233761916402, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2277590964, "stage_ordering_ns": 1263967658, "stage_eval_ns": 2635503245, "stage_threat_ns": 6039244663, "stage_proof_ns": 447852252, "tactical_annotations": 509747, "root_tactical_annotations": 2024, "search_tactical_annotations": 507723, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 218330, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1383745758, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 562353, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4402487929, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75917, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2979341283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 109160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 167798543, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5622, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 33545461, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 218320, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28439279, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 95465, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 160020241, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 229067, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 832664325, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 185215, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23227693, "child_limit_applications": 37187, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37187, "child_cap_hits": 37187, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37187, "child_moves_before_total": 2970958, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2970958, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 345703, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 345703, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.8923817463092, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.29634011885874, "tt_hits": 21246, "tt_cutoffs": 2591, "beta_cutoffs": 29428, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2027.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2764.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 508, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2451, "avg_search_time_ms": 272.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 82940, "safety_nodes": 627, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 83567, "avg_nodes": 9285.222222222223, "eval_calls": 79466, "avg_eval_calls": 8829.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79466, "pattern_eval_ns": 1722071, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.67053834344248, "pattern_frame_queries": 79466, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1722071, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.67053834344248, "pattern_frame_updates": 165828, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1304030943, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7863.756078587452, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3457, "avg_candidate_generations": 384.1111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 248091, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.7648249927683, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 583, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 3448, "search_candidate_moves_total": 247508, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 11384, "avg_legality_checks": 1264.888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11384, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 295710, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32856.666666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 728764602, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2464.45707618951, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2035, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 226.11111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19216847, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9443.168058968058, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 38430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2016, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19012107, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 166310, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 31224557, "stage_ordering_ns": 118060, "stage_eval_ns": 1305753014, "stage_threat_ns": 1093011938, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 165837, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 957537185, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 206783, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10111, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 82914, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 114825532, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 165828, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20442438, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 200, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3124, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5338.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6227.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1117, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21074, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 80, 82, 144, 97, 127, 68, 110, 52, 67, 84, 100, 85, 83, 54, 40, 51, 50, 36, 20, 65, 81, 37, 79, 53, 55, 69, 101, 21 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 10547, "avg_search_time_ms": 703.1333333333333, "search_nodes": 301704, "safety_nodes": 89, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 301793, "avg_nodes": 20119.533333333333, "eval_calls": 292337, "avg_eval_calls": 19489.133333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 292337, "pattern_eval_ns": 6001823, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.53049391626787, "pattern_frame_queries": 292337, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6001823, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.53049391626787, "pattern_frame_updates": 603322, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6262659523, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10380.29364584749, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9339, "avg_candidate_generations": 622.6, "candidate_moves_total": 743972, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.66291894207089, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1101, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 9324, "search_candidate_moves_total": 742871, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 281800, "avg_legality_checks": 18786.666666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 66, "root_legality_checks": 1101, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 280699, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 66, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2026376, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 135091.73333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4434413473, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2188.34681865557, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24320, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1621.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 165472159, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6803.95390625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 205, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1351948, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24108, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 164057081, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 63130, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 635253437, "stage_ordering_ns": 317610, "stage_eval_ns": 6268661346, "stage_threat_ns": 3585595663, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 603337, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3139193050, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 30440, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 301661, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 378209079, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 603322, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 68163094, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 995, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7918, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5496.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6030.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 10514, "avg_search_time_ms": 751.0, "search_nodes": 84208, "safety_nodes": 1354, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 13, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 13, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 22, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4002960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85562, "avg_nodes": 6111.571428571428, "eval_calls": 53284, "avg_eval_calls": 3806.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53284, "pattern_eval_ns": 1150325, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.588563170933114, "pattern_frame_queries": 53284, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1150325, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.588563170933114, "pattern_frame_updates": 168256, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1804049057, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10722.048883843667, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28795, "avg_candidate_generations": 2056.785714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 2375361, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.49213405105053, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1029, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 28781, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2374332, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 1411847, "avg_legality_checks": 100846.21428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4291, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1411847, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4291, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3326631, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 237616.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6727243429, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2022.2391449487484, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54278, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3877.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 177145930, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3263.6782858616752, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5159, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 43081327, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13298, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72344108, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 35814, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 61657525, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 62970, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 117193, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8370.92857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1021669347, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8717.83593730001, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 166060, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11861.42857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 458152521, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2758.957732145008, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3296267721, "stage_ordering_ns": 918374098, "stage_eval_ns": 1805199382, "stage_threat_ns": 4403641784, "stage_proof_ns": 22746482, "tactical_annotations": 481343, "root_tactical_annotations": 976, "search_tactical_annotations": 480367, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 168296, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 967221026, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 459577, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3285320159, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 57722, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1841843207, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84141, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 122605239, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 26, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 155161, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 168282, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20349638, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 100558, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 280708043, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 301262, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1162465237, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79523, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7990561, "child_limit_applications": 28781, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28781, "child_cap_hits": 28781, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28781, "child_moves_before_total": 2370041, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2370041, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 256327, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 256327, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.34741669851638, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.906118619922866, "tt_hits": 9727, "tt_cutoffs": 2065, "beta_cutoffs": 21872, "depth_sum": 78, "avg_depth": 5.571428571428571, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 78, "avg_effective_depth": 5.571428571428571, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5223.214285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5794.642857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1118, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 37272, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 128, 82, 142, 100, 143, 83, 156, 170, 158, 113, 81, 110, 124, 68, 54, 64, 48, 140, 188, 173, 126, 127, 155, 97, 67, 111, 109, 69, 125, 55 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 25155, "avg_search_time_ms": 1572.1875, "search_nodes": 222192, "safety_nodes": 1241, "corridor_nodes": 2805, "corridor_branch_probes": 3238, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1278, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 2783, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2783, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1278, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 40, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 2, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 211, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23827840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 226238, "avg_nodes": 14139.875, "eval_calls": 140564, "avg_eval_calls": 8785.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 140564, "pattern_eval_ns": 2937460, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.897669389032753, "pattern_frame_queries": 140564, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2937460, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.897669389032753, "pattern_frame_updates": 444200, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6196385135, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13949.53880009005, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 74423, "avg_candidate_generations": 4651.4375, "candidate_moves_total": 7155421, "avg_candidate_moves": 96.14529110624403, "candidate_moves_max": 134, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1384, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 74407, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7154037, "search_candidate_moves_max": 134, "legality_checks": 1919891, "avg_legality_checks": 119993.1875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4368, "root_legality_checks": 1384, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1918507, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7107638, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 444227.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14960302059, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2104.820484526646, "renju_forbidden_checks": 107150, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6696.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 564321922, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5266.653495100327, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5769, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 39550149, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 50406, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 353558616, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 50418, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 167103980, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 557, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4109177, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 190609, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11913.0625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1786746775, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9373.88462769334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 263635, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16477.1875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 833999583, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3163.4630568778803, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4518031103, "stage_ordering_ns": 2574511848, "stage_eval_ns": 6199322595, "stage_threat_ns": 11422715548, "stage_proof_ns": 355741501, "tactical_annotations": 1609478, "root_tactical_annotations": 4056, "search_tactical_annotations": 1605422, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 449864, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2615287847, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1404055, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8326986604, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 150225, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5242457076, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 224924, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 326273759, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5648, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 34706915, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 449848, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 54947123, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 411237, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 450768943, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 687756, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2242421087, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 510485, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 64513300, "child_limit_applications": 74407, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 74407, "child_cap_hits": 74407, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 74407, "child_moves_before_total": 7149672, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7149672, "child_moves_before_max": 134, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 134, "child_moves_after_total": 918361, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 918361, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 96.08870133186393, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.342400580590535, "tt_hits": 43845, "tt_cutoffs": 7131, "beta_cutoffs": 61481, "depth_sum": 89, "avg_depth": 5.5625, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 89, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5625, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3125, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1674.9375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2107.8125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 12102, "avg_search_time_ms": 806.8, "search_nodes": 373316, "safety_nodes": 1199, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 374515, "avg_nodes": 24967.666666666668, "eval_calls": 366449, "avg_eval_calls": 24429.933333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 366449, "pattern_eval_ns": 7473549, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.39451328834299, "pattern_frame_queries": 366449, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7473549, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.39451328834299, "pattern_frame_updates": 746544, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7434181946, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9958.129656122077, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6838, "avg_candidate_generations": 455.8666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 676286, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.90114068441065, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1306, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 6823, "search_candidate_moves_total": 674980, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 22254, "avg_legality_checks": 1483.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 22254, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2213174, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 147544.93333333332, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4908287019, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2217.759208720146, "renju_forbidden_checks": 62994, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4199.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 200083185, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3176.226069149443, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17760, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 62953, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 200041534, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 23891, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 54172375, "stage_ordering_ns": 248542, "stage_eval_ns": 7441655495, "stage_threat_ns": 4560850145, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 746559, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3993544975, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 190252, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15240, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 373272, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 481579744, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 746544, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 85535174, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 453, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6185, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5920.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6453.733333333334, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1119, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20247, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 80, 110, 158, 111, 113, 124, 82, 108, 109, 140, 156, 155, 125, 138, 152, 93, 78, 92, 76, 79, 95, 107, 174, 190, 65, 123, 153, 139, 171, 91 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 11475, "avg_search_time_ms": 717.1875, "search_nodes": 459301, "safety_nodes": 189, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 459490, "avg_nodes": 28718.125, "eval_calls": 447514, "avg_eval_calls": 27969.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 447514, "pattern_eval_ns": 8717793, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.48049223041067, "pattern_frame_queries": 447514, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 8717793, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.48049223041067, "pattern_frame_updates": 918510, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6885212742, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7496.067263285103, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11757, "avg_candidate_generations": 734.8125, "candidate_moves_total": 943444, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.24530067194011, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1209, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 11741, "search_candidate_moves_total": 942235, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 428904, "avg_legality_checks": 26806.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 244, "root_legality_checks": 1209, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 427695, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 244, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3119570, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 194973.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4645741461, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1489.2249447840568, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34708, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2169.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 163201394, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4702.126138066152, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 533, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2855064, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34161, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 160281610, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 64720, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 679831495, "stage_ordering_ns": 395020, "stage_eval_ns": 6893930535, "stage_threat_ns": 3805264603, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 918526, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3278539853, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 24730, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9840, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 459255, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 448994918, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 918510, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 77705102, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1021, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 10226, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5769.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6269.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 790, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 8759, "avg_search_time_ms": 583.9333333333333, "search_nodes": 107107, "safety_nodes": 1548, "corridor_nodes": 256, "corridor_branch_probes": 284, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 76, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 242, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 242, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 47, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 76, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 47, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 47, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 212, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 39939040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2002800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 108911, "avg_nodes": 7260.733333333334, "eval_calls": 60228, "avg_eval_calls": 4015.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60228, "pattern_eval_ns": 1184924, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.673972238825794, "pattern_frame_queries": 60228, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1184924, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.673972238825794, "pattern_frame_updates": 214030, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1336296041, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6243.498766528057, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42521, "avg_candidate_generations": 2834.733333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 3589699, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.4217915853343, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1134, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 42506, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3588565, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1934471, "avg_legality_checks": 128964.73333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 997, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1934471, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 997, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4393378, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 292891.86666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5488982977, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1249.376442682601, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31577, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2105.133333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 53060333, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1680.3474997624853, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1435, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6426230, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6947, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26441422, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23169, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20065191, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 127490, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 139910, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9327.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 716788026, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5123.207962261454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 189682, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12645.466666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 304096964, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1603.1935766177075, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2757589406, "stage_ordering_ns": 840365954, "stage_eval_ns": 1337480965, "stage_threat_ns": 3682119790, "stage_proof_ns": 47903446, "tactical_annotations": 688453, "root_tactical_annotations": 1198, "search_tactical_annotations": 687255, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 214623, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 777400247, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 590912, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2755027586, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 85438, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1697849557, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 107304, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107821996, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 578, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2315498, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 214608, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17761493, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 122305, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 314349201, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 365265, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 734705241, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 200883, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21792970, "child_limit_applications": 42506, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42506, "child_cap_hits": 42506, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42506, "child_moves_before_total": 3587568, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3587568, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 405556, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 405556, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.40144920717076, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.541147132169575, "tt_hits": 21180, "tt_cutoffs": 4282, "beta_cutoffs": 34449, "depth_sum": 91, "avg_depth": 6.066666666666666, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 91, "avg_effective_depth": 6.066666666666666, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5494.733333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6028.066666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1120, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26460, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 128, 110, 114, 156, 129, 125, 100, 86, 130, 127, 95, 82, 68, 124, 138, 64, 48, 97, 67, 109, 132, 131, 84, 116, 99, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 22509, "avg_search_time_ms": 1607.7857142857142, "search_nodes": 181897, "safety_nodes": 725, "corridor_nodes": 1942, "corridor_branch_probes": 2269, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 884, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1927, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1927, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 27, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 12, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 884, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 27, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 27, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 163, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23823520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 184564, "avg_nodes": 13183.142857142857, "eval_calls": 114711, "avg_eval_calls": 8193.642857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 114711, "pattern_eval_ns": 2533439, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.085405933171188, "pattern_frame_queries": 114711, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2533439, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.085405933171188, "pattern_frame_updates": 363632, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5411522286, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14881.864868878427, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 61209, "avg_candidate_generations": 4372.071428571428, "candidate_moves_total": 5709921, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.2856442679998, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1168, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 61195, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5708753, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 1664061, "avg_legality_checks": 118861.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4259, "root_legality_checks": 1168, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1662893, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4257, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5900106, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 421436.14285714284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13479812028, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2284.67285638597, "renju_forbidden_checks": 81641, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5831.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 574141374, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7032.51275707059, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5463, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 55733821, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 38177, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 353031031, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37624, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 162342272, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 377, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3034250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 162010, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11572.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1668876393, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10301.070261094994, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 229367, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16383.357142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 790384307, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3445.9373275144203, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4281458438, "stage_ordering_ns": 2265312514, "stage_eval_ns": 5414055725, "stage_threat_ns": 10207545473, "stage_proof_ns": 262732584, "tactical_annotations": 1288667, "root_tactical_annotations": 3719, "search_tactical_annotations": 1284948, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 367554, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2303011570, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1130528, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7494331873, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 123369, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4734013506, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 183770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 289015337, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3908, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24021681, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 367540, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48452809, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 342494, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 471797349, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 556227, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1993493400, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 389946, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 48712203, "child_limit_applications": 61195, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 61195, "child_cap_hits": 61195, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 61195, "child_moves_before_total": 5704496, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5704496, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 759157, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 759157, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.21833483127706, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.405539668273551, "tt_hits": 35213, "tt_cutoffs": 5913, "beta_cutoffs": 50392, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1457.2857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1862.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3937, "avg_search_time_ms": 281.2142857142857, "search_nodes": 113378, "safety_nodes": 1726, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 115104, "avg_nodes": 8221.714285714286, "eval_calls": 109780, "avg_eval_calls": 7841.428571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 109780, "pattern_eval_ns": 2356110, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.462106030242303, "pattern_frame_queries": 109780, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2356110, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.462106030242303, "pattern_frame_updates": 226676, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2380942192, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10503.724223120225, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3572, "avg_candidate_generations": 255.14285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 305307, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.47228443449048, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1195, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 3558, "search_candidate_moves_total": 304112, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 6335, "avg_legality_checks": 452.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6335, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 614618, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 43901.28571428572, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1502943323, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2445.3291686868915, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11049, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 789.2142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 95613955, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8653.629740247987, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 211421, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10979, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 94902823, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 499711, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18374060, "stage_ordering_ns": 118390, "stage_eval_ns": 2383298302, "stage_threat_ns": 1508877290, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 226690, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1322465319, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 304861, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 113338, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 157840932, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 226676, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28266178, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 167, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3285, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6256.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6827.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1962, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1121, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17333, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 114, 81, 83, 66, 113, 50, 34, 111, 99, 79, 78, 129, 115, 116, 131, 67, 147 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9889, "avg_search_time_ms": 899.0, "search_nodes": 285480, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 285866, "avg_nodes": 25987.81818181818, "eval_calls": 279154, "avg_eval_calls": 25377.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 279154, "pattern_eval_ns": 5655904, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.260873926219936, "pattern_frame_queries": 279154, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5655904, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.260873926219936, "pattern_frame_updates": 570898, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5922680645, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10374.323688294582, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6306, "avg_candidate_generations": 573.2727272727273, "candidate_moves_total": 496696, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.76562004440216, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 817, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 6295, "search_candidate_moves_total": 495879, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 275957, "avg_legality_checks": 25087.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 202, "root_legality_checks": 817, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 275140, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 202, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1910539, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 173685.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4087121005, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2139.250235143067, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25651, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2331.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 218462462, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8516.723012748042, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 206, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1637417, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25445, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 216825045, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.9090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 113250, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11325.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.2727272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 61360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4382.857142857143, "stage_move_gen_ns": 609724775, "stage_ordering_ns": 214633, "stage_eval_ns": 5928336549, "stage_threat_ns": 3309926454, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 570909, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2891585815, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 170821, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 285449, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 354508438, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 570898, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63661380, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 494, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5536, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4209.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4937.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7432, "avg_search_time_ms": 743.2, "search_nodes": 58291, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 679, "corridor_branch_probes": 794, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 334, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 673, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 673, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 334, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 13, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 35, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4016560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2002560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59943, "avg_nodes": 5994.3, "eval_calls": 35886, "avg_eval_calls": 3588.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35886, "pattern_eval_ns": 756632, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.084322577049544, "pattern_frame_queries": 35886, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 756632, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.084322577049544, "pattern_frame_updates": 116474, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1032210682, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8862.155347974654, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20318, "avg_candidate_generations": 2031.8, "candidate_moves_total": 1773477, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.28600255930702, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 749, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 20308, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1772728, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1108428, "avg_legality_checks": 110842.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1092, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1108428, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1092, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2437374, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 243737.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4831574177, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1982.2867467200356, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17071, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1707.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 68557340, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4016.011950090797, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1343, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10844327, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4604, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37860294, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11124, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19852719, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 82735, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8273.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 766023072, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9258.754722910497, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 114292, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11429.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 365600786, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3198.830941798201, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2500252447, "stage_ordering_ns": 681661476, "stage_eval_ns": 1032967314, "stage_threat_ns": 3154679999, "stage_proof_ns": 15282701, "tactical_annotations": 314629, "root_tactical_annotations": 951, "search_tactical_annotations": 313678, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 117856, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 663685204, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 309178, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2376972596, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40979, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1345869457, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58923, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 83201233, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1372, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7808978, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 117846, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13865530, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52662, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 297097338, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 180343, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 709833645, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 81624, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9146458, "child_limit_applications": 20308, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20308, "child_cap_hits": 20308, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20308, "child_moves_before_total": 1771636, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1771636, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 206273, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 206273, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.23832972227693, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.157228678353357, "tt_hits": 9428, "tt_cutoffs": 2043, "beta_cutoffs": 16086, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 5.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4376.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5176.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1734, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1122, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12783, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 114, 81, 79, 66, 113, 84, 83, 111, 100, 86, 99, 38, 115, 116, 131, 67, 147 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11429, "avg_search_time_ms": 1142.9, "search_nodes": 108360, "safety_nodes": 568, "corridor_nodes": 2766, "corridor_branch_probes": 3169, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1200, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2743, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2743, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1200, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 555, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 27914080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 111694, "avg_nodes": 11169.4, "eval_calls": 67957, "avg_eval_calls": 6795.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67957, "pattern_eval_ns": 1458153, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.456994864399547, "pattern_frame_queries": 67957, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1458153, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.456994864399547, "pattern_frame_updates": 216612, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2413913026, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11143.94874706849, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37842, "avg_candidate_generations": 3784.2, "candidate_moves_total": 3018548, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.76713704349665, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 651, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 37832, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3017897, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 917711, "avg_legality_checks": 91771.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 856, "root_legality_checks": 651, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 917060, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 853, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3448617, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 344861.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6953764256, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2016.3921525643468, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19871, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1987.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 109962620, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5533.824165869861, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 910, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8377661, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9112, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71554765, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9401, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26139090, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 448, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3891104, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81079, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8107.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 668892393, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8249.884594037914, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 105799, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10579.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 282391329, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2669.130417111693, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1992061289, "stage_ordering_ns": 1123954215, "stage_eval_ns": 2415371179, "stage_threat_ns": 5416863095, "stage_proof_ns": 416197350, "tactical_annotations": 505226, "root_tactical_annotations": 2024, "search_tactical_annotations": 503202, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 222246, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1239060248, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 563220, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3941654721, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 77203, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2623146469, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111118, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 155026535, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5624, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 32116862, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 222236, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26018001, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 95822, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 147727523, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 229114, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 759592851, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 180290, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22986728, "child_limit_applications": 37832, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37832, "child_cap_hits": 37832, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37832, "child_moves_before_total": 3017044, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3017044, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 348153, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 348153, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.74846690632269, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.202606259251427, "tt_hits": 21229, "tt_cutoffs": 2517, "beta_cutoffs": 29974, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2963.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3763.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1266, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1346, "avg_search_time_ms": 149.55555555555554, "search_nodes": 52848, "safety_nodes": 627, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53475, "avg_nodes": 5941.666666666667, "eval_calls": 50368, "avg_eval_calls": 5596.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50368, "pattern_eval_ns": 1031146, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.472244282083864, "pattern_frame_queries": 50368, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1031146, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.472244282083864, "pattern_frame_updates": 105644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 741651268, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7020.287645299307, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2463, "avg_candidate_generations": 273.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 173850, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.58465286236297, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 583, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 2454, "search_candidate_moves_total": 173267, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 10814, "avg_legality_checks": 1201.5555555555557, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10814, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 214832, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23870.222222222223, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 430833628, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2005.4443844492441, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2554, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 283.77777777777777, "renju_forbidden_ns": 24327704, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9525.334377447141, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 38750, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2535, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24114653, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 174301, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22971976, "stage_ordering_ns": 90350, "stage_eval_ns": 742682414, "stage_threat_ns": 559348044, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 105653, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 489090462, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 180480, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52822, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 59133284, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 105644, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10943818, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 200, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2172, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5589.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6478.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1990, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1123, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19157, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 140, 154, 142, 99, 129, 100, 127, 69, 54, 97, 143, 86, 72, 141, 157, 172, 171, 115, 185 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11278, "avg_search_time_ms": 1025.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 267517, "safety_nodes": 383, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 267900, "avg_nodes": 24354.545454545456, "eval_calls": 261516, "avg_eval_calls": 23774.18181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 261516, "pattern_eval_ns": 5604985, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.432665687759066, "pattern_frame_queries": 261516, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5604985, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.432665687759066, "pattern_frame_updates": 534972, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6966002312, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13021.246554959886, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5981, "avg_candidate_generations": 543.7272727272727, "candidate_moves_total": 465472, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.82511285738171, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 809, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 5970, "search_candidate_moves_total": 464663, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 257622, "avg_legality_checks": 23420.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 89, "root_legality_checks": 809, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 256813, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 89, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1923933, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 174903.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4859329333, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2525.726900572941, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31589, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2871.7272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 335188151, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10610.913640824338, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 92, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 868322, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 31497, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 334319829, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.9090909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 120610, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 12061.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.2727272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 65440, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4674.285714285715, "stage_move_gen_ns": 664637617, "stage_ordering_ns": 212241, "stage_eval_ns": 6971607297, "stage_threat_ns": 3614246138, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 534983, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3173550944, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 29, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 176020, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11270, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 267486, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 370541605, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 534972, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69977569, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 495, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5122, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4034.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4761.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7869, "avg_search_time_ms": 786.9, "search_nodes": 52972, "safety_nodes": 953, "corridor_nodes": 530, "corridor_branch_probes": 590, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 248, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 524, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 524, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 248, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 13, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 35, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4012800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2002560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 54455, "avg_nodes": 5445.5, "eval_calls": 32470, "avg_eval_calls": 3247.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32470, "pattern_eval_ns": 724003, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.297597782568523, "pattern_frame_queries": 32470, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 724003, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.297597782568523, "pattern_frame_updates": 105836, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1192681179, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11269.14451604369, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18405, "avg_candidate_generations": 1840.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1582726, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.99434936158653, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 739, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 18395, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1581987, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 969672, "avg_legality_checks": 96967.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 526, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 969672, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 526, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2403306, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 240330.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5157478158, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2145.993126967602, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14616, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1461.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57729187, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3949.7254378763, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 730, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6968975, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3634, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32855103, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10252, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17905109, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 101297, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10129.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1078160150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10643.554596878486, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 143899, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14389.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 531185247, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3691.37552727955, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2400644051, "stage_ordering_ns": 667082685, "stage_eval_ns": 1193405182, "stage_threat_ns": 3542660859, "stage_proof_ns": 18820023, "tactical_annotations": 332030, "root_tactical_annotations": 951, "search_tactical_annotations": 331079, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 106920, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 668953797, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 321344, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2762646077, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37129, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1357874517, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 53455, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81384104, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1074, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6105738, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 106910, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14193220, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 54596, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 346132136, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 200739, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1039458495, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76695, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9377923, "child_limit_applications": 18395, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18395, "child_cap_hits": 18395, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18395, "child_moves_before_total": 1581461, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1581461, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 212299, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 212299, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.9723294373471, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.541125305789617, "tt_hits": 8225, "tt_cutoffs": 2054, "beta_cutoffs": 14504, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 5.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4222.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5022.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1613, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1124, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30864, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 141, 99, 129, 86, 140, 154, 142, 54, 69, 143, 127, 157, 156, 171, 124, 199, 185, 100, 72, 172, 170, 155, 158, 174, 110, 94, 111, 96, 109, 108, 113 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 28151, "avg_search_time_ms": 1655.9411764705883, "search_nodes": 268800, "safety_nodes": 757, "corridor_nodes": 754, "corridor_branch_probes": 903, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 333, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 747, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 747, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 30, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 23, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 333, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 30, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 169, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6113280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 270311, "avg_nodes": 15900.64705882353, "eval_calls": 184672, "avg_eval_calls": 10863.058823529413, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 184672, "pattern_eval_ns": 3903789, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.139041110726044, "pattern_frame_queries": 184672, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3903789, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.139041110726044, "pattern_frame_updates": 537422, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8456311248, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15734.955487493999, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 77968, "avg_candidate_generations": 4586.35294117647, "candidate_moves_total": 7432754, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.33082803201313, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1435, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 77951, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7431319, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 1894211, "avg_legality_checks": 111424.17647058824, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5976, "root_legality_checks": 1435, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1892776, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5973, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7723592, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 454328.9411764706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16559573929, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2144.0249470712592, "renju_forbidden_checks": 126107, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7418.058823529412, "renju_forbidden_ns": 766434111, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6077.649226450554, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7209, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 64578269, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 73963, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 529760487, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 44649, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 169862190, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 286, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2233165, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 226934, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13349.058823529413, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1949744298, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8591.679950998969, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 298502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17558.941176470587, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 820375951, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2748.3097299180577, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4481691346, "stage_ordering_ns": 2787912151, "stage_eval_ns": 8460215037, "stage_threat_ns": 12196698464, "stage_proof_ns": 140501023, "tactical_annotations": 1758488, "root_tactical_annotations": 4365, "search_tactical_annotations": 1754123, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 538993, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3134507358, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1436394, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8512313763, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 156429, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5482616364, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 269488, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 396376498, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1554, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9022814, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 538976, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 68329653, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 566208, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 656363877, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 670332, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2252907375, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 521948, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 76148378, "child_limit_applications": 77951, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 77951, "child_cap_hits": 77951, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 77951, "child_moves_before_total": 7425346, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7425346, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 1058295, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1058295, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.25658426447383, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.576413387897526, "tt_hits": 44284, "tt_cutoffs": 6090, "beta_cutoffs": 63931, "depth_sum": 85, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 85, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4117647058823529, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2535.0588235294117, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2887.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 2695, "avg_search_time_ms": 168.4375, "search_nodes": 85856, "safety_nodes": 2065, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87921, "avg_nodes": 5495.0625, "eval_calls": 82053, "avg_eval_calls": 5128.3125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82053, "pattern_eval_ns": 1743895, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.253275322047944, "pattern_frame_queries": 82053, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1743895, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.253275322047944, "pattern_frame_updates": 171618, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1477914662, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8611.652985118111, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3772, "avg_candidate_generations": 235.75, "candidate_moves_total": 314418, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.3557794273595, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1342, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 3756, "search_candidate_moves_total": 313076, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 9310, "avg_legality_checks": 581.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9310, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 374800, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 23425.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 892585115, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2381.497105122732, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4084, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 255.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32309113, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7911.144221351616, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 37950, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4058, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32149723, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 121440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 25680814, "stage_ordering_ns": 124061, "stage_eval_ns": 1479658557, "stage_threat_ns": 1158453980, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 171634, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1022687355, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 471771, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17170, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85809, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 114414501, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 171618, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20880353, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 149, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3474, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6608.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7108.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1125, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18287, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 84, 82, 140, 97, 127, 66, 114, 52, 67, 80, 94, 79, 81, 50, 34, 53, 54, 38, 24, 69, 125, 83, 68, 55, 41, 111 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 8834, "avg_search_time_ms": 631.0, "search_nodes": 274804, "safety_nodes": 422, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 275226, "avg_nodes": 19659.0, "eval_calls": 266527, "avg_eval_calls": 19037.64285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 266527, "pattern_eval_ns": 5226664, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.610260874132827, "pattern_frame_queries": 266527, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5226664, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.610260874132827, "pattern_frame_updates": 549528, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5185963995, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9437.124213870813, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8251, "avg_candidate_generations": 589.3571428571429, "candidate_moves_total": 648321, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.57483941340443, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1013, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 8237, "search_candidate_moves_total": 647308, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 256650, "avg_legality_checks": 18332.14285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 80, "root_legality_checks": 1013, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 255637, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 80, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1835856, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 131132.57142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3629517368, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1977.0163716544216, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21174, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1512.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_ns": 122802392, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5799.678473599698, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 90, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 613391, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21079, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 122180811, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8190, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.6428571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 222361, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9667.869565217392, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 37, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.642857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 114691, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3099.7567567567567, "stage_move_gen_ns": 540691581, "stage_ordering_ns": 265960, "stage_eval_ns": 5191190659, "stage_threat_ns": 3051415199, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 549542, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2668330019, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 40, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 334802, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12350, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 274764, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 324290353, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 549528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58460025, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 751, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7065, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 2.7857142857142856, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7857142857142856, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5328.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5899.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 9440, "avg_search_time_ms": 726.1538461538462, "search_nodes": 93239, "safety_nodes": 1187, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 13, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 13, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 22, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4002640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 94426, "avg_nodes": 7263.538461538462, "eval_calls": 60293, "avg_eval_calls": 4637.923076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60293, "pattern_eval_ns": 1180027, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.57154230175974, "pattern_frame_queries": 60293, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1180027, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.57154230175974, "pattern_frame_updates": 186330, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1655196866, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8883.147458809639, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30663, "avg_candidate_generations": 2358.6923076923076, "candidate_moves_total": 2542086, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.90402113296155, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 944, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 30650, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2541142, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 1554194, "avg_legality_checks": 119553.38461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2031, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1554194, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2031, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3716265, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 285866.53846153844, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5985747449, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1610.6890786851852, "renju_forbidden_checks": 63896, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4915.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 119550373, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1871.014977463378, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3048, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15333532, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14847, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 56200378, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 46001, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 48016463, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 136649, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10511.461538461539, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 929531392, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6802.328535152105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 199229, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15325.307692307691, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 421692388, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2116.621515943964, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2901087265, "stage_ordering_ns": 813319060, "stage_eval_ns": 1656376893, "stage_threat_ns": 3979485745, "stage_proof_ns": 19503512, "tactical_annotations": 526001, "root_tactical_annotations": 964, "search_tactical_annotations": 525037, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 186369, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 885032923, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 510165, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2951981593, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61452, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1634415293, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 93178, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 115085635, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 26, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 132450, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 186356, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18999857, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 111460, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 267888265, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 337219, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1049425804, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 77322, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8253287, "child_limit_applications": 30650, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30650, "child_cap_hits": 30650, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30650, "child_moves_before_total": 2539111, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2539111, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 276974, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 276974, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.8421207177814, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.036672104404568, "tt_hits": 9878, "tt_cutoffs": 2223, "beta_cutoffs": 22920, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5074.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5689.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1126, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28596, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 126, 82, 142, 94, 141, 81, 156, 111, 158, 174, 83, 114, 130, 66, 50, 70, 56, 113, 115, 67, 186, 171, 144, 172, 143, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 22375, "avg_search_time_ms": 1598.2142857142858, "search_nodes": 193730, "safety_nodes": 713, "corridor_nodes": 2047, "corridor_branch_probes": 2380, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 937, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2032, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2032, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 27, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 12, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 937, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 27, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 27, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 163, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23822320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 196490, "avg_nodes": 14035.0, "eval_calls": 122804, "avg_eval_calls": 8771.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 122804, "pattern_eval_ns": 2527146, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.57869450506498, "pattern_frame_queries": 122804, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2527146, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.57869450506498, "pattern_frame_updates": 387298, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5452130614, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14077.35287556352, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 64197, "avg_candidate_generations": 4585.5, "candidate_moves_total": 6018280, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.7470598314563, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1156, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 64183, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6017124, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 1748642, "avg_legality_checks": 124903.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4566, "root_legality_checks": 1156, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1747486, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4564, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6190586, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 442184.71428571426, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13282537732, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2145.602650863747, "renju_forbidden_checks": 97196, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6942.571428571428, "renju_forbidden_ns": 609665627, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6272.538242314498, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5979, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 54714009, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 48035, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 381814500, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 42796, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 170180705, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 386, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2956413, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 167545, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11967.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1611668792, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9619.318941179981, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 234355, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16739.64285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 749954415, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3200.078577371936, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4198427343, "stage_ordering_ns": 2272439204, "stage_eval_ns": 5454657760, "stage_threat_ns": 10114773272, "stage_proof_ns": 257187745, "tactical_annotations": 1383763, "root_tactical_annotations": 3719, "search_tactical_annotations": 1380044, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 391430, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2287776148, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1202949, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7403348013, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 129393, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4670046332, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 195708, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 288576179, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4118, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 23902796, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 391416, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48635105, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 354760, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 453710121, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 605012, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1984585346, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 423991, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 62535031, "child_limit_applications": 64183, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 64183, "child_cap_hits": 64183, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 64183, "child_moves_before_total": 6012560, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6012560, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 817651, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 817651, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.67838835828802, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.739370238225074, "tt_hits": 37513, "tt_cutoffs": 6665, "beta_cutoffs": 52688, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1551.2142857142858, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1959.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6206, "avg_search_time_ms": 443.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 183308, "safety_nodes": 1703, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 185011, "avg_nodes": 13215.07142857143, "eval_calls": 179294, "avg_eval_calls": 12806.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 179294, "pattern_eval_ns": 3632712, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.2612022711301, "pattern_frame_queries": 179294, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3632712, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.2612022711301, "pattern_frame_updates": 366536, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3849363538, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10502.006727852107, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3988, "avg_candidate_generations": 284.85714285714283, "candidate_moves_total": 339615, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.15922768304915, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1184, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 3974, "search_candidate_moves_total": 338431, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 7185, "avg_legality_checks": 513.2142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7185, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1081234, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 77231.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2441324394, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2257.9056836910418, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24054, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1718.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 189828656, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7891.770848923256, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 237400, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23978, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 189112232, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 479024, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19491872, "stage_ordering_ns": 121191, "stage_eval_ns": 3852996250, "stage_threat_ns": 2310043451, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 366550, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2023148834, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 291044, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14531, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 183268, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 243112171, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 366536, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43491402, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 169, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3679, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6144.214285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6715.642857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1127, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14730, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 128, 64, 113, 157, 172, 143, 83, 68, 129, 145, 65, 81, 144, 79, 80, 111, 95, 125, 50 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4855, "avg_search_time_ms": 441.3636363636364, "search_nodes": 203330, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 204143, "avg_nodes": 18558.454545454544, "eval_calls": 198163, "avg_eval_calls": 18014.81818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 198163, "pattern_eval_ns": 3563444, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 17.982388235947173, "pattern_frame_queries": 198163, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3563444, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 17.982388235947173, "pattern_frame_updates": 406596, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2972777513, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7311.37914047359, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5146, "avg_candidate_generations": 467.8181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 371735, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.23766031869413, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 755, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 5135, "search_candidate_moves_total": 370980, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 194364, "avg_legality_checks": 17669.454545454544, "illegal_moves_skipped": 205, "root_legality_checks": 755, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 193609, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 204, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1420099, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 129099.90909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1949609970, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1372.869053495566, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21204, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1927.6363636363637, "renju_forbidden_ns": 100111251, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4721.338002263724, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 205, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1027049, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20990, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 99055492, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 28710, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.272727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 148382, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5935.28, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.1818181818181817, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 75071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2144.885714285714, "stage_move_gen_ns": 286593623, "stage_ordering_ns": 149530, "stage_eval_ns": 2976340957, "stage_threat_ns": 1547773220, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 406607, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1341304107, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 228253, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5961, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 203298, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 175066025, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 406596, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31174835, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 245, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4563, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5210.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5937.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1895, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9863, "avg_search_time_ms": 896.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 117486, "safety_nodes": 652, "corridor_nodes": 1616, "corridor_branch_probes": 1908, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 8, "corridor_depth_exits": 610, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1595, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1595, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 76, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 55, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 610, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 76, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 74, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 567, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 52354800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4000000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 119754, "avg_nodes": 10886.727272727272, "eval_calls": 72890, "avg_eval_calls": 6626.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72890, "pattern_eval_ns": 1329385, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.23823569762656, "pattern_frame_queries": 72890, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1329385, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.23823569762656, "pattern_frame_updates": 234838, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1541771443, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6565.25538030472, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41560, "avg_candidate_generations": 3778.181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 3551823, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.46253609239653, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 783, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 41549, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3551040, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 2481525, "avg_legality_checks": 225593.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3731, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2481525, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3731, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5518231, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 501657.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6295306416, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1140.81966050352, "renju_forbidden_checks": 51827, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4711.545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 103570225, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1998.3835645512956, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3781, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19480997, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10193, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 50770966, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37835, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 33225101, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 93161, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 190281, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17298.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1042163170, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5476.969166653528, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 275593, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25053.909090909092, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 525909843, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1908.2844738436752, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3256268735, "stage_ordering_ns": 793917918, "stage_eval_ns": 1543100828, "stage_threat_ns": 4114494825, "stage_proof_ns": 63086158, "tactical_annotations": 791498, "root_tactical_annotations": 2461, "search_tactical_annotations": 789037, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 238191, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 856455471, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 732497, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3084169153, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 84208, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1686990174, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 119090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 115845894, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3342, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12352678, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 238180, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19029467, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 203404, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 474822109, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 346198, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 879011689, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 241896, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26642162, "child_limit_applications": 41549, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41549, "child_cap_hits": 41549, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41549, "child_moves_before_total": 3547309, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3547309, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 467786, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 467786, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.37651929047631, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.258658451466943, "tt_hits": 23302, "tt_cutoffs": 2980, "beta_cutoffs": 33731, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 6.090909090909091, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 6.090909090909091, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5225.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5952.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1866, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1128, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10399, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 99, 128, 144, 129, 130, 126, 125, 111, 141, 143, 95, 157, 172, 115, 101, 171 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9977, "avg_search_time_ms": 997.7, "search_nodes": 145602, "safety_nodes": 312, "corridor_nodes": 8172, "corridor_branch_probes": 8782, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4169, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 8148, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8148, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 82, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 58, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4169, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 82, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 81, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 683, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 67361360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1983840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 154086, "avg_nodes": 15408.6, "eval_calls": 94143, "avg_eval_calls": 9414.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 94143, "pattern_eval_ns": 1708360, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.146436803586035, "pattern_frame_queries": 94143, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1708360, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.146436803586035, "pattern_frame_updates": 291096, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2234219845, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7675.19940157199, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 47912, "avg_candidate_generations": 4791.2, "candidate_moves_total": 3468737, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.39808398731007, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 578, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 47902, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3468159, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1077102, "avg_legality_checks": 107710.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1362, "root_legality_checks": 578, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1076524, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1362, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4969232, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 496923.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5968368326, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1201.0645359282883, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37665, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3766.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 90100339, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2392.1502455860877, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1542, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5278457, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17755, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57810427, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16503, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23519756, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1865, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3491699, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 123448, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12344.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 615411349, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4985.186872205301, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 165815, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16581.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 271488444, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1637.297252962639, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1483609176, "stage_ordering_ns": 829590070, "stage_eval_ns": 2235928205, "stage_threat_ns": 4890813801, "stage_proof_ns": 477886747, "tactical_annotations": 712112, "root_tactical_annotations": 2651, "search_tactical_annotations": 709461, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 307566, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1111463507, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 938143, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3524004915, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 99853, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2160180922, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 153778, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 150768716, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 16460, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 52892284, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 307556, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24489240, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 127950, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 119978993, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 301102, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 653480731, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 283060, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 27195139, "child_limit_applications": 47902, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 47902, "child_cap_hits": 47902, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 47902, "child_moves_before_total": 3466797, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3466797, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 539651, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 539651, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.37269842595299, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.265730032148971, "tt_hits": 29121, "tt_cutoffs": 3503, "beta_cutoffs": 37813, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3728.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4528.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1720, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 413, "avg_search_time_ms": 45.888888888888886, "search_nodes": 22186, "safety_nodes": 730, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 22916, "avg_nodes": 2546.222222222222, "eval_calls": 21058, "avg_eval_calls": 2339.777777777778, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 21058, "pattern_eval_ns": 381092, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.09725519992402, "pattern_frame_queries": 21058, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 381092, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.09725519992402, "pattern_frame_updates": 44320, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 227700077, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5137.637116425993, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1111, "avg_candidate_generations": 123.44444444444444, "candidate_moves_total": 70821, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.74527452745274, "candidate_moves_max": 81, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 513, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 1102, "search_candidate_moves_total": 70308, "search_candidate_moves_max": 81, "legality_checks": 3319, "avg_legality_checks": 368.77777777777777, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3319, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 101916, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11324.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 131933055, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1294.5274049217003, "renju_forbidden_checks": 455, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 50.55555555555556, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2153685, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4733.373626373626, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 455, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 2153685, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5162850, "stage_ordering_ns": 32660, "stage_eval_ns": 228081169, "stage_threat_ns": 171722155, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 44329, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 149323321, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 154930, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 22160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 18866603, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 44320, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 3377301, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 69, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 981, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5702.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6591.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1129, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25306, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 126, 70, 127, 108, 109, 125, 99, 85, 129, 130, 84, 114, 97, 146, 162, 100, 115, 81, 143, 101, 131, 83, 145, 161, 173, 158, 159, 117, 187 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 3785, "avg_search_time_ms": 236.5625, "search_nodes": 159042, "safety_nodes": 1718, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 160760, "avg_nodes": 10047.5, "eval_calls": 154012, "avg_eval_calls": 9625.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 154012, "pattern_eval_ns": 2855033, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.53773082616939, "pattern_frame_queries": 154012, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2855033, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.53773082616939, "pattern_frame_updates": 317990, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2287640408, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7194.06398943363, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4999, "avg_candidate_generations": 312.4375, "candidate_moves_total": 356110, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.23624724944989, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1185, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4983, "search_candidate_moves_total": 354925, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 149705, "avg_legality_checks": 9356.5625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 1185, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 148520, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1097575, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 68598.4375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1539768154, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1402.8819479306653, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11448, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 715.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 49471581, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4321.416928721174, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13370, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11434, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 49450631, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7580, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 414543, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6096.220588235294, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 208261, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2288.5824175824177, "stage_move_gen_ns": 224113054, "stage_ordering_ns": 146502, "stage_eval_ns": 2290495441, "stage_threat_ns": 1231683360, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 318006, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1065509815, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 612433, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10970, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 158995, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 140828065, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 317990, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24733047, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 188, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4553, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6293.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6793.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1871, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 21504, "avg_search_time_ms": 1344.0, "search_nodes": 228723, "safety_nodes": 426, "corridor_nodes": 2197, "corridor_branch_probes": 2398, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 920, "corridor_neutral_exits": 69, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 2175, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2175, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 102, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 80, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 73, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 920, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 102, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 823, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 22277440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1979760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 231346, "avg_nodes": 14459.125, "eval_calls": 145755, "avg_eval_calls": 9109.6875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 145755, "pattern_eval_ns": 2904678, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.928496449521457, "pattern_frame_queries": 145755, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2904678, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.928496449521457, "pattern_frame_updates": 457258, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3054412989, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6679.845927244575, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 77653, "avg_candidate_generations": 4853.3125, "candidate_moves_total": 7015987, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.35049515150735, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1222, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 77637, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7014765, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 5071808, "avg_legality_checks": 316988.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1503, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5071808, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1503, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10238648, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 639915.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14002542148, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1367.6163247335, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39739, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2483.6875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 72572802, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1826.2362414756285, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1727, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9228447, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7891, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38169307, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30121, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25175048, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 318981, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19936.3125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2108430753, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6609.894485878469, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 450446, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 28152.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1069726192, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2374.815609418221, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7917855085, "stage_ordering_ns": 1812078414, "stage_eval_ns": 3057317667, "stage_threat_ns": 8429407055, "stage_proof_ns": 97871126, "tactical_annotations": 1453506, "root_tactical_annotations": 4857, "search_tactical_annotations": 1448649, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 461828, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1909984059, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1243396, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6143691115, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 156901, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3381294418, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 230906, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 258018448, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4554, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17636512, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 461812, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42748769, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 386913, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1253389077, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 572891, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1454894427, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 493702, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 57328152, "child_limit_applications": 77637, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 77637, "child_cap_hits": 77637, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 77637, "child_moves_before_total": 7013262, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7013262, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 830429, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 830429, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.33401599752695, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.696304597034919, "tt_hits": 46464, "tt_cutoffs": 5239, "beta_cutoffs": 63247, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 5.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 5.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4954.4375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5454.4375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1775, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1130, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20025, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 143, 126, 140, 141, 156, 96, 81, 97, 95, 83, 125, 99, 100, 69, 55, 84, 70, 114, 54, 129 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 18049, "avg_search_time_ms": 1504.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 171269, "safety_nodes": 222, "corridor_nodes": 4009, "corridor_branch_probes": 4368, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1996, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 3988, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3988, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 65, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1996, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 65, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 545, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 41686720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1982000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 175500, "avg_nodes": 14625.0, "eval_calls": 108252, "avg_eval_calls": 9021.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 108252, "pattern_eval_ns": 2338156, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.59919447215756, "pattern_frame_queries": 108252, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2338156, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.59919447215756, "pattern_frame_updates": 342410, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4290412248, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12530.043655267078, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 58950, "avg_candidate_generations": 4912.5, "candidate_moves_total": 4337859, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.58539440203562, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 58938, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4337125, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 1124979, "avg_legality_checks": 93748.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1192, "root_legality_checks": 734, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1124245, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1192, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5077109, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 423092.4166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10769168936, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2121.1222638710337, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34137, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2844.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 155707346, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4561.248674458799, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1303, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10495700, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17000, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 103464493, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15265, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39759008, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 569, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1988145, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 120223, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10018.583333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1027677669, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8548.095364447734, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 158594, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13216.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 420852132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2653.644728047719, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2662687390, "stage_ordering_ns": 1756036238, "stage_eval_ns": 4292750404, "stage_threat_ns": 8797742955, "stage_proof_ns": 481470978, "tactical_annotations": 969742, "root_tactical_annotations": 3546, "search_tactical_annotations": 966196, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 350528, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2085601844, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 929458, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6313127496, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 119926, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4264057445, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 175258, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 263946716, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8106, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 45958980, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 350516, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44145840, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 204252, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 253500419, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 396787, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1255729466, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 368703, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 44962079, "child_limit_applications": 58938, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 58938, "child_cap_hits": 58938, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 58938, "child_moves_before_total": 4335933, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4335933, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 674041, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 674041, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.56769825918762, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.436441684481998, "tt_hits": 35640, "tt_cutoffs": 4015, "beta_cutoffs": 47621, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.083333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.083333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1079.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1578.8333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1966, "avg_search_time_ms": 178.72727272727272, "search_nodes": 61763, "safety_nodes": 888, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 62651, "avg_nodes": 5695.545454545455, "eval_calls": 59607, "avg_eval_calls": 5418.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 59607, "pattern_eval_ns": 1259568, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.131209421712214, "pattern_frame_queries": 59607, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1259568, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.131209421712214, "pattern_frame_updates": 123462, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1137157903, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9210.590327388185, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2135, "avg_candidate_generations": 194.0909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 138974, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.09320843091335, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 670, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 2124, "search_candidate_moves_total": 138304, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 4468, "avg_legality_checks": 406.1818181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4468, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 303695, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27608.636363636364, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 682706245, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2247.9996213306113, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1669, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 151.72727272727272, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12594900, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7546.375074895147, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1669, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12594900, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10633622, "stage_ordering_ns": 69780, "stage_eval_ns": 1138417471, "stage_threat_ns": 797815826, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 123473, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 699926390, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 240002, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61731, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 82597952, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 123462, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15051482, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1937, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5894.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6621.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1934, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1131, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32159, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 128, 96, 160, 111, 52, 67, 81, 143, 159, 141, 156, 144, 142, 113, 170, 184, 158, 157, 99, 125, 173, 171, 129, 155, 169, 123, 124, 139, 187, 107 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 4858, "avg_search_time_ms": 303.625, "search_nodes": 115688, "safety_nodes": 1718, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 117406, "avg_nodes": 7337.875, "eval_calls": 112202, "avg_eval_calls": 7012.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 112202, "pattern_eval_ns": 2420687, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.57436587583109, "pattern_frame_queries": 112202, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2420687, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.57436587583109, "pattern_frame_updates": 231282, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2978311301, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12877.402050310877, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3455, "avg_candidate_generations": 215.9375, "candidate_moves_total": 273460, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.14905933429812, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1185, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3439, "search_candidate_moves_total": 272275, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 108555, "avg_legality_checks": 6784.6875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 1185, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 107370, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 868739, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 54296.1875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2131798393, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2453.8997247734937, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11555, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 722.1875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 115070412, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9958.495196884465, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11650, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11545, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 115047992, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 10770, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 684044, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10059.470588235294, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 327733, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3601.4615384615386, "stage_move_gen_ns": 274902842, "stage_ordering_ns": 119900, "stage_eval_ns": 2980731988, "stage_threat_ns": 1572998393, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 231298, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1374936114, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1016974, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17600, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115641, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 167699102, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 231282, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29346203, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 188, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3124, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6604.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7104.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1852, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 27286, "avg_search_time_ms": 1705.375, "search_nodes": 175503, "safety_nodes": 426, "corridor_nodes": 1401, "corridor_branch_probes": 1653, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 453, "corridor_neutral_exits": 65, "corridor_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_plies_followed": 1376, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1376, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 101, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 76, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 69, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 453, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 101, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 822, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26396560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1990080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 177330, "avg_nodes": 11083.125, "eval_calls": 105686, "avg_eval_calls": 6605.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105686, "pattern_eval_ns": 2383811, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.55559866018205, "pattern_frame_queries": 105686, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2383811, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.55559866018205, "pattern_frame_updates": 350814, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3367704018, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9599.68535463237, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 65398, "avg_candidate_generations": 4087.375, "candidate_moves_total": 5732551, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.65636563809291, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1222, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 65382, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5731329, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 4296620, "avg_legality_checks": 268538.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 249, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4296620, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 249, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8660164, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 541260.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18514725966, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2137.918631333079, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31304, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1956.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61035025, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1949.7516291847687, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 303, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2547893, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3892, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27611908, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 27109, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30875224, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 288434, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18027.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2933105608, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10169.070248306372, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 409106, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25569.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1471504043, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3596.8771980855818, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10350474740, "stage_ordering_ns": 2290759645, "stage_eval_ns": 3370087829, "stage_threat_ns": 10935564505, "stage_proof_ns": 172266942, "tactical_annotations": 1167299, "root_tactical_annotations": 5027, "search_tactical_annotations": 1162272, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 353784, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2189568931, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1029645, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8347717610, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 131999, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4571722482, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 176884, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 283039952, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2954, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17882670, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 353768, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46182605, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 325320, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1472048127, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 476451, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2228820262, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 365528, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 51172737, "child_limit_applications": 65382, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 65382, "child_cap_hits": 65382, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 65382, "child_moves_before_total": 5731080, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5731080, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 679931, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 679931, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.65531797742499, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.399360680309565, "tt_hits": 37826, "tt_cutoffs": 4342, "beta_cutoffs": 54256, "depth_sum": 93, "avg_depth": 5.8125, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 93, "avg_effective_depth": 5.8125, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1663.8125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1962.9375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1132, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15059, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 96, 128, 95, 98, 94, 93, 127, 142, 82, 67, 100, 158, 110, 156, 170, 174, 190, 113, 143, 68, 83, 159, 111, 79, 125, 69, 139 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 10184, "avg_search_time_ms": 727.4285714285714, "search_nodes": 89110, "safety_nodes": 1291, "corridor_nodes": 293, "corridor_branch_probes": 325, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 120, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 288, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 288, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 7, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 2, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 120, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 7, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 7, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 10, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 21280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 90694, "avg_nodes": 6478.142857142857, "eval_calls": 53686, "avg_eval_calls": 3834.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53686, "pattern_eval_ns": 1169702, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.787840405319823, "pattern_frame_queries": 53686, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1169702, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.787840405319823, "pattern_frame_updates": 178060, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2317873868, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13017.375424014377, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32160, "avg_candidate_generations": 2297.1428571428573, "candidate_moves_total": 2446449, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.07117537313432, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1097, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 32146, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2445352, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 787878, "avg_legality_checks": 56277.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1964, "root_legality_checks": 1097, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 786781, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1961, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2741189, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 195799.2142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6079002298, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2217.651646055781, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31569, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2254.9285714285716, "renju_forbidden_ns": 172335943, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5459.024454369794, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2198, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19677085, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12354, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 100341660, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16397, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 47513745, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 620, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4803453, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4683.571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 628042623, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9578.200747292969, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92309, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6593.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 294864927, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3194.3247895654813, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1936338211, "stage_ordering_ns": 1033266470, "stage_eval_ns": 2319043570, "stage_threat_ns": 4806527006, "stage_proof_ns": 42793821, "tactical_annotations": 463865, "root_tactical_annotations": 1452, "search_tactical_annotations": 462413, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 178664, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1101409000, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 430837, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3528177789, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64561, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2463150196, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89325, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 135293151, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 590, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3862429, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 178650, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23274062, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 63339, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 72960944, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 285960, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 948636319, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 114566, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14510575, "child_limit_applications": 32146, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32146, "child_cap_hits": 32146, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32146, "child_moves_before_total": 2443391, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2443391, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 349596, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 349596, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.0091768804828, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.875256641572824, "tt_hits": 14501, "tt_cutoffs": 3200, "beta_cutoffs": 25884, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4177.785714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4749.214285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 4860, "avg_search_time_ms": 373.84615384615387, "search_nodes": 156346, "safety_nodes": 1468, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 157814, "avg_nodes": 12139.538461538461, "eval_calls": 152835, "avg_eval_calls": 11756.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 152835, "pattern_eval_ns": 3222498, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.084816959466092, "pattern_frame_queries": 152835, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3222498, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.084816959466092, "pattern_frame_updates": 312616, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2900797878, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9279.108804411802, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3486, "avg_candidate_generations": 268.15384615384613, "candidate_moves_total": 307639, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.24985656913368, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1024, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 3473, "search_candidate_moves_total": 306615, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 6611, "avg_legality_checks": 508.53846153846155, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6611, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 784765, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 60366.53846153846, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1685907344, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2148.295787911031, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20247, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1557.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_ns": 172071074, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8498.596038919346, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 191581, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20181, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 171483502, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 46, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 395991, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17944506, "stage_ordering_ns": 122711, "stage_eval_ns": 2904020376, "stage_threat_ns": 1904574933, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 312629, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1667638478, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 338021, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13920, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 156308, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 200397972, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 312616, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36200462, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 155, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3200, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6359.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6974.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1763, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1133, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17363, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 114, 111, 126, 140, 84, 143, 141, 127, 98, 70, 95, 146, 68, 159, 175, 145, 144, 83, 116, 115, 100, 132, 52 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5540, "avg_search_time_ms": 461.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 129225, "safety_nodes": 638, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 129863, "avg_nodes": 10821.916666666666, "eval_calls": 124994, "avg_eval_calls": 10416.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 124994, "pattern_eval_ns": 2694817, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.55957085940125, "pattern_frame_queries": 124994, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2694817, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.55957085940125, "pattern_frame_updates": 258382, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3445435285, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13334.656767886308, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4209, "avg_candidate_generations": 350.75, "candidate_moves_total": 317072, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.33190781658351, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 860, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 4197, "search_candidate_moves_total": 316212, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 117379, "avg_legality_checks": 9781.583333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 65, "root_legality_checks": 860, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 116519, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 65, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 955737, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 79644.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2432483560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2545.139049759505, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15551, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1295.9166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 142998768, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9195.470902192785, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 667275, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15476, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 142331493, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.0833333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 250240, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10009.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 32, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.6666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 108070, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3377.1875, "stage_move_gen_ns": 309121585, "stage_ordering_ns": 152850, "stage_eval_ns": 3448130102, "stage_threat_ns": 1760347364, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 258394, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1543225718, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 361580, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129191, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 183794908, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 258382, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32965158, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 423, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3627, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5542.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6209.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1772, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11811, "avg_search_time_ms": 1073.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 79100, "safety_nodes": 846, "corridor_nodes": 146, "corridor_branch_probes": 161, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 36, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 137, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 137, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 58, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 58, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 440, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6525440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 80092, "avg_nodes": 7281.090909090909, "eval_calls": 47403, "avg_eval_calls": 4309.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47403, "pattern_eval_ns": 1069254, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.556673628251378, "pattern_frame_queries": 47403, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1069254, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.556673628251378, "pattern_frame_updates": 158076, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2025698663, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12814.71357448316, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29424, "avg_candidate_generations": 2674.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 2268490, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.0965878194671, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 29413, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2267704, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1442185, "avg_legality_checks": 131107.72727272726, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5437, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1442185, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5437, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3423788, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 311253.45454545453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7749398296, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2263.3989884887733, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33834, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3075.818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 251324993, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7428.178548205947, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5607, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 62214385, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12593, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 132990762, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15597, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 55640844, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 479002, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 105551, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9595.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1061582648, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10057.532832469611, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 146252, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13295.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 495520310, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3388.126726472117, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3728534391, "stage_ordering_ns": 994386248, "stage_eval_ns": 2026767917, "stage_threat_ns": 4892042032, "stage_proof_ns": 107007447, "tactical_annotations": 422555, "root_tactical_annotations": 1732, "search_tactical_annotations": 420823, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 158477, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1011148750, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 362608, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3716858922, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59220, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2306600558, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79233, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 124990941, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 390, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2146874, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 158466, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21216116, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71329, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 316111891, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 220663, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1086521570, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 130563, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15680429, "child_limit_applications": 29413, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29413, "child_cap_hits": 29413, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29413, "child_moves_before_total": 2262267, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2262267, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 274138, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 274138, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.91384761840003, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.32030054737701, "tt_hits": 15329, "tt_cutoffs": 2223, "beta_cutoffs": 23580, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2861.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3588.2727272727275, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1192, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1134, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14480, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 124, 82, 114, 98, 140, 83, 128, 84, 70, 85, 86, 81 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 10097, "avg_search_time_ms": 1262.125, "search_nodes": 80612, "safety_nodes": 448, "corridor_nodes": 893, "corridor_branch_probes": 1041, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 418, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 881, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 881, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 39, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 27, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 418, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 39, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 288, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 25910480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2028640, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 81953, "avg_nodes": 10244.125, "eval_calls": 49090, "avg_eval_calls": 6136.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49090, "pattern_eval_ns": 1080264, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.00578529232023, "pattern_frame_queries": 49090, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1080264, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.00578529232023, "pattern_frame_updates": 161144, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2173971974, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13490.865151665592, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28903, "avg_candidate_generations": 3612.875, "candidate_moves_total": 2211592, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.51773172335052, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 489, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 28895, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2211103, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 776580, "avg_legality_checks": 97072.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3586, "root_legality_checks": 489, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 776091, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3583, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2684010, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 335501.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6156637620, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2293.8206713089744, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29374, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3671.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 238769721, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8128.607646217743, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3700, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 41151472, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12324, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 126784433, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12763, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 64892150, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 587, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5941666, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 69875, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8734.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 737638798, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10556.548093023255, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98859, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12357.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 353804281, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3578.8778057637646, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2020597950, "stage_ordering_ns": 987194806, "stage_eval_ns": 2175052238, "stage_threat_ns": 4707074448, "stage_proof_ns": 170936590, "tactical_annotations": 382177, "root_tactical_annotations": 1524, "search_tactical_annotations": 380653, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 162992, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1028869124, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 359164, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3499999340, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58328, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2361685896, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 81492, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 127282869, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1840, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10145841, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 162984, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21520205, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 64077, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 108733846, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 187587, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 885849689, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 130513, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19257069, "child_limit_applications": 28895, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28895, "child_cap_hits": 28895, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28895, "child_moves_before_total": 2207520, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2207520, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 289008, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 289008, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.39799273230663, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.002007267693372, "tt_hits": 16432, "tt_cutoffs": 2587, "beta_cutoffs": 23040, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1210.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1952.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 47, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 4376, "avg_search_time_ms": 625.1428571428571, "search_nodes": 124619, "safety_nodes": 476, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 125095, "avg_nodes": 17870.714285714286, "eval_calls": 121700, "avg_eval_calls": 17385.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 121700, "pattern_eval_ns": 2617678, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.509268693508627, "pattern_frame_queries": 121700, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2617678, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.509268693508627, "pattern_frame_updates": 249198, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2602405391, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10443.123102914149, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2906, "avg_candidate_generations": 415.14285714285717, "candidate_moves_total": 202972, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.84583620096352, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 418, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 2899, "search_candidate_moves_total": 202554, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 5113, "avg_legality_checks": 730.4285714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5113, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 592193, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 84599.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1488685723, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2513.8522795777726, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11645, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1663.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_ns": 123116863, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10572.50863031344, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 80020, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11622, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 122862913, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 173930, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15209759, "stage_ordering_ns": 96460, "stage_eval_ns": 2605023069, "stage_threat_ns": 1748364951, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 249205, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1536960188, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 145701, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7660, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124599, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 178852461, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 249198, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32406601, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 119, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2537, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3639.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4782.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1956, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1135, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23932, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 142, 97, 98, 126, 70, 111, 157, 172, 141, 81, 66, 125, 139, 69, 83, 140, 85, 84, 113, 99, 129, 54 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8394, "avg_search_time_ms": 763.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 210619, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 211432, "avg_nodes": 19221.090909090908, "eval_calls": 205259, "avg_eval_calls": 18659.909090909092, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 205259, "pattern_eval_ns": 4311193, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.00367340774339, "pattern_frame_queries": 205259, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4311193, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.00367340774339, "pattern_frame_updates": 421174, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5129082424, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12178.060431080741, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5339, "avg_candidate_generations": 485.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 392498, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.51526503090466, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 755, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 5328, "search_candidate_moves_total": 391743, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 201719, "avg_legality_checks": 18338.090909090908, "illegal_moves_skipped": 194, "root_legality_checks": 755, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 200964, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 193, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1483840, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 134894.54545454544, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3536171944, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2383.122131766228, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22920, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2083.6363636363635, "renju_forbidden_ns": 196319646, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8565.429581151833, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 196, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1679968, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22715, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 194579576, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 60102, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.272727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 245360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9814.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.1818181818181817, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 114930, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3283.714285714286, "stage_move_gen_ns": 502634748, "stage_ordering_ns": 175881, "stage_eval_ns": 5133393617, "stage_threat_ns": 2734151203, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 421185, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2399563927, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 385910, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 210587, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 282324374, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 421174, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51876992, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 245, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4763, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4283.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5010.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 503, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 15525, "avg_search_time_ms": 1411.3636363636363, "search_nodes": 108424, "safety_nodes": 652, "corridor_nodes": 346, "corridor_branch_probes": 399, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 100, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 337, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 337, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 60, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 100, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 60, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 431, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2352240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2015920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 109422, "avg_nodes": 9947.454545454546, "eval_calls": 68171, "avg_eval_calls": 6197.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68171, "pattern_eval_ns": 1483304, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.7585776943275, "pattern_frame_queries": 68171, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1483304, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.7585776943275, "pattern_frame_updates": 216716, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2347344546, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10831.431670942617, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37668, "avg_candidate_generations": 3424.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 3189657, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.67816183497929, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 783, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 37657, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3188874, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 2202222, "avg_legality_checks": 200202.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3576, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2202222, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3576, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4965642, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 451422.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10279561633, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2070.1374833304535, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45125, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4102.272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 168864437, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3742.148188365651, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3604, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 36188381, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9022, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 80068350, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32481, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 52415515, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 192191, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 174613, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15873.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1699773097, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9734.516313218375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 252195, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22926.81818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 841859655, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3338.129840004758, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5230664144, "stage_ordering_ns": 1284795963, "stage_eval_ns": 2348827850, "stage_threat_ns": 6470084964, "stage_proof_ns": 107047832, "tactical_annotations": 687824, "root_tactical_annotations": 2379, "search_tactical_annotations": 685445, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 217521, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1318491043, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 594484, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4932617644, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75821, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2737481431, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108755, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 161860601, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 794, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4211094, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 217510, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28024465, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 172410, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 751887218, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 320912, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1423209889, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 194502, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24880117, "child_limit_applications": 37657, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37657, "child_cap_hits": 37657, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37657, "child_moves_before_total": 3185298, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3185298, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 415181, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 415181, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.58714183285976, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.025333935257722, "tt_hits": 20120, "tt_cutoffs": 2531, "beta_cutoffs": 30253, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.909090909090909, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2758.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3351.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1772, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1136, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29806, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 98, 68, 54, 142, 126, 84, 140, 154, 125, 128, 100, 83, 99, 101, 85, 170, 156, 80, 81, 124, 110, 113, 70, 115, 86, 38, 53, 52, 95, 155, 67, 109, 39 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 22753, "avg_search_time_ms": 1264.0555555555557, "search_nodes": 210702, "safety_nodes": 1321, "corridor_nodes": 2959, "corridor_branch_probes": 3385, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1401, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 34, "corridor_plies_followed": 2935, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2935, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 76, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1401, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 98, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 733, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 71790120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2029600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 214982, "avg_nodes": 11943.444444444445, "eval_calls": 134496, "avg_eval_calls": 7472.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 134496, "pattern_eval_ns": 2788294, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.731426956935522, "pattern_frame_queries": 134496, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2788294, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.731426956935522, "pattern_frame_updates": 421200, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5208830536, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12366.644197530864, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 69975, "avg_candidate_generations": 3887.5, "candidate_moves_total": 6067030, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.7028224365845, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1427, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 69957, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6065603, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 1957923, "avg_legality_checks": 108773.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2930, "root_legality_checks": 1427, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1956496, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2930, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6598618, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 366589.8888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13597549031, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2060.6661926785278, "renju_forbidden_checks": 64735, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3596.3888888888887, "renju_forbidden_ns": 314999019, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4865.976967637291, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3403, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 31238871, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26391, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 187565739, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 34285, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 93143827, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 656, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3050582, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 172696, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9594.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1508314960, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8733.931069625238, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 241140, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13396.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 684233486, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2837.4947582317327, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4508351320, "stage_ordering_ns": 2298671693, "stage_eval_ns": 5211618830, "stage_threat_ns": 10222604193, "stage_proof_ns": 423344256, "tactical_annotations": 1393225, "root_tactical_annotations": 3966, "search_tactical_annotations": 1389259, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 427288, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2474032804, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1299190, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7295192863, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 141637, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4629588670, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 213635, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 312496744, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6070, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 39912675, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 427270, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52376401, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 405637, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 309736009, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 602517, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1987673585, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 385071, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 48592706, "child_limit_applications": 69957, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 69957, "child_cap_hits": 69957, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 69957, "child_moves_before_total": 6062673, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6062673, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 802686, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 802686, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.66285003645096, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.473991166001973, "tt_hits": 38314, "tt_cutoffs": 6147, "beta_cutoffs": 55595, "depth_sum": 101, "avg_depth": 5.611111111111111, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 101, "avg_effective_depth": 5.611111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3968.277777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4412.722222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 7032, "avg_search_time_ms": 413.6470588235294, "search_nodes": 247233, "safety_nodes": 1762, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 248995, "avg_nodes": 14646.764705882353, "eval_calls": 240661, "avg_eval_calls": 14156.529411764706, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 240661, "pattern_eval_ns": 4877771, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.268223767041608, "pattern_frame_queries": 240661, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4877771, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.268223767041608, "pattern_frame_updates": 494366, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3947892086, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7985.76780361109, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6539, "avg_candidate_generations": 384.6470588235294, "candidate_moves_total": 534383, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.72243462303105, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1346, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 6522, "search_candidate_moves_total": 533037, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 16545, "avg_legality_checks": 973.2352941176471, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 16545, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1057807, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 62223.94117647059, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2298487546, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2172.8798788436834, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9502, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 558.9411764705883, "renju_forbidden_ns": 71343657, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7508.277941486003, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9502, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71343657, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 41441076, "stage_ordering_ns": 216072, "stage_eval_ns": 3952769857, "stage_threat_ns": 2995920526, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 494383, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2621398571, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 47, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 336562, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 247183, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 316857011, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 494366, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57328382, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 328, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5942, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6276.882352941177, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6747.470588235294, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1137, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30619, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 126, 98, 154, 113, 52, 67, 83, 141, 155, 143, 158, 140, 142, 111, 174, 190, 156, 157, 95, 129, 171, 173, 125, 159, 175, 131, 130, 145, 187, 117 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 4521, "avg_search_time_ms": 282.5625, "search_nodes": 115177, "safety_nodes": 1718, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 116895, "avg_nodes": 7305.9375, "eval_calls": 111810, "avg_eval_calls": 6988.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 111810, "pattern_eval_ns": 2265140, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.258831947053036, "pattern_frame_queries": 111810, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2265140, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.258831947053036, "pattern_frame_updates": 230260, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2776850275, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12059.629440632329, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3336, "avg_candidate_generations": 208.5, "candidate_moves_total": 262796, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.7757793764988, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1185, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3320, "search_candidate_moves_total": 261611, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 108018, "avg_legality_checks": 6751.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 1185, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 106833, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 875236, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 54702.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1999883234, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2284.964551275313, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11941, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 746.3125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 104238344, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8729.448454903275, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10730, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11931, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 104217264, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 10350, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 634811, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9335.45588235294, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 306600, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3369.230769230769, "stage_move_gen_ns": 255993246, "stage_ordering_ns": 104873, "stage_eval_ns": 2779115415, "stage_threat_ns": 1459094175, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 230276, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1278427039, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 941701, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16710, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115130, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 152408192, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 230260, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27317243, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 188, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3004, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6601.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7101.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1817, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 26080, "avg_search_time_ms": 1630.0, "search_nodes": 189062, "safety_nodes": 426, "corridor_nodes": 1453, "corridor_branch_probes": 1735, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 467, "corridor_neutral_exits": 69, "corridor_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_plies_followed": 1427, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1427, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 101, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 75, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 73, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 467, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 101, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 822, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26417440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1990240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 190941, "avg_nodes": 11933.8125, "eval_calls": 116549, "avg_eval_calls": 7284.3125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 116549, "pattern_eval_ns": 2427255, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.826047413534223, "pattern_frame_queries": 116549, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2427255, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.826047413534223, "pattern_frame_updates": 377936, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3341112692, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8840.419256170357, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 67784, "avg_candidate_generations": 4236.5, "candidate_moves_total": 6037809, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.07425056060427, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1222, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 67768, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6036587, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 4479915, "avg_legality_checks": 279994.6875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 283, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4479915, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 283, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8949997, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 559374.8125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17627533234, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1969.5574461086412, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26469, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1654.3125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50631885, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1912.8748724923496, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2742362, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3978, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25626739, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22158, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22262784, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 283859, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17741.1875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2635717434, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9285.305147978397, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 403252, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25203.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1312441299, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3254.642999910726, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9882952881, "stage_ordering_ns": 2218038053, "stage_eval_ns": 3343539947, "stage_threat_ns": 10313492161, "stage_proof_ns": 162197914, "tactical_annotations": 1234233, "root_tactical_annotations": 4857, "search_tactical_annotations": 1229376, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 381008, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2162217597, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1056078, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7758816729, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 136793, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4339459477, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 190496, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 279892884, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3056, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17139244, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 380992, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45850098, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 335716, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1456485871, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 483740, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1888792963, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 414777, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 49575609, "child_limit_applications": 67768, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 67768, "child_cap_hits": 67768, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 67768, "child_moves_before_total": 6036304, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6036304, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 707721, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 707721, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.0730728367371, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.44329181914768, "tt_hits": 40846, "tt_cutoffs": 4652, "beta_cutoffs": 55655, "depth_sum": 91, "avg_depth": 5.6875, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 91, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6875, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2633.6875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3007.8125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1138, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11105, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 127, 142, 126, 156, 114, 82, 98, 140, 99, 96, 84, 70, 69, 54, 129 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 9162, "avg_search_time_ms": 1145.25, "search_nodes": 79784, "safety_nodes": 448, "corridor_nodes": 741, "corridor_branch_probes": 878, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 314, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 730, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 730, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 39, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 28, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 314, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 39, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 288, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23934960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2025680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 80973, "avg_nodes": 10121.625, "eval_calls": 48678, "avg_eval_calls": 6084.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48678, "pattern_eval_ns": 1000614, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.55577468260816, "pattern_frame_queries": 48678, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1000614, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.55577468260816, "pattern_frame_updates": 159488, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1987683224, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12462.90143459069, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28669, "avg_candidate_generations": 3583.625, "candidate_moves_total": 2189137, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.359028916251, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 489, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 28661, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2188648, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 733959, "avg_legality_checks": 91744.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2641, "root_legality_checks": 489, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 733470, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2638, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2548892, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 318611.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5588734228, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2192.61319349741, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24071, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3008.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 178666790, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7422.4913796684805, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2695, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 28359025, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10244, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 99103133, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10709, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 47492424, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 423, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3712208, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 57178, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7147.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 567102413, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9918.19253908846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 82304, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10288.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 272989981, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3316.8494969867807, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1802406238, "stage_ordering_ns": 931045949, "stage_eval_ns": 1988683838, "stage_threat_ns": 4255227280, "stage_proof_ns": 150497195, "tactical_annotations": 355565, "root_tactical_annotations": 1524, "search_tactical_annotations": 354041, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 161034, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 949081401, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 329912, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3144383194, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 57826, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2237266256, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 80513, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118782035, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1538, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8061794, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 161026, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20006630, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 59968, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 91807458, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 167803, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 698847403, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 127794, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14912226, "child_limit_applications": 28661, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28661, "child_cap_hits": 28661, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28661, "child_moves_before_total": 2186010, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2186010, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 275814, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 275814, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.27123966365444, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.623320889012945, "tt_hits": 16478, "tt_cutoffs": 2405, "beta_cutoffs": 22703, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1647.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2505.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 366, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1937, "avg_search_time_ms": 276.7142857142857, "search_nodes": 58061, "safety_nodes": 476, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 58537, "avg_nodes": 8362.42857142857, "eval_calls": 56280, "avg_eval_calls": 8040.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 56280, "pattern_eval_ns": 1138358, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.22668798862829, "pattern_frame_queries": 56280, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1138358, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.22668798862829, "pattern_frame_updates": 116082, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1154947367, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9949.409615616547, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1768, "avg_candidate_generations": 252.57142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 121463, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.70079185520362, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 418, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 1761, "search_candidate_moves_total": 121045, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 2967, "avg_legality_checks": 423.85714285714283, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2967, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 289027, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 41289.57142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 675667972, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2337.7330560812657, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5677, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 811.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 53828942, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9481.934472432622, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 90580, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5654, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 53553502, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 184860, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8355372, "stage_ordering_ns": 56570, "stage_eval_ns": 1156085725, "stage_threat_ns": 761178887, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 116089, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 668788405, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 140421, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7260, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58041, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 78121294, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116082, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14128767, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 119, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1566, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4670.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5813.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1970, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1139, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19947, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 128, 64, 127, 115, 116, 129, 125, 124, 143, 159, 79, 95, 144, 65, 80, 97, 81, 83, 78 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5888, "avg_search_time_ms": 535.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 153980, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 154793, "avg_nodes": 14072.09090909091, "eval_calls": 149213, "avg_eval_calls": 13564.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 149213, "pattern_eval_ns": 2992575, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.05572570754559, "pattern_frame_queries": 149213, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2992575, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.05572570754559, "pattern_frame_updates": 307896, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3568252146, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11589.14745888222, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4746, "avg_candidate_generations": 431.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 335712, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.73577749683945, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 755, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 4735, "search_candidate_moves_total": 334957, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 144641, "avg_legality_checks": 13149.181818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 179, "root_legality_checks": 755, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 143886, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 178, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1066495, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 96954.09090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2476988267, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2322.550285749113, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14787, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1344.2727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 116218510, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7859.505646851964, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 179, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1452657, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14599, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 114710483, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55370, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.272727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 151571, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6062.84, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.1818181818181817, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 68470, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1956.2857142857142, "stage_move_gen_ns": 354019885, "stage_ordering_ns": 161710, "stage_eval_ns": 3571244721, "stage_threat_ns": 1944615752, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 307907, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1703392122, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 30, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 262351, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 153948, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 204483969, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 307896, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36477310, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 245, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4243, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4858.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5585.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1730, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14048, "avg_search_time_ms": 1277.090909090909, "search_nodes": 110263, "safety_nodes": 652, "corridor_nodes": 296, "corridor_branch_probes": 340, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 66, "corridor_neutral_exits": 27, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 287, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 287, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 60, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 27, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 66, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 60, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 431, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2368640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2015920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 111211, "avg_nodes": 10110.09090909091, "eval_calls": 69217, "avg_eval_calls": 6292.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 69217, "pattern_eval_ns": 1416944, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.47104035135877, "pattern_frame_queries": 69217, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1416944, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.47104035135877, "pattern_frame_updates": 220394, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2107477662, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9562.318674737062, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38351, "avg_candidate_generations": 3486.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 3235339, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.36126828505124, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 783, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 38340, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3234556, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 2240710, "avg_legality_checks": 203700.9090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3718, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2240710, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3718, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5056401, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 459672.8181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9275524057, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1834.4122740660798, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46880, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4261.818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 148663596, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3171.151791808874, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3760, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30366788, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9340, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 69927848, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 33762, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 48219949, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 149011, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 179005, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16273.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1566892326, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8753.343906594788, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 258545, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23504.090909090908, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 775528250, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2999.5871124949235, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4750035094, "stage_ordering_ns": 1139307506, "stage_eval_ns": 2108894606, "stage_threat_ns": 5866969953, "stage_proof_ns": 98543429, "tactical_annotations": 703164, "root_tactical_annotations": 2379, "search_tactical_annotations": 700785, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 221099, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1194410000, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 605840, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4470520014, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 77178, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2457966600, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 110544, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 151699277, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 694, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3123394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 221088, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25453821, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 175400, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 685357344, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 329574, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1311394317, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 198190, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21763447, "child_limit_applications": 38340, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38340, "child_cap_hits": 38340, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38340, "child_moves_before_total": 3230838, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3230838, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 426614, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 426614, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.2680751173709, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.127125717266562, "tt_hits": 20442, "tt_cutoffs": 2641, "beta_cutoffs": 30830, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.909090909090909, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3322.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4048.3636363636365, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1672, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1140, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19277, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 141, 128, 144, 143, 158, 98, 83, 97, 99, 81, 129, 95, 94, 65, 49, 80, 64, 110, 50, 125 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 17901, "avg_search_time_ms": 1491.75, "search_nodes": 191612, "safety_nodes": 222, "corridor_nodes": 6772, "corridor_branch_probes": 7321, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3551, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 6746, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6746, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 81, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 55, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3551, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 81, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 80, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 681, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 65361600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1983840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 198606, "avg_nodes": 16550.5, "eval_calls": 123871, "avg_eval_calls": 10322.583333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 123871, "pattern_eval_ns": 2472454, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.959909906273463, "pattern_frame_queries": 123871, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2472454, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.959909906273463, "pattern_frame_updates": 383096, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4277093906, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11164.548588343392, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 63497, "avg_candidate_generations": 5291.416666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 4681920, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.7345071420697, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 63485, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4681186, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 1283381, "avg_legality_checks": 106948.41666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1760, "root_legality_checks": 734, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1282647, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1760, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5921693, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 493474.4166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10720312222, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1810.3458288026752, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43463, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3621.9166666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 159295296, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3665.0782504659137, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1972, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13974444, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20574, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 97196149, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19552, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42565477, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1365, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5559226, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 145717, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12143.083333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1084264748, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7440.893979425873, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 193306, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16108.833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 450224457, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2329.0764746050304, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2564313190, "stage_ordering_ns": 1617546812, "stage_eval_ns": 4279566360, "stage_threat_ns": 8749431732, "stage_proof_ns": 625521992, "tactical_annotations": 1072958, "root_tactical_annotations": 3546, "search_tactical_annotations": 1069412, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 396762, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2071000442, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1113533, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6253480699, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 130209, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3986871280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 198375, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 261665401, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 13654, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 71378621, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 396750, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43841100, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 223234, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 234101577, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 428830, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1273210028, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 420894, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 48065469, "child_limit_applications": 63485, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 63485, "child_cap_hits": 63485, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 63485, "child_moves_before_total": 4679426, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4679426, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 738025, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 738025, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.7091596440104, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.625187052059541, "tt_hits": 38781, "tt_cutoffs": 4193, "beta_cutoffs": 50907, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1681.0833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2193.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1364, "avg_search_time_ms": 124.0, "search_nodes": 55652, "safety_nodes": 888, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 56540, "avg_nodes": 5140.0, "eval_calls": 53624, "avg_eval_calls": 4874.909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53624, "pattern_eval_ns": 1021694, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.052924063852007, "pattern_frame_queries": 53624, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1021694, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.052924063852007, "pattern_frame_updates": 111240, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 791276079, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7113.23336030205, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2007, "avg_candidate_generations": 182.45454545454547, "candidate_moves_total": 131150, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.3462879920279, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 670, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 1996, "search_candidate_moves_total": 130480, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 4313, "avg_legality_checks": 392.09090909090907, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4313, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 267787, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24344.272727272728, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 483705895, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1806.308353280779, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1274, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 115.81818181818181, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6634507, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5207.619309262166, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1274, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6634507, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8465846, "stage_ordering_ns": 57610, "stage_eval_ns": 792297773, "stage_threat_ns": 544007955, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 111251, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 475387734, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 196901, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 55620, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 57862826, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 111240, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10560494, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1823, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6018.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6745.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1943, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1141, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16621, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 144, 80, 141, 143, 127, 96, 64, 99, 138, 66, 155, 169, 139, 140, 81, 108, 109, 94, 122, 52 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5183, "avg_search_time_ms": 431.9166666666667, "search_nodes": 128322, "safety_nodes": 638, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 128960, "avg_nodes": 10746.666666666666, "eval_calls": 124114, "avg_eval_calls": 10342.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 124114, "pattern_eval_ns": 2508615, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.212183959907826, "pattern_frame_queries": 124114, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2508615, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.212183959907826, "pattern_frame_updates": 256576, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3235629843, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12610.804763500873, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4186, "avg_candidate_generations": 348.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 320214, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.49641662685141, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 860, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 4174, "search_candidate_moves_total": 319354, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 116447, "avg_legality_checks": 9703.916666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 66, "root_legality_checks": 860, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 115587, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 66, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 972119, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 81009.91666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2298366950, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2364.285596722212, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17497, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1458.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 142328740, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8134.4653369149, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 630151, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17422, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 141698589, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.0833333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 236631, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9465.24, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 32, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.6666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 102400, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3200.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 284013277, "stage_ordering_ns": 147181, "stage_eval_ns": 3238138458, "stage_threat_ns": 1635894257, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 256588, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1434501849, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 341911, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128288, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 170475913, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 256576, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30574584, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 423, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3594, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5689.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6356.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1824, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11428, "avg_search_time_ms": 1038.909090909091, "search_nodes": 79200, "safety_nodes": 846, "corridor_nodes": 146, "corridor_branch_probes": 161, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 36, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 137, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 137, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 58, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 58, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 440, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6475760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 80192, "avg_nodes": 7290.181818181818, "eval_calls": 46987, "avg_eval_calls": 4271.545454545455, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46987, "pattern_eval_ns": 993877, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.152169749079533, "pattern_frame_queries": 46987, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 993877, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.152169749079533, "pattern_frame_updates": 158276, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1886969972, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11922.02211327049, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29886, "avg_candidate_generations": 2716.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 2323167, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.73429030315198, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 29875, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2322381, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1525503, "avg_legality_checks": 138682.0909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6363, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1525503, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3557795, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 323435.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7491713879, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2105.7182549865856, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36970, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3360.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 259904178, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7030.1373546118475, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6561, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 68388544, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13554, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 135152940, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16818, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 55912232, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 450462, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 113850, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10350.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1097675176, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9641.415687307861, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 159131, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14466.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 526631810, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3309.423116803137, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3694269984, "stage_ordering_ns": 954064238, "stage_eval_ns": 1887963849, "stage_threat_ns": 4730865572, "stage_proof_ns": 100100809, "tactical_annotations": 440812, "root_tactical_annotations": 1732, "search_tactical_annotations": 439080, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 158677, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 959876747, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 376179, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3614350149, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60144, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2178929538, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79333, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 119656896, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 390, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2025319, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 158666, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20007043, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 76736, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 335721687, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 227903, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1092571114, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 136173, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14949418, "child_limit_applications": 29875, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29875, "child_cap_hits": 29875, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29875, "child_moves_before_total": 2316018, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2316018, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 281575, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 281575, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.52361506276151, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.42510460251046, "tt_hits": 15413, "tt_cutoffs": 2277, "beta_cutoffs": 24019, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3066.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3794.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1397, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1142, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13718, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 113, 114, 128, 130, 82, 110, 96, 144, 81, 126, 80, 64, 79, 78, 83 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 9479, "avg_search_time_ms": 1184.875, "search_nodes": 80364, "safety_nodes": 448, "corridor_nodes": 887, "corridor_branch_probes": 1034, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 414, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 875, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 875, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 39, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 27, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 414, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 39, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 288, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23937680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2030880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 81699, "avg_nodes": 10212.375, "eval_calls": 48600, "avg_eval_calls": 6075.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48600, "pattern_eval_ns": 1022503, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.039156378600822, "pattern_frame_queries": 48600, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1022503, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.039156378600822, "pattern_frame_updates": 160648, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2054291218, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12787.530613515262, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29298, "avg_candidate_generations": 3662.25, "candidate_moves_total": 2230241, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.12263635743054, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 489, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 29290, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2229752, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 749458, "avg_legality_checks": 93682.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3054, "root_legality_checks": 489, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 748969, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3051, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2613079, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 326634.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5775566431, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2210.253280134278, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26632, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3329.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 203031312, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7623.584860318414, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3138, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33535141, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11299, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 111983117, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11622, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 51930049, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 573, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5583005, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60313, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7539.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 602463952, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9988.956808648218, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86108, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10763.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 287179418, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3335.1072838760624, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1863739974, "stage_ordering_ns": 950130390, "stage_eval_ns": 2055313721, "stage_threat_ns": 4412358251, "stage_proof_ns": 161783868, "tactical_annotations": 372433, "root_tactical_annotations": 1524, "search_tactical_annotations": 370909, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 162484, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 975045791, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 350371, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3271602298, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59117, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2304455945, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 81238, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121062953, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1828, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9628503, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 162476, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20350344, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 63106, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 97886142, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 179187, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 733814822, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 130140, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14668362, "child_limit_applications": 29290, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29290, "child_cap_hits": 29290, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29290, "child_moves_before_total": 2226701, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2226701, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 284418, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 284418, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.02256742915671, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.710413110276544, "tt_hits": 16323, "tt_cutoffs": 2434, "beta_cutoffs": 23380, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1455.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2274.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 189, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 4231, "avg_search_time_ms": 604.4285714285714, "search_nodes": 126952, "safety_nodes": 476, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 127428, "avg_nodes": 18204.0, "eval_calls": 124086, "avg_eval_calls": 17726.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 124086, "pattern_eval_ns": 2526640, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.362006995148526, "pattern_frame_queries": 124086, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2526640, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.362006995148526, "pattern_frame_updates": 253864, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2545184437, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10025.77930309142, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2853, "avg_candidate_generations": 407.57142857142856, "candidate_moves_total": 200340, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.22082018927445, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 418, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 2846, "search_candidate_moves_total": 199922, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 4882, "avg_legality_checks": 697.4285714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4882, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 616743, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 88106.14285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1454965736, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2359.1118764217836, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12780, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1825.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 126585318, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9904.954460093897, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 80961, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12757, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 126330897, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 173460, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13839566, "stage_ordering_ns": 90300, "stage_eval_ns": 2547711077, "stage_threat_ns": 1657635522, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 253871, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1457190440, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 141731, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 126932, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 168902012, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 253864, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31401339, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 119, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2511, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3727.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4870.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1143, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14638, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 82, 98, 143, 126, 140, 96, 95, 111, 141, 81, 66, 70, 84, 100, 99, 139, 125, 110, 173, 158, 157, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6614, "avg_search_time_ms": 551.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 170780, "safety_nodes": 814, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 171594, "avg_nodes": 14299.5, "eval_calls": 165242, "avg_eval_calls": 13770.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 165242, "pattern_eval_ns": 3361976, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.345771656116483, "pattern_frame_queries": 165242, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3361976, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.345771656116483, "pattern_frame_updates": 341490, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4006334608, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11731.923652229934, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5515, "avg_candidate_generations": 459.5833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 356631, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.66563916591114, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 724, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 5503, "search_candidate_moves_total": 355907, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 159578, "avg_legality_checks": 13298.166666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 724, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 158854, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1221662, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 101805.16666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2883591555, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2360.3840956009108, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9579, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 798.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 71978366, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7514.183735254202, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 196341, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9555, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71782025, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 316111, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8780.861111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.8333333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 135060, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2936.086956521739, "stage_move_gen_ns": 392741507, "stage_ordering_ns": 173850, "stage_eval_ns": 4009696584, "stage_threat_ns": 2186998869, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 341502, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1917260481, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 429602, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11250, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 170745, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 227916985, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 341490, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41391801, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 261, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4972, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5187.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5854.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1550, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8012, "avg_search_time_ms": 667.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 68533, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 478, "corridor_branch_probes": 629, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 162, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 467, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 467, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 18, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 162, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 18, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 17, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 37, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 7987280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 69824, "avg_nodes": 5818.666666666667, "eval_calls": 39948, "avg_eval_calls": 3329.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39948, "pattern_eval_ns": 832122, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.830129167918294, "pattern_frame_queries": 39948, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 832122, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.830129167918294, "pattern_frame_updates": 136926, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1387289232, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10131.671355330616, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25989, "avg_candidate_generations": 2165.75, "candidate_moves_total": 1805903, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.48720612566855, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 749, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 25977, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1805154, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 983974, "avg_legality_checks": 81997.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 983974, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2547966, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 212330.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5109246920, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2005.2257055235432, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13925, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1160.4166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19842764, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1424.9740754039497, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 584183, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2239, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10663054, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11576, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8591087, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76265, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6355.416666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 614769046, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8060.959103127254, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 101504, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8458.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 252601190, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2488.5836026166457, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2161452944, "stage_ordering_ns": 717551561, "stage_eval_ns": 1388121354, "stage_threat_ns": 3674108543, "stage_proof_ns": 25843964, "tactical_annotations": 375444, "root_tactical_annotations": 901, "search_tactical_annotations": 374543, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 137908, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 809477492, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 359189, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2732584448, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52337, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1813771527, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68948, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99155669, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 970, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5769808, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 137896, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17169872, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 64711, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 201754375, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 210613, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 694077696, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 100120, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9951254, "child_limit_applications": 25977, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25977, "child_cap_hits": 25977, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25977, "child_moves_before_total": 1805058, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1805058, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 241446, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 241446, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.48677676406051, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.294606767525119, "tt_hits": 12365, "tt_cutoffs": 2538, "beta_cutoffs": 20897, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 5.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 5.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4497.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5163.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1144, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32117, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 98, 156, 82, 67, 114, 66, 96, 99, 68, 110, 126, 140, 84, 70, 83, 170, 184, 125, 155, 95, 80, 81, 53, 38, 52, 109, 123, 36, 54, 40, 51, 55, 50 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 29250, "avg_search_time_ms": 1625.0, "search_nodes": 226128, "safety_nodes": 811, "corridor_nodes": 27032, "corridor_branch_probes": 29293, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 13824, "corridor_neutral_exits": 27, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 26981, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 26981, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 101, "corridor_proof_active": 51, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 27, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 13824, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 101, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 763, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 67487520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 253971, "avg_nodes": 14109.5, "eval_calls": 144445, "avg_eval_calls": 8024.722222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 144445, "pattern_eval_ns": 2991752, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.71204956904012, "pattern_frame_queries": 144445, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2991752, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.71204956904012, "pattern_frame_updates": 452048, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5563980143, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12308.383496885286, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 75686, "avg_candidate_generations": 4204.777777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 6613924, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.38635943239173, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1337, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 75668, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6612587, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1661005, "avg_legality_checks": 92278.05555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1801, "root_legality_checks": 1337, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1659668, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1801, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9051371, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 502853.94444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17968374191, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1985.1549771852242, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56901, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3161.1666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 315696683, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5548.174601500852, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3133, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25999054, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24279, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 172915854, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 27584, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 99240469, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1905, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 17541306, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 238483, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13249.055555555555, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1936055983, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8118.213805596206, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 314822, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17490.11111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 829695510, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2635.443234589705, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3749354610, "stage_ordering_ns": 2456941173, "stage_eval_ns": 5566971895, "stage_threat_ns": 15015846109, "stage_proof_ns": 2378324854, "tactical_annotations": 1657183, "root_tactical_annotations": 4207, "search_tactical_annotations": 1652976, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 506230, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3212965977, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2533977, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10933199659, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 164549, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5654071114, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 253106, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 385953594, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 54164, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 344790520, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 506212, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61298196, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 484574, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 453447079, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 597464, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1781911907, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 575145, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 77638163, "child_limit_applications": 75668, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 75668, "child_cap_hits": 75668, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 75668, "child_moves_before_total": 6610786, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6610786, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 923705, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 923705, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.36567637574669, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.207339958767246, "tt_hits": 47203, "tt_cutoffs": 5911, "beta_cutoffs": 62481, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2099.277777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2479.0555555555557, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 2849, "avg_search_time_ms": 167.58823529411765, "search_nodes": 85002, "safety_nodes": 1927, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 86929, "avg_nodes": 5113.470588235294, "eval_calls": 82184, "avg_eval_calls": 4834.35294117647, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82184, "pattern_eval_ns": 1673162, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.358731626593983, "pattern_frame_queries": 82184, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1673162, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.358731626593983, "pattern_frame_updates": 169904, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1725656780, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10156.657759676053, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2785, "avg_candidate_generations": 163.8235294117647, "candidate_moves_total": 222994, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.06965888689408, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1261, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 2768, "search_candidate_moves_total": 221733, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 5365, "avg_legality_checks": 315.5882352941176, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5365, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 522590, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 30740.58823529412, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1140727454, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2182.8344476549496, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4576, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 269.1764705882353, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31565431, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6898.039991258741, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 50150, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4557, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31385901, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 129380, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13883093, "stage_ordering_ns": 84000, "stage_eval_ns": 1727329942, "stage_threat_ns": 1081181567, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169921, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 948830361, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 441683, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17201, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84952, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 111692985, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169904, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20216538, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2591, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6734.764705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7205.35294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1988, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1145, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22900, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 80, 141, 155, 128, 125, 129, 130, 99, 85, 140, 139, 97, 108, 109, 153, 167, 145, 100, 98, 114, 65, 95, 144, 86, 142, 72 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 4450, "avg_search_time_ms": 317.85714285714283, "search_nodes": 105245, "safety_nodes": 1510, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 106755, "avg_nodes": 7625.357142857143, "eval_calls": 101469, "avg_eval_calls": 7247.785714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 101469, "pattern_eval_ns": 2073446, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.434280420621075, "pattern_frame_queries": 101469, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2073446, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.434280420621075, "pattern_frame_updates": 210408, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2826771957, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13434.717106764001, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3749, "avg_candidate_generations": 267.7857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 291372, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.71992531341691, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1033, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 3735, "search_candidate_moves_total": 290339, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 97921, "avg_legality_checks": 6994.357142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 109, "root_legality_checks": 1033, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 96888, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 104, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 886032, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 63288.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2081297345, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2349.0092287863195, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13435, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 959.6428571428571, "renju_forbidden_ns": 97875351, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7285.102419054708, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 123, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 991675, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13255, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 96535566, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 348110, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 92, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.571428571428571, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 888015, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9652.33695652174, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.428571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 433152, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3670.7796610169494, "stage_move_gen_ns": 241924087, "stage_ordering_ns": 122070, "stage_eval_ns": 2828845403, "stage_threat_ns": 1355787528, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 210422, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1186025724, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 39, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1243886, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 105204, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 143072243, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 210408, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25445675, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 190, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3390, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6264.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6836.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1877, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 18436, "avg_search_time_ms": 1316.857142857143, "search_nodes": 133908, "safety_nodes": 981, "corridor_nodes": 2104, "corridor_branch_probes": 2428, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 825, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 61, "corridor_plies_followed": 2079, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1809, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 270, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 825, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 61, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 55, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 347, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 15891240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1988240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 136993, "avg_nodes": 9785.214285714286, "eval_calls": 84873, "avg_eval_calls": 6062.357142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84873, "pattern_eval_ns": 1800011, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.20828767688193, "pattern_frame_queries": 84873, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1800011, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.20828767688193, "pattern_frame_updates": 267644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3158311053, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11800.417917083887, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44489, "avg_candidate_generations": 3177.785714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 3853783, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.6232776641417, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1078, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 44475, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3852705, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 2336499, "avg_legality_checks": 166892.7857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12894, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2336499, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12894, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5732718, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 409479.85714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11762618977, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2051.8398039115127, "renju_forbidden_checks": 103882, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7420.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 347268767, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3342.9156831789915, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17433, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 118313315, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22953, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 112034237, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 63095, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 115697858, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 401, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1223357, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 208235, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14873.92857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2023579467, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9717.768228203711, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 279854, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19989.571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 988824340, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3533.3578937588886, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5574237756, "stage_ordering_ns": 1498859375, "stage_eval_ns": 3160111064, "stage_threat_ns": 8013877176, "stage_proof_ns": 104578786, "tactical_annotations": 994191, "root_tactical_annotations": 2562, "search_tactical_annotations": 991629, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 271928, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1669713559, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 937012, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6045025378, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90236, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3235354107, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 135957, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 206925738, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4270, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 23503010, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 271914, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34926024, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 257990, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1038994179, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 466426, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1652773738, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 269775, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33783467, "child_limit_applications": 44475, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44475, "child_cap_hits": 44475, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44475, "child_moves_before_total": 3839811, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3839811, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 537193, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 537193, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.33639123102867, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.078538504777965, "tt_hits": 23811, "tt_cutoffs": 4475, "beta_cutoffs": 36193, "depth_sum": 84, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 84, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3694.4285714285716, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4265.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 234, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1146, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15598, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 123, 81, 97, 83, 139, 153, 94, 124, 80, 65, 96, 98, 128, 64, 144 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 14808, "avg_search_time_ms": 1139.076923076923, "search_nodes": 183991, "safety_nodes": 715, "corridor_nodes": 15130, "corridor_branch_probes": 15821, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 7816, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 15083, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 15083, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 47, "corridor_proof_quiet": 45, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 7816, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 90, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 709, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 67466400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 5, "total_nodes": 199836, "avg_nodes": 15372.0, "eval_calls": 120794, "avg_eval_calls": 9291.846153846154, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 120794, "pattern_eval_ns": 2259617, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.706367865953606, "pattern_frame_queries": 120794, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2259617, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.706367865953606, "pattern_frame_updates": 367840, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3235005911, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8794.600671487604, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 58609, "avg_candidate_generations": 4508.384615384615, "candidate_moves_total": 4934131, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.1872579296695, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 813, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 58596, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4933318, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1387958, "avg_legality_checks": 106766.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1117, "root_legality_checks": 813, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1387145, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1117, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6728637, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 517587.46153846156, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8911826711, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1324.4624001859515, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35525, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2732.6923076923076, "renju_forbidden_ns": 109520318, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3082.908318085855, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1284, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6834570, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15654, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72104943, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17648, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27383526, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 939, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3197279, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 176050, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13542.307692307691, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 913087462, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5186.523499005964, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 226475, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17421.153846153848, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 394437359, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1741.6375273208964, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2168011350, "stage_ordering_ns": 1254390832, "stage_eval_ns": 3237265528, "stage_threat_ns": 7212058379, "stage_proof_ns": 866677509, "tactical_annotations": 1138586, "root_tactical_annotations": 2952, "search_tactical_annotations": 1135634, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 398203, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1660641727, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1618184, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5142284677, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 124401, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2945369994, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 199095, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 219383233, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 30350, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 113994228, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 398190, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34752709, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 315511, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 201369142, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 444498, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 964290261, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 378577, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 41001805, "child_limit_applications": 58596, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 58596, "child_cap_hits": 58596, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 58596, "child_moves_before_total": 4932201, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4932201, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 648978, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 648978, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.17299815687078, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.075465902109359, "tt_hits": 35309, "tt_cutoffs": 4530, "beta_cutoffs": 46799, "depth_sum": 71, "avg_depth": 5.461538461538462, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 71, "avg_effective_depth": 5.461538461538462, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4076.3846153846152, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4691.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1173, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 777, "avg_search_time_ms": 64.75, "search_nodes": 31268, "safety_nodes": 1061, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 32329, "avg_nodes": 2694.0833333333335, "eval_calls": 29706, "avg_eval_calls": 2475.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 29706, "pattern_eval_ns": 566281, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.06284925604255, "pattern_frame_queries": 29706, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 566281, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.06284925604255, "pattern_frame_updates": 62466, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 441398181, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7066.2149169148015, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1539, "avg_candidate_generations": 128.25, "candidate_moves_total": 106877, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.44574398960364, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 1527, "search_candidate_moves_total": 106129, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 3496, "avg_legality_checks": 291.3333333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3496, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 172852, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14404.333333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 284312353, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1644.8311445629788, "renju_forbidden_checks": 774, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 64.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3997114, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5164.229974160206, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 774, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 3997114, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7374436, "stage_ordering_ns": 47190, "stage_eval_ns": 441964462, "stage_threat_ns": 313011338, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 62478, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 273274265, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 204681, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 31233, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 33628098, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 62466, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5904294, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 67, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1391, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6241.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6908.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1147, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8775, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 67, 81, 126, 113, 129, 83, 84, 98, 128, 65, 49, 79, 80, 68, 53, 130, 114, 127, 142, 99, 100, 156, 86 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 3568, "avg_search_time_ms": 297.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 162713, "safety_nodes": 892, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 163605, "avg_nodes": 13633.75, "eval_calls": 156970, "avg_eval_calls": 13080.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 156970, "pattern_eval_ns": 2858203, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.208593998853285, "pattern_frame_queries": 156970, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2858203, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.208593998853285, "pattern_frame_updates": 325356, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2111333534, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6489.302591622715, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5720, "avg_candidate_generations": 476.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 372730, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.16258741258741, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 5708, "search_candidate_moves_total": 372008, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 151449, "avg_legality_checks": 12620.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 150727, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1107056, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 92254.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1452829454, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1312.33601010247, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8812, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 734.3333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33538688, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3806.0245120290515, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 96670, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8790, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33442018, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.083333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 272351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5558.183673469388, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 134921, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2044.2575757575758, "stage_move_gen_ns": 210943552, "stage_ordering_ns": 162701, "stage_eval_ns": 2114191737, "stage_threat_ns": 1204494839, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 325368, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1042098547, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 372241, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 162678, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 137410740, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 325356, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24613311, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 265, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5174, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5832.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6499.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1912, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5198, "avg_search_time_ms": 433.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 75326, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 438, "corridor_branch_probes": 582, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 134, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_plies_followed": 427, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 427, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 34, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 23, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 134, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 34, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 33, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 173, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 35750320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 76803, "avg_nodes": 6400.25, "eval_calls": 42395, "avg_eval_calls": 3532.9166666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 42395, "pattern_eval_ns": 783097, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.471447104611393, "pattern_frame_queries": 42395, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 783097, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.471447104611393, "pattern_frame_updates": 150520, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 941426389, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6254.493681902737, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29311, "avg_candidate_generations": 2442.5833333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 1958557, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.81986285012452, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 744, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 29299, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1957813, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 955102, "avg_legality_checks": 79591.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 955102, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2595467, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 216288.91666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3196087977, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1231.4115251706148, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11714, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 976.1666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13936546, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1189.7341642479084, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 56, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 243162, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2692, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8580175, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8966, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5113209, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67717, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5643.083333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 350762601, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5179.830781044641, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89114, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7426.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 145986273, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1638.196837758377, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1321160450, "stage_ordering_ns": 459724126, "stage_eval_ns": 942209486, "stage_threat_ns": 2399934692, "stage_proof_ns": 28950020, "tactical_annotations": 372094, "root_tactical_annotations": 456, "search_tactical_annotations": 371638, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 151454, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 548709896, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 351540, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1751775379, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59025, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1205412576, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75721, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 72733274, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 922, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3270466, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 151442, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12198428, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 45839, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 115761174, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 216503, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 417313212, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 109752, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11247249, "child_limit_applications": 29299, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29299, "child_cap_hits": 29299, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29299, "child_moves_before_total": 1957763, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1957763, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 265033, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 265033, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 66.82013037987645, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.045803611044745, "tt_hits": 15363, "tt_cutoffs": 3566, "beta_cutoffs": 23511, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5129.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5796.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 787, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1148, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13155, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 143, 67, 52, 95, 53, 83, 80, 51, 99, 113, 129, 65, 49, 68, 66, 84, 85, 98, 128, 126, 70, 140 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 11821, "avg_search_time_ms": 909.3076923076923, "search_nodes": 153216, "safety_nodes": 715, "corridor_nodes": 17192, "corridor_branch_probes": 17814, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 9096, "corridor_neutral_exits": 26, "corridor_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_plies_followed": 17149, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 17149, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 94, "corridor_proof_active": 43, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 9096, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 94, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 92, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 722, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 65451200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 7, "total_nodes": 171123, "avg_nodes": 13163.307692307691, "eval_calls": 94812, "avg_eval_calls": 7293.2307692307695, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 94812, "pattern_eval_ns": 1735674, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.30648019238071, "pattern_frame_queries": 94812, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1735674, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.30648019238071, "pattern_frame_updates": 306290, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2263596071, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7390.368836723367, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 54277, "avg_candidate_generations": 4175.153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 4318661, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.56705418501392, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 813, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 54264, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4317848, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1091775, "avg_legality_checks": 83982.69230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 870, "root_legality_checks": 813, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1090962, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 870, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5949280, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 457636.92307692306, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7109824598, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1195.0731177554258, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24833, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1910.2307692307693, "renju_forbidden_ns": 77084052, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3104.097450972496, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 990, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4736673, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10607, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 46594262, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11540, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20997745, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1696, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4755372, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 141751, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10903.923076923076, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 690602067, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4871.937884036091, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 183515, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14116.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 305279905, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1663.5147263166498, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1485333696, "stage_ordering_ns": 957749323, "stage_eval_ns": 2265331745, "stage_threat_ns": 6110993571, "stage_proof_ns": 936161428, "tactical_annotations": 1019279, "root_tactical_annotations": 2952, "search_tactical_annotations": 1016327, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 340789, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1336781422, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1554954, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4393292005, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 116531, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2421047992, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 170388, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 174983108, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 34486, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 139755767, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 340776, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27302007, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 264721, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 150866528, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 363241, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 655718733, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 391317, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 38879262, "child_limit_applications": 54264, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 54264, "child_cap_hits": 54264, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 54264, "child_moves_before_total": 4316978, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4316978, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 600408, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 600408, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.55510098776352, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.064573197700133, "tt_hits": 34451, "tt_cutoffs": 4069, "beta_cutoffs": 44351, "depth_sum": 71, "avg_depth": 5.461538461538462, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 71, "avg_effective_depth": 5.461538461538462, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5554.538461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6169.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1820, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 1323, "avg_search_time_ms": 110.25, "search_nodes": 66737, "safety_nodes": 1061, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67798, "avg_nodes": 5649.833333333333, "eval_calls": 64911, "avg_eval_calls": 5409.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64911, "pattern_eval_ns": 1187156, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.288980296097733, "pattern_frame_queries": 64911, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1187156, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.288980296097733, "pattern_frame_updates": 133404, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 785043955, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5884.710765794129, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1803, "avg_candidate_generations": 150.25, "candidate_moves_total": 129824, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.00443704936218, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 1791, "search_candidate_moves_total": 129076, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 3462, "avg_legality_checks": 288.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3462, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 388999, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32416.583333333332, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 483880565, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1243.912105172507, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2238, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 186.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9335249, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4171.246201966042, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2238, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9335249, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5521163, "stage_ordering_ns": 51810, "stage_eval_ns": 786231111, "stage_threat_ns": 510609615, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 133416, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 443234362, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 152301, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6970, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66702, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 56896154, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 133404, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10326798, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 67, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1657, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6268.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6935.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1988, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1149, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9282, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 110, 96, 99, 128, 144, 126, 141, 127, 129, 80, 64, 66, 81, 125, 124, 159, 143, 114, 115, 142, 157, 101, 171 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 3101, "avg_search_time_ms": 258.4166666666667, "search_nodes": 124935, "safety_nodes": 892, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 125827, "avg_nodes": 10485.583333333334, "eval_calls": 120088, "avg_eval_calls": 10007.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 120088, "pattern_eval_ns": 2236033, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.619953700619547, "pattern_frame_queries": 120088, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2236033, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.619953700619547, "pattern_frame_updates": 249800, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1812797022, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7256.993682946357, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4824, "avg_candidate_generations": 402.0, "candidate_moves_total": 318208, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.96351575456053, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 4812, "search_candidate_moves_total": 317486, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 115942, "avg_legality_checks": 9661.833333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 115220, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 814948, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 67912.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1253470751, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1538.0990578539981, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8482, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 706.8333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30697966, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3619.1895779297333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 69151, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8465, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30628815, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.083333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 380132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7757.7959183673465, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 183461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2779.712121212121, "stage_move_gen_ns": 187523289, "stage_ordering_ns": 143191, "stage_eval_ns": 1815033055, "stage_threat_ns": 1063243078, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 249812, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 923501205, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 526312, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9150, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124900, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118080687, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 249800, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21134874, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 265, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4276, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6033.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6700.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1883, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6170, "avg_search_time_ms": 514.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 76959, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 569, "corridor_branch_probes": 732, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 181, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 25, "corridor_plies_followed": 558, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 558, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 34, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 23, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 181, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 34, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 33, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 173, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 27840000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 78567, "avg_nodes": 6547.25, "eval_calls": 43466, "avg_eval_calls": 3622.1666666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 43466, "pattern_eval_ns": 820491, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.876616205770027, "pattern_frame_queries": 43466, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 820491, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.876616205770027, "pattern_frame_updates": 153786, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1094846169, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7119.283738441731, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30064, "avg_candidate_generations": 2505.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2033627, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.64326104310804, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 744, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 30052, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2032883, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 997333, "avg_legality_checks": 83111.08333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 76, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 997333, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 76, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2707614, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 225634.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3834759383, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1416.2873227129126, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12022, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1001.8333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16443257, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1367.76384960905, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 80, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 601272, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2754, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9778723, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9188, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6063262, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68653, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5721.083333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 425720281, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6201.044105865731, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91029, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7585.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 177303261, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1947.7667666348086, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1602114380, "stage_ordering_ns": 556136608, "stage_eval_ns": 1095666660, "stage_threat_ns": 2829276714, "stage_proof_ns": 31696297, "tactical_annotations": 383131, "root_tactical_annotations": 456, "search_tactical_annotations": 382675, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 154982, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 630716427, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 369605, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2085502518, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60604, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1423147587, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77485, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81413403, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1184, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5973559, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 154970, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13855090, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 45425, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 127489350, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 227116, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 513873098, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110590, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11815717, "child_limit_applications": 30052, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30052, "child_cap_hits": 30052, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30052, "child_moves_before_total": 2032807, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2032807, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 270678, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 270678, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.64298549181419, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.006987887661387, "tt_hits": 15087, "tt_cutoffs": 3375, "beta_cutoffs": 24165, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4869.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5536.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 183, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1150, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 31969, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 110, 109, 82, 124, 126, 81, 94, 142, 128, 144, 80, 64, 95, 146, 162, 143, 145, 141, 140, 125, 93, 92, 108, 157, 173, 122, 78, 62, 123, 63, 138 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 29252, "avg_search_time_ms": 1625.111111111111, "search_nodes": 217639, "safety_nodes": 811, "corridor_nodes": 33593, "corridor_branch_probes": 35913, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 18423, "corridor_neutral_exits": 26, "corridor_terminal_exits": 36, "corridor_plies_followed": 33541, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 33541, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 101, "corridor_proof_active": 52, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 18423, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 101, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 763, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 67569600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 252043, "avg_nodes": 14002.388888888889, "eval_calls": 137049, "avg_eval_calls": 7613.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 137049, "pattern_eval_ns": 2838057, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.708337893746034, "pattern_frame_queries": 137049, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2838057, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.708337893746034, "pattern_frame_updates": 435070, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5185927238, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11919.753690210771, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 74538, "avg_candidate_generations": 4141.0, "candidate_moves_total": 6517750, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.44197590490757, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1337, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 74520, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6516413, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1669771, "avg_legality_checks": 92765.05555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1595, "root_legality_checks": 1337, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1668434, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1595, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9302583, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 516810.1666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17999486492, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1934.8912546117567, "renju_forbidden_checks": 52853, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2936.277777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 291100614, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5507.740601290371, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2961, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26614025, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20811, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 146727766, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26161, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 97992646, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2920, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 19766177, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 248136, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13785.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1971613657, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7945.697750427185, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 326454, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18136.333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 843504809, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2583.8397109546827, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3803142314, "stage_ordering_ns": 2433972668, "stage_eval_ns": 5188765295, "stage_threat_ns": 15267269411, "stage_proof_ns": 2477689767, "tactical_annotations": 1638885, "root_tactical_annotations": 4207, "search_tactical_annotations": 1634678, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 502372, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3230128851, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2709492, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11120243209, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 164180, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5640562916, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 251177, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 384746798, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 67284, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 396675782, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 502354, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60146665, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 478751, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 434193652, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 592783, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1768553105, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 567351, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 75328106, "child_limit_applications": 74520, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 74520, "child_cap_hits": 74520, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 74520, "child_moves_before_total": 6514818, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6514818, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 908597, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 908597, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.42375201288245, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.192659688674182, "tt_hits": 46603, "tt_cutoffs": 5966, "beta_cutoffs": 61621, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2085.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2465.9444444444443, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 2699, "avg_search_time_ms": 158.76470588235293, "search_nodes": 85132, "safety_nodes": 1927, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87059, "avg_nodes": 5121.117647058823, "eval_calls": 82452, "avg_eval_calls": 4850.117647058823, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82452, "pattern_eval_ns": 1673818, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.3005142385873, "pattern_frame_queries": 82452, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1673818, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.3005142385873, "pattern_frame_updates": 170164, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1605857051, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9437.113907759573, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2647, "avg_candidate_generations": 155.7058823529412, "candidate_moves_total": 214210, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.92557612391387, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1261, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 2630, "search_candidate_moves_total": 212949, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 5666, "avg_legality_checks": 333.29411764705884, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5666, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 495785, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29163.823529411766, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1036374787, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2090.3714049436753, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4651, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 273.5882352941176, "renju_forbidden_ns": 34575601, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7434.014405504193, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 80710, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4628, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34364980, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 129911, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14190449, "stage_ordering_ns": 82960, "stage_eval_ns": 1607530869, "stage_threat_ns": 1049398487, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 170181, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 920265542, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 434770, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85082, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 109007592, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 170164, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19690583, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2463, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6761.411764705882, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7232.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1151, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13532, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 82, 96, 141, 128, 144, 98, 99, 113, 143, 80, 64, 94, 95, 83, 68, 145, 129, 142, 157, 114, 115, 171, 101 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6185, "avg_search_time_ms": 515.4166666666666, "search_nodes": 164463, "safety_nodes": 892, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 165355, "avg_nodes": 13779.583333333334, "eval_calls": 158720, "avg_eval_calls": 13226.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 158720, "pattern_eval_ns": 3209909, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.223721018145163, "pattern_frame_queries": 158720, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3209909, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.223721018145163, "pattern_frame_updates": 328856, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3683058576, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11199.608874400954, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5720, "avg_candidate_generations": 476.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 374674, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.50244755244755, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 5708, "search_candidate_moves_total": 373952, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 153206, "avg_legality_checks": 12767.166666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 152484, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1124154, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 93679.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2627358297, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2337.1871620792167, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8817, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 734.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60793633, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6895.047408415561, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 190740, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8795, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60602893, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.083333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 455141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9288.591836734693, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 211011, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3197.1363636363635, "stage_move_gen_ns": 371382097, "stage_ordering_ns": 177702, "stage_eval_ns": 3686268485, "stage_threat_ns": 2104939040, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 328868, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1844630443, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 35, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 625613, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 164428, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 220118050, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 328856, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39564934, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 265, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5175, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5295.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5962.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1491, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7337, "avg_search_time_ms": 611.4166666666666, "search_nodes": 62319, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 438, "corridor_branch_probes": 582, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 134, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_plies_followed": 427, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 427, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 18, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 134, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 18, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 17, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 37, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 7988560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 63796, "avg_nodes": 5316.333333333333, "eval_calls": 36054, "avg_eval_calls": 3004.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36054, "pattern_eval_ns": 749834, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.797525933322238, "pattern_frame_queries": 36054, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 749834, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.797525933322238, "pattern_frame_updates": 124506, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1288812790, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10351.411096653976, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23861, "avg_candidate_generations": 1988.4166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1617711, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.79728427140522, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 744, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 23849, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1616967, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 805047, "avg_legality_checks": 67087.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 805047, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2215429, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 184619.08333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4649221157, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2098.564728095552, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10923, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 910.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18784942, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1719.7603222557905, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 56, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 468521, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2210, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11160156, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8657, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7156265, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64776, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5398.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 546824517, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8441.776537606522, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 85179, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7098.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 222574443, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2613.020145810587, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1890835858, "stage_ordering_ns": 666179788, "stage_eval_ns": 1289562624, "stage_threat_ns": 3421376407, "stage_proof_ns": 26197199, "tactical_annotations": 316008, "root_tactical_annotations": 456, "search_tactical_annotations": 315552, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125408, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 758360120, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 312207, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2540834825, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48061, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1708267993, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 62698, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91959921, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 890, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5177431, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 125396, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15807161, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 42128, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 166298948, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 191877, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 644504740, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 82003, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9236949, "child_limit_applications": 23849, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23849, "child_cap_hits": 23849, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23849, "child_moves_before_total": 1616917, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1616917, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 220113, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 220113, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.7981047423372, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.22944358254015, "tt_hits": 11087, "tt_cutoffs": 2351, "beta_cutoffs": 19067, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4494.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5161.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1152, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32095, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 158, 82, 67, 110, 68, 98, 95, 66, 114, 128, 144, 80, 64, 81, 174, 190, 129, 159, 99, 84, 83, 51, 36, 52, 115, 131, 38, 50, 34, 53, 49, 54 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 29245, "avg_search_time_ms": 1624.7222222222222, "search_nodes": 213728, "safety_nodes": 811, "corridor_nodes": 31892, "corridor_branch_probes": 34238, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 17322, "corridor_neutral_exits": 26, "corridor_terminal_exits": 33, "corridor_plies_followed": 31841, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 31841, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 101, "corridor_proof_active": 51, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 17322, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 33, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 101, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 763, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 67519520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 246431, "avg_nodes": 13690.611111111111, "eval_calls": 134281, "avg_eval_calls": 7460.055555555556, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 134281, "pattern_eval_ns": 2792111, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.793045926080385, "pattern_frame_queries": 134281, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2792111, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.793045926080385, "pattern_frame_updates": 427248, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5185359261, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12136.649582912032, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 73678, "avg_candidate_generations": 4093.222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 6403469, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.91154754472163, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1337, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 73660, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6402132, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1593047, "avg_legality_checks": 88502.61111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1685, "root_legality_checks": 1337, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1591710, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1685, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9045146, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 502508.1111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18061905948, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1996.861736449583, "renju_forbidden_checks": 52843, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2935.722222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 292271106, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5530.933255114206, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2978, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25794666, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21444, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 149096963, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25623, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 97311266, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2798, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 20068211, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 238759, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13264.388888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1949345847, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8164.491587751666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 314053, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17447.38888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 834651700, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2657.6778441855354, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3666960599, "stage_ordering_ns": 2403673353, "stage_eval_ns": 5188151372, "stage_threat_ns": 15348136332, "stage_proof_ns": 2556979334, "tactical_annotations": 1608781, "root_tactical_annotations": 4207, "search_tactical_annotations": 1604574, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 491150, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3231036714, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2629812, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11190022625, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 161862, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5673256919, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 245566, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 380335317, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 63884, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 411216705, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 491132, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59744914, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 473045, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 426612581, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 579849, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1727123926, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 555887, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 75780057, "child_limit_applications": 73660, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 73660, "child_cap_hits": 73660, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 73660, "child_moves_before_total": 6400447, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6400447, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 898254, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 898254, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.891759435243, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.194596796090144, "tt_hits": 45941, "tt_cutoffs": 5684, "beta_cutoffs": 61048, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2012.388888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2392.6111111111113, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 2833, "avg_search_time_ms": 166.64705882352942, "search_nodes": 84800, "safety_nodes": 1927, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 86727, "avg_nodes": 5101.588235294118, "eval_calls": 82097, "avg_eval_calls": 4829.235294117647, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82097, "pattern_eval_ns": 1677361, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.431453037260802, "pattern_frame_queries": 82097, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1677361, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.431453037260802, "pattern_frame_updates": 169500, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1710978266, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10094.267056047198, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2670, "avg_candidate_generations": 157.05882352941177, "candidate_moves_total": 215657, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.77041198501873, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1261, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 2653, "search_candidate_moves_total": 214396, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 5112, "avg_legality_checks": 300.70588235294116, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5112, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 519294, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 30546.70588235294, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1128910721, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2173.933688815969, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4670, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 274.70588235294116, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32565034, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6973.24068522484, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 75411, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4648, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32351212, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 138411, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13324549, "stage_ordering_ns": 82540, "stage_eval_ns": 1712655627, "stage_threat_ns": 1079077056, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169517, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 948409962, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 459701, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17920, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84750, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 110282946, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169500, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19924447, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2484, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6747.470588235294, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7218.058823529412, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1153, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19784, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 83, 128, 67, 127, 99, 115, 82, 52, 81, 84, 95, 53, 51, 35, 109, 123, 79, 80, 93, 143, 158, 65, 94, 96, 124, 64, 139 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 11051, "avg_search_time_ms": 789.3571428571429, "search_nodes": 115434, "safety_nodes": 184, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 115618, "avg_nodes": 8258.42857142857, "eval_calls": 77832, "avg_eval_calls": 5559.428571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77832, "pattern_eval_ns": 1620677, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.822759276390173, "pattern_frame_queries": 77832, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1620677, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.822759276390173, "pattern_frame_updates": 230744, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2962010281, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12836.781372430052, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35052, "avg_candidate_generations": 2503.714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 2752567, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.52810110692685, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 983, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 35038, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2751584, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 722099, "avg_legality_checks": 51578.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2252, "root_legality_checks": 983, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 721116, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2248, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3020438, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 215745.57142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6356385792, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2104.458291148502, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46037, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3288.3571428571427, "renju_forbidden_ns": 271145988, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5889.7405999522125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2680, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26004078, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20997, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 165825475, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22340, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 79106883, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 209552, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 91157, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6511.214285714285, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 849849033, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9322.9157716906, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 125626, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8973.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 393269392, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3130.4777036600703, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1729759167, "stage_ordering_ns": 1033809647, "stage_eval_ns": 2963630958, "stage_threat_ns": 5278607028, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 739792, "root_tactical_annotations": 3609, "search_tactical_annotations": 736183, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 230758, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1353150075, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 610887, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3707621477, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70165, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2453054066, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115372, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 165079268, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 230744, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28167535, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 256403, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 295717681, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 284307, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 958833650, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 199082, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24588673, "child_limit_applications": 35038, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35038, "child_cap_hits": 35038, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35038, "child_moves_before_total": 2749336, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2749336, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 563232, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 563232, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.46726411324848, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.074890119299045, "tt_hits": 17413, "tt_cutoffs": 2502, "beta_cutoffs": 30054, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5578.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6150.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 752, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8721, "avg_search_time_ms": 670.8461538461538, "search_nodes": 69576, "safety_nodes": 1278, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 70854, "avg_nodes": 5450.307692307692, "eval_calls": 40810, "avg_eval_calls": 3139.230769230769, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40810, "pattern_eval_ns": 874443, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.427174712080372, "pattern_frame_queries": 40810, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 874443, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.427174712080372, "pattern_frame_updates": 138998, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1538051958, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11065.28121267932, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25084, "avg_candidate_generations": 1929.5384615384614, "candidate_moves_total": 1889338, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.3204433104768, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 922, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 25071, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1888416, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 1033524, "avg_legality_checks": 79501.84615384616, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2936, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1033524, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2936, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2685992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 206614.76923076922, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5473442787, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2037.7733020053672, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36826, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2832.769230769231, "renju_forbidden_ns": 152342939, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4136.831016129908, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3393, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 32597824, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10547, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73289084, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22866, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 46236641, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 219390, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98467, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7574.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 890566956, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9044.318969807144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 134394, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10338.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 403361179, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3001.3332366028244, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2426037939, "stage_ordering_ns": 733204969, "stage_eval_ns": 1538926401, "stage_threat_ns": 3971794330, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 472413, "root_tactical_annotations": 450, "search_tactical_annotations": 471963, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 139011, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 829742569, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 416616, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3011020377, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50245, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1706514043, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 69499, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 101467717, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 138998, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17245195, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 68340, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 217037827, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 298024, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1087249375, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 106049, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12318472, "child_limit_applications": 25071, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25071, "child_cap_hits": 25071, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25071, "child_moves_before_total": 1885480, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1885480, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 286320, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 286320, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.20561605041682, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.420366160105301, "tt_hits": 12966, "tt_cutoffs": 3619, "beta_cutoffs": 20851, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 5.846153846153846, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 5.846153846153846, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5202.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5817.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1154, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26836, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 83, 155, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 53, 141, 169, 39, 69, 55, 37, 85, 80, 79, 96, 64, 125, 111, 95, 109, 110, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 23523, "avg_search_time_ms": 1568.2, "search_nodes": 247732, "safety_nodes": 778, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 248510, "avg_nodes": 16567.333333333332, "eval_calls": 175147, "avg_eval_calls": 11676.466666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 175147, "pattern_eval_ns": 3600864, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.559096073583905, "pattern_frame_queries": 175147, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3600864, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.559096073583905, "pattern_frame_updates": 495314, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6889970822, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13910.309060515148, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 68829, "avg_candidate_generations": 4588.6, "candidate_moves_total": 6157646, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.46295892719638, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1165, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 68814, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6156481, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1639418, "avg_legality_checks": 109294.53333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3135, "root_legality_checks": 1165, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1638253, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3132, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6379368, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 425291.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13602698688, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2132.29565812789, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60435, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4029.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 323286773, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5349.33023909986, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3774, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 32005724, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34338, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 220313757, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22296, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 70718811, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 248481, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 171710, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11447.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1356526949, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7900.104530895114, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 212944, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14196.266666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 515501942, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2420.8333740326093, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3845483867, "stage_ordering_ns": 2359259707, "stage_eval_ns": 6893571686, "stage_threat_ns": 10365568706, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1345202, "root_tactical_annotations": 4093, "search_tactical_annotations": 1341109, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 495329, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2912176357, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1204173, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6985484764, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 137732, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4664251976, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 247657, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 368514604, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 495314, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61285499, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 374266, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 420483698, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 692162, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1900207297, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 278774, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 38107482, "child_limit_applications": 68814, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 68814, "child_cap_hits": 68814, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 68814, "child_moves_before_total": 6153349, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6153349, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 736948, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 736948, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.42001627575785, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.709274275583457, "tt_hits": 31049, "tt_cutoffs": 3698, "beta_cutoffs": 53473, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2883.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3318.866666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 658, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3298, "avg_search_time_ms": 235.57142857142858, "search_nodes": 32596, "safety_nodes": 1641, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34237, "avg_nodes": 2445.5, "eval_calls": 22196, "avg_eval_calls": 1585.4285714285713, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22196, "pattern_eval_ns": 466015, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.995449630564064, "pattern_frame_queries": 22196, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 466015, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.995449630564064, "pattern_frame_updates": 65062, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 687904470, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10573.06061910178, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9851, "avg_candidate_generations": 703.6428571428571, "candidate_moves_total": 795303, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.73322505329408, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1092, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 9837, "search_candidate_moves_total": 794211, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 314931, "avg_legality_checks": 22495.071428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 372, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 314931, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 372, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 956719, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 68337.07142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1983243944, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2072.9638943096143, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5125, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 366.07142857142856, "renju_forbidden_ns": 26457407, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5162.420878048781, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 422, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4034008, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1976, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15081560, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2705, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7111569, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 230270, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 31145, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2224.6428571428573, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 274618040, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8817.40375662225, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41038, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2931.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 120341488, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2932.440372337833, "stage_move_gen_ns": 743048037, "stage_ordering_ns": 315695408, "stage_eval_ns": 688370485, "stage_threat_ns": 1522075922, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 176073, "root_tactical_annotations": 331, "search_tactical_annotations": 175742, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 65076, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 390679601, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 171024, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1074532831, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19767, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 654359792, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 32531, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 46744328, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 65062, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7973162, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44020, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 111141198, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 107228, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 308675898, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 24825, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2146000, "child_limit_applications": 9837, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9837, "child_cap_hits": 9837, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9837, "child_moves_before_total": 793839, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 793839, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 158867, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 158867, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.69929856663617, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.14994408864491, "tt_hits": 2930, "tt_cutoffs": 498, "beta_cutoffs": 8389, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6298.071428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6869.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1847, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1155, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21475, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 129, 96, 141, 110, 109, 142, 158, 82, 124, 68, 54, 94, 78, 66, 81, 52, 130, 131, 80, 67, 97, 69, 65, 70 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 11391, "avg_search_time_ms": 813.6428571428571, "search_nodes": 116727, "safety_nodes": 184, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 116911, "avg_nodes": 8350.785714285714, "eval_calls": 80819, "avg_eval_calls": 5772.785714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80819, "pattern_eval_ns": 1665156, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.60352144916418, "pattern_frame_queries": 80819, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1665156, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.60352144916418, "pattern_frame_updates": 233330, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3333251860, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14285.569193845626, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33591, "avg_candidate_generations": 2399.3571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 2705529, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.54327051888899, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 976, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 33577, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2704553, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 681007, "avg_legality_checks": 48643.357142857145, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2025, "root_legality_checks": 976, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 680031, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2021, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3036698, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 216907.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6572872640, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2164.4801820925227, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42270, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3019.285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 267851706, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6336.68573456352, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2412, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23460858, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 169917923, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19408, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 74263414, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 209511, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83189, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5942.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 790308616, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9500.15766507591, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 113911, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8136.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 364385116, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3198.8580207354867, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1652644153, "stage_ordering_ns": 1066364253, "stage_eval_ns": 3334917016, "stage_threat_ns": 5301243407, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 763207, "root_tactical_annotations": 3574, "search_tactical_annotations": 759633, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 233344, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1381864519, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 623457, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3691946617, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67243, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2485721754, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 116665, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 171378556, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 233330, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29197029, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 266979, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 263534456, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 289223, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 942675967, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 207005, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26856686, "child_limit_applications": 33577, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33577, "child_cap_hits": 33577, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33577, "child_moves_before_total": 2702532, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2702532, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 543554, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 543554, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.48759567561129, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.188283646543766, "tt_hits": 17013, "tt_cutoffs": 2269, "beta_cutoffs": 28359, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5559.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6130.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1188, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 10070, "avg_search_time_ms": 774.6153846153846, "search_nodes": 86682, "safety_nodes": 1245, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87927, "avg_nodes": 6763.615384615385, "eval_calls": 52081, "avg_eval_calls": 4006.230769230769, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 52081, "pattern_eval_ns": 1089202, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.91361532996678, "pattern_frame_queries": 52081, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1089202, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.91361532996678, "pattern_frame_updates": 173210, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2079602589, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12006.250152993476, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29721, "avg_candidate_generations": 2286.230769230769, "candidate_moves_total": 2174450, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.16207395444299, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 911, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 29708, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2173539, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 954814, "avg_legality_checks": 73447.23076923077, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1928, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 954814, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1928, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2957608, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 227508.3076923077, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6146051944, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2078.04818758943, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30668, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2359.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 123349083, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4022.0778335724535, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2269, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20811508, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9520, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62349789, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18859, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39974132, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 213654, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 100239, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7710.692307692308, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 907012018, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9048.494278673968, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137994, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10614.923076923076, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 402887790, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2919.603678420801, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2265224452, "stage_ordering_ns": 896651499, "stage_eval_ns": 2080691791, "stage_threat_ns": 4785316031, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 558290, "root_tactical_annotations": 457, "search_tactical_annotations": 557833, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 173223, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1038127609, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 501985, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3582362951, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59519, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2166766743, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86605, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 129563716, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 173210, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22004555, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 74792, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 193776476, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 367667, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1221582578, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 115831, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13257200, "child_limit_applications": 29708, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29708, "child_cap_hits": 29708, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29708, "child_moves_before_total": 2171611, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2171611, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 342376, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 342376, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.09852564965666, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.524707149589336, "tt_hits": 13827, "tt_cutoffs": 4816, "beta_cutoffs": 24306, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 5.923076923076923, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 5.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4562.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5178.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 196, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1156, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17662, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 110, 109, 142, 94, 96, 141, 124, 138, 98, 140, 81, 66, 82, 68, 84, 70, 83, 80, 85 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 15142, "avg_search_time_ms": 1261.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 148097, "safety_nodes": 283, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148380, "avg_nodes": 12365.0, "eval_calls": 94624, "avg_eval_calls": 7885.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 94624, "pattern_eval_ns": 1975598, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.87840294217112, "pattern_frame_queries": 94624, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1975598, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.87840294217112, "pattern_frame_updates": 296066, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4041720779, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13651.41819391622, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 50320, "avg_candidate_generations": 4193.333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4278930, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.0343799682035, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 761, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 50308, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4278169, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1050127, "avg_legality_checks": 87510.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1120, "root_legality_checks": 761, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1049366, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1119, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4131810, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 344317.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8958799881, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2168.250689407306, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27918, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2326.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 155877763, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5583.414392148435, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1188, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11041025, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14674, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 107048388, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12051, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37741929, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 46421, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 94126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7843.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 793562793, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8430.856437116207, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 121637, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10136.416666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 319209797, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2624.282060557232, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2486740506, "stage_ordering_ns": 1690162784, "stage_eval_ns": 4043696377, "stage_threat_ns": 6878092065, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 835220, "root_tactical_annotations": 3058, "search_tactical_annotations": 832162, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 296078, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1737354366, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 646151, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4849440421, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 100703, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3620032414, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148033, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 217510963, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 296066, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36874882, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 241288, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 218911127, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 304149, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1010191889, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 289783, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 36911433, "child_limit_applications": 50308, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 50308, "child_cap_hits": 50308, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 50308, "child_moves_before_total": 4277050, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4277050, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 471787, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 471787, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.01729347221118, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.377971694362726, "tt_hits": 30961, "tt_cutoffs": 3101, "beta_cutoffs": 40692, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3158.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3825.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1197, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2506, "avg_search_time_ms": 227.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 25438, "safety_nodes": 941, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 26379, "avg_nodes": 2398.090909090909, "eval_calls": 17694, "avg_eval_calls": 1608.5454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 17694, "pattern_eval_ns": 372370, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.04498700124336, "pattern_frame_queries": 17694, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 372370, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.04498700124336, "pattern_frame_updates": 50776, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 541287001, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10660.292283756105, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7285, "avg_candidate_generations": 662.2727272727273, "candidate_moves_total": 537856, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.83061084420041, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 696, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 7274, "search_candidate_moves_total": 537160, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 225786, "avg_legality_checks": 20526.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 90, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 225786, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 90, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 715250, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 65022.72727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1523773580, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2130.4069626004894, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3052, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 277.45454545454544, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13949618, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4570.648099606815, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 94, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 865410, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1201, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9203686, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1752, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3831772, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 48750, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 20848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1895.2727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 197391804, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9468.141020721412, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 28864, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2624.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 91210394, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3160.0053353658536, "stage_move_gen_ns": 544289288, "stage_ordering_ns": 226355731, "stage_eval_ns": 541659371, "stage_threat_ns": 1173639273, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 109139, "root_tactical_annotations": 311, "search_tactical_annotations": 108828, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 50787, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 307745189, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 105345, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 820452807, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14620, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 537423076, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 25388, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 37398515, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 50776, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6220934, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 28749, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 83974957, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 61970, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 198821494, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 18420, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1821828, "child_limit_applications": 7274, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 7274, "child_cap_hits": 7274, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 7274, "child_moves_before_total": 537070, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 537070, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 116471, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 116471, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.8342040142975, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.011960406928786, "tt_hits": 2468, "tt_cutoffs": 420, "beta_cutoffs": 6106, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5836.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6563.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1840, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1157, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 41006, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 109, 95, 98, 63, 127, 99, 125, 114, 113, 129, 144, 79, 47, 65, 128, 143, 126, 124, 93, 80, 50, 77, 78, 157, 171, 64, 66, 83, 82, 34, 49, 115, 101, 67, 51, 131 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 15249, "avg_search_time_ms": 802.578947368421, "search_nodes": 200350, "safety_nodes": 1142, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 201492, "avg_nodes": 10604.842105263158, "eval_calls": 153467, "avg_eval_calls": 8077.210526315789, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 153467, "pattern_eval_ns": 3168287, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.6447444727531, "pattern_frame_queries": 153467, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3168287, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.6447444727531, "pattern_frame_updates": 400526, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4164345726, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10397.192007510124, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44482, "avg_candidate_generations": 2341.157894736842, "candidate_moves_total": 3651083, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.08000989164157, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1439, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 44463, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3649644, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1303962, "avg_legality_checks": 68629.57894736843, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1200, "root_legality_checks": 1439, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1302523, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1198, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4296470, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 226130.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8755317728, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2037.7932879782704, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37617, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1979.842105263158, "renju_forbidden_ns": 135355262, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3598.247122311721, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1971, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12502508, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18235, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 90179248, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17399, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32579995, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 93511, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 119662, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6298.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 966675121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8078.380112316358, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 158346, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8334.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 403808420, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2550.1649552246345, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2977877373, "stage_ordering_ns": 1369479320, "stage_eval_ns": 4167514013, "stage_threat_ns": 6664449714, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 714378, "root_tactical_annotations": 3761, "search_tactical_annotations": 710617, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 400545, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2155231005, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 641995, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4166127851, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 89050, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2748887575, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 200263, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 277360411, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 400526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46182837, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 229430, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 259846093, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 323499, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1156848842, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 161449, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19547610, "child_limit_applications": 44463, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44463, "child_cap_hits": 44463, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44463, "child_moves_before_total": 3648446, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3648446, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 711704, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 711704, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.05577671322223, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.006657220610396, "tt_hits": 18829, "tt_cutoffs": 2333, "beta_cutoffs": 34427, "depth_sum": 87, "avg_depth": 4.578947368421052, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 87, "avg_effective_depth": 4.578947368421052, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5783.421052631579, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6204.473684210527, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1296, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 25738, "avg_search_time_ms": 1429.888888888889, "search_nodes": 195525, "safety_nodes": 1433, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 196958, "avg_nodes": 10942.111111111111, "eval_calls": 115438, "avg_eval_calls": 6413.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 115438, "pattern_eval_ns": 2474237, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.43347078085206, "pattern_frame_queries": 115438, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2474237, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.43347078085206, "pattern_frame_updates": 390824, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3826453033, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9790.731973983175, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 75002, "avg_candidate_generations": 4166.777777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 6368989, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.91758886429695, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1373, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 74984, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6367616, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 3838780, "avg_legality_checks": 213265.55555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6511, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3838780, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6511, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8576276, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 476459.77777777775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16764932198, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1954.80325003533, "renju_forbidden_checks": 66091, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3671.722222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 218539599, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3306.6468808158447, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8201, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 60713053, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15766, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 92084694, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 42114, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 65645792, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 96060, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 322439, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17913.277777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2776240241, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8610.125453186494, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 438212, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 24345.11111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1267562638, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2892.57856471297, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8583002489, "stage_ordering_ns": 2347361727, "stage_eval_ns": 3828927270, "stage_threat_ns": 10831454897, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1306608, "root_tactical_annotations": 3277, "search_tactical_annotations": 1303331, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 390842, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2243299073, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1133958, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8210307872, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 150117, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4506697339, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 195412, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 287624770, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 390824, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47805044, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 321681, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1312517673, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 662147, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2390835108, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 322780, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 42418138, "child_limit_applications": 74984, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 74984, "child_cap_hits": 74984, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 74984, "child_moves_before_total": 6361105, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6361105, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 756755, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 756755, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.8328310039475, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.092219673530353, "tt_hits": 34889, "tt_cutoffs": 4991, "beta_cutoffs": 61413, "depth_sum": 110, "avg_depth": 6.111111111111111, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 110, "avg_effective_depth": 6.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3438.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3882.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1158, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22516, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 145, 109, 108, 81, 123, 125, 80, 93, 129, 161, 77, 79, 63, 65, 107, 94, 124, 126, 142, 140, 155, 98, 84, 154 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 19152, "avg_search_time_ms": 1368.0, "search_nodes": 211411, "safety_nodes": 592, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 212003, "avg_nodes": 15143.07142857143, "eval_calls": 156131, "avg_eval_calls": 11152.214285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 156131, "pattern_eval_ns": 3212041, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.572730591618576, "pattern_frame_queries": 156131, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3212041, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.572730591618576, "pattern_frame_updates": 422686, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5798025629, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13717.098813303492, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52204, "avg_candidate_generations": 3728.8571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 4506474, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.3243046509846, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1052, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 52190, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4505422, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1466509, "avg_legality_checks": 104750.64285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1215, "root_legality_checks": 1052, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1465457, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1215, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5477089, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 391220.64285714284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11419434759, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2084.945992113694, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40917, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2922.6428571428573, "renju_forbidden_ns": 168887349, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4127.559425177799, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1758, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11198262, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22456, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 117413969, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16703, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40275118, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 163964, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11711.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1219032252, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7434.755507306482, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 204315, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14593.92857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 436077311, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2134.3382081589702, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3374934431, "stage_ordering_ns": 1736550979, "stage_eval_ns": 5801237670, "stage_threat_ns": 8185036170, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 921912, "root_tactical_annotations": 3769, "search_tactical_annotations": 918143, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 422700, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2471268386, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 774533, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5320358516, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 104475, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3565511681, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 211343, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 307378402, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 422686, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52597121, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 293687, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 361655611, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 376359, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1392803552, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 251866, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33433745, "child_limit_applications": 52190, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52190, "child_cap_hits": 52190, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52190, "child_moves_before_total": 4504207, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4504207, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 538925, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 538925, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.30402375934086, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.326211917991952, "tt_hits": 27367, "tt_cutoffs": 3022, "beta_cutoffs": 38569, "depth_sum": 68, "avg_depth": 4.857142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 68, "avg_effective_depth": 4.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.42857142857142855, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4086.285714285714, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4657.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1158, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3350, "avg_search_time_ms": 257.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 33390, "safety_nodes": 1601, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34991, "avg_nodes": 2691.6153846153848, "eval_calls": 22806, "avg_eval_calls": 1754.3076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22806, "pattern_eval_ns": 473892, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.779268613522756, "pattern_frame_queries": 22806, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 473892, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.779268613522756, "pattern_frame_updates": 66660, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 697627920, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10465.465346534653, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10098, "avg_candidate_generations": 776.7692307692307, "candidate_moves_total": 819340, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.1388393741335, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 973, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 10085, "search_candidate_moves_total": 818367, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 319366, "avg_legality_checks": 24566.615384615383, "illegal_moves_skipped": 98, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 319366, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 98, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 983942, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 75687.84615384616, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2013996726, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2046.8652888076736, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3997, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 307.46153846153845, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18591384, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4651.334500875657, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 98, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 920344, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1492, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12674753, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2407, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4996287, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 33251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2557.769230769231, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 272153519, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8184.822080538931, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 43290, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3330.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 112015155, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2587.552668052668, "stage_move_gen_ns": 742454362, "stage_ordering_ns": 322495245, "stage_eval_ns": 698101812, "stage_threat_ns": 1558148160, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 176300, "root_tactical_annotations": 331, "search_tactical_annotations": 175969, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 66673, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 401610466, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 172468, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1098399042, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20256, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 682412659, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 33330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 47990175, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 66660, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8126515, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 43299, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 108686109, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 108903, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 306911082, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 24098, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2021962, "child_limit_applications": 10085, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10085, "child_cap_hits": 10085, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10085, "child_moves_before_total": 818269, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 818269, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 162835, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 162835, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.13723351512147, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.146256817055033, "tt_hits": 2779, "tt_cutoffs": 439, "beta_cutoffs": 8598, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6166.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6781.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1874, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1159, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 34008, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 101, 100, 128, 130, 115, 129, 126, 144, 99, 116, 158, 132, 148, 174, 159, 160, 146, 97, 145, 102, 88, 81, 65, 84, 68, 82, 147, 149, 131, 83, 163 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 16894, "avg_search_time_ms": 993.7647058823529, "search_nodes": 206101, "safety_nodes": 172, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 206273, "avg_nodes": 12133.70588235294, "eval_calls": 152029, "avg_eval_calls": 8942.882352941177, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 152029, "pattern_eval_ns": 3151610, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.730321188720573, "pattern_frame_queries": 152029, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3151610, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.730321188720573, "pattern_frame_updates": 412042, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4743805305, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11512.916899248135, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 51533, "avg_candidate_generations": 3031.3529411764707, "candidate_moves_total": 4052983, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.64830302912696, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1129, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 51516, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4051854, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 1216720, "avg_legality_checks": 71571.76470588235, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3027, "root_legality_checks": 1129, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 1215591, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3022, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4523345, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 266079.1176470588, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9566551100, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2114.9284655492784, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36988, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2175.764705882353, "renju_forbidden_ns": 191693975, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5182.5990861901155, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3314, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30385116, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16602, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 117991791, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17047, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43069487, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 247581, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 113307, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6665.117647058823, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 888540569, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7841.885929377709, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 144446, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8496.823529411764, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 358667412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2483.0553424809273, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2881999682, "stage_ordering_ns": 1574770644, "stage_eval_ns": 4746956915, "stage_threat_ns": 7624155663, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1021330, "root_tactical_annotations": 4766, "search_tactical_annotations": 1016564, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 412059, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2313866951, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 882547, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4939390322, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 103146, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3478251832, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 206021, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 292347233, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 412042, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50409544, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 380291, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 282263164, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 399095, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1178856386, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 241944, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28141613, "child_limit_applications": 51516, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 51516, "child_cap_hits": 51516, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 51516, "child_moves_before_total": 4048832, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4048832, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 824705, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 824705, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.59367963351193, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.008715738799598, "tt_hits": 23263, "tt_cutoffs": 2476, "beta_cutoffs": 41673, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5170.117647058823, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5640.705882352941, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1076, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 17095, "avg_search_time_ms": 1005.5882352941177, "search_nodes": 142801, "safety_nodes": 1438, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 144239, "avg_nodes": 8484.64705882353, "eval_calls": 84742, "avg_eval_calls": 4984.823529411765, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84742, "pattern_eval_ns": 1792748, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.155365698237002, "pattern_frame_queries": 84742, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1792748, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.155365698237002, "pattern_frame_updates": 285392, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2926386269, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10253.918361411672, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52966, "avg_candidate_generations": 3115.6470588235293, "candidate_moves_total": 3973981, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.02890533549824, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1147, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 52949, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3972834, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 2180040, "avg_legality_checks": 128237.64705882352, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4728, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2180040, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4728, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5210035, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 306472.64705882355, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10776771490, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2068.4643174182133, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41708, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2453.4117647058824, "renju_forbidden_ns": 161014727, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3860.523808382085, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4929, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 46149365, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11501, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72214037, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25248, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42343274, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 308051, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 142613, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8389.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1176103362, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8246.817344842335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 189816, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11165.64705882353, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 501393923, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2641.4734427024064, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5103683921, "stage_ordering_ns": 1576279281, "stage_eval_ns": 2928179017, "stage_threat_ns": 7395614167, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1036815, "root_tactical_annotations": 1793, "search_tactical_annotations": 1035022, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 285409, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1634498675, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 866013, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5481555083, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 106036, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3534815702, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 142696, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 209350387, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 285392, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35453609, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 199933, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 349850070, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 560032, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1596583720, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 276850, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 34756413, "child_limit_applications": 52949, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52949, "child_cap_hits": 52949, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52949, "child_moves_before_total": 3968106, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3968106, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 532703, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 532703, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.942038565412, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.060681032691836, "tt_hits": 26454, "tt_cutoffs": 5005, "beta_cutoffs": 43188, "depth_sum": 105, "avg_depth": 6.176470588235294, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 105, "avg_effective_depth": 6.176470588235294, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3933.235294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4403.823529411765, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 188, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1160, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11758, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 95, 99, 94, 129, 79, 63, 96, 97, 93, 92, 81, 144, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7397, "avg_search_time_ms": 821.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 67804, "safety_nodes": 428, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68232, "avg_nodes": 7581.333333333333, "eval_calls": 41038, "avg_eval_calls": 4559.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41038, "pattern_eval_ns": 891733, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.729445879428823, "pattern_frame_queries": 41038, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 891733, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.729445879428823, "pattern_frame_updates": 135522, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1514077963, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11172.193171588377, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25166, "avg_candidate_generations": 2796.222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 1889524, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.08241277914647, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 554, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 25157, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1888970, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 595771, "avg_legality_checks": 66196.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 590, "root_legality_checks": 554, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 595217, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 590, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1932765, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 214751.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4454873179, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2304.92231543928, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14505, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1611.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 69479566, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4790.042468114443, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 635, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6716849, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4651, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 39896798, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9217, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22863019, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2900, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44109, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4901.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 398301885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9029.945929402164, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 61124, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6791.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 162544972, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2659.2659511812053, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1521746684, "stage_ordering_ns": 830671000, "stage_eval_ns": 1514969696, "stage_threat_ns": 3494353102, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 239941, "root_tactical_annotations": 1337, "search_tactical_annotations": 238604, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 135531, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 832735567, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 210848, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2530688629, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50374, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1941507271, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67761, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 103555890, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 135522, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17316927, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 31393, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 66977536, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 129076, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 522077142, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79472, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10056089, "child_limit_applications": 25157, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25157, "child_cap_hits": 25157, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25157, "child_moves_before_total": 1888380, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1888380, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 214149, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 214149, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.0637993401439, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.512501490638789, "tt_hits": 13299, "tt_cutoffs": 1566, "beta_cutoffs": 19800, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2962.777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3851.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 713, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 4354, "avg_search_time_ms": 544.25, "search_nodes": 40863, "safety_nodes": 687, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 41550, "avg_nodes": 5193.75, "eval_calls": 28575, "avg_eval_calls": 3571.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 28575, "pattern_eval_ns": 617343, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.604304461942256, "pattern_frame_queries": 28575, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 617343, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.604304461942256, "pattern_frame_updates": 81656, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 759782408, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9304.673361418634, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11804, "avg_candidate_generations": 1475.5, "candidate_moves_total": 846160, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.68417485598103, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 492, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 11796, "search_candidate_moves_total": 845668, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 481351, "avg_legality_checks": 60168.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1383, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 481351, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1383, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1195028, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 149378.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2714326545, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2271.3497466168155, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7247, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 905.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 41829454, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5771.968262729405, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1383, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14474239, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1669, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17536987, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4195, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9818228, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 34293, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4286.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 317013503, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9244.262764995772, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 46575, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5821.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 134826774, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2894.8314331723027, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1246132416, "stage_ordering_ns": 379935486, "stage_eval_ns": 760399751, "stage_threat_ns": 1938697888, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 144563, "root_tactical_annotations": 628, "search_tactical_annotations": 143935, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 81664, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 499261749, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 138423, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1364858472, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23643, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 920464543, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40828, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 60430231, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 81656, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10515608, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 29269, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 75494818, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 85504, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 368565459, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 29790, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3631828, "child_limit_applications": 11796, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11796, "child_cap_hits": 11796, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11796, "child_moves_before_total": 844285, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 844285, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 188803, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 188803, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.57383858935232, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00567989148864, "tt_hits": 3610, "tt_cutoffs": 457, "beta_cutoffs": 9956, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 4.375, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 4.375, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4017.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5017.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1857, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1161, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28938, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 97, 127, 126, 143, 159, 158, 113, 95, 79, 173, 188, 129, 98, 140, 101, 157, 115, 185, 171, 125, 70, 84, 100, 99, 85, 130, 55 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 8773, "avg_search_time_ms": 626.6428571428571, "search_nodes": 88242, "safety_nodes": 1250, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 89492, "avg_nodes": 6392.285714285715, "eval_calls": 63465, "avg_eval_calls": 4533.214285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 63465, "pattern_eval_ns": 1372797, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.63077286693453, "pattern_frame_queries": 63465, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1372797, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.63077286693453, "pattern_frame_updates": 176360, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2198101042, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12463.716500340213, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23117, "avg_candidate_generations": 1651.2142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 1808441, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.22991737682226, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1035, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 23103, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1807406, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 769270, "avg_legality_checks": 54947.857142857145, "illegal_moves_skipped": 205, "root_legality_checks": 1035, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 768235, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 205, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2306183, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 164727.35714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5354877181, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2321.965421217657, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9500, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 678.5714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33283205, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3503.495263157895, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 253, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2404418, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22828693, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5623, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8044324, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5770, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52612, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3758.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 475929446, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9046.024595149396, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72538, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5181.285714285715, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 193260259, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2664.262303895889, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1945023319, "stage_ordering_ns": 791802986, "stage_eval_ns": 2199473839, "stage_threat_ns": 3789051513, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 288844, "root_tactical_annotations": 1374, "search_tactical_annotations": 287470, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 176374, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1089700635, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 281455, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2535642770, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46295, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1796685162, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 88180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 133357516, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 176360, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22808000, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 58894, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 62866230, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 176256, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 675544187, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53694, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7542592, "child_limit_applications": 23103, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23103, "child_cap_hits": 23103, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23103, "child_moves_before_total": 1807201, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1807201, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 369655, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 369655, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.22365060814613, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000302990953557, "tt_hits": 7877, "tt_cutoffs": 1613, "beta_cutoffs": 18949, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 4.357142857142857, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 4.357142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5353.785714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5925.214285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 20151, "avg_search_time_ms": 1550.076923076923, "search_nodes": 124638, "safety_nodes": 535, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 125173, "avg_nodes": 9628.692307692309, "eval_calls": 74350, "avg_eval_calls": 5719.2307692307695, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74350, "pattern_eval_ns": 1652894, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.231257565568256, "pattern_frame_queries": 74350, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1652894, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.231257565568256, "pattern_frame_updates": 249136, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2776022958, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11142.600659880547, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 47271, "avg_candidate_generations": 3636.230769230769, "candidate_moves_total": 4112752, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.00370205834444, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 977, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 47258, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4111775, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 3086553, "avg_legality_checks": 237427.15384615384, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1000, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3086553, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1000, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6180714, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 475439.53846153844, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13662008658, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2210.4256333491567, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34219, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2632.230769230769, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50838755, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1485.6879219147258, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1040, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10405247, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2371, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19729542, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30808, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20703966, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 199805, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15369.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1902576091, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9522.164565451316, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 277353, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21334.846153846152, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 842723605, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3038.4513778470036, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7587922491, "stage_ordering_ns": 1737445550, "stage_eval_ns": 2777675852, "stage_threat_ns": 7928775694, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 905414, "root_tactical_annotations": 3438, "search_tactical_annotations": 901976, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 249149, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1550282343, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 817363, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6124091197, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 94612, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3380095357, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124568, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 195757740, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 249136, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32606036, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 185658, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 361011673, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 537083, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2382899136, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 182673, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26038378, "child_limit_applications": 47258, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 47258, "child_cap_hits": 47258, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 47258, "child_moves_before_total": 4110775, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4110775, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 426333, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 426333, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.98580134580388, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.021393203267172, "tt_hits": 18853, "tt_cutoffs": 2964, "beta_cutoffs": 37996, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 4.923076923076923, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 4.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.46153846153846156, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.46153846153846156, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1464.6153846153845, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1918.6923076923076, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1162, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 48571, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 125, 173, 141, 113, 143, 140, 109, 93, 129, 171, 115, 101, 174, 159, 158, 126, 145, 144, 160, 100, 190, 206, 188, 98, 99, 146, 189, 83, 68, 187, 175, 205, 203, 161, 191, 192, 201, 69, 55, 116, 131, 114, 202, 216, 200, 199, 204 ], "move_count": 53, "black_stats": { "move_count": 27, "search_move_count": 25, "total_time_ms": 34507, "avg_search_time_ms": 1380.28, "search_nodes": 411010, "safety_nodes": 915, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 411925, "avg_nodes": 16477.0, "eval_calls": 248379, "avg_eval_calls": 9935.16, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 248379, "pattern_eval_ns": 5075697, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.435290423103403, "pattern_frame_queries": 248379, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5075697, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.435290423103403, "pattern_frame_updates": 821730, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7497487014, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9124.027373954948, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 154195, "avg_candidate_generations": 6167.8, "candidate_moves_total": 14854187, "avg_candidate_moves": 96.33377865689549, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 25, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2159, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 154170, "search_candidate_moves_total": 14852028, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 3675371, "avg_legality_checks": 147014.84, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11358, "root_legality_checks": 2159, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 3673212, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11350, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11023029, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 440921.16, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19124254035, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1734.9363804631196, "renju_forbidden_checks": 216905, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8676.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 332948787, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1534.998211198451, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25733, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 31155031, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 87238, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 175890689, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 103821, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 125784577, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 113, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 118490, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 254571, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10182.84, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1396161914, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5484.37140915501, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 317043, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12681.72, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 520287527, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1641.0629693763938, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6953490023, "stage_ordering_ns": 4491103337, "stage_eval_ns": 7502562711, "stage_threat_ns": 15376163439, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 3666730, "root_tactical_annotations": 8966, "search_tactical_annotations": 3657764, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 821755, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3871308669, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2952302, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10756274405, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 308534, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7672767158, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 410865, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 528975354, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 821730, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 87313154, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1181889, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 424679907, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1461859, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2658741049, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1022982, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 132291857, "child_limit_applications": 154170, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 154170, "child_cap_hits": 154170, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 154170, "child_moves_before_total": 14840678, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 14840678, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 1459335, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1459335, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 96.26177596160083, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.465752091846662, "tt_hits": 77573, "tt_cutoffs": 8319, "beta_cutoffs": 125770, "depth_sum": 141, "avg_depth": 5.64, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 141, "avg_effective_depth": 5.64, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16, "pooled_budget_moves": 25, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.32, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3239.12, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3559.12, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 14039, "avg_search_time_ms": 584.9583333333334, "search_nodes": 145965, "safety_nodes": 2366, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148331, "avg_nodes": 6180.458333333333, "eval_calls": 96325, "avg_eval_calls": 4013.5416666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 96325, "pattern_eval_ns": 1977828, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.532862704386194, "pattern_frame_queries": 96325, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1977828, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.532862704386194, "pattern_frame_updates": 291700, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2026036157, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6945.615896468975, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46913, "avg_candidate_generations": 1954.7083333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4360992, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.95913712616972, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2081, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 46889, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4358911, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 2895759, "avg_legality_checks": 120656.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 14635, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2895759, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 14635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5393164, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 224715.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8871484265, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1644.9498411322186, "renju_forbidden_checks": 73105, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3046.0416666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 69353473, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 948.683031256412, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17539, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7317123, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18919, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31035261, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 36457, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30811869, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 190, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 189220, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 148123, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6171.791666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1006012660, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6791.738352585351, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 206770, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8615.416666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 414416925, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2004.2410649513952, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4916145157, "stage_ordering_ns": 1322714306, "stage_eval_ns": 2028013985, "stage_threat_ns": 5649964656, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 872265, "root_tactical_annotations": 3186, "search_tactical_annotations": 869079, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 291724, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1401029739, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 813798, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4013085590, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 93941, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2519643738, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 145850, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 187660553, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 291700, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31069815, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 319140, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 421696183, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 400699, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1071235167, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 152426, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17118959, "child_limit_applications": 46889, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46889, "child_cap_hits": 46889, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46889, "child_moves_before_total": 4344276, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4344276, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 750364, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 750364, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 92.65021646868135, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002985774915224, "tt_hits": 17602, "tt_cutoffs": 2636, "beta_cutoffs": 40677, "depth_sum": 115, "avg_depth": 4.791666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 115, "avg_effective_depth": 4.791666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6308.291666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6641.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1054, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1163, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28683, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 129, 124, 127, 95, 96, 80, 143, 65, 115, 157, 159, 175, 144, 50, 35, 174, 145, 146, 128, 160, 131, 130, 173, 117, 187 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 13695, "avg_search_time_ms": 978.2142857142857, "search_nodes": 165709, "safety_nodes": 551, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 166260, "avg_nodes": 11875.714285714286, "eval_calls": 125496, "avg_eval_calls": 8964.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 125496, "pattern_eval_ns": 2718780, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.66427615222796, "pattern_frame_queries": 125496, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2718780, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.66427615222796, "pattern_frame_updates": 331294, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3687570533, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11130.80989393107, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38489, "avg_candidate_generations": 2749.214285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 3200303, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.14850996388579, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1037, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 38475, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3199266, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 1031542, "avg_legality_checks": 73681.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 263, "root_legality_checks": 1037, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1030505, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 263, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3445026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 246073.2857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7834277467, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2274.083698352349, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20308, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1450.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64755349, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3188.662054362813, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 538, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2515570, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9348, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44587120, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10418, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17647179, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5480, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 84084, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6006.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 665519398, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7914.935041149327, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 103794, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7413.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 230160589, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2217.474892575679, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2571790869, "stage_ordering_ns": 1328596830, "stage_eval_ns": 3690289313, "stage_threat_ns": 6043211642, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 512156, "root_tactical_annotations": 3415, "search_tactical_annotations": 508741, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 331308, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1973440514, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 473428, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3766326698, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 77039, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2745591728, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 165647, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 245369904, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 331294, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41808720, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 160381, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 193419034, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 235996, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 827038984, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 115779, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16265806, "child_limit_applications": 38475, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38475, "child_cap_hits": 38475, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38475, "child_moves_before_total": 3199003, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3199003, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 617114, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 617114, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.14497725795971, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.039350227420403, "tt_hits": 16726, "tt_cutoffs": 1676, "beta_cutoffs": 30331, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4445.214285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5016.642857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1031, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 14974, "avg_search_time_ms": 1151.8461538461538, "search_nodes": 123582, "safety_nodes": 1103, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 124685, "avg_nodes": 9591.153846153846, "eval_calls": 77289, "avg_eval_calls": 5945.307692307692, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77289, "pattern_eval_ns": 1717891, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.22684987514394, "pattern_frame_queries": 77289, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1717891, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.22684987514394, "pattern_frame_updates": 247010, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2584835906, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10464.499032427837, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43166, "avg_candidate_generations": 3320.4615384615386, "candidate_moves_total": 3483211, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.69339294815364, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 955, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 43153, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3482256, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1834622, "avg_legality_checks": 141124.76923076922, "illegal_moves_skipped": 320, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1834622, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 320, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4258186, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 327552.76923076925, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9519427382, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2235.559316103148, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21260, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1635.3846153846155, "renju_forbidden_ns": 56426160, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2654.099717779868, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 370, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1649506, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7435, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37355570, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13455, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17421084, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 116321, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8947.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 936959344, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8054.945744964366, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 147753, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11365.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 332905406, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2253.1211278282, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4544411715, "stage_ordering_ns": 1458521282, "stage_eval_ns": 2586553797, "stage_threat_ns": 6298789066, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 649507, "root_tactical_annotations": 1648, "search_tactical_annotations": 647859, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 247023, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1497697291, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 608526, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4563791448, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 86409, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3047696900, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123505, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 187439896, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 247010, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31733048, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 130626, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 306142785, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 391482, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1209709703, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 127399, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18127383, "child_limit_applications": 43153, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43153, "child_cap_hits": 43153, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43153, "child_moves_before_total": 3481936, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3481936, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 410345, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 410345, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.68815609575232, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.509072370402984, "tt_hits": 16968, "tt_cutoffs": 3064, "beta_cutoffs": 33835, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 5.769230769230769, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 5.769230769230769, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2743.5384615384614, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3358.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1164, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16103, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 81, 129, 127, 143, 109, 108, 95, 145, 161, 123, 80, 125, 79, 63, 78, 77, 82 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10947, "avg_search_time_ms": 1094.7, "search_nodes": 102794, "safety_nodes": 160, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 102954, "avg_nodes": 10295.4, "eval_calls": 66067, "avg_eval_calls": 6606.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 66067, "pattern_eval_ns": 1484045, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.462727231446866, "pattern_frame_queries": 66067, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1484045, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.462727231446866, "pattern_frame_updates": 205496, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2702258059, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13149.930212753532, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34385, "avg_candidate_generations": 3438.5, "candidate_moves_total": 2664020, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.47622509815326, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 673, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 34375, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2663347, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 822660, "avg_legality_checks": 82266.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1245, "root_legality_checks": 673, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 821987, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1243, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2811990, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 281199.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6538899468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2325.363699017422, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25161, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2516.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 164064403, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6520.583561861611, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1318, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13666860, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12678, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 112114009, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11155, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 38155331, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 128203, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5811.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 539170098, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9278.119803138767, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76414, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7641.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 226573809, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2965.08243253854, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2109315779, "stage_ordering_ns": 1158132213, "stage_eval_ns": 2703742104, "stage_threat_ns": 4930739549, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 421283, "root_tactical_annotations": 2659, "search_tactical_annotations": 418624, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 205506, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1260732423, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 350613, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3464719994, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 68815, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2636412860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102748, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159003932, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 205496, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26626919, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 92987, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 90826310, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 188803, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 737471094, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 139493, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19656281, "child_limit_applications": 34375, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34375, "child_cap_hits": 34375, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34375, "child_moves_before_total": 2662104, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2662104, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 338915, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 338915, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.44302545454545, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.859345454545455, "tt_hits": 19095, "tt_cutoffs": 2306, "beta_cutoffs": 26297, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2507.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3307.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 558, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5147, "avg_search_time_ms": 571.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 51371, "safety_nodes": 753, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 52124, "avg_nodes": 5791.555555555556, "eval_calls": 36783, "avg_eval_calls": 4087.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36783, "pattern_eval_ns": 817174, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.216078079547618, "pattern_frame_queries": 36783, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 817174, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.216078079547618, "pattern_frame_updates": 102662, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1100817944, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10722.740098575909, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13929, "avg_candidate_generations": 1547.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1013731, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.77844784263048, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 598, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 13920, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1013133, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 524031, "avg_legality_checks": 58225.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 607, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 524031, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 607, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1366873, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 151874.77777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3147233705, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2302.506308193958, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10568, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1174.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 70592923, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6679.875378501136, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 607, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6837390, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 47625406, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5521, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15998157, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 131970, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28717, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3190.777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 274999270, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9576.183793571752, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 39803, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4422.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 120609837, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3030.169509835942, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1342024583, "stage_ordering_ns": 450348380, "stage_eval_ns": 1101635118, "stage_threat_ns": 2218604076, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 162912, "root_tactical_annotations": 576, "search_tactical_annotations": 162336, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 102671, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 630029823, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 154924, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1493317070, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27898, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1075173654, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51331, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 76767467, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 102662, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13075409, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32061, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 78830998, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 94959, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 339122337, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 35892, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5414307, "child_limit_applications": 13920, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13920, "child_cap_hits": 13920, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13920, "child_moves_before_total": 1012526, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1012526, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 222947, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 222947, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.7389367816092, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01630747126437, "tt_hits": 4389, "tt_cutoffs": 628, "beta_cutoffs": 11510, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4239.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5128.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1638, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1165, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "draw", "winner": null, "end_reason": "max_moves", "duration_ms": 122132, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 84, 98, 83, 85, 99, 97, 129, 69, 115, 67, 101, 143, 131, 147, 116, 146, 144, 114, 87, 73, 71, 86, 81, 80, 128, 130, 162, 68, 66, 95, 94, 110, 125, 127, 111, 100, 103, 55, 160, 176, 159, 161, 117, 145, 189, 174, 72, 102, 118, 119, 148, 133, 175, 38, 70, 37, 141, 50, 65, 53, 21, 157, 49, 56, 54, 8, 23, 36, 35, 39, 40, 11, 25, 22, 64, 7, 52, 79, 191, 6, 9, 190, 207, 223, 26, 158, 17, 33, 27, 24, 28, 29, 206, 47, 31, 19, 61, 57, 62, 172, 126, 202, 187, 63, 46, 76, 78, 30, 171, 156, 155, 203, 139, 123, 140, 188 ], "move_count": 120, "black_stats": { "move_count": 60, "search_move_count": 58, "total_time_ms": 38543, "avg_search_time_ms": 664.5344827586207, "search_nodes": 513242, "safety_nodes": 3036, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 516278, "avg_nodes": 8901.344827586207, "eval_calls": 346011, "avg_eval_calls": 5965.706896551724, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 346011, "pattern_eval_ns": 7672345, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.173702570149505, "pattern_frame_queries": 346011, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7672345, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.173702570149505, "pattern_frame_updates": 1025904, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 9215933631, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8983.231989542881, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 158826, "avg_candidate_generations": 2738.3793103448274, "candidate_moves_total": 14241122, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.66492891592057, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 58, "root_candidate_moves_total": 4909, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 158768, "search_candidate_moves_total": 14236213, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 3779527, "avg_legality_checks": 65164.25862068965, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12126, "root_legality_checks": 4909, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "search_legality_checks": 3774618, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12104, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11091558, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 191233.75862068965, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21270628723, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1917.731370380969, "renju_forbidden_checks": 131787, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2272.189655172414, "renju_forbidden_ns": 424382964, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3220.218716565367, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15987, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 60183856, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 53384, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 242532125, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 62287, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 121055210, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 129, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 611773, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 278939, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4809.293103448276, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2050014818, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7349.330204811805, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 370634, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6390.241379310345, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 851044527, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2296.185797849091, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7854029916, "stage_ordering_ns": 4203720468, "stage_eval_ns": 9223605976, "stage_threat_ns": 17009959591, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 3900037, "root_tactical_annotations": 14905, "search_tactical_annotations": 3885132, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1025962, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5035669991, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3513436, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11027707439, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 317942, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7278597747, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 512952, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 740100441, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1025904, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 119514307, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1981527, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 934650860, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1213919, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2813503518, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 704591, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 86967413, "child_limit_applications": 158768, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 158768, "child_cap_hits": 158768, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 158768, "child_moves_before_total": 14224109, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 14224109, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 2540660, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 2540660, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.59052831804898, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002343041418925, "tt_hits": 73289, "tt_cutoffs": 8173, "beta_cutoffs": 136705, "depth_sum": 290, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 290, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 5, "count": 58 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 58, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7214.8448275862065, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7352.775862068966, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 339, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 60, "search_move_count": 58, "total_time_ms": 83531, "avg_search_time_ms": 1440.1896551724137, "search_nodes": 807208, "safety_nodes": 4264, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 811472, "avg_nodes": 13990.896551724138, "eval_calls": 489334, "avg_eval_calls": 8436.793103448275, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 489334, "pattern_eval_ns": 10908850, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.293259818447115, "pattern_frame_queries": 489334, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 10908850, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.293259818447115, "pattern_frame_updates": 1613616, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 11168106551, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6921.167459296388, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 296030, "avg_candidate_generations": 5103.9655172413795, "candidate_moves_total": 27248227, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.04549201094484, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 58, "root_candidate_moves_total": 4937, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 295972, "search_candidate_moves_total": 27243290, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 17667385, "avg_legality_checks": 304610.0862068966, "illegal_moves_skipped": 48714, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 17667385, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 48714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 31459442, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 542404.1724137932, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 53096170748, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1687.7658144095499, "renju_forbidden_checks": 410650, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7080.172413793103, "renju_forbidden_ns": 662744534, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1613.8914744916597, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 94187, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 188361308, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 81997, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 218865556, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 234312, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 254813378, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 154, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 704292, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 989083, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17053.155172413793, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 6835284352, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6910.728778070193, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1368376, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23592.689655172413, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3021284833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2207.934685349641, "stage_move_gen_ns": 33374281015, "stage_ordering_ns": 7413775344, "stage_eval_ns": 11179015401, "stage_threat_ns": 30799875525, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 7680430, "root_tactical_annotations": 15118, "search_tactical_annotations": 7665312, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1613674, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 7260864317, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 6719704, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 22010381089, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 592460, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11071329904, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 806808, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1139445236, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1613616, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 179769288, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 3116421, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 3773396918, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 3010781, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 7164842295, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1553228, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 209415595, "child_limit_applications": 295972, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 295972, "child_cap_hits": 295972, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 295972, "child_moves_before_total": 27194576, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 27194576, "child_moves_before_max": 131, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 131, "child_moves_after_total": 2642016, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 2642016, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.88225913262065, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.926574135391185, "tt_hits": 139470, "tt_cutoffs": 21509, "beta_cutoffs": 239390, "depth_sum": 391, "avg_depth": 6.741379310344827, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 391, "avg_effective_depth": 6.741379310344827, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 47 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 9, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.15517241379310345, "pooled_budget_moves": 58, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3103448275862069, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 9, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.15517241379310345, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5236.051724137931, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5373.982758620689, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1166, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14107, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 155, 169, 51, 81, 84, 53, 95, 111, 125, 68, 110, 140, 65, 80, 79, 38, 23, 98 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 11593, "avg_search_time_ms": 891.7692307692307, "search_nodes": 115470, "safety_nodes": 697, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 116167, "avg_nodes": 8935.923076923076, "eval_calls": 79542, "avg_eval_calls": 6118.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79542, "pattern_eval_ns": 1753258, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.041914963164114, "pattern_frame_queries": 79542, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1753258, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.041914963164114, "pattern_frame_updates": 230822, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3019744722, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13082.568914574867, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33891, "avg_candidate_generations": 2607.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2803298, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.71511610752117, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 922, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 33878, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2802376, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 908480, "avg_legality_checks": 69883.07692307692, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1149, "root_legality_checks": 922, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 907558, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1149, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3099776, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 238444.3076923077, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6911697616, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2229.740992897551, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23464, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1804.923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 134895408, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5749.037163314013, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1291, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11214832, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11823, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 94484067, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10348, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29193629, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2880, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83585, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6429.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 711914145, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8517.247652090686, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 108920, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8378.461538461539, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 287947945, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2643.6645703268455, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2261034319, "stage_ordering_ns": 1161961055, "stage_eval_ns": 3021497980, "stage_threat_ns": 5098603466, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 504184, "root_tactical_annotations": 2375, "search_tactical_annotations": 501809, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 230835, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1405964634, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 404043, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3462201281, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67840, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2421210614, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115411, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 176386205, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 230822, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29934864, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 117647, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 181709175, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 218547, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 858826810, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 167990, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24116482, "child_limit_applications": 33878, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33878, "child_cap_hits": 33878, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33878, "child_moves_before_total": 2801227, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2801227, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 346958, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 346958, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.68572524942441, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.241395595961981, "tt_hits": 18204, "tt_cutoffs": 1991, "beta_cutoffs": 25858, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5246.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5862.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 888, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 2500, "avg_search_time_ms": 208.33333333333334, "search_nodes": 23081, "safety_nodes": 1375, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 24456, "avg_nodes": 2038.0, "eval_calls": 15977, "avg_eval_calls": 1331.4166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 15977, "pattern_eval_ns": 356692, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.325342680102647, "pattern_frame_queries": 15977, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 356692, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.325342680102647, "pattern_frame_updates": 46052, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 483244195, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10493.44643012247, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6725, "avg_candidate_generations": 560.4166666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 514978, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.57665427509293, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 852, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 6713, "search_candidate_moves_total": 514126, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 261335, "avg_legality_checks": 21777.916666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 178, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 261335, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 178, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 720121, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 60010.083333333336, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1569149851, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2179.008598554965, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3401, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 283.4166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15248284, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4483.4707438988535, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 178, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1497800, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9638391, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2143, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4112093, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23689, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1974.0833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 228604599, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9650.242686478956, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 33094, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2757.8333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 106180404, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3208.4487822566025, "stage_move_gen_ns": 651790348, "stage_ordering_ns": 218782656, "stage_eval_ns": 483600887, "stage_threat_ns": 1118152181, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 98438, "root_tactical_annotations": 356, "search_tactical_annotations": 98082, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 46064, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 291086149, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 90354, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 784432380, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13505, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 476613171, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 23026, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 34647613, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 46052, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5848202, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 22801, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 102472565, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 54039, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 204946082, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 21598, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2137837, "child_limit_applications": 6713, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6713, "child_cap_hits": 6713, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6713, "child_moves_before_total": 513948, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 513948, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 107645, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 107645, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.56010725458066, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.035304632802028, "tt_hits": 2515, "tt_cutoffs": 336, "beta_cutoffs": 5671, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6029.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6695.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1866, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1167, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 37538, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 141, 93, 97, 83, 98, 84, 82, 85, 114, 130, 66, 50, 108, 109, 80, 94, 67, 52, 95, 125, 68, 65, 79, 126, 78, 81, 47, 63, 128, 77, 61, 99, 71, 49, 91, 51, 53, 48 ], "move_count": 44, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 12828, "avg_search_time_ms": 641.4, "search_nodes": 232343, "safety_nodes": 948, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 233291, "avg_nodes": 11664.55, "eval_calls": 170013, "avg_eval_calls": 8500.65, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 170013, "pattern_eval_ns": 3399547, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.99580620305506, "pattern_frame_queries": 170013, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3399547, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.99580620305506, "pattern_frame_updates": 464496, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3548147519, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7638.7041416933625, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 59242, "avg_candidate_generations": 2962.1, "candidate_moves_total": 5188022, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.5733769960501, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1549, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 59222, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5186473, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1438605, "avg_legality_checks": 71930.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 237, "root_legality_checks": 1549, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1437056, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 237, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4748107, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 237405.35, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6964318210, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1466.7567959188789, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28485, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1424.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61211426, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2148.900333508864, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1470, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2628931, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11972, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43303739, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15007, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15224786, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 36, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 53970, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 88374, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4418.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 479406722, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5424.748478059158, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 112793, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5639.65, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 186461279, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1653.128110787017, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2310374112, "stage_ordering_ns": 1257018290, "stage_eval_ns": 3551547066, "stage_threat_ns": 5608080287, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1179978, "root_tactical_annotations": 4822, "search_tactical_annotations": 1175156, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 464516, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1838363624, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1086630, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3456104373, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 118579, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2500965747, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 232248, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 248208207, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 464496, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42119712, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 470089, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 118050719, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 497945, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 836881246, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 211944, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23284371, "child_limit_applications": 59222, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 59222, "child_cap_hits": 59222, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 59222, "child_moves_before_total": 5186236, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5186236, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 999351, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 999351, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.57279389416095, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.874658066259162, "tt_hits": 23631, "tt_cutoffs": 3013, "beta_cutoffs": 48248, "depth_sum": 95, "avg_depth": 4.75, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 95, "avg_effective_depth": 4.75, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6026.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6426.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1206, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 24691, "avg_search_time_ms": 1234.55, "search_nodes": 294363, "safety_nodes": 1242, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 295605, "avg_nodes": 14780.25, "eval_calls": 187392, "avg_eval_calls": 9369.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 187392, "pattern_eval_ns": 3801645, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.287125384221312, "pattern_frame_queries": 187392, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3801645, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.287125384221312, "pattern_frame_updates": 588478, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3641930385, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6188.728185250766, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 99135, "avg_candidate_generations": 4956.75, "candidate_moves_total": 8656802, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.32336712563676, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1569, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 99115, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8655233, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 6024351, "avg_legality_checks": 301217.55, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1298, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6024351, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1298, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11150758, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 557537.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15586422828, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1397.7904307491922, "renju_forbidden_checks": 61237, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3061.85, "renju_forbidden_ns": 75543661, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1233.6277250681778, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5083, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10916515, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11050, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33539324, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 45057, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31022791, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 47, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 65031, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 260827, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13041.35, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1476156640, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5659.52389898285, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 342117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17105.85, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 621966795, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1817.9944141916362, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9125186951, "stage_ordering_ns": 2195597122, "stage_eval_ns": 3645732030, "stage_threat_ns": 9485508156, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1893983, "root_tactical_annotations": 4101, "search_tactical_annotations": 1889882, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 588498, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2452289064, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1562292, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6577189570, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 198393, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4170607816, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 294239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 336681722, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 588478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55679241, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 453113, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 628868911, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 910772, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1777563803, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 530098, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 63668559, "child_limit_applications": 99115, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 99115, "child_cap_hits": 99115, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 99115, "child_moves_before_total": 8653935, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8653935, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 939667, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 939667, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.31206174645614, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.480573071684407, "tt_hits": 52063, "tt_cutoffs": 7732, "beta_cutoffs": 81670, "depth_sum": 124, "avg_depth": 6.2, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 124, "avg_effective_depth": 6.2, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4973.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5373.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 482, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1168, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13411, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 71, 85, 93, 95, 140, 123, 81, 97, 83, 124, 121, 139, 153, 154, 169, 94 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10955, "avg_search_time_ms": 912.9166666666666, "search_nodes": 119250, "safety_nodes": 388, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 119638, "avg_nodes": 9969.833333333334, "eval_calls": 87307, "avg_eval_calls": 7275.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87307, "pattern_eval_ns": 1897379, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.732266599470833, "pattern_frame_queries": 87307, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1897379, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.732266599470833, "pattern_frame_updates": 238392, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3241603981, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13597.788436692506, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30291, "avg_candidate_generations": 2524.25, "candidate_moves_total": 2536213, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.72826912284177, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 869, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 30279, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2535344, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 907774, "avg_legality_checks": 75647.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1122, "root_legality_checks": 869, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 906905, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1122, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3127711, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 260642.58333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6564605873, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2098.8530823340134, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26724, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2227.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 142896174, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5347.110237988325, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1301, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10103736, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15293, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 107013244, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10130, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25779194, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83961, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6996.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 703743355, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8381.7886280535, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109677, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9139.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 284278536, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2591.9612680872015, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2134160277, "stage_ordering_ns": 984440435, "stage_eval_ns": 3243501360, "stage_threat_ns": 4540663592, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 418894, "root_tactical_annotations": 2707, "search_tactical_annotations": 416187, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 238404, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1357881271, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 367410, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2966066702, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60635, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1967104354, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 119196, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 173106152, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 238392, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29316565, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 102976, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 194452185, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 203789, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 804188792, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 112129, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14292902, "child_limit_applications": 30279, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30279, "child_cap_hits": 30279, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30279, "child_moves_before_total": 2534222, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2534222, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 287106, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 287106, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.69569668747316, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.482017239671059, "tt_hits": 14293, "tt_cutoffs": 1610, "beta_cutoffs": 21439, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5392.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6059.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1402, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2445, "avg_search_time_ms": 222.27272727272728, "search_nodes": 22536, "safety_nodes": 1229, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 23765, "avg_nodes": 2160.4545454545455, "eval_calls": 15341, "avg_eval_calls": 1394.6363636363637, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 15341, "pattern_eval_ns": 338341, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.05469004628121, "pattern_frame_queries": 15341, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 338341, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.05469004628121, "pattern_frame_updates": 44972, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 479658124, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10665.705861424887, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6882, "avg_candidate_generations": 625.6363636363636, "candidate_moves_total": 542221, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.78828828828829, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 782, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 6871, "search_candidate_moves_total": 541439, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 247962, "avg_legality_checks": 22542.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 117, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 247962, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 117, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 702649, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 63877.181818181816, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1510430762, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2149.623442145367, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2854, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 259.45454545454544, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13648688, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4782.301331464611, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1144122, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1021, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9113107, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1716, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3391459, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21447, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1949.7272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 208947848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9742.521005268802, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 29998, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2727.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 98400684, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3280.2414827655175, "stage_move_gen_ns": 606409512, "stage_ordering_ns": 227168035, "stage_eval_ns": 479996465, "stage_threat_ns": 1106423008, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 100109, "root_tactical_annotations": 321, "search_tactical_annotations": 99788, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 44983, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 280264600, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 94581, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 784997155, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13814, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 491403408, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 22486, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 33519482, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 44972, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5755222, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 21671, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 91700146, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 59088, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 201560449, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 19350, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1886549, "child_limit_applications": 6871, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6871, "child_cap_hits": 6871, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6871, "child_moves_before_total": 541322, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 541322, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 110012, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 110012, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.78358317566584, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.011060980934364, "tt_hits": 2230, "tt_cutoffs": 274, "beta_cutoffs": 5872, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5863.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6590.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1924, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1169, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20664, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 125, 129, 127, 99, 98, 130, 140, 126, 155, 110, 141, 169, 142, 131, 132, 139, 157, 172, 109, 173, 93 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 11122, "avg_search_time_ms": 926.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 134931, "safety_nodes": 155, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 135086, "avg_nodes": 11257.166666666666, "eval_calls": 104188, "avg_eval_calls": 8682.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 104188, "pattern_eval_ns": 2284727, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.928888163704073, "pattern_frame_queries": 104188, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2284727, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.928888163704073, "pattern_frame_updates": 269758, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3155472434, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11697.419294330473, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29285, "avg_candidate_generations": 2440.4166666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2099675, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.69796824312787, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 29273, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2098941, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 807250, "avg_legality_checks": 67270.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 278, "root_legality_checks": 734, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 806516, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 278, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2816889, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 234740.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6457992389, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2292.5973969865336, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17797, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1483.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42826130, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2406.367927178738, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 459, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1678037, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28421990, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9908, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12726103, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68510, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5709.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 561056103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8189.404510290468, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 87414, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7284.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 207187679, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2370.1887455098727, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2045579377, "stage_ordering_ns": 924352102, "stage_eval_ns": 3157757161, "stage_threat_ns": 4944321006, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 400461, "root_tactical_annotations": 2581, "search_tactical_annotations": 397880, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 269770, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1611707667, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 362382, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3085785484, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58621, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2226711448, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134879, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 199666355, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 269758, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35085081, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 103545, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 112910965, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 200206, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 746150951, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 96710, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12076419, "child_limit_applications": 29273, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29273, "child_cap_hits": 29273, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29273, "child_moves_before_total": 2098663, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2098663, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 468588, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 468588, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.69278857650394, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.007515457930516, "tt_hits": 12229, "tt_cutoffs": 1418, "beta_cutoffs": 22444, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4321.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4988.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1016, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9531, "avg_search_time_ms": 866.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 80875, "safety_nodes": 810, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 81685, "avg_nodes": 7425.909090909091, "eval_calls": 49738, "avg_eval_calls": 4521.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49738, "pattern_eval_ns": 1112367, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.364530137922713, "pattern_frame_queries": 49738, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1112367, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.364530137922713, "pattern_frame_updates": 161624, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1518254569, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9393.74454907687, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29089, "avg_candidate_generations": 2644.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 2079628, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.49190415621025, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 668, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 29078, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2078960, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 1171286, "avg_legality_checks": 106480.54545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 45, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1171286, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 45, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2686308, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 244209.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6138268705, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2285.0204462779398, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7730, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 702.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 11045775, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1428.9489003880983, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 55, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 144740, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1485, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 5945567, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6190, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4955468, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59049, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5368.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 505037542, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8552.855120323798, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 77250, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7022.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 195033688, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2524.707935275081, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2969062093, "stage_ordering_ns": 924147871, "stage_eval_ns": 1519366936, "stage_threat_ns": 4057480598, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 340207, "root_tactical_annotations": 1159, "search_tactical_annotations": 339048, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 161635, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 976208123, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 305660, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2927508751, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58241, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2150429202, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 80812, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121820440, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 161624, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20898385, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 61081, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 165293346, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 186330, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 611574131, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 92796, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11044899, "child_limit_applications": 29078, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29078, "child_cap_hits": 29078, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29078, "child_moves_before_total": 2078915, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2078915, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 254931, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 254931, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.49442877777014, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.767143544948071, "tt_hits": 13108, "tt_cutoffs": 1996, "beta_cutoffs": 22380, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3248.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3976.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 366, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1170, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 44776, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 83, 125, 126, 140, 115, 116, 99, 139, 153, 131, 129, 84, 101, 143, 100, 141, 142, 138, 137, 98, 110, 158, 87, 73, 103, 102, 51, 67, 94, 78, 157, 173, 188, 159, 127, 172, 71, 85, 55, 39, 119 ], "move_count": 47, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 34588, "avg_search_time_ms": 1572.1818181818182, "search_nodes": 345629, "safety_nodes": 1179, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 346808, "avg_nodes": 15764.0, "eval_calls": 227579, "avg_eval_calls": 10344.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 227579, "pattern_eval_ns": 4992059, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.935499321114865, "pattern_frame_queries": 227579, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4992059, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.935499321114865, "pattern_frame_updates": 691026, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8901442727, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12881.487421602082, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 109848, "avg_candidate_generations": 4993.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 10466808, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.28446580729735, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1918, "root_candidate_moves_max": 127, "search_candidate_generations": 109826, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10464890, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 2376346, "avg_legality_checks": 108015.72727272728, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10191, "root_legality_checks": 1918, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "search_legality_checks": 2374428, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10176, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8921272, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 405512.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19517664714, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2187.76702627159, "renju_forbidden_checks": 77743, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3533.7727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 519045559, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6676.428218617753, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11191, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 125018426, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 36995, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 276464658, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29479, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 116684458, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 78, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 878017, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 228407, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10382.136363636364, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2065136527, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9041.476517794988, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 315201, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14327.318181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 912461902, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2894.8572561635274, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5931213212, "stage_ordering_ns": 4035431808, "stage_eval_ns": 8906434786, "stage_threat_ns": 15605400853, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2526595, "root_tactical_annotations": 7026, "search_tactical_annotations": 2519569, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 691048, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4089774551, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1868888, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10758224577, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 219811, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7314641045, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 345513, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 541123256, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 691026, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 89732336, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 733087, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 747947988, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 915973, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2695301543, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 877535, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 126546133, "child_limit_applications": 109826, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 109826, "child_cap_hits": 109826, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 109826, "child_moves_before_total": 10454714, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10454714, "child_moves_before_max": 135, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 135, "child_moves_after_total": 1280951, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1280951, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.19343324895745, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.66345856172491, "tt_hits": 66438, "tt_cutoffs": 8108, "beta_cutoffs": 89498, "depth_sum": 114, "avg_depth": 5.181818181818182, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 114, "avg_effective_depth": 5.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2959.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3322.6363636363635, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 10166, "avg_search_time_ms": 484.0952380952381, "search_nodes": 76158, "safety_nodes": 2144, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 78302, "avg_nodes": 3728.6666666666665, "eval_calls": 50610, "avg_eval_calls": 2410.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50610, "pattern_eval_ns": 1124416, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.21726931436475, "pattern_frame_queries": 50610, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1124416, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.21726931436475, "pattern_frame_updates": 152116, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1567329652, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10303.516079833811, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23895, "avg_candidate_generations": 1137.857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 2348244, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.27344632768362, "candidate_moves_max": 138, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1834, "root_candidate_moves_max": 123, "search_candidate_generations": 23874, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2346410, "search_candidate_moves_max": 138, "legality_checks": 1524106, "avg_legality_checks": 72576.47619047618, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3947, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1524106, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3947, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3128264, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 148964.95238095237, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6548892024, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2093.4588717576266, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32478, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1546.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_ns": 129040106, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3973.1543198472814, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4089, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 46564644, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4952, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44609236, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23362, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36968463, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 75, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 897763, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 107275, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5108.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1009327622, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9408.78696807271, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 157432, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7496.761904761905, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 474358730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3013.102355302607, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3596925849, "stage_ordering_ns": 907322798, "stage_eval_ns": 1568454068, "stage_threat_ns": 4011514383, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 513652, "root_tactical_annotations": 1856, "search_tactical_annotations": 511796, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152137, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 941614067, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 462887, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2916643781, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47890, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1554667221, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76058, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 120069371, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19768468, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 186108, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 455452178, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 228876, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 906051640, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 98668, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13418696, "child_limit_applications": 23874, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23874, "child_cap_hits": 23874, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23874, "child_moves_before_total": 2342463, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2342463, "child_moves_before_max": 138, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 138, "child_moves_after_total": 383913, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 383913, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 98.11774315154561, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.080799195777832, "tt_hits": 10170, "tt_cutoffs": 1574, "beta_cutoffs": 20617, "depth_sum": 100, "avg_depth": 4.761904761904762, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 100, "avg_effective_depth": 4.761904761904762, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09523809523809523, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6680.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7061.619047619048, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1871, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1171, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 39075, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 97, 127, 128, 141, 155, 156, 111, 99, 85, 171, 186, 125, 96, 144, 95, 94, 109, 114, 129, 123, 124, 108, 81, 138, 67, 53, 80, 64, 82, 52, 79, 78, 83 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 14752, "avg_search_time_ms": 867.7647058823529, "search_nodes": 148408, "safety_nodes": 1417, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 149825, "avg_nodes": 8813.235294117647, "eval_calls": 107792, "avg_eval_calls": 6340.705882352941, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107792, "pattern_eval_ns": 2371119, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.997170476473208, "pattern_frame_queries": 107792, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2371119, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.997170476473208, "pattern_frame_updates": 296662, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4002246894, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13490.932084324922, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38150, "avg_candidate_generations": 2244.1176470588234, "candidate_moves_total": 3253117, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.27174311926605, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1273, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 38133, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3251844, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1261516, "avg_legality_checks": 74206.82352941176, "illegal_moves_skipped": 489, "root_legality_checks": 1273, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1260243, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 489, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3897360, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 229256.4705882353, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8935946859, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2292.8204884845127, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22278, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1310.4705882352941, "renju_forbidden_ns": 85546350, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3839.9474818206304, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5230596, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10138, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 61613543, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11392, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18654410, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 47801, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 84420, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4965.882352941177, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 755374577, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8947.815411040037, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 114071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6710.058823529412, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 311855423, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2733.8712117891487, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3131158032, "stage_ordering_ns": 1371532276, "stage_eval_ns": 4004618013, "stage_threat_ns": 6179969148, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 567974, "root_tactical_annotations": 2200, "search_tactical_annotations": 565774, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 296679, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1791465627, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 547838, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4110728486, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 76376, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2858326225, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148331, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 225006926, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 296662, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38505458, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 142131, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 94006359, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 329318, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1157783909, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 96525, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14262651, "child_limit_applications": 38133, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38133, "child_cap_hits": 38133, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38133, "child_moves_before_total": 3251355, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3251355, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 610136, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 610136, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.26355125481867, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000209792043638, "tt_hits": 13153, "tt_cutoffs": 2407, "beta_cutoffs": 31100, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 4.470588235294118, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 4.470588235294118, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5637.058823529412, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6107.64705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 24305, "avg_search_time_ms": 1519.0625, "search_nodes": 157625, "safety_nodes": 772, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 158397, "avg_nodes": 9899.8125, "eval_calls": 94065, "avg_eval_calls": 5879.0625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 94065, "pattern_eval_ns": 2115749, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.49241481953968, "pattern_frame_queries": 94065, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2115749, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.49241481953968, "pattern_frame_updates": 315068, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3642815276, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11561.997016517069, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 59631, "avg_candidate_generations": 3726.9375, "candidate_moves_total": 5228134, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.67476648052188, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1202, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 59615, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5226932, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 3567390, "avg_legality_checks": 222961.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1151, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3567390, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1151, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7439423, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 464963.9375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16236352976, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2182.474766658651, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38010, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2375.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 70303468, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1849.604525124967, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1248, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12310152, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4658, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30259043, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32083, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27698193, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 36080, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 233500, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14593.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2235040433, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9571.907635974305, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 328246, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20515.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1012459235, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3084.4526209001783, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8673440036, "stage_ordering_ns": 2185279726, "stage_eval_ns": 3644931025, "stage_threat_ns": 9658953115, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1159283, "root_tactical_annotations": 3932, "search_tactical_annotations": 1155351, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 315084, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1930025421, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1038450, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7406972517, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 119353, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4148071695, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 157534, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 246167996, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 315068, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41489185, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 252368, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 561283171, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 666717, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2697459330, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 240198, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 34297996, "child_limit_applications": 59615, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 59615, "child_cap_hits": 59615, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 59615, "child_moves_before_total": 5225781, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5225781, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 530134, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 530134, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.6588274763063, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.892627694372221, "tt_hits": 24168, "tt_cutoffs": 3858, "beta_cutoffs": 47526, "depth_sum": 85, "avg_depth": 5.3125, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 85, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3125, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1750.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2236.3125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1172, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 55298, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 129, 171, 143, 141, 111, 95, 115, 101, 159, 175, 144, 174, 172, 157, 186, 158, 96, 128, 173, 131, 187, 201, 188, 185, 156, 140, 114, 99, 146, 145, 98, 130, 190, 189, 204, 220, 176, 162, 82, 170, 66, 50, 155, 161, 203, 169, 153, 154, 81, 51, 68, 168, 167, 182 ], "move_count": 60, "black_stats": { "move_count": 30, "search_move_count": 28, "total_time_ms": 40979, "avg_search_time_ms": 1463.5357142857142, "search_nodes": 421060, "safety_nodes": 939, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 421999, "avg_nodes": 15071.392857142857, "eval_calls": 259504, "avg_eval_calls": 9268.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 259504, "pattern_eval_ns": 5749438, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.155488932733213, "pattern_frame_queries": 259504, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5749438, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.155488932733213, "pattern_frame_updates": 841772, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 9256948290, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10996.97814847726, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 151098, "avg_candidate_generations": 5396.357142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 13106777, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.74355054335597, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 28, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2220, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 151070, "search_candidate_moves_total": 13104557, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 3915780, "avg_legality_checks": 139849.2857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1782, "root_legality_checks": 2220, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3913560, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1782, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11438750, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 408526.78571428574, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23772704457, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2078.2606890613047, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65500, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2339.285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 218853625, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3341.2767175572517, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2856, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15967815, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28195, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 137023303, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 34448, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 65860967, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1540, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 229955, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8212.67857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1749181055, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7606.62327411885, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 300685, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10738.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 705500181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2346.309862480669, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8627331034, "stage_ordering_ns": 4763400954, "stage_eval_ns": 9262697728, "stage_threat_ns": 18128667900, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 3678345, "root_tactical_annotations": 10772, "search_tactical_annotations": 3667573, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 841800, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4589482876, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2906659, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 12673384846, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 302370, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9047110939, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 420886, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 631474509, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 841772, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 104401490, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1312968, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 576723556, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1291294, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3049136738, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1074083, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 129924179, "child_limit_applications": 151070, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 151070, "child_cap_hits": 151070, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 151070, "child_moves_before_total": 13102775, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 13102775, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 1543739, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1543739, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.73313695637783, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.218699940424969, "tt_hits": 84676, "tt_cutoffs": 10313, "beta_cutoffs": 119853, "depth_sum": 172, "avg_depth": 6.142857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 172, "avg_effective_depth": 6.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 28, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4378.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4664.214285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 30, "search_move_count": 28, "total_time_ms": 14290, "avg_search_time_ms": 510.35714285714283, "search_nodes": 138359, "safety_nodes": 2575, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 140934, "avg_nodes": 5033.357142857143, "eval_calls": 92031, "avg_eval_calls": 3286.8214285714284, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 92031, "pattern_eval_ns": 1991830, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.6430333257272, "pattern_frame_queries": 92031, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1991830, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.6430333257272, "pattern_frame_updates": 276450, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2330921034, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8431.618860553446, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43289, "avg_candidate_generations": 1546.0357142857142, "candidate_moves_total": 3812840, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.0787266973134, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 28, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2247, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 43261, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3810593, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 2440163, "avg_legality_checks": 87148.67857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 435, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2440163, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 435, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5049727, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 180347.39285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8947518638, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1771.8816557805997, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27366, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 977.3571428571429, "renju_forbidden_ns": 56855734, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2077.6048381202954, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1267, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9138255, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2867, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20240913, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23212, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27456316, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 20250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 154315, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5511.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1251581064, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8110.559984447396, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 219197, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7828.464285714285, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 592197955, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2701.669981797196, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4595278365, "stage_ordering_ns": 1246367742, "stage_eval_ns": 2332912864, "stage_threat_ns": 5993846356, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1029391, "root_tactical_annotations": 3058, "search_tactical_annotations": 1026333, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 276478, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1451839740, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 949629, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4294822359, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 86711, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2446732961, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 138225, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 194839829, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 276450, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32553437, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 436175, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 588204012, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 426724, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1259366053, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 166492, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19790991, "child_limit_applications": 43261, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43261, "child_cap_hits": 43261, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43261, "child_moves_before_total": 3810158, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3810158, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 692696, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 692696, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.07373847114029, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01202006426111, "tt_hits": 17163, "tt_cutoffs": 2933, "beta_cutoffs": 37313, "depth_sum": 134, "avg_depth": 4.785714285714286, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 134, "avg_effective_depth": 4.785714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 26 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 28, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6843.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7129.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1619, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1173, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22298, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 127, 97, 96, 125, 83, 110, 84, 81, 80, 64, 129, 139, 153, 130, 99, 114, 85, 86, 113, 141, 71 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9728, "avg_search_time_ms": 884.3636363636364, "search_nodes": 111884, "safety_nodes": 260, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 112144, "avg_nodes": 10194.90909090909, "eval_calls": 83049, "avg_eval_calls": 7549.909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83049, "pattern_eval_ns": 1830824, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.045105901335358, "pattern_frame_queries": 83049, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1830824, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.045105901335358, "pattern_frame_updates": 223674, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2607335851, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11656.857082182105, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26906, "avg_candidate_generations": 2446.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2059349, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.53865308853044, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 26895, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2058627, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 747152, "avg_legality_checks": 67922.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1073, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 746430, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1072, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2459961, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 223632.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5668245070, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2304.201192620533, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21541, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1958.2727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 96924411, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4499.531637342741, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1192, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9900625, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10963, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 66910872, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9381, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20049274, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 63640, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 57436, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5221.454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 509832825, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8876.537798593217, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76678, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6970.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 201803973, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2631.836680664597, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1911516052, "stage_ordering_ns": 867919492, "stage_eval_ns": 2609166675, "stage_threat_ns": 4293882870, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 352342, "root_tactical_annotations": 2196, "search_tactical_annotations": 350146, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 223685, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1337559066, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 325951, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2750593152, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53858, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1975365333, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111837, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 168162702, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 223674, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28174862, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96460, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 109485301, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 175624, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 665594747, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 80258, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9393088, "child_limit_applications": 26895, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26895, "child_cap_hits": 26895, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26895, "child_moves_before_total": 2057555, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2057555, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 430413, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 430413, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.50325339282395, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00345789180145, "tt_hits": 10630, "tt_cutoffs": 1893, "beta_cutoffs": 21568, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4398.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5125.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 12560, "avg_search_time_ms": 1256.0, "search_nodes": 91860, "safety_nodes": 639, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92499, "avg_nodes": 9249.9, "eval_calls": 56221, "avg_eval_calls": 5622.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 56221, "pattern_eval_ns": 1274093, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.66222585866491, "pattern_frame_queries": 56221, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1274093, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.66222585866491, "pattern_frame_updates": 183610, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1939488834, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10563.089341539131, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33356, "avg_candidate_generations": 3335.6, "candidate_moves_total": 2666593, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.94342846864133, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 653, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 33346, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2665940, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1823368, "avg_legality_checks": 182336.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10139, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1823368, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10139, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3794969, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 379496.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8207331693, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2162.6874140473874, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44003, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4400.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 224236780, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5095.943003886098, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10191, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 99561233, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11442, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 81221309, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22360, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43384638, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 69600, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 102243, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10224.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 919810071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8996.313400428391, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 147256, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14725.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 403093866, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2737.3680257510728, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4480434816, "stage_ordering_ns": 1079733391, "stage_eval_ns": 1940762927, "stage_threat_ns": 4985918403, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 511683, "root_tactical_annotations": 1697, "search_tactical_annotations": 509986, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 183620, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1110926398, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 428479, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3688107225, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 66767, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2370353239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91805, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 143003902, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 183610, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23332814, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96044, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 282253688, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 265660, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1035343748, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 149979, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20548064, "child_limit_applications": 33346, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33346, "child_cap_hits": 33346, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33346, "child_moves_before_total": 2655801, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2655801, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 290321, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 290321, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.64376536915972, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.706321597792838, "tt_hits": 15907, "tt_cutoffs": 2239, "beta_cutoffs": 25989, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2775.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3523.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1321, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1174, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25115, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 96, 128, 68, 110, 97, 127, 67, 52, 66, 65, 54, 40, 69, 70, 84, 99, 85, 83, 95, 143, 113, 159, 175, 129, 39, 24, 53, 81, 101, 37, 117 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 17176, "avg_search_time_ms": 1073.5, "search_nodes": 177031, "safety_nodes": 775, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 177806, "avg_nodes": 11112.875, "eval_calls": 111522, "avg_eval_calls": 6970.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 111522, "pattern_eval_ns": 2434893, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.83329746597084, "pattern_frame_queries": 111522, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2434893, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.83329746597084, "pattern_frame_updates": 353910, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4316938155, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12197.84169704162, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 61179, "avg_candidate_generations": 3823.6875, "candidate_moves_total": 4627130, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.63265172689975, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1132, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 61163, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4625998, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1308184, "avg_legality_checks": 81761.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1158, "root_legality_checks": 1132, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1307052, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1155, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4663900, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 291493.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10080196884, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2161.3235455305644, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38887, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2430.4375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 163515920, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4204.899323681436, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1889, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11955377, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17900, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 105040925, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19077, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 46367177, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 152441, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 84993, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5312.0625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 688087391, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8095.812490440389, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110075, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6879.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 273650704, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2486.03864637747, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3130062353, "stage_ordering_ns": 1737672409, "stage_eval_ns": 4319373048, "stage_threat_ns": 7916277487, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1102575, "root_tactical_annotations": 3214, "search_tactical_annotations": 1099361, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 353926, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2088860977, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 829046, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5459362944, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 122433, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4081929079, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 176955, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 264934385, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 353910, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44180438, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 217425, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 117695222, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 489175, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1259438673, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 395975, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 58938743, "child_limit_applications": 61163, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 61163, "child_cap_hits": 61163, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 61163, "child_moves_before_total": 4624843, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4624843, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 661854, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 661854, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.6150450435721, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.821150041691872, "tt_hits": 33404, "tt_cutoffs": 4271, "beta_cutoffs": 46936, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3469.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3969.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 7927, "avg_search_time_ms": 528.4666666666667, "search_nodes": 65568, "safety_nodes": 1081, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 66649, "avg_nodes": 4443.266666666666, "eval_calls": 43728, "avg_eval_calls": 2915.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 43728, "pattern_eval_ns": 973334, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.25882729601171, "pattern_frame_queries": 43728, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 973334, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.25882729601171, "pattern_frame_updates": 130996, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1278412830, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9759.174554948242, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20187, "avg_candidate_generations": 1345.8, "candidate_moves_total": 1584445, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.48838361321643, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1059, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 20172, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1583386, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 1147690, "avg_legality_checks": 76512.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5191, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1147690, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5191, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2601048, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 173403.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5150303629, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1980.0878834223743, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28962, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1930.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 102966262, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3555.2193218700368, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 46863693, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3617, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26402273, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20113, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29550276, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 150020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 103732, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6915.466666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 949829048, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9156.567385184899, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 143935, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9595.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 447052047, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3105.9300864973775, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2617888063, "stage_ordering_ns": 584340370, "stage_eval_ns": 1279386164, "stage_threat_ns": 3380846089, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 434468, "root_tactical_annotations": 1486, "search_tactical_annotations": 432982, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 131011, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 769797277, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 392254, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2489062168, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40444, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1254765572, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 65498, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94834715, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 130996, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15975549, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 157978, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 454770463, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 193823, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 779311623, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 82667, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11176380, "child_limit_applications": 20172, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20172, "child_cap_hits": 20172, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20172, "child_moves_before_total": 1578195, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1578195, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 323068, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 323068, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.23691255205235, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.015665278604004, "tt_hits": 7998, "tt_cutoffs": 1599, "beta_cutoffs": 17349, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6036.266666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6569.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1175, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12570, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 114, 126, 113, 111, 82, 66, 97, 127, 115, 116, 130, 146, 67, 52, 129, 125, 124, 81, 145, 96 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7350, "avg_search_time_ms": 735.0, "search_nodes": 79960, "safety_nodes": 597, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 80557, "avg_nodes": 8055.7, "eval_calls": 61875, "avg_eval_calls": 6187.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 61875, "pattern_eval_ns": 1285978, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.78348282828283, "pattern_frame_queries": 61875, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1285978, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.78348282828283, "pattern_frame_updates": 159828, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2285380479, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14298.999418124484, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17033, "avg_candidate_generations": 1703.3, "candidate_moves_total": 1162919, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.27446721070862, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 630, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 17023, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1162289, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 515246, "avg_legality_checks": 51524.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2376, "root_legality_checks": 630, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 514616, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2368, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1959279, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 195927.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4337147585, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2213.64470552688, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26891, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2689.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 230777058, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8581.944070506861, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2870, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 35694583, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14147, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 144472387, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9820, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 49856926, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 54, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 753162, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58256, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5825.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 569697351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9779.204734276298, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81722, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8172.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 260903414, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3192.5725508431024, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1307581861, "stage_ordering_ns": 496761487, "stage_eval_ns": 2286666457, "stage_threat_ns": 3230876223, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 257399, "root_tactical_annotations": 1277, "search_tactical_annotations": 256122, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 159838, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 951767501, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 240790, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2136212069, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34112, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1352645357, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79914, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 116593808, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 159828, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20173251, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 60829, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 102033017, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 145840, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 680974551, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 50730, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6129594, "child_limit_applications": 17023, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17023, "child_cap_hits": 17023, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17023, "child_moves_before_total": 1159921, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1159921, "child_moves_before_max": 96, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 96, "child_moves_after_total": 274682, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 274682, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.13845973095223, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.13593373670916, "tt_hits": 6425, "tt_cutoffs": 1016, "beta_cutoffs": 12983, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3709.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4509.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 348, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5208, "avg_search_time_ms": 520.8, "search_nodes": 38079, "safety_nodes": 905, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 38984, "avg_nodes": 3898.4, "eval_calls": 22803, "avg_eval_calls": 2280.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22803, "pattern_eval_ns": 488292, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.413498223917905, "pattern_frame_queries": 22803, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 488292, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.413498223917905, "pattern_frame_updates": 76058, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 993210982, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13058.599779115937, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13914, "avg_candidate_generations": 1391.4, "candidate_moves_total": 989623, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.12426333189593, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 644, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 13904, "search_candidate_moves_total": 988979, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 535341, "avg_legality_checks": 53534.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2633, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 535341, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2633, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1543549, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 154354.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3246402685, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2103.206755988958, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22329, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2232.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 188027440, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8420.772985803216, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3401, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 45380152, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7583, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 84974385, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11281, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 56763339, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 64, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 909564, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58680, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5868.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 605301650, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10315.297375596456, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 83141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8314.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 289366384, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3480.429439145548, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1337395524, "stage_ordering_ns": 406741067, "stage_eval_ns": 993699274, "stage_threat_ns": 2439965402, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 270622, "root_tactical_annotations": 367, "search_tactical_annotations": 270255, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 76068, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 468534821, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 237269, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1898652385, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27877, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1050060446, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38029, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 57137168, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 76058, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9782542, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 35125, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 118764445, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 174261, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 729574733, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 61236, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5858486, "child_limit_applications": 13904, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13904, "child_cap_hits": 13904, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13904, "child_moves_before_total": 986346, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 986346, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 170381, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 170381, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.93972957422325, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.254099539700805, "tt_hits": 6085, "tt_cutoffs": 1323, "beta_cutoffs": 11533, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.9, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.9, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4534.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5334.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1176, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24636, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 126, 114, 110, 158, 94, 78, 125, 129, 99, 82, 66, 130, 146, 70, 56, 144, 124, 127, 122, 123, 80, 108, 95, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 17352, "avg_search_time_ms": 1334.7692307692307, "search_nodes": 147489, "safety_nodes": 787, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148276, "avg_nodes": 11405.846153846154, "eval_calls": 85444, "avg_eval_calls": 6572.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 85444, "pattern_eval_ns": 1807879, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.158641917513226, "pattern_frame_queries": 85444, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1807879, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.158641917513226, "pattern_frame_updates": 294826, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4117771178, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13966.784401647074, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 56755, "avg_candidate_generations": 4365.7692307692305, "candidate_moves_total": 5303324, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.44241036032068, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1110, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 56742, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5302214, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 1266301, "avg_legality_checks": 97407.76923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1198, "root_legality_checks": 1110, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1265191, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1198, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4585258, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 352712.1538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10126458485, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2208.4817222934894, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58726, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4517.384615384615, "renju_forbidden_ns": 425772998, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7250.161734155229, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11617335, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29206, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 267839517, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28185, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 146316146, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 110710, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8516.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1071611880, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9679.449733538073, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 155139, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11933.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 505848615, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3260.6154158528802, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3075401706, "stage_ordering_ns": 2033330521, "stage_eval_ns": 4119579057, "stage_threat_ns": 8065930656, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1140117, "root_tactical_annotations": 3208, "search_tactical_annotations": 1136909, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 294839, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1784486860, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 766388, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5954018663, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 113586, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4256478997, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147413, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 222265236, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 294826, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37536680, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 212119, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 338019136, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 440675, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1359223729, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 487323, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 67623217, "child_limit_applications": 56742, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 56742, "child_cap_hits": 56742, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 56742, "child_moves_before_total": 5301016, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5301016, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 678510, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 678510, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.42314335060449, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.95780903034789, "tt_hits": 36971, "tt_cutoffs": 5228, "beta_cutoffs": 48167, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 5.769230769230769, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 5.769230769230769, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2476.4615384615386, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3091.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7270, "avg_search_time_ms": 559.2307692307693, "search_nodes": 51922, "safety_nodes": 1563, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53485, "avg_nodes": 4114.2307692307695, "eval_calls": 34869, "avg_eval_calls": 2682.230769230769, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34869, "pattern_eval_ns": 737241, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.143164415383293, "pattern_frame_queries": 34869, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 737241, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.143164415383293, "pattern_frame_updates": 103730, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1080561852, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10417.062103538032, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15943, "avg_candidate_generations": 1226.3846153846155, "candidate_moves_total": 1432082, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.82512701499091, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1138, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 15930, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1430944, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1034285, "avg_legality_checks": 79560.38461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 106, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1034285, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 106, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2357391, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 181337.76923076922, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4926369864, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2089.755099599515, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7153, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 550.2307692307693, "renju_forbidden_ns": 25264313, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3531.988396477003, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 106, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 768481, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2002, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17589804, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5045, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6906028, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99907, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7685.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1040077937, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10410.461098821905, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 148369, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11413.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 521071798, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3511.9991238061857, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2484743503, "stage_ordering_ns": 579171194, "stage_eval_ns": 1081299093, "stage_threat_ns": 3073233844, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 281196, "root_tactical_annotations": 1136, "search_tactical_annotations": 280060, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 103743, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 612084594, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 260877, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2365796063, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31942, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1103207979, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51865, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 76067344, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 103730, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12602898, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 81104, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 517941461, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 147821, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 744329362, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 52271, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6682945, "child_limit_applications": 15930, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15930, "child_cap_hits": 15930, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15930, "child_moves_before_total": 1430838, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1430838, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 255314, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 255314, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.82033898305085, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02724419334589, "tt_hits": 6316, "tt_cutoffs": 1066, "beta_cutoffs": 13668, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5063.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5678.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1848, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1177, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28591, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 142, 96, 114, 156, 127, 157, 113, 115, 98, 141, 111, 171, 186, 143, 129, 82, 68, 83, 81, 124, 138, 97, 154, 122, 130, 131, 100, 86, 146, 162, 170, 202, 99, 125, 123, 109, 93, 173 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 12004, "avg_search_time_ms": 631.7894736842105, "search_nodes": 116692, "safety_nodes": 1473, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 118165, "avg_nodes": 6219.210526315789, "eval_calls": 82314, "avg_eval_calls": 4332.315789473684, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82314, "pattern_eval_ns": 1822744, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.143790849673202, "pattern_frame_queries": 82314, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1822744, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.143790849673202, "pattern_frame_updates": 233204, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3171097833, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13597.956437282379, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32293, "avg_candidate_generations": 1699.6315789473683, "candidate_moves_total": 2625594, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.30536029480074, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1526, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 32274, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2624068, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 888945, "avg_legality_checks": 46786.57894736842, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1222, "root_legality_checks": 1526, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 887419, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1219, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3141035, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 165317.63157894736, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7095517104, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2258.974224738024, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29908, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1574.1052631578948, "renju_forbidden_ns": 170998554, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5717.48542196068, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13198914, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12459, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 114852029, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16100, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42777839, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 169772, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98515, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5185.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 879906288, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8931.69860427346, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 131714, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6932.315789473684, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 358715730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2723.4442048681235, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2226087285, "stage_ordering_ns": 1083457287, "stage_eval_ns": 3172920577, "stage_threat_ns": 5464455030, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 728463, "root_tactical_annotations": 2831, "search_tactical_annotations": 725632, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 233223, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1439797959, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 624185, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3793438472, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64676, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2444781637, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 116602, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 180331735, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 233204, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30691768, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 252517, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 240062500, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 306979, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1108082493, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 168967, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20195096, "child_limit_applications": 32274, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32274, "child_cap_hits": 32274, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32274, "child_moves_before_total": 2622849, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2622849, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 535465, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 535465, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.26817252277375, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.591218937844705, "tt_hits": 14637, "tt_cutoffs": 2014, "beta_cutoffs": 26957, "depth_sum": 90, "avg_depth": 4.7368421052631575, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 90, "avg_effective_depth": 4.7368421052631575, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5828.263157894737, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6249.315789473684, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 285, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 16568, "avg_search_time_ms": 872.0, "search_nodes": 114841, "safety_nodes": 2252, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 117093, "avg_nodes": 6162.789473684211, "eval_calls": 67048, "avg_eval_calls": 3528.842105263158, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67048, "pattern_eval_ns": 1503550, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.42497911943682, "pattern_frame_queries": 67048, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1503550, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.42497911943682, "pattern_frame_updates": 229454, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2738477852, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11934.7575200258, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42381, "avg_candidate_generations": 2230.5789473684213, "candidate_moves_total": 3548347, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.72494750005899, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1553, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 42362, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3546794, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 2112178, "avg_legality_checks": 111167.26315789473, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4496, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2112178, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4496, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4975177, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 261851.42105263157, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10662142253, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2143.0679256235508, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55712, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2932.2105263157896, "renju_forbidden_ns": 163245654, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2930.1704121194716, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4622, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30954972, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9419, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72052588, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 41656, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 60064724, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 173370, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 198859, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10466.263157894737, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1754260488, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8821.629838227085, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 268602, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14136.947368421053, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 711785797, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2649.964620516601, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5119276451, "stage_ordering_ns": 1445686157, "stage_eval_ns": 2739981402, "stage_threat_ns": 7167121894, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1047222, "root_tactical_annotations": 1077, "search_tactical_annotations": 1046145, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 229473, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1420666640, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 845232, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5498879142, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 84875, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2938533376, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 114727, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 182361473, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 229454, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30484061, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 223589, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 631405262, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 536755, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1928453701, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 286878, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 34730578, "child_limit_applications": 42362, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42362, "child_cap_hits": 42362, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42362, "child_moves_before_total": 3542298, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3542298, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 559440, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 559440, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.61970634058827, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.20617534582881, "tt_hits": 22809, "tt_cutoffs": 5318, "beta_cutoffs": 36331, "depth_sum": 113, "avg_depth": 5.947368421052632, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 113, "avg_effective_depth": 5.947368421052632, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.10526315789473684, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5868.0526315789475, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6289.105263157895, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1178, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32080, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 142, 125, 95, 97, 114, 156, 111, 127, 113, 115, 98, 124, 123, 143, 82, 66, 109, 81, 144, 160, 129, 159, 68, 83, 100, 86, 84, 99, 116, 52, 132 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 25128, "avg_search_time_ms": 1478.1176470588234, "search_nodes": 244842, "safety_nodes": 440, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 245282, "avg_nodes": 14428.35294117647, "eval_calls": 157871, "avg_eval_calls": 9286.529411764706, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 157871, "pattern_eval_ns": 3443540, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.812365792324112, "pattern_frame_queries": 157871, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3443540, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.812365792324112, "pattern_frame_updates": 489522, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6522924082, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13325.088723285164, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 81532, "avg_candidate_generations": 4796.0, "candidate_moves_total": 6805828, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.47431683265467, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1204, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 81515, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6804624, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1705482, "avg_legality_checks": 100322.4705882353, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1167, "root_legality_checks": 1204, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1704278, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1167, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6485542, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 381502.4705882353, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14575241021, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2247.343556020453, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38716, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2277.4117647058824, "renju_forbidden_ns": 152234880, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3932.092158280814, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1499, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10538518, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20058, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 101869354, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17159, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39827008, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 150752, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8867.764705882353, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1163393679, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7717.268619985141, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 181812, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10694.823529411764, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 382188919, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2102.1105262578926, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4248039265, "stage_ordering_ns": 2793677131, "stage_eval_ns": 6526367622, "stage_threat_ns": 11479556110, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1882589, "root_tactical_annotations": 4832, "search_tactical_annotations": 1877757, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 489539, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2941013485, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1465125, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8016660912, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 163144, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5716692595, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 244761, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 378006193, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 489522, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63514438, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 527335, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 370171289, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 774631, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1929563777, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 580623, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 80361082, "child_limit_applications": 81515, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 81515, "child_cap_hits": 81515, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 81515, "child_moves_before_total": 6803457, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6803457, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 867686, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 867686, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.462638778139, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.644494878243268, "tt_hits": 43300, "tt_cutoffs": 5377, "beta_cutoffs": 64178, "depth_sum": 79, "avg_depth": 4.647058823529412, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 79, "avg_effective_depth": 4.647058823529412, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2156.8823529411766, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2627.470588235294, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 137, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 6935, "avg_search_time_ms": 433.4375, "search_nodes": 57313, "safety_nodes": 1421, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 58734, "avg_nodes": 3670.875, "eval_calls": 38136, "avg_eval_calls": 2383.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38136, "pattern_eval_ns": 834082, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.871250262219426, "pattern_frame_queries": 38136, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 834082, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.871250262219426, "pattern_frame_updates": 114476, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1218443715, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10643.660810999685, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18001, "avg_candidate_generations": 1125.0625, "candidate_moves_total": 1387490, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.07849563913116, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1130, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 17985, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1386360, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 759845, "avg_legality_checks": 47490.3125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1961, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 759845, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1961, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1972999, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 123312.4375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4397127235, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2228.6515274462886, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10702, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 668.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62721837, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5860.758456363296, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1963, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21524260, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3012, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29417856, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5722, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11718651, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61070, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74040, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4627.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 701765345, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9478.192125877904, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97221, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6076.3125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 302769988, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3114.2447413624627, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1954067427, "stage_ordering_ns": 598529562, "stage_eval_ns": 1219277797, "stage_threat_ns": 3114819680, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 328135, "root_tactical_annotations": 966, "search_tactical_annotations": 327169, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 114492, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 712611900, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 307400, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2292364963, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36077, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1333744966, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57238, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88144280, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 114476, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14805053, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 100002, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 359369289, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171311, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 598912495, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 56822, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6893484, "child_limit_applications": 17985, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17985, "child_cap_hits": 17985, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17985, "child_moves_before_total": 1384399, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1384399, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 288292, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 288292, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.97520155685294, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.029580205726994, "tt_hits": 6269, "tt_cutoffs": 1117, "beta_cutoffs": 15492, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5895.8125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6395.8125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1711, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1179, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20200, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 81, 68, 111, 113, 94, 54, 40, 78, 140, 154, 125, 95, 127, 85, 86, 128, 142, 158, 157, 172, 97 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 10476, "avg_search_time_ms": 805.8461538461538, "search_nodes": 129740, "safety_nodes": 369, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 130109, "avg_nodes": 10008.384615384615, "eval_calls": 96583, "avg_eval_calls": 7429.461538461538, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 96583, "pattern_eval_ns": 2031500, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.033722290672273, "pattern_frame_queries": 96583, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2031500, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.033722290672273, "pattern_frame_updates": 259366, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2876572523, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11090.784925549224, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31306, "avg_candidate_generations": 2408.153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 2705939, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.43515620008944, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 991, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 31293, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2704948, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 876409, "avg_legality_checks": 67416.07692307692, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1327, "root_legality_checks": 991, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 875418, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1324, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3007599, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 231353.76923076922, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5992815866, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1992.558138900831, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41829, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3217.6153846153848, "renju_forbidden_ns": 212730270, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5085.712543928853, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1895, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13446626, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24283, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 158227749, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15636, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40964695, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 91200, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81525, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6271.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 655697025, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8042.895124195033, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 111917, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8609.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 275357304, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2460.370667548272, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1975633029, "stage_ordering_ns": 989740900, "stage_eval_ns": 2878604023, "stage_threat_ns": 4579003300, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 487535, "root_tactical_annotations": 2982, "search_tactical_annotations": 484553, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 259379, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1383428498, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 423311, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2977797587, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62668, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2028916732, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129683, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 173492773, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 259366, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29247649, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 139883, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 191137853, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 220750, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 757597491, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 126902, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15036793, "child_limit_applications": 31293, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31293, "child_cap_hits": 31293, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31293, "child_moves_before_total": 2703624, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2703624, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 501227, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 501227, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.39708561020036, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.017224299364074, "tt_hits": 14052, "tt_cutoffs": 1807, "beta_cutoffs": 24984, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5236.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5851.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 925, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9713, "avg_search_time_ms": 809.4166666666666, "search_nodes": 75772, "safety_nodes": 1311, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 77083, "avg_nodes": 6423.583333333333, "eval_calls": 46439, "avg_eval_calls": 3869.9166666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46439, "pattern_eval_ns": 1017752, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.915889661706753, "pattern_frame_queries": 46439, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1017752, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.915889661706753, "pattern_frame_updates": 151404, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1691065027, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11169.22292013421, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26320, "avg_candidate_generations": 2193.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2141893, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.37891337386019, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 26308, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2140979, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1207329, "avg_legality_checks": 100610.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1249, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1207329, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1249, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2918356, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 243196.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6243768935, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2139.4815899773707, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23760, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1980.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 129128019, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5434.680934343434, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1725, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16112056, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8760, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 79848278, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13260, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 33070915, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 96770, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98826, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8235.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 889246122, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8998.098901098901, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 133487, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11123.916666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 379324691, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2841.6601691550486, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2911755858, "stage_ordering_ns": 870176505, "stage_eval_ns": 1692082779, "stage_threat_ns": 4183044058, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 418535, "root_tactical_annotations": 963, "search_tactical_annotations": 417572, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 151416, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 907468249, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 363935, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3130698194, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52710, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1902812467, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75702, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113635288, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 151404, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19072665, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 73839, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 307862990, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 237377, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 919727236, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 107319, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12169662, "child_limit_applications": 26308, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26308, "child_cap_hits": 26308, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26308, "child_moves_before_total": 2139730, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2139730, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 274856, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 274856, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.33381480918352, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.447620495666717, "tt_hits": 12857, "tt_cutoffs": 2956, "beta_cutoffs": 21096, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 5.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 5.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4021.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4687.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 128, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1180, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17458, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 85, 68, 111, 109, 142, 94, 113, 114, 99, 127, 158, 174, 143, 128, 140, 154, 141, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 13981, "avg_search_time_ms": 1165.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 145085, "safety_nodes": 192, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 145277, "avg_nodes": 12106.416666666666, "eval_calls": 84751, "avg_eval_calls": 7062.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84751, "pattern_eval_ns": 1784214, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.052424160186902, "pattern_frame_queries": 84751, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1784214, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.052424160186902, "pattern_frame_updates": 290042, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3134561683, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10807.268199088408, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 56320, "avg_candidate_generations": 4693.333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4753655, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.4043856534091, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 825, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 56308, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4752830, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1148978, "avg_legality_checks": 95748.16666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1672, "root_legality_checks": 825, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1148153, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1671, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4117720, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 343143.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8140839494, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1977.025998368029, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29382, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2448.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 173079284, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5890.657000884896, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1839, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17713745, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12940, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 105209035, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14598, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 50125054, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 31450, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 94700, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7891.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 717765141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7579.357349524816, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 124134, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10344.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 287717119, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2317.794633218941, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2438966100, "stage_ordering_ns": 1683008783, "stage_eval_ns": 3136345897, "stage_threat_ns": 6656452058, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 976898, "root_tactical_annotations": 3719, "search_tactical_annotations": 973179, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 290054, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1537898702, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 726609, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4836300780, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 112703, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3671096587, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 145021, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 197772305, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 290042, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33333468, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 263864, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 247314046, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 350031, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 917801397, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 363003, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 51146803, "child_limit_applications": 56308, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 56308, "child_cap_hits": 56308, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 56308, "child_moves_before_total": 4751159, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4751159, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 638332, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 638332, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.37804574838388, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.336435320025574, "tt_hits": 35240, "tt_cutoffs": 3962, "beta_cutoffs": 46975, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3599.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4265.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1722, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3466, "avg_search_time_ms": 315.09090909090907, "search_nodes": 49092, "safety_nodes": 887, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49979, "avg_nodes": 4543.545454545455, "eval_calls": 35211, "avg_eval_calls": 3201.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35211, "pattern_eval_ns": 705432, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.034421061600067, "pattern_frame_queries": 35211, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 705432, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.034421061600067, "pattern_frame_updates": 98084, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 619402019, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6315.015894539374, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13331, "avg_candidate_generations": 1211.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 1031986, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.41249718700773, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 760, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 13320, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1031226, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 532903, "avg_legality_checks": 48445.72727272727, "illegal_moves_skipped": 133, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 532903, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 133, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1363959, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 123996.27272727272, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2071778249, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1518.9446669584643, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3626, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 329.6363636363636, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10254058, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2827.9255377826807, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 135, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1331627, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 788, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6009670, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2698, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2848920, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 63841, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46452, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4222.909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 307436479, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6618.369047619048, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 62981, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5725.545454545455, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 136229981, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2163.032994077579, "stage_move_gen_ns": 897807581, "stage_ordering_ns": 307805769, "stage_eval_ns": 620107451, "stage_threat_ns": 1601956591, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 192037, "root_tactical_annotations": 686, "search_tactical_annotations": 191351, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 98095, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 424628203, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 181440, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1109251546, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26712, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 681472360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 49042, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 54724098, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 98084, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9317260, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 46843, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 149746192, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 107879, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 277846843, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 37315, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4035484, "child_limit_applications": 13320, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13320, "child_cap_hits": 13320, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13320, "child_moves_before_total": 1031093, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1031093, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 213659, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 213659, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.40938438438438, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.040465465465466, "tt_hits": 4536, "tt_cutoffs": 511, "beta_cutoffs": 11025, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5620.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6348.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1921, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1181, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19280, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 82, 128, 68, 110, 97, 67, 84, 113, 83, 85, 69, 158, 143, 55, 54, 40, 39, 24, 99 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10815, "avg_search_time_ms": 1081.5, "search_nodes": 125805, "safety_nodes": 419, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 126224, "avg_nodes": 12622.4, "eval_calls": 100958, "avg_eval_calls": 10095.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 100958, "pattern_eval_ns": 2187813, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.670526357495195, "pattern_frame_queries": 100958, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2187813, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.670526357495195, "pattern_frame_updates": 251526, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3472943594, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13807.493436066252, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23808, "avg_candidate_generations": 2380.8, "candidate_moves_total": 1750916, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.54317876344086, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 635, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 23798, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1750281, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 790438, "avg_legality_checks": 79043.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 565, "root_legality_checks": 635, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 789803, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 565, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2864963, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 286496.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6460320929, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2254.9404404175552, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26902, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2690.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 117158441, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4355.008586722177, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 843, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5990588, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13791, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 90503775, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12268, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20664078, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 82988, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8298.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 731395782, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8813.27158143346, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110364, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11036.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 304779181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2761.5815030263493, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2001115217, "stage_ordering_ns": 764853379, "stage_eval_ns": 3475131407, "stage_threat_ns": 4534395586, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 365305, "root_tactical_annotations": 1793, "search_tactical_annotations": 363512, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 251536, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1508935677, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 338695, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2795897742, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47657, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1771318072, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 125763, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 187348540, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 251526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31929597, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96770, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 160348364, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 194260, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 863984324, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 74275, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10284030, "child_limit_applications": 23798, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23798, "child_cap_hits": 23798, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23798, "child_moves_before_total": 1749716, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1749716, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 380982, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 380982, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.5236574502059, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.008992352298513, "tt_hits": 8879, "tt_cutoffs": 1007, "beta_cutoffs": 17171, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2761.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3561.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 401, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8454, "avg_search_time_ms": 939.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 62962, "safety_nodes": 752, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 63714, "avg_nodes": 7079.333333333333, "eval_calls": 37639, "avg_eval_calls": 4182.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37639, "pattern_eval_ns": 846845, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.499136533914292, "pattern_frame_queries": 37639, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 846845, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.499136533914292, "pattern_frame_updates": 125830, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1450638297, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11528.556759119447, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23088, "avg_candidate_generations": 2565.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 1744659, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.5656185031185, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 564, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 23079, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1744095, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 957214, "avg_legality_checks": 106357.11111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 546, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 957214, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 546, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2493568, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 277063.1111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5451847684, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2186.364151288435, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14469, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1607.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50163789, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3466.9838274932613, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 558, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5623605, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3557, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30274278, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10354, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14265906, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89101, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9900.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 844159771, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9474.189638724594, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 121010, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13445.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 380915249, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3147.799760350384, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2393506789, "stage_ordering_ns": 739482124, "stage_eval_ns": 1451485142, "stage_threat_ns": 3824980101, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 390303, "root_tactical_annotations": 789, "search_tactical_annotations": 389514, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125839, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 788604496, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 357309, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2911942433, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46223, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1708229584, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 62915, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 98002447, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 125830, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16390683, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 66648, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 245846569, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 244431, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 957623489, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79224, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10040042, "child_limit_applications": 23079, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23079, "child_cap_hits": 23079, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23079, "child_moves_before_total": 1743549, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1743549, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 227671, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 227671, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.54699077083063, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.864855496338663, "tt_hits": 9217, "tt_cutoffs": 2198, "beta_cutoffs": 18695, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 5.111111111111111, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 5.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2857.8888888888887, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3746.777777777778, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1182, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16216, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 128, 82, 100, 142, 86, 72, 143, 83, 81, 110, 113, 158, 126, 124, 68, 138 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10516, "avg_search_time_ms": 1168.4444444444443, "search_nodes": 91776, "safety_nodes": 517, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92293, "avg_nodes": 10254.777777777777, "eval_calls": 58109, "avg_eval_calls": 6456.555555555556, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 58109, "pattern_eval_ns": 1273908, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.92273141854102, "pattern_frame_queries": 58109, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1273908, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.92273141854102, "pattern_frame_updates": 183462, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2342254014, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12766.970893154985, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31103, "avg_candidate_generations": 3455.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 2533662, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.46037359740218, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 639, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 31094, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2533023, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 872960, "avg_legality_checks": 96995.55555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1037, "root_legality_checks": 639, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 872321, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1037, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2776547, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 308505.22222222225, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6395571140, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2303.4262124862285, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35332, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3925.777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 133151869, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3768.5913336352314, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1282, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12281119, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12058, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72577860, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21988, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 48285190, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7700, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 77470, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8607.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 739140689, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9540.992500322705, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 101198, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11244.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 319834421, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3160.481639953359, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2249891144, "stage_ordering_ns": 1071746760, "stage_eval_ns": 2343527922, "stage_threat_ns": 4810194649, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 455928, "root_tactical_annotations": 1469, "search_tactical_annotations": 454459, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 183471, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1129441280, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 360113, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3491246409, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62250, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2406855643, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91731, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 142809838, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 183462, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23622993, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 69252, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 141180546, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 228605, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 942884599, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 158071, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23074129, "child_limit_applications": 31094, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31094, "child_cap_hits": 31094, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31094, "child_moves_before_total": 2531986, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2531986, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 315963, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 315963, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.4300508136618, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.161542419759439, "tt_hits": 16823, "tt_cutoffs": 2529, "beta_cutoffs": 24772, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 4.888888888888889, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 4.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1996.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2831.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5691, "avg_search_time_ms": 711.375, "search_nodes": 40335, "safety_nodes": 660, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40995, "avg_nodes": 5124.375, "eval_calls": 26794, "avg_eval_calls": 3349.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 26794, "pattern_eval_ns": 593293, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.142755840859895, "pattern_frame_queries": 26794, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 593293, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.142755840859895, "pattern_frame_updates": 80600, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 814640982, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10107.208213399505, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12783, "avg_candidate_generations": 1597.875, "candidate_moves_total": 1111202, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.92810764296331, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 12775, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1110622, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 769879, "avg_legality_checks": 96234.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 78, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 769879, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 78, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1714618, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 214327.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3804284293, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2218.735772632738, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25292, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3161.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 54898151, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2170.573738731615, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 126, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1105775, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2406, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14969184, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22760, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 38823192, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 71684, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8960.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 757606666, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10568.699654037164, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92292, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11536.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 354777489, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3844.0762904693797, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1946624973, "stage_ordering_ns": 467077287, "stage_eval_ns": 815234275, "stage_threat_ns": 2443344916, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 213924, "root_tactical_annotations": 1077, "search_tactical_annotations": 212847, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 80608, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 511520321, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 190064, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1834315000, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25601, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 928796796, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80812245, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 80600, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10127756, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70845, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 470777107, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 93611, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 434539017, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49468, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6569594, "child_limit_applications": 12775, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12775, "child_cap_hits": 12775, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12775, "child_moves_before_total": 1110544, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1110544, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 204662, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 204662, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.93103718199609, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02050880626223, "tt_hits": 5722, "tt_cutoffs": 731, "beta_cutoffs": 11053, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 4.375, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 4.375, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3755.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4755.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1844, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1183, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26735, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 110, 128, 82, 124, 111, 109, 97, 67, 98, 125, 127, 123, 122, 95, 81, 114, 100, 99, 129, 137, 151, 113, 66, 51, 83, 84, 80, 79, 69, 55, 68, 54, 38, 53, 52, 94, 24 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 10891, "avg_search_time_ms": 573.2105263157895, "search_nodes": 115631, "safety_nodes": 1318, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 116949, "avg_nodes": 6155.210526315789, "eval_calls": 82055, "avg_eval_calls": 4318.684210526316, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82055, "pattern_eval_ns": 1689317, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.58761806105661, "pattern_frame_queries": 82055, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1689317, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.58761806105661, "pattern_frame_updates": 231088, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2999147221, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12978.37715935055, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31548, "avg_candidate_generations": 1660.421052631579, "candidate_moves_total": 2523152, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.97819196145556, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1419, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 31529, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2521733, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 849902, "avg_legality_checks": 44731.68421052631, "illegal_moves_skipped": 926, "root_legality_checks": 1419, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 848483, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 925, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3058774, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 160988.1052631579, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6476816234, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2117.4549783671496, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29468, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1550.9473684210527, "renju_forbidden_ns": 140357100, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4763.034478077915, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1044, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8218123, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12901, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 99181390, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15511, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32941417, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 16170, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90785, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4778.1578947368425, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 754336956, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8309.048367020983, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 120605, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6347.631578947368, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 306126241, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2538.2549728452386, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1977842150, "stage_ordering_ns": 972263115, "stage_eval_ns": 3000836538, "stage_threat_ns": 4890753797, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 664322, "root_tactical_annotations": 2837, "search_tactical_annotations": 661485, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 231107, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1342429506, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 574036, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3334793314, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 63182, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2186039523, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115544, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 166998786, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 231088, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28333106, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 232437, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 190911193, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 278404, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 957371976, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 153481, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18199085, "child_limit_applications": 31529, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31529, "child_cap_hits": 31529, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31529, "child_moves_before_total": 2520808, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2520808, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 513518, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 513518, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.95204414983031, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.2871641980399, "tt_hits": 14520, "tt_cutoffs": 1960, "beta_cutoffs": 26205, "depth_sum": 87, "avg_depth": 4.578947368421052, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 87, "avg_effective_depth": 4.578947368421052, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5931.263157894737, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6352.315789473684, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 412, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 15824, "avg_search_time_ms": 879.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 120995, "safety_nodes": 1825, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122820, "avg_nodes": 6823.333333333333, "eval_calls": 73171, "avg_eval_calls": 4065.0555555555557, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73171, "pattern_eval_ns": 1538167, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.021538587691847, "pattern_frame_queries": 73171, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1538167, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.021538587691847, "pattern_frame_updates": 241766, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2697081138, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11155.75034537528, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43261, "avg_candidate_generations": 2403.3888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 3539078, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.80758650978942, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1348, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 43243, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3537730, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 2129613, "avg_legality_checks": 118311.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3942, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2129613, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3942, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5057735, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 280985.27777777775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10162169808, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2009.2333441748135, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54172, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3009.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 161257077, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2976.760632799232, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4156, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33069862, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9805, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71404595, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 40199, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 56759310, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 23310, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 198732, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11040.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1646635151, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8285.707138256546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 268380, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14910.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 661915567, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2466.337159997019, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4825071934, "stage_ordering_ns": 1329015016, "stage_eval_ns": 2698619305, "stage_threat_ns": 6882760021, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1028523, "root_tactical_annotations": 1055, "search_tactical_annotations": 1027468, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 241784, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1418554802, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 840133, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5220334391, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 86634, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2802774988, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 120883, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 180187884, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 241766, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29995082, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 204362, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 488457386, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 549126, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1928702374, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 275035, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33687862, "child_limit_applications": 43243, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43243, "child_cap_hits": 43243, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43243, "child_moves_before_total": 3533788, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3533788, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 553855, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 553855, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.71930717110284, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.807968919825173, "tt_hits": 21937, "tt_cutoffs": 4470, "beta_cutoffs": 36792, "depth_sum": 111, "avg_depth": 6.166666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 111, "avg_effective_depth": 6.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5708.388888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6152.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1184, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25875, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 128, 110, 114, 156, 100, 86, 129, 125, 95, 82, 68, 124, 138, 64, 48, 140, 130, 127, 132, 131, 84, 116, 99, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18550, "avg_search_time_ms": 1426.923076923077, "search_nodes": 163611, "safety_nodes": 787, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 164398, "avg_nodes": 12646.0, "eval_calls": 101531, "avg_eval_calls": 7810.076923076923, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 101531, "pattern_eval_ns": 2149514, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.17101180920113, "pattern_frame_queries": 101531, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2149514, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.17101180920113, "pattern_frame_updates": 327070, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4552124040, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13917.889259179992, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 56757, "avg_candidate_generations": 4365.923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 5148001, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.7024860369646, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1110, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 56744, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5146891, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 1490031, "avg_legality_checks": 114617.76923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1573, "root_legality_checks": 1110, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1488921, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1573, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5114961, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 393458.53846153844, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11111485229, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2172.3499414756047, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58516, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4501.2307692307695, "renju_forbidden_ns": 343127643, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5863.826013398045, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15233006, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29111, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 231018962, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 27691, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 96875675, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 135050, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10388.461538461539, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1286133895, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9523.390559052203, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 190179, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14629.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 603853806, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3175.1865663401322, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3599070941, "stage_ordering_ns": 1977194802, "stage_eval_ns": 4554273554, "stage_threat_ns": 8360055636, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1080872, "root_tactical_annotations": 3208, "search_tactical_annotations": 1077664, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 327083, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1934283908, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 786102, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6087080485, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 113590, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4115342102, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 163535, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 244769804, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 327070, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40583799, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 192329, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 277164078, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 480175, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1694278884, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 408368, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 53337640, "child_limit_applications": 56744, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 56744, "child_cap_hits": 56744, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 56744, "child_moves_before_total": 5145318, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5145318, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 616017, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 616017, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.67598336387988, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.85607288876357, "tt_hits": 34234, "tt_cutoffs": 5262, "beta_cutoffs": 46380, "depth_sum": 74, "avg_depth": 5.6923076923076925, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 74, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6923076923076925, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1826.3076923076924, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2404.3076923076924, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7311, "avg_search_time_ms": 562.3846153846154, "search_nodes": 52839, "safety_nodes": 1563, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 54402, "avg_nodes": 4184.7692307692305, "eval_calls": 35520, "avg_eval_calls": 2732.3076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35520, "pattern_eval_ns": 757404, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.32331081081081, "pattern_frame_queries": 35520, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 757404, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.32331081081081, "pattern_frame_updates": 105564, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1088807148, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10314.1899511197, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16256, "avg_candidate_generations": 1250.4615384615386, "candidate_moves_total": 1459494, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.78186515748031, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1138, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 16243, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1458356, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1032883, "avg_legality_checks": 79452.53846153847, "illegal_moves_skipped": 102, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1032883, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 102, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2366249, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 182019.15384615384, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4925570622, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2081.5943808111488, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7134, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 548.7692307692307, "renju_forbidden_ns": 24375199, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3416.764648163723, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 692971, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1966, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16219317, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5066, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7462911, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99494, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7653.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1039651881, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10449.392737250488, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 147726, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11363.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 522737937, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3538.5642134763007, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2467403066, "stage_ordering_ns": 598877842, "stage_eval_ns": 1089564552, "stage_threat_ns": 3095703040, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 284546, "root_tactical_annotations": 1136, "search_tactical_annotations": 283410, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 105577, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 620073926, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 265408, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2378449687, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32568, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1115857500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52782, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 77548184, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 105564, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12630775, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 81118, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 514218235, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 151712, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 748059070, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 51716, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7000468, "child_limit_applications": 16243, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16243, "child_cap_hits": 16243, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16243, "child_moves_before_total": 1458254, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1458254, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 260281, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 260281, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.7773810256726, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.024195037862462, "tt_hits": 6271, "tt_cutoffs": 1019, "beta_cutoffs": 13944, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5046.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5661.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1846, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1185, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19092, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 144, 96, 114, 68, 110, 100, 113, 111, 99, 84, 116, 115, 130, 36, 52, 54, 40, 158, 129, 159, 127, 126, 131 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10752, "avg_search_time_ms": 896.0, "search_nodes": 125121, "safety_nodes": 513, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 125634, "avg_nodes": 10469.5, "eval_calls": 95935, "avg_eval_calls": 7994.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 95935, "pattern_eval_ns": 1976721, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.604794913222495, "pattern_frame_queries": 95935, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1976721, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.604794913222495, "pattern_frame_updates": 250138, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2958715927, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11828.33446737401, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27448, "avg_candidate_generations": 2287.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2276898, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.95314777032935, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 886, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 27436, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2276012, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 928666, "avg_legality_checks": 77388.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1173, "root_legality_checks": 886, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 927780, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1173, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2902989, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 241915.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6262511794, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2157.263356492222, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46676, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3889.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 277761622, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5950.844588225212, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2943, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26777427, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21286, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 173548489, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22426, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 77241004, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 194702, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 82657, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6888.083333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 732442280, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8861.225062608128, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 108925, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9077.083333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 295666665, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2714.405921505623, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2251104312, "stage_ordering_ns": 894633168, "stage_eval_ns": 2960692648, "stage_threat_ns": 4599008156, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 496641, "root_tactical_annotations": 2166, "search_tactical_annotations": 494475, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 250150, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1393467579, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 435021, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2982783657, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54947, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1929263550, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 125069, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 176216183, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 250138, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29528087, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 158771, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 235793896, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 221294, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 817444861, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 116576, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17012650, "child_limit_applications": 27436, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27436, "child_cap_hits": 27436, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27436, "child_moves_before_total": 2274839, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2274839, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 439737, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 439737, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.91438256305584, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.027737279486807, "tt_hits": 10831, "tt_cutoffs": 1698, "beta_cutoffs": 21185, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4321.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4987.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 15, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8326, "avg_search_time_ms": 756.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 61905, "safety_nodes": 1044, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 62949, "avg_nodes": 5722.636363636364, "eval_calls": 39060, "avg_eval_calls": 3550.909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39060, "pattern_eval_ns": 823543, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.08405017921147, "pattern_frame_queries": 39060, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 823543, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.08405017921147, "pattern_frame_updates": 123684, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1449932287, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11722.876742343391, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20960, "avg_candidate_generations": 1905.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 1684785, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.38096374045801, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 813, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 20949, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1683972, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1027332, "avg_legality_checks": 93393.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 606, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1027332, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 606, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2563977, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 233088.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5449955221, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2125.5866261670835, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28684, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2607.6363636363635, "renju_forbidden_ns": 103773283, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3617.8107307209593, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1563, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13025097, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6685, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 49494697, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20415, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41055117, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 198372, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 102086, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9280.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 935210391, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9161.005338636052, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 135170, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12288.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 400848156, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2965.511252496856, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2489908110, "stage_ordering_ns": 680388888, "stage_eval_ns": 1450755830, "stage_threat_ns": 3660423071, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 392914, "root_tactical_annotations": 984, "search_tactical_annotations": 391930, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 123695, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 741416917, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 340514, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2800550758, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41983, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1550432475, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61842, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92540503, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 123684, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15474366, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 80394, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 339095619, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 218130, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 910815324, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 94390, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10440527, "child_limit_applications": 20949, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20949, "child_cap_hits": 20949, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20949, "child_moves_before_total": 1683366, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1683366, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 231443, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 231443, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.35543462695117, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.047925915318153, "tt_hits": 9725, "tt_cutoffs": 1834, "beta_cutoffs": 16996, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3903.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4630.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1186, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20162, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 114, 81, 79, 66, 113, 115, 142, 100, 111, 110, 95, 127, 156, 170, 141, 126, 144, 160, 143, 145, 140 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 15506, "avg_search_time_ms": 1292.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 148526, "safety_nodes": 192, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148718, "avg_nodes": 12393.166666666666, "eval_calls": 87297, "avg_eval_calls": 7274.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87297, "pattern_eval_ns": 1816086, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.803532767449052, "pattern_frame_queries": 87297, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1816086, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.803532767449052, "pattern_frame_updates": 296924, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3387949034, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11410.155575164015, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 57290, "avg_candidate_generations": 4774.166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 4818614, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.1091639029499, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 825, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 57278, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4817789, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1187060, "avg_legality_checks": 98921.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1669, "root_legality_checks": 825, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1186235, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4219051, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 351587.5833333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9131760579, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2164.411043857967, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30916, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2576.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 194949587, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6305.782992625178, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1838, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18853827, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13921, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 121158942, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15152, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 54879027, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57791, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98146, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8178.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 825959774, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8415.623397795121, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 128319, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10693.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 332720416, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2592.9162166164015, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2828384311, "stage_ordering_ns": 1840362606, "stage_eval_ns": 3389765120, "stage_threat_ns": 7391799018, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 983113, "root_tactical_annotations": 3719, "search_tactical_annotations": 979394, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 296936, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1714341216, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 733185, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5381104856, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 114643, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4059029624, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148462, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 215470279, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 296924, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36176862, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 262311, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 270404975, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 356220, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1051532356, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 364582, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 44705805, "child_limit_applications": 57278, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 57278, "child_cap_hits": 57278, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 57278, "child_moves_before_total": 4816121, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4816121, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 638858, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 638858, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.0832605887077, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.153636649324348, "tt_hits": 35344, "tt_cutoffs": 3887, "beta_cutoffs": 47706, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2281.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2948.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 626, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4644, "avg_search_time_ms": 422.1818181818182, "search_nodes": 48969, "safety_nodes": 887, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49856, "avg_nodes": 4532.363636363636, "eval_calls": 35198, "avg_eval_calls": 3199.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35198, "pattern_eval_ns": 726246, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.6331609750554, "pattern_frame_queries": 35198, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 726246, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.6331609750554, "pattern_frame_updates": 97838, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 779974426, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7972.101085467814, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13260, "avg_candidate_generations": 1205.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 1026042, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.3787330316742, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 760, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 13249, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1025282, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 525923, "avg_legality_checks": 47811.181818181816, "illegal_moves_skipped": 101, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 525923, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 101, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1348871, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 122624.63636363637, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2855211780, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2116.741912310369, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3559, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 323.54545454545456, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12536815, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3522.566732228154, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 103, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1048342, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 798, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8448449, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2653, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2980434, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 59590, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46263, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4205.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 434990247, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9402.55165034693, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 62792, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5708.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 197240086, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3141.1658491527583, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1271748212, "stage_ordering_ns": 415955859, "stage_eval_ns": 780700672, "stage_threat_ns": 2143284329, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 190275, "root_tactical_annotations": 686, "search_tactical_annotations": 189589, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 97849, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 559538648, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 180073, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1499726543, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26570, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 917208824, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48919, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68261860, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 97838, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11612093, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 47273, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 214490076, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 106224, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 367836541, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 36778, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4145185, "child_limit_applications": 13249, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13249, "child_cap_hits": 13249, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13249, "child_moves_before_total": 1025181, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1025181, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 212510, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 212510, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.37799079175787, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0397011095177, "tt_hits": 4488, "tt_cutoffs": 472, "beta_cutoffs": 10956, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5241.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5968.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1883, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1187, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27588, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 142, 98, 110, 158, 127, 157, 111, 109, 96, 143, 113, 173, 188, 141, 125, 82, 66, 81, 83, 130, 146, 97, 160, 132, 124, 123, 94, 78, 138, 152, 174, 202, 95, 129, 131, 115, 101, 171 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 11366, "avg_search_time_ms": 598.2105263157895, "search_nodes": 116872, "safety_nodes": 1473, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 118345, "avg_nodes": 6228.684210526316, "eval_calls": 82638, "avg_eval_calls": 4349.368421052632, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82638, "pattern_eval_ns": 1708898, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.6793242818074, "pattern_frame_queries": 82638, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1708898, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.6793242818074, "pattern_frame_updates": 233564, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3049554795, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13056.61315528078, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32122, "avg_candidate_generations": 1690.6315789473683, "candidate_moves_total": 2609944, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.25098063632402, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1526, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 32103, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2608418, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 884965, "avg_legality_checks": 46577.10526315789, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1265, "root_legality_checks": 1526, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 883439, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1262, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3159903, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 166310.68421052632, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6728027438, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2129.187964947025, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30407, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1600.3684210526317, "renju_forbidden_ns": 161533608, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5312.382280395961, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1378, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12880111, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12784, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 109106914, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16230, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39382011, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 164572, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98540, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5186.315789473684, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 834331712, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8466.934361680536, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 131794, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6936.526315789473, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 345031101, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2617.95757773495, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2088825892, "stage_ordering_ns": 1030139536, "stage_eval_ns": 3051263693, "stage_threat_ns": 5143634383, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 724848, "root_tactical_annotations": 2831, "search_tactical_annotations": 722017, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 233583, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1358524400, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 618662, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3566139194, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64334, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2293740846, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 116782, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 169610495, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 233564, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28864821, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 247005, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 223721580, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 307310, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1048176896, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 170533, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20495473, "child_limit_applications": 32103, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32103, "child_cap_hits": 32103, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32103, "child_moves_before_total": 2607156, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2607156, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 534327, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 534327, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.21222315671433, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.64414540697131, "tt_hits": 14630, "tt_cutoffs": 2041, "beta_cutoffs": 26769, "depth_sum": 90, "avg_depth": 4.7368421052631575, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 90, "avg_effective_depth": 4.7368421052631575, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5906.263157894737, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6327.315789473684, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 358, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 16202, "avg_search_time_ms": 852.7368421052631, "search_nodes": 118290, "safety_nodes": 2252, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 120542, "avg_nodes": 6344.315789473684, "eval_calls": 69592, "avg_eval_calls": 3662.7368421052633, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 69592, "pattern_eval_ns": 1472106, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.153379698815957, "pattern_frame_queries": 69592, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1472106, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.153379698815957, "pattern_frame_updates": 236352, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2664847900, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11274.911572569727, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43356, "avg_candidate_generations": 2281.8947368421054, "candidate_moves_total": 3647273, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.12383522465171, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1553, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 43337, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3645720, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 2200738, "avg_legality_checks": 115828.31578947368, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3604, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2200738, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3604, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5163374, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 271756.5263157895, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10420974736, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2018.2490627252646, "renju_forbidden_checks": 62305, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3279.2105263157896, "renju_forbidden_ns": 171188565, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2747.5895193002166, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3786, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 31760970, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9912, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73901979, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 48592, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 65359495, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 166121, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 205729, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10827.842105263158, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1748734787, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8500.186104049502, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 282335, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14859.736842105263, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 724546715, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2566.266013777959, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5031668364, "stage_ordering_ns": 1417030805, "stage_eval_ns": 2666320006, "stage_threat_ns": 6994264229, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1072932, "root_tactical_annotations": 1077, "search_tactical_annotations": 1071855, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 236371, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1386032008, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 867275, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5368967292, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 86825, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2836696706, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 118176, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 175039794, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 236352, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29562522, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 227271, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 611367787, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 553166, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1920429557, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 292495, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 34662613, "child_limit_applications": 43337, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43337, "child_cap_hits": 43337, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43337, "child_moves_before_total": 3642116, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3642116, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 567533, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 567533, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.04171954680758, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.09580727784572, "tt_hits": 22918, "tt_cutoffs": 5248, "beta_cutoffs": 37203, "depth_sum": 113, "avg_depth": 5.947368421052632, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 113, "avg_effective_depth": 5.947368421052632, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.10526315789473684, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5900.368421052632, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6321.421052631579, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1188, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20332, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 141, 129, 99, 100, 140, 154, 142, 86, 72, 143, 111, 156, 158, 110, 157, 127, 125, 131, 130, 173, 139, 138, 153, 97, 167 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 16547, "avg_search_time_ms": 1181.9285714285713, "search_nodes": 167285, "safety_nodes": 614, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 167899, "avg_nodes": 11992.785714285714, "eval_calls": 121912, "avg_eval_calls": 8708.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 121912, "pattern_eval_ns": 2531777, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.767250147647484, "pattern_frame_queries": 121912, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2531777, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.767250147647484, "pattern_frame_updates": 334442, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5113218759, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15288.805709211163, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42775, "avg_candidate_generations": 3055.3571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 3716523, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.88540035067213, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1053, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 42761, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3715470, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1233710, "avg_legality_checks": 88122.14285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6596, "root_legality_checks": 1053, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 1232657, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6591, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4554263, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 325304.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9778830728, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2147.181822393656, "renju_forbidden_checks": 80009, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5714.928571428572, "renju_forbidden_ns": 517328664, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6465.880888400055, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7309, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 70090638, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 46958, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 358501378, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25717, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 88453018, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 283630, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 127800, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9128.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1101182226, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8616.449342723005, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 165969, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11854.92857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 456984983, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2753.435780175816, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2974217904, "stage_ordering_ns": 1432580055, "stage_eval_ns": 5115750536, "stage_threat_ns": 6972047734, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 846494, "root_tactical_annotations": 3024, "search_tactical_annotations": 843470, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 334456, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1954626322, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 673975, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4695212647, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 85613, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3058941856, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 167221, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 245664693, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 334442, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41709521, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 221633, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 283841082, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 366718, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1352100368, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 258143, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 34834551, "child_limit_applications": 42761, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42761, "child_cap_hits": 42761, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42761, "child_moves_before_total": 3708879, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3708879, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 488410, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 488410, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.73508570894039, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.421856364444237, "tt_hits": 22003, "tt_cutoffs": 2548, "beta_cutoffs": 31751, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 4.571428571428571, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 4.571428571428571, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4897.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5468.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 525, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3773, "avg_search_time_ms": 290.2307692307692, "search_nodes": 32675, "safety_nodes": 1471, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34146, "avg_nodes": 2626.6153846153848, "eval_calls": 21993, "avg_eval_calls": 1691.7692307692307, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 21993, "pattern_eval_ns": 463592, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.079070613376985, "pattern_frame_queries": 21993, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 463592, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.079070613376985, "pattern_frame_updates": 65230, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 730217971, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11194.511283151924, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9901, "avg_candidate_generations": 761.6153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 768756, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.64427835572164, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 976, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 9888, "search_candidate_moves_total": 767780, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 409574, "avg_legality_checks": 31505.69230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2548, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 409574, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2548, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1102625, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 84817.30769230769, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2344822233, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2126.581778029702, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12319, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 947.6153846153846, "renju_forbidden_ns": 94720825, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7689.002759964283, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2579, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 29043051, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5099, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 49311391, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4611, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16008653, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 357730, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37185, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2860.3846153846152, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 366403753, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9853.536452870781, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50948, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3919.076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 177633264, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3486.560100494622, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1021122920, "stage_ordering_ns": 309021199, "stage_eval_ns": 730681563, "stage_threat_ns": 1680536675, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 174800, "root_tactical_annotations": 661, "search_tactical_annotations": 174139, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 65243, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 396559246, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 159388, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1223858715, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19862, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 725057754, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 32615, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 48368281, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 65230, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8094427, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44979, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 162205854, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 94537, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 336245235, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 35284, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3656006, "child_limit_applications": 9888, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9888, "child_cap_hits": 9888, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9888, "child_moves_before_total": 765232, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 765232, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 159819, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 159819, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.38996763754045, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.162924757281555, "tt_hits": 4010, "tt_cutoffs": 734, "beta_cutoffs": 8457, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5981.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6596.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1875, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1189, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25613, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 82, 126, 97, 127, 66, 114, 52, 67, 38, 80, 50, 34, 51, 53, 81, 65, 36, 21, 24, 10, 48, 49, 68, 125, 95, 124, 123, 128 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 17270, "avg_search_time_ms": 1233.5714285714287, "search_nodes": 227502, "safety_nodes": 167, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 227669, "avg_nodes": 16262.07142857143, "eval_calls": 175900, "avg_eval_calls": 12564.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 175900, "pattern_eval_ns": 3625937, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.613627060830016, "pattern_frame_queries": 175900, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3625937, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.613627060830016, "pattern_frame_updates": 454874, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5481158329, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12049.83870038736, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 48167, "avg_candidate_generations": 3440.5, "candidate_moves_total": 3808259, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.06365353872984, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 971, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 48153, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3807288, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1243800, "avg_legality_checks": 88842.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 631, "root_legality_checks": 971, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1242829, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 631, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4722203, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 337300.21428571426, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9879877544, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2092.217878816307, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35978, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2569.8571428571427, "renju_forbidden_ns": 179890609, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5000.016927010951, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 984, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6579512, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21215, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 145933154, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13779, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27377943, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 106157, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7582.642857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 905057291, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8525.648718407641, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 149853, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10703.785714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 417634463, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2786.9609750889203, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2910393373, "stage_ordering_ns": 1399467609, "stage_eval_ns": 5484784266, "stage_threat_ns": 7409706765, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1027624, "root_tactical_annotations": 4026, "search_tactical_annotations": 1023598, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 454888, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2477687940, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 914326, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4530825294, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 96399, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2975020966, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 227437, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 317734457, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 454874, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53288699, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 345506, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 230012255, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 472409, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1325779033, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 209709, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30170375, "child_limit_applications": 48153, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 48153, "child_cap_hits": 48153, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 48153, "child_moves_before_total": 3806657, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3806657, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 774741, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 774741, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.0533715448674, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.08915332378045, "tt_hits": 20245, "tt_cutoffs": 3384, "beta_cutoffs": 36587, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3434.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4005.9285714285716, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 476, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 8329, "avg_search_time_ms": 594.9285714285714, "search_nodes": 65701, "safety_nodes": 1280, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 66981, "avg_nodes": 4784.357142857143, "eval_calls": 38589, "avg_eval_calls": 2756.3571428571427, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38589, "pattern_eval_ns": 827112, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.433880121278083, "pattern_frame_queries": 38589, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 827112, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.433880121278083, "pattern_frame_updates": 131250, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1226620634, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9345.681020952381, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24387, "avg_candidate_generations": 1741.9285714285713, "candidate_moves_total": 1939842, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.54410136548161, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1000, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 24373, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1938842, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 1200949, "avg_legality_checks": 85782.07142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 193, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1200949, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 193, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2725889, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 194706.35714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5442521636, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1996.604276990002, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16188, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1156.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29212458, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1804.5748702742771, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 211, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1040145, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2613, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16264697, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13364, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11907616, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93592, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6685.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 826414990, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8829.974677322849, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 135865, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9704.642857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 392478736, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2888.7405586427703, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2707608385, "stage_ordering_ns": 709437198, "stage_eval_ns": 1227447746, "stage_threat_ns": 3627937435, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 493034, "root_tactical_annotations": 913, "search_tactical_annotations": 492121, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 131264, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 751945444, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 437411, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2751027362, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48849, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1556910742, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 65625, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 95891353, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 131250, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15747087, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 119793, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 271852973, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 268761, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 922005147, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 104480, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13326189, "child_limit_applications": 24373, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24373, "child_cap_hits": 24373, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24373, "child_moves_before_total": 1938649, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1938649, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 255713, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 255713, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.54084437697452, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.49165059697206, "tt_hits": 11642, "tt_cutoffs": 2664, "beta_cutoffs": 20282, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 5.357142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 5.357142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5693.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6264.928571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1190, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15913, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 126, 82, 94, 142, 78, 62, 141, 81, 83, 114, 111, 156, 128, 130, 66, 146 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10601, "avg_search_time_ms": 1177.888888888889, "search_nodes": 100004, "safety_nodes": 517, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 100521, "avg_nodes": 11169.0, "eval_calls": 64805, "avg_eval_calls": 7200.555555555556, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64805, "pattern_eval_ns": 1325981, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.4610909652033, "pattern_frame_queries": 64805, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1325981, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.4610909652033, "pattern_frame_updates": 199918, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2456134056, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12285.707420042218, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32582, "avg_candidate_generations": 3620.222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 2668204, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.89196488858879, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 639, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 32573, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2667565, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 921697, "avg_legality_checks": 102410.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1286, "root_legality_checks": 639, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 921058, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2968840, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 329871.1111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6418840136, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2162.0700798965254, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43945, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4882.777777777777, "renju_forbidden_ns": 148426814, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3377.5586301058142, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14388278, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16565, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 83088509, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25662, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 50943107, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6920, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83104, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9233.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 739745857, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8901.447066326531, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 107582, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11953.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 317163409, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2948.108503281218, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2236193464, "stage_ordering_ns": 1061790718, "stage_eval_ns": 2457460037, "stage_threat_ns": 4805128973, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 488108, "root_tactical_annotations": 1469, "search_tactical_annotations": 486639, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 199927, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1163508764, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 379046, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3447858875, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 65208, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2362181841, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 99959, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 144458664, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 199918, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24422445, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71007, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 137159967, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 242825, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 948213995, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 174276, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24880225, "child_limit_applications": 32573, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32573, "child_cap_hits": 32573, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32573, "child_moves_before_total": 2666279, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2666279, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 336433, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 336433, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.85549381389494, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.328585024406717, "tt_hits": 17734, "tt_cutoffs": 2581, "beta_cutoffs": 25777, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 4.888888888888889, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 4.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2015.7777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2842.1111111111113, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5302, "avg_search_time_ms": 662.75, "search_nodes": 39773, "safety_nodes": 660, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40433, "avg_nodes": 5054.125, "eval_calls": 26305, "avg_eval_calls": 3288.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 26305, "pattern_eval_ns": 546782, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.786238357726667, "pattern_frame_queries": 26305, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 546782, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.786238357726667, "pattern_frame_updates": 79476, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 748215621, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9414.35931601993, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12709, "avg_candidate_generations": 1588.625, "candidate_moves_total": 1103026, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.79093555747895, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 12701, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1102446, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 768168, "avg_legality_checks": 96021.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 79, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 768168, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 79, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1705001, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 213125.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3555913523, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2085.5785556724013, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25230, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3153.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50220202, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1990.495521204915, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 126, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1040247, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2327, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13523568, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22777, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 35656387, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72054, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9006.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 710869671, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9865.790532100924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92665, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11583.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 330555627, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3567.2112124318783, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1829488534, "stage_ordering_ns": 437336542, "stage_eval_ns": 748762403, "stage_threat_ns": 2248818247, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 213611, "root_tactical_annotations": 1077, "search_tactical_annotations": 212534, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 79484, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 459411676, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 189381, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1716769708, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25453, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 865225117, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 39738, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 57022448, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 79476, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9507166, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70412, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 441664373, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 93509, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 409693498, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49690, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6107249, "child_limit_applications": 12701, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12701, "child_cap_hits": 12701, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12701, "child_moves_before_total": 1102367, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1102367, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 203505, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 203505, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.79371703015511, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.022754113849302, "tt_hits": 5681, "tt_cutoffs": 732, "beta_cutoffs": 11010, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 4.375, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 4.375, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3915.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4915.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1847, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1191, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25309, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 99, 113, 144, 68, 172, 157, 128, 96, 124, 83, 53, 125, 160, 176, 139, 95, 94, 80, 140, 65 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7672, "avg_search_time_ms": 697.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 86609, "safety_nodes": 1000, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87609, "avg_nodes": 7964.454545454545, "eval_calls": 68097, "avg_eval_calls": 6190.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68097, "pattern_eval_ns": 1405985, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.646797949983114, "pattern_frame_queries": 68097, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1405985, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.646797949983114, "pattern_frame_updates": 173116, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1852160101, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10698.953886411424, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17584, "avg_candidate_generations": 1598.5454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 1286840, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.18243858052776, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 17573, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1286032, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 728041, "avg_legality_checks": 66185.54545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6687, "root_legality_checks": 808, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 23, "search_legality_checks": 727233, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2096929, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 190629.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4518358234, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2154.750224733408, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31087, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2826.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 218971012, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7043.812912149773, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7158, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 75848181, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10413, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 100763852, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13401, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41036981, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 115, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1321998, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 71714, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6519.454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 687292462, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9583.797612739492, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97221, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8838.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 319946527, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3290.9199349934684, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1852001957, "stage_ordering_ns": 546953819, "stage_eval_ns": 1853566086, "stage_threat_ns": 3380183917, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 214503, "root_tactical_annotations": 853, "search_tactical_annotations": 213650, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 173127, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 992527378, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 217678, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2240585231, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35219, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1345473859, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86558, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 122257359, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 173116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20859359, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 43718, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 122216356, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 138733, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 772271623, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 32052, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3954590, "child_limit_applications": 17573, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17573, "child_cap_hits": 17573, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17573, "child_moves_before_total": 1279368, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1279368, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 282740, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 282740, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.80305013372788, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.089455414556422, "tt_hits": 5101, "tt_cutoffs": 888, "beta_cutoffs": 13104, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 4.636363636363637, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 4.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4221.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4948.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 664, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 17626, "avg_search_time_ms": 1602.3636363636363, "search_nodes": 124131, "safety_nodes": 691, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 124822, "avg_nodes": 11347.454545454546, "eval_calls": 82504, "avg_eval_calls": 7500.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82504, "pattern_eval_ns": 1760041, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.33279598564918, "pattern_frame_queries": 82504, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1760041, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.33279598564918, "pattern_frame_updates": 248142, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3449802539, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13902.53378710577, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38248, "avg_candidate_generations": 3477.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 3143191, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.17922505751935, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 846, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 38237, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3142345, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 2137056, "avg_legality_checks": 194277.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 38518, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2137056, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 38518, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5161497, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 469227.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10891820196, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2110.2056624270053, "renju_forbidden_checks": 150154, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 13650.363636363636, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1194289788, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7953.766053518388, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 40819, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 436710160, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 53078, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 534417209, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 56113, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 221574783, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 144, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1587636, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 199102, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18100.18181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1981422790, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9951.7975208687, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 264379, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 24034.454545454544, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 946905049, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3581.6197542164846, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5565685907, "stage_ordering_ns": 1263559373, "stage_eval_ns": 3451562580, "stage_threat_ns": 7259227204, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 751304, "root_tactical_annotations": 2361, "search_tactical_annotations": 748943, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 248153, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1496845976, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 638233, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5514819135, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 76555, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2947313344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124071, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 187637457, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 248142, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31529825, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 181626, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 698894668, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 380044, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1868492480, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 189634, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28394811, "child_limit_applications": 38237, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38237, "child_cap_hits": 38237, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38237, "child_moves_before_total": 3103827, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3103827, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 456647, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 456647, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.17339226403745, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.94254256348563, "tt_hits": 19591, "tt_cutoffs": 3331, "beta_cutoffs": 30893, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 5.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 5.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1462.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1865.6363636363637, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1192, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 60649, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 128, 113, 155, 99, 85, 114, 115, 129, 144, 69, 84, 145, 83, 82, 125, 95, 100, 157, 172, 130, 68, 52, 56, 70, 185, 111, 86, 87, 116, 132, 71, 101, 26, 41, 53, 38, 143, 140, 57, 54, 158, 22, 6, 37, 67, 39, 40, 24, 9, 66, 10, 80 ], "move_count": 59, "black_stats": { "move_count": 30, "search_move_count": 28, "total_time_ms": 43316, "avg_search_time_ms": 1547.0, "search_nodes": 490145, "safety_nodes": 1360, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 491505, "avg_nodes": 17553.75, "eval_calls": 296503, "avg_eval_calls": 10589.392857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 296503, "pattern_eval_ns": 6028557, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.332195627025698, "pattern_frame_queries": 296503, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6028557, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.332195627025698, "pattern_frame_updates": 979950, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 10036917850, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10242.275473238431, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 181083, "avg_candidate_generations": 6467.25, "candidate_moves_total": 17403315, "avg_candidate_moves": 96.10684050960057, "candidate_moves_max": 136, "root_candidate_generations": 28, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2390, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 181055, "search_candidate_moves_total": 17400925, "search_candidate_moves_max": 136, "legality_checks": 4232977, "avg_legality_checks": 151177.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10274, "root_legality_checks": 2390, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 4230587, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10268, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13495860, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 481995.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24540327603, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1818.3596749669898, "renju_forbidden_checks": 140239, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5008.535714285715, "renju_forbidden_ns": 552214112, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3937.6643587019303, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11278, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 97808344, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 61673, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 300299981, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 67258, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 153797722, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 308065, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 332794, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11885.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2324772241, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6985.619455278641, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 430747, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15383.82142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 975349039, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2264.319981334751, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8412807882, "stage_ordering_ns": 5417190879, "stage_eval_ns": 10042946407, "stage_threat_ns": 19238108358, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 3969184, "root_tactical_annotations": 8302, "search_tactical_annotations": 3960882, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 979978, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4798241271, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3171761, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 13513720381, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 362335, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9295500480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 489975, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 656416437, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 979950, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 107793841, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1304967, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 919988152, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1504437, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3298002498, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1159780, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 161936428, "child_limit_applications": 181055, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 181055, "child_cap_hits": 181055, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 181055, "child_moves_before_total": 17390657, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 17390657, "child_moves_before_max": 136, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 136, "child_moves_after_total": 1761404, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1761404, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 96.0517908922703, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.728557620612522, "tt_hits": 102562, "tt_cutoffs": 12421, "beta_cutoffs": 152137, "depth_sum": 165, "avg_depth": 5.892857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 165, "avg_effective_depth": 5.892857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.17857142857142858, "pooled_budget_moves": 28, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.17857142857142858, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3790.535714285714, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4006.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 17306, "avg_search_time_ms": 640.9629629629629, "search_nodes": 176333, "safety_nodes": 2364, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 178697, "avg_nodes": 6618.407407407408, "eval_calls": 118565, "avg_eval_calls": 4391.2962962962965, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 118565, "pattern_eval_ns": 2353968, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.85381858052545, "pattern_frame_queries": 118565, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2353968, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.85381858052545, "pattern_frame_updates": 352408, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2702654895, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7669.107667816848, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 54368, "avg_candidate_generations": 2013.6296296296296, "candidate_moves_total": 5028368, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.48763978811066, "candidate_moves_max": 132, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2309, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 54341, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5026059, "search_candidate_moves_max": 132, "legality_checks": 3526894, "avg_legality_checks": 130625.70370370371, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11284, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3526894, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7071720, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 261915.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11167263467, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1579.1438952616902, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38174, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1413.851851851852, "renju_forbidden_ns": 196468055, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5146.645753654319, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11330, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 104257773, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8078, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64012790, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18736, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27875432, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 322060, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 265606, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9837.25925925926, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1878359944, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7071.978584821126, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 339801, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12585.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 811635962, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2388.5626057604304, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6299951331, "stage_ordering_ns": 1411934658, "stage_eval_ns": 2705008863, "stage_threat_ns": 6734420839, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1266931, "root_tactical_annotations": 4117, "search_tactical_annotations": 1262814, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 352435, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1558838894, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1191968, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4908565075, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 108865, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2373403554, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 176204, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 212907446, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 352408, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34472454, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 569210, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1136320590, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 513873, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1398361908, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 183848, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19636970, "child_limit_applications": 54341, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 54341, "child_cap_hits": 54341, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 54341, "child_moves_before_total": 5014775, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5014775, "child_moves_before_max": 131, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 131, "child_moves_after_total": 876282, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 876282, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 92.28345080142066, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.125614177140648, "tt_hits": 20368, "tt_cutoffs": 3299, "beta_cutoffs": 46738, "depth_sum": 128, "avg_depth": 4.7407407407407405, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 128, "avg_effective_depth": 4.7407407407407405, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 24 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.037037037037037035, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07407407407407407, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.037037037037037035, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6758.2962962962965, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7054.592592592592, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1882, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1193, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24064, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 113, 114, 126, 98, 66, 110, 96, 81, 156, 141, 80, 100, 86, 99, 64, 48, 101, 84, 69, 129, 144, 130, 146, 131, 132, 127 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8002, "avg_search_time_ms": 615.5384615384615, "search_nodes": 95523, "safety_nodes": 1033, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 96556, "avg_nodes": 7427.384615384615, "eval_calls": 70768, "avg_eval_calls": 5443.692307692308, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70768, "pattern_eval_ns": 1460155, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.63298383450147, "pattern_frame_queries": 70768, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1460155, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.63298383450147, "pattern_frame_updates": 190926, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1792436754, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9388.122906256875, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23508, "avg_candidate_generations": 1808.3076923076924, "candidate_moves_total": 1802896, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.69287051216607, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 943, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 23495, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1801953, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 755858, "avg_legality_checks": 58142.92307692308, "illegal_moves_skipped": 94, "root_legality_checks": 943, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 754915, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 94, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2195853, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 168911.76923076922, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4700754305, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2140.7418005667955, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13747, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1057.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37501152, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2727.9516985524115, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 208, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 879851, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3540, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21867618, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9999, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14753683, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 56435, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4341.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 514824744, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9122.437210950651, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76903, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5915.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 237444512, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3087.5845155585607, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1810140351, "stage_ordering_ns": 743355690, "stage_eval_ns": 1793896909, "stage_threat_ns": 3609314657, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 280917, "root_tactical_annotations": 1496, "search_tactical_annotations": 279421, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 190939, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1075017848, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 271078, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2374176011, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47076, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1632913752, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 95463, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 131733610, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 190926, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22647948, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62099, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 87802486, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 161893, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 652896800, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 56925, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5739240, "child_limit_applications": 23495, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23495, "child_cap_hits": 23495, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23495, "child_moves_before_total": 1801859, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1801859, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 376413, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 376413, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.69116833368801, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02098318791232, "tt_hits": 8412, "tt_cutoffs": 1200, "beta_cutoffs": 18884, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5152.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5767.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1005, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 16048, "avg_search_time_ms": 1234.4615384615386, "search_nodes": 124906, "safety_nodes": 398, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 125304, "avg_nodes": 9638.76923076923, "eval_calls": 81429, "avg_eval_calls": 6263.7692307692305, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 81429, "pattern_eval_ns": 1714957, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.060764592467056, "pattern_frame_queries": 81429, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1714957, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.060764592467056, "pattern_frame_updates": 249676, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2233759664, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8946.633493006937, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 40804, "avg_candidate_generations": 3138.769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 3605371, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.358273698657, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 982, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 40791, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3604389, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 2491270, "avg_legality_checks": 191636.15384615384, "illegal_moves_skipped": 75, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2491270, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5171643, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 397818.6923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10564495034, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2042.7734540067827, "renju_forbidden_checks": 62702, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4823.2307692307695, "renju_forbidden_ns": 105654432, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1685.024911486077, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1515, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4275670, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5039, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20432729, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 56148, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 80946033, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 169115, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13008.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1580412515, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9345.19418738728, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 236980, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18229.23076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 775094218, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3270.715748164402, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5805913226, "stage_ordering_ns": 1431053498, "stage_eval_ns": 2235474621, "stage_threat_ns": 6480291148, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 626746, "root_tactical_annotations": 3369, "search_tactical_annotations": 623377, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 249689, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1466854798, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 539449, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4779787735, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 81675, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2730357062, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124838, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 182759012, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 249676, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31119604, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 138034, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 601857258, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 319731, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1447519535, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 168981, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19769999, "child_limit_applications": 40791, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 40791, "child_cap_hits": 40791, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 40791, "child_moves_before_total": 3604314, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3604314, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 416963, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 416963, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.36052070309627, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.221936211419186, "tt_hits": 21016, "tt_cutoffs": 2619, "beta_cutoffs": 31580, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 5.153846153846154, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 5.153846153846154, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4347.307692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4962.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1426, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1194, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 64536, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 126, 127, 79, 143, 159, 142, 157, 141, 140, 109, 108, 155, 124, 156, 80, 81, 94, 66, 78, 169, 183, 51, 96, 36, 21, 76, 95, 93, 125, 123, 64, 139, 171, 91, 107, 145, 144, 106, 61, 154, 49, 34, 48, 32, 35, 136, 121, 152, 153, 184, 199, 168, 120, 200 ], "move_count": 61, "black_stats": { "move_count": 31, "search_move_count": 29, "total_time_ms": 41047, "avg_search_time_ms": 1415.4137931034484, "search_nodes": 414994, "safety_nodes": 1772, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 416766, "avg_nodes": 14371.241379310344, "eval_calls": 245515, "avg_eval_calls": 8466.034482758621, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 245515, "pattern_eval_ns": 5360812, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.834967313606093, "pattern_frame_queries": 245515, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5360812, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.834967313606093, "pattern_frame_updates": 829634, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8026319246, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9674.53026997447, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 158395, "avg_candidate_generations": 5461.896551724138, "candidate_moves_total": 15092744, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.28548249629092, "candidate_moves_max": 132, "root_candidate_generations": 29, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2503, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 158366, "search_candidate_moves_total": 15090241, "search_candidate_moves_max": 132, "legality_checks": 4368653, "avg_legality_checks": 150643.2068965517, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1006, "root_legality_checks": 2503, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4366150, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1006, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11716244, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 404008.4137931034, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23654916740, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2018.984645591198, "renju_forbidden_checks": 59028, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2035.448275862069, "renju_forbidden_ns": 170254688, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2884.3038557972486, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1899, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10399523, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18642, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 98917702, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 38486, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 60935963, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1500, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 246655, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8505.344827586207, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1834784009, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7438.665378767914, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 315093, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10865.275862068966, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 745954313, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2367.409980545426, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9606980542, "stage_ordering_ns": 5200907307, "stage_eval_ns": 8031680058, "stage_threat_ns": 17998146636, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 3474972, "root_tactical_annotations": 9990, "search_tactical_annotations": 3464982, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 829663, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4523845426, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2813069, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 12634338697, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 316966, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8902970278, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 414817, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 610957892, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 829634, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 99774300, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1104938, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 492634650, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1391139, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3238114127, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 978895, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 129230321, "child_limit_applications": 158366, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 158366, "child_cap_hits": 158366, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 158366, "child_moves_before_total": 15089235, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 15089235, "child_moves_before_max": 132, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 132, "child_moves_after_total": 1481452, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1481452, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.28077365090992, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.354608943838956, "tt_hits": 86195, "tt_cutoffs": 10938, "beta_cutoffs": 128284, "depth_sum": 174, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 174, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.10344827586206896, "pooled_budget_moves": 29, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.27586206896551724, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.10344827586206896, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4566.620689655172, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4842.482758620689, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 30, "search_move_count": 28, "total_time_ms": 23462, "avg_search_time_ms": 837.9285714285714, "search_nodes": 220785, "safety_nodes": 1855, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 222640, "avg_nodes": 7951.428571428572, "eval_calls": 148327, "avg_eval_calls": 5297.392857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 148327, "pattern_eval_ns": 3201253, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.58240239470899, "pattern_frame_queries": 148327, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3201253, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.58240239470899, "pattern_frame_updates": 441300, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2938867522, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6659.5683707228645, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 68071, "avg_candidate_generations": 2431.1071428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 6514284, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.69837375681274, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 28, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2434, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 68043, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6511850, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 4625571, "avg_legality_checks": 165198.9642857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 31, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4625571, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 31, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8054725, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 287668.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15236749886, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1891.6536425514216, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29239, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1044.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 28326153, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 968.7798146311434, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 181431, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2184, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13134307, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 27018, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15010415, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 231057, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8252.035714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1547232770, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6696.325019367516, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 273622, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9772.214285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 558405714, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2040.7924582087699, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9586877093, "stage_ordering_ns": 2177727795, "stage_eval_ns": 2942068775, "stage_threat_ns": 8551796540, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1407330, "root_tactical_annotations": 5246, "search_tactical_annotations": 1402084, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 441328, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2315011915, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1297099, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5839929880, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 136277, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3534969429, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 220650, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 312319020, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 441300, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50924314, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 609321, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 882509110, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 551483, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1422117191, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 246526, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33611411, "child_limit_applications": 68043, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 68043, "child_cap_hits": 68043, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 68043, "child_moves_before_total": 6511819, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6511819, "child_moves_before_max": 131, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 131, "child_moves_after_total": 1089265, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1089265, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.70152697558896, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.008479931807827, "tt_hits": 29661, "tt_cutoffs": 4280, "beta_cutoffs": 58366, "depth_sum": 135, "avg_depth": 4.821428571428571, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 135, "avg_effective_depth": 4.821428571428571, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 26 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 28, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6838.785714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7124.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1877, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1195, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19123, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 67, 82, 98, 96, 68, 111, 141, 66, 81, 110, 83, 124, 138, 113, 53, 38, 39, 95, 25 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8716, "avg_search_time_ms": 871.6, "search_nodes": 100806, "safety_nodes": 314, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 101120, "avg_nodes": 10112.0, "eval_calls": 78770, "avg_eval_calls": 7877.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 78770, "pattern_eval_ns": 1710496, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.715069188777452, "pattern_frame_queries": 78770, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1710496, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.715069188777452, "pattern_frame_updates": 201528, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2512530235, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12467.400237187885, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20773, "avg_candidate_generations": 2077.3, "candidate_moves_total": 1492526, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.8493236412651, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 626, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 20763, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1491900, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 691297, "avg_legality_checks": 69129.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1606, "root_legality_checks": 626, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 690671, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1604, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2279145, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 227914.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5197431391, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2280.430332866053, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20624, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2062.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 106411384, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5159.5899922420485, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1676, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16219680, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9748, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 66031189, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9190, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24045585, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 114930, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58665, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5866.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 543748224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9268.698951674764, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 83865, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8386.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 239471169, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2855.436344124486, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1786014372, "stage_ordering_ns": 651312058, "stage_eval_ns": 2514240731, "stage_threat_ns": 3720640259, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 267808, "root_tactical_annotations": 1515, "search_tactical_annotations": 266293, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 201538, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1206176524, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 255010, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2334841780, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41587, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1555320655, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 100764, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 147387750, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 201528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25451637, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56369, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 83090813, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 157047, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 696303181, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 54392, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6782568, "child_limit_applications": 20763, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20763, "child_cap_hits": 20763, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20763, "child_moves_before_total": 1490296, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1490296, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 332553, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 332553, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.77652555025767, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01661609593989, "tt_hits": 7089, "tt_cutoffs": 1232, "beta_cutoffs": 15752, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 4.1, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 4.1, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3580.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4380.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10398, "avg_search_time_ms": 1155.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 69676, "safety_nodes": 525, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 70201, "avg_nodes": 7800.111111111111, "eval_calls": 38661, "avg_eval_calls": 4295.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38661, "pattern_eval_ns": 842554, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.79338351310106, "pattern_frame_queries": 38661, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 842554, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.79338351310106, "pattern_frame_updates": 139260, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1329983564, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9550.363090621859, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28069, "avg_candidate_generations": 3118.777777777778, "candidate_moves_total": 2073601, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.87512914603299, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 569, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 28060, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2073032, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 1572642, "avg_legality_checks": 174738.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6327, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1572642, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6327, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3163080, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 351453.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6971567169, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2204.0438967715013, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33649, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3738.777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 164261594, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4881.618889120034, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 64124816, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6777, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64497242, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20529, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 35525356, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 114180, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90787, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10087.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 879409558, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9686.514126471851, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 128106, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14234.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 409916184, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3199.820336284015, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3976390990, "stage_ordering_ns": 874507319, "stage_eval_ns": 1330826118, "stage_threat_ns": 4146300748, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 448684, "root_tactical_annotations": 1460, "search_tactical_annotations": 447224, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 139269, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 854107255, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 358128, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3149084445, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56184, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1951509159, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 69630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105433916, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 139260, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17778119, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 93329, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 181453628, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 208608, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1015994777, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 146747, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19897013, "child_limit_applications": 28060, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28060, "child_cap_hits": 28060, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28060, "child_moves_before_total": 2066705, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2066705, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 239315, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 239315, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.65306486101211, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.528688524590164, "tt_hits": 16081, "tt_cutoffs": 2911, "beta_cutoffs": 22673, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 4.888888888888889, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 4.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1635.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2482.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1196, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22020, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 96, 98, 82, 127, 128, 144, 110, 124, 80, 64, 125, 95, 79, 81, 67, 52, 69, 68, 111, 83, 109, 113, 108 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 16852, "avg_search_time_ms": 1404.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 161019, "safety_nodes": 223, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 161242, "avg_nodes": 13436.833333333334, "eval_calls": 105363, "avg_eval_calls": 8780.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105363, "pattern_eval_ns": 2299138, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.821113673680514, "pattern_frame_queries": 105363, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2299138, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.821113673680514, "pattern_frame_updates": 321926, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4463208905, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13864.083376303872, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52428, "avg_candidate_generations": 4369.0, "candidate_moves_total": 4147988, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.1177996490425, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 776, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 52416, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4147212, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1182333, "avg_legality_checks": 98527.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4639, "root_legality_checks": 776, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 1181557, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4356451, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 363037.5833333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9882958107, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2268.5801141800976, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58903, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4908.583333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 307318498, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5217.365804797718, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5299, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53162343, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27599, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 179484205, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25985, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 74440559, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 231391, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 95471, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7955.916666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 870033204, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9113.062647296038, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 128262, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10688.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 362494961, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2826.206990379068, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3017803221, "stage_ordering_ns": 1751003044, "stage_eval_ns": 4465508043, "stage_threat_ns": 7561808877, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 745493, "root_tactical_annotations": 3328, "search_tactical_annotations": 742165, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 321938, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1994790689, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 629884, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5242425690, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 104911, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3810632183, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 160963, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 250766248, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 321926, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42520972, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 147435, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 163158740, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 377527, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1268560177, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 220531, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 31305278, "child_limit_applications": 52416, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52416, "child_cap_hits": 52416, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52416, "child_moves_before_total": 4142577, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4142577, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 459266, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 459266, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.03268086080585, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.761942918192918, "tt_hits": 24772, "tt_cutoffs": 3186, "beta_cutoffs": 40114, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 4.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 4.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3030.4166666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3630.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5156, "avg_search_time_ms": 468.72727272727275, "search_nodes": 47149, "safety_nodes": 879, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48028, "avg_nodes": 4366.181818181818, "eval_calls": 33368, "avg_eval_calls": 3033.4545454545455, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33368, "pattern_eval_ns": 729482, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.86172380724047, "pattern_frame_queries": 33368, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 729482, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.86172380724047, "pattern_frame_updates": 94198, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 968157258, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10277.896112444001, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12935, "avg_candidate_generations": 1175.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 973004, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.22257441051411, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 715, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 12924, "search_candidate_moves_total": 972289, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 569781, "avg_legality_checks": 51798.27272727273, "illegal_moves_skipped": 740, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 569781, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 740, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1496336, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 136030.54545454544, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3250089027, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2172.0315671079225, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19776, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1797.8181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 58111008, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2938.4611650485435, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 756, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8330704, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2403, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20979209, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16597, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28545084, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 256011, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 57173, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5197.545454545455, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 550534211, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9629.26925296906, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84345, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7667.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 246234058, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2919.3675736558184, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1426149017, "stage_ordering_ns": 413660597, "stage_eval_ns": 968886740, "stage_threat_ns": 2311296769, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 190803, "root_tactical_annotations": 701, "search_tactical_annotations": 190102, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 94209, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 581175201, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 184130, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1643873755, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25920, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 934605523, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47099, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 70072086, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 94198, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12056949, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 54627, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 204186745, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 103576, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 504878827, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 32600, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4118778, "child_limit_applications": 12924, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12924, "child_cap_hits": 12924, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12924, "child_moves_before_total": 971549, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 971549, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 206810, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 206810, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.17401733209533, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002011761064686, "tt_hits": 4009, "tt_cutoffs": 807, "beta_cutoffs": 10744, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5268.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5995.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1197, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22027, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 82, 124, 114, 98, 84, 125, 127, 153, 139, 140, 154, 156, 108, 157, 54, 68, 69, 99, 24, 39, 83, 141, 171, 109, 93, 173 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 9679, "avg_search_time_ms": 645.2666666666667, "search_nodes": 107667, "safety_nodes": 793, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 108460, "avg_nodes": 7230.666666666667, "eval_calls": 76997, "avg_eval_calls": 5133.133333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 76997, "pattern_eval_ns": 1657790, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.530579113471955, "pattern_frame_queries": 76997, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1657790, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.530579113471955, "pattern_frame_updates": 215200, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2319734239, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10779.434196096654, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29120, "avg_candidate_generations": 1941.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 2333624, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.13818681318682, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1078, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 29105, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2332546, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 778566, "avg_legality_checks": 51904.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1080, "root_legality_checks": 1078, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 777488, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1079, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2618163, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 174544.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5606390992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2141.3452836970046, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23385, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1559.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 98422677, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4208.795253367543, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1159, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10252166, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7862, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 58614440, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14357, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29498471, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57600, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 80068, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5337.866666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 671655447, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8388.562809112254, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 107977, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7198.466666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 282618852, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2617.3986311899757, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1875520290, "stage_ordering_ns": 940850374, "stage_eval_ns": 2321392029, "stage_threat_ns": 4489725553, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 476079, "root_tactical_annotations": 2611, "search_tactical_annotations": 473468, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 215215, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1260040029, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 415673, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3036014959, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58306, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2066829847, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 107600, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 154430570, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 215200, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26729235, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 147613, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 210403885, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 209743, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 758384056, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 118723, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12510760, "child_limit_applications": 29105, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29105, "child_cap_hits": 29105, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29105, "child_moves_before_total": 2331467, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2331467, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 465782, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 465782, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.10537708297544, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00350455248239, "tt_hits": 12882, "tt_cutoffs": 1498, "beta_cutoffs": 24104, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5478.933333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6012.266666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 900, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 12331, "avg_search_time_ms": 880.7857142857143, "search_nodes": 91180, "safety_nodes": 1369, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92549, "avg_nodes": 6610.642857142857, "eval_calls": 55899, "avg_eval_calls": 3992.785714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 55899, "pattern_eval_ns": 1219736, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.820354568060253, "pattern_frame_queries": 55899, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1219736, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.820354568060253, "pattern_frame_updates": 182192, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1982811940, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10883.090036884167, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32695, "avg_candidate_generations": 2335.3571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 2580539, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.92763419483101, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1000, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 32681, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2579539, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 1661599, "avg_legality_checks": 118685.64285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1146, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1661599, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1146, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3903706, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 278836.14285714284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8124334416, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2081.1850113712458, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29314, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2093.8571428571427, "renju_forbidden_ns": 80468285, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2745.046223647404, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1437, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9455040, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6514, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 46262623, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21358, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24692732, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57890, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 149534, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10681.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1315386615, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8796.572117377988, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 208492, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14892.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 574833254, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2757.0998119831934, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3924239682, "stage_ordering_ns": 1035721415, "stage_eval_ns": 1984031676, "stage_threat_ns": 5309289389, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 563726, "root_tactical_annotations": 1460, "search_tactical_annotations": 562266, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 182206, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1105685939, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 472398, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4024442821, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 65474, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2309061878, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91096, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 137213709, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 182192, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23375269, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 131908, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 556332463, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 275005, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1158762209, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 156813, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18571651, "child_limit_applications": 32681, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32681, "child_cap_hits": 32681, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32681, "child_moves_before_total": 2578393, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2578393, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 336430, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 336430, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.89578042287567, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.294360637679386, "tt_hits": 16551, "tt_cutoffs": 2516, "beta_cutoffs": 26353, "depth_sum": 83, "avg_depth": 5.928571428571429, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 83, "avg_effective_depth": 5.928571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4699.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5271.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 246, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1198, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23589, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 68, 82, 114, 98, 140, 97, 67, 129, 145, 125, 83, 124, 123, 139, 153, 109, 154, 93, 141, 79, 94, 65, 81, 51, 37, 107 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 18600, "avg_search_time_ms": 1240.0, "search_nodes": 258016, "safety_nodes": 211, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 258227, "avg_nodes": 17215.133333333335, "eval_calls": 173208, "avg_eval_calls": 11547.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 173208, "pattern_eval_ns": 3273201, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.89751628100319, "pattern_frame_queries": 173208, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3273201, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.89751628100319, "pattern_frame_updates": 515894, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5334928386, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10341.132841242581, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 78845, "avg_candidate_generations": 5256.333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 6554626, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.1330585325639, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1076, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 78830, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6553550, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1860583, "avg_legality_checks": 124038.86666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5851, "root_legality_checks": 1076, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1859507, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5850, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7018819, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 467921.26666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10607278402, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1511.2625645425535, "renju_forbidden_checks": 177505, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11833.666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 456709772, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2572.940322807808, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 20651, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 60599510, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 74317, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 267117243, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 82434, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 128827156, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 103, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 165863, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 165458, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11030.533333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1007097745, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6086.72741722975, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 213564, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14237.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 406193461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1901.975337603716, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3221180005, "stage_ordering_ns": 1769010097, "stage_eval_ns": 5338201587, "stage_threat_ns": 8181062982, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1671463, "root_tactical_annotations": 4193, "search_tactical_annotations": 1667270, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 515909, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2190682824, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1255805, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5574196849, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 157758, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3877021152, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 257947, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 292258499, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 515894, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48262177, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 399192, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 254380387, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 698841, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1442703359, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 573430, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 75662633, "child_limit_applications": 78830, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 78830, "child_cap_hits": 78830, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 78830, "child_moves_before_total": 6547700, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6547700, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 947356, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 947356, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.06101737917037, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.017708994037802, "tt_hits": 43169, "tt_cutoffs": 5910, "beta_cutoffs": 60084, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3561.4666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4094.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 554, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 4975, "avg_search_time_ms": 355.35714285714283, "search_nodes": 50710, "safety_nodes": 1415, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 52125, "avg_nodes": 3723.214285714286, "eval_calls": 34499, "avg_eval_calls": 2464.214285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34499, "pattern_eval_ns": 703374, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.388243137482245, "pattern_frame_queries": 34499, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 703374, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.388243137482245, "pattern_frame_updates": 101290, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 998841039, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9861.200898410505, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15297, "avg_candidate_generations": 1092.642857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 1143967, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.78374844740799, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 994, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 15283, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1142973, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 555467, "avg_legality_checks": 39676.21428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2040, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 555467, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2040, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1585402, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 113243.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3068847558, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1935.6904797647537, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18435, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1316.7857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 76213154, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4134.15535665853, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3113, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22291274, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5944, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35555074, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9265, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18182165, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 113, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 184641, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3607.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 468715701, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9281.131460140192, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5150.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 223376263, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3098.145117891817, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1276139158, "stage_ordering_ns": 416145637, "stage_eval_ns": 999544413, "stage_threat_ns": 2255167208, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 256827, "root_tactical_annotations": 646, "search_tactical_annotations": 256181, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 101304, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 542086422, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 249026, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1627987609, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30659, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 976205882, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50645, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 69159882, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 101290, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11307495, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 150231502, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 156287, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 501253435, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 38470, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4625800, "child_limit_applications": 15283, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15283, "child_cap_hits": 15283, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15283, "child_moves_before_total": 1140933, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1140933, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 247022, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 247022, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.6537329058431, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.163187855787477, "tt_hits": 4591, "tt_cutoffs": 863, "beta_cutoffs": 13051, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5775.785714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6347.214285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1829, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1199, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26900, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 66, 97, 98, 84, 99, 113, 129, 126, 130, 111, 141, 83, 125, 82, 85, 68, 131, 128, 132, 133, 110, 100, 142, 52, 36, 116 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 9083, "avg_search_time_ms": 698.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 136315, "safety_nodes": 1017, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 137332, "avg_nodes": 10564.0, "eval_calls": 107608, "avg_eval_calls": 8277.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107608, "pattern_eval_ns": 2112657, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.632899040963498, "pattern_frame_queries": 107608, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2112657, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.632899040963498, "pattern_frame_updates": 272510, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2427502948, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8907.940802172398, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27082, "avg_candidate_generations": 2083.230769230769, "candidate_moves_total": 1926483, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.13518203973119, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 825, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 27069, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1925658, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 1026735, "avg_legality_checks": 78979.61538461539, "illegal_moves_skipped": 132, "root_legality_checks": 825, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1025910, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 131, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2873782, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 221060.15384615384, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5343810832, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1859.5045942942088, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12768, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 982.1538461538462, "renju_forbidden_ns": 35121499, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2750.7439692982457, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 193, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1362473, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4648, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24791232, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7914, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8900214, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 67580, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 62008, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4769.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 467669796, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7542.088053154432, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 85257, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6558.2307692307695, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 207857532, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2438.0113304479396, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2084885704, "stage_ordering_ns": 684209051, "stage_eval_ns": 2429615605, "stage_threat_ns": 3827693291, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 316529, "root_tactical_annotations": 1477, "search_tactical_annotations": 315052, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 272523, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1306479081, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 314929, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2319371184, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54224, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1607470457, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 136255, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 167780960, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 272510, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28138751, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 65334, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 67410295, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 195359, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 643761728, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 55836, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5923315, "child_limit_applications": 27069, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27069, "child_cap_hits": 27069, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27069, "child_moves_before_total": 1925527, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1925527, "child_moves_before_max": 97, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 97, "child_moves_after_total": 433114, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 433114, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.13402785474159, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000369426280987, "tt_hits": 8677, "tt_cutoffs": 1578, "beta_cutoffs": 19996, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4403.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5018.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 245, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 17803, "avg_search_time_ms": 1369.4615384615386, "search_nodes": 156888, "safety_nodes": 232, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 157120, "avg_nodes": 12086.153846153846, "eval_calls": 93219, "avg_eval_calls": 7170.692307692308, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 93219, "pattern_eval_ns": 1903004, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.414336133191732, "pattern_frame_queries": 93219, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1903004, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.414336133191732, "pattern_frame_updates": 313634, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2418504536, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7711.231996530988, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 58490, "avg_candidate_generations": 4499.2307692307695, "candidate_moves_total": 4400356, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.23262096084801, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 861, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 58477, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4399495, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 3241029, "avg_legality_checks": 249309.92307692306, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1184, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3241029, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1184, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6166102, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 474315.53846153844, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11783461752, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1911.006621687413, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36586, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2814.3076923076924, "renju_forbidden_ns": 63663938, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1740.117476630405, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1367, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10975614, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4306, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30218052, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30903, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22361702, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 108570, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 124970, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9613.076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 994943001, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7961.454757141714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 165446, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12726.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 426159746, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2575.823809581374, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6766577214, "stage_ordering_ns": 1576159859, "stage_eval_ns": 2420407540, "stage_threat_ns": 6915493018, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 881288, "root_tactical_annotations": 3854, "search_tactical_annotations": 877434, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 313647, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1640628537, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 736515, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4995343184, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 117050, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3460681787, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 156817, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 212873376, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 313634, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35733457, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 214317, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 343383689, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 405138, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1191265908, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 261833, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30914464, "child_limit_applications": 58477, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 58477, "child_cap_hits": 58477, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 58477, "child_moves_before_total": 4398311, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4398311, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 502070, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 502070, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.21437488243241, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.585768763787472, "tt_hits": 31396, "tt_cutoffs": 5123, "beta_cutoffs": 46915, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 5.153846153846154, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 5.153846153846154, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1457.3846153846155, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2072.769230769231, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1200, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17967, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 98, 54, 68, 84, 83, 53, 113, 128, 99, 85, 81, 129, 115, 131, 65, 49, 67, 51, 66, 64, 69 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 14186, "avg_search_time_ms": 1182.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 151348, "safety_nodes": 349, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 151697, "avg_nodes": 12641.416666666666, "eval_calls": 103540, "avg_eval_calls": 8628.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 103540, "pattern_eval_ns": 2142837, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.695740776511492, "pattern_frame_queries": 103540, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2142837, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.695740776511492, "pattern_frame_updates": 302588, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4200123734, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13880.668546009756, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 45109, "avg_candidate_generations": 3759.0833333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 3268666, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.46150435611519, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 756, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 45097, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3267910, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 891084, "avg_legality_checks": 74257.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1438, "root_legality_checks": 756, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 890328, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1438, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3948694, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 329057.8333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8422090595, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2132.880034512677, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31363, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2613.5833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 185731556, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5921.995854988362, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1621, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13424598, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17957, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 134873181, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11782, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37429367, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4410, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 105407, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8783.916666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 855492802, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8116.090980674908, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 136179, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11348.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 335587425, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2464.3111272663186, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2124817410, "stage_ordering_ns": 1283278720, "stage_eval_ns": 4202266571, "stage_threat_ns": 6531755511, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 779039, "root_tactical_annotations": 2666, "search_tactical_annotations": 776373, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 302600, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1774798247, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 600304, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4463856908, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90271, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3156318796, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 151294, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 218754978, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 302588, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37615572, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 185646, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 206444147, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 324376, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1100897043, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 269017, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 36729806, "child_limit_applications": 45097, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 45097, "child_cap_hits": 45097, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 45097, "child_moves_before_total": 3266472, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3266472, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 466233, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 466233, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.43213517528882, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.338448233807126, "tt_hits": 24982, "tt_cutoffs": 2657, "beta_cutoffs": 35405, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3522.9166666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4189.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 685, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3769, "avg_search_time_ms": 342.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 34165, "safety_nodes": 845, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35010, "avg_nodes": 3182.7272727272725, "eval_calls": 22662, "avg_eval_calls": 2060.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22662, "pattern_eval_ns": 475892, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.999558732680256, "pattern_frame_queries": 22662, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 475892, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.999558732680256, "pattern_frame_updates": 68230, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 682905677, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10008.87698959402, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10781, "avg_candidate_generations": 980.0909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 758125, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.32047119933216, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 681, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 10770, "search_candidate_moves_total": 757444, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 438225, "avg_legality_checks": 39838.63636363636, "illegal_moves_skipped": 130, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 438225, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 130, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1163276, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 105752.36363636363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2412160458, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2073.592559289455, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4287, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 389.72727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 17673970, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4122.68952647539, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 132, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1201606, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1454, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12576508, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2701, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3895856, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42197, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3836.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 383063505, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9077.979595705856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 57586, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5235.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 171535102, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2978.7639704094745, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1042767974, "stage_ordering_ns": 311378036, "stage_eval_ns": 683381569, "stage_threat_ns": 1701853071, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 159923, "root_tactical_annotations": 626, "search_tactical_annotations": 159297, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 68241, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 402275702, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 154665, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1240162293, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21612, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 730217083, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34115, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 48339025, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 68230, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8237154, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 40333, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 143384734, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 92713, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 366339024, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 26877, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2838897, "child_limit_applications": 10770, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10770, "child_cap_hits": 10770, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10770, "child_moves_before_total": 757314, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 757314, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 172915, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 172915, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.31699164345405, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.055246053853296, "tt_hits": 3744, "tt_cutoffs": 683, "beta_cutoffs": 9303, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5502.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6229.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1881, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1201, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21065, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 67, 82, 96, 98, 66, 113, 143, 114, 68, 69, 81, 111, 53, 39, 38, 23, 64, 65, 80, 48, 52, 24, 94 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10489, "avg_search_time_ms": 874.0833333333334, "search_nodes": 124805, "safety_nodes": 188, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 124993, "avg_nodes": 10416.083333333334, "eval_calls": 90583, "avg_eval_calls": 7548.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 90583, "pattern_eval_ns": 1865459, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.593919388847798, "pattern_frame_queries": 90583, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1865459, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.593919388847798, "pattern_frame_updates": 249506, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2774672634, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11120.664969980682, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32284, "avg_candidate_generations": 2690.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2417085, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.86943997026391, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 782, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 32272, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2416303, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 862536, "avg_legality_checks": 71878.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1377, "root_legality_checks": 782, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 861754, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1377, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2869276, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 239106.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6140643274, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2140.136840791893, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24803, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2066.9166666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 133315983, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5374.994274886102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1497, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13012859, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12708, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 86877859, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10598, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 33425265, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67178, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5598.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 548651243, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8167.1267825776295, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89558, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7463.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 220392212, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2460.888050202104, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2079409526, "stage_ordering_ns": 948549150, "stage_eval_ns": 2776538093, "stage_threat_ns": 4632222303, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 483312, "root_tactical_annotations": 2905, "search_tactical_annotations": 480407, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 249518, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1399060205, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 431369, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3018150715, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64619, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2162483370, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124753, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 172456740, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 249506, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29516311, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 147449, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 111912164, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 219290, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 743630441, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 116573, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13038332, "child_limit_applications": 32272, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32272, "child_cap_hits": 32272, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32272, "child_moves_before_total": 2414926, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2414926, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 519882, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 519882, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.8303792761527, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.109382746653445, "tt_hits": 13446, "tt_cutoffs": 1899, "beta_cutoffs": 26483, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4141.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4807.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10565, "avg_search_time_ms": 960.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 82271, "safety_nodes": 865, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 83136, "avg_nodes": 7557.818181818182, "eval_calls": 46024, "avg_eval_calls": 4184.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46024, "pattern_eval_ns": 957844, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.811837302277073, "pattern_frame_queries": 46024, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 957844, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.811837302277073, "pattern_frame_updates": 164418, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1478201959, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8990.511738374144, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32734, "avg_candidate_generations": 2975.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2448690, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.80570660475347, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 723, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 32723, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2447967, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 1656434, "avg_legality_checks": 150584.9090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1476, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1656434, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1476, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3342725, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 303884.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6992998720, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2092.005390811389, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21300, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1936.3636363636363, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65780128, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3088.2689201877934, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1482, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13228222, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4988, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 36407719, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14830, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16144187, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75830, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6893.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 631729800, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8330.869049188976, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98174, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8924.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 264200062, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2691.14085195673, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3859913859, "stage_ordering_ns": 954620348, "stage_eval_ns": 1479159803, "stage_threat_ns": 4200204161, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 526019, "root_tactical_annotations": 1201, "search_tactical_annotations": 524818, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 164429, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 954894213, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 412508, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3081421490, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 65530, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2100622654, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 82209, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118943161, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 164418, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19923732, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96299, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 146834674, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 250671, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 833746231, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 179049, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 25021565, "child_limit_applications": 32723, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32723, "child_cap_hits": 32723, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32723, "child_moves_before_total": 2446491, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2446491, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 301916, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 301916, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.76365247685115, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.226415670934816, "tt_hits": 18803, "tt_cutoffs": 3462, "beta_cutoffs": 26810, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3198.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3925.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 492, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1202, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 34515, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 127, 142, 126, 114, 156, 82, 98, 84, 171, 100, 86, 141, 140, 154, 124, 108, 139, 125, 155, 123, 172, 188, 173, 170, 187, 203, 159, 201, 175, 174, 143, 111, 191 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 26460, "avg_search_time_ms": 1556.4705882352941, "search_nodes": 274387, "safety_nodes": 275, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 274662, "avg_nodes": 16156.588235294117, "eval_calls": 173211, "avg_eval_calls": 10188.882352941177, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 173211, "pattern_eval_ns": 3482369, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.104779719532825, "pattern_frame_queries": 173211, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3482369, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.104779719532825, "pattern_frame_updates": 548620, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6665070142, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12148.79177208268, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 92663, "avg_candidate_generations": 5450.764705882353, "candidate_moves_total": 8510281, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.84119875246863, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1338, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 92646, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8508943, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 2339560, "avg_legality_checks": 137621.17647058822, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2373, "root_legality_checks": 1338, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2338222, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2373, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7852581, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 461916.5294117647, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15419512998, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1963.6235523071969, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65120, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3830.5882352941176, "renju_forbidden_ns": 297601346, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4570.0452395577395, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2807, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19597413, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33663, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 199198410, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28650, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 78805523, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 163448, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9614.588235294117, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1289899028, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7891.800621604425, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 223155, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13126.764705882353, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 558460625, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2502.5682821357354, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5068244892, "stage_ordering_ns": 2934606334, "stage_eval_ns": 6668552511, "stage_threat_ns": 11692184963, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2041509, "root_tactical_annotations": 5181, "search_tactical_annotations": 2036328, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 548637, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2884680776, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1658590, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8293323545, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 185402, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5729964591, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 274310, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 374657531, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 548620, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63314953, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 498710, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 314237129, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 974463, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2249012575, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 568336, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 76208158, "child_limit_applications": 92646, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 92646, "child_cap_hits": 92646, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 92646, "child_moves_before_total": 8506570, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8506570, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 1203343, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1203343, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.81799538026466, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.988612568270621, "tt_hits": 48270, "tt_cutoffs": 8455, "beta_cutoffs": 72896, "depth_sum": 74, "avg_depth": 4.352941176470588, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 74, "avg_effective_depth": 4.352941176470588, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2343.529411764706, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2791.4117647058824, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 402, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 8039, "avg_search_time_ms": 502.4375, "search_nodes": 76161, "safety_nodes": 1660, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 77821, "avg_nodes": 4863.8125, "eval_calls": 53298, "avg_eval_calls": 3331.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53298, "pattern_eval_ns": 1101613, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.66893692070997, "pattern_frame_queries": 53298, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1101613, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.66893692070997, "pattern_frame_updates": 152172, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1427742673, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9382.42694451016, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21686, "avg_candidate_generations": 1355.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1788164, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.45706907682376, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1262, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 21670, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1786902, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1008863, "avg_legality_checks": 63053.9375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 192, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1008863, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 192, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2418021, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 151126.3125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5060026984, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2092.63152966827, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13563, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 847.6875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37767944, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2784.6305389663053, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 203, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2010227, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2414, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19631969, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10946, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16125748, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72419, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4526.1875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 645175494, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8908.925751529296, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 99121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6195.0625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 293283932, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2958.8475903189033, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2373992071, "stage_ordering_ns": 716528795, "stage_eval_ns": 1428844286, "stage_threat_ns": 3467183812, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 366987, "root_tactical_annotations": 1111, "search_tactical_annotations": 365876, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152188, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 883894733, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 336120, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2446919703, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43447, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1536269582, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76086, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108147741, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152172, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18633479, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 101331, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 311083085, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 191331, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 599268463, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 74325, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9588156, "child_limit_applications": 21670, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21670, "child_cap_hits": 21670, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21670, "child_moves_before_total": 1786710, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1786710, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 351245, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 351245, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.4508537148131, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.208814028610984, "tt_hits": 8064, "tt_cutoffs": 1118, "beta_cutoffs": 18188, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5759.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6259.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1158, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1203, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27171, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 96, 142, 94, 98, 128, 80, 95, 93, 79, 63, 64, 109, 127, 143, 141, 99, 81, 78, 49, 34, 66, 51, 65, 97, 33, 17, 67, 68, 53, 39, 108, 100, 101, 84, 144, 160, 52, 132, 116, 174, 158, 146, 118, 188 ], "move_count": 50, "black_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 7507, "avg_search_time_ms": 326.39130434782606, "search_nodes": 147800, "safety_nodes": 2036, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 149836, "avg_nodes": 6514.608695652174, "eval_calls": 107942, "avg_eval_calls": 4693.130434782609, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107942, "pattern_eval_ns": 1995897, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.490457838468807, "pattern_frame_queries": 107942, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1995897, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.490457838468807, "pattern_frame_updates": 295380, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1900490462, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6434.052616967973, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37699, "avg_candidate_generations": 1639.0869565217392, "candidate_moves_total": 3020730, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.12758959123585, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1797, "root_candidate_moves_max": 115, "search_candidate_generations": 37676, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3018933, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 1056435, "avg_legality_checks": 45931.95652173913, "illegal_moves_skipped": 266, "root_legality_checks": 1797, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1054638, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 266, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3291632, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 143114.4347826087, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4192735945, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1273.755980316147, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22394, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 973.6521739130435, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44299425, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1978.1827721711172, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1361, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3081564, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7580, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26678678, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13417, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14452882, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 36, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 86301, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 92632, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4027.478260869565, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 437979659, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4728.1680088954145, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 111131, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4831.782608695652, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 151710799, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1365.1528286436728, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1483779061, "stage_ordering_ns": 687570013, "stage_eval_ns": 1902486359, "stage_threat_ns": 3361545158, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 618544, "root_tactical_annotations": 3241, "search_tactical_annotations": 615303, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 295403, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1043239191, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 552209, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2139888398, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75508, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1459764620, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147690, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 144381370, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 295380, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23670235, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 212648, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 133163112, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 264034, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 546254583, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 141862, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10365964, "child_limit_applications": 37676, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37676, "child_cap_hits": 37676, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37676, "child_moves_before_total": 3018667, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3018667, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 603509, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 603509, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.12174859326892, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01839367236437, "tt_hits": 16556, "tt_cutoffs": 2072, "beta_cutoffs": 30665, "depth_sum": 110, "avg_depth": 4.782608695652174, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 110, "avg_effective_depth": 4.782608695652174, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6823.260869565217, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7171.086956521739, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1401, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 19640, "avg_search_time_ms": 853.9130434782609, "search_nodes": 209601, "safety_nodes": 1688, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 211289, "avg_nodes": 9186.478260869566, "eval_calls": 123265, "avg_eval_calls": 5359.347826086957, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 123265, "pattern_eval_ns": 2376251, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.277580821806676, "pattern_frame_queries": 123265, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2376251, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.277580821806676, "pattern_frame_updates": 418916, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2700499407, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6446.398340001337, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 80861, "avg_candidate_generations": 3515.695652173913, "candidate_moves_total": 7273224, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.94724279937176, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1809, "root_candidate_moves_max": 115, "search_candidate_generations": 80838, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7271415, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 4797237, "avg_legality_checks": 208575.52173913043, "illegal_moves_skipped": 842, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4797237, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 842, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9039588, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 393025.5652173913, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12776992730, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1413.44856977995, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38138, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1658.1739130434783, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60751107, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1592.9284965126644, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1444, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4289998, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8338, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 36456112, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28314, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19893557, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 111440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 253844, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11036.695652173914, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1261595452, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4969.963646964277, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 300037, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13045.08695652174, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 412149350, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1373.6617483843659, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7431282327, "stage_ordering_ns": 1807096788, "stage_eval_ns": 2702875658, "stage_threat_ns": 7514806050, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1417872, "root_tactical_annotations": 3633, "search_tactical_annotations": 1414239, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 418939, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1741537387, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1176086, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5451193998, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 161864, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3497138060, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 209458, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 235089403, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 418916, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38559799, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 342316, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 536920807, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 671892, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1416934689, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 403664, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 48425463, "child_limit_applications": 80838, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 80838, "child_cap_hits": 80838, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 80838, "child_moves_before_total": 7270573, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7270573, "child_moves_before_max": 131, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 131, "child_moves_after_total": 801589, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 801589, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.94004057497712, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.91599247878473, "tt_hits": 41881, "tt_cutoffs": 5356, "beta_cutoffs": 67370, "depth_sum": 142, "avg_depth": 6.173913043478261, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 142, "avg_effective_depth": 6.173913043478261, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.043478260869565216, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21739130434782608, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.043478260869565216, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6177.695652173913, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6525.521739130435, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1059, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1204, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19677, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 128, 127, 85, 141, 155, 142, 157, 143, 144, 115, 116, 87, 158, 129, 101, 140, 139, 159, 130, 102, 172 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 15223, "avg_search_time_ms": 1268.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 185980, "safety_nodes": 558, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 186538, "avg_nodes": 15544.833333333334, "eval_calls": 116834, "avg_eval_calls": 9736.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 116834, "pattern_eval_ns": 2321679, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.87160415632436, "pattern_frame_queries": 116834, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2321679, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.87160415632436, "pattern_frame_updates": 371828, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3345671089, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8997.899805824198, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 64735, "avg_candidate_generations": 5394.583333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 5164703, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.78223526685719, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 817, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 64723, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5163886, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1551732, "avg_legality_checks": 129311.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 277, "root_legality_checks": 817, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1550915, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 277, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4796108, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 399675.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8874785723, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1850.4140696998484, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16765, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1397.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 58012314, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3460.3229346853564, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 685, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3505398, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7208, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 40440034, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8870, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14064682, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2200, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72345, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6028.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 518168812, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7162.468892114175, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92413, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7701.083333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 201665959, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2182.2250008115743, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3055688536, "stage_ordering_ns": 1703971324, "stage_eval_ns": 3347992768, "stage_threat_ns": 7037578327, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 866138, "root_tactical_annotations": 3071, "search_tactical_annotations": 863067, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 371840, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1812721566, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 660012, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4907218777, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 129536, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3881316632, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185914, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 231625485, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 371828, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39772389, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 109556, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 103266631, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 420909, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 922422652, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 335673, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 46240110, "child_limit_applications": 64723, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 64723, "child_cap_hits": 64723, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 64723, "child_moves_before_total": 5163609, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5163609, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 591435, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 591435, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.78012453069233, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.137941689971107, "tt_hits": 35314, "tt_cutoffs": 4358, "beta_cutoffs": 49187, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2470.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3136.9166666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 338, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 4444, "avg_search_time_ms": 370.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 52869, "safety_nodes": 805, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53674, "avg_nodes": 4472.833333333333, "eval_calls": 35326, "avg_eval_calls": 2943.8333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35326, "pattern_eval_ns": 697072, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.73254826473419, "pattern_frame_queries": 35326, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 697072, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.73254826473419, "pattern_frame_updates": 105630, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 741424814, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7019.0742592066645, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16232, "avg_candidate_generations": 1352.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1217502, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.00628388368655, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 830, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 16220, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1216672, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 727892, "avg_legality_checks": 60657.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 727892, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1628055, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 135671.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2743857928, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1685.3594798701517, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4590, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 382.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6900902, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1503.4644880174292, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 67430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 611, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 4144712, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3965, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2688760, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43322, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3610.1666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 283497352, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6543.958081344352, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 59817, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4984.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 120669923, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2017.3182038550913, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1297842027, "stage_ordering_ns": 406719684, "stage_eval_ns": 742121886, "stage_threat_ns": 1954411833, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 179242, "root_tactical_annotations": 1218, "search_tactical_annotations": 178024, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 105642, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 526679866, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 183025, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1349082489, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32517, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 942847756, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52815, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 64592777, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 105630, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11071734, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 46388, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 119017010, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 104112, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 286988921, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 28742, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2984967, "child_limit_applications": 16220, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16220, "child_cap_hits": 16220, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16220, "child_moves_before_total": 1216666, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1216666, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 262666, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 262666, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.0102342786683, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.19395807644883, "tt_hits": 5953, "tt_cutoffs": 1269, "beta_cutoffs": 13957, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5651.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6318.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1857, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1205, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25618, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 144, 141, 97, 109, 108, 125, 93, 95, 80, 143, 127, 157, 173, 129, 115, 156, 96, 155, 140, 158, 159, 154 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18431, "avg_search_time_ms": 1417.7692307692307, "search_nodes": 237788, "safety_nodes": 78, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 237866, "avg_nodes": 18297.384615384617, "eval_calls": 193056, "avg_eval_calls": 14850.461538461539, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 193056, "pattern_eval_ns": 3869511, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.043464072600695, "pattern_frame_queries": 193056, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3869511, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.043464072600695, "pattern_frame_updates": 475462, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6601341088, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13884.056113842957, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42467, "avg_candidate_generations": 3266.6923076923076, "candidate_moves_total": 3316785, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.10264440624485, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 864, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 42454, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3315921, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 1327479, "avg_legality_checks": 102113.76923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5449, "root_legality_checks": 864, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 1326615, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5443, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5364341, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 412641.6153846154, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10627734164, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1981.181689232657, "renju_forbidden_checks": 99827, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7679.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 519203954, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5201.037334588838, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6589, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 51821476, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 60260, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 377804800, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32948, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 89427498, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 150180, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 155293, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11945.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1289783299, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8305.48253301823, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 207985, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15998.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 569977386, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2740.4735245330194, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2950468827, "stage_ordering_ns": 1248167329, "stage_eval_ns": 6605210599, "stage_threat_ns": 7559817129, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 795763, "root_tactical_annotations": 3585, "search_tactical_annotations": 792178, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 475475, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2549077748, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 701279, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4610205201, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 84990, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2770915259, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 237731, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 322395451, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 475462, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 54918013, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 228762, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 293665226, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 387515, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1545611616, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 179486, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23220716, "child_limit_applications": 42454, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42454, "child_cap_hits": 42454, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42454, "child_moves_before_total": 3310478, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3310478, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 680927, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 680927, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.97799971734112, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.039171809487918, "tt_hits": 17493, "tt_cutoffs": 2221, "beta_cutoffs": 29843, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2843.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3432.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 948, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7175, "avg_search_time_ms": 597.9166666666666, "search_nodes": 66002, "safety_nodes": 1080, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67082, "avg_nodes": 5590.166666666667, "eval_calls": 41783, "avg_eval_calls": 3481.9166666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41783, "pattern_eval_ns": 846623, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.262379436612978, "pattern_frame_queries": 41783, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 846623, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.262379436612978, "pattern_frame_updates": 131874, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1428788279, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10834.49564736036, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22232, "avg_candidate_generations": 1852.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1628758, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.26187477509896, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 796, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 22220, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1627962, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 936559, "avg_legality_checks": 78046.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1702, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 936559, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1702, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2434539, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 202878.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4581865532, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1882.0259326303665, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25532, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2127.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 93324674, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3655.2042143192857, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2202, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15234747, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9461, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 52164605, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13832, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25710201, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 215121, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76743, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6395.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 611407866, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7966.952894726555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 103515, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8626.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 261825577, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2529.3491474665507, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2000239531, "stage_ordering_ns": 600075826, "stage_eval_ns": 1429634902, "stage_threat_ns": 3098610170, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 314757, "root_tactical_annotations": 829, "search_tactical_annotations": 313928, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 131886, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 710462525, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 272478, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2275195546, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44529, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1423610980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 65937, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 89123823, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 131874, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15070995, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44782, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 128466493, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 183159, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 722899082, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 86816, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8757281, "child_limit_applications": 22220, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22220, "child_cap_hits": 22220, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22220, "child_moves_before_total": 1626260, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1626260, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 214202, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 214202, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.1890189018902, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.64005400540054, "tt_hits": 10544, "tt_cutoffs": 1934, "beta_cutoffs": 17226, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4957.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5623.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1413, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1206, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27360, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 113, 114, 128, 66, 82, 110, 96, 144, 97, 67, 125, 139, 129, 81, 130, 131, 145, 161, 115, 160, 101, 143, 85, 100, 69, 83, 53, 37, 117 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 21198, "avg_search_time_ms": 1413.2, "search_nodes": 212186, "safety_nodes": 211, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 212397, "avg_nodes": 14159.8, "eval_calls": 141362, "avg_eval_calls": 9424.133333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 141362, "pattern_eval_ns": 2935635, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.76679022651066, "pattern_frame_queries": 141362, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2935635, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.76679022651066, "pattern_frame_updates": 424234, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5806681882, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13687.45051551738, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 66474, "avg_candidate_generations": 4431.6, "candidate_moves_total": 5484225, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.50180521707735, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1076, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 66459, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5483149, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1574643, "avg_legality_checks": 104976.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3813, "root_legality_checks": 1076, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1573567, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3812, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5792594, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 386172.93333333335, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12252415130, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2115.186241259097, "renju_forbidden_checks": 127614, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8507.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 454758884, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3563.550112056671, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15249, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 65992515, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 51082, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 252685916, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 61180, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 135762911, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 103, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 317542, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 135053, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9003.533333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1098308747, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8132.427617305799, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 174195, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11613.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 418230574, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2400.93328740779, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3736716217, "stage_ordering_ns": 2125409491, "stage_eval_ns": 5809617517, "stage_threat_ns": 9459579109, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1368369, "root_tactical_annotations": 4193, "search_tactical_annotations": 1364176, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 424249, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2495921715, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1130738, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6545488060, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 133016, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4535415034, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 212117, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 313050985, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 424234, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53183517, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 351232, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 287972252, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 646476, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1722005774, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 370661, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 51934832, "child_limit_applications": 66459, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 66459, "child_cap_hits": 66459, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 66459, "child_moves_before_total": 5479337, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5479337, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 794080, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 794080, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.44687702192329, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.948419326201117, "tt_hits": 31158, "tt_cutoffs": 4298, "beta_cutoffs": 51178, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2789.733333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3323.0666666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 262, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6148, "avg_search_time_ms": 439.14285714285717, "search_nodes": 57592, "safety_nodes": 1415, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59007, "avg_nodes": 4214.785714285715, "eval_calls": 38888, "avg_eval_calls": 2777.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38888, "pattern_eval_ns": 808862, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.799783995062743, "pattern_frame_queries": 38888, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 808862, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.799783995062743, "pattern_frame_updates": 115054, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1173892903, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10202.973412484573, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17683, "avg_candidate_generations": 1263.0714285714287, "candidate_moves_total": 1349108, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.29406774868518, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 994, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 17669, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1348114, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 667374, "avg_legality_checks": 47669.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2015, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 667374, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2015, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1785940, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 127567.14285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3777501047, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2115.1332334792883, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20499, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1464.2142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 82935329, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4045.823162105469, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3283, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23709533, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5610, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34989701, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11493, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23899494, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 113, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 336601, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51385, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3670.3571428571427, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 499473816, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9720.226058188187, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 75570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5397.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 236186694, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3125.4028582770943, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1621809135, "stage_ordering_ns": 550537788, "stage_eval_ns": 1174701765, "stage_threat_ns": 2761432641, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 285466, "root_tactical_annotations": 646, "search_tactical_annotations": 284820, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 115068, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 686137580, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 275612, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1971808390, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35431, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1237320755, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57527, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 84134150, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 115054, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14124490, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70669, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 201733929, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 169502, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 532363875, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 45295, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5228031, "child_limit_applications": 17669, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17669, "child_cap_hits": 17669, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17669, "child_moves_before_total": 1346099, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1346099, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 285104, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 285104, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.18422095194974, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.135831116644972, "tt_hits": 5471, "tt_cutoffs": 970, "beta_cutoffs": 15143, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5598.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6169.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1824, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1207, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20312, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 98, 143, 82, 142, 114, 130, 97, 67, 96, 99, 110, 68, 66, 50, 124, 138, 94, 95, 108, 158, 173, 80, 109, 111, 139, 79, 154 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 11408, "avg_search_time_ms": 814.8571428571429, "search_nodes": 115508, "safety_nodes": 184, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 115692, "avg_nodes": 8263.714285714286, "eval_calls": 77896, "avg_eval_calls": 5564.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77896, "pattern_eval_ns": 1624077, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.84929906542056, "pattern_frame_queries": 77896, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1624077, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.84929906542056, "pattern_frame_updates": 230892, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3054846106, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13230.62776536216, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35109, "avg_candidate_generations": 2507.785714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 2801997, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.80851063829788, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 983, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 35095, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2801014, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 733817, "avg_legality_checks": 52415.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2271, "root_legality_checks": 983, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 732834, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2267, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3078327, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 219880.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6589557331, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2140.6294168878094, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46535, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3323.9285714285716, "renju_forbidden_ns": 274487852, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5898.524809283335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2707, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25886960, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21163, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 167973682, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22645, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 80426307, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 200903, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 91595, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6542.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 865598019, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9450.275877504231, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 126218, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9015.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 397653200, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3150.5268662155954, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1777270738, "stage_ordering_ns": 1085345458, "stage_eval_ns": 3056470183, "stage_threat_ns": 5449875621, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 746184, "root_tactical_annotations": 3609, "search_tactical_annotations": 742575, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 230906, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1372002299, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 614682, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3854648625, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70279, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2577050449, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115446, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 170718769, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 230892, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28728013, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 256917, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 299312380, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 287474, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 978270836, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 201793, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23777915, "child_limit_applications": 35095, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35095, "child_cap_hits": 35095, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35095, "child_moves_before_total": 2798747, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2798747, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 565508, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 565508, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.74774184356745, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.11363442085767, "tt_hits": 17379, "tt_cutoffs": 2455, "beta_cutoffs": 30111, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5496.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6068.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 687, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8890, "avg_search_time_ms": 683.8461538461538, "search_nodes": 69150, "safety_nodes": 1278, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 70428, "avg_nodes": 5417.538461538462, "eval_calls": 40712, "avg_eval_calls": 3131.6923076923076, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40712, "pattern_eval_ns": 871160, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.398113578306152, "pattern_frame_queries": 40712, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 871160, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.398113578306152, "pattern_frame_updates": 138146, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1581121614, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11445.294210472977, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24773, "avg_candidate_generations": 1905.6153846153845, "candidate_moves_total": 1888175, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.2190691478626, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 922, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 24760, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1887253, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 1029670, "avg_legality_checks": 79205.38461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2999, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1029670, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2999, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2699691, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 207668.53846153847, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5582996044, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2068.0129851897864, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37461, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2881.6153846153848, "renju_forbidden_ns": 155024791, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4138.298256853795, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3474, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33080258, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10685, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 74565942, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23282, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 47173201, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 205390, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99206, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7631.2307692307695, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 912875996, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9201.822430094953, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 135314, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10408.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 407708294, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3013.0532982544305, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2449459227, "stage_ordering_ns": 758494025, "stage_eval_ns": 1581992774, "stage_threat_ns": 4050841099, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 471480, "root_tactical_annotations": 450, "search_tactical_annotations": 471030, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 138159, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 832687097, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 418262, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3086267056, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49623, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1750495719, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 69073, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 103315998, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 138146, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17313297, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 68422, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 219171152, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 300210, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1116377804, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 102848, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11257651, "child_limit_applications": 24760, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24760, "child_cap_hits": 24760, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24760, "child_moves_before_total": 1884254, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1884254, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 284805, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 284805, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.10072697899838, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.50262520193861, "tt_hits": 12567, "tt_cutoffs": 3602, "beta_cutoffs": 20587, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 5.846153846153846, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 5.846153846153846, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5171.846153846154, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5787.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1208, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 46738, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 98, 156, 82, 67, 114, 66, 96, 99, 68, 54, 84, 70, 100, 52, 124, 110, 126, 140, 130, 146, 116, 132, 125, 123, 102, 144, 141, 145, 143, 147, 148, 170, 184, 83, 111, 81, 159, 95, 175 ], "move_count": 45, "black_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 32998, "avg_search_time_ms": 1571.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 312520, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 313559, "avg_nodes": 14931.380952380952, "eval_calls": 192124, "avg_eval_calls": 9148.761904761905, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 192124, "pattern_eval_ns": 4012207, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.883424246840583, "pattern_frame_queries": 192124, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4012207, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.883424246840583, "pattern_frame_updates": 624786, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7909360606, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12659.311517863716, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 110987, "avg_candidate_generations": 5285.0952380952385, "candidate_moves_total": 10321799, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.00007208051393, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1715, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 110966, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10320084, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 2837752, "avg_legality_checks": 135131.04761904763, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7405, "root_legality_checks": 1715, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 2836037, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7400, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9606301, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 457442.90476190473, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19256885158, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2004.6098032947334, "renju_forbidden_checks": 104647, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4983.190476190476, "renju_forbidden_ns": 533082856, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5094.10547841792, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10003, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 86770397, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 40906, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 280316345, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 53689, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 165540314, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 49, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 455800, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 281733, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13415.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2244945898, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7968.34555412394, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 373846, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17802.190476190477, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 915014108, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2447.569608876382, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6245098544, "stage_ordering_ns": 3650256239, "stage_eval_ns": 7913372813, "stage_threat_ns": 15073286713, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2940723, "root_tactical_annotations": 6892, "search_tactical_annotations": 2933831, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 624807, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3488240087, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2344171, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10953927500, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 222100, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7153695321, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 312393, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 451805148, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 624786, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74933480, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 985207, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 773333694, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1136847, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3026314032, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 818669, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 104380498, "child_limit_applications": 110966, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 110966, "child_cap_hits": 110966, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 110966, "child_moves_before_total": 10312684, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10312684, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 1513015, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1513015, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 92.9355298019213, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.634942234558332, "tt_hits": 64553, "tt_cutoffs": 9309, "beta_cutoffs": 93953, "depth_sum": 119, "avg_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 119, "avg_effective_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 8, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.38095238095238093, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 8, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.38095238095238093, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1814.4285714285713, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2195.3809523809523, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 13721, "avg_search_time_ms": 686.05, "search_nodes": 96000, "safety_nodes": 1647, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 97647, "avg_nodes": 4882.35, "eval_calls": 63168, "avg_eval_calls": 3158.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 63168, "pattern_eval_ns": 1341794, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.24167299898683, "pattern_frame_queries": 63168, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1341794, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.24167299898683, "pattern_frame_updates": 191810, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2016052252, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10510.673332985767, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30827, "avg_candidate_generations": 1541.35, "candidate_moves_total": 3063467, "avg_candidate_moves": 99.37609887436338, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1636, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 30807, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3061831, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 2217706, "avg_legality_checks": 110885.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10911, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2217706, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10911, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4642101, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 232105.05, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8743993493, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1883.628446041997, "renju_forbidden_checks": 126968, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6348.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 726777724, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5724.10153739525, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24812, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 252336129, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18451, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 155968232, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 83647, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 317863300, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 58, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 610063, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 201075, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10053.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2072917602, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10309.176187989557, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 306975, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15348.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 926167380, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3017.077547031517, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4967069904, "stage_ordering_ns": 1032509443, "stage_eval_ns": 2017394046, "stage_threat_ns": 5607557854, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 888843, "root_tactical_annotations": 2406, "search_tactical_annotations": 886437, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 191830, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1061337245, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 781745, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4362852310, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61749, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1808573788, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 95905, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 136949823, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 191810, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22418996, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 406011, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1454542307, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 313973, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1099428375, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 168859, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23999480, "child_limit_applications": 30807, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30807, "child_cap_hits": 30807, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30807, "child_moves_before_total": 3050920, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3050920, "child_moves_before_max": 134, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 134, "child_moves_after_total": 509925, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 509925, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 99.03333657934886, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.552244619729283, "tt_hits": 14389, "tt_cutoffs": 1930, "beta_cutoffs": 27167, "depth_sum": 95, "avg_depth": 4.75, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 95, "avg_effective_depth": 4.75, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6564.55, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6964.55, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1841, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1209, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20872, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 128, 95, 140, 109, 108, 141, 157, 81, 123, 67, 53, 93, 77, 65, 80, 51, 129, 130, 79, 66, 96, 68, 64, 69 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 11052, "avg_search_time_ms": 789.4285714285714, "search_nodes": 116685, "safety_nodes": 184, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 116869, "avg_nodes": 8347.785714285714, "eval_calls": 80786, "avg_eval_calls": 5770.428571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80786, "pattern_eval_ns": 1652818, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.459213230015102, "pattern_frame_queries": 80786, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1652818, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.459213230015102, "pattern_frame_updates": 233246, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3217974848, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13796.484604237587, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33584, "avg_candidate_generations": 2398.8571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 2678779, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.7635481181515, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 976, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 33570, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2677803, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 676413, "avg_legality_checks": 48315.21428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2007, "root_legality_checks": 976, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 675437, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2003, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3008493, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 214892.35714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6354056286, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2112.03957795481, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41973, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2998.0714285714284, "renju_forbidden_ns": 259922019, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6192.6004574369235, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2386, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22606212, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20343, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 164875970, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19224, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 72231156, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 208681, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 82921, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5922.928571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 764341971, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9217.712895406472, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 113553, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8110.928571428572, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 355923077, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3134.422489938619, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1611354545, "stage_ordering_ns": 1030652969, "stage_eval_ns": 3219627666, "stage_threat_ns": 5157451205, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 757937, "root_tactical_annotations": 3574, "search_tactical_annotations": 754363, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 233260, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1362408913, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 620686, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3571324226, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67229, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2401833389, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 116623, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 170535639, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 233246, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28812556, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 267021, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 254236351, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 286424, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 915239756, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 204492, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24369871, "child_limit_applications": 33570, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33570, "child_cap_hits": 33570, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33570, "child_moves_before_total": 2675800, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2675800, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 542018, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 542018, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.708072683944, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.145904081024725, "tt_hits": 17014, "tt_cutoffs": 2267, "beta_cutoffs": 28353, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5619.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6191.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1220, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 9806, "avg_search_time_ms": 754.3076923076923, "search_nodes": 85930, "safety_nodes": 1245, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87175, "avg_nodes": 6705.7692307692305, "eval_calls": 51551, "avg_eval_calls": 3965.4615384615386, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51551, "pattern_eval_ns": 1075856, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.86974064518632, "pattern_frame_queries": 51551, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1075856, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.86974064518632, "pattern_frame_updates": 171706, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2017060860, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11747.177501077424, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29505, "avg_candidate_generations": 2269.6153846153848, "candidate_moves_total": 2153994, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.0043721403152, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 911, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 29492, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2153083, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 942089, "avg_legality_checks": 72468.38461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1888, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 942089, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1888, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2911841, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 223987.76923076922, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5964972600, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2048.5227730497645, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30098, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2315.230769230769, "renju_forbidden_ns": 122416572, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4067.265997740714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20818734, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9415, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 61892648, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18446, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39492160, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 213030, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98899, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7607.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 878204244, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8879.809138616163, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 136186, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10475.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 392238265, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2880.1658393667485, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2210077792, "stage_ordering_ns": 870423976, "stage_eval_ns": 2018136716, "stage_threat_ns": 4666131170, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 553788, "root_tactical_annotations": 457, "search_tactical_annotations": 553331, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 171719, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1026461507, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 497775, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3478795798, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59087, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2102349570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85853, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 126899543, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 171706, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21763175, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 74438, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 187137654, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 364243, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1189075623, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 115107, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12211147, "child_limit_applications": 29492, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29492, "child_cap_hits": 29492, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29492, "child_moves_before_total": 2151195, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2151195, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 339366, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 339366, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.94164519191645, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.507052760070527, "tt_hits": 13807, "tt_cutoffs": 4810, "beta_cutoffs": 24132, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 5.923076923076923, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 5.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4678.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5294.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 338, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1210, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19098, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 85, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 123, 71, 99, 137, 97, 83, 80, 65, 96, 98, 128, 64, 144 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 16471, "avg_search_time_ms": 1372.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 162382, "safety_nodes": 583, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 162965, "avg_nodes": 13580.416666666666, "eval_calls": 107867, "avg_eval_calls": 8988.916666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107867, "pattern_eval_ns": 2252080, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.878303837132766, "pattern_frame_queries": 107867, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2252080, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.878303837132766, "pattern_frame_updates": 324646, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4723911853, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14550.962750195598, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 51394, "avg_candidate_generations": 4282.833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4421632, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.03401175234463, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 864, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 51382, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4420768, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1116164, "avg_legality_checks": 93013.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1365, "root_legality_checks": 864, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1115300, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4503737, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 375311.4166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9576595483, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2126.3665003085216, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55400, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4616.666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 265719784, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4796.385992779783, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2169, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14212092, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 30577, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 188475894, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22654, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 63031798, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 106040, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8836.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 875531922, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8256.619407770653, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 136163, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11346.916666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 350272757, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2572.451818776026, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2611375440, "stage_ordering_ns": 1719303291, "stage_eval_ns": 4726163933, "stage_threat_ns": 7374301370, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 950617, "root_tactical_annotations": 2932, "search_tactical_annotations": 947685, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 324658, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1917680350, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 834222, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5145472175, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 102846, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3601252201, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 162323, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 241180878, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 324646, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41085239, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 255730, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 248672945, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 475636, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1295145766, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 219251, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28882728, "child_limit_applications": 51382, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 51382, "child_cap_hits": 51382, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 51382, "child_moves_before_total": 4419403, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4419403, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 506628, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 506628, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.01072359970418, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.860028803861274, "tt_hits": 25280, "tt_cutoffs": 3075, "beta_cutoffs": 40663, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 4.833333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 4.833333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3139.0833333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3770.0833333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1276, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2615, "avg_search_time_ms": 237.72727272727272, "search_nodes": 26384, "safety_nodes": 1149, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 27533, "avg_nodes": 2503.0, "eval_calls": 18102, "avg_eval_calls": 1645.6363636363637, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 18102, "pattern_eval_ns": 380723, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.032095901005412, "pattern_frame_queries": 18102, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 380723, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.032095901005412, "pattern_frame_updates": 52668, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 544080875, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10330.387996506417, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7847, "avg_candidate_generations": 713.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 608098, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.49432904294635, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 7836, "search_candidate_moves_total": 607312, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 253472, "avg_legality_checks": 23042.909090909092, "illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 253472, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 773198, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 70290.72727272728, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1592426756, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2059.5329475761705, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3895, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 354.09090909090907, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13782969, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3538.631322207959, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 98, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 854371, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1280, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8402638, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2517, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4525960, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2111.2727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 206186843, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8878.17959869101, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31666, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2878.7272727272725, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 93219071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2943.822112044464, "stage_move_gen_ns": 591448078, "stage_ordering_ns": 243418524, "stage_eval_ns": 544461598, "stage_threat_ns": 1213012206, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 124487, "root_tactical_annotations": 306, "search_tactical_annotations": 124181, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 52679, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 310636906, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 120119, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 856819151, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15744, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 553124391, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 26334, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 37461397, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 52668, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6344964, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32788, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 83948018, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 71580, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 219473372, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 20119, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1749788, "child_limit_applications": 7836, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 7836, "child_cap_hits": 7836, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 7836, "child_moves_before_total": 607228, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 607228, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 125406, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 125406, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.4920877998979, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00382848392037, "tt_hits": 2469, "tt_cutoffs": 396, "beta_cutoffs": 6642, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5849.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6576.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1845, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1211, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20420, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 81, 126, 67, 127, 95, 109, 82, 52, 83, 80, 99, 51, 49, 65, 84, 85, 129, 114, 53, 39, 113, 145, 115, 131, 98, 68, 143, 128, 157, 101, 171 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 12208, "avg_search_time_ms": 763.0, "search_nodes": 141998, "safety_nodes": 97, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 142095, "avg_nodes": 8880.9375, "eval_calls": 95321, "avg_eval_calls": 5957.5625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 95321, "pattern_eval_ns": 1968096, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.64703475624469, "pattern_frame_queries": 95321, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1968096, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.64703475624469, "pattern_frame_updates": 283852, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3115339683, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10975.225409720559, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43914, "avg_candidate_generations": 2744.625, "candidate_moves_total": 3547543, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.78387302454799, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1125, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 43898, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3546418, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 802760, "avg_legality_checks": 50172.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 919, "root_legality_checks": 1125, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 801635, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 918, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3258011, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 203625.6875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6793792466, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2085.2576820643026, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36513, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2282.0625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 139274466, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3814.3802481308026, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1072, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6452073, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17401, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 92785672, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18035, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40031111, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 80226, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5014.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 665010355, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8289.212412434872, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 104320, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6520.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 274146287, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2627.9360333588957, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1866687474, "stage_ordering_ns": 1295188279, "stage_eval_ns": 3117307779, "stage_threat_ns": 5880129404, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1059344, "root_tactical_annotations": 4776, "search_tactical_annotations": 1054568, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 283868, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1633622326, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 853625, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3979939974, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 87899, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2806820484, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 141926, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 200851478, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 283852, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34172838, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 395661, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 229240884, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 370050, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 943859726, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 293633, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 31542788, "child_limit_applications": 43898, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43898, "child_cap_hits": 43898, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43898, "child_moves_before_total": 3545500, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3545500, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 710627, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 710627, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.766777529728, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.188140689780855, "tt_hits": 22351, "tt_cutoffs": 2707, "beta_cutoffs": 37795, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5900.9375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6400.9375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 775, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 8199, "avg_search_time_ms": 546.6, "search_nodes": 67052, "safety_nodes": 1381, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68433, "avg_nodes": 4562.2, "eval_calls": 38774, "avg_eval_calls": 2584.9333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38774, "pattern_eval_ns": 811254, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.922628565533604, "pattern_frame_queries": 38774, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 811254, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.922628565533604, "pattern_frame_updates": 133920, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1420152096, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10604.48100358423, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25015, "avg_candidate_generations": 1667.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1851447, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.0134719168499, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1061, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 25000, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1850386, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 995187, "avg_legality_checks": 66345.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1195, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 995187, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1195, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2531881, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 168792.06666666668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5181178420, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2046.3751732407645, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22138, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1475.8666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66219338, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2991.2068840907036, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1283, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9196701, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6704, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37814732, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14146, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19202035, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5870, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 84339, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5622.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 709220523, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8409.164479066623, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110366, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7357.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 298447543, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2704.1619973542574, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2294557196, "stage_ordering_ns": 711875882, "stage_eval_ns": 1420963350, "stage_threat_ns": 3720811448, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 478316, "root_tactical_annotations": 485, "search_tactical_annotations": 477831, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 133935, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 805587473, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 419692, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2789147869, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50122, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1678909046, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66960, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 98734765, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 133920, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16674276, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 72664, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 155679220, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 296899, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 954346522, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 108753, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10667065, "child_limit_applications": 25000, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25000, "child_cap_hits": 25000, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25000, "child_moves_before_total": 1849191, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1849191, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 280317, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 280317, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.96764, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.21268, "tt_hits": 12490, "tt_cutoffs": 3186, "beta_cutoffs": 20708, "depth_sum": 91, "avg_depth": 6.066666666666666, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 91, "avg_effective_depth": 6.066666666666666, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5596.066666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6129.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1212, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25001, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 159, 67, 52, 95, 53, 83, 80, 51, 143, 175, 35, 65, 49, 37, 79, 84, 85, 98, 70, 129, 113, 99, 115, 114, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 21921, "avg_search_time_ms": 1461.4, "search_nodes": 245599, "safety_nodes": 778, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 246377, "avg_nodes": 16425.133333333335, "eval_calls": 173616, "avg_eval_calls": 11574.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 173616, "pattern_eval_ns": 3551254, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.454647037139434, "pattern_frame_queries": 173616, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3551254, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.454647037139434, "pattern_frame_updates": 491048, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6414745117, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13063.376934637754, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 68352, "avg_candidate_generations": 4556.8, "candidate_moves_total": 6115364, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.46869147940075, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1165, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 68337, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6114199, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1634816, "avg_legality_checks": 108987.73333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3560, "root_legality_checks": 1165, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1633651, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6339295, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 422619.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12600232766, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1987.639440347862, "renju_forbidden_checks": 64481, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4298.733333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 320378011, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4968.564553899599, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4244, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33060301, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 36312, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 215975830, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23898, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 71106296, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 235584, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 172822, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11521.466666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1263255307, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7309.574631701982, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 214146, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14276.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 475067759, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2218.429291231216, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3581034929, "stage_ordering_ns": 2182320103, "stage_eval_ns": 6418296371, "stage_threat_ns": 9676348772, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1357375, "root_tactical_annotations": 4093, "search_tactical_annotations": 1353282, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 491063, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2749245960, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1215968, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6484653557, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 136778, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4294891745, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 245524, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 346721605, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 491048, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58689458, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 379777, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 393512157, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 699400, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1795708453, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 278198, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 37038192, "child_limit_applications": 68337, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 68337, "child_cap_hits": 68337, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 68337, "child_moves_before_total": 6110642, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6110642, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 738214, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 738214, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.41923116320588, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.802552058182243, "tt_hits": 30630, "tt_cutoffs": 3571, "beta_cutoffs": 53093, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3959.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4493.133333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1223, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3065, "avg_search_time_ms": 218.92857142857142, "search_nodes": 33035, "safety_nodes": 1641, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34676, "avg_nodes": 2476.8571428571427, "eval_calls": 22539, "avg_eval_calls": 1609.9285714285713, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22539, "pattern_eval_ns": 460453, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.429167221260926, "pattern_frame_queries": 22539, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 460453, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.429167221260926, "pattern_frame_updates": 65940, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 633673736, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9609.853442523507, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9944, "avg_candidate_generations": 710.2857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 802153, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.66703539823008, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1092, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 9930, "search_candidate_moves_total": 801061, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 313550, "avg_legality_checks": 22396.428571428572, "illegal_moves_skipped": 387, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 313550, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 387, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 959160, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 68511.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1834511409, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1912.6229294382586, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5620, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 401.42857142857144, "renju_forbidden_ns": 28125582, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5004.5519572953735, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 438, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3968868, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2312, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16696574, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2848, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7237568, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 222572, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 31293, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2235.214285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 257150633, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8217.512958169558, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41267, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2947.6428571428573, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 112650706, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2729.8011970824145, "stage_move_gen_ns": 686844910, "stage_ordering_ns": 290757263, "stage_eval_ns": 634134189, "stage_threat_ns": 1424505867, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 178455, "root_tactical_annotations": 331, "search_tactical_annotations": 178124, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 65954, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 366782913, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 173623, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1003885622, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19953, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 610939111, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 32970, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 44486783, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 65940, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7444233, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44746, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 104277587, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 108915, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 288349663, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 24794, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1906316, "child_limit_applications": 9930, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9930, "child_cap_hits": 9930, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9930, "child_moves_before_total": 800674, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 800674, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 160409, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 160409, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.63182275931521, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.1539778449144, "tt_hits": 2931, "tt_cutoffs": 501, "beta_cutoffs": 8463, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6299.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6870.928571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1847, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1213, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "draw", "winner": null, "end_reason": "max_moves", "duration_ms": 133073, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 110, 96, 99, 64, 128, 100, 126, 115, 114, 130, 145, 80, 48, 66, 129, 144, 127, 125, 94, 81, 51, 78, 79, 158, 172, 65, 67, 84, 68, 35, 50, 49, 63, 33, 17, 34, 36, 86, 85, 116, 102, 71, 101, 132, 148, 19, 4, 52, 117, 69, 133, 149, 118, 103, 47, 83, 82, 24, 38, 39, 54, 55, 87, 41, 27, 26, 56, 23, 7, 22, 25, 31, 32, 62, 5, 6, 72, 57, 171, 173, 157, 187, 188, 140, 199, 185, 170, 142, 141, 169, 204, 156, 201, 153, 200, 202, 139, 124, 108, 198, 123, 155, 107, 183, 91, 75, 106, 109, 168, 184, 186, 182, 181, 197, 211 ], "move_count": 120, "black_stats": { "move_count": 60, "search_move_count": 58, "total_time_ms": 49778, "avg_search_time_ms": 858.2413793103449, "search_nodes": 778509, "safety_nodes": 4184, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 782693, "avg_nodes": 13494.706896551725, "eval_calls": 576458, "avg_eval_calls": 9938.931034482759, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 576458, "pattern_eval_ns": 11896897, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.63792505264911, "pattern_frame_queries": 576458, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11896897, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.63792505264911, "pattern_frame_updates": 1556438, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 12036059613, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7733.080028243978, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 188932, "avg_candidate_generations": 3257.448275862069, "candidate_moves_total": 18640990, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.66507526517478, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 58, "root_candidate_moves_total": 5400, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 188874, "search_candidate_moves_total": 18635590, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 6159550, "avg_legality_checks": 106199.13793103448, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1897, "root_legality_checks": 5400, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 6154150, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1895, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15316865, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 264083.8793103448, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 27265768559, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1780.1141786520936, "renju_forbidden_checks": 316666, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5459.758620689655, "renju_forbidden_ns": 486843580, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1537.4040155874013, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 54363, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 88812534, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 61427, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 191864842, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 200522, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 205585631, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 354, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 580573, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 428009, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7379.4655172413795, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2508186185, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5860.12486886958, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 495805, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8548.362068965518, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 802428040, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1618.4347475317918, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12081548882, "stage_ordering_ns": 5110084699, "stage_eval_ns": 12047956510, "stage_threat_ns": 20210998528, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 4393442, "root_tactical_annotations": 15810, "search_tactical_annotations": 4377632, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1556496, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 7174194694, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 4035704, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11719178856, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 378154, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7154245969, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 778219, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1057448700, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1556438, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 169846798, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 2149310, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1063740171, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1508187, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3499833307, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 735945, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 90329480, "child_limit_applications": 188874, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 188874, "child_cap_hits": 188874, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 188874, "child_moves_before_total": 18633695, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 18633695, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 3022742, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 3022742, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 98.65675000264727, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00401325751559, "tt_hits": 82638, "tt_cutoffs": 12887, "beta_cutoffs": 151082, "depth_sum": 290, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 290, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 5, "count": 58 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 58, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08620689655172414, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7181.603448275862, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7319.5344827586205, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1281, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 60, "search_move_count": 58, "total_time_ms": 83236, "avg_search_time_ms": 1435.103448275862, "search_nodes": 742857, "safety_nodes": 3859, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 746716, "avg_nodes": 12874.413793103447, "eval_calls": 438791, "avg_eval_calls": 7565.362068965517, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 438791, "pattern_eval_ns": 9367940, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.349435152498568, "pattern_frame_queries": 438791, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 9367940, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.349435152498568, "pattern_frame_updates": 1484932, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 9951043458, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6701.346228648854, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 284285, "avg_candidate_generations": 4901.4655172413795, "candidate_moves_total": 28199226, "avg_candidate_moves": 99.19350651634804, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 58, "root_candidate_moves_total": 5440, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 284227, "search_candidate_moves_total": 28193786, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 18851413, "avg_legality_checks": 325024.3620689655, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7087, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 18851413, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7087, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 31437009, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 542017.3965517242, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 53691282194, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1707.900461968249, "renju_forbidden_checks": 982996, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 16948.206896551725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1132047837, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1151.6301561756102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 211979, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 318425638, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 76321, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 187200252, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 694364, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 625833815, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 332, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 588132, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1001973, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17275.396551724138, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 6289895158, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6277.509631497056, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1213958, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20930.310344827587, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2270374911, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1870.225255733724, "stage_move_gen_ns": 35530805363, "stage_ordering_ns": 7879369470, "stage_eval_ns": 9960411398, "stage_threat_ns": 29145606850, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 6214140, "root_tactical_annotations": 17377, "search_tactical_annotations": 6196763, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1484990, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 7066061609, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 5515149, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 20702655668, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 568961, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10968373182, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 742466, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1050351940, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1484932, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 165541833, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 2500935, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 3418553989, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 2445214, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 6315311865, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1267991, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 160995800, "child_limit_applications": 284227, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 284227, "child_cap_hits": 284227, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 284227, "child_moves_before_total": 28186699, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 28186699, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 2522320, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 2522320, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 99.16967423925243, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.874315248023587, "tt_hits": 136238, "tt_cutoffs": 19459, "beta_cutoffs": 227893, "depth_sum": 375, "avg_depth": 6.4655172413793105, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 375, "avg_effective_depth": 6.4655172413793105, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 5, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 15 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 35 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 16, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.27586206896551724, "pooled_budget_moves": 58, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3103448275862069, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 16, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.27586206896551724, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4359.068965517241, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4497.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1214, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 34063, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 110, 109, 82, 124, 126, 81, 94, 78, 80, 64, 66, 108, 128, 144, 68, 54, 52, 38, 95, 146, 162, 125, 36, 84, 158, 142, 143, 173, 127, 79, 159 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 30090, "avg_search_time_ms": 1671.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 298834, "safety_nodes": 411, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 299245, "avg_nodes": 16624.722222222223, "eval_calls": 194492, "avg_eval_calls": 10805.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 194492, "pattern_eval_ns": 4030481, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.723119717006355, "pattern_frame_queries": 194492, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4030481, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.723119717006355, "pattern_frame_updates": 597466, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7830905683, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13106.864127833216, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 96775, "avg_candidate_generations": 5376.388888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 8847830, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.42681477654352, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1422, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 96757, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8846408, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 2297045, "avg_legality_checks": 127613.61111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1808, "root_legality_checks": 1422, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2295623, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1808, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8532714, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 474039.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17653938635, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2068.9710958318774, "renju_forbidden_checks": 61230, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3401.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 222619085, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3635.784501061571, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2106, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14274100, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 30806, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 150410993, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28318, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 57933992, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 246496, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13694.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1926194981, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7814.305226048293, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 313715, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17428.61111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 746986093, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2381.097789394833, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5224566626, "stage_ordering_ns": 3223538194, "stage_eval_ns": 7834936164, "stage_threat_ns": 13717855120, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2536516, "root_tactical_annotations": 6134, "search_tactical_annotations": 2530382, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 597484, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3442716573, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2028793, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9667117448, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 193650, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6398142046, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 298733, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 438385282, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 597466, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 73836052, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 879581, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 693875682, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 955546, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2574786847, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 701389, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 95799765, "child_limit_applications": 96757, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 96757, "child_cap_hits": 96757, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 96757, "child_moves_before_total": 8844600, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8844600, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 1414064, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1414064, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.41044058827785, "avg_child_moves_after": 14.614591192368511, "tt_hits": 55682, "tt_cutoffs": 7489, "beta_cutoffs": 80341, "depth_sum": 95, "avg_depth": 5.277777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 95, "avg_effective_depth": 5.277777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1743.9444444444443, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2076.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 3955, "avg_search_time_ms": 232.64705882352942, "search_nodes": 38974, "safety_nodes": 1953, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40927, "avg_nodes": 2407.470588235294, "eval_calls": 27100, "avg_eval_calls": 1594.1176470588234, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 27100, "pattern_eval_ns": 563482, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.79269372693727, "pattern_frame_queries": 27100, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 563482, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.79269372693727, "pattern_frame_updates": 77788, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 847200062, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10891.140818635266, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11261, "avg_candidate_generations": 662.4117647058823, "candidate_moves_total": 921431, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.82497113933043, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1338, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 11244, "search_candidate_moves_total": 920093, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 377241, "avg_legality_checks": 22190.647058823528, "illegal_moves_skipped": 137, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 377241, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 137, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1171141, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 68890.64705882352, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2383267160, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2034.9959227795798, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6022, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 354.2352941176471, "renju_forbidden_ns": 22226438, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3690.873131849884, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 139, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1121027, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2383, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14911156, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3500, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6194255, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 41622, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2448.3529411764707, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 353745153, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8498.994594204987, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 55771, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3280.6470588235293, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 151596148, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2718.189525021965, "stage_move_gen_ns": 872397155, "stage_ordering_ns": 352426241, "stage_eval_ns": 847763544, "stage_threat_ns": 1849584621, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 247607, "root_tactical_annotations": 381, "search_tactical_annotations": 247226, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 77805, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 471380628, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 239739, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1309574629, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22602, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 761466000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38894, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 56648859, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 77788, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9559552, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 72182, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 158434031, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 144945, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 389273305, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 30480, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2420953, "child_limit_applications": 11244, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11244, "child_cap_hits": 11244, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11244, "child_moves_before_total": 919956, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 919956, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 195309, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 195309, "child_moves_after_max": 29, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 29, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.81750266808965, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.370064034151547, "tt_hits": 3290, "tt_cutoffs": 550, "beta_cutoffs": 9533, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6602.941176470588, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7073.529411764706, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1871, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1215, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21052, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 96, 141, 82, 142, 110, 124, 97, 67, 98, 95, 114, 66, 64, 80, 99, 100, 144, 129, 68, 54, 128, 160, 130, 146, 113, 83, 158, 143, 172, 116, 186 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 12686, "avg_search_time_ms": 792.875, "search_nodes": 141860, "safety_nodes": 97, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 141957, "avg_nodes": 8872.3125, "eval_calls": 95182, "avg_eval_calls": 5948.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 95182, "pattern_eval_ns": 1981526, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.81828496984724, "pattern_frame_queries": 95182, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1981526, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.81828496984724, "pattern_frame_updates": 283576, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3242754069, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11435.220431207154, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43992, "avg_candidate_generations": 2749.5, "candidate_moves_total": 3616802, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.2149936352064, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1125, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 43976, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3615677, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 814673, "avg_legality_checks": 50917.0625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 917, "root_legality_checks": 1125, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 813548, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 916, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3333966, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 208372.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7101521238, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2130.05208751379, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36789, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2299.3125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 143558360, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3902.208812416755, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1072, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6699104, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17469, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 95675313, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18243, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41178563, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5380, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 80714, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5044.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 683350264, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8466.316425898853, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 104793, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6549.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 279410363, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2666.307510997872, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1926756334, "stage_ordering_ns": 1369139375, "stage_eval_ns": 3244735595, "stage_threat_ns": 6095627146, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1063211, "root_tactical_annotations": 4776, "search_tactical_annotations": 1058435, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 283592, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1649139645, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 856756, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4169250362, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 88055, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2961412119, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 141788, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 202617948, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 283576, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34583735, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 397179, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 236217013, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 371507, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 971602810, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 294525, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 40035456, "child_limit_applications": 43976, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43976, "child_cap_hits": 43976, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43976, "child_moves_before_total": 3614761, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3614761, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 711879, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 711879, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.19849463343643, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.187897944333272, "tt_hits": 22302, "tt_cutoffs": 2630, "beta_cutoffs": 37886, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5840.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6340.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 714, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 8352, "avg_search_time_ms": 556.8, "search_nodes": 66531, "safety_nodes": 1381, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67912, "avg_nodes": 4527.466666666666, "eval_calls": 38556, "avg_eval_calls": 2570.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38556, "pattern_eval_ns": 808962, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.98148148148148, "pattern_frame_queries": 38556, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 808962, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.98148148148148, "pattern_frame_updates": 132878, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1458295470, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10974.69460708319, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24722, "avg_candidate_generations": 1648.1333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 1849733, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.8213332254672, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1061, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 24707, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1848672, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 990466, "avg_legality_checks": 66031.06666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1192, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 990466, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1192, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2537695, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 169179.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5278886318, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2080.189430959985, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22364, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1490.9333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 68847709, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3078.5060364872115, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1282, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9602152, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6774, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 39291651, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14303, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19947736, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6170, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 84206, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5613.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 724407920, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8602.806450846732, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110056, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7337.066666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 300285257, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2728.4769299265827, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2320253491, "stage_ordering_ns": 738594445, "stage_eval_ns": 1459104432, "stage_threat_ns": 3784894462, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 475854, "root_tactical_annotations": 485, "search_tactical_annotations": 475369, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 132893, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 806838420, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 419939, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2851551076, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49536, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1717171520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66439, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 98931480, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 132878, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16754437, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 72526, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 156085305, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 297870, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 978071640, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 105458, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10819049, "child_limit_applications": 24707, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24707, "child_cap_hits": 24707, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24707, "child_moves_before_total": 1847480, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1847480, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 277740, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 277740, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.77556967660986, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.241348605658315, "tt_hits": 12184, "tt_cutoffs": 3177, "beta_cutoffs": 20461, "depth_sum": 91, "avg_depth": 6.066666666666666, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 91, "avg_effective_depth": 6.066666666666666, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5577.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6110.466666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1216, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 34063, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 158, 82, 67, 110, 68, 98, 95, 66, 50, 80, 64, 94, 52, 128, 144, 124, 138, 108, 122, 81, 174, 190, 83, 92, 140, 130, 114, 129, 131, 113, 65, 145 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 30095, "avg_search_time_ms": 1671.9444444444443, "search_nodes": 299074, "safety_nodes": 411, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 299485, "avg_nodes": 16638.055555555555, "eval_calls": 193618, "avg_eval_calls": 10756.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 193618, "pattern_eval_ns": 4015800, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.740840211137396, "pattern_frame_queries": 193618, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4015800, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.740840211137396, "pattern_frame_updates": 597946, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7795602411, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13037.301714536095, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 97687, "avg_candidate_generations": 5427.055555555556, "candidate_moves_total": 8935109, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.46671512074278, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1422, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 97669, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8933687, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 2299103, "avg_legality_checks": 127727.94444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2061, "root_legality_checks": 1422, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2297681, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2061, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8575062, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 476392.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17667159540, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2060.2952538418963, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65914, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3661.8888888888887, "renju_forbidden_ns": 233195913, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3537.8813757320145, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2339, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15959003, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33473, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 156484362, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30102, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 60752548, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 248570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13809.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1955752661, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7868.015693768355, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 316766, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17598.11111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 765703981, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2417.254317066857, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5205908212, "stage_ordering_ns": 3236900330, "stage_eval_ns": 7799618211, "stage_threat_ns": 13763646829, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2590101, "root_tactical_annotations": 6134, "search_tactical_annotations": 2583967, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 597964, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3424807439, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2049746, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9731313446, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 195474, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6430823224, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 298973, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 438607039, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 597946, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 73568439, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 884791, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 727574482, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 969465, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2572598508, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 735845, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 95350466, "child_limit_applications": 97669, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 97669, "child_cap_hits": 97669, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 97669, "child_moves_before_total": 8931626, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8931626, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 1451114, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1451114, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.44791080076585, "avg_child_moves_after": 14.857467569034187, "tt_hits": 56412, "tt_cutoffs": 7688, "beta_cutoffs": 81279, "depth_sum": 95, "avg_depth": 5.277777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 95, "avg_effective_depth": 5.277777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1728.1666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2060.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 3950, "avg_search_time_ms": 232.35294117647058, "search_nodes": 38148, "safety_nodes": 1953, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40101, "avg_nodes": 2358.8823529411766, "eval_calls": 26343, "avg_eval_calls": 1549.5882352941176, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 26343, "pattern_eval_ns": 548163, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.80867782712675, "pattern_frame_queries": 26343, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 548163, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.80867782712675, "pattern_frame_updates": 76136, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 826216403, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10851.849361668594, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11145, "avg_candidate_generations": 655.5882352941177, "candidate_moves_total": 913495, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.9645580978017, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1338, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 11128, "search_candidate_moves_total": 912157, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 388052, "avg_legality_checks": 22826.58823529412, "illegal_moves_skipped": 143, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 388052, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1180085, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 69416.76470588235, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2399591138, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2033.4053377510943, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5956, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 350.3529411764706, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19818196, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3327.433848220282, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 145, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1178810, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2193, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12929032, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3618, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5710354, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2552.3529411764707, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 369997480, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8527.25236229546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 57768, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3398.1176470588234, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 158466730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2743.1576305220883, "stage_move_gen_ns": 895648689, "stage_ordering_ns": 348851197, "stage_eval_ns": 826764566, "stage_threat_ns": 1844633649, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 247320, "root_tactical_annotations": 381, "search_tactical_annotations": 246939, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 76153, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 461805596, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 239492, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1314872114, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22370, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 749017123, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38068, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 55752862, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 76136, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9356283, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 72844, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 167548126, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 144268, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 397900854, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 30208, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2846794, "child_limit_applications": 11128, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11128, "child_cap_hits": 11128, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11128, "child_moves_before_total": 912014, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 912014, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 193379, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 193379, "child_moves_after_max": 29, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 29, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.95668583752696, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.377695902228613, "tt_hits": 3351, "tt_cutoffs": 597, "beta_cutoffs": 9464, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6598.823529411765, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7069.411764705882, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1839, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1217, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17465, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 83, 128, 67, 82, 111, 69, 35, 51, 66, 125, 65, 64, 80, 50, 52, 94, 36, 79, 38, 24, 37, 34, 39 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9772, "avg_search_time_ms": 814.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 121063, "safety_nodes": 380, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 121443, "avg_nodes": 10120.25, "eval_calls": 82675, "avg_eval_calls": 6889.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82675, "pattern_eval_ns": 1703366, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.603156939824615, "pattern_frame_queries": 82675, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1703366, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.603156939824615, "pattern_frame_updates": 242022, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2273009704, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9391.74828734578, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35206, "avg_candidate_generations": 2933.8333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2630086, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.70561836050673, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 769, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 35194, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2629317, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 851647, "avg_legality_checks": 70970.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 129, "root_legality_checks": 769, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 850878, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 129, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2747938, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 228994.83333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5661938223, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2060.4315756032343, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12218, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1018.1666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 36277092, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2969.1514159436897, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 143, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1236864, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3511, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24355299, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8561, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10680529, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4400, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59062, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4921.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 493853194, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8361.606345873828, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 79326, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6610.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 212348338, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2676.907167889469, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1942293660, "stage_ordering_ns": 979858327, "stage_eval_ns": 2274713070, "stage_threat_ns": 4519469889, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 419246, "root_tactical_annotations": 2716, "search_tactical_annotations": 416530, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 242034, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1331475387, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 410358, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2988837360, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70463, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2209201766, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121011, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 162519495, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 242022, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27998812, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 126655, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 108560635, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 213229, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 670853449, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79362, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8638835, "child_limit_applications": 35194, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35194, "child_cap_hits": 35194, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35194, "child_moves_before_total": 2629188, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2629188, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 563108, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 563108, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.70557481388873, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000113655736772, "tt_hits": 15109, "tt_cutoffs": 3142, "beta_cutoffs": 29794, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4732.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5398.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 750, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7683, "avg_search_time_ms": 698.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 251042, "safety_nodes": 908, "corridor_nodes": 963, "corridor_branch_probes": 1124, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 379, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 945, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 945, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 379, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 353, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 143360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 252913, "avg_nodes": 22992.090909090908, "eval_calls": 246518, "avg_eval_calls": 22410.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 246518, "pattern_eval_ns": 5011450, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.32894149717262, "pattern_frame_queries": 246518, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5011450, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.32894149717262, "pattern_frame_updates": 502020, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4297618452, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8560.65187044341, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4503, "avg_candidate_generations": 409.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 340700, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.66067066400177, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 718, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 4492, "search_candidate_moves_total": 339982, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 9471, "avg_legality_checks": 861.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9471, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1265383, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 115034.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2742206513, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2167.096059453936, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3102, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 282.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21349506, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6882.497098646035, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3088, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21305335, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44171, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23279000, "stage_ordering_ns": 148260, "stage_eval_ns": 4302629902, "stage_threat_ns": 3228317284, "stage_proof_ns": 93624294, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 504043, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2760748621, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59493, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 74562820, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 688, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 29523269, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 252016, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 322858844, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2012, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11688232, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 504032, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58458767, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 177, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4144, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5581.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6308.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1787, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1218, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11760, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 80, 99, 85, 141, 155, 128, 83, 143, 158, 84, 69, 111, 52, 67, 55, 41, 159, 126, 156, 157, 79, 81, 96, 129, 125, 130 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 4169, "avg_search_time_ms": 297.7857142857143, "search_nodes": 73932, "safety_nodes": 1451, "corridor_nodes": 2861, "corridor_branch_probes": 3426, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1165, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 2826, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2806, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 20, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 88, "corridor_proof_active": 35, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1165, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 88, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 4, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 536, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 218720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 20400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 78244, "avg_nodes": 5588.857142857143, "eval_calls": 70709, "avg_eval_calls": 5050.642857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70709, "pattern_eval_ns": 1438687, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.346589543056755, "pattern_frame_queries": 70709, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1438687, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.346589543056755, "pattern_frame_updates": 147782, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1991662711, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13477.031783302433, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3196, "avg_candidate_generations": 228.28571428571428, "candidate_moves_total": 262699, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.19618272841052, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1051, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 3182, "search_candidate_moves_total": 261648, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 68100, "avg_legality_checks": 4864.285714285715, "illegal_moves_skipped": 324, "root_legality_checks": 1051, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 67049, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 318, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1072527, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 76609.07142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2279533268, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2125.3854383153057, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16894, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1206.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124740286, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7383.703445010063, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 332, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2792692, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14884, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 113807626, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 426, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2459261, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1252, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5680707, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 8071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 576.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 77785209, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9637.617271713541, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10545, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 753.2142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 41746528, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3958.893124703651, "stage_move_gen_ns": 158638180, "stage_ordering_ns": 103440, "stage_eval_ns": 1993101398, "stage_threat_ns": 1534522476, "stage_proof_ns": 456030587, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 153624, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 867000062, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 171536, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 511476136, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1565, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 100934997, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76805, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 102454561, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5828, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 36128314, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 153610, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17463403, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 187, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2877, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6437.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7008.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1838, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 7577, "avg_search_time_ms": 541.2142857142857, "search_nodes": 56210, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 57183, "avg_nodes": 4084.5, "eval_calls": 37399, "avg_eval_calls": 2671.3571428571427, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37399, "pattern_eval_ns": 789685, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.11513676836279, "pattern_frame_queries": 37399, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 789685, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.11513676836279, "pattern_frame_updates": 112296, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1160497496, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10334.272779083849, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17637, "avg_candidate_generations": 1259.7857142857142, "candidate_moves_total": 1497125, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.8854680501219, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1096, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 17623, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1496029, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1081577, "avg_legality_checks": 77255.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3554, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1081577, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3554, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2453291, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 175235.07142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4975884948, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2028.248971687419, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58204, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4157.428571428572, "renju_forbidden_ns": 144485235, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2482.393564016219, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5470, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 38496403, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7402, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33073207, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 45208, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 72325891, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 124, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 589734, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98796, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7056.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 977270099, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9891.798240819466, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 130465, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9318.92857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 481862990, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3693.4272793469513, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2570996740, "stage_ordering_ns": 586613908, "stage_eval_ns": 1161287181, "stage_threat_ns": 3203634420, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 344535, "root_tactical_annotations": 1582, "search_tactical_annotations": 342953, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 112310, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 673277293, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 300472, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2425466454, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35335, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1217545570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56148, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81328098, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 112296, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13915904, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 107419, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 501123174, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 157709, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 706536320, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79407, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9646671, "child_limit_applications": 17623, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17623, "child_cap_hits": 17623, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17623, "child_moves_before_total": 1492475, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1492475, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 282757, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 282757, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.68904272825286, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.044771037848268, "tt_hits": 7777, "tt_cutoffs": 1126, "beta_cutoffs": 15262, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5712.642857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6284.071428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1847, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1219, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12411, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 142, 110, 141, 96, 98, 140, 68, 125, 83, 53, 95, 124, 82, 156, 84, 70, 81, 85, 80 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8256, "avg_search_time_ms": 688.0, "search_nodes": 90448, "safety_nodes": 900, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91348, "avg_nodes": 7612.333333333333, "eval_calls": 67644, "avg_eval_calls": 5637.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67644, "pattern_eval_ns": 1461936, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.61220507362072, "pattern_frame_queries": 67644, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1461936, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.61220507362072, "pattern_frame_updates": 180792, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2109044997, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11665.58806252489, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21899, "avg_candidate_generations": 1824.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1638336, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.81327914516645, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 742, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 21887, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1637594, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 704042, "avg_legality_checks": 58670.166666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 731, "root_legality_checks": 742, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 703300, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 730, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2130992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 177582.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4898471484, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2298.681310863673, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11704, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 975.3333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 58977079, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5039.053229665072, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 755, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8452185, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4490, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37085975, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6452, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13375609, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 63310, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54626, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4552.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 470048575, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8604.85071211511, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68669, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5722.416666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 181532523, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2643.5876887678573, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1774949949, "stage_ordering_ns": 727597645, "stage_eval_ns": 2110506933, "stage_threat_ns": 3603839820, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 280565, "root_tactical_annotations": 1377, "search_tactical_annotations": 279188, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 180804, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1088334872, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 270776, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2348968880, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43849, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1653024830, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 90396, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 137039075, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 180792, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23482685, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 78564, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 95688742, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 148352, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 599766415, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53649, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6014308, "child_limit_applications": 21887, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21887, "child_cap_hits": 21887, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21887, "child_moves_before_total": 1636864, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1636864, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 350195, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 350195, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.7870425366656, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000137067665737, "tt_hits": 8177, "tt_cutoffs": 865, "beta_cutoffs": 17463, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5012.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5679.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1156, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4143, "avg_search_time_ms": 376.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 111777, "safety_nodes": 518, "corridor_nodes": 3625, "corridor_branch_probes": 3944, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1447, "corridor_neutral_exits": 68, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 3600, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3600, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 68, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1447, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 92, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 705, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 302720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 115920, "avg_nodes": 10538.181818181818, "eval_calls": 107737, "avg_eval_calls": 9794.272727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107737, "pattern_eval_ns": 2302338, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.36998431365269, "pattern_frame_queries": 107737, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2302338, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.36998431365269, "pattern_frame_updates": 223490, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2093469062, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9367.171068056736, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4019, "avg_candidate_generations": 365.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 297477, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.01766608609107, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 678, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 4008, "search_candidate_moves_total": 296799, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 10186, "avg_legality_checks": 926.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10186, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 658325, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 59847.72727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1527857263, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2320.825220066077, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2969, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 269.90909090909093, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16068990, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5412.2566520714045, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33400, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2874, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15768618, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 79, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 106280, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 160692, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 27774358, "stage_ordering_ns": 143560, "stage_eval_ns": 2095771400, "stage_threat_ns": 1867021612, "stage_proof_ns": 138016444, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 230885, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1367950509, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 217724, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 264145456, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2352, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 108600354, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115437, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 162194523, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7384, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 43906159, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 230874, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28824965, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 316, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3524, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5962.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6689.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1220, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12130, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 81, 100, 142, 72, 86, 129, 126, 130, 131, 66, 110, 109, 94, 78, 158 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4155, "avg_search_time_ms": 461.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 91539, "safety_nodes": 510, "corridor_nodes": 374, "corridor_branch_probes": 445, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 116, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 366, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 366, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 116, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 287, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 101360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 92423, "avg_nodes": 10269.222222222223, "eval_calls": 88931, "avg_eval_calls": 9881.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 88931, "pattern_eval_ns": 1888618, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.236891522641148, "pattern_frame_queries": 88931, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1888618, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.236891522641148, "pattern_frame_updates": 183028, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2450880086, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13390.738499027471, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2592, "avg_candidate_generations": 288.0, "candidate_moves_total": 189345, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.04976851851852, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 628, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 2583, "search_candidate_moves_total": 188717, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 86742, "avg_legality_checks": 9638.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 628, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 86114, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 787787, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 87531.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1966286589, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2495.962219483185, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8261, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 917.8888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66684289, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8072.181212928217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 181020, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8126, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 65731424, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 381943, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 80, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 389902, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 124.11111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 11830994, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10591.758281110117, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1496, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 166.22222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 6135767, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4101.448529411765, "stage_move_gen_ns": 223033388, "stage_ordering_ns": 84670, "stage_eval_ns": 2452768704, "stage_threat_ns": 1332200381, "stage_proof_ns": 126595750, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 183851, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1086169931, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26858, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 91083881, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 337, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19632767, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91921, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 127526403, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 814, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4235753, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 183842, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23184413, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2213, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5188.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6077.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1834, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7966, "avg_search_time_ms": 995.75, "search_nodes": 58991, "safety_nodes": 553, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59544, "avg_nodes": 7443.0, "eval_calls": 40173, "avg_eval_calls": 5021.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40173, "pattern_eval_ns": 879113, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.883180245438478, "pattern_frame_queries": 40173, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 879113, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.883180245438478, "pattern_frame_updates": 117912, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1327177593, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11255.661790148586, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17661, "avg_candidate_generations": 2207.625, "candidate_moves_total": 1427615, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.83432421720174, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 555, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 17653, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1427060, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1036861, "avg_legality_checks": 129607.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 690, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1036861, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 690, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2385686, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 298210.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5299368690, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2221.318601861268, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14946, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1868.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 40605864, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2716.8382175833, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 696, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7438322, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1859, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14391797, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12391, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18775745, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 95415, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11926.875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 927307499, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9718.676298275952, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 127269, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15908.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 406633816, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3195.073552868334, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2614332772, "stage_ordering_ns": 626410030, "stage_eval_ns": 1328056706, "stage_threat_ns": 3349385920, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 259139, "root_tactical_annotations": 981, "search_tactical_annotations": 258158, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 117920, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 732023338, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 250104, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2507060523, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35357, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1325966289, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58956, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88312217, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 117912, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15390816, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52346, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 285860811, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 162395, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 895129633, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 44398, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6599026, "child_limit_applications": 17653, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17653, "child_cap_hits": 17653, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17653, "child_moves_before_total": 1426370, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1426370, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 282495, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 282495, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.80043052172435, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00266243697955, "tt_hits": 5227, "tt_cutoffs": 1131, "beta_cutoffs": 15068, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2526.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3526.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 490, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1221, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "draw", "winner": null, "end_reason": "max_moves", "duration_ms": 77074, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 129, 81, 109, 125, 80, 127, 143, 140, 155, 98, 126, 139, 157, 171, 156, 158, 145, 161, 144, 142, 159, 153, 167, 138, 141, 174, 173, 79, 63, 131, 114, 99, 146, 147, 189, 205, 187, 201, 115, 101, 100, 137, 136, 169, 185, 130, 188, 186, 190, 191, 86, 72, 117, 116, 172, 123, 108, 121, 105, 122, 124, 154, 170, 106, 90, 92, 200, 215, 204, 220, 107, 177, 163, 162, 192, 176, 120, 175, 178, 133, 119, 134, 132, 168, 183, 182, 196, 135, 193, 221, 206, 223, 217, 202, 148, 208, 222, 70, 48, 71, 60, 75, 64, 32, 62, 61, 66, 65, 52, 94, 93, 78, 34 ], "move_count": 120, "black_stats": { "move_count": 60, "search_move_count": 58, "total_time_ms": 29407, "avg_search_time_ms": 507.01724137931035, "search_nodes": 363270, "safety_nodes": 5742, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 369012, "avg_nodes": 6362.275862068966, "eval_calls": 248826, "avg_eval_calls": 4290.103448275862, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 248826, "pattern_eval_ns": 5430149, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.82307717039216, "pattern_frame_queries": 248826, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5430149, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.82307717039216, "pattern_frame_updates": 725962, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6568118597, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9047.468871648929, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 107742, "avg_candidate_generations": 1857.6206896551723, "candidate_moves_total": 10663755, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.97491229047168, "candidate_moves_max": 141, "root_candidate_generations": 58, "root_candidate_moves_total": 5405, "root_candidate_moves_max": 120, "search_candidate_generations": 107684, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10658350, "search_candidate_moves_max": 141, "legality_checks": 3490996, "avg_legality_checks": 60189.58620689655, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6030, "root_legality_checks": 5405, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 3485591, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6020, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8897321, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 153402.08620689655, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16802094874, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1888.4442714835172, "renju_forbidden_checks": 67993, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1172.2931034482758, "renju_forbidden_ns": 239196750, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3517.9614077919787, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6470, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52211232, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21560, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 117041877, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 39905, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 69451119, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 58, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 492522, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 254262, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4383.827586206897, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1855352936, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7297.01227867318, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 334259, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5763.086206896552, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 814501206, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2436.736799906659, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7257033420, "stage_ordering_ns": 3245672815, "stage_eval_ns": 6573548746, "stage_threat_ns": 12105726776, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2630645, "root_tactical_annotations": 8589, "search_tactical_annotations": 2622056, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 726020, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3538884141, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2471934, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7921687564, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 215773, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4791611633, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 362981, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 519688075, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 725962, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 85099902, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1378473, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 878206739, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 877649, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2250089894, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 374523, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 40367094, "child_limit_applications": 107684, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 107684, "child_cap_hits": 107684, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 107684, "child_moves_before_total": 10652330, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10652330, "child_moves_before_max": 140, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 140, "child_moves_after_total": 1723176, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1723176, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 98.92212399242227, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002154451914862, "tt_hits": 45765, "tt_cutoffs": 6471, "beta_cutoffs": 91575, "depth_sum": 289, "avg_depth": 4.982758620689655, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 289, "avg_effective_depth": 4.982758620689655, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 57 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 58, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.034482758620689655, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7430.413793103448, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7568.3448275862065, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1249, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 60, "search_move_count": 58, "total_time_ms": 47611, "avg_search_time_ms": 820.8793103448276, "search_nodes": 1765161, "safety_nodes": 5745, "corridor_nodes": 12233, "corridor_branch_probes": 13331, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4998, "corridor_neutral_exits": 337, "corridor_terminal_exits": 19, "corridor_plies_followed": 12123, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 12123, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 55, "corridor_proof_completed": 55, "corridor_proof_checks": 349, "corridor_proof_active": 110, "corridor_proof_quiet": 239, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 337, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4998, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 7, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 349, "corridor_proof_wins": 9, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 340, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 7, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 2300, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 797600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 28960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 11, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 1783139, "avg_nodes": 30743.775862068964, "eval_calls": 1729008, "avg_eval_calls": 29810.48275862069, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 1729008, "pattern_eval_ns": 36758978, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.260154955905353, "pattern_frame_queries": 1729008, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 36758978, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.260154955905353, "pattern_frame_updates": 3529974, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 26387649397, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7475.309845624925, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 36037, "avg_candidate_generations": 621.3275862068965, "candidate_moves_total": 3767930, "avg_candidate_moves": 104.55726059327912, "candidate_moves_max": 144, "root_candidate_generations": 58, "root_candidate_moves_total": 5433, "root_candidate_moves_max": 121, "search_candidate_generations": 35979, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3762497, "search_candidate_moves_max": 144, "legality_checks": 92836, "avg_legality_checks": 1600.6206896551723, "illegal_moves_skipped": 52, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 92836, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 52, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8655543, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 149233.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16961242128, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1959.5815222684469, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46486, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 801.4827586206897, "renju_forbidden_ns": 320040281, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6884.659488878372, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 383530, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 46134, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 317497983, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 150, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 764024, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 150, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1394744, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 231653789, "stage_ordering_ns": 1250493, "stage_eval_ns": 26424408375, "stage_threat_ns": 20246306694, "stage_proof_ns": 404663948, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 3554976, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 16799834842, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 592763, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 608582491, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 8088, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 257627406, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 1777459, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 2264086258, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 24944, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 174926077, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 3554918, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 398877026, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1779, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 33008, "depth_sum": 171, "avg_depth": 2.9482758620689653, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 171, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9482758620689653, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 55 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05172413793103448, "pooled_budget_moves": 58, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1206896551724138, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05172413793103448, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6968.793103448276, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7106.724137931034, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1913, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1222, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13530, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 145, 129, 98, 125, 99, 100, 140, 127, 79, 109, 108, 157, 173, 143, 159, 115, 101, 171 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9202, "avg_search_time_ms": 836.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 196091, "safety_nodes": 426, "corridor_nodes": 4593, "corridor_branch_probes": 4987, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2421, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 4573, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4573, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 81, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 61, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2421, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 81, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 77, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 599, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 213760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 11, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 8, "total_nodes": 201110, "avg_nodes": 18282.727272727272, "eval_calls": 190481, "avg_eval_calls": 17316.454545454544, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 190481, "pattern_eval_ns": 3867569, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.30422456832965, "pattern_frame_queries": 190481, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3867569, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.30422456832965, "pattern_frame_updates": 392120, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4807506672, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12260.29448128124, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5590, "avg_candidate_generations": 508.1818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 426629, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.32003577817531, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 5579, "search_candidate_moves_total": 425907, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 186542, "avg_legality_checks": 16958.363636363636, "illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 185820, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2083882, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 189443.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4626458757, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2220.115513738302, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30453, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2768.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 126815111, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4164.289593800282, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 154, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 460713, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28576, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 120228965, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 172, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1968111, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1551, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4157322, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 11743, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1067.5454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 109090371, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9289.821255215873, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1458.2727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 55206641, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3441.5959728196494, "stage_move_gen_ns": 449787042, "stage_ordering_ns": 179880, "stage_eval_ns": 4811374241, "stage_threat_ns": 3378162006, "stage_proof_ns": 535542289, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 401439, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2275256147, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 224544, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 730269524, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2144, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 140302250, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 200714, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 271463048, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9308, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 53609720, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 401428, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47563567, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 452, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4723, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5489.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6216.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1789, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 4318, "avg_search_time_ms": 431.8, "search_nodes": 37577, "safety_nodes": 842, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 38419, "avg_nodes": 3841.9, "eval_calls": 25452, "avg_eval_calls": 2545.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 25452, "pattern_eval_ns": 539463, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.195308816595944, "pattern_frame_queries": 25452, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 539463, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.195308816595944, "pattern_frame_updates": 75064, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 746285528, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9941.989875306404, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11545, "avg_candidate_generations": 1154.5, "candidate_moves_total": 830409, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.92802078822001, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 645, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 11535, "search_candidate_moves_total": 829764, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 507663, "avg_legality_checks": 50766.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 28, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 507663, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 28, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1348373, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 134837.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2791437717, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2070.226648709222, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7208, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 720.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14803172, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2053.714206437292, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 62, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 283402, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1697, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8268034, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5449, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6251736, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50943, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5094.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 481690920, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9455.48789823921, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 71867, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7186.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 228074000, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3173.556708920645, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1214586926, "stage_ordering_ns": 349328768, "stage_eval_ns": 746824991, "stage_threat_ns": 1977253506, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 157816, "root_tactical_annotations": 556, "search_tactical_annotations": 157260, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 75074, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 451754025, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 152666, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1459818207, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23135, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 842680285, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37532, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 53543331, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 75064, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9372762, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32346, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 166943265, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 97178, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 449992504, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 28292, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2765181, "child_limit_applications": 11535, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11535, "child_cap_hits": 11535, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11535, "child_moves_before_total": 829736, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 829736, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 185082, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 185082, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.9320329432163, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.04525357607282, "tt_hits": 3587, "tt_cutoffs": 545, "beta_cutoffs": 9888, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5047.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5847.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1873, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1223, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3617, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 95, 129, 97, 115, 116, 101, 157, 87 ], "move_count": 15, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 3018, "avg_search_time_ms": 503.0, "search_nodes": 42858, "safety_nodes": 295, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 43153, "avg_nodes": 7192.166666666667, "eval_calls": 33192, "avg_eval_calls": 5532.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33192, "pattern_eval_ns": 676432, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.37936852253555, "pattern_frame_queries": 33192, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 676432, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.37936852253555, "pattern_frame_updates": 85672, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 747416557, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8724.16375245121, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9225, "avg_candidate_generations": 1537.5, "candidate_moves_total": 636470, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.9940379403794, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 325, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 9219, "search_candidate_moves_total": 636145, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 222773, "avg_legality_checks": 37128.833333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "root_legality_checks": 325, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 222448, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 761710, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 126951.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1689150329, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2217.5766748500087, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3039, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 506.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9104863, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2996.0062520565975, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 118871, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1152, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6533420, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1861, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2450272, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2300, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15507, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2584.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 137632201, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8875.488553556459, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20376, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3396.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 59879132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2938.708873184138, "stage_move_gen_ns": 558717569, "stage_ordering_ns": 271809699, "stage_eval_ns": 748092989, "stage_threat_ns": 1421938315, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 65638, "root_tactical_annotations": 733, "search_tactical_annotations": 64905, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 85678, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 477286225, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 70509, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 875319671, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18471, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 680387514, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42836, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 57869170, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 85672, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10017986, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 10766, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 18219555, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 41267, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 176581161, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 13605, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1445263, "child_limit_applications": 9219, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9219, "child_cap_hits": 9219, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9219, "child_moves_before_total": 636133, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 636133, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 147504, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 147504, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.00238637596269, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 3564, "tt_cutoffs": 425, "beta_cutoffs": 7037, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3007.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4340.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1073, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 7, "search_move_count": 5, "total_time_ms": 594, "avg_search_time_ms": 118.8, "search_nodes": 20255, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 130, "corridor_branch_probes": 153, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 40, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 127, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 127, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 35, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 40, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 35, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 35, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 276, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 64240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 3920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 20585, "avg_nodes": 4117.0, "eval_calls": 19068, "avg_eval_calls": 3813.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 19068, "pattern_eval_ns": 376894, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.765785609397945, "pattern_frame_queries": 19068, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 376894, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.765785609397945, "pattern_frame_updates": 40482, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 279796970, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6911.639000049405, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1178, "avg_candidate_generations": 235.6, "candidate_moves_total": 74808, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.50424448217318, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 5, "root_candidate_moves_total": 266, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 1173, "search_candidate_moves_total": 74542, "search_candidate_moves_max": 83, "legality_checks": 3985, "avg_legality_checks": 797.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3985, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 102388, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20477.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 192793240, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1882.9671445872564, "renju_forbidden_checks": 215, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 43.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1781147, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8284.404651162791, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 195, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 1585175, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 195972, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10204223, "stage_ordering_ns": 38472, "stage_eval_ns": 280173864, "stage_threat_ns": 250083052, "stage_proof_ns": 46743154, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 40811, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 207878058, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 9703, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 12042924, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6788288, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 20403, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 24520312, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 324, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1141193, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 40806, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4500565, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 107, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1020, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3700.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5300.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1969, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1224, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19589, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 95, 141, 96, 159, 175, 144, 142, 156, 93, 171, 126, 186, 201, 94, 100, 86, 80, 64, 110, 125, 68, 124, 116, 115, 84, 52, 132 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 14066, "avg_search_time_ms": 879.125, "search_nodes": 296610, "safety_nodes": 565, "corridor_nodes": 4943, "corridor_branch_probes": 5361, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2250, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 4915, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4915, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 129, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 101, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2250, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 129, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 126, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 996, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 205920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 302118, "avg_nodes": 18882.375, "eval_calls": 287706, "avg_eval_calls": 17981.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 287706, "pattern_eval_ns": 6165044, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.428277477702935, "pattern_frame_queries": 287706, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6165044, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.428277477702935, "pattern_frame_updates": 593128, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7585298272, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12788.636301101955, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8874, "avg_candidate_generations": 554.625, "candidate_moves_total": 804776, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.68920441739914, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1267, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 8858, "search_candidate_moves_total": 803509, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 275753, "avg_legality_checks": 17234.5625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "root_legality_checks": 1267, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 274486, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2873658, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 179603.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6848647957, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2383.2508798889776, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30306, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1894.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 229879320, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7585.274203128093, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 111, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 899833, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28587, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 222484305, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 288, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2082949, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1320, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4412233, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10860, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 678.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 115862893, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10668.77467771639, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15382, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 961.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 62810962, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4083.406709140554, "stage_move_gen_ns": 698028371, "stage_ordering_ns": 328131, "stage_eval_ns": 7591463316, "stage_threat_ns": 4986730335, "stage_proof_ns": 754345351, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 603232, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3514102774, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 272847, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 908137406, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2831, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 182924368, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 301608, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 425293639, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10088, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 64400040, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 603216, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74796476, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 827, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7756, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6106.9375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6606.9375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1750, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 5509, "avg_search_time_ms": 367.26666666666665, "search_nodes": 53369, "safety_nodes": 1750, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 55119, "avg_nodes": 3674.6, "eval_calls": 38187, "avg_eval_calls": 2545.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38187, "pattern_eval_ns": 831591, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.77680886165449, "pattern_frame_queries": 38187, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 831591, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.77680886165449, "pattern_frame_updates": 106598, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1063273077, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9974.606249648212, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14506, "avg_candidate_generations": 967.0666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1110333, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.54301668275197, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1186, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 14491, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1109147, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 534941, "avg_legality_checks": 35662.73333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 57, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 534941, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 57, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1484313, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 98954.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3374629798, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2273.5297730330462, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4761, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 317.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16989100, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3568.3889939088426, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 691990, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1292, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10579068, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3397, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5718042, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45688, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3045.866666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 459966995, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10067.56686657328, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63821, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4254.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 210811201, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3303.163551182213, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1377646986, "stage_ordering_ns": 497994162, "stage_eval_ns": 1064104668, "stage_threat_ns": 2531929897, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 192804, "root_tactical_annotations": 646, "search_tactical_annotations": 192158, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 106613, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 668907532, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 186130, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1764657029, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29082, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1135971167, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 53299, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80848978, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 106598, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13873028, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 45950, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 211428618, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 111087, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 416896821, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 35767, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3643330, "child_limit_applications": 14491, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14491, "child_cap_hits": 14491, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14491, "child_moves_before_total": 1109090, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1109090, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 232799, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 232799, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.53647091298048, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.06507487405976, "tt_hits": 4842, "tt_cutoffs": 621, "beta_cutoffs": 12002, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5907.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6440.733333333334, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1855, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1225, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12699, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 97, 127, 126, 143, 159, 158, 113, 95, 79, 173, 188, 129, 98, 140, 101, 157, 115, 125, 70, 84, 100, 99, 85, 130, 55 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 5660, "avg_search_time_ms": 435.38461538461536, "search_nodes": 87592, "safety_nodes": 1113, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 88705, "avg_nodes": 6823.461538461538, "eval_calls": 62975, "avg_eval_calls": 4844.2307692307695, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62975, "pattern_eval_ns": 1180985, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.753235410877334, "pattern_frame_queries": 62975, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1180985, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.753235410877334, "pattern_frame_updates": 175070, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1397493023, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7982.481424573028, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22991, "avg_candidate_generations": 1768.5384615384614, "candidate_moves_total": 1774298, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.17358966552129, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 916, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 22978, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1773382, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 750844, "avg_legality_checks": 57757.230769230766, "illegal_moves_skipped": 205, "root_legality_checks": 916, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 749928, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 205, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2284354, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 175719.53846153847, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3396332845, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1486.7804398967935, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8886, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 683.5384615384615, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19330314, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2175.367319378798, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 249, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1186424, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3499, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13343915, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5135, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4796565, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3410, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53301, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4100.076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 332234632, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6233.178214292415, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74001, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5692.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 138495455, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1871.5349116903826, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1252690376, "stage_ordering_ns": 485859135, "stage_eval_ns": 1398674008, "stage_threat_ns": 2481266161, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 282101, "root_tactical_annotations": 1369, "search_tactical_annotations": 280732, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 175083, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 708825244, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 275267, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1659567009, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46038, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1165640153, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 87535, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92311679, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 175070, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15750507, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56485, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 42759276, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 172734, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 450879919, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 52882, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4811722, "child_limit_applications": 22978, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22978, "child_cap_hits": 22978, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22978, "child_moves_before_total": 1773177, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1773177, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 367659, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 367659, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.16846548872834, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00047871877448, "tt_hits": 7768, "tt_cutoffs": 1583, "beta_cutoffs": 18862, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5491.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6106.538461538462, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7027, "avg_search_time_ms": 585.5833333333334, "search_nodes": 271125, "safety_nodes": 517, "corridor_nodes": 1266, "corridor_branch_probes": 1410, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 16, "corridor_depth_exits": 401, "corridor_neutral_exits": 36, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1243, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1243, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 90, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 52, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 401, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 90, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 89, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 699, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 241760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 272908, "avg_nodes": 22742.333333333332, "eval_calls": 265131, "avg_eval_calls": 22094.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 265131, "pattern_eval_ns": 5022215, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.94239074268946, "pattern_frame_queries": 265131, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5022215, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.94239074268946, "pattern_frame_updates": 542180, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4168541776, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7688.483116308237, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5971, "avg_candidate_generations": 497.5833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 489193, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.9281527382348, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 865, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 5959, "search_candidate_moves_total": 488328, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 10942, "avg_legality_checks": 911.8333333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10942, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1545304, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 128775.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2647059991, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1712.9703870565274, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6921, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 576.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 54739533, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7909.194191590811, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6901, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 54603603, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 135930, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20197704, "stage_ordering_ns": 175930, "stage_eval_ns": 4173563991, "stage_threat_ns": 2701619344, "stage_proof_ns": 93432636, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 544858, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2299817546, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 86163, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 55726475, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1088, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 23004953, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 272423, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 285669199, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2666, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8768598, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 544846, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51637526, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 435, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5260, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5931.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6597.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1226, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 35628, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 83, 95, 98, 139, 153, 140, 110, 94, 53, 93, 96, 92, 91, 68, 158, 174, 84, 70, 157, 172, 82, 81, 66, 114, 156, 155, 50, 34, 52, 170, 185, 171, 173, 123, 187, 107 ], "move_count": 44, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 29163, "avg_search_time_ms": 1458.15, "search_nodes": 624068, "safety_nodes": 799, "corridor_nodes": 10367, "corridor_branch_probes": 11289, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4771, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 10322, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 10322, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 18, "corridor_proof_completed": 18, "corridor_proof_checks": 192, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 147, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4771, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 192, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 192, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1539, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 263200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 635234, "avg_nodes": 31761.7, "eval_calls": 609781, "avg_eval_calls": 30489.05, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 609781, "pattern_eval_ns": 13137529, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.54466767577212, "pattern_frame_queries": 609781, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 13137529, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.54466767577212, "pattern_frame_updates": 1248018, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 15964750470, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12792.083503603313, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14248, "avg_candidate_generations": 712.4, "candidate_moves_total": 1344905, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.39254632229085, "candidate_moves_max": 140, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1709, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 14228, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1343196, "search_candidate_moves_max": 140, "legality_checks": 587489, "avg_legality_checks": 29374.45, "illegal_moves_skipped": 273, "root_legality_checks": 1709, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 585780, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6023661, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 301183.05, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14151884641, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2349.3826496876236, "renju_forbidden_checks": 63649, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3182.45, "renju_forbidden_ns": 541450815, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8506.823595028987, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 399, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3115674, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 59989, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 527602738, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 864, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3657822, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2397, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7074581, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21892, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1094.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 222369509, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10157.569386077106, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 30591, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1529.55, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 120516971, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3939.621816874244, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1454102376, "stage_ordering_ns": 548993, "stage_eval_ns": 15977887999, "stage_threat_ns": 10326580983, "stage_proof_ns": 1329975628, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1269066, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 7359535700, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 542776, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1762309215, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 5709, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 345646708, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 634523, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 900189211, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 21028, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 148696785, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1269046, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 155850072, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 953, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 12730, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.45, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4642.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5042.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 446, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 6442, "avg_search_time_ms": 322.1, "search_nodes": 64727, "safety_nodes": 2744, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67471, "avg_nodes": 3373.55, "eval_calls": 46533, "avg_eval_calls": 2326.65, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46533, "pattern_eval_ns": 1026912, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.068467539165752, "pattern_frame_queries": 46533, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1026912, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.068467539165752, "pattern_frame_updates": 129270, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1245958618, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9638.420499729249, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17361, "avg_candidate_generations": 868.05, "candidate_moves_total": 1393880, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.2880018432118, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1742, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 17341, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1392138, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 629235, "avg_legality_checks": 31461.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 629235, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1738758, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 86937.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3881638768, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2232.4203644210406, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8590, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 429.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 22733394, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2646.495227008149, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 406, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1490668, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2185, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11460327, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5963, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9613619, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 36, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 168780, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53161, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2658.05, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 514171677, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9671.971501664755, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72951, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3647.55, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 230971209, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3166.1143644364024, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1586907538, "stage_ordering_ns": 590990798, "stage_eval_ns": 1246985530, "stage_threat_ns": 2967271138, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 273204, "root_tactical_annotations": 715, "search_tactical_annotations": 272489, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 129290, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 804667600, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 263936, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2043493117, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34813, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1303476450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64635, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 97596439, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 129270, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16631043, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 75487, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 245973445, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 153621, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 493533551, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 44096, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4882939, "child_limit_applications": 17341, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17341, "child_cap_hits": 17341, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17341, "child_moves_before_total": 1392102, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1392102, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 285558, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 285558, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.27806931549507, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.46721642350499, "tt_hits": 5647, "tt_cutoffs": 761, "beta_cutoffs": 14395, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6385.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6785.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1619, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1227, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10549, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 129, 98, 96, 128, 143, 124, 127, 95, 157, 171, 141, 172, 109, 108, 125, 173, 93 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8254, "avg_search_time_ms": 825.4, "search_nodes": 102432, "safety_nodes": 167, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 102599, "avg_nodes": 10259.9, "eval_calls": 77473, "avg_eval_calls": 7747.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77473, "pattern_eval_ns": 1584683, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.45464871632698, "pattern_frame_queries": 77473, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1584683, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.45464871632698, "pattern_frame_updates": 204780, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2127333163, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10388.38345053228, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23914, "avg_candidate_generations": 2391.4, "candidate_moves_total": 1731892, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.42167767834741, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 576, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 23904, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1731316, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 638994, "avg_legality_checks": 63899.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 114, "root_legality_checks": 576, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 638418, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 114, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2192471, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 219247.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4775589088, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2178.176627193701, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11854, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1185.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 40435793, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3411.151763117935, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 182, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1122864, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4757, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28362775, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6915, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10950154, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58796, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5879.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 490493865, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8342.299901353834, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 75224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7522.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 198303388, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2636.171806870148, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1560358903, "stage_ordering_ns": 725680449, "stage_eval_ns": 2128917846, "stage_threat_ns": 3803825023, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 294311, "root_tactical_annotations": 2017, "search_tactical_annotations": 292294, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 204790, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1174845551, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 276998, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2452628249, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47869, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1753690858, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 145314531, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 204780, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24960954, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 84645, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 117652922, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 144475, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 581183268, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 65191, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6075738, "child_limit_applications": 23904, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23904, "child_cap_hits": 23904, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23904, "child_moves_before_total": 1731202, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1731202, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 382492, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 382492, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.42310910307899, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001171352074966, "tt_hits": 9671, "tt_cutoffs": 1013, "beta_cutoffs": 18850, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4002.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4802.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1076, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2285, "avg_search_time_ms": 253.88888888888889, "search_nodes": 68066, "safety_nodes": 449, "corridor_nodes": 28, "corridor_branch_probes": 22, "corridor_max_depth": 3, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 20, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 15, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 75, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 75, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 74, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 568, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 192560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68543, "avg_nodes": 7615.888888888889, "eval_calls": 64381, "avg_eval_calls": 7153.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64381, "pattern_eval_ns": 1308645, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.32657150401516, "pattern_frame_queries": 64381, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1308645, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.32657150401516, "pattern_frame_updates": 136080, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1239060092, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9105.37986478542, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3668, "avg_candidate_generations": 407.55555555555554, "candidate_moves_total": 255356, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.61723009814612, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 516, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 3659, "search_candidate_moves_total": 254840, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 7053, "avg_legality_checks": 783.6666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7053, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 383292, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 42588.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 860697136, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2245.539004205671, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1034, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 114.88888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6787022, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6563.851063829788, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1030, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6783472, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3550, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 187811, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6955.962962962963, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.4444444444444446, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 63011, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2032.6129032258063, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19035110, "stage_ordering_ns": 114280, "stage_eval_ns": 1240368737, "stage_threat_ns": 880705038, "stage_proof_ns": 130171537, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136279, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 764652864, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3410, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8943086, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 328, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6682017, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68135, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 89785182, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 190, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 932173, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136270, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16391733, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 231, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3226, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5494.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6383.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1228, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14010, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 80, 129, 81, 145, 161, 128, 125, 95, 79, 130, 127, 131, 132, 78, 96, 83, 64, 48, 109, 108, 94, 49, 124 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 6721, "avg_search_time_ms": 517.0, "search_nodes": 173233, "safety_nodes": 1083, "corridor_nodes": 920, "corridor_branch_probes": 1079, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 371, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 906, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 906, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 79, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 65, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 371, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 79, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 76, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 575, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 178080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 175236, "avg_nodes": 13479.692307692309, "eval_calls": 167538, "avg_eval_calls": 12887.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 167538, "pattern_eval_ns": 3338054, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.924160488963697, "pattern_frame_queries": 167538, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3338054, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.924160488963697, "pattern_frame_updates": 346392, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3918035329, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11310.986769324927, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5671, "avg_candidate_generations": 436.2307692307692, "candidate_moves_total": 458083, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.77640627755245, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 938, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 5658, "search_candidate_moves_total": 457145, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 163034, "avg_legality_checks": 12541.076923076924, "illegal_moves_skipped": 179, "root_legality_checks": 938, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 162096, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 179, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1543056, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 118696.61538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3202452861, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2075.396395853423, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17350, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1334.6153846153845, "renju_forbidden_ns": 107608332, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6202.209337175793, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 181, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1558615, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16964, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 104373762, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 54, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 624141, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 151, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1051814, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2068, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 159.07692307692307, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 19256034, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9311.428433268858, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2762, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 212.46153846153845, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 9991033, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3617.3182476466327, "stage_move_gen_ns": 358047449, "stage_ordering_ns": 173881, "stage_eval_ns": 3921373383, "stage_threat_ns": 2187124180, "stage_proof_ns": 222596506, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 348375, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1753797301, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 56469, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 169675793, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 698, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 37814310, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 174181, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 215028039, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1970, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10781571, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 348362, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37841476, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 273, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5091, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5969.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6584.538461538462, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1767, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7276, "avg_search_time_ms": 606.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 56416, "safety_nodes": 934, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 57350, "avg_nodes": 4779.166666666667, "eval_calls": 37278, "avg_eval_calls": 3106.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37278, "pattern_eval_ns": 772653, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.726782552712056, "pattern_frame_queries": 37278, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 772653, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.726782552712056, "pattern_frame_updates": 112722, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1268951638, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11257.355600503895, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17862, "avg_candidate_generations": 1488.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1474252, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.53566229985444, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 868, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 17850, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1473384, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1051524, "avg_legality_checks": 87627.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1906, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1051524, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1906, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2455704, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 204642.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4854013944, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1976.6282679019946, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17607, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1467.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 81951577, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4654.488385301301, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1942, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19973589, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4625, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43609900, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11040, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18368088, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99654, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8304.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 869677006, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8726.965360146105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 133251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11104.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 394784943, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2962.716549969606, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2366909976, "stage_ordering_ns": 548983588, "stage_eval_ns": 1269724291, "stage_threat_ns": 3043560746, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 350160, "root_tactical_annotations": 1391, "search_tactical_annotations": 348769, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 112734, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 639585312, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 308557, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2301876215, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35779, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1194497673, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56361, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 79224125, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 112722, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13347490, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 103533, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 392356922, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 169236, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 714817649, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 77391, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9527604, "child_limit_applications": 17850, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17850, "child_cap_hits": 17850, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17850, "child_moves_before_total": 1471478, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1471478, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 288264, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 288264, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.43574229691876, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.14924369747899, "tt_hits": 7489, "tt_cutoffs": 1233, "beta_cutoffs": 15452, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5186.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5853.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1887, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1229, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29852, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 84, 141, 83, 81, 126, 98, 85, 86, 97, 127, 155, 143, 111, 128, 158, 125, 142, 110, 69, 55, 53, 101, 54, 99, 67, 52, 66, 100, 102, 114, 72, 68, 87, 117, 116, 157, 39, 24, 25, 11, 57, 42, 37, 21, 130, 144, 74, 88, 174, 190, 173, 129, 115, 159 ], "move_count": 58, "black_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 25177, "avg_search_time_ms": 932.4814814814815, "search_nodes": 303251, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 305142, "avg_nodes": 11301.555555555555, "eval_calls": 239126, "avg_eval_calls": 8856.518518518518, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 239126, "pattern_eval_ns": 5234730, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.891095071217684, "pattern_frame_queries": 239126, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5234730, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.891095071217684, "pattern_frame_updates": 606242, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7994310088, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13186.664876402492, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 60888, "avg_candidate_generations": 2255.1111111111113, "candidate_moves_total": 5074459, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.34087176455131, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2108, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 60861, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5072351, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1848563, "avg_legality_checks": 68465.29629629629, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1187, "root_legality_checks": 2108, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1846455, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1187, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6755688, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 250210.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14559238509, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2155.1081857243853, "renju_forbidden_checks": 86566, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3206.1481481481483, "renju_forbidden_ns": 338117121, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3905.8882355659266, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2882, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15195400, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 46578, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 246300436, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37086, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 76586335, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 34950, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 210835, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7808.7037037037035, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1711042801, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8115.55387388242, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 259497, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9611.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 676317013, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2606.261394158699, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4474376532, "stage_ordering_ns": 2010105078, "stage_eval_ns": 7999544818, "stage_threat_ns": 10585139190, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1336348, "root_tactical_annotations": 5265, "search_tactical_annotations": 1331083, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 606269, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3491418230, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1160342, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6525462839, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 121906, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3966829380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 303121, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 455984222, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 606242, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 76419468, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 476115, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 523500453, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 562298, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2034167860, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 297935, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 35854431, "child_limit_applications": 60861, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 60861, "child_cap_hits": 60861, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 60861, "child_moves_before_total": 5071164, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5071164, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 982472, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 982472, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.323704835609, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.14288296281691, "tt_hits": 26070, "tt_cutoffs": 3134, "beta_cutoffs": 45458, "depth_sum": 130, "avg_depth": 4.814814814814815, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 130, "avg_effective_depth": 4.814814814814815, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 25 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18518518518518517, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5943.814814814815, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6240.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 345, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 4651, "avg_search_time_ms": 172.25925925925927, "search_nodes": 143167, "safety_nodes": 2697, "corridor_nodes": 3724, "corridor_branch_probes": 3975, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2165, "corridor_neutral_exits": 22, "corridor_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_plies_followed": 3702, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3702, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 26, "corridor_proof_completed": 26, "corridor_proof_checks": 91, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2165, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 91, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 483, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 181520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 149588, "avg_nodes": 5540.2962962962965, "eval_calls": 138286, "avg_eval_calls": 5121.7037037037035, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 138286, "pattern_eval_ns": 2992068, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.636810667746555, "pattern_frame_queries": 138286, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2992068, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.636810667746555, "pattern_frame_updates": 286176, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2399711330, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8385.43878592195, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4829, "avg_candidate_generations": 178.85185185185185, "candidate_moves_total": 408195, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.52992337958169, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2141, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 4802, "search_candidate_moves_total": 406054, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 9230, "avg_legality_checks": 341.85185185185185, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9230, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 870407, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32237.296296296296, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1784205629, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2049.8521140110315, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2957, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 109.51851851851852, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15440261, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5221.596550557998, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2909, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15272911, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 140770, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 26580, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 24911732, "stage_ordering_ns": 161381, "stage_eval_ns": 2402703398, "stage_threat_ns": 2066317834, "stage_proof_ns": 126459069, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 293789, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1596105828, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 139243, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 174477390, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1784, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 74541971, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 146881, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 201042118, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7586, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 60168463, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 293762, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34524035, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 348, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4273, "depth_sum": 79, "avg_depth": 2.925925925925926, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 79, "avg_effective_depth": 2.925925925925926, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 26 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7174.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7470.962962962963, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1500, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1230, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6059, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 84, 85, 99, 126, 69, 114, 83, 111, 67, 52, 51, 35, 115 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1798, "avg_search_time_ms": 224.75, "search_nodes": 37214, "safety_nodes": 411, "corridor_nodes": 510, "corridor_branch_probes": 582, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 215, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 500, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 500, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 215, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 426, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 181440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 38135, "avg_nodes": 4766.875, "eval_calls": 35213, "avg_eval_calls": 4401.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35213, "pattern_eval_ns": 761772, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.633260443586174, "pattern_frame_queries": 35213, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 761772, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.633260443586174, "pattern_frame_updates": 74384, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 922685419, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12404.353342116585, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1987, "avg_candidate_generations": 248.375, "candidate_moves_total": 125917, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.3704076497232, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 444, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 1979, "search_candidate_moves_total": 125473, "search_candidate_moves_max": 85, "legality_checks": 32316, "avg_legality_checks": 4039.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 444, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 31872, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 379927, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 47490.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 881853685, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2321.113490223122, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5649, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 706.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33993789, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6017.664896441848, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 117522, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5553, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33426987, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 217150, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 232130, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1033, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 129.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 9255595, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8959.917715392063, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1305, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 163.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4260626, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3264.847509578544, "stage_move_gen_ns": 80563458, "stage_ordering_ns": 73900, "stage_eval_ns": 923447191, "stage_threat_ns": 616268427, "stage_proof_ns": 161891035, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 75504, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 452673857, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31021, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 95152930, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 449, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 22500881, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37748, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 52717324, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1112, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6431100, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 75496, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9293216, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 224, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1677, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5212.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6212.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1822, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 4254, "avg_search_time_ms": 607.7142857142857, "search_nodes": 34352, "safety_nodes": 430, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34782, "avg_nodes": 4968.857142857143, "eval_calls": 23139, "avg_eval_calls": 3305.5714285714284, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23139, "pattern_eval_ns": 521283, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.52832879554, "pattern_frame_queries": 23139, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 521283, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.52832879554, "pattern_frame_updates": 68644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 823371010, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11994.799399801876, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10574, "avg_candidate_generations": 1510.5714285714287, "candidate_moves_total": 729093, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.9514847739739, "candidate_moves_max": 92, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 383, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 10567, "search_candidate_moves_total": 728710, "search_candidate_moves_max": 92, "legality_checks": 467793, "avg_legality_checks": 66827.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 758, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 467793, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 758, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1253924, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 179132.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2766144460, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2205.990522551606, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7141, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1020.1428571428571, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44419131, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6220.295616860384, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 768, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8465818, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2836, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27357988, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3537, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8595325, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48681, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6954.428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 480758841, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9875.697726012202, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65044, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9292.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 220736146, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3393.6434721111864, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1197607915, "stage_ordering_ns": 321397497, "stage_eval_ns": 823892293, "stage_threat_ns": 1884355112, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 162312, "root_tactical_annotations": 556, "search_tactical_annotations": 161756, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 68651, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 420931996, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 148496, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1397973175, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21178, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 774991908, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34322, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 51805251, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 68644, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8779966, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 35218, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 172366482, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 92095, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 450472004, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 34999, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4864724, "child_limit_applications": 10567, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10567, "child_cap_hits": 10567, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10567, "child_moves_before_total": 727952, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 727952, "child_moves_before_max": 92, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 92, "child_moves_after_total": 169073, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 169073, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.8891833065203, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000094634238668, "tt_hits": 3534, "tt_cutoffs": 616, "beta_cutoffs": 9070, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 4.285714285714286, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 4.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3469.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4612.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1866, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1231, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4347, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 141, 99, 125, 97, 109, 108, 93, 157, 77 ], "move_count": 15, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 3301, "avg_search_time_ms": 550.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 43786, "safety_nodes": 295, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 44081, "avg_nodes": 7346.833333333333, "eval_calls": 33906, "avg_eval_calls": 5651.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33906, "pattern_eval_ns": 735230, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.684362649678523, "pattern_frame_queries": 33906, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 735230, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.684362649678523, "pattern_frame_updates": 87528, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 819102064, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9358.171830728452, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9436, "avg_candidate_generations": 1572.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 651064, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.99788045782111, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 325, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 9430, "search_candidate_moves_total": 650739, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 240577, "avg_legality_checks": 40096.166666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 325, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 240252, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 795911, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 132651.83333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1862913096, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2340.6047862135338, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3371, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 561.8333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10973540, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3255.277365766835, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 137781, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1246, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8136847, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2101, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2696012, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2900, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15956, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2659.3333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 151966992, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9524.128352970669, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20996, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3499.3333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 66513649, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3167.9200323871214, "stage_move_gen_ns": 624617681, "stage_ordering_ns": 299018519, "stage_eval_ns": 819837294, "stage_threat_ns": 1537429677, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 67199, "root_tactical_annotations": 733, "search_tactical_annotations": 66466, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 87534, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 514720137, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 72322, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 947286541, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18893, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 732170956, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43764, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 63278734, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 87528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10898170, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 11057, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 18830388, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 42367, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 196094625, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 13775, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1246095, "child_limit_applications": 9430, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9430, "child_cap_hits": 9430, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9430, "child_moves_before_total": 650729, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 650729, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 150880, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 150880, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.00625662778367, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 3621, "tt_cutoffs": 428, "beta_cutoffs": 7204, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2834.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4167.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1045, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 7, "search_move_count": 5, "total_time_ms": 1042, "avg_search_time_ms": 208.4, "search_nodes": 31696, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 130, "corridor_branch_probes": 153, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 40, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 127, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 127, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 35, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 40, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 35, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 35, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 276, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 55600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 3680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 32026, "avg_nodes": 6405.2, "eval_calls": 30280, "avg_eval_calls": 6056.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 30280, "pattern_eval_ns": 651275, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.5084214002642, "pattern_frame_queries": 30280, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 651275, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.5084214002642, "pattern_frame_updates": 63364, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 496690163, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7838.680686194053, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1407, "avg_candidate_generations": 281.4, "candidate_moves_total": 88619, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.98436389481166, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 5, "root_candidate_moves_total": 266, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 1402, "search_candidate_moves_total": 88353, "search_candidate_moves_max": 83, "legality_checks": 4089, "avg_legality_checks": 817.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4089, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 130991, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26198.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 313964634, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2396.841263903627, "renju_forbidden_checks": 452, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 90.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2782999, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6157.077433628318, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 432, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 2540019, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 242980, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11680710, "stage_ordering_ns": 52480, "stage_eval_ns": 497341438, "stage_threat_ns": 460567669, "stage_proof_ns": 63553034, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 63693, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 389408722, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 9703, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 17365134, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9602387, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 31844, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 44006140, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 324, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1595808, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 63688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8191865, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 107, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1221, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3475.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5075.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1967, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1232, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10113, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 126, 141, 99, 143, 98, 155, 169, 140, 142, 158, 100, 173, 128, 188, 203, 156, 101, 97, 102 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5142, "avg_search_time_ms": 467.45454545454544, "search_nodes": 101499, "safety_nodes": 671, "corridor_nodes": 3015, "corridor_branch_probes": 3297, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 1296, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 2995, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2995, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 79, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 59, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1296, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 79, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 78, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 586, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 170720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 105185, "avg_nodes": 9562.272727272728, "eval_calls": 97804, "avg_eval_calls": 8891.272727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 97804, "pattern_eval_ns": 1993659, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.384227638951373, "pattern_frame_queries": 97804, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1993659, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.384227638951373, "pattern_frame_updates": 202936, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2428133072, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11965.018882800488, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3675, "avg_candidate_generations": 334.09090909090907, "candidate_moves_total": 247290, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.28979591836735, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 699, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 3664, "search_candidate_moves_total": 246591, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 92992, "avg_legality_checks": 8453.818181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 699, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 92293, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1128161, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 102560.09090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2534077348, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2246.2018701231473, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8125, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 738.6363636363636, "renju_forbidden_ns": 69249387, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8523.001476923077, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 408870, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7600, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 66332816, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 88, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 851624, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 395, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1656077, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 6658, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 605.2727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 65474147, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9833.906127966357, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9114, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 828.5454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 34400100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3774.4239631336404, "stage_move_gen_ns": 236106466, "stage_ordering_ns": 124141, "stage_eval_ns": 2430126731, "stage_threat_ns": 2006096808, "stage_proof_ns": 460748615, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 209095, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1239675309, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 177490, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 556879169, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1758, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 112791360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 104542, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 149766738, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6148, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 33897934, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 209084, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25877658, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 241, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3260, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5413.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6141.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1765, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 4960, "avg_search_time_ms": 496.0, "search_nodes": 50510, "safety_nodes": 972, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 51482, "avg_nodes": 5148.2, "eval_calls": 36400, "avg_eval_calls": 3640.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36400, "pattern_eval_ns": 765802, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.038516483516485, "pattern_frame_queries": 36400, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 765802, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.038516483516485, "pattern_frame_updates": 100930, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 864860609, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8568.915178836818, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13513, "avg_candidate_generations": 1351.3, "candidate_moves_total": 988525, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.15362983793383, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 636, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 13503, "search_candidate_moves_total": 987889, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 571087, "avg_legality_checks": 57108.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 62, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 571087, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 62, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1453562, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 145356.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3084653265, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2122.1339475027553, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4383, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 438.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14853934, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3388.98790782569, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 62, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 650012, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 909, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9914116, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3412, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4289806, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4715.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 451139488, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9568.17577942736, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65665, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6566.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 210561493, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3206.601583796543, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1383294671, "stage_ordering_ns": 424710695, "stage_eval_ns": 865626411, "stage_threat_ns": 2256732364, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 157790, "root_tactical_annotations": 631, "search_tactical_annotations": 157159, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 100940, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 590835294, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 147732, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1575644457, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27071, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 999223505, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50465, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73002573, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 100930, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12481844, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 33635, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 204133304, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 87017, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 371870565, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 37138, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4768196, "child_limit_applications": 13503, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13503, "child_cap_hits": 13503, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13503, "child_moves_before_total": 987827, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 987827, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 216061, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 216061, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.15611345626898, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000962749018736, "tt_hits": 4903, "tt_cutoffs": 562, "beta_cutoffs": 11123, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4799.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5599.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1870, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1233, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11104, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 125, 96, 98, 126, 141, 130, 127, 99, 157, 173, 143, 172, 115, 116, 129, 171, 101 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8844, "avg_search_time_ms": 884.4, "search_nodes": 103055, "safety_nodes": 167, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 103222, "avg_nodes": 10322.2, "eval_calls": 77739, "avg_eval_calls": 7773.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77739, "pattern_eval_ns": 1721736, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.147647898738086, "pattern_frame_queries": 77739, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1721736, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.147647898738086, "pattern_frame_updates": 206026, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2255780494, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10949.008833836506, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24222, "avg_candidate_generations": 2422.2, "candidate_moves_total": 1756349, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.51048633473701, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 576, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 24212, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1755773, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 654816, "avg_legality_checks": 65481.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "root_legality_checks": 576, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 654240, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2203563, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 220356.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5115132559, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2321.300801928513, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11598, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1159.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 41848007, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3608.2089153302295, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 168, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1048882, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4428, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29117196, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7002, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11681929, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58433, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5843.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 512242433, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8766.32096589256, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 73926, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7392.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 203193145, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2748.6019127235345, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1698800635, "stage_ordering_ns": 782797224, "stage_eval_ns": 2257502230, "stage_threat_ns": 4069465688, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 295891, "root_tactical_annotations": 2017, "search_tactical_annotations": 293874, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 206036, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1252388418, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 279024, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2626903993, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48485, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1890799904, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 103013, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 155866229, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 206026, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26575409, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 85113, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 126488545, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 145417, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 609510204, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 65361, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7731639, "child_limit_applications": 24212, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24212, "child_cap_hits": 24212, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24212, "child_moves_before_total": 1755677, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1755677, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 387406, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 387406, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.51267966297704, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00057822567322, "tt_hits": 9711, "tt_cutoffs": 1062, "beta_cutoffs": 19141, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3688.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4488.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1016, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2252, "avg_search_time_ms": 250.22222222222223, "search_nodes": 64160, "safety_nodes": 449, "corridor_nodes": 30, "corridor_branch_probes": 23, "corridor_max_depth": 3, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 21, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 16, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 75, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 66, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 75, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 74, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 568, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 198880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 64639, "avg_nodes": 7182.111111111111, "eval_calls": 60441, "avg_eval_calls": 6715.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60441, "pattern_eval_ns": 1312165, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.7098492744991, "pattern_frame_queries": 60441, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1312165, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.7098492744991, "pattern_frame_updates": 128268, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1199467402, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9351.259877755949, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3702, "avg_candidate_generations": 411.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 255465, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.00729335494327, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 516, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 3693, "search_candidate_moves_total": 254949, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 6891, "avg_legality_checks": 765.6666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6891, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 342471, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 38052.333333333336, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 824442777, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2407.336028452044, "renju_forbidden_checks": 593, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 65.88888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5467064, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9219.33220910624, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 589, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 5463274, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3790, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 203541, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7538.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.4444444444444446, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 66630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2149.3548387096776, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19874849, "stage_ordering_ns": 128980, "stage_eval_ns": 1200779567, "stage_threat_ns": 877059211, "stage_proof_ns": 137309465, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 128469, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 760447441, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3614, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9465456, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 328, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6989406, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 89938256, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 192, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 995666, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16212392, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 231, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3276, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5481.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6370.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1969, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1234, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17396, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 84, 125, 83, 139, 153, 126, 129, 99, 85, 124, 127, 123, 122, 86, 98, 81, 70, 56, 115, 116, 100, 55, 130 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8589, "avg_search_time_ms": 660.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 191808, "safety_nodes": 1083, "corridor_nodes": 1168, "corridor_branch_probes": 1369, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 481, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 1153, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1153, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 79, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 481, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 79, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 76, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 575, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 176320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 194059, "avg_nodes": 14927.615384615385, "eval_calls": 185846, "avg_eval_calls": 14295.846153846154, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 185846, "pattern_eval_ns": 3988629, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.462011557956586, "pattern_frame_queries": 185846, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3988629, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.462011557956586, "pattern_frame_updates": 383542, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5006390067, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13053.042605503439, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5938, "avg_candidate_generations": 456.7692307692308, "candidate_moves_total": 478279, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.5454698551701, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 938, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 5925, "search_candidate_moves_total": 477341, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 181552, "avg_legality_checks": 13965.538461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 162, "root_legality_checks": 938, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 180614, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 162, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1700033, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 130771.76923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4100587787, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2412.0636405293308, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18697, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1438.2307692307693, "renju_forbidden_ns": 136538385, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7302.689468898754, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 164, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1655719, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18243, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 132287049, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 66, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 857756, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 224, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1737861, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2563, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 197.15384615384616, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 25823171, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10075.369098712446, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3409, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 262.2307692307692, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 13279945, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3895.5544147843943, "stage_move_gen_ns": 462687149, "stage_ordering_ns": 210780, "stage_eval_ns": 5010378696, "stage_threat_ns": 2800068970, "stage_proof_ns": 279391070, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 386019, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2241356274, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 70654, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 224764701, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 789, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 48145928, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 193003, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 271249343, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2464, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14523372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 386006, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48175280, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 273, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5346, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8461538461538463, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5776.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6392.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1749, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8796, "avg_search_time_ms": 733.0, "search_nodes": 58984, "safety_nodes": 934, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59918, "avg_nodes": 4993.166666666667, "eval_calls": 38526, "avg_eval_calls": 3210.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38526, "pattern_eval_ns": 867814, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.525411410476043, "pattern_frame_queries": 38526, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 867814, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.525411410476043, "pattern_frame_updates": 117858, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1471393038, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12484.45619304587, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19143, "avg_candidate_generations": 1595.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1559115, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.4456981664316, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 868, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 19131, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1558247, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1146489, "avg_legality_checks": 95540.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4774, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1146489, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4774, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2682144, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 223512.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5854053560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2182.6022614744024, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25309, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2109.0833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 160708722, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6349.8645541111855, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4810, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52786936, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7162, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 75243341, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13337, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32678445, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 114781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9565.083333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1113567783, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9701.673473832778, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 150888, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12574.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 501704759, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3325.014308626266, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2893650723, "stage_ordering_ns": 652929909, "stage_eval_ns": 1472260852, "stage_threat_ns": 3719437419, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 374416, "root_tactical_annotations": 1391, "search_tactical_annotations": 373025, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 117870, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 742047539, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 337717, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2860062400, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38341, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1447237752, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58929, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90277641, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 117858, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15614016, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 110577, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 467777365, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 188790, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 944829763, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 75049, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11435823, "child_limit_applications": 19131, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19131, "child_cap_hits": 19131, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19131, "child_moves_before_total": 1553473, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1553473, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 308804, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 308804, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.2018713083477, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.141550363284722, "tt_hits": 7476, "tt_cutoffs": 1272, "beta_cutoffs": 16639, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4853.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5520.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1872, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1235, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17078, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 97, 127, 128, 141, 155, 156, 111, 99, 85, 171, 186, 125, 96, 144, 95, 93, 109, 114, 64, 80, 94, 98, 79, 124, 49 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 9160, "avg_search_time_ms": 704.6153846153846, "search_nodes": 90903, "safety_nodes": 1116, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92019, "avg_nodes": 7078.384615384615, "eval_calls": 64879, "avg_eval_calls": 4990.692307692308, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64879, "pattern_eval_ns": 1408309, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.706700164922395, "pattern_frame_queries": 64879, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1408309, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.706700164922395, "pattern_frame_updates": 181692, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2280008274, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12548.754342513705, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24359, "avg_candidate_generations": 1873.7692307692307, "candidate_moves_total": 1929081, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.19376821708609, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 911, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 24346, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1928170, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 794728, "avg_legality_checks": 61132.92307692308, "illegal_moves_skipped": 285, "root_legality_checks": 911, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 793817, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 285, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2439451, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 187650.07692307694, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5603642330, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2297.091571013314, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9260, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 712.3076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 38293231, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4135.338120950324, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 308, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3099149, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26503322, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5328, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8685620, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5140, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58574, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4505.692307692308, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 538690181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9196.745672141224, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81900, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6300.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 226813742, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2769.398559218559, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2003084470, "stage_ordering_ns": 841558379, "stage_eval_ns": 2281416583, "stage_threat_ns": 3985078305, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 282037, "root_tactical_annotations": 1334, "search_tactical_annotations": 280703, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 181705, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1113718165, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 283075, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2706960531, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48774, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1902379673, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 90846, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 134449808, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 181692, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23877379, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56321, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 67339998, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 177970, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 736645679, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 47746, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6072422, "child_limit_applications": 24346, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24346, "child_cap_hits": 24346, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24346, "child_moves_before_total": 1927885, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1927885, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 389550, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 389550, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.18693009118542, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000575043128233, "tt_hits": 8146, "tt_cutoffs": 1622, "beta_cutoffs": 20129, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5067.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5683.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7906, "avg_search_time_ms": 658.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 220532, "safety_nodes": 667, "corridor_nodes": 635, "corridor_branch_probes": 758, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 204, "corridor_neutral_exits": 22, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 618, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 618, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 79, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 62, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 204, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 79, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 78, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 578, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 184400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 221834, "avg_nodes": 18486.166666666668, "eval_calls": 215487, "avg_eval_calls": 17957.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 215487, "pattern_eval_ns": 4648047, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.569964777457574, "pattern_frame_queries": 215487, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4648047, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.569964777457574, "pattern_frame_updates": 440994, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4695811743, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10648.244064545095, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5022, "avg_candidate_generations": 418.5, "candidate_moves_total": 395149, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.68359219434488, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 851, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 5010, "search_candidate_moves_total": 394298, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 8831, "avg_legality_checks": 735.9166666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8831, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1258410, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 104867.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3075945480, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2444.3110591937443, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6307, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 525.5833333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62975596, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9985.031869351515, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6279, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62712775, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 262821, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 25447374, "stage_ordering_ns": 179402, "stage_eval_ns": 4700459790, "stage_threat_ns": 3015435106, "stage_proof_ns": 136757083, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 442400, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2586646762, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43373, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 54961723, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 640, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 22347149, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 221194, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 309588028, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1394, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8174458, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 442388, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56064135, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 350, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4445, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5736.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6402.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1957, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1236, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23945, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 81, 129, 96, 130, 131, 111, 95, 157, 172, 98, 67, 109, 65, 49, 66, 64, 93, 94, 79, 51, 68, 69, 110, 50, 82, 54, 124 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 6531, "avg_search_time_ms": 435.4, "search_nodes": 142812, "safety_nodes": 1634, "corridor_nodes": 1641, "corridor_branch_probes": 1868, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 739, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1619, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1594, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 25, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 73, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 739, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 73, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 5, "corridor_proof_unknown": 68, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 385, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 220800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 146087, "avg_nodes": 9739.133333333333, "eval_calls": 138883, "avg_eval_calls": 9258.866666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 138883, "pattern_eval_ns": 2997261, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.58119424263589, "pattern_frame_queries": 138883, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2997261, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.58119424263589, "pattern_frame_updates": 285536, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3461317374, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12122.175046228847, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3900, "avg_candidate_generations": 260.0, "candidate_moves_total": 271237, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.54794871794871, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1101, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 3885, "search_candidate_moves_total": 270136, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 137179, "avg_legality_checks": 9145.266666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "root_legality_checks": 1101, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 136078, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 43, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1143624, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 76241.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2791726058, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2441.122307681546, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14454, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 963.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 158587472, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10971.874360038744, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 615881, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13754, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 149778793, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 182, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2760685, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 446, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5432113, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4250, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 283.3333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 45819233, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10780.996, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5760, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 384.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 25092699, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4356.371354166667, "stage_move_gen_ns": 366030023, "stage_ordering_ns": 121150, "stage_eval_ns": 3464314635, "stage_threat_ns": 2372496366, "stage_proof_ns": 303934059, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 288935, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1805612216, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 91971, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 298117454, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 947, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 62231910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 144460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 209927509, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3384, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20850093, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 288920, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37989094, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 126, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3607, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5581.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6114.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 420, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 17400, "avg_search_time_ms": 1160.0, "search_nodes": 124182, "safety_nodes": 576, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 124758, "avg_nodes": 8317.2, "eval_calls": 85716, "avg_eval_calls": 5714.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 85716, "pattern_eval_ns": 1920488, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.405245228428765, "pattern_frame_queries": 85716, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1920488, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.405245228428765, "pattern_frame_updates": 248230, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2791218997, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11244.486955645974, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 36505, "avg_candidate_generations": 2433.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 3241166, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.78690590330092, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1126, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 36490, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3240040, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 2399274, "avg_legality_checks": 159951.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 19339, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2399274, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 19339, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5253588, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 350239.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11173139286, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2126.763515905701, "renju_forbidden_checks": 78513, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5234.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 608193152, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7746.400621553119, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 19461, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 215153323, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25358, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 277189930, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 33640, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 115315905, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 54, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 533994, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 219982, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14665.466666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2293431549, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10425.541857970198, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 280361, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18690.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1136442469, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4053.4969878121424, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6024065496, "stage_ordering_ns": 1318269170, "stage_eval_ns": 2793139485, "stage_threat_ns": 7162575309, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 862643, "root_tactical_annotations": 3437, "search_tactical_annotations": 859206, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 248245, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1525890722, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 738423, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5384945578, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 73076, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2577266621, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124115, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 191726969, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 248230, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32305951, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 351026, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1345479244, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 314310, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1462100142, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 197307, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 27706089, "child_limit_applications": 36490, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 36490, "child_cap_hits": 36490, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 36490, "child_moves_before_total": 3220701, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3220701, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 585236, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 585236, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.26256508632503, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.038257056727872, "tt_hits": 16832, "tt_cutoffs": 1909, "beta_cutoffs": 30990, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5932.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6466.133333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1626, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1237, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14319, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 127, 97, 96, 83, 69, 68, 113, 53, 38, 99, 128, 125, 139, 80, 131, 67, 115, 95, 160, 144, 130, 129, 145, 100, 175 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7735, "avg_search_time_ms": 595.0, "search_nodes": 83676, "safety_nodes": 1109, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 84785, "avg_nodes": 6521.923076923077, "eval_calls": 60088, "avg_eval_calls": 4622.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60088, "pattern_eval_ns": 1327075, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.08552456397284, "pattern_frame_queries": 60088, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1327075, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.08552456397284, "pattern_frame_updates": 167238, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1839271753, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10997.929615278825, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21730, "avg_candidate_generations": 1671.5384615384614, "candidate_moves_total": 1596295, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.46042337781869, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 899, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 21717, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1595396, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 689781, "avg_legality_checks": 53060.07692307692, "illegal_moves_skipped": 226, "root_legality_checks": 899, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 688882, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 226, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2029597, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 156122.84615384616, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4660430860, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2296.2346022387696, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9540, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 733.8461538461538, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32926831, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3451.4497903563943, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 290, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2581221, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3125, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22009808, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6122, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8326882, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8920, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50151, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3857.769230769231, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 452436090, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9021.47693964228, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5245.461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 180845521, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2652.0438327638544, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1747009140, "stage_ordering_ns": 670234591, "stage_eval_ns": 1840598828, "stage_threat_ns": 3427178770, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 282148, "root_tactical_annotations": 1304, "search_tactical_annotations": 280844, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 167251, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1007021475, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 274003, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2271209979, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43516, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1570839890, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 83619, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121110003, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 167238, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21043703, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62925, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 59100636, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 167552, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 640735000, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 51671, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6793610, "child_limit_applications": 21717, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21717, "child_cap_hits": 21717, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21717, "child_moves_before_total": 1595170, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1595170, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 347491, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 347491, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.45259474144679, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00087489063867, "tt_hits": 7617, "tt_cutoffs": 1815, "beta_cutoffs": 17876, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5268.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5883.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6573, "avg_search_time_ms": 547.75, "search_nodes": 204148, "safety_nodes": 637, "corridor_nodes": 1720, "corridor_branch_probes": 1913, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 13, "corridor_depth_exits": 580, "corridor_neutral_exits": 39, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1695, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1695, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 96, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 71, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 52, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 580, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 96, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 95, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 720, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 283520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 206505, "avg_nodes": 17208.75, "eval_calls": 198377, "avg_eval_calls": 16531.416666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 198377, "pattern_eval_ns": 4310250, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.72756922425483, "pattern_frame_queries": 198377, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4310250, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.72756922425483, "pattern_frame_updates": 408226, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3480987679, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8527.109196866442, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5748, "avg_candidate_generations": 479.0, "candidate_moves_total": 432096, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.17327766179541, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 848, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 5736, "search_candidate_moves_total": 431248, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 15997, "avg_legality_checks": 1333.0833333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 15997, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 919501, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 76625.08333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2233825335, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2429.3886956077263, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4418, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 368.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44386037, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10046.635808057945, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4388, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44045813, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 340224, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 41792654, "stage_ordering_ns": 208070, "stage_eval_ns": 3485297929, "stage_threat_ns": 2847797164, "stage_proof_ns": 156907616, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 411820, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2352362687, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 114921, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 142304815, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1332, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 60079352, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 205904, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 280954171, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3582, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21747865, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 411808, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50427626, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 399, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5131, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5795.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6461.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1963, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1238, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5404, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 80, 79, 95, 128, 65, 110, 81, 113, 67, 52, 53, 39, 109 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1818, "avg_search_time_ms": 227.25, "search_nodes": 38987, "safety_nodes": 411, "corridor_nodes": 381, "corridor_branch_probes": 437, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 144, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 372, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 372, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 144, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 426, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 168320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 39779, "avg_nodes": 4972.375, "eval_calls": 36951, "avg_eval_calls": 4618.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36951, "pattern_eval_ns": 801053, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.678790831100645, "pattern_frame_queries": 36951, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 801053, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.678790831100645, "pattern_frame_updates": 77930, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 956366975, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12272.12851276787, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2022, "avg_candidate_generations": 252.75, "candidate_moves_total": 128277, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.4406528189911, "candidate_moves_max": 84, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 444, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 2014, "search_candidate_moves_total": 127833, "search_candidate_moves_max": 84, "legality_checks": 34006, "avg_legality_checks": 4250.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 444, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 33562, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 383941, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 47992.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 885511294, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2306.373359448457, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5322, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 665.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32875698, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6177.320180383314, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 114621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5239, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32390485, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 170981, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 199611, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 814, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 101.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 7279108, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8942.39312039312, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1024, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 128.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3345963, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3267.5419921875, "stage_move_gen_ns": 83763315, "stage_ordering_ns": 74390, "stage_eval_ns": 957168028, "stage_threat_ns": 611716968, "stage_proof_ns": 150390663, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 78794, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 467465594, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24925, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 75046574, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 409, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18626016, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 39393, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 54609138, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 856, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4849466, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 78786, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9746196, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 224, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1710, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5205.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6205.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1819, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 3578, "avg_search_time_ms": 511.14285714285717, "search_nodes": 29592, "safety_nodes": 430, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 30022, "avg_nodes": 4288.857142857143, "eval_calls": 19812, "avg_eval_calls": 2830.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 19812, "pattern_eval_ns": 446480, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.535836866545527, "pattern_frame_queries": 19812, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 446480, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.535836866545527, "pattern_frame_updates": 59124, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 671397616, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11355.754279142142, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9143, "avg_candidate_generations": 1306.142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 629924, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.89686098654708, "candidate_moves_max": 92, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 383, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 9136, "search_candidate_moves_total": 629541, "search_candidate_moves_max": 92, "legality_checks": 407942, "avg_legality_checks": 58277.42857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 236, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 407942, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 236, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1069810, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 152830.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2330520919, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2178.443760106935, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5250, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 750.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 27417236, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5222.330666666667, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 246, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2554293, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2067, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19195627, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2937, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5667316, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39934, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5704.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 397747239, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9960.115165022287, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 53815, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7687.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 187174632, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3478.112645173279, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1026429444, "stage_ordering_ns": 268204166, "stage_eval_ns": 671844096, "stage_threat_ns": 1585658658, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 140638, "root_tactical_annotations": 556, "search_tactical_annotations": 140082, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 59131, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 362969885, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 126583, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1165931014, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18316, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 650303454, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 29562, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 44076157, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 59124, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7548393, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 30938, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 153732955, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 77324, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 361755565, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 32376, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5133209, "child_limit_applications": 9136, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9136, "child_cap_hits": 9136, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9136, "child_moves_before_total": 629305, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 629305, "child_moves_before_max": 92, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 92, "child_moves_after_total": 146177, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 146177, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.88189579684763, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00010945709282, "tt_hits": 3357, "tt_cutoffs": 614, "beta_cutoffs": 7839, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 4.285714285714286, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 4.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3790.4285714285716, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4933.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1849, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1239, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12794, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 114, 156, 113, 111, 66, 82, 126, 140, 84, 70, 99, 69, 97, 170, 184, 96, 129, 144, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10043, "avg_search_time_ms": 913.0, "search_nodes": 103763, "safety_nodes": 171, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 103934, "avg_nodes": 9448.545454545454, "eval_calls": 75036, "avg_eval_calls": 6821.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75036, "pattern_eval_ns": 1663348, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.16733301348686, "pattern_frame_queries": 75036, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1663348, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.16733301348686, "pattern_frame_updates": 207432, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2842432364, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13702.959832619847, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26860, "avg_candidate_generations": 2441.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2207464, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.18406552494416, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 26849, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2206678, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 676854, "avg_legality_checks": 61532.181818181816, "illegal_moves_skipped": 446, "root_legality_checks": 786, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 676068, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 446, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2609471, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 237224.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5987254279, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2294.4321967939095, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23930, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2175.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 104264961, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4357.081529460927, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 562, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3340566, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11366, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 74237676, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12002, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26686719, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 71396, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6490.545454545455, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 685959301, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9607.81137598745, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98916, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8992.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 302375218, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3056.8888551902623, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1719205821, "stage_ordering_ns": 958891319, "stage_eval_ns": 2844095712, "stage_threat_ns": 4476976268, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 372569, "root_tactical_annotations": 2729, "search_tactical_annotations": 369840, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 207443, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1257572307, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 337467, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3025735417, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53766, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2076969805, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 103716, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156024156, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 207432, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26896747, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 113019, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 200787641, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 170673, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 747966441, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 88877, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10747641, "child_limit_applications": 26849, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26849, "child_cap_hits": 26849, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26849, "child_moves_before_total": 2206232, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2206232, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 432294, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 432294, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.17184997579054, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.100934857909046, "tt_hits": 12930, "tt_cutoffs": 1831, "beta_cutoffs": 21973, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4412.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5139.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 262, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2742, "avg_search_time_ms": 274.2, "search_nodes": 72100, "safety_nodes": 1085, "corridor_nodes": 864, "corridor_branch_probes": 1076, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 362, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 853, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 848, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 362, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 40, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 196, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 50480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 74049, "avg_nodes": 7404.9, "eval_calls": 70448, "avg_eval_calls": 7044.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70448, "pattern_eval_ns": 1534011, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.775082330229388, "pattern_frame_queries": 70448, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1534011, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.775082330229388, "pattern_frame_updates": 144142, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1554170475, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10782.21805580608, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1633, "avg_candidate_generations": 163.3, "candidate_moves_total": 126409, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.40906307409675, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 720, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 1623, "search_candidate_moves_total": 125689, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 3340, "avg_legality_checks": 334.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3340, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 436388, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 43638.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1061916526, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2433.4228393081385, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2337, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 233.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18489047, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7911.445014976465, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2335, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18488607, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 30, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 232772, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7759.066666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 85911, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2260.815789473684, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9686451, "stage_ordering_ns": 54610, "stage_eval_ns": 1555704486, "stage_threat_ns": 1091021082, "stage_proof_ns": 68627557, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 145940, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 899350392, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 51628, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 58645235, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 480, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16512209, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72965, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 103593705, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1788, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10468741, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 145930, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18963009, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1502, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5628.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6428.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1597, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1240, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26949, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 140, 82, 114, 156, 141, 143, 127, 100, 155, 84, 70, 113, 125, 110, 109, 157, 139, 138, 124, 154, 171, 123, 153, 111, 170, 185, 167, 181, 169, 183, 168 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 2361, "avg_search_time_ms": 147.5625, "search_nodes": 50063, "safety_nodes": 1656, "corridor_nodes": 332, "corridor_branch_probes": 408, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 116, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 323, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 323, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 75, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 66, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 116, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 75, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 75, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 459, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 141280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 52051, "avg_nodes": 3253.1875, "eval_calls": 47222, "avg_eval_calls": 2951.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47222, "pattern_eval_ns": 1021472, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.631273558934396, "pattern_frame_queries": 47222, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1021472, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.631273558934396, "pattern_frame_updates": 100032, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1254384370, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12539.83095409469, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2810, "avg_candidate_generations": 175.625, "candidate_moves_total": 208836, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.31886120996441, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1169, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 2794, "search_candidate_moves_total": 207667, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 43885, "avg_legality_checks": 2742.8125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 1169, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 42716, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 19, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 468414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29275.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1137233656, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2427.838740942841, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3108, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 194.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30491949, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9810.7944015444, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 224890, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3007, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29388205, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 302011, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 576843, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 53.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 9001189, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10614.609669811322, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1163, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4788535, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4117.3989681857265, "stage_move_gen_ns": 114622348, "stage_ordering_ns": 99840, "stage_eval_ns": 1255405842, "stage_threat_ns": 781423855, "stage_proof_ns": 182036823, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 100844, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 615885544, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23067, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 77183284, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 461, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20045716, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50414, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 71179156, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 796, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4461547, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 100828, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12714324, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 182, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2492, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6562.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7062.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1718, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 24570, "avg_search_time_ms": 1535.625, "search_nodes": 238913, "safety_nodes": 252, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 239165, "avg_nodes": 14947.8125, "eval_calls": 185294, "avg_eval_calls": 11580.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 185294, "pattern_eval_ns": 4120745, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.238955389812947, "pattern_frame_queries": 185294, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4120745, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.238955389812947, "pattern_frame_updates": 477682, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5147835254, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10776.699255990387, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 51042, "avg_candidate_generations": 3190.125, "candidate_moves_total": 4497794, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.11947024019435, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1196, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 51026, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4496598, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 2976209, "avg_legality_checks": 186013.0625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4690, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2976209, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4690, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7337081, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 458567.5625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15573433308, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2122.5652692126473, "renju_forbidden_checks": 70417, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4401.0625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 262320138, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3725.2387633668004, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4700, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52068354, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11208, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 115554153, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 54499, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 94570850, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 126781, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 284746, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17796.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2862257358, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10051.966868718086, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 401394, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25087.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1394414373, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3473.9292889280855, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7288940772, "stage_ordering_ns": 1792821597, "stage_eval_ns": 5151955999, "stage_threat_ns": 10204302072, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1191355, "root_tactical_annotations": 4572, "search_tactical_annotations": 1186783, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 477698, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2763719289, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1009734, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6984132307, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 102155, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3375676192, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 238841, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 355596100, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 477682, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60773033, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 438772, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1642315863, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 468793, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1966075751, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 283790, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 40081343, "child_limit_applications": 51026, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 51026, "child_cap_hits": 51026, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 51026, "child_moves_before_total": 4491908, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4491908, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 842294, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 842294, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.03174852036217, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.507153216007527, "tt_hits": 22295, "tt_cutoffs": 2521, "beta_cutoffs": 39187, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4185.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4653.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1756, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1241, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17673, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 142, 94, 144, 96, 141, 143, 114, 100, 129, 99, 97, 82, 127, 157, 130, 131, 156, 170, 159, 174, 176, 160, 124, 171, 116, 185, 199, 68, 54, 78, 62, 172, 173, 102, 113, 115, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 43, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 11230, "avg_search_time_ms": 561.5, "search_nodes": 102127, "safety_nodes": 2005, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 104132, "avg_nodes": 5206.6, "eval_calls": 70485, "avg_eval_calls": 3524.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70485, "pattern_eval_ns": 1559936, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.13146059445272, "pattern_frame_queries": 70485, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1559936, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.13146059445272, "pattern_frame_updates": 204070, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2656592921, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13018.04734159847, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29669, "avg_candidate_generations": 1483.45, "candidate_moves_total": 2580565, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.97849607334254, "candidate_moves_max": 138, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1742, "root_candidate_moves_max": 128, "search_candidate_generations": 29649, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2578823, "search_candidate_moves_max": 138, "legality_checks": 902869, "avg_legality_checks": 45143.45, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3562, "root_legality_checks": 1742, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 901127, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3554, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3021311, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 151065.55, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6656081226, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2203.044051406823, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46126, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2306.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 270983261, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5874.8484802497505, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3603, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 37420176, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15972, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 149352249, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26499, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 83686353, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 524483, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 111992, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5599.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1136349266, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10146.700353596685, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 161906, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8095.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 548712312, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3389.0795399799886, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2273884375, "stage_ordering_ns": 1065952622, "stage_eval_ns": 2658152857, "stage_threat_ns": 5171145175, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 573210, "root_tactical_annotations": 2452, "search_tactical_annotations": 570758, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 204090, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1256360198, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 525211, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3718714697, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59429, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2196547378, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102035, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 157407920, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 204070, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26394417, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 218023, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 418101815, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 247744, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1102655978, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 107443, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12267943, "child_limit_applications": 29649, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29649, "child_cap_hits": 29649, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29649, "child_moves_before_total": 2575269, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2575269, "child_moves_before_max": 138, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 138, "child_moves_after_total": 483890, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 483890, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.8585449762218, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.320617896050457, "tt_hits": 12904, "tt_cutoffs": 1901, "beta_cutoffs": 25176, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5988.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6388.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 276, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 6426, "avg_search_time_ms": 338.2105263157895, "search_nodes": 168954, "safety_nodes": 2347, "corridor_nodes": 11950, "corridor_branch_probes": 13433, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 6055, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_plies_followed": 11903, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 11903, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 18, "corridor_proof_completed": 18, "corridor_proof_checks": 93, "corridor_proof_active": 47, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 6055, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 93, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 93, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 475, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 242000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 16480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 183251, "avg_nodes": 9644.78947368421, "eval_calls": 163951, "avg_eval_calls": 8629.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 163951, "pattern_eval_ns": 3563361, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.734304761788582, "pattern_frame_queries": 163951, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3563361, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.734304761788582, "pattern_frame_updates": 337796, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2978961320, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8818.817629575247, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4966, "avg_candidate_generations": 261.36842105263156, "candidate_moves_total": 498609, "avg_candidate_moves": 100.40455094643576, "candidate_moves_max": 138, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1648, "root_candidate_moves_max": 127, "search_candidate_generations": 4947, "search_candidate_moves_total": 496961, "search_candidate_moves_max": 138, "legality_checks": 10441, "avg_legality_checks": 549.5263157894736, "illegal_moves_skipped": 48, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10441, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 48, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 934501, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 49184.26315789474, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2130563708, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2279.894519106989, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14246, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 749.7894736842105, "renju_forbidden_ns": 113514363, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7968.156886143479, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 481952, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13818, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 109900526, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 256, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1718680, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 124, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1413205, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 29520554, "stage_ordering_ns": 167120, "stage_eval_ns": 2982524681, "stage_threat_ns": 3350597999, "stage_proof_ns": 86113571, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 361807, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2198260333, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 562008, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 686184575, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 5371, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 250091176, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 180894, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 259561404, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 23992, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 162172503, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 361788, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44419184, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 200, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4591, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6881.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7302.0526315789475, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1791, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1242, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20378, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 144, 160, 142, 95, 125, 50, 65, 78, 127, 94, 62, 157, 143, 141, 113, 158, 97, 82, 81, 49, 129 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 12754, "avg_search_time_ms": 1062.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 283725, "safety_nodes": 727, "corridor_nodes": 1885, "corridor_branch_probes": 2183, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 855, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1863, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1863, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 71, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 855, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 71, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 68, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 552, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 192720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 286337, "avg_nodes": 23861.416666666668, "eval_calls": 277389, "avg_eval_calls": 23115.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 277389, "pattern_eval_ns": 5970147, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.52265230416491, "pattern_frame_queries": 277389, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5970147, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.52265230416491, "pattern_frame_updates": 567382, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7474646123, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13173.921842779644, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6314, "avg_candidate_generations": 526.1666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 516801, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.85001583782072, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 919, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 6302, "search_candidate_moves_total": 515882, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 270242, "avg_legality_checks": 22520.166666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 315, "root_legality_checks": 919, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 269323, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 312, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2405676, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 200473.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5903127724, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2453.8332360633767, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39294, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3274.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 371354738, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9450.672825367741, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 326, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3147348, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37643, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 358859933, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 405, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3825654, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 920, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5521803, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 5507, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 458.9166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 60882792, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11055.527873615398, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7645, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 637.0833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 33395038, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4368.219489862655, "stage_move_gen_ns": 682159309, "stage_ordering_ns": 229080, "stage_eval_ns": 7480616270, "stage_threat_ns": 4208644877, "stage_proof_ns": 333923168, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 571262, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3336530480, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 104828, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 378192497, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1011, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 74970392, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 285625, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 398779479, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3868, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24202193, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 571250, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 70940228, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 439, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5603, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4286.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4953.416666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7613, "avg_search_time_ms": 692.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 86192, "safety_nodes": 1023, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87215, "avg_nodes": 7928.636363636364, "eval_calls": 69008, "avg_eval_calls": 6273.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 69008, "pattern_eval_ns": 1521107, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.042473336424763, "pattern_frame_queries": 69008, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1521107, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.042473336424763, "pattern_frame_updates": 172284, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1669275477, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9689.091714842934, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16129, "avg_candidate_generations": 1466.2727272727273, "candidate_moves_total": 1375846, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.3026226052452, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 845, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 16118, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1375001, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 738064, "avg_legality_checks": 67096.72727272728, "illegal_moves_skipped": 350, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 738064, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 350, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2043107, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 185737.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4588804529, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2245.9932490075166, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5011, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 455.54545454545456, "renju_forbidden_ns": 47706618, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9520.378766713231, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 367, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4133874, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2839, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30565057, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1783, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12783786, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 223901, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73180, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6652.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 792061919, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10823.475252801312, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 104529, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9502.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 385019598, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3683.375886117728, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1890648933, "stage_ordering_ns": 589910777, "stage_eval_ns": 1670796584, "stage_threat_ns": 3417628244, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 282688, "root_tactical_annotations": 1121, "search_tactical_annotations": 281567, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 172295, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1019622487, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 245713, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2240042230, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32308, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1214680773, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86142, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 127671389, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 172284, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21549182, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62180, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 363630126, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 151217, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 661474779, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 69291, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8742956, "child_limit_applications": 16118, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16118, "child_cap_hits": 16118, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16118, "child_moves_before_total": 1374651, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1374651, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 258931, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 258931, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.28669810150143, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.064710261819084, "tt_hits": 6151, "tt_cutoffs": 1016, "beta_cutoffs": 11562, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4765.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5492.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1714, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1243, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11402, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 81, 68, 111, 54, 40, 109, 142, 94, 127, 157, 128, 125, 114, 113, 156, 100, 170 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8400, "avg_search_time_ms": 763.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 96461, "safety_nodes": 586, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 97047, "avg_nodes": 8822.454545454546, "eval_calls": 70111, "avg_eval_calls": 6373.727272727273, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70111, "pattern_eval_ns": 1504114, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.45332401477657, "pattern_frame_queries": 70111, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1504114, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.45332401477657, "pattern_frame_updates": 192828, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2085957392, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10817.710042110068, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24720, "avg_candidate_generations": 2247.2727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 1974199, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.86241909385113, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 760, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 24709, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1973439, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 722087, "avg_legality_checks": 65644.27272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1245, "root_legality_checks": 760, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 721327, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1245, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2345197, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 213199.72727272726, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4915505553, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2095.9883340290817, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22919, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2083.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 138699453, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6051.723591779746, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1339, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12801367, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 93177140, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10957, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32717876, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3070, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72676, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6606.909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 645555077, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8882.644573174088, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95933, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8721.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 270690288, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2821.659783390491, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1691654222, "stage_ordering_ns": 760005399, "stage_eval_ns": 2087461506, "stage_threat_ns": 3815713052, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 403416, "root_tactical_annotations": 2034, "search_tactical_annotations": 401382, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 192839, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1044034879, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 364394, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2604608544, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49486, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1681450609, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 96414, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 134002827, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 192828, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22241645, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 132553, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 192845616, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 182346, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 729880896, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 88517, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10825157, "child_limit_applications": 24709, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24709, "child_cap_hits": 24709, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24709, "child_moves_before_total": 1972194, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1972194, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 401339, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 401339, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.81682787648225, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.242624145048364, "tt_hits": 10451, "tt_cutoffs": 1594, "beta_cutoffs": 20153, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5112.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5839.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1419, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2990, "avg_search_time_ms": 299.0, "search_nodes": 95373, "safety_nodes": 987, "corridor_nodes": 3005, "corridor_branch_probes": 3702, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 5, "corridor_depth_exits": 1480, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 2989, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2989, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 58, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1480, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 58, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 342, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 226400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 99365, "avg_nodes": 9936.5, "eval_calls": 91742, "avg_eval_calls": 9174.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 91742, "pattern_eval_ns": 1983240, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.61757973447276, "pattern_frame_queries": 91742, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1983240, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.61757973447276, "pattern_frame_updates": 190688, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1366884749, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7168.173922847794, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3612, "avg_candidate_generations": 361.2, "candidate_moves_total": 258982, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.70044296788483, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 694, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 3602, "search_candidate_moves_total": 258288, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 8859, "avg_legality_checks": 885.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8859, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 351086, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 35108.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 847169510, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2412.9971289085865, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1826, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 182.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18173716, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9952.746987951807, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1740, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17859032, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 86, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 314684, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 24777860, "stage_ordering_ns": 124513, "stage_eval_ns": 1368867989, "stage_threat_ns": 1505676323, "stage_proof_ns": 76589788, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 196792, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1143353653, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 154690, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 163557666, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1205, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 43465282, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 98391, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 135655685, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6094, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 39336105, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 196782, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23773214, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 135, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3337, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5561.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6361.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1244, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19859, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 110, 83, 81, 86, 85, 54, 111, 68, 40, 109, 125, 95, 127, 124, 113, 114, 99, 71, 141 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 12861, "avg_search_time_ms": 1071.75, "search_nodes": 296754, "safety_nodes": 727, "corridor_nodes": 2098, "corridor_branch_probes": 2402, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 970, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2076, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2076, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 970, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 554, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 201760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 299579, "avg_nodes": 24964.916666666668, "eval_calls": 290262, "avg_eval_calls": 24188.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 290262, "pattern_eval_ns": 6299869, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.704077695323534, "pattern_frame_queries": 290262, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6299869, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.704077695323534, "pattern_frame_updates": 593440, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7316544737, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12329.038718320302, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6470, "avg_candidate_generations": 539.1666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 526421, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.36336939721792, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 919, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 6458, "search_candidate_moves_total": 525502, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 284771, "avg_legality_checks": 23730.916666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 427, "root_legality_checks": 919, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 283852, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 424, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2379652, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 198304.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5815621626, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2443.8958410725604, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35887, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2990.5833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 337778859, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9412.290216512944, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 439, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4351770, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33725, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 320771226, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 503, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5073353, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1220, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7582510, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 6307, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 525.5833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 70266453, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11141.026319961948, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8777, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 731.4166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 38506678, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4387.22547567506, "stage_move_gen_ns": 719997108, "stage_ordering_ns": 240221, "stage_eval_ns": 7322844606, "stage_threat_ns": 4426079749, "stage_proof_ns": 353778686, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 597748, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3490276902, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 114549, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 417145277, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1119, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 83453442, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 298868, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 416610731, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4296, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28180188, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 597736, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 73866651, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 445, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5756, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4434.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5100.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6985, "avg_search_time_ms": 635.0, "search_nodes": 86480, "safety_nodes": 1023, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87503, "avg_nodes": 7954.818181818182, "eval_calls": 69761, "avg_eval_calls": 6341.909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 69761, "pattern_eval_ns": 1527667, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.89858230243259, "pattern_frame_queries": 69761, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1527667, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.89858230243259, "pattern_frame_updates": 172860, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1409306653, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8152.87893671179, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15899, "avg_candidate_generations": 1445.3636363636363, "candidate_moves_total": 1388184, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.31266117365873, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 845, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 15888, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1387339, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 752675, "avg_legality_checks": 68425.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 322, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 752675, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 322, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1864746, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 169522.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4084349739, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2190.29816339598, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6318, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 574.3636363636364, "renju_forbidden_ns": 55740622, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8822.510604621715, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 339, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3435910, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3909, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 39648461, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2048, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12459371, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 196880, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 56433, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5130.272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 562707946, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9971.256995020643, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 79461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7223.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 261649338, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3292.8019783289915, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1886548184, "stage_ordering_ns": 584834610, "stage_eval_ns": 1410834320, "stage_threat_ns": 3058958958, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 238975, "root_tactical_annotations": 1121, "search_tactical_annotations": 237854, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 172871, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1005712153, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 221100, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1902867563, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31848, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1142364243, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 123043108, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 172860, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21196875, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 57197, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 283115357, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 132047, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 477151093, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49731, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6139259, "child_limit_applications": 15888, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15888, "child_cap_hits": 15888, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15888, "child_moves_before_total": 1387017, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1387017, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 256087, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 256087, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.29966012084593, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.11826535750252, "tt_hits": 5983, "tt_cutoffs": 781, "beta_cutoffs": 11302, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5061.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5789.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1864, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1245, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18708, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 82, 130, 52, 97, 80, 128, 68, 146, 162, 110, 36, 84, 66, 94, 81, 51, 79, 78, 83 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 14278, "avg_search_time_ms": 1427.8, "search_nodes": 148672, "safety_nodes": 176, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148848, "avg_nodes": 14884.8, "eval_calls": 116432, "avg_eval_calls": 11643.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 116432, "pattern_eval_ns": 2545182, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.859815171086986, "pattern_frame_queries": 116432, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2545182, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.859815171086986, "pattern_frame_updates": 297260, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4607285804, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15499.17851039494, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30381, "avg_candidate_generations": 3038.1, "candidate_moves_total": 2691296, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.58483920871598, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 775, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 30371, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2690521, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1053406, "avg_legality_checks": 105340.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1239, "root_legality_checks": 775, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1052631, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1239, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3910009, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 391000.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8725341740, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2231.5400655088006, "renju_forbidden_checks": 63069, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6306.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 310775176, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4927.542469358956, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1744, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11839957, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37274, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 237169504, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24051, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 61765715, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 131015, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13101.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1227287153, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9367.531603251537, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 172241, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17224.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 534608420, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3103.8395039508596, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2642107395, "stage_ordering_ns": 1108679754, "stage_eval_ns": 4609830986, "stage_threat_ns": 5867282569, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 508977, "root_tactical_annotations": 2621, "search_tactical_annotations": 506356, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 297270, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1733454215, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 464760, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3860113408, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60803, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2237641219, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 220451278, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 297260, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36922469, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 148644, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 362821355, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 255305, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1259641384, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 105028, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16341199, "child_limit_applications": 30371, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30371, "child_cap_hits": 30371, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30371, "child_moves_before_total": 2689282, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2689282, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 490258, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 490258, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.54769352342696, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.14230680583451, "tt_hits": 12636, "tt_cutoffs": 1827, "beta_cutoffs": 22947, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2150.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2727.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 391, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4418, "avg_search_time_ms": 490.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 121136, "safety_nodes": 995, "corridor_nodes": 378, "corridor_branch_probes": 443, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 178, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 373, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 368, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 47, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 178, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 47, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 46, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 302, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 47920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122509, "avg_nodes": 13612.111111111111, "eval_calls": 118496, "avg_eval_calls": 13166.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 118496, "pattern_eval_ns": 2564829, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.64485721036997, "pattern_frame_queries": 118496, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2564829, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.64485721036997, "pattern_frame_updates": 242220, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2611164509, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10780.135864090496, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2623, "avg_candidate_generations": 291.44444444444446, "candidate_moves_total": 202368, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.15135341212353, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 707, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 2614, "search_candidate_moves_total": 201661, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 5048, "avg_legality_checks": 560.8888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5048, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 678849, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 75427.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1658626598, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2443.292393448322, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10385, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1153.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 83024924, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7994.696581608088, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10384, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 83024704, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 220, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.777777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 261511, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6081.6511627906975, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 47, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.222222222222222, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 70970, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1510.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14519413, "stage_ordering_ns": 90960, "stage_eval_ns": 2613729338, "stage_threat_ns": 1690642982, "stage_proof_ns": 85195140, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 243069, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1458441678, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 20772, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 28640844, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 339, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11088621, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121530, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 168333788, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 840, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4601538, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 243060, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30625134, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 124, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2378, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4205.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5094.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 723, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1246, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16748, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 144, 82, 129, 99, 130, 110, 68, 97, 67, 111, 146, 162, 113, 126, 83, 53, 159, 174, 141, 124, 138, 125, 127, 80, 64, 95, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 10904, "avg_search_time_ms": 726.9333333333333, "search_nodes": 192445, "safety_nodes": 443, "corridor_nodes": 9754, "corridor_branch_probes": 10117, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 5518, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 9725, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9725, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 63, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5518, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 6, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 698, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 195360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 202642, "avg_nodes": 13509.466666666667, "eval_calls": 186057, "avg_eval_calls": 12403.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 186057, "pattern_eval_ns": 4020435, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.608619939050936, "pattern_frame_queries": 186057, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4020435, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.608619939050936, "pattern_frame_updates": 384804, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5136318209, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13347.88154229166, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6360, "avg_candidate_generations": 424.0, "candidate_moves_total": 549801, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.44669811320755, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1151, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 6345, "search_candidate_moves_total": 548650, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 176250, "avg_legality_checks": 11750.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 605, "root_legality_checks": 1151, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 175099, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 602, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2552958, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 170197.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5839658623, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2287.4088108774213, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55176, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3678.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 277562847, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5030.4996193997395, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 721, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1549033, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 48243, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 237761799, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1571, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15036259, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4641, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 23215756, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 20171, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1344.7333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 195307982, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9682.612760894353, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26762, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1784.1333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 91954812, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3436.0216725207383, "stage_move_gen_ns": 435861442, "stage_ordering_ns": 247963, "stage_eval_ns": 5140338644, "stage_threat_ns": 4351186714, "stage_proof_ns": 944278799, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 404453, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2441740266, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 426763, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1431401795, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 4310, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 288316965, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 202219, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 290275743, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 19634, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 137844750, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 404438, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49924160, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 764, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5294, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6382.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6915.466666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1763, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 5829, "avg_search_time_ms": 416.35714285714283, "search_nodes": 47363, "safety_nodes": 1523, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48886, "avg_nodes": 3491.8571428571427, "eval_calls": 32211, "avg_eval_calls": 2300.785714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32211, "pattern_eval_ns": 717613, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.278507342212286, "pattern_frame_queries": 32211, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 717613, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.278507342212286, "pattern_frame_updates": 94596, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1033865754, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10929.275593048333, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14464, "avg_candidate_generations": 1033.142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 1154036, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.78678097345133, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1080, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 14450, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1152956, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 686801, "avg_legality_checks": 49057.21428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 593, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 686801, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 593, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1690425, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 120744.64285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3777109184, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2234.413939689723, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10857, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 775.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44377698, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4087.473335175463, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 693, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3133333, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4266, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29056311, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5878, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12163744, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 24310, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60341, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4310.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 585465756, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9702.619379857808, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81411, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5815.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 256928209, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3155.939725589908, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1741134245, "stage_ordering_ns": 492814509, "stage_eval_ns": 1034583367, "stage_threat_ns": 2515984330, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 236636, "root_tactical_annotations": 751, "search_tactical_annotations": 235885, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 94610, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 588731322, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 222154, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1839014912, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28993, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1066086751, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47298, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 70774494, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 94596, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12136481, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70127, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 262658310, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 123024, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 509849719, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 43485, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5327121, "child_limit_applications": 14450, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14450, "child_cap_hits": 14450, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14450, "child_moves_before_total": 1152363, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1152363, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 234066, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 234066, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.7483044982699, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.198339100346022, "tt_hits": 5266, "tt_cutoffs": 637, "beta_cutoffs": 12387, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5779.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6350.928571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1841, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1247, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12391, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 110, 158, 111, 113, 68, 82, 128, 144, 80, 64, 95, 65, 97, 174, 190, 98, 125, 140, 139, 83, 153 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9635, "avg_search_time_ms": 875.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 103593, "safety_nodes": 171, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 103764, "avg_nodes": 9433.09090909091, "eval_calls": 74853, "avg_eval_calls": 6804.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74853, "pattern_eval_ns": 1631973, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.802372650394773, "pattern_frame_queries": 74853, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1631973, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.802372650394773, "pattern_frame_updates": 207092, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2754622943, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13301.445459023043, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26849, "avg_candidate_generations": 2440.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2223720, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.82319639465157, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 26838, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2222934, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 681863, "avg_legality_checks": 61987.545454545456, "illegal_moves_skipped": 537, "root_legality_checks": 786, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 681077, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 537, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2607091, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 237008.27272727274, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5743362095, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2202.977224423697, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24715, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2246.818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 108123755, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4374.823184301032, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 652, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4799483, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11808, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 76992875, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12255, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26331397, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 70163, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6378.454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 662941242, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9448.587460627396, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98444, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8949.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 293893329, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2985.385894518711, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1674235029, "stage_ordering_ns": 908991595, "stage_eval_ns": 2756254916, "stage_threat_ns": 4252654610, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 376752, "root_tactical_annotations": 2729, "search_tactical_annotations": 374023, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 207103, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1205493192, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 342463, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2859724181, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53744, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1943895788, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 103546, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 150867580, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 207092, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25780059, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116870, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 176293455, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171840, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 739524168, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 88042, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10789598, "child_limit_applications": 26838, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26838, "child_cap_hits": 26838, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26838, "child_moves_before_total": 2222397, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2222397, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 431882, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 431882, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.80784708249497, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.09218272598554, "tt_hits": 12959, "tt_cutoffs": 1855, "beta_cutoffs": 21959, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4555.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5282.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 335, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2745, "avg_search_time_ms": 274.5, "search_nodes": 76241, "safety_nodes": 1085, "corridor_nodes": 907, "corridor_branch_probes": 1114, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 398, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 896, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 891, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 398, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 40, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 196, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 48240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 78233, "avg_nodes": 7823.3, "eval_calls": 74559, "avg_eval_calls": 7455.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74559, "pattern_eval_ns": 1589497, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.318646977561393, "pattern_frame_queries": 74559, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1589497, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.318646977561393, "pattern_frame_updates": 152424, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1569852272, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10299.245998005563, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1663, "avg_candidate_generations": 166.3, "candidate_moves_total": 128224, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.10402886349969, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 720, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 1653, "search_candidate_moves_total": 127504, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 3399, "avg_legality_checks": 339.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3399, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 462697, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 46269.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1068244144, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2308.7336723600974, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2504, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 250.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20161515, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8051.723242811501, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2502, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20161065, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 450, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 30, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 230150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7671.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 83940, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2208.9473684210525, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9238394, "stage_ordering_ns": 61091, "stage_eval_ns": 1571441769, "stage_threat_ns": 1083585226, "stage_proof_ns": 63937176, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 154308, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 891950281, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52236, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 58826308, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 484, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16107354, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77149, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 103230300, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1874, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10844473, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 154298, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18733864, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1527, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5599.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6399.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1545, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1248, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21731, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 144, 82, 110, 158, 143, 141, 127, 94, 159, 80, 64, 111, 129, 114, 115, 157, 145, 146, 130, 160, 173, 131, 161, 113, 174, 189, 177, 193, 175, 191, 176 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 2018, "avg_search_time_ms": 126.125, "search_nodes": 47044, "safety_nodes": 1656, "corridor_nodes": 333, "corridor_branch_probes": 406, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 115, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 324, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 324, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 75, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 66, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 115, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 75, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 75, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 459, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 146160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49033, "avg_nodes": 3064.5625, "eval_calls": 44352, "avg_eval_calls": 2772.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44352, "pattern_eval_ns": 944002, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.28431637806638, "pattern_frame_queries": 44352, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 944002, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.28431637806638, "pattern_frame_updates": 93994, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1036857505, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11031.10310232568, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2661, "avg_candidate_generations": 166.3125, "candidate_moves_total": 197657, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.27921833897031, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1169, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 2645, "search_candidate_moves_total": 196488, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 41646, "avg_legality_checks": 2602.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "root_legality_checks": 1169, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 40477, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 19, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 446483, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27905.1875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 963111997, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2157.1078786874305, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3270, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 204.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 23341041, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7137.933027522936, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 114140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3159, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22378961, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 298584, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 549356, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 845, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 52.8125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 8819749, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10437.57278106509, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1162, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4684655, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4031.5447504302924, "stage_move_gen_ns": 97358605, "stage_ordering_ns": 94240, "stage_eval_ns": 1037801507, "stage_threat_ns": 682534675, "stage_proof_ns": 175964152, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 94808, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 527239546, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 23272, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 77670833, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 466, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20423248, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47396, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 62140874, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 798, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4526594, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 94792, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10956828, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 182, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2341, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6590.4375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7090.4375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1768, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 19697, "avg_search_time_ms": 1231.0625, "search_nodes": 238010, "safety_nodes": 252, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 238262, "avg_nodes": 14891.375, "eval_calls": 184540, "avg_eval_calls": 11533.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 184540, "pattern_eval_ns": 3848922, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.856844044651567, "pattern_frame_queries": 184540, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3848922, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.856844044651567, "pattern_frame_updates": 475876, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4043504899, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8496.971688002757, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 50878, "avg_candidate_generations": 3179.875, "candidate_moves_total": 4478459, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.0234875584732, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1196, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 50862, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4477263, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 2971299, "avg_legality_checks": 185706.1875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4834, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2971299, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4834, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7272484, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 454530.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12345574562, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1697.57328610142, "renju_forbidden_checks": 64473, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4029.5625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 131953029, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2046.6401284258527, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4936, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 29130781, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7378, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 45155029, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 52149, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 57606548, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 60671, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 284159, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17759.9375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2189344362, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7704.645504805409, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 400325, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25020.3125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1069686438, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2672.045058390058, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5903380707, "stage_ordering_ns": 1460860947, "stage_eval_ns": 4047353821, "stage_threat_ns": 8150187325, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1194133, "root_tactical_annotations": 4572, "search_tactical_annotations": 1189561, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 475892, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2247190837, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1013389, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5515663266, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 101827, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2715814761, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 237938, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 300727907, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 475876, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50295256, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 443594, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1234929534, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 467954, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1564857820, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 282585, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 36310059, "child_limit_applications": 50862, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 50862, "child_cap_hits": 50862, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 50862, "child_moves_before_total": 4472429, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4472429, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 839553, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 839553, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.93262160355472, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.506488144390705, "tt_hits": 22281, "tt_cutoffs": 2536, "beta_cutoffs": 39083, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5635.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6135.1875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1813, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1249, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9701, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 144, 96, 160, 176, 97, 110, 124, 66, 114, 81, 111, 83, 84, 68, 54, 53, 113, 38 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7319, "avg_search_time_ms": 813.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 85000, "safety_nodes": 832, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85832, "avg_nodes": 9536.888888888889, "eval_calls": 65657, "avg_eval_calls": 7295.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 65657, "pattern_eval_ns": 1447978, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.053672875702514, "pattern_frame_queries": 65657, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1447978, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.053672875702514, "pattern_frame_updates": 169920, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1512858166, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8903.355496704331, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17980, "avg_candidate_generations": 1997.7777777777778, "candidate_moves_total": 1423989, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.19849833147943, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 676, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 17971, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1423313, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 770518, "avg_legality_checks": 85613.11111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 79, "root_legality_checks": 676, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 769842, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 78, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1868294, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 207588.22222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4357879081, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2332.544600046888, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6537, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 726.3333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20680498, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3163.606853296619, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 85, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 550891, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1752, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14500797, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4695, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5623520, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5290, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43138, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4793.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 409802732, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9499.808336037831, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 57283, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6364.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 178756908, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3120.5926365588393, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1977154003, "stage_ordering_ns": 630410338, "stage_eval_ns": 1514306144, "stage_threat_ns": 3151724186, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 199480, "root_tactical_annotations": 886, "search_tactical_annotations": 198594, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169929, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 997920159, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 205571, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2004997844, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36000, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1398677334, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84960, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 123443819, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169920, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21137733, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 38117, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 61684144, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 131447, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 544275085, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 29916, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4224631, "child_limit_applications": 17971, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17971, "child_cap_hits": 17971, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17971, "child_moves_before_total": 1423235, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1423235, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 287611, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 287611, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.19620499693951, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.004173390462412, "tt_hits": 4946, "tt_cutoffs": 1333, "beta_cutoffs": 13660, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 4.222222222222222, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 4.222222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2866.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3755.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2373, "avg_search_time_ms": 263.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 75814, "safety_nodes": 251, "corridor_nodes": 947, "corridor_branch_probes": 1036, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 376, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 935, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 935, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 376, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 415, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 100800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 77012, "avg_nodes": 8556.888888888889, "eval_calls": 72610, "avg_eval_calls": 8067.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72610, "pattern_eval_ns": 1568297, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.598911995592893, "pattern_frame_queries": 72610, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1568297, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.598911995592893, "pattern_frame_updates": 151578, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1145154813, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7554.887998258322, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3188, "avg_candidate_generations": 354.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 293651, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.11135508155583, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 703, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 3179, "search_candidate_moves_total": 292948, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 6293, "avg_legality_checks": 699.2222222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6293, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 295343, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32815.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 722833054, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2447.4358762523575, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3723, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 413.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13124776, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3525.3225893096965, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1680, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3668, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12642204, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 41, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 467872, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16858033, "stage_ordering_ns": 120730, "stage_eval_ns": 1146723110, "stage_threat_ns": 1097951395, "stage_proof_ns": 92595245, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 153565, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 884992880, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59448, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 78637104, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 709, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 35915627, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76778, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104658442, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1978, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11127593, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 153556, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18535376, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 503, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2608, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5666.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6555.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1250, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19362, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 114, 81, 83, 78, 79, 50, 113, 66, 34, 115, 129, 99, 127, 130, 111, 110, 95, 63, 143 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 12412, "avg_search_time_ms": 1034.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 292522, "safety_nodes": 727, "corridor_nodes": 2187, "corridor_branch_probes": 2490, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 1011, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 2165, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2165, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1011, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 554, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 198640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 295436, "avg_nodes": 24619.666666666668, "eval_calls": 286319, "avg_eval_calls": 23859.916666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 286319, "pattern_eval_ns": 6143350, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.456312714140523, "pattern_frame_queries": 286319, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6143350, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.456312714140523, "pattern_frame_updates": 584976, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7049883887, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12051.577991233828, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6181, "avg_candidate_generations": 515.0833333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 502035, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.22229412716389, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 919, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 6169, "search_candidate_moves_total": 501116, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 280631, "avg_legality_checks": 23385.916666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 419, "root_legality_checks": 919, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 279712, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 416, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2392739, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 199394.91666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5621194172, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2349.271764283526, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36748, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3062.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 336723691, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9163.048084249484, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 430, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4284080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34633, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 319176390, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 506, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5331228, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1179, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7931993, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 6529, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 544.0833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 73211483, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11213.276612038597, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9073, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 756.0833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 40509395, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4464.829163452, "stage_move_gen_ns": 683160591, "stage_ordering_ns": 248740, "stage_eval_ns": 7056027237, "stage_threat_ns": 4259631103, "stage_proof_ns": 364059664, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 589462, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3322513471, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 119312, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 439293140, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1163, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 86818035, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 294725, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 397068637, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4474, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 29893969, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 589450, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 70861886, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 438, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5498, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4477.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5144.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6943, "avg_search_time_ms": 631.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 85528, "safety_nodes": 1023, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 86551, "avg_nodes": 7868.272727272727, "eval_calls": 69117, "avg_eval_calls": 6283.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 69117, "pattern_eval_ns": 1522862, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.03310328862653, "pattern_frame_queries": 69117, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1522862, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.03310328862653, "pattern_frame_updates": 170956, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1381183678, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8079.176384566789, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15588, "avg_candidate_generations": 1417.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 1359980, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.24531691044393, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 845, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 15577, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1359135, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 737464, "avg_legality_checks": 67042.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 313, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 737464, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 313, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1805953, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 164177.54545454544, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4056358994, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2246.104408032767, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5108, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 464.3636363636364, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46214587, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9047.491581832419, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 330, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3572987, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3003, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31587045, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1753, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10852845, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 201710, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 55234, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5021.272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 565540998, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10239.001303544917, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 77911, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7082.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 263946224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3387.7915056923925, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1883133140, "stage_ordering_ns": 581122279, "stage_eval_ns": 1382706540, "stage_threat_ns": 3050903595, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 232656, "root_tactical_annotations": 1121, "search_tactical_annotations": 231535, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 170967, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1001050594, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 215375, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1896730811, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31226, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1133983834, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85478, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125011941, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 170956, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21296187, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 55077, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 289011590, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 129064, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 473490312, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 48515, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6814062, "child_limit_applications": 15577, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15577, "child_cap_hits": 15577, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15577, "child_moves_before_total": 1358822, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1358822, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 250603, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 250603, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.23258650574564, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0880143801759, "tt_hits": 5939, "tt_cutoffs": 784, "beta_cutoffs": 11032, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5058.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5785.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1877, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1251, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14944, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 142, 100, 140, 98, 143, 141, 110, 94, 125, 95, 97, 82, 127, 157, 124, 123, 155, 170, 158, 174, 168, 154, 130, 173, 108, 189, 205, 66, 50, 86, 72, 172, 171, 92, 111, 109, 139, 83, 153 ], "move_count": 43, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 10140, "avg_search_time_ms": 507.0, "search_nodes": 102107, "safety_nodes": 2001, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 104108, "avg_nodes": 5205.4, "eval_calls": 70905, "avg_eval_calls": 3545.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70905, "pattern_eval_ns": 1536044, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.663408786404343, "pattern_frame_queries": 70905, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1536044, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.663408786404343, "pattern_frame_updates": 204030, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2511564602, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12309.780924373867, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29304, "avg_candidate_generations": 1465.2, "candidate_moves_total": 2556998, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.257644007644, "candidate_moves_max": 138, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1740, "root_candidate_moves_max": 128, "search_candidate_generations": 29284, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2555258, "search_candidate_moves_max": 138, "legality_checks": 892673, "avg_legality_checks": 44633.65, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3744, "root_legality_checks": 1740, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 890933, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3736, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3010959, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 150547.95, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5978906611, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1985.7150532438336, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47358, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2367.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 242173693, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5113.680750876304, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3800, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33146560, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16675, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 139480521, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26831, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 69101381, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 445231, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 110069, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5503.45, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 975927223, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8866.503947523826, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 159246, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7962.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 466659299, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2930.4302714039914, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1970240886, "stage_ordering_ns": 943603561, "stage_eval_ns": 2513100646, "stage_threat_ns": 4656303480, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 566503, "root_tactical_annotations": 2452, "search_tactical_annotations": 564051, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 204050, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1157361954, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 517043, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3316459856, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58699, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2008127386, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102015, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 145647164, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 204030, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24747457, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 215792, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 349752929, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 242537, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 957207935, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 108174, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12087049, "child_limit_applications": 29284, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29284, "child_cap_hits": 29284, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29284, "child_moves_before_total": 2551522, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2551522, "child_moves_before_max": 138, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 138, "child_moves_after_total": 477861, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 477861, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.13024177024997, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.318160087419752, "tt_hits": 12774, "tt_cutoffs": 1826, "beta_cutoffs": 24783, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5998.85, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6398.85, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 275, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 4786, "avg_search_time_ms": 251.89473684210526, "search_nodes": 171178, "safety_nodes": 2345, "corridor_nodes": 12133, "corridor_branch_probes": 13667, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 6131, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_plies_followed": 12085, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 12085, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 18, "corridor_proof_completed": 18, "corridor_proof_checks": 93, "corridor_proof_active": 48, "corridor_proof_quiet": 45, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 6131, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 93, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 93, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 475, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 229080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 16480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 185656, "avg_nodes": 9771.368421052632, "eval_calls": 166169, "avg_eval_calls": 8745.736842105263, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 166169, "pattern_eval_ns": 3308975, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.913311147085196, "pattern_frame_queries": 166169, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3308975, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.913311147085196, "pattern_frame_updates": 342244, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2213033432, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6466.244644171994, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4972, "avg_candidate_generations": 261.6842105263158, "candidate_moves_total": 498762, "avg_candidate_moves": 100.3141592920354, "candidate_moves_max": 138, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1646, "root_candidate_moves_max": 127, "search_candidate_generations": 4953, "search_candidate_moves_total": 497116, "search_candidate_moves_max": 138, "legality_checks": 10188, "avg_legality_checks": 536.2105263157895, "illegal_moves_skipped": 31, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10188, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 31, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 956175, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 50325.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1539978395, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1610.5612414045545, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13400, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 705.2631578947369, "renju_forbidden_ns": 83736794, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6249.0144776119405, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 31, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 287953, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12993, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 81213802, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 252, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1178527, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 124, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1056512, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 24477671, "stage_ordering_ns": 161210, "stage_eval_ns": 2216342407, "stage_threat_ns": 2456256485, "stage_proof_ns": 76352430, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 366619, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1615559979, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 571442, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 492000523, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 5437, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 172826508, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 183300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 198396108, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 24356, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 116336398, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 366600, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33963477, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 200, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4600, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6873.473684210527, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7294.526315789473, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1777, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1252, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14070, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 96, 142, 100, 99, 129, 141, 97, 140, 143, 170, 156, 155, 185, 139, 138, 171, 95, 94, 123, 169, 127, 168, 172, 167 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 5074, "avg_search_time_ms": 390.3076923076923, "search_nodes": 161089, "safety_nodes": 1236, "corridor_nodes": 1230, "corridor_branch_probes": 1455, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 537, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_plies_followed": 1216, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1216, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 73, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 59, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 537, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 73, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 72, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 464, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 129680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 163555, "avg_nodes": 12581.153846153846, "eval_calls": 156549, "avg_eval_calls": 12042.23076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 156549, "pattern_eval_ns": 3103077, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.821761876473182, "pattern_frame_queries": 156549, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3103077, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.821761876473182, "pattern_frame_updates": 322102, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2858720208, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8875.201669036516, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4515, "avg_candidate_generations": 347.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 317576, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.33798449612404, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 901, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 4502, "search_candidate_moves_total": 316675, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 154445, "avg_legality_checks": 11880.384615384615, "illegal_moves_skipped": 98, "root_legality_checks": 901, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 153544, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 95, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1292166, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 99397.38461538461, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2164573566, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1675.151308732779, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11086, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 852.7692307692307, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65736711, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5929.70512357929, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 98, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 561902, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10284, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 63337070, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 77, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 509381, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 627, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1328358, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3649, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 280.6923076923077, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 22204615, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6085.123321457933, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5435, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 418.0769230769231, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 12285188, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2260.3841766329347, "stage_move_gen_ns": 291173748, "stage_ordering_ns": 139661, "stage_eval_ns": 2861823285, "stage_threat_ns": 1719551493, "stage_proof_ns": 165154073, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 324693, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1366630414, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 69305, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 139181524, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 813, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 28279483, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 162340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 171257251, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2578, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11517979, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 324680, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30964325, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 181, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4045, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5477.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6092.538461538462, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 822, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8983, "avg_search_time_ms": 691.0, "search_nodes": 118594, "safety_nodes": 435, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 119029, "avg_nodes": 9156.076923076924, "eval_calls": 84463, "avg_eval_calls": 6497.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84463, "pattern_eval_ns": 1650979, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.546771959319464, "pattern_frame_queries": 84463, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1650979, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.546771959319464, "pattern_frame_updates": 237070, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1688809757, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7123.675526215886, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32391, "avg_candidate_generations": 2491.6153846153848, "candidate_moves_total": 2688753, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.00926183199037, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 920, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 32378, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2687833, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1946763, "avg_legality_checks": 149751.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3554, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1946763, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3554, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4487339, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 345179.92307692306, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5692398515, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1268.546574038645, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36215, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2785.769230769231, "renju_forbidden_ns": 88655857, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2448.0424409774955, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3554, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23883262, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7746, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 40447844, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24895, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24196511, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 128240, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 162307, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12485.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1002301383, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6175.342918050362, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 231732, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17825.53846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 506840829, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2187.185321837295, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2846982821, "stage_ordering_ns": 672544758, "stage_eval_ns": 1690460736, "stage_threat_ns": 3687704552, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 648893, "root_tactical_annotations": 3126, "search_tactical_annotations": 645767, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 237083, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 876407174, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 540882, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2651802563, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64840, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1381881760, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 118535, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 120438585, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 237070, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20306751, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 206524, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 612175832, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 269507, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 657669321, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 172862, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18749479, "child_limit_applications": 32378, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32378, "child_cap_hits": 32378, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32378, "child_moves_before_total": 2684279, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2684279, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 522373, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 522373, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.9044104021249, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.133578355673606, "tt_hits": 15075, "tt_cutoffs": 1694, "beta_cutoffs": 27076, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6034.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6650.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1869, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1253, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5894, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 82, 124, 126, 140, 127, 97, 130, 114, 84, 70, 83, 81, 128, 129, 113, 143, 68 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4768, "avg_search_time_ms": 529.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 75872, "safety_nodes": 223, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76095, "avg_nodes": 8455.0, "eval_calls": 51361, "avg_eval_calls": 5706.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51361, "pattern_eval_ns": 1021243, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.88362765522478, "pattern_frame_queries": 51361, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1021243, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.88362765522478, "pattern_frame_updates": 151670, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1170781923, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7719.271596228655, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22751, "avg_candidate_generations": 2527.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 1790316, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.69174981319503, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 588, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 22742, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1789728, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 536899, "avg_legality_checks": 59655.444444444445, "illegal_moves_skipped": 271, "root_legality_checks": 588, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 536311, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 271, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1875655, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 208406.11111111112, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2718321119, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1449.2649868979104, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17410, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1934.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51417917, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2953.3553704767373, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 379, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1948159, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7501, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35731210, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9528, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13734748, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3800, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46498, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5166.444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 270071316, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5808.235106886318, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63634, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7070.444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 119325542, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1875.185309740076, "stage_move_gen_ns": 830944679, "stage_ordering_ns": 490432035, "stage_eval_ns": 1171803166, "stage_threat_ns": 2239021961, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 326902, "root_tactical_annotations": 2193, "search_tactical_annotations": 324709, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 151679, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 593387132, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 285894, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1542389449, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45538, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1130196543, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75835, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80160399, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 151670, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13415657, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 94874, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 89426665, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 145474, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 322702270, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 86554, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9669324, "child_limit_applications": 22742, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22742, "child_cap_hits": 22742, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22742, "child_moves_before_total": 1789457, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1789457, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 366468, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 366468, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.68512004221265, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.114150030780056, "tt_hits": 10867, "tt_cutoffs": 1732, "beta_cutoffs": 19384, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4844.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5733.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1057, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1118, "avg_search_time_ms": 139.75, "search_nodes": 42734, "safety_nodes": 731, "corridor_nodes": 808, "corridor_branch_probes": 1014, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 5, "corridor_depth_exits": 355, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 799, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 799, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 27, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 355, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 188, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 45360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 44273, "avg_nodes": 5534.125, "eval_calls": 41533, "avg_eval_calls": 5191.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41533, "pattern_eval_ns": 840827, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.244793296896443, "pattern_frame_queries": 41533, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 840827, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.244793296896443, "pattern_frame_updates": 85422, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 589278455, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6898.438985273115, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1186, "avg_candidate_generations": 148.25, "candidate_moves_total": 87025, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.37689713322091, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 527, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 1178, "search_candidate_moves_total": 86498, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 2630, "avg_legality_checks": 328.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2630, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 236908, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29613.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 393778333, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1662.1571791581541, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1480, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 185.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6983686, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4718.7067567567565, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1474, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6975756, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7930, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5710546, "stage_ordering_ns": 38330, "stage_eval_ns": 590119282, "stage_threat_ns": 473921826, "stage_proof_ns": 34537878, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 87100, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 372680538, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46725, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 39397465, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 446, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12242069, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43546, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 46076085, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1670, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7599280, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 87092, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8168458, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 66, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1078, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5291.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6291.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1815, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1254, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17966, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 140, 82, 125, 95, 124, 114, 66, 97, 67, 113, 138, 152, 111, 128, 81, 51, 155, 170, 143, 130, 146, 129, 127, 84, 70, 99, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 12020, "avg_search_time_ms": 801.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 217437, "safety_nodes": 443, "corridor_nodes": 9535, "corridor_branch_probes": 9898, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 5263, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 9506, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9506, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 63, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5263, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 6, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 698, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 193120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 227415, "avg_nodes": 15161.0, "eval_calls": 210779, "avg_eval_calls": 14051.933333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 210779, "pattern_eval_ns": 4577507, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.717092309954978, "pattern_frame_queries": 210779, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4577507, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.717092309954978, "pattern_frame_updates": 434788, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5760908373, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13249.92495883051, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6630, "avg_candidate_generations": 442.0, "candidate_moves_total": 571350, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.17647058823529, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1151, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 6615, "search_candidate_moves_total": 570199, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 200703, "avg_legality_checks": 13380.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1008, "root_legality_checks": 1151, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 199552, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1005, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2729854, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 181990.26666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6299748165, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2307.7234771529907, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60711, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4047.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 307065952, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5057.830574360495, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1144, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2203541, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 53864, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 267767194, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1565, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15512582, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4138, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 21582635, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21076, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1405.0666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 203876354, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9673.38935281837, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27696, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1846.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 98809385, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3567.6409950895436, "stage_move_gen_ns": 496932641, "stage_ordering_ns": 264343, "stage_eval_ns": 5765485880, "stage_threat_ns": 4747558078, "stage_proof_ns": 969746667, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 453999, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2751722221, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 431137, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1475548970, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 4354, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 294250296, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 226992, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 331835793, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 19196, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 132280356, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 453984, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56170738, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 764, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5507, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6250.533333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6783.866666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1706, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 5931, "avg_search_time_ms": 423.64285714285717, "search_nodes": 47928, "safety_nodes": 1523, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49451, "avg_nodes": 3532.214285714286, "eval_calls": 32554, "avg_eval_calls": 2325.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32554, "pattern_eval_ns": 731005, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.455151440683174, "pattern_frame_queries": 32554, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 731005, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.455151440683174, "pattern_frame_updates": 95726, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1052300022, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10992.83394271149, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14675, "avg_candidate_generations": 1048.2142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 1173318, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.95352640545144, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1080, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 14661, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1172238, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 690449, "avg_legality_checks": 49317.78571428572, "illegal_moves_skipped": 651, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 690449, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 651, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1705569, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 121826.35714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3827323232, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2244.0154763600885, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11246, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 803.2857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44767087, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3980.7119864840834, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 757, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3374535, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4416, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28968349, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6053, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12400933, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 23270, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60815, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4343.928571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 588528906, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9677.36423579709, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81984, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5856.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 258126017, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3148.4925961163153, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1758508095, "stage_ordering_ns": 501638986, "stage_eval_ns": 1053031027, "stage_threat_ns": 2573401664, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 242335, "root_tactical_annotations": 751, "search_tactical_annotations": 241584, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 95740, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 605352644, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 227659, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1876366602, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29415, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1095334808, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47863, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73938483, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 95726, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12475338, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71468, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 260377598, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 126766, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 520234156, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 44101, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5268597, "child_limit_applications": 14661, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14661, "child_cap_hits": 14661, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14661, "child_moves_before_total": 1171587, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1171587, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 237547, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 237547, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.91180683445877, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.20264647704795, "tt_hits": 5303, "tt_cutoffs": 648, "beta_cutoffs": 12574, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5755.357142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6326.785714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1821, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1255, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9866, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 99, 95, 113, 141, 85, 71, 157, 172, 114, 115, 128, 156, 96, 80, 144, 160, 129, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8505, "avg_search_time_ms": 773.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 96311, "safety_nodes": 425, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 96736, "avg_nodes": 8794.181818181818, "eval_calls": 68772, "avg_eval_calls": 6252.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68772, "pattern_eval_ns": 1511517, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.97866864421567, "pattern_frame_queries": 68772, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1511517, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.97866864421567, "pattern_frame_updates": 192528, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2175168480, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11297.933183744703, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26318, "avg_candidate_generations": 2392.5454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 2107682, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.0851888441371, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 772, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 26307, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2106910, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 517771, "avg_legality_checks": 47070.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2401, "root_legality_checks": 772, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 516999, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2398, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1985574, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 180506.72727272726, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4670259446, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2352.095387026623, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19244, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1749.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 167564694, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8707.373415090418, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2451, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 27113123, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9472, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 101040608, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7302, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39229932, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 181031, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39879, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3625.3636363636365, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 398971078, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10004.54068557386, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 54726, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4975.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 182561034, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3335.9104264883235, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1363433582, "stage_ordering_ns": 910662504, "stage_eval_ns": 2176679997, "stage_threat_ns": 4019618332, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 308498, "root_tactical_annotations": 2593, "search_tactical_annotations": 305905, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 192539, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1185554793, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 274517, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2651410139, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52682, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2035787392, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 96264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 146772741, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 192528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25079013, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 78118, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 111297174, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 143707, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 504090502, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 86673, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10801646, "child_limit_applications": 26307, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26307, "child_cap_hits": 26307, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26307, "child_moves_before_total": 2104512, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2104512, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 421314, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 421314, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.99817539058046, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0152811038887, "tt_hits": 12113, "tt_cutoffs": 1185, "beta_cutoffs": 21849, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4605.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5333.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 949, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 1350, "avg_search_time_ms": 135.0, "search_nodes": 39264, "safety_nodes": 982, "corridor_nodes": 904, "corridor_branch_probes": 1104, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 8, "corridor_depth_exits": 370, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 896, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 896, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 28, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 370, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 180, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 41120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 41150, "avg_nodes": 4115.0, "eval_calls": 37505, "avg_eval_calls": 3750.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37505, "pattern_eval_ns": 812154, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.65455272630316, "pattern_frame_queries": 37505, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 812154, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.65455272630316, "pattern_frame_updates": 78470, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 622542534, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7933.510054798012, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1740, "avg_candidate_generations": 174.0, "candidate_moves_total": 127887, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.49827586206897, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 705, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 1730, "search_candidate_moves_total": 127182, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 5396, "avg_legality_checks": 539.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5396, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 162788, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16278.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 396297049, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2434.4365002334325, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2958, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 295.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30223924, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10217.688979039891, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 93572, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2874, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29346350, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 377192, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 406810, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15662858, "stage_ordering_ns": 58920, "stage_eval_ns": 623354688, "stage_threat_ns": 637713065, "stage_proof_ns": 57484546, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 80344, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 490674903, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 54008, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 67799044, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 523, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 23562614, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40167, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 58022608, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1864, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11216665, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 80334, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9999845, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 73, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1583, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5802.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6602.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1949, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1256, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19151, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 128, 113, 155, 99, 85, 111, 140, 95, 143, 81, 66, 67, 53, 115, 114, 83, 51, 131 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11908, "avg_search_time_ms": 1082.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 248956, "safety_nodes": 368, "corridor_nodes": 3874, "corridor_branch_probes": 4028, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1773, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 3856, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3856, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 90, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 72, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1773, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 90, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 87, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 711, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 161920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 253198, "avg_nodes": 23018.0, "eval_calls": 242755, "avg_eval_calls": 22068.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 242755, "pattern_eval_ns": 5267117, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.697254433482318, "pattern_frame_queries": 242755, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5267117, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.697254433482318, "pattern_frame_updates": 497850, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6354869397, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12764.626688761675, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6181, "avg_candidate_generations": 561.9090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 436581, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.6327455104352, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 717, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 6170, "search_candidate_moves_total": 435864, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 233806, "avg_legality_checks": 21255.090909090908, "illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "root_legality_checks": 717, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 233089, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 47, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2239926, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 203629.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5523894844, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2466.1059535002496, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18864, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1714.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 164245286, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8706.811174724342, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 66, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 473032, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18337, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 160136232, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 121, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1480425, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 340, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2155597, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 8091, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 735.5454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 80800175, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9986.426276109258, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11146, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1013.2727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 41644815, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3736.3013637179256, "stage_move_gen_ns": 624812074, "stage_ordering_ns": 229071, "stage_eval_ns": 6360136514, "stage_threat_ns": 4333748648, "stage_proof_ns": 570324069, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 505753, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3125665845, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 215119, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 719675048, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2333, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 144526251, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 252871, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 373669687, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7892, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 48973405, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 505742, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65764663, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 508, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5335, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2984.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3711.3636363636365, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7233, "avg_search_time_ms": 723.3, "search_nodes": 59566, "safety_nodes": 791, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 60357, "avg_nodes": 6035.7, "eval_calls": 40191, "avg_eval_calls": 4019.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40191, "pattern_eval_ns": 891559, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.18305093180065, "pattern_frame_queries": 40191, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 891559, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.18305093180065, "pattern_frame_updates": 119042, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1200981994, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10088.724937417046, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18166, "avg_candidate_generations": 1816.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1330591, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.2462292194209, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 647, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 18156, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1329944, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 834296, "avg_legality_checks": 83429.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 51, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 834296, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 51, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2084809, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 208480.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4697594439, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2253.249309169329, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6167, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 616.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21688487, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3516.8618453056592, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 53, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 501813, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1625, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16627395, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4489, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4559279, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 78850, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7885.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 751139983, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9526.188750792644, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110135, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11013.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 332679115, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3020.648431470468, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2128023309, "stage_ordering_ns": 597892745, "stage_eval_ns": 1201873553, "stage_threat_ns": 3262848912, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 217380, "root_tactical_annotations": 921, "search_tactical_annotations": 216459, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 119052, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 747561647, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 216116, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2401108072, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36377, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1454898322, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 59521, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93246539, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 119042, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15686791, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 53498, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 313219197, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 126233, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 632726551, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 37649, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5245863, "child_limit_applications": 18156, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18156, "child_cap_hits": 18156, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18156, "child_moves_before_total": 1329893, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1329893, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 290499, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 290499, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.24812734082397, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00016523463318, "tt_hits": 5727, "tt_cutoffs": 1174, "beta_cutoffs": 15513, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4285.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5085.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1875, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1257, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11339, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 113, 114, 126, 98, 66, 100, 110, 109, 142, 86, 72, 94, 141, 130, 146, 96, 97, 145, 127, 157, 155, 99, 169 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7358, "avg_search_time_ms": 613.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 74467, "safety_nodes": 989, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 75456, "avg_nodes": 6288.0, "eval_calls": 54909, "avg_eval_calls": 4575.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 54909, "pattern_eval_ns": 1205577, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.955908867398787, "pattern_frame_queries": 54909, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1205577, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.955908867398787, "pattern_frame_updates": 148830, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1892039034, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12712.753033662568, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18457, "avg_candidate_generations": 1538.0833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1574797, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.32247927615539, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 920, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 18445, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1573877, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 586144, "avg_legality_checks": 48845.333333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1612, "root_legality_checks": 920, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 585224, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1603, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1851709, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 154309.08333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4291996880, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2317.857114697828, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34363, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2863.5833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 188180393, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5476.250414690219, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2331, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21047080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13781, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 113253110, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18186, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 53269971, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 65, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 610232, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53465, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4455.416666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 526826114, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9853.66340596652, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 71295, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5941.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 232888352, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3266.5453678378567, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1520141327, "stage_ordering_ns": 645189597, "stage_eval_ns": 1893244611, "stage_threat_ns": 3260927142, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 313635, "root_tactical_annotations": 1526, "search_tactical_annotations": 312109, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 148842, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 921968785, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 270508, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2196100937, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36965, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1440294980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74415, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113250807, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 148830, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19200727, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 84765, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 111601472, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 148769, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 643528770, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 80101, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10405886, "child_limit_applications": 18445, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18445, "child_cap_hits": 18445, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18445, "child_moves_before_total": 1572274, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1572274, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 296243, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 296243, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.24120357820547, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.060883708322038, "tt_hits": 7928, "tt_cutoffs": 1061, "beta_cutoffs": 14864, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5313.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5980.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 931, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3971, "avg_search_time_ms": 361.0, "search_nodes": 113294, "safety_nodes": 1032, "corridor_nodes": 1332, "corridor_branch_probes": 1578, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 7, "corridor_depth_exits": 497, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 19, "corridor_plies_followed": 1311, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1311, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 53, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 21, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 497, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 53, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 320, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 213840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 115658, "avg_nodes": 10514.363636363636, "eval_calls": 110064, "avg_eval_calls": 10005.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110064, "pattern_eval_ns": 2396373, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.77254143044047, "pattern_frame_queries": 110064, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2396373, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.77254143044047, "pattern_frame_updates": 226524, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2159085380, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9531.37583655595, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3209, "avg_candidate_generations": 291.72727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 259441, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.84792770333438, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 851, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 3198, "search_candidate_moves_total": 258590, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 12921, "avg_legality_checks": 1174.6363636363637, "illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 12921, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 545651, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 49604.63636363636, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1349251726, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2472.7375666863986, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15609, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1419.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 135765332, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8697.88788519444, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 326590, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15217, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 132517397, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 216, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1911928, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 141, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1009417, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 36136958, "stage_ordering_ns": 119360, "stage_eval_ns": 2161481753, "stage_threat_ns": 1662509286, "stage_proof_ns": 85825933, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 229263, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1347089576, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 85161, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 109770169, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 827, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 41946677, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 114626, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 160775261, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2728, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16203709, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 229252, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28670571, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 221, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2874, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5867.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6594.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1258, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12949, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 126, 70, 127, 108, 109, 125, 155, 141, 97, 80, 129, 130, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6634, "avg_search_time_ms": 737.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 160286, "safety_nodes": 589, "corridor_nodes": 298, "corridor_branch_probes": 345, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 84, "corridor_neutral_exits": 22, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 285, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 285, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 80, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 80, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 80, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 591, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 171360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 161173, "avg_nodes": 17908.11111111111, "eval_calls": 155391, "avg_eval_calls": 17265.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 155391, "pattern_eval_ns": 3385686, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.788173060215843, "pattern_frame_queries": 155391, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3385686, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.788173060215843, "pattern_frame_updates": 320520, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3777854630, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11786.642424809685, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4878, "avg_candidate_generations": 542.0, "candidate_moves_total": 348666, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.47724477244772, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 607, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 4869, "search_candidate_moves_total": 348059, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 150131, "avg_legality_checks": 16681.222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 607, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 149524, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1124000, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 124888.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2814991817, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2504.441118327402, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10045, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1116.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 75541177, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7520.276455948233, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 55010, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9999, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 75091113, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 168261, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 226793, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 424, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 47.111111111111114, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 4079150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9620.63679245283, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 554, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 61.55555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2009064, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3626.4693140794225, "stage_move_gen_ns": 393731385, "stage_ordering_ns": 162780, "stage_eval_ns": 3781240316, "stage_threat_ns": 2245627651, "stage_proof_ns": 191789970, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 321259, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1901929858, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22610, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 70043225, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 480, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20058113, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 160625, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 228676385, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 730, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4101785, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 321250, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40876398, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 238, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4358, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3916.222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4805.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1492, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6306, "avg_search_time_ms": 700.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 51120, "safety_nodes": 586, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 51706, "avg_nodes": 5745.111111111111, "eval_calls": 32990, "avg_eval_calls": 3665.5555555555557, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32990, "pattern_eval_ns": 720145, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.829190663837526, "pattern_frame_queries": 32990, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 720145, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.829190663837526, "pattern_frame_updates": 102166, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 798073753, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7811.539582640017, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17077, "avg_candidate_generations": 1897.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 1409356, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.52948410142297, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 638, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 17068, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1408718, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1085577, "avg_legality_checks": 120619.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1072, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1085577, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1072, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2130967, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 236774.11111111112, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4207341787, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1974.3814836175313, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13519, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1502.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 34146984, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2525.8513203639322, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1090, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7258238, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1794, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15147259, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10635, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11741487, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67176, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7464.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 573423903, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8536.14241693462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 93432, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10381.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 274185369, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2934.598092730542, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2413345136, "stage_ordering_ns": 555868805, "stage_eval_ns": 798793898, "stage_threat_ns": 2486134573, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 187288, "root_tactical_annotations": 1352, "search_tactical_annotations": 185936, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 102175, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 579361730, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 184747, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1816604994, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34190, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1121839360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51083, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 72847217, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 102166, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12214589, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 59672, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 318354664, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 90878, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 376305380, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 36738, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5106043, "child_limit_applications": 17068, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17068, "child_cap_hits": 17068, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17068, "child_moves_before_total": 1407646, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1407646, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 273088, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 273088, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.47281462385752, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 6930, "tt_cutoffs": 1025, "beta_cutoffs": 14924, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4512.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5401.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1870, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1259, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13280, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 67, 82, 98, 96, 68, 111, 141, 110, 66, 69, 83, 53, 99, 124, 138, 51, 113, 128, 127, 85, 155 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10560, "avg_search_time_ms": 960.0, "search_nodes": 121000, "safety_nodes": 260, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 121260, "avg_nodes": 11023.636363636364, "eval_calls": 92222, "avg_eval_calls": 8383.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 92222, "pattern_eval_ns": 2017632, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.877990067445946, "pattern_frame_queries": 92222, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2017632, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.877990067445946, "pattern_frame_updates": 241906, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3025296501, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12506.082945441618, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27125, "avg_candidate_generations": 2465.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 2025002, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.65445161290323, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 713, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 27114, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2024289, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 800971, "avg_legality_checks": 72815.54545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1444, "root_legality_checks": 713, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 800258, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2680699, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 243699.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6187344265, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2308.108543704459, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25855, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2350.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 148588993, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5747.011912589441, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1557, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14552879, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13517, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 99709565, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10781, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 34326549, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65217, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5928.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 573483146, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8793.460999432664, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86318, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7847.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 228874522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2651.527166987187, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2062850252, "stage_ordering_ns": 864099478, "stage_eval_ns": 3027314133, "stage_threat_ns": 4559223177, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 377495, "root_tactical_annotations": 2225, "search_tactical_annotations": 375270, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 241917, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1467137569, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 344834, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2868673433, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54296, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2009888603, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 120953, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 181571527, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 241906, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30904529, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 101914, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 108100774, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 188615, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 750554045, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 86966, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10936119, "child_limit_applications": 27114, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27114, "child_cap_hits": 27114, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27114, "child_moves_before_total": 2022845, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2022845, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 435969, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 435969, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.60518551301911, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.07911042265988, "tt_hits": 10517, "tt_cutoffs": 1618, "beta_cutoffs": 21232, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3692.3636363636365, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4419.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2710, "avg_search_time_ms": 271.0, "search_nodes": 74146, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 686, "corridor_branch_probes": 833, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 262, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 676, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 671, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 262, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 448, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 210720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 75629, "avg_nodes": 7562.9, "eval_calls": 71548, "avg_eval_calls": 7154.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71548, "pattern_eval_ns": 1561519, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.824774976239727, "pattern_frame_queries": 71548, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1561519, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.824774976239727, "pattern_frame_updates": 148234, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1480643990, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9988.55856281285, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2579, "avg_candidate_generations": 257.9, "candidate_moves_total": 182687, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.83637068631252, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 648, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 2569, "search_candidate_moves_total": 182039, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 5014, "avg_legality_checks": 501.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5014, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 438199, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 43819.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1046501374, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2388.187499286854, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3288, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 328.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32851886, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9991.449513381995, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3260, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32594265, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 249411, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8210, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 342141, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7956.767441860465, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 53, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 117550, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2217.9245283018868, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14116339, "stage_ordering_ns": 92580, "stage_eval_ns": 1482205509, "stage_threat_ns": 1076426048, "stage_proof_ns": 115816150, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 149728, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 889168879, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 44025, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 55578597, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 546, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18298139, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74859, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104202142, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1484, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8879475, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 149718, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18596955, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 184, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2271, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5664.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6464.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1942, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1260, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13005, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 128, 144, 80, 99, 129, 113, 96, 64, 141, 54, 94, 85, 71, 69, 84, 95, 52, 67, 66, 38, 108 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 4422, "avg_search_time_ms": 368.5, "search_nodes": 94579, "safety_nodes": 638, "corridor_nodes": 1051, "corridor_branch_probes": 1194, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 428, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 26, "corridor_plies_followed": 1034, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1034, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 70, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 428, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 70, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 472, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 146480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 96268, "avg_nodes": 8022.333333333333, "eval_calls": 91028, "avg_eval_calls": 7585.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 91028, "pattern_eval_ns": 1969717, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.63858373247792, "pattern_frame_queries": 91028, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1969717, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.63858373247792, "pattern_frame_updates": 189090, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2436020405, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12882.862155587287, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3529, "avg_candidate_generations": 294.0833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 282661, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.09662793992632, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 860, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 3517, "search_candidate_moves_total": 281801, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 84729, "avg_legality_checks": 7060.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 41, "root_legality_checks": 860, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 83869, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 41, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 908026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 75668.83333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2150072364, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2367.8533037600246, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18155, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1512.9166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 151368723, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8337.577692095841, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 427325, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17365, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 143920876, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 212, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2659735, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 528, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4360787, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3024, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 252.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 33370999, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11035.383267195768, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4263, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 355.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 18413066, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4319.27422003284, "stage_move_gen_ns": 207225441, "stage_ordering_ns": 128250, "stage_eval_ns": 2437990122, "stage_threat_ns": 1489064507, "stage_proof_ns": 257362339, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 191310, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1110281975, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64239, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 209219912, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 735, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 44872113, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 95649, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 132348666, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2208, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13974366, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 191298, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23239588, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 423, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2973, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6104.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6771.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1813, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8572, "avg_search_time_ms": 779.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 66251, "safety_nodes": 846, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67097, "avg_nodes": 6099.727272727273, "eval_calls": 44620, "avg_eval_calls": 4056.3636363636365, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44620, "pattern_eval_ns": 997314, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.351277454056476, "pattern_frame_queries": 44620, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 997314, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.351277454056476, "pattern_frame_updates": 132402, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1408539492, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10638.355100376128, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20416, "avg_candidate_generations": 1856.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1604597, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.59507249216301, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 20405, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1603811, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1082574, "avg_legality_checks": 98415.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3615, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1082574, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3615, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2505574, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 227779.45454545456, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5579898457, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2226.9940768063525, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18485, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1680.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 136634678, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7391.651501217203, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3689, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 42730950, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6189, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64645535, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8602, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29191263, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 66930, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89209, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8109.909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 932100784, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10448.506137273145, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 125669, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11424.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 449500813, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3576.863132514781, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2789447356, "stage_ordering_ns": 696054843, "stage_eval_ns": 1409536806, "stage_threat_ns": 3621790717, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 309977, "root_tactical_annotations": 1296, "search_tactical_annotations": 308681, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 132413, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 812439118, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 278788, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2682177481, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40882, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1496354974, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66201, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 100197500, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 132402, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17065300, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 73687, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 387469498, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 164211, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 798219896, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 72079, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9911318, "child_limit_applications": 20405, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20405, "child_cap_hits": 20405, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20405, "child_moves_before_total": 1600196, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1600196, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 326544, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 326544, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.42175937270277, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.003136486155356, "tt_hits": 7970, "tt_cutoffs": 1176, "beta_cutoffs": 17492, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4557.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5284.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1843, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1261, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21031, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 124, 82, 114, 98, 140, 84, 70, 85, 138, 152, 141, 139, 83, 97, 67, 99, 71, 129, 145, 125, 153, 128, 127, 143, 158, 101, 100, 115, 157, 87 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 14104, "avg_search_time_ms": 829.6470588235294, "search_nodes": 151383, "safety_nodes": 363, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 151746, "avg_nodes": 8926.235294117647, "eval_calls": 103650, "avg_eval_calls": 6097.058823529412, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 103650, "pattern_eval_ns": 2290332, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.096787264833573, "pattern_frame_queries": 103650, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2290332, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.096787264833573, "pattern_frame_updates": 302612, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3617909143, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11955.603687229852, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44992, "avg_candidate_generations": 2646.5882352941176, "candidate_moves_total": 3990302, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.68914473684211, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1329, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 44975, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3988973, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 949444, "avg_legality_checks": 55849.64705882353, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2085, "root_legality_checks": 1329, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 948115, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2084, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3537353, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 208079.58823529413, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7922082650, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2239.55105696265, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34137, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2008.0588235294117, "renju_forbidden_ns": 210547543, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6167.72250051264, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2267, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23705077, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14795, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 122889971, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17070, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 63890595, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61900, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 80839, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4755.235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 764640161, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9458.802817946784, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109725, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6454.411764705882, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 336302230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3064.955388471178, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2353721179, "stage_ordering_ns": 1579936591, "stage_eval_ns": 3620199475, "stage_threat_ns": 6485753697, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 850970, "root_tactical_annotations": 4740, "search_tactical_annotations": 846230, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 302629, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1806942612, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 728035, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4383860474, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90060, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3132491385, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 151306, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 228882487, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 302612, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39153245, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 312558, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 218846785, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 325403, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1032405704, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 213009, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26914879, "child_limit_applications": 44975, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44975, "child_cap_hits": 44975, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44975, "child_moves_before_total": 3986889, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3986889, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 722292, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 722292, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.64678154530294, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.059855475264037, "tt_hits": 22178, "tt_cutoffs": 2681, "beta_cutoffs": 38306, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5802.764705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6273.35294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 899, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 6912, "avg_search_time_ms": 432.0, "search_nodes": 192642, "safety_nodes": 1728, "corridor_nodes": 1598, "corridor_branch_probes": 1863, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 37, "corridor_depth_exits": 609, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 38, "corridor_plies_followed": 1578, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1573, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 74, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 43, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 609, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 38, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 74, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 73, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 386, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 251400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 195968, "avg_nodes": 12248.0, "eval_calls": 188022, "avg_eval_calls": 11751.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 188022, "pattern_eval_ns": 4074239, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.668948314558936, "pattern_frame_queries": 188022, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4074239, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.668948314558936, "pattern_frame_updates": 385190, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3935708859, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10217.577971909966, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4589, "avg_candidate_generations": 286.8125, "candidate_moves_total": 360934, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.65199389845282, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1247, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 4573, "search_candidate_moves_total": 359687, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 8582, "avg_legality_checks": 536.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8582, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1015953, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 63497.0625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2475905918, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2437.028010154013, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15726, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 982.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 157075159, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9988.246152867861, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 66950, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15601, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 155897636, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 93, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 824663, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 285910, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 24, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 208931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8705.458333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.9375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 91340, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2946.451612903226, "stage_move_gen_ns": 24688815, "stage_ordering_ns": 150301, "stage_eval_ns": 3939783098, "stage_threat_ns": 2798898122, "stage_proof_ns": 118204852, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 388510, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2334292172, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 94919, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 116228733, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 981, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 39982688, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 194247, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 276793768, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3304, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21836939, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 388494, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49746510, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 150, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4136, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6066.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6566.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1952, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1262, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24657, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 114, 111, 126, 98, 154, 97, 115, 116, 99, 95, 94, 127, 79, 143, 159, 144, 140, 168, 145, 130, 158, 129, 64, 128, 109, 131 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7597, "avg_search_time_ms": 584.3846153846154, "search_nodes": 163025, "safety_nodes": 1090, "corridor_nodes": 1664, "corridor_branch_probes": 2061, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 628, "corridor_neutral_exits": 19, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1644, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1644, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 89, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 628, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 89, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 89, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 606, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 198000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 165779, "avg_nodes": 12752.23076923077, "eval_calls": 158354, "avg_eval_calls": 12181.076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 158354, "pattern_eval_ns": 3427558, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.64490950654862, "pattern_frame_queries": 158354, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3427558, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.64490950654862, "pattern_frame_updates": 325974, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4178677440, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12819.051335382577, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4646, "avg_candidate_generations": 357.38461538461536, "candidate_moves_total": 346616, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.60525182953079, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 956, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 4633, "search_candidate_moves_total": 345660, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 148717, "avg_legality_checks": 11439.76923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 219, "root_legality_checks": 956, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 147761, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 216, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1444145, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 111088.07692307692, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3510025041, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2430.521201818377, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17643, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1357.1538461538462, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124421286, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7052.161537153545, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 273, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2147967, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14376, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 114455259, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 769, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1753884, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2225, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6064176, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3813, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 293.3076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 39683486, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10407.418305795962, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5345, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 411.15384615384613, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 21119150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3951.197380729654, "stage_move_gen_ns": 394812666, "stage_ordering_ns": 159082, "stage_eval_ns": 4182104998, "stage_threat_ns": 2639514672, "stage_proof_ns": 356057303, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 329453, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2002294360, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 102646, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 331086137, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1045, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 65122096, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 164720, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 239238680, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3466, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24559027, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 329440, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42336468, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 258, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4147, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5498.538461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6113.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1735, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 17046, "avg_search_time_ms": 1311.2307692307693, "search_nodes": 139162, "safety_nodes": 524, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 139686, "avg_nodes": 10745.076923076924, "eval_calls": 102058, "avg_eval_calls": 7850.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 102058, "pattern_eval_ns": 2260394, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.148131454663034, "pattern_frame_queries": 102058, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2260394, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.148131454663034, "pattern_frame_updates": 278206, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2876528265, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10339.562284781781, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34838, "avg_candidate_generations": 2679.846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 3151275, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.45510649291005, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 992, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 34825, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3150283, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 2240687, "avg_legality_checks": 172360.53846153847, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5327, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2240687, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5327, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5219807, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 401523.6153846154, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11062414033, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2119.3147625956285, "renju_forbidden_checks": 57141, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4395.461538461538, "renju_forbidden_ns": 188284711, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3295.0895329098194, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5847, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 58084335, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9135, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62019403, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 42132, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 67936902, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 244071, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 210319, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16178.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2223611677, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10572.566800907194, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 306641, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23587.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1129923058, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3684.8401159662276, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5562382964, "stage_ordering_ns": 1330331684, "stage_eval_ns": 2878788659, "stage_threat_ns": 7180874710, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 669049, "root_tactical_annotations": 3074, "search_tactical_annotations": 665975, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 278219, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1692441780, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 595333, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5218547642, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69734, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2526996775, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 139103, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 213434243, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 278206, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35735997, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 235378, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1235748969, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 290211, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1455698417, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 143460, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20715048, "child_limit_applications": 34825, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34825, "child_cap_hits": 34825, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34825, "child_moves_before_total": 3144956, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3144956, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 557686, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 557686, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.30742282842786, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.013955491744436, "tt_hits": 15024, "tt_cutoffs": 2220, "beta_cutoffs": 28161, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4616.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5232.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1874, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1263, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 61464, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 82, 97, 98, 95, 84, 126, 81, 83, 111, 94, 93, 110, 142, 80, 125, 66, 157, 172, 108, 65, 50, 64, 63, 78, 62, 109, 79, 70, 52, 48, 32, 68, 67, 69, 47, 55, 41, 77, 53, 51, 39, 25, 40, 42, 143, 100, 72, 124, 115, 138, 152, 139, 154, 129, 56, 24, 159, 175, 31, 15, 17, 2, 88, 104, 141, 140, 145, 144, 173, 189, 131, 187, 117 ], "move_count": 77, "black_stats": { "move_count": 39, "search_move_count": 37, "total_time_ms": 44092, "avg_search_time_ms": 1191.6756756756756, "search_nodes": 550265, "safety_nodes": 1960, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 552225, "avg_nodes": 14925.0, "eval_calls": 421079, "avg_eval_calls": 11380.513513513513, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 421079, "pattern_eval_ns": 9176629, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.793129080291347, "pattern_frame_queries": 421079, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 9176629, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.793129080291347, "pattern_frame_updates": 1100176, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 12591795723, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11445.255779984293, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 122283, "avg_candidate_generations": 3304.945945945946, "candidate_moves_total": 13177452, "avg_candidate_moves": 107.76192929515959, "candidate_moves_max": 142, "root_candidate_generations": 37, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3525, "root_candidate_moves_max": 127, "search_candidate_generations": 122246, "search_candidate_moves_total": 13173927, "search_candidate_moves_max": 142, "legality_checks": 4107222, "avg_legality_checks": 111006.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15561, "root_legality_checks": 3525, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "search_legality_checks": 4103697, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15544, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13196366, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 356658.54054054053, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25114667921, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1903.150300696419, "renju_forbidden_checks": 401067, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10839.648648648648, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1000821393, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2495.397010973229, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21612, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 46047503, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 161885, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 597691186, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 217477, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 356886464, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 93, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 196240, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 468548, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12663.45945945946, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3960059782, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8451.769684215918, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 658832, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17806.27027027027, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1913988641, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2905.1239784952763, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8974334063, "stage_ordering_ns": 3912897031, "stage_eval_ns": 12600972352, "stage_threat_ns": 18374456221, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2962022, "root_tactical_annotations": 10178, "search_tactical_annotations": 2951844, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1100213, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5867396163, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2732607, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11509020424, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 244742, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5998339219, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 550088, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 798271728, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1100176, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 129564412, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1421641, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1897785185, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1066196, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3612372169, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 474185, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 70203494, "child_limit_applications": 122246, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 122246, "child_cap_hits": 122246, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 122246, "child_moves_before_total": 13158383, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 13158383, "child_moves_before_max": 142, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 142, "child_moves_after_total": 2027852, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 2027852, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 107.6385566807912, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.588289187376272, "tt_hits": 51496, "tt_cutoffs": 6765, "beta_cutoffs": 98751, "depth_sum": 171, "avg_depth": 4.621621621621622, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 171, "avg_effective_depth": 4.621621621621622, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 29 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16216216216216217, "pooled_budget_moves": 37, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16216216216216217, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16216216216216217, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5304.918918918919, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5445.945945945946, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 38, "search_move_count": 36, "total_time_ms": 17334, "avg_search_time_ms": 481.5, "search_nodes": 654453, "safety_nodes": 3526, "corridor_nodes": 7588, "corridor_branch_probes": 8374, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2850, "corridor_neutral_exits": 189, "corridor_terminal_exits": 115, "corridor_plies_followed": 7521, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 7516, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 34, "corridor_proof_completed": 34, "corridor_proof_checks": 276, "corridor_proof_active": 67, "corridor_proof_quiet": 209, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 189, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2850, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 115, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 276, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 275, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1966, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 657360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 665567, "avg_nodes": 18487.972222222223, "eval_calls": 635195, "avg_eval_calls": 17644.305555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 635195, "pattern_eval_ns": 13716635, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.59436865844347, "pattern_frame_queries": 635195, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 13716635, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.59436865844347, "pattern_frame_updates": 1308692, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8677669724, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6630.796034513851, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19187, "avg_candidate_generations": 532.9722222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 1943018, "avg_candidate_moves": 101.26742064939803, "candidate_moves_max": 139, "root_candidate_generations": 36, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3446, "root_candidate_moves_max": 126, "search_candidate_generations": 19151, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1939572, "search_candidate_moves_max": 139, "legality_checks": 40325, "avg_legality_checks": 1120.138888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 91, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 40325, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 91, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3094750, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 85965.27777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5909827169, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1909.6299116245254, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41389, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1149.6944444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 67048158, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1619.9511464398754, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 91, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 110600, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 40972, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 66016867, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 65, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 473250, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 261, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 447441, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 61, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.6944444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 631193, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10347.426229508197, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.7777777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 387713, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3877.13, "stage_move_gen_ns": 98254949, "stage_ordering_ns": 680312, "stage_eval_ns": 8691386359, "stage_threat_ns": 7971769203, "stage_proof_ns": 391579467, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1324322, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6437137269, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 438101, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 448755110, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 5431, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 204044128, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 662143, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 831071017, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 15594, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 109634820, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1324286, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 145170987, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1209, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 17164, "depth_sum": 106, "avg_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 106, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9444444444444446, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 34 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.027777777777777776, "pooled_budget_moves": 36, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.027777777777777776, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.027777777777777776, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7308.805555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7531.027777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1940, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1264, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26903, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 142, 97, 98, 126, 70, 111, 157, 172, 141, 81, 66, 113, 65, 129, 145, 144, 84, 56, 159, 158, 130, 143, 64, 128, 67, 173 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 9361, "avg_search_time_ms": 720.0769230769231, "search_nodes": 224036, "safety_nodes": 1090, "corridor_nodes": 1964, "corridor_branch_probes": 2392, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 746, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_plies_followed": 1943, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1943, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 89, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 68, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 746, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 89, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 89, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 606, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 206400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 227090, "avg_nodes": 17468.46153846154, "eval_calls": 218879, "avg_eval_calls": 16836.846153846152, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 218879, "pattern_eval_ns": 4434453, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.25983762718214, "pattern_frame_queries": 218879, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4434453, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.25983762718214, "pattern_frame_updates": 447996, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5236446962, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11688.602045553978, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5132, "avg_candidate_generations": 394.7692307692308, "candidate_moves_total": 378292, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.71239282930631, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 956, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 5119, "search_candidate_moves_total": 377336, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 203339, "avg_legality_checks": 15641.461538461539, "illegal_moves_skipped": 92, "root_legality_checks": 956, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 202383, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 89, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1888190, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 145245.38461538462, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4248554259, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2250.067132544924, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24688, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1899.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 145162880, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5879.896305897602, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 142, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 897525, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20743, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 135312012, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 892, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1938532, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2911, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7014811, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4707, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 362.0769230769231, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 46510404, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9881.114085404717, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6655, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 511.9230769230769, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 24858553, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3735.3197595792635, "stage_move_gen_ns": 489652132, "stage_ordering_ns": 181470, "stage_eval_ns": 5240881415, "stage_threat_ns": 3237888291, "stage_proof_ns": 366641684, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 452073, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2494518971, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 119484, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 363258996, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1165, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 69604701, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 226030, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 299733640, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4064, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 27285613, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 452060, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53091071, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 258, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4573, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4848.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5463.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 632, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 17529, "avg_search_time_ms": 1348.3846153846155, "search_nodes": 148016, "safety_nodes": 524, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148540, "avg_nodes": 11426.153846153846, "eval_calls": 107849, "avg_eval_calls": 8296.076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107849, "pattern_eval_ns": 2300275, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.328663223581117, "pattern_frame_queries": 107849, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2300275, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.328663223581117, "pattern_frame_updates": 295914, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2770847270, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9363.69103861257, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37826, "avg_candidate_generations": 2909.6923076923076, "candidate_moves_total": 3436403, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.84764447734362, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 992, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 37813, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3435411, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 2492671, "avg_legality_checks": 191743.92307692306, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6363, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2492671, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5726864, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 440528.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11411353247, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1992.600705551939, "renju_forbidden_checks": 78101, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6007.7692307692305, "renju_forbidden_ns": 227824878, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2917.0545575600822, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7469, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 70970026, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10626, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 63627988, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 59979, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 92993254, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 233610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 246138, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18933.69230769231, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2496245189, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10141.64894896359, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 355310, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27331.53846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1287287942, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3622.9994708845798, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5888974448, "stage_ordering_ns": 1333251929, "stage_eval_ns": 2773147545, "stage_threat_ns": 7431029932, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 720019, "root_tactical_annotations": 3074, "search_tactical_annotations": 716945, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 295927, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1689829111, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 657277, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5472524368, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75710, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2494304295, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147957, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 210758864, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 295914, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35667874, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 272540, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1472073817, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 309017, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1506048826, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 138462, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22249715, "child_limit_applications": 37813, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37813, "child_cap_hits": 37813, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37813, "child_moves_before_total": 3429048, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3429048, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 605559, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 605559, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.68436781001243, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.014571708142704, "tt_hits": 15677, "tt_cutoffs": 2295, "beta_cutoffs": 30769, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4289.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4904.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1854, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1265, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12745, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 67, 82, 96, 98, 66, 113, 143, 114, 68, 65, 81, 51, 95, 130, 146, 53, 111, 126, 127, 79, 159 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10109, "avg_search_time_ms": 919.0, "search_nodes": 121581, "safety_nodes": 260, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 121841, "avg_nodes": 11076.454545454546, "eval_calls": 92530, "avg_eval_calls": 8411.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 92530, "pattern_eval_ns": 1926044, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.815346374148923, "pattern_frame_queries": 92530, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1926044, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.815346374148923, "pattern_frame_updates": 243068, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2862018678, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11774.55970345747, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27405, "avg_candidate_generations": 2491.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 2045439, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.63743842364532, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 713, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 27394, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2044726, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 847840, "avg_legality_checks": 77076.36363636363, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1474, "root_legality_checks": 713, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 847127, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1474, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2747670, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 249788.18181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5968152798, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2172.077723307384, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26457, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2405.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 137980731, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5215.2825717201495, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1587, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14027866, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13302, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 90792148, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11568, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 33160717, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68813, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6255.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 566803912, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8236.872567683431, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 90805, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8255.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 223202998, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2458.047442321458, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2056291106, "stage_ordering_ns": 818898352, "stage_eval_ns": 2863944722, "stage_threat_ns": 4320927423, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 381050, "root_tactical_annotations": 2225, "search_tactical_annotations": 378825, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 243079, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1377239427, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 350320, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2734047318, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54856, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1886981876, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121534, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 168733154, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 243068, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28953743, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 100891, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 102965403, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 194564, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 743972878, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 85595, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11953781, "child_limit_applications": 27394, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27394, "child_cap_hits": 27394, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27394, "child_moves_before_total": 2043252, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2043252, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 440447, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 440447, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.58757392129664, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0782288092283, "tt_hits": 10424, "tt_cutoffs": 1611, "beta_cutoffs": 21465, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3850.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4578.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2625, "avg_search_time_ms": 262.5, "search_nodes": 75880, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 674, "corridor_branch_probes": 805, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 254, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 664, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 659, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 254, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 448, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 216400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 77351, "avg_nodes": 7735.1, "eval_calls": 73292, "avg_eval_calls": 7329.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73292, "pattern_eval_ns": 1503389, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.512320580690936, "pattern_frame_queries": 73292, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1503389, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.512320580690936, "pattern_frame_updates": 151702, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1447988167, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9544.951068542274, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2569, "avg_candidate_generations": 256.9, "candidate_moves_total": 182041, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.86064616582328, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 648, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 2559, "search_candidate_moves_total": 181393, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 4779, "avg_legality_checks": 477.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4779, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 461487, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 46148.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1031857595, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2235.9407632284333, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3350, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 335.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30775033, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9186.577014925373, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3310, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30466393, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 33, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 300270, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8370, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 319421, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7428.395348837209, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 53, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 114280, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2156.2264150943397, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12413134, "stage_ordering_ns": 92180, "stage_eval_ns": 1449491556, "stage_threat_ns": 1036227554, "stage_proof_ns": 109881258, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 153172, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 857216003, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43649, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 52132170, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 546, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17640500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76581, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 100951171, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1460, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7987137, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 153162, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17941073, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 184, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2255, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5712.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6512.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1943, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1266, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23135, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 126, 98, 154, 143, 113, 111, 52, 67, 95, 129, 140, 168, 81, 157, 115, 159, 175, 114, 65, 49, 144, 142, 156, 131, 130, 187, 145, 172 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 7454, "avg_search_time_ms": 496.93333333333334, "search_nodes": 188454, "safety_nodes": 1382, "corridor_nodes": 437, "corridor_branch_probes": 475, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 113, "corridor_neutral_exits": 34, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 421, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 421, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 97, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 81, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 113, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 97, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 97, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 639, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 185040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 190273, "avg_nodes": 12684.866666666667, "eval_calls": 183261, "avg_eval_calls": 12217.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 183261, "pattern_eval_ns": 3730594, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.356726199245884, "pattern_frame_queries": 183261, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3730594, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.356726199245884, "pattern_frame_updates": 376820, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4389710026, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11649.355198768642, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5164, "avg_candidate_generations": 344.26666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 439849, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.1760263361735, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1218, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 5149, "search_candidate_moves_total": 438631, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 163639, "avg_legality_checks": 10909.266666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 1218, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 162421, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1542087, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 102805.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3466957656, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2248.2244231356594, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8671, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 578.0666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 75517191, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8709.167454734172, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33200, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8647, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 75318510, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 85561, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 79920, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 644, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 42.93333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 6058881, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9408.200310559007, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56.53333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3115450, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3673.879716981132, "stage_move_gen_ns": 385496059, "stage_ordering_ns": 176500, "stage_eval_ns": 4393440620, "stage_threat_ns": 2408547260, "stage_proof_ns": 228751152, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 377871, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2023022186, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 33813, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 95754282, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 660, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 26459795, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 188928, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 240007397, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1036, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6080291, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 377856, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43683104, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 295, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4665, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6311.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6845.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1781, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 15669, "avg_search_time_ms": 1044.6, "search_nodes": 151660, "safety_nodes": 458, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 152118, "avg_nodes": 10141.2, "eval_calls": 110083, "avg_eval_calls": 7338.866666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110083, "pattern_eval_ns": 2244883, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.392640098834516, "pattern_frame_queries": 110083, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2244883, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.392640098834516, "pattern_frame_updates": 303186, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2439873215, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8047.446831318069, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39259, "avg_candidate_generations": 2617.266666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 3805945, "avg_candidate_moves": 96.9445222751471, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1253, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 39244, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3804692, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 2658741, "avg_legality_checks": 177249.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 69, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2658741, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 69, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5181045, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 345403.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10204894833, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1969.6595634664436, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9545, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 636.3333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14476099, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1516.6159245678366, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 69, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 589790, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1266, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9628002, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8200, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4208817, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 49490, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 137734, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9182.266666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1186599225, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8615.151124631537, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 187307, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12487.133333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 538518692, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2875.0590848179727, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5855288671, "stage_ordering_ns": 1358790133, "stage_eval_ns": 2442118098, "stage_threat_ns": 5901109358, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 752063, "root_tactical_annotations": 3808, "search_tactical_annotations": 748255, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 303201, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1612746302, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 654267, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4023619778, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 78584, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2382258898, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 151593, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 203989471, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 303186, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34425551, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 259888, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 592248333, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 315784, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1049055637, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 176391, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26328256, "child_limit_applications": 39244, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39244, "child_cap_hits": 39244, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39244, "child_moves_before_total": 3804623, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3804623, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 628461, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 628461, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 96.94789012333095, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.014193252471717, "tt_hits": 18003, "tt_cutoffs": 2266, "beta_cutoffs": 32077, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5829.266666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6362.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1847, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1267, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13728, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 96, 94, 142, 114, 128, 80, 144, 160, 145, 78, 62, 81, 79, 143, 127, 157, 129, 161, 99, 85, 95, 63, 98, 97, 83, 68, 131, 130, 115, 67, 147 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 11537, "avg_search_time_ms": 678.6470588235294, "search_nodes": 156925, "safety_nodes": 363, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 157288, "avg_nodes": 9252.235294117647, "eval_calls": 107258, "avg_eval_calls": 6309.294117647059, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107258, "pattern_eval_ns": 2141692, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.96766674746872, "pattern_frame_queries": 107258, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2141692, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.96766674746872, "pattern_frame_updates": 313696, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2913039822, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9286.187334234419, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46923, "avg_candidate_generations": 2760.176470588235, "candidate_moves_total": 4156545, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.58225177418323, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1329, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 46906, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4155216, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 938889, "avg_legality_checks": 55228.76470588235, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1943, "root_legality_checks": 1329, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 937560, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1942, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3477550, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 204561.76470588235, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6285580070, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1807.473672556829, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31210, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1835.8823529411766, "renju_forbidden_ns": 173746165, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5567.003043896187, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2092, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19537012, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13236, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 99117838, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15877, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 55035485, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55830, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76830, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4519.411764705882, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 576881449, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7508.544175452297, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 104885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6169.705882352941, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 255837091, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2439.2152452686278, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1820783295, "stage_ordering_ns": 1391914649, "stage_eval_ns": 2915181514, "stage_threat_ns": 5342429209, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 847515, "root_tactical_annotations": 4740, "search_tactical_annotations": 842775, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 313713, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1482569547, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 744245, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3610338271, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 93922, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2609709944, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 156848, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 193180568, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 313696, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33002752, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 326872, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 194320109, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 323437, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 806239917, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 197206, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23338071, "child_limit_applications": 46906, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46906, "child_cap_hits": 46906, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46906, "child_moves_before_total": 4153274, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4153274, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 752914, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 752914, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.54462115720803, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.051549908327292, "tt_hits": 22204, "tt_cutoffs": 2684, "beta_cutoffs": 39964, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6315.64705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6786.235294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1438, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 2176, "avg_search_time_ms": 136.0, "search_nodes": 81732, "safety_nodes": 1728, "corridor_nodes": 1542, "corridor_branch_probes": 1815, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 53, "corridor_depth_exits": 641, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1522, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1517, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 74, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 62, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 641, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 74, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 73, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 386, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 254440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85002, "avg_nodes": 5312.625, "eval_calls": 78231, "avg_eval_calls": 4889.4375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 78231, "pattern_eval_ns": 1533950, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.607955925400418, "pattern_frame_queries": 78231, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1533950, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.607955925400418, "pattern_frame_updates": 163370, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1047355608, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6410.942082389668, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3470, "avg_candidate_generations": 216.875, "candidate_moves_total": 279918, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.66801152737752, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1247, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 3454, "search_candidate_moves_total": 278671, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 7797, "avg_legality_checks": 487.3125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7797, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 389603, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 24350.1875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 721863624, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1852.8184433898095, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2908, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 181.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21108614, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7258.808115543328, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 58180, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2806, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20224411, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 561723, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 264300, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 24, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 194540, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8105.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1.9375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 86420, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2787.7419354838707, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17804272, "stage_ordering_ns": 105280, "stage_eval_ns": 1048889558, "stage_threat_ns": 995930963, "stage_proof_ns": 84420123, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 166578, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 769503465, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 85357, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 95428080, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 931, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 30061862, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 83281, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94657471, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3192, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19950344, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 166562, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16391603, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 150, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3149, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6659.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7159.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1268, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24910, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 128, 64, 127, 115, 116, 129, 125, 124, 97, 139, 83, 69, 84, 80, 48, 85, 100, 68, 99, 154, 98, 109, 101 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7389, "avg_search_time_ms": 568.3846153846154, "search_nodes": 175435, "safety_nodes": 1090, "corridor_nodes": 1553, "corridor_branch_probes": 1920, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 583, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_plies_followed": 1533, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1533, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 89, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 583, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 89, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 89, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 606, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 218720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 178078, "avg_nodes": 13698.307692307691, "eval_calls": 170389, "avg_eval_calls": 13106.846153846154, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 170389, "pattern_eval_ns": 3539589, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.773576932783218, "pattern_frame_queries": 170389, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3539589, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.773576932783218, "pattern_frame_updates": 350794, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4052642749, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11552.770996653306, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5021, "avg_candidate_generations": 386.2307692307692, "candidate_moves_total": 367384, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.16948814977096, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 956, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 5008, "search_candidate_moves_total": 366428, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 157761, "avg_legality_checks": 12135.461538461539, "illegal_moves_skipped": 151, "root_legality_checks": 956, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 156805, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 148, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1463700, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 112592.30769230769, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3350941206, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2289.3633982373435, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20841, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1603.1538461538462, "renju_forbidden_ns": 125392332, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6016.617820642004, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 229, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1587420, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18940, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 119269584, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 611, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1273382, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1061, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3261946, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3453, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 265.61538461538464, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 34143479, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9888.062264697364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4858, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 373.6923076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 18627025, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3834.2990942774804, "stage_move_gen_ns": 388885326, "stage_ordering_ns": 169501, "stage_eval_ns": 4056182338, "stage_threat_ns": 2593687765, "stage_proof_ns": 324822367, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 354051, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1999772255, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 95602, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 289607311, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1008, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 58287618, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 177019, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 237628291, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3244, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21175571, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 354038, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45504337, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 258, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4513, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5299.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5914.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1651, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 17508, "avg_search_time_ms": 1346.7692307692307, "search_nodes": 147718, "safety_nodes": 524, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148242, "avg_nodes": 11403.23076923077, "eval_calls": 107449, "avg_eval_calls": 8265.307692307691, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107449, "pattern_eval_ns": 2275218, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.174864354251785, "pattern_frame_queries": 107449, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2275218, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.174864354251785, "pattern_frame_updates": 295318, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2769985140, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9379.669170182651, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37899, "avg_candidate_generations": 2915.3076923076924, "candidate_moves_total": 3423081, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.32114303807488, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 992, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 37886, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3422089, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 2489300, "avg_legality_checks": 191484.61538461538, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2200, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2489300, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2200, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5779524, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 444578.76923076925, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11428377361, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1977.3907610730573, "renju_forbidden_checks": 91617, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7047.461538461538, "renju_forbidden_ns": 190007659, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2073.9345208858617, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3256, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26861538, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8461, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 39267715, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 79873, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 123640556, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 237850, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 254486, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19575.846153846152, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2613920777, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10271.37358047201, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 371467, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 28574.384615384617, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1360387992, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3662.204158108257, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5821394513, "stage_ordering_ns": 1326282555, "stage_eval_ns": 2772260358, "stage_threat_ns": 7491950086, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 730966, "root_tactical_annotations": 3074, "search_tactical_annotations": 727892, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 295331, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1693330834, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 665601, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5526651922, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75856, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2432448704, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147659, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 211841000, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 295318, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38147378, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 279195, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1524183943, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 310540, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1569918605, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 141231, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21978952, "child_limit_applications": 37886, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37886, "child_cap_hits": 37886, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37886, "child_moves_before_total": 3419889, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3419889, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 607939, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 607939, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.26788259515388, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.04653433986169, "tt_hits": 15728, "tt_cutoffs": 2324, "beta_cutoffs": 30875, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4292.538461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4907.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1858, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1269, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9746, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 83, 144, 96, 95, 99, 127, 68, 53, 100, 97, 101, 102, 143, 67, 82, 81, 109, 39 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8067, "avg_search_time_ms": 733.3636363636364, "search_nodes": 94448, "safety_nodes": 288, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 94736, "avg_nodes": 8612.363636363636, "eval_calls": 72140, "avg_eval_calls": 6558.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72140, "pattern_eval_ns": 1503886, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.846770169115608, "pattern_frame_queries": 72140, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1503886, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.846770169115608, "pattern_frame_updates": 188802, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2117807816, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11217.083590216205, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21403, "avg_candidate_generations": 1945.7272727272727, "candidate_moves_total": 1637081, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.48838947811055, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 716, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 21392, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1636365, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 629551, "avg_legality_checks": 57231.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3899, "root_legality_checks": 716, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 628835, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2191059, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 199187.18181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4692280553, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2141.5582843729903, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23250, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2113.6363636363635, "renju_forbidden_ns": 140007736, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6021.838107526882, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3949, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 40883034, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10106, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 76765092, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9145, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21874700, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 484910, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74084, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6734.909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 652728772, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8810.657793855624, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98905, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8991.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 282145846, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2852.6954754562457, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1565257051, "stage_ordering_ns": 682431093, "stage_eval_ns": 2119311702, "stage_threat_ns": 3663925620, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 272745, "root_tactical_annotations": 1806, "search_tactical_annotations": 270939, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 188813, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1087639208, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 258550, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2411144917, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42852, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1544865360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 94401, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 133711402, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 188802, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23119331, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70875, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 180532863, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 144816, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 685738164, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 57054, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8310762, "child_limit_applications": 21392, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21392, "child_cap_hits": 21392, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21392, "child_moves_before_total": 1632476, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1632476, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 342814, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 342814, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.31245325355273, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.025336574420344, "tt_hits": 8499, "tt_cutoffs": 869, "beta_cutoffs": 16707, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4715.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5442.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 932, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 1668, "avg_search_time_ms": 166.8, "search_nodes": 47429, "safety_nodes": 915, "corridor_nodes": 905, "corridor_branch_probes": 1049, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 413, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 894, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 889, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 413, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 330, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 89680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49249, "avg_nodes": 4924.9, "eval_calls": 44922, "avg_eval_calls": 4492.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44922, "pattern_eval_ns": 922813, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.542562664173456, "pattern_frame_queries": 44922, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 922813, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.542562664173456, "pattern_frame_updates": 94800, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 845016450, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8913.675632911392, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2488, "avg_candidate_generations": 248.8, "candidate_moves_total": 175176, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.40836012861736, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 650, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 2478, "search_candidate_moves_total": 174526, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 5079, "avg_legality_checks": 507.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5079, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 263818, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26381.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 595841447, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2258.532196438454, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3898, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 389.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33891220, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8694.515135967162, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 233891, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3690, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32171946, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 81, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 437743, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 103, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1047640, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 326502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8592.157894736842, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 48, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 148311, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3089.8125, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14202923, "stage_ordering_ns": 82140, "stage_eval_ns": 845939263, "stage_threat_ns": 702018739, "stage_proof_ns": 88702985, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 96708, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 556924765, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 50408, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 57869000, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 565, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20287822, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48349, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 64455520, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1898, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11281034, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 96698, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11488420, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 131, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2215, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5820.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6620.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1955, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1270, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21496, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 96, 160, 97, 108, 109, 95, 129, 145, 127, 130, 99, 100, 115, 144, 176, 85, 143, 157, 83, 67, 53, 68, 81, 175, 65 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 9073, "avg_search_time_ms": 648.0714285714286, "search_nodes": 196070, "safety_nodes": 1182, "corridor_nodes": 3012, "corridor_branch_probes": 3646, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 1314, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 2982, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2982, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 98, "corridor_proof_active": 30, "corridor_proof_quiet": 68, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1314, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 98, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 98, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 638, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 254800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 200264, "avg_nodes": 14304.57142857143, "eval_calls": 190595, "avg_eval_calls": 13613.92857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 190595, "pattern_eval_ns": 3925761, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.59739762323251, "pattern_frame_queries": 190595, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3925761, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.59739762323251, "pattern_frame_updates": 392058, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4926948425, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12566.886595860817, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5448, "avg_candidate_generations": 389.14285714285717, "candidate_moves_total": 401084, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.62041116005874, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 989, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 5434, "search_candidate_moves_total": 400095, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 185472, "avg_legality_checks": 13248.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 174, "root_legality_checks": 989, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 184483, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 169, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1863430, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 133102.14285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4267239941, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2289.9920796595525, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19866, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1419.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 197390751, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9936.109483539716, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 176, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1728478, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19342, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 193755976, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 120, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 680291, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 228, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1226006, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 7598, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 542.7142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 75258550, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9905.047380889708, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11019, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 787.0714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 41775836, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3791.2547418096015, "stage_move_gen_ns": 461944928, "stage_ordering_ns": 178392, "stage_eval_ns": 4930874186, "stage_threat_ns": 3181414784, "stage_proof_ns": 475691514, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 398232, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2305223121, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 171175, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 514512558, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1522, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 99607181, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 199109, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 273761863, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6160, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 39343762, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 398218, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48573480, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 248, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4910, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5748.928571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6320.357142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1788, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 12408, "avg_search_time_ms": 886.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 93037, "safety_nodes": 540, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 93577, "avg_nodes": 6684.071428571428, "eval_calls": 62070, "avg_eval_calls": 4433.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62070, "pattern_eval_ns": 1328955, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.410584823586273, "pattern_frame_queries": 62070, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1328955, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.410584823586273, "pattern_frame_updates": 185950, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1753006264, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9427.299080397956, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29489, "avg_candidate_generations": 2106.3571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 2526871, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.6885957475669, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1025, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 29475, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2525846, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1913801, "avg_legality_checks": 136700.07142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6846, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1913801, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6846, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4077659, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 291261.35714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8279287219, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2030.4020564250222, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20942, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1495.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 119435589, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5703.160586381435, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6846, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 66723336, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3965, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 36770078, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10091, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15513424, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 428751, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 152657, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10904.07142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1481324530, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9703.613525747263, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 217788, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15556.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 749414890, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3441.0293037265596, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4499301954, "stage_ordering_ns": 999920491, "stage_eval_ns": 1754335219, "stage_threat_ns": 5073320501, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 544876, "root_tactical_annotations": 2684, "search_tactical_annotations": 542192, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 185964, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1077486310, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 493808, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3820744713, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59039, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1989232902, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92975, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 135623628, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 185950, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22922729, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 206890, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 788287063, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 227869, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1043128318, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110117, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16543121, "child_limit_applications": 29475, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29475, "child_cap_hits": 29475, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29475, "child_moves_before_total": 2519000, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2519000, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 472464, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 472464, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.46225614927906, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.029312977099238, "tt_hits": 12668, "tt_cutoffs": 1430, "beta_cutoffs": 25530, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5746.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6318.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1868, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1271, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16364, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 98, 143, 82, 97, 126, 84, 50, 66, 81, 140, 80, 79, 95, 65, 67, 109, 51, 94, 53, 39, 52, 49, 54 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9185, "avg_search_time_ms": 765.4166666666666, "search_nodes": 122291, "safety_nodes": 395, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122686, "avg_nodes": 10223.833333333334, "eval_calls": 83714, "avg_eval_calls": 6976.166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83714, "pattern_eval_ns": 1680283, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.07170843586497, "pattern_frame_queries": 83714, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1680283, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.07170843586497, "pattern_frame_updates": 244478, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2111833707, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8638.133930251393, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35846, "avg_candidate_generations": 2987.1666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2755252, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.86358310550689, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 779, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 35834, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2754473, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 906732, "avg_legality_checks": 75561.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 131, "root_legality_checks": 779, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 905953, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 131, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2883473, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 240289.41666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5370800665, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1862.6152091592326, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12974, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1081.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 35194058, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2712.6605518729766, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 145, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1128973, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3663, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 23759276, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9163, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10302459, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3350, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 61848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5154.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 490433905, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7929.6647425947485, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 82531, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6877.583333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 209557397, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2539.1355611830704, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1896804853, "stage_ordering_ns": 908052449, "stage_eval_ns": 2113513990, "stage_threat_ns": 4215179625, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 433390, "root_tactical_annotations": 2716, "search_tactical_annotations": 430674, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 244490, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1193669969, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 424482, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2835387500, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 71743, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2086292379, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 122239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 150522490, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 244478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25825150, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 130861, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 104346333, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 221867, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 644601148, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 80662, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9774516, "child_limit_applications": 35834, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35834, "child_cap_hits": 35834, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35834, "child_moves_before_total": 2754342, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2754342, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 573348, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 573348, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.86392811296534, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00011162583022, "tt_hits": 14799, "tt_cutoffs": 2691, "beta_cutoffs": 30391, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4649.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5316.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 701, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7168, "avg_search_time_ms": 651.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 287651, "safety_nodes": 913, "corridor_nodes": 963, "corridor_branch_probes": 1124, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 379, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 945, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 945, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 379, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 353, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 137840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 289527, "avg_nodes": 26320.636363636364, "eval_calls": 282701, "avg_eval_calls": 25700.090909090908, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 282701, "pattern_eval_ns": 5538180, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.59023844981093, "pattern_frame_queries": 282701, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5538180, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.59023844981093, "pattern_frame_updates": 575238, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4046484297, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7034.4523432040305, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4929, "avg_candidate_generations": 448.09090909090907, "candidate_moves_total": 382796, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.66200040576182, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 723, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 4918, "search_candidate_moves_total": 382073, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 9797, "avg_legality_checks": 890.6363636363636, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9797, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1431290, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 130117.27272727272, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2456776441, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1716.4770528683914, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3368, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 306.1818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21217503, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6299.733669833729, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3354, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21186543, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30960, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22374763, "stage_ordering_ns": 148880, "stage_eval_ns": 4052022477, "stage_threat_ns": 2968503801, "stage_proof_ns": 78613400, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 577261, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2543005269, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59493, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 50636015, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 688, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19868447, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 288625, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 309832377, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2012, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8158141, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 577250, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56871999, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 181, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4548, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5570.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6297.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1783, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1272, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8683, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 95, 114, 100, 156, 170, 143, 98, 158, 173, 99, 84, 126, 67, 82, 70, 56, 174, 141, 171, 172, 94, 96, 111, 144, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3418, "avg_search_time_ms": 244.14285714285714, "search_nodes": 74516, "safety_nodes": 1451, "corridor_nodes": 2861, "corridor_branch_probes": 3426, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1165, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 2826, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2806, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 20, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 88, "corridor_proof_active": 35, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1165, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 88, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 4, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 536, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 218720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 20400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 78828, "avg_nodes": 5630.571428571428, "eval_calls": 71293, "avg_eval_calls": 5092.357142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71293, "pattern_eval_ns": 1370630, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.22530963769234, "pattern_frame_queries": 71293, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1370630, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.22530963769234, "pattern_frame_updates": 148950, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1625969254, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10916.20848606915, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3196, "avg_candidate_generations": 228.28571428571428, "candidate_moves_total": 263070, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.31226533166458, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1051, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 3182, "search_candidate_moves_total": 262019, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 68683, "avg_legality_checks": 4905.928571428572, "illegal_moves_skipped": 323, "root_legality_checks": 1051, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 67632, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 317, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1088353, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 77739.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1858492287, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1707.6190234234664, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16919, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1208.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 97902511, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5786.542407943732, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 331, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1965449, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14910, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 88814759, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 426, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2208280, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1252, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4914023, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 8071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 576.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 67698137, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8387.825176558048, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10545, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 753.2142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 36368592, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3448.894452347084, "stage_move_gen_ns": 127460952, "stage_ordering_ns": 96670, "stage_eval_ns": 1627339884, "stage_threat_ns": 1272228625, "stage_proof_ns": 369374916, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 154792, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 683342061, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 171536, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 458607418, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1565, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 89353999, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77389, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 84296454, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5828, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 31517467, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 154778, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14465225, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 187, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2877, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6492.071428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7063.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1906, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 5252, "avg_search_time_ms": 375.14285714285717, "search_nodes": 56249, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 57222, "avg_nodes": 4087.285714285714, "eval_calls": 37435, "avg_eval_calls": 2673.9285714285716, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37435, "pattern_eval_ns": 726241, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.400053425938292, "pattern_frame_queries": 37435, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 726241, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.400053425938292, "pattern_frame_updates": 112374, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 834995213, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7430.501833164255, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17648, "avg_candidate_generations": 1260.5714285714287, "candidate_moves_total": 1511056, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.6219401631913, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1096, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 17634, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1509960, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1092459, "avg_legality_checks": 78032.78571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3552, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1092459, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3552, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2482005, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 177286.07142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3370959894, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1358.1599932312788, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58239, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4159.928571428572, "renju_forbidden_ns": 103192977, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1771.8878586514193, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5468, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 31387992, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7410, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24989197, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 45237, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 46369957, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 124, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 445831, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98813, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7058.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 692059333, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7003.72757633105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 130490, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9320.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 340873483, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2612.257513985746, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1730567218, "stage_ordering_ns": 402938517, "stage_eval_ns": 835721454, "stage_threat_ns": 2232053423, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 344895, "root_tactical_annotations": 1582, "search_tactical_annotations": 343313, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 112388, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 459302665, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 300873, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1695795327, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35357, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 831166867, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56187, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 58449526, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 112374, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10259064, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 107539, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 351356190, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 157968, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 513102858, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79388, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8246841, "child_limit_applications": 17634, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17634, "child_cap_hits": 17634, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17634, "child_moves_before_total": 1506408, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1506408, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 282947, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 282947, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.42633548826132, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.045537030736078, "tt_hits": 7768, "tt_cutoffs": 1118, "beta_cutoffs": 15272, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6151.357142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6722.785714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1911, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1273, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6897, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 99, 141, 109, 140, 95, 97, 139, 67, 124, 82, 52, 94, 123, 81, 155, 83, 69, 80, 84, 79 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 4549, "avg_search_time_ms": 379.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 90402, "safety_nodes": 900, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91302, "avg_nodes": 7608.5, "eval_calls": 67607, "avg_eval_calls": 5633.916666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67607, "pattern_eval_ns": 1236853, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.294747585309214, "pattern_frame_queries": 67607, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1236853, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.294747585309214, "pattern_frame_updates": 180700, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1204333241, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6664.821477587161, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21891, "avg_candidate_generations": 1824.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1640447, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.93705175642958, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 742, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 21879, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1639705, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 705127, "avg_legality_checks": 58760.583333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 731, "root_legality_checks": 742, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 704385, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 730, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2134572, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 177881.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2594350033, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1215.3958887308556, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11643, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 970.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31204831, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2680.136648630078, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 755, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3916226, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4470, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20505417, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6411, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6755248, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 27940, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54645, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4553.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 249625841, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4568.136901820843, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68623, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5718.583333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 98261681, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1431.9059353278055, "stage_move_gen_ns": 934453786, "stage_ordering_ns": 380527457, "stage_eval_ns": 1205570094, "stage_threat_ns": 1990505286, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 280629, "root_tactical_annotations": 1377, "search_tactical_annotations": 279252, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 180712, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 619448532, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 270674, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1266557372, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43833, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 891764049, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 90350, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 82481029, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 180700, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17379549, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 78565, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 51973512, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 148265, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 322543780, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53799, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4638804, "child_limit_applications": 21879, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21879, "child_cap_hits": 21879, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21879, "child_moves_before_total": 1638975, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1638975, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 350067, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 350067, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.9108734402852, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000137117784178, "tt_hits": 8191, "tt_cutoffs": 864, "beta_cutoffs": 17458, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5887.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6553.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1536, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2336, "avg_search_time_ms": 212.36363636363637, "search_nodes": 111074, "safety_nodes": 518, "corridor_nodes": 3431, "corridor_branch_probes": 3749, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1411, "corridor_neutral_exits": 44, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 3407, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3407, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 68, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 44, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1411, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 92, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 705, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 301040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 115023, "avg_nodes": 10456.636363636364, "eval_calls": 107038, "avg_eval_calls": 9730.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107038, "pattern_eval_ns": 1946308, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.18333675890805, "pattern_frame_queries": 107038, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1946308, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.18333675890805, "pattern_frame_updates": 222084, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1176985625, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5299.731745645791, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4015, "avg_candidate_generations": 365.0, "candidate_moves_total": 296538, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.85753424657534, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 678, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 4004, "search_candidate_moves_total": 295860, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 10181, "avg_legality_checks": 925.5454545454545, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10181, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 650216, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 59110.545454545456, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 815545491, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1254.2685676759722, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2927, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 266.09090909090907, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8549221, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2920.8134608814485, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15980, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2844, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8407251, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 49210, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 76780, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17311324, "stage_ordering_ns": 123041, "stage_eval_ns": 1178931933, "stage_threat_ns": 1039827186, "stage_proof_ns": 83852035, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 229093, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 762414794, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 202006, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 131685282, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2196, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 53291813, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 114541, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99438736, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6998, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 23526395, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 229082, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22761979, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 316, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3520, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6056.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6783.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1985, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1274, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10310, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 80, 99, 141, 71, 85, 128, 125, 129, 130, 65, 109, 108, 93, 77, 157 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 3350, "avg_search_time_ms": 372.22222222222223, "search_nodes": 92008, "safety_nodes": 510, "corridor_nodes": 374, "corridor_branch_probes": 445, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 116, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 366, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 366, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 116, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 287, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 101360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 92892, "avg_nodes": 10321.333333333334, "eval_calls": 89400, "avg_eval_calls": 9933.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89400, "pattern_eval_ns": 1740126, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.464496644295302, "pattern_frame_queries": 89400, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1740126, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.464496644295302, "pattern_frame_updates": 183966, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2014346102, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10949.55645064849, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2592, "avg_candidate_generations": 288.0, "candidate_moves_total": 190185, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.3738425925926, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 628, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 2583, "search_candidate_moves_total": 189557, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 87211, "avg_legality_checks": 9690.111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 628, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 86583, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 793979, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 88219.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1590805515, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2003.586385786022, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8299, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 922.1111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 56946694, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6861.87420171105, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 176590, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8164, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 56264483, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 248961, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 80, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 256660, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 124.11111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 8782759, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7862.810205908684, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1496, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 166.22222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4598132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3073.6176470588234, "stage_move_gen_ns": 178361133, "stage_ordering_ns": 79220, "stage_eval_ns": 2016086228, "stage_threat_ns": 1047467643, "stage_proof_ns": 90085226, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 184789, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 852843690, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26858, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 65392494, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 337, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13588619, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 106544550, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 814, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3348420, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 184780, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19338489, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2213, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5446.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6335.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1882, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6951, "avg_search_time_ms": 868.875, "search_nodes": 61132, "safety_nodes": 553, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 61685, "avg_nodes": 7710.625, "eval_calls": 41759, "avg_eval_calls": 5219.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41759, "pattern_eval_ns": 849442, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.341531166934075, "pattern_frame_queries": 41759, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 849442, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.341531166934075, "pattern_frame_updates": 122194, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1158346691, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9479.570936379854, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18182, "avg_candidate_generations": 2272.75, "candidate_moves_total": 1484661, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.65553844461556, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 555, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 18174, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1484106, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1075060, "avg_legality_checks": 134382.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 691, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1075060, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 691, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2450814, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 306351.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4586429313, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1871.3902046422127, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14982, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1872.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 35966141, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2400.6234815111466, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 697, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5972988, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1876, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12974667, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12409, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17018486, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 96379, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12047.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 789060321, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8187.056526836759, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 128588, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16073.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 350260115, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2723.894259184372, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2310780286, "stage_ordering_ns": 556304786, "stage_eval_ns": 1159196133, "stage_threat_ns": 2883529403, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 266598, "root_tactical_annotations": 981, "search_tactical_annotations": 265617, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 122202, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 640880131, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 254070, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2141221541, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36399, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1127815752, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61097, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80640598, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 122194, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13626453, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 53784, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 250450583, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 163881, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 762874426, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 48933, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7160680, "child_limit_applications": 18174, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18174, "child_cap_hits": 18174, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18174, "child_moves_before_total": 1483415, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1483415, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 290831, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 290831, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.62292285682844, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002586112028172, "tt_hits": 5609, "tt_cutoffs": 1164, "beta_cutoffs": 15487, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3227.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4227.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1488, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1275, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21784, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 81, 126, 67, 82, 39, 53, 65, 49, 68, 66, 50, 141, 156, 110, 35, 80, 51, 124, 138, 83, 37, 79, 20, 5, 36, 38, 52, 84, 4 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 14553, "avg_search_time_ms": 970.2, "search_nodes": 177856, "safety_nodes": 416, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 178272, "avg_nodes": 11884.8, "eval_calls": 132457, "avg_eval_calls": 8830.466666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 132457, "pattern_eval_ns": 2870131, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.668398046158377, "pattern_frame_queries": 132457, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2870131, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.668398046158377, "pattern_frame_updates": 355578, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4031369538, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11337.511145233957, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41854, "avg_candidate_generations": 2790.266666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 3398624, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.20189229225403, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1084, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 41839, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3397540, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1139455, "avg_legality_checks": 75963.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 262, "root_legality_checks": 1084, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1138371, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 262, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3928268, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 261884.53333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8434239428, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2147.0631402949084, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35341, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2356.0666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 88987794, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2517.976118389406, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 430, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2145438, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15316, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 58229197, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19595, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28613159, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 111059, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7403.933333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 865927661, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7797.005744694262, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 139002, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9266.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 344603479, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2479.126048546064, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2745391054, "stage_ordering_ns": 1285629295, "stage_eval_ns": 4034239669, "stage_threat_ns": 6416100646, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 773771, "root_tactical_annotations": 3779, "search_tactical_annotations": 769992, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 355593, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2049196330, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 682516, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4043937828, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 83774, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2689064738, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 177789, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 255558799, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 355578, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43661168, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 265398, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 245297337, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 333332, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1109463732, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 175041, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23746521, "child_limit_applications": 41839, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41839, "child_cap_hits": 41839, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41839, "child_moves_before_total": 3397278, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3397278, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 670239, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 670239, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.1988336241306, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.019479433064845, "tt_hits": 19304, "tt_cutoffs": 3493, "beta_cutoffs": 33185, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5566.866666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6100.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 704, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 7217, "avg_search_time_ms": 515.5, "search_nodes": 237572, "safety_nodes": 1418, "corridor_nodes": 676, "corridor_branch_probes": 859, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 8, "corridor_depth_exits": 249, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 664, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 664, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 62, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 249, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 62, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 346, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 113200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 239666, "avg_nodes": 17119.0, "eval_calls": 232892, "avg_eval_calls": 16635.14285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 232892, "pattern_eval_ns": 4958283, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.29005290005668, "pattern_frame_queries": 232892, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4958283, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.29005290005668, "pattern_frame_updates": 475062, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3927687757, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8267.737173253176, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4653, "avg_candidate_generations": 332.35714285714283, "candidate_moves_total": 364733, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.3866322802493, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1033, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 4639, "search_candidate_moves_total": 363700, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 11120, "avg_legality_checks": 794.2857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11120, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1093725, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 78123.21428571429, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2447840138, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2238.076425061144, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4400, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 314.2857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33895562, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7703.5368181818185, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4385, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33831252, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 64310, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 28191592, "stage_ordering_ns": 166840, "stage_eval_ns": 3932646040, "stage_threat_ns": 3100519640, "stage_proof_ns": 104785894, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 476528, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2671363461, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42171, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 52303615, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 556, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19638564, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 238257, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 311156771, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1452, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9183993, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 476514, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56511800, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 182, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4301, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6196.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6768.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1788, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1276, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12322, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 159, 143, 126, 83, 141, 156, 84, 113, 129, 67, 52, 65, 49, 79, 80, 128, 98, 115, 51, 114, 116, 142, 100, 170 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 7679, "avg_search_time_ms": 548.5, "search_nodes": 113602, "safety_nodes": 1186, "corridor_nodes": 10329, "corridor_branch_probes": 12077, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4788, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 162, "corridor_plies_followed": 10290, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 10290, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 104, "corridor_proof_active": 39, "corridor_proof_quiet": 65, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4788, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 162, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 104, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 694, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 377120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 25200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 125117, "avg_nodes": 8936.92857142857, "eval_calls": 109782, "avg_eval_calls": 7841.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 109782, "pattern_eval_ns": 2276022, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.732196534951086, "pattern_frame_queries": 109782, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2276022, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.732196534951086, "pattern_frame_updates": 227124, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2711968837, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11940.476730772618, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3794, "avg_candidate_generations": 271.0, "candidate_moves_total": 292992, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.22509225092251, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 954, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 3780, "search_candidate_moves_total": 292038, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 105961, "avg_legality_checks": 7568.642857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 581, "root_legality_checks": 954, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 105007, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 579, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2298044, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 164146.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4531449733, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1971.8724850350993, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23381, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1670.0714285714287, "renju_forbidden_ns": 127907498, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5470.574312475942, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 585, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2912656, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18892, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 102037488, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 816, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9035912, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3088, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13921442, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 30225, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2158.9285714285716, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 285467440, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9444.745740281223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41329, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2952.0714285714284, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 147249945, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3562.872196278642, "stage_move_gen_ns": 224359218, "stage_ordering_ns": 142460, "stage_eval_ns": 2714244859, "stage_threat_ns": 3531137672, "stage_proof_ns": 1178565770, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 247926, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1398650728, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 554919, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1813192013, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 5274, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 335719785, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123956, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 165372082, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 20788, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 126432158, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 247912, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27490691, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 328, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3302, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6370.785714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6942.214285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1829, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 4627, "avg_search_time_ms": 355.9230769230769, "search_nodes": 41167, "safety_nodes": 1089, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 42256, "avg_nodes": 3250.4615384615386, "eval_calls": 27835, "avg_eval_calls": 2141.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 27835, "pattern_eval_ns": 599223, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.527680977186996, "pattern_frame_queries": 27835, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 599223, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.527680977186996, "pattern_frame_updates": 82214, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 833678814, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10140.350962123239, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12475, "avg_candidate_generations": 959.6153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 906195, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.64088176352705, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 888, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 12462, "search_candidate_moves_total": 905307, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 532989, "avg_legality_checks": 40999.153846153844, "illegal_moves_skipped": 236, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 532989, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 236, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1453410, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 111800.76923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2981764708, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2051.5647394747525, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6925, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 532.6923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15734708, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2272.16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 238, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1123948, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1805, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9234913, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4872, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5320507, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55340, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54447, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4188.2307692307695, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 525197787, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9646.037192131798, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76876, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5913.538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 253935176, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3303.178833446069, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1290186439, "stage_ordering_ns": 369481232, "stage_eval_ns": 834278037, "stage_threat_ns": 2097747118, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 188940, "root_tactical_annotations": 571, "search_tactical_annotations": 188369, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 82227, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 488948451, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 181735, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1537627729, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25010, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 862021814, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 41107, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 57577644, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 82214, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10219281, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44158, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 192368088, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 112560, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 483021265, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 32222, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3374013, "child_limit_applications": 12462, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12462, "child_cap_hits": 12462, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12462, "child_moves_before_total": 905071, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 905071, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 200255, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 200255, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.62646445193388, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.06925052158562, "tt_hits": 4162, "tt_cutoffs": 810, "beta_cutoffs": 10656, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5698.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6314.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1839, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1277, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21721, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 82, 110, 126, 81, 128, 144, 141, 156, 99, 127, 140, 158, 172, 157, 159, 146, 162, 145, 143, 160, 154, 168, 139, 142, 175, 174, 132, 115, 100, 202, 188, 206, 190, 147, 64, 148 ], "move_count": 44, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 9692, "avg_search_time_ms": 484.6, "search_nodes": 113171, "safety_nodes": 1606, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 114777, "avg_nodes": 5738.85, "eval_calls": 81167, "avg_eval_calls": 4058.35, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 81167, "pattern_eval_ns": 1707819, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.0408047605554, "pattern_frame_queries": 81167, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1707819, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.0408047605554, "pattern_frame_updates": 226150, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2165910351, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9577.317492814504, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30297, "avg_candidate_generations": 1514.85, "candidate_moves_total": 2402759, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.30682905898274, "candidate_moves_max": 134, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1479, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 30277, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2401280, "search_candidate_moves_max": 134, "legality_checks": 1056177, "avg_legality_checks": 52808.85, "illegal_moves_skipped": 859, "root_legality_checks": 1479, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1054698, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2923410, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 146170.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5786811887, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1979.4732476799354, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14893, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 744.65, "renju_forbidden_ns": 63124772, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4238.553145773182, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 887, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7979900, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4893, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38246282, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9099, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16787210, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 111380, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76865, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3843.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 581734340, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7568.260456644767, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 100695, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5034.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 239644032, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2379.9000148964697, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2331362893, "stage_ordering_ns": 918998164, "stage_eval_ns": 2167618170, "stage_threat_ns": 4206368544, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 438324, "root_tactical_annotations": 2380, "search_tactical_annotations": 435944, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 226170, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1194102701, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 415416, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2824134196, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60690, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1945523114, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 113075, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 152790343, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 226150, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25893810, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 137254, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 182830064, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 217456, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 695033895, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 83614, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9447494, "child_limit_applications": 30277, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30277, "child_cap_hits": 30277, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30277, "child_moves_before_total": 2400423, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2400423, "child_moves_before_max": 134, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 134, "child_moves_after_total": 484749, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 484749, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.28206229150841, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01046999372461, "tt_hits": 11636, "tt_cutoffs": 1631, "beta_cutoffs": 25002, "depth_sum": 96, "avg_depth": 4.8, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 96, "avg_effective_depth": 4.8, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6593.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6993.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1238, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 12005, "avg_search_time_ms": 600.25, "search_nodes": 372818, "safety_nodes": 783, "corridor_nodes": 7142, "corridor_branch_probes": 7544, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3109, "corridor_neutral_exits": 99, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 7103, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 7103, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 19, "corridor_proof_completed": 19, "corridor_proof_checks": 150, "corridor_proof_active": 39, "corridor_proof_quiet": 111, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 99, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3109, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 150, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 145, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1083, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 300640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9360, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 20, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 11, "total_nodes": 380743, "avg_nodes": 19037.15, "eval_calls": 362971, "avg_eval_calls": 18148.55, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 362971, "pattern_eval_ns": 7768423, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.402324152618252, "pattern_frame_queries": 362971, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7768423, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.402324152618252, "pattern_frame_updates": 745520, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6387141953, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8567.364997585579, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9809, "avg_candidate_generations": 490.45, "candidate_moves_total": 837077, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.33764909776735, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1519, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 9789, "search_candidate_moves_total": 835558, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 21010, "avg_legality_checks": 1050.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 21010, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1852853, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 92642.65, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4069533792, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2196.360851076691, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10185, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 509.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 74062734, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7271.746097201767, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 40940, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10124, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73424542, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 403181, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 194071, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 54805687, "stage_ordering_ns": 397382, "stage_eval_ns": 6394910376, "stage_threat_ns": 5359095217, "stage_proof_ns": 167537687, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 760046, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4226550223, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 383777, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 425460179, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 4475, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 181783745, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 380013, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 515334944, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 14506, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 99451208, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 760026, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 92298663, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 966, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8430, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6652.55, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7052.55, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1278, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9197, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 110, 109, 82, 124, 126, 81, 94, 78, 144, 128, 142, 158, 141, 156, 143, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6711, "avg_search_time_ms": 610.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 115205, "safety_nodes": 282, "corridor_nodes": 6208, "corridor_branch_probes": 6499, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2984, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 6182, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6182, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 79, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2984, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 79, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 75, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 581, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 186400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 121695, "avg_nodes": 11063.181818181818, "eval_calls": 110978, "avg_eval_calls": 10088.90909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110978, "pattern_eval_ns": 2388475, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.52205842599434, "pattern_frame_queries": 110978, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2388475, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.52205842599434, "pattern_frame_updates": 230348, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2762127674, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11991.107689235418, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4207, "avg_candidate_generations": 382.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 297484, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.71167102448301, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 687, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 4196, "search_candidate_moves_total": 296797, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 104845, "avg_legality_checks": 9531.363636363636, "illegal_moves_skipped": 135, "root_legality_checks": 687, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 104158, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 134, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1521942, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 138358.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3476476516, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2284.2371890650234, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12701, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1154.6363636363637, "renju_forbidden_ns": 103653371, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8161.040154318557, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 145, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1175237, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11781, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 97544689, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 156, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2000070, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 619, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2933375, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 12690, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1153.6363636363637, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 122806301, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9677.407486209613, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16660, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1514.5454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 60905903, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3655.816506602641, "stage_move_gen_ns": 271581592, "stage_ordering_ns": 168001, "stage_eval_ns": 2764516149, "stage_threat_ns": 2891575750, "stage_proof_ns": 759170650, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 242881, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1532244030, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 330179, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1070771759, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 3222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 218466160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121435, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 178060327, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12522, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 79526126, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 242870, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30973508, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 510, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3497, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5580.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6307.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1778, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2475, "avg_search_time_ms": 247.5, "search_nodes": 24403, "safety_nodes": 874, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 25277, "avg_nodes": 2527.7, "eval_calls": 17074, "avg_eval_calls": 1707.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 17074, "pattern_eval_ns": 373554, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.878528757174653, "pattern_frame_queries": 17074, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 373554, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.878528757174653, "pattern_frame_updates": 48716, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 514493817, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10561.085002873799, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6942, "avg_candidate_generations": 694.2, "candidate_moves_total": 498274, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.7767214059349, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 625, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 6932, "search_candidate_moves_total": 497649, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 216082, "avg_legality_checks": 21608.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 112, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 216082, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 112, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 670643, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 67064.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1498738258, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2234.7780533010855, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3176, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 317.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 17985735, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5663.014798488665, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 118, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1149497, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1286, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12307098, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1767, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4473000, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 56140, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 19598, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1959.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 195999675, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10001.003928972345, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27362, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2736.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 91292359, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3336.465134127622, "stage_move_gen_ns": 550084177, "stage_ordering_ns": 217754865, "stage_eval_ns": 514867371, "stage_threat_ns": 1170473126, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 99483, "root_tactical_annotations": 311, "search_tactical_annotations": 99172, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 48726, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 312488928, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 95498, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 813110312, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13929, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 534463860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 24358, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 36760755, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 48716, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6382244, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 24385, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 78491849, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 57178, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 199935721, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 17920, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1730887, "child_limit_applications": 6932, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6932, "child_cap_hits": 6932, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6932, "child_moves_before_total": 497537, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 497537, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 110969, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 110969, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.77394691286786, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.008222735141374, "tt_hits": 2321, "tt_cutoffs": 352, "beta_cutoffs": 5805, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5602.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6402.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1865, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1279, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21155, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 96, 141, 82, 97, 54, 68, 80, 64, 83, 81, 65, 156, 171, 125, 50, 95, 66, 139, 153, 34, 52, 94, 35, 20, 51, 53, 67, 19, 99 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 13779, "avg_search_time_ms": 918.6, "search_nodes": 149057, "safety_nodes": 431, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 149488, "avg_nodes": 9965.866666666667, "eval_calls": 105213, "avg_eval_calls": 7014.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105213, "pattern_eval_ns": 2291771, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.782203720072616, "pattern_frame_queries": 105213, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2291771, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.782203720072616, "pattern_frame_updates": 297980, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3691950578, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12389.927438083092, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 40986, "avg_candidate_generations": 2732.4, "candidate_moves_total": 3449666, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.16693505099302, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1109, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 40971, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3448557, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1021840, "avg_legality_checks": 68122.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 346, "root_legality_checks": 1109, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1020731, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 346, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3626784, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 241785.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8057015819, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2221.531753476358, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27992, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1866.1333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 81559240, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2913.662474992855, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 560, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3368930, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11642, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 53769970, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15790, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24420340, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93034, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6202.266666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 785466377, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8442.788410688565, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 119497, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7966.466666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 315665722, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2641.620475827845, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2501903806, "stage_ordering_ns": 1354521374, "stage_eval_ns": 3694242349, "stage_threat_ns": 6166434544, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 741763, "root_tactical_annotations": 3859, "search_tactical_annotations": 737904, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 297995, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1801621462, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 647551, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4077880748, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 82038, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2840777264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 225817027, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 297980, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38183472, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 259650, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 215846989, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 305851, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1021129224, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 176262, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22931835, "child_limit_applications": 40971, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 40971, "child_cap_hits": 40971, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 40971, "child_moves_before_total": 3448211, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3448211, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 662917, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 662917, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.16223670401016, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.180151814698203, "tt_hits": 19048, "tt_cutoffs": 2806, "beta_cutoffs": 34191, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5465.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5998.466666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 651, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 7362, "avg_search_time_ms": 525.8571428571429, "search_nodes": 232643, "safety_nodes": 1446, "corridor_nodes": 586, "corridor_branch_probes": 723, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 218, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_plies_followed": 574, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 574, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 62, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 218, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 62, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 346, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 113200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 234675, "avg_nodes": 16762.5, "eval_calls": 228100, "avg_eval_calls": 16292.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 228100, "pattern_eval_ns": 4917200, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.557211749232792, "pattern_frame_queries": 228100, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4917200, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.557211749232792, "pattern_frame_updates": 465204, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4041178588, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8686.89561568688, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4516, "avg_candidate_generations": 322.57142857142856, "candidate_moves_total": 364892, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.79982285208149, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1056, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 4502, "search_candidate_moves_total": 363836, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 11001, "avg_legality_checks": 785.7857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11001, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1069910, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 76422.14285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2478841664, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2316.8693291959135, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4416, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 315.42857142857144, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37700407, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8537.229846014492, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4399, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37632317, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 68090, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 29330787, "stage_ordering_ns": 171070, "stage_eval_ns": 4046095788, "stage_threat_ns": 3142482643, "stage_proof_ns": 106256720, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 466490, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2712585492, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37201, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 43933775, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 506, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16004824, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 233238, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 320756438, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1272, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7663935, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 466476, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57543003, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 179, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4187, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6184.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6756.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1783, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1280, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9514, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 158, 82, 67, 110, 68, 98, 95, 66, 50, 144, 128, 114, 130, 99, 100, 129, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7062, "avg_search_time_ms": 642.0, "search_nodes": 122833, "safety_nodes": 282, "corridor_nodes": 5183, "corridor_branch_probes": 5480, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2503, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_plies_followed": 5158, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5158, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 78, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2503, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 78, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 74, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 575, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 196160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 5, "total_nodes": 128298, "avg_nodes": 11663.454545454546, "eval_calls": 118728, "avg_eval_calls": 10793.454545454546, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 118728, "pattern_eval_ns": 2556600, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.533252476248233, "pattern_frame_queries": 118728, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2556600, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.533252476248233, "pattern_frame_updates": 245604, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3315278616, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13498.471588410612, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4085, "avg_candidate_generations": 371.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 303258, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.23696450428396, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 687, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 4074, "search_candidate_moves_total": 302571, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 112111, "avg_legality_checks": 10191.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 146, "root_legality_checks": 687, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 111424, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 145, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1577417, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 143401.54545454544, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3692837027, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2341.0658227976496, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19711, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1791.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 193138490, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9798.513013038404, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 156, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1220572, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18990, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 187405949, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 152, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1923719, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 413, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2588250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 11115, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1010.4545454545455, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 110195483, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9914.123526765632, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14693, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1335.7272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 55760683, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3795.05090859593, "stage_move_gen_ns": 283223040, "stage_ordering_ns": 176160, "stage_eval_ns": 3317835216, "stage_threat_ns": 2775911313, "stage_proof_ns": 659939670, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 256087, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1577950521, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 275373, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 911683267, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2680, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 186476523, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128038, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 187555812, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10472, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 66764757, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 256076, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31956956, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 510, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3420, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5857.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6585.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1824, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2442, "avg_search_time_ms": 244.2, "search_nodes": 23398, "safety_nodes": 874, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 24272, "avg_nodes": 2427.2, "eval_calls": 16204, "avg_eval_calls": 1620.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 16204, "pattern_eval_ns": 359972, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.215008639842015, "pattern_frame_queries": 16204, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 359972, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.215008639842015, "pattern_frame_updates": 46706, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 501124862, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10729.346593585407, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6774, "avg_candidate_generations": 677.4, "candidate_moves_total": 483797, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.41969294360791, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 625, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 6764, "search_candidate_moves_total": 483172, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 215648, "avg_legality_checks": 21564.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 119, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 215648, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 119, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 662637, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 66263.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1491161024, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2250.343738728746, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3004, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 300.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15671659, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5216.9304260985355, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1303383, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1163, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10329330, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1711, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3981585, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57361, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 20158, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2015.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 205608889, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10199.865512451632, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 28019, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2801.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 96669884, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3450.154680752347, "stage_move_gen_ns": 551882489, "stage_ordering_ns": 212321356, "stage_eval_ns": 501484834, "stage_threat_ns": 1153727447, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 97673, "root_tactical_annotations": 311, "search_tactical_annotations": 97362, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 46716, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 300416086, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 94040, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 809716834, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13593, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 521581256, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 23353, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 35840009, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 46706, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6073015, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 24917, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 84243679, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 55524, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 203667789, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 17232, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1681503, "child_limit_applications": 6764, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6764, "child_cap_hits": 6764, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6764, "child_moves_before_total": 483053, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 483053, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 108289, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 108289, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.41528681253696, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.009609698403313, "tt_hits": 2340, "tt_cutoffs": 385, "beta_cutoffs": 5698, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5593.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6393.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1828, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1281, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23830, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 83, 82, 66, 69, 96, 81, 80, 128, 95, 94, 110, 65, 143, 127, 125, 140, 141, 130, 111, 139, 109, 108, 157, 93, 173 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 13276, "avg_search_time_ms": 1021.2307692307693, "search_nodes": 161387, "safety_nodes": 548, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 161935, "avg_nodes": 12456.538461538461, "eval_calls": 124420, "avg_eval_calls": 9570.76923076923, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 124420, "pattern_eval_ns": 2707918, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.764330493489794, "pattern_frame_queries": 124420, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2707918, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.764330493489794, "pattern_frame_updates": 322660, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3640736582, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11283.507661315316, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34861, "avg_candidate_generations": 2681.6153846153848, "candidate_moves_total": 2520891, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.31264163391756, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 809, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 34848, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2520082, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 1138528, "avg_legality_checks": 87579.07692307692, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1148, "root_legality_checks": 809, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1137719, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1148, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3458218, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 266016.76923076925, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7804140845, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2256.694298913487, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22337, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1718.2307692307693, "renju_forbidden_ns": 56116305, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2512.257912879975, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1278, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4046157, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8400, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37347376, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12657, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14719972, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2800, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 84660, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6512.307692307692, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 682081337, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8056.713170328372, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 107714, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8285.692307692309, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 245197790, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2276.378093841098, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2825030840, "stage_ordering_ns": 1071579837, "stage_eval_ns": 3643444500, "stage_threat_ns": 5673569939, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 413607, "root_tactical_annotations": 2526, "search_tactical_annotations": 411081, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 322673, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1904621077, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 407912, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3479006115, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69778, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2418646506, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 161330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 239315605, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 322660, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40203660, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 86726, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 105432187, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 251396, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 954678832, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 75485, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10423482, "child_limit_applications": 34848, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34848, "child_cap_hits": 34848, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34848, "child_moves_before_total": 2518934, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2518934, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 557569, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 557569, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.2834595959596, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000028696051423, "tt_hits": 12990, "tt_cutoffs": 2062, "beta_cutoffs": 26691, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4012.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4628.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 667, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10539, "avg_search_time_ms": 878.25, "search_nodes": 108428, "safety_nodes": 536, "corridor_nodes": 88, "corridor_branch_probes": 97, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_plies_followed": 81, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 81, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 104, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 97, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 104, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 831, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 193040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 109052, "avg_nodes": 9087.666666666666, "eval_calls": 78934, "avg_eval_calls": 6577.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 78934, "pattern_eval_ns": 1734546, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.974637038538525, "pattern_frame_queries": 78934, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1734546, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.974637038538525, "pattern_frame_updates": 216746, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1920622640, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8861.16763400478, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27890, "avg_candidate_generations": 2324.1666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2026779, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.6704553603442, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 27878, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2026031, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 1252230, "avg_legality_checks": 104352.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 582, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1252230, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 582, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3010422, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 250868.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6553275304, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2176.8626803816874, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13692, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1141.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30309576, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2213.6704645048203, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 588, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5809693, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1886, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12021326, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11218, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12478557, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90580, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7548.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 785300343, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8669.68804371826, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 121105, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10092.083333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 315703170, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2606.854960571405, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3080540942, "stage_ordering_ns": 849138690, "stage_eval_ns": 1922357186, "stage_threat_ns": 4433653532, "stage_proof_ns": 187343238, "tactical_annotations": 380323, "root_tactical_annotations": 1671, "search_tactical_annotations": 378652, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 217128, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1278646890, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 365395, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2955312820, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56295, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1862848067, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108558, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 160091766, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 370, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2155987, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 217116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26743317, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 104988, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 325473953, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 197538, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 762281946, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 77797, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10702752, "child_limit_applications": 27878, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27878, "child_cap_hits": 27878, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27878, "child_moves_before_total": 2025449, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2025449, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 446048, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 446048, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.65402826601621, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 9381, "tt_cutoffs": 1561, "beta_cutoffs": 22724, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4284.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4950.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 357, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1282, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16388, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 83, 82, 66, 69, 96, 81, 80, 128, 95, 94, 65, 143, 158, 110, 64, 48, 67, 63, 68 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9815, "avg_search_time_ms": 981.5, "search_nodes": 114816, "safety_nodes": 145, "corridor_nodes": 884, "corridor_branch_probes": 947, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 279, "corridor_neutral_exits": 51, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 863, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 863, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 85, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 51, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 279, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 85, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 82, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 688, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 424240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 115845, "avg_nodes": 11584.5, "eval_calls": 89135, "avg_eval_calls": 8913.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89135, "pattern_eval_ns": 1928558, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.636371795590957, "pattern_frame_queries": 89135, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1928558, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.636371795590957, "pattern_frame_updates": 229548, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2664655602, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11608.271916984682, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24172, "avg_candidate_generations": 2417.2, "candidate_moves_total": 1687725, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.82148767168624, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 584, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 24162, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1687141, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 771405, "avg_legality_checks": 77140.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 382, "root_legality_checks": 584, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 770821, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 382, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2612428, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 261242.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5857978371, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2242.35017041618, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20546, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2054.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 79793104, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3883.6320451669426, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 559, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4004177, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8877, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 56969884, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11025, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18378912, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 85, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 440131, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 56562, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5656.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 503794592, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8906.944450337682, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 80269, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8026.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 212204919, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2643.672139929487, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1922843613, "stage_ordering_ns": 722503510, "stage_eval_ns": 2666584160, "stage_threat_ns": 4179724234, "stage_proof_ns": 275716911, "tactical_annotations": 230439, "root_tactical_annotations": 1881, "search_tactical_annotations": 228558, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 231454, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1371394592, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 302780, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2592535103, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49229, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1745868227, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115722, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 170805683, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1896, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10808212, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 231444, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28615702, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 41309, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 54350305, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 149920, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 661556695, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 39210, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5564942, "child_limit_applications": 24162, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24162, "child_cap_hits": 24162, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24162, "child_moves_before_total": 1686759, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1686759, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 386593, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 386593, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.81040476781723, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000041387302375, "tt_hits": 9355, "tt_cutoffs": 1477, "beta_cutoffs": 18312, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3352.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4152.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 640, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6561, "avg_search_time_ms": 729.0, "search_nodes": 78159, "safety_nodes": 517, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 78676, "avg_nodes": 8741.777777777777, "eval_calls": 59411, "avg_eval_calls": 6601.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 59411, "pattern_eval_ns": 1283554, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.60465233710929, "pattern_frame_queries": 59411, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1283554, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.60465233710929, "pattern_frame_updates": 156238, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1395737631, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8933.406924051767, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17682, "avg_candidate_generations": 1964.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1191802, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.40199072503111, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 526, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 17673, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1191276, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 660180, "avg_legality_checks": 73353.33333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 551, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 660180, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 551, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1824044, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 202671.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3962329236, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2172.277223575747, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7163, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 795.8888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 26807638, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3742.5154264972775, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 559, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5579543, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1461, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12065142, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5143, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9162953, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 56071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6230.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 507498158, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9050.991742612045, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 80686, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8965.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 217265608, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2692.7299407580003, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1657958406, "stage_ordering_ns": 508396337, "stage_eval_ns": 1397021185, "stage_threat_ns": 2956548011, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 201324, "root_tactical_annotations": 991, "search_tactical_annotations": 200333, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 156247, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 907898830, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 193142, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1912394963, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35404, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1232620614, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78119, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 110983789, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 156238, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19043256, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 43810, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 169397780, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 113921, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 510236537, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 43593, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6227173, "child_limit_applications": 17673, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17673, "child_cap_hits": 17673, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17673, "child_moves_before_total": 1190725, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1190725, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 282768, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 282768, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.37537486561422, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 5739, "tt_cutoffs": 1035, "beta_cutoffs": 13779, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3525.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4414.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 401, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1283, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22614, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 142, 110, 141, 96, 98, 140, 68, 125, 83, 53, 95, 124, 82, 84, 97, 138, 152, 155, 170, 72, 86, 156, 67, 52, 69, 55, 66, 65, 70 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 10293, "avg_search_time_ms": 605.4705882352941, "search_nodes": 112520, "safety_nodes": 1498, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 114018, "avg_nodes": 6706.941176470588, "eval_calls": 82555, "avg_eval_calls": 4856.176470588235, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82555, "pattern_eval_ns": 1780874, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.571970201683726, "pattern_frame_queries": 82555, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1780874, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.571970201683726, "pattern_frame_updates": 224886, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2554418198, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11358.724856149338, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28670, "avg_candidate_generations": 1686.4705882352941, "candidate_moves_total": 2269637, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.1641785838856, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1267, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 28653, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2268370, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 954060, "avg_legality_checks": 56121.17647058824, "illegal_moves_skipped": 889, "root_legality_checks": 1267, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 952793, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 887, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2785378, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 163845.76470588235, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6108388806, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2193.0196928388177, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14609, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 859.3529411764706, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66756036, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4569.514408926005, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 917, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9611269, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5260, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 41668329, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8419, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15384318, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 92120, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72878, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4286.941176470588, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 585362957, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8032.094143637311, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91625, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5389.705882352941, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 224621528, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2451.5310013642566, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2269503426, "stage_ordering_ns": 938456169, "stage_eval_ns": 2556199072, "stage_threat_ns": 4471038463, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 441352, "root_tactical_annotations": 1795, "search_tactical_annotations": 439557, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 224903, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1317230686, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 422677, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2949807324, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 57416, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2042234252, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 112443, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 164951384, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 224886, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28360586, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 142799, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 127537447, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 222449, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 779419335, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76104, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10688483, "child_limit_applications": 28653, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28653, "child_cap_hits": 28653, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28653, "child_moves_before_total": 2267483, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2267483, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 458510, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 458510, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.13597180050955, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00216382228737, "tt_hits": 10522, "tt_cutoffs": 1235, "beta_cutoffs": 23272, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5888.882352941177, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6359.470588235294, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1154, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 12307, "avg_search_time_ms": 769.1875, "search_nodes": 103778, "safety_nodes": 672, "corridor_nodes": 5950, "corridor_branch_probes": 6703, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2474, "corridor_neutral_exits": 22, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 5898, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5898, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 156, "corridor_proof_active": 52, "corridor_proof_quiet": 104, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2474, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 156, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 156, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1249, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 454640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 110400, "avg_nodes": 6900.0, "eval_calls": 68287, "avg_eval_calls": 4267.9375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68287, "pattern_eval_ns": 1438316, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.062808440845256, "pattern_frame_queries": 68287, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1438316, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.062808440845256, "pattern_frame_updates": 207406, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1670547687, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8054.481003442524, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33808, "avg_candidate_generations": 2113.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2918821, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.33521651680076, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1187, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 33792, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2917634, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 2227403, "avg_legality_checks": 139212.6875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 654, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2227403, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 654, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4510843, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 281927.6875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7905244406, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1752.49823724745, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16723, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1045.1875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 26991636, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1614.0426956885726, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 664, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5958167, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1425, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10572604, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14614, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10244175, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 216690, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 148250, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9265.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1051244790, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7091.027251264755, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 190683, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11917.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 433828178, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2275.1277145838903, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4224603817, "stage_ordering_ns": 964349898, "stage_eval_ns": 1671986003, "stage_threat_ns": 5172226383, "stage_proof_ns": 180672035, "tactical_annotations": 695928, "root_tactical_annotations": 3361, "search_tactical_annotations": 692567, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 219530, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1217211455, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 927770, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3685872529, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 71175, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2071986568, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 109757, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 152129034, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12108, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 68893573, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 219514, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25008736, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 253948, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 574900889, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 261687, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 817564808, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 180293, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23111056, "child_limit_applications": 33792, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33792, "child_cap_hits": 33792, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33792, "child_moves_before_total": 2916980, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2916980, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 541003, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 541003, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.32161458333333, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00979521780303, "tt_hits": 16324, "tt_cutoffs": 1624, "beta_cutoffs": 29440, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6207.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6707.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1829, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1284, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15320, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 142, 110, 141, 96, 98, 140, 68, 125, 83, 53, 95, 124, 82, 84, 97, 138, 152, 155, 170, 72, 86, 156, 67, 52, 69, 55, 66, 65, 70 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 6869, "avg_search_time_ms": 404.05882352941177, "search_nodes": 112520, "safety_nodes": 1498, "corridor_nodes": 1802, "corridor_branch_probes": 2043, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 576, "corridor_neutral_exits": 79, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1762, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1762, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 126, "corridor_proof_active": 40, "corridor_proof_quiet": 86, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 79, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 576, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 126, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 124, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 916, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24319200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 115820, "avg_nodes": 6812.941176470588, "eval_calls": 82555, "avg_eval_calls": 4856.176470588235, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82555, "pattern_eval_ns": 1543077, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.691502634607232, "pattern_frame_queries": 82555, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1543077, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.691502634607232, "pattern_frame_updates": 224886, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1606183962, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7142.21410848163, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28670, "avg_candidate_generations": 1686.4705882352941, "candidate_moves_total": 2269637, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.1641785838856, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1267, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 28653, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2268370, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 954060, "avg_legality_checks": 56121.17647058824, "illegal_moves_skipped": 889, "root_legality_checks": 1267, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 952793, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 887, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3113588, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 183152.23529411765, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4057557219, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1303.1773050898191, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14848, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 873.4117647058823, "renju_forbidden_ns": 41263368, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2779.0522629310344, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 917, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5305112, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5260, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25662064, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8466, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9492201, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 205, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 803991, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75722, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4454.235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 393217367, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5192.907833918808, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95371, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5610.058823529412, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 158925322, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1666.3904331505385, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1360630750, "stage_ordering_ns": 541393872, "stage_eval_ns": 1607727039, "stage_threat_ns": 3007835185, "stage_proof_ns": 294791463, "tactical_annotations": 441352, "root_tactical_annotations": 1795, "search_tactical_annotations": 439557, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 228679, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 832608099, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 549899, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2019526397, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58810, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1246672634, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 114331, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113702026, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3776, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14970705, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 228662, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18754430, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 142799, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 86367597, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 222449, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 487910768, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76104, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8273528, "child_limit_applications": 28653, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28653, "child_cap_hits": 28653, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28653, "child_moves_before_total": 2267483, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2267483, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 458510, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 458510, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.13597180050955, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00216382228737, "tt_hits": 10522, "tt_cutoffs": 1235, "beta_cutoffs": 23272, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6349.764705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6820.35294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1495, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 8435, "avg_search_time_ms": 527.1875, "search_nodes": 103778, "safety_nodes": 672, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 104450, "avg_nodes": 6528.125, "eval_calls": 68287, "avg_eval_calls": 4267.9375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68287, "pattern_eval_ns": 1285437, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.824036785918256, "pattern_frame_queries": 68287, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1285437, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.824036785918256, "pattern_frame_updates": 207406, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1219268560, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5878.656162309673, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33808, "avg_candidate_generations": 2113.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2918821, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.33521651680076, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1187, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 33792, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2917634, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 2227403, "avg_legality_checks": 139212.6875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 654, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2227403, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 654, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4352517, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 272032.3125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5486247764, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1260.4770444319918, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16640, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1040.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18270847, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1098.0076322115385, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 664, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3831050, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1425, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7778945, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14541, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6599152, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61700, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 148250, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9265.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 823862100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5557.248566610455, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 190683, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11917.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 349154612, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1831.0736248118606, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3060714928, "stage_ordering_ns": 687165545, "stage_eval_ns": 1220553997, "stage_threat_ns": 3375991349, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 695928, "root_tactical_annotations": 3361, "search_tactical_annotations": 692567, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 207422, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 777908547, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 583338, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2455956473, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67691, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1370418141, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 103703, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105075883, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 207406, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17838120, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 253948, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 448843677, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 261687, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 636607305, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 180293, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19212326, "child_limit_applications": 33792, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33792, "child_cap_hits": 33792, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33792, "child_moves_before_total": 2916980, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2916980, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 541003, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 541003, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.32161458333333, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00979521780303, "tt_hits": 16324, "tt_cutoffs": 1624, "beta_cutoffs": 29440, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6377.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6877.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1910, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1285, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3797, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 145, 81, 177, 109, 108, 67, 53, 123 ], "move_count": 15, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 2087, "avg_search_time_ms": 347.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 44421, "safety_nodes": 201, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 44622, "avg_nodes": 7437.0, "eval_calls": 33782, "avg_eval_calls": 5630.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33782, "pattern_eval_ns": 625314, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.510271742347996, "pattern_frame_queries": 33782, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 625314, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.510271742347996, "pattern_frame_updates": 88798, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 574569920, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6470.527714588166, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9981, "avg_candidate_generations": 1663.5, "candidate_moves_total": 675921, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.72076946197775, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 377, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 9975, "search_candidate_moves_total": 675544, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 256882, "avg_legality_checks": 42813.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 149, "root_legality_checks": 377, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 256505, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 149, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 944610, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 157435.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1171489385, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1240.1831284868888, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6726, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1121.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18944702, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2816.6372286648825, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 151, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 707993, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3035, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13687380, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3540, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4549329, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 24363, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4060.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 134912493, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5537.59770964167, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 34136, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5689.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 64550860, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1890.9907429107102, "stage_move_gen_ns": 357843104, "stage_ordering_ns": 161501102, "stage_eval_ns": 575195234, "stage_threat_ns": 974056966, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 86615, "root_tactical_annotations": 838, "search_tactical_annotations": 85777, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 88804, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 302411756, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 87340, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 621314066, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19983, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 442671256, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 44399, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 41413487, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 88798, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7057539, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 16795, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 30554385, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 50557, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 148008254, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 19263, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1860118, "child_limit_applications": 9975, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9975, "child_cap_hits": 9975, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9975, "child_moves_before_total": 675395, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 675395, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 159637, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 159637, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.70877192982456, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.003709273182956, "tt_hits": 4007, "tt_cutoffs": 642, "beta_cutoffs": 7756, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3777.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5111.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1595, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 7, "search_move_count": 5, "total_time_ms": 1705, "avg_search_time_ms": 341.0, "search_nodes": 24380, "safety_nodes": 235, "corridor_nodes": 12, "corridor_branch_probes": 11, "corridor_max_depth": 3, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 8, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 34, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 34, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 275, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 134800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 24627, "avg_nodes": 4925.4, "eval_calls": 16281, "avg_eval_calls": 3256.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 16281, "pattern_eval_ns": 297621, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.28026533996683, "pattern_frame_queries": 16281, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 297621, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.28026533996683, "pattern_frame_updates": 48720, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 274621992, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5636.74039408867, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7653, "avg_candidate_generations": 1530.6, "candidate_moves_total": 537243, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.20031360250881, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 5, "root_candidate_moves_total": 300, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 7648, "search_candidate_moves_total": 536943, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 358949, "avg_legality_checks": 71789.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 159, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 358949, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 159, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 942863, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 188572.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1083092073, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1148.7268807875587, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4539, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 907.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9225055, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2032.3981053095395, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 159, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 724345, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1157, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6420263, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3223, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2080447, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37738, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7547.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 210351587, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5573.999337537761, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 55429, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11085.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 105473250, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1902.853199588663, "stage_move_gen_ns": 481044304, "stage_ordering_ns": 126621327, "stage_eval_ns": 274919613, "stage_threat_ns": 768140929, "stage_proof_ns": 36930561, "tactical_annotations": 94869, "root_tactical_annotations": 511, "search_tactical_annotations": 94358, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 48809, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 167635345, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 89136, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 571649146, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15466, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 318973644, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 24402, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 22304701, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 84, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 215901, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 48804, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 3816761, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 23773, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 86626908, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 48542, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 165559623, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 22554, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2519075, "child_limit_applications": 7648, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 7648, "child_cap_hits": 7648, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 7648, "child_moves_before_total": 536784, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 536784, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 122370, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 122370, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.18619246861925, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00026150627615, "tt_hits": 2866, "tt_cutoffs": 431, "beta_cutoffs": 6587, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3183.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4783.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1925, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1286, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 3924, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 145, 81, 177, 109, 108, 67, 53, 123 ], "move_count": 15, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 2238, "avg_search_time_ms": 373.0, "search_nodes": 44421, "safety_nodes": 201, "corridor_nodes": 407, "corridor_branch_probes": 499, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 160, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 400, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 400, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 160, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 288, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23981440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 45029, "avg_nodes": 7504.833333333333, "eval_calls": 33782, "avg_eval_calls": 5630.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33782, "pattern_eval_ns": 621554, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.398969865608905, "pattern_frame_queries": 33782, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 621554, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.398969865608905, "pattern_frame_updates": 88798, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 574948183, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6474.787528998401, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9981, "avg_candidate_generations": 1663.5, "candidate_moves_total": 675921, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.72076946197775, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 377, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 9975, "search_candidate_moves_total": 675544, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 256882, "avg_legality_checks": 42813.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 149, "root_legality_checks": 377, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 256505, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 149, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1023090, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 170515.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1280438909, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1251.5408312074208, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6782, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1130.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19245611, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2837.7485992332645, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 151, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 744613, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3035, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13544966, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3567, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4806512, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 149520, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 25484, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4247.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 149813070, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5878.710955893895, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 35666, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5944.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 71239156, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1997.396848539225, "stage_move_gen_ns": 369396641, "stage_ordering_ns": 163517213, "stage_eval_ns": 575569737, "stage_threat_ns": 1044810827, "stage_proof_ns": 62581402, "tactical_annotations": 86615, "root_tactical_annotations": 838, "search_tactical_annotations": 85777, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 89680, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 307663040, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 113644, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 684502951, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20275, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 459459815, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 44837, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 41193537, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 876, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2470991, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 89674, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7007951, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 16795, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 31346865, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 50557, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 157189559, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 19263, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1972357, "child_limit_applications": 9975, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9975, "child_cap_hits": 9975, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9975, "child_moves_before_total": 675395, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 675395, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 159637, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 159637, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.70877192982456, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.003709273182956, "tt_hits": 4007, "tt_cutoffs": 642, "beta_cutoffs": 7756, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3694.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5027.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1547, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 7, "search_move_count": 5, "total_time_ms": 1683, "avg_search_time_ms": 336.6, "search_nodes": 24380, "safety_nodes": 235, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 24615, "avg_nodes": 4923.0, "eval_calls": 16281, "avg_eval_calls": 3256.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 16281, "pattern_eval_ns": 298711, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.347214544561144, "pattern_frame_queries": 16281, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 298711, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.347214544561144, "pattern_frame_updates": 48720, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 279701586, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5741.001354679803, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7653, "avg_candidate_generations": 1530.6, "candidate_moves_total": 537243, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.20031360250881, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 5, "root_candidate_moves_total": 300, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 7648, "search_candidate_moves_total": 536943, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 358949, "avg_legality_checks": 71789.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 159, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 358949, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 159, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 922399, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 184479.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1065589658, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1155.23722163619, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4539, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 907.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9830998, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2165.895131086142, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 159, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 851712, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1157, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6772076, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3223, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2207210, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37738, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7547.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 210231558, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5570.818750331231, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 55429, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11085.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 104472908, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1884.8059319128977, "stage_move_gen_ns": 484207233, "stage_ordering_ns": 128144848, "stage_eval_ns": 280000297, "stage_threat_ns": 772706385, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 94869, "root_tactical_annotations": 511, "search_tactical_annotations": 94358, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 48725, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 170259420, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 87644, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 573516780, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15326, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 320492515, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 24360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 22549176, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 48720, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4130356, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 23773, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 85476822, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 48542, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 167520163, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 22554, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2250653, "child_limit_applications": 7648, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 7648, "child_cap_hits": 7648, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 7648, "child_moves_before_total": 536784, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 536784, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 122370, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 122370, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.18619246861925, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00026150627615, "tt_hits": 2866, "tt_cutoffs": 431, "beta_cutoffs": 6587, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3194.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4794.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1919, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1287, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4089, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 95, 129, 79, 63, 97, 115, 116, 101, 87, 157 ], "move_count": 17, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1972, "avg_search_time_ms": 281.7142857142857, "search_nodes": 44628, "safety_nodes": 441, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 45069, "avg_nodes": 6438.428571428572, "eval_calls": 34491, "avg_eval_calls": 4927.285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34491, "pattern_eval_ns": 635614, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.428401612014728, "pattern_frame_queries": 34491, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 635614, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.428401612014728, "pattern_frame_updates": 89202, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 496608808, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5567.2384924104845, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9657, "avg_candidate_generations": 1379.5714285714287, "candidate_moves_total": 674626, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.85875530703117, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 439, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 9650, "search_candidate_moves_total": 674187, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 249767, "avg_legality_checks": 35681.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 439, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 249328, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 829029, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 118432.71428571429, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1075861025, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1297.7362975239707, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3574, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 510.57142857142856, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6512681, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1822.2386681589255, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 36, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 118520, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1284, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 4638870, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2252, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1752381, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2910, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 19230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2747.1428571428573, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 106340999, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5529.953146125845, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25901, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3700.1428571428573, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 47475185, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1832.947955677387, "stage_move_gen_ns": 366825022, "stage_ordering_ns": 168597294, "stage_eval_ns": 497244422, "stage_threat_ns": 918474189, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 72817, "root_tactical_annotations": 738, "search_tactical_annotations": 72079, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 89209, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 303297800, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 78249, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 566166790, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19340, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 418825254, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 44601, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 40679365, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 89202, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6933629, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 12967, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 21111451, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 45937, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 126118125, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 13913, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1396605, "child_limit_applications": 9650, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9650, "child_cap_hits": 9650, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9650, "child_moves_before_total": 674163, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 674163, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 154401, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 154401, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.86145077720207, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000103626943005, "tt_hits": 3662, "tt_cutoffs": 460, "beta_cutoffs": 7380, "depth_sum": 27, "avg_depth": 3.857142857142857, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 27, "avg_effective_depth": 3.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4360.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5503.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1437, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 2112, "avg_search_time_ms": 352.0, "search_nodes": 28563, "safety_nodes": 232, "corridor_nodes": 264, "corridor_branch_probes": 335, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 86, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 258, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 258, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 50, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 411, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 369840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 17520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 29059, "avg_nodes": 4843.166666666667, "eval_calls": 18627, "avg_eval_calls": 3104.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 18627, "pattern_eval_ns": 339692, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.236538358297096, "pattern_frame_queries": 18627, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 339692, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.236538358297096, "pattern_frame_updates": 57076, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 277877450, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 4868.551580349008, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9328, "avg_candidate_generations": 1554.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 682426, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.15887650085763, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 369, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 9322, "search_candidate_moves_total": 682057, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 522601, "avg_legality_checks": 87100.16666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 67, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 522601, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 67, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1194120, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 199020.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1365970911, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1143.9142724349313, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3940, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 656.6666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3720883, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 944.3865482233502, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 323763, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 396, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 2004857, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3477, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1392263, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7576.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 242177147, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5327.140780009238, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 64519, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10753.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 113927584, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1765.7989739456593, "stage_move_gen_ns": 690160355, "stage_ordering_ns": 158846532, "stage_eval_ns": 278217142, "stage_threat_ns": 914342665, "stage_proof_ns": 46184680, "tactical_annotations": 129466, "root_tactical_annotations": 891, "search_tactical_annotations": 128575, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 57698, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 197546472, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 132071, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 680494888, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19008, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 380552623, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 28846, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 26390793, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 616, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1801967, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 57692, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4461499, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 38157, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 105543522, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 56181, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 186165967, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 35128, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3647046, "child_limit_applications": 9322, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9322, "child_cap_hits": 9322, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9322, "child_moves_before_total": 681990, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 681990, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 149178, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 149178, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.15919330615748, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002789101051277, "tt_hits": 4285, "tt_cutoffs": 589, "beta_cutoffs": 8113, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3933.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5266.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1922, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1288, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4103, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 95, 129, 79, 63, 97, 115, 116, 101, 87, 157 ], "move_count": 17, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 2030, "avg_search_time_ms": 290.0, "search_nodes": 44628, "safety_nodes": 441, "corridor_nodes": 57, "corridor_branch_probes": 67, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 45, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 49, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 410, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 25748160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 45126, "avg_nodes": 6446.571428571428, "eval_calls": 34491, "avg_eval_calls": 4927.285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34491, "pattern_eval_ns": 630953, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.293264909686584, "pattern_frame_queries": 34491, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 630953, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.293264909686584, "pattern_frame_updates": 89202, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 497784394, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5580.417412165646, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9657, "avg_candidate_generations": 1379.5714285714287, "candidate_moves_total": 674626, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.85875530703117, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 439, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 9650, "search_candidate_moves_total": 674187, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 249767, "avg_legality_checks": 35681.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 439, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 249328, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 867126, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 123875.14285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1117440068, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1288.6709290230024, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3584, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 512.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 6616750, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1846.19140625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 36, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 116490, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1284, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 4762613, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2256, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1713757, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 23890, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 19353, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2764.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 100847840, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5210.966775176975, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26067, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3723.8571428571427, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 45196242, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1733.8490044884336, "stage_move_gen_ns": 354340702, "stage_ordering_ns": 167488128, "stage_eval_ns": 498415347, "stage_threat_ns": 936603371, "stage_proof_ns": 53094710, "tactical_annotations": 72817, "root_tactical_annotations": 738, "search_tactical_annotations": 72079, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 89413, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 304598655, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 82811, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 581758681, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19559, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 436107965, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 44703, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 41376153, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 204, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 508481, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 89406, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6938601, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 12967, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 18675055, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 45937, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 121733953, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 13913, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1422800, "child_limit_applications": 9650, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9650, "child_cap_hits": 9650, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9650, "child_moves_before_total": 674163, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 674163, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 154401, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 154401, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.86145077720207, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000103626943005, "tt_hits": 3662, "tt_cutoffs": 460, "beta_cutoffs": 7380, "depth_sum": 27, "avg_depth": 3.857142857142857, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 27, "avg_effective_depth": 3.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4328.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5470.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1412, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 2067, "avg_search_time_ms": 344.5, "search_nodes": 28563, "safety_nodes": 232, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 28795, "avg_nodes": 4799.166666666667, "eval_calls": 18627, "avg_eval_calls": 3104.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 18627, "pattern_eval_ns": 342541, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.389488377087023, "pattern_frame_queries": 18627, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 342541, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.389488377087023, "pattern_frame_updates": 57076, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 283168237, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 4961.248808606069, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9328, "avg_candidate_generations": 1554.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 682426, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.15887650085763, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 369, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 9322, "search_candidate_moves_total": 682057, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 522601, "avg_legality_checks": 87100.16666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 67, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 522601, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 67, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159168, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 193194.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1345243962, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1160.5254475623897, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3920, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 653.3333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 3593717, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 916.7645408163265, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 334101, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 396, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 2018012, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3457, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1241604, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7576.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 240990577, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5301.039946327622, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 64519, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10753.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 113732207, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1762.7707652009485, "stage_move_gen_ns": 698919816, "stage_ordering_ns": 159892527, "stage_eval_ns": 283510778, "stage_threat_ns": 900831539, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 129466, "root_tactical_annotations": 891, "search_tactical_annotations": 128575, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 57082, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 194263958, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 113023, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 672413305, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18681, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 382475587, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 28538, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 26237322, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 57076, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4388240, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 38157, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 106039071, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 56181, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 183869217, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 35128, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3528714, "child_limit_applications": 9322, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9322, "child_cap_hits": 9322, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9322, "child_moves_before_total": 681990, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 681990, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 149178, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 149178, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.15919330615748, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002789101051277, "tt_hits": 4285, "tt_cutoffs": 589, "beta_cutoffs": 8113, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3951.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5285.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1923, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1289, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8374, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 97, 127, 126, 143, 159, 79, 95, 113, 158, 83, 110, 98 ], "move_count": 16, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 4124, "avg_search_time_ms": 687.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 48447, "safety_nodes": 276, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48723, "avg_nodes": 8120.5, "eval_calls": 36540, "avg_eval_calls": 6090.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36540, "pattern_eval_ns": 754363, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.644854953475644, "pattern_frame_queries": 36540, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 754363, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.644854953475644, "pattern_frame_updates": 96842, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 975081101, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10068.783182916502, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11162, "avg_candidate_generations": 1860.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 709090, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.52714567281849, "candidate_moves_max": 87, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 328, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 11156, "search_candidate_moves_total": 708762, "search_candidate_moves_max": 87, "legality_checks": 379799, "avg_legality_checks": 63299.833333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 167, "root_legality_checks": 328, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 379471, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 164, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1132228, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 188704.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2500365211, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2208.358396895325, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5290, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 881.6666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18029537, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3408.230056710775, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 177, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1840221, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1820, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11219004, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3276, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4794781, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 175531, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28779, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4796.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 250037692, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8688.199450988568, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41247, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6874.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 103136215, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2500.45372996824, "stage_move_gen_ns": 942661146, "stage_ordering_ns": 313166922, "stage_eval_ns": 975835464, "stage_threat_ns": 1870179496, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 91914, "root_tactical_annotations": 580, "search_tactical_annotations": 91334, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 96848, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 563419834, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 100767, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1226394281, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22350, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 881014518, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48421, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 66866226, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 96842, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11927140, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 10551, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 23500718, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 67861, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 321615934, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 13502, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1572015, "child_limit_applications": 11156, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11156, "child_cap_hits": 11156, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11156, "child_moves_before_total": 708598, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 708598, "child_moves_before_max": 87, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 87, "child_moves_after_total": 178496, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 178496, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 63.517210469702405, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 2770, "tt_cutoffs": 726, "beta_cutoffs": 8770, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2043.8333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3358.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 4246, "avg_search_time_ms": 707.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 56929, "safety_nodes": 284, "corridor_nodes": 59, "corridor_branch_probes": 66, "corridor_max_depth": 6, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 53, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 53, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 9, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 9, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 6, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2008400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1978720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 57272, "avg_nodes": 9545.333333333334, "eval_calls": 46486, "avg_eval_calls": 7747.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46486, "pattern_eval_ns": 961015, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.673213440605775, "pattern_frame_queries": 46486, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 961015, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.673213440605775, "pattern_frame_updates": 113810, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1021090712, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8971.88921887356, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9866, "avg_candidate_generations": 1644.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 677561, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.67636326778836, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 340, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 9860, "search_candidate_moves_total": 677221, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 390009, "avg_legality_checks": 65001.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 526, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 390009, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 526, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1170835, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 195139.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2484058610, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2121.6128745724204, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5221, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 870.1666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19079863, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3654.446083125838, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 526, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5988628, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 614, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 5615922, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4048, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7117671, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 33, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 357642, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 32090, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5348.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 320866797, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9998.965316297912, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50316, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8386.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 153586124, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3052.4311153509816, "stage_move_gen_ns": 961550607, "stage_ordering_ns": 288192182, "stage_eval_ns": 1022051727, "stage_threat_ns": 1936029123, "stage_proof_ns": 15598281, "tactical_annotations": 137177, "root_tactical_annotations": 833, "search_tactical_annotations": 136344, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 113940, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 649776242, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 125959, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1189494178, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19842, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 759389632, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56967, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 78238554, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 124, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 520634, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 113934, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13975078, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 26665, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 124465590, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 73494, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 301573076, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 37018, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4024437, "child_limit_applications": 9860, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9860, "child_cap_hits": 9860, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9860, "child_moves_before_total": 676695, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 676695, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 157760, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 157760, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.63032454361054, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 4040, "tt_cutoffs": 559, "beta_cutoffs": 6782, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2923.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4218.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1828, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1290, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 39443, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 97, 127, 126, 143, 159, 158, 113, 95, 79, 173, 188, 129, 98, 140, 101, 110, 125, 157, 171, 130, 131, 116, 144, 100, 84, 70, 83, 68, 115, 67, 69, 81, 99, 147, 54, 39, 114 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 14989, "avg_search_time_ms": 788.8947368421053, "search_nodes": 157593, "safety_nodes": 1584, "corridor_nodes": 908, "corridor_branch_probes": 994, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 317, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_plies_followed": 884, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 884, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 130, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 106, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 317, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 130, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 129, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 925, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 540880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 17520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 160085, "avg_nodes": 8425.526315789473, "eval_calls": 114451, "avg_eval_calls": 6023.736842105263, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 114451, "pattern_eval_ns": 2352831, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.557539907908186, "pattern_frame_queries": 114451, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2352831, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.557539907908186, "pattern_frame_updates": 315012, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3816879205, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12116.615255926758, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39982, "avg_candidate_generations": 2104.315789473684, "candidate_moves_total": 3500557, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.55332399579811, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1480, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 39963, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3499077, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 1409017, "avg_legality_checks": 74158.78947368421, "illegal_moves_skipped": 835, "root_legality_checks": 1480, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1407537, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 832, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4258468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 224129.8947368421, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9086827896, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2133.825567316697, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31917, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1679.842105263158, "renju_forbidden_ns": 94511409, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2961.16204530501, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1571, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9570456, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11335, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 53458079, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18835, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30749341, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 176, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 733533, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 87966, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4629.789473684211, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 749517370, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8520.534865743582, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118831, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6254.263157894737, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 316132815, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2660.356430561049, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3269507535, "stage_ordering_ns": 1325931163, "stage_eval_ns": 3819232036, "stage_threat_ns": 6183401517, "stage_proof_ns": 316465778, "tactical_annotations": 739685, "root_tactical_annotations": 2778, "search_tactical_annotations": 736907, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 317059, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1795177073, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 735169, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4091123031, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 81045, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2720491529, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 158520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 226238950, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2028, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14178970, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 317040, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38498528, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 228610, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 92861550, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 368831, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1165721234, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 142244, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18184965, "child_limit_applications": 39963, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39963, "child_cap_hits": 39963, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39963, "child_moves_before_total": 3498245, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3498245, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 639416, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 639416, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.53709681455346, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000200185171284, "tt_hits": 15496, "tt_cutoffs": 3093, "beta_cutoffs": 32459, "depth_sum": 86, "avg_depth": 4.526315789473684, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 86, "avg_effective_depth": 4.526315789473684, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.10526315789473684, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6057.315789473684, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6478.368421052632, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 24438, "avg_search_time_ms": 1357.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 217454, "safety_nodes": 705, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 218159, "avg_nodes": 12119.944444444445, "eval_calls": 157881, "avg_eval_calls": 8771.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 157881, "pattern_eval_ns": 3268537, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.702535453917825, "pattern_frame_queries": 157881, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3268537, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.702535453917825, "pattern_frame_updates": 434738, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4466225770, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10273.37331910254, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 56002, "avg_candidate_generations": 3111.222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 5229465, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.37996857255098, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1414, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 55984, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5228051, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 3891972, "avg_legality_checks": 216220.66666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6398, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3891972, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6398, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7721450, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 428969.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15921747726, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2062.0152595691225, "renju_forbidden_checks": 85793, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4766.277777777777, "renju_forbidden_ns": 247484357, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2884.6684111757368, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8876, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 66099832, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14946, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 79949454, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 61956, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 101286281, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 148790, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 203355, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11297.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1786956795, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8787.375746846648, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 275777, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15320.944444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 780400187, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2829.8233246427367, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8838745783, "stage_ordering_ns": 1959644990, "stage_eval_ns": 4469494307, "stage_threat_ns": 9012712774, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1217217, "root_tactical_annotations": 4636, "search_tactical_annotations": 1212581, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 434756, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2429114071, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1070284, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6188185990, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 112089, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3606628375, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 217369, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 308006921, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 434738, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52286300, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 426149, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 733226633, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 532031, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1848222491, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 259037, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 35119492, "child_limit_applications": 55984, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 55984, "child_cap_hits": 55984, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 55984, "child_moves_before_total": 5221653, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5221653, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 895769, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 895769, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.27045227207773, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000446556158902, "tt_hits": 23491, "tt_cutoffs": 3505, "beta_cutoffs": 45617, "depth_sum": 84, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 84, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5245.944444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5690.388888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1835, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1291, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 41107, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 129, 98, 96, 128, 143, 99, 101, 115, 68, 82, 127, 95, 66, 131, 83, 114, 67, 130, 146, 117, 116, 147, 163, 65, 108, 109, 81, 51, 80, 94, 142, 79, 157, 172, 64, 48, 171, 185, 159, 175, 93, 132, 145, 144, 69, 70, 102, 133, 134, 161, 189, 119 ], "move_count": 58, "black_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 21892, "avg_search_time_ms": 810.8148148148148, "search_nodes": 266562, "safety_nodes": 2401, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 268963, "avg_nodes": 9961.592592592593, "eval_calls": 206922, "avg_eval_calls": 7663.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 206922, "pattern_eval_ns": 4241188, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.4965542571597, "pattern_frame_queries": 206922, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4241188, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.4965542571597, "pattern_frame_updates": 532864, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6585198737, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12358.12277992133, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 56561, "avg_candidate_generations": 2094.8518518518517, "candidate_moves_total": 4853958, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.81810788352398, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2258, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 56534, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4851700, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 1921602, "avg_legality_checks": 71170.44444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 584, "root_legality_checks": 2258, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1919344, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 584, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6290592, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 232984.88888888888, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12932938060, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2055.917481216394, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43784, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1621.6296296296296, "renju_forbidden_ns": 134384671, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3069.2643659784394, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 979, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5464992, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19714, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 92917265, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23079, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 35980554, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 21860, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 176523, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6537.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1321553440, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7486.579312610821, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 212167, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7858.037037037037, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 490391683, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2311.3475846856486, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4329383978, "stage_ordering_ns": 1771278333, "stage_eval_ns": 6589439925, "stage_threat_ns": 9106856830, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1344939, "root_tactical_annotations": 4496, "search_tactical_annotations": 1340443, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 532891, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2960460404, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1191984, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5667509610, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 113252, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3543530517, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 266432, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 380803452, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 532864, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64586984, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 507569, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 396122858, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 571141, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1726642287, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 266229, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33496380, "child_limit_applications": 56534, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 56534, "child_cap_hits": 56534, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 56534, "child_moves_before_total": 4851116, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4851116, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 916693, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 916693, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.80882300916262, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.214897229985496, "tt_hits": 22869, "tt_cutoffs": 2976, "beta_cutoffs": 43030, "depth_sum": 130, "avg_depth": 4.814814814814815, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 130, "avg_effective_depth": 4.814814814814815, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 25 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14814814814814814, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6293.2962962962965, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6589.592592592592, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1097, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 19188, "avg_search_time_ms": 710.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 184664, "safety_nodes": 2187, "corridor_nodes": 4631, "corridor_branch_probes": 5359, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 2349, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 135, "corridor_plies_followed": 4601, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4601, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 25, "corridor_proof_completed": 25, "corridor_proof_checks": 133, "corridor_proof_active": 30, "corridor_proof_quiet": 103, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2349, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 135, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 133, "corridor_proof_wins": 6, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 127, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 900, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 367440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 17280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 191482, "avg_nodes": 7091.925925925926, "eval_calls": 133315, "avg_eval_calls": 4937.592592592592, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 133315, "pattern_eval_ns": 2746824, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.60401305179462, "pattern_frame_queries": 133315, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2746824, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.60401305179462, "pattern_frame_updates": 369074, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3423968430, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9277.18677013282, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49258, "avg_candidate_generations": 1824.3703703703704, "candidate_moves_total": 4492460, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.20264728572009, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 115, "search_candidate_generations": 49231, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4490158, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 2751581, "avg_legality_checks": 101910.4074074074, "illegal_moves_skipped": 133, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2751581, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 133, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6156122, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 228004.5185185185, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12004059048, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1949.938459309286, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32537, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1205.0740740740741, "renju_forbidden_ns": 53740386, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1651.6699757199497, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 167, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 955092, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3808, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18221165, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28562, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 34564129, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 198085, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7336.481481481482, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1604490075, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8100.00795113209, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 253437, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9386.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 688461174, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2716.4982776784764, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5955566539, "stage_ordering_ns": 1571082114, "stage_eval_ns": 3426715254, "stage_threat_ns": 7946073167, "stage_proof_ns": 186827538, "tactical_annotations": 1205557, "root_tactical_annotations": 3428, "search_tactical_annotations": 1202129, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 378569, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2139533831, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1298210, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5394582999, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 100851, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2945475718, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 189271, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 272271349, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9468, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 65620602, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 378542, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45522369, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 490669, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 928027938, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 502705, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1388298499, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 212183, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28542017, "child_limit_applications": 49231, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49231, "child_cap_hits": 49231, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49231, "child_moves_before_total": 4490025, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4490025, "child_moves_before_max": 131, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 131, "child_moves_after_total": 797800, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 797800, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.20320529747517, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.205236537953727, "tt_hits": 18158, "tt_cutoffs": 1991, "beta_cutoffs": 41038, "depth_sum": 127, "avg_depth": 4.703703703703703, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 127, "avg_effective_depth": 4.703703703703703, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 25 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14814814814814814, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6551.185185185185, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6847.481481481482, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1885, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1292, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 40749, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 129, 98, 96, 128, 143, 99, 101, 115, 68, 82, 127, 95, 66, 131, 83, 114, 67, 130, 146, 117, 116, 147, 163, 65, 108, 109, 81, 51, 80, 94, 142, 79, 157, 172, 64, 48, 171, 185, 159, 175, 93, 132, 145, 144, 69, 70, 102, 133, 134, 161, 189, 119 ], "move_count": 58, "black_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 26450, "avg_search_time_ms": 979.6296296296297, "search_nodes": 266562, "safety_nodes": 2401, "corridor_nodes": 59498, "corridor_branch_probes": 67641, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 72, "corridor_depth_exits": 33174, "corridor_neutral_exits": 175, "corridor_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_plies_followed": 59373, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 59343, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 30, "corridor_proof_passes": 25, "corridor_proof_completed": 25, "corridor_proof_checks": 269, "corridor_proof_active": 125, "corridor_proof_quiet": 144, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 247, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 33174, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 269, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 6, "corridor_proof_unknown": 263, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 2009, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 125776800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2011600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 328461, "avg_nodes": 12165.222222222223, "eval_calls": 206922, "avg_eval_calls": 7663.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 206922, "pattern_eval_ns": 4021869, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.436642792936468, "pattern_frame_queries": 206922, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4021869, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.436642792936468, "pattern_frame_updates": 532864, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5458267631, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10243.265882101248, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 56561, "avg_candidate_generations": 2094.8518518518517, "candidate_moves_total": 4853958, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.81810788352398, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2258, "root_candidate_moves_max": 116, "search_candidate_generations": 56534, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4851700, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 1921602, "avg_legality_checks": 71170.44444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 584, "root_legality_checks": 2258, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1919344, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 584, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11332503, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 419722.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16234203007, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1432.534631316665, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48787, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1806.9259259259259, "renju_forbidden_ns": 119150179, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2442.252628774059, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 979, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4394752, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19714, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 79815150, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23276, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29274627, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4818, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5665650, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 267717, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9915.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1479087256, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5524.816339642234, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 314649, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11653.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 591509363, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1879.902249808517, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3535212766, "stage_ordering_ns": 1417653315, "stage_eval_ns": 5462289500, "stage_threat_ns": 13374356590, "stage_proof_ns": 2561457387, "tactical_annotations": 1344939, "root_tactical_annotations": 4496, "search_tactical_annotations": 1340443, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 652175, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3479643343, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3615780, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8809106008, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 139637, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3763910284, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 326074, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 424094644, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 119284, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 569484711, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 652148, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63762532, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 507569, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 302195093, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 571141, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1403491265, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 266229, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28265352, "child_limit_applications": 56534, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 56534, "child_cap_hits": 56534, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 56534, "child_moves_before_total": 4851116, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4851116, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 916693, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 916693, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.80882300916262, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.214897229985496, "tt_hits": 22869, "tt_cutoffs": 2976, "beta_cutoffs": 43030, "depth_sum": 130, "avg_depth": 4.814814814814815, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 130, "avg_effective_depth": 4.814814814814815, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 25 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6039.592592592592, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6335.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1059, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 14270, "avg_search_time_ms": 528.5185185185185, "search_nodes": 184664, "safety_nodes": 2187, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 186851, "avg_nodes": 6920.407407407408, "eval_calls": 133315, "avg_eval_calls": 4937.592592592592, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 133315, "pattern_eval_ns": 2570016, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.27777069347035, "pattern_frame_queries": 133315, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2570016, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.27777069347035, "pattern_frame_updates": 369074, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2682125226, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7267.174674997426, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49258, "avg_candidate_generations": 1824.3703703703704, "candidate_moves_total": 4492460, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.20264728572009, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 115, "search_candidate_generations": 49231, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4490158, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 2751581, "avg_legality_checks": 101910.4074074074, "illegal_moves_skipped": 133, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2751581, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 133, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6044730, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 223878.88888888888, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8851794288, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1464.3820795966074, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32448, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1201.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37331065, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1150.4889361439841, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 167, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 608327, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3808, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15208544, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28473, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21514194, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 198085, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7336.481481481482, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1188183075, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5998.349572153368, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 253437, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9386.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 511877569, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2019.7428512805943, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4373833096, "stage_ordering_ns": 1199663140, "stage_eval_ns": 2684695242, "stage_threat_ns": 5890379958, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1205557, "root_tactical_annotations": 3428, "search_tactical_annotations": 1202129, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 369101, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1577666081, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1092034, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4044681930, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 98642, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2328762479, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 184537, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 211127076, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 369074, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35474899, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 490669, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 663640246, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 502705, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1052007285, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 212183, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21429972, "child_limit_applications": 49231, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49231, "child_cap_hits": 49231, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49231, "child_moves_before_total": 4490025, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4490025, "child_moves_before_max": 131, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 131, "child_moves_after_total": 797800, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 797800, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.20320529747517, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.205236537953727, "tt_hits": 18158, "tt_cutoffs": 1991, "beta_cutoffs": 41038, "depth_sum": 127, "avg_depth": 4.703703703703703, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 127, "avg_effective_depth": 4.703703703703703, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 25 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.037037037037037035, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6627.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6923.2962962962965, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1888, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1293, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14837, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 84, 98, 83, 85, 99, 97, 129, 69, 115, 67, 101, 95, 94, 143, 131, 147, 116, 146, 128, 130, 86, 71, 114, 144, 145, 68, 70, 65, 66, 81, 49, 53, 39, 109 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 10137, "avg_search_time_ms": 596.2941176470588, "search_nodes": 148797, "safety_nodes": 470, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 149267, "avg_nodes": 8780.411764705883, "eval_calls": 106920, "avg_eval_calls": 6289.411764705882, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 106920, "pattern_eval_ns": 2125044, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.875084175084176, "pattern_frame_queries": 106920, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2125044, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.875084175084176, "pattern_frame_updates": 297434, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2529770647, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8505.31764021598, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39926, "avg_candidate_generations": 2348.5882352941176, "candidate_moves_total": 3054822, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.51209738015328, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1177, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 39909, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3053645, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 959381, "avg_legality_checks": 56434.17647058824, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1179, "root_legality_checks": 1177, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 958204, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1178, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3410298, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 200605.76470588235, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5775489320, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1693.5438838482737, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34846, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2049.764705882353, "renju_forbidden_ns": 91941496, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2638.5093267519946, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1536, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10100709, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11676, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 53265713, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21622, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28492763, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 82311, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 102825, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6048.529411764706, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 675762003, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6571.962100656455, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 133938, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7878.705882352941, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 261667518, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1953.6465976795234, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1827896858, "stage_ordering_ns": 979507751, "stage_eval_ns": 2531895691, "stage_threat_ns": 4728832367, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 659679, "root_tactical_annotations": 3556, "search_tactical_annotations": 656123, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 297451, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1335508447, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 580094, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3174336636, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 79932, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2162606841, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148717, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 171746717, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 297434, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29650100, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 222853, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 200384157, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 277298, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 811335078, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 159528, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17590467, "child_limit_applications": 39909, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39909, "child_cap_hits": 39909, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39909, "child_moves_before_total": 3052467, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3052467, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 639383, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 639383, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.48567992182214, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02102282693127, "tt_hits": 17643, "tt_cutoffs": 1888, "beta_cutoffs": 33055, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6119.823529411765, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6590.411764705882, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1071, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 4679, "avg_search_time_ms": 275.2352941176471, "search_nodes": 61131, "safety_nodes": 1854, "corridor_nodes": 591, "corridor_branch_probes": 657, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 226, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 576, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 576, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 226, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 344, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 111840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 24560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 63576, "avg_nodes": 3739.764705882353, "eval_calls": 44735, "avg_eval_calls": 2631.470588235294, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44735, "pattern_eval_ns": 884094, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.7629149435565, "pattern_frame_queries": 44735, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 884094, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.7629149435565, "pattern_frame_updates": 122108, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 923157663, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7560.173477577227, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15639, "avg_candidate_generations": 919.9411764705883, "candidate_moves_total": 1081064, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.12615896157044, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1203, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 15622, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1079861, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 555275, "avg_legality_checks": 32663.235294117647, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3385, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 555275, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3385, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1696757, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 99809.23529411765, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2784398260, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1641.0118007469543, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16437, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 966.8823529411765, "renju_forbidden_ns": 89147332, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5423.576808420028, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3444, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30553811, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4899, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38231158, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8034, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19798421, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 563942, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 61788, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3634.5882352941176, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 449238399, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7270.641532336376, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84842, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4990.705882352941, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 200833090, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2367.1423351641874, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1098351625, "stage_ordering_ns": 346460320, "stage_eval_ns": 924041757, "stage_threat_ns": 2178481286, "stage_proof_ns": 89778792, "tactical_annotations": 244976, "root_tactical_annotations": 708, "search_tactical_annotations": 244268, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 123405, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 572067651, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 270137, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1512597847, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31889, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 878866055, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61694, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 70522237, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1280, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7281047, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 123388, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12351634, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 63430, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 196031280, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 138940, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 415522121, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 42606, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3660870, "child_limit_applications": 15622, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15622, "child_cap_hits": 15622, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15622, "child_moves_before_total": 1076476, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1076476, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 250330, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 250330, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.90769427730125, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.024196645755985, "tt_hits": 4970, "tt_cutoffs": 697, "beta_cutoffs": 12692, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6292.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6762.588235294118, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1147, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1294, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20443, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 84, 98, 83, 85, 99, 97, 129, 69, 115, 67, 101, 95, 94, 143, 131, 147, 116, 146, 100, 68, 132, 148, 130, 128, 133 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 14974, "avg_search_time_ms": 1151.8461538461538, "search_nodes": 129385, "safety_nodes": 460, "corridor_nodes": 11842, "corridor_branch_probes": 12707, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 5460, "corridor_neutral_exits": 63, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 11794, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 11794, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 133, "corridor_proof_active": 48, "corridor_proof_quiet": 85, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 63, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5460, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 133, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 131, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1096, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 30494240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 141687, "avg_nodes": 10899.0, "eval_calls": 94918, "avg_eval_calls": 7301.384615384615, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 94918, "pattern_eval_ns": 2048206, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.578688973640407, "pattern_frame_queries": 94918, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2048206, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.578688973640407, "pattern_frame_updates": 258656, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2845088603, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10999.507465514042, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32913, "avg_candidate_generations": 2531.769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 2440795, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.15899492601707, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 850, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 32900, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2439945, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 819427, "avg_legality_checks": 63032.846153846156, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1094, "root_legality_checks": 850, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 818577, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1093, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4299218, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 330709.07692307694, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9246322854, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2150.6987675433065, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28740, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2210.769230769231, "renju_forbidden_ns": 122514565, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4262.858907446068, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1299, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11680196, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10432, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 65596844, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15146, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31791780, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1863, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13445745, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 106859, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8219.923076923076, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 901557472, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8436.88853535968, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137608, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10585.23076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 375267313, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2727.0748284983433, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2029118387, "stage_ordering_ns": 995743015, "stage_eval_ns": 2847136809, "stage_threat_ns": 7591352489, "stage_proof_ns": 1449225013, "tactical_annotations": 488545, "root_tactical_annotations": 2808, "search_tactical_annotations": 485737, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 282523, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1824691998, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1083205, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5347175204, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 72282, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2730426005, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 141255, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 212299989, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 23854, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 154503579, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 282510, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35761635, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 151119, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 171387017, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 218984, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 851399176, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 118442, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16920084, "child_limit_applications": 32900, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32900, "child_cap_hits": 32900, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32900, "child_moves_before_total": 2438852, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2438852, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 527152, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 527152, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.12924012158055, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02285714285714, "tt_hits": 13959, "tt_cutoffs": 1510, "beta_cutoffs": 26825, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3607.6153846153848, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4223.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 374, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5455, "avg_search_time_ms": 454.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 57055, "safety_nodes": 1135, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 58190, "avg_nodes": 4849.166666666667, "eval_calls": 41971, "avg_eval_calls": 3497.5833333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41971, "pattern_eval_ns": 909717, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.674894570060278, "pattern_frame_queries": 41971, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 909717, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.674894570060278, "pattern_frame_updates": 114000, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1130671213, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9918.16853508772, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14399, "avg_candidate_generations": 1199.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 976493, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.8167233835683, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 790, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 14387, "search_candidate_moves_total": 975703, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 506422, "avg_legality_checks": 42201.833333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3410, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 506422, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3410, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1518658, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 126554.83333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3268052702, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2151.934604104413, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14131, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1177.5833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 103706412, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7338.929445899087, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3414, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 36350140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4822, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 46604345, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5885, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20629047, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 122880, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 56711, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4725.916666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 528592951, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9320.818730052371, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 77362, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6446.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 235311616, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3041.6950957834597, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1303592791, "stage_ordering_ns": 411205658, "stage_eval_ns": 1131580930, "stage_threat_ns": 2566954257, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 213089, "root_tactical_annotations": 626, "search_tactical_annotations": 212463, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 114012, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 690697592, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 205713, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1774233719, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28853, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1057175432, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 82403514, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 114000, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14705972, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 49783, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 206912796, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 127068, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 509837581, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 36238, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4913460, "child_limit_applications": 14387, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14387, "child_cap_hits": 14387, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14387, "child_moves_before_total": 972293, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 972293, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 230655, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 230655, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.58135817057065, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.03218183081949, "tt_hits": 4377, "tt_cutoffs": 642, "beta_cutoffs": 11642, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5139.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5806.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 452, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1295, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8770, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 141, 99, 125, 85, 71, 97, 109, 108, 93, 77, 157 ], "move_count": 17, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 3604, "avg_search_time_ms": 514.8571428571429, "search_nodes": 46127, "safety_nodes": 441, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 46568, "avg_nodes": 6652.571428571428, "eval_calls": 35579, "avg_eval_calls": 5082.714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35579, "pattern_eval_ns": 775754, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.803704432389893, "pattern_frame_queries": 35579, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 775754, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.803704432389893, "pattern_frame_updates": 92200, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 859193961, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9318.806518438178, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10067, "avg_candidate_generations": 1438.142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 707974, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.32621436376279, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 439, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 10060, "search_candidate_moves_total": 707535, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 286364, "avg_legality_checks": 40909.142857142855, "illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "root_legality_checks": 439, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 285925, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 902043, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 128863.28571428571, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2067599645, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2292.129804233279, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4091, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 584.4285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12330621, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3014.0848203373257, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 227330, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1394, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9038158, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2661, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3062113, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21925, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3132.1428571428573, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 207773740, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9476.567388825542, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 29827, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4261.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 92666373, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3106.7949508834276, "stage_move_gen_ns": 733500463, "stage_ordering_ns": 319287515, "stage_eval_ns": 859969715, "stage_threat_ns": 1668421110, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 78223, "root_tactical_annotations": 738, "search_tactical_annotations": 77485, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 92207, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 541693704, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 84279, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1047326456, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20160, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 765390154, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 46100, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 66206401, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 92200, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11339088, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 14553, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 40083271, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 49561, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 241665140, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 14109, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1855461, "child_limit_applications": 10060, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10060, "child_cap_hits": 10060, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10060, "child_moves_before_total": 707513, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 707513, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 160961, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 160961, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.329324055666, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000099403578528, "tt_hits": 3731, "tt_cutoffs": 461, "beta_cutoffs": 7722, "depth_sum": 27, "avg_depth": 3.857142857142857, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 27, "avg_effective_depth": 3.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3515.4285714285716, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4658.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1056, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 5159, "avg_search_time_ms": 859.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 35792, "safety_nodes": 232, "corridor_nodes": 264, "corridor_branch_probes": 335, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 86, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 258, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 258, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 50, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 411, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 344880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 17520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 36288, "avg_nodes": 6048.0, "eval_calls": 23146, "avg_eval_calls": 3857.6666666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23146, "pattern_eval_ns": 511923, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.117126069299232, "pattern_frame_queries": 23146, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 511923, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.117126069299232, "pattern_frame_updates": 71534, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 615416885, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8603.138158078676, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11907, "avg_candidate_generations": 1984.5, "candidate_moves_total": 896405, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.28386663307299, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 369, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 11901, "search_candidate_moves_total": 896036, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 720378, "avg_legality_checks": 120063.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 67, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 720378, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 67, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1606148, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 267691.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3484795291, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2169.6601377955208, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6464, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1077.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 11031551, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1706.6137066831684, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 676752, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 709, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7358645, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5688, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2996154, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 66000, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11000.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 645816390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9785.096818181819, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 94683, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15780.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 308444909, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3257.658808867484, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1810048716, "stage_ordering_ns": 393945119, "stage_eval_ns": 615928808, "stage_threat_ns": 2216282247, "stage_proof_ns": 89705248, "tactical_annotations": 166849, "root_tactical_annotations": 891, "search_tactical_annotations": 165958, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 72156, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 446615946, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 176280, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1697656500, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24166, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 906154180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 36075, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 55102582, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 616, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3212152, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 72150, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9278785, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 50610, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 263796447, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 82779, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 512122466, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 33460, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4416282, "child_limit_applications": 11901, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11901, "child_cap_hits": 11901, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11901, "child_moves_before_total": 895969, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 895969, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 190442, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 190442, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.28518611881354, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002184690362153, "tt_hits": 4462, "tt_cutoffs": 720, "beta_cutoffs": 10392, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2446.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3589.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1863, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1296, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8784, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 141, 99, 125, 85, 71, 97, 109, 108, 93, 77, 157 ], "move_count": 17, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 3728, "avg_search_time_ms": 532.5714285714286, "search_nodes": 46127, "safety_nodes": 441, "corridor_nodes": 57, "corridor_branch_probes": 67, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 45, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 49, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 410, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 25749520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 46625, "avg_nodes": 6660.714285714285, "eval_calls": 35579, "avg_eval_calls": 5082.714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35579, "pattern_eval_ns": 781603, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.968099159616628, "pattern_frame_queries": 35579, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 781603, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.968099159616628, "pattern_frame_updates": 92200, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 863120117, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9361.389555314534, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10067, "avg_candidate_generations": 1438.142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 707974, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.32621436376279, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 439, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 10060, "search_candidate_moves_total": 707535, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 286364, "avg_legality_checks": 40909.142857142855, "illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "root_legality_checks": 439, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 285925, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 940140, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 134305.7142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2151849546, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2288.860750526517, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4101, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 585.8571428571429, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12446138, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3034.903194342843, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 226460, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1394, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9071449, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2665, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3105018, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 43211, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 22048, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3149.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 209724062, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9512.1581095791, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 29993, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4284.714285714285, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 93834055, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3128.5318240922884, "stage_move_gen_ns": 734751667, "stage_ordering_ns": 318319057, "stage_eval_ns": 863901720, "stage_threat_ns": 1688996005, "stage_proof_ns": 98109910, "tactical_annotations": 78223, "root_tactical_annotations": 738, "search_tactical_annotations": 77485, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 92411, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 544678335, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 88841, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1064362557, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20379, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 772643428, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 46202, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 66167316, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 204, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 841553, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 92404, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11332357, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 14553, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 40234801, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 49561, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 242896441, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 14109, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1613887, "child_limit_applications": 10060, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10060, "child_cap_hits": 10060, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10060, "child_moves_before_total": 707513, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 707513, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 160961, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 160961, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.329324055666, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000099403578528, "tt_hits": 3731, "tt_cutoffs": 461, "beta_cutoffs": 7722, "depth_sum": 27, "avg_depth": 3.857142857142857, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 27, "avg_effective_depth": 3.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3447.714285714286, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4590.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1014, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 5049, "avg_search_time_ms": 841.5, "search_nodes": 35792, "safety_nodes": 232, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 36024, "avg_nodes": 6004.0, "eval_calls": 23146, "avg_eval_calls": 3857.6666666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23146, "pattern_eval_ns": 521870, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.54687635012529, "pattern_frame_queries": 23146, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 521870, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.54687635012529, "pattern_frame_updates": 71534, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 619303243, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8657.466980736433, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11907, "avg_candidate_generations": 1984.5, "candidate_moves_total": 896405, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.28386663307299, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 369, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 11901, "search_candidate_moves_total": 896036, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 720378, "avg_legality_checks": 120063.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 67, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 720378, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 67, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1571187, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 261864.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3421377369, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2177.5748965590983, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6444, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1074.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10794469, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1675.1193358162632, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 679723, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 709, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7354888, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5668, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2759858, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 66000, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11000.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 651673996, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9873.848424242424, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 94683, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15780.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 312296650, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3298.339194998046, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1815514365, "stage_ordering_ns": 394964443, "stage_eval_ns": 619825113, "stage_threat_ns": 2185762298, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 166849, "root_tactical_annotations": 891, "search_tactical_annotations": 165958, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 71540, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 439536526, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 157232, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1678280898, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23839, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 895164008, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35767, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 53864981, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 71534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9189035, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 50610, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 265703629, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 82779, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 517357811, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 33460, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4890858, "child_limit_applications": 11901, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11901, "child_cap_hits": 11901, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11901, "child_moves_before_total": 895969, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 895969, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 190442, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 190442, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.28518611881354, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002184690362153, "tt_hits": 4462, "tt_cutoffs": 720, "beta_cutoffs": 10392, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2500.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3661.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1866, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1297, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11220, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 125, 95, 127, 96, 98, 94, 93, 126, 116, 115, 81, 156, 82, 141 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5153, "avg_search_time_ms": 644.125, "search_nodes": 64155, "safety_nodes": 390, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 64545, "avg_nodes": 8068.125, "eval_calls": 51127, "avg_eval_calls": 6390.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51127, "pattern_eval_ns": 1102246, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.558980577776907, "pattern_frame_queries": 51127, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1102246, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.558980577776907, "pattern_frame_updates": 128238, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1281882123, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9996.117554858934, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12404, "avg_candidate_generations": 1550.5, "candidate_moves_total": 842922, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.95565946468881, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 441, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 12396, "search_candidate_moves_total": 842481, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 446435, "avg_legality_checks": 55804.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 455, "root_legality_checks": 441, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 445994, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 452, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1309098, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 163637.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3020707609, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2307.472480287954, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6588, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 823.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30931271, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4695.092744383728, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 467, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4885527, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2515, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20455863, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3587, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5381989, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 207892, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 35101, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4387.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 339289448, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9666.090652687957, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 46162, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5770.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 150554888, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3261.4463844720767, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1154771433, "stage_ordering_ns": 384010491, "stage_eval_ns": 1282984369, "stage_threat_ns": 2302118392, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 114368, "root_tactical_annotations": 883, "search_tactical_annotations": 113485, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 128246, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 758926996, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 119422, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1431218958, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24844, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 977311973, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64119, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93554320, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128238, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15913797, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 18890, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 56550185, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 75681, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 396914889, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 19797, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2504321, "child_limit_applications": 12396, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12396, "child_cap_hits": 12396, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12396, "child_moves_before_total": 842029, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 842029, "child_moves_before_max": 97, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 97, "child_moves_after_total": 198348, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 198348, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.92747660535656, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000968054211036, "tt_hits": 4025, "tt_cutoffs": 596, "beta_cutoffs": 9034, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3447.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4447.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1027, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6060, "avg_search_time_ms": 757.5, "search_nodes": 48284, "safety_nodes": 222, "corridor_nodes": 115, "corridor_branch_probes": 127, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 32, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 109, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 109, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 278, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 198000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 48621, "avg_nodes": 6077.625, "eval_calls": 31955, "avg_eval_calls": 3994.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 31955, "pattern_eval_ns": 711224, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.257048975121265, "pattern_frame_queries": 31955, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 711224, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.257048975121265, "pattern_frame_updates": 96500, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 951341658, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9858.462777202072, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15542, "avg_candidate_generations": 1942.75, "candidate_moves_total": 1079984, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.48809677004246, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 462, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 15534, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1079522, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 720402, "avg_legality_checks": 90050.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2050, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 720402, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2050, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1749977, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 218747.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3932667831, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2247.268296097606, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9172, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1146.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60741154, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6622.454644570432, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2050, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21745700, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2806, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30149478, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4292, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8577935, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 268041, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 55325, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6915.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 590073407, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10665.583497514686, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 77335, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9666.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 290709750, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3759.096786707183, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1860425289, "stage_ordering_ns": 484106788, "stage_eval_ns": 952052882, "stage_threat_ns": 2661314728, "stage_proof_ns": 66094946, "tactical_annotations": 192141, "root_tactical_annotations": 1268, "search_tactical_annotations": 190873, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 96800, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 602707739, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 189796, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1964745076, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31329, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1218123259, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48396, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73977548, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 292, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1612375, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 96792, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12556297, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 51490, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 271265324, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 98559, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 468705771, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 42092, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5715693, "child_limit_applications": 15534, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15534, "child_cap_hits": 15534, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15534, "child_moves_before_total": 1077472, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1077472, "child_moves_before_max": 94, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 94, "child_moves_after_total": 248558, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 248558, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.36217329728338, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00090124887344, "tt_hits": 5539, "tt_cutoffs": 761, "beta_cutoffs": 13496, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3551.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4551.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1868, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1298, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11288, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 125, 95, 127, 96, 98, 94, 93, 126, 116, 115, 81, 156, 82, 141 ], "move_count": 20, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5335, "avg_search_time_ms": 666.875, "search_nodes": 64155, "safety_nodes": 390, "corridor_nodes": 496, "corridor_branch_probes": 620, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 198, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 487, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 487, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 198, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 425, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 27726480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2002240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 65041, "avg_nodes": 8130.125, "eval_calls": 51127, "avg_eval_calls": 6390.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51127, "pattern_eval_ns": 1100716, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.52905509808907, "pattern_frame_queries": 51127, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1100716, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.52905509808907, "pattern_frame_updates": 128238, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1252634168, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9768.04198443519, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12404, "avg_candidate_generations": 1550.5, "candidate_moves_total": 842922, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.95565946468881, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 441, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 12396, "search_candidate_moves_total": 842481, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 446435, "avg_legality_checks": 55804.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 455, "root_legality_checks": 441, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 445994, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 452, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1407817, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 175977.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3160638861, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2245.063712826312, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6741, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 842.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31460926, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4667.10072689512, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 467, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4761290, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2515, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19884933, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3630, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5830670, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 129, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 984033, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4543.875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 344660009, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9481.445049654754, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 47928, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5991.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 154391929, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3221.3305166082455, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1133110361, "stage_ordering_ns": 379275471, "stage_eval_ns": 1253734884, "stage_threat_ns": 2377911111, "stage_proof_ns": 162865348, "tactical_annotations": 114368, "root_tactical_annotations": 883, "search_tactical_annotations": 113485, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 129332, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 757134001, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 150615, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1504084495, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25234, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 979025920, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64662, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92251020, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1086, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6056352, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 129324, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15832526, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 18890, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 55145572, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 75681, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 388607522, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 19797, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2552717, "child_limit_applications": 12396, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12396, "child_cap_hits": 12396, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12396, "child_moves_before_total": 842029, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 842029, "child_moves_before_max": 97, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 97, "child_moves_after_total": 198348, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 198348, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.92747660535656, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000968054211036, "tt_hits": 4025, "tt_cutoffs": 596, "beta_cutoffs": 9034, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3396.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4396.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 996, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5943, "avg_search_time_ms": 742.875, "search_nodes": 48284, "safety_nodes": 222, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48506, "avg_nodes": 6063.25, "eval_calls": 31955, "avg_eval_calls": 3994.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 31955, "pattern_eval_ns": 711435, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.263652010639962, "pattern_frame_queries": 31955, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 711435, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.263652010639962, "pattern_frame_updates": 96500, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 950402478, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9848.730341968912, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15542, "avg_candidate_generations": 1942.75, "candidate_moves_total": 1079984, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.48809677004246, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 462, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 15534, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1079522, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 720402, "avg_legality_checks": 90050.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2050, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 720402, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2050, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1725869, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 215733.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3857522272, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2235.1188137686, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9146, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1143.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 63851144, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6981.319046577739, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2050, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21106649, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2806, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34296452, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4270, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8217803, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 230240, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 55325, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6915.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 581125815, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10503.855671034795, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 77335, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9666.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 285151737, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3687.227477856081, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1850905018, "stage_ordering_ns": 483235797, "stage_eval_ns": 951113913, "stage_threat_ns": 2620998980, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 192141, "root_tactical_annotations": 1268, "search_tactical_annotations": 190873, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 96508, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 596529363, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 181172, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1933968356, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31117, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1205130986, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48250, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 72706795, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 96500, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12604251, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 51490, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 267186875, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 98559, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 461598855, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 42092, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5190215, "child_limit_applications": 15534, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15534, "child_cap_hits": 15534, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15534, "child_moves_before_total": 1077472, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1077472, "child_moves_before_max": 94, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 94, "child_moves_after_total": 248558, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 248558, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.36217329728338, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00090124887344, "tt_hits": 5539, "tt_cutoffs": 761, "beta_cutoffs": 13496, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3610.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4610.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1872, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1299, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8947, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 97, 127, 128, 141, 155, 85, 99, 111, 156, 81, 114, 96 ], "move_count": 16, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 4390, "avg_search_time_ms": 731.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 47656, "safety_nodes": 276, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 47932, "avg_nodes": 7988.666666666667, "eval_calls": 35945, "avg_eval_calls": 5990.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35945, "pattern_eval_ns": 774374, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.5433022673529, "pattern_frame_queries": 35945, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 774374, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.5433022673529, "pattern_frame_updates": 95260, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1037015420, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10886.158093638463, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11001, "avg_candidate_generations": 1833.5, "candidate_moves_total": 703363, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.936278520134536, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 328, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 10995, "search_candidate_moves_total": 703035, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 394577, "avg_legality_checks": 65762.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 175, "root_legality_checks": 328, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 394249, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 172, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1146891, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 191148.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2684496388, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2340.6726428230754, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5636, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 939.3333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 22955672, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4073.0432931156847, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 183, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2033892, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1905, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14917043, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3531, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5804536, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 200201, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 29509, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4918.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 268604159, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9102.44871056288, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 42434, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7072.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 110292052, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2599.1434227270584, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1037248638, "stage_ordering_ns": 328914433, "stage_eval_ns": 1037789794, "stage_threat_ns": 1963474107, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 87327, "root_tactical_annotations": 580, "search_tactical_annotations": 86747, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 95266, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 587534706, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 96737, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1291192040, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22028, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 924828262, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 70614590, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 95260, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12467845, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 9658, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 21467805, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 65046, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 344609632, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 12623, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1664926, "child_limit_applications": 10995, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10995, "child_cap_hits": 10995, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10995, "child_moves_before_total": 702863, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 702863, "child_moves_before_max": 93, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 93, "child_moves_after_total": 175920, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 175920, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 63.92569349704411, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 2750, "tt_cutoffs": 691, "beta_cutoffs": 8676, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1876.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3146.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 4552, "avg_search_time_ms": 758.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 56939, "safety_nodes": 284, "corridor_nodes": 59, "corridor_branch_probes": 66, "corridor_max_depth": 6, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 53, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 53, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 9, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 9, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 6, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2008400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1978720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 57282, "avg_nodes": 9547.0, "eval_calls": 46534, "avg_eval_calls": 7755.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46534, "pattern_eval_ns": 1009294, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.689388404177592, "pattern_frame_queries": 46534, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1009294, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.689388404177592, "pattern_frame_updates": 113830, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1101760306, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9678.997680751998, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9845, "avg_candidate_generations": 1640.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 677897, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.85698324022346, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 340, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 9839, "search_candidate_moves_total": 677557, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 393381, "avg_legality_checks": 65563.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 528, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 393381, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 528, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1179962, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 196660.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2661807490, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2255.841705071858, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5236, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 872.6666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21737467, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4151.540679908327, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 528, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6436384, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 686, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7023577, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3989, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7875933, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 33, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 401573, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 32193, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5365.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 340647904, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10581.427763799584, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50463, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8410.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 163203953, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3234.131006876325, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1030053827, "stage_ordering_ns": 309054063, "stage_eval_ns": 1102769600, "stage_threat_ns": 2071561457, "stage_proof_ns": 16439523, "tactical_annotations": 136198, "root_tactical_annotations": 833, "search_tactical_annotations": 135365, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 113960, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 694537148, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 124732, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1271909416, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19800, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 814488722, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56977, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 85153694, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 124, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 567894, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 113954, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14927813, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 24604, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 131801894, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 74370, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 321291074, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 37224, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4465492, "child_limit_applications": 9839, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9839, "child_cap_hits": 9839, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9839, "child_moves_before_total": 677029, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 677029, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 157424, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 157424, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.81075312531762, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 4035, "tt_cutoffs": 542, "beta_cutoffs": 6760, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2786.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4029.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1824, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1300, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20749, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 97, 127, 128, 141, 155, 156, 111, 99, 85, 171, 186, 125, 96, 144, 95, 93, 109, 114, 64, 80, 94, 98, 79, 124, 49 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 9480, "avg_search_time_ms": 729.2307692307693, "search_nodes": 90865, "safety_nodes": 1116, "corridor_nodes": 375, "corridor_branch_probes": 421, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 135, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 363, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 363, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 135, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 446, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 256720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 92356, "avg_nodes": 7104.307692307692, "eval_calls": 64861, "avg_eval_calls": 4989.307692307692, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64861, "pattern_eval_ns": 1410336, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.743975578544887, "pattern_frame_queries": 64861, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1410336, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.743975578544887, "pattern_frame_updates": 181616, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2311117855, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12725.298734692979, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24339, "avg_candidate_generations": 1872.2307692307693, "candidate_moves_total": 1927875, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.20929372611857, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 911, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 24326, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1926964, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 793573, "avg_legality_checks": 61044.07692307692, "illegal_moves_skipped": 285, "root_legality_checks": 911, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 792662, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 285, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2519302, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 193792.46153846153, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5840111878, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2318.1468033606134, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9297, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 715.1538461538462, "renju_forbidden_ns": 39288821, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4225.96762396472, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 308, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3189541, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27125010, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5330, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8916840, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57430, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58855, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4527.307692307692, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 546519188, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9285.85826182992, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 82236, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6325.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 230815467, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2806.7448197869544, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2023977653, "stage_ordering_ns": 840964396, "stage_eval_ns": 2312528191, "stage_threat_ns": 4098792630, "stage_proof_ns": 159387700, "tactical_annotations": 281776, "root_tactical_annotations": 1334, "search_tactical_annotations": 280442, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 182481, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1132335194, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 307141, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2792747123, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49166, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1935965236, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91234, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 138607128, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 852, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5631246, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 182468, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23828644, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56318, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 67386207, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 177712, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 738329199, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 47746, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5643295, "child_limit_applications": 24326, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24326, "child_cap_hits": 24326, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24326, "child_moves_before_total": 1926679, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1926679, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 389230, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 389230, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.2024582750966, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000575515908903, "tt_hits": 8146, "tt_cutoffs": 1622, "beta_cutoffs": 20110, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5029.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5644.538461538462, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 11257, "avg_search_time_ms": 938.0833333333334, "search_nodes": 121086, "safety_nodes": 667, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 121753, "avg_nodes": 10146.083333333334, "eval_calls": 95620, "avg_eval_calls": 7968.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 95620, "pattern_eval_ns": 2092841, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.88706337586279, "pattern_frame_queries": 95620, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2092841, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.88706337586279, "pattern_frame_updates": 242062, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2596601369, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10727.009481042047, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24024, "avg_candidate_generations": 2002.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1942655, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.86309523809524, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 851, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 24012, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1941804, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1225341, "avg_legality_checks": 102111.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 152, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1225341, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 152, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3148101, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 262341.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7020146926, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2229.962420519545, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4248, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 354.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15006939, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3532.7069209039546, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 156, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1742170, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1082, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8909438, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3010, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4355331, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89970, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7497.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 892684155, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9922.02017339113, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 130637, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10886.416666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 409252132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3132.7428829504656, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3064318838, "stage_ordering_ns": 841003427, "stage_eval_ns": 2598694210, "stage_threat_ns": 4693973521, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 393704, "root_tactical_annotations": 1936, "search_tactical_annotations": 391768, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 242074, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1444977781, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 340120, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3022769702, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48103, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1833112107, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121031, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 182044693, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 242062, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30870698, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 99188, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 361401996, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 192820, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 828104829, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 101696, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13310647, "child_limit_applications": 24012, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24012, "child_cap_hits": 24012, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24012, "child_moves_before_total": 1941652, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1941652, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 384193, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 384193, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.86173579876728, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000041645843744, "tt_hits": 9801, "tt_cutoffs": 1399, "beta_cutoffs": 17700, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4467.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5134.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1829, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1301, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8346, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 127, 97, 96, 83, 69, 139, 125, 113, 68, 143, 54, 128 ], "move_count": 16, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 3903, "avg_search_time_ms": 650.5, "search_nodes": 46786, "safety_nodes": 276, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 47062, "avg_nodes": 7843.666666666667, "eval_calls": 35468, "avg_eval_calls": 5911.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35468, "pattern_eval_ns": 777121, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.91048268862073, "pattern_frame_queries": 35468, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 777121, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.91048268862073, "pattern_frame_updates": 93520, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 869178776, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9294.041659538067, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10517, "avg_candidate_generations": 1752.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 652614, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.05324712370448, "candidate_moves_max": 92, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 328, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 10511, "search_candidate_moves_total": 652286, "search_candidate_moves_max": 92, "legality_checks": 361111, "avg_legality_checks": 60185.166666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 379, "root_legality_checks": 328, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 360783, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 376, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1025764, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 170960.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2343406524, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2284.547443661505, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5163, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 860.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20927125, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4053.2878171605657, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 415, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4374283, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1602, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11122590, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3129, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5238891, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 191361, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28669, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4778.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 265254019, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9252.29408071436, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41140, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6856.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 110996527, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2698.019615945552, "stage_move_gen_ns": 940100810, "stage_ordering_ns": 292887335, "stage_eval_ns": 869955897, "stage_threat_ns": 1774855563, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 85272, "root_tactical_annotations": 580, "search_tactical_annotations": 84692, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 93526, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 547572574, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 94181, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1147607996, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21060, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 789502277, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 46760, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 66575239, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 93520, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11510445, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 10946, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 21568133, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 62170, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 336261944, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 12156, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1589309, "child_limit_applications": 10511, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10511, "child_cap_hits": 10511, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10511, "child_moves_before_total": 651910, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 651910, "child_moves_before_max": 91, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 91, "child_moves_after_total": 168176, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 168176, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 62.02169156122158, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 2707, "tt_cutoffs": 782, "beta_cutoffs": 8296, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 4.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2201.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3534.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 4437, "avg_search_time_ms": 739.5, "search_nodes": 57273, "safety_nodes": 288, "corridor_nodes": 106, "corridor_branch_probes": 113, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 15, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 102, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 102, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 7, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 7, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 4, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 11, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 57667, "avg_nodes": 9611.166666666666, "eval_calls": 46710, "avg_eval_calls": 7785.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46710, "pattern_eval_ns": 1008605, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.592913722971527, "pattern_frame_queries": 46710, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1008605, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.592913722971527, "pattern_frame_updates": 114498, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1044212824, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9119.921954968646, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10047, "avg_candidate_generations": 1674.5, "candidate_moves_total": 695440, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.21867224046979, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 344, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 10041, "search_candidate_moves_total": 695096, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 405109, "avg_legality_checks": 67518.16666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2222, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 405109, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1167706, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 194617.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2577047752, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2206.9320119961703, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7471, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1245.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65629927, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8784.624146700575, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2222, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24808199, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2788, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30586038, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2433, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9901687, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 334003, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 32149, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5358.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 336927624, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10480.189865936733, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 49269, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8211.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 161585758, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3279.663845420041, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1073147000, "stage_ordering_ns": 305318985, "stage_eval_ns": 1045221429, "stage_threat_ns": 1973435623, "stage_proof_ns": 12402352, "tactical_annotations": 132385, "root_tactical_annotations": 833, "search_tactical_annotations": 131552, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 114722, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 669815446, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 126409, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1202227668, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20227, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 750691018, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57358, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81191053, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 218, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1090858, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 114716, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14225969, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 26096, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 118815312, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 70785, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 325217739, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 35504, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4884629, "child_limit_applications": 10041, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10041, "child_cap_hits": 10041, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10041, "child_moves_before_total": 692874, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 692874, "child_moves_before_max": 96, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 96, "child_moves_after_total": 160656, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 160656, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.00448162533613, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 4044, "tt_cutoffs": 498, "beta_cutoffs": 6953, "depth_sum": 24, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 24, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2868.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4134.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1850, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1302, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28768, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 127, 97, 96, 83, 69, 139, 125, 68, 113, 99, 126, 128, 53, 67, 115, 65, 124, 123, 110, 138, 142, 51, 35, 64, 66, 101, 100, 94, 130, 85, 116, 114, 158, 174, 144, 172, 102 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 20029, "avg_search_time_ms": 1054.157894736842, "search_nodes": 205726, "safety_nodes": 795, "corridor_nodes": 11476, "corridor_branch_probes": 12031, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 6311, "corridor_neutral_exits": 36, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 11434, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 11434, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 113, "corridor_proof_active": 42, "corridor_proof_quiet": 71, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 6311, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 113, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 110, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 844, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2314240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 217997, "avg_nodes": 11473.526315789473, "eval_calls": 156600, "avg_eval_calls": 8242.105263157895, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 156600, "pattern_eval_ns": 3211764, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.50934865900383, "pattern_frame_queries": 156600, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3211764, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.50934865900383, "pattern_frame_updates": 411278, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5244842520, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12752.548203404996, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46185, "avg_candidate_generations": 2430.7894736842104, "candidate_moves_total": 4032754, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.31739742340586, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1477, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 46166, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4031277, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1444234, "avg_legality_checks": 76012.31578947368, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2093, "root_legality_checks": 1477, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1442757, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2090, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6301628, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 331664.63157894736, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12169936790, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1931.236942263174, "renju_forbidden_checks": 52733, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2775.4210526315787, "renju_forbidden_ns": 210330507, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3988.593613107542, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2311, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12142897, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 30014, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 151237685, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18929, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39070941, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1479, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7878984, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 184798, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9726.21052631579, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1520310802, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8226.879089600538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 261440, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13760.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 686683748, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2626.54432374541, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3092399563, "stage_ordering_ns": 1367569534, "stage_eval_ns": 5248054284, "stage_threat_ns": 9262752591, "stage_proof_ns": 980634770, "tactical_annotations": 969965, "root_tactical_annotations": 3891, "search_tactical_annotations": 966074, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 434391, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2567244273, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1362129, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6160005799, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 97563, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3062332444, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 217186, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 305388969, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 23094, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 154944455, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 434372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51012190, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 357396, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 457637828, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 412095, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1365824647, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 200474, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24156905, "child_limit_applications": 46166, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46166, "child_cap_hits": 46166, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46166, "child_moves_before_total": 4029187, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4029187, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 757659, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 757659, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.27606896850496, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.411623272538232, "tt_hits": 19267, "tt_cutoffs": 2874, "beta_cutoffs": 36338, "depth_sum": 86, "avg_depth": 4.526315789473684, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 86, "avg_effective_depth": 4.526315789473684, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15789473684210525, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5715.368421052632, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6136.421052631579, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 8721, "avg_search_time_ms": 484.5, "search_nodes": 135842, "safety_nodes": 1583, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 137425, "avg_nodes": 7634.722222222223, "eval_calls": 104024, "avg_eval_calls": 5779.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 104024, "pattern_eval_ns": 1975727, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.992992001845728, "pattern_frame_queries": 104024, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1975727, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.992992001845728, "pattern_frame_updates": 271514, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1801017385, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6633.239483046915, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30405, "avg_candidate_generations": 1689.1666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 2448349, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.524551882914, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1399, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 30387, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2446950, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1377347, "avg_legality_checks": 76519.27777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2703, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1377347, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2703, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3471849, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 192880.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5199411959, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1497.5916173197625, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17828, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 990.4444444444445, "renju_forbidden_ns": 53139735, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2980.6896455014585, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2705, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14789123, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4791, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26063860, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10312, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12202201, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 84551, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 106965, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5942.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 702015303, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6563.037470200533, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 152980, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8498.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 316272817, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2067.412844816316, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2354424456, "stage_ordering_ns": 719386225, "stage_eval_ns": 1802993112, "stage_threat_ns": 3765293203, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 556422, "root_tactical_annotations": 2021, "search_tactical_annotations": 554401, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 271532, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1100739366, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 513958, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2486725096, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60895, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1465586373, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 135757, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 143214233, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 271514, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24664165, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 172932, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 330450838, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 280118, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 690386694, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 103372, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9950343, "child_limit_applications": 30387, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30387, "child_cap_hits": 30387, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30387, "child_moves_before_total": 2444247, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2444247, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 490552, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 490552, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.43725935432916, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.143482410241223, "tt_hits": 10564, "tt_cutoffs": 1346, "beta_cutoffs": 23641, "depth_sum": 85, "avg_depth": 4.722222222222222, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 85, "avg_effective_depth": 4.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6536.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6980.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1856, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1303, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19835, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 114, 156, 113, 111, 66, 170, 184, 130, 126, 140, 84, 70, 129, 144, 82, 50, 145, 97, 99, 69, 83, 141, 143, 139, 138, 125, 153, 155, 110, 185 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 15286, "avg_search_time_ms": 1019.0666666666667, "search_nodes": 172616, "safety_nodes": 668, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 173284, "avg_nodes": 11552.266666666666, "eval_calls": 130986, "avg_eval_calls": 8732.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 130986, "pattern_eval_ns": 2773383, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.17312537217718, "pattern_frame_queries": 130986, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2773383, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.17312537217718, "pattern_frame_updates": 345092, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4503267923, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13049.470642611246, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39141, "avg_candidate_generations": 2609.4, "candidate_moves_total": 3745507, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.69267519991824, "candidate_moves_max": 136, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1298, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 39126, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3744209, "search_candidate_moves_max": 136, "legality_checks": 1253731, "avg_legality_checks": 83582.06666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3357, "root_legality_checks": 1298, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 1252433, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3351, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4247709, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 283180.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8878341001, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2090.148124789151, "renju_forbidden_checks": 62507, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4167.133333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 381238679, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6099.135760794791, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4387, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 41971936, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 32934, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 250959274, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25156, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 87939826, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 367643, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 117828, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7855.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 979840519, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8315.854627083545, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 154509, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10300.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 405684348, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2625.6357105411334, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2865557224, "stage_ordering_ns": 1420062851, "stage_eval_ns": 4506041306, "stage_threat_ns": 6427410583, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 685751, "root_tactical_annotations": 3656, "search_tactical_annotations": 682095, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 345107, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1905816032, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 608720, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4221554707, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 78352, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2813794018, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 172546, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 237718680, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 345092, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41058407, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 231454, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 261911653, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 298904, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1145752666, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 155393, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21262757, "child_limit_applications": 39126, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39126, "child_cap_hits": 39126, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39126, "child_moves_before_total": 3740858, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3740858, "child_moves_before_max": 136, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 136, "child_moves_after_total": 627988, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 627988, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.6105403056791, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.05040126769923, "tt_hits": 18070, "tt_cutoffs": 2434, "beta_cutoffs": 30577, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4470.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5003.533333333334, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 378, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 4533, "avg_search_time_ms": 302.2, "search_nodes": 45564, "safety_nodes": 2138, "corridor_nodes": 818, "corridor_branch_probes": 938, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 14, "corridor_depth_exits": 371, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 21, "corridor_plies_followed": 808, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 808, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 27, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 17, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 371, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 21, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 27, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 24, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 56, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 73920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 15520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 48520, "avg_nodes": 3234.6666666666665, "eval_calls": 34226, "avg_eval_calls": 2281.733333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34226, "pattern_eval_ns": 724285, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.16183603108748, "pattern_frame_queries": 34226, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 724285, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.16183603108748, "pattern_frame_updates": 90994, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 953061612, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10473.895113963557, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10717, "avg_candidate_generations": 714.4666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 882200, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.31781282075208, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1320, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 10702, "search_candidate_moves_total": 880880, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 433484, "avg_legality_checks": 28898.933333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 872, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 433484, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 872, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1292167, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 86144.46666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2744229652, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2123.742250034245, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8905, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 593.6666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50245821, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5642.427961819203, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 922, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10170434, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2748, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25176581, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5190, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14341764, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 557042, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44699, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2979.9333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 414537124, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9273.96863464507, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63620, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4241.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 182806867, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2873.4182175416536, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1062973569, "stage_ordering_ns": 362499526, "stage_eval_ns": 953785897, "stage_threat_ns": 2075793788, "stage_proof_ns": 40525567, "tactical_annotations": 171833, "root_tactical_annotations": 416, "search_tactical_annotations": 171417, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 92679, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 569925244, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 207107, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1414069377, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21921, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 825678104, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 46332, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 66297690, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1670, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11231096, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 92664, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11578311, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 45949, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 161085508, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 97067, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 392920848, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 28817, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2692070, "child_limit_applications": 10702, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10702, "child_cap_hits": 10702, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10702, "child_moves_before_total": 880008, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 880008, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 173047, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 173047, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.22836852924686, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.169594468323677, "tt_hits": 3298, "tt_cutoffs": 570, "beta_cutoffs": 8493, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 4.4, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 4.4, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5937.066666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6470.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1304, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23585, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 114, 156, 113, 111, 66, 170, 184, 130, 126, 140, 84, 70, 129, 144, 81, 143, 141, 145, 146, 115, 99, 69, 127, 85, 155 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 16390, "avg_search_time_ms": 1260.7692307692307, "search_nodes": 147213, "safety_nodes": 729, "corridor_nodes": 6080, "corridor_branch_probes": 6845, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2532, "corridor_neutral_exits": 38, "corridor_terminal_exits": 42, "corridor_plies_followed": 6033, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6033, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 104, "corridor_proof_active": 47, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 38, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2532, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 42, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 104, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 102, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 830, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 53726520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1983200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 154022, "avg_nodes": 11847.846153846154, "eval_calls": 114656, "avg_eval_calls": 8819.692307692309, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 114656, "pattern_eval_ns": 2472694, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.56619801842032, "pattern_frame_queries": 114656, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2472694, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.56619801842032, "pattern_frame_updates": 294312, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4287681608, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14568.490608605833, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30495, "avg_candidate_generations": 2345.769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 2801951, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.88230857517625, "candidate_moves_max": 136, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1060, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 30482, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2800891, "search_candidate_moves_max": 136, "legality_checks": 1073289, "avg_legality_checks": 82560.69230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1200, "root_legality_checks": 1060, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1072229, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1200, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4437493, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 341345.6153846154, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10087644270, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2273.2755341811244, "renju_forbidden_checks": 51099, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3930.6923076923076, "renju_forbidden_ns": 294515344, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5763.622458365135, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2053, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16376919, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26620, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 197377549, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20439, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 62339221, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1987, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 18421655, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 116759, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8981.461538461539, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1105364584, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9467.061074521022, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 154508, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11885.23076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 471662933, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3052.676450410335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2714009556, "stage_ordering_ns": 1188701918, "stage_eval_ns": 4290154302, "stage_threat_ns": 7233395593, "stage_proof_ns": 906797411, "tactical_annotations": 469775, "root_tactical_annotations": 2650, "search_tactical_annotations": 467125, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 306599, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1943783114, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 795950, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4932163070, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64335, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2648786053, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 153293, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 233142649, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12274, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 71130778, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 306586, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40169118, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 140683, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 238107222, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 229936, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1067340971, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 99156, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13006864, "child_limit_applications": 30482, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30482, "child_cap_hits": 30482, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30482, "child_moves_before_total": 2799691, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2799691, "child_moves_before_max": 136, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 136, "child_moves_after_total": 489723, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 489723, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.84735253592284, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.065973361328, "tt_hits": 13314, "tt_cutoffs": 2018, "beta_cutoffs": 22972, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2453.3846153846152, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3068.769230769231, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 218, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7182, "avg_search_time_ms": 598.5, "search_nodes": 56119, "safety_nodes": 1399, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 57518, "avg_nodes": 4793.166666666667, "eval_calls": 39971, "avg_eval_calls": 3330.9166666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39971, "pattern_eval_ns": 877475, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.95279077331065, "pattern_frame_queries": 39971, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 877475, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.95279077331065, "pattern_frame_updates": 112128, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1244206196, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11096.302404394977, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15023, "avg_candidate_generations": 1251.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1346348, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.61911735339146, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 991, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 15011, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1345357, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 932823, "avg_legality_checks": 77735.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 151, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 932823, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 151, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2165450, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 180454.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4719133085, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2179.285176291302, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20930, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1744.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 47971067, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2291.9764452938366, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 182, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1673009, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3172, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20866054, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17576, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25432004, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 95853, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7987.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 872831739, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9105.940753028075, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 133387, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11115.583333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 358233526, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2685.6704626387877, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2285854390, "stage_ordering_ns": 557002468, "stage_eval_ns": 1245083671, "stage_threat_ns": 3044689931, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 276938, "root_tactical_annotations": 856, "search_tactical_annotations": 276082, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 112140, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 701629685, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 252874, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2236635518, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30101, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1137846974, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56064, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 84095269, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 112128, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14786322, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 81308, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 340640062, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 141456, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 757898131, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 54174, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7543137, "child_limit_applications": 15011, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15011, "child_cap_hits": 15011, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15011, "child_moves_before_total": 1345206, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1345206, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 243380, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 243380, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.61468256611818, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.21344347478516, "tt_hits": 5422, "tt_cutoffs": 1082, "beta_cutoffs": 12512, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5306.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5972.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1305, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14941, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 142, 96, 114, 156, 127, 97, 113, 111, 141, 81, 66, 99, 100, 86, 115, 116, 130, 98, 95, 145, 143, 139, 129, 131, 101, 87, 157 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 10817, "avg_search_time_ms": 772.6428571428571, "search_nodes": 113357, "safety_nodes": 732, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 114089, "avg_nodes": 8149.214285714285, "eval_calls": 84648, "avg_eval_calls": 6046.285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84648, "pattern_eval_ns": 1843724, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.781069842169927, "pattern_frame_queries": 84648, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1843724, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.781069842169927, "pattern_frame_updates": 226590, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3135054970, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13835.804625093782, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26951, "avg_candidate_generations": 1925.0714285714287, "candidate_moves_total": 2077372, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.07958888352937, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 962, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 26937, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2076410, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 721705, "avg_legality_checks": 51550.357142857145, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2987, "root_legality_checks": 962, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 720743, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2979, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2745273, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 196090.92857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6269466004, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2283.731346208556, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35567, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2540.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 218951550, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6156.030871313296, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3306, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 32055410, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16874, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 132754009, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15343, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 53731349, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 410782, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 85385, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6098.928571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 748913062, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8771.01437020554, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 111654, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7975.285714285715, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 294476077, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2637.39836459061, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1868533902, "stage_ordering_ns": 893180512, "stage_eval_ns": 3136898694, "stage_threat_ns": 4877426523, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 539139, "root_tactical_annotations": 2363, "search_tactical_annotations": 536776, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 226604, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1410911043, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 455296, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3241099346, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53963, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2116142285, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 113295, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 177159755, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 226590, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30278743, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 152266, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 191532091, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 249057, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 933079668, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 137816, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17977636, "child_limit_applications": 26937, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26937, "child_cap_hits": 26937, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26937, "child_moves_before_total": 2073431, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2073431, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 442824, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 442824, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.97334521290418, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.439247132197348, "tt_hits": 12111, "tt_cutoffs": 1710, "beta_cutoffs": 21405, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5209.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5780.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 284, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 4111, "avg_search_time_ms": 316.2307692307692, "search_nodes": 39435, "safety_nodes": 1351, "corridor_nodes": 1198, "corridor_branch_probes": 1467, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 565, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_plies_followed": 1188, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1188, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 40, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 565, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 40, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 182, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 68920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 41984, "avg_nodes": 3229.5384615384614, "eval_calls": 29146, "avg_eval_calls": 2242.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 29146, "pattern_eval_ns": 639143, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.929012557469292, "pattern_frame_queries": 29146, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 639143, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.929012557469292, "pattern_frame_updates": 78750, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 891401705, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11319.38673015873, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9760, "avg_candidate_generations": 750.7692307692307, "candidate_moves_total": 702306, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.95758196721312, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 887, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 9747, "search_candidate_moves_total": 701419, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 302993, "avg_legality_checks": 23307.153846153848, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1049, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 302993, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1049, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1063443, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 81803.30769230769, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2407077235, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2263.4755553424116, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7544, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 580.3076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50360541, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6675.575424178155, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1071, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10203464, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27001422, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3258, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12302321, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 75, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 853334, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37413, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2877.923076923077, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 351372626, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9391.725496485178, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 51655, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3973.4615384615386, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 148062630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2866.375568676798, "stage_move_gen_ns": 801964629, "stage_ordering_ns": 314881327, "stage_eval_ns": 892040848, "stage_threat_ns": 2011225151, "stage_proof_ns": 60227496, "tactical_annotations": 168015, "root_tactical_annotations": 371, "search_tactical_annotations": 167644, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 81219, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 536943367, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 225253, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1381070850, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20185, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 823475040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40603, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 63896850, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2456, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15816155, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 81206, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10778527, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 39644, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 128521087, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 102863, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 374787083, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 25508, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2719402, "child_limit_applications": 9747, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9747, "child_cap_hits": 9747, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9747, "child_moves_before_total": 700370, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 700370, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 157345, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 157345, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.85492972196573, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.14291576895455, "tt_hits": 2698, "tt_cutoffs": 482, "beta_cutoffs": 7852, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5678.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6294.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 20, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1306, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25450, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 142, 96, 114, 156, 127, 97, 113, 141, 111, 115, 98, 143, 83, 68, 157, 172, 82, 130, 85, 186, 171, 84, 100, 86, 144, 140, 99, 71, 160, 176, 159, 129, 101, 102, 161, 158, 188, 70, 162, 163, 50, 66, 69, 54, 38, 118 ], "move_count": 50, "black_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 17589, "avg_search_time_ms": 764.7391304347826, "search_nodes": 133260, "safety_nodes": 2167, "corridor_nodes": 16365, "corridor_branch_probes": 17717, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 7019, "corridor_neutral_exits": 436, "corridor_terminal_exits": 52, "corridor_plies_followed": 16254, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 16214, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 40, "corridor_proof_passes": 21, "corridor_proof_completed": 21, "corridor_proof_checks": 220, "corridor_proof_active": 111, "corridor_proof_quiet": 109, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 436, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 7019, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 52, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 220, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 8, "corridor_proof_unknown": 212, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1547, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 40830400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 151792, "avg_nodes": 6599.652173913043, "eval_calls": 95585, "avg_eval_calls": 4155.869565217391, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 95585, "pattern_eval_ns": 2112509, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.10084218235079, "pattern_frame_queries": 95585, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2112509, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.10084218235079, "pattern_frame_updates": 266300, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3215595685, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12075.08706346226, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35777, "avg_candidate_generations": 1555.5217391304348, "candidate_moves_total": 2849648, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.65027811163597, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1788, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 35754, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2847860, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 928884, "avg_legality_checks": 40386.260869565216, "illegal_moves_skipped": 884, "root_legality_checks": 1788, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 927096, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 882, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5069009, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 220391.69565217392, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10968643769, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2163.863541966487, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23966, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1042.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 112719980, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4703.32888258366, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1005, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7187891, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10041, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 74769483, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11858, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27190671, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1062, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3571935, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 104081, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4525.260869565217, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 882087084, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8475.005851212038, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 133640, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5810.434782608696, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 357427762, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2674.5567345106256, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2278189598, "stage_ordering_ns": 1187580606, "stage_eval_ns": 3217708194, "stage_threat_ns": 8852044433, "stage_proof_ns": 1991160244, "tactical_annotations": 721480, "root_tactical_annotations": 3222, "search_tactical_annotations": 718258, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 299271, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2052450172, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1527635, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6265820548, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 81158, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3119183019, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 149624, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 246466332, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 32948, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 229335782, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 299248, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39133711, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 247732, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 198800416, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 301136, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 941335620, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 172612, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18837888, "child_limit_applications": 35754, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35754, "child_cap_hits": 35754, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35754, "child_moves_before_total": 2846978, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2846978, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 572877, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 572877, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.62683895508195, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.022738714549423, "tt_hits": 16238, "tt_cutoffs": 1811, "beta_cutoffs": 29550, "depth_sum": 110, "avg_depth": 4.782608695652174, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 110, "avg_effective_depth": 4.782608695652174, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6005.521739130435, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6353.347826086957, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 241, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 7838, "avg_search_time_ms": 340.7826086956522, "search_nodes": 70721, "safety_nodes": 2138, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 72859, "avg_nodes": 3167.782608695652, "eval_calls": 48798, "avg_eval_calls": 2121.6521739130435, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48798, "pattern_eval_ns": 1079034, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.112258699127015, "pattern_frame_queries": 48798, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1079034, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.112258699127015, "pattern_frame_updates": 141228, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1378049822, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9757.624706148923, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20375, "avg_candidate_generations": 885.8695652173913, "candidate_moves_total": 1770783, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.90959509202455, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1816, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 20352, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1768967, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1023292, "avg_legality_checks": 44490.95652173913, "illegal_moves_skipped": 441, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1023292, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 441, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2330506, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 101326.34782608696, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4885117575, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2096.1617670154037, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9621, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 418.30434782608694, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21515364, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2236.2918615528533, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 449, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1955555, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1866, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11120494, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7291, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8371055, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 68260, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76634, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3331.913043478261, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 656203392, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8562.823185531226, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 102058, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4437.304347826087, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 276534166, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2709.578533774912, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2355514319, "stage_ordering_ns": 694513467, "stage_eval_ns": 1379128856, "stage_threat_ns": 3343904098, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 470195, "root_tactical_annotations": 1321, "search_tactical_annotations": 468874, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 141251, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 865018878, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 432883, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2340291486, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40856, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1368371707, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70614, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 110204340, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 141228, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18445680, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 176231, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 366337349, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 215785, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 605212407, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78179, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9943714, "child_limit_applications": 20352, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20352, "child_cap_hits": 20352, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20352, "child_moves_before_total": 1768526, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1768526, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 325976, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 325976, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.89691430817611, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01690251572327, "tt_hits": 7998, "tt_cutoffs": 1464, "beta_cutoffs": 17149, "depth_sum": 107, "avg_depth": 4.6521739130434785, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 107, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6521739130434785, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6708.347826086957, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7056.173913043478, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 49, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1307, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17121, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 81, 68, 111, 109, 142, 94, 140, 154, 139, 141, 113, 114, 158, 174, 143, 128, 157, 86, 85, 100, 72, 52, 36, 116 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 11871, "avg_search_time_ms": 847.9285714285714, "search_nodes": 121173, "safety_nodes": 389, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 121562, "avg_nodes": 8683.0, "eval_calls": 84471, "avg_eval_calls": 6033.642857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84471, "pattern_eval_ns": 1853987, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.948207076985, "pattern_frame_queries": 84471, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1853987, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.948207076985, "pattern_frame_updates": 242216, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3051175747, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12596.920711265977, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34794, "avg_candidate_generations": 2485.285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 2951181, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.81867563372995, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1011, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 34780, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2950170, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 819502, "avg_legality_checks": 58535.857142857145, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3752, "root_legality_checks": 1011, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 818491, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3743, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2885397, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 206099.7857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6616931077, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2293.248061531914, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54200, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3871.4285714285716, "renju_forbidden_ns": 496866651, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9167.281383763837, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4630, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53471389, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25919, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 300989556, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23543, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 141262531, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 108, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1143175, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5489.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 764954195, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9954.11975588174, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 104945, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7496.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 335863988, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3200.381037686407, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2130630850, "stage_ordering_ns": 1207410167, "stage_eval_ns": 3053029734, "stage_threat_ns": 5428041587, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 653826, "root_tactical_annotations": 3356, "search_tactical_annotations": 650470, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 242230, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1453905095, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 563810, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3738753011, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69653, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2600598489, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121108, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 183912832, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 242216, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30590704, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 242570, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 268717919, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 251576, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 869290192, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 159680, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20879945, "child_limit_applications": 34780, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34780, "child_cap_hits": 34780, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34780, "child_moves_before_total": 2946427, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2946427, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 562217, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 562217, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.71612995974698, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.1649511213341, "tt_hits": 16069, "tt_cutoffs": 1857, "beta_cutoffs": 29332, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5215.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5786.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 896, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 5236, "avg_search_time_ms": 374.0, "search_nodes": 41669, "safety_nodes": 1427, "corridor_nodes": 1398, "corridor_branch_probes": 1498, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 766, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1381, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1381, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 766, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 57, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 351, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 265280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 44494, "avg_nodes": 3178.1428571428573, "eval_calls": 28645, "avg_eval_calls": 2046.0714285714287, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 28645, "pattern_eval_ns": 646054, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.553813929132485, "pattern_frame_queries": 28645, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 646054, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.553813929132485, "pattern_frame_updates": 83214, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 885691541, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10643.540041339198, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12362, "avg_candidate_generations": 883.0, "candidate_moves_total": 964063, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.98600550072804, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1039, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 12348, "search_candidate_moves_total": 963024, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 537213, "avg_legality_checks": 38372.357142857145, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1265, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 537213, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1265, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1448287, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 103449.07142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3229272655, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2229.718733234504, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16714, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1193.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 123811801, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7407.670276414981, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2197, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23911436, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5259, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57554386, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9078, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40377102, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 180, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1968877, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3815.1428571428573, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 562362769, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10528.771980079382, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74384, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5313.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 258858961, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3480.0355049473005, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1400232103, "stage_ordering_ns": 409006658, "stage_eval_ns": 886337595, "stage_threat_ns": 2405454765, "stage_proof_ns": 94218743, "tactical_annotations": 211673, "root_tactical_annotations": 750, "search_tactical_annotations": 210923, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 86108, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 560373952, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 264260, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1744797341, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25526, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 970861004, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43047, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 67693568, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2880, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17814149, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 86094, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11040181, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 60402, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 276974868, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 113962, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 455074628, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 37309, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3735574, "child_limit_applications": 12348, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12348, "child_cap_hits": 12348, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12348, "child_moves_before_total": 961759, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 961759, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 198891, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 198891, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.88783608681568, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.107142857142858, "tt_hits": 4390, "tt_cutoffs": 614, "beta_cutoffs": 10507, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5937.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6508.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1858, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1308, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15400, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 81, 68, 111, 109, 142, 94, 140, 154, 158, 174, 113, 114, 143, 128, 141, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11502, "avg_search_time_ms": 1045.6363636363637, "search_nodes": 101055, "safety_nodes": 189, "corridor_nodes": 4679, "corridor_branch_probes": 5151, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1974, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 4640, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4640, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 39, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1974, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 89, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 713, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24074560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 105923, "avg_nodes": 9629.363636363636, "eval_calls": 71623, "avg_eval_calls": 6511.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71623, "pattern_eval_ns": 1569356, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.911341328902726, "pattern_frame_queries": 71623, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1569356, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.911341328902726, "pattern_frame_updates": 202016, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2525111436, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12499.56159908126, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27896, "avg_candidate_generations": 2536.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2338151, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.81671207341554, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 755, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 27885, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2337396, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 654918, "avg_legality_checks": 59538.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1033, "root_legality_checks": 755, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 654163, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1030, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2980859, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 270987.1818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6803383106, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2282.35656433263, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39637, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3603.3636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 360053776, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9083.77970078462, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1138, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12488068, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21360, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 228658608, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15444, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 101250448, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1695, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 17656652, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 69858, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6350.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 690496197, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9884.282358498669, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92693, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8426.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 311427549, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3359.77419006829, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1693651847, "stage_ordering_ns": 976083787, "stage_eval_ns": 2526680792, "stage_threat_ns": 5539447019, "stage_proof_ns": 721697308, "tactical_annotations": 448299, "root_tactical_annotations": 2760, "search_tactical_annotations": 445539, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 211491, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1335666337, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 668978, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3940282381, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58439, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2342091479, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 105740, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 162618264, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9464, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 61132682, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 211480, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26889588, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 156640, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 207535966, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 177130, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 612004285, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 114529, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12857767, "child_limit_applications": 27885, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27885, "child_cap_hits": 27885, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27885, "child_moves_before_total": 2336366, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2336366, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 448389, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 448389, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.78576295499373, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.079935449166218, "tt_hits": 12788, "tt_cutoffs": 1500, "beta_cutoffs": 23242, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3674.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4401.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 831, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 3889, "avg_search_time_ms": 388.9, "search_nodes": 32121, "safety_nodes": 742, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 32863, "avg_nodes": 3286.3, "eval_calls": 21624, "avg_eval_calls": 2162.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 21624, "pattern_eval_ns": 482821, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.328015168331483, "pattern_frame_queries": 21624, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 482821, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.328015168331483, "pattern_frame_updates": 64152, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 631873418, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9849.629286694102, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9997, "avg_candidate_generations": 999.7, "candidate_moves_total": 752457, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.26828048414524, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 688, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 9987, "search_candidate_moves_total": 751769, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 437655, "avg_legality_checks": 43765.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 286, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 437655, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1102607, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 110260.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2486629621, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2255.2274935675177, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5935, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 593.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42305714, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7128.174220724515, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 327, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3933327, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2485, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27108673, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3094, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10736982, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 526732, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 41565, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4156.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 422916188, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10174.815060748226, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56120, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5612.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 194791816, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3470.9874554526014, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1136074399, "stage_ordering_ns": 326387109, "stage_eval_ns": 632356239, "stage_threat_ns": 1762176074, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 145155, "root_tactical_annotations": 636, "search_tactical_annotations": 144519, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 64162, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 399947202, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 136058, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1301974426, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20039, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 760132109, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 32076, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 48723720, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 64152, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8223738, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 36347, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 200283809, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 79667, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 341412368, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 29141, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3306988, "child_limit_applications": 9987, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9987, "child_cap_hits": 9987, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9987, "child_moves_before_total": 751483, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 751483, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 160117, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 160117, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.24611995594273, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.032542304996497, "tt_hits": 3610, "tt_cutoffs": 465, "beta_cutoffs": 8584, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5151.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5951.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1862, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1309, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15894, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 82, 130, 52, 97, 80, 128, 68, 146, 162, 54, 36, 84, 66, 99, 69, 129, 144, 131, 127, 132 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10211, "avg_search_time_ms": 1021.1, "search_nodes": 98314, "safety_nodes": 350, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 98664, "avg_nodes": 9866.4, "eval_calls": 72130, "avg_eval_calls": 7213.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72130, "pattern_eval_ns": 1571832, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.791653958131153, "pattern_frame_queries": 72130, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1571832, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.791653958131153, "pattern_frame_updates": 196538, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2842139179, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14461.016083403718, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24549, "avg_candidate_generations": 2454.9, "candidate_moves_total": 2072133, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.40804106073567, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 759, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 24539, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2071374, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 774005, "avg_legality_checks": 77400.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 702, "root_legality_checks": 759, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 773246, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 702, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2749053, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 274905.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6234115705, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2267.73208992333, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28923, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2892.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 181803150, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6285.763924904056, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 749, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7630810, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14443, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 137046727, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13731, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37125613, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 95868, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9586.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 938646012, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9791.025284766554, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 130459, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13045.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 426165849, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3266.664998198668, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1970747849, "stage_ordering_ns": 866417702, "stage_eval_ns": 2843711011, "stage_threat_ns": 4486414701, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 384252, "root_tactical_annotations": 2061, "search_tactical_annotations": 382191, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 196548, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1184662612, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 348702, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3116271223, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49143, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1885799544, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 98269, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 148995582, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 196538, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25112568, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 107561, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 270285678, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 191992, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 960178651, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 84699, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11372716, "child_limit_applications": 24539, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24539, "child_cap_hits": 24539, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24539, "child_moves_before_total": 2070672, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2070672, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 396274, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 396274, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.38290068869962, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.14874281755573, "tt_hits": 10499, "tt_cutoffs": 1600, "beta_cutoffs": 19941, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3083.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3883.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 380, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5673, "avg_search_time_ms": 567.3, "search_nodes": 53942, "safety_nodes": 1253, "corridor_nodes": 388, "corridor_branch_probes": 457, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 178, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 382, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 382, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 14, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 8, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 178, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 14, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 12, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 28, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 37280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 55583, "avg_nodes": 5558.3, "eval_calls": 39991, "avg_eval_calls": 3999.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39991, "pattern_eval_ns": 877234, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.935785551749145, "pattern_frame_queries": 39991, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 877234, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.935785551749145, "pattern_frame_updates": 107800, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1124460178, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10430.98495361781, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12938, "avg_candidate_generations": 1293.8, "candidate_moves_total": 984082, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.061369608904, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 791, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 12928, "search_candidate_moves_total": 983291, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 552597, "avg_legality_checks": 55259.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 159, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 552597, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 159, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1639675, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 163967.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3564728736, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2174.0459151966093, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13355, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1335.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 38590588, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2889.5985024335455, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 219, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1927457, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1973, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17806844, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11163, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18856287, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73044, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7304.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 722915965, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9896.993113739663, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 102476, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10247.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 330175980, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3221.983488816894, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1417973496, "stage_ordering_ns": 427293898, "stage_eval_ns": 1125337412, "stage_threat_ns": 2643615890, "stage_proof_ns": 22515732, "tactical_annotations": 194449, "root_tactical_annotations": 682, "search_tactical_annotations": 193767, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 108602, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 654013119, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 213798, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1887871531, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26110, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 972981083, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 54296, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80384899, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 792, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4539073, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 108592, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13657461, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 50597, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 295328778, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 115915, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 601899030, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 27937, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3149807, "child_limit_applications": 12928, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12928, "child_cap_hits": 12928, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12928, "child_moves_before_total": 983132, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 983132, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 208296, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 208296, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.04672029702971, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.11200495049505, "tt_hits": 3664, "tt_cutoffs": 981, "beta_cutoffs": 10334, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4059.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4859.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1310, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9784, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 82, 128, 68, 110, 97, 67, 84, 143, 83, 158, 113, 81, 69, 173, 188, 111, 54, 40, 39, 24, 99 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7002, "avg_search_time_ms": 636.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 125237, "safety_nodes": 346, "corridor_nodes": 1799, "corridor_branch_probes": 1907, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 738, "corridor_neutral_exits": 28, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 1775, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1775, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 75, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 738, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 75, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 72, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 576, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 45978000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1993440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 127382, "avg_nodes": 11580.181818181818, "eval_calls": 100149, "avg_eval_calls": 9104.454545454546, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 100149, "pattern_eval_ns": 1947812, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.449140780237446, "pattern_frame_queries": 100149, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1947812, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.449140780237446, "pattern_frame_updates": 250380, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2147885103, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8578.50109034268, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23929, "avg_candidate_generations": 2175.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 1795108, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.01809519829496, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 720, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 23918, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1794388, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 807956, "avg_legality_checks": 73450.54545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 745, "root_legality_checks": 720, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 807236, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 745, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3169048, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 288095.2727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4113978830, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1298.174981887305, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24891, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2262.818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 72185851, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2900.0783817444058, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 909, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4399796, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12460, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 55385211, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11253, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11522269, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 269, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 878575, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89294, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8117.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 471242313, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5277.424160637893, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10772.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 205964953, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1738.0715346576428, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1187621675, "stage_ordering_ns": 456125265, "stage_eval_ns": 2149832915, "stage_threat_ns": 2953648552, "stage_proof_ns": 200387870, "tactical_annotations": 366888, "root_tactical_annotations": 1881, "search_tactical_annotations": 365007, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 254091, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 925071270, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 454211, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1860391776, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49131, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1070525938, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 127040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125296434, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3700, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13923609, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 254080, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20986544, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 101598, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 92474963, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 194992, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 538215929, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 70298, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7978919, "child_limit_applications": 23918, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23918, "child_cap_hits": 23918, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23918, "child_moves_before_total": 1793643, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1793643, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 384220, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 384220, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.99134543021992, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.064052178275777, "tt_hits": 9030, "tt_cutoffs": 1123, "beta_cutoffs": 17355, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4925.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5652.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1035, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2772, "avg_search_time_ms": 277.2, "search_nodes": 49044, "safety_nodes": 916, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49960, "avg_nodes": 4996.0, "eval_calls": 36257, "avg_eval_calls": 3625.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36257, "pattern_eval_ns": 707383, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.510246297266736, "pattern_frame_queries": 36257, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 707383, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.510246297266736, "pattern_frame_updates": 97998, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 592147831, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6042.448121390233, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12034, "avg_candidate_generations": 1203.4, "candidate_moves_total": 868169, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.14301146750873, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 651, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 12024, "search_candidate_moves_total": 867518, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 468337, "avg_legality_checks": 46833.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 45, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 468337, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 45, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1345286, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 134528.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1667396615, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1239.436532454809, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4023, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 402.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9089777, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2259.452398707432, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 49, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 252422, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1286, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6155923, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2688, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2681432, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47966, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4796.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 261280527, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5447.202747779677, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66696, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6669.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 119676333, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1794.3554785894207, "stage_move_gen_ns": 677633017, "stage_ordering_ns": 215662853, "stage_eval_ns": 592855214, "stage_threat_ns": 1255040992, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 177265, "root_tactical_annotations": 626, "search_tactical_annotations": 176639, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 98008, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 345508025, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 167070, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 852417371, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24113, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 505920461, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48999, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 45708945, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 97998, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7889131, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 47390, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 116660494, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 95559, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 229658314, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 34316, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3517520, "child_limit_applications": 12024, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12024, "child_cap_hits": 12024, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12024, "child_moves_before_total": 867473, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 867473, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 192618, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 192618, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.145126413839, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.019461077844312, "tt_hits": 4008, "tt_cutoffs": 718, "beta_cutoffs": 9667, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5318.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6118.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 758, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1311, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9311, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 110, 128, 82, 124, 111, 113, 97, 127, 125, 129, 130, 83, 68, 54, 67, 52, 66, 98, 143, 65, 95, 155, 81, 51, 53, 39, 109 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6701, "avg_search_time_ms": 478.64285714285717, "search_nodes": 116943, "safety_nodes": 732, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 117675, "avg_nodes": 8405.357142857143, "eval_calls": 87494, "avg_eval_calls": 6249.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87494, "pattern_eval_ns": 1699599, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.42532059341212, "pattern_frame_queries": 87494, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1699599, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.42532059341212, "pattern_frame_updates": 233762, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2058450360, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8805.752688632027, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27596, "avg_candidate_generations": 1971.142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 2114895, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.6377373532396, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 962, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 27582, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2113933, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 720515, "avg_legality_checks": 51465.357142857145, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2337, "root_legality_checks": 962, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 719553, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2329, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2843842, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 203131.57142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3812059238, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1340.460981306275, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31205, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2228.9285714285716, "renju_forbidden_ns": 107792321, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3454.328505047268, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2632, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14978464, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14757, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 68748898, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13772, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23850407, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 214552, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 84876, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6062.571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 441730758, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5204.424784391347, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 111063, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7933.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 180575252, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1625.8812745918983, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1085872611, "stage_ordering_ns": 535314769, "stage_eval_ns": 2060149959, "stage_threat_ns": 2971397883, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 504617, "root_tactical_annotations": 2363, "search_tactical_annotations": 502254, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 233776, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 882697092, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 446172, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1938616069, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 55253, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1278613515, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 116881, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118532982, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 233762, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20118441, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 157044, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 105712532, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 233865, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 554081491, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 113708, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11433299, "child_limit_applications": 27582, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27582, "child_cap_hits": 27582, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27582, "child_moves_before_total": 2111604, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2111604, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 442756, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 442756, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.55731999129867, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.052352983830033, "tt_hits": 12217, "tt_cutoffs": 1805, "beta_cutoffs": 21847, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5832.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6403.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 877, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 2598, "avg_search_time_ms": 199.84615384615384, "search_nodes": 42615, "safety_nodes": 1351, "corridor_nodes": 1114, "corridor_branch_probes": 1397, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 519, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1104, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1104, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 40, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 519, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 40, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 182, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 75640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 45080, "avg_nodes": 3467.6923076923076, "eval_calls": 31466, "avg_eval_calls": 2420.4615384615386, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 31466, "pattern_eval_ns": 609173, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.359721604271275, "pattern_frame_queries": 31466, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 609173, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.359721604271275, "pattern_frame_updates": 85110, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 609630526, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7162.854259193984, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10532, "avg_candidate_generations": 810.1538461538462, "candidate_moves_total": 737926, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.06513482719332, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 887, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 10519, "search_candidate_moves_total": 737039, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 314716, "avg_legality_checks": 24208.923076923078, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1077, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 314716, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1077, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1156358, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 88950.61538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1494456034, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1292.3818004458826, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7588, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 583.6923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30153939, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3973.8981286241433, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1101, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5880453, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3094, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15837566, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3318, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7942238, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 75, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 493682, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 40099, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3084.5384615384614, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 228833230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5706.706651038679, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 55449, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4265.307692307692, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 100147934, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1806.1269635160238, "stage_move_gen_ns": 481419807, "stage_ordering_ns": 187978021, "stage_eval_ns": 610239699, "stage_threat_ns": 1254696710, "stage_proof_ns": 34986411, "tactical_annotations": 171998, "root_tactical_annotations": 371, "search_tactical_annotations": 171627, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 87411, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 339437763, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 227128, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 853166543, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21699, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 501370577, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43699, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 43972581, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2288, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8749733, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 87398, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7273983, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 42616, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 85431147, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 103871, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 236338204, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 25511, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2096107, "child_limit_applications": 10519, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10519, "child_cap_hits": 10519, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10519, "child_moves_before_total": 735962, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 735962, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 169084, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 169084, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.9650156859017, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.074151535317046, "tt_hits": 2834, "tt_cutoffs": 570, "beta_cutoffs": 8479, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5979.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6594.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 629, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1312, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14569, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 110, 128, 82, 124, 111, 113, 97, 125, 127, 67, 98, 95, 99, 100, 109, 108, 114, 66, 69, 122, 123, 84, 68, 54, 80, 140, 64, 48, 83, 55, 79, 81, 53, 38, 49, 94, 92, 70, 34, 19, 130, 146, 85, 86, 22, 102 ], "move_count": 50, "black_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 9841, "avg_search_time_ms": 427.8695652173913, "search_nodes": 134009, "safety_nodes": 2185, "corridor_nodes": 13595, "corridor_branch_probes": 14426, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 5947, "corridor_neutral_exits": 320, "corridor_terminal_exits": 47, "corridor_plies_followed": 13493, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 13453, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 40, "corridor_proof_passes": 21, "corridor_proof_completed": 21, "corridor_proof_checks": 216, "corridor_proof_active": 102, "corridor_proof_quiet": 114, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 320, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5947, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 47, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 216, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 8, "corridor_proof_unknown": 208, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1513, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 40833520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 149789, "avg_nodes": 6512.565217391304, "eval_calls": 96165, "avg_eval_calls": 4181.086956521739, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 96165, "pattern_eval_ns": 1864577, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.389351635210314, "pattern_frame_queries": 96165, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1864577, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.389351635210314, "pattern_frame_updates": 267798, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2071247056, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7734.363423177171, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35976, "avg_candidate_generations": 1564.1739130434783, "candidate_moves_total": 2851651, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.26537135868357, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1797, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 35953, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2849854, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 868479, "avg_legality_checks": 37759.95652173913, "illegal_moves_skipped": 880, "root_legality_checks": 1797, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 866682, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 878, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4733382, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 205799.21739130435, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5895573099, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1245.5308063029775, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24899, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1082.5652173913043, "renju_forbidden_ns": 76573034, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3075.345756857705, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 991, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3979668, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11463, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 53615844, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11748, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17037881, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 697, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1939641, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97268, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4229.04347826087, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 485346741, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4989.788429905005, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 124884, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5429.739130434783, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 203068657, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1626.0582380449057, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1210035166, "stage_ordering_ns": 660286167, "stage_eval_ns": 2073111633, "stage_threat_ns": 4856315926, "stage_proof_ns": 978761623, "tactical_annotations": 699996, "root_tactical_annotations": 3202, "search_tactical_annotations": 696794, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 295239, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1189843179, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1352730, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3354188551, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 79920, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1730089306, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147608, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156331432, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 27418, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 117168866, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 295216, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24423835, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 243756, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 115691852, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 292905, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 536852894, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 163335, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14360063, "child_limit_applications": 35953, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35953, "child_cap_hits": 35953, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35953, "child_moves_before_total": 2848976, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2848976, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 575684, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 575684, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.24167663338247, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.012126943509582, "tt_hits": 16105, "tt_cutoffs": 1781, "beta_cutoffs": 29706, "depth_sum": 110, "avg_depth": 4.782608695652174, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 110, "avg_effective_depth": 4.782608695652174, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6665.478260869565, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7013.304347826087, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 957, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 4704, "avg_search_time_ms": 204.52173913043478, "search_nodes": 75636, "safety_nodes": 2134, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 77770, "avg_nodes": 3381.304347826087, "eval_calls": 52497, "avg_eval_calls": 2282.478260869565, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 52497, "pattern_eval_ns": 1018481, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.40074670933577, "pattern_frame_queries": 52497, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1018481, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.40074670933577, "pattern_frame_updates": 151058, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 903515397, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5981.24824239696, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21565, "avg_candidate_generations": 937.6086956521739, "candidate_moves_total": 1817846, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.29612798516114, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1812, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 21542, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1816034, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1008333, "avg_legality_checks": 43840.565217391304, "illegal_moves_skipped": 439, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1008333, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 439, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2401864, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 104428.86956521739, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2836560614, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1180.983025683386, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10506, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 456.7826086956522, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16278582, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1549.4557395773843, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 451, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1135663, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2367, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8961380, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7673, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6135888, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 45651, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 79229, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3444.7391304347825, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 398685128, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5032.060583877115, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 105921, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4605.260869565217, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 171430607, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1618.476100112348, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1329811147, "stage_ordering_ns": 392266381, "stage_eval_ns": 904533878, "stage_threat_ns": 2019988125, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 478967, "root_tactical_annotations": 1321, "search_tactical_annotations": 477646, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 151081, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 540700839, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 447570, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1385212965, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43236, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 798284668, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75529, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73858999, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 151058, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12225559, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 186800, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 228989868, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 217523, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 357716519, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 74644, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7989763, "child_limit_applications": 21542, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21542, "child_cap_hits": 21542, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21542, "child_moves_before_total": 1815595, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1815595, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 345317, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 345317, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.2816358741064, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.029941509609134, "tt_hits": 8175, "tt_cutoffs": 1490, "beta_cutoffs": 18116, "depth_sum": 107, "avg_depth": 4.6521739130434785, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 107, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6521739130434785, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6871.826086956522, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7219.652173913043, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 701, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1313, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14709, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 144, 96, 114, 68, 110, 54, 40, 95, 99, 129, 100, 142, 113, 111, 115, 116, 130, 85, 83, 94, 97, 131, 146, 92, 93, 81, 145, 160, 147, 143, 148 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 7885, "avg_search_time_ms": 492.8125, "search_nodes": 145113, "safety_nodes": 1009, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 146122, "avg_nodes": 9132.625, "eval_calls": 105042, "avg_eval_calls": 6565.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105042, "pattern_eval_ns": 2044760, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.46611831457893, "pattern_frame_queries": 105042, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2044760, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.46611831457893, "pattern_frame_updates": 290082, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1983131729, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6836.4522066174395, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37525, "avg_candidate_generations": 2345.3125, "candidate_moves_total": 3244854, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.47179213857429, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1282, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 37509, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3243572, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1145391, "avg_legality_checks": 71586.9375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3506, "root_legality_checks": 1282, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 1144109, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3500, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3438270, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 214891.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4438569875, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1290.93115869318, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42697, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2668.5625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 80080794, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1875.5602032929714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4043, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6742803, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15486, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 47833290, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23133, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25448850, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55851, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 95781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5986.3125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 461733375, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4820.719923575657, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118633, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7414.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 177960485, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1500.092596495073, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1639541341, "stage_ordering_ns": 746010192, "stage_eval_ns": 1985176489, "stage_threat_ns": 3448855699, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 584978, "root_tactical_annotations": 3082, "search_tactical_annotations": 581896, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 290098, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1034242396, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 535119, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2238161573, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75121, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1537914592, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 145041, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 142004013, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 290082, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23717645, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 200227, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 172910094, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 259759, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 527029855, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 124992, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10730072, "child_limit_applications": 37509, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37509, "child_cap_hits": 37509, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37509, "child_moves_before_total": 3240072, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3240072, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 601206, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 601206, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.38118851475646, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02831320483084, "tt_hits": 15993, "tt_cutoffs": 2490, "beta_cutoffs": 30675, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6114.3125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6614.3125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1409, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 6808, "avg_search_time_ms": 453.8666666666667, "search_nodes": 80374, "safety_nodes": 1274, "corridor_nodes": 3143, "corridor_branch_probes": 3686, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 15, "corridor_depth_exits": 1394, "corridor_neutral_exits": 19, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 3108, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3108, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 105, "corridor_proof_active": 35, "corridor_proof_quiet": 70, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1394, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 105, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 105, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 740, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 300640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 84791, "avg_nodes": 5652.733333333334, "eval_calls": 52435, "avg_eval_calls": 3495.6666666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 52435, "pattern_eval_ns": 1030084, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.6449699628111, "pattern_frame_queries": 52435, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1030084, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.6449699628111, "pattern_frame_updates": 160608, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 936151453, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5828.797152072126, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25982, "avg_candidate_generations": 1732.1333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 2284498, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.92617966284351, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1205, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 25967, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2283293, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1637165, "avg_legality_checks": 109144.33333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6719, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1637165, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6719, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3491442, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 232762.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4256672938, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1219.173320937309, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35850, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2390.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 28694465, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 800.4034867503486, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6780, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4587159, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3476, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9111180, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25474, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14845606, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 120, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 150520, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 143831, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9588.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 720166967, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5007.035805911104, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 188834, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12588.933333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 289885520, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1535.1341389792092, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2220362576, "stage_ordering_ns": 514516578, "stage_eval_ns": 937181537, "stage_threat_ns": 2968883868, "stage_proof_ns": 95320694, "tactical_annotations": 525612, "root_tactical_annotations": 2041, "search_tactical_annotations": 523571, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 167049, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 686185288, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 641296, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2140925173, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53658, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1100811084, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 83517, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 85265452, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6426, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 29989516, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 167034, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13982683, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 189128, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 394434602, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 226177, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 550535163, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110307, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12535756, "child_limit_applications": 25967, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25967, "child_cap_hits": 25967, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25967, "child_moves_before_total": 2276574, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2276574, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 416385, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 416385, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.67181422574807, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.035160010782917, "tt_hits": 11291, "tt_cutoffs": 1902, "beta_cutoffs": 22587, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6103.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6637.133333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1929, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1314, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10925, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 144, 96, 114, 68, 110, 54, 40, 95, 99, 129, 100, 142, 113, 111, 85, 94, 97, 93, 92, 127, 115, 116, 130, 70, 145 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 6920, "avg_search_time_ms": 532.3076923076923, "search_nodes": 103455, "safety_nodes": 975, "corridor_nodes": 7594, "corridor_branch_probes": 7944, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4052, "corridor_neutral_exits": 48, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 7565, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 7565, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 81, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 52, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 48, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4052, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 81, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 77, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 589, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24045360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 112024, "avg_nodes": 8617.23076923077, "eval_calls": 77206, "avg_eval_calls": 5938.923076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77206, "pattern_eval_ns": 1511487, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.577325596456234, "pattern_frame_queries": 77206, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1511487, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.577325596456234, "pattern_frame_updates": 206796, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1365605178, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6603.634393315151, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24463, "avg_candidate_generations": 1881.7692307692307, "candidate_moves_total": 2002657, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.86473449699547, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 998, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 24450, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2001659, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 818451, "avg_legality_checks": 62957.769230769234, "illegal_moves_skipped": 219, "root_legality_checks": 998, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 817453, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 219, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3160424, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 243109.53846153847, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4122986699, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1304.5675830205062, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29229, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2248.3846153846152, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50519947, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1728.4185911252523, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 523, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1495027, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8228, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25687996, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18585, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19303755, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1893, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4033169, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 84301, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6484.692307692308, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 437619443, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5191.153639933097, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 106888, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8222.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 184144087, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1722.7760553102312, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1246228881, "stage_ordering_ns": 496721217, "stage_eval_ns": 1367116665, "stage_threat_ns": 3300168216, "stage_proof_ns": 459196558, "tactical_annotations": 309846, "root_tactical_annotations": 1832, "search_tactical_annotations": 308014, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 222101, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 870733282, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 652558, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2231588572, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52503, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1193163334, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111044, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 114210074, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 15292, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 58623756, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 222088, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18287627, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 91344, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 119645964, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 152777, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 375174317, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 65725, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6724905, "child_limit_applications": 24450, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24450, "child_cap_hits": 24450, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24450, "child_moves_before_total": 2001440, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2001440, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 391398, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 391398, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.85848670756646, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.008098159509203, "tt_hits": 9799, "tt_cutoffs": 1742, "beta_cutoffs": 19378, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5545.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6160.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1314, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 3992, "avg_search_time_ms": 332.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 51273, "safety_nodes": 1181, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 52454, "avg_nodes": 4371.166666666667, "eval_calls": 33517, "avg_eval_calls": 2793.0833333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33517, "pattern_eval_ns": 655353, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.552853775695915, "pattern_frame_queries": 33517, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 655353, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.552853775695915, "pattern_frame_updates": 102436, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 576602051, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5628.900493966965, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16433, "avg_candidate_generations": 1369.4166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1342790, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.71301649120672, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 930, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 16421, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1341860, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 923123, "avg_legality_checks": 76926.91666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 114, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 923123, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 114, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2113420, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 176118.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2572931552, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1217.4255718219758, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22580, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1881.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19712278, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 872.997254207263, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 513, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 996165, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2372, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6725598, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19667, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11945395, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 45120, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 96836, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8069.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 519166004, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5361.2912966252225, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 126624, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10552.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 226430720, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1788.2132928986607, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1304511741, "stage_ordering_ns": 316214926, "stage_eval_ns": 577257404, "stage_threat_ns": 1750917763, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 278476, "root_tactical_annotations": 1116, "search_tactical_annotations": 277360, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 102448, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 368556210, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 255292, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1319159965, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32921, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 672682451, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51218, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 48552000, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 102436, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8312960, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 84047, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 265249158, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 138315, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 381074526, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 56114, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6336628, "child_limit_applications": 16421, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16421, "child_cap_hits": 16421, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16421, "child_moves_before_total": 1341746, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1341746, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 263000, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 263000, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.70915291395164, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01607697460569, "tt_hits": 6632, "tt_cutoffs": 1280, "beta_cutoffs": 14231, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5707.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6374.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1932, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1315, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13610, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 142, 98, 110, 158, 127, 97, 111, 113, 143, 83, 68, 95, 94, 78, 109, 108, 124, 96, 99, 139, 141, 145, 125, 123, 93, 77, 157 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 10059, "avg_search_time_ms": 718.5, "search_nodes": 115495, "safety_nodes": 732, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 116227, "avg_nodes": 8301.92857142857, "eval_calls": 86584, "avg_eval_calls": 6184.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 86584, "pattern_eval_ns": 1835468, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.198697218885705, "pattern_frame_queries": 86584, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1835468, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.198697218885705, "pattern_frame_updates": 230866, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2994616209, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12971.230969480132, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27172, "avg_candidate_generations": 1940.857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 2092100, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.99470042691006, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 962, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 27158, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2091138, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 732673, "avg_legality_checks": 52333.78571428572, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2418, "root_legality_checks": 962, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 731711, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2410, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2799611, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 199972.2142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5837265841, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2085.0274702449733, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31721, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2265.785714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 177200647, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5586.225119006336, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2747, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 27048141, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15193, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 109249076, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13737, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40480598, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 422832, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 86290, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6163.571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 692856605, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8029.396279986094, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 112673, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8048.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 272218522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2416.0049168833702, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1686317903, "stage_ordering_ns": 824418719, "stage_eval_ns": 2996451677, "stage_threat_ns": 4495933366, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 517346, "root_tactical_annotations": 2363, "search_tactical_annotations": 514983, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 230880, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1314143067, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 445023, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2973406689, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54405, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1934901432, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115433, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 164461526, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 230866, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28231868, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 150676, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 167247370, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 239932, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 870911347, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 126738, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15690216, "child_limit_applications": 27158, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27158, "child_cap_hits": 27158, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27158, "child_moves_before_total": 2088728, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2088728, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 436387, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 436387, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.91022903012004, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.068451285072538, "tt_hits": 12149, "tt_cutoffs": 1691, "beta_cutoffs": 21494, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5557.071428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6128.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 969, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3539, "avg_search_time_ms": 272.2307692307692, "search_nodes": 41841, "safety_nodes": 1351, "corridor_nodes": 1153, "corridor_branch_probes": 1429, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 546, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1143, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1143, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 40, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 546, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 40, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 182, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 71720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 44345, "avg_nodes": 3411.153846153846, "eval_calls": 30563, "avg_eval_calls": 2351.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 30563, "pattern_eval_ns": 628844, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.575336190818962, "pattern_frame_queries": 30563, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 628844, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.575336190818962, "pattern_frame_updates": 83562, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 770823791, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9224.57326296642, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10679, "avg_candidate_generations": 821.4615384615385, "candidate_moves_total": 756729, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.86141024440491, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 887, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 10666, "search_candidate_moves_total": 755842, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 355953, "avg_legality_checks": 27381.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1039, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 355953, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1039, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1217794, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 93676.46153846153, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2066955940, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1697.2952239869796, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7211, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 554.6923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 49529425, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6868.593121619748, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1061, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10214697, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2865, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24893714, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3210, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13561199, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 75, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 859815, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45687, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3514.3846153846152, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 307676041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6734.433011578786, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63888, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4914.461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 128144149, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2005.7624123466067, "stage_move_gen_ns": 692656683, "stage_ordering_ns": 265421074, "stage_eval_ns": 771452635, "stage_threat_ns": 1727209013, "stage_proof_ns": 46601931, "tactical_annotations": 181173, "root_tactical_annotations": 371, "search_tactical_annotations": 180802, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 85941, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 442559398, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 238246, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1205254725, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22008, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 703023000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42964, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 53043512, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2366, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14930003, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 85928, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9059257, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 41948, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 106317195, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 114125, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 344284429, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 25100, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2362118, "child_limit_applications": 10666, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10666, "child_cap_hits": 10666, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10666, "child_moves_before_total": 754803, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 754803, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 171643, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 171643, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.76720420026251, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.092537033564597, "tt_hits": 2789, "tt_cutoffs": 552, "beta_cutoffs": 8700, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5893.538461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6508.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 580, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1316, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26448, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 142, 100, 140, 98, 143, 144, 110, 72, 86, 158, 125, 155, 80, 95, 94, 78, 154, 168, 139, 141, 109, 124, 111, 113, 108 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 22071, "avg_search_time_ms": 1697.7692307692307, "search_nodes": 180364, "safety_nodes": 182, "corridor_nodes": 6264, "corridor_branch_probes": 6812, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2938, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 6224, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6224, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 67, "corridor_proof_active": 40, "corridor_proof_quiet": 27, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2938, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 67, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 67, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 548, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 353440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 186810, "avg_nodes": 14370.0, "eval_calls": 139413, "avg_eval_calls": 10724.076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 139413, "pattern_eval_ns": 3032487, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.75182371801769, "pattern_frame_queries": 139413, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3032487, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.75182371801769, "pattern_frame_updates": 360614, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6975597289, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 19343.667436649714, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38055, "avg_candidate_generations": 2927.3076923076924, "candidate_moves_total": 3575363, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.95251609512547, "candidate_moves_max": 139, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1079, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 38042, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3574284, "search_candidate_moves_max": 139, "legality_checks": 1285332, "avg_legality_checks": 98871.69230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5709, "root_legality_checks": 1079, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1284253, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5708, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5905489, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 454268.3846153846, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13246232912, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2243.0374372046076, "renju_forbidden_checks": 148789, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11445.307692307691, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1205917714, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8104.884863800416, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8007, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 80473551, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 93128, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 875689660, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 45468, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 222182519, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2186, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 27571984, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 187600, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14430.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1942959730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10356.928198294243, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 270491, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20807.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 900005443, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3327.3027309596255, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3289888906, "stage_ordering_ns": 1466444736, "stage_eval_ns": 6978629776, "stage_threat_ns": 9453343974, "stage_proof_ns": 829466814, "tactical_annotations": 797027, "root_tactical_annotations": 4062, "search_tactical_annotations": 792965, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 373209, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2370597986, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1079544, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6649404043, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 79176, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3281308642, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 186598, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 295127141, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12582, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 69164883, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 373196, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48671040, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 247948, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 429778822, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 407307, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1961318704, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 141772, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20378881, "child_limit_applications": 38042, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38042, "child_cap_hits": 38042, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38042, "child_moves_before_total": 3568576, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3568576, "child_moves_before_max": 139, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 139, "child_moves_after_total": 619354, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 619354, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.80621418432258, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.280794910887966, "tt_hits": 15453, "tt_cutoffs": 2856, "beta_cutoffs": 29273, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.46153846153846156, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.46153846153846156, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 861.8461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1169.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 4368, "avg_search_time_ms": 364.0, "search_nodes": 35907, "safety_nodes": 1283, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 37190, "avg_nodes": 3099.1666666666665, "eval_calls": 25166, "avg_eval_calls": 2097.1666666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 25166, "pattern_eval_ns": 550225, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.863824207263768, "pattern_frame_queries": 25166, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 550225, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.863824207263768, "pattern_frame_updates": 71704, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 982467440, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13701.710364833203, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10046, "avg_candidate_generations": 837.1666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 790049, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.64314154887518, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 997, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 10034, "search_candidate_moves_total": 789052, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 353588, "avg_legality_checks": 29465.666666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 660, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 353588, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 660, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1196757, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 99729.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2697182132, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2253.7425158156584, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12403, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1033.5833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 99489900, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8021.438361686689, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 820, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8957327, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6719, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 66649252, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4845, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23704021, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 179300, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50880, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4240.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 513554094, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10093.437382075472, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 73280, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6106.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 231745972, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3162.472325327511, "stage_move_gen_ns": 938002517, "stage_ordering_ns": 349997046, "stage_eval_ns": 983017665, "stage_threat_ns": 2066923232, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 176582, "root_tactical_annotations": 341, "search_tactical_annotations": 176241, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 71716, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 462006826, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 180265, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1538524658, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20147, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 844416225, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 35852, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 55381717, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 71704, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9475316, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 39901, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 163549682, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 120211, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 530339800, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 16470, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1534715, "child_limit_applications": 10034, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10034, "child_cap_hits": 10034, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10034, "child_moves_before_total": 788392, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 788392, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 162502, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 162502, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.57205501295594, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.195136535778353, "tt_hits": 2260, "tt_cutoffs": 652, "beta_cutoffs": 8439, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5390.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6057.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1317, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32040, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 82, 126, 97, 127, 66, 50, 52, 67, 38, 80, 95, 125, 124, 94, 142, 130, 68, 83, 84, 78, 62, 36, 64, 99, 70, 56, 24, 10, 100, 116, 65, 63, 115, 93, 85, 55, 108, 102, 88, 35, 51, 33, 48, 34, 32, 37 ], "move_count": 50, "black_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 12012, "avg_search_time_ms": 522.2608695652174, "search_nodes": 166756, "safety_nodes": 2561, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 169317, "avg_nodes": 7361.608695652174, "eval_calls": 126192, "avg_eval_calls": 5486.608695652174, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 126192, "pattern_eval_ns": 2524392, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.004374286801067, "pattern_frame_queries": 126192, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2524392, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.004374286801067, "pattern_frame_updates": 333292, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3213774210, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9642.518302269482, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37893, "avg_candidate_generations": 1647.5217391304348, "candidate_moves_total": 3164491, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.51122898688412, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2005, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 37870, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3162486, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1370636, "avg_legality_checks": 59592.86956521739, "illegal_moves_skipped": 605, "root_legality_checks": 2005, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1368631, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 605, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4059341, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 176493.08695652173, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7100412640, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1749.154022783501, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30234, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1314.5217391304348, "renju_forbidden_ns": 107680359, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3561.5650922802142, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 778, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4796502, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13660, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 80507823, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15788, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22361894, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 14140, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 111858, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4863.391304347826, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 796716931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7122.574433656958, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 146836, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6384.173913043478, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 351683813, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2395.078952028113, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2703496103, "stage_ordering_ns": 1004022399, "stage_eval_ns": 3216298602, "stage_threat_ns": 4995093994, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 727698, "root_tactical_annotations": 2831, "search_tactical_annotations": 724867, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 333315, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1546904102, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 658887, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3199256497, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75896, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1977979548, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 166646, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 198834338, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 333292, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34538309, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 237779, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 177714709, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 345193, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1042488376, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 144726, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15560748, "child_limit_applications": 37870, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37870, "child_cap_hits": 37870, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37870, "child_moves_before_total": 3161881, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3161881, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 609379, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 609379, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.49302878267758, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.09133879059942, "tt_hits": 15432, "tt_cutoffs": 2584, "beta_cutoffs": 29630, "depth_sum": 110, "avg_depth": 4.782608695652174, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 110, "avg_effective_depth": 4.782608695652174, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6463.304347826087, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6811.130434782609, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1068, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 20006, "avg_search_time_ms": 869.8260869565217, "search_nodes": 195312, "safety_nodes": 1403, "corridor_nodes": 10146, "corridor_branch_probes": 11555, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 5094, "corridor_neutral_exits": 32, "corridor_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_plies_followed": 10086, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 10086, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 21, "corridor_proof_completed": 21, "corridor_proof_checks": 137, "corridor_proof_active": 60, "corridor_proof_quiet": 77, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 43, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5094, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 137, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 134, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1001, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 534320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 15120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 206861, "avg_nodes": 8993.95652173913, "eval_calls": 139193, "avg_eval_calls": 6051.869565217391, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 139193, "pattern_eval_ns": 2871103, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.626777208624, "pattern_frame_queries": 139193, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2871103, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.626777208624, "pattern_frame_updates": 390410, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2965938569, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7596.98411669783, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52460, "avg_candidate_generations": 2280.8695652173915, "candidate_moves_total": 4983982, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.00537552420892, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2034, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 52437, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4981948, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 3545542, "avg_legality_checks": 154154.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 307, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3545542, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 307, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7235009, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 314565.60869565216, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12589648153, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1740.101242859546, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34367, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1494.2173913043478, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60483090, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1759.917653563011, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 331, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2159920, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3881, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18244831, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30150, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40037229, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 41110, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 238746, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10380.260869565218, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1807753526, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7571.869375822003, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 312169, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13572.565217391304, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 843541285, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2702.194276177327, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7026339788, "stage_ordering_ns": 1514988212, "stage_eval_ns": 2968809672, "stage_threat_ns": 8258583562, "stage_proof_ns": 112319787, "tactical_annotations": 1218179, "root_tactical_annotations": 4565, "search_tactical_annotations": 1213614, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 410879, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2214897966, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1557782, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5563503507, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 109531, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2759721128, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 205428, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 272664138, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 20446, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 129063634, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 410856, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45031683, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 471937, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1023248062, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 494394, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1437245010, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 251848, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33422634, "child_limit_applications": 52437, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52437, "child_cap_hits": 52437, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52437, "child_moves_before_total": 4981641, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4981641, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 858460, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 858460, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.00240288346015, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.371264565097164, "tt_hits": 23822, "tt_cutoffs": 3575, "beta_cutoffs": 44075, "depth_sum": 107, "avg_depth": 4.6521739130434785, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 107, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6521739130434785, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.17391304347826086, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6646.826086956522, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6994.652173913043, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 562, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1318, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12514, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 82, 124, 126, 140, 127, 138, 152, 142, 114, 130, 113, 141, 139, 144, 143, 158, 115, 116, 111 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8788, "avg_search_time_ms": 878.8, "search_nodes": 64354, "safety_nodes": 485, "corridor_nodes": 6204, "corridor_branch_probes": 6801, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 2551, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 6159, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6159, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 21, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2551, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 83, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 683, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 443760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 71043, "avg_nodes": 7104.3, "eval_calls": 43998, "avg_eval_calls": 4399.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 43998, "pattern_eval_ns": 912025, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.72878312650575, "pattern_frame_queries": 43998, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 912025, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.72878312650575, "pattern_frame_updates": 128620, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1469375445, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11424.159889597264, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18861, "avg_candidate_generations": 1886.1, "candidate_moves_total": 1480473, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.4938762525847, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 714, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 18851, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1479759, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 554182, "avg_legality_checks": 55418.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 341, "root_legality_checks": 714, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 553468, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 341, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2671460, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 267146.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5630732227, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2107.7359297912003, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17502, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1750.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 93302376, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5330.95509084676, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 384, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3855629, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5570, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 45860380, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10023, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29028222, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1525, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 14558145, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73830, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7383.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 674638891, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9137.733861573886, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 99695, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9969.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 300332752, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3012.5156928632327, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1323975779, "stage_ordering_ns": 607043657, "stage_eval_ns": 1470287470, "stage_threat_ns": 4492674609, "stage_proof_ns": 861979272, "tactical_annotations": 260625, "root_tactical_annotations": 1612, "search_tactical_annotations": 259013, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 141114, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 908772864, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 613824, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3385735719, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41181, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1680876322, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70552, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105859014, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12484, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 67510084, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 141104, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17627903, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 60558, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 151648399, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 135770, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 565969743, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 64297, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7169025, "child_limit_applications": 18851, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18851, "child_cap_hits": 18851, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18851, "child_moves_before_total": 1479418, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1479418, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 302174, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 302174, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.47955015649038, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02960055169487, "tt_hits": 8334, "tt_cutoffs": 1461, "beta_cutoffs": 15978, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 4.4, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 4.4, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3586.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4386.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 447, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 3717, "avg_search_time_ms": 413.0, "search_nodes": 37803, "safety_nodes": 1081, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 38884, "avg_nodes": 4320.444444444444, "eval_calls": 28035, "avg_eval_calls": 3115.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 28035, "pattern_eval_ns": 572132, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.407775994292848, "pattern_frame_queries": 28035, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 572132, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.407775994292848, "pattern_frame_updates": 75526, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 779749469, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10324.252164817413, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9108, "avg_candidate_generations": 1012.0, "candidate_moves_total": 666381, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.16436100131752, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 640, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 9099, "search_candidate_moves_total": 665741, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 369159, "avg_legality_checks": 41017.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 109, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 369159, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 109, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1114628, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 123847.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2329367907, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2089.81642933786, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4390, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 487.77777777777777, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20059769, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4569.423462414578, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 164, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1572842, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1546, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12480131, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2680, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6006796, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46751, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5194.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 428444095, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9164.38354259802, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66064, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7340.444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 187203165, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2833.663795713248, "stage_move_gen_ns": 896855531, "stage_ordering_ns": 280167846, "stage_eval_ns": 780321601, "stage_threat_ns": 1733996979, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 130331, "root_tactical_annotations": 386, "search_tactical_annotations": 129945, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 75535, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 442786390, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 130813, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1226953515, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18256, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 678110245, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37763, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 53167599, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 75526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9268957, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 28252, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 147080968, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 84297, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 401411071, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 17782, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1820518, "child_limit_applications": 9099, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9099, "child_cap_hits": 9099, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9099, "child_moves_before_total": 665632, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 665632, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 145953, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 145953, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.1544125728102, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.04055390702275, "tt_hits": 2489, "tt_cutoffs": 629, "beta_cutoffs": 7287, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4614.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5503.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1319, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14083, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 99, 113, 144, 83, 128, 68, 53, 96, 82, 95, 94, 81, 172, 157, 160, 176, 65, 145, 126, 129 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7000, "avg_search_time_ms": 636.3636363636364, "search_nodes": 84622, "safety_nodes": 848, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85470, "avg_nodes": 7770.0, "eval_calls": 67087, "avg_eval_calls": 6098.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67087, "pattern_eval_ns": 1360043, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.27282483938766, "pattern_frame_queries": 67087, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1360043, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.27282483938766, "pattern_frame_updates": 169142, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1751427050, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10354.773208310176, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16547, "avg_candidate_generations": 1504.2727272727273, "candidate_moves_total": 1171213, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.78098749017948, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 749, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 16536, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1170464, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 645202, "avg_legality_checks": 58654.72727272727, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3552, "root_legality_checks": 749, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "search_legality_checks": 644453, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3535, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1902848, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 172986.18181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4113527647, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2161.77416535635, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18256, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1659.6363636363637, "renju_forbidden_ns": 130562821, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7151.775909290096, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3760, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 37831026, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7716, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71514518, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6689, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20372001, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 91, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 845276, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 61413, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5583.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 560838403, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9132.242407959227, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 80754, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7341.272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 247877579, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3069.539329321148, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1613000728, "stage_ordering_ns": 501900361, "stage_eval_ns": 1752787093, "stage_threat_ns": 3096424948, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 187808, "root_tactical_annotations": 1030, "search_tactical_annotations": 186778, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169153, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 958183277, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 190652, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1997402946, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33145, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1259833997, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84571, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 116829708, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169142, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20354992, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 36809, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 94511852, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 120689, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 642261465, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 30310, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3654025, "child_limit_applications": 16536, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16536, "child_cap_hits": 16536, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16536, "child_moves_before_total": 1166929, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1166929, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 265144, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 265144, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.56900096758588, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.034349298500242, "tt_hits": 5056, "tt_cutoffs": 948, "beta_cutoffs": 12124, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 4.636363636363637, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 4.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4237.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4964.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 676, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7073, "avg_search_time_ms": 643.0, "search_nodes": 53090, "safety_nodes": 611, "corridor_nodes": 903, "corridor_branch_probes": 1045, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 365, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 34, "corridor_plies_followed": 892, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 892, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 33, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 22, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 365, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 33, "corridor_proof_wins": 6, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 27, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 177, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 102960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 16800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 13, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 7, "total_nodes": 54604, "avg_nodes": 4964.0, "eval_calls": 35110, "avg_eval_calls": 3191.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35110, "pattern_eval_ns": 723682, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.611848476217602, "pattern_frame_queries": 35110, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 723682, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.611848476217602, "pattern_frame_updates": 106082, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1093876216, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10311.610037518147, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16865, "avg_candidate_generations": 1533.1818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 1284868, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.18547287281352, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 16854, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1284082, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 919054, "avg_legality_checks": 83550.36363636363, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11089, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 919054, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11089, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2148258, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 195296.18181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4507885265, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2098.3910056427117, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31483, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2862.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 258177281, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8200.529841501762, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11277, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 110905917, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10887, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 104238900, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9191, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41752082, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 128, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1280382, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 82199, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7472.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 761860948, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9268.49411793331, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 105591, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9599.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 351012481, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3324.265145703706, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2309481177, "stage_ordering_ns": 522965901, "stage_eval_ns": 1094599898, "stage_threat_ns": 3052234514, "stage_proof_ns": 48882048, "tactical_annotations": 271657, "root_tactical_annotations": 1589, "search_tactical_annotations": 270068, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 107943, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 644271732, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 302027, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2298991356, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34271, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1301239162, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 53966, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 77677851, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1850, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10155470, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 107932, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13301846, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 80895, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 321482736, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 132900, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 635566439, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 57862, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7836259, "child_limit_applications": 16854, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16854, "child_cap_hits": 16854, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16854, "child_moves_before_total": 1272993, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1272993, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 270887, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 270887, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.53061587753649, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.07256437640916, "tt_hits": 6992, "tt_cutoffs": 1077, "beta_cutoffs": 14587, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5007.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5734.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1879, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1320, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18374, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 99, 113, 144, 68, 172, 157, 128, 96, 124, 83, 53, 125, 160, 176, 139, 95, 94, 80, 140, 65 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7507, "avg_search_time_ms": 682.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 86609, "safety_nodes": 1000, "corridor_nodes": 1043, "corridor_branch_probes": 1245, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 492, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1033, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1033, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 70, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 60, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 492, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 70, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 70, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 466, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 27847200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1970800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 88652, "avg_nodes": 8059.272727272727, "eval_calls": 68097, "avg_eval_calls": 6190.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68097, "pattern_eval_ns": 1353067, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.869700574180946, "pattern_frame_queries": 68097, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1353067, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.869700574180946, "pattern_frame_updates": 173116, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1706732449, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9858.894897063241, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17584, "avg_candidate_generations": 1598.5454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 1286840, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.18243858052776, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 17573, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1286032, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 728041, "avg_legality_checks": 66185.54545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6687, "root_legality_checks": 808, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 23, "search_legality_checks": 727233, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2266366, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 206033.27272727274, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4482823394, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1977.9785762758531, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32290, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2935.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 225254468, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6975.982285537318, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7158, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 74097665, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10413, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 98724963, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13660, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43160658, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1059, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9271182, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6828.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 696178613, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9267.923545935007, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 102078, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9279.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 326430150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3197.850173396814, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1738613252, "stage_ordering_ns": 492854332, "stage_eval_ns": 1708085516, "stage_threat_ns": 3322920325, "stage_proof_ns": 203783052, "tactical_annotations": 214503, "root_tactical_annotations": 853, "search_tactical_annotations": 213650, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 175333, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 917397743, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 274674, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2256324066, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35831, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1245030961, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 87661, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113597092, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2206, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12793081, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 175322, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19409217, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 43718, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 117019644, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 138733, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 738803475, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 32052, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3399126, "child_limit_applications": 17573, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17573, "child_cap_hits": 17573, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17573, "child_moves_before_total": 1279368, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1279368, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 282740, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 282740, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.80305013372788, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.089455414556422, "tt_hits": 5101, "tt_cutoffs": 888, "beta_cutoffs": 13104, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 4.636363636363637, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 4.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4461.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5189.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1184, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10856, "avg_search_time_ms": 986.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 90932, "safety_nodes": 691, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91623, "avg_nodes": 8329.363636363636, "eval_calls": 66467, "avg_eval_calls": 6042.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 66467, "pattern_eval_ns": 1388957, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.896941339311237, "pattern_frame_queries": 66467, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1388957, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.896941339311237, "pattern_frame_updates": 181770, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2346207171, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12907.55994388513, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23055, "avg_candidate_generations": 2095.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 1938800, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.09455649533724, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 846, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 23044, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1937954, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1352162, "avg_legality_checks": 122923.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 26188, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1352162, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 26188, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3234979, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 294089.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6522963920, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2016.385243922758, "renju_forbidden_checks": 109721, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9974.636363636364, "renju_forbidden_ns": 840235130, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7657.9244629560435, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 26818, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 283210370, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 42556, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 425657979, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 40203, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 129866514, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 144, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1500267, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 122126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11102.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1182477857, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9682.441552167433, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 162453, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14768.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 573436486, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3529.860858217454, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3371357192, "stage_ordering_ns": 731593349, "stage_eval_ns": 2347596128, "stage_threat_ns": 4347073696, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 451250, "root_tactical_annotations": 1887, "search_tactical_annotations": 449363, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 181781, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1043676008, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 398277, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3140389101, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46156, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1649528485, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 90885, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 127311623, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 181770, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22315964, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 144975, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 574833942, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 207138, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 915928173, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 99137, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13381000, "child_limit_applications": 23044, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23044, "child_cap_hits": 23044, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23044, "child_moves_before_total": 1911766, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1911766, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 373828, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 373828, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.96155181392119, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.22235722964763, "tt_hits": 9763, "tt_cutoffs": 1374, "beta_cutoffs": 18876, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5040.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5767.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1934, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1321, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11892, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 113, 114, 126, 98, 66, 130, 146, 129, 131, 99, 96, 81, 84, 86, 110, 109, 141, 156, 142, 100, 72, 101, 97, 102 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 4981, "avg_search_time_ms": 415.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 58461, "safety_nodes": 1205, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59666, "avg_nodes": 4972.166666666667, "eval_calls": 45466, "avg_eval_calls": 3788.8333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 45466, "pattern_eval_ns": 930092, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.456868869045, "pattern_frame_queries": 45466, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 930092, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.456868869045, "pattern_frame_updates": 116812, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1170404843, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10019.560002397015, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12359, "avg_candidate_generations": 1029.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 898901, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.73250262966259, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 826, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 12347, "search_candidate_moves_total": 898075, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 495920, "avg_legality_checks": 41326.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 220, "root_legality_checks": 826, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 495094, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 220, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1405812, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 117151.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3011761659, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2142.36445484887, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13034, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1086.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30029343, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2303.9238146386374, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 284, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2346308, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2716, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15633542, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10030, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12042602, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6891, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44387, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3698.9166666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 411365723, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9267.707279158312, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 60134, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5011.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 186386828, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3099.5248611434463, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1196076515, "stage_ordering_ns": 381066866, "stage_eval_ns": 1171334935, "stage_threat_ns": 2196957505, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 139565, "root_tactical_annotations": 676, "search_tactical_annotations": 138889, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 116824, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 666577727, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 142166, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1434410021, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24773, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 891826864, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58406, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 79935569, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116812, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14107241, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 25901, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 62391429, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 91483, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 479469105, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 22181, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1926947, "child_limit_applications": 12347, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12347, "child_cap_hits": 12347, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12347, "child_moves_before_total": 897855, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 897855, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 197701, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 197701, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.7184741232688, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.012067708755165, "tt_hits": 4044, "tt_cutoffs": 593, "beta_cutoffs": 9352, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5357.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6024.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1007, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6900, "avg_search_time_ms": 575.0, "search_nodes": 52897, "safety_nodes": 765, "corridor_nodes": 842, "corridor_branch_probes": 986, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 291, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_plies_followed": 827, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 827, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 58, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 291, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 58, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 422, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 110960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 54504, "avg_nodes": 4542.0, "eval_calls": 33805, "avg_eval_calls": 2817.0833333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33805, "pattern_eval_ns": 706121, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.88806389587339, "pattern_frame_queries": 33805, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 706121, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.88806389587339, "pattern_frame_updates": 105690, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 936786765, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8863.532642634118, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17970, "avg_candidate_generations": 1497.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1385645, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.10879243183084, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 855, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 17958, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1384790, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 999427, "avg_legality_checks": 83285.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 74, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 999427, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 74, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2148611, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 179050.91666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4550488295, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2117.8744291079215, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21884, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1823.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31236432, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1427.363918844818, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 162, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 913572, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1406, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7424390, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20311, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22837860, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 60610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 66252, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5521.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 586488920, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8852.395701261848, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 85187, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7098.916666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 254703296, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2989.9315153720636, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2373976522, "stage_ordering_ns": 567524835, "stage_eval_ns": 937492886, "stage_threat_ns": 2880043413, "stage_proof_ns": 93085928, "tactical_annotations": 261484, "root_tactical_annotations": 1613, "search_tactical_annotations": 259871, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 107472, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 654003184, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 283203, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2116005203, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36600, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1303775463, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 53730, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 78479846, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1770, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9778857, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 107460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13622678, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 59847, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 230113030, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 130925, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 540884348, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 70712, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8153645, "child_limit_applications": 17958, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17958, "child_cap_hits": 17958, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17958, "child_moves_before_total": 1384716, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1384716, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 287673, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 287673, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.10858670230537, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.019211493484796, "tt_hits": 8260, "tt_cutoffs": 1082, "beta_cutoffs": 15773, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5328.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5994.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1846, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1322, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11246, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 113, 114, 126, 98, 66, 130, 146, 129, 131, 99, 96, 81, 84, 100, 110, 109, 141, 156, 142, 101, 97, 102 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5174, "avg_search_time_ms": 470.3636363636364, "search_nodes": 55793, "safety_nodes": 1002, "corridor_nodes": 1971, "corridor_branch_probes": 2315, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 785, "corridor_neutral_exits": 28, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 1937, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1902, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 35, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 34, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 785, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 7, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 426, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 43790960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 58766, "avg_nodes": 5342.363636363636, "eval_calls": 43431, "avg_eval_calls": 3948.2727272727275, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 43431, "pattern_eval_ns": 873914, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.12189449932076, "pattern_frame_queries": 43431, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 873914, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.12189449932076, "pattern_frame_updates": 111486, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1066075517, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9562.416061209478, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11794, "avg_candidate_generations": 1072.1818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 842540, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.43801933186366, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 719, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 11783, "search_candidate_moves_total": 841821, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 459602, "avg_legality_checks": 41782.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 98, "root_legality_checks": 719, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 458883, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 98, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1595569, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 145051.72727272726, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3191681251, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2000.3404747773366, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11807, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1073.3636363636363, "renju_forbidden_ns": 22490556, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1904.8493266706191, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 130, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 632022, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2398, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11470069, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8837, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9009247, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 442, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1379218, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43989, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3999.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 367288419, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8349.55145604583, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 58779, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5343.545454545455, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 166410954, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2831.129382942888, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1040962740, "stage_ordering_ns": 340439636, "stage_eval_ns": 1066949431, "stage_threat_ns": 2380420192, "stage_proof_ns": 316904186, "tactical_annotations": 129005, "root_tactical_annotations": 676, "search_tactical_annotations": 128329, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 115515, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 663553055, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 251512, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1597702524, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24755, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 885451598, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57752, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80144296, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4018, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 23767842, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 115504, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13375678, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 24207, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 50154719, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 82899, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 386916180, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 21899, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1876797, "child_limit_applications": 11783, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11783, "child_cap_hits": 11783, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11783, "child_moves_before_total": 841723, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 841723, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 188846, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 188846, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.43537299499279, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02698803360774, "tt_hits": 3903, "tt_cutoffs": 529, "beta_cutoffs": 8927, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5074.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5801.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 968, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6060, "avg_search_time_ms": 550.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 50759, "safety_nodes": 554, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 51313, "avg_nodes": 4664.818181818182, "eval_calls": 32249, "avg_eval_calls": 2931.7272727272725, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32249, "pattern_eval_ns": 661425, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.509938292660237, "pattern_frame_queries": 32249, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 661425, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.509938292660237, "pattern_frame_updates": 101424, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 833815572, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8221.087434926645, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17467, "avg_candidate_generations": 1587.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 1336726, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.52865403331998, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 740, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 17456, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1335986, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 978464, "avg_legality_checks": 88951.27272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 978464, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2040184, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 185471.27272727274, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4012901926, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1966.9313777580846, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20579, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1870.8181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21802003, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1059.429661305214, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 89670, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 946, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 3872808, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19594, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17778895, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 60630, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64638, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5876.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 519530793, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8037.544370184721, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 82456, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7496.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 225636101, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2736.442478412729, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2151841331, "stage_ordering_ns": 513823877, "stage_eval_ns": 834476997, "stage_threat_ns": 2512359547, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 249761, "root_tactical_annotations": 1585, "search_tactical_annotations": 248176, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 101435, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 573727359, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 216405, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1849751529, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34980, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1164948519, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50712, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 69275659, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 101424, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12124543, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56704, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 203939348, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 124714, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 480765902, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 68343, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7480457, "child_limit_applications": 17456, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17456, "child_cap_hits": 17456, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17456, "child_moves_before_total": 1335976, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1335976, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 279663, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 279663, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.53391384051329, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02102428964253, "tt_hits": 8023, "tt_cutoffs": 1007, "beta_cutoffs": 15378, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5262.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5989.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1848, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1323, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14672, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 67, 82, 98, 96, 68, 111, 141, 66, 81, 110, 83, 124, 138, 113, 53, 38, 39, 95, 25 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8318, "avg_search_time_ms": 831.8, "search_nodes": 102159, "safety_nodes": 314, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 102473, "avg_nodes": 10247.3, "eval_calls": 79837, "avg_eval_calls": 7983.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79837, "pattern_eval_ns": 1627794, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.388967521324698, "pattern_frame_queries": 79837, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1627794, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.388967521324698, "pattern_frame_updates": 204234, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2394310106, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11723.366853707023, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21054, "avg_candidate_generations": 2105.4, "candidate_moves_total": 1510439, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.74118932269403, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 626, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 21044, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1509813, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 706284, "avg_legality_checks": 70628.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1607, "root_legality_checks": 626, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 705658, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1605, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2320447, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 232044.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4968413223, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2141.144884153786, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20867, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2086.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 100846342, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4832.814587626396, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1677, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15365318, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9816, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62491709, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9364, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22882485, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 106830, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60352, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6035.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 523787344, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8678.873011664899, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86311, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8631.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 230631947, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2672.1037527082294, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1715200828, "stage_ordering_ns": 619537212, "stage_eval_ns": 2395937900, "stage_threat_ns": 3545075339, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 270582, "root_tactical_annotations": 1515, "search_tactical_annotations": 269067, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 204244, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1147994381, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 258299, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2227739559, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42149, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1480273746, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102117, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 138958143, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 204234, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24143360, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56600, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 78657546, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 159543, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 668691126, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 54439, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6239896, "child_limit_applications": 21044, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21044, "child_cap_hits": 21044, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21044, "child_moves_before_total": 1508208, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1508208, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 337049, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 337049, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.66926439840334, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01639422163087, "tt_hits": 7104, "tt_cutoffs": 1237, "beta_cutoffs": 15966, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 4.1, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 4.1, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3748.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4548.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6344, "avg_search_time_ms": 704.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 84640, "safety_nodes": 525, "corridor_nodes": 268, "corridor_branch_probes": 318, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 86, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 261, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 261, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 73, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 66, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 73, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 73, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 563, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 28138080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85433, "avg_nodes": 9492.555555555555, "eval_calls": 68800, "avg_eval_calls": 7644.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68800, "pattern_eval_ns": 1410977, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.508386627906976, "pattern_frame_queries": 68800, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1410977, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.508386627906976, "pattern_frame_updates": 169200, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1600828264, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9461.159952718675, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14911, "avg_candidate_generations": 1656.7777777777778, "candidate_moves_total": 1066576, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.5294748843136, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 569, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 14902, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1066007, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 613423, "avg_legality_checks": 68158.11111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1638, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 613423, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1638, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1759816, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 195535.11111111112, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3696041630, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2100.2432242916307, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19107, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2123.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 147733171, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7731.887318783692, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1641, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16236739, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10900, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 101587083, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6492, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29103976, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 805373, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39517, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4390.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 355163936, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8987.623959308652, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 59564, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6618.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 158270506, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2657.1503928547445, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1496231966, "stage_ordering_ns": 433040350, "stage_eval_ns": 1602239241, "stage_threat_ns": 2652281845, "stage_proof_ns": 124053249, "tactical_annotations": 215471, "root_tactical_annotations": 1171, "search_tactical_annotations": 214300, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169877, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 937080159, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 213471, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1572068098, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30274, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1048740069, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84934, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113875246, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 668, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3527766, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169868, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19467288, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56320, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 132085412, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 107874, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 377169954, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 51277, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6263288, "child_limit_applications": 14902, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14902, "child_cap_hits": 14902, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14902, "child_moves_before_total": 1064369, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1064369, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 238434, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 238434, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.42457388270032, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00013421017313, "tt_hits": 5865, "tt_cutoffs": 898, "beta_cutoffs": 10348, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4127.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5016.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1846, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1324, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14661, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 67, 82, 98, 96, 68, 111, 141, 66, 81, 110, 83, 124, 138, 113, 53, 38, 39, 95, 25 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8463, "avg_search_time_ms": 846.3, "search_nodes": 102082, "safety_nodes": 314, "corridor_nodes": 99, "corridor_branch_probes": 107, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 96, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 96, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 35, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 35, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 279, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 288160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 21520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 102495, "avg_nodes": 10249.5, "eval_calls": 79770, "avg_eval_calls": 7977.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79770, "pattern_eval_ns": 1636677, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.517450169236554, "pattern_frame_queries": 79770, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1636677, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.517450169236554, "pattern_frame_updates": 204080, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2410048329, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11809.331286750294, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21043, "avg_candidate_generations": 2104.3, "candidate_moves_total": 1509738, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.74537851066863, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 626, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 21033, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1509112, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 705774, "avg_legality_checks": 70577.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1607, "root_legality_checks": 626, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 705148, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1605, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2356256, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 235625.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5069987959, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2151.713548527834, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20886, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2088.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 102134372, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4890.087714258355, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1677, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15496323, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9810, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 63071580, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9361, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23331818, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 234651, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60526, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6052.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 529927799, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8755.374533258435, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86536, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8653.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 233822195, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2702.0222219654247, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1720349938, "stage_ordering_ns": 622322725, "stage_eval_ns": 2411685006, "stage_threat_ns": 3587489025, "stage_proof_ns": 80143400, "tactical_annotations": 270478, "root_tactical_annotations": 1515, "search_tactical_annotations": 268963, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 204358, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1151980549, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 266019, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2262272359, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42329, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1493259251, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102174, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 141109295, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 268, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1335226, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 204348, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24284544, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56593, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 79745965, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 159467, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 673340863, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 54418, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6507052, "child_limit_applications": 21033, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21033, "child_cap_hits": 21033, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21033, "child_moves_before_total": 1507507, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1507507, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 336873, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 336873, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.6734179622498, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.016402795606904, "tt_hits": 7101, "tt_cutoffs": 1237, "beta_cutoffs": 15962, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 4.1, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 4.1, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3689.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4489.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6188, "avg_search_time_ms": 687.5555555555555, "search_nodes": 84640, "safety_nodes": 525, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 85165, "avg_nodes": 9462.777777777777, "eval_calls": 68800, "avg_eval_calls": 7644.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68800, "pattern_eval_ns": 1424414, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.703691860465117, "pattern_frame_queries": 68800, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1424414, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.703691860465117, "pattern_frame_updates": 169200, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1608278499, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9505.192074468085, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14911, "avg_candidate_generations": 1656.7777777777778, "candidate_moves_total": 1066576, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.5294748843136, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 569, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 14902, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1066007, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 613423, "avg_legality_checks": 68158.11111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1638, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 613423, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1638, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1712534, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 190281.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3609713481, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2107.8200380255225, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19013, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2112.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 147708786, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7768.831115552517, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1641, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16419451, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10900, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 102081491, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6462, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29096562, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 111282, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39517, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4390.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 357356526, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9043.10868740036, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 59564, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6618.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 159747269, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2681.943271103351, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1500261832, "stage_ordering_ns": 427569905, "stage_eval_ns": 1609702913, "stage_threat_ns": 2613014540, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 215471, "root_tactical_annotations": 1171, "search_tactical_annotations": 214300, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169209, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 926864156, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 194063, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1548717351, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29862, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1036439351, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84600, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112152643, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169200, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19500366, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56320, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 132856373, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 107874, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 379303807, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 51277, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5780024, "child_limit_applications": 14902, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14902, "child_cap_hits": 14902, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14902, "child_moves_before_total": 1064369, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1064369, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 238434, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 238434, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.42457388270032, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00013421017313, "tt_hits": 5865, "tt_cutoffs": 898, "beta_cutoffs": 10348, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4201.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5090.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1853, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1325, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26536, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 68, 82, 114, 98, 140, 97, 67, 129, 145, 125, 83, 124, 123, 139, 153, 109, 154, 93, 141, 79, 94, 65, 81, 51, 37, 107 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 21113, "avg_search_time_ms": 1407.5333333333333, "search_nodes": 268063, "safety_nodes": 211, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 268274, "avg_nodes": 17884.933333333334, "eval_calls": 216011, "avg_eval_calls": 14400.733333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 216011, "pattern_eval_ns": 4418273, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.45392595747439, "pattern_frame_queries": 216011, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4418273, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.45392595747439, "pattern_frame_updates": 535992, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7208137841, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13448.219079762384, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49545, "avg_candidate_generations": 3303.0, "candidate_moves_total": 4104681, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.84753254617014, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1076, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 49530, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4103605, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1543819, "avg_legality_checks": 102921.26666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4578, "root_legality_checks": 1076, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1542743, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4577, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5921525, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 394768.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12031017909, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2031.7431588991012, "renju_forbidden_checks": 157534, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10502.266666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 602984545, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3827.647015882286, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16481, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 72316712, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 74060, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 392183619, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 66890, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 138184283, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 103, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 299931, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 168548, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11236.533333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1390817291, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8251.75790279327, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 220495, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14699.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 567584305, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2574.1368511757637, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3526822000, "stage_ordering_ns": 1546142534, "stage_eval_ns": 7212556114, "stage_threat_ns": 8741562835, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1059653, "root_tactical_annotations": 4291, "search_tactical_annotations": 1055362, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 536007, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2955469092, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 928810, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5318430130, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 99156, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3261811473, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 267996, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 369709710, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 535992, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65771298, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 365721, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 375075026, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 463919, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1681450641, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 230013, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32182605, "child_limit_applications": 49530, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49530, "child_cap_hits": 49530, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49530, "child_moves_before_total": 4099028, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4099028, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 807768, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 807768, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.7584898041591, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.308661417322835, "tt_hits": 20622, "tt_cutoffs": 2455, "beta_cutoffs": 35427, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3095.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3629.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 967, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 5407, "avg_search_time_ms": 386.2142857142857, "search_nodes": 50710, "safety_nodes": 1415, "corridor_nodes": 78, "corridor_branch_probes": 96, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 73, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 73, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 301, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 191120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 52203, "avg_nodes": 3728.785714285714, "eval_calls": 34499, "avg_eval_calls": 2464.214285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34499, "pattern_eval_ns": 711700, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.629583466187427, "pattern_frame_queries": 34499, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 711700, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.629583466187427, "pattern_frame_updates": 101290, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1070591970, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10569.57221838286, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15297, "avg_candidate_generations": 1092.642857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 1143967, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.78374844740799, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 994, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 15283, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1142973, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 555467, "avg_legality_checks": 39676.21428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2040, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 555467, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2040, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1617298, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 115521.28571428571, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3327606402, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2057.5097489763793, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18492, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1320.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 83313843, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4505.399253731343, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3113, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22829952, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5944, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38310461, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9270, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21701879, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 165, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 471551, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3607.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 476696548, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9439.161775771257, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5150.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 221459258, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3071.5569764216366, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1334248778, "stage_ordering_ns": 455230954, "stage_eval_ns": 1071303670, "stage_threat_ns": 2424109835, "stage_proof_ns": 86493544, "tactical_annotations": 256827, "root_tactical_annotations": 646, "search_tactical_annotations": 256181, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 101552, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 592376963, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 255128, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1742284117, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30896, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1054748337, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50769, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 71511815, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 248, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1335786, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 101538, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12297697, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 153800204, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 156287, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 529105255, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 38470, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4303457, "child_limit_applications": 15283, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15283, "child_cap_hits": 15283, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15283, "child_moves_before_total": 1140933, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1140933, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 247022, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 247022, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.6537329058431, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.163187855787477, "tt_hits": 4591, "tt_cutoffs": 863, "beta_cutoffs": 13051, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5767.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6338.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1828, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1326, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15274, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 68, 82, 114, 98, 140, 97, 67, 81, 65, 84, 70, 83, 80, 85 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10716, "avg_search_time_ms": 1190.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 113770, "safety_nodes": 459, "corridor_nodes": 1544, "corridor_branch_probes": 1785, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 716, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1521, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1521, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 76, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 716, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 76, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 74, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 581, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 71341120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1993440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 115773, "avg_nodes": 12863.666666666666, "eval_calls": 92229, "avg_eval_calls": 10247.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 92229, "pattern_eval_ns": 2002177, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.70875754914398, "pattern_frame_queries": 92229, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2002177, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.70875754914398, "pattern_frame_updates": 227466, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3326597630, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14624.592818267345, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20390, "avg_candidate_generations": 2265.5555555555557, "candidate_moves_total": 1477376, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.45590975968612, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 558, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 20381, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1476818, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 684542, "avg_legality_checks": 76060.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2253, "root_legality_checks": 558, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 683984, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2252, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2763511, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 307056.77777777775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6351197551, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2298.234944966747, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36032, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4003.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 262616876, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7288.434613676732, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2344, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23878091, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21192, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 192283048, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11918, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41423468, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 578, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5032269, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75159, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8351.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 781558038, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10398.72853550473, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 108130, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12014.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 376205019, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3479.191889392398, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1788576310, "stage_ordering_ns": 679686054, "stage_eval_ns": 3328599807, "stage_threat_ns": 4574747761, "stage_proof_ns": 309506624, "tactical_annotations": 276745, "root_tactical_annotations": 1505, "search_tactical_annotations": 275240, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 230669, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1439769561, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 350047, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2903432967, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41718, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1682445407, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 175383505, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3194, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18685072, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 230660, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30139493, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 64113, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 136228213, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 158958, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 854411818, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53674, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7337163, "child_limit_applications": 20381, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20381, "child_cap_hits": 20381, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20381, "child_moves_before_total": 1474566, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1474566, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 326604, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 326604, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.35003189244885, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02492517540847, "tt_hits": 7752, "tt_cutoffs": 1123, "beta_cutoffs": 14304, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2179.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2998.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 858, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 4549, "avg_search_time_ms": 568.625, "search_nodes": 38774, "safety_nodes": 603, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 39377, "avg_nodes": 4922.125, "eval_calls": 26531, "avg_eval_calls": 3316.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 26531, "pattern_eval_ns": 587112, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.129282725867853, "pattern_frame_queries": 26531, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 587112, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.129282725867853, "pattern_frame_updates": 77478, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 868426587, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11208.686168977, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11435, "avg_candidate_generations": 1429.375, "candidate_moves_total": 818105, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.5439440314823, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 485, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 11427, "search_candidate_moves_total": 817620, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 477918, "avg_legality_checks": 59739.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1881, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 477918, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1881, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1282229, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 160278.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2874955455, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2242.1544474504944, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9719, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1214.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 68215810, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7018.809548307439, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1883, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20088776, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3358, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33574147, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4473, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14492096, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 60791, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43293, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5411.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 455017852, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10510.194534913266, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63528, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7941.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 219276527, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3451.6516654073794, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1246623442, "stage_ordering_ns": 366583499, "stage_eval_ns": 869013699, "stage_threat_ns": 2037889621, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 157465, "root_tactical_annotations": 596, "search_tactical_annotations": 156869, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 77486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 486508763, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 151062, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1479986017, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22905, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 882552123, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38739, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 57362561, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 77478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10156561, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 35760, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 141623610, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 92391, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 455597243, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 29314, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3875719, "child_limit_applications": 11427, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11427, "child_cap_hits": 11427, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11427, "child_moves_before_total": 815739, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 815739, "child_moves_before_max": 96, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 96, "child_moves_after_total": 183452, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 183452, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.38697820950381, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.054257460400805, "tt_hits": 3879, "tt_cutoffs": 781, "beta_cutoffs": 9685, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 4.375, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 4.375, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4026.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5026.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1820, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1327, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 34079, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 82, 97, 98, 84, 99, 113, 129, 126, 130, 111, 141, 83, 125, 65, 81, 93, 157, 173, 142, 172, 144, 143, 128, 131, 102, 116, 100, 101, 86, 69, 55, 117, 115, 85, 53, 133 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 17475, "avg_search_time_ms": 970.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 193597, "safety_nodes": 705, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 194302, "avg_nodes": 10794.555555555555, "eval_calls": 139527, "avg_eval_calls": 7751.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 139527, "pattern_eval_ns": 3045922, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.83034108093774, "pattern_frame_queries": 139527, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3045922, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.83034108093774, "pattern_frame_updates": 387024, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4398157506, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11364.043330646162, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 51091, "avg_candidate_generations": 2838.3888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 4364171, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.41956508974184, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1344, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 51073, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4362827, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1480764, "avg_legality_checks": 82264.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 707, "root_legality_checks": 1344, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1479420, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 705, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4476709, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 248706.05555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10141685958, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2265.4333703620227, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34577, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1920.9444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 120957746, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3498.2140150967407, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 892, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7094490, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11664, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71437695, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22007, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42357861, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 67700, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 88657, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4925.388888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 773733727, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8727.27169879423, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 119163, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6620.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 323216584, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2712.3904567692994, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3668498481, "stage_ordering_ns": 1770260317, "stage_eval_ns": 4401203428, "stage_threat_ns": 7553678856, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 923693, "root_tactical_annotations": 4251, "search_tactical_annotations": 919442, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 387042, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2281328934, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 830078, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4909785736, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 102267, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3568274531, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 193512, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 287722903, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 387024, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49551332, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 345179, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 200570345, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 382617, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1140733210, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 195897, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 25289951, "child_limit_applications": 51073, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 51073, "child_cap_hits": 51073, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 51073, "child_moves_before_total": 4362122, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4362122, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 834176, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 834176, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.40955103479334, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.333013529653634, "tt_hits": 21198, "tt_cutoffs": 2912, "beta_cutoffs": 42009, "depth_sum": 84, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 84, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5060.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5504.944444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 16585, "avg_search_time_ms": 921.3888888888889, "search_nodes": 155102, "safety_nodes": 1191, "corridor_nodes": 1659, "corridor_branch_probes": 1767, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 624, "corridor_neutral_exits": 53, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 1635, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1635, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 141, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 117, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 53, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 624, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 141, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 138, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1047, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 775040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 157952, "avg_nodes": 8775.111111111111, "eval_calls": 111257, "avg_eval_calls": 6180.944444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 111257, "pattern_eval_ns": 2451005, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.030119453158004, "pattern_frame_queries": 111257, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2451005, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.030119453158004, "pattern_frame_updates": 310040, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2760310599, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8903.078954328474, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41185, "avg_candidate_generations": 2288.0555555555557, "candidate_moves_total": 3368833, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.79757193152847, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1376, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 41167, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3367457, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 2276311, "avg_legality_checks": 126461.72222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 186, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2276311, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 186, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4779466, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 265525.8888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10416893955, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2179.5100027911067, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42257, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2347.6111111111113, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65841565, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1558.1220862815628, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 402, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1726220, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3485, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16120210, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 38324, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 47794905, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 46, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 200230, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 107055, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5947.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1005166652, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9389.254607444771, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 150209, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8344.944444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 471835598, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3141.193923133767, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5492138608, "stage_ordering_ns": 1362869991, "stage_eval_ns": 2762761604, "stage_threat_ns": 6621400133, "stage_proof_ns": 240464598, "tactical_annotations": 812814, "root_tactical_annotations": 3090, "search_tactical_annotations": 809724, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 313610, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1859263628, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 809604, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4438635104, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 83903, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2823306985, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 156796, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 233283856, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3552, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 23756770, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 313592, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40264010, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 267947, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 372296430, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 357540, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1171961805, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 187327, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26196765, "child_limit_applications": 41167, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41167, "child_cap_hits": 41167, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41167, "child_moves_before_total": 3367271, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3367271, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 663574, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 663574, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.79539436927637, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.119075958899117, "tt_hits": 17277, "tt_cutoffs": 2596, "beta_cutoffs": 33998, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5682.722222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6127.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1860, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1328, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26773, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 82, 97, 98, 84, 99, 113, 129, 126, 130, 111, 141, 83, 125, 65, 81, 93, 157, 173, 143, 94, 95, 69, 55, 171, 142, 172, 140, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 15924, "avg_search_time_ms": 1061.6, "search_nodes": 178133, "safety_nodes": 680, "corridor_nodes": 1106, "corridor_branch_probes": 1214, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 432, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 1091, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1091, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 110, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 95, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 432, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 110, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 106, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 845, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 861680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 15920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 179919, "avg_nodes": 11994.6, "eval_calls": 136380, "avg_eval_calls": 9092.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 136380, "pattern_eval_ns": 2942592, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.57641882974043, "pattern_frame_queries": 136380, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2942592, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.57641882974043, "pattern_frame_updates": 356132, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4300030442, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12074.260223737267, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39423, "avg_candidate_generations": 2628.2, "candidate_moves_total": 3153610, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.99416584227481, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1056, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 39408, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3152554, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1283590, "avg_legality_checks": 85572.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 439, "root_legality_checks": 1056, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1282534, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 439, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4256222, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 283748.13333333336, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9421056971, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2213.4787543976795, "renju_forbidden_checks": 52038, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3469.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 175341228, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3369.484376801568, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2405, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18929461, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19618, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 82969271, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29420, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 70351537, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 595, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3090959, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97740, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6516.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 896674377, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9174.077931246164, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 135576, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9038.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 380574376, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2807.092523750516, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3166172164, "stage_ordering_ns": 1302148263, "stage_eval_ns": 4302973034, "stage_threat_ns": 6765952259, "stage_proof_ns": 318986643, "tactical_annotations": 620014, "root_tactical_annotations": 2946, "search_tactical_annotations": 617068, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 358549, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2116206535, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 638560, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4308554778, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 79951, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2831677214, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 179267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 263649161, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2402, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15643512, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 358534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45468340, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 190400, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 258445501, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 302149, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1055563559, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 127465, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16429933, "child_limit_applications": 39408, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39408, "child_cap_hits": 39408, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39408, "child_moves_before_total": 3152115, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3152115, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 632318, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 632318, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.9866778319123, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.045422249289484, "tt_hits": 14901, "tt_cutoffs": 2278, "beta_cutoffs": 30564, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 4.4, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 4.4, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4370.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4903.466666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 10834, "avg_search_time_ms": 773.8571428571429, "search_nodes": 121803, "safety_nodes": 981, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122784, "avg_nodes": 8770.285714285714, "eval_calls": 89328, "avg_eval_calls": 6380.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89328, "pattern_eval_ns": 1938209, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.69766478595737, "pattern_frame_queries": 89328, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1938209, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.69766478595737, "pattern_frame_updates": 243476, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2047260010, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8408.467405411622, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30513, "avg_candidate_generations": 2179.5, "candidate_moves_total": 2248195, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.67990692491725, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 984, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 30499, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2247211, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1404694, "avg_legality_checks": 100335.28571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 43, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1404694, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 43, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3140942, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 224353.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6615522534, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2106.2224434580453, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15661, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1118.642857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29793402, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1902.3946108166783, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 255, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2181980, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1855, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10341040, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13537, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17138432, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 131950, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67085, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4791.785714285715, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 582085958, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8676.842185287322, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 93297, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6664.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 249206585, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2671.1103786831304, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3246637151, "stage_ordering_ns": 914938650, "stage_eval_ns": 2049198219, "stage_threat_ns": 4545923114, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 487494, "root_tactical_annotations": 2071, "search_tactical_annotations": 485423, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 243490, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1379145056, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 444820, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2951164684, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61091, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2029528093, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121738, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 172519809, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 243476, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30052425, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 141480, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 247903483, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 242237, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 673497787, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 103777, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13041140, "child_limit_applications": 30499, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30499, "child_cap_hits": 30499, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30499, "child_moves_before_total": 2247168, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2247168, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 488001, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 488001, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.68005508377324, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000557395324435, "tt_hits": 11771, "tt_cutoffs": 1911, "beta_cutoffs": 24620, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5307.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5878.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1865, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1329, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20860, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 67, 82, 96, 98, 66, 113, 143, 68, 83, 114, 69, 111, 115, 130, 146, 99, 129, 101, 157, 171, 142, 127, 141, 71, 85, 100, 102, 86, 72, 116, 56, 131 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 12646, "avg_search_time_ms": 790.375, "search_nodes": 139004, "safety_nodes": 755, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 139759, "avg_nodes": 8734.9375, "eval_calls": 103729, "avg_eval_calls": 6483.0625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 103729, "pattern_eval_ns": 2276516, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.94676512836333, "pattern_frame_queries": 103729, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2276516, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.94676512836333, "pattern_frame_updates": 277858, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3442020638, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12387.69672998438, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33105, "avg_candidate_generations": 2069.0625, "candidate_moves_total": 2568303, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.58051653828727, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1132, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 33089, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2567171, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1065393, "avg_legality_checks": 66587.0625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1803, "root_legality_checks": 1132, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1064261, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1801, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3335666, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 208479.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7534470989, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2258.7606160209084, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30897, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1931.0625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 128430559, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4156.732336472796, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2922, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22199131, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11582, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 70316432, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16327, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 35636535, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 66, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 278461, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 82285, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5142.8125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 715328421, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8693.302801239593, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 108379, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6773.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 294394372, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2716.341468365643, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2694118001, "stage_ordering_ns": 1071466644, "stage_eval_ns": 3444297154, "stage_threat_ns": 5372501927, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 518292, "root_tactical_annotations": 2621, "search_tactical_annotations": 515671, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 277874, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1671532331, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 470587, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3443810929, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 66285, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2333587272, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 138929, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 207691486, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 277858, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37213234, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 136067, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 121735476, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 268225, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 988292450, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 114000, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12253947, "child_limit_applications": 33089, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33089, "child_cap_hits": 33089, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33089, "child_moves_before_total": 2565370, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2565370, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 529584, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 529584, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.52939043186558, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.004835443803078, "tt_hits": 13070, "tt_cutoffs": 2112, "beta_cutoffs": 26394, "depth_sum": 74, "avg_depth": 4.625, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 74, "avg_effective_depth": 4.625, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5151.6875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5651.6875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 8200, "avg_search_time_ms": 512.5, "search_nodes": 101392, "safety_nodes": 1606, "corridor_nodes": 596, "corridor_branch_probes": 677, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 232, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 7, "corridor_plies_followed": 583, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 583, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 87, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 74, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 232, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 87, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 591, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 28114080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 103594, "avg_nodes": 6474.625, "eval_calls": 81313, "avg_eval_calls": 5082.0625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 81313, "pattern_eval_ns": 1774414, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.82202107904025, "pattern_frame_queries": 81313, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1774414, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.82202107904025, "pattern_frame_updates": 202640, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2009269006, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9915.460945519148, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18942, "avg_candidate_generations": 1183.875, "candidate_moves_total": 1412962, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.59412944778798, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1168, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 18926, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1411794, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 752983, "avg_legality_checks": 47061.4375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3018, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 752983, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3018, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2136385, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 133524.0625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4747459981, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2222.193088324436, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23211, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1450.6875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 161764902, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6969.320666925165, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3884, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33537452, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10416, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 94715607, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8690, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32169357, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 221, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1342486, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45946, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2871.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 418436560, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9107.137944543594, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65129, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4070.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 177067043, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2718.7127546868523, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1941470159, "stage_ordering_ns": 591952211, "stage_eval_ns": 2011043420, "stage_threat_ns": 3445485741, "stage_proof_ns": 154622188, "tactical_annotations": 299956, "root_tactical_annotations": 1292, "search_tactical_annotations": 298664, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 203996, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1219018781, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 306399, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2036131582, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38554, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1361127211, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 101990, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 148114828, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1340, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8600696, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 203980, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25862638, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 78223, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 153803724, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 153876, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 493786676, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 67857, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7757216, "child_limit_applications": 18926, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18926, "child_cap_hits": 18926, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18926, "child_moves_before_total": 1408776, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1408776, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 302821, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 302821, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.43601394906477, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00026418683293, "tt_hits": 7112, "tt_cutoffs": 1081, "beta_cutoffs": 13552, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5664.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6164.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1839, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1330, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15774, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 67, 82, 96, 98, 66, 113, 143, 68, 83, 114, 81, 146, 130, 111, 51, 36, 99, 115, 35 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9213, "avg_search_time_ms": 921.3, "search_nodes": 101625, "safety_nodes": 316, "corridor_nodes": 455, "corridor_branch_probes": 491, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 148, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 447, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 447, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 45, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 148, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 45, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 42, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 314, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 376480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 26080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 10, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 8, "total_nodes": 102396, "avg_nodes": 10239.6, "eval_calls": 79116, "avg_eval_calls": 7911.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79116, "pattern_eval_ns": 1724766, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.800470195662065, "pattern_frame_queries": 79116, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1724766, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.800470195662065, "pattern_frame_updates": 203166, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2533633329, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12470.754599686956, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21259, "avg_candidate_generations": 2125.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1538169, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.35377957570911, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 628, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 21249, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1537541, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 755500, "avg_legality_checks": 75550.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2014, "root_legality_checks": 628, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 754872, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2012, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2451408, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 245140.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5576818519, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2274.945059737098, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21987, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2198.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 112748846, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5127.9777141037885, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2076, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19900489, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9824, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 66221851, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9933, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25677512, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 154, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 948994, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 61403, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6140.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 566944791, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9233.177385469766, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 87990, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8799.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 247826883, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2816.534640300034, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1947015302, "stage_ordering_ns": 675691812, "stage_eval_ns": 2535358095, "stage_threat_ns": 3863644967, "stage_proof_ns": 144225662, "tactical_annotations": 258141, "root_tactical_annotations": 1515, "search_tactical_annotations": 256626, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 204160, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1220699508, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 285224, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2455611695, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42973, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1586069104, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102075, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 149580189, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 984, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5934143, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 204150, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25779665, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52085, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 77572102, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 159021, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 720281202, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 47035, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6039767, "child_limit_applications": 21249, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21249, "child_cap_hits": 21249, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21249, "child_moves_before_total": 1535529, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1535529, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 340086, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 340086, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.26358887477058, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.004800225892982, "tt_hits": 7051, "tt_cutoffs": 1219, "beta_cutoffs": 16169, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 4.1, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 4.1, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3378.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4178.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6552, "avg_search_time_ms": 728.0, "search_nodes": 88059, "safety_nodes": 521, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 88580, "avg_nodes": 9842.222222222223, "eval_calls": 72123, "avg_eval_calls": 8013.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72123, "pattern_eval_ns": 1566973, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.726397959042192, "pattern_frame_queries": 72123, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1566973, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.726397959042192, "pattern_frame_updates": 176038, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1690038820, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9600.420477396925, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15101, "avg_candidate_generations": 1677.888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 1077265, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.33732865373155, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 565, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 15092, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1076700, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 613641, "avg_legality_checks": 68182.33333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2980, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 613641, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2980, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1704928, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 189436.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3777248469, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2215.4885537688397, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17306, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1922.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 143846413, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8311.938807350052, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2981, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30247465, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8970, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 88214844, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5345, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25270734, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 113370, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37144, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4127.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 342097850, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9210.04334482016, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 54504, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6056.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 147820062, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2712.095662703655, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1591387874, "stage_ordering_ns": 455365759, "stage_eval_ns": 1691605793, "stage_threat_ns": 2769211945, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 217485, "root_tactical_annotations": 1171, "search_tactical_annotations": 216314, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 176047, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1024870021, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 191941, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1592941378, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30242, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1086656447, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 88019, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 122065003, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 176038, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21631517, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52798, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 116120920, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 108894, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 390034000, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 55793, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7704026, "child_limit_applications": 15092, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15092, "child_cap_hits": 15092, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15092, "child_moves_before_total": 1073720, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1073720, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 241475, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 241475, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.14497747150808, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000198780811026, "tt_hits": 5801, "tt_cutoffs": 804, "beta_cutoffs": 10331, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3992.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4881.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1844, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1331, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29020, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 96, 142, 94, 98, 128, 80, 95, 158, 174, 93, 79, 63, 64, 109, 127, 143, 141, 99, 144, 160, 159, 189, 81, 66, 34, 49, 155, 169, 129, 114, 130, 50 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 21351, "avg_search_time_ms": 1255.9411764705883, "search_nodes": 273054, "safety_nodes": 853, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 273907, "avg_nodes": 16112.176470588236, "eval_calls": 219730, "avg_eval_calls": 12925.29411764706, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 219730, "pattern_eval_ns": 4821798, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.944195148591454, "pattern_frame_queries": 219730, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4821798, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.944195148591454, "pattern_frame_updates": 545948, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6277594087, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11498.520164924132, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 50753, "avg_candidate_generations": 2985.470588235294, "candidate_moves_total": 4452942, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.73751305341557, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1306, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 50736, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4451636, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1749617, "avg_legality_checks": 102918.64705882352, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3172, "root_legality_checks": 1306, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 1748311, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3168, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5542682, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 326040.1176470588, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12209486739, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2202.8120572314992, "renju_forbidden_checks": 50898, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2994.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 151924925, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2984.889877794805, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3784, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9603242, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28938, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 112996339, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18145, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29291614, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 31, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 33730, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 160734, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9454.941176470587, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1268222284, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7890.193014545771, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 196292, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11546.588235294117, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 437995305, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2231.3456737921056, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4242100905, "stage_ordering_ns": 1785751680, "stage_eval_ns": 6282415885, "stage_threat_ns": 8947091225, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 911094, "root_tactical_annotations": 4043, "search_tactical_annotations": 907051, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 545965, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3158326509, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 816769, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5290162808, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 101586, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3395129765, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 272974, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 403305807, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 545948, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67979233, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 305888, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 376602382, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 409280, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1518062379, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 195926, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 27316868, "child_limit_applications": 50736, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 50736, "child_cap_hits": 50736, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 50736, "child_moves_before_total": 4448468, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4448468, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 814202, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 814202, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.67872910753705, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.04781614632608, "tt_hits": 19899, "tt_cutoffs": 2508, "beta_cutoffs": 36292, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4117647058823529, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4900.64705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5371.235294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 935, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 7650, "avg_search_time_ms": 450.0, "search_nodes": 70399, "safety_nodes": 1669, "corridor_nodes": 350, "corridor_branch_probes": 398, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 129, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_plies_followed": 339, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 339, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 129, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 323, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 259840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 72418, "avg_nodes": 4259.882352941177, "eval_calls": 48836, "avg_eval_calls": 2872.705882352941, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48836, "pattern_eval_ns": 1087997, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.27858546973544, "pattern_frame_queries": 48836, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1087997, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.27858546973544, "pattern_frame_updates": 140644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1389090329, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9876.641228918405, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20494, "avg_candidate_generations": 1205.5294117647059, "candidate_moves_total": 1694875, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.70103444910706, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1327, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 20477, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1693548, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 880700, "avg_legality_checks": 51805.882352941175, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2903, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 880700, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2903, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2148640, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 126390.58823529411, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4743094374, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2207.486770236056, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14108, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 829.8823529411765, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33448420, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2370.8831868443435, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2903, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3249364, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3781, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18727493, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7394, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11435043, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 36520, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 61400, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3611.764705882353, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 531632024, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8658.502019543974, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 79232, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4660.705882352941, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 208144353, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2627.0238413772213, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2140952598, "stage_ordering_ns": 697975744, "stage_eval_ns": 1390178326, "stage_threat_ns": 3262518454, "stage_proof_ns": 104362613, "tactical_annotations": 313994, "root_tactical_annotations": 1112, "search_tactical_annotations": 312882, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 141457, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 873290601, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 317805, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2248975273, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41463, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1452306355, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70720, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 109613869, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 796, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5142640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 141440, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17968079, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 85667, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 261658402, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 168978, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 518105003, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 59349, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7527992, "child_limit_applications": 20477, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20477, "child_cap_hits": 20477, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20477, "child_moves_before_total": 1690645, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1690645, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 327887, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 327887, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.56311959759731, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.012452996044342, "tt_hits": 7361, "tt_cutoffs": 1009, "beta_cutoffs": 17288, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6013.176470588235, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6483.764705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1750, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1332, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 34015, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 96, 142, 94, 98, 128, 80, 95, 158, 174, 93, 79, 63, 64, 109, 127, 143, 141, 99, 144, 160, 159, 189, 81, 66, 34, 49, 155, 169, 129, 114, 130, 50 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 26514, "avg_search_time_ms": 1559.6470588235295, "search_nodes": 273054, "safety_nodes": 853, "corridor_nodes": 15038, "corridor_branch_probes": 15849, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 6840, "corridor_neutral_exits": 21, "corridor_terminal_exits": 37, "corridor_plies_followed": 14972, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 14972, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 194, "corridor_proof_active": 66, "corridor_proof_quiet": 128, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 21, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 6840, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 37, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 194, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 194, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1556, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 113253040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2013360, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 288945, "avg_nodes": 16996.764705882353, "eval_calls": 219730, "avg_eval_calls": 12925.29411764706, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 219730, "pattern_eval_ns": 4762389, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.67382241842261, "pattern_frame_queries": 219730, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4762389, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.67382241842261, "pattern_frame_updates": 545948, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6312132977, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11561.784230366262, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 50753, "avg_candidate_generations": 2985.470588235294, "candidate_moves_total": 4452942, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.73751305341557, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1306, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 50736, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4451636, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1749617, "avg_legality_checks": 102918.64705882352, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3172, "root_legality_checks": 1306, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 1748311, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3168, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7349188, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 432305.17647058825, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15958965570, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2171.5277347647116, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54135, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3184.4117647058824, "renju_forbidden_ns": 160438061, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2963.666038607186, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3784, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9623029, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28938, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 113359711, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18448, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31371335, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2965, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6083986, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 189023, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11119.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1555716645, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8230.303428683283, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 234151, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13773.588235294117, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 579436639, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2474.6280776080393, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4268705727, "stage_ordering_ns": 1787343355, "stage_eval_ns": 6316895366, "stage_threat_ns": 12207742472, "stage_proof_ns": 1827556645, "tactical_annotations": 911094, "root_tactical_annotations": 4043, "search_tactical_annotations": 907051, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 576297, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3566462367, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1630979, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7898195925, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 109970, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3903792753, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 288140, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 437865426, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 30332, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 204508258, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 576280, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 72086174, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 305888, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 381104405, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 409280, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1520257045, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 195926, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28624322, "child_limit_applications": 50736, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 50736, "child_cap_hits": 50736, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 50736, "child_moves_before_total": 4448468, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4448468, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 814202, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 814202, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.67872910753705, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.04781614632608, "tt_hits": 19899, "tt_cutoffs": 2508, "beta_cutoffs": 36292, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4117647058823529, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2730.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3177.764705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 142, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 7483, "avg_search_time_ms": 440.1764705882353, "search_nodes": 70399, "safety_nodes": 1669, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 72068, "avg_nodes": 4239.294117647059, "eval_calls": 48836, "avg_eval_calls": 2872.705882352941, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48836, "pattern_eval_ns": 1075777, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.02836022606274, "pattern_frame_queries": 48836, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1075777, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.02836022606274, "pattern_frame_updates": 140644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1382734418, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9831.449745456614, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20494, "avg_candidate_generations": 1205.5294117647059, "candidate_moves_total": 1694875, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.70103444910706, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1327, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 20477, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1693548, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 880700, "avg_legality_checks": 51805.882352941175, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2903, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 880700, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2903, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2108366, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 124021.5294117647, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4650023037, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2205.5103511439665, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14058, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 826.9411764705883, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32722543, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2327.6812491108267, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2903, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3135838, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3781, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18467060, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7354, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11098095, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 21550, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 61400, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3611.764705882353, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 530596442, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8641.635863192183, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 79232, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4660.705882352941, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 206760649, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2609.5598874192247, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2139864338, "stage_ordering_ns": 698183323, "stage_eval_ns": 1383810195, "stage_threat_ns": 3203590775, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 313994, "root_tactical_annotations": 1112, "search_tactical_annotations": 312882, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 140661, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 858921047, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 295720, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2213611911, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41064, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1434288697, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70322, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105252200, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 140644, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17913040, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 85667, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 261710122, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 168978, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 517201211, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 59349, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7892577, "child_limit_applications": 20477, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20477, "child_cap_hits": 20477, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20477, "child_moves_before_total": 1690645, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1690645, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 327887, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 327887, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.56311959759731, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.012452996044342, "tt_hits": 7361, "tt_cutoffs": 1009, "beta_cutoffs": 17288, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6039.058823529412, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6509.64705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1825, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1333, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 37077, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 96, 95, 99, 125, 97, 100, 80, 109, 108, 81, 123, 79, 127, 63, 47, 141, 93, 138, 94, 140, 155, 157, 173, 139, 137, 122, 66, 52, 114, 82, 84, 129, 69, 54, 85, 71, 53, 153, 167, 101, 68, 83, 67, 65, 70 ], "move_count": 52, "black_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 15416, "avg_search_time_ms": 642.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 170507, "safety_nodes": 2674, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 173181, "avg_nodes": 7215.875, "eval_calls": 134968, "avg_eval_calls": 5623.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 134968, "pattern_eval_ns": 2945161, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.8211798352202, "pattern_frame_queries": 134968, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2945161, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.8211798352202, "pattern_frame_updates": 340784, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4663412411, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13684.364321681769, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33570, "avg_candidate_generations": 1398.75, "candidate_moves_total": 2705522, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.59344652963956, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2052, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 33546, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2703470, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 1265328, "avg_legality_checks": 52722.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3469, "root_legality_checks": 2052, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 1263276, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3465, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4120313, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 171679.70833333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9145004157, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2219.492586364191, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40486, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1686.9166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 243220909, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6007.531220668873, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3685, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 36988790, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20519, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 163472210, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16262, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42535928, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 223981, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 125808, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5242.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1128235849, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8967.91816895587, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 166051, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6918.791666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 486079804, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2927.2922415402495, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3108315066, "stage_ordering_ns": 1125993893, "stage_eval_ns": 4666357572, "stage_threat_ns": 6440422879, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 617407, "root_tactical_annotations": 2366, "search_tactical_annotations": 615041, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 340808, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2074179680, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 569214, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4047775005, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67255, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2441327753, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 170392, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 260540584, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 340784, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44029831, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 187443, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 291859382, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 314498, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1313559598, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 115466, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13897779, "child_limit_applications": 33546, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33546, "child_cap_hits": 33546, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33546, "child_moves_before_total": 2700005, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2700005, "child_moves_before_max": 131, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 131, "child_moves_after_total": 537437, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 537437, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.48664520360103, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.020896679186787, "tt_hits": 13055, "tt_cutoffs": 1878, "beta_cutoffs": 24706, "depth_sum": 115, "avg_depth": 4.791666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 115, "avg_effective_depth": 4.791666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5964.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6298.208333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 864, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 21637, "avg_search_time_ms": 901.5416666666666, "search_nodes": 147307, "safety_nodes": 1404, "corridor_nodes": 1721, "corridor_branch_probes": 1958, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 534, "corridor_neutral_exits": 60, "corridor_terminal_exits": 21, "corridor_plies_followed": 1689, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1689, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 22, "corridor_proof_completed": 22, "corridor_proof_checks": 135, "corridor_proof_active": 32, "corridor_proof_quiet": 103, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 60, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 534, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 21, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 135, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 130, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 986, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 475920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 150432, "avg_nodes": 6268.0, "eval_calls": 94434, "avg_eval_calls": 3934.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 94434, "pattern_eval_ns": 2104827, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.288868416036596, "pattern_frame_queries": 94434, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2104827, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.288868416036596, "pattern_frame_updates": 294390, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2660686134, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9037.963701212677, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49716, "avg_candidate_generations": 2071.5, "candidate_moves_total": 5035115, "avg_candidate_moves": 101.2775565210395, "candidate_moves_max": 134, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2084, "root_candidate_moves_max": 119, "search_candidate_generations": 49692, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5033031, "search_candidate_moves_max": 134, "legality_checks": 3869822, "avg_legality_checks": 161242.58333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 813, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3869822, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 813, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7332204, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 305508.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14553523136, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1984.877007786472, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25920, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1080.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 63680704, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2456.8172839506174, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 839, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8920122, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3705, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 36249174, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21342, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18116287, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 395121, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 269709, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11237.875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2435835591, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9031.347085191817, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 384813, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16033.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1161378121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3018.0324495274326, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8576246091, "stage_ordering_ns": 1782416059, "stage_eval_ns": 2662790961, "stage_threat_ns": 8240340818, "stage_proof_ns": 212153333, "tactical_annotations": 1289932, "root_tactical_annotations": 4928, "search_tactical_annotations": 1285004, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 298062, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1775531053, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1226791, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6126160699, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 101052, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2948890751, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 149019, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 234882070, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3648, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26839427, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 298038, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37913018, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 594076, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1447528463, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 421844, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1654664386, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 274012, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 39014551, "child_limit_applications": 49692, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49692, "child_cap_hits": 49692, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49692, "child_moves_before_total": 5032218, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5032218, "child_moves_before_max": 134, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 134, "child_moves_after_total": 795197, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 795197, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 101.26817193914513, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002515495451984, "tt_hits": 24013, "tt_cutoffs": 3069, "beta_cutoffs": 43617, "depth_sum": 112, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 112, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6551.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6885.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1856, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1334, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 41892, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 96, 95, 99, 125, 140, 141, 97, 100, 109, 124, 127, 123, 122, 156, 65, 81, 83, 171, 126, 139, 155, 153, 167, 138, 168, 201, 186, 169, 185, 152, 166, 154, 184, 187, 68, 53, 67, 151, 150, 108, 93, 51, 66, 69, 64 ], "move_count": 52, "black_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 24825, "avg_search_time_ms": 1034.375, "search_nodes": 259052, "safety_nodes": 1143, "corridor_nodes": 4368, "corridor_branch_probes": 4895, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1792, "corridor_neutral_exits": 144, "corridor_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_plies_followed": 4302, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4252, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 50, "corridor_proof_passes": 22, "corridor_proof_completed": 22, "corridor_proof_checks": 285, "corridor_proof_active": 66, "corridor_proof_quiet": 219, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 144, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1792, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 285, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 10, "corridor_proof_unknown": 275, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 2287, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 44616000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1990800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 264563, "avg_nodes": 11023.458333333334, "eval_calls": 184313, "avg_eval_calls": 7679.708333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 184313, "pattern_eval_ns": 4020456, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.813198200886536, "pattern_frame_queries": 184313, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4020456, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.813198200886536, "pattern_frame_updates": 517874, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5894654084, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11382.409783074647, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 71069, "avg_candidate_generations": 2961.2083333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 6205493, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.31645302452546, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1867, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 71045, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6203626, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 1802894, "avg_legality_checks": 75120.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2292, "root_legality_checks": 1867, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1801027, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2289, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6553827, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 273076.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14335062090, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2187.281124448357, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39549, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1647.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 169008888, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4273.4048395661075, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2623, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25093958, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14042, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 91199833, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21932, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45981939, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 952, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6733158, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 137883, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5745.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1157588335, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8395.439140430655, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 175659, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7319.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 468598348, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2667.6592033428406, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4361354540, "stage_ordering_ns": 2453928805, "stage_eval_ns": 5898674540, "stage_threat_ns": 11058701103, "stage_proof_ns": 952239418, "tactical_annotations": 1413401, "root_tactical_annotations": 5972, "search_tactical_annotations": 1407429, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 527072, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3171630469, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1527779, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7315874634, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 145388, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4845203434, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 263524, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 403360121, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9174, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 64102267, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 527048, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67441649, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 554057, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 261375657, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 577028, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1674349324, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 282316, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 36291963, "child_limit_applications": 71045, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 71045, "child_cap_hits": 71045, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 71045, "child_moves_before_total": 6201337, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6201337, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 1141982, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1141982, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.28745161517348, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.074065732986135, "tt_hits": 30132, "tt_cutoffs": 3579, "beta_cutoffs": 59071, "depth_sum": 115, "avg_depth": 4.791666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 115, "avg_effective_depth": 4.791666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5478.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5811.958333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 821, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 17042, "avg_search_time_ms": 710.0833333333334, "search_nodes": 137538, "safety_nodes": 1605, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 139143, "avg_nodes": 5797.625, "eval_calls": 91043, "avg_eval_calls": 3793.4583333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 91043, "pattern_eval_ns": 2016659, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.150621135068043, "pattern_frame_queries": 91043, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2016659, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.150621135068043, "pattern_frame_updates": 274848, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2648535476, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9636.364375945977, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43733, "avg_candidate_generations": 1822.2083333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 3746541, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.66851119292068, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1896, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 43709, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3744645, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 2558038, "avg_legality_checks": 106584.91666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4043, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2558038, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4043, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5187916, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 216163.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11063080547, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2132.471024395923, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39073, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1628.0416666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 131941890, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3376.8046988969363, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4061, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 41734018, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5818, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 50382598, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29179, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39650394, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 174880, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 155718, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6488.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1378228463, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8850.79735804467, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 210080, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8753.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 599143119, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2851.976004379284, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6044775186, "stage_ordering_ns": 1487342568, "stage_eval_ns": 2650552135, "stage_threat_ns": 6737794960, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 914740, "root_tactical_annotations": 3587, "search_tactical_annotations": 911153, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 274872, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1643552538, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 827932, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4820545928, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 87579, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2875356376, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 137424, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 213262434, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 274848, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35587099, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 363791, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 671679154, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 376546, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1273252507, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 174403, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24846961, "child_limit_applications": 43709, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43709, "child_cap_hits": 43709, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43709, "child_moves_before_total": 3740602, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3740602, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 701308, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 701308, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.57967466654465, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.044933537715345, "tt_hits": 18021, "tt_cutoffs": 2672, "beta_cutoffs": 37824, "depth_sum": 114, "avg_depth": 4.75, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 114, "avg_effective_depth": 4.75, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.041666666666666664, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6407.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6740.958333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1859, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1335, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24629, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 98, 97, 81, 84, 111, 96, 95, 143, 110, 109, 125, 80, 158, 142, 140, 155, 156, 145, 126, 154, 124, 123, 172, 108, 188 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 13715, "avg_search_time_ms": 1055.0, "search_nodes": 161204, "safety_nodes": 548, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 161752, "avg_nodes": 12442.461538461539, "eval_calls": 124329, "avg_eval_calls": 9563.76923076923, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 124329, "pattern_eval_ns": 2696782, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.69069163268425, "pattern_frame_queries": 124329, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2696782, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.69069163268425, "pattern_frame_updates": 322294, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3791070727, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11762.771652590493, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34834, "avg_candidate_generations": 2679.5384615384614, "candidate_moves_total": 2548140, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.15094447953149, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 809, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 34821, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2547331, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 1156049, "avg_legality_checks": 88926.84615384616, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1148, "root_legality_checks": 809, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1155240, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1148, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3543506, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 272577.3846153846, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8123209650, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2292.4215875463456, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22593, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1737.923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57357543, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2538.7307130527156, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1278, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4012095, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8447, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38171772, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12866, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15170666, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3010, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 84856, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6527.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 695548133, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8196.80556472141, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 107998, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8307.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 247287744, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2289.743735995111, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2905556465, "stage_ordering_ns": 1124324188, "stage_eval_ns": 3793767509, "stage_threat_ns": 5830373985, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 413785, "root_tactical_annotations": 2526, "search_tactical_annotations": 411259, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 322307, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1901233305, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 408036, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3638460290, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69724, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2565289442, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 161147, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 239790812, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 322294, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40905778, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 86678, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 106803000, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 251622, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 966123068, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 75485, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9983800, "child_limit_applications": 34821, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34821, "child_cap_hits": 34821, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34821, "child_moves_before_total": 2546183, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2546183, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 557137, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 557137, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.1220527842394, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000028718302175, "tt_hits": 12925, "tt_cutoffs": 1997, "beta_cutoffs": 26671, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3817.769230769231, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4433.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 613, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10902, "avg_search_time_ms": 908.5, "search_nodes": 108412, "safety_nodes": 536, "corridor_nodes": 88, "corridor_branch_probes": 97, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_plies_followed": 81, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 81, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 104, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 97, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 104, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 831, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 191840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 109036, "avg_nodes": 9086.333333333334, "eval_calls": 78918, "avg_eval_calls": 6576.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 78918, "pattern_eval_ns": 1725466, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.864036088091435, "pattern_frame_queries": 78918, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1725466, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.864036088091435, "pattern_frame_updates": 216714, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1996287411, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9211.621819540962, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27890, "avg_candidate_generations": 2324.1666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2049658, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.49078522768018, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 27878, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2048910, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1264629, "avg_legality_checks": 105385.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 582, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1264629, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 582, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3073221, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 256101.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6814719174, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2217.451714016011, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13693, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1141.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30421766, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2221.7020375374277, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 588, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5744101, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1885, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12129901, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11220, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12547764, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90580, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7548.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 792983343, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8754.508092294105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 121105, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10092.083333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 314082613, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2593.4735394905247, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3159772989, "stage_ordering_ns": 893852375, "stage_eval_ns": 1998012877, "stage_threat_ns": 4598112433, "stage_proof_ns": 187869771, "tactical_annotations": 380669, "root_tactical_annotations": 1671, "search_tactical_annotations": 378998, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 217096, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1284664509, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 365741, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3112995245, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56295, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2013281252, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108542, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 160588107, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 370, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2170235, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 217084, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27358059, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 104990, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 326745981, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 197882, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 768490733, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 77797, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10336278, "child_limit_applications": 27878, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27878, "child_cap_hits": 27878, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27878, "child_moves_before_total": 2048328, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2048328, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 446048, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 446048, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.47471124183944, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 9381, "tt_cutoffs": 1561, "beta_cutoffs": 22725, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4131.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4797.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 295, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1336, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17041, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 98, 97, 81, 84, 111, 96, 95, 143, 110, 109, 80, 158, 173, 125, 79, 63, 82, 78, 83 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10194, "avg_search_time_ms": 1019.4, "search_nodes": 114627, "safety_nodes": 145, "corridor_nodes": 884, "corridor_branch_probes": 947, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 279, "corridor_neutral_exits": 51, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 863, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 863, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 85, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 51, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 279, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 85, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 82, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 688, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 423280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 115656, "avg_nodes": 11565.6, "eval_calls": 89028, "avg_eval_calls": 8902.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89028, "pattern_eval_ns": 1924640, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.61836725524554, "pattern_frame_queries": 89028, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1924640, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.61836725524554, "pattern_frame_updates": 229170, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2797730962, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12208.102989047433, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24152, "avg_candidate_generations": 2415.2, "candidate_moves_total": 1704685, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.58152533951639, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 584, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 24142, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1704101, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 783005, "avg_legality_checks": 78300.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 382, "root_legality_checks": 584, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 782421, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 382, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2678509, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 267850.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6122463933, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2285.7731420726977, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20770, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2077.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 82247052, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3959.8965816080886, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 559, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4120874, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8926, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 58661158, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11200, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18995187, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 85, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 469833, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 56639, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5663.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 516373407, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9116.923091862498, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 80454, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8045.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 214847142, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2670.4345588783654, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1980084444, "stage_ordering_ns": 764514160, "stage_eval_ns": 2799655602, "stage_threat_ns": 4328021749, "stage_proof_ns": 275883259, "tactical_annotations": 230376, "root_tactical_annotations": 1881, "search_tactical_annotations": 228495, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 231076, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1379531726, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 302685, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2733491611, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49189, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1869530896, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115533, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 169510818, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1896, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10860072, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 231066, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29318896, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 41310, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 55622912, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 149864, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 673089248, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 39202, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5308626, "child_limit_applications": 24142, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24142, "child_cap_hits": 24142, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24142, "child_moves_before_total": 1703719, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1703719, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 386273, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 386273, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.57074807389611, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000041421588932, "tt_hits": 9294, "tt_cutoffs": 1415, "beta_cutoffs": 18300, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3162.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3962.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 589, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6837, "avg_search_time_ms": 759.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 78146, "safety_nodes": 517, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 78663, "avg_nodes": 8740.333333333334, "eval_calls": 59398, "avg_eval_calls": 6599.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 59398, "pattern_eval_ns": 1288836, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.69830634028082, "pattern_frame_queries": 59398, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1288836, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.69830634028082, "pattern_frame_updates": 156212, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1461104268, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9353.34204798607, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17685, "avg_candidate_generations": 1965.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1205284, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.15289793610404, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 526, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 17676, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1204758, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 666100, "avg_legality_checks": 74011.11111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 551, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 666100, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 551, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1863249, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 207027.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4145172357, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2224.701237998786, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7172, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 796.8888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 27430973, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3824.7313162297824, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 559, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5773674, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1465, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12357873, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5148, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9299426, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 56071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6230.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 519379052, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9262.881917568797, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 80686, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8965.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 219280629, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2717.703554519991, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1704823269, "stage_ordering_ns": 538495520, "stage_eval_ns": 1462393104, "stage_threat_ns": 3090642139, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 201562, "root_tactical_annotations": 991, "search_tactical_annotations": 200571, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 156221, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 923145698, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 193386, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2028876884, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35410, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1335748017, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78106, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112199896, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 156212, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19684584, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 43810, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 172341479, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 114159, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 520641658, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 43593, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6735077, "child_limit_applications": 17676, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17676, "child_cap_hits": 17676, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17676, "child_moves_before_total": 1204207, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1204207, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 282816, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 282816, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.12666892962208, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 5736, "tt_cutoffs": 1032, "beta_cutoffs": 13783, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3374.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4263.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 339, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1337, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6742, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 85, 141, 57, 109, 108, 93, 77, 157 ], "move_count": 15, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 3696, "avg_search_time_ms": 616.0, "search_nodes": 41356, "safety_nodes": 201, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 41557, "avg_nodes": 6926.166666666667, "eval_calls": 31589, "avg_eval_calls": 5264.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 31589, "pattern_eval_ns": 683465, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.636170818955964, "pattern_frame_queries": 31589, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 683465, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.636170818955964, "pattern_frame_updates": 82668, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1079347205, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13056.408828083418, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9159, "avg_candidate_generations": 1526.5, "candidate_moves_total": 621505, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.85729883175019, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 377, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 9153, "search_candidate_moves_total": 621128, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 242505, "avg_legality_checks": 40417.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 117, "root_legality_checks": 377, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 242128, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 117, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 937724, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 156287.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2187599182, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2332.8817242600167, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6637, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1106.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 36153256, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5447.2285671237005, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 119, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1176532, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3214, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26738813, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3304, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8237911, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 26154, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4359.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 268906430, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10281.655960847289, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 36979, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6163.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 125595943, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3396.412639606263, "stage_move_gen_ns": 628521354, "stage_ordering_ns": 280252691, "stage_eval_ns": 1080030670, "stage_threat_ns": 1689575196, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 83560, "root_tactical_annotations": 838, "search_tactical_annotations": 82722, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 82674, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 514438106, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 85028, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1099504628, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18339, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 757005370, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 41334, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 62983088, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 82668, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10803891, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 18197, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 67436266, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 48487, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 274926732, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 16876, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1845483, "child_limit_applications": 9153, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9153, "child_cap_hits": 9153, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9153, "child_moves_before_total": 621011, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 621011, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 146481, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 146481, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.84780946137879, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.003605375286792, "tt_hits": 3900, "tt_cutoffs": 592, "beta_cutoffs": 7081, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2793.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4126.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1167, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 7, "search_move_count": 5, "total_time_ms": 3042, "avg_search_time_ms": 608.4, "search_nodes": 23347, "safety_nodes": 234, "corridor_nodes": 12, "corridor_branch_probes": 11, "corridor_max_depth": 3, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 8, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 34, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 34, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 275, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 139840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 23593, "avg_nodes": 4718.6, "eval_calls": 15525, "avg_eval_calls": 3105.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 15525, "pattern_eval_ns": 339550, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.871175523349436, "pattern_frame_queries": 15525, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 339550, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.871175523349436, "pattern_frame_updates": 46654, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 439091688, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9411.662194024093, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7355, "avg_candidate_generations": 1471.0, "candidate_moves_total": 518475, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.49286199864038, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 5, "root_candidate_moves_total": 299, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 7350, "search_candidate_moves_total": 518176, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 355960, "avg_legality_checks": 71192.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 71, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 355960, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 71, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 917627, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 183525.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2007030613, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2187.196554809307, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3652, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 730.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8228956, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2253.273822562979, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 71, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 809456, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 499, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 4921923, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3082, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2497577, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38003, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7600.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 401764642, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10571.91911164908, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 55583, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11116.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 198228817, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3566.3569256787146, "stage_move_gen_ns": 902294895, "stage_ordering_ns": 232571874, "stage_eval_ns": 439431238, "stage_threat_ns": 1386977691, "stage_proof_ns": 62192564, "tactical_annotations": 91703, "root_tactical_annotations": 511, "search_tactical_annotations": 91192, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 46743, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 290862897, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 85982, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1050682042, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14870, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 577715417, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 23369, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 35884133, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 84, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 352793, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 46738, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6012264, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 25346, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 184009190, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 44411, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 288161671, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 21946, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3183562, "child_limit_applications": 7350, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 7350, "child_cap_hits": 7350, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 7350, "child_moves_before_total": 518105, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 518105, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 117602, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 117602, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.49047619047619, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000272108843536, "tt_hits": 2859, "tt_cutoffs": 452, "beta_cutoffs": 6338, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2528.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3921.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1832, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1338, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6898, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 85, 141, 57, 109, 108, 93, 77, 157 ], "move_count": 15, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 3920, "avg_search_time_ms": 653.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 41356, "safety_nodes": 201, "corridor_nodes": 383, "corridor_branch_probes": 467, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 148, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 376, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 376, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 148, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 288, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23981280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 41940, "avg_nodes": 6990.0, "eval_calls": 31589, "avg_eval_calls": 5264.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 31589, "pattern_eval_ns": 693782, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.962771850960777, "pattern_frame_queries": 31589, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 693782, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.962771850960777, "pattern_frame_updates": 82668, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1083746973, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13109.63096966178, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9159, "avg_candidate_generations": 1526.5, "candidate_moves_total": 621505, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.85729883175019, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 377, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 9153, "search_candidate_moves_total": 621128, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 242505, "avg_legality_checks": 40417.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 117, "root_legality_checks": 377, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 242128, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 117, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1012763, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 168793.83333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2353206158, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2323.550680662702, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6685, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1114.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 36392626, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5443.923111443531, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 119, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1155106, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3214, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26561264, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3327, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8418814, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 257442, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27153, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4525.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 280675947, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10336.830074024969, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 38338, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6389.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 131911356, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3440.74693515572, "stage_move_gen_ns": 631615201, "stage_ordering_ns": 280446641, "stage_eval_ns": 1084440755, "stage_threat_ns": 1789753610, "stage_proof_ns": 117966822, "tactical_annotations": 83560, "root_tactical_annotations": 838, "search_tactical_annotations": 82722, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 83502, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 523231037, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 110070, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1185103538, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18625, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 775666026, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 41748, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 64296124, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 828, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4243906, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 83496, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10925160, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 18197, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 67380862, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 48487, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 276687994, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 16876, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1953845, "child_limit_applications": 9153, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9153, "child_cap_hits": 9153, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9153, "child_moves_before_total": 621011, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 621011, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 146481, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 146481, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.84780946137879, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.003605375286792, "tt_hits": 3900, "tt_cutoffs": 592, "beta_cutoffs": 7081, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2658.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3991.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1124, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 7, "search_move_count": 5, "total_time_ms": 2973, "avg_search_time_ms": 594.6, "search_nodes": 23347, "safety_nodes": 234, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 23581, "avg_nodes": 4716.2, "eval_calls": 15525, "avg_eval_calls": 3105.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 15525, "pattern_eval_ns": 350752, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.592721417069242, "pattern_frame_queries": 15525, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 350752, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.592721417069242, "pattern_frame_updates": 46654, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 439592770, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9422.402580700476, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7355, "avg_candidate_generations": 1471.0, "candidate_moves_total": 518475, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.49286199864038, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 5, "root_candidate_moves_total": 299, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 7350, "search_candidate_moves_total": 518176, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 355960, "avg_legality_checks": 71192.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 71, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 355960, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 71, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 897141, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 179428.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1958630569, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2183.1914593135302, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3652, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 730.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8152376, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2232.3044906900327, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 71, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 794689, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 499, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 4889807, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3082, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2467880, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38003, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7600.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 401496546, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10564.864510696523, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 55583, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11116.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 198441971, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3570.191803249195, "stage_move_gen_ns": 900266813, "stage_ordering_ns": 233226962, "stage_eval_ns": 439943522, "stage_threat_ns": 1380507722, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 91703, "root_tactical_annotations": 511, "search_tactical_annotations": 91192, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 46659, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 290119002, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 84490, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1045005023, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14730, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 572827336, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 23327, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 36044153, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 46654, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6067744, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 25346, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 183347570, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 44411, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 288778437, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 21946, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3271800, "child_limit_applications": 7350, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 7350, "child_cap_hits": 7350, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 7350, "child_moves_before_total": 518105, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 518105, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 117602, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 117602, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.49047619047619, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000272108843536, "tt_hits": 2859, "tt_cutoffs": 452, "beta_cutoffs": 6338, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2561.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3968.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1835, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1339, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19631, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 81, 82, 49, 65, 68, 110, 50, 51, 79, 94, 78, 80, 64, 92, 95, 124, 138, 108, 36, 22, 34, 19, 66, 140, 76, 156 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 9516, "avg_search_time_ms": 732.0, "search_nodes": 118973, "safety_nodes": 625, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 119598, "avg_nodes": 9199.846153846154, "eval_calls": 84944, "avg_eval_calls": 6534.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84944, "pattern_eval_ns": 1831375, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.55979233377284, "pattern_frame_queries": 84944, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1831375, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.55979233377284, "pattern_frame_updates": 237826, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2269877096, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9544.276471033445, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31392, "avg_candidate_generations": 2414.769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 2206618, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.29236748216105, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 829, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 31379, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2205789, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 824791, "avg_legality_checks": 63445.46153846154, "illegal_moves_skipped": 37, "root_legality_checks": 829, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 823962, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 37, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2463615, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 189508.84615384616, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5483645151, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2225.853126807557, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10014, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 770.3076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30814630, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3077.154983023767, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 63, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 408693, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3252, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22586953, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6699, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7818984, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45609, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3508.3846153846152, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 379599312, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8322.903637439978, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 59808, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4600.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 153948733, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2574.049174023542, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2017580711, "stage_ordering_ns": 855727346, "stage_eval_ns": 2271708471, "stage_threat_ns": 4310913953, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 446322, "root_tactical_annotations": 2258, "search_tactical_annotations": 444064, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 237839, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1374947483, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 413878, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2725800994, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62844, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2029810614, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 118913, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 168423531, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 237826, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28723317, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 123561, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 41432156, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 227462, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 654112582, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 95299, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13018628, "child_limit_applications": 31379, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31379, "child_cap_hits": 31379, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31379, "child_moves_before_total": 2205752, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2205752, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 502091, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 502091, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.2938908187004, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000860448070366, "tt_hits": 12589, "tt_cutoffs": 2590, "beta_cutoffs": 25774, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4668.846153846154, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5284.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 709, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 10105, "avg_search_time_ms": 777.3076923076923, "search_nodes": 124155, "safety_nodes": 470, "corridor_nodes": 506, "corridor_branch_probes": 558, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 178, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 34, "corridor_plies_followed": 494, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 494, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 93, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 81, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 178, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 93, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 89, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 711, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 358560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 125131, "avg_nodes": 9625.461538461539, "eval_calls": 94802, "avg_eval_calls": 7292.461538461538, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 94802, "pattern_eval_ns": 2055913, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.68638847281703, "pattern_frame_queries": 94802, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2055913, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.68638847281703, "pattern_frame_updates": 248192, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1853862718, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7469.470079615781, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27620, "avg_candidate_generations": 2124.6153846153848, "candidate_moves_total": 2004671, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.58041274438813, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 867, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 27607, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2003804, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 1274573, "avg_legality_checks": 98044.07692307692, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1274573, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2887078, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 222082.92307692306, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6104133320, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2114.294563569117, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6967, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 535.9230769230769, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14919564, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2141.461748241711, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 203952, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1508, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8587124, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5414, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6128488, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67205, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5169.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 559217145, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8321.064578528383, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 90413, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6954.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 237898619, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2631.243504805725, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3030111184, "stage_ordering_ns": 772351880, "stage_eval_ns": 1855918631, "stage_threat_ns": 4203683836, "stage_proof_ns": 161854860, "tactical_annotations": 435432, "root_tactical_annotations": 2424, "search_tactical_annotations": 433008, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 249379, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1409094734, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 426465, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2572103573, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 55872, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1700807402, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124683, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 172691024, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1174, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7179040, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 249366, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29459808, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 133250, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 192374752, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 204607, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 657531278, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 97575, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13155657, "child_limit_applications": 27607, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27607, "child_cap_hits": 27607, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27607, "child_moves_before_total": 2003789, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2003789, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 441803, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 441803, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.58264208352954, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.003296265439925, "tt_hits": 11329, "tt_cutoffs": 1687, "beta_cutoffs": 21404, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4926.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5541.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 397, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1340, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20092, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 81, 82, 49, 65, 68, 110, 50, 51, 79, 94, 78, 80, 64, 92, 95, 124, 138, 108, 36, 22, 34, 19, 66, 140, 76, 156 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 10092, "avg_search_time_ms": 776.3076923076923, "search_nodes": 118973, "safety_nodes": 625, "corridor_nodes": 694, "corridor_branch_probes": 788, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 220, "corridor_neutral_exits": 29, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 666, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 626, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 40, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 143, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 115, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 29, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 220, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 143, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 8, "corridor_proof_unknown": 135, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1146, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 34484160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2002960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 120292, "avg_nodes": 9253.23076923077, "eval_calls": 84944, "avg_eval_calls": 6534.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84944, "pattern_eval_ns": 1848684, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.763561876059523, "pattern_frame_queries": 84944, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1848684, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.763561876059523, "pattern_frame_updates": 237826, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2296648693, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9656.844470327045, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31392, "avg_candidate_generations": 2414.769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 2206618, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.29236748216105, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 829, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 31379, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2205789, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 824791, "avg_legality_checks": 63445.46153846154, "illegal_moves_skipped": 37, "root_legality_checks": 829, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 823962, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 37, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2625732, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 201979.38461538462, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5888343972, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2242.5533039929437, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10036, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 772.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31427319, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3131.4586488640894, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 63, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 418331, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3252, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22815050, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6710, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8082177, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 111761, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46724, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3594.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 396255701, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8480.774355791456, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 61390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4722.307692307692, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 162672983, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2649.828685453657, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2035694528, "stage_ordering_ns": 860573319, "stage_eval_ns": 2298497377, "stage_threat_ns": 4499517513, "stage_proof_ns": 337642337, "tactical_annotations": 446322, "root_tactical_annotations": 2258, "search_tactical_annotations": 444064, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 239457, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1401262104, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 462204, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2874944134, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 63733, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2087074108, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 119722, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 170744952, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1618, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10891640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 239444, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28961017, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 123561, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 42058455, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 227462, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 663161617, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 95299, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12713666, "child_limit_applications": 31379, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31379, "child_cap_hits": 31379, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31379, "child_moves_before_total": 2205752, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2205752, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 502091, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 502091, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.2938908187004, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000860448070366, "tt_hits": 12589, "tt_cutoffs": 2590, "beta_cutoffs": 25774, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4544.846153846154, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5160.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 654, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 9987, "avg_search_time_ms": 768.2307692307693, "search_nodes": 124155, "safety_nodes": 470, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 124625, "avg_nodes": 9586.538461538461, "eval_calls": 94802, "avg_eval_calls": 7292.461538461538, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 94802, "pattern_eval_ns": 2068151, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.815478576401343, "pattern_frame_queries": 94802, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2068151, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.815478576401343, "pattern_frame_updates": 248192, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1883307526, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7588.107295964414, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27620, "avg_candidate_generations": 2124.6153846153848, "candidate_moves_total": 2004671, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.58041274438813, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 867, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 27607, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2003804, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 1274573, "avg_legality_checks": 98044.07692307692, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1274573, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2826682, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 217437.07692307694, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6055204764, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2142.159876491236, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6967, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 535.9230769230769, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15225252, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2185.33830917181, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 207810, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1508, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8726082, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5414, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6291360, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67205, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5169.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 569330200, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8471.545271929172, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 90413, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6954.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 243897342, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2697.5915189187394, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3066256236, "stage_ordering_ns": 775216834, "stage_eval_ns": 1885375677, "stage_threat_ns": 4183670263, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 435432, "root_tactical_annotations": 2424, "search_tactical_annotations": 433008, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 248205, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1398956079, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 393165, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2569035110, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 55298, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1704960774, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124096, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 173552247, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 248192, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29281763, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 133250, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 194409996, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 204607, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 669583879, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 97575, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12845064, "child_limit_applications": 27607, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27607, "child_cap_hits": 27607, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27607, "child_moves_before_total": 2003789, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2003789, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 441803, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 441803, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.58264208352954, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.003296265439925, "tt_hits": 11329, "tt_cutoffs": 1687, "beta_cutoffs": 21404, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4974.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5590.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 414, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1341, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9872, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 82, 110, 126, 141, 80, 146, 162, 128, 81, 66, 79, 83, 78 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6542, "avg_search_time_ms": 726.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 76777, "safety_nodes": 254, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 77031, "avg_nodes": 8559.0, "eval_calls": 59381, "avg_eval_calls": 6597.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 59381, "pattern_eval_ns": 1285386, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.64641888819656, "pattern_frame_queries": 59381, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1285386, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.64641888819656, "pattern_frame_updates": 153480, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1854847272, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12085.270211102425, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16455, "avg_candidate_generations": 1828.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1227622, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.60480097234883, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 562, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 16446, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1227060, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 486966, "avg_legality_checks": 54107.333333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 449, "root_legality_checks": 562, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 486404, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 449, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1659587, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 184398.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3835338725, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2311.0199856952363, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17657, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1961.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 78723707, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4458.498442544033, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 753, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6100272, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7186, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 50826569, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9718, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21796866, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39060, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4340.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 376027290, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9626.914746543778, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 53902, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5989.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 161504726, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2996.2659270527997, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1238308553, "stage_ordering_ns": 537542338, "stage_eval_ns": 1856132658, "stage_threat_ns": 2876191627, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 175339, "root_tactical_annotations": 1464, "search_tactical_annotations": 173875, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 153489, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 914926769, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 165727, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1822387501, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32946, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1295918212, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76740, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113462459, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 153480, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19448976, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 33419, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 76242430, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 99355, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 450073948, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 42565, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5965922, "child_limit_applications": 16446, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16446, "child_cap_hits": 16446, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16446, "child_moves_before_total": 1226611, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1226611, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 263136, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 263136, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.58415420162957, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 6909, "tt_cutoffs": 913, "beta_cutoffs": 12542, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4405.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5294.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1240, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 3321, "avg_search_time_ms": 415.125, "search_nodes": 27159, "safety_nodes": 640, "corridor_nodes": 20, "corridor_branch_probes": 15, "corridor_max_depth": 3, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 12, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 12, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 44, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 36, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 44, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 44, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 298, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 124400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 27819, "avg_nodes": 3477.375, "eval_calls": 18426, "avg_eval_calls": 2303.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 18426, "pattern_eval_ns": 404643, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.960436339954413, "pattern_frame_queries": 18426, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 404643, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.960436339954413, "pattern_frame_updates": 54248, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 546070388, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10066.184707270315, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8225, "avg_candidate_generations": 1028.125, "candidate_moves_total": 567429, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.9883282674772, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 499, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 8217, "search_candidate_moves_total": 566930, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 354674, "avg_legality_checks": 44334.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 179, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 354674, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 179, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 966819, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 120852.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2147261228, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2220.954726789606, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4847, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 605.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20699215, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4270.520940788117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 187, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1886699, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1371, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14087902, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3289, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4724614, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36142, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4517.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 379835737, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10509.538404072824, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 53042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6630.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 182900039, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3448.211587044229, "stage_move_gen_ns": 911990423, "stage_ordering_ns": 252692039, "stage_eval_ns": 546475031, "stage_threat_ns": 1506366728, "stage_proof_ns": 79976545, "tactical_annotations": 100981, "root_tactical_annotations": 526, "search_tactical_annotations": 100455, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 54368, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 343603802, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 95540, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1110892142, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16665, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 647846383, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 27180, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 41183380, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 112, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 470242, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 54360, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7022341, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 23843, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 151012906, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 52818, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 310848020, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 24320, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3194821, "child_limit_applications": 8217, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 8217, "child_cap_hits": 8217, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 8217, "child_moves_before_total": 566751, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 566751, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 131472, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 131472, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.97298284045272, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 3139, "tt_cutoffs": 481, "beta_cutoffs": 7011, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 4.375, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 4.375, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4468.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5468.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1859, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1342, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10299, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 82, 110, 126, 141, 80, 146, 162, 128, 81, 66, 79, 83, 78 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7057, "avg_search_time_ms": 784.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 76777, "safety_nodes": 254, "corridor_nodes": 861, "corridor_branch_probes": 1042, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 298, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 844, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 844, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 298, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 421, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24082960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 77892, "avg_nodes": 8654.666666666666, "eval_calls": 59381, "avg_eval_calls": 6597.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 59381, "pattern_eval_ns": 1300135, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.894797999360065, "pattern_frame_queries": 59381, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1300135, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.894797999360065, "pattern_frame_updates": 153480, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1873647189, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12207.761200156372, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16455, "avg_candidate_generations": 1828.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1227622, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.60480097234883, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 562, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 16446, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1227060, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 486966, "avg_legality_checks": 54107.333333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 449, "root_legality_checks": 562, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 486404, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 449, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1814297, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 201588.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4199477172, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2314.6580587412095, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17795, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1977.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 81043496, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4554.28468670975, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 753, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6226613, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7186, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 51282088, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9770, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22784271, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 86, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 750524, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 40842, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4538.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 397796715, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9739.89312472455, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56324, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6258.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 173039868, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3072.2226404374687, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1249974566, "stage_ordering_ns": 544254764, "stage_eval_ns": 1874947324, "stage_threat_ns": 3137998478, "stage_proof_ns": 215745324, "tactical_annotations": 175339, "root_tactical_annotations": 1464, "search_tactical_annotations": 173875, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 155287, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 948747001, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 224163, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2037250830, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33523, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1354344645, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77639, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 116699996, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1798, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9807791, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 155278, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19852596, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 33419, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 76689015, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 99355, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 454064757, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 42565, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5640264, "child_limit_applications": 16446, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16446, "child_cap_hits": 16446, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16446, "child_moves_before_total": 1226611, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1226611, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 263136, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 263136, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.58415420162957, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 6909, "tt_cutoffs": 913, "beta_cutoffs": 12542, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4153.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5042.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1191, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 3235, "avg_search_time_ms": 404.375, "search_nodes": 27159, "safety_nodes": 640, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 27799, "avg_nodes": 3474.875, "eval_calls": 18426, "avg_eval_calls": 2303.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 18426, "pattern_eval_ns": 409031, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.198578096168458, "pattern_frame_queries": 18426, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 409031, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.198578096168458, "pattern_frame_updates": 54248, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 545535590, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10056.326316177556, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8225, "avg_candidate_generations": 1028.125, "candidate_moves_total": 567429, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.9883282674772, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 499, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 8217, "search_candidate_moves_total": 566930, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 354674, "avg_legality_checks": 44334.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 179, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 354674, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 179, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 940464, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 117558.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2083335035, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2215.2203965276713, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4847, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 605.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21035312, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4339.86218279348, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 187, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1900505, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1371, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14345703, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3289, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4789104, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36142, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4517.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 380134410, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10517.802279895966, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 53042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6630.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 183891834, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3466.909882734437, "stage_move_gen_ns": 907357222, "stage_ordering_ns": 255711050, "stage_eval_ns": 545944621, "stage_threat_ns": 1502996201, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 100981, "root_tactical_annotations": 526, "search_tactical_annotations": 100455, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 54256, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 345640622, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 93152, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1105697754, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 16485, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 643314181, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 27124, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 41731401, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 54248, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7058664, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 23843, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 151339496, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 52818, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 310851447, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 24320, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2867760, "child_limit_applications": 8217, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 8217, "child_cap_hits": 8217, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 8217, "child_moves_before_total": 566751, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 566751, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 131472, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 131472, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.97298284045272, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 3139, "tt_cutoffs": 481, "beta_cutoffs": 7011, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 4.375, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 4.375, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4499.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5499.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1862, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1343, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21165, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 96, 97, 64, 80, 83, 125, 65, 66, 94, 109, 93, 95, 79, 107, 110, 139, 153, 123, 51, 37, 49, 34, 81, 155, 91, 171 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 10260, "avg_search_time_ms": 789.2307692307693, "search_nodes": 119211, "safety_nodes": 659, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 119870, "avg_nodes": 9220.76923076923, "eval_calls": 85258, "avg_eval_calls": 6558.307692307692, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 85258, "pattern_eval_ns": 1863220, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.85390227310047, "pattern_frame_queries": 85258, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1863220, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.85390227310047, "pattern_frame_updates": 238302, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2497939873, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10482.244685315272, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31548, "avg_candidate_generations": 2426.769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 2283443, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.37996069481426, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 850, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 31535, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2282593, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 853879, "avg_legality_checks": 65683.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 37, "root_legality_checks": 850, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 853029, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 37, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2587541, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 199041.61538461538, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5973532700, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2308.5750911772993, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9984, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 768.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32507965, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3256.006109775641, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 431500, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3116, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 23736090, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6811, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8340375, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46652, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3588.6153846153848, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 405308968, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8687.92266140787, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 60929, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4686.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 164347165, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2697.3553644405783, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2157304785, "stage_ordering_ns": 933737764, "stage_eval_ns": 2499803093, "stage_threat_ns": 4618285069, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 449646, "root_tactical_annotations": 2258, "search_tactical_annotations": 447388, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 238315, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1429888065, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 417225, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2968236578, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 63156, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2233966029, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 119151, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 178179223, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 238302, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29769401, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 124161, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 42852990, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 229897, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 690948118, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 95588, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12211802, "child_limit_applications": 31535, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31535, "child_cap_hits": 31535, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31535, "child_moves_before_total": 2282556, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2282556, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 504633, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 504633, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.38167115902965, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002314888219438, "tt_hits": 12385, "tt_cutoffs": 2358, "beta_cutoffs": 25924, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4392.846153846154, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5008.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 621, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 10893, "avg_search_time_ms": 837.9230769230769, "search_nodes": 125397, "safety_nodes": 483, "corridor_nodes": 506, "corridor_branch_probes": 558, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 178, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 34, "corridor_plies_followed": 494, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 494, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 93, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 81, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 178, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 93, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 89, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 711, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 332560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 126386, "avg_nodes": 9722.0, "eval_calls": 95999, "avg_eval_calls": 7384.538461538462, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 95999, "pattern_eval_ns": 2109070, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.969708017791852, "pattern_frame_queries": 95999, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2109070, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.969708017791852, "pattern_frame_updates": 250676, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2015927481, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8041.964452121463, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27855, "avg_candidate_generations": 2142.6923076923076, "candidate_moves_total": 2100029, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.39145575300664, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 888, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 27842, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2099141, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1333130, "avg_legality_checks": 102548.46153846153, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1333130, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3007367, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 231335.92307692306, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6622011444, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2201.9299420389993, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7056, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 542.7692307692307, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15026362, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2129.5864512471653, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 205371, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1405, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8399611, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5612, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6421380, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67995, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5230.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 593766497, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8732.502345760719, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91467, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7035.923076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 250818606, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2742.175932303454, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3285360120, "stage_ordering_ns": 844904621, "stage_eval_ns": 2018036551, "stage_threat_ns": 4508152360, "stage_proof_ns": 164446960, "tactical_annotations": 443921, "root_tactical_annotations": 2448, "search_tactical_annotations": 441473, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 251863, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1481422251, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 432953, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2793786581, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56342, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1872750627, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 125925, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 181642239, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1174, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7106050, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 251850, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30678111, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 134810, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 202453526, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 209065, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 697640696, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 100046, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13517128, "child_limit_applications": 27842, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27842, "child_cap_hits": 27842, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27842, "child_moves_before_total": 2099126, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2099126, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 445664, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 445664, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.39422455283385, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.006896056317792, "tt_hits": 11202, "tt_cutoffs": 1497, "beta_cutoffs": 21574, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4661.076923076923, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5276.461538461538, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 292, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1344, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19945, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 96, 97, 64, 80, 83, 125, 65, 66, 94, 109, 93, 95, 79, 107, 110, 139, 153, 123, 51, 37, 49, 34, 81, 155, 91, 171 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 10174, "avg_search_time_ms": 782.6153846153846, "search_nodes": 119211, "safety_nodes": 659, "corridor_nodes": 894, "corridor_branch_probes": 1034, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 326, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 866, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 826, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 40, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 143, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 115, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 326, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 143, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 8, "corridor_proof_unknown": 135, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1146, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 34482320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2003200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 120764, "avg_nodes": 9289.538461538461, "eval_calls": 85258, "avg_eval_calls": 6558.307692307692, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 85258, "pattern_eval_ns": 1846413, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.65677121208567, "pattern_frame_queries": 85258, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1846413, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.65677121208567, "pattern_frame_updates": 238302, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2358805809, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9898.388637107535, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31548, "avg_candidate_generations": 2426.769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 2283443, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.37996069481426, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 850, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 31535, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2282593, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 853879, "avg_legality_checks": 65683.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 37, "root_legality_checks": 850, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 853029, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 37, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2772271, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 213251.61538461538, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5952226805, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2147.0580635875785, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10010, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 770.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31482987, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3145.1535464535464, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 431283, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3116, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 23084951, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6823, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7836061, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 130692, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48346, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3718.923076923077, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 393661761, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8142.592168948827, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63387, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4875.923076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 162901326, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2569.9485067916135, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1995600140, "stage_ordering_ns": 878222907, "stage_eval_ns": 2360652222, "stage_threat_ns": 4542876942, "stage_proof_ns": 343037211, "tactical_annotations": 449646, "root_tactical_annotations": 2258, "search_tactical_annotations": 447388, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 240333, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1381009395, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 474867, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2937957967, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64110, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2145159543, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 120160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 169744141, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2018, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13744799, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 240320, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28886834, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 124161, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 42774563, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 229897, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 639142576, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 95588, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11533806, "child_limit_applications": 31535, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31535, "child_cap_hits": 31535, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31535, "child_moves_before_total": 2282556, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2282556, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 504633, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 504633, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.38167115902965, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002314888219438, "tt_hits": 12385, "tt_cutoffs": 2358, "beta_cutoffs": 25924, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4468.076923076923, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5083.461538461538, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 603, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 9760, "avg_search_time_ms": 750.7692307692307, "search_nodes": 125397, "safety_nodes": 483, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 125880, "avg_nodes": 9683.076923076924, "eval_calls": 95999, "avg_eval_calls": 7384.538461538462, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 95999, "pattern_eval_ns": 2066707, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.528422171064282, "pattern_frame_queries": 95999, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2066707, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.528422171064282, "pattern_frame_updates": 250676, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1844180953, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7356.83094113517, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27855, "avg_candidate_generations": 2142.6923076923076, "candidate_moves_total": 2100029, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.39145575300664, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 888, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 27842, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2099141, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1333130, "avg_legality_checks": 102548.46153846153, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1333130, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2946127, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 226625.15384615384, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5900434971, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2002.7768561911962, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7056, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 542.7692307692307, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12788993, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1812.499007936508, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 178020, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1405, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7516297, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5612, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5094676, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67995, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5230.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 548646650, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8068.926391646444, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91467, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7035.923076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 229994055, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2514.5030994785006, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2982882222, "stage_ordering_ns": 775657315, "stage_eval_ns": 1846247660, "stage_threat_ns": 4083276886, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 443921, "root_tactical_annotations": 2448, "search_tactical_annotations": 441473, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 250689, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1348067043, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 399653, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2524915391, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 55768, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1697334388, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 125338, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 167453309, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 250676, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28542057, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 134810, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 193340767, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 209065, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 634160116, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 100046, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14299086, "child_limit_applications": 27842, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27842, "child_cap_hits": 27842, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27842, "child_moves_before_total": 2099126, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2099126, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 445664, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 445664, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.39422455283385, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.006896056317792, "tt_hits": 11202, "tt_cutoffs": 1497, "beta_cutoffs": 21574, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5013.846153846154, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5629.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 344, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1345, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13315, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 83, 128, 67, 127, 99, 115, 82, 52, 81, 143, 158, 84, 95, 53, 125, 111, 80, 79, 110, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7996, "avg_search_time_ms": 726.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 116727, "safety_nodes": 146, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 116873, "avg_nodes": 10624.818181818182, "eval_calls": 87525, "avg_eval_calls": 7956.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87525, "pattern_eval_ns": 1750545, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.00051413881748, "pattern_frame_queries": 87525, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1750545, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.00051413881748, "pattern_frame_updates": 233360, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2390455356, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10243.637967089475, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27184, "avg_candidate_generations": 2471.2727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 1968114, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.39972042377869, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 676, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 27173, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1967438, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 747965, "avg_legality_checks": 67996.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 834, "root_legality_checks": 676, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 747289, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 834, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2898875, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 263534.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4684752007, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1616.0586458539951, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29592, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2690.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 113885413, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3848.5203095431198, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 946, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4786938, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16168, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 89067007, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12478, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20031468, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90371, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8215.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 599011803, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6628.363114273384, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 119917, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10901.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 263016184, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2193.3185786835893, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1361638296, "stage_ordering_ns": 600112040, "stage_eval_ns": 2392205901, "stage_threat_ns": 3591615900, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 477572, "root_tactical_annotations": 2332, "search_tactical_annotations": 475240, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 233371, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1044297952, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 420671, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2376623941, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54414, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1533061216, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 116680, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 137116065, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 233360, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23148648, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 142239, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 146643413, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 224009, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 696908102, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 111324, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10429294, "child_limit_applications": 27173, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27173, "child_cap_hits": 27173, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27173, "child_moves_before_total": 1966604, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1966604, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 435446, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 435446, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.37345894822066, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02495123836161, "tt_hits": 11812, "tt_cutoffs": 1982, "beta_cutoffs": 21499, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5072.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5799.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 697, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5307, "avg_search_time_ms": 530.7, "search_nodes": 49246, "safety_nodes": 948, "corridor_nodes": 241, "corridor_branch_probes": 292, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 74, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_plies_followed": 236, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 236, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 8, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 74, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 12, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 32, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6045280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2003760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 50435, "avg_nodes": 5043.5, "eval_calls": 29368, "avg_eval_calls": 2936.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 29368, "pattern_eval_ns": 602442, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.513552165622446, "pattern_frame_queries": 29368, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 602442, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.513552165622446, "pattern_frame_updates": 98382, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 863810883, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8780.172013173142, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17639, "avg_candidate_generations": 1763.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1232388, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.86722603322184, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 622, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 17629, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1231766, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 768927, "avg_legality_checks": 76892.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 591, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 768927, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 591, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1944102, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 194410.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3434657494, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1766.706424868654, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14907, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1490.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29695027, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1992.0189843697592, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 602, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3497947, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3711, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18164820, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10594, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8032260, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 69033, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6903.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 516487961, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7481.754537684876, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 93061, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9306.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 235210813, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2527.4907103942573, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1572703922, "stage_ordering_ns": 428050121, "stage_eval_ns": 864413325, "stage_threat_ns": 2386351833, "stage_proof_ns": 18288238, "tactical_annotations": 271224, "root_tactical_annotations": 395, "search_tactical_annotations": 270829, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 98890, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 499716984, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 255917, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1803082642, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35476, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1086022581, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 49440, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 63956148, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 498, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2317292, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 98880, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10673497, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32916, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 124682715, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 170387, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 580261986, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 67921, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6605270, "child_limit_applications": 17629, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17629, "child_cap_hits": 17629, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17629, "child_moves_before_total": 1231175, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1231175, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 183033, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 183033, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.83805093879403, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.382494752963867, "tt_hits": 8991, "tt_cutoffs": 2194, "beta_cutoffs": 14327, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4546.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5346.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1346, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21489, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 83, 155, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 53, 141, 169, 39, 69, 55, 37, 85, 80, 79, 96, 64, 125, 111, 95, 109, 110, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 19290, "avg_search_time_ms": 1286.0, "search_nodes": 249170, "safety_nodes": 778, "corridor_nodes": 2932, "corridor_branch_probes": 3246, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1284, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2910, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2910, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1284, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 429, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 41679920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2026960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 252880, "avg_nodes": 16858.666666666668, "eval_calls": 175830, "avg_eval_calls": 11722.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 175830, "pattern_eval_ns": 3505051, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.934317238241483, "pattern_frame_queries": 175830, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3505051, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.934317238241483, "pattern_frame_updates": 498190, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5485095700, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11010.047772938036, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 69503, "avg_candidate_generations": 4633.533333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 6224640, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.55929959857848, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1165, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 69488, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6223475, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1644623, "avg_legality_checks": 109641.53333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3161, "root_legality_checks": 1165, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1643458, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3158, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6809390, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 453959.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10984372259, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1613.121330838739, "renju_forbidden_checks": 61693, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4112.866666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 273452094, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4432.46549851685, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3804, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 28002230, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34768, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 183543347, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22774, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 59943458, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 347, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1963059, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 178500, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11900.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1080998605, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6056.014593837535, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 222241, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14816.066666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 410781231, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1848.35935313466, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2973329967, "stage_ordering_ns": 1865486692, "stage_eval_ns": 5488600751, "stage_threat_ns": 8631468371, "stage_proof_ns": 243322320, "tactical_annotations": 1362148, "root_tactical_annotations": 4093, "search_tactical_annotations": 1358055, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 504137, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2350999691, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1392537, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5868173158, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 140592, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3727215739, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 252061, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 307475106, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5932, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21789315, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 504122, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51725835, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 377407, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 338218573, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 704959, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1548081661, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 279782, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 31305266, "child_limit_applications": 69488, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 69488, "child_cap_hits": 69488, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 69488, "child_moves_before_total": 6220317, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6220317, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 744646, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 744646, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.51642010131246, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.71618121114437, "tt_hits": 31214, "tt_cutoffs": 3778, "beta_cutoffs": 54105, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5160.533333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5693.866666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1798, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2184, "avg_search_time_ms": 156.0, "search_nodes": 32596, "safety_nodes": 1641, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34237, "avg_nodes": 2445.5, "eval_calls": 22196, "avg_eval_calls": 1585.4285714285713, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22196, "pattern_eval_ns": 429141, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.33415930798342, "pattern_frame_queries": 22196, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 429141, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.33415930798342, "pattern_frame_updates": 65062, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 471195568, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7242.254587931511, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9851, "avg_candidate_generations": 703.6428571428571, "candidate_moves_total": 795303, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.73322505329408, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1092, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 9837, "search_candidate_moves_total": 794211, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 314931, "avg_legality_checks": 22495.071428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 372, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 314931, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 372, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 956719, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 68337.07142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1269441727, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1326.8699869031554, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5125, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 366.07142857142856, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21445759, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4184.538341463414, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 422, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3474806, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1976, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12061486, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2705, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5668647, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 240820, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 31145, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2224.6428571428573, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 175204400, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5625.442286081233, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41038, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2931.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 75811551, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1847.3500414250207, "stage_move_gen_ns": 472588174, "stage_ordering_ns": 207418728, "stage_eval_ns": 471624709, "stage_threat_ns": 1004787435, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 176073, "root_tactical_annotations": 331, "search_tactical_annotations": 175742, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 65076, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 261562483, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 171024, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 702139817, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19767, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 423271073, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 32531, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 33916462, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 65062, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5649833, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44020, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 71310212, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 107228, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 207303860, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 24825, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1518840, "child_limit_applications": 9837, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9837, "child_cap_hits": 9837, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9837, "child_moves_before_total": 793839, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 793839, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 158867, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 158867, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.69929856663617, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.14994408864491, "tt_hits": 2930, "tt_cutoffs": 498, "beta_cutoffs": 8389, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6407.071428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6978.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1910, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1347, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16368, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 129, 96, 141, 110, 109, 142, 158, 82, 130, 131, 124, 84, 98, 81, 66, 83, 80, 85 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8229, "avg_search_time_ms": 748.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 100524, "safety_nodes": 151, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 100675, "avg_nodes": 9152.272727272728, "eval_calls": 75116, "avg_eval_calls": 6828.727272727273, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75116, "pattern_eval_ns": 1546168, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.583737153203046, "pattern_frame_queries": 75116, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1546168, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.583737153203046, "pattern_frame_updates": 200954, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2645332861, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13163.87263254277, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23775, "avg_candidate_generations": 2161.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 1710890, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.96172450052576, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 661, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 23764, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1710229, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 589755, "avg_legality_checks": 53614.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 679, "root_legality_checks": 661, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 589094, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 679, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2482555, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 225686.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4859978444, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1957.6518723653655, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25938, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2358.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 128458205, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4952.5100239031535, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 876, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5961609, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14973, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 99997784, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10089, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22498812, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68142, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6194.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 539360273, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7915.239837398374, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89755, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8159.545454545455, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 227779300, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2537.7895381872877, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1296293136, "stage_ordering_ns": 615547164, "stage_eval_ns": 2646879029, "stage_threat_ns": 3636940128, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 447141, "root_tactical_annotations": 2232, "search_tactical_annotations": 444909, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 200965, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1058194155, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 382654, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2406488174, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47596, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1602716410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 100477, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 135606964, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 200954, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23117854, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 134007, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 124274934, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 201042, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 679487260, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 112092, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13532981, "child_limit_applications": 23764, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23764, "child_cap_hits": 23764, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23764, "child_moves_before_total": 1709550, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1709550, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 381442, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 381442, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.93864669247601, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.051253997643496, "tt_hits": 10891, "tt_cutoffs": 1597, "beta_cutoffs": 18859, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4982.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5709.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1197, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8131, "avg_search_time_ms": 813.1, "search_nodes": 74235, "safety_nodes": 904, "corridor_nodes": 721, "corridor_branch_probes": 880, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 279, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 30, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 25, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 279, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 30, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 166, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 10019920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 75860, "avg_nodes": 7586.0, "eval_calls": 44758, "avg_eval_calls": 4475.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44758, "pattern_eval_ns": 949583, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.215939050002234, "pattern_frame_queries": 44758, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 949583, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.215939050002234, "pattern_frame_updates": 148358, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1661873312, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11201.777538117258, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25579, "avg_candidate_generations": 2557.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1777776, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.50138785722663, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 603, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 25569, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1777173, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 793010, "avg_legality_checks": 79301.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 469, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 793010, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 469, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2490688, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 249068.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4976700989, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1998.123004165917, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14332, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1433.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44887029, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3131.9445297236953, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 473, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4076536, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4377, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27051813, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9482, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13758680, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 79326, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7932.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 657089970, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8283.412374253083, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 106489, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10648.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 278334657, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2613.740921597536, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1798736795, "stage_ordering_ns": 705439801, "stage_eval_ns": 1662822895, "stage_threat_ns": 3882035638, "stage_proof_ns": 43997232, "tactical_annotations": 436994, "root_tactical_annotations": 418, "search_tactical_annotations": 436576, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 149860, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 852165223, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 443452, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2886625914, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51589, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1815996049, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74925, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107425257, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1492, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7244242, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 149850, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18273191, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52768, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 129366557, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 293407, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 908275014, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 90819, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10301811, "child_limit_applications": 25569, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25569, "child_cap_hits": 25569, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25569, "child_moves_before_total": 1776704, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1776704, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 278956, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 278956, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.4866439829481, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.909929993351325, "tt_hits": 11368, "tt_cutoffs": 3852, "beta_cutoffs": 20705, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 5.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3655.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4455.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 91, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1348, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15424, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 110, 109, 142, 94, 96, 141, 124, 138, 84, 98, 82, 68, 81, 66, 83, 80, 85 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 13544, "avg_search_time_ms": 1231.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 132347, "safety_nodes": 282, "corridor_nodes": 6019, "corridor_branch_probes": 6377, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2825, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 5991, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5991, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 58, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2825, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 58, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 428, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 39703680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 138648, "avg_nodes": 12604.363636363636, "eval_calls": 86740, "avg_eval_calls": 7885.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 86740, "pattern_eval_ns": 1817169, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.94960802397971, "pattern_frame_queries": 86740, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1817169, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.94960802397971, "pattern_frame_updates": 264580, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3256047049, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12306.474597475244, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42783, "avg_candidate_generations": 3889.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 3573066, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.5160227193044, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 687, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 42772, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3572379, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 941328, "avg_legality_checks": 85575.27272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 849, "root_legality_checks": 687, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 940641, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 848, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4376455, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 397859.54545454547, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8225026742, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1879.3810840052051, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23114, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2101.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 108028038, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4673.705892532665, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 911, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6612807, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12294, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 74065062, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9473, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25464069, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 436, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1886100, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93425, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8493.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 717371353, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7678.580176612256, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 123500, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11227.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 310256461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2512.198064777328, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1934132341, "stage_ordering_ns": 1253016683, "stage_eval_ns": 3257864218, "stage_threat_ns": 6419685163, "stage_proof_ns": 627615099, "tactical_annotations": 675893, "root_tactical_annotations": 2553, "search_tactical_annotations": 673340, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 276689, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1519417497, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 849493, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4577826187, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 88661, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2890670996, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 138339, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 192336020, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12098, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 69616481, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 276678, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31524196, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 187208, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 165455864, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 248326, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 769557367, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 240359, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28964782, "child_limit_applications": 42772, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42772, "child_cap_hits": 42772, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42772, "child_moves_before_total": 3571531, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3571531, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 396938, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 396938, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.50161320490041, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.280323576171327, "tt_hits": 26133, "tt_cutoffs": 2778, "beta_cutoffs": 33833, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 5.181818181818182, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 5.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3650.2727272727275, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4377.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1805, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 1872, "avg_search_time_ms": 187.2, "search_nodes": 24152, "safety_nodes": 874, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 25026, "avg_nodes": 2502.6, "eval_calls": 16815, "avg_eval_calls": 1681.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 16815, "pattern_eval_ns": 345533, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.549093071662206, "pattern_frame_queries": 16815, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 345533, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.549093071662206, "pattern_frame_updates": 48214, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 419605324, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8702.97681171444, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6937, "avg_candidate_generations": 693.7, "candidate_moves_total": 507920, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.21897073662967, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 625, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 6927, "search_candidate_moves_total": 507295, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 217329, "avg_legality_checks": 21732.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 74, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 217329, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 74, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 682640, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 68264.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1106181012, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1620.4456404547052, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2808, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 280.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10198197, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3631.8365384615386, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 82, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 699131, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 971, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6511635, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1750, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2931671, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55760, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 20052, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2005.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 140160246, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6989.838719329743, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27936, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2793.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 63382436, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2268.8443585337914, "stage_move_gen_ns": 386825159, "stage_ordering_ns": 169409785, "stage_eval_ns": 419950857, "stage_threat_ns": 875248896, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 101433, "root_tactical_annotations": 311, "search_tactical_annotations": 101122, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 48224, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 238364721, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 97645, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 600707421, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13919, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 392320156, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 24107, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 29822100, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 48214, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4971058, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 26860, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 60553883, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 56860, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 147673082, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 17713, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1383596, "child_limit_applications": 6927, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6927, "child_cap_hits": 6927, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6927, "child_moves_before_total": 507221, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 507221, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 110866, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 110866, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.22376209037101, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.004908329724266, "tt_hits": 2361, "tt_cutoffs": 365, "beta_cutoffs": 5820, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5772.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6572.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1906, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1349, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 38376, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 109, 95, 98, 63, 127, 99, 125, 114, 113, 129, 144, 79, 47, 65, 128, 143, 126, 124, 93, 80, 50, 77, 78, 157, 171, 64, 68, 83, 66, 115, 101, 131, 67, 147 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 15646, "avg_search_time_ms": 869.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 196644, "safety_nodes": 753, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 197397, "avg_nodes": 10966.5, "eval_calls": 150817, "avg_eval_calls": 8378.722222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 150817, "pattern_eval_ns": 3268390, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.671230696804738, "pattern_frame_queries": 150817, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3268390, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.671230696804738, "pattern_frame_updates": 393124, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4302975876, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10945.594458745842, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43505, "avg_candidate_generations": 2416.9444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 3562248, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.88134697161246, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1349, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 43487, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3560899, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1247573, "avg_legality_checks": 69309.61111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1214, "root_legality_checks": 1349, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 1246224, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1210, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4185408, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 232522.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8943893389, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2136.922705982308, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40838, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2268.777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 146624750, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3590.3998726676136, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1924, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12204703, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20147, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 97985137, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18747, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36252489, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 182421, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 114798, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6377.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 984294078, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8574.139601735222, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 152306, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8461.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 415684937, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2729.2748611348206, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2991632009, "stage_ordering_ns": 1409692118, "stage_eval_ns": 4306244266, "stage_threat_ns": 6858726123, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 698539, "root_tactical_annotations": 3818, "search_tactical_annotations": 694721, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 393142, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2221445849, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 624875, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4285904613, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 87091, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2840400156, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 196562, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 283815696, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 393124, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48355493, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 223515, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 267167986, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 314254, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1177883229, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 160770, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19204472, "child_limit_applications": 43487, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43487, "child_cap_hits": 43487, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43487, "child_moves_before_total": 3559689, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3559689, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 696103, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 696103, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.85639386483317, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00715156253593, "tt_hits": 18532, "tt_cutoffs": 2258, "beta_cutoffs": 33627, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5502.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5947.277777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1256, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 22710, "avg_search_time_ms": 1335.8823529411766, "search_nodes": 164319, "safety_nodes": 1432, "corridor_nodes": 1352, "corridor_branch_probes": 1620, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 9, "corridor_depth_exits": 456, "corridor_neutral_exits": 57, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1333, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1333, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 57, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 66, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 456, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 57, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 339, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6137600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 167103, "avg_nodes": 9829.588235294117, "eval_calls": 98275, "avg_eval_calls": 5780.882352941177, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 98275, "pattern_eval_ns": 2212029, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.50856270669041, "pattern_frame_queries": 98275, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2212029, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.50856270669041, "pattern_frame_updates": 328428, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3415985937, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10401.019209689795, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 61646, "avg_candidate_generations": 3626.235294117647, "candidate_moves_total": 5094279, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.63762450118418, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1279, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 61629, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5093000, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 3094828, "avg_legality_checks": 182048.70588235295, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2051, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3094828, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2051, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7148438, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 420496.35294117645, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14780978022, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2067.721371018396, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40669, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2392.294117647059, "renju_forbidden_ns": 122791869, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3019.2989500602425, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2603, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20319864, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10651, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64223530, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 27389, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37996775, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 251700, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 263462, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15497.764705882353, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2446084225, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9284.391012745671, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 358018, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21059.882352941175, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1142135555, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3190.1623801037936, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7282626652, "stage_ordering_ns": 2004357251, "stage_eval_ns": 3418197966, "stage_threat_ns": 9788091228, "stage_proof_ns": 86692300, "tactical_annotations": 1006517, "root_tactical_annotations": 2618, "search_tactical_annotations": 1003899, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 331225, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2042206320, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 963368, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7395401668, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 124277, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4095428276, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 165604, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 257632512, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2780, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18333104, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 331208, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43311376, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 221452, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1088244698, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 529909, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2139453653, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 255156, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 31206248, "child_limit_applications": 61629, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 61629, "child_cap_hits": 61629, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 61629, "child_moves_before_total": 5090949, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5090949, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 627120, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 627120, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.6063866037093, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.17572895876941, "tt_hits": 28723, "tt_cutoffs": 4313, "beta_cutoffs": 50192, "depth_sum": 102, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 102, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.29411764705882354, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3116.529411764706, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3587.1176470588234, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1350, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20035, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 145, 109, 108, 81, 123, 125, 80, 93, 129, 161, 77, 79, 63, 65, 107, 94, 124, 126, 142, 140, 155, 98, 84, 154 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 16993, "avg_search_time_ms": 1213.7857142857142, "search_nodes": 211411, "safety_nodes": 592, "corridor_nodes": 3043, "corridor_branch_probes": 3384, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1345, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 3021, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3021, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1345, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 429, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 41758480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2026960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 215046, "avg_nodes": 15360.42857142857, "eval_calls": 156131, "avg_eval_calls": 11152.214285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 156131, "pattern_eval_ns": 3181946, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.37997578956133, "pattern_frame_queries": 156131, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3181946, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.37997578956133, "pattern_frame_updates": 422686, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4723228972, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11174.320824441784, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52204, "avg_candidate_generations": 3728.8571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 4506474, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.3243046509846, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1052, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 52190, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4505422, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1466509, "avg_legality_checks": 104750.64285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1215, "root_legality_checks": 1052, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1465457, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1215, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5886239, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 420445.64285714284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10118658129, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1719.0362350220573, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41442, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2960.1428571428573, "renju_forbidden_ns": 148989897, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3595.142536557116, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1758, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9659126, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22456, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 99454937, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16924, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37286134, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 304, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2589700, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 170876, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12205.42857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1038644289, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6078.350903579204, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 213854, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15275.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 403953310, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1888.920992826882, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2800506910, "stage_ordering_ns": 1483101372, "stage_eval_ns": 4726410918, "stage_threat_ns": 7540667720, "stage_proof_ns": 360315332, "tactical_annotations": 921912, "root_tactical_annotations": 3769, "search_tactical_annotations": 918143, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 428854, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2103153162, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 950798, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5064612507, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 106012, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3269255454, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 214420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 267938746, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6154, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 29336949, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 428840, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45567938, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 293687, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 279410739, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 376359, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1145871113, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 251866, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30058418, "child_limit_applications": 52190, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52190, "child_cap_hits": 52190, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52190, "child_moves_before_total": 4504207, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4504207, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 538925, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 538925, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.30402375934086, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.326211917991952, "tt_hits": 27367, "tt_cutoffs": 3022, "beta_cutoffs": 38569, "depth_sum": 68, "avg_depth": 4.857142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 68, "avg_effective_depth": 4.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4088.785714285714, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4660.214285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 972, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3028, "avg_search_time_ms": 232.92307692307693, "search_nodes": 33390, "safety_nodes": 1601, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34991, "avg_nodes": 2691.6153846153848, "eval_calls": 22806, "avg_eval_calls": 1754.3076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22806, "pattern_eval_ns": 481401, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.10852407261247, "pattern_frame_queries": 22806, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 481401, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.10852407261247, "pattern_frame_updates": 66660, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 630903017, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9464.491704170418, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10098, "avg_candidate_generations": 776.7692307692307, "candidate_moves_total": 819340, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.1388393741335, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 973, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 10085, "search_candidate_moves_total": 818367, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 319366, "avg_legality_checks": 24566.615384615383, "illegal_moves_skipped": 98, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 319366, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 98, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 983942, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 75687.84615384616, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1809927661, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1839.465802862364, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3997, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 307.46153846153845, "renju_forbidden_ns": 17505377, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4379.628971728796, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 98, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 935275, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1492, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11990864, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2407, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4579238, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 33251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2557.769230769231, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 246893077, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7425.13238699588, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 43290, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3330.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 108172421, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2498.785423885424, "stage_move_gen_ns": 672547234, "stage_ordering_ns": 284750476, "stage_eval_ns": 631384418, "stage_threat_ns": 1413616931, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 176300, "root_tactical_annotations": 331, "search_tactical_annotations": 175969, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 66673, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 369214417, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 172468, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 990460602, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20256, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 623955067, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 33330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 44407797, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 66660, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7727096, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 43299, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 99371183, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 108903, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 266791719, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 24098, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1807019, "child_limit_applications": 10085, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10085, "child_cap_hits": 10085, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10085, "child_moves_before_total": 818269, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 818269, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 162835, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 162835, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.13723351512147, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.146256817055033, "tt_hits": 2779, "tt_cutoffs": 439, "beta_cutoffs": 8598, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6151.538461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6766.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1866, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1351, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27155, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 101, 100, 128, 130, 115, 129, 126, 144, 99, 116, 125, 124, 158, 84, 132, 97, 145, 81, 65, 83, 82, 86, 141, 72, 58, 87, 85, 102, 88, 57, 42, 117 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 15319, "avg_search_time_ms": 851.0555555555555, "search_nodes": 265484, "safety_nodes": 888, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 266372, "avg_nodes": 14798.444444444445, "eval_calls": 213400, "avg_eval_calls": 11855.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 213400, "pattern_eval_ns": 4284730, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.078397375820057, "pattern_frame_queries": 213400, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4284730, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.078397375820057, "pattern_frame_updates": 530804, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4944072518, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9314.309082071724, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49405, "avg_candidate_generations": 2744.722222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 3961127, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.17664204027932, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1295, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 49387, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3959832, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1582067, "avg_legality_checks": 87892.61111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3416, "root_legality_checks": 1295, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 1580772, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3412, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5514602, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 306366.77777777775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8575079818, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1554.9770986192657, "renju_forbidden_checks": 50277, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2793.1666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 140400071, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2792.530799371482, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4200, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18795738, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27299, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 96086436, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18757, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25411797, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 106100, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 145159, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8064.388888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 761021073, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5242.672331719012, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 178222, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9901.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 274257600, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1538.8537890945001, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2795296855, "stage_ordering_ns": 1196902131, "stage_eval_ns": 4948357248, "stage_threat_ns": 6256524013, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 907246, "root_tactical_annotations": 3996, "search_tactical_annotations": 903250, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 530822, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2229947616, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 806613, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3650647895, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 98891, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2410489454, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 265402, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 301802833, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 530804, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51473802, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 274291, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 201145851, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 433415, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1038767379, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 199540, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22651867, "child_limit_applications": 49387, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49387, "child_cap_hits": 49387, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49387, "child_moves_before_total": 3956420, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3956420, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 791659, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 791659, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.11055540931824, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02970417316298, "tt_hits": 19950, "tt_cutoffs": 2615, "beta_cutoffs": 35435, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6139.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6583.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1411, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 11821, "avg_search_time_ms": 695.3529411764706, "search_nodes": 141701, "safety_nodes": 1346, "corridor_nodes": 796, "corridor_branch_probes": 932, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 5, "corridor_depth_exits": 268, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_plies_followed": 785, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 785, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 98, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 87, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 268, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 98, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 97, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 716, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 54578000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2022240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 143843, "avg_nodes": 8461.35294117647, "eval_calls": 82789, "avg_eval_calls": 4869.941176470588, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82789, "pattern_eval_ns": 1622475, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.597712256459193, "pattern_frame_queries": 82789, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1622475, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.597712256459193, "pattern_frame_updates": 283194, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1922587952, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6788.943099076958, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 54079, "avg_candidate_generations": 3181.1176470588234, "candidate_moves_total": 4272071, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.99685645074798, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1218, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 54062, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4270853, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 2624342, "avg_legality_checks": 154373.0588235294, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4061, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2624342, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4061, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5747282, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 338075.4117647059, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7426296070, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1292.1405405198493, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40399, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2376.4117647058824, "renju_forbidden_ns": 85133074, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2107.306467981881, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5015, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22900345, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10703, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 40727213, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24634, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21263586, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 47, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 241930, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 159868, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9404.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 782854400, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4896.8799259389, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 203867, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11992.176470588236, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 309697349, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1519.1146629910677, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3746934555, "stage_ordering_ns": 1057634700, "stage_eval_ns": 1924210427, "stage_threat_ns": 4876380062, "stage_proof_ns": 99384358, "tactical_annotations": 1017052, "root_tactical_annotations": 2316, "search_tactical_annotations": 1014736, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 284977, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1072092474, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 881593, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3592972826, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 109016, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2322794579, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 142480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 149590438, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1766, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7124728, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 284960, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24803070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 225791, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 272199148, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 495882, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 973744620, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 295379, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 29796526, "child_limit_applications": 54062, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 54062, "child_cap_hits": 54062, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 54062, "child_moves_before_total": 4266792, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4266792, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 522392, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 522392, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.9240501646258, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.662831563760127, "tt_hits": 28657, "tt_cutoffs": 4746, "beta_cutoffs": 44147, "depth_sum": 104, "avg_depth": 6.117647058823529, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 104, "avg_effective_depth": 6.117647058823529, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5851.058823529412, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6321.64705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1843, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1352, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11121, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 95, 99, 94, 129, 79, 63, 96, 97, 93, 92, 81, 144, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6814, "avg_search_time_ms": 757.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 67804, "safety_nodes": 428, "corridor_nodes": 103, "corridor_branch_probes": 130, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 99, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 99, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 35, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 35, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 275, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 236400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 68335, "avg_nodes": 7592.777777777777, "eval_calls": 41038, "avg_eval_calls": 4559.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41038, "pattern_eval_ns": 871925, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.24677128515035, "pattern_frame_queries": 41038, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 871925, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.24677128515035, "pattern_frame_updates": 135522, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1387254254, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10236.376780153776, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25166, "avg_candidate_generations": 2796.222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 1889524, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.08241277914647, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 554, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 25157, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1888970, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 595771, "avg_legality_checks": 66196.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 590, "root_legality_checks": 554, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 595217, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 590, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1971009, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 219001.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4137270152, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2099.062029650803, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14565, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1618.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 68997115, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4737.186062478544, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 635, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6800318, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4651, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 39457150, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9221, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22642066, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 58, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 97581, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44526, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4947.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 384170702, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8628.008399586759, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 61710, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6856.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 157426565, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2551.070572030465, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1397963772, "stage_ordering_ns": 734333807, "stage_eval_ns": 1388126179, "stage_threat_ns": 3177059713, "stage_proof_ns": 81096727, "tactical_annotations": 239941, "root_tactical_annotations": 1337, "search_tactical_annotations": 238604, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 135799, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 739696886, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 219876, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2317632877, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50555, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1743440964, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67895, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93561892, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 268, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1341116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 135790, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15785972, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 31393, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 63039134, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 129076, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 490485085, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79472, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9040970, "child_limit_applications": 25157, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25157, "child_cap_hits": 25157, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25157, "child_moves_before_total": 1888380, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1888380, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 214149, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 214149, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.0637993401439, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.512501490638789, "tt_hits": 13299, "tt_cutoffs": 1566, "beta_cutoffs": 19800, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3392.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4281.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1343, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 4300, "avg_search_time_ms": 537.5, "search_nodes": 40863, "safety_nodes": 687, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 41550, "avg_nodes": 5193.75, "eval_calls": 28575, "avg_eval_calls": 3571.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 28575, "pattern_eval_ns": 623652, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.82509186351706, "pattern_frame_queries": 28575, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 623652, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.82509186351706, "pattern_frame_updates": 81656, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 753336223, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9225.730172920545, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11804, "avg_candidate_generations": 1475.5, "candidate_moves_total": 846160, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.68417485598103, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 492, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 11796, "search_candidate_moves_total": 845668, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 481351, "avg_legality_checks": 60168.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1383, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 481351, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1383, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1195028, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 149378.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2685282615, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2247.0457721492717, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7247, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 905.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42408318, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5851.844625362219, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1383, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14752174, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1669, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17712676, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4195, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9943468, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 34293, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4286.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 317356329, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9254.259732306884, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 46575, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5821.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 135591700, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2911.2549651100376, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1234091495, "stage_ordering_ns": 370113369, "stage_eval_ns": 753959875, "stage_threat_ns": 1912166437, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 144563, "root_tactical_annotations": 628, "search_tactical_annotations": 143935, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 81664, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 489391483, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 138423, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1348831651, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23643, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 905284497, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40828, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 59897053, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 81656, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10229390, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 29269, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 75660233, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 85504, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 367579439, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 29790, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3816860, "child_limit_applications": 11796, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11796, "child_cap_hits": 11796, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11796, "child_moves_before_total": 844285, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 844285, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 188803, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 188803, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.57383858935232, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00567989148864, "tt_hits": 3610, "tt_cutoffs": 457, "beta_cutoffs": 9956, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 4.375, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 4.375, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4059.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5059.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1912, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1353, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18628, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 97, 127, 126, 143, 159, 158, 113, 95, 79, 129, 98, 84, 99, 101, 115, 188, 173, 130, 96, 131 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6832, "avg_search_time_ms": 683.2, "search_nodes": 75901, "safety_nodes": 491, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76392, "avg_nodes": 7639.2, "eval_calls": 54605, "avg_eval_calls": 5460.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 54605, "pattern_eval_ns": 1177928, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.571797454445562, "pattern_frame_queries": 54605, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1177928, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.571797454445562, "pattern_frame_updates": 151710, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1702956945, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11225.080383626657, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19825, "avg_candidate_generations": 1982.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1441145, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.69331651954603, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 633, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 19815, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1440512, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 568931, "avg_legality_checks": 56893.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 152, "root_legality_checks": 633, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 568298, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 151, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1816060, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 181606.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4066697115, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2239.2966724667685, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5499, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 549.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19458860, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3538.617930532824, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 162, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1062206, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2049, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13554591, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3283, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4788603, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 53460, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39534, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3953.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 327489507, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8283.743284261649, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 55302, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5530.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 134281848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2428.155365086254, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1390133916, "stage_ordering_ns": 626507559, "stage_eval_ns": 1704134873, "stage_threat_ns": 3077911154, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 226666, "root_tactical_annotations": 1353, "search_tactical_annotations": 225313, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 151720, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 911143918, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 223342, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2032720197, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 39696, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1519600473, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75855, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 110014159, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 151710, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19298980, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 51941, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 52467754, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 131697, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 460435279, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 43028, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4733900, "child_limit_applications": 19815, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19815, "child_cap_hits": 19815, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19815, "child_moves_before_total": 1440361, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1440361, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 317040, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 317040, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.69043653797628, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 6717, "tt_cutoffs": 1436, "beta_cutoffs": 16246, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4285.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5085.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11786, "avg_search_time_ms": 1178.6, "search_nodes": 118652, "safety_nodes": 443, "corridor_nodes": 569, "corridor_branch_probes": 602, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 224, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 564, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 564, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 10, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 5, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 224, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 10, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 9, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 28, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 115040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 28640, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 119664, "avg_nodes": 11966.4, "eval_calls": 73330, "avg_eval_calls": 7333.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73330, "pattern_eval_ns": 1485204, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.253702441020046, "pattern_frame_queries": 73330, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1485204, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.253702441020046, "pattern_frame_updates": 237200, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1807863918, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7621.685994940978, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42592, "avg_candidate_generations": 4259.2, "candidate_moves_total": 3372490, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.18130165289256, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 650, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 42582, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3371840, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 2284293, "avg_legality_checks": 228429.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1440, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2284293, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1440, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5149568, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 514956.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7612893175, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1478.3556941087097, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20701, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2070.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37228183, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1798.3760687889474, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1444, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9276614, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2750, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19080936, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16497, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8760171, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 110462, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 173066, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17306.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1114539860, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6439.970069222147, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 250329, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25032.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 530949330, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2121.0060760039787, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3839670954, "stage_ordering_ns": 1008577605, "stage_eval_ns": 1809349122, "stage_threat_ns": 5020177923, "stage_proof_ns": 13970270, "tactical_annotations": 750511, "root_tactical_annotations": 1900, "search_tactical_annotations": 748611, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 238358, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1030718859, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 698974, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3800470815, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 85588, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2180999930, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 119174, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 137765378, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1148, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6408372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 238348, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22777407, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 118318, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 256960114, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 460271, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1338560648, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 171922, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22037092, "child_limit_applications": 42582, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42582, "child_cap_hits": 42582, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42582, "child_moves_before_total": 3370400, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3370400, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 402629, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 402629, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.15081489831384, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.455380207599456, "tt_hits": 16842, "tt_cutoffs": 2690, "beta_cutoffs": 33142, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2890.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3690.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 916, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1354, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 62362, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 125, 173, 141, 113, 143, 140, 109, 93, 129, 171, 115, 101, 174, 159, 158, 126, 145, 144, 160, 100, 190, 206, 188, 98, 99, 146, 189, 83, 68, 187, 175, 205, 203, 161, 172, 157, 176, 96, 95, 81, 66, 82, 192, 191, 177, 178, 202, 216, 208, 224, 80, 114, 65, 130 ], "move_count": 60, "black_stats": { "move_count": 30, "search_move_count": 28, "total_time_ms": 45331, "avg_search_time_ms": 1618.9642857142858, "search_nodes": 422095, "safety_nodes": 1210, "corridor_nodes": 10356, "corridor_branch_probes": 11079, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 4406, "corridor_neutral_exits": 113, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 10296, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 10296, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 90, "corridor_proof_active": 60, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 117, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4406, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 90, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 90, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 2, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 585, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 12328320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 433661, "avg_nodes": 15487.892857142857, "eval_calls": 255867, "avg_eval_calls": 9138.107142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 255867, "pattern_eval_ns": 5628201, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.996588071146338, "pattern_frame_queries": 255867, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5628201, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.996588071146338, "pattern_frame_updates": 843848, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 9012871898, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10680.681708080128, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 157330, "avg_candidate_generations": 5618.928571428572, "candidate_moves_total": 15022485, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.48391915082946, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 28, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2384, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 157302, "search_candidate_moves_total": 15020101, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 3730711, "avg_legality_checks": 133239.67857142858, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12754, "root_legality_checks": 2384, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "search_legality_checks": 3728327, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12739, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12294079, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 439074.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 25569042142, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2079.785085324407, "renju_forbidden_checks": 225682, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8060.071428571428, "renju_forbidden_ns": 449463961, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1991.5809014453966, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 27212, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 48969761, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 89021, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 221517667, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 105677, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 172247168, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3772, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6729365, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 279959, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9998.535714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2037465692, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7277.728853153498, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 358356, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12798.42857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 787785256, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2198.3314246168616, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8761959714, "stage_ordering_ns": 5674425898, "stage_eval_ns": 9018500099, "stage_threat_ns": 20601753979, "stage_proof_ns": 1089677441, "tactical_annotations": 3776551, "root_tactical_annotations": 9891, "search_tactical_annotations": 3766660, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 864648, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5037883918, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3648876, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 14481099920, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 320504, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9402208111, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 432310, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 667070090, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 20772, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 171911703, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 864620, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 108356776, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1248853, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 652911979, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1537765, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3491509982, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 989933, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 135431572, "child_limit_applications": 157302, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 157302, "child_cap_hits": 157302, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 157302, "child_moves_before_total": 15007362, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 15007362, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 1549090, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1549090, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.40477552732959, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.847872245743856, "tt_hits": 77785, "tt_cutoffs": 8763, "beta_cutoffs": 128638, "depth_sum": 163, "avg_depth": 5.821428571428571, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 163, "avg_effective_depth": 5.821428571428571, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 9 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 10, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_moves": 28, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.32142857142857145, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 10, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1516.3214285714287, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1802.0357142857142, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 30, "search_move_count": 28, "total_time_ms": 17005, "avg_search_time_ms": 607.3214285714286, "search_nodes": 146489, "safety_nodes": 2633, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 149122, "avg_nodes": 5325.785714285715, "eval_calls": 98028, "avg_eval_calls": 3501.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 98028, "pattern_eval_ns": 2165567, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.091310645937895, "pattern_frame_queries": 98028, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2165567, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.091310645937895, "pattern_frame_updates": 292710, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2522066238, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8616.262642205596, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46070, "avg_candidate_generations": 1645.357142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 4150800, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.09767744736271, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 28, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2409, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 46042, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4148391, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 2523178, "avg_legality_checks": 90113.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12493, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2523178, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12493, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5319267, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 189973.82142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10762648751, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2023.3330552875047, "renju_forbidden_checks": 69316, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2475.5714285714284, "renju_forbidden_ns": 91745409, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1323.5819868428646, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15397, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14866303, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22443, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 41620412, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 31236, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 34759070, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 240, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 499624, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 185411, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6621.821428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1522060364, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8209.115769830269, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 252446, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9015.92857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 673616276, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2668.3578904003234, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5761195699, "stage_ordering_ns": 1603843688, "stage_eval_ns": 2524231805, "stage_threat_ns": 6985165273, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1008420, "root_tactical_annotations": 3320, "search_tactical_annotations": 1005100, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 292738, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1671313366, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 926503, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5033184532, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 92273, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2867710177, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 146355, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 221047757, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 292710, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36563542, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 402570, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 796003255, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 431641, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1368841907, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 174209, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23056076, "child_limit_applications": 46042, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46042, "child_cap_hits": 46042, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46042, "child_moves_before_total": 4135898, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4135898, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 738998, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 738998, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.82880847921463, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.050519091264498, "tt_hits": 17270, "tt_cutoffs": 2285, "beta_cutoffs": 39864, "depth_sum": 134, "avg_depth": 4.785714285714286, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 134, "avg_effective_depth": 4.785714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 26 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 28, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6565.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6851.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1069, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1355, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26458, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 129, 124, 127, 95, 96, 122, 144, 128, 114, 159, 125, 98, 143, 101, 142, 68, 83, 100, 99, 84, 145, 141, 146 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 11072, "avg_search_time_ms": 851.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 129503, "safety_nodes": 565, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 130068, "avg_nodes": 10005.23076923077, "eval_calls": 97231, "avg_eval_calls": 7479.307692307692, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 97231, "pattern_eval_ns": 2092308, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.518939432896914, "pattern_frame_queries": 97231, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2092308, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.518939432896914, "pattern_frame_updates": 258892, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2843544938, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10983.517984333235, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30942, "avg_candidate_generations": 2380.153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 2302271, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.40601771055523, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 888, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 30929, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2301383, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 969471, "avg_legality_checks": 74574.69230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 566, "root_legality_checks": 888, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 968583, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 566, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2938772, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 226059.38461538462, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6518399893, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2218.069279617473, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16786, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1291.2307692307693, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62785497, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3740.3489217204815, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 733, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6862132, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5622, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 39435905, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10430, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16485959, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1501, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68490, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5268.461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 539531372, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7877.520397138268, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86448, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6649.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 197238182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2281.5817832685543, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2355747247, "stage_ordering_ns": 960278528, "stage_eval_ns": 2845637246, "stage_threat_ns": 4852835369, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 373691, "root_tactical_annotations": 2416, "search_tactical_annotations": 371275, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 258905, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1537730967, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 359162, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3085435764, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61940, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2256240265, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129446, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 188421761, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 258892, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32702827, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 91184, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 97003894, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 206028, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 732005214, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76479, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8544050, "child_limit_applications": 30929, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30929, "child_cap_hits": 30929, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30929, "child_moves_before_total": 2300817, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2300817, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 494864, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 494864, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.39028096608361, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 12046, "tt_cutoffs": 1286, "beta_cutoffs": 24572, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4300.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4916.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1024, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 15374, "avg_search_time_ms": 1281.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 131525, "safety_nodes": 839, "corridor_nodes": 262, "corridor_branch_probes": 285, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 60, "corridor_neutral_exits": 31, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 251, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 251, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 65, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 31, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 60, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 65, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 457, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6242240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2015200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 132626, "avg_nodes": 11052.166666666666, "eval_calls": 82975, "avg_eval_calls": 6914.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82975, "pattern_eval_ns": 1812927, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.84907502259717, "pattern_frame_queries": 82975, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1812927, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.84907502259717, "pattern_frame_updates": 262912, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2655732772, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10101.22311648004, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 45780, "avg_candidate_generations": 3815.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3465310, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.69484491044125, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 807, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 45768, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3464503, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 2078298, "avg_legality_checks": 173191.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1509, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2078298, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1509, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4761368, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 396780.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9901157274, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2079.4774262354854, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24080, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2006.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 98377599, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4085.4484634551495, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1748, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17920828, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6753, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 52759070, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15579, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27697701, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 119270, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9939.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 983557563, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8246.479106229563, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 158319, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13193.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 396436226, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2504.034424168925, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4764798763, "stage_ordering_ns": 1374668018, "stage_eval_ns": 2657545699, "stage_threat_ns": 6381400824, "stage_proof_ns": 102146118, "tactical_annotations": 693032, "root_tactical_annotations": 2095, "search_tactical_annotations": 690937, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 263556, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1508824305, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 631664, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4627605632, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 92043, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3130545109, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 131772, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 190021469, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 632, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3310421, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 263544, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32600052, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 153342, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 380059687, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 365747, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1103897119, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 173943, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19038945, "child_limit_applications": 45768, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 45768, "child_cap_hits": 45768, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 45768, "child_moves_before_total": 3462994, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3462994, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 402398, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 402398, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.66408844607587, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.792125502534521, "tt_hits": 19555, "tt_cutoffs": 2714, "beta_cutoffs": 35410, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 5.583333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 5.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2138.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2805.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1356, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14695, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 81, 129, 127, 143, 109, 108, 95, 145, 161, 123, 80, 125, 79, 63, 78, 77, 82 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9907, "avg_search_time_ms": 990.7, "search_nodes": 102794, "safety_nodes": 160, "corridor_nodes": 184, "corridor_branch_probes": 207, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 64, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 176, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 176, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 544, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26346480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 103138, "avg_nodes": 10313.8, "eval_calls": 66067, "avg_eval_calls": 6606.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 66067, "pattern_eval_ns": 1353181, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.481950141523, "pattern_frame_queries": 66067, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1353181, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.481950141523, "pattern_frame_updates": 205496, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2347721151, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11424.65620255382, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34385, "avg_candidate_generations": 3438.5, "candidate_moves_total": 2664020, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.47622509815326, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 673, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 34375, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2663347, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 822660, "avg_legality_checks": 82266.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1245, "root_legality_checks": 673, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 821987, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1243, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2875197, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 287519.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5945935805, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2068.009880714261, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25197, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2519.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 126893471, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5036.054728737548, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1318, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10783935, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12678, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 87279948, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11173, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28586317, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 243271, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5850.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 474371362, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8108.634952651191, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76928, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7692.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 201693951, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2621.85356437188, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1900567642, "stage_ordering_ns": 1033703247, "stage_eval_ns": 2349074332, "stage_threat_ns": 4447484959, "stage_proof_ns": 135020020, "tactical_annotations": 421283, "root_tactical_annotations": 2659, "search_tactical_annotations": 418624, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 205986, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1122323311, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 363563, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3140649159, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69149, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2389759236, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102988, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 142564728, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 480, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2481977, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 205976, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24047341, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 92987, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 72409914, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 188803, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 651657204, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 139493, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15418443, "child_limit_applications": 34375, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34375, "child_cap_hits": 34375, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34375, "child_moves_before_total": 2662104, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2662104, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 338915, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 338915, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.44302545454545, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.859345454545455, "tt_hits": 19095, "tt_cutoffs": 2306, "beta_cutoffs": 26297, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2906.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3706.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 805, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4779, "avg_search_time_ms": 531.0, "search_nodes": 51371, "safety_nodes": 753, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 52124, "avg_nodes": 5791.555555555556, "eval_calls": 36783, "avg_eval_calls": 4087.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36783, "pattern_eval_ns": 760943, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.68735557186744, "pattern_frame_queries": 36783, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 760943, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.68735557186744, "pattern_frame_updates": 102662, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1016897222, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9905.293312033664, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13929, "avg_candidate_generations": 1547.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1013731, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.77844784263048, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 598, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 13920, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1013133, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 524031, "avg_legality_checks": 58225.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 607, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 524031, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 607, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1366873, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 151874.77777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2925448339, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2140.2488299937154, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10568, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1174.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62945742, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5956.2587055261165, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 607, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5832285, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 42691149, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5521, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14350378, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 71930, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28717, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3190.777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 253798048, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8837.902566424069, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 39803, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4422.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 112395410, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2823.7924277064544, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1256053399, "stage_ordering_ns": 416642333, "stage_eval_ns": 1017658165, "stage_threat_ns": 2060285219, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 162912, "root_tactical_annotations": 576, "search_tactical_annotations": 162336, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 102671, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 583883199, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 154924, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1386930322, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27898, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1002040335, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51331, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 72168588, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 102662, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12280493, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32061, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 72159843, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 94959, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 312565884, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 35892, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5022617, "child_limit_applications": 13920, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13920, "child_cap_hits": 13920, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13920, "child_moves_before_total": 1012526, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1012526, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 222947, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 222947, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.7389367816092, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01630747126437, "tt_hits": 4389, "tt_cutoffs": 628, "beta_cutoffs": 11510, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4366.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5255.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1888, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1357, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17037, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 84, 98, 83, 85, 99, 97, 129, 69, 115, 67, 101, 143, 131, 147, 116, 146, 144, 114, 87, 73, 71, 86, 81, 80, 128, 130, 162, 66, 160, 176, 68, 94, 95, 52, 38, 108 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 8845, "avg_search_time_ms": 491.3888888888889, "search_nodes": 165133, "safety_nodes": 602, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 165735, "avg_nodes": 9207.5, "eval_calls": 117826, "avg_eval_calls": 6545.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 117826, "pattern_eval_ns": 2182107, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.51974097397858, "pattern_frame_queries": 117826, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2182107, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.51974097397858, "pattern_frame_updates": 330096, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2368992979, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7176.678841912656, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 45329, "avg_candidate_generations": 2518.277777777778, "candidate_moves_total": 3544042, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.1848706126321, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1267, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 45311, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3542775, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1024582, "avg_legality_checks": 56921.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3985, "root_legality_checks": 1267, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 1023315, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3976, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3781873, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 210104.05555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4897412982, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1294.970238820817, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44707, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2483.722222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 153485616, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3433.1450555841366, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4376, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24945055, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19150, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 90316310, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21136, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 38005151, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 219100, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 103818, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5767.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 534388608, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5147.359879789632, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 136266, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7570.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 229257424, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1682.4257261532591, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1528598857, "stage_ordering_ns": 797080606, "stage_eval_ns": 2371175086, "stage_threat_ns": 4078901960, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 744003, "root_tactical_annotations": 4156, "search_tactical_annotations": 739847, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 330114, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1191239794, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 655754, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2685183889, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90743, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1879495648, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 165048, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 160673268, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 330096, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27359066, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 261584, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 162776867, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 303412, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 642780713, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 179007, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14445943, "child_limit_applications": 45311, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 45311, "child_cap_hits": 45311, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 45311, "child_moves_before_total": 3538799, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3538799, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 725335, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 725335, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.10021848999139, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0079230209, "tt_hits": 20302, "tt_cutoffs": 1911, "beta_cutoffs": 37777, "depth_sum": 85, "avg_depth": 4.722222222222222, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 85, "avg_effective_depth": 4.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6151.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6595.555555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 706, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 8173, "avg_search_time_ms": 454.05555555555554, "search_nodes": 109493, "safety_nodes": 1646, "corridor_nodes": 804, "corridor_branch_probes": 948, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 284, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 787, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 787, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 284, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 49, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 225, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 18115040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2021280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 111943, "avg_nodes": 6219.055555555556, "eval_calls": 64827, "avg_eval_calls": 3601.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64827, "pattern_eval_ns": 1197317, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.469418606444844, "pattern_frame_queries": 64827, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1197317, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.469418606444844, "pattern_frame_updates": 218764, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1399108789, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6395.51657951034, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 40636, "avg_candidate_generations": 2257.5555555555557, "candidate_moves_total": 3054470, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.16660104340978, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1292, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 40618, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3053178, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1663259, "avg_legality_checks": 92403.27777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6346, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1663259, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6346, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4163050, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 231280.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4985141607, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1197.4733925847636, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41966, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2331.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 134589326, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3207.1039889434305, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6554, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 40282376, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12028, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60863786, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23274, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31192954, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 110, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2250210, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 136471, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7581.722222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 725130536, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5313.440481860615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 188721, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10484.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 334383619, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1771.8410722707065, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2263339306, "stage_ordering_ns": 687986591, "stage_eval_ns": 1400306106, "stage_threat_ns": 3689651244, "stage_proof_ns": 59707017, "tactical_annotations": 703751, "root_tactical_annotations": 1469, "search_tactical_annotations": 702282, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 220458, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 796208701, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 661937, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2747622582, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 81989, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1661451924, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 110220, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108429160, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1676, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6511558, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 220440, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18063921, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 136868, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 241211918, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 393874, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 825427553, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 173009, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12815322, "child_limit_applications": 40618, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 40618, "child_cap_hits": 40618, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 40618, "child_moves_before_total": 3046832, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3046832, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 389917, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 389917, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.01186666010143, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.59961100989709, "tt_hits": 19194, "tt_cutoffs": 3937, "beta_cutoffs": 32589, "depth_sum": 111, "avg_depth": 6.166666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 111, "avg_effective_depth": 6.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6080.722222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6525.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 853, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1358, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12739, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 155, 169, 51, 81, 84, 53, 95, 111, 125, 68, 110, 140, 65, 80, 79, 38, 23, 98 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 10417, "avg_search_time_ms": 801.3076923076923, "search_nodes": 115470, "safety_nodes": 697, "corridor_nodes": 942, "corridor_branch_probes": 1117, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 444, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 937, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 937, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 24, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 444, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 24, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 151, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2193200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2024480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 117109, "avg_nodes": 9008.384615384615, "eval_calls": 79542, "avg_eval_calls": 6118.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79542, "pattern_eval_ns": 1612398, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.271026627442104, "pattern_frame_queries": 79542, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1612398, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.271026627442104, "pattern_frame_updates": 230822, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2699399481, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11694.723557546507, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33891, "avg_candidate_generations": 2607.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2803298, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.71511610752117, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 922, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 33878, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2802376, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 908480, "avg_legality_checks": 69883.07692307692, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1149, "root_legality_checks": 922, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 907558, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1149, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3220468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 247728.3076923077, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6235231843, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1936.1260049781586, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23670, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1820.7692307692307, "renju_forbidden_ns": 125914281, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5319.5724968314325, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1291, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10515268, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11823, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 87856946, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10381, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27001261, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 175, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 540806, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 85924, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6609.538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 659942486, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7680.537288766817, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 112148, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8626.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 264332915, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2357.000704426294, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1959607431, "stage_ordering_ns": 980002837, "stage_eval_ns": 2701011879, "stage_threat_ns": 4595889082, "stage_proof_ns": 129846291, "tactical_annotations": 504184, "root_tactical_annotations": 2375, "search_tactical_annotations": 501809, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 232757, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1255466076, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 455176, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3126122402, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 68305, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2074713283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 116372, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156781660, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1922, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10713372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 232744, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26323387, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 117647, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 168592937, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 218547, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 765257114, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 167990, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20482185, "child_limit_applications": 33878, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33878, "child_cap_hits": 33878, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33878, "child_moves_before_total": 2801227, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2801227, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 346958, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 346958, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.68572524942441, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.241395595961981, "tt_hits": 18204, "tt_cutoffs": 1991, "beta_cutoffs": 25858, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5741.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6357.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1701, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 2310, "avg_search_time_ms": 192.5, "search_nodes": 23081, "safety_nodes": 1375, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 24456, "avg_nodes": 2038.0, "eval_calls": 15977, "avg_eval_calls": 1331.4166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 15977, "pattern_eval_ns": 331181, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.728609876697753, "pattern_frame_queries": 15977, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 331181, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.728609876697753, "pattern_frame_updates": 46052, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 446264169, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9690.440567184922, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6725, "avg_candidate_generations": 560.4166666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 514978, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.57665427509293, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 852, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 6713, "search_candidate_moves_total": 514126, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 261335, "avg_legality_checks": 21777.916666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 178, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 261335, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 178, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 720121, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 60010.083333333336, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1448846911, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2011.949257138731, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3401, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 283.4166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13958815, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4104.326668626874, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 178, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1394364, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8904079, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2143, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3660372, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23689, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1974.0833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 210389611, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8881.320908438516, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 33094, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2757.8333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 98113375, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2964.6877077415847, "stage_move_gen_ns": 602307317, "stage_ordering_ns": 201949615, "stage_eval_ns": 446595350, "stage_threat_ns": 1032425973, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 98438, "root_tactical_annotations": 356, "search_tactical_annotations": 98082, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 46064, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 269116156, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 90354, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 725039337, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13505, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 441262875, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 23026, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 31297918, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 46052, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5413686, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 22801, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 93820979, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 54039, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 189597741, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 21598, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1558876, "child_limit_applications": 6713, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6713, "child_cap_hits": 6713, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6713, "child_moves_before_total": 513948, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 513948, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 107645, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 107645, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.56010725458066, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.035304632802028, "tt_hits": 2515, "tt_cutoffs": 336, "beta_cutoffs": 5671, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6047.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6714.416666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1874, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1359, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28219, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 141, 93, 97, 83, 98, 84, 82, 114, 99, 86, 126, 85, 87, 100, 140, 154, 156, 171, 108, 109, 124, 92, 172 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 11496, "avg_search_time_ms": 884.3076923076923, "search_nodes": 151597, "safety_nodes": 842, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 152439, "avg_nodes": 11726.076923076924, "eval_calls": 121245, "avg_eval_calls": 9326.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 121245, "pattern_eval_ns": 2444674, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.16309126149532, "pattern_frame_queries": 121245, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2444674, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.16309126149532, "pattern_frame_updates": 303080, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3351359486, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11057.672845453346, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29269, "avg_candidate_generations": 2251.4615384615386, "candidate_moves_total": 2232733, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.28320065598415, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 931, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 29256, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2231802, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 984278, "avg_legality_checks": 75713.69230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 370, "root_legality_checks": 931, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 983347, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 366, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3087819, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 237524.53846153847, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6704661558, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2171.3259611395615, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15878, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1221.3846153846155, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61933304, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3900.573371961204, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 596, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4026986, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8499, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 48067214, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6757, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9607404, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 231700, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72435, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5571.923076923077, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 554137965, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7650.141022986126, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89420, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6878.461538461538, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 196363189, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2195.9649854618656, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2340880412, "stage_ordering_ns": 926634548, "stage_eval_ns": 3353804160, "stage_threat_ns": 4822696903, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 371576, "root_tactical_annotations": 2228, "search_tactical_annotations": 369348, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 303093, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1688988858, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 354136, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2876336362, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58594, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2031724946, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 151540, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 210753958, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 303080, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36197370, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 94984, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 86870166, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 200547, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 757071238, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76045, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10420355, "child_limit_applications": 29256, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29256, "child_cap_hits": 29256, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29256, "child_moves_before_total": 2231436, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2231436, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 468452, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 468452, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.27276456111566, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.012168444079848, "tt_hits": 10868, "tt_cutoffs": 1039, "beta_cutoffs": 21306, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3966.230769230769, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4581.615384615385, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1104, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 16713, "avg_search_time_ms": 1392.75, "search_nodes": 127743, "safety_nodes": 424, "corridor_nodes": 347, "corridor_branch_probes": 395, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 161, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_plies_followed": 343, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 343, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 62, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 161, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 66, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 532, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 355920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 25520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 128514, "avg_nodes": 10709.5, "eval_calls": 74958, "avg_eval_calls": 6246.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74958, "pattern_eval_ns": 1589207, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.20129939432749, "pattern_frame_queries": 74958, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1589207, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.20129939432749, "pattern_frame_updates": 255344, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2381788336, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9327.763080393508, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 48938, "avg_candidate_generations": 4078.1666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 3948978, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.69348972168866, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 844, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 48926, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3948134, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 2507799, "avg_legality_checks": 208983.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 524, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2507799, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 524, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5237533, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 436461.0833333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11054291577, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2110.591298804227, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16452, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1371.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 49715106, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3021.8274981765135, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 528, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4883339, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4506, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30689819, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11396, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13884467, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 257481, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 148337, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12361.416666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1151949487, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7765.7596351550865, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 183517, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15293.083333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 414019725, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2256.029277941553, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5827752279, "stage_ordering_ns": 1585931765, "stage_eval_ns": 2383377543, "stage_threat_ns": 6700164800, "stage_proof_ns": 110651923, "tactical_annotations": 775671, "root_tactical_annotations": 3236, "search_tactical_annotations": 772435, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 256174, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1482019442, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 662744, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4963543405, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 98344, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3289508653, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128081, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 186628129, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 818, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4695428, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 256162, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31327613, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 191759, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 484346994, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 353901, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1176295705, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 230011, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 31950783, "child_limit_applications": 48926, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 48926, "child_cap_hits": 48926, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 48926, "child_moves_before_total": 3947610, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3947610, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 460372, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 460372, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.68532068838654, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.409557290602134, "tt_hits": 26499, "tt_cutoffs": 3791, "beta_cutoffs": 39369, "depth_sum": 68, "avg_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 68, "avg_effective_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1334.3333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1951.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1360, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13653, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 71, 85, 93, 95, 140, 123, 81, 97, 83, 124, 121, 139, 153, 154, 169, 94 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 11279, "avg_search_time_ms": 939.9166666666666, "search_nodes": 119250, "safety_nodes": 388, "corridor_nodes": 490, "corridor_branch_probes": 584, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 208, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 485, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 485, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 22, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 17, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 208, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 22, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 149, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2203920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2024480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 120128, "avg_nodes": 10010.666666666666, "eval_calls": 87307, "avg_eval_calls": 7275.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87307, "pattern_eval_ns": 1810718, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.739665777085456, "pattern_frame_queries": 87307, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1810718, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.739665777085456, "pattern_frame_updates": 238392, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3184480128, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13358.166918352965, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30291, "avg_candidate_generations": 2524.25, "candidate_moves_total": 2536213, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.72826912284177, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 869, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 30279, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2535344, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 907774, "avg_legality_checks": 75647.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1122, "root_legality_checks": 869, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 906905, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1122, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3205642, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 267136.8333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6796177538, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2120.067536549621, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26808, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2234.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 137255588, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5119.948821247389, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1301, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9642666, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15293, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 101785854, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10169, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25382205, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 444863, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 85326, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7110.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 698180544, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8182.506434146684, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 111540, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9295.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 283806091, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2544.4333064371526, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2151456399, "stage_ordering_ns": 1022945095, "stage_eval_ns": 3186290846, "stage_threat_ns": 4780940530, "stage_proof_ns": 93264679, "tactical_annotations": 418894, "root_tactical_annotations": 2707, "search_tactical_annotations": 416187, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 239418, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1385186419, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 397314, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3172230748, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60897, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2110400818, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 119703, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 174338928, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1014, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5256257, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 239406, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29170988, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 102976, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 187752434, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 203789, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 797734100, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 112129, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14757190, "child_limit_applications": 30279, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30279, "child_cap_hits": 30279, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30279, "child_moves_before_total": 2534222, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2534222, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 287106, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 287106, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.69569668747316, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.482017239671059, "tt_hits": 14293, "tt_cutoffs": 1610, "beta_cutoffs": 21439, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5019.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5686.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 804, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2365, "avg_search_time_ms": 215.0, "search_nodes": 22536, "safety_nodes": 1229, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 23765, "avg_nodes": 2160.4545454545455, "eval_calls": 15341, "avg_eval_calls": 1394.6363636363637, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 15341, "pattern_eval_ns": 315910, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.5925298220455, "pattern_frame_queries": 15341, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 315910, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.5925298220455, "pattern_frame_updates": 44972, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 459142845, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10209.526927866227, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6882, "avg_candidate_generations": 625.6363636363636, "candidate_moves_total": 542221, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.78828828828829, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 782, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 6871, "search_candidate_moves_total": 541439, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 247962, "avg_legality_checks": 22542.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 117, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 247962, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 117, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 702649, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 63877.181818181816, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1463457215, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2082.771362372963, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2854, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 259.45454545454544, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12864157, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4507.413104414856, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1058332, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1021, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8601601, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1716, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3204224, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21447, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1949.7272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 198864052, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9272.348207208468, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 29998, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2727.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 93716747, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3124.0998399893324, "stage_move_gen_ns": 586993987, "stage_ordering_ns": 221351642, "stage_eval_ns": 459458755, "stage_threat_ns": 1072745958, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 100109, "root_tactical_annotations": 321, "search_tactical_annotations": 99788, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 44983, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 271945271, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 94581, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 761628230, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13814, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 481036192, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 22486, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 31794813, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 44972, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5450162, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 21671, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 86828006, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 59088, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 193443161, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 19350, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1927482, "child_limit_applications": 6871, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6871, "child_cap_hits": 6871, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6871, "child_moves_before_total": 541322, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 541322, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 110012, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 110012, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.78358317566584, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.011060980934364, "tt_hits": 2230, "tt_cutoffs": 274, "beta_cutoffs": 5872, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5861.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6588.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1873, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1361, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17532, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 125, 129, 127, 99, 98, 130, 140, 126, 155, 110, 141, 169, 142, 131, 132, 139, 157, 172, 109, 173, 93 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10268, "avg_search_time_ms": 855.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 134931, "safety_nodes": 155, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 135086, "avg_nodes": 11257.166666666666, "eval_calls": 104188, "avg_eval_calls": 8682.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 104188, "pattern_eval_ns": 2114339, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.29349829154989, "pattern_frame_queries": 104188, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2114339, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.29349829154989, "pattern_frame_updates": 269758, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2904123022, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10765.660414148979, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29285, "avg_candidate_generations": 2440.4166666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2099675, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.69796824312787, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 29273, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2098941, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 807250, "avg_legality_checks": 67270.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 278, "root_legality_checks": 734, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 806516, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 278, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2816889, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 234740.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5947650412, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2111.425197087993, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17797, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1483.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 40364780, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2268.066528066528, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 459, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1583886, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26819442, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9908, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11961452, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68510, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5709.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 517260090, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7550.139979565027, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 87414, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7284.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 191473401, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2190.4203102477863, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1883827671, "stage_ordering_ns": 861066146, "stage_eval_ns": 2906237361, "stage_threat_ns": 4570515700, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 400461, "root_tactical_annotations": 2581, "search_tactical_annotations": 397880, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 269770, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1486965341, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 362382, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2854330967, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58621, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2057601331, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134879, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184329671, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 269758, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32300410, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 103545, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 104713816, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 200206, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 692004370, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 96710, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12589311, "child_limit_applications": 29273, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29273, "child_cap_hits": 29273, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29273, "child_moves_before_total": 2098663, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2098663, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 468588, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 468588, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.69278857650394, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.007515457930516, "tt_hits": 12229, "tt_cutoffs": 1418, "beta_cutoffs": 22444, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4634.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5300.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1080, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7252, "avg_search_time_ms": 659.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 80875, "safety_nodes": 810, "corridor_nodes": 146, "corridor_branch_probes": 176, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 50, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 142, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 142, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 60, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 50, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 60, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 60, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 437, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 8247520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2002160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 81831, "avg_nodes": 7439.181818181818, "eval_calls": 49738, "avg_eval_calls": 4521.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49738, "pattern_eval_ns": 972558, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.553620973903254, "pattern_frame_queries": 49738, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 972558, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.553620973903254, "pattern_frame_updates": 161624, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1160789711, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7182.038007969113, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29089, "avg_candidate_generations": 2644.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 2079628, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.49190415621025, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 668, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 29078, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2078960, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 1171286, "avg_legality_checks": 106480.54545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 45, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1171286, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 45, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2723281, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 247571.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4608160039, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1692.1353466645564, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7730, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 702.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9034581, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1168.7685640362224, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 55, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 133050, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1485, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 4853138, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6190, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4048393, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59049, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5368.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 376047746, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6368.401598672289, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 77250, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7022.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 143819230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1861.7376051779936, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2172665689, "stage_ordering_ns": 684198895, "stage_eval_ns": 1161762269, "stage_threat_ns": 3083381157, "stage_proof_ns": 91878587, "tactical_annotations": 340207, "root_tactical_annotations": 1159, "search_tactical_annotations": 339048, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 162039, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 742740414, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 315894, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2217362313, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58537, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1618099662, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 81014, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94689939, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 404, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1929827, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 162028, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16263203, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 61081, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 122641518, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 186330, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 469219460, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 92796, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10395461, "child_limit_applications": 29078, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29078, "child_cap_hits": 29078, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29078, "child_moves_before_total": 2078915, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2078915, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 254931, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 254931, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.49442877777014, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.767143544948071, "tt_hits": 13108, "tt_cutoffs": 1996, "beta_cutoffs": 22380, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4419.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5146.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1626, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1362, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 44493, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 83, 125, 126, 140, 115, 116, 99, 139, 153, 131, 129, 84, 101, 143, 100, 141, 142, 138, 137, 98, 110, 158, 87, 73, 103, 102, 51, 67, 94, 78, 157, 173, 188, 159, 127, 172, 71, 85, 55, 39, 119 ], "move_count": 47, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 34624, "avg_search_time_ms": 1573.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 346892, "safety_nodes": 1179, "corridor_nodes": 6788, "corridor_branch_probes": 7120, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3307, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 6758, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6758, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 117, "corridor_proof_active": 30, "corridor_proof_quiet": 87, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3307, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 117, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 116, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 3, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 931, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 28526000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2019680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 354859, "avg_nodes": 16129.954545454546, "eval_calls": 228416, "avg_eval_calls": 10382.545454545454, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 228416, "pattern_eval_ns": 4756618, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.82436431773606, "pattern_frame_queries": 228416, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4756618, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.82436431773606, "pattern_frame_updates": 693552, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8351725419, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12041.95996695273, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 110235, "avg_candidate_generations": 5010.681818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 10509137, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.33394112577675, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1918, "root_candidate_moves_max": 127, "search_candidate_generations": 110213, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10507219, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 2384444, "avg_legality_checks": 108383.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10214, "root_legality_checks": 1918, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "search_legality_checks": 2382526, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10199, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9742655, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 442847.95454545453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19829498842, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2035.3280334775275, "renju_forbidden_checks": 80699, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3668.1363636363635, "renju_forbidden_ns": 518476676, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6424.821571518854, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11214, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 117800064, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37066, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 258900501, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29935, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 114451572, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2484, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 27324539, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 245527, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11160.318181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2092188712, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8521.216452773015, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 339048, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15411.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 942436764, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2779.655871734976, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5526181313, "stage_ordering_ns": 3795240513, "stage_eval_ns": 8356482037, "stage_threat_ns": 16039990935, "stage_proof_ns": 794062620, "tactical_annotations": 2537863, "root_tactical_annotations": 7026, "search_tactical_annotations": 2530837, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 707324, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4016167144, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2208093, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11211030009, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 224307, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7127832774, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 353651, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 518625780, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 13750, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 87146451, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 707302, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 85681785, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 736104, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 703569847, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 917009, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2531013047, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 884750, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 121339766, "child_limit_applications": 110213, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 110213, "child_cap_hits": 110213, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 110213, "child_moves_before_total": 10497020, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10497020, "child_moves_before_max": 135, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 135, "child_moves_after_total": 1285594, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1285594, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.2430294066943, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.664631214103599, "tt_hits": 66816, "tt_cutoffs": 8147, "beta_cutoffs": 89813, "depth_sum": 115, "avg_depth": 5.2272727272727275, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 115, "avg_effective_depth": 5.2272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3182.9545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3546.590909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 9844, "avg_search_time_ms": 468.76190476190476, "search_nodes": 76158, "safety_nodes": 2144, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 78302, "avg_nodes": 3728.6666666666665, "eval_calls": 50610, "avg_eval_calls": 2410.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50610, "pattern_eval_ns": 1090835, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.553744319304485, "pattern_frame_queries": 50610, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1090835, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.553744319304485, "pattern_frame_updates": 152116, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1501941380, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9873.658129322359, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23895, "avg_candidate_generations": 1137.857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 2348244, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.27344632768362, "candidate_moves_max": 138, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1834, "root_candidate_moves_max": 123, "search_candidate_generations": 23874, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2346410, "search_candidate_moves_max": 138, "legality_checks": 1524106, "avg_legality_checks": 72576.47619047618, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3947, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1524106, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3947, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3128264, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 148964.95238095237, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6348883490, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2029.5229206997874, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32478, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1546.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124884233, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3845.1946856333516, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4089, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 45161985, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4952, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 42384435, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23362, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36483470, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 75, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 854343, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 107275, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5108.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 989049246, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9219.755264507108, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 157432, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7496.761904761905, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 468594405, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2976.4876581635244, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3511247497, "stage_ordering_ns": 880614987, "stage_eval_ns": 1503032215, "stage_threat_ns": 3867513326, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 513652, "root_tactical_annotations": 1856, "search_tactical_annotations": 511796, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152137, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 903718937, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 462887, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2819153804, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47890, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1489247613, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76058, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112452924, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152116, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18972713, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 186108, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 446860363, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 228876, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 882602697, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 98668, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13214948, "child_limit_applications": 23874, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23874, "child_cap_hits": 23874, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23874, "child_moves_before_total": 2342463, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2342463, "child_moves_before_max": 138, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 138, "child_moves_after_total": 383913, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 383913, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 98.11774315154561, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.080799195777832, "tt_hits": 10170, "tt_cutoffs": 1574, "beta_cutoffs": 20617, "depth_sum": 100, "avg_depth": 4.761904761904762, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 100, "avg_effective_depth": 4.761904761904762, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09523809523809523, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6706.761904761905, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7087.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1880, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1363, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 39150, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 97, 127, 128, 141, 155, 156, 111, 99, 85, 171, 186, 125, 96, 144, 95, 94, 109, 114, 129, 123, 124, 108, 81, 138, 67, 53, 80, 64, 82, 52, 79, 78, 83 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 14785, "avg_search_time_ms": 869.7058823529412, "search_nodes": 148504, "safety_nodes": 1417, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 149921, "avg_nodes": 8818.882352941177, "eval_calls": 107846, "avg_eval_calls": 6343.882352941177, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107846, "pattern_eval_ns": 2356781, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.85320735122304, "pattern_frame_queries": 107846, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2356781, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.85320735122304, "pattern_frame_updates": 296854, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4003850574, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13487.608635895087, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38192, "avg_candidate_generations": 2246.5882352941176, "candidate_moves_total": 3255582, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.24251152073732, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1273, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 38175, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3254309, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1263878, "avg_legality_checks": 74345.76470588235, "illegal_moves_skipped": 489, "root_legality_checks": 1273, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1262605, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 489, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3903794, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 229634.9411764706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8944362709, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2291.1974117999052, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22278, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1310.4705882352941, "renju_forbidden_ns": 87999935, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3950.0823682556784, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5330979, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10138, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 63024180, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11392, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19558095, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 86681, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 84805, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4988.529411764706, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 763155872, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8998.949024232063, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 114641, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6743.588235294118, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 315239205, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2749.794619725927, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3136557119, "stage_ordering_ns": 1380914583, "stage_eval_ns": 4006207355, "stage_threat_ns": 6189818721, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 568442, "root_tactical_annotations": 2200, "search_tactical_annotations": 566242, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 296871, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1800984542, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 548390, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4109473615, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 76460, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2849716263, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148427, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 227196174, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 296854, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38956614, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 142152, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 93617639, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 329765, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1165423601, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 96525, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13207776, "child_limit_applications": 38175, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38175, "child_cap_hits": 38175, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38175, "child_moves_before_total": 3253820, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3253820, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 610808, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 610808, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.23431565160445, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000209561231173, "tt_hits": 13153, "tt_cutoffs": 2407, "beta_cutoffs": 31140, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 4.470588235294118, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 4.470588235294118, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5647.35294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6117.941176470588, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 24347, "avg_search_time_ms": 1521.6875, "search_nodes": 156755, "safety_nodes": 772, "corridor_nodes": 417, "corridor_branch_probes": 514, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 147, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 409, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 409, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 29, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 21, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 147, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 29, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 168, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4201680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2011520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 157944, "avg_nodes": 9871.5, "eval_calls": 93606, "avg_eval_calls": 5850.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 93606, "pattern_eval_ns": 2117747, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.62405187701643, "pattern_frame_queries": 93606, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2117747, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.62405187701643, "pattern_frame_updates": 313328, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3626525900, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11574.215837716387, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 59234, "avg_candidate_generations": 3702.125, "candidate_moves_total": 5188915, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.6002802444542, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1202, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 59218, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5187713, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 3545412, "avg_legality_checks": 221588.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1146, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3545412, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1146, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7415616, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 463476.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16266815579, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2193.589255295851, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37692, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2355.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 70630793, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1873.8934787222752, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1239, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12297678, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4627, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30365215, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 31805, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27902090, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 65810, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 232130, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14508.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2235030749, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9628.358027829234, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 326290, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20393.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1012470193, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3102.9764718501947, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8640280440, "stage_ordering_ns": 2180296457, "stage_eval_ns": 3628643647, "stage_threat_ns": 9707354115, "stage_proof_ns": 47975872, "tactical_annotations": 1150703, "root_tactical_annotations": 3932, "search_tactical_annotations": 1146771, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 314220, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1935626303, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1056668, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7445218011, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 118851, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4176407921, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 157102, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 248282436, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 876, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5455066, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 314204, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41483339, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 250613, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 560548826, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 661224, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2688476896, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 238866, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 31288960, "child_limit_applications": 59218, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 59218, "child_cap_hits": 59218, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 59218, "child_moves_before_total": 5186567, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5186567, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 526730, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 526730, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.58429869296498, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.894761727853018, "tt_hits": 24066, "tt_cutoffs": 3846, "beta_cutoffs": 47185, "depth_sum": 85, "avg_depth": 5.3125, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 85, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3125, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1739.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2222.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1364, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21183, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 129, 171, 143, 141, 111, 95, 115, 101, 159, 175, 144, 174, 128, 156, 186, 172, 173, 96, 145, 146, 187, 131, 201 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 16052, "avg_search_time_ms": 1234.7692307692307, "search_nodes": 138605, "safety_nodes": 677, "corridor_nodes": 3282, "corridor_branch_probes": 3625, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1521, "corridor_neutral_exits": 30, "corridor_terminal_exits": 33, "corridor_plies_followed": 3255, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3255, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 87, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 60, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1521, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 33, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 87, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 697, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 89172440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 18, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 16, "total_nodes": 142564, "avg_nodes": 10966.461538461539, "eval_calls": 84034, "avg_eval_calls": 6464.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84034, "pattern_eval_ns": 1874083, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.30148511316848, "pattern_frame_queries": 84034, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1874083, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.30148511316848, "pattern_frame_updates": 277068, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3409383813, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12305.224035254883, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 50970, "avg_candidate_generations": 3920.769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 4007104, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.61691190896606, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 913, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 50957, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4006191, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1162675, "avg_legality_checks": 89436.53846153847, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1284, "root_legality_checks": 913, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1161762, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1283, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4233522, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 325655.53846153844, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9715432510, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2294.8817816465817, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34468, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2651.3846153846152, "renju_forbidden_ns": 154636639, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4486.382702796797, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1624, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11272539, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15576, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 89513767, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15507, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45011790, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1761, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8838543, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74274, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5713.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 636201697, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8565.604343377225, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 96818, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7447.538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 251535262, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2598.021669524262, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2944272613, "stage_ordering_ns": 1721178087, "stage_eval_ns": 3411257896, "stage_threat_ns": 7426005968, "stage_proof_ns": 485583103, "tactical_annotations": 589408, "root_tactical_annotations": 3128, "search_tactical_annotations": 586280, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 283765, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1770373045, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 662162, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5325746880, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 103833, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3912860778, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 141876, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 219848063, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6684, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 47549508, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 283752, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36916333, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 114193, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 95458736, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 268806, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 879676108, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 206409, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 25572139, "child_limit_applications": 50957, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 50957, "child_cap_hits": 50957, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 50957, "child_moves_before_total": 4004908, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4004908, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 439897, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 439897, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.59387326569461, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.632709931903369, "tt_hits": 28102, "tt_cutoffs": 3543, "beta_cutoffs": 40277, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 5.384615384615385, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 5.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2194.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2809.5384615384614, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5117, "avg_search_time_ms": 426.4166666666667, "search_nodes": 45601, "safety_nodes": 1218, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 46819, "avg_nodes": 3901.5833333333335, "eval_calls": 31595, "avg_eval_calls": 2632.9166666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 31595, "pattern_eval_ns": 693944, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.963728438043994, "pattern_frame_queries": 31595, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 693944, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.963728438043994, "pattern_frame_updates": 91092, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 906982923, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9956.77911342379, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13329, "avg_candidate_generations": 1110.75, "candidate_moves_total": 968773, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.68159651886863, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 844, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 13317, "search_candidate_moves_total": 967929, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 543799, "avg_legality_checks": 45316.583333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 469, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 543799, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 469, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1423955, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 118662.91666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3227519536, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2266.5881548223083, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7376, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 614.6666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21076067, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2857.3843546637745, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 500, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1578007, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1921, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12854258, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4940, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6627402, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 16400, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48056, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4004.6666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 457481279, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9519.753599966705, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66089, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5507.416666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 200656027, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3036.148632904114, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1395780323, "stage_ordering_ns": 429522358, "stage_eval_ns": 907676867, "stage_threat_ns": 2347616465, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 174282, "root_tactical_annotations": 681, "search_tactical_annotations": 173601, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 91104, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 576545008, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 169131, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1685784556, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26713, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1075554646, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 45546, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 69662225, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 91092, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12103922, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 43331, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 154775110, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 99078, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 455119799, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 31873, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3520754, "child_limit_applications": 13317, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13317, "child_cap_hits": 13317, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13317, "child_moves_before_total": 967460, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 967460, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 213074, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 213074, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.64849440564691, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00015018397537, "tt_hits": 4153, "tt_cutoffs": 634, "beta_cutoffs": 11290, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5295.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5961.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1623, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1365, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17228, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 127, 97, 96, 125, 83, 100, 81, 80, 99, 139, 153, 110, 85, 84, 113, 71, 141 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6014, "avg_search_time_ms": 668.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 65886, "safety_nodes": 535, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 66421, "avg_nodes": 7380.111111111111, "eval_calls": 47904, "avg_eval_calls": 5322.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47904, "pattern_eval_ns": 1049212, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.902388109552437, "pattern_frame_queries": 47904, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1049212, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.902388109552437, "pattern_frame_updates": 131698, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1365985040, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10372.10162644839, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16908, "avg_candidate_generations": 1878.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1117932, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.11852377572747, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 549, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 16899, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1117383, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 511961, "avg_legality_checks": 56884.555555555555, "illegal_moves_skipped": 939, "root_legality_checks": 549, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 511412, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 938, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1589990, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 176665.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3621257153, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2277.534546129221, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10724, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1191.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 52815452, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4924.976874300634, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 985, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11343141, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3254, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27335942, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6477, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14065318, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 71051, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45674, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5074.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 441929031, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9675.72428515129, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65626, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7291.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 197596175, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3010.9434522902507, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1325679619, "stage_ordering_ns": 500353451, "stage_eval_ns": 1367034252, "stage_threat_ns": 2785869723, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 152410, "root_tactical_annotations": 1057, "search_tactical_annotations": 151353, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 131707, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 788431073, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 161934, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1880682145, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33852, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1292840989, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 65849, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 97003089, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 131698, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16627628, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32276, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 83709039, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 95799, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 503779425, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 24335, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3125788, "child_limit_applications": 16899, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16899, "child_cap_hits": 16899, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16899, "child_moves_before_total": 1116445, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1116445, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 270386, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 270386, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 66.06574353512042, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000118350198235, "tt_hits": 5515, "tt_cutoffs": 1047, "beta_cutoffs": 13882, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3674.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4562.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 11206, "avg_search_time_ms": 1400.75, "search_nodes": 76000, "safety_nodes": 350, "corridor_nodes": 48, "corridor_branch_probes": 52, "corridor_max_depth": 3, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 40, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 40, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 25, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 17, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 25, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 25, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 163, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 20072240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76398, "avg_nodes": 9549.75, "eval_calls": 47166, "avg_eval_calls": 5895.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47166, "pattern_eval_ns": 1085412, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 23.01259381758046, "pattern_frame_queries": 47166, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1085412, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 23.01259381758046, "pattern_frame_updates": 151918, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1729930328, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11387.26370805303, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26994, "avg_candidate_generations": 3374.25, "candidate_moves_total": 2023118, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.94695117433504, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 479, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 26986, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2022639, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1459732, "avg_legality_checks": 182466.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5996, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1459732, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5996, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3407510, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 425938.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7454292043, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2187.6067988061664, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29619, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3702.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 155600065, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5253.386846281103, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6004, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 70697885, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5902, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 52844728, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17708, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31989822, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 67630, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 123254, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15406.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1291806447, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10480.848061726192, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 180889, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22611.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 638907742, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3532.0430871971207, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3733794838, "stage_ordering_ns": 878380785, "stage_eval_ns": 1731015740, "stage_threat_ns": 4754443589, "stage_proof_ns": 45622834, "tactical_annotations": 448975, "root_tactical_annotations": 1492, "search_tactical_annotations": 447483, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152056, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 940952913, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 373774, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3654713324, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54157, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2012836249, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76024, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 119097750, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 130, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 648064, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152048, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19829501, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 92512, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 480526731, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 222025, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1158477070, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 134438, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19202037, "child_limit_applications": 26986, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26986, "child_cap_hits": 26986, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26986, "child_moves_before_total": 2016643, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2016643, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 263178, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 263178, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.72922997109612, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.75239012821463, "tt_hits": 13187, "tt_cutoffs": 1808, "beta_cutoffs": 20992, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1775.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2378.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 836, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1366, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25891, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 96, 128, 68, 110, 97, 127, 67, 52, 66, 65, 54, 40, 69, 70, 84, 99, 85, 83, 95, 143, 113, 159, 175, 129, 39, 24, 53, 81, 101, 37, 117 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 17611, "avg_search_time_ms": 1100.6875, "search_nodes": 174564, "safety_nodes": 775, "corridor_nodes": 313, "corridor_branch_probes": 336, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 88, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 304, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 304, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 88, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 50, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 411, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 13955680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1984320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 175652, "avg_nodes": 10978.25, "eval_calls": 109962, "avg_eval_calls": 6872.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 109962, "pattern_eval_ns": 2403876, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.860970153325695, "pattern_frame_queries": 109962, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2403876, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.860970153325695, "pattern_frame_updates": 348976, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4363180282, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12502.809024116272, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 60296, "avg_candidate_generations": 3768.5, "candidate_moves_total": 4551557, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.48688138516651, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1132, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 60280, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4550425, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1286298, "avg_legality_checks": 80393.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1137, "root_legality_checks": 1132, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1285166, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1134, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4664722, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 291545.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10360263356, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2220.981948334756, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38473, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2404.5625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 167048423, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4341.9650924024645, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1868, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12508871, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17697, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 106524546, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18869, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 47733006, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 282000, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83967, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5247.9375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 701948416, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8359.812974144605, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 108683, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6792.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 279541200, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2572.0784299292436, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3170222838, "stage_ordering_ns": 1766090877, "stage_eval_ns": 4365584158, "stage_threat_ns": 8098417573, "stage_proof_ns": 136351405, "tactical_annotations": 1084262, "root_tactical_annotations": 3214, "search_tactical_annotations": 1081048, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 349702, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2121273120, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 845673, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5604126967, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 121047, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4156140055, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 174843, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 266380514, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 710, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4011364, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 349686, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44631941, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 215369, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 120666675, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 486010, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1282668707, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 382883, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 57993667, "child_limit_applications": 60280, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 60280, "child_cap_hits": 60280, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 60280, "child_moves_before_total": 4549291, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4549291, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 651261, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 651261, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.46932647644327, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.803931652289316, "tt_hits": 32677, "tt_cutoffs": 4248, "beta_cutoffs": 46263, "depth_sum": 74, "avg_depth": 4.625, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 74, "avg_effective_depth": 4.625, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3323.4375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3823.4375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 8264, "avg_search_time_ms": 550.9333333333333, "search_nodes": 65278, "safety_nodes": 1081, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 66359, "avg_nodes": 4423.933333333333, "eval_calls": 43472, "avg_eval_calls": 2898.133333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 43472, "pattern_eval_ns": 962024, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.129738682370263, "pattern_frame_queries": 43472, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 962024, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.129738682370263, "pattern_frame_updates": 130416, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1323228956, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10146.2163844927, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20153, "avg_candidate_generations": 1343.5333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1582499, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.52423956731008, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1059, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 20138, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1581440, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 1146760, "avg_legality_checks": 76450.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5191, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1146760, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5191, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2597943, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 173196.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5372823713, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2068.1068495344202, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28962, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1930.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 110111844, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3801.9419929562873, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 50321801, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3617, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27950242, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20113, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31682541, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 157260, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 103700, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6913.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 995762828, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9602.341639344262, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 143888, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9592.533333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 469675921, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3264.177144723674, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2748076531, "stage_ordering_ns": 611575402, "stage_eval_ns": 1324190980, "stage_threat_ns": 3515482851, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 434153, "root_tactical_annotations": 1486, "search_tactical_annotations": 432667, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 130431, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 796915974, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 392045, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2594125643, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40376, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1303218943, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 65208, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 98298037, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 130416, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16454604, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 157931, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 479140236, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 193729, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 811548004, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 82493, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9688593, "child_limit_applications": 20138, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20138, "child_cap_hits": 20138, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20138, "child_moves_before_total": 1576249, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1576249, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 322524, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 322524, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.27237064256629, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.015691727083126, "tt_hits": 7980, "tt_cutoffs": 1599, "beta_cutoffs": 17332, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6025.733333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6559.066666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1367, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12345, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 114, 126, 113, 111, 82, 66, 97, 127, 115, 116, 130, 146, 67, 52, 129, 125, 124, 81, 145, 96 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7187, "avg_search_time_ms": 718.7, "search_nodes": 79960, "safety_nodes": 597, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 80557, "avg_nodes": 8055.7, "eval_calls": 61875, "avg_eval_calls": 6187.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 61875, "pattern_eval_ns": 1316306, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.273632323232324, "pattern_frame_queries": 61875, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1316306, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.273632323232324, "pattern_frame_updates": 159828, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2209283756, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13822.883074304878, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17033, "avg_candidate_generations": 1703.3, "candidate_moves_total": 1162919, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.27446721070862, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 630, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 17023, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1162289, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 515246, "avg_legality_checks": 51524.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2376, "root_legality_checks": 630, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 514616, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2368, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1959279, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 195927.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4221504981, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2154.6216649083667, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26891, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2689.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 236397649, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8790.957904131494, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2870, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 37866030, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14147, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 145797093, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9820, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 51944793, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 54, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 789733, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58256, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5825.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 573489962, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9844.30723015655, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81722, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8172.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 264401068, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3235.3719683806075, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1290921774, "stage_ordering_ns": 488251899, "stage_eval_ns": 2210600062, "stage_threat_ns": 3164301791, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 257399, "root_tactical_annotations": 1277, "search_tactical_annotations": 256122, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 159838, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 919267283, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 240790, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2105858550, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34112, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1322489891, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79914, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113630146, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 159828, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19537463, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 60829, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 102232409, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 145840, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 680549468, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 50730, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6008349, "child_limit_applications": 17023, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17023, "child_cap_hits": 17023, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17023, "child_moves_before_total": 1159921, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1159921, "child_moves_before_max": 96, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 96, "child_moves_after_total": 274682, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 274682, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.13845973095223, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.13593373670916, "tt_hits": 6425, "tt_cutoffs": 1016, "beta_cutoffs": 12983, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3789.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4589.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 257, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5147, "avg_search_time_ms": 514.7, "search_nodes": 37687, "safety_nodes": 905, "corridor_nodes": 808, "corridor_branch_probes": 952, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 386, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 802, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 802, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 10, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 4, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 386, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 10, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 10, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 21, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2047760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2009920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 39400, "avg_nodes": 3940.0, "eval_calls": 22640, "avg_eval_calls": 2264.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22640, "pattern_eval_ns": 495151, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.870627208480567, "pattern_frame_queries": 22640, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 495151, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.870627208480567, "pattern_frame_updates": 75274, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 966856746, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12844.498047134468, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13703, "avg_candidate_generations": 1370.3, "candidate_moves_total": 973339, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.03108808290155, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 644, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 13693, "search_candidate_moves_total": 972695, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 520783, "avg_legality_checks": 52078.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2633, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 520783, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2633, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1525637, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 152563.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3157747149, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2069.7893070238856, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22113, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2211.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 193374691, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8744.84199339755, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3401, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 48117300, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7583, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 85020905, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11055, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 59143677, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1092809, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 56872, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5687.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 587498261, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10330.184642706428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 80562, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8056.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 282852294, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3510.9889774335293, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1287755583, "stage_ordering_ns": 391904268, "stage_eval_ns": 967351897, "stage_threat_ns": 2457203519, "stage_proof_ns": 10228214, "tactical_annotations": 267226, "root_tactical_annotations": 367, "search_tactical_annotations": 266859, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 76908, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 472791699, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 277417, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1900448978, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27821, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1036790543, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38449, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 58132451, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1624, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9483604, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 76898, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9636374, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 34739, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 120381313, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171725, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 705211313, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 60762, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6710413, "child_limit_applications": 13693, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13693, "child_cap_hits": 13693, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13693, "child_moves_before_total": 970062, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 970062, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 168125, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 168125, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.84364273716497, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.27817132841598, "tt_hits": 6019, "tt_cutoffs": 1305, "beta_cutoffs": 11344, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.9, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.9, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4603.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5403.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1368, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26430, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 126, 114, 110, 158, 94, 78, 125, 129, 99, 82, 66, 130, 146, 70, 56, 144, 124, 127, 122, 123, 80, 108, 95, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18681, "avg_search_time_ms": 1437.0, "search_nodes": 135944, "safety_nodes": 787, "corridor_nodes": 4438, "corridor_branch_probes": 5062, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2026, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 4409, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4409, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 53, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2026, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 53, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 354, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4282960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 141169, "avg_nodes": 10859.153846153846, "eval_calls": 78635, "avg_eval_calls": 6048.846153846154, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 78635, "pattern_eval_ns": 1739530, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.1215743625612, "pattern_frame_queries": 78635, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1739530, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.1215743625612, "pattern_frame_updates": 271736, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4030290630, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14831.640378897166, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52375, "avg_candidate_generations": 4028.846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 4835991, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.3339570405728, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1110, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 52362, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4834881, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 1173840, "avg_legality_checks": 90295.38461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1064, "root_legality_checks": 1110, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1172730, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1064, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4809397, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 369953.6153846154, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11178822957, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2324.371008881155, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54575, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4198.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 430077005, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7880.476500229042, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1181, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11499000, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26243, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 259452909, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26038, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 148587911, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1113, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 10537185, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 116400, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8953.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1216771826, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10453.366202749141, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 163619, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12586.076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 580908990, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3550.3761176880435, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3033551783, "stage_ordering_ns": 1977668864, "stage_eval_ns": 4032030160, "stage_threat_ns": 8999839306, "stage_proof_ns": 583892023, "tactical_annotations": 1042295, "root_tactical_annotations": 3208, "search_tactical_annotations": 1039087, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 280673, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1857294327, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 979272, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6763267801, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 106922, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4348839735, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 140330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 227866007, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8924, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 58490376, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 280660, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37590831, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 196013, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 338394928, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 432363, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1405230247, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 413919, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 55329964, "child_limit_applications": 52362, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52362, "child_cap_hits": 52362, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52362, "child_moves_before_total": 4833817, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4833817, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 625218, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 625218, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 92.31536228562697, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.940300217715137, "tt_hits": 32714, "tt_cutoffs": 4873, "beta_cutoffs": 44489, "depth_sum": 74, "avg_depth": 5.6923076923076925, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 74, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6923076923076925, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1627.2307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2194.6923076923076, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7735, "avg_search_time_ms": 595.0, "search_nodes": 51922, "safety_nodes": 1563, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53485, "avg_nodes": 4114.2307692307695, "eval_calls": 34869, "avg_eval_calls": 2682.230769230769, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34869, "pattern_eval_ns": 773585, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.185465599816457, "pattern_frame_queries": 34869, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 773585, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.185465599816457, "pattern_frame_updates": 103730, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1156326085, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11147.460570712426, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15943, "avg_candidate_generations": 1226.3846153846155, "candidate_moves_total": 1432082, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.82512701499091, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1138, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 15930, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1430944, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1034285, "avg_legality_checks": 79560.38461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 106, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1034285, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 106, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2357391, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 181337.76923076922, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5248008938, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2226.193676823234, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7153, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 550.2307692307693, "renju_forbidden_ns": 27078458, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3785.608555850692, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 106, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 843844, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2002, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18763584, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5045, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7471030, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99907, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7685.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1115239565, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11162.777032640355, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 148369, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11413.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 557208086, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3755.555985414743, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2636833934, "stage_ordering_ns": 614260309, "stage_eval_ns": 1157099670, "stage_threat_ns": 3272660996, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 281196, "root_tactical_annotations": 1136, "search_tactical_annotations": 280060, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 103743, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 647301454, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 260877, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2524527269, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31942, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1172129005, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51865, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80343224, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 103730, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13232193, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 81104, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 554834858, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 147821, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 797225222, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 52271, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7256856, "child_limit_applications": 15930, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15930, "child_cap_hits": 15930, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15930, "child_moves_before_total": 1430838, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1430838, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 255314, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 255314, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.82033898305085, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02724419334589, "tt_hits": 6316, "tt_cutoffs": 1066, "beta_cutoffs": 13668, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4908.307692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5523.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1621, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1369, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12147, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 142, 96, 114, 156, 127, 157, 113, 115, 98, 111, 141, 81, 66, 155, 83, 68, 143 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6697, "avg_search_time_ms": 744.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 68736, "safety_nodes": 337, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 69073, "avg_nodes": 7674.777777777777, "eval_calls": 50812, "avg_eval_calls": 5645.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50812, "pattern_eval_ns": 1095425, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.558391718491695, "pattern_frame_queries": 50812, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1095425, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.558391718491695, "pattern_frame_updates": 137398, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1854235282, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13495.358607839999, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16958, "avg_candidate_generations": 1884.2222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 1176395, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.37109328930299, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 544, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 16949, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1175851, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 453159, "avg_legality_checks": 50351.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 922, "root_legality_checks": 544, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 452615, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 920, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1688434, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 187603.77777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3958194183, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2344.299026790505, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18236, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2026.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 110328443, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6050.035259925422, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 986, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7899718, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8619, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 78475567, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8617, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23933078, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 20080, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50338, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5593.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 477693667, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9489.722813778855, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 70268, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7807.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 201762201, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2871.3240877782205, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1189178671, "stage_ordering_ns": 534947391, "stage_eval_ns": 1855330707, "stage_threat_ns": 3092861366, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 254204, "root_tactical_annotations": 1388, "search_tactical_annotations": 252816, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 137407, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 862238802, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 227320, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2098673801, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33952, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1421660487, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68699, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107048762, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 137398, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18136114, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 61658, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 88112313, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 131704, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 588741131, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 60842, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6763887, "child_limit_applications": 16949, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16949, "child_cap_hits": 16949, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16949, "child_moves_before_total": 1174931, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1174931, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 271899, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 271899, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.32155289397605, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.042185379668418, "tt_hits": 7092, "tt_cutoffs": 938, "beta_cutoffs": 13639, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3403.222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4292.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 275, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5441, "avg_search_time_ms": 680.125, "search_nodes": 37375, "safety_nodes": 785, "corridor_nodes": 641, "corridor_branch_probes": 751, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 336, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 635, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 635, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 12, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 6, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 336, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 12, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 11, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 26, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2019440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 38801, "avg_nodes": 4850.125, "eval_calls": 22037, "avg_eval_calls": 2754.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22037, "pattern_eval_ns": 484232, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.973589871579616, "pattern_frame_queries": 22037, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 484232, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.973589871579616, "pattern_frame_updates": 74660, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 924735075, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12385.950642914546, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13873, "avg_candidate_generations": 1734.125, "candidate_moves_total": 976229, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.36899012470266, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 483, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 13865, "search_candidate_moves_total": 975746, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 572328, "avg_legality_checks": 71541.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1170, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 572328, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1170, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1564277, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 195534.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3494027189, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2233.637130124652, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16739, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2092.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 71454498, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4268.743533066491, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1272, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12003717, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4025, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38644313, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11429, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20791057, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 15411, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 61518, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7689.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 604406405, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9824.870850807894, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84989, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10623.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 266939832, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3140.8750779512643, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1474242406, "stage_ordering_ns": 438185135, "stage_eval_ns": 925219307, "stage_threat_ns": 2558284499, "stage_proof_ns": 15580954, "tactical_annotations": 239446, "root_tactical_annotations": 428, "search_tactical_annotations": 239018, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 75962, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 494384385, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 243863, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1980074279, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28086, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1124185384, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37977, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 60917636, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1294, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7533934, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 75954, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10172996, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 34111, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 141194064, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 150361, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 689120432, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 54974, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5201269, "child_limit_applications": 13865, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13865, "child_cap_hits": 13865, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13865, "child_moves_before_total": 974576, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 974576, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 151870, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 151870, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.29037143887487, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.95347998557519, "tt_hits": 5740, "tt_cutoffs": 1429, "beta_cutoffs": 11431, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3346.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4346.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1370, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32427, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 142, 125, 95, 97, 114, 156, 111, 127, 113, 115, 98, 124, 123, 143, 82, 66, 109, 81, 144, 160, 129, 159, 68, 83, 100, 86, 84, 99, 116, 52, 132 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 25448, "avg_search_time_ms": 1496.9411764705883, "search_nodes": 243626, "safety_nodes": 440, "corridor_nodes": 1510, "corridor_branch_probes": 1617, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 906, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1504, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1504, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 39, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 906, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 39, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 289, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4121440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2025520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 245576, "avg_nodes": 14445.64705882353, "eval_calls": 156989, "avg_eval_calls": 9234.64705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 156989, "pattern_eval_ns": 3414216, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.748122479918976, "pattern_frame_queries": 156989, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3414216, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.748122479918976, "pattern_frame_updates": 487090, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6499970254, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13344.495378677451, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 81228, "avg_candidate_generations": 4778.117647058823, "candidate_moves_total": 6778418, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.44927857389078, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1204, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 81211, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6777214, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1695890, "avg_legality_checks": 99758.23529411765, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1156, "root_legality_checks": 1204, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1694686, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1156, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6598232, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 388131.29411764705, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14783332655, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2240.4990692961387, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38707, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2276.8823529411766, "renju_forbidden_ns": 152683333, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3944.5922701320173, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1482, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10531532, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19861, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 100911906, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17088, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40168106, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 276, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1071789, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 152446, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8967.411764705883, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1183854220, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7765.728323471918, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 184038, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10825.764705882353, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 388779779, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2112.497304904422, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4218043575, "stage_ordering_ns": 2786695918, "stage_eval_ns": 6503384470, "stage_threat_ns": 11680309283, "stage_proof_ns": 173851915, "tactical_annotations": 1877211, "root_tactical_annotations": 4832, "search_tactical_annotations": 1872379, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 490193, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2980637070, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1521938, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8152866044, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 163196, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5712291279, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 245088, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 380675881, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3086, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20968381, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 490176, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63700014, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 526190, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 370306740, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 773224, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1923993550, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 577797, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 81461893, "child_limit_applications": 81211, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 81211, "child_cap_hits": 81211, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 81211, "child_moves_before_total": 6776058, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6776058, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 864975, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 864975, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.43768701284309, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.650958613980865, "tt_hits": 43046, "tt_cutoffs": 5346, "beta_cutoffs": 63978, "depth_sum": 78, "avg_depth": 4.588235294117647, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 78, "avg_effective_depth": 4.588235294117647, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2001.7058823529412, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2472.294117647059, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 6965, "avg_search_time_ms": 435.3125, "search_nodes": 57313, "safety_nodes": 1421, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 58734, "avg_nodes": 3670.875, "eval_calls": 38136, "avg_eval_calls": 2383.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38136, "pattern_eval_ns": 834761, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.889054961191526, "pattern_frame_queries": 38136, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 834761, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.889054961191526, "pattern_frame_updates": 114476, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1230181891, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10746.199124707362, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18001, "avg_candidate_generations": 1125.0625, "candidate_moves_total": 1387490, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.07849563913116, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1130, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 17985, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1386360, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 759845, "avg_legality_checks": 47490.3125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1961, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 759845, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1961, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1972999, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 123312.4375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4413555143, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2236.977891524527, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10702, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 668.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64612769, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6037.448047094001, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1963, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22282514, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3012, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30243523, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5722, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12021622, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 65110, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74040, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4627.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 711655608, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9611.77212317666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97221, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6076.3125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 306663942, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3154.2973431665996, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1958833943, "stage_ordering_ns": 598683121, "stage_eval_ns": 1231016652, "stage_threat_ns": 3127872214, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 328135, "root_tactical_annotations": 966, "search_tactical_annotations": 327169, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 114492, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 716316238, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 307400, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2300651135, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36077, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1333177883, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57238, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 89116342, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 114476, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14792526, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 100002, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 363735842, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171311, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 603406378, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 56822, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6995973, "child_limit_applications": 17985, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17985, "child_cap_hits": 17985, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17985, "child_moves_before_total": 1384399, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1384399, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 288292, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 288292, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.97520155685294, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.029580205726994, "tt_hits": 6269, "tt_cutoffs": 1117, "beta_cutoffs": 15492, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5883.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6383.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1713, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1371, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22222, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 81, 68, 111, 113, 94, 54, 40, 78, 140, 154, 125, 95, 127, 85, 86, 128, 142, 158, 157, 172, 97 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 11851, "avg_search_time_ms": 911.6153846153846, "search_nodes": 129740, "safety_nodes": 369, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 130109, "avg_nodes": 10008.384615384615, "eval_calls": 96583, "avg_eval_calls": 7429.461538461538, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 96583, "pattern_eval_ns": 2104267, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.787136452584825, "pattern_frame_queries": 96583, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2104267, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.787136452584825, "pattern_frame_updates": 259366, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3380543367, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13033.872469791722, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31306, "avg_candidate_generations": 2408.153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 2705939, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.43515620008944, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 991, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 31293, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2704948, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 876409, "avg_legality_checks": 67416.07692307692, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1327, "root_legality_checks": 991, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 875418, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1324, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3007599, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 231353.76923076922, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6826398294, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2269.7169050794337, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41829, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3217.6153846153848, "renju_forbidden_ns": 283132975, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6768.820076980086, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1895, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17546008, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24283, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 211800156, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15636, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 53596521, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 190290, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81525, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6271.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 759047773, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9310.61359092303, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 111917, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8609.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 312956137, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2796.3234986641887, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2202551456, "stage_ordering_ns": 1105504420, "stage_eval_ns": 3382647634, "stage_threat_ns": 5107212563, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 487535, "root_tactical_annotations": 2982, "search_tactical_annotations": 484553, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 259379, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1541445346, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 423311, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3321532857, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62668, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2230463765, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129683, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 194217131, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 259366, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32509166, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 139883, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 222056527, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 220750, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 868868384, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 126902, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17508063, "child_limit_applications": 31293, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31293, "child_cap_hits": 31293, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31293, "child_moves_before_total": 2703624, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2703624, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 501227, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 501227, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.39708561020036, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.017224299364074, "tt_hits": 14052, "tt_cutoffs": 1807, "beta_cutoffs": 24984, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5151.307692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5766.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 911, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10359, "avg_search_time_ms": 863.25, "search_nodes": 75509, "safety_nodes": 1311, "corridor_nodes": 1418, "corridor_branch_probes": 1648, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 12, "corridor_depth_exits": 682, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1403, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1403, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 39, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 682, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 39, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 39, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 202, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 33974160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 78238, "avg_nodes": 6519.833333333333, "eval_calls": 46300, "avg_eval_calls": 3858.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46300, "pattern_eval_ns": 1022604, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.08647948164147, "pattern_frame_queries": 46300, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1022604, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.08647948164147, "pattern_frame_updates": 150878, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1787333725, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11846.21830220443, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26207, "avg_candidate_generations": 2183.9166666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2133066, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.39298660663182, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 914, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 26195, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2132152, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1206423, "avg_legality_checks": 100535.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1247, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1206423, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1247, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2947697, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 245641.41666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6623080473, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2246.8661036056283, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23704, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1975.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 138882964, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5859.05180560243, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1723, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18017814, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8731, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 85010369, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13235, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 35652401, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 202380, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98756, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8229.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 943538290, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9554.237615942322, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 133386, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11115.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 401351521, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3008.947873090129, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3052414154, "stage_ordering_ns": 897905655, "stage_eval_ns": 1788356329, "stage_threat_ns": 4507284689, "stage_proof_ns": 57112959, "tactical_annotations": 417155, "root_tactical_annotations": 963, "search_tactical_annotations": 416192, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 153774, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 986072077, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 437128, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3347969907, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53147, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1997044234, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76881, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 123044701, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2884, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17149807, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 153762, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20147664, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 73742, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 324749294, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 236263, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 974786421, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 107150, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12900533, "child_limit_applications": 26195, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26195, "child_cap_hits": 26195, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26195, "child_moves_before_total": 2130905, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2130905, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 273751, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 273751, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.34777629318572, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.450505821721702, "tt_hits": 12832, "tt_cutoffs": 2945, "beta_cutoffs": 20996, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 5.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 5.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3835.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4502.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 67, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1372, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19956, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 85, 68, 111, 109, 142, 94, 127, 80, 81, 54, 40, 157, 113, 114, 99, 141, 71 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14982, "avg_search_time_ms": 1362.0, "search_nodes": 128608, "safety_nodes": 336, "corridor_nodes": 2237, "corridor_branch_probes": 2522, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 865, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 2215, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2215, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 865, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 422, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4257200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 131181, "avg_nodes": 11925.545454545454, "eval_calls": 84074, "avg_eval_calls": 7643.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84074, "pattern_eval_ns": 1856167, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.077776720508123, "pattern_frame_queries": 84074, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1856167, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.077776720508123, "pattern_frame_updates": 257106, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3729510196, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14505.729916843637, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41284, "avg_candidate_generations": 3753.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 3359487, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.3750363336886, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 747, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 41273, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3358740, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 978649, "avg_legality_checks": 88968.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1181, "root_legality_checks": 747, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 977902, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1179, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3962776, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 360252.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9104138532, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2297.4143711378083, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41035, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3730.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 280893963, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6845.228780309492, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1409, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13399121, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24042, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 208227326, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14995, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 53921704, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 589, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5345812, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 101432, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9221.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 957893796, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9443.704117043932, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 134404, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12218.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 407682834, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3033.264143924288, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2487691608, "stage_ordering_ns": 1392004525, "stage_eval_ns": 3731366363, "stage_threat_ns": 6938241074, "stage_proof_ns": 384279615, "tactical_annotations": 685324, "root_tactical_annotations": 2500, "search_tactical_annotations": 682824, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 261657, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1647276101, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 669537, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4991816234, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 83924, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3290189471, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 130823, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 204398661, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4540, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26760013, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 261646, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34328395, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 162668, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 304436383, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 281131, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1012295943, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 241525, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33661670, "child_limit_applications": 41273, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41273, "child_cap_hits": 41273, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41273, "child_moves_before_total": 3357561, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3357561, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 472093, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 472093, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.35005936084123, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.438301068495143, "tt_hits": 24133, "tt_cutoffs": 3206, "beta_cutoffs": 33196, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.45454545454545453, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1922.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2564.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 522, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 4964, "avg_search_time_ms": 496.4, "search_nodes": 48216, "safety_nodes": 951, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49167, "avg_nodes": 4916.7, "eval_calls": 34804, "avg_eval_calls": 3480.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34804, "pattern_eval_ns": 760314, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.84559246063671, "pattern_frame_queries": 34804, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 760314, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.84559246063671, "pattern_frame_updates": 96342, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 867715179, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9006.613719872952, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12832, "avg_candidate_generations": 1283.2, "candidate_moves_total": 983410, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.63731296758105, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 681, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 12822, "search_candidate_moves_total": 982729, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 528225, "avg_legality_checks": 52822.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 220, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 528225, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 220, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1374755, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 137475.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3077849301, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2238.8347749235318, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4999, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 499.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 22994404, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4599.80076015203, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 308, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3050343, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1460, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13231862, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3221, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6603399, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 108800, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4925.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 489081512, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9930.387443909769, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66232, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6623.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 219501943, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3314.137320328542, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1355440483, "stage_ordering_ns": 423812342, "stage_eval_ns": 868475493, "stage_threat_ns": 2281632291, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 190866, "root_tactical_annotations": 716, "search_tactical_annotations": 190150, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 96352, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 583036704, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 176566, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1609217898, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25709, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 963602982, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48171, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 71880632, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 96342, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12240393, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 45961, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 237544190, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 104888, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 407722414, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 40017, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5256664, "child_limit_applications": 12822, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12822, "child_cap_hits": 12822, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12822, "child_moves_before_total": 982509, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 982509, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 208623, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 208623, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.6268132896584, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.27070659803463, "tt_hits": 4616, "tt_cutoffs": 545, "beta_cutoffs": 10569, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4851.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5651.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1863, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1373, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18365, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 82, 128, 68, 110, 97, 67, 84, 113, 83, 85, 69, 158, 143, 55, 54, 40, 39, 24, 99 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10233, "avg_search_time_ms": 1023.3, "search_nodes": 125805, "safety_nodes": 419, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 126224, "avg_nodes": 12622.4, "eval_calls": 100958, "avg_eval_calls": 10095.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 100958, "pattern_eval_ns": 2095818, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.759305849957407, "pattern_frame_queries": 100958, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2095818, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.759305849957407, "pattern_frame_updates": 251526, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3278397510, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13034.030318933232, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23808, "avg_candidate_generations": 2380.8, "candidate_moves_total": 1750916, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.54317876344086, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 635, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 23798, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1750281, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 790438, "avg_legality_checks": 79043.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 565, "root_legality_checks": 635, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 789803, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 565, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2864963, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 286496.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6114008082, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2134.0617948643667, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26902, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2690.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 110219509, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4097.074901494313, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 843, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5663687, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13791, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 85081387, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12268, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19474435, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 82988, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8298.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 692971850, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8350.265701065215, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110364, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11036.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 288646853, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2615.407678228408, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1896498458, "stage_ordering_ns": 725128416, "stage_eval_ns": 3280493328, "stage_threat_ns": 4289440693, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 365305, "root_tactical_annotations": 1793, "search_tactical_annotations": 363512, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 251536, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1427172146, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 338695, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2648089085, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47657, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1677695122, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 125763, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 174863933, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 251526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30464503, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96770, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 151539017, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 194260, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 818623736, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 74275, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8851026, "child_limit_applications": 23798, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23798, "child_cap_hits": 23798, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23798, "child_moves_before_total": 1749716, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1749716, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 380982, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 380982, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.5236574502059, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.008992352298513, "tt_hits": 8879, "tt_cutoffs": 1007, "beta_cutoffs": 17171, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3084.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3884.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 469, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8121, "avg_search_time_ms": 902.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 63346, "safety_nodes": 752, "corridor_nodes": 179, "corridor_branch_probes": 223, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 45, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 173, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 173, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 22, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 16, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 45, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 22, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 149, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4009120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 64277, "avg_nodes": 7141.888888888889, "eval_calls": 37798, "avg_eval_calls": 4199.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37798, "pattern_eval_ns": 802226, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.22403301761998, "pattern_frame_queries": 37798, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 802226, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.22403301761998, "pattern_frame_updates": 126598, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1367522892, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10802.089227317967, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23295, "avg_candidate_generations": 2588.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 1760384, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.56917793517923, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 564, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 23286, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1759820, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 971216, "avg_legality_checks": 107912.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 546, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 971216, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 546, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2538693, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 282077.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5233560976, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2061.5178660830593, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14731, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1636.7777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46901923, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3183.8926753105698, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 558, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5223642, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3557, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28300741, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10616, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13377540, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90453, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10050.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 817964954, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9042.983140415465, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 122955, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13661.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 370106498, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3010.0971737627588, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2294955229, "stage_ordering_ns": 707561312, "stage_eval_ns": 1368325118, "stage_threat_ns": 3670960116, "stage_proof_ns": 36315662, "tactical_annotations": 392892, "root_tactical_annotations": 789, "search_tactical_annotations": 392103, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 126997, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 752150773, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 373588, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2799466927, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46820, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1630220081, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 63494, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92422186, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 390, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2084840, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 126988, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15644104, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 66889, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 236418666, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 246345, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 922319395, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79658, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9191286, "child_limit_applications": 23286, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23286, "child_cap_hits": 23286, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23286, "child_moves_before_total": 1759274, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1759274, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 229493, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 229493, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.55071716911449, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.855406682126599, "tt_hits": 9283, "tt_cutoffs": 2216, "beta_cutoffs": 18878, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 5.111111111111111, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 5.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3026.777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3915.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1374, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15135, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 128, 82, 100, 142, 86, 72, 143, 83, 81, 110, 113, 158, 126, 124, 68, 138 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9973, "avg_search_time_ms": 1108.111111111111, "search_nodes": 94419, "safety_nodes": 517, "corridor_nodes": 2488, "corridor_branch_probes": 2723, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1050, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2473, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2473, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 30, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 15, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1050, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 30, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 30, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 178, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4234320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 97424, "avg_nodes": 10824.888888888889, "eval_calls": 59794, "avg_eval_calls": 6643.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 59794, "pattern_eval_ns": 1205700, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.16423052480182, "pattern_frame_queries": 59794, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1205700, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.16423052480182, "pattern_frame_updates": 188748, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2047507757, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10847.838159874542, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32039, "avg_candidate_generations": 3559.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 2610196, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.46933424888417, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 639, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 32030, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2609557, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 893043, "avg_legality_checks": 99227.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1037, "root_legality_checks": 639, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 892404, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1037, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3173116, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 352568.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6105146749, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1924.0225535404315, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36206, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4022.8888888888887, "renju_forbidden_ns": 113190267, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3126.28478705187, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1282, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8702122, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12066, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60854771, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22248, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41374042, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 610, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2259332, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 84160, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9351.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 680664423, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8087.742668726236, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110289, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12254.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 302086579, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2739.045407973597, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1973425285, "stage_ordering_ns": 968843039, "stage_eval_ns": 2048713457, "stage_threat_ns": 4705425704, "stage_proof_ns": 235308380, "tactical_annotations": 466554, "root_tactical_annotations": 1469, "search_tactical_annotations": 465085, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 193763, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1051237433, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 512388, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3457717054, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 65414, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2240404493, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 96877, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 133319389, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5006, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19915727, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 193754, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21793192, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70300, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 123231800, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 229267, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 813492924, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 166987, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21442909, "child_limit_applications": 32030, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32030, "child_cap_hits": 32030, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32030, "child_moves_before_total": 2608520, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2608520, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 324978, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 324978, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.43990009366219, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.146050577583516, "tt_hits": 17626, "tt_cutoffs": 2550, "beta_cutoffs": 25467, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2146.1111111111113, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3035.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5154, "avg_search_time_ms": 644.25, "search_nodes": 40335, "safety_nodes": 660, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40995, "avg_nodes": 5124.375, "eval_calls": 26794, "avg_eval_calls": 3349.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 26794, "pattern_eval_ns": 551371, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.578151825035455, "pattern_frame_queries": 26794, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 551371, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.578151825035455, "pattern_frame_updates": 80600, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 726825684, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9017.688387096774, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12783, "avg_candidate_generations": 1597.875, "candidate_moves_total": 1111202, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.92810764296331, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 12775, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1110622, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 769879, "avg_legality_checks": 96234.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 78, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 769879, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 78, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1714618, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 214327.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3457633023, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2016.5617198699651, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25292, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3161.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46702069, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1846.515459433813, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 126, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 769202, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2406, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11963096, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22760, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 33969771, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 71684, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8960.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 690569659, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9633.525737961052, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92292, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11536.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 324427731, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3515.231341828111, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1785969104, "stage_ordering_ns": 425588408, "stage_eval_ns": 727377055, "stage_threat_ns": 2179916679, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 213924, "root_tactical_annotations": 1077, "search_tactical_annotations": 212847, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 80608, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 444848552, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 190064, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1664277017, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25601, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 841187137, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 56072186, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 80600, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9235670, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70845, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 432555918, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 93611, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 390392651, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49468, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5483254, "child_limit_applications": 12775, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12775, "child_cap_hits": 12775, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12775, "child_moves_before_total": 1110544, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1110544, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 204662, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 204662, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.93103718199609, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02050880626223, "tt_hits": 5722, "tt_cutoffs": 731, "beta_cutoffs": 11053, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 4.375, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 4.375, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3923.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4923.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1853, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1375, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17675, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 110, 158, 111, 113, 68, 124, 128, 144, 80, 64, 125, 140, 82, 54, 139, 97, 95, 65, 81, 143, 141, 145, 146, 174, 190, 129, 161, 159, 114, 189 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 8243, "avg_search_time_ms": 549.5333333333333, "search_nodes": 105896, "safety_nodes": 640, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 106536, "avg_nodes": 7102.4, "eval_calls": 71656, "avg_eval_calls": 4777.066666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71656, "pattern_eval_ns": 1399046, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.524478061851067, "pattern_frame_queries": 71656, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1399046, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.524478061851067, "pattern_frame_updates": 211652, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2104621248, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9943.781528168882, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32194, "avg_candidate_generations": 2146.266666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 2780434, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.3649748400323, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1203, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 32179, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2779231, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 764693, "avg_legality_checks": 50979.53333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2357, "root_legality_checks": 1203, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 763490, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2350, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2780493, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 185366.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4692147833, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1687.523699214492, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35450, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2363.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 211522997, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5966.798222849083, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2632, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 27853425, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15203, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 125906114, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17580, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 57364667, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 398791, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 80077, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5338.466666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 537164308, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6708.097306342645, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 106061, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7070.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 216391493, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2040.2550701954535, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1439404033, "stage_ordering_ns": 886479604, "stage_eval_ns": 2106020294, "stage_threat_ns": 3762290794, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 568069, "root_tactical_annotations": 3251, "search_tactical_annotations": 564818, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 211667, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 962444247, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 486358, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2636519062, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64458, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1817728096, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 105826, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 124867024, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 211652, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20850284, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 193977, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 183078607, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 227913, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 635620148, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 146179, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17610177, "child_limit_applications": 32179, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32179, "child_cap_hits": 32179, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32179, "child_moves_before_total": 2776881, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2776881, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 518694, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 518694, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.29481960284657, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.119021722241214, "tt_hits": 15973, "tt_cutoffs": 1991, "beta_cutoffs": 27571, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6143.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6676.933333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1073, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 9416, "avg_search_time_ms": 627.7333333333333, "search_nodes": 81531, "safety_nodes": 1984, "corridor_nodes": 1888, "corridor_branch_probes": 2158, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 34, "corridor_depth_exits": 888, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1869, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1869, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 35, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 16, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 38, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 888, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 35, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 33, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 97, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 16059560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2005520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 85403, "avg_nodes": 5693.533333333334, "eval_calls": 46505, "avg_eval_calls": 3100.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46505, "pattern_eval_ns": 922312, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.832534136114397, "pattern_frame_queries": 46505, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 922312, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.832534136114397, "pattern_frame_updates": 162888, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1353838998, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8311.471673788124, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30882, "avg_candidate_generations": 2058.8, "candidate_moves_total": 2678888, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.74593614403213, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1223, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 30867, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2677665, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1723474, "avg_legality_checks": 114898.26666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5799, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1723474, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5799, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3773556, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 251570.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6005856623, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1591.564196476745, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47660, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3177.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 183167113, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3843.2042173730592, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6140, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 61388559, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7738, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64947401, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 33732, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 56251581, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 579572, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 144051, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9603.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 966488411, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6709.3488486716515, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 194191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12946.066666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 390654981, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2011.7048730373704, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3160841305, "stage_ordering_ns": 811150918, "stage_eval_ns": 1354761310, "stage_threat_ns": 3984351297, "stage_proof_ns": 32038307, "tactical_annotations": 593911, "root_tactical_annotations": 647, "search_tactical_annotations": 593264, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 166711, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 817034983, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 565457, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3000800163, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62722, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1609780584, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 83348, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104613618, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3808, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22640045, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 166696, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16924741, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116058, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 341160492, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 290538, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 979564934, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 187315, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22337747, "child_limit_applications": 30867, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30867, "child_cap_hits": 30867, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30867, "child_moves_before_total": 2671866, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2671866, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 366833, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 366833, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.56059869763826, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.884310104642498, "tt_hits": 18011, "tt_cutoffs": 4072, "beta_cutoffs": 26031, "depth_sum": 86, "avg_depth": 5.733333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 86, "avg_effective_depth": 5.733333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5868.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6401.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1376, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26197, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 128, 110, 114, 156, 100, 86, 129, 125, 95, 82, 68, 124, 138, 64, 48, 140, 130, 127, 132, 131, 84, 116, 99, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18675, "avg_search_time_ms": 1436.5384615384614, "search_nodes": 152933, "safety_nodes": 787, "corridor_nodes": 2295, "corridor_branch_probes": 2727, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1017, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2276, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2276, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 43, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1017, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 43, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 43, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 299, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4257040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 156015, "avg_nodes": 12001.153846153846, "eval_calls": 93354, "avg_eval_calls": 7181.076923076923, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 93354, "pattern_eval_ns": 2007747, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.50681277717077, "pattern_frame_queries": 93354, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2007747, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.50681277717077, "pattern_frame_updates": 305714, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4288409305, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14027.520182261853, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 54518, "avg_candidate_generations": 4193.692307692308, "candidate_moves_total": 4907151, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.00973990241755, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1110, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 54505, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4906041, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 1381511, "avg_legality_checks": 106270.07692307692, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1290, "root_legality_checks": 1110, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1380401, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1290, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5067088, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 389776.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11287902981, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2227.690338316603, "renju_forbidden_checks": 50704, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3900.3076923076924, "renju_forbidden_ns": 324554278, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6400.960042600189, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1392, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13401946, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24551, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 211434317, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24369, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 95950802, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 392, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3767213, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 128067, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9851.307692307691, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1258366591, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9825.845776039105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 179618, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13816.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 591522300, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3293.22395305593, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3415961116, "stage_ordering_ns": 1945182709, "stage_eval_ns": 4290417052, "stage_threat_ns": 8630919187, "stage_proof_ns": 330073741, "tactical_annotations": 1022300, "root_tactical_annotations": 3208, "search_tactical_annotations": 1019092, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 310365, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1917924985, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 877419, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6355682435, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 110192, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4155283758, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 155176, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 237802452, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4638, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28697101, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 310352, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39613129, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 184390, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 272913601, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 452573, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1586803956, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 385337, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 51199085, "child_limit_applications": 54505, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 54505, "child_cap_hits": 54505, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 54505, "child_moves_before_total": 4904751, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4904751, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 589419, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 589419, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.9871754884873, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.81403540959545, "tt_hits": 32810, "tt_cutoffs": 5000, "beta_cutoffs": 44797, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1598.6923076923076, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2167.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7512, "avg_search_time_ms": 577.8461538461538, "search_nodes": 52839, "safety_nodes": 1563, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 54402, "avg_nodes": 4184.7692307692305, "eval_calls": 35520, "avg_eval_calls": 2732.3076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35520, "pattern_eval_ns": 754413, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.23910472972973, "pattern_frame_queries": 35520, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 754413, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.23910472972973, "pattern_frame_updates": 105564, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1099366671, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10414.219535068774, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16256, "avg_candidate_generations": 1250.4615384615386, "candidate_moves_total": 1459494, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.78186515748031, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1138, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 16243, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1458356, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1032883, "avg_legality_checks": 79452.53846153847, "illegal_moves_skipped": 102, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1032883, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 102, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2366249, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 182019.15384615384, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5054492676, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2136.078103361058, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7134, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 548.7692307692307, "renju_forbidden_ns": 25378600, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3557.415194841604, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 724972, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1966, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16879191, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5066, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7774437, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99494, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7653.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1062845873, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10682.512241944238, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 147726, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11363.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 519031765, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3513.47606379378, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2484404069, "stage_ordering_ns": 593722006, "stage_eval_ns": 1100121084, "stage_threat_ns": 3278348151, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 284546, "root_tactical_annotations": 1136, "search_tactical_annotations": 283410, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 105577, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 682271773, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 265408, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2500835979, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32568, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1195111173, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52782, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 76120529, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 105564, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12788632, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 81118, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 524994918, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 151712, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 780403328, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 51716, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6331238, "child_limit_applications": 16243, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16243, "child_cap_hits": 16243, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16243, "child_moves_before_total": 1458254, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1458254, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 260281, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 260281, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.7773810256726, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.024195037862462, "tt_hits": 6271, "tt_cutoffs": 1019, "beta_cutoffs": 13944, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5001.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5617.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1841, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1377, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24190, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 144, 96, 160, 176, 97, 110, 124, 114, 130, 66, 50, 81, 51, 80, 83, 52, 94, 125, 95, 126, 111, 78, 55, 79 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8268, "avg_search_time_ms": 689.0, "search_nodes": 89843, "safety_nodes": 1229, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91072, "avg_nodes": 7589.333333333333, "eval_calls": 68716, "avg_eval_calls": 5726.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68716, "pattern_eval_ns": 1487926, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.653268525525352, "pattern_frame_queries": 68716, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1487926, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.653268525525352, "pattern_frame_updates": 179574, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1637569633, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9119.191157962734, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19694, "avg_candidate_generations": 1641.1666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1601003, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.29394739514574, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 973, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 19682, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1600030, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 873833, "avg_legality_checks": 72819.41666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 181, "root_legality_checks": 973, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 872860, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 180, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2205418, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 183784.83333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5012918707, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2273.001629169618, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6201, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 516.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19399332, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3128.4199322689888, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 187, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1466569, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1650, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12211815, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4359, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5657658, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 63290, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67174, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5597.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 679316742, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10112.792776967279, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92595, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7716.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 320278789, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3458.9209892542794, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2226885327, "stage_ordering_ns": 697489326, "stage_eval_ns": 1639057559, "stage_threat_ns": 3655322675, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 253379, "root_tactical_annotations": 1094, "search_tactical_annotations": 252285, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 179586, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1059477967, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 258320, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2437320607, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 39444, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1512778992, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89787, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 131902002, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 179574, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22145644, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56667, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 168935369, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 162199, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 754686043, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 34513, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4476455, "child_limit_applications": 19682, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19682, "child_cap_hits": 19682, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19682, "child_moves_before_total": 1599850, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1599850, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 319567, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 319567, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.28493039325272, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.23651051722386, "tt_hits": 5277, "tt_cutoffs": 1390, "beta_cutoffs": 15211, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4213.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4879.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 15910, "avg_search_time_ms": 1325.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 126659, "safety_nodes": 266, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 3, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 3, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 3, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 3, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 1280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 126925, "avg_nodes": 10577.083333333334, "eval_calls": 91233, "avg_eval_calls": 7602.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 91233, "pattern_eval_ns": 2003695, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.96239299376322, "pattern_frame_queries": 91233, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2003695, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.96239299376322, "pattern_frame_updates": 253204, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2731976413, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10789.625807649169, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33313, "avg_candidate_generations": 2776.0833333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 3279927, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.45786930027316, "candidate_moves_max": 134, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1012, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 33301, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3278915, "search_candidate_moves_max": 134, "legality_checks": 2055732, "avg_legality_checks": 171311.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 832, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2055732, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 832, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4761183, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 396765.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10407428727, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2185.89134822165, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15612, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1301.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 49051441, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3141.906290033308, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1017, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9832228, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5060, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24130814, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9525, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14960869, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 127530, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 183923, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15326.916666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1959034355, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10651.383214714853, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 259383, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21615.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 972300410, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3748.51246997683, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5124495165, "stage_ordering_ns": 1328325519, "stage_eval_ns": 2733980108, "stage_threat_ns": 6633802746, "stage_proof_ns": 5604284, "tactical_annotations": 634140, "root_tactical_annotations": 3711, "search_tactical_annotations": 630429, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 253222, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1570829741, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 573439, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4816930854, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 66694, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2379869709, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 126605, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 196267790, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26550, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 253210, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32915604, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 209914, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1085873271, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 296815, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1351124493, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 127411, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16832207, "child_limit_applications": 33301, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33301, "child_cap_hits": 33301, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33301, "child_moves_before_total": 3278083, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3278083, "child_moves_before_max": 134, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 134, "child_moves_after_total": 405620, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 405620, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 98.43797483559052, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.180415002552476, "tt_hits": 14100, "tt_cutoffs": 2069, "beta_cutoffs": 23726, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3791.9166666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4458.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1706, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1378, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20842, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 114, 81, 79, 66, 113, 115, 142, 100, 127, 84, 83, 50, 34, 157, 111, 110, 95, 143, 63 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 15792, "avg_search_time_ms": 1435.6363636363637, "search_nodes": 132967, "safety_nodes": 336, "corridor_nodes": 2674, "corridor_branch_probes": 2951, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1058, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 2652, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2652, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1058, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 422, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4257200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 135977, "avg_nodes": 12361.545454545454, "eval_calls": 87195, "avg_eval_calls": 7926.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87195, "pattern_eval_ns": 1905084, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.848546361603304, "pattern_frame_queries": 87195, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1905084, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.848546361603304, "pattern_frame_updates": 265824, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3890039143, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14633.889878265318, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42545, "avg_candidate_generations": 3867.7272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 3454938, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.20667528499236, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 747, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 42534, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3454191, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1028657, "avg_legality_checks": 93514.27272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1176, "root_legality_checks": 747, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1027910, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1174, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4151548, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 377413.45454545453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9644381568, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2323.0808286451224, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42852, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3895.6363636363635, "renju_forbidden_ns": 299157151, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6981.1712638849995, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1411, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13863437, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24750, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 217424486, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15854, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 59509486, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 837, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8359742, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 107412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9764.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1035192927, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9637.591023349347, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 141994, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12908.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 442270623, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3114.7134597236504, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2635419698, "stage_ordering_ns": 1434491282, "stage_eval_ns": 3891944227, "stage_threat_ns": 7342895558, "stage_proof_ns": 441483675, "tactical_annotations": 695965, "root_tactical_annotations": 2500, "search_tactical_annotations": 693465, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 271249, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1730808198, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 707116, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5294879579, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 86692, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3433654503, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 135619, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 216744212, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5414, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 32371157, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 271238, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35461412, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 163487, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 317307150, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 290681, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1078707699, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 241797, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32631000, "child_limit_applications": 42534, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42534, "child_cap_hits": 42534, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42534, "child_moves_before_total": 3453017, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3453017, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 480614, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 480614, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.18251281327879, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.299525085813702, "tt_hits": 24363, "tt_cutoffs": 3183, "beta_cutoffs": 34173, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.45454545454545453, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1448.1818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2018.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 215, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5041, "avg_search_time_ms": 504.1, "search_nodes": 48338, "safety_nodes": 951, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49289, "avg_nodes": 4928.9, "eval_calls": 34922, "avg_eval_calls": 3492.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34922, "pattern_eval_ns": 765033, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.906906820915182, "pattern_frame_queries": 34922, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 765033, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.906906820915182, "pattern_frame_updates": 96586, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 882100348, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9132.7971755741, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12879, "avg_candidate_generations": 1287.9, "candidate_moves_total": 986666, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.61045112198153, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 681, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 12869, "search_candidate_moves_total": 985985, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 531310, "avg_legality_checks": 53131.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 267, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 531310, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 267, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1380192, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 138019.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3131680052, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2269.0176815979225, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5161, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 516.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 25115168, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4866.337531486146, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 355, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3814442, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1505, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14240928, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3291, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6941808, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 117990, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50458, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5045.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 512443049, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10155.83354473027, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 67729, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6772.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 230573096, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3404.348152194776, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1378380452, "stage_ordering_ns": 426316559, "stage_eval_ns": 882865381, "stage_threat_ns": 2318888623, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 191504, "root_tactical_annotations": 716, "search_tactical_annotations": 190788, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 96596, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 590708434, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 177638, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1638526847, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25803, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 968250485, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48293, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 72621508, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 96586, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12253993, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 46897, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 251472872, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 104930, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 418451129, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 39677, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4777841, "child_limit_applications": 12869, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12869, "child_cap_hits": 12869, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12869, "child_moves_before_total": 985718, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 985718, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 208998, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 208998, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.59631673012666, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.240422721268164, "tt_hits": 4578, "tt_cutoffs": 502, "beta_cutoffs": 10608, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4836.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5636.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1876, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1379, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12439, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 142, 98, 110, 158, 127, 157, 111, 109, 96, 113, 143, 83, 68, 159, 81, 66, 141 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6844, "avg_search_time_ms": 760.4444444444445, "search_nodes": 69144, "safety_nodes": 337, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 69481, "avg_nodes": 7720.111111111111, "eval_calls": 51248, "avg_eval_calls": 5694.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51248, "pattern_eval_ns": 1116450, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.78524039962535, "pattern_frame_queries": 51248, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1116450, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.78524039962535, "pattern_frame_updates": 138214, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1941373342, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14046.141071092654, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16958, "avg_candidate_generations": 1884.2222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 1175745, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.33276329755867, "candidate_moves_max": 93, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 544, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 16949, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1175201, "search_candidate_moves_max": 93, "legality_checks": 450301, "avg_legality_checks": 50033.444444444445, "illegal_moves_skipped": 919, "root_legality_checks": 544, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 449757, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 917, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1706926, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 189658.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4063509848, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2380.6010617917823, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18953, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2105.8888888888887, "renju_forbidden_ns": 117847870, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6217.900596211682, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 983, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8223968, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9145, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 84304603, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8811, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25298419, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 20880, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50311, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5590.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 487272498, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9685.20796644869, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 70169, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7796.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 207547773, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2957.8271458906356, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1195023091, "stage_ordering_ns": 539048704, "stage_eval_ns": 1942489792, "stage_threat_ns": 3143680951, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 255342, "root_tactical_annotations": 1388, "search_tactical_annotations": 253954, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 138223, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 873707900, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 228412, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2135675395, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33952, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1446938275, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 69107, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107610866, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 138214, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18378212, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62582, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 89600712, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 131872, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 598982557, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 60888, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8308578, "child_limit_applications": 16949, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16949, "child_cap_hits": 16949, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16949, "child_moves_before_total": 1174284, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1174284, "child_moves_before_max": 92, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 92, "child_moves_after_total": 271881, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 271881, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.28337955041596, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.04112337011033, "tt_hits": 7098, "tt_cutoffs": 910, "beta_cutoffs": 13611, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3322.222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4211.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 250, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5585, "avg_search_time_ms": 698.125, "search_nodes": 38135, "safety_nodes": 785, "corridor_nodes": 643, "corridor_branch_probes": 745, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 338, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 637, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 637, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 12, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 6, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 338, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 12, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 11, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 26, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2020160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 39563, "avg_nodes": 4945.375, "eval_calls": 22797, "avg_eval_calls": 2849.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22797, "pattern_eval_ns": 504892, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.147300083344298, "pattern_frame_queries": 22797, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 504892, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.147300083344298, "pattern_frame_updates": 76180, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 962366652, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12632.799317406143, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13950, "avg_candidate_generations": 1743.75, "candidate_moves_total": 985924, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.67555555555556, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 483, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 13942, "search_candidate_moves_total": 985441, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 582653, "avg_legality_checks": 72831.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1192, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 582653, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1192, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1588895, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 198611.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3592926257, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2261.2735624443403, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17127, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2140.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 76315925, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4455.883984352193, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1294, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12619170, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4273, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 42022779, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11547, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21657976, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 16000, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 62055, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7756.875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 619496334, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9983.020449601161, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86002, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10750.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 274353579, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3190.0837073556427, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1519332895, "stage_ordering_ns": 443851466, "stage_eval_ns": 962871544, "stage_threat_ns": 2615058923, "stage_proof_ns": 15800748, "tactical_annotations": 243666, "root_tactical_annotations": 428, "search_tactical_annotations": 243238, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 77486, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 509823590, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 246356, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2017780642, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28240, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1142957623, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38739, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 63465369, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1298, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7432755, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 77478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10444674, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 34824, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 143307256, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 152191, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 705915048, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 56651, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6111893, "child_limit_applications": 13942, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13942, "child_cap_hits": 13942, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13942, "child_moves_before_total": 984249, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 984249, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 153423, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 153423, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.5959690144886, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.004375268971453, "tt_hits": 5732, "tt_cutoffs": 1352, "beta_cutoffs": 11497, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3288.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4288.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1380, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19847, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 141, 129, 99, 100, 140, 154, 142, 86, 72, 143, 111, 156, 158, 110, 157, 127, 125, 131, 130, 173, 139, 138, 153, 97, 167 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 16021, "avg_search_time_ms": 1144.357142857143, "search_nodes": 167285, "safety_nodes": 614, "corridor_nodes": 577, "corridor_branch_probes": 697, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 232, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 571, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 571, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 28, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 22, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 232, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 28, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 27, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 165, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6082800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2022320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 168476, "avg_nodes": 12034.0, "eval_calls": 121912, "avg_eval_calls": 8708.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 121912, "pattern_eval_ns": 2613285, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.435830763173435, "pattern_frame_queries": 121912, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2613285, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.435830763173435, "pattern_frame_updates": 334442, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4909153525, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14678.639420288122, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42775, "avg_candidate_generations": 3055.3571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 3716523, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.88540035067213, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1053, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 42761, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3715470, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1233710, "avg_legality_checks": 88122.14285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6596, "root_legality_checks": 1053, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 1232657, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6591, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4647453, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 331960.9285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9458441286, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2035.1881527365636, "renju_forbidden_checks": 80214, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5729.571428571428, "renju_forbidden_ns": 526407504, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6562.5390081531905, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7309, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 72384312, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 46958, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 363697830, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25781, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 88739475, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 166, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1585887, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 129378, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9241.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1078412833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8335.36484564609, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 168066, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12004.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 457905878, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2724.5598633870027, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2848951257, "stage_ordering_ns": 1323913024, "stage_eval_ns": 4911766810, "stage_threat_ns": 6763002826, "stage_proof_ns": 116350787, "tactical_annotations": 846494, "root_tactical_annotations": 3024, "search_tactical_annotations": 843470, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 335654, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1863516626, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 709865, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4579085847, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 85956, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2924517313, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 167820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 239742219, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1198, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6442954, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 335640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39952114, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 221633, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 267771322, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 366718, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1297273926, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 258143, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 34263066, "child_limit_applications": 42761, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42761, "child_cap_hits": 42761, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42761, "child_moves_before_total": 3708879, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3708879, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 488410, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 488410, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.73508570894039, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.421856364444237, "tt_hits": 22003, "tt_cutoffs": 2548, "beta_cutoffs": 31751, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 4.571428571428571, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 4.571428571428571, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4661.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5232.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 256, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3811, "avg_search_time_ms": 293.15384615384613, "search_nodes": 32675, "safety_nodes": 1471, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34146, "avg_nodes": 2626.6153846153848, "eval_calls": 21993, "avg_eval_calls": 1691.7692307692307, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 21993, "pattern_eval_ns": 487035, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.145000682035192, "pattern_frame_queries": 21993, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 487035, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.145000682035192, "pattern_frame_updates": 65230, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 741896777, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11373.551694005826, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9901, "avg_candidate_generations": 761.6153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 768756, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.64427835572164, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 976, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 9888, "search_candidate_moves_total": 767780, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 409574, "avg_legality_checks": 31505.69230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2548, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 409574, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2548, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1102625, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 84817.30769230769, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2364377432, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2144.316909193969, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12319, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 947.6153846153846, "renju_forbidden_ns": 100772076, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8180.21560191574, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2579, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 31253141, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5099, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 52328774, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4611, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16802581, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 387580, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37185, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2860.3846153846152, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 380692487, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10237.797149388194, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50948, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3919.076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 185924448, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3649.2982648975426, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1028130899, "stage_ordering_ns": 308207203, "stage_eval_ns": 742383812, "stage_threat_ns": 1703242887, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 174800, "root_tactical_annotations": 661, "search_tactical_annotations": 174139, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 65243, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 397762010, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 159388, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1244957070, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19862, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 732683966, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 32615, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 48946888, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 65230, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8082926, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44979, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 169157942, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 94537, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 342781119, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 35284, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3493993, "child_limit_applications": 9888, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9888, "child_cap_hits": 9888, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9888, "child_moves_before_total": 765232, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 765232, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 159819, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 159819, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.38996763754045, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.162924757281555, "tt_hits": 4010, "tt_cutoffs": 734, "beta_cutoffs": 8457, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5943.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6558.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1866, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1381, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25924, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 82, 124, 126, 140, 127, 142, 84, 70, 67, 97, 114, 130, 66, 50, 99, 69, 141, 113, 65, 138, 152, 68, 129, 144, 125, 128, 109, 93, 95, 71, 72, 123, 81, 53, 83, 80, 85 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 14308, "avg_search_time_ms": 753.0526315789474, "search_nodes": 170670, "safety_nodes": 695, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 171365, "avg_nodes": 9019.21052631579, "eval_calls": 112726, "avg_eval_calls": 5932.9473684210525, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 112726, "pattern_eval_ns": 2304168, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.440430779057184, "pattern_frame_queries": 112726, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2304168, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.440430779057184, "pattern_frame_updates": 341166, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4036525314, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11831.557992297005, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 53591, "avg_candidate_generations": 2820.5789473684213, "candidate_moves_total": 4961337, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.57780224291392, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1585, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 53572, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4959752, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1225830, "avg_legality_checks": 64517.36842105263, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11310, "root_legality_checks": 1585, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "search_legality_checks": 1224245, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11297, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4674775, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 246040.7894736842, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7995766942, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1710.4067986159762, "renju_forbidden_checks": 94397, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4968.263157894737, "renju_forbidden_ns": 658193808, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6972.613621195589, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11669, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 94716651, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 48592, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 409584824, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 34067, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 153153819, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 69, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 738514, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 125038, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6580.9473684210525, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 960881659, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7684.717117996129, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 171047, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9002.473684210527, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 459241101, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2684.882523516928, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2340657619, "stage_ordering_ns": 1446671974, "stage_eval_ns": 4038829482, "stage_threat_ns": 6402855558, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1226208, "root_tactical_annotations": 5451, "search_tactical_annotations": 1220757, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 341185, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1611060511, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1051653, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4514556668, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 107268, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3016112766, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 170583, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 208732441, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 341166, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34861469, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 488680, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 409239956, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 455689, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1088875514, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 281839, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33644469, "child_limit_applications": 53572, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 53572, "child_cap_hits": 53572, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 53572, "child_moves_before_total": 4948455, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4948455, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 864191, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 864191, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 92.37017471813634, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.131393265138506, "tt_hits": 26949, "tt_cutoffs": 4285, "beta_cutoffs": 46283, "depth_sum": 87, "avg_depth": 4.578947368421052, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 87, "avg_effective_depth": 4.578947368421052, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6408.684210526316, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6829.736842105263, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 926, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 11597, "avg_search_time_ms": 644.2777777777778, "search_nodes": 106643, "safety_nodes": 2269, "corridor_nodes": 2370, "corridor_branch_probes": 2859, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 1019, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 36, "corridor_plies_followed": 2355, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2355, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 40, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 25, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1019, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 40, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 94, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 22139200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2011200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 111282, "avg_nodes": 6182.333333333333, "eval_calls": 61402, "avg_eval_calls": 3411.222222222222, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 61402, "pattern_eval_ns": 1258367, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.493908993192406, "pattern_frame_queries": 61402, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1258367, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.493908993192406, "pattern_frame_updates": 213060, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2012585576, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9446.097700178354, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38912, "avg_candidate_generations": 2161.777777777778, "candidate_moves_total": 3483583, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.52464535361842, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1502, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 38894, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3482081, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1925272, "avg_legality_checks": 106959.55555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15561, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1925272, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15561, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4517530, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 250973.88888888888, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7004899195, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1550.603802299044, "renju_forbidden_checks": 73701, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4094.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 393429616, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5338.1855877125145, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16054, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 130516296, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21658, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 160402712, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 35809, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 100592201, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 180, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1918407, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 152602, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8477.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1104788566, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7239.67291385434, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 209091, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11616.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 523863203, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2505.431620681904, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3433131811, "stage_ordering_ns": 985202455, "stage_eval_ns": 2013843943, "stage_threat_ns": 5040660464, "stage_proof_ns": 36851278, "tactical_annotations": 893033, "root_tactical_annotations": 651, "search_tactical_annotations": 892382, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 217868, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1054031226, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 896634, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3780210567, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 79009, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2017738173, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108925, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 134899265, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4790, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28445382, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 217850, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21900145, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 187089, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 329524028, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 500397, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1345166644, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 205547, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21173879, "child_limit_applications": 38894, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38894, "child_cap_hits": 38894, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38894, "child_moves_before_total": 3466520, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3466520, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 456453, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 456453, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.12737183113076, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.73582043502854, "tt_hits": 21219, "tt_cutoffs": 6235, "beta_cutoffs": 32670, "depth_sum": 112, "avg_depth": 6.222222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 112, "avg_effective_depth": 6.222222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6037.277777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6481.722222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1382, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16587, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 126, 82, 94, 142, 78, 62, 141, 81, 83, 114, 111, 156, 128, 130, 66, 146 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 11301, "avg_search_time_ms": 1255.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 99165, "safety_nodes": 517, "corridor_nodes": 1968, "corridor_branch_probes": 2129, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 838, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1957, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1957, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 16, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 5, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 838, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 16, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 49, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 7, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4094240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 101650, "avg_nodes": 11294.444444444445, "eval_calls": 64259, "avg_eval_calls": 7139.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64259, "pattern_eval_ns": 1330267, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.701644905771953, "pattern_frame_queries": 64259, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1330267, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.701644905771953, "pattern_frame_updates": 198240, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2454252608, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12380.208878127522, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32303, "avg_candidate_generations": 3589.222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 2645152, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.88564529610252, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 639, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 32294, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2644513, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 915062, "avg_legality_checks": 101673.55555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1286, "root_legality_checks": 639, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 914423, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3215772, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 357308.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6933664142, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2156.1429547865955, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44607, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4956.333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 153740396, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3446.553141883561, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14252023, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16565, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 82921933, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25862, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 53502261, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 466, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3064179, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 88334, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9814.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 797406832, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9027.179025063962, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 114651, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12739.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 347141922, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3027.814166470419, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2217665223, "stage_ordering_ns": 1066338023, "stage_eval_ns": 2455582875, "stage_threat_ns": 5272137552, "stage_proof_ns": 246895617, "tactical_annotations": 485006, "root_tactical_annotations": 1469, "search_tactical_annotations": 483537, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 202195, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1208681003, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 494889, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3843468631, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 65671, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2443109450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 101093, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 150554604, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3946, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21337592, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 202186, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25016272, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70720, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 137245605, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 242527, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 951423945, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 171759, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23079450, "child_limit_applications": 32294, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32294, "child_cap_hits": 32294, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32294, "child_moves_before_total": 2643227, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2643227, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 333695, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 333695, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.8488573728866, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.333034000123861, "tt_hits": 17495, "tt_cutoffs": 2568, "beta_cutoffs": 25577, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 4.888888888888889, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 4.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1726.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2475.222222222222, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5277, "avg_search_time_ms": 659.625, "search_nodes": 39773, "safety_nodes": 660, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40433, "avg_nodes": 5054.125, "eval_calls": 26305, "avg_eval_calls": 3288.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 26305, "pattern_eval_ns": 551532, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.966812393081163, "pattern_frame_queries": 26305, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 551532, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.966812393081163, "pattern_frame_updates": 79476, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 741371631, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9328.245394836176, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12709, "avg_candidate_generations": 1588.625, "candidate_moves_total": 1103026, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.79093555747895, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 12701, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1102446, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 768168, "avg_legality_checks": 96021.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 79, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 768168, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 79, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1705001, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 213125.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3539781812, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2076.117147145368, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25230, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3153.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 49525109, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1962.945263575109, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 126, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1033873, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2327, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13514932, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22777, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 34976304, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72054, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9006.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 704517410, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9777.630804674272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92665, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11583.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 326455315, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3522.9624453677225, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1822786672, "stage_ordering_ns": 438708560, "stage_eval_ns": 741923163, "stage_threat_ns": 2235552844, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 213611, "root_tactical_annotations": 1077, "search_tactical_annotations": 212534, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 79484, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 457099831, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 189381, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1707266011, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25453, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 863808256, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 39738, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 55869996, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 79476, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9510886, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70412, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 436994205, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 93509, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 406274829, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49690, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5806120, "child_limit_applications": 12701, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12701, "child_cap_hits": 12701, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12701, "child_moves_before_total": 1102367, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1102367, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 203505, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 203505, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.79371703015511, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.022754113849302, "tt_hits": 5681, "tt_cutoffs": 732, "beta_cutoffs": 11010, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 4.375, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 4.375, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3926.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4926.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1846, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1383, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19875, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 99, 113, 144, 68, 172, 157, 128, 83, 53, 96, 160, 176, 124, 125, 139, 95, 94, 80, 140, 65 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8159, "avg_search_time_ms": 741.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 89998, "safety_nodes": 1019, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91017, "avg_nodes": 8274.272727272728, "eval_calls": 70591, "avg_eval_calls": 6417.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70591, "pattern_eval_ns": 1442876, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.439942768908217, "pattern_frame_queries": 70591, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1442876, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.439942768908217, "pattern_frame_updates": 179894, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1964142012, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10918.329749741515, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18391, "avg_candidate_generations": 1671.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 1366735, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.3154260235985, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 813, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 18380, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1365922, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 779021, "avg_legality_checks": 70820.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7267, "root_legality_checks": 813, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "search_legality_checks": 778208, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7246, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2244952, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 204086.54545454544, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4816552163, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2145.50340630891, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34066, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3096.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 249181942, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7314.681559326014, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7987, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 83421702, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12016, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 116631839, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13958, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 47964194, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 105, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1164207, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 78585, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7144.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 766053157, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9748.083692816695, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 108413, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9855.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 358509012, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3306.8821266822247, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1982150878, "stage_ordering_ns": 579015171, "stage_eval_ns": 1965584888, "stage_threat_ns": 3588740824, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 232764, "root_tactical_annotations": 843, "search_tactical_annotations": 231921, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 179905, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1035544969, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 236879, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2402803044, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36833, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1408498102, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89947, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125113036, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 179894, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21872002, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 46458, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 138752769, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 153580, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 854917551, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 32726, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3407773, "child_limit_applications": 18380, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18380, "child_cap_hits": 18380, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18380, "child_moves_before_total": 1358676, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1358676, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 296041, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 296041, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.92143634385201, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.106692056583242, "tt_hits": 5238, "tt_cutoffs": 976, "beta_cutoffs": 13757, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 4.636363636363637, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 4.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4240.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4967.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 665, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11705, "avg_search_time_ms": 1064.090909090909, "search_nodes": 98098, "safety_nodes": 836, "corridor_nodes": 615, "corridor_branch_probes": 730, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 7, "corridor_depth_exits": 285, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 610, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 610, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 39, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 285, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 39, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 282, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2369440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1975040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 99549, "avg_nodes": 9049.90909090909, "eval_calls": 67420, "avg_eval_calls": 6129.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67420, "pattern_eval_ns": 1392073, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.647775140907743, "pattern_frame_queries": 67420, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1392073, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.647775140907743, "pattern_frame_updates": 196086, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2445489056, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12471.51278520649, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27979, "avg_candidate_generations": 2543.5454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 2288902, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.80785589191893, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 851, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 27968, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2288051, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1371910, "avg_legality_checks": 124719.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21896, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1371910, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 21896, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3431672, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 311970.1818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7086990091, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2065.1711734105124, "renju_forbidden_checks": 102346, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9304.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 714635867, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6982.548091767143, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22648, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 219731744, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 44000, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 363066505, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 35540, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 130115052, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 158, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1722566, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99143, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9013.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 998761145, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10073.945160021383, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 136213, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12383.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 494976672, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3633.843113359224, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3433725595, "stage_ordering_ns": 895149363, "stage_eval_ns": 2446881129, "stage_threat_ns": 4805219296, "stage_proof_ns": 62678461, "tactical_annotations": 498151, "root_tactical_annotations": 1801, "search_tactical_annotations": 496350, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 197395, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1126131814, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 447245, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3493633539, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56391, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2119663835, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 98692, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 137925173, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1298, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7019591, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 197384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23545091, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 117493, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 415810094, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 240216, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 930908351, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 140442, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16964088, "child_limit_applications": 27968, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27968, "child_cap_hits": 27968, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27968, "child_moves_before_total": 2266155, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2266155, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 314682, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 314682, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.02670909610984, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.25150171624714, "tt_hits": 15178, "tt_cutoffs": 2655, "beta_cutoffs": 21906, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3913.5454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4640.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 398, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1384, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 77663, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 128, 113, 155, 99, 85, 114, 115, 129, 144, 145, 125, 140, 139, 111, 171, 187, 70, 100, 84, 173, 159, 126, 81, 95, 56, 42, 107, 123, 79, 156, 141, 124, 172, 168, 154, 138, 153, 161, 177, 151, 167, 181, 86, 83, 87, 88, 101, 92, 108, 93, 94, 71, 80, 109, 137, 77, 122, 136, 66 ], "move_count": 66, "black_stats": { "move_count": 33, "search_move_count": 31, "total_time_ms": 50635, "avg_search_time_ms": 1633.3870967741937, "search_nodes": 470367, "safety_nodes": 2767, "corridor_nodes": 9510, "corridor_branch_probes": 10278, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3678, "corridor_neutral_exits": 263, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 9427, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9427, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 22, "corridor_proof_completed": 22, "corridor_proof_checks": 222, "corridor_proof_active": 83, "corridor_proof_quiet": 139, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 263, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3678, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 222, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 222, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1610, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 11165920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1991040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 482644, "avg_nodes": 15569.161290322581, "eval_calls": 281434, "avg_eval_calls": 9078.516129032258, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 281434, "pattern_eval_ns": 5767873, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.494584876027773, "pattern_frame_queries": 281434, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5767873, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.494584876027773, "pattern_frame_updates": 940338, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 9062970516, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9637.992419746943, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 174486, "avg_candidate_generations": 5628.580645161291, "candidate_moves_total": 18459098, "avg_candidate_moves": 105.79128411448482, "candidate_moves_max": 151, "root_candidate_generations": 31, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3088, "root_candidate_moves_max": 135, "search_candidate_generations": 174455, "search_candidate_moves_total": 18456010, "search_candidate_moves_max": 151, "legality_checks": 6211392, "avg_legality_checks": 200367.48387096773, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5867, "root_legality_checks": 3088, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 6208304, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5865, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16123399, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 520109.6451612903, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29612512051, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1836.617207761217, "renju_forbidden_checks": 282563, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9114.935483870968, "renju_forbidden_ns": 690800174, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2444.76514617979, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 32912, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 120542971, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 81635, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 270191348, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 146631, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 257050078, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 21385, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 43015777, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 372824, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12026.58064516129, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2508255535, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6727.720144089436, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 461990, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14902.90322580645, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 901969971, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1952.358213381242, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12280118006, "stage_ordering_ns": 5847989059, "stage_eval_ns": 9068738389, "stage_threat_ns": 21933717460, "stage_proof_ns": 1250549254, "tactical_annotations": 4678014, "root_tactical_annotations": 9577, "search_tactical_annotations": 4668437, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 959667, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5112704972, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 4373552, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 15729016955, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 355040, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9715739563, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 479818, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 676636967, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 19298, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 143407525, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 959636, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 110561176, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1595477, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 941129573, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1877737, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3906027282, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1204800, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 161389865, "child_limit_applications": 174455, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 174455, "child_cap_hits": 174455, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 174455, "child_moves_before_total": 18450145, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 18450145, "child_moves_before_max": 151, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 151, "child_moves_after_total": 1783627, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1783627, "child_moves_after_max": 35, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 35, "avg_child_moves_before": 105.75876300478633, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.223994726433752, "tt_hits": 93150, "tt_cutoffs": 14280, "beta_cutoffs": 141980, "depth_sum": 196, "avg_depth": 6.32258064516129, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 196, "avg_effective_depth": 6.32258064516129, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06451612903225806, "pooled_budget_moves": 31, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3870967741935484, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06451612903225806, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3106.2580645161293, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3364.3225806451615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 33, "search_move_count": 31, "total_time_ms": 26995, "avg_search_time_ms": 870.8064516129032, "search_nodes": 227413, "safety_nodes": 2780, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 230193, "avg_nodes": 7425.580645161291, "eval_calls": 149640, "avg_eval_calls": 4827.096774193548, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 149640, "pattern_eval_ns": 3101458, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.72612937717188, "pattern_frame_queries": 149640, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3101458, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.72612937717188, "pattern_frame_updates": 454528, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3382325778, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7441.40246145452, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 72907, "avg_candidate_generations": 2351.8387096774195, "candidate_moves_total": 7902339, "avg_candidate_moves": 108.38930418204014, "candidate_moves_max": 154, "root_candidate_generations": 31, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3115, "root_candidate_moves_max": 134, "search_candidate_generations": 72876, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7899224, "search_candidate_moves_max": 154, "legality_checks": 5766457, "avg_legality_checks": 186014.74193548388, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7456, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5766457, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7456, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9930745, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 320346.6129032258, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17680927724, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1780.4230925272977, "renju_forbidden_checks": 126585, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4083.3870967741937, "renju_forbidden_ns": 336129142, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2655.363131492673, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 27589, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 129234787, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19856, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 83033601, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 78989, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 123376193, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 151, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 484561, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 305250, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9846.774193548386, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2220413705, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7274.082571662571, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 382577, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12341.193548387097, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 893631774, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2335.8220018453803, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11251525960, "stage_ordering_ns": 2421808765, "stage_eval_ns": 3385427236, "stage_threat_ns": 9717024832, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1810153, "root_tactical_annotations": 6401, "search_tactical_annotations": 1803752, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 454559, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2343845377, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1620661, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6959223944, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 145962, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3854077282, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 227264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 316312135, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 454528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51925843, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 834931, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1432414424, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 639744, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1672183374, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 335478, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 45717533, "child_limit_applications": 72876, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 72876, "child_cap_hits": 72876, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 72876, "child_moves_before_total": 7891768, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7891768, "child_moves_before_max": 154, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 154, "child_moves_after_total": 1191268, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1191268, "child_moves_after_max": 32, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 32, "avg_child_moves_before": 108.29035622152698, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.346506394423404, "tt_hits": 33022, "tt_cutoffs": 4748, "beta_cutoffs": 63725, "depth_sum": 149, "avg_depth": 4.806451612903226, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 149, "avg_effective_depth": 4.806451612903226, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 29 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 31, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16129032258064516, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6859.387096774193, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7117.451612903225, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1935, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1385, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16505, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 113, 114, 126, 98, 66, 110, 96, 81, 156, 141, 80, 100, 86, 99, 64, 48, 101, 84, 69, 129, 144, 130, 146, 131, 132, 127 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 5083, "avg_search_time_ms": 391.0, "search_nodes": 95523, "safety_nodes": 1033, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 96556, "avg_nodes": 7427.384615384615, "eval_calls": 70768, "avg_eval_calls": 5443.692307692308, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70768, "pattern_eval_ns": 1378028, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.472473434320598, "pattern_frame_queries": 70768, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1378028, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.472473434320598, "pattern_frame_updates": 190926, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1188460183, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6224.716293223552, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23508, "avg_candidate_generations": 1808.3076923076924, "candidate_moves_total": 1802896, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.69287051216607, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 943, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 23495, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1801953, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 755858, "avg_legality_checks": 58142.92307692308, "illegal_moves_skipped": 94, "root_legality_checks": 943, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 754915, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 94, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2195853, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 168911.76923076922, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2884738057, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1313.7209353267272, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13747, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1057.4615384615386, "renju_forbidden_ns": 23594385, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1716.3297446715646, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 208, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 482221, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3540, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14068684, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9999, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9043480, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 56435, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4341.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 322162749, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5708.562930805351, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76903, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5915.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 151523186, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1970.3156703899717, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1111691530, "stage_ordering_ns": 454568688, "stage_eval_ns": 1189838211, "stage_threat_ns": 2275649792, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 280917, "root_tactical_annotations": 1496, "search_tactical_annotations": 279421, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 190939, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 681021335, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 271078, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1481048303, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47076, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1011169535, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 95463, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92887651, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 190926, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15529578, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62099, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 56773575, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 161893, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 412700341, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 56925, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5162925, "child_limit_applications": 23495, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23495, "child_cap_hits": 23495, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23495, "child_moves_before_total": 1801859, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1801859, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 376413, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 376413, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.69116833368801, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02098318791232, "tt_hits": 8412, "tt_cutoffs": 1200, "beta_cutoffs": 18884, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5845.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6460.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1357, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 11409, "avg_search_time_ms": 877.6153846153846, "search_nodes": 131870, "safety_nodes": 398, "corridor_nodes": 669, "corridor_branch_probes": 828, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 8, "corridor_depth_exits": 247, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 656, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 656, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 55, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 247, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 68, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 549, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 79390480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1992320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 132937, "avg_nodes": 10225.923076923076, "eval_calls": 83795, "avg_eval_calls": 6445.7692307692305, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83795, "pattern_eval_ns": 1634599, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.507118563160095, "pattern_frame_queries": 83795, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1634599, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.507118563160095, "pattern_frame_updates": 263604, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1553889807, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5894.788421268266, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44777, "avg_candidate_generations": 3444.3846153846152, "candidate_moves_total": 4020322, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.78542555329746, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 982, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 44764, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4019340, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 2876313, "avg_legality_checks": 221254.84615384616, "illegal_moves_skipped": 75, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2876313, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6052243, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 465557.1538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7288356682, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1204.2405901415393, "renju_forbidden_checks": 91530, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7040.7692307692305, "renju_forbidden_ns": 87386510, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 954.7307986452529, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1533, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2438593, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4340, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12429948, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 85657, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 72517969, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 224563, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17274.076923076922, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1279911721, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5699.566362223519, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 314804, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 24215.69230769231, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 640622726, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2034.9891551568594, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4041156070, "stage_ordering_ns": 969770118, "stage_eval_ns": 1555524406, "stage_threat_ns": 4658947673, "stage_proof_ns": 65286286, "tactical_annotations": 730009, "root_tactical_annotations": 3369, "search_tactical_annotations": 726640, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 265065, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 990050836, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 687495, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3491472869, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90171, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1806291411, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 132526, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 132482356, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1448, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5056869, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 265052, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22274046, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 155200, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 428034393, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 399451, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1237590249, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 175358, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17610697, "child_limit_applications": 44764, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44764, "child_cap_hits": 44764, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44764, "child_moves_before_total": 4019265, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4019265, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 477318, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 477318, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.78788758824055, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.662988115449915, "tt_hits": 22336, "tt_cutoffs": 3243, "beta_cutoffs": 35249, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 5.153846153846154, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 5.153846153846154, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5566.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6181.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1773, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1386, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 45151, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 126, 127, 79, 143, 159, 142, 157, 141, 140, 155, 81, 80, 65, 97, 93, 107, 158, 160, 67, 123, 139, 99, 100, 83, 69, 145, 144, 130, 51, 37, 66, 68, 36, 96, 21 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 31693, "avg_search_time_ms": 1668.0526315789473, "search_nodes": 314511, "safety_nodes": 900, "corridor_nodes": 7702, "corridor_branch_probes": 8192, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3272, "corridor_neutral_exits": 161, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 7650, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 7650, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 153, "corridor_proof_active": 52, "corridor_proof_quiet": 101, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 161, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3272, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 153, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 153, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1142, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 998200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 30720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 323113, "avg_nodes": 17005.947368421053, "eval_calls": 191970, "avg_eval_calls": 10103.684210526315, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 191970, "pattern_eval_ns": 4020768, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.944772620721988, "pattern_frame_queries": 191970, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4020768, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.944772620721988, "pattern_frame_updates": 628798, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5992405622, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9529.937471175163, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 113814, "avg_candidate_generations": 5990.210526315789, "candidate_moves_total": 10411239, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.4759080605198, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1482, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 113795, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10409757, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 3147024, "avg_legality_checks": 165632.84210526315, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3516, "root_legality_checks": 1482, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 3145542, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3514, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10115879, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 532414.6842105263, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18397524075, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1818.6777515824378, "renju_forbidden_checks": 255442, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 13444.315789473685, "renju_forbidden_ns": 662508358, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2593.5764596268427, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 36436, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 127196035, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 64371, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 231156632, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 136313, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 264130748, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18322, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 40024943, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 259767, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13671.947368421053, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1902532641, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7323.996662393606, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 325917, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17153.526315789473, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 689572647, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2115.7922016955235, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6515969476, "stage_ordering_ns": 3435998122, "stage_eval_ns": 5996426390, "stage_threat_ns": 14601318958, "stage_proof_ns": 984458198, "tactical_annotations": 2256067, "root_tactical_annotations": 5876, "search_tactical_annotations": 2250191, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 644423, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3371019422, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2149021, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10500791570, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 232214, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6509964577, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 322202, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 435260578, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 15606, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 119273391, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 644404, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 72142164, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 603704, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 643998292, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 889767, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2301855399, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 762596, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 102831833, "child_limit_applications": 113795, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 113795, "child_cap_hits": 113795, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 113795, "child_moves_before_total": 10406243, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10406243, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 1160366, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1160366, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.44727799991212, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.196985807812293, "tt_hits": 64848, "tt_cutoffs": 8634, "beta_cutoffs": 91359, "depth_sum": 112, "avg_depth": 5.894736842105263, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 112, "avg_effective_depth": 5.894736842105263, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3684210526315789, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3878.7368421052633, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4216.1578947368425, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 498, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 13437, "avg_search_time_ms": 707.2105263157895, "search_nodes": 118075, "safety_nodes": 1815, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 119890, "avg_nodes": 6310.0, "eval_calls": 77994, "avg_eval_calls": 4104.9473684210525, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77994, "pattern_eval_ns": 1681199, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.555491448060106, "pattern_frame_queries": 77994, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1681199, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.555491448060106, "pattern_frame_updates": 235976, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1890171380, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8010.0153405431065, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37707, "avg_candidate_generations": 1984.578947368421, "candidate_moves_total": 3268331, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.67703609409394, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1503, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 37688, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3266828, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 2136689, "avg_legality_checks": 112457.31578947368, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6516, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2136689, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6516, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4616035, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 242949.2105263158, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8494319102, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1840.1764938957351, "renju_forbidden_checks": 109233, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5749.105263157895, "renju_forbidden_ns": 328583531, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3008.097653639468, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25174, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 122366430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20264, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 86621431, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 63645, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 119068426, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 150, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 527244, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 188192, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9904.842105263158, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1554048148, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8257.780075667404, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 246428, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12969.894736842105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 653406977, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2651.5127217686304, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4655527315, "stage_ordering_ns": 1161371241, "stage_eval_ns": 1891852579, "stage_threat_ns": 5626179357, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 670321, "root_tactical_annotations": 2614, "search_tactical_annotations": 667707, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 235995, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1233030335, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 622882, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4191734277, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75500, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2183682632, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 117988, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159041740, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 235976, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26579396, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 227217, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 896991497, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 320148, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1110586597, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 122956, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15793609, "child_limit_applications": 37688, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37688, "child_cap_hits": 37688, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37688, "child_moves_before_total": 3260312, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3260312, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 603752, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 603752, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.50796009339842, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.019741031628104, "tt_hits": 14485, "tt_cutoffs": 2306, "beta_cutoffs": 32620, "depth_sum": 87, "avg_depth": 4.578947368421052, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 87, "avg_effective_depth": 4.578947368421052, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6569.9473684210525, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6991.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1928, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1387, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19111, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 67, 82, 98, 96, 68, 111, 141, 66, 81, 110, 83, 124, 138, 113, 53, 38, 39, 95, 25 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8699, "avg_search_time_ms": 869.9, "search_nodes": 100888, "safety_nodes": 314, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 101202, "avg_nodes": 10120.2, "eval_calls": 78824, "avg_eval_calls": 7882.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 78824, "pattern_eval_ns": 1726670, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.905384146960316, "pattern_frame_queries": 78824, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1726670, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.905384146960316, "pattern_frame_updates": 201692, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2508852590, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12439.028766634274, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20800, "avg_candidate_generations": 2080.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1494087, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.83110576923077, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 626, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 20790, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1493461, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 692758, "avg_legality_checks": 69275.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1606, "root_legality_checks": 626, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 692132, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1604, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2282930, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 228293.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5187218197, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2272.1757552793997, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20625, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2062.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 105798978, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5129.6474181818185, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1676, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16069738, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9749, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 65631153, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9190, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23981627, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 116460, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58849, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5884.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 543817038, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9240.888341348196, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84137, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8413.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 239405967, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2845.4302744333645, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1783045322, "stage_ordering_ns": 647263082, "stage_eval_ns": 2510579260, "stage_threat_ns": 3715712454, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 268105, "root_tactical_annotations": 1515, "search_tactical_annotations": 266590, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 201702, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1206507492, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 255361, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2328970183, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41641, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1548917722, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 100846, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 147555508, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 201692, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25382638, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56403, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 83656587, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 157310, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 696268414, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 54392, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7296633, "child_limit_applications": 20790, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20790, "child_cap_hits": 20790, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20790, "child_moves_before_total": 1491857, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1491857, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 332985, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 332985, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.75839345839346, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.016594516594516, "tt_hits": 7090, "tt_cutoffs": 1233, "beta_cutoffs": 15776, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 4.1, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 4.1, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3587.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4387.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10403, "avg_search_time_ms": 1155.888888888889, "search_nodes": 71288, "safety_nodes": 525, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 19, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 19, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 19, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 142, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 20274640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2022000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 71813, "avg_nodes": 7979.222222222223, "eval_calls": 39350, "avg_eval_calls": 4372.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39350, "pattern_eval_ns": 875603, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.251664548919948, "pattern_frame_queries": 39350, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 875603, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.251664548919948, "pattern_frame_updates": 142484, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1324656483, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9296.878828500043, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28958, "avg_candidate_generations": 3217.5555555555557, "candidate_moves_total": 2147400, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.15567373437392, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 569, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 28949, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2146831, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 1638390, "avg_legality_checks": 182043.33333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6995, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1638390, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6995, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3276240, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 364026.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6962046627, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2125.0111795839134, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34838, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3870.8888888888887, "renju_forbidden_ns": 171843111, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4932.634221252655, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7001, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 69718107, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6957, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 65351749, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20870, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36656975, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 116280, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 92112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10234.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 845291042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9176.774383359389, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 130014, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14446.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 392749869, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3020.8275185749226, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3993304418, "stage_ordering_ns": 875372895, "stage_eval_ns": 1325532086, "stage_threat_ns": 4100037136, "stage_proof_ns": 35272905, "tactical_annotations": 464068, "root_tactical_annotations": 1460, "search_tactical_annotations": 462608, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 142531, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 858083492, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 365152, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3094534991, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58038, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1942948011, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 71261, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 106755791, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 38, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 131251, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 142522, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17813683, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 97417, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 190367209, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 209652, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 961059620, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 156999, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22717928, "child_limit_applications": 28949, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28949, "child_cap_hits": 28949, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28949, "child_moves_before_total": 2139836, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2139836, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 246471, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 246471, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.91744101696086, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.513972848803068, "tt_hits": 16938, "tt_cutoffs": 2945, "beta_cutoffs": 23462, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 4.888888888888889, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 4.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1690.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2538.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1388, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22531, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 96, 98, 82, 127, 128, 144, 110, 124, 80, 64, 125, 95, 79, 81, 67, 52, 69, 68, 111, 83, 109, 113, 108 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 17443, "avg_search_time_ms": 1453.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 161110, "safety_nodes": 223, "corridor_nodes": 2048, "corridor_branch_probes": 2242, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 912, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2040, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2040, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 1, "corridor_proof_completed": 1, "corridor_proof_checks": 16, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 8, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 912, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 16, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 136, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23617120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1969840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 163381, "avg_nodes": 13615.083333333334, "eval_calls": 105427, "avg_eval_calls": 8785.583333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105427, "pattern_eval_ns": 2291623, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.736585504661992, "pattern_frame_queries": 105427, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2291623, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.736585504661992, "pattern_frame_updates": 322108, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4415990213, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13709.65704980938, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52476, "avg_candidate_generations": 4373.0, "candidate_moves_total": 4153783, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.1558617272658, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 776, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 52464, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4153007, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1182577, "avg_legality_checks": 98548.08333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4654, "root_legality_checks": 776, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 1181801, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4650, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4616159, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 384679.9166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10347841536, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2241.6562202471796, "renju_forbidden_checks": 59872, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4989.333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 317224486, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5298.377973009086, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5314, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53262896, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27594, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 178177195, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26374, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 79794689, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 590, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5989706, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 100574, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8381.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 911490491, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9062.883956092031, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 135198, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11266.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 385358361, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2850.325899791417, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2999338900, "stage_ordering_ns": 1727611208, "stage_eval_ns": 4418281836, "stage_threat_ns": 7980117783, "stage_proof_ns": 261479756, "tactical_annotations": 746652, "root_tactical_annotations": 3328, "search_tactical_annotations": 743324, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 326232, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2026265790, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 747628, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5598176430, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 106041, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3874373490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 163110, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 254005899, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4112, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25720227, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 326220, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42574875, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 147420, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 160769640, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 377592, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1254964500, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 221640, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33374562, "child_limit_applications": 52464, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52464, "child_cap_hits": 52464, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52464, "child_moves_before_total": 4148357, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4148357, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 459597, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 459597, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.07054361085697, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.760235590118938, "tt_hits": 24802, "tt_cutoffs": 3165, "beta_cutoffs": 40153, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 4.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 4.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2710.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3262.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5077, "avg_search_time_ms": 461.54545454545456, "search_nodes": 47187, "safety_nodes": 879, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 48066, "avg_nodes": 4369.636363636364, "eval_calls": 33401, "avg_eval_calls": 3036.4545454545455, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33401, "pattern_eval_ns": 723966, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.67497979102422, "pattern_frame_queries": 33401, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 723966, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.67497979102422, "pattern_frame_updates": 94274, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 953242860, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10111.407811273522, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12940, "avg_candidate_generations": 1176.3636363636363, "candidate_moves_total": 973278, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.21468315301391, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 715, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 12929, "search_candidate_moves_total": 972563, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 569887, "avg_legality_checks": 51807.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 740, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 569887, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 740, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1496869, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 136079.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3197043623, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2135.820584834077, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19776, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1797.8181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 58178078, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2941.852649676375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 756, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8536563, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2403, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21009320, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16597, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28367875, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 264320, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 57179, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5198.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 545138572, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9533.894821525386, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84352, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7668.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 244605325, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2899.81654258346, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1405678797, "stage_ordering_ns": 404377249, "stage_eval_ns": 953966826, "stage_threat_ns": 2275985753, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 190847, "root_tactical_annotations": 701, "search_tactical_annotations": 190146, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 94285, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 572383449, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 184157, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1617622362, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25930, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 916831982, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47137, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 70001340, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 94274, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11846674, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 54634, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 203426362, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 103586, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 497176547, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 32627, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4131928, "child_limit_applications": 12929, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12929, "child_cap_hits": 12929, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12929, "child_moves_before_total": 971823, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 971823, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 206890, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 206890, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.16613813906721, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002010983061336, "tt_hits": 4011, "tt_cutoffs": 807, "beta_cutoffs": 10747, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5289.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6016.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1389, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23012, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 82, 124, 114, 98, 84, 125, 127, 153, 139, 140, 154, 156, 108, 157, 54, 68, 69, 99, 24, 39, 83, 141, 171, 109, 93, 173 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 9987, "avg_search_time_ms": 665.8, "search_nodes": 107667, "safety_nodes": 793, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 108460, "avg_nodes": 7230.666666666667, "eval_calls": 76997, "avg_eval_calls": 5133.133333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 76997, "pattern_eval_ns": 1665859, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.63537540423653, "pattern_frame_queries": 76997, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1665859, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.63537540423653, "pattern_frame_updates": 215200, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2394102393, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11125.011119888475, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29120, "avg_candidate_generations": 1941.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 2333624, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.13818681318682, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1078, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 29105, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2332546, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 778566, "avg_legality_checks": 51904.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1080, "root_legality_checks": 1078, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 777488, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1079, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2618163, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 174544.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5792977812, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2212.611595229174, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23385, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1559.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 103536667, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4427.4820183878555, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1159, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11379620, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7862, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60677386, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14357, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31418131, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61530, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 80068, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5337.866666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 704942715, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8804.30028226008, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 107977, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7198.466666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 295791646, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2739.3949266973523, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1947593135, "stage_ordering_ns": 964625209, "stage_eval_ns": 2395768252, "stage_threat_ns": 4627641837, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 476079, "root_tactical_annotations": 2611, "search_tactical_annotations": 473468, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 215215, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1292710007, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 415673, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3133817526, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58306, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2121666962, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 107600, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159907337, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 215200, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27291901, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 147613, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 216204741, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 209743, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 795560963, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 118723, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13915066, "child_limit_applications": 29105, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29105, "child_cap_hits": 29105, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29105, "child_moves_before_total": 2331467, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2331467, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 465782, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 465782, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.10537708297544, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00350455248239, "tt_hits": 12882, "tt_cutoffs": 1498, "beta_cutoffs": 24104, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5461.733333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5995.066666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 904, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 13009, "avg_search_time_ms": 929.2142857142857, "search_nodes": 92893, "safety_nodes": 1369, "corridor_nodes": 1102, "corridor_branch_probes": 1247, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 430, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1083, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1083, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 62, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 430, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 62, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 62, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 351, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 39996560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2005280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 95364, "avg_nodes": 6811.714285714285, "eval_calls": 57000, "avg_eval_calls": 4071.4285714285716, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 57000, "pattern_eval_ns": 1261232, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.126877192982455, "pattern_frame_queries": 57000, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1261232, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.126877192982455, "pattern_frame_updates": 185618, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2062902680, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11113.699533450419, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33294, "avg_candidate_generations": 2378.1428571428573, "candidate_moves_total": 2628473, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.94734787048718, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1000, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 33280, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2627473, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 1700892, "avg_legality_checks": 121492.28571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1168, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1700892, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1168, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4042541, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 288752.9285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8510367114, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2105.2024244157324, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30140, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2152.8571428571427, "renju_forbidden_ns": 88113660, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2923.479097544791, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1459, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11063576, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6770, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 49819082, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21898, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27068882, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 162120, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 153602, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10971.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1350933964, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8795.028476191716, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 213927, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15280.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 589160363, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2754.0252656279945, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4056713443, "stage_ordering_ns": 1080099516, "stage_eval_ns": 2064163912, "stage_threat_ns": 5632171902, "stage_proof_ns": 100349164, "tactical_annotations": 573475, "root_tactical_annotations": 1460, "search_tactical_annotations": 572015, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 187922, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1182109431, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 548789, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4245844650, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67424, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2428405775, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 93954, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 146285549, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2290, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14344458, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 187908, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24617805, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 133413, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 565673597, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 281307, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1203380667, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 158755, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18970009, "child_limit_applications": 33280, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33280, "child_cap_hits": 33280, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33280, "child_moves_before_total": 2626305, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2626305, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 342314, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 342314, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.91541466346153, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.285877403846154, "tt_hits": 16759, "tt_cutoffs": 2530, "beta_cutoffs": 26820, "depth_sum": 83, "avg_depth": 5.928571428571429, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 83, "avg_effective_depth": 5.928571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4460.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5031.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 208, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1390, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27250, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 68, 82, 114, 98, 140, 97, 67, 129, 145, 125, 83, 124, 123, 139, 153, 109, 154, 93, 141, 79, 94, 65, 81, 51, 37, 107 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 21472, "avg_search_time_ms": 1431.4666666666667, "search_nodes": 201292, "safety_nodes": 211, "corridor_nodes": 73, "corridor_branch_probes": 94, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 69, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 69, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 22, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 22, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 21, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 152, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4083040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2032640, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 201576, "avg_nodes": 13438.4, "eval_calls": 133666, "avg_eval_calls": 8911.066666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 133666, "pattern_eval_ns": 2920259, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.847433154280072, "pattern_frame_queries": 133666, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2920259, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.847433154280072, "pattern_frame_updates": 402446, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5883703037, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14619.857165930336, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 63390, "avg_candidate_generations": 4226.0, "candidate_moves_total": 5212616, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.23088815270548, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1076, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 63375, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5211540, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1484968, "avg_legality_checks": 98997.86666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4085, "root_legality_checks": 1076, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1483892, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4084, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5556335, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 370422.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12394160271, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2230.635890564554, "renju_forbidden_checks": 127387, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8492.466666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 506482489, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3975.9354486721563, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 14905, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 69849773, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 52029, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 284508616, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 60283, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 151665189, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 170, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 458911, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 131673, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8778.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1133713915, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8610.071275052593, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 169681, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11312.066666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 431714464, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2544.27109694073, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3725994638, "stage_ordering_ns": 2147624403, "stage_eval_ns": 5886623296, "stage_threat_ns": 9588973758, "stage_proof_ns": 52318018, "tactical_annotations": 1303573, "root_tactical_annotations": 4193, "search_tactical_annotations": 1299380, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 402643, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2501068343, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1107382, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6674493476, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 126970, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4591962953, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 201314, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 312622821, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 182, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 965001, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 402628, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53456562, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 337183, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 315586058, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 637341, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1753378309, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 329049, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 46367555, "child_limit_applications": 63375, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 63375, "child_cap_hits": 63375, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 63375, "child_moves_before_total": 5207456, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5207456, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 753705, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 753705, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.16893096646943, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.892781065088757, "tt_hits": 29060, "tt_cutoffs": 4183, "beta_cutoffs": 48836, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2569.5333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3102.866666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 358, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 5762, "avg_search_time_ms": 411.57142857142856, "search_nodes": 50710, "safety_nodes": 1415, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 52125, "avg_nodes": 3723.214285714286, "eval_calls": 34499, "avg_eval_calls": 2464.214285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34499, "pattern_eval_ns": 759332, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.010261166990347, "pattern_frame_queries": 34499, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 759332, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.010261166990347, "pattern_frame_updates": 101290, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1168374360, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11534.942837397572, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15297, "avg_candidate_generations": 1092.642857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 1143967, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.78374844740799, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 994, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 15283, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1142973, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 555467, "avg_legality_checks": 39676.21428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2040, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 555467, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2040, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1585402, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 113243.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3537564460, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2231.3359387713654, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18435, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1316.7857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 90257678, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4895.995551939246, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3113, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24698339, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5944, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 41636202, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9265, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23572807, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 113, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 350330, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3607.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 512209522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10142.361134212506, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5150.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 237531897, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3294.4784604715674, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1436498061, "stage_ordering_ns": 497687968, "stage_eval_ns": 1169133692, "stage_threat_ns": 2622022674, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 256827, "root_tactical_annotations": 646, "search_tactical_annotations": 256181, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 101304, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 641667424, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 249026, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1884462822, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30659, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1144003611, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50645, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 78245198, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 101290, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13176494, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 164745616, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 156287, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 575302743, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 38470, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4470736, "child_limit_applications": 15283, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15283, "child_cap_hits": 15283, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15283, "child_moves_before_total": 1140933, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1140933, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 247022, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 247022, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.6537329058431, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.163187855787477, "tt_hits": 4591, "tt_cutoffs": 863, "beta_cutoffs": 13051, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5708.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6279.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1820, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1391, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 59736, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 82, 97, 98, 84, 99, 113, 129, 126, 130, 111, 141, 83, 125, 65, 81, 157, 115, 69, 55, 100, 101, 87, 131, 128, 132, 133, 86, 116, 147, 163, 162, 117, 66, 148, 178, 142, 156, 174, 158, 50, 118, 52, 68, 51, 146, 194, 160, 104, 161, 159, 176, 191, 192, 177, 208, 144, 224 ], "move_count": 61, "black_stats": { "move_count": 31, "search_move_count": 29, "total_time_ms": 19000, "avg_search_time_ms": 655.1724137931035, "search_nodes": 270824, "safety_nodes": 2468, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 273292, "avg_nodes": 9423.862068965518, "eval_calls": 197241, "avg_eval_calls": 6801.413793103448, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 197241, "pattern_eval_ns": 4004823, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.30421159900832, "pattern_frame_queries": 197241, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4004823, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.30421159900832, "pattern_frame_updates": 541374, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4943879430, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9132.096166420995, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 69198, "avg_candidate_generations": 2386.137931034483, "candidate_moves_total": 6022377, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.03108471343103, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 29, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2375, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 69169, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6020002, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 2165701, "avg_legality_checks": 74679.3448275862, "illegal_moves_skipped": 533, "root_legality_checks": 2375, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2163326, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 533, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6177827, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 213028.5172413793, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10867155961, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1759.0579925595198, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40774, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1406.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 90023916, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2207.8755089027322, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1391, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3390406, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13486, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 55052970, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25892, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31573740, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6800, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 122952, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4239.724137931034, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 810002513, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6587.957194677598, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 159867, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5512.6551724137935, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 331699325, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2074.845496569023, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4077421758, "stage_ordering_ns": 1874420071, "stage_eval_ns": 4947884253, "stage_threat_ns": 7972358975, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1281263, "root_tactical_annotations": 5086, "search_tactical_annotations": 1276177, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 541403, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2529693279, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1170873, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5022602347, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 138532, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3522622640, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 270687, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 334640432, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 541374, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56602497, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 448308, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 220754475, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 584008, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1278353850, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 248947, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28820420, "child_limit_applications": 69169, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 69169, "child_cap_hits": 69169, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 69169, "child_moves_before_total": 6019469, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6019469, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 1107127, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1107127, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.02553166881117, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.006115456346052, "tt_hits": 26753, "tt_cutoffs": 4277, "beta_cutoffs": 56268, "depth_sum": 136, "avg_depth": 4.689655172413793, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 136, "avg_effective_depth": 4.689655172413793, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 26 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.034482758620689655, "pooled_budget_moves": 29, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.034482758620689655, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.034482758620689655, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6551.862068965517, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6827.724137931034, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 30, "search_move_count": 28, "total_time_ms": 40709, "avg_search_time_ms": 1453.892857142857, "search_nodes": 352775, "safety_nodes": 1489, "corridor_nodes": 5158, "corridor_branch_probes": 5575, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 1991, "corridor_neutral_exits": 89, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 5107, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5107, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 21, "corridor_proof_completed": 21, "corridor_proof_checks": 199, "corridor_proof_active": 51, "corridor_proof_quiet": 148, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 100, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1991, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 199, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 199, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1550, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 47525600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2023760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 359422, "avg_nodes": 12836.5, "eval_calls": 202598, "avg_eval_calls": 7235.642857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 202598, "pattern_eval_ns": 4198685, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.724217415769157, "pattern_frame_queries": 202598, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4198685, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.724217415769157, "pattern_frame_updates": 705186, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5118357111, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7258.166088095906, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 140431, "avg_candidate_generations": 5015.392857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 12502241, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.02764346903462, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 28, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2309, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 140403, "search_candidate_moves_total": 12499932, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 8782596, "avg_legality_checks": 313664.14285714284, "illegal_moves_skipped": 692, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8782596, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 692, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15694646, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 560523.0714285715, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 26835188143, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1709.8307373737516, "renju_forbidden_checks": 75436, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2694.1428571428573, "renju_forbidden_ns": 92645299, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1228.1311177687046, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2561, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7026113, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30819096, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 63445, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 54800090, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 337041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12037.17857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2087830003, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6194.587611002816, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 433130, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15468.92857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 827297439, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1910.0441876572854, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16499308464, "stage_ordering_ns": 3828721583, "stage_eval_ns": 5122555796, "stage_threat_ns": 14702208671, "stage_proof_ns": 203987098, "tactical_annotations": 3059007, "root_tactical_annotations": 8018, "search_tactical_annotations": 3050989, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 715826, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3406707628, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2768757, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10571450450, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 284554, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6828235666, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 357899, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 460641550, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10612, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 80730671, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 715798, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 75134893, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1014814, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 905736902, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1185080, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2648060593, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 859113, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 107543479, "child_limit_applications": 140403, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 140403, "child_cap_hits": 140403, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 140403, "child_moves_before_total": 12499240, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 12499240, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 1197287, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1197287, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.02402370319723, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.527502973583186, "tt_hits": 76944, "tt_cutoffs": 9595, "beta_cutoffs": 115058, "depth_sum": 178, "avg_depth": 6.357142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 178, "avg_effective_depth": 6.357142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 21 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 28, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.32142857142857145, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3662.214285714286, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3947.9285714285716, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1392, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19903, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 98, 54, 68, 84, 83, 53, 113, 128, 99, 85, 81, 129, 115, 131, 65, 49, 67, 51, 66, 64, 69 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 15871, "avg_search_time_ms": 1322.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 151348, "safety_nodes": 349, "corridor_nodes": 2064, "corridor_branch_probes": 2323, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1003, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2052, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2052, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1003, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 424, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 31955440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2032640, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 153761, "avg_nodes": 12813.416666666666, "eval_calls": 103540, "avg_eval_calls": 8628.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 103540, "pattern_eval_ns": 2282939, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.048860343828473, "pattern_frame_queries": 103540, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2282939, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.048860343828473, "pattern_frame_updates": 302588, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4492626123, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14847.337379539176, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 45109, "avg_candidate_generations": 3759.0833333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 3268666, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.46150435611519, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 756, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 45097, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3267910, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 891084, "avg_legality_checks": 74257.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1438, "root_legality_checks": 756, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 890328, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1438, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4229482, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 352456.8333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9545552755, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2256.9082348618576, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31621, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2635.0833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 200992287, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6356.291293760476, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1621, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14172985, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17957, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 144596172, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11854, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41150777, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 189, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1072353, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 111216, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9268.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 974710048, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8764.117105452453, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 144486, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12040.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 392075135, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2713.585641515441, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2241776905, "stage_ordering_ns": 1359260179, "stage_eval_ns": 4494909062, "stage_threat_ns": 7421637841, "stage_proof_ns": 306126345, "tactical_annotations": 779039, "root_tactical_annotations": 2666, "search_tactical_annotations": 776373, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 306812, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1920232684, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 710301, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5161019594, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 91383, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3435960880, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 153400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 237486785, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4212, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24851239, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 306800, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40483013, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 185646, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 219431937, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 324376, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1170649489, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 269017, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 37564526, "child_limit_applications": 45097, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 45097, "child_cap_hits": 45097, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 45097, "child_moves_before_total": 3266472, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3266472, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 466233, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 466233, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.43213517528882, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.338448233807126, "tt_hits": 24982, "tt_cutoffs": 2657, "beta_cutoffs": 35405, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2544.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3211.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 436, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4020, "avg_search_time_ms": 365.45454545454544, "search_nodes": 34165, "safety_nodes": 845, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35010, "avg_nodes": 3182.7272727272725, "eval_calls": 22662, "avg_eval_calls": 2060.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22662, "pattern_eval_ns": 504434, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.25902391668873, "pattern_frame_queries": 22662, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 504434, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.25902391668873, "pattern_frame_updates": 68230, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 728501840, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10677.148468415653, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10781, "avg_candidate_generations": 980.0909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 758125, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.32047119933216, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 681, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 10770, "search_candidate_moves_total": 757444, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 438225, "avg_legality_checks": 39838.63636363636, "illegal_moves_skipped": 130, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 438225, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 130, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1163276, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 105752.36363636363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2580548622, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2218.3459660476105, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4287, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 389.72727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18912986, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4411.706554700257, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 132, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1280425, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1454, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13488017, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2701, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4144544, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42197, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3836.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 405653987, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9613.337132971537, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 57586, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5235.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 181761298, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3156.3452575278716, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1123108757, "stage_ordering_ns": 330566695, "stage_eval_ns": 729006274, "stage_threat_ns": 1806814882, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 159923, "root_tactical_annotations": 626, "search_tactical_annotations": 159297, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 68241, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 426112284, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 154665, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1317172108, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21612, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 777045146, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34115, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 51556554, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 68230, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8775302, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 40333, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 152227923, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 92713, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 387659195, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 26877, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3198634, "child_limit_applications": 10770, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10770, "child_cap_hits": 10770, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10770, "child_moves_before_total": 757314, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 757314, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 172915, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 172915, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.31699164345405, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.055246053853296, "tt_hits": 3744, "tt_cutoffs": 683, "beta_cutoffs": 9303, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5443.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6170.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1874, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1393, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21008, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 67, 82, 96, 98, 66, 113, 143, 114, 68, 69, 81, 111, 53, 39, 38, 23, 64, 65, 80, 48, 52, 24, 94 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10068, "avg_search_time_ms": 839.0, "search_nodes": 123834, "safety_nodes": 188, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 124022, "avg_nodes": 10335.166666666666, "eval_calls": 89911, "avg_eval_calls": 7492.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89911, "pattern_eval_ns": 1898446, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.114724560954723, "pattern_frame_queries": 89911, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1898446, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.114724560954723, "pattern_frame_updates": 247564, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2654095635, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10720.846467984036, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31985, "avg_candidate_generations": 2665.4166666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2396746, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.93343754885102, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 782, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 31973, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2395964, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 844058, "avg_legality_checks": 70338.16666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1377, "root_legality_checks": 782, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 843276, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1377, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2829275, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 235772.91666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5863037705, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2072.2756554240927, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24571, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2047.5833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 129243586, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5260.005127996418, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1497, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12132871, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12692, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 84414984, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10382, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32695731, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65433, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5452.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 522970617, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7992.459722158544, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 87214, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7267.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 209918419, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2406.9348843075654, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1960877418, "stage_ordering_ns": 922323488, "stage_eval_ns": 2655994081, "stage_threat_ns": 4478674997, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 480627, "root_tactical_annotations": 2905, "search_tactical_annotations": 477722, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 247576, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1343983527, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 428098, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2925454236, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64021, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2104222091, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123782, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 166282409, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 247564, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29406843, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 147339, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 112188156, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 216727, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 708913769, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 116561, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13547982, "child_limit_applications": 31973, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31973, "child_cap_hits": 31973, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31973, "child_moves_before_total": 2394587, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2394587, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 515098, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 515098, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.8940355925312, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.110405654771213, "tt_hits": 13443, "tt_cutoffs": 1898, "beta_cutoffs": 26222, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4344.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5011.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10927, "avg_search_time_ms": 993.3636363636364, "search_nodes": 82271, "safety_nodes": 865, "corridor_nodes": 717, "corridor_branch_probes": 822, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 306, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 707, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 707, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 52, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 306, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 52, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 323, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 42140960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2022000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 83853, "avg_nodes": 7623.0, "eval_calls": 46024, "avg_eval_calls": 4184.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46024, "pattern_eval_ns": 990304, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.517121501825134, "pattern_frame_queries": 46024, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 990304, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.517121501825134, "pattern_frame_updates": 164418, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1493776930, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9085.239633130193, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32734, "avg_candidate_generations": 2975.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2448690, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.80570660475347, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 723, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 32723, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2447967, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 1656434, "avg_legality_checks": 150584.9090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1476, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1656434, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1476, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3380867, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 307351.54545454547, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7220911002, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2135.8163459254683, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21320, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1938.1818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64971014, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3047.420919324578, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1482, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13451286, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4988, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35301874, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14850, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16217854, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75830, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6893.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 653199266, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8613.99533166293, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98174, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8924.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 265720502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2706.6280481593903, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3946683638, "stage_ordering_ns": 971827781, "stage_eval_ns": 1494767234, "stage_threat_ns": 4358404512, "stage_proof_ns": 84805405, "tactical_annotations": 526019, "root_tactical_annotations": 1201, "search_tactical_annotations": 524818, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 165947, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 989009342, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 454622, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3193997568, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 66020, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2159190068, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 82968, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 122276268, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1518, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8990996, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 165936, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20312172, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96299, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 161274207, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 250671, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 842693503, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 179049, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23818166, "child_limit_applications": 32723, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32723, "child_cap_hits": 32723, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32723, "child_moves_before_total": 2446491, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2446491, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 301916, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 301916, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.76365247685115, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.226415670934816, "tt_hits": 18803, "tt_cutoffs": 3462, "beta_cutoffs": 26810, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2994.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3722.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 253, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1394, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 33900, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 127, 142, 126, 114, 156, 82, 98, 84, 171, 100, 86, 141, 140, 154, 124, 108, 139, 125, 155, 123, 172, 188, 173, 170, 187, 203, 159, 201, 175, 174, 143, 111, 191 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 25865, "avg_search_time_ms": 1521.4705882352941, "search_nodes": 270552, "safety_nodes": 275, "corridor_nodes": 986, "corridor_branch_probes": 1115, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 470, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 977, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 977, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 59, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 470, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 68, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 554, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 49729200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2025680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 271813, "avg_nodes": 15989.0, "eval_calls": 170467, "avg_eval_calls": 10027.470588235294, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 170467, "pattern_eval_ns": 3507447, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.575519015410606, "pattern_frame_queries": 170467, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3507447, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.575519015410606, "pattern_frame_updates": 540950, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6496165242, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12008.809024863665, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 91665, "avg_candidate_generations": 5392.058823529412, "candidate_moves_total": 8405711, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.70033273332243, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1338, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 91648, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8404373, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 2307598, "avg_legality_checks": 135741.0588235294, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2325, "root_legality_checks": 1338, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2306260, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2325, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7908662, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 465215.4117647059, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15065330965, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1904.915264427788, "renju_forbidden_checks": 64496, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3793.8823529411766, "renju_forbidden_ns": 292883339, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4541.1085803770775, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2753, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18749393, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 196476087, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28469, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 76647031, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 134, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1010828, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 163439, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9614.058823529413, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1268115011, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7758.949889561243, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 223300, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13135.29411764706, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 551209996, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2468.4728884908195, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4860851571, "stage_ordering_ns": 2795790622, "stage_eval_ns": 6499672689, "stage_threat_ns": 11383087112, "stage_proof_ns": 207631982, "tactical_annotations": 2020522, "root_tactical_annotations": 5181, "search_tactical_annotations": 2015341, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 543057, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2795555810, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1703641, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8077508443, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 184055, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5435245484, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 271520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 361861681, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2090, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11026081, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 543040, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61459352, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 495202, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 313254690, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 970828, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2192839038, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 554492, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 75675745, "child_limit_applications": 91648, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 91648, "child_cap_hits": 91648, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 91648, "child_moves_before_total": 8402048, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8402048, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 1191442, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1191442, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.67737430167598, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.000196403631286, "tt_hits": 47394, "tt_cutoffs": 8363, "beta_cutoffs": 72198, "depth_sum": 74, "avg_depth": 4.352941176470588, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 74, "avg_effective_depth": 4.352941176470588, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2991.823529411765, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3462.4117647058824, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1468, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 8023, "avg_search_time_ms": 501.4375, "search_nodes": 76161, "safety_nodes": 1660, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 77821, "avg_nodes": 4863.8125, "eval_calls": 53298, "avg_eval_calls": 3331.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53298, "pattern_eval_ns": 1149238, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.562497654696237, "pattern_frame_queries": 53298, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1149238, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.562497654696237, "pattern_frame_updates": 152172, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1456292295, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9570.04110480246, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21686, "avg_candidate_generations": 1355.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1788164, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.45706907682376, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1262, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 21670, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1786902, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1008863, "avg_legality_checks": 63053.9375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 192, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1008863, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 192, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2418021, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 151126.3125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5042135126, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2085.2321489350174, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13563, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 847.6875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37921202, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2795.9302514193023, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 203, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2047696, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2414, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19984338, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10946, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15889168, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72419, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4526.1875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 657845040, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9083.873569090985, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 99121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6195.0625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 301086944, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3037.569677464917, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2346687535, "stage_ordering_ns": 700311648, "stage_eval_ns": 1457441533, "stage_threat_ns": 3460822986, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 366987, "root_tactical_annotations": 1111, "search_tactical_annotations": 365876, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152188, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 883689698, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 336120, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2441021493, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43447, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1519013863, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76086, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107465185, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152172, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18745775, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 101331, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 314224328, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 191331, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 607478892, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 74325, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9900835, "child_limit_applications": 21670, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21670, "child_cap_hits": 21670, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21670, "child_moves_before_total": 1786710, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1786710, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 351245, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 351245, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.4508537148131, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.208814028610984, "tt_hits": 8064, "tt_cutoffs": 1118, "beta_cutoffs": 18188, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5719.9375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6219.9375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 989, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1395, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 48610, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 96, 142, 94, 98, 128, 80, 95, 93, 79, 63, 64, 109, 127, 143, 141, 99, 81, 78, 49, 34, 66, 51, 65, 97, 33, 17, 67, 68, 53, 39, 108, 100, 101, 84, 144, 160, 52, 115, 130, 69, 54, 129, 114, 158, 174, 157, 171, 159, 156, 161 ], "move_count": 56, "black_stats": { "move_count": 28, "search_move_count": 26, "total_time_ms": 13753, "avg_search_time_ms": 528.9615384615385, "search_nodes": 169452, "safety_nodes": 2207, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 171659, "avg_nodes": 6602.2692307692305, "eval_calls": 122304, "avg_eval_calls": 4704.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 122304, "pattern_eval_ns": 2523944, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.636643118785976, "pattern_frame_queries": 122304, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2523944, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.636643118785976, "pattern_frame_updates": 338654, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3186386913, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9408.974685076804, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44709, "avg_candidate_generations": 1719.576923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 3765923, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.23187725066542, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 26, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2072, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 44683, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3763851, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 1365436, "avg_legality_checks": 52516.769230769234, "illegal_moves_skipped": 326, "root_legality_checks": 2072, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1363364, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 326, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3908159, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 150313.8076923077, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7938126141, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2031.167652339631, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23579, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 906.8846153846154, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65534202, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2779.346113066712, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 981, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3660899, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7485, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 39627293, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15105, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22232570, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 108445, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4170.961538461538, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 787021796, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7257.335939877357, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 129698, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4988.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 265181704, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2044.6090456290767, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2962727862, "stage_ordering_ns": 1338523459, "stage_eval_ns": 3188910857, "stage_threat_ns": 6170645364, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 797171, "root_tactical_annotations": 3771, "search_tactical_annotations": 793400, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 338680, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1875849107, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 712766, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4000062635, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 89543, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2755175865, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 169327, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 236563426, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 338654, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39494752, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 292421, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 236672989, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 330782, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1007342235, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 173968, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18675444, "child_limit_applications": 44683, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44683, "child_cap_hits": 44683, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44683, "child_moves_before_total": 3763525, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3763525, "child_moves_before_max": 131, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 131, "child_moves_after_total": 717922, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 717922, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.22722288118524, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.067005348790367, "tt_hits": 19220, "tt_cutoffs": 2340, "beta_cutoffs": 36846, "depth_sum": 125, "avg_depth": 4.8076923076923075, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 125, "avg_effective_depth": 4.8076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 24 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 26, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6620.038461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6927.7307692307695, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 989, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 28, "search_move_count": 26, "total_time_ms": 34833, "avg_search_time_ms": 1339.7307692307693, "search_nodes": 259018, "safety_nodes": 1451, "corridor_nodes": 5462, "corridor_branch_probes": 5910, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 2227, "corridor_neutral_exits": 22, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 5424, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5424, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 20, "corridor_proof_completed": 20, "corridor_proof_checks": 97, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 59, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2227, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 97, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 95, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 612, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 44006880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2003600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 265931, "avg_nodes": 10228.115384615385, "eval_calls": 150214, "avg_eval_calls": 5777.461538461538, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 150214, "pattern_eval_ns": 3185419, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.20587295458479, "pattern_frame_queries": 150214, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3185419, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.20587295458479, "pattern_frame_updates": 517710, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4153779799, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8023.371769909795, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 102385, "avg_candidate_generations": 3937.8846153846152, "candidate_moves_total": 9835026, "avg_candidate_moves": 96.0592469600039, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 26, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2088, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 102359, "search_candidate_moves_total": 9832938, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 7134402, "avg_legality_checks": 274400.07692307694, "illegal_moves_skipped": 990, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7134402, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 990, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12533081, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 482041.57692307694, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23169462575, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1848.664552235799, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47464, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1825.5384615384614, "renju_forbidden_ns": 84680619, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1784.102035226698, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2357, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10543910, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7879, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43620613, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37228, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30516096, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 360245, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13855.576923076924, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2613110545, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7253.703854321365, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 435199, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16738.423076923078, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 954381120, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2192.9763625375977, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14021282109, "stage_ordering_ns": 3098884050, "stage_eval_ns": 4156965218, "stage_threat_ns": 13212089236, "stage_proof_ns": 109630866, "tactical_annotations": 1970316, "root_tactical_annotations": 5788, "search_tactical_annotations": 1964528, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 528778, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3012781782, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1928309, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9603383122, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 208169, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5669658038, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 264376, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 391762890, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 11042, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 67588654, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 528752, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62870448, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 613201, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1290426484, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 804759, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2437718205, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 552356, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 73702340, "child_limit_applications": 102359, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 102359, "child_cap_hits": 102359, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 102359, "child_moves_before_total": 9831948, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 9831948, "child_moves_before_max": 131, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 131, "child_moves_after_total": 995759, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 995759, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 96.05357613888373, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.728104026026045, "tt_hits": 56508, "tt_cutoffs": 6284, "beta_cutoffs": 86827, "depth_sum": 160, "avg_depth": 6.153846153846154, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 160, "avg_effective_depth": 6.153846153846154, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.11538461538461539, "pooled_budget_moves": 26, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.11538461538461539, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5076.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5358.038461538462, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 323, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1396, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 34274, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 128, 127, 85, 141, 155, 142, 157, 143, 144, 115, 116, 159, 130, 158, 83, 81, 88, 102, 87, 84, 86, 89, 101, 131, 69, 175, 191, 139, 140, 97, 53, 37, 117 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 20871, "avg_search_time_ms": 1159.5, "search_nodes": 203001, "safety_nodes": 1391, "corridor_nodes": 1306, "corridor_branch_probes": 1450, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 588, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 1281, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1266, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 15, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 53, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 28, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 588, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 53, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 3, "corridor_proof_unknown": 50, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 281, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 10383920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 205698, "avg_nodes": 11427.666666666666, "eval_calls": 125222, "avg_eval_calls": 6956.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 125222, "pattern_eval_ns": 2647317, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.14098960246602, "pattern_frame_queries": 125222, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2647317, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.14098960246602, "pattern_frame_updates": 405786, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4248412298, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10469.588152375884, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 72262, "avg_candidate_generations": 4014.5555555555557, "candidate_moves_total": 5844283, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.8762973623758, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1325, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 72244, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5842958, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 1927693, "avg_legality_checks": 107094.05555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 400, "root_legality_checks": 1325, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1926368, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 400, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5775461, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 320858.94444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12414086211, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2149.453733823153, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26182, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1454.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 85888047, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3280.423458864869, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 906, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5218284, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9567, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 54622400, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14930, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24711797, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 779, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1335566, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 101869, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5659.388888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 844381758, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8288.89807497865, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132484, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7360.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 343066433, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2589.4933199480693, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4531514094, "stage_ordering_ns": 2306861384, "stage_eval_ns": 4251059615, "stage_threat_ns": 9488878587, "stage_proof_ns": 207521642, "tactical_annotations": 1065371, "root_tactical_annotations": 3250, "search_tactical_annotations": 1062121, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 408472, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2370032473, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 914011, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6696244616, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 145438, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4960475219, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 204227, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 300907775, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2668, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22487402, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 408454, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50322714, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 158172, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 168988470, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 542689, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1408195523, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 364510, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 48883607, "child_limit_applications": 72244, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 72244, "child_cap_hits": 72244, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 72244, "child_moves_before_total": 5842558, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5842558, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 664076, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 664076, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.87257073251757, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.192126681800564, "tt_hits": 38178, "tt_cutoffs": 5428, "beta_cutoffs": 55699, "depth_sum": 105, "avg_depth": 5.833333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 105, "avg_effective_depth": 5.833333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3463.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3907.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 13383, "avg_search_time_ms": 743.5, "search_nodes": 107511, "safety_nodes": 1041, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 108552, "avg_nodes": 6030.666666666667, "eval_calls": 68817, "avg_eval_calls": 3823.1666666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68817, "pattern_eval_ns": 1499310, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.786913117398317, "pattern_frame_queries": 68817, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1499310, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.786913117398317, "pattern_frame_updates": 214858, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1867445570, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8691.533803721528, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35929, "avg_candidate_generations": 1996.0555555555557, "candidate_moves_total": 2993149, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.30732834200785, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1347, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 35911, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2991802, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 2200029, "avg_legality_checks": 122223.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 158, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2200029, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 158, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4259911, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 236661.72222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8868505292, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2081.8522480868733, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19091, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1060.611111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29479628, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1544.1636373160127, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 188, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1581298, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1674, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12036417, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17229, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15861913, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 125379, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6965.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1084170249, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8647.143851841218, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 165611, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9200.611111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 466005419, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2813.8554745759643, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5025757895, "stage_ordering_ns": 1141572139, "stage_eval_ns": 1868944880, "stage_threat_ns": 5251436757, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 643937, "root_tactical_annotations": 3269, "search_tactical_annotations": 640668, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 214876, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1253797421, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 571123, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3793130688, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 71939, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2329416393, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 107429, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 158741661, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 214858, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26781028, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 248394, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 604785813, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 250776, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 858652661, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 144767, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18985959, "child_limit_applications": 35911, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35911, "child_cap_hits": 35911, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35911, "child_moves_before_total": 2991644, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2991644, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 574686, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 574686, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.3071760741834, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.003063128289384, "tt_hits": 16731, "tt_cutoffs": 2701, "beta_cutoffs": 31416, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6347.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6791.611111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1858, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1397, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29466, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 144, 141, 97, 109, 108, 125, 93, 95, 80, 143, 127, 157, 173, 129, 115, 156, 96, 155, 140, 158, 159, 154 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 20864, "avg_search_time_ms": 1604.923076923077, "search_nodes": 237788, "safety_nodes": 78, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 237866, "avg_nodes": 18297.384615384617, "eval_calls": 193056, "avg_eval_calls": 14850.461538461539, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 193056, "pattern_eval_ns": 4188951, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.698113500745897, "pattern_frame_queries": 193056, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4188951, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.698113500745897, "pattern_frame_updates": 475462, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7448659539, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15666.151109867877, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42467, "avg_candidate_generations": 3266.6923076923076, "candidate_moves_total": 3316785, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.10264440624485, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 864, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 42454, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3315921, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 1327479, "avg_legality_checks": 102113.76923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5449, "root_legality_checks": 864, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 1326615, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5443, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5364341, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 412641.6153846154, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12104754069, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2256.5221094259296, "renju_forbidden_checks": 99827, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7679.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 575514681, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5765.1204684103495, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6589, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 56215678, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 60260, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 422806121, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32948, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 96313090, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 179792, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 155293, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11945.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1458310013, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9390.700244054788, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 207985, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15998.846153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 644259082, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3097.62281895329, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3387332475, "stage_ordering_ns": 1406943168, "stage_eval_ns": 7452848490, "stage_threat_ns": 8550621293, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 795763, "root_tactical_annotations": 3585, "search_tactical_annotations": 792178, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 475475, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2883018207, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 701279, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5218527398, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 84990, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3156532657, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 237731, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 363073467, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 475462, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62194592, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 228762, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 318905504, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 387515, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1743075917, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 179486, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23807629, "child_limit_applications": 42454, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42454, "child_cap_hits": 42454, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42454, "child_moves_before_total": 3310478, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3310478, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 680927, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 680927, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.97799971734112, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.039171809487918, "tt_hits": 17493, "tt_cutoffs": 2221, "beta_cutoffs": 29843, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1345.3076923076924, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1744.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 81, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8590, "avg_search_time_ms": 715.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 66002, "safety_nodes": 1080, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 34, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 34, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 275, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 180320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67082, "avg_nodes": 5590.166666666667, "eval_calls": 41783, "avg_eval_calls": 3481.9166666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41783, "pattern_eval_ns": 927805, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.205322738912955, "pattern_frame_queries": 41783, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 927805, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.205322738912955, "pattern_frame_updates": 131874, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1676047653, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12709.462464170345, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22232, "avg_candidate_generations": 1852.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1628758, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.26187477509896, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 796, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 22220, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1627962, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 936559, "avg_legality_checks": 78046.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1702, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 936559, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1702, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2455030, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 204585.83333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5512715680, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2245.477928986611, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25532, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2127.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 116004778, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4543.505326648911, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2202, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19752956, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9461, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 65464720, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13832, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30530901, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 256201, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76743, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6395.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 714750294, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9313.556858605996, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 103515, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8626.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 307429736, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2969.905192484181, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2393044596, "stage_ordering_ns": 721544368, "stage_eval_ns": 1676975458, "stage_threat_ns": 3687995222, "stage_proof_ns": 62639932, "tactical_annotations": 314757, "root_tactical_annotations": 829, "search_tactical_annotations": 313928, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 131954, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 838994079, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 272682, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2717420592, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44665, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1723466461, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 65971, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 103764876, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 68, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 263270, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 131942, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17760273, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44782, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 150284903, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 183159, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 843356846, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 86816, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9792132, "child_limit_applications": 22220, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22220, "child_cap_hits": 22220, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22220, "child_moves_before_total": 1626260, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1626260, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 214202, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 214202, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.1890189018902, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.64005400540054, "tt_hits": 10544, "tt_cutoffs": 1934, "beta_cutoffs": 17226, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4375.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5042.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 355, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1398, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28626, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 113, 114, 128, 66, 82, 110, 96, 144, 97, 67, 125, 139, 129, 81, 130, 131, 145, 161, 115, 160, 101, 143, 85, 100, 69, 83, 53, 37, 117 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 22075, "avg_search_time_ms": 1471.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 207290, "safety_nodes": 211, "corridor_nodes": 73, "corridor_branch_probes": 94, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 69, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 69, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 22, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 22, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 21, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 152, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4085040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2032880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 207574, "avg_nodes": 13838.266666666666, "eval_calls": 137988, "avg_eval_calls": 9199.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 137988, "pattern_eval_ns": 3014964, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.849465170884425, "pattern_frame_queries": 137988, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3014964, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.849465170884425, "pattern_frame_updates": 414442, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6017016996, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14518.357203179214, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 65058, "avg_candidate_generations": 4337.2, "candidate_moves_total": 5358619, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.3667957822251, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1076, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 65043, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5357543, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1539695, "avg_legality_checks": 102646.33333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3688, "root_legality_checks": 1076, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1538619, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3687, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5687263, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 379150.86666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12783551426, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2247.751058110026, "renju_forbidden_checks": 123578, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8238.533333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 467870061, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3786.0303694832414, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 14686, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 67279527, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 49488, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 260477246, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 59234, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 139644375, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 170, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 468913, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 132387, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8825.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1144763212, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8647.09685996359, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 170780, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11385.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 436509758, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2555.97703478159, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3884906397, "stage_ordering_ns": 2211890264, "stage_eval_ns": 6020031960, "stage_threat_ns": 9834773634, "stage_proof_ns": 52376118, "tactical_annotations": 1334903, "root_tactical_annotations": 4193, "search_tactical_annotations": 1330710, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 414639, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2574892797, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1122001, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6830764373, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 130306, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4724044576, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 207312, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 323914398, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 182, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 970384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 414624, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55330242, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 344856, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 300004780, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 640951, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1793027100, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 349096, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 48901440, "child_limit_applications": 65043, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 65043, "child_cap_hits": 65043, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 65043, "child_moves_before_total": 5353856, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5353856, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 776995, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 776995, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.31256245868119, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.945866580569778, "tt_hits": 29913, "tt_cutoffs": 4190, "beta_cutoffs": 50149, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2284.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2816.866666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 18, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6536, "avg_search_time_ms": 466.85714285714283, "search_nodes": 57592, "safety_nodes": 1415, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59007, "avg_nodes": 4214.785714285715, "eval_calls": 38888, "avg_eval_calls": 2777.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38888, "pattern_eval_ns": 853403, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.94515017486114, "pattern_frame_queries": 38888, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 853403, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.94515017486114, "pattern_frame_updates": 115054, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1251235438, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10875.201540146367, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17683, "avg_candidate_generations": 1263.0714285714287, "candidate_moves_total": 1349108, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.29406774868518, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 994, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 17669, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1348114, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 667374, "avg_legality_checks": 47669.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2015, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 667374, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2015, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1785940, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 127567.14285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4020325333, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2251.097647737326, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20499, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1464.2142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 88414598, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4313.117615493438, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3283, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25235565, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5610, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37313445, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11493, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25505922, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 113, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 359666, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51385, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3670.3571428571427, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 533959725, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10391.35399435633, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 75570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5397.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 252753625, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3344.6291517798068, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1724918576, "stage_ordering_ns": 586053466, "stage_eval_ns": 1252088841, "stage_threat_ns": 2929465614, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 285466, "root_tactical_annotations": 646, "search_tactical_annotations": 284820, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 115068, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 723785914, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 275612, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2097700372, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35431, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1315257185, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57527, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87583012, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 115054, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15084785, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70669, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 215278039, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 169502, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 566748028, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 45295, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5311531, "child_limit_applications": 17669, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17669, "child_cap_hits": 17669, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17669, "child_moves_before_total": 1346099, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1346099, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 285104, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 285104, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.18422095194974, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.135831116644972, "tt_hits": 5471, "tt_cutoffs": 970, "beta_cutoffs": 15143, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5509.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6081.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1560, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1399, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16449, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 98, 143, 82, 142, 114, 130, 97, 67, 96, 158, 173, 99, 110, 68, 140, 126, 95, 94, 125, 80, 155 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9912, "avg_search_time_ms": 901.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 116732, "safety_nodes": 146, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 116878, "avg_nodes": 10625.272727272728, "eval_calls": 87528, "avg_eval_calls": 7957.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87528, "pattern_eval_ns": 1849578, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.13127227858514, "pattern_frame_queries": 87528, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1849578, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.13127227858514, "pattern_frame_updates": 233370, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2973419003, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12741.222106526116, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27212, "avg_candidate_generations": 2473.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 1990944, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.164192268117, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 676, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 27201, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1990268, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 757516, "avg_legality_checks": 68865.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 838, "root_legality_checks": 676, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 756840, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 838, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2945916, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 267810.54545454547, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5909330667, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2005.9399748669005, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29719, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2701.7272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 138217614, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4650.816447390558, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 950, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6634892, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16221, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 105684782, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12548, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25897940, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90475, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8225.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 752360602, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8315.673965183752, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 120203, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10927.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 323153412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2688.3972280225953, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1693150041, "stage_ordering_ns": 752129846, "stage_eval_ns": 2975268581, "stage_threat_ns": 4446977768, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 477784, "root_tactical_annotations": 2332, "search_tactical_annotations": 475452, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 233381, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1267839733, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 420935, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2978744634, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54470, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1930440870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 116685, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 158454868, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 233370, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27713299, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 142385, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 185566404, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 224071, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 862726929, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 111328, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14225234, "child_limit_applications": 27201, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27201, "child_cap_hits": 27201, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27201, "child_moves_before_total": 1989430, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1989430, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 435847, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 435847, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.13811992206169, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02319767655601, "tt_hits": 11789, "tt_cutoffs": 1956, "beta_cutoffs": 21525, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4578.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5305.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 633, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6527, "avg_search_time_ms": 652.7, "search_nodes": 48545, "safety_nodes": 948, "corridor_nodes": 241, "corridor_branch_probes": 292, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 74, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_plies_followed": 236, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 236, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 8, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 74, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 12, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 32, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6044800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2003760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 49734, "avg_nodes": 4973.4, "eval_calls": 29095, "avg_eval_calls": 2909.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 29095, "pattern_eval_ns": 647854, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.266849974222374, "pattern_frame_queries": 29095, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 647854, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.266849974222374, "pattern_frame_updates": 96980, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1127531889, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11626.437296349763, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17230, "avg_candidate_generations": 1723.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1219978, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.80545560069646, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 622, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 17220, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1219356, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 757795, "avg_legality_checks": 75779.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 594, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 757795, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 594, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1937081, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 193708.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4236906488, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2187.263458781538, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14976, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1497.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46021716, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3073.03125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 605, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6190464, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3730, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28410380, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10641, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11420872, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68986, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6898.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 651747576, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9447.533934421477, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92869, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9286.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 286440505, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3084.3500522241006, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1884254671, "stage_ordering_ns": 531030627, "stage_eval_ns": 1128179743, "stage_threat_ns": 2923009390, "stage_proof_ns": 21601087, "tactical_annotations": 267630, "root_tactical_annotations": 395, "search_tactical_annotations": 267235, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 97488, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 609046091, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 255221, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2216669273, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34658, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1299320398, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48739, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74918458, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 498, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2689778, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 97478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12804564, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32578, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 142617131, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 170847, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 761225363, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 64205, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6881226, "child_limit_applications": 17220, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17220, "child_cap_hits": 17220, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17220, "child_moves_before_total": 1218762, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1218762, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 179807, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 179807, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.77595818815331, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.441753774680604, "tt_hits": 8550, "tt_cutoffs": 2176, "beta_cutoffs": 13966, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4332.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5132.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1400, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16294, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 98, 156, 82, 67, 114, 66, 96, 99, 68, 54, 140, 126, 110, 124, 95, 94, 125, 80, 155 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14152, "avg_search_time_ms": 1286.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 132658, "safety_nodes": 282, "corridor_nodes": 6133, "corridor_branch_probes": 6475, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2911, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 6106, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6106, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2911, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 57, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 432, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 39692720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 139073, "avg_nodes": 12643.0, "eval_calls": 86238, "avg_eval_calls": 7839.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 86238, "pattern_eval_ns": 1747720, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.266239940629422, "pattern_frame_queries": 86238, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1747720, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.266239940629422, "pattern_frame_updates": 265202, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3291305554, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12410.560832874564, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43486, "avg_candidate_generations": 3953.2727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 3482770, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.08945407717427, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 687, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 43475, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3482083, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 959647, "avg_legality_checks": 87240.63636363637, "illegal_moves_skipped": 778, "root_legality_checks": 687, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 958960, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 777, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4381767, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 398342.45454545453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8660151895, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1976.40629796153, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23516, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2137.818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 130258048, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5539.1243408742985, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 900, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7782453, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12365, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 89195323, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9733, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30370351, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 518, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2909921, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93505, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8500.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 762123302, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8150.615496497513, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 122668, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11151.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 325977410, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2657.3956533081164, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2069391819, "stage_ordering_ns": 1290030148, "stage_eval_ns": 3293053274, "stage_threat_ns": 6765724267, "stage_proof_ns": 674226064, "tactical_annotations": 668247, "root_tactical_annotations": 2553, "search_tactical_annotations": 665694, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 277543, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1595028797, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 840400, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4842960961, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90102, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3056905924, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 138766, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 193991177, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12330, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 73794858, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 277532, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32181015, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 168613, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 173978691, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 253603, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 808346099, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 246031, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 27767459, "child_limit_applications": 43475, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43475, "child_cap_hits": 43475, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43475, "child_moves_before_total": 3481306, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3481306, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 406321, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 406321, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.07604370327775, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.346083956296722, "tt_hits": 26352, "tt_cutoffs": 2888, "beta_cutoffs": 34365, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 5.181818181818182, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 5.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3146.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3867.2727272727275, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1672, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2134, "avg_search_time_ms": 213.4, "search_nodes": 23315, "safety_nodes": 874, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 24189, "avg_nodes": 2418.9, "eval_calls": 16136, "avg_eval_calls": 1613.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 16136, "pattern_eval_ns": 335320, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.780862667327714, "pattern_frame_queries": 16136, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 335320, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.780862667327714, "pattern_frame_updates": 46540, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 444985304, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9561.351611516975, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6760, "avg_candidate_generations": 676.0, "candidate_moves_total": 484368, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.65207100591716, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 625, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 6750, "search_candidate_moves_total": 483743, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 215937, "avg_legality_checks": 21593.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 121, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 215937, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 121, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 663426, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 66342.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1292530394, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1948.2661125732184, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2769, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 276.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12059548, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4355.199711087035, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 127, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1212506, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 974, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7504880, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1663, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3285832, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 56330, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 20103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2010.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 165869536, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8250.984231209271, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27924, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2792.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 77165136, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2763.398366996132, "stage_move_gen_ns": 471770920, "stage_ordering_ns": 192881836, "stage_eval_ns": 445320624, "stage_threat_ns": 1003137607, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 97664, "root_tactical_annotations": 311, "search_tactical_annotations": 97353, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 46550, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 265787838, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 94049, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 699399528, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13565, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 461066457, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 23270, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 31081990, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 46540, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5394619, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 25097, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 71163415, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 55381, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 166966014, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 17186, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1473632, "child_limit_applications": 6750, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6750, "child_cap_hits": 6750, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6750, "child_moves_before_total": 483622, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 483622, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 108067, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 108067, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.6477037037037, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.009925925925927, "tt_hits": 2349, "tt_cutoffs": 384, "beta_cutoffs": 5687, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5670.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6470.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1842, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1401, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18578, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 128, 95, 140, 109, 108, 141, 157, 81, 129, 130, 123, 83, 97, 80, 65, 82, 79, 84 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9582, "avg_search_time_ms": 871.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 100495, "safety_nodes": 151, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 100646, "avg_nodes": 9149.636363636364, "eval_calls": 75089, "avg_eval_calls": 6826.272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75089, "pattern_eval_ns": 1651950, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.999893459761083, "pattern_frame_queries": 75089, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1651950, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.999893459761083, "pattern_frame_updates": 200896, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3051852881, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15191.207794082511, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23767, "avg_candidate_generations": 2160.6363636363635, "candidate_moves_total": 1706283, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.79210670257079, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 661, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 23756, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1705622, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 588513, "avg_legality_checks": 53501.181818181816, "illegal_moves_skipped": 678, "root_legality_checks": 661, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 587852, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 678, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2466770, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 224251.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5673161819, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2299.834122759722, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25882, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2352.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 153000077, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5911.447222007573, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 877, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7060937, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14933, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 118780097, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10072, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27159043, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68156, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6196.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 625259667, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9173.9489846822, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89707, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8155.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 266225164, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2967.7189516983067, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1502873187, "stage_ordering_ns": 748410038, "stage_eval_ns": 3053504831, "stage_threat_ns": 4246619727, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 447104, "root_tactical_annotations": 2232, "search_tactical_annotations": 444872, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 200907, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1244472100, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 382601, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2804516964, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47580, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1873184129, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 100448, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156919635, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 200896, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26463252, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 133961, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 148316669, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 201051, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 783005146, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 112092, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14247776, "child_limit_applications": 23756, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23756, "child_cap_hits": 23756, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23756, "child_moves_before_total": 1704944, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1704944, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 381324, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 381324, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.76898467755514, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.05169220407476, "tt_hits": 10895, "tt_cutoffs": 1603, "beta_cutoffs": 18853, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4798.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5526.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1161, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8983, "avg_search_time_ms": 898.3, "search_nodes": 73647, "safety_nodes": 904, "corridor_nodes": 721, "corridor_branch_probes": 880, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 279, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 30, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 25, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 279, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 30, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 166, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 10019920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 75272, "avg_nodes": 7527.2, "eval_calls": 44337, "avg_eval_calls": 4433.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44337, "pattern_eval_ns": 1000743, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.571283578049936, "pattern_frame_queries": 44337, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1000743, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.571283578049936, "pattern_frame_updates": 147182, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1830085544, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12434.166841053933, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25418, "avg_candidate_generations": 2541.8, "candidate_moves_total": 1764586, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.42269258006138, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 603, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 25408, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1763983, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 784720, "avg_legality_checks": 78472.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 469, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 784720, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 469, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2457992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 245799.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5493063024, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2234.776607897829, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14136, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1413.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50561832, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3576.8132427843802, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 473, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4482155, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4341, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30876848, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9322, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15202829, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 78537, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7853.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 719916760, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9166.593580096005, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 105475, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10547.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 306600665, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2906.856269258118, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1987863403, "stage_ordering_ns": 786186526, "stage_eval_ns": 1831086287, "stage_threat_ns": 4291090377, "stage_proof_ns": 47057309, "tactical_annotations": 434504, "root_tactical_annotations": 418, "search_tactical_annotations": 434086, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 148684, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 959810410, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 440822, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3173856028, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51267, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1989022400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74337, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118661877, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1492, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8290542, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 148674, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20035220, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52682, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 142670151, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 291185, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1002197770, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 90637, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10436300, "child_limit_applications": 25408, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25408, "child_cap_hits": 25408, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25408, "child_moves_before_total": 1763514, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1763514, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 277150, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 277150, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.4078243073048, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.907981738035264, "tt_hits": 11365, "tt_cutoffs": 3846, "beta_cutoffs": 20586, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 5.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3300.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4100.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 42, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1402, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21094, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 85, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 123, 71, 99, 137, 97, 83, 80, 65, 96, 98, 128, 64, 144 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 18258, "avg_search_time_ms": 1521.5, "search_nodes": 160872, "safety_nodes": 583, "corridor_nodes": 2386, "corridor_branch_probes": 2659, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1014, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2366, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2366, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 45, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 25, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1014, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 45, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 45, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 308, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 21989760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2026960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 163841, "avg_nodes": 13653.416666666666, "eval_calls": 107246, "avg_eval_calls": 8937.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107246, "pattern_eval_ns": 2340888, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.827275609346735, "pattern_frame_queries": 107246, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2340888, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.827275609346735, "pattern_frame_updates": 321626, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4978314202, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15478.581339817054, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 50530, "avg_candidate_generations": 4210.833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4338301, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.85594696220068, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 864, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 50518, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4337437, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1111347, "avg_legality_checks": 92612.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1366, "root_legality_checks": 864, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1110483, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1366, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4788863, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 399071.9166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10800976683, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2255.4365583229255, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54885, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4573.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 284340491, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5180.659396920834, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2133, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14993890, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 30091, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 199122866, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22367, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 67788884, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 294, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2434851, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 111398, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9283.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 986626764, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8856.772688917215, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 143498, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11958.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 401589859, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2798.5746073116, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2774519280, "stage_ordering_ns": 1810376592, "stage_eval_ns": 4980655090, "stage_threat_ns": 8283728451, "stage_proof_ns": 358807943, "tactical_annotations": 926663, "root_tactical_annotations": 2932, "search_tactical_annotations": 923731, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 326460, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2073013282, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 952745, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5848847977, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 102363, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3886041789, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 163224, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 259197304, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4822, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28865171, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 326448, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43511049, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 250473, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 260863240, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 458447, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1336051922, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 217743, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30293668, "child_limit_applications": 50518, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 50518, "child_cap_hits": 50518, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 50518, "child_moves_before_total": 4336071, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4336071, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 497663, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 497663, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.832198424324, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.851201551922086, "tt_hits": 25104, "tt_cutoffs": 3050, "beta_cutoffs": 39866, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 4.833333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 4.833333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2115.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2599.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 778, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2825, "avg_search_time_ms": 256.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 26384, "safety_nodes": 1149, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 27533, "avg_nodes": 2503.0, "eval_calls": 18102, "avg_eval_calls": 1645.6363636363637, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 18102, "pattern_eval_ns": 397104, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.937023533311237, "pattern_frame_queries": 18102, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 397104, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.937023533311237, "pattern_frame_updates": 52668, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 591145602, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11223.999430394168, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7847, "avg_candidate_generations": 713.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 608098, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.49432904294635, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 7836, "search_candidate_moves_total": 607312, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 253472, "avg_legality_checks": 23042.909090909092, "illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 253472, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 773198, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 70290.72727272728, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1724372828, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2230.182731978096, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3895, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 354.09090909090907, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14694914, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3772.7635430038513, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 98, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 918227, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1280, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8982187, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2517, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4794500, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2111.2727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 223881540, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9640.093868411988, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31666, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2878.7272727272725, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 101284489, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3198.5248847344155, "stage_move_gen_ns": 637204022, "stage_ordering_ns": 260753672, "stage_eval_ns": 591542706, "stage_threat_ns": 1310791406, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 124487, "root_tactical_annotations": 306, "search_tactical_annotations": 124181, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 52679, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 336349620, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 120119, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 925280822, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15744, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 597457809, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 26334, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 40419082, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 52668, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6818900, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32788, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 91628012, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 71580, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 235911010, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 20119, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1922982, "child_limit_applications": 7836, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 7836, "child_cap_hits": 7836, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 7836, "child_moves_before_total": 607228, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 607228, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 125406, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 125406, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.4920877998979, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00382848392037, "tt_hits": 2469, "tt_cutoffs": 396, "beta_cutoffs": 6642, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5815.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6542.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1835, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1403, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8341, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 81, 141, 126, 127, 98, 140, 113, 129, 83, 128, 84, 70, 82, 85, 80 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5091, "avg_search_time_ms": 636.375, "search_nodes": 91010, "safety_nodes": 66, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91076, "avg_nodes": 11384.5, "eval_calls": 70672, "avg_eval_calls": 8834.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70672, "pattern_eval_ns": 1373674, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.437316051618744, "pattern_frame_queries": 70672, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1373674, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.437316051618744, "pattern_frame_updates": 181956, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1650155137, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9068.97896744268, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19241, "avg_candidate_generations": 2405.125, "candidate_moves_total": 1238175, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.35086533963931, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 420, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 19233, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1237755, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 538566, "avg_legality_checks": 67320.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 552, "root_legality_checks": 420, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 538146, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 552, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2145988, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 268248.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2967156539, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1382.6529034645114, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20910, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2613.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 74460879, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3561.0176470588235, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3412312, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11633, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 59597474, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8611, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11451093, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60803, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7600.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 343173256, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5644.018485929971, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 83694, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10461.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 153267247, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1831.281179057041, "stage_move_gen_ns": 837107967, "stage_ordering_ns": 336397308, "stage_eval_ns": 1651528811, "stage_threat_ns": 2228070871, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 241166, "root_tactical_annotations": 1503, "search_tactical_annotations": 239663, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 181964, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 690015119, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 228786, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1425682061, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38513, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 950080642, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 90978, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91889494, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 181956, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15790083, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 50781, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 66030146, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 139485, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 409564863, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 50900, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4694114, "child_limit_applications": 19233, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19233, "child_cap_hits": 19233, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19233, "child_moves_before_total": 1237203, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1237203, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 307795, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 307795, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 64.32709405708938, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.003483595902875, "tt_hits": 7388, "tt_cutoffs": 1073, "beta_cutoffs": 14640, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3928.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4928.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1034, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 3243, "avg_search_time_ms": 463.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 38003, "safety_nodes": 435, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 18, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 18, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 18, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 139, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 27811280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1986720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 38438, "avg_nodes": 5491.142857142857, "eval_calls": 21346, "avg_eval_calls": 3049.4285714285716, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 21346, "pattern_eval_ns": 416932, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.532090321371687, "pattern_frame_queries": 21346, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 416932, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.532090321371687, "pattern_frame_updates": 75938, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 456769021, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6015.0256920119045, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15699, "avg_candidate_generations": 2242.714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 1020618, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.01165679342633, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 363, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 15692, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1020255, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 735692, "avg_legality_checks": 105098.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1463, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 735692, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1463, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1778203, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 254029.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2117576799, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1190.852112497842, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13044, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1863.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_ns": 23625784, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1811.2376571603802, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1482, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8434862, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2000, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9933756, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9562, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5257166, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 66228, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9461.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 406169251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6132.893202270943, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 96478, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13782.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 206755395, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2143.0315201393064, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1020759684, "stage_ordering_ns": 249283746, "stage_eval_ns": 457185953, "stage_threat_ns": 1462269667, "stage_proof_ns": 20073109, "tactical_annotations": 197491, "root_tactical_annotations": 557, "search_tactical_annotations": 196934, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 75981, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 272790457, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 166716, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1139659763, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31504, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 635233738, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37987, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 37467712, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 36, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 86690, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 75974, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6259387, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 25733, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 108219073, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 109438, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 396091711, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 62320, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6005658, "child_limit_applications": 15692, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15692, "child_cap_hits": 15692, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15692, "child_moves_before_total": 1018792, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1018792, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 149319, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 149319, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 64.92429263318888, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.515613051236299, "tt_hits": 7467, "tt_cutoffs": 931, "beta_cutoffs": 12798, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.857142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3545.5714285714284, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4688.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 554, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1404, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21227, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 159, 67, 52, 95, 53, 83, 80, 51, 143, 175, 35, 65, 49, 37, 79, 84, 85, 98, 70, 129, 113, 99, 115, 114, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 18972, "avg_search_time_ms": 1264.8, "search_nodes": 258856, "safety_nodes": 778, "corridor_nodes": 3040, "corridor_branch_probes": 3379, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1342, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 3018, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3018, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1342, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 429, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 41708160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2026960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 262674, "avg_nodes": 17511.6, "eval_calls": 179362, "avg_eval_calls": 11957.466666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 179362, "pattern_eval_ns": 3591453, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.02348881033887, "pattern_frame_queries": 179362, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3591453, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.02348881033887, "pattern_frame_updates": 517562, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5388946774, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10412.176268736886, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 75203, "avg_candidate_generations": 5013.533333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 6802360, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.45330638405383, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1165, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 75188, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6801195, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1679234, "avg_legality_checks": 111948.93333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3552, "root_legality_checks": 1165, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1678069, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3549, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7068734, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 471248.93333333335, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10729354257, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1517.860801806943, "renju_forbidden_checks": 66315, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4421.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 282351014, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4257.724707833823, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4259, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30159047, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37086, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 187495262, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24638, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 62648878, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 332, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2047827, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 181428, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12095.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1057131779, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5826.728944815574, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 225182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15012.133333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 408752361, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1815.2088577239745, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2883066261, "stage_ordering_ns": 1863899002, "stage_eval_ns": 5392538227, "stage_threat_ns": 8473368241, "stage_proof_ns": 265165617, "tactical_annotations": 1501831, "root_tactical_annotations": 4093, "search_tactical_annotations": 1497738, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 523725, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2324718138, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1546789, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5738438167, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 152017, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3644419030, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 261855, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 302855004, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6148, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22667520, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 523710, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51523611, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 410643, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 330018642, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 809389, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1494513849, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 281799, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33165801, "child_limit_applications": 75188, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 75188, "child_cap_hits": 75188, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 75188, "child_moves_before_total": 6797646, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6797646, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 804871, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 804871, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.40865563653774, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.704780018087993, "tt_hits": 32293, "tt_cutoffs": 4233, "beta_cutoffs": 59486, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5202.933333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5736.266666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1785, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2242, "avg_search_time_ms": 160.14285714285714, "search_nodes": 33035, "safety_nodes": 1641, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34676, "avg_nodes": 2476.8571428571427, "eval_calls": 22539, "avg_eval_calls": 1609.9285714285713, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22539, "pattern_eval_ns": 442360, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.62642530724522, "pattern_frame_queries": 22539, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 442360, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.62642530724522, "pattern_frame_updates": 65940, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 487244922, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7389.216287534122, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9944, "avg_candidate_generations": 710.2857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 802153, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.66703539823008, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1092, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 9930, "search_candidate_moves_total": 801061, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 313550, "avg_legality_checks": 22396.428571428572, "illegal_moves_skipped": 387, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 313550, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 387, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 959160, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 68511.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1297428640, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1352.671754451812, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5620, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 401.42857142857144, "renju_forbidden_ns": 24145616, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4296.372953736654, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 438, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3710753, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2312, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13949930, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2848, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6256752, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 228181, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 31293, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2235.214285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 177330638, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5666.782922698367, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41267, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2947.6428571428573, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 75823767, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1837.394697942666, "stage_move_gen_ns": 478721852, "stage_ordering_ns": 211925420, "stage_eval_ns": 487687282, "stage_threat_ns": 1035647696, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 178455, "root_tactical_annotations": 331, "search_tactical_annotations": 178124, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 65954, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 270095776, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 173623, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 723184031, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19953, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 437407734, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 32970, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 34751750, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 65940, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5803860, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44746, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 71871825, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 108915, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 213645960, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 24794, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1812279, "child_limit_applications": 9930, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9930, "child_cap_hits": 9930, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9930, "child_moves_before_total": 800674, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 800674, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 160409, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 160409, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.63182275931521, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.1539778449144, "tt_hits": 2931, "tt_cutoffs": 501, "beta_cutoffs": 8463, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6405.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6977.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1909, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1405, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 39690, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 110, 96, 99, 64, 128, 100, 126, 115, 114, 130, 145, 80, 48, 66, 129, 144, 127, 125, 94, 81, 51, 78, 79, 158, 172, 65, 69, 84, 67, 116, 102, 132, 68, 148 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 16242, "avg_search_time_ms": 902.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 196902, "safety_nodes": 753, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 197655, "avg_nodes": 10980.833333333334, "eval_calls": 151050, "avg_eval_calls": 8391.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 151050, "pattern_eval_ns": 3272694, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.666295928500496, "pattern_frame_queries": 151050, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3272694, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.666295928500496, "pattern_frame_updates": 393640, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4496159936, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11422.009795752465, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43591, "avg_candidate_generations": 2421.722222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 3611161, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.84189396893854, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1349, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 43573, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3609812, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1262546, "avg_legality_checks": 70141.44444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1222, "root_legality_checks": 1349, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 1261197, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1218, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4264866, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 236937.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9346808715, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2191.583209179374, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42023, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2334.6111111111113, "renju_forbidden_ns": 155535892, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3701.2086714418297, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1936, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13343034, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20307, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 102484283, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19760, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39509235, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 199340, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 118122, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6562.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1031029248, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8728.511606643979, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 153179, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8509.944444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 432401611, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2822.851768192768, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3111336303, "stage_ordering_ns": 1442843773, "stage_eval_ns": 4499432630, "stage_threat_ns": 7110162302, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 702589, "root_tactical_annotations": 3818, "search_tactical_annotations": 698771, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 393658, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2276441605, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 628344, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4475151271, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 87263, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2970971536, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 196820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 289209616, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 393640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48889708, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 224378, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 284944918, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 316688, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1218768686, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 161523, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20470102, "child_limit_applications": 43573, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43573, "child_cap_hits": 43573, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43573, "child_moves_before_total": 3608594, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3608594, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 697748, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 697748, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.81720331397884, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01331099534115, "tt_hits": 18504, "tt_cutoffs": 2197, "beta_cutoffs": 33710, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5400.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5844.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1238, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 23431, "avg_search_time_ms": 1378.2941176470588, "search_nodes": 166203, "safety_nodes": 1432, "corridor_nodes": 1356, "corridor_branch_probes": 1621, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 9, "corridor_depth_exits": 462, "corridor_neutral_exits": 53, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1337, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1337, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 57, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 62, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 462, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 57, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 339, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6140000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 168991, "avg_nodes": 9940.64705882353, "eval_calls": 99721, "avg_eval_calls": 5865.941176470588, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 99721, "pattern_eval_ns": 2228648, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.34883324475286, "pattern_frame_queries": 99721, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2228648, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.34883324475286, "pattern_frame_updates": 332196, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3583981317, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10788.755183686739, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 61920, "avg_candidate_generations": 3642.3529411764707, "candidate_moves_total": 5179322, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.6453811369509, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1279, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 61903, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5178043, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 3111558, "avg_legality_checks": 183032.82352941178, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2139, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3111558, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2139, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7250397, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 426493.9411764706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15266190572, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2105.566160308187, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44194, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2599.6470588235293, "renju_forbidden_ns": 137157665, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3103.53588722451, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2726, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22203360, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11825, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71066435, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29617, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43620980, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 266890, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 268370, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15786.470588235294, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2517317827, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9380.026929239482, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 361364, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21256.70588235294, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1170740884, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3239.7828339292237, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7488450651, "stage_ordering_ns": 2066093584, "stage_eval_ns": 3586209965, "stage_threat_ns": 10072716315, "stage_proof_ns": 87889025, "tactical_annotations": 1024590, "root_tactical_annotations": 2618, "search_tactical_annotations": 1021972, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 335001, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2092741205, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 983873, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7623955613, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 124824, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4220187288, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 167492, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 260661579, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2788, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18393848, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 334984, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43905085, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 224502, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1110180212, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 546996, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2222132292, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 253092, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33058985, "child_limit_applications": 61903, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 61903, "child_cap_hits": 61903, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 61903, "child_moves_before_total": 5175904, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5175904, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 633842, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 633842, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.61313668158247, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.239277579438799, "tt_hits": 28483, "tt_cutoffs": 4476, "beta_cutoffs": 50474, "depth_sum": 102, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 102, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.29411764705882354, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2885.470588235294, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3356.0588235294117, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1406, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 33306, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 110, 109, 82, 124, 126, 81, 94, 78, 80, 64, 66, 108, 128, 144, 68, 54, 52, 38, 95, 146, 162, 125, 158, 142, 143, 173, 127, 159, 79 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 29268, "avg_search_time_ms": 1721.6470588235295, "search_nodes": 252980, "safety_nodes": 410, "corridor_nodes": 6694, "corridor_branch_probes": 7063, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3176, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 6668, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6668, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 58, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3176, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 58, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 431, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 39773280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 260084, "avg_nodes": 15299.058823529413, "eval_calls": 163709, "avg_eval_calls": 9629.941176470587, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 163709, "pattern_eval_ns": 3584442, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.89520429542664, "pattern_frame_queries": 163709, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3584442, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.89520429542664, "pattern_frame_updates": 505766, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6989462565, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13819.557987290566, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 83046, "avg_candidate_generations": 4885.058823529412, "candidate_moves_total": 7483305, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.11036052308359, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1314, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 83029, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7481991, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1897910, "avg_legality_checks": 111641.76470588235, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1547, "root_legality_checks": 1314, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1896596, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1547, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7980349, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 469432.29411764705, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17483409535, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2190.8076369842975, "renju_forbidden_checks": 51532, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3031.294117647059, "renju_forbidden_ns": 209519084, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4065.8054024683693, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1832, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13540596, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25804, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 136814363, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23317, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 55860029, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 579, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3304096, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 213893, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12581.941176470587, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1838213553, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8594.079997942898, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 277208, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16306.35294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 755664240, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2725.9827999191943, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4602276469, "stage_ordering_ns": 2918333445, "stage_eval_ns": 6993047007, "stage_threat_ns": 13886449274, "stage_proof_ns": 780138310, "tactical_annotations": 2084088, "root_tactical_annotations": 5755, "search_tactical_annotations": 2078333, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 519235, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3261774348, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2066089, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9991210184, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 169537, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6154868427, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 259609, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 408661824, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 13452, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 85691573, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 519218, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67654842, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 731030, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 645541568, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 808107, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2254816854, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 544951, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 71456503, "child_limit_applications": 83029, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 83029, "child_cap_hits": 83029, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 83029, "child_moves_before_total": 7480444, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7480444, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 1159534, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1159534, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.09435257560611, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.965409676137254, "tt_hits": 46163, "tt_cutoffs": 6150, "beta_cutoffs": 68959, "depth_sum": 91, "avg_depth": 5.352941176470588, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 91, "avg_effective_depth": 5.352941176470588, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 7, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.4117647058823529, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 7, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.4117647058823529, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1209.5882352941176, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1492.5882352941176, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 4020, "avg_search_time_ms": 251.25, "search_nodes": 37563, "safety_nodes": 1740, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 39303, "avg_nodes": 2456.4375, "eval_calls": 26198, "avg_eval_calls": 1637.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 26198, "pattern_eval_ns": 580533, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.159439651881822, "pattern_frame_queries": 26198, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 580533, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.159439651881822, "pattern_frame_updates": 74976, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 869474534, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11596.704732180964, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10745, "avg_candidate_generations": 671.5625, "candidate_moves_total": 865647, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.56277338296883, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1229, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 10729, "search_candidate_moves_total": 864418, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 354621, "avg_legality_checks": 22163.8125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 125, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 354621, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1114798, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 69674.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2420972898, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2171.669574218827, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5461, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 341.3125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 22571185, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4133.159677714704, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 127, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1195766, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2157, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15231325, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3177, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6144094, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39196, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2449.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 359600199, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9174.410628635575, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 52816, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3301.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 156776833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2968.3586981217813, "stage_move_gen_ns": 877024395, "stage_ordering_ns": 355692950, "stage_eval_ns": 870055067, "stage_threat_ns": 1883612364, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 226757, "root_tactical_annotations": 371, "search_tactical_annotations": 226386, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 74992, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 481585068, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 219855, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1331518868, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21565, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 780715951, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37488, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 58300860, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 74976, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9766231, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 64567, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 158965428, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 133714, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 391460326, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 28476, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2441337, "child_limit_applications": 10729, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10729, "child_cap_hits": 10729, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10729, "child_moves_before_total": 864293, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 864293, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 184270, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 184270, "child_moves_after_max": 29, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 29, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.5567154441234, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.174946406934477, "tt_hits": 3202, "tt_cutoffs": 561, "beta_cutoffs": 9065, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6496.9375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.9375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1862, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1407, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 38739, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 96, 141, 82, 142, 110, 124, 97, 67, 98, 156, 171, 95, 114, 66, 64, 80, 99, 100, 69, 84, 68, 54, 113, 53, 115, 116, 71, 85, 81, 132, 148, 65, 129, 145, 70, 72, 83, 128, 55, 41, 143, 157, 87, 101, 39, 103, 23 ], "move_count": 51, "black_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 25496, "avg_search_time_ms": 1062.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 312813, "safety_nodes": 805, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 313618, "avg_nodes": 13067.416666666666, "eval_calls": 235331, "avg_eval_calls": 9805.458333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 235331, "pattern_eval_ns": 4986487, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.189248335323438, "pattern_frame_queries": 235331, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4986487, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.189248335323438, "pattern_frame_updates": 625402, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7982474503, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12763.749561082312, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 73000, "avg_candidate_generations": 3041.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 6806088, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.23408219178083, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1977, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 72976, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6804111, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 2039028, "avg_legality_checks": 84959.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2841, "root_legality_checks": 1977, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 2037051, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2840, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7389485, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 307895.2083333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14664488357, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1984.5074936886672, "renju_forbidden_checks": 114264, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4761.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 400807763, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3507.734395785199, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3761, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21369464, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 62400, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 297336662, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 48090, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 82070487, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 31150, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 213170, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8882.083333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1623115791, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7614.184880611719, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 271149, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11297.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 644848538, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2378.207325123825, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4505966771, "stage_ordering_ns": 2183793798, "stage_eval_ns": 7987460990, "stage_threat_ns": 10706444870, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2118274, "root_tactical_annotations": 6910, "search_tactical_annotations": 2111364, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 625426, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3377032346, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1798768, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6768251854, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 146111, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4146269790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 312701, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 431332791, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 625402, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 72818533, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 901087, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 445659616, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 751549, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2176071106, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 465638, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 57009346, "child_limit_applications": 72976, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 72976, "child_cap_hits": 72976, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 72976, "child_moves_before_total": 6801271, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6801271, "child_moves_before_max": 131, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 131, "child_moves_after_total": 1214964, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1214964, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.19873657092742, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.648816049112035, "tt_hits": 33676, "tt_cutoffs": 4394, "beta_cutoffs": 57751, "depth_sum": 112, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 112, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5684.541666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6017.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 649, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 13220, "avg_search_time_ms": 574.7826086956521, "search_nodes": 119954, "safety_nodes": 2594, "corridor_nodes": 921, "corridor_branch_probes": 1231, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 16, "corridor_depth_exits": 318, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 56, "corridor_plies_followed": 912, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 912, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 33, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 318, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 56, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 33, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 30, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 3, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 63, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 16008240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2003760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 123469, "avg_nodes": 5368.217391304348, "eval_calls": 69785, "avg_eval_calls": 3034.1304347826085, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 69785, "pattern_eval_ns": 1467475, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.028516156767214, "pattern_frame_queries": 69785, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1467475, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.028516156767214, "pattern_frame_updates": 239618, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2358999605, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9844.834716089776, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44712, "avg_candidate_generations": 1944.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3918953, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.64879674360351, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1906, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 44689, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3917047, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1801603, "avg_legality_checks": 78330.56521739131, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2218, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1801603, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2218, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4492848, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 195341.21739130435, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8032486854, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1787.8385500689096, "renju_forbidden_checks": 59271, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2577.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 117961295, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1990.2025442459212, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3059, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13726558, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18477, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 63686560, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37707, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40480407, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 67770, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 152302, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6621.826086956522, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1114470068, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7317.501201560059, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 195721, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8509.608695652174, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 447705665, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2287.468718226455, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3573335615, "stage_ordering_ns": 1222429070, "stage_eval_ns": 2360467080, "stage_threat_ns": 5933827975, "stage_proof_ns": 45861576, "tactical_annotations": 1183180, "root_tactical_annotations": 543, "search_tactical_annotations": 1182637, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 241531, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1277109481, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1120568, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4435353352, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90020, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2468546782, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 120754, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 165497397, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1890, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9507829, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 241508, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27089959, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 252856, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 216754293, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 721090, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1717439699, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 209234, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19269957, "child_limit_applications": 44689, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44689, "child_cap_hits": 44689, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44689, "child_moves_before_total": 3914829, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3914829, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 608670, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 608670, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.6016245608539, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.620130233390768, "tt_hits": 20507, "tt_cutoffs": 5335, "beta_cutoffs": 37691, "depth_sum": 144, "avg_depth": 6.260869565217392, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 144, "avg_effective_depth": 6.260869565217392, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.043478260869565216, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.043478260869565216, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6431.217391304348, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6779.04347826087, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1408, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11840, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 158, 82, 67, 110, 68, 98, 95, 66, 50, 144, 128, 114, 130, 99, 100, 129, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10389, "avg_search_time_ms": 944.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 124958, "safety_nodes": 282, "corridor_nodes": 5935, "corridor_branch_probes": 6310, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2823, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 5908, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5908, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2823, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 57, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 432, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 39724400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 131175, "avg_nodes": 11925.0, "eval_calls": 79849, "avg_eval_calls": 7259.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79849, "pattern_eval_ns": 1602207, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.065461057746496, "pattern_frame_queries": 79849, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1602207, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.065461057746496, "pattern_frame_updates": 249802, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2361545294, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9453.668481437298, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42365, "avg_candidate_generations": 3851.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 3366702, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.46894842440695, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 687, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 42354, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3366015, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 918310, "avg_legality_checks": 83482.72727272728, "illegal_moves_skipped": 830, "root_legality_checks": 687, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 917623, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 829, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4176359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 379669.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6219844406, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1489.2983112802324, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20834, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1894.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 79635284, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3822.3713161178844, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 935, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5354740, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10238, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 51578532, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9214, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20938770, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 447, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1763242, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 88268, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8024.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 519369296, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5884.004350387457, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 115520, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10501.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 221201666, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1914.8343663434903, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1546546922, "stage_ordering_ns": 977800324, "stage_eval_ns": 2363147501, "stage_threat_ns": 5004980031, "stage_proof_ns": 440098547, "tactical_annotations": 648450, "root_tactical_annotations": 2553, "search_tactical_annotations": 645897, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 261747, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1164050876, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 812059, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3585699804, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 87725, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2346409413, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 130868, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 152641646, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 11934, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 49950562, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 261736, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24675017, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 164041, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 112291632, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 243373, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 595847325, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 241036, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 27962126, "child_limit_applications": 42354, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42354, "child_cap_hits": 42354, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42354, "child_moves_before_total": 3365186, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3365186, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 393571, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 393571, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.4537942107003, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.292416300703593, "tt_hits": 25763, "tt_cutoffs": 2698, "beta_cutoffs": 33553, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 5.181818181818182, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 5.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4815.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5543.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1805, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 1442, "avg_search_time_ms": 144.2, "search_nodes": 23398, "safety_nodes": 874, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 24272, "avg_nodes": 2427.2, "eval_calls": 16204, "avg_eval_calls": 1620.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 16204, "pattern_eval_ns": 315570, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.474821031843987, "pattern_frame_queries": 16204, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 315570, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.474821031843987, "pattern_frame_updates": 46706, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 309689488, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6630.614653363594, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6774, "avg_candidate_generations": 677.4, "candidate_moves_total": 483797, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.41969294360791, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 625, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 6764, "search_candidate_moves_total": 483172, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 215648, "avg_legality_checks": 21564.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 119, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 215648, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 119, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 662637, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 66263.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 850019779, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1282.7834530821551, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3004, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 300.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10158522, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3381.6651131824233, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 761835, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1163, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6826856, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1711, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2512141, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57690, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 20158, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2015.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 115703387, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5739.8247345966865, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 28019, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2801.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 54510073, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1945.4681823048645, "stage_move_gen_ns": 311222183, "stage_ordering_ns": 123692376, "stage_eval_ns": 310005058, "stage_threat_ns": 677765268, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 97673, "root_tactical_annotations": 311, "search_tactical_annotations": 97362, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 46716, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 181006468, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 94040, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 468236811, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13593, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 302003121, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 23353, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 23310750, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 46706, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 3955082, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 24917, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 48127411, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 55524, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 117978469, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 17232, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1256157, "child_limit_applications": 6764, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6764, "child_cap_hits": 6764, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6764, "child_moves_before_total": 483053, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 483053, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 108289, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 108289, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.41528681253696, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.009609698403313, "tt_hits": 2340, "tt_cutoffs": 385, "beta_cutoffs": 5698, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5768.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6568.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1904, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1409, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25922, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 53, 95, 111, 125, 69, 55, 68, 155, 169, 110, 140, 80, 65, 66, 38, 23, 37, 94, 108, 21, 39, 25, 36, 40, 35 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 22789, "avg_search_time_ms": 1266.0555555555557, "search_nodes": 226327, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 227124, "avg_nodes": 12618.0, "eval_calls": 144744, "avg_eval_calls": 8041.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 144744, "pattern_eval_ns": 3174154, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.929434035262258, "pattern_frame_queries": 144744, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3174154, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.929434035262258, "pattern_frame_updates": 452446, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5727308559, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12658.546122631209, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 75582, "avg_candidate_generations": 4199.0, "candidate_moves_total": 6442313, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.2360747267868, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 75564, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6441011, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1597541, "avg_legality_checks": 88752.27777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1795, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1596239, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1795, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6104706, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 339150.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13130860937, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2150.9407557055165, "renju_forbidden_checks": 53946, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2997.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 294449370, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5458.224335446557, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3148, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25295195, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25249, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 185166037, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25535, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 83867768, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 120370, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 173783, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9654.611111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1428691383, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8221.122796821322, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 227666, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12648.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 571760756, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2511.401597076419, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3899120160, "stage_ordering_ns": 2529644626, "stage_eval_ns": 5730482713, "stage_threat_ns": 10550256335, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1611248, "root_tactical_annotations": 4128, "search_tactical_annotations": 1607120, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 452464, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2697579503, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1211598, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7374774183, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 151267, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5074611805, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 226223, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 343071179, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 452446, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57320051, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 466521, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 462767700, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 593797, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1836917207, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 550930, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 77511419, "child_limit_applications": 75564, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 75564, "child_cap_hits": 75564, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 75564, "child_moves_before_total": 6439216, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6439216, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 903504, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 903504, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.21539357365941, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.956804827695729, "tt_hits": 46663, "tt_cutoffs": 5915, "beta_cutoffs": 62365, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4381.611111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4826.055555555556, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 915, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 3116, "avg_search_time_ms": 183.2941176470588, "search_nodes": 84204, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 1077, "corridor_branch_probes": 1319, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 10, "corridor_depth_exits": 402, "corridor_neutral_exits": 24, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 1057, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1052, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 402, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 218, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 216960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 87172, "avg_nodes": 5127.764705882353, "eval_calls": 81401, "avg_eval_calls": 4788.294117647059, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 81401, "pattern_eval_ns": 1750261, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.501713738160465, "pattern_frame_queries": 81401, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1750261, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.501713738160465, "pattern_frame_updates": 168308, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1739895475, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10337.568475651782, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2770, "avg_candidate_generations": 162.94117647058823, "candidate_moves_total": 217538, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.53357400722021, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1235, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2753, "search_candidate_moves_total": 216303, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5313, "avg_legality_checks": 312.52941176470586, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5313, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 564039, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 33178.76470588235, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1253285018, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2221.982908983244, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4306, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 253.2941176470588, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29595964, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6873.191825359962, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 55750, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4265, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29292232, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37330, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 210652, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.4705882352941178, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 279832, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6662.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.0588235294117645, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 90811, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1746.3653846153845, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14479315, "stage_ordering_ns": 90070, "stage_eval_ns": 1741645736, "stage_threat_ns": 1245804933, "stage_proof_ns": 84438301, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 170547, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1012118576, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64892, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 78461314, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 691, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 28106365, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85265, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118639584, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2222, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15632423, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 170530, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20953036, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2573, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6721.117647058823, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7191.705882352941, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1410, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16974, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 67, 83, 128, 111, 125, 81, 80, 96, 126, 66, 51, 55, 69, 85, 84, 124, 110, 95, 158, 143, 142, 94, 174 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8911, "avg_search_time_ms": 742.5833333333334, "search_nodes": 170015, "safety_nodes": 814, "corridor_nodes": 8847, "corridor_branch_probes": 9871, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4145, "corridor_neutral_exits": 46, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 8802, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8797, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 114, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 46, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4145, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 114, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 113, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 818, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 373680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 24160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 179676, "avg_nodes": 14973.0, "eval_calls": 164466, "avg_eval_calls": 13705.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 164466, "pattern_eval_ns": 3496475, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.259561246701445, "pattern_frame_queries": 164466, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3496475, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.259561246701445, "pattern_frame_updates": 339960, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3852989731, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11333.656109542299, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5526, "avg_candidate_generations": 460.5, "candidate_moves_total": 355461, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.32519001085777, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 724, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 5514, "search_candidate_moves_total": 354737, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 158802, "avg_legality_checks": 13233.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 724, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 158078, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2279281, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 189940.08333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4593871048, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2015.491309759525, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9990, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 832.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 76247269, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7632.3592592592595, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 206722, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9597, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73118671, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 166, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1417346, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 203, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1504530, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1367.6666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 133401522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8128.291615890812, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22557, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1879.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 69606083, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3085.786363434854, "stage_move_gen_ns": 378384381, "stage_ordering_ns": 187762, "stage_eval_ns": 3856486206, "stage_threat_ns": 3720689857, "stage_proof_ns": 925314195, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 357804, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2084021447, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 483107, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1263429375, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 4668, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 257562353, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 178896, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 242809645, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 17832, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 87810126, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 357792, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42619264, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 261, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4981, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4691.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5357.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1433, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8050, "avg_search_time_ms": 670.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 68037, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68850, "avg_nodes": 5737.5, "eval_calls": 39651, "avg_eval_calls": 3304.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39651, "pattern_eval_ns": 865184, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.81997931956319, "pattern_frame_queries": 39651, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 865184, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.81997931956319, "pattern_frame_updates": 135934, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1398464997, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10287.823480512601, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25722, "avg_candidate_generations": 2143.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1768989, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.77338465127129, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 749, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 25710, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1768240, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 961183, "avg_legality_checks": 80098.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 961183, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2477096, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 206424.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5155407785, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2081.23051549072, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13729, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1144.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19657343, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1431.811712433535, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 563162, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2190, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10595367, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11429, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8489854, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8960, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75770, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6314.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 633288857, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8358.042193480269, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 100926, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8410.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 261629047, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2592.285902542457, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2222912231, "stage_ordering_ns": 707597267, "stage_eval_ns": 1399330181, "stage_threat_ns": 3672865565, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 371958, "root_tactical_annotations": 901, "search_tactical_annotations": 371057, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 135946, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 824268725, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 324470, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2719818068, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51513, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1801035801, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67967, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 100690828, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 135934, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17257528, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 64333, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 211796639, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 208616, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 706759165, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 99009, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10830416, "child_limit_applications": 25710, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25710, "child_cap_hits": 25710, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25710, "child_moves_before_total": 1768144, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1768144, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 239093, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 239093, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.77261765849863, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.299611046285492, "tt_hits": 12325, "tt_cutoffs": 2607, "beta_cutoffs": 20659, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 5.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 5.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4505.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5172.416666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1411, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25689, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 110, 109, 142, 94, 96, 141, 124, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 125, 86, 72, 83, 85, 81, 80, 95, 123, 122, 108, 67, 53, 92, 138, 152, 93, 153, 78 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 24258, "avg_search_time_ms": 1347.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 247359, "safety_nodes": 811, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 248170, "avg_nodes": 13787.222222222223, "eval_calls": 162253, "avg_eval_calls": 9014.055555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 162253, "pattern_eval_ns": 3491387, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.518166073970896, "pattern_frame_queries": 162253, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3491387, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.518166073970896, "pattern_frame_updates": 494510, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6399915730, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12941.933894157854, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 78785, "avg_candidate_generations": 4376.944444444444, "candidate_moves_total": 7102457, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.14986355270673, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1337, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 78767, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7101120, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1896093, "avg_legality_checks": 105338.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2172, "root_legality_checks": 1337, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1894756, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2172, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6984121, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 388006.72222222225, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14040151634, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2010.296160962847, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65802, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3655.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 334518350, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5083.710981429136, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3617, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30410078, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 30080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 207890881, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32091, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 96084230, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 133161, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 208448, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11580.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1632013559, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7829.355805764507, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 269568, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14976.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 626142049, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2322.761043595679, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4287571472, "stage_ordering_ns": 2618046852, "stage_eval_ns": 6403407117, "stage_threat_ns": 10854250666, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1746648, "root_tactical_annotations": 4207, "search_tactical_annotations": 1742441, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 494528, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2790511466, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1357240, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7569513235, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 157673, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4979167807, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 247255, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 360082577, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 494510, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60312046, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 535356, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 515868123, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 664198, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2074127643, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 547094, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 73831342, "child_limit_applications": 78767, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 78767, "child_cap_hits": 78767, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 78767, "child_moves_before_total": 7098948, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7098948, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 940667, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 940667, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.12591567534628, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.942399735930021, "tt_hits": 47377, "tt_cutoffs": 6236, "beta_cutoffs": 64112, "depth_sum": 102, "avg_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 102, "avg_effective_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4442.722222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4887.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 952, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 1416, "avg_search_time_ms": 83.29411764705883, "search_nodes": 42782, "safety_nodes": 1927, "corridor_nodes": 957, "corridor_branch_probes": 1154, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 348, "corridor_neutral_exits": 24, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 937, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 932, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 348, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 218, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 207280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 45666, "avg_nodes": 2686.235294117647, "eval_calls": 40302, "avg_eval_calls": 2370.705882352941, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40302, "pattern_eval_ns": 842052, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.89355366979306, "pattern_frame_queries": 40302, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 842052, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.89355366979306, "pattern_frame_updates": 85464, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 696712461, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8152.116224375175, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2447, "avg_candidate_generations": 143.94117647058823, "candidate_moves_total": 194805, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.60972619534124, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1261, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 2430, "search_candidate_moves_total": 193544, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 5529, "avg_legality_checks": 325.2352941176471, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5529, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 272212, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16012.470588235294, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 549608889, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2019.0472462639414, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1440, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 84.70588235294117, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8203536, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5696.9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34850, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1401, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7901364, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36910, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 230412, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.4705882352941178, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 280131, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6669.785714285715, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.0588235294117645, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 88710, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1705.9615384615386, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13334331, "stage_ordering_ns": 76780, "stage_eval_ns": 697554513, "stage_threat_ns": 607965104, "stage_proof_ns": 68845913, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 87463, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 462704198, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 58162, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 67391904, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 650, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 24601352, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43723, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 54558231, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1982, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13769486, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 87446, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9541285, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2257, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6777.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7247.588235294118, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1412, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24310, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 81, 142, 156, 129, 126, 130, 131, 100, 86, 141, 140, 98, 109, 110, 154, 168, 146, 101, 99, 115, 66, 96, 145, 87, 143, 73 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6150, "avg_search_time_ms": 439.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 105042, "safety_nodes": 1510, "corridor_nodes": 3467, "corridor_branch_probes": 4114, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1387, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 3426, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3386, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 40, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 91, "corridor_proof_active": 41, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1387, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 91, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 8, "corridor_proof_unknown": 83, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 543, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 231680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 110019, "avg_nodes": 7858.5, "eval_calls": 101266, "avg_eval_calls": 7233.285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 101266, "pattern_eval_ns": 2188792, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.614283175004445, "pattern_frame_queries": 101266, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2188792, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.614283175004445, "pattern_frame_updates": 210002, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3014137040, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14352.896829554003, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3749, "avg_candidate_generations": 267.7857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 290966, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.61162976793811, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1033, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 3735, "search_candidate_moves_total": 289933, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 97729, "avg_legality_checks": 6980.642857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 109, "root_legality_checks": 1033, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 96696, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 104, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1375670, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 98262.14285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3248863381, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2361.6589596342146, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14636, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1045.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_ns": 117516913, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8029.305342989888, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 123, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1167965, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13247, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 106509505, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 405, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3268192, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 861, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6571251, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9666, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 690.4285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 100139287, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10359.95106559073, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12727, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 909.0714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 53480333, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4202.116209633064, "stage_move_gen_ns": 256978646, "stage_ordering_ns": 127431, "stage_eval_ns": 3016325832, "stage_threat_ns": 2284319621, "stage_proof_ns": 565601281, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 217050, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1347301106, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 210645, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 704277435, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1853, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 137602225, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108518, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159568090, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7034, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 45656797, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 217036, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27516193, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 190, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3390, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6209.357142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6780.785714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1832, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 18149, "avg_search_time_ms": 1296.357142857143, "search_nodes": 129387, "safety_nodes": 981, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 130368, "avg_nodes": 9312.0, "eval_calls": 81472, "avg_eval_calls": 5819.428571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 81472, "pattern_eval_ns": 1795802, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.041953063629222, "pattern_frame_queries": 81472, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1795802, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.041953063629222, "pattern_frame_updates": 258602, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3156957484, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12207.784487358953, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43426, "avg_candidate_generations": 3101.8571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 3747664, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.30000460553586, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1078, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 43412, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3746586, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 2252328, "avg_legality_checks": 160880.57142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12120, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2252328, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12120, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5470981, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 390784.35714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11668004456, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2132.707910336373, "renju_forbidden_checks": 101642, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7260.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 370604444, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3646.174258672596, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16659, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 131833682, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22414, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 118894585, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 62413, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 119229847, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 156, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 646330, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 203409, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14529.214285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2097846269, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10313.438780978226, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 273367, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19526.214285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1025533177, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3751.488573968328, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5626077092, "stage_ordering_ns": 1504381055, "stage_eval_ns": 3158753286, "stage_threat_ns": 7764102294, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 963205, "root_tactical_annotations": 2562, "search_tactical_annotations": 960643, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 258616, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1571406109, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 797569, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5930921574, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 86937, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3146800142, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129301, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 195552889, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 258602, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33701023, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 248381, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1051110657, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 462241, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1732648413, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 252583, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32520699, "child_limit_applications": 43412, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43412, "child_cap_hits": 43412, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43412, "child_moves_before_total": 3734466, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3734466, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 522202, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 522202, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.02381829908781, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.028978162719985, "tt_hits": 22837, "tt_cutoffs": 4419, "beta_cutoffs": 35404, "depth_sum": 84, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 84, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3869.5714285714284, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4441.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 563, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1413, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25063, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 129, 109, 108, 81, 123, 125, 80, 93, 141, 127, 143, 79, 63, 94, 145, 161, 142, 144, 140, 139, 124, 92, 91, 107, 156, 172, 121, 77, 61, 122, 62, 137 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 22054, "avg_search_time_ms": 1225.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 221586, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 222383, "avg_nodes": 12354.611111111111, "eval_calls": 140505, "avg_eval_calls": 7805.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 140505, "pattern_eval_ns": 3010981, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.42970712786022, "pattern_frame_queries": 140505, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3010981, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.42970712786022, "pattern_frame_updates": 442964, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5360560746, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12101.57201488157, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 74958, "avg_candidate_generations": 4164.333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 6416196, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.59721444008645, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 74940, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6414894, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1628419, "avg_legality_checks": 90467.72222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1555, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1627117, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1555, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6053798, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 336322.1111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12732674106, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2103.253875666152, "renju_forbidden_checks": 49647, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2758.1666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 264980799, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5337.297298930449, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2782, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23400299, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23138, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 164074372, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23713, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 77391836, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 114292, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 173818, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9656.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1385609878, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7971.61328516034, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 225854, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12547.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 553576678, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2451.0377411956397, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3911089871, "stage_ordering_ns": 2474966959, "stage_eval_ns": 5363571727, "stage_threat_ns": 10218326436, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1616831, "root_tactical_annotations": 4128, "search_tactical_annotations": 1612703, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 442982, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2580498856, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1211852, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7179208490, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 150019, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4939916126, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 221482, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 328873653, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 442964, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55316150, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 462315, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 443203267, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 599505, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1795620524, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 555011, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 74429287, "child_limit_applications": 74940, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 74940, "child_cap_hits": 74940, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 74940, "child_moves_before_total": 6413339, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6413339, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 900887, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 900887, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.57965038697625, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.021443821724047, "tt_hits": 46507, "tt_cutoffs": 6037, "beta_cutoffs": 61869, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4615.277777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5059.722222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1013, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 2989, "avg_search_time_ms": 175.8235294117647, "search_nodes": 83574, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 1131, "corridor_branch_probes": 1376, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 9, "corridor_depth_exits": 441, "corridor_neutral_exits": 24, "corridor_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_plies_followed": 1111, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1106, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 33, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 441, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 218, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 215040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 86596, "avg_nodes": 5093.882352941177, "eval_calls": 80904, "avg_eval_calls": 4759.058823529412, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80904, "pattern_eval_ns": 1720116, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.26119845743103, "pattern_frame_queries": 80904, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1720116, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.26119845743103, "pattern_frame_updates": 167048, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1643575334, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9838.940508117428, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2637, "avg_candidate_generations": 155.11764705882354, "candidate_moves_total": 209213, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.33750474023512, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1235, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2620, "search_candidate_moves_total": 207978, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5654, "avg_legality_checks": 332.5882352941176, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5654, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 530093, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 31181.941176470587, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1146487548, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2162.8045418445445, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4211, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 247.7058823529412, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30300804, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7195.631441462835, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 68140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4169, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29962904, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 74400, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 195360, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.7058823529411766, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 274092, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5958.521739130435, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2941176470588234, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 82451, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1472.3392857142858, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15176669, "stage_ordering_ns": 84780, "stage_eval_ns": 1645295450, "stage_threat_ns": 1218790965, "stage_proof_ns": 82695304, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169395, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 989624183, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 66068, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 76355083, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 689, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 26259207, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84689, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 116518410, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2330, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15444028, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169378, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20849261, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2451, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6748.764705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7219.35294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1414, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14825, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 109, 95, 98, 127, 143, 125, 140, 126, 128, 79, 63, 65, 80, 124, 123, 158, 142, 113, 114, 141, 156, 100, 170 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7521, "avg_search_time_ms": 626.75, "search_nodes": 124321, "safety_nodes": 892, "corridor_nodes": 9775, "corridor_branch_probes": 10994, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4597, "corridor_neutral_exits": 41, "corridor_terminal_exits": 30, "corridor_plies_followed": 9725, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9701, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 24, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 118, "corridor_proof_active": 50, "corridor_proof_quiet": 68, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 41, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4597, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 118, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 4, "corridor_proof_unknown": 114, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 832, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 489920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 24880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 134988, "avg_nodes": 11249.0, "eval_calls": 119474, "avg_eval_calls": 9956.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 119474, "pattern_eval_ns": 2411448, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.183872641746323, "pattern_frame_queries": 119474, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2411448, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.183872641746323, "pattern_frame_updates": 248572, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2574745309, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10358.146971501215, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4824, "avg_candidate_generations": 402.0, "candidate_moves_total": 317188, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.75207296849088, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 4812, "search_candidate_moves_total": 316466, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 115328, "avg_legality_checks": 9610.666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 114606, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1987938, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 165661.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4083199875, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2053.987536331616, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8981, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 748.4166666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51841643, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5772.368667186282, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 128491, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8454, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 46817117, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 195, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2210020, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 315, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2686015, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 18613, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1551.0833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 177333388, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9527.394186858648, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25754, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2146.1666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 93518276, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3631.2136367166268, "stage_move_gen_ns": 271684874, "stage_ordering_ns": 151200, "stage_eval_ns": 2577156757, "stage_threat_ns": 3532697313, "stage_proof_ns": 1114580554, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 268270, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1612365824, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 530966, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1589029745, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 5013, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 316231410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134129, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 185696223, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 19686, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 113733777, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 268258, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31871744, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 265, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4276, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5496.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6162.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1792, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7291, "avg_search_time_ms": 607.5833333333334, "search_nodes": 63858, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 64897, "avg_nodes": 5408.083333333333, "eval_calls": 37048, "avg_eval_calls": 3087.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37048, "pattern_eval_ns": 761052, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.542323472252214, "pattern_frame_queries": 37048, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 761052, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.542323472252214, "pattern_frame_updates": 127584, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1293303764, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10136.880517933283, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24442, "avg_candidate_generations": 2036.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1650444, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.52491612797644, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 744, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 24430, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1649700, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 825238, "avg_legality_checks": 68769.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 68, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 825238, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 68, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2240889, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 186740.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4618284701, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2060.9163153552004, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11159, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 929.9166666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19038309, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1706.0945425217312, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 627753, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2279, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11094532, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8808, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7316024, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65313, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5442.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 543321306, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8318.731431721097, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86450, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7204.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 222765916, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2576.817998843262, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1899520258, "stage_ordering_ns": 658252377, "stage_eval_ns": 1294064816, "stage_threat_ns": 3396635149, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 326181, "root_tactical_annotations": 456, "search_tactical_annotations": 325725, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 127596, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 762810616, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 292403, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2516591706, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48949, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1699321471, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 63792, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92378297, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 127584, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15881929, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 41481, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 156322030, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 201966, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 660704834, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 82734, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8972601, "child_limit_applications": 24430, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24430, "child_cap_hits": 24430, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24430, "child_moves_before_total": 1649632, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1649632, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 224342, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 224342, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.52484650020466, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.18305362259517, "tt_hits": 10980, "tt_cutoffs": 2315, "beta_cutoffs": 19544, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4506.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5172.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1415, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8227, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 95, 99, 96, 129, 79, 63, 94, 97, 81, 144, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6921, "avg_search_time_ms": 865.125, "search_nodes": 67335, "safety_nodes": 342, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67677, "avg_nodes": 8459.625, "eval_calls": 40795, "avg_eval_calls": 5099.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40795, "pattern_eval_ns": 848935, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.809780610368918, "pattern_frame_queries": 40795, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 848935, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.809780610368918, "pattern_frame_updates": 134582, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1414977570, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10513.869388179697, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24867, "avg_candidate_generations": 3108.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1855398, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.61286041742068, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 468, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 24859, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1854930, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 597332, "avg_legality_checks": 74666.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 603, "root_legality_checks": 468, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 596864, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 603, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1923488, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 240436.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4176277055, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2171.1999528980687, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14537, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1817.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61571426, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4235.497420375594, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 654, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6461045, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4429, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34868037, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9452, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20239654, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2690, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44585, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5573.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 377715427, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8471.805024111249, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 61848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7731.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 153906257, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2488.4597238390893, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1441206040, "stage_ordering_ns": 766393275, "stage_eval_ns": 1415826505, "stage_threat_ns": 3267572916, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 248399, "root_tactical_annotations": 1321, "search_tactical_annotations": 247078, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 134590, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 776611747, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 217261, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2367386406, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49777, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1807276926, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67291, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96960749, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 134582, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16440237, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 36788, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 62810763, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 130691, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 497178336, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 80920, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10173777, "child_limit_applications": 24859, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24859, "child_cap_hits": 24859, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24859, "child_moves_before_total": 1854327, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1854327, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 213756, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 213756, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.59378896978961, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.59873687598053, "tt_hits": 13217, "tt_cutoffs": 1637, "beta_cutoffs": 19570, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2622.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3622.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1001, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1296, "avg_search_time_ms": 185.14285714285714, "search_nodes": 38407, "safety_nodes": 526, "corridor_nodes": 1422, "corridor_branch_probes": 1733, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 16, "corridor_depth_exits": 642, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1410, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1395, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 15, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 642, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 3, "corridor_proof_unknown": 47, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 327, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 125280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40355, "avg_nodes": 5765.0, "eval_calls": 36196, "avg_eval_calls": 5170.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36196, "pattern_eval_ns": 739544, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.43164990606697, "pattern_frame_queries": 36196, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 739544, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.43164990606697, "pattern_frame_updates": 76774, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 574298594, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7480.378695912679, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2198, "avg_candidate_generations": 314.0, "candidate_moves_total": 147949, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.31073703366697, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 407, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 2191, "search_candidate_moves_total": 147542, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 4717, "avg_legality_checks": 673.8571428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4717, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 183573, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26224.714285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 407652077, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2220.653783508468, "renju_forbidden_checks": 898, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 128.28571428571428, "renju_forbidden_ns": 7566015, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8425.406458797328, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 832, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7337145, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 206410, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 22460, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11.571428571428571, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 609172, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7520.641975308642, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 114, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16.285714285714285, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 215850, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1893.421052631579, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12678461, "stage_ordering_ns": 68150, "stage_eval_ns": 575038138, "stage_threat_ns": 622725306, "stage_proof_ns": 75166631, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 79701, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 459229056, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 78405, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 84915947, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 716, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 24557783, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 39847, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 52745768, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2920, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16399390, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 79694, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9435145, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 122, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1961, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4844.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5987.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1968, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1416, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23584, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 95, 141, 96, 159, 175, 144, 142, 156, 93, 171, 126, 94, 100, 86, 80, 64, 110, 125, 68, 186, 201, 124, 116, 115, 84, 52, 132 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 13506, "avg_search_time_ms": 844.125, "search_nodes": 303887, "safety_nodes": 590, "corridor_nodes": 4913, "corridor_branch_probes": 5390, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2201, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 4884, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4884, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 129, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 100, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2201, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 129, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 125, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 996, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 204800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 309390, "avg_nodes": 19336.875, "eval_calls": 294779, "avg_eval_calls": 18423.6875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 294779, "pattern_eval_ns": 6032204, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.463479420175794, "pattern_frame_queries": 294779, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6032204, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.463479420175794, "pattern_frame_updates": 607682, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7284026086, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11986.575356847825, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9078, "avg_candidate_generations": 567.375, "candidate_moves_total": 818159, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.12546816479401, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1280, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 9062, "search_candidate_moves_total": 816879, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 282850, "avg_legality_checks": 17678.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "root_legality_checks": 1280, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 281570, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2918131, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 182383.1875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6525980830, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2236.3563630282533, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31818, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1988.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 222328068, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6987.493494248539, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 111, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 840614, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29882, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 215043725, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 348, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2108326, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1477, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4335403, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10918, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 682.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 107332354, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9830.770653965928, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 961.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 57031405, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3705.7443144899285, "stage_move_gen_ns": 671372295, "stage_ordering_ns": 316832, "stage_eval_ns": 7290058290, "stage_threat_ns": 4790791589, "stage_proof_ns": 707977173, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 617724, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3389456188, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 274852, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 858484845, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2805, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 172549405, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 308854, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 411603742, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10026, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 59259147, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 617708, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 71987667, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 815, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7963, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6152.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6652.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1766, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 10063, "avg_search_time_ms": 670.8666666666667, "search_nodes": 84287, "safety_nodes": 1782, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 86069, "avg_nodes": 5737.933333333333, "eval_calls": 50585, "avg_eval_calls": 3372.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50585, "pattern_eval_ns": 1067751, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.108055747751308, "pattern_frame_queries": 50585, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1067751, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.108055747751308, "pattern_frame_updates": 168394, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1645587853, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9772.247544449327, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30012, "avg_candidate_generations": 2000.8, "candidate_moves_total": 2441160, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.33946421431428, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1199, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 29997, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2439961, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 1248972, "avg_legality_checks": 83264.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 330, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1248972, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 330, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3064275, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 204285.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6366302439, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2077.5884798198595, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16303, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1086.8666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 36702415, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2251.267558118138, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 515, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3666016, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3618, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18870226, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12170, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14166173, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99433, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6628.866666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 853204349, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8580.696036527108, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 133947, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8929.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 361270527, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2697.115478510157, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2917128600, "stage_ordering_ns": 986160244, "stage_eval_ns": 1646655604, "stage_threat_ns": 4451718130, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 450085, "root_tactical_annotations": 917, "search_tactical_annotations": 449168, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 168409, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 984778319, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 407128, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3313999870, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60114, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2074952602, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84197, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121320577, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 168394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20863034, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71455, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 279004389, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 275548, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 959700727, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 103082, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10756330, "child_limit_applications": 29997, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29997, "child_cap_hits": 29997, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29997, "child_moves_before_total": 2439631, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2439631, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 304031, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 304031, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.32916624995833, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.135380204687136, "tt_hits": 14076, "tt_cutoffs": 3616, "beta_cutoffs": 23969, "depth_sum": 89, "avg_depth": 5.933333333333334, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 89, "avg_effective_depth": 5.933333333333334, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5268.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5802.133333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 518, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1417, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 38689, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 125, 83, 98, 81, 157, 172, 141, 173, 143, 140, 171, 129, 113, 99, 84, 70, 155, 169, 139, 69, 55, 123, 109, 93, 124, 94, 185, 199, 187, 203, 144, 145, 126, 51, 156, 186, 158, 154, 159 ], "move_count": 45, "black_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 36201, "avg_search_time_ms": 1723.857142857143, "search_nodes": 373500, "safety_nodes": 751, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 374251, "avg_nodes": 17821.47619047619, "eval_calls": 235075, "avg_eval_calls": 11194.047619047618, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 235075, "pattern_eval_ns": 4831890, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.554674040199938, "pattern_frame_queries": 235075, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4831890, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.554674040199938, "pattern_frame_updates": 746750, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8799728683, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11784.035732172748, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 128605, "avg_candidate_generations": 6124.047619047619, "candidate_moves_total": 11801576, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.76607441390304, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1685, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 128584, "search_candidate_moves_total": 11799891, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 2954914, "avg_legality_checks": 140710.19047619047, "illegal_moves_skipped": 14767, "root_legality_checks": 1685, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 2953229, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 14756, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10289773, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 489989.1904761905, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20272320713, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1970.142656499808, "renju_forbidden_checks": 124197, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5914.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 795965069, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6408.891269515367, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15840, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 158679680, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 55711, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 440101383, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 52577, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 196533865, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 69, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 650141, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 265205, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12628.809523809523, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2046841485, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7717.95963499934, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 344424, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16401.14285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 857522862, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2489.730280119852, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6600807829, "stage_ordering_ns": 4064961271, "stage_eval_ns": 8804560573, "stage_threat_ns": 16599025000, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 3297547, "root_tactical_annotations": 8030, "search_tactical_annotations": 3289517, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 746771, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4025781501, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2763578, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11858821149, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 257334, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7770227749, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 373375, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 524463549, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 746750, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 88608698, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 998231, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 760513779, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1507994, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3327750190, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 791322, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 101350103, "child_limit_applications": 128584, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 128584, "child_cap_hits": 128584, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 128584, "child_moves_before_total": 11785135, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 11785135, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 1658402, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1658402, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.65319946494121, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.897421141043987, "tt_hits": 64616, "tt_cutoffs": 9722, "beta_cutoffs": 105978, "depth_sum": 116, "avg_depth": 5.523809523809524, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 116, "avg_effective_depth": 5.523809523809524, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 9, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.42857142857142855, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 9, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.42857142857142855, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 775.1904761904761, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1057.8095238095239, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 2464, "avg_search_time_ms": 123.2, "search_nodes": 89955, "safety_nodes": 2009, "corridor_nodes": 2234, "corridor_branch_probes": 2788, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 7, "corridor_depth_exits": 911, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_plies_followed": 2219, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2219, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 19, "corridor_proof_completed": 19, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 911, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 70, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 357, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 86240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 94198, "avg_nodes": 4709.9, "eval_calls": 85843, "avg_eval_calls": 4292.15, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 85843, "pattern_eval_ns": 1705764, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.8707407709423, "pattern_frame_queries": 85843, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1705764, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.8707407709423, "pattern_frame_updates": 179792, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1089769655, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6061.280006896858, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4073, "avg_candidate_generations": 203.65, "candidate_moves_total": 336837, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.69997544807268, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1593, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 4053, "search_candidate_moves_total": 335244, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 15835, "avg_legality_checks": 791.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 15835, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 360975, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18048.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 714153859, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1978.4025458826789, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3190, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 159.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 26524901, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8315.015987460814, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 282461, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3000, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24612873, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 470542, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 105, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1159025, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 37420156, "stage_ordering_ns": 136140, "stage_eval_ns": 1091475419, "stage_threat_ns": 1215415657, "stage_proof_ns": 84697025, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 184394, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 919517008, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 131270, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 137928781, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1160, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 37261159, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92187, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 110267848, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4582, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28313998, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 184374, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19388022, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 245, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3656, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 2.95, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 2.95, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6923.85, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7323.85, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1418, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 37861, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 83, 95, 98, 139, 153, 140, 110, 94, 53, 93, 96, 68, 158, 174, 84, 70, 157, 172, 82, 81, 66, 50, 156, 155, 114, 130, 69, 91, 92, 123, 107, 109, 137, 67 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 23859, "avg_search_time_ms": 1255.7368421052631, "search_nodes": 581815, "safety_nodes": 694, "corridor_nodes": 9050, "corridor_branch_probes": 9961, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4071, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_plies_followed": 9007, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9007, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 17, "corridor_proof_completed": 17, "corridor_proof_checks": 176, "corridor_proof_active": 43, "corridor_proof_quiet": 133, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4071, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 176, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 173, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1403, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 288240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 591559, "avg_nodes": 31134.684210526317, "eval_calls": 568882, "avg_eval_calls": 29941.157894736843, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 568882, "pattern_eval_ns": 11420084, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.07460949722438, "pattern_frame_queries": 568882, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11420084, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.07460949722438, "pattern_frame_updates": 1163518, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 13189800083, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11336.137544068935, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12896, "avg_candidate_generations": 678.7368421052631, "candidate_moves_total": 1175989, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.19021401985111, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1584, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 12877, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1174405, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 545890, "avg_legality_checks": 28731.052631578947, "illegal_moves_skipped": 291, "root_legality_checks": 1584, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 544306, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 291, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5433971, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 285998.4736842105, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11223110173, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2065.3607045381727, "renju_forbidden_checks": 64965, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3419.2105263157896, "renju_forbidden_ns": 482843800, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7432.368198260602, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 537, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3281230, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 60364, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 467993819, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 938, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3945477, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3126, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7623274, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 19216, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1011.3684210526316, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 156092881, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8123.06832847627, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26436, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1391.3684210526317, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 83599413, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3162.332160689968, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1216708302, "stage_ordering_ns": 443580, "stage_eval_ns": 13201220167, "stage_threat_ns": 8377575472, "stage_proof_ns": 993923765, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1181903, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6150449135, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 488476, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1241219299, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 5057, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 245816041, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 590942, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 753798687, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 18366, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 100447619, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1181884, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 131660732, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 942, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 11447, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21052631578947367, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5094.263157894737, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5515.315789473684, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 640, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 13985, "avg_search_time_ms": 736.0526315789474, "search_nodes": 123607, "safety_nodes": 2503, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 126110, "avg_nodes": 6637.368421052632, "eval_calls": 73714, "avg_eval_calls": 3879.684210526316, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 73714, "pattern_eval_ns": 1515947, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.565252190899965, "pattern_frame_queries": 73714, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1515947, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.565252190899965, "pattern_frame_updates": 246986, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2226448573, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9014.472775784863, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42778, "avg_candidate_generations": 2251.4736842105262, "candidate_moves_total": 3821275, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.32804245172753, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1610, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 42759, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3819665, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 2104499, "avg_legality_checks": 110763.1052631579, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2375, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2104499, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4706889, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 247731.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8745437058, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1858.0079237050204, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55907, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2942.4736842105262, "renju_forbidden_ns": 116738662, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2088.0866796644427, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6775, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 27818671, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11301, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 41957738, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37807, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 46934133, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 28120, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 157411, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8284.78947368421, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1210316197, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7688.8921168152165, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 207812, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10937.473684210527, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 506170287, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2435.7125045714397, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4311525451, "stage_ordering_ns": 1322352609, "stage_eval_ns": 2227964520, "stage_threat_ns": 6030947598, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 871196, "root_tactical_annotations": 1003, "search_tactical_annotations": 870193, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 247005, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1342198499, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 752419, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4464603671, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 85669, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2610272486, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123493, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 170432725, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 246986, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28639738, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 169584, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 422272852, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 497152, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1431658351, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 204460, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 25072965, "child_limit_applications": 42759, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42759, "child_cap_hits": 42759, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42759, "child_moves_before_total": 3817290, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3817290, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 504793, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 504793, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.27453869360836, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.805538015388573, "tt_hits": 22651, "tt_cutoffs": 7020, "beta_cutoffs": 35224, "depth_sum": 113, "avg_depth": 5.947368421052632, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 113, "avg_effective_depth": 5.947368421052632, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5858.684210526316, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6279.736842105263, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 552, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1419, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12477, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 81, 129, 127, 98, 95, 143, 109, 108, 67, 53, 123 ], "move_count": 17, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 7914, "avg_search_time_ms": 1130.5714285714287, "search_nodes": 76291, "safety_nodes": 319, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76610, "avg_nodes": 10944.285714285714, "eval_calls": 48139, "avg_eval_calls": 6877.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48139, "pattern_eval_ns": 992574, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.618916055589022, "pattern_frame_queries": 48139, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 992574, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.618916055589022, "pattern_frame_updates": 152516, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1755160785, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11508.043647879567, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26481, "avg_candidate_generations": 3783.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1921374, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.55670103092784, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 395, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 26474, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1920979, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 664124, "avg_legality_checks": 94874.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1277, "root_legality_checks": 395, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 663729, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1277, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2156545, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 308077.85714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4798857869, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2225.252832192233, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17132, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2447.4285714285716, "renju_forbidden_ns": 103820619, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6060.040800840532, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14421125, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6983, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62704476, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8812, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26692078, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2940, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49782, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7111.714285714285, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 448448677, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9008.249507854245, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66593, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9513.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 192947051, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2897.407400177196, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1661113909, "stage_ordering_ns": 815627921, "stage_eval_ns": 1756153359, "stage_threat_ns": 3647783486, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 249776, "root_tactical_annotations": 1321, "search_tactical_annotations": 248455, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152523, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 886364609, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 224019, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2621170245, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52994, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1974908504, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76258, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 111599792, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152516, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18737367, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 34370, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 45096592, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 136649, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 600931978, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78757, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9911473, "child_limit_applications": 26474, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26474, "child_cap_hits": 26474, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26474, "child_moves_before_total": 1919702, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1919702, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 231642, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 231642, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.5127294704238, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.749792248999018, "tt_hits": 13642, "tt_cutoffs": 1645, "beta_cutoffs": 20281, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.42857142857142855, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1419.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2292.4285714285716, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 190, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 4557, "avg_search_time_ms": 759.5, "search_nodes": 142815, "safety_nodes": 317, "corridor_nodes": 323, "corridor_branch_probes": 387, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 123, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 319, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 319, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 39, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 35, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 123, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 39, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 39, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 286, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 50240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 143455, "avg_nodes": 23909.166666666668, "eval_calls": 139429, "avg_eval_calls": 23238.166666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 139429, "pattern_eval_ns": 2833599, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.322881179668506, "pattern_frame_queries": 139429, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2833599, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.322881179668506, "pattern_frame_updates": 285596, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2556031767, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8949.816408493116, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3375, "avg_candidate_generations": 562.5, "candidate_moves_total": 220115, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.21925925925926, "candidate_moves_max": 82, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 330, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 3369, "search_candidate_moves_total": 219785, "search_candidate_moves_max": 82, "legality_checks": 5514, "avg_legality_checks": 919.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5514, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 617645, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 102940.83333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1454745038, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2355.3093411263753, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6336, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1056.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62616381, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9882.635890151516, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6316, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62367260, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 249121, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15628743, "stage_ordering_ns": 103230, "stage_eval_ns": 2558865366, "stage_threat_ns": 1912935071, "stage_proof_ns": 64903091, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 286318, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1650981272, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21106, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 29118930, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 308, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12305957, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 143156, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 193652327, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 716, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3910848, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 286312, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35271694, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 110, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3025, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2659.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3902.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1823, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1420, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30467, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 80, 129, 81, 145, 161, 128, 125, 95, 79, 78, 83, 82, 109, 108, 64, 94, 93, 96, 98, 127, 130, 141, 155, 99, 85, 142, 61, 77, 51, 144, 143, 114, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 14089, "avg_search_time_ms": 782.7222222222222, "search_nodes": 330311, "safety_nodes": 1093, "corridor_nodes": 2671, "corridor_branch_probes": 2976, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 958, "corridor_neutral_exits": 64, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 2637, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2637, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 131, "corridor_proof_active": 34, "corridor_proof_quiet": 97, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 64, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 958, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 131, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 130, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 993, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 365040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 334075, "avg_nodes": 18559.722222222223, "eval_calls": 320592, "avg_eval_calls": 17810.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 320592, "pattern_eval_ns": 6535044, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.38430154214703, "pattern_frame_queries": 320592, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6535044, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.38430154214703, "pattern_frame_updates": 660516, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8209231137, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12428.512158675945, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9684, "avg_candidate_generations": 538.0, "candidate_moves_total": 823608, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.04832713754647, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1389, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 9666, "search_candidate_moves_total": 822219, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 303614, "avg_legality_checks": 16867.444444444445, "illegal_moves_skipped": 145, "root_legality_checks": 1389, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 302225, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 145, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3104412, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 172467.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6936882325, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2234.5237439489347, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25670, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1426.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 164648666, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6414.05009738995, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 157, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1535007, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25182, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 161201913, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 59, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 670592, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 272, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1241154, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4223, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 234.61111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 36707671, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8692.320861946484, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5421, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 301.1666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 18644063, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3439.2294779560966, "stage_move_gen_ns": 719157320, "stage_ordering_ns": 324921, "stage_eval_ns": 8215766181, "stage_threat_ns": 4597945290, "stage_proof_ns": 514865568, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 666070, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3617370616, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 166435, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 424586880, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1979, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 92605339, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 333026, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 441222079, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5536, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 37590060, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 666052, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 77175655, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 573, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8542, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6286.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6730.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1763, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 16360, "avg_search_time_ms": 908.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 118351, "safety_nodes": 1764, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 120115, "avg_nodes": 6673.055555555556, "eval_calls": 70813, "avg_eval_calls": 3934.0555555555557, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70813, "pattern_eval_ns": 1494698, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.107677968734553, "pattern_frame_queries": 70813, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1494698, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.107677968734553, "pattern_frame_updates": 236478, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2665375883, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11271.136778051236, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42880, "avg_candidate_generations": 2382.222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 3681409, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.8537546641791, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1428, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 42862, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3679981, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 2464398, "avg_legality_checks": 136911.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3353, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2464398, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3353, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5232753, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 290708.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10851544232, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2073.7734481256807, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30408, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1689.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 164702437, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5416.417949223888, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3440, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 37146088, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9134, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 88039464, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17834, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39516885, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 158563, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8809.055555555555, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1438716289, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9073.46788973468, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 209399, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11633.277777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 662142596, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3162.1096375818415, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5701455472, "stage_ordering_ns": 1413416015, "stage_eval_ns": 2666870581, "stage_threat_ns": 6481167161, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 898252, "root_tactical_annotations": 2755, "search_tactical_annotations": 895497, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 236496, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1395159614, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 705188, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4848327302, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 85871, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2853729869, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 118239, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 176542894, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 236478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29391952, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 237088, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 613325611, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 382215, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1380955981, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 278949, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 31745399, "child_limit_applications": 42862, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42862, "child_cap_hits": 42862, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42862, "child_moves_before_total": 3676628, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3676628, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 426026, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 426026, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.77826512995193, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.93948019224488, "tt_hits": 25702, "tt_cutoffs": 4564, "beta_cutoffs": 34578, "depth_sum": 111, "avg_depth": 6.166666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 111, "avg_effective_depth": 6.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4983.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5427.611111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1421, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19314, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 53, 95, 111, 125, 69, 55, 85, 155, 169, 110, 140, 65, 80, 79, 37, 101, 21 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 16265, "avg_search_time_ms": 1161.7857142857142, "search_nodes": 163901, "safety_nodes": 741, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 164642, "avg_nodes": 11760.142857142857, "eval_calls": 102938, "avg_eval_calls": 7352.714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 102938, "pattern_eval_ns": 2131641, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.70800870426859, "pattern_frame_queries": 102938, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2131641, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.70800870426859, "pattern_frame_updates": 327638, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3927257961, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11986.576529584481, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 56485, "avg_candidate_generations": 4034.6428571428573, "candidate_moves_total": 4653254, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.38034876515889, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 979, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 56471, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4652275, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1264842, "avg_legality_checks": 90345.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4117, "root_legality_checks": 979, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 1263863, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4542467, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 324461.9285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9589543158, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2111.087027819905, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37933, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2709.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 233847114, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6164.740832520497, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4285, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 39997892, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16664, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 136709771, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16954, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 56819148, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 320303, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 118664, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8476.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 939207327, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7914.846347670734, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 150098, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10721.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 375259912, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2500.099348425695, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3016247414, "stage_ordering_ns": 1822012846, "stage_eval_ns": 3929389602, "stage_threat_ns": 7439718775, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 959265, "root_tactical_annotations": 2964, "search_tactical_annotations": 956301, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 327652, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1867208404, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 718927, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5251527427, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 113051, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3812425069, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 163819, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 237536619, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 327638, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39495112, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 252311, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 297535901, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 353555, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1141138867, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 353399, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 43951213, "child_limit_applications": 56471, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 56471, "child_cap_hits": 56471, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 56471, "child_moves_before_total": 4648164, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4648164, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 611864, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 611864, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.31063731826956, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.835012661366012, "tt_hits": 35494, "tt_cutoffs": 4410, "beta_cutoffs": 46222, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 5.857142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 5.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3698.785714285714, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4270.214285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1000, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3036, "avg_search_time_ms": 233.53846153846155, "search_nodes": 84826, "safety_nodes": 1386, "corridor_nodes": 1423, "corridor_branch_probes": 1736, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 617, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 1404, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1404, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 49, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 617, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 49, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 49, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 212, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 209600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87635, "avg_nodes": 6741.153846153846, "eval_calls": 82350, "avg_eval_calls": 6334.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82350, "pattern_eval_ns": 1681674, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.421056466302367, "pattern_frame_queries": 82350, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1681674, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.421056466302367, "pattern_frame_updates": 169576, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1714875029, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10112.72249021088, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2451, "avg_candidate_generations": 188.53846153846155, "candidate_moves_total": 186715, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.17911056711546, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 898, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2438, "search_candidate_moves_total": 185817, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 4564, "avg_legality_checks": 351.0769230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4564, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 552551, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 42503.92307692308, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1192391394, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2157.975271060952, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8473, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 651.7692307692307, "renju_forbidden_ns": 69595574, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8213.805499822967, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 230972, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8352, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 68324058, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 429792, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 58, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 610752, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12259765, "stage_ordering_ns": 74701, "stage_eval_ns": 1716556703, "stage_threat_ns": 1219032178, "stage_proof_ns": 68536290, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 172495, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 976514706, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 79841, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 90960306, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 741, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 29848136, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113524975, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2906, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17755022, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 172482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20277169, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 78, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2253, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6289.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6904.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1422, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24114, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 84, 141, 99, 155, 169, 126, 81, 83, 69, 54, 129, 114, 67, 52, 70, 68, 53, 98, 128, 111, 156, 95, 79, 143, 159, 142, 25, 39, 144, 140, 139, 110, 125, 94, 78, 158 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 4898, "avg_search_time_ms": 257.7894736842105, "search_nodes": 110492, "safety_nodes": 1541, "corridor_nodes": 2109, "corridor_branch_probes": 2381, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 796, "corridor_neutral_exits": 28, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 2076, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2071, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 18, "corridor_proof_completed": 18, "corridor_proof_checks": 126, "corridor_proof_active": 33, "corridor_proof_quiet": 93, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 796, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 126, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 124, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 889, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 352400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 114142, "avg_nodes": 6007.473684210527, "eval_calls": 105137, "avg_eval_calls": 5533.526315789473, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105137, "pattern_eval_ns": 2135570, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.31225924270238, "pattern_frame_queries": 105137, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2135570, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.31225924270238, "pattern_frame_updates": 220872, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2450567466, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11094.96661414756, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5318, "avg_candidate_generations": 279.89473684210526, "candidate_moves_total": 445555, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.78243700639338, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1467, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 5299, "search_candidate_moves_total": 444088, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 97188, "avg_legality_checks": 5115.1578947368425, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "root_legality_checks": 1467, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 95721, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1203669, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 63351.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2529957790, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2101.8716856544447, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10691, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 562.6842105263158, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57895376, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5415.337760733327, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 126680, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10316, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 55772496, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 62, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 694722, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 298, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1301478, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3770, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 198.42105263157896, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 34316828, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9102.606896551724, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4946, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 260.3157894736842, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 17761122, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3591.007278608977, "stage_move_gen_ns": 217914456, "stage_ordering_ns": 186770, "stage_eval_ns": 2452703036, "stage_threat_ns": 1735968485, "stage_proof_ns": 453865091, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 225295, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1185588168, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 131427, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 355824005, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1548, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 76813793, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 112638, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 141350505, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4404, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28562757, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 225276, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24643050, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 426, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4688, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6850.105263157895, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7271.1578947368425, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1832, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 19197, "avg_search_time_ms": 1010.3684210526316, "search_nodes": 138437, "safety_nodes": 1363, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 139800, "avg_nodes": 7357.894736842105, "eval_calls": 82689, "avg_eval_calls": 4352.0526315789475, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82689, "pattern_eval_ns": 1784624, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.582362829396896, "pattern_frame_queries": 82689, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1784624, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.582362829396896, "pattern_frame_updates": 276644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2761921993, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9983.668516215786, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 50744, "avg_candidate_generations": 2670.7368421052633, "candidate_moves_total": 4481086, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.30770140312156, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1504, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 50725, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4479582, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 3154442, "avg_legality_checks": 166023.26315789475, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2358, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3154442, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2358, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6396201, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 336642.15789473685, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12869459097, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2012.0473226216625, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32586, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1715.0526315789473, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124371717, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3816.722426809059, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2449, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25575305, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6676, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 59690647, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23461, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39105765, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 208549, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10976.263157894737, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1822804970, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8740.415777587043, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 270152, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14218.526315789473, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 842151820, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3117.3258758032516, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7100162158, "stage_ordering_ns": 1669703175, "stage_eval_ns": 2763706617, "stage_threat_ns": 7541992483, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1083372, "root_tactical_annotations": 3575, "search_tactical_annotations": 1079797, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 276663, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1612327131, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 838544, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5648093493, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 101602, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3234447584, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 138322, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 204948965, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 276644, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34260547, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 330123, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 911621205, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 406804, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1501752573, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 346445, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 42362347, "child_limit_applications": 50725, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 50725, "child_cap_hits": 50725, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 50725, "child_moves_before_total": 4477224, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4477224, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 516806, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 516806, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.2646426811237, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.18838836865451, "tt_hits": 31208, "tt_cutoffs": 4908, "beta_cutoffs": 41232, "depth_sum": 115, "avg_depth": 6.052631578947368, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 115, "avg_effective_depth": 6.052631578947368, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2631578947368421, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5086.368421052632, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5507.421052631579, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 17, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1423, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22710, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 123, 81, 97, 83, 139, 153, 157, 173, 155, 85, 71, 82, 84, 79, 80, 65, 107, 171, 91 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 20967, "avg_search_time_ms": 1397.8, "search_nodes": 206169, "safety_nodes": 791, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 206960, "avg_nodes": 13797.333333333334, "eval_calls": 132660, "avg_eval_calls": 8844.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 132660, "pattern_eval_ns": 2780508, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.959656264133876, "pattern_frame_queries": 132660, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2780508, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.959656264133876, "pattern_frame_updates": 412160, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5094841535, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12361.319718070652, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 67782, "avg_candidate_generations": 4518.8, "candidate_moves_total": 5928029, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.45727479271783, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1105, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 67767, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5926924, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1738627, "avg_legality_checks": 115908.46666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6722, "root_legality_checks": 1105, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 1737522, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6715, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5917457, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 394497.13333333336, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12330355363, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2083.725384569757, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56398, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3759.866666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 326788395, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5794.325951274868, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6968, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 67753693, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22947, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 182360437, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26448, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 76298982, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 375283, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 169312, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11287.466666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1347262978, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7957.279921092421, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 217994, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14532.933333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 551974242, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2532.061625549327, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4133176689, "stage_ordering_ns": 2303075692, "stage_eval_ns": 5097622043, "stage_threat_ns": 9361431400, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1249849, "root_tactical_annotations": 3550, "search_tactical_annotations": 1246299, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 412175, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2358891439, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 995827, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6601678635, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 135652, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4516537704, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 206080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 300703778, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 412160, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50178228, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 346872, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 408603180, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 513292, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1676095949, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 389685, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 49979320, "child_limit_applications": 67767, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 67767, "child_cap_hits": 67767, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 67767, "child_moves_before_total": 5920209, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5920209, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 753632, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 753632, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.3612377705963, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.120929065769475, "tt_hits": 39673, "tt_cutoffs": 5655, "beta_cutoffs": 55054, "depth_sum": 87, "avg_depth": 5.8, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 87, "avg_effective_depth": 5.8, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2444.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2977.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 1729, "avg_search_time_ms": 123.5, "search_nodes": 48567, "safety_nodes": 1536, "corridor_nodes": 1469, "corridor_branch_probes": 1780, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 651, "corridor_neutral_exits": 22, "corridor_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_plies_followed": 1449, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1449, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 651, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 50, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 213, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 230960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 51572, "avg_nodes": 3683.714285714286, "eval_calls": 46124, "avg_eval_calls": 3294.5714285714284, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46124, "pattern_eval_ns": 944543, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.478340993842686, "pattern_frame_queries": 46124, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 944543, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.478340993842686, "pattern_frame_updates": 97052, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 854981628, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8809.520957837036, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2416, "avg_candidate_generations": 172.57142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 189523, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.44495033112582, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1021, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 2402, "search_candidate_moves_total": 188502, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 5696, "avg_legality_checks": 406.85714285714283, "illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5696, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 280495, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20035.35714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 618175216, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2203.8724968359506, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3700, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 264.2857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31295669, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8458.288918918919, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 261500, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3567, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29897845, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 43, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 431330, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 65, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 704994, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15149938, "stage_ordering_ns": 77770, "stage_eval_ns": 855926171, "stage_threat_ns": 769967513, "stage_proof_ns": 68323623, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 100064, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 581988759, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 78959, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 90224485, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 756, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 29961384, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50025, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 66687427, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2998, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19231278, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 100050, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11835564, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 79, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2226, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6424.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1968, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1424, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12538, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 126, 141, 99, 143, 98, 155, 169, 140, 142, 158, 100, 173, 128, 188, 203, 156, 101, 97, 102 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5030, "avg_search_time_ms": 457.27272727272725, "search_nodes": 101499, "safety_nodes": 671, "corridor_nodes": 3015, "corridor_branch_probes": 3297, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 1296, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 2995, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2995, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 79, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 59, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1296, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 79, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 78, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 586, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 170720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 105185, "avg_nodes": 9562.272727272728, "eval_calls": 97804, "avg_eval_calls": 8891.272727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 97804, "pattern_eval_ns": 1988581, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.33230747208703, "pattern_frame_queries": 97804, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1988581, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.33230747208703, "pattern_frame_updates": 202936, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2385101000, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11752.971380139552, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3675, "avg_candidate_generations": 334.09090909090907, "candidate_moves_total": 247290, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.28979591836735, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 699, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 3664, "search_candidate_moves_total": 246591, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 92992, "avg_legality_checks": 8453.818181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 699, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 92293, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1128161, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 102560.09090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2466808439, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2186.574823097058, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8125, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 738.6363636363636, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66478956, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8182.025353846154, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 408124, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7600, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 63652739, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 88, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 813546, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 395, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1604547, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 6658, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 605.2727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 62245163, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9348.928056473416, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9114, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 828.5454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 32625316, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3579.69234145271, "stage_move_gen_ns": 232606524, "stage_ordering_ns": 130000, "stage_eval_ns": 2387089581, "stage_threat_ns": 1952627430, "stage_proof_ns": 442367678, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 209095, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1219001664, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 177490, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 533446345, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1758, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 108018376, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 104542, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 142964419, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6148, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 31965676, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 209084, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25249326, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 241, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3260, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5438.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6166.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1765, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7498, "avg_search_time_ms": 749.8, "search_nodes": 63481, "safety_nodes": 972, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 64453, "avg_nodes": 6445.3, "eval_calls": 38800, "avg_eval_calls": 3880.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38800, "pattern_eval_ns": 820404, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.14443298969072, "pattern_frame_queries": 38800, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 820404, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.14443298969072, "pattern_frame_updates": 126844, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1246586142, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9827.71074705938, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22311, "avg_candidate_generations": 2231.1, "candidate_moves_total": 1673108, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.9902738559455, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 636, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 22301, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1672472, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 887693, "avg_legality_checks": 88769.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 419, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 887693, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 419, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2284183, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 228418.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4791911394, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2097.866674430201, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7598, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 759.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21013466, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2765.6575414582785, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 421, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4364180, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1471, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10133293, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5706, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6515993, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75697, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7569.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 686015545, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9062.651690291557, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 104258, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10425.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 306047387, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2935.481085384335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2117208775, "stage_ordering_ns": 707430217, "stage_eval_ns": 1247406546, "stage_threat_ns": 3385105262, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 278086, "root_tactical_annotations": 863, "search_tactical_annotations": 277223, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 126854, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 747362774, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 251333, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2522402460, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44681, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1600480735, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 63422, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91574737, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 126844, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15720779, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 41123, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 231910380, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 165520, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 689602563, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 71443, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8044512, "child_limit_applications": 22301, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22301, "child_cap_hits": 22301, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22301, "child_moves_before_total": 1672053, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1672053, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 207724, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 207724, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.97659297789336, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.314559885206942, "tt_hits": 10362, "tt_cutoffs": 2322, "beta_cutoffs": 17398, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 5.8, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 5.8, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3840.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4640.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 459, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1425, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 42452, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 83, 125, 126, 95, 115, 116, 99, 131, 129, 84, 101, 143, 127, 141, 140, 154, 85, 71, 69, 139, 153, 53, 67, 51, 68, 66, 87, 73, 117, 133, 144, 159, 130, 96, 81, 94, 93, 98 ], "move_count": 44, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 36106, "avg_search_time_ms": 1805.3, "search_nodes": 362336, "safety_nodes": 425, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 362761, "avg_nodes": 18138.05, "eval_calls": 227072, "avg_eval_calls": 11353.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 227072, "pattern_eval_ns": 4738046, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.86583110202931, "pattern_frame_queries": 227072, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4738046, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.86583110202931, "pattern_frame_updates": 724442, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8902414035, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12288.649795290721, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 125842, "avg_candidate_generations": 6292.1, "candidate_moves_total": 11421411, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.75992911746475, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1569, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 125822, "search_candidate_moves_total": 11419842, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 2647048, "avg_legality_checks": 132352.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 14940, "root_legality_checks": 1569, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 2645479, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 14929, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9692775, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 484638.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20140895957, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2077.928762093415, "renju_forbidden_checks": 120184, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6009.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 826545260, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6877.331924382614, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15863, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 161702981, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 55003, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 457251916, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 49249, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 206889061, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 69, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 701302, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 240804, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12040.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1979458628, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8220.206591252638, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 309031, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15451.55, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 832251615, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2693.100740702389, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6267499915, "stage_ordering_ns": 4097708236, "stage_eval_ns": 8907152081, "stage_threat_ns": 16726570398, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 3215712, "root_tactical_annotations": 7894, "search_tactical_annotations": 3207818, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 724462, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4106561156, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2661291, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11900454727, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 251799, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7946779794, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 362221, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 531459220, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 724442, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 88490352, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 988041, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 707759553, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1421434, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3245768819, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 806237, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 99604943, "child_limit_applications": 125822, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 125822, "child_cap_hits": 125822, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 125822, "child_moves_before_total": 11404913, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 11404913, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 1623785, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1623785, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.64323409260702, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.905413997552097, "tt_hits": 65587, "tt_cutoffs": 9329, "beta_cutoffs": 103723, "depth_sum": 106, "avg_depth": 5.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 106, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 9, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.45, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 9, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.45, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 649.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 848.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 3997 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 6326, "avg_search_time_ms": 316.3, "search_nodes": 201926, "safety_nodes": 2303, "corridor_nodes": 2026, "corridor_branch_probes": 2520, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 833, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 7, "corridor_plies_followed": 2011, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2011, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 19, "corridor_proof_completed": 19, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 833, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 70, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 357, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 71600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 206255, "avg_nodes": 10312.75, "eval_calls": 196409, "avg_eval_calls": 9820.45, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 196409, "pattern_eval_ns": 3994694, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.33865046917402, "pattern_frame_queries": 196409, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3994694, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.33865046917402, "pattern_frame_updates": 403736, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3432371549, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8501.524632433075, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5479, "avg_candidate_generations": 273.95, "candidate_moves_total": 426513, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.84504471618908, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1586, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 5459, "search_candidate_moves_total": 424927, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 10342, "avg_legality_checks": 517.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 29, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10342, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 29, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 922838, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 46141.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2033564482, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2203.598553592288, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17303, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 865.15, "renju_forbidden_ns": 152795016, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8830.550540368722, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 35, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 340330, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17089, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 150673297, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 484553, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 122, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1296836, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 28074103, "stage_ordering_ns": 172380, "stage_eval_ns": 3436366243, "stage_threat_ns": 2732365987, "stage_proof_ns": 100134986, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 407922, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2258407804, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 119904, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 128688367, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1065, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 34486366, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 203951, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 271711624, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4166, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25388998, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 407902, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48169194, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 152, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5072, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6553.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6953.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1971, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1426, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30450, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 84, 125, 83, 139, 153, 126, 129, 99, 85, 86, 81, 82, 115, 116, 70, 100, 101, 98, 96, 127, 124, 143, 159, 95, 79, 142, 73, 87, 53, 140, 141, 110, 80, 155 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 14994, "avg_search_time_ms": 833.0, "search_nodes": 351109, "safety_nodes": 1093, "corridor_nodes": 2920, "corridor_branch_probes": 3265, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1075, "corridor_neutral_exits": 66, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 2884, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2884, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 131, "corridor_proof_active": 36, "corridor_proof_quiet": 95, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 66, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1075, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 131, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 130, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 993, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 374000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 355122, "avg_nodes": 19729.0, "eval_calls": 341102, "avg_eval_calls": 18950.11111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 341102, "pattern_eval_ns": 6931385, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.320563936886913, "pattern_frame_queries": 341102, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6931385, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.320563936886913, "pattern_frame_updates": 702112, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8748074080, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12459.656123239598, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9972, "avg_candidate_generations": 554.0, "candidate_moves_total": 851470, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.38608102687525, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1389, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 9954, "search_candidate_moves_total": 850081, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 324118, "avg_legality_checks": 18006.555555555555, "illegal_moves_skipped": 123, "root_legality_checks": 1389, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 322729, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 123, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3301794, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 183433.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7381352349, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2235.558108410155, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25040, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1391.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 176407844, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7045.041693290735, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 131, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1221764, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24495, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 172537101, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 70, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 833687, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 344, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1815292, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4709, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 261.6111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 41287758, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8767.839881078786, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6067, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 337.05555555555554, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 20886146, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3442.5821658150653, "stage_move_gen_ns": 771898273, "stage_ordering_ns": 346301, "stage_eval_ns": 8755005465, "stage_threat_ns": 4881150248, "stage_proof_ns": 538105278, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 708160, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3825756151, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 179991, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 465166682, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2071, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 99643040, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 354071, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 467628710, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6030, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 40222361, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 708142, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 82376344, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 572, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8903, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6211.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6656.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1763, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 15441, "avg_search_time_ms": 857.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 114690, "safety_nodes": 1764, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 116454, "avg_nodes": 6469.666666666667, "eval_calls": 68098, "avg_eval_calls": 3783.222222222222, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68098, "pattern_eval_ns": 1430505, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.006564069429352, "pattern_frame_queries": 68098, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1430505, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.006564069429352, "pattern_frame_updates": 229156, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2544365390, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11103.202141772417, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42131, "avg_candidate_generations": 2340.6111111111113, "candidate_moves_total": 3580633, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.98808478317628, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1428, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 42113, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3579205, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 2445428, "avg_legality_checks": 135857.11111111112, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8367, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2445428, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8367, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5156112, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 286450.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10161741996, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1970.814830244184, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46070, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2559.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 317899709, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6900.362687215107, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8446, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 88315537, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15024, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 152437953, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22600, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 77146219, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 158365, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8798.055555555555, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1373404177, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8672.39716477757, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 204360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11353.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 622329858, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3045.262566059894, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5375021967, "stage_ordering_ns": 1297067513, "stage_eval_ns": 2545795895, "stage_threat_ns": 6121987725, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 870810, "root_tactical_annotations": 2755, "search_tactical_annotations": 868055, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 229174, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1298635342, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 694537, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4603550349, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 84373, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2712611302, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 114578, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 164129289, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 229156, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27651967, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 235313, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 541310561, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 374837, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1349314376, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 260660, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28020778, "child_limit_applications": 42113, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42113, "child_cap_hits": 42113, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42113, "child_moves_before_total": 3570838, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3570838, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 406872, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 406872, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.79182200270701, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.661434711371786, "tt_hits": 24853, "tt_cutoffs": 4368, "beta_cutoffs": 34014, "depth_sum": 111, "avg_depth": 6.166666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 111, "avg_effective_depth": 6.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5017.277777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5461.722222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1427, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 38155, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 129, 81, 96, 83, 157, 172, 143, 171, 141, 144, 173, 125, 111, 95, 80, 64, 159, 175, 145, 65, 49, 131, 115, 101, 130, 100, 189, 205, 187, 201, 140, 139, 128, 53, 158, 188, 156, 160, 155 ], "move_count": 45, "black_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 35801, "avg_search_time_ms": 1704.8095238095239, "search_nodes": 366985, "safety_nodes": 751, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 367736, "avg_nodes": 17511.238095238095, "eval_calls": 224884, "avg_eval_calls": 10708.761904761905, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 224884, "pattern_eval_ns": 4614971, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.52156222763736, "pattern_frame_queries": 224884, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4614971, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.52156222763736, "pattern_frame_updates": 733716, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8484938038, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11564.335571256453, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 131730, "avg_candidate_generations": 6272.857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 12176727, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.43700751537236, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1685, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 131709, "search_candidate_moves_total": 12175042, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 3079920, "avg_legality_checks": 146662.85714285713, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15514, "root_legality_checks": 1685, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 3078235, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15503, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10350457, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 492878.90476190473, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20336360044, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1964.7789507265236, "renju_forbidden_checks": 126148, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6007.047619047619, "renju_forbidden_ns": 794946749, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6301.699186669626, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16923, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 161974291, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 54140, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 422001987, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 55016, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 210316407, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 69, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 654064, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 262093, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12480.619047619048, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2047367296, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7811.606170328852, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 341701, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16271.47619047619, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 851862911, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2493.006783708564, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6851891411, "stage_ordering_ns": 4089237679, "stage_eval_ns": 8489553009, "stage_threat_ns": 16228980136, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 3371489, "root_tactical_annotations": 8220, "search_tactical_annotations": 3363269, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 733737, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3903033552, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2673474, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11614992713, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 263586, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7803441573, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 366858, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 505377931, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 733716, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 85347582, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1060024, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 771238524, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1349845, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3039988845, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 961620, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 120228358, "child_limit_applications": 131709, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 131709, "child_cap_hits": 131709, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 131709, "child_moves_before_total": 12159539, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 12159539, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 1686714, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1686714, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 92.32124608037415, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.806368585290299, "tt_hits": 72944, "tt_cutoffs": 10267, "beta_cutoffs": 109462, "depth_sum": 121, "avg_depth": 5.761904761904762, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 121, "avg_effective_depth": 5.761904761904762, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23809523809523808, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 928.1904761904761, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1228.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 2332, "avg_search_time_ms": 116.6, "search_nodes": 84883, "safety_nodes": 2009, "corridor_nodes": 2119, "corridor_branch_probes": 2640, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 7, "corridor_depth_exits": 854, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 2104, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2104, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 19, "corridor_proof_completed": 19, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 854, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 70, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 357, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 92400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 89011, "avg_nodes": 4450.55, "eval_calls": 80915, "avg_eval_calls": 4045.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80915, "pattern_eval_ns": 1602268, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.80186615584255, "pattern_frame_queries": 80915, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1602268, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.80186615584255, "pattern_frame_updates": 169648, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1025296709, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6043.671065971895, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3929, "avg_candidate_generations": 196.45, "candidate_moves_total": 328241, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.543140748282, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1593, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 3909, "search_candidate_moves_total": 326648, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 15474, "avg_legality_checks": 773.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 15474, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 348524, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17426.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 686426448, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1969.524187717345, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4665, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 233.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31243533, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6697.434726688103, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 143, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1226972, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4352, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28406079, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 65, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 501120, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 105, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1109362, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 37002426, "stage_ordering_ns": 131540, "stage_eval_ns": 1026898977, "stage_threat_ns": 1148661666, "stage_proof_ns": 84412763, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 174020, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 868676983, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 125994, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 131687213, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1116, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 36056715, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 87000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 103190396, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4352, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26852051, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 174000, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18255023, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 245, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3512, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 2.95, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 2.95, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6938.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7338.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1989, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1428, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 38892, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 129, 81, 99, 96, 145, 161, 144, 114, 100, 51, 101, 98, 66, 156, 170, 80, 64, 157, 172, 82, 83, 68, 54, 158, 159, 110, 124, 65, 103, 102, 131, 117, 115, 147, 67 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 23940, "avg_search_time_ms": 1260.0, "search_nodes": 546888, "safety_nodes": 694, "corridor_nodes": 9383, "corridor_branch_probes": 10251, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4252, "corridor_neutral_exits": 31, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 9338, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9338, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 17, "corridor_proof_completed": 17, "corridor_proof_checks": 176, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 131, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 31, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4252, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 176, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 173, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1403, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 300320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 556965, "avg_nodes": 29313.947368421053, "eval_calls": 534464, "avg_eval_calls": 28129.684210526317, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 534464, "pattern_eval_ns": 10859448, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.318390013172074, "pattern_frame_queries": 534464, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 10859448, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.318390013172074, "pattern_frame_updates": 1093664, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 12926843878, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11819.758059147965, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12387, "avg_candidate_generations": 651.9473684210526, "candidate_moves_total": 1138858, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.93977557116331, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1584, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 12368, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1137274, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 510449, "avg_legality_checks": 26865.736842105263, "illegal_moves_skipped": 304, "root_legality_checks": 1584, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 508865, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 304, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5191612, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 273242.7368421053, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11393330104, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2194.565022193492, "renju_forbidden_checks": 66924, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3522.315789473684, "renju_forbidden_ns": 505628487, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7555.263986013986, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 362, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3159334, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 59492, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 481594612, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1271, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5949785, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5799, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 14924756, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 20412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1074.3157894736842, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 191578095, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9385.562169312168, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 28284, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1488.6315789473683, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 102300440, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3616.901428369396, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1190521627, "stage_ordering_ns": 438271, "stage_eval_ns": 12937703326, "stage_threat_ns": 8602343900, "stage_proof_ns": 1139870037, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1112711, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6120591896, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 503202, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1486162374, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 5160, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 293454824, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 556346, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 735224800, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 19028, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 130435190, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1112692, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 129929640, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 942, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 11005, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21052631578947367, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5220.8421052631575, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5641.894736842105, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 628, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 14932, "avg_search_time_ms": 785.8947368421053, "search_nodes": 129448, "safety_nodes": 2503, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 131951, "avg_nodes": 6944.789473684211, "eval_calls": 78980, "avg_eval_calls": 4156.8421052631575, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 78980, "pattern_eval_ns": 1638497, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.745720435553306, "pattern_frame_queries": 78980, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1638497, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.745720435553306, "pattern_frame_updates": 258668, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2405460801, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9299.41392441276, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43452, "avg_candidate_generations": 2286.9473684210525, "candidate_moves_total": 3888102, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.48039215686275, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1610, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 43433, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3886492, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 2139737, "avg_legality_checks": 112617.73684210527, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2197, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2139737, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2197, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4783471, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 251761.63157894736, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9331204731, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1950.7183655968647, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55667, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2929.842105263158, "renju_forbidden_ns": 135979544, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2442.7316722654355, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6878, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33907765, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11034, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 46832681, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37731, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 55186638, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 52460, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 157846, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8307.684210526315, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1257268782, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7965.160865653866, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 207673, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10930.157894736842, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 512167875, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2466.2227395954214, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4676242283, "stage_ordering_ns": 1433309401, "stage_eval_ns": 2407099298, "stage_threat_ns": 6317138359, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 874876, "root_tactical_annotations": 1003, "search_tactical_annotations": 873873, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 258687, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1446489712, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 755267, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4635501083, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 87017, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2701289951, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129334, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 183452252, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 258668, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30618333, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 172470, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 435227823, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 495766, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1498528437, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 206640, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21076979, "child_limit_applications": 43433, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43433, "child_cap_hits": 43433, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43433, "child_moves_before_total": 3884295, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3884295, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 509058, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 509058, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.43188359081805, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.720535077015173, "tt_hits": 22734, "tt_cutoffs": 6922, "beta_cutoffs": 35529, "depth_sum": 113, "avg_depth": 5.947368421052632, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 113, "avg_effective_depth": 5.947368421052632, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15789473684210525, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5944.631578947368, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6365.684210526316, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 880, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1429, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22318, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 96, 97, 68, 110, 80, 128, 83, 81, 65, 113, 66, 129, 145, 143, 158, 64, 52, 94, 36, 84, 20, 4, 38, 24, 35, 50, 37, 34, 39 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 20373, "avg_search_time_ms": 1358.2, "search_nodes": 228693, "safety_nodes": 211, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 228904, "avg_nodes": 15260.266666666666, "eval_calls": 150560, "avg_eval_calls": 10037.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 150560, "pattern_eval_ns": 3127497, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.772429596174284, "pattern_frame_queries": 150560, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3127497, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.772429596174284, "pattern_frame_updates": 457244, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5566109603, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12173.171442380873, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 72369, "avg_candidate_generations": 4824.6, "candidate_moves_total": 6194760, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.59963520291838, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1024, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 72354, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6193736, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1706491, "avg_legality_checks": 113766.06666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5068, "root_legality_checks": 1024, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1705467, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5065, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6219314, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 414620.93333333335, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11796662535, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1896.778733956832, "renju_forbidden_checks": 107541, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7169.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 375846898, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3494.9172687626115, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7098, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 27143153, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 60191, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 256962940, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 40223, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 91635155, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 105650, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 153576, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10238.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1099205885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7157.406658592488, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 200245, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13349.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 422865348, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2111.7398586731256, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3750420980, "stage_ordering_ns": 2043770554, "stage_eval_ns": 5569237100, "stage_threat_ns": 8909557770, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1653847, "root_tactical_annotations": 3975, "search_tactical_annotations": 1649872, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 457259, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2338539533, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1453685, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6164180134, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 144808, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4025743704, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 228622, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 306989350, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 457244, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50708930, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 440302, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 269197083, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 868563, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1869225997, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 344982, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 49139823, "child_limit_applications": 72354, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 72354, "child_cap_hits": 72354, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 72354, "child_moves_before_total": 6188671, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6188671, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 964871, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 964871, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.5332255300329, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.335420294662354, "tt_hits": 32147, "tt_cutoffs": 5710, "beta_cutoffs": 56531, "depth_sum": 68, "avg_depth": 4.533333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 68, "avg_effective_depth": 4.533333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4361.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4894.733333333334, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 1933, "avg_search_time_ms": 138.07142857142858, "search_nodes": 52615, "safety_nodes": 1353, "corridor_nodes": 94, "corridor_branch_probes": 114, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 12, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 91, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 86, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 48, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 301, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 38560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 54062, "avg_nodes": 3861.5714285714284, "eval_calls": 50538, "avg_eval_calls": 3609.8571428571427, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50538, "pattern_eval_ns": 1077103, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.31273497170446, "pattern_frame_queries": 50538, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1077103, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.31273497170446, "pattern_frame_updates": 105148, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1086977400, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10337.594628523604, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2050, "avg_candidate_generations": 146.42857142857142, "candidate_moves_total": 148631, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.50292682926829, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 964, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 2036, "search_candidate_moves_total": 147667, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 4516, "avg_legality_checks": 322.57142857142856, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4516, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 365965, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26140.35714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 793022928, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2166.936532182039, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7057, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 504.07142857142856, "renju_forbidden_ns": 23467965, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3325.4874592603087, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25600, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6968, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 23201453, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17680, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 223232, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 218492, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7803.285714285715, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 37, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2.642857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 68570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1853.2432432432433, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11856753, "stage_ordering_ns": 71250, "stage_eval_ns": 1088054503, "stage_threat_ns": 722414692, "stage_proof_ns": 90875512, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 105446, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 619665696, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 8463, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 13744036, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 268, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6906869, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52716, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74455885, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 284, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1709633, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 105432, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12839442, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 126, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1819, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6505.785714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7077.214285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1847, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1430, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24415, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 80, 143, 95, 159, 175, 128, 83, 81, 65, 50, 125, 110, 67, 52, 64, 66, 51, 96, 126, 113, 158, 99, 85, 141, 155, 142, 19, 35, 140, 144, 145, 114, 129, 100, 86, 156 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 5823, "avg_search_time_ms": 306.4736842105263, "search_nodes": 134460, "safety_nodes": 1541, "corridor_nodes": 1959, "corridor_branch_probes": 2229, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 726, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 1927, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1922, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 18, "corridor_proof_completed": 18, "corridor_proof_checks": 126, "corridor_proof_active": 32, "corridor_proof_quiet": 94, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 726, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 126, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 124, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 889, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 345600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 137960, "avg_nodes": 7261.0526315789475, "eval_calls": 128226, "avg_eval_calls": 6748.736842105263, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 128226, "pattern_eval_ns": 2626549, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.483747445915807, "pattern_frame_queries": 128226, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2626549, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.483747445915807, "pattern_frame_updates": 268808, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3045586784, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11329.970774679325, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6197, "avg_candidate_generations": 326.1578947368421, "candidate_moves_total": 526043, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.88671938034533, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1467, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 6178, "search_candidate_moves_total": 524576, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 120585, "avg_legality_checks": 6346.578947368421, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "root_legality_checks": 1467, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 119118, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1368022, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 72001.15789473684, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2949272427, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2155.8662265665316, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12945, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 681.3157894736842, "renju_forbidden_ns": 70182189, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5421.567323290846, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 131450, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12600, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 67997791, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 63, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 735451, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 267, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1317497, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3602, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 189.57894736842104, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 33177059, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9210.732648528596, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4763, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 250.68421052631578, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 17246036, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3620.8347680033594, "stage_move_gen_ns": 268676110, "stage_ordering_ns": 214702, "stage_eval_ns": 3048213333, "stage_threat_ns": 2024248253, "stage_proof_ns": 437014970, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 272933, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1458321499, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 123293, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 333456012, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1479, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 72662844, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 136457, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 175073765, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4106, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26610171, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 272914, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30786806, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 426, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5498, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9473684210526314, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6845.315789473684, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7266.368421052632, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1828, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 18573, "avg_search_time_ms": 977.5263157894736, "search_nodes": 132536, "safety_nodes": 1363, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 133899, "avg_nodes": 7047.315789473684, "eval_calls": 78549, "avg_eval_calls": 4134.1578947368425, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 78549, "pattern_eval_ns": 1698939, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.62903410609938, "pattern_frame_queries": 78549, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1698939, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.62903410609938, "pattern_frame_updates": 264842, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2735272013, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10327.938971160163, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49156, "avg_candidate_generations": 2587.157894736842, "candidate_moves_total": 4286820, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.20847912767516, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1504, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 49137, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4285316, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 3012564, "avg_legality_checks": 158556.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3202, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3012564, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3202, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6140987, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 323209.84210526315, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12445784551, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2026.6749548566054, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31340, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1649.4736842105262, "renju_forbidden_ns": 155045862, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4947.21959157626, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3293, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34545457, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8647, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 81530418, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19400, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 38969987, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 197332, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10385.894736842105, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1727353467, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8753.539552632112, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 254703, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13405.421052631578, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 791413041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3107.1995265073438, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6829144396, "stage_ordering_ns": 1601005187, "stage_eval_ns": 2736970952, "stage_threat_ns": 7278428363, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1031482, "root_tactical_annotations": 3575, "search_tactical_annotations": 1027907, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 264861, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1551825604, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 793441, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5456036101, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 98426, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3159694222, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 132421, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 195307942, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 264842, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33016138, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 308432, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 836559487, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 386568, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1459506888, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 336482, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 42242578, "child_limit_applications": 49137, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49137, "child_cap_hits": 49137, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49137, "child_moves_before_total": 4282114, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4282114, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 494444, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 494444, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.14642733581618, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.062559781834462, "tt_hits": 30413, "tt_cutoffs": 4735, "beta_cutoffs": 39933, "depth_sum": 114, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 114, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2631578947368421, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5111.578947368421, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5532.631578947368, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1431, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26173, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 126, 114, 110, 158, 125, 129, 94, 78, 124, 127, 99, 82, 66, 130, 146, 70, 56, 97, 67, 115, 122, 123, 80, 108, 95, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 22423, "avg_search_time_ms": 1601.642857142857, "search_nodes": 191564, "safety_nodes": 725, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 192289, "avg_nodes": 13734.92857142857, "eval_calls": 117208, "avg_eval_calls": 8372.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 117208, "pattern_eval_ns": 2533511, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.615512592997064, "pattern_frame_queries": 117208, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2533511, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.615512592997064, "pattern_frame_updates": 382964, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5455753362, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14246.125907395995, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 67361, "avg_candidate_generations": 4811.5, "candidate_moves_total": 6503760, "avg_candidate_moves": 96.55082317661555, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1168, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 67347, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6502592, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 1770688, "avg_legality_checks": 126477.71428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4098, "root_legality_checks": 1168, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1769520, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4096, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6027366, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 430526.14285714284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13245614753, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2197.5792996476403, "renju_forbidden_checks": 87047, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6217.642857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 553788361, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6361.946546118764, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5462, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 49694067, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 38274, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 329397858, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 43273, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 174277985, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 418451, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 165063, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11790.214285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1605419387, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9726.100864518396, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 231577, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16541.214285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 751356908, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3244.523022579963, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4323279199, "stage_ordering_ns": 2446678019, "stage_eval_ns": 5458286873, "stage_threat_ns": 10115482694, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1516942, "root_tactical_annotations": 3826, "search_tactical_annotations": 1513116, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 382978, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2283824065, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1085884, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7409068787, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 134804, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4929887587, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 191482, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 289729671, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 382964, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48499476, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 357250, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 501785361, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 593821, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1977098478, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 565871, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 84360695, "child_limit_applications": 67347, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 67347, "child_cap_hits": 67347, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 67347, "child_moves_before_total": 6498496, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6498496, "child_moves_before_max": 131, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 131, "child_moves_after_total": 863509, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 863509, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 96.49273167327424, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.821788646858806, "tt_hits": 42852, "tt_cutoffs": 6928, "beta_cutoffs": 56597, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 5.714285714285714, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 5.714285714285714, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.42857142857142855, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1945.642857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2352.714285714286, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3735, "avg_search_time_ms": 266.7857142857143, "search_nodes": 106102, "safety_nodes": 1726, "corridor_nodes": 1973, "corridor_branch_probes": 2359, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 37, "corridor_depth_exits": 871, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1951, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1951, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 39, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 55, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 871, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 349, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 237360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 109801, "avg_nodes": 7842.928571428572, "eval_calls": 102716, "avg_eval_calls": 7336.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 102716, "pattern_eval_ns": 2131027, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.746787258070796, "pattern_frame_queries": 102716, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2131027, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.746787258070796, "pattern_frame_updates": 212124, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2063139585, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9726.1016433784, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3360, "avg_candidate_generations": 240.0, "candidate_moves_total": 289169, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.06220238095239, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1195, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 3346, "search_candidate_moves_total": 287974, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 6675, "avg_legality_checks": 476.7857142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6675, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 605823, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 43273.07142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1412058597, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2330.810479298409, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9824, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 701.7142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 84679724, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8619.678745928339, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 222200, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9709, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 83555588, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 191911, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 69, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 710025, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18337093, "stage_ordering_ns": 110550, "stage_eval_ns": 2065270612, "stage_threat_ns": 1535826753, "stage_proof_ns": 89235557, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 216162, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1220555488, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 110255, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 121191586, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 995, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 38118712, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108074, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 145892204, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4024, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22678396, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 216148, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25509079, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 167, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3072, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6295.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6866.928571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1960, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1432, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24713, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 84, 114, 140, 113, 111, 130, 82, 116, 115, 144, 158, 159, 129, 146, 162, 101, 86, 102, 88, 85, 141, 99, 100, 71, 57, 127 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 16602, "avg_search_time_ms": 1185.857142857143, "search_nodes": 426628, "safety_nodes": 422, "corridor_nodes": 1454, "corridor_branch_probes": 1664, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 512, "corridor_neutral_exits": 19, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1429, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1429, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 162, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 137, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 512, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 162, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 160, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1362, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 293760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 428504, "avg_nodes": 30607.428571428572, "eval_calls": 415796, "avg_eval_calls": 29699.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 415796, "pattern_eval_ns": 8530380, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.515781777602477, "pattern_frame_queries": 415796, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 8530380, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.515781777602477, "pattern_frame_updates": 853176, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 9441436855, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11066.224149530695, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10806, "avg_candidate_generations": 771.8571428571429, "candidate_moves_total": 878846, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.32944660373866, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1013, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 10792, "search_candidate_moves_total": 877833, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 402772, "avg_legality_checks": 28769.428571428572, "illegal_moves_skipped": 357, "root_legality_checks": 1013, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 401759, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 357, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3124473, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 223176.64285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7192688824, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2302.048641162846, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30593, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2185.214285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 236939113, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7744.879972542739, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 372, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3363315, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29867, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 230057267, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 152, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1735927, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 202, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1782604, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2488, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 177.71428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 24373607, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9796.465836012861, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3507, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 250.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 13184251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3759.4100370687197, "stage_move_gen_ns": 978650321, "stage_ordering_ns": 380813, "stage_eval_ns": 9449967235, "stage_threat_ns": 5674941531, "stage_proof_ns": 457431577, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 856372, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4710110456, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 97524, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 265091893, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1401, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 62162956, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 428179, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 579044299, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3182, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18214742, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 856358, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 102480141, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 760, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9403, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 2.7857142857142856, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7857142857142856, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4168.214285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4739.642857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8098, "avg_search_time_ms": 622.9230769230769, "search_nodes": 59280, "safety_nodes": 1187, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 60467, "avg_nodes": 4651.307692307692, "eval_calls": 34814, "avg_eval_calls": 2678.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34814, "pattern_eval_ns": 748208, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.491583845579363, "pattern_frame_queries": 34814, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 748208, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.491583845579363, "pattern_frame_updates": 118412, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1221815502, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10318.341907914739, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22567, "avg_candidate_generations": 1735.923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 1849585, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.95971994505251, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 944, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 22554, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1848641, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1115215, "avg_legality_checks": 85785.76923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 637, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1115215, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 637, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2548621, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 196047.76923076922, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5299954597, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2079.538149061787, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22007, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1692.8461538461538, "renju_forbidden_ns": 54207926, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2463.2128868087425, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 757, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6304599, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4546, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27428050, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16704, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20475277, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89546, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6888.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 804506971, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8984.287081500011, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 124885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9606.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 360061483, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2883.1443568082636, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2621543006, "stage_ordering_ns": 741684051, "stage_eval_ns": 1222563710, "stage_threat_ns": 3456996997, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 365550, "root_tactical_annotations": 964, "search_tactical_annotations": 364586, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 118425, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 696286285, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 333460, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2650142654, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45208, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1532855748, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 59206, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87016565, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 118412, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14810423, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71004, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 269154788, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 217240, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 847897246, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 77306, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8741070, "child_limit_applications": 22554, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22554, "child_cap_hits": 22554, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22554, "child_moves_before_total": 1848004, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1848004, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 210321, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 210321, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.93686264077326, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.325219473264166, "tt_hits": 8980, "tt_cutoffs": 1839, "beta_cutoffs": 17913, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5173.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5788.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1433, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16593, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 142, 95, 65, 94, 127, 140, 125, 97, 114, 156, 113, 78, 62, 111, 141, 155, 157, 172, 173, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 12211, "avg_search_time_ms": 1017.5833333333334, "search_nodes": 149505, "safety_nodes": 493, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 149998, "avg_nodes": 12499.833333333334, "eval_calls": 99994, "avg_eval_calls": 8332.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 99994, "pattern_eval_ns": 1947518, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.476348580914856, "pattern_frame_queries": 99994, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1947518, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.476348580914856, "pattern_frame_updates": 298890, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3135375708, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10490.065602730101, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46428, "avg_candidate_generations": 3869.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3800603, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.86014904798829, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 807, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 46416, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3799796, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1119692, "avg_legality_checks": 93307.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1176, "root_legality_checks": 807, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1118885, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1176, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4217466, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 351455.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7234748239, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1715.425385527708, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37921, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3160.0833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124982908, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3295.8758471559295, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1306, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5633508, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21317, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 93254873, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15298, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26094527, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 117939, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9828.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 784671759, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6653.20003561163, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 154959, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12913.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 333041305, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2149.2220845513975, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2158924116, "stage_ordering_ns": 1239929511, "stage_eval_ns": 3137323226, "stage_threat_ns": 5606272826, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 781490, "root_tactical_annotations": 2778, "search_tactical_annotations": 778712, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 298902, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1396031844, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 627373, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3966355927, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 92915, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2794282824, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 149445, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 182178743, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 298890, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30422624, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 202738, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 224037738, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 331711, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 947808364, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 247041, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 31283688, "child_limit_applications": 46416, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46416, "child_cap_hits": 46416, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46416, "child_moves_before_total": 3798620, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3798620, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 496873, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 496873, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.83859014133057, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.704778524646674, "tt_hits": 25583, "tt_cutoffs": 3035, "beta_cutoffs": 36829, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3880.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4547.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 566, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4370, "avg_search_time_ms": 397.27272727272725, "search_nodes": 148788, "safety_nodes": 1080, "corridor_nodes": 1018, "corridor_branch_probes": 1225, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 12, "corridor_depth_exits": 404, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1005, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1005, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 404, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 59, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 341, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 204880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 150886, "avg_nodes": 13716.90909090909, "eval_calls": 144378, "avg_eval_calls": 13125.272727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 144378, "pattern_eval_ns": 2944699, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.395759741788915, "pattern_frame_queries": 144378, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2944699, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.395759741788915, "pattern_frame_updates": 297512, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2305055692, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7747.77384441636, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4389, "avg_candidate_generations": 399.0, "candidate_moves_total": 314768, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.71747550694919, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 743, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 4378, "search_candidate_moves_total": 314025, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 9512, "avg_legality_checks": 864.7272727272727, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9512, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 581969, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 52906.27272727273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1305672467, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2243.5429842483018, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4096, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 372.3636363636364, "renju_forbidden_ns": 39270622, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9587.55419921875, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4071, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 39190972, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 79650, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 24248727, "stage_ordering_ns": 135122, "stage_eval_ns": 2308000391, "stage_threat_ns": 1927217321, "stage_proof_ns": 86216154, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 299651, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1639957984, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 62149, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 53087506, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 672, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20924512, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 149820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 189505821, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2128, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9456914, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 299640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35209096, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 140, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4012, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5280.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6007.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1434, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12629, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 97, 95, 125, 142, 94, 111, 67, 127, 144, 160, 79, 158, 174, 159, 143, 157, 156, 161 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 4192, "avg_search_time_ms": 419.2, "search_nodes": 159013, "safety_nodes": 707, "corridor_nodes": 214, "corridor_branch_probes": 243, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 38, "corridor_neutral_exits": 28, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 198, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 193, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 52, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 67, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 461, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 163440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 159934, "avg_nodes": 15993.4, "eval_calls": 154929, "avg_eval_calls": 15492.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 154929, "pattern_eval_ns": 2885872, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.62706142813805, "pattern_frame_queries": 154929, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2885872, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.62706142813805, "pattern_frame_updates": 317968, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2403019551, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7557.425750389976, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4065, "avg_candidate_generations": 406.5, "candidate_moves_total": 270297, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.49372693726937, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 624, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 4055, "search_candidate_moves_total": 269673, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 153195, "avg_legality_checks": 15319.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 624, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 152571, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1077240, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 107724.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1663602571, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1544.3193448070997, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5536, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 553.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31410005, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5673.772579479769, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5536, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31410005, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 22.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1217165, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5433.772321428572, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 296, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 29.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 584722, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1975.412162162162, "stage_move_gen_ns": 254922500, "stage_ordering_ns": 122630, "stage_eval_ns": 2405905423, "stage_threat_ns": 1410298592, "stage_proof_ns": 86206903, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 318510, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1199601485, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19004, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 29923871, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 406, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8693461, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 159250, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 151834888, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 532, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1571846, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 318500, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27366502, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 170, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3671, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4834.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5634.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 961, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8427, "avg_search_time_ms": 842.7, "search_nodes": 114675, "safety_nodes": 359, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 115034, "avg_nodes": 11503.4, "eval_calls": 71057, "avg_eval_calls": 7105.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71057, "pattern_eval_ns": 1345924, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.941469524466275, "pattern_frame_queries": 71057, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1345924, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.941469524466275, "pattern_frame_updates": 229246, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1422904087, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6206.887304467689, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 40774, "avg_candidate_generations": 4077.4, "candidate_moves_total": 3195640, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.37445430911856, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 647, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 40764, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3194993, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1700932, "avg_legality_checks": 170093.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 489, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1700932, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 489, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3935639, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 393563.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5228122886, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1328.4050915238922, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11752, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1175.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 35903765, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3055.119554118448, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 509, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3555910, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3057, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21128665, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8186, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11219190, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 91733, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9173.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 503923864, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5493.376036976879, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 129094, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12909.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 233503189, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1808.784211504795, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2549366684, "stage_ordering_ns": 798825916, "stage_eval_ns": 1424250011, "stage_threat_ns": 3571078510, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 559078, "root_tactical_annotations": 1867, "search_tactical_annotations": 557211, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 229256, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 857543667, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 480616, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2559660672, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 81599, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1785180265, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 114623, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 115498463, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 229246, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19429320, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 97726, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 240746139, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 301283, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 533687278, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 160069, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18946388, "child_limit_applications": 40764, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 40764, "child_cap_hits": 40764, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 40764, "child_moves_before_total": 3194504, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3194504, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 357137, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 357137, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.3658129722304, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.761088215091748, "tt_hits": 19045, "tt_cutoffs": 2802, "beta_cutoffs": 31657, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 5.2, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 5.2, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4068.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4868.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1758, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1435, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10210, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 85, 68, 111, 80, 81, 113, 94, 78, 95, 36, 109, 108, 123, 67, 137 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8412, "avg_search_time_ms": 841.2, "search_nodes": 106403, "safety_nodes": 568, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 106971, "avg_nodes": 10697.1, "eval_calls": 66571, "avg_eval_calls": 6657.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 66571, "pattern_eval_ns": 1361397, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.45030118219645, "pattern_frame_queries": 66571, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1361397, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.45030118219645, "pattern_frame_updates": 212698, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1940365789, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9122.63297727294, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37197, "avg_candidate_generations": 3719.7, "candidate_moves_total": 2972424, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.91031534801193, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 651, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 37187, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2971773, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 891539, "avg_legality_checks": 89153.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 818, "root_legality_checks": 651, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 890888, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 815, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3000171, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 300017.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4955493730, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1651.7370943189571, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18368, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1836.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 76402204, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4159.527656794425, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 873, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6058999, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8780, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 53777892, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8698, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16400163, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 165150, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72017, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7201.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 468885936, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6510.767402141161, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 93376, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9337.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 193907601, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2076.6321217443456, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1626321450, "stage_ordering_ns": 894659699, "stage_eval_ns": 1941727186, "stage_threat_ns": 3897639072, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 509747, "root_tactical_annotations": 2024, "search_tactical_annotations": 507723, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 212708, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 954494515, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 398987, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2774356006, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 74447, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2047731135, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 106349, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 126133166, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 212698, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21272976, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 95465, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 114667537, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 229067, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 611589673, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 185215, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21382409, "child_limit_applications": 37187, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37187, "child_cap_hits": 37187, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37187, "child_moves_before_total": 2970958, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2970958, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 345703, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 345703, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.8923817463092, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.29634011885874, "tt_hits": 21246, "tt_cutoffs": 2591, "beta_cutoffs": 29428, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4056.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4856.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1199, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1791, "avg_search_time_ms": 199.0, "search_nodes": 82940, "safety_nodes": 627, "corridor_nodes": 835, "corridor_branch_probes": 989, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 311, "corridor_neutral_exits": 23, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 819, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 819, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 65, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 311, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 65, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 453, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 250560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 84402, "avg_nodes": 9378.0, "eval_calls": 79466, "avg_eval_calls": 8829.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79466, "pattern_eval_ns": 1564596, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.688873228802255, "pattern_frame_queries": 79466, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1564596, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.688873228802255, "pattern_frame_updates": 165828, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 886887978, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5348.240212750561, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3457, "avg_candidate_generations": 384.1111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 248091, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.7648249927683, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 583, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 3448, "search_candidate_moves_total": 247508, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 11384, "avg_legality_checks": 1264.888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11384, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 344209, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 38245.444444444445, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 564253621, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1639.2761984724398, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2052, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 228.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15607720, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7606.1013645224175, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 38190, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2016, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15280108, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 100061, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 189361, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22544798, "stage_ordering_ns": 111080, "stage_eval_ns": 888452574, "stage_threat_ns": 778656692, "stage_proof_ns": 76114820, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 167605, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 630070246, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 54401, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 44754694, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 644, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17758009, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 83798, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81127118, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1768, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7887304, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 167596, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14817330, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 200, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3124, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5502.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6391.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1436, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25898, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 81, 99, 142, 94, 111, 85, 86, 113, 127, 97, 95, 71, 57, 79, 140, 154, 125, 80, 155 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 13645, "avg_search_time_ms": 1137.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 309031, "safety_nodes": 472, "corridor_nodes": 4005, "corridor_branch_probes": 4450, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1771, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 3976, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3976, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 81, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 52, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1771, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 81, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 77, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 595, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 186960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 313508, "avg_nodes": 26125.666666666668, "eval_calls": 302372, "avg_eval_calls": 25197.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 302372, "pattern_eval_ns": 6425351, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.249821412035505, "pattern_frame_queries": 302372, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6425351, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.249821412035505, "pattern_frame_updates": 617994, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7475466957, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12096.342289730968, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6637, "avg_candidate_generations": 553.0833333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 487961, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.5213198734368, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 803, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 6625, "search_candidate_moves_total": 487158, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 299428, "avg_legality_checks": 24952.333333333332, "illegal_moves_skipped": 783, "root_legality_checks": 803, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 298625, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 781, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2745904, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 228825.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6381466295, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2323.994682625467, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44711, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3725.9166666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 402123142, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8993.830198385185, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 807, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8138121, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 41834, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 369861893, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 711, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9901556, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1359, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 14221572, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10801, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 900.0833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 110941729, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10271.431256365151, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14447, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1203.9166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 58230206, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4030.608846127224, "stage_move_gen_ns": 726027562, "stage_ordering_ns": 219252, "stage_eval_ns": 7481892308, "stage_threat_ns": 4799634075, "stage_proof_ns": 589420871, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 626120, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3470818731, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 229821, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 785269605, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2200, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 157006791, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 313054, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 420090202, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8114, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 48697746, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 626108, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74757791, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 464, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5869, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3790.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4456.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 294, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 12243, "avg_search_time_ms": 1113.0, "search_nodes": 106478, "safety_nodes": 1071, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 107549, "avg_nodes": 9777.181818181818, "eval_calls": 67555, "avg_eval_calls": 6141.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67555, "pattern_eval_ns": 1460830, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.624306120938495, "pattern_frame_queries": 67555, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1460830, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.624306120938495, "pattern_frame_updates": 212830, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2554775067, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12003.829662171685, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34937, "avg_candidate_generations": 3176.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 2766905, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.19698314108253, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 738, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 34926, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2766167, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 1426161, "avg_legality_checks": 129651.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2797, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1426161, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2797, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3832834, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 348439.45454545453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7590567122, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1980.4059142660496, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36742, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3340.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 230863277, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6283.361738609766, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2881, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30458503, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16267, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 142862124, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17584, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 57426900, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 115750, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 134000, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12181.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1069756164, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7983.254955223881, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 177466, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16133.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 452134869, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2547.7267138494135, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3144765171, "stage_ordering_ns": 1083199424, "stage_eval_ns": 2556235897, "stage_threat_ns": 5392696808, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 638226, "root_tactical_annotations": 921, "search_tactical_annotations": 637305, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 212841, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1210220964, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 552794, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3985336914, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69937, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2401608922, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 106415, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 152841540, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 212830, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26095465, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 104805, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 332049184, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 378043, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1251310027, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 155378, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18201925, "child_limit_applications": 34926, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34926, "child_cap_hits": 34926, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34926, "child_moves_before_total": 2763370, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2763370, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 421576, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 421576, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.12071236328237, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.070549161083434, "tt_hits": 16125, "tt_cutoffs": 3934, "beta_cutoffs": 28360, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3097.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3824.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1169, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1437, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28496, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 128, 82, 142, 100, 143, 83, 156, 170, 158, 113, 81, 110, 124, 68, 54, 64, 48, 111, 109, 67, 188, 173, 140, 172, 141, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 22368, "avg_search_time_ms": 1597.7142857142858, "search_nodes": 190428, "safety_nodes": 725, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 191153, "avg_nodes": 13653.785714285714, "eval_calls": 120806, "avg_eval_calls": 8629.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 120806, "pattern_eval_ns": 2692607, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.288685992417594, "pattern_frame_queries": 120806, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2692607, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.288685992417594, "pattern_frame_updates": 380694, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5643008135, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14822.950020226219, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 63216, "avg_candidate_generations": 4515.428571428572, "candidate_moves_total": 5922482, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.68644014173627, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1168, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 63202, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5921314, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 1688185, "avg_legality_checks": 120584.64285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3902, "root_legality_checks": 1168, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1687017, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3900, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5784787, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 413199.0714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13235287002, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2287.9471624452203, "renju_forbidden_checks": 84198, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6014.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 570205180, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6772.193876339105, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5057, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 50022223, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 41011, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 359395233, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 38092, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 160378621, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 409103, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 156766, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11197.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1604497563, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10234.984390747994, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 220740, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15767.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 750322544, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3399.123602428196, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4311128239, "stage_ordering_ns": 2340969230, "stage_eval_ns": 5645700742, "stage_threat_ns": 9990349901, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1341849, "root_tactical_annotations": 3719, "search_tactical_annotations": 1338130, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 380708, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2331791037, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1047858, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7253493405, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 126513, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4773658776, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 190347, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 297178526, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 380694, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49763404, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 352633, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 461206536, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 568703, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2018311702, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 420513, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 58123529, "child_limit_applications": 63202, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 63202, "child_cap_hits": 63202, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 63202, "child_moves_before_total": 5917414, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5917414, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 790455, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 790455, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.6270054745103, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.506803582165121, "tt_hits": 37198, "tt_cutoffs": 6343, "beta_cutoffs": 51849, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1658.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2064.714285714286, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6115, "avg_search_time_ms": 436.7857142857143, "search_nodes": 159158, "safety_nodes": 1726, "corridor_nodes": 2086, "corridor_branch_probes": 2492, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 37, "corridor_depth_exits": 926, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 2062, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2062, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 45, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 926, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 349, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 275840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 162970, "avg_nodes": 11640.714285714286, "eval_calls": 155446, "avg_eval_calls": 11103.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 155446, "pattern_eval_ns": 3400463, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.87552590610244, "pattern_frame_queries": 155446, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3400463, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.87552590610244, "pattern_frame_updates": 318236, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3627351686, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11398.307187118993, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3686, "avg_candidate_generations": 263.2857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 316223, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.79028757460662, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1195, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 3672, "search_candidate_moves_total": 315028, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 6336, "avg_legality_checks": 452.57142857142856, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6336, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1015619, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 72544.21428571429, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2442984635, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2405.41446644854, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22389, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1599.2142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 190121320, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8491.728974049756, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 219331, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22267, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 188998886, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 213871, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 69, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 689232, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18452578, "stage_ordering_ns": 118250, "stage_eval_ns": 3630752149, "stage_threat_ns": 2341338731, "stage_proof_ns": 93620768, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 322496, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1913210901, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 116369, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 137159561, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1024, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 41368414, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 161241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 225549951, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4246, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25021061, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 322482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40397257, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 167, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3390, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6184.928571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6756.357142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1969, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1438, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16798, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 80, 82, 144, 97, 127, 68, 110, 52, 67, 84, 100, 85, 83, 54, 40, 51, 50, 69, 95, 65, 140, 125, 99, 53, 55, 101, 37, 117 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 9783, "avg_search_time_ms": 652.2, "search_nodes": 227650, "safety_nodes": 254, "corridor_nodes": 2123, "corridor_branch_probes": 2492, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 712, "corridor_neutral_exits": 42, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 2088, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2088, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 146, "corridor_proof_active": 35, "corridor_proof_quiet": 111, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 42, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 712, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 146, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 141, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1197, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 305360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 18, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 14, "total_nodes": 230027, "avg_nodes": 15335.133333333333, "eval_calls": 220196, "avg_eval_calls": 14679.733333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 220196, "pattern_eval_ns": 4767089, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.64929880651783, "pattern_frame_queries": 220196, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4767089, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.64929880651783, "pattern_frame_updates": 455214, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5177594270, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11373.978546354023, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7426, "avg_candidate_generations": 495.06666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 577816, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.80985725828171, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1088, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 7411, "search_candidate_moves_total": 576728, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 212765, "avg_legality_checks": 14184.333333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 219, "root_legality_checks": 1088, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 211677, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 215, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1865796, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 124386.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4362872570, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2338.343832873476, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19632, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1308.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 144339742, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7352.268846780766, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 336, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2400975, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18566, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 136095641, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 199, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2271771, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 531, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3571355, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3744, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 249.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 36804958, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9830.384081196582, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5300, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 353.3333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 19462607, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3672.19, "stage_move_gen_ns": 537869524, "stage_ordering_ns": 260391, "stage_eval_ns": 5182361359, "stage_threat_ns": 3480228240, "stage_proof_ns": 539188471, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 459697, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2694457586, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 143632, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 383576843, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1705, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 84471087, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 229841, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 316720596, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4468, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28460106, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 459682, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57013109, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 810, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6298, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5370.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5903.533333333334, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 7003, "avg_search_time_ms": 500.2142857142857, "search_nodes": 55613, "safety_nodes": 1587, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 57200, "avg_nodes": 4085.714285714286, "eval_calls": 33387, "avg_eval_calls": 2384.785714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33387, "pattern_eval_ns": 742013, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.224608380507384, "pattern_frame_queries": 33387, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 742013, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.224608380507384, "pattern_frame_updates": 111066, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1103272350, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9933.484144562692, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20561, "avg_candidate_generations": 1468.642857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 1640582, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.79096347453918, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1018, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 20547, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1639564, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 895586, "avg_legality_checks": 63970.42857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 913, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 895586, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 913, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2100625, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 150044.64285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4497373945, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2140.9694471883367, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19759, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1411.357142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 58309209, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2951.0202439394707, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1389, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10618573, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5128, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27383940, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13208, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19975726, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 330970, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67014, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4786.714285714285, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 590370133, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8809.653699227027, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 88761, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6340.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 246568445, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2777.891697930397, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2190224244, "stage_ordering_ns": 669578448, "stage_eval_ns": 1104014363, "stage_threat_ns": 2982939933, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 295307, "root_tactical_annotations": 524, "search_tactical_annotations": 294783, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 111080, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 661237077, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 278171, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2220607920, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41202, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1375140007, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 55533, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81370794, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 111066, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13765896, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 54046, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 182511225, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 182913, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 662552937, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 58348, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5958246, "child_limit_applications": 20547, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20547, "child_cap_hits": 20547, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20547, "child_moves_before_total": 1638651, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1638651, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 185300, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 185300, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.75135056212586, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.018348177349491, "tt_hits": 7657, "tt_cutoffs": 1600, "beta_cutoffs": 16202, "depth_sum": 79, "avg_depth": 5.642857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 79, "avg_effective_depth": 5.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5366.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5938.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1439, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 33050, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 128, 110, 114, 156, 129, 125, 100, 86, 130, 127, 95, 82, 68, 124, 138, 64, 48, 97, 67, 69, 132, 131, 83, 140, 116, 84, 113, 98, 115, 117, 145, 85, 160 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 26665, "avg_search_time_ms": 1568.5294117647059, "search_nodes": 304897, "safety_nodes": 934, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 305831, "avg_nodes": 17990.058823529413, "eval_calls": 194351, "avg_eval_calls": 11432.411764705883, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 194351, "pattern_eval_ns": 3882454, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.976506423944308, "pattern_frame_queries": 194351, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3882454, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.976506423944308, "pattern_frame_updates": 609586, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6311195797, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10353.249249490638, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 98262, "avg_candidate_generations": 5780.117647058823, "candidate_moves_total": 9802389, "avg_candidate_moves": 99.75767845148684, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1487, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 98245, "search_candidate_moves_total": 9800902, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 3659543, "avg_legality_checks": 215267.23529411765, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8780, "root_legality_checks": 1487, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 3658056, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10545826, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 620342.7058823529, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15861616943, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1504.06586861949, "renju_forbidden_checks": 189201, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11129.470588235294, "renju_forbidden_ns": 648875194, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3429.554780365854, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 13146, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 66733163, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 75889, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 394018110, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 100156, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 188065931, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57990, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 337340, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19843.529411764706, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2292682589, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6796.355573012391, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 475262, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27956.58823529412, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1070424779, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2252.283538343061, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6186033371, "stage_ordering_ns": 2521176175, "stage_eval_ns": 6315078251, "stage_threat_ns": 11448732705, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2364052, "root_tactical_annotations": 4713, "search_tactical_annotations": 2359339, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 609603, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2617481371, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1815440, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8330484161, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 196628, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4916415169, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 304793, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 348747530, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 609586, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58004864, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 589581, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 492370487, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1029221, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2921389064, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 745250, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 94014779, "child_limit_applications": 98245, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 98245, "child_cap_hits": 98245, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 98245, "child_moves_before_total": 9792124, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 9792124, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 1294015, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1294015, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 99.67045651178177, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.17130642780803, "tt_hits": 61002, "tt_cutoffs": 12199, "beta_cutoffs": 81233, "depth_sum": 102, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 102, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2731.294117647059, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3172.176470588235, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 6368, "avg_search_time_ms": 374.5882352941176, "search_nodes": 232162, "safety_nodes": 1934, "corridor_nodes": 2783, "corridor_branch_probes": 3232, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 49, "corridor_depth_exits": 1254, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2755, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2755, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 94, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 66, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 56, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1254, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 94, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 90, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 622, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 325840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 236879, "avg_nodes": 13934.058823529413, "eval_calls": 226581, "avg_eval_calls": 13328.29411764706, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 226581, "pattern_eval_ns": 4588652, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.251706895105944, "pattern_frame_queries": 226581, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4588652, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.251706895105944, "pattern_frame_updates": 464226, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3571369433, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7693.169777220578, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5549, "avg_candidate_generations": 326.4117647058824, "candidate_moves_total": 529034, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.33861957109389, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1512, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 5532, "search_candidate_moves_total": 527522, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 15681, "avg_legality_checks": 922.4117647058823, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 15681, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1312353, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 77197.23529411765, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2409135641, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1835.737519554571, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17220, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1012.9411764705883, "renju_forbidden_ns": 71835468, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4171.629965156794, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 28351, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17155, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71445487, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 47, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 256420, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 105210, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 30651364, "stage_ordering_ns": 182510, "stage_eval_ns": 3575958085, "stage_threat_ns": 2590945479, "stage_proof_ns": 112476930, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 469941, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2121483039, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 151238, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 132857967, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1497, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 45172713, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 234962, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 264898992, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5698, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25166555, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 469924, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46538926, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 390, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5000, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6560.529411764706, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7031.117647058823, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1960, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1440, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22783, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 80, 110, 144, 111, 113, 124, 82, 108, 109, 140, 156, 155, 125, 138, 152, 93, 78, 92, 76, 79, 143, 95, 94, 63, 47, 127 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 14391, "avg_search_time_ms": 1027.9285714285713, "search_nodes": 373857, "safety_nodes": 422, "corridor_nodes": 1678, "corridor_branch_probes": 1927, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 586, "corridor_neutral_exits": 26, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1650, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1650, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 162, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 134, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 586, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 162, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 160, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1362, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 292160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 375957, "avg_nodes": 26854.071428571428, "eval_calls": 363961, "avg_eval_calls": 25997.214285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 363961, "pattern_eval_ns": 7504295, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.61840416967752, "pattern_frame_queries": 363961, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7504295, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.61840416967752, "pattern_frame_updates": 747634, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8049209157, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10766.242783233507, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9870, "avg_candidate_generations": 705.0, "candidate_moves_total": 796142, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.6628166160081, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1013, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 9856, "search_candidate_moves_total": 795129, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 351897, "avg_legality_checks": 25135.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 372, "root_legality_checks": 1013, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 350884, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 372, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2783066, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 198790.42857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6260594935, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2249.5316083053726, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27800, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1985.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 206548414, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7429.799064748201, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 385, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3224407, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27009, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 199615020, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 169, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1810598, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 237, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1898389, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2804, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 200.28571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 27163382, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9687.368758915834, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3947, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 281.92857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 14710727, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3727.065366100836, "stage_move_gen_ns": 836535006, "stage_ordering_ns": 340291, "stage_eval_ns": 8056713452, "stage_threat_ns": 4976891503, "stage_proof_ns": 479269341, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 751272, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4075134132, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 112521, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 298039651, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1521, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 68886137, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 375629, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 494821789, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3624, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21083001, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 751258, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 87812930, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 752, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8561, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 2.7857142857142856, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7857142857142856, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4583.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5154.928571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8378, "avg_search_time_ms": 644.4615384615385, "search_nodes": 61067, "safety_nodes": 1187, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 62254, "avg_nodes": 4788.7692307692305, "eval_calls": 35989, "avg_eval_calls": 2768.3846153846152, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35989, "pattern_eval_ns": 789763, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.94456639528745, "pattern_frame_queries": 35989, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 789763, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.94456639528745, "pattern_frame_updates": 121986, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1256522170, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10300.544078828718, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23163, "avg_candidate_generations": 1781.7692307692307, "candidate_moves_total": 1904393, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.21702715537711, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 944, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 23150, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1903449, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1142143, "avg_legality_checks": 87857.15384615384, "illegal_moves_skipped": 609, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1142143, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 609, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2602263, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 200174.07692307694, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5465286383, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2100.2052379025486, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22701, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1746.2307692307693, "renju_forbidden_ns": 53499031, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2356.681688031364, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 723, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5342523, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4544, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28244873, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17434, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19911635, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93303, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7177.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 832790315, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8925.654212619102, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 130199, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10015.307692307691, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 371500426, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2853.327798216576, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2714446643, "stage_ordering_ns": 768853020, "stage_eval_ns": 1257311933, "stage_threat_ns": 3583042747, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 380845, "root_tactical_annotations": 964, "search_tactical_annotations": 379881, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 121999, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 734549057, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 349565, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2732722531, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46400, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1574173320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 60993, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91796966, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 121986, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15387395, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 77252, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 292307334, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 225905, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 866007186, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 77688, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8586798, "child_limit_applications": 23150, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23150, "child_cap_hits": 23150, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23150, "child_moves_before_total": 1902840, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1902840, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 216658, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 216658, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.19611231101511, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.358876889848812, "tt_hits": 9017, "tt_cutoffs": 1855, "beta_cutoffs": 18364, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5160.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5775.615384615385, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1441, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12252, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 114, 81, 79, 66, 113, 84, 83, 111, 100, 86, 99, 38, 115, 116, 131, 67, 147 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10748, "avg_search_time_ms": 1074.8, "search_nodes": 108360, "safety_nodes": 568, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 108928, "avg_nodes": 10892.8, "eval_calls": 67957, "avg_eval_calls": 6795.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67957, "pattern_eval_ns": 1398237, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.575319687449415, "pattern_frame_queries": 67957, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1398237, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.575319687449415, "pattern_frame_updates": 216612, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2452682495, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11322.929916163463, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37842, "avg_candidate_generations": 3784.2, "candidate_moves_total": 3018548, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.76713704349665, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 651, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 37832, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3017897, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 917711, "avg_legality_checks": 91771.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 856, "root_legality_checks": 651, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 917060, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 853, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3064582, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 306458.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6453907737, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2105.9667311887883, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19124, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1912.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 98318437, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5141.102122986823, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 910, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7973191, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9112, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 68718039, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9085, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21466236, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 160971, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74801, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7480.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 614797088, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8219.102525367309, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 96883, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9688.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 252666744, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2607.957474479527, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2118348091, "stage_ordering_ns": 1162452388, "stage_eval_ns": 2454080732, "stage_threat_ns": 4971658589, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 505226, "root_tactical_annotations": 2024, "search_tactical_annotations": 503202, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 216622, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1216227362, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 400681, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3551908660, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75737, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2626738331, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108306, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 154260184, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 216612, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25561517, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 95822, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 144122468, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 229114, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 780640530, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 180290, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23700866, "child_limit_applications": 37832, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37832, "child_cap_hits": 37832, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37832, "child_moves_before_total": 3017044, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3017044, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 348153, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 348153, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.74846690632269, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.202606259251427, "tt_hits": 21229, "tt_cutoffs": 2517, "beta_cutoffs": 29974, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2958.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3758.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 541, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1494, "avg_search_time_ms": 166.0, "search_nodes": 52848, "safety_nodes": 627, "corridor_nodes": 865, "corridor_branch_probes": 1026, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 317, "corridor_neutral_exits": 24, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 848, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 848, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 65, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 317, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 65, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 453, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 272960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 54340, "avg_nodes": 6037.777777777777, "eval_calls": 50368, "avg_eval_calls": 5596.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50368, "pattern_eval_ns": 970535, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.268881035578143, "pattern_frame_queries": 50368, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 970535, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.268881035578143, "pattern_frame_updates": 105644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 723098693, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6844.673554579531, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2463, "avg_candidate_generations": 273.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 173850, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.58465286236297, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 583, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 2454, "search_candidate_moves_total": 173267, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 10814, "avg_legality_checks": 1201.5555555555557, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10814, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 263800, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29311.11111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 523691790, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1985.1849507202426, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2573, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 285.8888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 23410979, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9098.709288767976, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 37100, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2535, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 23032518, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 157371, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 183990, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 24912569, "stage_ordering_ns": 84001, "stage_eval_ns": 724069228, "stage_threat_ns": 635082155, "stage_proof_ns": 92031241, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 107479, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 494380689, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 56875, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 60260369, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 661, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 24490295, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 53735, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 59877973, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1826, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10063809, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 107470, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10499315, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 200, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2172, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5553.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6442.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1442, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18420, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 114, 81, 83, 66, 113, 50, 34, 111, 99, 79, 78, 129, 115, 116, 131, 67, 147 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11110, "avg_search_time_ms": 1010.0, "search_nodes": 285531, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 1304, "corridor_branch_probes": 1514, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 576, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 1286, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1286, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 576, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 416, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 183200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 287221, "avg_nodes": 26111.0, "eval_calls": 279204, "avg_eval_calls": 25382.18181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 279204, "pattern_eval_ns": 5614998, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.110736235870547, "pattern_frame_queries": 279204, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5614998, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.110736235870547, "pattern_frame_updates": 571000, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6396637752, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11202.51795446585, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6307, "avg_candidate_generations": 573.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 496764, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.76391311241478, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 817, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 6296, "search_candidate_moves_total": 495947, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 276007, "avg_legality_checks": 25091.545454545456, "illegal_moves_skipped": 202, "root_legality_checks": 817, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 275190, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 202, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2108283, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 191662.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4854715474, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2302.686818610215, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26161, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2378.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 257563541, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9845.324758227896, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 206, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1934668, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25445, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 250465899, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 200, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2457503, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 310, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2705471, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3567, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 324.27272727272725, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 37257638, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10445.090552284833, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4989, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 453.54545454545456, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 20330798, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4075.1248747243935, "stage_move_gen_ns": 648277920, "stage_ordering_ns": 221150, "stage_eval_ns": 6402252750, "stage_threat_ns": 3800726084, "stage_proof_ns": 224509706, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 573693, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3097213821, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 75261, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 250402903, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 730, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 49874980, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 286841, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 371515851, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2682, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14956213, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 573682, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66637296, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 494, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5537, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3925.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4652.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7300, "avg_search_time_ms": 730.0, "search_nodes": 58010, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 58983, "avg_nodes": 5898.3, "eval_calls": 35706, "avg_eval_calls": 3570.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35706, "pattern_eval_ns": 737103, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.643673332213073, "pattern_frame_queries": 35706, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 737103, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.643673332213073, "pattern_frame_updates": 115912, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1031653508, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8900.316688522327, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20219, "avg_candidate_generations": 2021.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1764676, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.27810475295514, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 749, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 20209, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1763927, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1101859, "avg_legality_checks": 110185.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1092, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1101859, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1092, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2412871, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 241287.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4772113556, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1977.7740111261646, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17071, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1707.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 79806624, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4674.982367758186, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1343, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13579210, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4604, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43415451, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11124, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22811963, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 82598, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8259.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 783552820, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9486.341315770358, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 114092, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11409.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 375960661, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3295.2412176138555, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2476928627, "stage_ordering_ns": 661770247, "stage_eval_ns": 1032390611, "stage_threat_ns": 3073069203, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 313365, "root_tactical_annotations": 951, "search_tactical_annotations": 312414, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 115922, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 632961219, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 273120, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2337184722, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40492, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1306236793, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57956, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80612555, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 115912, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13405785, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52430, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 296477957, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 180191, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 734279482, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 80744, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8904922, "child_limit_applications": 20209, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20209, "child_cap_hits": 20209, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20209, "child_moves_before_total": 1762835, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1762835, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 205409, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 205409, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.23019446781137, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.164233757236875, "tt_hits": 9344, "tt_cutoffs": 2042, "beta_cutoffs": 16011, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 5.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4560.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5360.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1734, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1443, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18736, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 141, 99, 129, 86, 140, 154, 142, 54, 69, 143, 127, 157, 156, 171, 97, 82, 111, 96, 83, 55, 125 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 16886, "avg_search_time_ms": 1407.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 153482, "safety_nodes": 719, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 154201, "avg_nodes": 12850.083333333334, "eval_calls": 97125, "avg_eval_calls": 8093.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 97125, "pattern_eval_ns": 2092058, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.539850707850707, "pattern_frame_queries": 97125, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2092058, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.539850707850707, "pattern_frame_updates": 306836, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4614746159, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15039.780726511883, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52200, "avg_candidate_generations": 4350.0, "candidate_moves_total": 4658594, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.24509578544061, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 887, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 52188, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4657707, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1110381, "avg_legality_checks": 92531.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2685, "root_legality_checks": 887, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1109494, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2683, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4499841, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 374986.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9893188961, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2198.564118376627, "renju_forbidden_checks": 57213, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4767.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 455527753, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7961.96236869243, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3090, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 31872956, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 31788, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 311312107, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22315, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 112175430, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 167260, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 118176, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9848.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1160980735, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9824.166793595992, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 165223, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13768.583333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 551342775, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3336.9614097310905, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2699797594, "stage_ordering_ns": 1845799896, "stage_eval_ns": 4616838217, "stage_threat_ns": 7663644081, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 931458, "root_tactical_annotations": 2532, "search_tactical_annotations": 928926, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 306848, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1828292639, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 713592, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5522591086, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 104463, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3828570556, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 153418, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 228319550, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 306836, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38711904, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 245579, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 403056613, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 363540, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1290456116, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 322339, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 45728902, "child_limit_applications": 52188, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52188, "child_cap_hits": 52188, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52188, "child_moves_before_total": 4655024, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4655024, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 596702, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 596702, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.19721008660994, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.433701234000154, "tt_hits": 31145, "tt_cutoffs": 4106, "beta_cutoffs": 43811, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3221.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3823.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 504, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1838, "avg_search_time_ms": 167.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 53783, "safety_nodes": 1057, "corridor_nodes": 2139, "corridor_branch_probes": 2573, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 10, "corridor_depth_exits": 907, "corridor_neutral_exits": 17, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2116, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2116, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 27, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 907, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 55, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 329, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 177440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 56979, "avg_nodes": 5179.909090909091, "eval_calls": 51085, "avg_eval_calls": 4644.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51085, "pattern_eval_ns": 1054096, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.63415875501615, "pattern_frame_queries": 51085, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1054096, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.63415875501615, "pattern_frame_updates": 107502, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 820627512, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7633.602277166937, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2677, "avg_candidate_generations": 243.36363636363637, "candidate_moves_total": 200622, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.94284646992902, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 807, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 2666, "search_candidate_moves_total": 199815, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 7120, "avg_legality_checks": 647.2727272727273, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7120, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 250623, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22783.909090909092, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 583325030, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2327.499990024858, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2021, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 183.72727272727272, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19256499, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9528.203364670955, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 39290, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1842, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17428300, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 156, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1616388, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 172521, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19164849, "stage_ordering_ns": 86370, "stage_eval_ns": 821681608, "stage_threat_ns": 902527181, "stage_proof_ns": 79271104, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 111855, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 646146000, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 125365, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 144433877, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1158, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 53501948, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 55922, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74455312, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4342, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24210103, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 111844, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13281889, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 132, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2435, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5958.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6685.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1444, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19723, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 140, 154, 142, 99, 129, 100, 127, 69, 54, 97, 143, 86, 72, 141, 157, 172, 171, 115, 185 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11872, "avg_search_time_ms": 1079.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 265067, "safety_nodes": 383, "corridor_nodes": 1230, "corridor_branch_probes": 1441, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 520, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 1212, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1212, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 520, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 416, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 166880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 266680, "avg_nodes": 24243.636363636364, "eval_calls": 259115, "avg_eval_calls": 23555.909090909092, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 259115, "pattern_eval_ns": 5588385, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.56719989193987, "pattern_frame_queries": 259115, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5588385, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.56719989193987, "pattern_frame_updates": 530072, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7056301907, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13311.968764620655, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5932, "avg_candidate_generations": 539.2727272727273, "candidate_moves_total": 462087, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.8973364801079, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 809, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 5921, "search_candidate_moves_total": 461278, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 255221, "avg_legality_checks": 23201.909090909092, "illegal_moves_skipped": 89, "root_legality_checks": 809, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 254412, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 89, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2105674, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 191424.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5329724212, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2531.1250516461714, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32246, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2931.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 356524440, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11056.392730881349, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 92, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 898154, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 31484, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 349475823, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 213, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2599199, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 457, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3551264, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3511, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 319.1818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 38675117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11015.413557391057, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4992, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 453.8181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 20977044, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4202.132211538462, "stage_move_gen_ns": 665987938, "stage_ordering_ns": 205700, "stage_eval_ns": 7061890292, "stage_threat_ns": 3881356162, "stage_proof_ns": 246465825, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 532617, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3162727420, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 73416, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 255282583, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 707, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 50820685, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 266303, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 380576052, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2534, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15042178, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 532606, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67727929, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 493, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5083, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3778.3636363636365, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4505.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7839, "avg_search_time_ms": 783.9, "search_nodes": 52706, "safety_nodes": 953, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53659, "avg_nodes": 5365.9, "eval_calls": 32302, "avg_eval_calls": 3230.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32302, "pattern_eval_ns": 715775, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.15884465358182, "pattern_frame_queries": 32302, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 715775, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.15884465358182, "pattern_frame_updates": 105304, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1202585747, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11420.133584669149, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18309, "avg_candidate_generations": 1830.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1573698, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.9521546780272, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 739, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 18299, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1572959, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 962815, "avg_legality_checks": 96281.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 526, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 962815, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 526, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2377377, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 237737.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5186673038, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2181.67881577049, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14616, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1461.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60516547, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4140.431513409962, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 730, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7506851, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3634, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34188528, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10252, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18821168, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 101016, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10101.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1086950910, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10760.185614160133, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 143478, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14347.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 535708924, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3733.735652852702, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2422905134, "stage_ordering_ns": 657886581, "stage_eval_ns": 1203301522, "stage_threat_ns": 3511635923, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 330041, "root_tactical_annotations": 951, "search_tactical_annotations": 329090, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 105314, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 654196647, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 291435, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2753393242, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36672, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1357258820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52652, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81691531, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 105304, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13730151, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 54194, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 345359323, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 200562, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1050577889, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 75285, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8624352, "child_limit_applications": 18299, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18299, "child_cap_hits": 18299, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18299, "child_moves_before_total": 1572433, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1572433, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 211117, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 211117, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.92999617465435, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.53707852888136, "tt_hits": 8141, "tt_cutoffs": 2052, "beta_cutoffs": 14431, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 5.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4229.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5029.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1618, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1445, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29369, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 126, 82, 142, 94, 141, 81, 156, 111, 158, 174, 83, 114, 130, 66, 50, 70, 56, 113, 115, 67, 186, 171, 144, 172, 143, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 22366, "avg_search_time_ms": 1597.5714285714287, "search_nodes": 187476, "safety_nodes": 713, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 188189, "avg_nodes": 13442.07142857143, "eval_calls": 118888, "avg_eval_calls": 8492.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 118888, "pattern_eval_ns": 2626205, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.089739923289144, "pattern_frame_queries": 118888, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2626205, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.089739923289144, "pattern_frame_updates": 374790, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5651125259, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15078.111099549082, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 62083, "avg_candidate_generations": 4434.5, "candidate_moves_total": 5815942, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.68010566499686, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1156, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 62069, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5814786, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 1694594, "avg_legality_checks": 121042.42857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4503, "root_legality_checks": 1156, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1693438, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4501, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5760389, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 411456.35714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13198844846, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2291.311376019918, "renju_forbidden_checks": 94801, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6771.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 634939495, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6697.603348065949, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5864, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 57595018, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 46990, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 400859059, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 41909, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 176089867, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 395551, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 159895, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11421.07142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1629161571, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10188.946314769068, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 223500, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15964.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 752146142, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3365.3071230425057, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4334391431, "stage_ordering_ns": 2320310571, "stage_eval_ns": 5653751464, "stage_threat_ns": 9987557484, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1339484, "root_tactical_annotations": 3719, "search_tactical_annotations": 1335765, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 374804, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2320450031, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1063676, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7271197417, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 124247, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4734561044, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 187395, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 293661120, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 374790, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49195076, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 346643, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 469841867, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 592777, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2066476405, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 400064, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 53053840, "child_limit_applications": 62069, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 62069, "child_cap_hits": 62069, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 62069, "child_moves_before_total": 5810285, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5810285, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 790948, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 790948, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.61009521661377, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.743044031642205, "tt_hits": 35762, "tt_cutoffs": 6441, "beta_cutoffs": 51006, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1626.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2032.7142857142858, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6989, "avg_search_time_ms": 499.2142857142857, "search_nodes": 183308, "safety_nodes": 1703, "corridor_nodes": 2552, "corridor_branch_probes": 2995, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 22, "corridor_depth_exits": 1195, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 2527, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2527, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1195, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 60, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 362, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 200640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 187563, "avg_nodes": 13397.357142857143, "eval_calls": 179294, "avg_eval_calls": 12806.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 179294, "pattern_eval_ns": 3862663, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.543738217675998, "pattern_frame_queries": 179294, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3862663, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.543738217675998, "pattern_frame_updates": 366536, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4128890151, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11264.623805028701, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3988, "avg_candidate_generations": 284.85714285714283, "candidate_moves_total": 339615, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.15922768304915, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1184, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 3974, "search_candidate_moves_total": 338431, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 7185, "avg_legality_checks": 513.2142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7185, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1141468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 81533.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2761716529, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2419.4427955930432, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24124, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1723.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 201923874, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8370.248466257668, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 249481, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23978, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 200445018, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 51, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 489754, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 71, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 739621, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20849309, "stage_ordering_ns": 132080, "stage_eval_ns": 4132752814, "stage_threat_ns": 2722920790, "stage_proof_ns": 91493336, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 371730, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2220122057, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 138099, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 163311430, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1176, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 53817447, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185858, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 262536457, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5180, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 30243374, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 371716, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46707472, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 169, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3679, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6057.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6629.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1967, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1446, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16697, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 84, 82, 140, 97, 127, 66, 114, 52, 67, 80, 94, 79, 81, 50, 34, 53, 54, 65, 99, 69, 144, 129, 95, 51, 49, 93, 37, 107 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 9664, "avg_search_time_ms": 644.2666666666667, "search_nodes": 237252, "safety_nodes": 254, "corridor_nodes": 2224, "corridor_branch_probes": 2564, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 769, "corridor_neutral_exits": 43, "corridor_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_plies_followed": 2189, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2189, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 146, "corridor_proof_active": 35, "corridor_proof_quiet": 111, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 43, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 769, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 146, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 141, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1197, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 342480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 18, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 14, "total_nodes": 239730, "avg_nodes": 15982.0, "eval_calls": 229642, "avg_eval_calls": 15309.466666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 229642, "pattern_eval_ns": 4663225, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.306498811193073, "pattern_frame_queries": 229642, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4663225, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.306498811193073, "pattern_frame_updates": 474418, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5132656164, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10818.847859904135, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7582, "avg_candidate_generations": 505.46666666666664, "candidate_moves_total": 588252, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.58533368504352, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1088, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 7567, "search_candidate_moves_total": 587164, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 221337, "avg_legality_checks": 14755.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 219, "root_legality_checks": 1088, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 220249, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 215, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1926549, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 128436.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4279908568, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2221.5415066006626, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19714, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1314.2666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 138404789, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7020.634523688749, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 324, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2312069, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18448, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 129393744, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 235, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2569247, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 707, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4129729, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4164, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 277.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 39046480, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9377.156580211335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5924, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 394.93333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 20679139, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3490.739196488859, "stage_move_gen_ns": 529920466, "stage_ordering_ns": 260880, "stage_eval_ns": 5137319389, "stage_threat_ns": 3447834556, "stage_proof_ns": 518963883, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 479103, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2664018015, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 147976, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 379179851, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1755, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 83200226, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 239544, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 320023415, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4670, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28736882, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 479088, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55876393, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 814, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6430, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5396.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5930.133333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 7019, "avg_search_time_ms": 501.35714285714283, "search_nodes": 56880, "safety_nodes": 1587, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 58467, "avg_nodes": 4176.214285714285, "eval_calls": 34252, "avg_eval_calls": 2446.5714285714284, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34252, "pattern_eval_ns": 719956, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.019385729300478, "pattern_frame_queries": 34252, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 719956, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.019385729300478, "pattern_frame_updates": 113600, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1123397382, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9889.061461267605, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20911, "avg_candidate_generations": 1493.642857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 1662506, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.50389747023098, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1018, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 20897, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1661488, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 924863, "avg_legality_checks": 66061.64285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 928, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 924863, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 928, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2169531, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 154966.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4509855728, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2078.7238015958287, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20336, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1452.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61561553, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3027.2203481510624, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1410, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10564606, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5570, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30142796, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13322, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20533520, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 320631, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 69946, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4996.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 590379065, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8440.497884082006, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 93193, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6656.642857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 245031445, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2629.2902363911453, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2183276471, "stage_ordering_ns": 664247567, "stage_eval_ns": 1124117338, "stage_threat_ns": 2999052379, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 301949, "root_tactical_annotations": 524, "search_tactical_annotations": 301425, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 113614, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 668828230, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 284798, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2226783890, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41902, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1375113176, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56800, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 83409151, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 113600, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13734283, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 54139, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 174728106, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 188747, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 676556367, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 59063, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6296825, "child_limit_applications": 20897, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20897, "child_cap_hits": 20897, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20897, "child_moves_before_total": 1660560, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1660560, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 189091, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 189091, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.46403790017706, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.048715126573192, "tt_hits": 7700, "tt_cutoffs": 1652, "beta_cutoffs": 16438, "depth_sum": 79, "avg_depth": 5.642857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 79, "avg_effective_depth": 5.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5379.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5951.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1447, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18927, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 99, 128, 144, 129, 130, 126, 125, 111, 141, 95, 143, 81, 66, 79, 63, 80, 64, 82, 78, 83 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 17946, "avg_search_time_ms": 1495.5, "search_nodes": 181384, "safety_nodes": 222, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 181606, "avg_nodes": 15133.833333333334, "eval_calls": 115435, "avg_eval_calls": 9619.583333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 115435, "pattern_eval_ns": 2393817, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.737358686706806, "pattern_frame_queries": 115435, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2393817, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.737358686706806, "pattern_frame_updates": 362640, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4501586948, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12413.376759320538, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 61797, "avg_candidate_generations": 5149.75, "candidate_moves_total": 4549344, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.61755425020633, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 61785, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4548610, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1241448, "avg_legality_checks": 103454.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1324, "root_legality_checks": 734, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1240714, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1324, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4921094, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 410091.1666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10615154421, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2157.0720699502995, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36162, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3013.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 146221179, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4043.503650240584, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1506, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10029206, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17675, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 97753723, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16981, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 38438250, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 122500, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10208.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1019591048, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8323.192228571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 160945, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13412.083333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 406812674, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2527.650278045295, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2998536729, "stage_ordering_ns": 1883794119, "stage_eval_ns": 4503980765, "stage_threat_ns": 8510053875, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1030889, "root_tactical_annotations": 3546, "search_tactical_annotations": 1027343, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 362652, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2124827801, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 749943, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6028466704, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 123657, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4432968744, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 181320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 263775358, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 362640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45275117, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 217350, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 256730512, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 408925, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1338631767, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 404614, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 47708895, "child_limit_applications": 61785, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 61785, "child_cap_hits": 61785, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 61785, "child_moves_before_total": 4547286, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4547286, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 713644, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 713644, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.59854333576111, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.55044104556122, "tt_hits": 37793, "tt_cutoffs": 4102, "beta_cutoffs": 49720, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1065.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1575.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 968, "avg_search_time_ms": 88.0, "search_nodes": 25142, "safety_nodes": 888, "corridor_nodes": 1117, "corridor_branch_probes": 1376, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 493, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1108, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1108, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 29, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 493, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 183, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 59760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 27147, "avg_nodes": 2467.909090909091, "eval_calls": 23851, "avg_eval_calls": 2168.2727272727275, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23851, "pattern_eval_ns": 487511, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.43985577124649, "pattern_frame_queries": 23851, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 487511, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.43985577124649, "pattern_frame_updates": 50220, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 443724044, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8835.604221425727, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1270, "avg_candidate_generations": 115.45454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 83926, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.08346456692914, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 670, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 1259, "search_candidate_moves_total": 83256, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 3671, "avg_legality_checks": 333.72727272727275, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3671, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 153760, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13978.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 344931502, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2243.311017169615, "renju_forbidden_checks": 489, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 44.45454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4044812, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8271.59918200409, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 473, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 3944921, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 99891, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9769809, "stage_ordering_ns": 42030, "stage_eval_ns": 444211555, "stage_threat_ns": 445903922, "stage_proof_ns": 54057713, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 52523, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 323691029, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 62954, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 65890052, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 566, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16703350, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 26256, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 36267812, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2292, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13409282, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 52512, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6645747, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1130, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6063.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6790.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1952, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1448, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 42646, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 128, 113, 99, 114, 115, 157, 172, 141, 83, 155, 169, 131, 100, 101, 85, 70, 86, 84, 160, 156, 158, 154, 153, 126, 111, 140, 168, 139, 138, 143 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 18589, "avg_search_time_ms": 1093.4705882352941, "search_nodes": 438002, "safety_nodes": 1198, "corridor_nodes": 1991, "corridor_branch_probes": 2336, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 901, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1972, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1972, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 97, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 78, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 901, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 97, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 93, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 709, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 222720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 441191, "avg_nodes": 25952.41176470588, "eval_calls": 428365, "avg_eval_calls": 25197.941176470587, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 428365, "pattern_eval_ns": 9133471, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.32170228660138, "pattern_frame_queries": 428365, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 9133471, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.32170228660138, "pattern_frame_updates": 875906, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 10953982304, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12505.887965146945, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9605, "avg_candidate_generations": 565.0, "candidate_moves_total": 764729, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.61780322748568, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1299, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 9588, "search_candidate_moves_total": 763430, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 418021, "avg_legality_checks": 24589.470588235294, "illegal_moves_skipped": 392, "root_legality_checks": 1299, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 416722, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 392, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3522407, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 207200.41176470587, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8357274866, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2372.603411814705, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45539, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2678.764705882353, "renju_forbidden_ns": 372999518, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8190.7709435868155, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 651, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4531024, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 43534, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 361180064, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 219, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2416815, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1135, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4871615, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 5399, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 317.5882352941176, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 55146528, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10214.211520651972, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7759, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 456.4117647058824, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 30091158, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3878.226317824462, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1050405611, "stage_ordering_ns": 340222, "stage_eval_ns": 10963115775, "stage_threat_ns": 6165350986, "stage_proof_ns": 367305191, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 880061, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5065448088, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 107082, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 340354415, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1207, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 69245872, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 440022, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 617464237, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4138, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 31408418, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 880044, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 110675828, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 604, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8478, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.764705882352941, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.764705882352941, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4322.058823529412, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4792.64705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 24040, "avg_search_time_ms": 1502.5, "search_nodes": 191765, "safety_nodes": 896, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 192661, "avg_nodes": 12041.3125, "eval_calls": 127183, "avg_eval_calls": 7948.9375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 127183, "pattern_eval_ns": 2796794, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.990313170785402, "pattern_frame_queries": 127183, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2796794, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.990313170785402, "pattern_frame_updates": 383356, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4371884086, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11404.240669247383, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 58880, "avg_candidate_generations": 3680.0, "candidate_moves_total": 5043916, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.66433423913044, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1223, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 58864, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5042693, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 3051591, "avg_legality_checks": 190724.4375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2181, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3051591, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2181, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7490105, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 468131.5625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15399386247, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2055.964001439232, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41790, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2611.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 176249840, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4217.512323522374, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2526, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22358900, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12149, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 102200635, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 27115, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 51690305, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 286983, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17936.4375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2673304863, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9315.202862190443, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 398235, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 24889.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1289424164, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3237.8474117041446, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7145618695, "stage_ordering_ns": 2000400486, "stage_eval_ns": 4374680880, "stage_threat_ns": 10391848000, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1203797, "root_tactical_annotations": 3198, "search_tactical_annotations": 1200599, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 383372, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2313816008, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1066967, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7699695964, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 117847, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4057409381, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 191678, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 295789171, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 383356, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50147931, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 300231, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1001249882, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 648879, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2640871139, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 254687, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32398926, "child_limit_applications": 58864, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 58864, "child_cap_hits": 58864, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 58864, "child_moves_before_total": 5040512, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5040512, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 674448, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 674448, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.62979070399565, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.457733079641207, "tt_hits": 26904, "tt_cutoffs": 5633, "beta_cutoffs": 45978, "depth_sum": 84, "avg_depth": 5.25, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 84, "avg_effective_depth": 5.25, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2168.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2668.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1449, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20303, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 143, 126, 140, 141, 156, 96, 81, 97, 95, 83, 125, 99, 100, 69, 55, 84, 70, 114, 54, 129 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 18027, "avg_search_time_ms": 1502.25, "search_nodes": 174294, "safety_nodes": 222, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 174516, "avg_nodes": 14543.0, "eval_calls": 110250, "avg_eval_calls": 9187.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110250, "pattern_eval_ns": 2436427, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.09911111111111, "pattern_frame_queries": 110250, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2436427, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.09911111111111, "pattern_frame_updates": 348460, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4539452831, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13027.184844745452, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 59839, "avg_candidate_generations": 4986.583333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4403738, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.59310817359916, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 59827, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4403004, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 1150702, "avg_legality_checks": 95891.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1297, "root_legality_checks": 734, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1149968, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1297, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4682201, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 390183.4166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10606917809, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2265.3700276856976, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34861, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2905.0833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 158514229, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4547.0362009121945, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1411, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10640098, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17590, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 107695632, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15860, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40178499, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 115780, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9648.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1008847931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8713.490507859735, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 152076, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12673.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 401907812, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2642.808937636445, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2922905571, "stage_ordering_ns": 1909363368, "stage_eval_ns": 4541889258, "stage_threat_ns": 8600013906, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 989537, "root_tactical_annotations": 3546, "search_tactical_annotations": 985991, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 348472, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2134486324, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 729795, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6104555147, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 119741, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4499617638, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 174230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 268121659, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 348460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45971921, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 207317, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 259217769, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 402726, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1345578689, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 379494, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 46878855, "child_limit_applications": 59827, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 59827, "child_cap_hits": 59827, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 59827, "child_moves_before_total": 4401707, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4401707, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 686330, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 686330, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.57392147358216, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.471910675781837, "tt_hits": 36377, "tt_cutoffs": 4155, "beta_cutoffs": 48339, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 934.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1437.0833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2266, "avg_search_time_ms": 206.0, "search_nodes": 61763, "safety_nodes": 888, "corridor_nodes": 1159, "corridor_branch_probes": 1438, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 513, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1150, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1150, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 29, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 513, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 183, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 43600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 63810, "avg_nodes": 5800.909090909091, "eval_calls": 59607, "avg_eval_calls": 5418.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 59607, "pattern_eval_ns": 1296915, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.75776334994212, "pattern_frame_queries": 59607, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1296915, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.75776334994212, "pattern_frame_updates": 123462, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1205055557, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9760.538116991464, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2135, "avg_candidate_generations": 194.0909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 138974, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.09320843091335, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 670, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 2124, "search_candidate_moves_total": 138304, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 4468, "avg_legality_checks": 406.1818181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4468, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 333575, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 30325.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 793624721, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2379.1492797721653, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1690, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 153.63636363636363, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13959425, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8260.014792899408, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1669, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13783115, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 176310, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12863035, "stage_ordering_ns": 71551, "stage_eval_ns": 1206352472, "stage_threat_ns": 973418405, "stage_proof_ns": 57073408, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125849, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 780281272, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64988, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 71780319, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 576, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17587662, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 62919, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90832303, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2376, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14251611, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 125838, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16272900, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1937, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5857.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6584.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1930, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1450, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25982, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 126, 70, 127, 108, 109, 125, 99, 85, 129, 130, 84, 114, 97, 146, 162, 100, 115, 81, 143, 101, 131, 83, 145, 161, 173, 158, 159, 117, 187 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 4356, "avg_search_time_ms": 272.25, "search_nodes": 159042, "safety_nodes": 1718, "corridor_nodes": 1086, "corridor_branch_probes": 1259, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 368, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1061, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1056, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 368, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 91, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 528, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 197600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 161846, "avg_nodes": 10115.375, "eval_calls": 154012, "avg_eval_calls": 9625.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 154012, "pattern_eval_ns": 2859898, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.56931927382282, "pattern_frame_queries": 154012, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2859898, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.56931927382282, "pattern_frame_updates": 317990, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2381826712, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7490.256649580176, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4999, "avg_candidate_generations": 312.4375, "candidate_moves_total": 356110, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.23624724944989, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1185, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4983, "search_candidate_moves_total": 354925, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 149705, "avg_legality_checks": 9356.5625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 1185, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 148520, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1296834, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 81052.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1905140268, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1469.070264968377, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11500, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 718.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 52224529, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4541.263391304348, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12440, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11434, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 52096478, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 53650, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 41, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61961, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1896, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 118.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 14313143, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7549.1260548523205, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2568, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 160.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 7510659, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2924.711448598131, "stage_move_gen_ns": 233435996, "stage_ordering_ns": 147202, "stage_eval_ns": 2384686610, "stage_threat_ns": 1494542578, "stage_proof_ns": 200697757, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 320312, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1141400494, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 72363, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 166823658, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 872, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 35061668, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 160148, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 146838596, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2306, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13239442, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 320296, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26240388, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 188, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4553, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6261.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6761.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1841, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 21609, "avg_search_time_ms": 1350.5625, "search_nodes": 204053, "safety_nodes": 426, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 204479, "avg_nodes": 12779.9375, "eval_calls": 126085, "avg_eval_calls": 7880.3125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 126085, "pattern_eval_ns": 2471437, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.60135622794147, "pattern_frame_queries": 126085, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2471437, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.60135622794147, "pattern_frame_updates": 407918, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2885663624, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7074.126721546978, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 72919, "avg_candidate_generations": 4557.4375, "candidate_moves_total": 6527619, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.51876739944322, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1222, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 72903, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6526397, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 4751644, "avg_legality_checks": 296977.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1321, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4751644, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1321, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9506255, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 594140.9375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14378910516, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1512.5736176864602, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37972, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2373.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61092207, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1608.875144843569, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1545, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8623257, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6712, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29733433, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29715, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22735517, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 309008, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19313.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2258335573, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7308.340149769585, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 436562, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27285.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1134598588, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2598.9403292086804, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8267395004, "stage_ordering_ns": 1860852460, "stage_eval_ns": 2888135061, "stage_threat_ns": 8414414370, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1339551, "root_tactical_annotations": 4857, "search_tactical_annotations": 1334694, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 407934, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1799085291, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1048323, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6285535276, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 145931, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3395693555, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 203959, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 237450243, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 407918, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39683261, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 359598, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1294389461, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 542782, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1595415150, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 437171, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 52660299, "child_limit_applications": 72903, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 72903, "child_cap_hits": 72903, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 72903, "child_moves_before_total": 6525076, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6525076, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 774057, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 774057, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.50353209058612, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.617628904160323, "tt_hits": 42828, "tt_cutoffs": 4973, "beta_cutoffs": 60039, "depth_sum": 91, "avg_depth": 5.6875, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 91, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6875, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4869.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5368.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1773, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1451, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13805, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 96, 128, 95, 98, 94, 93, 127, 142, 82, 67, 100, 158, 110, 156, 170, 174, 190, 113, 143, 68, 83, 159, 111, 79, 125, 69, 139 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 9446, "avg_search_time_ms": 674.7142857142857, "search_nodes": 93645, "safety_nodes": 1291, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 94936, "avg_nodes": 6781.142857142857, "eval_calls": 56307, "avg_eval_calls": 4021.9285714285716, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 56307, "pattern_eval_ns": 1148953, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.405153888504092, "pattern_frame_queries": 56307, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1148953, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.405153888504092, "pattern_frame_updates": 187130, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2205384908, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11785.309186127291, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33896, "avg_candidate_generations": 2421.1428571428573, "candidate_moves_total": 2575605, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.98551451498702, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1097, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 33882, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2574508, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 825501, "avg_legality_checks": 58964.357142857145, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1981, "root_legality_checks": 1097, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 824404, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1978, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2818530, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 201323.57142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5611419991, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1990.9030562030562, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31444, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2246.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 141038895, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4485.399281261926, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2215, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13148198, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12682, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 89852290, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16499, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37857556, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 180851, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 66192, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4728.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 535008894, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8082.682106598984, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 93035, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6645.357142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 250831766, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2696.101101735906, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1772318905, "stage_ordering_ns": 985386141, "stage_eval_ns": 2206533861, "stage_threat_ns": 4440361381, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 486917, "root_tactical_annotations": 1452, "search_tactical_annotations": 485465, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 187144, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1032812713, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 423303, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3239264563, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67871, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2346627363, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 93565, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 129640996, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 187130, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22039599, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 66250, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 61766802, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 289173, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 830404587, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 131494, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16603510, "child_limit_applications": 33882, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33882, "child_cap_hits": 33882, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33882, "child_moves_before_total": 2572530, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2572530, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 368763, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 368763, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.92615548078626, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.883743580662298, "tt_hits": 16054, "tt_cutoffs": 3377, "beta_cutoffs": 27273, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4226.071428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4797.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 4347, "avg_search_time_ms": 334.38461538461536, "search_nodes": 156346, "safety_nodes": 1468, "corridor_nodes": 3596, "corridor_branch_probes": 4019, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 26, "corridor_depth_exits": 1644, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 3570, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3555, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 15, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 27, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1644, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 3, "corridor_proof_unknown": 63, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 375, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 182000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 161410, "avg_nodes": 12416.153846153846, "eval_calls": 152835, "avg_eval_calls": 11756.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 152835, "pattern_eval_ns": 2969831, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.4316157948114, "pattern_frame_queries": 152835, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2969831, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.4316157948114, "pattern_frame_updates": 312616, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2388424120, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7640.1211710213165, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3486, "avg_candidate_generations": 268.15384615384613, "candidate_moves_total": 307639, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.24985656913368, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1024, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 3473, "search_candidate_moves_total": 306615, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 6611, "avg_legality_checks": 508.53846153846155, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6611, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 869564, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 66889.53846153847, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1485366000, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1708.173291442608, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20613, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1585.6153846153845, "renju_forbidden_ns": 126125169, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6118.719691456848, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 124191, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20181, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 123592454, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 265, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1780054, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 147, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 628470, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.846153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 461230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5182.359550561798, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 116, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.923076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 226250, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1950.4310344827586, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14735944, "stage_ordering_ns": 109242, "stage_eval_ns": 2391393951, "stage_threat_ns": 1849504801, "stage_proof_ns": 61579512, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 319901, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1456139250, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 194710, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 158529255, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1940, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 65024698, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 159944, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 175587084, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7272, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 27471162, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 319888, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31778050, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 155, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3200, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6352.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6968.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1746, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1452, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 31125, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 128, 96, 160, 111, 52, 67, 81, 143, 159, 141, 156, 144, 142, 113, 170, 184, 158, 157, 99, 125, 173, 171, 129, 155, 169, 123, 124, 139, 187, 107 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 5016, "avg_search_time_ms": 313.5, "search_nodes": 115688, "safety_nodes": 1718, "corridor_nodes": 1190, "corridor_branch_probes": 1419, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 436, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1165, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1160, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 436, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 91, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 528, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 202160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 118596, "avg_nodes": 7412.25, "eval_calls": 112202, "avg_eval_calls": 7012.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 112202, "pattern_eval_ns": 2295588, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.459421400688043, "pattern_frame_queries": 112202, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2295588, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.459421400688043, "pattern_frame_updates": 231282, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2737511201, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11836.248393735787, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3455, "avg_candidate_generations": 215.9375, "candidate_moves_total": 273460, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.14905933429812, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1185, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3439, "search_candidate_moves_total": 272275, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 108555, "avg_legality_checks": 6784.6875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 1185, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 107370, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1076711, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 67294.4375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2352560190, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2184.950455600435, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11663, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 728.9375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 103327998, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8859.469947697848, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11110, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11545, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 103111397, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 47310, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 94, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 158181, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2139, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 133.6875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 19729710, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9223.800841514727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2904, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 181.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 10180222, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3505.58608815427, "stage_move_gen_ns": 253700656, "stage_ordering_ns": 106510, "stage_eval_ns": 2739806789, "stage_threat_ns": 1719230796, "stage_proof_ns": 276220723, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 233812, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1304039758, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 75956, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 216788708, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 888, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 47851525, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 116898, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 154174177, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2514, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16163264, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 233796, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28064889, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 188, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3124, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6611.9375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7111.9375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1898, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 26092, "avg_search_time_ms": 1630.75, "search_nodes": 185996, "safety_nodes": 426, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 186422, "avg_nodes": 11651.375, "eval_calls": 113860, "avg_eval_calls": 7116.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 113860, "pattern_eval_ns": 2397706, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.058369927981733, "pattern_frame_queries": 113860, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2397706, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.058369927981733, "pattern_frame_updates": 371804, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3307910606, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8896.92043657411, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 67533, "avg_candidate_generations": 4220.8125, "candidate_moves_total": 5957391, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.21451734707476, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1222, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 67517, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5956169, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 4439489, "avg_legality_checks": 277468.0625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 279, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4439489, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 279, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8863041, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 553940.0625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17727121468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2000.1172811905078, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30649, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1915.5625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57100293, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1863.0393487552612, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2640190, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4033, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26591399, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26283, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27868704, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 294263, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18391.4375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2775703613, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9432.730628723284, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 417100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26068.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1379131059, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3306.4758067609687, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9992070554, "stage_ordering_ns": 2242022528, "stage_eval_ns": 3310308312, "stage_threat_ns": 10382244499, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1219638, "root_tactical_annotations": 4857, "search_tactical_annotations": 1214781, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 371820, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2118318046, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 958805, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7896791229, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 135159, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4375151741, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185902, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 270134041, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 371804, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45938775, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 324148, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1377880882, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 499486, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2143720256, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 396004, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 51062408, "child_limit_applications": 67517, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 67517, "child_cap_hits": 67517, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 67517, "child_moves_before_total": 5955890, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5955890, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 707161, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 707161, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.21319075195876, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.473821407941703, "tt_hits": 39528, "tt_cutoffs": 4528, "beta_cutoffs": 55650, "depth_sum": 91, "avg_depth": 5.6875, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 91, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6875, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2491.3125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2865.4375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1453, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 34535, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 124, 82, 114, 98, 140, 97, 138, 152, 139, 141, 137, 136, 67, 128, 83, 81, 129, 168, 184, 143, 158, 65, 49, 70, 84, 99, 155, 127, 85, 95, 159, 79 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 28604, "avg_search_time_ms": 1589.111111111111, "search_nodes": 279051, "safety_nodes": 1059, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 280110, "avg_nodes": 15561.666666666666, "eval_calls": 187774, "avg_eval_calls": 10431.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 187774, "pattern_eval_ns": 3871621, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.61851481035713, "pattern_frame_queries": 187774, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3871621, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.61851481035713, "pattern_frame_updates": 557906, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7563465668, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13556.881747104351, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 85171, "avg_candidate_generations": 4731.722222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 7577550, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.96866304258492, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1432, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 85153, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7576118, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 2321045, "avg_legality_checks": 128946.94444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10882, "root_legality_checks": 1432, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 2319613, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10873, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8116467, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 450914.8333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16574237256, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2042.050716894432, "renju_forbidden_checks": 141008, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7833.777777777777, "renju_forbidden_ns": 773933095, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5488.575790026098, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12466, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 115956511, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 62150, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 467622262, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 66344, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 189876539, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 477783, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 261490, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14527.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2168389408, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8292.437217484416, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 344835, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19157.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 894028173, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2592.625960241855, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5356360390, "stage_ordering_ns": 2794535973, "stage_eval_ns": 7567337289, "stage_threat_ns": 12788225008, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1971182, "root_tactical_annotations": 4684, "search_tactical_annotations": 1966498, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 557924, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3173214658, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1627497, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9069266203, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 170439, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5537162799, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 278953, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 404405900, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 557906, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69046485, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 473552, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 512275085, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 983492, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3019529137, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 514138, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 72291762, "child_limit_applications": 85153, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 85153, "child_cap_hits": 85153, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 85153, "child_moves_before_total": 7565245, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7565245, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 1234342, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1234342, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.84296501591254, "avg_child_moves_after": 14.495578546850963, "tt_hits": 41477, "tt_cutoffs": 6028, "beta_cutoffs": 69428, "depth_sum": 95, "avg_depth": 5.277777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 95, "avg_effective_depth": 5.277777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2783.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3198.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 5916, "avg_search_time_ms": 348.0, "search_nodes": 172393, "safety_nodes": 1953, "corridor_nodes": 2496, "corridor_branch_probes": 3073, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 23, "corridor_depth_exits": 1194, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 46, "corridor_plies_followed": 2482, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2482, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 29, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1194, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 46, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 67, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 353, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 215600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 176842, "avg_nodes": 10402.470588235294, "eval_calls": 167999, "avg_eval_calls": 9882.29411764706, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 167999, "pattern_eval_ns": 3386272, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.156500931553165, "pattern_frame_queries": 167999, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3386272, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.156500931553165, "pattern_frame_updates": 344686, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3347151618, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9710.726916671985, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4361, "avg_candidate_generations": 256.52941176470586, "candidate_moves_total": 344912, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.09011694565467, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1349, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 4344, "search_candidate_moves_total": 343563, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 8022, "avg_legality_checks": 471.88235294117646, "illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8022, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 927798, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 54576.35294117647, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2117769227, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2282.575762180992, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17417, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1024.5294117647059, "renju_forbidden_ns": 168414266, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9669.533559166332, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 251832, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17176, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 166573919, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 106, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 411812, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 108, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1176703, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 21759830, "stage_ordering_ns": 136600, "stage_eval_ns": 3350537890, "stage_threat_ns": 2428969868, "stage_proof_ns": 102100906, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 349803, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1985003998, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 122636, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 133800946, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1313, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 49100339, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 174893, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 231417147, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5100, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 35710767, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 349786, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43037010, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 148, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3912, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6249.35294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6719.941176470588, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1956, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1454, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15243, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 114, 111, 126, 140, 84, 143, 141, 127, 98, 70, 95, 145, 68, 144, 146, 175, 159, 130, 83, 53, 128 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5115, "avg_search_time_ms": 465.0, "search_nodes": 122041, "safety_nodes": 800, "corridor_nodes": 1144, "corridor_branch_probes": 1292, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 520, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1128, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1128, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 520, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 67, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 471, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 130160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 123985, "avg_nodes": 11271.363636363636, "eval_calls": 118141, "avg_eval_calls": 10740.09090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 118141, "pattern_eval_ns": 2353382, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.92011240805478, "pattern_frame_queries": 118141, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2353382, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.92011240805478, "pattern_frame_updates": 244020, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2943140620, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12061.063109581182, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3880, "avg_candidate_generations": 352.72727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 279087, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.92963917525773, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 756, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 3869, "search_candidate_moves_total": 278331, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 112047, "avg_legality_checks": 10186.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 97, "root_legality_checks": 756, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 111291, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 97, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1088001, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 98909.18181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2338636022, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2149.4796622429576, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16326, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1484.1818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 135447170, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8296.408795785863, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 97, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 854021, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 129693942, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 204, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1902366, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 404, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2996841, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3021, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 274.6363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 23992879, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7942.03210857332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4234, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 384.90909090909093, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 13472182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3181.904109589041, "stage_move_gen_ns": 264322162, "stage_ordering_ns": 132091, "stage_eval_ns": 2945494002, "stage_threat_ns": 1682521898, "stage_proof_ns": 199964176, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 246425, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1327346692, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64483, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 156819531, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 744, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 34547462, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123207, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 158982280, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2394, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10859335, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 246414, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28514060, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 249, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3451, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5356.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6084.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1749, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10119, "avg_search_time_ms": 1011.9, "search_nodes": 84167, "safety_nodes": 719, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 84886, "avg_nodes": 8488.6, "eval_calls": 50355, "avg_eval_calls": 5035.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50355, "pattern_eval_ns": 1025003, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.355535696554462, "pattern_frame_queries": 50355, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1025003, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.355535696554462, "pattern_frame_updates": 168214, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1797600734, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10686.391941217735, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31242, "avg_candidate_generations": 3124.2, "candidate_moves_total": 2414294, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.27719096088599, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 681, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 31232, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2413613, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 1499025, "avg_legality_checks": 149902.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5664, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1499025, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3550746, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 355074.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6580580627, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1853.295230636041, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35832, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3583.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 201392301, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5620.45939383791, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5808, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 45886810, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13387, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 112780300, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16632, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42694411, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 30780, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 109893, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10989.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 949647034, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8641.560736352634, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 152514, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15251.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 444561924, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2914.892560682954, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3147471777, "stage_ordering_ns": 859294085, "stage_eval_ns": 1798625737, "stage_threat_ns": 4251111443, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 455327, "root_tactical_annotations": 1824, "search_tactical_annotations": 453503, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 168224, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 875466968, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 378513, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3230631013, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62544, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1968218081, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84107, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 110885410, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 168214, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18855371, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 75314, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 274613410, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 240647, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 987632622, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 139366, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15272681, "child_limit_applications": 31232, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31232, "child_cap_hits": 31232, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31232, "child_moves_before_total": 2407949, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2407949, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 292583, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 292583, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.09877689549181, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.36805199795082, "tt_hits": 16229, "tt_cutoffs": 2521, "beta_cutoffs": 25070, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 5.9, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 5.9, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3320.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4120.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1627, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1455, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16979, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 98, 68, 54, 142, 126, 84, 140, 154, 125, 128, 100, 83, 99, 101, 85, 81, 80, 156, 170, 124, 113, 110 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 11471, "avg_search_time_ms": 955.9166666666666, "search_nodes": 133570, "safety_nodes": 757, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 134327, "avg_nodes": 11193.916666666666, "eval_calls": 84360, "avg_eval_calls": 7030.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84360, "pattern_eval_ns": 1645141, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.50143432906591, "pattern_frame_queries": 84360, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1645141, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.50143432906591, "pattern_frame_updates": 267000, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2688121177, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10067.869576779027, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44716, "avg_candidate_generations": 3726.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 3569592, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.82807048931032, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 862, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 44704, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3568730, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1260992, "avg_legality_checks": 105082.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2858, "root_legality_checks": 862, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1260130, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3956909, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 329742.4166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6769389948, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1710.7772627573695, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43936, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3661.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 245112017, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5578.842338856519, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3227, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 28322474, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18782, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 146508036, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21922, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 70276237, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5270, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98032, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8169.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 768022496, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7834.406071486861, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 136792, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11399.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 364468405, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2664.3985393882685, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2417821760, "stage_ordering_ns": 1134408170, "stage_eval_ns": 2689766318, "stage_threat_ns": 5165653532, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 652738, "root_tactical_annotations": 2339, "search_tactical_annotations": 650399, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 267012, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1250423327, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 542444, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3705476482, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 89502, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2538909545, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 133500, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 160061894, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 267000, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27953589, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 111734, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 61197156, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 341198, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1104958091, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 199806, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21738240, "child_limit_applications": 44704, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44704, "child_cap_hits": 44704, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44704, "child_moves_before_total": 3565873, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3565873, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 446487, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 446487, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.76630726556908, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.98762974230494, "tt_hits": 24426, "tt_cutoffs": 4436, "beta_cutoffs": 34890, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 5.833333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 5.833333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4008.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4675.416666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1534, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5497, "avg_search_time_ms": 458.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 208196, "safety_nodes": 1123, "corridor_nodes": 2503, "corridor_branch_probes": 2955, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 7, "corridor_depth_exits": 1123, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 2480, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2480, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 65, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1123, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 65, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 62, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 439, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 225200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 22480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 211822, "avg_nodes": 17651.833333333332, "eval_calls": 202876, "avg_eval_calls": 16906.333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 202876, "pattern_eval_ns": 4011325, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.772299335554724, "pattern_frame_queries": 202876, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4011325, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.772299335554724, "pattern_frame_updates": 416324, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2824366297, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6784.0583223643125, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5298, "avg_candidate_generations": 441.5, "candidate_moves_total": 411503, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.67138542846357, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 883, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 5286, "search_candidate_moves_total": 410620, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 13494, "avg_legality_checks": 1124.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 13494, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 820921, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 68410.08333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1643441701, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2001.9486661932146, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8781, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 731.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 59257224, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6748.345746498121, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4800, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8676, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 58472112, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 80, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 745322, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 34990, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 29416875, "stage_ordering_ns": 161381, "stage_eval_ns": 2828377622, "stage_threat_ns": 2540629631, "stage_proof_ns": 71724228, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 421426, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2050239484, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 138791, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 163475332, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1368, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 60695742, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 210707, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 250932434, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5090, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 29857600, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 421414, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46124781, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 226, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4842, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5697.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6363.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1456, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30426, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 142, 97, 98, 126, 70, 111, 157, 172, 141, 81, 66, 113, 65, 129, 145, 144, 84, 56, 159, 158, 130, 143, 64, 128, 67, 173 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8733, "avg_search_time_ms": 671.7692307692307, "search_nodes": 224036, "safety_nodes": 1090, "corridor_nodes": 1964, "corridor_branch_probes": 2392, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 746, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_plies_followed": 1943, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1943, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 89, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 68, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 746, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 89, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 89, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 606, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 206400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 227090, "avg_nodes": 17468.46153846154, "eval_calls": 218879, "avg_eval_calls": 16836.846153846152, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 218879, "pattern_eval_ns": 4390362, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.058397562123364, "pattern_frame_queries": 218879, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4390362, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.058397562123364, "pattern_frame_updates": 447996, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4930809392, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11006.369235439603, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5132, "avg_candidate_generations": 394.7692307692308, "candidate_moves_total": 378292, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.71239282930631, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 956, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 5119, "search_candidate_moves_total": 377336, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 203339, "avg_legality_checks": 15641.461538461539, "illegal_moves_skipped": 92, "root_legality_checks": 956, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 202383, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 89, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1888190, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 145245.38461538462, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3853007281, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2040.5823995466558, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24688, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1899.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 128039310, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5186.297391445237, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 142, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 530023, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20743, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 121822244, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 892, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1282734, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2911, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4404309, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4707, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 362.0769230769231, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 32860045, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6981.101550881665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6655, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 511.9230769230769, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 17671975, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2655.443275732532, "stage_move_gen_ns": 477285420, "stage_ordering_ns": 163611, "stage_eval_ns": 4935199754, "stage_threat_ns": 2999147418, "stage_proof_ns": 296680537, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 452073, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2373922615, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 119484, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 267175960, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1165, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 53337656, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 226030, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 286442850, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4064, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20105932, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 452060, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51500061, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 258, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4573, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4751.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5366.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 318, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 21679, "avg_search_time_ms": 1667.6153846153845, "search_nodes": 170201, "safety_nodes": 524, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 170725, "avg_nodes": 13132.692307692309, "eval_calls": 105371, "avg_eval_calls": 8105.461538461538, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105371, "pattern_eval_ns": 2169417, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.5883687162502, "pattern_frame_queries": 105371, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2169417, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.5883687162502, "pattern_frame_updates": 340256, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3124209285, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9181.937379502493, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 58664, "avg_candidate_generations": 4512.615384615385, "candidate_moves_total": 5369832, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.53538797218056, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 992, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 58651, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5368840, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 3606399, "avg_legality_checks": 277415.3076923077, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10561, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3606399, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10561, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8092035, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 622464.2307692308, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14254920436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1761.59895947064, "renju_forbidden_checks": 127309, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9793.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 295296579, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2319.5263414212664, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 13733, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 85364446, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18781, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 89138497, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 94768, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 120612486, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 181150, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 312281, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 24021.615384615383, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2708775021, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8674.158917769573, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 452175, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 34782.692307692305, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1400430987, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3097.0995455299385, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7458841330, "stage_ordering_ns": 1826958683, "stage_eval_ns": 3126378702, "stage_threat_ns": 9132597487, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1145248, "root_tactical_annotations": 4104, "search_tactical_annotations": 1141144, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 340269, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1797579351, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 977221, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7033532897, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 117400, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3636805221, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 170128, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 228218323, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 340256, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38688082, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 307206, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1375411740, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 552605, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2021213856, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 285437, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 34578834, "child_limit_applications": 58651, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 58651, "child_cap_hits": 58651, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 58651, "child_moves_before_total": 5358279, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5358279, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 657966, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 657966, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.35869806141413, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.218325348246406, "tt_hits": 31010, "tt_cutoffs": 6108, "beta_cutoffs": 46739, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 5.384615384615385, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 5.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1800.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2139.4615384615386, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1457, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23018, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 127, 142, 126, 156, 114, 82, 98, 140, 113, 170, 184, 155, 125, 185, 200, 115, 96, 99, 129, 81, 168, 152, 111, 83, 95, 94, 79, 143, 63 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 19637, "avg_search_time_ms": 1309.1333333333334, "search_nodes": 192403, "safety_nodes": 757, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 193160, "avg_nodes": 12877.333333333334, "eval_calls": 132794, "avg_eval_calls": 8852.933333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 132794, "pattern_eval_ns": 2748134, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.694715122671205, "pattern_frame_queries": 132794, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2748134, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.694715122671205, "pattern_frame_updates": 384652, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5301405787, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13782.342967149527, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 55181, "avg_candidate_generations": 3678.733333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4560974, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.65479059821315, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1079, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 55166, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4559895, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1623301, "avg_legality_checks": 108220.06666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6216, "root_legality_checks": 1079, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 1622222, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6210, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5581288, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 372085.86666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11748927461, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2105.0566573522096, "renju_forbidden_checks": 69423, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4628.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 435600295, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6274.5818388718435, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6856, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 67412398, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33622, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 264736300, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28913, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 103104366, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 347231, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 175347, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11689.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1490747031, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8501.696812605862, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 235319, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15687.933333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 628851918, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2672.3380517510273, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3815742432, "stage_ordering_ns": 1781173401, "stage_eval_ns": 5304153921, "stage_threat_ns": 8669149356, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1044802, "root_tactical_annotations": 3337, "search_tactical_annotations": 1041465, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 384667, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2201365338, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 831577, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6091172182, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 110438, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3917875613, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 192326, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 285411827, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 384652, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47955279, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 248582, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 369323889, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 472546, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1803602888, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 323674, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 43244730, "child_limit_applications": 55166, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 55166, "child_cap_hits": 55166, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 55166, "child_moves_before_total": 4553685, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4553685, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 693895, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 693895, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.5451364971178, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.578309103433273, "tt_hits": 29965, "tt_cutoffs": 4366, "beta_cutoffs": 42692, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 5.133333333333334, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 5.133333333333334, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3842.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4375.733333333334, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 380, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3366, "avg_search_time_ms": 240.42857142857142, "search_nodes": 86437, "safety_nodes": 1587, "corridor_nodes": 1883, "corridor_branch_probes": 2238, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 33, "corridor_depth_exits": 854, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 65, "corridor_plies_followed": 1867, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1867, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 52, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 39, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 854, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 65, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 68, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 359, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 244160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 89907, "avg_nodes": 6421.928571428572, "eval_calls": 83709, "avg_eval_calls": 5979.214285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83709, "pattern_eval_ns": 1702356, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.336594631401642, "pattern_frame_queries": 83709, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1702356, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.336594631401642, "pattern_frame_updates": 172792, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1930359033, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11171.5764213621, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2701, "avg_candidate_generations": 192.92857142857142, "candidate_moves_total": 202444, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.95149944465012, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1003, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 2687, "search_candidate_moves_total": 201441, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 4861, "avg_legality_checks": 347.2142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4861, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 22, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 574615, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 41043.92857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1322198274, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2301.0159393680988, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11673, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 833.7857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 111407698, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9544.050201319284, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 232222, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11452, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 109647891, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 112, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 529173, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 87, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 998412, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13375614, "stage_ordering_ns": 92161, "stage_eval_ns": 1932061389, "stage_threat_ns": 1306714554, "stage_proof_ns": 100980953, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 176676, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1032672497, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 95194, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 105240968, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 963, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 36080047, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 88331, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121958273, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3870, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25197477, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 176662, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21645339, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 144, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2439, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6318.214285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6889.642857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1966, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1458, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28302, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 126, 98, 154, 113, 52, 67, 83, 141, 155, 143, 158, 140, 142, 111, 174, 190, 156, 157, 95, 129, 171, 173, 125, 159, 175, 131, 130, 145, 187, 117 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 4244, "avg_search_time_ms": 265.25, "search_nodes": 115177, "safety_nodes": 1718, "corridor_nodes": 1130, "corridor_branch_probes": 1313, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 396, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1105, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1100, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 396, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 91, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 528, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 204560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 118025, "avg_nodes": 7376.5625, "eval_calls": 111810, "avg_eval_calls": 6988.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 111810, "pattern_eval_ns": 2230493, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.948958053841338, "pattern_frame_queries": 111810, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2230493, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.948958053841338, "pattern_frame_updates": 230260, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2315303225, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10055.169048032658, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3336, "avg_candidate_generations": 208.5, "candidate_moves_total": 262796, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.7757793764988, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1185, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3320, "search_candidate_moves_total": 261611, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 108018, "avg_legality_checks": 6751.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 1185, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 106833, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1078340, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 67396.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1955286238, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1813.2372331546637, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12023, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 751.4375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 82849619, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6890.927305996839, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6530, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11931, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 82739529, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32000, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 68, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 71560, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1985, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 124.0625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 15457927, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7787.368765743073, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2707, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 169.1875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 8136416, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3005.694865164389, "stage_move_gen_ns": 212295632, "stage_ordering_ns": 114030, "stage_eval_ns": 2317533718, "stage_threat_ns": 1431215774, "stage_proof_ns": 251583182, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 232670, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1085912045, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 73990, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 172479909, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 878, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 38863762, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 116327, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 135873078, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2394, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12951759, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 232654, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23998983, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 188, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3004, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6581.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7081.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1781, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 24041, "avg_search_time_ms": 1502.5625, "search_nodes": 201398, "safety_nodes": 426, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 201824, "avg_nodes": 12614.0, "eval_calls": 126130, "avg_eval_calls": 7883.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 126130, "pattern_eval_ns": 2654217, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.04350273527313, "pattern_frame_queries": 126130, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2654217, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.04350273527313, "pattern_frame_updates": 402608, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3223358135, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8006.194946449152, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 70320, "avg_candidate_generations": 4395.0, "candidate_moves_total": 6294050, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.50583048919226, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1222, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 70304, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6292828, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 4657989, "avg_legality_checks": 291124.3125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 348, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4657989, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 348, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9199111, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 574944.4375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16104329565, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1750.6397699734246, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26566, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1660.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 49473827, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1862.2986900549574, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 398, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3385302, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4049, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26046122, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22119, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20042403, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 288180, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18011.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2450549582, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8503.538004025262, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 409396, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25587.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1230916264, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3006.6641198253037, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9105527587, "stage_ordering_ns": 2049125550, "stage_eval_ns": 3226012352, "stage_threat_ns": 9479875432, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1292427, "root_tactical_annotations": 4857, "search_tactical_annotations": 1287570, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 402624, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2027300990, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 987780, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7085486373, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 140733, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3965672651, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 201304, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 264901822, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 402608, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44371243, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 347729, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1351725393, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 499306, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1768030019, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 445392, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 57815004, "child_limit_applications": 70304, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 70304, "child_cap_hits": 70304, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 70304, "child_moves_before_total": 6292480, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6292480, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 735519, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 735519, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.50386891215294, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.461979403732363, "tt_hits": 42949, "tt_cutoffs": 4871, "beta_cutoffs": 57455, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 5.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 5.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3563.8125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4063.8125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1564, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1459, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20079, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 141, 128, 144, 143, 158, 98, 83, 97, 99, 81, 129, 95, 94, 65, 49, 80, 64, 110, 50, 125 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 18023, "avg_search_time_ms": 1501.9166666666667, "search_nodes": 172676, "safety_nodes": 222, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 172898, "avg_nodes": 14408.166666666666, "eval_calls": 109322, "avg_eval_calls": 9110.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 109322, "pattern_eval_ns": 2409133, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.03703737582554, "pattern_frame_queries": 109322, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2409133, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.03703737582554, "pattern_frame_updates": 345224, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4523128952, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13102.011887933631, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 59449, "avg_candidate_generations": 4954.083333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4373598, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.56890780332722, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 59437, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4372864, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 1159343, "avg_legality_checks": 96611.91666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1248, "root_legality_checks": 734, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1158609, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1248, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4668091, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 389007.5833333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10644503994, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2280.2691708452126, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34117, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2843.0833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 148234763, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4344.894422135592, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1426, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11557672, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16173, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 96454197, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16518, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40222894, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 115016, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9584.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1020250371, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8870.508198859288, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 151516, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12626.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 411583526, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2716.4360595580665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2960114022, "stage_ordering_ns": 1894981694, "stage_eval_ns": 4525538085, "stage_threat_ns": 8595676189, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 976138, "root_tactical_annotations": 3546, "search_tactical_annotations": 972592, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 345236, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2126476758, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 726678, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6101822618, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 118961, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4484810173, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 172612, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 265336274, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 345224, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51356340, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 205327, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 256975207, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 402379, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1359897428, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 368432, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 50684199, "child_limit_applications": 59437, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 59437, "child_cap_hits": 59437, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 59437, "child_moves_before_total": 4371616, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4371616, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 679127, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 679127, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.5504147248347, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.425997274425022, "tt_hits": 35626, "tt_cutoffs": 3854, "beta_cutoffs": 48029, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.083333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.083333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 872.1666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1376.6666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2043, "avg_search_time_ms": 185.72727272727272, "search_nodes": 55652, "safety_nodes": 888, "corridor_nodes": 1145, "corridor_branch_probes": 1420, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 505, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1136, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1136, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 29, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 505, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 183, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 46160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 57685, "avg_nodes": 5244.090909090909, "eval_calls": 53624, "avg_eval_calls": 4874.909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53624, "pattern_eval_ns": 1158556, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.6051767865135, "pattern_frame_queries": 53624, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1158556, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.6051767865135, "pattern_frame_updates": 111240, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1068913412, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9609.07418194894, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2007, "avg_candidate_generations": 182.45454545454547, "candidate_moves_total": 131150, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.3462879920279, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 670, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 1996, "search_candidate_moves_total": 130480, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 4313, "avg_legality_checks": 392.09090909090907, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4313, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 297648, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27058.909090909092, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 711260725, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2389.6035753641886, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1294, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 117.63636363636364, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10266972, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7934.29057187017, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1274, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10096862, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 170110, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12346454, "stage_ordering_ns": 66710, "stage_eval_ns": 1070071968, "stage_threat_ns": 888548065, "stage_proof_ns": 57544752, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 113599, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 707091869, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64178, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 70514132, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 574, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17433228, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56794, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81934414, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2348, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14168639, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 113588, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14839011, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1823, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5896.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6623.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1935, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1460, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29547, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 128, 64, 127, 115, 116, 129, 125, 124, 97, 139, 83, 69, 84, 80, 48, 85, 100, 68, 99, 154, 98, 109, 101 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7749, "avg_search_time_ms": 596.0769230769231, "search_nodes": 175435, "safety_nodes": 1090, "corridor_nodes": 1553, "corridor_branch_probes": 1920, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 583, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_plies_followed": 1533, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1533, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 89, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 583, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 89, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 89, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 606, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 218720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 178078, "avg_nodes": 13698.307692307691, "eval_calls": 170389, "avg_eval_calls": 13106.846153846154, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 170389, "pattern_eval_ns": 3662749, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.49639354653176, "pattern_frame_queries": 170389, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3662749, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.49639354653176, "pattern_frame_updates": 350794, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4244629132, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12100.061950888556, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5021, "avg_candidate_generations": 386.2307692307692, "candidate_moves_total": 367384, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.16948814977096, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 956, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 5008, "search_candidate_moves_total": 366428, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 157761, "avg_legality_checks": 12135.461538461539, "illegal_moves_skipped": 151, "root_legality_checks": 956, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 156805, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 148, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1463700, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 112592.30769230769, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3501114475, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2391.961792033887, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20841, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1603.1538461538462, "renju_forbidden_ns": 129669368, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6221.840026870112, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 229, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1661413, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18940, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 123301757, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 611, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1344607, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1061, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3361591, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3453, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 265.61538461538464, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 35669198, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10329.915435852881, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4858, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 373.6923076923077, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 19367827, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3986.790242898312, "stage_move_gen_ns": 407085849, "stage_ordering_ns": 185600, "stage_eval_ns": 4248291881, "stage_threat_ns": 2730369859, "stage_proof_ns": 339033524, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 354051, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2108715941, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 95602, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 303392537, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1008, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 60775357, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 177019, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 251403897, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3244, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22024494, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 354038, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44832990, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 258, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4513, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5223.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5839.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1448, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 21784, "avg_search_time_ms": 1675.6923076923076, "search_nodes": 143099, "safety_nodes": 524, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 143623, "avg_nodes": 11047.923076923076, "eval_calls": 90007, "avg_eval_calls": 6923.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 90007, "pattern_eval_ns": 2001758, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.240025775772995, "pattern_frame_queries": 90007, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2001758, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.240025775772995, "pattern_frame_updates": 286048, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3124314923, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10922.344931619868, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49037, "avg_candidate_generations": 3772.076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 4352868, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.76701266390684, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 992, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 49024, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4351876, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 3054019, "avg_legality_checks": 234924.53846153847, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4035, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3054019, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4035, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6859374, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 527644.1538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14505885743, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2114.7535829071285, "renju_forbidden_checks": 109845, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8449.615384615385, "renju_forbidden_ns": 277799242, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2529.011261322773, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6304, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 49827399, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12837, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73441061, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 90677, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 154291152, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 239630, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 269427, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 20725.153846153848, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2894346538, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10742.600177413547, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 394812, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 30370.153846153848, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1498052567, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3794.3440599576506, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7521925902, "stage_ordering_ns": 1783201965, "stage_eval_ns": 3126316681, "stage_threat_ns": 9227573766, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 927388, "root_tactical_annotations": 3931, "search_tactical_annotations": 923457, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 286061, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1807235183, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 782687, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7130460138, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 98148, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3585318514, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 143024, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 220340813, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 286048, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37775499, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 271222, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1494627503, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 413307, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2050411341, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 242859, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 31762133, "child_limit_applications": 49024, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49024, "child_cap_hits": 49024, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49024, "child_moves_before_total": 4347841, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4347841, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 551153, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 551153, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.6880099543081, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.24251387075718, "tt_hits": 26292, "tt_cutoffs": 3995, "beta_cutoffs": 38807, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 5.538461538461538, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 5.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1660.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1991.3076923076924, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1461, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 35182, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 113, 114, 128, 130, 82, 110, 96, 144, 97, 146, 162, 145, 143, 147, 148, 67, 126, 81, 83, 125, 176, 190, 141, 156, 69, 55, 64, 80, 95, 159, 127, 79, 99, 155, 85 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 28641, "avg_search_time_ms": 1591.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 282266, "safety_nodes": 1059, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 283325, "avg_nodes": 15740.277777777777, "eval_calls": 190126, "avg_eval_calls": 10562.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 190126, "pattern_eval_ns": 4081380, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.466711549183174, "pattern_frame_queries": 190126, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4081380, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.466711549183174, "pattern_frame_updates": 564336, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7645966153, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13548.606066244223, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 86059, "avg_candidate_generations": 4781.055555555556, "candidate_moves_total": 7632186, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.68550645487399, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1432, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 86041, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7630754, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 2290645, "avg_legality_checks": 127258.05555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10194, "root_legality_checks": 1432, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 2289213, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10185, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8101364, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 450075.77777777775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16430937617, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2028.1692832219364, "renju_forbidden_checks": 141225, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7845.833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 778439402, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5512.050996636573, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11821, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 110860353, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 63979, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 485730272, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 65377, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 181318495, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 530282, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 252794, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14044.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2019043473, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7986.912161681053, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 333028, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18501.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 837864348, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2515.8976062072857, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5187458703, "stage_ordering_ns": 2880035653, "stage_eval_ns": 7650047533, "stage_threat_ns": 12807732217, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1976230, "root_tactical_annotations": 4684, "search_tactical_annotations": 1971546, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 564354, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3151025559, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1636178, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9111097642, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 172215, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5681402227, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 282168, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 405654549, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 564336, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69528987, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 472400, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 485723119, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 991549, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2943642515, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 512281, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 70425480, "child_limit_applications": 86041, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 86041, "child_cap_hits": 86041, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 86041, "child_moves_before_total": 7620569, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7620569, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 1239833, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1239833, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.56904266570588, "avg_child_moves_after": 14.409793005660092, "tt_hits": 41387, "tt_cutoffs": 6004, "beta_cutoffs": 70060, "depth_sum": 95, "avg_depth": 5.277777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 95, "avg_effective_depth": 5.277777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2548.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2961.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 6526, "avg_search_time_ms": 383.88235294117646, "search_nodes": 177127, "safety_nodes": 1953, "corridor_nodes": 2568, "corridor_branch_probes": 3157, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 23, "corridor_depth_exits": 1230, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 45, "corridor_plies_followed": 2554, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2554, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 29, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1230, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 45, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 67, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 353, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 206880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 181648, "avg_nodes": 10685.176470588236, "eval_calls": 172839, "avg_eval_calls": 10167.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 172839, "pattern_eval_ns": 3704742, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.434641487164356, "pattern_frame_queries": 172839, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3704742, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.434641487164356, "pattern_frame_updates": 354154, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3732773825, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10539.973641410234, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4255, "avg_candidate_generations": 250.2941176470588, "candidate_moves_total": 337525, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.32432432432432, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1349, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 4238, "search_candidate_moves_total": 336176, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 7705, "avg_legality_checks": 453.2352941176471, "illegal_moves_skipped": 23, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7705, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 23, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 973566, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 57268.58823529412, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2349152733, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2412.9362909140214, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18951, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1114.764705882353, "renju_forbidden_ns": 196418524, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10364.546672998786, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 241330, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18709, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 194458986, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 111, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 474081, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 108, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1244127, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22090432, "stage_ordering_ns": 140150, "stage_eval_ns": 3736478567, "stage_threat_ns": 2645095521, "stage_proof_ns": 106540078, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 359415, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2164806916, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 126006, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 146181987, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1350, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 53303456, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 179699, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 248683360, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5244, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 38746371, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 359398, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46676887, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 148, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3837, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6160.588235294118, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6631.176470588235, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1462, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17715, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 144, 80, 141, 143, 127, 96, 64, 99, 138, 66, 155, 169, 139, 140, 81, 108, 109, 94, 122, 52 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5994, "avg_search_time_ms": 499.5, "search_nodes": 128322, "safety_nodes": 638, "corridor_nodes": 1184, "corridor_branch_probes": 1347, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 507, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_plies_followed": 1167, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1167, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 70, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 507, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 70, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 472, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 121760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 130144, "avg_nodes": 10845.333333333334, "eval_calls": 124114, "avg_eval_calls": 10342.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 124114, "pattern_eval_ns": 2659597, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.42866235879917, "pattern_frame_queries": 124114, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2659597, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.42866235879917, "pattern_frame_updates": 256576, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3391352422, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13217.730504801697, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4186, "avg_candidate_generations": 348.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 320214, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.49641662685141, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 860, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 4174, "search_candidate_moves_total": 319354, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 116447, "avg_legality_checks": 9703.916666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 66, "root_legality_checks": 860, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 115587, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 66, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159973, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 96664.41666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2800830682, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2414.565409712123, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18247, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1520.5833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 155697286, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8532.7607825944, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 668263, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17422, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 147861388, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 216, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2754136, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 534, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4413499, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3338, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 278.1666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 36382937, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10899.621629718395, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4727, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 393.9166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 20093403, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4250.772794584303, "stage_move_gen_ns": 299644974, "stage_ordering_ns": 152971, "stage_eval_ns": 3394012019, "stage_threat_ns": 2013848446, "stage_proof_ns": 263077936, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 259062, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1556640185, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 69621, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 225192691, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 785, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 46945618, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129525, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 183642373, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2474, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15326620, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 259050, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33046577, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 423, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3594, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5582.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6249.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1779, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11709, "avg_search_time_ms": 1064.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 78014, "safety_nodes": 846, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 78860, "avg_nodes": 7169.090909090909, "eval_calls": 46243, "avg_eval_calls": 4203.909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46243, "pattern_eval_ns": 1035353, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.38939947667755, "pattern_frame_queries": 46243, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1035353, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.38939947667755, "pattern_frame_updates": 155904, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1929360904, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12375.313680213465, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29488, "avg_candidate_generations": 2680.7272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 2289902, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.65538524145416, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 29477, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2289116, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1503651, "avg_legality_checks": 136695.54545454544, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6202, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1503651, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6202, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3461563, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 314687.54545454547, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7671179472, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2216.1028044267864, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36048, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3277.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 261695144, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7259.63004882379, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6400, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 68562261, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13189, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 136375045, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16454, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 56696208, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61630, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 111258, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10114.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1127192176, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10131.335957863705, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 155238, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14112.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 538037444, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3465.8875017714736, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3833205330, "stage_ordering_ns": 998992781, "stage_eval_ns": 1930396257, "stage_threat_ns": 4882529674, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 433251, "root_tactical_annotations": 1732, "search_tactical_annotations": 431519, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 155915, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 993634334, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 358528, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3728649791, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59038, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2255337208, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77952, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 122072989, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 155904, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21031278, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 75566, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 347464416, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 223916, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1125715847, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 133769, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17141282, "child_limit_applications": 29477, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29477, "child_cap_hits": 29477, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29477, "child_moves_before_total": 2282914, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2282914, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 277086, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 277086, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.44729789327272, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.400074634460767, "tt_hits": 15177, "tt_cutoffs": 2233, "beta_cutoffs": 23700, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2895.5454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3622.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1207, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1463, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26595, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 98, 156, 82, 67, 114, 66, 96, 99, 68, 110, 126, 140, 84, 70, 83, 170, 184, 125, 155, 95, 80, 81, 53, 38, 52, 109, 123, 36, 54, 40, 51, 55, 50 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 23368, "avg_search_time_ms": 1298.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 224863, "safety_nodes": 811, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 225674, "avg_nodes": 12537.444444444445, "eval_calls": 143508, "avg_eval_calls": 7972.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 143508, "pattern_eval_ns": 3140448, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.883435069821893, "pattern_frame_queries": 143508, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3140448, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.883435069821893, "pattern_frame_updates": 449518, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5885911310, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13093.827855614236, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 75394, "avg_candidate_generations": 4188.555555555556, "candidate_moves_total": 6583582, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.32235986948564, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1337, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 75376, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6582245, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1653988, "avg_legality_checks": 91888.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1796, "root_legality_checks": 1337, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1652651, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1796, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6251034, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 347279.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13562268072, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2169.603952242141, "renju_forbidden_checks": 53411, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2967.277777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 294790249, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5519.279717661156, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3128, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26771610, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24138, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 180328922, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26131, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 87563725, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 125992, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 176244, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9791.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1479632338, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8395.362894623364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 230272, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12792.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 584282660, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2537.3586888549194, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3996867409, "stage_ordering_ns": 2608192067, "stage_eval_ns": 5889051758, "stage_threat_ns": 10796921834, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1648605, "root_tactical_annotations": 4207, "search_tactical_annotations": 1644398, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 449536, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2699479177, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1229543, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7619106240, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 150891, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5257127992, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 224759, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 344677547, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 449518, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58429762, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 482398, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 473541051, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 596241, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1887956945, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 569966, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 75229108, "child_limit_applications": 75376, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 75376, "child_cap_hits": 75376, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 75376, "child_moves_before_total": 6580449, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6580449, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 919975, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 919975, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.30164773933348, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.205144873699851, "tt_hits": 46925, "tt_cutoffs": 5875, "beta_cutoffs": 62256, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4215.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4659.611111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 840, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 3212, "avg_search_time_ms": 188.94117647058823, "search_nodes": 85002, "safety_nodes": 1927, "corridor_nodes": 1079, "corridor_branch_probes": 1316, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 10, "corridor_depth_exits": 402, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 1058, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1053, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 35, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 402, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 218, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 207840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 88008, "avg_nodes": 5176.941176470588, "eval_calls": 82184, "avg_eval_calls": 4834.35294117647, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82184, "pattern_eval_ns": 1765850, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.48654239267984, "pattern_frame_queries": 82184, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1765850, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.48654239267984, "pattern_frame_updates": 169904, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1813767379, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10675.248251954044, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2785, "avg_candidate_generations": 163.8235294117647, "candidate_moves_total": 222994, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.06965888689408, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1261, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 2768, "search_candidate_moves_total": 221733, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 5365, "avg_legality_checks": 315.5882352941176, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5365, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 566590, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 33328.82352941176, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1294757472, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2285.175297834413, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4597, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 270.4117647058824, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32561912, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7083.296062649554, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 47740, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4557, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32256981, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37740, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 219451, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.4705882352941178, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 285661, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6801.452380952381, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.0588235294117645, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 90931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1748.673076923077, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14784255, "stage_ordering_ns": 90550, "stage_eval_ns": 1815533229, "stage_threat_ns": 1268617146, "stage_proof_ns": 84814177, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 172145, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1034020278, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 65108, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 76458872, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 691, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 27284591, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86064, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 120914747, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2224, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15433343, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 172128, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21789906, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2591, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6719.941176470588, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7190.529411764706, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1464, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18548, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 82, 98, 143, 126, 140, 96, 95, 111, 141, 81, 66, 70, 84, 100, 99, 139, 125, 110, 173, 158, 157, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10016, "avg_search_time_ms": 834.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 170780, "safety_nodes": 814, "corridor_nodes": 8847, "corridor_branch_probes": 9871, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4145, "corridor_neutral_exits": 46, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 8802, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8797, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 114, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 46, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4145, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 114, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 113, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 818, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 373680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 24160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 180441, "avg_nodes": 15036.75, "eval_calls": 165242, "avg_eval_calls": 13770.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 165242, "pattern_eval_ns": 3555370, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.516139964415828, "pattern_frame_queries": 165242, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3555370, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.516139964415828, "pattern_frame_updates": 341490, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4230678437, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12388.879431315705, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5515, "avg_candidate_generations": 459.5833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 356631, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.66563916591114, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 724, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 5503, "search_candidate_moves_total": 355907, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 159578, "avg_legality_checks": 13298.166666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 724, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 158854, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2301482, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 191790.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5257716026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2284.49148244479, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9948, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 829.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 79308667, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7972.3227784479295, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 209162, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9555, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 74818572, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 166, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2052583, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 203, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2228350, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1367.6666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 167945439, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10233.087923470632, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22557, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1879.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 87278457, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3869.240457507647, "stage_move_gen_ns": 415490238, "stage_ordering_ns": 183740, "stage_eval_ns": 4234233807, "stage_threat_ns": 4248535617, "stage_proof_ns": 1097270708, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 359334, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2270365503, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 483107, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1561032275, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 4668, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 315850623, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 179661, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 262642136, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 17832, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 107334396, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 359322, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47161307, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 261, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4972, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4442.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5108.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1363, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8521, "avg_search_time_ms": 710.0833333333334, "search_nodes": 66958, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67771, "avg_nodes": 5647.583333333333, "eval_calls": 39219, "avg_eval_calls": 3268.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39219, "pattern_eval_ns": 869654, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.174303271373567, "pattern_frame_queries": 39219, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 869654, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.174303271373567, "pattern_frame_updates": 133776, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1460652433, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10918.643351572779, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25299, "avg_candidate_generations": 2108.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1760129, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.573066129096, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 749, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 25287, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1759380, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 963082, "avg_legality_checks": 80256.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 963082, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2478942, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 206578.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5471252006, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2207.0915761643473, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13832, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1152.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21334842, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1542.4264025448235, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 799991, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2183, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10931924, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11539, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9594427, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8500, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75854, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6321.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 682256182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8994.33361457537, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 101024, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8418.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 282613662, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2797.4903191320873, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2377251518, "stage_ordering_ns": 772454543, "stage_eval_ns": 1461522087, "stage_threat_ns": 3858148989, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 368109, "root_tactical_annotations": 901, "search_tactical_annotations": 367208, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 133788, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 848344804, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 322688, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2879680903, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50667, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1894132257, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66888, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 101974293, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 133776, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18168107, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 64118, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 232285254, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 207895, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 753040962, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 96096, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9980882, "child_limit_applications": 25287, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25287, "child_cap_hits": 25287, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25287, "child_moves_before_total": 1759284, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1759284, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 235750, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 235750, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.5726657966544, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.32297227824574, "tt_hits": 11807, "tt_cutoffs": 2383, "beta_cutoffs": 20325, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 5.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 5.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4467.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5134.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1465, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25722, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 123, 81, 97, 83, 139, 153, 124, 85, 71, 82, 84, 80, 79, 94, 122, 121, 107, 66, 52, 91, 137, 151, 92, 152, 77 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 24139, "avg_search_time_ms": 1341.0555555555557, "search_nodes": 250649, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 251446, "avg_nodes": 13969.222222222223, "eval_calls": 165481, "avg_eval_calls": 9193.388888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 165481, "pattern_eval_ns": 3537620, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.37780168115977, "pattern_frame_queries": 165481, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3537620, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.37780168115977, "pattern_frame_updates": 501090, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6331973468, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12636.399584904908, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 78868, "avg_candidate_generations": 4381.555555555556, "candidate_moves_total": 6966658, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.33313891565653, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 78850, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6965356, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1881946, "avg_legality_checks": 104552.55555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2301, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1880644, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2301, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6918697, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 384372.05555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14002639528, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2023.8839087764648, "renju_forbidden_checks": 68462, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3803.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 321545692, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4696.703163798896, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3962, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26210002, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 32047, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 210857898, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32439, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 84363521, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 114271, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 210332, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11685.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1592483338, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7571.284150771162, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 273614, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15200.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 629807455, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2301.810049924346, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4315418595, "stage_ordering_ns": 2563989088, "stage_eval_ns": 6335511088, "stage_threat_ns": 10826176830, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1701924, "root_tactical_annotations": 4128, "search_tactical_annotations": 1697796, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 501108, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2825566669, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1319228, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7497730843, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 157839, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5007338191, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 250545, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 368820750, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 501090, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61595900, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 513099, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 484242820, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 648277, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2005682259, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 540548, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 72462668, "child_limit_applications": 78850, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 78850, "child_cap_hits": 78850, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 78850, "child_moves_before_total": 6963055, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6963055, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 923348, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 923348, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.30760938490805, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.710183893468612, "tt_hits": 47640, "tt_cutoffs": 6214, "beta_cutoffs": 63945, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3888888888888889, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3593.1111111111113, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4037.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 1566, "avg_search_time_ms": 92.11764705882354, "search_nodes": 42485, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 957, "corridor_branch_probes": 1159, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 348, "corridor_neutral_exits": 24, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 937, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 932, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 348, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 218, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 206560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 45333, "avg_nodes": 2666.6470588235293, "eval_calls": 40031, "avg_eval_calls": 2354.764705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40031, "pattern_eval_ns": 855095, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.36082036421773, "pattern_frame_queries": 40031, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 855095, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.36082036421773, "pattern_frame_updates": 84870, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 769077987, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9061.835595616825, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2421, "avg_candidate_generations": 142.41176470588235, "candidate_moves_total": 189525, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.28376703841388, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1235, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2404, "search_candidate_moves_total": 188290, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5477, "avg_legality_checks": 322.1764705882353, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5477, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 269968, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15880.470588235294, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 600272915, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2223.4965440348487, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1399, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 82.29411764705883, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8915155, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6372.519656897784, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 38110, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1359, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8639425, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36640, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 200980, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.4705882352941178, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 146791, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 3495.0238095238096, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.0588235294117645, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 50131, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 964.0576923076923, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14391650, "stage_ordering_ns": 78291, "stage_eval_ns": 769933082, "stage_threat_ns": 671967691, "stage_proof_ns": 83740823, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 86869, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 517311567, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 58162, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 69937836, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 650, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 26220468, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43426, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 60226604, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1982, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13891593, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 86852, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10600091, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2230, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6747.764705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7218.35294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1466, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21493, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 80, 141, 155, 128, 125, 129, 130, 99, 85, 140, 139, 97, 108, 109, 153, 167, 145, 100, 98, 114, 65, 95, 144, 86, 142, 72 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 5145, "avg_search_time_ms": 367.5, "search_nodes": 105245, "safety_nodes": 1510, "corridor_nodes": 3467, "corridor_branch_probes": 4114, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1387, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 3426, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3386, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 40, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 91, "corridor_proof_active": 41, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1387, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 91, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 8, "corridor_proof_unknown": 83, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 543, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 230720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 110222, "avg_nodes": 7873.0, "eval_calls": 101469, "avg_eval_calls": 7247.785714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 101469, "pattern_eval_ns": 1976801, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.4818220343159, "pattern_frame_queries": 101469, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1976801, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.4818220343159, "pattern_frame_updates": 210408, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2505964300, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11910.023858408425, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3749, "avg_candidate_generations": 267.7857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 291372, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.71992531341691, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1033, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 3735, "search_candidate_moves_total": 290339, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 97921, "avg_legality_checks": 6994.357142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 109, "root_legality_checks": 1033, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 96888, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 104, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1376303, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 98307.35714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2750472985, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1998.4501850246638, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14644, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1046.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 99612311, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6802.261062551215, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 123, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1002067, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13255, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 90168141, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 405, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2852671, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 861, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5589432, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9666, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 690.4285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 91101726, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9424.966480446927, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12727, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 909.0714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 48879544, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3840.6178989549776, "stage_move_gen_ns": 206145902, "stage_ordering_ns": 119291, "stage_eval_ns": 2507941101, "stage_threat_ns": 1921447239, "stage_proof_ns": 483261664, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 217456, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1103665660, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 210645, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 608083710, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1853, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 116334372, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 108721, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 133462596, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7034, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 53320387, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 217442, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22914886, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 190, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3390, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6366.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6938.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1911, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 16333, "avg_search_time_ms": 1166.642857142857, "search_nodes": 133774, "safety_nodes": 981, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 134755, "avg_nodes": 9625.357142857143, "eval_calls": 84749, "avg_eval_calls": 6053.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84749, "pattern_eval_ns": 1729717, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.409880942547996, "pattern_frame_queries": 84749, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1729717, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.409880942547996, "pattern_frame_updates": 267376, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2874890538, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10752.238562922626, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44478, "avg_candidate_generations": 3177.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3852610, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.61832816223752, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1078, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 44464, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3851532, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 2335964, "avg_legality_checks": 166854.57142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12890, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2335964, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12890, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5643335, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 403095.35714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10376819710, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1838.774361259787, "renju_forbidden_checks": 102938, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7352.714285714285, "renju_forbidden_ns": 332492188, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3230.0237813052518, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17429, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 119758328, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22923, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 108518529, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 62430, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 103636818, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 156, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 578513, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 207687, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14834.785714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1843761957, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8877.599257536582, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 279120, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19937.14285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 909086210, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3256.972664087131, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5019219778, "stage_ordering_ns": 1370639134, "stage_eval_ns": 2876620255, "stage_threat_ns": 6982785573, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 993808, "root_tactical_annotations": 2562, "search_tactical_annotations": 991246, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 267390, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1461620899, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 813218, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5263789788, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 89041, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2796887373, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 133688, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 195360437, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 267376, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31495656, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 257963, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 986573705, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 466204, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1480006218, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 269641, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30518793, "child_limit_applications": 44464, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44464, "child_cap_hits": 44464, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44464, "child_moves_before_total": 3838642, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3838642, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 537017, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 537017, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.3314591579705, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.077568369917236, "tt_hits": 23808, "tt_cutoffs": 4475, "beta_cutoffs": 36189, "depth_sum": 84, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 84, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4670.928571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5242.357142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1780, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1467, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23887, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 143, 67, 52, 95, 53, 83, 80, 51, 99, 113, 129, 65, 49, 66, 159, 175, 114, 144, 84, 69, 68, 36, 21, 37, 100, 116, 23, 35, 19, 38, 34, 39 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 20959, "avg_search_time_ms": 1164.388888888889, "search_nodes": 221470, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 222267, "avg_nodes": 12348.166666666666, "eval_calls": 140784, "avg_eval_calls": 7821.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 140784, "pattern_eval_ns": 2908682, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.66060063643596, "pattern_frame_queries": 140784, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2908682, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.66060063643596, "pattern_frame_updates": 442732, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5201979951, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11749.726586286964, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 74871, "avg_candidate_generations": 4159.5, "candidate_moves_total": 6369253, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.06969320564704, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 74853, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6367951, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1570008, "avg_legality_checks": 87222.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1668, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1568706, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5979632, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 332201.77777777775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12053084475, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2015.6900081811054, "renju_forbidden_checks": 50606, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2811.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 261322401, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5163.862012409596, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3007, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23738500, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23666, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 159786479, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23919, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 77680832, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 116590, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 170013, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9445.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1313162695, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7723.895790321916, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 221985, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12332.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 524903582, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2364.5903191657094, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3587901308, "stage_ordering_ns": 2342128217, "stage_eval_ns": 5204888633, "stage_threat_ns": 9742453364, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1601733, "root_tactical_annotations": 4128, "search_tactical_annotations": 1597605, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 442750, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2485937553, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1199673, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6818443024, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 149845, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4702362314, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 221366, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 319179828, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 442732, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53100990, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 464706, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 422110780, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 585109, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1693517439, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 551918, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 65791969, "child_limit_applications": 74853, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 74853, "child_cap_hits": 74853, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 74853, "child_moves_before_total": 6366283, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6366283, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 895971, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 895971, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.0504722589609, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.969740691755842, "tt_hits": 46393, "tt_cutoffs": 5730, "beta_cutoffs": 61829, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5004.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5448.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1239, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 2908, "avg_search_time_ms": 171.05882352941177, "search_nodes": 83589, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 1160, "corridor_branch_probes": 1414, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 462, "corridor_neutral_exits": 24, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 1140, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1135, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 35, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 462, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 218, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 214560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 86640, "avg_nodes": 5096.470588235294, "eval_calls": 80899, "avg_eval_calls": 4758.764705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80899, "pattern_eval_ns": 1635406, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.21540439313218, "pattern_frame_queries": 80899, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1635406, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.21540439313218, "pattern_frame_updates": 167078, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1617453618, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9680.829420989, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2657, "avg_candidate_generations": 156.2941176470588, "candidate_moves_total": 210366, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.1742566804667, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1235, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2640, "search_candidate_moves_total": 209131, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5095, "avg_legality_checks": 299.70588235294116, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5095, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 558911, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32877.117647058825, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1160003901, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2075.471588499779, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4401, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 258.88235294117646, "renju_forbidden_ns": 28432537, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6460.471938195865, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 77841, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4359, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28073184, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 77711, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 203801, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.7058823529411766, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 278070, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6045.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2941176470588234, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 88150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1574.107142857143, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13113368, "stage_ordering_ns": 81920, "stage_eval_ns": 1619089024, "stage_threat_ns": 1168391338, "stage_proof_ns": 79081045, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169483, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 947356286, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 67032, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 76030262, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 697, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 26100548, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84733, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 109545620, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2388, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15552597, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169466, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19906573, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2469, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6740.588235294118, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7211.176470588235, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1468, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16251, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 67, 81, 126, 113, 129, 83, 84, 98, 128, 65, 49, 79, 80, 68, 53, 130, 114, 127, 142, 99, 100, 156, 86 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9000, "avg_search_time_ms": 750.0, "search_nodes": 162713, "safety_nodes": 892, "corridor_nodes": 9609, "corridor_branch_probes": 10757, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4513, "corridor_neutral_exits": 41, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 9560, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9540, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 20, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 118, "corridor_proof_active": 49, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 41, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4513, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 118, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 4, "corridor_proof_unknown": 114, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 832, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 475200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 24880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 173214, "avg_nodes": 14434.5, "eval_calls": 156970, "avg_eval_calls": 13080.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 156970, "pattern_eval_ns": 3214313, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.477244059374403, "pattern_frame_queries": 156970, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3214313, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.477244059374403, "pattern_frame_updates": 325356, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3497143588, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10748.667883794982, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5720, "avg_candidate_generations": 476.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 372730, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.16258741258741, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 5708, "search_candidate_moves_total": 372008, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 151449, "avg_legality_checks": 12620.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 150727, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2267603, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 188966.91666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4760347691, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2099.286202655403, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9257, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 771.4166666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 63864436, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6899.042454358863, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 187920, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8790, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 59229013, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 173, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1989110, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 272, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2458393, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 18105, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1508.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 174595063, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9643.472134769401, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25020, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2085.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 91491518, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3656.7353317346124, "stage_move_gen_ns": 353602860, "stage_ordering_ns": 177111, "stage_eval_ns": 3500357901, "stage_threat_ns": 4000345525, "stage_proof_ns": 1115287930, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 344724, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2034895906, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 522964, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1577327762, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 4971, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 315434077, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 172356, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 235912065, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 19356, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 110996306, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 344712, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41213486, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 265, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5174, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4858.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5524.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1508, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7241, "avg_search_time_ms": 603.4166666666666, "search_nodes": 63730, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 64769, "avg_nodes": 5397.416666666667, "eval_calls": 36634, "avg_eval_calls": 3052.8333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36634, "pattern_eval_ns": 769192, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.996669760331933, "pattern_frame_queries": 36634, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 769192, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.996669760331933, "pattern_frame_updates": 127328, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1293892228, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10161.88291656195, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24424, "avg_candidate_generations": 2035.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1633388, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.87635113003603, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 744, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 24412, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1632644, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 805141, "avg_legality_checks": 67095.08333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 805141, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2202754, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 183562.83333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4593129907, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2085.176060059362, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10955, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 912.9166666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19181301, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1750.9174806024646, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 56, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 463641, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2283, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11473088, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8616, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7244572, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64557, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5379.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 542682853, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8406.258856514398, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84870, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7072.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 220917865, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2603.014787321786, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1874321671, "stage_ordering_ns": 650060435, "stage_eval_ns": 1294661420, "stage_threat_ns": 3378427750, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 320781, "root_tactical_annotations": 456, "search_tactical_annotations": 320325, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 127340, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 766418056, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 284380, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2494930589, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48913, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1690574852, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 63664, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92782272, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 127328, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15950039, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 42333, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 166162594, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 193127, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 637945982, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 85321, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8346794, "child_limit_applications": 24412, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24412, "child_cap_hits": 24412, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24412, "child_moves_before_total": 1632594, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1632594, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 224641, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 224641, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 66.87669998361461, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.202072751106014, "tt_hits": 11723, "tt_cutoffs": 2618, "beta_cutoffs": 19516, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4515.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5181.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1469, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20862, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 110, 109, 82, 124, 126, 81, 94, 142, 128, 144, 80, 64, 95, 146, 162, 143, 145, 141, 140, 125, 93, 92, 108, 157, 173, 122, 78, 62, 123, 63, 138 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 18491, "avg_search_time_ms": 1027.2777777777778, "search_nodes": 218624, "safety_nodes": 811, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 219435, "avg_nodes": 12190.833333333334, "eval_calls": 137901, "avg_eval_calls": 7661.166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 137901, "pattern_eval_ns": 2760863, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.020616239186083, "pattern_frame_queries": 137901, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2760863, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.020616239186083, "pattern_frame_updates": 437040, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4541306978, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10391.05568826652, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 74670, "avg_candidate_generations": 4148.333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 6531303, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.46890317396544, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1337, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 74652, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6529966, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1675131, "avg_legality_checks": 93062.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1599, "root_legality_checks": 1337, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1673794, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1599, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6134172, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 340787.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10593324314, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1726.9363027316483, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48716, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2706.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 239202959, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4910.151880285738, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2969, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24506559, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20997, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 137955056, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24736, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 76602943, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 138401, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 174437, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9690.944444444445, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1162945413, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6666.850570693145, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 226987, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12610.388888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 467428269, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2059.2733019952684, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3220788929, "stage_ordering_ns": 2063961004, "stage_eval_ns": 4544067841, "stage_threat_ns": 8571834928, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1642916, "root_tactical_annotations": 4207, "search_tactical_annotations": 1638709, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 437058, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2136536046, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1223122, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6043896177, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 149443, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4170000046, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 218520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 279265585, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 437040, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46783461, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 479793, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 367798451, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 593873, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1505670048, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 569250, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 65353659, "child_limit_applications": 74652, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 74652, "child_cap_hits": 74652, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 74652, "child_moves_before_total": 6528367, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6528367, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 910748, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 910748, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.45066441622461, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.199914268874243, "tt_hits": 46689, "tt_cutoffs": 5967, "beta_cutoffs": 61702, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5384.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5828.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1144, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 2355, "avg_search_time_ms": 138.52941176470588, "search_nodes": 85132, "safety_nodes": 1927, "corridor_nodes": 1149, "corridor_branch_probes": 1400, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 9, "corridor_depth_exits": 449, "corridor_neutral_exits": 21, "corridor_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_plies_followed": 1128, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1123, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 449, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 218, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 202960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 88208, "avg_nodes": 5188.705882352941, "eval_calls": 82452, "avg_eval_calls": 4850.117647058823, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82452, "pattern_eval_ns": 1591178, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.298234124096442, "pattern_frame_queries": 82452, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1591178, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.298234124096442, "pattern_frame_updates": 170164, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1300829449, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7644.563180226135, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2647, "avg_candidate_generations": 155.7058823529412, "candidate_moves_total": 214210, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.92557612391387, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1261, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 2630, "search_candidate_moves_total": 212949, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 5666, "avg_legality_checks": 333.29411764705884, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5666, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 539568, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 31739.29411764706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 885744193, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1641.580288304718, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4670, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 274.70588235294116, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32771465, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7017.444325481799, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 77160, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4628, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32404683, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 68130, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 221492, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.7058823529411766, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 280352, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6094.608695652174, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2941176470588234, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 81381, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1453.232142857143, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12251766, "stage_ordering_ns": 78191, "stage_eval_ns": 1302420627, "stage_threat_ns": 943131304, "stage_proof_ns": 68400468, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 172545, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 770390249, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 67096, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 50628288, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 693, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17465702, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94610576, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2364, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10540329, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 172528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16961862, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2463, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6754.411764705882, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7225.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1470, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15066, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 110, 96, 99, 128, 144, 126, 141, 127, 129, 80, 64, 66, 81, 125, 124, 159, 143, 114, 115, 142, 157, 101, 171 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7688, "avg_search_time_ms": 640.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 124935, "safety_nodes": 892, "corridor_nodes": 9775, "corridor_branch_probes": 10994, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4597, "corridor_neutral_exits": 41, "corridor_terminal_exits": 30, "corridor_plies_followed": 9725, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9701, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 24, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 118, "corridor_proof_active": 50, "corridor_proof_quiet": 68, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 41, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4597, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 118, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 4, "corridor_proof_unknown": 114, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 832, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 489920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 24880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 135602, "avg_nodes": 11300.166666666666, "eval_calls": 120088, "avg_eval_calls": 10007.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 120088, "pattern_eval_ns": 2459840, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.483645326760374, "pattern_frame_queries": 120088, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2459840, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.483645326760374, "pattern_frame_updates": 249800, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2650660547, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10611.131092874299, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4824, "avg_candidate_generations": 402.0, "candidate_moves_total": 318208, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.96351575456053, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 4812, "search_candidate_moves_total": 317486, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 115942, "avg_legality_checks": 9661.833333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 115220, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2001887, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 166823.91666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4175007346, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2085.535969812482, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8992, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 749.3333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 52505963, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5839.186276690391, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 120780, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8465, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 47164171, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 195, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2345559, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 315, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2875453, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 18621, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1551.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 179527182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9641.113903657162, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25754, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2146.1666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 93903679, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3646.1784188863867, "stage_move_gen_ns": 280129815, "stage_ordering_ns": 151501, "stage_eval_ns": 2653120387, "stage_threat_ns": 3604661699, "stage_proof_ns": 1125433857, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 269498, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1638972041, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 530966, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1629542824, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 5013, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 326824989, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134743, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 190210583, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 19686, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 113315603, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 269486, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32620648, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 265, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4276, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5459.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6125.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1787, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7366, "avg_search_time_ms": 613.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 62630, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 63669, "avg_nodes": 5305.75, "eval_calls": 36444, "avg_eval_calls": 3037.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36444, "pattern_eval_ns": 763373, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.946465810558664, "pattern_frame_queries": 36444, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 763373, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.946465810558664, "pattern_frame_updates": 125128, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1299230277, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10383.209809155425, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23940, "avg_candidate_generations": 1995.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1622365, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.76796157059314, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 744, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 23928, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1621621, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 814368, "avg_legality_checks": 67864.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 68, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 814368, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 68, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2218078, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 184839.83333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4682915632, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2111.249303225585, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11082, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 923.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19058453, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1719.7665583829635, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 649326, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2228, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11068586, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8782, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7340541, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5422.583333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 554819405, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8526.369734597594, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86145, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7178.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 225616249, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2619.0289511869523, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1928757931, "stage_ordering_ns": 676427109, "stage_eval_ns": 1299993650, "stage_threat_ns": 3417464537, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 320734, "root_tactical_annotations": 456, "search_tactical_annotations": 320278, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125140, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 754676775, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 288560, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2545505332, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47945, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1716388365, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 62564, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91349968, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 125128, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15961719, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 41248, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 157682546, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 199360, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 671190130, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 80126, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9970743, "child_limit_applications": 23928, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23928, "child_cap_hits": 23928, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23928, "child_moves_before_total": 1621553, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1621553, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 220156, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 220156, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.76801237044467, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.20076897358743, "tt_hits": 10585, "tt_cutoffs": 2192, "beta_cutoffs": 19142, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4491.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5158.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1471, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24723, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 158, 82, 67, 110, 68, 98, 95, 66, 114, 128, 144, 80, 64, 81, 174, 190, 129, 159, 99, 84, 83, 51, 36, 52, 115, 131, 38, 50, 34, 53, 49, 54 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 21672, "avg_search_time_ms": 1204.0, "search_nodes": 219875, "safety_nodes": 811, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 220686, "avg_nodes": 12260.333333333334, "eval_calls": 139261, "avg_eval_calls": 7736.722222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 139261, "pattern_eval_ns": 2917420, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.94929664443024, "pattern_frame_queries": 139261, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2917420, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.94929664443024, "pattern_frame_updates": 439542, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5353218545, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12179.083102411147, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 74777, "avg_candidate_generations": 4154.277777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 6518121, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.16745790818032, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1337, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 74759, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6516784, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1629932, "avg_legality_checks": 90551.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1716, "root_legality_checks": 1337, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1628595, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6126436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 340357.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12576408059, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2052.809832502943, "renju_forbidden_checks": 49691, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2760.6111111111113, "renju_forbidden_ns": 259243081, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5217.103318508382, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3019, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25680923, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22181, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 152185703, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24477, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 81250275, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 126180, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 172408, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9578.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1371165116, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7953.024894436453, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 224388, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12466.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 541231433, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2412.0337674028915, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3734408284, "stage_ordering_ns": 2449033045, "stage_eval_ns": 5356135965, "stage_threat_ns": 10053913834, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1640645, "root_tactical_annotations": 4207, "search_tactical_annotations": 1636438, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 439560, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2487605789, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1217132, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7121515457, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 149657, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4925440460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 219771, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 316422325, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 439542, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53469263, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 480803, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 430260606, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 586659, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1765345539, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 573183, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 74901000, "child_limit_applications": 74759, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 74759, "child_cap_hits": 74759, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 74759, "child_moves_before_total": 6515068, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6515068, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 913066, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 913066, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.14760764590217, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.213459249053626, "tt_hits": 46813, "tt_cutoffs": 5752, "beta_cutoffs": 61799, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4844.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5289.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1093, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 3032, "avg_search_time_ms": 178.35294117647058, "search_nodes": 84800, "safety_nodes": 1927, "corridor_nodes": 1162, "corridor_branch_probes": 1411, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 462, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 1141, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1136, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 462, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 218, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 202480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 87889, "avg_nodes": 5169.941176470588, "eval_calls": 82097, "avg_eval_calls": 4829.235294117647, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82097, "pattern_eval_ns": 1672609, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.373570288804707, "pattern_frame_queries": 82097, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1672609, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.373570288804707, "pattern_frame_updates": 169500, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1706716190, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10069.122064896756, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2670, "avg_candidate_generations": 157.05882352941177, "candidate_moves_total": 215657, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.77041198501873, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1261, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 2653, "search_candidate_moves_total": 214396, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 5112, "avg_legality_checks": 300.70588235294116, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5112, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 563079, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 33122.294117647056, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1218021286, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2163.144578291856, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4689, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 275.8235294117647, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32315926, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6891.8588185114095, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 69811, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4648, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31946455, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 82850, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 216810, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.7058823529411766, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 284083, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6175.717391304348, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2941176470588234, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 82292, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1469.5, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13310585, "stage_ordering_ns": 80390, "stage_eval_ns": 1708388799, "stage_threat_ns": 1205859804, "stage_proof_ns": 79837784, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 171907, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 980886456, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 67248, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 74847971, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 697, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 25533372, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85945, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 114165947, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2390, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15423197, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 171890, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20536233, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2484, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6739.529411764706, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7210.117647058823, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1472, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16701, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 82, 96, 141, 128, 144, 98, 99, 113, 143, 80, 64, 94, 95, 83, 68, 145, 129, 142, 157, 114, 115, 171, 101 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9349, "avg_search_time_ms": 779.0833333333334, "search_nodes": 164463, "safety_nodes": 892, "corridor_nodes": 9609, "corridor_branch_probes": 10757, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4513, "corridor_neutral_exits": 41, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 9560, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9540, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 20, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 118, "corridor_proof_active": 49, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 41, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4513, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 118, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 4, "corridor_proof_unknown": 114, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 832, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 475200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 24880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 174964, "avg_nodes": 14580.333333333334, "eval_calls": 158720, "avg_eval_calls": 13226.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 158720, "pattern_eval_ns": 3221685, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.29791456653226, "pattern_frame_queries": 158720, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3221685, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.29791456653226, "pattern_frame_updates": 328856, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3716618937, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11301.660717760966, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5720, "avg_candidate_generations": 476.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 374674, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.50244755244755, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 5708, "search_candidate_moves_total": 373952, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 153206, "avg_legality_checks": 12767.166666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 152484, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2293466, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 191122.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4942481436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2155.0271231402603, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9262, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 771.8333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66437173, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7173.091448931116, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 191841, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8795, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 61452168, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 173, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2120530, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 272, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2672634, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 18105, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1508.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 179017449, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9887.735376967688, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25020, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2085.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 94425052, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3773.9828936850517, "stage_move_gen_ns": 374782222, "stage_ordering_ns": 177121, "stage_eval_ns": 3719840622, "stage_threat_ns": 4110066988, "stage_proof_ns": 1121535477, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 348224, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2086830467, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 522964, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1626462833, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 4971, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 326994391, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 174106, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 241972230, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 19356, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 112416099, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 348212, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42385359, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 265, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5175, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4756.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5423.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1430, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7340, "avg_search_time_ms": 611.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 63278, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 64317, "avg_nodes": 5359.75, "eval_calls": 36485, "avg_eval_calls": 3040.4166666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36485, "pattern_eval_ns": 763905, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.937508565163768, "pattern_frame_queries": 36485, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 763905, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.937508565163768, "pattern_frame_updates": 126424, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1306749511, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10336.245578371196, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24266, "avg_candidate_generations": 2022.1666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1643716, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.73741036841672, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 744, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 24254, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1642972, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 816835, "avg_legality_checks": 68069.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 816835, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2230424, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 185868.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4674344927, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2095.7203325466367, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10992, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 916.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19161165, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1743.191866812227, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 56, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 493230, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2261, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11410673, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8675, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7257262, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65012, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5417.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 549065864, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8445.607949301668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 85452, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7121.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 223049519, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2610.2316973271545, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1915089348, "stage_ordering_ns": 672646921, "stage_eval_ns": 1307513416, "stage_threat_ns": 3403052896, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 320316, "root_tactical_annotations": 456, "search_tactical_annotations": 319860, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 126436, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 752975726, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 284657, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2533467750, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48597, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1720128317, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 63212, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91922886, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 126424, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15809658, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 42479, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 167733946, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 193574, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 645361896, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 84263, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8876876, "child_limit_applications": 24254, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24254, "child_cap_hits": 24254, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24254, "child_moves_before_total": 1642922, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1642922, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 223484, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 223484, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.73818751546136, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.214315164508948, "tt_hits": 11444, "tt_cutoffs": 2474, "beta_cutoffs": 19403, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4491.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5158.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1473, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26851, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 83, 155, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 53, 141, 169, 39, 69, 55, 37, 85, 80, 79, 96, 64, 125, 111, 95, 109, 110, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 23457, "avg_search_time_ms": 1563.8, "search_nodes": 249038, "safety_nodes": 778, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 249816, "avg_nodes": 16654.4, "eval_calls": 175765, "avg_eval_calls": 11717.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 175765, "pattern_eval_ns": 3605474, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.5130372941143, "pattern_frame_queries": 175765, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3605474, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.5130372941143, "pattern_frame_updates": 497926, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6826004564, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13708.873535424942, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 69428, "avg_candidate_generations": 4628.533333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 6217808, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.5576424497321, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1165, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 69413, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6216643, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1643523, "avg_legality_checks": 109568.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3170, "root_legality_checks": 1165, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1642358, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3167, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6410012, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 427334.13333333336, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13568606105, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2116.783261092179, "renju_forbidden_checks": 61196, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4079.733333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 320226868, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5232.807176939669, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3814, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 31249000, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34790, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 218367227, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22565, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 70383730, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 226911, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 171978, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11465.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1346056561, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7826.911354940748, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 213256, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14217.066666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 510135633, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2392.127926060697, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3837224477, "stage_ordering_ns": 2380664832, "stage_eval_ns": 6829610038, "stage_threat_ns": 10343970350, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1361828, "root_tactical_annotations": 4093, "search_tactical_annotations": 1357735, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 497941, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2889208484, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1220991, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6992330675, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 138930, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4675976565, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 248963, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 362216700, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 497926, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61873287, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 377385, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 419353803, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 704663, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1896457656, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 279780, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 38341204, "child_limit_applications": 69413, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 69413, "child_cap_hits": 69413, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 69413, "child_moves_before_total": 6213476, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6213476, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 744236, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 744236, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.51458660481465, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.721853255153933, "tt_hits": 31220, "tt_cutoffs": 3787, "beta_cutoffs": 54037, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2909.866666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3350.133333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 722, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3379, "avg_search_time_ms": 241.35714285714286, "search_nodes": 32596, "safety_nodes": 1641, "corridor_nodes": 282, "corridor_branch_probes": 335, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 102, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 272, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 272, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 102, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 41, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 184, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 70480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 5040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34519, "avg_nodes": 2465.6428571428573, "eval_calls": 22196, "avg_eval_calls": 1585.4285714285713, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22196, "pattern_eval_ns": 461161, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.77676157866282, "pattern_frame_queries": 22196, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 461161, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.77676157866282, "pattern_frame_updates": 65062, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 679827812, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10448.922750607113, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9851, "avg_candidate_generations": 703.6428571428571, "candidate_moves_total": 795303, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.73322505329408, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1092, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 9837, "search_candidate_moves_total": 794211, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 314931, "avg_legality_checks": 22495.071428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 372, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 314931, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 372, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 984542, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 70324.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2032386234, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2064.296123476703, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5148, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 367.7142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 25892956, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5029.711732711733, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 422, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3876485, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1976, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14710247, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2719, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7003274, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 31, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 302950, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 31145, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2224.6428571428573, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 272062680, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8735.356558034997, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41038, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2931.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 118635773, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2890.876090452751, "stage_move_gen_ns": 740637500, "stage_ordering_ns": 315253670, "stage_eval_ns": 680288973, "stage_threat_ns": 1544899574, "stage_proof_ns": 68759743, "tactical_annotations": 176073, "root_tactical_annotations": 331, "search_tactical_annotations": 175742, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 65702, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 394981671, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 187960, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1089202963, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20055, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 662494679, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 32844, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 46815823, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 626, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4008861, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 65688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7923721, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44020, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 110014517, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 107228, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 305421341, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 24825, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1966535, "child_limit_applications": 9837, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9837, "child_cap_hits": 9837, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9837, "child_moves_before_total": 793839, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 793839, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 158867, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 158867, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.69929856663617, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.14994408864491, "tt_hits": 2930, "tt_cutoffs": 498, "beta_cutoffs": 8389, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6290.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6861.928571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1844, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1474, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15868, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 83, 128, 67, 127, 99, 115, 82, 52, 81, 84, 95, 53, 125, 143, 158, 111, 80, 79, 110, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9451, "avg_search_time_ms": 859.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 80182, "safety_nodes": 155, "corridor_nodes": 6581, "corridor_branch_probes": 7315, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2942, "corridor_neutral_exits": 46, "corridor_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_plies_followed": 6528, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6528, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 102, "corridor_proof_active": 53, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 46, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2942, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 102, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 99, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 828, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 444800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 86918, "avg_nodes": 7901.636363636364, "eval_calls": 55422, "avg_eval_calls": 5038.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 55422, "pattern_eval_ns": 1142977, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.62316408646386, "pattern_frame_queries": 55422, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1142977, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.62316408646386, "pattern_frame_updates": 160270, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1899705813, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11853.15912522618, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23178, "avg_candidate_generations": 2107.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 1604571, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.22819052549832, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 669, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 23167, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1603902, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 480007, "avg_legality_checks": 43637.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 398, "root_legality_checks": 669, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 479338, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 398, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2816327, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 256029.72727272726, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5888361699, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2090.7947475559477, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20349, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1849.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 107781396, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5296.643373138729, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 454, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3817232, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9069, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 67466301, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9392, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29278465, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1434, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7219398, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 70139, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6376.272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 635197361, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9056.26485977844, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 94924, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8629.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 289801425, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3052.983702751675, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1157697238, "stage_ordering_ns": 635144816, "stage_eval_ns": 1900848790, "stage_threat_ns": 4860710384, "stage_proof_ns": 865198556, "tactical_annotations": 391997, "root_tactical_annotations": 2252, "search_tactical_annotations": 389745, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 173541, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1089625814, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 708045, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3535463021, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49667, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1910233675, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86765, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 128240650, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 13260, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 75592471, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 173530, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21295808, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116256, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 147019695, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 166901, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 581605731, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 108840, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10492620, "child_limit_applications": 23167, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23167, "child_cap_hits": 23167, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23167, "child_moves_before_total": 1603504, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1603504, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 371894, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 371894, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.21500410066042, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.052747442482843, "tt_hits": 10868, "tt_cutoffs": 1546, "beta_cutoffs": 19606, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4198.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4926.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 713, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6406, "avg_search_time_ms": 640.6, "search_nodes": 52332, "safety_nodes": 933, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53265, "avg_nodes": 5326.5, "eval_calls": 30480, "avg_eval_calls": 3048.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 30480, "pattern_eval_ns": 638162, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.93707349081365, "pattern_frame_queries": 30480, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 638162, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.93707349081365, "pattern_frame_updates": 104552, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1076393197, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10295.290353125718, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19449, "avg_candidate_generations": 1944.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1364732, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.16977736644557, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 615, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 19439, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1364117, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 784498, "avg_legality_checks": 78449.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 518, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 784498, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 518, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1984596, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 198459.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4116317558, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2074.1337571979384, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15848, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1584.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44543480, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2810.668854114084, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 532, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4763889, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4126, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26627438, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11190, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13152153, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 66039, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6603.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 580958930, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8797.209679128999, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 88407, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8840.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 253157978, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2863.551279876028, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1841749900, "stage_ordering_ns": 548027103, "stage_eval_ns": 1077031359, "stage_threat_ns": 2900681951, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 316217, "root_tactical_annotations": 429, "search_tactical_annotations": 315788, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 104562, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 615240925, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 276506, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2189288753, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38954, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1337058181, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52276, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 75181293, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 104552, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12910251, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 40338, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 147428526, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 197207, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 704593366, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78672, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8060729, "child_limit_applications": 19439, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19439, "child_cap_hits": 19439, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19439, "child_moves_before_total": 1363599, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1363599, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 205552, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 205552, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.14758989659961, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.574206492103503, "tt_hits": 9769, "tt_cutoffs": 2357, "beta_cutoffs": 16018, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4390.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5190.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1475, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17635, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 110, 109, 142, 94, 96, 141, 124, 138, 98, 140, 81, 66, 82, 68, 84, 70, 83, 80, 85 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 15055, "avg_search_time_ms": 1254.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 148097, "safety_nodes": 283, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148380, "avg_nodes": 12365.0, "eval_calls": 94624, "avg_eval_calls": 7885.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 94624, "pattern_eval_ns": 1959086, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.70390175853906, "pattern_frame_queries": 94624, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1959086, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.70390175853906, "pattern_frame_updates": 296066, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3999175953, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13507.71771496896, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 50320, "avg_candidate_generations": 4193.333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4278930, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.0343799682035, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 761, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 50308, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4278169, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1050127, "avg_legality_checks": 87510.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1120, "root_legality_checks": 761, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1049366, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1119, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4131810, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 344317.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8905861932, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2155.4383991519453, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27918, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2326.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 153556193, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5500.257647395945, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1188, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10814203, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14674, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 105458623, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12051, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37231887, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 51480, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 94126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7843.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 786211603, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8352.756974693495, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 121637, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10136.416666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 315963191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2597.591119478448, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2476604919, "stage_ordering_ns": 1692577984, "stage_eval_ns": 4001135039, "stage_threat_ns": 6835237403, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 835220, "root_tactical_annotations": 3058, "search_tactical_annotations": 832162, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 296078, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1727568563, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 646151, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4819893098, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 100703, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3602469200, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148033, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 213635623, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 296066, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36944441, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 241288, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 216472306, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 304149, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1000644001, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 289783, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 37195678, "child_limit_applications": 50308, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 50308, "child_cap_hits": 50308, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 50308, "child_moves_before_total": 4277050, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4277050, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 471787, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 471787, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.01729347221118, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.377971694362726, "tt_hits": 30961, "tt_cutoffs": 3101, "beta_cutoffs": 40692, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3216.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3882.9166666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1202, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2568, "avg_search_time_ms": 233.45454545454547, "search_nodes": 25438, "safety_nodes": 941, "corridor_nodes": 78, "corridor_branch_probes": 79, "corridor_max_depth": 5, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 23, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 67, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 67, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 26, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 182, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 86240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 26457, "avg_nodes": 2405.181818181818, "eval_calls": 17694, "avg_eval_calls": 1608.5454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 17694, "pattern_eval_ns": 365533, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.658584831016164, "pattern_frame_queries": 17694, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 365533, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.658584831016164, "pattern_frame_updates": 50776, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 536620954, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10568.397550023634, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7285, "avg_candidate_generations": 662.2727272727273, "candidate_moves_total": 537856, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.83061084420041, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 696, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 7274, "search_candidate_moves_total": 537160, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 225786, "avg_legality_checks": 20526.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 90, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 225786, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 90, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 739097, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 67190.63636363637, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1567862580, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2121.32180214505, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3052, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 277.45454545454544, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13983697, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4581.814220183486, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 94, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 866162, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1201, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9235128, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1752, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3830257, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 52150, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 20848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1895.2727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 195431061, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9374.091567536454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 28864, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2624.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 89773372, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3110.2193736141908, "stage_move_gen_ns": 542706476, "stage_ordering_ns": 222512678, "stage_eval_ns": 536986487, "stage_threat_ns": 1181295310, "stage_proof_ns": 62626391, "tactical_annotations": 109139, "root_tactical_annotations": 311, "search_tactical_annotations": 108828, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 50995, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 308963621, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 113701, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 827132042, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14816, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 542601200, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 25492, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 36383682, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 208, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 996556, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 50984, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6266540, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 28749, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 82934062, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 61970, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 196386820, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 18420, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1552869, "child_limit_applications": 7274, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 7274, "child_cap_hits": 7274, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 7274, "child_moves_before_total": 537070, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 537070, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 116471, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 116471, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.8342040142975, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.011960406928786, "tt_hits": 2468, "tt_cutoffs": 420, "beta_cutoffs": 6106, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5828.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6555.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1838, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1476, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18435, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 129, 96, 141, 110, 109, 142, 158, 82, 124, 84, 130, 131, 98, 81, 66, 83, 80, 85 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10083, "avg_search_time_ms": 916.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 81884, "safety_nodes": 155, "corridor_nodes": 7736, "corridor_branch_probes": 8653, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3665, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_plies_followed": 7688, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 7688, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 102, "corridor_proof_active": 48, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3665, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 102, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 99, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 828, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24183760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 89775, "avg_nodes": 8161.363636363636, "eval_calls": 58675, "avg_eval_calls": 5334.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 58675, "pattern_eval_ns": 1206428, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.5611930123562, "pattern_frame_queries": 58675, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1206428, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.5611930123562, "pattern_frame_updates": 163674, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2247082061, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13729.010478145583, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21809, "avg_candidate_generations": 1982.6363636363637, "candidate_moves_total": 1523745, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.86771516346462, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 657, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 21798, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1523088, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 451226, "avg_legality_checks": 41020.545454545456, "illegal_moves_skipped": 399, "root_legality_checks": 657, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 450569, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 399, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2978572, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 270779.2727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6321847053, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2122.442248500288, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18666, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1696.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 105840878, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5670.249544626594, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 435, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3735784, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8923, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 68092222, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8052, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27163603, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1256, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6849269, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 70982, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6452.909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 658830227, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9281.65206672114, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95475, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8679.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 303238593, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3176.1046661429696, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1103617772, "stage_ordering_ns": 635599874, "stage_eval_ns": 2248288489, "stage_threat_ns": 5137773501, "stage_proof_ns": 932235808, "tactical_annotations": 405330, "root_tactical_annotations": 2192, "search_tactical_annotations": 403138, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 179265, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1157104440, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 761332, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3719546159, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47192, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1943238315, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89627, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 137901354, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 15580, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 89706270, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 179254, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22466987, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 124059, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 131083784, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171143, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 584721099, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110128, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11048291, "child_limit_applications": 21798, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21798, "child_cap_hits": 21798, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21798, "child_moves_before_total": 1522689, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1522689, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 351001, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 351001, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.85452793834297, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.102440590879898, "tt_hits": 10427, "tt_cutoffs": 1364, "beta_cutoffs": 17989, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4103.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4831.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1168, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8342, "avg_search_time_ms": 834.2, "search_nodes": 73170, "safety_nodes": 895, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 74065, "avg_nodes": 7406.5, "eval_calls": 44125, "avg_eval_calls": 4412.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44125, "pattern_eval_ns": 922165, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.898923512747874, "pattern_frame_queries": 44125, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 922165, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.898923512747874, "pattern_frame_updates": 146228, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1734981627, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11864.907042426896, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25193, "avg_candidate_generations": 2519.3, "candidate_moves_total": 1743597, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.20958202675347, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 599, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 25183, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1742998, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 768679, "avg_legality_checks": 76867.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 269, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 768679, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 269, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2407043, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 240704.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5139689529, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2135.2711725548734, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14103, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1410.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43498363, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3084.334042402326, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 281, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2225418, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4259, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26954531, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9563, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14318414, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76147, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7614.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 677655006, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8899.300116879194, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 102517, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10251.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 288760617, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2816.709589629037, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1854455291, "stage_ordering_ns": 746533450, "stage_eval_ns": 1735903792, "stage_threat_ns": 3971661384, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 428691, "root_tactical_annotations": 436, "search_tactical_annotations": 428255, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 146238, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 882559914, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 388791, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2951511869, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50442, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1879076087, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 73114, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 109463302, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 146228, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18618353, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52566, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 145764709, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 285776, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 926440882, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 90349, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9507946, "child_limit_applications": 25183, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25183, "child_cap_hits": 25183, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25183, "child_moves_before_total": 1742729, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1742729, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 274359, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 274359, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.20259699003296, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.89461144422825, "tt_hits": 11165, "tt_cutoffs": 3806, "beta_cutoffs": 20384, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 5.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3578.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4378.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 219, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1477, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21302, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 145, 109, 108, 81, 123, 125, 80, 93, 129, 161, 77, 79, 63, 65, 107, 94, 124, 126, 142, 140, 155, 98, 84, 154 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 17999, "avg_search_time_ms": 1285.642857142857, "search_nodes": 211411, "safety_nodes": 592, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 212003, "avg_nodes": 15143.07142857143, "eval_calls": 156131, "avg_eval_calls": 11152.214285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 156131, "pattern_eval_ns": 3149970, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.175173412070635, "pattern_frame_queries": 156131, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3149970, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.175173412070635, "pattern_frame_updates": 422686, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5503661288, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13020.685066455952, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52204, "avg_candidate_generations": 3728.8571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 4506474, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.3243046509846, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1052, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 52190, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4505422, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1466509, "avg_legality_checks": 104750.64285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1215, "root_legality_checks": 1052, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1465457, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1215, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5477089, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 391220.64285714284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10694308910, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1952.5534293855733, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40917, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2922.6428571428573, "renju_forbidden_ns": 165064334, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4034.1260111933916, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1758, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10936129, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22456, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 114809850, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16703, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39318355, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 163964, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11711.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1149093970, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7008.208936107926, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 204315, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14593.92857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 414178954, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2027.1588184910554, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3147007609, "stage_ordering_ns": 1626038630, "stage_eval_ns": 5506811258, "stage_threat_ns": 7661451299, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 921912, "root_tactical_annotations": 3769, "search_tactical_annotations": 918143, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 422700, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2324634552, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 774533, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4959945369, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 104475, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3314704738, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 211343, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 292759966, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 422686, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50160477, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 293687, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 345360907, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 376359, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1299491543, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 251866, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33950935, "child_limit_applications": 52190, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52190, "child_cap_hits": 52190, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52190, "child_moves_before_total": 4504207, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4504207, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 538925, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 538925, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.30402375934086, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.326211917991952, "tt_hits": 27367, "tt_cutoffs": 3022, "beta_cutoffs": 38569, "depth_sum": 68, "avg_depth": 4.857142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 68, "avg_effective_depth": 4.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.42857142857142855, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4693.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5265.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1645, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 3289, "avg_search_time_ms": 253.0, "search_nodes": 33390, "safety_nodes": 1601, "corridor_nodes": 58, "corridor_branch_probes": 60, "corridor_max_depth": 5, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 49, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 49, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 41, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 185, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 73520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 5520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35049, "avg_nodes": 2696.076923076923, "eval_calls": 22806, "avg_eval_calls": 1754.3076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22806, "pattern_eval_ns": 474302, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.797246338682804, "pattern_frame_queries": 22806, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 474302, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.797246338682804, "pattern_frame_updates": 66660, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 671991510, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10080.880738073807, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10098, "avg_candidate_generations": 776.7692307692307, "candidate_moves_total": 819340, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.1388393741335, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 973, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 10085, "search_candidate_moves_total": 818367, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 319366, "avg_legality_checks": 24566.615384615383, "illegal_moves_skipped": 98, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 319366, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 98, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1009767, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 77674.38461538461, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1976825178, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1957.704280294365, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4001, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 307.7692307692308, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18312282, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4576.926268432891, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 98, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 933502, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1492, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12443888, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2411, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4934892, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 33251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2557.769230769231, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 261502041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7864.486511683859, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 43290, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3330.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 108743318, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2511.9731577731577, "stage_move_gen_ns": 708858607, "stage_ordering_ns": 307813308, "stage_eval_ns": 672465812, "stage_threat_ns": 1504497141, "stage_proof_ns": 66810664, "tactical_annotations": 176300, "root_tactical_annotations": 331, "search_tactical_annotations": 175969, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 66853, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 387486811, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 178784, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1059253960, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20454, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 657191755, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 33420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 46727368, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 180, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 859136, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 66840, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7928265, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 43299, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 104599183, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 108903, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 293326502, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 24098, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2241601, "child_limit_applications": 10085, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10085, "child_cap_hits": 10085, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10085, "child_moves_before_total": 818269, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 818269, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 162835, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 162835, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.13723351512147, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.146256817055033, "tt_hits": 2779, "tt_cutoffs": 439, "beta_cutoffs": 8598, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6170.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6785.538461538462, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1908, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1478, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 36245, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 109, 95, 98, 63, 127, 99, 125, 114, 113, 129, 144, 79, 47, 65, 128, 143, 126, 124, 93, 80, 50, 77, 78, 157, 171, 64, 66, 83, 82, 34, 49, 115, 101, 67, 51, 131 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 15308, "avg_search_time_ms": 805.6842105263158, "search_nodes": 200350, "safety_nodes": 1142, "corridor_nodes": 6690, "corridor_branch_probes": 7514, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2536, "corridor_neutral_exits": 198, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 6620, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6620, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 17, "corridor_proof_completed": 17, "corridor_proof_checks": 195, "corridor_proof_active": 70, "corridor_proof_quiet": 125, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 198, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2536, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 195, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 193, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1551, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 48446440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 208182, "avg_nodes": 10956.947368421053, "eval_calls": 153467, "avg_eval_calls": 8077.210526315789, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 153467, "pattern_eval_ns": 3060064, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.93955703832094, "pattern_frame_queries": 153467, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3060064, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.93955703832094, "pattern_frame_updates": 400526, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3804647286, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9499.126863174924, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44482, "avg_candidate_generations": 2341.157894736842, "candidate_moves_total": 3651083, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.08000989164157, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1439, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 44463, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3649644, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1303962, "avg_legality_checks": 68629.57894736843, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1200, "root_legality_checks": 1439, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1302523, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1198, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5238906, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 275731.8947368421, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8975407238, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1713.2216607818502, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40190, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2115.2631578947367, "renju_forbidden_ns": 118719268, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2953.9504354316996, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1971, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8919980, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18235, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 77139991, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17897, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27528755, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2087, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5130542, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 132457, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6971.421052631579, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 901946184, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6809.350838385288, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 176423, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9285.421052631578, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 383106509, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2171.5224715598306, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2642493166, "stage_ordering_ns": 1169336181, "stage_eval_ns": 3807707350, "stage_threat_ns": 6879799760, "stage_proof_ns": 732739332, "tactical_annotations": 714378, "root_tactical_annotations": 3761, "search_tactical_annotations": 710617, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 414175, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2074972867, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1049914, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4415442656, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 93156, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2595980813, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 207078, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 265959158, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 13630, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 59676826, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 414156, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43689514, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 229430, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 202497731, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 323499, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1021180946, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 161449, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20058739, "child_limit_applications": 44463, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44463, "child_cap_hits": 44463, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44463, "child_moves_before_total": 3648446, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3648446, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 711704, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 711704, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.05577671322223, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.006657220610396, "tt_hits": 18829, "tt_cutoffs": 2333, "beta_cutoffs": 34427, "depth_sum": 87, "avg_depth": 4.578947368421052, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 87, "avg_effective_depth": 4.578947368421052, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5571.315789473684, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5992.368421052632, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1255, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 20917, "avg_search_time_ms": 1162.0555555555557, "search_nodes": 219336, "safety_nodes": 1433, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 220769, "avg_nodes": 12264.944444444445, "eval_calls": 130722, "avg_eval_calls": 7262.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 130722, "pattern_eval_ns": 2528701, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.34411193219198, "pattern_frame_queries": 130722, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2528701, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.34411193219198, "pattern_frame_updates": 438446, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3254334664, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7422.429818039165, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 82525, "avg_candidate_generations": 4584.722222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 7068555, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.65349893971523, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1373, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 82507, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7067182, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 4055720, "avg_legality_checks": 225317.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6657, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4055720, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6657, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9271778, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 515098.77777777775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13287846994, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1433.149822396524, "renju_forbidden_checks": 71325, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3962.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 153122483, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2146.8276621100595, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8380, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33388474, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18394, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72422815, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 44541, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 47262404, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 48790, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 342994, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19055.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2116451592, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6170.520743803098, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 466525, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25918.055555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 974270777, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2088.357059107229, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6698356297, "stage_ordering_ns": 1891331108, "stage_eval_ns": 3256863365, "stage_threat_ns": 8908819054, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1471646, "root_tactical_annotations": 3277, "search_tactical_annotations": 1468369, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 438464, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1898547444, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1287730, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6674785059, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 165163, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3766063021, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 219223, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 250792091, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 438446, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41752841, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 345570, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 997328043, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 776984, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1911189785, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 349092, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 42941619, "child_limit_applications": 82507, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 82507, "child_cap_hits": 82507, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 82507, "child_moves_before_total": 7060525, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7060525, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 843843, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 843843, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.57486031488237, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.227532209388295, "tt_hits": 37613, "tt_cutoffs": 5994, "beta_cutoffs": 67422, "depth_sum": 111, "avg_depth": 6.166666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 111, "avg_effective_depth": 6.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4531.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4976.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1479, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6692, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 95, 99, 94, 129, 79, 63, 96, 97, 93, 92, 81, 144, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4164, "avg_search_time_ms": 462.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 67804, "safety_nodes": 428, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68232, "avg_nodes": 7581.333333333333, "eval_calls": 41038, "avg_eval_calls": 4559.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41038, "pattern_eval_ns": 752491, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.336444271163312, "pattern_frame_queries": 41038, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 752491, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.336444271163312, "pattern_frame_updates": 135522, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 889336806, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6562.305795369018, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25166, "avg_candidate_generations": 2796.222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 1889524, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.08241277914647, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 554, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 25157, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1888970, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 595771, "avg_legality_checks": 66196.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 590, "root_legality_checks": 554, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 595217, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 590, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1932765, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 214751.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2429492181, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1257.0034023794926, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14505, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1611.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 38418300, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2648.6246122026887, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 635, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3304620, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4651, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22884532, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9217, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12226468, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44109, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4901.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 216968152, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4918.908884808089, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 61124, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6791.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 90804462, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1485.577874484654, "stage_move_gen_ns": 826903563, "stage_ordering_ns": 453138611, "stage_eval_ns": 890089297, "stage_threat_ns": 1959949522, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 239941, "root_tactical_annotations": 1337, "search_tactical_annotations": 238604, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 135531, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 470345824, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 210848, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1406814763, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50374, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1078036504, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67761, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 64773465, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 135522, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10604600, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 31393, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 37278650, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 129076, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 291385239, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79472, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7410870, "child_limit_applications": 25157, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25157, "child_cap_hits": 25157, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25157, "child_moves_before_total": 1888380, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1888380, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 214149, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 214149, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.0637993401439, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.512501490638789, "tt_hits": 13299, "tt_cutoffs": 1566, "beta_cutoffs": 19800, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4568.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5457.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1770, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 2520, "avg_search_time_ms": 315.0, "search_nodes": 40863, "safety_nodes": 687, "corridor_nodes": 1392, "corridor_branch_probes": 1710, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 613, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1380, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1365, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 15, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 613, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 3, "corridor_proof_unknown": 47, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 327, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 8127680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 42942, "avg_nodes": 5367.75, "eval_calls": 28575, "avg_eval_calls": 3571.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 28575, "pattern_eval_ns": 521190, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.23937007874016, "pattern_frame_queries": 28575, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 521190, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.23937007874016, "pattern_frame_updates": 81656, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 439598297, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5383.539445968453, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11804, "avg_candidate_generations": 1475.5, "candidate_moves_total": 846160, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.68417485598103, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 492, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 11796, "search_candidate_moves_total": 845668, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 481351, "avg_legality_checks": 60168.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1383, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 481351, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1383, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1238176, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 154772.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1485154371, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1199.4695188729227, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7313, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 914.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21843809, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2986.9833173800084, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1383, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7053607, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1669, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9476696, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4237, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5293866, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 19640, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 34374, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4296.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 170701562, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4966.008087508, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 46689, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5836.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 73565257, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1575.6443059393005, "stage_move_gen_ns": 655279020, "stage_ordering_ns": 202256935, "stage_eval_ns": 440119487, "stage_threat_ns": 1152890773, "stage_proof_ns": 42959286, "tactical_annotations": 144563, "root_tactical_annotations": 628, "search_tactical_annotations": 143935, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 84524, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 299899481, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 217182, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 791981123, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24339, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 509094695, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42258, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 40330862, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2860, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10923941, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 84516, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6570958, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 29269, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 41659591, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 85504, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 200945582, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 29790, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3184408, "child_limit_applications": 11796, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11796, "child_cap_hits": 11796, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11796, "child_moves_before_total": 844285, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 844285, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 188803, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 188803, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.57383858935232, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00567989148864, "tt_hits": 3610, "tt_cutoffs": 457, "beta_cutoffs": 9956, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 4.375, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 4.375, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4799.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5799.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1923, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1480, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16628, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 101, 100, 128, 130, 115, 129, 126, 144, 99, 116, 158, 132, 148, 146, 125, 124, 142, 174, 159, 160, 118, 188 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7974, "avg_search_time_ms": 613.3846153846154, "search_nodes": 145934, "safety_nodes": 294, "corridor_nodes": 6493, "corridor_branch_probes": 6990, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3142, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 30, "corridor_plies_followed": 6454, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6454, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 132, "corridor_proof_active": 39, "corridor_proof_quiet": 93, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3142, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 132, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 129, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1093, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26162320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 152721, "avg_nodes": 11747.76923076923, "eval_calls": 112775, "avg_eval_calls": 8675.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 112775, "pattern_eval_ns": 2056898, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.238953668809575, "pattern_frame_queries": 112775, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2056898, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.238953668809575, "pattern_frame_updates": 291754, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2065869838, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7080.862089294405, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31536, "avg_candidate_generations": 2425.846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 2276667, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.19263698630137, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 799, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 31523, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2275868, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 862126, "avg_legality_checks": 66317.38461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2082, "root_legality_checks": 799, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 861327, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2079, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3872686, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 297898.92307692306, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4586338101, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1184.278328013167, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31078, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2390.6153846153848, "renju_forbidden_ns": 90394839, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2908.644024712015, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2221, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10626359, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13067, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 52743972, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13010, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19635901, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2780, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7388607, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 94686, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7283.538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 455321232, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4808.74925543375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 125553, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9657.923076923076, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 201788075, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1607.194372097839, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1183459109, "stage_ordering_ns": 533280556, "stage_eval_ns": 2067926736, "stage_threat_ns": 3675897684, "stage_proof_ns": 456498370, "tactical_annotations": 453764, "root_tactical_annotations": 2629, "search_tactical_annotations": 451135, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 304939, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1055436631, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 753657, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2393923154, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 66529, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1390988761, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 152463, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 144587320, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 13172, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 48440876, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 304926, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23775831, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 130680, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 99313483, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 221658, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 483687257, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 101426, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9733872, "child_limit_applications": 31523, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31523, "child_cap_hits": 31523, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31523, "child_moves_before_total": 2273789, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2273789, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 505220, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 505220, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.13111061764425, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.027027884401864, "tt_hits": 12861, "tt_cutoffs": 1579, "beta_cutoffs": 24166, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5618.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6233.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1446, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8643, "avg_search_time_ms": 720.25, "search_nodes": 121217, "safety_nodes": 859, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122076, "avg_nodes": 10173.0, "eval_calls": 72063, "avg_eval_calls": 6005.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72063, "pattern_eval_ns": 1320605, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.32570112262881, "pattern_frame_queries": 72063, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1320605, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.32570112262881, "pattern_frame_updates": 242292, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1525540116, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6296.287603387648, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44761, "avg_candidate_generations": 3730.0833333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 3283196, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.34947834051965, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 738, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 44749, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3282458, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 1940411, "avg_legality_checks": 161700.91666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4160, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1940411, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4160, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4582989, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 381915.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5340006492, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1165.179862312565, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37741, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3145.0833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 78828920, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2088.6812750059617, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4218, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20687731, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10578, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37838794, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22930, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20222955, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 79440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 129895, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10824.583333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 630175977, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4851.425974825821, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 176699, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14724.916666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 278887936, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1578.3220957673784, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2567892894, "stage_ordering_ns": 759638369, "stage_eval_ns": 1526860721, "stage_threat_ns": 3704618975, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 808990, "root_tactical_annotations": 1715, "search_tactical_annotations": 807275, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 242304, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 819889325, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 661618, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2725132347, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 89593, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1741100766, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121146, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 115482865, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 242292, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19497338, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 152972, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 197006410, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 419043, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 786888290, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 236975, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24617100, "child_limit_applications": 44749, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44749, "child_cap_hits": 44749, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44749, "child_moves_before_total": 3278298, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3278298, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 449086, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 449086, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.25969295403249, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.035665601465954, "tt_hits": 23202, "tt_cutoffs": 4334, "beta_cutoffs": 36436, "depth_sum": 71, "avg_depth": 5.916666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 71, "avg_effective_depth": 5.916666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5161.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5828.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1855, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1481, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26831, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 125, 173, 143, 141, 157, 172, 171, 129, 81, 145, 140, 177, 161, 159, 185, 199, 155, 170, 187, 131, 117, 130, 132, 139, 126, 154, 110, 95, 94, 158, 78 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 19340, "avg_search_time_ms": 1137.6470588235295, "search_nodes": 255748, "safety_nodes": 999, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 256747, "avg_nodes": 15102.764705882353, "eval_calls": 162821, "avg_eval_calls": 9577.70588235294, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 162821, "pattern_eval_ns": 3164243, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.4338752372237, "pattern_frame_queries": 162821, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3164243, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.4338752372237, "pattern_frame_updates": 511318, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4624069905, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9043.432668124338, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 86613, "avg_candidate_generations": 5094.882352941177, "candidate_moves_total": 7124694, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.25894496207266, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1356, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 86596, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7123338, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 2180055, "avg_legality_checks": 128238.5294117647, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3661, "root_legality_checks": 1356, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 2178699, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3657, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6966559, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 409797.5882352941, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11164448188, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1602.5771385844862, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54485, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3205.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 243549114, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4470.021363678076, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4078, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34760650, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25460, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 156894484, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24925, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 51667509, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 226471, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 147001, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8647.117647058823, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1001058975, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6809.878674294732, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 198831, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11695.941176470587, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 459081485, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2308.9029628176695, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3833019239, "stage_ordering_ns": 2111694113, "stage_eval_ns": 4627234148, "stage_threat_ns": 8656904927, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1274026, "root_tactical_annotations": 3586, "search_tactical_annotations": 1270440, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 511335, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2189891895, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1055361, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6072132858, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 173314, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4367850561, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 255659, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 293490230, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 511318, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49588627, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 259556, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 228494359, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 622477, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1475330947, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 391993, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 51801317, "child_limit_applications": 86596, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 86596, "child_cap_hits": 86596, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 86596, "child_moves_before_total": 7119681, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7119681, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 797509, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 797509, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.21720402789967, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.209536237239595, "tt_hits": 43985, "tt_cutoffs": 6243, "beta_cutoffs": 67553, "depth_sum": 88, "avg_depth": 5.176470588235294, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 88, "avg_effective_depth": 5.176470588235294, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3972.3529411764707, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4442.941176470588, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 7476, "avg_search_time_ms": 467.25, "search_nodes": 79556, "safety_nodes": 1426, "corridor_nodes": 511, "corridor_branch_probes": 554, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 159, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 496, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 496, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 99, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 84, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 159, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 99, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 99, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 715, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 470000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 16800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 81493, "avg_nodes": 5093.3125, "eval_calls": 53101, "avg_eval_calls": 3318.8125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53101, "pattern_eval_ns": 1045127, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.681870397920942, "pattern_frame_queries": 53101, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1045127, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.681870397920942, "pattern_frame_updates": 158962, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1135350110, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7142.273688051232, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24861, "avg_candidate_generations": 1553.8125, "candidate_moves_total": 2052354, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.55315554482925, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1276, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 24845, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2051078, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 1290745, "avg_legality_checks": 80671.5625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 785, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1290745, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 785, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2835595, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 177224.6875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4748500946, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1674.6047817124802, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16492, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1030.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 54859634, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3326.4391219985446, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 853, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8569360, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3891, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29812166, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11706, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15993333, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 484775, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75533, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4720.8125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 530096189, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7018.074073583732, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 102332, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6395.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 248543311, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2428.79364226244, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2433837941, "stage_ordering_ns": 659805902, "stage_eval_ns": 1136395237, "stage_threat_ns": 3041623362, "stage_proof_ns": 134411926, "tactical_annotations": 373728, "root_tactical_annotations": 1771, "search_tactical_annotations": 371957, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 160168, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 734680634, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 381689, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2180191261, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50474, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1408264445, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 80076, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94215913, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1190, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7082819, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 160152, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15984569, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 108821, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 196752006, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 187558, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 553506455, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 77349, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9468166, "child_limit_applications": 24845, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24845, "child_cap_hits": 24845, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24845, "child_moves_before_total": 2050293, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2050293, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 397974, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 397974, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.5233648621453, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.018273294425438, "tt_hits": 9698, "tt_cutoffs": 1535, "beta_cutoffs": 21411, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6395.9375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6895.9375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1764, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1482, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28677, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 97, 127, 126, 143, 159, 158, 113, 95, 79, 173, 188, 129, 98, 140, 101, 157, 115, 185, 171, 125, 70, 84, 100, 99, 85, 130, 55 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 8518, "avg_search_time_ms": 608.4285714285714, "search_nodes": 88860, "safety_nodes": 1250, "corridor_nodes": 367, "corridor_branch_probes": 414, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 129, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 355, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 355, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 52, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 129, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 62, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 447, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 252400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 17520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 90477, "avg_nodes": 6462.642857142857, "eval_calls": 63844, "avg_eval_calls": 4560.285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 63844, "pattern_eval_ns": 1319514, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.66778397343525, "pattern_frame_queries": 63844, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1319514, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.66778397343525, "pattern_frame_updates": 177596, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2078274443, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11702.259302011307, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23343, "avg_candidate_generations": 1667.357142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 1822099, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.05761898641991, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1035, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 23329, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1821064, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 781815, "avg_legality_checks": 55843.92857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 205, "root_legality_checks": 1035, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 780780, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 205, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2425696, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 173264.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5226412931, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2154.6034338185823, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9650, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 689.2857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31260884, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3239.4698445595855, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 253, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2267720, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3631, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21364922, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5732, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7567801, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 60441, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 55323, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3951.6428571428573, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 467962479, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8458.732877826582, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76300, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5450.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 192176559, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2518.6967103538664, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1837540983, "stage_ordering_ns": 745432571, "stage_eval_ns": 2079593957, "stage_threat_ns": 3670513344, "stage_proof_ns": 139982825, "tactical_annotations": 292185, "root_tactical_annotations": 1374, "search_tactical_annotations": 290811, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 178448, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1036032546, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 309373, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2475728232, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47177, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1722079490, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89217, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125676254, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 838, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4603709, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 178434, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21995842, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 59041, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 60004975, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 179450, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 653243510, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53694, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6476761, "child_limit_applications": 23329, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23329, "child_cap_hits": 23329, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23329, "child_moves_before_total": 1820859, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1820859, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 373271, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 373271, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.05130952891251, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000300055724633, "tt_hits": 7892, "tt_cutoffs": 1626, "beta_cutoffs": 19154, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 4.357142857142857, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 4.357142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5384.928571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5956.357142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 20145, "avg_search_time_ms": 1549.6153846153845, "search_nodes": 141043, "safety_nodes": 535, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 141578, "avg_nodes": 10890.615384615385, "eval_calls": 82953, "avg_eval_calls": 6381.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82953, "pattern_eval_ns": 1731174, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.869335647897003, "pattern_frame_queries": 82953, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1731174, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.869335647897003, "pattern_frame_updates": 281944, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2752991050, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9764.318623556452, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 54533, "avg_candidate_generations": 4194.846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 4794947, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.92743843177526, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 977, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 54520, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4793970, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 3638896, "avg_legality_checks": 279915.07692307694, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1112, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3638896, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1112, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7169025, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 551463.4615384615, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13616996586, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1899.4209932312972, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40942, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3149.3846153846152, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50858905, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1242.2183821015094, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1158, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10184347, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2687, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19998609, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37097, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20675949, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 230809, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17754.53846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1880291702, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8146.526790549762, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 319529, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 24579.153846153848, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 847147284, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2651.237552772988, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7631011470, "stage_ordering_ns": 1739778708, "stage_eval_ns": 2754722224, "stage_threat_ns": 7884965567, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1070257, "root_tactical_annotations": 3526, "search_tactical_annotations": 1066731, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 281957, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1532784286, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 950188, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6096085600, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 109137, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3377109388, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 140972, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 194030493, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 281944, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33308347, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 213124, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 344155081, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 627917, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2374740521, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 229216, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28756841, "child_limit_applications": 54520, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 54520, "child_cap_hits": 54520, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 54520, "child_moves_before_total": 4792858, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4792858, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 492271, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 492271, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.91008804108584, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.029181951577403, "tt_hits": 22446, "tt_cutoffs": 3504, "beta_cutoffs": 44253, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.46153846153846156, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.46153846153846156, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1491.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1946.4615384615386, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1483, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15218, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 81, 129, 127, 143, 109, 108, 95, 145, 161, 123, 80, 125, 79, 63, 78, 77, 82 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10024, "avg_search_time_ms": 1002.4, "search_nodes": 102794, "safety_nodes": 160, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 102954, "avg_nodes": 10295.4, "eval_calls": 66067, "avg_eval_calls": 6606.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 66067, "pattern_eval_ns": 1411827, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.369624774849775, "pattern_frame_queries": 66067, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1411827, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.369624774849775, "pattern_frame_updates": 205496, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2509474922, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12211.794497216491, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34385, "avg_candidate_generations": 3438.5, "candidate_moves_total": 2664020, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.47622509815326, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 673, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 34375, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2663347, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 822660, "avg_legality_checks": 82266.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1245, "root_legality_checks": 673, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 821987, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1243, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2811990, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 281199.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5953475015, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2117.1750308500386, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25161, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2516.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 148439090, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5899.570366837566, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1318, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10206110, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12678, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 103420584, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11155, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 34686885, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 125511, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58112, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5811.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 457402106, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7871.043949614537, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76414, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7641.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 192863896, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2523.934043499882, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1882511552, "stage_ordering_ns": 1066613701, "stage_eval_ns": 2510886749, "stage_threat_ns": 4522012298, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 421283, "root_tactical_annotations": 2659, "search_tactical_annotations": 418624, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 205506, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1168749446, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 350613, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3162865654, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 68815, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2445799195, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102748, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 148858925, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 205496, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25548827, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 92987, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 85376608, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 188803, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 631679661, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 139493, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15989446, "child_limit_applications": 34375, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34375, "child_cap_hits": 34375, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34375, "child_moves_before_total": 2662104, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2662104, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 338915, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 338915, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.44302545454545, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.859345454545455, "tt_hits": 19095, "tt_cutoffs": 2306, "beta_cutoffs": 26297, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3154.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3954.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1059, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5184, "avg_search_time_ms": 576.0, "search_nodes": 51371, "safety_nodes": 753, "corridor_nodes": 188, "corridor_branch_probes": 228, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 72, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 186, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 186, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 43, "corridor_proof_active": 2, "corridor_proof_quiet": 41, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 72, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 43, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 43, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 292, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 150080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 52312, "avg_nodes": 5812.444444444444, "eval_calls": 36783, "avg_eval_calls": 4087.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36783, "pattern_eval_ns": 800671, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.767419731941384, "pattern_frame_queries": 36783, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 800671, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.767419731941384, "pattern_frame_updates": 102662, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1084574561, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10564.518137188054, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13929, "avg_candidate_generations": 1547.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1013731, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.77844784263048, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 598, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 13920, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1013133, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 524031, "avg_legality_checks": 58225.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 607, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 524031, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 607, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1394217, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 154913.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3175401235, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2277.5516544411666, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10568, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1174.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 69986804, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6622.521196063588, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 607, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6790994, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 47221068, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5521, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15844421, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 130321, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28717, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3190.777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 269794068, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9394.925235922972, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 39803, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4422.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 118602204, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2979.730271587569, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1336086000, "stage_ordering_ns": 442155460, "stage_eval_ns": 1085375232, "stage_threat_ns": 2213023686, "stage_proof_ns": 77017951, "tactical_annotations": 162912, "root_tactical_annotations": 576, "search_tactical_annotations": 162336, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 103129, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 623933511, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 167190, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1492575089, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28140, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1072683741, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 76298345, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 458, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2422326, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 103120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13080980, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32061, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 75923110, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 94959, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 333893243, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 35892, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4713435, "child_limit_applications": 13920, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13920, "child_cap_hits": 13920, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13920, "child_moves_before_total": 1012526, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1012526, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 222947, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 222947, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.7389367816092, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01630747126437, "tt_hits": 4389, "tt_cutoffs": 628, "beta_cutoffs": 11510, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4227.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5116.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1634, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1484, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28612, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 129, 124, 127, 95, 96, 122, 144, 128, 114, 159, 125, 98, 143, 101, 142, 68, 83, 100, 99, 84, 145, 141, 146 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 12413, "avg_search_time_ms": 954.8461538461538, "search_nodes": 129503, "safety_nodes": 565, "corridor_nodes": 1943, "corridor_branch_probes": 2103, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 744, "corridor_neutral_exits": 64, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 1919, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1919, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 121, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 97, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 64, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 744, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 121, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 118, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 976, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26198160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 132011, "avg_nodes": 10154.692307692309, "eval_calls": 97231, "avg_eval_calls": 7479.307692307692, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 97231, "pattern_eval_ns": 2109256, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.69324598121998, "pattern_frame_queries": 97231, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2109256, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.69324598121998, "pattern_frame_updates": 258892, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2975211602, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11492.095553358156, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30942, "avg_candidate_generations": 2380.153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 2302271, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.40601771055523, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 888, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 30929, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2301383, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 969471, "avg_legality_checks": 74574.69230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 566, "root_legality_checks": 888, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 968583, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 566, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3251147, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 250088.23076923078, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7439741922, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2288.343751297619, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17095, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1315.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 68571456, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4011.1995320269084, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 733, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7707550, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5622, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 42017184, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10458, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18130140, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 282, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 716582, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 71450, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5496.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 593654012, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8308.663568929322, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 90624, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6971.076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 221430335, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2443.3961754060733, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2429506244, "stage_ordering_ns": 1008975716, "stage_eval_ns": 2977320858, "stage_threat_ns": 5497860748, "stage_proof_ns": 449295548, "tactical_annotations": 373691, "root_tactical_annotations": 2416, "search_tactical_annotations": 371275, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 262985, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1622810370, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 480928, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3606983600, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 63510, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2443194971, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 131486, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 199501652, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4080, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25051050, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 262972, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34434113, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 91184, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 105735078, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 206028, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 765080650, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76479, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9079963, "child_limit_applications": 30929, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30929, "child_cap_hits": 30929, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30929, "child_moves_before_total": 2300817, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2300817, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 494864, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 494864, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.39028096608361, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 12046, "tt_cutoffs": 1286, "beta_cutoffs": 24572, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3915.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4531.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 992, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 16186, "avg_search_time_ms": 1348.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 128598, "safety_nodes": 839, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 129437, "avg_nodes": 10786.416666666666, "eval_calls": 80697, "avg_eval_calls": 6724.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80697, "pattern_eval_ns": 1805696, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.376246948461528, "pattern_frame_queries": 80697, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1805696, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.376246948461528, "pattern_frame_updates": 257058, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2802839864, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10903.530969664434, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 45149, "avg_candidate_generations": 3762.4166666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 3413160, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.5976876564265, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 807, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 45137, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3412353, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 2037416, "avg_legality_checks": 169784.66666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1360, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2037416, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1360, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4606354, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 383862.8333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10444322724, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2267.373007806174, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22449, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1870.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 100491227, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4476.423315069714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1568, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18311420, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5999, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 53275652, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14882, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28904155, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 114732, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9561.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1023774691, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8923.183514625387, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 151719, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12643.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 414456948, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2731.7405730330415, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5088492597, "stage_ordering_ns": 1472515932, "stage_eval_ns": 2804645560, "stage_threat_ns": 6727463504, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 678243, "root_tactical_annotations": 2095, "search_tactical_annotations": 676148, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 257070, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1582272655, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 597986, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4889481698, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90367, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3326895597, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128529, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 199204136, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 257058, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34072087, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 149943, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 401297406, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 357666, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1161070254, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 170634, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22432928, "child_limit_applications": 45137, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 45137, "child_cap_hits": 45137, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 45137, "child_moves_before_total": 3410993, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3410993, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 395988, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 395988, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.56977645833796, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.773024348095797, "tt_hits": 19298, "tt_cutoffs": 2697, "beta_cutoffs": 35009, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 5.583333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 5.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4166666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1785.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2443.4166666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1485, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14181, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 155, 169, 51, 81, 84, 53, 95, 111, 125, 68, 110, 140, 65, 80, 79, 38, 23, 98 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 11507, "avg_search_time_ms": 885.1538461538462, "search_nodes": 115470, "safety_nodes": 697, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 116167, "avg_nodes": 8935.923076923076, "eval_calls": 79542, "avg_eval_calls": 6118.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79542, "pattern_eval_ns": 1736839, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.83549571295668, "pattern_frame_queries": 79542, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1736839, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.83549571295668, "pattern_frame_updates": 230822, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3023007675, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13096.705145090156, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33891, "avg_candidate_generations": 2607.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2803298, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.71511610752117, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 922, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 33878, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2802376, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 908480, "avg_legality_checks": 69883.07692307692, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1149, "root_legality_checks": 922, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 907558, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1149, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3099776, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 238444.3076923077, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6863900238, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2214.3213696731636, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23464, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1804.923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 133964013, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5709.342524718718, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1291, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11232831, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11823, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 94435796, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10348, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28292436, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2950, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83585, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6429.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 709723497, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8491.039026141054, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 108920, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8378.461538461539, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 287646319, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2640.895326845391, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2252010379, "stage_ordering_ns": 1138219295, "stage_eval_ns": 3024744514, "stage_threat_ns": 5042738079, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 504184, "root_tactical_annotations": 2375, "search_tactical_annotations": 501809, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 230835, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1412511722, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 404043, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3403018820, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67840, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2376094283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115411, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 174532655, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 230822, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29840656, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 117647, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 179365463, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 218547, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 847103013, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 167990, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22834226, "child_limit_applications": 33878, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33878, "child_cap_hits": 33878, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33878, "child_moves_before_total": 2801227, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2801227, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 346958, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 346958, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.68572524942441, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.241395595961981, "tt_hits": 18204, "tt_cutoffs": 1991, "beta_cutoffs": 25858, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5233.076923076923, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5848.461538461538, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 855, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 2661, "avg_search_time_ms": 221.75, "search_nodes": 23081, "safety_nodes": 1375, "corridor_nodes": 758, "corridor_branch_probes": 931, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 328, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 749, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 749, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 328, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 41, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 192, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 116160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 25214, "avg_nodes": 2101.1666666666665, "eval_calls": 15977, "avg_eval_calls": 1331.4166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 15977, "pattern_eval_ns": 354401, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.181949051761908, "pattern_frame_queries": 15977, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 354401, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.181949051761908, "pattern_frame_updates": 46052, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 486562419, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10565.500282289586, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6725, "avg_candidate_generations": 560.4166666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 514978, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.57665427509293, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 852, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 6713, "search_candidate_moves_total": 514126, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 261335, "avg_legality_checks": 21777.916666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 178, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 261335, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 178, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 752352, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 62696.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1646496680, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2188.46587767428, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3428, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 285.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15582472, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4545.645274212368, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 178, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1511565, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9740368, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2170, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4330539, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23689, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1974.0833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 228919390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9663.531174806873, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 33094, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2757.8333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 106237255, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3210.1666465220283, "stage_move_gen_ns": 653979812, "stage_ordering_ns": 219165102, "stage_eval_ns": 486916820, "stage_threat_ns": 1209257518, "stage_proof_ns": 65663692, "tactical_annotations": 98438, "root_tactical_annotations": 356, "search_tactical_annotations": 98082, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 47644, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 313958471, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 133324, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 840407986, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13958, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 497797683, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 23816, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 36386370, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1580, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10676021, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 47632, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6103752, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 22801, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 102603245, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 54039, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 204666593, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 21598, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1724918, "child_limit_applications": 6713, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6713, "child_cap_hits": 6713, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6713, "child_moves_before_total": 513948, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 513948, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 107645, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 107645, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.56010725458066, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.035304632802028, "tt_hits": 2515, "tt_cutoffs": 336, "beta_cutoffs": 5671, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6015.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6682.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1863, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1486, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27934, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 84, 98, 83, 85, 99, 97, 129, 69, 115, 67, 101, 143, 131, 147, 116, 146, 100, 95, 94, 128, 158, 144, 145, 68, 103, 102, 117, 89, 159 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 16340, "avg_search_time_ms": 1089.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 127149, "safety_nodes": 650, "corridor_nodes": 19286, "corridor_branch_probes": 20248, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 10373, "corridor_neutral_exits": 231, "corridor_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_plies_followed": 19229, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 19229, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 135, "corridor_proof_active": 57, "corridor_proof_quiet": 78, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 231, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 10373, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 135, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 130, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1098, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 30502880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 147085, "avg_nodes": 9805.666666666666, "eval_calls": 93473, "avg_eval_calls": 6231.533333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 93473, "pattern_eval_ns": 2029557, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.712761974045982, "pattern_frame_queries": 93473, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2029557, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.712761974045982, "pattern_frame_updates": 254164, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2836533836, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11160.250216395712, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32237, "avg_candidate_generations": 2149.133333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 2367274, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.43344604026429, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1011, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 32222, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2366263, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 814338, "avg_legality_checks": 54289.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1688, "root_legality_checks": 1011, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 813327, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1686, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4771557, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 318103.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10220815648, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2142.02945663229, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34056, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2270.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 164888834, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4841.697028423772, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1905, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18749335, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11931, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 83756725, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16345, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44250249, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3875, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 18132525, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 119655, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7977.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 978592854, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8178.453503823493, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 153353, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10223.533333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 397111654, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2589.526478125632, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2033975225, "stage_ordering_ns": 967894783, "stage_eval_ns": 2838563393, "stage_threat_ns": 8583024052, "stage_proof_ns": 1865466270, "tactical_annotations": 454898, "root_tactical_annotations": 2696, "search_tactical_annotations": 452202, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 292907, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2013856505, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1316700, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6024171697, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 73456, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2862353702, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 146446, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 233950752, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 38728, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 261397714, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 292892, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37608502, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 139733, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 203087479, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 210452, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 833030415, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 104713, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12038882, "child_limit_applications": 32222, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32222, "child_cap_hits": 32222, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32222, "child_moves_before_total": 2364577, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2364577, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 516103, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 516103, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.38393023400161, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.017100117931847, "tt_hits": 13489, "tt_cutoffs": 1387, "beta_cutoffs": 26232, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3669.866666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4203.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 303, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 11579, "avg_search_time_ms": 827.0714285714286, "search_nodes": 89000, "safety_nodes": 1455, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 90455, "avg_nodes": 6461.071428571428, "eval_calls": 52079, "avg_eval_calls": 3719.9285714285716, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 52079, "pattern_eval_ns": 1162111, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.314387757061386, "pattern_frame_queries": 52079, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1162111, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.314387757061386, "pattern_frame_updates": 177832, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2027454127, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11400.952173961941, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33585, "avg_candidate_generations": 2398.9285714285716, "candidate_moves_total": 2408204, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.70474914396308, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 951, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 33571, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2407253, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 1280391, "avg_legality_checks": 91456.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6535, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1280391, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6535, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3394498, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 242464.14285714287, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7295972886, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2149.352536369148, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43866, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3133.285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 221791687, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5056.118337664706, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6673, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 69088124, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12475, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 98553752, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24703, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 53956681, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 193130, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 128822, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9201.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1115453628, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8658.875254226763, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 169493, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12106.642857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 463942008, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2737.2340332639105, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3209996529, "stage_ordering_ns": 983966999, "stage_eval_ns": 2028616238, "stage_threat_ns": 5296411625, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 576103, "root_tactical_annotations": 920, "search_tactical_annotations": 575183, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 177846, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1102676767, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 509895, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4015504944, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67254, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2400761856, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 88916, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 139399808, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 177832, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23714477, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 98460, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 343976696, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 344170, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1270377989, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 133473, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15115629, "child_limit_applications": 33571, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33571, "child_cap_hits": 33571, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33571, "child_moves_before_total": 2400718, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2400718, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 342993, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 342993, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.51166185100236, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.21694319501951, "tt_hits": 14608, "tt_cutoffs": 3266, "beta_cutoffs": 27377, "depth_sum": 83, "avg_depth": 5.928571428571429, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 83, "avg_effective_depth": 5.928571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4349.071428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4920.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1487, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14170, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 71, 85, 93, 95, 140, 123, 81, 97, 83, 124, 121, 139, 153, 154, 169, 94 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 11592, "avg_search_time_ms": 966.0, "search_nodes": 119250, "safety_nodes": 388, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 119638, "avg_nodes": 9969.833333333334, "eval_calls": 87307, "avg_eval_calls": 7275.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87307, "pattern_eval_ns": 1893976, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.693289197887914, "pattern_frame_queries": 87307, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1893976, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.693289197887914, "pattern_frame_updates": 238392, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3346532973, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14037.941596194503, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30291, "avg_candidate_generations": 2524.25, "candidate_moves_total": 2536213, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.72826912284177, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 869, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 30279, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2535344, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 907774, "avg_legality_checks": 75647.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1122, "root_legality_checks": 869, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 906905, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1122, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3127711, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 260642.58333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6955332580, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2223.777254356301, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26724, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2227.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 143875306, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5383.748914833109, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1301, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10182569, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15293, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 107607519, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10130, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26085218, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83961, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6996.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 713525538, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8498.297280880408, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109677, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9139.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 286855985, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2615.4616282356374, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2256458865, "stage_ordering_ns": 1066204489, "stage_eval_ns": 3348426949, "stage_threat_ns": 4881451416, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 418894, "root_tactical_annotations": 2707, "search_tactical_annotations": 416187, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 238404, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1443839125, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 367410, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3206897881, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60635, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2183587340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 119196, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 185187279, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 238392, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30913177, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 102976, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 196308405, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 203789, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 826681966, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 112129, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14613954, "child_limit_applications": 30279, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30279, "child_cap_hits": 30279, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30279, "child_moves_before_total": 2534222, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2534222, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 287106, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 287106, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.69569668747316, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.482017239671059, "tt_hits": 14293, "tt_cutoffs": 1610, "beta_cutoffs": 21439, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4970.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5637.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 662, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2565, "avg_search_time_ms": 233.1818181818182, "search_nodes": 22536, "safety_nodes": 1229, "corridor_nodes": 182, "corridor_branch_probes": 237, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 60, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 177, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 177, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 34, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 29, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 60, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 34, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 168, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 74000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 5600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 23947, "avg_nodes": 2177.0, "eval_calls": 15341, "avg_eval_calls": 1394.6363636363637, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 15341, "pattern_eval_ns": 334690, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.816700345479433, "pattern_frame_queries": 15341, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 334690, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.816700345479433, "pattern_frame_updates": 44972, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 482970227, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10739.35397580717, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6882, "avg_candidate_generations": 625.6363636363636, "candidate_moves_total": 542221, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.78828828828829, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 782, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 6871, "search_candidate_moves_total": 541439, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 247962, "avg_legality_checks": 22542.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 117, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 247962, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 117, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 725375, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 65943.18181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1585972029, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2186.416721006376, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2866, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 260.54545454545456, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13750413, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4797.771458478716, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1120382, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1021, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9092560, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1728, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3537471, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21447, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1949.7272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 207273572, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9664.455261808178, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 29998, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2727.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 97304012, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3243.6833122208145, "stage_move_gen_ns": 616518519, "stage_ordering_ns": 230152430, "stage_eval_ns": 483304917, "stage_threat_ns": 1151969854, "stage_proof_ns": 59899969, "tactical_annotations": 100109, "root_tactical_annotations": 321, "search_tactical_annotations": 99788, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 45405, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 290925701, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 107647, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 816591651, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14026, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 514021282, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 22697, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 34623784, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 422, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2177802, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 45394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5865557, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 21671, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 90317211, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 59088, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 201073394, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 19350, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1785359, "child_limit_applications": 6871, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6871, "child_cap_hits": 6871, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6871, "child_moves_before_total": 541322, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 541322, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 110012, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 110012, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.78358317566584, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.011060980934364, "tt_hits": 2230, "tt_cutoffs": 274, "beta_cutoffs": 5872, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5830.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6557.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1862, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1488, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28761, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 141, 93, 97, 83, 98, 84, 82, 114, 99, 86, 126, 85, 87, 100, 140, 154, 156, 171, 108, 109, 124, 92, 172 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 12086, "avg_search_time_ms": 929.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 151597, "safety_nodes": 842, "corridor_nodes": 413, "corridor_branch_probes": 457, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 88, "corridor_neutral_exits": 58, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 392, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 392, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 116, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 95, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 58, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 88, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 116, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 113, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 956, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26084640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 152852, "avg_nodes": 11757.846153846154, "eval_calls": 121245, "avg_eval_calls": 9326.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 121245, "pattern_eval_ns": 2609513, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.522644232751865, "pattern_frame_queries": 121245, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2609513, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.522644232751865, "pattern_frame_updates": 303080, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3439404268, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11348.17298403062, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29269, "avg_candidate_generations": 2251.4615384615386, "candidate_moves_total": 2232733, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.28320065598415, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 931, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 29256, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2231802, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 984278, "avg_legality_checks": 75713.69230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 370, "root_legality_checks": 931, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 983347, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 366, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3219780, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 247675.38461538462, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7076923749, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2197.952577194715, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15992, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1230.1538461538462, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65677803, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4106.916145572786, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 596, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4335593, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8499, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 50214624, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6784, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10242705, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 113, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 884881, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73130, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5625.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 563838076, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7710.078982633666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 90313, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6947.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 200856418, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2224.0033882165358, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2346616849, "stage_ordering_ns": 933836778, "stage_eval_ns": 3442013781, "stage_threat_ns": 5034863588, "stage_proof_ns": 275728104, "tactical_annotations": 371576, "root_tactical_annotations": 2228, "search_tactical_annotations": 369348, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 304109, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1742180698, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 387697, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3018756567, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59304, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2099747218, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 152048, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 220450604, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1016, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6362211, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 304096, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37517859, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 94984, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 89842060, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 200547, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 757155037, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76045, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9595649, "child_limit_applications": 29256, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29256, "child_cap_hits": 29256, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29256, "child_moves_before_total": 2231436, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2231436, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 468452, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 468452, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.27276456111566, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.012168444079848, "tt_hits": 10868, "tt_cutoffs": 1039, "beta_cutoffs": 21306, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3722.769230769231, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4338.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1019, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 16661, "avg_search_time_ms": 1388.4166666666667, "search_nodes": 121670, "safety_nodes": 424, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122094, "avg_nodes": 10174.5, "eval_calls": 71328, "avg_eval_calls": 5944.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71328, "pattern_eval_ns": 1591484, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.31219156572454, "pattern_frame_queries": 71328, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1591484, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.31219156572454, "pattern_frame_updates": 243198, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2395625172, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9850.513458169886, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46646, "avg_candidate_generations": 3887.1666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 3752293, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.44190284268747, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 844, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 46634, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3751449, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 2402260, "avg_legality_checks": 200188.33333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 523, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2402260, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 523, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4988359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 415696.5833333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11076257656, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2220.4211156414362, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16153, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1346.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51607442, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3194.913762149446, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 527, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5172836, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4406, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32174857, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11200, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14038828, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 220921, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 145817, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12151.416666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1186811525, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8139.047744775987, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 180711, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15059.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 425035982, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2352.0205300175417, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5891999779, "stage_ordering_ns": 1579211915, "stage_eval_ns": 2397216656, "stage_threat_ns": 6696597842, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 732926, "root_tactical_annotations": 3236, "search_tactical_annotations": 729690, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 243210, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1480496234, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 612359, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4970191347, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 93363, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3281847272, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121599, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 186920112, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 243198, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31601969, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 183360, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 491045049, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 335628, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1197244276, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 213938, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 27388180, "child_limit_applications": 46634, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46634, "child_cap_hits": 46634, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46634, "child_moves_before_total": 3750926, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3750926, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 438328, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 438328, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.43328901659733, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.399322382810825, "tt_hits": 25048, "tt_cutoffs": 3640, "beta_cutoffs": 37523, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 5.583333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 5.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1289.1666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1904.6666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1489, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 38653, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 83, 125, 126, 140, 115, 116, 99, 139, 153, 131, 129, 84, 101, 143, 100, 141, 142, 138, 137, 98, 110, 158, 87, 73, 103, 102, 51, 67, 94, 78, 159, 144, 130, 173, 188, 157, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 44, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 33465, "avg_search_time_ms": 1673.25, "search_nodes": 344884, "safety_nodes": 576, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 345460, "avg_nodes": 17273.0, "eval_calls": 227200, "avg_eval_calls": 11360.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 227200, "pattern_eval_ns": 4962018, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.839867957746478, "pattern_frame_queries": 227200, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4962018, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.839867957746478, "pattern_frame_updates": 689554, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8764640891, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12710.593936080422, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 109588, "avg_candidate_generations": 5479.4, "candidate_moves_total": 10435472, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.22458663357303, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1662, "root_candidate_moves_max": 120, "search_candidate_generations": 109568, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10433810, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 2360648, "avg_legality_checks": 118032.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10113, "root_legality_checks": 1662, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "search_legality_checks": 2358986, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10100, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8892575, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 444628.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18885102415, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2123.6933526003436, "renju_forbidden_checks": 77023, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3851.15, "renju_forbidden_ns": 499651518, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6487.043065058489, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11153, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 121129670, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 36782, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 267633539, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29009, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 110085234, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 79, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 803075, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 227267, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11363.35, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1979152144, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8708.488887519965, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 314294, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15714.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 877310456, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2791.3687693688075, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5667562432, "stage_ordering_ns": 3879207478, "stage_eval_ns": 8769602909, "stage_threat_ns": 15038510556, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2518778, "root_tactical_annotations": 6967, "search_tactical_annotations": 2511811, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 689574, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3951664376, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1860677, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10354810444, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 219283, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7050950499, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 344777, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 519314518, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 689554, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 86730704, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 731167, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 718819370, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 910213, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2585023875, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 877398, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 125990514, "child_limit_applications": 109568, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 109568, "child_cap_hits": 109568, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 109568, "child_moves_before_total": 10423710, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10423710, "child_moves_before_max": 135, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 135, "child_moves_after_total": 1279199, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1279199, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.13461959696262, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.67493246203271, "tt_hits": 66222, "tt_cutoffs": 8009, "beta_cutoffs": 89207, "depth_sum": 106, "avg_depth": 5.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 106, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3183.15, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3515.35, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 710, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 5165, "avg_search_time_ms": 258.25, "search_nodes": 48589, "safety_nodes": 2477, "corridor_nodes": 844, "corridor_branch_probes": 992, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 390, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 836, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 836, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 18, "corridor_proof_completed": 18, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 58, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 390, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 340, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 109200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 51910, "avg_nodes": 2595.5, "eval_calls": 33360, "avg_eval_calls": 1668.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33360, "pattern_eval_ns": 724674, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.722841726618704, "pattern_frame_queries": 33360, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 724674, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.722841726618704, "pattern_frame_updates": 96994, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 995616136, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10264.718807348909, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14264, "avg_candidate_generations": 713.2, "candidate_moves_total": 1185975, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.14462983735278, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1703, "root_candidate_moves_max": 121, "search_candidate_generations": 14244, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1184272, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 560145, "avg_legality_checks": 28007.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1631, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 560145, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1631, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1550855, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 77542.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3127983668, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2016.9414084488878, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10659, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 532.95, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62869766, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5898.279951214936, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1807, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15773182, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3968, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33046575, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4747, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12680353, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 137, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1369656, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47336, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2366.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 387434339, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8184.771400202805, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 64783, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3239.15, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 173314661, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2675.3108222836236, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1303746324, "stage_ordering_ns": 456895764, "stage_eval_ns": 996340810, "stage_threat_ns": 2259285330, "stage_proof_ns": 103420865, "tactical_annotations": 254033, "root_tactical_annotations": 706, "search_tactical_annotations": 253327, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 98818, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 584928307, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 291979, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1578547207, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29174, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 971338976, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 49399, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 71619624, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1804, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8816885, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 98798, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11981938, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70797, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 160656882, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 147114, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 421317061, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 36122, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3391369, "child_limit_applications": 14244, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14244, "child_cap_hits": 14244, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14244, "child_moves_before_total": 1182641, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1182641, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 229818, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 229818, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.0273097444538, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.13437236731255, "tt_hits": 4795, "tt_cutoffs": 893, "beta_cutoffs": 12100, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6651.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7051.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1866, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1490, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20005, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 125, 129, 127, 99, 98, 130, 140, 126, 155, 110, 141, 169, 142, 131, 132, 139, 157, 172, 109, 173, 93 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10591, "avg_search_time_ms": 882.5833333333334, "search_nodes": 134931, "safety_nodes": 155, "corridor_nodes": 1399, "corridor_branch_probes": 1496, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 538, "corridor_neutral_exits": 52, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1377, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1377, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 115, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 93, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 52, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 538, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 115, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 112, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 955, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26165920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 136485, "avg_nodes": 11373.75, "eval_calls": 104188, "avg_eval_calls": 8682.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 104188, "pattern_eval_ns": 2206719, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.180164702268975, "pattern_frame_queries": 104188, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2206719, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.180164702268975, "pattern_frame_updates": 269758, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2790238540, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10343.48764448135, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29285, "avg_candidate_generations": 2440.4166666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2099675, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.69796824312787, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 29273, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2098941, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 807250, "avg_legality_checks": 67270.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 278, "root_legality_checks": 734, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 806516, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 278, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3060434, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 255036.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6203417494, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2026.9731332222816, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17903, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1491.9166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33902980, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1893.7038485170083, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 459, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1100056, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 23036252, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9908, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9674332, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 106, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 92340, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 70677, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5889.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 497924401, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7045.06983884432, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 90386, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7532.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 188214080, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2082.33664505565, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1838597032, "stage_ordering_ns": 818028082, "stage_eval_ns": 2792445259, "stage_threat_ns": 4733800112, "stage_proof_ns": 363122841, "tactical_annotations": 400461, "root_tactical_annotations": 2581, "search_tactical_annotations": 397880, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 272754, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1485116170, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 451511, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2999170501, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59824, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2067299506, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 136371, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 188363817, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2984, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16243216, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 272742, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33249490, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 103545, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 88632644, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 200206, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 646841206, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 96710, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11656918, "child_limit_applications": 29273, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29273, "child_cap_hits": 29273, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29273, "child_moves_before_total": 2098663, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2098663, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 468588, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 468588, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.69278857650394, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.007515457930516, "tt_hits": 12229, "tt_cutoffs": 1418, "beta_cutoffs": 22444, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4146.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4813.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 984, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9405, "avg_search_time_ms": 855.0, "search_nodes": 80875, "safety_nodes": 810, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 81685, "avg_nodes": 7425.909090909091, "eval_calls": 49738, "avg_eval_calls": 4521.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49738, "pattern_eval_ns": 1105802, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.232538501749165, "pattern_frame_queries": 49738, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1105802, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.232538501749165, "pattern_frame_updates": 161624, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1496859436, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9261.368583873682, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29089, "avg_candidate_generations": 2644.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 2079628, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.49190415621025, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 668, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 29078, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2078960, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 1171286, "avg_legality_checks": 106480.54545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 45, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1171286, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 45, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2686308, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 244209.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6052488081, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2253.0879113638493, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7730, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 702.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10530800, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1362.3285899094437, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 55, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 130041, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1485, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 5761678, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6190, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4639081, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59049, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5368.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 490949006, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8314.264526071567, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 77250, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7022.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 191130304, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2474.1786925566344, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2936481063, "stage_ordering_ns": 913539769, "stage_eval_ns": 1497965238, "stage_threat_ns": 4001198510, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 340207, "root_tactical_annotations": 1159, "search_tactical_annotations": 339048, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 161635, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 962414805, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 305660, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2885221898, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58241, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2128776745, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 80812, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121323612, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 161624, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20565924, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 61081, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 162247259, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 186330, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 594026293, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 92796, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11672271, "child_limit_applications": 29078, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29078, "child_cap_hits": 29078, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29078, "child_moves_before_total": 2078915, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2078915, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 254931, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 254931, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.49442877777014, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.767143544948071, "tt_hits": 13108, "tt_cutoffs": 1996, "beta_cutoffs": 22380, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3241.5454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3968.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 341, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1491, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26512, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 129, 171, 141, 143, 157, 172, 173, 125, 83, 139, 144, 167, 153, 155, 189, 205, 159, 174, 187, 123, 107, 124, 122, 145, 128, 160, 114, 99, 100, 156, 86 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 19033, "avg_search_time_ms": 1119.5882352941176, "search_nodes": 248325, "safety_nodes": 999, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 249324, "avg_nodes": 14666.117647058823, "eval_calls": 158179, "avg_eval_calls": 9304.64705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 158179, "pattern_eval_ns": 3238571, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.474089480904546, "pattern_frame_queries": 158179, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3238571, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.474089480904546, "pattern_frame_updates": 496472, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4548980128, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9162.611643758359, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 84121, "avg_candidate_generations": 4948.294117647059, "candidate_moves_total": 6901922, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.04755055218078, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1356, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 84104, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6900566, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 2054921, "avg_legality_checks": 120877.70588235294, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3187, "root_legality_checks": 1356, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 2053565, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3183, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6607945, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 388702.64705882355, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10919617293, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1652.4982113198582, "renju_forbidden_checks": 49213, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2894.8823529411766, "renju_forbidden_ns": 234878927, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4772.700851401052, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3572, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 32520129, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23679, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 151630970, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21940, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 50504017, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 223811, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 130564, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7680.235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 961071932, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7360.925921387213, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 177138, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10419.882352941177, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 438007649, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2472.691624609062, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3752274914, "stage_ordering_ns": 2086911816, "stage_eval_ns": 4552218699, "stage_threat_ns": 8531365731, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1204245, "root_tactical_annotations": 3586, "search_tactical_annotations": 1200659, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 496489, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2190830127, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1004642, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5944211703, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 168330, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4290519305, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 248236, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 296695344, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 496472, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49850960, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 249156, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 237872298, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 587142, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1415335757, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 367947, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 49777597, "child_limit_applications": 84104, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 84104, "child_cap_hits": 84104, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 84104, "child_moves_before_total": 6897383, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6897383, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 770150, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 770150, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.01016598497098, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.157115000475601, "tt_hits": 42277, "tt_cutoffs": 5954, "beta_cutoffs": 65614, "depth_sum": 88, "avg_depth": 5.176470588235294, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 88, "avg_effective_depth": 5.176470588235294, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4078.235294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4548.823529411765, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 607, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 7462, "avg_search_time_ms": 466.375, "search_nodes": 81244, "safety_nodes": 1426, "corridor_nodes": 511, "corridor_branch_probes": 554, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 159, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 496, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 496, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 99, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 84, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 159, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 99, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 99, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 715, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 468080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 16800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 83181, "avg_nodes": 5198.8125, "eval_calls": 54422, "avg_eval_calls": 3401.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 54422, "pattern_eval_ns": 1110185, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.399562676858622, "pattern_frame_queries": 54422, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1110185, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.399562676858622, "pattern_frame_updates": 162338, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1111511034, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6846.893727901046, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25235, "avg_candidate_generations": 1577.1875, "candidate_moves_total": 2083914, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.58030513176145, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1276, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 25219, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2082638, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1301239, "avg_legality_checks": 81327.4375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 787, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1301239, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 787, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2831740, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 176983.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4733095285, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1671.4441597745556, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14930, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 933.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 53223156, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3564.846349631614, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 855, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8904718, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2935, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26217041, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11098, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17613512, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 487885, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72800, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4550.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 554782407, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7620.637458791209, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97606, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6100.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 259390828, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2657.52953711862, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2440970791, "stage_ordering_ns": 650072084, "stage_eval_ns": 1112621219, "stage_threat_ns": 3052122742, "stage_proof_ns": 136406515, "tactical_annotations": 375252, "root_tactical_annotations": 1771, "search_tactical_annotations": 373481, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 163544, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 735699265, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 382843, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2187706141, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1394107081, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 81764, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96022236, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1190, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7541676, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 163528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16089086, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 109967, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 220873858, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 186818, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 549813833, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78467, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9064338, "child_limit_applications": 25219, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25219, "child_cap_hits": 25219, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25219, "child_moves_before_total": 2081851, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2081851, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 403958, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 403958, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.55089416709623, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.018002299853286, "tt_hits": 9828, "tt_cutoffs": 1528, "beta_cutoffs": 21701, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6367.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6867.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1785, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1492, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17038, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 143, 127, 141, 144, 128, 114, 140, 139, 129, 115, 156, 130, 170, 184, 188, 116, 117, 102, 158, 88 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9094, "avg_search_time_ms": 909.4, "search_nodes": 122791, "safety_nodes": 174, "corridor_nodes": 1058, "corridor_branch_probes": 1178, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 426, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1038, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1038, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 128, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 108, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 426, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 128, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 128, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1088, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24332800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1985040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 124023, "avg_nodes": 12402.3, "eval_calls": 93481, "avg_eval_calls": 9348.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 93481, "pattern_eval_ns": 1952749, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.8892609193312, "pattern_frame_queries": 93481, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1952749, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.8892609193312, "pattern_frame_updates": 245492, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2295840939, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9351.999002004139, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27522, "avg_candidate_generations": 2752.2, "candidate_moves_total": 1885730, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.5171862509992, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 586, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 27512, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1885144, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 787713, "avg_legality_checks": 78771.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 141, "root_legality_checks": 586, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 787127, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 141, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2767630, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 276763.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5259834858, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1900.483394817949, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11111, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1111.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 48486373, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4363.817208172081, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 157, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1425113, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4531, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33439901, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6199, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12606096, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 224, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1015263, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53563, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5356.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 379596917, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7086.924126729272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 71956, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7195.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 158436225, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2201.84869920507, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1602773976, "stage_ordering_ns": 722965776, "stage_eval_ns": 2297793688, "stage_threat_ns": 4128706793, "stage_proof_ns": 292138785, "tactical_annotations": 335889, "root_tactical_annotations": 2066, "search_tactical_annotations": 333823, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 247834, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1258180451, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 374496, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2658605524, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56107, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1932579953, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123912, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 158149796, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2332, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15081177, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 247824, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28933935, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 73751, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 61516987, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 180538, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 533738811, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 81600, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9755910, "child_limit_applications": 27512, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27512, "child_cap_hits": 27512, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27512, "child_moves_before_total": 1885003, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1885003, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 440274, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 440274, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.51566589124745, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002980517592324, "tt_hits": 10654, "tt_cutoffs": 1753, "beta_cutoffs": 21396, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3725.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4525.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 203, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7935, "avg_search_time_ms": 793.5, "search_nodes": 77349, "safety_nodes": 610, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 77959, "avg_nodes": 7795.9, "eval_calls": 44796, "avg_eval_calls": 4479.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44796, "pattern_eval_ns": 926924, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.69211536744352, "pattern_frame_queries": 44796, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 926924, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.69211536744352, "pattern_frame_updates": 154588, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1064648356, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6887.005175045929, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29959, "avg_candidate_generations": 2995.9, "candidate_moves_total": 2164736, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.25661737708201, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 609, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 29949, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2164127, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1503612, "avg_legality_checks": 150361.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 75, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1503612, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3079051, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 307905.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5194415458, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1687.0183241524742, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13089, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1308.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12738238, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 973.201772480709, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 85, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 788894, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 993, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7168015, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12006, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4723009, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 58320, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67299, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6729.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 455638162, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6770.35560706697, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 91481, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9148.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 204188433, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2232.031055629038, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2834406355, "stage_ordering_ns": 726073907, "stage_eval_ns": 1065575280, "stage_threat_ns": 3242335883, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 405299, "root_tactical_annotations": 1404, "search_tactical_annotations": 403895, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 154598, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 723840857, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 335466, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2391316033, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59972, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1694602452, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77294, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94597618, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 154588, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16384957, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 69619, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 123324922, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 205868, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 573308629, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 129812, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16196418, "child_limit_applications": 29949, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29949, "child_cap_hits": 29949, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29949, "child_moves_before_total": 2164052, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2164052, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 254604, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 254604, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.25790510534576, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.50125212861865, "tt_hits": 15593, "tt_cutoffs": 2549, "beta_cutoffs": 23849, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4356.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5156.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 828, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1493, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26055, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 96, 128, 68, 110, 97, 127, 67, 52, 66, 65, 54, 40, 69, 70, 84, 99, 85, 83, 95, 143, 113, 159, 175, 129, 39, 24, 53, 81, 101, 37, 117 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 17558, "avg_search_time_ms": 1097.375, "search_nodes": 176499, "safety_nodes": 775, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 177274, "avg_nodes": 11079.625, "eval_calls": 111204, "avg_eval_calls": 6950.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 111204, "pattern_eval_ns": 2446817, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.0029585266717, "pattern_frame_queries": 111204, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2446817, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.0029585266717, "pattern_frame_updates": 352846, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4415361486, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12513.565368461028, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 60968, "avg_candidate_generations": 3810.5, "candidate_moves_total": 4608955, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.59629641779294, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1132, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 60952, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4607823, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1302165, "avg_legality_checks": 81385.3125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1152, "root_legality_checks": 1132, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1301033, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1149, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4645697, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 290356.0625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10313957297, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2220.1097697503733, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38750, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2421.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 169715358, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4379.751174193549, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1883, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12659086, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17857, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 108695521, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18989, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 48191781, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 168970, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 84438, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5277.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 700753102, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8299.025344039414, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109328, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6833.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 278553917, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2547.8735273671887, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3203845552, "stage_ordering_ns": 1780834340, "stage_eval_ns": 4417808303, "stage_threat_ns": 8091798010, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1098170, "root_tactical_annotations": 3214, "search_tactical_annotations": 1094956, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 352862, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2138203049, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 827075, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5577869522, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 122011, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4180862203, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 176423, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 272368806, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 352846, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46529728, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 216851, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 119658432, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 488200, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1277030135, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 393119, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 56826905, "child_limit_applications": 60952, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 60952, "child_cap_hits": 60952, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 60952, "child_moves_before_total": 4606674, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4606674, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 659257, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 659257, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.5787176794855, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.816002756267226, "tt_hits": 33247, "tt_cutoffs": 4268, "beta_cutoffs": 46769, "depth_sum": 74, "avg_depth": 4.625, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 74, "avg_effective_depth": 4.625, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3356.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3856.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 8483, "avg_search_time_ms": 565.5333333333333, "search_nodes": 65422, "safety_nodes": 1081, "corridor_nodes": 1228, "corridor_branch_probes": 1359, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 570, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1215, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1215, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 570, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 63, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 430, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 280080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67731, "avg_nodes": 4515.4, "eval_calls": 43600, "avg_eval_calls": 2906.6666666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 43600, "pattern_eval_ns": 965511, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.144747706422017, "pattern_frame_queries": 43600, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 965511, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.144747706422017, "pattern_frame_updates": 130704, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1324260537, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10131.752180499449, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20169, "avg_candidate_generations": 1344.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1583424, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.50780901383311, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1059, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 20154, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1582365, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 1147204, "avg_legality_checks": 76480.26666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5191, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1147204, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5191, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2648281, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 176552.06666666668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5480289894, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2069.3762837100744, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29070, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1938.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 111535795, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3836.800653594771, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 50583073, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3617, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28110832, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20125, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31627923, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 111, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1213967, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 103712, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6914.133333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 991529450, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9560.412006325208, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 143905, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9593.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 467035859, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3245.445669017755, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2750090745, "stage_ordering_ns": 608017934, "stage_eval_ns": 1325226048, "stage_threat_ns": 3641751477, "stage_proof_ns": 97546372, "tactical_annotations": 434305, "root_tactical_annotations": 1486, "search_tactical_annotations": 432819, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 133275, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 828365373, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 456316, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2666748252, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41178, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1333397377, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 100980162, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2556, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18290745, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 133260, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16929314, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 157951, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 476610716, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 193778, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 806885202, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 82576, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10437631, "child_limit_applications": 20154, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20154, "child_cap_hits": 20154, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20154, "child_moves_before_total": 1577174, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1577174, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 322780, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 322780, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.2561278158182, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.015679269623895, "tt_hits": 7988, "tt_cutoffs": 1599, "beta_cutoffs": 17340, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6019.933333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6553.266666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1494, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17601, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 127, 97, 96, 125, 83, 100, 81, 80, 99, 139, 153, 110, 85, 84, 113, 71, 141 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6475, "avg_search_time_ms": 719.4444444444445, "search_nodes": 65939, "safety_nodes": 535, "corridor_nodes": 962, "corridor_branch_probes": 1165, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 315, "corridor_neutral_exits": 39, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 945, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 945, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 52, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 35, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 39, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 315, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 52, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 413, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 241600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 67436, "avg_nodes": 7492.888888888889, "eval_calls": 47926, "avg_eval_calls": 5325.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47926, "pattern_eval_ns": 1043283, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.768622459625256, "pattern_frame_queries": 47926, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1043283, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.768622459625256, "pattern_frame_updates": 131804, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1356946946, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10295.187900215471, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16934, "avg_candidate_generations": 1881.5555555555557, "candidate_moves_total": 1119529, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.11131451517657, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 549, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 16925, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1118980, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 513447, "avg_legality_checks": 57049.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 939, "root_legality_checks": 549, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 512898, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 938, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1761478, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 195719.77777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3969792926, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2253.6715905620167, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10781, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1197.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 52940584, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4910.5448474167515, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 985, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11167937, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3254, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27050612, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6485, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14060080, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 661955, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47249, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5249.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 456044452, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9651.938707697518, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 67845, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7538.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 204946992, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3020.812027415432, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1324568973, "stage_ordering_ns": 499947168, "stage_eval_ns": 1357990229, "stage_threat_ns": 3029821140, "stage_proof_ns": 229506841, "tactical_annotations": 152662, "root_tactical_annotations": 1057, "search_tactical_annotations": 151605, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 133807, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 812198273, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 230286, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2086942334, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34574, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1336737258, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66899, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99326551, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1994, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11623316, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 133798, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16922331, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32326, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 83274220, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 95988, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 500954320, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 24348, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2808335, "child_limit_applications": 16925, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16925, "child_cap_hits": 16925, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16925, "child_moves_before_total": 1118042, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1118042, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 270802, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 270802, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 66.05861152141802, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000118168389957, "tt_hits": 5524, "tt_cutoffs": 1052, "beta_cutoffs": 13906, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3481.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4370.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 11118, "avg_search_time_ms": 1389.75, "search_nodes": 76316, "safety_nodes": 350, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76666, "avg_nodes": 9583.25, "eval_calls": 47376, "avg_eval_calls": 5922.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47376, "pattern_eval_ns": 1055846, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.286516379601487, "pattern_frame_queries": 47376, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1055846, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.286516379601487, "pattern_frame_updates": 152550, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1726759880, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11319.304359226484, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27099, "avg_candidate_generations": 3387.375, "candidate_moves_total": 2031027, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.94841138049375, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 479, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 27091, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2030548, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1465622, "avg_legality_checks": 183202.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6053, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1465622, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6053, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3402716, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 425339.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7400603620, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2174.910753645029, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29722, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3715.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 154274517, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5190.5833052957405, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6061, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 69987633, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5921, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 52567851, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17735, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31657123, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61910, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 123360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15420.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1282816805, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10398.968912127108, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 181064, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22633.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 634071932, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3501.921596783458, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3735865692, "stage_ordering_ns": 880458516, "stage_eval_ns": 1727815726, "stage_threat_ns": 4717114034, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 450507, "root_tactical_annotations": 1492, "search_tactical_annotations": 449015, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152558, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 942000608, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 369214, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3617275376, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54239, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1994157672, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76275, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 119837784, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152550, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20031073, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 92742, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 478258087, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 222227, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1144780127, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 135538, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17969193, "child_limit_applications": 27091, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27091, "child_cap_hits": 27091, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27091, "child_moves_before_total": 2024495, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2024495, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 264099, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 264099, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.72943043815289, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.748588091986269, "tt_hits": 13275, "tt_cutoffs": 1809, "beta_cutoffs": 21069, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1813.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2427.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 916, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1495, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25061, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 126, 114, 110, 158, 94, 78, 125, 129, 99, 82, 66, 130, 146, 70, 56, 144, 124, 127, 122, 123, 80, 108, 95, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 17488, "avg_search_time_ms": 1345.2307692307693, "search_nodes": 147337, "safety_nodes": 787, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148124, "avg_nodes": 11394.153846153846, "eval_calls": 85335, "avg_eval_calls": 6564.2307692307695, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 85335, "pattern_eval_ns": 1809978, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.21026542450343, "pattern_frame_queries": 85335, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1809978, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.21026542450343, "pattern_frame_updates": 294522, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4181553789, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14197.763796931979, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 56712, "avg_candidate_generations": 4362.461538461538, "candidate_moves_total": 5299866, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.45228523063902, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1110, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 56699, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5298756, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 1265075, "avg_legality_checks": 97313.46153846153, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1198, "root_legality_checks": 1110, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1263965, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1198, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4582131, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 352471.6153846154, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10236051067, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2233.9062473333915, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58723, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4517.153846153846, "renju_forbidden_ns": 438160749, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7461.4844098564445, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12302933, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29204, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 274555224, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28184, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 151302592, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 110697, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8515.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1088059885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9829.172290125298, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 155117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11932.076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 517081605, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3333.4941044501893, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3093074664, "stage_ordering_ns": 2031845348, "stage_eval_ns": 4183363767, "stage_threat_ns": 8133054172, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1139727, "root_tactical_annotations": 3208, "search_tactical_annotations": 1136519, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 294535, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1787950185, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 766181, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6019050048, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 113500, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4302055552, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147261, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 224031356, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 294522, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37334532, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 212051, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 342361449, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 440622, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1374336595, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 487054, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 64688051, "child_limit_applications": 56699, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 56699, "child_cap_hits": 56699, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 56699, "child_moves_before_total": 5297558, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5297558, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 678166, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 678166, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.43300587311946, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.960810596306812, "tt_hits": 36940, "tt_cutoffs": 5228, "beta_cutoffs": 48139, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 5.769230769230769, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 5.769230769230769, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2385.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3000.3846153846152, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7559, "avg_search_time_ms": 581.4615384615385, "search_nodes": 51922, "safety_nodes": 1563, "corridor_nodes": 921, "corridor_branch_probes": 1037, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 394, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 900, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 900, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 394, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 441, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 282560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 54406, "avg_nodes": 4185.076923076923, "eval_calls": 34869, "avg_eval_calls": 2682.230769230769, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34869, "pattern_eval_ns": 741402, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.262496773638475, "pattern_frame_queries": 34869, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 741402, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.262496773638475, "pattern_frame_updates": 103730, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1102889331, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10632.308213631544, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15943, "avg_candidate_generations": 1226.3846153846155, "candidate_moves_total": 1432082, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.82512701499091, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1138, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 15930, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1430944, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1034285, "avg_legality_checks": 79560.38461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 106, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1034285, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 106, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2408979, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 185306.07692307694, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5094253980, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2114.6942252298586, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7169, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 551.4615384615385, "renju_forbidden_ns": 26201035, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3654.768447482215, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 106, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 816373, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2002, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18105944, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5061, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7278718, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99907, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7685.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1056589394, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10575.72936831253, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 148369, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11413.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 532422499, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3588.5023084337026, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2505176461, "stage_ordering_ns": 579998111, "stage_eval_ns": 1103630733, "stage_threat_ns": 3215517463, "stage_proof_ns": 105909316, "tactical_annotations": 281196, "root_tactical_annotations": 1136, "search_tactical_annotations": 280060, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 105671, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 637289542, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 315979, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2469104531, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32579, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1147912084, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52829, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 79137730, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1928, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10597085, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 105658, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12797745, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 81104, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 524880687, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 147821, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 755588460, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 52271, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6590830, "child_limit_applications": 15930, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15930, "child_cap_hits": 15930, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15930, "child_moves_before_total": 1430838, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1430838, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 255314, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 255314, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.82033898305085, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02724419334589, "tt_hits": 6316, "tt_cutoffs": 1066, "beta_cutoffs": 13668, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4966.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5581.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1803, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1496, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14255, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 114, 126, 113, 111, 82, 66, 97, 127, 115, 116, 130, 146, 67, 52, 129, 125, 124, 81, 145, 96 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9003, "avg_search_time_ms": 900.3, "search_nodes": 79960, "safety_nodes": 597, "corridor_nodes": 4228, "corridor_branch_probes": 5080, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1816, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 74, "corridor_plies_followed": 4192, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4192, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 86, "corridor_proof_active": 36, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1816, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 74, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 86, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 622, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 51925680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2005840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 84785, "avg_nodes": 8478.5, "eval_calls": 61875, "avg_eval_calls": 6187.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 61875, "pattern_eval_ns": 1274467, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.597446464646463, "pattern_frame_queries": 61875, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1274467, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.597446464646463, "pattern_frame_updates": 159828, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2319780782, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14514.232687639213, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17033, "avg_candidate_generations": 1703.3, "candidate_moves_total": 1162919, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.27446721070862, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 630, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 17023, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1162289, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 515246, "avg_legality_checks": 51524.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2376, "root_legality_checks": 630, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 514616, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2368, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2537305, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 253730.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5532454533, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2180.445209779668, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30203, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3020.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 270602019, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8959.441744197597, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2870, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 36935173, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14147, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 148322164, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10597, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 61620378, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2589, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 23724304, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 70136, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7013.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 708591773, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10103.110713470971, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98423, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9842.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 339143223, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3445.7720553122745, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1319801203, "stage_ordering_ns": 498975157, "stage_eval_ns": 2321055249, "stage_threat_ns": 4227956996, "stage_proof_ns": 612401493, "tactical_annotations": 257399, "root_tactical_annotations": 1277, "search_tactical_annotations": 256122, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 168394, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1059438201, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 485629, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2963485248, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36284, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1523359546, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84192, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 128339737, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8556, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 49633161, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 168384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21243666, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 60829, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 103702083, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 145840, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 689798926, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 50730, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5816983, "child_limit_applications": 17023, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17023, "child_cap_hits": 17023, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17023, "child_moves_before_total": 1159921, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1159921, "child_moves_before_max": 96, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 96, "child_moves_after_total": 274682, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 274682, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.13845973095223, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.13593373670916, "tt_hits": 6425, "tt_cutoffs": 1016, "beta_cutoffs": 12983, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3065.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3865.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 290, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5241, "avg_search_time_ms": 524.1, "search_nodes": 37940, "safety_nodes": 905, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 38845, "avg_nodes": 3884.5, "eval_calls": 22745, "avg_eval_calls": 2274.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22745, "pattern_eval_ns": 483560, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.260057155418774, "pattern_frame_queries": 22745, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 483560, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.260057155418774, "pattern_frame_updates": 75780, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1011569153, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13348.761586170494, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13838, "avg_candidate_generations": 1383.8, "candidate_moves_total": 983539, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.07522763405116, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 644, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 13828, "search_candidate_moves_total": 982895, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 529927, "avg_legality_checks": 52992.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2633, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 529927, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2633, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1531781, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 153178.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3267279529, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2132.9938999112796, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22236, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2223.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 195698848, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8800.99154524195, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3401, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 47714660, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7583, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 87984988, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11188, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 59082705, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 64, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 916495, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58050, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5805.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 609959707, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10507.488492678725, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 82235, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8223.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 293249480, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3565.9935550556334, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1340545191, "stage_ordering_ns": 406420727, "stage_eval_ns": 1012052713, "stage_threat_ns": 2454021287, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 269392, "root_tactical_annotations": 367, "search_tactical_annotations": 269025, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 75790, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 468556466, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 236057, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1911902156, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27725, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1057930354, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37890, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 58090801, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 75780, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9649013, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 34966, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 119646235, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 173360, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 734074966, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 61066, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5822851, "child_limit_applications": 13828, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13828, "child_cap_hits": 13828, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13828, "child_moves_before_total": 980262, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 980262, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 169587, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 169587, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.88964420017356, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.264029505351461, "tt_hits": 6062, "tt_cutoffs": 1318, "beta_cutoffs": 11464, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.9, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.9, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4518.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5318.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1497, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 31201, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 142, 125, 95, 97, 114, 156, 111, 127, 113, 115, 98, 124, 123, 143, 82, 66, 109, 81, 144, 160, 129, 159, 68, 83, 100, 86, 84, 99, 116, 52, 132 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 24375, "avg_search_time_ms": 1433.8235294117646, "search_nodes": 247853, "safety_nodes": 440, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 248293, "avg_nodes": 14605.470588235294, "eval_calls": 159968, "avg_eval_calls": 9409.882352941177, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 159968, "pattern_eval_ns": 3324561, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.78266278255651, "pattern_frame_queries": 159968, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3324561, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.78266278255651, "pattern_frame_updates": 495544, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6373050828, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12860.716360202121, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 82292, "avg_candidate_generations": 4840.705882352941, "candidate_moves_total": 6870760, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.49244154960385, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1204, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 82275, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6869556, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1728901, "avg_legality_checks": 101700.05882352941, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1183, "root_legality_checks": 1204, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1727697, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1183, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6564326, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 386136.82352941175, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14155712489, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2156.4609205880392, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39493, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2323.1176470588234, "renju_forbidden_ns": 151806544, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3843.884840351455, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1527, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10615680, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20546, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 101740761, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17420, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39450103, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 152608, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8976.941176470587, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1134038224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7431.053575172992, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 184020, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10824.70588235294, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 374231174, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2033.6440278230627, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4142966695, "stage_ordering_ns": 2696741388, "stage_eval_ns": 6376375389, "stage_threat_ns": 11100148560, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1900301, "root_tactical_annotations": 4832, "search_tactical_annotations": 1895469, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 495561, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2857999957, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1473967, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7727626775, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 164664, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5513041214, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 247772, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 375848536, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 495544, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61184620, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 531060, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 356103681, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 778228, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1858255328, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 591013, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 77488672, "child_limit_applications": 82275, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 82275, "child_cap_hits": 82275, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 82275, "child_moves_before_total": 6868373, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6868373, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 875111, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 875111, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.4806806441811, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.636414463688848, "tt_hits": 44003, "tt_cutoffs": 5530, "beta_cutoffs": 64670, "depth_sum": 79, "avg_depth": 4.647058823529412, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 79, "avg_effective_depth": 4.647058823529412, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.29411764705882354, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2534.3529411764707, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3004.9411764705883, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 489, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 6812, "avg_search_time_ms": 425.75, "search_nodes": 57313, "safety_nodes": 1421, "corridor_nodes": 64, "corridor_branch_probes": 69, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 12, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 59, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 59, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 63, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 68, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 440, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 198880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 15440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 58798, "avg_nodes": 3674.875, "eval_calls": 38136, "avg_eval_calls": 2383.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38136, "pattern_eval_ns": 799032, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.952171176840782, "pattern_frame_queries": 38136, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 799032, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.952171176840782, "pattern_frame_updates": 114476, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1180975664, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10316.360320067088, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18001, "avg_candidate_generations": 1125.0625, "candidate_moves_total": 1387490, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.07849563913116, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1130, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 17985, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1386360, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 759845, "avg_legality_checks": 47490.3125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1961, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 759845, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1961, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2015406, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 125962.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4320366413, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2143.67051254189, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10740, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 671.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 63192653, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5883.859683426444, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1963, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21733929, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3012, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29222910, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5728, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11768582, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 467232, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74040, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4627.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 683167465, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9227.00519989195, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97221, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6076.3125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 297583816, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3060.9005873216693, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1878629758, "stage_ordering_ns": 572642053, "stage_eval_ns": 1181774696, "stage_threat_ns": 3018814436, "stage_proof_ns": 119135592, "tactical_annotations": 328135, "root_tactical_annotations": 966, "search_tactical_annotations": 327169, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 114746, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 688026547, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 313216, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2221045819, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36388, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1289197376, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57365, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87405657, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 254, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1364601, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 114730, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14144650, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 100002, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 349571646, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171311, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 578388221, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 56822, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6827162, "child_limit_applications": 17985, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17985, "child_cap_hits": 17985, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17985, "child_moves_before_total": 1384399, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1384399, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 288292, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 288292, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.97520155685294, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.029580205726994, "tt_hits": 6269, "tt_cutoffs": 1117, "beta_cutoffs": 15492, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5912.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6412.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1721, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1498, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24055, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 142, 96, 114, 156, 127, 157, 113, 115, 98, 141, 111, 171, 186, 143, 129, 82, 68, 83, 99, 124, 138, 185, 199, 84, 85, 71, 100, 86, 101, 102, 97 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 11503, "avg_search_time_ms": 718.9375, "search_nodes": 100497, "safety_nodes": 796, "corridor_nodes": 5588, "corridor_branch_probes": 6344, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 2687, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 107, "corridor_plies_followed": 5549, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5549, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 39, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2687, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 107, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 7, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 76, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 590, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 22319840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2015040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 10, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 106881, "avg_nodes": 6680.0625, "eval_calls": 71483, "avg_eval_calls": 4467.6875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71483, "pattern_eval_ns": 1476999, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.66224137207448, "pattern_frame_queries": 71483, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1476999, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.66224137207448, "pattern_frame_updates": 200850, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2586442848, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12877.48492905153, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27187, "avg_candidate_generations": 1699.1875, "candidate_moves_total": 2145667, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.92253650641851, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1182, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 27171, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2144485, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 743805, "avg_legality_checks": 46487.8125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1357, "root_legality_checks": 1182, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 742623, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1357, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3348822, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 209301.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7035468542, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2100.878620004288, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32378, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2023.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 161409423, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4985.157298165421, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1478, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13723011, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12104, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 95925412, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16762, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42118131, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2034, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9642869, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 104496, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6531.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 909839198, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8706.928475731129, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 142348, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8896.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 392247952, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2755.5564672492765, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1789235117, "stage_ordering_ns": 855984199, "stage_eval_ns": 2587919847, "stage_threat_ns": 5586601956, "stage_proof_ns": 643108978, "tactical_annotations": 536081, "root_tactical_annotations": 2449, "search_tactical_annotations": 533632, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 212130, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1325842241, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 743780, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3987267055, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 57263, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2162124399, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 106057, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159384460, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 11264, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 71301099, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 212114, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26653361, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 157288, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 200311820, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 248702, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 938402627, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 130091, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16153740, "child_limit_applications": 27171, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27171, "child_cap_hits": 27171, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27171, "child_moves_before_total": 2143128, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2143128, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 447119, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 447119, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.87556586066026, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.45574325567701, "tt_hits": 12250, "tt_cutoffs": 1771, "beta_cutoffs": 22542, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5358.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5858.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 333, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 12536, "avg_search_time_ms": 835.7333333333333, "search_nodes": 87063, "safety_nodes": 1592, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 88655, "avg_nodes": 5910.333333333333, "eval_calls": 50076, "avg_eval_calls": 3338.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50076, "pattern_eval_ns": 1061465, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.197080437734645, "pattern_frame_queries": 50076, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1061465, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.197080437734645, "pattern_frame_updates": 173944, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1964510637, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11293.925843949777, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33325, "avg_candidate_generations": 2221.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2667226, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.03678919729933, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1104, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 33310, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2666122, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1665265, "avg_legality_checks": 111017.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5322, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1665265, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5322, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4030967, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 268731.13333333336, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8175316104, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2028.1277678532224, "renju_forbidden_checks": 52199, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3479.9333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 146666975, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2809.7659916856646, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5380, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 37030988, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8081, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57881234, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 38738, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 51754753, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 178426, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11895.066666666668, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1529783920, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8573.77243226884, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 247053, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16470.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 639018487, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2586.564368779169, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3884151542, "stage_ordering_ns": 1053050405, "stage_eval_ns": 1965572102, "stage_threat_ns": 5561232348, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 760795, "root_tactical_annotations": 1006, "search_tactical_annotations": 759789, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 173959, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1028559468, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 617789, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4354197699, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 66741, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2257502302, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86972, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 130248326, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 173944, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22063205, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 154836, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 552871873, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 396201, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1543389872, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 209758, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26163650, "child_limit_applications": 33310, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33310, "child_cap_hits": 33310, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33310, "child_moves_before_total": 2660800, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2660800, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 430784, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 430784, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.87991594115881, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.932572800960672, "tt_hits": 17268, "tt_cutoffs": 3587, "beta_cutoffs": 28678, "depth_sum": 90, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 90, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5446.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5979.733333333334, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1499, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21247, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 85, 68, 111, 109, 142, 94, 113, 114, 99, 127, 158, 174, 143, 128, 140, 154, 141, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 16065, "avg_search_time_ms": 1338.75, "search_nodes": 145085, "safety_nodes": 192, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 145277, "avg_nodes": 12106.416666666666, "eval_calls": 84751, "avg_eval_calls": 7062.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84751, "pattern_eval_ns": 1904798, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.475227430944766, "pattern_frame_queries": 84751, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1904798, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.475227430944766, "pattern_frame_updates": 290042, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3506638059, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12090.104395225519, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 56320, "avg_candidate_generations": 4693.333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4753655, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.4043856534091, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 825, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 56308, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4752830, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1148978, "avg_legality_checks": 95748.16666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1672, "root_legality_checks": 825, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1148153, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1671, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4117720, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 343143.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9450617751, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2295.109369019749, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29382, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2448.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 190577000, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6486.182016200395, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1839, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20009116, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12940, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 114993756, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14598, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 55509777, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 64351, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 94700, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7891.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 841096436, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8881.694149947201, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 124134, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10344.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 338907146, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2730.171798218055, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2905358421, "stage_ordering_ns": 1935736215, "stage_eval_ns": 3508542857, "stage_threat_ns": 7658124474, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 976898, "root_tactical_annotations": 3719, "search_tactical_annotations": 973179, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 290054, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1764854325, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 726609, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5583928641, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 112703, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4228580845, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 145021, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 222554824, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 290042, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37770515, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 263864, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 278412055, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 350031, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1076791450, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 363003, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 49016169, "child_limit_applications": 56308, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 56308, "child_cap_hits": 56308, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 56308, "child_moves_before_total": 4751159, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4751159, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 638332, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 638332, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.37804574838388, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.336435320025574, "tt_hits": 35240, "tt_cutoffs": 3962, "beta_cutoffs": 46975, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2052.4166666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2718.0833333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 564, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5169, "avg_search_time_ms": 469.90909090909093, "search_nodes": 49092, "safety_nodes": 887, "corridor_nodes": 1200, "corridor_branch_probes": 1280, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 8, "corridor_depth_exits": 600, "corridor_neutral_exits": 17, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1185, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1185, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 600, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 55, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 341, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 261360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 51179, "avg_nodes": 4652.636363636364, "eval_calls": 35211, "avg_eval_calls": 3201.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35211, "pattern_eval_ns": 779085, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.12618215898441, "pattern_frame_queries": 35211, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 779085, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.12618215898441, "pattern_frame_updates": 98084, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 823108897, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8391.877339831166, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13331, "avg_candidate_generations": 1211.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 1031986, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.41249718700773, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 760, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 13320, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1031226, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 532903, "avg_legality_checks": 48445.72727272727, "illegal_moves_skipped": 133, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 532903, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 133, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1413147, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 128467.90909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3156208664, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2233.460966198138, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3661, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 332.8181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 11528667, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3149.0486205954658, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 135, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1468845, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 788, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6343264, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2731, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3628238, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 88320, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46452, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4222.909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 457960790, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9858.795961422544, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 62981, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5725.545454545455, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 206876672, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3284.747336498309, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1360374555, "stage_ordering_ns": 443934000, "stage_eval_ns": 823887982, "stage_threat_ns": 2415874597, "stage_proof_ns": 88614758, "tactical_annotations": 192037, "root_tactical_annotations": 686, "search_tactical_annotations": 191351, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 100575, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 620757231, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 242742, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1687119276, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27417, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1027505903, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50282, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 75608476, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2480, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15024693, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 100564, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12725336, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 46843, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 220458965, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 107879, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 395846760, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 37315, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4639585, "child_limit_applications": 13320, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13320, "child_cap_hits": 13320, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13320, "child_moves_before_total": 1031093, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1031093, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 213659, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 213659, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.40938438438438, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.040465465465466, "tt_hits": 4536, "tt_cutoffs": 511, "beta_cutoffs": 11025, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5105.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5833.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1860, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1500, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21225, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 81, 68, 111, 113, 94, 54, 40, 78, 140, 154, 95, 85, 86, 125, 109, 108, 123, 67, 137 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 12004, "avg_search_time_ms": 1000.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 116790, "safety_nodes": 363, "corridor_nodes": 3937, "corridor_branch_probes": 4383, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1746, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 3904, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3904, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 89, "corridor_proof_active": 33, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1746, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 89, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 696, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24054320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 121090, "avg_nodes": 10090.833333333334, "eval_calls": 87969, "avg_eval_calls": 7330.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87969, "pattern_eval_ns": 1897679, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.572133365162728, "pattern_frame_queries": 87969, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1897679, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.572133365162728, "pattern_frame_updates": 233476, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2922536043, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12517.500912299338, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27112, "avg_candidate_generations": 2259.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2294410, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.62710239008557, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 888, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 27100, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2293522, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 793313, "avg_legality_checks": 66109.41666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1317, "root_legality_checks": 888, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 792425, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1315, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3181872, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 265156.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7175351893, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2255.0724520030976, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34410, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2867.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 212035141, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6162.020953211276, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1890, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16884723, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17342, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 135784745, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14144, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 49393748, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1034, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9971925, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 80349, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6695.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 781561230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9727.080984206399, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109539, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9128.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 344834668, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3148.053825578105, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2013797209, "stage_ordering_ns": 965942751, "stage_eval_ns": 2924433722, "stage_threat_ns": 5434950325, "stage_proof_ns": 608988156, "tactical_annotations": 409427, "root_tactical_annotations": 2522, "search_tactical_annotations": 406905, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 241474, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1488327783, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 583837, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3672556980, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56364, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2107747731, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 120731, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 182478320, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7986, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 48221815, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 241462, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30542911, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 107326, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 191328359, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 196198, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 775310994, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 105903, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12822516, "child_limit_applications": 27100, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27100, "child_cap_hits": 27100, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27100, "child_moves_before_total": 2292207, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2292207, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 434041, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 434041, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.58328413284133, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.016273062730626, "tt_hits": 11949, "tt_cutoffs": 1669, "beta_cutoffs": 21341, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4514.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5181.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 828, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9209, "avg_search_time_ms": 837.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 68734, "safety_nodes": 1125, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 69859, "avg_nodes": 6350.818181818182, "eval_calls": 42389, "avg_eval_calls": 3853.5454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 42389, "pattern_eval_ns": 945491, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.305102738918116, "pattern_frame_queries": 42389, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 945491, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.305102738918116, "pattern_frame_updates": 137342, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1551929488, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11299.744346230578, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23860, "avg_candidate_generations": 2169.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 1902113, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.71974015088013, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 818, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 23849, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1901295, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1121479, "avg_legality_checks": 101952.63636363637, "illegal_moves_skipped": 874, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1121479, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 874, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2663098, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 242099.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5986450883, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2247.927369927806, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18347, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1667.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 98523839, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5370.024472665831, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1169, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11917791, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6408, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 61068542, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10760, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25421896, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 115610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90515, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8228.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 853100499, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9424.962702314533, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 120149, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10922.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 361915286, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3012.2205428259913, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2839698599, "stage_ordering_ns": 813395307, "stage_eval_ns": 1552874979, "stage_threat_ns": 3949440451, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 359788, "root_tactical_annotations": 947, "search_tactical_annotations": 358841, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 137353, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 859009273, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 312413, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2956189604, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47783, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1801398708, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68671, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105555029, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 137342, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18054045, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 63152, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 300721848, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 201470, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 853822296, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 95166, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10632500, "child_limit_applications": 23849, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23849, "child_cap_hits": 23849, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23849, "child_moves_before_total": 1900421, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1900421, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 241661, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 241661, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.68556333598893, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.132961549750513, "tt_hits": 11614, "tt_cutoffs": 2434, "beta_cutoffs": 18999, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3615.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4342.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 105, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1501, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16573, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 128, 82, 100, 142, 86, 72, 143, 83, 81, 110, 113, 158, 126, 124, 68, 138 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10556, "avg_search_time_ms": 1172.888888888889, "search_nodes": 91467, "safety_nodes": 517, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91984, "avg_nodes": 10220.444444444445, "eval_calls": 57929, "avg_eval_calls": 6436.555555555556, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 57929, "pattern_eval_ns": 1273326, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.980804087762607, "pattern_frame_queries": 57929, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1273326, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.980804087762607, "pattern_frame_updates": 182844, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2348060129, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12841.87684036665, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30983, "avg_candidate_generations": 3442.5555555555557, "candidate_moves_total": 2524266, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.47261401413678, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 639, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 30974, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2523627, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 870909, "avg_legality_checks": 96767.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1037, "root_legality_checks": 639, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 870270, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1037, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2769517, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 307724.1111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6427678619, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2320.8662806547136, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35330, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3925.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 133652725, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3782.9811774695727, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1282, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12299464, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12057, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72540728, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21987, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 48804793, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7740, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 77427, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8603.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 752191197, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9714.843620442482, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 101145, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11238.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 326785698, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3230.8635918730533, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2254349739, "stage_ordering_ns": 1075080411, "stage_eval_ns": 2349333455, "stage_threat_ns": 4831321324, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 454310, "root_tactical_annotations": 1469, "search_tactical_annotations": 452841, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 182853, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1125370051, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 359557, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3518880402, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62010, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2418877184, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91422, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 141633387, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 182844, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23765343, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 69044, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 142251195, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 228497, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 957428573, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 156769, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21672141, "child_limit_applications": 30974, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30974, "child_cap_hits": 30974, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30974, "child_moves_before_total": 2522590, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2522590, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 314704, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 314704, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.44217731000194, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.1602634467618, "tt_hits": 16708, "tt_cutoffs": 2520, "beta_cutoffs": 24678, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 4.888888888888889, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 4.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1979.3333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2810.777777777778, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6009, "avg_search_time_ms": 751.125, "search_nodes": 40335, "safety_nodes": 660, "corridor_nodes": 1180, "corridor_branch_probes": 1449, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 5, "corridor_depth_exits": 503, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1159, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1159, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 503, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 59, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 436, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 217120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 17840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 42175, "avg_nodes": 5271.875, "eval_calls": 26794, "avg_eval_calls": 3349.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 26794, "pattern_eval_ns": 602301, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.4789505113085, "pattern_frame_queries": 26794, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 602301, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.4789505113085, "pattern_frame_updates": 80600, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 823041297, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10211.430483870969, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12783, "avg_candidate_generations": 1597.875, "candidate_moves_total": 1111202, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.92810764296331, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 12775, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1110622, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 769879, "avg_legality_checks": 96234.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 78, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 769879, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 78, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1763707, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 220463.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3982536391, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2258.0487524288333, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25329, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3166.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 56730390, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2239.740613525998, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 126, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1131093, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2406, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15219190, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22797, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40380107, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 71684, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8960.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 766851513, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10697.666327213883, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92292, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11536.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 359973822, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3900.3794695098168, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1965924978, "stage_ordering_ns": 475130401, "stage_eval_ns": 823643598, "stage_threat_ns": 2590380211, "stage_proof_ns": 101269018, "tactical_annotations": 213924, "root_tactical_annotations": 1077, "search_tactical_annotations": 212847, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 83044, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 526699232, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 261098, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1968223581, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26309, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 994935141, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 41518, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 64874866, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2436, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13317019, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 83036, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10547164, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70845, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 477531825, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 93611, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 439378659, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49468, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6718349, "child_limit_applications": 12775, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12775, "child_cap_hits": 12775, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12775, "child_moves_before_total": 1110544, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1110544, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 204662, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 204662, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.93103718199609, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02050880626223, "tt_hits": 5722, "tt_cutoffs": 731, "beta_cutoffs": 11053, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 4.375, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 4.375, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3630.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4630.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1838, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1502, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20061, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 82, 128, 68, 110, 97, 67, 84, 113, 83, 85, 69, 158, 143, 55, 54, 40, 39, 24, 99 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11589, "avg_search_time_ms": 1158.9, "search_nodes": 125805, "safety_nodes": 419, "corridor_nodes": 1607, "corridor_branch_probes": 1715, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 692, "corridor_neutral_exits": 28, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1584, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1584, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 74, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 692, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 74, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 71, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 575, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 45950480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1993440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 127831, "avg_nodes": 12783.1, "eval_calls": 100958, "avg_eval_calls": 10095.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 100958, "pattern_eval_ns": 2186313, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.65566869391232, "pattern_frame_queries": 100958, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2186313, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.65566869391232, "pattern_frame_updates": 251526, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3493927885, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13890.921356042716, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23808, "avg_candidate_generations": 2380.8, "candidate_moves_total": 1750916, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.54317876344086, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 635, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 23798, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1750281, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 790438, "avg_legality_checks": 79043.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 565, "root_legality_checks": 635, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 789803, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 565, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3104204, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 310420.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7010981106, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2258.543931391107, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27114, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2711.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 118863638, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4383.847385114701, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 843, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5964655, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13791, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 90515583, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12328, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21408263, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 152, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 975137, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 86369, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8636.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 771786627, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8935.92176591138, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 115015, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11501.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 325117165, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2826.7370777724645, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2016313991, "stage_ordering_ns": 780125338, "stage_eval_ns": 3496114198, "stage_threat_ns": 4928440180, "stage_proof_ns": 319906766, "tactical_annotations": 365305, "root_tactical_annotations": 1793, "search_tactical_annotations": 363512, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 254852, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1555707261, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 434118, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3117709722, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48744, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1851999928, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 127421, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 192325173, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3316, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19862292, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 254842, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32804134, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96770, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 160638339, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 194260, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 868129196, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 74275, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10031598, "child_limit_applications": 23798, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23798, "child_cap_hits": 23798, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23798, "child_moves_before_total": 1749716, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1749716, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 380982, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 380982, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.5236574502059, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.008992352298513, "tt_hits": 8879, "tt_cutoffs": 1007, "beta_cutoffs": 17171, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2315.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3115.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 330, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8461, "avg_search_time_ms": 940.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 62757, "safety_nodes": 752, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 63509, "avg_nodes": 7056.555555555556, "eval_calls": 37550, "avg_eval_calls": 4172.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37550, "pattern_eval_ns": 839954, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.36894806924101, "pattern_frame_queries": 37550, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 839954, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.36894806924101, "pattern_frame_updates": 125420, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1453977828, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11592.870578855047, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22971, "avg_candidate_generations": 2552.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 1735319, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.5439031822733, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 564, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 22962, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1734755, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 948926, "avg_legality_checks": 105436.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 546, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 948926, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 546, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2477011, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 275223.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5450296723, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2200.3522483347874, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14320, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1591.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 49527870, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3458.6501396648046, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 558, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5500702, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3557, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29828359, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10205, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14198809, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 88278, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9808.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 843323580, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9553.043566913613, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 119883, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13320.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 382186175, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3187.993084924468, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2388308411, "stage_ordering_ns": 746144922, "stage_eval_ns": 1454817782, "stage_threat_ns": 3826341944, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 388831, "root_tactical_annotations": 789, "search_tactical_annotations": 388042, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125429, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 785320201, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 355796, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2918850034, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45989, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1714603413, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 62710, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 95686483, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 125420, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16602806, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 66484, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 246471181, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 243316, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 957534979, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79031, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9882420, "child_limit_applications": 22962, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22962, "child_cap_hits": 22962, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22962, "child_moves_before_total": 1734209, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1734209, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 226611, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 226611, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.52517202334292, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.8689574078913, "tt_hits": 9190, "tt_cutoffs": 2198, "beta_cutoffs": 18594, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 5.111111111111111, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 5.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2852.1111111111113, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3741.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1503, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26551, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 128, 110, 114, 156, 100, 86, 129, 125, 95, 82, 68, 124, 138, 64, 48, 140, 130, 127, 132, 131, 84, 116, 99, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18571, "avg_search_time_ms": 1428.5384615384614, "search_nodes": 153718, "safety_nodes": 787, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 154505, "avg_nodes": 11885.0, "eval_calls": 94246, "avg_eval_calls": 7249.692307692308, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 94246, "pattern_eval_ns": 2081429, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.085064618127028, "pattern_frame_queries": 94246, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2081429, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.085064618127028, "pattern_frame_updates": 307284, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4499159013, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14641.69632327098, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 54274, "avg_candidate_generations": 4174.923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 4906999, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.4115967129749, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1110, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 54261, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4905889, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 1397795, "avg_legality_checks": 107522.69230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1351, "root_legality_checks": 1110, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1396685, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1351, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4824803, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 371138.6923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11125356386, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2305.867490548319, "renju_forbidden_checks": 52429, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4033.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 338802591, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6462.121936332946, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1456, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14282204, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26037, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 228354070, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24936, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 96166317, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 127365, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9797.307692307691, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1280998528, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10057.696604247634, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 178842, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13757.076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 599578399, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3352.5592366446363, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3575296995, "stage_ordering_ns": 2001945332, "stage_eval_ns": 4501240442, "stage_threat_ns": 8427961964, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1032020, "root_tactical_annotations": 3208, "search_tactical_annotations": 1028812, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 307297, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1925329176, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 757380, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6170241109, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 108624, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4189846645, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 153642, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 240742013, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 307284, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40680680, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 185706, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 287162490, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 463042, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1692922213, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 383272, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 50968986, "child_limit_applications": 54261, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 54261, "child_cap_hits": 54261, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 54261, "child_moves_before_total": 4904538, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4904538, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 588967, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 588967, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.38790291369492, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.854333683492747, "tt_hits": 32430, "tt_cutoffs": 5138, "beta_cutoffs": 44599, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1686.5384615384614, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2261.769230769231, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7968, "avg_search_time_ms": 612.9230769230769, "search_nodes": 52839, "safety_nodes": 1563, "corridor_nodes": 1123, "corridor_branch_probes": 1271, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 513, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 1102, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1102, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 513, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 441, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 282560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 55525, "avg_nodes": 4271.153846153846, "eval_calls": 35520, "avg_eval_calls": 2732.3076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35520, "pattern_eval_ns": 796575, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.426097972972972, "pattern_frame_queries": 35520, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 796575, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.426097972972972, "pattern_frame_updates": 105564, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1153443669, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10926.48695578038, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16256, "avg_candidate_generations": 1250.4615384615386, "candidate_moves_total": 1459494, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.78186515748031, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1138, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 16243, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1458356, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1032883, "avg_legality_checks": 79452.53846153847, "illegal_moves_skipped": 102, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1032883, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 102, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2418646, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 186049.6923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5342805707, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2209.0069017954675, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7158, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 550.6153846153846, "renju_forbidden_ns": 26008175, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3633.441603799944, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 729981, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1966, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17224477, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5090, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8053717, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99494, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7653.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1097615087, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11031.972651617183, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 147726, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11363.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 549395916, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3719.0197798627187, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2617557409, "stage_ordering_ns": 623623310, "stage_eval_ns": 1154240244, "stage_threat_ns": 3406775898, "stage_proof_ns": 110005123, "tactical_annotations": 284546, "root_tactical_annotations": 1136, "search_tactical_annotations": 283410, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 107909, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 682399814, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 328980, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2607020817, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33256, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1219145737, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 53948, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 83389779, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2332, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13372166, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 107896, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13735484, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 81118, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 543060714, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 151712, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 793478083, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 51716, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6857838, "child_limit_applications": 16243, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16243, "child_cap_hits": 16243, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16243, "child_moves_before_total": 1458254, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1458254, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 260281, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 260281, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.7773810256726, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.024195037862462, "tt_hits": 6271, "tt_cutoffs": 1019, "beta_cutoffs": 13944, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4839.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5455.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1491, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1504, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17944, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 110, 128, 82, 124, 111, 109, 97, 67, 98, 125, 127, 123, 122, 95, 81, 114, 100, 99, 83, 156, 170, 137, 151, 84, 69, 55, 68, 54, 53, 38, 113 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 8598, "avg_search_time_ms": 537.375, "search_nodes": 99974, "safety_nodes": 796, "corridor_nodes": 6002, "corridor_branch_probes": 6665, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 3019, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 105, "corridor_plies_followed": 5964, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5964, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 84, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3019, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 105, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 84, "corridor_proof_wins": 7, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 77, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 592, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 22318560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2015040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 11, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 106772, "avg_nodes": 6673.25, "eval_calls": 71368, "avg_eval_calls": 4460.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71368, "pattern_eval_ns": 1460663, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.466637708777043, "pattern_frame_queries": 71368, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1460663, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.466637708777043, "pattern_frame_updates": 199804, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2152176331, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10771.437663910632, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26870, "avg_candidate_generations": 1679.375, "candidate_moves_total": 2110395, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.54093784890212, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1182, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 26854, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2109213, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 728691, "avg_legality_checks": 45543.1875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1019, "root_legality_checks": 1182, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 727509, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1019, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3370627, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 210664.1875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5184500537, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1538.1412826159644, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30228, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1889.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 109643148, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3627.204843191743, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1130, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6289782, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11928, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73954877, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15530, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24701723, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1640, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4696766, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 102970, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6435.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 660826420, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6417.659706710692, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 139947, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8746.6875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 293542414, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2097.525591831193, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1321038639, "stage_ordering_ns": 599091358, "stage_eval_ns": 2153636994, "stage_threat_ns": 4064535081, "stage_proof_ns": 414301119, "tactical_annotations": 516688, "root_tactical_annotations": 2449, "search_tactical_annotations": 514239, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 211916, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1037232825, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 743125, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2811005859, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56765, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1552450359, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 105950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 131226333, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12096, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 51733218, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 211900, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21705646, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 167588, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 142098804, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 231719, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 687102060, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 117381, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11631200, "child_limit_applications": 26854, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26854, "child_cap_hits": 26854, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26854, "child_moves_before_total": 2108194, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2108194, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 438876, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 438876, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.50577195203694, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.343040142995456, "tt_hits": 12162, "tt_cutoffs": 1680, "beta_cutoffs": 22236, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5599.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6099.1875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 293, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 9334, "avg_search_time_ms": 622.2666666666667, "search_nodes": 96866, "safety_nodes": 1592, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 98458, "avg_nodes": 6563.866666666667, "eval_calls": 58332, "avg_eval_calls": 3888.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 58332, "pattern_eval_ns": 1164665, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.966142083247618, "pattern_frame_queries": 58332, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1164665, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.966142083247618, "pattern_frame_updates": 193550, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1561397274, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8067.152022733144, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35039, "avg_candidate_generations": 2335.9333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 2794586, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.75644282085676, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1104, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 35024, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2793482, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1774139, "avg_legality_checks": 118275.93333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4312, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1774139, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4312, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4309816, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 287321.06666666665, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5950727547, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1380.7381909111666, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48394, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3226.266666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 92085130, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1902.8212175063024, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4426, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20882295, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7946, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 39612902, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 36022, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31589933, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 186901, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12460.066666666668, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1170316090, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6261.689825094569, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 259881, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17325.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 509387026, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1960.077981845537, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2794186202, "stage_ordering_ns": 731898279, "stage_eval_ns": 1562561939, "stage_threat_ns": 4167830672, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 814194, "root_tactical_annotations": 1006, "search_tactical_annotations": 813188, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 193565, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 806096951, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 655861, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3213109589, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70169, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1621025838, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 96775, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107857305, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 193550, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18087020, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 171532, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 376891526, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 414149, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1214884775, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 228513, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22679807, "child_limit_applications": 35024, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35024, "child_cap_hits": 35024, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35024, "child_moves_before_total": 2789170, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2789170, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 462398, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 462398, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.6359639104614, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.202318410232984, "tt_hits": 18234, "tt_cutoffs": 3420, "beta_cutoffs": 30035, "depth_sum": 90, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 90, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5782.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6315.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1505, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19582, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 114, 81, 79, 66, 113, 115, 142, 100, 111, 110, 95, 127, 156, 170, 141, 126, 144, 160, 143, 145, 140 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 14570, "avg_search_time_ms": 1214.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 148526, "safety_nodes": 192, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148718, "avg_nodes": 12393.166666666666, "eval_calls": 87297, "avg_eval_calls": 7274.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87297, "pattern_eval_ns": 1867718, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.394984936481208, "pattern_frame_queries": 87297, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1867718, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.394984936481208, "pattern_frame_updates": 296924, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3262654656, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10988.181002546105, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 57290, "avg_candidate_generations": 4774.166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 4818614, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.1091639029499, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 825, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 57278, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4817789, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1187060, "avg_legality_checks": 98921.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1669, "root_legality_checks": 825, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1186235, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1668, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4219051, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 351587.5833333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8537328639, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2023.5187104872637, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30916, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2576.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 187232345, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6056.1633134946305, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1838, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18953319, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13921, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 114673851, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15152, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 53546405, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 58770, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98146, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8178.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 817483488, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8329.259348317812, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 128319, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10693.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 328955700, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2563.577490472962, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2614268722, "stage_ordering_ns": 1715192993, "stage_eval_ns": 3264522374, "stage_threat_ns": 6918039160, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 983113, "root_tactical_annotations": 3719, "search_tactical_annotations": 979394, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 296936, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1606602765, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 733185, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5026558486, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 114643, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3739076333, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148462, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 204634535, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 296924, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34450024, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 262311, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 272520590, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 356220, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1014815073, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 364582, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 45793350, "child_limit_applications": 57278, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 57278, "child_cap_hits": 57278, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 57278, "child_moves_before_total": 4816121, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4816121, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 638858, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 638858, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.0832605887077, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.153636649324348, "tt_hits": 35344, "tt_cutoffs": 3887, "beta_cutoffs": 47706, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3165.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3832.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1741, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4999, "avg_search_time_ms": 454.45454545454544, "search_nodes": 48969, "safety_nodes": 887, "corridor_nodes": 1208, "corridor_branch_probes": 1290, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 8, "corridor_depth_exits": 602, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1193, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1193, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 602, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 55, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 341, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 262880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 51064, "avg_nodes": 4642.181818181818, "eval_calls": 35198, "avg_eval_calls": 3199.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35198, "pattern_eval_ns": 767794, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.81356895278141, "pattern_frame_queries": 35198, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 767794, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.81356895278141, "pattern_frame_updates": 97838, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 807286970, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8251.26198409616, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13260, "avg_candidate_generations": 1205.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 1026042, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.3787330316742, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 760, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 13249, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1025282, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 525923, "avg_legality_checks": 47811.181818181816, "illegal_moves_skipped": 101, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 525923, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 101, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1398226, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 127111.45454545454, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3046570182, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2178.882513985579, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3602, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 327.45454545454544, "renju_forbidden_ns": 11048227, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3067.2479178234316, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 103, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1104224, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 798, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6354632, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2694, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3501001, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 88370, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46263, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4205.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 431765388, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9332.844562609429, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 62792, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5708.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 193745104, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3085.5061791310995, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1319405488, "stage_ordering_ns": 425926688, "stage_eval_ns": 808054764, "stage_threat_ns": 2322341977, "stage_proof_ns": 88435881, "tactical_annotations": 190275, "root_tactical_annotations": 686, "search_tactical_annotations": 189589, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 100345, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 609524339, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 242013, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1608002723, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27280, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 981747311, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50167, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73086131, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2496, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15189752, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 100334, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12463021, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 47273, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 217957473, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 106224, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 364311345, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 36778, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4076011, "child_limit_applications": 13249, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13249, "child_cap_hits": 13249, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13249, "child_moves_before_total": 1025181, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1025181, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 212510, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 212510, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.37799079175787, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0397011095177, "tt_hits": 4488, "tt_cutoffs": 472, "beta_cutoffs": 10956, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5173.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5900.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1913, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1506, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24250, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 144, 96, 160, 176, 97, 110, 124, 114, 130, 66, 50, 81, 51, 80, 83, 52, 94, 125, 95, 126, 111, 78, 55, 79 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8297, "avg_search_time_ms": 691.4166666666666, "search_nodes": 89016, "safety_nodes": 1229, "corridor_nodes": 16, "corridor_branch_probes": 18, "corridor_max_depth": 3, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 12, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 12, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 30, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 26, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 30, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 30, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 158, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23855840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 90261, "avg_nodes": 7521.75, "eval_calls": 67993, "avg_eval_calls": 5666.083333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67993, "pattern_eval_ns": 1494515, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.98042445545865, "pattern_frame_queries": 67993, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1494515, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.98042445545865, "pattern_frame_updates": 177920, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1615969863, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9082.564427832735, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19595, "avg_candidate_generations": 1632.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1593480, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.32074508803267, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 973, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 19583, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1592507, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 869995, "avg_legality_checks": 72499.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 181, "root_legality_checks": 973, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 869022, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 180, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2213049, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 184420.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5034799023, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2275.050856533226, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6142, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 511.8333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18849410, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3068.9368283946596, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 187, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1465695, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1599, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11660910, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4351, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5662925, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 59880, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 66844, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5570.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 674324171, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10088.028409430914, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92127, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7677.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 319217754, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3464.975023608714, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2226484810, "stage_ordering_ns": 698441979, "stage_eval_ns": 1617464378, "stage_threat_ns": 3646489508, "stage_proof_ns": 59485593, "tactical_annotations": 251924, "root_tactical_annotations": 1094, "search_tactical_annotations": 250830, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 178016, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1055059008, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 259297, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2434468665, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 39374, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1511019126, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89002, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 130016151, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 84, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 381862, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 178004, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22289279, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56412, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 168128977, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 161697, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 751544195, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 33815, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4274543, "child_limit_applications": 19583, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19583, "child_cap_hits": 19583, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19583, "child_moves_before_total": 1592327, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1592327, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 317983, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 317983, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.31169892253484, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.237706173722106, "tt_hits": 5215, "tt_cutoffs": 1384, "beta_cutoffs": 15161, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4206.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4872.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 15940, "avg_search_time_ms": 1328.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 126560, "safety_nodes": 266, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 126826, "avg_nodes": 10568.833333333334, "eval_calls": 91198, "avg_eval_calls": 7599.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 91198, "pattern_eval_ns": 2043304, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.405140463606656, "pattern_frame_queries": 91198, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2043304, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.405140463606656, "pattern_frame_updates": 253006, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2724550057, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10768.71717271527, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33262, "avg_candidate_generations": 2771.8333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 3274712, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.45204738139618, "candidate_moves_max": 134, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1012, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 33250, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3273700, "search_candidate_moves_max": 134, "legality_checks": 2051205, "avg_legality_checks": 170933.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 832, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2051205, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 832, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4751540, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 395961.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10415680591, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2192.064170984565, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15580, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1298.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 49038082, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3147.502053915276, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1017, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9861151, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5060, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24146172, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9493, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14902418, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 128341, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 183596, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15299.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1956483224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10656.45887709972, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 258944, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21578.666666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 976224042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3770.01993481216, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5141408790, "stage_ordering_ns": 1339155255, "stage_eval_ns": 2726593361, "stage_threat_ns": 6653002909, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 633347, "root_tactical_annotations": 3711, "search_tactical_annotations": 629636, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 253018, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1580531287, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 572600, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4825377813, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 66580, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2388353437, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 126503, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 197203853, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 253006, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33348026, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 209768, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1086699476, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 296242, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1350268190, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 127337, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16541930, "child_limit_applications": 33250, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33250, "child_cap_hits": 33250, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33250, "child_moves_before_total": 3272868, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3272868, "child_moves_before_max": 134, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 134, "child_moves_after_total": 405189, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 405189, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 98.43212030075188, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.186135338345865, "tt_hits": 14074, "tt_cutoffs": 2056, "beta_cutoffs": 23683, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3781.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4447.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1710, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1507, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21279, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 141, 129, 99, 100, 140, 154, 142, 86, 72, 143, 111, 156, 158, 110, 157, 127, 125, 130, 131, 109, 139, 138, 153, 97, 167 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 17114, "avg_search_time_ms": 1222.4285714285713, "search_nodes": 162616, "safety_nodes": 608, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 163224, "avg_nodes": 11658.857142857143, "eval_calls": 117729, "avg_eval_calls": 8409.214285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 117729, "pattern_eval_ns": 2559849, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.743572102030935, "pattern_frame_queries": 117729, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2559849, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.743572102030935, "pattern_frame_updates": 325096, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5246500555, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 16138.31162179787, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42223, "avg_candidate_generations": 3015.9285714285716, "candidate_moves_total": 3658092, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.63742510006395, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1042, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 42209, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3657050, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1212443, "avg_legality_checks": 86603.07142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7133, "root_legality_checks": 1042, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 1211401, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7127, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4443605, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 317400.35714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10093576011, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2271.483628945417, "renju_forbidden_checks": 79537, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5681.214285714285, "renju_forbidden_ns": 570247571, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7169.5886317059985, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7907, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 82194047, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 45930, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 388735757, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25670, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 98956937, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 360830, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 123557, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8825.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1134202848, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9179.591993978487, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 161533, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11538.07142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 473108799, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2928.867779339206, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3102477593, "stage_ordering_ns": 1488765661, "stage_eval_ns": 5249060404, "stage_threat_ns": 7224254679, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 842172, "root_tactical_annotations": 3010, "search_tactical_annotations": 839162, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 325110, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2009747518, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 669388, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4884751005, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 84513, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3192730822, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 162548, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 253310008, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 325096, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42763368, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 223807, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 302863928, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 361057, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1388812573, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 257308, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33682780, "child_limit_applications": 42209, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42209, "child_cap_hits": 42209, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42209, "child_moves_before_total": 3649923, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3649923, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 482094, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 482094, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.4726243218271, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.421592551351608, "tt_hits": 21894, "tt_cutoffs": 2610, "beta_cutoffs": 31383, "depth_sum": 68, "avg_depth": 4.857142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 68, "avg_effective_depth": 4.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4547.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5119.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 343, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 4149, "avg_search_time_ms": 319.15384615384613, "search_nodes": 32668, "safety_nodes": 1465, "corridor_nodes": 728, "corridor_branch_probes": 849, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 8, "corridor_depth_exits": 245, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 52, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 245, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 52, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 307, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 154800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 34861, "avg_nodes": 2681.6153846153848, "eval_calls": 21983, "avg_eval_calls": 1691.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 21983, "pattern_eval_ns": 482353, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.94209161624892, "pattern_frame_queries": 21983, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 482353, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.94209161624892, "pattern_frame_updates": 65216, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 768315971, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11781.096218719333, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9901, "avg_candidate_generations": 761.6153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 768869, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.65569134430865, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 970, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 9888, "search_candidate_moves_total": 767899, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 409768, "avg_legality_checks": 31520.615384615383, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2580, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 409768, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2580, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1144106, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 88008.15384615384, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2555764807, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2233.853163081043, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12694, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 976.4615384615385, "renju_forbidden_ns": 101854310, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8023.815188277927, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2613, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30154922, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5193, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 52489813, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4793, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18004101, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 95, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1205474, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37119, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2855.3076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 381962305, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10290.210000269404, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50948, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3919.076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 183999563, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3611.5168995838894, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1071328175, "stage_ordering_ns": 325118625, "stage_eval_ns": 768798324, "stage_threat_ns": 1862470202, "stage_proof_ns": 90222761, "tactical_annotations": 176289, "root_tactical_annotations": 661, "search_tactical_annotations": 175628, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 66765, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 435922592, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 210569, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1354100663, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20410, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 792715157, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 33376, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 51881764, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1536, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8523555, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 66752, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8731325, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 45840, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 169106370, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 95093, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 353513422, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 35356, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3310303, "child_limit_applications": 9888, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9888, "child_cap_hits": 9888, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9888, "child_moves_before_total": 765319, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 765319, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 159811, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 159811, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.39876618122977, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.16211569579288, "tt_hits": 4013, "tt_cutoffs": 737, "beta_cutoffs": 8458, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5916.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6531.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1864, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1508, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25386, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 142, 98, 110, 158, 127, 157, 111, 109, 96, 143, 113, 173, 188, 141, 125, 82, 66, 81, 95, 130, 146, 189, 205, 80, 79, 63, 94, 78, 93, 92, 97 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 12238, "avg_search_time_ms": 764.875, "search_nodes": 100950, "safety_nodes": 796, "corridor_nodes": 5845, "corridor_branch_probes": 6514, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 2800, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 107, "corridor_plies_followed": 5806, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5806, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 39, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2800, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 107, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 7, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 76, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 590, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 22334720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2015040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 10, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 107591, "avg_nodes": 6724.4375, "eval_calls": 71999, "avg_eval_calls": 4499.9375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71999, "pattern_eval_ns": 1563819, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.720010000138892, "pattern_frame_queries": 71999, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1563819, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.720010000138892, "pattern_frame_updates": 201756, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2777357847, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13765.92441860465, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27128, "avg_candidate_generations": 1695.5, "candidate_moves_total": 2135461, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.71796667649662, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1182, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 27112, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2134279, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 740347, "avg_legality_checks": 46271.6875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1370, "root_legality_checks": 1182, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 739165, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1370, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3379802, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 211237.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7491877913, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2216.6617787077466, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32192, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2012.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 171475334, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5326.644321570577, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1490, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14606676, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12313, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 103556777, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16617, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43921043, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1772, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9390838, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 104384, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6524.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 961722485, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9213.313199340895, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 142070, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8879.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 415763940, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2926.4724431618215, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1875619220, "stage_ordering_ns": 908068142, "stage_eval_ns": 2778921666, "stage_threat_ns": 5933126395, "stage_proof_ns": 699348864, "tactical_annotations": 530145, "root_tactical_annotations": 2449, "search_tactical_annotations": 527696, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 213550, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1414818238, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 758355, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4225046050, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 57298, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2281996779, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 106767, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 169604731, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 11778, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 80324025, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 213534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28202288, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 164946, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 209025764, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 241681, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 980949732, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 123518, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15131063, "child_limit_applications": 27112, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27112, "child_cap_hits": 27112, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27112, "child_moves_before_total": 2132909, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2132909, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 446041, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 446041, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.67029359693124, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.451792564178223, "tt_hits": 12257, "tt_cutoffs": 1767, "beta_cutoffs": 22450, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5212.9375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5712.9375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 229, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 13132, "avg_search_time_ms": 875.4666666666667, "search_nodes": 85776, "safety_nodes": 1592, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87368, "avg_nodes": 5824.533333333334, "eval_calls": 49887, "avg_eval_calls": 3325.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49887, "pattern_eval_ns": 1107390, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.197967406338325, "pattern_frame_queries": 49887, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1107390, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.197967406338325, "pattern_frame_updates": 171370, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2052785868, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11978.676944622746, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32446, "avg_candidate_generations": 2163.0666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 2604007, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.25664180484497, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1104, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 32431, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2602903, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1678254, "avg_legality_checks": 111883.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3832, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1678254, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3832, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4011500, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 267433.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8588553222, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2140.9829794341267, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54200, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3613.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 155060498, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2860.8947970479703, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3886, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 35441058, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7537, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 61105982, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 42777, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 58513458, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 174905, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11660.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1611942285, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9216.101798118978, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 247322, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16488.133333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 691250885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2794.942969084837, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4132527171, "stage_ordering_ns": 1095501345, "stage_eval_ns": 2053893258, "stage_threat_ns": 5776360944, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 742628, "root_tactical_annotations": 1006, "search_tactical_annotations": 741622, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 171385, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1076089456, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 591992, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4514271453, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64983, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2326816651, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85685, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 135946043, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 171370, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22885034, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 150816, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 589682366, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 376182, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1597309745, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 215630, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 27168958, "child_limit_applications": 32431, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32431, "child_cap_hits": 32431, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32431, "child_moves_before_total": 2599071, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2599071, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 414314, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 414314, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.14156208565878, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.775245906694213, "tt_hits": 17157, "tt_cutoffs": 3367, "beta_cutoffs": 27926, "depth_sum": 90, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 90, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5303.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5837.133333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1509, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9579, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 126, 82, 94, 142, 78, 62, 141, 81, 83, 114, 111, 156, 128, 130, 66, 146 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6361, "avg_search_time_ms": 706.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 100168, "safety_nodes": 517, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 100685, "avg_nodes": 11187.222222222223, "eval_calls": 64899, "avg_eval_calls": 7211.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64899, "pattern_eval_ns": 1194002, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.397848965315337, "pattern_frame_queries": 64899, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1194002, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.397848965315337, "pattern_frame_updates": 200246, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1546052719, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7720.767051526623, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32652, "avg_candidate_generations": 3628.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2674069, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.89602474580424, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 639, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 32643, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2673430, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 922618, "avg_legality_checks": 102513.11111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1286, "root_legality_checks": 639, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 921979, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2972215, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 330246.1111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3713652585, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1249.4562422301212, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43945, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4882.777777777777, "renju_forbidden_ns": 88270307, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2008.6541586073502, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7787753, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16565, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 51328059, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25662, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29149775, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4720, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83108, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9234.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 430631091, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5181.584095393945, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 107588, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11954.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 189489279, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1761.249200654348, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1284965714, "stage_ordering_ns": 615373485, "stage_eval_ns": 1547246721, "stage_threat_ns": 2863912557, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 488934, "root_tactical_annotations": 1469, "search_tactical_annotations": 487465, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 200255, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 702226695, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 379303, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2028355035, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 65348, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1385746692, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 100123, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96043042, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 200246, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15866960, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71092, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 81929972, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 242857, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 560499441, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 174985, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21420825, "child_limit_applications": 32643, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32643, "child_cap_hits": 32643, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32643, "child_moves_before_total": 2672144, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2672144, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 337066, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 337066, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.85963299941794, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.32582789572037, "tt_hits": 17799, "tt_cutoffs": 2581, "beta_cutoffs": 25836, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4227.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5116.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1588, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 3212, "avg_search_time_ms": 401.5, "search_nodes": 39773, "safety_nodes": 660, "corridor_nodes": 1128, "corridor_branch_probes": 1326, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 468, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1107, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1107, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 468, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 59, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 436, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 217120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 17840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 41561, "avg_nodes": 5195.125, "eval_calls": 26305, "avg_eval_calls": 3288.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 26305, "pattern_eval_ns": 486853, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.508002280935184, "pattern_frame_queries": 26305, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 486853, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.508002280935184, "pattern_frame_updates": 79476, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 461529243, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5807.152385625849, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12709, "avg_candidate_generations": 1588.625, "candidate_moves_total": 1103026, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.79093555747895, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 12701, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1102446, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 768168, "avg_legality_checks": 96021.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 79, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 768168, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 79, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1754622, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 219327.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2059585798, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1173.8059810033158, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25272, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3159.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 28579900, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1130.891896169674, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 126, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 539163, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2327, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8343533, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22819, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19697204, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72054, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9006.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 401923556, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5578.088045077303, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92665, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11583.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 188739745, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2036.7964711595532, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1035823839, "stage_ordering_ns": 248731283, "stage_eval_ns": 462016096, "stage_threat_ns": 1377871063, "stage_proof_ns": 52206169, "tactical_annotations": 213611, "root_tactical_annotations": 1077, "search_tactical_annotations": 212534, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 81816, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 289752410, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 258497, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1030609504, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26156, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 516387104, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40904, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 39310283, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2332, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7379847, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 81808, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6323062, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70412, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 251891191, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 93509, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 233346201, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49690, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4495957, "child_limit_applications": 12701, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12701, "child_cap_hits": 12701, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12701, "child_moves_before_total": 1102367, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1102367, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 203505, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 203505, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.79371703015511, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.022754113849302, "tt_hits": 5681, "tt_cutoffs": 732, "beta_cutoffs": 11010, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 4.375, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 4.375, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4727.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5727.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1903, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1510, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30664, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 82, 124, 126, 140, 127, 142, 84, 70, 67, 97, 114, 130, 66, 50, 99, 69, 141, 113, 65, 64, 129, 144, 125, 128, 109, 93, 157, 173, 156, 158, 143, 172, 116, 186 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 20277, "avg_search_time_ms": 1192.764705882353, "search_nodes": 185569, "safety_nodes": 185, "corridor_nodes": 10075, "corridor_branch_probes": 11796, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4050, "corridor_neutral_exits": 19, "corridor_terminal_exits": 81, "corridor_plies_followed": 9971, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9971, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 226, "corridor_proof_active": 104, "corridor_proof_quiet": 122, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4050, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 81, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 226, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 225, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1907, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 995120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 195829, "avg_nodes": 11519.35294117647, "eval_calls": 121729, "avg_eval_calls": 7160.529411764706, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 121729, "pattern_eval_ns": 2531455, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.795825152593054, "pattern_frame_queries": 121729, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2531455, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.795825152593054, "pattern_frame_updates": 370978, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4874681076, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13140.081287839172, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 59114, "avg_candidate_generations": 3477.294117647059, "candidate_moves_total": 5380776, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.02371688601684, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1339, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 59097, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5379437, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1275952, "avg_legality_checks": 75056.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 14716, "root_legality_checks": 1339, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "search_legality_checks": 1274613, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 14696, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6433453, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 378438.4117647059, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11476948256, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1783.948410907797, "renju_forbidden_checks": 127123, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7477.823529411765, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1092148316, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8591.27235826719, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15323, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 161734024, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 60322, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 596599110, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 45657, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 275284634, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5821, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 58530548, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 152242, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8955.411764705883, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1308066056, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8592.01833922308, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 213148, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12538.117647058823, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 657461768, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3084.5317244356033, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2734644174, "stage_ordering_ns": 1760497548, "stage_eval_ns": 4877212531, "stage_threat_ns": 9617584383, "stage_proof_ns": 1210581866, "tactical_annotations": 1538589, "root_tactical_annotations": 5676, "search_tactical_annotations": 1532913, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 391389, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2129849097, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1934677, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7027799253, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 123681, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3919877375, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 195686, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 267829203, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 20394, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 103370658, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 391372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43024758, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 613229, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 462103989, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 591372, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1433114627, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 333988, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 45711414, "child_limit_applications": 59097, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 59097, "child_cap_hits": 59097, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 59097, "child_moves_before_total": 5364741, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5364741, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 986274, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 986274, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.77856743997157, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.68907051119346, "tt_hits": 28071, "tt_cutoffs": 4663, "beta_cutoffs": 51326, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6073.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6543.588235294118, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1084, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 10372, "avg_search_time_ms": 610.1176470588235, "search_nodes": 94675, "safety_nodes": 2008, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 96683, "avg_nodes": 5687.235294117647, "eval_calls": 54877, "avg_eval_calls": 3228.0588235294117, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 54877, "pattern_eval_ns": 1124183, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.485503945186508, "pattern_frame_queries": 54877, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1124183, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.485503945186508, "pattern_frame_updates": 189148, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1792352657, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9475.927088840484, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33978, "avg_candidate_generations": 1998.7058823529412, "candidate_moves_total": 2912139, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.70660427335335, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1355, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 33961, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2910784, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1736916, "avg_legality_checks": 102171.5294117647, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16061, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1736916, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16061, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3971955, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 233644.41176470587, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6348756005, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1598.3957534765625, "renju_forbidden_checks": 66872, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3933.6470588235293, "renju_forbidden_ns": 441412772, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6600.86092834071, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16712, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 166799149, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18765, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 167231069, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 31244, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 105890827, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 151, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1491727, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 134355, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7903.235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1013700893, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7544.943567414685, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 187254, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11014.941176470587, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 492357443, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2629.3560778407937, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3294480800, "stage_ordering_ns": 865885852, "stage_eval_ns": 1793476840, "stage_threat_ns": 4335720490, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 730916, "root_tactical_annotations": 603, "search_tactical_annotations": 730313, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 189165, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 914649681, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 610477, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3262363196, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 68056, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1768696267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 94574, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118610397, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 189148, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19459993, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 147066, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 303943165, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 395345, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1189295433, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 188505, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20637223, "child_limit_applications": 33961, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33961, "child_cap_hits": 33961, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33961, "child_moves_before_total": 2894723, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2894723, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 399273, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 399273, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.23668325432114, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.756809281234357, "tt_hits": 19502, "tt_cutoffs": 5736, "beta_cutoffs": 28547, "depth_sum": 101, "avg_depth": 5.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 101, "avg_effective_depth": 5.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6100.941176470588, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6571.529411764706, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 17, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1511, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 39659, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 128, 113, 155, 99, 85, 114, 115, 129, 144, 69, 84, 145, 83, 82, 125, 95, 100, 157, 172, 130, 68, 52, 70, 55, 86, 87, 38, 53, 54, 22, 102 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 23220, "avg_search_time_ms": 1365.8823529411766, "search_nodes": 209716, "safety_nodes": 1115, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 210831, "avg_nodes": 12401.823529411764, "eval_calls": 128791, "avg_eval_calls": 7575.941176470588, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 128791, "pattern_eval_ns": 2813755, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.847450520610913, "pattern_frame_queries": 128791, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2813755, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.847450520610913, "pattern_frame_updates": 419236, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4428842116, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10564.078743237698, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 75126, "avg_candidate_generations": 4419.176470588235, "candidate_moves_total": 6126206, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.54574980699093, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1232, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 75109, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6124974, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 2431638, "avg_legality_checks": 143037.5294117647, "illegal_moves_skipped": 410, "root_legality_checks": 1232, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2430406, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 410, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6349016, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 373471.5294117647, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13975790583, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2201.2530103877516, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23193, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1364.2941176470588, "renju_forbidden_ns": 75682664, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3263.16836976674, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 944, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5587189, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8029, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 50582184, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14220, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19513291, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 140454, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8262.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1161692168, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8270.979594742763, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 178919, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10524.64705882353, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 467767985, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2614.4120244356386, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5827613675, "stage_ordering_ns": 2533850852, "stage_eval_ns": 4431655871, "stage_threat_ns": 10314927714, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1208028, "root_tactical_annotations": 3139, "search_tactical_annotations": 1204889, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 419253, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2507133352, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1009108, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7386525580, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 150350, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5256662125, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 209618, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 318527816, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 419236, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53765245, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 182990, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 235317047, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 675755, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1894165107, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 349283, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 48975721, "child_limit_applications": 75109, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 75109, "child_cap_hits": 75109, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 75109, "child_moves_before_total": 6124564, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6124564, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 717143, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 717143, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.54234512508488, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.54803019611498, "tt_hits": 36132, "tt_cutoffs": 5720, "beta_cutoffs": 58484, "depth_sum": 95, "avg_depth": 5.588235294117647, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 95, "avg_effective_depth": 5.588235294117647, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2513.529411764706, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2984.1176470588234, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 16423, "avg_search_time_ms": 966.0588235294117, "search_nodes": 121640, "safety_nodes": 923, "corridor_nodes": 30454, "corridor_branch_probes": 30826, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 19221, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 30416, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 30416, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 117, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 79, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 19221, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 117, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 114, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 866, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 389920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 7, "total_nodes": 153017, "avg_nodes": 9001.0, "eval_calls": 80388, "avg_eval_calls": 4728.705882352941, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80388, "pattern_eval_ns": 1758664, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.877195601333533, "pattern_frame_queries": 80388, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1758664, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.877195601333533, "pattern_frame_updates": 243126, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1966768924, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8089.504717718385, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38947, "avg_candidate_generations": 2291.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3328135, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.4529232033276, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1255, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 38930, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3326880, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 2339318, "avg_legality_checks": 137606.9411764706, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2339318, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4725453, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 277967.82352941175, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9819439972, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2077.9891307775147, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10812, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 636.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13721677, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1269.1155197928229, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 94350, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 900, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7374159, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9900, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6253168, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 105876, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6228.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 883233161, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8342.147049378518, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 133173, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7833.705882352941, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 377628947, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2835.62694390004, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5271045513, "stage_ordering_ns": 1271932432, "stage_eval_ns": 1968527588, "stage_threat_ns": 7977002420, "stage_proof_ns": 128485694, "tactical_annotations": 723074, "root_tactical_annotations": 3393, "search_tactical_annotations": 719681, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 304209, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2154375481, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1723713, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5111472335, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 89346, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3040127498, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 152096, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 241759425, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 61066, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 412754089, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 304192, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37032496, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 279150, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 531029243, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 282445, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 759183388, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 161479, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19608594, "child_limit_applications": 38930, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38930, "child_cap_hits": 38930, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38930, "child_moves_before_total": 3326872, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3326872, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 623285, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 623285, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.45779604418186, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.010403287952737, "tt_hits": 17154, "tt_cutoffs": 2245, "beta_cutoffs": 33761, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6101.705882352941, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6572.294117647059, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1871, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1512, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26157, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 99, 113, 144, 68, 172, 157, 128, 96, 124, 83, 53, 125, 160, 176, 139, 95, 94, 80, 140, 65 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8517, "avg_search_time_ms": 774.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 86609, "safety_nodes": 1000, "corridor_nodes": 1043, "corridor_branch_probes": 1245, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 492, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1033, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1033, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 70, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 60, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 492, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 70, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 70, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 466, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 27847200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1970800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 88652, "avg_nodes": 8059.272727272727, "eval_calls": 68097, "avg_eval_calls": 6190.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68097, "pattern_eval_ns": 1483204, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.780753924548804, "pattern_frame_queries": 68097, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1483204, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.780753924548804, "pattern_frame_updates": 173116, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1937518064, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11192.02190438781, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17584, "avg_candidate_generations": 1598.5454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 1286840, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.18243858052776, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 808, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 17573, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1286032, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 728041, "avg_legality_checks": 66185.54545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6687, "root_legality_checks": 808, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 23, "search_legality_checks": 727233, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2266366, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 206033.27272727274, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5074199915, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2238.9145949948065, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32290, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2935.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 232811419, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7210.016073087643, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7158, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 76123626, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10413, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 102433014, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13660, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44608009, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1059, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9646770, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6828.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 748478973, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9964.17552617916, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 102078, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9279.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 350073005, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3429.4657516800876, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1938244399, "stage_ordering_ns": 572754765, "stage_eval_ns": 1939001268, "stage_threat_ns": 3785033658, "stage_proof_ns": 239633793, "tactical_annotations": 214503, "root_tactical_annotations": 853, "search_tactical_annotations": 213650, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 175333, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1074461288, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 274674, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2542237277, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35831, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1458172143, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 87661, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 129173365, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2206, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13245928, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 175322, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22321331, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 43718, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 125007622, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 138733, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 798822784, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 32052, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3594469, "child_limit_applications": 17573, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17573, "child_cap_hits": 17573, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17573, "child_moves_before_total": 1279368, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1279368, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 282740, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 282740, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.80305013372788, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.089455414556422, "tt_hits": 5101, "tt_cutoffs": 888, "beta_cutoffs": 13104, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 4.636363636363637, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 4.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3900.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4628.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 237, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 17629, "avg_search_time_ms": 1602.6363636363637, "search_nodes": 122378, "safety_nodes": 691, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 123069, "avg_nodes": 11188.09090909091, "eval_calls": 81576, "avg_eval_calls": 7416.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 81576, "pattern_eval_ns": 1774885, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.757440913994312, "pattern_frame_queries": 81576, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1774885, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.757440913994312, "pattern_frame_updates": 244636, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3466639447, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14170.602229434751, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37470, "avg_candidate_generations": 3406.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 3074391, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.04939951961569, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 846, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 37459, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3073545, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 2074447, "avg_legality_checks": 188586.0909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 37470, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2074447, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 37470, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5029324, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 457211.2727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10904561639, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2168.196290197251, "renju_forbidden_checks": 147312, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 13392.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1174159411, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7970.561875475182, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 39619, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 423714288, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 52544, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 531611848, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 55005, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 217257091, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 144, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1576184, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 192552, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17504.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1951133803, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10133.022783455897, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 255770, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23251.81818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 933229809, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3648.707076670446, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5536894390, "stage_ordering_ns": 1270720218, "stage_eval_ns": 3468414332, "stage_threat_ns": 7275114563, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 732743, "root_tactical_annotations": 2361, "search_tactical_annotations": 730382, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 244647, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1516185903, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 622103, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5513963281, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 74999, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2985722470, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 122318, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 187413890, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 244636, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32095825, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 178175, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 696145902, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 368921, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1831969138, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 185647, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 25455664, "child_limit_applications": 37459, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37459, "child_cap_hits": 37459, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37459, "child_moves_before_total": 3036075, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3036075, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 446888, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 446888, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.05061533943778, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.930056862169305, "tt_hits": 19283, "tt_cutoffs": 3285, "beta_cutoffs": 30198, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 5.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 5.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1308.5454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1710.5454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1513, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 34855, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 126, 127, 79, 143, 159, 142, 157, 141, 140, 109, 108, 155, 124, 156, 80, 81, 94, 66, 78, 169, 183, 51, 96, 36, 21, 76, 123, 145, 144, 93, 122, 125, 136 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 23477, "avg_search_time_ms": 1304.2777777777778, "search_nodes": 241099, "safety_nodes": 955, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 242054, "avg_nodes": 13447.444444444445, "eval_calls": 144149, "avg_eval_calls": 8008.277777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 144149, "pattern_eval_ns": 3037534, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.072182255860255, "pattern_frame_queries": 144149, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3037534, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.072182255860255, "pattern_frame_updates": 481982, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4886057405, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10137.427134208332, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 90351, "avg_candidate_generations": 5019.5, "candidate_moves_total": 7642494, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.58671182388684, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1387, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 90333, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7641107, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 2131166, "avg_legality_checks": 118398.11111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 465, "root_legality_checks": 1387, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2129779, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 465, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6445218, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 358067.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13664627474, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2120.118741367631, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28907, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1605.9444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 104846639, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3627.032864012177, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 911, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5552705, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11310, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 67089802, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16686, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32204132, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 109490, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6082.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 852575253, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7786.78649191707, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 136656, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7592.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 325656023, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2383.0349417515513, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4903979678, "stage_ordering_ns": 2876378804, "stage_eval_ns": 4889094939, "stage_threat_ns": 10712760392, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1485661, "root_tactical_annotations": 5645, "search_tactical_annotations": 1480016, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 482000, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2733864247, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1137088, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7509540711, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 180810, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5850180878, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 240991, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 345801930, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 481982, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59066903, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 365986, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 266765890, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 590275, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1392344153, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 529400, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 64486601, "child_limit_applications": 90333, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 90333, "child_cap_hits": 90333, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 90333, "child_moves_before_total": 7640642, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7640642, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 827359, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 827359, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.58306488215824, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.158989516566482, "tt_hits": 52807, "tt_cutoffs": 6512, "beta_cutoffs": 72011, "depth_sum": 105, "avg_depth": 5.833333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 105, "avg_effective_depth": 5.833333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3230.8888888888887, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3675.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 11360, "avg_search_time_ms": 631.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 95742, "safety_nodes": 1050, "corridor_nodes": 1107, "corridor_branch_probes": 1283, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 325, "corridor_neutral_exits": 32, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 1084, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1084, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 113, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 90, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 32, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 325, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 113, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 111, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 842, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 379600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 97899, "avg_nodes": 5438.833333333333, "eval_calls": 62165, "avg_eval_calls": 3453.6111111111113, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62165, "pattern_eval_ns": 1301857, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.941960910480173, "pattern_frame_queries": 62165, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1301857, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.941960910480173, "pattern_frame_updates": 191316, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1463688276, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7650.631813335006, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31511, "avg_candidate_generations": 1750.611111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 2659248, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.39110152010409, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1419, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 31493, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2657829, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 1895172, "avg_legality_checks": 105287.33333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1895172, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3626354, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 201464.11111111112, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7419586491, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2046.0182571806283, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10709, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 594.9444444444445, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12803404, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1195.5741899337006, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 140821, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 812, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7387384, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9877, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5275199, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 92986, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5165.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 730127571, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7852.016120706343, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118083, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6560.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 285580092, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2418.469144584741, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4228574227, "stage_ordering_ns": 1006671593, "stage_eval_ns": 1464990133, "stage_threat_ns": 4394396841, "stage_proof_ns": 179084742, "tactical_annotations": 512713, "root_tactical_annotations": 2908, "search_tactical_annotations": 509805, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 193728, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1133894454, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 557350, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3069995043, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64160, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1997152404, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 96855, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 139669995, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2394, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16043921, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 193710, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23647041, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 210114, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 412049046, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 206507, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 614666313, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 96092, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11146387, "child_limit_applications": 31493, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31493, "child_cap_hits": 31493, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31493, "child_moves_before_total": 2657815, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2657815, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 504181, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 504181, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.39383355031276, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.009303654780428, "tt_hits": 13586, "tt_cutoffs": 2000, "beta_cutoffs": 27464, "depth_sum": 84, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 84, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6325.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6769.944444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1873, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1514, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24541, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 113, 114, 126, 98, 66, 110, 96, 81, 156, 141, 80, 100, 86, 99, 64, 48, 101, 84, 69, 129, 144, 130, 146, 131, 132, 127 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8404, "avg_search_time_ms": 646.4615384615385, "search_nodes": 95523, "safety_nodes": 1033, "corridor_nodes": 456, "corridor_branch_probes": 562, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 160, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 443, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 443, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 87, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 160, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 100, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 730, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23797600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 97012, "avg_nodes": 7462.461538461538, "eval_calls": 70768, "avg_eval_calls": 5443.692307692308, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70768, "pattern_eval_ns": 1482105, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.94315227221343, "pattern_frame_queries": 70768, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1482105, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.94315227221343, "pattern_frame_updates": 190926, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1805764139, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9457.9268355279, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23508, "avg_candidate_generations": 1808.3076923076924, "candidate_moves_total": 1802896, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.69287051216607, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 943, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 23495, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1801953, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 755858, "avg_legality_checks": 58142.92307692308, "illegal_moves_skipped": 94, "root_legality_checks": 943, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 754915, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 94, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2318433, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 178341.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4974800945, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2145.760065095692, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13849, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1065.3076923076924, "renju_forbidden_ns": 38739179, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2797.254603220449, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 208, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 874035, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3540, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21902090, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10059, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15519514, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 443540, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 57350, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4411.538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 529851803, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9238.915483870967, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 78199, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6015.307692307692, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 245427055, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3138.493522935076, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1821971545, "stage_ordering_ns": 745816074, "stage_eval_ns": 1807246244, "stage_threat_ns": 3752185905, "stage_proof_ns": 231653273, "tactical_annotations": 280917, "root_tactical_annotations": 1496, "search_tactical_annotations": 279421, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 192025, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1097129949, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 302382, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2484519613, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47657, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1665900397, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 96006, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 134580325, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1086, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6086711, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 192012, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23065472, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62099, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 88396642, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 161893, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 660784327, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 56925, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6803835, "child_limit_applications": 23495, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23495, "child_cap_hits": 23495, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23495, "child_moves_before_total": 1801859, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1801859, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 376413, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 376413, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.69116833368801, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02098318791232, "tt_hits": 8412, "tt_cutoffs": 1200, "beta_cutoffs": 18884, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5061.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5676.615384615385, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 967, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 16121, "avg_search_time_ms": 1240.076923076923, "search_nodes": 124250, "safety_nodes": 398, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 124648, "avg_nodes": 9588.307692307691, "eval_calls": 80925, "avg_eval_calls": 6225.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80925, "pattern_eval_ns": 1713121, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.16924312635156, "pattern_frame_queries": 80925, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1713121, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.16924312635156, "pattern_frame_updates": 248364, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2249718027, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9058.148632652075, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 40655, "avg_candidate_generations": 3127.3076923076924, "candidate_moves_total": 3591663, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.34492682326898, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 982, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 40642, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3590681, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 2480154, "avg_legality_checks": 190781.07692307694, "illegal_moves_skipped": 75, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2480154, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5142024, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 395540.3076923077, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10605708868, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2062.555302736821, "renju_forbidden_checks": 61405, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4723.461538461538, "renju_forbidden_ns": 103928906, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1692.5153651982737, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1223, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3504206, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4235, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18504456, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 55947, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 81920244, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 167485, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12883.461538461539, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1590387941, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9495.70374063349, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 234655, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18050.384615384617, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 778702425, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3318.499179646715, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5821979157, "stage_ordering_ns": 1434745362, "stage_eval_ns": 2251431148, "stage_threat_ns": 6517434238, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 622705, "root_tactical_annotations": 3369, "search_tactical_annotations": 619336, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 248377, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1474258890, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 535869, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4806780885, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 81377, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2742613989, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124182, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 183324780, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 248364, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31097851, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 137117, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 607220061, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 317366, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1456895334, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 168222, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21971832, "child_limit_applications": 40642, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 40642, "child_cap_hits": 40642, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 40642, "child_moves_before_total": 3590606, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3590606, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 414882, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 414882, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.34717779636829, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.208208257467644, "tt_hits": 20971, "tt_cutoffs": 2615, "beta_cutoffs": 31472, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 5.153846153846154, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 5.153846153846154, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4333.384615384615, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4948.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1397, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1515, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21303, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 96, 98, 82, 127, 128, 144, 110, 124, 80, 64, 125, 95, 79, 81, 67, 52, 69, 68, 111, 83, 109, 113, 108 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 16489, "avg_search_time_ms": 1374.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 172056, "safety_nodes": 223, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 172279, "avg_nodes": 14356.583333333334, "eval_calls": 112572, "avg_eval_calls": 9381.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 112572, "pattern_eval_ns": 2313015, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.546983264044346, "pattern_frame_queries": 112572, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2313015, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.546983264044346, "pattern_frame_updates": 344000, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4351582060, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12649.94784883721, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 55971, "avg_candidate_generations": 4664.25, "candidate_moves_total": 4445630, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.42738203712636, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 776, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 55959, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4444854, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1281535, "avg_legality_checks": 106794.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5054, "root_legality_checks": 776, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 1280759, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5050, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4655775, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 387981.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9653467260, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2073.439386568294, "renju_forbidden_checks": 63805, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5317.083333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 299147154, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4688.459431079069, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5821, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52052126, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29694, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 174205773, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28270, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 72702575, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 186680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 101131, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8427.583333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 840649419, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8312.48004073924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 136061, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11338.416666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 350743820, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2577.8424383181073, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2983698671, "stage_ordering_ns": 1708981782, "stage_eval_ns": 4353895075, "stage_threat_ns": 7394792259, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 803404, "root_tactical_annotations": 3328, "search_tactical_annotations": 800076, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 344012, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1969957251, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 656641, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5090355207, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 111997, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3717226994, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 172000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 256478455, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 344000, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42232052, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 156315, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 154079442, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 388318, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1218980611, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 258771, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 35769294, "child_limit_applications": 55959, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 55959, "child_cap_hits": 55959, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 55959, "child_moves_before_total": 4439804, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4439804, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 490451, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 490451, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.34030272163548, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.764470415840169, "tt_hits": 27730, "tt_cutoffs": 3471, "beta_cutoffs": 42731, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 4.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 4.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3262.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3897.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4802, "avg_search_time_ms": 436.54545454545456, "search_nodes": 48963, "safety_nodes": 879, "corridor_nodes": 60, "corridor_branch_probes": 73, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 18, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 57, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 57, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 30, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 27, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 30, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 30, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 159, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 102640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49902, "avg_nodes": 4536.545454545455, "eval_calls": 34954, "avg_eval_calls": 3177.6363636363635, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34954, "pattern_eval_ns": 716882, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.509297934428105, "pattern_frame_queries": 34954, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 716882, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.509297934428105, "pattern_frame_updates": 97826, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 922331072, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9428.281561139165, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13162, "avg_candidate_generations": 1196.5454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 987301, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.01147242060478, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 715, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 13151, "search_candidate_moves_total": 986586, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 575458, "avg_legality_checks": 52314.36363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 740, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 575458, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 740, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1539061, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 139914.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3005580826, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1952.8666024283639, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19804, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1800.3636363636363, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51725876, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2611.890325186831, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 756, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7377507, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2406, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19538841, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16602, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24357016, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 452512, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 57431, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5221.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 505467956, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8801.308631227037, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84686, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7698.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 225065683, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2657.6492336395627, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1266025592, "stage_ordering_ns": 373759062, "stage_eval_ns": 923047954, "stage_threat_ns": 2168707890, "stage_proof_ns": 38278609, "tactical_annotations": 193127, "root_tactical_annotations": 701, "search_tactical_annotations": 192426, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 98011, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 554059471, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 190141, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1529797125, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26524, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 876895778, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 49000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68752361, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 174, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 674384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 98000, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11604059, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 54973, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 181534356, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 104405, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 469505313, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 33749, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3820490, "child_limit_applications": 13151, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13151, "child_cap_hits": 13151, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13151, "child_moves_before_total": 985846, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 985846, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 210442, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 210442, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.96357691430309, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001977035966846, "tt_hits": 4106, "tt_cutoffs": 808, "beta_cutoffs": 10866, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5276.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6003.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1516, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25700, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 67, 82, 98, 96, 68, 111, 141, 110, 66, 65, 83, 113, 115, 99, 53, 38, 39, 81, 69, 70, 54, 124, 138, 84, 55, 41, 52, 56, 51 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 14029, "avg_search_time_ms": 935.2666666666667, "search_nodes": 149479, "safety_nodes": 280, "corridor_nodes": 5259, "corridor_branch_probes": 5643, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2586, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_plies_followed": 5230, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5230, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 135, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 106, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2586, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 135, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 132, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1099, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 645280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 21520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 155018, "avg_nodes": 10334.533333333333, "eval_calls": 106757, "avg_eval_calls": 7117.133333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 106757, "pattern_eval_ns": 2193592, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.54752381576852, "pattern_frame_queries": 106757, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2193592, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.54752381576852, "pattern_frame_updates": 298824, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3256579729, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10897.98586793564, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39947, "avg_candidate_generations": 2663.133333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 3123404, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.18870002753648, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1046, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 39932, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3122358, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1005858, "avg_legality_checks": 67057.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1317, "root_legality_checks": 1046, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1004812, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1317, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4043905, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 269593.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8343493062, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2063.226772636845, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26224, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1748.2666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 132088358, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5036.926403294692, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1379, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12374386, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12289, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 82607724, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11728, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 33037460, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 828, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4068788, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90898, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6059.866666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 735118514, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8087.290303417017, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 122045, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8136.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 314752897, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2578.9905116965056, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2382218447, "stage_ordering_ns": 1181420326, "stage_eval_ns": 3258773321, "stage_threat_ns": 6443575787, "stage_proof_ns": 698824142, "tactical_annotations": 686504, "root_tactical_annotations": 3738, "search_tactical_annotations": 682766, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 309569, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1794769217, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 862297, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4313799333, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 82791, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2713080342, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 154777, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 216535644, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10730, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 64731285, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 309554, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36595912, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 220759, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 157092371, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 291244, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 884097076, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 174501, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17144396, "child_limit_applications": 39932, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39932, "child_cap_hits": 39932, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39932, "child_moves_before_total": 3121041, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3121041, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 645722, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 645722, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.1588951217069, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.170539917860363, "tt_hits": 17851, "tt_cutoffs": 2723, "beta_cutoffs": 33139, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 4.4, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 4.4, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4668.266666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5201.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 11657, "avg_search_time_ms": 832.6428571428571, "search_nodes": 89875, "safety_nodes": 1290, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91165, "avg_nodes": 6511.785714285715, "eval_calls": 50986, "avg_eval_calls": 3641.8571428571427, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50986, "pattern_eval_ns": 1071314, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.011924842113523, "pattern_frame_queries": 50986, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1071314, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.011924842113523, "pattern_frame_updates": 179586, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1635434891, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9106.694792467119, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34823, "avg_candidate_generations": 2487.3571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 2673349, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.76963501134308, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 983, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 34809, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2672366, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1830273, "avg_legality_checks": 130733.78571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5599, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1830273, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5599, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3739178, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 267084.14285714284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7669891066, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2051.2238427804186, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30603, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2185.9285714285716, "renju_forbidden_ns": 139109586, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4545.619253014411, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5603, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 49982093, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7200, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 59165209, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17800, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29962284, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 94668, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6762.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 830191363, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8769.503559809016, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 128791, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9199.357142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 377410336, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2930.4092366702644, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4257531552, "stage_ordering_ns": 1033554932, "stage_eval_ns": 1636506205, "stage_threat_ns": 4648319886, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 596723, "root_tactical_annotations": 1257, "search_tactical_annotations": 595466, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 179600, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1042879721, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 467202, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3431663069, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69728, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2224563916, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89793, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 128222916, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 179586, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21747937, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 124168, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 197944033, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 273296, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1008874578, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 199259, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23806243, "child_limit_applications": 34809, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34809, "child_cap_hits": 34809, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34809, "child_moves_before_total": 2666767, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2666767, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 328114, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 328114, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.6114223333046, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.426125427332012, "tt_hits": 20699, "tt_cutoffs": 3998, "beta_cutoffs": 28520, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 5.857142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 5.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4208.642857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4780.071428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 197, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1517, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24233, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 68, 82, 114, 98, 140, 97, 67, 129, 145, 125, 83, 124, 123, 139, 153, 109, 154, 93, 141, 79, 94, 65, 81, 51, 37, 107 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 19195, "avg_search_time_ms": 1279.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 208477, "safety_nodes": 211, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 208688, "avg_nodes": 13912.533333333333, "eval_calls": 138814, "avg_eval_calls": 9254.266666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 138814, "pattern_eval_ns": 2791366, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.10867779906926, "pattern_frame_queries": 138814, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2791366, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.10867779906926, "pattern_frame_updates": 416816, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5208656640, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12496.297263060918, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 65181, "avg_candidate_generations": 4345.4, "candidate_moves_total": 5358592, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.2109510440159, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1076, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 65166, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5357516, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1527443, "avg_legality_checks": 101829.53333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4327, "root_legality_checks": 1076, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1526367, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4326, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5715195, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 381013.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11015726541, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1927.4454399193728, "renju_forbidden_checks": 133007, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8867.133333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 430487389, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3236.576939559572, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15557, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 61571839, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 54690, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 231420964, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 62657, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 137209915, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 103, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 284671, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 135979, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9065.266666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 977365090, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7187.617867464829, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 175457, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11697.133333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 363072386, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2069.2955310987877, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3340561604, "stage_ordering_ns": 1960904374, "stage_eval_ns": 5211448006, "stage_threat_ns": 8611042119, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1345780, "root_tactical_annotations": 4193, "search_tactical_annotations": 1341587, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 416831, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2236942349, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1119732, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5994617138, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 130430, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4174318575, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 208408, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 285618890, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 416816, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48529315, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 343497, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 270423363, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 645791, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1549783369, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 356492, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 45334427, "child_limit_applications": 65166, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 65166, "child_cap_hits": 65166, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 65166, "child_moves_before_total": 5353190, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5353190, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 776308, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 776308, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.1469784857134, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.912776601295153, "tt_hits": 30706, "tt_cutoffs": 4429, "beta_cutoffs": 50116, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3932.9333333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4466.266666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 602, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 5023, "avg_search_time_ms": 358.7857142857143, "search_nodes": 50710, "safety_nodes": 1415, "corridor_nodes": 78, "corridor_branch_probes": 96, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 73, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 73, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 301, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 191120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 52203, "avg_nodes": 3728.785714285714, "eval_calls": 34499, "avg_eval_calls": 2464.214285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34499, "pattern_eval_ns": 691004, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.02968201976869, "pattern_frame_queries": 34499, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 691004, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.02968201976869, "pattern_frame_updates": 101290, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 977510950, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9650.61654654951, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15297, "avg_candidate_generations": 1092.642857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 1143967, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.78374844740799, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 994, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 15283, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1142973, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 555467, "avg_legality_checks": 39676.21428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2040, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 555467, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2040, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1617298, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 115521.28571428571, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3093582468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1912.8091842072395, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18492, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1320.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 70832825, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3830.457765520225, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3113, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19648021, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5944, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31873770, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9270, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18841902, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 165, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 469132, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3607.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 453630294, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8982.422359510514, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5150.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 209708719, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2908.5814008321777, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1249106317, "stage_ordering_ns": 422697620, "stage_eval_ns": 978201954, "stage_threat_ns": 2267734760, "stage_proof_ns": 69666435, "tactical_annotations": 256827, "root_tactical_annotations": 646, "search_tactical_annotations": 256181, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 101552, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 542567524, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 255128, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1642648345, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30896, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 989549806, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50769, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 65927613, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 248, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1256316, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 101538, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11354094, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 141560016, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 156287, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 506970225, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 38470, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3980868, "child_limit_applications": 15283, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15283, "child_cap_hits": 15283, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15283, "child_moves_before_total": 1140933, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1140933, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 247022, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 247022, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.6537329058431, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.163187855787477, "tt_hits": 4591, "tt_cutoffs": 863, "beta_cutoffs": 13051, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5847.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6419.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1827, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1518, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17668, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 82, 124, 114, 98, 84, 125, 127, 139, 54, 68, 69, 99, 24, 39, 153, 154, 140, 109, 169, 94 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9559, "avg_search_time_ms": 796.5833333333334, "search_nodes": 99081, "safety_nodes": 412, "corridor_nodes": 2997, "corridor_branch_probes": 3361, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1356, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 32, "corridor_plies_followed": 2973, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2973, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 77, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1356, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 32, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 77, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 72, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 573, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23979440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 5, "total_nodes": 102490, "avg_nodes": 8540.833333333334, "eval_calls": 75288, "avg_eval_calls": 6274.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75288, "pattern_eval_ns": 1548677, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.5700377218149, "pattern_frame_queries": 75288, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1548677, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.5700377218149, "pattern_frame_updates": 198058, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2316402313, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11695.575604115966, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22599, "avg_candidate_generations": 1883.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1754846, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.65148900393822, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 813, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 22587, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1754033, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 672809, "avg_legality_checks": 56067.416666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1561, "root_legality_checks": 813, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 671996, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1555, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2746757, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 228896.41666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5762048338, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2097.7641407667297, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30175, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2514.5833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124801693, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4135.930173985087, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1787, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11959296, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11554, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72967956, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16014, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36343563, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 820, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3530878, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 78525, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6543.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 688726975, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8770.798790194205, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109373, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9114.416666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 302940204, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2769.7896555822736, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1618600147, "stage_ordering_ns": 715175819, "stage_eval_ns": 2317950990, "stage_threat_ns": 4427893323, "stage_proof_ns": 437953557, "tactical_annotations": 319035, "root_tactical_annotations": 1947, "search_tactical_annotations": 317088, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 204170, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1207621546, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 462232, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3009007424, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46821, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1727164384, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102079, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 145598790, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6100, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 33668261, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 204158, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24910496, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 83837, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 176859562, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 163162, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 668286782, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 72036, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7086806, "child_limit_applications": 22587, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22587, "child_cap_hits": 22587, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22587, "child_moves_before_total": 1752478, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1752478, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 361490, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 361490, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.58790454686324, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00433877894364, "tt_hits": 9305, "tt_cutoffs": 1154, "beta_cutoffs": 17654, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4687.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5354.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 930, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8100, "avg_search_time_ms": 736.3636363636364, "search_nodes": 63967, "safety_nodes": 1067, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 65034, "avg_nodes": 5912.181818181818, "eval_calls": 40242, "avg_eval_calls": 3658.3636363636365, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40242, "pattern_eval_ns": 840532, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.88693404900353, "pattern_frame_queries": 40242, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 840532, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.88693404900353, "pattern_frame_updates": 127810, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1465302212, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11464.691432595258, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21887, "avg_candidate_generations": 1989.7272727272727, "candidate_moves_total": 1643938, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.11024809247499, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 731, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 21876, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1643207, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 1002732, "avg_legality_checks": 91157.45454545454, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1331, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1002732, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1331, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2535859, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 230532.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5285079037, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2084.1375790215466, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23525, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2138.6363636363635, "renju_forbidden_ns": 75752765, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3220.0962805526037, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1696, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9978777, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6522, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 45054871, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15268, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20627367, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 91750, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90942, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8267.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 803162118, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8831.586263772515, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 126441, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11494.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 354214082, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2801.417910329719, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2384174920, "stage_ordering_ns": 680146492, "stage_eval_ns": 1466142744, "stage_threat_ns": 3521102179, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 321531, "root_tactical_annotations": 862, "search_tactical_annotations": 320669, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 127821, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 764090007, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 281495, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2639772134, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43836, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1583018999, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 63905, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93233701, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 127810, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16099672, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 57510, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 240031374, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 180140, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 816392741, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 83881, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7906665, "child_limit_applications": 21876, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21876, "child_cap_hits": 21876, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21876, "child_moves_before_total": 1641876, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1641876, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 215561, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 215561, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.05375754251234, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.853766684951545, "tt_hits": 10266, "tt_cutoffs": 1788, "beta_cutoffs": 17084, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3988.5454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4715.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 355, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1519, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18066, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 98, 54, 68, 84, 83, 53, 113, 128, 99, 85, 81, 129, 115, 131, 65, 49, 67, 51, 66, 64, 69 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 14183, "avg_search_time_ms": 1181.9166666666667, "search_nodes": 151348, "safety_nodes": 349, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 151697, "avg_nodes": 12641.416666666666, "eval_calls": 103540, "avg_eval_calls": 8628.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 103540, "pattern_eval_ns": 2132608, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.59694803940506, "pattern_frame_queries": 103540, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2132608, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.59694803940506, "pattern_frame_updates": 302588, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4214622596, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13928.584729070551, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 45109, "avg_candidate_generations": 3759.0833333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 3268666, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.46150435611519, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 756, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 45097, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3267910, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 891084, "avg_legality_checks": 74257.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1438, "root_legality_checks": 756, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 890328, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1438, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3948694, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 329057.8333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8430088904, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2134.9055925832695, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31363, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2613.5833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 186611976, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5950.067786882632, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1621, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13485088, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17957, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 135331618, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11782, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37790699, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4571, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 105407, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8783.916666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 858243075, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8142.182919540448, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 136179, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11348.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 337338448, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2477.16937266392, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2113214635, "stage_ordering_ns": 1279438192, "stage_eval_ns": 4216755204, "stage_threat_ns": 6530646469, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 779039, "root_tactical_annotations": 2666, "search_tactical_annotations": 776373, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 302600, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1760485870, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 600304, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4475817641, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90271, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3167064201, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 151294, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 221337621, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 302588, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37618847, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 185646, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 206179956, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 324376, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1102377972, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 269017, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 35386490, "child_limit_applications": 45097, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 45097, "child_cap_hits": 45097, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 45097, "child_moves_before_total": 3266472, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3266472, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 466233, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 466233, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.43213517528882, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.338448233807126, "tt_hits": 24982, "tt_cutoffs": 2657, "beta_cutoffs": 35405, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3489.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4156.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 678, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3871, "avg_search_time_ms": 351.90909090909093, "search_nodes": 34165, "safety_nodes": 845, "corridor_nodes": 28, "corridor_branch_probes": 28, "corridor_max_depth": 3, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 22, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 22, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 46, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 46, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 46, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 296, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 201360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35038, "avg_nodes": 3185.2727272727275, "eval_calls": 22662, "avg_eval_calls": 2060.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22662, "pattern_eval_ns": 483142, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.319477539493427, "pattern_frame_queries": 22662, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 483142, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.319477539493427, "pattern_frame_updates": 68230, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 688393063, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10089.301817382384, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10781, "avg_candidate_generations": 980.0909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 758125, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.32047119933216, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 681, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 10770, "search_candidate_moves_total": 757444, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 438225, "avg_legality_checks": 39838.63636363636, "illegal_moves_skipped": 130, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 438225, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 130, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1191362, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 108305.63636363637, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2482354293, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2083.6272207775637, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4287, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 389.72727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 17820123, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4156.78166550035, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 132, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1207695, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1454, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12687515, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2701, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3924913, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42197, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3836.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 385599868, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9138.087257387966, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 57586, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5235.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 173201741, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3007.7057097211127, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1044620531, "stage_ordering_ns": 310872300, "stage_eval_ns": 688876205, "stage_threat_ns": 1718469527, "stage_proof_ns": 79272620, "tactical_annotations": 159923, "root_tactical_annotations": 626, "search_tactical_annotations": 159297, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 68377, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 403360261, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 157937, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1253865319, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21812, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 739160526, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34183, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 49075682, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 136, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 644892, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 68366, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8246631, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 40333, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 144515871, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 92713, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 368026775, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 26877, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3276742, "child_limit_applications": 10770, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10770, "child_cap_hits": 10770, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10770, "child_moves_before_total": 757314, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 757314, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 172915, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 172915, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.31699164345405, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.055246053853296, "tt_hits": 3744, "tt_cutoffs": 683, "beta_cutoffs": 9303, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5474.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6201.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1877, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1520, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29667, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 82, 97, 98, 84, 99, 113, 129, 126, 130, 111, 141, 83, 125, 65, 81, 93, 157, 109, 143, 94, 95, 69, 55, 115, 142, 172, 140, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 12208, "avg_search_time_ms": 813.8666666666667, "search_nodes": 156499, "safety_nodes": 476, "corridor_nodes": 1204, "corridor_branch_probes": 1290, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 554, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 1190, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1190, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 109, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 95, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 554, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 109, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 105, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 842, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 862320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 15920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 158179, "avg_nodes": 10545.266666666666, "eval_calls": 116470, "avg_eval_calls": 7764.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 116470, "pattern_eval_ns": 2419062, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.769829140551217, "pattern_frame_queries": 116470, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2419062, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.769829140551217, "pattern_frame_updates": 312864, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3046870248, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9738.641224301933, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37723, "avg_candidate_generations": 2514.866666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 2936547, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.84500172308671, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1025, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 37708, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2935522, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1148199, "avg_legality_checks": 76546.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 162, "root_legality_checks": 1025, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1147174, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 162, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3694394, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 246292.93333333332, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7183059272, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1944.313268157105, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30594, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2039.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 80508367, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2631.5083676537884, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1013, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5153514, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9721, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 42404978, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19088, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30355599, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 772, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2594276, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76834, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5122.266666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 566911259, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7378.390543249083, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 103767, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6917.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 232503046, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2240.626075727351, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2519214218, "stage_ordering_ns": 1035909153, "stage_eval_ns": 3049289310, "stage_threat_ns": 5279720330, "stage_proof_ns": 259449660, "tactical_annotations": 571792, "root_tactical_annotations": 2959, "search_tactical_annotations": 568833, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 315477, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1630082162, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 593789, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3382480093, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 76532, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2369443167, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 157731, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 203619277, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2598, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13724445, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 315462, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35355409, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 190965, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 138941351, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 262675, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 748023521, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 118152, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14458944, "child_limit_applications": 37708, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37708, "child_cap_hits": 37708, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37708, "child_moves_before_total": 2935360, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2935360, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 603432, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 603432, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.84448923305399, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002758035430148, "tt_hits": 14614, "tt_cutoffs": 2254, "beta_cutoffs": 30099, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 4.4, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 4.4, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4781.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5314.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 17448, "avg_search_time_ms": 1246.2857142857142, "search_nodes": 145504, "safety_nodes": 940, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 146444, "avg_nodes": 10460.285714285714, "eval_calls": 81521, "avg_eval_calls": 5822.928571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 81521, "pattern_eval_ns": 1659980, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.362605954293986, "pattern_frame_queries": 81521, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1659980, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.362605954293986, "pattern_frame_updates": 290842, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2330848856, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8014.14120381513, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 58817, "avg_candidate_generations": 4201.214285714285, "candidate_moves_total": 4331543, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.64440552901372, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 958, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 58803, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4330585, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 3072245, "avg_legality_checks": 219446.07142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 427, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3072245, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 427, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6034521, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 431037.21428571426, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11643282159, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1929.445959173893, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42725, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3051.785714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 56268039, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1316.98160327677, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1421, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7427725, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3954, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16373691, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37336, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32404091, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 62532, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 128340, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9167.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 924399989, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7202.74262895434, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 167546, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11967.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 379404081, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2264.4771047951012, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6572813532, "stage_ordering_ns": 1570313849, "stage_eval_ns": 2332508836, "stage_threat_ns": 6851314207, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 957000, "root_tactical_annotations": 2820, "search_tactical_annotations": 954180, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 290856, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1528504931, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 745494, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5050244454, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 117717, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3592711729, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 145421, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 195308970, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 290842, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33545866, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 209688, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 289194001, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 418077, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1168158863, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 329235, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 43709986, "child_limit_applications": 58803, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 58803, "child_cap_hits": 58803, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 58803, "child_moves_before_total": 4330158, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4330158, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 497870, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 497870, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.63838579664304, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.466744893967995, "tt_hits": 33256, "tt_cutoffs": 5098, "beta_cutoffs": 47874, "depth_sum": 81, "avg_depth": 5.785714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 81, "avg_effective_depth": 5.785714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2064.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2636.285714285714, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1521, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30019, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 127, 142, 126, 114, 156, 82, 98, 84, 171, 100, 86, 141, 140, 154, 124, 108, 139, 125, 155, 123, 172, 188, 173, 170, 187, 203, 159, 201, 175, 174, 143, 111, 191 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 23101, "avg_search_time_ms": 1358.8823529411766, "search_nodes": 273021, "safety_nodes": 275, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 273296, "avg_nodes": 16076.235294117647, "eval_calls": 172263, "avg_eval_calls": 10133.117647058823, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 172263, "pattern_eval_ns": 3373995, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.586301179011162, "pattern_frame_queries": 172263, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3373995, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.586301179011162, "pattern_frame_updates": 545888, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5902750493, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10813.116413989683, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 92264, "avg_candidate_generations": 5427.294117647059, "candidate_moves_total": 8465831, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.7566006242955, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1338, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 92247, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8464493, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 2326795, "avg_legality_checks": 136870.29411764705, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2344, "root_legality_checks": 1338, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2325457, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2344, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7814165, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 459656.76470588235, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13311341724, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1703.4886931617134, "renju_forbidden_checks": 64784, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3810.823529411765, "renju_forbidden_ns": 244992077, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3781.6756760928624, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2774, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15322845, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33457, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 167747109, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28553, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 61922123, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 162714, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9571.411764705883, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1105489531, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6794.065237164596, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 222240, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13072.941176470587, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 476609767, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2144.5723857091434, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4405627988, "stage_ordering_ns": 2563816594, "stage_eval_ns": 5906124488, "stage_threat_ns": 10112023783, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2034884, "root_tactical_annotations": 5181, "search_tactical_annotations": 2029703, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 545905, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2509913175, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1656102, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7140657478, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 184604, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4854952577, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 272944, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 331776069, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 545888, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56693834, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 497839, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 278383684, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 973644, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2007252067, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 563401, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 72983227, "child_limit_applications": 92247, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 92247, "child_cap_hits": 92247, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 92247, "child_moves_before_total": 8462149, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8462149, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 1199096, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1199096, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.733595672488, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.998753346992315, "tt_hits": 47926, "tt_cutoffs": 8435, "beta_cutoffs": 72609, "depth_sum": 74, "avg_depth": 4.352941176470588, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 74, "avg_effective_depth": 4.352941176470588, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4967.235294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5437.823529411765, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1741, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 6903, "avg_search_time_ms": 431.4375, "search_nodes": 76161, "safety_nodes": 1660, "corridor_nodes": 1454, "corridor_branch_probes": 1714, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 5, "corridor_depth_exits": 689, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1438, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1438, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 73, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 689, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 73, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 73, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 457, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 271760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 79275, "avg_nodes": 4954.6875, "eval_calls": 53298, "avg_eval_calls": 3331.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53298, "pattern_eval_ns": 1039742, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.508086607377386, "pattern_frame_queries": 53298, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1039742, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.508086607377386, "pattern_frame_updates": 152172, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1166205305, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7663.731205478011, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21686, "avg_candidate_generations": 1355.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1788164, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.45706907682376, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1262, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 21670, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1786902, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1008863, "avg_legality_checks": 63053.9375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 192, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1008863, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 192, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2476141, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 154758.8125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4300807961, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1736.899458068018, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13574, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 848.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31613467, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2328.97207897451, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 203, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1484204, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2414, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16187051, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10957, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13942212, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72419, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4526.1875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 562087932, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7761.608583382814, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 99121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6195.0625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 253523581, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2557.7181525610113, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1994042157, "stage_ordering_ns": 588992071, "stage_eval_ns": 1167245047, "stage_threat_ns": 3025586695, "stage_proof_ns": 74421496, "tactical_annotations": 366987, "root_tactical_annotations": 1111, "search_tactical_annotations": 365876, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 155210, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 742951906, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 412800, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2149267073, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44304, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1302497983, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77597, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91944446, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3022, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16933685, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 155194, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15933752, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 101331, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 265435605, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 191331, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 529339816, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 74325, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8555833, "child_limit_applications": 21670, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21670, "child_cap_hits": 21670, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21670, "child_moves_before_total": 1786710, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1786710, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 351245, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 351245, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.4508537148131, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.208814028610984, "tt_hits": 8064, "tt_cutoffs": 1118, "beta_cutoffs": 18188, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6077.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6577.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1911, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1522, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22515, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 67, 82, 96, 98, 66, 113, 143, 114, 68, 69, 81, 111, 53, 39, 38, 23, 64, 65, 80, 48, 52, 24, 94 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 11992, "avg_search_time_ms": 999.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 124901, "safety_nodes": 188, "corridor_nodes": 5858, "corridor_branch_probes": 6112, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3117, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 5836, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5836, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 85, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 63, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3117, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 85, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 82, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 686, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 663680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 26080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 130947, "avg_nodes": 10912.25, "eval_calls": 90653, "avg_eval_calls": 7554.416666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 90653, "pattern_eval_ns": 1847494, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.379844020606047, "pattern_frame_queries": 90653, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1847494, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.379844020606047, "pattern_frame_updates": 249698, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2736334864, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10958.577417520364, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32310, "avg_candidate_generations": 2692.5, "candidate_moves_total": 2418784, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.86177653977097, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 782, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 32298, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2418002, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 864121, "avg_legality_checks": 72010.08333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1377, "root_legality_checks": 782, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 863339, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1377, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3479197, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 289933.0833333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7245083527, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2082.4010617967306, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26407, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2200.5833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 138541084, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5246.377248456849, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1497, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12838497, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12712, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 84416242, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10946, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 35980490, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1252, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5305855, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 79119, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6593.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 642047083, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8114.954473640972, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 105202, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8766.833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 265369266, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2522.4735841523925, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2070995499, "stage_ordering_ns": 946644023, "stage_eval_ns": 2738182358, "stage_threat_ns": 5555291745, "stage_proof_ns": 629059080, "tactical_annotations": 483543, "root_tactical_annotations": 2905, "search_tactical_annotations": 480638, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 261552, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1522783961, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 710346, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3739436631, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67464, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2295353692, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 130770, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 181389197, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 11842, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 70227716, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 261540, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30825001, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 147455, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 110626045, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 219515, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 738695654, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 116573, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10629239, "child_limit_applications": 32298, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32298, "child_cap_hits": 32298, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32298, "child_moves_before_total": 2416625, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2416625, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 520298, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 520298, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.82274444238033, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.109294693169854, "tt_hits": 13446, "tt_cutoffs": 1899, "beta_cutoffs": 26506, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3753.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4419.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10511, "avg_search_time_ms": 955.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 82271, "safety_nodes": 865, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 83136, "avg_nodes": 7557.818181818182, "eval_calls": 46024, "avg_eval_calls": 4184.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46024, "pattern_eval_ns": 942564, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.479836606987657, "pattern_frame_queries": 46024, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 942564, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.479836606987657, "pattern_frame_updates": 164418, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1471087845, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8947.243276283618, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32734, "avg_candidate_generations": 2975.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2448690, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.80570660475347, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 723, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 32723, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2447967, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 1656434, "avg_legality_checks": 150584.9090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1476, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1656434, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1476, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3342725, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 303884.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6963459990, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2083.1686692743197, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21300, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1936.3636363636363, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65036438, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3053.353896713615, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1482, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13111565, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4988, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35914205, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14830, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16010668, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75830, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6893.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 630625208, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8316.30236054332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98174, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8924.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 265468110, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2704.0571841831847, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3843416281, "stage_ordering_ns": 955865846, "stage_eval_ns": 1472030409, "stage_threat_ns": 4167863076, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 526019, "root_tactical_annotations": 1201, "search_tactical_annotations": 524818, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 164429, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 942847939, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 412508, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3067835584, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 65530, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2093003408, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 82209, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 116030801, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 164418, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19826131, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96299, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 146033212, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 250671, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 828586394, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 179049, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21322621, "child_limit_applications": 32723, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32723, "child_cap_hits": 32723, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32723, "child_moves_before_total": 2446491, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2446491, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 301916, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 301916, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.76365247685115, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.226415670934816, "tt_hits": 18803, "tt_cutoffs": 3462, "beta_cutoffs": 26810, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3218.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3945.3636363636365, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 494, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1523, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 51858, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 128, 127, 85, 141, 155, 142, 157, 143, 144, 115, 116, 159, 130, 158, 83, 81, 88, 102, 87, 84, 86, 89, 69, 139, 140, 97, 129, 65, 49, 101, 125, 110, 133, 95, 98, 109, 170, 185, 131, 132, 67, 94, 93, 124, 154, 79 ], "move_count": 53, "black_stats": { "move_count": 27, "search_move_count": 25, "total_time_ms": 33182, "avg_search_time_ms": 1327.28, "search_nodes": 320916, "safety_nodes": 1434, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 322350, "avg_nodes": 12894.0, "eval_calls": 197164, "avg_eval_calls": 7886.56, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 197164, "pattern_eval_ns": 4263880, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.626057495283113, "pattern_frame_queries": 197164, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4263880, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.626057495283113, "pattern_frame_updates": 641550, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7306413216, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11388.688669628244, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 115342, "avg_candidate_generations": 4613.68, "candidate_moves_total": 10329306, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.55372717657055, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 25, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2019, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 115317, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10327287, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 2986991, "avg_legality_checks": 119479.64, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1354, "root_legality_checks": 2019, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2984972, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1354, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9058207, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 362328.28, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19428791981, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2144.8827545009735, "renju_forbidden_checks": 81289, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3251.56, "renju_forbidden_ns": 232881521, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2864.8589723086766, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3178, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16492655, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28056, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 126848908, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 50047, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 89526578, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13380, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 192206, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7688.24, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1641236570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8538.945558411287, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 265483, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10619.32, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 697375621, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2626.818368784442, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7028488974, "stage_ordering_ns": 3912715728, "stage_eval_ns": 7310677096, "stage_threat_ns": 14791597416, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2269541, "root_tactical_annotations": 6386, "search_tactical_annotations": 2263155, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 641575, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3697770689, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1816637, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10444334814, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 230824, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7426434520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 320775, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 477825862, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 641550, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 80638400, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 638055, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 509416398, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 947738, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2508039343, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 683748, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 91027651, "child_limit_applications": 115317, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 115317, "child_cap_hits": 115317, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 115317, "child_moves_before_total": 10325933, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10325933, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 1096640, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1096640, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.54389205407702, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.509786067969163, "tt_hits": 62564, "tt_cutoffs": 8298, "beta_cutoffs": 91842, "depth_sum": 137, "avg_depth": 5.48, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 137, "avg_effective_depth": 5.48, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16, "pooled_budget_moves": 25, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.24, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4596.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4916.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 18652, "avg_search_time_ms": 777.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 145545, "safety_nodes": 1885, "corridor_nodes": 2914, "corridor_branch_probes": 3485, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 7, "corridor_depth_exits": 935, "corridor_neutral_exits": 42, "corridor_terminal_exits": 67, "corridor_plies_followed": 2863, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2863, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 22, "corridor_proof_completed": 22, "corridor_proof_checks": 184, "corridor_proof_active": 51, "corridor_proof_quiet": 133, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 49, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 935, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 67, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 184, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 182, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1331, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 1154720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 23280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 7, "total_nodes": 150344, "avg_nodes": 6264.333333333333, "eval_calls": 95483, "avg_eval_calls": 3978.4583333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 95483, "pattern_eval_ns": 2108321, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.080590262140905, "pattern_frame_queries": 95483, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2108321, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.080590262140905, "pattern_frame_updates": 290860, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2646549497, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9099.049360517087, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46462, "avg_candidate_generations": 1935.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 4148735, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.29307821445482, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1932, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 46438, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4146803, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 2860205, "avg_legality_checks": 119175.20833333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 193, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2860205, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 193, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5718588, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 238274.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12084175493, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2113.1397283735078, "renju_forbidden_checks": 61993, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2583.0416666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 110037390, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1774.9970157921055, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 495, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2659266, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6594, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35808698, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 54904, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 71569426, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 153918, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6413.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1418963191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9218.955489286504, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 221029, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9209.541666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 655833010, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2967.1808224260167, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6683279593, "stage_ordering_ns": 1579669463, "stage_eval_ns": 2648657818, "stage_threat_ns": 7330576359, "stage_proof_ns": 281920792, "tactical_annotations": 934813, "root_tactical_annotations": 3946, "search_tactical_annotations": 930867, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 296978, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1794854962, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1032944, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5206818602, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 95152, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3073911479, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148477, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 225083579, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6094, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 43760907, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 296954, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37347847, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 367834, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 767137351, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 380783, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1231410198, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 186196, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22710462, "child_limit_applications": 46438, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46438, "child_cap_hits": 46438, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46438, "child_moves_before_total": 4146610, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4146610, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 743400, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 743400, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.29346655756062, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.008441362677118, "tt_hits": 20593, "tt_cutoffs": 3509, "beta_cutoffs": 40201, "depth_sum": 115, "avg_depth": 4.791666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 115, "avg_effective_depth": 4.791666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6719.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7052.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1856, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1524, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 122926, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 96, 142, 94, 98, 128, 80, 95, 93, 79, 63, 64, 109, 127, 143, 141, 99, 81, 97, 144, 160, 66, 51, 67, 108, 53, 39, 68, 65, 78, 77, 49, 34, 69, 70, 61, 101, 100, 115, 129, 131, 83, 116, 146, 56, 106, 92, 174, 114, 86, 28, 84, 117, 118, 159, 36, 52, 145, 161, 147, 148, 50, 22, 162, 62, 47, 122, 107, 42, 14, 76, 48, 46, 124, 87, 155, 169, 123, 139, 33, 19, 177, 132, 175, 72, 102, 73, 59, 71, 74, 55, 23, 103 ], "move_count": 98, "black_stats": { "move_count": 49, "search_move_count": 47, "total_time_ms": 47971, "avg_search_time_ms": 1020.6595744680851, "search_nodes": 369267, "safety_nodes": 4739, "corridor_nodes": 76998, "corridor_branch_probes": 80647, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 36294, "corridor_neutral_exits": 633, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 76781, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 76756, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 25, "corridor_proof_passes": 45, "corridor_proof_completed": 45, "corridor_proof_checks": 499, "corridor_proof_active": 217, "corridor_proof_quiet": 282, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 633, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 36294, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 499, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 5, "corridor_proof_unknown": 494, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 3667, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 36919040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2012480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 451004, "avg_nodes": 9595.829787234043, "eval_calls": 255917, "avg_eval_calls": 5445.04255319149, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 255917, "pattern_eval_ns": 5497551, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.481773387465466, "pattern_frame_queries": 255917, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5497551, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.481773387465466, "pattern_frame_updates": 738074, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6156570800, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8341.400455780857, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 107269, "avg_candidate_generations": 2282.31914893617, "candidate_moves_total": 10729015, "avg_candidate_moves": 100.0197167867697, "candidate_moves_max": 141, "root_candidate_generations": 47, "root_candidate_moves_total": 4518, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 107222, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10724497, "search_candidate_moves_max": 141, "legality_checks": 3323862, "avg_legality_checks": 70720.46808510639, "illegal_moves_skipped": 587, "root_legality_checks": 4518, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3319344, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 587, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16315659, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 347141.6808510638, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29779351713, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1825.2006684498615, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48316, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1028.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 107307787, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2220.9575916880535, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 921, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4734112, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14535, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57021417, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28826, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37399817, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4034, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8152441, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 413114, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8789.659574468085, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2896267347, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7010.818677169013, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 537211, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11430.021276595744, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1207305846, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2247.3587584766506, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6519450994, "stage_ordering_ns": 2999367312, "stage_eval_ns": 6162068351, "stage_threat_ns": 25838601109, "stage_proof_ns": 6265459777, "tactical_annotations": 2746066, "root_tactical_annotations": 9276, "search_tactical_annotations": 2736790, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 892681, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5843827305, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 6018808, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 17891406260, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 255859, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6779619329, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 446317, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 687368151, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 154560, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1259605429, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 892634, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 101618237, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1325128, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1037582785, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 932628, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2310290889, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 488310, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 54775727, "child_limit_applications": 107222, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 107222, "child_cap_hits": 107222, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 107222, "child_moves_before_total": 10723910, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10723910, "child_moves_before_max": 141, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 141, "child_moves_after_total": 1739479, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1739479, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 100.0159482195818, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.223153830370634, "tt_hits": 47185, "tt_cutoffs": 5898, "beta_cutoffs": 90955, "depth_sum": 230, "avg_depth": 4.8936170212765955, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 230, "avg_effective_depth": 4.8936170212765955, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 45 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 47, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0851063829787234, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6818.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6988.212765957447, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 890, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 49, "search_move_count": 47, "total_time_ms": 74905, "avg_search_time_ms": 1593.723404255319, "search_nodes": 584786, "safety_nodes": 3965, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 588751, "avg_nodes": 12526.617021276596, "eval_calls": 355904, "avg_eval_calls": 7572.425531914893, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 355904, "pattern_eval_ns": 7840242, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.02909211472757, "pattern_frame_queries": 355904, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7840242, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.02909211472757, "pattern_frame_updates": 1168966, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8405824023, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7190.819940870821, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 212670, "avg_candidate_generations": 4524.893617021276, "candidate_moves_total": 22222994, "avg_candidate_moves": 104.4951991348098, "candidate_moves_max": 132, "root_candidate_generations": 47, "root_candidate_moves_total": 4519, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 212623, "search_candidate_moves_total": 22218475, "search_candidate_moves_max": 132, "legality_checks": 15689328, "avg_legality_checks": 333815.4893617021, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5985, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 15689328, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5985, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 28801809, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 612804.4468085107, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 49518879694, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1719.2975515530986, "renju_forbidden_checks": 141568, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3012.0851063829787, "renju_forbidden_ns": 228097468, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1611.221942811935, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6363, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 50132177, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16503, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72292297, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 118702, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 105672994, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1278785, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 27208.191489361703, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 9389161739, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7342.2520118706425, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1723031, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 36660.234042553195, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4069571076, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2361.8675903103313, "stage_move_gen_ns": 30383661072, "stage_ordering_ns": 6422348221, "stage_eval_ns": 8413664265, "stage_threat_ns": 29068295435, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 5779809, "root_tactical_annotations": 13038, "search_tactical_annotations": 5766771, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1169013, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6008234758, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 4955477, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 21902331551, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 425642, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9476662194, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 584483, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 852664774, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1168966, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 136303140, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 2359595, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 5721399985, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 2170206, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 6703706320, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1250008, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 168761212, "child_limit_applications": 212623, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 212623, "child_cap_hits": 212623, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 212623, "child_moves_before_total": 22212490, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 22212490, "child_moves_before_max": 132, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 132, "child_moves_after_total": 2588817, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 2588817, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 104.4688956509879, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.175620699548027, "tt_hits": 107944, "tt_cutoffs": 15971, "beta_cutoffs": 180638, "depth_sum": 285, "avg_depth": 6.0638297872340425, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 285, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0638297872340425, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 10 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 26 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 18, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3829787234042553, "pooled_budget_moves": 47, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2765957446808511, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 18, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3829787234042553, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3546.9148936170213, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3717.127659574468, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1525, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27416, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 113, 114, 128, 66, 82, 110, 96, 144, 97, 67, 125, 139, 129, 81, 130, 131, 145, 161, 115, 160, 101, 143, 85, 100, 69, 83, 53, 37, 117 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 21194, "avg_search_time_ms": 1412.9333333333334, "search_nodes": 212065, "safety_nodes": 211, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 212276, "avg_nodes": 14151.733333333334, "eval_calls": 141273, "avg_eval_calls": 9418.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 141273, "pattern_eval_ns": 2935644, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.779936718268882, "pattern_frame_queries": 141273, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2935644, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.779936718268882, "pattern_frame_updates": 423992, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5808713314, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13700.054043472519, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 66441, "avg_candidate_generations": 4429.4, "candidate_moves_total": 5481366, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.49975165936695, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1076, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 66426, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5480290, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1573761, "avg_legality_checks": 104917.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3815, "root_legality_checks": 1076, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1572685, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3814, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5789593, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 385972.86666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12249918652, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2115.851434116353, "renju_forbidden_checks": 127421, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8494.733333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 454187625, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3564.4644524842843, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15221, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 66147458, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 51027, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 251780864, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 61070, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 135946401, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 103, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 312902, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 134959, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8997.266666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1095700601, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8118.7664475877855, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 174090, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11606.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 416724489, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2393.7301912803723, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3738545903, "stage_ordering_ns": 2126221461, "stage_eval_ns": 5811648958, "stage_threat_ns": 9446255951, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1367434, "root_tactical_annotations": 4193, "search_tactical_annotations": 1363241, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 424007, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2487982946, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1130320, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6539427435, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 132950, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4534037968, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 211996, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 311207358, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 423992, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53243877, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 351004, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 288922407, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 646352, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1716376189, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 370078, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 54394335, "child_limit_applications": 66426, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 66426, "child_cap_hits": 66426, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 66426, "child_moves_before_total": 5476476, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5476476, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 793611, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 793611, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.44476560382982, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.947294733989702, "tt_hits": 31131, "tt_cutoffs": 4297, "beta_cutoffs": 51155, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2809.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3342.4666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 267, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6207, "avg_search_time_ms": 443.35714285714283, "search_nodes": 57592, "safety_nodes": 1415, "corridor_nodes": 66, "corridor_branch_probes": 86, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 63, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 63, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 301, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 178560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12640, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59073, "avg_nodes": 4219.5, "eval_calls": 38888, "avg_eval_calls": 2777.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38888, "pattern_eval_ns": 816512, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.996502777206334, "pattern_frame_queries": 38888, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 816512, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.996502777206334, "pattern_frame_updates": 115054, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1166529216, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10138.971404731692, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17683, "avg_candidate_generations": 1263.0714285714287, "candidate_moves_total": 1349108, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.29406774868518, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 994, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 17669, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1348114, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 667374, "avg_legality_checks": 47669.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2015, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 667374, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2015, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1817577, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 129826.92857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3815969564, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2099.4816527717944, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20554, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1468.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 82480749, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4012.8806558334145, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3283, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23402953, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5610, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34696033, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11496, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23868071, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 165, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 513692, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51385, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3670.3571428571427, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 496204720, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9656.606402646687, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 75570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5397.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 234250004, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3099.775095937541, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1609817547, "stage_ordering_ns": 549196364, "stage_eval_ns": 1167345728, "stage_threat_ns": 2750457841, "stage_proof_ns": 87396088, "tactical_annotations": 285466, "root_tactical_annotations": 646, "search_tactical_annotations": 284820, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 115296, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 681056677, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 280418, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1967594279, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35660, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1234710227, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57641, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80987883, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 228, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1259605, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 115282, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14353838, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70669, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 200613578, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 169502, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 528355047, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 45295, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5205559, "child_limit_applications": 17669, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17669, "child_cap_hits": 17669, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17669, "child_moves_before_total": 1346099, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1346099, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 285104, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 285104, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.18422095194974, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.135831116644972, "tt_hits": 5471, "tt_cutoffs": 970, "beta_cutoffs": 15143, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5589.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6161.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1804, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1526, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16685, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 144, 141, 97, 109, 108, 125, 93, 80, 65, 96, 64, 126, 81, 156 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10607, "avg_search_time_ms": 1178.5555555555557, "search_nodes": 124879, "safety_nodes": 361, "corridor_nodes": 797, "corridor_branch_probes": 944, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 299, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 778, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 778, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 299, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 81, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 684, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 45862640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1993040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 126037, "avg_nodes": 14004.111111111111, "eval_calls": 102131, "avg_eval_calls": 11347.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 102131, "pattern_eval_ns": 2154528, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.09572999383145, "pattern_frame_queries": 102131, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2154528, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.09572999383145, "pattern_frame_updates": 249684, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3458663206, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13852.161956713286, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21744, "avg_candidate_generations": 2416.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1582611, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.78380242825607, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 553, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 21735, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1582058, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 678815, "avg_legality_checks": 75423.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2442, "root_legality_checks": 553, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 678262, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2440, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2725577, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 302841.8888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6185623813, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2269.47314752069, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33807, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3756.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 243759778, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7210.334486940575, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2577, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26590408, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20730, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 180440516, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10060, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 34038070, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 440, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2690784, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65669, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7296.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 623225627, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9490.408366200185, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 88238, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9804.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 282330843, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3199.651431356105, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1729156062, "stage_ordering_ns": 683244928, "stage_eval_ns": 3460817734, "stage_threat_ns": 4446637792, "stage_proof_ns": 246935319, "tactical_annotations": 278052, "root_tactical_annotations": 1710, "search_tactical_annotations": 276342, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 251415, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1496937684, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 311897, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2717936655, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44201, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1741110117, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 125703, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 182034566, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1722, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10314608, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 251406, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31563578, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 57538, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 90318742, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 159213, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 755414568, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 61301, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7850701, "child_limit_applications": 21735, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21735, "child_cap_hits": 21735, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21735, "child_moves_before_total": 1579618, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1579618, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 348016, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 348016, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.67623648493213, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.011778237865194, "tt_hits": 8471, "tt_cutoffs": 976, "beta_cutoffs": 15019, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2065.777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2891.8888888888887, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 894, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6068, "avg_search_time_ms": 758.5, "search_nodes": 48670, "safety_nodes": 562, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49232, "avg_nodes": 6154.0, "eval_calls": 29538, "avg_eval_calls": 3692.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 29538, "pattern_eval_ns": 625260, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.16798699979687, "pattern_frame_queries": 29538, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 625260, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.16798699979687, "pattern_frame_updates": 97258, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1089716011, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11204.384328281478, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17753, "avg_candidate_generations": 2219.125, "candidate_moves_total": 1276788, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.91956289077902, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 491, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 17745, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1276297, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 720453, "avg_legality_checks": 90056.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1064, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 720453, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1064, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1792512, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 224064.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3917160803, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2185.2912577433235, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11323, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1415.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64112931, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5662.185904795549, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1104, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11527057, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4465, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38648539, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5744, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13806414, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 130921, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47345, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5918.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 434429912, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9175.835082902102, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 64012, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8001.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 190785016, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2980.4570393051304, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1769975820, "stage_ordering_ns": 546792346, "stage_eval_ns": 1090341271, "stage_threat_ns": 2628611572, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 207862, "root_tactical_annotations": 781, "search_tactical_annotations": 207081, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 97266, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 592066948, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 180640, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1944139748, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35547, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1337207159, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48629, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 72748627, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 97258, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12400052, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 24606, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 102734079, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 120482, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 504081039, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 62774, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7256197, "child_limit_applications": 17745, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17745, "child_cap_hits": 17745, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17745, "child_moves_before_total": 1275233, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1275233, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 159685, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 159685, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.86435615666385, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.998872921949845, "tt_hits": 8526, "tt_cutoffs": 1346, "beta_cutoffs": 13858, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 5.125, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 5.125, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3079.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4079.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 738, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1527, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 31505, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 98, 156, 82, 67, 114, 66, 96, 99, 68, 54, 84, 70, 100, 52, 124, 110, 126, 140, 125, 123, 94, 95, 109, 139, 141, 170, 184, 157, 81, 111, 83, 80, 85 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 27883, "avg_search_time_ms": 1549.0555555555557, "search_nodes": 296239, "safety_nodes": 560, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 296799, "avg_nodes": 16488.833333333332, "eval_calls": 186847, "avg_eval_calls": 10380.388888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 186847, "pattern_eval_ns": 3853733, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.625072920624895, "pattern_frame_queries": 186847, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3853733, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.625072920624895, "pattern_frame_updates": 592270, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6952312724, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11738.41782295237, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 101568, "avg_candidate_generations": 5642.666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 9103284, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.62748109640832, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1333, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 101550, "search_candidate_moves_total": 9101951, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 2564806, "avg_legality_checks": 142489.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5269, "root_legality_checks": 1333, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 2563473, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5266, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8827365, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 490409.1666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16249813598, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1840.8453256436094, "renju_forbidden_checks": 89308, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4961.555555555556, "renju_forbidden_ns": 290745621, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3255.5383728221436, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5813, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33241113, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 35460, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 174861137, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 48020, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 82562051, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 81320, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 268236, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14902.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1751084731, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6528.149580966015, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 339653, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18869.61111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 656653686, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1933.3074814590184, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5023023673, "stage_ordering_ns": 3030073072, "stage_eval_ns": 6956166457, "stage_threat_ns": 12744247362, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2506440, "root_tactical_annotations": 5957, "search_tactical_annotations": 2500483, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 592288, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3074486553, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1953784, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9107930410, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 203239, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6159450449, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 296135, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 402221235, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 592270, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66864719, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 786921, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 530565194, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 963608, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2417529245, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 755911, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 92744445, "child_limit_applications": 101550, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 101550, "child_cap_hits": 101550, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 101550, "child_moves_before_total": 9096685, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 9096685, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 1305793, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1305793, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.57838503200394, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.85862136878385, "tt_hits": 58961, "tt_cutoffs": 7740, "beta_cutoffs": 84436, "depth_sum": 100, "avg_depth": 5.555555555555555, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 100, "avg_effective_depth": 5.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3888888888888889, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2005.388888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2449.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 3604, "avg_search_time_ms": 212.0, "search_nodes": 37677, "safety_nodes": 1845, "corridor_nodes": 1187, "corridor_branch_probes": 1338, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 21, "corridor_depth_exits": 532, "corridor_neutral_exits": 23, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1169, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1169, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 53, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 35, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 44, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 532, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 53, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 217, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 123200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 16000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40709, "avg_nodes": 2394.6470588235293, "eval_calls": 26181, "avg_eval_calls": 1540.0588235294117, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 26181, "pattern_eval_ns": 540944, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.66170123371911, "pattern_frame_queries": 26181, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 540944, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.66170123371911, "pattern_frame_updates": 75194, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 731828942, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9732.54437854084, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10965, "avg_candidate_generations": 645.0, "candidate_moves_total": 873201, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.63529411764706, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1263, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 10948, "search_candidate_moves_total": 871938, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 352500, "avg_legality_checks": 20735.29411764706, "illegal_moves_skipped": 493, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 352500, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 493, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1128534, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 66384.35294117648, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2142774877, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1898.7242537663908, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6229, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 366.4117647058824, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20971363, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3366.7302937871245, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 519, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3247349, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2427, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12092208, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3242, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5391396, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 41, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 240410, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36415, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2142.0588235294117, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 289502558, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7950.090841686118, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 47697, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2805.705882352941, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 122428119, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2566.7886659538335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 760467400, "stage_ordering_ns": 309813969, "stage_eval_ns": 732369886, "stage_threat_ns": 1697270560, "stage_proof_ns": 73683674, "tactical_annotations": 229465, "root_tactical_annotations": 391, "search_tactical_annotations": 229074, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 77655, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 435477915, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 284404, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1187785016, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22702, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 709952756, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38819, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 52405857, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2444, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10791134, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 77638, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8765187, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 67132, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 129136441, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 133520, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 316950541, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 28813, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2045451, "child_limit_applications": 10948, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10948, "child_cap_hits": 10948, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10948, "child_moves_before_total": 871445, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 871445, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 179720, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 179720, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.59855681402996, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.41578370478626, "tt_hits": 3310, "tt_cutoffs": 468, "beta_cutoffs": 9260, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6593.588235294118, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7064.176470588235, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1837, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1528, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10305, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 98, 143, 82, 142, 114, 130, 97, 67, 96, 99, 110, 68, 140, 158, 173, 126, 95, 94, 125, 80, 155 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6128, "avg_search_time_ms": 557.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 80194, "safety_nodes": 155, "corridor_nodes": 6581, "corridor_branch_probes": 7315, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2942, "corridor_neutral_exits": 46, "corridor_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_plies_followed": 6528, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6528, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 102, "corridor_proof_active": 53, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 46, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2942, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 102, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 99, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 828, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 444320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 86930, "avg_nodes": 7902.727272727273, "eval_calls": 55434, "avg_eval_calls": 5039.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 55434, "pattern_eval_ns": 1081493, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.50956091929141, "pattern_frame_queries": 55434, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1081493, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.50956091929141, "pattern_frame_updates": 160294, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1279916655, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7984.807010867531, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23196, "avg_candidate_generations": 2108.7272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 1624162, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.01905500948439, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 669, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 23185, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1623493, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 487084, "avg_legality_checks": 44280.36363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 398, "root_legality_checks": 669, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 486415, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 398, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2870914, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 260992.18181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3715431520, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1294.1632943376221, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20453, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1859.3636363636363, "renju_forbidden_ns": 69335622, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3389.9976531560164, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 454, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2209150, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9110, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44470592, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9455, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18110777, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1434, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4545103, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 70259, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6387.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 413159926, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5880.526708322065, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95093, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8644.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 189480533, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1992.5812941015638, "stage_move_gen_ns": 729422256, "stage_ordering_ns": 399871741, "stage_eval_ns": 1280998148, "stage_threat_ns": 3157157944, "stage_proof_ns": 525578628, "tactical_annotations": 392199, "root_tactical_annotations": 2252, "search_tactical_annotations": 389947, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 173565, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 694556466, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 708272, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2295999100, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49703, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1228185099, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86777, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91872267, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 13260, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 49825541, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 173554, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14732451, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116324, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 96925719, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 167024, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 380298466, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 108851, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10172119, "child_limit_applications": 23185, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23185, "child_cap_hits": 23185, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23185, "child_moves_before_total": 1623095, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1623095, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 372182, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 372182, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.00625404356265, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.052706491265905, "tt_hits": 10851, "tt_cutoffs": 1528, "beta_cutoffs": 19624, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5269.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5996.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1166, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 4168, "avg_search_time_ms": 416.8, "search_nodes": 53855, "safety_nodes": 933, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 54788, "avg_nodes": 5478.8, "eval_calls": 31227, "avg_eval_calls": 3122.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 31227, "pattern_eval_ns": 608022, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.4710346815256, "pattern_frame_queries": 31227, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 608022, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.4710346815256, "pattern_frame_updates": 107598, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 728533588, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6770.884105652522, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20176, "avg_candidate_generations": 2017.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1431309, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.94116772402855, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 615, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 20166, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1430694, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 842368, "avg_legality_checks": 84236.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 529, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 842368, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 529, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2095845, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 209584.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2600952653, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1241.0042980277644, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16097, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1609.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 28622271, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1778.1121326955333, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 543, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2902820, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4173, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17573154, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11381, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8146297, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67355, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6735.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 367202702, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5451.751198871651, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 90366, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9036.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 159620660, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1766.3796118008986, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1180056814, "stage_ordering_ns": 353115543, "stage_eval_ns": 729141610, "stage_threat_ns": 1863766414, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 323764, "root_tactical_annotations": 429, "search_tactical_annotations": 323335, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 107608, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 394112157, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 280631, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1399618044, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40408, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 856660763, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 53799, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 52799935, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 107598, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8938179, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 41149, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 93820948, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 199067, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 448988203, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 83548, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8298099, "child_limit_applications": 20166, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20166, "child_cap_hits": 20166, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20166, "child_moves_before_total": 1430165, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1430165, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 211868, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 211868, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.91961717742736, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.50619855201825, "tt_hits": 10378, "tt_cutoffs": 2406, "beta_cutoffs": 16643, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 5.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5120.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5920.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 595, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1529, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12892, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 85, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 123, 71, 99, 137, 97, 83, 80, 65, 96, 98, 128, 64, 144 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 11178, "avg_search_time_ms": 931.5, "search_nodes": 174926, "safety_nodes": 583, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 175509, "avg_nodes": 14625.75, "eval_calls": 116587, "avg_eval_calls": 9715.583333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 116587, "pattern_eval_ns": 2266049, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.436549529535885, "pattern_frame_queries": 116587, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2266049, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.436549529535885, "pattern_frame_updates": 349740, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3327229036, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9513.435798021388, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 54562, "avg_candidate_generations": 4546.833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4728484, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.66258568234302, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 864, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 54550, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4727620, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1184720, "avg_legality_checks": 98726.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1522, "root_legality_checks": 864, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1183856, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1522, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4807135, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 400594.5833333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6300832624, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1310.7251250484956, "renju_forbidden_checks": 62775, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5231.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 178407591, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2842.0165830346477, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2730, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8978990, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 35405, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 128628558, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24640, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40800043, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 112572, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9381.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 577130823, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5126.770626798849, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 143490, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11957.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 234644100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1635.2644783608614, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1716322198, "stage_ordering_ns": 1111697660, "stage_eval_ns": 3329495085, "stage_threat_ns": 4948367870, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1030039, "root_tactical_annotations": 2647, "search_tactical_annotations": 1027392, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 349752, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1299701345, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 849351, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3400009315, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 109179, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2374099341, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 174870, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 179742379, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 349740, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30022352, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 256617, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 158127530, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 483545, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 867525044, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 289877, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 38892479, "child_limit_applications": 54550, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 54550, "child_cap_hits": 54550, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 54550, "child_moves_before_total": 4726098, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4726098, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 541073, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 541073, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.63791017415215, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.918845096241979, "tt_hits": 28228, "tt_cutoffs": 3733, "beta_cutoffs": 43086, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5295.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5962.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1809, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1703, "avg_search_time_ms": 154.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 26384, "safety_nodes": 1149, "corridor_nodes": 58, "corridor_branch_probes": 60, "corridor_max_depth": 5, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 49, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 49, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 27, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 177, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 77920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 27591, "avg_nodes": 2508.2727272727275, "eval_calls": 18102, "avg_eval_calls": 1645.6363636363637, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 18102, "pattern_eval_ns": 352561, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.476356203734394, "pattern_frame_queries": 18102, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 352561, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.476356203734394, "pattern_frame_updates": 52668, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 363281662, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6897.578453710033, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7847, "avg_candidate_generations": 713.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 608098, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.49432904294635, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 7836, "search_candidate_moves_total": 607312, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 253472, "avg_legality_checks": 23042.909090909092, "illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 253472, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 796026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 72366.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1006669818, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1264.6192687173534, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3895, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 354.09090909090907, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8782907, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2254.918356867779, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 98, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 466000, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1280, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 5650392, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2517, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2666515, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2111.2727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 128997252, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5554.4803651395105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31666, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2878.7272727272725, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 59549107, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1880.5377060569697, "stage_move_gen_ns": 361018943, "stage_ordering_ns": 148335858, "stage_eval_ns": 363634223, "stage_threat_ns": 774982066, "stage_proof_ns": 36071655, "tactical_annotations": 124487, "root_tactical_annotations": 306, "search_tactical_annotations": 124181, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 52849, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 200722923, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 126405, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 541189574, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15922, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 348060937, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 26419, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 26486685, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 170, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 529503, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 52838, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 4450631, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32788, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 54285902, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 71580, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 136338884, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 20119, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1602750, "child_limit_applications": 7836, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 7836, "child_cap_hits": 7836, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 7836, "child_moves_before_total": 607228, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 607228, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 125406, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 125406, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.4920877998979, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00382848392037, "tt_hits": 2469, "tt_cutoffs": 396, "beta_cutoffs": 6642, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5958.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6686.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1897, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1530, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15654, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 128, 95, 140, 109, 108, 141, 157, 81, 123, 83, 129, 130, 97, 80, 65, 82, 79, 84 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8868, "avg_search_time_ms": 806.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 81865, "safety_nodes": 155, "corridor_nodes": 7736, "corridor_branch_probes": 8653, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3665, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_plies_followed": 7688, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 7688, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 102, "corridor_proof_active": 48, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3665, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 102, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 99, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 828, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24184720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 89756, "avg_nodes": 8159.636363636364, "eval_calls": 58657, "avg_eval_calls": 5332.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 58657, "pattern_eval_ns": 1221996, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.832909968119747, "pattern_frame_queries": 58657, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1221996, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.832909968119747, "pattern_frame_updates": 163636, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1933673440, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11816.919504265565, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21806, "avg_candidate_generations": 1982.3636363636363, "candidate_moves_total": 1519217, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.6696780702559, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 657, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 21795, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1518560, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 450420, "avg_legality_checks": 40947.27272727273, "illegal_moves_skipped": 399, "root_legality_checks": 657, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 449763, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 399, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2945038, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 267730.7272727273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5514007349, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1872.3043128815316, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18619, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1692.6363636363637, "renju_forbidden_ns": 98255956, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5277.187604060368, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 435, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3470077, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8898, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 63034969, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8030, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25099316, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1256, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6651594, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 70970, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6451.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 578665378, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8153.661800760885, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95463, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8678.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 268195930, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2809.4228130270367, "stage_move_gen_ns": 926098392, "stage_ordering_ns": 563046598, "stage_eval_ns": 1934895436, "stage_threat_ns": 4526006543, "stage_proof_ns": 886966268, "tactical_annotations": 405300, "root_tactical_annotations": 2192, "search_tactical_annotations": 403108, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 179227, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1011490873, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 761292, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3270103047, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47186, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1667721255, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89608, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 122390008, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 15580, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 90672380, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 179216, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19755344, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 124033, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 118119332, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171135, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 506070367, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110132, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11594891, "child_limit_applications": 21795, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21795, "child_cap_hits": 21795, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21795, "child_moves_before_total": 1518161, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1518161, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 350953, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 350953, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.65638908006423, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.10245469144299, "tt_hits": 10428, "tt_cutoffs": 1366, "beta_cutoffs": 17987, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4901.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5628.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1480, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6773, "avg_search_time_ms": 677.3, "search_nodes": 72587, "safety_nodes": 895, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 73482, "avg_nodes": 7348.2, "eval_calls": 43708, "avg_eval_calls": 4370.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 43708, "pattern_eval_ns": 927613, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.22295689576279, "pattern_frame_queries": 43708, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 927613, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.22295689576279, "pattern_frame_updates": 145062, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1430212950, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9859.321876163296, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25033, "avg_candidate_generations": 2503.3, "candidate_moves_total": 1730451, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.12679263372348, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 599, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 25023, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1729852, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 760433, "avg_legality_checks": 76043.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 271, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 760433, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 271, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2374897, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 237489.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4096798936, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1725.0427854344841, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13918, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1391.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 39769220, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2857.394740623653, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 283, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2086486, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4227, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24998134, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9408, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12684600, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75372, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7537.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 548045271, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7271.205102690655, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 101517, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10151.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 229075035, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2256.5189574159995, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1508302649, "stage_ordering_ns": 603244966, "stage_eval_ns": 1431140563, "stage_threat_ns": 3183762117, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 426227, "root_tactical_annotations": 436, "search_tactical_annotations": 425791, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 145072, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 712209992, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 386189, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2356254570, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50122, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1465743284, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72531, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90976028, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 145062, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15540319, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52475, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 115059196, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 283585, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 775250529, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 90167, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8781208, "child_limit_applications": 25023, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25023, "child_cap_hits": 25023, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25023, "child_moves_before_total": 1729581, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1729581, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 272568, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 272568, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.11964992207169, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.892698717180194, "tt_hits": 11162, "tt_cutoffs": 3800, "beta_cutoffs": 20266, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 5.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4576.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5376.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1718, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1531, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26917, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 159, 67, 52, 95, 53, 83, 80, 51, 143, 175, 35, 65, 49, 37, 79, 84, 85, 98, 70, 129, 113, 99, 115, 114, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 23406, "avg_search_time_ms": 1560.4, "search_nodes": 244238, "safety_nodes": 778, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 245016, "avg_nodes": 16334.4, "eval_calls": 173009, "avg_eval_calls": 11533.933333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 173009, "pattern_eval_ns": 3760938, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.738395112392997, "pattern_frame_queries": 173009, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3760938, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.738395112392997, "pattern_frame_updates": 488326, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6826243969, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13978.866513353783, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 67667, "avg_candidate_generations": 4511.133333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 6048057, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.37971241520978, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1165, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 67652, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6046892, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1629886, "avg_legality_checks": 108659.06666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3538, "root_legality_checks": 1165, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1628721, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3535, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6303620, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 420241.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13541464724, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2148.20447996548, "renju_forbidden_checks": 64050, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4270.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 328915813, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5135.297626854021, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4222, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34132640, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 36103, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 223030058, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23698, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 71593215, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 27, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 159900, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 172429, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11495.266666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1378797526, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7996.320375342895, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 213670, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14244.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 515555352, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2412.857921093275, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3878677134, "stage_ordering_ns": 2314906547, "stage_eval_ns": 6830004907, "stage_threat_ns": 10300632672, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1342165, "root_tactical_annotations": 4093, "search_tactical_annotations": 1338072, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 488341, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2921660099, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1199803, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6914071850, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 135408, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4586529330, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 244163, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 364133018, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 488326, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62192030, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 376839, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 426843628, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 687543, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1900234140, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 277783, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 38575675, "child_limit_applications": 67652, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 67652, "child_cap_hits": 67652, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 67652, "child_moves_before_total": 6043357, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6043357, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 731296, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 731296, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.33005676107136, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.80967303257849, "tt_hits": 30503, "tt_cutoffs": 3503, "beta_cutoffs": 52451, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3179.866666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3627.866666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 805, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3493, "avg_search_time_ms": 249.5, "search_nodes": 33035, "safety_nodes": 1641, "corridor_nodes": 282, "corridor_branch_probes": 335, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 102, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 272, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 272, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 102, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 41, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 184, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 63840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34958, "avg_nodes": 2497.0, "eval_calls": 22539, "avg_eval_calls": 1609.9285714285713, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22539, "pattern_eval_ns": 494903, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.957628998624607, "pattern_frame_queries": 22539, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 494903, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.957628998624607, "pattern_frame_updates": 65940, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 707719351, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10732.77754018805, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9944, "avg_candidate_generations": 710.2857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 802153, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.66703539823008, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1092, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 9930, "search_candidate_moves_total": 801061, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 313550, "avg_legality_checks": 22396.428571428572, "illegal_moves_skipped": 387, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 313550, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 387, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 986962, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 70497.28571428571, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2098015519, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2125.73079713302, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5647, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 403.35714285714283, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29740715, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5266.639808748007, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 438, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3930013, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2312, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17847195, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2866, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7726677, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 31, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 236830, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 31293, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2235.214285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 281048441, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8981.191991819256, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41267, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2947.6428571428573, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 122161035, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2960.2596505682504, "stage_move_gen_ns": 762819887, "stage_ordering_ns": 323519468, "stage_eval_ns": 708214254, "stage_threat_ns": 1596426506, "stage_proof_ns": 72392906, "tactical_annotations": 178455, "root_tactical_annotations": 331, "search_tactical_annotations": 178124, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 66580, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 411322750, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 190559, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1123009055, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20241, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 685402691, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 33283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 48845612, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 626, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2883243, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 66566, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8289801, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44746, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 112615335, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 108915, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 316425871, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 24794, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2076045, "child_limit_applications": 9930, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9930, "child_cap_hits": 9930, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9930, "child_moves_before_total": 800674, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 800674, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 160409, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 160409, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.63182275931521, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.1539778449144, "tt_hits": 2931, "tt_cutoffs": 501, "beta_cutoffs": 8463, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6277.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6848.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1836, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1532, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15325, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 81, 126, 67, 127, 95, 109, 82, 52, 83, 80, 99, 51, 129, 141, 156, 113, 84, 85, 114, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9095, "avg_search_time_ms": 826.8181818181819, "search_nodes": 79978, "safety_nodes": 155, "corridor_nodes": 6900, "corridor_branch_probes": 7661, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3107, "corridor_neutral_exits": 45, "corridor_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_plies_followed": 6846, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6846, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 104, "corridor_proof_active": 54, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 45, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3107, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 104, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 839, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 467280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 87033, "avg_nodes": 7912.090909090909, "eval_calls": 54978, "avg_eval_calls": 4998.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 54978, "pattern_eval_ns": 1176914, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.406999163301684, "pattern_frame_queries": 54978, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1176914, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.406999163301684, "pattern_frame_updates": 159862, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1797759059, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11245.693529419124, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23378, "avg_candidate_generations": 2125.2727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 1617438, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.18632902729061, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 669, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 23367, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1616769, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 490757, "avg_legality_checks": 44614.27272727273, "illegal_moves_skipped": 539, "root_legality_checks": 669, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 490088, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2865693, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 260517.54545454544, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5626646086, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1963.4504065857718, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20834, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1894.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 116435185, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5588.7100412786795, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 591, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5253331, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9082, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 74804751, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9747, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29157195, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1414, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7219908, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73076, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6643.272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 629824435, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8618.759031693033, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98127, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8920.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 284653415, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2900.867396333323, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1118493297, "stage_ordering_ns": 600962386, "stage_eval_ns": 1798935973, "stage_threat_ns": 4698086248, "stage_proof_ns": 841060221, "tactical_annotations": 398310, "root_tactical_annotations": 2252, "search_tactical_annotations": 396058, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 173773, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1041809598, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 730014, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3419927873, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50207, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1789143359, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86881, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 123488186, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 13900, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 78086686, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 173762, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20200307, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 119232, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 145338164, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 169664, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 577161932, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 109414, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14573598, "child_limit_applications": 23367, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23367, "child_cap_hits": 23367, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23367, "child_moves_before_total": 1616230, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1616230, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 375151, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 375151, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.16720160910685, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.05473531048059, "tt_hits": 10935, "tt_cutoffs": 1586, "beta_cutoffs": 19838, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4607.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5334.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 906, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6221, "avg_search_time_ms": 622.1, "search_nodes": 51726, "safety_nodes": 933, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 52659, "avg_nodes": 5265.9, "eval_calls": 30057, "avg_eval_calls": 3005.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 30057, "pattern_eval_ns": 652763, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.717503410187312, "pattern_frame_queries": 30057, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 652763, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.717503410187312, "pattern_frame_updates": 103340, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1058780680, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10245.603638474937, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19377, "avg_candidate_generations": 1937.7, "candidate_moves_total": 1342700, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.2934922846674, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 615, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 19367, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1342085, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 776232, "avg_legality_checks": 77623.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 808, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 776232, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 808, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2006750, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 200675.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3965582386, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1976.121781985798, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16210, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1621.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 52072149, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3212.3472547809993, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 822, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7941200, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4334, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29778037, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11054, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14352912, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 70545, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7054.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 599934229, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8504.27711389893, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95057, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9505.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 263560866, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2772.661308478071, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1750277088, "stage_ordering_ns": 519952727, "stage_eval_ns": 1059433443, "stage_threat_ns": 2846103704, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 320370, "root_tactical_annotations": 429, "search_tactical_annotations": 319941, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 103350, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 594347524, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 278777, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2157611338, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38810, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1277718697, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51670, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 71506578, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 103340, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12518866, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 39653, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 128337934, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 200307, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 751347086, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 80410, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10119398, "child_limit_applications": 19367, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19367, "child_cap_hits": 19367, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19367, "child_moves_before_total": 1341277, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1341277, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 208215, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 208215, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.25579594155006, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.751019775907471, "tt_hits": 9555, "tt_cutoffs": 2247, "beta_cutoffs": 15992, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4565.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5365.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1533, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 33484, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 110, 109, 82, 124, 126, 81, 94, 78, 80, 64, 66, 108, 128, 144, 68, 54, 52, 38, 95, 146, 162, 125, 158, 142, 143, 173, 127, 159, 79 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 29276, "avg_search_time_ms": 1722.1176470588234, "search_nodes": 275902, "safety_nodes": 410, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 276312, "avg_nodes": 16253.64705882353, "eval_calls": 180284, "avg_eval_calls": 10604.941176470587, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 180284, "pattern_eval_ns": 4007009, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.226093275054914, "pattern_frame_queries": 180284, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4007009, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.226093275054914, "pattern_frame_updates": 551608, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7648548302, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13865.9125719714, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 88601, "avg_candidate_generations": 5211.823529411765, "candidate_moves_total": 8001671, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.31129445491585, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1314, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 88584, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8000357, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 2115455, "avg_legality_checks": 124438.5294117647, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1637, "root_legality_checks": 1314, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2114141, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1637, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7880423, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 463554.29411764705, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17238164486, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2187.4669019670646, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55537, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3266.8823529411766, "renju_forbidden_ns": 218890250, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3941.340907863226, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1931, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13992750, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28122, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 148564865, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25484, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 56332635, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 226140, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13302.35294117647, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1891615877, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8364.800022110197, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 291024, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17119.058823529413, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 750379556, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2578.4112513057344, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5091446696, "stage_ordering_ns": 3107099253, "stage_eval_ns": 7652555311, "stage_threat_ns": 13326667653, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2220311, "root_tactical_annotations": 5829, "search_tactical_annotations": 2214482, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 551625, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3346568589, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1784743, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9401230683, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 177299, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6248773860, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 275804, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 419788203, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 551608, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 71538856, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 759941, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 680464088, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 847488, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2471663223, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 612882, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 87541322, "child_limit_applications": 88584, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 88584, "child_cap_hits": 88584, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 88584, "child_moves_before_total": 7998720, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7998720, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 1231836, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1231836, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.29531292332702, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.905852072609049, "tt_hits": 50812, "tt_cutoffs": 6940, "beta_cutoffs": 73192, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 5.411764705882353, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 5.411764705882353, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4117647058823529, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1557.764705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1840.3529411764705, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 4191, "avg_search_time_ms": 261.9375, "search_nodes": 37563, "safety_nodes": 1740, "corridor_nodes": 1410, "corridor_branch_probes": 1738, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 606, "corridor_neutral_exits": 19, "corridor_terminal_exits": 32, "corridor_plies_followed": 1395, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1395, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 49, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 606, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 32, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 49, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 49, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 207, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 107680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40713, "avg_nodes": 2544.5625, "eval_calls": 26198, "avg_eval_calls": 1637.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 26198, "pattern_eval_ns": 584783, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.321665776013436, "pattern_frame_queries": 26198, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 584783, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.321665776013436, "pattern_frame_updates": 74976, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 856940666, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11429.532997225779, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10745, "avg_candidate_generations": 671.5625, "candidate_moves_total": 865647, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.56277338296883, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1229, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 10729, "search_candidate_moves_total": 864418, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 354621, "avg_legality_checks": 22163.8125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 125, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 354621, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1153581, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 72098.8125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2478421457, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2148.458978606617, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5480, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 342.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 22037187, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4021.384489051095, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 127, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1137747, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2157, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14800970, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3196, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6098470, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39196, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2449.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 353843425, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9027.539162159404, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 52816, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3301.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 153306459, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2902.6518289912146, "stage_move_gen_ns": 867192033, "stage_ordering_ns": 352251958, "stage_eval_ns": 857525449, "stage_threat_ns": 2008620934, "stage_proof_ns": 78853449, "tactical_annotations": 226757, "root_tactical_annotations": 371, "search_tactical_annotations": 226386, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 77880, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 514884831, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 297059, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1400661093, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 22244, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 795500792, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38932, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 59971154, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2888, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20326176, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 77864, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10026987, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 64567, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 157084978, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 133714, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 386764959, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 28476, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2750693, "child_limit_applications": 10729, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10729, "child_cap_hits": 10729, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10729, "child_moves_before_total": 864293, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 864293, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 184270, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 184270, "child_moves_after_max": 29, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 29, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.5567154441234, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.174946406934477, "tt_hits": 3202, "tt_cutoffs": 561, "beta_cutoffs": 9065, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6496.4375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6996.4375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1862, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1534, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "draw", "winner": null, "end_reason": "max_moves", "duration_ms": 143644, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 110, 96, 99, 64, 128, 100, 126, 115, 114, 130, 145, 80, 48, 66, 129, 144, 127, 125, 94, 81, 51, 78, 79, 158, 172, 65, 67, 84, 68, 35, 50, 49, 63, 33, 17, 34, 36, 86, 85, 116, 102, 71, 101, 132, 148, 19, 4, 52, 117, 69, 133, 149, 118, 103, 47, 83, 82, 24, 38, 39, 54, 55, 87, 41, 27, 26, 56, 23, 7, 22, 25, 31, 32, 62, 5, 6, 72, 57, 171, 173, 157, 187, 188, 140, 199, 185, 170, 142, 141, 169, 204, 156, 201, 153, 200, 202, 139, 124, 108, 198, 123, 155, 107, 183, 91, 75, 106, 109, 168, 182, 163, 178, 184, 197, 211 ], "move_count": 120, "black_stats": { "move_count": 60, "search_move_count": 58, "total_time_ms": 61733, "avg_search_time_ms": 1064.3620689655172, "search_nodes": 757048, "safety_nodes": 4492, "corridor_nodes": 43306, "corridor_branch_probes": 45313, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 19177, "corridor_neutral_exits": 744, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 43105, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 43105, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 58, "corridor_proof_completed": 58, "corridor_proof_checks": 625, "corridor_proof_active": 201, "corridor_proof_quiet": 424, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 744, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 19177, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 625, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 622, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 4696, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 147096760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2013280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 804846, "avg_nodes": 13876.655172413793, "eval_calls": 562449, "avg_eval_calls": 9697.396551724138, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 562449, "pattern_eval_ns": 12189102, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.67147954747897, "pattern_frame_queries": 562449, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 12189102, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.67147954747897, "pattern_frame_updates": 1513516, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 12414948049, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8202.720056477765, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 181739, "avg_candidate_generations": 3133.4310344827586, "candidate_moves_total": 17943624, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.73293019109822, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 58, "root_candidate_moves_total": 5414, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 181681, "search_candidate_moves_total": 17938210, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 6096314, "avg_legality_checks": 105108.86206896552, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2032, "root_legality_checks": 5414, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 6090900, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2030, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19177434, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 330645.4137931034, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 35472343144, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1849.6918380217082, "renju_forbidden_checks": 343265, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5918.362068965517, "renju_forbidden_ns": 562253565, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1637.957744017013, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 53518, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 91205986, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 60727, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 202626695, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 199981, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 220179287, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29039, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 48241597, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 481067, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8294.258620689656, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3007864431, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6252.485477074919, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 562349, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9695.672413793103, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1010177127, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1796.3526688942277, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12308942580, "stage_ordering_ns": 5164266422, "stage_eval_ns": 12427137151, "stage_threat_ns": 27379480802, "stage_proof_ns": 4089783594, "tactical_annotations": 4193898, "root_tactical_annotations": 14890, "search_tactical_annotations": 4179008, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1601034, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 8495032779, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 5897856, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 16728222040, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 389036, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8181612897, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 800488, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1159911876, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 87460, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 724688776, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1600976, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 181855511, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 2023930, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1091807632, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1470633, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3591396471, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 699335, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 89769820, "child_limit_applications": 181681, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 181681, "child_cap_hits": 181681, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 181681, "child_moves_before_total": 17936180, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 17936180, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 2907654, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 2907654, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 98.72347686329336, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00417214788558, "tt_hits": 78652, "tt_cutoffs": 12628, "beta_cutoffs": 144766, "depth_sum": 290, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 290, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 5, "count": 58 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 58, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1724137931034483, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6511.637931034483, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6649.568965517241, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1199, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 60, "search_move_count": 58, "total_time_ms": 81854, "avg_search_time_ms": 1411.2758620689656, "search_nodes": 731285, "safety_nodes": 4078, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 735363, "avg_nodes": 12678.672413793103, "eval_calls": 432146, "avg_eval_calls": 7450.793103448276, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 432146, "pattern_eval_ns": 9556354, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.113716197766497, "pattern_frame_queries": 432146, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 9556354, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.113716197766497, "pattern_frame_updates": 1461790, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 9935578657, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6796.857727170113, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 279747, "avg_candidate_generations": 4823.224137931034, "candidate_moves_total": 27742643, "avg_candidate_moves": 99.17047546533118, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 58, "root_candidate_moves_total": 5457, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 279689, "search_candidate_moves_total": 27737186, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 18671812, "avg_legality_checks": 321927.7931034483, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7045, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 18671812, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7045, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 31013917, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 534722.7068965518, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 52600602109, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1696.032207379674, "renju_forbidden_checks": 973696, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 16787.862068965518, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1151837535, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1182.9539558548047, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 211206, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 325602539, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 75956, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 188501544, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 686154, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 637095889, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 380, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 637563, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 985444, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16990.41379310345, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 6322617899, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6416.009330819407, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1193756, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20582.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2288596635, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1917.1393777287822, "stage_move_gen_ns": 34681381663, "stage_ordering_ns": 7679707494, "stage_eval_ns": 9945135011, "stage_threat_ns": 28771876286, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 6096185, "root_tactical_annotations": 17306, "search_tactical_annotations": 6078879, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1461848, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6941971108, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 5383718, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 20471404917, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 559884, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10781118406, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 730895, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1033576369, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1461790, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 163503028, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 2461493, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 3396264048, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 2362300, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 6293536882, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1272392, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 161420864, "child_limit_applications": 279689, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 279689, "child_cap_hits": 279689, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 279689, "child_moves_before_total": 27730141, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 27730141, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 2478742, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 2478742, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 99.14634111459515, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.862493698357818, "tt_hits": 136257, "tt_cutoffs": 19075, "beta_cutoffs": 224133, "depth_sum": 374, "avg_depth": 6.448275862068965, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 374, "avg_effective_depth": 6.448275862068965, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 5, "count": 9 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 14 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 35 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 16, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.27586206896551724, "pooled_budget_moves": 58, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.27586206896551724, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 16, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.27586206896551724, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4337.620689655172, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4475.551724137931, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1535, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 35529, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 158, 82, 67, 110, 68, 98, 95, 66, 50, 80, 64, 94, 52, 128, 144, 124, 138, 108, 122, 81, 174, 190, 83, 92, 140, 130, 114, 129, 131, 113, 65, 145 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 31185, "avg_search_time_ms": 1732.5, "search_nodes": 294265, "safety_nodes": 411, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 294676, "avg_nodes": 16370.888888888889, "eval_calls": 188541, "avg_eval_calls": 10474.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 188541, "pattern_eval_ns": 4179233, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.16617605719711, "pattern_frame_queries": 188541, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4179233, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.16617605719711, "pattern_frame_updates": 588322, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8006755518, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13609.47834349217, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 98100, "avg_candidate_generations": 5450.0, "candidate_moves_total": 9010794, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.8531498470948, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1422, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 98082, "search_candidate_moves_total": 9009372, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 2249613, "avg_legality_checks": 124978.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1942, "root_legality_checks": 1422, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2248191, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1942, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8439173, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 468842.94444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18208613321, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2157.630056997291, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65595, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3644.1666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 239788609, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3655.5927890845337, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2238, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16007216, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33000, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 160161190, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30357, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 63620203, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 242852, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13491.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2004068342, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8252.220867030126, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 310174, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17231.88888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 785121178, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2531.2282073932697, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5315682053, "stage_ordering_ns": 3429933478, "stage_eval_ns": 8010934751, "stage_threat_ns": 14331716085, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2634227, "root_tactical_annotations": 6465, "search_tactical_annotations": 2627762, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 588340, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3521334136, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2116233, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10187750553, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 196303, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6735416124, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 294161, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 450565454, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 588322, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 76317723, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 931811, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 779299089, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 988103, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2672699438, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 714313, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 95748219, "child_limit_applications": 98082, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 98082, "child_cap_hits": 98082, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 98082, "child_moves_before_total": 9007430, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 9007430, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 1469238, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1469238, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.83570889663751, "avg_child_moves_after": 14.97969046308191, "tt_hits": 55875, "tt_cutoffs": 7542, "beta_cutoffs": 82188, "depth_sum": 98, "avg_depth": 5.444444444444445, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 98, "avg_effective_depth": 5.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1619.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1892.8333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 4327, "avg_search_time_ms": 254.52941176470588, "search_nodes": 38148, "safety_nodes": 1953, "corridor_nodes": 1364, "corridor_branch_probes": 1681, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 578, "corridor_neutral_exits": 23, "corridor_terminal_exits": 32, "corridor_plies_followed": 1349, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1349, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 36, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 578, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 32, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 210, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 104400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 41465, "avg_nodes": 2439.1176470588234, "eval_calls": 26343, "avg_eval_calls": 1549.5882352941176, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 26343, "pattern_eval_ns": 584012, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.169532703184906, "pattern_frame_queries": 26343, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 584012, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.169532703184906, "pattern_frame_updates": 76136, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 861103948, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11310.076021855626, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11145, "avg_candidate_generations": 655.5882352941177, "candidate_moves_total": 913495, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.9645580978017, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1338, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 11128, "search_candidate_moves_total": 912157, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 388052, "avg_legality_checks": 22826.58823529412, "illegal_moves_skipped": 143, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 388052, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1219902, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 71758.94117647059, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2581071906, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2115.802667755279, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5975, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 351.47058823529414, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20954960, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3507.1062761506278, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 145, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1255118, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2193, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13593087, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3637, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6106755, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2552.3529411764707, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 388347987, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8950.172551279096, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 57768, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3398.1176470588234, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 166363618, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2879.8576720675806, "stage_move_gen_ns": 931033127, "stage_ordering_ns": 362388380, "stage_eval_ns": 861687960, "stage_threat_ns": 2059199059, "stage_proof_ns": 81254003, "tactical_annotations": 247320, "root_tactical_annotations": 381, "search_tactical_annotations": 246939, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 78953, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 519033482, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 314908, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1447809849, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23046, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 797152950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 39468, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 60269030, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2800, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19507952, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 78936, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10107254, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 72844, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 175796273, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 144268, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 415164940, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 30208, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2471492, "child_limit_applications": 11128, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11128, "child_cap_hits": 11128, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11128, "child_moves_before_total": 912014, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 912014, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 193379, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 193379, "child_moves_after_max": 29, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 29, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.95668583752696, "avg_child_moves_after": 17.377695902228613, "tt_hits": 3351, "tt_cutoffs": 597, "beta_cutoffs": 9464, "depth_sum": 80, "avg_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 80, "avg_effective_depth": 4.705882352941177, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6594.941176470588, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7065.529411764706, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1893, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1536, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17005, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 96, 141, 82, 142, 110, 124, 97, 67, 98, 95, 114, 66, 144, 156, 171, 128, 99, 100, 129, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10354, "avg_search_time_ms": 941.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 79990, "safety_nodes": 155, "corridor_nodes": 6900, "corridor_branch_probes": 7661, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3107, "corridor_neutral_exits": 45, "corridor_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_plies_followed": 6846, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6846, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 104, "corridor_proof_active": 54, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 45, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3107, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 104, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 839, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 466560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 87045, "avg_nodes": 7913.181818181818, "eval_calls": 54990, "avg_eval_calls": 4999.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 54990, "pattern_eval_ns": 1220682, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.198254228041463, "pattern_frame_queries": 54990, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1220682, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.198254228041463, "pattern_frame_updates": 159886, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2047058277, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12803.236537282814, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23397, "avg_candidate_generations": 2127.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1637440, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.98504081719878, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 669, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 23386, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1636771, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 498301, "avg_legality_checks": 45300.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 538, "root_legality_checks": 669, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 497632, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 538, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2921610, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 265600.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6473721801, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2215.806285233142, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20898, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1899.8181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 118629946, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5676.617188247679, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 590, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5713884, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9100, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73352511, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9794, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31916638, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1414, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7646913, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73207, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6655.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 697992068, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9534.49899599765, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98310, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8937.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 312380632, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3177.5061743464553, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1271256593, "stage_ordering_ns": 693424535, "stage_eval_ns": 2048278959, "stage_threat_ns": 5371648098, "stage_proof_ns": 937922867, "tactical_annotations": 398526, "root_tactical_annotations": 2252, "search_tactical_annotations": 396274, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 173797, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1175380929, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 730269, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3937817395, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50245, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2118391298, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86893, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 139760664, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 13900, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 83874297, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 173786, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22865090, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 119314, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 160651757, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 169799, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 631778618, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 109413, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11949723, "child_limit_applications": 23386, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23386, "child_cap_hits": 23386, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23386, "child_moves_before_total": 1636233, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1636233, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 375455, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 375455, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.96634738732575, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.054690840673906, "tt_hits": 10917, "tt_cutoffs": 1567, "beta_cutoffs": 19857, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3851.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4579.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 607, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6642, "avg_search_time_ms": 664.2, "search_nodes": 50001, "safety_nodes": 933, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 50934, "avg_nodes": 5093.4, "eval_calls": 29350, "avg_eval_calls": 2935.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 29350, "pattern_eval_ns": 660461, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.502930153321977, "pattern_frame_queries": 29350, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 660461, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.502930153321977, "pattern_frame_updates": 99890, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1153426008, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11546.961737911703, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18402, "avg_candidate_generations": 1840.2, "candidate_moves_total": 1295637, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.40740136941636, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 615, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 18392, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1295022, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 733291, "avg_legality_checks": 73329.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 813, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 733291, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 813, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1945098, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 194509.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4257956117, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2189.070225253432, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16261, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1626.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 55116303, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3389.4780763790664, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 827, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8464674, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4358, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31369540, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11076, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15282089, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 70046, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7004.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 659640167, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9417.242483510836, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 94212, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9421.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 287745939, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3054.2387275506303, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1830847162, "stage_ordering_ns": 554525090, "stage_eval_ns": 1154086469, "stage_threat_ns": 3064865258, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 309399, "root_tactical_annotations": 429, "search_tactical_annotations": 308970, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 99900, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 632176195, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 276316, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2335141595, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36860, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1383327284, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 49945, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 77180408, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 99890, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13234772, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 38788, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 141030554, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 200661, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 810559875, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 69950, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7132288, "child_limit_applications": 18392, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18392, "child_cap_hits": 18392, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18392, "child_moves_before_total": 1294209, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1294209, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 199332, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 199332, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.3680404523706, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.837973031752936, "tt_hits": 8528, "tt_cutoffs": 2204, "beta_cutoffs": 15131, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4334.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5134.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1537, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13417, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 67, 83, 128, 81, 84, 111, 69, 79, 80, 127, 142, 95, 143, 63 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7884, "avg_search_time_ms": 985.5, "search_nodes": 78312, "safety_nodes": 66, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 78378, "avg_nodes": 9797.25, "eval_calls": 50071, "avg_eval_calls": 6258.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50071, "pattern_eval_ns": 1100253, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.9738571228855, "pattern_frame_queries": 50071, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1100253, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.9738571228855, "pattern_frame_updates": 156552, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2032983821, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12985.997119168072, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26627, "avg_candidate_generations": 3328.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1732019, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.04747061253615, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 416, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 26619, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1731603, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 507037, "avg_legality_checks": 63379.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 291, "root_legality_checks": 416, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 506621, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 291, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2057747, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 257218.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4760548472, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2313.4760842805263, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14033, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1754.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62730145, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4470.187771681038, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 468, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3049326, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7005, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44650187, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6560, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15030632, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43091, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5386.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 383597060, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8902.022696154649, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 55814, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6976.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 151035386, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2706.048410792991, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1285127089, "stage_ordering_ns": 743293104, "stage_eval_ns": 2034084074, "stage_threat_ns": 3795060293, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 271953, "root_tactical_annotations": 1619, "search_tactical_annotations": 270334, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 156560, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 983292739, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 217404, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2659352004, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53289, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2091199326, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78276, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118416780, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 156552, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20783790, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 38047, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 83384202, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 126061, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 484760046, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 107845, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13214980, "child_limit_applications": 26619, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26619, "child_cap_hits": 26619, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26619, "child_moves_before_total": 1731312, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1731312, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 240999, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 240999, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 65.0404598219317, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.053645892032007, "tt_hits": 15869, "tt_cutoffs": 1586, "beta_cutoffs": 20630, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2431.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3431.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1384, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 5524, "avg_search_time_ms": 789.1428571428571, "search_nodes": 45297, "safety_nodes": 459, "corridor_nodes": 8, "corridor_branch_probes": 4, "corridor_max_depth": 1, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 4, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 10, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 6, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 10, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 10, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 23, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 7959280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 45764, "avg_nodes": 6537.714285714285, "eval_calls": 26254, "avg_eval_calls": 3750.5714285714284, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 26254, "pattern_eval_ns": 585604, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.305324902871945, "pattern_frame_queries": 26254, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 585604, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.305324902871945, "pattern_frame_updates": 90522, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 966166696, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10673.280484302159, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17200, "avg_candidate_generations": 2457.1428571428573, "candidate_moves_total": 1112370, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.67267441860466, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 368, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 17193, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1112002, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 603676, "avg_legality_checks": 86239.42857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 603676, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1619910, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 231415.7142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3579042640, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2209.4083251538664, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8870, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1267.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14763341, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1664.4127395715896, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 46, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 241540, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1795, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9121741, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7029, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5400060, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49843, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7120.428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 449543256, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9019.185362036795, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66241, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9463.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 185010480, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2792.9904439848433, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1487222301, "stage_ordering_ns": 474329147, "stage_eval_ns": 966752300, "stage_threat_ns": 2545876170, "stage_proof_ns": 17962234, "tactical_annotations": 191475, "root_tactical_annotations": 359, "search_tactical_annotations": 191116, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 90557, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 564731161, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 173158, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1895451442, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34476, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1277775245, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 45275, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 67082550, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 28, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 126511, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 90550, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11755348, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 22203, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 129246610, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 115611, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 487907233, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53661, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6729158, "child_limit_applications": 17193, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17193, "child_cap_hits": 17193, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17193, "child_moves_before_total": 1111960, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1111960, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 151611, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 151611, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 64.67515849473622, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.818181818181818, "tt_hits": 7990, "tt_cutoffs": 1815, "beta_cutoffs": 13567, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2356.4285714285716, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3499.285714285714, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1538, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13706, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 67, 83, 128, 81, 84, 111, 69, 79, 80, 127, 142, 95, 143, 63 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 8201, "avg_search_time_ms": 1025.125, "search_nodes": 78312, "safety_nodes": 66, "corridor_nodes": 689, "corridor_branch_probes": 798, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 211, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 679, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 679, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 34, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 211, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 34, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 274, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 12024400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1967120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 79067, "avg_nodes": 9883.375, "eval_calls": 50071, "avg_eval_calls": 6258.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50071, "pattern_eval_ns": 1105832, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.085278903956382, "pattern_frame_queries": 50071, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1105832, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.085278903956382, "pattern_frame_updates": 156552, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2023866449, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12927.758501967397, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26627, "avg_candidate_generations": 3328.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1732019, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.04747061253615, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 416, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 26619, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1731603, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 507037, "avg_legality_checks": 63379.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 291, "root_legality_checks": 416, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 506621, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 291, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2181991, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 272748.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4995755006, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2289.5396937934206, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14076, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1759.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62498682, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4440.088235294118, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 468, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3009602, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7005, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44400515, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6565, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15023175, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 65390, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44301, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5537.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 393361572, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8879.29328909054, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 57437, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7179.625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 155696979, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2710.74357992235, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1278760114, "stage_ordering_ns": 742315484, "stage_eval_ns": 2024972281, "stage_threat_ns": 3967440130, "stage_proof_ns": 160770025, "tactical_annotations": 271953, "root_tactical_annotations": 1619, "search_tactical_annotations": 270334, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 157986, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 998052545, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 267991, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2808333893, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53781, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2114053141, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78989, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 119339524, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1426, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7491740, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 157978, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20923542, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 38047, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 82955348, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 126061, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 481907031, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 107845, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13298886, "child_limit_applications": 26619, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26619, "child_cap_hits": 26619, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26619, "child_moves_before_total": 1731312, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1731312, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 240999, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 240999, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 65.0404598219317, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.053645892032007, "tt_hits": 15869, "tt_cutoffs": 1586, "beta_cutoffs": 20630, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2239.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3216.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1369, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 5495, "avg_search_time_ms": 785.0, "search_nodes": 45385, "safety_nodes": 459, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 45844, "avg_nodes": 6549.142857142857, "eval_calls": 26288, "avg_eval_calls": 3755.4285714285716, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 26288, "pattern_eval_ns": 581671, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.126863968350577, "pattern_frame_queries": 26288, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 581671, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.126863968350577, "pattern_frame_updates": 90698, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 959856630, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10582.99664821716, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17246, "avg_candidate_generations": 2463.714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 1115011, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.65331091267541, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 368, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 17239, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1114643, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 604259, "avg_legality_checks": 86322.71428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 604259, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1616723, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 230960.42857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3553574504, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2198.0107315848168, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8876, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1268.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14710580, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1657.3433979269942, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 46, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 241252, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1800, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9097211, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7030, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5372117, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49860, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7122.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 448487034, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8994.926474127557, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66264, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9466.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 185316656, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2796.6415549921526, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1485281065, "stage_ordering_ns": 476050875, "stage_eval_ns": 960438301, "stage_threat_ns": 2542845701, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 191971, "root_tactical_annotations": 359, "search_tactical_annotations": 191612, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 90705, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 564705706, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 172695, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1891111609, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34528, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1273900508, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 45349, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68287326, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 90698, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11824684, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 22222, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 129320598, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 115941, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 487746683, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53808, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6916376, "child_limit_applications": 17239, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17239, "child_cap_hits": 17239, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17239, "child_moves_before_total": 1114601, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1114601, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 151992, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 151992, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 64.65578049770869, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.816752711874239, "tt_hits": 8014, "tt_cutoffs": 1823, "beta_cutoffs": 13608, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2371.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3514.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1539, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21523, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 129, 96, 141, 110, 109, 142, 158, 82, 130, 131, 124, 84, 98, 81, 66, 83, 80, 85 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 13214, "avg_search_time_ms": 1201.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 131068, "safety_nodes": 151, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 131219, "avg_nodes": 11929.0, "eval_calls": 83814, "avg_eval_calls": 7619.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83814, "pattern_eval_ns": 1800760, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.485193404443173, "pattern_frame_queries": 83814, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1800760, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.485193404443173, "pattern_frame_updates": 262030, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3534837244, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13490.200526657252, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43240, "avg_candidate_generations": 3930.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 3067462, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.94037927844589, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 661, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 43229, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3066801, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 938803, "avg_legality_checks": 85345.72727272728, "illegal_moves_skipped": 839, "root_legality_checks": 661, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 938142, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 839, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3793144, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 344831.2727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7992456149, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2107.0795490495484, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25835, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2348.6363636363635, "renju_forbidden_ns": 120422849, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4661.2289142635955, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 961, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7046583, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12131, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 83341635, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12743, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30034631, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98077, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8916.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 810209401, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8260.95211925324, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 129939, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11812.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 343499999, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2643.548118732636, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2144222617, "stage_ordering_ns": 1249406624, "stage_eval_ns": 3536638004, "stage_threat_ns": 6238342419, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 763569, "root_tactical_annotations": 2718, "search_tactical_annotations": 760851, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 262041, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1505132296, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 567635, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4475452483, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 86532, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3227033894, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 131015, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 187964907, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 262030, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32391527, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 166182, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 169533155, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 314912, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1078874414, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 282475, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 37401206, "child_limit_applications": 43229, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43229, "child_cap_hits": 43229, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43229, "child_moves_before_total": 3065962, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3065962, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 495738, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 495738, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.92373175414652, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.467718429757802, "tt_hits": 26174, "tt_cutoffs": 3972, "beta_cutoffs": 34318, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 4.818181818181818, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 4.818181818181818, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2440.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3167.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 958, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8299, "avg_search_time_ms": 829.9, "search_nodes": 74235, "safety_nodes": 904, "corridor_nodes": 721, "corridor_branch_probes": 880, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 279, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 30, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 25, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 279, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 30, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 166, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 10019920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 75860, "avg_nodes": 7586.0, "eval_calls": 44758, "avg_eval_calls": 4475.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44758, "pattern_eval_ns": 949585, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.21598373475133, "pattern_frame_queries": 44758, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 949585, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.21598373475133, "pattern_frame_updates": 148358, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1703616558, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11483.145890346324, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25579, "avg_candidate_generations": 2557.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1777776, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.50138785722663, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 603, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 25569, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1777173, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 793010, "avg_legality_checks": 79301.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 469, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 793010, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 469, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2490688, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 249068.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5068720791, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2035.0685396966621, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14332, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1433.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44468269, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3102.7259977672343, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 473, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3695267, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4377, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27263165, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9482, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13509837, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 79326, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7932.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 661549959, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8339.63592012707, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 106489, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10648.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 282974633, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2657.313271793331, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1807808867, "stage_ordering_ns": 729401348, "stage_eval_ns": 1704566143, "stage_threat_ns": 3969295799, "stage_proof_ns": 44797034, "tactical_annotations": 436994, "root_tactical_annotations": 418, "search_tactical_annotations": 436576, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 149860, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 886281143, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 443452, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2938499599, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51589, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1854083821, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74925, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108308899, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1492, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7753062, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 149850, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18801667, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52768, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 133639258, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 293407, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 914811481, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 90819, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9651429, "child_limit_applications": 25569, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25569, "child_cap_hits": 25569, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25569, "child_moves_before_total": 1776704, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1776704, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 278956, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 278956, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.4866439829481, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.909929993351325, "tt_hits": 11368, "tt_cutoffs": 3852, "beta_cutoffs": 20705, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 5.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3584.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4384.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 165, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1540, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21431, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 129, 96, 141, 110, 109, 142, 158, 98, 84, 94, 78, 95, 97, 140, 154, 125, 80, 155 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 13671, "avg_search_time_ms": 1242.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 117847, "safety_nodes": 661, "corridor_nodes": 3980, "corridor_branch_probes": 4568, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1828, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 3953, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3953, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 39, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1828, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 546, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 37793280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1984240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 122488, "avg_nodes": 11135.272727272728, "eval_calls": 72748, "avg_eval_calls": 6613.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72748, "pattern_eval_ns": 1525760, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.97322263155001, "pattern_frame_queries": 72748, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1525760, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.97322263155001, "pattern_frame_updates": 235580, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3130666122, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13289.184659139146, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 40831, "avg_candidate_generations": 3711.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 2845248, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.68352477284417, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 653, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 40820, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2844595, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 825102, "avg_legality_checks": 75009.27272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 552, "root_legality_checks": 653, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 824449, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 552, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3952571, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 359324.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8420599398, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2130.410661313864, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25169, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2288.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 107061976, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4253.723866661369, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 917, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5895809, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10431, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 65392986, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13409, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 33191601, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 412, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2581580, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 98775, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8979.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 887280630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8982.846165527715, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 131898, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11990.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 393254997, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2981.508415593868, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1991582483, "stage_ordering_ns": 1192328597, "stage_eval_ns": 3132191882, "stage_threat_ns": 6801458516, "stage_proof_ns": 518175927, "tactical_annotations": 700272, "root_tactical_annotations": 2021, "search_tactical_annotations": 698251, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 243629, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1489308507, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 745674, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5018614743, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 83500, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3214023078, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121809, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 185209242, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8038, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 44231663, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 243618, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30756594, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 129275, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 159723353, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 309881, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1059311483, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 261116, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33337767, "child_limit_applications": 40820, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 40820, "child_cap_hits": 40820, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 40820, "child_moves_before_total": 2844043, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2844043, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 461421, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 461421, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.67278294953454, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.303797158255756, "tt_hits": 25283, "tt_cutoffs": 4223, "beta_cutoffs": 33101, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 5.090909090909091, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 5.090909090909091, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1793.3636363636363, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2520.6363636363635, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7749, "avg_search_time_ms": 774.9, "search_nodes": 70225, "safety_nodes": 737, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 70962, "avg_nodes": 7096.2, "eval_calls": 42136, "avg_eval_calls": 4213.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 42136, "pattern_eval_ns": 894774, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.23538067210936, "pattern_frame_queries": 42136, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 894774, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.23538067210936, "pattern_frame_updates": 140336, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1655571568, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11797.197924980048, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24450, "avg_candidate_generations": 2445.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1673814, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.45865030674847, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 587, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 24440, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1673227, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 656876, "avg_legality_checks": 65687.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 142, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 656876, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2217579, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 221757.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4704965436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2121.667564492629, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12376, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1237.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 36073808, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2914.819650937298, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 320, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1518331, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4088, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21931880, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7968, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12623597, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65166, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6516.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 594293357, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9119.684452014855, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 88883, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8888.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 263449121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2963.998976182172, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1581113173, "stage_ordering_ns": 717096340, "stage_eval_ns": 1656466342, "stage_threat_ns": 3762175899, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 406427, "root_tactical_annotations": 401, "search_tactical_annotations": 406026, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 140346, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 845522651, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 370903, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2784995386, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48957, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1815638118, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70168, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105104304, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 140336, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17847152, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 47807, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 133633201, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 274134, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 835539187, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 84486, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8706406, "child_limit_applications": 24440, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24440, "child_cap_hits": 24440, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24440, "child_moves_before_total": 1673085, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1673085, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 260772, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 260772, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.45683306055646, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.669885433715221, "tt_hits": 11085, "tt_cutoffs": 3592, "beta_cutoffs": 19831, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 5.7, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 5.7, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3710.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4510.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 226, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1541, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 41150, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 109, 95, 98, 127, 143, 113, 114, 99, 141, 79, 63, 65, 50, 93, 82, 66, 51, 125, 80, 126, 128, 142, 158, 67, 68, 107, 121, 123, 124, 155, 140, 139, 91, 171 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 29720, "avg_search_time_ms": 1651.111111111111, "search_nodes": 306861, "safety_nodes": 168, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 307029, "avg_nodes": 17057.166666666668, "eval_calls": 187771, "avg_eval_calls": 10431.722222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 187771, "pattern_eval_ns": 3894138, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.738761576601284, "pattern_frame_queries": 187771, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3894138, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.738761576601284, "pattern_frame_updates": 613522, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7232733762, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11788.874338654523, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 110546, "avg_candidate_generations": 6141.444444444444, "candidate_moves_total": 9439193, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.38701536012158, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1263, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 110528, "search_candidate_moves_total": 9437930, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 2168671, "avg_legality_checks": 120481.72222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1073, "root_legality_checks": 1263, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2167408, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1073, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8194013, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 455222.94444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17088116428, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2085.4392625444943, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56585, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3143.6111111111113, "renju_forbidden_ns": 181808469, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3213.0152690642394, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2009, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10452649, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26232, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 116058341, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28344, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 55297479, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 184194, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10233.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1391854083, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7556.457229877195, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 232238, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12902.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 516746816, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2225.074346144903, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4979532402, "stage_ordering_ns": 3488121889, "stage_eval_ns": 7236627900, "stage_threat_ns": 13926754506, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2146656, "root_tactical_annotations": 6223, "search_tactical_annotations": 2140433, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 613540, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3540938531, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1631849, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9765755031, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 221191, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7173486796, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 306761, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 452749122, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 613522, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 75898152, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 534940, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 450552996, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 875702, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2141695849, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 736014, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 91413670, "child_limit_applications": 110528, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 110528, "child_cap_hits": 110528, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 110528, "child_moves_before_total": 9436857, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 9436857, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 1124661, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1124661, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.37978611754488, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.175349232773597, "tt_hits": 66065, "tt_cutoffs": 8467, "beta_cutoffs": 90401, "depth_sum": 95, "avg_depth": 5.277777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 95, "avg_effective_depth": 5.277777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3888888888888889, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1312.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1666.3333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 11411, "avg_search_time_ms": 671.2352941176471, "search_nodes": 100283, "safety_nodes": 1743, "corridor_nodes": 848, "corridor_branch_probes": 919, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 346, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 833, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 833, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 22, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 346, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 93, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 7, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 20001520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2007120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 102874, "avg_nodes": 6051.411764705882, "eval_calls": 58418, "avg_eval_calls": 3436.3529411764707, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 58418, "pattern_eval_ns": 1231814, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.086206306275464, "pattern_frame_queries": 58418, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1231814, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.086206306275464, "pattern_frame_updates": 200356, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2061242386, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10287.899468945277, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38277, "avg_candidate_generations": 2251.5882352941176, "candidate_moves_total": 3029418, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.14460380907595, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1195, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 38260, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3028223, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1270989, "avg_legality_checks": 74764.05882352941, "illegal_moves_skipped": 344, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1270989, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 344, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3442711, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 202512.41176470587, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6949589406, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2018.6386269425461, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19302, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1135.4117647058824, "renju_forbidden_ns": 34232055, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1773.497824059683, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3009713, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4913, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18434625, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13723, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12787717, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 105149, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6185.235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 782316756, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7440.077946533015, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132090, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7770.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 283355347, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2145.168801574684, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2840881292, "stage_ordering_ns": 1131609024, "stage_eval_ns": 2062474200, "stage_threat_ns": 5262266512, "stage_proof_ns": 49558263, "tactical_annotations": 703601, "root_tactical_annotations": 554, "search_tactical_annotations": 703047, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 202113, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1188168037, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 690051, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3875711572, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 77199, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2467810197, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 101048, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 148247103, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1740, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11070733, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 202096, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24833511, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116735, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 246362189, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 447423, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1127848496, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 139443, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14235556, "child_limit_applications": 38260, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38260, "child_cap_hits": 38260, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38260, "child_moves_before_total": 3027879, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3027879, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 395557, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 395557, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.13954521693675, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.338656560376371, "tt_hits": 15607, "tt_cutoffs": 3501, "beta_cutoffs": 31335, "depth_sum": 104, "avg_depth": 6.117647058823529, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 104, "avg_effective_depth": 6.117647058823529, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5722.941176470588, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6193.529411764706, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1542, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 36956, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 109, 95, 98, 127, 143, 113, 114, 99, 141, 79, 63, 65, 50, 93, 82, 66, 51, 125, 80, 126, 128, 142, 158, 107, 121, 123, 124, 155, 140, 139, 91, 171 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 28113, "avg_search_time_ms": 1653.7058823529412, "search_nodes": 333080, "safety_nodes": 167, "corridor_nodes": 11174, "corridor_branch_probes": 11761, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 5510, "corridor_neutral_exits": 31, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 11123, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 11123, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 122, "corridor_proof_active": 51, "corridor_proof_quiet": 71, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 31, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5510, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 122, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 122, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 3, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 983, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 59778480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1988000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 344421, "avg_nodes": 20260.058823529413, "eval_calls": 210673, "avg_eval_calls": 12392.529411764706, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 210673, "pattern_eval_ns": 4135876, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.631732590317696, "pattern_frame_queries": 210673, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4135876, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.631732590317696, "pattern_frame_updates": 665974, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6521994349, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9793.166623621943, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 113555, "avg_candidate_generations": 6679.705882352941, "candidate_moves_total": 9626759, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.776178944124, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1178, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 113538, "search_candidate_moves_total": 9625581, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 2332402, "avg_legality_checks": 137200.11764705883, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1096, "root_legality_checks": 1178, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2331224, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1096, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10049981, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 591175.3529411765, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16369695921, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1628.8285441534665, "renju_forbidden_checks": 61741, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3631.823529411765, "renju_forbidden_ns": 145609144, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2358.3865502664357, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2068, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7732861, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29011, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 94616187, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30316, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42513071, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 346, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 747025, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 226698, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13335.176470588236, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1388276945, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6123.904688175458, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 290661, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17097.70588235294, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 540262658, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1858.7380419113676, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4250520660, "stage_ordering_ns": 2844588541, "stage_eval_ns": 6526130225, "stage_threat_ns": 13546803978, "stage_proof_ns": 836572014, "tactical_annotations": 2263881, "root_tactical_annotations": 5647, "search_tactical_annotations": 2258234, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 688481, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3349655314, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2220572, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9473983603, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 232801, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6228911290, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 344232, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 436378716, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 22490, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 105964950, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 688464, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 70852453, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 542484, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 397689651, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 884688, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1886129429, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 836709, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 109968942, "child_limit_applications": 113538, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 113538, "child_cap_hits": 113538, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 113538, "child_moves_before_total": 9624485, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 9624485, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 1163580, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1163580, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.76884391128961, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.248374993394282, "tt_hits": 69772, "tt_cutoffs": 8777, "beta_cutoffs": 91669, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 5.411764705882353, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 5.411764705882353, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4117647058823529, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1724.9411764705883, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2077.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 8827, "avg_search_time_ms": 551.6875, "search_nodes": 92351, "safety_nodes": 1582, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 93933, "avg_nodes": 5870.8125, "eval_calls": 53988, "avg_eval_calls": 3374.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53988, "pattern_eval_ns": 1079273, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.990979476920796, "pattern_frame_queries": 53988, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1079273, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.990979476920796, "pattern_frame_updates": 184506, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1601385274, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8679.312726957389, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35066, "avg_candidate_generations": 2191.625, "candidate_moves_total": 2737589, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.06961158957395, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1111, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 35050, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2736478, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1156429, "avg_legality_checks": 72276.8125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 338, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1156429, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 338, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3126114, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 195382.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5397508097, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1726.5870972715647, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18533, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1158.3125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 25815456, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1392.9453407435385, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 660, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1951044, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4791, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14449623, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13082, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9414789, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93877, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5867.3125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 622576470, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6631.831758577713, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 120974, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7560.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 242434303, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2004.019896837337, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2232810029, "stage_ordering_ns": 855501951, "stage_eval_ns": 1602464547, "stage_threat_ns": 4082111297, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 613179, "root_tactical_annotations": 505, "search_tactical_annotations": 612674, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 184522, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 927183691, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 563159, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3003275351, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70230, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1950928553, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92253, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 119403825, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 184506, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19661914, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 92826, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 188560288, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 400094, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 863512488, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 120259, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12586516, "child_limit_applications": 35050, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35050, "child_cap_hits": 35050, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35050, "child_moves_before_total": 2736140, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2736140, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 351073, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 351073, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.06390870185449, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.016348074179744, "tt_hits": 14289, "tt_cutoffs": 3216, "beta_cutoffs": 28617, "depth_sum": 97, "avg_depth": 6.0625, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 97, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0625, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5609.6875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6109.6875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1543, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 38537, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 101, 100, 128, 129, 126, 99, 84, 115, 116, 130, 145, 144, 159, 171, 157, 131, 125, 124, 83, 133, 132, 97, 156, 81, 65, 85, 70, 71, 57, 147, 163, 158, 141, 96, 173, 189, 109 ], "move_count": 44, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 22806, "avg_search_time_ms": 1140.3, "search_nodes": 224986, "safety_nodes": 1549, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 226535, "avg_nodes": 11326.75, "eval_calls": 139887, "avg_eval_calls": 6994.35, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 139887, "pattern_eval_ns": 2917329, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.854897166999077, "pattern_frame_queries": 139887, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2917329, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.854897166999077, "pattern_frame_updates": 449722, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5494575591, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12217.715813324676, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 79506, "avg_candidate_generations": 3975.3, "candidate_moves_total": 6161155, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.49295650642719, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1503, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 79486, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6159652, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1840670, "avg_legality_checks": 92033.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2058, "root_legality_checks": 1503, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1839167, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2057, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6329736, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 316486.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13422730025, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2120.5829160963426, "renju_forbidden_checks": 50140, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2507.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 236366436, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4714.129158356602, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2474, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18842583, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23675, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 148294396, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23986, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 69178847, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 50610, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 143972, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7198.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1108912653, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7702.279978051288, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 185625, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9281.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 425983030, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2294.858074074074, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4289123475, "stage_ordering_ns": 2451385104, "stage_eval_ns": 5497492920, "stage_threat_ns": 10488328684, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1332850, "root_tactical_annotations": 4272, "search_tactical_annotations": 1328578, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 449742, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2613757151, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1089711, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7437373921, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 159137, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5458487822, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 224861, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 333926230, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 449722, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56192438, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 298658, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 270655509, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 631899, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1707925439, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 402293, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 47078944, "child_limit_applications": 79486, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 79486, "child_cap_hits": 79486, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 79486, "child_moves_before_total": 6157595, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6157595, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 785575, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 785575, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.46766726215938, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.883186976322875, "tt_hits": 42485, "tt_cutoffs": 5491, "beta_cutoffs": 63319, "depth_sum": 117, "avg_depth": 5.85, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 117, "avg_effective_depth": 5.85, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 9 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 8, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 8, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2890.95, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3290.95, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 15711, "avg_search_time_ms": 785.55, "search_nodes": 125965, "safety_nodes": 1369, "corridor_nodes": 1456, "corridor_branch_probes": 1796, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 10, "corridor_depth_exits": 525, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 54, "corridor_plies_followed": 1441, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1441, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 525, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 54, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 371, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 12153600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 14, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 10, "total_nodes": 128790, "avg_nodes": 6439.5, "eval_calls": 75563, "avg_eval_calls": 3778.15, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75563, "pattern_eval_ns": 1607317, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.271217394756693, "pattern_frame_queries": 75563, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1607317, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.271217394756693, "pattern_frame_updates": 251678, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2489300227, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9890.813766002591, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46763, "avg_candidate_generations": 2338.15, "candidate_moves_total": 3746495, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.11665205397429, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1528, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 46743, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3744967, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 2212206, "avg_legality_checks": 110610.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2861, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2212206, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2861, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4856026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 242801.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10016788678, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2062.754334099529, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24706, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1235.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 108443095, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4389.342467416822, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2861, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 28388589, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6468, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 51620280, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15370, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28358695, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 75531, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 122968, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6148.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1018778007, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8284.903446425085, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 166957, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8347.85, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 435334360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2607.463957785538, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5031296941, "stage_ordering_ns": 1454864330, "stage_eval_ns": 2490907544, "stage_threat_ns": 6544394962, "stage_proof_ns": 94413771, "tactical_annotations": 860556, "root_tactical_annotations": 2532, "search_tactical_annotations": 858024, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 254712, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1501579648, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 801475, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4770654149, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 94502, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3104731138, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 127346, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 192243751, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3014, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19816667, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 254692, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31676145, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 200683, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 340266137, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 418130, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1258629682, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 241743, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28424602, "child_limit_applications": 46743, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46743, "child_cap_hits": 46743, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46743, "child_moves_before_total": 3742106, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3742106, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 452569, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 452569, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.05703527800954, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.68207004257322, "tt_hits": 24431, "tt_cutoffs": 3534, "beta_cutoffs": 37910, "depth_sum": 125, "avg_depth": 6.25, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 125, "avg_effective_depth": 6.25, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5331.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5731.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1544, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 64867, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 101, 100, 128, 129, 126, 99, 84, 115, 116, 130, 145, 144, 159, 171, 157, 131, 125, 124, 83, 133, 132, 97, 81, 85, 70, 141, 158, 142, 140, 156, 95, 80, 71, 163, 147, 201, 186, 148, 56, 42, 86 ], "move_count": 48, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 36555, "avg_search_time_ms": 1661.590909090909, "search_nodes": 350614, "safety_nodes": 1342, "corridor_nodes": 2316, "corridor_branch_probes": 2581, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 684, "corridor_neutral_exits": 72, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2276, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2251, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 25, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 40, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 72, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 684, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 5, "corridor_proof_unknown": 67, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 385, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 12284160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997360, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 354272, "avg_nodes": 16103.272727272728, "eval_calls": 220622, "avg_eval_calls": 10028.272727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 220622, "pattern_eval_ns": 4667248, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.154952815222416, "pattern_frame_queries": 220622, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4667248, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.154952815222416, "pattern_frame_updates": 700938, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7336931030, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10467.303855690518, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 120980, "avg_candidate_generations": 5499.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 10214720, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.43312944288311, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1613, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 120958, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10213107, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 4283297, "avg_legality_checks": 194695.31818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2477, "root_legality_checks": 1613, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 4281684, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2476, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11324617, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 514755.3181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 22101718731, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1951.6526458245785, "renju_forbidden_checks": 71389, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3244.9545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 258711273, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3623.965498886383, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2932, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20251128, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28244, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 165585288, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 40208, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 72819846, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55011, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 309316, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14059.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2146594995, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6939.812344010656, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 388426, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17655.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 831335803, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2140.2681669095273, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9173957102, "stage_ordering_ns": 3684921501, "stage_eval_ns": 7341598278, "stage_threat_ns": 15795775108, "stage_proof_ns": 378227148, "tactical_annotations": 2471051, "root_tactical_annotations": 6127, "search_tactical_annotations": 2464924, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 705656, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3838824371, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2291661, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11268550301, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 243719, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7257303697, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 352817, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 505306031, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4696, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 30748971, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 705634, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 84164625, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 706684, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 570782324, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1187477, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3182160519, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 576890, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 68180809, "child_limit_applications": 120958, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 120958, "child_cap_hits": 120958, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 120958, "child_moves_before_total": 10210631, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10210631, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 1346279, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1346279, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.41468112898693, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.130136080292333, "tt_hits": 58832, "tt_cutoffs": 8891, "beta_cutoffs": 98386, "depth_sum": 135, "avg_depth": 6.136363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 135, "avg_effective_depth": 6.136363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 11 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 10, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.45454545454545453, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 10, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.45454545454545453, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2791.681818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3081.8636363636365, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 28288, "avg_search_time_ms": 1285.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 235905, "safety_nodes": 1525, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 237430, "avg_nodes": 10792.272727272728, "eval_calls": 146752, "avg_eval_calls": 6670.545454545455, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 146752, "pattern_eval_ns": 3131252, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.337031181857828, "pattern_frame_queries": 146752, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3131252, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.337031181857828, "pattern_frame_updates": 471526, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3989264071, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8460.3268345754, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 83740, "avg_candidate_generations": 3806.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 7337198, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.61879627418199, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1643, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 83718, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7335555, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 5015523, "avg_legality_checks": 227978.31818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2877, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5015523, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2877, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9277592, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 421708.7272727273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18315741804, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1974.1913423224476, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39561, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1798.2272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 119496543, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3020.564267839539, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2877, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 29586851, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6686, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 54150736, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29993, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 35702746, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 56210, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 240680, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10940.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1644008122, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6830.68024763171, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 295659, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13439.045454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 587854727, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1988.2862588319651, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10721715327, "stage_ordering_ns": 2690188262, "stage_eval_ns": 3992395323, "stage_threat_ns": 10690612985, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1696279, "root_tactical_annotations": 3724, "search_tactical_annotations": 1692555, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 471548, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2588791983, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1432508, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7645030676, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 167621, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4875826358, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 235763, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 343996372, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 471526, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57256093, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 453847, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 607915291, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 811027, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2161010425, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 431405, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 55537861, "child_limit_applications": 83718, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 83718, "child_cap_hits": 83718, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 83718, "child_moves_before_total": 7332678, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7332678, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 832206, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 832206, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.5878305740701, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.940586253852219, "tt_hits": 41084, "tt_cutoffs": 5296, "beta_cutoffs": 69880, "depth_sum": 138, "avg_depth": 6.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 138, "avg_effective_depth": 6.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4942.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5306.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1545, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30359, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 125, 173, 141, 113, 143, 140, 109, 93, 129, 115, 174, 114, 158, 126, 144, 145, 172, 157, 186, 130, 200 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 17966, "avg_search_time_ms": 1497.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 178202, "safety_nodes": 83, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 178285, "avg_nodes": 14857.083333333334, "eval_calls": 110217, "avg_eval_calls": 9184.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110217, "pattern_eval_ns": 2295306, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.825335474563815, "pattern_frame_queries": 110217, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2295306, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.825335474563815, "pattern_frame_updates": 356284, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4155792199, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11664.268389823848, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 64187, "avg_candidate_generations": 5348.916666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 5296535, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.51725427267203, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 807, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 64175, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5295728, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1504879, "avg_legality_checks": 125406.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 999, "root_legality_checks": 807, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1504072, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 999, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4910222, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 409185.1666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10605170778, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2159.8149285307263, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29775, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2481.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 108305941, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3637.479126784215, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1405, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5312201, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14745, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 74644795, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13625, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28348945, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 85814, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7151.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 651041500, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7586.658354114713, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 108092, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9007.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 236284958, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2185.9615697738964, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3559453902, "stage_ordering_ns": 2151126569, "stage_eval_ns": 4158087505, "stage_threat_ns": 8030500549, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 886985, "root_tactical_annotations": 3817, "search_tactical_annotations": 883168, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 356296, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2022700540, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 737075, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5672207594, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 128433, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4401230553, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 178142, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 255423066, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 356284, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43610316, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 164491, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 107532155, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 444140, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1163432646, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 278354, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 36559033, "child_limit_applications": 64175, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 64175, "child_cap_hits": 64175, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 64175, "child_moves_before_total": 5294729, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5294729, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 541798, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 541798, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.50454226723802, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.442508765095441, "tt_hits": 31039, "tt_cutoffs": 3753, "beta_cutoffs": 49979, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1175.3333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1682.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 12383, "avg_search_time_ms": 1125.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 91814, "safety_nodes": 712, "corridor_nodes": 4, "corridor_branch_probes": 2, "corridor_max_depth": 1, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 2, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 424, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 33910400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1991680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92530, "avg_nodes": 8411.818181818182, "eval_calls": 53945, "avg_eval_calls": 4904.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53945, "pattern_eval_ns": 1140573, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.143257021039947, "pattern_frame_queries": 53945, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1140573, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.143257021039947, "pattern_frame_updates": 183504, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1911963545, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10419.192742392537, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35409, "avg_candidate_generations": 3219.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2816062, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.5295546330029, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 743, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 35398, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2815319, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1755466, "avg_legality_checks": 159587.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1360, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1755466, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1360, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3898296, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 354390.54545454547, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8164808959, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2094.455874823256, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23921, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2174.6363636363635, "renju_forbidden_ns": 69425352, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2902.276326240542, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1367, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6369920, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5883, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43702895, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16657, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19339257, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13280, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 115134, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10466.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 959149425, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8330.722679660223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 152421, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13856.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 398573258, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2614.9497641401117, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4082841989, "stage_ordering_ns": 1139505487, "stage_eval_ns": 1913104118, "stage_threat_ns": 5078868717, "stage_proof_ns": 96735216, "tactical_annotations": 572678, "root_tactical_annotations": 1859, "search_tactical_annotations": 570819, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 183631, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1067411638, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 483669, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3833398708, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 71104, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2459815428, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 134675664, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 116, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 488503, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 183620, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22859060, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 124271, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 268658378, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 287770, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1104509189, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 160637, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20035144, "child_limit_applications": 35398, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35398, "child_cap_hits": 35398, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35398, "child_moves_before_total": 2813959, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2813959, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 313914, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 313914, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.49485846658003, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.868128142832928, "tt_hits": 16826, "tt_cutoffs": 2409, "beta_cutoffs": 28403, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2826.3636363636365, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3553.6363636363635, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1546, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30355, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 125, 173, 141, 113, 143, 140, 109, 93, 129, 115, 174, 114, 158, 126, 144, 145, 172, 157, 186, 130, 200 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 17999, "avg_search_time_ms": 1499.9166666666667, "search_nodes": 176801, "safety_nodes": 83, "corridor_nodes": 11, "corridor_branch_probes": 21, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 10, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 10, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 17, "corridor_proof_active": 1, "corridor_proof_quiet": 16, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 17, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 137, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 174160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 176895, "avg_nodes": 14741.25, "eval_calls": 109256, "avg_eval_calls": 9104.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 109256, "pattern_eval_ns": 2279108, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.860254814380905, "pattern_frame_queries": 109256, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2279108, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.860254814380905, "pattern_frame_updates": 353482, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4169076219, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11794.309806439931, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 63785, "avg_candidate_generations": 5315.416666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 5262706, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.50695304538685, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 807, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 63773, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5261899, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1485747, "avg_legality_checks": 123812.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 986, "root_legality_checks": 807, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1484940, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 986, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4869037, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 405753.0833333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10628836205, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2182.9442259321504, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29158, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2429.8333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 108049842, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3705.667123945401, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1374, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5255842, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14504, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 74239042, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13274, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28548788, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6170, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83882, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6990.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 643555533, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7672.152941036217, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 105417, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8784.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 233409057, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2214.150061185577, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3543578231, "stage_ordering_ns": 2148679852, "stage_eval_ns": 4171355327, "stage_threat_ns": 8040355777, "stage_proof_ns": 31006838, "tactical_annotations": 879319, "root_tactical_annotations": 3817, "search_tactical_annotations": 875502, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 353548, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2021959544, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 732965, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5680036545, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 127703, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4415381144, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 176768, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 257555639, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 54, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 266933, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 353536, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43419268, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 163814, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 108415095, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 440408, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1154449159, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 275097, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 37117848, "child_limit_applications": 63773, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 63773, "child_cap_hits": 63773, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 63773, "child_moves_before_total": 5260913, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5260913, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 537945, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 537945, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.49436281812052, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.435309613786398, "tt_hits": 30796, "tt_cutoffs": 3714, "beta_cutoffs": 49689, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1151.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1655.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 12344, "avg_search_time_ms": 1122.1818181818182, "search_nodes": 91584, "safety_nodes": 712, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92296, "avg_nodes": 8390.545454545454, "eval_calls": 53786, "avg_eval_calls": 4889.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53786, "pattern_eval_ns": 1153393, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.44411185066746, "pattern_frame_queries": 53786, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1153393, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.44411185066746, "pattern_frame_updates": 183044, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1921328222, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10496.537564738534, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35343, "avg_candidate_generations": 3213.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2811018, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.53535353535354, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 743, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 35332, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2810275, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1751496, "avg_legality_checks": 159226.9090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1356, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1751496, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1356, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3854448, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 350404.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8136106588, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2110.8357378280884, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23845, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2167.7272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 69603067, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2918.9795344936047, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1363, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6452073, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5848, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43428378, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16624, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19713196, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9420, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 114745, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10431.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 964580068, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8406.292805786745, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 151843, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13803.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 402096071, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2648.1041009463725, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4105746633, "stage_ordering_ns": 1145729856, "stage_eval_ns": 1922481615, "stage_threat_ns": 5102706267, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 571598, "root_tactical_annotations": 1859, "search_tactical_annotations": 569739, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 183055, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1072665245, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 481890, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3849625313, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70748, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2470133176, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91522, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 137756306, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 183044, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22923477, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 124120, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 270129760, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 287014, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1109168977, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 160464, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19735926, "child_limit_applications": 35332, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35332, "child_cap_hits": 35332, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35332, "child_moves_before_total": 2808919, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2808919, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 313305, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 313305, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.50070757387071, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.86745726253821, "tt_hits": 16808, "tt_cutoffs": 2405, "beta_cutoffs": 28355, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2835.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3562.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1547, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25362, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 81, 123, 125, 140, 93, 141, 109, 108, 79, 155, 77, 61, 80, 78, 95, 65, 127, 143, 63 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 13413, "avg_search_time_ms": 1219.3636363636363, "search_nodes": 134041, "safety_nodes": 655, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 134696, "avg_nodes": 12245.09090909091, "eval_calls": 79640, "avg_eval_calls": 7240.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79640, "pattern_eval_ns": 1654616, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.776192867905575, "pattern_frame_queries": 79640, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1654616, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.776192867905575, "pattern_frame_updates": 267970, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3157203209, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11781.92786132776, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 50592, "avg_candidate_generations": 4599.272727272727, "candidate_moves_total": 3796504, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.04158760278305, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 713, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 50581, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3795791, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 964110, "avg_legality_checks": 87646.36363636363, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1530, "root_legality_checks": 713, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 963397, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1525, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3586619, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 326056.2727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7813555540, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2178.5295678186058, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34235, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3112.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 162886817, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4757.903227690959, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1837, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14154737, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16221, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 103256576, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16145, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45190054, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 285450, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5530.272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 528101462, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8681.167491328719, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 80826, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7347.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 228302243, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2824.613898992898, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2321265425, "stage_ordering_ns": 1512580115, "stage_eval_ns": 3158857825, "stage_threat_ns": 6370068436, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 702432, "root_tactical_annotations": 2296, "search_tactical_annotations": 700136, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 267981, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1523236437, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 644749, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4601032341, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 101239, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3513186198, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 133985, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 193962230, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 267970, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32564392, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 124960, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 63613922, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 418540, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1023679929, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 158932, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19273036, "child_limit_applications": 50581, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 50581, "child_cap_hits": 50581, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 50581, "child_moves_before_total": 3794266, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3794266, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 464192, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 464192, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.01366125620292, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.177200925248611, "tt_hits": 21333, "tt_cutoffs": 3766, "beta_cutoffs": 40661, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1605.7272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2333.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11939, "avg_search_time_ms": 1193.9, "search_nodes": 89672, "safety_nodes": 444, "corridor_nodes": 407, "corridor_branch_probes": 467, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 95, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 56, "corridor_plies_followed": 404, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 404, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 35, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 95, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 56, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 280, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26206880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2003440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 90523, "avg_nodes": 9052.3, "eval_calls": 51715, "avg_eval_calls": 5171.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51715, "pattern_eval_ns": 1098694, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.24517064681427, "pattern_frame_queries": 51715, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1098694, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.24517064681427, "pattern_frame_updates": 179230, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1989017752, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11097.571567259945, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34758, "avg_candidate_generations": 3475.8, "candidate_moves_total": 2571830, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.99246216698315, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 644, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 34748, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2571186, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1563129, "avg_legality_checks": 156312.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3033, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1563129, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3033, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3747601, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 374760.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7780497193, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2076.127419381092, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35952, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3595.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 160290174, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4458.449432576769, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3116, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30490611, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10107, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 85480617, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22704, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44036056, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 282890, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 113172, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11317.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1039461168, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9184.791008376631, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 157008, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15700.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 491840111, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3132.579938601855, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3671999263, "stage_ordering_ns": 1023088878, "stage_eval_ns": 1990116446, "stage_threat_ns": 5127251962, "stage_proof_ns": 61890333, "tactical_annotations": 580291, "root_tactical_annotations": 1703, "search_tactical_annotations": 578588, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 180124, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1044793608, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 498991, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3898604361, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69894, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2421346806, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 90057, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 132876883, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 884, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5120672, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 180114, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21937226, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 106668, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 276133595, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 290901, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1179043045, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 182722, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23919212, "child_limit_applications": 34748, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34748, "child_cap_hits": 34748, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34748, "child_moves_before_total": 2568153, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2568153, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 344159, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 344159, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.90793714746172, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.904426154023254, "tt_hits": 17731, "tt_cutoffs": 3153, "beta_cutoffs": 28497, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 5.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1829.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2629.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1548, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22103, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 81, 123, 125, 140, 93, 141, 95, 139, 109, 108, 77, 61, 80, 65, 79, 78, 63, 47, 127 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11639, "avg_search_time_ms": 1058.090909090909, "search_nodes": 117104, "safety_nodes": 758, "corridor_nodes": 736, "corridor_branch_probes": 762, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 328, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 728, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 728, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 24, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 16, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 328, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 24, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 159, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 216080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 118598, "avg_nodes": 10781.636363636364, "eval_calls": 70002, "avg_eval_calls": 6363.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70002, "pattern_eval_ns": 1438952, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.555869832290504, "pattern_frame_queries": 70002, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1438952, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.555869832290504, "pattern_frame_updates": 234098, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2674026360, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11422.679219813925, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43764, "avg_candidate_generations": 3978.5454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 3247303, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.20032446759895, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 697, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 43753, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3246606, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 820492, "avg_legality_checks": 74590.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1198, "root_legality_checks": 697, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 819795, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1194, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3186264, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 289660.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6867563444, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2155.3654825839917, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27350, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2486.3636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 151862788, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5552.569945155393, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1460, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12065122, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13866, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 95581855, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11657, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41656667, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 367, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2559144, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51082, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4643.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 445564756, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8722.53936807486, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 68182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6198.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 194359400, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2850.596931741515, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1970535262, "stage_ordering_ns": 1283616897, "stage_eval_ns": 2675465312, "stage_threat_ns": 5548194624, "stage_proof_ns": 116709067, "tactical_annotations": 513915, "root_tactical_annotations": 1851, "search_tactical_annotations": 512064, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 235613, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1325021341, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 501238, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4001192604, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 88042, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3089785143, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 117801, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 166072518, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1504, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9050174, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 235602, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29858919, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 80915, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 45879273, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 291048, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 769609255, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 141952, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16999068, "child_limit_applications": 43753, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43753, "child_cap_hits": 43753, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43753, "child_moves_before_total": 3245412, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3245412, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 395457, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 395457, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.1757593764999, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.038397367037689, "tt_hits": 20403, "tt_cutoffs": 3297, "beta_cutoffs": 34930, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2325.6363636363635, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3052.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10453, "avg_search_time_ms": 1045.3, "search_nodes": 90598, "safety_nodes": 430, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91028, "avg_nodes": 9102.8, "eval_calls": 52086, "avg_eval_calls": 5208.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 52086, "pattern_eval_ns": 1067596, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.496793764159275, "pattern_frame_queries": 52086, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1067596, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.496793764159275, "pattern_frame_updates": 181082, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1811722695, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10004.985006792504, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35294, "avg_candidate_generations": 3529.4, "candidate_moves_total": 2578505, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.05788519295065, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 630, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 35284, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2577875, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1483089, "avg_legality_checks": 148308.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4907, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1483089, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4907, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3572931, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 357293.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6698892781, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1874.901245224159, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33124, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3312.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 189485677, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5720.495018717546, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4964, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 47017481, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11611, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 95235159, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16529, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 47012625, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 220412, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 96830, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9683.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 780235282, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8057.784591552205, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 135039, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13503.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 360881378, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2672.4233591777192, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3163793003, "stage_ordering_ns": 937154460, "stage_eval_ns": 1812790291, "stage_threat_ns": 4477371165, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 542143, "root_tactical_annotations": 1703, "search_tactical_annotations": 540440, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 181092, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 939846725, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 447715, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3376235574, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70645, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2222345141, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 90541, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 120933715, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 181082, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20151559, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 83284, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 176283437, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 293781, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 977558626, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 165078, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20203592, "child_limit_applications": 35284, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35284, "child_cap_hits": 35284, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35284, "child_moves_before_total": 2572968, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2572968, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 336247, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 336247, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.92166421040699, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.529730189320938, "tt_hits": 17844, "tt_cutoffs": 3171, "beta_cutoffs": 28678, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 5.7, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 5.7, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2330.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3130.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 149, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1549, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 96493, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 53, 95, 111, 125, 69, 55, 85, 101, 37, 21, 39, 25, 36, 38, 66, 68, 50, 155, 169, 34, 64, 22, 65, 63, 49, 33, 20, 80, 110, 109, 93, 126, 128, 123, 124, 139, 114, 98, 171, 137, 151, 100, 116, 107, 91, 24, 23, 157, 173, 140, 138, 143, 142, 185, 5, 170 ], "move_count": 70, "black_stats": { "move_count": 35, "search_move_count": 33, "total_time_ms": 52141, "avg_search_time_ms": 1580.030303030303, "search_nodes": 547567, "safety_nodes": 1966, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 549533, "avg_nodes": 16652.515151515152, "eval_calls": 332816, "avg_eval_calls": 10085.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 332816, "pattern_eval_ns": 6810231, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.462450723522906, "pattern_frame_queries": 332816, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6810231, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.462450723522906, "pattern_frame_updates": 1094700, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 9482188998, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8661.906456563442, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 200288, "avg_candidate_generations": 6069.333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 19360175, "avg_candidate_moves": 96.66168217766416, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 33, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2925, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 200255, "search_candidate_moves_total": 19357250, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 7380998, "avg_legality_checks": 223666.60606060605, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11883, "root_legality_checks": 2925, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 7378073, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11877, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18004846, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 545601.3939393939, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 31005413353, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1722.059347411247, "renju_forbidden_checks": 166404, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5042.545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 489584464, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2942.143602317252, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16164, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 70423858, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 59679, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 256877378, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 90531, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 162145948, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 137280, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 633776, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19205.333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3738984638, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5899.536489232789, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 761063, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23062.515151515152, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1236216402, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1624.3286061732078, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14214632099, "stage_ordering_ns": 5706602216, "stage_eval_ns": 9488999229, "stage_threat_ns": 22414404676, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 5307426, "root_tactical_annotations": 9924, "search_tactical_annotations": 5297502, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1094733, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5261698119, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 4291705, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 16124152862, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 400793, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9683378356, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 547350, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 727939238, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1094700, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 118723985, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1751494, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1166360287, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 2139394, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 5273791964, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1416538, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 181890472, "child_limit_applications": 200255, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 200255, "child_cap_hits": 200255, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 200255, "child_moves_before_total": 19345373, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 19345373, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 2687474, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 2687474, "child_moves_after_max": 29, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 29, "avg_child_moves_before": 96.60369528850715, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.420259169558813, "tt_hits": 107239, "tt_cutoffs": 14281, "beta_cutoffs": 170554, "depth_sum": 215, "avg_depth": 6.515151515151516, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 215, "avg_effective_depth": 6.515151515151516, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 27 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06060606060606061, "pooled_budget_moves": 33, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.30303030303030304, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06060606060606061, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4192.757575757576, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4435.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 549, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 35, "search_move_count": 33, "total_time_ms": 44320, "avg_search_time_ms": 1343.030303030303, "search_nodes": 369552, "safety_nodes": 2530, "corridor_nodes": 9332, "corridor_branch_probes": 10038, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 5754, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 9297, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9297, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 20, "corridor_proof_completed": 20, "corridor_proof_checks": 82, "corridor_proof_active": 35, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5754, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 82, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 82, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 334, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24215600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2009440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 381414, "avg_nodes": 11558.0, "eval_calls": 230987, "avg_eval_calls": 6999.606060606061, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 230987, "pattern_eval_ns": 4804932, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.801742089381655, "pattern_frame_queries": 230987, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4804932, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.801742089381655, "pattern_frame_updates": 738684, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5137356670, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6954.7420412517395, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 128558, "avg_candidate_generations": 3895.6969696969695, "candidate_moves_total": 13025126, "avg_candidate_moves": 101.3171175656124, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 33, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2946, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 128525, "search_candidate_moves_total": 13022180, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 9969924, "avg_legality_checks": 302118.9090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4422, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9969924, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4422, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 17077814, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 517509.51515151514, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 29416538343, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1722.5002182949177, "renju_forbidden_checks": 79241, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2401.242424242424, "renju_forbidden_ns": 152873636, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1929.2239623427265, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5861, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 28234660, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11020, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 51314196, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 62264, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 72910256, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 96, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 414524, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 639485, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19378.333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3746041977, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5857.90437148643, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 738325, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22373.484848484848, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1180386836, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1598.736106728067, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18908330632, "stage_ordering_ns": 3798856843, "stage_eval_ns": 5142161602, "stage_threat_ns": 16083395743, "stage_proof_ns": 79810483, "tactical_annotations": 3555899, "root_tactical_annotations": 8048, "search_tactical_annotations": 3547851, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 757475, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3777396122, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3430352, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11476367755, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 260531, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5743211433, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 378721, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 529056709, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 18758, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 117604769, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 757442, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 84731482, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1536766, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 2154014647, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1313546, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3360347603, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 705587, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 98238906, "child_limit_applications": 128525, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 128525, "child_cap_hits": 128525, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 128525, "child_moves_before_total": 13017758, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 13017758, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 1437439, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1437439, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 101.28580431822603, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.184119821046488, "tt_hits": 67334, "tt_cutoffs": 9840, "beta_cutoffs": 111895, "depth_sum": 200, "avg_depth": 6.0606060606060606, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 200, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0606060606060606, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 10, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.30303030303030304, "pooled_budget_moves": 33, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 10, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.30303030303030304, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4409.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4539.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1550, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20921, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 53, 95, 111, 125, 68, 155, 169, 110, 140, 65, 80, 79, 38, 23, 98 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 15218, "avg_search_time_ms": 1170.6153846153845, "search_nodes": 138128, "safety_nodes": 699, "corridor_nodes": 8367, "corridor_branch_probes": 9062, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3740, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 8329, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8329, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 85, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3740, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 85, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 82, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 650, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 63464160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2024480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 15, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 13, "total_nodes": 147194, "avg_nodes": 11322.615384615385, "eval_calls": 88397, "avg_eval_calls": 6799.7692307692305, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 88397, "pattern_eval_ns": 1797316, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.332318970100797, "pattern_frame_queries": 88397, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1797316, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.332318970100797, "pattern_frame_updates": 276114, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3153762852, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11421.95923422934, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46395, "avg_candidate_generations": 3568.846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 3741747, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.64978984804397, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 864, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 46382, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3740883, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 1025448, "avg_legality_checks": 78880.61538461539, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1525, "root_legality_checks": 864, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1024584, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1525, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4781969, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 367843.76923076925, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9356282066, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1956.5752237206054, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28823, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2217.153846153846, "renju_forbidden_ns": 175020508, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6072.2516046213095, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1660, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13441011, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13435, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 104332610, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12258, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44502359, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1470, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 12744528, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 109769, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8443.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 863078652, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7862.6811941440665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 145360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11181.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 373975654, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2572.7549119427626, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2309779472, "stage_ordering_ns": 1383566588, "stage_eval_ns": 3155560168, "stage_threat_ns": 7389899637, "stage_proof_ns": 923797164, "tactical_annotations": 708793, "root_tactical_annotations": 2451, "search_tactical_annotations": 706342, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 292955, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1677186898, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1009393, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5351391008, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 97248, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3273073264, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 146471, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 207008940, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 16828, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 91569055, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 292942, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33401406, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 185788, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 225050671, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 258184, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 834732960, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 264821, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 29342330, "child_limit_applications": 46382, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46382, "child_cap_hits": 46382, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46382, "child_moves_before_total": 3739358, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3739358, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 465746, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 465746, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.62088741322064, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.041524729420896, "tt_hits": 28680, "tt_cutoffs": 3278, "beta_cutoffs": 37284, "depth_sum": 71, "avg_depth": 5.461538461538462, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 71, "avg_effective_depth": 5.461538461538462, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3230.230769230769, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3845.6153846153848, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 968, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5692, "avg_search_time_ms": 474.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 50055, "safety_nodes": 1258, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 51313, "avg_nodes": 4276.083333333333, "eval_calls": 29405, "avg_eval_calls": 2450.4166666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 29405, "pattern_eval_ns": 605481, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.59108995068866, "pattern_frame_queries": 29405, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 605481, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.59108995068866, "pattern_frame_updates": 99968, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 977919870, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9782.329045294495, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18717, "avg_candidate_generations": 1559.75, "candidate_moves_total": 1461785, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.09932147245819, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 794, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 18705, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1460991, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 731878, "avg_legality_checks": 60989.833333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 903, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 731878, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 903, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1859618, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 154968.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3622529362, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1947.996503582994, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10838, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 903.1666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 38728626, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3573.410776896106, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 907, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6663433, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2868, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20449323, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7063, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11615870, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59871, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4989.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 469204618, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7836.926358337091, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81343, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6778.583333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 196500219, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2415.6991873916627, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1624348806, "stage_ordering_ns": 536105601, "stage_eval_ns": 978525351, "stage_threat_ns": 2512338413, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 312232, "root_tactical_annotations": 551, "search_tactical_annotations": 311681, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 99980, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 556323103, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 257362, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1866460387, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37505, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1186768820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 49984, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 69460500, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 99968, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11505740, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 54231, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 172958423, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 165617, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 506356132, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 92384, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8588683, "child_limit_applications": 18705, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18705, "child_cap_hits": 18705, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18705, "child_moves_before_total": 1460088, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1460088, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 191679, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 191679, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.05870088211708, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.247473937449879, "tt_hits": 9692, "tt_cutoffs": 1874, "beta_cutoffs": 15318, "depth_sum": 71, "avg_depth": 5.916666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 71, "avg_effective_depth": 5.916666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5648.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6315.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1648, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1551, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 64169, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 123, 81, 97, 83, 139, 153, 157, 173, 155, 171, 137, 151, 154, 124, 107, 91, 92, 122, 80, 65, 79, 63, 78, 77, 49, 85, 71, 64, 156, 158, 62, 67, 66, 115, 51, 131 ], "move_count": 50, "black_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 36708, "avg_search_time_ms": 1596.0, "search_nodes": 361421, "safety_nodes": 1472, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 362893, "avg_nodes": 15777.95652173913, "eval_calls": 230138, "avg_eval_calls": 10006.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 230138, "pattern_eval_ns": 4814208, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.91878785772015, "pattern_frame_queries": 230138, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4814208, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.91878785772015, "pattern_frame_updates": 722552, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7791942726, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10783.91967083338, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 121292, "avg_candidate_generations": 5273.565217391304, "candidate_moves_total": 11348291, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.5617435609933, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1852, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 121269, "search_candidate_moves_total": 11346439, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 3965195, "avg_legality_checks": 172399.78260869565, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7502, "root_legality_checks": 1852, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 3963343, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7498, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10713379, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 465799.0869565217, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21538516889, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2010.4317124410516, "renju_forbidden_checks": 89499, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3891.2608695652175, "renju_forbidden_ns": 416593596, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4654.729058425234, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8108, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 77177367, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 30226, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 225785968, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 51145, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 113426551, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 203710, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 282867, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12298.565217391304, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2064632789, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7298.952472363337, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 360527, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15675.08695652174, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 787558672, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2184.46516349677, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8733504330, "stage_ordering_ns": 4071761895, "stage_eval_ns": 7796756934, "stage_threat_ns": 15939819860, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2755274, "root_tactical_annotations": 6680, "search_tactical_annotations": 2748594, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 722575, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4022520848, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2329715, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11224013557, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 242729, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7457852586, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 361276, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 523246160, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 722552, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 87620150, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 870226, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 594942996, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1216740, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3170559521, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 668308, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 82419145, "child_limit_applications": 121269, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 121269, "child_cap_hits": 121269, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 121269, "child_moves_before_total": 11338941, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 11338941, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 1451717, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1451717, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.5023872547807, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.971047835803049, "tt_hits": 62505, "tt_cutoffs": 9873, "beta_cutoffs": 99732, "depth_sum": 138, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 138, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 7, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.30434782608695654, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.34782608695652173, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 7, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.30434782608695654, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1963.608695652174, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2311.4347826086955, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 25, "search_move_count": 23, "total_time_ms": 27442, "avg_search_time_ms": 1193.1304347826087, "search_nodes": 208918, "safety_nodes": 2190, "corridor_nodes": 2430, "corridor_branch_probes": 2697, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1044, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 76, "corridor_plies_followed": 2409, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2409, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 57, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 36, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1044, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 76, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 57, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 57, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 239, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 20102400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 213538, "avg_nodes": 9284.260869565218, "eval_calls": 124317, "avg_eval_calls": 5405.086956521739, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 124317, "pattern_eval_ns": 2658642, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.385989044137165, "pattern_frame_queries": 124317, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2658642, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.385989044137165, "pattern_frame_updates": 417542, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3420389845, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8191.726449075782, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 76937, "avg_candidate_generations": 3345.086956521739, "candidate_moves_total": 7387518, "avg_candidate_moves": 96.02035431586883, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 23, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1875, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 76914, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7385643, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 5277096, "avg_legality_checks": 229438.95652173914, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2651, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5277096, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2651, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9449150, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 410832.60869565216, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17935072385, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1898.0619828238518, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58702, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2552.2608695652175, "renju_forbidden_ns": 132199543, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2252.0449558788455, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2924, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26933210, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7666, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 53500437, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 48073, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 51354506, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 411390, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 269960, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11737.391304347826, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1874333685, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6943.005204474737, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 355686, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15464.608695652174, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 715002471, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2010.2069550108804, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10866139053, "stage_ordering_ns": 2480282665, "stage_eval_ns": 3423048487, "stage_threat_ns": 10404957657, "stage_proof_ns": 76429627, "tactical_annotations": 1829478, "root_tactical_annotations": 3347, "search_tactical_annotations": 1826131, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 422497, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2378573362, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1634619, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7567083476, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 155277, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4479961359, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 211237, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 310184185, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4932, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 33504642, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 422474, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51546306, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 555740, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 736937292, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 797724, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2256950392, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 476014, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 64065686, "child_limit_applications": 76914, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 76914, "child_cap_hits": 76914, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 76914, "child_moves_before_total": 7382992, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7382992, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 832556, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 832556, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.99022284629586, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.824505291624412, "tt_hits": 43129, "tt_cutoffs": 7542, "beta_cutoffs": 66825, "depth_sum": 143, "avg_depth": 6.217391304347826, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 143, "avg_effective_depth": 6.217391304347826, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.17391304347826086, "pooled_budget_moves": 23, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.17391304347826086, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.17391304347826086, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5311.652173913043, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5635.826086956522, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1552, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28794, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 123, 81, 97, 83, 137, 151, 80, 65, 124, 85, 71, 84, 82, 86, 87, 121, 139, 153, 154, 94, 169 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 21636, "avg_search_time_ms": 1352.25, "search_nodes": 189238, "safety_nodes": 582, "corridor_nodes": 7420, "corridor_branch_probes": 8107, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3332, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 7383, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 7383, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 37, "corridor_proof_quiet": 35, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3332, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 70, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 559, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 65477600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2024480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 197240, "avg_nodes": 12327.5, "eval_calls": 120386, "avg_eval_calls": 7524.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 120386, "pattern_eval_ns": 2504943, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.80759390626817, "pattern_frame_queries": 120386, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2504943, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.80759390626817, "pattern_frame_updates": 378296, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4679259909, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12369.308448939455, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 63957, "avg_candidate_generations": 3997.3125, "candidate_moves_total": 5578889, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.22874743968605, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1180, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 63941, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5577709, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1591662, "avg_legality_checks": 99478.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2878, "root_legality_checks": 1180, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1590482, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2878, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6342554, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 396409.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13076331918, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2061.682394505431, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47837, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2989.8125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 282852536, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5912.840186466543, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3150, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 29008431, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20379, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 165038276, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22875, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 75701193, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1433, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13104636, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 161538, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10096.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1330699230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8237.685436244103, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 215880, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13492.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 571909001, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2649.1986335000925, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3698519170, "stage_ordering_ns": 2148544727, "stage_eval_ns": 4681764852, "stage_threat_ns": 10158808567, "stage_proof_ns": 880370323, "tactical_annotations": 1182373, "root_tactical_annotations": 4136, "search_tactical_annotations": 1178237, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 393222, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2341976195, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1361507, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7343744741, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 131812, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4529831078, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 196603, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 295225209, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 14910, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 85910942, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 393206, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47858110, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 360127, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 367780199, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 455176, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1459621134, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 367070, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 44093370, "child_limit_applications": 63941, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 63941, "child_cap_hits": 63941, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 63941, "child_moves_before_total": 5574831, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5574831, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 696464, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 696464, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.18710999202389, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.892291331070831, "tt_hits": 37586, "tt_cutoffs": 4824, "beta_cutoffs": 51743, "depth_sum": 87, "avg_depth": 5.4375, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 87, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4375, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2438.3125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2938.3125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 7141, "avg_search_time_ms": 476.06666666666666, "search_nodes": 59029, "safety_nodes": 1703, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 60732, "avg_nodes": 4048.8, "eval_calls": 34930, "avg_eval_calls": 2328.6666666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34930, "pattern_eval_ns": 732542, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.971714858288003, "pattern_frame_queries": 34930, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 732542, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.971714858288003, "pattern_frame_updates": 117876, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1266305506, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10742.691523295667, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21569, "avg_candidate_generations": 1437.9333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 1786335, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.81955584403542, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1107, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 21554, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1785228, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 862716, "avg_legality_checks": 57514.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 977, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 862716, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 977, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2200900, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 146726.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4464623274, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2028.5443563996546, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14328, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 955.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 56430552, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3938.4807370184253, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 981, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8942412, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4063, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30706732, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9284, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16781408, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 71109, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4740.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 590173982, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8299.568015300454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98695, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6579.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 254832265, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2582.0179847003396, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1975315796, "stage_ordering_ns": 698789819, "stage_eval_ns": 1267038048, "stage_threat_ns": 3153804294, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 406558, "root_tactical_annotations": 583, "search_tactical_annotations": 405975, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 117891, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 696392516, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 345421, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2345899203, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43229, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1441667409, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58938, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87930254, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 117876, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14552209, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 73319, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 202536549, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 228863, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 701239172, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 104376, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9030112, "child_limit_applications": 21554, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21554, "child_cap_hits": 21554, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21554, "child_moves_before_total": 1784251, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1784251, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 233201, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 233201, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.78050477869537, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.819383873063005, "tt_hits": 11037, "tt_cutoffs": 2454, "beta_cutoffs": 17725, "depth_sum": 91, "avg_depth": 6.066666666666666, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 91, "avg_effective_depth": 6.066666666666666, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6127.466666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6660.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1724, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1553, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 49721, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 83, 131, 99, 127, 129, 84, 51, 67, 143, 157, 142, 144, 82, 66, 68, 125, 96, 124, 126, 54, 158, 110, 98, 53, 115, 116, 101, 87, 100, 102, 130, 146, 145, 160, 85 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 29702, "avg_search_time_ms": 1563.2631578947369, "search_nodes": 348098, "safety_nodes": 174, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 348272, "avg_nodes": 18330.105263157893, "eval_calls": 217835, "avg_eval_calls": 11465.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 217835, "pattern_eval_ns": 4371512, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.06799641930819, "pattern_frame_queries": 217835, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4371512, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.06799641930819, "pattern_frame_updates": 695982, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7125542907, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10238.11378311508, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 123327, "avg_candidate_generations": 6490.894736842105, "candidate_moves_total": 10751265, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.17689557031306, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1430, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 123308, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10749835, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 2830580, "avg_legality_checks": 148977.8947368421, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2224, "root_legality_checks": 1430, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2829150, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2224, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9383059, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 493845.2105263158, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17070729866, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1819.3139216112784, "renju_forbidden_checks": 81541, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4291.631578947368, "renju_forbidden_ns": 184645989, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2264.455782980341, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3647, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13033180, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37053, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 111813236, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 40841, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 59799573, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 177361, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9334.78947368421, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1091588724, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6154.615298740986, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 217910, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11468.947368421053, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 371458020, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1704.6396218622367, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5655469643, "stage_ordering_ns": 3482143240, "stage_eval_ns": 7129914419, "stage_threat_ns": 13290899040, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2564599, "root_tactical_annotations": 7250, "search_tactical_annotations": 2557349, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 696001, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3463528511, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1925380, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9198804710, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 246760, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6857871616, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 347991, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 447872021, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 695982, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 75812530, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 664320, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 296549080, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1014283, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2044365784, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 885996, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 104881268, "child_limit_applications": 123308, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 123308, "child_cap_hits": 123308, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 123308, "child_moves_before_total": 10747611, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10747611, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 1242649, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1242649, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.16069516981867, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.07760242644435, "tt_hits": 66381, "tt_cutoffs": 6850, "beta_cutoffs": 96305, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.421052631578948, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.421052631578948, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.21052631578947367, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3157894736842105, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.21052631578947367, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1724.8947368421052, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2145.9473684210525, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 20001, "avg_search_time_ms": 1111.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 166756, "safety_nodes": 1342, "corridor_nodes": 210, "corridor_branch_probes": 252, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 46, "corridor_neutral_exits": 22, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 202, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 202, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 87, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 79, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 46, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 87, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 87, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 602, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 36204400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 168308, "avg_nodes": 9350.444444444445, "eval_calls": 98127, "avg_eval_calls": 5451.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 98127, "pattern_eval_ns": 2019071, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.57610035973789, "pattern_frame_queries": 98127, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2019071, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.57610035973789, "pattern_frame_updates": 333290, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3265662072, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9798.259989798675, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 63795, "avg_candidate_generations": 3544.1666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 5200867, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.52468061760327, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1352, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 63777, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5199515, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 3180336, "avg_legality_checks": 176685.33333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6734, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3180336, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6734, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6976875, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 387604.1666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12950909957, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1856.2622889187494, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54955, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3053.0555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 164410218, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2991.7244654717497, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6935, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 44906862, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12853, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 75949413, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 35156, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43541743, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 12200, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 197039, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10946.611111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1396712043, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7088.505539512482, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 260557, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14475.388888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 563613232, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2163.109154618759, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6612487087, "stage_ordering_ns": 1829149510, "stage_eval_ns": 3267681143, "stage_threat_ns": 8027337427, "stage_proof_ns": 133191414, "tactical_annotations": 1211361, "root_tactical_annotations": 3014, "search_tactical_annotations": 1208347, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 333886, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1751093889, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1045237, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5975889117, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 128173, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3756146792, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 166934, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 222839524, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 578, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3442772, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 333868, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37876945, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 266375, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 439955924, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 634913, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1769523260, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 310073, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 36195180, "child_limit_applications": 63777, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 63777, "child_cap_hits": 63777, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 63777, "child_moves_before_total": 5192781, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5192781, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 583178, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 583178, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.42090408768051, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.144017435752701, "tt_hits": 29810, "tt_cutoffs": 4743, "beta_cutoffs": 51243, "depth_sum": 109, "avg_depth": 6.055555555555555, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 109, "avg_effective_depth": 6.055555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3574.777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4019.222222222222, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 72, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1554, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 52352, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 83, 131, 99, 127, 129, 84, 51, 67, 143, 157, 142, 144, 82, 66, 68, 125, 96, 124, 126, 54, 158, 110, 98, 53, 115, 116, 101, 87, 100, 102, 130, 146, 145, 160, 85 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 32100, "avg_search_time_ms": 1689.4736842105262, "search_nodes": 314336, "safety_nodes": 174, "corridor_nodes": 2042, "corridor_branch_probes": 2074, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1133, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 2034, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2034, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 22, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 14, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1133, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 22, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 21, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 148, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 162080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 316552, "avg_nodes": 16660.63157894737, "eval_calls": 194522, "avg_eval_calls": 10238.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 194522, "pattern_eval_ns": 4198106, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.581651432742827, "pattern_frame_queries": 194522, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4198106, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.581651432742827, "pattern_frame_updates": 628458, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7488019496, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11914.908388468282, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 113541, "avg_candidate_generations": 5975.8421052631575, "candidate_moves_total": 9855829, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.80414123532468, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1430, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 113522, "search_candidate_moves_total": 9854399, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 2556392, "avg_legality_checks": 134546.94736842104, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2208, "root_legality_checks": 1430, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2554962, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2208, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8684791, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 457094.2631578947, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18601412580, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2141.8376769227953, "renju_forbidden_checks": 73760, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3882.1052631578946, "renju_forbidden_ns": 211402454, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2866.085330802603, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3431, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16587269, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 32974, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 123483601, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37183, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 71058913, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 172, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 272671, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 163031, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8580.578947368422, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1207023022, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7403.641160270133, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 200118, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10532.526315789473, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 411197309, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2054.7742282053587, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5997955576, "stage_ordering_ns": 3754118331, "stage_eval_ns": 7492217602, "stage_threat_ns": 14550770920, "stage_proof_ns": 188446467, "tactical_annotations": 2367496, "root_tactical_annotations": 7250, "search_tactical_annotations": 2360246, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 632589, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3702268851, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1906647, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10155503160, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 228162, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7383836433, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 316285, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 476759883, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4112, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28998773, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 632570, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 79011435, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 629493, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 323798142, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 961707, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2242194354, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 776296, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 108228818, "child_limit_applications": 113522, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 113522, "child_cap_hits": 113522, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 113522, "child_moves_before_total": 9852191, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 9852191, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 1152182, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1152182, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.78662285724353, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.149415972234456, "tt_hits": 59026, "tt_cutoffs": 6190, "beta_cutoffs": 89452, "depth_sum": 98, "avg_depth": 5.157894736842105, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 98, "avg_effective_depth": 5.157894736842105, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 10, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.5263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2631578947368421, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 10, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.5263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 901.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1216.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 20235, "avg_search_time_ms": 1124.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 147268, "safety_nodes": 1342, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 148610, "avg_nodes": 8256.111111111111, "eval_calls": 86726, "avg_eval_calls": 4818.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 86726, "pattern_eval_ns": 1921999, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.16173927080691, "pattern_frame_queries": 86726, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1921999, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.16173927080691, "pattern_frame_updates": 294316, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3316418961, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11268.225176341075, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 56372, "avg_candidate_generations": 3131.777777777778, "candidate_moves_total": 4584027, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.31744483076704, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1352, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 56354, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4582675, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 2799935, "avg_legality_checks": 155551.94444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4573, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2799935, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4573, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6072021, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 337334.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13201322793, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2174.123375561448, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45044, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2502.4444444444443, "renju_forbidden_ns": 158277743, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3513.847415860048, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4744, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 40198473, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10317, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 74467535, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29978, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43605755, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5980, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 170082, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9449.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1434780203, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8435.814507120094, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 225472, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12526.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 578539979, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2565.9060947700823, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6757147075, "stage_ordering_ns": 1864099368, "stage_eval_ns": 3318340960, "stage_threat_ns": 8176042024, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1054567, "root_tactical_annotations": 2938, "search_tactical_annotations": 1051629, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 294334, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1780075381, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 904768, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6096603441, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 112854, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3850623011, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 147158, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 227443373, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 294316, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38196648, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 237834, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 439646418, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 554068, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1806069640, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 262665, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33723181, "child_limit_applications": 56354, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 56354, "child_cap_hits": 56354, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 56354, "child_moves_before_total": 4578102, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4578102, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 513432, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 513432, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.23827944777655, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.110835078255315, "tt_hits": 26102, "tt_cutoffs": 4081, "beta_cutoffs": 45230, "depth_sum": 107, "avg_depth": 5.944444444444445, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 107, "avg_effective_depth": 5.944444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3367.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3811.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1555, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 39358, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 129, 171, 143, 111, 141, 144, 115, 101, 125, 109, 170, 110, 156, 128, 108, 172, 154, 186, 140, 139, 155, 185, 153, 152, 157 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 20517, "avg_search_time_ms": 1465.5, "search_nodes": 202968, "safety_nodes": 607, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 203575, "avg_nodes": 14541.07142857143, "eval_calls": 124793, "avg_eval_calls": 8913.785714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 124793, "pattern_eval_ns": 2615047, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.95507760851971, "pattern_frame_queries": 124793, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2615047, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.95507760851971, "pattern_frame_updates": 405790, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4702603668, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11588.76184233224, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 73487, "avg_candidate_generations": 5249.071428571428, "candidate_moves_total": 6206319, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.45465184318314, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1005, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 73473, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6205314, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1705533, "avg_legality_checks": 121823.78571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1348, "root_legality_checks": 1005, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1704528, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1348, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5497992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 392713.71428571426, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11912677160, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2166.7323561038284, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39129, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2794.9285714285716, "renju_forbidden_ns": 134855538, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3446.434562600629, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1973, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5966641, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20219, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 91800123, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16935, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37085894, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2880, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 91721, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6551.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 678114369, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7393.229129643157, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 112857, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8061.214285714285, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 233806893, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2071.7092692522397, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4055760042, "stage_ordering_ns": 2506619919, "stage_eval_ns": 4705218715, "stage_threat_ns": 9175164504, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1131509, "root_tactical_annotations": 4229, "search_tactical_annotations": 1127280, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 405804, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2344638737, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 953231, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6435181852, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 147046, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4934947102, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 202895, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 302025549, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 405790, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50038187, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 229437, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 150640025, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 576735, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1349373164, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 325337, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 43280179, "child_limit_applications": 73473, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 73473, "child_cap_hits": 73473, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 73473, "child_moves_before_total": 6203966, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6203966, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 619463, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 619463, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.43871898520545, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.431165189933717, "tt_hits": 34654, "tt_cutoffs": 4634, "beta_cutoffs": 57320, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.785714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.785714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.42857142857142855, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.42857142857142855, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1317.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1860.9285714285713, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18828, "avg_search_time_ms": 1448.3076923076924, "search_nodes": 134398, "safety_nodes": 734, "corridor_nodes": 14, "corridor_branch_probes": 14, "corridor_max_depth": 3, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 9, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 88, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 83, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 88, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 88, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 696, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 45973520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 135146, "avg_nodes": 10395.846153846154, "eval_calls": 77323, "avg_eval_calls": 5947.923076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77323, "pattern_eval_ns": 1655405, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.4089598179067, "pattern_frame_queries": 77323, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1655405, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.4089598179067, "pattern_frame_updates": 268644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2716972901, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10113.655622310567, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 53076, "avg_candidate_generations": 4082.769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 4422006, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.3146054713995, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 932, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 53063, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4421074, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 2853197, "avg_legality_checks": 219476.6923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3365, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2853197, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5990262, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 460789.3846153846, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12408436569, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2071.434700018129, "renju_forbidden_checks": 52729, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4056.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 118341211, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2244.3287564717707, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4244, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13279904, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9723, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 58084110, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 38748, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 46962887, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 14310, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 183606, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14123.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1409140828, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7674.808165310502, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 235274, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18098.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 545947692, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2320.4760917058406, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6584587427, "stage_ordering_ns": 1789222767, "stage_eval_ns": 2718628306, "stage_threat_ns": 7474997925, "stage_proof_ns": 150876236, "tactical_annotations": 966660, "root_tactical_annotations": 3028, "search_tactical_annotations": 963632, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 268851, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1569381472, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 797830, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5631273852, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 106584, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3563272759, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134419, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 202455589, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 194, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 991923, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 268838, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34043276, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 246481, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 495861945, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 443179, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1571147655, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 277000, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 36851813, "child_limit_applications": 53063, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 53063, "child_cap_hits": 53063, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 53063, "child_moves_before_total": 4417709, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4417709, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 476188, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 476188, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.25403765335544, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.97401202344383, "tt_hits": 26849, "tt_cutoffs": 3936, "beta_cutoffs": 43024, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 5.769230769230769, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 5.769230769230769, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2285.846153846154, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2847.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1556, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30671, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 129, 171, 143, 111, 141, 144, 115, 101, 125, 109, 170, 110, 156, 128, 140, 139, 172, 157, 188, 124, 204 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 18121, "avg_search_time_ms": 1510.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 178266, "safety_nodes": 83, "corridor_nodes": 11, "corridor_branch_probes": 21, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 10, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 10, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 17, "corridor_proof_active": 1, "corridor_proof_quiet": 16, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 17, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 137, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 163600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 178360, "avg_nodes": 14863.333333333334, "eval_calls": 110417, "avg_eval_calls": 9201.416666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110417, "pattern_eval_ns": 2387140, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.619315866216255, "pattern_frame_queries": 110417, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2387140, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.619315866216255, "pattern_frame_updates": 356412, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4151493169, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11648.017375958161, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 63798, "avg_candidate_generations": 5316.5, "candidate_moves_total": 5312353, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.2683312956519, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 807, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 63786, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5311546, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1509156, "avg_legality_checks": 125763.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1095, "root_legality_checks": 807, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1508349, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1095, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4857387, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 404782.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10589821608, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2180.1478053941346, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31577, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2631.4166666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 112377509, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3558.8405801691106, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1519, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4777035, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16511, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 77782515, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13539, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29809709, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8250, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81124, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6760.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 606234032, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7472.930723337114, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 100218, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8351.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 211244798, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2107.8528607635353, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3605474549, "stage_ordering_ns": 2178039475, "stage_eval_ns": 4153880309, "stage_threat_ns": 8076396017, "stage_proof_ns": 31280703, "tactical_annotations": 911001, "root_tactical_annotations": 3817, "search_tactical_annotations": 907184, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 356478, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2067422047, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 756407, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5665771884, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 127729, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4404264385, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 178233, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 260802526, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 54, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 275941, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 356466, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44574748, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 174669, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 126743351, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 452969, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1132952621, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 283363, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 37548871, "child_limit_applications": 63786, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 63786, "child_cap_hits": 63786, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 63786, "child_moves_before_total": 5310451, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5310451, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 538397, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 538397, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.25417803279717, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.440676637506662, "tt_hits": 31042, "tt_cutoffs": 4004, "beta_cutoffs": 49523, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1128.4166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1627.8333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 12540, "avg_search_time_ms": 1140.0, "search_nodes": 94180, "safety_nodes": 712, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 94892, "avg_nodes": 8626.545454545454, "eval_calls": 55353, "avg_eval_calls": 5032.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 55353, "pattern_eval_ns": 1242055, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.43880187162394, "pattern_frame_queries": 55353, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1242055, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.43880187162394, "pattern_frame_updates": 188236, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1918367095, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10191.286974861345, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 36255, "avg_candidate_generations": 3295.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 2891201, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.74626948007172, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 743, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 36244, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2890458, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1825464, "avg_legality_checks": 165951.27272727274, "illegal_moves_skipped": 832, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1825464, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 832, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3985478, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 362316.1818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8257173162, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2071.815014911637, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25161, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2287.3636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62603913, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2488.1329438416597, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 839, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5133069, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5459, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38569724, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18853, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18891680, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 117558, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10687.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 968162454, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8235.615219721329, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 155584, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14144.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 395469143, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2541.836840549157, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4223758860, "stage_ordering_ns": 1160505365, "stage_eval_ns": 1919609150, "stage_threat_ns": 5161104796, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 588750, "root_tactical_annotations": 1859, "search_tactical_annotations": 586891, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 188247, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1095093559, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 497353, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3885877273, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 72572, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2492033438, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 94118, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 136262422, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 188236, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23725963, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 129464, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 272751786, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 295309, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1120890907, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 163977, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20145579, "child_limit_applications": 36244, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 36244, "child_cap_hits": 36244, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 36244, "child_moves_before_total": 2889626, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2889626, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 319680, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 319680, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.72701688555347, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.820218518927271, "tt_hits": 17271, "tt_cutoffs": 2522, "beta_cutoffs": 29042, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2772.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3500.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1557, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15265, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 96, 97, 68, 54, 80, 128, 83, 81, 65, 125, 50, 95, 67, 139, 153, 69, 35, 20, 51, 99, 19 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10812, "avg_search_time_ms": 982.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 136508, "safety_nodes": 161, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 136669, "avg_nodes": 12424.454545454546, "eval_calls": 90125, "avg_eval_calls": 8193.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 90125, "pattern_eval_ns": 1935078, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.471045769764217, "pattern_frame_queries": 90125, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1935078, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.471045769764217, "pattern_frame_updates": 272914, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2705403354, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9913.025180093362, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43639, "avg_candidate_generations": 3967.181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 3397342, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.85105066568894, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 728, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 43628, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3396614, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1062455, "avg_legality_checks": 96586.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2700, "root_legality_checks": 728, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 1061727, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2696, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3569116, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 324465.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6355794581, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1780.7755704773956, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43128, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3920.7272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 122487198, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2840.085281023929, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3384, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9522879, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22154, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 80965069, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17570, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31977339, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 21911, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 77436, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7039.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 539741024, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6970.156309726742, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 99784, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9071.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 213933759, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2143.968562094123, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2136967659, "stage_ordering_ns": 1082125764, "stage_eval_ns": 2707338432, "stage_threat_ns": 4819987372, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 609710, "root_tactical_annotations": 2949, "search_tactical_annotations": 606761, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 272925, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1334563942, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 491893, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3259494134, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 87328, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2401947742, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 136457, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 170269313, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 272914, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28599598, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 149536, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 109989772, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 255020, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 747546970, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 205154, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 27060385, "child_limit_applications": 43628, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43628, "child_cap_hits": 43628, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43628, "child_moves_before_total": 3393918, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3393918, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 383633, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 383633, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.79219767122032, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.793274961034198, "tt_hits": 23328, "tt_cutoffs": 2704, "beta_cutoffs": 32760, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3920.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4648.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 4443, "avg_search_time_ms": 444.3, "search_nodes": 44202, "safety_nodes": 933, "corridor_nodes": 76, "corridor_branch_probes": 102, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 32, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 74, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 74, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 23, "corridor_proof_active": 2, "corridor_proof_quiet": 21, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 23, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 23, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 152, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4062560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 45211, "avg_nodes": 4521.1, "eval_calls": 25717, "avg_eval_calls": 2571.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 25717, "pattern_eval_ns": 640885, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 24.920675039856903, "pattern_frame_queries": 25717, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 640885, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 24.920675039856903, "pattern_frame_updates": 88298, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 629865063, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7133.401243516274, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17269, "avg_candidate_generations": 1726.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1295464, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.01673519022526, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 665, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 17259, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1294799, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 845816, "avg_legality_checks": 84581.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1441, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 845816, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1441, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1922057, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 192205.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2891013762, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1504.1248839134323, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22441, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2244.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 26347797, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1174.0919299496456, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1833, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3855412, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4652, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11721214, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15923, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10737191, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 33, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 33980, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67400, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6740.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 467752523, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6939.948412462908, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89626, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8962.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 209068296, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2332.6746256666593, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1443818762, "stage_ordering_ns": 367277194, "stage_eval_ns": 630505948, "stage_threat_ns": 1932981917, "stage_proof_ns": 25301627, "tactical_annotations": 279012, "root_tactical_annotations": 811, "search_tactical_annotations": 278201, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 88502, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 403134290, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 244971, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1461236201, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34715, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 831906288, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 44246, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 51133501, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 194, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 952154, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 88492, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8452803, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62199, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 125909013, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 143519, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 499855641, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 73294, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8072968, "child_limit_applications": 17259, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17259, "child_cap_hits": 17259, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17259, "child_moves_before_total": 1293358, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1293358, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 155801, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 155801, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.93817718291906, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.027232168723565, "tt_hits": 7756, "tt_cutoffs": 1173, "beta_cutoffs": 13829, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 5.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5099.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5899.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 469, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1558, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17224, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 96, 97, 68, 54, 80, 128, 83, 81, 65, 125, 35, 50, 64, 48, 67, 66, 51, 99, 19 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11530, "avg_search_time_ms": 1153.0, "search_nodes": 120849, "safety_nodes": 82, "corridor_nodes": 965, "corridor_branch_probes": 1007, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 399, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 957, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 957, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 21, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 13, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 399, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 21, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 19, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 147, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 230640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 121896, "avg_nodes": 12189.6, "eval_calls": 78433, "avg_eval_calls": 7843.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 78433, "pattern_eval_ns": 1668188, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.268955669169866, "pattern_frame_queries": 78433, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1668188, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.268955669169866, "pattern_frame_updates": 241606, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2662439015, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11019.75536617468, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39955, "avg_candidate_generations": 3995.5, "candidate_moves_total": 3085194, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.21671880865975, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 645, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 39945, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3084549, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 943207, "avg_legality_checks": 94320.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2222, "root_legality_checks": 645, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 942562, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2221, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3246261, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 324626.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6854471073, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2111.4972188003367, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36114, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3611.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 136750408, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3786.631444869026, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2898, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17011292, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17538, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 81587629, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15408, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37324654, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 270, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 826833, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64292, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6429.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 523664201, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8145.091162197474, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 82664, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8266.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 210162006, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2542.364342398142, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2235139317, "stage_ordering_ns": 1184899608, "stage_eval_ns": 2664107203, "stage_threat_ns": 5252097095, "stage_proof_ns": 139553973, "tactical_annotations": 485209, "root_tactical_annotations": 2639, "search_tactical_annotations": 482570, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 243572, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1396218740, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 456254, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3616616042, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 80553, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2695315215, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121781, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 174556865, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1956, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12191109, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 243562, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29372626, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 108704, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 98631099, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 209412, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 709113502, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 167093, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23141713, "child_limit_applications": 39945, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39945, "child_cap_hits": 39945, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39945, "child_moves_before_total": 3082328, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3082328, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 333407, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 333407, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.16430091375642, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.346651646013267, "tt_hits": 21482, "tt_cutoffs": 2426, "beta_cutoffs": 30154, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2732.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3532.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5684, "avg_search_time_ms": 631.5555555555555, "search_nodes": 43285, "safety_nodes": 710, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 43995, "avg_nodes": 4888.333333333333, "eval_calls": 25041, "avg_eval_calls": 2782.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 25041, "pattern_eval_ns": 558673, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.31033105706641, "pattern_frame_queries": 25041, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 558673, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.31033105706641, "pattern_frame_updates": 86476, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 804131193, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9298.894410009714, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17112, "avg_candidate_generations": 1901.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1284791, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.08128798503974, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 584, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 17103, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1284207, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 818016, "avg_legality_checks": 90890.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1147, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 818016, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1147, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1841295, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 204588.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3742533265, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2032.5549490983249, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21403, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2378.1111111111113, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42286177, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1975.7126103817222, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1622, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8379488, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4308, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16793795, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15468, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17059244, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 53650, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 62805, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6978.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 550348536, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8762.814043467877, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 83399, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9266.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 241676086, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2897.8295423206514, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1893743733, "stage_ordering_ns": 495452583, "stage_eval_ns": 804689866, "stage_threat_ns": 2450714501, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 269807, "root_tactical_annotations": 776, "search_tactical_annotations": 269031, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 86485, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 507804260, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 233653, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1860755061, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34271, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1108600334, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43238, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 62538911, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 86476, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10517993, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 58845, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 146908559, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 140531, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 605102857, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 70431, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9098276, "child_limit_applications": 17103, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17103, "child_cap_hits": 17103, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17103, "child_moves_before_total": 1283060, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1283060, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 151894, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 151894, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.01958720692276, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.881131965152312, "tt_hits": 7613, "tt_cutoffs": 1094, "beta_cutoffs": 13719, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 5.222222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 5.222222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4446.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5335.444444444444, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 445, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1559, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "draw", "winner": null, "end_reason": "max_moves", "duration_ms": 183023, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 70, 114, 110, 82, 130, 83, 85, 115, 113, 127, 99, 66, 50, 94, 81, 80, 52, 97, 67, 95, 96, 108, 122, 69, 111, 126, 140, 55, 41, 125, 51, 53, 143, 124, 123, 38, 68, 141, 71, 57, 56, 86, 26, 11, 109, 157, 131, 156, 133, 132, 158, 173, 189, 171, 186, 172, 170, 154, 155, 187, 145, 146, 174, 217, 202, 100, 103, 117, 190, 206, 102, 118, 116, 144, 72, 88, 160, 175, 191, 188, 161, 177, 162, 159, 204, 201, 215, 148, 176, 218, 208, 192, 164, 163, 49, 48, 40, 185, 24, 8, 25, 27, 23, 22, 65, 37, 12, 54, 42, 5, 21, 169, 153, 43, 10 ], "move_count": 120, "black_stats": { "move_count": 60, "search_move_count": 58, "total_time_ms": 80642, "avg_search_time_ms": 1390.3793103448277, "search_nodes": 937738, "safety_nodes": 4248, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 941986, "avg_nodes": 16241.137931034482, "eval_calls": 578011, "avg_eval_calls": 9965.706896551725, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 578011, "pattern_eval_ns": 13236345, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.89981505542282, "pattern_frame_queries": 578011, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 13236345, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.89981505542282, "pattern_frame_updates": 1874686, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 15720246861, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8385.535956954925, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 337301, "avg_candidate_generations": 5815.5344827586205, "candidate_moves_total": 35374510, "avg_candidate_moves": 104.87520048858438, "candidate_moves_max": 137, "root_candidate_generations": 58, "root_candidate_moves_total": 5594, "root_candidate_moves_max": 119, "search_candidate_generations": 337243, "search_candidate_moves_total": 35368916, "search_candidate_moves_max": 137, "legality_checks": 12710948, "avg_legality_checks": 219154.27586206896, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12275, "root_legality_checks": 5594, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 12705354, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12266, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 28161543, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 485543.8448275862, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 46086406427, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1636.5014668052813, "renju_forbidden_checks": 236257, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4073.396551724138, "renju_forbidden_ns": 765683657, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3240.892997879428, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 19016, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 85878388, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 83831, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 447722472, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 133363, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 231762034, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 47, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 320763, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 601545, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10371.465517241379, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3552086176, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5904.938410260246, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 759443, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13093.844827586207, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1386675207, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1825.9108412349576, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22896206680, "stage_ordering_ns": 9209451202, "stage_eval_ns": 15733483206, "stage_threat_ns": 32135484694, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 9896433, "root_tactical_annotations": 19495, "search_tactical_annotations": 9876938, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1874744, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 8629655445, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 8584967, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 21816034777, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 674997, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13339298684, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 937343, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1237691749, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1874686, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 201609559, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 4194574, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1058961216, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 3715351, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 7416824583, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1986508, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 250493164, "child_limit_applications": 337243, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 337243, "child_cap_hits": 337243, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 337243, "child_moves_before_total": 35356650, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 35356650, "child_moves_before_max": 137, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 137, "child_moves_after_total": 3157408, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 3157408, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 104.84027837494033, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.362412266525917, "tt_hits": 163978, "tt_cutoffs": 22091, "beta_cutoffs": 269354, "depth_sum": 387, "avg_depth": 6.672413793103448, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 387, "avg_effective_depth": 6.672413793103448, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 9 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 44 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 8, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13793103448275862, "pooled_budget_moves": 58, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.20689655172413793, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 8, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13793103448275862, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4807.293103448276, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4945.224137931034, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 60, "search_move_count": 58, "total_time_ms": 102325, "avg_search_time_ms": 1764.2241379310344, "search_nodes": 954933, "safety_nodes": 2530, "corridor_nodes": 23171, "corridor_branch_probes": 23667, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 13578, "corridor_neutral_exits": 93, "corridor_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_plies_followed": 23128, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 23128, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 31, "corridor_proof_completed": 29, "corridor_proof_checks": 183, "corridor_proof_active": 43, "corridor_proof_quiet": 140, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 96, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 13578, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 183, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 183, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 2, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1300, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 71994680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2020400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 980634, "avg_nodes": 16907.48275862069, "eval_calls": 585884, "avg_eval_calls": 10101.448275862069, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 585884, "pattern_eval_ns": 13943217, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 23.798596650531504, "pattern_frame_queries": 585884, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 13943217, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 23.798596650531504, "pattern_frame_updates": 1909108, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 11980816513, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6275.609610875865, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 347487, "avg_candidate_generations": 5991.1551724137935, "candidate_moves_total": 36039118, "avg_candidate_moves": 103.71357201852156, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 58, "root_candidate_moves_total": 5610, "root_candidate_moves_max": 120, "search_candidate_generations": 347429, "search_candidate_moves_total": 36033508, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 26464050, "avg_legality_checks": 456276.724137931, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16852, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 26464050, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16852, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 41722187, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 719348.051724138, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 65828933735, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1577.7920207059137, "renju_forbidden_checks": 270562, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4664.862068965517, "renju_forbidden_ns": 500075196, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1848.2831883265203, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 29921, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 105430059, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 36156, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 169769203, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 204382, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 224048789, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 103, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 827145, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1013866, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17480.44827586207, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 6181368267, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6096.829627386656, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1360170, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23451.206896551725, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2576641602, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1894.3526191578994, "stage_move_gen_ns": 45691365444, "stage_ordering_ns": 8976756095, "stage_eval_ns": 11994759730, "stage_threat_ns": 34746822104, "stage_proof_ns": 148758582, "tactical_annotations": 9711369, "root_tactical_annotations": 23042, "search_tactical_annotations": 9688327, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1955788, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 9072584822, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 9284996, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 23497840561, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 705354, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11988052986, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 977865, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 1348714551, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 46622, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 385702188, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1955730, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 211357365, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 4286539, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 2694391339, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 3627248, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 8395910430, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1797582, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 230622617, "child_limit_applications": 347429, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 347429, "child_cap_hits": 347429, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 347429, "child_moves_before_total": 36016656, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 36016656, "child_moves_before_max": 135, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 135, "child_moves_after_total": 3088014, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 3088014, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 103.66623396434954, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.88818722674273, "tt_hits": 162396, "tt_cutoffs": 21256, "beta_cutoffs": 283368, "depth_sum": 357, "avg_depth": 6.155172413793103, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 357, "avg_effective_depth": 6.155172413793103, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 17 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 9 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 31 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 24, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.41379310344827586, "pooled_budget_moves": 58, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3793103448275862, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 24, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.41379310344827586, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2777.7413793103447, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2836.0344827586205, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1560, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 66348, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 70, 114, 110, 82, 130, 83, 85, 115, 113, 127, 99, 66, 50, 80, 81, 52, 38, 68, 36, 116, 100, 108, 94, 126, 140, 54, 40, 55, 53, 39, 69, 117, 118, 37, 22, 64, 65, 129, 49, 97, 48, 47, 125, 155, 95, 23, 109, 71, 67 ], "move_count": 54, "black_stats": { "move_count": 27, "search_move_count": 25, "total_time_ms": 35772, "avg_search_time_ms": 1430.88, "search_nodes": 331433, "safety_nodes": 1535, "corridor_nodes": 1697, "corridor_branch_probes": 2047, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 8, "corridor_depth_exits": 637, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 7, "corridor_plies_followed": 1676, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1676, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 637, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 331, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 30161840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2007280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 334665, "avg_nodes": 13386.6, "eval_calls": 205861, "avg_eval_calls": 8234.44, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 205861, "pattern_eval_ns": 4594640, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.319137670564118, "pattern_frame_queries": 205861, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4594640, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.319137670564118, "pattern_frame_updates": 662550, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8005425011, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12082.74848841597, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 116060, "avg_candidate_generations": 4642.4, "candidate_moves_total": 10717380, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.34344304669999, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 25, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2147, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 116035, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10715233, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 3428243, "avg_legality_checks": 137129.72, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11486, "root_legality_checks": 2147, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 3426096, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11476, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10279016, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 411160.64, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20581733080, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2002.3057732374382, "renju_forbidden_checks": 349255, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 13970.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1135406903, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3250.9395799630643, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 42622, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 156763145, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 112187, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 555833477, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 191640, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 416926750, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2806, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5883531, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 277121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11084.84, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2336728879, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8432.160965787509, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 384226, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15369.04, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 997288786, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2595.5786073821137, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7662325436, "stage_ordering_ns": 3746351385, "stage_eval_ns": 8010019651, "stage_threat_ns": 15938295962, "stage_proof_ns": 245375446, "tactical_annotations": 2734599, "root_tactical_annotations": 7911, "search_tactical_annotations": 2726688, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 666035, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3838682046, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2353209, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11415140273, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 233435, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7285362158, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 333005, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 486216780, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3460, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28063155, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 666010, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 81843242, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 889698, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 620691795, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1133762, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3317522014, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 711139, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 88350466, "child_limit_applications": 116035, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 116035, "child_cap_hits": 116035, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 116035, "child_moves_before_total": 10703757, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10703757, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 1362493, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1362493, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 92.24593441633989, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.742086439436378, "tt_hits": 60391, "tt_cutoffs": 9382, "beta_cutoffs": 95135, "depth_sum": 150, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 150, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 12 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 8, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.32, "pooled_budget_moves": 25, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 8, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.32, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2460.56, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2780.56, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 27, "search_move_count": 25, "total_time_ms": 30549, "avg_search_time_ms": 1221.96, "search_nodes": 233958, "safety_nodes": 2260, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 236218, "avg_nodes": 9448.72, "eval_calls": 146780, "avg_eval_calls": 5871.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 146780, "pattern_eval_ns": 3382769, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 23.046525412181495, "pattern_frame_queries": 146780, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3382769, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 23.046525412181495, "pattern_frame_updates": 467620, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4450151050, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9516.596916299559, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 79650, "avg_candidate_generations": 3186.0, "candidate_moves_total": 7625213, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.73399874450722, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 25, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2181, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 79625, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7623032, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 5222860, "avg_legality_checks": 208914.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21019, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5222860, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 21019, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10145476, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 405819.04, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19347362211, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1906.9940346810736, "renju_forbidden_checks": 397446, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 15897.84, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1007090380, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2533.904932997187, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 82698, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 307014286, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 79739, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 289793818, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 234742, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 409324473, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 267, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 957803, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 337652, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13506.08, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2951975562, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8742.656824185848, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 496038, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19841.52, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1339961730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2701.3287893266242, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11416953499, "stage_ordering_ns": 2547088679, "stage_eval_ns": 4453533819, "stage_threat_ns": 11923368480, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1813225, "root_tactical_annotations": 4192, "search_tactical_annotations": 1809033, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 467645, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2708859782, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1504876, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8750093523, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 159447, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4637471299, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 233810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 347391032, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 467620, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58090476, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 538036, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1317347734, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 807375, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2794833439, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 467814, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 58933667, "child_limit_applications": 79625, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 79625, "child_cap_hits": 79625, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 79625, "child_moves_before_total": 7602013, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7602013, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 831714, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 831714, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.47269073783359, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.445387755102042, "tt_hits": 41979, "tt_cutoffs": 7408, "beta_cutoffs": 65825, "depth_sum": 145, "avg_depth": 5.8, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 145, "avg_effective_depth": 5.8, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.12, "pooled_budget_moves": 25, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.12, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5631.24, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5951.24, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1561, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27344, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 142, 95, 65, 94, 127, 97, 114, 156, 144, 160, 129, 140, 125, 159, 130, 131, 172, 157, 158, 186, 116 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 16644, "avg_search_time_ms": 1387.0, "search_nodes": 150818, "safety_nodes": 360, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 151178, "avg_nodes": 12598.166666666666, "eval_calls": 89308, "avg_eval_calls": 7442.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89308, "pattern_eval_ns": 1903496, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.313835266717426, "pattern_frame_queries": 89308, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1903496, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.313835266717426, "pattern_frame_updates": 301508, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3971137233, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13170.918294041949, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 57733, "avg_candidate_generations": 4811.083333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4924570, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.29904907072212, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 838, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 57721, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4923732, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1147599, "avg_legality_checks": 95633.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3413, "root_legality_checks": 838, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1146761, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3411, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4385597, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 365466.4166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9606555487, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2190.4783971258644, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60336, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5028.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 501246860, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8307.591819146115, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3609, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 38601185, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 31249, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 318030335, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25468, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 144503120, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 112220, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 107707, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8975.583333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 957107320, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8886.212780970596, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 141868, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11822.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 403761519, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2846.0365903515944, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2785406260, "stage_ordering_ns": 1934296381, "stage_eval_ns": 3973040729, "stage_threat_ns": 7899110026, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 986838, "root_tactical_annotations": 3151, "search_tactical_annotations": 983687, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 301520, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1773951678, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 751696, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5815785238, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 115529, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4290692537, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 150754, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 223267743, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 301508, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37919269, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 244897, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 310121360, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 391261, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1214833780, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 350680, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 48186098, "child_limit_applications": 57721, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 57721, "child_cap_hits": 57721, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 57721, "child_moves_before_total": 4920321, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4920321, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 627884, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 627884, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.24316973025415, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.877912718074878, "tt_hits": 34221, "tt_cutoffs": 3725, "beta_cutoffs": 48619, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1809.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2425.9166666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 375, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10689, "avg_search_time_ms": 971.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 80282, "safety_nodes": 976, "corridor_nodes": 1480, "corridor_branch_probes": 1656, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 16, "corridor_depth_exits": 674, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1463, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1463, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 674, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 41, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 213, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 29969520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 82738, "avg_nodes": 7521.636363636364, "eval_calls": 50925, "avg_eval_calls": 4629.545454545455, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50925, "pattern_eval_ns": 1099133, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.5833676975945, "pattern_frame_queries": 50925, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1099133, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.5833676975945, "pattern_frame_updates": 160438, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2017597221, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12575.557043842482, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27185, "avg_candidate_generations": 2471.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 2205754, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.1386426338054, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 768, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 27174, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2204986, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1250124, "avg_legality_checks": 113647.63636363637, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2408, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1250124, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2408, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3199142, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 290831.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6814016516, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2129.951254430094, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29616, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2692.3636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 197750085, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6677.136851701783, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2451, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26971749, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12673, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 127079125, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14482, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43588540, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 110671, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 114087, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10371.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1048775370, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9192.768413579111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 154717, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14065.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 461809452, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2984.865606235902, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3018792297, "stage_ordering_ns": 890990672, "stage_eval_ns": 2018696354, "stage_threat_ns": 4652545443, "stage_proof_ns": 56754028, "tactical_annotations": 459509, "root_tactical_annotations": 917, "search_tactical_annotations": 458592, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 163457, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 997670292, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 476773, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3479737982, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 55207, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1999833756, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 81723, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 122670245, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3008, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17697323, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 163446, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20907406, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 79740, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 303437649, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 261457, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1119769031, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 118312, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13862195, "child_limit_applications": 27174, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27174, "child_cap_hits": 27174, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27174, "child_moves_before_total": 2202578, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2202578, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 299837, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 299837, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.05461102524472, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.033966291307868, "tt_hits": 12571, "tt_cutoffs": 2120, "beta_cutoffs": 21693, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3251.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3979.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1562, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27375, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 142, 95, 65, 94, 127, 97, 114, 156, 144, 160, 129, 140, 125, 159, 130, 131, 172, 157, 158, 186, 116 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 17378, "avg_search_time_ms": 1448.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 150818, "safety_nodes": 360, "corridor_nodes": 5199, "corridor_branch_probes": 5632, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2237, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 5170, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5170, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 71, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2237, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 71, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 557, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4279200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 156377, "avg_nodes": 13031.416666666666, "eval_calls": 89308, "avg_eval_calls": 7442.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89308, "pattern_eval_ns": 1861188, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.840103910064048, "pattern_frame_queries": 89308, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1861188, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.840103910064048, "pattern_frame_updates": 301508, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3743166664, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12414.817066213831, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 57733, "avg_candidate_generations": 4811.083333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4924570, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.29904907072212, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 838, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 57721, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4923732, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1147599, "avg_legality_checks": 95633.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3413, "root_legality_checks": 838, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1146761, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3411, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5077839, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 423153.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10204241844, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2009.5638802254266, "renju_forbidden_checks": 63124, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5260.333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 521516087, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8261.771861732463, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3609, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 38742786, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 31249, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 311229445, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26385, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 153701507, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1881, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 17842349, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 121865, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10155.416666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1033184008, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8478.102884339229, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 161571, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13464.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 456077481, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2822.7682009766604, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2607423905, "stage_ordering_ns": 1804718040, "stage_eval_ns": 3745027852, "stage_threat_ns": 8554738033, "stage_proof_ns": 615344482, "tactical_annotations": 986838, "root_tactical_annotations": 3151, "search_tactical_annotations": 983687, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 312002, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1844847378, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1055894, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6350542958, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 118385, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4189692532, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 155995, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 222647326, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10482, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 55280866, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 311990, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36635488, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 244897, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 290196532, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 391261, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1140207197, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 350680, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 44784017, "child_limit_applications": 57721, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 57721, "child_cap_hits": 57721, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 57721, "child_moves_before_total": 4920321, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4920321, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 627884, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 627884, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.24316973025415, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.877912718074878, "tt_hits": 34221, "tt_cutoffs": 3725, "beta_cutoffs": 48619, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4166666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1506.5833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2065.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9985, "avg_search_time_ms": 907.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 80541, "safety_nodes": 976, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 81517, "avg_nodes": 7410.636363636364, "eval_calls": 51088, "avg_eval_calls": 4644.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51088, "pattern_eval_ns": 1072077, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.984908393360477, "pattern_frame_queries": 51088, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1072077, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.984908393360477, "pattern_frame_updates": 160956, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1923177359, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11948.466406968364, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27281, "avg_candidate_generations": 2480.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 2214058, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.15750888897034, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 768, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 27270, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2213290, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1256796, "avg_legality_checks": 114254.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2408, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1256796, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2408, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3170520, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 288229.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6393227964, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2016.460380000757, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29717, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2701.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 191522424, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6444.87747753811, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2451, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 27212314, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12691, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 122742888, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14565, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41456232, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 110990, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 114736, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10430.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1018326126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8875.384587226328, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 155622, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14147.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 450632883, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2895.688803639588, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2881221147, "stage_ordering_ns": 831307570, "stage_eval_ns": 1924249436, "stage_threat_ns": 4295813936, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 460922, "root_tactical_annotations": 917, "search_tactical_annotations": 460005, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 160967, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 929770149, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 396933, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3220190274, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54625, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1837946494, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 80478, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113812151, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 160956, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19364396, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 79902, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 291039784, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 262399, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1090993475, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 118621, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12676966, "child_limit_applications": 27270, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27270, "child_cap_hits": 27270, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27270, "child_moves_before_total": 2210882, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2210882, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 300770, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 300770, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.07378071140447, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.02933626696003, "tt_hits": 12605, "tt_cutoffs": 2121, "beta_cutoffs": 21770, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3581.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4309.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1563, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28990, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 85, 68, 111, 113, 94, 78, 108, 109, 80, 66, 140, 154, 124, 54, 40, 92, 125, 95, 123, 122, 127 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 19703, "avg_search_time_ms": 1515.6153846153845, "search_nodes": 195527, "safety_nodes": 292, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 195819, "avg_nodes": 15063.0, "eval_calls": 126031, "avg_eval_calls": 9694.692307692309, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 126031, "pattern_eval_ns": 2747515, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.800311034586727, "pattern_frame_queries": 126031, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2747515, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.800311034586727, "pattern_frame_updates": 390916, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5001686620, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12794.786143314675, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 64957, "avg_candidate_generations": 4996.692307692308, "candidate_moves_total": 5702964, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.79598811521468, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 959, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 64944, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5702005, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1499900, "avg_legality_checks": 115376.92307692308, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1674, "root_legality_checks": 959, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1498941, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1672, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5413194, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 416399.53846153844, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11516123352, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2127.417445596814, "renju_forbidden_checks": 89069, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6851.461538461538, "renju_forbidden_ns": 342418136, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3844.414285553896, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2946, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18469522, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 44526, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 229911223, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 41587, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 93978521, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 58870, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 138715, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10670.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1130835901, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8152.225072991385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 174777, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13444.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 440204793, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2518.665459413996, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3515781902, "stage_ordering_ns": 2162440918, "stage_eval_ns": 5004434135, "stage_threat_ns": 8943510401, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1066022, "root_tactical_annotations": 4191, "search_tactical_annotations": 1061831, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 390929, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2287456568, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 816979, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6275801872, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 129982, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4522124580, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 195458, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 283362693, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 390916, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48360207, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 254101, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 332160388, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 432885, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1421375143, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 379036, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 48529061, "child_limit_applications": 64944, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 64944, "child_cap_hits": 64944, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 64944, "child_moves_before_total": 5700333, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5700333, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 642151, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 642151, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.77305062823355, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.887764843557527, "tt_hits": 38828, "tt_cutoffs": 4483, "beta_cutoffs": 52158, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 5.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1992.076923076923, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2483.3846153846152, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 543, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9274, "avg_search_time_ms": 772.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 74307, "safety_nodes": 1187, "corridor_nodes": 666, "corridor_branch_probes": 742, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 262, "corridor_neutral_exits": 19, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 653, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 653, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 23, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 262, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 193, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 29958240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76160, "avg_nodes": 6346.666666666667, "eval_calls": 46652, "avg_eval_calls": 3887.6666666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46652, "pattern_eval_ns": 1107286, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 23.735016719540425, "pattern_frame_queries": 46652, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1107286, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 23.735016719540425, "pattern_frame_updates": 148476, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1567745049, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10558.912208033622, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25597, "avg_candidate_generations": 2133.0833333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2078107, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.18556862132282, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 887, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 25585, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2077220, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1167948, "avg_legality_checks": 97329.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 406, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1167948, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 406, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2850039, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 237503.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5980801257, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2098.498040553129, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21925, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1827.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60612605, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2764.5429874572405, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 548, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2073787, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6543, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 39254546, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14824, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19224202, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 60070, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 96387, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8032.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 821134925, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8519.145994791828, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 126236, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10519.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 340005586, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2693.4122278906175, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2754707852, "stage_ordering_ns": 828165523, "stage_eval_ns": 1568852335, "stage_threat_ns": 4014002482, "stage_proof_ns": 57293095, "tactical_annotations": 377460, "root_tactical_annotations": 912, "search_tactical_annotations": 376548, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 149866, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 901417322, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 374487, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2966342042, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51714, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1815782263, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74927, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 110110911, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1378, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7571463, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 149854, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18848488, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 64840, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 255811624, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 216268, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 867202010, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 96352, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9712256, "child_limit_applications": 25585, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25585, "child_cap_hits": 25585, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25585, "child_moves_before_total": 2076814, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2076814, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 251509, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 251509, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.17310924369748, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.830330271643541, "tt_hits": 11576, "tt_cutoffs": 2001, "beta_cutoffs": 20169, "depth_sum": 68, "avg_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 68, "avg_effective_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4069.4166666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4736.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 167, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1564, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29120, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 85, 68, 111, 113, 94, 78, 108, 109, 80, 66, 140, 154, 122, 136, 125, 95, 124, 123, 156, 92, 172 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 20089, "avg_search_time_ms": 1545.3076923076924, "search_nodes": 180802, "safety_nodes": 368, "corridor_nodes": 4956, "corridor_branch_probes": 5492, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2168, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 4920, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4920, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 36, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2168, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 100, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 826, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 34133760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 186126, "avg_nodes": 14317.384615384615, "eval_calls": 110333, "avg_eval_calls": 8487.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110333, "pattern_eval_ns": 2341223, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.219607914223307, "pattern_frame_queries": 110333, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2341223, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.219607914223307, "pattern_frame_updates": 361462, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4367891617, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12083.957973452258, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 65541, "avg_candidate_generations": 5041.615384615385, "candidate_moves_total": 5766537, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.98365908362705, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 933, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 65528, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5765604, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1390605, "avg_legality_checks": 106969.61538461539, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1358, "root_legality_checks": 933, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1389672, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1358, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5717133, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 439779.46153846156, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11977454540, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2095.010653066843, "renju_forbidden_checks": 70269, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5405.307692307692, "renju_forbidden_ns": 281554435, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4006.808621155844, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2042, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11310002, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 32564, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 176190927, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 34384, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 86281202, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1279, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7772304, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 131967, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10151.307692307691, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1103515947, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8362.059810407147, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 168224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12940.307692307691, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 448094676, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2663.6786427620314, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3222203978, "stage_ordering_ns": 2148922722, "stage_eval_ns": 4370232840, "stage_threat_ns": 9580758966, "stage_proof_ns": 702483089, "tactical_annotations": 1061472, "root_tactical_annotations": 4337, "search_tactical_annotations": 1057135, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 371515, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2202215878, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1098956, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6958561107, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 133828, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4682167761, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185751, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 270899244, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10040, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 56929712, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 371502, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45387151, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 249820, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 293707838, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 430766, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1290268055, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 380886, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 46765874, "child_limit_applications": 65528, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 65528, "child_cap_hits": 65528, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 65528, "child_moves_before_total": 5764246, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5764246, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 626810, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 626810, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.96615187400806, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.565529239409107, "tt_hits": 39942, "tt_cutoffs": 4870, "beta_cutoffs": 53769, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 5.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1427.2307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1887.6923076923076, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9017, "avg_search_time_ms": 751.4166666666666, "search_nodes": 73019, "safety_nodes": 995, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 74014, "avg_nodes": 6167.833333333333, "eval_calls": 45633, "avg_eval_calls": 3802.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 45633, "pattern_eval_ns": 976594, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.401047487563826, "pattern_frame_queries": 45633, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 976594, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.401047487563826, "pattern_frame_updates": 145898, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1549338561, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10619.326933885317, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25380, "avg_candidate_generations": 2115.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2059412, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.14310480693459, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 870, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 25368, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2058542, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1123949, "avg_legality_checks": 93662.41666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 201, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1123949, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 201, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2737661, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 228138.41666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5811798722, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2122.9066425682363, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19101, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1591.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 58323669, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3053.435369875923, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 315, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1575102, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6209, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 39163462, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12577, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17585105, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90777, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7564.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 793549662, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8741.748041904888, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 119331, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9944.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 333487319, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2794.641115887741, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2679431027, "stage_ordering_ns": 830214398, "stage_eval_ns": 1550315155, "stage_threat_ns": 3909022881, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 371705, "root_tactical_annotations": 889, "search_tactical_annotations": 370816, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 145910, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 875231902, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 330138, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2897768092, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50830, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1799568935, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72949, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 107408447, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 145898, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18444809, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 61643, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 245112988, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 217659, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 852898228, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 92403, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10169631, "child_limit_applications": 25368, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25368, "child_cap_hits": 25368, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25368, "child_moves_before_total": 2058341, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2058341, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 246816, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 246816, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.13926994638915, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.72942289498581, "tt_hits": 11483, "tt_cutoffs": 1948, "beta_cutoffs": 20021, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 5.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 5.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4127.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4794.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 210, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1565, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17588, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 64, 82, 100, 81, 83, 66, 51, 68, 110, 52, 94, 67, 97, 69, 70, 65 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10958, "avg_search_time_ms": 1217.5555555555557, "search_nodes": 126813, "safety_nodes": 72, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 126885, "avg_nodes": 14098.333333333334, "eval_calls": 94065, "avg_eval_calls": 10451.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 94065, "pattern_eval_ns": 1913970, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.347313028225162, "pattern_frame_queries": 94065, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1913970, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.347313028225162, "pattern_frame_updates": 253548, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3402014633, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13417.635449697887, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31060, "avg_candidate_generations": 3451.1111111111113, "candidate_moves_total": 2405459, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.44555698647778, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 31051, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2404879, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 811932, "avg_legality_checks": 90214.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1043, "root_legality_checks": 580, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 811352, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1042, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3198598, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 355399.77777777775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6521895153, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2038.985565863544, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29183, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3242.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 175396409, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6010.225439468183, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1356, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10956488, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17654, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 138583731, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10168, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25826060, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 30130, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93612, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10401.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 743424005, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7941.546009058668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 120601, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13400.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 306304781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2539.8195786104593, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1856051148, "stage_ordering_ns": 919293055, "stage_eval_ns": 3403928603, "stage_threat_ns": 4739691260, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 443489, "root_tactical_annotations": 2372, "search_tactical_annotations": 441117, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 253557, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1412422628, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 380612, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3105863044, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62158, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2073210357, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 126774, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 174484278, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 253548, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30064961, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 99533, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 199512785, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 218913, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 833131252, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 125043, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16856349, "child_limit_applications": 31051, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31051, "child_cap_hits": 31051, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31051, "child_moves_before_total": 2403837, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2403837, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 321212, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 321212, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.41576760812856, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.344658787156613, "tt_hits": 14986, "tt_cutoffs": 1658, "beta_cutoffs": 22246, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1655.7777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2447.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 78, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6620, "avg_search_time_ms": 827.5, "search_nodes": 58011, "safety_nodes": 766, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 1, "corridor_proof_completed": 1, "corridor_proof_checks": 2, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 2, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 2, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 2, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 5120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 5120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 58777, "avg_nodes": 7347.125, "eval_calls": 40006, "avg_eval_calls": 5000.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40006, "pattern_eval_ns": 832863, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.818452232165175, "pattern_frame_queries": 40006, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 832863, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.818452232165175, "pattern_frame_updates": 115944, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1567760764, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13521.706720485752, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16403, "avg_candidate_generations": 2050.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1258741, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.73846247637627, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 518, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 16395, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1258223, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 664137, "avg_legality_checks": 83017.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 618, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 664137, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 618, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2006661, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 250832.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4212170603, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2099.094268040292, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17799, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2224.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 81830032, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4597.45109275802, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 674, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6782681, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7618, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60298633, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9502, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14688498, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 60220, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 79717, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9964.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 725154673, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9096.612679854987, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 106058, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13257.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 321942936, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3035.5365554696486, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1591076169, "stage_ordering_ns": 512218538, "stage_eval_ns": 1568593627, "stage_threat_ns": 2913749974, "stage_proof_ns": 3549854, "tactical_annotations": 262945, "root_tactical_annotations": 419, "search_tactical_annotations": 262526, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 115956, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 690667790, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 237619, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2117869792, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32853, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1161689835, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57974, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 84145424, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16750, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 115948, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14497149, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 43657, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 194974889, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 161099, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 760986616, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 58189, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6553069, "child_limit_applications": 16395, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16395, "child_cap_hits": 16395, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16395, "child_moves_before_total": 1257605, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1257605, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 181739, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 181739, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.70661787130223, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.085025922537358, "tt_hits": 6511, "tt_cutoffs": 1572, "beta_cutoffs": 12463, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 4.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 4.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2679.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3679.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1566, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15198, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 64, 82, 100, 81, 83, 66, 51, 68, 110, 52, 94, 67, 97, 69, 70, 65 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 9180, "avg_search_time_ms": 1020.0, "search_nodes": 126813, "safety_nodes": 72, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 1, "corridor_proof_completed": 1, "corridor_proof_checks": 16, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 16, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 16, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 136, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 271840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 28400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 126885, "avg_nodes": 14098.333333333334, "eval_calls": 94065, "avg_eval_calls": 10451.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 94065, "pattern_eval_ns": 1842616, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.58875245840642, "pattern_frame_queries": 94065, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1842616, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.58875245840642, "pattern_frame_updates": 253548, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2847715288, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11231.46421190465, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31060, "avg_candidate_generations": 3451.1111111111113, "candidate_moves_total": 2405459, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.44555698647778, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 31051, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2404879, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 811932, "avg_legality_checks": 90214.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1043, "root_legality_checks": 580, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 811352, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1042, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3208499, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 356499.8888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5418304229, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1688.734897221411, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29183, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3242.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 133861647, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4586.9734777096255, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1356, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8628331, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17654, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 103990528, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10168, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21184798, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57990, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93612, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10401.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 627824513, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6706.667019185575, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 120601, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13400.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 253135927, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2098.953798061376, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1544181677, "stage_ordering_ns": 756877014, "stage_eval_ns": 2849557904, "stage_threat_ns": 3970050649, "stage_proof_ns": 15114852, "tactical_annotations": 443489, "root_tactical_annotations": 2372, "search_tactical_annotations": 441117, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 253589, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1190464334, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 380708, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2589649167, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1708933210, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 126790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 149719300, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 32, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 52180, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 253580, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25722361, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 99533, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 178451327, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 218913, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 702237559, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 125043, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14443307, "child_limit_applications": 31051, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31051, "child_cap_hits": 31051, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31051, "child_moves_before_total": 2403837, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2403837, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 321212, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 321212, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.41576760812856, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.344658787156613, "tt_hits": 14986, "tt_cutoffs": 1658, "beta_cutoffs": 22246, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3019.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3908.222222222222, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1057, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6009, "avg_search_time_ms": 751.125, "search_nodes": 69644, "safety_nodes": 766, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 70410, "avg_nodes": 8801.25, "eval_calls": 47700, "avg_eval_calls": 5962.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47700, "pattern_eval_ns": 917121, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.22685534591195, "pattern_frame_queries": 47700, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 917121, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.22685534591195, "pattern_frame_updates": 139210, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1370956933, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9848.121061705337, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20106, "avg_candidate_generations": 2513.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1555870, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.3833681488113, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 518, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 20098, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1555352, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 900202, "avg_legality_checks": 112525.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 618, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 900202, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 618, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2562176, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 320272.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3818585850, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1490.3682846143279, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21970, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2746.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61053365, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2778.942421483842, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 674, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5154650, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8412, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44143191, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12879, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11696154, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 59370, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 105077, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13134.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 683317843, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6503.020099546047, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 139207, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17400.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 301588178, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2166.4727923164783, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1515115615, "stage_ordering_ns": 450014301, "stage_eval_ns": 1371874054, "stage_threat_ns": 2624939721, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 317543, "root_tactical_annotations": 419, "search_tactical_annotations": 317124, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 139218, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 606863879, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 289156, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1920607020, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40251, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1027608645, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 69605, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 77558913, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 139210, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13160666, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 50827, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 178885152, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 198072, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 713935270, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 68644, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6749243, "child_limit_applications": 20098, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20098, "child_cap_hits": 20098, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20098, "child_moves_before_total": 1554734, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1554734, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 218311, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 218311, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.35764752711712, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.862324609413871, "tt_hits": 7737, "tt_cutoffs": 1808, "beta_cutoffs": 15277, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 4.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 4.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3057.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4057.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1567, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 64856, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 64, 110, 114, 82, 124, 81, 79, 109, 111, 127, 95, 68, 54, 84, 83, 52, 36, 66, 38, 108, 94, 107, 106, 50, 34, 49, 51, 35, 65, 100, 116, 128, 144, 37, 22, 70, 130, 158, 143, 69, 67, 98, 56, 99, 97, 71, 72, 102, 101, 85, 113, 55, 115, 40 ], "move_count": 59, "black_stats": { "move_count": 30, "search_move_count": 28, "total_time_ms": 36316, "avg_search_time_ms": 1297.0, "search_nodes": 343633, "safety_nodes": 2521, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 346154, "avg_nodes": 12362.642857142857, "eval_calls": 213877, "avg_eval_calls": 7638.464285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 213877, "pattern_eval_ns": 4453239, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.82149553247895, "pattern_frame_queries": 213877, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4453239, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.82149553247895, "pattern_frame_updates": 686928, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8148489952, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11862.218386788718, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 119782, "avg_candidate_generations": 4277.928571428572, "candidate_moves_total": 10907997, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.06541049573391, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 28, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2424, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 119754, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10905573, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 3601109, "avg_legality_checks": 128611.03571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10035, "root_legality_checks": 2424, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 3598685, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10024, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10693423, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 381907.96428571426, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20967718047, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1960.8050712105937, "renju_forbidden_checks": 372121, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 13290.035714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1145640919, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3078.6784916734073, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 45230, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 174191295, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 110324, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 515103915, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 216285, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 455214440, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 282, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1131269, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 328244, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11723.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2692036400, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8201.327061576145, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 444975, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15891.964285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1112404526, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2499.9258969605035, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7921231623, "stage_ordering_ns": 3778957266, "stage_eval_ns": 8152943191, "stage_threat_ns": 16304151047, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2772202, "root_tactical_annotations": 7178, "search_tactical_annotations": 2765024, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 686956, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3895366399, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2314021, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11746063964, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 239732, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7374258849, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 343464, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 493293101, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 686928, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 82958150, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 840846, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 735868037, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1233417, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3634510770, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 697939, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 86469433, "child_limit_applications": 119754, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 119754, "child_cap_hits": 119754, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 119754, "child_moves_before_total": 10895549, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10895549, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 1423880, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1423880, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.98275631711675, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.890041251231692, "tt_hits": 61316, "tt_cutoffs": 9837, "beta_cutoffs": 98598, "depth_sum": 162, "avg_depth": 5.785714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 162, "avg_effective_depth": 5.785714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 7, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_moves": 28, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 7, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3209.8214285714284, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3495.535714285714, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 28507, "avg_search_time_ms": 1055.8148148148148, "search_nodes": 217857, "safety_nodes": 2613, "corridor_nodes": 6069, "corridor_branch_probes": 6771, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 3465, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_plies_followed": 6050, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6050, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 17, "corridor_proof_completed": 17, "corridor_proof_checks": 52, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3465, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 52, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 50, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 224, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6230040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 226539, "avg_nodes": 8390.333333333334, "eval_calls": 134169, "avg_eval_calls": 4969.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 134169, "pattern_eval_ns": 2790464, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.798127734424494, "pattern_frame_queries": 134169, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2790464, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.798127734424494, "pattern_frame_updates": 435376, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4193516650, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9631.942619712616, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 76334, "avg_candidate_generations": 2827.185185185185, "candidate_moves_total": 7088174, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.8573636911468, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2346, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 76307, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7085828, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 4729320, "avg_legality_checks": 175160.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9831, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4729320, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9831, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10081028, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 373371.4074074074, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17912955073, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1776.897660932992, "renju_forbidden_checks": 393169, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 14561.814814814816, "renju_forbidden_ns": 912945094, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2322.016979975532, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 66454, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 212767610, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 74200, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 276354605, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 252055, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 421441969, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 460, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2380910, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 414901, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15366.703703703704, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3337034227, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8042.965013340532, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 587315, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21752.40740740741, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1448126861, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2465.673209436163, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9793228902, "stage_ordering_ns": 2265481084, "stage_eval_ns": 4196307114, "stage_threat_ns": 12052500361, "stage_proof_ns": 54839192, "tactical_annotations": 1763003, "root_tactical_annotations": 2965, "search_tactical_annotations": 1760038, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 447607, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2531851484, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1750488, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9011650159, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 155271, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4337974192, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 223790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 318934933, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12204, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 85741765, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 447580, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52065074, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 487712, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1352555694, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 877456, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3170684243, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 397835, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 52256946, "child_limit_applications": 76307, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 76307, "child_cap_hits": 76307, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 76307, "child_moves_before_total": 7075997, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7075997, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 892782, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 892782, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 92.73064070137733, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.699870260919706, "tt_hits": 36299, "tt_cutoffs": 7215, "beta_cutoffs": 64025, "depth_sum": 165, "avg_depth": 6.111111111111111, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 165, "avg_effective_depth": 6.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14814814814814814, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18518518518518517, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14814814814814814, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5874.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6171.185185185185, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1568, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 65652, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 64, 110, 114, 82, 124, 81, 79, 109, 111, 127, 95, 68, 54, 84, 83, 52, 36, 66, 38, 108, 94, 107, 106, 50, 34, 49, 51, 35, 65, 100, 116, 128, 144, 37, 22, 70, 130, 158, 143, 69, 67, 98, 56, 99, 97, 71, 72, 102, 101, 85, 113, 55, 115, 40 ], "move_count": 59, "black_stats": { "move_count": 30, "search_move_count": 28, "total_time_ms": 37686, "avg_search_time_ms": 1345.9285714285713, "search_nodes": 339658, "safety_nodes": 2521, "corridor_nodes": 5823, "corridor_branch_probes": 6496, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 12, "corridor_depth_exits": 2978, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 5785, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5785, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 75, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2978, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 75, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 73, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 409, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 28562960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2011520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 348002, "avg_nodes": 12428.642857142857, "eval_calls": 211041, "avg_eval_calls": 7537.178571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 211041, "pattern_eval_ns": 4395384, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.827156808392683, "pattern_frame_queries": 211041, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4395384, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.827156808392683, "pattern_frame_updates": 678978, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8075681366, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11893.877807528374, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 118757, "avg_candidate_generations": 4241.321428571428, "candidate_moves_total": 10811349, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.0375725220408, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 28, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2424, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 118729, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10808925, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 3554846, "avg_legality_checks": 126958.78571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10001, "root_legality_checks": 2424, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 3552422, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9990, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11118148, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 397076.71428571426, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 21886111647, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1968.5033556847777, "renju_forbidden_checks": 377018, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 13464.92857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1153643222, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3059.9155000557002, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 45159, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 173049806, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 109359, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 509706804, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 217201, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 455927662, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5299, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 14958950, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 333896, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11924.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2752179186, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8242.62400867336, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 453283, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16188.67857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1146968103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2530.357641914654, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7871031831, "stage_ordering_ns": 3796096054, "stage_eval_ns": 8080076750, "stage_threat_ns": 17265393003, "stage_proof_ns": 521020804, "tactical_annotations": 2751027, "root_tactical_annotations": 7178, "search_tactical_annotations": 2743849, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 690726, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4072763093, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2555931, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 12421603046, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 240512, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7524215736, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 345349, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 509345468, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 11720, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 93228856, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 690698, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 84381912, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 836786, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 735002699, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1222225, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3618018631, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 692016, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 84070628, "child_limit_applications": 118729, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 118729, "child_cap_hits": 118729, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 118729, "child_moves_before_total": 10798935, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10798935, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 1414545, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1414545, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.95448458253671, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.914064803038853, "tt_hits": 60768, "tt_cutoffs": 9721, "beta_cutoffs": 97926, "depth_sum": 162, "avg_depth": 5.785714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 162, "avg_effective_depth": 5.785714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 8, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_moves": 28, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.17857142857142858, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 8, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2846.3571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3132.0714285714284, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 29, "search_move_count": 27, "total_time_ms": 27941, "avg_search_time_ms": 1034.851851851852, "search_nodes": 207671, "safety_nodes": 2613, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 210284, "avg_nodes": 7788.2962962962965, "eval_calls": 127649, "avg_eval_calls": 4727.740740740741, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 127649, "pattern_eval_ns": 2699455, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.147482549804543, "pattern_frame_queries": 127649, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2699455, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.147482549804543, "pattern_frame_updates": 415004, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4192705476, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10102.80738498906, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 72950, "avg_candidate_generations": 2701.8518518518517, "candidate_moves_total": 6803290, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.25962988348184, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 27, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2346, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 72923, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6800944, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 4494122, "avg_legality_checks": 166448.96296296295, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9690, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4494122, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9690, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9452693, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 350099.74074074073, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17700636135, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1872.5495618021234, "renju_forbidden_checks": 384180, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 14228.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 905978239, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2358.2129184236555, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 65359, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 212686906, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 73123, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 275846751, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 245450, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 416281127, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 248, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1163455, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 387296, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14344.296296296296, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3285393470, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8482.900597992233, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 548176, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20302.814814814814, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1424743467, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2599.062102317504, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9713301105, "stage_ordering_ns": 2300595459, "stage_eval_ns": 4195404931, "stage_threat_ns": 11556021164, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1699136, "root_tactical_annotations": 2965, "search_tactical_annotations": 1696171, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 415031, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2399549222, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1460499, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8749705324, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 146069, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4279249863, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 207502, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 306740089, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 415004, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50939041, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 477729, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1353910672, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 836687, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3116181629, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 384720, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 49087488, "child_limit_applications": 72923, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 72923, "child_cap_hits": 72923, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 72923, "child_moves_before_total": 6791254, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6791254, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 854185, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 854185, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.12910878597974, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.713519739999725, "tt_hits": 34920, "tt_cutoffs": 6933, "beta_cutoffs": 61372, "depth_sum": 165, "avg_depth": 6.111111111111111, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 165, "avg_effective_depth": 6.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14814814814814814, "pooled_budget_moves": 27, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18518518518518517, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14814814814814814, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5871.185185185185, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6167.481481481482, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1569, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28640, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 114, 81, 79, 66, 113, 111, 100, 86, 116, 115, 84, 68, 144, 160, 130, 50, 34, 102, 129, 99, 131, 132, 127 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 19577, "avg_search_time_ms": 1505.923076923077, "search_nodes": 202661, "safety_nodes": 292, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 202953, "avg_nodes": 15611.76923076923, "eval_calls": 130832, "avg_eval_calls": 10064.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 130832, "pattern_eval_ns": 2808094, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.46335758835759, "pattern_frame_queries": 130832, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2808094, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.46335758835759, "pattern_frame_updates": 405184, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5074028761, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12522.776716257305, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 67278, "avg_candidate_generations": 5175.2307692307695, "candidate_moves_total": 5895427, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.62785754630042, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 959, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 67265, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5894468, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1557107, "avg_legality_checks": 119777.46153846153, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1770, "root_legality_checks": 959, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1556148, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1768, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5615496, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 431961.23076923075, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11444942124, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2038.0999512776787, "renju_forbidden_checks": 91533, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7041.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 353820216, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3865.493494149651, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3083, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16042250, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 46036, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 240844500, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 42404, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 96874016, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 59450, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 144774, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11136.461538461539, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1175657868, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8120.642297650131, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 182785, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14060.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 464287351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2540.073589189485, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3522917875, "stage_ordering_ns": 2090944396, "stage_eval_ns": 5076836855, "stage_threat_ns": 8806008007, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1100310, "root_tactical_annotations": 4191, "search_tactical_annotations": 1096119, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 405197, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2256211496, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 851536, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6166193025, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 134624, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4370703101, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 202592, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 287953444, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 405184, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48426116, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 257735, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 339090107, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 459166, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1456254845, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 383409, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 47223926, "child_limit_applications": 67265, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 67265, "child_cap_hits": 67265, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 67265, "child_moves_before_total": 5892700, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5892700, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 664359, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 664359, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.60425183973835, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.876741247305434, "tt_hits": 39160, "tt_cutoffs": 4495, "beta_cutoffs": 54032, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 5.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2058.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2558.6153846153848, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 378, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9051, "avg_search_time_ms": 754.25, "search_nodes": 74197, "safety_nodes": 1187, "corridor_nodes": 674, "corridor_branch_probes": 752, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 264, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 661, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 661, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 23, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 264, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 193, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 29958480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76058, "avg_nodes": 6338.166666666667, "eval_calls": 46895, "avg_eval_calls": 3907.9166666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46895, "pattern_eval_ns": 1030264, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.969591640899882, "pattern_frame_queries": 46895, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1030264, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.969591640899882, "pattern_frame_updates": 148256, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1582493920, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10674.063241959853, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25313, "avg_candidate_generations": 2109.4166666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2054954, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.18176431082843, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 887, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 25301, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2054067, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1134732, "avg_legality_checks": 94561.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 418, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1134732, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 418, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2803795, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 233649.58333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5817982678, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2075.038538124221, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21770, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1814.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 62276689, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2860.6655489205327, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 590, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2276031, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6741, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 40111794, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14429, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19828473, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 60391, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 95363, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7946.916666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 823771229, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8638.268814949193, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 125093, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10424.416666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 348894610, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2789.081803138465, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2647855026, "stage_ordering_ns": 801070016, "stage_eval_ns": 1583524184, "stage_threat_ns": 3911898793, "stage_proof_ns": 55562041, "tactical_annotations": 377056, "root_tactical_annotations": 912, "search_tactical_annotations": 376144, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 149662, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 872413984, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 374497, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2895426052, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51151, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1751501178, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74825, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 109427192, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1394, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6558112, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 149650, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18396549, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 64903, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 257991269, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 216145, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 862022279, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 96008, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9676904, "child_limit_applications": 25301, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25301, "child_cap_hits": 25301, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25301, "child_moves_before_total": 2053649, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2053649, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 250028, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 250028, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.16868898462512, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.882139045887515, "tt_hits": 11410, "tt_cutoffs": 1933, "beta_cutoffs": 19901, "depth_sum": 68, "avg_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 68, "avg_effective_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4145.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4812.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 15, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1570, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 34891, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 114, 81, 79, 66, 113, 111, 100, 86, 116, 115, 84, 68, 144, 160, 129, 99, 131, 130, 145, 50, 34, 161, 159, 174, 173, 117, 187 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 24062, "avg_search_time_ms": 1604.1333333333334, "search_nodes": 215069, "safety_nodes": 295, "corridor_nodes": 3135, "corridor_branch_probes": 3494, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1383, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 3111, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3111, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 84, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 60, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1383, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 84, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 690, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 29993920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 218499, "avg_nodes": 14566.6, "eval_calls": 132789, "avg_eval_calls": 8852.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 132789, "pattern_eval_ns": 2947124, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.194037156692197, "pattern_frame_queries": 132789, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2947124, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.194037156692197, "pattern_frame_updates": 429972, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5433649459, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12637.21697924516, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 77116, "avg_candidate_generations": 5141.066666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 6826724, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.52539032107474, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1120, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 77101, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6825604, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1629205, "avg_legality_checks": 108613.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3347, "root_legality_checks": 1120, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1628085, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3345, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6366273, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 424418.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14134846031, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2220.2701692183164, "renju_forbidden_checks": 84289, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5619.266666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 394136464, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4676.013050338715, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4031, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 29200915, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 41916, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 239877364, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37727, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 121125955, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 615, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3932230, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 151839, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10122.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1347140345, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8872.162915983377, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 200957, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13397.133333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 554166751, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2757.6384549928594, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4019389488, "stage_ordering_ns": 2683616649, "stage_eval_ns": 5436596583, "stage_threat_ns": 11338303209, "stage_proof_ns": 509323376, "tactical_annotations": 1338577, "root_tactical_annotations": 5303, "search_tactical_annotations": 1333274, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 436377, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2674692555, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1231093, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8179807053, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 156040, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5655031366, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 218181, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 335636930, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6390, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 36847550, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 436362, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56008907, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 353614, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 423675696, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 540901, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1627945202, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 444062, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 55310214, "child_limit_applications": 77101, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 77101, "child_cap_hits": 77101, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 77101, "child_moves_before_total": 6822259, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6822259, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 783724, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 783724, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.48470188454105, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.164900584947018, "tt_hits": 44967, "tt_cutoffs": 5098, "beta_cutoffs": 63445, "depth_sum": 79, "avg_depth": 5.266666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 79, "avg_effective_depth": 5.266666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 900.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1301.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 10814, "avg_search_time_ms": 772.4285714285714, "search_nodes": 82998, "safety_nodes": 1417, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 84415, "avg_nodes": 6029.642857142857, "eval_calls": 51878, "avg_eval_calls": 3705.5714285714284, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51878, "pattern_eval_ns": 1164817, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.45300512741432, "pattern_frame_queries": 51878, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1164817, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.45300512741432, "pattern_frame_updates": 165830, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1886318828, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11375.015546041126, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28753, "avg_candidate_generations": 2053.785714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 2374215, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.57277501478107, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1045, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 28739, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2373170, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1280460, "avg_legality_checks": 91461.42857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1524, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1280460, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1524, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3117992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 222713.7142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6925803739, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2221.238456994117, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28650, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2046.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_ns": 103723350, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3620.361256544503, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1823, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15322107, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9028, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57000838, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17770, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31153424, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 29, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 246981, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 107918, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7708.428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 986437489, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9140.620554495079, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 144914, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10351.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 412183465, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2844.331569068551, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3200718056, "stage_ordering_ns": 994334914, "stage_eval_ns": 1887483645, "stage_threat_ns": 4665281460, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 461941, "root_tactical_annotations": 966, "search_tactical_annotations": 460975, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 165844, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1033534383, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 404375, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3470498329, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 57589, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2093583320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 82915, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 127308978, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 165830, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21837182, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 85616, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 305965763, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 261161, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1070591793, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 115164, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12102588, "child_limit_applications": 28739, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28739, "child_cap_hits": 28739, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28739, "child_moves_before_total": 2371646, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2371646, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 294600, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 294600, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.52360903302133, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.250878597028429, "tt_hits": 13223, "tt_cutoffs": 2299, "beta_cutoffs": 22829, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 5.857142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 5.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4530.071428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5101.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 61, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1571, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 38082, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 141, 99, 129, 54, 69, 86, 140, 154, 142, 139, 127, 157, 156, 111, 124, 172, 110, 100, 72, 158, 125, 123, 155, 170, 95 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 23306, "avg_search_time_ms": 1664.7142857142858, "search_nodes": 218173, "safety_nodes": 657, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 218830, "avg_nodes": 15630.714285714286, "eval_calls": 144126, "avg_eval_calls": 10294.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 144126, "pattern_eval_ns": 3125259, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.6842138129137, "pattern_frame_queries": 144126, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3125259, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.6842138129137, "pattern_frame_updates": 436194, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6576623316, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15077.289728882102, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 68288, "avg_candidate_generations": 4877.714285714285, "candidate_moves_total": 6205103, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.86666764292409, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1081, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 68274, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6204022, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1641495, "avg_legality_checks": 117249.64285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5353, "root_legality_checks": 1081, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1640414, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5353, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6444743, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 460338.78571428574, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13572881204, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2106.039170840482, "renju_forbidden_checks": 104670, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7476.428571428572, "renju_forbidden_ns": 704779935, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6733.351820005732, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8395, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 77426659, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 52185, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 431988529, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 44076, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 195236546, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 128201, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 199554, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14253.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1796396985, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9002.059517724525, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 275921, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19708.64285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 792147749, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2870.9222893509373, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3896924268, "stage_ordering_ns": 2344896501, "stage_eval_ns": 6579748575, "stage_threat_ns": 10409297501, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1458216, "root_tactical_annotations": 3599, "search_tactical_annotations": 1454617, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 436208, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2542761819, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1167863, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7429082349, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 136651, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4760450631, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 218097, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 323859942, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 436194, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55409264, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 419273, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 630777985, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 611928, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2037553871, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 427015, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 58184127, "child_limit_applications": 68274, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 68274, "child_cap_hits": 68274, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 68274, "child_moves_before_total": 6198669, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6198669, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 895978, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 895978, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.79106248352228, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.12326800831942, "tt_hits": 37606, "tt_cutoffs": 5699, "beta_cutoffs": 56880, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.42857142857142855, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2406.5714285714284, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2747.6428571428573, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 14766, "avg_search_time_ms": 1135.8461538461538, "search_nodes": 113203, "safety_nodes": 1372, "corridor_nodes": 1907, "corridor_branch_probes": 2364, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 13, "corridor_depth_exits": 790, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1888, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1888, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 67, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 790, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 67, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 67, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 452, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 41780480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 116482, "avg_nodes": 8960.153846153846, "eval_calls": 70494, "avg_eval_calls": 5422.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70494, "pattern_eval_ns": 1555122, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.060345561324368, "pattern_frame_queries": 70494, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1555122, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.060345561324368, "pattern_frame_updates": 226252, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2817359144, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12452.30603044393, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37884, "avg_candidate_generations": 2914.153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 3247908, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.73297434273044, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 997, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 37871, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3246911, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1607570, "avg_legality_checks": 123659.23076923077, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3883, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1607570, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3883, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4221261, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 324712.3846153846, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9115518324, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2159.4301617455067, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41230, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3171.5384615384614, "renju_forbidden_ns": 269514888, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6536.863642978414, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5440, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53855997, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15325, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 140775818, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20451, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 74783481, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 99592, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 137625, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10586.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1316747529, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9567.647803814714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 192731, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14825.461538461539, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 601861789, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3122.807379196912, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3969105808, "stage_ordering_ns": 1327491091, "stage_eval_ns": 2818914266, "stage_threat_ns": 6475882255, "stage_proof_ns": 102945335, "tactical_annotations": 754699, "root_tactical_annotations": 1369, "search_tactical_annotations": 753330, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 230175, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1439351283, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 753368, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4784476478, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 76805, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2757156813, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115081, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 177472852, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3910, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21052532, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 230162, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30201643, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 133980, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 438817634, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 430291, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1504773502, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 190428, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23327467, "child_limit_applications": 37871, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37871, "child_cap_hits": 37871, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37871, "child_moves_before_total": 3243028, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3243028, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 476380, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 476380, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.63354545694595, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.579018246151408, "tt_hits": 19547, "tt_cutoffs": 4761, "beta_cutoffs": 31175, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 5.923076923076923, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 5.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3718.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4333.538461538462, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1615, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1572, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 37694, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 141, 99, 129, 54, 69, 86, 140, 154, 142, 139, 127, 157, 156, 111, 124, 172, 110, 100, 72, 158, 125, 123, 155, 170, 95 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 23468, "avg_search_time_ms": 1676.2857142857142, "search_nodes": 215907, "safety_nodes": 657, "corridor_nodes": 550, "corridor_branch_probes": 658, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 236, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 545, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 545, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 29, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 236, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 29, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 168, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 10074480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4000000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 217114, "avg_nodes": 15508.142857142857, "eval_calls": 143786, "avg_eval_calls": 10270.42857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 143786, "pattern_eval_ns": 3078265, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.408655919213274, "pattern_frame_queries": 143786, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3078265, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.408655919213274, "pattern_frame_updates": 431654, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6607337612, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15307.022782135691, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 66740, "avg_candidate_generations": 4767.142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 6045974, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.58996104285286, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1081, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 66726, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6044893, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1562725, "avg_legality_checks": 111623.21428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5362, "root_legality_checks": 1081, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1561644, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5362, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6378276, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 455591.14285714284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13641725169, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2138.7793769037276, "renju_forbidden_checks": 104023, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7430.214285714285, "renju_forbidden_ns": 713715779, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6861.134354902281, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8034, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 75166014, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 54436, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 442039868, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 41375, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 195169132, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 178, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1340765, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 190757, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13625.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1759849437, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9225.608690637828, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 264089, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18863.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 781937954, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2960.8880112386355, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3779937390, "stage_ordering_ns": 2377566730, "stage_eval_ns": 6610415877, "stage_threat_ns": 10512165038, "stage_proof_ns": 112973331, "tactical_annotations": 1407485, "root_tactical_annotations": 3603, "search_tactical_annotations": 1403882, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 432816, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2575445268, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1169881, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7493088671, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 133875, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4799795345, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 216401, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 326351901, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1148, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6178071, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 432802, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55587456, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 409751, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 641855208, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 593674, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1965549341, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 404060, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 55513671, "child_limit_applications": 66726, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 66726, "child_cap_hits": 66726, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 66726, "child_moves_before_total": 6039531, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6039531, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 871274, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 871274, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.51240895602913, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.057488834936906, "tt_hits": 36353, "tt_cutoffs": 5316, "beta_cutoffs": 55471, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.42857142857142855, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2313.5714285714284, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2644.4285714285716, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 14211, "avg_search_time_ms": 1093.1538461538462, "search_nodes": 113203, "safety_nodes": 1372, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 114575, "avg_nodes": 8813.461538461539, "eval_calls": 70494, "avg_eval_calls": 5422.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70494, "pattern_eval_ns": 1519837, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.559806508355322, "pattern_frame_queries": 70494, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1519837, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.559806508355322, "pattern_frame_updates": 226252, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2785160250, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12309.991734879692, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37884, "avg_candidate_generations": 2914.153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 3247908, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.73297434273044, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 997, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 37871, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3246911, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1607570, "avg_legality_checks": 123659.23076923077, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3883, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1607570, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3883, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4166925, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 320532.6923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8825321335, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2117.945807759919, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41188, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3168.3076923076924, "renju_forbidden_ns": 267627368, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6497.702437603185, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5440, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 54546451, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15325, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 138617885, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20409, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 74337212, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 125820, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 137625, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10586.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1291846806, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9386.716119891009, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 192731, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14825.461538461539, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 588813431, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3055.104944196834, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3888475397, "stage_ordering_ns": 1317087914, "stage_eval_ns": 2786680087, "stage_threat_ns": 6151094614, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 754699, "root_tactical_annotations": 1369, "search_tactical_annotations": 753330, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 226265, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1355989772, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 640126, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4574172191, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75845, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2667978063, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 113126, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 169707612, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 226252, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28978721, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 133980, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 431141696, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 430291, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1474740551, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 190428, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22246318, "child_limit_applications": 37871, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37871, "child_cap_hits": 37871, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37871, "child_moves_before_total": 3243028, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3243028, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 476380, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 476380, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.63354545694595, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.579018246151408, "tt_hits": 19547, "tt_cutoffs": 4761, "beta_cutoffs": 31175, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 5.923076923076923, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 5.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4055.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4670.538461538462, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1620, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1573, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19385, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 70, 82, 94, 83, 81, 66, 50, 68, 53, 52, 36, 67, 97, 65, 64, 69 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 12962, "avg_search_time_ms": 1440.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 130872, "safety_nodes": 74, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 130946, "avg_nodes": 14549.555555555555, "eval_calls": 98448, "avg_eval_calls": 10938.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 98448, "pattern_eval_ns": 2151710, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.85630993011539, "pattern_frame_queries": 98448, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2151710, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.85630993011539, "pattern_frame_updates": 261666, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4320039285, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 16509.74633693334, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30807, "avg_candidate_generations": 3423.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2421517, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.60281754146784, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 596, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 30798, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2420921, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 821832, "avg_legality_checks": 91314.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1427, "root_legality_checks": 596, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 821236, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1426, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3381888, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 375765.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7749318904, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2291.4179606184475, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45423, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5047.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 286342521, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6303.910375800806, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1924, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16300445, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28075, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 227865095, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15419, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42115951, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61030, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97993, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10888.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 879204556, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8972.115926647823, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 127844, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14204.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 354300746, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2771.3521635743564, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2083906892, "stage_ordering_ns": 1029549088, "stage_eval_ns": 4322190995, "stage_threat_ns": 5491755937, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 461175, "root_tactical_annotations": 2426, "search_tactical_annotations": 458749, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 261675, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1660016321, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 395418, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3577128541, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61652, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2347397531, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 130833, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 201765282, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 261666, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35232422, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 99961, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 221265610, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 233797, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1008456800, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 127417, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17613371, "child_limit_applications": 30798, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30798, "child_cap_hits": 30798, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30798, "child_moves_before_total": 2419495, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2419495, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 315625, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 315625, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.56013377492044, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.248230404571725, "tt_hits": 14396, "tt_cutoffs": 1588, "beta_cutoffs": 21947, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 4.222222222222222, "max_depth": 6, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 4.222222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 6, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1018.3333333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1582.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6416, "avg_search_time_ms": 802.0, "search_nodes": 52882, "safety_nodes": 782, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 1, "corridor_proof_completed": 1, "corridor_proof_checks": 2, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 2, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 2, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 2, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 1920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53664, "avg_nodes": 6708.0, "eval_calls": 36433, "avg_eval_calls": 4554.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36433, "pattern_eval_ns": 797462, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.888452776329153, "pattern_frame_queries": 36433, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 797462, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.888452776329153, "pattern_frame_updates": 105686, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1522552677, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14406.380003027838, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15042, "avg_candidate_generations": 1880.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1166194, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.52918494881, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 529, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 15034, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1165665, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 621215, "avg_legality_checks": 77651.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 790, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 621215, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 790, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1852581, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 231572.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4089900161, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2207.67683626249, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17284, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2160.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 88021515, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5092.658817403379, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 891, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8897483, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7778, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64391162, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8610, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14675940, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 56930, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72153, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9019.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 685853470, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9505.543359250481, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 96264, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12033.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 302255293, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3139.8580258455913, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1559078019, "stage_ordering_ns": 497195920, "stage_eval_ns": 1523350139, "stage_threat_ns": 2801597916, "stage_proof_ns": 3704056, "tactical_annotations": 235393, "root_tactical_annotations": 419, "search_tactical_annotations": 234974, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 105698, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 673392076, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 212454, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2027740667, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30131, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1127265751, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52845, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80924836, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16850, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 105690, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14067833, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 38757, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 186371527, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 143556, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 713861729, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53080, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5455654, "child_limit_applications": 15034, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15034, "child_cap_hits": 15034, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15034, "child_moves_before_total": 1164875, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1164875, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 161727, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 161727, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.48270586670215, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.757416522548889, "tt_hits": 6029, "tt_cutoffs": 1377, "beta_cutoffs": 11351, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 4.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 4.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2804.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3804.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1574, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19407, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 70, 82, 94, 83, 81, 66, 50, 68, 53, 52, 36, 67, 97, 65, 64, 69 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 12976, "avg_search_time_ms": 1441.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 130372, "safety_nodes": 74, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 130446, "avg_nodes": 14494.0, "eval_calls": 98113, "avg_eval_calls": 10901.444444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 98113, "pattern_eval_ns": 2139070, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.80210573522367, "pattern_frame_queries": 98113, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2139070, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.80210573522367, "pattern_frame_updates": 260666, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4322656462, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 16583.123468346468, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30644, "avg_candidate_generations": 3404.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 2408049, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.58141887482051, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 596, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 30635, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2407453, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 817938, "avg_legality_checks": 90882.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1427, "root_legality_checks": 596, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 817342, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1426, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3371179, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 374575.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7751251411, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2299.270199238901, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45397, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5044.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 288016383, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6344.392426812345, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1924, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16529762, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28061, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 229158620, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15407, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42268420, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 59581, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97881, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10875.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 881256543, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9003.346338921752, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 127695, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14188.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 355743859, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2785.8871451505543, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2080767282, "stage_ordering_ns": 1027017514, "stage_eval_ns": 4324795532, "stage_threat_ns": 5510364621, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 459914, "root_tactical_annotations": 2426, "search_tactical_annotations": 457488, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 260675, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1670265067, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 394885, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3583498060, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 61326, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2349189331, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 130333, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 202966077, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 260666, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34774840, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 99950, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 222246303, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 233601, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1012052426, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 126363, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18860577, "child_limit_applications": 30635, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30635, "child_cap_hits": 30635, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30635, "child_moves_before_total": 2406027, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2406027, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 314289, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 314289, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.53850171372613, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.25914803329525, "tt_hits": 14264, "tt_cutoffs": 1586, "beta_cutoffs": 21831, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 4.222222222222222, "max_depth": 6, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 4.222222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 6, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1014.2222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1577.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6421, "avg_search_time_ms": 802.625, "search_nodes": 52519, "safety_nodes": 782, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53301, "avg_nodes": 6662.625, "eval_calls": 36189, "avg_eval_calls": 4523.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36189, "pattern_eval_ns": 800016, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.106606980021553, "pattern_frame_queries": 36189, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 800016, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.106606980021553, "pattern_frame_updates": 104960, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1525959181, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14538.483050685976, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14939, "avg_candidate_generations": 1867.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1157531, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.48383425932124, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 529, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 14931, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1157002, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 614667, "avg_legality_checks": 76833.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 790, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 614667, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 790, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1834510, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 229313.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4092081954, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2230.6130541670527, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17183, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2147.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 88253588, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5136.098934993889, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 891, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9050999, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7752, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64382115, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8535, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14759384, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 61090, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 71337, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8917.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 686150847, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9618.44270154338, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95168, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11896.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 303185517, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3185.792671906523, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1558200900, "stage_ordering_ns": 497518447, "stage_eval_ns": 1526759197, "stage_threat_ns": 2810269626, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 233738, "root_tactical_annotations": 419, "search_tactical_annotations": 233319, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 104968, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 673065028, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 210971, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2034268848, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29917, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1130688651, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 82403270, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 104960, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13936859, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 38519, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 187215122, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 142529, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 716120782, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 52690, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6595621, "child_limit_applications": 14931, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14931, "child_cap_hits": 14931, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14931, "child_moves_before_total": 1156212, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1156212, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 160607, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 160607, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.43701024713683, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.756613756613756, "tt_hits": 5977, "tt_cutoffs": 1361, "beta_cutoffs": 11276, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 4.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 4.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2802.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3802.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1575, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 42919, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 128, 113, 99, 114, 115, 131, 130, 100, 83, 111, 68, 141, 53, 38, 67, 51, 81, 95, 39, 25, 143, 155, 169, 156, 126, 157, 172, 158, 154, 159 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 25483, "avg_search_time_ms": 1499.0, "search_nodes": 228310, "safety_nodes": 495, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 228805, "avg_nodes": 13459.117647058823, "eval_calls": 137000, "avg_eval_calls": 8058.823529411765, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 137000, "pattern_eval_ns": 3025954, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.087255474452554, "pattern_frame_queries": 137000, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3025954, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.087255474452554, "pattern_frame_updates": 456434, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5827976667, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12768.498111446563, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 84276, "avg_candidate_generations": 4957.411764705882, "candidate_moves_total": 7130172, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.60501210308985, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1261, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 84259, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7128911, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 2051011, "avg_legality_checks": 120647.70588235294, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1809, "root_legality_checks": 1261, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 2049750, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1806, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6663619, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 391977.5882352941, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15086181194, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2263.9621493965965, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37252, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2191.294117647059, "renju_forbidden_ns": 169962361, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4562.502979705788, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2229, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18448912, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15843, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 105693839, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19165, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45649879, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 169731, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 135665, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7980.294117647059, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1122788081, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8276.180894114179, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 170199, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10011.70588235294, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 423733877, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2489.6378768382892, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5071713657, "stage_ordering_ns": 2864356776, "stage_eval_ns": 5831002621, "stage_threat_ns": 11612691458, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1459482, "root_tactical_annotations": 4657, "search_tactical_annotations": 1454825, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 456451, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2806602306, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1254532, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8343378874, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 168644, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6076545724, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 228217, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 351277903, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 456434, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59826702, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 289987, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 224704642, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 795888, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2041990698, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 373607, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 51605673, "child_limit_applications": 84259, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 84259, "child_cap_hits": 84259, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 84259, "child_moves_before_total": 7127105, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7127105, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 792062, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 792062, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.58568224165964, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.400325187813765, "tt_hits": 41564, "tt_cutoffs": 6961, "beta_cutoffs": 67098, "depth_sum": 87, "avg_depth": 5.117647058823529, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 87, "avg_effective_depth": 5.117647058823529, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2232.470588235294, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2703.0588235294117, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 17422, "avg_search_time_ms": 1088.875, "search_nodes": 141831, "safety_nodes": 1378, "corridor_nodes": 601, "corridor_branch_probes": 621, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 261, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 592, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 592, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 41, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 261, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 47, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 308, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 10253200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 143810, "avg_nodes": 8988.125, "eval_calls": 86074, "avg_eval_calls": 5379.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 86074, "pattern_eval_ns": 1887967, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.934231010525828, "pattern_frame_queries": 86074, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1887967, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.934231010525828, "pattern_frame_updates": 283466, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2870513319, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10126.481902591493, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 51843, "avg_candidate_generations": 3240.1875, "candidate_moves_total": 4120021, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.47111471172579, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1184, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 51827, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4118837, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 2242770, "avg_legality_checks": 140173.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2086, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2242770, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2086, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5176014, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 323500.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11151374421, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2154.4328166423043, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24816, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1551.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 91367723, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3681.8070196647323, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2358, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21574781, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6737, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 46957527, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15685, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22531735, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 36, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 303680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 130168, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8135.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1091912949, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8388.489866941183, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 172226, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10764.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 447049503, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2595.7143694912497, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5366019946, "stage_ordering_ns": 1680573309, "stage_eval_ns": 2872401286, "stage_threat_ns": 7319744439, "stage_proof_ns": 83021741, "tactical_annotations": 713356, "root_tactical_annotations": 2163, "search_tactical_annotations": 711193, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 284766, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1690190135, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 683778, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5355878789, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 104279, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3649566034, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 142375, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 210761127, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1284, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9334325, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 284750, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35836368, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 119758, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 307923667, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 426834, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1378259022, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 166764, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17743695, "child_limit_applications": 51827, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 51827, "child_cap_hits": 51827, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 51827, "child_moves_before_total": 4116751, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4116751, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 466026, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 466026, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.43255446003049, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.991954000810388, "tt_hits": 22255, "tt_cutoffs": 3834, "beta_cutoffs": 40678, "depth_sum": 95, "avg_depth": 5.9375, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 95, "avg_effective_depth": 5.9375, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3148.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3648.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1576, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 35556, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 128, 113, 99, 114, 115, 131, 130, 100, 83, 111, 68, 141, 53, 38, 67, 51, 81, 157, 172, 155, 169, 156, 126, 158, 154, 159 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 18741, "avg_search_time_ms": 1249.4, "search_nodes": 161567, "safety_nodes": 959, "corridor_nodes": 1598, "corridor_branch_probes": 1682, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 692, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1587, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1587, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 53, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 692, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 53, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 414, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 48059760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2007920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 164124, "avg_nodes": 10941.6, "eval_calls": 96529, "avg_eval_calls": 6435.266666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 96529, "pattern_eval_ns": 2144838, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.219623118441092, "pattern_frame_queries": 96529, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2144838, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.219623118441092, "pattern_frame_updates": 322964, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3778372865, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11699.05272723895, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 59900, "avg_candidate_generations": 3993.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 4599202, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.78133555926544, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1065, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 59885, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4598137, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1555316, "avg_legality_checks": 103687.73333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2021, "root_legality_checks": 1065, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "search_legality_checks": 1554251, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2014, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5012518, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 334167.86666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11356939375, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2265.715429849828, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30167, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2011.1333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 158377127, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5250.012497099479, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2265, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21282076, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11607, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 93829518, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15952, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41026955, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 343, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2238578, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 114138, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7609.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 995965574, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8725.977097899035, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 147579, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9838.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 406612853, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2755.2216304487765, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3901857586, "stage_ordering_ns": 1974121024, "stage_eval_ns": 3780517703, "stage_threat_ns": 8736595679, "stage_proof_ns": 262064826, "tactical_annotations": 775995, "root_tactical_annotations": 3190, "search_tactical_annotations": 772805, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 326259, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2031358753, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 741807, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6358309733, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 120914, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4567677634, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 163122, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 252288416, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3280, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20960957, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 326244, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42893199, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 118707, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 189280924, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 413732, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1375071541, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 243556, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30784621, "child_limit_applications": 59885, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 59885, "child_cap_hits": 59885, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 59885, "child_moves_before_total": 4596123, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4596123, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 551039, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 551039, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.74915254237288, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.201619771228188, "tt_hits": 31999, "tt_cutoffs": 5071, "beta_cutoffs": 47690, "depth_sum": 81, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 81, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2192.5333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2725.866666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 16800, "avg_search_time_ms": 1200.0, "search_nodes": 133019, "safety_nodes": 1021, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 134040, "avg_nodes": 9574.285714285714, "eval_calls": 80894, "avg_eval_calls": 5778.142857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80894, "pattern_eval_ns": 1798973, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.238645635028554, "pattern_frame_queries": 80894, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1798973, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.238645635028554, "pattern_frame_updates": 265870, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2782612819, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10466.06544175725, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 48219, "avg_candidate_generations": 3444.214285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 3786093, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.51869594972936, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 991, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 48205, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3785102, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 2107491, "avg_legality_checks": 150535.07142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2263, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2107491, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2263, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4800734, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 342909.5714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10778549961, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2245.187915222964, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23938, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1709.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 97656752, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4079.5702230762804, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2495, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23115793, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6782, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 50637146, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14621, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23511500, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 392313, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 119892, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8563.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1075937864, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8974.22566976946, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 159896, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11421.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 453267768, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2834.7661479961976, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5242105551, "stage_ordering_ns": 1627732799, "stage_eval_ns": 2784411792, "stage_threat_ns": 7052313779, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 635311, "root_tactical_annotations": 2121, "search_tactical_annotations": 633190, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 265884, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1633342664, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 574984, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5159668679, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 96522, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3535744344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 132935, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 205102344, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 265870, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34829928, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 104168, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 311307272, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 374284, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1312423600, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 156859, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19370164, "child_limit_applications": 48205, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 48205, "child_cap_hits": 48205, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 48205, "child_moves_before_total": 3782839, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3782839, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 435554, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 435554, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.47399647339488, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.035452753863707, "tt_hits": 21663, "tt_cutoffs": 3838, "beta_cutoffs": 37748, "depth_sum": 81, "avg_depth": 5.785714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 81, "avg_effective_depth": 5.785714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2499.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3070.4285714285716, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1577, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 45219, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 126, 127, 79, 143, 159, 142, 157, 141, 140, 109, 108, 155, 124, 156, 80, 81, 94, 66, 78, 169, 183, 51, 96, 36, 21, 76, 122, 136, 123, 125, 93, 63, 138 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 23731, "avg_search_time_ms": 1318.388888888889, "search_nodes": 230509, "safety_nodes": 751, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 231260, "avg_nodes": 12847.777777777777, "eval_calls": 137438, "avg_eval_calls": 7635.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 137438, "pattern_eval_ns": 3015829, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.94319620483418, "pattern_frame_queries": 137438, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3015829, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.94319620483418, "pattern_frame_updates": 460808, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4915330682, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10666.765077863232, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 86708, "avg_candidate_generations": 4817.111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 7336407, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.61049730128708, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1383, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 86690, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7335024, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 2048723, "avg_legality_checks": 113817.94444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 463, "root_legality_checks": 1383, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2047340, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 463, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6201037, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 344502.05555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13815696420, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2227.9654870628897, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28712, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1595.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 108677216, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3785.0799665645027, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 909, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5795285, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11210, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 69364646, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16593, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 33517285, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 107517, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5973.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 882056609, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8203.880400308788, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 134450, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7469.444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 338043659, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2514.270427668278, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4955381862, "stage_ordering_ns": 2905714182, "stage_eval_ns": 4918346511, "stage_threat_ns": 10835306531, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1431641, "root_tactical_annotations": 5610, "search_tactical_annotations": 1426031, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 460826, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2749776064, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1108395, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7620588366, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 173521, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5913515881, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 230404, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 347977381, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 460808, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59182138, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 358066, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 277351789, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 576793, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1429521574, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 496782, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 57782582, "child_limit_applications": 86690, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 86690, "child_cap_hits": 86690, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 86690, "child_moves_before_total": 7334561, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7334561, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 794425, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 794425, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.60677125389319, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.16397508363133, "tt_hits": 49945, "tt_cutoffs": 6279, "beta_cutoffs": 69325, "depth_sum": 102, "avg_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 102, "avg_effective_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3122.277777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3566.722222222222, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 21468, "avg_search_time_ms": 1192.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 161250, "safety_nodes": 942, "corridor_nodes": 969, "corridor_branch_probes": 1097, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 302, "corridor_neutral_exits": 27, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 950, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 950, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 89, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 70, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 27, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 302, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 89, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 88, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 691, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 562160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 16560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 163161, "avg_nodes": 9064.5, "eval_calls": 99636, "avg_eval_calls": 5535.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 99636, "pattern_eval_ns": 2239621, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.478030029306677, "pattern_frame_queries": 99636, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2239621, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.478030029306677, "pattern_frame_updates": 322290, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2890008186, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8967.10473796891, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 57885, "avg_candidate_generations": 3215.8333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 4994654, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.28580806772048, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1413, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 57867, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4993241, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 3565120, "avg_legality_checks": 198062.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 116, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3565120, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 116, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6599453, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 366636.27777777775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14222638106, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2155.123781622507, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18116, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1006.4444444444445, "renju_forbidden_ns": 36970678, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2040.7748951203357, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 142, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1254373, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3039, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25218647, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14935, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10497658, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 147181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8176.722222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1208955839, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8214.075451315048, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 187352, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10408.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 470535264, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2511.5038216832486, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8329280437, "stage_ordering_ns": 1983812858, "stage_eval_ns": 2892247807, "stage_threat_ns": 7965501475, "stage_proof_ns": 146115039, "tactical_annotations": 986489, "root_tactical_annotations": 3778, "search_tactical_annotations": 982711, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 324386, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1975180259, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 885326, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5650014924, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 116765, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3792684032, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 162184, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 248539972, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2078, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14665504, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 324368, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41795327, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 300698, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 538884989, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 402309, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1276259854, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 283482, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 35305489, "child_limit_applications": 57867, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 57867, "child_cap_hits": 57867, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 57867, "child_moves_before_total": 4993125, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4993125, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 516933, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 516933, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.28622530976205, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.933122505054694, "tt_hits": 31610, "tt_cutoffs": 3643, "beta_cutoffs": 46927, "depth_sum": 104, "avg_depth": 5.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 104, "avg_effective_depth": 5.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4824.555555555556, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5269.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1578, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 55835, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 126, 127, 143, 142, 157, 109, 108, 95, 129, 171, 158, 173, 159, 160, 174, 144, 154, 81, 123, 96, 97, 155, 138, 51, 66, 79, 63, 125, 140, 65, 80, 93, 37, 107 ], "move_count": 41, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 29078, "avg_search_time_ms": 1530.421052631579, "search_nodes": 255773, "safety_nodes": 1530, "corridor_nodes": 6329, "corridor_branch_probes": 6757, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3080, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 6300, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6300, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 106, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 77, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3080, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 106, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 773, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 40300000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006640, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 263632, "avg_nodes": 13875.368421052632, "eval_calls": 154454, "avg_eval_calls": 8129.1578947368425, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 154454, "pattern_eval_ns": 3325562, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.53108368834734, "pattern_frame_queries": 154454, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3325562, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.53108368834734, "pattern_frame_updates": 511320, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6204616205, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12134.507167722757, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 92358, "avg_candidate_generations": 4860.9473684210525, "candidate_moves_total": 7781435, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.25296130275666, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1438, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 92339, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7779997, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 2356848, "avg_legality_checks": 124044.63157894737, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2196, "root_legality_checks": 1438, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 2355410, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2195, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8451646, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 444823.4736842105, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17459316952, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2065.788954246309, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58951, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3102.684210526316, "renju_forbidden_ns": 296128216, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5023.294193482723, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2910, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23747364, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23723, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 175347458, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30029, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 87045364, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2289, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9988030, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 215375, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11335.526315789473, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1942853813, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9020.795417295414, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 289330, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15227.894736842105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 885713632, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3061.257498358276, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5445714149, "stage_ordering_ns": 2960846931, "stage_eval_ns": 6207941767, "stage_threat_ns": 13639218905, "stage_proof_ns": 701782568, "tactical_annotations": 1774667, "root_tactical_annotations": 4218, "search_tactical_annotations": 1770449, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 524151, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3066845599, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1794901, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9964287322, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 188066, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6282632354, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 262066, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 385024244, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12812, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 96900714, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 524132, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65074764, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 488594, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 417951886, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 807797, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2516612793, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 478276, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 61086262, "child_limit_applications": 92339, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 92339, "child_cap_hits": 92339, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 92339, "child_moves_before_total": 7777802, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7777802, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 930169, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 930169, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.23095333499388, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.073414266994444, "tt_hits": 50000, "tt_cutoffs": 8870, "beta_cutoffs": 75176, "depth_sum": 110, "avg_depth": 5.7894736842105265, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 110, "avg_effective_depth": 5.7894736842105265, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.21052631578947367, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2631578947368421, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.21052631578947367, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1749.8947368421052, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2170.9473684210525, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 26740, "avg_search_time_ms": 1485.5555555555557, "search_nodes": 197172, "safety_nodes": 1064, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 198236, "avg_nodes": 11013.111111111111, "eval_calls": 122778, "avg_eval_calls": 6821.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 122778, "pattern_eval_ns": 2712660, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.094023359233738, "pattern_frame_queries": 122778, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2712660, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.094023359233738, "pattern_frame_updates": 394122, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4402597157, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11170.645528541923, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 68648, "avg_candidate_generations": 3813.777777777778, "candidate_moves_total": 5903945, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.00316105349027, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1364, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 68630, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5902581, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 3746792, "avg_legality_checks": 208155.11111111112, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1446, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3746792, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1446, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8557184, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 475399.1111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17523880879, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2047.8560328958686, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45050, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2502.777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 153387458, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3404.8270366259712, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1795, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14207052, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12314, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 91620360, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30929, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 47441886, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 118160, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 314523, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17473.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2989095451, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9503.583047980594, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 428969, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23831.61111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1427792764, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3328.428776904625, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8708101465, "stage_ordering_ns": 2299525959, "stage_eval_ns": 4405309817, "stage_threat_ns": 11180733614, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1443119, "root_tactical_annotations": 3948, "search_tactical_annotations": 1439171, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 394140, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2320769779, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1236095, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8469087891, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 137407, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4476002293, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 197061, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 295978647, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 394122, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50213479, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 429791, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1325956963, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 668885, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2666952012, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 344443, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 44683818, "child_limit_applications": 68630, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 68630, "child_cap_hits": 68630, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 68630, "child_moves_before_total": 5901135, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5901135, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 757469, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 757469, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.98477342270144, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.036995483024917, "tt_hits": 33378, "tt_cutoffs": 5659, "beta_cutoffs": 55740, "depth_sum": 105, "avg_depth": 5.833333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 105, "avg_effective_depth": 5.833333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1984.0555555555557, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2428.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1579, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 36465, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 96, 128, 95, 98, 94, 93, 82, 127, 125, 142, 100, 156, 170, 130, 129, 158, 174, 113, 143, 157, 67, 52, 155, 172, 187, 144, 186, 116 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 15583, "avg_search_time_ms": 1113.0714285714287, "search_nodes": 139475, "safety_nodes": 1219, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 140694, "avg_nodes": 10049.57142857143, "eval_calls": 83451, "avg_eval_calls": 5960.785714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83451, "pattern_eval_ns": 1686155, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.205330073935603, "pattern_frame_queries": 83451, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1686155, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.205330073935603, "pattern_frame_updates": 278784, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3532359519, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12670.59630036157, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 50142, "avg_candidate_generations": 3581.5714285714284, "candidate_moves_total": 3975583, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.28648637868453, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1044, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 50128, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3974539, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1481820, "avg_legality_checks": 105844.28571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12985, "root_legality_checks": 1044, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 1480776, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12977, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4791727, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 342266.21428571426, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9258232492, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1932.1285398771674, "renju_forbidden_checks": 110564, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7897.428571428572, "renju_forbidden_ns": 674212101, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6097.935141637423, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 14472, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 146793352, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 35908, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 333027201, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 60100, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 193843264, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 84, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 548284, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 153143, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10938.785714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1473046213, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9618.762940519646, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 210063, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15004.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 717484379, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3415.5676106691803, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3442360616, "stage_ordering_ns": 1439368402, "stage_eval_ns": 3534045674, "stage_threat_ns": 7093580243, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 853156, "root_tactical_annotations": 1468, "search_tactical_annotations": 851688, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 278798, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1467086653, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 714498, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5378139257, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 100367, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3274217009, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 139392, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184878822, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 278784, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31675572, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 118955, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 196864699, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 495167, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1906311866, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 239034, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 31799939, "child_limit_applications": 50128, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 50128, "child_cap_hits": 50128, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 50128, "child_moves_before_total": 3961562, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3961562, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 587753, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 587753, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.0289259495691, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.725043887647622, "tt_hits": 26185, "tt_cutoffs": 5814, "beta_cutoffs": 41113, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 5.857142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 5.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3195.6428571428573, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3767.0714285714284, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 20867, "avg_search_time_ms": 1490.5, "search_nodes": 133258, "safety_nodes": 850, "corridor_nodes": 1315, "corridor_branch_probes": 1512, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 610, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1305, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1305, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 22, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 12, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 610, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 22, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 21, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 144, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 17816560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1984800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 135423, "avg_nodes": 9673.07142857143, "eval_calls": 82373, "avg_eval_calls": 5883.785714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82373, "pattern_eval_ns": 1724836, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.93933691865053, "pattern_frame_queries": 82373, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1724836, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.93933691865053, "pattern_frame_updates": 266360, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3604737587, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13533.32927992191, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46311, "avg_candidate_generations": 3307.9285714285716, "candidate_moves_total": 4034091, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.10869987691909, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1079, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 46297, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4033012, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 2831937, "avg_legality_checks": 202281.2142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 46219, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2831937, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 46219, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6472269, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 462304.9285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12992426070, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2007.3989616315391, "renju_forbidden_checks": 215598, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 15399.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 1436723893, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6663.901766250151, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 49370, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 498279580, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 51141, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 531541934, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 114946, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 405862511, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 141, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1039868, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 250774, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17912.428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2577754495, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10279.19359662485, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 334743, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23910.214285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1292073876, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3859.8981188553607, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6964090485, "stage_ordering_ns": 1564057348, "stage_eval_ns": 3606462423, "stage_threat_ns": 8600627522, "stage_proof_ns": 23575982, "tactical_annotations": 999349, "root_tactical_annotations": 3310, "search_tactical_annotations": 996039, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 269028, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1596050196, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 895727, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6721538407, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 93319, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3380809081, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134507, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 198331849, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2654, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14899467, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 269014, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33383704, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 246660, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1023102346, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 484435, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2260014169, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 268254, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 36423899, "child_limit_applications": 46297, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46297, "child_cap_hits": 46297, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46297, "child_moves_before_total": 3986793, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3986793, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 539965, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 539965, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.11341987601789, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.663066721385835, "tt_hits": 24172, "tt_cutoffs": 4516, "beta_cutoffs": 38628, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.42857142857142855, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.42857142857142855, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1708.642857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2223.785714285714, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1580, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15848, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 96, 128, 95, 98, 94, 93, 127, 142, 82, 67, 100, 143, 113, 141, 140, 156, 170, 171, 111, 186 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8935, "avg_search_time_ms": 893.5, "search_nodes": 86703, "safety_nodes": 717, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87420, "avg_nodes": 8742.0, "eval_calls": 52686, "avg_eval_calls": 5268.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 52686, "pattern_eval_ns": 1095005, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.783604752685722, "pattern_frame_queries": 52686, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1095005, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.783604752685722, "pattern_frame_updates": 173302, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2132057382, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12302.554973399037, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31113, "avg_candidate_generations": 3111.3, "candidate_moves_total": 2289274, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.5793398257963, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 648, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 31103, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2288626, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 641263, "avg_legality_checks": 64126.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 573, "root_legality_checks": 648, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 640615, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 572, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2397562, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 239756.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5280223606, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2202.3303697672886, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16645, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1664.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 117469211, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7057.327185340943, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 613, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5996448, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8945, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 81813394, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7082, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29607539, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 51830, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46540, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4654.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 442046605, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9498.208100558659, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65817, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6581.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 206818810, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3142.331160642387, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1573308653, "stage_ordering_ns": 945686718, "stage_eval_ns": 2133152387, "stage_threat_ns": 4246925158, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 414667, "root_tactical_annotations": 1389, "search_tactical_annotations": 413278, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 173312, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1010472942, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 364405, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3073110238, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 62278, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2292178124, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86651, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125166433, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 173302, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21388369, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 57050, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 54266839, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 245069, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 726275743, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 112548, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16787176, "child_limit_applications": 31103, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31103, "child_cap_hits": 31103, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31103, "child_moves_before_total": 2288054, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2288054, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 332701, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 332701, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.56377198340996, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.696749509693598, "tt_hits": 13991, "tt_cutoffs": 2865, "beta_cutoffs": 24793, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.9, "max_depth": 6, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.9, "max_effective_depth": 6, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2719.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3519.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6904, "avg_search_time_ms": 690.4, "search_nodes": 61328, "safety_nodes": 419, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 61747, "avg_nodes": 6174.7, "eval_calls": 42886, "avg_eval_calls": 4288.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 42886, "pattern_eval_ns": 890012, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.752972998181225, "pattern_frame_queries": 42886, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 890012, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.752972998181225, "pattern_frame_updates": 122566, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1299096498, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10599.158804236085, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17356, "avg_candidate_generations": 1735.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1338736, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.13390182069601, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 670, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 17346, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1338066, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 803132, "avg_legality_checks": 80313.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 515, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 803132, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 515, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2119108, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 211910.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4361774108, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2058.306659216991, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10041, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1004.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43772695, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4359.395976496365, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 519, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5318632, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2763, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27196810, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6754, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11200782, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 56471, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76168, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7616.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 758517172, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9958.47563281168, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110685, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11068.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 378171628, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3416.6474951438768, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1919369669, "stage_ordering_ns": 559595567, "stage_eval_ns": 1299986510, "stage_threat_ns": 3082922692, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 299887, "root_tactical_annotations": 1523, "search_tactical_annotations": 298364, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 122576, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 731666915, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 265114, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2237266073, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34756, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1231452797, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 89303036, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 122566, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15359583, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 59546, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 232965606, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 170805, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 772754350, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 69536, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9327085, "child_limit_applications": 17346, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17346, "child_cap_hits": 17346, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17346, "child_moves_before_total": 1337551, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1337551, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 189975, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 189975, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.11005419116799, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.952092701487375, "tt_hits": 7064, "tt_cutoffs": 1052, "beta_cutoffs": 12831, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 4.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 4.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4680.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5480.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1581, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 40875, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 82, 124, 114, 98, 84, 123, 125, 140, 154, 156, 172, 108, 92, 138, 93, 141, 171, 137, 139, 153, 168, 169, 95, 94, 80, 65, 68, 54, 83, 81, 86, 85, 100, 128, 116, 52, 132 ], "move_count": 44, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 27762, "avg_search_time_ms": 1388.1, "search_nodes": 277447, "safety_nodes": 783, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 278230, "avg_nodes": 13911.5, "eval_calls": 165214, "avg_eval_calls": 8260.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 165214, "pattern_eval_ns": 3316208, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.072197271417675, "pattern_frame_queries": 165214, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3316208, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.072197271417675, "pattern_frame_updates": 554644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6063043282, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10931.414171973374, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 104182, "avg_candidate_generations": 5209.1, "candidate_moves_total": 9374926, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.98604365437407, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1614, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 104162, "search_candidate_moves_total": 9373312, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 2886888, "avg_legality_checks": 144344.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5954, "root_legality_checks": 1614, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 2885274, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5952, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9228020, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 461401.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16294645910, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1765.779214826149, "renju_forbidden_checks": 130375, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6518.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 493751229, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3787.1618715244485, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6998, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 51080575, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 43205, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 260080443, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 80162, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 182579551, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 10660, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 289082, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14454.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2215538269, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7664.047809963955, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 404002, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20200.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 993580371, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2459.3451789842625, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5830379533, "stage_ordering_ns": 2942641943, "stage_eval_ns": 6066359490, "stage_threat_ns": 12804060433, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2401335, "root_tactical_annotations": 6142, "search_tactical_annotations": 2395193, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 554664, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2811728631, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1900108, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9488779904, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 208489, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5999100828, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 277322, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 362498990, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 554644, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61687866, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 703562, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 563735159, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 988044, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2925838247, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 709729, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 79365042, "child_limit_applications": 104162, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 104162, "child_cap_hits": 104162, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 104162, "child_moves_before_total": 9367360, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 9367360, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 1281721, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1281721, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.93068489468328, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.305072867264453, "tt_hits": 59562, "tt_cutoffs": 7948, "beta_cutoffs": 87870, "depth_sum": 122, "avg_depth": 6.1, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 122, "avg_effective_depth": 6.1, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.15, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.15, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3697.85, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4097.85, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 13092, "avg_search_time_ms": 654.6, "search_nodes": 132641, "safety_nodes": 2498, "corridor_nodes": 3278, "corridor_branch_probes": 3731, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 1577, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 3252, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3252, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 60, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1577, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 60, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 254, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 33916320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2007440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 138417, "avg_nodes": 6920.85, "eval_calls": 82148, "avg_eval_calls": 4107.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82148, "pattern_eval_ns": 1606412, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.555095680966062, "pattern_frame_queries": 82148, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1606412, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.555095680966062, "pattern_frame_updates": 265038, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2235907233, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8436.17606909198, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 45773, "avg_candidate_generations": 2288.65, "candidate_moves_total": 3809874, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.2340899657003, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1633, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 45753, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3808241, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 2203135, "avg_legality_checks": 110156.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2388, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2203135, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2388, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5260107, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 263005.35, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8139848123, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1547.4681642407654, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56061, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2803.05, "renju_forbidden_ns": 149849824, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2672.9780774513474, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3051, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18406682, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13207, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73774041, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 39788, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 57652661, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 16440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 172789, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8639.45, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1112774645, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6440.07804316247, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 235021, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11751.05, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 487903171, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2075.9981916509587, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3913425593, "stage_ordering_ns": 1117138507, "stage_eval_ns": 2237513645, "stage_threat_ns": 5675257796, "stage_proof_ns": 55078599, "tactical_annotations": 882231, "root_tactical_annotations": 1146, "search_tactical_annotations": 881085, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 271682, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1283687283, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 903272, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4134379702, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 93312, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2393162153, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 135831, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 163808837, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6624, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 42998711, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 271662, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27104187, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 177436, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 386889594, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 470837, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1248335069, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 233958, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23279076, "child_limit_applications": 45753, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 45753, "child_cap_hits": 45753, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 45753, "child_moves_before_total": 3805853, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3805853, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 500892, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 500892, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.18258911983914, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.947741131729067, "tt_hits": 23482, "tt_cutoffs": 4619, "beta_cutoffs": 36853, "depth_sum": 121, "avg_depth": 6.05, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 121, "avg_effective_depth": 6.05, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5907.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6307.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 312, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1582, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 119306, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 82, 124, 114, 98, 84, 123, 125, 140, 154, 156, 172, 108, 92, 138, 93, 141, 171, 95, 68, 54, 81, 83, 127, 139, 137, 107, 91, 94, 157, 187, 143, 129, 100, 52, 72, 86, 185, 199, 153, 169, 173, 174, 158, 188, 144, 130, 66, 51, 50, 55, 53, 67, 186, 200, 34, 18, 35, 132, 145, 146, 160, 131, 133, 128 ], "move_count": 71, "black_stats": { "move_count": 36, "search_move_count": 34, "total_time_ms": 59582, "avg_search_time_ms": 1752.4117647058824, "search_nodes": 567722, "safety_nodes": 2567, "corridor_nodes": 10173, "corridor_branch_probes": 11076, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4639, "corridor_neutral_exits": 106, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 10107, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 10107, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 23, "corridor_proof_completed": 23, "corridor_proof_checks": 208, "corridor_proof_active": 66, "corridor_proof_quiet": 142, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 106, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4639, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 208, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 208, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1459, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 62269480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 580462, "avg_nodes": 17072.41176470588, "eval_calls": 349081, "avg_eval_calls": 10267.088235294117, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 349081, "pattern_eval_ns": 7270027, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.826189337145248, "pattern_frame_queries": 349081, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7270027, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.826189337145248, "pattern_frame_updates": 1135004, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 12515129820, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11026.507236978901, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 201270, "avg_candidate_generations": 5919.705882352941, "candidate_moves_total": 21155209, "avg_candidate_moves": 105.10860535598947, "candidate_moves_max": 142, "root_candidate_generations": 34, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3270, "root_candidate_moves_max": 129, "search_candidate_generations": 201236, "search_candidate_moves_total": 21151939, "search_candidate_moves_max": 142, "legality_checks": 5586837, "avg_legality_checks": 164318.73529411765, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8524, "root_legality_checks": 3270, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 5583567, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8518, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18456811, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 542847.3823529412, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 34342220912, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1860.680098636758, "renju_forbidden_checks": 196794, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5788.058823529412, "renju_forbidden_ns": 695416591, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3533.7286248564487, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10336, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 74636985, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 71127, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 369408103, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 113924, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 243211634, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1407, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8159869, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 586325, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17244.852941176472, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 4890997639, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8341.785936127575, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 836659, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 24607.617647058825, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2352098097, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2811.2983867979665, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11740419102, "stage_ordering_ns": 6445894782, "stage_eval_ns": 12522399847, "stage_threat_ns": 27564713813, "stage_proof_ns": 1075446146, "tactical_annotations": 5881154, "root_tactical_annotations": 10442, "search_tactical_annotations": 5870712, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1155668, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6336194961, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 5412509, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 19926223218, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 408325, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11091686459, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 577817, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 839784866, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 20630, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 150639887, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1155634, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 137145868, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 2240554, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 2004066130, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 2265301, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 5790405258, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 1375299, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 174725013, "child_limit_applications": 201236, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 201236, "child_cap_hits": 201236, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 201236, "child_moves_before_total": 21143421, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 21143421, "child_moves_before_max": 142, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 142, "child_moves_after_total": 2591563, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 2591563, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 105.06778608201316, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.878227553718023, "tt_hits": 108491, "tt_cutoffs": 17191, "beta_cutoffs": 171288, "depth_sum": 213, "avg_depth": 6.264705882352941, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 213, "avg_effective_depth": 6.264705882352941, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 23 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 7, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.20588235294117646, "pooled_budget_moves": 34, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 7, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.20588235294117646, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3032.970588235294, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3268.264705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 35, "search_move_count": 33, "total_time_ms": 59695, "avg_search_time_ms": 1808.939393939394, "search_nodes": 430135, "safety_nodes": 2729, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 432864, "avg_nodes": 13117.09090909091, "eval_calls": 264284, "avg_eval_calls": 8008.606060606061, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 264284, "pattern_eval_ns": 5642592, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.350486597750905, "pattern_frame_queries": 264284, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5642592, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.350486597750905, "pattern_frame_updates": 859850, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8473425816, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9854.539531313601, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 151971, "avg_candidate_generations": 4605.181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 15842273, "avg_candidate_moves": 104.2453691822782, "candidate_moves_max": 141, "root_candidate_generations": 33, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3169, "root_candidate_moves_max": 129, "search_candidate_generations": 151938, "search_candidate_moves_total": 15839104, "search_candidate_moves_max": 141, "legality_checks": 10332339, "avg_legality_checks": 313101.1818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 34999, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10332339, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 34999, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 21075698, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 638657.5151515151, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 38654093188, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1834.0599294979459, "renju_forbidden_checks": 262744, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7961.939393939394, "renju_forbidden_ns": 910144728, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3463.9981426788054, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 36714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 317082462, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 48346, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 300213917, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 177635, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 292455608, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 49, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 392741, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 891885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 27026.81818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 7572936741, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8490.934078945156, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1239716, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 37567.15151515151, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3624853736, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2923.938818245469, "stage_move_gen_ns": 21830593619, "stage_ordering_ns": 5107450750, "stage_eval_ns": 8479068408, "stage_threat_ns": 23906708680, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 4512538, "root_tactical_annotations": 9711, "search_tactical_annotations": 4502827, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 859883, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4697286955, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3847470, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 18331052700, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 304152, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8076059762, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 429925, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 644989046, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 859850, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 104763498, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1689440, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 4243798816, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1853852, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 6010739172, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 969246, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 128616481, "child_limit_applications": 151938, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 151938, "child_cap_hits": 151938, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 151938, "child_moves_before_total": 15804105, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 15804105, "child_moves_before_max": 141, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 141, "child_moves_after_total": 1927006, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1927006, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 104.01680290644869, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.68284431807711, "tt_hits": 78236, "tt_cutoffs": 13715, "beta_cutoffs": 129832, "depth_sum": 194, "avg_depth": 5.878787878787879, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 194, "avg_effective_depth": 5.878787878787879, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 9 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 16, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.48484848484848486, "pooled_budget_moves": 33, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.24242424242424243, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 16, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.48484848484848486, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2153.939393939394, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2279.757575757576, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1583, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25498, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 98, 110, 124, 142, 68, 126, 94, 128, 100, 141, 156, 158, 174, 140, 99, 101, 139, 143, 144, 173, 113, 188 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10540, "avg_search_time_ms": 878.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 93764, "safety_nodes": 1139, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 94903, "avg_nodes": 7908.583333333333, "eval_calls": 58271, "avg_eval_calls": 4855.916666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 58271, "pattern_eval_ns": 1285924, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.067992655008496, "pattern_frame_queries": 58271, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1285924, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.067992655008496, "pattern_frame_updates": 187394, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2192904957, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11702.108696116204, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32830, "avg_candidate_generations": 2735.8333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2555906, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.85275662503807, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 864, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 32818, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2555042, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 926280, "avg_legality_checks": 77190.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2913, "root_legality_checks": 864, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 925416, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2912, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2865871, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 238822.58333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6346748854, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2214.596837750199, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21299, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1774.9166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 142006910, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6667.30409878398, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2923, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30830613, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9046, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 81131281, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9325, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29985996, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 59020, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76754, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6396.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 727155780, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9473.848659353258, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 105643, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8803.583333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 339174162, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3210.5692000416498, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2316957368, "stage_ordering_ns": 1098915477, "stage_eval_ns": 2194190881, "stage_threat_ns": 4884912099, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 431548, "root_tactical_annotations": 1085, "search_tactical_annotations": 430463, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 187406, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1135598887, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 382278, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3568158015, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 65727, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2481544948, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 93697, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 141917103, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 187394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23957620, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 63365, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 117370010, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 253177, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 968683106, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 115006, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15280474, "child_limit_applications": 32818, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32818, "child_cap_hits": 32818, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32818, "child_moves_before_total": 2552130, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2552130, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 306494, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 306494, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.76616490950089, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.339204095313548, "tt_hits": 15155, "tt_cutoffs": 2609, "beta_cutoffs": 25505, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3429.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4095.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 14947, "avg_search_time_ms": 1245.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 134055, "safety_nodes": 617, "corridor_nodes": 543, "corridor_branch_probes": 591, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 192, "corridor_neutral_exits": 19, "corridor_terminal_exits": 7, "corridor_plies_followed": 529, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 529, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 192, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 416, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 51884160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 135215, "avg_nodes": 11267.916666666666, "eval_calls": 87931, "avg_eval_calls": 7327.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87931, "pattern_eval_ns": 1870566, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.273111871808577, "pattern_frame_queries": 87931, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1870566, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.273111871808577, "pattern_frame_updates": 267978, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2474164889, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9232.716450604154, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42914, "avg_candidate_generations": 3576.1666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 3553008, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.79368038402386, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 890, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 42902, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3552118, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 2292211, "avg_legality_checks": 191017.58333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5231, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2292211, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5231, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5240689, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 436724.0833333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9585043769, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1828.966338013952, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24057, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2004.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 155264222, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6454.014299372324, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5235, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52400142, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8257, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71154269, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10523, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31178969, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 530842, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 158617, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13218.083333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1310675132, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8263.144127048172, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 217233, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18102.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 645035700, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2969.326483545318, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4790836876, "stage_ordering_ns": 1282507471, "stage_eval_ns": 2476035455, "stage_threat_ns": 6215013256, "stage_proof_ns": 92181114, "tactical_annotations": 740897, "root_tactical_annotations": 3217, "search_tactical_annotations": 737680, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 269156, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1453413195, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 612334, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4510584727, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 86412, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2781253023, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134572, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 182623413, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1166, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6568438, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 269144, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31114175, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 189809, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 597581329, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 301762, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1106153969, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 249326, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30709308, "child_limit_applications": 42902, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42902, "child_cap_hits": 42902, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42902, "child_moves_before_total": 3546887, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3546887, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 456398, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 456398, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.67416437462123, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.63815206750268, "tt_hits": 24838, "tt_cutoffs": 3156, "beta_cutoffs": 32935, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2556.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3222.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1179, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1584, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23318, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 98, 110, 124, 142, 100, 126, 94, 141, 156, 81, 111, 83, 80, 84, 85, 99, 69, 144, 129, 143, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9315, "avg_search_time_ms": 776.25, "search_nodes": 124409, "safety_nodes": 955, "corridor_nodes": 340, "corridor_branch_probes": 421, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 114, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 332, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 332, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 34, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 26, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 114, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 34, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 182, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 18056400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2029440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 125704, "avg_nodes": 10475.333333333334, "eval_calls": 76387, "avg_eval_calls": 6365.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 76387, "pattern_eval_ns": 1484929, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.439551232539568, "pattern_frame_queries": 76387, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1484929, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.439551232539568, "pattern_frame_updates": 248682, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1909637058, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7679.032089174126, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44097, "avg_candidate_generations": 3674.75, "candidate_moves_total": 3448328, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.19869832414903, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 798, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 44085, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3447530, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1486507, "avg_legality_checks": 123875.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8871, "root_legality_checks": 798, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 9, "search_legality_checks": 1485709, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8862, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4313963, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 359496.9166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5551791317, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1286.9353114526018, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42237, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3519.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 168385360, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3986.678978147122, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9155, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53757594, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14965, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 79951308, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 18053, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 34297294, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 64, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 379164, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 127548, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10629.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 733597192, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5751.5381817041425, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 179203, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14933.583333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 350447217, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1955.5878919437732, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2216766914, "stage_ordering_ns": 883140905, "stage_eval_ns": 1911121987, "stage_threat_ns": 4162811300, "stage_proof_ns": 59462977, "tactical_annotations": 623702, "root_tactical_annotations": 1156, "search_tactical_annotations": 622546, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 249426, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 923457368, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 557578, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3066738366, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 88537, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1974078678, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124707, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125546714, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 732, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2656932, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 249414, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20903687, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 79035, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 86968682, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 366824, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 973140265, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 177843, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23508233, "child_limit_applications": 44085, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44085, "child_cap_hits": 44085, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44085, "child_moves_before_total": 3438668, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3438668, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 419387, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 419387, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.00086197119201, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.513145060678236, "tt_hits": 21356, "tt_cutoffs": 3869, "beta_cutoffs": 34559, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 5.583333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 5.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4189.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4856.416666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1017, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 13992, "avg_search_time_ms": 1166.0, "search_nodes": 178804, "safety_nodes": 165, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 178969, "avg_nodes": 14914.083333333334, "eval_calls": 117394, "avg_eval_calls": 9782.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 117394, "pattern_eval_ns": 2280955, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.429911239075253, "pattern_frame_queries": 117394, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2280955, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.429911239075253, "pattern_frame_updates": 357480, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2457816765, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6875.396567640148, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 57358, "avg_candidate_generations": 4779.833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4637794, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.85696851354649, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 817, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 57346, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4636977, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 3130919, "avg_legality_checks": 260909.91666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 25082, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3130919, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 25082, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6905894, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 575491.1666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8710158758, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1261.2644732166466, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60781, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5065.083333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 287600409, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4731.748556292262, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25086, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 146518572, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16160, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 97384148, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19475, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43268217, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 429472, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 193536, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16128.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1170700883, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6049.008365368717, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 275791, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22982.583333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 602138981, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2183.316282982403, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4627286188, "stage_ordering_ns": 1165505761, "stage_eval_ns": 2460097720, "stage_threat_ns": 5612429789, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 974800, "root_tactical_annotations": 3822, "search_tactical_annotations": 970978, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 357492, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1334359811, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 742137, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4021224483, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 114779, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2477841486, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 178740, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 181469011, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 357480, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30531491, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 234318, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 616024301, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 393029, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 927322566, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 347453, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 44844993, "child_limit_applications": 57346, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 57346, "child_cap_hits": 57346, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 57346, "child_moves_before_total": 4611895, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4611895, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 579989, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 579989, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.42226136086214, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.113852753461444, "tt_hits": 33555, "tt_cutoffs": 4000, "beta_cutoffs": 44785, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3864.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4530.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1816, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1585, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 50008, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 127, 142, 126, 114, 156, 82, 98, 84, 171, 141, 140, 154, 124, 108, 172, 188, 170, 173, 143, 100, 86, 129, 99, 68, 125, 123, 185, 155, 157, 199, 169, 168, 116, 109, 107, 153, 138, 151, 152, 137, 95, 165 ], "move_count": 46, "black_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 22097, "avg_search_time_ms": 1052.2380952380952, "search_nodes": 238863, "safety_nodes": 1843, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 240706, "avg_nodes": 11462.190476190477, "eval_calls": 143666, "avg_eval_calls": 6841.238095238095, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 143666, "pattern_eval_ns": 2917636, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.308465468517255, "pattern_frame_queries": 143666, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2917636, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.308465468517255, "pattern_frame_updates": 477462, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4793580047, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10039.710064884744, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 88184, "avg_candidate_generations": 4199.238095238095, "candidate_moves_total": 7983462, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.53186519096435, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1757, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 88163, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7981705, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 2589087, "avg_legality_checks": 123289.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7702, "root_legality_checks": 1757, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 2587330, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7691, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7930280, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 377632.38095238095, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12958785843, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1634.0893187882396, "renju_forbidden_checks": 98314, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4681.619047619048, "renju_forbidden_ns": 366970912, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3732.6414549301217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8065, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 66056714, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 35668, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 189707593, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 54521, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 110504313, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 702292, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 232619, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11077.095238095239, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1665169981, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7158.357576122329, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 324339, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15444.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 762676299, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2351.478850832, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4851588711, "stage_ordering_ns": 2396263125, "stage_eval_ns": 4796497683, "stage_threat_ns": 9915780273, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1880722, "root_tactical_annotations": 4602, "search_tactical_annotations": 1876120, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 477483, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2197539566, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1500537, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7306769308, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 176500, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4647327269, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 238731, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 294689008, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 477462, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49443213, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 499956, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 470797979, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 824064, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2187667714, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 556702, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 67339178, "child_limit_applications": 88163, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 88163, "child_cap_hits": 88163, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 88163, "child_moves_before_total": 7974014, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7974014, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 987984, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 987984, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.44626430588795, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.206333722763517, "tt_hits": 49470, "tt_cutoffs": 6902, "beta_cutoffs": 73097, "depth_sum": 132, "avg_depth": 6.285714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 132, "avg_effective_depth": 6.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09523809523809523, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5907.0952380952385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6288.047619047619, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1726, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 27890, "avg_search_time_ms": 1328.095238095238, "search_nodes": 206565, "safety_nodes": 1312, "corridor_nodes": 3871, "corridor_branch_probes": 4440, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 1945, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 3845, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3845, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 57, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1945, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 57, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 57, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 326, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 52028000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2011760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 211748, "avg_nodes": 10083.238095238095, "eval_calls": 123561, "avg_eval_calls": 5883.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 123561, "pattern_eval_ns": 2594832, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.00041275159638, "pattern_frame_queries": 123561, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2594832, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.00041275159638, "pattern_frame_updates": 412874, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3789695538, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9178.81856934561, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 76701, "avg_candidate_generations": 3652.4285714285716, "candidate_moves_total": 7171541, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.49996740590083, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1776, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 76680, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7169765, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 5160954, "avg_legality_checks": 245759.7142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 25684, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5160954, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 25684, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10639104, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 506624.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18129199323, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1704.0156128749188, "renju_forbidden_checks": 134376, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6398.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 670240175, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4987.796741977734, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25808, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 268870775, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27535, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 226052054, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 80965, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 174463403, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 68, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 853943, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 401443, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 19116.333333333332, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3212939246, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8003.47557685649, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 573865, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27326.904761904763, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1564444832, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2726.154813414305, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10364407142, "stage_ordering_ns": 2283738134, "stage_eval_ns": 3792290370, "stage_threat_ns": 11225133208, "stage_proof_ns": 42659574, "tactical_annotations": 1871229, "root_tactical_annotations": 4411, "search_tactical_annotations": 1866818, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 420699, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2131425513, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1722200, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8648715206, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 155373, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4273250715, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 210339, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 282094978, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7804, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 49619471, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 420678, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46423828, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 613135, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1380789012, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 771132, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2869598080, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 486962, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 66854212, "child_limit_applications": 76680, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 76680, "child_cap_hits": 76680, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 76680, "child_moves_before_total": 7144081, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7144081, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 850200, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 850200, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.16746218049035, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.087636932707355, "tt_hits": 40510, "tt_cutoffs": 6199, "beta_cutoffs": 64251, "depth_sum": 123, "avg_depth": 5.857142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 123, "avg_effective_depth": 5.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23809523809523808, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23809523809523808, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4987.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5368.0952380952385, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 847, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1586, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 42935, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 127, 142, 126, 114, 156, 82, 98, 84, 171, 141, 140, 154, 124, 108, 172, 188, 170, 173, 125, 123, 185, 155, 169, 168, 153, 143, 158, 144, 145, 99, 129, 54, 69, 100, 86, 68, 96, 52, 36, 116 ], "move_count": 44, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 28149, "avg_search_time_ms": 1407.45, "search_nodes": 241689, "safety_nodes": 774, "corridor_nodes": 2595, "corridor_branch_probes": 2868, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 1161, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 2570, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2570, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 120, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 95, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1161, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 120, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 120, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 966, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 29970360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2025680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 245058, "avg_nodes": 12252.9, "eval_calls": 144168, "avg_eval_calls": 7208.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 144168, "pattern_eval_ns": 3047041, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.135349037234338, "pattern_frame_queries": 144168, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3047041, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.135349037234338, "pattern_frame_updates": 483128, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6091732674, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12608.941468927489, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 90484, "avg_candidate_generations": 4524.2, "candidate_moves_total": 8053925, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.00938287432032, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1606, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 90464, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8052319, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 2361192, "avg_legality_checks": 118059.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4286, "root_legality_checks": 1606, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 2359586, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4283, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8067546, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 403377.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16753999427, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2076.7156985531906, "renju_forbidden_checks": 102447, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5122.35, "renju_forbidden_ns": 437901708, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4274.421974289145, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5017, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 33633231, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34859, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 242218656, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 62295, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 160573204, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 276, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1476617, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 218973, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10948.65, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1873739526, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8556.943212176844, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 301372, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15068.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 834407243, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2768.695310115074, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5435893930, "stage_ordering_ns": 3027402652, "stage_eval_ns": 6094779715, "stage_threat_ns": 13035081678, "stage_proof_ns": 460864640, "tactical_annotations": 1966667, "root_tactical_annotations": 6142, "search_tactical_annotations": 1960525, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 488528, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2886216271, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1676338, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9614113644, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 182703, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6346761536, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 244254, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 365978388, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5380, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 33187272, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 488508, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61627339, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 586212, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 525992156, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 763894, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2394552741, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 616561, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 73958764, "child_limit_applications": 90464, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 90464, "child_cap_hits": 90464, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 90464, "child_moves_before_total": 8048036, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8048036, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 1073095, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1073095, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.96396356561726, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.86212194906261, "tt_hits": 54067, "tt_cutoffs": 6934, "beta_cutoffs": 75757, "depth_sum": 121, "avg_depth": 6.05, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 121, "avg_effective_depth": 6.05, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2122.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2522.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 14763, "avg_search_time_ms": 738.15, "search_nodes": 114447, "safety_nodes": 2485, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 116932, "avg_nodes": 5846.6, "eval_calls": 71026, "avg_eval_calls": 3551.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71026, "pattern_eval_ns": 1500578, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.127164700250614, "pattern_frame_queries": 71026, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1500578, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.127164700250614, "pattern_frame_updates": 228652, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2470502528, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10804.63992442664, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39237, "avg_candidate_generations": 1961.85, "candidate_moves_total": 3334777, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.99062109743355, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1631, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 39217, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3333146, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 2081963, "avg_legality_checks": 104098.15, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3494, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2081963, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3494, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4691200, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 234560.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9521298599, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2029.6083302779673, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55048, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2752.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 158824856, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2885.206656009301, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4181, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24156272, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10579, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 70586639, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 40268, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 64056985, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 24960, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 163527, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8176.35, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1386613813, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8479.418157246204, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 223282, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11164.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 606214129, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2715.0156707661163, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4731538023, "stage_ordering_ns": 1284588351, "stage_eval_ns": 2472003106, "stage_threat_ns": 6188114348, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 810323, "root_tactical_annotations": 1136, "search_tactical_annotations": 809187, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 228672, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1341436340, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 684971, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4626978724, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 78594, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2644321799, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 114326, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 170666103, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 228652, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28973746, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 188425, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 470700592, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 417938, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1511393272, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 203960, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20059435, "child_limit_applications": 39217, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39217, "child_cap_hits": 39217, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39217, "child_moves_before_total": 3329652, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3329652, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 434821, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 434821, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.90328174006171, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.087564066603768, "tt_hits": 20366, "tt_cutoffs": 4084, "beta_cutoffs": 31776, "depth_sum": 120, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 120, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5704.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6104.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 151, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1587, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 43052, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 128, 127, 141, 142, 157, 173, 158, 156, 125, 97, 124, 99, 109, 93, 123, 122, 95, 81, 137, 151, 129, 85, 71, 100, 98, 115, 116, 130, 70, 145 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 25585, "avg_search_time_ms": 1505.0, "search_nodes": 240752, "safety_nodes": 490, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 241242, "avg_nodes": 14190.70588235294, "eval_calls": 145235, "avg_eval_calls": 8543.235294117647, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 145235, "pattern_eval_ns": 3030115, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.86353151788481, "pattern_frame_queries": 145235, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3030115, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.86353151788481, "pattern_frame_updates": 481318, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5939708543, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12340.507820193718, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 88085, "avg_candidate_generations": 5181.470588235294, "candidate_moves_total": 7462695, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.72151898734177, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1257, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 88068, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7461438, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 2189424, "avg_legality_checks": 128789.64705882352, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2284, "root_legality_checks": 1257, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 2188167, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2280, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7080602, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 416506.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15231679705, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2151.184278540158, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42112, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2477.176470588235, "renju_forbidden_ns": 184715674, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4386.295450227964, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2887, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21439465, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18104, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 114854532, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21101, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 48262966, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 158711, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 146116, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8595.058823529413, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1162056696, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7952.973637383996, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 184288, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10840.470588235294, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 441655194, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2396.5488474561557, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5138344101, "stage_ordering_ns": 2829869535, "stage_eval_ns": 5942738658, "stage_threat_ns": 11582820840, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 1539841, "root_tactical_annotations": 4657, "search_tactical_annotations": 1535184, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 481335, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2784346768, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1293466, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8327106314, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 176262, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6037391150, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 240659, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 352922806, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 481318, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59632420, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 306821, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 202104532, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 810370, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2087481372, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 422650, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 58812532, "child_limit_applications": 88068, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 88068, "child_cap_hits": 88068, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 88068, "child_moves_before_total": 7459158, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7459158, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 833081, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 833081, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.69771085979016, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.459519916428215, "tt_hits": 45636, "tt_cutoffs": 7361, "beta_cutoffs": 69777, "depth_sum": 87, "avg_depth": 5.117647058823529, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 87, "avg_effective_depth": 5.117647058823529, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2215.6470588235293, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2686.235294117647, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 17451, "avg_search_time_ms": 1090.6875, "search_nodes": 141083, "safety_nodes": 1376, "corridor_nodes": 514, "corridor_branch_probes": 548, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 229, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 506, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 506, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 49, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 41, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 229, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 49, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 46, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 305, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 8261040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 142973, "avg_nodes": 8935.8125, "eval_calls": 86152, "avg_eval_calls": 5384.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 86152, "pattern_eval_ns": 1817179, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.09270823660507, "pattern_frame_queries": 86152, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1817179, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.09270823660507, "pattern_frame_updates": 281970, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2955959542, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10483.241273894386, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 51074, "avg_candidate_generations": 3192.125, "candidate_moves_total": 4048773, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.27268277401417, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1183, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 51058, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4047590, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 2229123, "avg_legality_checks": 139320.1875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2616, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2229123, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2616, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5253937, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 328371.0625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11195829058, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2130.940865488109, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26943, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1683.9375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 98443835, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3653.7815016887503, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2928, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22941274, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7444, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 52236030, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16528, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22984651, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 43, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 281880, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 145211, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9075.6875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1263293294, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8699.707969781904, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 193633, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12102.0625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 538221810, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2779.597537609808, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5281921320, "stage_ordering_ns": 1630662015, "stage_eval_ns": 2957776721, "stage_threat_ns": 7412410297, "stage_proof_ns": 78141424, "tactical_annotations": 736886, "root_tactical_annotations": 2163, "search_tactical_annotations": 734723, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 283096, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1663521289, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 709666, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5481052696, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 102678, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3557243155, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 141540, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 207567550, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1110, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7413990, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 283080, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35071313, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 125645, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 302357313, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 453529, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1604299037, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 157712, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17783459, "child_limit_applications": 51058, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 51058, "child_cap_hits": 51058, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 51058, "child_moves_before_total": 4044974, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4044974, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 473476, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 473476, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.2231188060637, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.2732970347448, "tt_hits": 21117, "tt_cutoffs": 3777, "beta_cutoffs": 39991, "depth_sum": 95, "avg_depth": 5.9375, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 95, "avg_effective_depth": 5.9375, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3122.0625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3622.0625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1588, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 35738, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 128, 127, 141, 142, 157, 173, 158, 156, 125, 97, 124, 99, 109, 93, 123, 122, 95, 115, 116, 85, 71, 100, 98, 130, 70, 145 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 18750, "avg_search_time_ms": 1250.0, "search_nodes": 169791, "safety_nodes": 954, "corridor_nodes": 1850, "corridor_branch_probes": 1904, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 824, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1839, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1839, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 53, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 824, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 53, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 414, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 48064240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2007920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 172595, "avg_nodes": 11506.333333333334, "eval_calls": 101686, "avg_eval_calls": 6779.066666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 101686, "pattern_eval_ns": 2121415, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.862409771256612, "pattern_frame_queries": 101686, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2121415, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.862409771256612, "pattern_frame_updates": 339412, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3831517273, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11288.69124544801, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 62909, "avg_candidate_generations": 4193.933333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4823978, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.68184202578327, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1061, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 62894, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4822917, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1650419, "avg_legality_checks": 110027.93333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2326, "root_legality_checks": 1061, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 1649358, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2318, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5321590, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 354772.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11417943259, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2145.5886791353714, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32906, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2193.733333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 165867401, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5040.64307421139, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2738, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22817332, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12547, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 98047839, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17225, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42370481, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 396, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2631749, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 121855, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8123.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1016236292, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8339.717631611342, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 158312, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10554.133333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 418381484, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2642.7654505028045, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3911629880, "stage_ordering_ns": 1941530560, "stage_eval_ns": 3833638688, "stage_threat_ns": 8724589732, "stage_proof_ns": 265689936, "tactical_annotations": 828014, "root_tactical_annotations": 3190, "search_tactical_annotations": 824824, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 343211, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2008442872, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 779548, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6363288873, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 127078, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4545903059, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 171598, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 253483536, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3784, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 23264327, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 343196, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42436594, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 125298, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 156767695, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 427011, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1419248717, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 275705, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33673530, "child_limit_applications": 62894, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 62894, "child_cap_hits": 62894, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 62894, "child_moves_before_total": 4820599, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4820599, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 584197, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 584197, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.64640506248608, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.288596686488377, "tt_hits": 34917, "tt_cutoffs": 5128, "beta_cutoffs": 49956, "depth_sum": 81, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 81, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2199.5333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2732.866666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 16977, "avg_search_time_ms": 1212.642857142857, "search_nodes": 140325, "safety_nodes": 1019, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 141344, "avg_nodes": 10096.0, "eval_calls": 85971, "avg_eval_calls": 6140.785714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 85971, "pattern_eval_ns": 1800453, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.942562026729945, "pattern_frame_queries": 85971, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1800453, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.942562026729945, "pattern_frame_updates": 280482, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2887528070, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10294.87835226503, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 50460, "avg_candidate_generations": 3604.285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 3969463, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.66553705905667, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 990, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 50446, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3968473, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 2213094, "avg_legality_checks": 158078.14285714287, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2811, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2213094, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2811, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5170388, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 369313.4285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10902330594, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2108.6097588807647, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27334, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1952.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_ns": 103924206, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3802.0123655520597, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3123, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24818414, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7737, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 54769615, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16429, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23971056, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 365121, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 143276, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10234.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1252431441, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8741.390330550825, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 192418, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13744.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 543849185, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2826.3945420906566, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5192072789, "stage_ordering_ns": 1592096321, "stage_eval_ns": 2889328523, "stage_threat_ns": 7212633331, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 711017, "root_tactical_annotations": 2121, "search_tactical_annotations": 708896, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 280496, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1618244622, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 655371, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5337088274, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 101004, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3471930006, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 140241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 204652826, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 280482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34620501, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 117853, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 297840496, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 436504, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1567129701, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 156660, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18027108, "child_limit_applications": 50446, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 50446, "child_cap_hits": 50446, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 50446, "child_moves_before_total": 3965662, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3965662, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 471012, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 471012, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.61202077468977, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.33695436704595, "tt_hits": 21341, "tt_cutoffs": 3826, "beta_cutoffs": 39484, "depth_sum": 81, "avg_depth": 5.785714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 81, "avg_effective_depth": 5.785714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2457.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3028.5714285714284, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1589, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15324, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 113, 114, 128, 82, 66, 110, 158, 68, 143, 173, 124, 54, 127, 96 ], "move_count": 18, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 8163, "avg_search_time_ms": 1166.142857142857, "search_nodes": 78661, "safety_nodes": 388, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 79049, "avg_nodes": 11292.714285714286, "eval_calls": 48024, "avg_eval_calls": 6860.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48024, "pattern_eval_ns": 997497, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.770802098950526, "pattern_frame_queries": 48024, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 997497, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.770802098950526, "pattern_frame_updates": 157246, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1637995228, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10416.768808109586, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28438, "avg_candidate_generations": 4062.5714285714284, "candidate_moves_total": 2161883, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.02092270905126, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 444, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 28431, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2161439, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 698142, "avg_legality_checks": 99734.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2203, "root_legality_checks": 444, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 697698, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2199, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2188243, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 312606.14285714284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4836144904, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2210.058436837225, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16413, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2344.714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 100388996, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6116.43185279961, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2209, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23566408, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6344, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 53707307, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7838, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 22880151, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 235130, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43320, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6188.571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 398997034, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9210.45784856879, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 58019, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8288.42857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 177435262, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3058.2268222478842, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1726656613, "stage_ordering_ns": 913407388, "stage_eval_ns": 1638992725, "stage_threat_ns": 3849030955, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 326028, "root_tactical_annotations": 1241, "search_tactical_annotations": 324787, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 157253, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 915419552, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 299202, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2790251828, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56914, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2118003606, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78623, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112377719, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 157246, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19318017, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 45096, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 50501230, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 197185, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 621457680, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 83747, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11663839, "child_limit_applications": 28431, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28431, "child_cap_hits": 28431, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28431, "child_moves_before_total": 2159240, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2159240, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 254924, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 254924, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.94667792198656, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.966409904681509, "tt_hits": 12246, "tt_cutoffs": 2169, "beta_cutoffs": 21983, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1242.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2080.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 7156, "avg_search_time_ms": 1022.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 57688, "safety_nodes": 244, "corridor_nodes": 93, "corridor_branch_probes": 109, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 20, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 87, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 87, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 35, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 278, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23971520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1987680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 58025, "avg_nodes": 8289.285714285714, "eval_calls": 36335, "avg_eval_calls": 5190.714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36335, "pattern_eval_ns": 758070, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.863354891977433, "pattern_frame_queries": 36335, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 758070, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.863354891977433, "pattern_frame_updates": 115302, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1093076919, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9480.121064682313, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19909, "avg_candidate_generations": 2844.1428571428573, "candidate_moves_total": 1526029, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.65020844844041, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 459, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 19902, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1525570, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 993886, "avg_legality_checks": 141983.7142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5778, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 993886, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2122425, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 303203.5714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4630030021, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2181.481098743183, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18034, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2576.285714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 138216512, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7664.21825440834, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5778, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 60329739, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5271, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 51831889, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6924, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25352920, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 61, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 701964, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46615, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6659.285714285715, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 436746855, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9369.234259358576, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 61741, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8820.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 196365519, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3180.4719554267017, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2460071302, "stage_ordering_ns": 642058580, "stage_eval_ns": 1093834989, "stage_threat_ns": 2856430345, "stage_proof_ns": 62295380, "tactical_annotations": 239905, "root_tactical_annotations": 1506, "search_tactical_annotations": 238399, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 115555, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 681352745, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 198443, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2064874723, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40052, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1462832323, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57774, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 83621518, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 246, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1079786, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 115548, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14364494, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 40402, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 163462011, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 110356, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 433133357, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 89147, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11137079, "child_limit_applications": 19902, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19902, "child_cap_hits": 19902, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19902, "child_moves_before_total": 1519792, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1519792, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 174222, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 174222, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.36378253441865, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.753994573409708, "tt_hits": 11184, "tt_cutoffs": 1414, "beta_cutoffs": 15247, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 5.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1970.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2950.285714285714, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1012, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1590, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24125, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 113, 114, 128, 82, 66, 110, 127, 96, 68, 126, 94, 144, 99, 130, 146, 158, 174, 116, 102, 172 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 12770, "avg_search_time_ms": 1277.0, "search_nodes": 118553, "safety_nodes": 604, "corridor_nodes": 62, "corridor_branch_probes": 71, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 59, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 59, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 22, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 22, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 149, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4078160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2033680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 119219, "avg_nodes": 11921.9, "eval_calls": 72484, "avg_eval_calls": 7248.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72484, "pattern_eval_ns": 1494975, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.624896528889135, "pattern_frame_queries": 72484, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1494975, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.624896528889135, "pattern_frame_updates": 237000, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2696068382, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11375.815957805908, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42713, "avg_candidate_generations": 4271.3, "candidate_moves_total": 3352940, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.49928593168356, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 659, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 42703, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3352281, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 1023531, "avg_legality_checks": 102353.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2606, "root_legality_checks": 659, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1022872, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2605, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3516732, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 351673.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7622393837, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2167.465088895031, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23192, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2319.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 134577029, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5802.734951707485, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2612, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 28072659, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8465, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71686150, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12110, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 34761170, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57050, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 88087, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8808.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 855851954, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9715.984810471466, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 121310, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12131.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 410575717, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3384.5166680405573, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2495087667, "stage_ordering_ns": 1368378193, "stage_eval_ns": 2697563357, "stage_threat_ns": 6116672265, "stage_proof_ns": 49866064, "tactical_annotations": 613226, "root_tactical_annotations": 1506, "search_tactical_annotations": 611720, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 237172, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1384510699, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 538700, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4504924563, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 85595, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3167470216, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 118581, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 174818825, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 162, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 771581, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 237162, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29249704, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 111268, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 228551419, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 336921, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1097592800, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 165037, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22396893, "child_limit_applications": 42703, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42703, "child_cap_hits": 42703, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42703, "child_moves_before_total": 3349676, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3349676, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 435301, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 435301, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.44123363698101, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.19368662623235, "tt_hits": 19270, "tt_cutoffs": 3315, "beta_cutoffs": 34275, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 5.1, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 5.1, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1761.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2488.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 11344, "avg_search_time_ms": 1134.4, "search_nodes": 91001, "safety_nodes": 659, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 91660, "avg_nodes": 9166.0, "eval_calls": 59875, "avg_eval_calls": 5987.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 59875, "pattern_eval_ns": 1228286, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.514171189979123, "pattern_frame_queries": 59875, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1228286, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.514171189979123, "pattern_frame_updates": 181908, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1836209813, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10094.167452778327, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29176, "avg_candidate_generations": 2917.6, "candidate_moves_total": 2257599, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.3786331231149, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 687, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 29166, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2256912, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 1517190, "avg_legality_checks": 151719.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4439, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1517190, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4439, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3691117, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 369111.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7440821357, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2015.8725277470207, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20781, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2078.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124457018, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5988.981184736057, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4439, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 47963838, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5264, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 51920340, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11068, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24453470, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 119370, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 140585, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14058.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1333996038, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9488.893110929332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 199196, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19919.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 640262699, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3214.234718568646, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3608295027, "stage_ordering_ns": 911762846, "stage_eval_ns": 1837438099, "stage_threat_ns": 4924260009, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 483175, "root_tactical_annotations": 1897, "search_tactical_annotations": 481278, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 181918, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1025444612, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 424984, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3733979473, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58398, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2029450391, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 90954, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 129118849, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 181908, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21772575, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 111587, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 500666187, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 254990, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1203677154, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 116598, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13944500, "child_limit_applications": 29166, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29166, "child_cap_hits": 29166, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29166, "child_moves_before_total": 2252473, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2252473, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 313919, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 313919, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.22941095796476, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.763183158472193, "tt_hits": 13198, "tt_cutoffs": 1914, "beta_cutoffs": 22399, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2582.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3382.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1181, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1591, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10306, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 82, 98, 143, 96, 99, 126, 84, 94, 95, 142, 157, 110, 158, 78 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5653, "avg_search_time_ms": 706.625, "search_nodes": 78478, "safety_nodes": 66, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 78544, "avg_nodes": 9818.0, "eval_calls": 50215, "avg_eval_calls": 6276.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50215, "pattern_eval_ns": 964092, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.1992830827442, "pattern_frame_queries": 50215, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 964092, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.1992830827442, "pattern_frame_updates": 156884, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1424759453, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9081.610954590653, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26725, "avg_candidate_generations": 3340.625, "candidate_moves_total": 1757916, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.77796071094481, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 416, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 26717, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1757500, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 517380, "avg_legality_checks": 64672.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 291, "root_legality_checks": 416, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 516964, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 291, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2092890, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 261611.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3346945427, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1599.1979640592674, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14144, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1768.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 38262372, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2705.201640271493, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 468, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1591096, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7017, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27591482, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6659, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9079794, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43518, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5439.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 260831424, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5993.644560871364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56377, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7047.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 106318962, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1885.8570338968018, "stage_move_gen_ns": 935382162, "stage_ordering_ns": 538107857, "stage_eval_ns": 1425723545, "stage_threat_ns": 2724754191, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 273420, "root_tactical_annotations": 1619, "search_tactical_annotations": 271801, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 156892, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 689635148, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 218616, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1916808797, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53485, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1519247064, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78442, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91297112, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 156884, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15247887, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 38107, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 53681423, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 127017, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 343873939, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 108296, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11765247, "child_limit_applications": 26717, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26717, "child_cap_hits": 26717, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26717, "child_moves_before_total": 1757209, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1757209, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 241949, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 241949, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 65.77119437062544, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.05599431073848, "tt_hits": 15819, "tt_cutoffs": 1510, "beta_cutoffs": 20719, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3474.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4474.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1364, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 4647, "avg_search_time_ms": 663.8571428571429, "search_nodes": 58656, "safety_nodes": 459, "corridor_nodes": 8, "corridor_branch_probes": 4, "corridor_max_depth": 1, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 4, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 26, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 22, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 26, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 26, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 159, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 33743680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59123, "avg_nodes": 8446.142857142857, "eval_calls": 32900, "avg_eval_calls": 4700.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32900, "pattern_eval_ns": 624611, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.9851367781155, "pattern_frame_queries": 32900, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 624611, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.9851367781155, "pattern_frame_updates": 117240, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 821304286, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7005.3248549982945, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22909, "avg_candidate_generations": 3272.714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 1511029, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.95787681697149, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 368, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 22902, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1510661, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 792999, "avg_legality_checks": 113285.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 792999, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2095538, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 299362.5714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2925435508, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1396.03076059704, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9595, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1370.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10820996, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1127.7744658676395, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 46, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 119300, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2226, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6922935, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7323, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3778761, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53529, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7647.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 318022208, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5941.119916307049, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 71115, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10159.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 135105348, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1899.8150601139, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1220762395, "stage_ordering_ns": 414538634, "stage_eval_ns": 821928897, "stage_threat_ns": 2125554396, "stage_proof_ns": 26593025, "tactical_annotations": 252862, "root_tactical_annotations": 359, "search_tactical_annotations": 252503, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 117307, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 473980028, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 216441, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1569137158, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45958, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1115964074, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58650, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 62238517, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 60, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 153680, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 117300, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10556598, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 26519, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 108167019, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 143064, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 344624802, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 83279, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9488415, "child_limit_applications": 22902, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22902, "child_cap_hits": 22902, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22902, "child_moves_before_total": 1510619, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1510619, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 198983, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 198983, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 65.96013448607108, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.688455156754868, "tt_hits": 12187, "tt_cutoffs": 2818, "beta_cutoffs": 18255, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2827.285714285714, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3970.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 198, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1592, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13149, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 82, 98, 143, 96, 99, 126, 84, 94, 95, 142, 157, 110, 158, 78 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7669, "avg_search_time_ms": 958.625, "search_nodes": 78478, "safety_nodes": 66, "corridor_nodes": 689, "corridor_branch_probes": 798, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 211, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 679, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 679, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 34, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 211, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 34, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 274, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 12026320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1967120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 79233, "avg_nodes": 9904.125, "eval_calls": 50215, "avg_eval_calls": 6276.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50215, "pattern_eval_ns": 1019389, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.30048790202131, "pattern_frame_queries": 50215, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1019389, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.30048790202131, "pattern_frame_updates": 156884, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1925915491, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12276.047850641238, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26725, "avg_candidate_generations": 3340.625, "candidate_moves_total": 1757916, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.77796071094481, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 416, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 26717, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1757500, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 517380, "avg_legality_checks": 64672.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 291, "root_legality_checks": 416, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 516964, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 291, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2217291, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 277161.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4685118130, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2112.9919933829165, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14187, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1773.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 59690384, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4207.400014097413, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 468, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2919113, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7017, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 42233360, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6664, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14478671, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 59240, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44728, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5591.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 371729328, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8310.886424610982, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 58000, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7250.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 148867339, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2566.6782586206896, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1192738929, "stage_ordering_ns": 705753367, "stage_eval_ns": 1926934880, "stage_threat_ns": 3664155928, "stage_proof_ns": 153172575, "tactical_annotations": 273420, "root_tactical_annotations": 1619, "search_tactical_annotations": 271801, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 158318, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 898210841, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 269203, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2613438200, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53977, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1958423228, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79155, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112019569, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1426, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7227903, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 158310, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19086825, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 38107, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 78802400, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 127017, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 452332686, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 108296, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14172590, "child_limit_applications": 26717, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26717, "child_cap_hits": 26717, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26717, "child_moves_before_total": 1757209, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1757209, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 241949, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 241949, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 65.77119437062544, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.05599431073848, "tt_hits": 15819, "tt_cutoffs": 1510, "beta_cutoffs": 20719, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2628.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3628.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1765, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 5472, "avg_search_time_ms": 781.7142857142857, "search_nodes": 46430, "safety_nodes": 459, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 46889, "avg_nodes": 6698.428571428572, "eval_calls": 26823, "avg_eval_calls": 3831.8571428571427, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 26823, "pattern_eval_ns": 559550, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.860828393542857, "pattern_frame_queries": 26823, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 559550, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.860828393542857, "pattern_frame_updates": 92788, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 957267150, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10316.712829245162, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17759, "avg_candidate_generations": 2537.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1165602, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.63443887606284, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 368, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 17752, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1165234, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 632823, "avg_legality_checks": 90403.28571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 632823, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1685767, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 240823.85714285713, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3540952769, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2100.499516837143, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8998, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1285.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14533168, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1615.1553678595244, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 46, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 233361, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1840, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8911265, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7112, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5388542, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50497, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7213.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 441088792, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8734.950432698972, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 67019, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9574.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 184280158, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2749.6703621361107, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1484292521, "stage_ordering_ns": 485032850, "stage_eval_ns": 957826700, "stage_threat_ns": 2516906560, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 198178, "root_tactical_annotations": 359, "search_tactical_annotations": 197819, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 92795, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 543978413, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 177266, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1885728574, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35554, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1278811317, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 46394, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68508610, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 92788, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11395532, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 22736, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 131745931, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 118972, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 475054226, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 56470, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7295431, "child_limit_applications": 17752, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17752, "child_cap_hits": 17752, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17752, "child_moves_before_total": 1165192, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1165192, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 156244, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 156244, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 65.6372239747634, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.801487156376746, "tt_hits": 8268, "tt_cutoffs": 1819, "beta_cutoffs": 14048, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2405.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3547.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1593, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21903, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 128, 95, 140, 109, 108, 141, 157, 81, 129, 130, 123, 83, 97, 80, 65, 82, 79, 84 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 13429, "avg_search_time_ms": 1220.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 131405, "safety_nodes": 151, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 131556, "avg_nodes": 11959.636363636364, "eval_calls": 84016, "avg_eval_calls": 7637.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84016, "pattern_eval_ns": 1741994, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.734074462007236, "pattern_frame_queries": 84016, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1741994, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.734074462007236, "pattern_frame_updates": 262704, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3570678837, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13592.023102046409, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43326, "avg_candidate_generations": 3938.7272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 3066298, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.77269999538383, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 661, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 43315, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3065637, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 936880, "avg_legality_checks": 85170.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 840, "root_legality_checks": 661, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 936219, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 840, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3771835, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 342894.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8111233487, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2150.474102658255, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25612, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2328.3636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 126100468, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4923.491644541621, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 961, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8050783, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12064, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 86779309, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12587, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31270376, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97868, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8897.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 840499216, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8588.090244002125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 129676, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11788.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 359543569, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2772.6300086369106, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2253496965, "stage_ordering_ns": 1267127524, "stage_eval_ns": 3572420831, "stage_threat_ns": 6297501696, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 764426, "root_tactical_annotations": 2718, "search_tactical_annotations": 761708, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 262715, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1546796814, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 568109, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4487833886, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 86704, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3202184418, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 131352, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 196734010, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 262704, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33176303, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 166383, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 171200285, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 315013, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1114438773, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 283030, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32960683, "child_limit_applications": 43315, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43315, "child_cap_hits": 43315, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43315, "child_moves_before_total": 3064797, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3064797, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 496454, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 496454, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.75601985455386, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.46147985686252, "tt_hits": 26275, "tt_cutoffs": 4021, "beta_cutoffs": 34378, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 4.818181818181818, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 4.818181818181818, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2357.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3084.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 654, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8460, "avg_search_time_ms": 846.0, "search_nodes": 73647, "safety_nodes": 904, "corridor_nodes": 721, "corridor_branch_probes": 880, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 279, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 30, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 25, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 279, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 30, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 166, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 10019920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 75272, "avg_nodes": 7527.2, "eval_calls": 44337, "avg_eval_calls": 4433.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44337, "pattern_eval_ns": 926533, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.89751223583012, "pattern_frame_queries": 44337, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 926533, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.89751223583012, "pattern_frame_updates": 147182, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1717043232, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11666.122433449742, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25418, "avg_candidate_generations": 2541.8, "candidate_moves_total": 1764586, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.42269258006138, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 603, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 25408, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1763983, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 784720, "avg_legality_checks": 78472.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 469, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 784720, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 469, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2457992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 245799.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5180930195, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2107.789689714206, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14136, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1413.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 47675324, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3372.617713638936, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 473, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4240476, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4341, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29160001, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9322, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14274847, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 78537, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7853.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 675717425, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8603.809987649134, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 105475, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10547.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 287829678, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2728.890049774828, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1895446987, "stage_ordering_ns": 737583632, "stage_eval_ns": 1717969765, "stage_threat_ns": 4031936135, "stage_proof_ns": 44162462, "tactical_annotations": 434504, "root_tactical_annotations": 418, "search_tactical_annotations": 434086, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 148684, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 904512700, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 440822, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2978011411, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51267, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1864749256, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74337, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 113275911, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1492, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7783494, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 148674, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19051387, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52682, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 133947699, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 291185, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 941571015, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 90637, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9301232, "child_limit_applications": 25408, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25408, "child_cap_hits": 25408, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25408, "child_moves_before_total": 1763514, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1763514, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 277150, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 277150, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.4078243073048, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.907981738035264, "tt_hits": 11365, "tt_cutoffs": 3846, "beta_cutoffs": 20586, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 5.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3577.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4377.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 283, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1594, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27820, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 128, 95, 140, 109, 108, 141, 157, 81, 123, 97, 129, 130, 83, 98, 99, 67, 53, 82, 52, 114, 66, 146 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18993, "avg_search_time_ms": 1461.0, "search_nodes": 175131, "safety_nodes": 306, "corridor_nodes": 8475, "corridor_branch_probes": 9148, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4604, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 8441, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8441, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 82, "corridor_proof_active": 34, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4604, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 82, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 81, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 682, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 59596240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1984240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 183912, "avg_nodes": 14147.076923076924, "eval_calls": 112257, "avg_eval_calls": 8635.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 112257, "pattern_eval_ns": 2298023, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.471088662622375, "pattern_frame_queries": 112257, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2298023, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.471088662622375, "pattern_frame_updates": 350124, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4557475337, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13016.746458397596, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 57524, "avg_candidate_generations": 4424.923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 4336992, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.39447882622905, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 824, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 57511, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4336168, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1233353, "avg_legality_checks": 94873.30769230769, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1228, "root_legality_checks": 824, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1232529, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1228, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5869156, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 451473.53846153844, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11541089388, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1966.3967677805804, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56626, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4355.846153846154, "renju_forbidden_ns": 230281520, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4066.709991876523, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1903, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11267370, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28709, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 150124326, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24497, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 62839905, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1517, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6049919, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 151414, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11647.23076923077, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1188616367, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7850.108754804708, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 196365, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15105.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 493839811, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2514.907498790518, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2770895594, "stage_ordering_ns": 1637529776, "stage_eval_ns": 4559773360, "stage_threat_ns": 9198561087, "stage_proof_ns": 773829522, "tactical_annotations": 1214767, "root_tactical_annotations": 3117, "search_tactical_annotations": 1211650, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 367183, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2122500768, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1286692, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6612430387, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 118600, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4048665114, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 183585, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 266518544, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 17046, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 96484898, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 367170, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 43819459, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 304883, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 230359859, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 467258, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1437246697, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 442626, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 56807031, "child_limit_applications": 57511, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 57511, "child_cap_hits": 57511, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 57511, "child_moves_before_total": 4334940, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4334940, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 721745, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 721745, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.37584114343343, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.549686146997965, "tt_hits": 35516, "tt_cutoffs": 5294, "beta_cutoffs": 46461, "depth_sum": 68, "avg_depth": 5.230769230769231, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 68, "avg_effective_depth": 5.230769230769231, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1721.5384615384614, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2265.4615384615386, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8815, "avg_search_time_ms": 734.5833333333334, "search_nodes": 92031, "safety_nodes": 1127, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 93158, "avg_nodes": 7763.166666666667, "eval_calls": 54723, "avg_eval_calls": 4560.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 54723, "pattern_eval_ns": 1099203, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.086672879776327, "pattern_frame_queries": 54723, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1099203, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.086672879776327, "pattern_frame_updates": 183922, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1866030621, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10145.771691260426, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32572, "avg_candidate_generations": 2714.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2367087, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.67244872896967, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 762, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 32560, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2366325, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 971270, "avg_legality_checks": 80939.16666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1111, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 971270, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3027902, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 252325.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5296199110, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1749.1316132424365, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27678, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2306.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 78765540, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2845.781487101669, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1495, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6550589, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10154, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 47063550, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16029, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25151401, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97498, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8124.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 667109543, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6842.289513631049, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 126340, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10528.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 258832619, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2048.698899794206, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1964420087, "stage_ordering_ns": 813302585, "stage_eval_ns": 1867129824, "stage_threat_ns": 4122822305, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 643281, "root_tactical_annotations": 455, "search_tactical_annotations": 642826, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 183934, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 908735115, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 584850, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3063656830, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 65214, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1879988601, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91961, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 117407671, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 183922, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19755721, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96404, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 146405442, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 423224, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1036984835, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 123653, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13266968, "child_limit_applications": 32560, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32560, "child_cap_hits": 32560, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32560, "child_moves_before_total": 2365214, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2365214, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 376253, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 376253, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.64170761670762, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.555681818181819, "tt_hits": 14190, "tt_cutoffs": 4678, "beta_cutoffs": 26773, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 5.833333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 5.833333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5175.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5842.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1604, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1595, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13041, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 67, 81, 126, 83, 80, 113, 65, 85, 84, 127, 142, 99, 141, 71 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7583, "avg_search_time_ms": 947.875, "search_nodes": 79158, "safety_nodes": 66, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 79224, "avg_nodes": 9903.0, "eval_calls": 50458, "avg_eval_calls": 6307.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50458, "pattern_eval_ns": 1041613, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.64316857584526, "pattern_frame_queries": 50458, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1041613, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.64316857584526, "pattern_frame_updates": 158244, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1933690056, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12219.673769621597, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27073, "avg_candidate_generations": 3384.125, "candidate_moves_total": 1751897, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.7101170908285, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 416, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 27065, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1751481, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 529468, "avg_legality_checks": 66183.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 269, "root_legality_checks": 416, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 529052, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 269, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2095368, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 261921.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4583881465, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2187.6259754849743, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13864, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1733.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 58991565, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4255.017671667629, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 444, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2759225, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6850, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 42104858, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6570, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14127482, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44442, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5555.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 373533487, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8404.965730615184, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 57583, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7197.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 147175232, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2555.879895107931, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1267263390, "stage_ordering_ns": 708020615, "stage_eval_ns": 1934731669, "stage_threat_ns": 3649239419, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 278629, "root_tactical_annotations": 1619, "search_tactical_annotations": 277010, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 158252, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 945720054, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 222634, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2555272004, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54181, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2000473605, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79122, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 115126374, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 158244, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20159147, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 37919, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 73792412, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 130527, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 480998166, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110183, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12961840, "child_limit_applications": 27065, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27065, "child_cap_hits": 27065, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27065, "child_moves_before_total": 1751212, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1751212, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 245276, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 245276, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 64.70393497136523, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.062479216700536, "tt_hits": 15994, "tt_cutoffs": 1599, "beta_cutoffs": 21015, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2607.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3607.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1420, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 5450, "avg_search_time_ms": 778.5714285714286, "search_nodes": 47258, "safety_nodes": 459, "corridor_nodes": 8, "corridor_branch_probes": 4, "corridor_max_depth": 1, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 4, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 10, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 6, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 10, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 10, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 23, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 7960960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 47725, "avg_nodes": 6817.857142857143, "eval_calls": 27292, "avg_eval_calls": 3898.8571428571427, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 27292, "pattern_eval_ns": 575731, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.095229371244322, "pattern_frame_queries": 27292, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 575731, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.095229371244322, "pattern_frame_updates": 94444, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 950604066, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10065.266888314769, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18022, "avg_candidate_generations": 2574.5714285714284, "candidate_moves_total": 1157698, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.23804239263123, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 368, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 18015, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1157330, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 618521, "avg_legality_checks": 88360.14285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 618521, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1657154, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 236736.2857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3524978863, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2127.128114224749, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8748, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1249.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14865057, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1699.2520576131687, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 123750, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1892, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9437725, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6822, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5303582, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48954, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6993.428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 422563612, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8631.850553580913, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 64825, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9260.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 174923098, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2698.389479367528, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1477306406, "stage_ordering_ns": 467206163, "stage_eval_ns": 951179797, "stage_threat_ns": 2509396201, "stage_proof_ns": 17174291, "tactical_annotations": 198428, "root_tactical_annotations": 359, "search_tactical_annotations": 198069, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 94479, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 562247745, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 178790, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1860427766, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36120, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1271026022, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47236, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68346189, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 28, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 122871, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 94472, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11626394, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 22774, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 124673872, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 119028, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 464234482, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 56626, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6625236, "child_limit_applications": 18015, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18015, "child_cap_hits": 18015, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18015, "child_moves_before_total": 1157298, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1157298, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 157794, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 157794, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 64.24079933388843, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.759034138218151, "tt_hits": 8518, "tt_cutoffs": 1916, "beta_cutoffs": 14243, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2397.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3540.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1596, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13479, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 67, 81, 126, 83, 80, 113, 65, 85, 84, 127, 142, 99, 141, 71 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 8031, "avg_search_time_ms": 1003.875, "search_nodes": 79158, "safety_nodes": 66, "corridor_nodes": 753, "corridor_branch_probes": 858, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 235, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 743, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 743, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 34, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 235, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 34, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 274, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 12021520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1966880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 79977, "avg_nodes": 9997.125, "eval_calls": 50458, "avg_eval_calls": 6307.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50458, "pattern_eval_ns": 1054982, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.908121606088233, "pattern_frame_queries": 50458, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1054982, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.908121606088233, "pattern_frame_updates": 158244, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1960002272, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12385.950001263871, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27073, "avg_candidate_generations": 3384.125, "candidate_moves_total": 1751897, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.7101170908285, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 416, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 27065, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1751481, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 529468, "avg_legality_checks": 66183.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 269, "root_legality_checks": 416, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 529052, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 269, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2227837, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 278479.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4906269159, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2202.256789432979, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13915, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1739.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60056510, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4315.9547251167805, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 444, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2801774, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6850, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 42714380, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6577, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14448796, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 91560, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45706, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5713.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 389805017, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8528.530543035926, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 59273, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7409.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 154909975, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2613.499822853576, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1280032273, "stage_ordering_ns": 714855419, "stage_eval_ns": 1961057254, "stage_threat_ns": 3891048870, "stage_proof_ns": 160818876, "tactical_annotations": 278629, "root_tactical_annotations": 1619, "search_tactical_annotations": 277010, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 159806, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 974820414, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 277421, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2755279992, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54715, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2061944131, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79899, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 119025328, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1554, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8070122, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 159798, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20257348, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 37919, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 74749431, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 130527, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 485688755, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110183, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13595666, "child_limit_applications": 27065, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27065, "child_cap_hits": 27065, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27065, "child_moves_before_total": 1751212, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1751212, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 245276, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 245276, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 64.70393497136523, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.062479216700536, "tt_hits": 15994, "tt_cutoffs": 1599, "beta_cutoffs": 21015, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2343.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3342.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1371, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 5440, "avg_search_time_ms": 777.1428571428571, "search_nodes": 47080, "safety_nodes": 459, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 47539, "avg_nodes": 6791.285714285715, "eval_calls": 27223, "avg_eval_calls": 3889.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 27223, "pattern_eval_ns": 588644, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.623039341733094, "pattern_frame_queries": 27223, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 588644, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.623039341733094, "pattern_frame_updates": 94088, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 954755445, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10147.473057137999, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17931, "avg_candidate_generations": 2561.5714285714284, "candidate_moves_total": 1151696, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.22932351792984, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 368, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 17924, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1151328, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 617404, "avg_legality_checks": 88200.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 617404, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1646253, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 235179.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3517856226, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2136.886751914803, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8731, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1247.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14956805, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1713.0689497193907, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 124250, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1882, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9505603, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6815, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5326952, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48954, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6993.428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 425407834, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8689.950443273277, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 64825, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9260.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 176323230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2719.9881218665637, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1480788728, "stage_ordering_ns": 466126323, "stage_eval_ns": 955344089, "stage_threat_ns": 2510434534, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 197587, "root_tactical_annotations": 359, "search_tactical_annotations": 197228, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 94095, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 564020508, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 177119, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1859301670, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35898, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1267985347, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 47044, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68971036, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 94088, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11697912, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 22774, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 125499779, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 118443, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 465681324, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 56370, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6443408, "child_limit_applications": 17924, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17924, "child_cap_hits": 17924, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17924, "child_moves_before_total": 1151296, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1151296, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 157059, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 157059, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 64.23209105110466, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.762497210444097, "tt_hits": 8470, "tt_cutoffs": 1897, "beta_cutoffs": 14163, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2402.5714285714284, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3545.4285714285716, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1597, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 42555, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 110, 96, 99, 128, 144, 114, 115, 100, 142, 80, 64, 66, 51, 94, 83, 67, 52, 126, 81, 141, 156, 127, 129, 143, 159, 68, 69, 125, 124, 173, 158, 157, 189, 109 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 30117, "avg_search_time_ms": 1673.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 291018, "safety_nodes": 342, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 291360, "avg_nodes": 16186.666666666666, "eval_calls": 178303, "avg_eval_calls": 9905.722222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 178303, "pattern_eval_ns": 3952736, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.168645507927515, "pattern_frame_queries": 178303, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3952736, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.168645507927515, "pattern_frame_updates": 581836, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7327355570, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12593.506709794512, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 104429, "avg_candidate_generations": 5801.611111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 8952020, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.72350592268431, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1266, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 104411, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8950754, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 2079176, "avg_legality_checks": 115509.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1097, "root_legality_checks": 1266, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2077910, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1097, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7834113, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 435228.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17342156677, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2213.6720107305064, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56228, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3123.777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 194551958, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3460.0547414099738, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1989, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12268400, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25677, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 122305189, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28560, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 59974869, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3500, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 176807, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9822.611111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1461926779, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8268.489250991193, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 226515, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12584.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 565551026, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2496.748674480719, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5060661763, "stage_ordering_ns": 3519605741, "stage_eval_ns": 7331308306, "stage_threat_ns": 14110285010, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 2081360, "root_tactical_annotations": 6166, "search_tactical_annotations": 2075194, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 581854, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3547276017, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1634176, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9941176728, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 208957, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7216931441, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 290918, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 454261849, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 581836, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 76264385, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 545266, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 464145851, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 879937, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2260000086, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 656157, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 91306031, "child_limit_applications": 104411, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 104411, "child_cap_hits": 104411, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 104411, "child_moves_before_total": 8949657, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8949657, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 1064235, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1064235, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.71565256534274, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.192747890547931, "tt_hits": 60677, "tt_cutoffs": 8209, "beta_cutoffs": 85379, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 5.111111111111111, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 5.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 8, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 8, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1119.1666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1451.7777777777778, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 12421, "avg_search_time_ms": 730.6470588235294, "search_nodes": 102142, "safety_nodes": 1749, "corridor_nodes": 748, "corridor_branch_probes": 795, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 294, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 733, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 733, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 22, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 294, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 93, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 7, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 20018240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2007120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 104639, "avg_nodes": 6155.235294117647, "eval_calls": 60046, "avg_eval_calls": 3532.1176470588234, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60046, "pattern_eval_ns": 1342486, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.35762582020451, "pattern_frame_queries": 60046, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1342486, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.35762582020451, "pattern_frame_updates": 204074, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2255240313, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11051.090844497585, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38537, "avg_candidate_generations": 2266.8823529411766, "candidate_moves_total": 3149944, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.73817370319433, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1191, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 38520, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3148753, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1280240, "avg_legality_checks": 75308.23529411765, "illegal_moves_skipped": 351, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1280240, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 351, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3489425, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 205260.29411764705, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7549249686, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2163.465237395846, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20773, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1221.9411764705883, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42376192, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2039.964954508256, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 651, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3842195, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5796, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22823145, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14326, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15710852, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 106444, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6261.411764705882, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 853105293, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8014.592583893878, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 134217, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7895.117647058823, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 309276261, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2304.300207872326, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3088574540, "stage_ordering_ns": 1255272353, "stage_eval_ns": 2256582799, "stage_threat_ns": 5695397806, "stage_proof_ns": 56443192, "tactical_annotations": 758111, "root_tactical_annotations": 554, "search_tactical_annotations": 757557, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 205631, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1287411787, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 729549, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4193896649, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 77691, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2643036513, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102807, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159571151, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1540, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10631056, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 205614, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26939392, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 130677, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 266237153, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 477459, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1253498958, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 149975, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16947771, "child_limit_applications": 38520, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38520, "child_cap_hits": 38520, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38520, "child_moves_before_total": 3148402, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3148402, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 409708, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 409708, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.73421599169262, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.636240913811008, "tt_hits": 15584, "tt_cutoffs": 3471, "beta_cutoffs": 31596, "depth_sum": 104, "avg_depth": 6.117647058823529, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 104, "avg_effective_depth": 6.117647058823529, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5702.588235294118, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6173.176470588235, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1598, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 42503, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 110, 96, 99, 128, 144, 114, 115, 100, 142, 80, 64, 66, 51, 94, 83, 67, 52, 126, 81, 141, 156, 127, 129, 143, 159, 68, 69, 125, 124, 173, 158, 157, 189, 109 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 30139, "avg_search_time_ms": 1674.388888888889, "search_nodes": 294689, "safety_nodes": 342, "corridor_nodes": 3071, "corridor_branch_probes": 3360, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1255, "corridor_neutral_exits": 24, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 3049, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3049, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 65, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1255, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 65, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 545, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 35769280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1988000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 298102, "avg_nodes": 16561.222222222223, "eval_calls": 180654, "avg_eval_calls": 10036.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 180654, "pattern_eval_ns": 3967632, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.96260254408981, "pattern_frame_queries": 180654, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3967632, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.96260254408981, "pattern_frame_updates": 589178, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7079179320, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12015.34904561949, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 105630, "avg_candidate_generations": 5868.333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 9059897, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.77011265738899, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1266, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 105612, "search_candidate_moves_total": 9058631, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 2109662, "avg_legality_checks": 117203.44444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1104, "root_legality_checks": 1266, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2108396, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1104, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8364157, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 464675.3888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17545607792, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2097.7138272272987, "renju_forbidden_checks": 57286, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3182.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 183711747, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3206.9222323080685, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2022, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11522391, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26173, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 115194882, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28927, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 56232052, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 164, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 762422, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 183861, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10214.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1476638676, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8031.277301874786, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 236607, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13144.833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 577793560, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2441.9968978094475, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4877541608, "stage_ordering_ns": 3328774201, "stage_eval_ns": 7083146952, "stage_threat_ns": 14279494285, "stage_proof_ns": 472295597, "tactical_annotations": 2103468, "root_tactical_annotations": 6166, "search_tactical_annotations": 2097302, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 595424, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3501957845, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1827287, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10127030238, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 213153, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7008099165, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 297703, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 441725838, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6228, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 39100654, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 595406, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74476721, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 546234, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 453950082, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 882903, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2175774007, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 674331, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 95202989, "child_limit_applications": 105612, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 105612, "child_cap_hits": 105612, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 105612, "child_moves_before_total": 9057527, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 9057527, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 1075101, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1075101, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.76229027004507, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.17972389501193, "tt_hits": 61782, "tt_cutoffs": 8328, "beta_cutoffs": 86273, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 5.111111111111111, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 5.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 8, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 8, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 971.6111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1304.1666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 12345, "avg_search_time_ms": 726.1764705882352, "search_nodes": 102050, "safety_nodes": 1749, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 103799, "avg_nodes": 6105.823529411765, "eval_calls": 60009, "avg_eval_calls": 3529.9411764705883, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60009, "pattern_eval_ns": 1351975, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.529537236081254, "pattern_frame_queries": 60009, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1351975, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.529537236081254, "pattern_frame_updates": 203890, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2258865908, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11078.84598558046, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38491, "avg_candidate_generations": 2264.176470588235, "candidate_moves_total": 3146663, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.75061702735704, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1191, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 38474, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3145472, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1277303, "avg_legality_checks": 75135.4705882353, "illegal_moves_skipped": 351, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1277303, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 351, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3452653, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 203097.23529411765, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7502058236, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2172.83875211323, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20729, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1219.3529411764705, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42003927, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2026.3363886342804, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 651, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3770846, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5796, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22760929, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14282, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15472152, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 106363, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6256.64705882353, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 853239005, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8021.95316980529, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 134136, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7890.35294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 309106769, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2304.4281102761374, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3100207787, "stage_ordering_ns": 1256860789, "stage_eval_ns": 2260217883, "stage_threat_ns": 5648898094, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 757537, "root_tactical_annotations": 554, "search_tactical_annotations": 756983, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 203907, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1288863650, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 685138, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4158399283, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 77087, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2629866313, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 101945, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 157826986, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 203890, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26793441, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 130582, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 266567612, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 477459, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1261546406, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 149496, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17014734, "child_limit_applications": 38474, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38474, "child_cap_hits": 38474, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38474, "child_moves_before_total": 3145121, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3145121, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 409329, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 409329, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.74666008213339, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.63910692935489, "tt_hits": 15530, "tt_cutoffs": 3463, "beta_cutoffs": 31554, "depth_sum": 104, "avg_depth": 6.117647058823529, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 104, "avg_effective_depth": 6.117647058823529, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5704.058823529412, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6174.64705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1599, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12898, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 82, 96, 141, 98, 95, 128, 80, 100, 99, 142, 157, 114, 156, 86 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7394, "avg_search_time_ms": 924.25, "search_nodes": 79259, "safety_nodes": 66, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 79325, "avg_nodes": 9915.625, "eval_calls": 50556, "avg_eval_calls": 6319.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50556, "pattern_eval_ns": 1092143, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.602638658121688, "pattern_frame_queries": 50556, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1092143, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.602638658121688, "pattern_frame_updates": 158446, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1837842226, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11599.170859472628, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27152, "avg_candidate_generations": 3394.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1777682, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.47149381261049, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 416, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 27144, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1777266, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 539538, "avg_legality_checks": 67442.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 269, "root_legality_checks": 416, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 539122, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 269, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2130308, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 266288.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4449841874, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2088.825594233322, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13950, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1743.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51304868, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3677.7683154121864, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 444, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2237920, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6861, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 36802847, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6645, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12264101, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44899, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5612.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 359709407, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8011.523797857413, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 58188, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7273.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 144175686, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2477.7563415137142, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1260752358, "stage_ordering_ns": 711231312, "stage_eval_ns": 1838934369, "stage_threat_ns": 3555751273, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 279980, "root_tactical_annotations": 1619, "search_tactical_annotations": 278361, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 158454, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 904030537, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 223708, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2505820946, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54339, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1973719409, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79223, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112863546, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 158446, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19324479, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 37968, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 70204482, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 131394, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 461889344, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110618, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13711765, "child_limit_applications": 27144, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27144, "child_cap_hits": 27144, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27144, "child_moves_before_total": 1776997, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1776997, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 246056, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 246056, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 65.46555408193339, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.064839375184203, "tt_hits": 15942, "tt_cutoffs": 1523, "beta_cutoffs": 21091, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2520.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3520.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1110, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 5499, "avg_search_time_ms": 785.5714285714286, "search_nodes": 44141, "safety_nodes": 459, "corridor_nodes": 8, "corridor_branch_probes": 4, "corridor_max_depth": 1, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 4, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 10, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 6, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 10, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 10, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 23, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 7961760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 44608, "avg_nodes": 6372.571428571428, "eval_calls": 25920, "avg_eval_calls": 3702.8571428571427, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 25920, "pattern_eval_ns": 586773, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.637847222222224, "pattern_frame_queries": 25920, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 586773, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.637847222222224, "pattern_frame_updates": 88210, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 944547121, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10707.936979934248, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16677, "avg_candidate_generations": 2382.4285714285716, "candidate_moves_total": 1088981, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.29837500749535, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 368, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 16670, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1088613, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 596512, "avg_legality_checks": 85216.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 596512, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1593855, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 227693.57142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3564199888, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2236.213387039599, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8633, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1233.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14209017, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1645.8956330360245, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 111751, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1771, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9010372, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6828, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5086894, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48529, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6932.714285714285, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 441803361, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9103.904077973995, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 64313, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9187.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 181857383, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2827.692426103587, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1496807915, "stage_ordering_ns": 482162156, "stage_eval_ns": 945133894, "stage_threat_ns": 2529525047, "stage_proof_ns": 18116795, "tactical_annotations": 184766, "root_tactical_annotations": 359, "search_tactical_annotations": 184407, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 88245, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 551732974, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 169523, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1891795950, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33430, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1283910296, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 44119, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68238131, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 28, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 126591, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 88238, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11643829, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 21668, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 124908769, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 113557, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 482476853, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49541, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5987572, "child_limit_applications": 16670, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16670, "child_cap_hits": 16670, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16670, "child_moves_before_total": 1088581, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1088581, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 146866, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 146866, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 65.30179964007199, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.810197960407919, "tt_hits": 7326, "tt_cutoffs": 1516, "beta_cutoffs": 13131, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2357.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3500.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1600, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12511, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 82, 96, 141, 98, 95, 128, 80, 100, 99, 142, 157, 114, 156, 86 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7092, "avg_search_time_ms": 886.5, "search_nodes": 79259, "safety_nodes": 66, "corridor_nodes": 753, "corridor_branch_probes": 858, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 235, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 743, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 743, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 34, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 235, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 34, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 274, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 12023120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1967120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 80078, "avg_nodes": 10009.75, "eval_calls": 50556, "avg_eval_calls": 6319.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50556, "pattern_eval_ns": 1065364, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.072948809241236, "pattern_frame_queries": 50556, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1065364, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.072948809241236, "pattern_frame_updates": 158446, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1763892858, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11132.454325132852, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27152, "avg_candidate_generations": 3394.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1777682, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.47149381261049, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 416, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 27144, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1777266, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 539538, "avg_legality_checks": 67442.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 269, "root_legality_checks": 416, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 539122, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 269, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2262880, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 282860.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4306969824, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1903.3133988545571, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13999, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1749.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 54642152, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3903.2896635473962, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 444, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2603467, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6861, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38987116, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6650, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12978659, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 44, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 72910, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46163, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5770.375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 343044797, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7431.163420921517, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 59878, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7484.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 133948810, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2237.0287918768163, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1151419013, "stage_ordering_ns": 652987157, "stage_eval_ns": 1764958222, "stage_threat_ns": 3371454662, "stage_proof_ns": 120035685, "tactical_annotations": 279980, "root_tactical_annotations": 1619, "search_tactical_annotations": 278361, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 160008, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 837140675, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 278495, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2392052086, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54873, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1804149460, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 80000, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104221215, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1554, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5818584, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 160000, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18112776, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 37968, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 63926693, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 131394, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 429761820, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110618, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14109326, "child_limit_applications": 27144, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27144, "child_cap_hits": 27144, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27144, "child_moves_before_total": 1776997, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1776997, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 246056, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 246056, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 65.46555408193339, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.064839375184203, "tt_hits": 15942, "tt_cutoffs": 1523, "beta_cutoffs": 21091, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3056.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4056.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1808, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 5410, "avg_search_time_ms": 772.8571428571429, "search_nodes": 59271, "safety_nodes": 459, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 0, "corridor_proof_completed": 0, "corridor_proof_checks": 0, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 0, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 0, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59730, "avg_nodes": 8532.857142857143, "eval_calls": 33346, "avg_eval_calls": 4763.714285714285, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33346, "pattern_eval_ns": 685833, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.567174473699993, "pattern_frame_queries": 33346, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 685833, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.567174473699993, "pattern_frame_updates": 118470, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 967078995, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8163.070777412003, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23133, "avg_candidate_generations": 3304.714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 1519587, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.68914537673453, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 368, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 23126, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1519219, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 795229, "avg_legality_checks": 113604.14285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 795229, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 32, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2079461, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 297065.85714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3419504999, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1644.4189138435393, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9580, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1368.5714285714287, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14472099, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1510.65751565762, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 118110, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2305, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9160442, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7241, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5193547, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52675, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7525.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 347657461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6600.046720455624, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 69763, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9966.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 142936947, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2048.8933532101546, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1423906934, "stage_ordering_ns": 494248004, "stage_eval_ns": 967764828, "stage_threat_ns": 2483292249, "stage_proof_ns": 0, "tactical_annotations": 252390, "root_tactical_annotations": 359, "search_tactical_annotations": 252031, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 118477, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 557690905, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 216592, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1831054012, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46302, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1320631574, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 59235, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 71063674, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 0, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 118470, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12189608, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 26520, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 120695448, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 143766, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 389622790, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 82104, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11294050, "child_limit_applications": 23126, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23126, "child_cap_hits": 23126, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23126, "child_moves_before_total": 1519187, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1519187, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 200097, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 200097, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 65.69173224941625, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.652469082418058, "tt_hits": 12164, "tt_cutoffs": 2763, "beta_cutoffs": 18433, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2452.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3595.714285714286, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 20, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1601, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16748, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 80, 99, 85, 141, 155, 128, 83, 143, 158, 84, 69, 111, 52, 67, 55, 41, 159, 129, 79, 81, 157, 156, 126, 144, 114, 142, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 6285, "avg_search_time_ms": 419.0, "search_nodes": 110608, "safety_nodes": 1647, "corridor_nodes": 3038, "corridor_branch_probes": 3580, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1232, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 3000, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2967, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 33, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 94, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1232, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 94, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 5, "corridor_proof_unknown": 89, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 557, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 264640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 20880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 115293, "avg_nodes": 7686.2, "eval_calls": 106747, "avg_eval_calls": 7116.466666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 106747, "pattern_eval_ns": 2329467, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.82231819161194, "pattern_frame_queries": 106747, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2329467, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.82231819161194, "pattern_frame_updates": 221128, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3352419221, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15160.53697858254, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3832, "avg_candidate_generations": 255.46666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 328864, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.8204592901879, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1149, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 3817, "search_candidate_moves_total": 327715, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 104095, "avg_legality_checks": 6939.666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 721, "root_legality_checks": 1149, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 102946, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 715, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1479417, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 98627.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3379900296, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2284.616369826763, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28615, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1907.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 249276997, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8711.409994757994, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 729, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6554580, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26160, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 233696137, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 430, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2646657, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1296, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6379623, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 8494, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 566.2666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 86642526, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10200.438662585355, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11088, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 739.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 46488061, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4192.646194083694, "stage_move_gen_ns": 256562644, "stage_ordering_ns": 126850, "stage_eval_ns": 3354748688, "stage_threat_ns": 2127011895, "stage_proof_ns": 512486232, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 227331, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1324606449, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 182069, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 574038104, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1659, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 112594951, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 113658, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159583381, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6188, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 41242252, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 227316, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27541709, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 193, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3492, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6534.933333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7068.266666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1830, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 10450, "avg_search_time_ms": 696.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 68400, "safety_nodes": 976, "corridor_nodes": 2195, "corridor_branch_probes": 2537, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 843, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 79, "corridor_plies_followed": 2168, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1988, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 180, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 843, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 79, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 453, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 179120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 16560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 71571, "avg_nodes": 4771.4, "eval_calls": 45228, "avg_eval_calls": 3015.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 45228, "pattern_eval_ns": 1025766, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.679888564605996, "pattern_frame_queries": 45228, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1025766, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.679888564605996, "pattern_frame_updates": 136666, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1482972073, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10851.068100332197, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21738, "avg_candidate_generations": 1449.2, "candidate_moves_total": 1923680, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.49388168184745, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1193, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 21723, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1922487, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1429537, "avg_legality_checks": 95302.46666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6527, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1429537, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6527, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3241317, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 216087.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6819368300, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2103.8881109129406, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65729, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4381.933333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 201144061, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3060.2026654901183, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8447, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 65992124, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9134, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 49077137, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 47863, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 85042808, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 285, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1031992, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 130575, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8705.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1348568097, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10327.91956346927, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 171362, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11424.133333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 674426230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3935.681364596585, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3523120530, "stage_ordering_ns": 774018529, "stage_eval_ns": 1483997839, "stage_threat_ns": 4472839281, "stage_proof_ns": 124343666, "tactical_annotations": 468878, "root_tactical_annotations": 2060, "search_tactical_annotations": 466818, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 141155, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 912702637, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 533677, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3390431836, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44763, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1616499452, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70570, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 109750716, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4474, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26448518, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 141140, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18490934, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 162812, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 731798699, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 195354, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 915999749, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110712, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15014640, "child_limit_applications": 21723, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21723, "child_cap_hits": 21723, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21723, "child_moves_before_total": 1915960, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1915960, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 348960, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 348960, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.19960410624684, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.06407954702389, "tt_hits": 10030, "tt_cutoffs": 1382, "beta_cutoffs": 18864, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5705.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6238.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1836, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1602, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18492, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 83, 128, 67, 82, 111, 69, 35, 51, 66, 125, 65, 64, 80, 50, 52, 94, 36, 79, 38, 24, 37, 34, 39 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10625, "avg_search_time_ms": 885.4166666666666, "search_nodes": 121063, "safety_nodes": 380, "corridor_nodes": 1038, "corridor_branch_probes": 1178, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 285, "corridor_neutral_exits": 84, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1002, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1002, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 145, "corridor_proof_active": 36, "corridor_proof_quiet": 109, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 84, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 285, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 145, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 144, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1225, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 858880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 122481, "avg_nodes": 10206.75, "eval_calls": 82675, "avg_eval_calls": 6889.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82675, "pattern_eval_ns": 1810186, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.89520411248866, "pattern_frame_queries": 82675, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1810186, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.89520411248866, "pattern_frame_updates": 242022, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2332066802, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9635.763699167845, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35206, "avg_candidate_generations": 2933.8333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2630086, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.70561836050673, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 769, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 35194, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2629317, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 851647, "avg_legality_checks": 70970.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 129, "root_legality_checks": 769, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 850878, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 129, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2986917, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 248909.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6236682664, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2087.999989286612, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12231, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1019.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 34945285, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2857.107758973101, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 143, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1257086, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3511, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 23018971, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8565, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10643857, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 25371, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60340, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5028.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 483956965, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8020.499917136228, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81014, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6751.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 208186635, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2569.7612141111413, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1960396352, "stage_ordering_ns": 1021482729, "stage_eval_ns": 2333876988, "stage_threat_ns": 4848988746, "stage_proof_ns": 408526710, "tactical_annotations": 419246, "root_tactical_annotations": 2716, "search_tactical_annotations": 416530, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 244328, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1363006056, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 490607, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3265664991, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 71605, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2316547690, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 122158, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 169785802, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2294, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12548301, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 244316, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28520161, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 126655, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 106588651, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 213229, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 665257874, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79362, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9463435, "child_limit_applications": 35194, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35194, "child_cap_hits": 35194, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35194, "child_moves_before_total": 2629188, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2629188, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 563108, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 563108, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.70557481388873, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000113655736772, "tt_hits": 15109, "tt_cutoffs": 3142, "beta_cutoffs": 29794, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4672.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5339.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1209, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7856, "avg_search_time_ms": 714.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 241057, "safety_nodes": 908, "corridor_nodes": 963, "corridor_branch_probes": 1124, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 379, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 945, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 945, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 379, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 353, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 143360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 242928, "avg_nodes": 22084.363636363636, "eval_calls": 236675, "avg_eval_calls": 21515.909090909092, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 236675, "pattern_eval_ns": 5160498, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.804153374881167, "pattern_frame_queries": 236675, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5160498, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.804153374881167, "pattern_frame_updates": 482050, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4434464036, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9199.17858313453, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4361, "avg_candidate_generations": 396.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 329774, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.6188947489108, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 718, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 4350, "search_candidate_moves_total": 329056, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 9331, "avg_legality_checks": 848.2727272727273, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9331, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1220509, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 110955.36363636363, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2838598345, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2325.749621674236, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3028, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 275.27272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21983680, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7260.132100396301, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3014, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21934970, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 48710, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23794319, "stage_ordering_ns": 169281, "stage_eval_ns": 4439624534, "stage_threat_ns": 3276715262, "stage_proof_ns": 87322923, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 484073, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2796558060, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59493, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 79156238, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 688, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 31132207, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 242031, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 329531143, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2012, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12565130, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 484062, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58904691, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 175, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4011, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5601.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6328.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1871, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1603, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12409, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 81, 100, 142, 72, 86, 129, 126, 130, 131, 66, 110, 109, 94, 78, 158 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4205, "avg_search_time_ms": 467.22222222222223, "search_nodes": 91539, "safety_nodes": 510, "corridor_nodes": 374, "corridor_branch_probes": 445, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 116, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 366, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 366, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 116, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 287, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 101360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 92423, "avg_nodes": 10269.222222222223, "eval_calls": 88931, "avg_eval_calls": 9881.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 88931, "pattern_eval_ns": 1936932, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.780166646051434, "pattern_frame_queries": 88931, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1936932, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.780166646051434, "pattern_frame_updates": 183028, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2482718560, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13564.692615337544, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2592, "avg_candidate_generations": 288.0, "candidate_moves_total": 189345, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.04976851851852, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 628, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 2583, "search_candidate_moves_total": 188717, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 86742, "avg_legality_checks": 9638.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 628, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 86114, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 787787, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 87531.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1992919433, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2529.769383094669, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8261, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 917.8888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 67787933, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8205.77811402978, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 186061, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8126, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 66818248, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 387462, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 80, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 396162, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 124.11111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 11837809, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10597.859444941809, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1496, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 166.22222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 6138581, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4103.329545454545, "stage_move_gen_ns": 229769322, "stage_ordering_ns": 92800, "stage_eval_ns": 2484655492, "stage_threat_ns": 1342505463, "stage_proof_ns": 127722638, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 183851, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1093235222, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26858, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 91544572, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 337, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19647787, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91921, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 130321029, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 814, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4267401, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 183842, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23137239, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2213, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5173.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6062.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1832, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 8197, "avg_search_time_ms": 1024.625, "search_nodes": 58573, "safety_nodes": 553, "corridor_nodes": 1046, "corridor_branch_probes": 1222, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 448, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1034, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1034, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 42, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 448, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 42, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 42, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 296, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 192720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 16560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 60172, "avg_nodes": 7521.5, "eval_calls": 39822, "avg_eval_calls": 4977.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39822, "pattern_eval_ns": 895184, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.47963437295967, "pattern_frame_queries": 39822, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 895184, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.47963437295967, "pattern_frame_updates": 117076, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1337435924, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11423.655779152004, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17594, "avg_candidate_generations": 2199.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1421882, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.81630101170853, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 555, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 17586, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1421327, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1035409, "avg_legality_checks": 129426.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 690, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1035409, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 690, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2416681, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 302085.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5421198896, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2243.241410844046, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14977, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1872.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 41773433, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2789.1722641383453, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 696, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7647235, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1858, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14654422, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12423, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19471776, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 95404, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11925.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 939483567, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9847.423242212066, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 127258, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15907.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 413812770, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3251.762325354791, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2633327392, "stage_ordering_ns": 621251606, "stage_eval_ns": 1338331108, "stage_threat_ns": 3490197441, "stage_proof_ns": 68490339, "tactical_annotations": 258444, "root_tactical_annotations": 981, "search_tactical_annotations": 257463, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 119236, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 757166058, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 312741, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2606756412, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35794, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1359475227, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 59614, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93401616, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2152, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11125492, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 119228, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15721186, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52289, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 288965296, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 161937, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 905378281, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 44218, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6026677, "child_limit_applications": 17586, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17586, "child_cap_hits": 17586, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17586, "child_moves_before_total": 1420637, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1420637, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 281423, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 281423, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.78226998749005, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00267258046173, "tt_hits": 5208, "tt_cutoffs": 1131, "beta_cutoffs": 15024, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2375.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3353.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 291, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1604, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13340, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 142, 110, 141, 96, 98, 140, 68, 125, 83, 53, 95, 124, 82, 156, 84, 70, 81, 85, 80 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9152, "avg_search_time_ms": 762.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 90448, "safety_nodes": 900, "corridor_nodes": 1719, "corridor_branch_probes": 1956, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 536, "corridor_neutral_exits": 79, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 1680, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1680, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 106, "corridor_proof_active": 39, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 79, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 536, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 106, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 105, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 776, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24290080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 93067, "avg_nodes": 7755.583333333333, "eval_calls": 67644, "avg_eval_calls": 5637.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67644, "pattern_eval_ns": 1482367, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.91424220921294, "pattern_frame_queries": 67644, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1482367, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.91424220921294, "pattern_frame_updates": 180792, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2120214898, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11727.371222177973, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21899, "avg_candidate_generations": 1824.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1638336, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.81327914516645, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 742, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 21887, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1637594, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 704042, "avg_legality_checks": 58670.166666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 731, "root_legality_checks": 742, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 703300, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 730, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2439301, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 203275.08333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5562956754, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2280.5536315526456, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11933, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 994.4166666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61189125, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5127.7235397636805, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 755, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8497132, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4490, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37420847, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6498, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14096505, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 190, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1174641, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 57297, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4774.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 495223372, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8643.09426322495, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72177, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6014.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 193784457, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2684.8505341036616, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1783306752, "stage_ordering_ns": 721523322, "stage_eval_ns": 2121697265, "stage_threat_ns": 4051911939, "stage_proof_ns": 430326110, "tactical_annotations": 280565, "root_tactical_annotations": 1377, "search_tactical_annotations": 279188, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 184376, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1133341777, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 393920, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2726380092, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45129, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1738219599, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92182, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 140667033, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3572, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20732251, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 184364, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23823778, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 78564, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 95840468, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 148352, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 598655090, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53649, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6967008, "child_limit_applications": 21887, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21887, "child_cap_hits": 21887, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21887, "child_moves_before_total": 1636864, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1636864, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 350195, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 350195, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.7870425366656, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000137067665737, "tt_hits": 8177, "tt_cutoffs": 865, "beta_cutoffs": 17463, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4751.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5417.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1125, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4175, "avg_search_time_ms": 379.54545454545456, "search_nodes": 111777, "safety_nodes": 518, "corridor_nodes": 3625, "corridor_branch_probes": 3944, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1447, "corridor_neutral_exits": 68, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 3600, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3600, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 68, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1447, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 92, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 705, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 302720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 115920, "avg_nodes": 10538.181818181818, "eval_calls": 107737, "avg_eval_calls": 9794.272727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107737, "pattern_eval_ns": 2314908, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.48665732292527, "pattern_frame_queries": 107737, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2314908, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.48665732292527, "pattern_frame_updates": 223490, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2125847622, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9512.048064790371, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4019, "avg_candidate_generations": 365.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 297477, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.01766608609107, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 678, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 4008, "search_candidate_moves_total": 296799, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 10186, "avg_legality_checks": 926.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10186, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 658325, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 59847.72727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1551993230, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2357.4879125052216, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2969, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 269.90909090909093, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16464471, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5545.460087571573, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 35640, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2874, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16149221, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 79, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 111270, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 168340, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 27812282, "stage_ordering_ns": 154190, "stage_eval_ns": 2128162530, "stage_threat_ns": 1867883993, "stage_proof_ns": 137867634, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 230885, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1366743571, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 217724, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 265779552, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2352, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 110704378, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115437, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 162430690, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7384, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 44389890, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 230874, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28540290, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 316, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3524, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5958.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6685.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1605, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14351, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 145, 129, 98, 125, 99, 100, 140, 127, 79, 109, 108, 157, 173, 143, 159, 115, 101, 171 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9688, "avg_search_time_ms": 880.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 196091, "safety_nodes": 426, "corridor_nodes": 4593, "corridor_branch_probes": 4987, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2421, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 4573, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4573, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 81, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 61, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2421, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 81, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 77, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 599, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 213760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 11, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 8, "total_nodes": 201110, "avg_nodes": 18282.727272727272, "eval_calls": 190481, "avg_eval_calls": 17316.454545454544, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 190481, "pattern_eval_ns": 4092280, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.483927530829845, "pattern_frame_queries": 190481, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4092280, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.483927530829845, "pattern_frame_updates": 392120, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5063117075, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12912.162284504744, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5590, "avg_candidate_generations": 508.1818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 426629, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.32003577817531, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 5579, "search_candidate_moves_total": 425907, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 186542, "avg_legality_checks": 16958.363636363636, "illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 185820, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2083882, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 189443.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4878931531, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2341.270537871146, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30453, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2768.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 134085060, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4403.016451581125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 154, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 483483, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28576, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 127126969, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 172, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2057393, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1551, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4417215, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 11743, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1067.5454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 115207166, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9810.709869709613, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1458.2727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 58479386, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3645.6197244560813, "stage_move_gen_ns": 475364909, "stage_ordering_ns": 190750, "stage_eval_ns": 5067209355, "stage_threat_ns": 3551358904, "stage_proof_ns": 565073610, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 401439, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2386470305, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 224544, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 771759764, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2144, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 148579540, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 200714, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 286104865, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9308, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 56830940, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 401428, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50193030, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 452, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4723, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5416.545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6143.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1779, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 4653, "avg_search_time_ms": 465.3, "search_nodes": 37577, "safety_nodes": 842, "corridor_nodes": 177, "corridor_branch_probes": 221, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 59, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 172, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 172, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 46, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 41, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 59, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 46, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 46, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 298, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 81040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 38596, "avg_nodes": 3859.6, "eval_calls": 25452, "avg_eval_calls": 2545.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 25452, "pattern_eval_ns": 558953, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.96106396353921, "pattern_frame_queries": 25452, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 558953, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.96106396353921, "pattern_frame_updates": 75064, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 789450198, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10517.028109346691, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11545, "avg_candidate_generations": 1154.5, "candidate_moves_total": 830409, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.92802078822001, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 645, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 11535, "search_candidate_moves_total": 829764, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 507663, "avg_legality_checks": 50766.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 28, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 507663, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 28, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1377528, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 137752.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3003752295, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2180.538105214558, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7208, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 720.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15518883, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2153.0081853496117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 62, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 301071, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1697, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8680214, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5449, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6537598, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50943, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5094.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 505367027, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9920.244724496006, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 71867, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7186.7, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 239261402, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3329.224845895891, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1278649379, "stage_ordering_ns": 365262863, "stage_eval_ns": 790009151, "stage_threat_ns": 2105577260, "stage_proof_ns": 81839182, "tactical_annotations": 157816, "root_tactical_annotations": 556, "search_tactical_annotations": 157260, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 75510, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 478743089, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 165278, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1553851167, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 23389, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 894760865, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37750, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 57238842, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 436, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2381829, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 75500, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9888605, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32346, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 175772259, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 97178, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 473148709, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 28292, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3473728, "child_limit_applications": 11535, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11535, "child_cap_hits": 11535, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11535, "child_moves_before_total": 829736, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 829736, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 185082, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 185082, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.9320329432163, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.04525357607282, "tt_hits": 3587, "tt_cutoffs": 545, "beta_cutoffs": 9888, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4941.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5741.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1865, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1606, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9766, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 129, 81, 109, 125, 80, 127, 143, 126, 128, 140, 155, 98, 154, 84 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5746, "avg_search_time_ms": 638.4444444444445, "search_nodes": 59974, "safety_nodes": 410, "corridor_nodes": 1142, "corridor_branch_probes": 1423, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 384, "corridor_neutral_exits": 34, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1120, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1120, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 71, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 384, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 71, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 558, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24230080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 61526, "avg_nodes": 6836.222222222223, "eval_calls": 44079, "avg_eval_calls": 4897.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44079, "pattern_eval_ns": 961424, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.811384105810024, "pattern_frame_queries": 44079, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 961424, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.811384105810024, "pattern_frame_updates": 119874, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1332400891, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11115.011520429785, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15001, "avg_candidate_generations": 1666.7777777777778, "candidate_moves_total": 1020572, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.03359776014932, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 491, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 14992, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1020081, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 357106, "avg_legality_checks": 39678.444444444445, "illegal_moves_skipped": 450, "root_legality_checks": 491, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 356615, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 450, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1513347, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 168149.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3429035814, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2265.862233843263, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8308, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 923.1111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50561265, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6085.852792489167, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 456, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4755048, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3352, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32482561, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4351, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12046203, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 149, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1277453, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 33694, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3743.777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 325697919, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9666.34768801567, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 46146, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5127.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 148964256, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3228.107658301911, "stage_move_gen_ns": 920358342, "stage_ordering_ns": 447459920, "stage_eval_ns": 1333362315, "stage_threat_ns": 2734782931, "stage_proof_ns": 284637441, "tactical_annotations": 166750, "root_tactical_annotations": 1315, "search_tactical_annotations": 165435, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 122265, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 756320198, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 234702, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1851874012, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30816, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1229876435, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61128, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93329278, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2382, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13236228, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 122256, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15619115, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 40689, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 66877755, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 85100, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 360894584, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 40961, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4404100, "child_limit_applications": 14992, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14992, "child_cap_hits": 14992, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14992, "child_moves_before_total": 1019631, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1019631, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 239872, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 239872, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.01167289220918, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 6526, "tt_cutoffs": 866, "beta_cutoffs": 12104, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4241.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5130.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1214, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 4012, "avg_search_time_ms": 501.5, "search_nodes": 111012, "safety_nodes": 547, "corridor_nodes": 428, "corridor_branch_probes": 528, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 156, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 418, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 418, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 48, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 156, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 48, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 48, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 311, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 183520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 111987, "avg_nodes": 13998.375, "eval_calls": 108412, "avg_eval_calls": 13551.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 108412, "pattern_eval_ns": 2343611, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.617634579197876, "pattern_frame_queries": 108412, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2343611, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.617634579197876, "pattern_frame_updates": 221978, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2333173064, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10510.830190379227, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2585, "avg_candidate_generations": 323.125, "candidate_moves_total": 168809, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.30328820116054, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 434, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 2577, "search_candidate_moves_total": 168375, "search_candidate_moves_max": 88, "legality_checks": 4982, "avg_legality_checks": 622.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4982, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 615417, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 76927.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1475639387, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2397.7878202909574, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6757, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 844.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 55297291, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8183.704454639633, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6745, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 55281101, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16190, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14342754, "stage_ordering_ns": 86352, "stage_eval_ns": 2335516675, "stage_threat_ns": 1564506696, "stage_proof_ns": 82754208, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 222918, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1342378968, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27816, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 32621100, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 378, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10700320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111455, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 155181349, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 932, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5510723, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 222910, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28814556, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 108, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2316, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4461.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5461.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1607, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19547, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 95, 141, 96, 159, 175, 144, 142, 156, 93, 171, 126, 186, 201, 94, 100, 86, 80, 64, 110, 125, 68, 124, 116, 115, 84, 52, 132 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 13966, "avg_search_time_ms": 872.875, "search_nodes": 296610, "safety_nodes": 565, "corridor_nodes": 4943, "corridor_branch_probes": 5361, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2250, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 4915, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4915, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 129, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 101, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2250, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 129, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 126, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 996, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 205920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 302118, "avg_nodes": 18882.375, "eval_calls": 287706, "avg_eval_calls": 17981.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 287706, "pattern_eval_ns": 6215358, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.603157389835456, "pattern_frame_queries": 287706, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 6215358, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.603157389835456, "pattern_frame_updates": 593128, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7528720389, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12693.247307495178, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 8874, "avg_candidate_generations": 554.625, "candidate_moves_total": 804776, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.68920441739914, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1267, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 8858, "search_candidate_moves_total": 803509, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 275753, "avg_legality_checks": 17234.5625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "root_legality_checks": 1267, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 274486, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 86, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2873658, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 179603.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6780469982, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2359.525727139416, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30306, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1894.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 226683486, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7479.822015442486, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 111, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 883352, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28587, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 219472134, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 288, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2036818, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1320, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4291182, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 10860, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 678.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 113518265, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10452.87891344383, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15382, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 961.375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 61278254, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3983.7637498374725, "stage_move_gen_ns": 692522752, "stage_ordering_ns": 343850, "stage_eval_ns": 7534935747, "stage_threat_ns": 4945276186, "stage_proof_ns": 745045294, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 603232, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3489082813, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 272847, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 894321427, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2831, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 180074013, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 301608, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 424307987, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10088, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 63395105, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 603216, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 74168854, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 827, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 7756, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6114.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6614.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1752, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 5564, "avg_search_time_ms": 370.93333333333334, "search_nodes": 53369, "safety_nodes": 1750, "corridor_nodes": 275, "corridor_branch_probes": 358, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 90, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 263, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 263, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 62, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 90, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 62, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 62, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 338, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 348720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 20320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 55394, "avg_nodes": 3692.9333333333334, "eval_calls": 38187, "avg_eval_calls": 2545.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38187, "pattern_eval_ns": 845225, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.133841359625002, "pattern_frame_queries": 38187, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 845225, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.133841359625002, "pattern_frame_updates": 106598, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1047157019, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9823.420880316704, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14506, "avg_candidate_generations": 967.0666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1110333, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.54301668275197, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1186, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 14491, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1109147, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 534941, "avg_legality_checks": 35662.73333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 57, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 534941, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 57, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1523724, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 101581.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3403632748, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2233.759360619115, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4761, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 317.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16731957, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3514.378701953371, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 671053, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1292, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10477561, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3397, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5583343, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45688, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3045.866666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 450188228, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9853.53326912975, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63821, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4254.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 205372107, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3217.9393459832972, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1354531507, "stage_ordering_ns": 485521404, "stage_eval_ns": 1048002244, "stage_threat_ns": 2525748705, "stage_proof_ns": 109588971, "tactical_annotations": 192804, "root_tactical_annotations": 646, "search_tactical_annotations": 192158, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 107263, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 667748339, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 204512, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1755052598, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29442, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1125985155, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 53624, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80325504, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 650, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3938150, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 107248, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13844804, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 45950, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 206835282, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 111087, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 408487159, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 35767, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4839310, "child_limit_applications": 14491, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14491, "child_cap_hits": 14491, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14491, "child_moves_before_total": 1109090, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1109090, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 232799, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 232799, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.53647091298048, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.06507487405976, "tt_hits": 4842, "tt_cutoffs": 621, "beta_cutoffs": 12002, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5900.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6433.933333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1853, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1608, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4076, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 95, 129, 97, 115, 116, 101, 157, 87 ], "move_count": 15, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 3341, "avg_search_time_ms": 556.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 42858, "safety_nodes": 295, "corridor_nodes": 57, "corridor_branch_probes": 67, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 49, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 49, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 48, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 409, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 25748160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 43210, "avg_nodes": 7201.666666666667, "eval_calls": 33192, "avg_eval_calls": 5532.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33192, "pattern_eval_ns": 734241, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.121023138105567, "pattern_frame_queries": 33192, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 734241, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.121023138105567, "pattern_frame_updates": 85672, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 798820442, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9324.171748062377, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9225, "avg_candidate_generations": 1537.5, "candidate_moves_total": 636470, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.9940379403794, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 325, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 9219, "search_candidate_moves_total": 636145, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 222773, "avg_legality_checks": 37128.833333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "root_legality_checks": 325, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 222448, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 12, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 799182, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 133197.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1884350988, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2357.8496362530686, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3049, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 508.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10513929, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3448.320432928829, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 160981, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1152, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7475340, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1865, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2827418, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 50190, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 15630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2605.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 149886019, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9589.636532309662, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20542, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3423.6666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 65317719, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3179.7156557297244, "stage_move_gen_ns": 588341711, "stage_ordering_ns": 290244325, "stage_eval_ns": 799554683, "stage_threat_ns": 1545123918, "stage_proof_ns": 98713107, "tactical_annotations": 65638, "root_tactical_annotations": 733, "search_tactical_annotations": 64905, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 85880, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 513893467, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 75071, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 954941838, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18686, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 734501473, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42937, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 62814368, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 202, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 882133, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 85874, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10903459, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 10766, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 19890484, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 41267, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 190632181, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 13605, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1688653, "child_limit_applications": 9219, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9219, "child_cap_hits": 9219, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9219, "child_moves_before_total": 636133, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 636133, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 147504, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 147504, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.00238637596269, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 3564, "tt_cutoffs": 425, "beta_cutoffs": 7037, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2802.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4135.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 990, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 7, "search_move_count": 5, "total_time_ms": 730, "avg_search_time_ms": 146.0, "search_nodes": 20255, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 130, "corridor_branch_probes": 153, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 40, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 127, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 127, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 35, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 40, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 35, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 35, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 276, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 64240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 3920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 20585, "avg_nodes": 4117.0, "eval_calls": 19068, "avg_eval_calls": 3813.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 19068, "pattern_eval_ns": 415161, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.772655758338576, "pattern_frame_queries": 19068, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 415161, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.772655758338576, "pattern_frame_updates": 40482, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 341986792, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8447.87293117929, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1178, "avg_candidate_generations": 235.6, "candidate_moves_total": 74808, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.50424448217318, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 5, "root_candidate_moves_total": 266, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 1173, "search_candidate_moves_total": 74542, "search_candidate_moves_max": 83, "legality_checks": 3985, "avg_legality_checks": 797.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3985, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 102388, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20477.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 248334418, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2425.4250302769856, "renju_forbidden_checks": 215, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 43.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2185726, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10166.167441860465, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 195, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 1935946, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 249780, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11399695, "stage_ordering_ns": 44501, "stage_eval_ns": 342401953, "stage_threat_ns": 305064025, "stage_proof_ns": 63501417, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 40811, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 251748265, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 9703, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 17416686, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9682798, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 20403, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 29032271, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 324, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1626717, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 40806, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5240086, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 107, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1020, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3644.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5244.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1966, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1609, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 35785, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 83, 95, 98, 139, 153, 140, 110, 94, 53, 93, 96, 92, 91, 68, 158, 174, 84, 70, 157, 172, 82, 81, 66, 114, 156, 155, 50, 34, 52, 170, 185, 171, 173, 123, 187, 107 ], "move_count": 44, "black_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 29185, "avg_search_time_ms": 1459.25, "search_nodes": 632628, "safety_nodes": 799, "corridor_nodes": 10367, "corridor_branch_probes": 11289, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4771, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 10322, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 10322, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 18, "corridor_proof_completed": 18, "corridor_proof_checks": 192, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 147, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4771, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 192, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 192, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1539, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 263200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 643794, "avg_nodes": 32189.7, "eval_calls": 618235, "avg_eval_calls": 30911.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 618235, "pattern_eval_ns": 13371528, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.62855224954912, "pattern_frame_queries": 618235, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 13371528, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.62855224954912, "pattern_frame_updates": 1265138, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 15960317167, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12615.47528174792, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14354, "avg_candidate_generations": 717.7, "candidate_moves_total": 1357121, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.54653755050857, "candidate_moves_max": 140, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1709, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 14334, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1355412, "search_candidate_moves_max": 140, "legality_checks": 595943, "avg_legality_checks": 29797.15, "illegal_moves_skipped": 273, "root_legality_checks": 1709, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 594234, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6097074, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 304853.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14179047423, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2325.549505057672, "renju_forbidden_checks": 64460, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3223.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 536840269, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8328.269764194849, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 399, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3121722, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 60800, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 523091930, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 864, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3631845, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2397, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6994772, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21892, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1094.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 222100685, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10145.289831902064, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 30591, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1529.55, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 120106268, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3926.1962014971723, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1484322939, "stage_ordering_ns": 546641, "stage_eval_ns": 15973688695, "stage_threat_ns": 10296587632, "stage_proof_ns": 1331526084, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1286186, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 7337438531, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 542776, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1764164839, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 5709, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 346197478, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 643083, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 890210663, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 21028, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 148767786, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1286166, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 156005813, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 955, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 12829, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.45, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4647.95, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5047.95, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 416, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 6580, "avg_search_time_ms": 329.0, "search_nodes": 64727, "safety_nodes": 2744, "corridor_nodes": 255, "corridor_branch_probes": 313, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 64, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 241, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 241, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 18, "corridor_proof_completed": 18, "corridor_proof_checks": 67, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 67, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 342, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 363760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 67726, "avg_nodes": 3386.3, "eval_calls": 46533, "avg_eval_calls": 2326.65, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46533, "pattern_eval_ns": 1031876, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.17514452109256, "pattern_frame_queries": 46533, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1031876, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.17514452109256, "pattern_frame_updates": 129270, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1242847135, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9614.350854800032, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17361, "avg_candidate_generations": 868.05, "candidate_moves_total": 1393880, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.2880018432118, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1742, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 17341, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1392138, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 629235, "avg_legality_checks": 31461.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 629235, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 36, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1781220, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 89061.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3967583210, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2227.4526504306036, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8605, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 430.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 22606708, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2627.159558396281, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 406, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1465607, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2185, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11425669, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5966, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9513479, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 201953, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53161, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2658.05, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 512773829, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9645.676887191737, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72951, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3647.55, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 229684950, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3148.4825430768597, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1581185247, "stage_ordering_ns": 586961732, "stage_eval_ns": 1243879011, "stage_threat_ns": 2997133395, "stage_proof_ns": 119795864, "tactical_annotations": 273204, "root_tactical_annotations": 715, "search_tactical_annotations": 272489, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 129906, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 809570690, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 282638, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2064235755, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35192, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1314155913, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64943, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 97873640, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 616, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3795740, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 129886, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16745063, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 75487, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 245854427, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 153621, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 490662299, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 44096, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4912507, "child_limit_applications": 17341, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17341, "child_cap_hits": 17341, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17341, "child_moves_before_total": 1392102, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1392102, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 285558, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 285558, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.27806931549507, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.46721642350499, "tt_hits": 5647, "tt_cutoffs": 761, "beta_cutoffs": 14395, "depth_sum": 92, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 92, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 18 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6366.85, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6766.85, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1612, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1610, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18420, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 97, 127, 126, 143, 159, 158, 113, 95, 79, 173, 188, 129, 98, 140, 101, 157, 115, 125, 70, 84, 100, 99, 85, 130, 55 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8830, "avg_search_time_ms": 679.2307692307693, "search_nodes": 86528, "safety_nodes": 1113, "corridor_nodes": 367, "corridor_branch_probes": 414, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 129, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 355, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 355, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 129, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 446, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 252400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 17520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 88008, "avg_nodes": 6769.846153846154, "eval_calls": 62305, "avg_eval_calls": 4792.692307692308, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62305, "pattern_eval_ns": 1376488, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.092737340502367, "pattern_frame_queries": 62305, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1376488, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.092737340502367, "pattern_frame_updates": 172942, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2166893895, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12529.59891177389, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22619, "avg_candidate_generations": 1739.923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 1752046, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.45903886113445, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 916, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 22606, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1751130, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 730502, "avg_legality_checks": 56192.46153846154, "illegal_moves_skipped": 205, "root_legality_checks": 916, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 729586, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 205, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2308426, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 177571.23076923078, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5411441170, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2344.2125370273943, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8766, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 674.3076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32334750, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3688.6550308008214, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 249, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2392630, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3479, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22273007, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5004, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7582403, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 86710, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50287, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3868.230769230769, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 464107586, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9229.17624833456, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 69710, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5362.307692307692, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 191126094, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2741.731372830297, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1874515921, "stage_ordering_ns": 771978110, "stage_eval_ns": 2168270383, "stage_threat_ns": 3811253967, "stage_proof_ns": 160884163, "tactical_annotations": 276728, "root_tactical_annotations": 1369, "search_tactical_annotations": 275359, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 173791, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1080744439, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 293397, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2562725200, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45720, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1801000847, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86889, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 132511853, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 836, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5697256, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 173778, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22816523, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56262, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 58895355, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 167680, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 651507494, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 52786, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6758696, "child_limit_applications": 22606, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22606, "child_cap_hits": 22606, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22606, "child_moves_before_total": 1750925, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1750925, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 361707, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 361707, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.4539945147306, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00048659647881, "tt_hits": 7732, "tt_cutoffs": 1561, "beta_cutoffs": 18529, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5119.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5734.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9578, "avg_search_time_ms": 798.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 264532, "safety_nodes": 517, "corridor_nodes": 1266, "corridor_branch_probes": 1410, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 16, "corridor_depth_exits": 401, "corridor_neutral_exits": 36, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1243, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1243, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 90, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 52, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 401, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 90, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 89, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 699, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 241760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 266315, "avg_nodes": 22192.916666666668, "eval_calls": 258634, "avg_eval_calls": 21552.833333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 258634, "pattern_eval_ns": 5635782, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.790568912053327, "pattern_frame_queries": 258634, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5635782, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.790568912053327, "pattern_frame_updates": 528994, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5661815196, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10702.985659572698, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5875, "avg_candidate_generations": 489.5833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 481775, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.00425531914894, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 865, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 5863, "search_candidate_moves_total": 480910, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 10847, "avg_legality_checks": 903.9166666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10847, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1509340, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 125778.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3741554139, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2478.933930724688, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6678, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 556.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61999704, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9284.172506738545, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6658, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 61756233, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 243471, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 31648143, "stage_ordering_ns": 221181, "stage_eval_ns": 5667450978, "stage_threat_ns": 3710417493, "stage_proof_ns": 151886216, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 531672, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3137678384, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 86163, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 106477811, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1088, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 43763234, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 265830, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 382587213, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2666, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16427847, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 531660, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67246238, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 434, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5169, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5744.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6411.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1960, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1611, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11277, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 80, 129, 81, 145, 161, 128, 125, 95, 79, 127, 130, 78, 96, 83, 64, 48, 109, 108, 94, 49, 124 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5232, "avg_search_time_ms": 436.0, "search_nodes": 153421, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 798, "corridor_branch_probes": 937, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 315, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 785, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 785, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 78, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 65, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 315, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 78, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 75, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 574, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 177040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 155192, "avg_nodes": 12932.666666666666, "eval_calls": 148379, "avg_eval_calls": 12364.916666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 148379, "pattern_eval_ns": 2993796, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.176682684207336, "pattern_frame_queries": 148379, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2993796, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.176682684207336, "pattern_frame_updates": 306774, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3035826534, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9895.970760233919, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5020, "avg_candidate_generations": 418.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 388017, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.29422310756972, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 838, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 5008, "search_candidate_moves_total": 387179, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 143985, "avg_legality_checks": 11998.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 181, "root_legality_checks": 838, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 143147, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 181, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1352339, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 112694.91666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2388569709, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1766.2507026714457, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16799, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1399.9166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 94092418, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5601.072563843086, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 183, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1509357, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16429, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 91095202, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 544221, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 137, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 943638, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 157.08333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 13803275, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7322.692307692308, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2506, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 208.83333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 7364620, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2938.7948922585792, "stage_move_gen_ns": 283335609, "stage_ordering_ns": 163700, "stage_eval_ns": 3038820330, "stage_threat_ns": 1696608278, "stage_proof_ns": 178915815, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 308512, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1368334815, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 49828, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 117467035, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 648, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 26993864, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 154250, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 172669936, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1726, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7587474, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 308500, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30549018, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 267, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4487, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5781.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6448.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1748, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6033, "avg_search_time_ms": 548.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 53507, "safety_nodes": 765, "corridor_nodes": 1362, "corridor_branch_probes": 1581, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 599, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1343, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1343, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 76, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 599, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 76, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 75, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 569, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 468240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 55634, "avg_nodes": 5057.636363636364, "eval_calls": 35176, "avg_eval_calls": 3197.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35176, "pattern_eval_ns": 728153, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.700278599044804, "pattern_frame_queries": 35176, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 728153, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.700278599044804, "pattern_frame_updates": 106914, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1005442026, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9404.212974914417, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17121, "avg_candidate_generations": 1556.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 1392652, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.34174405700601, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 770, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 17110, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1391882, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 1010821, "avg_legality_checks": 91892.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1901, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1010821, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1901, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2420983, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 220089.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3964191239, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1637.4304317708963, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17133, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1557.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 67616834, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3946.584602813284, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1937, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16189867, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4499, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 36355761, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10697, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15071206, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97372, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8852.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 704042254, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7230.438462802448, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 130179, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11834.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 324439579, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2492.2574224721347, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1926856454, "stage_ordering_ns": 428594318, "stage_eval_ns": 1006170179, "stage_threat_ns": 2540051255, "stage_proof_ns": 86368242, "tactical_annotations": 307661, "root_tactical_annotations": 1346, "search_tactical_annotations": 306315, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 109763, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 529467040, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 348915, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1908980738, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35129, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 972553505, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 54876, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68602565, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2838, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12482087, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 109752, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11106268, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 83056, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 308022063, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 153145, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 582639179, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 71460, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9412557, "child_limit_applications": 17110, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17110, "child_cap_hits": 17110, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17110, "child_moves_before_total": 1389981, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1389981, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 273940, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 273940, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.23793103448276, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01052016364699, "tt_hits": 7184, "tt_cutoffs": 1171, "beta_cutoffs": 14830, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5165.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5893.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1874, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1612, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12107, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 129, 98, 96, 128, 143, 124, 127, 95, 157, 171, 141, 172, 109, 108, 125, 173, 93 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9677, "avg_search_time_ms": 967.7, "search_nodes": 102432, "safety_nodes": 167, "corridor_nodes": 2524, "corridor_branch_probes": 2628, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 963, "corridor_neutral_exits": 33, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 2501, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2501, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 101, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 78, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 33, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 963, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 101, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 100, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 827, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26102800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 105123, "avg_nodes": 10512.3, "eval_calls": 77473, "avg_eval_calls": 7747.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77473, "pattern_eval_ns": 1678162, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.661249725710892, "pattern_frame_queries": 77473, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1678162, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.661249725710892, "pattern_frame_updates": 204780, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2238230606, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10929.927756616857, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23914, "avg_candidate_generations": 2391.4, "candidate_moves_total": 1731892, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.42167767834741, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 576, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 23904, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1731316, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 638994, "avg_legality_checks": 63899.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 114, "root_legality_checks": 576, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 638418, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 114, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2573407, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 257340.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5770660462, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2242.4204418500453, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12150, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1215.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 45435788, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3739.5710288065843, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 182, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1185605, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4757, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29819114, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7036, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12746106, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 175, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1684963, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 63351, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6335.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 564477488, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8910.316932645104, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 80691, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8069.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 238368251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2954.0872092302734, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1614955856, "stage_ordering_ns": 746532936, "stage_eval_ns": 2239908768, "stage_threat_ns": 4544288694, "stage_proof_ns": 496070520, "tactical_annotations": 294311, "root_tactical_annotations": 2017, "search_tactical_annotations": 292294, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 209994, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1284379162, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 438199, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3036923382, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49680, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1906568513, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 104992, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 158378454, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5204, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 29949865, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 209984, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26882764, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 84645, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 123766851, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 144475, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 617418625, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 65191, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7775067, "child_limit_applications": 23904, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23904, "child_cap_hits": 23904, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23904, "child_moves_before_total": 1731202, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1731202, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 382492, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 382492, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.42310910307899, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001171352074966, "tt_hits": 9671, "tt_cutoffs": 1013, "beta_cutoffs": 18850, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3538.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4338.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1144, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2422, "avg_search_time_ms": 269.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 68066, "safety_nodes": 449, "corridor_nodes": 28, "corridor_branch_probes": 22, "corridor_max_depth": 3, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 20, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 15, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 75, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 75, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 74, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 568, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 192560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68543, "avg_nodes": 7615.888888888889, "eval_calls": 64381, "avg_eval_calls": 7153.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64381, "pattern_eval_ns": 1388328, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.564250322300058, "pattern_frame_queries": 64381, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1388328, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.564250322300058, "pattern_frame_updates": 136080, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1315478470, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9666.949368018812, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3668, "avg_candidate_generations": 407.55555555555554, "candidate_moves_total": 255356, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.61723009814612, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 516, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 3659, "search_candidate_moves_total": 254840, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 7053, "avg_legality_checks": 783.6666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7053, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 383292, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 42588.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 913730612, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2383.9021216200704, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1034, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 114.88888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 7272951, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7033.801740812379, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1030, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7269241, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3710, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 203001, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7518.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.4444444444444446, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 68110, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2197.0967741935483, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20120164, "stage_ordering_ns": 122550, "stage_eval_ns": 1316866798, "stage_threat_ns": 932171874, "stage_proof_ns": 137480320, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136279, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 809242380, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3410, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9423884, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 328, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7034794, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68135, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 95154737, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 190, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 973044, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136270, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17377829, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 231, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3226, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5480.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6368.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1613, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6135, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 84, 85, 99, 126, 69, 114, 83, 111, 67, 52, 51, 35, 115 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1800, "avg_search_time_ms": 225.0, "search_nodes": 37214, "safety_nodes": 411, "corridor_nodes": 510, "corridor_branch_probes": 582, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 215, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 500, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 500, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 215, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 426, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 181440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 38135, "avg_nodes": 4766.875, "eval_calls": 35213, "avg_eval_calls": 4401.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35213, "pattern_eval_ns": 761565, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.627381932808905, "pattern_frame_queries": 35213, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 761565, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.627381932808905, "pattern_frame_updates": 74384, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 925695771, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12444.823765863626, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1987, "avg_candidate_generations": 248.375, "candidate_moves_total": 125917, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.3704076497232, "candidate_moves_max": 85, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 444, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 1979, "search_candidate_moves_total": 125473, "search_candidate_moves_max": 85, "legality_checks": 32316, "avg_legality_checks": 4039.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 444, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 31872, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 379927, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 47490.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 884120288, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2327.079381038989, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5649, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 706.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 34266103, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6065.870596565764, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 115591, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5553, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33702192, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 216600, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 231720, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1033, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 129.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 9308570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9011.200387221685, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1305, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 163.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4297468, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3293.078927203065, "stage_move_gen_ns": 80710283, "stage_ordering_ns": 73450, "stage_eval_ns": 926457336, "stage_threat_ns": 616765392, "stage_proof_ns": 161505910, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 75504, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 452187032, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 31021, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 95748965, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 449, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 22682474, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37748, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 52967405, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1112, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6490080, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 75496, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9371910, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 224, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1677, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5213.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6213.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1822, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 4327, "avg_search_time_ms": 618.1428571428571, "search_nodes": 34352, "safety_nodes": 430, "corridor_nodes": 122, "corridor_branch_probes": 159, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 43, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 118, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 118, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 43, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 281, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 268560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34904, "avg_nodes": 4986.285714285715, "eval_calls": 23139, "avg_eval_calls": 3305.5714285714284, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23139, "pattern_eval_ns": 509682, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.026967457539218, "pattern_frame_queries": 23139, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 509682, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.026967457539218, "pattern_frame_updates": 68644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 821715712, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11970.685158207563, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10574, "avg_candidate_generations": 1510.5714285714287, "candidate_moves_total": 729093, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.9514847739739, "candidate_moves_max": 92, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 383, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 10567, "search_candidate_moves_total": 728710, "search_candidate_moves_max": 92, "legality_checks": 467793, "avg_legality_checks": 66827.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 758, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 467793, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 758, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1277839, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 182548.42857142858, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2808061633, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2197.5081626089045, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7145, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1020.7142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44455751, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6221.93855843247, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 768, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8451046, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2836, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27404526, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3541, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8600179, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48681, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6954.428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 477937584, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9817.743760399335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65044, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9292.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 218013804, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3351.789619334604, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1193251931, "stage_ordering_ns": 319714813, "stage_eval_ns": 822225394, "stage_threat_ns": 1896813480, "stage_proof_ns": 69148715, "tactical_annotations": 162312, "root_tactical_annotations": 556, "search_tactical_annotations": 161756, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 68963, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 425627051, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 156912, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1403767899, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21378, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 776779907, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34478, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 52310613, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 312, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1635396, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 68956, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8871728, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 35218, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 171500298, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 92095, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 448409212, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 34999, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4600793, "child_limit_applications": 10567, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10567, "child_cap_hits": 10567, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10567, "child_moves_before_total": 727952, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 727952, "child_moves_before_max": 92, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 92, "child_moves_after_total": 169073, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 169073, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.8891833065203, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000094634238668, "tt_hits": 3534, "tt_cutoffs": 616, "beta_cutoffs": 9070, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 4.285714285714286, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 4.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3426.4285714285716, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4569.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1863, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1614, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21214, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 84, 141, 83, 81, 126, 98, 85, 86, 97, 127, 155, 143, 111, 128, 158, 125, 142, 110, 69, 55, 99, 54, 67, 52, 51, 115, 35 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 19602, "avg_search_time_ms": 1400.142857142857, "search_nodes": 214586, "safety_nodes": 434, "corridor_nodes": 5053, "corridor_branch_probes": 5710, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2263, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 5011, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5011, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 138, "corridor_proof_active": 42, "corridor_proof_quiet": 96, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2263, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 138, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 136, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1111, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 69427040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1983600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 220073, "avg_nodes": 15719.5, "eval_calls": 173025, "avg_eval_calls": 12358.92857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 173025, "pattern_eval_ns": 3727298, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.541962144198816, "pattern_frame_queries": 173025, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3727298, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.541962144198816, "pattern_frame_updates": 429048, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5869664335, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13680.670542689862, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39594, "avg_candidate_generations": 2828.1428571428573, "candidate_moves_total": 3106018, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.44668384098601, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 941, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 39580, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3105077, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1215902, "avg_legality_checks": 86850.14285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1030, "root_legality_checks": 941, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1214961, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1030, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5347809, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 381986.35714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11640725385, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2176.727961862512, "renju_forbidden_checks": 58741, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4195.785714285715, "renju_forbidden_ns": 268233880, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4566.382594780477, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1919, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11890404, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 32818, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 197153337, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23498, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 56076408, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 506, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3113731, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 149778, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10698.42857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1333719644, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8904.643165217856, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 192384, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13741.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 581205784, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3021.0713157019295, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2995977165, "stage_ordering_ns": 1301272128, "stage_eval_ns": 5873391633, "stage_threat_ns": 8592719993, "stage_proof_ns": 780429175, "tactical_annotations": 718050, "root_tactical_annotations": 3261, "search_tactical_annotations": 714789, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 439360, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2648205903, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 915708, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5465291680, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 81855, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2994332619, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 219673, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 333123280, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10298, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 66573579, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 439346, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55744969, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 217700, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 292696014, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 336082, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1420993266, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 164268, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23780582, "child_limit_applications": 39580, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39580, "child_cap_hits": 39580, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39580, "child_moves_before_total": 3104047, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3104047, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 635598, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 635598, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.42463365336029, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.058564931783728, "tt_hits": 16033, "tt_cutoffs": 1919, "beta_cutoffs": 28407, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3389.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3961.285714285714, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 299, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 1598, "avg_search_time_ms": 122.92307692307692, "search_nodes": 45514, "safety_nodes": 1210, "corridor_nodes": 268, "corridor_branch_probes": 317, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 104, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 263, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 263, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 52, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 52, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 306, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 41760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 3200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 46992, "avg_nodes": 3614.769230769231, "eval_calls": 43205, "avg_eval_calls": 3323.4615384615386, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 43205, "pattern_eval_ns": 927526, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.46802453419743, "pattern_frame_queries": 43205, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 927526, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.46802453419743, "pattern_frame_updates": 90952, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 818606244, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9000.420485530829, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2284, "avg_candidate_generations": 175.69230769230768, "candidate_moves_total": 168036, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.57092819614711, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 877, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 2271, "search_candidate_moves_total": 167159, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 4918, "avg_legality_checks": 378.3076923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4918, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 248180, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 19090.76923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 581640069, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2343.621843017165, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1402, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 107.84615384615384, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12419872, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8858.681883024252, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1398, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12370502, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 49370, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13809024, "stage_ordering_ns": 80200, "stage_eval_ns": 819533770, "stage_threat_ns": 650550166, "stage_proof_ns": 92263865, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 91595, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 547621491, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 16661, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 24297459, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 349, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11185722, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 45791, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 63193390, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 630, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4011882, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 91582, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11425944, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 136, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2023, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6284.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6899.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1496, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1615, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10529, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 126, 141, 99, 143, 98, 155, 169, 140, 142, 158, 100, 173, 128, 156, 101, 97, 102 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5293, "avg_search_time_ms": 529.3, "search_nodes": 99765, "safety_nodes": 586, "corridor_nodes": 3014, "corridor_branch_probes": 3297, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 1296, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 2995, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2995, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 78, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 59, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1296, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 78, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 77, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 585, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 170720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 103365, "avg_nodes": 10336.5, "eval_calls": 96165, "avg_eval_calls": 9616.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 96165, "pattern_eval_ns": 2046088, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.276847085738055, "pattern_frame_queries": 96165, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2046088, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.276847085738055, "pattern_frame_updates": 199474, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2486714298, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12466.35801157043, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3582, "avg_candidate_generations": 358.2, "candidate_moves_total": 239291, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.8037409268565, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 614, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 3572, "search_candidate_moves_total": 238677, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 91424, "avg_legality_checks": 9142.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 614, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 90810, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1110667, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 111066.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2605787428, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2346.1464399320407, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8036, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 803.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 71706456, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8923.15281234445, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 427941, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7511, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 68680159, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 88, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 884461, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 395, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1713895, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 6658, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 665.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 67918558, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10201.045058576148, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9114, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 911.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 35578564, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3903.726574500768, "stage_move_gen_ns": 242848552, "stage_ordering_ns": 124240, "stage_eval_ns": 2488760386, "stage_threat_ns": 2066617267, "stage_proof_ns": 479745315, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 205630, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1273897235, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 177486, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 581699687, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1752, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 117559214, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 150241716, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6146, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 34624464, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 205620, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26154165, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 237, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3174, "depth_sum": 28, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 28, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5105.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5905.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1755, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5226, "avg_search_time_ms": 580.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 49928, "safety_nodes": 819, "corridor_nodes": 309, "corridor_branch_probes": 404, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 91, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 297, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 297, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 91, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 49, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 312, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2335600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 51056, "avg_nodes": 5672.888888888889, "eval_calls": 35976, "avg_eval_calls": 3997.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35976, "pattern_eval_ns": 783852, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.78819212808539, "pattern_frame_queries": 35976, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 783852, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.78819212808539, "pattern_frame_updates": 99772, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 881602264, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8836.169105560679, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13360, "avg_candidate_generations": 1484.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 975558, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.02080838323353, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 555, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 13351, "search_candidate_moves_total": 975003, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 560366, "avg_legality_checks": 62262.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 62, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 560366, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 62, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1460585, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 162287.22222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3238381487, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2217.1811205783983, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4086, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 454.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15096252, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3694.6284875183555, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 62, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 672804, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 888, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10170688, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3136, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4252760, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45677, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5075.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 461971134, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10113.867679576155, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 63912, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7101.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 217901427, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3409.397718738265, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1418663141, "stage_ordering_ns": 440302465, "stage_eval_ns": 882386116, "stage_threat_ns": 2368164665, "stage_proof_ns": 87372737, "tactical_annotations": 154919, "root_tactical_annotations": 609, "search_tactical_annotations": 154310, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 100475, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 619189877, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 166171, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1650378025, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27098, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1044303528, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50233, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 76480940, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 694, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4299812, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 100466, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12838453, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32808, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 211185152, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 85083, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 379325889, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 37028, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4977558, "child_limit_applications": 13351, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13351, "child_cap_hits": 13351, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13351, "child_moves_before_total": 974941, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 974941, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 213629, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 213629, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.02381844056625, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00097370983447, "tt_hits": 4870, "tt_cutoffs": 559, "beta_cutoffs": 10998, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4310.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5199.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1785, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1616, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 4462, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 141, 99, 125, 97, 109, 108, 93, 157, 77 ], "move_count": 15, "black_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 3415, "avg_search_time_ms": 569.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 43786, "safety_nodes": 295, "corridor_nodes": 57, "corridor_branch_probes": 67, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 52, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 49, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 49, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 48, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 409, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 25749520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 44138, "avg_nodes": 7356.333333333333, "eval_calls": 33906, "avg_eval_calls": 5651.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33906, "pattern_eval_ns": 729663, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.520173420633515, "pattern_frame_queries": 33906, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 729663, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.520173420633515, "pattern_frame_updates": 87528, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 823946951, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9413.524255095512, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9436, "avg_candidate_generations": 1572.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 651064, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.99788045782111, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 325, "root_candidate_moves_max": 69, "search_candidate_generations": 9430, "search_candidate_moves_total": 650739, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 240577, "avg_legality_checks": 40096.166666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 325, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 240252, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 833383, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 138897.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1939062730, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2326.7366024984913, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3381, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 563.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 11087795, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3279.4424726412303, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 137360, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1246, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8152677, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2105, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2751078, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 46680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16079, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2679.8333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 152948537, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9512.316499782324, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21162, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3527.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 67111287, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3171.3111709668274, "stage_move_gen_ns": 622931155, "stage_ordering_ns": 295891945, "stage_eval_ns": 824676614, "stage_threat_ns": 1555848184, "stage_proof_ns": 97598590, "tactical_annotations": 67199, "root_tactical_annotations": 733, "search_tactical_annotations": 66466, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 87736, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 516634657, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 76884, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 961857226, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 19108, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 736741567, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43865, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 64064096, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 202, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 887773, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 87730, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10786122, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 11057, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 18870546, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 42367, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 196442112, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 13775, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1618310, "child_limit_applications": 9430, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9430, "child_cap_hits": 9430, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9430, "child_moves_before_total": 650729, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 650729, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 150880, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 150880, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.00625662778367, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 3621, "tt_cutoffs": 428, "beta_cutoffs": 7204, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 3.6666666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2761.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4094.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1013, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 7, "search_move_count": 5, "total_time_ms": 1041, "avg_search_time_ms": 208.2, "search_nodes": 31696, "safety_nodes": 200, "corridor_nodes": 130, "corridor_branch_probes": 153, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 40, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 127, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 127, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 35, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 40, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 35, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 35, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 276, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 55600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 3680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 32026, "avg_nodes": 6405.2, "eval_calls": 30280, "avg_eval_calls": 6056.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 30280, "pattern_eval_ns": 648475, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.415951122853368, "pattern_frame_queries": 30280, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 648475, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.415951122853368, "pattern_frame_updates": 63364, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 501628287, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7916.61332933527, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1407, "avg_candidate_generations": 281.4, "candidate_moves_total": 88619, "avg_candidate_moves": 62.98436389481166, "candidate_moves_max": 83, "root_candidate_generations": 5, "root_candidate_moves_total": 266, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 1402, "search_candidate_moves_total": 88353, "search_candidate_moves_max": 83, "legality_checks": 4089, "avg_legality_checks": 817.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4089, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 130991, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26198.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 313823406, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2395.763113496347, "renju_forbidden_checks": 452, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 90.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 2815718, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6229.4646017699115, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 432, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 2569347, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 246371, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11605577, "stage_ordering_ns": 49832, "stage_eval_ns": 502276762, "stage_threat_ns": 457903103, "stage_proof_ns": 62764982, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 63693, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 386347386, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 9703, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 17281367, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 9536783, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 31844, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 44612956, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 324, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1600025, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 63688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8061369, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 107, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1221, "depth_sum": 14, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 14, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3473.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5073.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1967, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1617, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16354, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 84, 125, 83, 139, 153, 126, 129, 99, 85, 127, 124, 86, 98, 81, 70, 56, 115, 116, 100, 55, 130 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7631, "avg_search_time_ms": 635.9166666666666, "search_nodes": 170390, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 1010, "corridor_branch_probes": 1184, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 413, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 996, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 996, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 78, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 413, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 78, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 75, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 574, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 175280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 172373, "avg_nodes": 14364.416666666666, "eval_calls": 164958, "avg_eval_calls": 13746.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 164958, "pattern_eval_ns": 3522967, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.356751415511827, "pattern_frame_queries": 164958, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3522967, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.356751415511827, "pattern_frame_updates": 340712, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4438991852, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13028.5750193712, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5410, "avg_candidate_generations": 450.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 418931, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.43641404805915, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 838, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 5398, "search_candidate_moves_total": 418093, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 160821, "avg_legality_checks": 13401.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 162, "root_legality_checks": 838, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 159983, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 162, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1491746, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 124312.16666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3597798600, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2411.8037521132956, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19282, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1606.8333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 142499182, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7390.269785291982, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 212, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1778256, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18803, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 138296132, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 62, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 797223, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 205, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1627571, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2310, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 192.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 23201497, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10043.938095238096, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3062, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 255.16666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 11967724, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3908.4663618549966, "stage_move_gen_ns": 412821064, "stage_ordering_ns": 179531, "stage_eval_ns": 4442514819, "stage_threat_ns": 2490479695, "stage_proof_ns": 260104014, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 342872, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1999769785, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 61575, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 195403292, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 723, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 42766081, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 171430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 240045644, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2148, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12446387, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 342860, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42814587, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 267, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4875, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5643.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6310.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1748, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8709, "avg_search_time_ms": 791.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 56638, "safety_nodes": 765, "corridor_nodes": 1226, "corridor_branch_probes": 1428, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 540, "corridor_neutral_exits": 17, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1208, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1208, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 76, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 58, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 540, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 76, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 75, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 569, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 459680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 58629, "avg_nodes": 5329.909090909091, "eval_calls": 36766, "avg_eval_calls": 3342.3636363636365, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36766, "pattern_eval_ns": 803173, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.845536637110374, "pattern_frame_queries": 36766, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 803173, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.845536637110374, "pattern_frame_updates": 113176, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1387919024, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12263.36877076412, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18602, "avg_candidate_generations": 1691.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 1496184, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.43135146758414, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 770, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 18591, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1495414, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1106629, "avg_legality_checks": 100602.63636363637, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4776, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1106629, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4776, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2659031, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 241730.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5765810446, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2168.3878247376583, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25083, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2280.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 158606286, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6323.258222700634, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4812, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 51766721, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7240, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 74499522, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13031, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32340043, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 112323, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10211.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1083807596, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9649.026432698556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 147648, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13422.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 489671005, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3316.4757057325533, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2787058253, "stage_ordering_ns": 626605498, "stage_eval_ns": 1388722197, "stage_threat_ns": 3730698400, "stage_proof_ns": 125992419, "tactical_annotations": 335339, "root_tactical_annotations": 1346, "search_tactical_annotations": 333993, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 115755, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 740770947, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 373203, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2859187911, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 38037, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1443788815, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57872, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90199560, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2568, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15370188, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 115744, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15119914, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 90292, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 445997909, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 174955, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 911842265, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 70092, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10049880, "child_limit_applications": 18591, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18591, "child_cap_hits": 18591, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18591, "child_moves_before_total": 1490638, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1490638, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 297624, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 297624, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.18062503361841, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.009036630627723, "tt_hits": 7255, "tt_cutoffs": 1231, "beta_cutoffs": 16197, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4455.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5183.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1868, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1618, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12075, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 125, 96, 98, 126, 141, 130, 127, 99, 157, 173, 143, 172, 115, 116, 129, 171, 101 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9849, "avg_search_time_ms": 984.9, "search_nodes": 103055, "safety_nodes": 167, "corridor_nodes": 2666, "corridor_branch_probes": 2800, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1025, "corridor_neutral_exits": 34, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 2641, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2641, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 101, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 76, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1025, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 101, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 100, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 827, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26166960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 105888, "avg_nodes": 10588.8, "eval_calls": 77739, "avg_eval_calls": 7773.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 77739, "pattern_eval_ns": 1688464, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.719651654896513, "pattern_frame_queries": 77739, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1688464, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.719651654896513, "pattern_frame_updates": 206026, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2218696470, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10769.012017900654, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24222, "avg_candidate_generations": 2422.2, "candidate_moves_total": 1756349, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.51048633473701, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 576, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 24212, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1755773, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 654816, "avg_legality_checks": 65481.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "root_legality_checks": 576, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 654240, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2601229, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 260122.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5863010381, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2253.9385732667133, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11912, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1191.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44120459, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3703.866605104097, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 168, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1024288, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4428, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28408800, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7132, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12897735, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 184, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1789636, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 63306, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6330.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 544714565, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8604.469797491549, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 79838, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7983.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 217432246, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2723.4179964427967, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1675068678, "stage_ordering_ns": 776091901, "stage_eval_ns": 2220384934, "stage_threat_ns": 4633699803, "stage_proof_ns": 506645186, "tactical_annotations": 295891, "root_tactical_annotations": 2017, "search_tactical_annotations": 293874, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 211520, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1308154435, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 448126, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3101961059, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50362, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1973321824, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 105755, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 157696506, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5484, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 31545423, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 211510, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27187649, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 85113, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 124551937, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 145417, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 595855362, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 65361, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7154731, "child_limit_applications": 24212, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24212, "child_cap_hits": 24212, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24212, "child_moves_before_total": 1755677, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1755677, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 387406, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 387406, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.51267966297704, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00057822567322, "tt_hits": 9711, "tt_cutoffs": 1062, "beta_cutoffs": 19141, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3369.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4169.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 998, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2215, "avg_search_time_ms": 246.11111111111111, "search_nodes": 64160, "safety_nodes": 449, "corridor_nodes": 30, "corridor_branch_probes": 23, "corridor_max_depth": 3, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 21, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 16, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 75, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 66, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 75, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 74, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 568, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 198880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 64639, "avg_nodes": 7182.111111111111, "eval_calls": 60441, "avg_eval_calls": 6715.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60441, "pattern_eval_ns": 1289794, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.3397197266756, "pattern_frame_queries": 60441, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1289794, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.3397197266756, "pattern_frame_updates": 128268, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1174911409, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9159.817015935385, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3702, "avg_candidate_generations": 411.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 255465, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.00729335494327, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 516, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 3693, "search_candidate_moves_total": 254949, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 6891, "avg_legality_checks": 765.6666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6891, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 342471, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 38052.333333333336, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 806796117, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2355.8085706526977, "renju_forbidden_checks": 593, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 65.88888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5333304, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8993.767284991569, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 589, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 5329494, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3810, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 27, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 201921, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7478.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.4444444444444446, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 67270, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2170.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19547713, "stage_ordering_ns": 123232, "stage_eval_ns": 1176201203, "stage_threat_ns": 869889899, "stage_proof_ns": 136071912, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 128469, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 754826586, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3614, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9314815, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 328, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6888522, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88601579, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 192, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 958774, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128460, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16188145, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 231, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3276, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5485.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6374.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1970, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1619, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21600, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 81, 129, 96, 130, 131, 111, 95, 157, 172, 98, 67, 109, 65, 49, 66, 64, 51, 36, 93, 94, 79, 107, 37 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 6084, "avg_search_time_ms": 468.0, "search_nodes": 134343, "safety_nodes": 1278, "corridor_nodes": 1275, "corridor_branch_probes": 1491, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 577, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1261, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1261, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 577, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 63, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 354, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 162720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 136896, "avg_nodes": 10530.461538461539, "eval_calls": 130826, "avg_eval_calls": 10063.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 130826, "pattern_eval_ns": 2827367, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.611659761821045, "pattern_frame_queries": 130826, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2827367, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.611659761821045, "pattern_frame_updates": 268610, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3268831472, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12169.433275008376, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3492, "avg_candidate_generations": 268.61538461538464, "candidate_moves_total": 231710, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.35452462772051, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 920, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 3479, "search_candidate_moves_total": 230790, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 129497, "avg_legality_checks": 9961.307692307691, "illegal_moves_skipped": 34, "root_legality_checks": 920, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 128577, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 28, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1030163, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 79243.30769230769, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2566628384, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2491.477935045231, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11990, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 922.3076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 132906861, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11084.809090909092, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 367190, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11541, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 127419617, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 126, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1795261, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 289, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3324793, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3342, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 257.0769230769231, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 35782111, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10706.795631358467, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4523, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 347.9230769230769, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 19434178, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4296.745080698652, "stage_move_gen_ns": 348908695, "stage_ordering_ns": 117132, "stage_eval_ns": 3271658839, "stage_threat_ns": 2190140864, "stage_proof_ns": 254896334, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 271271, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1701844281, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 72138, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 240675949, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 758, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 50281302, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 135629, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 195881998, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2648, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15339779, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 271258, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36398857, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 116, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3220, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5191.076923076923, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5806.461538461538, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 376, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 15502, "avg_search_time_ms": 1192.4615384615386, "search_nodes": 108755, "safety_nodes": 401, "corridor_nodes": 2675, "corridor_branch_probes": 2930, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1058, "corridor_neutral_exits": 45, "corridor_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_plies_followed": 2648, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2648, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 88, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 61, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 45, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1058, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 88, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 85, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 690, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24231680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1984240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 111831, "avg_nodes": 8602.384615384615, "eval_calls": 75402, "avg_eval_calls": 5800.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75402, "pattern_eval_ns": 1686866, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.371634704649743, "pattern_frame_queries": 75402, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1686866, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.371634704649743, "pattern_frame_updates": 217396, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2379378413, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10944.90428986734, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31600, "avg_candidate_generations": 2430.769230769231, "candidate_moves_total": 2743597, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.82268987341772, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 949, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 31587, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2742648, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 2045482, "avg_legality_checks": 157344.76923076922, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16362, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2045482, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16362, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4621551, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 355503.92307692306, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9854439988, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2132.2798315976606, "renju_forbidden_checks": 67036, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5156.615384615385, "renju_forbidden_ns": 522736541, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7797.848036875708, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16364, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 180565685, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22139, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 243451594, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28412, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 97372916, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 121, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1346346, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 199501, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15346.23076923077, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2007786941, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10064.044496017565, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 249270, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19174.615384615383, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 968146416, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3883.9267300517513, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5155757274, "stage_ordering_ns": 1136745522, "stage_eval_ns": 2381065279, "stage_threat_ns": 6607433660, "stage_proof_ns": 137934671, "tactical_annotations": 696820, "root_tactical_annotations": 2952, "search_tactical_annotations": 693868, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 222881, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1407579379, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 758863, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4936932223, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64968, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2378934438, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111434, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 172424801, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5472, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 34097640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 222868, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30305894, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 268059, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1217805710, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 264267, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1227958944, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 164494, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26093723, "child_limit_applications": 31587, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31587, "child_cap_hits": 31587, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31587, "child_moves_before_total": 2726286, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2726286, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 509304, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 509304, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.31038085288252, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.123848418653242, "tt_hits": 14521, "tt_cutoffs": 1709, "beta_cutoffs": 26749, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5412.076923076923, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6027.461538461538, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1622, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1620, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17425, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 97, 127, 128, 141, 155, 156, 111, 99, 85, 171, 186, 125, 96, 144, 95, 93, 109, 114, 64, 80, 94, 98, 79, 124, 49 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 9480, "avg_search_time_ms": 729.2307692307693, "search_nodes": 90962, "safety_nodes": 1116, "corridor_nodes": 375, "corridor_branch_probes": 421, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 135, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 363, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 363, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 135, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 446, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 256720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 92453, "avg_nodes": 7111.7692307692305, "eval_calls": 64914, "avg_eval_calls": 4993.384615384615, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64914, "pattern_eval_ns": 1400269, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.571140277906153, "pattern_frame_queries": 64914, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1400269, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.571140277906153, "pattern_frame_updates": 181810, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2297893925, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12638.985341840384, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24382, "avg_candidate_generations": 1875.5384615384614, "candidate_moves_total": 1930423, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.17410384710033, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 911, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 24369, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1929512, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 795972, "avg_legality_checks": 61228.61538461538, "illegal_moves_skipped": 285, "root_legality_checks": 911, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 795061, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 285, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2525776, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 194290.46153846153, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5829280689, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2307.916730937344, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9297, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 715.1538461538462, "renju_forbidden_ns": 39109417, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4206.67064644509, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 308, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3189362, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27035564, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5330, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8829250, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55241, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59233, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4556.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 549648909, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9279.437290024141, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 82798, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6369.076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 232025937, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2802.313304669195, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2022216611, "stage_ordering_ns": 845513594, "stage_eval_ns": 2299294194, "stage_threat_ns": 4108269183, "stage_proof_ns": 160124736, "tactical_annotations": 282260, "root_tactical_annotations": 1334, "search_tactical_annotations": 280926, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 182675, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1138580289, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 307711, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2796369392, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49252, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1931966022, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91331, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 137348945, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 852, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5668857, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 182662, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23944181, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 56346, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 67856825, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 178168, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 745335342, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 47746, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6357519, "child_limit_applications": 24369, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24369, "child_cap_hits": 24369, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24369, "child_moves_before_total": 1929227, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1929227, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 389918, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 389918, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.16726168492757, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00057450038984, "tt_hits": 8147, "tt_cutoffs": 1623, "beta_cutoffs": 20150, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5034.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5650.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7932, "avg_search_time_ms": 661.0, "search_nodes": 219352, "safety_nodes": 667, "corridor_nodes": 635, "corridor_branch_probes": 758, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 204, "corridor_neutral_exits": 22, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 618, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 618, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 79, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 62, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 204, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 79, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 78, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 578, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 184400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 220654, "avg_nodes": 18387.833333333332, "eval_calls": 214325, "avg_eval_calls": 17860.416666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 214325, "pattern_eval_ns": 4618420, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.548676076052725, "pattern_frame_queries": 214325, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4618420, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.548676076052725, "pattern_frame_updates": 438634, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4707226062, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10731.557658549042, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5004, "avg_candidate_generations": 417.0, "candidate_moves_total": 393797, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.69644284572342, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 851, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 4992, "search_candidate_moves_total": 392946, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 8813, "avg_legality_checks": 734.4166666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8813, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1252321, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 104360.08333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3086682691, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2464.769568664903, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6279, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 523.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 63390714, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10095.670329670329, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6251, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 63131072, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 259642, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 25595401, "stage_ordering_ns": 175191, "stage_eval_ns": 4711844482, "stage_threat_ns": 3040383902, "stage_proof_ns": 137762061, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 440040, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2608357317, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 43373, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 55525345, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 640, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 22592608, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 220014, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 312219455, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1394, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8250654, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 440028, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56031131, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 350, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4428, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5731.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6398.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1957, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1621, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5473, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 80, 79, 95, 128, 65, 110, 81, 113, 67, 52, 53, 39, 109 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1818, "avg_search_time_ms": 227.25, "search_nodes": 38987, "safety_nodes": 411, "corridor_nodes": 381, "corridor_branch_probes": 437, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 144, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 372, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 372, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 144, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 426, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 168320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 39779, "avg_nodes": 4972.375, "eval_calls": 36951, "avg_eval_calls": 4618.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36951, "pattern_eval_ns": 795911, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.53963356878028, "pattern_frame_queries": 36951, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 795911, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.53963356878028, "pattern_frame_updates": 77930, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 954497494, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12248.139278839984, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2022, "avg_candidate_generations": 252.75, "candidate_moves_total": 128277, "avg_candidate_moves": 63.4406528189911, "candidate_moves_max": 84, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 444, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 2014, "search_candidate_moves_total": 127833, "search_candidate_moves_max": 84, "legality_checks": 34006, "avg_legality_checks": 4250.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 444, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 33562, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 383941, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 47992.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 882794648, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2299.2976733404353, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5322, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 665.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32602779, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6126.038895152198, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 115491, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5239, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32118476, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 169581, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 199231, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 814, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 101.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 7189174, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8831.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1024, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 128.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3278414, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3201.576171875, "stage_move_gen_ns": 83653637, "stage_ordering_ns": 73940, "stage_eval_ns": 955293405, "stage_threat_ns": 613835328, "stage_proof_ns": 150069057, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 78794, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 469993826, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 24925, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 74533925, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 409, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18455149, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 39393, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 54757067, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 856, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4843986, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 78786, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9706524, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 224, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1710, "depth_sum": 22, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 22, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5205.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6205.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1818, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 3648, "avg_search_time_ms": 521.1428571428571, "search_nodes": 29592, "safety_nodes": 430, "corridor_nodes": 124, "corridor_branch_probes": 161, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 45, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 120, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 120, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 45, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 281, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 252080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 30146, "avg_nodes": 4306.571428571428, "eval_calls": 19812, "avg_eval_calls": 2830.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 19812, "pattern_eval_ns": 433600, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.885725822733697, "pattern_frame_queries": 19812, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 433600, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.885725822733697, "pattern_frame_updates": 59124, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 667239610, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11285.427406806035, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9143, "avg_candidate_generations": 1306.142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 629924, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.89686098654708, "candidate_moves_max": 92, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 383, "root_candidate_moves_max": 64, "search_candidate_generations": 9136, "search_candidate_moves_total": 629541, "search_candidate_moves_max": 92, "legality_checks": 407942, "avg_legality_checks": 58277.42857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 236, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 407942, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 236, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1093710, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 156244.2857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2367895811, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2165.0124905139387, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5254, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 750.5714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 27231990, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5183.096688237533, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 246, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2500937, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2067, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19084062, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2941, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5646991, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 39934, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5704.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 396546586, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9930.049231231533, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 53815, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7687.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 186763522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3470.4733252810556, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1021168746, "stage_ordering_ns": 268062680, "stage_eval_ns": 667673210, "stage_threat_ns": 1597996900, "stage_proof_ns": 68467415, "tactical_annotations": 140638, "root_tactical_annotations": 556, "search_tactical_annotations": 140082, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 59447, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 368039932, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 134999, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1171454332, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 18516, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 650996266, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 29720, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 44908787, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 316, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1625962, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 59440, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7581354, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 30938, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 153008421, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 77324, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 360252824, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 32376, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4386533, "child_limit_applications": 9136, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9136, "child_cap_hits": 9136, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9136, "child_moves_before_total": 629305, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 629305, "child_moves_before_max": 92, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 92, "child_moves_after_total": 146177, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 146177, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.88189579684763, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00010945709282, "tt_hits": 3357, "tt_cutoffs": 614, "beta_cutoffs": 7839, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 4.285714285714286, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 4.285714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3758.4285714285716, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4901.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1843, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1622, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14599, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 127, 97, 96, 83, 69, 68, 113, 53, 38, 99, 128, 125, 139, 80, 131, 67, 115, 95, 160, 144, 130, 129, 145, 100, 175 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8008, "avg_search_time_ms": 616.0, "search_nodes": 83724, "safety_nodes": 1109, "corridor_nodes": 412, "corridor_branch_probes": 468, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 144, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 399, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 399, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 144, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 446, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 222000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 85245, "avg_nodes": 6557.307692307692, "eval_calls": 60108, "avg_eval_calls": 4623.692307692308, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60108, "pattern_eval_ns": 1318887, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.941954481932523, "pattern_frame_queries": 60108, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1318887, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.941954481932523, "pattern_frame_updates": 167334, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1836202060, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10973.275365436792, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21752, "avg_candidate_generations": 1673.2307692307693, "candidate_moves_total": 1597618, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.44694740713497, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 899, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 21739, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1596719, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 691050, "avg_legality_checks": 53157.692307692305, "illegal_moves_skipped": 226, "root_legality_checks": 899, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 690151, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 226, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2121135, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 163164.23076923078, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4853758901, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2288.2838202188923, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9573, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 736.3846153846154, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33195444, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3467.611407082419, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 290, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2632394, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3125, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22107072, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6126, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8387978, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 68000, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50813, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3908.6923076923076, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 456039326, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8974.85537165686, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 69079, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5313.7692307692305, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 183658795, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2658.6776733884394, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1753110928, "stage_ordering_ns": 671163788, "stage_eval_ns": 1837520947, "stage_threat_ns": 3533318298, "stage_proof_ns": 166804098, "tactical_annotations": 282362, "root_tactical_annotations": 1304, "search_tactical_annotations": 281058, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 168271, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1023046218, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 301531, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2352037118, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44013, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1592851668, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84129, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 124428223, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 924, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5994422, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 168258, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21203136, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62968, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 59518882, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 167710, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 639755175, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 51684, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6609181, "child_limit_applications": 21739, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21739, "child_cap_hits": 21739, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21739, "child_moves_before_total": 1596493, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1596493, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 347843, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 347843, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.4391186347118, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000874005244032, "tt_hits": 7626, "tt_cutoffs": 1821, "beta_cutoffs": 17897, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 4.3076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5255.846153846154, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5871.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6580, "avg_search_time_ms": 548.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 204148, "safety_nodes": 637, "corridor_nodes": 1720, "corridor_branch_probes": 1913, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 13, "corridor_depth_exits": 580, "corridor_neutral_exits": 39, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1695, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1695, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 96, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 71, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 52, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 580, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 96, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 95, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 720, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 283520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 206505, "avg_nodes": 17208.75, "eval_calls": 198377, "avg_eval_calls": 16531.416666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 198377, "pattern_eval_ns": 4256942, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.4588485560322, "pattern_frame_queries": 198377, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4256942, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.4588485560322, "pattern_frame_updates": 408226, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3495392640, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8562.395927745905, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5748, "avg_candidate_generations": 479.0, "candidate_moves_total": 432096, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.17327766179541, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 848, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 5736, "search_candidate_moves_total": 431248, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 15997, "avg_legality_checks": 1333.0833333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 15997, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 919501, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 76625.08333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2246431358, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2443.098330507525, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4418, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 368.1666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44827546, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10146.56994114984, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4388, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44494536, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 333010, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 42189737, "stage_ordering_ns": 206560, "stage_eval_ns": 3499649582, "stage_threat_ns": 2845875952, "stage_proof_ns": 157881823, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 411820, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2350259724, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 114921, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 143774137, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1332, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 60958258, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 205904, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 279713138, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3582, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21902477, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 411808, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50226476, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 399, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5131, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5792.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6459.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1963, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1623, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18425, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 140, 82, 114, 156, 141, 143, 127, 100, 155, 84, 70, 113, 125, 110, 109, 157, 139, 138, 171, 96, 124, 68, 54, 116, 52, 132 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2704, "avg_search_time_ms": 193.14285714285714, "search_nodes": 56705, "safety_nodes": 1496, "corridor_nodes": 395, "corridor_branch_probes": 472, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 136, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 383, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 383, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 70, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 58, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 136, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 70, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 67, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 451, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 130000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 58596, "avg_nodes": 4185.428571428572, "eval_calls": 53933, "avg_eval_calls": 3852.3571428571427, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53933, "pattern_eval_ns": 1159212, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.49355682049951, "pattern_frame_queries": 53933, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1159212, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.49355682049951, "pattern_frame_updates": 113330, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1483712564, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13091.966504897202, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2746, "avg_candidate_generations": 196.14285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 203219, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.00546249089585, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1003, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 2732, "search_candidate_moves_total": 202216, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 50324, "avg_legality_checks": 3594.5714285714284, "illegal_moves_skipped": 55, "root_legality_checks": 1003, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 49321, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 53, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 544299, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 38878.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1324838595, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2434.0272442168734, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6199, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 442.7857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 41573545, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6706.492176157445, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 56, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 566065, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5964, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 39852804, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 353341, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 151, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 801335, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1017, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 72.64285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 10653935, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10475.845624385447, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1370, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97.85714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 5501872, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4015.9649635036494, "stage_move_gen_ns": 131199156, "stage_ordering_ns": 99810, "stage_eval_ns": 1484871776, "stage_threat_ns": 881252921, "stage_proof_ns": 182591936, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 114250, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 691346517, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26939, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 88442580, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 464, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 21761817, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57118, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81682566, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 906, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5383678, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 114236, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14397580, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 198, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2418, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6355.857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6927.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1717, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 15708, "avg_search_time_ms": 1208.3076923076924, "search_nodes": 122999, "safety_nodes": 425, "corridor_nodes": 11685, "corridor_branch_probes": 12759, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 6189, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 11646, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 11646, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 119, "corridor_proof_active": 39, "corridor_proof_quiet": 80, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 6189, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 119, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 117, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 963, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 57851440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1989680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 135109, "avg_nodes": 10393.0, "eval_calls": 89457, "avg_eval_calls": 6881.307692307692, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89457, "pattern_eval_ns": 1972158, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.04587678996613, "pattern_frame_queries": 89457, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1972158, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.04587678996613, "pattern_frame_updates": 245878, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2623124028, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10668.396635729914, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31933, "avg_candidate_generations": 2456.3846153846152, "candidate_moves_total": 2690705, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.26095261954718, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 935, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 31920, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2689770, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1842363, "avg_legality_checks": 141720.23076923078, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4698, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1842363, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4698, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4397622, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 338278.6153846154, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9742264898, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2215.348408298849, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47487, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3652.846153846154, "renju_forbidden_ns": 226087024, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4761.0298397456145, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4724, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 53184292, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10310, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 107115407, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32379, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 64832279, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 955046, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 146818, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11293.692307692309, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1581630533, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10772.729045484886, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 208758, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16058.307692307691, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 791149973, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3789.7947527759416, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4680163795, "stage_ordering_ns": 1130520227, "stage_eval_ns": 2625096186, "stage_threat_ns": 7100521070, "stage_proof_ns": 143671118, "tactical_annotations": 613496, "root_tactical_annotations": 2796, "search_tactical_annotations": 610700, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 269421, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1763655609, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1070936, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4916545836, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69371, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2560975032, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134704, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 214995372, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 23530, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 147400296, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 269408, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34637206, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 197891, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 862045819, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 257590, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1135727252, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 158015, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23286751, "child_limit_applications": 31920, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31920, "child_cap_hits": 31920, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31920, "child_moves_before_total": 2685072, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2685072, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 514533, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 514533, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.11879699248121, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.119454887218044, "tt_hits": 14126, "tt_cutoffs": 1562, "beta_cutoffs": 26144, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4175.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4791.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1754, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1624, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14035, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 114, 156, 113, 111, 66, 82, 126, 140, 84, 70, 99, 69, 97, 170, 184, 96, 129, 144, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11273, "avg_search_time_ms": 1024.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 103763, "safety_nodes": 171, "corridor_nodes": 2715, "corridor_branch_probes": 3228, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1066, "corridor_neutral_exits": 30, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2677, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2677, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 99, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 61, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1066, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 99, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 96, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 819, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 761600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 20000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 106649, "avg_nodes": 9695.363636363636, "eval_calls": 75036, "avg_eval_calls": 6821.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75036, "pattern_eval_ns": 1644295, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.913414894184125, "pattern_frame_queries": 75036, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1644295, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.913414894184125, "pattern_frame_updates": 207432, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2851125701, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13744.869166763085, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26860, "avg_candidate_generations": 2441.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2207464, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.18406552494416, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 26849, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2206678, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 676854, "avg_legality_checks": 61532.181818181816, "illegal_moves_skipped": 446, "root_legality_checks": 786, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 676068, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 446, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3039744, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 276340.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6886910780, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2265.62196684984, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24254, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2204.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 107919599, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4449.558794425662, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 562, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3351434, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11366, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 74885065, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12119, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28160974, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 207, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1522126, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 77925, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7084.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 756489840, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9707.922232916266, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 108057, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9823.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 339689685, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3143.615730586635, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1719429371, "stage_ordering_ns": 956844875, "stage_eval_ns": 2852769996, "stage_threat_ns": 5175548391, "stage_proof_ns": 529792320, "tactical_annotations": 372569, "root_tactical_annotations": 2729, "search_tactical_annotations": 369840, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 212995, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1333536793, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 511813, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3608129765, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 55275, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2196140907, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 106492, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 164977738, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5552, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 30038142, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 212984, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27755591, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 113019, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 200825239, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 170673, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 749691391, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 88877, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11110362, "child_limit_applications": 26849, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26849, "child_cap_hits": 26849, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26849, "child_moves_before_total": 2206232, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2206232, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 432294, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 432294, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.17184997579054, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.100934857909046, "tt_hits": 12930, "tt_cutoffs": 1831, "beta_cutoffs": 21973, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3740.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4467.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 197, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2754, "avg_search_time_ms": 275.4, "search_nodes": 72100, "safety_nodes": 1085, "corridor_nodes": 864, "corridor_branch_probes": 1076, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 362, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 853, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 848, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 362, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 40, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 196, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 50480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 74049, "avg_nodes": 7404.9, "eval_calls": 70448, "avg_eval_calls": 7044.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70448, "pattern_eval_ns": 1506680, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.387122416534183, "pattern_frame_queries": 70448, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1506680, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.387122416534183, "pattern_frame_updates": 144142, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1565639134, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10861.783061148035, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1633, "avg_candidate_generations": 163.3, "candidate_moves_total": 126409, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.40906307409675, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 720, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 1623, "search_candidate_moves_total": 125689, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 3340, "avg_legality_checks": 334.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3340, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 436388, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 43638.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1066034529, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2442.859402641686, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2337, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 233.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 18613655, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7964.764655541292, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2335, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18613195, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 460, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 30, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 235801, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7860.033333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 87041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2290.5526315789475, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9702244, "stage_ordering_ns": 57021, "stage_eval_ns": 1567145814, "stage_threat_ns": 1093040619, "stage_proof_ns": 68645751, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 145940, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 899545420, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 51628, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 58587426, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 480, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 16426933, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 72965, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105591494, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1788, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10520099, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 145930, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18796180, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1502, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5623.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6423.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1590, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1625, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18722, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 144, 160, 142, 95, 125, 50, 65, 78, 127, 94, 62, 157, 143, 141, 113, 158, 97, 82, 81, 49, 129 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 11829, "avg_search_time_ms": 985.75, "search_nodes": 289145, "safety_nodes": 727, "corridor_nodes": 1885, "corridor_branch_probes": 2183, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 855, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1863, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1863, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 71, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 855, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 71, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 68, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 552, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 192720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 291757, "avg_nodes": 24313.083333333332, "eval_calls": 282701, "avg_eval_calls": 23558.416666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 282701, "pattern_eval_ns": 5685663, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.11193098008143, "pattern_frame_queries": 282701, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5685663, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.11193098008143, "pattern_frame_updates": 578222, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6911127812, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11952.377827201317, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6422, "avg_candidate_generations": 535.1666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 523628, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.53659296169418, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 919, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 6410, "search_candidate_moves_total": 522709, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 275554, "avg_legality_checks": 22962.833333333332, "illegal_moves_skipped": 315, "root_legality_checks": 919, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 274635, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 312, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2438370, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 203197.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5421596600, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2223.4511579456766, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39642, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3303.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 335537399, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8464.189470763331, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 326, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2999546, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37991, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 324189260, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 405, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3461074, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 920, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4887519, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 5507, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 458.9166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 55090552, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10003.731977483203, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7645, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 637.0833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 30159290, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3944.9692609548724, "stage_move_gen_ns": 633749689, "stage_ordering_ns": 217850, "stage_eval_ns": 6916813475, "stage_threat_ns": 3935814438, "stage_proof_ns": 311270981, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 582102, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3119396809, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 104828, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 345215761, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1011, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 68740706, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 291045, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 375802997, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3868, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21957787, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 582090, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 73441084, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 441, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5702, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4567.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5234.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6881, "avg_search_time_ms": 625.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 86192, "safety_nodes": 1023, "corridor_nodes": 541, "corridor_branch_probes": 687, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 254, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 533, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 533, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 254, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 431, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26016560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87756, "avg_nodes": 7977.818181818182, "eval_calls": 69008, "avg_eval_calls": 6273.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 69008, "pattern_eval_ns": 1382146, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.028779271968467, "pattern_frame_queries": 69008, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1382146, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.028779271968467, "pattern_frame_updates": 172284, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1463782241, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8496.333037310487, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16129, "avg_candidate_generations": 1466.2727272727273, "candidate_moves_total": 1375846, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.3026226052452, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 845, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 16118, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1375001, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 738064, "avg_legality_checks": 67096.72727272728, "illegal_moves_skipped": 350, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 738064, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 350, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2084734, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 189521.27272727274, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4158324307, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1994.6546211650982, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5038, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 458.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 37361912, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7416.020643112346, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 367, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2903806, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2839, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25340127, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1806, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8905037, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 212942, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73180, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6652.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 718685666, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9820.7934681607, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 104529, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9502.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 348339204, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3332.4647131418074, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1687802580, "stage_ordering_ns": 518721767, "stage_eval_ns": 1465164387, "stage_threat_ns": 3075843428, "stage_proof_ns": 89819706, "tactical_annotations": 282688, "root_tactical_annotations": 1121, "search_tactical_annotations": 281567, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 173483, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 902185022, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 275059, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2028017657, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32730, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1085054630, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86736, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 112623337, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1188, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5470960, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 173472, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19604057, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62180, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 321853082, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 151217, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 604396337, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 69291, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7942395, "child_limit_applications": 16118, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16118, "child_cap_hits": 16118, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16118, "child_moves_before_total": 1374651, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1374651, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 258931, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 258931, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.28669810150143, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.064710261819084, "tt_hits": 6151, "tt_cutoffs": 1016, "beta_cutoffs": 11562, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4949.363636363636, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5676.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1727, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1626, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11511, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 142, 94, 144, 96, 141, 143, 114, 100, 129, 99, 97, 82, 156, 170, 157, 127, 159, 174, 158, 160, 155 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10831, "avg_search_time_ms": 984.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 75224, "safety_nodes": 688, "corridor_nodes": 11190, "corridor_branch_probes": 12737, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 5409, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 11130, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 11130, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 60, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5409, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 97, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 821, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 504560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 87102, "avg_nodes": 7918.363636363636, "eval_calls": 52751, "avg_eval_calls": 4795.545454545455, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 52751, "pattern_eval_ns": 1090265, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.66813899262573, "pattern_frame_queries": 52751, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1090265, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.66813899262573, "pattern_frame_updates": 150354, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1836862628, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12216.91892467111, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21146, "avg_candidate_generations": 1922.3636363636363, "candidate_moves_total": 1678401, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.37203253570415, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 745, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 21135, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1677656, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 549047, "avg_legality_checks": 49913.36363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1794, "root_legality_checks": 745, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 548302, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1788, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3372609, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 306600.8181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6930160117, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2054.8365129192266, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25495, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2317.7272727272725, "renju_forbidden_ns": 176900099, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6938.6192979015495, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1815, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 17316448, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10801, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 95519788, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10451, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45153882, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2428, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 18909981, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99545, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9049.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 941039407, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9453.407072178412, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137735, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12521.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 452651298, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3286.3926961193597, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1340709716, "stage_ordering_ns": 678249486, "stage_eval_ns": 1837952893, "stage_threat_ns": 5686299815, "stage_proof_ns": 1255511000, "tactical_annotations": 309773, "root_tactical_annotations": 1871, "search_tactical_annotations": 307902, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 172825, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1123036434, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 883419, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4272685855, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47589, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1887050076, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86407, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 132386990, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 22460, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 128439648, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 172814, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21026370, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 98909, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 214033317, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 143121, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 632943926, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 67743, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8724518, "child_limit_applications": 21135, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21135, "child_cap_hits": 21135, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21135, "child_moves_before_total": 1675868, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1675868, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 339399, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 339399, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.29349420392714, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.05862313697658, "tt_hits": 9536, "tt_cutoffs": 1291, "beta_cutoffs": 17750, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3261.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3989.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 375, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 669, "avg_search_time_ms": 66.9, "search_nodes": 17563, "safety_nodes": 927, "corridor_nodes": 1204, "corridor_branch_probes": 1484, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 480, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1190, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1190, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 27, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 480, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 41, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 199, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 87680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 19694, "avg_nodes": 1969.4, "eval_calls": 16463, "avg_eval_calls": 1646.3, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 16463, "pattern_eval_ns": 324061, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.684200935430965, "pattern_frame_queries": 16463, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 324061, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.684200935430965, "pattern_frame_updates": 35068, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 271528979, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7742.9274267138135, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1081, "avg_candidate_generations": 108.1, "candidate_moves_total": 78046, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.19796484736355, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 673, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 1071, "search_candidate_moves_total": 77373, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 3065, "avg_legality_checks": 306.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3065, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 120967, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12096.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 240517010, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1988.2861441550174, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1574, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 157.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14264190, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9062.382465057179, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 122720, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1469, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13201089, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 474540, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 465841, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7276446, "stage_ordering_ns": 34260, "stage_eval_ns": 271853040, "stage_threat_ns": 326962100, "stage_proof_ns": 47451244, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 37540, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 208677950, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 74704, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 77167902, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 660, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 22276667, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 18765, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 23292791, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2462, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13839435, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 37530, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 3984022, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 948, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5914.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6714.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1888, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1627, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17982, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 110, 83, 81, 86, 85, 54, 111, 68, 40, 109, 125, 95, 127, 124, 113, 114, 99, 71, 141 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 11256, "avg_search_time_ms": 938.0, "search_nodes": 302988, "safety_nodes": 727, "corridor_nodes": 2098, "corridor_branch_probes": 2402, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 970, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2076, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2076, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 970, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 554, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 201760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 305813, "avg_nodes": 25484.416666666668, "eval_calls": 296369, "avg_eval_calls": 24697.416666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 296369, "pattern_eval_ns": 5871898, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.812794185626704, "pattern_frame_queries": 296369, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5871898, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.812794185626704, "pattern_frame_updates": 605908, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6335968984, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10456.981891640315, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6597, "avg_candidate_generations": 549.75, "candidate_moves_total": 534963, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.0918599363347, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 919, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 6585, "search_candidate_moves_total": 534044, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 290878, "avg_legality_checks": 24239.833333333332, "illegal_moves_skipped": 427, "root_legality_checks": 919, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 289959, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 424, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2411344, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 200945.33333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4975475637, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2063.3620242487177, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36123, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3010.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 270917626, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7499.865072114719, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 439, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2984081, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33961, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 257121693, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 503, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4481635, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1220, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6330217, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 6307, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 525.5833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 61338127, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9725.404629776438, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8777, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 731.4166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 33827062, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3854.057422809616, "stage_move_gen_ns": 633060168, "stage_ordering_ns": 219323, "stage_eval_ns": 6341840882, "stage_threat_ns": 3914229679, "stage_proof_ns": 318157504, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 610216, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3083332651, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 114549, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 369970953, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1119, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 74416271, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 305102, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 369283278, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4296, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25008585, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 610204, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66634212, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 448, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5874, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4624.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5291.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6713, "avg_search_time_ms": 610.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 86480, "safety_nodes": 1023, "corridor_nodes": 548, "corridor_branch_probes": 696, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 254, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 540, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 540, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 254, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 431, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26027200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 88051, "avg_nodes": 8004.636363636364, "eval_calls": 69761, "avg_eval_calls": 6341.909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 69761, "pattern_eval_ns": 1421616, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.37837760353206, "pattern_frame_queries": 69761, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1421616, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.37837760353206, "pattern_frame_updates": 172860, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1315198071, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7608.458122179799, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15899, "avg_candidate_generations": 1445.3636363636363, "candidate_moves_total": 1388184, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.31266117365873, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 845, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 15888, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1387339, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 752675, "avg_legality_checks": 68425.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 322, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 752675, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 322, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1906132, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 173284.72727272726, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3917334327, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2055.122272224589, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6343, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 576.6363636363636, "renju_forbidden_ns": 48157086, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7592.162383730096, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 339, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2487498, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3909, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34883411, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2069, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10663717, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 122460, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 56433, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5130.272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 528137152, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9358.658090124572, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 79461, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7223.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 245630853, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3091.212708120965, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1786105281, "stage_ordering_ns": 549603978, "stage_eval_ns": 1316619687, "stage_threat_ns": 2915821199, "stage_proof_ns": 102085625, "tactical_annotations": 238975, "root_tactical_annotations": 1121, "search_tactical_annotations": 237854, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 174073, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 958781300, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 251216, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1806795127, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32267, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1077489218, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 87031, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118170626, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1202, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5490120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 174062, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20200493, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 57197, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 267143742, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 132047, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 444980507, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49731, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6383533, "child_limit_applications": 15888, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15888, "child_cap_hits": 15888, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15888, "child_moves_before_total": 1387017, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1387017, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 256087, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 256087, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.29966012084593, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.11826535750252, "tt_hits": 5983, "tt_cutoffs": 781, "beta_cutoffs": 11302, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5118.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5845.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1867, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1628, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12363, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 81, 68, 111, 54, 40, 109, 142, 94, 127, 157, 128, 125, 114, 113, 156, 100, 170 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9510, "avg_search_time_ms": 864.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 96461, "safety_nodes": 586, "corridor_nodes": 4081, "corridor_branch_probes": 4486, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1725, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 4049, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4049, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 87, "corridor_proof_active": 32, "corridor_proof_quiet": 55, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1725, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 87, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 85, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 693, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24138320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 101128, "avg_nodes": 9193.454545454546, "eval_calls": 70111, "avg_eval_calls": 6373.727272727273, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70111, "pattern_eval_ns": 1414555, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.175935302591604, "pattern_frame_queries": 70111, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1414555, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.175935302591604, "pattern_frame_updates": 192828, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1979246402, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10264.310172796482, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24720, "avg_candidate_generations": 2247.2727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 1974199, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.86241909385113, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 760, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 24709, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1973439, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 722087, "avg_legality_checks": 65644.27272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1245, "root_legality_checks": 760, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 721327, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1245, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2921004, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 265545.8181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5813720694, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1990.3158961781635, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24676, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2243.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 150103965, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6082.994204895445, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1339, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12375294, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 89230886, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11621, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39359662, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1095, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9138123, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 83231, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7566.454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 721361255, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8666.978109117998, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110232, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10021.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 313504800, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2844.045286305247, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1586163191, "stage_ordering_ns": 715114278, "stage_eval_ns": 1980660957, "stage_threat_ns": 4588626907, "stage_proof_ns": 589708833, "tactical_annotations": 403416, "root_tactical_annotations": 2034, "search_tactical_annotations": 401382, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 201111, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1084372671, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 606836, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3289476326, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51786, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1788754791, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 100550, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 133315472, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8272, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 48595034, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 201100, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21979936, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 132553, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 183042468, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 182346, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 684547482, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 88517, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10887468, "child_limit_applications": 24709, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24709, "child_cap_hits": 24709, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24709, "child_moves_before_total": 1972194, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1972194, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 401339, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 401339, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.81682787648225, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.242624145048364, "tt_hits": 10451, "tt_cutoffs": 1594, "beta_cutoffs": 20153, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4824.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5551.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1408, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2841, "avg_search_time_ms": 284.1, "search_nodes": 95373, "safety_nodes": 987, "corridor_nodes": 3005, "corridor_branch_probes": 3702, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 5, "corridor_depth_exits": 1480, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 2989, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2989, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 58, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1480, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 58, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 342, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 226400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 99365, "avg_nodes": 9936.5, "eval_calls": 91742, "avg_eval_calls": 9174.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 91742, "pattern_eval_ns": 1867235, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.353109807939656, "pattern_frame_queries": 91742, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1867235, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.353109807939656, "pattern_frame_updates": 190688, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1298803810, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6811.14600813895, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3612, "avg_candidate_generations": 361.2, "candidate_moves_total": 258982, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.70044296788483, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 694, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 3602, "search_candidate_moves_total": 258288, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 8859, "avg_legality_checks": 885.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8859, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 351086, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 35108.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 804631090, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2291.8347356488152, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1826, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 182.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 17219300, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9430.065717415115, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1740, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16898609, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 86, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 320691, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 23548458, "stage_ordering_ns": 119140, "stage_eval_ns": 1300671045, "stage_threat_ns": 1431873164, "stage_proof_ns": 72294120, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 196792, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1087127321, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 154690, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 155544859, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1205, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 41664749, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 98391, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 129091791, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6094, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 37616412, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 196782, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22492781, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 135, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3337, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5595.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6395.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1987, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1629, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16385, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 144, 82, 129, 99, 130, 110, 68, 97, 67, 111, 146, 162, 113, 126, 83, 53, 159, 174, 141, 124, 138, 125, 127, 80, 64, 95, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 10371, "avg_search_time_ms": 691.4, "search_nodes": 192445, "safety_nodes": 443, "corridor_nodes": 9754, "corridor_branch_probes": 10117, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 5518, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 9725, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9725, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 63, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5518, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 6, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 698, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 195360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 202642, "avg_nodes": 13509.466666666667, "eval_calls": 186057, "avg_eval_calls": 12403.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 186057, "pattern_eval_ns": 3768628, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.255233611205167, "pattern_frame_queries": 186057, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3768628, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.255233611205167, "pattern_frame_updates": 384804, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4889165634, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12705.59982224717, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6360, "avg_candidate_generations": 424.0, "candidate_moves_total": 549801, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.44669811320755, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1151, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 6345, "search_candidate_moves_total": 548650, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 176250, "avg_legality_checks": 11750.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 605, "root_legality_checks": 1151, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 175099, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 602, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2552958, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 170197.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5554787198, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2175.823964984931, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55176, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3678.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 264288421, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4789.9162860664055, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 721, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1465166, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 48243, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 225998905, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1571, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14299080, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4641, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 22525270, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 20171, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1344.7333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 184636629, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9153.568439839373, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 26762, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1784.1333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 88827094, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3319.150063522906, "stage_move_gen_ns": 412329025, "stage_ordering_ns": 237172, "stage_eval_ns": 4892934262, "stage_threat_ns": 4126807484, "stage_proof_ns": 900237383, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 404453, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2313047082, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 426763, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1360980189, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 4310, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 275395212, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 202219, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 273375908, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 19634, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 132295760, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 404438, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47108545, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 764, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5294, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6412.866666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6946.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1773, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6001, "avg_search_time_ms": 428.64285714285717, "search_nodes": 47363, "safety_nodes": 1523, "corridor_nodes": 4033, "corridor_branch_probes": 4514, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2243, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 4010, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4010, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2243, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 72, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 396, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 277360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 52919, "avg_nodes": 3779.9285714285716, "eval_calls": 32211, "avg_eval_calls": 2300.785714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32211, "pattern_eval_ns": 670911, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.828629971127874, "pattern_frame_queries": 32211, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 670911, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.828629971127874, "pattern_frame_updates": 94596, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 987430343, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10438.39425557106, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14464, "avg_candidate_generations": 1033.142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 1154036, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.78678097345133, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1080, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 14450, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1152956, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 686801, "avg_legality_checks": 49057.21428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 593, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 686801, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 593, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1771063, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 126504.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3763353683, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2124.9123735293438, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10984, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 784.5714285714286, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42499859, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3869.2515477057536, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 693, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3017326, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4266, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27498010, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5995, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11949763, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 34760, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60341, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4310.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 553965694, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9180.585240549544, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81411, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5815.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 243831376, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2995.066710886735, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1655323058, "stage_ordering_ns": 466924669, "stage_eval_ns": 988101254, "stage_threat_ns": 2767825626, "stage_proof_ns": 82212953, "tactical_annotations": 236636, "root_tactical_annotations": 751, "search_tactical_annotations": 235885, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 102774, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 659461953, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 404468, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1963311488, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30621, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1102812181, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 76733724, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8164, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 51125233, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 102760, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12571355, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70127, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 248008411, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 123024, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 481945787, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 43485, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4621873, "child_limit_applications": 14450, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14450, "child_cap_hits": 14450, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14450, "child_moves_before_total": 1152363, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1152363, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 234066, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 234066, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.7483044982699, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.198339100346022, "tt_hits": 5266, "tt_cutoffs": 637, "beta_cutoffs": 12387, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5794.214285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6365.642857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1844, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1630, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19793, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 82, 130, 52, 97, 80, 128, 68, 146, 162, 110, 36, 84, 66, 94, 81, 51, 79, 78, 83 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 15589, "avg_search_time_ms": 1558.9, "search_nodes": 148672, "safety_nodes": 176, "corridor_nodes": 6605, "corridor_branch_probes": 7389, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3239, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 6554, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6554, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 51, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3239, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 81, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 683, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 14185040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1978160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 155453, "avg_nodes": 15545.3, "eval_calls": 116432, "avg_eval_calls": 11643.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 116432, "pattern_eval_ns": 2411360, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.710457606156382, "pattern_frame_queries": 116432, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2411360, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.710457606156382, "pattern_frame_updates": 297260, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4322529885, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14541.242969117944, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30381, "avg_candidate_generations": 3038.1, "candidate_moves_total": 2691296, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.58483920871598, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 775, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 30371, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2690521, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1053406, "avg_legality_checks": 105340.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1239, "root_legality_checks": 775, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1052631, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1239, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4697963, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 469796.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9771224645, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2079.8853982034343, "renju_forbidden_checks": 66049, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6604.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 309177725, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4681.035670487063, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1744, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11126487, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37274, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 220000880, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24647, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 65190167, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2384, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 12860191, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 147516, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14751.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1308738735, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8871.842613682584, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 194285, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19428.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 588024383, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3026.607216203001, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2505026914, "stage_ordering_ns": 1051601896, "stage_eval_ns": 4324941245, "stage_threat_ns": 6850303074, "stage_proof_ns": 805595090, "tactical_annotations": 508977, "root_tactical_annotations": 2621, "search_tactical_annotations": 506356, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 310544, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1803256936, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 815327, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4697702485, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 63711, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2330964673, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 155267, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 225203805, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 13274, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 72285046, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 310534, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36807322, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 148644, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 338953879, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 255305, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1181187326, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 105028, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15047480, "child_limit_applications": 30371, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30371, "child_cap_hits": 30371, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30371, "child_moves_before_total": 2689282, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2689282, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 490258, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 490258, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.54769352342696, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.14230680583451, "tt_hits": 12636, "tt_cutoffs": 1827, "beta_cutoffs": 22947, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1355.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1801.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 256, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4195, "avg_search_time_ms": 466.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 121136, "safety_nodes": 995, "corridor_nodes": 378, "corridor_branch_probes": 443, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 178, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 373, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 368, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 47, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 178, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 47, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 46, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 302, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 47920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122509, "avg_nodes": 13612.111111111111, "eval_calls": 118496, "avg_eval_calls": 13166.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 118496, "pattern_eval_ns": 2401887, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.269772819335675, "pattern_frame_queries": 118496, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2401887, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.269772819335675, "pattern_frame_updates": 242220, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2480994597, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10242.732214515729, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2623, "avg_candidate_generations": 291.44444444444446, "candidate_moves_total": 202368, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.15135341212353, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 707, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 2614, "search_candidate_moves_total": 201661, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 5048, "avg_legality_checks": 560.8888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5048, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 678849, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 75427.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1559442047, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2297.185452140314, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10385, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1153.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 77967825, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7507.734713529128, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10384, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 77967615, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 210, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4.777777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 257882, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5997.2558139534885, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 47, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5.222222222222222, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 69010, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1468.2978723404256, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13488681, "stage_ordering_ns": 86750, "stage_eval_ns": 2483396484, "stage_threat_ns": 1600501781, "stage_proof_ns": 80842720, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 243069, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1379876857, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 20772, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 27024996, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 339, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10452148, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121530, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159886731, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 840, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4332164, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 243060, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29381033, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 124, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2378, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4323.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5212.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 891, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1631, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16823, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 144, 82, 110, 158, 143, 141, 127, 94, 159, 80, 64, 111, 129, 114, 115, 157, 145, 146, 173, 98, 130, 66, 50, 108, 52, 122 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2425, "avg_search_time_ms": 173.21428571428572, "search_nodes": 54111, "safety_nodes": 1496, "corridor_nodes": 396, "corridor_branch_probes": 470, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 135, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 384, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 384, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 70, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 58, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 135, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 70, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 67, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 451, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 134880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 56003, "avg_nodes": 4000.214285714286, "eval_calls": 51423, "avg_eval_calls": 3673.0714285714284, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51423, "pattern_eval_ns": 1044983, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.321315364720068, "pattern_frame_queries": 51423, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1044983, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.321315364720068, "pattern_frame_updates": 108142, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1317123668, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12179.575632039356, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2662, "avg_candidate_generations": 190.14285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 198267, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.48046581517656, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1003, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 2648, "search_candidate_moves_total": 197264, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 48362, "avg_legality_checks": 3454.4285714285716, "illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "root_legality_checks": 1003, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 47359, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 52, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 526590, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 37613.57142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1192678419, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2264.90897852219, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6531, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 466.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 39087384, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5984.900321543409, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 55, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 537862, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6287, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37418787, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 330213, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 161, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 800522, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1014, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 72.42857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 10034660, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9896.11439842209, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1369, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97.78571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 5165488, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3773.18334550767, "stage_move_gen_ns": 116108871, "stage_ordering_ns": 87521, "stage_eval_ns": 1318168651, "stage_threat_ns": 796929911, "stage_proof_ns": 171697294, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 109064, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 621443266, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 27144, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 83879645, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 469, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 21016090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 54525, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73610233, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 908, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5165211, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 109050, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12831556, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 198, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2333, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6397.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6969.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1779, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 14384, "avg_search_time_ms": 1106.4615384615386, "search_nodes": 121895, "safety_nodes": 425, "corridor_nodes": 8852, "corridor_branch_probes": 9300, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4476, "corridor_neutral_exits": 22, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 8816, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8816, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 120, "corridor_proof_active": 36, "corridor_proof_quiet": 84, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4476, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 120, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 118, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 967, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 59778800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1989680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 131172, "avg_nodes": 10090.153846153846, "eval_calls": 88630, "avg_eval_calls": 6817.692307692308, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 88630, "pattern_eval_ns": 1855814, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.938892023017036, "pattern_frame_queries": 88630, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1855814, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.938892023017036, "pattern_frame_updates": 243670, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2368766065, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9721.205175031806, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31654, "avg_candidate_generations": 2434.923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 2661354, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.0763884501169, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 935, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 31641, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2660419, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1838367, "avg_legality_checks": 141412.84615384616, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4842, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1838367, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4842, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4330670, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 333128.46153846156, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9004295652, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2079.192284796579, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41807, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3215.923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 168039974, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4019.421962829191, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4960, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52807410, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6904, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64815522, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29869, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 49538360, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 878682, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 146237, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11249.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1477397840, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10102.763596080335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 207672, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15974.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 737583376, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3551.674640779691, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4386704432, "stage_ordering_ns": 1051010920, "stage_eval_ns": 2370621879, "stage_threat_ns": 6378802715, "stage_proof_ns": 148882546, "tactical_annotations": 614405, "root_tactical_annotations": 2796, "search_tactical_annotations": 611609, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 261555, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1586410444, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 960122, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4439767011, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67772, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2304390417, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 130771, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 194123175, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 17872, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 105326052, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 261542, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31193194, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 200480, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 784085432, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 257389, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1082944014, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 156536, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21982839, "child_limit_applications": 31641, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31641, "child_cap_hits": 31641, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31641, "child_moves_before_total": 2655577, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2655577, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 510112, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 510112, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.92835245409437, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.121867197623338, "tt_hits": 14024, "tt_cutoffs": 1564, "beta_cutoffs": 25929, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4775.846153846154, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5391.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1818, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1632, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13317, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 110, 158, 111, 113, 68, 82, 128, 144, 80, 64, 95, 65, 97, 174, 190, 98, 125, 140, 139, 83, 153 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10559, "avg_search_time_ms": 959.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 103593, "safety_nodes": 171, "corridor_nodes": 2713, "corridor_branch_probes": 3224, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1056, "corridor_neutral_exits": 30, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2675, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2675, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 99, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 61, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1056, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 99, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 96, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 819, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 725520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 106477, "avg_nodes": 9679.727272727272, "eval_calls": 74853, "avg_eval_calls": 6804.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74853, "pattern_eval_ns": 1549896, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.705863492445193, "pattern_frame_queries": 74853, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1549896, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.705863492445193, "pattern_frame_updates": 207092, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2677719155, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12930.094619782512, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26849, "avg_candidate_generations": 2440.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2223720, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.82319639465157, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 26838, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2222934, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 681863, "avg_legality_checks": 61987.545454545456, "illegal_moves_skipped": 537, "root_legality_checks": 786, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 681077, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 537, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3038565, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 276233.1818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6460757352, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2126.2528042019835, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25035, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2275.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 105705107, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4222.293069702417, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 652, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4011874, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11808, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73747169, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12374, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26505258, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 201, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1440806, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6966.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 696423948, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9088.137126451782, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 107481, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9771.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 314010181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2921.5413049748327, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1622442295, "stage_ordering_ns": 902104817, "stage_eval_ns": 2679269051, "stage_threat_ns": 4816549383, "stage_proof_ns": 499935186, "tactical_annotations": 376752, "root_tactical_annotations": 2729, "search_tactical_annotations": 374023, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 212651, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1248701623, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 517610, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3349572401, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 55261, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2037620510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 106320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 153075738, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5548, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28227613, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 212640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26389693, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116870, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 169188114, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171840, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 710946738, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 88042, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10582315, "child_limit_applications": 26838, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26838, "child_cap_hits": 26838, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26838, "child_moves_before_total": 2222397, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2222397, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 431882, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 431882, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.80784708249497, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.09218272598554, "tt_hits": 12959, "tt_cutoffs": 1855, "beta_cutoffs": 21959, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4116.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4844.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 387, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2747, "avg_search_time_ms": 274.7, "search_nodes": 76241, "safety_nodes": 1085, "corridor_nodes": 907, "corridor_branch_probes": 1114, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 398, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 896, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 891, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 398, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 40, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 196, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 48240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 78233, "avg_nodes": 7823.3, "eval_calls": 74559, "avg_eval_calls": 7455.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74559, "pattern_eval_ns": 1514379, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.311149559409326, "pattern_frame_queries": 74559, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1514379, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.311149559409326, "pattern_frame_updates": 152424, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1562304299, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10249.72641447541, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1663, "avg_candidate_generations": 166.3, "candidate_moves_total": 128224, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.10402886349969, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 720, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 1653, "search_candidate_moves_total": 127504, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 3399, "avg_legality_checks": 339.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3399, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 462697, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 46269.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1058622327, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2287.9386012876676, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2504, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 250.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19079424, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7619.5782747603835, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2502, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19078984, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 30, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 229782, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7659.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 85181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2241.6052631578946, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9263253, "stage_ordering_ns": 52542, "stage_eval_ns": 1563818678, "stage_threat_ns": 1095751476, "stage_proof_ns": 64287103, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 154308, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 905164296, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52236, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 55766306, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 484, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15375360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77149, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104164074, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1874, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10244661, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 154298, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20412139, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1527, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5604.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6404.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1563, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1633, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18770, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 114, 81, 83, 78, 79, 50, 113, 66, 34, 115, 129, 99, 127, 130, 111, 110, 95, 63, 143 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 12479, "avg_search_time_ms": 1039.9166666666667, "search_nodes": 297357, "safety_nodes": 727, "corridor_nodes": 2187, "corridor_branch_probes": 2490, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 1011, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 2165, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2165, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1011, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 554, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 198640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 300271, "avg_nodes": 25022.583333333332, "eval_calls": 291064, "avg_eval_calls": 24255.333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 291064, "pattern_eval_ns": 5907874, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.297508451749444, "pattern_frame_queries": 291064, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5907874, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.297508451749444, "pattern_frame_updates": 594646, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7140096576, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12007.306155258759, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6271, "avg_candidate_generations": 522.5833333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 507885, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.98947536278105, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 919, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 6259, "search_candidate_moves_total": 506966, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 285376, "avg_legality_checks": 23781.333333333332, "illegal_moves_skipped": 419, "root_legality_checks": 919, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 284457, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 416, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2420601, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 201716.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5668795337, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2341.8958089334014, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37005, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3083.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 342170900, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9246.612619916228, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 430, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4167384, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34890, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 325500095, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 506, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5017976, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1179, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7485445, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 6529, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 544.0833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 68900450, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10552.98667483535, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9073, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 756.0833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 37969327, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4184.87016422352, "stage_move_gen_ns": 688733979, "stage_ordering_ns": 213912, "stage_eval_ns": 7146004450, "stage_threat_ns": 4259331940, "stage_proof_ns": 346878582, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 599132, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3345280497, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 119312, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 413424583, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1163, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 82503188, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 299560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 401590017, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4474, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 27583733, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 599120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 71453110, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 440, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5581, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 2.75, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 2.75, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4509.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5176.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6282, "avg_search_time_ms": 571.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 85528, "safety_nodes": 1023, "corridor_nodes": 558, "corridor_branch_probes": 718, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 258, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 550, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 550, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 258, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 431, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26021200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 87109, "avg_nodes": 7919.0, "eval_calls": 69117, "avg_eval_calls": 6283.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 69117, "pattern_eval_ns": 1373634, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.874039671860757, "pattern_frame_queries": 69117, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1373634, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.874039671860757, "pattern_frame_updates": 170956, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1202681088, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7035.032920751539, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15588, "avg_candidate_generations": 1417.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 1359980, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.24531691044393, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 845, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 15577, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1359135, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 737464, "avg_legality_checks": 67042.18181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 313, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 737464, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 313, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1847501, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 167954.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3672930515, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1988.0533298764115, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5132, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 466.54545454545456, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43490068, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8474.292283710054, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 330, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3388538, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3003, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29424307, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1773, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10431123, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 246100, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 55234, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5021.272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 516979474, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9359.80508382518, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 77911, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7082.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 239704181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3076.641051969555, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1674378326, "stage_ordering_ns": 522231512, "stage_eval_ns": 1204054722, "stage_threat_ns": 2742216690, "stage_proof_ns": 90230182, "tactical_annotations": 232656, "root_tactical_annotations": 1121, "search_tactical_annotations": 231535, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 172189, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 873052278, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 246123, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1726533011, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31650, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1010506103, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86089, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 109217220, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1222, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7089749, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 172178, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18638858, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 55077, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 257561815, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 129064, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 436542352, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 48515, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7685574, "child_limit_applications": 15577, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15577, "child_cap_hits": 15577, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15577, "child_moves_before_total": 1358822, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1358822, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 250603, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 250603, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.23258650574564, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0880143801759, "tt_hits": 5939, "tt_cutoffs": 784, "beta_cutoffs": 11032, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5301.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6028.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1878, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1634, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9662, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 144, 96, 160, 176, 97, 110, 124, 66, 114, 81, 111, 83, 84, 68, 54, 53, 113, 38 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7395, "avg_search_time_ms": 821.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 89221, "safety_nodes": 832, "corridor_nodes": 347, "corridor_branch_probes": 367, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 163, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 341, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 341, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 26, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 20, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 163, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 26, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 26, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 155, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23856640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 90400, "avg_nodes": 10044.444444444445, "eval_calls": 69340, "avg_eval_calls": 7704.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 69340, "pattern_eval_ns": 1468315, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.175584078453994, "pattern_frame_queries": 69340, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1468315, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.175584078453994, "pattern_frame_updates": 178362, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1532648333, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8592.908427804128, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18495, "avg_candidate_generations": 2055.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1465187, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.22070829954042, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 676, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 18486, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1464511, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 792799, "avg_legality_checks": 88088.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 79, "root_legality_checks": 676, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 792123, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 78, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1991588, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 221287.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4402798814, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2210.6976011102697, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7211, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 801.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 24374401, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3380.1693246429068, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 85, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 515373, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1884, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14926618, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4926, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6953301, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 316, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1979109, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45652, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5072.444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 415697203, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9105.782944887409, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 60621, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6735.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 182559078, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3011.4824565744543, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1930516445, "stage_ordering_ns": 616870784, "stage_eval_ns": 1534116648, "stage_threat_ns": 3188921596, "stage_proof_ns": 80763422, "tactical_annotations": 206663, "root_tactical_annotations": 886, "search_tactical_annotations": 205777, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 179105, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1003176426, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 229773, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2031552860, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37286, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1383274415, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 89548, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 123254724, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 734, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4681121, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 179096, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21455557, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 39277, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 59784941, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 134551, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 540209307, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 32835, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4800908, "child_limit_applications": 18486, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18486, "child_cap_hits": 18486, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18486, "child_moves_before_total": 1464433, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1464433, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 295854, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 295854, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.21848966785676, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0042194092827, "tt_hits": 5206, "tt_cutoffs": 1356, "beta_cutoffs": 13929, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 4.222222222222222, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 4.222222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2872.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3761.222222222222, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2257, "avg_search_time_ms": 250.77777777777777, "search_nodes": 75814, "safety_nodes": 251, "corridor_nodes": 947, "corridor_branch_probes": 1036, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 376, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 935, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 935, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 376, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 415, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 100800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 77012, "avg_nodes": 8556.888888888889, "eval_calls": 72610, "avg_eval_calls": 8067.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72610, "pattern_eval_ns": 1475326, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.31849607492081, "pattern_frame_queries": 72610, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1475326, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.31849607492081, "pattern_frame_updates": 151578, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1089239801, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7186.001932998192, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3188, "avg_candidate_generations": 354.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 293651, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.11135508155583, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 703, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 3179, "search_candidate_moves_total": 292948, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 6293, "avg_legality_checks": 699.2222222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6293, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 295343, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32815.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 687175706, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2326.7038866673665, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3723, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 413.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12424855, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3337.3233951114694, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1470, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3668, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11967810, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 41, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 443225, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 12350, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15942997, "stage_ordering_ns": 108891, "stage_eval_ns": 1090715127, "stage_threat_ns": 1042588472, "stage_proof_ns": 88344478, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 153565, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 839742921, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59448, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 75252772, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 709, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 34496100, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76778, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99259098, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1978, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10665641, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 153556, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17668040, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 503, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2608, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5673.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6561.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1635, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21864, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 96, 142, 100, 99, 129, 141, 97, 140, 143, 170, 156, 155, 185, 139, 138, 171, 95, 94, 123, 169, 127, 168, 172, 167 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 6751, "avg_search_time_ms": 519.3076923076923, "search_nodes": 161089, "safety_nodes": 1236, "corridor_nodes": 1230, "corridor_branch_probes": 1455, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 537, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_plies_followed": 1216, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1216, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 73, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 59, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 537, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 73, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 72, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 464, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 129680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 163555, "avg_nodes": 12581.153846153846, "eval_calls": 156549, "avg_eval_calls": 12042.23076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 156549, "pattern_eval_ns": 3170363, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.2515697960383, "pattern_frame_queries": 156549, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3170363, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.2515697960383, "pattern_frame_updates": 322102, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3764643794, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11687.738027084588, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4515, "avg_candidate_generations": 347.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 317576, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.33798449612404, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 901, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 4502, "search_candidate_moves_total": 316675, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 154445, "avg_legality_checks": 11880.384615384615, "illegal_moves_skipped": 98, "root_legality_checks": 901, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 153544, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 95, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1292166, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 99397.38461538461, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3007272379, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2327.311180606826, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11086, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 852.7692307692307, "renju_forbidden_ns": 105086140, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9479.175536712972, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 98, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 991886, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10284, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 101061423, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 77, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 745745, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 627, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2287086, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3649, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 280.6923076923077, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 37273606, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10214.745409701289, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5435, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 418.0769230769231, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 20219983, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3720.3280588776447, "stage_move_gen_ns": 382914528, "stage_ordering_ns": 138881, "stage_eval_ns": 3767814157, "stage_threat_ns": 2326347483, "stage_proof_ns": 248961644, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 324693, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1823880846, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 69305, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 230237949, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 813, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 45666768, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 162340, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 214929256, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2578, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17980201, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 324680, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39319231, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 181, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4045, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5105.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5721.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 104, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 15101, "avg_search_time_ms": 1161.6153846153845, "search_nodes": 118594, "safety_nodes": 435, "corridor_nodes": 10141, "corridor_branch_probes": 10472, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 4703, "corridor_neutral_exits": 23, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 10105, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 10105, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 117, "corridor_proof_active": 36, "corridor_proof_quiet": 81, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4703, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 117, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 114, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 958, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 574960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 20000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 129170, "avg_nodes": 9936.153846153846, "eval_calls": 84463, "avg_eval_calls": 6497.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84463, "pattern_eval_ns": 1742447, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.629707682653944, "pattern_frame_queries": 84463, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1742447, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.629707682653944, "pattern_frame_updates": 237070, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2533355530, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10686.10760534863, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32391, "avg_candidate_generations": 2491.6153846153848, "candidate_moves_total": 2688753, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.00926183199037, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 920, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 32378, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2687833, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1946763, "avg_legality_checks": 149751.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3554, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1946763, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3554, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4691595, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 360891.92307692306, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9533393413, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2032.0154260970949, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36758, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2827.5384615384614, "renju_forbidden_ns": 153008392, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4162.58751836335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3554, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 41055058, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7746, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 65167766, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25434, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 46496577, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 288991, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 162307, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12485.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1625174401, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10012.965559094802, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 231732, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17825.53846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 812973862, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3508.2503150190737, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4495812649, "stage_ordering_ns": 1046969937, "stage_eval_ns": 2535097977, "stage_threat_ns": 6857646775, "stage_proof_ns": 134036815, "tactical_annotations": 648893, "root_tactical_annotations": 3126, "search_tactical_annotations": 645767, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 257527, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1577897189, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1088258, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4907716951, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70463, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2473614089, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128757, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 190709547, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 20444, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 125112422, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 257514, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31479901, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 206524, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 997084486, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 269507, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1029290153, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 172862, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24730765, "child_limit_applications": 32378, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32378, "child_cap_hits": 32378, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32378, "child_moves_before_total": 2684279, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2684279, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 522373, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 522373, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.9044104021249, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.133578355673606, "tt_hits": 15075, "tt_cutoffs": 1694, "beta_cutoffs": 27076, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5152.076923076923, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5767.461538461538, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1871, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1636, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11643, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 142, 100, 140, 98, 143, 141, 110, 94, 125, 95, 97, 82, 154, 168, 155, 170, 157, 127, 156, 158, 153 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10784, "avg_search_time_ms": 980.3636363636364, "search_nodes": 74486, "safety_nodes": 711, "corridor_nodes": 10839, "corridor_branch_probes": 12371, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 5322, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 10779, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 10779, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 60, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5322, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 97, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 821, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 505600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 86036, "avg_nodes": 7821.454545454545, "eval_calls": 52432, "avg_eval_calls": 4766.545454545455, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 52432, "pattern_eval_ns": 1081926, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.634841318278912, "pattern_frame_queries": 52432, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1081926, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.634841318278912, "pattern_frame_updates": 148878, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1909656935, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12826.992134499389, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20761, "avg_candidate_generations": 1887.3636363636363, "candidate_moves_total": 1659779, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.94696787245316, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 756, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 20750, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1659023, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 532658, "avg_legality_checks": 48423.454545454544, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1746, "root_legality_checks": 756, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 531902, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1740, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3287328, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 298848.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6858262151, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2086.272544449474, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26195, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2381.3636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 181593256, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6932.363275434243, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1764, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16382194, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11427, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 101625804, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10585, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45596031, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2419, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 17989227, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 95405, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8673.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 914751431, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9588.086903202138, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132055, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12005.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 439627646, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3329.1253341410775, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1318502583, "stage_ordering_ns": 689858875, "stage_eval_ns": 1910738861, "stage_threat_ns": 5616801483, "stage_proof_ns": 1216301392, "tactical_annotations": 301634, "root_tactical_annotations": 1871, "search_tactical_annotations": 299763, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 170647, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1132581868, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 847702, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4196650559, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46566, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1901852861, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85318, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 133648604, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 21758, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 125189901, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 170636, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21274069, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 94056, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 207359131, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 140217, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 630559311, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 67361, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7456482, "child_limit_applications": 20750, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20750, "child_cap_hits": 20750, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20750, "child_moves_before_total": 1657283, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1657283, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 333157, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 333157, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.86906024096386, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.05575903614458, "tt_hits": 9411, "tt_cutoffs": 1257, "beta_cutoffs": 17381, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3239.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3967.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 312, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 846, "avg_search_time_ms": 84.6, "search_nodes": 20254, "safety_nodes": 942, "corridor_nodes": 1196, "corridor_branch_probes": 1506, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 470, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1182, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1182, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 27, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 470, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 41, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 199, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 87200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 22392, "avg_nodes": 2239.2, "eval_calls": 19090, "avg_eval_calls": 1909.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 19090, "pattern_eval_ns": 385951, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.217443687794656, "pattern_frame_queries": 19090, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 385951, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.217443687794656, "pattern_frame_updates": 40450, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 369505499, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9134.87018541409, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1145, "avg_candidate_generations": 114.5, "candidate_moves_total": 84430, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.73799126637554, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 688, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 1135, "search_candidate_moves_total": 83742, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 3166, "avg_legality_checks": 316.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3166, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 133762, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13376.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 308549155, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2306.7026135972847, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1728, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 172.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15406863, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8916.008680555555, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 132831, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1624, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14376316, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 41, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 432953, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 464763, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8548635, "stage_ordering_ns": 38050, "stage_eval_ns": 369891450, "stage_threat_ns": 391808580, "stage_proof_ns": 61340356, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 42906, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 265759048, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 74208, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 77754087, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 643, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 21236807, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 21448, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 29709089, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2446, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13457681, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 42896, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5128675, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1013, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5866.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6666.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1787, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1637, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17415, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 140, 82, 125, 95, 124, 114, 66, 97, 67, 113, 138, 152, 111, 128, 81, 51, 155, 170, 143, 130, 146, 129, 127, 84, 70, 99, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 11345, "avg_search_time_ms": 756.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 217437, "safety_nodes": 443, "corridor_nodes": 9535, "corridor_branch_probes": 9898, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 5263, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 9506, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9506, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 63, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 5263, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 6, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 698, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 193120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 227415, "avg_nodes": 15161.0, "eval_calls": 210779, "avg_eval_calls": 14051.933333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 210779, "pattern_eval_ns": 4287345, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.340475094767505, "pattern_frame_queries": 210779, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4287345, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.340475094767505, "pattern_frame_updates": 434788, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5441948103, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12516.325434464612, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6630, "avg_candidate_generations": 442.0, "candidate_moves_total": 571350, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.17647058823529, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1151, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 6615, "search_candidate_moves_total": 570199, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 200703, "avg_legality_checks": 13380.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1008, "root_legality_checks": 1151, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 199552, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1005, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2729854, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 181990.26666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5950639512, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2179.8380103844383, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60711, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4047.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 292402436, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4816.300769218099, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1144, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2096881, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 53864, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 254851201, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1565, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14864984, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 4138, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 20589370, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21076, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1405.0666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 192429630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9130.272822167393, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27696, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1846.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 93699743, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3383.150743789717, "stage_move_gen_ns": 467318375, "stage_ordering_ns": 272151, "stage_eval_ns": 5446235448, "stage_threat_ns": 4474505259, "stage_proof_ns": 915552716, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 453999, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2591354878, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 431137, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1395219582, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 4354, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 278581003, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 226992, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 308226120, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 19196, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 126626727, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 453984, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53077952, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 764, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5507, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6305.866666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6839.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1723, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6054, "avg_search_time_ms": 432.42857142857144, "search_nodes": 47928, "safety_nodes": 1523, "corridor_nodes": 4054, "corridor_branch_probes": 4544, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 2254, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_plies_followed": 4031, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4031, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2254, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 72, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 396, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 276080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53505, "avg_nodes": 3821.785714285714, "eval_calls": 32554, "avg_eval_calls": 2325.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32554, "pattern_eval_ns": 683763, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.003962646679362, "pattern_frame_queries": 32554, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 683763, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.003962646679362, "pattern_frame_updates": 95726, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 993131454, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10374.730522533064, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14675, "avg_candidate_generations": 1048.2142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 1173318, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.95352640545144, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1080, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 14661, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1172238, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 690449, "avg_legality_checks": 49317.78571428572, "illegal_moves_skipped": 651, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 690449, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 651, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1786681, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 127620.07142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3778870640, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2115.022569781623, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11338, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 809.8571428571429, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43307077, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3819.6398835773507, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 757, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3301153, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4416, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27996499, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6135, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11975355, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 34070, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60815, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4343.928571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 553380756, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9099.412250267203, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81984, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5856.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 242850690, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2962.1717652224825, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1660077254, "stage_ordering_ns": 475021649, "stage_eval_ns": 993815217, "stage_threat_ns": 2806766894, "stage_proof_ns": 81938538, "tactical_annotations": 242335, "root_tactical_annotations": 751, "search_tactical_annotations": 241584, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 103946, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 675326019, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 410770, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1982044624, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31059, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1114228479, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51966, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 78064775, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8206, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 52965790, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 103932, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12916320, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71468, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 245465921, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 126766, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 491882529, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 44101, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5449366, "child_limit_applications": 14661, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14661, "child_cap_hits": 14661, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14661, "child_moves_before_total": 1171587, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1171587, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 237547, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 237547, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.91180683445877, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.20264647704795, "tt_hits": 5303, "tt_cutoffs": 648, "beta_cutoffs": 12574, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5793.642857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6365.071428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1828, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1638, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9646, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 82, 124, 126, 140, 127, 97, 130, 114, 84, 70, 83, 81, 128, 129, 113, 143, 68 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8114, "avg_search_time_ms": 901.5555555555555, "search_nodes": 75872, "safety_nodes": 223, "corridor_nodes": 2529, "corridor_branch_probes": 2964, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 965, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 2493, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2493, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 82, "corridor_proof_active": 36, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 965, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 82, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 80, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 682, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 462240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 78624, "avg_nodes": 8736.0, "eval_calls": 51361, "avg_eval_calls": 5706.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51361, "pattern_eval_ns": 1073916, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.909172329199198, "pattern_frame_queries": 51361, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1073916, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.909172329199198, "pattern_frame_updates": 151670, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1642400796, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10828.778242236434, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22751, "avg_candidate_generations": 2527.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 1790316, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.69174981319503, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 588, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 22742, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1789728, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 536899, "avg_legality_checks": 59655.444444444445, "illegal_moves_skipped": 271, "root_legality_checks": 588, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 536311, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 271, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2276626, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 252958.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4942996757, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2171.1940200103136, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17895, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1988.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 74999588, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4191.091813355686, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 379, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3123879, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7501, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 47653705, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9691, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21576256, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 324, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2645748, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51985, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5776.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 487636907, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9380.338693853997, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 71329, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7925.444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 218449578, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3062.563305247515, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1308054486, "stage_ordering_ns": 725731367, "stage_eval_ns": 1643474712, "stage_threat_ns": 3946427408, "stage_proof_ns": 459554905, "tactical_annotations": 326902, "root_tactical_annotations": 2193, "search_tactical_annotations": 324709, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 156829, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 928741710, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 451909, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2846396753, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46980, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1790634583, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78410, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 115534444, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5150, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 26207712, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 156820, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19109217, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 94874, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 132345238, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 145474, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 502079483, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 86554, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10437572, "child_limit_applications": 22742, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22742, "child_cap_hits": 22742, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22742, "child_moves_before_total": 1789457, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1789457, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 366468, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 366468, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.68512004221265, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.114150030780056, "tt_hits": 10867, "tt_cutoffs": 1732, "beta_cutoffs": 19384, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3160.1111111111113, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4049.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 440, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 1522, "avg_search_time_ms": 190.25, "search_nodes": 42734, "safety_nodes": 731, "corridor_nodes": 808, "corridor_branch_probes": 1014, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 5, "corridor_depth_exits": 355, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 799, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 799, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 27, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 355, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 188, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 45360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 44273, "avg_nodes": 5534.125, "eval_calls": 41533, "avg_eval_calls": 5191.625, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41533, "pattern_eval_ns": 842904, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.29480172393037, "pattern_frame_queries": 41533, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 842904, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.29480172393037, "pattern_frame_updates": 85422, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 804904404, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9422.68272810283, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1186, "avg_candidate_generations": 148.25, "candidate_moves_total": 87025, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.37689713322091, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 527, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 1178, "search_candidate_moves_total": 86498, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 2630, "avg_legality_checks": 328.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2630, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 236908, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29613.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 552747313, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2333.17284768771, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1480, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 185.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9402165, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6352.814189189189, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1474, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9393734, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8431, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7168452, "stage_ordering_ns": 43110, "stage_eval_ns": 805747308, "stage_threat_ns": 642879798, "stage_proof_ns": 55935373, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 87100, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 514206076, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 46725, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 49272040, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 446, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15225444, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43546, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 59837318, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1670, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9025436, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 87092, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10538928, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 66, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1078, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5171.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6171.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1712, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1639, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17766, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 128, 64, 113, 157, 172, 143, 83, 68, 129, 145, 65, 81, 144, 79, 80, 111, 95, 125, 50 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8703, "avg_search_time_ms": 791.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 203330, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 1000, "corridor_branch_probes": 1162, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 368, "corridor_neutral_exits": 21, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 982, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 982, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 84, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 66, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 21, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 368, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 84, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 597, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 154320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 205143, "avg_nodes": 18649.363636363636, "eval_calls": 198163, "avg_eval_calls": 18014.81818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 198163, "pattern_eval_ns": 4019386, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.283231481154402, "pattern_frame_queries": 198163, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4019386, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.283231481154402, "pattern_frame_updates": 406596, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5012454549, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12327.850123955966, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5146, "avg_candidate_generations": 467.8181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 371735, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.23766031869413, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 755, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 5135, "search_candidate_moves_total": 370980, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 194364, "avg_legality_checks": 17669.454545454544, "illegal_moves_skipped": 205, "root_legality_checks": 755, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 193609, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 204, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1600614, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 145510.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3805564529, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2377.565439887443, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21472, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1952.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 185522665, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8640.21353390462, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 205, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1878859, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20990, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 181632888, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 58, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 634135, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 219, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1376783, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2161, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 196.45454545454547, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 20446375, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9461.534012031467, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3032, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 275.6363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 10799916, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3561.9775725593668, "stage_move_gen_ns": 490192617, "stage_ordering_ns": 177060, "stage_eval_ns": 5016473935, "stage_threat_ns": 2920403406, "stage_proof_ns": 262235659, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 408739, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2381227220, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 63824, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 188630621, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 796, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 40291200, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 204364, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 283894368, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2132, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13118718, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 408728, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53532479, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 245, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4563, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4088.5454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4815.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 166, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9052, "avg_search_time_ms": 822.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 63752, "safety_nodes": 652, "corridor_nodes": 1048, "corridor_branch_probes": 1218, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 356, "corridor_neutral_exits": 28, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 1034, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1034, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 356, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 81, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 609, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 406960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 13, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 9, "total_nodes": 65452, "avg_nodes": 5950.181818181818, "eval_calls": 40735, "avg_eval_calls": 3703.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40735, "pattern_eval_ns": 859756, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.106075856143367, "pattern_frame_queries": 40735, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 859756, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.106075856143367, "pattern_frame_updates": 127410, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1143328383, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8973.615752295738, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21620, "avg_candidate_generations": 1965.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 1795790, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.06151711378354, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 783, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 21609, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1795007, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1327172, "avg_legality_checks": 120652.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1127, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1327172, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1127, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2975701, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 270518.2727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6020327988, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2023.1629414380006, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26013, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2364.818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65952954, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2535.3843847307116, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1173, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11377761, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3119, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25317312, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21703, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29067071, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 190810, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 120397, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10945.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1162130016, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9652.483168185254, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 172818, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15710.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 576746394, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3337.3051071068985, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3120956345, "stage_ordering_ns": 718115691, "stage_eval_ns": 1144188139, "stage_threat_ns": 3876202753, "stage_proof_ns": 135488041, "tactical_annotations": 357059, "root_tactical_annotations": 1757, "search_tactical_annotations": 355302, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 129655, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 783069463, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 399592, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2958358480, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44131, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1505425222, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64822, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96051865, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2234, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12960800, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 129644, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16127839, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 125638, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 629613169, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 160137, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 770011023, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 71284, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9634306, "child_limit_applications": 21609, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21609, "child_cap_hits": 21609, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21609, "child_moves_before_total": 1793880, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1793880, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 346434, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 346434, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.01541024573095, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.03193113980286, "tt_hits": 9101, "tt_cutoffs": 1361, "beta_cutoffs": 18960, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4952.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5679.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1878, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1640, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10874, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 99, 95, 113, 141, 85, 71, 157, 172, 114, 115, 128, 156, 84, 96, 94, 111, 126, 125, 69, 129, 54 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9251, "avg_search_time_ms": 770.9166666666666, "search_nodes": 96969, "safety_nodes": 399, "corridor_nodes": 2567, "corridor_branch_probes": 2977, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 1050, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_plies_followed": 2532, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2532, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 123, "corridor_proof_active": 35, "corridor_proof_quiet": 88, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1050, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 123, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 121, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 999, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 28178880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1970800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 10, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 9, "total_nodes": 99935, "avg_nodes": 8327.916666666666, "eval_calls": 68969, "avg_eval_calls": 5747.416666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68969, "pattern_eval_ns": 1418247, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.563543041076425, "pattern_frame_queries": 68969, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1418247, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.563543041076425, "pattern_frame_updates": 193834, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2049345477, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10572.683208312268, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26629, "avg_candidate_generations": 2219.0833333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2133967, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.13695595027977, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 837, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 26617, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2133130, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 550662, "avg_legality_checks": 45888.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2424, "root_legality_checks": 837, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 549825, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2421, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2455109, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 204592.41666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5292405336, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2155.670210976376, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21241, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1770.0833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 162287192, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7640.280212796008, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2471, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24881103, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9275, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 92871456, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8831, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39842295, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 664, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4692338, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50588, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4215.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 466666502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9224.845852771408, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 70181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5848.416666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 215986822, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3077.5683162109403, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1354309410, "stage_ordering_ns": 869069135, "stage_eval_ns": 2050763724, "stage_threat_ns": 4442400979, "stage_proof_ns": 498164497, "tactical_annotations": 318445, "root_tactical_annotations": 2576, "search_tactical_annotations": 315869, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 199156, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1194245543, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 441177, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3039288269, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54869, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2032376102, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 99572, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 144139227, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5310, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 30455238, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 199144, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24492352, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 80081, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 113916697, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 151290, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 510059169, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 87074, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9780350, "child_limit_applications": 26617, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26617, "child_cap_hits": 26617, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26617, "child_moves_before_total": 2130709, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2130709, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 426331, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 426331, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.0506818950295, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.017244618101213, "tt_hits": 12248, "tt_cutoffs": 1331, "beta_cutoffs": 22139, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4762.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5429.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1611, "avg_search_time_ms": 146.45454545454547, "search_nodes": 50029, "safety_nodes": 1214, "corridor_nodes": 1005, "corridor_branch_probes": 1229, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 17, "corridor_depth_exits": 377, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 38, "corridor_plies_followed": 995, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 995, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 27, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 377, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 38, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 181, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 41400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 52248, "avg_nodes": 4749.818181818182, "eval_calls": 47716, "avg_eval_calls": 4337.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47716, "pattern_eval_ns": 978548, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.507754212423507, "pattern_frame_queries": 47716, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 978548, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.507754212423507, "pattern_frame_updates": 99994, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 782673287, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7827.202502150129, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2292, "avg_candidate_generations": 208.36363636363637, "candidate_moves_total": 175131, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.40968586387434, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 779, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 2281, "search_candidate_moves_total": 174352, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 6500, "avg_legality_checks": 590.9090909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6500, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 224383, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 20398.454545454544, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 503070710, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2242.0179336224223, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3696, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 336.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 28250886, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7643.637987012987, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 69741, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3601, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27595205, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 41, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 278820, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 43, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 307120, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 17320586, "stage_ordering_ns": 72202, "stage_eval_ns": 783651835, "stage_threat_ns": 736912844, "stage_proof_ns": 54984261, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 102069, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 577555302, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 60938, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 68342901, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 551, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 21647352, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51029, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 67025067, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2064, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12031241, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 102058, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11958333, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 83, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2112, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6011.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6738.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1952, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1641, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11953, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 126, 70, 127, 108, 109, 125, 155, 141, 97, 80, 129, 130, 145, 81, 161 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5795, "avg_search_time_ms": 643.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 160286, "safety_nodes": 589, "corridor_nodes": 298, "corridor_branch_probes": 345, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 84, "corridor_neutral_exits": 22, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 285, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 285, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 80, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 80, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 80, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 591, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 171360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 161173, "avg_nodes": 17908.11111111111, "eval_calls": 155391, "avg_eval_calls": 17265.666666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 155391, "pattern_eval_ns": 3090422, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.88803727371598, "pattern_frame_queries": 155391, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3090422, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.88803727371598, "pattern_frame_updates": 320520, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3315785222, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10345.01816423312, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4878, "avg_candidate_generations": 542.0, "candidate_moves_total": 348666, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.47724477244772, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 607, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 4869, "search_candidate_moves_total": 348059, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 150131, "avg_legality_checks": 16681.222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "root_legality_checks": 607, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 149524, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1124000, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 124888.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2433717361, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2165.22896886121, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10045, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1116.111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66053000, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6575.709308113489, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9999, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 65718727, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 126800, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 173393, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 424, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 47.111111111111114, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3047504, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7187.509433962264, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 554, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 61.55555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1529419, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2760.6841155234656, "stage_move_gen_ns": 341883418, "stage_ordering_ns": 152720, "stage_eval_ns": 3318875644, "stage_threat_ns": 1957846495, "stage_proof_ns": 155579784, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 321259, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1663868467, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 22610, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 52723694, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 480, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15503013, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 160625, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 202355702, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 730, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3085289, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 321250, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35813343, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 238, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4358, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4125.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5014.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1679, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6150, "avg_search_time_ms": 683.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 51120, "safety_nodes": 586, "corridor_nodes": 547, "corridor_branch_probes": 620, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 154, "corridor_neutral_exits": 36, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 535, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 535, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 154, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 67, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 549, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 343520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 52253, "avg_nodes": 5805.888888888889, "eval_calls": 32990, "avg_eval_calls": 3665.5555555555557, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32990, "pattern_eval_ns": 673354, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.410851773264625, "pattern_frame_queries": 32990, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 673354, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.410851773264625, "pattern_frame_updates": 102166, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 751904757, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7359.637814928646, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17077, "avg_candidate_generations": 1897.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 1409356, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.52948410142297, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 638, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 17068, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1408718, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1085577, "avg_legality_checks": 120619.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1072, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1085577, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1072, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2181422, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 242380.22222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4094016516, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1876.765025749259, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13580, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1508.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 36790437, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2709.1632547864506, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1090, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10292282, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1794, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14850460, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10696, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11647695, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67176, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7464.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 558631598, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8315.940186971537, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 93432, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10381.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 266961814, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2857.28459200274, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2321942829, "stage_ordering_ns": 522610088, "stage_eval_ns": 752578111, "stage_threat_ns": 2398997253, "stage_proof_ns": 103497971, "tactical_annotations": 187288, "root_tactical_annotations": 1352, "search_tactical_annotations": 185936, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 103381, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 547274196, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 225956, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1763658688, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34755, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1062360968, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51686, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 67888638, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1206, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4288082, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 103372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11393981, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 59672, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 292689632, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 90878, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 387568255, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 36738, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4493668, "child_limit_applications": 17068, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17068, "child_cap_hits": 17068, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17068, "child_moves_before_total": 1407646, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1407646, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 273088, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 273088, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.47281462385752, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 6930, "tt_cutoffs": 1025, "beta_cutoffs": 14924, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4641.888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5530.777777777777, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1874, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1642, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9287, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 113, 114, 126, 98, 66, 100, 110, 109, 142, 86, 72, 94, 127, 130, 146, 97, 96, 81, 141, 156, 99, 85, 155 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6421, "avg_search_time_ms": 535.0833333333334, "search_nodes": 72696, "safety_nodes": 802, "corridor_nodes": 1424, "corridor_branch_probes": 1710, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 566, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 17, "corridor_plies_followed": 1403, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1403, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 566, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 332, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23784640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 5, "total_nodes": 74922, "avg_nodes": 6243.5, "eval_calls": 53856, "avg_eval_calls": 4488.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53856, "pattern_eval_ns": 1065012, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.775178253119428, "pattern_frame_queries": 53856, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1065012, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.775178253119428, "pattern_frame_updates": 145288, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1539030705, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10592.965041847916, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17815, "avg_candidate_generations": 1484.5833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1497412, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.05343811394891, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 913, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 17803, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1496499, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 546423, "avg_legality_checks": 45535.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 909, "root_legality_checks": 913, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 545510, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 905, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1972387, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 164365.58333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3809310778, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1931.3201608000863, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22818, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1901.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 118691332, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5201.653606801648, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1270, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10456854, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9294, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72637786, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11895, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32468437, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 359, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3128255, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50222, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4185.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 406398093, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8092.033232447931, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 65816, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5484.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 177592658, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2698.3204387990763, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1152080125, "stage_ordering_ns": 524058292, "stage_eval_ns": 1540095717, "stage_threat_ns": 2917056295, "stage_proof_ns": 246129194, "tactical_annotations": 310395, "root_tactical_annotations": 1597, "search_tactical_annotations": 308798, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 148216, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 781989695, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 355681, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1996246590, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36526, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1209862997, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74102, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96280049, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2916, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16833400, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 148204, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16148100, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 89988, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 84446884, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 141620, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 478920632, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78787, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9558461, "child_limit_applications": 17803, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17803, "child_cap_hits": 17803, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17803, "child_moves_before_total": 1495594, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1495594, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 288470, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 288470, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.00797618378925, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.203448856934223, "tt_hits": 7673, "tt_cutoffs": 985, "beta_cutoffs": 14278, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5563.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6230.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1072, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2859, "avg_search_time_ms": 259.90909090909093, "search_nodes": 90421, "safety_nodes": 1116, "corridor_nodes": 1282, "corridor_branch_probes": 1538, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 496, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 7, "corridor_plies_followed": 1260, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1255, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 496, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 330, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 201360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92819, "avg_nodes": 8438.09090909091, "eval_calls": 87590, "avg_eval_calls": 7962.727272727273, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87590, "pattern_eval_ns": 1758564, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.077223427331887, "pattern_frame_queries": 87590, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1758564, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.077223427331887, "pattern_frame_updates": 180778, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1483098546, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8203.976955160473, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2810, "avg_candidate_generations": 255.45454545454547, "candidate_moves_total": 220912, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.61637010676156, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 844, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 2799, "search_candidate_moves_total": 220068, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 6634, "avg_legality_checks": 603.0909090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6634, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 422749, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 38431.72727272727, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 953986978, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2256.627403021651, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4704, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 427.6363636363636, "renju_forbidden_ns": 39943193, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8491.325042517006, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 105110, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4577, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38814845, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 68, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 527604, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 49, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 495634, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.272727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 299851, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8329.194444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 44, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 126250, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2869.318181818182, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16216259, "stage_ordering_ns": 90850, "stage_eval_ns": 1484857110, "stage_threat_ns": 1248377443, "stage_proof_ns": 86816479, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 183419, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 999183974, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 80587, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 96168415, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 786, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 34525431, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91704, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 117406248, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2630, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14134186, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 183408, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21484620, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 129, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2573, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5906.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6634.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1972, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1643, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12445, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 128, 144, 80, 99, 129, 113, 96, 64, 141, 54, 94, 85, 71, 69, 84, 95, 52, 67, 66, 38, 108 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 4191, "avg_search_time_ms": 349.25, "search_nodes": 94579, "safety_nodes": 638, "corridor_nodes": 1051, "corridor_branch_probes": 1194, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 428, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 26, "corridor_plies_followed": 1034, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1034, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 70, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 428, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 70, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 472, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 146480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 96268, "avg_nodes": 8022.333333333333, "eval_calls": 91028, "avg_eval_calls": 7585.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 91028, "pattern_eval_ns": 1851866, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.343916157665774, "pattern_frame_queries": 91028, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1851866, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.343916157665774, "pattern_frame_updates": 189090, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2317770803, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12257.500676926331, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3529, "avg_candidate_generations": 294.0833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 282661, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.09662793992632, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 860, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 3517, "search_candidate_moves_total": 281801, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 84729, "avg_legality_checks": 7060.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 41, "root_legality_checks": 860, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 83869, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 41, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 908026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 75668.83333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2031527547, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2237.301076180638, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18155, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1512.9166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 143769681, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7919.012999173781, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 403433, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17365, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 136831694, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 212, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2499899, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 528, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4034655, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3024, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 252.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 30981735, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10245.282738095239, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4263, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 355.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 16965030, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3979.5988740323714, "stage_move_gen_ns": 194889798, "stage_ordering_ns": 129431, "stage_eval_ns": 2319622669, "stage_threat_ns": 1409310184, "stage_proof_ns": 241185952, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 191310, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1052850554, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64239, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 195779336, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 735, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 41972274, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 95649, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125268371, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2208, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12919618, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 191298, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22492305, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 423, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2973, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6117.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6784.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1822, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8242, "avg_search_time_ms": 749.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 66251, "safety_nodes": 846, "corridor_nodes": 338, "corridor_branch_probes": 396, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 110, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 325, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 325, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 82, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 110, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 82, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 82, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 597, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 339120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67435, "avg_nodes": 6130.454545454545, "eval_calls": 44620, "avg_eval_calls": 4056.3636363636365, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44620, "pattern_eval_ns": 936123, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.979896907216496, "pattern_frame_queries": 44620, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 936123, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.979896907216496, "pattern_frame_updates": 132402, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1322037993, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9985.03038473739, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20416, "avg_candidate_generations": 1856.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1604597, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.59507249216301, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 20405, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1603811, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1082574, "avg_legality_checks": 98415.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3615, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1082574, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3615, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2559924, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 232720.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5350830367, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2090.230165817423, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18565, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1687.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 129236436, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6961.294694317264, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3689, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 40914130, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6189, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60359602, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8650, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27519183, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 443521, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89209, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8109.909090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 869311037, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9744.656223026825, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 125669, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11424.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 417210911, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3319.91908107807, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2621458393, "stage_ordering_ns": 652526662, "stage_eval_ns": 1322974116, "stage_threat_ns": 3450718745, "stage_proof_ns": 142223821, "tactical_annotations": 309977, "root_tactical_annotations": 1296, "search_tactical_annotations": 308681, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 133227, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 777063134, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 302622, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2547189301, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41368, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1422848381, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66608, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 95990007, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 814, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4441336, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 133216, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16163499, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 73687, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 361141567, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 164211, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 747275699, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 72079, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9871468, "child_limit_applications": 20405, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20405, "child_cap_hits": 20405, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20405, "child_moves_before_total": 1600196, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1600196, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 326544, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 326544, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.42175937270277, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.003136486155356, "tt_hits": 7970, "tt_cutoffs": 1176, "beta_cutoffs": 17492, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4692.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5420.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1848, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1644, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10977, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 67, 82, 98, 96, 68, 111, 141, 110, 66, 69, 113, 124, 138, 128, 65, 64, 81, 129, 49 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8572, "avg_search_time_ms": 857.2, "search_nodes": 96468, "safety_nodes": 255, "corridor_nodes": 1068, "corridor_branch_probes": 1238, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 455, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 25, "corridor_plies_followed": 1058, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1058, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 455, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 416, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 409920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 21520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 97791, "avg_nodes": 9779.1, "eval_calls": 71936, "avg_eval_calls": 7193.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71936, "pattern_eval_ns": 1487494, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.67801935053381, "pattern_frame_queries": 71936, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1487494, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.67801935053381, "pattern_frame_updates": 192852, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2189108368, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11351.234978117935, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23134, "avg_candidate_generations": 2313.4, "candidate_moves_total": 1670810, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.22313477997753, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 639, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 23124, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1670171, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 660974, "avg_legality_checks": 66097.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1357, "root_legality_checks": 639, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 660335, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1357, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2329106, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 232910.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5080707157, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2181.3979943377417, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18427, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1842.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 120010916, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6512.775601020242, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1419, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13866857, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8928, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 77181691, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7884, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28039032, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 196, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 923336, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50680, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5068.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 453482811, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8947.963910812943, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 70779, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7077.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 199335916, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2816.3143870357026, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1626836319, "stage_ordering_ns": 692117797, "stage_eval_ns": 2190595862, "stage_threat_ns": 3814207824, "stage_proof_ns": 207219808, "tactical_annotations": 294469, "root_tactical_annotations": 1872, "search_tactical_annotations": 292597, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 195086, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1134647374, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 333276, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2497938310, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46955, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1705673008, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 97538, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 137853144, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2224, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12663200, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 195076, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23545673, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 72427, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 63020921, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 152177, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 580756033, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 69865, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7560123, "child_limit_applications": 23124, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23124, "child_cap_hits": 23124, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23124, "child_moves_before_total": 1668814, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1668814, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 371471, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 371471, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.16805051029233, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.064305483480368, "tt_hits": 8764, "tt_cutoffs": 1366, "beta_cutoffs": 18575, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 4.1, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 4.1, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3397.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4197.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2395, "avg_search_time_ms": 266.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 69430, "safety_nodes": 659, "corridor_nodes": 371, "corridor_branch_probes": 445, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 129, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 363, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 358, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 129, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 63, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 446, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 216080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 70460, "avg_nodes": 7828.888888888889, "eval_calls": 66872, "avg_eval_calls": 7430.222222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 66872, "pattern_eval_ns": 1363385, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.387980021533675, "pattern_frame_queries": 66872, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1363385, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.387980021533675, "pattern_frame_updates": 138808, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1323971679, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9538.151108005302, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2541, "avg_candidate_generations": 282.3333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 179363, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.58756395120031, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 2532, "search_candidate_moves_total": 178783, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 4869, "avg_legality_checks": 541.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4869, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 413324, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 45924.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 935149928, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2262.510592174662, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3575, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 397.22222222222223, "renju_forbidden_ns": 32553530, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9105.882517482518, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3544, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32298699, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 246091, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8740, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 33, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.6666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 299491, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9075.484848484848, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.777777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 136011, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3163.046511627907, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12734679, "stage_ordering_ns": 92600, "stage_eval_ns": 1325335064, "stage_threat_ns": 927530030, "stage_proof_ns": 109242804, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 139671, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 781722559, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25558, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 32929998, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 429, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13302324, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 69831, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91623004, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 854, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4704475, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 139662, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16549994, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 182, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2239, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5440.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6329.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1946, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1645, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17428, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 114, 111, 126, 98, 154, 97, 115, 116, 99, 95, 94, 83, 69, 139, 125, 84, 140, 168, 155, 170, 127, 141, 128, 124, 129 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 10613, "avg_search_time_ms": 816.3846153846154, "search_nodes": 255130, "safety_nodes": 662, "corridor_nodes": 489, "corridor_branch_probes": 570, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 172, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 474, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 474, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 67, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 52, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 172, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 67, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 454, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 129040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 256281, "avg_nodes": 19713.923076923078, "eval_calls": 248879, "avg_eval_calls": 19144.53846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 248879, "pattern_eval_ns": 5037333, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.24008855708999, "pattern_frame_queries": 248879, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5037333, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.24008855708999, "pattern_frame_updates": 510186, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6523514007, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12786.540608719173, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6227, "avg_candidate_generations": 479.0, "candidate_moves_total": 495621, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.59225951501526, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 949, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 6214, "search_candidate_moves_total": 494672, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 245310, "avg_legality_checks": 18870.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1267, "root_legality_checks": 949, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 244361, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1265, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2051618, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 157816.76923076922, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4692934420, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2287.43090575341, "renju_forbidden_checks": 49378, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3798.3076923076924, "renju_forbidden_ns": 466736186, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9452.310462149135, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1279, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12843341, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 47907, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 453054111, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 33, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 252051, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 159, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 586683, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1171, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 90.07692307692308, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 7913388, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6757.803586678053, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1651, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 127.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4140269, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2507.734100545124, "stage_move_gen_ns": 618181640, "stage_ordering_ns": 203151, "stage_eval_ns": 6528551340, "stage_threat_ns": 3277198320, "stage_proof_ns": 155725072, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 511281, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2799776856, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32432, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 71559424, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 494, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17631958, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 255634, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 340668373, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1082, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4798937, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 511268, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60394730, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 489, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5366, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 2.769230769230769, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 2.769230769230769, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5359.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5975.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1750, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6803, "avg_search_time_ms": 566.9166666666666, "search_nodes": 51752, "safety_nodes": 925, "corridor_nodes": 668, "corridor_branch_probes": 798, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 204, "corridor_neutral_exits": 31, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 656, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 656, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 52, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 31, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 204, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 62, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 438, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 302560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 53345, "avg_nodes": 4445.416666666667, "eval_calls": 33583, "avg_eval_calls": 2798.5833333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33583, "pattern_eval_ns": 709282, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.12026918381324, "pattern_frame_queries": 33583, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 709282, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.12026918381324, "pattern_frame_updates": 103394, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 950729798, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9195.212468808635, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17026, "avg_candidate_generations": 1418.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1366922, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.28438858216845, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 888, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 17014, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1366034, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 952464, "avg_legality_checks": 79372.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 228, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 952464, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 228, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2232119, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 186009.91666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4489848866, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2011.4737905998738, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7945, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 662.0833333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 28587538, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3598.1797356828192, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 232, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2116548, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2248, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20077263, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5447, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6188637, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 205090, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81139, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6761.583333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 769137592, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9479.258950689558, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 115732, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9644.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 376384923, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3252.211341720527, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2190522914, "stage_ordering_ns": 557886823, "stage_eval_ns": 951439080, "stage_threat_ns": 2951714305, "stage_proof_ns": 104735783, "tactical_annotations": 247237, "root_tactical_annotations": 1371, "search_tactical_annotations": 245866, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 104846, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 621997460, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 279570, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2228355534, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34697, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1245561011, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52417, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 75240095, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1440, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7271605, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 104834, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12778414, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71236, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 364143643, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 125869, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 585053219, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 50132, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6071197, "child_limit_applications": 17014, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17014, "child_cap_hits": 17014, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17014, "child_moves_before_total": 1365806, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1365806, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 272251, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 272251, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.27542024215352, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001586928411896, "tt_hits": 7126, "tt_cutoffs": 1100, "beta_cutoffs": 14833, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5357.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6024.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1878, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1646, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9663, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 124, 82, 114, 98, 140, 83, 128, 84, 70, 85, 86, 81 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5380, "avg_search_time_ms": 672.5, "search_nodes": 59746, "safety_nodes": 448, "corridor_nodes": 908, "corridor_branch_probes": 1059, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 398, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 891, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 891, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 398, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 57, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 440, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23840000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 61102, "avg_nodes": 7637.75, "eval_calls": 45250, "avg_eval_calls": 5656.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 45250, "pattern_eval_ns": 937238, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.712441988950275, "pattern_frame_queries": 45250, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 937238, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.712441988950275, "pattern_frame_updates": 119428, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1315152166, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11012.092356901228, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13786, "avg_candidate_generations": 1723.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1006831, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.03285942260264, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 489, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 13778, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1006342, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 377439, "avg_legality_checks": 47179.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 783, "root_legality_checks": 489, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 376950, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 780, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1453031, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 181628.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3188613789, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2194.4568209487616, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11355, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1419.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 82872104, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7298.291853808895, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 805, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8373400, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5143, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 50288144, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4909, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19489058, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 498, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4721502, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 34274, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4284.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 335280106, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9782.345393009278, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 47332, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5916.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 157107630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3319.2687822192174, "stage_move_gen_ns": 937944574, "stage_ordering_ns": 431437247, "stage_eval_ns": 1316089404, "stage_threat_ns": 2466920593, "stage_proof_ns": 203372439, "tactical_annotations": 151302, "root_tactical_annotations": 1164, "search_tactical_annotations": 150138, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 121336, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 703331379, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 197047, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1649012012, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28196, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1085614935, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 60664, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 86013501, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1900, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9876267, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 121328, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14932627, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 38136, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 64215690, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 77851, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 357056476, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 35315, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3754807, "child_limit_applications": 13778, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13778, "child_cap_hits": 13778, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13778, "child_moves_before_total": 1005562, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1005562, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 220701, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 220701, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.9831615619103, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.018362607054726, "tt_hits": 5635, "tt_cutoffs": 686, "beta_cutoffs": 10818, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3511.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4511.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 924, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 4275, "avg_search_time_ms": 610.7142857142857, "search_nodes": 124619, "safety_nodes": 476, "corridor_nodes": 639, "corridor_branch_probes": 741, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 7, "corridor_depth_exits": 236, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 630, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 630, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 43, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 236, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 43, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 43, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 296, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 166400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 15600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 125734, "avg_nodes": 17962.0, "eval_calls": 121700, "avg_eval_calls": 17385.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 121700, "pattern_eval_ns": 2478201, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.36319638455218, "pattern_frame_queries": 121700, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2478201, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.36319638455218, "pattern_frame_updates": 249198, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2470859888, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9915.247666514177, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2906, "avg_candidate_generations": 415.14285714285717, "candidate_moves_total": 202972, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.84583620096352, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 418, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 2899, "search_candidate_moves_total": 202554, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 5113, "avg_legality_checks": 730.4285714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5113, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 625291, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 89327.28571428571, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1482876866, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2371.4988157513862, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11705, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1672.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 117888320, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10071.620674925245, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 78800, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11622, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 116960336, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 551873, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 297311, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14348210, "stage_ordering_ns": 92590, "stage_eval_ns": 2473338089, "stage_threat_ns": 1711854219, "stage_proof_ns": 69382458, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 250551, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1450442663, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 41231, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 49604579, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 488, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19485341, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 125272, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 170279878, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1346, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7288857, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 250544, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34238242, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 119, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2537, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3710.714285714286, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4853.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1955, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1647, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17905, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 142, 97, 98, 126, 70, 111, 157, 172, 141, 81, 66, 125, 139, 69, 83, 140, 85, 84, 113, 99, 129, 54 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8856, "avg_search_time_ms": 805.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 210619, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 688, "corridor_branch_probes": 804, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 236, "corridor_neutral_exits": 21, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 673, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 673, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 84, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 21, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 236, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 84, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 597, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 142640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 212120, "avg_nodes": 19283.636363636364, "eval_calls": 205259, "avg_eval_calls": 18659.909090909092, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 205259, "pattern_eval_ns": 4172627, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.328594604865074, "pattern_frame_queries": 205259, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4172627, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.328594604865074, "pattern_frame_updates": 421174, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5186479807, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12314.339933139272, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5339, "avg_candidate_generations": 485.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 392498, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.51526503090466, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 755, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 5328, "search_candidate_moves_total": 391743, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 201719, "avg_legality_checks": 18338.090909090908, "illegal_moves_skipped": 194, "root_legality_checks": 755, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 200964, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 193, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1627388, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 147944.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3860440847, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2372.1699109247456, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23113, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2101.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 201792601, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8730.697053606196, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 196, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1695232, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22715, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 198521388, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 508181, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 157, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1067800, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1485, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 135.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 14110588, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9502.079461279462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2085, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 189.54545454545453, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 7506446, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3600.213908872902, "stage_move_gen_ns": 505188845, "stage_ordering_ns": 168650, "stage_eval_ns": 5190652434, "stage_threat_ns": 2908549063, "stage_proof_ns": 229499516, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 422699, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2423328226, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45848, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 137714404, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 656, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 30814681, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 211344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 287019191, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1514, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8981248, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 422688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 51505994, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 245, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4763, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4173.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4901.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 345, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9036, "avg_search_time_ms": 821.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 62977, "safety_nodes": 652, "corridor_nodes": 1029, "corridor_branch_probes": 1196, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 343, "corridor_neutral_exits": 32, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 1014, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1014, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 68, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 343, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 81, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 609, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 398800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 13, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 9, "total_nodes": 64658, "avg_nodes": 5878.0, "eval_calls": 40376, "avg_eval_calls": 3670.5454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40376, "pattern_eval_ns": 855254, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.182236972458888, "pattern_frame_queries": 40376, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 855254, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.182236972458888, "pattern_frame_updates": 125860, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1139806233, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9056.143596059113, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21294, "avg_candidate_generations": 1935.8181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 1769281, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.08824081901005, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 783, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 21283, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1768498, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1322459, "avg_legality_checks": 120223.54545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1155, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1322459, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1155, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2967218, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 269747.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6033476277, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2033.3781599464548, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25591, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2326.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65009752, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2540.3365245594155, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1170, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11437017, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2746, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 23948032, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21657, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29440363, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 184340, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 120576, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10961.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1171348409, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9714.606629843418, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 173148, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15740.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 581647672, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3359.251461177721, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3123282404, "stage_ordering_ns": 713486622, "stage_eval_ns": 1140661487, "stage_threat_ns": 3866890860, "stage_proof_ns": 135344862, "tactical_annotations": 351823, "root_tactical_annotations": 1757, "search_tactical_annotations": 350066, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 128065, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 768778832, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 393504, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2966165770, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43473, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1509766941, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64027, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94577889, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2194, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12665183, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128054, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15818135, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 123091, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 628642697, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 157778, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 775469429, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 70954, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8885051, "child_limit_applications": 21283, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21283, "child_cap_hits": 21283, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21283, "child_moves_before_total": 1767343, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1767343, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 341221, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 341221, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.04012592209745, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.032561199079076, "tt_hits": 8968, "tt_cutoffs": 1271, "beta_cutoffs": 18665, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4961.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5688.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1851, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1648, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 59806, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 82, 97, 98, 95, 84, 126, 81, 83, 111, 94, 93, 110, 142, 80, 125, 66, 157, 172, 108, 65, 50, 64, 63, 78, 62, 109, 79, 70, 52, 48, 32, 68, 67, 69, 47, 55, 41, 77, 53, 51, 39, 25, 40, 42, 143, 100, 72, 124, 115, 138, 152, 139, 154, 129, 56, 24, 159, 175, 26, 71, 144, 145, 113, 140, 158, 128, 160, 156, 161 ], "move_count": 73, "black_stats": { "move_count": 37, "search_move_count": 35, "total_time_ms": 42083, "avg_search_time_ms": 1202.3714285714286, "search_nodes": 501298, "safety_nodes": 2422, "corridor_nodes": 18985, "corridor_branch_probes": 19640, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 9695, "corridor_neutral_exits": 63, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 18911, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 18911, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 31, "corridor_proof_completed": 27, "corridor_proof_checks": 232, "corridor_proof_active": 74, "corridor_proof_quiet": 158, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 63, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 9695, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 232, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 231, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 4, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1665, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 1040000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 22240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 522705, "avg_nodes": 14934.42857142857, "eval_calls": 385488, "avg_eval_calls": 11013.942857142858, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 385488, "pattern_eval_ns": 7919920, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.545179097663222, "pattern_frame_queries": 385488, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7919920, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.545179097663222, "pattern_frame_updates": 1002262, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 10373951538, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10350.53861964237, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 110352, "avg_candidate_generations": 3152.9142857142856, "candidate_moves_total": 11725585, "avg_candidate_moves": 106.25620740901842, "candidate_moves_max": 142, "root_candidate_generations": 35, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3263, "root_candidate_moves_max": 127, "search_candidate_generations": 110317, "search_candidate_moves_total": 11722322, "search_candidate_moves_max": 142, "legality_checks": 3917913, "avg_legality_checks": 111940.37142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 15731, "root_legality_checks": 3263, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "search_legality_checks": 3914650, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 15718, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13575885, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 387882.4285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 24528027180, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1806.735043792725, "renju_forbidden_checks": 356343, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 10181.228571428572, "renju_forbidden_ns": 802196933, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2251.193184656356, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21244, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 39232810, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 134042, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 459516024, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 184231, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 280134239, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16826, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 23313860, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 468422, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13383.485714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 3597921656, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7680.940809782632, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 635595, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18159.85714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1681145520, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2644.9948788143392, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8124166333, "stage_ordering_ns": 3399489266, "stage_eval_ns": 10381871458, "stage_threat_ns": 18347876159, "stage_proof_ns": 1624706041, "tactical_annotations": 2588263, "root_tactical_annotations": 8305, "search_tactical_annotations": 2579958, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1040583, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5500722360, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3181085, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11705497500, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 230605, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5561252461, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 520274, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 716368714, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 38286, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 250609716, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1040548, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 114579526, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1201637, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1437491892, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 959511, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3139002220, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 427115, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 60098343, "child_limit_applications": 110317, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 110317, "child_cap_hits": 110317, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 110317, "child_moves_before_total": 11706604, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 11706604, "child_moves_before_max": 142, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 142, "child_moves_after_total": 1822030, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1822030, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 106.11786034790649, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.516312082453293, "tt_hits": 44816, "tt_cutoffs": 5326, "beta_cutoffs": 88257, "depth_sum": 165, "avg_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 165, "avg_effective_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 31 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.17142857142857143, "pooled_budget_moves": 35, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.17142857142857143, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.17142857142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5609.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5773.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 36, "search_move_count": 34, "total_time_ms": 17688, "avg_search_time_ms": 520.2352941176471, "search_nodes": 716097, "safety_nodes": 3273, "corridor_nodes": 8364, "corridor_branch_probes": 9227, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3162, "corridor_neutral_exits": 189, "corridor_terminal_exits": 113, "corridor_plies_followed": 8291, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8291, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 32, "corridor_proof_completed": 32, "corridor_proof_checks": 290, "corridor_proof_active": 73, "corridor_proof_quiet": 217, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 189, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3162, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 113, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 290, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 290, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 2101, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 722720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 727734, "avg_nodes": 21403.941176470587, "eval_calls": 696197, "avg_eval_calls": 20476.382352941175, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 696197, "pattern_eval_ns": 14238912, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.45241792193876, "pattern_frame_queries": 696197, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 14238912, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.45241792193876, "pattern_frame_updates": 1431992, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8779233387, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6130.783822116325, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19833, "avg_candidate_generations": 583.3235294117648, "candidate_moves_total": 2019833, "avg_candidate_moves": 101.8420309585035, "candidate_moves_max": 139, "root_candidate_generations": 34, "root_candidate_moves_total": 3191, "root_candidate_moves_max": 126, "search_candidate_generations": 19799, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2016642, "search_candidate_moves_max": 139, "legality_checks": 45285, "avg_legality_checks": 1331.9117647058824, "illegal_moves_skipped": 124, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 45285, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 124, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3356782, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 98728.88235294117, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5964817877, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1776.9452639462438, "renju_forbidden_checks": 49698, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1461.7058823529412, "renju_forbidden_ns": 68655927, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1381.4625739466378, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 129, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 107011, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 49073, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 67284362, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 252, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 971833, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 244, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 292721, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 101935470, "stage_ordering_ns": 686784, "stage_eval_ns": 8793472299, "stage_threat_ns": 8223760678, "stage_proof_ns": 389250463, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1449188, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6614576207, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 473632, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 485498058, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 5901, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 221194949, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 724577, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 851494047, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 17162, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 122733033, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1449154, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 149459333, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 1333, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 17688, "depth_sum": 100, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 100, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 32 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.029411764705882353, "pooled_budget_moves": 34, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.029411764705882353, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.029411764705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 7272.088235294118, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7507.382352941177, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1942, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1649, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29810, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 126, 98, 154, 143, 113, 111, 52, 67, 95, 129, 140, 168, 81, 157, 115, 159, 175, 158, 65, 49, 156, 114, 144, 100, 86, 131, 130, 173, 188, 145, 187, 117 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 8048, "avg_search_time_ms": 473.4117647058824, "search_nodes": 194517, "safety_nodes": 1827, "corridor_nodes": 737, "corridor_branch_probes": 807, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 219, "corridor_neutral_exits": 35, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 104, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 83, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 35, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 219, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 104, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 659, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 200480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 197081, "avg_nodes": 11593.0, "eval_calls": 188964, "avg_eval_calls": 11115.529411764706, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 188964, "pattern_eval_ns": 3845609, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.351013949747042, "pattern_frame_queries": 188964, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3845609, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.351013949747042, "pattern_frame_updates": 388934, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4711045971, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12112.713136419032, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5520, "avg_candidate_generations": 324.70588235294116, "candidate_moves_total": 481294, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.1909420289855, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1447, "root_candidate_moves_max": 117, "search_candidate_generations": 5503, "search_candidate_moves_total": 479847, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 178248, "avg_legality_checks": 10485.176470588236, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "root_legality_checks": 1447, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 176801, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1668263, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 98133.11764705883, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3821700378, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2290.826073586719, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9334, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 549.0588235294117, "renju_forbidden_ns": 84588564, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9062.413113349046, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9220, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9186, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 84250303, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 98801, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 117, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 230240, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1165, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 68.52941176470588, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 10533589, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9041.70729613734, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1500, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 88.23529411764706, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 5322165, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3548.11, "stage_move_gen_ns": 418907518, "stage_ordering_ns": 177201, "stage_eval_ns": 4714891580, "stage_threat_ns": 2615235647, "stage_proof_ns": 270791045, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 390591, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2151106791, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 52603, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 147960372, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 858, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 36703781, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 195287, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 259109229, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1640, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11123536, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 390574, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45935719, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 302, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5004, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6512.823529411765, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6983.411764705882, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1784, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 21743, "avg_search_time_ms": 1279.0, "search_nodes": 181903, "safety_nodes": 696, "corridor_nodes": 7473, "corridor_branch_probes": 7870, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4087, "corridor_neutral_exits": 53, "corridor_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_plies_followed": 7444, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 7444, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 110, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 81, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 53, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4087, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 110, "corridor_proof_wins": 6, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 104, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 837, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2583520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1972240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 10, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 190072, "avg_nodes": 11180.70588235294, "eval_calls": 129948, "avg_eval_calls": 7644.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 129948, "pattern_eval_ns": 2707389, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.834402991966016, "pattern_frame_queries": 129948, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2707389, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.834402991966016, "pattern_frame_updates": 363652, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3231540522, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8886.354322264142, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 49083, "avg_candidate_generations": 2887.235294117647, "candidate_moves_total": 4966779, "avg_candidate_moves": 101.1914308416356, "candidate_moves_max": 134, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1494, "root_candidate_moves_max": 118, "search_candidate_generations": 49066, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4965285, "search_candidate_moves_max": 134, "legality_checks": 3590740, "avg_legality_checks": 211220.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3590740, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 13, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7055374, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 415022.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14132298274, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2003.0544481412326, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28147, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1655.7058823529412, "renju_forbidden_ns": 38290858, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1360.3886026930045, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 91, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 340972, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1265, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8853369, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26791, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29096517, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 202237, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11896.29411764706, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1873236127, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9262.57869232633, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 282927, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16642.764705882353, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 920417023, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3253.1961353988836, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8001511565, "stage_ordering_ns": 1774635152, "stage_eval_ns": 3234247911, "stage_threat_ns": 8494627714, "stage_proof_ns": 160942666, "tactical_annotations": 1072345, "root_tactical_annotations": 4836, "search_tactical_annotations": 1067509, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 378777, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2235230677, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1254455, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5806193845, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 101799, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3113345047, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 189380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 273502518, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 15108, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 97370234, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 378760, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45674764, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 427043, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1107649666, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 398402, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1365065123, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 246900, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 36655676, "child_limit_applications": 49066, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 49066, "child_cap_hits": 49066, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 49066, "child_moves_before_total": 4965272, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4965272, "child_moves_before_max": 134, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 134, "child_moves_after_total": 786221, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 786221, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 101.1957771165369, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.023743529124037, "tt_hits": 23218, "tt_cutoffs": 2812, "beta_cutoffs": 40605, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.29411764705882354, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5734.823529411765, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6205.411764705882, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1845, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1650, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10918, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 67, 82, 96, 98, 66, 113, 143, 114, 68, 65, 111, 130, 146, 126, 69, 70, 83, 125, 55 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8505, "avg_search_time_ms": 850.5, "search_nodes": 96214, "safety_nodes": 255, "corridor_nodes": 880, "corridor_branch_probes": 1017, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 357, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 26, "corridor_plies_followed": 870, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 870, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 357, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 416, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 479440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 26080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 97349, "avg_nodes": 9734.9, "eval_calls": 71556, "avg_eval_calls": 7155.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 71556, "pattern_eval_ns": 1478026, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.655514562021352, "pattern_frame_queries": 71556, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1478026, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.655514562021352, "pattern_frame_updates": 192344, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2123403261, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11039.612678326332, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23258, "avg_candidate_generations": 2325.8, "candidate_moves_total": 1683012, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.36271390489294, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 639, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 23248, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1682373, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 705666, "avg_legality_checks": 70566.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1376, "root_legality_checks": 639, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 705027, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1376, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2354433, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 235443.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5082889354, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2158.859204742713, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18855, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1885.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 114760772, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6086.490161760807, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1435, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13909969, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8613, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71708915, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8599, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28224034, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 208, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 917854, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53219, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5321.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 466753176, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8770.42364569045, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 73705, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7370.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 201733178, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2737.0351807882776, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1721831789, "stage_ordering_ns": 687585973, "stage_eval_ns": 2124881287, "stage_threat_ns": 3739372764, "stage_proof_ns": 191067648, "tactical_annotations": 288954, "root_tactical_annotations": 1872, "search_tactical_annotations": 287082, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 194202, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1108366512, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 324877, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2455535524, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47126, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1667124894, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 97096, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 133419790, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1848, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10463374, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 194192, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23164747, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71350, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 67449549, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 153198, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 596590749, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 64406, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8422817, "child_limit_applications": 23248, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23248, "child_cap_hits": 23248, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23248, "child_moves_before_total": 1680997, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1680997, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 373645, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 373645, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.30716620784584, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.07213523743978, "tt_hits": 8668, "tt_cutoffs": 1369, "beta_cutoffs": 18690, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 4.1, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 4.1, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3373.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4173.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2403, "avg_search_time_ms": 267.0, "search_nodes": 69720, "safety_nodes": 659, "corridor_nodes": 367, "corridor_branch_probes": 431, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 125, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 359, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 354, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 125, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 63, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 446, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 221760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 70746, "avg_nodes": 7860.666666666667, "eval_calls": 67181, "avg_eval_calls": 7464.555555555556, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67181, "pattern_eval_ns": 1363766, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.29987645316384, "pattern_frame_queries": 67181, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1363766, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.29987645316384, "pattern_frame_updates": 139388, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1339908317, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9612.795341062358, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2522, "avg_candidate_generations": 280.22222222222223, "candidate_moves_total": 178037, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.59357652656622, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 2513, "search_candidate_moves_total": 177457, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 4631, "avg_legality_checks": 514.5555555555555, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4631, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 428845, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 47649.444444444445, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 958798731, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2235.7698725646796, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3566, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 396.22222222222223, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31407165, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8807.3934380258, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3527, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31123994, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 31, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 274641, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8530, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 33, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.6666666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 304861, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9238.212121212122, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 43, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.777777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 135810, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3158.3720930232557, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11998563, "stage_ordering_ns": 83291, "stage_eval_ns": 1341272083, "stage_threat_ns": 924574549, "stage_proof_ns": 109789933, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 140243, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 780314059, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 25586, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 33089094, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 431, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 13686596, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70117, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90220657, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 846, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4532658, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 140234, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16418081, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 182, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2214, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5459.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6348.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1943, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1651, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15429, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 128, 64, 127, 115, 116, 129, 125, 124, 143, 159, 79, 95, 144, 65, 80, 97, 81, 83, 78 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6487, "avg_search_time_ms": 589.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 153980, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 992, "corridor_branch_probes": 1154, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 368, "corridor_neutral_exits": 21, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 974, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 974, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 84, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 66, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 21, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 368, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 84, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 597, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 170880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 155785, "avg_nodes": 14162.272727272728, "eval_calls": 149213, "avg_eval_calls": 13564.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 149213, "pattern_eval_ns": 3021173, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.24738461126041, "pattern_frame_queries": 149213, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3021173, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.24738461126041, "pattern_frame_updates": 307896, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3637848114, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11815.18471821654, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4746, "avg_candidate_generations": 431.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 335712, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.73577749683945, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 755, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 4735, "search_candidate_moves_total": 334957, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 144641, "avg_legality_checks": 13149.181818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 179, "root_legality_checks": 755, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 143886, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 178, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1245456, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 113223.27272727272, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2888778158, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2319.454206330854, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15051, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1368.2727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 125314514, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8325.992558633978, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 179, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1725320, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14599, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 121588305, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 643294, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 216, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1357595, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 193.27272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 19966532, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9391.595484477893, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2975, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 270.45454545454544, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 10550549, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3546.4030252100843, "stage_move_gen_ns": 358851546, "stage_ordering_ns": 151821, "stage_eval_ns": 3640869287, "stage_threat_ns": 2209176008, "stage_proof_ns": 259581004, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 310023, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1764714958, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 63034, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 185482413, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 792, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 39923228, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 155006, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 208680475, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2116, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12891716, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 310012, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37406446, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 245, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4243, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4829.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5557.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1696, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8934, "avg_search_time_ms": 812.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 63013, "safety_nodes": 652, "corridor_nodes": 920, "corridor_branch_probes": 1081, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 282, "corridor_neutral_exits": 41, "corridor_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_plies_followed": 905, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 905, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 68, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 43, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 282, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 81, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 609, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 435680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 13, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 9, "total_nodes": 64585, "avg_nodes": 5871.363636363636, "eval_calls": 40310, "avg_eval_calls": 3664.5454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40310, "pattern_eval_ns": 849078, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.063706276358225, "pattern_frame_queries": 40310, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 849078, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.063706276358225, "pattern_frame_updates": 125932, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1135743266, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9018.702680811866, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21334, "avg_candidate_generations": 1939.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 1764821, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.72339926877285, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 783, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 21323, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1764038, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1323739, "avg_legality_checks": 120339.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1144, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1323739, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1144, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2961003, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 269182.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5963769685, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2014.1045736866865, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26019, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2365.3636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 67576138, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2597.1842884046273, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1184, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11614615, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3222, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26682740, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21595, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29100961, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 177822, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 120196, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10926.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1157351933, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9628.872283603449, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 172394, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15672.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 575000598, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3335.386370755363, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3102476765, "stage_ordering_ns": 702583530, "stage_eval_ns": 1136592344, "stage_threat_ns": 3796483744, "stage_proof_ns": 136515870, "tactical_annotations": 351349, "root_tactical_annotations": 1757, "search_tactical_annotations": 349592, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 127919, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 762843135, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 387033, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2904309820, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43515, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1466320881, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 63954, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92729552, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1976, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10673296, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 127908, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15658029, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 123405, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 623024990, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 156320, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 766632659, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 71624, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10269912, "child_limit_applications": 21323, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21323, "child_cap_hits": 21323, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21323, "child_moves_before_total": 1762894, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1762894, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 341889, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 341889, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.67570229329831, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.033813253294564, "tt_hits": 9072, "tt_cutoffs": 1333, "beta_cutoffs": 18702, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4964.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5692.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1856, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1652, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 6753, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 96, 94, 142, 114, 128, 80, 143, 98, 144, 160, 145, 146, 141 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5563, "avg_search_time_ms": 695.375, "search_nodes": 64202, "safety_nodes": 448, "corridor_nodes": 916, "corridor_branch_probes": 1092, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 366, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 898, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 898, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 60, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 366, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 60, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 447, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23854880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 7, "total_nodes": 65566, "avg_nodes": 8195.75, "eval_calls": 48366, "avg_eval_calls": 6045.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48366, "pattern_eval_ns": 989741, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.463569449613363, "pattern_frame_queries": 48366, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 989741, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.463569449613363, "pattern_frame_updates": 128340, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1324208391, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10317.970944366527, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15171, "avg_candidate_generations": 1896.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1129124, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.42647155757696, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 489, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 15163, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1128635, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 390293, "avg_legality_checks": 48786.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 635, "root_legality_checks": 489, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 389804, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 632, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1489851, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 186231.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3254610877, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2184.521054118835, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10757, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1344.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 76712755, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7131.4265129683, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 651, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6893312, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4706, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 45277101, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4870, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19298453, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 530, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5243889, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 33022, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4127.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 316348560, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9579.933377748168, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 45798, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5724.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 145553225, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3178.156797240054, "stage_move_gen_ns": 959338608, "stage_ordering_ns": 475132553, "stage_eval_ns": 1325198132, "stage_threat_ns": 2565169590, "stage_proof_ns": 213913674, "tactical_annotations": 167585, "root_tactical_annotations": 1164, "search_tactical_annotations": 166421, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 130264, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 737876680, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 219272, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1706514690, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30984, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1135338203, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 65128, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90858436, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1916, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10298979, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 130256, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15320521, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 41701, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 62717770, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 89548, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 358025180, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 36336, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4300284, "child_limit_applications": 15163, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15163, "child_cap_hits": 15163, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15163, "child_moves_before_total": 1128003, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1128003, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 242695, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 242695, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.39180900877135, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00573765086065, "tt_hits": 5669, "tt_cutoffs": 641, "beta_cutoffs": 12002, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3471.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4471.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 964, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 1182, "avg_search_time_ms": 168.85714285714286, "search_nodes": 35686, "safety_nodes": 476, "corridor_nodes": 511, "corridor_branch_probes": 605, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 9, "corridor_depth_exits": 186, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 502, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 502, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 43, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 186, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 43, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 43, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 296, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 173360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 36673, "avg_nodes": 5239.0, "eval_calls": 33872, "avg_eval_calls": 4838.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33872, "pattern_eval_ns": 685113, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.2265292867265, "pattern_frame_queries": 33872, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 685113, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.2265292867265, "pattern_frame_updates": 71332, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 577498352, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8095.922615375988, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1801, "avg_candidate_generations": 257.2857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 123911, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.80122154358689, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 418, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 1794, "search_candidate_moves_total": 123493, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 4161, "avg_legality_checks": 594.4285714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4161, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 176380, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 25197.14285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 404838586, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2295.2635559587256, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1283, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 183.28571428571428, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12894360, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10050.16367887763, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 66640, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1220, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12189547, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 31, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 342792, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 295381, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11095384, "stage_ordering_ns": 58110, "stage_eval_ns": 578183465, "stage_threat_ns": 510071852, "stage_proof_ns": 71262386, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 72429, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 409576881, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 32991, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 39075409, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 426, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15299494, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 36211, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 47023286, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1090, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5855486, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 72422, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8540790, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 119, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1572, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4813.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5956.285714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1967, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1653, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17857, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 96, 160, 97, 108, 109, 95, 129, 145, 127, 130, 99, 100, 115, 144, 176, 85, 157, 143, 141, 155, 125, 173, 93 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8163, "avg_search_time_ms": 627.9230769230769, "search_nodes": 178022, "safety_nodes": 1100, "corridor_nodes": 2972, "corridor_branch_probes": 3630, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1312, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 2943, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2938, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 95, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 66, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1312, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 95, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 94, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 633, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 247600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 182094, "avg_nodes": 14007.23076923077, "eval_calls": 173048, "avg_eval_calls": 13311.384615384615, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 173048, "pattern_eval_ns": 3529373, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.39534117701447, "pattern_frame_queries": 173048, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3529373, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.39534117701447, "pattern_frame_updates": 355968, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4314796075, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12121.303249168464, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4949, "avg_candidate_generations": 380.6923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 354620, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.65487977369166, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 891, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 4936, "search_candidate_moves_total": 353729, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 170058, "avg_legality_checks": 13081.384615384615, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 891, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 169167, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1684885, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 129606.53846153847, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3792816669, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2251.0834086599384, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15118, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1162.923076923077, "renju_forbidden_ns": 145691578, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9636.961105966398, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 31040, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14921, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 144099984, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 71, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 752841, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 121, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 807713, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 7673, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 590.2307692307693, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 75986677, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9903.124853381989, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11271, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 867.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 42467673, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3767.8709076390737, "stage_move_gen_ns": 421443659, "stage_ordering_ns": 159331, "stage_eval_ns": 4318325448, "stage_threat_ns": 2950835194, "stage_proof_ns": 459803417, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 362057, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2112968130, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 167718, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 502136717, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1481, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 97077119, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 181022, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 249256694, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6076, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 38503399, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 362044, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47970254, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 245, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4431, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5577.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6192.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1788, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 9682, "avg_search_time_ms": 744.7692307692307, "search_nodes": 72001, "safety_nodes": 535, "corridor_nodes": 1812, "corridor_branch_probes": 2062, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 704, "corridor_neutral_exits": 31, "corridor_terminal_exits": 29, "corridor_plies_followed": 1792, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1792, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 78, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 58, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 35, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 704, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 29, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 78, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 76, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 575, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 417680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 74348, "avg_nodes": 5719.076923076923, "eval_calls": 47600, "avg_eval_calls": 3661.5384615384614, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47600, "pattern_eval_ns": 1011416, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.24823529411765, "pattern_frame_queries": 47600, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1011416, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.24823529411765, "pattern_frame_updates": 143888, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1250606629, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8691.528334537974, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23185, "avg_candidate_generations": 1783.4615384615386, "candidate_moves_total": 1918324, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.73987491912875, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 925, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 23172, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1917399, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1419502, "avg_legality_checks": 109192.46153846153, "illegal_moves_skipped": 38, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1419502, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 38, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3171061, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 243927.76923076922, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6416873423, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2023.5730006455253, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7741, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 595.4615384615385, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13251896, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1711.9100891357705, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 38, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 389341, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 926, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8906596, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6777, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3955959, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 118734, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9133.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1161432694, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9781.80381356646, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 173330, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13333.076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 593035711, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3421.425667801304, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3299839931, "stage_ordering_ns": 768805745, "stage_eval_ns": 1251618045, "stage_threat_ns": 4183130960, "stage_proof_ns": 122225503, "tactical_annotations": 381228, "root_tactical_annotations": 2233, "search_tactical_annotations": 378995, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 147641, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 886247344, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 448332, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3136726228, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47571, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1655695744, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 73814, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108229380, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3740, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 23019238, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 147628, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18581896, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 130361, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 595873981, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 160847, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 803967109, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 90020, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10326874, "child_limit_applications": 23172, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23172, "child_cap_hits": 23172, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23172, "child_moves_before_total": 1917361, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1917361, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 372778, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 372778, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.74473502503021, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.087433108924564, "tt_hits": 10487, "tt_cutoffs": 1172, "beta_cutoffs": 20138, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5617.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6232.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1865, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1654, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 10907, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 83, 144, 96, 95, 99, 127, 68, 53, 100, 97, 101, 102, 143, 67, 82, 81, 109, 39 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9225, "avg_search_time_ms": 838.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 94448, "safety_nodes": 288, "corridor_nodes": 3230, "corridor_branch_probes": 3428, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1649, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 3206, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3206, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 84, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 60, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1649, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 84, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 81, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 684, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24008720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1970560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 97966, "avg_nodes": 8906.0, "eval_calls": 72140, "avg_eval_calls": 6558.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72140, "pattern_eval_ns": 1479895, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.514208483504298, "pattern_frame_queries": 72140, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1479895, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.514208483504298, "pattern_frame_updates": 188802, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2134245655, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11304.147493140963, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21403, "avg_candidate_generations": 1945.7272727272727, "candidate_moves_total": 1637081, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.48838947811055, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 716, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 21392, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1636365, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 629551, "avg_legality_checks": 57231.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3899, "root_legality_checks": 716, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "search_legality_checks": 628835, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2595423, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 235947.54545454544, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5537649037, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2133.621007828011, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24105, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2191.3636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 150834367, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6257.389213856047, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3949, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 41842925, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10106, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 77622167, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9378, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25012688, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 672, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6356587, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81301, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7391.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 737672469, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9073.35049999385, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109056, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9914.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 329037781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3017.1451456132627, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1575457446, "stage_ordering_ns": 684812123, "stage_eval_ns": 2135725550, "stage_threat_ns": 4343862092, "stage_proof_ns": 452176978, "tactical_annotations": 272745, "root_tactical_annotations": 1806, "search_tactical_annotations": 270939, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 195393, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1163393900, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 422753, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2971998029, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44543, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1667015574, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 97691, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 142114039, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6580, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 35443641, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 195382, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23698961, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70875, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 182259540, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 144816, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 692562750, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 57054, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7213522, "child_limit_applications": 21392, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21392, "child_cap_hits": 21392, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21392, "child_moves_before_total": 1632476, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1632476, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 342814, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 342814, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.31245325355273, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.025336574420344, "tt_hits": 8499, "tt_cutoffs": 869, "beta_cutoffs": 16707, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4378.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5105.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 885, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 1672, "avg_search_time_ms": 167.2, "search_nodes": 47429, "safety_nodes": 915, "corridor_nodes": 905, "corridor_branch_probes": 1049, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 413, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 894, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 889, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 413, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 330, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 89680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49249, "avg_nodes": 4924.9, "eval_calls": 44922, "avg_eval_calls": 4492.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44922, "pattern_eval_ns": 912661, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.31657094519389, "pattern_frame_queries": 44922, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 912661, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.31657094519389, "pattern_frame_updates": 94800, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 851207034, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8978.977151898735, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2488, "avg_candidate_generations": 248.8, "candidate_moves_total": 175176, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.40836012861736, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 650, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 2478, "search_candidate_moves_total": 174526, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 5079, "avg_legality_checks": 507.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5079, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 263818, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26381.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 598808634, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2269.7792948168812, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3898, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 389.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 34305698, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8800.84607491021, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 233642, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3690, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 32595983, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 81, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 442473, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 103, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1033600, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 38, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 324692, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8544.526315789473, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 48, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 147042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3063.375, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14057103, "stage_ordering_ns": 78291, "stage_eval_ns": 852119695, "stage_threat_ns": 702385452, "stage_proof_ns": 88266326, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 96708, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 556675745, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 50408, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 58087189, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 565, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20500308, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48349, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 64619803, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1898, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11420127, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 96698, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11582588, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 131, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2215, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5818.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6618.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1955, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1655, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16265, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 95, 114, 100, 156, 170, 143, 98, 158, 173, 99, 84, 126, 67, 82, 70, 56, 174, 144, 94, 96, 172, 171, 141, 159, 129, 157, 155, 160 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 6068, "avg_search_time_ms": 404.53333333333336, "search_nodes": 109530, "safety_nodes": 1647, "corridor_nodes": 3038, "corridor_branch_probes": 3580, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1232, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 3000, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2967, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 33, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 94, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1232, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 94, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 5, "corridor_proof_unknown": 89, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 557, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 265120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 20880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 114215, "avg_nodes": 7614.333333333333, "eval_calls": 105697, "avg_eval_calls": 7046.466666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105697, "pattern_eval_ns": 2145720, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.300670785358147, "pattern_frame_queries": 105697, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2145720, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.300670785358147, "pattern_frame_updates": 218972, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3252558135, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14853.76274135506, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3804, "avg_candidate_generations": 253.6, "candidate_moves_total": 326703, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.88406940063092, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1149, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 3789, "search_candidate_moves_total": 325554, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 103031, "avg_legality_checks": 6868.733333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 684, "root_legality_checks": 1149, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 101882, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 678, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1481450, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 98763.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3265921335, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2204.5437476796383, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28022, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1868.1333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 245491072, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8760.654913996146, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 692, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6586855, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 25604, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 229731143, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 430, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2634382, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1296, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6538692, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 8494, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 566.2666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 82845307, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9753.391452790205, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11088, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 739.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 44214526, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3987.6015512265512, "stage_move_gen_ns": 249555117, "stage_ordering_ns": 119010, "stage_eval_ns": 3254703855, "stage_threat_ns": 2053333084, "stage_proof_ns": 484147061, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 225175, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1266663572, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 182069, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 568954526, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1659, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 112374522, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 112580, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 152232688, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6188, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 39039622, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 225160, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26442676, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 193, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3465, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6538.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7071.733333333334, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1837, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 10182, "avg_search_time_ms": 678.8, "search_nodes": 68450, "safety_nodes": 976, "corridor_nodes": 2195, "corridor_branch_probes": 2537, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 843, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 79, "corridor_plies_followed": 2168, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1988, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 180, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 843, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 79, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 453, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 179120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 16560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 71621, "avg_nodes": 4774.733333333334, "eval_calls": 45267, "avg_eval_calls": 3017.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 45267, "pattern_eval_ns": 948702, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.95791636291338, "pattern_frame_queries": 45267, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 948702, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.95791636291338, "pattern_frame_updates": 136766, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1460192871, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10676.578031089599, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21746, "avg_candidate_generations": 1449.7333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1938412, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.13878414421043, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1193, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 21731, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1937219, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1440846, "avg_legality_checks": 96056.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6519, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1440846, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6519, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3268344, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 217889.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6664560782, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2039.1246398787887, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65797, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4386.466666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 205214910, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3118.909828715595, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8439, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 72110554, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9168, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 51390261, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 47905, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 80636642, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 285, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1077453, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 130549, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8703.266666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1307159933, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10012.791618472756, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 171336, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11422.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 652273477, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3806.9843874025305, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3437766581, "stage_ordering_ns": 761800002, "stage_eval_ns": 1461141573, "stage_threat_ns": 4340409085, "stage_proof_ns": 117270598, "tactical_annotations": 469159, "root_tactical_annotations": 2060, "search_tactical_annotations": 467099, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 141255, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 875038054, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 534004, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3303598056, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44779, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1591949068, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70620, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105061561, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4474, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24942675, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 141240, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17842566, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 162850, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 717268387, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 195627, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 878045410, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110682, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13926173, "child_limit_applications": 21731, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21731, "child_cap_hits": 21731, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21731, "child_moves_before_total": 1930700, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1930700, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 349117, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 349117, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.84542819014311, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.065390456030556, "tt_hits": 10030, "tt_cutoffs": 1385, "beta_cutoffs": 18871, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5755.933333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6289.266666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1838, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1656, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19684, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 98, 143, 82, 97, 126, 84, 50, 66, 81, 140, 80, 79, 95, 65, 67, 109, 51, 94, 53, 39, 52, 49, 54 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 11426, "avg_search_time_ms": 952.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 122291, "safety_nodes": 395, "corridor_nodes": 1046, "corridor_branch_probes": 1188, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 289, "corridor_neutral_exits": 83, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1010, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1010, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 145, "corridor_proof_active": 36, "corridor_proof_quiet": 109, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 83, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 289, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 145, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 144, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1225, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 860480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 123732, "avg_nodes": 10311.0, "eval_calls": 83714, "avg_eval_calls": 6976.166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83714, "pattern_eval_ns": 1728065, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.64248512793559, "pattern_frame_queries": 83714, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1728065, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.64248512793559, "pattern_frame_updates": 244478, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2491994064, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10193.12193326189, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35846, "avg_candidate_generations": 2987.1666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2755252, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.86358310550689, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 779, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 35834, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2754473, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 906732, "avg_legality_checks": 75561.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 131, "root_legality_checks": 779, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 905953, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 131, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3125906, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 260492.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6794431037, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2173.5877652750914, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12987, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1082.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 40112331, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3088.6525756525757, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 145, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1359702, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3663, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26732676, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9167, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11995373, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 24580, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 63139, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5261.583333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 554556726, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8783.109108474951, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84229, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7019.083333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 238079363, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2826.5723563143333, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2175343023, "stage_ordering_ns": 1112281305, "stage_eval_ns": 2493722129, "stage_threat_ns": 5196865185, "stage_proof_ns": 401881587, "tactical_annotations": 433390, "root_tactical_annotations": 2716, "search_tactical_annotations": 430674, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 246800, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1412968272, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 505129, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3557518698, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 72887, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2528774851, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123394, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 174555414, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2310, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11995725, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 246788, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29708940, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 130861, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 116181200, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 221867, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 738848328, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 80662, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10118136, "child_limit_applications": 35834, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35834, "child_cap_hits": 35834, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35834, "child_moves_before_total": 2754342, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2754342, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 573348, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 573348, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.86392811296534, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00011162583022, "tt_hits": 14799, "tt_cutoffs": 2691, "beta_cutoffs": 30391, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4098.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4765.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 651, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8248, "avg_search_time_ms": 749.8181818181819, "search_nodes": 264348, "safety_nodes": 913, "corridor_nodes": 963, "corridor_branch_probes": 1124, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 379, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 945, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 945, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 379, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 353, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 137840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 266224, "avg_nodes": 24202.18181818182, "eval_calls": 259733, "avg_eval_calls": 23612.090909090908, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 259733, "pattern_eval_ns": 5239087, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.171048730812025, "pattern_frame_queries": 259733, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5239087, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.171048730812025, "pattern_frame_updates": 528632, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4676132613, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8845.723703824211, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4594, "avg_candidate_generations": 417.6363636363636, "candidate_moves_total": 357241, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.76251632564214, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 723, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 4583, "search_candidate_moves_total": 356518, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 9468, "avg_legality_checks": 860.7272727272727, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9468, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1329644, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 120876.72727272728, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2943834367, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2214.0019185586516, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3156, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 286.90909090909093, "renju_forbidden_ns": 22361960, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7085.538656527249, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3142, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22315620, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 46340, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 24730210, "stage_ordering_ns": 139551, "stage_eval_ns": 4681371700, "stage_threat_ns": 3426986931, "stage_proof_ns": 95021393, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 530655, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2933076408, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 59493, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 72395973, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 688, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 28820491, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 265322, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 346554449, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2012, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11701405, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 530644, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 63258696, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 175, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4235, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5567.636363636364, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6294.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1781, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1657, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12116, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 80, 99, 141, 71, 85, 128, 125, 129, 130, 65, 109, 108, 93, 77, 157 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4143, "avg_search_time_ms": 460.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 92008, "safety_nodes": 510, "corridor_nodes": 374, "corridor_branch_probes": 445, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 116, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 366, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 366, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 116, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 287, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 101360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 92892, "avg_nodes": 10321.333333333334, "eval_calls": 89400, "avg_eval_calls": 9933.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 89400, "pattern_eval_ns": 1873144, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.952393736017896, "pattern_frame_queries": 89400, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1873144, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.952393736017896, "pattern_frame_updates": 183966, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2456046583, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13350.546204189905, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2592, "avg_candidate_generations": 288.0, "candidate_moves_total": 190185, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.3738425925926, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 628, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 2583, "search_candidate_moves_total": 189557, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 87211, "avg_legality_checks": 9690.111111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "root_legality_checks": 628, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 86583, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 17, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 793979, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 88219.88888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1960886374, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2469.695513357406, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8299, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 922.1111111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 67683449, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8155.615013857091, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 187592, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8164, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 66760603, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 363602, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 80, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 371652, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 124.11111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 11439094, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10240.907788719785, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1496, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 166.22222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 5962399, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3985.5608288770054, "stage_move_gen_ns": 222436779, "stage_ordering_ns": 86510, "stage_eval_ns": 2457919727, "stage_threat_ns": 1324182426, "stage_proof_ns": 122992627, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 184789, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1082350366, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 26858, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 84815163, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 337, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 18212730, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92390, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 130052884, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 814, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4144495, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 184780, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22819518, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 256, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2213, "depth_sum": 25, "avg_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 25, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7777777777777777, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5225.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6113.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1842, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 7963, "avg_search_time_ms": 995.375, "search_nodes": 60361, "safety_nodes": 553, "corridor_nodes": 1046, "corridor_branch_probes": 1222, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 448, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1034, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1034, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 42, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 448, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 42, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 42, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 296, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 192480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 16560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 61960, "avg_nodes": 7745.0, "eval_calls": 41244, "avg_eval_calls": 5155.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41244, "pattern_eval_ns": 881783, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.379667345553294, "pattern_frame_queries": 41244, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 881783, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.379667345553294, "pattern_frame_updates": 120652, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1284021358, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10642.354523754268, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17938, "avg_candidate_generations": 2242.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1461629, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.4822722711562, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 555, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 17930, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1461074, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 1055867, "avg_legality_checks": 131983.375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 691, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1055867, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 691, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2454491, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 306811.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5248905986, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2138.490622291954, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15015, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1876.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 39170172, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2608.736063936064, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 697, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6897766, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1876, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14071012, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12442, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18201394, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 95800, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11975.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 882743015, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9214.436482254698, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 127792, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15974.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 388567969, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3040.628278765494, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2579455868, "stage_ordering_ns": 620493236, "stage_eval_ns": 1284903141, "stage_threat_ns": 3367863608, "stage_proof_ns": 65381331, "tactical_annotations": 262816, "root_tactical_annotations": 981, "search_tactical_annotations": 261835, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 122812, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 747115726, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 315811, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2497403821, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36482, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1316897036, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61402, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90638984, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2152, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10660958, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 122804, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15413105, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52969, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 277678559, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 163639, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 850062318, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 46208, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6631014, "child_limit_applications": 17930, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17930, "child_cap_hits": 17930, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17930, "child_moves_before_total": 1460383, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1460383, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 286927, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 286927, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.44913552704963, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.002621305075294, "tt_hits": 5383, "tt_cutoffs": 1152, "beta_cutoffs": 15276, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2546.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3546.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 550, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1658, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13351, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 99, 141, 109, 140, 95, 97, 139, 67, 124, 82, 52, 94, 123, 81, 155, 83, 69, 80, 84, 79 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9225, "avg_search_time_ms": 768.75, "search_nodes": 90402, "safety_nodes": 900, "corridor_nodes": 1719, "corridor_branch_probes": 1956, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 536, "corridor_neutral_exits": 79, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 1680, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1680, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 106, "corridor_proof_active": 39, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 79, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 536, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 106, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 105, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 776, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24289840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 93021, "avg_nodes": 7751.75, "eval_calls": 67607, "avg_eval_calls": 5633.916666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67607, "pattern_eval_ns": 1476478, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.83912908426642, "pattern_frame_queries": 67607, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1476478, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.83912908426642, "pattern_frame_updates": 180700, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2136992851, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11826.19175982291, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21891, "avg_candidate_generations": 1824.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1640447, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.93705175642958, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 742, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 21879, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1639705, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 705127, "avg_legality_checks": 58760.583333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 731, "root_legality_checks": 742, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 704385, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 730, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2440572, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 203381.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5588811954, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2289.9598757996077, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11872, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 989.3333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61338586, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5166.659871967655, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 755, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8446299, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4470, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37758257, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6457, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13943823, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 190, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1190207, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 57316, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4776.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 494903542, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8634.648998534441, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72131, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6010.916666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 193868888, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2687.7332630907654, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1792758007, "stage_ordering_ns": 731848846, "stage_eval_ns": 2138469329, "stage_threat_ns": 4088192305, "stage_proof_ns": 433270270, "tactical_annotations": 280629, "root_tactical_annotations": 1377, "search_tactical_annotations": 279252, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 184284, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1155060825, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 393818, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2737766894, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45113, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1753949268, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92136, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 143041547, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3572, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20815282, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 184272, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23918019, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 78565, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 95730110, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 148265, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 600682911, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53799, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7589738, "child_limit_applications": 21879, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21879, "child_cap_hits": 21879, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21879, "child_moves_before_total": 1638975, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1638975, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 350067, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 350067, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.9108734402852, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000137117784178, "tt_hits": 8191, "tt_cutoffs": 864, "beta_cutoffs": 17458, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4731.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5398.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1117, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4115, "avg_search_time_ms": 374.09090909090907, "search_nodes": 111074, "safety_nodes": 518, "corridor_nodes": 3431, "corridor_branch_probes": 3749, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1411, "corridor_neutral_exits": 44, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 3407, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3407, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 68, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 44, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1411, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 92, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 705, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 301040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 115023, "avg_nodes": 10456.636363636364, "eval_calls": 107038, "avg_eval_calls": 9730.727272727272, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107038, "pattern_eval_ns": 2313908, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.61763112165773, "pattern_frame_queries": 107038, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2313908, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.61763112165773, "pattern_frame_updates": 222084, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2091531204, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9417.748257416113, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4015, "avg_candidate_generations": 365.0, "candidate_moves_total": 296538, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.85753424657534, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 678, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 4004, "search_candidate_moves_total": 295860, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 10181, "avg_legality_checks": 925.5454545454545, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10181, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 650216, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 59110.545454545456, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1511962109, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2325.3228296443026, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2927, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 266.09090909090907, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16173574, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5525.648787154083, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34990, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2844, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15881072, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 67, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 92811, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 164701, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 27728723, "stage_ordering_ns": 148141, "stage_eval_ns": 2093845112, "stage_threat_ns": 1835811969, "stage_proof_ns": 140666613, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 229093, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1367712978, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 202006, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 237635236, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2196, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 97868846, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 114541, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 160618100, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6998, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 41136940, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 229082, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28708715, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 316, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3520, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5959.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6686.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1972, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1659, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13471, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 159, 143, 126, 83, 141, 156, 84, 113, 129, 67, 52, 65, 49, 79, 80, 128, 98, 115, 51, 114, 116, 142, 100, 170 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 8443, "avg_search_time_ms": 603.0714285714286, "search_nodes": 113602, "safety_nodes": 1186, "corridor_nodes": 10329, "corridor_branch_probes": 12077, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4788, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 162, "corridor_plies_followed": 10290, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 10290, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 104, "corridor_proof_active": 39, "corridor_proof_quiet": 65, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4788, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 162, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 104, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 694, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 377120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 25200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 125117, "avg_nodes": 8936.92857142857, "eval_calls": 109782, "avg_eval_calls": 7841.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 109782, "pattern_eval_ns": 2366360, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.555081889562953, "pattern_frame_queries": 109782, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2366360, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.555081889562953, "pattern_frame_updates": 227124, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3123079469, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13750.548022225745, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3794, "avg_candidate_generations": 271.0, "candidate_moves_total": 292992, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.22509225092251, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 954, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 3780, "search_candidate_moves_total": 292038, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 105961, "avg_legality_checks": 7568.642857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 581, "root_legality_checks": 954, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 105007, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 579, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2298044, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 164146.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4969578963, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2162.5255926344316, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23381, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1670.0714285714287, "renju_forbidden_ns": 167258163, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7153.5932167144265, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 585, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4906080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18892, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 137545917, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 816, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9547393, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3088, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 15258773, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 30225, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2158.9285714285716, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 299815566, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9919.456277915633, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41329, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2952.0714285714284, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 154450389, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3737.094751869148, "stage_move_gen_ns": 256609631, "stage_ordering_ns": 137651, "stage_eval_ns": 3125445829, "stage_threat_ns": 3797207211, "stage_proof_ns": 1232896073, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 247926, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1563443049, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 554919, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1888096995, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 5274, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 348423054, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123956, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 183400478, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 20788, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 131609015, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 247912, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30657674, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 328, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3302, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6368.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6939.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1827, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 5011, "avg_search_time_ms": 385.46153846153845, "search_nodes": 41167, "safety_nodes": 1089, "corridor_nodes": 409, "corridor_branch_probes": 526, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 133, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 399, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 399, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 49, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 39, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 133, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 49, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 49, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 301, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 82960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 42665, "avg_nodes": 3281.923076923077, "eval_calls": 27835, "avg_eval_calls": 2141.153846153846, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 27835, "pattern_eval_ns": 611312, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.961990299982038, "pattern_frame_queries": 27835, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 611312, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.961990299982038, "pattern_frame_updates": 82214, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 897523984, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10916.923930230862, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12475, "avg_candidate_generations": 959.6153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 906195, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.64088176352705, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 888, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 12462, "search_candidate_moves_total": 905307, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 532989, "avg_legality_checks": 40999.153846153844, "illegal_moves_skipped": 236, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 532989, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 236, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1486519, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 114347.61538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3209221963, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2158.8839180663012, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6933, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 533.3076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20349726, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2935.197749891822, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 238, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2118417, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1805, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11612921, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4876, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6482196, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 14, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 136192, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 54447, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4188.2307692307695, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 547335509, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10052.62932760299, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76876, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5913.538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 264330689, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3438.4032597949945, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1336363928, "stage_ordering_ns": 389622924, "stage_eval_ns": 898135296, "stage_threat_ns": 2264557368, "stage_proof_ns": 85074765, "tactical_annotations": 188940, "root_tactical_annotations": 571, "search_tactical_annotations": 188369, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 83123, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 527309991, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 209667, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1655006510, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 25374, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 921573092, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 41555, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 62436768, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 896, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5391243, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 83110, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10822001, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44158, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 200976373, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 112560, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 510640403, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 32222, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3590855, "child_limit_applications": 12462, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12462, "child_cap_hits": 12462, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12462, "child_moves_before_total": 905071, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 905071, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 200255, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 200255, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.62646445193388, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.06925052158562, "tt_hits": 4162, "tt_cutoffs": 810, "beta_cutoffs": 10656, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5663.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6278.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1834, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1660, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23296, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 81, 126, 67, 82, 39, 53, 65, 49, 68, 66, 50, 141, 156, 110, 35, 80, 51, 124, 138, 83, 37, 79, 20, 5, 36, 38, 52, 84, 4 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 16051, "avg_search_time_ms": 1070.0666666666666, "search_nodes": 177856, "safety_nodes": 416, "corridor_nodes": 4817, "corridor_branch_probes": 5010, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2538, "corridor_neutral_exits": 88, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 4772, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4772, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 133, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 88, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 88, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2538, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 133, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 130, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1093, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 949680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 183089, "avg_nodes": 12205.933333333332, "eval_calls": 132457, "avg_eval_calls": 8830.466666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 132457, "pattern_eval_ns": 2907915, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.953652883577313, "pattern_frame_queries": 132457, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2907915, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.953652883577313, "pattern_frame_updates": 355578, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4015794216, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11293.70831716248, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41854, "avg_candidate_generations": 2790.266666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 3398624, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.20189229225403, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1084, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 41839, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3397540, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1139455, "avg_legality_checks": 75963.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 262, "root_legality_checks": 1084, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1138371, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 262, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4447458, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 296497.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9508885264, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2138.04947995012, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36556, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2437.0666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 90385979, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2472.534713863661, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 430, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2138240, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15316, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57932660, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19603, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28482969, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1207, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1832110, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 118224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7881.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 918853688, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7772.141764785492, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 147961, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9864.066666666668, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 367814698, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2485.8895114253082, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2760441624, "stage_ordering_ns": 1291716826, "stage_eval_ns": 4018702131, "stage_threat_ns": 7243476998, "stage_proof_ns": 665732684, "tactical_annotations": 773771, "root_tactical_annotations": 3779, "search_tactical_annotations": 769992, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 365403, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2174896798, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 912473, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4664626672, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 86339, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2822344979, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 182694, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 270866014, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9810, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 62978274, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 365388, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46079955, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 265398, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 246196846, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 333332, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1102900097, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 175041, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24029285, "child_limit_applications": 41839, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41839, "child_cap_hits": 41839, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41839, "child_moves_before_total": 3397278, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3397278, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 670239, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 670239, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.1988336241306, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.019479433064845, "tt_hits": 19304, "tt_cutoffs": 3493, "beta_cutoffs": 33185, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5267.066666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5800.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 654, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 7227, "avg_search_time_ms": 516.2142857142857, "search_nodes": 234843, "safety_nodes": 1418, "corridor_nodes": 676, "corridor_branch_probes": 859, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 8, "corridor_depth_exits": 249, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 664, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 664, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 62, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 249, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 62, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 346, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 113200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 236937, "avg_nodes": 16924.071428571428, "eval_calls": 230217, "avg_eval_calls": 16444.071428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 230217, "pattern_eval_ns": 4952130, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.510705117345807, "pattern_frame_queries": 230217, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4952130, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.510705117345807, "pattern_frame_updates": 469604, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3915904535, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8338.73760657916, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4599, "avg_candidate_generations": 328.5, "candidate_moves_total": 360586, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.40530550119591, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1033, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 4585, "search_candidate_moves_total": 359553, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 11067, "avg_legality_checks": 790.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11067, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1082865, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 77347.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2434238553, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2247.9612444764584, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4334, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 309.57142857142856, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33627458, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7758.988924780803, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4319, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33559478, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 67980, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 28345881, "stage_ordering_ns": 165310, "stage_eval_ns": 3920856665, "stage_threat_ns": 3132316494, "stage_proof_ns": 106300546, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 471070, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2690784074, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 42171, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 53010564, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 556, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 19957487, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 235528, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 317530437, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1452, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9225724, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 471056, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61765695, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 181, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4251, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6193.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6764.928571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1783, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1661, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9359, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 110, 109, 82, 124, 126, 81, 94, 78, 144, 128, 142, 158, 141, 156, 143, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6792, "avg_search_time_ms": 617.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 115205, "safety_nodes": 282, "corridor_nodes": 6208, "corridor_branch_probes": 6499, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2984, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 6182, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6182, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 79, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2984, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 79, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 75, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 581, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 186400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 121695, "avg_nodes": 11063.181818181818, "eval_calls": 110978, "avg_eval_calls": 10088.90909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 110978, "pattern_eval_ns": 2381894, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.462758384544685, "pattern_frame_queries": 110978, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2381894, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.462758384544685, "pattern_frame_updates": 230348, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2851823964, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12380.502387691666, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4207, "avg_candidate_generations": 382.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 297484, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.71167102448301, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 687, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 4196, "search_candidate_moves_total": 296797, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 104845, "avg_legality_checks": 9531.363636363636, "illegal_moves_skipped": 135, "root_legality_checks": 687, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 104158, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 134, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1521942, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 138358.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3551930634, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2333.814714358366, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12701, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1154.6363636363637, "renju_forbidden_ns": 109050213, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8585.954885442092, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 145, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1180423, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11781, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 102958747, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 156, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1979098, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 619, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2931945, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 12690, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1153.6363636363637, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 121586560, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9581.289204097715, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16660, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1514.5454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 59719997, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3584.6336734693878, "stage_move_gen_ns": 271487796, "stage_ordering_ns": 157660, "stage_eval_ns": 2854205858, "stage_threat_ns": 2888249033, "stage_proof_ns": 757182830, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 242881, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1531492652, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 330179, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1066944728, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 3222, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 218412743, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121435, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 179189741, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12522, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 79508801, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 242870, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31113111, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 510, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3497, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5576.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6303.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1774, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2555, "avg_search_time_ms": 255.5, "search_nodes": 24403, "safety_nodes": 874, "corridor_nodes": 94, "corridor_branch_probes": 103, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 8, "corridor_neutral_exits": 19, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 83, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 83, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 26, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 186, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 78240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 5520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 25371, "avg_nodes": 2537.1, "eval_calls": 17074, "avg_eval_calls": 1707.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 17074, "pattern_eval_ns": 376591, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.056401546210612, "pattern_frame_queries": 17074, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 376591, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.056401546210612, "pattern_frame_updates": 48716, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 513407021, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10538.776192626652, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6942, "avg_candidate_generations": 694.2, "candidate_moves_total": 498274, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.7767214059349, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 625, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 6932, "search_candidate_moves_total": 497649, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 216082, "avg_legality_checks": 21608.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 112, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 216082, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 112, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 694527, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 69452.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1546653016, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2226.915607312603, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3180, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 318.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 17906995, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5631.1305031446545, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 118, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1171287, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1286, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12161130, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1771, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4518048, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 56530, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 19598, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1959.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 195826007, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9992.14241249107, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27362, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2736.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 91064943, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3328.153753380601, "stage_move_gen_ns": 548305537, "stage_ordering_ns": 217261233, "stage_eval_ns": 513783612, "stage_threat_ns": 1187407452, "stage_proof_ns": 66553922, "tactical_annotations": 99483, "root_tactical_annotations": 311, "search_tactical_annotations": 99172, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 48966, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 314961426, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 104666, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 826031820, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14129, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 541176655, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 24478, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 37004642, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 240, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1170255, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 48956, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6527671, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 24385, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 78246445, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 57178, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 200391025, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 17920, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1711638, "child_limit_applications": 6932, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6932, "child_cap_hits": 6932, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6932, "child_moves_before_total": 497537, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 497537, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 110969, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 110969, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.77394691286786, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.008222735141374, "tt_hits": 2321, "tt_cutoffs": 352, "beta_cutoffs": 5805, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5589.6, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6389.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1859, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1662, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9879, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 82, 110, 126, 81, 128, 144, 127, 129, 141, 156, 99, 155, 85 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5824, "avg_search_time_ms": 647.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 60004, "safety_nodes": 410, "corridor_nodes": 1142, "corridor_branch_probes": 1423, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 384, "corridor_neutral_exits": 34, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1120, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1120, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 71, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 384, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 71, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 558, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24230080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 61556, "avg_nodes": 6839.555555555556, "eval_calls": 44094, "avg_eval_calls": 4899.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44094, "pattern_eval_ns": 959736, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.765682405769493, "pattern_frame_queries": 44094, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 959736, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.765682405769493, "pattern_frame_updates": 119934, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1360518809, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11343.895884403088, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15016, "avg_candidate_generations": 1668.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 1022656, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.10442194992008, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 491, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 15007, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1022165, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 357651, "avg_legality_checks": 39739.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 450, "root_legality_checks": 491, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 357160, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 450, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1524604, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 169400.44444444444, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3480999453, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2283.2154795605943, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8322, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 924.6666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51706734, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6213.258111031002, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 456, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4999360, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3356, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33019272, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4361, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12393998, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 149, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1294104, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 33696, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3744.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 330534234, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9809.301816239316, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 46146, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5127.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 149504143, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3239.807198890478, "stage_move_gen_ns": 921714915, "stage_ordering_ns": 454131886, "stage_eval_ns": 1361478545, "stage_threat_ns": 2778262813, "stage_proof_ns": 281026285, "tactical_annotations": 167007, "root_tactical_annotations": 1315, "search_tactical_annotations": 165692, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 122325, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 760886990, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 234989, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1890966233, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30846, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1256451307, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61158, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 92931632, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2382, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13257765, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 122316, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15811363, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 40791, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 67735677, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 85255, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 364583813, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 40961, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4408830, "child_limit_applications": 15007, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15007, "child_cap_hits": 15007, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15007, "child_moves_before_total": 1021715, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1021715, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 240112, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 240112, "child_moves_after_max": 16, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 16, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.08256147131338, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.0, "tt_hits": 6526, "tt_cutoffs": 866, "beta_cutoffs": 12118, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4210.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5099.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1201, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 4045, "avg_search_time_ms": 505.625, "search_nodes": 110599, "safety_nodes": 547, "corridor_nodes": 430, "corridor_branch_probes": 531, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 156, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 419, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 419, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 48, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 156, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 48, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 48, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 311, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 173920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 111576, "avg_nodes": 13947.0, "eval_calls": 108020, "avg_eval_calls": 13502.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 108020, "pattern_eval_ns": 2322449, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.500175893353084, "pattern_frame_queries": 108020, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2322449, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.500175893353084, "pattern_frame_updates": 221152, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2365524924, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10696.375904355375, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2564, "avg_candidate_generations": 320.5, "candidate_moves_total": 167524, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.33697347893916, "candidate_moves_max": 88, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 434, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 2556, "search_candidate_moves_total": 167090, "search_candidate_moves_max": 88, "legality_checks": 4961, "avg_legality_checks": 620.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4961, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 613449, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 76681.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1505784117, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2454.6198901620182, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6752, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 844.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 56021114, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8296.965936018958, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6740, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 56005304, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 15810, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14239322, "stage_ordering_ns": 91140, "stage_eval_ns": 2367847373, "stage_threat_ns": 1564383200, "stage_proof_ns": 82740386, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 222094, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1342356576, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 28032, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 30624673, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 378, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 10174823, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111043, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 156940975, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 934, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5493020, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 222086, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28967956, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 108, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2296, "depth_sum": 23, "avg_depth": 2.875, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 23, "avg_effective_depth": 2.875, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4456.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5456.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1979, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1663, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 9524, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 158, 82, 67, 110, 68, 98, 95, 66, 50, 144, 128, 114, 130, 99, 100, 129, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7011, "avg_search_time_ms": 637.3636363636364, "search_nodes": 122833, "safety_nodes": 282, "corridor_nodes": 5183, "corridor_branch_probes": 5480, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2503, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_plies_followed": 5158, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5158, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 78, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2503, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 78, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 74, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 575, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 196160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 5, "total_nodes": 128298, "avg_nodes": 11663.454545454546, "eval_calls": 118728, "avg_eval_calls": 10793.454545454546, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 118728, "pattern_eval_ns": 2561801, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.57705848662489, "pattern_frame_queries": 118728, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2561801, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.57705848662489, "pattern_frame_updates": 245604, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3290910488, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13399.254442110063, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4085, "avg_candidate_generations": 371.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 303258, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.23696450428396, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 687, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 4074, "search_candidate_moves_total": 302571, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 112111, "avg_legality_checks": 10191.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 146, "root_legality_checks": 687, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 111424, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 145, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1577417, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 143401.54545454544, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3664393874, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2323.0343491923823, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19711, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1791.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 191745653, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9727.850083709603, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 156, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1214096, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18990, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 186035251, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 152, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1940665, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 413, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2555641, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 11115, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1010.4545454545455, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 108449428, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9757.03355825461, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14693, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1335.7272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 54496893, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3709.0378411488464, "stage_move_gen_ns": 281293261, "stage_ordering_ns": 153200, "stage_eval_ns": 3293472289, "stage_threat_ns": 2753425742, "stage_proof_ns": 654767219, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 256087, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1569612226, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 275373, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 901051285, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 2680, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 183865838, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128038, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184199030, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10472, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 65589778, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 256076, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32973423, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 510, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3420, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5864.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6591.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1826, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2503, "avg_search_time_ms": 250.3, "search_nodes": 23398, "safety_nodes": 874, "corridor_nodes": 78, "corridor_branch_probes": 79, "corridor_max_depth": 5, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 23, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 67, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 67, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 26, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 186, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 66480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 24350, "avg_nodes": 2435.0, "eval_calls": 16204, "avg_eval_calls": 1620.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 16204, "pattern_eval_ns": 356442, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.997161194766726, "pattern_frame_queries": 16204, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 356442, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.997161194766726, "pattern_frame_updates": 46706, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 497596071, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10653.793324198175, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6774, "avg_candidate_generations": 677.4, "candidate_moves_total": 483797, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.41969294360791, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 625, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 6764, "search_candidate_moves_total": 483172, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 215648, "avg_legality_checks": 21564.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 119, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 215648, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 119, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 686503, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 68650.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1530684605, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2229.6837814255728, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3008, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 300.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15532465, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5163.718417553191, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1275795, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1163, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10231955, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1715, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3967644, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57071, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 20158, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2015.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 202286005, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10035.02356384562, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 28019, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2801.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 94524777, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3373.595667225811, "stage_move_gen_ns": 548790435, "stage_ordering_ns": 210087736, "stage_eval_ns": 497952513, "stage_threat_ns": 1156216689, "stage_proof_ns": 66923706, "tactical_annotations": 97673, "root_tactical_annotations": 311, "search_tactical_annotations": 97362, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 46924, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 300663220, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 102396, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 811357767, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13789, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 522859502, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 23457, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 35429334, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 208, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1033541, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 46914, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6193599, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 24917, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 82992639, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 55524, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 200036085, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 17232, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1539228, "child_limit_applications": 6764, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6764, "child_cap_hits": 6764, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6764, "child_moves_before_total": 483053, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 483053, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 108289, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 108289, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.41528681253696, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.009609698403313, "tt_hits": 2340, "tt_cutoffs": 385, "beta_cutoffs": 5698, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5586.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6386.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1827, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1664, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20074, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 96, 141, 82, 97, 54, 68, 80, 64, 83, 81, 65, 156, 171, 125, 50, 95, 66, 139, 153, 34, 52, 94, 35, 20, 51, 53, 67, 19, 99 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 12888, "avg_search_time_ms": 859.2, "search_nodes": 149057, "safety_nodes": 431, "corridor_nodes": 3147, "corridor_branch_probes": 3356, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1424, "corridor_neutral_exits": 84, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 3102, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3102, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 133, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 88, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 84, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1424, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 133, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 130, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1093, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 977360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 152635, "avg_nodes": 10175.666666666666, "eval_calls": 105213, "avg_eval_calls": 7014.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105213, "pattern_eval_ns": 2167430, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.60040109111992, "pattern_frame_queries": 105213, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2167430, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.60040109111992, "pattern_frame_updates": 297980, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3076585854, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10324.80654406336, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 40986, "avg_candidate_generations": 2732.4, "candidate_moves_total": 3449666, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.16693505099302, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1109, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 40971, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3448557, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1021840, "avg_legality_checks": 68122.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 346, "root_legality_checks": 1109, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1020731, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 346, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4055309, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 270353.93333333335, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7654890699, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1887.6220527215066, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28495, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1899.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64940918, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2279.0285313212844, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 560, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2439285, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11642, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43781656, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15794, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18303227, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 499, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 416750, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 97936, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6529.066666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 708770291, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7237.076161983336, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 125766, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8384.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 296440541, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2357.080140896586, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2178006306, "stage_ordering_ns": 1154826447, "stage_eval_ns": 3078753284, "stage_threat_ns": 5906875529, "stage_proof_ns": 507748184, "tactical_annotations": 741763, "root_tactical_annotations": 3859, "search_tactical_annotations": 737904, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 304465, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1610454215, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 823246, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4003474133, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 84043, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2609423792, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 152225, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 206142819, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6470, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 32495730, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 304450, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34883153, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 259650, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 179964586, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 305851, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 865761798, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 176262, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19425479, "child_limit_applications": 40971, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 40971, "child_cap_hits": 40971, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 40971, "child_moves_before_total": 3448211, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3448211, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 662917, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 662917, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.16223670401016, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.180151814698203, "tt_hits": 19048, "tt_cutoffs": 2806, "beta_cutoffs": 34191, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5329.133333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5862.466666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 604, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 7174, "avg_search_time_ms": 512.4285714285714, "search_nodes": 233113, "safety_nodes": 1446, "corridor_nodes": 586, "corridor_branch_probes": 723, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 218, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_plies_followed": 574, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 574, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 62, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 218, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 62, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 346, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 113200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 235145, "avg_nodes": 16796.071428571428, "eval_calls": 228565, "avg_eval_calls": 16326.07142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 228565, "pattern_eval_ns": 4855177, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.241996806160174, "pattern_frame_queries": 228565, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4855177, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.241996806160174, "pattern_frame_updates": 466144, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3949453336, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8472.603607468936, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4521, "avg_candidate_generations": 322.92857142857144, "candidate_moves_total": 365327, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.8066799380668, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1056, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 4507, "search_candidate_moves_total": 364271, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 11007, "avg_legality_checks": 786.2142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11007, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1071789, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 76556.35714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2394033585, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2233.6799360695063, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4416, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 315.42857142857144, "renju_forbidden_ns": 38219715, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8654.826766304348, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4399, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38151434, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 68281, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 28046677, "stage_ordering_ns": 158890, "stage_eval_ns": 3954308513, "stage_threat_ns": 3048846556, "stage_proof_ns": 102095000, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 467430, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2638601876, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37201, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 39871697, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 506, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 14499747, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 233708, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 307482518, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1272, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6697441, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 467416, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 56193024, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 179, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4193, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6183.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6754.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1780, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1665, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18308, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 67, 83, 128, 111, 125, 81, 80, 96, 126, 66, 51, 55, 69, 85, 84, 124, 110, 95, 158, 143, 142, 94, 174 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9763, "avg_search_time_ms": 813.5833333333334, "search_nodes": 170015, "safety_nodes": 814, "corridor_nodes": 8847, "corridor_branch_probes": 9871, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4145, "corridor_neutral_exits": 46, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 8802, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8797, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 114, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 46, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4145, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 114, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 113, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 818, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 373680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 24160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 179676, "avg_nodes": 14973.0, "eval_calls": 164466, "avg_eval_calls": 13705.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 164466, "pattern_eval_ns": 3542917, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.541941799520874, "pattern_frame_queries": 164466, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3542917, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.541941799520874, "pattern_frame_updates": 339960, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4060690741, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11944.613310389457, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5526, "avg_candidate_generations": 460.5, "candidate_moves_total": 355461, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.32519001085777, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 724, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 5514, "search_candidate_moves_total": 354737, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 158802, "avg_legality_checks": 13233.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 724, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 158078, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2279281, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 189940.08333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5156875981, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2262.501192700681, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9990, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 832.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 79381045, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7946.050550550551, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 205370, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9597, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 75060935, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 166, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1975316, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 203, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2139424, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1367.6666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 167670282, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10216.322325127956, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22557, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1879.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 87929217, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3898.090038568959, "stage_move_gen_ns": 397879789, "stage_ordering_ns": 191371, "stage_eval_ns": 4064233658, "stage_threat_ns": 4170037003, "stage_proof_ns": 1102243120, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 357804, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2219783219, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 483107, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1535557920, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 4668, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 309836380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 178896, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 260949908, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 17832, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 108375321, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 357792, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45370635, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 261, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4981, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4521.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5188.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1401, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8531, "avg_search_time_ms": 710.9166666666666, "search_nodes": 68103, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 478, "corridor_branch_probes": 629, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 162, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 467, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 467, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 18, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 162, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 18, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 17, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 37, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 7985520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 69394, "avg_nodes": 5782.833333333333, "eval_calls": 39677, "avg_eval_calls": 3306.4166666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 39677, "pattern_eval_ns": 887751, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.374448673034756, "pattern_frame_queries": 39677, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 887751, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.374448673034756, "pattern_frame_updates": 136066, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1452481653, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10674.831721370512, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25755, "avg_candidate_generations": 2146.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1771273, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.77394680644535, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 749, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 25743, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1770524, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 963200, "avg_legality_checks": 80266.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 963200, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2497040, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 208086.66666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5452889795, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2183.7414678979912, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13736, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1144.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21533170, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1567.6448747815957, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 805323, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2190, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10922744, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11436, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9795253, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9850, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75809, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6317.416666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 676098487, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8918.446187128178, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 100965, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8413.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 281438176, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2787.482553360075, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2342749752, "stage_ordering_ns": 745386948, "stage_eval_ns": 1453369404, "stage_threat_ns": 3911698924, "stage_proof_ns": 27258650, "tactical_annotations": 372338, "root_tactical_annotations": 901, "search_tactical_annotations": 371437, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 137048, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 873939861, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 356425, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2896635452, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51869, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1894661695, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68518, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105650831, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 970, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6197257, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 137036, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18417836, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 64412, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 232618793, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 208616, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 744004788, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 99310, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10857687, "child_limit_applications": 25743, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25743, "child_cap_hits": 25743, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25743, "child_moves_before_total": 1770428, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1770428, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 239365, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 239365, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.77318105892864, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.298255836538088, "tt_hits": 12364, "tt_cutoffs": 2613, "beta_cutoffs": 20689, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 5.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 5.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4467.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5134.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1666, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32315, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 53, 95, 111, 125, 69, 55, 68, 155, 169, 110, 140, 80, 65, 66, 38, 23, 37, 94, 108, 21, 39, 25, 36, 40, 35 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 29174, "avg_search_time_ms": 1620.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 218906, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 25280, "corridor_branch_probes": 27518, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 12728, "corridor_neutral_exits": 27, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 25230, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 25230, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 50, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 27, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 12728, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 100, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 762, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 67487360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 244983, "avg_nodes": 13610.166666666666, "eval_calls": 140087, "avg_eval_calls": 7782.611111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 140087, "pattern_eval_ns": 3075687, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.955549051660753, "pattern_frame_queries": 140087, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3075687, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.955549051660753, "pattern_frame_updates": 437604, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5558971666, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12703.201218453214, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 72980, "avg_candidate_generations": 4054.4444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 6204384, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.0148533844889, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 72962, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6203082, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1562121, "avg_legality_checks": 86784.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1775, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1560819, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8501869, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 472326.05555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17877211513, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2102.738999271807, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56094, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3116.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 317321903, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5656.966930509502, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25326457, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24721, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 181052029, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26516, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 95942178, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1740, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 15001239, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 227082, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12615.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1907492228, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8400.015095868453, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 301029, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16723.833333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 827079184, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2747.5066654707684, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3813028355, "stage_ordering_ns": 2434159366, "stage_eval_ns": 5562047353, "stage_threat_ns": 14864888959, "stage_proof_ns": 2417085128, "tactical_annotations": 1542594, "root_tactical_annotations": 4128, "search_tactical_annotations": 1538466, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 488282, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3258139264, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2417623, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10747999085, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 158479, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5599605098, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 244132, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 396367372, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 50660, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 335448369, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 488264, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62472215, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 446868, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 446745966, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 589461, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1818742049, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 506265, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 64462654, "child_limit_applications": 72962, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 72962, "child_cap_hits": 72962, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 72962, "child_moves_before_total": 6201307, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6201307, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 867426, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 867426, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.99365423096954, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.88873660261506, "tt_hits": 44121, "tt_cutoffs": 5754, "beta_cutoffs": 60145, "depth_sum": 102, "avg_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 102, "avg_effective_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1842.0555555555557, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2225.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 3123, "avg_search_time_ms": 183.7058823529412, "search_nodes": 84204, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 1077, "corridor_branch_probes": 1319, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 10, "corridor_depth_exits": 402, "corridor_neutral_exits": 24, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 1057, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1052, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 402, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 218, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 216960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 87172, "avg_nodes": 5127.764705882353, "eval_calls": 81401, "avg_eval_calls": 4788.294117647059, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 81401, "pattern_eval_ns": 1753586, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.54256090220022, "pattern_frame_queries": 81401, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1753586, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.54256090220022, "pattern_frame_updates": 168308, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1741884307, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10349.385097559236, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2770, "avg_candidate_generations": 162.94117647058823, "candidate_moves_total": 217538, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.53357400722021, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1235, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2753, "search_candidate_moves_total": 216303, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5313, "avg_legality_checks": 312.52941176470586, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5313, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 564039, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 33178.76470588235, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1254921609, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2224.884465435901, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4306, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 253.2941176470588, "renju_forbidden_ns": 29617309, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6878.148862052949, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 57900, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4265, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29303058, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 38000, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 218351, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.4705882352941178, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 278152, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6622.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.0588235294117645, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 92321, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1775.4038461538462, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14555546, "stage_ordering_ns": 91110, "stage_eval_ns": 1743637893, "stage_threat_ns": 1250478442, "stage_proof_ns": 84954490, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 170547, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1014588170, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64892, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 78277499, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 691, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 28083449, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85265, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 120731216, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2222, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15584177, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 170530, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21297380, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2573, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6719.823529411765, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7190.411764705882, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1667, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26095, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 81, 142, 156, 100, 86, 129, 126, 130, 131, 141, 140, 98, 109, 110, 154, 168, 146, 101, 99, 115, 66, 96, 145, 87, 143, 73 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6276, "avg_search_time_ms": 448.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 109231, "safety_nodes": 1548, "corridor_nodes": 3353, "corridor_branch_probes": 3976, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1343, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 3313, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3273, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 40, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 91, "corridor_proof_active": 40, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1343, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 91, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 8, "corridor_proof_unknown": 83, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 543, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 227680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 114132, "avg_nodes": 8152.285714285715, "eval_calls": 105408, "avg_eval_calls": 7529.142857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105408, "pattern_eval_ns": 2299109, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.81152284456588, "pattern_frame_queries": 105408, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2299109, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.81152284456588, "pattern_frame_updates": 218380, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3126838584, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14318.337686601337, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3796, "avg_candidate_generations": 271.14285714285717, "candidate_moves_total": 297129, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.27423603793467, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1056, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 3782, "search_candidate_moves_total": 296073, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 101825, "avg_legality_checks": 7273.214285714285, "illegal_moves_skipped": 109, "root_legality_checks": 1056, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 100769, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 104, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1394377, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 99598.35714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3300139233, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2366.748184314572, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14690, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1049.2857142857142, "renju_forbidden_ns": 118139459, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8042.168754254595, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 116, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1150747, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13356, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 107474863, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 365, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3172052, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 853, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6341797, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9413, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 672.3571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 96855295, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10289.524593647084, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12389, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 884.9285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 51669570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4170.600532730648, "stage_move_gen_ns": 270315824, "stage_ordering_ns": 130381, "stage_eval_ns": 3129137693, "stage_threat_ns": 2301301961, "stage_proof_ns": 548958339, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 225202, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1389014381, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 203258, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 674346697, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1807, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 131776534, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 112594, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 165211568, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6808, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 44058741, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 225188, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28670574, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 190, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3437, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6208.214285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6779.642857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1831, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 19806, "avg_search_time_ms": 1414.7142857142858, "search_nodes": 132357, "safety_nodes": 883, "corridor_nodes": 1431, "corridor_branch_probes": 1670, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 523, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 61, "corridor_plies_followed": 1414, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1234, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 180, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 32, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 15, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 523, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 61, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 32, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 31, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 175, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 15878080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1988240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 134671, "avg_nodes": 9619.357142857143, "eval_calls": 82895, "avg_eval_calls": 5921.071428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82895, "pattern_eval_ns": 1865634, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.505989504795224, "pattern_frame_queries": 82895, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1865634, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.505989504795224, "pattern_frame_updates": 264544, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3370010613, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12738.941775281239, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44808, "avg_candidate_generations": 3200.5714285714284, "candidate_moves_total": 3902734, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.09904481342618, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1101, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 44794, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3901633, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 2401940, "avg_legality_checks": 171567.14285714287, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11380, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2401940, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11380, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5832047, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 416574.78571428574, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12728722142, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2182.547935913411, "renju_forbidden_checks": 112563, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8040.214285714285, "renju_forbidden_ns": 395519085, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3513.7574958023506, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15566, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 129019984, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21698, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 121378702, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 75029, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 144159914, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 270, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 960485, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 217416, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15529.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2275549795, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10466.340080766824, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 294083, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21005.928571428572, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1119685356, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3807.3787196131702, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6115624309, "stage_ordering_ns": 1624557310, "stage_eval_ns": 3371876247, "stage_threat_ns": 8532943555, "stage_proof_ns": 63414383, "tactical_annotations": 987041, "root_tactical_annotations": 2950, "search_tactical_annotations": 984091, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 267450, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1722277206, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 904320, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6510668548, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90476, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3427825043, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 133718, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 212921869, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2892, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16878715, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 267436, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36169948, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 253419, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1098234331, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 474272, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1897766929, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 259350, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 34027269, "child_limit_applications": 44794, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44794, "child_cap_hits": 44794, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44794, "child_moves_before_total": 3890253, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3890253, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 536012, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 536012, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.84763584408626, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.966156181631469, "tt_hits": 23761, "tt_cutoffs": 4587, "beta_cutoffs": 36557, "depth_sum": 81, "avg_depth": 5.785714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 81, "avg_effective_depth": 5.785714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2732.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3304.285714285714, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1668, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27051, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 110, 109, 142, 94, 96, 141, 124, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 125, 86, 72, 83, 85, 81, 80, 95, 123, 122, 108, 67, 53, 92, 138, 152, 93, 153, 78 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 25784, "avg_search_time_ms": 1432.4444444444443, "search_nodes": 260262, "safety_nodes": 811, "corridor_nodes": 28953, "corridor_branch_probes": 31307, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 14970, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 28897, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 28897, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 103, "corridor_proof_active": 56, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 14970, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 103, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 102, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 766, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 71481440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 290026, "avg_nodes": 16112.555555555555, "eval_calls": 172889, "avg_eval_calls": 9604.944444444445, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 172889, "pattern_eval_ns": 3453952, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.977858626054868, "pattern_frame_queries": 172889, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3453952, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.977858626054868, "pattern_frame_updates": 520316, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5542536198, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10652.250167206083, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 81028, "avg_candidate_generations": 4501.555555555556, "candidate_moves_total": 7338475, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.56714962728933, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1337, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 81010, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7337138, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1977758, "avg_legality_checks": 109875.44444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2344, "root_legality_checks": 1337, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1976421, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2344, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10235226, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 568623.6666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15543862780, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1518.663367081489, "renju_forbidden_checks": 75218, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4178.777777777777, "renju_forbidden_ns": 304106270, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4042.9986173522293, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3930, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22069144, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 33957, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 186658590, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 35112, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 83558745, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2219, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 11819791, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 285794, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15877.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1701570450, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5953.8354549080805, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 374278, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20793.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 732075016, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1955.965929068767, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3560860501, "stage_ordering_ns": 2146093042, "stage_eval_ns": 5545990150, "stage_threat_ns": 12741103913, "stage_proof_ns": 1691560530, "tactical_annotations": 1809849, "root_tactical_annotations": 4207, "search_tactical_annotations": 1805642, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 578334, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2867356591, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2773308, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9132816951, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 175998, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4885629194, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 289158, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 367488779, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 58000, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 247330774, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 578316, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57360920, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 555986, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 406106630, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 677781, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1655021811, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 576082, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 68749898, "child_limit_applications": 81010, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 81010, "child_cap_hits": 81010, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 81010, "child_moves_before_total": 7334794, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7334794, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 969369, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 969369, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.54183434143933, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.966041229477842, "tt_hits": 48967, "tt_cutoffs": 6259, "beta_cutoffs": 65584, "depth_sum": 104, "avg_depth": 5.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 104, "avg_effective_depth": 5.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2969.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3413.8888888888887, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 1252, "avg_search_time_ms": 73.6470588235294, "search_nodes": 42782, "safety_nodes": 1927, "corridor_nodes": 957, "corridor_branch_probes": 1154, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 348, "corridor_neutral_exits": 24, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 937, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 932, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 348, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 218, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 207280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 45666, "avg_nodes": 2686.235294117647, "eval_calls": 40302, "avg_eval_calls": 2370.705882352941, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40302, "pattern_eval_ns": 799271, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.83204307478537, "pattern_frame_queries": 40302, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 799271, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.83204307478537, "pattern_frame_updates": 85464, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 626237423, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7327.499567069175, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2447, "avg_candidate_generations": 143.94117647058823, "candidate_moves_total": 194805, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.60972619534124, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1261, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 2430, "search_candidate_moves_total": 193544, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 5529, "avg_legality_checks": 325.2352941176471, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5529, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 272212, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 16012.470588235294, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 477884041, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1755.5583185164505, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1440, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 84.70588235294117, "renju_forbidden_ns": 7151652, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4966.425, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18710, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1401, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6996302, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21970, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 114670, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.4705882352941178, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 163980, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 3904.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.0588235294117645, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 58650, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1127.8846153846155, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11699089, "stage_ordering_ns": 77620, "stage_eval_ns": 627036694, "stage_threat_ns": 515089726, "stage_proof_ns": 70506468, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 87463, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 404669319, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 58162, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 44585862, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 650, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17597093, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43723, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 48361395, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1982, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8950861, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 87446, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8522289, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2257, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6750.588235294118, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7221.176470588235, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1669, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14965, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 109, 95, 98, 127, 143, 125, 140, 126, 128, 79, 63, 65, 80, 124, 123, 158, 142, 113, 114, 141, 156, 100, 170 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7320, "avg_search_time_ms": 610.0, "search_nodes": 124321, "safety_nodes": 892, "corridor_nodes": 9775, "corridor_branch_probes": 10994, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4597, "corridor_neutral_exits": 41, "corridor_terminal_exits": 30, "corridor_plies_followed": 9725, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9701, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 24, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 118, "corridor_proof_active": 50, "corridor_proof_quiet": 68, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 41, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4597, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 118, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 4, "corridor_proof_unknown": 114, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 832, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 489920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 24880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 134988, "avg_nodes": 11249.0, "eval_calls": 119474, "avg_eval_calls": 9956.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 119474, "pattern_eval_ns": 2498887, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.91573898923615, "pattern_frame_queries": 119474, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2498887, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.91573898923615, "pattern_frame_updates": 248572, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2376861445, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9562.064291231514, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4824, "avg_candidate_generations": 402.0, "candidate_moves_total": 317188, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.75207296849088, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 4812, "search_candidate_moves_total": 316466, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 115328, "avg_legality_checks": 9610.666666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 114606, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1987938, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 165661.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4074233123, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2049.476957027835, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8981, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 748.4166666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 49105013, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5467.655383587574, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 126792, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8454, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43859498, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 195, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2323455, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 315, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2795268, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 18613, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1551.0833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 188057731, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10103.569064632245, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25754, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2146.1666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 98700478, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3832.432942455541, "stage_move_gen_ns": 243882684, "stage_ordering_ns": 156670, "stage_eval_ns": 2379360332, "stage_threat_ns": 3505318432, "stage_proof_ns": 1162645189, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 268270, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1488969990, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 530966, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1689523126, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 5013, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 334691301, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134129, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 177460171, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 19686, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 119573970, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 268258, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29791175, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 265, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4276, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5705.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6372.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1870, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7633, "avg_search_time_ms": 636.0833333333334, "search_nodes": 66873, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 569, "corridor_branch_probes": 732, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 181, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 25, "corridor_plies_followed": 558, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 558, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 18, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 181, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 18, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 17, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 37, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 7988320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 68481, "avg_nodes": 5706.75, "eval_calls": 38455, "avg_eval_calls": 3204.5833333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38455, "pattern_eval_ns": 835878, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.73652320894552, "pattern_frame_queries": 38455, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 835878, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.73652320894552, "pattern_frame_updates": 133614, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1336915112, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10005.801128624245, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25780, "avg_candidate_generations": 2148.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 1738427, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.43316524437549, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 744, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 25768, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1737683, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 869467, "avg_legality_checks": 72455.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 76, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 869467, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 76, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2363347, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 196945.58333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4808965857, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2034.8115858568378, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11346, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 945.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20912386, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1843.1505376344087, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 80, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 740901, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2393, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12232607, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8873, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7938878, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 66254, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5521.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 539710564, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8146.082711987201, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 87788, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7315.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 222240689, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2531.5611359183486, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1970780153, "stage_ordering_ns": 690887771, "stage_eval_ns": 1337750990, "stage_threat_ns": 3557973528, "stage_proof_ns": 26040395, "tactical_annotations": 340287, "root_tactical_annotations": 456, "search_tactical_annotations": 339831, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 134778, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 790280428, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 338109, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2636716178, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51972, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1787753090, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67383, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 96620875, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1152, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7531192, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 134766, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16679883, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 42646, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 158675895, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 207063, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 661449256, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 90578, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10144972, "child_limit_applications": 25768, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25768, "child_cap_hits": 25768, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25768, "child_moves_before_total": 1737607, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1737607, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 235376, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 235376, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.43274604160199, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.134430301148711, "tt_hits": 12097, "tt_cutoffs": 2584, "beta_cutoffs": 20655, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4449.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5115.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1670, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32207, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 129, 109, 108, 81, 123, 125, 80, 93, 141, 127, 143, 79, 63, 94, 145, 161, 142, 144, 140, 139, 124, 92, 91, 107, 156, 172, 121, 77, 61, 122, 62, 137 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 29163, "avg_search_time_ms": 1620.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 207649, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 29515, "corridor_branch_probes": 31813, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 15729, "corridor_neutral_exits": 26, "corridor_terminal_exits": 34, "corridor_plies_followed": 29464, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 29464, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 51, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 15729, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 34, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 100, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 762, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 67565200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 237961, "avg_nodes": 13220.055555555555, "eval_calls": 128915, "avg_eval_calls": 7161.944444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 128915, "pattern_eval_ns": 2847148, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.08546716828918, "pattern_frame_queries": 128915, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2847148, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.08546716828918, "pattern_frame_updates": 415090, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5069881246, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12213.932511021707, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 72653, "avg_candidate_generations": 4036.277777777778, "candidate_moves_total": 6189810, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.19689482884395, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 72635, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6188508, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1555993, "avg_legality_checks": 86444.05555555556, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1431, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1554691, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1431, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8567803, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 475989.05555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17937138000, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2093.551637450114, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48496, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2694.222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 273028575, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5629.919477895084, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2560, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 22761537, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19713, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 142729916, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23850, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 89967149, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2373, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 17569973, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 227890, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12660.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1906901516, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8367.640159726183, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 299853, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16658.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 826061590, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2754.8885287124026, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3800769581, "stage_ordering_ns": 2455127614, "stage_eval_ns": 5072728394, "stage_threat_ns": 15176182691, "stage_proof_ns": 2574466776, "tactical_annotations": 1547934, "root_tactical_annotations": 4128, "search_tactical_annotations": 1543806, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 474236, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3232360099, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2526674, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11034922685, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 159028, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5667356859, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 237109, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 384537962, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 59128, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 397776660, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 474218, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60455725, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 444920, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 429226333, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 585283, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1758809352, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 517731, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 66129560, "child_limit_applications": 72635, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 72635, "child_cap_hits": 72635, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 72635, "child_moves_before_total": 6187077, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6187077, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 865225, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 865225, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.18038135884903, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.91195704550148, "tt_hits": 44770, "tt_cutoffs": 5997, "beta_cutoffs": 60274, "depth_sum": 102, "avg_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 102, "avg_effective_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1820.7222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2205.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 3025, "avg_search_time_ms": 177.94117647058823, "search_nodes": 83574, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 1131, "corridor_branch_probes": 1376, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 9, "corridor_depth_exits": 441, "corridor_neutral_exits": 24, "corridor_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_plies_followed": 1111, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1106, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 33, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 441, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 218, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 215040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 86596, "avg_nodes": 5093.882352941177, "eval_calls": 80904, "avg_eval_calls": 4759.058823529412, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80904, "pattern_eval_ns": 1754258, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.683204785919113, "pattern_frame_queries": 80904, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1754258, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.683204785919113, "pattern_frame_updates": 167048, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1656130685, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9914.100647718022, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2637, "avg_candidate_generations": 155.11764705882354, "candidate_moves_total": 209213, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.33750474023512, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1235, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2620, "search_candidate_moves_total": 207978, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5654, "avg_legality_checks": 332.5882352941176, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5654, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 530093, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 31181.941176470587, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1162018878, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2192.1037968809246, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4211, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 247.7058823529412, "renju_forbidden_ns": 31238067, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7418.2063642840185, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 73351, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4169, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30879554, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 77260, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 207902, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.7058823529411766, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 303352, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6594.608695652174, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2941176470588234, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 91830, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1639.8214285714287, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15515009, "stage_ordering_ns": 85760, "stage_eval_ns": 1657884943, "stage_threat_ns": 1239971577, "stage_proof_ns": 83838330, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169395, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1004403969, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 66068, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 79722529, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 689, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 27377725, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84689, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 118298838, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2330, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16367118, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169378, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21179123, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2451, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6748.588235294118, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7219.176470588235, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1671, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12039, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 128, 143, 95, 115, 96, 144, 142, 100, 94, 97, 110, 101, 99, 129, 157, 87 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4876, "avg_search_time_ms": 541.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 110138, "safety_nodes": 224, "corridor_nodes": 2636, "corridor_branch_probes": 2980, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1118, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 2614, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2614, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 86, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1118, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 86, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 692, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 305440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 112998, "avg_nodes": 12555.333333333334, "eval_calls": 106100, "avg_eval_calls": 11788.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 106100, "pattern_eval_ns": 2109214, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.879491046182846, "pattern_frame_queries": 106100, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2109214, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.879491046182846, "pattern_frame_updates": 220224, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2318146071, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10526.30989810375, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4021, "avg_candidate_generations": 446.77777777777777, "candidate_moves_total": 263027, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.41333001740861, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 4012, "search_candidate_moves_total": 262527, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 99905, "avg_legality_checks": 11100.555555555555, "illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 99405, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 18, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1076560, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 119617.77777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2281402086, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2119.159253548339, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7658, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 850.8888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 59270508, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7739.685035257247, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 178731, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7199, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 56468658, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 100, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1165014, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 340, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1458105, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 6705, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 745.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 62379326, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9303.4043251305, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9340, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1037.7777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 32846853, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3516.793683083512, "stage_move_gen_ns": 235406849, "stage_ordering_ns": 136970, "stage_eval_ns": 2320255285, "stage_threat_ns": 1899727026, "stage_proof_ns": 403375411, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 225633, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1238497436, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 157371, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 457164308, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1556, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 92631316, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 112812, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 150385373, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5400, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 27799359, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 225624, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25880550, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 327, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3503, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4945.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5834.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1764, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7155, "avg_search_time_ms": 795.0, "search_nodes": 69735, "safety_nodes": 743, "corridor_nodes": 442, "corridor_branch_probes": 524, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 162, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 432, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 432, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 47, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 162, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 47, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 47, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 310, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 36033760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2007120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 70920, "avg_nodes": 7880.0, "eval_calls": 41700, "avg_eval_calls": 4633.333333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41700, "pattern_eval_ns": 847893, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.3331654676259, "pattern_frame_queries": 41700, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 847893, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.3331654676259, "pattern_frame_updates": 139372, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1157632958, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8306.065479436329, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25092, "avg_candidate_generations": 2788.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1843833, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.48290291726447, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 511, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 25083, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1843322, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 918002, "avg_legality_checks": 102000.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 316, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 918002, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 316, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2446859, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 271873.22222222225, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4457578078, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1821.7551881820734, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9375, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1041.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 22649856, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2415.98464, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 320, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3251650, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1803, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11035321, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7252, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8362885, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75775, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8419.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 604595431, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7978.8245595513035, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 105932, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11770.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 272701387, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2574.306035947589, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1891161807, "stage_ordering_ns": 693721991, "stage_eval_ns": 1158480851, "stage_threat_ns": 3302169719, "stage_proof_ns": 66888329, "tactical_annotations": 305601, "root_tactical_annotations": 835, "search_tactical_annotations": 304766, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 140339, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 725048909, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 307772, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2457022964, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50609, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1591933231, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70165, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 91453270, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 958, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4972326, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 140330, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15344302, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 42917, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 194772960, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 185975, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 651362589, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76709, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8327948, "child_limit_applications": 25083, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25083, "child_cap_hits": 25083, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25083, "child_moves_before_total": 1843006, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1843006, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 239421, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 239421, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.47629868835466, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.54515010166248, "tt_hits": 11596, "tt_cutoffs": 2903, "beta_cutoffs": 19754, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 5.444444444444445, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 5.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3563.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4452.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1043, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1672, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 5645, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 95, 99, 96, 129, 79, 63, 94, 97, 81, 144, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 4708, "avg_search_time_ms": 588.5, "search_nodes": 67335, "safety_nodes": 342, "corridor_nodes": 103, "corridor_branch_probes": 130, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 99, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 99, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 35, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 35, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 275, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 236400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 67780, "avg_nodes": 8472.5, "eval_calls": 40795, "avg_eval_calls": 5099.375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40795, "pattern_eval_ns": 796491, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.524230910650815, "pattern_frame_queries": 40795, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 796491, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.524230910650815, "pattern_frame_updates": 134582, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 985401685, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7321.942644633012, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24867, "avg_candidate_generations": 3108.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1855398, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.61286041742068, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 468, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 24859, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1854930, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 597332, "avg_legality_checks": 74666.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 603, "root_legality_checks": 468, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 596864, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 603, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1961702, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 245212.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2789786045, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1422.1252998671562, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14597, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1824.625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43126790, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2954.4968144139207, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 654, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4405374, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4429, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25020944, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9456, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13623532, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 58, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 76940, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 45002, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5625.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 267284457, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5939.39062708324, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 62434, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7804.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 110178682, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1764.722458916616, "stage_move_gen_ns": 956424447, "stage_ordering_ns": 488934322, "stage_eval_ns": 986198176, "stage_threat_ns": 2181269051, "stage_proof_ns": 60243542, "tactical_annotations": 248399, "root_tactical_annotations": 1321, "search_tactical_annotations": 247078, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 134858, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 514671755, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 226289, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1574426676, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 49958, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1166960165, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67425, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 70058091, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 268, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1039476, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 134850, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11625380, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 36788, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 40947512, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 130691, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 351896077, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 80920, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9447673, "child_limit_applications": 24859, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24859, "child_cap_hits": 24859, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24859, "child_moves_before_total": 1854327, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1854327, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 213756, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 213756, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.59378896978961, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.59873687598053, "tt_hits": 13217, "tt_cutoffs": 1637, "beta_cutoffs": 19570, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3875.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4875.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1756, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 928, "avg_search_time_ms": 132.57142857142858, "search_nodes": 38407, "safety_nodes": 526, "corridor_nodes": 1422, "corridor_branch_probes": 1733, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 16, "corridor_depth_exits": 642, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1410, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1395, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 15, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 642, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 3, "corridor_proof_unknown": 47, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 327, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 125280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 40355, "avg_nodes": 5765.0, "eval_calls": 36196, "avg_eval_calls": 5170.857142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36196, "pattern_eval_ns": 711343, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.652530666371973, "pattern_frame_queries": 36196, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 711343, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.652530666371973, "pattern_frame_updates": 76774, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 421225437, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5486.563641336911, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2198, "avg_candidate_generations": 314.0, "candidate_moves_total": 147949, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.31073703366697, "candidate_moves_max": 90, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 407, "root_candidate_moves_max": 70, "search_candidate_generations": 2191, "search_candidate_moves_total": 147542, "search_candidate_moves_max": 90, "legality_checks": 4717, "avg_legality_checks": 673.8571428571429, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4717, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 183573, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 26224.714285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 280254078, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1526.6628425748884, "renju_forbidden_checks": 898, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 128.28571428571428, "renju_forbidden_ns": 5914128, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6585.888641425389, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 832, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 5773457, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 126891, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13780, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11.571428571428571, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 360122, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 4445.950617283951, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 114, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16.285714285714285, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 135631, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1189.7456140350878, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9368495, "stage_ordering_ns": 69862, "stage_eval_ns": 421936780, "stage_threat_ns": 434494898, "stage_proof_ns": 50656755, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 79701, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 323516421, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 78405, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 52294589, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 716, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 15299578, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 39847, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 40928695, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2920, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10676447, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 79694, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7078746, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 122, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1961, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4921.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6063.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1981, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1673, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11245, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 126, 125, 83, 157, 98, 140, 110, 158, 68, 113, 82, 173, 143, 141, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 22, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 5020, "avg_search_time_ms": 557.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 144851, "safety_nodes": 224, "corridor_nodes": 2100, "corridor_branch_probes": 2464, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 826, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 2078, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2078, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 86, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 826, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 86, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 692, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 293520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 147175, "avg_nodes": 16352.777777777777, "eval_calls": 140326, "avg_eval_calls": 15591.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 140326, "pattern_eval_ns": 2773768, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.766600629961662, "pattern_frame_queries": 140326, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2773768, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.766600629961662, "pattern_frame_updates": 289650, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2482324587, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8570.083158984982, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4508, "avg_candidate_generations": 500.8888888888889, "candidate_moves_total": 289553, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.23092280390416, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 500, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 4499, "search_candidate_moves_total": 289053, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 134057, "avg_legality_checks": 14895.222222222223, "illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "root_legality_checks": 500, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 133557, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 54, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1240119, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 137791.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2269497502, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1830.0642938298663, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9590, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1065.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 68349565, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7127.170490093848, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 69, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 620424, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9095, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 65127604, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 87, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1156382, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 339, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1445155, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 5164, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 573.7777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 51562732, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9985.037180480247, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7236, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 804.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 27193319, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3758.059563294638, "stage_move_gen_ns": 246393148, "stage_ordering_ns": 153692, "stage_eval_ns": 2485098355, "stage_threat_ns": 1867842650, "stage_proof_ns": 381045069, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 293987, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1253492818, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 132702, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 411112347, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1308, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 85437569, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 146989, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 152372033, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4328, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22703740, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 293978, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28161712, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 327, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3997, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4737.111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5626.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1874, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6218, "avg_search_time_ms": 690.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 72609, "safety_nodes": 743, "corridor_nodes": 538, "corridor_branch_probes": 646, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 178, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 526, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 526, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 47, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 35, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 178, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 47, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 47, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 310, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 36037840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2007120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 73890, "avg_nodes": 8210.0, "eval_calls": 43384, "avg_eval_calls": 4820.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 43384, "pattern_eval_ns": 871163, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.080283053660335, "pattern_frame_queries": 43384, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 871163, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.080283053660335, "pattern_frame_updates": 145120, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1006735675, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6937.263471609703, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26148, "avg_candidate_generations": 2905.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 1924978, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.61855591249808, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 511, "root_candidate_moves_max": 68, "search_candidate_generations": 26139, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1924467, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 954452, "avg_legality_checks": 106050.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 339, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 954452, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 339, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2553599, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 283733.22222222225, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3827238436, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1498.7625057810565, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9999, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1111.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19897218, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1989.920792079208, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 341, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2750646, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1725, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9580860, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7933, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7565712, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81392, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9043.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 540820499, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6644.639510025555, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 113584, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12620.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 240293322, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2115.556081842513, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1636693230, "stage_ordering_ns": 585417361, "stage_eval_ns": 1007606838, "stage_threat_ns": 2877725787, "stage_proof_ns": 57312999, "tactical_annotations": 321468, "root_tactical_annotations": 835, "search_tactical_annotations": 320633, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 146275, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 632628195, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 332166, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2136363486, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 52765, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1359104806, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 73133, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81032340, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1146, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6021203, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 146266, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13894322, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 46152, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 182023343, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 196800, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 569838873, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78516, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7786241, "child_limit_applications": 26139, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26139, "child_cap_hits": 26139, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26139, "child_moves_before_total": 1924128, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1924128, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 249038, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 249038, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.61138528635372, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.527449405103486, "tt_hits": 11952, "tt_cutoffs": 3037, "beta_cutoffs": 20602, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 5.444444444444445, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 5.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4150.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5039.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1842, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1674, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 38625, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 125, 83, 98, 81, 157, 172, 141, 173, 143, 140, 171, 129, 113, 99, 84, 70, 155, 169, 139, 69, 55, 123, 109, 93, 124, 94, 185, 199, 187, 203, 144, 145, 126, 51, 156, 186, 158, 154, 159 ], "move_count": 45, "black_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 36225, "avg_search_time_ms": 1725.0, "search_nodes": 360916, "safety_nodes": 751, "corridor_nodes": 2561, "corridor_branch_probes": 2969, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1065, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_plies_followed": 2544, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2544, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 55, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1065, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 72, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 580, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 31941360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1988080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 364228, "avg_nodes": 17344.190476190477, "eval_calls": 224656, "avg_eval_calls": 10697.904761904761, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 224656, "pattern_eval_ns": 4634817, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.630728758635424, "pattern_frame_queries": 224656, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4634817, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.630728758635424, "pattern_frame_updates": 721582, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8432523468, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11686.16105723258, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 126583, "avg_candidate_generations": 6027.761904761905, "candidate_moves_total": 11626494, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.84877906195935, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1685, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 126562, "search_candidate_moves_total": 11624809, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 2861008, "avg_legality_checks": 136238.47619047618, "illegal_moves_skipped": 14389, "root_legality_checks": 1685, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "search_legality_checks": 2859323, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 14378, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10295540, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 490263.8095238095, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20421347545, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1983.51398226805, "renju_forbidden_checks": 118890, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5661.428571428572, "renju_forbidden_ns": 774852159, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6517.387156194802, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15422, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 154428922, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 51747, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 419481141, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 51113, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 195529656, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 608, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5412440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 259017, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12334.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2035410016, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7858.210140647139, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 335885, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15994.52380952381, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 855888297, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2548.1587358768625, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6400081214, "stage_ordering_ns": 4013370785, "stage_eval_ns": 8437158285, "stage_threat_ns": 16869862397, "stage_proof_ns": 360925612, "tactical_annotations": 3252914, "root_tactical_annotations": 8030, "search_tactical_annotations": 3244884, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 726835, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3967568622, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2889140, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 12177398255, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 254749, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7793585145, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 363407, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 511744571, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5232, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 30643736, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 726814, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 85766791, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 987741, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 744500255, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1500263, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 3272688920, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 764910, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 96740422, "child_limit_applications": 126562, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 126562, "child_cap_hits": 126562, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 126562, "child_moves_before_total": 11610431, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 11610431, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 1628762, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1628762, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.73710118360961, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.869281458889715, "tt_hits": 63016, "tt_cutoffs": 9581, "beta_cutoffs": 104705, "depth_sum": 115, "avg_depth": 5.476190476190476, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 115, "avg_effective_depth": 5.476190476190476, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 8 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 10, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.47619047619047616, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 10, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.47619047619047616, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 696.1428571428571, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 978.8095238095239, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 22, "search_move_count": 20, "total_time_ms": 2383, "avg_search_time_ms": 119.15, "search_nodes": 89955, "safety_nodes": 2009, "corridor_nodes": 2234, "corridor_branch_probes": 2788, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 7, "corridor_depth_exits": 911, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_plies_followed": 2219, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2219, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 19, "corridor_proof_completed": 19, "corridor_proof_checks": 72, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 911, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 72, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 70, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 357, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 86240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 94198, "avg_nodes": 4709.9, "eval_calls": 85843, "avg_eval_calls": 4292.15, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 85843, "pattern_eval_ns": 1680468, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.576063278310404, "pattern_frame_queries": 85843, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1680468, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.576063278310404, "pattern_frame_updates": 179792, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1043489664, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5803.871495950876, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4073, "avg_candidate_generations": 203.65, "candidate_moves_total": 336837, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.69997544807268, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 20, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1593, "root_candidate_moves_max": 108, "search_candidate_generations": 4053, "search_candidate_moves_total": 335244, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 15835, "avg_legality_checks": 791.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 15835, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 26, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 360975, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18048.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 688723978, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1907.9547835722694, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3190, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 159.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 26374393, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8267.834796238245, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 279972, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3000, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24493116, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 456291, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 105, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1145014, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 34206650, "stage_ordering_ns": 129330, "stage_eval_ns": 1045170132, "stage_threat_ns": 1177785846, "stage_proof_ns": 84245661, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 184394, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 888171688, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 131270, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 137122001, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1160, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 36856723, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 92187, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 105553093, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4582, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28178038, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 184374, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18761026, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 245, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3656, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 2.95, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 2.95, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 20, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6936.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7336.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1975, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1675, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20733, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 80, 129, 81, 145, 161, 128, 125, 95, 79, 127, 130, 78, 96, 143, 66, 51, 108, 109, 94, 52, 122 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6795, "avg_search_time_ms": 566.25, "search_nodes": 153097, "safety_nodes": 966, "corridor_nodes": 804, "corridor_branch_probes": 941, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 311, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 791, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 791, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 78, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 65, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 311, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 78, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 75, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 574, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 177040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 154867, "avg_nodes": 12905.583333333334, "eval_calls": 148125, "avg_eval_calls": 12343.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 148125, "pattern_eval_ns": 3155243, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.301218565400845, "pattern_frame_queries": 148125, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3155243, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.301218565400845, "pattern_frame_updates": 306126, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3967070195, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12958.945646563834, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4950, "avg_candidate_generations": 412.5, "candidate_moves_total": 380631, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.89515151515151, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 833, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 4938, "search_candidate_moves_total": 379798, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 143614, "avg_legality_checks": 11967.833333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 177, "root_legality_checks": 833, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 142781, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 177, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1363472, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 113622.66666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3227011531, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2366.760396253095, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17035, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1419.5833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 140917545, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8272.23627825066, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 179, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1831256, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16632, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 137410871, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 603340, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 176, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1072078, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1902, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 158.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 19482743, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10243.292849631966, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2534, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 211.16666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 10163165, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4010.7202052091557, "stage_move_gen_ns": 357767831, "stage_ordering_ns": 163993, "stage_eval_ns": 3970225438, "stage_threat_ns": 2194896423, "stage_proof_ns": 237019870, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 307876, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1771676711, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 50426, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 163931541, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 654, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 37001169, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 153932, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 211134927, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1738, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10263297, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 307864, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37889947, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 270, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4414, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5804.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6470.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1771, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 13926, "avg_search_time_ms": 1266.0, "search_nodes": 93987, "safety_nodes": 762, "corridor_nodes": 774, "corridor_branch_probes": 881, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 356, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 764, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 764, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 45, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 35, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 356, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 45, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 44, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 303, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 30025360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 95523, "avg_nodes": 8683.90909090909, "eval_calls": 57118, "avg_eval_calls": 5192.545454545455, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 57118, "pattern_eval_ns": 1286366, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.521201722749396, "pattern_frame_queries": 57118, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1286366, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.521201722749396, "pattern_frame_updates": 187846, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2300193933, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12245.104676170906, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33698, "avg_candidate_generations": 3063.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 2734051, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.13392486200962, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 767, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 33687, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2733284, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1791808, "avg_legality_checks": 162891.63636363635, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3286, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1791808, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4174609, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 379509.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9178721169, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2198.7020027504373, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35157, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3196.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 165467220, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4706.522740848195, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3384, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 35939178, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9839, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 85275301, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21934, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44252741, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 147867, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13442.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1391567981, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9410.943489757688, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 199787, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18162.454545454544, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 608226365, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3044.37408339882, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4467126332, "stage_ordering_ns": 1145474291, "stage_eval_ns": 2301480299, "stage_threat_ns": 5858858019, "stage_proof_ns": 75561515, "tactical_annotations": 604346, "root_tactical_annotations": 1878, "search_tactical_annotations": 602468, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 189475, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1210009822, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 530104, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4443909652, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67939, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2542777465, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 94732, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 145119717, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1618, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9325087, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 189464, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26797317, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 112335, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 482622803, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 307035, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1382421133, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 184976, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23696424, "child_limit_applications": 33687, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33687, "child_cap_hits": 33687, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33687, "child_moves_before_total": 2729998, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2729998, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 360099, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 360099, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.04010449134681, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.689553833823137, "tt_hits": 17959, "tt_cutoffs": 3119, "beta_cutoffs": 27420, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2291.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3018.2727272727275, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1676, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12428, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 81, 129, 127, 98, 95, 143, 109, 108, 67, 53, 123 ], "move_count": 17, "black_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 7635, "avg_search_time_ms": 1090.7142857142858, "search_nodes": 76291, "safety_nodes": 319, "corridor_nodes": 95, "corridor_branch_probes": 113, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 28, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 91, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 91, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 33, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 29, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 33, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 273, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 324320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 76705, "avg_nodes": 10957.857142857143, "eval_calls": 48139, "avg_eval_calls": 6877.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48139, "pattern_eval_ns": 1033404, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.46708489997715, "pattern_frame_queries": 48139, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1033404, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.46708489997715, "pattern_frame_updates": 152516, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1691024984, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11087.52513834614, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26481, "avg_candidate_generations": 3783.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1921374, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.55670103092784, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 395, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 26474, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1920979, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 664124, "avg_legality_checks": 94874.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1277, "root_legality_checks": 395, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 663729, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1277, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2190093, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 312870.4285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4609189790, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2104.56350027145, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17150, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2450.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 102804132, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5994.410029154519, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13326273, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6983, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62720335, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8816, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26700304, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 57220, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50012, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7144.571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 427990767, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8557.761477245462, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66903, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9557.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 184384535, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2755.9980120472924, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1551188803, "stage_ordering_ns": 780550474, "stage_eval_ns": 1692058388, "stage_threat_ns": 3502103578, "stage_proof_ns": 74710024, "tactical_annotations": 249776, "root_tactical_annotations": 1321, "search_tactical_annotations": 248455, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152771, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 851312864, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 231184, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2512760039, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53163, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1878902477, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76382, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108320619, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 248, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1290605, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152764, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18205588, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 34370, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 43411838, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 136649, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 573803407, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78757, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10213863, "child_limit_applications": 26474, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26474, "child_cap_hits": 26474, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26474, "child_moves_before_total": 1919702, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1919702, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 231642, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 231642, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.5127294704238, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.749792248999018, "tt_hits": 13642, "tt_cutoffs": 1645, "beta_cutoffs": 20281, "depth_sum": 33, "avg_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 33, "avg_effective_depth": 4.714285714285714, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.42857142857142855, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1672.2857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2584.5714285714284, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 466, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 8, "search_move_count": 6, "total_time_ms": 4787, "avg_search_time_ms": 797.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 142815, "safety_nodes": 317, "corridor_nodes": 323, "corridor_branch_probes": 387, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 123, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 319, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 319, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 39, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 35, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 123, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 39, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 39, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 286, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 50240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 143455, "avg_nodes": 23909.166666666668, "eval_calls": 139429, "avg_eval_calls": 23238.166666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 139429, "pattern_eval_ns": 3010371, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.59070924986911, "pattern_frame_queries": 139429, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3010371, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.59070924986911, "pattern_frame_updates": 285596, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2678334294, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9378.052542752699, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3375, "avg_candidate_generations": 562.5, "candidate_moves_total": 220115, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.21925925925926, "candidate_moves_max": 82, "root_candidate_generations": 6, "root_candidate_moves_total": 330, "root_candidate_moves_max": 71, "search_candidate_generations": 3369, "search_candidate_moves_total": 219785, "search_candidate_moves_max": 82, "legality_checks": 5514, "avg_legality_checks": 919.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5514, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 617645, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 102940.83333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1525471475, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2469.81919225445, "renju_forbidden_checks": 6336, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1056.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65498780, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10337.559974747475, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6316, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 65236538, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 262242, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 16301442, "stage_ordering_ns": 111110, "stage_eval_ns": 2681344665, "stage_threat_ns": 2013457723, "stage_proof_ns": 66624859, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 286318, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1739250993, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 21106, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 30496100, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 308, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12758724, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 143156, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 202088667, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 716, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4106681, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 286312, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37515282, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 110, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3025, "depth_sum": 17, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 17, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2543.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3747.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1610, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1677, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17065, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 84, 141, 99, 155, 169, 126, 81, 83, 69, 111, 156, 54, 98, 129, 67, 52, 70, 56, 68, 66, 71 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 3602, "avg_search_time_ms": 300.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 77542, "safety_nodes": 957, "corridor_nodes": 1170, "corridor_branch_probes": 1335, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 501, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1153, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1153, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 78, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 61, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 501, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 78, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 75, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 574, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 193520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 79669, "avg_nodes": 6639.083333333333, "eval_calls": 74193, "avg_eval_calls": 6182.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74193, "pattern_eval_ns": 1498387, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.19580014287062, "pattern_frame_queries": 74193, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1498387, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.19580014287062, "pattern_frame_updates": 155016, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1888142978, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12180.31027764876, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3327, "avg_candidate_generations": 277.25, "candidate_moves_total": 260441, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.28103396453261, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 831, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 3315, "search_candidate_moves_total": 259610, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 70022, "avg_legality_checks": 5835.166666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 148, "root_legality_checks": 831, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 69191, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 147, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 832537, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 69378.08333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1801399694, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2163.7473097291772, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11937, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 994.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 75592115, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6332.589008963726, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 150, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1317614, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11563, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72558460, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 536544, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 179, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1179497, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2506, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 208.83333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 23731762, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9469.976855546687, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3265, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 272.0833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 12242305, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3749.5574272588055, "stage_move_gen_ns": 160206392, "stage_ordering_ns": 112511, "stage_eval_ns": 1889641365, "stage_threat_ns": 1267993610, "stage_proof_ns": 260025386, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 157490, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 924351867, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 69118, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 209091788, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 794, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 45755152, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 78739, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 102277582, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2462, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14427089, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 157478, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17845284, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 267, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2910, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6180.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6847.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1833, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 13452, "avg_search_time_ms": 1222.909090909091, "search_nodes": 99949, "safety_nodes": 758, "corridor_nodes": 1183, "corridor_branch_probes": 1360, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 550, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 1169, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1169, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 550, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 60, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 439, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 30130720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 101890, "avg_nodes": 9262.727272727272, "eval_calls": 60920, "avg_eval_calls": 5538.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 60920, "pattern_eval_ns": 1283257, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.06462573867367, "pattern_frame_queries": 60920, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1283257, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.06462573867367, "pattern_frame_updates": 199770, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2218525544, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11105.398928768083, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35533, "avg_candidate_generations": 3230.2727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 2849832, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.20240339965666, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 763, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 35522, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2849069, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1765989, "avg_legality_checks": 160544.45454545456, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2436, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1765989, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2436, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4195099, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 381372.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8759590985, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2088.0534607168984, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33234, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3021.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 129520144, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3897.2180297285913, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2537, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25346626, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8315, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 62889168, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22377, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 41229500, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 54850, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 140555, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12777.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1293631874, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9203.741410835615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 193062, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17551.090909090908, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 585660954, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3033.538210523044, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4167019830, "stage_ordering_ns": 1120658183, "stage_eval_ns": 2219808801, "stage_threat_ns": 5781017008, "stage_proof_ns": 92875474, "tactical_annotations": 634635, "root_tactical_annotations": 1878, "search_tactical_annotations": 632757, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 202241, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1224916269, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 562728, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4339319913, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 71832, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2534871454, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 101115, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 150970413, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2460, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14272791, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 202230, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25318455, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 115103, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 502061826, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 311757, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1252028527, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 207775, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26219167, "child_limit_applications": 35522, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35522, "child_cap_hits": 35522, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35522, "child_moves_before_total": 2846633, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2846633, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 382116, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 382116, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.13718259107033, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.757164574066776, "tt_hits": 19470, "tt_cutoffs": 3444, "beta_cutoffs": 28697, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2448.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3176.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1678, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17638, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 53, 95, 111, 125, 68, 155, 169, 110, 140, 65, 80, 79, 38, 23, 98 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 14857, "avg_search_time_ms": 1142.8461538461538, "search_nodes": 138128, "safety_nodes": 699, "corridor_nodes": 8367, "corridor_branch_probes": 9062, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3740, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 8329, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8329, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 85, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 47, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3740, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 85, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 82, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 650, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 63464160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2024480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 15, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 13, "total_nodes": 147194, "avg_nodes": 11322.615384615385, "eval_calls": 88397, "avg_eval_calls": 6799.7692307692305, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 88397, "pattern_eval_ns": 1839750, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.812357885448602, "pattern_frame_queries": 88397, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1839750, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.812357885448602, "pattern_frame_updates": 276114, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3034402444, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10989.672541051885, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46395, "avg_candidate_generations": 3568.846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 3741747, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.64978984804397, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 864, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 46382, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3740883, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 1025448, "avg_legality_checks": 78880.61538461539, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1525, "root_legality_checks": 864, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1024584, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1525, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4781969, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 367843.76923076925, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9112655080, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1905.6282213456423, "renju_forbidden_checks": 28823, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2217.153846153846, "renju_forbidden_ns": 159901847, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5547.716996842799, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1660, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11213332, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13435, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 95462116, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12258, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40007278, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1470, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13219121, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 109769, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8443.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 833590759, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7594.045304229791, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 145360, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11181.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 360721966, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2481.576541001651, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2193311620, "stage_ordering_ns": 1343020039, "stage_eval_ns": 3036242194, "stage_threat_ns": 7235961574, "stage_proof_ns": 985834369, "tactical_annotations": 708793, "root_tactical_annotations": 2451, "search_tactical_annotations": 706342, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 292955, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1638551288, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1009393, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5233321489, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 97248, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3141053677, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 146471, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 203844174, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 16828, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 95858086, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 292942, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33220883, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 185788, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 215446122, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 258184, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 792184415, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 264821, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 31165654, "child_limit_applications": 46382, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46382, "child_cap_hits": 46382, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46382, "child_moves_before_total": 3739358, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3739358, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 465746, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 465746, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.62088741322064, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.041524729420896, "tt_hits": 28680, "tt_cutoffs": 3278, "beta_cutoffs": 37284, "depth_sum": 71, "avg_depth": 5.461538461538462, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 71, "avg_effective_depth": 5.461538461538462, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3492.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4108.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1005, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 2768, "avg_search_time_ms": 230.66666666666666, "search_nodes": 78865, "safety_nodes": 1258, "corridor_nodes": 1116, "corridor_branch_probes": 1362, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 444, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1097, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1097, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 444, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 226, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 234960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 15760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 81239, "avg_nodes": 6769.916666666667, "eval_calls": 76614, "avg_eval_calls": 6384.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 76614, "pattern_eval_ns": 1618297, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.122732137729397, "pattern_frame_queries": 76614, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1618297, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.122732137729397, "pattern_frame_updates": 157660, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1548236111, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9820.094576937714, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2228, "avg_candidate_generations": 185.66666666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 163131, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.21858168761221, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 794, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 2216, "search_candidate_moves_total": 162337, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 3942, "avg_legality_checks": 328.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3942, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 519566, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 43297.166666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1099244479, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2115.697484053999, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3760, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 313.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 24741563, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6580.202925531915, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3726, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 24550361, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 191202, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10545269, "stage_ordering_ns": 72050, "stage_eval_ns": 1549854408, "stage_threat_ns": 1110728017, "stage_proof_ns": 73003860, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 159968, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 894913554, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 67563, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 77652395, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 670, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 26634806, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79978, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104625695, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2296, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14590032, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 159956, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18946341, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 80, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2035, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6141.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6808.416666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1679, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12376, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 126, 141, 99, 143, 98, 155, 169, 140, 142, 158, 100, 173, 128, 188, 203, 156, 101, 97, 102 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4973, "avg_search_time_ms": 452.09090909090907, "search_nodes": 101499, "safety_nodes": 671, "corridor_nodes": 3015, "corridor_branch_probes": 3297, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 1296, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 2995, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2995, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 79, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 59, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1296, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 79, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 78, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 586, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 170720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 105185, "avg_nodes": 9562.272727272728, "eval_calls": 97804, "avg_eval_calls": 8891.272727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 97804, "pattern_eval_ns": 2039200, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.8498629912887, "pattern_frame_queries": 97804, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2039200, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.8498629912887, "pattern_frame_updates": 202936, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2308151155, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11373.788558954548, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3675, "avg_candidate_generations": 334.09090909090907, "candidate_moves_total": 247290, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.28979591836735, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 699, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 3664, "search_candidate_moves_total": 246591, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 92992, "avg_legality_checks": 8453.818181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "root_legality_checks": 699, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 92293, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 42, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1128161, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 102560.09090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2487272852, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2204.714444126326, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8125, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 738.6363636363636, "renju_forbidden_ns": 67204549, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8271.329107692307, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 427551, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7600, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64169807, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 88, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 883314, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 395, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1723877, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 6658, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 605.2727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 68594706, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10302.599279062782, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9114, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 828.5454545454545, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 36137924, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3965.1002852754004, "stage_move_gen_ns": 217713389, "stage_ordering_ns": 122690, "stage_eval_ns": 2310190355, "stage_threat_ns": 1952309846, "stage_proof_ns": 472640678, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 209095, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1164139575, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 177490, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 586325899, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1758, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 118117838, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 104542, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 142981413, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6148, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 34576686, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 209084, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24286273, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 241, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3260, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5521.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6248.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1753, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7394, "avg_search_time_ms": 739.4, "search_nodes": 61467, "safety_nodes": 972, "corridor_nodes": 167, "corridor_branch_probes": 214, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 54, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 158, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 158, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 29, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 20, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 29, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 167, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26018880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 62606, "avg_nodes": 6260.6, "eval_calls": 37559, "avg_eval_calls": 3755.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37559, "pattern_eval_ns": 819733, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.825208338880163, "pattern_frame_queries": 37559, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 819733, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.825208338880163, "pattern_frame_updates": 122816, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1212939721, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9876.0725068395, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21649, "avg_candidate_generations": 2164.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1621249, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.88793939673889, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 636, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 21639, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1620613, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 873673, "avg_legality_checks": 87367.3, "illegal_moves_skipped": 419, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 873673, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 419, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2253191, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 225319.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4707958503, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2089.4626789295717, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7488, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 748.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21188496, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2829.6602564102564, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 421, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4535311, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1428, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10192599, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5639, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6460586, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74574, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7457.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 667594059, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8952.102059699091, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 102576, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10257.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 297358895, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2898.9129523475276, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2076430037, "stage_ordering_ns": 689898129, "stage_eval_ns": 1213759454, "stage_threat_ns": 3314075822, "stage_proof_ns": 51313976, "tactical_annotations": 271962, "root_tactical_annotations": 863, "search_tactical_annotations": 271099, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 123200, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 732676832, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 256764, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2467044138, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43542, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1558514768, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 61595, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88904377, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 374, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2132878, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 123190, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15517937, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 40815, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 222805423, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 160899, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 676720556, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 70248, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7799660, "child_limit_applications": 21639, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21639, "child_cap_hits": 21639, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21639, "child_moves_before_total": 1620194, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1620194, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 201941, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 201941, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.87379268912612, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.332270437635751, "tt_hits": 10117, "tt_cutoffs": 2211, "beta_cutoffs": 16902, "depth_sum": 58, "avg_depth": 5.8, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 58, "avg_effective_depth": 5.8, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3958.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4758.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 707, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1680, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 23571, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 123, 81, 97, 83, 137, 151, 80, 65, 124, 85, 71, 84, 82, 86, 87, 121, 139, 153, 154, 94, 169 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 21751, "avg_search_time_ms": 1359.4375, "search_nodes": 185381, "safety_nodes": 582, "corridor_nodes": 5402, "corridor_branch_probes": 5799, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2480, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 5373, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5373, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2480, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 57, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 429, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 39752720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2024480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 191365, "avg_nodes": 11960.3125, "eval_calls": 117503, "avg_eval_calls": 7343.9375, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 117503, "pattern_eval_ns": 2584358, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.993974621924547, "pattern_frame_queries": 117503, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2584358, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.993974621924547, "pattern_frame_updates": 370582, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4789521087, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12924.321977322159, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 63059, "avg_candidate_generations": 3941.1875, "candidate_moves_total": 5494421, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.13143246800615, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1180, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 63043, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5493241, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1554917, "avg_legality_checks": 97182.3125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2756, "root_legality_checks": 1180, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1553737, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2756, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5978948, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 373684.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13052873910, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2183.1388916578635, "renju_forbidden_checks": 46040, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2877.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 281130276, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6106.217984361425, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3028, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 28586243, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19769, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 167239809, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22207, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 76128476, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1036, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9175748, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 152826, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9551.625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1324257126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8665.129794668446, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 204359, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12772.4375, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 564173708, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2760.6991030490462, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3820736198, "stage_ordering_ns": 2249214278, "stage_eval_ns": 4792105445, "stage_threat_ns": 10125088586, "stage_proof_ns": 683675021, "tactical_annotations": 1160848, "root_tactical_annotations": 4136, "search_tactical_annotations": 1156712, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 381462, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2375359284, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1228969, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7294001974, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 128958, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4656794378, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 190723, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 298492022, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10864, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 65468105, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 381446, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49129914, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 355473, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 381179625, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 447759, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1497742453, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 357616, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 42637287, "child_limit_applications": 63043, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 63043, "child_cap_hits": 63043, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 63043, "child_moves_before_total": 5490485, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5490485, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 684996, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 684996, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.09111241533556, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.865536221309265, "tt_hits": 37004, "tt_cutoffs": 4747, "beta_cutoffs": 51134, "depth_sum": 87, "avg_depth": 5.4375, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 87, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4375, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2344.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2844.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 1809, "avg_search_time_ms": 120.6, "search_nodes": 49744, "safety_nodes": 1703, "corridor_nodes": 1421, "corridor_branch_probes": 1704, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 10, "corridor_depth_exits": 621, "corridor_neutral_exits": 22, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1401, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1396, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 36, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 32, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 621, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 55, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 234, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 270560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 52868, "avg_nodes": 3524.5333333333333, "eval_calls": 47481, "avg_eval_calls": 3165.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47481, "pattern_eval_ns": 1018494, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.450559171036836, "pattern_frame_queries": 47481, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1018494, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.450559171036836, "pattern_frame_updates": 99400, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 860742920, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8659.38551307847, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2234, "avg_candidate_generations": 148.93333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 169583, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.91002685765443, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1107, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 2219, "search_candidate_moves_total": 168476, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 5670, "avg_legality_checks": 378.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5670, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 279536, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 18635.733333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 643087355, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2300.552898374449, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1228, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 81.86666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8727586, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7107.154723127036, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1210, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8579426, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 142030, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6130, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 442062, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8667.882352941177, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4.933333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 206250, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2787.162162162162, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15348006, "stage_ordering_ns": 74600, "stage_eval_ns": 861761414, "stage_threat_ns": 819809929, "stage_proof_ns": 84429952, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 102329, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 623299432, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 78561, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 91539520, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 755, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 28292718, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51157, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 71736552, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2914, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 20614991, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 102314, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12619434, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 85, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2043, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6523.466666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7056.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1966, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1681, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21441, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 84, 125, 83, 139, 153, 126, 129, 99, 85, 127, 124, 86, 98, 141, 68, 53, 116, 115, 100, 52, 132 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7586, "avg_search_time_ms": 632.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 167443, "safety_nodes": 966, "corridor_nodes": 1045, "corridor_branch_probes": 1220, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 422, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 1031, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1031, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 78, "corridor_proof_active": 14, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 422, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 78, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 75, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 574, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 175280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 169454, "avg_nodes": 14121.166666666666, "eval_calls": 162219, "avg_eval_calls": 13518.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 162219, "pattern_eval_ns": 3479153, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.44725956885445, "pattern_frame_queries": 162219, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3479153, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.44725956885445, "pattern_frame_updates": 334818, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4409157263, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13168.817874188366, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5202, "avg_candidate_generations": 433.5, "candidate_moves_total": 399175, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.73490965013457, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 833, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 5190, "search_candidate_moves_total": 398342, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 157977, "avg_legality_checks": 13164.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 158, "root_legality_checks": 833, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 157144, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 158, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1486595, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 123882.91666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3595272592, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2418.46137784669, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19088, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1590.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 137831677, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7220.854830259849, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 208, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1723993, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18572, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 133665582, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 785613, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 248, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1656489, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2402, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 200.16666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 24352107, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10138.262697751874, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3203, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 266.9166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 12541396, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3915.5154542616297, "stage_move_gen_ns": 407471075, "stage_ordering_ns": 184071, "stage_eval_ns": 4412636416, "stage_threat_ns": 2474203914, "stage_proof_ns": 264829130, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 337048, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1975837321, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 63769, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 204734177, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 741, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 44942696, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 168518, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 238040811, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2218, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13014548, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 337036, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42577057, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 270, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4666, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5645.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6311.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1746, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 13843, "avg_search_time_ms": 1258.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 104006, "safety_nodes": 762, "corridor_nodes": 707, "corridor_branch_probes": 812, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 332, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 697, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 697, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 45, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 35, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 332, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 45, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 44, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 303, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 29941840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 105475, "avg_nodes": 9588.636363636364, "eval_calls": 64067, "avg_eval_calls": 5824.272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64067, "pattern_eval_ns": 1388833, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.677821655454448, "pattern_frame_queries": 64067, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1388833, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.677821655454448, "pattern_frame_updates": 207884, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2495587833, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12004.713364183872, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 36447, "avg_candidate_generations": 3313.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 2928064, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.33758608390265, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 767, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 36436, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2927297, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1850654, "avg_legality_checks": 168241.27272727274, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9218, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1850654, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9218, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4423406, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 402127.8181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8918417536, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2016.1878733265723, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56139, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5103.545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 318896885, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5680.487450791785, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9314, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 79677304, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19561, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 159702854, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 27264, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 79516727, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 153055, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13914.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1313364068, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8580.994204697658, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 201418, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18310.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 571657268, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2838.163758949051, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4247233775, "stage_ordering_ns": 1122494976, "stage_eval_ns": 2496976666, "stage_threat_ns": 5832081670, "stage_proof_ns": 62635168, "tactical_annotations": 650610, "root_tactical_annotations": 1878, "search_tactical_annotations": 648732, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 209379, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1226025317, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 564602, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4392062442, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 73403, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2572552300, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 104684, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 151485047, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1484, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7861758, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 209368, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26192564, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 116112, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 443521414, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 336558, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1347480888, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 197940, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28454542, "child_limit_applications": 36436, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 36436, "child_cap_hits": 36436, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 36436, "child_moves_before_total": 2918079, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2918079, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 387464, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 387464, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.08779778241299, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.634098144692063, "tt_hits": 19221, "tt_cutoffs": 3440, "beta_cutoffs": 29247, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2235.3636363636365, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2962.6363636363635, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1682, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24969, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 83, 125, 126, 95, 115, 116, 99, 131, 129, 84, 127, 141, 101, 139, 153, 143, 140, 154, 100, 102, 85, 71, 130, 145, 70 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 19824, "avg_search_time_ms": 1416.0, "search_nodes": 182445, "safety_nodes": 164, "corridor_nodes": 715, "corridor_branch_probes": 807, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 301, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 703, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 703, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 52, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 301, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 544, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 18164560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1988800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 183324, "avg_nodes": 13094.57142857143, "eval_calls": 118120, "avg_eval_calls": 8437.142857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 118120, "pattern_eval_ns": 2592233, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.945758550626483, "pattern_frame_queries": 118120, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2592233, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.945758550626483, "pattern_frame_updates": 364740, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4858611509, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13320.75316389757, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 59343, "avg_candidate_generations": 4238.785714285715, "candidate_moves_total": 4804708, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.96503378663027, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 963, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 59329, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4803745, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1422898, "avg_legality_checks": 101635.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3560, "root_legality_checks": 963, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1421935, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3559, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5232686, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 373763.28571428574, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11749642106, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2245.4322896500958, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45623, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3258.785714285714, "renju_forbidden_ns": 303271039, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6647.327860947329, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3791, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 40778853, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21679, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 187639239, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20002, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 73061031, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 151, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1791916, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 135342, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9667.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1223870048, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9042.795643628733, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 179406, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12814.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 521193345, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2905.1054312564797, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3591440998, "stage_ordering_ns": 2014276328, "stage_eval_ns": 4861203742, "stage_threat_ns": 9081730629, "stage_proof_ns": 202619306, "tactical_annotations": 1083984, "root_tactical_annotations": 4405, "search_tactical_annotations": 1079579, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 366288, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2233567889, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 930537, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6467191683, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 119321, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4456284887, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 183137, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 281945736, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1534, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8553263, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 366274, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47799642, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 314305, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 362012983, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 453885, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1533510493, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 315794, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 42672416, "child_limit_applications": 59329, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 59329, "child_cap_hits": 59329, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 59329, "child_moves_before_total": 4800186, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4800186, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 714067, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 714067, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.90792024136594, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.03571609162467, "tt_hits": 32918, "tt_cutoffs": 4923, "beta_cutoffs": 47414, "depth_sum": 72, "avg_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 72, "avg_effective_depth": 5.142857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1734.0714285714287, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2305.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 5130, "avg_search_time_ms": 394.61538461538464, "search_nodes": 150329, "safety_nodes": 1310, "corridor_nodes": 1533, "corridor_branch_probes": 1944, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 9, "corridor_depth_exits": 638, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1524, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1519, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 60, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 638, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 60, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 59, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 332, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 58000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 3920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 153172, "avg_nodes": 11782.461538461539, "eval_calls": 146166, "avg_eval_calls": 11243.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 146166, "pattern_eval_ns": 3135732, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.453224416074875, "pattern_frame_queries": 146166, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3135732, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.453224416074875, "pattern_frame_updates": 300582, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2780152961, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9249.233024598945, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4138, "avg_candidate_generations": 318.3076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 289440, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.94683421942968, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 884, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 4125, "search_candidate_moves_total": 288556, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 7630, "avg_legality_checks": 586.9230769230769, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7630, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 672434, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 51725.692307692305, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1637883098, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2435.752948244735, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8406, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 646.6153846153846, "renju_forbidden_ns": 88703976, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10552.459671663099, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 67190, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8361, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 88142905, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 320581, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 173300, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 36, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.769230769230769, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 247191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6866.416666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 44, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.3846153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 85790, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1949.7727272727273, "stage_move_gen_ns": 22056016, "stage_ordering_ns": 135410, "stage_eval_ns": 2783288693, "stage_threat_ns": 2209596729, "stage_proof_ns": 92985679, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 303763, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1833440859, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 90581, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 102318722, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 789, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 23674246, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 151875, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 215208684, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3168, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19414639, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 303750, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39213825, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 131, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3793, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5708.2307692307695, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6323.615384615385, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1970, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1683, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 41615, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 128, 129, 81, 99, 96, 145, 161, 144, 114, 100, 51, 101, 98, 66, 156, 170, 80, 64, 157, 172, 82, 83, 68, 54, 158, 159, 110, 124, 65, 103, 102, 131, 117, 115, 147, 67 ], "move_count": 42, "black_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 25360, "avg_search_time_ms": 1334.7368421052631, "search_nodes": 541378, "safety_nodes": 694, "corridor_nodes": 9383, "corridor_branch_probes": 10251, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4252, "corridor_neutral_exits": 31, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 9338, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9338, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 17, "corridor_proof_completed": 17, "corridor_proof_checks": 176, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 131, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 31, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4252, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 176, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 173, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1403, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 300320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 551455, "avg_nodes": 29023.947368421053, "eval_calls": 529052, "avg_eval_calls": 27844.842105263157, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 529052, "pattern_eval_ns": 11375911, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.502443994163144, "pattern_frame_queries": 529052, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 11375911, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.502443994163144, "pattern_frame_updates": 1082644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 13667678675, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12624.351749051397, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12289, "avg_candidate_generations": 646.7894736842105, "candidate_moves_total": 1127828, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.77540890227033, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1584, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 12270, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1126244, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 505037, "avg_legality_checks": 26580.894736842107, "illegal_moves_skipped": 304, "root_legality_checks": 1584, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 503453, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 304, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5148671, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 270982.6842105263, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12083738846, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2346.96271057133, "renju_forbidden_checks": 66286, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3488.7368421052633, "renju_forbidden_ns": 535115153, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8072.823114986573, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 362, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3378156, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 58854, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 509696166, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1271, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6268771, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5799, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 15772060, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 20412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1074.3157894736842, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 206501379, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10116.665637860082, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 28284, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1488.6315789473683, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 110199431, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3896.1756116532315, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1257490834, "stage_ordering_ns": 480735, "stage_eval_ns": 13679054586, "stage_threat_ns": 9124725792, "stage_proof_ns": 1226760030, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 1101691, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 6471669174, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 503202, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1600263652, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 5160, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 315577628, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 550836, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 777380106, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 19028, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 139155776, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 1101672, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 136257084, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 940, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 10914, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8947368421052633, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 17 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21052631578947367, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4925.368421052632, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5346.421052631579, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 377, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 21, "search_move_count": 19, "total_time_ms": 16238, "avg_search_time_ms": 854.6315789473684, "search_nodes": 125853, "safety_nodes": 2503, "corridor_nodes": 1571, "corridor_branch_probes": 1956, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 49, "corridor_depth_exits": 659, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1553, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1553, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 56, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 659, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 50, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 217, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 44060400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2008880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 129927, "avg_nodes": 6838.263157894737, "eval_calls": 76915, "avg_eval_calls": 4048.157894736842, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 76915, "pattern_eval_ns": 1708088, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.20747578495742, "pattern_frame_queries": 76915, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1708088, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.20747578495742, "pattern_frame_updates": 251478, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2563402486, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10193.346877261629, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42147, "avg_candidate_generations": 2218.2631578947367, "candidate_moves_total": 3786517, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.84072413220396, "candidate_moves_max": 127, "root_candidate_generations": 19, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1610, "root_candidate_moves_max": 109, "search_candidate_generations": 42128, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3784907, "search_candidate_moves_max": 127, "legality_checks": 2102679, "avg_legality_checks": 110667.31578947368, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2197, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2102679, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2197, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4716757, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 248250.36842105264, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10128251568, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2147.2913631124097, "renju_forbidden_checks": 55278, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2909.3684210526317, "renju_forbidden_ns": 143492807, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2595.8393393393394, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6878, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 35890213, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10954, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 49241495, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37398, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 58233189, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 48, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 127910, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 154648, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8139.368421052632, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1353925329, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8754.884182142672, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 203228, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10696.21052631579, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 557978756, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2745.5801169130236, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5040438915, "stage_ordering_ns": 1520050043, "stage_eval_ns": 2565110574, "stage_threat_ns": 6937332733, "stage_proof_ns": 71890335, "tactical_annotations": 860615, "root_tactical_annotations": 1003, "search_tactical_annotations": 859612, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 254705, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1586404743, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 824569, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5072386048, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 85215, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2933563084, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 127343, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 197125712, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3208, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 23038164, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 254686, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33033536, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 171471, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 481861070, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 484881, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1587322112, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 204263, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 25344530, "child_limit_applications": 42128, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42128, "child_cap_hits": 42128, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42128, "child_moves_before_total": 3782710, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3782710, "child_moves_before_max": 127, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 127, "child_moves_after_total": 497193, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 497193, "child_moves_after_max": 31, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 31, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.79087542726927, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.801960691226737, "tt_hits": 22235, "tt_cutoffs": 6697, "beta_cutoffs": 34517, "depth_sum": 113, "avg_depth": 5.947368421052632, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 113, "avg_effective_depth": 5.947368421052632, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_moves": 19, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15789473684210525, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05263157894736842, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5724.578947368421, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6145.631578947368, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 313, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1684, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 31007, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 129, 81, 96, 83, 157, 172, 143, 171, 141, 144, 173, 125, 111, 95, 80, 64, 159, 175, 145, 65, 49, 131, 115, 101, 130, 100, 188, 98, 99, 68, 53, 128 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 29323, "avg_search_time_ms": 1724.8823529411766, "search_nodes": 301305, "safety_nodes": 417, "corridor_nodes": 5689, "corridor_branch_probes": 6701, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2232, "corridor_neutral_exits": 125, "corridor_terminal_exits": 42, "corridor_plies_followed": 5652, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5652, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 102, "corridor_proof_active": 37, "corridor_proof_quiet": 65, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 125, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2232, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 42, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 102, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 821, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 49877200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 14, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 14, "total_nodes": 307411, "avg_nodes": 18083.0, "eval_calls": 190222, "avg_eval_calls": 11189.529411764706, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 190222, "pattern_eval_ns": 4001564, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.03628392089243, "pattern_frame_queries": 190222, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4001564, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.03628392089243, "pattern_frame_updates": 602404, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6713275210, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11144.141157761236, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 103221, "avg_candidate_generations": 6071.823529411765, "candidate_moves_total": 9186261, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.99604731595315, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1258, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 103204, "search_candidate_moves_total": 9185003, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 2481995, "avg_legality_checks": 145999.70588235295, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10111, "root_legality_checks": 1258, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 2480737, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10105, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9247610, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 543977.0588235294, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17045623289, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1843.2463402976553, "renju_forbidden_checks": 85581, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5034.176470588235, "renju_forbidden_ns": 492723582, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5757.394538507379, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10535, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 97553911, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37183, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 272301221, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 36233, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 111170926, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1630, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 11697524, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 239745, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14102.64705882353, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1824660718, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7610.839508644602, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 312201, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18364.764705882353, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 768824204, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2462.5936624162, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5183757705, "stage_ordering_ns": 3022785595, "stage_eval_ns": 6717276774, "stage_threat_ns": 13583771164, "stage_proof_ns": 692029370, "tactical_annotations": 2350353, "root_tactical_annotations": 6015, "search_tactical_annotations": 2344338, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 613929, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3155773523, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2260055, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9810694517, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 209649, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6032711017, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 306956, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 410300317, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 11508, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 64552584, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 613912, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67956216, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 692090, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 621068478, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1020528, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2425883573, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 637735, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 74494007, "child_limit_applications": 103204, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 103204, "child_cap_hits": 103204, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 103204, "child_moves_before_total": 9174898, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 9174898, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 1307590, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1307590, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.9006046277276, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.66995465292043, "tt_hits": 54233, "tt_cutoffs": 7779, "beta_cutoffs": 84782, "depth_sum": 98, "avg_depth": 5.764705882352941, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 98, "avg_effective_depth": 5.764705882352941, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.29411764705882354, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.29411764705882354, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 869.8823529411765, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1149.4705882352941, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 1668, "avg_search_time_ms": 98.11764705882354, "search_nodes": 56941, "safety_nodes": 1984, "corridor_nodes": 1979, "corridor_branch_probes": 2460, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 800, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1964, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1964, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 800, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 67, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 354, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 92400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 60904, "avg_nodes": 3582.5882352941176, "eval_calls": 53681, "avg_eval_calls": 3157.705882352941, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53681, "pattern_eval_ns": 1104600, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.577112944989846, "pattern_frame_queries": 53681, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1104600, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.577112944989846, "pattern_frame_updates": 113784, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 685176054, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6021.725848977009, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3228, "avg_candidate_generations": 189.88235294117646, "candidate_moves_total": 251231, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.82868649318463, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1275, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 3211, "search_candidate_moves_total": 249956, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 8403, "avg_legality_checks": 494.29411764705884, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 8403, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 242944, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 14290.823529411764, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 494454439, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2035.2609613738146, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1876, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 110.3529411764706, "renju_forbidden_ns": 17310861, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9227.537846481877, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 158040, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1735, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 15955339, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 65, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 518111, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 60, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 679371, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19008375, "stage_ordering_ns": 104681, "stage_eval_ns": 686280654, "stage_threat_ns": 840998370, "stage_proof_ns": 92039544, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 117867, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 600783493, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 118588, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 132363536, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1039, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 36110976, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58925, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 69540293, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4066, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25934654, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 117850, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12376394, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 148, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2920, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8823529411764706, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6740.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7210.588235294118, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1988, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1685, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16759, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 97, 127, 80, 143, 95, 159, 175, 128, 83, 81, 65, 113, 158, 50, 96, 129, 94, 93, 52, 67, 66, 38, 108 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 3323, "avg_search_time_ms": 276.9166666666667, "search_nodes": 75993, "safety_nodes": 970, "corridor_nodes": 943, "corridor_branch_probes": 1088, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 386, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 928, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 928, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 78, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 63, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 386, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 78, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 75, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 574, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 185840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 77906, "avg_nodes": 6492.166666666667, "eval_calls": 72637, "avg_eval_calls": 6053.083333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72637, "pattern_eval_ns": 1550345, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.343736663133114, "pattern_frame_queries": 72637, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1550345, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.343736663133114, "pattern_frame_updates": 151918, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1826281615, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12021.495905685962, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3334, "avg_candidate_generations": 277.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 261373, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.39622075584883, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 837, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 3322, "search_candidate_moves_total": 260536, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 68293, "avg_legality_checks": 5691.083333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 19, "root_legality_checks": 837, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 67456, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 19, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 795230, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 66269.16666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1681423552, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2114.3864693233404, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11640, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 970.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66617588, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5723.160481099656, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 180290, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11401, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 64743504, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 50, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 588641, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 168, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1105153, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2166, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 180.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 19023853, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8782.942289935365, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2855, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 237.91666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 9834929, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3444.8087565674255, "stage_move_gen_ns": 151309834, "stage_ordering_ns": 115160, "stage_eval_ns": 1827831960, "stage_threat_ns": 1108992438, "stage_proof_ns": 212546270, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 153942, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 815071686, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 57723, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 165897320, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 714, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 36463457, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76965, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99331568, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2012, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11223772, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 153930, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17468092, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 270, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2914, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6232.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6898.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1896, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 13424, "avg_search_time_ms": 1220.3636363636363, "search_nodes": 103419, "safety_nodes": 762, "corridor_nodes": 946, "corridor_branch_probes": 1088, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 440, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 935, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 935, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 440, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 60, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 439, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 30006240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 105127, "avg_nodes": 9557.0, "eval_calls": 64128, "avg_eval_calls": 5829.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64128, "pattern_eval_ns": 1385673, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.607924775449103, "pattern_frame_queries": 64128, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1385673, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.607924775449103, "pattern_frame_updates": 206710, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2302402994, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11138.324193314305, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35948, "avg_candidate_generations": 3268.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2904139, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.78722042950929, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 767, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 35937, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2903372, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1855503, "avg_legality_checks": 168682.0909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3408, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1855503, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3408, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4411484, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 401044.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8693651898, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1970.6864850920915, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40410, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3673.6363636363635, "renju_forbidden_ns": 181171442, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4483.3318980450385, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3512, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34715958, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11676, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 94467660, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25222, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 51987824, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 156772, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14252.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1335641648, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8519.644120123492, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 213444, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 19404.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 591741866, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2772.3518393583327, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4168035181, "stage_ordering_ns": 1102676486, "stage_eval_ns": 2303788667, "stage_threat_ns": 5676894619, "stage_proof_ns": 89439390, "tactical_annotations": 639348, "root_tactical_annotations": 1878, "search_tactical_annotations": 637470, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 208713, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1202630699, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 578718, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4265369684, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 72556, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2406989912, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 104351, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 149064300, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1992, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11176690, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 208702, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25561872, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 118375, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 462064762, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 335915, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1353483235, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 185058, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23091374, "child_limit_applications": 35937, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35937, "child_cap_hits": 35937, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35937, "child_moves_before_total": 2899964, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2899964, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 382271, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 382271, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.69577315858308, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.637254083535074, "tt_hits": 18068, "tt_cutoffs": 3291, "beta_cutoffs": 28875, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2776.6363636363635, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3503.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 516, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1686, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12366, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 96, 97, 68, 110, 80, 128, 83, 81, 65, 113, 35, 129, 145, 143, 158, 95, 64, 48, 67, 66, 51, 99, 19 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10401, "avg_search_time_ms": 866.75, "search_nodes": 99275, "safety_nodes": 732, "corridor_nodes": 3149, "corridor_branch_probes": 3267, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1285, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 3138, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3138, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 25, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 14, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1285, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 25, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 21, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 160, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 115360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11360, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 6, "total_nodes": 103156, "avg_nodes": 8596.333333333334, "eval_calls": 63445, "avg_eval_calls": 5287.083333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 63445, "pattern_eval_ns": 1371097, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.61079675309323, "pattern_frame_queries": 63445, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1371097, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.61079675309323, "pattern_frame_updates": 198430, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2113224756, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10649.724114297233, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33659, "avg_candidate_generations": 2804.9166666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2445290, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.64892005110075, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 784, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 33647, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2444506, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 797884, "avg_legality_checks": 66490.33333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1560, "root_legality_checks": 784, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 797100, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2988441, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 249036.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6390938196, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2138.5525750717516, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21644, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1803.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 92067401, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4253.714701533912, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1823, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13303481, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8754, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 49894568, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9960, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24749328, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1107, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4120024, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 63926, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5327.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 529140308, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8277.388042424052, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 81953, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6829.416666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 214589380, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2618.4444742718388, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1956981706, "stage_ordering_ns": 965306196, "stage_eval_ns": 2114595853, "stage_threat_ns": 4918252265, "stage_proof_ns": 396883681, "tactical_annotations": 422147, "root_tactical_annotations": 1872, "search_tactical_annotations": 420275, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 204768, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1200519292, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 533409, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3487620448, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69211, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2330292269, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102378, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 148643835, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6326, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 39819911, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 204756, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24498137, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 79086, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 89350413, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 197020, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 654262415, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 146041, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17150642, "child_limit_applications": 33647, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33647, "child_cap_hits": 33647, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33647, "child_moves_before_total": 2442949, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2442949, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 299105, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 299105, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.60525455464084, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.889499806817843, "tt_hits": 17222, "tt_cutoffs": 2124, "beta_cutoffs": 25709, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.916666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.916666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4081.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4747.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1951, "avg_search_time_ms": 177.36363636363637, "search_nodes": 58697, "safety_nodes": 987, "corridor_nodes": 575, "corridor_branch_probes": 687, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 196, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_plies_followed": 566, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 566, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 45, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 196, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 330, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 87040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 60259, "avg_nodes": 5478.090909090909, "eval_calls": 57024, "avg_eval_calls": 5184.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 57024, "pattern_eval_ns": 1186077, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.79961069023569, "pattern_frame_queries": 57024, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1186077, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.79961069023569, "pattern_frame_updates": 117330, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1084806325, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9245.771115656695, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1652, "avg_candidate_generations": 150.1818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 117741, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.27179176755448, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 728, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 1641, "search_candidate_moves_total": 117013, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 3777, "avg_legality_checks": 343.3636363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3777, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 383539, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 34867.181818181816, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 757449694, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1974.8961487619251, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8325, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 756.8181818181819, "renju_forbidden_ns": 69029472, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8291.828468468468, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 118980, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8216, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 67793039, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 58, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 627461, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 41, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 489992, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8933465, "stage_ordering_ns": 55740, "stage_eval_ns": 1085992402, "stage_threat_ns": 755658946, "stage_proof_ns": 79647976, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 118581, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 613127448, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 37457, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 49428721, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 492, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20305446, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 59285, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 72728841, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1240, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7372866, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 118570, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13001070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 121, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1444, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6098.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6826.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1848, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1687, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25645, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 126, 84, 114, 140, 113, 111, 130, 82, 116, 115, 144, 158, 159, 129, 146, 162, 101, 86, 102, 88, 85, 141, 99, 100, 71, 57, 127 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 17304, "avg_search_time_ms": 1236.0, "search_nodes": 422167, "safety_nodes": 422, "corridor_nodes": 1454, "corridor_branch_probes": 1664, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 512, "corridor_neutral_exits": 19, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1429, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1429, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 162, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 137, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 512, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 162, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 160, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1362, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 293760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 424043, "avg_nodes": 30288.785714285714, "eval_calls": 411430, "avg_eval_calls": 29387.85714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 411430, "pattern_eval_ns": 8787942, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.359507085044843, "pattern_frame_queries": 411430, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 8787942, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.359507085044843, "pattern_frame_updates": 844254, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 9819373599, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11630.828635694945, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10711, "avg_candidate_generations": 765.0714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 872583, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.46606292596397, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1013, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 10697, "search_candidate_moves_total": 871570, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 398406, "avg_legality_checks": 28457.571428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 357, "root_legality_checks": 1013, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 397393, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 357, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3099582, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 221398.7142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7511933314, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2423.531080642487, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30456, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2175.4285714285716, "renju_forbidden_ns": 243778823, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8004.295475439979, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 372, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3509454, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 29730, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 236617187, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 152, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1809110, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 202, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1843072, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2488, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 177.71428571428572, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 25571656, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10277.996784565916, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3507, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 250.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 13795248, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3933.6321642429425, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1022159877, "stage_ordering_ns": 375722, "stage_eval_ns": 9828161541, "stage_threat_ns": 5939343097, "stage_proof_ns": 481277640, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 847450, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4936746787, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 97524, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 278568247, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1401, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 65278375, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 423718, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 597763496, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3182, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 19086914, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 847436, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 107177653, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 758, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 9319, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 2.7857142857142856, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7857142857142856, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3914.3571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4485.785714285715, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8325, "avg_search_time_ms": 640.3846153846154, "search_nodes": 58309, "safety_nodes": 1187, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 13, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 13, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 22, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4004880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59496, "avg_nodes": 4576.615384615385, "eval_calls": 34267, "avg_eval_calls": 2635.923076923077, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34267, "pattern_eval_ns": 758652, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.13943444129921, "pattern_frame_queries": 34267, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 758652, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.13943444129921, "pattern_frame_updates": 116470, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1244455563, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10684.773443805272, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22176, "avg_candidate_generations": 1705.8461538461538, "candidate_moves_total": 1817691, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.9665854978355, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 944, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 22163, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1816747, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1089842, "avg_legality_checks": 83834.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 637, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1089842, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 637, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2502324, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 192486.46153846153, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5451529674, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2178.586655445098, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21639, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1664.5384615384614, "renju_forbidden_ns": 56377430, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2605.3620777300243, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 757, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6636586, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4497, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28568468, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16385, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21172376, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 87231, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6710.076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 811399334, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9301.731425754606, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 121685, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9360.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 362101256, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2975.7263097341497, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2698790266, "stage_ordering_ns": 768556326, "stage_eval_ns": 1245214215, "stage_threat_ns": 3534871807, "stage_proof_ns": 23715053, "tactical_annotations": 360346, "root_tactical_annotations": 964, "search_tactical_annotations": 359382, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 116509, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 719045971, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 328257, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2704221084, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44478, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1574077910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58248, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88746055, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 26, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 161652, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116496, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15208746, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70316, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 271500657, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 213429, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 858371337, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76601, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7488299, "child_limit_applications": 22163, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22163, "child_cap_hits": 22163, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22163, "child_moves_before_total": 1816110, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1816110, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 206933, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 206933, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.9433289717096, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.336867752560574, "tt_hits": 8862, "tt_cutoffs": 1805, "beta_cutoffs": 17603, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5160.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5775.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1688, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17983, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 126, 114, 110, 158, 125, 129, 94, 78, 124, 127, 99, 82, 66, 113, 122, 123, 80, 108, 95, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14675, "avg_search_time_ms": 1334.090909090909, "search_nodes": 114689, "safety_nodes": 659, "corridor_nodes": 2560, "corridor_branch_probes": 3022, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1117, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 2538, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2538, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 43, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 21, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1117, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 43, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 42, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 299, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 19930240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 16, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 16, "total_nodes": 117908, "avg_nodes": 10718.90909090909, "eval_calls": 72198, "avg_eval_calls": 6563.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 72198, "pattern_eval_ns": 1572908, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.78603285409568, "pattern_frame_queries": 72198, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1572908, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.78603285409568, "pattern_frame_updates": 229254, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3175832902, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13852.900721470509, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38834, "avg_candidate_generations": 3530.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 3369600, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.76932584848329, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 797, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 38823, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3368803, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 1113277, "avg_legality_checks": 101207.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1592, "root_legality_checks": 797, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1112480, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1592, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3998897, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 363536.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9071141221, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2268.4108195334866, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34818, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3165.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 206147574, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5920.718421506118, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2021, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19562828, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14919, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 122495825, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17312, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 59396762, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 566, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4692159, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 114098, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10372.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1141382765, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10003.529991761468, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 158729, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14429.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 530896047, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3344.669512187439, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2876021590, "stage_ordering_ns": 1398015120, "stage_eval_ns": 3177405810, "stage_threat_ns": 6803652086, "stage_proof_ns": 369481718, "tactical_annotations": 736307, "root_tactical_annotations": 1808, "search_tactical_annotations": 734499, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 234427, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1478426764, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 692955, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5038955585, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 78938, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3083580966, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 117208, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 185351358, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5162, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 33217749, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 234416, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30387400, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 148675, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 273528990, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 318458, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1282916301, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 269174, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 37313230, "child_limit_applications": 38823, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38823, "child_cap_hits": 38823, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38823, "child_moves_before_total": 3367211, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3367211, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 469429, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 469429, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.73237513844886, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.09151791463823, "tt_hits": 22668, "tt_cutoffs": 3607, "beta_cutoffs": 31723, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2240.2727272727275, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2909.6363636363635, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3298, "avg_search_time_ms": 299.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 86461, "safety_nodes": 1280, "corridor_nodes": 1973, "corridor_branch_probes": 2359, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 37, "corridor_depth_exits": 871, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1951, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1951, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 58, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 36, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 55, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 871, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 58, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 55, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 346, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 237360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 89714, "avg_nodes": 8155.818181818182, "eval_calls": 83689, "avg_eval_calls": 7608.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83689, "pattern_eval_ns": 1800107, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.509481532817933, "pattern_frame_queries": 83689, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1800107, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.509481532817933, "pattern_frame_updates": 172860, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1808608901, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10462.853760268425, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2752, "avg_candidate_generations": 250.1818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 215500, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.30668604651163, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 815, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 2741, "search_candidate_moves_total": 214685, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 5223, "avg_legality_checks": 474.8181818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5223, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 514325, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 46756.818181818184, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1264085586, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2457.756449715647, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5567, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 506.09090909090907, "renju_forbidden_ns": 49239647, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8844.915933177654, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 73260, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5512, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 48748943, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 191450, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 225994, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 15098729, "stage_ordering_ns": 98110, "stage_eval_ns": 1810409008, "stage_threat_ns": 1366574155, "stage_proof_ns": 88325967, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 176889, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1067387748, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 110285, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 127811642, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 977, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 39901507, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 88439, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125399071, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4018, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 23857434, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 176878, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22118260, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 164, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2483, "depth_sum": 31, "avg_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 31, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8181818181818183, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5805.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6532.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1957, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1689, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14438, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 97, 95, 125, 142, 94, 111, 67, 127, 144, 160, 79, 158, 174, 159, 143, 157, 156, 161 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5311, "avg_search_time_ms": 531.1, "search_nodes": 159013, "safety_nodes": 707, "corridor_nodes": 214, "corridor_branch_probes": 243, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 38, "corridor_neutral_exits": 28, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 198, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 193, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 52, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 67, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 461, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 163440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 159934, "avg_nodes": 15993.4, "eval_calls": 154929, "avg_eval_calls": 15492.9, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 154929, "pattern_eval_ns": 3144423, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.295896830160913, "pattern_frame_queries": 154929, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3144423, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.295896830160913, "pattern_frame_updates": 317968, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3038778378, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9556.868546520405, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4065, "avg_candidate_generations": 406.5, "candidate_moves_total": 270297, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.49372693726937, "candidate_moves_max": 95, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 624, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 4055, "search_candidate_moves_total": 269673, "search_candidate_moves_max": 95, "legality_checks": 153195, "avg_legality_checks": 15319.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 624, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 152571, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1077240, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 107724.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2153792294, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1999.3616037280458, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5536, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 553.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43355350, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7831.529985549133, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5536, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 43355350, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 22.4, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1338224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5974.214285714285, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 296, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 29.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 617803, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2087.1722972972975, "stage_move_gen_ns": 327061652, "stage_ordering_ns": 125191, "stage_eval_ns": 3041922801, "stage_threat_ns": 1796609168, "stage_proof_ns": 120030665, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 318510, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1540107358, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 19004, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 37904882, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 406, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 11594671, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 159250, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 183043256, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 532, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1886126, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 318500, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33667546, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 170, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3671, "depth_sum": 29, "avg_depth": 2.9, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 29, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4343.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5143.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 136, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9119, "avg_search_time_ms": 911.9, "search_nodes": 114088, "safety_nodes": 359, "corridor_nodes": 1389, "corridor_branch_probes": 1494, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 522, "corridor_neutral_exits": 30, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1370, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1370, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 43, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 522, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 43, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 42, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 305, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 49638320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1990000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 115836, "avg_nodes": 11583.6, "eval_calls": 70706, "avg_eval_calls": 7070.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70706, "pattern_eval_ns": 1397766, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.768704211806636, "pattern_frame_queries": 70706, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1397766, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.768704211806636, "pattern_frame_updates": 228072, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1475273890, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 6468.456846960609, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 40560, "avg_candidate_generations": 4056.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3177555, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.34208579881657, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 647, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 40550, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3176908, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1693582, "avg_legality_checks": 169358.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 488, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1693582, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 488, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3963730, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 396373.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5641598166, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1423.3053628778953, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11775, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1177.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 35070202, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2978.36110403397, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 508, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2916278, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3039, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20075040, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8228, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12078884, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 91147, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9114.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 538705855, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5910.297157339243, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 128336, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12833.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 249023019, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1940.3987891160702, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2723978445, "stage_ordering_ns": 852656416, "stage_eval_ns": 1476671656, "stage_threat_ns": 3939411732, "stage_proof_ns": 52366360, "tactical_annotations": 556466, "root_tactical_annotations": 1867, "search_tactical_annotations": 554599, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 230908, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 930738380, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 568333, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2834951550, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 82081, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1956080982, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115449, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 124275752, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2826, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10139372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 230898, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20581694, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 97286, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 249543815, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 299384, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 581650952, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 159796, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18724984, "child_limit_applications": 40550, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 40550, "child_cap_hits": 40550, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 40550, "child_moves_before_total": 3176420, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3176420, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 355353, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 355353, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.33341553637484, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.763329223181257, "tt_hits": 18988, "tt_cutoffs": 2781, "beta_cutoffs": 31490, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 5.1, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 5.1, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3446.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4246.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1030, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1690, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20235, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 142, 95, 65, 94, 127, 140, 125, 97, 114, 156, 113, 78, 62, 111, 141, 155, 157, 172, 173, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 16115, "avg_search_time_ms": 1342.9166666666667, "search_nodes": 149505, "safety_nodes": 493, "corridor_nodes": 4032, "corridor_branch_probes": 4471, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1746, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 4005, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4005, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1746, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 555, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 55583520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 154030, "avg_nodes": 12835.833333333334, "eval_calls": 99994, "avg_eval_calls": 8332.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 99994, "pattern_eval_ns": 2151278, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.514070844250654, "pattern_frame_queries": 99994, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2151278, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.514070844250654, "pattern_frame_updates": 298890, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4041801272, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13522.704914851618, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46428, "avg_candidate_generations": 3869.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3800603, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.86014904798829, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 807, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 46416, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3799796, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1119692, "avg_legality_checks": 93307.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1176, "root_legality_checks": 807, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1118885, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1176, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4759475, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 396622.9166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9883765086, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2076.650278864791, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39364, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3280.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 199271451, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5062.276470887105, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1306, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10556882, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21317, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 135726500, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15868, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44111664, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 873, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8876405, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 128003, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10666.916666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1127604286, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8809.202018702686, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 168713, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14059.416666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 473864249, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2808.7002720596515, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2524777434, "stage_ordering_ns": 1418513150, "stage_eval_ns": 4043952550, "stage_threat_ns": 7478505850, "stage_proof_ns": 590242900, "tactical_annotations": 781490, "root_tactical_annotations": 2778, "search_tactical_annotations": 778712, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 307050, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1774709171, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 862827, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5364511779, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 95071, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3254102998, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 153519, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 220226806, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8148, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 49218852, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 307038, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37077681, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 202738, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 301495061, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 331711, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1176719665, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 247041, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32761561, "child_limit_applications": 46416, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46416, "child_cap_hits": 46416, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46416, "child_moves_before_total": 3798620, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3798620, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 496873, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 496873, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.83859014133057, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.704778524646674, "tt_hits": 25583, "tt_cutoffs": 3035, "beta_cutoffs": 36829, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3046.1666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3710.5833333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1736, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 4110, "avg_search_time_ms": 373.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 148788, "safety_nodes": 1080, "corridor_nodes": 1018, "corridor_branch_probes": 1225, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 12, "corridor_depth_exits": 404, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1005, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1005, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 404, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 59, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 341, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 204880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 150886, "avg_nodes": 13716.90909090909, "eval_calls": 144378, "avg_eval_calls": 13125.272727272728, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 144378, "pattern_eval_ns": 3177931, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.011185914751554, "pattern_frame_queries": 144378, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3177931, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.011185914751554, "pattern_frame_updates": 297512, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2128157022, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7153.180449864207, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4389, "avg_candidate_generations": 399.0, "candidate_moves_total": 314768, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.71747550694919, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 743, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 4378, "search_candidate_moves_total": 314025, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 9512, "avg_legality_checks": 864.7272727272727, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 9512, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 581969, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 52906.27272727273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1236313859, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2124.3637702351843, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4096, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 372.3636363636364, "renju_forbidden_ns": 36190407, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8835.548583984375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4071, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 36038807, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 151600, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 25297931, "stage_ordering_ns": 142780, "stage_eval_ns": 2131334953, "stage_threat_ns": 1822682443, "stage_proof_ns": 95945024, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 299651, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1524067268, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 62149, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 72017663, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 672, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 26676876, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 149820, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 180242642, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2128, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13074577, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 299640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33280293, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 140, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4012, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5407.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6135.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1691, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19316, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 140, 154, 110, 83, 81, 68, 111, 54, 40, 113, 95, 85, 86, 125, 109, 108, 123, 67, 137 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11182, "avg_search_time_ms": 1016.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 267757, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 1499, "corridor_branch_probes": 1728, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 659, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_plies_followed": 1481, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1481, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 659, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 416, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 180480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 269642, "avg_nodes": 24512.909090909092, "eval_calls": 261552, "avg_eval_calls": 23777.454545454544, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 261552, "pattern_eval_ns": 5811474, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.219191594788036, "pattern_frame_queries": 261552, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5811474, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.219191594788036, "pattern_frame_updates": 535452, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6348512898, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11856.362284574529, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6185, "avg_candidate_generations": 562.2727272727273, "candidate_moves_total": 486449, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.64979789814066, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 817, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 6174, "search_candidate_moves_total": 485632, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 257995, "avg_legality_checks": 23454.090909090908, "illegal_moves_skipped": 185, "root_legality_checks": 817, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 257178, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 185, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1998130, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 181648.18181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4903207487, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2453.8981382592724, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23782, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2162.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 244029273, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10261.091287528383, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 189, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1808708, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22987, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 235723322, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 234, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2999327, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 372, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3497916, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4056, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 368.72727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 43578264, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10744.147928994083, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5629, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 511.72727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 23599595, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4192.502220643099, "stage_move_gen_ns": 653711498, "stage_ordering_ns": 213590, "stage_eval_ns": 6354324372, "stage_threat_ns": 3869537172, "stage_proof_ns": 268910038, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 538535, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3113924071, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 86555, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 297561098, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 822, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 60602129, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 269262, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 373191859, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3072, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18499293, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 538524, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66360851, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 497, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5407, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3840.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4568.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8124, "avg_search_time_ms": 812.4, "search_nodes": 57660, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 679, "corridor_branch_probes": 794, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 334, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 673, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 673, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 334, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 13, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 35, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4015520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2002560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59312, "avg_nodes": 5931.2, "eval_calls": 35561, "avg_eval_calls": 3556.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35561, "pattern_eval_ns": 789005, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.187368184246786, "pattern_frame_queries": 35561, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 789005, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.187368184246786, "pattern_frame_updates": 115212, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1160994585, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10077.028304343297, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19885, "avg_candidate_generations": 1988.5, "candidate_moves_total": 1729291, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.96459642946945, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 749, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 19875, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1728542, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1086085, "avg_legality_checks": 108608.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1976, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1086085, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1976, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2416106, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 241610.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5293832259, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2191.059605414663, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19258, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1925.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 107180108, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5565.484889396615, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2227, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 24013315, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5591, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 56186785, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11440, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26980008, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 82971, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8297.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 845367199, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10188.70688553832, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 114481, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11448.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 403072025, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3520.863942488273, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2729657484, "stage_ordering_ns": 715583866, "stage_eval_ns": 1161783590, "stage_threat_ns": 3447333893, "stage_proof_ns": 17195722, "tactical_annotations": 313644, "root_tactical_annotations": 951, "search_tactical_annotations": 312693, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 116594, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 725535526, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 310657, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2599266790, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 40113, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1456918472, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58292, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90009869, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1372, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7784107, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 116584, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14893812, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52699, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 310046554, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 182651, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 807667097, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 78294, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9843789, "child_limit_applications": 19875, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19875, "child_cap_hits": 19875, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19875, "child_moves_before_total": 1726566, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1726566, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 204550, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 204550, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.87124528301887, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.29182389937107, "tt_hits": 9342, "tt_cutoffs": 2171, "beta_cutoffs": 15724, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 5.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4238.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5038.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1769, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1692, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15223, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 85, 68, 111, 80, 81, 113, 94, 78, 95, 36, 109, 108, 123, 67, 137 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 12585, "avg_search_time_ms": 1258.5, "search_nodes": 106403, "safety_nodes": 568, "corridor_nodes": 2765, "corridor_branch_probes": 3172, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1191, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2742, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2742, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1191, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 555, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 27922880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 109736, "avg_nodes": 10973.6, "eval_calls": 66571, "avg_eval_calls": 6657.1, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 66571, "pattern_eval_ns": 1484674, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.30211353291974, "pattern_frame_queries": 66571, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1484674, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.30211353291974, "pattern_frame_updates": 212698, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2619376693, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12315.003869335866, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37197, "avg_candidate_generations": 3719.7, "candidate_moves_total": 2972424, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.91031534801193, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 651, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 37187, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2971773, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 891539, "avg_legality_checks": 89153.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 818, "root_legality_checks": 651, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 890888, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 815, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3386534, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 338653.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7705095623, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2275.215787882242, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19101, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1910.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 112671582, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5898.72687293859, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 873, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8130546, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8780, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73844761, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9015, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26815770, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 433, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3880505, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 78283, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7828.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 717839920, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9169.805960425636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 102275, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10227.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 302326576, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2956.0163871913956, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2254115882, "stage_ordering_ns": 1251651018, "stage_eval_ns": 2620861367, "stage_threat_ns": 5964017568, "stage_proof_ns": 445673914, "tactical_annotations": 509747, "root_tactical_annotations": 2024, "search_tactical_annotations": 507723, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 218330, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1373735532, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 562353, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4335792504, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75917, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2928147761, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 109160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 168011013, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5622, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 33519004, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 218320, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28313683, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 95465, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 158759288, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 229067, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 821830463, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 185215, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24645832, "child_limit_applications": 37187, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37187, "child_cap_hits": 37187, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37187, "child_moves_before_total": 2970958, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2970958, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 345703, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 345703, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.8923817463092, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.29634011885874, "tt_hits": 21246, "tt_cutoffs": 2591, "beta_cutoffs": 29428, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2080.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2825.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 551, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 2630, "avg_search_time_ms": 292.22222222222223, "search_nodes": 82940, "safety_nodes": 627, "corridor_nodes": 835, "corridor_branch_probes": 989, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 311, "corridor_neutral_exits": 23, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 819, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 819, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 65, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 311, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 65, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 453, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 250560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 84402, "avg_nodes": 9378.0, "eval_calls": 79466, "avg_eval_calls": 8829.555555555555, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79466, "pattern_eval_ns": 1708446, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.499081368132284, "pattern_frame_queries": 79466, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1708446, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.499081368132284, "pattern_frame_updates": 165828, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1290588399, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7782.692904696432, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3457, "avg_candidate_generations": 384.1111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 248091, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.7648249927683, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 583, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 3448, "search_candidate_moves_total": 247508, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 11384, "avg_legality_checks": 1264.888888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 11384, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 344209, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 38245.444444444445, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 825106130, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2397.1079489496205, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2052, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 228.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19400047, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9454.213937621833, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 38770, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2016, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19022695, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 145280, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 193302, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 30730445, "stage_ordering_ns": 120280, "stage_eval_ns": 1292296845, "stage_threat_ns": 1173261158, "stage_proof_ns": 111452422, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 167605, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 966586054, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 54401, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 62022944, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 644, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 25414968, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 83798, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 114007711, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1768, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10274026, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 167596, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20370423, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 200, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3124, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5320.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6208.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1693, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17090, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 128, 80, 82, 144, 97, 127, 68, 110, 52, 67, 84, 100, 85, 83, 54, 40, 51, 50, 69, 95, 65, 140, 125, 99, 53, 55, 101, 37, 117 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 9836, "avg_search_time_ms": 655.7333333333333, "search_nodes": 226654, "safety_nodes": 254, "corridor_nodes": 2123, "corridor_branch_probes": 2492, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 712, "corridor_neutral_exits": 42, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 2088, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2088, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 146, "corridor_proof_active": 35, "corridor_proof_quiet": 111, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 42, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 712, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 146, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 141, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1197, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 305360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 18, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 14, "total_nodes": 229031, "avg_nodes": 15268.733333333334, "eval_calls": 219224, "avg_eval_calls": 14614.933333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 219224, "pattern_eval_ns": 4721027, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.535174068532644, "pattern_frame_queries": 219224, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4721027, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.535174068532644, "pattern_frame_updates": 453222, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5218349403, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11513.892536108133, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7402, "avg_candidate_generations": 493.46666666666664, "candidate_moves_total": 576322, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.86030802485814, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1088, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 7387, "search_candidate_moves_total": 575234, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 211793, "avg_legality_checks": 14119.533333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 219, "root_legality_checks": 1088, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 210705, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 215, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1859000, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 123933.33333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4388648269, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2360.7575411511566, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19521, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1301.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 145494585, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7453.234209313047, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 336, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2440236, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18455, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 137153749, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 199, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2298636, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 531, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3601964, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3744, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 249.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 36907479, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9857.766826923076, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5300, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 353.3333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 19489197, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3677.2069811320753, "stage_move_gen_ns": 539144867, "stage_ordering_ns": 264891, "stage_eval_ns": 5223070430, "stage_threat_ns": 3490259803, "stage_proof_ns": 541571520, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 457705, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2697822577, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 143632, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 384767510, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1705, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 84883953, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 228845, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 321937539, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4468, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 28645168, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 457690, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57087009, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 809, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6278, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5366.466666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5899.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 7242, "avg_search_time_ms": 517.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 55689, "safety_nodes": 1587, "corridor_nodes": 89, "corridor_branch_probes": 113, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 29, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 87, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 87, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 17, "corridor_proof_active": 2, "corridor_proof_quiet": 15, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 17, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 17, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 36, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 8018080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 57365, "avg_nodes": 4097.5, "eval_calls": 33411, "avg_eval_calls": 2386.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33411, "pattern_eval_ns": 748075, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.390081111011344, "pattern_frame_queries": 33411, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 748075, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.390081111011344, "pattern_frame_updates": 111218, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1144311280, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10288.903594741858, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20597, "avg_candidate_generations": 1471.2142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 1643452, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.79084332669807, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1018, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 20583, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1642434, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 897051, "avg_legality_checks": 64075.07142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 913, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 897051, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 913, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2116010, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 151143.57142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4638252486, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2191.9804188070943, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19767, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1411.9285714285713, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61450285, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3108.730965750999, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1389, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10815766, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5128, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29265068, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13216, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21030590, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 338861, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 67134, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4795.285714285715, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 596691535, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8888.067670628892, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 88937, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6352.642857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 248168954, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2790.390433677772, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2231003873, "stage_ordering_ns": 694687205, "stage_eval_ns": 1145059355, "stage_threat_ns": 3087655764, "stage_proof_ns": 29848689, "tactical_annotations": 295700, "root_tactical_annotations": 524, "search_tactical_annotations": 295176, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 111440, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 688911854, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 284428, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2292352499, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41390, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1427640042, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 55713, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 85194226, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 208, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1491565, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 111426, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14305003, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 54104, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 182646973, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 183022, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 677218151, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 58574, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5400617, "child_limit_applications": 20583, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20583, "child_cap_hits": 20583, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20583, "child_moves_before_total": 1641521, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1641521, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 185603, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 185603, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.75129961618812, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.017295826653063, "tt_hits": 7700, "tt_cutoffs": 1616, "beta_cutoffs": 16235, "depth_sum": 79, "avg_depth": 5.642857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 79, "avg_effective_depth": 5.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5363.785714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5935.214285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1694, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28491, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 128, 82, 142, 100, 143, 83, 156, 170, 158, 113, 81, 110, 124, 68, 54, 64, 48, 111, 109, 67, 188, 173, 140, 172, 141, 139, 144 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 22372, "avg_search_time_ms": 1598.0, "search_nodes": 183568, "safety_nodes": 725, "corridor_nodes": 1999, "corridor_branch_probes": 2317, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 915, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1983, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1983, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 28, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 12, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 915, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 28, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 28, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 164, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23824960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 186292, "avg_nodes": 13306.57142857143, "eval_calls": 115348, "avg_eval_calls": 8239.142857142857, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 115348, "pattern_eval_ns": 2579684, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.364358289697265, "pattern_frame_queries": 115348, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2579684, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.364358289697265, "pattern_frame_updates": 366974, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5376738672, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14651.552077258879, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 61925, "avg_candidate_generations": 4423.214285714285, "candidate_moves_total": 5788785, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.48058134840532, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1168, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 61911, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5787617, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 1648490, "avg_legality_checks": 117749.28571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3809, "root_legality_checks": 1168, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1647322, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3807, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5866476, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 419034.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13332934500, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2272.7331536002193, "renju_forbidden_checks": 81039, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5788.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 549436375, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6779.900726810548, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4954, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 48840483, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 38406, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 338538563, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37285, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 158868809, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 394, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3188520, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 156478, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11177.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1598477150, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10215.347524891678, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 220340, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15738.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 749970049, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3403.6945130253243, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4197068725, "stage_ordering_ns": 2280321361, "stage_eval_ns": 5379318356, "stage_threat_ns": 10167170886, "stage_proof_ns": 268593994, "tactical_annotations": 1309892, "root_tactical_annotations": 3719, "search_tactical_annotations": 1306173, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 371010, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2307625303, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1141328, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7436371052, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 124835, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4738209245, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185498, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 290753895, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4022, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25054402, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 370996, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48577626, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 345807, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 448771554, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 559812, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1948090805, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 404273, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 58788608, "child_limit_applications": 61911, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 61911, "child_cap_hits": 61911, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 61911, "child_moves_before_total": 5783810, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5783810, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 773677, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 773677, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.42136292419764, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.496599958004232, "tt_hits": 36157, "tt_cutoffs": 6231, "beta_cutoffs": 50939, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1490.2857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1896.9285714285713, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6105, "avg_search_time_ms": 436.07142857142856, "search_nodes": 159158, "safety_nodes": 1726, "corridor_nodes": 2086, "corridor_branch_probes": 2492, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 37, "corridor_depth_exits": 926, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 2062, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2062, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 45, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 926, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 349, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 275840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 162970, "avg_nodes": 11640.714285714286, "eval_calls": 155446, "avg_eval_calls": 11103.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 155446, "pattern_eval_ns": 3354794, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.581732563076567, "pattern_frame_queries": 155446, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3354794, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.581732563076567, "pattern_frame_updates": 318236, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3615376662, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11360.677805150894, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3686, "avg_candidate_generations": 263.2857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 316223, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.79028757460662, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1195, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 3672, "search_candidate_moves_total": 315028, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 6336, "avg_legality_checks": 452.57142857142856, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6336, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1015619, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 72544.21428571429, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2435711511, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2398.2531943573326, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22389, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1599.2142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 189596279, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8468.278127651973, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 228153, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22267, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 188453870, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 32, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 208282, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 69, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 705974, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18377664, "stage_ordering_ns": 121921, "stage_eval_ns": 3618731456, "stage_threat_ns": 2344874868, "stage_proof_ns": 93408747, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 322496, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1915789401, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 116369, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 136746188, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1024, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 41279708, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 161241, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 227120939, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4246, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24885271, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 322482, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40333069, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 167, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3390, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6184.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6755.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1969, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1695, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24117, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 128, 80, 110, 144, 111, 113, 124, 82, 108, 109, 140, 156, 155, 125, 138, 152, 93, 78, 92, 76, 79, 143, 95, 94, 63, 47, 127 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 15449, "avg_search_time_ms": 1103.5, "search_nodes": 372640, "safety_nodes": 422, "corridor_nodes": 1678, "corridor_branch_probes": 1927, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 586, "corridor_neutral_exits": 26, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1650, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1650, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 162, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 134, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 586, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 162, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 160, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1362, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 292160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 374740, "avg_nodes": 26767.14285714286, "eval_calls": 362768, "avg_eval_calls": 25912.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 362768, "pattern_eval_ns": 7819123, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.554059343712787, "pattern_frame_queries": 362768, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 7819123, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.554059343712787, "pattern_frame_updates": 745200, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8623841670, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11572.519685990339, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9846, "avg_candidate_generations": 703.2857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 794535, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.69622181596587, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1013, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 9832, "search_candidate_moves_total": 793522, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 350704, "avg_legality_checks": 25050.285714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 372, "root_legality_checks": 1013, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 349691, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 372, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2776207, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 198300.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6714262286, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2418.502037492161, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27800, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1985.7142857142858, "renju_forbidden_ns": 218862796, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7872.762446043165, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 385, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3372253, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27009, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 211343419, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 169, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2002404, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 237, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2144720, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2804, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 200.28571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 28791958, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10268.17332382311, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3947, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 281.92857142857144, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 15544094, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3938.2047124398277, "stage_move_gen_ns": 896572107, "stage_ordering_ns": 377304, "stage_eval_ns": 8631660793, "stage_threat_ns": 5367911746, "stage_proof_ns": 511777224, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 748838, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4404049237, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 112521, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 314169057, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1521, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 72590859, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 374412, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 532689964, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3624, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22375156, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 748824, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 94628332, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 751, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8539, "depth_sum": 39, "avg_depth": 2.7857142857142856, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 39, "avg_effective_depth": 2.7857142857142856, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4319.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4890.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 8652, "avg_search_time_ms": 665.5384615384615, "search_nodes": 61047, "safety_nodes": 1187, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 13, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 13, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 22, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4005760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 62234, "avg_nodes": 4787.2307692307695, "eval_calls": 35981, "avg_eval_calls": 2767.769230769231, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35981, "pattern_eval_ns": 809980, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.511325421750367, "pattern_frame_queries": 35981, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 809980, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.511325421750367, "pattern_frame_updates": 121946, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1293802727, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10609.636453840225, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23151, "avg_candidate_generations": 1780.8461538461538, "candidate_moves_total": 1903420, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.21761478985789, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 944, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 23138, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1902476, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1141325, "avg_legality_checks": 87794.23076923077, "illegal_moves_skipped": 609, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1141325, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 609, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2608510, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 200654.61538461538, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5638590019, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2161.613342099513, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22686, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1745.076923076923, "renju_forbidden_ns": 57246633, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2523.4344088865378, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 723, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6057884, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4544, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30064531, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17419, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21124218, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93223, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7171.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 855407231, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9175.924728875922, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 130092, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10007.076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 381423318, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2931.9506041878058, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2795629717, "stage_ordering_ns": 791487887, "stage_eval_ns": 1294612707, "stage_threat_ns": 3690151593, "stage_proof_ns": 23728133, "tactical_annotations": 380671, "root_tactical_annotations": 964, "search_tactical_annotations": 379707, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 121985, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 761302921, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 349457, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2808010848, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46428, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1613238848, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 60986, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 95605284, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 26, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 162980, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 121972, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15799317, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 77219, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 300837607, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 225776, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 893670132, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 77676, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9270243, "child_limit_applications": 23138, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23138, "child_cap_hits": 23138, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23138, "child_moves_before_total": 1901867, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1901867, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 216553, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 216553, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.19668942864551, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.359192670066557, "tt_hits": 9016, "tt_cutoffs": 1855, "beta_cutoffs": 18354, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5149.153846153846, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5764.538461538462, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1696, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26643, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 128, 110, 114, 156, 129, 125, 100, 86, 130, 127, 95, 82, 68, 124, 138, 64, 48, 97, 67, 109, 132, 131, 84, 116, 99, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 22398, "avg_search_time_ms": 1599.857142857143, "search_nodes": 181521, "safety_nodes": 725, "corridor_nodes": 1942, "corridor_branch_probes": 2269, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 884, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1927, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1927, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 27, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 12, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 884, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 27, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 27, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 163, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23823520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 184188, "avg_nodes": 13156.285714285714, "eval_calls": 114370, "avg_eval_calls": 8169.285714285715, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 114370, "pattern_eval_ns": 2525048, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.07788755792603, "pattern_frame_queries": 114370, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2525048, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.07788755792603, "pattern_frame_updates": 362880, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5353429628, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14752.616920194003, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 61177, "avg_candidate_generations": 4369.785714285715, "candidate_moves_total": 5706465, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.27794759468428, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1168, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 61163, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5705297, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 1662204, "avg_legality_checks": 118728.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4252, "root_legality_checks": 1168, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1661036, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4250, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5889820, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 420701.4285714286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13399014978, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2274.944731417938, "renju_forbidden_checks": 81217, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5801.214285714285, "renju_forbidden_ns": 562416196, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6924.858046960611, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5457, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 55049755, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 37916, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 342787748, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 37467, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 161539658, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 377, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3039035, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 161565, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11540.357142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1658506559, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10265.25892984248, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 228717, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16336.92857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 782380670, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3420.7368494689945, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4248652810, "stage_ordering_ns": 2271709493, "stage_eval_ns": 5355954676, "stage_threat_ns": 10181021331, "stage_proof_ns": 263123425, "tactical_annotations": 1287554, "root_tactical_annotations": 3719, "search_tactical_annotations": 1283835, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 366802, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2297824622, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1129893, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7467501144, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 123305, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4716044327, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 183394, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 289402076, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3908, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24286194, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 366788, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48385793, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 342292, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 468636879, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 555858, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1987836884, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 389404, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 53621502, "child_limit_applications": 61163, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 61163, "child_cap_hits": 61163, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 61163, "child_moves_before_total": 5701047, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5701047, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 758620, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 758620, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.21071562872979, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.403250331082518, "tt_hits": 35184, "tt_cutoffs": 5911, "beta_cutoffs": 50383, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1452.5714285714287, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1857.4285714285713, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 4233, "avg_search_time_ms": 302.35714285714283, "search_nodes": 113378, "safety_nodes": 1726, "corridor_nodes": 2095, "corridor_branch_probes": 2507, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 37, "corridor_depth_exits": 929, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 2071, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2071, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 44, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 929, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 349, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 274080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 117199, "avg_nodes": 8371.357142857143, "eval_calls": 109780, "avg_eval_calls": 7841.428571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 109780, "pattern_eval_ns": 2378034, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.661814538167242, "pattern_frame_queries": 109780, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2378034, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.661814538167242, "pattern_frame_updates": 226676, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2364402226, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10430.756789426317, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3572, "avg_candidate_generations": 255.14285714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 305307, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.47228443449048, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1195, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 3558, "search_candidate_moves_total": 304112, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 6335, "avg_legality_checks": 452.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6335, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 668758, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 47768.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1621099137, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2424.0444779726, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11098, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 792.7142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 96282041, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8675.620922688773, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 211660, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10979, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 95120207, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 231531, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 69, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 718643, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18327672, "stage_ordering_ns": 114441, "stage_eval_ns": 2366780260, "stage_threat_ns": 1726022238, "stage_proof_ns": 92951528, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 230954, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1372807628, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 117007, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 136409925, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1029, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 41303226, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 115470, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 162816575, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4264, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25130251, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 230940, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28857859, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 167, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3285, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6218.785714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6790.214285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1958, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1697, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19720, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 144, 160, 114, 81, 83, 66, 113, 50, 34, 111, 99, 79, 78, 129, 115, 116, 131, 67, 147 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11715, "avg_search_time_ms": 1065.0, "search_nodes": 276880, "safety_nodes": 386, "corridor_nodes": 1304, "corridor_branch_probes": 1514, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 576, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 1286, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1286, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 576, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 416, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 183200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 278570, "avg_nodes": 25324.545454545456, "eval_calls": 270723, "avg_eval_calls": 24611.18181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 270723, "pattern_eval_ns": 5799689, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.42296369351699, "pattern_frame_queries": 270723, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5799689, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.42296369351699, "pattern_frame_updates": 553698, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6729387247, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12153.533599543434, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6137, "avg_candidate_generations": 557.9090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 485854, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.16799739286296, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 817, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 6126, "search_candidate_moves_total": 485037, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 267526, "avg_legality_checks": 24320.545454545456, "illegal_moves_skipped": 202, "root_legality_checks": 817, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 266709, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 202, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2058382, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 187125.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5132775782, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2493.5972924364864, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25652, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2332.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 268251898, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10457.348276937471, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 206, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2021883, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24936, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 260874090, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 200, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2575791, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 310, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2780134, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3567, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 324.27272727272725, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 39394584, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11044.178301093356, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4989, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 453.54545454545456, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 21478031, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4305.077370214472, "stage_move_gen_ns": 684147782, "stage_ordering_ns": 209640, "stage_eval_ns": 6735186936, "stage_threat_ns": 4011355962, "stage_proof_ns": 251825223, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 556391, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3265951778, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 75261, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 265060657, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 730, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 53473984, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 278190, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 395232304, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2682, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15808841, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 556380, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 69302382, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 489, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5382, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3676.6363636363635, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4403.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7994, "avg_search_time_ms": 799.4, "search_nodes": 55815, "safety_nodes": 973, "corridor_nodes": 679, "corridor_branch_probes": 794, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 334, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 673, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 673, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 334, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 13, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 35, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4016560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2002560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 57467, "avg_nodes": 5746.7, "eval_calls": 34277, "avg_eval_calls": 3427.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34277, "pattern_eval_ns": 755321, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.035796598302067, "pattern_frame_queries": 34277, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 755321, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.035796598302067, "pattern_frame_updates": 111522, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1114086676, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9989.837664317354, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19529, "avg_candidate_generations": 1952.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1703564, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.2325259869937, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 749, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 19519, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1702815, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1057424, "avg_legality_checks": 105742.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1070, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1057424, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1070, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2348951, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 234895.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5229316248, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2226.234709876877, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16986, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1698.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 84068567, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4949.285705875427, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1321, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14072875, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4584, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 45789509, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11081, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24206183, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81509, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8150.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 851542760, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10447.223742163442, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 112480, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11248.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 406301227, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3612.208632645804, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2684961600, "stage_ordering_ns": 719136507, "stage_eval_ns": 1114841997, "stage_threat_ns": 3407628357, "stage_proof_ns": 17356915, "tactical_annotations": 302930, "root_tactical_annotations": 951, "search_tactical_annotations": 301979, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 112904, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 704959386, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 303519, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2583941265, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 39401, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1440045179, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56447, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87797692, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1372, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7865945, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 112894, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14525577, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 51069, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 318497934, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 177855, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 801175209, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 74006, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8538492, "child_limit_applications": 19519, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19519, "child_cap_hits": 19519, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19519, "child_moves_before_total": 1701745, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1701745, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 198827, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 198827, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.18402582099493, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.186331266970644, "tt_hits": 8740, "tt_cutoffs": 1966, "beta_cutoffs": 15490, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 5.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4237.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5037.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1715, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1698, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14721, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 114, 81, 79, 66, 113, 84, 83, 111, 100, 86, 99, 38, 115, 116, 131, 67, 147 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 12855, "avg_search_time_ms": 1285.5, "search_nodes": 108360, "safety_nodes": 568, "corridor_nodes": 2766, "corridor_branch_probes": 3169, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1200, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2743, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2743, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1200, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 555, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 27914080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 111694, "avg_nodes": 11169.4, "eval_calls": 67957, "avg_eval_calls": 6795.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67957, "pattern_eval_ns": 1488519, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.903836249393, "pattern_frame_queries": 67957, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1488519, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.903836249393, "pattern_frame_updates": 216612, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2661101557, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12285.106813103614, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37842, "avg_candidate_generations": 3784.2, "candidate_moves_total": 3018548, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.76713704349665, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 651, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 37832, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3017897, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 917711, "avg_legality_checks": 91771.1, "illegal_moves_skipped": 856, "root_legality_checks": 651, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 917060, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 853, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3448617, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 344861.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7892418717, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2288.57501920335, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19871, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1987.1, "renju_forbidden_ns": 114656149, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5770.024105480348, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 910, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8278670, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9112, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 74979644, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9401, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27447969, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 448, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3949866, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81079, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8107.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 754950195, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9311.291394812466, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 105799, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10579.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 319180556, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3016.857966521423, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2329708753, "stage_ordering_ns": 1273411493, "stage_eval_ns": 2662590076, "stage_threat_ns": 6093192056, "stage_proof_ns": 447016990, "tactical_annotations": 505226, "root_tactical_annotations": 2024, "search_tactical_annotations": 503202, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 222246, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1398361232, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 563220, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4436654064, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 77203, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2988523356, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 111118, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 172680925, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5624, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 33169731, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 222236, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28607175, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 95822, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 164435398, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 229114, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 855569654, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 180290, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23718929, "child_limit_applications": 37832, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37832, "child_cap_hits": 37832, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37832, "child_moves_before_total": 3017044, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3017044, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 348153, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 348153, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.74846690632269, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.202606259251427, "tt_hits": 21229, "tt_cutoffs": 2517, "beta_cutoffs": 29974, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1821.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2539.6, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 318, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 1860, "avg_search_time_ms": 206.66666666666666, "search_nodes": 52848, "safety_nodes": 627, "corridor_nodes": 865, "corridor_branch_probes": 1026, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 317, "corridor_neutral_exits": 24, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 848, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 848, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 65, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 317, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 65, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 453, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 272960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 54340, "avg_nodes": 6037.777777777777, "eval_calls": 50368, "avg_eval_calls": 5596.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50368, "pattern_eval_ns": 1081012, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.462277636594663, "pattern_frame_queries": 50368, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1081012, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.462277636594663, "pattern_frame_updates": 105644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 898502145, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8504.999290068532, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2463, "avg_candidate_generations": 273.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 173850, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.58465286236297, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 583, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 2454, "search_candidate_moves_total": 173267, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 10814, "avg_legality_checks": 1201.5555555555557, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10814, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 263800, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29311.11111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 637738800, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2417.508718726308, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2573, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 285.8888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 25914035, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10071.525456665371, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 41130, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2535, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25510385, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 166730, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 195790, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 29176889, "stage_ordering_ns": 91690, "stage_eval_ns": 899583157, "stage_threat_ns": 799812368, "stage_proof_ns": 112120242, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 107479, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 637645444, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 56875, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 64115786, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 661, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 26510568, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 53735, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74317271, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1826, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10576870, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 107470, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13156997, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 200, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2172, "depth_sum": 26, "avg_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 26, "avg_effective_depth": 2.888888888888889, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5478.777777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6367.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1978, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1699, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19798, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 140, 154, 142, 99, 129, 100, 127, 69, 54, 97, 143, 86, 72, 141, 157, 172, 171, 115, 185 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11867, "avg_search_time_ms": 1078.8181818181818, "search_nodes": 264590, "safety_nodes": 383, "corridor_nodes": 1230, "corridor_branch_probes": 1441, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 520, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 1212, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1212, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 520, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 416, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 166880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 266203, "avg_nodes": 24200.272727272728, "eval_calls": 258650, "avg_eval_calls": 23513.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 258650, "pattern_eval_ns": 5534376, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.39716218828533, "pattern_frame_queries": 258650, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5534376, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.39716218828533, "pattern_frame_updates": 529118, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7050561488, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13325.12121681742, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5920, "avg_candidate_generations": 538.1818181818181, "candidate_moves_total": 461313, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.92449324324325, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 809, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 5909, "search_candidate_moves_total": 460504, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 254756, "avg_legality_checks": 23159.636363636364, "illegal_moves_skipped": 89, "root_legality_checks": 809, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 253947, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 89, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2103135, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 191194.0909090909, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5332459964, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2535.4815377995233, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32213, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2928.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 355333256, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 11030.740881010772, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 92, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 891886, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 31451, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 348217121, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 213, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2608036, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 457, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3616213, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3511, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 319.1818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 39096969, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11135.565081173454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4992, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 453.8181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 21302188, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4267.265224358975, "stage_move_gen_ns": 664586932, "stage_ordering_ns": 206014, "stage_eval_ns": 7056095864, "stage_threat_ns": 3878553727, "stage_proof_ns": 247309355, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 531663, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3154338837, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 73416, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 257129599, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 707, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 51265946, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 265826, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 385088541, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2534, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15113186, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 531652, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 66883564, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 493, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5071, "depth_sum": 30, "avg_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 30, "avg_effective_depth": 2.727272727272727, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3777.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4505.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 7922, "avg_search_time_ms": 792.2, "search_nodes": 52417, "safety_nodes": 953, "corridor_nodes": 530, "corridor_branch_probes": 590, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 248, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 524, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 524, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 248, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 13, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 35, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 6, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4012800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2002560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 53900, "avg_nodes": 5390.0, "eval_calls": 32118, "avg_eval_calls": 3211.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 32118, "pattern_eval_ns": 715004, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.26178466903294, "pattern_frame_queries": 32118, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 715004, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.26178466903294, "pattern_frame_updates": 104726, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1201962514, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11477.21209632756, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18206, "avg_candidate_generations": 1820.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1564274, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.92079534219488, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 739, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 18196, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1563535, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 955567, "avg_legality_checks": 95556.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 526, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 955567, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 526, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2378032, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 237803.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5224176114, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2196.8485344183764, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14616, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1461.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60230244, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4120.843185550082, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 730, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7513669, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3634, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33987294, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10252, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 18729281, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 100760, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10076.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1090748479, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10825.213169908693, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 143069, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14306.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 539011833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3767.4956349733347, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2433315094, "stage_ordering_ns": 656749272, "stage_eval_ns": 1202677518, "stage_threat_ns": 3563903932, "stage_proof_ns": 18875459, "tactical_annotations": 327892, "root_tactical_annotations": 951, "search_tactical_annotations": 326941, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 105810, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 667238338, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 319811, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2785154386, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36731, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1366393431, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52900, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 83287944, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1074, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6142317, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 105800, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13691713, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 53819, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 343486493, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 200381, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1056319832, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 73692, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8389234, "child_limit_applications": 18196, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18196, "child_cap_hits": 18196, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18196, "child_moves_before_total": 1563009, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1563009, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 209831, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 209831, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.89849417454386, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.531710265992526, "tt_hits": 8050, "tt_cutoffs": 2050, "beta_cutoffs": 14352, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 5.3, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4204.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5004.1, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1616, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1700, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18871, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 141, 99, 129, 86, 140, 154, 142, 54, 69, 143, 127, 157, 156, 171, 97, 82, 111, 96, 83, 55, 125 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 17042, "avg_search_time_ms": 1420.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 152321, "safety_nodes": 719, "corridor_nodes": 707, "corridor_branch_probes": 831, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 310, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 700, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 700, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 30, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 23, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 310, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 30, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 169, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6113280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 153747, "avg_nodes": 12812.25, "eval_calls": 96151, "avg_eval_calls": 8012.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 96151, "pattern_eval_ns": 2085048, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.685141080175974, "pattern_frame_queries": 96151, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2085048, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.685141080175974, "pattern_frame_updates": 304514, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4533939593, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14889.100642334999, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52017, "avg_candidate_generations": 4334.75, "candidate_moves_total": 4641449, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.2294634446431, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 887, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 52005, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4640562, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1104307, "avg_legality_checks": 92025.58333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2654, "root_legality_checks": 887, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1103420, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2652, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4578841, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 381570.0833333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10004089988, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2184.8520156083164, "renju_forbidden_checks": 56926, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4743.833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 449968001, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7904.437357270843, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3059, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 31784450, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 31363, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 303283198, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22292, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 113117734, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 212, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1782619, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 119296, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9941.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1161503358, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9736.314360917382, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 166842, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13903.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 553964507, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3320.2940926145693, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2687806393, "stage_ordering_ns": 1840440559, "stage_eval_ns": 4536024641, "stage_threat_ns": 7786100903, "stage_proof_ns": 121861192, "tactical_annotations": 927276, "root_tactical_annotations": 2532, "search_tactical_annotations": 924744, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 305986, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1826090965, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 752262, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5636165657, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 104482, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3866183961, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 152987, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 229898735, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1460, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7492576, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 305974, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38727514, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 244371, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 393052010, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 362317, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1276815445, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 320588, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 47725456, "child_limit_applications": 52005, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52005, "child_cap_hits": 52005, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52005, "child_moves_before_total": 4637910, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4637910, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 594489, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 594489, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.18200173060282, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.431381597923277, "tt_hits": 31012, "tt_cutoffs": 4101, "beta_cutoffs": 43691, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.166666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3012.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3600.9166666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 316, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1818, "avg_search_time_ms": 165.27272727272728, "search_nodes": 53783, "safety_nodes": 1057, "corridor_nodes": 2139, "corridor_branch_probes": 2573, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 10, "corridor_depth_exits": 907, "corridor_neutral_exits": 17, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2116, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2116, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 27, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 907, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 55, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 329, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 177440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 56979, "avg_nodes": 5179.909090909091, "eval_calls": 51085, "avg_eval_calls": 4644.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 51085, "pattern_eval_ns": 1077503, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.092355877459138, "pattern_frame_queries": 51085, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1077503, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.092355877459138, "pattern_frame_updates": 107502, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 810235504, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7536.934233781697, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2677, "avg_candidate_generations": 243.36363636363637, "candidate_moves_total": 200622, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.94284646992902, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 807, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 2666, "search_candidate_moves_total": 199815, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 7120, "avg_legality_checks": 647.2727272727273, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7120, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 250623, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 22783.909090909092, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 567524347, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2264.4543677156526, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2021, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 183.72727272727272, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19005117, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9403.818406729342, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 37730, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1842, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17205384, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 156, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1589403, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 172600, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 18269708, "stage_ordering_ns": 88340, "stage_eval_ns": 811313007, "stage_threat_ns": 889930367, "stage_proof_ns": 81970813, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 111855, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 638108289, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 125365, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 140796063, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1158, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 53331722, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 55922, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 74842775, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4342, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 23073496, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 111844, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13109744, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 132, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2435, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5950.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6677.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1972, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1701, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16923, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 126, 84, 82, 140, 97, 127, 66, 114, 52, 67, 80, 94, 79, 81, 50, 34, 53, 54, 65, 99, 69, 144, 129, 95, 51, 49, 93, 37, 107 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 9865, "avg_search_time_ms": 657.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 240286, "safety_nodes": 254, "corridor_nodes": 2224, "corridor_branch_probes": 2564, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 769, "corridor_neutral_exits": 43, "corridor_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_plies_followed": 2189, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2189, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 146, "corridor_proof_active": 35, "corridor_proof_quiet": 111, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 43, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 769, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 146, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 141, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1197, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 342480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 18, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 14, "total_nodes": 242764, "avg_nodes": 16184.266666666666, "eval_calls": 232621, "avg_eval_calls": 15508.066666666668, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 232621, "pattern_eval_ns": 4944639, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.256202148559243, "pattern_frame_queries": 232621, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4944639, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.256202148559243, "pattern_frame_updates": 480486, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5213302285, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10850.060740583493, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7637, "avg_candidate_generations": 509.1333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 591954, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.51132643708263, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1088, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 7622, "search_candidate_moves_total": 590866, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 224316, "avg_legality_checks": 14954.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 219, "root_legality_checks": 1088, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 223228, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 215, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1943848, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 129589.86666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4372676032, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2249.494832929324, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19756, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1317.0666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 141030200, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7138.600931362624, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 324, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2371920, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 18490, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 131881838, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 235, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2641553, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 707, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4134889, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 4164, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 277.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 40097620, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9629.591738712776, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5924, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 394.93333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 21145505, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3569.4640445644836, "stage_move_gen_ns": 542203499, "stage_ordering_ns": 296981, "stage_eval_ns": 5218246924, "stage_threat_ns": 3536730858, "stage_proof_ns": 521458285, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 485171, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2739744961, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 147976, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 385230925, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1755, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 83789450, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 242578, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 324561695, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4670, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 29206235, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 485156, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57987042, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 815, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 6482, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 2.8, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5373.866666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5907.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 7041, "avg_search_time_ms": 502.92857142857144, "search_nodes": 56536, "safety_nodes": 1587, "corridor_nodes": 89, "corridor_branch_probes": 113, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 29, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 87, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 87, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 17, "corridor_proof_active": 2, "corridor_proof_quiet": 15, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 17, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 17, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 36, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 8017760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 58212, "avg_nodes": 4158.0, "eval_calls": 34027, "avg_eval_calls": 2430.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34027, "pattern_eval_ns": 742571, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.82299350515767, "pattern_frame_queries": 34027, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 742571, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.82299350515767, "pattern_frame_updates": 112912, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1123762930, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9952.555352841151, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20792, "avg_candidate_generations": 1485.142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 1652705, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.48754328587918, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1018, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 20778, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1651687, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 917387, "avg_legality_checks": 65527.642857142855, "illegal_moves_skipped": 928, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 917387, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 928, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2165685, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 154691.7857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4513774822, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2084.2250013275248, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20246, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1446.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 60707042, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2998.4709078336464, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1410, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10567759, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5548, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29651190, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13254, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20172422, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 315671, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 69363, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4954.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 584569819, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8427.68938771391, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92429, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6602.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 241766369, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2615.6982007811403, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2178369870, "stage_ordering_ns": 662229511, "stage_eval_ns": 1124505501, "stage_threat_ns": 2992890044, "stage_proof_ns": 29660267, "tactical_annotations": 300664, "root_tactical_annotations": 524, "search_tactical_annotations": 300140, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 113134, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 671735724, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 289447, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2218509037, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41780, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1374296654, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81513408, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 208, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1473416, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 113120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14020920, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 53982, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 171268789, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 187773, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 668085156, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 58909, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5637539, "child_limit_applications": 20778, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20778, "child_cap_hits": 20778, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20778, "child_moves_before_total": 1650759, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1650759, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 188120, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 188120, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.44744441235923, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.05380691115603, "tt_hits": 7680, "tt_cutoffs": 1652, "beta_cutoffs": 16352, "depth_sum": 79, "avg_depth": 5.642857142857143, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 79, "avg_effective_depth": 5.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5375.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5947.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1702, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29347, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 126, 82, 142, 94, 141, 81, 156, 111, 158, 174, 83, 114, 130, 66, 50, 70, 56, 113, 115, 67, 186, 171, 144, 172, 143, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 22368, "avg_search_time_ms": 1597.7142857142858, "search_nodes": 182593, "safety_nodes": 713, "corridor_nodes": 2047, "corridor_branch_probes": 2380, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 937, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2032, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2032, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 27, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 12, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 937, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 27, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 27, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 163, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23822320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 185353, "avg_nodes": 13239.5, "eval_calls": 114880, "avg_eval_calls": 8205.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 114880, "pattern_eval_ns": 2528640, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.011142061281337, "pattern_frame_queries": 114880, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2528640, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.011142061281337, "pattern_frame_updates": 365024, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5356330199, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14673.912397540984, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 61272, "avg_candidate_generations": 4376.571428571428, "candidate_moves_total": 5730019, "avg_candidate_moves": 93.51774056665361, "candidate_moves_max": 133, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1156, "root_candidate_moves_max": 111, "search_candidate_generations": 61258, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5728863, "search_candidate_moves_max": 133, "legality_checks": 1668069, "avg_legality_checks": 119147.78571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4342, "root_legality_checks": 1156, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1666913, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4340, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5895534, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 421109.5714285714, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13266985313, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2250.344975196479, "renju_forbidden_checks": 90431, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 6459.357142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 595266020, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6582.543817938539, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5639, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 54488753, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 43433, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 367367055, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 40973, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 170262183, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 386, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3148029, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 161281, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11520.07142857143, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1627517331, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10091.19072302379, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 225643, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16117.357142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 755806785, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3349.5689429762942, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4212280463, "stage_ordering_ns": 2278759463, "stage_eval_ns": 5358858839, "stage_threat_ns": 10165882674, "stage_proof_ns": 270392128, "tactical_annotations": 1316388, "root_tactical_annotations": 3719, "search_tactical_annotations": 1312669, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 369156, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2299637354, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1164525, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7455728411, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 123543, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4685720601, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 184571, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 284845038, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4118, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25369671, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 369142, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 48297226, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 341616, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 459320812, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 585582, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2000282441, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 389190, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 52004974, "child_limit_applications": 61258, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 61258, "child_cap_hits": 61258, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 61258, "child_moves_before_total": 5724523, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5724523, "child_moves_before_max": 133, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 133, "child_moves_after_total": 778737, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 778737, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 93.44939436481765, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.712413072578276, "tt_hits": 35142, "tt_cutoffs": 6375, "beta_cutoffs": 50445, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.35714285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1467.357142857143, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1873.7142857142858, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6965, "avg_search_time_ms": 497.5, "search_nodes": 183308, "safety_nodes": 1703, "corridor_nodes": 2552, "corridor_branch_probes": 2995, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 22, "corridor_depth_exits": 1195, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 2527, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2527, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1195, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 60, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 362, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 200640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 187563, "avg_nodes": 13397.357142857143, "eval_calls": 179294, "avg_eval_calls": 12806.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 179294, "pattern_eval_ns": 3860990, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.534407174807857, "pattern_frame_queries": 179294, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3860990, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.534407174807857, "pattern_frame_updates": 366536, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4111362773, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11216.804824082765, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3988, "avg_candidate_generations": 284.85714285714283, "candidate_moves_total": 339615, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.15922768304915, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1184, "root_candidate_moves_max": 110, "search_candidate_generations": 3974, "search_candidate_moves_total": 338431, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 7185, "avg_legality_checks": 513.2142857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 7185, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1141468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 81533.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2748047530, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2407.4678659410515, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24124, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1723.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 204158616, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8462.88409882275, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 250231, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23978, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 202648176, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 51, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 491524, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 71, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 768685, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 20661995, "stage_ordering_ns": 133012, "stage_eval_ns": 4115223763, "stage_threat_ns": 2710276958, "stage_proof_ns": 91888610, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 371730, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2208893333, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 138099, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 162546963, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1176, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 53150494, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 185858, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 262521083, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5180, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 30234260, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 371716, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46081319, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 169, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3679, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6062.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6633.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1967, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1703, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 43315, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 128, 113, 99, 114, 115, 157, 172, 141, 83, 155, 169, 131, 100, 101, 85, 70, 86, 84, 160, 156, 158, 154, 153, 126, 111, 140, 168, 139, 138, 143 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 19180, "avg_search_time_ms": 1128.235294117647, "search_nodes": 440899, "safety_nodes": 1198, "corridor_nodes": 1991, "corridor_branch_probes": 2336, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 901, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1972, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1972, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 97, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 78, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 901, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 97, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 93, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 709, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 222720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 444088, "avg_nodes": 26122.823529411766, "eval_calls": 431206, "avg_eval_calls": 25365.058823529413, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 431206, "pattern_eval_ns": 9268793, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.49504645111617, "pattern_frame_queries": 431206, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 9268793, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.49504645111617, "pattern_frame_updates": 881700, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 11320228652, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12839.09340138369, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9661, "avg_candidate_generations": 568.2941176470588, "candidate_moves_total": 768421, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.53845357623435, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1299, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 9644, "search_candidate_moves_total": 767122, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 420862, "avg_legality_checks": 24756.58823529412, "illegal_moves_skipped": 392, "root_legality_checks": 1299, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 419563, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 392, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3540187, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 208246.29411764705, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8656267172, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2445.1440480404003, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45560, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2680.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 392254172, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8609.6174714662, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 651, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5168872, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 43555, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 379882928, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 219, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2395579, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1135, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4806793, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 5399, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 317.5882352941176, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 55768741, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10329.457492128171, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7759, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 456.4117647058824, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 30492609, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3929.966361644542, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1084736233, "stage_ordering_ns": 337923, "stage_eval_ns": 11329497445, "stage_threat_ns": 6355209049, "stage_proof_ns": 369021402, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 885855, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 5237531293, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 107082, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 342769535, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1207, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 69313476, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 442919, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 630109541, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4138, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 31825691, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 885838, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 112972989, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 608, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 8525, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.764705882352941, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.764705882352941, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4298.941176470588, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4769.529411764706, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 24118, "avg_search_time_ms": 1507.375, "search_nodes": 189148, "safety_nodes": 896, "corridor_nodes": 784, "corridor_branch_probes": 922, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 302, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 772, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 772, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 47, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 35, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 302, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 47, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 47, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 313, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24045440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 190828, "avg_nodes": 11926.75, "eval_calls": 126248, "avg_eval_calls": 7890.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 126248, "pattern_eval_ns": 2794859, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.137847728280843, "pattern_frame_queries": 126248, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2794859, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.137847728280843, "pattern_frame_updates": 378122, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4367119206, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11549.497797007316, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 57435, "avg_candidate_generations": 3589.6875, "candidate_moves_total": 4903282, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.37097588578393, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1223, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 57419, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4902059, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 2917912, "avg_legality_checks": 182369.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2168, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2917912, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2168, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7259969, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 453748.0625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 15445914891, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2127.5455709246144, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39823, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2488.9375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 178302687, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4477.379579639906, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2513, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23190103, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12167, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 102870433, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25143, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 52242151, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 271376, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16961.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2662021572, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9809.347812628972, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 377093, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 23568.3125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1284657464, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3406.739090887394, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7118363965, "stage_ordering_ns": 1997135951, "stage_eval_ns": 4369914065, "stage_threat_ns": 10437964770, "stage_proof_ns": 76472528, "tactical_annotations": 1166979, "root_tactical_annotations": 3198, "search_tactical_annotations": 1163781, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 379776, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2325082721, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1078145, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7727204151, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 115474, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4065481230, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 189880, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 292213093, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1638, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10276381, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 379760, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50009381, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 295129, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1007273522, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 619059, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2617521180, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 252791, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33179043, "child_limit_applications": 57419, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 57419, "child_cap_hits": 57419, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 57419, "child_moves_before_total": 4899891, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4899891, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 657581, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 657581, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.33570769257562, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.452324143576169, "tt_hits": 26476, "tt_cutoffs": 5397, "beta_cutoffs": 44645, "depth_sum": 84, "avg_depth": 5.25, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 84, "avg_effective_depth": 5.25, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2121.0625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2617.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1704, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19077, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 99, 128, 144, 129, 130, 126, 125, 111, 141, 95, 143, 81, 66, 79, 63, 80, 64, 82, 78, 83 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 18053, "avg_search_time_ms": 1504.4166666666667, "search_nodes": 164730, "safety_nodes": 222, "corridor_nodes": 1938, "corridor_branch_probes": 2194, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 912, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1925, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1925, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 41, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 912, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 424, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 43509840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1968080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 166890, "avg_nodes": 13907.5, "eval_calls": 102864, "avg_eval_calls": 8572.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 102864, "pattern_eval_ns": 2249506, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.86873930626847, "pattern_frame_queries": 102864, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2249506, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.86873930626847, "pattern_frame_updates": 329332, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4216496764, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12803.1796606464, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 58026, "avg_candidate_generations": 4835.5, "candidate_moves_total": 4267963, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.55259711163961, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 58014, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4267229, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1123045, "avg_legality_checks": 93587.08333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1012, "root_legality_checks": 734, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1122311, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1012, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4737142, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 394761.8333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10763028671, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2272.0510955761933, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29579, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2464.9166666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 129528570, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4379.071976740255, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1171, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8922653, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13676, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 83662204, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14606, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36305542, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 126, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 638171, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 111928, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9327.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 993318462, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8874.619952112072, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 147338, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12278.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 404506092, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2745.429502232961, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2871584735, "stage_ordering_ns": 1871321891, "stage_eval_ns": 4218746270, "stage_threat_ns": 8732765915, "stage_proof_ns": 308899702, "tactical_annotations": 944067, "root_tactical_annotations": 3546, "search_tactical_annotations": 940521, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 333302, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2070694851, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 809740, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6287145911, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 117159, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4478696373, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 166645, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 257868981, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3958, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21303311, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 333290, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 49355842, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 200984, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 254432213, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 384922, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1263176663, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 358161, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 46397019, "child_limit_applications": 58014, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 58014, "child_cap_hits": 58014, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 58014, "child_moves_before_total": 4266217, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4266217, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 660431, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 660431, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.53771503430207, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.383993518805806, "tt_hits": 34910, "tt_cutoffs": 3789, "beta_cutoffs": 47082, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.083333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.083333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 736.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1236.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 1014, "avg_search_time_ms": 92.18181818181819, "search_nodes": 25142, "safety_nodes": 888, "corridor_nodes": 1117, "corridor_branch_probes": 1376, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 493, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1108, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1108, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 29, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 493, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 183, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 59760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 27147, "avg_nodes": 2467.909090909091, "eval_calls": 23851, "avg_eval_calls": 2168.2727272727275, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23851, "pattern_eval_ns": 511923, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.463376797618547, "pattern_frame_queries": 23851, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 511923, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.463376797618547, "pattern_frame_updates": 50220, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 462490074, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9209.28064516129, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1270, "avg_candidate_generations": 115.45454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 83926, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.08346456692914, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 670, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 1259, "search_candidate_moves_total": 83256, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 3671, "avg_legality_checks": 333.72727272727275, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3671, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 153760, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 13978.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 360726552, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2346.036368366285, "renju_forbidden_checks": 489, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 44.45454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 4170042, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8527.693251533743, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 473, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 4067442, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 102600, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10236019, "stage_ordering_ns": 43180, "stage_eval_ns": 463001997, "stage_threat_ns": 466314914, "stage_proof_ns": 57482405, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 52523, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 338961620, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 62954, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 69022514, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 566, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17421262, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 26256, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 37416996, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2292, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13910910, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 52512, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7002874, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1130, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6057.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6785.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1950, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1705, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 34405, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 126, 70, 127, 108, 109, 125, 99, 85, 129, 130, 84, 114, 97, 146, 162, 100, 115, 81, 143, 101, 131, 83, 145, 161, 173, 158, 159, 117, 187 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 7071, "avg_search_time_ms": 441.9375, "search_nodes": 159042, "safety_nodes": 1718, "corridor_nodes": 1086, "corridor_branch_probes": 1259, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 368, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1061, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1056, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 368, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 91, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 528, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 197600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 161846, "avg_nodes": 10115.375, "eval_calls": 154012, "avg_eval_calls": 9625.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 154012, "pattern_eval_ns": 3318105, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.544457574734437, "pattern_frame_queries": 154012, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3318105, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.544457574734437, "pattern_frame_updates": 317990, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3905348592, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12281.356621277399, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4999, "avg_candidate_generations": 312.4375, "candidate_moves_total": 356110, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.23624724944989, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1185, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 4983, "search_candidate_moves_total": 354925, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 149705, "avg_legality_checks": 9356.5625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 1185, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 148520, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1296834, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 81052.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3169255855, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2443.8408115456564, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11500, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 718.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 89170274, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7753.936869565217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23331, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11434, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 88977523, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 71030, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 41, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 98390, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1896, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 118.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 18903499, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9970.199894514768, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2568, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 160.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 9789534, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3812.123831775701, "stage_move_gen_ns": 392542537, "stage_ordering_ns": 161801, "stage_eval_ns": 3908666697, "stage_threat_ns": 2442404456, "stage_proof_ns": 303848653, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 320312, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1934409617, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 72363, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 219834924, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 872, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 49083176, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 160148, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 231532112, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2306, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15343426, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 320296, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41284377, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 188, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4553, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5740.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6240.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1512, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 27312, "avg_search_time_ms": 1707.0, "search_nodes": 176778, "safety_nodes": 426, "corridor_nodes": 906, "corridor_branch_probes": 1046, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 314, "corridor_neutral_exits": 39, "corridor_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_plies_followed": 891, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 891, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 39, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 314, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 69, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 550, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 22131440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1979760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 178110, "avg_nodes": 11131.875, "eval_calls": 106845, "avg_eval_calls": 6677.8125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 106845, "pattern_eval_ns": 2413717, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.59082783471384, "pattern_frame_queries": 106845, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2413717, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.59082783471384, "pattern_frame_updates": 353366, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3460519386, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9793.01739839147, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 65382, "avg_candidate_generations": 4086.375, "candidate_moves_total": 5802950, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.75455018200728, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1222, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 65366, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5801728, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 4256868, "avg_legality_checks": 266054.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1302, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4256868, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1302, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8622401, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 538900.0625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18451726964, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2139.9755084459653, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37374, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2335.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 91017332, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2435.3114999732434, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1502, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14210328, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6022, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 40487553, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29850, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36319451, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 288415, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18025.9375, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2933240125, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10170.206559991679, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 407993, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25499.5625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1462686593, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3585.077667999206, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10279015366, "stage_ordering_ns": 2370750188, "stage_eval_ns": 3462933103, "stage_threat_ns": 10918679243, "stage_proof_ns": 120256366, "tactical_annotations": 1177442, "root_tactical_annotations": 4955, "search_tactical_annotations": 1172487, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 355302, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2203154431, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1022894, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8331120107, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 131568, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4580060801, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 177643, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 280143054, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1920, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10999459, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 355286, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46886681, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 332635, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1586959694, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 498224, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2116151651, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 346583, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 46375511, "child_limit_applications": 65366, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 65366, "child_cap_hits": 65366, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 65366, "child_moves_before_total": 5800426, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5800426, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 686818, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 686818, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.73766178135422, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.507266774775877, "tt_hits": 36543, "tt_cutoffs": 4476, "beta_cutoffs": 54332, "depth_sum": 90, "avg_depth": 5.625, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 90, "avg_effective_depth": 5.625, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 5, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3125, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 5, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1537.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1834.4375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1706, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20297, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 143, 126, 140, 141, 156, 96, 81, 97, 95, 83, 125, 99, 100, 69, 55, 84, 70, 114, 54, 129 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 18052, "avg_search_time_ms": 1504.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 171013, "safety_nodes": 222, "corridor_nodes": 2029, "corridor_branch_probes": 2221, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 952, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 2013, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2013, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 952, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 49, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 410, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 41618880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1982000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 173264, "avg_nodes": 14438.666666666666, "eval_calls": 107242, "avg_eval_calls": 8936.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107242, "pattern_eval_ns": 2334856, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.771843121165215, "pattern_frame_queries": 107242, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2334856, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.771843121165215, "pattern_frame_updates": 341898, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4278648117, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12514.39937349736, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 59491, "avg_candidate_generations": 4957.583333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 4376449, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.56489216856332, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 59479, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4375715, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 1153461, "avg_legality_checks": 96121.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1233, "root_legality_checks": 734, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1152727, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1233, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4898722, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 408226.8333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10712138320, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2186.7210100920197, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32945, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2745.4166666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 139979888, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4248.89628168159, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1346, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9505736, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15785, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 92596904, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15762, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37508727, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 52, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 368521, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 118547, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9878.916666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 992218607, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8369.8331210406, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 155783, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12981.916666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 398801162, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2559.978701141973, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2807882059, "stage_ordering_ns": 1876101721, "stage_eval_ns": 4280982973, "stage_threat_ns": 8719306397, "stage_proof_ns": 311887275, "tactical_annotations": 982801, "root_tactical_annotations": 3546, "search_tactical_annotations": 979255, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 346036, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2082991759, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 839302, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6259000147, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 120139, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4438901465, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 173012, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 264293812, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4126, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22651665, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 346024, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44651457, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 205508, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 249670739, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 401476, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1268137079, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 375817, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 45717557, "child_limit_applications": 59479, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 59479, "child_cap_hits": 59479, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 59479, "child_moves_before_total": 4374482, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4374482, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 680730, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 680730, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.54666352830411, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.444879705442258, "tt_hits": 36182, "tt_cutoffs": 4228, "beta_cutoffs": 48204, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.083333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.083333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 761.6666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1261.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2234, "avg_search_time_ms": 203.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 61763, "safety_nodes": 888, "corridor_nodes": 1159, "corridor_branch_probes": 1438, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 513, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1150, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1150, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 29, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 513, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 183, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 43600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 63810, "avg_nodes": 5800.909090909091, "eval_calls": 59607, "avg_eval_calls": 5418.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 59607, "pattern_eval_ns": 1281214, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.494354689885416, "pattern_frame_queries": 59607, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1281214, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.494354689885416, "pattern_frame_updates": 123462, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1187448012, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9617.92302084852, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2135, "avg_candidate_generations": 194.0909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 138974, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.09320843091335, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 670, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 2124, "search_candidate_moves_total": 138304, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 4468, "avg_legality_checks": 406.1818181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4468, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 333575, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 30325.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 781073582, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2341.5231417222512, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1690, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 153.63636363636363, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13866485, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8205.020710059172, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1669, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13684634, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 181851, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12551924, "stage_ordering_ns": 69640, "stage_eval_ns": 1188729226, "stage_threat_ns": 960273510, "stage_proof_ns": 57586628, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 125849, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 768511304, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64988, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 72423642, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 576, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17823910, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 62919, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88857498, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2376, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14400984, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 125838, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16080082, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1937, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5856.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6584.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1931, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1707, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26885, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 82, 127, 128, 96, 160, 111, 52, 67, 81, 143, 159, 141, 156, 144, 142, 113, 170, 184, 158, 157, 99, 125, 173, 93, 109, 123, 124, 95, 161, 79 ], "move_count": 34, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 4306, "avg_search_time_ms": 287.06666666666666, "search_nodes": 111388, "safety_nodes": 1472, "corridor_nodes": 932, "corridor_branch_probes": 1100, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 336, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 910, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 910, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 88, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 66, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 336, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 88, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 88, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 518, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 199040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 113792, "avg_nodes": 7586.133333333333, "eval_calls": 108003, "avg_eval_calls": 7200.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 108003, "pattern_eval_ns": 2217497, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.531809301593473, "pattern_frame_queries": 108003, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2217497, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.531809301593473, "pattern_frame_updates": 222688, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2353111807, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10566.855003412848, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3356, "avg_candidate_generations": 223.73333333333332, "candidate_moves_total": 266698, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.46901072705602, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1126, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 3341, "search_candidate_moves_total": 265572, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 101530, "avg_legality_checks": 6768.666666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7, "root_legality_checks": 1126, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 100404, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 993206, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 66213.73333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1949105777, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1962.4385847447559, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11666, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 777.7333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 89456790, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7668.163037887879, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 79811, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11537, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 89032599, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 70940, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 96, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 273440, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1561, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 104.06666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 13371896, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8566.237027546445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2090, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 139.33333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 6881595, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3292.629186602871, "stage_move_gen_ns": 215721608, "stage_ordering_ns": 114700, "stage_eval_ns": 2355329304, "stage_threat_ns": 1460039137, "stage_proof_ns": 244220837, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 224699, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1127386733, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 60772, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 157995256, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 778, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 36835428, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 112342, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 138960608, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1996, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11443939, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 224684, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24252601, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 184, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3032, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 2.933333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6490.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7023.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1814, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 22565, "avg_search_time_ms": 1504.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 201590, "safety_nodes": 436, "corridor_nodes": 2094, "corridor_branch_probes": 2375, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 806, "corridor_neutral_exits": 65, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 2067, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2067, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 103, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 76, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 69, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 806, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 103, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 824, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26396560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1990080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 204120, "avg_nodes": 13608.0, "eval_calls": 130582, "avg_eval_calls": 8705.466666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 130582, "pattern_eval_ns": 2738409, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.97079995711507, "pattern_frame_queries": 130582, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2738409, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.97079995711507, "pattern_frame_updates": 403006, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3173909687, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7875.589164925585, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 66472, "avg_candidate_generations": 4431.466666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 5879324, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.44812853532315, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1166, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 66457, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5878158, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 4261437, "avg_legality_checks": 284095.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 321, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4261437, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 321, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8681928, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 578795.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14802313135, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1704.9569099167834, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30096, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2006.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 56809301, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1887.6030369484317, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 375, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2016189, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4462, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27371253, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25239, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27179728, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 242131, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 264595, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 17639.666666666668, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2115979870, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7997.051607173227, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 373014, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 24867.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1057892332, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2836.0660243315265, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8057001059, "stage_ordering_ns": 1888047031, "stage_eval_ns": 3176648096, "stage_threat_ns": 9113168097, "stage_proof_ns": 162216148, "tactical_annotations": 1184560, "root_tactical_annotations": 4263, "search_tactical_annotations": 1180297, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 407361, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2071830630, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1032895, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6653264993, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 134487, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3857345678, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 203673, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 267612022, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4340, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21288706, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 407346, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44558543, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 291826, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1061708941, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 478244, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1656386623, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 414490, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 54613203, "child_limit_applications": 66457, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 66457, "child_cap_hits": 66457, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 66457, "child_moves_before_total": 5877837, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5877837, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 707225, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 707225, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.44571677927081, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.641843598116075, "tt_hits": 40084, "tt_cutoffs": 4464, "beta_cutoffs": 53653, "depth_sum": 87, "avg_depth": 5.8, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 87, "avg_effective_depth": 5.8, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2600.266666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3101.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1299, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1708, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16435, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 96, 128, 95, 98, 94, 93, 127, 142, 82, 67, 100, 158, 110, 156, 170, 174, 190, 113, 143, 68, 83, 159, 111, 79, 125, 69, 139 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 10485, "avg_search_time_ms": 748.9285714285714, "search_nodes": 88091, "safety_nodes": 1291, "corridor_nodes": 293, "corridor_branch_probes": 325, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 120, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 288, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 288, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 7, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 2, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 120, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 7, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 7, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 10, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 21280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 89675, "avg_nodes": 6405.357142857143, "eval_calls": 53203, "avg_eval_calls": 3800.214285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53203, "pattern_eval_ns": 1168198, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.95737082495348, "pattern_frame_queries": 53203, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1168198, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.95737082495348, "pattern_frame_updates": 176024, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2368590031, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13456.062985729219, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31685, "avg_candidate_generations": 2263.214285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 2409147, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.03430645415811, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1097, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 31671, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2408050, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 782113, "avg_legality_checks": 55865.21428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1957, "root_legality_checks": 1097, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 781016, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1954, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2716227, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 194016.2142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6273677712, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2309.7030226118804, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31337, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2238.3571428571427, "renju_forbidden_ns": 182058462, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5809.696588697067, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2191, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23064531, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12218, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 102676731, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16308, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 50611505, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 620, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5705695, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65480, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4677.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 675209648, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10311.692852779475, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92163, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6583.071428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 316390598, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3432.9459544502674, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2033590515, "stage_ordering_ns": 1042426724, "stage_eval_ns": 2369758229, "stage_threat_ns": 4945069458, "stage_proof_ns": 47992813, "tactical_annotations": 458811, "root_tactical_annotations": 1407, "search_tactical_annotations": 457404, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 176628, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1124610418, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 428860, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3636285958, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 63610, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2495810776, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 88307, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 140631999, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 590, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4276393, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 176614, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23180956, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62831, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 77917576, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 285442, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1014264754, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110538, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16083734, "child_limit_applications": 31671, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31671, "child_cap_hits": 31671, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31671, "child_moves_before_total": 2406096, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2406096, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 344678, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 344678, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.97158283603297, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.883079157588961, "tt_hits": 14140, "tt_cutoffs": 3139, "beta_cutoffs": 25474, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 5.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4160.642857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4732.071428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 5935, "avg_search_time_ms": 456.53846153846155, "search_nodes": 156346, "safety_nodes": 1468, "corridor_nodes": 3596, "corridor_branch_probes": 4019, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 26, "corridor_depth_exits": 1644, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 3570, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3555, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 15, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 27, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1644, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 3, "corridor_proof_unknown": 63, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 375, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 182000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 161410, "avg_nodes": 12416.153846153846, "eval_calls": 152835, "avg_eval_calls": 11756.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 152835, "pattern_eval_ns": 3285558, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.49741878496418, "pattern_frame_queries": 152835, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3285558, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.49741878496418, "pattern_frame_updates": 312616, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3279373588, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10490.101555902449, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3486, "avg_candidate_generations": 268.15384615384613, "candidate_moves_total": 307639, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.24985656913368, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1024, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 3473, "search_candidate_moves_total": 306615, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 6611, "avg_legality_checks": 508.53846153846155, "illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6611, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 16, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 869564, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 66889.53846153847, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2110889834, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2427.5267076373907, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20613, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1585.6153846153845, "renju_forbidden_ns": 213252196, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10345.519623538543, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 221991, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20181, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 208747863, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 265, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3092587, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 147, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1189755, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 89, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6.846153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 868993, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9763.966292134832, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 116, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8.923076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 417831, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3601.9913793103447, "stage_move_gen_ns": 19134554, "stage_ordering_ns": 119350, "stage_eval_ns": 3282659146, "stage_threat_ns": 2519290724, "stage_proof_ns": 86797627, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 319901, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1938430310, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 194710, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 269178833, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1940, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 107370216, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 159944, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 225920523, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7272, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 45557419, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 319888, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40203639, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 155, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3200, "depth_sum": 38, "avg_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 38, "avg_effective_depth": 2.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6331.923076923077, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6947.307692307692, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1730, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1709, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15867, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 114, 111, 126, 140, 84, 143, 141, 127, 98, 70, 95, 146, 68, 159, 175, 145, 144, 83, 116, 115, 100, 132, 52 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5727, "avg_search_time_ms": 477.25, "search_nodes": 129225, "safety_nodes": 638, "corridor_nodes": 1343, "corridor_branch_probes": 1523, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 580, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_plies_followed": 1326, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1326, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 70, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 580, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 70, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 472, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 130160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 131206, "avg_nodes": 10933.833333333334, "eval_calls": 124994, "avg_eval_calls": 10416.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 124994, "pattern_eval_ns": 2646333, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.17168024065155, "pattern_frame_queries": 124994, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2646333, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.17168024065155, "pattern_frame_updates": 258382, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3233097119, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12512.857393316872, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4209, "avg_candidate_generations": 350.75, "candidate_moves_total": 317072, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.33190781658351, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 860, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 4197, "search_candidate_moves_total": 316212, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 117379, "avg_legality_checks": 9781.583333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 65, "root_legality_checks": 860, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 116519, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 65, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1162114, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 96842.83333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2653623478, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2283.4450647698936, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16331, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1360.9166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 140282990, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8589.98163002878, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 652826, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15476, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 132859419, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 224, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2538356, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 556, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4232389, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3692, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 307.6666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 36561872, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9902.998916576382, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5270, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 439.1666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 20326451, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3857.0115749525617, "stage_move_gen_ns": 287696546, "stage_ordering_ns": 152740, "stage_eval_ns": 3235743452, "stage_threat_ns": 1932218875, "stage_proof_ns": 247871034, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 261186, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1476689330, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 78301, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 231810838, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 855, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 47588572, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 130587, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 176171196, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2792, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16056712, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 261174, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31490799, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 423, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3627, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5563.416666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6230.083333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1735, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10128, "avg_search_time_ms": 920.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 79208, "safety_nodes": 846, "corridor_nodes": 146, "corridor_branch_probes": 161, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 36, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 137, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 137, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 58, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 58, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 440, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6525440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 80200, "avg_nodes": 7290.909090909091, "eval_calls": 47478, "avg_eval_calls": 4316.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47478, "pattern_eval_ns": 1026263, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.615548253928136, "pattern_frame_queries": 47478, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1026263, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.615548253928136, "pattern_frame_updates": 158292, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1802419819, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11386.676641902308, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29457, "avg_candidate_generations": 2677.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 2271252, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.10398207556777, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 29446, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2270466, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1444448, "avg_legality_checks": 131313.45454545456, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5459, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1444448, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5459, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3429982, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 311816.54545454547, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6568929496, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1915.149845101228, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33912, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3082.909090909091, "renju_forbidden_ns": 206473406, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6088.505720688841, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5629, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 48748444, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12628, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 113442323, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15618, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44016879, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 265760, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 105878, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9625.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 951175882, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8983.697104214285, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 146757, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13341.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 450215198, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3067.7596162363634, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3101256436, "stage_ordering_ns": 846176110, "stage_eval_ns": 1803446082, "stage_threat_ns": 4231980502, "stage_proof_ns": 81548190, "tactical_annotations": 423243, "root_tactical_annotations": 1732, "search_tactical_annotations": 421511, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 158693, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 879640396, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 363329, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3206559397, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59286, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1940074829, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 79341, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 110182025, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 390, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1863746, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 158682, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18793635, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71444, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 275839912, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 221203, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 984122789, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 130596, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14941303, "child_limit_applications": 29446, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29446, "child_cap_hits": 29446, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29446, "child_moves_before_total": 2265007, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2265007, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 274530, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 274530, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.92070230251987, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.323167832642804, "tt_hits": 15333, "tt_cutoffs": 2223, "beta_cutoffs": 23605, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3858.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4586.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1451, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1710, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 34922, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 124, 82, 114, 98, 140, 97, 138, 152, 139, 141, 137, 136, 67, 128, 83, 81, 129, 168, 184, 143, 158, 65, 49, 169, 156, 127, 155, 159, 95, 175 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 28202, "avg_search_time_ms": 1658.9411764705883, "search_nodes": 252882, "safety_nodes": 804, "corridor_nodes": 1230, "corridor_branch_probes": 1448, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 584, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1217, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1217, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 40, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 27, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 584, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 40, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 40, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 287, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 25909360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2028640, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 254916, "avg_nodes": 14995.058823529413, "eval_calls": 170987, "avg_eval_calls": 10058.058823529413, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 170987, "pattern_eval_ns": 3807657, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.268692941568656, "pattern_frame_queries": 170987, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3807657, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.268692941568656, "pattern_frame_updates": 505584, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7484312919, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14803.302555065035, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 76642, "avg_candidate_generations": 4508.35294117647, "candidate_moves_total": 6707984, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.52360324626184, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1300, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 76625, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6706684, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1993908, "avg_legality_checks": 117288.70588235294, "illegal_moves_skipped": 10115, "root_legality_checks": 1300, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 1992608, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 10107, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7413308, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 436076.9411764706, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16358751926, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2206.6737178598273, "renju_forbidden_checks": 122660, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 7215.294117647059, "renju_forbidden_ns": 814827090, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6642.973177890102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 11363, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 120652567, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 56420, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 489600376, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 53645, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 191401332, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1232, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 13172815, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 230466, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13556.823529411764, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2115905693, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9180.988488540608, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 305598, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17976.352941176472, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 895177249, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2929.2640953147597, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5000064133, "stage_ordering_ns": 2672004444, "stage_eval_ns": 7488120576, "stage_threat_ns": 12744112843, "stage_proof_ns": 209596989, "tactical_annotations": 1719259, "root_tactical_annotations": 4537, "search_tactical_annotations": 1714722, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 508115, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3147892991, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1506230, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9052307525, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 153972, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5482792862, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 254049, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 399232371, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2514, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14521802, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 508098, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 67054497, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 426044, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 531715988, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 859890, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2835227132, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 433325, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 63103657, "child_limit_applications": 76625, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 76625, "child_cap_hits": 76625, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 76625, "child_moves_before_total": 6696577, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6696577, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 1098143, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1098143, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.3941533442088, "avg_child_moves_after": 14.331393148450244, "tt_hits": 36685, "tt_cutoffs": 5182, "beta_cutoffs": 62259, "depth_sum": 87, "avg_depth": 5.117647058823529, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 87, "avg_effective_depth": 5.117647058823529, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.47058823529411764, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1842.9411764705883, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2189.3529411764707, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 6703, "avg_search_time_ms": 418.9375, "search_nodes": 175497, "safety_nodes": 1617, "corridor_nodes": 4567, "corridor_branch_probes": 5366, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 53, "corridor_depth_exits": 2163, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 124, "corridor_plies_followed": 4542, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4542, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 79, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 59, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2163, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 124, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 79, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 78, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 442, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 234120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 13, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 13, "total_nodes": 181681, "avg_nodes": 11355.0625, "eval_calls": 170936, "avg_eval_calls": 10683.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 170936, "pattern_eval_ns": 3712053, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.716039921374083, "pattern_frame_queries": 170936, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3712053, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.716039921374083, "pattern_frame_updates": 350900, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3718901693, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10598.180943288686, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4530, "avg_candidate_generations": 283.125, "candidate_moves_total": 359807, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.42759381898455, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1219, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 4514, "search_candidate_moves_total": 358588, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 10639, "avg_legality_checks": 664.9375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 10639, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 989504, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 61844.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2420338819, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2446.012162659272, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17036, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1064.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 179321426, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10526.028762620334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 257800, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16570, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 176545256, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 340, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1311546, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 101, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1206824, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 29340711, "stage_ordering_ns": 163060, "stage_eval_ns": 3722613746, "stage_threat_ns": 2841073289, "stage_proof_ns": 110668035, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 360158, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2211026954, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 222855, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 256029687, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1956, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 83782427, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 180071, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 257977645, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9242, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 69966767, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 360142, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46072236, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 243, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3981, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6062.6875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6562.6875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1952, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1711, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 24782, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 142, 97, 98, 126, 70, 111, 157, 172, 141, 81, 66, 125, 139, 69, 83, 140, 85, 84, 113, 99, 129, 54 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9179, "avg_search_time_ms": 834.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 210619, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 688, "corridor_branch_probes": 804, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 236, "corridor_neutral_exits": 21, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 673, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 673, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 84, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 21, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 236, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 84, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 597, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 142640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 212120, "avg_nodes": 19283.636363636364, "eval_calls": 205259, "avg_eval_calls": 18659.909090909092, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 205259, "pattern_eval_ns": 4418375, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.52585270317014, "pattern_frame_queries": 205259, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4418375, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.52585270317014, "pattern_frame_updates": 421174, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5375864230, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12763.998323733183, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5339, "avg_candidate_generations": 485.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 392498, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.51526503090466, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 755, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 5328, "search_candidate_moves_total": 391743, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 201719, "avg_legality_checks": 18338.090909090908, "illegal_moves_skipped": 194, "root_legality_checks": 755, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 200964, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 193, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1627388, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 147944.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4000626075, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2458.3111556678555, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23113, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2101.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 209783259, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9076.418422532774, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 196, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1768591, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22715, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 206327802, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 547465, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 157, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1139401, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1485, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 135.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 14812157, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9974.516498316498, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2085, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 189.54545454545453, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 7880436, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3779.5856115107913, "stage_move_gen_ns": 524544657, "stage_ordering_ns": 176752, "stage_eval_ns": 5380282605, "stage_threat_ns": 3018679294, "stage_proof_ns": 228250107, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 422699, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2515383566, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 45848, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 143210609, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 656, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 31664281, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 211344, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 297096211, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1514, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9344089, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 422688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53644819, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 245, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4763, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4077.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4804.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 168, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 15593, "avg_search_time_ms": 1417.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 107272, "safety_nodes": 652, "corridor_nodes": 346, "corridor_branch_probes": 399, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 100, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 337, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 337, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 60, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 100, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 60, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 431, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2352240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2015920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 108270, "avg_nodes": 9842.727272727272, "eval_calls": 67401, "avg_eval_calls": 6127.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67401, "pattern_eval_ns": 1507207, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.36178988442308, "pattern_frame_queries": 67401, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1507207, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.36178988442308, "pattern_frame_updates": 214412, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2365549178, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11032.727543234521, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37300, "avg_candidate_generations": 3390.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 3153861, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.55391420911528, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 783, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 37289, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3153078, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 2171929, "avg_legality_checks": 197448.0909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3510, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2171929, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3510, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4896483, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 445134.8181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10315851930, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2106.7880619620246, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43761, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3978.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 171596859, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3921.2280112428875, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3538, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 36677773, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8798, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 81524455, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 31407, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 53201679, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 192952, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 171061, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15551.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1699937202, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9937.608233320278, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 246985, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22453.18181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 843641125, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3415.758548089965, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5245202665, "stage_ordering_ns": 1292388432, "stage_eval_ns": 2367056385, "stage_threat_ns": 6491558871, "stage_proof_ns": 108581404, "tactical_annotations": 677506, "root_tactical_annotations": 2379, "search_tactical_annotations": 675127, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 215217, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1325380357, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 584697, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4944863723, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75085, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2749674802, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 107603, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 163054926, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 794, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4328892, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 215206, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28071412, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 169489, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 761430057, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 314782, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1413368996, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 193235, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 25859561, "child_limit_applications": 37289, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37289, "child_cap_hits": 37289, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37289, "child_moves_before_total": 3149568, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3149568, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 410342, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 410342, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.46372924991284, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.004371262302556, "tt_hits": 20027, "tt_cutoffs": 2517, "beta_cutoffs": 29953, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.909090909090909, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2780.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3366.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1770, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1712, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20478, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 98, 68, 54, 142, 126, 84, 140, 154, 125, 128, 100, 83, 99, 101, 85, 81, 80, 156, 170, 124, 113, 110 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 13968, "avg_search_time_ms": 1164.0, "search_nodes": 120131, "safety_nodes": 757, "corridor_nodes": 1370, "corridor_branch_probes": 1657, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 574, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 1354, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1354, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 574, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 66, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 459, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 42113200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2029600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 122258, "avg_nodes": 10188.166666666666, "eval_calls": 75157, "avg_eval_calls": 6263.083333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75157, "pattern_eval_ns": 1657197, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.049802413614167, "pattern_frame_queries": 75157, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1657197, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.049802413614167, "pattern_frame_updates": 240122, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2961625914, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12333.838273877445, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41145, "avg_candidate_generations": 3428.75, "candidate_moves_total": 3256595, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.1492283388018, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 862, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 41133, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3255733, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1107620, "avg_legality_checks": 92301.66666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1969, "root_legality_checks": 862, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1106758, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1968, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3703575, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 308631.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8388182135, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2264.8878813038755, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33267, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2772.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 214037406, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6433.925692127334, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2192, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23824856, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12861, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 121041803, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17933, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 67595091, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 281, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1575656, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 86210, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7184.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 846932893, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9824.067892355875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 120095, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10007.916666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 390294886, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3249.8845580582038, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2816174636, "stage_ordering_ns": 1402982609, "stage_eval_ns": 2963283111, "stage_threat_ns": 6459255252, "stage_proof_ns": 267777631, "tactical_annotations": 578117, "root_tactical_annotations": 2339, "search_tactical_annotations": 575778, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 242974, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1528754763, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 572224, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4675066379, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 83176, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3198905088, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121481, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 185104687, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2840, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17685033, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 242962, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31955218, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 101644, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 77488829, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 309895, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1196682354, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 166578, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20689172, "child_limit_applications": 41133, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41133, "child_cap_hits": 41133, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41133, "child_moves_before_total": 3253765, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3253765, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 404299, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 404299, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.10351785670872, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.829066686115771, "tt_hits": 21684, "tt_cutoffs": 3772, "beta_cutoffs": 32259, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 5.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 5.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2341.5833333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3008.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6499, "avg_search_time_ms": 541.5833333333334, "search_nodes": 208196, "safety_nodes": 1123, "corridor_nodes": 2503, "corridor_branch_probes": 2955, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 7, "corridor_depth_exits": 1123, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 2480, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2480, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 65, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1123, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 65, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 62, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 439, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 225200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 22480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 211822, "avg_nodes": 17651.833333333332, "eval_calls": 202876, "avg_eval_calls": 16906.333333333332, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 202876, "pattern_eval_ns": 4394158, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.659328851120883, "pattern_frame_queries": 202876, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4394158, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.659328851120883, "pattern_frame_updates": 416324, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3349974945, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8046.557356770208, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5298, "avg_candidate_generations": 441.5, "candidate_moves_total": 411503, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.67138542846357, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 883, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 5286, "search_candidate_moves_total": 410620, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 13494, "avg_legality_checks": 1124.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 13494, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 820921, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 68410.08333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1954144280, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2380.429152135224, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8781, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 731.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 70436695, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8021.489010363284, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8676, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 69587274, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 80, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 809151, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 19, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 35190, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 36695470, "stage_ordering_ns": 180141, "stage_eval_ns": 3354369103, "stage_threat_ns": 2981228619, "stage_proof_ns": 93734773, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 421426, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2436197368, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 138791, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 174032291, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1368, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 64725489, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 210707, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 287365730, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5090, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 31476196, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 421414, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52157034, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 226, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4842, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5454.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6121.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1969, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1713, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32709, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 82, 127, 126, 98, 154, 113, 52, 67, 83, 141, 155, 143, 158, 140, 142, 111, 174, 190, 156, 157, 95, 129, 171, 173, 125, 159, 175, 131, 130, 145, 187, 117 ], "move_count": 36, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 5391, "avg_search_time_ms": 336.9375, "search_nodes": 115177, "safety_nodes": 1718, "corridor_nodes": 1130, "corridor_branch_probes": 1313, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 396, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1105, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1100, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 92, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 67, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 396, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 92, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 91, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 528, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 204560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 118025, "avg_nodes": 7376.5625, "eval_calls": 111810, "avg_eval_calls": 6988.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 111810, "pattern_eval_ns": 2424955, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.688176370628746, "pattern_frame_queries": 111810, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2424955, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.688176370628746, "pattern_frame_updates": 230260, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2954952364, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12833.111977764267, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3336, "avg_candidate_generations": 208.5, "candidate_moves_total": 262796, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.7757793764988, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1185, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 3320, "search_candidate_moves_total": 261611, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 108018, "avg_legality_checks": 6751.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 1185, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 106833, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1078340, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 67396.25, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2539837080, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2355.3212159430236, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12023, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 751.4375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 112289528, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9339.559843633037, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11990, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11931, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 112097447, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 50561, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 68, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 129530, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 1985, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 124.0625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 19548309, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9848.014609571788, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2707, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 169.1875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 10118127, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3737.7639453269303, "stage_move_gen_ns": 270772797, "stage_ordering_ns": 117610, "stage_eval_ns": 2957377319, "stage_threat_ns": 1827976837, "stage_proof_ns": 303147218, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 232670, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1393953485, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 73990, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 223314377, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 878, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 49615715, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 116327, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 165138350, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2394, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16162591, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 232654, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29408034, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 188, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3004, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 2.9375, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9375, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6573.9375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7073.9375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1771, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 27301, "avg_search_time_ms": 1706.3125, "search_nodes": 176413, "safety_nodes": 426, "corridor_nodes": 1453, "corridor_branch_probes": 1735, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 467, "corridor_neutral_exits": 69, "corridor_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_plies_followed": 1427, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1427, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 101, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 75, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 73, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 467, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 101, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 101, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 822, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26417440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1990240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 178292, "avg_nodes": 11143.25, "eval_calls": 106051, "avg_eval_calls": 6628.1875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 106051, "pattern_eval_ns": 2393892, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.573026185514518, "pattern_frame_queries": 106051, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2393892, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.573026185514518, "pattern_frame_updates": 352634, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3327168483, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9435.189128104494, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 65877, "avg_candidate_generations": 4117.3125, "candidate_moves_total": 5843784, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.70750034154561, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1222, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 65861, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5842562, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 4396610, "avg_legality_checks": 274788.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 262, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4396610, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 262, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8777258, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 548578.625, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18545680993, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2112.924217677092, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27200, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1700.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 52792545, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1940.9023897058823, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 312, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2679458, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3861, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26145021, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23027, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 23968066, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 288361, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 18022.5625, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2883239634, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9998.715616883004, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 410004, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25625.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1437242742, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3505.4359030643604, "stage_move_gen_ns": 10454015643, "stage_ordering_ns": 2325990368, "stage_eval_ns": 3329562375, "stage_threat_ns": 10848918890, "stage_proof_ns": 171742726, "tactical_annotations": 1188870, "root_tactical_annotations": 5027, "search_tactical_annotations": 1183843, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 355706, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2193607540, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1047573, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8256196264, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 132981, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4549221707, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 177845, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 278405033, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3056, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18321095, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 355690, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 46315530, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 341080, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1595514880, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 473683, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2032731580, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 374107, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 56073428, "child_limit_applications": 65861, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 65861, "child_cap_hits": 65861, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 65861, "child_moves_before_total": 5842300, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5842300, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 686619, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 686619, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.70651827333323, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.425274441627064, "tt_hits": 38796, "tt_cutoffs": 4407, "beta_cutoffs": 54806, "depth_sum": 93, "avg_depth": 5.8125, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 93, "avg_effective_depth": 5.8125, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1927.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2225.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1714, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11938, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 127, 142, 126, 156, 114, 82, 98, 140, 99, 96, 84, 70, 69, 54, 129 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 9731, "avg_search_time_ms": 1216.375, "search_nodes": 79784, "safety_nodes": 448, "corridor_nodes": 741, "corridor_branch_probes": 878, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 314, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 730, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 730, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 39, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 28, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 314, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 39, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 288, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23934960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2025680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 80973, "avg_nodes": 10121.625, "eval_calls": 48678, "avg_eval_calls": 6084.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48678, "pattern_eval_ns": 1080788, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.202802087185177, "pattern_frame_queries": 48678, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1080788, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.202802087185177, "pattern_frame_updates": 159488, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2113357237, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13250.885565058186, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 28669, "avg_candidate_generations": 3583.625, "candidate_moves_total": 2189137, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.359028916251, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 489, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 28661, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2188648, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 733959, "avg_legality_checks": 91744.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2641, "root_legality_checks": 489, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 733470, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2638, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2548892, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 318611.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5932543517, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2327.498974848679, "renju_forbidden_checks": 24071, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3008.875, "renju_forbidden_ns": 191115441, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7939.655228282996, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2695, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30298705, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10244, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 106183486, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10709, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 50596870, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 423, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4036380, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 57178, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7147.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 603378507, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10552.634002588407, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 82304, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10288.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 290249222, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3526.55061722395, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1915301447, "stage_ordering_ns": 987032461, "stage_eval_ns": 2114438025, "stage_threat_ns": 4516086727, "stage_proof_ns": 161687249, "tactical_annotations": 355565, "root_tactical_annotations": 1524, "search_tactical_annotations": 354041, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 161034, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1010178709, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 329912, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3331947092, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 57826, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2367528077, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 80513, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 126610778, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1538, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8705164, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 161026, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21205853, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 59968, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 97375219, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 167803, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 741652627, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 127794, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17439131, "child_limit_applications": 28661, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 28661, "child_cap_hits": 28661, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 28661, "child_moves_before_total": 2186010, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2186010, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 275814, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 275814, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.27123966365444, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.623320889012945, "tt_hits": 16478, "tt_cutoffs": 2405, "beta_cutoffs": 22703, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1327.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2114.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 181, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 2200, "avg_search_time_ms": 314.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 58061, "safety_nodes": 476, "corridor_nodes": 553, "corridor_branch_probes": 658, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 9, "corridor_depth_exits": 196, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 544, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 544, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 43, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 196, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 43, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 43, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 296, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 170080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59090, "avg_nodes": 8441.42857142857, "eval_calls": 56280, "avg_eval_calls": 8040.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 56280, "pattern_eval_ns": 1221255, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.699626865671643, "pattern_frame_queries": 56280, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1221255, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.699626865671643, "pattern_frame_updates": 116082, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1231961767, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10612.857867714201, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1768, "avg_candidate_generations": 252.57142857142858, "candidate_moves_total": 121463, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.70079185520362, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 418, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 1761, "search_candidate_moves_total": 121045, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 2967, "avg_legality_checks": 423.85714285714283, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2967, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 320827, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 45832.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 791953668, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2468.475745495236, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5727, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 818.1428571428571, "renju_forbidden_ns": 58217198, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10165.391653570805, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 97670, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5654, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 57282885, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 502032, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 334611, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8894264, "stage_ordering_ns": 63120, "stage_eval_ns": 1233183022, "stage_threat_ns": 872716119, "stage_proof_ns": 74304889, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 117263, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 721768542, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 36307, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 45312818, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 442, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17201952, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 58628, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 83664233, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1174, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6761995, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 117256, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15208531, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 119, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1566, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4596.285714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5739.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1964, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1715, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22995, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 128, 64, 127, 115, 116, 129, 125, 124, 143, 159, 79, 95, 144, 65, 80, 97, 81, 83, 78 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 6987, "avg_search_time_ms": 635.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 153980, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 992, "corridor_branch_probes": 1154, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 368, "corridor_neutral_exits": 21, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 974, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 974, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 84, "corridor_proof_active": 18, "corridor_proof_quiet": 66, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 21, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 368, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 84, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 597, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 170880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 155785, "avg_nodes": 14162.272727272728, "eval_calls": 149213, "avg_eval_calls": 13564.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 149213, "pattern_eval_ns": 3235842, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.68605952564455, "pattern_frame_queries": 149213, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3235842, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.68605952564455, "pattern_frame_updates": 307896, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3946589213, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12817.929472938915, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4746, "avg_candidate_generations": 431.45454545454544, "candidate_moves_total": 335712, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.73577749683945, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 755, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 4735, "search_candidate_moves_total": 334957, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 144641, "avg_legality_checks": 13149.181818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 179, "root_legality_checks": 755, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 143886, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 178, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1245456, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 113223.27272727272, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3093341155, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2483.701676333809, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15051, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1368.2727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 134886625, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8961.97096538436, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 179, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1856317, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14599, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 130865637, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 687834, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 216, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1476837, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 2126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 193.27272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 21235850, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9988.640639698966, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2975, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 270.45454545454544, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 11190191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3761.4087394957983, "stage_move_gen_ns": 384381417, "stage_ordering_ns": 169032, "stage_eval_ns": 3949825055, "stage_threat_ns": 2354357511, "stage_proof_ns": 275345436, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 310023, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1879616476, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 63034, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 197190344, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 792, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 42396807, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 155006, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 224114694, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2116, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13804640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 310012, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39631357, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 245, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4243, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4677.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5404.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1355, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 15998, "avg_search_time_ms": 1454.3636363636363, "search_nodes": 107597, "safety_nodes": 652, "corridor_nodes": 296, "corridor_branch_probes": 340, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 66, "corridor_neutral_exits": 27, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 287, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 287, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 60, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 27, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 66, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 60, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 2, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 431, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2368640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2015920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 6, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 108545, "avg_nodes": 9867.727272727272, "eval_calls": 67416, "avg_eval_calls": 6128.727272727273, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67416, "pattern_eval_ns": 1516777, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.49876883825798, "pattern_frame_queries": 67416, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1516777, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.49876883825798, "pattern_frame_updates": 215062, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2435807046, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11326.06897545824, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 37523, "avg_candidate_generations": 3411.181818181818, "candidate_moves_total": 3155970, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.10761399674865, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 783, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 37512, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3155187, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 2173611, "avg_legality_checks": 197601.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3583, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2173611, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3583, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4901948, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 445631.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10587550654, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2159.86596634644, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43884, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3989.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 175670538, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4003.0657642876677, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3625, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 38738345, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8804, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 82623513, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 31437, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 54112320, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 18, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 196360, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 171121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15556.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1732439781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10124.062978827847, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 246948, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22449.81818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 857336793, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3471.730052480684, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5382929116, "stage_ordering_ns": 1307647810, "stage_eval_ns": 2437323823, "stage_threat_ns": 6671525494, "stage_proof_ns": 109678206, "tactical_annotations": 680449, "root_tactical_annotations": 2379, "search_tactical_annotations": 678070, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 215767, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1373434843, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 584043, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5069791916, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 75522, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2827786320, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 107878, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 168377910, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 694, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3666315, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 215756, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 28828905, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 169423, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 777210748, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 315410, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1445854420, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 195616, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 27425605, "child_limit_applications": 37512, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 37512, "child_cap_hits": 37512, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 37512, "child_moves_before_total": 3151604, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3151604, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 415915, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 415915, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.01588824909362, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.087518660695244, "tt_hits": 20240, "tt_cutoffs": 2604, "beta_cutoffs": 30159, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.909090909090909, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2435.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2984.5454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1496, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1716, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 20116, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 141, 128, 144, 143, 158, 98, 83, 97, 99, 81, 129, 95, 94, 65, 49, 80, 64, 110, 50, 125 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 18046, "avg_search_time_ms": 1503.8333333333333, "search_nodes": 163819, "safety_nodes": 222, "corridor_nodes": 1880, "corridor_branch_probes": 2070, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 871, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1867, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1867, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 49, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 36, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 871, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 49, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 48, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 409, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 43507760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1968080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 165921, "avg_nodes": 13826.75, "eval_calls": 102278, "avg_eval_calls": 8523.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 102278, "pattern_eval_ns": 2230367, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.806908621599952, "pattern_frame_queries": 102278, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2230367, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.806908621599952, "pattern_frame_updates": 327510, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4248550767, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12972.277997618394, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 57734, "avg_candidate_generations": 4811.166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 4244671, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.52116603734368, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 57722, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4243937, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 1112039, "avg_legality_checks": 92669.91666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1112, "root_legality_checks": 734, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1111305, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1112, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4710324, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 392527.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10750284129, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2282.281246258219, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30337, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2528.0833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 135553542, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4468.257968816956, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1265, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10743771, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13636, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 86183781, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15387, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 38277879, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 49, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 348111, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 112508, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9375.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1009415075, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8971.940439790947, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 148333, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12361.083333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 411992296, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2777.482394342459, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2853272596, "stage_ordering_ns": 1846735636, "stage_eval_ns": 4250781134, "stage_threat_ns": 8742131353, "stage_proof_ns": 298046457, "tactical_annotations": 940883, "root_tactical_annotations": 3546, "search_tactical_annotations": 937337, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 331354, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2072380467, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 813550, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6295036114, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 116562, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4453948641, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 165671, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 260773174, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3832, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21195780, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 331342, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44068328, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 199051, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 252157989, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 392816, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1302433948, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 349016, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 48677490, "child_limit_applications": 57722, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 57722, "child_cap_hits": 57722, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 57722, "child_moves_before_total": 4242825, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4242825, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 656630, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 656630, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.50446969959461, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.37573195661966, "tt_hits": 34331, "tt_cutoffs": 3757, "beta_cutoffs": 46930, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 725.5833333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1225.6666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2058, "avg_search_time_ms": 187.0909090909091, "search_nodes": 55652, "safety_nodes": 888, "corridor_nodes": 1145, "corridor_branch_probes": 1420, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 505, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1136, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1136, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 38, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 29, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 505, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 38, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 183, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 46160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 57685, "avg_nodes": 5244.090909090909, "eval_calls": 53624, "avg_eval_calls": 4874.909090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53624, "pattern_eval_ns": 1151999, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.482899448008354, "pattern_frame_queries": 53624, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1151999, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.482899448008354, "pattern_frame_updates": 111240, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1079041849, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9700.124496583963, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2007, "avg_candidate_generations": 182.45454545454547, "candidate_moves_total": 131150, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.3462879920279, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 670, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 1996, "search_candidate_moves_total": 130480, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 4313, "avg_legality_checks": 392.09090909090907, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4313, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 297648, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 27058.909090909092, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 719514416, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2417.3332795785627, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1294, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 117.63636363636364, "renju_forbidden_ns": 10482436, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8100.800618238021, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1274, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 10307626, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 174810, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 12440036, "stage_ordering_ns": 66271, "stage_eval_ns": 1080193848, "stage_threat_ns": 891776981, "stage_proof_ns": 57494604, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 113599, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 709122835, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 64178, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 71574564, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 574, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 17811286, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56794, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81773711, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2348, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14546326, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 113588, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14759545, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 71, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1823, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 2.909090909090909, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5895.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6622.272727272727, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1934, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1717, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17866, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 144, 80, 141, 143, 127, 96, 64, 99, 138, 66, 155, 169, 139, 140, 81, 108, 109, 94, 122, 52 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5937, "avg_search_time_ms": 494.75, "search_nodes": 128322, "safety_nodes": 638, "corridor_nodes": 1184, "corridor_branch_probes": 1347, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 507, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_plies_followed": 1167, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1167, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 70, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 507, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 70, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 65, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 472, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 121760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 130144, "avg_nodes": 10845.333333333334, "eval_calls": 124114, "avg_eval_calls": 10342.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 124114, "pattern_eval_ns": 2679137, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.586098264498766, "pattern_frame_queries": 124114, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2679137, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.586098264498766, "pattern_frame_updates": 256576, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3361353852, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13100.811658144175, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4186, "avg_candidate_generations": 348.8333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 320214, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.49641662685141, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 860, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 4174, "search_candidate_moves_total": 319354, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 116447, "avg_legality_checks": 9703.916666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 66, "root_legality_checks": 860, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 115587, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 66, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1159973, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 96664.41666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2772771444, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2390.375848403368, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18247, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1520.5833333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 156629652, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8583.857730037815, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 75, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 659383, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17422, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 148736270, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 216, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2755320, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 534, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4478679, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 3338, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 278.1666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 36506140, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10936.530856800478, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4727, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 393.9166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 20192561, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4271.749735561667, "stage_move_gen_ns": 295905115, "stage_ordering_ns": 152652, "stage_eval_ns": 3364032989, "stage_threat_ns": 1985208078, "stage_proof_ns": 265968126, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 259062, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1529084848, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 69621, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 226365344, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 785, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 47320240, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129525, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 181823560, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2474, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15512147, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 259050, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32422179, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 423, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3594, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 2.8333333333333335, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5567.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6233.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1774, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11918, "avg_search_time_ms": 1083.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 77714, "safety_nodes": 846, "corridor_nodes": 146, "corridor_branch_probes": 161, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 36, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 137, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 137, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 58, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 58, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 58, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 440, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6475760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 78706, "avg_nodes": 7155.090909090909, "eval_calls": 46020, "avg_eval_calls": 4183.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46020, "pattern_eval_ns": 1043244, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.669361147327248, "pattern_frame_queries": 46020, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1043244, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.669361147327248, "pattern_frame_updates": 155304, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1935846670, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12464.886094369753, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29413, "avg_candidate_generations": 2673.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 2283830, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.64695882772924, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 29402, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2283044, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1500279, "avg_legality_checks": 136389.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6169, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1500279, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6169, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3488316, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 317119.63636363635, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7815378865, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2240.4446343163863, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35899, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3263.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 265140806, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7385.74350260453, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6367, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 69506017, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13059, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 137544824, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16436, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 57621234, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 468731, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 110872, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10079.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1136696747, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10252.333745219712, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 154690, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14062.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 543440933, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3513.0967289417545, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3859998788, "stage_ordering_ns": 1006325845, "stage_eval_ns": 1936889914, "stage_threat_ns": 4943525188, "stage_proof_ns": 105925974, "tactical_annotations": 431954, "root_tactical_annotations": 1732, "search_tactical_annotations": 430222, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 155705, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 998644918, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 369295, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3780756436, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59198, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2292002249, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77847, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 123238146, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 390, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2094435, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 155694, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21003286, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 75383, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 350850429, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 223318, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1130407070, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 133253, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17787967, "child_limit_applications": 29402, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29402, "child_cap_hits": 29402, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29402, "child_moves_before_total": 2276875, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2276875, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 276325, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 276325, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.43945990068703, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.398170192503912, "tt_hits": 15132, "tt_cutoffs": 2230, "beta_cutoffs": 23647, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2774.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3501.3636363636365, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1077, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1718, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14219, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 113, 114, 128, 130, 82, 110, 96, 144, 81, 126, 80, 64, 79, 78, 83 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 9523, "avg_search_time_ms": 1190.375, "search_nodes": 80364, "safety_nodes": 448, "corridor_nodes": 887, "corridor_branch_probes": 1034, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 414, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 875, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 875, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 39, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 27, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 414, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 39, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 288, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23937680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2030880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 81699, "avg_nodes": 10212.375, "eval_calls": 48600, "avg_eval_calls": 6075.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 48600, "pattern_eval_ns": 1065341, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.92059670781893, "pattern_frame_queries": 48600, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1065341, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.92059670781893, "pattern_frame_updates": 160648, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2059597163, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12820.559004780638, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29298, "avg_candidate_generations": 3662.25, "candidate_moves_total": 2230241, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.12263635743054, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 489, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 29290, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2229752, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 749458, "avg_legality_checks": 93682.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3054, "root_legality_checks": 489, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 748969, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3051, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2613079, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 326634.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5808546026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2222.8742514099267, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26632, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3329.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 200983201, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7546.6807224391705, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3138, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34231049, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11299, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 111050421, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11622, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 49816269, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 573, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5885462, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 60313, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7539.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 608975429, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10096.91822658465, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86108, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10763.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 289904046, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3366.7492683606633, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1889455226, "stage_ordering_ns": 945645757, "stage_eval_ns": 2060662504, "stage_threat_ns": 4416626516, "stage_proof_ns": 171821941, "tactical_annotations": 372433, "root_tactical_annotations": 1524, "search_tactical_annotations": 370909, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 162484, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 968444527, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 350371, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3279019313, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59117, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2296352153, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 81238, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121719450, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1828, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10184688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 162476, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20500856, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 63106, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 95341103, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 179187, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 743922427, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 130140, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16757682, "child_limit_applications": 29290, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29290, "child_cap_hits": 29290, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29290, "child_moves_before_total": 2226701, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2226701, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 284418, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 284418, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.02256742915671, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.710413110276544, "tt_hits": 16323, "tt_cutoffs": 2434, "beta_cutoffs": 23380, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1428.75, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2242.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 198, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 4689, "avg_search_time_ms": 669.8571428571429, "search_nodes": 126952, "safety_nodes": 476, "corridor_nodes": 643, "corridor_branch_probes": 746, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 7, "corridor_depth_exits": 238, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 634, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 634, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 43, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 238, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 43, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 43, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 296, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 155120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 15600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 128071, "avg_nodes": 18295.85714285714, "eval_calls": 124086, "avg_eval_calls": 17726.571428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 124086, "pattern_eval_ns": 2696815, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.733434875811938, "pattern_frame_queries": 124086, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2696815, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.733434875811938, "pattern_frame_updates": 253864, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2747527710, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10822.833131125328, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2853, "avg_candidate_generations": 407.57142857142856, "candidate_moves_total": 200340, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.22082018927445, "candidate_moves_max": 91, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 418, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 2846, "search_candidate_moves_total": 199922, "search_candidate_moves_max": 91, "legality_checks": 4882, "avg_legality_checks": 697.4285714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4882, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 649841, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 92834.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1641879976, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2526.587235954641, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12841, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1834.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_ns": 137729975, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 10725.798224437349, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 84671, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12757, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 136747249, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 51, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 583624, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 25, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 314431, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14753001, "stage_ordering_ns": 96600, "stage_eval_ns": 2750224525, "stage_threat_ns": 1841203935, "stage_proof_ns": 74410052, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 255225, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1563527783, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 41437, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 52134387, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 489, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 20246381, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 127609, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184615131, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1354, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7574960, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 255218, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33351674, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 119, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2511, "depth_sum": 20, "avg_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 20, "avg_effective_depth": 2.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3493.8571428571427, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4636.714285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1976, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1719, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18471, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 82, 98, 143, 126, 140, 96, 95, 111, 141, 81, 66, 70, 84, 100, 99, 139, 125, 110, 173, 158, 157, 109, 189 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9826, "avg_search_time_ms": 818.8333333333334, "search_nodes": 170780, "safety_nodes": 814, "corridor_nodes": 8847, "corridor_branch_probes": 9871, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4145, "corridor_neutral_exits": 46, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 8802, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8797, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 114, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 46, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4145, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 114, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 113, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 818, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 373680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 24160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 180441, "avg_nodes": 15036.75, "eval_calls": 165242, "avg_eval_calls": 13770.166666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 165242, "pattern_eval_ns": 3560746, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.548674065915446, "pattern_frame_queries": 165242, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3560746, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.548674065915446, "pattern_frame_updates": 341490, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4152050675, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12158.630340566342, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5515, "avg_candidate_generations": 459.5833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 356631, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.66563916591114, "candidate_moves_max": 97, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 724, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 5503, "search_candidate_moves_total": 355907, "search_candidate_moves_max": 97, "legality_checks": 159578, "avg_legality_checks": 13298.166666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 724, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 158854, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2301482, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 191790.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5167260005, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2245.1881027094714, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9948, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 829.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 77887736, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7829.486932046642, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 209781, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9555, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 73277763, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 166, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2110317, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 203, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2289875, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 16412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1367.6666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 165861494, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10106.111016329514, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22557, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 1879.75, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 86195575, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3821.2339850157377, "stage_move_gen_ns": 406690023, "stage_ordering_ns": 186541, "stage_eval_ns": 4155611421, "stage_threat_ns": 4149605306, "stage_proof_ns": 1083955942, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 359334, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2207884999, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 483107, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1533352090, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 4668, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 310997636, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 179661, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 256513002, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 17832, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 106363147, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 359322, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 45492068, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 261, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4972, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4538.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5205.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1350, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 8635, "avg_search_time_ms": 719.5833333333334, "search_nodes": 71349, "safety_nodes": 813, "corridor_nodes": 478, "corridor_branch_probes": 629, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 162, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 467, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 467, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 18, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 162, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 18, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 17, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 37, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 7987280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 72640, "avg_nodes": 6053.333333333333, "eval_calls": 41271, "avg_eval_calls": 3439.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41271, "pattern_eval_ns": 906534, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.965399433015918, "pattern_frame_queries": 41271, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 906534, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.965399433015918, "pattern_frame_updates": 142558, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1472209494, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10327.091387365143, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27268, "avg_candidate_generations": 2272.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 1889390, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.28964353821328, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 749, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 27256, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1888641, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 1019603, "avg_legality_checks": 84966.91666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1019603, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 96, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2638819, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 219901.58333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5503919334, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2085.7509870893, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14043, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1170.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21750082, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1548.820195115004, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 815452, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2316, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11186563, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11617, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9739687, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8380, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 76974, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6414.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 656413709, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8527.732857848105, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 102320, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8526.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 270274547, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2641.463516419077, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2383333524, "stage_ordering_ns": 779308482, "stage_eval_ns": 1473116028, "stage_threat_ns": 3914318306, "stage_proof_ns": 27382615, "tactical_annotations": 388655, "root_tactical_annotations": 901, "search_tactical_annotations": 387754, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 143540, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 860721174, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 368839, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2911079976, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54895, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1927098578, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 71764, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 104627039, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 970, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6100179, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 143528, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18339458, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 65599, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 227692322, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 216817, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 732014697, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 106239, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13450480, "child_limit_applications": 27256, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27256, "child_cap_hits": 27256, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27256, "child_moves_before_total": 1888545, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1888545, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 251798, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 251798, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.28914734370414, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.238259465805694, "tt_hits": 13287, "tt_cutoffs": 2753, "beta_cutoffs": 21964, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 5.75, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 5.75, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4446.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5113.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1720, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32590, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 98, 156, 82, 67, 114, 66, 96, 99, 68, 110, 126, 140, 84, 70, 83, 170, 184, 125, 155, 95, 80, 81, 53, 38, 52, 109, 123, 36, 54, 40, 51, 55, 50 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 29303, "avg_search_time_ms": 1627.9444444444443, "search_nodes": 211692, "safety_nodes": 811, "corridor_nodes": 24024, "corridor_branch_probes": 26280, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 12148, "corridor_neutral_exits": 27, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 23977, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 23977, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 86, "corridor_proof_active": 47, "corridor_proof_quiet": 39, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 27, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 12148, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 86, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 2, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 616, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 65491440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 236527, "avg_nodes": 13140.388888888889, "eval_calls": 134255, "avg_eval_calls": 7458.611111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 134255, "pattern_eval_ns": 3003381, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.370719898700234, "pattern_frame_queries": 134255, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3003381, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.370719898700234, "pattern_frame_updates": 423176, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5610489508, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13258.052224133693, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 71706, "avg_candidate_generations": 3983.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 6232567, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.91834713970937, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1337, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 71688, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6231230, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1568182, "avg_legality_checks": 87121.22222222222, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1750, "root_legality_checks": 1337, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1566845, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1750, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8393167, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 466287.05555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17955472474, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2139.296462705913, "renju_forbidden_checks": 53794, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2988.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 320297901, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5954.1566159794775, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3027, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26947447, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22777, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 174792379, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26250, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 101301097, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1740, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 17256978, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 220486, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12249.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1923980595, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8726.089615667208, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 291464, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16192.444444444445, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 823535485, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2825.5135625669036, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3842489774, "stage_ordering_ns": 2500403501, "stage_eval_ns": 5613492889, "stage_threat_ns": 15001171415, "stage_proof_ns": 2264100826, "tactical_annotations": 1547412, "root_tactical_annotations": 4207, "search_tactical_annotations": 1543205, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 471320, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3223229496, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2348085, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10939600409, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 155205, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5757203473, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 235651, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 384641829, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 48126, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 325997508, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 471302, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62618327, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 455146, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 449796183, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 582581, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1835042138, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 509685, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 65083846, "child_limit_applications": 71688, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 71688, "child_cap_hits": 71688, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 71688, "child_moves_before_total": 6229480, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6229480, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 866930, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 866930, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.8971096975784, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.093097868541458, "tt_hits": 43573, "tt_cutoffs": 5647, "beta_cutoffs": 59276, "depth_sum": 102, "avg_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 102, "avg_effective_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1740.1666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2116.6111111111113, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 3268, "avg_search_time_ms": 192.23529411764707, "search_nodes": 85002, "safety_nodes": 1927, "corridor_nodes": 1079, "corridor_branch_probes": 1316, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 10, "corridor_depth_exits": 402, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 1058, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1053, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 35, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 402, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 218, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 207840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 88008, "avg_nodes": 5176.941176470588, "eval_calls": 82184, "avg_eval_calls": 4834.35294117647, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82184, "pattern_eval_ns": 1796889, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.86421931276161, "pattern_frame_queries": 82184, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1796889, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.86421931276161, "pattern_frame_updates": 169904, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1854196848, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10913.203032300593, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2785, "avg_candidate_generations": 163.8235294117647, "candidate_moves_total": 222994, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.06965888689408, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1261, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 2768, "search_candidate_moves_total": 221733, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 5365, "avg_legality_checks": 315.5882352941176, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5365, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 566590, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 33328.82352941176, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1315479207, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2321.748013554775, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4597, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 270.4117647058824, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33743103, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7340.244289754188, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 52111, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4557, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33415520, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39411, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 236061, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.4705882352941178, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 282271, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6720.738095238095, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.0588235294117645, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 91001, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1750.0192307692307, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14936189, "stage_ordering_ns": 90390, "stage_eval_ns": 1855993737, "stage_threat_ns": 1284206817, "stage_proof_ns": 85207967, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 172145, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1045670583, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 65108, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 77423948, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 691, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 27751282, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 86064, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 123396073, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2224, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15749073, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 172128, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21967140, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2591, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6718.823529411765, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7189.411764705882, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1974, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1721, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26050, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 80, 141, 155, 99, 85, 128, 125, 129, 130, 140, 139, 97, 108, 109, 153, 167, 145, 100, 98, 114, 65, 95, 144, 86, 142, 72 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6275, "avg_search_time_ms": 448.2142857142857, "search_nodes": 109486, "safety_nodes": 1548, "corridor_nodes": 3353, "corridor_branch_probes": 3976, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1343, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 3313, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3273, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 40, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 91, "corridor_proof_active": 40, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1343, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 91, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 8, "corridor_proof_unknown": 83, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 543, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 226720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 114387, "avg_nodes": 8170.5, "eval_calls": 105663, "avg_eval_calls": 7547.357142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 105663, "pattern_eval_ns": 2304608, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.81092719305717, "pattern_frame_queries": 105663, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2304608, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.81092719305717, "pattern_frame_updates": 218890, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3156686186, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14421.335766823518, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 3796, "avg_candidate_generations": 271.14285714285717, "candidate_moves_total": 297600, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.39831401475237, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1056, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 3782, "search_candidate_moves_total": 296544, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 102069, "avg_legality_checks": 7290.642857142857, "illegal_moves_skipped": 109, "root_legality_checks": 1056, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 101013, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 104, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1396907, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 99779.07142857143, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3270627263, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2341.335008701367, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14698, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1049.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 114407313, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7783.869438018778, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 116, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1032612, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13364, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 104249433, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 365, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3072050, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 853, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6053218, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 9413, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 672.3571428571429, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 96029582, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10201.80410071178, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12389, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 884.9285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 51399763, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 4148.822584550811, "stage_move_gen_ns": 267655579, "stage_ordering_ns": 128800, "stage_eval_ns": 3158990794, "stage_threat_ns": 2274120643, "stage_proof_ns": 549054903, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 225712, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1396967944, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 203258, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 637620796, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 1807, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 123886886, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 112849, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 165208567, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6808, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 44185197, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 225698, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30138139, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 190, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 3437, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9285714285714284, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6212.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6783.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1831, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 19760, "avg_search_time_ms": 1411.4285714285713, "search_nodes": 132848, "safety_nodes": 883, "corridor_nodes": 1431, "corridor_branch_probes": 1670, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 523, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 61, "corridor_plies_followed": 1414, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1234, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 180, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 32, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 15, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 523, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 61, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 32, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 31, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 175, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 15878080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1988240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 135162, "avg_nodes": 9654.42857142857, "eval_calls": 83138, "avg_eval_calls": 5938.428571428572, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 83138, "pattern_eval_ns": 1873332, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.532800885275083, "pattern_frame_queries": 83138, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1873332, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.532800885275083, "pattern_frame_updates": 265526, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3318894291, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12499.319430112306, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 45077, "avg_candidate_generations": 3219.785714285714, "candidate_moves_total": 3921853, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.00341637642256, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1101, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 45063, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3920752, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 2418725, "avg_legality_checks": 172766.07142857142, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11453, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2418725, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5860050, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 418575.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12676976958, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2163.2881900325083, "renju_forbidden_checks": 112424, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8030.285714285715, "renju_forbidden_ns": 375217447, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3337.52087632534, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15653, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 119225195, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21417, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 114096124, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 75084, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 140952664, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 270, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 943464, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 218029, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15573.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2256357365, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10348.88645547152, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 294834, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21059.571428571428, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1114643846, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3780.581093089671, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6100051566, "stage_ordering_ns": 1625012353, "stage_eval_ns": 3320767623, "stage_threat_ns": 8555452205, "stage_proof_ns": 63403159, "tactical_annotations": 990627, "root_tactical_annotations": 2950, "search_tactical_annotations": 987677, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 268432, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1745655787, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 905590, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6503714644, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 91014, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3436383801, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134209, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 216958463, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2892, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17034392, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 268418, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37856807, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 254352, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1102707739, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 474071, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1876412886, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 262204, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 34232112, "child_limit_applications": 45063, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 45063, "child_cap_hits": 45063, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 45063, "child_moves_before_total": 3909299, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3909299, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 538345, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 538345, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.75185850919823, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.946497126245479, "tt_hits": 23967, "tt_cutoffs": 4565, "beta_cutoffs": 36769, "depth_sum": 81, "avg_depth": 5.785714285714286, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 81, "avg_effective_depth": 5.785714285714286, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.21428571428571427, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2857142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2742.714285714286, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3314.1428571428573, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1722, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30806, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 123, 81, 97, 83, 139, 153, 124, 85, 71, 82, 84, 80, 79, 94, 122, 121, 107, 66, 52, 91, 137, 151, 92, 152, 77 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 29184, "avg_search_time_ms": 1621.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 218695, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 23752, "corridor_branch_probes": 26070, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 12068, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 23705, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 23705, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 84, "corridor_proof_active": 47, "corridor_proof_quiet": 37, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 12068, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 84, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 626, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 69519760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 243244, "avg_nodes": 13513.555555555555, "eval_calls": 140725, "avg_eval_calls": 7818.055555555556, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 140725, "pattern_eval_ns": 3133907, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.269724640255816, "pattern_frame_queries": 140725, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3133907, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.269724640255816, "pattern_frame_updates": 437182, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5789284487, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13242.27549853379, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 72253, "avg_candidate_generations": 4014.0555555555557, "candidate_moves_total": 6338818, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.7308623863369, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 72235, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6337516, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1609436, "avg_legality_checks": 89413.11111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2046, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1608134, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2046, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8416103, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 467561.27777777775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17769401198, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2111.3573821518107, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60430, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3357.222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 349457974, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5782.855767003144, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3523, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 29978133, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26891, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 200375152, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28222, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 103285697, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1794, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 15818992, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 229251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12736.166666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1929529921, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8416.669593589559, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 303331, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16851.722222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 831962309, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2742.7539849207633, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3945549995, "stage_ordering_ns": 2527011192, "stage_eval_ns": 5792418394, "stage_threat_ns": 14610372830, "stage_proof_ns": 2231521368, "tactical_annotations": 1529081, "root_tactical_annotations": 4128, "search_tactical_annotations": 1524953, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 484778, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3231313360, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2346112, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10539182699, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 156074, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5528385936, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 242380, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 400164414, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 47578, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 313959725, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 484760, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62739208, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 467707, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 462171218, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 586278, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1849978204, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 475096, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 63013424, "child_limit_applications": 72235, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 72235, "child_cap_hits": 72235, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 72235, "child_moves_before_total": 6335470, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6335470, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 836272, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 836272, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.70637502595694, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.577102512632381, "tt_hits": 43315, "tt_cutoffs": 5632, "beta_cutoffs": 59361, "depth_sum": 101, "avg_depth": 5.611111111111111, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 101, "avg_effective_depth": 5.611111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3888888888888889, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1815.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2198.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 1604, "avg_search_time_ms": 94.3529411764706, "search_nodes": 42485, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 957, "corridor_branch_probes": 1159, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 348, "corridor_neutral_exits": 24, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 937, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 932, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 348, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 218, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 206560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 45333, "avg_nodes": 2666.6470588235293, "eval_calls": 40031, "avg_eval_calls": 2354.764705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40031, "pattern_eval_ns": 900381, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.492093627438734, "pattern_frame_queries": 40031, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 900381, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.492093627438734, "pattern_frame_updates": 84870, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 787550978, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9279.49779663014, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2421, "avg_candidate_generations": 142.41176470588235, "candidate_moves_total": 189525, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.28376703841388, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1235, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2404, "search_candidate_moves_total": 188290, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5477, "avg_legality_checks": 322.1764705882353, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5477, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 269968, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 15880.470588235294, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 618239179, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2290.046149914064, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1399, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 82.29411764705883, "renju_forbidden_ns": 9169133, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6554.062187276626, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 40940, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1359, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8880773, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37740, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 209680, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.4705882352941178, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 289511, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6893.119047619048, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 52, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.0588235294117645, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 94280, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1813.076923076923, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14988482, "stage_ordering_ns": 78970, "stage_eval_ns": 788451359, "stage_threat_ns": 688361497, "stage_proof_ns": 86367937, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 86869, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 529926790, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 58162, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 70844446, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 650, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 26433755, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 43426, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 62552422, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1982, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14041468, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 86852, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10996371, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2230, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6746.588235294118, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7217.176470588235, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1973, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1723, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16350, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 67, 81, 126, 113, 129, 83, 84, 98, 128, 65, 49, 79, 80, 68, 53, 130, 114, 127, 142, 99, 100, 156, 86 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9001, "avg_search_time_ms": 750.0833333333334, "search_nodes": 162713, "safety_nodes": 892, "corridor_nodes": 9609, "corridor_branch_probes": 10757, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4513, "corridor_neutral_exits": 41, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 9560, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9540, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 20, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 118, "corridor_proof_active": 49, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 41, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4513, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 118, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 4, "corridor_proof_unknown": 114, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 832, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 475200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 24880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 173214, "avg_nodes": 14434.5, "eval_calls": 156970, "avg_eval_calls": 13080.833333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 156970, "pattern_eval_ns": 3185938, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.29647703382812, "pattern_frame_queries": 156970, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3185938, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.29647703382812, "pattern_frame_updates": 325356, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3511864807, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10793.914379940741, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5720, "avg_candidate_generations": 476.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 372730, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.16258741258741, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 5708, "search_candidate_moves_total": 372008, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 151449, "avg_legality_checks": 12620.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 150727, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2267603, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 188966.91666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4776868346, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2106.571717359697, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9257, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 771.4166666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64701011, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6989.41460516366, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 189901, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8790, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60067271, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 173, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1981622, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 272, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2462217, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 18105, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1508.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 174969985, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9664.180336923502, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25020, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2085.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 92138855, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3682.6081135091927, "stage_move_gen_ns": 354088884, "stage_ordering_ns": 192642, "stage_eval_ns": 3515050745, "stage_threat_ns": 3990172499, "stage_proof_ns": 1114304213, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 344724, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2025299848, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 522964, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1580045870, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 4971, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 315479436, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 172356, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 231775926, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 19356, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 112209627, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 344712, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40841228, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 265, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5174, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4859.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5526.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1512, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7337, "avg_search_time_ms": 611.4166666666666, "search_nodes": 63412, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 438, "corridor_branch_probes": 582, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 134, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_plies_followed": 427, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 427, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 18, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 134, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 18, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 17, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 37, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 7987760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 64889, "avg_nodes": 5407.416666666667, "eval_calls": 36475, "avg_eval_calls": 3039.5833333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36475, "pattern_eval_ns": 769925, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.10829335161069, "pattern_frame_queries": 36475, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 769925, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.10829335161069, "pattern_frame_updates": 126692, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1302672604, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10282.200959808039, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24283, "avg_candidate_generations": 2023.5833333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 1624432, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.8958530659309, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 744, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 24271, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1623688, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 799991, "avg_legality_checks": 66665.91666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 799991, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2208250, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 184020.83333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4623220321, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2093.6127345182836, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10959, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 913.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19367513, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1767.2700976366457, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 56, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 458552, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2280, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11564174, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8623, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7344787, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 64511, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5375.916666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 545418578, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8454.660104478306, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84823, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7068.583333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 223244825, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2631.8902302441556, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1864693826, "stage_ordering_ns": 654026431, "stage_eval_ns": 1303442529, "stage_threat_ns": 3448970784, "stage_proof_ns": 26254919, "tactical_annotations": 319451, "root_tactical_annotations": 456, "search_tactical_annotations": 318995, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 127594, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 788381173, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 314003, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2537135072, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48905, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1700487485, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 63791, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93173533, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 890, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5325312, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 127582, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16151592, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 42264, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 166913400, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 192693, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 646344438, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 84494, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8804102, "child_limit_applications": 24271, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24271, "child_cap_hits": 24271, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24271, "child_moves_before_total": 1623638, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1623638, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 223513, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 223513, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 66.89621358823287, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.209056075151416, "tt_hits": 11609, "tt_cutoffs": 2601, "beta_cutoffs": 19400, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4493.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5159.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1724, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32053, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 143, 67, 52, 95, 53, 83, 80, 51, 99, 113, 129, 65, 49, 66, 159, 175, 114, 144, 84, 69, 68, 36, 21, 37, 100, 116, 23, 35, 19, 38, 34, 39 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 29108, "avg_search_time_ms": 1617.111111111111, "search_nodes": 218649, "safety_nodes": 797, "corridor_nodes": 33890, "corridor_branch_probes": 36244, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 18482, "corridor_neutral_exits": 26, "corridor_terminal_exits": 33, "corridor_plies_followed": 33838, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 33838, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 102, "corridor_proof_active": 52, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 18482, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 33, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 102, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 102, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 765, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 67516080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 253336, "avg_nodes": 14074.222222222223, "eval_calls": 138342, "avg_eval_calls": 7685.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 138342, "pattern_eval_ns": 2906226, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.007546515158086, "pattern_frame_queries": 138342, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2906226, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.007546515158086, "pattern_frame_updates": 437090, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5117873726, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11708.970065661535, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 74493, "avg_candidate_generations": 4138.5, "candidate_moves_total": 6331180, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.9902675419167, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1302, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 74475, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6329878, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1555844, "avg_legality_checks": 86435.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1648, "root_legality_checks": 1302, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1554542, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1648, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9083946, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 504663.6666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 17914390982, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1972.0935133255966, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54235, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3013.0555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 290252076, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5351.748428136812, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2975, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23423900, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23038, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 155224816, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25289, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 92050778, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2933, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 19552582, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 243293, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13516.277777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1921604202, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7898.312742249058, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 320841, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17824.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 837489454, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2610.294363874941, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3575690520, "stage_ordering_ns": 2358998385, "stage_eval_ns": 5120779952, "stage_threat_ns": 15242745069, "stage_proof_ns": 2731209062, "tactical_annotations": 1590472, "root_tactical_annotations": 4128, "search_tactical_annotations": 1586344, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 504988, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3289709081, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2706032, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11001769478, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 164332, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5498792830, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 252485, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 387396452, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 67880, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 432830033, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 504970, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 61230562, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 461635, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 417338764, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 582228, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1680101957, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 546609, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 69809463, "child_limit_applications": 74475, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 74475, "child_cap_hits": 74475, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 74475, "child_moves_before_total": 6328230, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6328230, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 890265, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 890265, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.97119838872105, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.95387713997986, "tt_hits": 46136, "tt_cutoffs": 5728, "beta_cutoffs": 61587, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 5.722222222222222, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2103.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2490.222222222222, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 2929, "avg_search_time_ms": 172.2941176470588, "search_nodes": 83589, "safety_nodes": 1891, "corridor_nodes": 1160, "corridor_branch_probes": 1414, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 462, "corridor_neutral_exits": 24, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 1140, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1135, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 35, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 462, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 218, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 214560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 86640, "avg_nodes": 5096.470588235294, "eval_calls": 80899, "avg_eval_calls": 4758.764705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80899, "pattern_eval_ns": 1643426, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.31454035278557, "pattern_frame_queries": 80899, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1643426, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.31454035278557, "pattern_frame_updates": 167078, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1630434666, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9758.52395886951, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2657, "avg_candidate_generations": 156.2941176470588, "candidate_moves_total": 210366, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.1742566804667, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1235, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 2640, "search_candidate_moves_total": 209131, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 5095, "avg_legality_checks": 299.70588235294116, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5095, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 558911, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 32877.117647058825, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1170730667, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2094.663849879498, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4401, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 258.88235294117646, "renju_forbidden_ns": 28809539, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6546.134742104067, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 9, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 72760, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4359, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28451579, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 77650, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 207550, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.7058823529411766, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 274831, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5974.586956521739, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2941176470588234, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 81980, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1463.9285714285713, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13174573, "stage_ordering_ns": 81290, "stage_eval_ns": 1632078092, "stage_threat_ns": 1175888317, "stage_proof_ns": 81330767, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 169483, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 952755112, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 67032, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 76476336, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 697, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 26235081, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84733, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 111098696, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2388, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15746066, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 169466, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19812107, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2469, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6739.35294117647, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7209.941176470588, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1977, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1725, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15268, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 110, 96, 99, 128, 144, 126, 141, 127, 129, 80, 64, 66, 81, 125, 124, 159, 143, 114, 115, 142, 157, 101, 171 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7777, "avg_search_time_ms": 648.0833333333334, "search_nodes": 124935, "safety_nodes": 892, "corridor_nodes": 9775, "corridor_branch_probes": 10994, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4597, "corridor_neutral_exits": 41, "corridor_terminal_exits": 30, "corridor_plies_followed": 9725, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9701, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 24, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 118, "corridor_proof_active": 50, "corridor_proof_quiet": 68, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 41, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4597, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 118, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 4, "corridor_proof_unknown": 114, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 832, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 489920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 24880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 135602, "avg_nodes": 11300.166666666666, "eval_calls": 120088, "avg_eval_calls": 10007.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 120088, "pattern_eval_ns": 2445464, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.36393311571514, "pattern_frame_queries": 120088, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2445464, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.36393311571514, "pattern_frame_updates": 249800, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2684440775, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10746.36018815052, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 4824, "avg_candidate_generations": 402.0, "candidate_moves_total": 318208, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.96351575456053, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 4812, "search_candidate_moves_total": 317486, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 115942, "avg_legality_checks": 9661.833333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 115220, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 11, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2001887, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 166823.91666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4228939484, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2112.476620308739, "renju_forbidden_checks": 8992, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 749.3333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 53282061, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5925.496107651245, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 17, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 126240, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8465, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 47887238, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 195, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2332787, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 315, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2935796, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 18621, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1551.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 184532164, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9909.895494334354, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25754, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2146.1666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 97743622, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3795.279257591054, "stage_move_gen_ns": 281738944, "stage_ordering_ns": 151580, "stage_eval_ns": 2686886239, "stage_threat_ns": 3653015771, "stage_proof_ns": 1136594178, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 269498, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1649239127, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 530966, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1661982420, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 5013, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 332372401, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 134743, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 191597836, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 19686, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 117512365, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 269486, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32684023, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 265, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 4276, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5447.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6114.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1788, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 7480, "avg_search_time_ms": 623.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 62588, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 569, "corridor_branch_probes": 732, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 181, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 25, "corridor_plies_followed": 558, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 558, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 18, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 181, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 18, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 17, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 37, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 7988560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 64196, "avg_nodes": 5349.666666666667, "eval_calls": 36412, "avg_eval_calls": 3034.3333333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36412, "pattern_eval_ns": 769791, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.14113479072833, "pattern_frame_queries": 36412, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 769791, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.14113479072833, "pattern_frame_updates": 125044, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1309295817, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10470.68085633857, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23933, "avg_candidate_generations": 1994.4166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1621908, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.76868758617807, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 744, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 23921, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1621164, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 814170, "avg_legality_checks": 67847.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 68, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 814170, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 68, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2235115, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 186259.58333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4735609748, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2118.7320330273833, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11089, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 924.0833333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 19236392, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1734.7273875011272, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 72, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 640224, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2228, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11106400, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8789, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7489768, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65069, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5422.416666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 556574899, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8553.61076703192, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 86143, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7178.583333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 228226075, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2649.3861950477694, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1933181855, "stage_ordering_ns": 675289081, "stage_eval_ns": 1310065608, "stage_threat_ns": 3496777176, "stage_proof_ns": 26377782, "tactical_annotations": 320634, "root_tactical_annotations": 456, "search_tactical_annotations": 320178, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 126208, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 771148550, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 325267, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2600525448, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48278, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1741154352, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 63098, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 93593898, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1152, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7272958, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 126196, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16093555, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 41246, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 158394344, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 199315, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 674455858, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 80073, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8142767, "child_limit_applications": 23921, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23921, "child_cap_hits": 23921, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23921, "child_moves_before_total": 1621096, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1621096, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 220089, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 220089, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.76873876510179, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.200660507503867, "tt_hits": 10579, "tt_cutoffs": 2190, "beta_cutoffs": 19138, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 5.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4470.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5137.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1726, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19998, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 110, 109, 82, 124, 126, 81, 94, 142, 128, 144, 80, 64, 125, 95, 141, 156, 127, 129, 99, 155, 85 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18194, "avg_search_time_ms": 1399.5384615384614, "search_nodes": 153634, "safety_nodes": 715, "corridor_nodes": 20357, "corridor_branch_probes": 20959, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 11051, "corridor_neutral_exits": 26, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 20312, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 20312, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 95, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 11051, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 95, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 93, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 730, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 65505920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 8, "total_nodes": 174706, "avg_nodes": 13438.923076923076, "eval_calls": 94930, "avg_eval_calls": 7302.307692307692, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 94930, "pattern_eval_ns": 1965585, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.705625197513957, "pattern_frame_queries": 94930, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1965585, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.705625197513957, "pattern_frame_updates": 307126, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3476585637, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11319.737296744659, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 54458, "avg_candidate_generations": 4189.076923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 4418233, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.13101839950053, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 813, "root_candidate_moves_max": 76, "search_candidate_generations": 54445, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4417420, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1145000, "avg_legality_checks": 88076.92307692308, "illegal_moves_skipped": 861, "root_legality_checks": 813, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1144187, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 861, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6350476, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 488498.1538461539, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11145635211, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1755.0865810688836, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25392, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1953.2307692307693, "renju_forbidden_ns": 120402609, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4741.753662570888, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 959, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8621172, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10362, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 71624217, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11807, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 33952998, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2264, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6204222, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 150032, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11540.923076923076, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1052610883, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7015.909159379333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 193995, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14922.692307692309, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 450517126, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2322.3130802340265, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2483553951, "stage_ordering_ns": 1577650484, "stage_eval_ns": 3478551222, "stage_threat_ns": 9339875669, "stage_proof_ns": 1260454863, "tactical_annotations": 1031695, "root_tactical_annotations": 2952, "search_tactical_annotations": 1028743, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 347953, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2025914589, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1683967, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6791778259, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 118103, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3894861164, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 173970, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 251124610, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 40814, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 182642471, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 347940, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39419477, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 269900, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 232986925, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 366509, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1022664732, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 395286, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 48996263, "child_limit_applications": 54445, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 54445, "child_cap_hits": 54445, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 54445, "child_moves_before_total": 4416559, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4416559, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 603092, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 603092, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.11964367710533, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.077086968500321, "tt_hits": 34655, "tt_cutoffs": 4188, "beta_cutoffs": 44479, "depth_sum": 71, "avg_depth": 5.461538461538462, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 71, "avg_effective_depth": 5.461538461538462, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.38461538461538464, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2426.4615384615386, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3031.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 228, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 1794, "avg_search_time_ms": 149.5, "search_nodes": 59196, "safety_nodes": 1061, "corridor_nodes": 744, "corridor_branch_probes": 871, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 272, "corridor_neutral_exits": 21, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 727, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 727, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 43, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 26, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 21, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 272, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 43, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 43, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 198, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 178720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 61001, "avg_nodes": 5083.416666666667, "eval_calls": 57444, "avg_eval_calls": 4787.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 57444, "pattern_eval_ns": 1143395, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.904515702249146, "pattern_frame_queries": 57444, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1143395, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.904515702249146, "pattern_frame_updates": 118322, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 986683425, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8338.968450499484, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 1729, "avg_candidate_generations": 144.08333333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 124909, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.2434933487565, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 748, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 1717, "search_candidate_moves_total": 124161, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 3930, "avg_legality_checks": 327.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3930, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 358452, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 29871.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 670662517, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1870.996722015779, "renju_forbidden_checks": 1700, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 141.66666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14157118, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8327.716470588235, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 0, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1696, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14112108, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45010, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 0.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 0.0, "stage_move_gen_ns": 9305040, "stage_ordering_ns": 54340, "stage_eval_ns": 987826820, "stage_threat_ns": 715895117, "stage_proof_ns": 62543573, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 119874, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 590205963, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 47149, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 36180083, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 507, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 12695210, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 59931, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 70626359, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1540, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6175069, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 119862, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12707643, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 67, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 1587, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6234.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6900.833333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1727, "black": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12587, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 82, 96, 141, 128, 144, 98, 99, 113, 143, 80, 64, 94, 95, 83, 68, 145, 129, 142, 157, 114, 115, 171, 101 ], "move_count": 28, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 6701, "avg_search_time_ms": 558.4166666666666, "search_nodes": 164463, "safety_nodes": 892, "corridor_nodes": 9609, "corridor_branch_probes": 10757, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4513, "corridor_neutral_exits": 41, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 9560, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9540, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 20, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 118, "corridor_proof_active": 49, "corridor_proof_quiet": 69, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 41, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4513, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 118, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 4, "corridor_proof_unknown": 114, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 832, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 475200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 24880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 174964, "avg_nodes": 14580.333333333334, "eval_calls": 158720, "avg_eval_calls": 13226.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 158720, "pattern_eval_ns": 3113214, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.614503528225807, "pattern_frame_queries": 158720, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3113214, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.614503528225807, "pattern_frame_updates": 328856, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2634408739, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8010.827654049189, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 5720, "avg_candidate_generations": 476.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 374674, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.50244755244755, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 722, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 5708, "search_candidate_moves_total": 373952, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 153206, "avg_legality_checks": 12767.166666666666, "illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "root_legality_checks": 722, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 152484, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2293466, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 191122.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3477777370, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1516.384969299741, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9262, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 771.8333333333334, "renju_forbidden_ns": 44949627, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4853.1231915353055, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 108271, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8795, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 41587175, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 173, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 1399861, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 272, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1854320, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 18105, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1508.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 134314293, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7418.629826014913, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 25020, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2085.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 71204591, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2845.9069144684254, "stage_move_gen_ns": 256296900, "stage_ordering_ns": 175542, "stage_eval_ns": 2637521953, "stage_threat_ns": 2962589478, "stage_proof_ns": 808619739, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 348224, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1447044958, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 522964, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1211283323, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 4971, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 237810808, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 174106, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 184983882, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 19356, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 88225517, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 348212, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31051798, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 265, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 5175, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9166666666666665, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5604.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6270.916666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1895, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5875, "avg_search_time_ms": 489.5833333333333, "search_nodes": 75545, "safety_nodes": 1039, "corridor_nodes": 438, "corridor_branch_probes": 582, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 134, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_plies_followed": 427, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 427, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 34, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 23, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 134, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 34, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 33, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 173, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 35751120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 77022, "avg_nodes": 6418.5, "eval_calls": 42588, "avg_eval_calls": 3549.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 42588, "pattern_eval_ns": 850443, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.969075795998872, "pattern_frame_queries": 42588, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 850443, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.969075795998872, "pattern_frame_updates": 150958, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1079289234, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7149.599451503067, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29445, "avg_candidate_generations": 2453.75, "candidate_moves_total": 1991120, "avg_candidate_moves": 67.62166751570724, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 744, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 29433, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1990376, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 977202, "avg_legality_checks": 81433.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 977202, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 50, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2651130, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 220927.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3582976674, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1351.4903735388307, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11790, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 982.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15602051, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1323.329177268872, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 56, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 312293, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2692, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9603097, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9042, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5686661, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68234, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5686.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 383787439, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5624.577761819621, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 89763, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7480.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 160071886, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1783.2724619275202, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1443130351, "stage_ordering_ns": 538281508, "stage_eval_ns": 1080139677, "stage_threat_ns": 2720070207, "stage_proof_ns": 37174336, "tactical_annotations": 374445, "root_tactical_annotations": 456, "search_tactical_annotations": 373989, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 151892, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 612803486, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 353901, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1996139398, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59293, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1377849603, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 75940, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 80302543, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 922, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4216832, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 151880, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13806857, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 46072, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 129057601, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 218363, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 472357006, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 110010, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12801091, "child_limit_applications": 29433, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29433, "child_cap_hits": 29433, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29433, "child_moves_before_total": 1990326, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1990326, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 266235, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 266235, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 67.62226072775456, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.045459178473143, "tt_hits": 15270, "tt_cutoffs": 3458, "beta_cutoffs": 23636, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4995.333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5662.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 557, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1728, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d3+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32540, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 158, 82, 67, 110, 68, 98, 95, 66, 114, 128, 144, 80, 64, 81, 174, 190, 129, 159, 99, 84, 83, 51, 36, 52, 115, 131, 38, 50, 34, 53, 49, 54 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 29322, "avg_search_time_ms": 1629.0, "search_nodes": 213636, "safety_nodes": 811, "corridor_nodes": 28448, "corridor_branch_probes": 30753, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 15066, "corridor_neutral_exits": 26, "corridor_terminal_exits": 31, "corridor_plies_followed": 28398, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 28398, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 50, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 15066, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 31, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 100, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 762, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 67519520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 242895, "avg_nodes": 13494.166666666666, "eval_calls": 134499, "avg_eval_calls": 7472.166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 134499, "pattern_eval_ns": 2948892, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.925010594874312, "pattern_frame_queries": 134499, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2948892, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.925010594874312, "pattern_frame_updates": 427064, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5362611261, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12556.926505160818, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 73404, "avg_candidate_generations": 4078.0, "candidate_moves_total": 6381610, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.9381777559806, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1337, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 73386, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6380273, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1592618, "avg_legality_checks": 88478.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1695, "root_legality_checks": 1337, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1591281, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1695, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8784453, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 488025.1666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 18028801119, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2052.353301793521, "renju_forbidden_checks": 52401, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2911.1666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 295774949, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5644.452376863037, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2996, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 26017377, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21603, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 156667641, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25515, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 96978638, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2287, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 16111293, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 231222, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12845.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1939783115, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8389.2670896368, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 304439, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 16913.277777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 829693086, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2725.3179980225923, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3777404577, "stage_ordering_ns": 2467834475, "stage_eval_ns": 5365560153, "stage_threat_ns": 15216273097, "stage_proof_ns": 2407927369, "tactical_annotations": 1602354, "root_tactical_annotations": 4207, "search_tactical_annotations": 1598147, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 484078, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3242556398, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2510026, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11085723601, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 160128, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5735753037, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 242030, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 382040993, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 56996, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 374407811, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 484060, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 60858353, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 471298, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 442524961, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 580324, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1771821481, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 550732, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 70685941, "child_limit_applications": 73386, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 73386, "child_cap_hits": 73386, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 73386, "child_moves_before_total": 6378578, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6378578, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 894506, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 894506, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.91818603003297, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.18905513313166, "tt_hits": 45626, "tt_cutoffs": 5649, "beta_cutoffs": 60791, "depth_sum": 102, "avg_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 102, "avg_effective_depth": 5.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4444444444444444, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1887.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2263.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 3204, "avg_search_time_ms": 188.47058823529412, "search_nodes": 84800, "safety_nodes": 1927, "corridor_nodes": 1162, "corridor_branch_probes": 1411, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 462, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_plies_followed": 1141, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1136, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 36, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 462, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 218, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 202480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 87889, "avg_nodes": 5169.941176470588, "eval_calls": 82097, "avg_eval_calls": 4829.235294117647, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 82097, "pattern_eval_ns": 1775346, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.62498020634128, "pattern_frame_queries": 82097, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1775346, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.62498020634128, "pattern_frame_updates": 169500, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1807769665, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10665.307758112094, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 2670, "avg_candidate_generations": 157.05882352941177, "candidate_moves_total": 215657, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.77041198501873, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1261, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 2653, "search_candidate_moves_total": 214396, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 5112, "avg_legality_checks": 300.70588235294116, "illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 5112, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 563079, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 33122.294117647056, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1286442742, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2284.6576448420205, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4689, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 275.8235294117647, "renju_forbidden_ns": 34594281, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7377.752399232246, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 8, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 76031, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4648, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 34194979, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 7, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 86340, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 236931, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 46, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2.7058823529411766, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 297551, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6468.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 56, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3.2941176470588234, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 85471, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1526.267857142857, "stage_move_gen_ns": 13946330, "stage_ordering_ns": 89452, "stage_eval_ns": 1809545011, "stage_threat_ns": 1269348221, "stage_proof_ns": 82865378, "tactical_annotations": 0, "root_tactical_annotations": 0, "search_tactical_annotations": 0, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 171907, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1034506090, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 67248, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 77594922, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 697, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 26223478, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 85945, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 119744733, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2390, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16111876, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 171890, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21390600, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 0, "child_limit_applications": 0, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 0, "child_cap_hits": 0, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 0, "child_moves_before_total": 0, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 0, "child_moves_before_max": 0, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 0, "child_moves_after_total": 0, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 0, "child_moves_after_max": 0, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 0, "avg_child_moves_before": 0.0, "avg_child_moves_after": 0.0, "tt_hits": 81, "tt_cutoffs": 0, "beta_cutoffs": 2484, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_depth": 3, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 2.9411764705882355, "max_effective_depth": 3, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6737.941176470588, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7208.529411764706, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1986, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1729, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19582, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 83, 128, 67, 127, 99, 115, 82, 52, 81, 143, 158, 84, 95, 53, 125, 111, 80, 79, 110, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 13102, "avg_search_time_ms": 1191.090909090909, "search_nodes": 116727, "safety_nodes": 146, "corridor_nodes": 5957, "corridor_branch_probes": 6611, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2593, "corridor_neutral_exits": 46, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 5907, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5907, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 99, "corridor_proof_active": 50, "corridor_proof_quiet": 49, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 46, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2593, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 99, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 97, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 819, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26122480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1983200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 122830, "avg_nodes": 11166.363636363636, "eval_calls": 87525, "avg_eval_calls": 7956.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87525, "pattern_eval_ns": 1905728, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.77352756355327, "pattern_frame_queries": 87525, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1905728, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.77352756355327, "pattern_frame_updates": 233360, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3306786399, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14170.322244600617, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27184, "avg_candidate_generations": 2471.2727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 1968114, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.39972042377869, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 676, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 27173, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1967438, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 747965, "avg_legality_checks": 67996.81818181818, "illegal_moves_skipped": 834, "root_legality_checks": 676, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 747289, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 834, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3681231, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 334657.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8139015993, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2210.94954187879, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31014, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2819.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 177611392, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5726.813439092023, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 946, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8390766, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16168, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 128529641, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12861, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 34639564, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1039, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6051421, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 103152, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9377.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 957700622, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9284.363095238095, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137310, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12482.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 421365429, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3068.7162551889883, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1884397107, "stage_ordering_ns": 833052136, "stage_eval_ns": 3308692127, "stage_threat_ns": 6181163505, "stage_proof_ns": 856357321, "tactical_annotations": 477572, "root_tactical_annotations": 2332, "search_tactical_annotations": 475240, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 245383, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1575152626, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 770393, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4298372166, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 57455, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2260296527, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 122686, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 190512506, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12012, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 72461909, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 245372, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31728305, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 142239, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 199204307, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 224009, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 964957133, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 111324, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12935993, "child_limit_applications": 27173, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27173, "child_cap_hits": 27173, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27173, "child_moves_before_total": 1966604, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1966604, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 435446, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 435446, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.37345894822066, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02495123836161, "tt_hits": 11812, "tt_cutoffs": 1982, "beta_cutoffs": 21499, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3409.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4137.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 647, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6468, "avg_search_time_ms": 646.8, "search_nodes": 49065, "safety_nodes": 948, "corridor_nodes": 241, "corridor_branch_probes": 292, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 74, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_plies_followed": 236, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 236, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 8, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 74, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 12, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 32, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6045280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2003760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 50254, "avg_nodes": 5025.4, "eval_calls": 29295, "avg_eval_calls": 2929.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 29295, "pattern_eval_ns": 646243, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.05983956306537, "pattern_frame_queries": 29295, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 646243, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.05983956306537, "pattern_frame_updates": 98020, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1102442035, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11247.113191185472, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17541, "avg_candidate_generations": 1754.1, "candidate_moves_total": 1226122, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.90034775668434, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 622, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 17531, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1225500, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 763375, "avg_legality_checks": 76337.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 591, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 763375, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 591, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1934840, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 193484.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4196111065, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2168.712175166939, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14907, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1490.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 43367242, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2909.1864224860806, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 602, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5958235, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3711, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 26138717, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10594, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11270290, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68987, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6898.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 641662417, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9301.207720295128, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92983, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9298.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 285397054, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3069.346590236925, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1884318970, "stage_ordering_ns": 521864645, "stage_eval_ns": 1103088278, "stage_threat_ns": 2898227630, "stage_proof_ns": 21665048, "tactical_annotations": 270306, "root_tactical_annotations": 395, "search_tactical_annotations": 269911, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 98528, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 616447492, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 255647, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2184257713, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35280, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1280893477, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 49259, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 75531971, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 498, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2646071, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 98518, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12758119, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32842, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 143950312, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 170387, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 744988471, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 67077, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6586264, "child_limit_applications": 17531, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17531, "child_cap_hits": 17531, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17531, "child_moves_before_total": 1224909, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1224909, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 182241, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 182241, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.87102846386401, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.395356796531859, "tt_hits": 8884, "tt_cutoffs": 2185, "beta_cutoffs": 14240, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4365.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5165.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1730, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27572, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 0, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 5, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 97, 98, 82, 127, 83, 155, 67, 52, 99, 51, 81, 84, 53, 141, 169, 39, 69, 55, 37, 85, 80, 79, 96, 64, 125, 111, 95, 109, 110, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 24190, "avg_search_time_ms": 1612.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 247080, "safety_nodes": 778, "corridor_nodes": 2932, "corridor_branch_probes": 3246, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1284, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2910, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2910, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1284, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 429, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 41679920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2026960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 250790, "avg_nodes": 16719.333333333332, "eval_calls": 174881, "avg_eval_calls": 11658.733333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 174881, "pattern_eval_ns": 3604574, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.611581589766757, "pattern_frame_queries": 174881, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3604574, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.611581589766757, "pattern_frame_updates": 494010, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6739635663, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13642.711003825834, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 68423, "avg_candidate_generations": 4561.533333333334, "candidate_moves_total": 6111419, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.31819709746722, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1165, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 68408, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6110254, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1637087, "avg_legality_checks": 109139.13333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3116, "root_legality_checks": 1165, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1635922, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3113, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6757707, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 450513.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14179431760, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2098.260809472799, "renju_forbidden_checks": 60751, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4050.0666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 317059670, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5219.003308587513, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3755, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 30274876, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34254, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 213146518, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22395, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 70339793, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 347, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3298483, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 178076, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11871.733333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1398750787, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7854.796755317954, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 221774, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14784.933333333332, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 540952522, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2439.206227961799, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3808447664, "stage_ordering_ns": 2325479956, "stage_eval_ns": 6743240237, "stage_threat_ns": 10835675309, "stage_proof_ns": 409569393, "tactical_annotations": 1328876, "root_tactical_annotations": 4093, "search_tactical_annotations": 1324783, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 499957, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2943542821, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1359592, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7393185621, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 138432, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4703809509, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 249971, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 363736662, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5932, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 34084791, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 499942, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 62770877, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 370280, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 413715354, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 681301, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1858174580, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 277295, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 38354537, "child_limit_applications": 68408, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 68408, "child_cap_hits": 68408, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 68408, "child_moves_before_total": 6107141, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6107141, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 729558, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 729558, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.27524558531167, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.66480528593147, "tt_hits": 31028, "tt_cutoffs": 3717, "beta_cutoffs": 53092, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2319.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2711.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 3370, "avg_search_time_ms": 240.71428571428572, "search_nodes": 32596, "safety_nodes": 1641, "corridor_nodes": 282, "corridor_branch_probes": 335, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 102, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 272, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 272, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 102, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 41, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 184, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 70480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 5040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34519, "avg_nodes": 2465.6428571428573, "eval_calls": 22196, "avg_eval_calls": 1585.4285714285713, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22196, "pattern_eval_ns": 462782, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.849792755451432, "pattern_frame_queries": 22196, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 462782, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.849792755451432, "pattern_frame_updates": 65062, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 676368652, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10395.755617718483, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9851, "avg_candidate_generations": 703.6428571428571, "candidate_moves_total": 795303, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.73322505329408, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1092, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 9837, "search_candidate_moves_total": 794211, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 314931, "avg_legality_checks": 22495.071428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 372, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 314931, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 372, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 984542, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 70324.42857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2026082405, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2057.893319939627, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5148, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 367.7142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 25623256, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4977.322455322455, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 422, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3832166, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1976, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14569127, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2719, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6916172, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 31, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 305791, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 31145, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2224.6428571428573, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 271750209, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8725.32377588698, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41038, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2931.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 118187075, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2879.942370485891, "stage_move_gen_ns": 736948117, "stage_ordering_ns": 313206375, "stage_eval_ns": 676831434, "stage_threat_ns": 1543208191, "stage_proof_ns": 68535286, "tactical_annotations": 176073, "root_tactical_annotations": 331, "search_tactical_annotations": 175742, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 65702, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 394452850, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 187960, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1088345839, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20055, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 662552677, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 32844, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 46550212, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 626, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4020034, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 65688, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 7969621, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44020, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 109969533, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 107228, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 304678070, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 24825, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1869635, "child_limit_applications": 9837, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9837, "child_cap_hits": 9837, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9837, "child_moves_before_total": 793839, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 793839, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 158867, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 158867, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.69929856663617, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.14994408864491, "tt_hits": 2930, "tt_cutoffs": 498, "beta_cutoffs": 8389, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6291.142857142857, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6862.571428571428, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1845, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1731, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19845, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 129, 96, 141, 110, 109, 142, 158, 82, 130, 131, 124, 84, 98, 81, 66, 83, 80, 85 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 11142, "avg_search_time_ms": 1012.9090909090909, "search_nodes": 100524, "safety_nodes": 151, "corridor_nodes": 7279, "corridor_branch_probes": 8055, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3441, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 7234, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 7234, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 99, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3441, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 99, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 97, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 819, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24181120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 107954, "avg_nodes": 9814.0, "eval_calls": 75116, "avg_eval_calls": 6828.727272727273, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75116, "pattern_eval_ns": 1581596, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.055381010703446, "pattern_frame_queries": 75116, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1581596, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.055381010703446, "pattern_frame_updates": 200954, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2846337009, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14164.12218219095, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23775, "avg_candidate_generations": 2161.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 1710890, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.96172450052576, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 661, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 23764, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1710229, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 589755, "avg_legality_checks": 53614.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 679, "root_legality_checks": 661, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 589094, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 679, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3396409, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 308764.45454545453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6904175812, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2032.7869264272942, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27164, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2469.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 155574094, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5727.215947577676, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 876, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6770583, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14973, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 114591969, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10403, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29034251, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 912, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5177291, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 85127, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7738.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 741891561, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8715.114605236882, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 113447, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10313.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 335793504, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2959.915237952524, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1379808718, "stage_ordering_ns": 679519294, "stage_eval_ns": 2847918605, "stage_threat_ns": 5347149343, "stage_proof_ns": 852322056, "tactical_annotations": 447141, "root_tactical_annotations": 2232, "search_tactical_annotations": 444909, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 215631, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1315759443, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 781760, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3753999437, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50988, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1942656198, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 107810, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 157255425, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 14666, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 80072991, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 215620, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26465040, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 134007, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 132059506, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 201042, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 721266053, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 112092, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13597007, "child_limit_applications": 23764, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23764, "child_cap_hits": 23764, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23764, "child_moves_before_total": 1709550, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1709550, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 381442, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 381442, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.93864669247601, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.051253997643496, "tt_hits": 10891, "tt_cutoffs": 1597, "beta_cutoffs": 18859, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4221.272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4948.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1168, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8691, "avg_search_time_ms": 869.1, "search_nodes": 74235, "safety_nodes": 904, "corridor_nodes": 721, "corridor_branch_probes": 880, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 279, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 30, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 25, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 279, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 30, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 166, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 10019920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 75860, "avg_nodes": 7586.0, "eval_calls": 44758, "avg_eval_calls": 4475.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44758, "pattern_eval_ns": 968033, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.628155860404842, "pattern_frame_queries": 44758, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 968033, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.628155860404842, "pattern_frame_updates": 148358, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1768273905, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11918.965643915393, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25579, "avg_candidate_generations": 2557.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1777776, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.50138785722663, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 603, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 25569, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1777173, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 793010, "avg_legality_checks": 79301.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 469, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 793010, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 469, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2490688, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 249068.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5334577838, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2141.808945158928, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14332, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1433.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 48164624, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3360.6352218811053, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 473, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4372524, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4377, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29229664, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9482, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14562436, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 79326, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7932.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 708561748, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8932.27627763911, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 106489, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10648.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 299350817, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2811.0961413854952, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1944190709, "stage_ordering_ns": 761652392, "stage_eval_ns": 1769241938, "stage_threat_ns": 4128765818, "stage_proof_ns": 44448358, "tactical_annotations": 436994, "root_tactical_annotations": 418, "search_tactical_annotations": 436576, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 149860, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 913956684, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 443452, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3067407955, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51589, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1920003734, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74925, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 110520272, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1492, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6558640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 149850, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19314547, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52768, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 140504472, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 293407, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 977369891, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 90819, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11007720, "child_limit_applications": 25569, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25569, "child_cap_hits": 25569, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25569, "child_moves_before_total": 1776704, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1776704, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 278956, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 278956, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.4866439829481, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.909929993351325, "tt_hits": 11368, "tt_cutoffs": 3852, "beta_cutoffs": 20705, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 5.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3491.3, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4291.3, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 87, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1732, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17907, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 1, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 6, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 113, 128, 111, 114, 126, 100, 110, 109, 142, 94, 96, 141, 124, 138, 84, 98, 82, 68, 81, 66, 83, 80, 85 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 15279, "avg_search_time_ms": 1389.0, "search_nodes": 132347, "safety_nodes": 282, "corridor_nodes": 6019, "corridor_branch_probes": 6377, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2825, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 5991, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5991, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 58, "corridor_proof_active": 28, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2825, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 58, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 428, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 39703680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 138648, "avg_nodes": 12604.363636363636, "eval_calls": 86740, "avg_eval_calls": 7885.454545454545, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 86740, "pattern_eval_ns": 1880667, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.6816578279917, "pattern_frame_queries": 86740, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1880667, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.6816578279917, "pattern_frame_updates": 264580, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3617298001, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13671.849727870587, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42783, "avg_candidate_generations": 3889.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 3573066, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.5160227193044, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 687, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 42772, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3572379, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 941328, "avg_legality_checks": 85575.27272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 849, "root_legality_checks": 687, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 940641, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 848, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4376455, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 397859.54545454547, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9348165412, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2136.013145799511, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23114, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2101.2727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 138825203, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6006.108981569611, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 911, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8913707, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12294, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 94396695, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9473, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32787172, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 436, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2727629, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93425, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8493.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 820220792, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8779.45723307466, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 123500, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11227.272727272728, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 360662589, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2920.3448502024294, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2213197696, "stage_ordering_ns": 1408713449, "stage_eval_ns": 3619178668, "stage_threat_ns": 7262498147, "stage_proof_ns": 726953093, "tactical_annotations": 675893, "root_tactical_annotations": 2553, "search_tactical_annotations": 673340, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 276689, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1705590756, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 849493, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5207265532, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 88661, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3313687680, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 138339, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 208962429, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12098, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 75511464, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 276678, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34864030, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 187208, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 181039802, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 248326, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 866302042, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 240359, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30303936, "child_limit_applications": 42772, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42772, "child_cap_hits": 42772, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42772, "child_moves_before_total": 3571531, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3571531, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 396938, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 396938, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.50161320490041, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.280323576171327, "tt_hits": 26133, "tt_cutoffs": 2778, "beta_cutoffs": 33833, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 5.181818181818182, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 5.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2179.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2794.909090909091, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 716, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2617, "avg_search_time_ms": 261.7, "search_nodes": 24152, "safety_nodes": 874, "corridor_nodes": 78, "corridor_branch_probes": 79, "corridor_max_depth": 5, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 23, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 67, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 67, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 26, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 186, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 85280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 25104, "avg_nodes": 2510.4, "eval_calls": 16815, "avg_eval_calls": 1681.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 16815, "pattern_eval_ns": 374013, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.242818911685994, "pattern_frame_queries": 16815, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 374013, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.242818911685994, "pattern_frame_updates": 48214, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 538209239, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11162.924441033725, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6937, "avg_candidate_generations": 693.7, "candidate_moves_total": 507920, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.21897073662967, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 625, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 6927, "search_candidate_moves_total": 507295, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 217329, "avg_legality_checks": 21732.9, "illegal_moves_skipped": 74, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 217329, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 74, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 706526, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 70652.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1595857728, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2258.7388546210614, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2808, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 280.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 11913222, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4242.600427350428, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 82, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 786124, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 971, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7545764, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1750, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3526734, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 54600, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 20052, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2005.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 203956551, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10171.381956912028, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27936, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2793.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 95446839, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3416.6251073883163, "stage_move_gen_ns": 559322368, "stage_ordering_ns": 225174557, "stage_eval_ns": 538583252, "stage_threat_ns": 1204311091, "stage_proof_ns": 66982072, "tactical_annotations": 101433, "root_tactical_annotations": 311, "search_tactical_annotations": 101122, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 48432, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 312939982, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 106001, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 845003225, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14115, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 552277365, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 24211, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 37049209, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 208, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1073415, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 48422, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6566409, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 26860, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 87264468, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 56860, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 200020870, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 17713, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1678851, "child_limit_applications": 6927, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6927, "child_cap_hits": 6927, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6927, "child_moves_before_total": 507221, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 507221, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 110866, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 110866, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.22376209037101, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.004908329724266, "tt_hits": 2361, "tt_cutoffs": 365, "beta_cutoffs": 5820, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5584.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6384.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1828, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1733, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 37893, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 109, 95, 98, 63, 127, 99, 125, 114, 113, 129, 144, 79, 47, 65, 128, 143, 126, 124, 93, 80, 50, 77, 78, 157, 171, 64, 68, 83, 66, 115, 101, 131, 67, 147 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 16196, "avg_search_time_ms": 899.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 196644, "safety_nodes": 753, "corridor_nodes": 5460, "corridor_branch_probes": 6121, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2130, "corridor_neutral_exits": 172, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 5399, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5399, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 179, "corridor_proof_active": 61, "corridor_proof_quiet": 118, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 172, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2130, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 179, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 177, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1415, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 48371520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 202857, "avg_nodes": 11269.833333333334, "eval_calls": 150817, "avg_eval_calls": 8378.722222222223, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 150817, "pattern_eval_ns": 3212227, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.2988389902995, "pattern_frame_queries": 150817, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3212227, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.2988389902995, "pattern_frame_updates": 393124, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3892740610, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9902.06807521291, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43505, "avg_candidate_generations": 2416.9444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 3562248, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.88134697161246, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1349, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 43487, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3560899, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1247573, "avg_legality_checks": 69309.61111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1214, "root_legality_checks": 1349, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 1246224, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1210, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4968669, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 276037.1666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9561970260, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1924.4530597630874, "renju_forbidden_checks": 43023, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2390.1666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 143506008, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3335.5648838993097, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1924, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11713463, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20147, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 88629171, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19254, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 35754680, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1698, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7408694, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 125742, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6985.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1010380552, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8035.346598590765, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 167775, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9320.833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 443100091, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2641.037645656385, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2713903817, "stage_ordering_ns": 1236016090, "stage_eval_ns": 3895952837, "stage_threat_ns": 7392092490, "stage_proof_ns": 880449131, "tactical_annotations": 698539, "root_tactical_annotations": 3818, "search_tactical_annotations": 694721, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 404298, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2134535138, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 955390, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4849902811, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90443, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2761490592, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 202140, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 271826965, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 11156, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 73530807, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 404280, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 44805974, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 223515, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 250667386, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 314254, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1066423506, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 160770, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17490795, "child_limit_applications": 43487, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43487, "child_cap_hits": 43487, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43487, "child_moves_before_total": 3559689, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3559689, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 696103, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 696103, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.85639386483317, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00715156253593, "tt_hits": 18532, "tt_cutoffs": 2258, "beta_cutoffs": 33627, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5394.222222222223, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5838.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1217, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 21681, "avg_search_time_ms": 1275.3529411764705, "search_nodes": 165796, "safety_nodes": 1432, "corridor_nodes": 1406, "corridor_branch_probes": 1674, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 9, "corridor_depth_exits": 456, "corridor_neutral_exits": 73, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1386, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1386, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 73, "corridor_proof_active": 20, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 82, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 456, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 73, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 72, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 475, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6137600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 168634, "avg_nodes": 9919.64705882353, "eval_calls": 99220, "avg_eval_calls": 5836.470588235294, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 99220, "pattern_eval_ns": 2186046, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.03231203386414, "pattern_frame_queries": 99220, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2186046, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.03231203386414, "pattern_frame_updates": 331382, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3277133524, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9889.292490237853, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 62147, "avg_candidate_generations": 3655.705882352941, "candidate_moves_total": 5142714, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.75080052134456, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1279, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 62130, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5141435, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 3120238, "avg_legality_checks": 183543.41176470587, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2051, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3120238, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2051, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7216507, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 424500.4117647059, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14077656643, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1950.7577063252347, "renju_forbidden_checks": 40828, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2401.6470588235293, "renju_forbidden_ns": 115304475, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2824.1519300480063, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2603, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18706649, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10712, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 61026105, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 27487, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 35388590, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 183131, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 264999, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15588.176470588236, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2283312761, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8616.307084177675, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 360111, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21183.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1066220684, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2960.8112054338803, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6959019437, "stage_ordering_ns": 1907745664, "stage_eval_ns": 3279319570, "stage_threat_ns": 9305762971, "stage_proof_ns": 100117380, "tactical_annotations": 1017049, "root_tactical_annotations": 2618, "search_tactical_annotations": 1014431, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 334317, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1958412979, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 976666, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7010696753, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 125395, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3916046134, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 167150, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 246105449, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2918, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18514888, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 334300, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41314317, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 223630, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1026023601, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 534599, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1995750636, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 258820, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30718585, "child_limit_applications": 62130, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 62130, "child_cap_hits": 62130, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 62130, "child_moves_before_total": 5139384, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5139384, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 632669, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 632669, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.71984548527281, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.182987284725575, "tt_hits": 28987, "tt_cutoffs": 4343, "beta_cutoffs": 50589, "depth_sum": 103, "avg_depth": 6.0588235294117645, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 103, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0588235294117645, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.29411764705882354, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3475.529411764706, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3946.1176470588234, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1734, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17389, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 2, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 7, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 111, 96, 110, 113, 95, 145, 109, 108, 81, 123, 125, 80, 93, 129, 161, 77, 79, 63, 65, 107, 94, 124, 126, 142, 140, 155, 98, 84, 154 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 14679, "avg_search_time_ms": 1048.5, "search_nodes": 211411, "safety_nodes": 592, "corridor_nodes": 3043, "corridor_branch_probes": 3384, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1345, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 3021, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3021, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1345, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 429, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 41758480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2026960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 215046, "avg_nodes": 15360.42857142857, "eval_calls": 156131, "avg_eval_calls": 11152.214285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 156131, "pattern_eval_ns": 3102967, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.874124933549393, "pattern_frame_queries": 156131, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3102967, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.874124933549393, "pattern_frame_updates": 422686, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4245980071, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10045.234691946267, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52204, "avg_candidate_generations": 3728.8571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 4506474, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.3243046509846, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1052, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 52190, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4505422, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 1466509, "avg_legality_checks": 104750.64285714286, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1215, "root_legality_checks": 1052, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1465457, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1215, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5886239, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 420445.64285714284, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8625624038, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1465.3880071808162, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41442, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2960.1428571428573, "renju_forbidden_ns": 120912531, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2917.6326190820905, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1758, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7061791, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 22456, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 82851243, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16924, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29290509, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 304, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1708988, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 170876, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12205.42857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 897689650, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5253.45660010768, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 213854, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15275.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 343356602, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1605.5654886043749, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2405016951, "stage_ordering_ns": 1280875330, "stage_eval_ns": 4249083038, "stage_threat_ns": 6403982347, "stage_proof_ns": 260951361, "tactical_annotations": 921912, "root_tactical_annotations": 3769, "search_tactical_annotations": 918143, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 428854, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1832278818, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 950798, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4240167928, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 106012, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2721976495, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 214420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 240013262, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6154, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22480349, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 428840, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40218495, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 293687, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 258818874, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 376359, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1000503684, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 251866, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28823495, "child_limit_applications": 52190, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52190, "child_cap_hits": 52190, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52190, "child_moves_before_total": 4504207, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4504207, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 538925, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 538925, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.30402375934086, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.326211917991952, "tt_hits": 27367, "tt_cutoffs": 3022, "beta_cutoffs": 38569, "depth_sum": 68, "avg_depth": 4.857142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 68, "avg_effective_depth": 4.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5397.428571428572, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5968.857142857143, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1816, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 2697, "avg_search_time_ms": 207.46153846153845, "search_nodes": 33390, "safety_nodes": 1601, "corridor_nodes": 58, "corridor_branch_probes": 60, "corridor_max_depth": 5, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 49, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 49, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 41, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 185, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 73520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 5520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35049, "avg_nodes": 2696.076923076923, "eval_calls": 22806, "avg_eval_calls": 1754.3076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22806, "pattern_eval_ns": 464561, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.370121897746206, "pattern_frame_queries": 22806, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 464561, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.370121897746206, "pattern_frame_updates": 66660, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 543514579, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8153.53403840384, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10098, "avg_candidate_generations": 776.7692307692307, "candidate_moves_total": 819340, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.1388393741335, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 973, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 10085, "search_candidate_moves_total": 818367, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 319366, "avg_legality_checks": 24566.615384615383, "illegal_moves_skipped": 98, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 319366, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 98, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1009767, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 77674.38461538461, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1610620380, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1595.0416086087187, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4001, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 307.7692307692308, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12622785, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3154.90752311922, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 98, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 506251, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1492, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 8617686, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2411, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3498848, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 33251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2557.769230769231, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 216812994, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6520.495443746053, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 43290, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3330.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 94895473, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2192.0876183876185, "stage_move_gen_ns": 589486935, "stage_ordering_ns": 242233320, "stage_eval_ns": 543979140, "stage_threat_ns": 1235291362, "stage_proof_ns": 61993800, "tactical_annotations": 176300, "root_tactical_annotations": 331, "search_tactical_annotations": 175969, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 66853, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 313498014, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 178784, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 872872960, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20454, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 544502949, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 33420, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 39272951, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 180, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 791181, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 66840, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6680257, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 43299, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 87003057, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 108903, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 237577981, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 24098, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2175999, "child_limit_applications": 10085, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10085, "child_cap_hits": 10085, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10085, "child_moves_before_total": 818269, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 818269, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 162835, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 162835, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.13723351512147, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.146256817055033, "tt_hits": 2779, "tt_cutoffs": 439, "beta_cutoffs": 8598, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6169.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6784.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1901, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1735, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 33115, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 101, 100, 128, 130, 115, 129, 126, 144, 99, 116, 125, 124, 158, 84, 132, 97, 145, 81, 65, 52, 68, 82, 67, 83, 80, 85 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 19549, "avg_search_time_ms": 1303.2666666666667, "search_nodes": 253385, "safety_nodes": 324, "corridor_nodes": 9100, "corridor_branch_probes": 9649, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3843, "corridor_neutral_exits": 109, "corridor_terminal_exits": 26, "corridor_plies_followed": 9049, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9049, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 150, "corridor_proof_active": 51, "corridor_proof_quiet": 99, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 109, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3843, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 26, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 150, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 147, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1233, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 49897440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1979360, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 262809, "avg_nodes": 17520.6, "eval_calls": 203818, "avg_eval_calls": 13587.866666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 203818, "pattern_eval_ns": 4087685, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.055564277934234, "pattern_frame_queries": 203818, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4087685, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.055564277934234, "pattern_frame_updates": 506636, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5378533771, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10616.169737247254, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46873, "avg_candidate_generations": 3124.866666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 3734802, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.67917564482751, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1014, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 46858, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3733788, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1466105, "avg_legality_checks": 97740.33333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3431, "root_legality_checks": 1014, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 1465091, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3427, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6353150, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 423543.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11618442498, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1828.7687994144637, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47578, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3171.866666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 208325009, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4378.599541805036, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3899, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 29785981, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 23908, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 123474397, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17596, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 40545279, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2175, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 14519352, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 149925, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9995.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1021588663, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6813.998085709522, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 187242, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12482.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 415038955, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2216.5911227181937, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2907283116, "stage_ordering_ns": 1284752720, "stage_eval_ns": 5382621456, "stage_threat_ns": 8701752434, "stage_proof_ns": 1189427233, "tactical_annotations": 836384, "root_tactical_annotations": 3873, "search_tactical_annotations": 832511, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 525049, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2591942864, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1265966, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5582534250, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 99039, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2997929792, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 262517, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 333002092, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 18398, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 116213857, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 525034, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 55409641, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 243076, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 225350283, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 404459, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1174433782, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 188849, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22649730, "child_limit_applications": 46858, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46858, "child_cap_hits": 46858, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46858, "child_moves_before_total": 3730361, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3730361, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 751073, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 751073, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.60990652610013, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02870374322421, "tt_hits": 19256, "tt_cutoffs": 2642, "beta_cutoffs": 33501, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4945.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5479.133333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1417, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 13550, "avg_search_time_ms": 967.8571428571429, "search_nodes": 116536, "safety_nodes": 1075, "corridor_nodes": 508, "corridor_branch_probes": 607, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 5, "corridor_depth_exits": 184, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 501, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 501, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 78, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 71, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 184, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 78, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 77, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 573, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 54536480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2022240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 118119, "avg_nodes": 8437.07142857143, "eval_calls": 68503, "avg_eval_calls": 4893.071428571428, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 68503, "pattern_eval_ns": 1464214, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.374450753981577, "pattern_frame_queries": 68503, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1464214, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.374450753981577, "pattern_frame_updates": 232906, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2279301769, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9786.359170652539, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43911, "avg_candidate_generations": 3136.5, "candidate_moves_total": 3274594, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.57343262508256, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 944, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 43897, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3273650, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 1940610, "avg_legality_checks": 138615.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3921, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1940610, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3921, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4565398, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 326099.85714285716, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8658337589, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1896.5132041061918, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31941, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2281.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 121087992, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3790.989386681694, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4062, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 38661783, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8276, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 53268498, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19563, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28729268, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 428443, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 122502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8750.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 972749993, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7940.686625524481, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 165474, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11819.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 423399777, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2558.708782044309, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4149119584, "stage_ordering_ns": 1201212091, "stage_eval_ns": 2280765983, "stage_threat_ns": 5726401597, "stage_proof_ns": 107610775, "tactical_annotations": 774236, "root_tactical_annotations": 1686, "search_tactical_annotations": 772550, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 234078, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1232879199, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 660836, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4271403346, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 88447, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2734764904, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 117032, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159871589, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1158, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6747507, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 234064, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27126231, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 139703, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 283503598, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 400308, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1226271718, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 234225, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28373725, "child_limit_applications": 43897, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43897, "child_cap_hits": 43897, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43897, "child_moves_before_total": 3269729, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3269729, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 425426, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 425426, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.4863885914755, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.691459553044627, "tt_hits": 22838, "tt_cutoffs": 4053, "beta_cutoffs": 35557, "depth_sum": 83, "avg_depth": 5.928571428571429, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 83, "avg_effective_depth": 5.928571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4225.714285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4797.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1554, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1736, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 11529, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 3, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 8, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 114, 98, 113, 111, 143, 95, 99, 94, 129, 79, 63, 96, 97, 93, 92, 81, 144, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7164, "avg_search_time_ms": 796.0, "search_nodes": 67804, "safety_nodes": 428, "corridor_nodes": 103, "corridor_branch_probes": 130, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 99, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 99, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 35, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 35, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 32, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 275, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 236400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 68335, "avg_nodes": 7592.777777777777, "eval_calls": 41038, "avg_eval_calls": 4559.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41038, "pattern_eval_ns": 859913, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.954066962327598, "pattern_frame_queries": 41038, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 859913, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.954066962327598, "pattern_frame_updates": 135522, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1441594783, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10637.348792078039, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25166, "avg_candidate_generations": 2796.222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 1889524, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.08241277914647, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 554, "root_candidate_moves_max": 77, "search_candidate_generations": 25157, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1888970, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 595771, "avg_legality_checks": 66196.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 590, "root_legality_checks": 554, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 595217, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 590, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1971009, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 219001.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4332125827, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2197.922904968978, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14565, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1618.3333333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66089509, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4537.556402334363, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 635, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6438220, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4651, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37815364, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9221, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21744945, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 58, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 90980, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 44526, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4947.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 390206927, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8763.5746979293, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 61710, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6856.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 159018559, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2576.868562631664, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1452751374, "stage_ordering_ns": 789835065, "stage_eval_ns": 1442454696, "stage_threat_ns": 3367501515, "stage_proof_ns": 77384113, "tactical_annotations": 239941, "root_tactical_annotations": 1337, "search_tactical_annotations": 238604, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 135799, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 792829359, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 219876, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2448218119, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50555, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1859018286, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67895, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 97502113, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 268, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1274124, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 135790, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16565720, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 31393, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 63981448, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 129076, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 505393998, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79472, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11112080, "child_limit_applications": 25157, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25157, "child_cap_hits": 25157, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25157, "child_moves_before_total": 1888380, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1888380, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 214149, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 214149, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.0637993401439, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.512501490638789, "tt_hits": 13299, "tt_cutoffs": 1566, "beta_cutoffs": 19800, "depth_sum": 43, "avg_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 43, "avg_effective_depth": 4.777777777777778, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3113.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4001.8888888888887, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 892, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 4358, "avg_search_time_ms": 544.75, "search_nodes": 40863, "safety_nodes": 687, "corridor_nodes": 1392, "corridor_branch_probes": 1710, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 11, "corridor_depth_exits": 613, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 1380, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1365, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 15, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 50, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 613, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 50, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 3, "corridor_proof_unknown": 47, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 327, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 8127680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 42942, "avg_nodes": 5367.75, "eval_calls": 28575, "avg_eval_calls": 3571.875, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 28575, "pattern_eval_ns": 594762, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.814068241469815, "pattern_frame_queries": 28575, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 594762, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.814068241469815, "pattern_frame_updates": 81656, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 724166141, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8868.498836582738, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 11804, "avg_candidate_generations": 1475.5, "candidate_moves_total": 846160, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.68417485598103, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 492, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 11796, "search_candidate_moves_total": 845668, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 481351, "avg_legality_checks": 60168.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1383, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 481351, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1383, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1238176, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 154772.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2670538563, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2156.832762870545, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7313, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 914.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 40133962, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5488.029809927526, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1383, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13880292, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1669, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16657432, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4237, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9572688, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 23550, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 34374, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4296.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 302398773, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8797.311136323966, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 46689, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5836.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 128391024, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2749.92019533509, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1183728365, "stage_ordering_ns": 358561956, "stage_eval_ns": 724760903, "stage_threat_ns": 1984833867, "stage_proof_ns": 76947283, "tactical_annotations": 144563, "root_tactical_annotations": 628, "search_tactical_annotations": 143935, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 84524, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 507301826, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 217182, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1385351442, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 24339, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 901014672, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 42258, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 61824943, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2860, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 16089976, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 84516, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10201277, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 29269, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 73354472, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 85504, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 349471191, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 29790, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4064403, "child_limit_applications": 11796, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 11796, "child_cap_hits": 11796, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 11796, "child_moves_before_total": 844285, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 844285, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 188803, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 188803, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.57383858935232, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00567989148864, "tt_hits": 3610, "tt_cutoffs": 457, "beta_cutoffs": 9956, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 4.375, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 4.375, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4064.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5064.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1860, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1737, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29194, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 97, 127, 126, 143, 159, 158, 113, 95, 79, 173, 188, 129, 98, 140, 101, 157, 115, 185, 171, 125, 70, 84, 100, 99, 85, 130, 55 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 9029, "avg_search_time_ms": 644.9285714285714, "search_nodes": 88212, "safety_nodes": 1250, "corridor_nodes": 367, "corridor_branch_probes": 414, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 129, "corridor_neutral_exits": 11, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 355, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 355, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 52, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 129, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 62, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 447, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 252400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 17520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 89829, "avg_nodes": 6416.357142857143, "eval_calls": 63453, "avg_eval_calls": 4532.357142857143, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 63453, "pattern_eval_ns": 1378713, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.72809796227129, "pattern_frame_queries": 63453, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1378713, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.72809796227129, "pattern_frame_updates": 176300, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2204162236, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12502.338264322178, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23102, "avg_candidate_generations": 1650.142857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 1807485, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.23932992814476, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1035, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 23088, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1806450, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 768373, "avg_legality_checks": 54883.78571428572, "illegal_moves_skipped": 205, "root_legality_checks": 1035, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 767338, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 205, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2386920, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 170494.2857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5549259820, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2324.86209005748, "renju_forbidden_checks": 9536, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 681.1428571428571, "renju_forbidden_ns": 33406011, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3503.147126677852, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 253, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2424553, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3621, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 22835217, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5628, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 8068800, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 34, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 77441, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 52944, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3781.714285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 480042730, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9066.990216077365, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72954, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5211.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 194585724, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2667.2385886997286, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1952325789, "stage_ordering_ns": 787949730, "stage_eval_ns": 2205540949, "stage_threat_ns": 3875484181, "stage_proof_ns": 161658025, "tactical_annotations": 288597, "root_tactical_annotations": 1374, "search_tactical_annotations": 287223, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 177152, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1094800645, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 305317, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2612397824, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46695, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1822644425, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 88569, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 132038413, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 838, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5673323, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 177138, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23018837, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 58878, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 63062571, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 176039, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 675887451, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 53680, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7555139, "child_limit_applications": 23088, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23088, "child_cap_hits": 23088, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23088, "child_moves_before_total": 1806245, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1806245, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 369415, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 369415, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.2330647955648, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000303187803187, "tt_hits": 7873, "tt_cutoffs": 1610, "beta_cutoffs": 18935, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 4.357142857142857, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 4.357142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5331.785714285715, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5903.214285714285, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 20151, "avg_search_time_ms": 1550.076923076923, "search_nodes": 124465, "safety_nodes": 535, "corridor_nodes": 161, "corridor_branch_probes": 195, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 3, "corridor_depth_exits": 62, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 159, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 159, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 7, "corridor_proof_active": 2, "corridor_proof_quiet": 5, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 62, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 7, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 7, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4078720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2011520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 125161, "avg_nodes": 9627.76923076923, "eval_calls": 74278, "avg_eval_calls": 5713.692307692308, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 74278, "pattern_eval_ns": 1658638, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.330138129728855, "pattern_frame_queries": 74278, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1658638, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.330138129728855, "pattern_frame_updates": 248790, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2776769100, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11161.096105148921, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 47176, "avg_candidate_generations": 3628.923076923077, "candidate_moves_total": 4103402, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.98071053077837, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 977, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 47163, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4102425, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 3085948, "avg_legality_checks": 237380.61538461538, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1000, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3085948, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1000, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6180960, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 475458.46153846156, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13681398324, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2213.4746583055057, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34211, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2631.6153846153848, "renju_forbidden_ns": 50858014, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1486.5982871006402, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1036, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10468020, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2341, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19647067, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 30834, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20742927, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 199802, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15369.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1902114249, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9519.99604108067, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 277288, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21329.846153846152, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 842934456, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3039.924035659675, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7592621725, "stage_ordering_ns": 1733536834, "stage_eval_ns": 2778427738, "stage_threat_ns": 7916423502, "stage_proof_ns": 11113535, "tactical_annotations": 903710, "root_tactical_annotations": 3438, "search_tactical_annotations": 900272, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 249135, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1543834306, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 826205, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6118107683, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 94509, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3383797259, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 124561, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 193193342, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 332, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2008410, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 249122, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32725387, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 185538, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 359374665, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 536447, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2367051265, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 181725, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26554374, "child_limit_applications": 47163, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 47163, "child_cap_hits": 47163, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 47163, "child_moves_before_total": 4101425, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4101425, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 425291, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 425291, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.96276742361597, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.01747132285902, "tt_hits": 18790, "tt_cutoffs": 2960, "beta_cutoffs": 37910, "depth_sum": 64, "avg_depth": 4.923076923076923, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 64, "avg_effective_depth": 4.923076923076923, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.46153846153846156, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.46153846153846156, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1459.4615384615386, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1913.6923076923076, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1738, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 53314, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 4, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 9, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 142, 128, 127, 97, 125, 173, 141, 113, 143, 140, 109, 93, 129, 171, 115, 101, 174, 159, 158, 126, 145, 144, 160, 100, 190, 206, 188, 98, 99, 146, 189, 83, 68, 187, 175, 205, 203, 161, 172, 157, 176, 114, 162, 82, 148, 130 ], "move_count": 48, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 40933, "avg_search_time_ms": 1860.590909090909, "search_nodes": 394851, "safety_nodes": 377, "corridor_nodes": 11056, "corridor_branch_probes": 11470, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 4, "corridor_depth_exits": 4496, "corridor_neutral_exits": 172, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 10991, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 10991, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 89, "corridor_proof_active": 65, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 176, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4496, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 89, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 88, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 2, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 688, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2389520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 8, "total_nodes": 406284, "avg_nodes": 18467.454545454544, "eval_calls": 239375, "avg_eval_calls": 10880.681818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 239375, "pattern_eval_ns": 5162088, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.564858485639686, "pattern_frame_queries": 239375, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 5162088, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.564858485639686, "pattern_frame_updates": 789436, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8220045259, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10412.554353994497, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 147367, "avg_candidate_generations": 6698.5, "candidate_moves_total": 14045551, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.31001513228878, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1821, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 147345, "search_candidate_moves_total": 14043730, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 3371747, "avg_legality_checks": 153261.22727272726, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8411, "root_legality_checks": 1821, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 5, "search_legality_checks": 3369926, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8406, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 11489885, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 522267.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23134090034, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2013.430946784933, "renju_forbidden_checks": 205267, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9330.318181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 410523365, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1999.948189431326, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22852, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 42733209, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 81277, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 204635144, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 97664, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 157745329, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3474, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5409683, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 238755, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10852.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1649114554, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6907.141437875646, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 299440, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13610.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 609264431, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2034.679505076142, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7669719020, "stage_ordering_ns": 5118551680, "stage_eval_ns": 8225207347, "stage_threat_ns": 18604104099, "stage_proof_ns": 1155225131, "tactical_annotations": 3412632, "root_tactical_annotations": 9117, "search_tactical_annotations": 3403515, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 811618, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4578256373, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3332366, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 13014607097, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 301331, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 8611425041, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 405798, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 597074481, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 22160, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 172641378, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 811596, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 98590162, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 1092193, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 500303403, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 1335016, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2916792845, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 985423, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 142934608, "child_limit_applications": 147345, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 147345, "child_cap_hits": 147345, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 147345, "child_moves_before_total": 14035324, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 14035324, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 1389711, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1389711, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.2548372866402, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.431680749261936, "tt_hits": 75818, "tt_cutoffs": 8003, "beta_cutoffs": 119725, "depth_sum": 127, "avg_depth": 5.7727272727272725, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 127, "avg_effective_depth": 5.7727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 8, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.45454545454545453, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 8, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 976.7272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1128.5454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 12357, "avg_search_time_ms": 561.6818181818181, "search_nodes": 112985, "safety_nodes": 2449, "corridor_nodes": 1343, "corridor_branch_probes": 1539, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 383, "corridor_neutral_exits": 15, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 1313, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 371, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 942, "corridor_proof_passes": 20, "corridor_proof_completed": 20, "corridor_proof_checks": 117, "corridor_proof_active": 30, "corridor_proof_quiet": 87, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 383, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 117, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 8, "corridor_proof_unknown": 108, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 696, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 16259040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 5, "total_nodes": 116777, "avg_nodes": 5308.045454545455, "eval_calls": 75424, "avg_eval_calls": 3428.3636363636365, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75424, "pattern_eval_ns": 1604196, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.269039032668648, "pattern_frame_queries": 75424, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1604196, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.269039032668648, "pattern_frame_updates": 225762, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1863488449, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8254.216604211515, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 35621, "avg_candidate_generations": 1619.1363636363637, "candidate_moves_total": 3105515, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.18213974902446, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1848, "root_candidate_moves_max": 102, "search_candidate_generations": 35599, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3103667, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 1770179, "avg_legality_checks": 80462.68181818182, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5073, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1770179, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5073, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4001951, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 181906.86363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7699270308, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1923.8792049178014, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47665, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2166.590909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 74786227, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1568.996685198783, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7977, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9897390, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13289, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 33980229, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25407, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28932040, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 992, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1976568, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 124412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5655.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 943153665, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7580.8898257402825, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 166547, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7570.318181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 396462383, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2380.483485142332, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3757040837, "stage_ordering_ns": 1144144896, "stage_eval_ns": 1865092645, "stage_threat_ns": 5228574853, "stage_proof_ns": 257684118, "tactical_annotations": 667892, "root_tactical_annotations": 2117, "search_tactical_annotations": 665775, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 228644, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1280767748, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 692435, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3721234366, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 72840, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2269130429, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 114311, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 161950247, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2860, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22304104, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 228622, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27366176, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 228465, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 400481651, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 326455, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 973381229, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 112972, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14952212, "child_limit_applications": 35599, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 35599, "child_cap_hits": 35599, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 35599, "child_moves_before_total": 3098594, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3098594, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 569927, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 569927, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.04160229219922, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00963510210961, "tt_hits": 12389, "tt_cutoffs": 1858, "beta_cutoffs": 30787, "depth_sum": 104, "avg_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 104, "avg_effective_depth": 4.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.045454545454545456, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6191.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6555.545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1031, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1739, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30034, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 129, 124, 127, 95, 96, 80, 143, 65, 115, 157, 159, 175, 144, 50, 35, 174, 145, 146, 128, 160, 131, 130, 173, 117, 187 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 15198, "avg_search_time_ms": 1085.5714285714287, "search_nodes": 165709, "safety_nodes": 551, "corridor_nodes": 8075, "corridor_branch_probes": 8141, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4550, "corridor_neutral_exits": 53, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 8049, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 8049, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 132, "corridor_proof_active": 26, "corridor_proof_quiet": 106, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 53, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4550, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 132, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 129, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1092, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26144640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 174335, "avg_nodes": 12452.5, "eval_calls": 125496, "avg_eval_calls": 8964.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 125496, "pattern_eval_ns": 2608442, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.785060878434372, "pattern_frame_queries": 125496, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2608442, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.785060878434372, "pattern_frame_updates": 331294, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3481907511, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10510.022852813514, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38489, "avg_candidate_generations": 2749.214285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 3200303, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.14850996388579, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1037, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 38475, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3199266, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 1031542, "avg_legality_checks": 73681.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 263, "root_legality_checks": 1037, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1030505, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 263, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4259829, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 304273.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9005056613, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2113.947910350392, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22769, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1626.357142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 71294030, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3131.1884579911284, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 538, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2375803, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9348, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 41690514, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10726, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20182730, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2157, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7044983, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99313, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7093.785714285715, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 750795641, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7559.892874044687, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 123897, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8849.785714285714, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 275585167, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2224.3086353987587, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2442093668, "stage_ordering_ns": 1259089886, "stage_eval_ns": 3484515953, "stage_threat_ns": 7120705292, "stage_proof_ns": 833977836, "tactical_annotations": 512156, "root_tactical_annotations": 3415, "search_tactical_annotations": 508741, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 347670, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2071009216, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 827907, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4640410303, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 80980, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2815230280, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 173828, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 249749238, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 16362, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 100973763, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 347656, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42106844, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 160381, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 181903154, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 235996, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 777985863, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 115779, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16455928, "child_limit_applications": 38475, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38475, "child_cap_hits": 38475, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38475, "child_moves_before_total": 3199003, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3199003, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 617114, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 617114, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.14497725795971, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.039350227420403, "tt_hits": 16726, "tt_cutoffs": 1676, "beta_cutoffs": 30331, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 4.428571428571429, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4157.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4729.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1045, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 14822, "avg_search_time_ms": 1140.1538461538462, "search_nodes": 127929, "safety_nodes": 1103, "corridor_nodes": 1228, "corridor_branch_probes": 1400, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 10, "corridor_depth_exits": 542, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1216, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1216, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 542, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 55, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 338, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 8038560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 130260, "avg_nodes": 10020.0, "eval_calls": 79631, "avg_eval_calls": 6125.461538461538, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79631, "pattern_eval_ns": 1696828, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.30863608393716, "pattern_frame_queries": 79631, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1696828, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.30863608393716, "pattern_frame_updates": 255702, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2497909014, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9768.828612994814, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 45015, "avg_candidate_generations": 3462.6923076923076, "candidate_moves_total": 3627737, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.58951460624236, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 955, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 45002, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3626782, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 1885063, "avg_legality_checks": 145004.84615384616, "illegal_moves_skipped": 320, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1885063, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 320, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4427597, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 340584.3846153846, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9355745012, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2113.0525230728995, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21682, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1667.8461538461538, "renju_forbidden_ns": 54364139, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2507.339682686099, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 370, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1560796, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7563, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35728844, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13749, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17074499, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 117182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9014.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 887215782, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7571.263351026608, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 148759, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11443.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 316973844, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2130.7876767119974, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4418413205, "stage_ordering_ns": 1443270187, "stage_eval_ns": 2499605842, "stage_threat_ns": 6296371933, "stage_proof_ns": 82229212, "tactical_annotations": 677754, "root_tactical_annotations": 1710, "search_tactical_annotations": 676044, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 258257, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1496900715, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 702382, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4547768351, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90816, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3040985113, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 129122, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 185992216, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2542, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15553221, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 258244, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31866550, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 130696, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 285714334, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 413545, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1175764365, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 133513, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18290880, "child_limit_applications": 45002, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 45002, "child_cap_hits": 45002, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 45002, "child_moves_before_total": 3626462, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3626462, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 427684, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 427684, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.58446291275943, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.503666503710946, "tt_hits": 17887, "tt_cutoffs": 3219, "beta_cutoffs": 35409, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 5.846153846153846, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 5.846153846153846, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2808.5384615384614, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3423.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1740, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14936, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 5, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 10, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 110, 126, 111, 113, 81, 129, 127, 143, 109, 108, 95, 145, 161, 123, 80, 125, 79, 63, 78, 77, 82 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10206, "avg_search_time_ms": 1020.6, "search_nodes": 102794, "safety_nodes": 160, "corridor_nodes": 184, "corridor_branch_probes": 207, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 64, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 176, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 176, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 544, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26346480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 103138, "avg_nodes": 10313.8, "eval_calls": 66067, "avg_eval_calls": 6606.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 66067, "pattern_eval_ns": 1373975, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.796691237682957, "pattern_frame_queries": 66067, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1373975, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.796691237682957, "pattern_frame_updates": 205496, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2465691945, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11998.73450091486, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34385, "avg_candidate_generations": 3438.5, "candidate_moves_total": 2664020, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.47622509815326, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 673, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 34375, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2663347, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 822660, "avg_legality_checks": 82266.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1245, "root_legality_checks": 673, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 821987, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1243, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2875197, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 287519.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6112968163, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2126.1041114747964, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25197, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2519.7, "renju_forbidden_ns": 150279526, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5964.1832757868, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1318, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12679808, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12678, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 102272756, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11173, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 35064171, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 28, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 262791, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 58502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5850.2, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 494684258, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8455.852073433387, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 76928, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7692.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 208405305, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2709.0955828826955, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1948547363, "stage_ordering_ns": 1062062358, "stage_eval_ns": 2467065920, "stage_threat_ns": 4570528373, "stage_proof_ns": 116466699, "tactical_annotations": 421283, "root_tactical_annotations": 2659, "search_tactical_annotations": 418624, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 205986, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1160833292, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 363563, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3219395517, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 69149, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2446087574, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102988, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 146533442, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 480, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1948341, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 205976, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24707723, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 92987, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 80823762, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 188803, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 671964030, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 139493, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 17110058, "child_limit_applications": 34375, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34375, "child_cap_hits": 34375, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34375, "child_moves_before_total": 2662104, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2662104, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 338915, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 338915, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.44302545454545, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.859345454545455, "tt_hits": 19095, "tt_cutoffs": 2306, "beta_cutoffs": 26297, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2870.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3670.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 762, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 4722, "avg_search_time_ms": 524.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 51371, "safety_nodes": 753, "corridor_nodes": 188, "corridor_branch_probes": 228, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 72, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 186, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 186, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 43, "corridor_proof_active": 2, "corridor_proof_quiet": 41, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 72, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 43, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 43, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 292, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 150080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 52312, "avg_nodes": 5812.444444444444, "eval_calls": 36783, "avg_eval_calls": 4087.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 36783, "pattern_eval_ns": 760475, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.674632302966042, "pattern_frame_queries": 36783, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 760475, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.674632302966042, "pattern_frame_updates": 102662, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 982868007, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9573.824852428357, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13929, "avg_candidate_generations": 1547.6666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 1013731, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.77844784263048, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 598, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 13920, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1013133, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 524031, "avg_legality_checks": 58225.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 607, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 524031, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 607, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1394217, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 154913.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2885066260, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2069.309339937757, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10568, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1174.2222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 63335060, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5993.098031794096, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 607, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5988678, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 42913195, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5521, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14306046, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 127141, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 28717, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3190.777777777778, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 243282215, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8471.714141449316, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 39803, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 4422.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 107454365, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2699.6549255081277, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1217905091, "stage_ordering_ns": 407255298, "stage_eval_ns": 983628482, "stage_threat_ns": 2008499670, "stage_proof_ns": 69197652, "tactical_annotations": 162912, "root_tactical_annotations": 576, "search_tactical_annotations": 162336, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 103129, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 568666997, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 167190, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1352625964, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28140, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 979763609, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 51560, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68771516, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 458, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1453984, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 103120, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12020518, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32061, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 68423965, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 94959, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 299093478, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 35892, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4960691, "child_limit_applications": 13920, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13920, "child_cap_hits": 13920, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13920, "child_moves_before_total": 1012526, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1012526, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 222947, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 222947, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.7389367816092, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01630747126437, "tt_hits": 4389, "tt_cutoffs": 628, "beta_cutoffs": 11510, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 4.444444444444445, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4366.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5254.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1831, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1741, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 28068, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 84, 98, 83, 85, 99, 97, 129, 69, 115, 67, 101, 143, 131, 147, 116, 146, 100, 95, 94, 128, 158, 144, 145, 68, 103, 102, 117, 89, 159 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 16166, "avg_search_time_ms": 1077.7333333333333, "search_nodes": 127149, "safety_nodes": 650, "corridor_nodes": 19286, "corridor_branch_probes": 20248, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 10373, "corridor_neutral_exits": 231, "corridor_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_plies_followed": 19229, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 19229, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 13, "corridor_proof_completed": 13, "corridor_proof_checks": 135, "corridor_proof_active": 57, "corridor_proof_quiet": 78, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 231, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 10373, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 24, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 135, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 130, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1098, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 30502880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1998080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 7, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 147085, "avg_nodes": 9805.666666666666, "eval_calls": 93473, "avg_eval_calls": 6231.533333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 93473, "pattern_eval_ns": 2005548, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.4559070533737, "pattern_frame_queries": 93473, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2005548, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.4559070533737, "pattern_frame_updates": 254164, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2774426414, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10915.89058245857, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32237, "avg_candidate_generations": 2149.133333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 2367274, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.43344604026429, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1011, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 32222, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2366263, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 814338, "avg_legality_checks": 54289.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1688, "root_legality_checks": 1011, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 813327, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1686, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4771557, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 318103.8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10127176821, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2122.405080983, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34056, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2270.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 163107344, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4789.386422363166, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1905, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 18265385, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11931, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 82718673, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16345, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43939854, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 3875, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 18183432, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 119655, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7977.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 965912170, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8072.4764531361, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 153353, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10223.533333333333, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 391793699, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2554.848610721668, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1988009404, "stage_ordering_ns": 953144548, "stage_eval_ns": 2776431962, "stage_threat_ns": 8521621312, "stage_proof_ns": 1874849157, "tactical_annotations": 454898, "root_tactical_annotations": 2696, "search_tactical_annotations": 452202, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 292907, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1981427195, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1316700, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5997690966, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 73456, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2833151473, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 146446, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 229595794, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 38728, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 263713581, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 292892, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36552555, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 139733, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 202350240, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 210452, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 816446716, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 104713, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12641221, "child_limit_applications": 32222, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32222, "child_cap_hits": 32222, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32222, "child_moves_before_total": 2364577, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2364577, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 516103, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 516103, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.38393023400161, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.017100117931847, "tt_hits": 13489, "tt_cutoffs": 1387, "beta_cutoffs": 26232, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 13 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3815.9333333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4349.266666666666, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 396, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 11887, "avg_search_time_ms": 849.0714285714286, "search_nodes": 91033, "safety_nodes": 1455, "corridor_nodes": 3188, "corridor_branch_probes": 3759, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1384, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 3163, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3163, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1384, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 263, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 22083200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2004000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 95676, "avg_nodes": 6834.0, "eval_calls": 53327, "avg_eval_calls": 3809.0714285714284, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53327, "pattern_eval_ns": 1169392, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.928704033603992, "pattern_frame_queries": 53327, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1169392, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.928704033603992, "pattern_frame_updates": 181898, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2023117805, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11122.265253053909, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34270, "avg_candidate_generations": 2447.8571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 2456432, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.67878611030055, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 951, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 34256, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2455481, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 1299585, "avg_legality_checks": 92827.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6792, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1299585, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6792, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3528288, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 252020.57142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7358995203, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2085.7127317838, "renju_forbidden_checks": 45263, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3233.0714285714284, "renju_forbidden_ns": 222683109, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4919.760267768376, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6930, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 67372538, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12920, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 98929342, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25354, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 55676061, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 59, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 705168, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 129976, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9284.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1086905667, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8362.356642764818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 171191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12227.92857142857, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 445403294, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2601.791531096845, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3147848670, "stage_ordering_ns": 979708508, "stage_eval_ns": 2024287197, "stage_threat_ns": 5613528831, "stage_proof_ns": 71209515, "tactical_annotations": 585771, "root_tactical_annotations": 920, "search_tactical_annotations": 584851, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 188350, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1184588320, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 697199, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4199072010, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70477, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2482323978, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 94168, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 144899461, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6438, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 45284833, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 188336, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24208267, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 99309, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 336152380, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 349771, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1245059717, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 136691, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 15475940, "child_limit_applications": 34256, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34256, "child_cap_hits": 34256, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34256, "child_moves_before_total": 2448689, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2448689, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 349149, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 349149, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.48204694068193, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.192345866417561, "tt_hits": 14967, "tt_cutoffs": 3366, "beta_cutoffs": 27890, "depth_sum": 84, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 84, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4383.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4954.928571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 134, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1742, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14478, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 6, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 11, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 82, 96, 97, 127, 83, 141, 67, 52, 99, 155, 169, 51, 81, 84, 53, 95, 111, 125, 68, 110, 140, 65, 80, 79, 38, 23, 98 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 11844, "avg_search_time_ms": 911.0769230769231, "search_nodes": 115470, "safety_nodes": 697, "corridor_nodes": 942, "corridor_branch_probes": 1117, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 444, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 937, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 937, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 24, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 19, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 444, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 24, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 151, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2193200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2024480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 117109, "avg_nodes": 9008.384615384615, "eval_calls": 79542, "avg_eval_calls": 6118.615384615385, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79542, "pattern_eval_ns": 1736177, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.827173065801716, "pattern_frame_queries": 79542, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1736177, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.827173065801716, "pattern_frame_updates": 230822, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2997843981, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12987.687399814577, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 33891, "avg_candidate_generations": 2607.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2803298, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.71511610752117, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 922, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 33878, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2802376, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 908480, "avg_legality_checks": 69883.07692307692, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1149, "root_legality_checks": 922, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 907558, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1149, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3220468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 247728.3076923077, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7083788575, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2199.614644517505, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23670, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1820.7692307692307, "renju_forbidden_ns": 134617188, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5687.24917617237, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1291, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11091972, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11823, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 93842901, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10381, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 29109633, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 175, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 572682, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 85924, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6609.538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 722407986, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8407.522764303338, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 112148, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8626.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 293473847, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2616.8442326211793, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2237798637, "stage_ordering_ns": 1157484835, "stage_eval_ns": 2999580158, "stage_threat_ns": 5263417636, "stage_proof_ns": 139013998, "tactical_annotations": 504184, "root_tactical_annotations": 2375, "search_tactical_annotations": 501809, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 232757, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1439037798, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 455176, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3581788438, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 68305, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2431059293, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 116372, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 178838965, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1922, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11724948, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 232744, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29893577, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 117647, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 178239832, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 218547, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 846066117, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 167990, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 22133910, "child_limit_applications": 33878, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 33878, "child_cap_hits": 33878, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 33878, "child_moves_before_total": 2801227, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2801227, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 346958, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 346958, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.68572524942441, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.241395595961981, "tt_hits": 18204, "tt_cutoffs": 1991, "beta_cutoffs": 25858, "depth_sum": 59, "avg_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 59, "avg_effective_depth": 4.538461538461538, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5139.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5755.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 847, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 2622, "avg_search_time_ms": 218.5, "search_nodes": 23081, "safety_nodes": 1375, "corridor_nodes": 758, "corridor_branch_probes": 931, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 328, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 749, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 749, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 328, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 41, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 192, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 116160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 9520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 25214, "avg_nodes": 2101.1666666666665, "eval_calls": 15977, "avg_eval_calls": 1331.4166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 15977, "pattern_eval_ns": 351433, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.996182011641736, "pattern_frame_queries": 15977, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 351433, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.996182011641736, "pattern_frame_updates": 46052, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 477888663, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10377.153283245027, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6725, "avg_candidate_generations": 560.4166666666666, "candidate_moves_total": 514978, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.57665427509293, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 852, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 6713, "search_candidate_moves_total": 514126, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 261335, "avg_legality_checks": 21777.916666666668, "illegal_moves_skipped": 178, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 261335, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 178, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 752352, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 62696.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1620727432, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2154.2142933095147, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3428, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 285.6666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 15210124, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4437.025670945158, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 178, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1484556, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1080, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9506772, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2170, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4218796, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23689, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1974.0833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 224764598, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9488.142091265989, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 33094, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2757.8333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 104085164, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3145.1370036864687, "stage_move_gen_ns": 644070692, "stage_ordering_ns": 216453645, "stage_eval_ns": 478240096, "stage_threat_ns": 1191733652, "stage_proof_ns": 65796398, "tactical_annotations": 98438, "root_tactical_annotations": 356, "search_tactical_annotations": 98082, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 47644, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 309675983, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 133324, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 827945961, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13958, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 490758951, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 23816, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 35842069, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1580, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10472131, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 47632, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5994808, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 22801, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 100455321, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 54039, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 201501777, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 21598, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1802700, "child_limit_applications": 6713, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6713, "child_cap_hits": 6713, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6713, "child_moves_before_total": 513948, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 513948, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 107645, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 107645, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.56010725458066, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.035304632802028, "tt_hits": 2515, "tt_cutoffs": 336, "beta_cutoffs": 5671, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6019.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6686.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1864, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1743, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 29164, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 141, 93, 97, 83, 98, 84, 82, 114, 99, 86, 126, 85, 87, 100, 140, 154, 156, 171, 108, 109, 124, 92, 172 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 12480, "avg_search_time_ms": 960.0, "search_nodes": 151597, "safety_nodes": 842, "corridor_nodes": 413, "corridor_branch_probes": 457, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 88, "corridor_neutral_exits": 58, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 392, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 392, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 116, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 95, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 58, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 88, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 116, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 113, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 956, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26084640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 152852, "avg_nodes": 11757.846153846154, "eval_calls": 121245, "avg_eval_calls": 9326.538461538461, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 121245, "pattern_eval_ns": 2638492, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.761656150769102, "pattern_frame_queries": 121245, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2638492, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.761656150769102, "pattern_frame_updates": 303080, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3529235372, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11644.567018608948, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29269, "avg_candidate_generations": 2251.4615384615386, "candidate_moves_total": 2232733, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.28320065598415, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 931, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 29256, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2231802, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 984278, "avg_legality_checks": 75713.69230769231, "illegal_moves_skipped": 370, "root_legality_checks": 931, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 983347, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 366, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3219780, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 247675.38461538462, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7337995270, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2279.0362291833603, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15992, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1230.1538461538462, "renju_forbidden_ns": 65771988, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4112.805652826413, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 596, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4275987, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8499, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 50360912, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6784, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 10285867, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 113, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 849222, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73130, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5625.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 588028486, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8040.865390400656, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 90313, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6947.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 209929240, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2324.463144840721, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2468042725, "stage_ordering_ns": 968008494, "stage_eval_ns": 3531873864, "stage_threat_ns": 5185828399, "stage_proof_ns": 274579576, "tactical_annotations": 371576, "root_tactical_annotations": 2228, "search_tactical_annotations": 369348, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 304109, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1790873340, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 387697, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3118182896, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59304, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2164938636, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 152048, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 222985141, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1016, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6274779, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 304096, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38469244, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 94984, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 90746286, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 200547, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 791111574, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 76045, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9042999, "child_limit_applications": 29256, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29256, "child_cap_hits": 29256, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29256, "child_moves_before_total": 2231436, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2231436, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 468452, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 468452, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.27276456111566, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.012168444079848, "tt_hits": 10868, "tt_cutoffs": 1039, "beta_cutoffs": 21306, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3546.3846153846152, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4161.7692307692305, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1015, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 16670, "avg_search_time_ms": 1389.1666666666667, "search_nodes": 120950, "safety_nodes": 424, "corridor_nodes": 125, "corridor_branch_probes": 137, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 53, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_plies_followed": 124, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 124, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 1, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 412, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 303680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 25520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 121499, "avg_nodes": 10124.916666666666, "eval_calls": 70894, "avg_eval_calls": 5907.833333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70894, "pattern_eval_ns": 1598286, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.544728749964737, "pattern_frame_queries": 70894, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1598286, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.544728749964737, "pattern_frame_updates": 241758, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2380239559, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9845.546203228021, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46379, "avg_candidate_generations": 3864.9166666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 3731207, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.45035468638824, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 844, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 46367, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3730363, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 2399073, "avg_legality_checks": 199922.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 524, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2399073, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 524, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5006304, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 417192.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11071993913, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2211.610384227566, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16155, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1346.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51256745, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3172.809965954813, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 528, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5089118, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4398, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 31942601, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11207, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13994536, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 22, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 230490, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 145882, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 12156.833333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1188282196, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8145.502502022182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 180764, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 15063.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 427252638, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2363.593624836804, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5854291736, "stage_ordering_ns": 1569068221, "stage_eval_ns": 2381837845, "stage_threat_ns": 6678373454, "stage_proof_ns": 91247146, "tactical_annotations": 729205, "root_tactical_annotations": 3236, "search_tactical_annotations": 725969, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 242120, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1474580942, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 616785, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4958347760, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 93096, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3265681592, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 121054, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 186428722, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 350, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2055630, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 242108, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31399984, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 183103, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 492141486, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 333376, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1195002640, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 212726, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 25560416, "child_limit_applications": 46367, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46367, "child_cap_hits": 46367, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46367, "child_moves_before_total": 3729839, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3729839, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 436034, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 436034, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.44167187870684, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.403972652964393, "tt_hits": 24941, "tt_cutoffs": 3620, "beta_cutoffs": 37318, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 5.583333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 5.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1261.8333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1876.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1744, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14569, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 7, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 12, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 110, 96, 111, 113, 125, 99, 109, 108, 141, 71, 85, 93, 95, 140, 123, 81, 97, 83, 124, 121, 139, 153, 154, 169, 94 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 11955, "avg_search_time_ms": 996.25, "search_nodes": 119250, "safety_nodes": 388, "corridor_nodes": 490, "corridor_branch_probes": 584, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 208, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 485, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 485, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 22, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 17, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 208, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 22, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 149, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2203920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2024480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 120128, "avg_nodes": 10010.666666666666, "eval_calls": 87307, "avg_eval_calls": 7275.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87307, "pattern_eval_ns": 1919470, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.985293275453287, "pattern_frame_queries": 87307, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1919470, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.985293275453287, "pattern_frame_updates": 238392, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3389426942, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14217.87200073828, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 30291, "avg_candidate_generations": 2524.25, "candidate_moves_total": 2536213, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.72826912284177, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 869, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 30279, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2535344, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 907774, "avg_legality_checks": 75647.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1122, "root_legality_checks": 869, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 906905, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1122, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3205642, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 267136.8333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7210754396, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2249.3947845704542, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26808, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2234.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 145309456, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5420.376603998806, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1301, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10294314, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15293, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 107643876, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10169, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26869063, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 502203, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 85326, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7110.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 737541925, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8643.812261209947, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 111540, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9295.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 298948056, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2680.1869822485205, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2283344230, "stage_ordering_ns": 1078077980, "stage_eval_ns": 3391346412, "stage_threat_ns": 5061319936, "stage_proof_ns": 99463361, "tactical_annotations": 418894, "root_tactical_annotations": 2707, "search_tactical_annotations": 416187, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 239418, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1470076912, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 397314, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3351414412, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 60897, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2232075829, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 119703, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 186943268, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1014, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5608140, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 239406, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31063614, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 102976, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 198578681, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 203789, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 838843457, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 112129, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 16213590, "child_limit_applications": 30279, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 30279, "child_cap_hits": 30279, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 30279, "child_moves_before_total": 2534222, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2534222, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 287106, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 287106, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.69569668747316, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.482017239671059, "tt_hits": 14293, "tt_cutoffs": 1610, "beta_cutoffs": 21439, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4809.083333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5475.75, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 608, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2601, "avg_search_time_ms": 236.45454545454547, "search_nodes": 22536, "safety_nodes": 1229, "corridor_nodes": 182, "corridor_branch_probes": 237, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 60, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 177, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 177, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 34, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 29, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 60, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 34, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 168, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 74000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 5600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 23947, "avg_nodes": 2177.0, "eval_calls": 15341, "avg_eval_calls": 1394.6363636363637, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 15341, "pattern_eval_ns": 337471, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.997979271233948, "pattern_frame_queries": 15341, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 337471, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.997979271233948, "pattern_frame_updates": 44972, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 489544580, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10885.541670372677, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6882, "avg_candidate_generations": 625.6363636363636, "candidate_moves_total": 542221, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.78828828828829, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 782, "root_candidate_moves_max": 90, "search_candidate_generations": 6871, "search_candidate_moves_total": 541439, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 247962, "avg_legality_checks": 22542.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 117, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 247962, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 117, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 725375, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 65943.18181818182, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1607892229, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2216.6358490435982, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2866, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 260.54545454545456, "renju_forbidden_ns": 13810730, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4818.817166782973, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 117, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1155205, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1021, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9115017, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1728, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3540508, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 21447, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1949.7272727272727, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 210663182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9822.501142350911, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 29998, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2727.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 99078549, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3302.8384892326153, "stage_move_gen_ns": 624325946, "stage_ordering_ns": 233439278, "stage_eval_ns": 489882051, "stage_threat_ns": 1169663260, "stage_proof_ns": 60785891, "tactical_annotations": 100109, "root_tactical_annotations": 321, "search_tactical_annotations": 99788, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 45405, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 295338343, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 107647, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 828397707, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14026, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 520349739, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 22697, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 35941097, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 422, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2215640, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 45394, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5875122, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 21671, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 91904494, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 59088, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 204849614, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 19350, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1895351, "child_limit_applications": 6871, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6871, "child_cap_hits": 6871, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6871, "child_moves_before_total": 541322, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 541322, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 110012, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 110012, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.78358317566584, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.011060980934364, "tt_hits": 2230, "tt_cutoffs": 274, "beta_cutoffs": 5872, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5825.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6552.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1862, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1745, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21405, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 125, 129, 127, 99, 98, 130, 140, 126, 155, 110, 141, 169, 142, 131, 132, 139, 157, 172, 109, 173, 93 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 11786, "avg_search_time_ms": 982.1666666666666, "search_nodes": 134931, "safety_nodes": 155, "corridor_nodes": 1399, "corridor_branch_probes": 1496, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 538, "corridor_neutral_exits": 52, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1377, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1377, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 115, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 93, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 52, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 538, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 115, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 112, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 955, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26165920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 136485, "avg_nodes": 11373.75, "eval_calls": 104188, "avg_eval_calls": 8682.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 104188, "pattern_eval_ns": 2287741, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.957816639152302, "pattern_frame_queries": 104188, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2287741, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.957816639152302, "pattern_frame_updates": 269758, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3138177745, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11633.30742739789, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29285, "avg_candidate_generations": 2440.4166666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2099675, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.69796824312787, "candidate_moves_max": 106, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 734, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 29273, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2098941, "search_candidate_moves_max": 106, "legality_checks": 807250, "avg_legality_checks": 67270.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 278, "root_legality_checks": 734, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 806516, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 278, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3060434, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 255036.16666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6938898869, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2267.2924392422774, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17903, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1491.9166666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42796028, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2390.438920851254, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 459, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1672508, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7430, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28268774, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9908, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12725746, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 106, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 129000, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 70677, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5889.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 576913889, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8162.682187981946, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 90386, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7532.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 215800051, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2387.5384572832077, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2034884982, "stage_ordering_ns": 923325746, "stage_eval_ns": 3140465486, "stage_threat_ns": 5269245774, "stage_proof_ns": 376522190, "tactical_annotations": 400461, "root_tactical_annotations": 2581, "search_tactical_annotations": 397880, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 272754, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1653282123, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 451511, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3346222311, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 59824, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2282700616, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 136371, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 205039552, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2984, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17433615, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 272742, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35431035, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 103545, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 111905011, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 200206, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 741785111, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 96710, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11837138, "child_limit_applications": 29273, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29273, "child_cap_hits": 29273, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29273, "child_moves_before_total": 2098663, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2098663, "child_moves_before_max": 106, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 106, "child_moves_after_total": 468588, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 468588, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.69278857650394, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.007515457930516, "tt_hits": 12229, "tt_cutoffs": 1418, "beta_cutoffs": 22444, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4129.666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4796.333333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 980, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9608, "avg_search_time_ms": 873.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 80875, "safety_nodes": 810, "corridor_nodes": 146, "corridor_branch_probes": 176, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 50, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 142, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 142, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 60, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 50, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 60, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 60, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 437, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 8247520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2002160, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 81831, "avg_nodes": 7439.181818181818, "eval_calls": 49738, "avg_eval_calls": 4521.636363636364, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49738, "pattern_eval_ns": 1105596, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.228396799227955, "pattern_frame_queries": 49738, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1105596, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.228396799227955, "pattern_frame_updates": 161624, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1511049305, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9349.1641402267, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 29089, "avg_candidate_generations": 2644.4545454545455, "candidate_moves_total": 2079628, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.49190415621025, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 668, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 29078, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2078960, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 1171286, "avg_legality_checks": 106480.54545454546, "illegal_moves_skipped": 45, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1171286, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 45, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2723281, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 247571.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6183231519, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2270.50808161185, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7730, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 702.7272727272727, "renju_forbidden_ns": 11027651, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1426.6042690815007, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 55, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 142410, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1485, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 5946056, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6190, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4939185, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 59049, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5368.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 503986658, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8535.058307507325, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 77250, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7022.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 194653624, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2519.7880129449836, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2948915796, "stage_ordering_ns": 921631106, "stage_eval_ns": 1512154901, "stage_threat_ns": 4061570665, "stage_proof_ns": 107180880, "tactical_annotations": 340207, "root_tactical_annotations": 1159, "search_tactical_annotations": 339048, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 162039, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 980048714, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 315894, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2926117031, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58537, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2146127578, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 81014, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 121516429, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 404, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2098988, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 162028, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21002249, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 61081, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 164825319, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 186330, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 607194432, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 92796, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10787254, "child_limit_applications": 29078, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 29078, "child_cap_hits": 29078, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 29078, "child_moves_before_total": 2078915, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2078915, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 254931, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 254931, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.49442877777014, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.767143544948071, "tt_hits": 13108, "tt_cutoffs": 1996, "beta_cutoffs": 22380, "depth_sum": 63, "avg_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 63, "avg_effective_depth": 5.7272727272727275, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3220.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3947.4545454545455, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 331, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1746, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 44908, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 8, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 13, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 114, 128, 113, 111, 83, 125, 126, 140, 115, 116, 99, 139, 153, 131, 129, 84, 101, 143, 100, 141, 142, 138, 137, 98, 110, 158, 87, 73, 103, 102, 51, 67, 94, 78, 157, 173, 188, 159, 127, 172, 71, 85, 55, 39, 119 ], "move_count": 47, "black_stats": { "move_count": 24, "search_move_count": 22, "total_time_ms": 34567, "avg_search_time_ms": 1571.2272727272727, "search_nodes": 333804, "safety_nodes": 1179, "corridor_nodes": 3696, "corridor_branch_probes": 3797, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1859, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 3677, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3677, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 76, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1859, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 76, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 75, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 3, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 577, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26270720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1991280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 338679, "avg_nodes": 15394.5, "eval_calls": 219221, "avg_eval_calls": 9964.59090909091, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 219221, "pattern_eval_ns": 4861985, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.178463742068505, "pattern_frame_queries": 219221, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4861985, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.178463742068505, "pattern_frame_updates": 667376, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 8550654124, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12812.348846826975, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 106683, "avg_candidate_generations": 4849.227272727273, "candidate_moves_total": 10100153, "avg_candidate_moves": 94.67443735178051, "candidate_moves_max": 135, "root_candidate_generations": 22, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1918, "root_candidate_moves_max": 127, "search_candidate_generations": 106661, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10098235, "search_candidate_moves_max": 135, "legality_checks": 2280077, "avg_legality_checks": 103639.86363636363, "illegal_moves_skipped": 9880, "root_legality_checks": 1918, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 15, "search_legality_checks": 2278159, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 9865, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9048172, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 411280.54545454547, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19672175965, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2174.1602574531075, "renju_forbidden_checks": 76922, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3496.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 520032112, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6760.512103169444, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 10806, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 120113485, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 35897, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 269404623, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28948, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 116003681, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1271, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 14510323, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 230523, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10478.318181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2083748201, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9039.220385818335, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 316752, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14397.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 925115665, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2920.6308563166135, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5664441288, "stage_ordering_ns": 3902533188, "stage_eval_ns": 8555516109, "stage_threat_ns": 15871820436, "stage_proof_ns": 471147813, "tactical_annotations": 2429120, "root_tactical_annotations": 7026, "search_tactical_annotations": 2422094, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 674904, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 4045464419, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1995795, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 11047184418, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 215550, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7226895747, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 337441, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 524680374, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7506, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 49322682, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 674882, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 86799894, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 703090, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 727080368, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 902107, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2612367239, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 823923, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 118368649, "child_limit_applications": 106661, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 106661, "child_cap_hits": 106661, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 106661, "child_moves_before_total": 10088370, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10088370, "child_moves_before_max": 135, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 135, "child_moves_after_total": 1243749, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1243749, "child_moves_after_max": 30, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 30, "avg_child_moves_before": 94.58349349809208, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.660766353212514, "tt_hits": 63566, "tt_cutoffs": 7808, "beta_cutoffs": 87176, "depth_sum": 113, "avg_depth": 5.136363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 113, "avg_effective_depth": 5.136363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_moves": 22, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2713.1363636363635, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3076.7727272727275, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 23, "search_move_count": 21, "total_time_ms": 10321, "avg_search_time_ms": 491.4761904761905, "search_nodes": 76158, "safety_nodes": 2144, "corridor_nodes": 935, "corridor_branch_probes": 1104, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 426, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 925, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 925, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 19, "corridor_proof_completed": 19, "corridor_proof_checks": 97, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 87, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 426, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 97, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 97, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 611, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 136640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 6560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 79237, "avg_nodes": 3773.190476190476, "eval_calls": 50610, "avg_eval_calls": 2410.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50610, "pattern_eval_ns": 1140472, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.53451886978858, "pattern_frame_queries": 50610, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1140472, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.53451886978858, "pattern_frame_updates": 152116, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1547747652, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10174.785374319597, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23895, "avg_candidate_generations": 1137.857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 2348244, "avg_candidate_moves": 98.27344632768362, "candidate_moves_max": 138, "root_candidate_generations": 21, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1834, "root_candidate_moves_max": 123, "search_candidate_generations": 23874, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2346410, "search_candidate_moves_max": 138, "legality_checks": 1524106, "avg_legality_checks": 72576.47619047618, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3947, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1524106, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3947, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3192725, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 152034.52380952382, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6614745163, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2071.81801219961, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32675, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1555.952380952381, "renju_forbidden_ns": 129458275, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3961.9977046671765, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4089, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 45856949, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4952, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 44162307, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23387, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36564175, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 247, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2874844, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 107275, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5108.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 998507195, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9307.920717781402, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 157432, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7496.761904761905, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 468149676, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2973.6627623354843, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3552567660, "stage_ordering_ns": 903020884, "stage_eval_ns": 1548888124, "stage_threat_ns": 4076409014, "stage_proof_ns": 161482211, "tactical_annotations": 513652, "root_tactical_annotations": 1856, "search_tactical_annotations": 511796, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 154181, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 963624030, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 513587, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2945528017, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48613, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1562475384, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77080, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 120281051, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2044, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14224858, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 154160, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19851836, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 186108, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 450317010, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 228876, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 894332713, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 98668, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12899222, "child_limit_applications": 23874, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23874, "child_cap_hits": 23874, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23874, "child_moves_before_total": 2342463, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2342463, "child_moves_before_max": 138, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 138, "child_moves_after_total": 383913, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 383913, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 98.11774315154561, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.080799195777832, "tt_hits": 10170, "tt_cutoffs": 1574, "beta_cutoffs": 20617, "depth_sum": 100, "avg_depth": 4.761904761904762, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 100, "avg_effective_depth": 4.761904761904762, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 19 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 21, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09523809523809523, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6671.809523809524, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7052.761904761905, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1869, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1747, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 39722, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 97, 127, 128, 141, 155, 156, 111, 99, 85, 171, 186, 125, 96, 144, 95, 94, 109, 114, 129, 123, 124, 108, 81, 138, 67, 53, 80, 64, 82, 52, 79, 78, 83 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 15310, "avg_search_time_ms": 900.5882352941177, "search_nodes": 148454, "safety_nodes": 1417, "corridor_nodes": 969, "corridor_branch_probes": 1089, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 346, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_plies_followed": 952, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 952, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 97, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 80, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 346, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 97, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 94, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 720, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 336080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 19040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 150840, "avg_nodes": 8872.941176470587, "eval_calls": 107822, "avg_eval_calls": 6342.470588235294, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107822, "pattern_eval_ns": 2386128, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.13025171115357, "pattern_frame_queries": 107822, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2386128, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.13025171115357, "pattern_frame_updates": 296754, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4006848212, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13502.25510692358, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38166, "avg_candidate_generations": 2245.0588235294117, "candidate_moves_total": 3254029, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.25989100246292, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1273, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 38149, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3252756, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1262378, "avg_legality_checks": 74257.5294117647, "illegal_moves_skipped": 489, "root_legality_checks": 1273, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1261105, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 489, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4072792, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 239576.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9346977664, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2294.980363347797, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22683, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1334.2941176470588, "renju_forbidden_ns": 89423083, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3942.2952431336244, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5419816, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10138, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 63005160, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11448, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20152115, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 383, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 845992, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 85972, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5057.176470588235, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 776105798, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9027.425184943935, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 116164, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6833.176470588235, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 321351047, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2766.356590682139, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3151446111, "stage_ordering_ns": 1376965550, "stage_eval_ns": 4009234340, "stage_threat_ns": 6420042221, "stage_proof_ns": 286768859, "tactical_annotations": 568180, "root_tactical_annotations": 2200, "search_tactical_annotations": 565980, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 298869, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1832945005, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 609013, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4292629781, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 77299, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2908372430, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 149426, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 227284968, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2098, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15390870, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 298852, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38796258, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 142132, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 93553705, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 329523, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1163510406, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 96525, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12995339, "child_limit_applications": 38149, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38149, "child_cap_hits": 38149, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38149, "child_moves_before_total": 3252267, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3252267, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 610392, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 610392, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.25169729219638, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000209704055152, "tt_hits": 13153, "tt_cutoffs": 2407, "beta_cutoffs": 31115, "depth_sum": 76, "avg_depth": 4.470588235294118, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 76, "avg_effective_depth": 4.470588235294118, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.058823529411764705, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5611.294117647059, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6081.882352941177, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 24394, "avg_search_time_ms": 1524.625, "search_nodes": 156706, "safety_nodes": 772, "corridor_nodes": 417, "corridor_branch_probes": 514, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 147, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 409, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 409, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 29, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 21, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 147, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 29, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 168, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4201680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2011520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 157895, "avg_nodes": 9868.4375, "eval_calls": 93564, "avg_eval_calls": 5847.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 93564, "pattern_eval_ns": 2131897, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.78544098157411, "pattern_frame_queries": 93564, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2131897, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.78544098157411, "pattern_frame_updates": 313230, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3619301593, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11554.773147527376, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 59224, "avg_candidate_generations": 3701.5, "candidate_moves_total": 5188013, "avg_candidate_moves": 87.59984128056193, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1202, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 59208, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5186811, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 3546136, "avg_legality_checks": 221633.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1151, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3546136, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1151, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7415730, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 463483.125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16294608129, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2197.303317272878, "renju_forbidden_checks": 37777, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2361.0625, "renju_forbidden_ns": 71481393, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1892.1934775127722, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1248, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12633542, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4633, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 30539877, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 31875, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 28241374, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 21, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 66600, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 232178, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14511.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2241251444, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9653.160264969118, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 326356, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 20397.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1016203950, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3113.7896959148907, "stage_move_gen_ns": 8686004370, "stage_ordering_ns": 2192048618, "stage_eval_ns": 3621433490, "stage_threat_ns": 9707203725, "stage_proof_ns": 48320554, "tactical_annotations": 1150687, "root_tactical_annotations": 3932, "search_tactical_annotations": 1146755, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 314122, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1956019495, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1056605, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7425618007, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 118831, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4150444439, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 157053, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 246314256, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 876, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5451119, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 314106, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 41324452, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 250659, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 563600306, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 661135, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2691810921, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 238893, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32476396, "child_limit_applications": 59208, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 59208, "child_cap_hits": 59208, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 59208, "child_moves_before_total": 5185660, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5185660, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 526688, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 526688, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 87.58377246318065, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.895554654776381, "tt_hits": 24066, "tt_cutoffs": 3847, "beta_cutoffs": 47177, "depth_sum": 85, "avg_depth": 5.3125, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 85, "avg_effective_depth": 5.3125, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 6, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 6, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1738.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2222.3125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1748, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21327, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 9, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 14, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 142, 126, 127, 97, 129, 171, 143, 141, 111, 95, 115, 101, 159, 175, 144, 174, 128, 156, 186, 172, 173, 96, 145, 146, 187, 131, 201 ], "move_count": 29, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 16024, "avg_search_time_ms": 1232.6153846153845, "search_nodes": 138707, "safety_nodes": 677, "corridor_nodes": 3282, "corridor_branch_probes": 3625, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1521, "corridor_neutral_exits": 30, "corridor_terminal_exits": 33, "corridor_plies_followed": 3255, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3255, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 87, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 60, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 30, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1521, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 33, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 87, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 84, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 697, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 89172440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 18, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 16, "total_nodes": 142666, "avg_nodes": 10974.307692307691, "eval_calls": 84113, "avg_eval_calls": 6470.2307692307695, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84113, "pattern_eval_ns": 1886063, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.422966723336465, "pattern_frame_queries": 84113, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1886063, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.422966723336465, "pattern_frame_updates": 277272, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3394965905, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12244.171445367725, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 50994, "avg_candidate_generations": 3922.6153846153848, "candidate_moves_total": 4009146, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.61995528885751, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 913, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 50981, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4008233, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1163796, "avg_legality_checks": 89522.76923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1284, "root_legality_checks": 913, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1162883, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1283, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4236092, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 325853.23076923075, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9712457585, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2292.787216377737, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34473, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2651.769230769231, "renju_forbidden_ns": 154117039, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4470.659327589708, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1624, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11187736, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 15581, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 88962041, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15507, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 45073676, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1761, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8893586, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74308, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5716.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 634757547, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8542.250457555041, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 96868, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7451.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 249117140, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2571.717595077838, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2958208563, "stage_ordering_ns": 1717227225, "stage_eval_ns": 3396851968, "stage_threat_ns": 7397584439, "stage_proof_ns": 488709523, "tactical_annotations": 589635, "root_tactical_annotations": 3128, "search_tactical_annotations": 586507, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 283969, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1768482440, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 662336, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5300549212, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 103881, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3890016492, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 141978, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 219501444, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6684, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 47549396, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 283956, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36848349, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 114220, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 94766880, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 268905, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 875611920, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 206510, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 24653598, "child_limit_applications": 50981, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 50981, "child_cap_hits": 50981, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 50981, "child_moves_before_total": 4006950, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4006950, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 440093, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 440093, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.59692826739374, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.632490535689767, "tt_hits": 28115, "tt_cutoffs": 3543, "beta_cutoffs": 40289, "depth_sum": 70, "avg_depth": 5.384615384615385, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 70, "avg_effective_depth": 5.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2208.6923076923076, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2824.076923076923, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 5291, "avg_search_time_ms": 440.9166666666667, "search_nodes": 45601, "safety_nodes": 1218, "corridor_nodes": 879, "corridor_branch_probes": 1078, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 297, "corridor_neutral_exits": 23, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 863, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 863, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 297, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 59, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 340, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 104080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 7920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 47698, "avg_nodes": 3974.8333333333335, "eval_calls": 31595, "avg_eval_calls": 2632.9166666666665, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 31595, "pattern_eval_ns": 708430, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.422218705491375, "pattern_frame_queries": 31595, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 708430, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.422218705491375, "pattern_frame_updates": 91092, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 899300365, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9872.44066438326, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13329, "avg_candidate_generations": 1110.75, "candidate_moves_total": 968773, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.68159651886863, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 844, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 13317, "search_candidate_moves_total": 967929, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 543799, "avg_legality_checks": 45316.583333333336, "illegal_moves_skipped": 469, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 543799, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 469, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1470815, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 122567.91666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3310655507, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2250.898656187216, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7443, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 620.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 20977227, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2818.3833131801694, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 500, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1546864, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1921, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12750775, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4999, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6654178, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 23, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 25410, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 48056, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4004.6666666666665, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 448107265, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9324.689216747129, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66089, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5507.416666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 194144120, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2937.6162447608526, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1386526251, "stage_ordering_ns": 426565411, "stage_eval_ns": 900008795, "stage_threat_ns": 2444141748, "stage_proof_ns": 96773121, "tactical_annotations": 174282, "root_tactical_annotations": 681, "search_tactical_annotations": 173601, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 92948, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 599452876, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 227903, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1744022506, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27426, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1102717603, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 46468, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 71241740, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1844, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13588433, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 92936, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12268599, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 43331, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 151550449, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 99078, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 445641756, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 31873, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3567594, "child_limit_applications": 13317, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13317, "child_cap_hits": 13317, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13317, "child_moves_before_total": 967460, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 967460, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 213074, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 213074, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.64849440564691, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00015018397537, "tt_hits": 4153, "tt_cutoffs": 634, "beta_cutoffs": 11290, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5277.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5944.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1618, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1749, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17591, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 127, 97, 96, 125, 83, 100, 81, 80, 99, 139, 153, 110, 85, 84, 113, 71, 141 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6473, "avg_search_time_ms": 719.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 65859, "safety_nodes": 535, "corridor_nodes": 962, "corridor_branch_probes": 1165, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 315, "corridor_neutral_exits": 39, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 945, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 945, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 52, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 35, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 39, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 315, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 52, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 413, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 241600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 67356, "avg_nodes": 7484.0, "eval_calls": 47893, "avg_eval_calls": 5321.444444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47893, "pattern_eval_ns": 1052731, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.980894911573717, "pattern_frame_queries": 47893, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1052731, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.980894911573717, "pattern_frame_updates": 131644, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1357857333, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10314.616184558354, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16895, "avg_candidate_generations": 1877.2222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 1117153, "avg_candidate_moves": 66.12329091447174, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 549, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 16886, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1116604, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 511236, "avg_legality_checks": 56804.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 939, "root_legality_checks": 549, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 510687, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 938, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1756702, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 195189.11111111112, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3968965921, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2259.327945775664, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10781, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1197.888888888889, "renju_forbidden_ns": 53189654, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4933.647528058622, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 985, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11199081, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3254, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 27256134, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 6485, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 14065608, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 57, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 668831, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47006, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5222.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 453571189, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9649.219014593882, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 67499, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7499.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 203994327, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3022.182950858531, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1326104244, "stage_ordering_ns": 498231121, "stage_eval_ns": 1358910064, "stage_threat_ns": 3023036757, "stage_proof_ns": 229334382, "tactical_annotations": 152289, "root_tactical_annotations": 1057, "search_tactical_annotations": 151232, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 133647, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 811038966, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 229848, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2082806690, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34496, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1335832697, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66819, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 97745969, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1994, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 11663095, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 133638, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16784865, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32253, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 82660622, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 95701, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 498766107, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 24335, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2997172, "child_limit_applications": 16886, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16886, "child_cap_hits": 16886, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16886, "child_moves_before_total": 1115666, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1115666, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 270178, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 270178, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 66.0704725808362, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00011844131233, "tt_hits": 5511, "tt_cutoffs": 1044, "beta_cutoffs": 13870, "depth_sum": 36, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 36, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3479.222222222222, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4368.111111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 11111, "avg_search_time_ms": 1388.875, "search_nodes": 76259, "safety_nodes": 350, "corridor_nodes": 48, "corridor_branch_probes": 52, "corridor_max_depth": 3, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 40, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 40, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 25, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 17, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 25, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 25, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 163, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 20072240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 76657, "avg_nodes": 9582.125, "eval_calls": 47332, "avg_eval_calls": 5916.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 47332, "pattern_eval_ns": 1074126, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.69344206879067, "pattern_frame_queries": 47332, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1074126, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.69344206879067, "pattern_frame_updates": 152436, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1713185278, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11238.718399853053, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27085, "avg_candidate_generations": 3385.625, "candidate_moves_total": 2030058, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.95137529998154, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 479, "root_candidate_moves_max": 75, "search_candidate_generations": 27077, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2029579, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1465082, "avg_legality_checks": 183135.25, "illegal_moves_skipped": 6053, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1465082, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 6053, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3417120, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 427140.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7393875812, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2163.7741173854006, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29718, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3714.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 155038575, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5216.992226933172, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 6061, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 70865522, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5921, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 52588012, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17731, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31518201, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 66840, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 123348, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 15418.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1274375369, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10331.544646042092, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 181042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 22630.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 629361363, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3476.3279404779, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3712165385, "stage_ordering_ns": 873425569, "stage_eval_ns": 1714259404, "stage_threat_ns": 4702096010, "stage_proof_ns": 45669463, "tactical_annotations": 450320, "root_tactical_annotations": 1492, "search_tactical_annotations": 448828, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 152574, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 938722471, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 374325, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3606533095, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 54339, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1990095419, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 76283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 117805408, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 130, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 630162, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 152566, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19799597, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 92718, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 474428889, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 222188, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1139159192, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 135414, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18605277, "child_limit_applications": 27077, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27077, "child_cap_hits": 27077, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27077, "child_moves_before_total": 2023526, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2023526, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 263977, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 263977, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.73228201056247, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.749122871810023, "tt_hits": 13266, "tt_cutoffs": 1809, "beta_cutoffs": 21062, "depth_sum": 40, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 40, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.375, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1809.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2425.125, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 932, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1750, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22471, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 10, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 15, "template_index": 1, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 82, 98, 96, 128, 68, 110, 97, 127, 67, 52, 66, 65, 54, 40, 69, 70, 84, 99, 85, 83, 95, 143, 113, 159, 175, 129, 39, 24, 53, 81, 101, 37, 117 ], "move_count": 35, "black_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 15086, "avg_search_time_ms": 942.875, "search_nodes": 178548, "safety_nodes": 775, "corridor_nodes": 390, "corridor_branch_probes": 432, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 115, "corridor_neutral_exits": 17, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 379, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 379, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 67, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 17, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 115, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 67, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 66, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 547, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 27893520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1995680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 179713, "avg_nodes": 11232.0625, "eval_calls": 112418, "avg_eval_calls": 7026.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 112418, "pattern_eval_ns": 2374642, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.12332544610294, "pattern_frame_queries": 112418, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2374642, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.12332544610294, "pattern_frame_updates": 356944, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3760159523, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10534.31216941593, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 61775, "avg_candidate_generations": 3860.9375, "candidate_moves_total": 4666763, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.54452448401457, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1132, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 61759, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4665631, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 1338856, "avg_legality_checks": 83678.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1158, "root_legality_checks": 1132, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1337724, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1155, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4825531, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 301595.6875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8843126777, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1832.5707112854523, "renju_forbidden_checks": 39640, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2477.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 132678626, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3347.089455095863, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1897, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8658415, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17962, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 86588187, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 19736, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37169633, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 45, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 262391, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 88988, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5561.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 626234669, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7037.293444059873, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 115617, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7226.0625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 253970645, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2196.6548604443983, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2716117572, "stage_ordering_ns": 1478098215, "stage_eval_ns": 3762534165, "stage_threat_ns": 6903459826, "stage_proof_ns": 141345969, "tactical_annotations": 1109056, "root_tactical_annotations": 3214, "search_tactical_annotations": 1105842, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 357852, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1818618548, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 864525, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4755380899, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 124100, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3512448950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 178918, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 233503678, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 892, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4491786, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 357836, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38972517, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 217833, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 101206205, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 494236, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1092676171, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 396987, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 52492398, "child_limit_applications": 61759, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 61759, "child_cap_hits": 61759, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 61759, "child_moves_before_total": 4664476, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4664476, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 667322, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 667322, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.52706488123188, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.805259152512184, "tt_hits": 33624, "tt_cutoffs": 4295, "beta_cutoffs": 47404, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1875, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3991.4375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4491.4375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 7372, "avg_search_time_ms": 491.46666666666664, "search_nodes": 66632, "safety_nodes": 1081, "corridor_nodes": 1228, "corridor_branch_probes": 1359, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 570, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 1215, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1215, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 63, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 570, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 63, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 63, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 430, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 280080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11120, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 68941, "avg_nodes": 4596.066666666667, "eval_calls": 44666, "avg_eval_calls": 2977.733333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44666, "pattern_eval_ns": 965154, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.60824788429678, "pattern_frame_queries": 44666, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 965154, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.60824788429678, "pattern_frame_updates": 133124, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1174010911, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8818.92754875154, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20310, "avg_candidate_generations": 1354.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1592350, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.40226489414081, "candidate_moves_max": 109, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1059, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 20295, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1591291, "search_candidate_moves_max": 109, "legality_checks": 1151486, "avg_legality_checks": 76765.73333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5191, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1151486, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5191, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2662372, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 177491.46666666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4715472754, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1771.1547274385398, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29070, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1938.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 84563126, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2908.9482628138976, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5217, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 36868811, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3617, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 21093081, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20125, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25638003, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 111, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 963231, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 103948, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6929.866666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 858048004, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8254.588871358756, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 144246, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9616.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 401858047, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2785.9215992124564, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2344552147, "stage_ordering_ns": 525735343, "stage_eval_ns": 1174976065, "stage_threat_ns": 3180902568, "stage_proof_ns": 80614574, "tactical_annotations": 435493, "root_tactical_annotations": 1486, "search_tactical_annotations": 434007, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 135695, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 738385192, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 457197, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2309728670, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 41460, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1154004034, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 67840, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90028217, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2556, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17551851, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 135680, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15220979, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 158164, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 412382194, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 194164, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 695408155, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 83165, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9987659, "child_limit_applications": 20295, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20295, "child_cap_hits": 20295, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20295, "child_moves_before_total": 1586100, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1586100, "child_moves_before_max": 109, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 109, "child_moves_after_total": 325036, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 325036, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.15225424981523, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.015570337521556, "tt_hits": 8053, "tt_cutoffs": 1601, "beta_cutoffs": 17411, "depth_sum": 69, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 69, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6023.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6556.533333333334, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1751, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14872, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 114, 126, 113, 111, 82, 66, 97, 127, 115, 116, 130, 146, 67, 52, 129, 125, 124, 81, 145, 96 ], "move_count": 24, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 9390, "avg_search_time_ms": 939.0, "search_nodes": 79960, "safety_nodes": 597, "corridor_nodes": 4228, "corridor_branch_probes": 5080, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1816, "corridor_neutral_exits": 13, "corridor_terminal_exits": 74, "corridor_plies_followed": 4192, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4192, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 86, "corridor_proof_active": 36, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 13, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1816, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 74, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 86, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 622, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 51925680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2005840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 84785, "avg_nodes": 8478.5, "eval_calls": 61875, "avg_eval_calls": 6187.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 61875, "pattern_eval_ns": 1363609, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.03812525252525, "pattern_frame_queries": 61875, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1363609, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.03812525252525, "pattern_frame_updates": 159828, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2402942369, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 15034.551949595816, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17033, "avg_candidate_generations": 1703.3, "candidate_moves_total": 1162919, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.27446721070862, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 630, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 17023, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1162289, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 515246, "avg_legality_checks": 51524.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2376, "root_legality_checks": 630, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 514616, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2368, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2537305, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 253730.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5768766959, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2273.580416623149, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30203, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3020.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 275428516, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9119.243651292918, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2870, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 37372968, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14147, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 151365565, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10597, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 62762328, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 2589, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 23927655, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 70136, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7013.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 732009309, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10436.9982462644, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98423, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9842.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 347715769, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3532.8710667222094, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1379703888, "stage_ordering_ns": 523622084, "stage_eval_ns": 2404305978, "stage_threat_ns": 4411587307, "stage_proof_ns": 645152095, "tactical_annotations": 257399, "root_tactical_annotations": 1277, "search_tactical_annotations": 256122, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 168394, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1112217252, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 485629, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3085103902, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36284, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1588942436, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 84192, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 134245213, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 8556, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 51473316, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 168384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22524466, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 60829, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 107255185, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 145840, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 713940869, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 50730, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6023158, "child_limit_applications": 17023, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17023, "child_cap_hits": 17023, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17023, "child_moves_before_total": 1159921, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1159921, "child_moves_before_max": 96, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 96, "child_moves_after_total": 274682, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 274682, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.13845973095223, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.13593373670916, "tt_hits": 6425, "tt_cutoffs": 1016, "beta_cutoffs": 12983, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 4.6, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2851.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3651.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 204, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5471, "avg_search_time_ms": 547.1, "search_nodes": 37514, "safety_nodes": 905, "corridor_nodes": 808, "corridor_branch_probes": 952, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 386, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 802, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 802, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 10, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 4, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 386, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 10, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 10, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 21, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2047760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2009920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 39227, "avg_nodes": 3922.7, "eval_calls": 22567, "avg_eval_calls": 2256.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22567, "pattern_eval_ns": 522865, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 23.16945096822794, "pattern_frame_queries": 22567, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 522865, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 23.16945096822794, "pattern_frame_updates": 74928, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1039951207, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13879.340259982917, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13608, "avg_candidate_generations": 1360.8, "candidate_moves_total": 966171, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.0002204585538, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 644, "root_candidate_moves_max": 82, "search_candidate_generations": 13598, "search_candidate_moves_total": 965527, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 514384, "avg_legality_checks": 51438.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2633, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 514384, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2633, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1511280, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 151128.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3375934839, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2233.8248630300145, "renju_forbidden_checks": 22003, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2200.3, "renju_forbidden_ns": 199849625, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 9082.83529518702, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3401, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 47917687, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7583, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 90648829, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10945, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 60220547, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 74, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1062562, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 56085, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5608.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 612859181, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10927.327823838816, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 79446, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7944.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 293405365, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3693.1420713440575, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1364377105, "stage_ordering_ns": 419622998, "stage_eval_ns": 1040474072, "stage_threat_ns": 2606863968, "stage_proof_ns": 10291689, "tactical_annotations": 265719, "root_tactical_annotations": 367, "search_tactical_annotations": 265352, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 76562, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 506501097, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 275926, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2012659099, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 27631, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1112009152, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 38276, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 61899608, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1624, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9425730, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 76552, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10337562, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 34580, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 121653594, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 170583, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 741006856, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 60556, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6040872, "child_limit_applications": 13598, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13598, "child_cap_hits": 13598, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13598, "child_moves_before_total": 962894, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 962894, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 167127, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 167127, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.81144285924401, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.290557434916899, "tt_hits": 5992, "tt_cutoffs": 1300, "beta_cutoffs": 11262, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.9, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.9, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4461.4, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5261.4, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1752, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26575, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 11, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 16, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 98, 142, 84, 126, 114, 110, 158, 94, 78, 125, 129, 99, 82, 66, 130, 146, 70, 56, 144, 124, 127, 122, 123, 80, 108, 95, 65, 140 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18664, "avg_search_time_ms": 1435.6923076923076, "search_nodes": 136617, "safety_nodes": 787, "corridor_nodes": 4840, "corridor_branch_probes": 5508, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2211, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 4808, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4808, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 32, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2211, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 390, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4305360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 142244, "avg_nodes": 10941.846153846154, "eval_calls": 79063, "avg_eval_calls": 6081.7692307692305, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79063, "pattern_eval_ns": 1745814, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.081302252633975, "pattern_frame_queries": 79063, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1745814, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.081302252633975, "pattern_frame_updates": 273082, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3978063839, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14567.286891849335, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 52614, "avg_candidate_generations": 4047.230769230769, "candidate_moves_total": 4856781, "avg_candidate_moves": 92.3096704299236, "candidate_moves_max": 130, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1110, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 52601, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4855671, "search_candidate_moves_max": 130, "legality_checks": 1181783, "avg_legality_checks": 90906.38461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1064, "root_legality_checks": 1110, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1180673, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1064, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4876472, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 375113.23076923075, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11167872839, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2290.154201439073, "renju_forbidden_checks": 54828, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4217.538461538462, "renju_forbidden_ns": 426144588, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7772.389800831692, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1181, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11299459, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26243, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 257208942, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 26166, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 146345733, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1238, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 11290454, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 117842, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9064.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1203775656, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10215.166545034877, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 165648, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12742.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 577212377, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3484.5719658553076, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3022627625, "stage_ordering_ns": 1969899689, "stage_eval_ns": 3979809653, "stage_threat_ns": 9015382611, "stage_proof_ns": 623613941, "tactical_annotations": 1045464, "root_tactical_annotations": 3208, "search_tactical_annotations": 1042256, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 282823, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1864557462, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1002810, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6764672798, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 107587, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4333983373, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 141405, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 225215192, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9728, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 63549940, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 282810, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 39587421, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 196469, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 331954901, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 433216, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1381077118, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 415779, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 57799798, "child_limit_applications": 52601, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 52601, "child_cap_hits": 52601, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 52601, "child_moves_before_total": 4854607, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4854607, "child_moves_before_max": 130, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 130, "child_moves_after_total": 627663, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 627663, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 92.29115416056729, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.932529799813691, "tt_hits": 32893, "tt_cutoffs": 4878, "beta_cutoffs": 44670, "depth_sum": 74, "avg_depth": 5.6923076923076925, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 74, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6923076923076925, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1649.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2217.153846153846, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7900, "avg_search_time_ms": 607.6923076923077, "search_nodes": 51922, "safety_nodes": 1563, "corridor_nodes": 921, "corridor_branch_probes": 1037, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 394, "corridor_neutral_exits": 25, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 900, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 900, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 25, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 394, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 441, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 282560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 54406, "avg_nodes": 4185.076923076923, "eval_calls": 34869, "avg_eval_calls": 2682.230769230769, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34869, "pattern_eval_ns": 771790, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.133987209268977, "pattern_frame_queries": 34869, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 771790, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.133987209268977, "pattern_frame_updates": 103730, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1142490832, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11014.083023233394, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15943, "avg_candidate_generations": 1226.3846153846155, "candidate_moves_total": 1432082, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.82512701499091, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1138, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 15930, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1430944, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1034285, "avg_legality_checks": 79560.38461538461, "illegal_moves_skipped": 106, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1034285, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 106, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2408979, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 185306.07692307694, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5325976590, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2210.8854373574864, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7169, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 551.4615384615385, "renju_forbidden_ns": 26663352, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3719.2568001115915, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 106, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 811284, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2002, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 18476993, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5061, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7375075, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99907, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7685.153846153846, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1099524088, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 11005.475972654569, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 148369, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11413.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 551702020, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3718.44536257574, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2627391748, "stage_ordering_ns": 609745736, "stage_eval_ns": 1143262622, "stage_threat_ns": 3354349672, "stage_proof_ns": 111327142, "tactical_annotations": 281196, "root_tactical_annotations": 1136, "search_tactical_annotations": 280060, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 105671, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 666667335, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 315979, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2574056987, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 32579, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1198459683, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 52829, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81574415, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1928, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 10978725, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 105658, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13793577, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 81104, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 546208870, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 147821, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 786669760, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 52271, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7278633, "child_limit_applications": 15930, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15930, "child_cap_hits": 15930, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15930, "child_moves_before_total": 1430838, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1430838, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 255314, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 255314, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.82033898305085, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02724419334589, "tt_hits": 6316, "tt_cutoffs": 1066, "beta_cutoffs": 13668, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4855.538461538462, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5470.923076923077, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1514, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1753, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12740, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 142, 96, 114, 156, 127, 157, 113, 115, 98, 111, 141, 81, 66, 155, 83, 68, 143 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7285, "avg_search_time_ms": 809.4444444444445, "search_nodes": 68736, "safety_nodes": 337, "corridor_nodes": 1366, "corridor_branch_probes": 1654, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 601, "corridor_neutral_exits": 12, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 1341, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1341, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 67, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 601, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 67, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 547, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 20278560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 70439, "avg_nodes": 7826.555555555556, "eval_calls": 50812, "avg_eval_calls": 5645.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50812, "pattern_eval_ns": 1103703, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.721305990710857, "pattern_frame_queries": 50812, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1103703, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.721305990710857, "pattern_frame_updates": 137398, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1847950772, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13449.61915020597, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16958, "avg_candidate_generations": 1884.2222222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 1176395, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.37109328930299, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 544, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 16949, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1175851, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 453159, "avg_legality_checks": 50351.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 922, "root_legality_checks": 544, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 452615, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 920, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1898159, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 210906.55555555556, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4378118193, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2306.5076176442544, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18617, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2068.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 112385918, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6036.736208841381, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 986, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7763417, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8619, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 77731919, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8735, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25190493, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 277, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1700089, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 53578, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5953.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 508828093, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9496.95944230841, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 74814, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8312.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 220317956, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2944.8760392439917, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1181947968, "stage_ordering_ns": 536173067, "stage_eval_ns": 1849054475, "stage_threat_ns": 3409503020, "stage_proof_ns": 283070747, "tactical_annotations": 254204, "root_tactical_annotations": 1388, "search_tactical_annotations": 252816, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 140223, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 898621547, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 308206, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2360701985, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34780, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1470299013, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 70107, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 108840399, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2816, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 15290655, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 140214, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18676282, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 61658, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 87713411, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 131704, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 589140314, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 60842, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7372152, "child_limit_applications": 16949, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16949, "child_cap_hits": 16949, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16949, "child_moves_before_total": 1174931, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1174931, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 271899, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 271899, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.32155289397605, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.042185379668418, "tt_hits": 7092, "tt_cutoffs": 938, "beta_cutoffs": 13639, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3103.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3992.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 263, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5446, "avg_search_time_ms": 680.75, "search_nodes": 37348, "safety_nodes": 785, "corridor_nodes": 641, "corridor_branch_probes": 751, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 336, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 635, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 635, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 12, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 6, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 336, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 12, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 11, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 26, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2019440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 38774, "avg_nodes": 4846.75, "eval_calls": 22026, "avg_eval_calls": 2753.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22026, "pattern_eval_ns": 489703, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.23295196585853, "pattern_frame_queries": 22026, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 489703, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.23295196585853, "pattern_frame_updates": 74606, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 918668978, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12313.60718977026, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13858, "avg_candidate_generations": 1732.25, "candidate_moves_total": 975094, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.36325588107952, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 483, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 13850, "search_candidate_moves_total": 974611, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 571334, "avg_legality_checks": 71416.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1170, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 571334, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1170, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1562239, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 195279.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3496910158, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2238.396402855133, "renju_forbidden_checks": 16722, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2090.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 70492575, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4215.558844635809, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1272, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11758560, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4025, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38052046, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11412, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 20666499, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 15470, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 61422, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7677.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 602131748, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9803.193448601478, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84860, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10607.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 268484189, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3163.8485623379684, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1473676306, "stage_ordering_ns": 444751668, "stage_eval_ns": 919158681, "stage_threat_ns": 2563898577, "stage_proof_ns": 15565407, "tactical_annotations": 239257, "root_tactical_annotations": 428, "search_tactical_annotations": 238829, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 75908, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 497107584, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 243679, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1983633233, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 28056, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1129403084, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 59903529, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1294, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7416678, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 75900, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10279928, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 34097, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 140805680, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 150221, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 687845085, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 54939, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5557625, "child_limit_applications": 13850, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13850, "child_cap_hits": 13850, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13850, "child_moves_before_total": 973441, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 973441, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 151736, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 151736, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.2845487364621, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.955667870036102, "tt_hits": 5735, "tt_cutoffs": 1428, "beta_cutoffs": 11418, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3351.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4351.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1754, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 32602, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 12, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 17, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 128, 110, 96, 80, 142, 125, 95, 97, 114, 156, 111, 127, 113, 115, 98, 124, 123, 143, 82, 66, 109, 81, 144, 160, 129, 159, 68, 83, 100, 86, 84, 99, 116, 52, 132 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 25479, "avg_search_time_ms": 1498.764705882353, "search_nodes": 243119, "safety_nodes": 440, "corridor_nodes": 1510, "corridor_branch_probes": 1617, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 906, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1504, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1504, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 39, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 906, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 39, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 289, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4121440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2025520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 245069, "avg_nodes": 14415.823529411764, "eval_calls": 156627, "avg_eval_calls": 9213.35294117647, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 156627, "pattern_eval_ns": 3448850, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.019511323079673, "pattern_frame_queries": 156627, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3448850, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.019511323079673, "pattern_frame_updates": 486076, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6475785592, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13322.578345773089, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 81097, "avg_candidate_generations": 4770.411764705882, "candidate_moves_total": 6765951, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.43034884151078, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1204, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 81080, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6764747, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 1691273, "avg_legality_checks": 99486.64705882352, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1156, "root_legality_checks": 1204, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1690069, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1156, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6584548, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 387326.35294117645, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14819705410, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2250.679228095839, "renju_forbidden_checks": 38648, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2273.4117647058824, "renju_forbidden_ns": 151274051, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3914.1495290830057, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1482, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10282290, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 19821, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 100041409, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17069, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39902790, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 276, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1047562, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 152120, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8948.235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1180620063, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7761.1100644228245, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 183672, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10804.235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 388985188, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2117.825188379285, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4231532299, "stage_ordering_ns": 2812559988, "stage_eval_ns": 6479234442, "stage_threat_ns": 11699192051, "stage_proof_ns": 174248579, "tactical_annotations": 1873776, "root_tactical_annotations": 4832, "search_tactical_annotations": 1868944, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 489179, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2968271950, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1520304, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8190275249, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 162934, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5748349867, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 244581, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 376563577, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3086, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 21018306, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 489162, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64450470, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 525436, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 368731831, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 772606, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1927467477, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 575734, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 78612499, "child_limit_applications": 81080, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 81080, "child_cap_hits": 81080, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 81080, "child_moves_before_total": 6763591, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6763591, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 863629, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 863629, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.41873458312777, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.651566354218057, "tt_hits": 42940, "tt_cutoffs": 5333, "beta_cutoffs": 63893, "depth_sum": 78, "avg_depth": 4.588235294117647, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 78, "avg_effective_depth": 4.588235294117647, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1979.1176470588234, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2449.705882352941, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 7106, "avg_search_time_ms": 444.125, "search_nodes": 57313, "safety_nodes": 1421, "corridor_nodes": 64, "corridor_branch_probes": 69, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 12, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 59, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 59, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 63, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 68, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 440, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 198880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 15440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 58798, "avg_nodes": 3674.875, "eval_calls": 38136, "avg_eval_calls": 2383.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38136, "pattern_eval_ns": 846883, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.206917348437173, "pattern_frame_queries": 38136, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 846883, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.206917348437173, "pattern_frame_updates": 114476, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1222761218, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10681.376166183305, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18001, "avg_candidate_generations": 1125.0625, "candidate_moves_total": 1387490, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.07849563913116, "candidate_moves_max": 112, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1130, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 17985, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1386360, "search_candidate_moves_max": 112, "legality_checks": 759845, "avg_legality_checks": 47490.3125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1961, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 759845, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1961, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2015406, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 125962.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4510154584, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2237.8392165151836, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10740, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 671.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 63831980, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5943.3873370577285, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1963, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 21783442, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3012, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29682696, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5728, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11902019, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 37, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 463823, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 74040, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4627.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 706001195, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9535.402417612102, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 97221, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6076.3125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 305360801, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3140.893438660372, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1962586241, "stage_ordering_ns": 604914976, "stage_eval_ns": 1223608101, "stage_threat_ns": 3139960808, "stage_proof_ns": 125443348, "tactical_annotations": 328135, "root_tactical_annotations": 966, "search_tactical_annotations": 327169, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 114746, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 715723432, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 313216, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2313298218, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 36388, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1349605839, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57365, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 88040297, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 254, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1410665, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 114730, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15003833, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 100002, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 361152207, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 171311, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 598459286, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 56822, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6484363, "child_limit_applications": 17985, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17985, "child_cap_hits": 17985, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17985, "child_moves_before_total": 1384399, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1384399, "child_moves_before_max": 112, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 112, "child_moves_after_total": 288292, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 288292, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.97520155685294, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.029580205726994, "tt_hits": 6269, "tt_cutoffs": 1117, "beta_cutoffs": 15492, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5860.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6360.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1707, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1755, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21248, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 81, 68, 111, 113, 94, 54, 40, 78, 140, 154, 95, 85, 86, 125, 109, 108, 123, 67, 137 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 11848, "avg_search_time_ms": 987.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 116790, "safety_nodes": 363, "corridor_nodes": 3937, "corridor_branch_probes": 4383, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1746, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 3904, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3904, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 89, "corridor_proof_active": 33, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1746, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 89, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 86, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 696, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24054320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 121090, "avg_nodes": 10090.833333333334, "eval_calls": 87969, "avg_eval_calls": 7330.75, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87969, "pattern_eval_ns": 1906606, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.673612295240368, "pattern_frame_queries": 87969, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1906606, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.673612295240368, "pattern_frame_updates": 233476, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2859992118, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12249.619309907657, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27112, "avg_candidate_generations": 2259.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2294410, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.62710239008557, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 888, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 27100, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2293522, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 793313, "avg_legality_checks": 66109.41666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1317, "root_legality_checks": 888, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 792425, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1315, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3181872, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 265156.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7077470053, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2224.3101083261677, "renju_forbidden_checks": 34410, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2867.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 205559168, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5973.820633536762, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1890, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16476722, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17342, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 130845927, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14144, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 48414306, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1034, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 9822213, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 80349, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6695.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 768418764, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9563.513721390435, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109539, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9128.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 338729533, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3092.319018796958, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1988986372, "stage_ordering_ns": 955352356, "stage_eval_ns": 2861898724, "stage_threat_ns": 5385527148, "stage_proof_ns": 607156173, "tactical_annotations": 409427, "root_tactical_annotations": 2522, "search_tactical_annotations": 406905, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 241474, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1474539236, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 583837, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3639101583, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56364, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2089254573, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 120731, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 179594471, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7986, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 48170988, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 241462, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30273021, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 107326, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 188551801, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 196198, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 764664396, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 105903, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13847849, "child_limit_applications": 27100, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27100, "child_cap_hits": 27100, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27100, "child_moves_before_total": 2292207, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2292207, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 434041, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 434041, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.58328413284133, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.016273062730626, "tt_hits": 11949, "tt_cutoffs": 1669, "beta_cutoffs": 21341, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4531.916666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5198.583333333333, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 832, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9387, "avg_search_time_ms": 853.3636363636364, "search_nodes": 68771, "safety_nodes": 1125, "corridor_nodes": 1077, "corridor_branch_probes": 1213, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 7, "corridor_depth_exits": 530, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1064, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1064, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 35, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 22, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 530, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 35, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 35, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 192, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 29972320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 70973, "avg_nodes": 6452.090909090909, "eval_calls": 42412, "avg_eval_calls": 3855.6363636363635, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 42412, "pattern_eval_ns": 948547, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.365061774969348, "pattern_frame_queries": 42412, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 948547, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.365061774969348, "pattern_frame_updates": 137416, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1551530155, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11290.753296559353, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23870, "avg_candidate_generations": 2170.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1902917, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.72002513615416, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 818, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 23859, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1902099, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1121710, "avg_legality_checks": 101973.63636363637, "illegal_moves_skipped": 874, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1121710, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 874, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2695819, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 245074.45454545456, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6066090971, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2250.184812481847, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18351, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1668.2727272727273, "renju_forbidden_ns": 98403297, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5362.285270557462, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1169, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11926528, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6410, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60951458, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10762, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25409868, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 115443, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90546, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8231.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 853496055, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9426.104466238156, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 120195, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10926.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 361665900, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3008.992886559341, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2843926747, "stage_ordering_ns": 817588168, "stage_eval_ns": 1552478702, "stage_threat_ns": 4066257706, "stage_proof_ns": 53896115, "tactical_annotations": 359933, "root_tactical_annotations": 947, "search_tactical_annotations": 358986, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 139625, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 889936584, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 368683, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3024695898, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48341, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1831593363, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 69807, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 109412249, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2198, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12819010, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 139614, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18323956, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 63162, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 300289093, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 201576, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 855236615, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 95195, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11070009, "child_limit_applications": 23859, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23859, "child_cap_hits": 23859, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23859, "child_moves_before_total": 1901225, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1901225, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 241768, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 241768, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.68586277714908, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.133199212037386, "tt_hits": 11619, "tt_cutoffs": 2437, "beta_cutoffs": 19009, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3540.3636363636365, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4267.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 68, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1756, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18675, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 13, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 18, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 126, 82, 98, 84, 110, 83, 85, 68, 111, 109, 142, 94, 127, 80, 81, 54, 40, 157, 113, 114, 99, 141, 71 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14208, "avg_search_time_ms": 1291.6363636363637, "search_nodes": 128608, "safety_nodes": 336, "corridor_nodes": 2237, "corridor_branch_probes": 2522, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 865, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 2215, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2215, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 865, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 422, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4257200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 131181, "avg_nodes": 11925.545454545454, "eval_calls": 84074, "avg_eval_calls": 7643.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 84074, "pattern_eval_ns": 1748694, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.79946237838095, "pattern_frame_queries": 84074, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1748694, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.79946237838095, "pattern_frame_updates": 257106, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3518506493, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13685.042328844913, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41284, "avg_candidate_generations": 3753.090909090909, "candidate_moves_total": 3359487, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.3750363336886, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 747, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 41273, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3358740, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 978649, "avg_legality_checks": 88968.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1181, "root_legality_checks": 747, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 977902, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1179, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3962776, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 360252.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8623560967, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2176.1414137463235, "renju_forbidden_checks": 41035, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3730.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 263874898, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6430.483684659437, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1409, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12526734, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24042, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 195592080, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14995, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 50717860, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 589, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5038224, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 101432, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9221.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 900178904, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8874.70328890291, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 134404, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12218.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 384494041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2860.733616559031, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2372640378, "stage_ordering_ns": 1321894614, "stage_eval_ns": 3520255187, "stage_threat_ns": 6581763280, "stage_proof_ns": 365636265, "tactical_annotations": 685324, "root_tactical_annotations": 2500, "search_tactical_annotations": 682824, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 261657, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1570828331, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 669537, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4725773911, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 83924, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3120295503, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 130823, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 194890538, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4540, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 25313715, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 261646, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32845405, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 162668, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 287116976, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 281131, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 954807198, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 241525, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32111380, "child_limit_applications": 41273, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41273, "child_cap_hits": 41273, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41273, "child_moves_before_total": 3357561, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3357561, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 472093, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 472093, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.35005936084123, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.438301068495143, "tt_hits": 24133, "tt_cutoffs": 3206, "beta_cutoffs": 33196, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2345.818181818182, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3061.7272727272725, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 690, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 4453, "avg_search_time_ms": 445.3, "search_nodes": 48216, "safety_nodes": 951, "corridor_nodes": 1964, "corridor_branch_probes": 2226, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 28, "corridor_depth_exits": 968, "corridor_neutral_exits": 17, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1947, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1947, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 45, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 968, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 366, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 361040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 20960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 51131, "avg_nodes": 5113.1, "eval_calls": 34804, "avg_eval_calls": 3480.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34804, "pattern_eval_ns": 690921, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.851769911504423, "pattern_frame_queries": 34804, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 690921, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.851769911504423, "pattern_frame_updates": 96342, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 724127296, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7516.216146644247, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12832, "avg_candidate_generations": 1283.2, "candidate_moves_total": 983410, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.63731296758105, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 681, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 12822, "search_candidate_moves_total": 982729, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 528225, "avg_legality_checks": 52822.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 220, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 528225, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 220, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1431552, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 143155.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2719427629, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1899.6359398750446, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5046, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 504.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 21977700, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4355.4696789536265, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 308, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2886394, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1460, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12324793, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3268, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 6662921, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 103592, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 49251, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4925.1, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 433196595, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8795.69135652068, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 66232, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6623.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 195165395, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2946.6933657446552, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1151220778, "stage_ordering_ns": 348494547, "stage_eval_ns": 724818217, "stage_threat_ns": 2109393845, "stage_proof_ns": 85863057, "tactical_annotations": 190866, "root_tactical_annotations": 716, "search_tactical_annotations": 190150, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 100368, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 525586489, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 276324, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1480358699, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26678, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 841529520, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50179, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 64201210, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4016, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24402658, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 100358, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10714576, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 45961, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 204553890, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 104888, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 362307665, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 40017, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4130213, "child_limit_applications": 12822, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12822, "child_cap_hits": 12822, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12822, "child_moves_before_total": 982509, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 982509, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 208623, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 208623, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.6268132896584, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.27070659803463, "tt_hits": 4616, "tt_cutoffs": 545, "beta_cutoffs": 10569, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5087.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5887.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1866, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1757, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19065, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 82, 128, 68, 110, 97, 67, 84, 113, 83, 85, 69, 158, 143, 55, 54, 40, 39, 24, 99 ], "move_count": 23, "black_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 10661, "avg_search_time_ms": 1066.1, "search_nodes": 125805, "safety_nodes": 419, "corridor_nodes": 1607, "corridor_branch_probes": 1715, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 692, "corridor_neutral_exits": 28, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1584, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1584, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 74, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 51, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 28, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 692, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 74, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 71, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 575, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 45950480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1993440, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 127831, "avg_nodes": 12783.1, "eval_calls": 100958, "avg_eval_calls": 10095.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 100958, "pattern_eval_ns": 2086058, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.662631985578162, "pattern_frame_queries": 100958, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2086058, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.662631985578162, "pattern_frame_updates": 251526, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3208979868, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12758.044369170582, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23808, "avg_candidate_generations": 2380.8, "candidate_moves_total": 1750916, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.54317876344086, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 635, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 23798, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1750281, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 790438, "avg_legality_checks": 79043.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 565, "root_legality_checks": 635, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 789803, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 565, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3104204, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 310420.4, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6436912168, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2073.6111956559557, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27114, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2711.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 106700706, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3935.262447444125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 843, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5426400, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13791, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 80683285, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12328, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19621058, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 152, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 969963, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 86369, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8636.9, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 716146944, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8291.71281362526, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 115015, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11501.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 300164615, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2609.786679998261, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1871649827, "stage_ordering_ns": 713018973, "stage_eval_ns": 3211065926, "stage_threat_ns": 4534786126, "stage_proof_ns": 283482911, "tactical_annotations": 365305, "root_tactical_annotations": 1793, "search_tactical_annotations": 363512, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 254852, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1434184740, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 434118, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2865610440, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48744, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1691874888, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 127421, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 176228470, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3316, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18674723, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 254842, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30634827, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96770, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 151930900, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 194260, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 806420456, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 74275, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9452926, "child_limit_applications": 23798, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23798, "child_cap_hits": 23798, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23798, "child_moves_before_total": 1749716, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1749716, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 380982, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 380982, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.5236574502059, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.008992352298513, "tt_hits": 8879, "tt_cutoffs": 1007, "beta_cutoffs": 17171, "depth_sum": 42, "avg_depth": 4.2, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 42, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3031.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3831.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 429, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 8394, "avg_search_time_ms": 932.6666666666666, "search_nodes": 63371, "safety_nodes": 752, "corridor_nodes": 179, "corridor_branch_probes": 223, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 45, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 173, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 173, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 22, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 16, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 45, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 22, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 149, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4009120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 64302, "avg_nodes": 7144.666666666667, "eval_calls": 37809, "avg_eval_calls": 4201.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 37809, "pattern_eval_ns": 817946, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.6336322039726, "pattern_frame_queries": 37809, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 817946, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.6336322039726, "pattern_frame_updates": 126648, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1422644232, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11233.05722948645, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23308, "avg_candidate_generations": 2589.777777777778, "candidate_moves_total": 1761394, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.57036210743092, "candidate_moves_max": 102, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 564, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 23299, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1760830, "search_candidate_moves_max": 102, "legality_checks": 972152, "avg_legality_checks": 108016.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 546, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 972152, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 546, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2540455, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 282272.77777777775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5391437172, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2122.232896075703, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14751, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1639.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 49104858, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3328.917225950783, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 558, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5548625, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3557, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29606623, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10636, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13949610, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90528, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10058.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 838606707, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9263.50639581124, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 123063, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13673.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 379257673, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3081.817223698431, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2358011822, "stage_ordering_ns": 733656090, "stage_eval_ns": 1423462178, "stage_threat_ns": 3789069113, "stage_proof_ns": 38569473, "tactical_annotations": 393041, "root_tactical_annotations": 789, "search_tactical_annotations": 392252, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 127047, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 776268576, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 373742, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2890102009, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46846, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1686378961, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 63519, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94716720, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 390, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2202197, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 127038, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16328487, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 66895, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 243860818, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 246467, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 948796991, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79679, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9451124, "child_limit_applications": 23299, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23299, "child_cap_hits": 23299, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23299, "child_moves_before_total": 1760284, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1760284, "child_moves_before_max": 102, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 102, "child_moves_after_total": 229598, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 229598, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.55191209923173, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.85441435254732, "tt_hits": 9286, "tt_cutoffs": 2217, "beta_cutoffs": 18892, "depth_sum": 46, "avg_depth": 5.111111111111111, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 46, "avg_effective_depth": 5.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2931.8888888888887, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3820.777777777778, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1758, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16096, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 14, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 19, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 96, 114, 80, 128, 82, 100, 142, 86, 72, 143, 83, 81, 110, 113, 158, 126, 124, 68, 138 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10529, "avg_search_time_ms": 1169.888888888889, "search_nodes": 94419, "safety_nodes": 517, "corridor_nodes": 2488, "corridor_branch_probes": 2723, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1050, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2473, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2473, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 44, "corridor_proof_active": 15, "corridor_proof_quiet": 29, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1050, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 44, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 44, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 311, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4245120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 97424, "avg_nodes": 10824.888888888889, "eval_calls": 59794, "avg_eval_calls": 6643.777777777777, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 59794, "pattern_eval_ns": 1239472, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.729036358163025, "pattern_frame_queries": 59794, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1239472, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.729036358163025, "pattern_frame_updates": 188748, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2153944161, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11411.745613198551, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32039, "avg_candidate_generations": 3559.8888888888887, "candidate_moves_total": 2610196, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.46933424888417, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 639, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 32030, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2609557, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 893043, "avg_legality_checks": 99227.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1037, "root_legality_checks": 639, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 892404, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1037, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3181654, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 353517.1111111111, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6527681178, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2051.6628074580076, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36206, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4022.8888888888887, "renju_forbidden_ns": 133119119, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3676.714329116721, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1282, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11382798, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12066, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 70292743, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22248, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 47737803, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 610, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3705775, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 84160, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9351.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 753198334, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8949.59997623574, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 110289, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12254.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 331899235, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3009.3593649412, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2064087885, "stage_ordering_ns": 965110537, "stage_eval_ns": 2155183633, "stage_threat_ns": 4947113306, "stage_proof_ns": 353502991, "tactical_annotations": 466554, "root_tactical_annotations": 1469, "search_tactical_annotations": 465085, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 193791, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1091270997, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 512472, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3646399494, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 65470, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2270157752, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 96891, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 136546231, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5034, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 27238906, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 193782, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22656635, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70300, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 131884805, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 229267, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 853654480, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 166987, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23001043, "child_limit_applications": 32030, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32030, "child_cap_hits": 32030, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32030, "child_moves_before_total": 2608520, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2608520, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 324978, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 324978, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.43990009366219, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.146050577583516, "tt_hits": 17626, "tt_cutoffs": 2550, "beta_cutoffs": 25467, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2216.777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3054.1111111111113, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 523, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5556, "avg_search_time_ms": 694.5, "search_nodes": 40335, "safety_nodes": 660, "corridor_nodes": 1180, "corridor_branch_probes": 1449, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 5, "corridor_depth_exits": 503, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1159, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1159, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 503, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 59, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 436, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 217120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 17840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 42175, "avg_nodes": 5271.875, "eval_calls": 26794, "avg_eval_calls": 3349.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 26794, "pattern_eval_ns": 565667, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.111704112861087, "pattern_frame_queries": 26794, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 565667, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.111704112861087, "pattern_frame_updates": 80600, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 768160807, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9530.531104218362, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12783, "avg_candidate_generations": 1597.875, "candidate_moves_total": 1111202, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.92810764296331, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 12775, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1110622, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 769879, "avg_legality_checks": 96234.875, "illegal_moves_skipped": 78, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 769879, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 78, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1763707, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 220463.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3678221414, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2085.5059338087335, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25329, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3166.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 51200242, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2021.4079513601012, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 126, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1016122, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2406, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 14011186, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22797, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36172934, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 71684, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8960.5, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 708284155, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9880.644983538865, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92292, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11536.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 330435706, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3580.3288042300524, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1824630138, "stage_ordering_ns": 440608604, "stage_eval_ns": 768726474, "stage_threat_ns": 2387944801, "stage_proof_ns": 97326689, "tactical_annotations": 213924, "root_tactical_annotations": 1077, "search_tactical_annotations": 212847, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 83044, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 492672804, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 261098, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1805906118, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26309, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 905225323, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 41518, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 60472903, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2436, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12331226, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 83036, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9981633, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70845, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 440782358, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 93611, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 407251260, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49468, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6580117, "child_limit_applications": 12775, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12775, "child_cap_hits": 12775, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12775, "child_moves_before_total": 1110544, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1110544, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 204662, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 204662, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.93103718199609, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02050880626223, "tt_hits": 5722, "tt_cutoffs": 731, "beta_cutoffs": 11053, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 4.375, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 4.375, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3805.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4805.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1842, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1759, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12075, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 110, 128, 82, 124, 111, 109, 97, 67, 98, 127, 125, 129, 130, 139, 99, 95, 100 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 6686, "avg_search_time_ms": 742.8888888888889, "search_nodes": 66963, "safety_nodes": 336, "corridor_nodes": 1196, "corridor_branch_probes": 1347, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 513, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 1173, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1173, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 67, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 513, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 67, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 547, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 20276560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1996320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 68495, "avg_nodes": 7610.555555555556, "eval_calls": 49573, "avg_eval_calls": 5508.111111111111, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 49573, "pattern_eval_ns": 1015090, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.47667076836181, "pattern_frame_queries": 49573, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1015090, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.47667076836181, "pattern_frame_updates": 133852, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1805940307, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13492.06815736784, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16453, "avg_candidate_generations": 1828.111111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 1131264, "avg_candidate_moves": 68.75730869750197, "candidate_moves_max": 94, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 543, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 16444, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1130721, "search_candidate_moves_max": 94, "legality_checks": 422936, "avg_legality_checks": 46992.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 783, "root_legality_checks": 543, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 422393, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 781, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1871116, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 207901.77777777778, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4054772859, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2167.034464458644, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19139, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2126.5555555555557, "renju_forbidden_ns": 106703261, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5575.174303777627, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1009, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 7346574, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8353, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72032550, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9429, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 25104625, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 348, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2219512, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51177, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5686.333333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 473200716, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9246.355120464272, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72536, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8059.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 209863423, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2893.2312644755707, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1033144049, "stage_ordering_ns": 479833782, "stage_eval_ns": 1806955397, "stage_threat_ns": 3094024437, "stage_proof_ns": 249286062, "tactical_annotations": 249890, "root_tactical_annotations": 1388, "search_tactical_annotations": 248502, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 136341, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 825290776, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 293454, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2131689106, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33728, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1328937889, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 68166, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99668433, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2480, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13166910, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 136332, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 17231295, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 59519, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 79805481, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 128940, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 548547275, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 61431, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6977917, "child_limit_applications": 16444, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16444, "child_cap_hits": 16444, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16444, "child_moves_before_total": 1129940, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1129940, "child_moves_before_max": 93, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 93, "child_moves_after_total": 265656, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 265656, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 68.71442471418146, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.155193383604963, "tt_hits": 7012, "tt_cutoffs": 909, "beta_cutoffs": 13202, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3395.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4284.222222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 409, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5380, "avg_search_time_ms": 672.5, "search_nodes": 39245, "safety_nodes": 785, "corridor_nodes": 623, "corridor_branch_probes": 718, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 332, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_plies_followed": 617, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 617, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 12, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 6, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 332, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 12, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 11, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 26, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2020880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 40653, "avg_nodes": 5081.625, "eval_calls": 23444, "avg_eval_calls": 2930.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 23444, "pattern_eval_ns": 491110, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.948217027810955, "pattern_frame_queries": 23444, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 491110, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.948217027810955, "pattern_frame_updates": 78400, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 931671852, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11883.569540816326, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 14423, "avg_candidate_generations": 1802.875, "candidate_moves_total": 1015162, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.38494071968384, "candidate_moves_max": 98, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 483, "root_candidate_moves_max": 72, "search_candidate_generations": 14415, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1014679, "search_candidate_moves_max": 98, "legality_checks": 598364, "avg_legality_checks": 74795.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1120, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 598364, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1120, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1673502, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 209187.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3466230759, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2071.2438700401913, "renju_forbidden_checks": 17714, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2214.25, "renju_forbidden_ns": 71702634, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4047.7946257197696, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1352, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11946944, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4279, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 37998763, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12070, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21742306, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 13, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 14621, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 68271, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8533.875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 643570254, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9426.700268049392, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 96415, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12051.875, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 293285368, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3041.9060104755486, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1435203280, "stage_ordering_ns": 420935340, "stage_eval_ns": 932162962, "stage_threat_ns": 2548278495, "stage_proof_ns": 14929433, "tactical_annotations": 261695, "root_tactical_annotations": 428, "search_tactical_annotations": 261267, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 79666, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 487719488, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 261245, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1979193063, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 29174, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1080607829, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 39829, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 58990989, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1258, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6830415, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 79658, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 10089324, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 37180, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 133704164, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 165228, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 741688703, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 59287, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5455216, "child_limit_applications": 14415, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 14415, "child_cap_hits": 14415, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 14415, "child_moves_before_total": 1013559, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1013559, "child_moves_before_max": 98, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 98, "child_moves_after_total": 163526, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 163526, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.31279916753383, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.344155393687132, "tt_hits": 5857, "tt_cutoffs": 1342, "beta_cutoffs": 11873, "depth_sum": 44, "avg_depth": 5.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 44, "avg_effective_depth": 5.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3374.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4374.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1760, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26197, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 15, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 20, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 96, 142, 80, 128, 110, 114, 156, 100, 86, 129, 125, 95, 82, 68, 124, 138, 64, 48, 140, 130, 127, 132, 131, 84, 116, 99, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 18640, "avg_search_time_ms": 1433.8461538461538, "search_nodes": 156608, "safety_nodes": 787, "corridor_nodes": 2295, "corridor_branch_probes": 2727, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1017, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2276, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2276, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 43, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 24, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1017, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 43, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 43, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 299, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4257040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2014000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 159690, "avg_nodes": 12283.846153846154, "eval_calls": 96129, "avg_eval_calls": 7394.538461538462, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 96129, "pattern_eval_ns": 2012359, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.933942930853334, "pattern_frame_queries": 96129, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2012359, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.933942930853334, "pattern_frame_updates": 313064, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4299669481, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13734.154936370838, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 55313, "avg_candidate_generations": 4254.846153846154, "candidate_moves_total": 4988931, "avg_candidate_moves": 90.19454739392187, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1110, "root_candidate_moves_max": 113, "search_candidate_generations": 55300, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4987821, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 1417912, "avg_legality_checks": 109070.15384615384, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1350, "root_legality_checks": 1110, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1416802, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1350, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5187283, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 399021.76923076925, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 11279853465, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2174.5205466908205, "renju_forbidden_checks": 53070, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4082.3076923076924, "renju_forbidden_ns": 328212623, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6184.522762389297, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1455, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13744494, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 26015, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 215927685, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25208, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 94865602, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 392, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3674842, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 132387, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10183.615384615385, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1268696032, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9583.237266498976, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 186021, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14309.307692307691, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 599228569, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3221.295278490063, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3454455641, "stage_ordering_ns": 1932068303, "stage_eval_ns": 4301681840, "stage_threat_ns": 8570000801, "stage_proof_ns": 318779606, "tactical_annotations": 1042095, "root_tactical_annotations": 3208, "search_tactical_annotations": 1038887, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 317715, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1906464532, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 891211, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6313283230, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 111782, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4114321186, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 158851, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 235727453, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4638, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 27603973, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 317702, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 40022997, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 187128, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 272235726, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 462037, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1596937113, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 392930, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 46898616, "child_limit_applications": 55300, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 55300, "child_cap_hits": 55300, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 55300, "child_moves_before_total": 4986471, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4986471, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 598854, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 598854, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 90.1712658227848, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.829186256781194, "tt_hits": 33318, "tt_cutoffs": 5106, "beta_cutoffs": 45360, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 5.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23076923076923078, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1622.3846153846155, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2192.6153846153848, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7546, "avg_search_time_ms": 580.4615384615385, "search_nodes": 52839, "safety_nodes": 1563, "corridor_nodes": 1123, "corridor_branch_probes": 1271, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 513, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 1102, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1102, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 64, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 43, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 513, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 64, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 441, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 282560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 55525, "avg_nodes": 4271.153846153846, "eval_calls": 35520, "avg_eval_calls": 2732.3076923076924, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35520, "pattern_eval_ns": 746941, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.02874436936937, "pattern_frame_queries": 35520, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 746941, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.02874436936937, "pattern_frame_updates": 105564, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1091650601, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10341.1257720435, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 16256, "avg_candidate_generations": 1250.4615384615386, "candidate_moves_total": 1459494, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.78186515748031, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1138, "root_candidate_moves_max": 112, "search_candidate_generations": 16243, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1458356, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 1032883, "avg_legality_checks": 79452.53846153847, "illegal_moves_skipped": 102, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1032883, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 102, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2418646, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 186049.6923076923, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5050651217, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2088.214321980149, "renju_forbidden_checks": 7158, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 550.6153846153846, "renju_forbidden_ns": 24755648, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3458.4587873707737, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 102, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 705764, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1966, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16373888, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5090, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7675996, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99494, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7653.384615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1039674278, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10449.61784630229, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 147726, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11363.538461538461, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 521183569, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3528.0422471332063, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2477133688, "stage_ordering_ns": 591690775, "stage_eval_ns": 1092397542, "stage_threat_ns": 3220225577, "stage_proof_ns": 103613602, "tactical_annotations": 284546, "root_tactical_annotations": 1136, "search_tactical_annotations": 283410, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 107909, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 644744200, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 328980, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2465921451, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 33256, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1151253095, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 53948, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 77665161, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2332, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 12651895, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 107896, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 13088960, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 81118, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 514559873, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 151712, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 751350731, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 51716, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6153910, "child_limit_applications": 16243, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 16243, "child_cap_hits": 16243, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 16243, "child_moves_before_total": 1458254, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1458254, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 260281, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 260281, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.7773810256726, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.024195037862462, "tt_hits": 6271, "tt_cutoffs": 1019, "beta_cutoffs": 13944, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 4.384615384615385, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4978.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5593.384615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1842, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1761, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18551, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 144, 96, 114, 68, 110, 100, 113, 111, 99, 84, 116, 115, 130, 36, 52, 54, 40, 158, 129, 159, 127, 126, 131 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 10767, "avg_search_time_ms": 897.25, "search_nodes": 125121, "safety_nodes": 513, "corridor_nodes": 3080, "corridor_branch_probes": 3758, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1372, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 3051, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3051, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 79, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1372, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 79, "corridor_proof_wins": 4, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 75, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 586, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26046880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2018000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 4, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 128714, "avg_nodes": 10726.166666666666, "eval_calls": 95935, "avg_eval_calls": 7994.583333333333, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 95935, "pattern_eval_ns": 1923475, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.04977328399437, "pattern_frame_queries": 95935, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1923475, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.04977328399437, "pattern_frame_updates": 250138, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2772514965, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11083.941524278598, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27448, "avg_candidate_generations": 2287.3333333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 2276898, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.95314777032935, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 886, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 27436, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2276012, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 928666, "avg_legality_checks": 77388.83333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1173, "root_legality_checks": 886, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 927780, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1173, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3327725, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 277310.4166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6355332817, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1909.8131056502566, "renju_forbidden_checks": 47944, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3995.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 288650510, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6020.5762973469045, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2943, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 27339801, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21286, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 173713462, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22881, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 81467132, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 834, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6130115, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 91138, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7594.833333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 732042641, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8032.243860958108, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 120579, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10048.25, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 306061188, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2538.262782076481, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1905295504, "stage_ordering_ns": 813809124, "stage_eval_ns": 2774438440, "stage_threat_ns": 4786187985, "stage_proof_ns": 436980685, "tactical_annotations": 496641, "root_tactical_annotations": 2166, "search_tactical_annotations": 494475, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 256410, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1329404711, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 612279, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3214225101, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56518, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1848304480, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 128199, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 167887195, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6260, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 33412649, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 256398, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 27976149, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 158771, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 217438464, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 221294, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 729125335, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 116576, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13282180, "child_limit_applications": 27436, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27436, "child_cap_hits": 27436, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27436, "child_moves_before_total": 2274839, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2274839, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 439737, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 439737, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.91438256305584, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.027737279486807, "tt_hits": 10831, "tt_cutoffs": 1698, "beta_cutoffs": 21185, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4564.583333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5231.25, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 837, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 7773, "avg_search_time_ms": 706.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 65921, "safety_nodes": 1044, "corridor_nodes": 780, "corridor_branch_probes": 871, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 24, "corridor_depth_exits": 298, "corridor_neutral_exits": 20, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 767, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 767, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 31, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 44, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 298, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 31, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 31, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 177, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 21968640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2011520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 67745, "avg_nodes": 6158.636363636364, "eval_calls": 41253, "avg_eval_calls": 3750.2727272727275, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 41253, "pattern_eval_ns": 839432, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.34838678399147, "pattern_frame_queries": 41253, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 839432, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.34838678399147, "pattern_frame_updates": 131716, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1382139664, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10493.33159221355, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22576, "avg_candidate_generations": 2052.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 1813938, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.34806874557052, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 813, "root_candidate_moves_max": 95, "search_candidate_generations": 22565, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1813125, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1056502, "avg_legality_checks": 96045.63636363637, "illegal_moves_skipped": 606, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1056502, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 606, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2704212, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 245837.45454545456, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4965842630, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1836.3362894625125, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30009, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2728.090909090909, "renju_forbidden_ns": 107943288, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3597.030490852744, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1579, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13027161, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7236, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 51950854, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 21155, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42581791, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 39, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 383482, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 103672, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9424.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 812520936, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7837.419322478587, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 137161, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12469.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 344129064, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2508.942512813409, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2190542932, "stage_ordering_ns": 644878058, "stage_eval_ns": 1382979096, "stage_threat_ns": 3469582256, "stage_proof_ns": 34561903, "tactical_annotations": 423202, "root_tactical_annotations": 984, "search_tactical_annotations": 422218, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 133323, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 711303827, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 415528, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2637072004, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 45709, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1479750510, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 66656, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 87850931, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1596, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8460657, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 133312, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15025568, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 83756, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 285777004, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 238890, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 841587592, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 100556, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9869269, "child_limit_applications": 22565, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22565, "child_cap_hits": 22565, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22565, "child_moves_before_total": 1812519, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1812519, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 250302, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 250302, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.32435187236871, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.092488366939952, "tt_hits": 10379, "tt_cutoffs": 2040, "beta_cutoffs": 18401, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4259.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4987.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 635, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1762, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19799, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 16, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 21, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 128, 82, 96, 80, 114, 81, 79, 66, 113, 115, 142, 100, 127, 84, 83, 50, 34, 157, 111, 110, 95, 143, 63 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14774, "avg_search_time_ms": 1343.090909090909, "search_nodes": 132967, "safety_nodes": 336, "corridor_nodes": 2674, "corridor_branch_probes": 2951, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1058, "corridor_neutral_exits": 14, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 2652, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2652, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 55, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 33, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1058, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 55, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 422, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4257200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 135977, "avg_nodes": 12361.545454545454, "eval_calls": 87195, "avg_eval_calls": 7926.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87195, "pattern_eval_ns": 1803278, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.68097941395722, "pattern_frame_queries": 87195, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1803278, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.68097941395722, "pattern_frame_updates": 265824, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3612213684, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13588.741738894907, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42545, "avg_candidate_generations": 3867.7272727272725, "candidate_moves_total": 3454938, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.20667528499236, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 747, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 42534, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3454191, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 1028657, "avg_legality_checks": 93514.27272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1176, "root_legality_checks": 747, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 1027910, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1174, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4151548, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 377413.45454545453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9007689185, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2169.7181834342273, "renju_forbidden_checks": 42852, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3895.6363636363635, "renju_forbidden_ns": 275487398, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6428.810743955942, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1411, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12545490, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 24750, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 201025250, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15854, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 54325439, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 837, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 7591219, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 107412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9764.727272727272, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 957084940, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8910.409823855807, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 141994, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12908.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 411313034, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2896.693057453132, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2471791590, "stage_ordering_ns": 1352699753, "stage_eval_ns": 3614016962, "stage_threat_ns": 6878952376, "stage_proof_ns": 411864070, "tactical_annotations": 695965, "root_tactical_annotations": 2500, "search_tactical_annotations": 693465, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 271249, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1627604741, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 707116, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4954702915, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 86692, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3228538848, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 135619, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 203802963, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5414, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 30625298, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 271238, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 33777785, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 163487, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 292703262, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 290681, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1000768279, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 241797, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 28438674, "child_limit_applications": 42534, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42534, "child_cap_hits": 42534, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42534, "child_moves_before_total": 3453017, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3453017, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 480614, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 480614, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.18251281327879, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.299525085813702, "tt_hits": 24363, "tt_cutoffs": 3183, "beta_cutoffs": 34173, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.45454545454545453, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1991.6363636363637, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2654.3636363636365, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 521, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 5014, "avg_search_time_ms": 501.4, "search_nodes": 48338, "safety_nodes": 951, "corridor_nodes": 1970, "corridor_branch_probes": 2246, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 28, "corridor_depth_exits": 968, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1953, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1953, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 61, "corridor_proof_active": 17, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 44, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 968, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 61, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 61, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 366, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 362560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 20960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 51259, "avg_nodes": 5125.9, "eval_calls": 34922, "avg_eval_calls": 3492.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34922, "pattern_eval_ns": 726043, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.79041864727106, "pattern_frame_queries": 34922, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 726043, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.79041864727106, "pattern_frame_updates": 96586, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 817563970, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8464.62189137142, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12879, "avg_candidate_generations": 1287.9, "candidate_moves_total": 986666, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.61045112198153, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 681, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 12869, "search_candidate_moves_total": 985985, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 531310, "avg_legality_checks": 53131.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 267, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 531310, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 267, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1437156, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 143715.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3057239043, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2127.2840547581472, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5232, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 523.2, "renju_forbidden_ns": 23870386, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4562.382645259939, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 355, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3497981, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1505, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13067610, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 3362, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7192615, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 112180, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50458, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5045.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 476001161, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9433.61134012446, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 67729, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6772.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 214369318, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3165.1038403047437, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1302539683, "stage_ordering_ns": 401494052, "stage_eval_ns": 818290013, "stage_threat_ns": 2374620261, "stage_proof_ns": 85502427, "tactical_annotations": 191504, "root_tactical_annotations": 716, "search_tactical_annotations": 190788, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 100624, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 607830653, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 278034, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1652768457, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26777, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 956592272, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50307, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73555782, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4028, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24221962, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 100614, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12148110, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 46897, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 233765905, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 104930, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 389981124, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 39677, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4095297, "child_limit_applications": 12869, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12869, "child_cap_hits": 12869, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12869, "child_moves_before_total": 985718, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 985718, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 208998, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 208998, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.59631673012666, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.240422721268164, "tt_hits": 4578, "tt_cutoffs": 502, "beta_cutoffs": 10608, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4889.8, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5689.8, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1879, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1763, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 12980, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 142, 86, 140, 98, 143, 144, 110, 158, 111, 100, 72, 113, 141, 139, 96, 81, 156 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 7106, "avg_search_time_ms": 789.5555555555555, "search_nodes": 72621, "safety_nodes": 159, "corridor_nodes": 5023, "corridor_branch_probes": 5611, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2334, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 4982, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4982, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 69, "corridor_proof_active": 41, "corridor_proof_quiet": 28, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2334, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 69, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 66, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 552, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 338640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14400, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 77803, "avg_nodes": 8644.777777777777, "eval_calls": 50739, "avg_eval_calls": 5637.666666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50739, "pattern_eval_ns": 972514, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.166991860304698, "pattern_frame_queries": 50739, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 972514, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.166991860304698, "pattern_frame_updates": 145168, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1632606482, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11246.324823652596, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 20727, "avg_candidate_generations": 2303.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1703271, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.17643653205963, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 643, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 20718, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1702628, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 477135, "avg_legality_checks": 53015.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2046, "root_legality_checks": 643, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "search_legality_checks": 476492, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2038, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2592449, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 288049.8888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4289777831, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1654.7202398195684, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33045, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3671.6666666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 267048468, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8081.357784838856, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2177, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23490830, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17348, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 163494164, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11998, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 63363189, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1522, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 16700285, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73726, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8191.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 548059572, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7433.735344383257, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 99925, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11102.777777777777, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 254894025, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2550.853390042532, "stage_move_gen_ns": 834728288, "stage_ordering_ns": 523246101, "stage_eval_ns": 1633578996, "stage_threat_ns": 3505825067, "stage_proof_ns": 573781703, "tactical_annotations": 323736, "root_tactical_annotations": 2058, "search_tactical_annotations": 321678, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 155279, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 736361841, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 568895, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2603166887, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 43846, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1366518957, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77635, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94760241, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10102, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 46725491, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 155270, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15390210, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 110531, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 159170143, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 133909, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 416171197, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 79296, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9420397, "child_limit_applications": 20718, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 20718, "child_cap_hits": 20718, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 20718, "child_moves_before_total": 1700590, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1700590, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 333417, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 333417, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.0827299932426, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.09310744280336, "tt_hits": 9793, "tt_cutoffs": 1127, "beta_cutoffs": 17481, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3975.777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4864.666666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1010, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5865, "avg_search_time_ms": 733.125, "search_nodes": 56522, "safety_nodes": 874, "corridor_nodes": 285, "corridor_branch_probes": 349, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 13, "corridor_depth_exits": 98, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 279, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 279, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 7, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 98, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 13, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 35, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 12013520, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 57681, "avg_nodes": 7210.125, "eval_calls": 33228, "avg_eval_calls": 4153.5, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 33228, "pattern_eval_ns": 645422, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.42403996629349, "pattern_frame_queries": 33228, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 645422, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.42403996629349, "pattern_frame_updates": 112960, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1205451945, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10671.493847379603, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21053, "avg_candidate_generations": 2631.625, "candidate_moves_total": 1689403, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.24523820833136, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 572, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 21045, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1688831, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 955689, "avg_legality_checks": 119461.125, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2966, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 955689, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2966, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2444340, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 305542.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3662484818, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1498.3532642758373, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31086, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3885.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 214952025, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6914.75342597954, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3148, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34516432, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 13638, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 135437977, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14260, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 44518133, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 479483, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 86286, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10785.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 606237084, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7025.903205618524, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118368, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14796.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 276824464, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2338.676534198432, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1581502641, "stage_ordering_ns": 488767456, "stage_eval_ns": 1206097367, "stage_threat_ns": 2533727710, "stage_proof_ns": 14305819, "tactical_annotations": 342204, "root_tactical_annotations": 464, "search_tactical_annotations": 341740, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 113552, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 502236599, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 302297, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1937713724, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 42316, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1109868436, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 56772, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 68298318, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 584, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2631721, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 113544, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11449733, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 58006, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 195827849, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 183745, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 620144714, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 100453, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11397615, "child_limit_applications": 21045, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21045, "child_cap_hits": 21045, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21045, "child_moves_before_total": 1685865, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1685865, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 229639, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 229639, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.10762651461155, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.911808030411024, "tt_hits": 10993, "tt_cutoffs": 2208, "beta_cutoffs": 17548, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 5.125, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 5.125, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.125, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3275.625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4275.625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1764, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 13432, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 17, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 22, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 126, 114, 98, 84, 141, 129, 99, 100, 140, 154, 142, 86, 72, 143, 111, 156, 158, 110, 157, 127, 125, 130, 131, 109, 139, 138, 153, 97, 167 ], "move_count": 31, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 11008, "avg_search_time_ms": 786.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 162616, "safety_nodes": 608, "corridor_nodes": 577, "corridor_branch_probes": 697, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 232, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 571, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 571, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 28, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 22, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 232, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 28, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 27, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 165, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6082800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2022320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 163801, "avg_nodes": 11700.07142857143, "eval_calls": 117729, "avg_eval_calls": 8409.214285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 117729, "pattern_eval_ns": 2270900, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.28921506170952, "pattern_frame_queries": 117729, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2270900, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.28921506170952, "pattern_frame_updates": 325096, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3388121449, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10421.910601791471, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42223, "avg_candidate_generations": 3015.9285714285716, "candidate_moves_total": 3658092, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.63742510006395, "candidate_moves_max": 124, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1042, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 42209, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3657050, "search_candidate_moves_max": 124, "legality_checks": 1212443, "avg_legality_checks": 86603.07142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7133, "root_legality_checks": 1042, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 1211401, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7127, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4536795, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 324056.78571428574, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6292016466, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1386.885778616843, "renju_forbidden_checks": 79742, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5695.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 358599079, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4496.991284392165, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7907, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 48484330, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 45930, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 248056641, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25734, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 61194086, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 171, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 864022, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 125135, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8938.214285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 708423474, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5661.273616494186, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 163630, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11687.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 307661745, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1880.2282283199902, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1891021879, "stage_ordering_ns": 937241790, "stage_eval_ns": 3390392349, "stage_threat_ns": 4657262010, "stage_proof_ns": 68234026, "tactical_annotations": 842172, "root_tactical_annotations": 3010, "search_tactical_annotations": 839162, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 326308, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1273955889, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 705278, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3145797396, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 84856, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2007931258, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 163147, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 172807198, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1198, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4239682, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 326294, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 29840454, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 223807, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 193409209, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 361057, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 889776492, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 257308, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30621391, "child_limit_applications": 42209, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42209, "child_cap_hits": 42209, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42209, "child_moves_before_total": 3649923, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3649923, "child_moves_before_max": 124, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 124, "child_moves_after_total": 482094, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 482094, "child_moves_after_max": 26, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 26, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.4726243218271, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.421592551351608, "tt_hits": 21894, "tt_cutoffs": 2610, "beta_cutoffs": 31383, "depth_sum": 68, "avg_depth": 4.857142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 68, "avg_effective_depth": 4.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5870.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6441.428571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1706, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 2411, "avg_search_time_ms": 185.46153846153845, "search_nodes": 32668, "safety_nodes": 1465, "corridor_nodes": 728, "corridor_branch_probes": 849, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 8, "corridor_depth_exits": 245, "corridor_neutral_exits": 7, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 52, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 245, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 52, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 307, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 154800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 11760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 34861, "avg_nodes": 2681.6153846153848, "eval_calls": 21983, "avg_eval_calls": 1691.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 21983, "pattern_eval_ns": 426272, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.390983942137105, "pattern_frame_queries": 21983, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 426272, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.390983942137105, "pattern_frame_updates": 65216, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 469066832, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7192.5115309126595, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9901, "avg_candidate_generations": 761.6153846153846, "candidate_moves_total": 768869, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.65569134430865, "candidate_moves_max": 114, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 970, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 9888, "search_candidate_moves_total": 767899, "search_candidate_moves_max": 114, "legality_checks": 409768, "avg_legality_checks": 31520.615384615383, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2580, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 409768, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2580, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1144106, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 88008.15384615384, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1431662889, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1251.3376286812586, "renju_forbidden_checks": 12694, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 976.4615384615385, "renju_forbidden_ns": 56024383, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4413.4538364581695, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2613, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15893756, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5193, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 29662097, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 4793, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 9807759, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 95, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 660771, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 37119, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2855.3076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 214588166, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5781.086936609284, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 50948, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 3919.076923076923, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 104310901, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2047.39932872733, "stage_move_gen_ns": 597509453, "stage_ordering_ns": 186910677, "stage_eval_ns": 469493104, "stage_threat_ns": 1079951141, "stage_proof_ns": 51006194, "tactical_annotations": 176289, "root_tactical_annotations": 661, "search_tactical_annotations": 175628, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 66765, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 258814527, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 210569, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 773342037, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20410, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 450872472, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 33376, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 34106878, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1536, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5161491, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 66752, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6179690, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 45840, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 95643956, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 95093, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 204410489, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 35356, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2346518, "child_limit_applications": 9888, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9888, "child_cap_hits": 9888, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9888, "child_moves_before_total": 765319, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 765319, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 159811, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 159811, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.39876618122977, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.16211569579288, "tt_hits": 4013, "tt_cutoffs": 737, "beta_cutoffs": 8458, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6191.307692307692, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6806.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1923, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1765, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 30073, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 82, 126, 97, 127, 66, 114, 52, 67, 38, 80, 50, 34, 51, 53, 81, 65, 36, 21, 24, 10, 48, 49, 68, 125, 95, 124, 123, 128 ], "move_count": 32, "black_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 21270, "avg_search_time_ms": 1519.2857142857142, "search_nodes": 227502, "safety_nodes": 167, "corridor_nodes": 9237, "corridor_branch_probes": 10471, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 4343, "corridor_neutral_exits": 40, "corridor_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_plies_followed": 9169, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 9169, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 192, "corridor_proof_active": 68, "corridor_proof_quiet": 124, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 40, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 4343, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 192, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 192, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1632, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 98278480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1993840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 236906, "avg_nodes": 16921.85714285714, "eval_calls": 175900, "avg_eval_calls": 12564.285714285714, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 175900, "pattern_eval_ns": 3812138, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.67218874360432, "pattern_frame_queries": 175900, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3812138, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.67218874360432, "pattern_frame_updates": 454874, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5829733400, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12816.149966803994, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 48167, "avg_candidate_generations": 3440.5, "candidate_moves_total": 3808259, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.06365353872984, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 971, "root_candidate_moves_max": 85, "search_candidate_generations": 48153, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3807288, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1243800, "avg_legality_checks": 88842.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 631, "root_legality_checks": 971, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1242829, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 631, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5783533, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 413109.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12613812470, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2180.9873774386692, "renju_forbidden_checks": 36909, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2636.3571428571427, "renju_forbidden_ns": 196788613, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5331.724321981089, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 984, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 6931738, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 21215, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 153539834, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14044, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32097620, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 666, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4219421, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 124533, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8895.214285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1148871912, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9225.441545614416, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 180237, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12874.07142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 551961243, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3062.419164766391, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3093898729, "stage_ordering_ns": 1490191651, "stage_eval_ns": 5833545538, "stage_threat_ns": 9532432857, "stage_proof_ns": 1247894562, "tactical_annotations": 1027624, "root_tactical_annotations": 4026, "search_tactical_annotations": 1023598, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 473610, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2873662441, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1402806, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6080954164, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 101139, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3407650933, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 236798, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 359879579, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 18722, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 129522469, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 473596, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58539303, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 345506, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 243693245, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 472409, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1403839425, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 209709, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 29874901, "child_limit_applications": 48153, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 48153, "child_cap_hits": 48153, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 48153, "child_moves_before_total": 3806657, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3806657, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 774741, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 774741, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.0533715448674, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.08915332378045, "tt_hits": 20245, "tt_cutoffs": 3384, "beta_cutoffs": 36587, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1858.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2347.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 349, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 8792, "avg_search_time_ms": 628.0, "search_nodes": 65211, "safety_nodes": 1280, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 25, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 25, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 25, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 25, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 148, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 57680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 66491, "avg_nodes": 4749.357142857143, "eval_calls": 38373, "avg_eval_calls": 2740.9285714285716, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38373, "pattern_eval_ns": 861446, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.449274229275794, "pattern_frame_queries": 38373, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 861446, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.449274229275794, "pattern_frame_updates": 130270, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1297764496, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9962.113272434175, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 24127, "avg_candidate_generations": 1723.357142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 1919492, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.5578397645791, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1000, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 24113, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1918492, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 1182636, "avg_legality_checks": 84474.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 193, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1182636, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 193, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2700433, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 192888.07142857142, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5736036096, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2124.117167876411, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15878, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1134.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 30892062, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1945.5889910568083, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 211, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1096155, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2612, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17111281, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 13055, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 12684626, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 91352, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6525.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 858436320, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9397.017251948508, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 132749, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9482.07142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 408559882, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3077.687078622061, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2834685448, "stage_ordering_ns": 747214197, "stage_eval_ns": 1298625942, "stage_threat_ns": 3798873959, "stage_proof_ns": 47604713, "tactical_annotations": 488843, "root_tactical_annotations": 913, "search_tactical_annotations": 487930, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 130334, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 792984150, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 433364, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2875980703, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 48429, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1635544999, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 65160, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 99622249, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 50, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 295713, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 130320, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16568893, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 119409, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 288785457, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 265468, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 951328717, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 103966, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13422251, "child_limit_applications": 24113, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 24113, "child_cap_hits": 24113, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 24113, "child_moves_before_total": 1918299, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1918299, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 252920, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 252920, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.55455563389043, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.48894787044333, "tt_hits": 11571, "tt_cutoffs": 2650, "beta_cutoffs": 20052, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 5.357142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 5.357142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5662.071428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6233.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1766, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 15152, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 18, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 23, "template_index": 2, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 98, 110, 84, 126, 82, 94, 142, 78, 62, 141, 81, 83, 114, 111, 156, 128, 130, 66, 146 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10014, "avg_search_time_ms": 1112.6666666666667, "search_nodes": 100168, "safety_nodes": 517, "corridor_nodes": 1342, "corridor_branch_probes": 1506, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 574, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1333, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1333, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 30, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 21, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 574, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 30, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 30, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 178, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4104080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2016000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 102027, "avg_nodes": 11336.333333333334, "eval_calls": 64899, "avg_eval_calls": 7211.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 64899, "pattern_eval_ns": 1347446, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.76219972572767, "pattern_frame_queries": 64899, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1347446, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.76219972572767, "pattern_frame_updates": 200246, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2262664740, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11299.425406749699, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32652, "avg_candidate_generations": 3628.0, "candidate_moves_total": 2674069, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.89602474580424, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 639, "root_candidate_moves_max": 91, "search_candidate_generations": 32643, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2673430, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 922618, "avg_legality_checks": 102513.11111111111, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1286, "root_legality_checks": 639, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 921979, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1286, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3167912, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 351990.22222222225, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6089480773, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1922.2379829363947, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44392, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4932.444444444444, "renju_forbidden_ns": 147101758, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3313.699720670391, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1714, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 14451647, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16565, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 79812740, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 25811, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 50471008, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 302, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2366363, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 87197, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9688.555555555555, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 710611781, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8149.4980446575, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 113156, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12572.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 307498753, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2717.47634239457, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1990774167, "stage_ordering_ns": 916612529, "stage_eval_ns": 2264012186, "stage_threat_ns": 4581929824, "stage_proof_ns": 210130708, "tactical_annotations": 488934, "root_tactical_annotations": 1469, "search_tactical_annotations": 487465, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 202981, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1096390032, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 459190, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3287912540, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 66067, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2095212880, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 101486, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 136170657, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2726, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14944905, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 202972, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22803647, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 71092, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 123458836, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 242857, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 842665463, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 174985, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23708043, "child_limit_applications": 32643, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32643, "child_cap_hits": 32643, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32643, "child_moves_before_total": 2672144, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2672144, "child_moves_before_max": 116, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 116, "child_moves_after_total": 337066, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 337066, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.85963299941794, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.32582789572037, "tt_hits": 17799, "tt_cutoffs": 2581, "beta_cutoffs": 25836, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2222222222222222, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2638.5555555555557, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3527.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 746, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5131, "avg_search_time_ms": 641.375, "search_nodes": 39773, "safety_nodes": 660, "corridor_nodes": 1128, "corridor_branch_probes": 1326, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 468, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1107, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1107, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 21, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 468, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 59, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 436, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 217120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 17840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 41561, "avg_nodes": 5195.125, "eval_calls": 26305, "avg_eval_calls": 3288.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 26305, "pattern_eval_ns": 549472, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.888500285116898, "pattern_frame_queries": 26305, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 549472, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.888500285116898, "pattern_frame_updates": 79476, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 706072864, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8884.101665911721, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 12709, "avg_candidate_generations": 1588.625, "candidate_moves_total": 1103026, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.79093555747895, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 580, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 12701, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1102446, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 768168, "avg_legality_checks": 96021.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 79, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 768168, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 79, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1754622, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 219327.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3399721738, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1937.5807085514714, "renju_forbidden_checks": 25272, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3159.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 48941814, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1936.60232668566, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 126, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1088605, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2327, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 13868979, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 22819, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 33984230, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72054, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9006.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 670990257, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9312.324881338996, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 92665, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11583.125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 310925785, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3355.3745750822854, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1701782406, "stage_ordering_ns": 405985021, "stage_eval_ns": 706622336, "stage_threat_ns": 2204358884, "stage_proof_ns": 72182514, "tactical_annotations": 213611, "root_tactical_annotations": 1077, "search_tactical_annotations": 212534, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 81816, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 450467895, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 258497, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1673684186, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26156, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 830104159, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 40904, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 55645188, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2332, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9748113, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 81808, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9215867, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70412, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 405065413, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 93509, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 400875357, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 49690, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5597635, "child_limit_applications": 12701, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 12701, "child_cap_hits": 12701, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 12701, "child_moves_before_total": 1102367, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1102367, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 203505, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 203505, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.79371703015511, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.022754113849302, "tt_hits": 5681, "tt_cutoffs": 732, "beta_cutoffs": 11010, "depth_sum": 35, "avg_depth": 4.375, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 35, "avg_effective_depth": 4.375, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4035.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5035.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1835, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1767, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22221, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 99, 113, 144, 68, 172, 157, 128, 83, 53, 96, 160, 176, 124, 125, 139, 95, 94, 80, 140, 65 ], "move_count": 26, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 9155, "avg_search_time_ms": 832.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 89998, "safety_nodes": 1019, "corridor_nodes": 1018, "corridor_branch_probes": 1198, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 488, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 1009, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1009, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 59, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 488, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 68, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 457, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 27825840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1970800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92035, "avg_nodes": 8366.818181818182, "eval_calls": 70591, "avg_eval_calls": 6417.363636363636, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70591, "pattern_eval_ns": 1541291, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.834100664390643, "pattern_frame_queries": 70591, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1541291, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.834100664390643, "pattern_frame_updates": 179894, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2085258927, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11591.59797992151, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 18391, "avg_candidate_generations": 1671.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 1366735, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.3154260235985, "candidate_moves_max": 116, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 813, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 18380, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1365922, "search_candidate_moves_max": 116, "legality_checks": 779021, "avg_legality_checks": 70820.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 7267, "root_legality_checks": 813, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 21, "search_legality_checks": 778208, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 7246, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2409059, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 219005.36363636365, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5464125110, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2268.157446538254, "renju_forbidden_checks": 35048, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3186.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 275445938, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 7859.105740698471, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 7987, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 89011411, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12016, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 124006658, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14163, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 53884476, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 882, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 8543393, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 81846, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7440.545454545455, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 851443201, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10402.990995283826, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 113091, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10281.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 403139752, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3564.7377068024866, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2110347585, "stage_ordering_ns": 614634419, "stage_eval_ns": 2086800218, "stage_threat_ns": 4060756259, "stage_proof_ns": 237238307, "tactical_annotations": 232764, "root_tactical_annotations": 843, "search_tactical_annotations": 231921, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 182059, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1127424355, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 291781, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2756572401, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 37437, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1539070057, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91024, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 136128417, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2154, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13464437, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 182048, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 23461050, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 46458, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 146655198, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 153580, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 908694031, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 32726, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3705599, "child_limit_applications": 18380, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 18380, "child_cap_hits": 18380, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 18380, "child_moves_before_total": 1358676, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1358676, "child_moves_before_max": 114, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 114, "child_moves_after_total": 296041, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 296041, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.92143634385201, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.106692056583242, "tt_hits": 5238, "tt_cutoffs": 976, "beta_cutoffs": 13757, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 4.636363636363637, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 4.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 2, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3886.3636363636365, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4613.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 223, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 13056, "avg_search_time_ms": 1186.909090909091, "search_nodes": 98098, "safety_nodes": 836, "corridor_nodes": 615, "corridor_branch_probes": 730, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 7, "corridor_depth_exits": 285, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 610, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 610, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 39, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 285, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 39, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 38, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 282, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 2369440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1975040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 99549, "avg_nodes": 9049.90909090909, "eval_calls": 67420, "avg_eval_calls": 6129.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 67420, "pattern_eval_ns": 1501839, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.27586769504598, "pattern_frame_queries": 67420, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1501839, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.27586769504598, "pattern_frame_updates": 196086, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2879980925, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 14687.335786338648, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27979, "avg_candidate_generations": 2543.5454545454545, "candidate_moves_total": 2288902, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.80785589191893, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 851, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 27968, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2288051, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1371910, "avg_legality_checks": 124719.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 21896, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1371910, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 21896, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3431672, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 311970.1818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7848960895, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2287.211859117072, "renju_forbidden_checks": 102346, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 9304.181818181818, "renju_forbidden_ns": 870875796, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 8509.133683778555, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 22648, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 254984936, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 44000, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 465085083, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 35540, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 148976223, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 158, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1829554, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 99143, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9013.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1088467117, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10978.759135793753, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 136213, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12383.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 542311658, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3981.350223546945, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3763742940, "stage_ordering_ns": 981826849, "stage_eval_ns": 2881482764, "stage_threat_ns": 5302241941, "stage_proof_ns": 66621341, "tactical_annotations": 498151, "root_tactical_annotations": 1801, "search_tactical_annotations": 496350, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 197395, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1275805594, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 447245, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3815557020, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 56391, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2320544038, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 98692, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 157696245, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1298, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7406790, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 197384, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26727121, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 117493, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 465697264, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 240216, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1000300491, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 140442, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 19049171, "child_limit_applications": 27968, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27968, "child_cap_hits": 27968, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27968, "child_moves_before_total": 2266155, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2266155, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 314682, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 314682, "child_moves_after_max": 27, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 27, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.02670909610984, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.25150171624714, "tt_hits": 15178, "tt_cutoffs": 2655, "beta_cutoffs": 21906, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 5.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 5.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2727272727272727, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3465.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4192.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 46, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1768, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 38718, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 19, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 24, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 127, 110, 142, 97, 96, 128, 113, 155, 99, 85, 114, 115, 129, 144, 69, 84, 145, 83, 82, 125, 95, 100, 157, 172, 130, 68, 52, 70, 55, 86, 87, 38, 53, 54, 22, 102 ], "move_count": 38, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 22985, "avg_search_time_ms": 1352.0588235294117, "search_nodes": 213004, "safety_nodes": 1115, "corridor_nodes": 288, "corridor_branch_probes": 292, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 96, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 272, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 272, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 46, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 30, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 96, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 46, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 46, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 239, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 10326720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994480, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 214407, "avg_nodes": 12612.176470588236, "eval_calls": 130673, "avg_eval_calls": 7686.64705882353, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 130673, "pattern_eval_ns": 2819542, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.577081723079747, "pattern_frame_queries": 130673, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2819542, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.577081723079747, "pattern_frame_updates": 425812, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4315866618, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10135.615290315915, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 76407, "avg_candidate_generations": 4494.529411764706, "candidate_moves_total": 6229466, "avg_candidate_moves": 81.53004305888204, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1232, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 76390, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6228234, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 2460647, "avg_legality_checks": 144743.9411764706, "illegal_moves_skipped": 416, "root_legality_checks": 1232, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2459415, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 416, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6493985, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 381999.1176470588, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 13816290640, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2127.551979254649, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23494, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1382.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 72134283, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3070.3278709457736, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 926, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5190157, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8099, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 47805543, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14445, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 19099343, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 24, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 39240, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 140837, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8284.529411764706, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1096363585, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7784.627512656475, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 179615, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10565.588235294117, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 438226001, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2439.807371321994, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5761007477, "stage_ordering_ns": 2514970567, "stage_eval_ns": 4318686160, "stage_threat_ns": 10169417268, "stage_proof_ns": 112882358, "tactical_annotations": 1232497, "root_tactical_annotations": 3139, "search_tactical_annotations": 1229358, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 426465, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2472839107, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1034131, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7270405182, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 153236, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5195116991, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 213224, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 315773776, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 636, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 4545483, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 426448, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 52948188, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 186335, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 220566728, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 675735, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1819616762, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 370427, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 52905532, "child_limit_applications": 76390, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 76390, "child_cap_hits": 76390, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 76390, "child_moves_before_total": 6227818, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6227818, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 732296, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 732296, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 81.52661343107737, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.586280926822882, "tt_hits": 37349, "tt_cutoffs": 5844, "beta_cutoffs": 59495, "depth_sum": 95, "avg_depth": 5.588235294117647, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 95, "avg_effective_depth": 5.588235294117647, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2662.764705882353, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3133.3529411764707, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 15717, "avg_search_time_ms": 924.5294117647059, "search_nodes": 121640, "safety_nodes": 923, "corridor_nodes": 30454, "corridor_branch_probes": 30826, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 19221, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_plies_followed": 30416, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 30416, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 117, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 79, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 19221, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 117, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 114, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 866, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 389920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 7, "total_nodes": 153017, "avg_nodes": 9001.0, "eval_calls": 80388, "avg_eval_calls": 4728.705882352941, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 80388, "pattern_eval_ns": 1703456, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.190426431805744, "pattern_frame_queries": 80388, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1703456, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.190426431805744, "pattern_frame_updates": 243126, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1838527614, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7562.036203450063, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 38947, "avg_candidate_generations": 2291.0, "candidate_moves_total": 3328135, "avg_candidate_moves": 85.4529232033276, "candidate_moves_max": 122, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1255, "root_candidate_moves_max": 96, "search_candidate_generations": 38930, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3326880, "search_candidate_moves_max": 122, "legality_checks": 2339318, "avg_legality_checks": 137606.9411764706, "illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2339318, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 8, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4725453, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 277967.82352941175, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9412761523, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1991.9278687143858, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10812, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 636.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12247987, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1132.8141879393268, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 12, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 58370, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 900, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 6466589, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9900, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5723028, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 105876, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6228.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 826096920, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7802.494616343647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 133173, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7833.705882352941, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 354874088, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2664.7600339408136, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5156105533, "stage_ordering_ns": 1224895311, "stage_eval_ns": 1840231070, "stage_threat_ns": 7559669477, "stage_proof_ns": 124622080, "tactical_annotations": 723074, "root_tactical_annotations": 3393, "search_tactical_annotations": 719681, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 304209, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2052291071, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1723713, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4822673218, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 89346, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2858118614, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 152096, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 233875129, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 61066, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 393946945, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 304192, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 35127223, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 279150, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 516212307, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 282445, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 704829556, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 161479, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 21755891, "child_limit_applications": 38930, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 38930, "child_cap_hits": 38930, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 38930, "child_moves_before_total": 3326872, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3326872, "child_moves_before_max": 122, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 122, "child_moves_after_total": 623285, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 623285, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 85.45779604418186, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.010403287952737, "tt_hits": 17154, "tt_cutoffs": 2245, "beta_cutoffs": 33761, "depth_sum": 77, "avg_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 77, "avg_effective_depth": 4.529411764705882, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.11764705882352941, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6219.176470588235, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6689.764705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1871, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1769, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 21712, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 113, 114, 126, 98, 66, 110, 96, 81, 156, 141, 80, 100, 86, 99, 64, 48, 101, 84, 69, 129, 144, 130, 146, 131, 132, 127 ], "move_count": 30, "black_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 7748, "avg_search_time_ms": 596.0, "search_nodes": 95523, "safety_nodes": 1033, "corridor_nodes": 456, "corridor_branch_probes": 562, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 160, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 443, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 443, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 11, "corridor_proof_completed": 11, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 87, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 160, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 100, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 730, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23797600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 97012, "avg_nodes": 7462.461538461538, "eval_calls": 70768, "avg_eval_calls": 5443.692307692308, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70768, "pattern_eval_ns": 1441435, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.368457494912956, "pattern_frame_queries": 70768, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1441435, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.368457494912956, "pattern_frame_updates": 190926, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1698779181, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8897.579067282612, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23508, "avg_candidate_generations": 1808.3076923076924, "candidate_moves_total": 1802896, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.69287051216607, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 943, "root_candidate_moves_max": 97, "search_candidate_generations": 23495, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1801953, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 755858, "avg_legality_checks": 58142.92307692308, "illegal_moves_skipped": 94, "root_legality_checks": 943, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 754915, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 94, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2318433, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 178341.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4536282730, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1956.615839232792, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13849, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1065.3076923076924, "renju_forbidden_ns": 34388318, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2483.0903314318725, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 208, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 807582, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3540, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19750657, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10059, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13492707, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 42, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 337372, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 57350, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4411.538461538462, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 450369017, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7852.990706190061, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 78199, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6015.307692307692, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 206083647, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2635.3744549163034, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1627339820, "stage_ordering_ns": 691187392, "stage_eval_ns": 1700220616, "stage_threat_ns": 3473370488, "stage_proof_ns": 211559522, "tactical_annotations": 280917, "root_tactical_annotations": 1496, "search_tactical_annotations": 279421, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 192025, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1031670844, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 302382, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2282661740, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 47657, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1573779428, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 96006, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 125761836, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1086, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5019506, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 192012, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21713809, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62099, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 72265054, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 161893, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 579050104, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 56925, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6542753, "child_limit_applications": 23495, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23495, "child_cap_hits": 23495, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23495, "child_moves_before_total": 1801859, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1801859, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 376413, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 376413, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.69116833368801, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02098318791232, "tt_hits": 8412, "tt_cutoffs": 1200, "beta_cutoffs": 18884, "depth_sum": 60, "avg_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 60, "avg_effective_depth": 4.615384615384615, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 11 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5071.615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5687.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 965, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 15, "search_move_count": 13, "total_time_ms": 13952, "avg_search_time_ms": 1073.2307692307693, "search_nodes": 125359, "safety_nodes": 398, "corridor_nodes": 669, "corridor_branch_probes": 828, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 8, "corridor_depth_exits": 247, "corridor_neutral_exits": 8, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 656, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 656, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 68, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 55, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 247, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 68, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 68, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 549, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 79390480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1992320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 126426, "avg_nodes": 9725.076923076924, "eval_calls": 81502, "avg_eval_calls": 6269.384615384615, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 81502, "pattern_eval_ns": 1627180, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.96490883659297, "pattern_frame_queries": 81502, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1627180, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.96490883659297, "pattern_frame_updates": 250582, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1974413417, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7879.310632846733, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 41136, "avg_candidate_generations": 3164.3076923076924, "candidate_moves_total": 3640422, "avg_candidate_moves": 88.49722870478413, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 13, "root_candidate_moves_total": 982, "root_candidate_moves_max": 101, "search_candidate_generations": 41123, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3639440, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 2524291, "avg_legality_checks": 194176.23076923078, "illegal_moves_skipped": 75, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2524291, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5285521, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 406578.53846153844, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9078505269, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1717.6178599990426, "renju_forbidden_checks": 64179, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4936.846153846154, "renju_forbidden_ns": 97733210, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1522.822262733916, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1379, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3343186, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4671, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 17832584, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 58129, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 76557440, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 173378, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13336.76923076923, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1430729599, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8252.082726758874, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 242806, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18677.384615384617, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 700010795, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2883.0045180102634, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4868058549, "stage_ordering_ns": 1202642490, "stage_eval_ns": 1976040597, "stage_threat_ns": 5716720474, "stage_proof_ns": 88603089, "tactical_annotations": 634728, "root_tactical_annotations": 3369, "search_tactical_annotations": 631359, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 252043, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1272122389, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 591049, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4231496727, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 82889, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2344346578, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 126015, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 159667920, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1448, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 5593312, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 252030, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 26989335, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 139188, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 504243099, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 326299, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1360059319, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 169241, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20850791, "child_limit_applications": 41123, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 41123, "child_cap_hits": 41123, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 41123, "child_moves_before_total": 3639365, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3639365, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 421497, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 421497, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 88.49950149551346, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.249665637234637, "tt_hits": 21117, "tt_cutoffs": 2666, "beta_cutoffs": 31896, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 5.153846153846154, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 5.153846153846154, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 13, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4704.461538461538, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5319.846153846154, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1304, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1770, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 35763, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 20, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 25, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 111, 82, 110, 113, 98, 126, 127, 79, 143, 159, 142, 157, 141, 140, 109, 108, 155, 124, 156, 80, 81, 94, 66, 78, 169, 183, 51, 96, 36, 21, 76, 123, 145, 144, 93, 122, 125, 136 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 24832, "avg_search_time_ms": 1379.5555555555557, "search_nodes": 241272, "safety_nodes": 955, "corridor_nodes": 4867, "corridor_branch_probes": 5044, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2085, "corridor_neutral_exits": 21, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 4824, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 4824, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 99, "corridor_proof_active": 43, "corridor_proof_quiet": 56, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 21, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2085, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 99, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 99, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 750, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 78326800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2006560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 247094, "avg_nodes": 13727.444444444445, "eval_calls": 144255, "avg_eval_calls": 8014.166666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 144255, "pattern_eval_ns": 2983162, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.67978232990191, "pattern_frame_queries": 144255, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2983162, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.67978232990191, "pattern_frame_updates": 482328, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4817145730, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9987.28195335954, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 90422, "avg_candidate_generations": 5023.444444444444, "candidate_moves_total": 7646876, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.56875539138706, "candidate_moves_max": 125, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1387, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 90404, "search_candidate_moves_total": 7645489, "search_candidate_moves_max": 125, "legality_checks": 2129414, "avg_legality_checks": 118300.77777777778, "illegal_moves_skipped": 465, "root_legality_checks": 1387, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2128027, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 465, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7041498, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 391194.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14656349422, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2081.42492151528, "renju_forbidden_checks": 29237, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1624.2777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 104780277, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3583.8245031980027, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 911, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5596536, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11304, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 66068055, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16718, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32384305, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 304, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 731381, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 116329, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6462.722222222223, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 897247979, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7713.020648333605, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 145164, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8064.666666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 348182234, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2398.5439502907057, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4851429289, "stage_ordering_ns": 2853444613, "stage_eval_ns": 4820128892, "stage_threat_ns": 11589586899, "stage_proof_ns": 611860323, "tactical_annotations": 1485882, "root_tactical_annotations": 5645, "search_tactical_annotations": 1480237, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 492192, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2825056326, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1405138, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8220731476, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 183874, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5973316924, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 246087, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 353505443, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 9846, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 65946129, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 492174, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 59251924, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 365850, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 264454258, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 589460, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1387785484, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 530572, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 65095601, "child_limit_applications": 90404, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 90404, "child_cap_hits": 90404, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 90404, "child_moves_before_total": 7645024, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 7645024, "child_moves_before_max": 125, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 125, "child_moves_after_total": 827839, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 827839, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.56510773859564, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.157105880270784, "tt_hits": 52908, "tt_cutoffs": 6507, "beta_cutoffs": 72068, "depth_sum": 105, "avg_depth": 5.833333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 105, "avg_effective_depth": 5.833333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.2777777777777778, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16666666666666666, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2919.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3363.9444444444443, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 10916, "avg_search_time_ms": 606.4444444444445, "search_nodes": 95742, "safety_nodes": 1050, "corridor_nodes": 1107, "corridor_branch_probes": 1283, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 325, "corridor_neutral_exits": 32, "corridor_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_plies_followed": 1084, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1084, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 113, "corridor_proof_active": 23, "corridor_proof_quiet": 90, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 32, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 325, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 14, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 113, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 111, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 842, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 379600, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 97899, "avg_nodes": 5438.833333333333, "eval_calls": 62165, "avg_eval_calls": 3453.6111111111113, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 62165, "pattern_eval_ns": 1292023, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.783769001849915, "pattern_frame_queries": 62165, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1292023, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.783769001849915, "pattern_frame_updates": 191316, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1432565612, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7487.955069100337, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 31511, "avg_candidate_generations": 1750.611111111111, "candidate_moves_total": 2659248, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.39110152010409, "candidate_moves_max": 123, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1419, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 31493, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2657829, "search_candidate_moves_max": 123, "legality_checks": 1895172, "avg_legality_checks": 105287.33333333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1895172, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 14, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3626354, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 201464.11111111112, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7110151859, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1960.6888513917836, "renju_forbidden_checks": 10709, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 594.9444444444445, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12897175, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1204.3304696983846, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 20, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 135461, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 812, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7463854, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9877, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5297860, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 92986, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5165.888888888889, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 719300700, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7735.580625040328, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118083, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6560.166666666667, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 285011728, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2413.6558861140047, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4020896988, "stage_ordering_ns": 958309721, "stage_eval_ns": 1433857635, "stage_threat_ns": 4246080337, "stage_proof_ns": 168877618, "tactical_annotations": 512713, "root_tactical_annotations": 2908, "search_tactical_annotations": 509805, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 193728, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1093717142, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 557350, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2967389457, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 64160, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1917556912, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 96855, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 135696548, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2394, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 14889676, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 193710, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 22730993, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 210114, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 404708591, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 206507, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 603746928, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 96092, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11656521, "child_limit_applications": 31493, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 31493, "child_cap_hits": 31493, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 31493, "child_moves_before_total": 2657815, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2657815, "child_moves_before_max": 123, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 123, "child_moves_after_total": 504181, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 504181, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.39383355031276, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.009303654780428, "tt_hits": 13586, "tt_cutoffs": 2000, "beta_cutoffs": 27464, "depth_sum": 84, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 84, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 3, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6323.166666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6767.611111111111, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1874, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1771, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 26066, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 67, 82, 98, 96, 68, 111, 141, 110, 66, 65, 83, 113, 115, 99, 53, 38, 39, 81, 69, 70, 54, 124, 138, 84, 55, 41, 52, 56, 51 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 14105, "avg_search_time_ms": 940.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 149566, "safety_nodes": 280, "corridor_nodes": 5259, "corridor_branch_probes": 5643, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2586, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_plies_followed": 5230, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5230, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 135, "corridor_proof_active": 29, "corridor_proof_quiet": 106, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2586, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 135, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 132, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1099, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 645280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 21520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 155105, "avg_nodes": 10340.333333333334, "eval_calls": 106836, "avg_eval_calls": 7122.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 106836, "pattern_eval_ns": 2221741, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.795808528960276, "pattern_frame_queries": 106836, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2221741, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.795808528960276, "pattern_frame_updates": 298998, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3278276246, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10964.207941190241, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 39955, "avg_candidate_generations": 2663.6666666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 3123965, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.18708547115504, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1046, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 39940, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3122919, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 1006163, "avg_legality_checks": 67077.53333333334, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1317, "root_legality_checks": 1046, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1005117, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1317, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4045123, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 269674.86666666664, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8403816610, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2077.518189187325, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26226, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1748.4, "renju_forbidden_ns": 133603625, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5094.319568367269, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1379, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12512085, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12291, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 83657963, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11728, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 33331653, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 828, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4101924, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90928, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6061.866666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 737337106, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8109.021489530178, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 122093, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8139.533333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 315218728, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2581.7919782460913, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2399618967, "stage_ordering_ns": 1184559785, "stage_eval_ns": 3280497987, "stage_threat_ns": 6471302928, "stage_proof_ns": 704752230, "tactical_annotations": 686557, "root_tactical_annotations": 3738, "search_tactical_annotations": 682819, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 309743, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1798138985, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 862366, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4335630677, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 82807, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2730009812, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 154864, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 217908055, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10730, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 64951060, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 309728, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 36602121, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 220769, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 157729140, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 291287, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 885615158, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 174501, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18072030, "child_limit_applications": 39940, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 39940, "child_cap_hits": 39940, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 39940, "child_moves_before_total": 3121602, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3121602, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 645850, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 645850, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 78.15728592889334, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.170505758637958, "tt_hits": 17851, "tt_cutoffs": 2723, "beta_cutoffs": 33143, "depth_sum": 66, "avg_depth": 4.4, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 66, "avg_effective_depth": 4.4, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.06666666666666667, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4646.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5179.533333333334, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 11946, "avg_search_time_ms": 853.2857142857143, "search_nodes": 89875, "safety_nodes": 1290, "corridor_nodes": 1011, "corridor_branch_probes": 1197, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 2, "corridor_depth_exits": 447, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 1001, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1001, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 44, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 447, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 325, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 54322320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2022000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 92176, "avg_nodes": 6584.0, "eval_calls": 50986, "avg_eval_calls": 3641.8571428571427, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 50986, "pattern_eval_ns": 1088456, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.348134782097045, "pattern_frame_queries": 50986, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1088456, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.348134782097045, "pattern_frame_updates": 179586, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1658499769, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9235.128400877575, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 34823, "avg_candidate_generations": 2487.3571428571427, "candidate_moves_total": 2673349, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.76963501134308, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 983, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 34809, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2672366, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 1830273, "avg_legality_checks": 130733.78571428571, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5599, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1830273, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5599, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3781158, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 270082.71428571426, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7828812767, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2070.4801986587177, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30653, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2189.5, "renju_forbidden_ns": 142809607, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4658.911264802792, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5603, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 51956484, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7200, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 60065301, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 17850, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30787822, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 94668, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6762.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 836903794, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8840.408522415177, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 128791, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9199.357142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 382287931, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2968.281409415254, "stage_move_gen_ns": 4296888190, "stage_ordering_ns": 1034701117, "stage_eval_ns": 1659588225, "stage_threat_ns": 4792821941, "stage_proof_ns": 82637769, "tactical_annotations": 596723, "root_tactical_annotations": 1257, "search_tactical_annotations": 595466, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 181710, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1073136708, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 524276, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3524763781, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 70322, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2265589663, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 90848, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 133546055, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2110, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 13313997, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 181696, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 21984899, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 124168, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 200244617, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 273296, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1015128889, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 199259, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26076501, "child_limit_applications": 34809, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 34809, "child_cap_hits": 34809, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 34809, "child_moves_before_total": 2666767, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2666767, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 328114, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 328114, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.6114223333046, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.426125427332012, "tt_hits": 20699, "tt_cutoffs": 3998, "beta_cutoffs": 28520, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 5.857142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 5.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.14285714285714285, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4113.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4684.928571428572, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 54, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1772, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22244, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 21, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 26, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 97, 114, 96, 98, 82, 127, 128, 144, 110, 124, 80, 64, 125, 95, 79, 81, 67, 52, 69, 68, 111, 83, 109, 113, 108 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 17173, "avg_search_time_ms": 1431.0833333333333, "search_nodes": 166996, "safety_nodes": 223, "corridor_nodes": 2048, "corridor_branch_probes": 2242, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 912, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2040, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2040, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 1, "corridor_proof_completed": 1, "corridor_proof_checks": 16, "corridor_proof_active": 8, "corridor_proof_quiet": 8, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 912, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 16, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 136, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23617120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1969840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 169267, "avg_nodes": 14105.583333333334, "eval_calls": 109276, "avg_eval_calls": 9106.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 109276, "pattern_eval_ns": 2261380, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.69420549800505, "pattern_frame_queries": 109276, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2261380, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.69420549800505, "pattern_frame_updates": 333880, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4348799259, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13025.036716784474, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 54338, "avg_candidate_generations": 4528.166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 4299458, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.1243328793846, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 776, "root_candidate_moves_max": 78, "search_candidate_generations": 54326, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4298682, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 1246566, "avg_legality_checks": 103880.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 4781, "root_legality_checks": 776, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 1245790, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 4777, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4777905, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 398158.75, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10201342443, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2135.1078439190396, "renju_forbidden_checks": 62072, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5172.666666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 309056927, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4979.007072432015, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 5486, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 51763511, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 28485, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 174035230, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 27511, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 77680568, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 590, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5577618, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 103580, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8631.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 893748138, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8628.57827765978, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 139256, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11604.666666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 377051969, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2707.61740248176, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2992230565, "stage_ordering_ns": 1711577055, "stage_eval_ns": 4351060639, "stage_threat_ns": 7822373169, "stage_proof_ns": 246027381, "tactical_annotations": 771461, "root_tactical_annotations": 3328, "search_tactical_annotations": 768133, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 338004, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1990029355, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 760216, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5483753365, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 109765, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3810602471, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 168996, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 249896444, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4112, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 24210055, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 337992, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42334261, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 150717, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 155805930, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 383159, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1227418414, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 237585, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 32149689, "child_limit_applications": 54326, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 54326, "child_cap_hits": 54326, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 54326, "child_moves_before_total": 4293905, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4293905, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 475666, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 475666, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.0395943010713, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.755770717520155, "tt_hits": 26253, "tt_cutoffs": 3339, "beta_cutoffs": 41508, "depth_sum": 53, "avg_depth": 4.416666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 53, "avg_effective_depth": 4.416666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 1 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2829.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3401.4166666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 5060, "avg_search_time_ms": 460.0, "search_nodes": 49037, "safety_nodes": 879, "corridor_nodes": 60, "corridor_branch_probes": 73, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 18, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 57, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 57, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 30, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 27, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 30, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 30, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 159, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 102640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 8960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49976, "avg_nodes": 4543.272727272727, "eval_calls": 35020, "avg_eval_calls": 3183.6363636363635, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 35020, "pattern_eval_ns": 727583, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.77621359223301, "pattern_frame_queries": 35020, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 727583, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.77621359223301, "pattern_frame_updates": 97974, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 954220520, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9739.528038050912, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 13171, "avg_candidate_generations": 1197.3636363636363, "candidate_moves_total": 987864, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.00296105079342, "candidate_moves_max": 110, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 715, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 13160, "search_candidate_moves_total": 987149, "search_candidate_moves_max": 110, "legality_checks": 575763, "avg_legality_checks": 52342.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 740, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 575763, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 740, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1540043, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 140003.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3181295845, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2065.7188435647577, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19804, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1800.3636363636363, "renju_forbidden_ns": 56386385, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2847.222025853363, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 756, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8075881, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2406, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 20139599, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16602, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 27675814, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 495091, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 57439, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5221.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 527685750, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9186.889569804489, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 84695, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 7699.545454545455, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 238041958, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2810.5786410059627, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1367873060, "stage_ordering_ns": 398880507, "stage_eval_ns": 954948103, "stage_threat_ns": 2255315838, "stage_proof_ns": 51380886, "tactical_annotations": 193237, "root_tactical_annotations": 701, "search_tactical_annotations": 192536, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 98159, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 574268262, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 190204, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1593867003, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 26542, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 911885561, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 49074, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 70483019, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 174, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1062412, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 98148, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 11883303, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 54983, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 197840416, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 104440, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 481020971, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 33814, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3751839, "child_limit_applications": 13160, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 13160, "child_cap_hits": 13160, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 13160, "child_moves_before_total": 986409, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 986409, "child_moves_before_max": 110, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 110, "child_moves_after_total": 210586, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 210586, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.95509118541034, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.001975683890578, "tt_hits": 4111, "tt_cutoffs": 808, "beta_cutoffs": 10870, "depth_sum": 49, "avg_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 49, "avg_effective_depth": 4.454545454545454, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5274.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6001.363636363636, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1773, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17799, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 82, 124, 114, 98, 84, 125, 127, 139, 54, 68, 69, 99, 24, 39, 153, 154, 140, 109, 169, 94 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 9537, "avg_search_time_ms": 794.75, "search_nodes": 99081, "safety_nodes": 412, "corridor_nodes": 2997, "corridor_branch_probes": 3361, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1356, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 32, "corridor_plies_followed": 2973, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2973, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 77, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1356, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 32, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 5, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 77, "corridor_proof_wins": 5, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 72, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 4, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 573, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 23979440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 9, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 5, "total_nodes": 102490, "avg_nodes": 8540.833333333334, "eval_calls": 75288, "avg_eval_calls": 6274.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75288, "pattern_eval_ns": 1559756, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.71719264690256, "pattern_frame_queries": 75288, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1559756, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.71719264690256, "pattern_frame_updates": 198058, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2299897464, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11612.242191681225, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 22599, "avg_candidate_generations": 1883.25, "candidate_moves_total": 1754846, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.65148900393822, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 813, "root_candidate_moves_max": 86, "search_candidate_generations": 22587, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1754033, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 672809, "avg_legality_checks": 56067.416666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1561, "root_legality_checks": 813, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 6, "search_legality_checks": 671996, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1555, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2746757, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 228896.41666666666, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5735560641, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2088.1208789128414, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30175, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2514.5833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 124426203, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4123.486429163215, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1787, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11991976, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11554, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 72431986, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 16014, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36404678, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 820, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3597563, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 78525, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6543.75, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 687751878, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8758.381127029608, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 109373, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9114.416666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 305288842, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2791.263309957668, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1606266653, "stage_ordering_ns": 720142103, "stage_eval_ns": 2301457220, "stage_threat_ns": 4430393556, "stage_proof_ns": 442515664, "tactical_annotations": 319035, "root_tactical_annotations": 1947, "search_tactical_annotations": 317088, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 204170, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1208581241, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 462232, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3007512984, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 46821, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1719751272, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 102079, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 146607547, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6100, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 34147659, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 204158, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 24862677, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 83837, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 176076267, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 163162, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 669106081, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 72036, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8681448, "child_limit_applications": 22587, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 22587, "child_cap_hits": 22587, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 22587, "child_moves_before_total": 1752478, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1752478, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 361490, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 361490, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.58790454686324, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00433877894364, "tt_hits": 9305, "tt_cutoffs": 1154, "beta_cutoffs": 17654, "depth_sum": 52, "avg_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 52, "avg_effective_depth": 4.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4672.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5339.166666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 921, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 8250, "avg_search_time_ms": 750.0, "search_nodes": 63743, "safety_nodes": 1067, "corridor_nodes": 517, "corridor_branch_probes": 607, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 6, "corridor_depth_exits": 179, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 504, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 499, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 5, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 34, "corridor_proof_active": 13, "corridor_proof_quiet": 21, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 179, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 34, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 1, "corridor_proof_unknown": 33, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 179, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 37892280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2005280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 65327, "avg_nodes": 5938.818181818182, "eval_calls": 40098, "avg_eval_calls": 3645.2727272727275, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 40098, "pattern_eval_ns": 851901, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.245473589705224, "pattern_frame_queries": 40098, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 851901, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.245473589705224, "pattern_frame_updates": 127362, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1472927304, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11564.888302633439, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21815, "avg_candidate_generations": 1983.1818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 1638643, "avg_candidate_moves": 75.11542516617007, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 731, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 21804, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1637912, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 998858, "avg_legality_checks": 90805.27272727272, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1322, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 998858, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1322, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2553626, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 232147.81818181818, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5353382194, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2096.38458959926, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23544, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2140.3636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 76696102, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3257.5646449201495, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1687, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10080149, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6495, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 45405902, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15297, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 21000711, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 65, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 209340, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90641, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8240.09090909091, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 807341085, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8907.018733244338, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 126042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11458.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 356463859, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2828.135534187017, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2392307455, "stage_ordering_ns": 688296455, "stage_eval_ns": 1473779205, "stage_threat_ns": 3596279353, "stage_proof_ns": 55533628, "tactical_annotations": 320448, "root_tactical_annotations": 862, "search_tactical_annotations": 319586, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 128449, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 785348851, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 315079, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2685415851, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44051, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1595758272, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 64219, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 94722698, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1076, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6109430, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 128438, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 16333165, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 57406, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 241857058, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 179549, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 822683639, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 83493, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8349358, "child_limit_applications": 21804, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21804, "child_cap_hits": 21804, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21804, "child_moves_before_total": 1636590, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1636590, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 214889, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 214889, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 75.05916345624657, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.85548523206751, "tt_hits": 10226, "tt_cutoffs": 1779, "beta_cutoffs": 17032, "depth_sum": 61, "avg_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 61, "avg_effective_depth": 5.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3932.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4660.181818181818, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 304, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1774, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22144, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 22, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 27, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 113, 142, 111, 110, 126, 68, 82, 114, 98, 140, 97, 67, 129, 145, 125, 83, 124, 123, 139, 153, 109, 154, 93, 141, 79, 94, 65, 81, 51, 37, 107 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 18088, "avg_search_time_ms": 1205.8666666666666, "search_nodes": 247689, "safety_nodes": 211, "corridor_nodes": 73, "corridor_branch_probes": 94, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 69, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 69, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 22, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 22, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 21, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 152, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4083040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2032640, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 247973, "avg_nodes": 16531.533333333333, "eval_calls": 166194, "avg_eval_calls": 11079.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 166194, "pattern_eval_ns": 3219552, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.372251705837755, "pattern_frame_queries": 166194, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3219552, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.372251705837755, "pattern_frame_updates": 495240, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5190890228, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10481.56495436556, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 75830, "avg_candidate_generations": 5055.333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 6288555, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.92964525913227, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1076, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 75815, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6287479, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1790061, "avg_legality_checks": 119337.4, "illegal_moves_skipped": 5439, "root_legality_checks": 1076, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1788985, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 5438, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6766145, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 451076.3333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10284444776, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1519.9858672848425, "renju_forbidden_checks": 168178, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 11211.866666666667, "renju_forbidden_ns": 435283183, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2588.229037091653, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 19642, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 59594809, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 69994, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 244466965, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 78372, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 130826079, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 170, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 395330, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 159750, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 10650.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 950931670, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5952.623912363068, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 206135, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13742.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 363808320, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1764.9031945084532, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3108455460, "stage_ordering_ns": 1738753614, "stage_eval_ns": 5194109780, "stage_threat_ns": 7918441272, "stage_proof_ns": 31018368, "tactical_annotations": 1601330, "root_tactical_annotations": 4193, "search_tactical_annotations": 1597137, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 495437, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2146841791, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1234149, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5373882772, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 151850, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3713305677, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 247711, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 283158761, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 182, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 705562, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 495422, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47372297, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 388226, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 255641625, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 688185, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1395350461, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 524919, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 66480089, "child_limit_applications": 75815, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 75815, "child_cap_hits": 75815, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 75815, "child_moves_before_total": 6282041, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6282041, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 910537, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 910537, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.86013321901999, "avg_child_moves_after": 12.009984831497725, "tt_hits": 40400, "tt_cutoffs": 5612, "beta_cutoffs": 57843, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4677.533333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5210.866666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1313, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 4042, "avg_search_time_ms": 288.7142857142857, "search_nodes": 50710, "safety_nodes": 1415, "corridor_nodes": 78, "corridor_branch_probes": 96, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 73, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 73, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 46, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 301, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 191120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 52203, "avg_nodes": 3728.785714285714, "eval_calls": 34499, "avg_eval_calls": 2464.214285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 34499, "pattern_eval_ns": 662002, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.18901997159338, "pattern_frame_queries": 34499, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 662002, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.18901997159338, "pattern_frame_updates": 101290, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 816734919, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8063.332204561161, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15297, "avg_candidate_generations": 1092.642857142857, "candidate_moves_total": 1143967, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.78374844740799, "candidate_moves_max": 107, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 994, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 15283, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1142973, "search_candidate_moves_max": 107, "legality_checks": 555467, "avg_legality_checks": 39676.21428571428, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2040, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 555467, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2040, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1617298, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 115521.28571428571, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2456753189, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1519.0479361255625, "renju_forbidden_checks": 18492, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1320.857142857143, "renju_forbidden_ns": 61566650, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3329.366753190569, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3113, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 15827012, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5944, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28620926, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9270, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16693859, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 165, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 424853, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 50502, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3607.285714285714, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 383855215, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7600.792344857629, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 72100, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5150.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 176204710, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2443.8933425797504, "stage_move_gen_ns": 973869978, "stage_ordering_ns": 332330929, "stage_eval_ns": 817396921, "stage_threat_ns": 1826971323, "stage_proof_ns": 55300736, "tactical_annotations": 256827, "root_tactical_annotations": 646, "search_tactical_annotations": 256181, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 101552, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 437234439, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 255128, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1321787280, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 30896, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 769327365, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 50769, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 54618868, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 248, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 928403, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 101538, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 9450323, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 62070, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 114354102, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 156287, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 435037539, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 38470, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 2952010, "child_limit_applications": 15283, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15283, "child_cap_hits": 15283, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15283, "child_moves_before_total": 1140933, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1140933, "child_moves_before_max": 107, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 107, "child_moves_after_total": 247022, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 247022, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.6537329058431, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.163187855787477, "tt_hits": 4591, "tt_cutoffs": 863, "beta_cutoffs": 13051, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6059.571428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6631.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1826, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1775, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 40292, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 82, 97, 98, 84, 99, 113, 129, 126, 130, 111, 141, 83, 125, 69, 55, 66, 81, 68, 67, 100, 52, 128, 37, 22, 142, 116, 132, 117, 115, 86, 72, 85, 87, 101, 133, 53 ], "move_count": 40, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 11065, "avg_search_time_ms": 614.7222222222222, "search_nodes": 123374, "safety_nodes": 1337, "corridor_nodes": 425, "corridor_branch_probes": 470, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 150, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 416, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 416, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 15, "corridor_proof_completed": 15, "corridor_proof_checks": 90, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 81, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 150, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 90, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 89, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 600, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 678960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 15920, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 125136, "avg_nodes": 6952.0, "eval_calls": 94967, "avg_eval_calls": 5275.944444444444, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 94967, "pattern_eval_ns": 2065329, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.747859782871945, "pattern_frame_queries": 94967, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2065329, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.747859782871945, "pattern_frame_updates": 246578, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2610843764, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10588.307813349124, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 26477, "avg_candidate_generations": 1470.9444444444443, "candidate_moves_total": 1840239, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.50330475507045, "candidate_moves_max": 103, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1214, "root_candidate_moves_max": 87, "search_candidate_generations": 26459, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1839025, "search_candidate_moves_max": 103, "legality_checks": 1048908, "avg_legality_checks": 58272.666666666664, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3800, "root_legality_checks": 1214, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 20, "search_legality_checks": 1047694, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3780, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2931466, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 162859.22222222222, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6678313471, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2278.1480225252485, "renju_forbidden_checks": 19813, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1100.7222222222222, "renju_forbidden_ns": 95210249, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4805.443345278352, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3909, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 40198444, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4901, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35744301, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10805, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 17396102, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 198, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1871402, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 69441, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3857.8333333333335, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 646923400, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9316.159041488458, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 95462, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5303.444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 288469031, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3021.8205254446793, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2689976723, "stage_ordering_ns": 802950645, "stage_eval_ns": 2612909093, "stage_threat_ns": 4683173931, "stage_proof_ns": 213866621, "tactical_annotations": 319703, "root_tactical_annotations": 1370, "search_tactical_annotations": 318333, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 247608, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1483053648, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 348766, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2974474285, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 53602, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1978036375, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 123795, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 181921501, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1012, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6528660, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 247590, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31384328, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 72712, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 143874496, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 195456, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 786026318, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 51535, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5811509, "child_limit_applications": 26459, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 26459, "child_cap_hits": 26459, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 26459, "child_moves_before_total": 1835245, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1835245, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 423354, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 423354, "child_moves_after_max": 18, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 18, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.36184285120375, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.000377943232927, "tt_hits": 8444, "tt_cutoffs": 1863, "beta_cutoffs": 20192, "depth_sum": 84, "avg_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 84, "avg_effective_depth": 4.666666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 15 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5133.444444444444, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5577.888888888889, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 29210, "avg_search_time_ms": 1622.7777777777778, "search_nodes": 192711, "safety_nodes": 427, "corridor_nodes": 568, "corridor_branch_probes": 592, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 92, "corridor_neutral_exits": 79, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 552, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 552, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 84, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 68, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 79, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 92, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 84, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 82, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 672, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 36880200, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2023760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 193706, "avg_nodes": 10761.444444444445, "eval_calls": 107989, "avg_eval_calls": 5999.388888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 107989, "pattern_eval_ns": 2466470, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.84001148265101, "pattern_frame_queries": 107989, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2466470, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.84001148265101, "pattern_frame_updates": 385218, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3483960376, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9044.126639980479, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 79116, "avg_candidate_generations": 4395.333333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 6172006, "avg_candidate_moves": 78.01210880226503, "candidate_moves_max": 115, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1248, "root_candidate_moves_max": 88, "search_candidate_generations": 79098, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6170758, "search_candidate_moves_max": 115, "legality_checks": 4629922, "avg_legality_checks": 257217.88888888888, "illegal_moves_skipped": 36449, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 4629922, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 36449, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 8958139, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 497674.3888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 19456971142, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2171.9880816763393, "renju_forbidden_checks": 102485, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5693.611111111111, "renju_forbidden_ns": 581685279, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5675.80893789335, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 37205, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 378434664, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12353, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 104790041, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 52736, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 96347319, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 191, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2113255, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 250170, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 13898.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2419211790, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9670.271375464685, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 336143, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 18674.61111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1148552300, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3416.8562189306335, "stage_move_gen_ns": 11577548920, "stage_ordering_ns": 2485942544, "stage_eval_ns": 3486426846, "stage_threat_ns": 11314936174, "stage_proof_ns": 145664365, "tactical_annotations": 1451173, "root_tactical_annotations": 6157, "search_tactical_annotations": 1445016, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 386508, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2325899309, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1166122, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8571672998, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 159086, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5304908534, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 193245, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 298781380, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1272, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8875379, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 386490, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 50095694, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 427788, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1316674688, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 532551, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1920949244, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 490834, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 59611414, "child_limit_applications": 79098, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 79098, "child_cap_hits": 79098, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 79098, "child_moves_before_total": 6134309, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6134309, "child_moves_before_max": 115, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 115, "child_moves_after_total": 706149, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 706149, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.55327568332955, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.92752029128423, "tt_hits": 46871, "tt_cutoffs": 5528, "beta_cutoffs": 64839, "depth_sum": 96, "avg_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 96, "avg_effective_depth": 5.333333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 7, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.3888888888888889, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 7, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.3888888888888889, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 899.8333333333334, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1282.0555555555557, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1776, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 18835, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 23, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 28, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 96, 127, 114, 97, 82, 98, 54, 68, 84, 83, 53, 113, 128, 99, 85, 81, 129, 115, 131, 65, 49, 67, 51, 66, 64, 69 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 14956, "avg_search_time_ms": 1246.3333333333333, "search_nodes": 151348, "safety_nodes": 349, "corridor_nodes": 2064, "corridor_branch_probes": 2323, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1003, "corridor_neutral_exits": 1, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 2052, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2052, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 54, "corridor_proof_active": 12, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1003, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 54, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 53, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 424, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 31955440, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2032640, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 153761, "avg_nodes": 12813.416666666666, "eval_calls": 103540, "avg_eval_calls": 8628.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 103540, "pattern_eval_ns": 2133227, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.602926405254006, "pattern_frame_queries": 103540, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2133227, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.602926405254006, "pattern_frame_updates": 302588, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4218943435, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13942.86434029109, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 45109, "avg_candidate_generations": 3759.0833333333335, "candidate_moves_total": 3268666, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.46150435611519, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 756, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 45097, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3267910, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 891084, "avg_legality_checks": 74257.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1438, "root_legality_checks": 756, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 890328, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1438, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4229482, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 352456.8333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8993813587, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2126.457468550522, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31621, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2635.0833333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 188950233, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5975.466715157649, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1621, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13574809, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17957, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 135611435, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11854, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 38749887, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 189, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1014102, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 111216, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9268.0, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 919919676, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8271.46881743634, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 144486, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12040.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 369630192, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2558.242265686641, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2120122833, "stage_ordering_ns": 1282443508, "stage_eval_ns": 4221076662, "stage_threat_ns": 7000431184, "stage_proof_ns": 288970300, "tactical_annotations": 779039, "root_tactical_annotations": 2666, "search_tactical_annotations": 776373, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 306812, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1809964679, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 710301, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4867588307, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 91383, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3243258906, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 153400, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 223852365, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 4212, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 23181853, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 306800, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 38154994, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 185646, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 207544325, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 324376, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1106551598, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 269017, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 37688986, "child_limit_applications": 45097, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 45097, "child_cap_hits": 45097, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 45097, "child_moves_before_total": 3266472, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3266472, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 466233, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 466233, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.43213517528882, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.338448233807126, "tt_hits": 24982, "tt_cutoffs": 2657, "beta_cutoffs": 35405, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3033.9166666666665, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3700.5833333333335, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 640, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 3868, "avg_search_time_ms": 351.6363636363636, "search_nodes": 34165, "safety_nodes": 845, "corridor_nodes": 28, "corridor_branch_probes": 28, "corridor_max_depth": 3, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 22, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 22, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 46, "corridor_proof_active": 6, "corridor_proof_quiet": 40, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 46, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 46, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 296, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 201360, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 14080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 35038, "avg_nodes": 3185.2727272727275, "eval_calls": 22662, "avg_eval_calls": 2060.181818181818, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22662, "pattern_eval_ns": 477120, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.05374635954461, "pattern_frame_queries": 22662, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 477120, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.05374635954461, "pattern_frame_updates": 68230, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 685873109, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10052.368591528653, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 10781, "avg_candidate_generations": 980.0909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 758125, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.32047119933216, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 681, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 10770, "search_candidate_moves_total": 757444, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 438225, "avg_legality_checks": 39838.63636363636, "illegal_moves_skipped": 130, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 438225, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 130, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1191362, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 108305.63636363637, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2479716723, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2081.4133093048126, "renju_forbidden_checks": 4287, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 389.72727272727275, "renju_forbidden_ns": 17836177, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4160.526475390716, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 132, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1227975, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1454, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 12691950, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2701, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3916252, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 42197, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3836.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 382040267, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9053.730525866767, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 57586, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5235.090909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 170472125, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2960.3050220539712, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1045107199, "stage_ordering_ns": 310739503, "stage_eval_ns": 686350229, "stage_threat_ns": 1715097246, "stage_proof_ns": 79595531, "tactical_annotations": 159923, "root_tactical_annotations": 626, "search_tactical_annotations": 159297, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 68377, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 404971304, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 157937, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1249567326, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 21812, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 738291963, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 34183, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 48398187, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 136, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 604664, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 68366, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 8283427, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 40333, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 143553223, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 92713, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 365840180, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 26877, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 3272338, "child_limit_applications": 10770, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 10770, "child_cap_hits": 10770, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 10770, "child_moves_before_total": 757314, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 757314, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 172915, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 172915, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.31699164345405, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.055246053853296, "tt_hits": 3744, "tt_cutoffs": 683, "beta_cutoffs": 9303, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5480.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6207.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1877, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1777, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 22967, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 67, 82, 96, 98, 66, 113, 143, 114, 68, 69, 81, 111, 53, 39, 38, 23, 64, 65, 80, 48, 52, 24, 94 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 12160, "avg_search_time_ms": 1013.3333333333334, "search_nodes": 124731, "safety_nodes": 188, "corridor_nodes": 5858, "corridor_branch_probes": 6112, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3117, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_plies_followed": 5836, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5836, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 85, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 63, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3117, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 20, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 3, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 85, "corridor_proof_wins": 3, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 82, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 3, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 686, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 663680, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 26080, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 130777, "avg_nodes": 10898.083333333334, "eval_calls": 90533, "avg_eval_calls": 7544.416666666667, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 90533, "pattern_eval_ns": 1880791, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.77464570929937, "pattern_frame_queries": 90533, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1880791, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.77464570929937, "pattern_frame_updates": 249358, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2792593656, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11199.134000112288, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32261, "avg_candidate_generations": 2688.4166666666665, "candidate_moves_total": 2415648, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.87827407705899, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 782, "root_candidate_moves_max": 84, "search_candidate_generations": 32249, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2414866, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 861209, "avg_legality_checks": 71767.41666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1377, "root_legality_checks": 782, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 860427, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1377, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3472714, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 289392.8333333333, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7336415798, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2112.5885396839476, "renju_forbidden_checks": 26361, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2196.75, "renju_forbidden_ns": 142989583, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5424.285231971473, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1497, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13334245, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12708, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 87521683, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10904, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 36684753, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1252, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5448902, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 78833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6569.416666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 650107834, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8246.645871652734, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 104827, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8735.583333333334, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 269428542, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2570.2208591298045, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2090257789, "stage_ordering_ns": 950787404, "stage_eval_ns": 2794474447, "stage_threat_ns": 5636735683, "stage_proof_ns": 634719250, "tactical_annotations": 483107, "root_tactical_annotations": 2905, "search_tactical_annotations": 480202, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 261212, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1553082099, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 709812, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3781693732, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 67366, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2315638258, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 130600, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 186565962, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 11842, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 72532665, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 261200, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 31410434, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 147443, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 112002418, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 219091, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 747165098, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 116573, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 11450791, "child_limit_applications": 32249, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32249, "child_cap_hits": 32249, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32249, "child_moves_before_total": 2413489, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2413489, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 519514, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 519514, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.8391888120562, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.10946075847313, "tt_hits": 13445, "tt_cutoffs": 1898, "beta_cutoffs": 26463, "depth_sum": 51, "avg_depth": 4.25, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 51, "avg_effective_depth": 4.25, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3704.8333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4371.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10797, "avg_search_time_ms": 981.5454545454545, "search_nodes": 82271, "safety_nodes": 865, "corridor_nodes": 717, "corridor_branch_probes": 822, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 306, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 707, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 707, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 52, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 42, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 7, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 306, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 52, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 323, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 42140960, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2022000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 83853, "avg_nodes": 7623.0, "eval_calls": 46024, "avg_eval_calls": 4184.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 46024, "pattern_eval_ns": 973771, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.15789588041022, "pattern_frame_queries": 46024, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 973771, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.15789588041022, "pattern_frame_updates": 164418, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1492334619, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9076.467412327118, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 32734, "avg_candidate_generations": 2975.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 2448690, "avg_candidate_moves": 74.80570660475347, "candidate_moves_max": 100, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 723, "root_candidate_moves_max": 83, "search_candidate_generations": 32723, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2447967, "search_candidate_moves_max": 100, "legality_checks": 1656434, "avg_legality_checks": 150584.9090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1476, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1656434, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1476, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3380867, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 307351.54545454547, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7114501083, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2104.3421947683833, "renju_forbidden_checks": 21320, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1938.1818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 66901502, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3137.9691369606003, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1482, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 13543275, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4988, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 36817341, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 14850, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16540886, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 75830, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6893.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 636475390, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8393.451008835553, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98174, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8924.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 266047491, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2709.9587569010123, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3885038574, "stage_ordering_ns": 962194105, "stage_eval_ns": 1493308390, "stage_threat_ns": 4298170278, "stage_proof_ns": 83271027, "tactical_annotations": 526019, "root_tactical_annotations": 1201, "search_tactical_annotations": 524818, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 165947, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 979771632, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 454622, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3145474218, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 66020, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2128250218, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 82968, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 120514276, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1518, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8975425, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 165936, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 20328280, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 96299, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 147546647, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 250671, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 838573073, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 179049, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23106447, "child_limit_applications": 32723, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 32723, "child_cap_hits": 32723, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 32723, "child_moves_before_total": 2446491, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2446491, "child_moves_before_max": 100, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 100, "child_moves_after_total": 301916, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 301916, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 74.76365247685115, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.226415670934816, "tt_hits": 18803, "tt_cutoffs": 3462, "beta_cutoffs": 26810, "depth_sum": 62, "avg_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 62, "avg_effective_depth": 5.636363636363637, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3107.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3834.2727272727275, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 393, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1778, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 36082, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 24, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 29, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 5 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 128, 97, 110, 127, 142, 126, 114, 156, 82, 98, 84, 171, 100, 86, 141, 140, 154, 124, 108, 139, 125, 155, 123, 172, 188, 173, 170, 187, 203, 159, 201, 175, 174, 143, 111, 191 ], "move_count": 37, "black_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 27714, "avg_search_time_ms": 1630.235294117647, "search_nodes": 266213, "safety_nodes": 275, "corridor_nodes": 800, "corridor_branch_probes": 903, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 386, "corridor_neutral_exits": 4, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 793, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 793, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 52, "corridor_proof_active": 7, "corridor_proof_quiet": 45, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 386, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 52, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 52, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 418, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 29862160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2025680, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 267288, "avg_nodes": 15722.823529411764, "eval_calls": 167624, "avg_eval_calls": 9860.235294117647, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 167624, "pattern_eval_ns": 3441824, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.533002434018996, "pattern_frame_queries": 167624, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3441824, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.533002434018996, "pattern_frame_updates": 532272, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6857832915, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12884.076026918568, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 90445, "avg_candidate_generations": 5320.294117647059, "candidate_moves_total": 8300748, "avg_candidate_moves": 91.77674830007187, "candidate_moves_max": 128, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1338, "root_candidate_moves_max": 98, "search_candidate_generations": 90428, "search_candidate_moves_total": 8299410, "search_candidate_moves_max": 128, "legality_checks": 2283329, "avg_legality_checks": 134313.4705882353, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2265, "root_legality_checks": 1338, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2281991, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2265, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7765776, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 456810.35294117645, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 16183492121, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2083.9504153866915, "renju_forbidden_checks": 63269, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3721.705882352941, "renju_forbidden_ns": 305580907, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4829.8678183628635, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2680, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 19697654, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 32353, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 203125389, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 28113, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 81902622, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 123, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 855242, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 161193, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9481.941176470587, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1325773987, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8224.761540513546, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 219933, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12937.235294117647, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 575136833, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2615.054734851068, "stage_move_gen_ns": 5189644716, "stage_ordering_ns": 3070347996, "stage_eval_ns": 6861274739, "stage_threat_ns": 12321375007, "stage_proof_ns": 171015259, "tactical_annotations": 2003508, "root_tactical_annotations": 5181, "search_tactical_annotations": 1998327, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 533979, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3014195890, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1688564, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 8770234035, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 181472, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 6020157566, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 266981, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 384168015, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1690, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 8841965, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 533962, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 65466330, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 496683, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 319162315, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 967208, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2316872184, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 539617, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 78468772, "child_limit_applications": 90428, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 90428, "child_cap_hits": 90428, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 90428, "child_moves_before_total": 8297145, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 8297145, "child_moves_before_max": 128, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 128, "child_moves_after_total": 1177781, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1177781, "child_moves_after_max": 28, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 28, "avg_child_moves_before": 91.754158004158, "avg_child_moves_after": 13.024516742601849, "tt_hits": 46065, "tt_cutoffs": 8087, "beta_cutoffs": 71267, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 4.294117647058823, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 4.294117647058823, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 6, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.35294117647058826, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.23529411764705882, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 1514.5294117647059, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 1891.764705882353, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 18, "search_move_count": 16, "total_time_ms": 8351, "avg_search_time_ms": 521.9375, "search_nodes": 76161, "safety_nodes": 1660, "corridor_nodes": 1454, "corridor_branch_probes": 1714, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 5, "corridor_depth_exits": 689, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 1438, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1438, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 14, "corridor_proof_completed": 14, "corridor_proof_checks": 73, "corridor_proof_active": 16, "corridor_proof_quiet": 57, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 15, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 689, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 73, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 73, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 457, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 271760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 18320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 79275, "avg_nodes": 4954.6875, "eval_calls": 53298, "avg_eval_calls": 3331.125, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 53298, "pattern_eval_ns": 1109582, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.818454726256146, "pattern_frame_queries": 53298, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1109582, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.818454726256146, "pattern_frame_updates": 152172, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1439351563, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9458.714894987252, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21686, "avg_candidate_generations": 1355.375, "candidate_moves_total": 1788164, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.45706907682376, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 16, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1262, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 21670, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1786902, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 1008863, "avg_legality_checks": 63053.9375, "illegal_moves_skipped": 192, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1008863, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 192, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2476141, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 154758.8125, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5203030451, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2101.265820888229, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13574, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 848.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 38016902, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2800.714748784441, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 203, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2009872, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2414, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 19775797, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10957, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 16231233, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 72419, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 4526.1875, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 645758037, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8916.96981455143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 99121, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 6195.0625, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 293682182, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2962.8654069268873, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2378122033, "stage_ordering_ns": 723898118, "stage_eval_ns": 1440461145, "stage_threat_ns": 3642877618, "stage_proof_ns": 110515956, "tactical_annotations": 366987, "root_tactical_annotations": 1111, "search_tactical_annotations": 365876, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 155210, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 926465796, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 412800, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2558110482, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44304, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1585066205, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 77597, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 110835178, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 3022, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 18093515, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 155194, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 19247332, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 101331, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 311774495, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 191331, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 604849604, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 74325, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 10125315, "child_limit_applications": 21670, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21670, "child_cap_hits": 21670, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21670, "child_moves_before_total": 1786710, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1786710, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 351245, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 351245, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.4508537148131, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.208814028610984, "tt_hits": 8064, "tt_cutoffs": 1118, "beta_cutoffs": 18188, "depth_sum": 75, "avg_depth": 4.6875, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 75, "avg_effective_depth": 4.6875, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 14 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 16, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0625, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5739.5625, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6239.5625, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1111, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1779, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "white_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 67277, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 111, 110, 96, 142, 94, 98, 128, 80, 95, 93, 79, 63, 64, 109, 127, 143, 141, 99, 81, 78, 49, 34, 66, 51, 65, 97, 33, 17, 67, 68, 53, 39, 108, 100, 101, 84, 144, 160, 52, 115, 130, 69, 54, 129, 114, 158, 174, 157, 171, 159, 156, 161 ], "move_count": 56, "black_stats": { "move_count": 28, "search_move_count": 26, "total_time_ms": 31176, "avg_search_time_ms": 1199.076923076923, "search_nodes": 169452, "safety_nodes": 2207, "corridor_nodes": 72634, "corridor_branch_probes": 75730, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 41417, "corridor_neutral_exits": 713, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 72531, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 72531, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 24, "corridor_proof_completed": 22, "corridor_proof_checks": 254, "corridor_proof_active": 103, "corridor_proof_quiet": 151, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 713, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 41417, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 254, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 254, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 2, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1843, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24380240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1971840, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 244293, "avg_nodes": 9395.884615384615, "eval_calls": 122304, "avg_eval_calls": 4704.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 122304, "pattern_eval_ns": 2662070, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.766009288330718, "pattern_frame_queries": 122304, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2662070, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.766009288330718, "pattern_frame_updates": 338654, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3214948939, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9493.314530464722, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 44709, "avg_candidate_generations": 1719.576923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 3765923, "avg_candidate_moves": 84.23187725066542, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 26, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2072, "root_candidate_moves_max": 106, "search_candidate_generations": 44683, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3763851, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 1365436, "avg_legality_checks": 52516.769230769234, "illegal_moves_skipped": 326, "root_legality_checks": 2072, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1363364, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 326, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 10143140, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 390120.76923076925, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20237210683, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1995.1623149241755, "renju_forbidden_checks": 30148, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1159.5384615384614, "renju_forbidden_ns": 82799051, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2746.4193644686216, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 981, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3813987, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 7485, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 42762282, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 15225, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24084968, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 6457, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 12137814, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 196433, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7555.115384615385, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1429394156, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7276.751645599263, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 231090, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8888.076923076924, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 493800488, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2136.8319183002295, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3034137429, "stage_ordering_ns": 1354585645, "stage_eval_ns": 3217611009, "stage_threat_ns": 18092024204, "stage_proof_ns": 5384612399, "tactical_annotations": 797171, "root_tactical_annotations": 3771, "search_tactical_annotations": 793400, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 484250, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3765405434, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 3731371, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 12876351196, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 121226, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4489943801, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 242112, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 413108257, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 145570, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 959745028, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 484224, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 58605259, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 292421, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 240049105, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 330782, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1024236669, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 173968, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 18809030, "child_limit_applications": 44683, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 44683, "child_cap_hits": 44683, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 44683, "child_moves_before_total": 3763525, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3763525, "child_moves_before_max": 131, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 131, "child_moves_after_total": 717922, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 717922, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 84.22722288118524, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.067005348790367, "tt_hits": 19220, "tt_cutoffs": 2340, "beta_cutoffs": 36846, "depth_sum": 125, "avg_depth": 4.8076923076923075, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 125, "avg_effective_depth": 4.8076923076923075, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 24 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_moves": 26, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.19230769230769232, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.07692307692307693, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5384.192307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5691.884615384615, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 948, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 28, "search_move_count": 26, "total_time_ms": 36075, "avg_search_time_ms": 1387.5, "search_nodes": 257657, "safety_nodes": 1451, "corridor_nodes": 5425, "corridor_branch_probes": 5872, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 2205, "corridor_neutral_exits": 22, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 5387, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5387, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 20, "corridor_proof_completed": 19, "corridor_proof_checks": 91, "corridor_proof_active": 38, "corridor_proof_quiet": 53, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2205, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 91, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 89, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 1, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 531, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 43994880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2003600, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 264533, "avg_nodes": 10174.346153846154, "eval_calls": 149918, "avg_eval_calls": 5766.076923076923, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 149918, "pattern_eval_ns": 3362254, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.427286916847876, "pattern_frame_queries": 149918, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3362254, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.427286916847876, "pattern_frame_updates": 514988, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4291451107, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8333.108940402495, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 101285, "avg_candidate_generations": 3895.576923076923, "candidate_moves_total": 9671011, "avg_candidate_moves": 95.48315150318409, "candidate_moves_max": 131, "root_candidate_generations": 26, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2088, "root_candidate_moves_max": 107, "search_candidate_generations": 101259, "search_candidate_moves_total": 9668923, "search_candidate_moves_max": 131, "legality_checks": 6978158, "avg_legality_checks": 268390.6923076923, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1011, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 6978158, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1011, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 12415282, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 477510.8461538461, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 23989791266, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1932.279207673253, "renju_forbidden_checks": 48935, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1882.1153846153845, "renju_forbidden_ns": 88846280, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1815.5978338612445, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2378, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 10676297, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 8425, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 45907248, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 38132, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32262735, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 367169, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 14121.884615384615, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2736881938, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7454.011471556694, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 445587, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 17137.96153846154, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 994932057, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2232.8570110887435, "stage_move_gen_ns": 14519808583, "stage_ordering_ns": 3211103429, "stage_eval_ns": 4294813361, "stage_threat_ns": 13685039632, "stage_proof_ns": 111986451, "tactical_annotations": 1937502, "root_tactical_annotations": 5788, "search_tactical_annotations": 1931714, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 525970, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3117397816, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1919552, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 9963653821, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 205933, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 5850892874, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 262972, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 396546642, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 10956, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 73055809, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 525944, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 64834710, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 596597, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1342310397, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 816412, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2551305150, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 524493, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 69550834, "child_limit_applications": 101259, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 101259, "child_cap_hits": 101259, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 101259, "child_moves_before_total": 9667912, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 9667912, "child_moves_before_max": 131, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 131, "child_moves_after_total": 989184, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 989184, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 95.47706376717132, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.768850176280626, "tt_hits": 54722, "tt_cutoffs": 6320, "beta_cutoffs": 85684, "depth_sum": 160, "avg_depth": 6.153846153846154, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 160, "avg_effective_depth": 6.153846153846154, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 20 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_moves": 26, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3076923076923077, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.15384615384615385, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4849.692307692308, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5098.692307692308, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 331, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1780, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 52827, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 25, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 30, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 6 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 126, 113, 82, 114, 111, 96, 128, 127, 85, 141, 155, 142, 157, 143, 144, 115, 116, 159, 130, 158, 83, 81, 88, 102, 87, 84, 86, 89, 69, 139, 140, 97, 129, 65, 49, 101, 125, 110, 133, 95, 98, 109, 170, 185, 131, 132, 67, 94, 93, 124, 154, 79 ], "move_count": 53, "black_stats": { "move_count": 27, "search_move_count": 25, "total_time_ms": 34022, "avg_search_time_ms": 1360.88, "search_nodes": 313544, "safety_nodes": 1434, "corridor_nodes": 3885, "corridor_branch_probes": 4102, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1534, "corridor_neutral_exits": 126, "corridor_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_plies_followed": 3845, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3845, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 98, "corridor_proof_active": 40, "corridor_proof_quiet": 58, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 126, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1534, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 4, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 98, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 97, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 662, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 40789760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2012000, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 318863, "avg_nodes": 12754.52, "eval_calls": 192398, "avg_eval_calls": 7695.92, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 192398, "pattern_eval_ns": 4194587, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.801614361895655, "pattern_frame_queries": 192398, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 4194587, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.801614361895655, "pattern_frame_updates": 626806, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 7136993386, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11386.2876009483, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 112887, "avg_candidate_generations": 4515.48, "candidate_moves_total": 10145359, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.8718098629603, "candidate_moves_max": 129, "root_candidate_generations": 25, "root_candidate_moves_total": 2019, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 112862, "search_candidate_moves_total": 10143340, "search_candidate_moves_max": 129, "legality_checks": 2933421, "avg_legality_checks": 117336.84, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1355, "root_legality_checks": 2019, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2931402, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1355, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 9370156, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 374806.24, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 20014314720, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2135.9638750945023, "renju_forbidden_checks": 82048, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3281.92, "renju_forbidden_ns": 233234065, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2842.6538733424336, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3169, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 16368552, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 27829, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 125717033, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 50470, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 90068626, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 580, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1079854, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 196412, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7856.48, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1663105886, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8467.435217807466, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 271290, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10851.6, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 713025555, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2628.278060378193, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6925030703, "stage_ordering_ns": 3871486472, "stage_eval_ns": 7141187973, "stage_threat_ns": 15403758528, "stage_proof_ns": 540207383, "tactical_annotations": 2239150, "root_tactical_annotations": 6386, "search_tactical_annotations": 2232764, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 634717, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 3785759515, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 2024289, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 10901662021, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 228416, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 7427023644, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 317346, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 486650581, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 7886, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 62532552, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 634692, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 80197206, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 637982, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 496017755, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 942647, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2500591646, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 658521, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 86956653, "child_limit_applications": 112862, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 112862, "child_cap_hits": 112862, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 112862, "child_moves_before_total": 10141985, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 10141985, "child_moves_before_max": 129, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 129, "child_moves_after_total": 1073788, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 1073788, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.86182240258015, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.514167744679343, "tt_hits": 60456, "tt_cutoffs": 8143, "beta_cutoffs": 90086, "depth_sum": 137, "avg_depth": 5.48, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 137, "avg_effective_depth": 5.48, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 4, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.16, "pooled_budget_moves": 25, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.32, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 4, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.16, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4483.04, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4803.04, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 26, "search_move_count": 24, "total_time_ms": 18781, "avg_search_time_ms": 782.5416666666666, "search_nodes": 145545, "safety_nodes": 1885, "corridor_nodes": 2914, "corridor_branch_probes": 3485, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 7, "corridor_depth_exits": 935, "corridor_neutral_exits": 42, "corridor_terminal_exits": 67, "corridor_plies_followed": 2863, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2863, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 22, "corridor_proof_completed": 22, "corridor_proof_checks": 184, "corridor_proof_active": 51, "corridor_proof_quiet": 133, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 49, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 935, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 67, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 184, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 182, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1331, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 1154720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 23280, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 8, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 7, "total_nodes": 150344, "avg_nodes": 6264.333333333333, "eval_calls": 95483, "avg_eval_calls": 3978.4583333333335, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 95483, "pattern_eval_ns": 2111309, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.111883790831875, "pattern_frame_queries": 95483, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2111309, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.111883790831875, "pattern_frame_updates": 290860, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2674377659, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9194.72481262463, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 46462, "avg_candidate_generations": 1935.9166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 4148735, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.29307821445482, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 24, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1932, "root_candidate_moves_max": 103, "search_candidate_generations": 46438, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4146803, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 2860205, "avg_legality_checks": 119175.20833333333, "illegal_moves_skipped": 193, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 2860205, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 193, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5718588, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 238274.5, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12136254197, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2122.2466449759977, "renju_forbidden_checks": 61993, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2583.0416666666665, "renju_forbidden_ns": 110400383, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1780.8524026906264, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 495, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 2618360, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 6594, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35909028, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 54904, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 71872995, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 153918, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6413.25, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1428187282, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9278.884094128041, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 221029, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9209.541666666666, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 660667588, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2989.053870759041, "stage_move_gen_ns": 6722075735, "stage_ordering_ns": 1596104519, "stage_eval_ns": 2676488968, "stage_threat_ns": 7371123578, "stage_proof_ns": 285710160, "tactical_annotations": 934813, "root_tactical_annotations": 3946, "search_tactical_annotations": 930867, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 296978, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1818146371, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1032944, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5219403923, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 95152, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3073805057, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 148477, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 229353390, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6094, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 43419327, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 296954, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 37720880, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 367834, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 769168512, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 380783, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1242318065, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 186196, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 23079687, "child_limit_applications": 46438, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 46438, "child_cap_hits": 46438, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 46438, "child_moves_before_total": 4146610, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4146610, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 743400, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 743400, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.29346655756062, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.008441362677118, "tt_hits": 20593, "tt_cutoffs": 3509, "beta_cutoffs": 40201, "depth_sum": 115, "avg_depth": 4.791666666666667, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 115, "avg_effective_depth": 4.791666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 22 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 24, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6688.958333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 7022.291666666667, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1845, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1781, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16295, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 110, 113, 128, 144, 141, 97, 109, 108, 125, 93, 80, 65, 96, 64, 126, 81, 156 ], "move_count": 21, "black_stats": { "move_count": 11, "search_move_count": 9, "total_time_ms": 10145, "avg_search_time_ms": 1127.2222222222222, "search_nodes": 124879, "safety_nodes": 361, "corridor_nodes": 797, "corridor_branch_probes": 944, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 299, "corridor_neutral_exits": 10, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 778, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 778, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 83, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 64, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 299, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 83, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 81, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 684, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 45862640, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1993040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 126037, "avg_nodes": 14004.111111111111, "eval_calls": 102131, "avg_eval_calls": 11347.888888888889, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 102131, "pattern_eval_ns": 2070403, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.272032977254703, "pattern_frame_queries": 102131, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2070403, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.272032977254703, "pattern_frame_updates": 249684, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3333257268, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13349.90334983419, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 21744, "avg_candidate_generations": 2416.0, "candidate_moves_total": 1582611, "avg_candidate_moves": 72.78380242825607, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 9, "root_candidate_moves_total": 553, "root_candidate_moves_max": 74, "search_candidate_generations": 21735, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1582058, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 678815, "avg_legality_checks": 75423.88888888889, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2442, "root_legality_checks": 553, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 2, "search_legality_checks": 678262, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2440, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2725577, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 302841.8888888889, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5917660838, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2171.1589281829133, "renju_forbidden_checks": 33807, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 3756.3333333333335, "renju_forbidden_ns": 235074174, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6953.417162126187, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2577, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 25859248, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20730, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 174044821, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10060, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32644007, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 440, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2526098, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 65669, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7296.555555555556, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 607862729, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9256.463917525773, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 88238, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9804.222222222223, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 274450670, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3110.3455427366894, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1645170732, "stage_ordering_ns": 644833118, "stage_eval_ns": 3335327671, "stage_threat_ns": 4246634261, "stage_proof_ns": 239935513, "tactical_annotations": 278052, "root_tactical_annotations": 1710, "search_tactical_annotations": 276342, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 251415, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1430609710, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 311897, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2590875529, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 44201, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1641720950, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 125703, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 177443467, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1722, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 9873107, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 251406, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30125639, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 57538, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 85937165, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 159213, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 737608817, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 61301, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 7706809, "child_limit_applications": 21735, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 21735, "child_cap_hits": 21735, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 21735, "child_moves_before_total": 1579618, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1579618, "child_moves_before_max": 103, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 103, "child_moves_after_total": 348016, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 348016, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 72.67623648493213, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.011778237865194, "tt_hits": 8471, "tt_cutoffs": 976, "beta_cutoffs": 15019, "depth_sum": 37, "avg_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 37, "avg_effective_depth": 4.111111111111111, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 9, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1111111111111111, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2355.777777777778, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3232.4444444444443, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1115, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 6142, "avg_search_time_ms": 767.75, "search_nodes": 48670, "safety_nodes": 562, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 34, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 34, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 34, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 275, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 180320, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 13040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 49232, "avg_nodes": 6154.0, "eval_calls": 29538, "avg_eval_calls": 3692.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 29538, "pattern_eval_ns": 618741, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.947288238878734, "pattern_frame_queries": 29538, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 618741, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.947288238878734, "pattern_frame_updates": 97258, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1090054974, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11207.869522301507, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17753, "avg_candidate_generations": 2219.125, "candidate_moves_total": 1276788, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.91956289077902, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 491, "root_candidate_moves_max": 73, "search_candidate_generations": 17745, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1276297, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 720453, "avg_legality_checks": 90056.625, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1064, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 720453, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1064, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1813003, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 226625.375, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3972749165, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2191.2534976500315, "renju_forbidden_checks": 11323, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1415.375, "renju_forbidden_ns": 64016811, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5653.696988430628, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1104, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11331618, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4465, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 38749397, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 5744, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13812286, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 10, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 123510, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 47345, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 5918.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 438563784, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9263.148885837998, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 64012, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 8001.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 191839809, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2996.93509029557, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1771634397, "stage_ordering_ns": 544034525, "stage_eval_ns": 1090673715, "stage_threat_ns": 2640362684, "stage_proof_ns": 59513749, "tactical_annotations": 207862, "root_tactical_annotations": 781, "search_tactical_annotations": 207081, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 97334, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 589021893, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 180844, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1958311642, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35683, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1344362135, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48663, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 72382495, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 68, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 253664, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 97326, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12352216, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 24606, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 104168061, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 120482, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 509608175, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 62774, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 8040774, "child_limit_applications": 17745, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17745, "child_cap_hits": 17745, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17745, "child_moves_before_total": 1275233, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1275233, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 159685, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 159685, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.86435615666385, "avg_child_moves_after": 8.998872921949845, "tt_hits": 8526, "tt_cutoffs": 1346, "beta_cutoffs": 13858, "depth_sum": 41, "avg_depth": 5.125, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 41, "avg_effective_depth": 5.125, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3015.875, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4015.875, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 629, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1782, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 27626, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 26, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 31, "template_index": 3, "transform_index": 7 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 98, 111, 142, 113, 114, 128, 66, 82, 110, 96, 144, 97, 67, 125, 139, 129, 81, 130, 131, 145, 161, 115, 160, 101, 143, 85, 100, 69, 83, 53, 37, 117 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 21339, "avg_search_time_ms": 1422.6, "search_nodes": 211753, "safety_nodes": 211, "corridor_nodes": 73, "corridor_branch_probes": 94, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_neutral_exits": 5, "corridor_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_plies_followed": 69, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 69, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 3, "corridor_proof_completed": 3, "corridor_proof_checks": 22, "corridor_proof_active": 4, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 5, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 22, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 21, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 152, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 4085040, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2032880, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 1, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 212037, "avg_nodes": 14135.8, "eval_calls": 141050, "avg_eval_calls": 9403.333333333334, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 141050, "pattern_eval_ns": 2930686, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.77763913505849, "pattern_frame_queries": 141050, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2930686, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.77763913505849, "pattern_frame_updates": 423368, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 5847908496, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13812.825948111336, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 66359, "avg_candidate_generations": 4423.933333333333, "candidate_moves_total": 5473856, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.48852454075559, "candidate_moves_max": 120, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1076, "root_candidate_moves_max": 94, "search_candidate_generations": 66344, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5472780, "search_candidate_moves_max": 120, "legality_checks": 1571364, "avg_legality_checks": 104757.6, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3807, "root_legality_checks": 1076, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 1570288, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3806, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5805971, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 387064.73333333334, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12360565616, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2128.9402954303423, "renju_forbidden_checks": 127240, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 8482.666666666666, "renju_forbidden_ns": 458585386, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3604.097657969192, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 15185, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 66757793, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 50928, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 254257695, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 60957, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 137112898, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 170, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 457000, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 134902, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8993.466666666667, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1106672998, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8203.532920193918, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 174021, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11601.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 421619047, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2422.8055636963354, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3748788072, "stage_ordering_ns": 2129896301, "stage_eval_ns": 5850839182, "stage_threat_ns": 9495384780, "stage_proof_ns": 49879370, "tactical_annotations": 1365426, "root_tactical_annotations": 4193, "search_tactical_annotations": 1361233, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 423565, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2489355309, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1135447, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6586126884, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 132908, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4558594986, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 211775, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 313823838, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 182, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 926082, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 423550, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 53354364, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 350692, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 290356090, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 645959, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1724050431, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 368775, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 51798303, "child_limit_applications": 66344, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 66344, "child_cap_hits": 66344, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 66344, "child_moves_before_total": 5468974, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5468974, "child_moves_before_max": 120, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 120, "child_moves_after_total": 792626, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 792626, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.43358856867238, "avg_child_moves_after": 11.947214518268419, "tt_hits": 31064, "tt_cutoffs": 4292, "beta_cutoffs": 51100, "depth_sum": 67, "avg_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 67, "avg_effective_depth": 4.466666666666667, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 3 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.26666666666666666, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2717.3333333333335, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3250.6666666666665, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 226, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 6272, "avg_search_time_ms": 448.0, "search_nodes": 57592, "safety_nodes": 1415, "corridor_nodes": 66, "corridor_branch_probes": 86, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 63, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 63, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 51, "corridor_proof_active": 3, "corridor_proof_quiet": 48, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 22, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 51, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 51, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 301, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 178560, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 12640, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 59073, "avg_nodes": 4219.5, "eval_calls": 38888, "avg_eval_calls": 2777.714285714286, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 38888, "pattern_eval_ns": 819273, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.06750154289241, "pattern_frame_queries": 38888, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 819273, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.06750154289241, "pattern_frame_updates": 115054, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1180269217, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10258.393597788865, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17683, "avg_candidate_generations": 1263.0714285714287, "candidate_moves_total": 1349108, "avg_candidate_moves": 76.29406774868518, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 994, "root_candidate_moves_max": 89, "search_candidate_generations": 17669, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1348114, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 667374, "avg_legality_checks": 47669.57142857143, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2015, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 667374, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2015, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1817577, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 129826.92857142857, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3863045669, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2125.3821263143186, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20554, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1468.142857142857, "renju_forbidden_ns": 83790074, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4076.5823683954463, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 3283, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 23842713, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 5610, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 35173117, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 11496, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 24249312, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 165, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 524932, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 51385, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 3670.3571428571427, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 503940205, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9807.146151600662, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 75570, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 5397.857142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 238982454, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3162.398491464867, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1627552667, "stage_ordering_ns": 553856295, "stage_eval_ns": 1181088490, "stage_threat_ns": 2781459594, "stage_proof_ns": 88272821, "tactical_annotations": 285466, "root_tactical_annotations": 646, "search_tactical_annotations": 284820, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 115296, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 687730978, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 280418, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1991182858, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35660, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1248362893, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 57641, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 81976333, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 228, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1266233, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 115282, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 14338580, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 70669, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 203557029, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 169502, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 535320431, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 45295, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4964612, "child_limit_applications": 17669, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17669, "child_cap_hits": 17669, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17669, "child_moves_before_total": 1346099, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1346099, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 285104, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 285104, "child_moves_after_max": 24, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 24, "avg_child_moves_before": 76.18422095194974, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.135831116644972, "tt_hits": 5471, "tt_cutoffs": 970, "beta_cutoffs": 15143, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.07142857142857142, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5573.214285714285, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6144.642857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1753, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1783, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19045, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 98, 143, 82, 142, 114, 130, 97, 67, 96, 158, 173, 99, 110, 68, 140, 126, 95, 94, 125, 80, 155 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 12688, "avg_search_time_ms": 1153.4545454545455, "search_nodes": 116732, "safety_nodes": 146, "corridor_nodes": 5631, "corridor_branch_probes": 6281, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2425, "corridor_neutral_exits": 46, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 5582, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5582, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 99, "corridor_proof_active": 49, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 46, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2425, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 99, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 97, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 819, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26121760, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1982960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 122509, "avg_nodes": 11137.181818181818, "eval_calls": 87528, "avg_eval_calls": 7957.090909090909, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87528, "pattern_eval_ns": 1806447, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.63850425006855, "pattern_frame_queries": 87528, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1806447, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.63850425006855, "pattern_frame_updates": 233370, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3240349179, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13885.028834040366, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27212, "avg_candidate_generations": 2473.818181818182, "candidate_moves_total": 1990944, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.164192268117, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 676, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 27201, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1990268, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 757516, "avg_legality_checks": 68865.09090909091, "illegal_moves_skipped": 838, "root_legality_checks": 676, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 756840, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 838, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3712796, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 337526.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7890281432, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2125.1588915738976, "renju_forbidden_checks": 31103, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2827.5454545454545, "renju_forbidden_ns": 172366235, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5541.788091180915, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 950, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8179154, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 16221, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 124830786, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12919, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 33618994, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1013, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5737301, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 102625, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9329.545454545454, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 916256288, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8928.197690621193, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 136690, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12426.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 400602432, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2930.73693759602, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1821266375, "stage_ordering_ns": 816802248, "stage_eval_ns": 3242155626, "stage_threat_ns": 5993154109, "stage_proof_ns": 780668233, "tactical_annotations": 477784, "root_tactical_annotations": 2332, "search_tactical_annotations": 475452, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 244743, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1503450084, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 754558, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4199635768, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 57355, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2250444288, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 122366, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 181300002, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 11362, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 64528607, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 244732, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30546845, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 142385, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 191926543, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 224071, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 926538570, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 111328, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 13692803, "child_limit_applications": 27201, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27201, "child_cap_hits": 27201, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27201, "child_moves_before_total": 1989430, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1989430, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 435847, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 435847, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.13811992206169, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.02319767655601, "tt_hits": 11789, "tt_cutoffs": 1956, "beta_cutoffs": 21525, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3584.3636363636365, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4311.636363636364, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 644, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6347, "avg_search_time_ms": 634.7, "search_nodes": 49124, "safety_nodes": 948, "corridor_nodes": 241, "corridor_branch_probes": 292, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 74, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_plies_followed": 236, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 236, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 8, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 74, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 11, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 12, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 32, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6044800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2003760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 50313, "avg_nodes": 5031.3, "eval_calls": 29342, "avg_eval_calls": 2934.2, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 29342, "pattern_eval_ns": 623122, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.236521027878126, "pattern_frame_queries": 29342, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 623122, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.236521027878126, "pattern_frame_updates": 98138, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1087081235, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11077.067343944242, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17549, "avg_candidate_generations": 1754.9, "candidate_moves_total": 1240653, "avg_candidate_moves": 70.69650692347142, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 622, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 17539, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1240031, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 776342, "avg_legality_checks": 77634.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 594, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 776342, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 594, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1967850, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 196785.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4134739278, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2101.145553776965, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14976, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1497.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 42761842, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2855.3580395299145, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 605, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5850857, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 3730, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 25885265, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10641, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11025720, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 69166, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 6916.6, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 626557686, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9058.75265303762, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 93191, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9319.1, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 276063656, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2962.342457962679, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1852125261, "stage_ordering_ns": 517224635, "stage_eval_ns": 1087704357, "stage_threat_ns": 2831571283, "stage_proof_ns": 20522084, "tactical_annotations": 270777, "root_tactical_annotations": 395, "search_tactical_annotations": 270382, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 98646, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 592225735, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 256141, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2145522094, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 35296, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1267909054, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 49318, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 73012375, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 498, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 2492559, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 98636, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12327672, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32860, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 138815279, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 170847, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 726055150, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 67070, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 5990848, "child_limit_applications": 17539, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17539, "child_cap_hits": 17539, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17539, "child_moves_before_total": 1239437, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1239437, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 182428, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 182428, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 70.66748389303837, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.401277153771595, "tt_hits": 8882, "tt_cutoffs": 2189, "beta_cutoffs": 14248, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4416.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5216.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1784, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17723, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 27, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 0, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 0 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 113, 127, 128, 97, 142, 98, 156, 82, 67, 114, 66, 96, 99, 68, 54, 140, 126, 110, 124, 95, 94, 125, 80, 155 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 15331, "avg_search_time_ms": 1393.7272727272727, "search_nodes": 132658, "safety_nodes": 282, "corridor_nodes": 6133, "corridor_branch_probes": 6475, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2911, "corridor_neutral_exits": 9, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 6106, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6106, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2911, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 57, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 432, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 39692720, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 139073, "avg_nodes": 12643.0, "eval_calls": 86238, "avg_eval_calls": 7839.818181818182, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 86238, "pattern_eval_ns": 1780130, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.64206034462766, "pattern_frame_queries": 86238, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1780130, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.64206034462766, "pattern_frame_updates": 265202, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3531315076, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13315.567288331158, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43486, "avg_candidate_generations": 3953.2727272727275, "candidate_moves_total": 3482770, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.08945407717427, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 687, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 43475, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3482083, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 959647, "avg_legality_checks": 87240.63636363637, "illegal_moves_skipped": 778, "root_legality_checks": 687, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 958960, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 777, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4381767, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 398342.45454545453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9412947544, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2148.208141601322, "renju_forbidden_checks": 23516, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2137.818181818182, "renju_forbidden_ns": 134261683, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5709.375871746895, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 900, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8022849, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12365, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 91785619, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9733, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 31514627, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 518, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 2938588, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 93505, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8500.454545454546, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 819112934, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8760.097684615796, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 122668, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 11151.636363636364, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 348720772, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2842.801480418691, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2296583910, "stage_ordering_ns": 1417708722, "stage_eval_ns": 3533095206, "stage_threat_ns": 7338395550, "stage_proof_ns": 699557752, "tactical_annotations": 668247, "root_tactical_annotations": 2553, "search_tactical_annotations": 665694, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 277543, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1712596511, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 840400, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5277752150, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90102, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3400640072, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 138766, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 209122251, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12330, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 73497293, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 277532, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 34687659, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 168613, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 178920016, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 253603, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 888144949, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 246031, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 30739686, "child_limit_applications": 43475, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43475, "child_cap_hits": 43475, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43475, "child_moves_before_total": 3481306, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3481306, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 406321, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 406321, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.07604370327775, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.346083956296722, "tt_hits": 26352, "tt_cutoffs": 2888, "beta_cutoffs": 34365, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 5.181818181818182, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 5.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2215.5454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 2829.5454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 553, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2380, "avg_search_time_ms": 238.0, "search_nodes": 23315, "safety_nodes": 874, "corridor_nodes": 78, "corridor_branch_probes": 79, "corridor_max_depth": 5, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 23, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 67, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 67, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 26, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 186, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 73120, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 5040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 24267, "avg_nodes": 2426.7, "eval_calls": 16136, "avg_eval_calls": 1613.6, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 16136, "pattern_eval_ns": 332560, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.609816559246404, "pattern_frame_queries": 16136, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 332560, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.609816559246404, "pattern_frame_updates": 46540, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 471969199, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10141.151675977653, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6760, "avg_candidate_generations": 676.0, "candidate_moves_total": 484368, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.65207100591716, "candidate_moves_max": 111, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 625, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 6750, "search_candidate_moves_total": 483743, "search_candidate_moves_max": 111, "legality_checks": 215937, "avg_legality_checks": 21593.7, "illegal_moves_skipped": 121, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 215937, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 121, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 687301, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 68730.1, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1459665133, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2123.764017511978, "renju_forbidden_checks": 2769, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 276.9, "renju_forbidden_ns": 12300830, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4442.336583604189, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 127, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1223921, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 974, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 7689349, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1663, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3332029, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 55531, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 20103, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2010.3, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 194726740, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9686.451773367158, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27924, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2792.4, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 91468210, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3275.6127345652485, "stage_move_gen_ns": 521151826, "stage_ordering_ns": 203124223, "stage_eval_ns": 472301759, "stage_threat_ns": 1098345895, "stage_proof_ns": 63264458, "tactical_annotations": 97664, "root_tactical_annotations": 311, "search_tactical_annotations": 97353, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 46758, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 283280818, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 102405, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 774299946, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13761, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 498147862, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 23374, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 32846593, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 208, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 990595, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 46748, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5705907, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 25097, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 80039978, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 55381, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 190980362, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 17186, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1222036, "child_limit_applications": 6750, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6750, "child_cap_hits": 6750, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6750, "child_moves_before_total": 483622, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 483622, "child_moves_before_max": 111, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 111, "child_moves_after_total": 108067, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 108067, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.6477037037037, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.009925925925927, "tt_hits": 2349, "tt_cutoffs": 384, "beta_cutoffs": 5687, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5607.2, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6407.2, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1836, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1785, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19054, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 128, 95, 140, 109, 108, 141, 157, 81, 129, 130, 123, 83, 97, 80, 65, 82, 79, 84 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 10705, "avg_search_time_ms": 973.1818181818181, "search_nodes": 100495, "safety_nodes": 151, "corridor_nodes": 7279, "corridor_branch_probes": 8055, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3441, "corridor_neutral_exits": 16, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 7234, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 7234, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 99, "corridor_proof_active": 45, "corridor_proof_quiet": 54, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 16, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3441, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 99, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 97, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 819, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 24182080, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 107925, "avg_nodes": 9811.363636363636, "eval_calls": 75089, "avg_eval_calls": 6826.272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 75089, "pattern_eval_ns": 1516206, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.192118685826152, "pattern_frame_queries": 75089, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1516206, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.192118685826152, "pattern_frame_updates": 200896, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 2641767040, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13149.923542529468, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 23767, "avg_candidate_generations": 2160.6363636363635, "candidate_moves_total": 1706283, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.79210670257079, "candidate_moves_max": 105, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 661, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 23756, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1705622, "search_candidate_moves_max": 105, "legality_checks": 588513, "avg_legality_checks": 53501.181818181816, "illegal_moves_skipped": 678, "root_legality_checks": 661, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 587852, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 678, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3359135, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 305375.9090909091, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 6653509253, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1980.7210049610985, "renju_forbidden_checks": 27108, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2464.3636363636365, "renju_forbidden_ns": 135745286, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5007.5728936107425, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 877, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 5912448, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 14933, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 97884062, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10386, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 26991630, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 912, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 4957146, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 85137, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7739.727272727273, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 719980511, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8456.728696101578, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 113399, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10309.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 327312113, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2886.375655869981, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1328714122, "stage_ordering_ns": 655705514, "stage_eval_ns": 2643283246, "stage_threat_ns": 5178170077, "stage_proof_ns": 867604787, "tactical_annotations": 447104, "root_tactical_annotations": 2232, "search_tactical_annotations": 444872, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 215573, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1264077092, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 781707, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 3640572924, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 50972, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1890754790, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 107781, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 154747129, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 14666, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 81057684, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 215562, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 25183248, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 133961, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 131207985, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 201051, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 692327864, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 112092, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 12532000, "child_limit_applications": 23756, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 23756, "child_cap_hits": 23756, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 23756, "child_moves_before_total": 1704944, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1704944, "child_moves_before_max": 105, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 105, "child_moves_after_total": 381324, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 381324, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.76898467755514, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.05169220407476, "tt_hits": 10895, "tt_cutoffs": 1603, "beta_cutoffs": 18853, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.09090909090909091, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4113.727272727273, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4841.0, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1171, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 8337, "avg_search_time_ms": 833.7, "search_nodes": 73647, "safety_nodes": 904, "corridor_nodes": 721, "corridor_branch_probes": 880, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 1, "corridor_depth_exits": 279, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 716, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 30, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 25, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 1, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 279, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 30, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 29, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 166, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 10019920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2000720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 75272, "avg_nodes": 7527.2, "eval_calls": 44337, "avg_eval_calls": 4433.7, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 44337, "pattern_eval_ns": 924824, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.858966551638588, "pattern_frame_queries": 44337, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 924824, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.858966551638588, "pattern_frame_updates": 147182, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1691676467, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11493.772791509831, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 25418, "avg_candidate_generations": 2541.8, "candidate_moves_total": 1764586, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.42269258006138, "candidate_moves_max": 101, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 603, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 25408, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1763983, "search_candidate_moves_max": 101, "legality_checks": 784720, "avg_legality_checks": 78472.0, "illegal_moves_skipped": 469, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 784720, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 469, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2457992, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 245799.2, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 5088964445, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2070.374698127577, "renju_forbidden_checks": 14136, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1413.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 46225202, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3270.0340973401244, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 473, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4133525, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4341, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28234527, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9322, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 13857150, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 78537, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7853.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 668127228, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8507.165132357997, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 105475, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10547.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 286011894, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2711.655785731216, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1840918221, "stage_ordering_ns": 733970516, "stage_eval_ns": 1692601291, "stage_threat_ns": 3989388070, "stage_proof_ns": 43724051, "tactical_annotations": 434504, "root_tactical_annotations": 418, "search_tactical_annotations": 434086, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 148684, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 895398466, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 440822, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2947979260, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 51267, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1848089701, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 74337, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 110482288, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1492, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 7848793, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 148674, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 18673464, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 52682, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 132690554, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 291185, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 929512234, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 90637, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 9005799, "child_limit_applications": 25408, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 25408, "child_cap_hits": 25408, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 25408, "child_moves_before_total": 1763514, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1763514, "child_moves_before_max": 101, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 101, "child_moves_after_total": 277150, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 277150, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.4078243073048, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.907981738035264, "tt_hits": 11365, "tt_cutoffs": 3846, "beta_cutoffs": 20586, "depth_sum": 56, "avg_depth": 5.6, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 56, "avg_effective_depth": 5.6, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3603.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4403.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 281, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1786, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 14833, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 28, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 1, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 1 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 127, 111, 126, 110, 113, 125, 85, 109, 108, 141, 93, 95, 140, 123, 71, 99, 137, 97, 83, 80, 65, 96, 98, 128, 64, 144 ], "move_count": 27, "black_stats": { "move_count": 14, "search_move_count": 12, "total_time_ms": 12747, "avg_search_time_ms": 1062.25, "search_nodes": 171203, "safety_nodes": 583, "corridor_nodes": 2946, "corridor_branch_probes": 3259, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1292, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 2922, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 2922, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 24, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1292, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 429, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 43693920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2026960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 174732, "avg_nodes": 14561.0, "eval_calls": 113763, "avg_eval_calls": 9480.25, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 113763, "pattern_eval_ns": 2162560, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.00934398706082, "pattern_frame_queries": 113763, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2162560, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.00934398706082, "pattern_frame_updates": 342294, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3483293383, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10176.320306520125, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 53786, "avg_candidate_generations": 4482.166666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 4652288, "avg_candidate_moves": 86.4962629680586, "candidate_moves_max": 117, "root_candidate_generations": 12, "root_candidate_moves_total": 864, "root_candidate_moves_max": 93, "search_candidate_generations": 53774, "search_candidate_moves_total": 4651424, "search_candidate_moves_max": 117, "legality_checks": 1156958, "avg_legality_checks": 96413.16666666667, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1507, "root_legality_checks": 864, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 1156094, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1507, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5104991, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 425415.9166666667, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7393035468, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1448.1975517684557, "renju_forbidden_checks": 61249, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 5104.083333333333, "renju_forbidden_ns": 181868335, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2969.327417590491, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2647, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 9228414, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 34308, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 127633393, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 23964, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 43287764, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 330, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 1718764, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 116236, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9686.333333333334, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 662147514, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5696.5786331257095, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 149154, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12429.5, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 274629998, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1841.251310725827, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1903552077, "stage_ordering_ns": 1214078569, "stage_eval_ns": 3485455943, "stage_threat_ns": 5802164358, "stage_proof_ns": 274452560, "tactical_annotations": 1009880, "root_tactical_annotations": 2647, "search_tactical_annotations": 1007233, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 348262, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1461999447, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1010727, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4055682558, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 109140, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2712356908, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 174125, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 193718181, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 5956, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 22196447, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 348250, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32011227, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 252291, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 157091679, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 479037, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 913097173, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 278552, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 36556498, "child_limit_applications": 53774, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 53774, "child_cap_hits": 53774, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 53774, "child_moves_before_total": 4649917, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 4649917, "child_moves_before_max": 117, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 117, "child_moves_after_total": 532461, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 532461, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 86.47147320266299, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.901829880611448, "tt_hits": 27565, "tt_cutoffs": 3610, "beta_cutoffs": 42592, "depth_sum": 55, "avg_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 55, "avg_effective_depth": 4.583333333333333, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 12, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 3, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.25, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4412.833333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5079.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1223, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 2076, "avg_search_time_ms": 188.72727272727272, "search_nodes": 26384, "safety_nodes": 1149, "corridor_nodes": 58, "corridor_branch_probes": 60, "corridor_max_depth": 5, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 49, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 49, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 36, "corridor_proof_active": 9, "corridor_proof_quiet": 27, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 36, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 36, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 177, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 77920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 10800, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 27591, "avg_nodes": 2508.2727272727275, "eval_calls": 18102, "avg_eval_calls": 1645.6363636363637, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 18102, "pattern_eval_ns": 346032, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.115677825654625, "pattern_frame_queries": 18102, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 346032, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.115677825654625, "pattern_frame_updates": 52668, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 419212617, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 7959.531727044885, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 7847, "avg_candidate_generations": 713.3636363636364, "candidate_moves_total": 608098, "avg_candidate_moves": 77.49432904294635, "candidate_moves_max": 118, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 786, "root_candidate_moves_max": 92, "search_candidate_generations": 7836, "search_candidate_moves_total": 607312, "search_candidate_moves_max": 118, "legality_checks": 253472, "avg_legality_checks": 23042.909090909092, "illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 253472, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 84, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 796026, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 72366.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1262858902, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1586.454339431124, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3895, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 354.09090909090907, "renju_forbidden_ns": 8916616, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2289.246726572529, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 98, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 447935, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1280, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 5578463, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2517, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 2890218, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 23224, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2111.2727272727275, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 167956600, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7232.027213227696, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 31666, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2878.7272727272725, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 78956254, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2493.407882271206, "stage_move_gen_ns": 456126766, "stage_ordering_ns": 177991335, "stage_eval_ns": 419558649, "stage_threat_ns": 954419865, "stage_proof_ns": 48872933, "tactical_annotations": 124487, "root_tactical_annotations": 306, "search_tactical_annotations": 124181, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 52849, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 238963454, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 126405, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 678198353, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 15922, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 437239514, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 26419, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 29885906, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 170, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 583275, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 52838, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5077400, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32788, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 67697570, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 71580, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 170697512, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 20119, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1711477, "child_limit_applications": 7836, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 7836, "child_cap_hits": 7836, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 7836, "child_moves_before_total": 607228, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 607228, "child_moves_before_max": 118, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 118, "child_moves_after_total": 125406, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 125406, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 77.4920877998979, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.00382848392037, "tt_hits": 2469, "tt_cutoffs": 396, "beta_cutoffs": 6642, "depth_sum": 50, "avg_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 50, "avg_effective_depth": 4.545454545454546, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5846.454545454545, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6573.727272727273, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1843, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1787, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 8377, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 81, 141, 126, 127, 98, 140, 113, 129, 83, 128, 84, 70, 82, 85, 80 ], "move_count": 19, "black_stats": { "move_count": 10, "search_move_count": 8, "total_time_ms": 5190, "avg_search_time_ms": 648.75, "search_nodes": 91010, "safety_nodes": 66, "corridor_nodes": 934, "corridor_branch_probes": 1115, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 262, "corridor_neutral_exits": 50, "corridor_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_plies_followed": 909, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 909, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 6, "corridor_proof_completed": 6, "corridor_proof_checks": 66, "corridor_proof_active": 25, "corridor_proof_quiet": 41, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 50, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 262, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 66, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 64, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 546, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 22364880, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1997040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 92010, "avg_nodes": 11501.25, "eval_calls": 70672, "avg_eval_calls": 8834.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 70672, "pattern_eval_ns": 1293862, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.30798618972153, "pattern_frame_queries": 70672, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1293862, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.30798618972153, "pattern_frame_updates": 181956, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1587686525, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8725.661835828441, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 19241, "avg_candidate_generations": 2405.125, "candidate_moves_total": 1238175, "avg_candidate_moves": 64.35086533963931, "candidate_moves_max": 96, "root_candidate_generations": 8, "root_candidate_moves_total": 420, "root_candidate_moves_max": 67, "search_candidate_generations": 19233, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1237755, "search_candidate_moves_max": 96, "legality_checks": 538566, "avg_legality_checks": 67320.75, "illegal_moves_skipped": 552, "root_legality_checks": 420, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 538146, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 552, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 2327127, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 290890.875, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 3078135279, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1322.7190776438072, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20969, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2621.125, "renju_forbidden_ns": 73512711, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3505.7804854785636, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 666, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 3572075, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 11633, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 58132801, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 8630, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11682565, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 40, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 125270, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 62041, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7755.125, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 343080731, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5529.903305878371, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 85288, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10661.0, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 153621276, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1801.206218928806, "stage_move_gen_ns": 785529124, "stage_ordering_ns": 328618456, "stage_eval_ns": 1588980387, "stage_threat_ns": 2293310163, "stage_proof_ns": 163036986, "tactical_annotations": 241166, "root_tactical_annotations": 1503, "search_tactical_annotations": 239663, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 183914, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 666294791, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 300363, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1510331623, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 39252, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 931449446, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 91953, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 90188736, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 1950, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 6494191, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 183906, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 15086300, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 50781, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 64768817, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 139485, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 406243551, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 50900, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 4914522, "child_limit_applications": 19233, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 19233, "child_cap_hits": 19233, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 19233, "child_moves_before_total": 1237203, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1237203, "child_moves_before_max": 95, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 95, "child_moves_after_total": 307795, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 307795, "child_moves_after_max": 20, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 20, "avg_child_moves_before": 64.32709405708938, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.003483595902875, "tt_hits": 7388, "tt_cutoffs": 1073, "beta_cutoffs": 14640, "depth_sum": 32, "avg_depth": 4.0, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 32, "avg_effective_depth": 4.0, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 6 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 8, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3964.375, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4964.375, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1292, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 9, "search_move_count": 7, "total_time_ms": 3181, "avg_search_time_ms": 454.42857142857144, "search_nodes": 38003, "safety_nodes": 435, "corridor_nodes": 0, "corridor_branch_probes": 0, "corridor_max_depth": 0, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 0, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 2, "corridor_proof_completed": 2, "corridor_proof_checks": 18, "corridor_proof_active": 0, "corridor_proof_quiet": 18, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 18, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 18, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 139, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 27811280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1986720, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 38438, "avg_nodes": 5491.142857142857, "eval_calls": 21346, "avg_eval_calls": 3049.4285714285716, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 21346, "pattern_eval_ns": 391083, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 18.321137449639277, "pattern_frame_queries": 21346, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 391083, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 18.321137449639277, "pattern_frame_updates": 75938, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 445376821, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 5865.005939055545, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 15699, "avg_candidate_generations": 2242.714285714286, "candidate_moves_total": 1020618, "avg_candidate_moves": 65.01165679342633, "candidate_moves_max": 99, "root_candidate_generations": 7, "root_candidate_moves_total": 363, "root_candidate_moves_max": 66, "search_candidate_generations": 15692, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1020255, "search_candidate_moves_max": 99, "legality_checks": 735692, "avg_legality_checks": 105098.85714285714, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1463, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 735692, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1463, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1778203, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 254029.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2088598147, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1174.5555186893735, "renju_forbidden_checks": 13044, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1863.4285714285713, "renju_forbidden_ns": 23230538, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 1780.9366758662986, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1482, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8422885, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2000, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9694874, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9562, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 5112779, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 66228, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9461.142857142857, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 393013213, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 5934.245530591291, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 96478, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 13782.57142857143, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 199132290, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2064.017599867327, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1010081605, "stage_ordering_ns": 246108576, "stage_eval_ns": 445767904, "stage_threat_ns": 1429601751, "stage_proof_ns": 16798428, "tactical_annotations": 197491, "root_tactical_annotations": 557, "search_tactical_annotations": 196934, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 75981, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 267677896, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 166716, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 1113662082, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 31504, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 626092328, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 37987, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 35854788, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 36, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 66650, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 75974, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5979286, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 25733, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 103467130, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 109438, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 383979313, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 62320, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6361049, "child_limit_applications": 15692, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 15692, "child_cap_hits": 15692, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 15692, "child_moves_before_total": 1018792, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1018792, "child_moves_before_max": 99, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 99, "child_moves_after_total": 149319, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 149319, "child_moves_after_max": 17, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 17, "avg_child_moves_before": 64.92429263318888, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.515613051236299, "tt_hits": 7467, "tt_cutoffs": 931, "beta_cutoffs": 12798, "depth_sum": 34, "avg_depth": 4.857142857142857, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 34, "avg_effective_depth": 4.857142857142857, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 2 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 7, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3584.285714285714, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4727.142857142857, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 602, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1788, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 25053, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 29, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 2, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 2 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 97, 96, 82, 127, 81, 159, 67, 52, 95, 53, 83, 80, 51, 143, 175, 35, 65, 49, 37, 79, 84, 85, 98, 70, 129, 113, 99, 115, 114, 69, 144 ], "move_count": 33, "black_stats": { "move_count": 17, "search_move_count": 15, "total_time_ms": 22302, "avg_search_time_ms": 1486.8, "search_nodes": 245565, "safety_nodes": 778, "corridor_nodes": 3040, "corridor_branch_probes": 3379, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 1342, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 3018, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 3018, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 5, "corridor_proof_completed": 5, "corridor_proof_checks": 56, "corridor_proof_active": 22, "corridor_proof_quiet": 34, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 1342, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 56, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 429, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 41708160, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2026960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 249383, "avg_nodes": 16625.533333333333, "eval_calls": 173601, "avg_eval_calls": 11573.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 173601, "pattern_eval_ns": 3502819, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.177412572508224, "pattern_frame_queries": 173601, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3502819, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.177412572508224, "pattern_frame_updates": 490980, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 6260674216, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12751.38338832539, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 68335, "avg_candidate_generations": 4555.666666666667, "candidate_moves_total": 6113740, "avg_candidate_moves": 89.46718372722617, "candidate_moves_max": 126, "root_candidate_generations": 15, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1165, "root_candidate_moves_max": 100, "search_candidate_generations": 68320, "search_candidate_moves_total": 6112575, "search_candidate_moves_max": 126, "legality_checks": 1634613, "avg_legality_checks": 108974.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 3560, "root_legality_checks": 1165, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 3, "search_legality_checks": 1633448, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 3557, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 6747639, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 449842.6, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 12984575657, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1924.3139203208707, "renju_forbidden_checks": 65004, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 4333.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 331355009, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5097.455679650483, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 4244, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 34912752, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 36310, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 218343156, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 24118, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 74745067, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 332, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3354034, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 179702, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 11980.133333333333, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1321004127, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 7351.081941213787, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 223647, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 14909.8, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 508717685, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2274.645691647999, "stage_move_gen_ns": 3472770753, "stage_ordering_ns": 2135927589, "stage_eval_ns": 6264177035, "stage_threat_ns": 9959290662, "stage_proof_ns": 400683384, "tactical_annotations": 1356660, "root_tactical_annotations": 4093, "search_tactical_annotations": 1352567, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 497143, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2699928424, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1391561, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 6796260871, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 138281, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4212804270, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 248564, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 337734408, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 6148, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 34481343, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 497128, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 57377174, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 379693, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 397568007, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 698847, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1758431534, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 278120, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 33508442, "child_limit_applications": 68320, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 68320, "child_cap_hits": 68320, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 68320, "child_moves_before_total": 6109018, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 6109018, "child_moves_before_max": 126, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 126, "child_moves_after_total": 737879, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 737879, "child_moves_after_max": 25, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 25, "avg_child_moves_before": 89.41771077283373, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.800336651053865, "tt_hits": 30626, "tt_cutoffs": 3571, "beta_cutoffs": 53074, "depth_sum": 73, "avg_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 73, "avg_effective_depth": 4.866666666666666, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 7 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 5 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 2, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_moves": 15, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.3333333333333333, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 2, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.13333333333333333, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4019.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4544.733333333334, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1822, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 16, "search_move_count": 14, "total_time_ms": 2739, "avg_search_time_ms": 195.64285714285714, "search_nodes": 33035, "safety_nodes": 1641, "corridor_nodes": 282, "corridor_branch_probes": 335, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 102, "corridor_neutral_exits": 18, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 272, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 272, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 12, "corridor_proof_completed": 12, "corridor_proof_checks": 41, "corridor_proof_active": 10, "corridor_proof_quiet": 31, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 18, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 102, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 41, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 41, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 184, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 63840, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4560, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 34958, "avg_nodes": 2497.0, "eval_calls": 22539, "avg_eval_calls": 1609.9285714285713, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 22539, "pattern_eval_ns": 444123, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 19.704645281512047, "pattern_frame_queries": 22539, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 444123, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 19.704645281512047, "pattern_frame_updates": 65940, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 573699714, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 8700.329299363057, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 9944, "avg_candidate_generations": 710.2857142857143, "candidate_moves_total": 802153, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.66703539823008, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 14, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1092, "root_candidate_moves_max": 99, "search_candidate_generations": 9930, "search_candidate_moves_total": 801061, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 313550, "avg_legality_checks": 22396.428571428572, "illegal_moves_skipped": 387, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 313550, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 387, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 986962, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 70497.28571428571, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1603364491, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1624.5453127881317, "renju_forbidden_checks": 5647, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 403.35714285714283, "renju_forbidden_ns": 28176457, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4989.632902426067, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 438, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 4019765, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 2312, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 16607981, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 2866, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 7225771, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 31, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 322940, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 31293, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2235.214285714286, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 206043491, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 6584.3316716198515, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 41267, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2947.6428571428573, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 86120232, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2086.9031429471493, "stage_move_gen_ns": 571448050, "stage_ordering_ns": 260303944, "stage_eval_ns": 574143837, "stage_threat_ns": 1251724019, "stage_proof_ns": 53228313, "tactical_annotations": 178455, "root_tactical_annotations": 331, "search_tactical_annotations": 178124, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 66580, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 331244519, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 190559, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 868595449, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 20241, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 526777694, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 33283, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 39709691, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 626, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 3886566, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 66566, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6721500, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 44746, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 82611449, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 108915, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 248188762, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 24794, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1566294, "child_limit_applications": 9930, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 9930, "child_cap_hits": 9930, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 9930, "child_moves_before_total": 800674, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 800674, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 160409, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 160409, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 80.63182275931521, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.1539778449144, "tt_hits": 2931, "tt_cutoffs": 501, "beta_cutoffs": 8463, "depth_sum": 65, "avg_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 65, "avg_effective_depth": 4.642857142857143, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 12 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 14, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 6403.071428571428, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6974.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1913, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1789, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 40303, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 110, 96, 99, 64, 128, 100, 126, 115, 114, 130, 145, 80, 48, 66, 129, 144, 127, 125, 94, 81, 51, 78, 79, 158, 172, 65, 69, 84, 67, 116, 102, 132, 68, 148 ], "move_count": 39, "black_stats": { "move_count": 20, "search_move_count": 18, "total_time_ms": 17444, "avg_search_time_ms": 969.1111111111111, "search_nodes": 196902, "safety_nodes": 753, "corridor_nodes": 5455, "corridor_branch_probes": 6051, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2125, "corridor_neutral_exits": 172, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 5393, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5393, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 16, "corridor_proof_completed": 16, "corridor_proof_checks": 179, "corridor_proof_active": 62, "corridor_proof_quiet": 117, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 172, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2125, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 179, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 177, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 2, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 1415, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 48354800, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1999040, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 2, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 1, "total_nodes": 203110, "avg_nodes": 11283.888888888889, "eval_calls": 151050, "avg_eval_calls": 8391.666666666666, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 151050, "pattern_eval_ns": 3153514, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.877285666997683, "pattern_frame_queries": 151050, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 3153514, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.877285666997683, "pattern_frame_updates": 393640, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 4246427010, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10787.59020932832, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 43591, "avg_candidate_generations": 2421.722222222222, "candidate_moves_total": 3611161, "avg_candidate_moves": 82.84189396893854, "candidate_moves_max": 121, "root_candidate_generations": 18, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1349, "root_candidate_moves_max": 104, "search_candidate_generations": 43573, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3609812, "search_candidate_moves_max": 121, "legality_checks": 1262546, "avg_legality_checks": 70141.44444444444, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1222, "root_legality_checks": 1349, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 4, "search_legality_checks": 1261197, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1218, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 5048357, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 280464.27777777775, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 10347216018, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2049.6205038589783, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44042, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2446.777777777778, "renju_forbidden_ns": 155056633, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3520.6537623177874, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1936, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 12428925, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 20307, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 96135489, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 20223, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 39613901, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 1576, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 6878318, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 129158, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7175.444444444444, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 1074434718, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8318.762430511466, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 168230, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9346.111111111111, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 461990034, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2746.181025976342, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2942455308, "stage_ordering_ns": 1376648754, "stage_eval_ns": 4249580524, "stage_threat_ns": 7913918223, "stage_proof_ns": 893051816, "tactical_annotations": 702589, "root_tactical_annotations": 3818, "search_tactical_annotations": 698771, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 404802, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2303328253, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 958904, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5183208817, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 90630, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3010220360, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 202392, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 285930847, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 11144, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 73001018, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 404784, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 47816621, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 224378, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 267664710, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 316688, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 1151417789, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 161523, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 20632667, "child_limit_applications": 43573, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 43573, "child_cap_hits": 43573, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 43573, "child_moves_before_total": 3608594, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3608594, "child_moves_before_max": 121, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 121, "child_moves_after_total": 697748, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 697748, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 82.81720331397884, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.01331099534115, "tt_hits": 18504, "tt_cutoffs": 2197, "beta_cutoffs": 33710, "depth_sum": 82, "avg_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 82, "avg_effective_depth": 4.555555555555555, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 16 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 18, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 1, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.05555555555555555, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5272.277777777777, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5716.722222222223, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1244, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 19, "search_move_count": 17, "total_time_ms": 22842, "avg_search_time_ms": 1343.6470588235295, "search_nodes": 171256, "safety_nodes": 1432, "corridor_nodes": 1356, "corridor_branch_probes": 1621, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 9, "corridor_depth_exits": 462, "corridor_neutral_exits": 53, "corridor_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_plies_followed": 1337, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 1337, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 10, "corridor_proof_completed": 10, "corridor_proof_checks": 57, "corridor_proof_active": 19, "corridor_proof_quiet": 38, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 62, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 462, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 10, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 57, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 56, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 339, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 6140000, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1994240, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 174044, "avg_nodes": 10237.882352941177, "eval_calls": 102746, "avg_eval_calls": 6043.882352941177, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 102746, "pattern_eval_ns": 2172131, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.140784069452824, "pattern_frame_queries": 102746, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 2172131, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.140784069452824, "pattern_frame_updates": 342302, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3493880821, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10207.012582456427, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 63801, "avg_candidate_generations": 3753.0, "candidate_moves_total": 5329596, "avg_candidate_moves": 83.53467813984106, "candidate_moves_max": 119, "root_candidate_generations": 17, "root_candidate_moves_total": 1279, "root_candidate_moves_max": 105, "search_candidate_generations": 63784, "search_candidate_moves_total": 5328317, "search_candidate_moves_max": 119, "legality_checks": 3180466, "avg_legality_checks": 187086.23529411765, "illegal_moves_skipped": 2139, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 3180466, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 2139, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 7425982, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 436822.4705882353, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 14870164602, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2002.4509353779742, "renju_forbidden_checks": 44796, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2635.0588235294117, "renju_forbidden_ns": 131659289, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 2939.0858335565676, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 2726, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 20445301, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 12158, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 68940531, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 29886, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 42031267, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 26, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 242190, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 272279, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 16016.411764705883, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 2432703599, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8934.598698393927, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 366617, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 21565.70588235294, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 1131530462, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3086.4102373867004, "stage_move_gen_ns": 7284064032, "stage_ordering_ns": 2030828468, "stage_eval_ns": 3496052952, "stage_threat_ns": 9821623568, "stage_proof_ns": 83418594, "tactical_annotations": 1055004, "root_tactical_annotations": 2618, "search_tactical_annotations": 1052386, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 345107, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 2042826239, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 1007388, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 7429045767, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 128586, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 4128391859, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 172545, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 254101236, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 2788, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 17314774, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 345090, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 42778618, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 229712, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 1080204575, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 561539, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 2153003294, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 263753, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 35556934, "child_limit_applications": 63784, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 63784, "child_cap_hits": 63784, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 63784, "child_moves_before_total": 5326178, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 5326178, "child_moves_before_max": 119, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 119, "child_moves_after_total": 652535, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 652535, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 83.50335507337263, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.23038693089176, "tt_hits": 29529, "tt_cutoffs": 4624, "beta_cutoffs": 51980, "depth_sum": 102, "avg_depth": 6.0, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 102, "avg_effective_depth": 6.0, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 5 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 10 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 3, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_moves": 17, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 5, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.29411764705882354, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 3, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.17647058823529413, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3187.0588235294117, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3657.6470588235293, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1790, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 16893, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 30, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 3, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 3 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 97, 113, 98, 111, 114, 96, 130, 110, 109, 82, 124, 126, 81, 94, 78, 144, 128, 142, 158, 141, 156, 143, 140, 145 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14472, "avg_search_time_ms": 1315.6363636363637, "search_nodes": 124913, "safety_nodes": 282, "corridor_nodes": 6908, "corridor_branch_probes": 7272, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 3282, "corridor_neutral_exits": 6, "corridor_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_plies_followed": 6881, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 6881, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 6, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 3282, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 12, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 57, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 432, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 39773280, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 132103, "avg_nodes": 12009.363636363636, "eval_calls": 79764, "avg_eval_calls": 7251.272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79764, "pattern_eval_ns": 1702036, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.338398274910986, "pattern_frame_queries": 79764, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1702036, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.338398274910986, "pattern_frame_updates": 249712, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3141752373, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 12581.50338389825, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42294, "avg_candidate_generations": 3844.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 3384071, "avg_candidate_moves": 80.0130278526505, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 687, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 42283, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3383384, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 936913, "avg_legality_checks": 85173.90909090909, "illegal_moves_skipped": 789, "root_legality_checks": 687, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 936226, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 788, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4278755, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 388977.7272727273, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 8898437706, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2079.6791837812634, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20603, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1873.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 112477445, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5459.275105567151, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 875, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8289438, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 9919, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 70570345, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9158, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 30580509, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 651, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3037153, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 90253, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8204.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 780435376, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8647.195949165125, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 118043, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10731.181818181818, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 335178850, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2839.4640088781207, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2222402835, "stage_ordering_ns": 1330970201, "stage_eval_ns": 3143454409, "stage_threat_ns": 7031032859, "stage_proof_ns": 695573211, "tactical_annotations": 650317, "root_tactical_annotations": 2553, "search_tactical_annotations": 647764, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 263603, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1607902417, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 864242, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5091635495, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 88097, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3263743634, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 131796, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 196523205, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 13880, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 75434927, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 263592, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32823291, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 164079, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 162078009, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 243983, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 835314194, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 242255, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 26713524, "child_limit_applications": 42283, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42283, "child_cap_hits": 42283, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42283, "child_moves_before_total": 3382596, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3382596, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 390548, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 390548, "child_moves_after_max": 23, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 23, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.99895939266372, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.236525317503489, "tt_hits": 25816, "tt_cutoffs": 2809, "beta_cutoffs": 33450, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 5.181818181818182, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 5.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2431.909090909091, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3119.818181818182, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 650, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2411, "avg_search_time_ms": 241.1, "search_nodes": 24403, "safety_nodes": 874, "corridor_nodes": 94, "corridor_branch_probes": 103, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 8, "corridor_neutral_exits": 19, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 83, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 83, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 26, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 19, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 186, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 78240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 5520, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 25371, "avg_nodes": 2537.1, "eval_calls": 17074, "avg_eval_calls": 1707.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 17074, "pattern_eval_ns": 368200, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.564952559447114, "pattern_frame_queries": 17074, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 368200, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.564952559447114, "pattern_frame_updates": 48716, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 485137251, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 9958.478754413334, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6942, "avg_candidate_generations": 694.2, "candidate_moves_total": 498274, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.7767214059349, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 625, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 6932, "search_candidate_moves_total": 497649, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 216082, "avg_legality_checks": 21608.2, "illegal_moves_skipped": 112, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 216082, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 112, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 694527, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 69452.7, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1462028812, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2105.0712384111775, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3180, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 318.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 16223774, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5101.815723270441, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 118, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1070106, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1286, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 11121976, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1771, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 4004632, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 27060, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 19598, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 1959.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 191064258, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9749.171241963466, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 27362, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2736.2, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 89972626, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3288.2328046195453, "stage_move_gen_ns": 521067348, "stage_ordering_ns": 201555367, "stage_eval_ns": 485505451, "stage_threat_ns": 1122632713, "stage_proof_ns": 61717621, "tactical_annotations": 99483, "root_tactical_annotations": 311, "search_tactical_annotations": 99172, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 48966, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 294744396, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 104666, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 783917658, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 14129, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 512245472, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 24478, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 35459091, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 240, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1054302, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 48956, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 6092150, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 24385, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 76518988, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 57178, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 189536270, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 17920, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1365116, "child_limit_applications": 6932, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6932, "child_cap_hits": 6932, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6932, "child_moves_before_total": 497537, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 497537, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 110969, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 110969, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.77394691286786, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.008222735141374, "tt_hits": 2321, "tt_cutoffs": 352, "beta_cutoffs": 5805, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5589.7, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6389.7, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1860, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1791, "black": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 19059, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 96, 141, 82, 142, 110, 124, 97, 67, 98, 156, 171, 95, 114, 66, 144, 128, 99, 100, 129, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 12793, "avg_search_time_ms": 1163.0, "search_nodes": 116507, "safety_nodes": 146, "corridor_nodes": 6018, "corridor_branch_probes": 6694, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2628, "corridor_neutral_exits": 45, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 5968, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5968, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 9, "corridor_proof_completed": 9, "corridor_proof_checks": 100, "corridor_proof_active": 50, "corridor_proof_quiet": 50, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 45, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2628, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 100, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 98, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 821, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 26140240, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 1982960, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 2, "total_nodes": 122671, "avg_nodes": 11151.90909090909, "eval_calls": 87178, "avg_eval_calls": 7925.272727272727, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 87178, "pattern_eval_ns": 1802035, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 20.670754089334466, "pattern_frame_queries": 87178, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1802035, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 20.670754089334466, "pattern_frame_updates": 232920, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3237712743, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13900.535561566203, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 27488, "avg_candidate_generations": 2498.909090909091, "candidate_moves_total": 2010104, "avg_candidate_moves": 73.12660069848661, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 676, "root_candidate_moves_max": 81, "search_candidate_generations": 27477, "search_candidate_moves_total": 2009428, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 746874, "avg_legality_checks": 67897.63636363637, "illegal_moves_skipped": 1138, "root_legality_checks": 676, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 746198, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 1138, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 3748871, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 340806.45454545453, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 7936307581, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2116.986042197771, "renju_forbidden_checks": 32279, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 2934.4545454545455, "renju_forbidden_ns": 206674212, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 6402.745190371449, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 1247, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 11354751, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 17066, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 152607319, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 12978, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 37358761, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 988, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 5353381, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 103916, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 9446.90909090909, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 922982338, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8882.004099464952, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 138070, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 12551.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 404856305, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2932.25396537988, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1793879621, "stage_ordering_ns": 809314784, "stage_eval_ns": 3239514778, "stage_threat_ns": 6081263899, "stage_proof_ns": 826220574, "tactical_annotations": 491963, "root_tactical_annotations": 2332, "search_tactical_annotations": 489631, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 245067, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1516779783, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 786165, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 4268616036, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 58071, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 2265336552, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 122528, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 181255861, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 12136, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 69670456, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 245056, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 30830320, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 149663, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 196911639, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 229124, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 925332244, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 113176, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 14111443, "child_limit_applications": 27477, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 27477, "child_cap_hits": 27477, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 27477, "child_moves_before_total": 2008290, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 2008290, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 440238, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 440238, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 73.08985697128507, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.022054809477016, "tt_hits": 11639, "tt_cutoffs": 1805, "beta_cutoffs": 21835, "depth_sum": 47, "avg_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 47, "avg_effective_depth": 4.2727272727272725, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 9 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 2, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.18181818181818182, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 3606.181818181818, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 4333.454545454545, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 685, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 6253, "avg_search_time_ms": 625.3, "search_nodes": 48269, "safety_nodes": 948, "corridor_nodes": 185, "corridor_branch_probes": 224, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 54, "corridor_neutral_exits": 3, "corridor_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_plies_followed": 180, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 180, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 4, "corridor_proof_completed": 4, "corridor_proof_checks": 13, "corridor_proof_active": 5, "corridor_proof_quiet": 8, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 3, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 54, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 8, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 13, "corridor_proof_wins": 1, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 12, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 32, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 5, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 10009920, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2003760, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 3, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 3, "total_nodes": 49402, "avg_nodes": 4940.2, "eval_calls": 28908, "avg_eval_calls": 2890.8, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 28908, "pattern_eval_ns": 607506, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 21.015151515151516, "pattern_frame_queries": 28908, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 607506, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 21.015151515151516, "pattern_frame_updates": 96428, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 1092599065, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 11330.724115402165, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 17196, "avg_candidate_generations": 1719.6, "candidate_moves_total": 1201232, "avg_candidate_moves": 69.85531518957897, "candidate_moves_max": 104, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 622, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 17186, "search_candidate_moves_total": 1200610, "search_candidate_moves_max": 104, "legality_checks": 747505, "avg_legality_checks": 74750.5, "illegal_moves_skipped": 835, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 747505, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 835, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 1958339, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 195833.9, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 4069803830, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2078.1916869346933, "renju_forbidden_checks": 15336, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1533.6, "renju_forbidden_ns": 49097228, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 3201.4363588941055, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 848, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8431264, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 4035, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 28693475, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 10453, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 11972489, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 0, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 0, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 73067, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 7306.7, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 662929136, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 9072.89386453529, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 98943, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 9894.3, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 295542546, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2986.998029168309, "stage_move_gen_ns": 1774937984, "stage_ordering_ns": 493906568, "stage_eval_ns": 1093206571, "stage_threat_ns": 2833775685, "stage_proof_ns": 20943830, "tactical_annotations": 271158, "root_tactical_annotations": 395, "search_tactical_annotations": 270763, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 96824, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 585135453, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 254268, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 2156580148, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 34570, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 1240916952, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 48407, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 71676083, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 386, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1983030, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 96814, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 12231906, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 32281, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 128593303, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 173797, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 777010783, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 65080, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 6169065, "child_limit_applications": 17186, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 17186, "child_cap_hits": 17186, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 17186, "child_moves_before_total": 1199775, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 1199775, "child_moves_before_max": 104, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 104, "child_moves_after_total": 182336, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 182336, "child_moves_after_max": 22, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 22, "avg_child_moves_before": 69.81118352147097, "avg_child_moves_after": 10.60956592575352, "tt_hits": 8409, "tt_cutoffs": 2120, "beta_cutoffs": 13947, "depth_sum": 54, "avg_depth": 5.4, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 54, "avg_effective_depth": 5.4, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 2 }, { "depth": 6, "count": 4 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 4 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 1, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 1, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.1, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 4463.9, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 5263.9, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 0, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } }, { "match_index": 1792, "black": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "white": "search-d5+tactical-cap-16+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "result": "black_won", "winner": "search-d7+tactical-cap-8+pattern-eval+corridor-proof-c16-d8-w4", "end_reason": "natural", "duration_ms": 17212, "opening": { "policy": "centered-suite", "index": 31, "ply_count": 4, "suite_index": 4, "template_index": 0, "transform_index": 4 }, "move_cells": [ 112, 111, 127, 126, 97, 142, 96, 158, 82, 67, 110, 68, 98, 95, 66, 50, 144, 128, 114, 130, 99, 100, 129, 84, 159 ], "move_count": 25, "black_stats": { "move_count": 13, "search_move_count": 11, "total_time_ms": 14743, "avg_search_time_ms": 1340.2727272727273, "search_nodes": 124958, "safety_nodes": 282, "corridor_nodes": 5935, "corridor_branch_probes": 6310, "corridor_max_depth": 8, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 2823, "corridor_neutral_exits": 2, "corridor_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_plies_followed": 5908, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 5908, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 7, "corridor_proof_completed": 7, "corridor_proof_checks": 59, "corridor_proof_active": 27, "corridor_proof_quiet": 32, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 2, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 2823, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 9, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 2, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 59, "corridor_proof_wins": 2, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 57, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 1, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 1, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 432, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 39724400, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 2027200, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 5, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 4, "total_nodes": 131175, "avg_nodes": 11925.0, "eval_calls": 79849, "avg_eval_calls": 7259.0, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 79849, "pattern_eval_ns": 1761854, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.064822352189758, "pattern_frame_queries": 79849, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 1761854, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.064822352189758, "pattern_frame_updates": 249802, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 3252245392, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 13019.292847935565, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 42365, "avg_candidate_generations": 3851.3636363636365, "candidate_moves_total": 3366702, "avg_candidate_moves": 79.46894842440695, "candidate_moves_max": 113, "root_candidate_generations": 11, "root_candidate_moves_total": 687, "root_candidate_moves_max": 80, "search_candidate_generations": 42354, "search_candidate_moves_total": 3366015, "search_candidate_moves_max": 113, "legality_checks": 918310, "avg_legality_checks": 83482.72727272728, "illegal_moves_skipped": 830, "root_legality_checks": 687, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 1, "search_legality_checks": 917623, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 829, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 4176359, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 379669.0, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 9038860167, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2164.2919507159227, "renju_forbidden_checks": 20834, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 1894.0, "renju_forbidden_ns": 119463798, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 5734.078813477969, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 935, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 8938165, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 10238, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 75391943, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 9214, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 32126174, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 447, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 3007516, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 88268, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 8024.363636363636, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 777249623, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 8805.565131191372, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 115520, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 10501.818181818182, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 334676870, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 2897.1335699445985, "stage_move_gen_ns": 2170278880, "stage_ordering_ns": 1382764702, "stage_eval_ns": 3254007246, "stage_threat_ns": 7176561170, "stage_proof_ns": 710235504, "tactical_annotations": 648450, "root_tactical_annotations": 2553, "search_tactical_annotations": 645897, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 261747, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 1637302997, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 812059, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 5203680047, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 87725, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 3355083650, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 130868, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 199022995, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 11934, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 75920743, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 261736, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 32934181, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 164041, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 164452855, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 243373, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 840916534, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 241036, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 27700207, "child_limit_applications": 42354, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 42354, "child_cap_hits": 42354, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 42354, "child_moves_before_total": 3365186, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 3365186, "child_moves_before_max": 113, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 113, "child_moves_after_total": 393571, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 393571, "child_moves_after_max": 21, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 21, "avg_child_moves_before": 79.4537942107003, "avg_child_moves_after": 9.292416300703593, "tt_hits": 25763, "tt_cutoffs": 2698, "beta_cutoffs": 33553, "depth_sum": 57, "avg_depth": 5.181818181818182, "max_depth": 7, "effective_depth_sum": 57, "avg_effective_depth": 5.181818181818182, "max_effective_depth": 7, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 3 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 7, "count": 7 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 11, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 4, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.36363636363636365, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 2490.090909090909, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 3154.090909090909, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 841, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 }, "white_stats": { "move_count": 12, "search_move_count": 10, "total_time_ms": 2459, "avg_search_time_ms": 245.9, "search_nodes": 23398, "safety_nodes": 874, "corridor_nodes": 78, "corridor_branch_probes": 79, "corridor_max_depth": 5, "corridor_width_exits": 0, "corridor_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_neutral_exits": 23, "corridor_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_plies_followed": 67, "corridor_own_plies_followed": 67, "corridor_opponent_plies_followed": 0, "corridor_proof_passes": 8, "corridor_proof_completed": 8, "corridor_proof_checks": 37, "corridor_proof_active": 11, "corridor_proof_quiet": 26, "corridor_proof_static_exits": 23, "corridor_proof_depth_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_deadline_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_exits": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_winning_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_losing_candidates": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_overrides": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_terminal_root_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidates_considered": 37, "corridor_proof_wins": 0, "corridor_proof_losses": 0, "corridor_proof_unknown": 37, "corridor_proof_deadline_skips": 0, "corridor_proof_move_changes": 0, "corridor_proof_move_confirmations": 0, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_total": 186, "corridor_proof_candidate_rank_max": 16, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_total": 66480, "corridor_proof_candidate_score_gap_max": 4320, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_total": 0, "corridor_proof_win_candidate_rank_max": 0, "total_nodes": 24350, "avg_nodes": 2435.0, "eval_calls": 16204, "avg_eval_calls": 1620.4, "line_shape_eval_calls": 0, "line_shape_eval_ns": 0, "avg_line_shape_eval_ns": 0.0, "pattern_eval_calls": 16204, "pattern_eval_ns": 362102, "avg_pattern_eval_ns": 22.346457664774128, "pattern_frame_queries": 16204, "pattern_frame_query_ns": 362102, "avg_pattern_frame_query_ns": 22.346457664774128, "pattern_frame_updates": 46706, "pattern_frame_update_ns": 485322054, "avg_pattern_frame_update_ns": 10391.000171284204, "pattern_frame_shadow_checks": 0, "pattern_frame_shadow_mismatches": 0, "candidate_generations": 6774, "avg_candidate_generations": 677.4, "candidate_moves_total": 483797, "avg_candidate_moves": 71.41969294360791, "candidate_moves_max": 108, "root_candidate_generations": 10, "root_candidate_moves_total": 625, "root_candidate_moves_max": 79, "search_candidate_generations": 6764, "search_candidate_moves_total": 483172, "search_candidate_moves_max": 108, "legality_checks": 215648, "avg_legality_checks": 21564.8, "illegal_moves_skipped": 119, "root_legality_checks": 0, "root_illegal_moves_skipped": 0, "search_legality_checks": 215648, "search_illegal_moves_skipped": 119, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 686503, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_checks": 68650.3, "renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 1502739936, "avg_renju_forbidden_prefilter_ns": 2188.977959309719, "renju_forbidden_checks": 3008, "avg_renju_forbidden_checks": 300.8, "renju_forbidden_ns": 14275424, "avg_renju_forbidden_ns": 4745.81914893617, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_checks": 125, "renju_forbidden_search_gate_ns": 1177107, "renju_forbidden_pattern_checks": 1163, "renju_forbidden_pattern_ns": 9416265, "renju_forbidden_threat_checks": 1715, "renju_forbidden_threat_ns": 3653262, "renju_forbidden_other_checks": 5, "renju_forbidden_other_ns": 28790, "renju_effective_filter_calls": 20158, "avg_renju_effective_filter_calls": 2015.8, "renju_effective_filter_ns": 203885042, "avg_renju_effective_filter_ns": 10114.34874491517, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 28019, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_checks": 2801.9, "renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 96393130, "avg_renju_effective_filter_continuation_ns": 3440.2773118241194, "stage_move_gen_ns": 539466649, "stage_ordering_ns": 206860336, "stage_eval_ns": 485684156, "stage_threat_ns": 1141403515, "stage_proof_ns": 64804334, "tactical_annotations": 97673, "root_tactical_annotations": 311, "search_tactical_annotations": 97362, "threat_view_shadow_checks": 0, "threat_view_shadow_mismatches": 0, "threat_view_scan_queries": 0, "threat_view_scan_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_rebuilds": 46924, "threat_view_frontier_rebuild_ns": 294643338, "threat_view_frontier_queries": 102396, "threat_view_frontier_query_ns": 803193281, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_queries": 13789, "threat_view_frontier_immediate_win_query_ns": 514551139, "threat_view_frontier_delta_captures": 23457, "threat_view_frontier_delta_capture_ns": 34960069, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_updates": 208, "threat_view_frontier_move_fact_update_ns": 1040035, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_marks": 46914, "threat_view_frontier_annotation_dirty_mark_ns": 5942426, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_queries": 24917, "threat_view_frontier_clean_annotation_query_ns": 84139039, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_queries": 55524, "threat_view_frontier_dirty_annotation_query_ns": 198948558, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_queries": 0, "threat_view_frontier_fallback_annotation_query_ns": 0, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_queries": 17232, "threat_view_frontier_memo_annotation_query_ns": 1624366, "child_limit_applications": 6764, "root_child_limit_applications": 0, "search_child_limit_applications": 6764, "child_cap_hits": 6764, "root_child_cap_hits": 0, "search_child_cap_hits": 6764, "child_moves_before_total": 483053, "root_child_moves_before_total": 0, "search_child_moves_before_total": 483053, "child_moves_before_max": 108, "root_child_moves_before_max": 0, "search_child_moves_before_max": 108, "child_moves_after_total": 108289, "root_child_moves_after_total": 0, "search_child_moves_after_total": 108289, "child_moves_after_max": 19, "root_child_moves_after_max": 0, "search_child_moves_after_max": 19, "avg_child_moves_before": 71.41528681253696, "avg_child_moves_after": 16.009609698403313, "tt_hits": 2340, "tt_cutoffs": 385, "beta_cutoffs": 5698, "depth_sum": 45, "avg_depth": 4.5, "max_depth": 5, "effective_depth_sum": 45, "avg_effective_depth": 4.5, "max_effective_depth": 5, "depth_reached_counts": [ { "depth": 1, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 4, "count": 1 }, { "depth": 5, "count": 8 } ], "budget_exhausted_count": 0, "budget_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_moves": 10, "pooled_budget_over_base_count": 0, "pooled_budget_over_base_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_count": 0, "pooled_budget_reserve_exhausted_rate": 0.0, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_before_ms": 5584.5, "pooled_budget_avg_reserve_after_ms": 6384.5, "pooled_budget_min_reserve_after_ms": 1832, "pooled_budget_max_move_budget_ms": 4000 } } ] }